We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Report of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. - Agricultural Workers (Weekly Half-Holidays) Bill, 1950—Committee.

Contributions 1–154 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Agricultural Workers (Weekly Half-Holidays) Bill, 1950
Enacted

No. 27 of 1950 ›

It is proposed to take amendments Nos. 1 and 2 to Section 1 together.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 1 and 2 standing in my name:—

In lines 13 and 14 to delete the words "or includes".

In line 14 to delete all words after the word "agriculture".

The first amendment proposes to delete the words "or includes" in lines 13 and 14. To my mind, the words "or includes" are superfluous. I believe that "any person employed in work in agriculture" should be quite sufficient. The addition of the words "or includes" seems to me to be just making the position more confused. I take it that the purpose of the Bill is to provide a half-holiday for persons employed in rural areas. I think that a definition of what would be mainly domestic would be very difficult. It would be very difficult to decide in respect of a great number of people whether the work upon which they were employed was mainly domestic or agricultural. Take the case of a person working with a farmer who has a certain amount of domestic work to do and at the same time would be employed carrying food for animals or working in the garden, or binding. That would be a very difficult thing to decide. I feel that if people who are employed in domestic work in rural areas are getting a half-holiday it is only right that this other type of person should get it. When passing this Bill at all we should not have any restrictive clause. I urge Senator O'Connell to accept the amendment and if people employed in domestic work get a holiday as a result of that it would be a step in the right direction.

Comment on this

I do not know if this amendment is necessary or serves any purpose. The position is clear enough.

"... whose work under such contract is or includes work in agriculture."

First of all I should point out that provision has already been made for domestic servants to get half-holidays. It is difficult to determine whether a man who is engaged by a farmer and is sent in to prepare tea for the rest of the men is engaged in agriculture. Is he not engaged in agriculture? Deleting these words does not strengthen in any way the section as it stands. I think it is quite clear as it stands. I would not be inclined to accept that amendment. I do not think it is necessary.

Comment on this

I am not very much concerned with it, and since people who are engaged in domestic work are covered already, I withdraw it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In line 15, after the word "domestic", to add the words "nor a herd whose main work on a farm is the care and management of live stock".

I am sure that a number of people in the House do not understand the responsibility a herd has on the farm. He is the most important man on the farm and he is never off duty. Although his actual working hours might not number more than four or five, he is still responsible for the care and management of the stock for the entire 24 hours. The herd on a farm is an expert and has to be capable of treating cattle. He may have to start at 4 o'clock or 5 o'clock in the morning and look at the cattle, and then have another look at them in the evening, and, if he has sick animals to attend to, he must be available, like the veterinary surgeon or dispensary doctor.

In many cases, he is an institution on the farm and his job is one which very often goes down from father to son. It takes a long time to make him an expert. In many cases, the herd is a farmer himself, a small farmer in the district who takes on a contract to look after cattle on a bigger farm, and it would be very hard on a farmer to have to say to him that he must take a half-day. I have winterage in County Wicklow, and for six months of the year there is not an animal on that land, except the few cattle and a pony belonging to the herd. It is dry mountain land and useful only for the winter. Senators from the West will know that, in Clare, Kerry, and several other counties, the same thing applies —no cattle are grazed on some of the winterages there, except from October to the middle or the end of April. I cannot see how a half-holiday can be arranged for in the case of such a herd. The only proper line to take is to exclude him from the provisions of this Bill.

Comment on this

We must oppose this amendment. Senator Counihan, true to form, opened with the statement that the herd was a man who is on duty all the time and his idea is that he should be kept on duty all the time when the purpose of the Bill is to give this relief to certain classes of workers. Every farmer, no matter what his category is, keeps stock of some kind, and, if the amendment were to be accepted, it would kill the whole purpose of the Bill because a farmer could make the case at any time that his workers were herds, within the meaning of this provision. The amendment may look very simple, but it is very serious when one studies its implications. I do not know how anybody could define a herd because every man working for a farmer or on a farm is in some way responsible for looking after the stock and the farmer could make the case that he is a herd and not subject to the provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this

In supporting the amendment, I should like to say that this is not an aspect of farming with which I am too familiar. I do not know that the amendment, as drafted, is the best way to achieve what the Senator wants, but it is very important that we, when passing legislation, should ensure that that legislation is in such a form as will make it workable. That is just the difficulty in regard to this point. Senator McCrea knows quite well the difference between a herd and a ploughman on the farm. The herd is employed to look after the live stock. He has no responsibility in the matter of going out to the plough in the field, for harvesting or anything of that nature. The live stock are his sole responsibility and he has to be out in the morning—certainly on spring mornings—and during the year when the cattle are rising to put his cattle out and to see that they are all right. Similarly, he must look after them in the evening, and, if there are sheep on the farm, he must attend to these too at lambing time and so on. He may have an hour, or, at most, two hours' work in the morning, after which he eases off, and then has to look after them again in the evening. If one animal is ill when he goes out in the evening, he is in a peculiar position, as also in his master, because, if he is a careful person, he will want to be on the spot to look after the sick animal. There is no use in trying to plan on the basis of somebody coming in for the half-day and taking over responsibility for the herd when animals are sick and require attendance, without the "vet." because in many instances these herds are just as efficient as a competent "vet". The position is that he just cannot be replaced.

Comment on this

Suppose he is ill?

Comment on this

If he is, the farmer will have to take on his job, and that is not an uncommon occurrence. The difficulty I see with regard to it is that it is next to impossible to legislate in such a way as to ensure that the herd will have his day off, and that is the part of the Bill which I regard as impracticable. How can you apply these industrial conditions to the management of live stock? From my knowledge of farming and of live stock, I know that you cannot do it. Where a man goes out to look at cattle in the morning or the evening and finds one of them seriously ill—perhaps a very valuable animal—you cannot make provision for somebody else to come in and take over. If you try to do that, you are trying to legislate for the impossible. Whether Senator Counihan has put his proposal in the best possible form is another matter, but I have every sympathy with the idea he has in mind.

Comment on this

I should be inclined to support the amendment if this Bill were definitely a Bill to give compulsory half-holidays to agricultural workers, but that is not so, because provision is made in the Bill whereby, in lieu of that half-holiday, certain payments or compensation may be given to the worker who is prepared to stay on working. A herd is more or less the manager of a farm. If we pass this amendment we will deprive the most important person on the farm of the benefit, if not of the half-holiday, of the increase which he will get as a result of not availing of the half-holiday.

Comment on this

What I had to say has been very ably said by Senator Hawkins. I submit that the argument in favour of this amendment by Senator Counihan, and supported by Senator Baxter, is really an argument against the passing of the Bill rather than an argument in favour of the amendment. This amendment seeks to exclude a particular group of agricultural workers from the scope of the Act, when it becomes law. Neither the mover of the amendment for Senator Baxter has suggested that the herd is more important than the agricultural worker on a dairy farm where the cows have to be attended to every morning and every evening, day in and day out, including Christmas Day. Being interested in that type of agriculture, Senator Counihan may argue that the herd is more important than the agricultural worker on a dairy or on a mixed farm.

Comment on this

He looks after the dairy cows, too.

Comment on this

Agreed, that may be so. However, if a case can be made for the exclusion of the herd I submit it is a good argument against the passing of this Bill. I may have mixed feelings about this Bill but I would oppose this amendment because it would be unfair to pass a Bill excluding one particular group of workers from its scope. In effect, it would mean that people engaged in that type of agriculture would either have to grant the half-holiday or alternatively pay extra remuneration to ensure that the worker will not in fact take the half-holiday. I believe that the intention of this Bill is really to give an increase in the agricultural wage. I believe that farmers will give an extra amount of money to the worker and that the worker will continue to work. I think most people in this House think that that is what will happen. Consider the position on a farm at the harvest. Surely, the farmer would expect his worker to work on the half-day even if it meant that he would have to pay extra. As that will be the position on many mixed farms, I submit that it is no reason why the herd should be excluded. It would be putting a particular type of farming—not the best type of farming from a national point of view—in a privileged position. The majority of our farmers carry on dairy farming or mixed farming or any other type of farming than grass land and the farmers, when this Bill becomes law, will have to pay extra. Surely it would be unfair to exclude, by this amendment, the operation of this Bill in so far as herds are concerned. It would be quite wrong.

Comment on this

It seems to me that what this boils down to is that a man can say: "I would prefer the money to the time off." I think that that is a rotten principle and it is one to which I do not subscribe.

Comment on this

We are dealing with one particular amendment— amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

I have not much to add to what Senator O'Reilly and Senator Hawkins have said on this amendment except to point out that I am not aware of any legal definition of the word "herd". If this word appears in the Bill without a proper definition I can foresee all sorts of legal confusion and wrangling. I was surprised that a farmer such as Senator Baxter should brush the matter aside and say that everybody knows what is meant by a "herd". He appears to imply that a herd has one job and one job only.

Comment on this

That was my interpretation.

Comment on this

I am certain that there are very few farms in this country where there are men confined to that particular work only. It may be so on a few very large farms, but in the majority of the farms where there are one or two men are employed, surely their work is not confined entirely to the care of animals. In any event, not alone would there be confusion about the definition of "herd", but there would be confusion also about the expression "...whose main work on a farm". What exactly is meant by "main work"? If this amendment is accepted, quite a number of workers all over the country will be excluded from the provisions of this Bill, which the House has already agreed, in principle, should be given to them. I could not, under any circumstances, accept this amendment (1) because it would deprive a great many men of the privilege already agreed to in principle, and (2) because it would lead to all sorts of confusion in regard to the definition of "herd" and the definition of "main work on a farm".

Comment on this

If Senator Dr. O'Connell knew anything about the practice of farming in his own county he would not have made the foolish statement which he has just made that he knows nothing about herds. I know his county. In Connemara and in Kerry the herd is a small farmer, and he has charge of the sheep belonging to one or two or more people. One or perhaps two men are paid by the lot to look after all the sheep of all the people who have the right of grazing there. How will the half-holiday be regulated for the small farmer who takes charge of all the cattle belonging to his neighbour on the next farm? The herd is the most important worker on the land, and why should he be denied a half-holiday? A herd's work in many cases would be completed in three or four hours, but he cannot work except late or early. Take the lambing season. The herd would have to go out a couple of times during the night with his lantern to look after the ewes when they are lambing. When you have a few sick bullocks, will any man be able to diagnose their disease and does them? Then you see people like Senator O'Connell and others who know absolutely nothing about farming dictating and laying down the law about how the farmer is to do his work, and I am afraid that most of it is for political propaganda.

Comment on this

If the Senator keeps to his point in the amendment it would be much better.

Comment on this

If he is referring to me I will take him on at any time at farming.

Comment on this

We have, thanks be to God, very few herds in County Mayo, but I always understood that the herd's business was, in the main, to look after the stock of the man who employs him and he gives his spare time to the amenities he enjoys because of being a herd. I am in full sympathy with the idea of giving a half-holiday to agricultural labourers. We have also very few of them in Mayo. They generally live around the domicile of the employer but the herd usually lives several miles away from his boss, and if you take him into the category of agricultural labourers and give him a half-holiday, who is to look after the stock? He may not be married but even if he is, you could not ask his wife to look after his work. Before rejecting Senator Counihan's amendment, the House might give the matter more consideration.

Comment on this

I want to make a point by way of further explanation with regard to the situation confronting us. There is no necessity to get hot and bothered, as Senator Counihan did, but you cannot blame him. When you understand the problem he is trying to resolve, it is not easy to be patient with the people who chose to ignore it or have no sympathy with his views.

I should like Senator McCrea or some Senator on the other side of the House to tell me what you could do in the following case. There is an estate close to me of 2,000 acres and there is a herd there. I do not know how many sheep and cattle there are but that man is entirely employed looking after the live stock. He lives about a mile from the residence. Probably he alone, with perhaps one other, knows what live stock there is on the farm. No matter what Senators O'Connell or O'Reilly say, a labourer is entitled to walk off on his half-day and it does not matter if his employer wants to pay him double or treble. There is no use pretending, as Senator O'Reilly tried to pretend, that he can keep any employee working at the hay if he does not want to stay, because he can walk off. It may be said that he will not do it but that depends entirely on the relations between the farmer and man. Those relations will not be improved by the Bill but will, perhaps, be rather poisoned.

Take the instances I have mentioned and Senator Counihan has other instances. Suppose this man gets a half-holiday. You cannot try to control the payment as these people are paid on a different basis. They are under a kind of contract and receive a lump sum, not weekly payment. Who else on the farm knows how many sheep and cattle there are, how many yearlings, two-year-olds and three-year-olds to be looked after? Must he explain to another employee the sheep which must be looked after and watched on that afternoon? It would be much easier for him to stay on at work. You cannot make a provision in a Bill like this for such a situation. You are legislating in a vaccum. I do not think it is wise to try to formulate legislation to cover a case like that. It would be far better to define in clear and precise language what Senator Counihan described as a herd. In my opinion a herd is an employee on a farm whose sole duty practically is to look after the live stock. If that is the situation it could be covered after further consideration by a different type of amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

Every argument advanced in favour of this amendment could be advanced with greater force to keep a herd on all night. If anything was to happen to the cattle on his half-day it would be far more likely to happen during the eight hours or if he was in bed. I am surprised that anyone should be anxious to exclude any section of farm workers from the Bill because if you exclude a labourer by calling him a herd or anything else, you are making it essential that a new Bill must immediately be brought in to extend to him the amenities which are granted to the other sections and there is no way of avoiding it.

I am glad that Senator Baxter mentioned the 2,000 acres, where one man and a dog have to go around minding all the cattle.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

Sheep, he said.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

He said 2,000 acres.

Comment on this

Senator O'Farrell always likes to misinterpret.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

Senator Baxter said one man and 2,000 acres.

Comment on this

I said he was a herd. There are 50 men at work in the place but he looks after the live stock. This is a demonstration of how much these people know of the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

He said that one man looked after the stock on 2,000 acres. On a previous occasion we had the case of the poor widows with no man to help them but now we have one man and 2,000 acres. I do not claim to have a farm but a lot of people talk about farming with no justification for their talk except that they own a farm. I have worked on farms but I have never worked on my own. There are people who own farms who have never worked on them and that does not give them a better right to talk about farming than I have.

This is nothing new in this Parliament in this generation or in this year. As far back as 1826, when an attempt was made to organise herds and other agricultural workers by Joseph Arch, one of the demands made was for a half-holiday every week. If it is practical at present in Northern Ireland and England and in practically every other country, it will not cause a collapse here. The exclusion of any section would cause trouble, in trying to interpret what the man's job is. We might as well let the Bill go through, covering all agricultural labourers, and not try to recast it by specifically excluding herds.

Another argument advanced was that a herd would leave a sick cow moaning or a sheep dying on the hill because he had this right to a half-day. It is not tied down to a specific day or hour and provision is also made in the Bill that he can work if he chooses. He has got the privilege or right to a half-day and it is rather reactionary on our part to try to exclude him. This is a depressed class, always despised and denied rights that even a domestic servant has.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I support Senator Counihan's amendment and think there is a case for putting the herd in a special position and excluding him from the provisions of this Bill. I know something about agricultural conditions and do not want to enforce a doctrinaire Bill on a community for whom it is not suited. We are primarily an agricultural country and it is important for us to see that we do nothing which would affect our major industry. People have talked about happenings in Britain and other places, but they are not agricultural countries. It is very important that the man in charge—Senator Baxter spoke of 50 men being under the herd —should be there at any time necessary. If he does not find that job suitable and if he is a good man, there will be many looking for him on his own conditions. I am glad that the father of the House has brought up this question and I hope we will be able to pass his amendment. He is a man who knows agriculture and what is good for agriculture and he is not making a doctrinaire approach to it.

Comment on this

We are getting away from facing up to the position of the person concerned. No one employed in agriculture has a closer relationship with his employer than the herd. He has certain concessions that no other employee has. Usually a house is provided and he has the grass of a certain number of stock as well. To suggest that the herd, above all other employees will, just in order to make it inconvenient for his employer, walk away from his employment at a critical stage, is to suggest something that would not happen in rural Ireland. Perhaps Senator Counihan could tell us the number of persons so employed as herds. Senator Baxter has laboured rather long on the position the herd occupies in the sole control of stock and thought that if he were absent for half-an-hour something extraordinary would happen. He tried to rectify that by saying the herd is only one of a number. In this country we are rapidly advancing to the stage when there will be no large farms and no herds, if we accept every statement being made at present.

We are asked to give the herd something he cannot on his own demand because of his close relationship with his employer, and we are going to victimise him over all the other employees if we exclude him. The vast majority of agricultural workers, and particularly herds, will accept payment in lieu of the holiday. I would sooner see this Bill introduced as a measure to give increased wages rather than as an excuse, saying: "You can give the half-day, or if you do not, you must increase the wages."

Comment on this

Hear, hear. It would have been better to have been straight about it.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Baxter. It would.

Comment on this

The promoters of this Bill are not responsible for that particular condition. It was put in to meet objections raised by the opponents of the measure in principle. It is not alleged that there was a want of straightness. I do not like the references to "these people" who brought in the Bill. The Party responsible for the introduction of this measure are in the minority both here and in the Dáil. The principle of this Bill has been agreed to unanimously here and in the other House. Therefore, both Houses are responsible for it, and the less references to "these people" in the tone that has been used the better, and personal references should be left out also.

Most of those opposing this amendment are inclined to argue against the principle of the Bill. That has been settled and we are dealing now only with this individual. No attempt has been made to define him in a way which will remove all doubt as to the position he holds. The Bill refers to people employed under a contract of service. It seeks to exclude a large number of people occupying the position to which Senator Counihan refers, who may be employed miles away on an out farm. They are rare cases and we cannot legislate for rare cases. As Senator Hawkins said, there is provision for this already in Section 3. I think there is no justification for accepting this amendment.

Comment on this

This amendment concerns the exclusion of a particular class of worker from the provisions of the Bill. With regard to a statement made by Senator O'Connell, the fact that a Bill is passed unanimously in the Dáil on the Second Stage does mean that the Dáil unanimously assents to the principle, but here it has not got the same meaning. I think that should be made clear. The position which I have always adopted here, both in opposition and at present, is that unless you have some overwhelming objection you should not endeavour to defeat a Bill on Second Stage, because by doing so you are taking from yourself your own right to amend a Bill.

We come to the point when we are considering amendments and even though it is not right to say that everybody in the Seanad is in favour of the principle of this Bill, it is right to say that nobody can amend the Bill in such a way as to defeat the principle. That is what Senator O'Connell meant. I commend that to Senator Counihan. Senator Counihan may be against this Bill but the Bill cannot now be amended in such a way as to defeat the principle of the Bill. It is contrary to commonsense and it cannot be done. I am afraid that Senator Counihan and everybody else who does not like the Bill in itself will have to stop talking about the principle of it.

I am afraid of my life of farmers. Farmers talk about everything—education, industry, commerce—but the moment anybody else talks about farming he is at once told that he has no practical knowledge.

Comment on this

And quite wrongly told in some cases.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Counihan would be in a better position to understand the whole matter if he allowed other amendments which are coming on later to be discussed and, perhaps, accepted. He would then be in a better position to see where he stands with regard to herds. I agree with my superiors in knowledge in this matter that the herd is a very important person on a farm and if his work is so vital to the farmer, why should he be prevented from getting a half-day's pay or the half-holiday? I do not understand that at all. The effect of this amendment is that the unimportant worker gets a half-holiday or a half-day's pay but the herd gets neither a half-day nor a half-day's pay. If that is so, it seems to be a most unjust thing. This amendment, in its present form, would work out very badly for the very people for whom Senator Counihan seems to have admiration.

There is another point. There is no definition of a herd in this Bill. Some definition is required in the Bill. Senator Counihan referred to the case of a man who works in the west for more than one farmer. He would appear to me not to be an agricultural labourer but an independent contractor. Perhaps the word is too elaborate for a person of that type. Therefore, he is not what this Bill describes as an agricultural worker employed under a contract of service by a particular farmer.

I would suggest that if Senator Counihan puts the amendment now and carries it, as he might, it would certainly need amendment afterwards. If he puts it and loses it, then he loses his chance of doing anything more about the matter. It would be much better if, instead of excluding a particular type of worker from this Bill, we went on to discuss certain amendments, for example, amendment No. 10 by Senator Orpen, and certain amendments by Senator Hawkins. We can then go into this question of excluding a certain class of person. I would suggest that this amendment, as it stands, would not be workable and would have the immediate effect of preventing this particular member from getting either a half-holiday or a half-day's pay. I must assume that we have to work within the framework of the Bill as we have it.

Comment on this

I am not going to say very much on this Bill. I have confessed on previous occasions my ignorance of agricultural affairs. I was rather surprised at Senator Counihan taking us all to task because we dared interfere and speak on matters regarding agriculture. I suggest that, although I myself may be ignorant in relation to agricultural matters, I might know as much about agriculture as Senator Counihan knows about closed trades. That is quite possible.

The question I would like to have defined—I agree with Senator Hayes— is, what is a herd? From the way Senators have been speaking about herds, I think they have been talking about stewards rather than about herds. The type of man I know that looks after the stock is the type of man I feel who is one of the most depressed of agricultural workers and not the type of man who, long ago, I saw going round in leggings and hard hat riding a white horse. That is not the type I have in mind. The type I have in mind is the man who has to do drudgery on the farm.

The principle of the Bill has been spoken against. I have realised for a long time that, when a man talks about something being against his principle, he generally means something is against his interests. You know the story of the man who, on principle, would not pay the interest and it was against his interest to pay the principal. I believe that Senator Counihan would be well advised to take Senator Hayes' advice that if this amendment is passed we will then want a definition of what is a herd.

Comment on this

He is defined in the amendment as a worker whose principal work on the farm is the care and management of the stock. If you read the amendment——

Comment on this

I have read the amendment. There are varied and different types of people minding stock and the type of people minding stock about whom Senator Counihan spoke might be on a different plane and in a different category to the men on other farms. They might be different people altogether. I am certainly satisfied that some definition of the word "herd" is required.

I think the point made by Senator Hawkins is one that should commend itself to us. I oppose the principle of pay in lieu of a holiday. I appreciate that there are difficulties in agricultural matters which are not found in industrial affairs and that provisions have to be made for a man taking money in lieu of a holiday. I suggest that it is most unfair to say that because a herd is a herd he should not get compensation if he has to work during his half-holiday. Every reform creates problems and it is a question of trying to meet these problems. I want to say that there is co-operation between the farmers and the workers which is not found generally in industrial affairs. I believe that the farm labourer is prepared to co-operate to the fullest extent with the farmer. The difficulties that are seen in this revolutionary idea of a half-holiday for workers can be overcome, and in another 12 months, when the thing is working, we will all wonder what we were talking about.

Comment on this

I oppose this amendment, because I consider it unfair to single out a class of worker on a farm, especially, as Senator Hawkins said, as the nature of his employment places him in an awkward position when it comes to pressing for a betterment of his conditions. The Bill, as it stands, seems to me to have sufficient flexibility to permit a herd or any other worker to remain at work when circumstances require that he should do so. As I have said before, the prosperity of the farm is as much the concern of the worker, be he herd or any other class of worker, as it is of the farmer himself.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

I am a little confused with regard to this matter of exactly what is a herd and my interpretation of a herd seems to differ from that of others; but as in this Bill we are trying to equate to some extent, conditions on the farm with those of the town worker, the parallel would seem to me to be that the herd is not an agricultural worker as much as a salaried official because, in my experience, the herd is a paid charge-hand. He has no hours; he arranges his own hours of work according to the work. He is a completely free individual and therefore is not like the ordinary agricultural worker or any other worker who works to time. If that is so—and that is the practice in certain counties where there are a few of these real herds who are responsible for a large number of animals—it seems to me that we are trying to bring within the ambit of this Bill a number of men who really do not fit into the scheme of the Bill.

I take it that the object of the Bill is to provide a relief from the laborious work of the farm, the manual work that goes on from morning to night six days a week. That is not the life of a herd at all. He works very hard occasionally, and his responsibility undoubtedly extends over the 24 hours, but I maintain that, strictly speaking, the true herd does not fit into the definition of an agricultural worker at all. He is a specialist—you may call him a charge hand—and a salaried man rather than an ordinary agricultural worker. I quite agree that we possibly should proceed to discuss other amendments, as Senator Hayes suggested, but I want to say that I do not feel convinced by the arguments in favour of a herd falling within the ambit of this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

It was said long ago that a rose by any other name would smell as sweet, and this amendment stinks in my nostrils. The Bill deals with agricultural workers, and it defines what an agriculture worker is. It defines an agricultural worker as a person employed whose work is or includes work in agriculture, and agriculture is defined as including dairy farming and the use of land for grazing, meadow or pasture land, and so on. Therefore, a man herding cattle on a mountainside, a man looking after live stock for a farmer, is engaged in agricultural work, and is an agricultural worker as defined by this Bill. Any attempt to take any agricultural workers out from under this Bill and to deprive them of benefits is an unfair attempt.

It may not be Senator Counihan's or Senator Baxter's desire that any one section of agricultural workers should be worse treated than the others, but, if the amendment were passed, this section of workers, who are undefinable and undefined, would be worse treated. Any farmer who wanted to say that his man was mainly engaged in looking after live stock would have a perpetual cause of conflict with his employees. He could say: "You are looking after the cows; you are looking after the feeding of the pigs; and you are looking after the horses. You are mainly engaged with live stock," but still they would all be agricultural workers and you would be picking out a few for concessions, whether good or bad—at least the Bill proposes to give certain rights —and deliberately excluding others. Since the Bill is meant to apply to all agricultural workers anything which attempts to segregate them, anything which attempts to make a difference between them, and to say that one man shall get the benefit of this legislation and another shall not, will only make for ill-will between the farmer and his employees.

I have heard it said, when it suited people to say it, that there never was anywhere more harmony than there is between the farmer and his employees, and the same people stand up almost the next day and argue that there never was such bitter animosity, such hatred and such irreconcilable differences as there are between the farmer and his men, and that, once you give a man a right, he will enforce it against the farmer at whatever consequence to the live stock or the crops. They do not put it as bluntly as that, but that is what it means. We are told that he will walk out and leave the cattle to die in the field; we are told that he will walk out and leave the sheep neglected on the mountainside and the cattle unmilked in the byre. I do not believe that any agricultural worker has such antagonism for his employer as that, whether he be a herd or an ordinary agricultural worker engaged in the routine work of a farm. The farmer and his man will maintain a good relationship and, giving him the right, without compelling him to enforce that right, is not going to injure the farmer, but taking that right from any section of agricultural workers is going to make trouble and put this House to the indignity of having to swallow its own amendments by and by when another Bill is brought in to reverse whatever adverse decision you might be able to secure here to-day.

Comment on this

I know nothing about farming, but I do know something about the difficulties in enforcing half-holiday, early closing and other legislation of which I have been in favour and in which I have been interested for many years. That is the only reason I intervene in this discussion. I agree substantially with what Senator Hawkins and Senator Hayes also said, but it seems to me that a difficulty may arise which is not dealt with in the Bill and which, in the interests both of the promoters and of the farmers, should be dealt with on Report Stage.

It would appear from the discussion —and I am depending on what has been said in the discussion—that there are certain persons employed to do a particular job but not fixed by hours. Where a man has to do a job and there are no fixed hours, you cannot provide for four hours off as provided in the Bill. Instead of exempting any particular class of persons, for the smooth working of the Bill and to avoid friction, it would be wise so to arrange that persons whose terms of contract provide for specific services and who fix their own hours shall not come within the Bill. That would probably meet the case of a certain type as suggested here. It would be a practical way of dealing with it; it would not cut across the principle of the Bill; and it would help to get the Bill enforced. Quite obviously, if you provide for four hours off in a 52 or 48-hour week, if a man has no number of hours fixed as part of his contract, there is no way of providing four hours out of it and therefore it is unworkable. In the interests of the Bill, it would be well if Senator Counihan would withdraw his amendment and let some of us get together and see what we can do to arrive at a satisfactory solution of this problem.

Comment on this

It is suggested that the definition of the word "herd" will cause confusion. I thought I made it plain enough for any man to understand, even in a court of law. I said that a herd is a man whose principal work on the farm is the care and management of live stock. I should have thought that that definition would meet even the Professor.

Comment on this

Yes, but the trouble is would it meet the lawyers?

Comment on this

Senator O'Farrell threatens that if this Bill does not pass as it stands a new Bill will be introduced. He must have hopes that Labour will be the next Government.

Comment on this

The Senator should deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

If I understood Senator O'Farrell correctly, Labour are the Government.

Comment on this

Senator M. Hayes has suggested that I should withdraw this amendment and that I will have an opportunity of reintroducing it on the Report Stage. Accordingly, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment on condition that I can reintroduce it on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I wonder if those who are sponsoring the Bill would explain the meaning of the word "contract" in this and in subsequent sections.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

I will explain it.

Comment on this

There is no need for me or for anybody in this House to define what is meant by "contract of service". I understand that in legal practice the term "contract of service" is very well understood. If it came to a question of the courts I think there would be no doubt whatsoever as to the definition of that term.

Comment on this

Is it something that we are all supposed to understand and yet do not understand?

Comment on this

Take for example a person who is thinning beet by contract. Is the "contract" referred to here? I assume not. The harvesting and the thinning of beet by contract is very common in the beet growing districts.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

My interpretation of Section 1 is that it is a wage contract. Section 2 says that the contract shall be for a period of not less than one week. Everybody who makes an arrangement with an employer for work makes a contract as to hours and wages. I think you must take "contract" in that loose definition. In Section 2 it is confined to people where the contract is for a period of not less than one week. Whether that would cover the thinning of beet or not I do not know.

Comment on this

I am still not satisfied with the explanation of "contract of service". Senator O'Callaghan has mentioned a contract in relation to the thinning of beet. Would a farmer who enters into a contract with some man to thin beet, and who employs other people to carry out that work of thinning beet, be covered by the definition? I think everybody will readily agree that that is not what is meant by the term "contract of service" in this Bill. Senator Dr. O'Connell says that the term is so well understood by everybody that there is no need to define it. It may be that it is already defined in the Agricultural Wages Act. If that is so, it should be stated in this Bill now that the term "contract of service" means what it is defined as in that particular Act. So far as this Bill is concerned the term is most ambiguous. An amendment might be needed on the Report Stage in order to clarify the position. It may be that it is impossible to define it.

I understand that, in relation to another Bill, the question of a fair price was something that everybody understood but that nobody could define. Again, it would seem that people had their own definition of "herd" but that nobody could write a definition of the word. I submit that there should be a definition of the expression "contract of service" in order to avoid misunderstanding.

Comment on this

Senator O'Callaghan's question can be answered as follows. The type of contract into which a farmer enters in connection with ploughing or the carrying out of other particular work does not come within the provisions of this Bill because that is for the carrying out of a particular type of work. It is usual in the country to enter into a contract for the threshing of wheat——

Comment on this

Or the thinning of beet.

Comment on this

An independent contract.

Comment on this

This Bill applies only where there is agreement to pay a weekly or a monthly wage.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that none of the sponsors of this Bill will offer to define the term?

Comment on this

Has Senator Hawkins not just done so?

Comment on this

He has not.

Comment on this

Neither Senator Hawkins nor I can give an authoritative definition. The best we can do is to explain what we understand by the term "contract". I might give an explanation to Senator O'Reilly which would satisfy him, but, if the question came up in a court of law my explanation or the explanation of Senator Hawkins might not be worth anything at all. The obvious commonsense explanation is that given by Senator Hawkins.

Comment on this

It would be well for this House to understand the meaning of the term. I do not know what it means. In the beet-growing districts the thinning of beet is done by contract and the harvesting of beet is done by contract. Is that the type of contract mentioned in this section or is it not?

Comment on this

Suppose a farmer brings in a man to thresh his corn; if he is engaged for two, three or four days it could not be suggested that the owner of the threshing mill should get a half-day.

Comment on this

I think I might give a case which would make the matter clearer. It is quite a common practice for small farmers with a reasonable amount of tillage to arrange to pay a certain sum to a labourer to do a particular piece of work, and he will start that piece of work in the morning and go on until sundown just to get that work done. Where a contract of that sort is entered into the half-day does not apply. That is what Senator O'Callaghan was puzzled about.

Comment on this

It is a contract of service.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In sub-section (1), line 23, before the word "employed" to insert the word "permanently," and in lines 23 and 24 to delete the words "on a contract for a period of not less than one week."

I am sure that the purpose of this amendment is very clear. It excludes from the Bill all except permanent employees on a farm. What I dislike about the section is that if I take on a man temporarily, before he is there a week at all he must get a half-day. I think that is very undesirable, and its net effect will be that fewer people will be employed. I do not want to go back over the argument about the original intention of the promoters of the Bill or the results which will accrue from the form which the Bill has now taken. I know that it can be argued against my amendment that if it be accepted, temporary employees will be paid less per week. I am sure that Senator O'Callaghan and others who are concerned with finding labour will agree that the fact is that men are just not available, and can practically fix their own price.

I am quite satisfied that very few agricultural workers work for the minimum wage—I do not know of any. Even the temporary employee is not going to work for the minimum agricultural wage. The net result of the Bill will be that men will be paid more; they will not take a holiday. That is what one would desire, but this is not the way to do it; it is a left-handed way of doing a thing that should be tackled from a different angle altogether.

As an employer, I dislike being put in the position that if I employ a man for only two days he must get a half-day. My idea is that it should not be Saturday. It is a very unsatisfactory situation that an employer must make this concession to a man he has taken on for a short time, and employers will hesitate about taking on this type of person. It is something which should be dispensed with. Where men are permanently employed the basis is entirely different. I put down the amendment because I wanted to state my point of view.

Comment on this

In this amendment we are up against the same difficulty with which we were faced on the last— the question of definition. When is a man permanently employed? Senator Baxter will say, and rightly so: "We all know when a man is permanently employed", but that is not sufficient. An employer could, if he wished, defeat the object of the Bill by never employing a man permanently in the sense that Senator Baxter means by permanence. He could employ a man for a few months and then knock him of and employ somebody else. What is meant exactly by "permanently"? That is my difficulty. I can quite see that all sorts of trouble would result if the amendment were accepted.

Comment on this

I was rather amused to hear Senator O'Connell questioning the meaning of the word "permanently". It is funny that he used the very same argument in favour of leaving the wording "contract of employment" as it was. I agree that there is something in this point of view. Just as "contract of employment" should be clearly defined, so should "permanently" be clearly defined. I quite sympathise with the viewpoint which I think is behind Senator Baxter's amendment, but he should have specified that "permanently" meant within the meaning of the Act 50 days, 100 days or 200 days as he thought fit. It was funny to hear Senator O'Connell using this argument in favour of different points of view in these two matters.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter could have made a better case if his amendment catered for the casual employee. Quite a number of persons have been employed on the land for a long period of years and have become part and parcel of the family. When their services are not such as might be expected from young and active people they are kept on because of their past associations with the family. We are now legislating to give such persons a half-holiday, as well as an annual holiday, or in lieu of that increased pay, with the result that such persons are in a more unfavourable position than they were up to this because it is quite possible that the employer might consider that a man who had given faithful service over the years had now reached a stage when he could not do the work of a young and active person, and now that a half-day was being forced upon him the best thing he could do would be to take on a younger person. Senator Baxter could have made a case that the half-day should apply to permanent employees but not to persons taken on from time to time at seasonal work. If we are to encourage young people in rural districts to accept employment from farmers, we must give them the same facilities as are given to workers for Bord na Móna or for a local authority.

Comment on this

Regarding the definition of "permanently", farmers who fill up forms regarding farm employment in order to get relief from rates have to define the number of persons employed.

Comment on this

It might not be the same person.

Comment on this

Wait a moment. We have to give the number of permanent employees. Even if I have a man for 240 days, if he is not with me for the full year I am not entitled to obtain remission of rates on his account. That is my interpretation of "permanently" employed and I hope Senator O'Connell accepts it. Senator Hawkins said I could have made a better case on behalf of those in permanent employment who because of this may be dropped. Some of the people I am thinking of are the sons of neighbouring farmers. They do not want to be permanently employed. They have work to do on their own farms but can take a week off and go to a neighbour. That takes place all over the country. I believe these people are paid more than the standard rate of wages and that the question of a half-day does not, and should not, enter into it, and they should not come under this legislation at all.

Comment on this

On the question of definition, I am sorry I have to correct Senator Baxter. I am a farmer myself and employ agricultural labourers and every January I get the form to which Senator Baxter refers. It asks me to state the number of men employed continuously during the 12 months ended the 31st December—not necessarily permanently, as we could get the relief if we employed a different man every week, so long as there was no interval of unemployment.

Comment on this

The Senator knows that that does not happen.

Comment on this

It could happen. I feel that this form is of no benefit to Senator Baxter's argument and does not help to define what "permanent" means.

Comment on this

Senator O'Connell's definition is amusing.

Comment on this

I did not define it.

Comment on this

The Senator disagreed with Senator Baxter. A farmer would have a nice job procuring the unemployment insurance card numbers every week, where he employed a man as in the case Senator O'Connell makes. I think Senator Baxter's motion should be accepted. This is only one instance where the Bill will create the utmost confusion. Take the case of men employed for a few days threshing or, as Senator O'Callaghan pointed out, the beet thinners and those employed under contract. Those will come under the scheme and must get the half-day, according to the Bill as it stands at presents. This is the result of the Labour Party trying to legislate for agriculture, when they know nothing about it.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter's attempted explanation cannot be accepted on this. In the sending of information to the county council, in order to get a rebate for agricultural labourers, it is for past service, which would mean that before the labourer could get a holiday he must be at least 12 months with that particular farmer. I do not think that could be accepted. If we accept the principle, we must ensure that it will apply justly all round.

Senator Counihan referred again to the points raised by Senator O'Callaghan: It is quite clear that where work is undertaken by a contractor this Bill does not apply, no more than it would if an ordinary person gave a contract to a builder to erect a house. It would not be that person's responsibility to ensure that the workers got a holiday: it would be the contractor's duty to do that.

Comment on this

If this amendment is accepted and the word "permanent" left in, too many abuses would take place. In fact, the whole purpose of the Bill could be defeated. Some farmers would endeavour to arrange that they would never have a permanent employee. We must remember that legislation is for all farmers and not for the good farmers only.

Comment on this

The amendment is one which could not be accepted. The majority of farm labourers would be cut out from the benefits of the Bill. As it stands, if a man is employed for a week he is entitled to a half-day. There is no use in Senator Counihan telling us we should not talk about this as we know nothing about it: we know probably as much about agriculture as he knows about closed trades.

Comment on this

No one is disputing anyone's right to express his views on this measure. We have a right to discuss everything that comes along. I assure Senator Miss Davidson that there is nothing further from our minds than to introduce something which would cause difficulty. There may be some farmers who would attempt to do what she suggests, but they are not representative of the farming community. If that were the way the farmers acted, it would be a dark day for agriculture. As far as I am concerned, and my neighbours too, the men are working for years and years. To suggest that there are farmers who would try to play ducks and drakes with this measure or act in such a way that they would have a different employee every week so as to evade this half-holiday legislation, is to suggest something completely unrepresentative of the facts about Irish agriculture. If that were tried once or twice, it would not be tried a third time, as that farmer would not have any men the next week. I have not changed my point of view. It does not seem that the House is with me, but it is my view still.

Comment on this

I do not think the word "permanently" is one which could be construed in a court and which could have a practical meaning. If there is to be a half-holiday for agricultural workers, for people employed under contract of service to work a specific number of hours per day, I do not see why a person who is employed casually for a week or a fortnight should not get his half-holiday, if there is going to be one at all, as well as a person employed over a period of 12 months. If it is going to be worked at all, let it be worked all round. I think Senator Baxter's object could only be achieved by differentiating between people who are employed for a longer period. I think it is very invidious and difficult to create two different classes of labourers, one who is entitled to a half-holiday and the other who is not. Again, when we come to the other amendment here, we will find we are nearer to a solution of the problem than by this particular type of amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

In sub-section (1), line 24, to delete all words after the word "half-holiday" and substitute therefor "of four consecutive hours, exclusive of meal hour, on a day agreed on by worker and employer in respect of each week so worked".

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would the Senator postpone the debate on the principle of his amendment (the days agreed upon by worker and employer) as it would anticipate the debate on amendments Nos. 10, 11 and 12?

Comment on this

You mean then to hold over this?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Yes, that particular portion of it.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this

Would you read that again, please?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There are two principles in this amendment (1) to make it clear that the four hours are consecutive and exclude mealtime, and (2) to have the days agreed upon by worker and employer. The Senator should be asked to postpone the debate on the second principle, as it would anticipate the debate on amendments Nos. 10, 11 and 12.

Comment on this

You wish me to deal with the question of the four consecutive hours?

Comment on this

Could we come back to the whole matter of that amendment again? I think it would include amendment No. 10, Senator Orpen's amendment. We could come back again, by agreement?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Yes.

Comment on this

We will come back for the whole of it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

In sub-section (2), line 30, after the word "rate" to add the words "in addition to his ordinary weekly wages."

That is really a drafting amendment. It is only inserted for the sake of clarity. I do not think there is any difficulty about that.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

May I say on this amendment that there is no definition under the Wages Act of ordinary weekly wages? Would it not be advisable to use the phraseology of the Agricultural Wages Act, which is a little more complicated but at least it is a fixed thing. The word "wages" is defined in the Agricultural Workers (Holidays) Bill, 1949. It does not use the words "ordinary wage" but it uses some phrase meaning the average weekly earnings for that individual worker. I will get it for the House.

Comment on this

I suggest that the sub-section is definite—"not less than the equivalent of four hours' pay." That would be the wage rate a man would be paid for the week.

Comment on this

The Senators might read: "in respect of such half-holiday a sum not less than the equivalent of four hours' pay." That might be read very narrowly to mean he would get no extra payment. That was my purpose in putting in the amendment.

Comment on this

I think it is necessary.

Comment on this

Without that it might mean he would get no extra payment. Assuming that the commonsense meaning is accepted, I would be quite willing to withdraw this and put in the legal phraseology if it covers the same point.

Comment on this

I take it that the Senator is withdrawing it and bringing it up again on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In sub-section (3) to delete all words following the word "him" in line 34 and insert "wages in respect of that half-holiday as provided by the foregoing sub-section".

It is just a matter of making some slight alteration in sub-section (3). It then reads:—

"Where a worker instead of taking the half-holiday which he is to be allowed under this section, remains at work with his employer's consent, the employer shall be deemed to have allowed the half-holiday to the worker if he pays him wages in respect of that half-holiday as provided by the foregoing sub-section."

As far as my information goes, a worker who forgoes a half-holiday and who is not paid wages in lieu of it is not in a position to recover or prosecute. If the word "remuneration" is left in, he can prosecute or recover wages or proscture in respect of remuneration. This particularly refers to people who are working under the system of contract. The question of contract has been discussed here to-day for some time and there seems to be some foggy mix-up as to what it means. In several parts of the country it has been the custom to employ workers on a contract basis for one, two or six months, or whatever it might be. If the word "wages" were included, it would bring it under the Agricultural Wages Board, and then the worker would be in a position to recover in cases where wages were withheld.

Comment on this

I see no necessity for the amendment. I think the section is explicit enough. It says:

"... the employer shall be deemed to have allowed the half-holiday to the worker if he pays him in addition to wages the half-holiday remuneration provided by the foregoing sub-section."

Comment on this

I do not think so. I have cited the case of a person working on a contract basis. Such a person has no defined hours and remuneration may mean that the employer gives him three or four hours on Sunday or tells him on Monday, if it is raining, that he can go home and come back at 2 o'clock. I ask the Seanad to accept the substitution of "wages" for "remuneration". It is not going to do any harm, if it is not going to do any good.

Comment on this

It is "remuneration provided by the foregoing sub-section," which says that it must be the equivalent of four hours' pay at the ordinary wage rate.

Comment on this

If an employer tells a person working on contract that he will give him four hours' remuneration on a Sunday and claims that as part of his wages, would the Senator consider it fair?

Comment on this

That would defeat the whole purpose of the Bill.

Comment on this

That is why I ask the Seanad to accept this slight alteration. It will not make any difference to the Bill and, as I say, if it does not do any good, it will not do any harm.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Colgan. I do not see much point in the amendment and I suggest that we should adopt the procedure we have adopted in relation to other amendments, of having them looked into. Senator McCrea made a reference to contracts and I think the introduction of this word has given rise to a lot of confusion. I think we should be quite clear that we are legislating only for persons who give their services for wages, weekly, fortnightly or monthly, and not for persons who enter into a contract to do a type of work over a particular period. You could have the case of a farmer employing a contractor under the farm improvements scheme. These people could be regarded as being, in a sense, agricultural workers, but the farmer would not be compelled by this legislation to accept the responsibility of seeing that persons employed by the contractor to do the particular work or any other job got a half-holiday. The best thing to do is to have it looked into before Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am perfectly clear with regard to the points raised by Senator Hawkins, but he is evidently not clear with regard to the point I am making. There are such things as hiring fairs—we do not have such fairs in my county, where men are engaged on a weekly basis, but I understand that it is the practice in the northern counties and in some of the southern counties—at which men are employed on a basis of six or 12 months. These are the people I am referring to.

Comment on this

Surely Senator McCrea should know that—whether by verbal contract or tacit understanding —an arrangement is made between a farmer and an agricultural workers that the worker will work for the farmer over a particular period of, say, six months. I do not think the Senator need have any fears about such an arrangement at a hiring fair, because any such contract so entered into, whether verbally, by tacit understanding or even written, is quite void if it clashes with the terms of the legislation which sets down the wages and conditions of agricultural workers and the responsibilities of agricultural employers to them.

While the Senator has made a case for the general principle of the Bill, he is really trying to defeat that principle, because what he has in mind is that contracts of employment can be entered into at hiring fairs, or even at some place in County Wicklow, after Mass, by which a farmer will employ a worker for six months on the basis of a contract, which, so far as wages and conditions are concerned, may not be at all in conformity with the agricultural wages prescribed and may not fulfil the other statutory requirements laid down. As I say, if these contracts are not in conformity with these statutory requirements, they are void, and, that being so, I do not think there is any case at all for the change proposed.

Comment on this

I suggest to Senator McCrea that he should not press this amendment, but should look into it further, because I am not at all satisfied that he may not defeat his whole purpose. He is seeking to remove, for some reason which he has not made clear, the words "in addition to wages" and I think there might be a legal doubt created by doing so. It is extremely important from his point of view to make it clear that whatever is paid should be in addition to wages and I suggest that he leave the section as it stands. He is trying to get over a difficulty which is not quite clear to me with regards to certain types of employment, but I do not think he does it by this amendment and there is a danger that he may defeat his purpose.

Comment on this

I am prepared to leave it over until Report Stage, and have it further examined.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (4), line 41, to delete all words after the word "exceeding" and substitute the words "five pounds, together with payment to the worker of the half-holiday remuneration accruing under sub-section (2) to such worker provided that such payment shall not exceed the total of the half-holiday remuneration over a period of two months".

The sub-section provides:—

If an agricultural employer fails to allow a half-holiday to an agricultural worker or pay him in respect of a half-holiday in accordance with this section he shall be guilty of an offence under this subsection and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £20.

I consider that £20 is too heavy a penalty to inflict for what one might term a "pass-over" mistake. I have already drawn the attention of the House to the good relations existing between the farmer and his employee, and we are dealing here with workers who may have grown up with the family, who probably are not alone agricultural workers but, to a great extent, have nursed every member of the family. There might be cases in which such a worker would not require or would not take a half-holiday. A position might arise in which the relations between that worker and the family were not so good and in which the employment was terminated at the end of a certain number of months or years. The position then would be that, while that employee, by his own wish, declined to assert the right we are giving him to a half-holiday, or to payment in lieu thereof, he, having left the farmer's employment, could have him fined £20. There is another flaw that I see in the sub-section and my object is to reduce the amount of the fine to £5. I am not so happy even about the £5, but when we accept that it is an offence for an employer not to comply with the provisions of this Bill, while we might regard £20 as extreme, I think £5 would meet the case.

In the Bill as it stands, no provision is made where by a worker may recoup money which he should have been given when he did not take the half-holiday. Here again I am confining the sum of money for which he is in a position to sue this employer to two months: probably eight weeks would be better. Where an employee has failed to exercise his right over eight, ten or 12 months, or a longer period, it would be most unfair that he should be in a position to sue his employer for a sum covering the full length of that period. This is a reasonable amendment and one which would probably improve the Bill. It would remove the impediment that might be there. It can quite easily be understood that a farmer might overlook the passage of this measure and that his worker might not be interested in getting the half-holiday. Attention would have to be given to such a set of circumstances. I suppose that there will be inspectors just as there are inspectors in connection with the enforcement of other measures. If a long period had elapsed, I think it would be most unfair on the employer. For that reason, I think we should treat both parties as lightly as possible and induce the farmer and the worker to avail of whatever benefits may be in this Bill. I think that that would be much better than the imposition of big penalties, thereby creating bad feeling between the employer and the worker.

Comment on this

The following two amendments (No. 9 and No. 14) stand in my name and I should like to know if I may refer to them on the discussion of this amendment:—

"In sub-section (4), line 41, to delete all words after the word ‘exceeding' and substitute therefor ‘the total of wages for eight weekly half-holidays'."

"To add a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) It shall not be lawful for a worker to claim for arrears of half-holiday wages a greater amount than the total of wages for eight such half-holidays, but wages due for half-holidays subsequent to date of claim shall be legally due."

Comment on this

I think we should discuss the amendment moved by Senator Hawkins and, on the result of that discussion, we can decide what to do with these two amendments. The question of arrears of extra wages can be discussed as the general question. Senator Hawkins referred to very heavy penalties. If a penalty of £5, £10, £15 or £20 is provided for in the Bill it does not mean that the court will always exact the maximum penalty. I am certain that the tendency will be in the other direction. A farmer who has deprived his worker of the half-holiday over a long period, and who is eventually brought to court, may be fined only, say, 2/6 or 5/- or something like that. I cannot understand why Senator Hawkins insists that the arrears of extra pay due to the worker will be confined to a two months' period. I am sure that Senator Hawkins will agree that there are many workmen who do not know their rights in this matter and who will not always wish to exercise them. They may be the odd men and not all the workers may be like them. However, here and there you will find a man who, perhaps, may not know anything about his rights and who will be willing to accept whatever his employer tells him. I cannot agree to the suggestion in this amendment or in the other amendments that the amount which the worker will be entitled to recover in respect of the extra wages which have been withheld shall be limited to a period of two months or eight weeks or any other period. I strongly oppose that part of the amendment.

Senator McCrea spoke about another form of contract which Senator O'Reilly did not understand. No doubt arrangements are made in some parts of the country whereby a man may be employed for six months, say, and agrees to accept a certain rate during that period. During all that time it is possible that the man would be denied his half-holiday. In such circumstances the man would only be able to recover eight weeks of the remuneration due. I do not think it is a reasonable amendment.

Comment on this

I have been given permission to refer, on this amendment, to two amendments in my name on the Order Paper—amendments Nos. 9 and 14. We are told that agricultural labourers are so scarce that they are almost impossible to get. From personal experience I know that if an agricultural employee is available, farmers will be glad to get him at any time. For that reason, the agricultural worker has a particular bargaining power at present, and there is no bother about his getting work. The question of any hindrance to his getting work does not, therefore, arise. I submit that the matter of the £20 fine, if he does not get his weekly half-holiday, is not necessary. If he does not get the half-holiday he can very easily change to another employer, and sue his previous employer in respect of the holidays which he did not get. It will be found that there will not be many cases of men not getting a weekly half-holiday over a long period, and if such a case should arise I submit that the employee is as guilty as the employer. On that account, the employee should suffer equally with the employer. That is the reason why I fixed on the period of eight weeks. I considered that if an employee works eight weeks and does not get a half-holiday during that time, he might be regarded as a party to the offence equally with the employer. I agree with Senator Hawkins that when there is to be a punishment for the employer there should always, in that particular way, be a punishment for the employee. I think eight weeks is a reasonable period. I stipulated that it shall not be lawful for a worker to claim for arrears of half-holiday wages a greater amount than the total of wages for eight such half-holidays, but that wages due for half-holidays subsequent to date of claim shall be legally due. I think that that was reasonable, and at the same time, I have allowed that if he continues to work for the employer any wages which may be due for half-holidays subsequent to the date of claim shall be legally due.

Senator Dr. O'Connell did not advert to the fact that the agricultural worker has not, in the Bill as it stands, any method of suing for wages not paid at all.

Comment on this

We have provided for that in amendment No. 15.

Comment on this

When Senator Hawkins was drafting his amendment he was not aware of the drafting of amendment No. 15. His amendment and my amendment, therefore, gave to the employee an opportunity of suing for wages. On many occasions I have read in the Press of an employee of a farmer suing for wages over seven years. The person suing might be a relative of the farmer or just some person who was hanging on and working with him for years. Maybe the old employer had died or may be the employer had had a row with this particular worker and had dispensed with his services. Then this employee sued for perhaps three or four years' wages due. That is a deplorable state of affairs. One of the reasons why I put down this amendment was to ensure that if an employee was so careless of his rights as to forfeit his half-day over a long period he should not be able to claim for more than the number of weeks I have stated.

Comment on this

In my opinion, these amendments are absolutely necessary if this Bill is to be effective at all and if it is not to be injurious both to the people it is designed to benefit and to the other side, the employers.

Senator O'Connell says that in many cases workers do not know their rights. If you were to go down the country at the present time to discuss the Bill with the workers I think you would probably find that Senator O'Connell was right and that many workers did not know what their rights were under this proposed legislation for the simple reason, as I said on the Second Stage, that there was not really any demand for this legislation from the agricultural workers of the country. However, once the Bill becomes law I cannot see that a situation will exist different from that which has always existed as far as legislation is concerned.

If any legislation is passed in this and the other House to benefit any particular section of the community and if any member of the Oireachtas is a little bit vague as to what is meant by that legislation, as we often are, the best thing he could do would be to go down the country and walk as far as he can up a mountainy boreen and the further he goes the more information he will get as long as it affects the people there directly and more power to them. It is a very desirable state of affairs and there is no use in shutting one's eyes to it and saying that the workers of the country will not know their rights. Of course they will know their rights and of course they will insist upon them.

I can see a lot of trouble coming from the Bill unless it is amended before passing its final stages to see that certain things will be provided for. We have had a discussion on the position of the herd and the same situation to a great extent could occur in connection with stud grooms or men employed on stud farms in the country. A good many of those men are employed on a seasonal basis plus their grooms' fees. If it is a man's half-day and he knows that a couple of mares are coming into the stud farm that afternoon he would need to be a bigger fool than any man in that position I know if he walks out. If he stays in he will collect a couple of guineas and has a chance of his wages as well. If he stays without consulting the owner of the farm who might be able to look after the work himself he will, having collected his stud groom's fees, come to the end of the season when he will have spent all his money as people in much more important positions do. He goes to the owner and says: "What are you going to do about this? After all I was entitled to half-holidays all the year and you did not give me a half-holiday." What constitutes an offence on the part of the owner of a stud farm or any other farm? Does he have to take the man by the collar, put him outside the gate, lock the gate and bolt it behind him? Even if he did that the man could say: "I was not in the yard but I was up the fields looking after cattle." Or: "A sheep got caught in some briars and I had to spend the evening getting it out and I had only left it when I met a sheep having lambs and I had to stay with her." You have to be definite.

The reduction of the fine from £20 to £5 is only just in my opinion for the simple reason that if a man wants to prove that he was denied—if you like to word it thus—his half-holiday on a particular day the boss cannot prove that he did not order him out of the place; because he did not put him outside the gate and lock the gate after him he must pay £20. It is an exorbitant fine and would, as Senator Hawkins said, only make for bad feeling.

In the same way the Bill as it stands makes no provision for the workers. While I do not want to fish for any compliments from any section on this matter, I would say that it will make for better feeling and a better working of the Bill if a provision is made whereby workers can claim for no longer a period than eight weeks as Senator Loughman states. If that is done it will help in a lot of ways. First of all it will compensate the worker for such grievances as he may have. On the other hand—which to my mind is also for the benefit of both parties— it will ensure that no worker will continue to miss his half-holiday for an indefinite period. The reason I think that section of Senators Hawkins's and Loughman's amendments not only desirable but necessary is that if a worker is employed by a farmer and if through his own fault he misses his half-holiday or fails to insist on getting it for three or four weeks it is not so bad. If he allows that position to continue for a longer period and carries on for 12 months and then falls out with the farmer and says: "I have been working on my half-holidays for a full 12 months and you will have to pay me now" it will be a very serious problem for the ordinary working farmer. In the interest of both parties, therefore, these amendments are very desirable.

On every stage of the Bill attempts have been made, I can see and I know, to push people to either side. Most of the stud farms are situated in Kildare and I can see a very good reason why the battle-scarred Vice-Premier of the Republic should legislate for one section only of the workers of his own constituency. I am here representing the Horse Owners and Bloodstock Breeders' Association and I appeal to the House to accept those amendments. They will be in the interest of both parties and will make for better feeling.

We are making provision for the man who works on a couple of his half-days; he will be paid for eight of them. If he goes on indefinitely, deliberately or otherwise, he will know that he will not be paid and he will quit after eight weeks. I would strongly appeal that the amendment be accepted, and I can assure the House that nobody will be sorry afterwards.

Comment on this

The question of the fine would not mean very much in practice probably because the amount of the fine will be decided by the court. While the maximum may be £20 a man might be fined £2 or 5/-. I am much more opposed to the second part of the amendment, because I think it entirely wrong that we should enact legislation which denies a man the right to recover what is properly due to him.

Comment on this

Improperly due to him.

Comment on this

It is properly due to him. Without referring to stud farms or anything else it is suggested in the amendments that the employee can recover nothing. No matter how much would be due to him he can only recover to the extent of eight weeks. We have in our legal enactments the Statute of Limitations. Under it one can go back six years. The income-tax people, even though they have not reminded you that the amount is due, can collect for a greater number of years.

Comment on this

There is no limit. It may be 66.

Comment on this

And if you have overpaid you cannot get it back, if there is a mistake.

Comment on this

They will get it, anyway. It is suggested that if a man does not draw the half-holiday pay for a number of weeks, that may be done deliberately. The farmer knows what the result will be, that the labourer will look for it. The farmer is equally responsible for allowing it to accumulate. He should not be permitted to allow the worker to fail to exercise his right, in the hope that no matter how long it goes on he will be responsible in the end only for eight weeks' payment. It would be wrong to put into this measure anything which would interfere with the right of a man to recover what is lawfully due to him and what should have been paid regularly to him.

Take the question of stamping an insurance card. Sometimes an employee will not bother about it and perhaps a farm labourer may not even know his obligations. If a farmer, however, fails to stamp the card over a long period of years he will have to do it in the end, and there is no question of confining him to eight stamps. The proposal in either of the amendments is quite wrong. I notice in Senator Loughman's amendment that he would not even fine the employee at all.

Comment on this

There is a fine. It is stated separatelty.

Comment on this

Except that he would have to pay for eight weeks. Surely the Senator does not suggest that that is proper punishment, in a case where there might be 28 weeks due. I could not accept the amendment for the reasons I have stated.

Comment on this

Senator Hawkins suggests a penalty of £5 and someone else suggests £25. It is perfectly clear that this is to cover a half-holiday. Therefore, the fine is for one instance. I think both are too high. You cannot get good will by colossal penalties which you know that no judge will impose. I support Senator Hawkins regarding £5 and think even £2 would be sufficient, because it is clearly a continuing offence.

On the second point, I do not quite agree with Senator O'Connell. I have a good deal of sympathy with the aim of amendment No. 14, but it may require redrafting. Senator Hawkins' amendment by itself will not meet the case, as the reference to two months does not give any date. That may be met to some extent by Senator Loughman's amendment. The House should realise that this is not a simple Bill, not nearly so simple as Senator O'Connell thinks. If an employee works on the half-day, that does not entitle him to payment. He has to prove that for each day he got his employer's consent. That is the Bill as it stands. This is an effort to get a half-day for as many agricultural workers as possible, and I am supporting that principle and any criticism I make is to try to make it work. My opinion is that it is not practicable to sue for more than about eight weeks, as the necessary proof, that the employer gave his consent, could not be proved in any court for a period of, say, a year, as the Senator suggests. You are really helping the worker by drawing his attention to the fact that he must give notice. The point made by Senator Loughman is extremely important. It is eight weeks back from the day he claims. When he claims, certainly after that he should be entitled, as the case may not be settled for many weeks. I do not think Senator Hawkins intended to stop that. The two amendments should be combined, or a new one put in. To make this practicable, there must be some limit and workers all over the country must be told that, if there is a doubt in regard to the payment, they should claim it within at least eight weeks. Once they make the claim, they should get also whatever they are entitled to afterwards.

In the very nature of this Bill, there are many doubts. There is not going to be a dispute about the payment of an amount, but if there is not goodwill between worker and farmer there will in many cases be a dispute as to whether the consent was asked or whether the man worked at all on the half-day. Where there is some uncertainty as to hours, there will be doubt as to whether or not the man got the four days. I honestly believe that for the protection of the workman there should be some limit, within a period which can be proved.

Comment on this

I see one weakness in the amendment, and in Senator Douglas's support of it. It means that the farm labourer would be suing for about £2 or £3, the amount of eight half-days' wages and the question is whether it is worth his while going to law.

Comment on this

There would be this inducement, that he would not continue to work more than the eight weeks.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I want to support Senator Loughman's amendment. Half of the people who work on agricultural holdings are either small farmers or relatives of the people for whom they work, and it would create very bad blood if there were claims made for three, four or five years. It might tend to cause family feuds. For that reason alone, I think it is necessary to adopt Senator Loughman's amendment. I am sorry that Senator Colgan did not make any reply to that. That was the main point Senator Loughman made in his amendment.

With regard to some of the points raised by Senator Quirke, there is probably need for clarification in the definition in connection with the stud farm. Stud farms are not mentioned in the definition at all.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

I hope that no agricultural labourer will ever have to go to law with his employer. I would be in favour of having a reduced penalty, because if you have a penalty of £20 it is rather a threatening amount. The courts will never impose a penalty of £20. The maximum penalty is very seldom imposed. It gives the impression that somebody wants to be vindictive. Senator O'Connell has given some of the reasons already for rejecting the limitation to eight weeks or two months. We must enable the worker to claim what he is legally entitled to. No Senator would accept this in relation to his own business. No farmer would accept it and no auctioneer either. There is a Statute of Limitations and we must not make a new Statute of Limitations for the most helpless and yet the most essential section of the community. The agricultural workers are the least well paid.

I do not think that anybody is likely to allow their half-day compensation to accumulate, because the Bill itself provides that the half-day must be given within fourteen days. If a man chooses not to take the half-day and says to the farmer that he will not take the half-day that week but will take the money instead, it is quite obvious that the farmer will be willing to pay and the worker willing to accept the money.

It was made abundantly clear in this House that a penal clause was necessary. One Senator has said: "Pass what law you like but never will I pay a man employed by me for a half-day that he has off in the week." That statement was made here by a Senator.

Comment on this

Who made it?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

It was made by Senator Bennett, when Senator Counihan was not here, on account of the snow. I said he was bluffing. I do not think it is right for any man, a member of the legislature, to get up in advance and say that he is going to treat the law with contempt. If there are such people as that, they justify the workers' right to recover over any period their claims may run. I do not believe there are many people who will do that, nor do I believe that Senator Bennett will do it either. If there is anybody who is going to flout the law of this country, let him put up with the consequences.

We had enough about ill-will between employers and employees in other sections of industry when the half-holiday was introduced, when the limitation of hours was introduced and when factory legislation was brought into force. All these things were denounced and decried as impositions on the employer, and we were told that they would make for ill-will. They did not. The Bill will not make for ill-will. In the interests of goodwill, Senator O'Connell might perhaps agree that the maximum penalty should be reduced from £20 to £5. At least, that would be a demonstration that this is not a Bill intended to penalise the farmer.

Comment on this

I find it very difficult to take some of the statements made here seriously at all.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

We all do.

Comment on this

Particularly, some of the statements made by Senator O'Farrell. Senator O'Farrell stands up in righteous wrath, if we are to accept his attitude, at the suggestion that the back payment, if you like to put it in plain language, for half-holidays should be limited to eight weeks. Senator O'Connell, in his statement, resented the suggestion also, and said that it was not done in connection with any other Bill and they asked why, therefore, it should be done in connection with this.

As I said previously, we have running through every discussion on this Bill from the Second Stage—it will go on to the last stage—a sort of pink ribbon, I will not call it red, an attempt to put one side of this House in the position where the workers of this country must be protected from the other people. I do not accept that position. I say that the protection of the workers of this country is quite safe in the hands of the majority of the members of this House. I yield to no man in my sympathy for and interest in the workers of this country. I do not know if there is anybody else in this House, there may be one, who in actual fact worked as an agricultural worker on the land for a day's wages. I did. Therefore, I ought to know what I am talking about. Right through the discussion on this Bill an attempt has been made, and I know it will succeed, to introduce industrial conditions on the land. Senator O'Connell and Senator O'Farrell do not seem to realise the possibility of a situation arising where the agricultural worker walks up to the farmer and salutes him by his first name: "Now, Jack, I want to have a talk with you about this legislation they are introducing in the Dáil. I am not interested in this half-holiday. We will work away." Has Senator O'Farrell realised any such situation as that arising?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

Very often.

Comment on this

That really can happen and will happen in a good many cases. It will go on for a certain length of time, until something happens to break up the diplomatic relations between the farmer and his man. Then the trouble will start. While some speakers who have spoken against these amendments could not say it would cause any embarrassment to the farmers to pay the half-holiday pay, I can assure the Senators that if there is any little change and that farmers are brought back by world conditions to the condition of "pulling the devil by the tail", the paying back of half-holiday pay for a long period might mean the breaking up of the farm altogether.

Apart altogether from the ordinary working man who is employed on a farm in the traditional way of this country, there is another type altogether. The type I have in mind is the man who goes to work, as Senator Burke says, for some of his relatives. The man I have in mind is the man who goes to work for his father's first cousin. He goes there not so much for the purpose of getting a job as in the hope that he will justify his position on the farm and eventually inherit the farm. I am assuming that the farmer is a bachelor. There is no talk about a half-holiday and the law in this or any other country does not operate to the effect that this man will be stamping a card. He is only helping on the farm; he is loaned by his grandmother. It finally gets to the stage where he has been working on the farm for seven or eight years. He is then in the position that he can blackmail the owner of that farm by saying to him, "If you do not give me the farm, I will take you into court." That situation is going to be allowed develop but you could obviate that position by accepting this amendment. I would appeal very strongly that the amendment should be accepted. If the amendment is not drafted in the proper manner, if there is a single comma missing from it that should be there, surely it is open to the House to draft an amendment which will meet with the requirements of the promoters of the Bill.

With regard to the statement that there was no precedent for this sort of legislation I would appeal to the experts whom we have in this House who were sergeant-majors, majors and colonels in the "no rates" campaign. They must know all about the law. If they will carry their minds back to that period of their wild career I think they will agree that they found that if a man does not pay his rates for five years, the most the county council can claim from him is two years' rates. It might not be a good thing if that got abroad or if it became public property, because we do not know that there may not be an opposition again.

With regard to Senator O'Farrell's statement that auctioneers can collect their bills, I wish it were true. There is a statute which prevents auctioneers, manufacturers or shopkeepers from collecting their bills if they allow their bills to run too long. If he takes the debtor into court he is told that this is statute barred.

Comment on this
A Senator

How long has he let it run?

Comment on this

Too long.

Comment on this

Six years.

Comment on this

It is not sixty years.

Comment on this

Six years.

Comment on this

There is one point which the promoters of the Bill forget and which I should like to mention in support of Senator Quirke's argument. A very big percentage of the people employed in agricultural work in this country are labourers housed and fed on the farms. If one of these workers on his half-day, say after his dinner or before his tea, goes out and does some small job on the farm he can claim that he was working during the half-day. Eight or nine months afterwards when he is leaving altogether, he can claim to be paid for working on that half-holiday. Perhaps he had not done half an hour's work altogether on that particular day. I may say that I am giving half-holidays to my workers and I have been giving them for a considerable number of years and I employ more workers than most farmers in this country. Yet, I think that this Bill with all the restrictions that it is going to set up will create the greatest mess that has ever been known in the agricultural work in this country. Anybody listening to Dr. O'Connell and members of the Labour Party would think that nobody had any regard for our agricultural workers except the Labour Party. I say that the farmers have more regard for the agricultural workers than any section of the community and have always been ready to give them every concession which it was possible for them to give.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Douglas's contribution was the wisest and really the most helpful we have had in this debate. Some of the suggestions made were anything but helpful. Senator O'Farrell purported to quote Senator Bennett, but I think that any of us who know the type of man Senator Bennett is, will agree that the sentiments attributed to him by Senator O'Farrell were not those to which he gave expression. I think that when Senator O'Farrell reads his own presentation of Senator Bennett's words, he will feel too that he did not do justice to Senator Bennett.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

I want to explain that I did intend to quote the exact words but I could not because I had not the book, but immediately afterwards I got up and pointed out to the Senator what he said. He said it in the heat of the moment but he said it.

Comment on this

Could we have the quotation from Senator Bennett's speech?

Comment on this