We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Report of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. - Agricultural Workers (Weekly Half-Holidays) Bill, 1950—Committee.

Contributions 155–313 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Agricultural Workers (Weekly Half-Holidays) Bill, 1950
Enacted

No. 27 of 1950 ›

Mr. O'Farrell

I gave you the rough quotation—that he never intended to pay this money or never intended to give the holiday.

Comment on this

The clear implication is that when this Bill becomes law he will not obey it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

He did not say that.

Comment on this

That is your understanding of it.

Comment on this

We should have the exact quotation in fairness to Senator Bennett.

Comment on this

I suggest that Senator O'Farrell should look it up. I suggest that Senator O'Connell, Senator McCrae, Senator Loughman and Senator Hawkins should consider the withdrawal of these two amendments and the presentation of them again after further consideration and discussion. From may point of view I am with them in the arguments they make. Whether or not the form in which the amendment is presented is the best, is a matter for further consideration. We are trying to legislate for a situation when the law is broken. I suggest to Senator Dr. O'Connell and others that that is one of the last things that will happen. When it happens it will be for reasons that will have to be inquired into in the particular and specific case—and I submit that they would be rather strong reasons. We ought to be hesitant in regard to the matter of determining the fine. I know that the £20 mentioned in the Bill is the maximum. I agree with Senator Douglas that even £5 would be high. If a farmer is brought into court by his employee there will be some peculiar circumstance surrounding that case that is unique in the district. A farmer can be stupid just as his man can be stupid. We are trying to legislate for the odd individual who will not obey this law. You will have to try and examine the circumstances under which the law was broken. When this Bill becomes law we must all stand for its being upheld. This measure should be presented not in the light that the labourers are the depressed people in this community. because they are not. Such a statement ought not to be made in this House. If there is a free, easy and happy section in this country to-day it is the agricultural labourer. He is happier than his master and in most cases he can order things as he likes. I should like to hear the opinions of Senators Counihan, Finan, O'Dwyer, and others who are in daily touch with farming and their workers, on that point.

I agree with Senator Quirke. There is no use in trying to contend that certain people are concerned about the welfare of the agricultural workers and that others have another point of view.

Comment on this

Nobody ever suggested that only one section was concerned with the workers.

Comment on this

I got up because I wanted to say that I do not think we can settle this question satisfactorily now. As Senator Douglas has said, it is a matter for some further study and examination. I suggest to Senator Dr. O'Connell that there is a good deal in the point of view put forward by Senator Quirke. Those of us who are acquainted with rural life know that a farmer can have an employee who is not 100 per cent. efficient or anything like 100 per cent. efficient. In many cases he is the sort of person, perhaps, who does not want to take his half-holiday at all. However, if something goes astray and if there should be a quarrel, punitive legislation of this nature might be applied in a way in which I do not think anybody ever intended that it should be applied. While there may be a difference of opinion as to whether the period should be eight weeks or 12 weeks, I think that in the interests both of employer and employee it would be wise to stipulate some limit. I suggest that that is a matter that ought to be considered. I do not think we can arrive at a decision now. I suggest that Senator Hawkins, together with Senator Loughman, should withdraw their amendments until the matter has been further considered.

Comment on this

I understand that there is a class of agricultural worker who works on a contract for six or nine months. This worker might not be entitled to payment for half-holidays worked until the expiration of his contract. At the end of six months he would be entitled to claim pay for twenty-six half-holidays, but the amendment proposes to limit his claim to eight half-holidays. The worker would thus be deprived of half-holiday pay to the amount of the difference between eight and 26.

Comment on this

This Bill provides for a half-holiday, or in lieu of a half-holiday, a half-day's pay. These three amendments deal with three separate things—firstly, the penalty upon the farmer who does not obey the law. It seems to me that there is agreement in the House that the amount of the penalty should be lower than £20— perhaps £5 or perhaps something higher. Secondly, the amount that the labourer can sue for, and thirdly, the fact that Senator Hawkins in this amendment, No. 8, is combining two things, namely, the penalty on the farmer and also that the labourer should be able to get a maximum of eight weeks' pay. There are two flaws in that. One is that the "two months" is not clearly defined. It is quite clear in amendment No. 14, which is in the name of Senator Loughman. In that amendment you get eight weeks at the time the claim is made and whatever else accrues after the claim is made, which I think is reasonable. It is doubtful whether the two points should be combined. I do not know enough about the matter to decide on that. One objection is that the labourer cannot sue without getting the farmer convicted of his offence, which, perhaps, is not intended.

But I know enough about the country and the conditions about which Senator Quirke has spoken to know that an indefinite and long claim is something that leads to long litigation, probably to a great deal of prejury and probably to very serious breaches of friendly relations, and that there is, therefore, something to be said for limiting the time. There is something to be said for saying to the labourer: "Now, look here, you must not let this matter run for a long time because if you do you cannot claim."

I do not think that in our present position any of the amendments on the paper before us satisfactorily represents what the House wants. Is that not correct? I think that on the next stage we should have a separate amendment dealing with the penalty, and another amendment, in the form of amendment No. 14, which is in the name of Senator Loughman, which would either make the period eight or perhaps 12 weeks. I do not think the House is very worried about that. Without wanting to grind the labourer's face in the dust, from what I know of rural conditions in two particular counties there is a great deal to be said for a limitation so as to keep litigation from going all wrong in every shape and form—and from the point of view of the labourer himself there is a good case. Amendments Nos. 8, 9 or 14, in their present form do not satisfy us. I suggest we might leave them over and perhaps the people interested would consult with Senator Dr. O'Connell before the next stage and draft amendments that would allow us to discuss the matter and, if necessary, to divide on the matter and to decide it. I do not think we could divide satisfactorily on any of the amendments we have now before us. In that way we would come on to No. 10, which contains another very important principle.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is there any possibility of that being agreed to?

Comment on this

I was just wondering whether it would be possible at this stage to amend the amendment by deleting all the words after "sub-section (2)", that is, the part of the amendment which deals with the penalty, and then accepting Senator Loughman's amendment, No. 14, which would meet the point I was making. If that were agreed by the House, we could probably proceed with the remaining sections and have the Report Stage.

While I do not want to re-open the discussion again, Senator O'Connell said that this section was trying to deprive the worker of something to which he was entitled. I would remind Senator O'Connell that we have old age pensions, widows' and orphans' pensions and children's allowances. While, under certain circumstances, people are entitled to an old age pension at the age of 70 they will receive that pension only from the time they apply for it even if they are 96 years of age. The same applies to the widows' pensions and to children's allowances. As a matter of fact, the regulations are more strict in that case. As Senator Quirke has interjected, we also have the question of rates. Nobody would suggest that in these cases people are being deprived of their rights and we are not depriving the worker of anything here but encouraging him to insist on his rights. As well, this provision will dissipate the possibility of any friction that might arise from long litigation between worker and employer.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Hayes' suggestion but I would not agree to putting anything into the Bill now.

Comment on this

There is no machinery for drafting now.

Comment on this

I understand that they will be recommitted in another form.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

They will come forward in another form.

Business suspended at 6.5 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

May I rise to give an explanation? Before the Adjournment, I quoted from memory the statement which I said was made by Senator Bennett on the last occasion when this Bill was under consideration. I was challenged to produce the official record and I have it here now if anyone wishes to see it. It is as follows, in Volume 39, No. 6. column 521, Senator Bennett speaking:

"I can say straightway that it will not be complied with. It cannot be complied with, and not even if we were all to be put in jail could we comply with it."

In column 522, he said:

"I say that I will not do it and my labourers will not ask me to do it."

In column 524, I referred to that and said, when Senator Bennett was listening:

"Senator Bennett and others may very well speak of defying the Government and say that he will never allow a half-day, but when threatened with a fine or imprisonment it will be a different story. I do not think it will be necessary to fine him or anyone for failing to give a half-holiday or pay in lieu of it."

I quote that to show that, if I did not give the exact words, I quoted the purport of his statement.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 10, 10a 11 and 12 may be debated together.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

I move amendment No. 10:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) The week-day in the week on which the half-holiday is allowed under sub-section (1) of this section shall be fixed by agreement between the agricultural employer and the worker but in the absence of any such agreement shall be determined in each case by the agricultural employer.

The purpose of this new sub-section is really to clarify the position. Section 2 (1) says:—

"An agricultural employer shall allow within a period ..."

Some people hold that the words "shall allow" there clearly give the employer the right and the power to determine the day of the week any particular employee may have. It is possible that a court will hold that that is true, but surely it would be better to write it into the Bill? This Bill consists of only three sections, and it is clearly obvious, from the number of amendments, that Senators are of opinion that some parts are not altogether self-evident. For that reason, I am moving this amendment, which shows a method of allocating the week-day on which any employee is to get his half-holiday, that it shall if possible be determined by agreement between employer and employee, and failing agreement, that it shall be determined by the employer.

This is somewhat similar to a section in the Shops Act regarding half-days. It shows, without a shadow of doubt, that it shall be competent for the employer to decide, and where he has more than one employee he may, if he thinks fit, ask them to go on different days. It was quite clear here on the Second Stage that some Senators were under the impression that the Bill was to provide a half-day for all the workers on pre-determined days. While that is possible in industry, it is scarcely so in agriculture, where the wheels must be kept moving regardless of the day of the week. I think the amendment is self-explanatory.

Comment on this

I move the following amendment to amendment No. 10:—

In line 3 of the amendment, after the word "worker", to insert the following words: "for each period of three months".

I do not know whether Senator Orpen is prepared to accept it. He suggests that the right to determine the day is to be left completely in the hands of the employer. There should be some period in which a particular half-day should operate and I think three months is a reasonable period. If the amendment is allowed to go through without being amended, there would be a council of war every Monday morning between the employer and his men to decide on what day of the week they would get. Senator Orpen mentioned the Shops Act. There is an arrangement under it by which the employees get a half-day on a particular day of the week. Some particular day is fixed for every worker in a shop. There should be some set period in this Bill, if this new sub-section is accepted. I see that Senator Hawkins has something on similar lines and may have something to say about it.

Comment on this

The difference between Senator Hawkins' amendment No. 12 and amendment No. 10 which was proposed by Senator Orpen, is that Senator Hawkins suggests that agreement is necessary, but he has made no provision for what would happen in the event of no agreement. While I might be inclined to accept Senator Hawkins' amendment from a working-man's point of view, if there is no agreement the worker is bound to get his half-holiday irrespective of what inconvenience it may cause to his employer. I remember when the point was raised during the Second Reading debate that somebody asked what would happen in the event of there being agreement. I indicated my personal view at the time that if there was no agreement the employer ought to be the person who would decide. The period of three months suggested in Senator McCrea's amendment is reasonable. I would be prepared to accept Senator Orpen's amendment as amended by Senator McCrea's. Perhaps, Senator Hawkins will agree to that. I would not, under any circumstances, agree to amendment No. 11. Amendment No. 11, as I read it, would not give any voice at all to the worker as to when he should take his holiday. In the event of non-agreement between them the most reasonable and the fairest thing would be for the employer to fix the date, but he ought to fix it over a period. I think three months is a reasonable period.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Senator O'Connell has accepted this new sub-section as proposed by Senator Orpen. It says: "shall be fixed by agreement between the agricultural employer and the worker but in the absence of any such agreement shall be determined in each case by the agricultural employer." Not "may be determined" but "shall be determined."

Comment on this

"May be" would be no good.

Comment on this

We hear many statements in this House relative to the good relations that exist between employers and employees in the agricultural industry. We all know they exist. We all know that there is an amount of co-operation between workers and employers in the agricultural industry that is not found in the same situation in industrial affairs. While I believe that where agreement cannot be got it rests with the employer to fix a date, I think it is injudicious to put it into the Bill. We should leave that to the employer. It will not create a good impression on the workers to think that the employer has the last say in this matter. I would rather that it would be left between the farmer and the worker than have it made a matter of law. Amendment No. 12 in Senator Hawkins' name covers the matter completely. It ought to be left at that. If there is not agreement I do not think we should legislate for it but we should leave it to the good sense of the employer and the worker.

Comment on this

I have an amendment down which Senator O'Connell said he could not accept under any circumstances. If Senator O'Connell says that, I suppose there is no hope that Senator Colgan could be induced to accept it. This is a very difficult problem because really we are concerned with human beings who have managed to live together for a very long time in a very intimate way. If you do not go out to make quarrels, my opinion is that no matter how you legislate the same good conditions will continue. Please God they will continue to exist. It would be very tragic if it were otherwise. I have put down the amendment because, in my judgment, we should be clear and explicit on this measure. My feeling is that there will less trouble if both employers and employees are clear about their rights and responsibilities.

There is nothing more conducive to woolly thinking or which may ultimately result in court proceedings, than the type of legislation that is not quite clear and explicit. In so far as Senator Orpen with the collaboration of Senators O'Connell and McCrae, can create a situation where the farmer and his men will have a talk at the beginning of the period, to determine or arrange his problems, and in so far as they are making preparation that that will take place, I think they are doing everybody a service. They are putting their relations between the two parties on a specific basis and there cannot be any question of each not knowing what his rights are. Senator O'Connell says that I as an employer might—it would be the last thing I would do—decide arbitrarily that my man was to go on Tuesday this week, on Wednesday next week and on Thursday the week following, if it suited me. I do not think that is the way it should be, but neither do I think it should be in the hands of my employee to say: "I am going now." If I say to him: "Look at what you are leaving", he should not be in the position of saying to me: "I do not give a brass farthing; I am going." That is all wrong; it is making for instability in the planning and execution of the work in the fields. If I have a field of hay waiting, and if I have planned beforehand that my man or men are to cut that field of hay or cut the grass for ensilage or whatever processes it has to go through, to make it fit to store up for the winter, that plan should be observed by my men. The men can similarly have a plan that they are going to have a half-day on certain days.

It is possible in certain circumstances to let the men go at any time they like. Senator McGee will tell you that he can allow his men off at any time as they can stop the tractors any time, but a man who has 20 or 30 cows to milk would be in a different position. Other people like that would like to know when the men are going and who is going on Wednesday, Thursday or Friday, if there are 30 men round the place. I think that a contribution is being made on both sides of the House to clarify the situation for all concerned. Why should we not all co-operate in that, because I do not think anybody is going to suffer for having the position clarified from the beginning? So far as I am concerned, I ask leave to withdraw my amendment in view of the obvious agreement between Senators O'Connell, McCrae and Orpen.

Comment on this

It was in order to make some contributions towards avoiding the pitfalls to which Senator Baxter refers that I was prompted to put down amendment No. 12. Those who understand the farming community appreciate that there are periods of the year in respect of which there would be a firm agreement between the farmer and his labourers providing that they would have their half-holidays on a particular day, just as in country towns shop assistants have half-holidays on a particular days. It is not the same in every town, but on a particular day in each town all the shops are closed. They usually have a half-holiday on a Saturday. It may not be suitable for the farming community to have the half-holiday on a Saturday, but the farmers and their employees will have to make provision that each case will be dealt with in the way best suited to themselves and, under my amendment, the farmer on the one hand and the worker on the other, would know that for a period of three months the half-holiday would be on a particular day. I think that it would probably suit the farmer to change the half-holiday according to the season of the year. It might suit a farmer in one case to have the half-holiday on a Saturday during the winter months, whereas, on the other hand, it would not be suitable to have it on that day in spring or in the harvest time. I can quite understand the desirability for reaching agreement, because, after all, the farmer must have some say, just as the shopkeeper or any other employer has his say, as to the particular day on which it would suit him to give the half-holiday. I am prepared to withdraw this amendment, provided we get a guarantee from Senator O'Connell that something will be done to bring about what we are trying to achieve in the various amendments before the House.

Comment on this

There is a small point which I wish to make. The three months would start probably when the Bill becomes law. If the first three months were a fixed period it might cut across two such periods. I would suggest that there should be a little flexibility regarding the first portion of that particular section.

Comment on this

I take it that the farmer and his workers can arrange, for example, for the month of June any way they please. Then you have a three-monthly agreement for the months of July, August and September. I assume that it should be flexible as between different parts and different farmers.

Comment on this

For the first period, they could agree on two different dates. Suppose the period embodied was three months it should be split. It should be open to the farmers or the workers to say that for the first three months, they would take Friday and for the remaining six weeks they would take Saturday or some other day.

Comment on this

It can be left to Senator O'Connell to bring in a new amendment.

Comment on this

There is no necessity. We can accept the amendment as it is.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

In the desire to avoid one difficulty, you may create another. If you make an agreement for three months and fix it inflexibily for 13 weeks, it may happen that within that period something would occur that would make it desirable for the farmer to change it, and no provision is made in the amended amendment for such a change.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

The amendment, as amended reads:—

"The week-day in the week on which the half-holiday is allowed under sub-section (1) of this section shall be fixed by agreement between the agricultural employer and the worker for each period of three months."

There is no provision made for an alteraction. It remains fixed for three months. I see Senator Hayes wagging his head although generally he professes to know nothing about agriculture. It seems to me that some difficulty may arise unless some provision is made for altering the day. I would suggest that if Senators O'Connell or Hawkins wanted to redraft the section, they should provide for that modification.

Comment on this

I think it necessary that something should be done to make it possible for the farmers and the workers in agreement to change the half-holiday. It may be that the hay-making season may come along and it may be necessary to change the day so as to enable as much hay-making as possible to be done within a short period.

If agreement is reached to give a man a half-holiday on a certain day every month for three months, and the farmer, say, is faced with the problem of new hay and old hay, and if there should be a month's harvest in between, the position would be very difficult indeed.

Comment on this

In most cases, agricultural workers want a half-holiday the whole year round on Saturday. The difficulty is that at certain times of the year Saturday is the most awkward day for a farmer to give a half-holiday. If it is to be insisted upon that the worker will have the right to walk out on Saturday, it will stop altogether any stall feeding that may be done in this country. On Saturday, provision is made for Sunday's work in respect of the preparation of the food for stall feeding. We must not forget that cattle have to be fed on Sundays as well as on Saturdays and other days of the week. Few could do the work on Sunday if the food were not prepared on Saturday.

Senator Orpen's amendment seeks to ensure that the farmer will have the right to declare on which day the half-holiday is to be taken.

Comment on this

Why should the farmer have that right? Senator Counihan's statement is a terrible admission—and he is a farmer. He has admitted that, in order to get along on Sunday, a farm labourer must do twice the amount of work on Saturday. I agree that it is most essential that there should be the utmost co-operation between the farmer and his worker, but I will not agree that the choice in this case should be given to the farmer.

Comment on this

Could we have the terms of the amended section?

Comment on this

It is to be fixed by agreement for periods of three months. That is what we will have when this is amended. Suppose we come to this week's work. Surely it is permissive for the employer and the employee— if, for instance, there should be a field of hay which requires attention and they know from the weather forecast that rain is coming—to arrange among themselves about the half-holiday. Would it not be better to do that than to have to do twice the amount of work the next day? There is nothing in this to exclude that agreement. I accept it that that is the position. We can all realise that we are doing the right thing.

Comment on this

I should be in favour of the House fixing the day were it not for the unfortunate weather which we experience in this country.

Comment on this

We have no control over that.

Comment on this

The hay and the harvest are the difficult periods. We have had hardly any good weather since June, 1949. There ought to be some sort of flexibility during these periods. I do not know how it should be done but the House ought to consider the matter carefully and allow the employer and the employee to arrange for days that are suitable in so far as the work on the farm is concerned. I think it would be in the interests of agricultural production if an amendment were inserted to cover that point.

Comment on this

That is what the amendment proposes—agreement between the two people.

Comment on this

We have heard a lot about the good relations that exist generally between the farmers and the workers. I subscribe whole-heartedly to that view. If there is a three-months agreement generally, it will work out that one man on the farm will get his half-day perhaps on Wednesday, another man perhaps on Thursday, another man perhaps on Friday, another man perhaps on Saturday, and so forth. Senator Baxter has mentioned the possibility of difficulty arising when hay is down and bad weather is coming. Despite-the good relations between the farmer and his workers, which we have heard so much about, is it reasonable to assume that the man who is due to take his half-holiday on Wednesday will walk out on that day, even though there is urgent work to be done, rather than stay and help with the work and take either extra pay or else the half-holiday due to him at some other time, perhaps in the next week? In all these matters you must legislate for the person who is not inclined to do the reasonable thing.

For perhaps 80 or 90 per cent. of our farmers, we did not need this measure at all, because the farmers were already giving a half-holiday. It was the other 20 per cent. or 10 per cent. who made this Bill necessary. We remembered the grumbling of some people in connection with compulsory tillage—we remember some people saying: "We do not mind tilling if the next man has to do it, too." I think that this amendment is reasonable and that it will meet all the difficulties that are likely to crop up.

Comment on this

What about amendment No. 5?

Comment on this

The principle of amendment No. 5 is dealt with in amendment No. 10.

Comment on this

It seems to be presupposed that the half-holiday must be as from midday until the end of the day. The fact that it might be taken between the working hours of the day, or in the morning portion of the day, does not seem to have been taken into consideration. I am just raising that point for the sake of having it discussed. I have not any special ideas in connection with it. It was mentioned against the Bill originally so far as the dairy farmers are concerned. They are very badly affected by this particular Bill. I felt that if it would suit the employee to get his four hours in the middle of the day he could then attend to the milking and the feeding of cattle in the morning and in the evening.

Comment on this

That is not a half day, I suggest.

Comment on this

The Bill states four hours.

Comment on this

I suggest to Senator Loughman that that matter could be covered by a special amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

In this case, it presupposed agreement between the farmer and the worker. I believe that the workers are strong at present.

In my opinion all the strength is with the employee at present. At the same time, I wish to see the farm labourer get the half-holiday.

Comment on this

I cannot understand why four hours given in the middle of the day should be regarded as a half-holiday. The day, after all, is broken in two. I would point out that industrial workers must get their half-holiday——

Comment on this

I suggested to Senator Loughman that that point might be covered by a special amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

In mentioning amendment No. 5, Senator Loughman suggested that the four hours might be taken at any time during the day. I submit that that is not a half-holiday. It must be either before or after lunch.

Comment on this

I would like to say the same. I would be awfully sorry if this House were even to suggest this amendment to give farm labourers a split day.

Comment on this

This amendment is not before the House.

Comment on this

And I hope it never will.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) For the purpose of the Act a period of five consecutive days shall be deemed to be one week in any week.

The Bill states that the worker will be entitled to a half-holiday if he works for a full week and I was puzzled as to what exactly a full week was and whether a person who worked for less than seven days would be entitled to a half-holiday. I should not have put in "five consecutive days" as it would have been better to say "five days". I would not like to think that an employee who worked for at least five days would be expected to work a full week in order to get a half-day. If other people were happy with four days, I would be happy too, but I want no worker to be refused a half-day because he did not work a full week of six or seven days.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

The point would be better covered by mentioning hours. The agricultural working week is 54 hours and you could say that after 50 hours' work a half-day of four hours would be granted. There is something similar in the Conditions of Employment Act, governing overtime. After 48 hours overtime must be paid.

Comment on this

As I understand it, the Bill requires a man to work a full week before he gets a half-day, but I argue that he should get a half-day after five days, which might be considered a week. I do not want farmers to start a new idea of employing a man for four days so as to avoid giving a half-day.

Comment on this

This amendment requires further consideration. You are defining a week. A week has more than one meaning and is found in more than one place in the Bill. A holiday must be given where there is a contract of a week. Senator Loughman proposes to reduce the week to five days, thereby defeating his own object. The amendment has not been thought out. I think that Senator Burke is probably much more correct. I put down no amendments myself because I did not feel I had enough knowledge of farming. On the question of what is a week, it is very doubtful whether the four hours proposition could really be worked and it would be better to take so many hours. That would be the practical proposition—again on theories not based on farming. If there is a 54-hour week, and 50 hours are worked, four should be the half-day. A difficulty may arise in the case of a shorter time and an employer who wants to be ultra strict may say: "You only worked 40 hours and, therefore, you are not entitled to a half-day". In practice, I think very few do that, but where the period is very much shorter, such as one day, it is obviously rather absurd. If you want to make this really watertight make it so many hours a week to entitle a man to four hours' holiday. The amendment is not satisfactory, because it would lessen the contract period, as it prescribes what a week is. Whether the definition of a week would make "weekly" five days as well I do not know, but on the other point I am pretty clear.

Comment on this

My sole concern is to see that we do not bring about a state of affairs where farmers would start to employ men for four days so as to evade the half-holiday. I have not very strong feelings other than that, and if hours cover the point better than days I will be very happy.

Comment on this

You would have to relate it to sub-section (1) of Section 2. If Senator Loughman would read that it would clarify the whole position. A period of two weeks is specified.

Comment on this

My feeling was that it only complicated matters.

Comment on this

That is all it does.

Comment on this

We might consider something else. We do not need it at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

There would be a difficulty there if the Agricultural Wages Board changed the number of hours.

Comment on this

With regard to sub-section (3), which deals with a case where the worker, instead of taking a half-day, remains at work, has the worker any right? Suppose the worker wanted to work on the half-day in order to gain extra remuneration, could he force the employer to allow him to do so?

Comment on this

Not under the terms of the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

There is the question of broken time in the country. We are trying to relate industrial conditions to some extent to agriculture I think, and we should put in some provision to cover wet or broken time so as to avoid friction and to have as far as possible something clear and concrete. I thought that on the Report Stage I would, with your permission, move an amendment where if an employer in any week pays an agricultural worker for wet or broken time, this payment may be offset against the half-holiday or the payment in lieu of the half-holiday or any portion thereof. I think that is necessary because if something like that is not done you will have a lot of argument. The farmer will say, "I paid you for two days which were wet and now you want a half-holiday."

Comment on this

I will not talk about that now but there will be a lot about it if it is put in.

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree with Senator Burke although I would be slow to introduce an amendment. As I said on a previous stage, if farmers were compelled by law to provide a half-holiday for their workers it would mean, I believe, the introduction of industrial conditions and also the introduction of the clock which never heretofore operated on the farm as most Senators will agree. If the farmer is compelled to make provision for a half-holiday I think that the natural result will be that the farmer will say to himself: "If I have to give a half-holiday and if there is a wet day I should be allowed to cut the man for that wet day." That has never been the case. Though we are agreed on the principle here, we ought to provide for this. As a Party we made provision for the builders' labourers. Then we were dealing with industrial conditions. This Bill is an attempt to introduce industrial conditions on the farm and you cannot close your eyes to the consequences which are bound to follow.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

To insert before Section 3 a new section as follows:—

(3) This Act shall be administered by the Agricultural Wages Board and the board may in the name and on behalf of an agricultural worker institute civil proceedings to recover any sum due to a worker under this Act in accordance with the provisions of the Agricultural Wages Acts of 1936 and 1945.

I think this is self-explanatory. I cannot see any provision in the Bill by which a worker can recover any privilege to which he is entitled under the Bill. This will enable the worker to apply to the Agricultural Wages Board to investigate his claim and if necessary the board can proceed against any unscrupulous employer who might be inclined to deprive him of his half-holiday wages. It will not improve the relations between the worker and the farmer if it is left to him to take whatever steps are necessary to bring the man to court. As the Agricultural Wages Board is operating the 1950 Holidays Bill, it is only right they should be asked to administer this also.

Comment on this

This amendment will help very considerably. The only other remedy which would be left would be for the employee to take the employer into court. In many cases the amount he could legally recover would be small —and if some of the amendments were passed it would be smaller still. If the amendment is accepted and the Agricultural Wages Board operate this, there may be no legal proceedings at all. In fact, there would not be any, except in an extreme case. If a farmer were visited by an officer of the board and told he should pay what the man is claiming or there would be legal proceedings, it would be settled and there would be no need to appeal to the court.

Comment on this

Earlier in the discussion on this Bill I raised a point as to what authority would be responsible for the administration of the Bill. Now we come to a very serious flaw in the Bill as introduced, in that no provision was made. This amendment provides that the administration be handed over to the Agricultural Wages Board, but before a case can be taken to court the employee must inform the board. Therefore, in the first instance, it is the employee who is taking action. An investigation will be carried out by the officials and the employer may agree to pay the money withheld and to comply with the regulations. The cost of administration will have to be borne by the Wages Board, but it will boil down to this, that it is the board which will act on information received. Otherwise the board must appoint sufficient inspectors to investigate the conditions on every farm.

Comment on this

The fewer inspectors the better.

Comment on this

That is all right. At this hour of the night, I do not wish to be drawn into a discussion as to whether we should have more inspectors or less. We have heard many a time that the freer you leave the farmer the better, but in this very Bill we are making provision for more inspectors, to place more obligations on the farmer by an Act of Parliament.

Comment on this

Is the Senator not for it?

Comment on this

I made it clear on the Second Reading that I would have opposed the Second Reading were it not for the fact that then the Bill as introduced would have become law, which would have been a bad thing for the farmer, the employee and the country as a whole. That is why we made every possible attempt to amend the Bill. From what we have seen here to-day, I think the best thing that could be done would be to withdraw the Bill and let us have a new one. Whether this is a responsibility that should be handed over to the Agricultural Wages Board or not, I am very doubtful. It is said that it will maintain good relations, but every farmer knows that an inspector was sent because some one of the employees gave information behind his back to the Board.

Comment on this

I presume that Senator McCrea was advised to put the amendment down in this form. I do not know what "shall be administered" means, whether it means that they can advise and go to no expense, or whether they can appoint inspectors to prosecute in the name of the person and incur legal costs. If it has the latter meaning, I have some doubt as to whether it can be accepted as an amendment from this House, as we have no right to incur expenditure. It seems as if this might have been put in this form to avoid expenditure, in which case it might be better to leave it until some authority can take it up, so that the worker can get the union or someone else to act. If you leave it to a body that has no function and no money to spend, you may be in a worse position. I am not opposing the amendment, but I would like to be quite sure as to how it would operate. I had experience before of an industrial Bill, a Private Member's Bill, which did not operate because, though the Bill was passed by a substantial majority in both Houses, we could not get machinery to enforce it—and what is the business of nobody or of very few people turns out not to be done at all.

Comment on this

I do not think this amendment is really necessary. It makes provision for a situation which will arise only when the employee is leaving. Once you reach the stage that action is being taken against an employer, that ends the good relations and they had better part company— and they will.

Comment on this

If he will not give him his half-day, it is about time the good relations were severed.

Comment on this

Pray God we have not the relations between some of them that we have between some of the commercial people and the labour organisations in this city, on a plan to keep down production. That is what it amounts to. If a worker has a grievance against his employer, that he is not getting his half-holiday and has not been given money in lieu of it, and proceeds to take action to secure his rights, as he is entitled to do—I do not mind if the Agricultural Wages Board is cited as the authority to do that—it simply means that they are paid up when the labourer is leaving. It has been argued here that he has no power of action. That is something I cannot accept. It seems to me that he has the same right of action against the employer in respect of the half-day's pay as he would have against the employer for arrears of wages. The labourer has a perfect right to go into court and take action if the employer owes him money. If he is owed a sum of money, whether it is £5, £3 or 30/-, he will have no difficulty whatever in finding a solicitor who will take up his case. If he is able to prove his case in court, the employer will not come very well out of it. The judgment of any district justice on any case like that would be that the employer was evading his legal responsibilities. The labourer would not only get a decree for arrears of wages but the employer, in addition, would be fined the maximum sum. That is my view about it.

I have had the wages inspector with me—not for some time now. He was the third inspector who came on a summer day. He came to know how many men I had and what they were being paid. He did not even accept what I said. He had to see the employees and the men had to come in out of the field. It may be Senator McCrea's or Senator O'Connell's idea that if you have inspectors from the wages board making investigations you will just keep everybody up to scratch. If that is what is in their minds, there may be something to be said for its insertion in the Bill. There are very few employees to-day so soft that they do not know their rights.

Comment on this

I am becoming more and more alarmed as we go from section to section. I am inclined to agree now with Senator Hawkins when he says that what we need is not amendments but a whole new Bill.

Comment on this

I thought Senator Quirke was going to agree with Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

If Senator Hayes would not be so irritable because of the fact that Senator Baxter has already expressed his agreement with me, we might be able to enlighten him on agricultural conditions between us. This amendment is really unnecessary. It is not, with due respect to Senator McCrea, properly drafted. It makes no provision as to who is to move in the matter. It does not say who is to approach the Agricultural Wages Board. We must assume that the Senator either forgot to examine the position sufficiently to make provision for that matter, or else he deliberately left it out.

I am becoming alarmed as we go from section to section. If there is anything that frightens me more than anything else it is this talk about inspectors. We had a statement from the shell-shocked Minister for Agriculture that never again would an inspector cross the farmer's fence without an invitation from the farmer. I felt sorry for the Minister at the time. I inquired from one of his colleagues and he told me: "Do not take any notice of the poor devil, as he was shell-shocked." I asked where he was shell-shocked. I do not know whether my informant said Ballaclava or Ballygar.

Comment on this

You are going away from the amendment.

Comment on this

I thought I was dealing very directly with the amendment. If we accept this amendment, it will mean that we will have numerous inspectors —which, we were told by the Minister for Agriculture, would not be necessary under the Coalition Government. I cannot see why this suggestion comes before the House, that the matter should be dealt with by the Agricultural Wages Board. I do not know why it could not be dealt with by some section of the Department of Agriculture or some section of the Department of Industry and Commerce, which would appear more appropriate, as far as I can judge. The only reason I can see for this amendment is that the Minister for Agriculture, reading over the Bill in his spare time, must have seen the difficulty with which he was going to be faced. He must have seen, as anybody would see, that the time for inspectors had not passed and that, with the introduction of this Bill, we would want not hundreds of inspectors but, perhaps, thousands, and that he would have to utilise Senator McCrea's amendment to get him out of his difficulty.

Comment on this

Freedom of speech is a marvellous thing.

Comment on this

There was no ulterior motive behind this amendment. We did not have to go to a very strong opponent of the Bill—as was shown by his vote in the Dáil—to advise us as to what kind of amendment we would put into it. The wages board, as Senator McCrea stated, administers the Agricultural Workers Holidays Act and the Wages Act. If anybody were to administer this, the wages board would appear to us to be the appropriate body. Senator Quirke asked: "Why not the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Industry and Commerce or inspectors from either Department?" I suppose Senator Quirke would have the same objection to an inspector from any of those Departments.

Comment on this

Not from the Department of Industry and Commerce, because the Minister for Industry and Commerce never said he would have inspectors.

Comment on this

The alternative to this is that the man himself would sue his employer. Senator Baxter states that he will get a solicitor to do that and go to court, but the amount involved in many cases would not be more than £2. I agree with Senator Hawkins that the employee should report the matter. I do not see any wrong in that. If an official from the wages board came and told the farmer that he would have to pay this amount and that he was legally bound to pay, otherwise the alternative would be to take the matter to court, I believe it would be settled in 99 cases out of 100. I still think that is a more practical way of dealing with it. Very probably, if the employee went up to his employer and said: "If you do not give me this money, I will have to report it to the wages board," that would be the end of the matter also.

Comment on this

If the workers, instead of going to the farmer and telling him they were going to take action in the court the next day, said they were going to report it to the wages board, I cannot see any difference between them.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Farrell

I have privately expressed objection to this amendment for the same reasons practically as have been publicly stated here to-night. I do not see that we have any right to ask that the Agricultural Wages Board should be the administering authority under this. I do not know that we have any power to insist that an existing body will administer a Bill passed in this House. Senator Baxter has already pointed out that if you agree to the amendment, it will mean additional expenditure by the Agriculture Wages Board for inspectors and for prosecutions. I am not convinced that we have power to force any Department, even an existing body like the Agricultural Wages Board, to go ahead and engage in prosecutions and involve themselves in all the expenditure connected with that. That is one reason why I objected to it.

Another is that up to the present the Agricultural Wages Board has not a very good reputation amongst agricultural workers. The fact is that, whether their grievances were justified or not, they have continually complained about that body. If that be the case, if it is unsatisfactory for the purpose for which it was specifically set up, it is bound to be unsatisfactory for the additional purposes for which we are providing now. There is a third reason. I am convinced that if you give a body like the Agricultural Wages Board power to prosecute without saying who is to bring the complaint before them, you are leaving it open for anybody who wants to make mischief, between men and men, to send in anonymous or other letters to the Agricultural Wages Board, saying that So-and-So is not giving his men a half-holiday or is not paying his workers. You then start an investigation which may be warranted or which may not be at all justified. It may be that the man and his employees had agreed for their own satisfactory reasons that they were going to work uninterruptedly that particular week. Again, where a worker is not enforcing payment for a half-holiday worked— he may get something in lieu of it— somebody outside comes along to act as the common informer and to create trouble between that man and his employer.

I think you are depriving the worker of no right by leaving out that amendment. There is nothing to prevent any man who thinks he has a justifiable grievance taking action himself to remedy his grievance. I understand also that the agricultural labourers are now being organised in a trade union and it will, therefore, be open to them to report their grievances to the trade union, which can take action to have such grievances remedied. I think this is a bad amendment and I do not think it desirable that it should be embodied in the Bill.

Comment on this

I think that after that speech, there will be no statement charging the Labour Party with having unanimously come to an agreement that we must force this Bill through the House.

Comment on this

It may mean that there are two Labour Parties yet.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon; you have something more to learn. If it is the considered view of the House that this is not necessary and that it is going to cause any difficulty reasonably anticipated by some members, there is no desire on our part to have it inserted. We thought, and I still think, that it would be the best way to administer the Act but if that view does not appeal to the House, we shall withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I think it is unnecessary because agricultural workers are difficult to get and if a worker is not getting his half-holiday or his payment in lieu of it, he just will not stay working for that man and he will get ten others ready to employ him. I think a provision of that kind is not necessary.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 16, 17 and 18 in the names of Senators Hawkins, Loughman and Hayes, may be debated together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

To insert before Section 3 a new section as follows:—

3. (1) Where a worker in any working week has been allowed by an agricultural employer a whole holiday on any public holiday or church holiday falling within the week such worker shall not be entitled to claim a half-holiday under the immediately preceding section in respect of that week.

(2) For the purposes of this section a public holiday or a church holiday shall be any one of the days which is so defined in Section 8 of the Holidays (Employees) Act, 1939.

As we have been a long time considering this measure of two sections, I shall be as brief as possible. Senators are aware that it is the practice amongst the agricultural community to keep church holidays and bank holidays as real holidays, that is as days on which no work is done. The purpose of my amendment is to secure that where such a church holiday is taken as a holiday, a half-holiday will not be taken in that week. I hope that no Senator would try to deprive an agricultural worker of anything he is entitled to, but in present circumstances, particularly having regard to world conditions, we should try to keep our agricultural community working as long as we possibly can to produce for the people the things they require very badly. It is only reasonable to expect that where a bank holiday or a church holiday is taken as a holiday by an agricultural worker, he should forgo a half-holiday in that particular week.

Comment on this

The only difficulty I see about this is the phrase "a whole holiday". I am wondering what would happen on church holidays where a man comes in to feed cattle or to milk cows? In that case he is not getting a whole holiday. Would Senator Hawkins explain how we would get over that?

Comment on this

I think we can leave it to the good relations which habitually exist between the farmers and their workers to find some solution for cases of that kind. The type of person I want to cover is the person who takes a whole holiday and does not turn in at all. With the exception of workers who may be engaged in feeding animals or milking cows, all agricultural workers take a church holiday as a full holiday.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Hawkins' amendment is a better one than mine and I should like to have my amendment withdrawn in favour of it.

Comment on this

In submitting amendment No. 18, which is on similar lines to Senator Hawkins' amendment, I had in mind that agricultural work, being purely seasonal work and the two most important periods being spring-time and harvest-time, if you had two consecutive days as a holiday and a half-holiday, it would retard work very seriously, particularly having regard to the experience we have had with the seasons of late. The farmer may be saving hay, corn and turf at the same time and to have two consecutive holidays in the same week would, as I say, retard production very seriously. These are the only reasons I have in mind in submitting this amendment.

Comment on this

We are accepting Senator Hawkins' amendment.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 19, 20 and 21 are similar and might be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:—

To insert before Section 3 a new section as follows:—

3. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act it shall be lawful for an agricultural employer and an agricultural worker to enter into a contract for a period not exceeding ten calendar months whereby the agricultural worker shall agree to work a full working week during the period and the agricultural employer shall agree to pay him over and above the agreed wages a sum which shall be equivalent to the half-holiday remuneration provided for in Section 2 of this Act in respect of the number of half-holidays that will have accrued during the agreed period.

I hope this amendment will be accepted unanimously by the House in the spirit in which it was put down. As it is at present drafted, the Bill will constitute a very grave hardship as far as the dairying industry is concerned and I may say that that is the industry which I have most in mind. We have heard a lot of talk this afternoon about the difficulties which arise at the harvest, but whatever may be said in regard to ordinary agricultural work it would undoubtedly be very difficult to operate the half-holiday system, as at present outlined in the Bill, in so far as the dairying industry is concerned. Cows have to be milked twice a day. If they are not milked regularly twice a day they will lose their milk. In addition, it is most desirable that there should be as little change as possible as far as the persons who are milking the cows are concerned. The person in charge must generally known each cow. It would be a very grave disturbance if there were much change of hands. We have not reached the stage at which a cow can keep her milk over from the half-holiday until the next morning. We all agree that the present Minister for Agriculture is most optimistic, but even he, in his greatest moments of optimism, has not promised us a dairy cow that need be milked only once a day, or a dairy cow that can keep her milk over until the next day, if necessary. Therefore, everybody must agree that an exception must be made in so far as the dairy industry is concerned. I have drafted my amendment accordingly. I might say that I put down the period of ten months because that would generally cover the milking period, and also because I have the agricultural worker in mind, and I did not like to extend it too long. In my amendment I stipulated that the agricultural worker shall agree to work a full working week during the period, and that the agricultural employer shall agree to pay him over and above the agreed wages a sum which shall be equivalent to the half-holiday remuneration provided for in Section 2 of this Act. I think that that is a very fair and reasonable undertaking and that the principle of the half-day would be accepted there.

As I explained on the Second Reading, there is a precedent for this. When the Agricultural Wages Act was brought in, a fixed period of, I think, 54 hours per week was laid down in respect of the whole agricultural industry. The Act was not long in operation when it was found that it was doing great harm to the dairying industry. After a time the matter became so urgent that the wages board had to bring in an amending Order which allowed an employer to make an arrangement with an employee for a period of not less than five months under which the employee could work any number of hours per day at a fixed wage and without any claim for overtime. This amendment follows on the same lines as that agricultural wages arrangement.

It may be argued that an amendment which was passed in the other House would have provided for the difficulty— that a worker, with his employer's consent, would work on his half-holiday and be paid extra money for having worked that half-holiday. That would not meet the position in this particular case. A dairy farmer hires his hands at the beginning of the year. It would never do for a farmer to hire a man to milk his cows and not to know whether that man would stay one week and go the next week. He wants the matter to be definite right from the start. If Senators will consider my amendment carefully they will realise that it is reasonable and that it is based on real necessity. I hope it will be unanimously accepted.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

The following amendment (No. 20) appears in my name on the Order Paper.

To insert before Section 3 a new section as follows:—

3. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act it shall be lawful for an agricultural worker employed on a dairy farm on which only one paid worker is employed for that worker to enter into a yearly agreement with the agricultural employer to work a full week provided that the agricultural worker is paid at least the minimum agricultural wage and in addition receives the half-holiday remuneration that he would be entitled to under the provisions of the immediately preceding section.

I put that amendment down for the purpose of drawing attention to what I think is a very serious possibility, namely, that on the small farm employing one man you may get a disruption of the pattern of our agriculture if this half-holiday is insisted upon on these farms. It appears at present that the small dairy farm is, to some extent, being replaced by the larger dairy farm. That may be desirable; I do not know. However, I think we should take note that the working of this Bill when it becomes an Act may have very serious consequences on the small farm on which one paid employee is at work. If, as I think, the coming into force of this Act will, as it were, be the last straw, so far as these small dairy farms are concerned, and if they will disappear and go into some other form of production, well and good, if that is desirable. But if we still think these small dairy farms form a valuable adjunct to our agricultural production, we should consider very carefully before we make the provisions of this Act apply to these farms. I am not speaking from experience in my own county because the small dairy farm is almost non-existent there. However, there are other parts of the country where it is quite a prominent feature. I think some of us feel that it would be very detrimental to the interests of the country to see these farms, as it were, thrown out of production and forced to alter their agricultural production through an Act which is very desirable in itself but which contains no clause which allows these farms to escape, if you like, its provisions.

Comment on this

I put down amendment No. 21 at the request of some agricultural workers. The contention of some of the people to whom I was talking was: "what good is a half-holiday to us? Give us a day in the month and we will be able to make a lot more of it. We can till our garden and the farmer will give us a horse and plough or the use of a tractor. We cannot do much in a half-day but we could if we had a whole day." There is no compulsion; the agricultural worker can do any of three things. He can take his half-holiday or he can work with extra pay or he can take his day's holiday in the month. It all depends on mutual agreement between worker and employer. No section should dictate to the worker and his employer or make regulations setting out how they are to work.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Counihan's amendment is in keeping with the way he used to buy cattle when I was a kid long ago. He suggests making a settlement with the agricultural workers by giving them a full day instead of four half days. When he used to buy cattle from me when I had not as much sense as I have now he used to bid half what they were worth.

Comment on this

But he did not get them.

Comment on this

He did succeed in getting the cattle. Maybe he would succeed in dividing a half day with the workers but I do not think he will.

I think Senator Orpen's amendment is not necessary at all. It reminds me of a story I heard a long time ago about an old woman who went to a wake. Someone came around with the whiskey and she said: "If I do not take it for God's sake make me take it because I am cold." There is already provision in the Bill for the idea behind the amendment.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

In what way?

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent a worker from working on every half-holiday in the year provided he gets paid and that is the one thing wrong with the Bill if there is anything wrong with it. I see no reason why the agricultural worker should not get a half-holiday but what is wrong is that he does not have to take it and can stay on the farm working with the farmer's consent. This is really a manner of hoodwinking the people by increasing agricultural wages by half a day's wages each week. There is nothing to prevent a farmer from paying a half a day's wages each week. There is nothing to prevent a farmer from paying half a day's money more than he paid heretofore and allowing the worker to stay on the farm and therefore the amendment is not needed.

Comment on this

Senator Quirke is absolutely right.

Comment on this

I am not going to say for once. Sub-section (3) of Section 2 provides that a worker need not take a half-holiday but can take his pay instead. He is not obliged to take his half-holiday and can take his pay on one occasion, on two occasions or on 52 occasions or for as long as he likes. Therefore, Senator O'Dwyer's suggestion about an agreement for ten calendar months is not necessary, because not only can the employer and worker make an agreement for ten calendar months but they can make one for 12 under sub-section (3) of Section 2.

The same applies to Senator Orpen's amendment. You need not specify that the worker must be one agricultural worker employed on a dairy farm, because one agricultural worker employed on a dairy farm, one agricultural worker employed on any kind of farm or any number of workers employed on any kind of farm can, if their employers agree, take a half-day's money instead of a half-day's holiday.

Senator Counihan, in his amendment, is substituting one day's pay for two days' pay.

Comment on this

With the consent of the worker; he has the option.

Comment on this

Senator Counihan's is the only amendment which is an amendment to sub-section (3) of Section 2, because what Senator Counihan really requires to do is to to pay, if he pays the additional wages, half the half-holiday remuneration, and everybody is happy—except the labourer, presumably.

Amendments Nos. 19 and 20 seem to me to be covered—although I am not an expert on this thing—by sub-section (3) of Section 2, which is very general, has no limit of time and does not compel the worker to take the half-holiday. Senator Counihan has a different idea.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes did not cover the possibility of a man refusing to take the money. What would you do with him?

Comment on this

What do you suggest?

Comment on this

Sack him.

Comment on this

The only people who ever refuse to take money are Dublin people and they do not work on the land.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with Senator Hayes. The employee is at liberty to work and take his extra pay or to take his half-day's holiday, but an agreement made at the beginning of the year that the worker would work for a full week each week would not be binding in law because the worker could decide to walk out and take his half-holiday at any time. The possibility of a definite agreement between employer and employee that would be binding in law is not in the Bill at the present time.

Comment on this

All the amendment says is that it shall be lawful for an employer and worker to make an agreement and that is lawful now.

Comment on this

But not binding. If a man hires a worker and he agrees at the beginning of the year to work a full week for 12 months, it is quite within the power of that worker after a few weeks to say: "I will take my half-holiday," and he is entitled to do that within the provisions of the Bill. The dairying industry is different from the others. It would be much better to have the amendment in that form, as it does no harm to anyone and the agreement will be freely made and binding in law.

Comment on this

Regarding the amendments in general, I agree entirely with Senators Hayes and Quirke that they are not necessary. Senator O'Dwyer's amendment suggests that it should be lawful for an agricultural employer to enter into such a contract. There is nothing in the world to prevent them from entering into a binding and legal contract. If this amendment were passed, it is of no more use than if it were not passed. The amendment says: "Notwithstanding anything contained in the Act, it shall be lawful...." That would imply that there is something in the Bill which would make it unlawful. There is nothing of that nature in the Bill. If the Senator and his employee wish to enter into a contract, the Bill does not prevent them.

I am not sure that Senator Counihan is serious. If he is, this is a case where there will be no bargaining. This may be against the principle of the Bill altogether.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is. It is out of order. This Bill is for a weekly-half-holiday and you cannot substitute a monthly half-holiday.

Comment on this

It may be, but after all, Senator Hayes and Senator Quirke must forget that this is only a Bill and not an Act, and we are entitled to put in suggestions to improve it. I contend that I am quite entitled to put a suggestion as to the best way to improve the Bill.

Comment on this

I suggested to Senator Counihan that on sub-section (3) he could attempt to provide that where a person does take a half-holiday he will get the half-holiday pay but where he does not take it he will get only half the half-holiday pay. That would be an inducement to him. Senator O'Dwyer begins his amendment: "Notwithstanding anything in this Act...." There is nothing in the Bill to make an agreement for ten months unlawful. If, having made the agreement, the man walks out, what can you do about it, particularly to a worker on a dairy farm? There is no use in sending a Guard to haul him back by the hair of the head and tell him he must go on working. He would not go on, or if he did he would be of no use to the farmer. There is no use in talking about binding agreements, as it all depends on goodwill. Under sub-section (3) all these agreements suggested in amendments Nos. 19 and 20 could be made. I think that meets the case both of Senator O'Dwyer and Senator Orpen. Whether they will be carried out or not is another question. Nothing we can put into the Bill will make it more likely that they would be carried out than the present situation makes it.

Comment on this

In view of Senator Counihan's statement that this provision was suggested by agricultural workers who wanted one whole day, may I say they have only to forgo one half-holiday and they will get the whole day the next week?

Comment on this

They are entitled to an annual holiday, anyway.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I have every sympathy with what Senator O'Dwyer wants to achieve, but I agree with Senator Hayes about this amendment. If the two people enter into a contract, that contract stands in so far as it is enforceable in the court. There is nothing to prevent the employer taking the employee to court, or vice versa, if the terms of the contract are broken. The Senator himself says:—

"Whereby the agricultural worker shall agree to work a full working week."

All that is covered earlier under subsections (2) and (3) to which Senator Hayes has referred and also in the amendment which has been agreed to as proposed by Senator Orpen and amended by Senator McCrea. These people sit down to determine when the half-holiday may be taken. Inherent in that agreement is this other consideration, that the man is going to be paid when he works on. We cannot make it any more secure for the dairy farmer. I regard this as superfluous and unnecessary and not actually covering the circumstances which Senator O'Dwyer wants to meet. There is nothing in the Bill to prevent Senator O'Dwyer and the Limerick dairyman entering into a ten-months' contract, as they were accustomed to do in the past. The question of getting the workers to work on the half-holiday is a matter for agreement between them. I am quite sure that case will be made, too.

Comment on this

I think Senator O'Dwyer has more fear than he should have and hence he was prompted to put down this amendment. Under the Bill as it stands, an arrangement could be made between employer and employee on the lines suggested. I agree with Senator Baxter's viewpoint, but he refers again to a contract and says it would be enforceable in law. Let us be realistic. In how many cases is there, in fact, a contract? I took it that he implied there was to be a contract document.

Comment on this

Then it is to be a verbal contract?

Comment on this

In how many cases will that be enforceable? That could be done before now, but in how many cases has it ever been brought to the courts? I have never heard of any case. Take a farmer who makes an arrangement for a worker to work at a certain rate and have certain additional rights or amenities. That may go on until, for some reason, the worker decides to go. He can give a day's notice.

Comment on this

Will he be paid the wages? If the worker is under contract for ten months at £140 and he walks out after three months, will the farmer pay him £40?

Comment on this

In nine cases out of ten he is paid by the week.

Comment on this

You cannot do that by contract.

Comment on this

I am trying to get a definition of a contract. Is there anything which is not binding or enforceable?

Comment on this

Ask Senator O'Dwyer.

Comment on this

I would urge the House to accept Senator O'Dwyer's amendment. My grounds for that would be firstly, that I would like this amendment to be accepted as it fits the facts as we know them in the south of Ireland. We know the ten months' contract. That is what we are accustomed to in hiring men in Kerry anyway outside the church gates after Mass on Sundays at the beginning of the year. The labourer wants one thing. He wants to be free at Christmas. He does not want a holiday in February, March, June, July, or August, but he wants to go home to his father and to his own household at Christmas. That is the history that we know in the south of Ireland.

Some Senators may be in doubt as to the remedy an employer has when an employee goes off in a huff in the middle of summer. Any one of us who has recourse to the law courts knows what that is. There is generally embodied in the ten months' contract a month's notice either way. We know that the farmer can succeed in retaining one month's wages. We know that if he wants to sack his employee during the ten months' contract he can pay him one month's wages in lieu of notice. I like the amendment of Senator Martin O'Dwyer for that reason, and it was out of Senator O'Dwyer's experience that this amendment came. In endeavouring to do anything in our legislative capacity, we must always seek to take cognisance of the facts that obtain in any industry. If this amendment is not inserted in the Bill the custom and the practice in the country that is of very long standing will be upset.

I stood in the labour market in Tralee last Sunday morning with a farmer who was hiring a man for the year and whether it is out of reading this Bill or not, I do not know, but that particular farm labourer said: "John, I would like to work for you as I worked for you before. I would like to live in your house, but I must be paid weekly. There is one condition I will lay down; I will not work on Sunday afternoon or Sunday evening." Was that, or was it not, his weekly half-holiday? I say that that is a binding decision in any court of law in this country. If you do not accept Senator O'Dwyer's amendment you will leave it to the courts to decide whether it is superfluous or not. Senator Baxter says it is superfluous. He is not satisfied that it is necessary. Earlier this evening we had the views expressed that a penalty of £20 was too much, but if you fail to accept this amendment you will impose a far greater penalty on some poor farmer or farm labourer down the country, to test whether this amendment is superfluous or not, or whether the ten-month contract is covered or not by the Bill as it stands without this amendment. For that reason, I would urge very strongly that the amendment should be accepted. If it is superfluous it will do no harm.

Comment on this

I fail completely to follow the reasoning of the Senator. Everything he has said, every statement he has made as to what may happen with regard to a contract is no help in any way to this amendment. I wonder if he has read this in connection with Sections 2 and 3 of the Bill: "Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act," implies there is something contained in this Bill which prevents a contract of any kind. There is nothing in this Bill which prevents a contract being entered into.

Comment on this

I do not suggest there is.

Comment on this

Then there is no sense in accepting the amendment. There is nothing in the Bill to prevent the employer and worker from entering into a contract. The amendment is entirely superfluous in view of the fact that it is already in the Bill. I fail entirely to follow the reasoning of Senator Woulfe in his last speech or his argument. It is entirely unnecessary. It would not help in any way the problem with which the Senator was faced outside the chapel in Tralee on last Sunday because John or Jim could still say to his master: "Unless you give me this and that, I will not enter into the contract." You have no way of forcing him into the contract. The only remedy John has is to leave Jim as he is and go and employ Martin if they can come to an agreement. There is nothing in this Bill to prevent them from entering into a contract. This will not help either Senator O'Dwyer or Senator Woulfe to solve their problems in any way whatsoever.

Comment on this

Will it do any harm?

Comment on this

It is superflous and you do not want to repeat what is already in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Bill lays down that an employer shall give the half-holiday to the employee. That is definite. The Bill in its present form allows the employee to work. On the side of the employer the Bill is definite and clear that he must allow the half-holiday. It is quite open to the employer and employee to come together and agree to work so many months but the employee can strike out at any moment he likes and claim his half-holiday. All the binding is upon the employer to give the half-holiday. It depends upon the worker whether he will take it or not. I feel quite sure that all the workers would only be too glad to get the additional half-holiday but it would prevent any misunderstanding and difficulties if the amendment were accepted.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would it meet your point if this amendment were deferred and an amendment brought in on Report Stage when the matter has been looked into.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Next stage?

Comment on this

I suggest the first day we meet after Easter would be a reasonable date.

Report Stage fixed for first meeting after Easter Recess.

Comment on this

I wonder would it be possible to have the Bill, as amended, circulated as soon as possible so that we can see in good time if any adjustments have to be made on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

It will be circulated without delay.

Comment on this

It may be necessary to have some sort of meeting between Senator O'Connell and some or all of the Senators who moved amendments which were more or less accepted so as to avoid any misunderstanding afterwards. Senator Hawkins, Senator Loughman and Senator O'Dwyer moved amendments which were more or less accepted, but the suggestion was that they would be put in a slightly different form. I would suggest that those Senators should have a meeting next week.

Comment on this

The proposal now is to adjourn until Tuesday. On Tuesday the business will consist of the Central Fund Bill, which will be concluded in the Dáil to-morrow night, and the Defence Forces (Temporary Provisions) Bill, which is a continuing Bill. Both these Bills need to be passed before the 31st March. Senator Quirke's suggestion with regard to a meeting of Senators who had proposed amendments to this Bill can be carried out on Tuesday.

The Seanad adjourned at 9.5 p.m. until Tuesday, 20th March, 1951, at 3 p.m.

Comment on this