Local Government Bill, 1954—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–217 of 440. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1954 ›
Before we take up consideration of the amendments tabled for this Bill, it would be as well if I indicated that there are certain amendments which I consider out of order and they may not be moved. These amendments are Nos. 10, 11, 19, 20 and 32.
I consider Nos. 10, 11 and 19 out of order because they increase the charge on the Exchequer, which is not permissible in an amendment by a Private Member.
Amendments Nos. 20 and 32 are also out of order as they deal with matters outside the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
I am advised that, under this section, duties can be imposed on an officer of a local authority without his consent and even without his knowledge which he never agreed to perform when he was appointed to his position. I understand that, if that is done, he has no remedy but to resign, and presumably if he does resign, he will get no pension. A similar position arises under the section with regard to an officer whose duties have been transferred— he is to lose some of his duties and presumably also some of his remuneration. I should like the Minister to clarify the position and, if possible, to assure me that my interpretation of the section is incorrect.
Comment on this
The House will appreciate that it is essential now that an officer of one local authority should perform certain duties for another, particularly in these days of regional spheres, be they in health or otherwise. An officer who is aggrieved by the decision to transfer him has a statutory right under the 1941 Act to appeal to the Minister. That right is not being taken from him. He has that statutory right under Section 10 (2) of the Local Government Act, 1941, and I may bring it to the notice of the House that, under Section 59 of this Bill, the making of an agreement or arrangement under the section between one local authority and another, or a statutory body, is a reserved function and not an executive function. That being so— such a transfer or agreement being a reserved function — and the person being transferred having that right of appeal, I think every person will be protected.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:—
In sub-section (1), line 36, before "direct", to insert "in consultation with the local authority".
This section provides that the appropriate Minister may direct that the remuneration of all the offices in relation to which he is the appropriate Minister—that is not the Minister for Local Government but any one of the many Ministers who may send directions to local authorities—or of such of those offices as belong to a specified class, description or grade, or of a specified one of those offices, shall be inclusive remuneration. That is giving authority and power to a number of Ministers to make regulations, so far as remuneration is concerned, without any consultation with the local authority concerned. This Bill is supposed to give back power to the local authorities and here we are giving, not to one Minister but to a number of Ministers, power to give directions and taking from the local authority any say in the matter of what remuneration should be paid to persons who may be appointed.
It is a very serious matter because I consider that the Minister, in exercising powers under this section, would be naturally inclined to be in order, in relation to remuneration to be paid to a particular service, one applicable to the whole country. The Minister will agree with me when I say that it is not the best way of fixing remuneration. It should be a matter for the local authorities to decide. The works involved in different counties, the areas to be covered, and so forth, are vastly different. In that regard I think a very desirable suggestion is being made to the Minister in asking him that this power should not be exercised, except in consultation with the local authority concerned, and where agreement is reached as to the remuneration to be paid to the various types of officers appointed.
Comment on this
I am in full agreement with the Senator, but the amendment is superfluous and absolutely unnecessary. If the Senator would refer to the section, and study its import, he will see how unnecessary the amendment is. Directions, first of all, as to inclusive remuneration require the consent of the holders of the office. That is essential. If the holder was going to lose, there would be an application for an increase in salary. Directions as to the inclusive remuneration are practically always associated with increases in salary. I think that is the case the Senator visualises. It is the local authority which awards such increases. Therefore, the local authority must be a party to the arrangement. If the local authority are going to award the increases, then, ipso facto, they are a party to the arrangement, and know all about it. Therefore, the Senator will understand that the amendment is absolutely unnecessary.
Comment on this
I think this section refers to the remuneration of persons now in receipt of fees for various services. Here you are taking away from a person appointed under a particular contract, as it were. You are now saying that these funds naturally will go into the revenue of the local authority, but the Minister still is the person who is to decide what the remuneration will be. I cannot see why, under this section, the local authority has power to make any decision. Of course, persons must give their consent to it.
Comment on this
I can assure the Senator and the House that it is the local authority which grants such increases. Increases in inclusive remuneration will be by agreement between the holder of the office and the local authority. First of all, there must be agreement. We may take it that if the holder of an office enters into such an agreement, he will do so only provided it increases his remuneration. It is the local authority which grants increases in remuneration and not the Minister. The Minister has no function whatsoever other than to sanction it. It is the local authority which enters into agreement with the holder of a particular office. Therefore they are not unaware of what is going on. The Senator's amendment "in consultation with the local authority" will be observed in practice. It is essential that it should be carried out because they are the people who are going to sanction the increased remuneration. I can assure the Senator that his amendment is absolutely superfluous in so far as that is concerned.
Comment on this
Arising out of the Minister's reply, if the local manager recommends it, does the Minister take him as representing the local authority?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator does not distinguish between a reserved function and an executive function. This is a reserved function and not an executive one.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is a little bit ambiguous. There is a Bill before the Dáil at the moment which gives powers to the local authority to veto every increase or decrease in the salaries of permanent officials. When that Bill becomes law, there will be no increase without the absolute sanction of the local authority—I mean the elected representatives of the people. The Bill which is at present before the Dáil and this particular section must be read in conjunction with each other. I think that should meet the point raised by Senator Hickey.
Comment on this
Why look upon the manager as representing the local authority or the local authority as representing the manager?
Comment on this
The Senator knows much better than I do that a reserved function is something which is reserved to the local authority, and an executive function is something which is in the absolute discretion of the county manager. They are two completely different things. This will be a reserved function and the local authority will have full powers to veto every increase or decrease of salary when the County Management (Amendment) Bill becomes law.
Comment on this
The Minister has shifted his ground somewhat. He referred to a Bill which is before the Dáil. I think we should consider only the Bill which is before us now. It is complicating matters a little by referring to a Bill which is to come before us later. As far as I can see, the purpose of this amendment is that where persons in the employment of local authorities receive fees of one kind or another at present, and where the occupants of these posts die or resign, there will be brought about a change in the system of appointment, and the change will be in the nature of an inclusive remuneration. That is the procedure which has been adopted up to the present.
It is proposed now to do away with this system and have an inclusive salary. But the filling of these posts is in almost every case referred to the Local Appointments Commission. It is here the question arises as to who is going to fix remuneration increases of that kind. It is not altogether a matter, if the present holder of an office agrees that he has received fees of £600 per year for the particular post he occupies, of either the local authority or the manager saying: "We are going to change that. We are not going to abolish fees. These fees will be paid in future into local government funds and we are going to give you an inclusive salary of £700 a year." That would be an increase of £100. But it is the Minister who is in this section all the time taking the power of giving the direction. I cannot therefore see the Minister's point of view that he is entirely in sympathy with the idea that it should be in consultation with the local authority. I ask the Minister to look into this question between now and the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Paragraph (5) of Section 12 states:—
"A local authority may, with the general or particular approval of the appropriate Minister, abolish offices, but in the case of an office held by a person in a permanent capacity, it shall not be abolished save with the consent of that person."
This, I understand, covers much the same case as we discussed on Section 9, that these offices will be abolished only on the death or resignation of the present holder. But the Minister is still making provision that these offices can be abolished and that the consent of the present holder be taken into account. The wording of Section 17, which deals with much the same matter, is as follows:—
"On account of any alteration (whether it has already occurred or is in contemplation) in the nature or extent of the duties attached to such office, it is in the public interest that such office should be abolished."
In Section 12 there is no account taken of whether it is or it is not in the public interest that this change should take place. The only condition laid down is that you must have the consent of the present occupants. Paragraph (6) of Section 12 states:—
"An appeal under sub-section (2) of this section shall not be brought after the expiration of six months after the decision is communicated to the officer."
I had experience of cases where the six months' period, owing to illness, was not sufficient. However, I do not stress that point. I want to draw the Minister's attention to the necessity to have the public interest taken into account in any implementation of this section, as it is in Section 17.
Comment on this
The Senator and the House will be able to distinguish the difference between Section 12 and Section 17. Paragraph (4) of Section 12 states:—
"For the purposes of this section, a local authority may, with the general or particular approval of the appropriate Minister, create offices either on a permanent or a temporary basis.
(5) A local authority may, with the general or particular approval of the appropriate Minister, abolish offices, but in the case of an office held by a person in a permanent capacity, it shall not be abolished save with the consent of that person.
(6) An appeal under sub-section (2) of this section shall not be brought after the expiration of six months after the decision is communicated to the officer."
I do not know exactly to which sub-section the Senator refers. I take it he is in agreement with sub-section (6) as prescribed in the section. I take it that the Senator has no objection to that. With regard to the six months' period in regard to an appeal, the reason that was put in was that I, as Minister, have been asked to allow appeals of officers, whose offices were abolished a considerable number of years ago. It is to put an end to that and this political waiting, if I may use the expression, until there is a change of Government to decide whether to appeal or otherwise. If they do not appeal within the six months' period that is the end of it. I think the House will agree it is a very proper thing. It is unfair that, if an officer feels aggrieved with the decision given, he should wait until the Minister approving the decision is supplanted by somebody else who is possibly of a different political persuasion. It is to put an end to that that the six months' period is there. We want to legalise the whole thing and say that the person has the legal right of appeal and that he has only six months in which to make it.
Paragraph (5) states:
"A local authority may, with the general or particular approval of the appropriate Minister, abolish offices, but in the case of an office held by a person in a permanent capacity, it shall not be abolished save with the consent of that person."
I can visualise, for instance, the curator of a museum saying we wish to abolish the museum; that there is no necessity for it; that it is outmoded and out of date. If the official is a permanent official he will be consulted and will only be removed with his consent. Again, in these days of regional hospitals it may be necessary to abolish particular offices for the purpose of creating a major office. I will deal with Section 17 when we come to it but there is no inconsistency between Section 12 and Section 17.
Comment on this
I am certain that Senator Hickey knows much more about the matter than I do. The local authority is defined under the County Management Acts. The local authority is the elected representatives but the county manager has certain functions known as executive functions.
Comment on this
The Senator is about 14 years late in his objection. When the Act became law in 1940, I was not a member of the House but the Senator was a very worthy member of it.
Comment on this
I was then in the kindergarten. When I refer to the local authority I may be referring to the county manager, depending on whether the function is an executive or a reserved function. If I refer to a reserved function, I refer to the local authority representatives, but if I refer to an executive function, then I refer to the city or county manager.
Comment on this
If he deals with an executive function. I think the matter will be clarified better when we come to discuss the County Management Bill.
Comment on this
I want to be clear on this Bill. It seems to me that the Minister is satisfied that the county manager is the local authority.
Comment on this
In the appointment of personnel, and the letting of houses, which are executive functions.
Comment on this
That is the law as it stands, but I am taking steps to amend that law. In other words, there will be no increases in the remuneration of the permanent personnel of a local authority without the prior consent and sanction of the elected representatives, when the County Management (Amendment) Bill becomes law. As we have got to take one Bill before the other Bill I prefer to take this one before the County Management Bill. Unfortunately, we cannot take both together.
Comment on this
We have had a long discussion on reserved functions. Would the Minister inform the House as to whether Section 12 of this Bill is a reserved function?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
To delete paragraphs (m) and (n) lines 47 to 62, inclusive.
The reason I propose the omission of paragraph (m) is that it apparently gives a new power to local authorities to impose short term disciplinary suspensions, not exceeding seven days. This is an extremely complex Bill. I do not pretend to be an expert on it. I am merely looking for clarification. I have been asked to say that this new paragraph enables county managers to impose short term disciplinary suspensions almost at their whim and without right of appeal It gives the power to the manager to suspend the official and it gives the official no right of appeal against the short sentences of suspension. That is giving too many discretionary powers to county managers.
My objection to paragraph (m) is the general objection in principle that I mentioned on the Second Reading to legislation by Order. Under this section, the Minister has power to give directions for the carrying out of the Act. It would be very difficult to interpret these directions owing to the fact that it is not quite clear in the text whether the directions will have the force of law or not. I think, personally, that they will probably not have the force of law. If they have the force of law, then they are giving the Minister power to which we object on general principles for it is the power of legislation by Order. If these directions have not the power of law, then it is very difficult to see the necessity for putting these words into the Bill at all.
The Minister has power to give directions and, if these directions have not the force of law, I do not see why it is necessary to include them in the Bill. I shall give this instance of what I mean. Under the Local Government (Superannuation) Act, local authorities were given powers to grant additional years for the purpose of calculating superannuation. There is a statutory maximum of ten years provided but under this Act the local authority has power to use its discretion in the number of years to be granted. I am informed that in 1951 the Department of Local Government issued a direction to local authorities setting out the number of additional years to be allowed in certain circumstances. That direction had no legal standing but it operated to take from local authorities whatever initiative they had to decide the number of additional years.
If these directions have got legal power and standing it means a further extension of legislation by decree and, if they have not legal power, there is no point in putting them into the Bill at all. I understand that these directions, if they have power of law, will limit the field of action of local authorities and, therefore, I propose that paragraphs (m) and (n) be deleted.
Comment on this
With regard to these amendments, it is my personal opinion that Senator O'Brien ministerprets what would happen if the amendments were accepted. The effect of the acceptance of the amendments would be that local authorities would have no power whatever to suspend an officer, as the powers given to them in that connection under Section 27 of the 1940 Act are being repealed under this Bill. Local authorities had certain disciplinary powers under Section 27 of the 1941 Act but these are now being repealed
Comment on this
I was then in the perhaps unusual that an ordinary pracby this Bill. If I were to accept the amendment as set out, it would leave the local authorities with no powers of suspension whatever. Possibly the Senator did not understand that point.
When the local authority suspends an officer at the moment, it takes months and months before a decision can be given. The offence may be merely a misdemeanour in the eyes of the local authority and I wish to provide for such a misdemeanour being dealt with quickly. Take the question of an employee turning up for work under the influence of intoxicating liquor. If he is suspended under present circumstances, that file may go on for weeks before a decision is given. It is for cases such as that that I want to give local authorities summary jurisdiction to suspend an officer for seven days. I think that is a reasonable attitude to adopt—to suspend him at once and get it over with. I cannot accept the amendment as it stands because if I did, local authorities would then have no power whatever to suspend an officer. I believe that if the House considers the matter, it will see that it is a good thing that the local authority should have some powers of summary jurisdiction and it is only for that purpose that the section has been put in.
With regard to the other point raised by Senator O'Brien, it has been the practice for years for predecessors of mine to issue directions which have absolutely no statutory validity at all. These directions have been issued down through the years and, while some local authorities have acted on them, others have treated them to the respect they deserve and thrown them in the waste paper basket. We want to legalise the position and make some statutory provision for these regulations which have been issued down through the years. There is no question of local government by the Civil Service, because in every instance the Minister must stand over the regulations issued and I think I can speak for my predecessors as well as for myself in that regard. The Custom House has too often been blamed in this matter. It is the Minister's Department and the Minister's responsibility and the Minister must bear that responsibility. It is to legalise these directions and to give them some statutory effect that I have put this provision into the Bill. What I should like to see would be that regulations would be made that would be applicable to all the local authorities and not merely that directions should be given. I want to see regulations made which would apply to the entire country with some legal effect and it is for that reason that I put in the section. The Minister must stand over any regulations made by the Custom House and there will be no such thing as legislation by civil servants.
Comment on this
I have stated in regard to paragraph (n) that I was not quite clear whether these regulations were to have the force of law. I have now got it from the Minister that they will have the force of law and that the object of including them in the Bill is to give them the force of law. A distinction has been drawn between regulations given by the Civil Service and regulations given by the Minister but that is a distinction which is not a very valid one. The Minister has stated that he wishes to legalise the regulations issued under his predecessor. While the Minister can give an assurance on the matter of his own acts he cannot give any assurance for the acts of his successor. If regulations of this kind can be issued, it seems to me to be a very wide extension of the principle of legislation by Order, which I oppose very strongly. The Statutory Orders Committee of the Seanad is constantly investigating matters of this kind. I suggest that further powers of this kind should not be conferred on any Department or any Minister without very strong justification being made by the Minister claiming the powers.
As regards (m), I think I am correct in taking the Minister to agree with me that short term disciplinary suspensions not exceeding seven days are new. The local government code was involved and complicated and for any layman to find his way through it was not very easy. I speak subject to correction, but I believe I am correct in assuming that these are new powers. There again, it seems to me, this is a new disciplinary power given to an executive official which can greatly interfere with the liberty of local officials. I am objecting to it on that ground, and I think there should be a strong case made for the extension of executive powers whether in the hands of the county manager or the Minister himself.
Comment on this
I would like to ask a question, to clarify my own mind on the amendment to paragraph (n). As the Bill stands at present, does the local authority have power to advise the Minister to suspend local government officials?
Comment on this
It is the county manager or the city manager, as the case may be, not the local authority.
Comment on this
I feel that there is great substance in the points that Senator O'Brien has made and that the Minister might consider them further. There is no doubt that under paragraph (m) it might be possible that a local government employee would be treated on quite a different basis to the manner in which an employee of any private employer could be treated. A private employer could not do the kind of thing that can be done under (m). I fully appreciate that it is very unlikely that such cases will arise, but it is a matter that the Minister should consider further.
As regards (n) it seems to me that the sub-section is extremely wide. The Minister should reconsider it. I can quite see the possibility that under some of his successors things might be done which are certainly not contemplated at present and which might give rise to grave difficulty in the future. I would respectfully suggest that those two paragraphs require some more consideration.
Comment on this
I have some difficulty in understanding these paragraphs. Paragraph (n) says "providing for the supplementing of the regulations by directions (being directions for the purpose of giving effect to the regulations, but neither extending the regulations nor widening their scope..." If they neither extend the regulations nor widen their scope, what are these supplementary regulations going to do? Is it merely to bring regulations into operation? I think the drafting needs further consideration.
Comment on this
Let me deal with paragraph (m) first. There is very little change in the existing law. Let us try to visualise what the law is at the moment. The local authority at the moment has the power to suspend sine die. When they suspend, they must report the matter to the Minister, who either confirms it or otherwise. It takes considerable time. Possibly the aggrieved person does not want the file to go to the Minister at all. It may be a simple misdemeanour. We are giving the local authority under paragraph (m), in the case of a misdemeanour, power to suspend for seven days. That ends the matter at the end of seven days. If the aggrieved person wishes, he may still appeal to the Minister but very often he is most anxious that the facts should never get to the Minister if it is a question of a simple misdemeanour. There is really very little change in the law. So far as a particular official is concerned there is absolutely no change whatever if he wishes to appeal, but if he is quite satisfied with the position at the end of the seven days there is an end to it. Remember it says “not exceeding seven days”; it may be only two days, or a day or half a day. One can visualise an officer turning in in the afternoon, possibly under the influence of drink, and the county manager tells him to go home and suspends him for the afternoon. Would it not be a tragedy if that man had to remain suspended until the Minister investigated the whole facts—as is the law at the moment?
With regard to (n) there is a multiplicity of regulations which are made by the Minister for various local authorities. I could give many examples; for instance, travelling expenses of officials and members of local authorities, where, as the price of petrol increases or decreases, the amount of travelling expenses alters accordingly. It is to govern such cases—simple cases such as that—that the Minister may give effect to his regulations by way of direction and we give the same statutory authority to these directions. I could continue to quote examples. It would be too bad, indeed, if we had to make statutory by means of a section in the Act any change in the payment of expenses every time there was an increase or decrease in the price of petrol. You may say to me that as the law stands, it is all right. It was all right so long as local authorities accepted the directions of the Minister, but local authorities have now learned that these directions have no legal effect whatsoever and some have refused to act on them. This is merely to enable the Minister to see that his regulations are carried out.
Comment on this
I would like to have it more clearly from the Minister whether this is a reserved function or an executive function. That is important in considering the suspension of the person for whom we are providing here and particularly where we are providing for a period of seven days. The Minister attempted to justify (n) by referring to regulations made in relation to such matters as travelling expenses and personal allowances to employees of local authorities. That case should not be sufficient to influence the House to accept this amendment. If we look at Section 19 of the 1941 Act we find that there the Minister has ample powers to make regulations without an opportunity being given for consultation with the local authorities or even provision being made that such regulations should be laid on the Table of this or the other House, to give an opportunity for a review within the specified period if the necessity arises. It is not the local authority that has the power of suspending or imposing any penalties in relation to this section: it is an executive function. Power is given to the Minister to do certain things. It is not a question of the county council or the local authority being given power to implement this particular section. For that reason, particularly in relation to paragraph (m) we should ask the Minister to reconsider the drafting of this.
Comment on this
The Senator will appreciate that any regulations made under the Act must be laid on the Tables of both Houses of the Oireachtas. The Senator opened by asking was it an executive or a reserved function. He answered that himself by saying it was an executive function and I confirm what he said.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:—
In line 10, page 8, before the word "absent" to insert the words "on holiday or suspended".
There may be certain occasions when the words "ill, absent or incapacitated" might not be sufficient to cover all eventualities. Therefore, I would ask the Minister to include the words "on holiday or suspended". For instance, a person may be absent but may be on holidays or a person might be incapacitated and may be suspended. Accordingly, I would ask the Minister to consider adding those two words.
Comment on this
I can assure the Senator that I sought legal advice on this matter and that I have been assured that the sub-section provides for the validation of certain acts of a person who is acting for an officer who is ill, absent or incapacitated. I would refer the Senator to Section 19, sub-section (1), paragraph (j) of the 1940 Act where the words "ill, absent, or incapacitated" are also used. I understand that that particular phrase goes back to regulations of 1882 and that it has never given rise to any difficulty whatever. I am advised that the word "absent" can mean "on holidays" and that "incapacitated" includes legally incapacitated which would be suspension. I think that, in these circumstances, the amendment is unnecessary.
Comment on this
If the Minister is satisfied that the words in the sub-section are sufficient I also am satisfied. I should like, however, to point out to the Minister that where a dispensary doctor who occupies a dispensary residence is on holidays, it would be difficult, I think, to appreciate that on an occasion like that the word "absent" would be sufficient.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
To delete all words after "amended by" in line 29 to the end of the section and substitute "the repeal of sub-section (1), paragraph (f)."
This amendment is on the lines of what I mentioned on the Second Reading of the Bill. At present, the Minister has power to lay down certain types of qualifications for the taking of a post under a local authority or for the retention of that post. Among the qualifications which he is permitted to lay down is the qualification that the holder of a post shall be either, if she is a woman, unmarried or a widow. The effect of this amendment which I am proposing, if it were passed, would be to remove the right to dismiss a woman employee of a local authority from her post on marriage, or to insist, where a post was to be given to a woman, that she be either unmarried or a widow.
My purpose in putting this amendment before the Seanad is to submit the view that married women ought not in any circumstances to lose any of their rights as full citizens of this country upon marriage. It seems to me that in the 20th century it is a generally recognised personal individual right of women, if they be married, to decide whether or not they want to retain a post for which they are qualified, or whether they prefer to resign and give it up in order to devote themselves to the running of their homes. I suggest that, as matters stand at present, a woman may be disqualified for the—I do not know whether one can call it either a misdemeanour or a crime—of marriage, but as things stand at present it seems to me that this is State interference with an individual right or liberty. I believe that married women should have full rights as citizens, although I recognise, as we all do, that many women on marriage would prefer to give up their job, whatever it may be, and to abandon whatever rights they may have in order to turn to domestic duties in their homes. I also recognise that other women may prefer to retain their jobs, at any rate for a time. It seems to me that the right to make that decision ought to be the personal right of the women involved, and not the right of a local authority or of the Minister.
I suggest, in all seriousness, that this may very well in a small way, and perhaps in a bigger way than we recognise, be one of the factors which discourage early marriage in this country. I recognise, of course, that it is a good thing, in the wide generality of cases, for married women with children, particularly during the early years of their marriage, while the children are young, to look after their own home, but should such a woman be compelled by the force of economic circumstances—by the fact that she is going to be dismissed from her job— to do so? Is that not a matter of personal decision on the part of the parent, and who is the State or the Minister to interfere in the making of a decision of that kind?
I think, for example, that we all recognise that in many cases it would be an excellent thing for the home if the man of the house were to spend more of his payroll on things for the house and perhaps less on things for himself. It might be better if some men, to put it very bluntly, spent less on drink and more on the home. What kind of an outcry would there be if the Oireachtas were to try to take power to insist that, for the sake of the home and of the children, men should be prevented from spending their money in whatever way they please? In other words, the individual must have his right, and the woman individual must have her right.
I suggest, furthermore, that there is a precedent to be found in most fields: in business, in the professions, in the sciences and in the universities—precedents for married women of talent and of distinction continuing to fulfil, with the same talent and distinction, the posts which they had before marriage. I think that from the community point of view that is an excellent thing—that they should have that right. It is a right that is recognised in most civilised countries to-day, and in particular, I think it would be a good thing for this country—one could think of several professions which might be greatly improved by it—were married women not to be dismissed automatically on marriage. One can think notably of the teaching profession where married women primary teachers who are fully qualified are replaced all too often by untrained teachers.
I can recall the case of the Countess Markievicz, a very distinguished woman—I need not pay any tribute to her because we all have the same admiration for her qualities, her courage and her service to the country. In her case, I do not think anyone would have suggested that the question should have been put to her before she served with the Citizen Army in the College of Surgeons in 1916 that a woman's place was in the home. I suggest, further, that throughout the national struggle in this country Irishwomen, married and unmarried, have been allowed to serve on an equal footing, as the Countess Markievicz served, with their male colleagues.
I would say, furthermore, in order to bring the point up to date, that I rather doubt if there is any political Party in this country to-day which refuses the services of married women at election time, for the purpose of addressing envelopes, canvassing, checking registers and doing all the little odd jobs which all the political Parties are so glad to get done by voluntary service. I doubt very much whether the women who do active service for the political Parties in that way are ever told that they would be better advised to go back to their homes. Therefore, I suggest that, in maintaining this principle that the woman employee must be "sacked" on marriage, we are behaving, in the light of our practice in other fields, in a somewhat hypocritical way. By reason of this process of the dismissing of a qualified woman simply because she is married, and whether or not she wants to continue in her post, I suggest that there is necessarily a lowering of the standards established in certain positions; and for all these reasons I would urge the Seanad to pass the amendment and leave it to the married woman herself to have her own personal free right to decide, to choose for herself whether or not she will continue in her employment, for some time or permanently after marriage.
Comment on this
The Senator appears to forget the fact that I am trying to modify the law. I am trying to assist married women. The Senator is inclined to forget that, as the law stands at the moment, a married woman who is in employment may not seek a transfer to employment under another local authority. I am trying to give that class of married women a little more scope to better themselves, if I may use the expression. That is the amendment which I propose in the Bill.
With regard to the broad principle which the Senator propounds, may I quote for him the Constitution of this country? Article 41 (2º) lays down:—
"The State, therefore, guarantees to protect the family in its constitution and authority ..."
It goes further, then, in 2 (1) and says:—
"In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved."
The woman's place is her home. That has been the policy of the State down through the years. It is the policy of the State in so far as the teaching profession is concerned and it is the policy of the State in so far as the Civil Service is concerned. Exceptions have never been allowed. As I am sure the Senator and the House appreciate once the married status of a woman changes, when she becomes a widow, the State has always been anxious to reconsider the position, and, if at all possible, to re-employ her, be it in the service of a local authority, the Civil Service or the teaching profession; but while she remains married, we believe, with the Constitution, that a married woman's place is her home, to look after the care and upbringing of her family, and we go so far under Civil Service regulations and the regulations appropriate to the teaching profession to lay down that, even in the case of a childless married woman, she is not capable of being employed. However, I am sure the Senator will appreciate that I am trying to help married women who are at present in the employment of a local authority and who sought and obtained that employment prior to this marriage bar being enforced. I am giving them the opportunity now, if they are in employment down the country, of applying for similar employment in the City of Dublin, which is something they could not do. I am assisting them and I ask the House to assist me in assisting them.
Comment on this
I recognise at once, I should like to say, that the purpose of the amendment as put forward by the Minister is to help certain married women who are at present not affected by this marriage bar, despite what the Minister has told us about the universality of its application and its being enshrined indelibly in the Constitution. I recognise that he is trying to help, but I suggest that he is not going far enough and that this section, as it is at present before us, becomes unnecessary if we remove the marriage bar. The Minister has told us of the Constitution's desire to protect the family, and he has told us that a woman's place is in the home. I am afraid I regard it as an individual right on the part of the woman herself to decide whether in certain circumstances her place is in the home or whether she should continue to serve in other fields.
I do not accept the suggestion made by the Minister on the universality of this practice, and I have already pointed out that the Minister's amendment, in fact, relates to women who are married and not affected by this marriage bar. The Minister mentioned the teaching profession, but there are grades in the teaching profession where it does not apply, notably, secondary teaching and, I think, university teaching. He has said that it is the duty of a woman to look after her home and children, and he has even said that it is the duty of the childless married woman to stay at home. I suggest with respect that that is an outmoded view, and a view which is going to deprive the country of a great deal of talent. I suggest that the real principle enshrined in the Constitution and deriving from the proclamation of the Republic is that men and women shall be equal before the law and shall have equal rights. For that reason, it seems to me that this ministerial amendment, while its intention is to be helpful, would become unnecessary if, in fact, quite simply, we removed this marriage bar.
Comment on this
Without expressing a personal opinion on what the Senator has said, let me say that it is completely contrary to public policy in this country to employ married women in local services, the Civil Service or the teaching profession, but we recognise that, before it became public policy, certain women had procured employment in these various services and that it would have been unfair that these women should automatically cease to hold the positions which they held prior to the marriage bar becoming operative. We permitted them to remain in that employment and I now by this Bill am trying to better their position, but I am not cutting across the public policy of this Government and of Governments down through the years. As I have said, I do not wish to express a personal opinion on the matter and all I can tell the Senator and the House is that it is contrary to public policy and I am sorry that I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Is there a ban on a woman taking her seat in the Seanad or Dáil, unless she happens to be either unmarried or a widow?
Comment on this
Surely if it is contrary to public policy, it is a consideration that must be taken into account.
Comment on this
The real difficulty about the amendment is this: the Minister is proposing to amend the law so as to help certain married women who are already in employment, and Senator Skeffington wishes to bring in an amendment to alter a particular principle which applies to the employment of married women in local government service and in the Civil Service. We could have an interesting discussion on that matter. There is a very important principle involved. What the Senator is endeavouring to do is to bring a side-wind to this particular Local Government Bill, and to get the Seanad to agree that certain things should be done in regard to employees of local authorities. If it were done in the case of local authorities, it should be done also in the case of the Civil Service. In other words, we are discussing something which I think should not be decided on this Bill. I found it very interesting to hear Senator Skeffington state that he was a State socialist. We find him to-day objecting to State interference and advocating suppressing the rights of individuals. That is common form.
Comment on this
The Minister has told us that this is contrary to public policy. I am sure he would agree that it is for the two Houses of the Oireachtas to create and establish, and if necessary to modify, public policy. He himself has referred to the fact that this was not always contrary to public policy. Therefore, public policy has changed in this respect within living memory because his aim is to help people—married women— who were employed before the marriage bar was brought in. Therefore, what he now avers is public policy was not always public policy. I personally would very much favour changing any aspect of public policy which seemed to me to be bad. I do not say that any individual has the right to lay down a law. I think that the Houses of the Oireachtas have the right to change public policy. There is nothing immutable about it. Senator Hayes has suggested that because it is not possible to do everything to-day in relation to removing the marriage ban, —because we cannot deal with the whole Civil Service—that, therefore, it is better to do nothing; because we cannot do everything, let us do nothing ! I do not share that view. I believe that one step forward is more valuable than any amount of marking time, however loudly and rhythmically. The mere fact that we cannot to-day change the marriage bar in relation to some women employees who might be applying for such posts, does not prevent us from setting an example which I hope would, as Senator Hayes has suggested, be later followed by the Civil Service, and so on. He has also suggested, of course, that for a socialist to object to State interference is something representing a contradiction of terms. I would be very happy to give Senator Hayes a long and detailed lecture on the theory of socialism, which, I suggest to him, so far from increasing State interference, does, in fact, liberate a number of people in a number of ways, increasing their personal, social and economic liberty which is, in fact, at present contravened by many things, not only by the marriage bar but by the whole economic circumstances in which we live in our present society. Therefore, while I share with him that view, I hope that he shares with me the view that any step we can take now to decrease State interference with the rights of the individual we should take.
Comment on this
May I make a suggestion? It seems to me that we have a kind of head on collision between two approaches to the same matter. While I sympathise a good deal with Senator Skeffington, I do not think it is the best way to introduce a general principle of this kind. It seems to me it would be better for the House if a motion were put down for debate on the general principle. We will get nowhere unless we approach it in that light.
Comment on this
I am not in sympathy with that view, I am afraid. I would in fact like to press the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not pressing for a division, as I appear to be alone.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
In line 50, before the word "that", to insert the words "subject to the consent of the holder of such office".
I think I have already drawn the attention of the House and the Minister to this section, and Section 12. Under Section 12 we have provision made for the abolition of an office of this kind which would not take place except with the consent of the holder of the office. In Section 17 we have no reference or no provision made for any reference to the holder of the office. I would like to have clarification from the Minister as to the reasons for the different wording in the sections.
Comment on this
The amendment cuts completely across the section. If we accept for the moment that this was accepted and became law it would mean, no matter what the circumstances, that neither the Minister nor the local authority could retire officers who had become redundant as the result of their duties having lapsed or having been transferred to another local authority. Let us, say, take the case of a mental hospital. I can visualise a mental hospital in a particular county. We wish to have a regional mental hospital to serve three, four or five counties. The local authority endeavours to enter into agreement with the local R.M.S. to ask him to retire or be transferred to the new regional hospital. He refuses to go. If the amendment is accepted we must get him to stay despite the fact that there may be no mental patients for treatment. It is cases such as that that we wish to provide for so that if the holder of the office becomes redundant or if his office is abolished the manager may compel the holder of the office to retire.
Comment on this
Who is to decide that it is in the public interest? Is it the local authority concerned or is it the Minister?
Comment on this
If we cast our minds back to Section 24 of the 1941 Act we will find:—
"(1) Where the appropriate Minister is satisfied"——
and so on. Under Section 17 we give the Minister very much wider powers than he has had under Section 24 of the 1941 Act. That is a section which Section 17 proposes to amend, despite the fact that this Bill in general was put before us as a Bill giving more power to the local authorities and as a Bill taking away from the Custom House, as the Minister refers to it, the powers of direction and making of regulations.
This is one of the sections where we give very wide powers to the Minister in regard to deciding whether or not the matter of the removal of a particular public officer, possibly with long service, is in the public interest without there being any regard for the person himself or without making any provision for further employment.
Comment on this
Section 12 gives, first of all, the parties an opportunity of coming together and entering into an agreement. Imagine an urban area with a town clerk and, further, imagine that the urban area becomes de-urbanised. What are we going to do with the town clerk? He has got to remain on and we have got to pay him. Imagine a gasworks switching over to electric light. What are we going to do with the gas manager? Unless he is prepared to enter into an agreement with the local authority, we shall have a gas manager without a gas works and, in the case of the deurbanised area, we shall have a town clerk. It is for cases such as these that we are trying to legislate. It is for cases such as these that I ask the House to accept this section.
Comment on this
I am afraid that the Minister is asking very much more from us than is contained in his simple statement about the town clerk. We might have a gas manager without any gas but you would have the gas anyhow. Section 12 gives power for the creation and abolition of offices.
Comment on this
By agreement and with the consent of the person. If the matter is as simple as the Minister says why were there not added in Section 12 the words "in the public interest"? There are far wider powers given in Section 17.
Comment on this
There is very little I can add. Section 12 gives the people an opportunity of coming together and settling their differences but where they do not come together, and where there is a deadlock, they may appeal to the Minister to abolish the appointment for the simple reason that it would be ridiculous to have a local authority employing a town clerk where there is no urban council. It would be ridiculous to employ a gas manager when we have no gasworks. Senator Hawkins said we would have the gas anyhow but we would have the laugh on some person. I think that, on reconsideration, the Senator will see my point of view. Section 12 gives these parties an opportunity of coming together and settling their differences but, when we find that they will neither lead nor drive, it is time for some person to step in and the only person who will have that authority will be the Minister.
Comment on this
Which is going to be the operative section? In Section 12 we are making provision for the coming together of the parties. That cannot be done without the consent of the persons concerned. We have gone to the trouble of putting in this Bill a section that we cannot abolish a particular office, without the consent of the present occupant of that office. We then passed five sections and we introduced in the fifth section a new clause. We say that the Minister may abolish any office in the public interest, despite the fact that we have already incorporated in the Bill a provision for consultation. Which is going to be the operative section?
Comment on this
The Minister can say that if there is no agreement under Section 12 he has Section 17. In this case it is the Minister who decides what is in the public interest. There is no reference to the occupant of the position despite the fact that we have made provision for consultation and the getting of consent in an earlier section. That seems to me to be contradictory.
Comment on this
Both sections will be operative. Section 12 enables the parties to come together. It may be in the interests of the individual himself to retire. Both parties may come together. They may fail to do so. The employee may not treat with the local authority. Would it not be unfair to give the local authority power to abolish the office right off the reel? I say that when the local authority and the employee cannot come together and it is in the public interest—those are the operative words—then the Minister should step in. I think the Senator will agree that some person must step in. It would be unfair to have an employer step in and abolish the office. The Minister only does it when there is failure to agree between the parties concerned and when it is in the public interest.
Comment on this
If all that Section 17 provides is the simple matter the Minister says, I am not prepared to accept it. I think it would be more fair to the person concerned to know definitely of the provision in the Bill. If he seeks advice in future he will be told that under Section 12 of the 1955 Act the post he now occupies cannot be abolished except with his consent, but then we have this matter of the public interest. What is the public interest? I think this matter is rather serious and I would like the Minister to look into it between this and the next stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
To delete paragraph (II), lines 52 to 54, inclusive.
I raised these points on the Second Stage of the Bill. I think they are very important points. As far as I know, they introduce new principles into local government which were not there before. These sections give power to move officials from one local authority area to another. Under Section 24 of the Act of 1941 it is possible for an officer of a local authority to resign in the public interest.
This section provides that compensation must be paid to the officer who is so required to resign. There is only one exception to this clause and that is where the local authority offers to appoint him to another office with salary and emoluments not less than those of the one he at present occupies. Under this section a person can be transferred from one office to another and that means that he can be transferred from Dublin to Donegal. He forfeits all rights to compensation if that position is offered to him and he refuses to take it. As I read this section it deprives a person of his pension if he is offered a position under any local authority, not merely the one by which he is already employed, but by any other and he refuses to accept it. If I am wrong, I hope the Minister will explain the position, but I cannot see why a person should be refused his pension if he refuses to go from Dublin to Donegal. It would involve him in uprooting his whole family, leaving his house and causing him inconvenience in the education of his children. In this instance the powers of a local authority would be exercised very much to the detriment of their own officials and would enable people to be uprooted and shifted throughout the country in a manner which they would not desire.
The second amendment is very much of the same nature. Paragraph 4 deals with the transfer of officers inside the area of the same local authority. I do not think that the transfer of an officer from one local authority to another is the same as the offer of an appointment to an officer of a local authority in another area of that local authority. Under this section, it would be possible to move a person from one part of the same county to another, and it would also be possible to move him from an urban to a rural district. That might mean that he might be required to travel a long distance to and from his work and his whole family might be inconvenienced as regards education and everything else. I read this section as authorising a transfer of that kind and, therefore, I suggest that both these sections are objectionable, the first because it authorises the transfer of an official from one part of the country to another and the second because it authorises the transfer of an official from one part of a local authority area to another.
Comment on this
I think the Senator has miscontrued the section. It is meant to deal with the transfer of functions from one local authority to another and we have very many instances of that no further away than Dublin. The Dublin City Council has taken over the administration of the road taxation for the entire county and, if there was no agreement between the two bodies, we might have had the officials in Parnell Square sitting up there and twiddling their fingers ever since that change was made.
Again, take the case of the medical hospital. I can visualise a central medical hospital being set up in the Midlands to cater for the whole area from Galway to Dublin. Suppose that a young resident medical superintendent had just been appointed to one of the smaller hospitals in that area. If I accepted this amendment, I would have no option but to retire him on a very small pension while, if the section is permitted to stand, I will be able to confirm the appointment of that young resident medical superintendent in the regional medical hospital in the Midlands.
We have now reached the stage where we have all over this country a number of sanatoria. I certainly hope that we will be able to close down a number of these after some time owing to the reduction in T.B., but I would be very sorry if we had to pension off the young resident medical superintendents in charge of these sanatoria. I would like to be in a position to be able to transfer them to some other centre or regional sanatorium which may take the place of all the smaller sanatoria all over the country. It is for that purpose and that purpose only, when the functions of one local authority are being transferred to another, that I require the section. I can assure the House and the Senator that it is only in circumstances such as I have mentioned that it will be implemented. It is not for the purpose of victimising officials of a local authority or for the purpose of transferring an officer from one local authority to another except where the functions of a local authority have been transferred. It is for that purpose that I require this section.
Comment on this
The Minister has given us the bright side of the picture, but is Senator O'Brien's darker side guarded against under the original Act or not? Suppose we had an unsympathetic and uncharitable Minister, would he have the power to act as Senator O'Brien has suggested?
Comment on this
It is only when the function an officer is performing is being transferred that he would be transferred. I cannot imagine an officer being transferred from Donegal to Cork.
Comment on this
That is stated in the original Act. Can we have an assurance as regards this Bill?
Comment on this
Section 18 provides that Section 27 of the Act of 1941 be repealed. Section 27 of the Act of 1941 provides for the suspension of an officer of a local authority by that local authority. In the very few words inscribed in Section 18, we are taking from the local authority the power of suspension of any of its employees who in the opinion of that local authority may have failed to have carried out his duties. We are now in the position that, despite all we have said up to this, under this section the only person who can now suspend an official of a local authority is the Minister. We are doing that by the deletion from Section 27 of the words "such local authority" where they occur. We should make sure that the local authority have some function in a very important matter of this kind. It could pass the notice of the House, because of the simple wording of Section 18, that there was not so much entailed in it in so far as the relations between the council and the employees are concerned.
Comment on this
Under the amendment of Section 27 of the Local Government Act of 1941, contained in this section, local authorities will no longer suspend officers under Section 27 but in accordance with regulations under paragraph (m) of Section 14 of this particular Bill. The powers of the appropriate Minister to suspend officers under Section 27 of the 1941 Act are not affected at all by the proposed amendment. The Senator will appreciate that at least three Ministers are concerned in these matters and the powers which I now ask will not affect in any way the powers given under Section 27 of the 1941 Act. I suggest to the House that the section is a reasonable one and I would ask the House to accept it.
Comment on this
We are considering a Bill that is expected to give to the local authorities additional powers, yet in a section of this kind, a very short section, we are taking from them one of the very important functions of any employer, that is, the authority to suspend one of their employees if, in their opinion, there is good and sufficient reason for it. Section 27 is quite definite: "Whenever in respect of the holder of an office under a local authority there is, in the opinion of such local authority or of the appropriate Minister.——" Section 18 proposes to delete the words "such local authority", that is, no longer will the local authority have a say in a suspension, no matter for what cause, of any of their employees. We are now giving the complete power to the Minister to do so.
Comment on this
If the Senator reads paragraph (m) of Section 14 he will see it says as follows:—
"Providing for the imposition by local authorities on holders of suspensions from performance of duties (including short term disciplinary suspensions, not exceeding seven days), the non-payment of remuneration during the continuance of the suspensions and, upon the termination thereof, the forfeiture (in whole or in part), payment or disposal otherwise of remuneration which would, but for the suspensions, have been paid during the periods thereof."
One can imagine the case of a man under suspension, who clears out of the country. There is certain remuneration due to him and this gives a method of disposal of it—I think a very reasonable and efficient method of disposal. We are not in any way affecting Section 27 of the 1941 Act.
The Senator has said to me that I propose to give back to local authorities more power than they have. I do, but not under this Bill. This Bill, I am advised, was instituted and drafted by the Minister preceding me, a Minister of the Senator's Party. It is not my Bill; I have to try to justify it. It was his Bill and I suggest I have amended it as best I can, but this particular amendment is not one of the amendments. I have had more criticism of the original Bill from the Senator's Party than from anyone else. However, I have amended the Bill as best I could and I now present it to the House. I am surprised the Senator did not have an opportunity of discussing it on another occasion.
This Bill, I am informed, was originally intended for the purpose of codification of the local government law. Merely for that purpose it was originally introduced, but if the Senator would compare the Bill as it now stands and as it was when originally introduced, he will appreciate the amount of good that I have done by the amendments which I have brought into it and which have been welcomed by all sides in the House below.
Comment on this
There is very little use in the Minister coming along and saying: "This is my predecessor's Bill".
Comment on this
Well, "was my predecessor's Bill, but, of course, I have amended it as best I can since then and it is now a much more worthy document that I present to you", when he is presented with a question. The question I asked was why are we making this provision in Section 18, which seems a very simple section and which one would be inclined to pass over without giving it any examination, because it simply says that Section 27 of the 1941 Act is hereby amended by the deletion of the words "local authority"? The Minister, in place of explaining to the House what these words mean, goes back to refer to Section 14. We have spent the greater part of this day going from Section 12 to Section 17 and being referred back from one section to another. When that has failed to convince us or when there is no convincing argument in the reference to other sections of the Bill, we are referred to a Bill which is not before the House at all. I hold that in this section we are taking from the local authority power that they now have, of suspending an employee of theirs for any just cause and, of course, for reinstatement likewise when they consider that such reinstatement should be done—by the deletion in this particular section of the words "such local authority" where the words may occur in Section 27 of the 1941 Act.
Comment on this
Might I refer again, to clarify the position, to Section 27 of the Local Government Act which provides, inter alia, that the appropriate Minister or the local authority can suspend an officer but only the appropriate Minister may reinstate him? Is that quite clear—that only the Minister may reinstate him? Under this sub-section (m) the method of reinstatement will be governed by regulations to be made by the Minister. We are not cutting across or taking away from any local authority a power which they had got: we are merely providing for the making of regulations governing reinstatement or otherwise. As the law stands at the moment, the local authority or the Minister may suspend but only the Minister may reinstate. We are leaving that as it stands, but (m) will give the Minister power to reinstate by a method of regulation. The regulation will govern general cases. Of course, if there are individual cases they will be dealt with in the ordinary way under the section in the 1941 Act.
Comment on this
The Minister has been referring back continually to Section 14 and paragraph (m) but the point at issue with me at the moment is that I hold that if we pass this section to-night we are taking from the local authority a function they have now, that is, the right to suspend any employee of theirs for any just cause.
Comment on this
The representatives of the local authority. It should have been a reserved function. I do not wish to be traversing up and down from Sections 7 to 14 continuously; my only desire is to elicit from the Minister a simple answer to a simple question. If I am not putting it clearly enough or if the Minister does not understand, I would like to be so informed. The question I am asking the Minister to answer is, is it not a fact that we are removing from the local authority under Section 18 of this Bill the powers that they have of suspending an official, an employee of theirs?
Comment on this
We are definitely removing it from one section—but we are putting it into another. That is quite clear. I have explained to the Senator and the House that it is for the purpose of codification that this Bill has been introduced. We are taking it out of one section but we are putting it into another, and the regulations which will be made will give the local authority any power which they have to-day. I am giving that assurance to the House.
Comment on this
If that is the case what use is there in our going from one section to another and from one Bill to another Bill? If what the Minister says is so, what is the need for Section 18 of this Bill?
Comment on this
For the purpose of depriving the local authorities of the powers which they now have.
Comment on this
I am now giving the House my word that I am not depriving them of any powers which they have. Any powers which are taken from them by this section will be given to them by another section.
Comment on this
I am completely against legislation by reference. I am absolutely against it, and I am surprised that it has been permitted in this House all down through the years. So far as I am concerned, I shall never introduce legislation by reference, but I am advised that it is essential in this case for the purposes of codification. I am advised of that, as my predecessor was advised of it, and we both accepted the legal advice that was tendered to us that this was necessary for the purposes of codification. I shall never initiate legislation by reference.
Comment on this
The Minister will find, as long as he is there, that he will accept advice.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
Before paragraph (i) to insert the following:—
(i) "With the consent of the local authorities concerned such consent being a reserved function" shall be inserted before "by Order fix".
What is meant by a reserved function is that it is to be a function of the representatives of the local authorities. What is proposed in Section 19 is the amendment of Section 29 of the Act of 1941. Section 29 of that Act provided:—
"The appropriate Minister may by Order fix the amount and nature of the remuneration of holders of specified major offices and such Order shall have the force of law in accordance with its terms in relation to such offices and holders thereof and, if and in so far as it conflicts with any regulation made under this part of this Act, shall override such regulation."
We are amending that section by extending it to other groups of employees of local authorities. In doing so, we are overlooking entirely the local authorities. What I am asking the Minister is that, in matters of this kind, the representatives of the local authorities should be consulted. They are the representatives of the people and will have to shoulder the responsibility of providing the money to pay the staffs that are referred to in this Bill. I think there is no justification for giving further powers to the Minister to deal with matters of this kind without any reference whatever to the representatives of the local authorities.
Comment on this
The Senator is right in pointing out that, as the law stands at present, in the case of major offices the appropriate Minister has the power to fix the remuneration without any reference whatever to a local authority. That is the law as it stands. I do not agree with it, and as a result I am amending it under the County Management Bill, but under the County Management Bill local authorities will have the power to veto increases in remuneration for permanent officials.
But here we are dealing with the case where new offices have been created. Take, for example, that it was necessary to appoint a civil defence officer to deal with atomic weapons. That would be a new office to be created, and the Minister would have the right to fix the remuneration for it. He has the right to do that at the moment for individual major offices but, instead of doing it for individual local authorities, we want to be able to fix a standard that will govern the whole country for these particular offices. The Minister can make an Order fixing the remuneration for the entire country for these particular offices. If I were to accept the Senator's amendment, the mere refusal to give its consent by one local authority to the fixing of that remuneration would have the effect of nullifying the entire section as well as the regulation made by me fixing such remuneration for the rest of the country. The intention of the section is to cover new offices so that there will be a standard remuneration fixed for the entire country for any new offices which may be created.
Comment on this
The fixing of the remuneration will be by the Minister, but the creation of the office will be a different matter.
Comment on this
The Minister is doing this without any consultation with the elected representatives?
Comment on this
Yes, under a completely different Bill. This merely amends the law as it stands. The Senator will appreciate, when we come to deal with the other Bill, that I am taking my hand out of the purse of the local authorities as much as I possibly can, and that I am proposing to allow them to distribute their own funds in whatever way they wish, but this deals with the fixing of a remuneration for new offices for the entire country. There has to be a general scale and someone must fix it. I say that the Minister should fix it for the entire country so as not to have different scales applying in different areas. This will make things simpler for everyone. The acceptance of the amendment would cut across the purpose of the entire section and would nullify it.
Comment on this
This section may make things easier from the point of view of the Minister, but not from the point of view of the ratepayers or of the people responsible for paying the remuneration to the holders of these major offices. As far as I can ascertain, those occupying major offices are county managers, county secretaries, county engineers and county medical officers of health. There is a tremendous number of such officials all over the country. If the remuneration of all these officials is to be standardised by the Minister without taking notice of the fact that the rates in some counties are very much higher than in others, that the standard of living in certain counties is higher than it is in others because the people are living on better land, and that road workers and agricultural labourers are paid a much less wage in some counties than in others, then it seems to me unfair that the Minister should standardise the remuneration. It would be unfair if he were to decide that the county manager in a small county should have the same remuneration as the county manager in a very large county where the responsibilities are so much greater.
We know, of course, that the City Manager in Dublin has a much bigger salary than the ordinary county manager because of the fact that you must attract a very good man for such a position. He carries tremendous responsibility. I understand that the cost of administration in Dublin runs to between £8,000,000 and £9,000,000 a year. It seems to me that if the Minister is going to standardise these salaries for the whole country there will be the incentive for principal officials in the larger counties to seek positions in the smaller counties because their responsibilities will be so much lighter in the small counties.
Comment on this
This is a section which will be very rarely used, just as the section in the old Act was very rarely used. As a matter of fact, I know of only one case in which it was used and used, in my opinion, wrongly. It was a case in which a dispensary was advertised and there was a local boycott. The Minister for Health stepped in, and, without consulting the local authority and against their wishes, fixed a very high salary for that dispensary area for the purpose of breaking the boycott. There was no outcry then from the Opposition Benches about the Minister stepping in and fixing this unprecedented salary for a dispensary doctor.
Senators know just as well as I know that in the smaller counties there was swopping and changing around. A medical officer was merely a bird of passage, waiting to get out of a particular county and into a better county. This will merely apply in the case of new posts such as that which I mentioned a few moments ago which may be created. The Minister at present has power to fix a salary for individuals and I am merely asking power here to fix a salary in general for any new post which may be created. I think it is not unreasonable. I can assure the House that, so far as I am concerned, it will be used very rarely indeed and I hope the Minister for Health will never have occasion to use it in the disgraceful manner in which the old section was used in the past.
Comment on this
The Minister has been more clear in presenting this section than he has been in presenting any of the other sections we have come to so far, so we are making some little progress. I join with Senator Walsh in the case he has put to the Minister. but there is another side to this question—that the Minister may fix a standard scale of salary to be accepted by all the local authorities throughout the country, which scale, for many of the local authorities, may be rather high. We had cases in the past in which the fixing of remuneration by the Minister or by the Department led to posts not being filled for a considerable time, because, in the view of the organisations catering for the particular group, such as engineers or doctors, the salaries were not attractive enough. Whether it is a matter of the salary fixed being too high or too low, as might be held by these organisations, I think the people to decide this question of remuneration are the people who are the employers and who are faced with the task of imposing the burden on the people of making the money available.
The Minister has given an assurance that the section will be used only in relation to new appointments. I do not know exactly what he has in mind. We have as many categories of appointments as we possibly can have at the moment, and, unless the Minister has in mind the creation of some other new office, the section would not be required at all.
I was somewhat surprised by the Minister's reference to a dispute in a particular dispensary district. Many years ago, in 1925, when a very important body was set up by the authority of the then Parliament—the Local Appointments Commission, to which we will probably be referring later on—that body was not accepted very freely throughout the country. The old system was there, but many of us who saw that it was necessary to have such a body, if the young people were to have a fair chance of securing the employment to which their ability entitled them, supported the decisions made by that body at the time. We supported these decisions against much opposition which came mainly from the very people who implemented the legislation setting up that authority.
A similar position to that which arose in County Leitrim—we might as well be frank now that the Minister has referred to it—arose in my own county of Galway. I was very closely associated with it at the time, a fact of which I have always been very proud, because the very authority of the Local Appointments Commission was challenged at that time. Had the opposition to the appointment made by that body succeeded, there would have been no further Local Appointments Commission appointments in this country. On both occasions, the same steps were taken—the Minister took steps to ensure that the person appointed on the advice of the Local Appointments Commission, as being the best possible person for the post, was enabled to take up the position by making up for the loss of any private practice of which he might be deprived because of the opposition to his coming there. The Minister for Local Government, in maintaining that authority and ensuring that persons appointed by it would find it possible to take up the positions, was quite justified and deserved full credit from the House and from all who stand for decency and honesty in public life. The Minister was ill-advised to refer to the matter this evening.
Comment on this
I did not take exception at all to the appointment made. What I did take exception to was the increased salary given to a dispensary doctor, without affording the other applicants an opportunity of applying for that dispensary. Here we have a dispensary offered at a salary of £300. A number of eminent men will not apply for it because the salary is merely £300, but, when an individual is appointed, his salary is doubled. Is that fair to the other competitors for the position? I am not finding fault with the method of appointment, but I am finding fault with the step of increasing the salary and the time at which it was increased.
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that the office of dispensary doctor is a major office under the section?
Comment on this
That is not the interpretation of it that I have.
Comment on this
We have much more respect for them than that, Senator, although I notice that you have not in Donegal.
Comment on this
Why then does the Minister not fix the remuneration of the Donegal dispensary doctor?
Comment on this
We will leave that to yourselves. It was the predecessor of the Minister for Health who did it, but you repudiated it and refused to implement his decision. You were unaware of the fact that it was the predecessor of the Minister for Health who had fixed it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that a local authority should have no control over the remuneration paid by it?
Comment on this
I am making no such suggestion; I am merely stating facts. It was the predecessor of the Minister for Health who fixed it and you refused to implement it—particularly the Fianna Fáil section of the council.
Comment on this
There is a situation in Cork City which is affected by this fixing of salaries in the Department. We in Cork have agreed to pay an engineer x pounds—I forget how much —but the Department will not agree to it. The result is that, for two years, we have had no engineer—just a temporary person from week to week. Can the Minister tell me why that is so? We are agreeable to pay the salary suggested by the engineers' association.
Comment on this
Many people think the Minister is getting away from this section so I might as well join with them. I think now is the proper time for the Minister to answer that question because we in Cork are very tired of waiting for a decision.
Comment on this
We would like a decision before we leave the corporation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
In sub-section (3), line 51, to add after the word "section" the words "but every such direction shall be given by Order under his seal".
This is a very small amendment. Every direction should be issued in a formal way, and that is why I suggest that "every such direction shall be given by Order under his seal".
Comment on this
I can assure the House that no direction is given in a very light way by the Department. For any direction given the Minister is responsible. I think that amendment would not achieve the end which the Senator desires. The fact that the direction is given by Order under seal does not of itself mean anything. I can assure the House that no such direction would be given without consulting the appropriate Minister, who may be the Minister for Health, or the Minister for Social Welfare.
Comment on this
Section 20 provides that:—
"(1) the power of a local authority under Section 10 of the Act of 1941 to assign remuneration to an officer shall not be exercised except in accordance with such one or more of the following as may be appropriate from time to time:—..."
Section 10 of the 1941 Act, which this Section 20 amends, provides that:—
"(a) every local authority may appoint such officers and employ such servants as are necessary for the performance of the functions for the time being of such local authority;
(b) every officer appointed or servant employed by a local authority shall perform such duties and be paid such remuneration as such local authority may from time to time assign to him."
I want to draw the attention of the House to the fact that in Section 10 of the 1941 Act a provision is made for the local authority to employ the staffs essential for the good performance of its work and to pay them remuneration in accordance with the work. Now we come to Section 20 of the Bill, which provides:—
"(1) the power of a local authority under Section 10 of the Act of 1941 to assign remuneration to an officer shall not be exercised except in accordance with such one or more of the following as may be appropriate from time to time:—..."
Therefore we take from the local authority under this section the powers that they had under Section 10 of the 1941 Act. The power
"shall not be exercised except in accordance with such one or more of the following as may be appropriate from time to time:—
(a) any Order made by the appropriate Minister under Section 29 of the Act of 1941,
(b) any regulation made by the appropriate Minister under paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the Act of 1941.
(c) any direction given by the appropriate Minister regarding the considerations that should govern levels of remuneration of officers generally,
(d) any direction given by the appropriate Minister regarding the considerations that should govern levels of remuneration of officers of a specified class, description or grade, the officer being in that class, description or grade,
(e) the sanction of the appropriate Minister."
In every case we are passing on to the Minister the authority to fix remuneration for all employees of local authorities, and depriving them of the powers they have under Section 10 of the 1941 Act. I think that, having regard to the fact that the Bill put before us is making better provision for giving to local authorities powers which they have not had for some time, we should oppose this section.
Comment on this
The only new principle introduced under this section is that the appropriate Minister can dispense local authorities from the necessity of seeking sanction to increases. Supposing that the Minister says particular remuneration shall be between £7 and £10 per week, you need not seek the Minister's sanction so long as you keep within the scale laid down. It is not necessary to send it back for sanction. For instance, the Minister makes a regulation that a particular tradesman's rate of pay will not exceed such and such a sum. So long as it does not exceed the trade union rates, there is no necessity to come back to the Minister. I think that is a reasonable thing, and I think it is going to save the local authority all this trouble of sending it back to the Minister for sanction. It is giving back to them a certain amount of discretion. It is going to make for a better method, and it is going to save time, correspondence and a lot of unpleasantness. Local authorities know well in advance the limit to which they may go in fixing the rate of remuneration. They also know the minimum. There is no necessity to seek the Minister's sanction so long as they fix the particular remuneration within that scale.
Comment on this
The whole principle involved under this section is that we are taking from the local authority the power that they now exercise in fixing the remuneration. What about an officer of a local authority who is aggrieved?
Comment on this
Provision is made that where an officer of a local authority is aggrieved he may apply to the Minister to have his grievance righted. Might I refer the Deputy to the section which has been repealed. not the one that the Deputy read out? It is Section 42 of the 1946 Act. Perhaps I mistook the Senator. Perhaps he did say the 1946 Act. My predecessors have for a good many years been issuing directions on the very same lines as I propose issuing directions under this section, without any legal authority at all. There will be no further directions. There will be regulations made which will be laid before both Houses, and which every Deputy and Senator will know. In fact, some of the documents which went out by way of directions will not be secret documents. I am going to regularise and legalise the practice which had existed down through the years. I am taking nothing away from the local authority. I am giving them something. They need not come to me for sanctioning the remuneration of some of their tradesmen or local employees.
Comment on this
If this Bill is passed and the County Management Bill is passed subsequently, which of the two will the local authority take direction from?
Comment on this
We have been referring to the County Management Bill.
Comment on this
There would be no difficulty whatsoever. A little pamphlet will be issued for nothing which will explain the position.
Comment on this
A provision is made under this Bill empowering the Minister to make regulations and sign Orders. I cannot understand why, when a member of the House asks for an explanation of a particular section, the Minister should devote so much time to a criticism of the actions of the Department in the past, the officials of local authorities, and the past actions of Ministers in regard to these matters, when powers were conferred on them by this or the other House.
Comment on this
If we propose to request every local authority to employ an attorney-general to examine every Order and direction sent to them to ascertain whether it is made in accordance with the authority given to the Minister by both Houses of the Oireachtas, we would probably overcome the difficulty.
Comment on this
There is a Committee of this House which devotes a lot of time to this matter. We have knowledge of all these things happening in the past and at the present time. If the other members of this House were members of this Committee they would soon realise that, while there may have been an excuse during the emergency years for legislating by regulations and Orders, the Orders have not lessened in any way in recent years. It is quite understandable that a Minister and his Department would be anxious to legislate by regulations and Orders rather than go before each House of the Oireachtas. However, I want to get back to Section 20.
Section 20 takes from the local authority the power they had of fixing the remuneration of their staffs. It hands over that power to the Minister. The Minister, sitting in his office in Dublin, is going to decide by regulations sent to local authorities. We understand from previous statements made by the Minister that his idea of the proper approach to these matters would be to fix a standard rate for the various classes of employees and tell the local authorities that as long as they paid this rate of remuneration they need not ask for sanction. If for one reason or another, having regard to the circumstances of the county, they suggested that any change should be made they could not do so because the Minister is taking the powers they had from them by Section 10 of this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not object to the Senator misquoting fact, but I do object to him misquoting law. I would refer the Senator to Section 42 of the Local Government Act, 1946, and I would advise him to listen. It says:—
"In this section, the word ‘employment' shall be construed as including, in addition to the employment of a servant of a local authority, an office other than a major office."
These are the conditions:—
"A local authority shall not—
(a) pay remuneration in respect of an employment held by any person immediately before the 26th day of August, 1942, unless they pay the remuneration either at a rate not greater than the rate at which they paid remuneration in respect of the employment immediately before that date or at a higher rate for the time being sanctioned by the appropriate Minister."
There are four sub-sections each one of which ends with the same five words "sanctioned by the appropriate Minister".
Comment on this
Was the local authority in 1946 taken as being the city manager or the county manager?
Comment on this
Senator Hawkins thinks that we are taking from the local authority something they never had. When the Senator purports to quote law, I hope he will quote it correctly. I do not mind him misquoting facts but I do object to his misquoting of the law.
Comment on this
I would expect, when the Minister replies, he would reply as the political head in charge of the Bill. I did quote the law correctly. I would refer the Minister to the section under consideration. The section under consideration is Section 20 of the 1955 Local Government Bill. There is no reference in the whole of Section 20 to the Act of 1946. Therefore, it does not propose to amend or extend.
Comment on this
Would the Senator look at the Second Schedule to the Bill? There is no use misquoting law. The Deputy will see that the Schedule repeals the section.
Comment on this
I want to make an observation on Section 23. The section, as I read it, seeks to improve the position of the servants of the local authorities in the matter of superannuation. It seeks to extend their period of service. I think that is desirable. I would like if the Minister would look into this section with a view to seeing if it would be possible to do a little more for those people. I am not referring to those higher officers of the local authorities. I am referring to the people who are classed as established servants of the local authority. Under the Superannuation Act, 1948, those people were given, on the passing of the Act, a period of six months within which to have their names entered on the register of established servants. A large number of them availed of that power.
Comment on this
I only raised the matter as the Superannuation Act is referred to in the section but if there is legislation coming I will wait.
Comment on this
I would like to welcome the Minister's assurance. Could he give us any idea as to how soon such a Superannuation Bill will be forthcoming?
Comment on this
Could we have an assurance that it is likely to come before us before the summer recess?
Comment on this
I introduced this present Bill in October and I have only got this far with it yet. The County Management Bill is before the Dáil and the Dáil has only reached half of the amendments although the Bill has been before the House since the end of January or the beginning of February. The Senator will appreciate that it is very difficult to give a date. I can assure the Senator that the Superannuation Bill will be introduced at the earliest possible moment. I will even go further and say that I will ask permission from Dáil Éireann to introduce the Bill before the summer recess.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:—
To add a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) Where as the result of a declaration by the appropriate Minister under Section 23 of the Act of 1941 the age limit for any particular office is less than 70 years the appropriate Minister may on the recommendation of the appropriate local authority extend the age limit to an age not exceeding 70 years.
As a member of a number of local authorities, I have been rather perturbed of late by the amount of money we have to provide for officials who retire at the age of 65.
One of the subsidiary bodies of the Clonmel Corporation is the gas company, and that body is tending to become insolvent by the number of pensioners which it has to leave off at the age of 65. That has become a great burden on the finances of that industry. In all European countries there has been a considerable increase in the expectancy of life. A commission sat recently in Britain, I cannot remember the name of it, but it made very definite recommendations that people over the retiring age should be encouraged to remain on in productive service for many years longer than they are allowed to do here. This trend will develop in this country, as it has done in neighbouring countries, and I believe that the day is not far distant when it will be felt in all the institutions of the State and in some other institutions such as commerce, banking, etc.
I know it is difficult for the officials of the Department and people who are engaged in service of that sort to suggest an increase in the retiring age to the Minister, but it is well that, from time to time, some people should be prepared to bring these matters to the attention of the powers that be. I want to ask the Minister to consider the question of allowing the local authorities to encourage officials to remain on in their service until the age of 70 if the local authority finds that the officer can give useful service.
There is another matter which it would be right to consider in this connection. That is that our marriage rate is far later than it is in many European countries. Owing to that fact many people are compelled to retire at the age of 65 when their burdens are greatest. In many cases grave hardship is inflicted on these people by being asked to retire at that age. Many competent and able officials will probably be asked to retire if the Minister does not try to do what I ask. I would ask him to have the Department of Local Government see what is the effect of this early retiring age on urban councils, corporations and other local authorities throughout the country and to see its effect on the finances and rates of all the towns and cities in Ireland. I would ask the Minister also to remember that whether they have to retire or not, their cost must still be borne by the community and, as time goes on, their numbers will increase until the burden will become such that it will be impossible to meet it.
Comment on this
The Senator has rightly referred to the late marriage rate, but in God's name what will happen if we put this amendment into the Bill? Surely we shall encourage an earlier marriage rate by retiring these old gentlemen when they reach the age of 65 and giving promotion to the younger men? There certainly is a late marriage rate in the country and I am afraid that one of the reasons for that late marriage rate is the fact that we keep these men on. I think we would be assisting in keeping the marriage age up by putting in this amendment.
There is another aspect of the matter. The age of 65 is the one which applies throughout the entire service and the amendment would give more favourable treatment to some individuals than to others. There would be a stultifying and blocking of promotion to juniors in the various services if these officers were allowed to remain until they are compelled, by physical debility, to retire.
Comment on this
My amendment simply asks the appropriate Minister, with the agreement of the appropriate local authority, to extend the age limit.
Comment on this
All my reading of late has borne in on me the increased burden that will have to be met by the State due to the number of pensioners and I think it is time that some people should say these things. Facts are facts and they have to be approached whether we like it or not. The expectancy of life to-day is very much greater than it was 30 or 40 years ago. Recently it was assessed in Britain at 79 years for women and 72 for men. The same tendency will arise here and sooner or later that matter will have to be faced up to.
Comment on this
I would be very sorry to see this amendment withdrawn. I agree with what Senator Burke has said. I do not agree that the general retirement age is 65, and I know that the State refuses to give old age pensions under the age of 70. In Britain they have a retiring age of 65, but they give the old age pension at the age of 65. We do not. We have an interim period of five years. I would suggest that officers of local authorities who have shown their worth, and who are still entirely competent to continue working between the ages of 65 and 70, should be allowed to continue to do so with the consent of the Minister. I would suggest that this is a praiseworthy amendment and I should like to see it go through.
Comment on this
Acceptance of the amendment would be a complete change of policy. The amendment covers more Departments and Ministries than that of Local Government. I think the suggestion made by Senator Stanford earlier would be a much more effective one. If we wish to amend the policy, let a motion be put down and let the whole matter be discussed.
Comment on this
I wonder is the retiring age of 65 as general as has been stated? I understand that some senior members of the judiciary are allowed to go on beyond 65, and I know that there are quite a number of professorships occupied by men of up to 70 and beyond.
Comment on this
This is a double-headed weapon and I understand it operates in the Army to some extent. There is a great deal of discontent among the younger officers.
Comment on this
It would be wrong for the Department of Local Government to set a headline in this matter, which is one which concerns all the branches of the service.
Comment on this
I understand that it is not necessary for a dispensary doctor to retire until the age of 70.
Comment on this
They must retire at 65. The Senator will appreciate that that is a matter for another Minister. I am not in a position definitely to say. The Minister for Health deals with that and I cannot say whether he has made an age limit Order or not. I know it was the law that they had to retire at a certain age.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware there are dispensary doctors over 75 at the moment?
Comment on this
It may be, but they may be only part time. I am not aware of any doctor in office over 75 but I am not in a position to deny that. This is a debatable point but could not be debated on an amendment to a section like this.
Comment on this
In conclusion, my idea in putting down the amendment was to give more power to the local authority. I think this is a very important thing in the life of any community. History would suggest that many of the people who have given the greatest contribution to civilisation have certainly been over 65. Drawing an arbitrary line is very difficult and the suggestion in my amendment was to allow a local authority, when they had an official of very much above average competence, to employ him for the public good for a longer period and that the Minister could give sanction to their wishes if he wanted to do so. The course of the last two wars would probably have been different but for the employment of two men over 70—one a statesman and the other a general. I would hate to think that a principle was brought in here that was unchangeable, that even when talent was available it could not be employed because the man was over 70 years of age.
The Minister has suggested to us to take the course of putting down a motion to discuss this at a later date when we would be supplied with more facts and figures and arguments in favour of the case. I hope that the Minister would opt to be the Minister who would come here and sit to listen and reply to this debate if he will afford us this opportunity.
Comment on this
May I protest against the suggestion that it would be impossible for the Department of Local Government to take a lead?
Comment on this
Undesirable, then. I suggest with respect that it would be eminently desirable that some Ministers should be prepared to take a lead, and show the way to better things to their colleagues.
Comment on this
This matter is wider than the section referred to by Senator Burke. Take the mass of unskilled workers who are not even adequately provided for at 65. I agree with the Minister that it is a bigger and wider problem than can be debated here on an amendment to a Bill of this kind— and I think it should not be discussed on terms of money altogether.
Comment on this
In the final analysis, did not some Labour leader say that prosperity was indivisible? I know that in the local gasworks we had to retire several men. I would hate to think that we had to retire so many men that maybe people now working there would have their employment put in jeopardy because we had to retire those men. With the increasing of the age we could arrive at such a position. It has been suggested we should discuss this in a fuller way here on some motion that would afford everyone an opportunity of putting the case for and against. I believe there will be a time in the near future when we will have to change the policy on this matter.
Comment on this
Someone said a long time ago that consistency was the impossibility of genius. We should not take it that everything has to be as it is at the moment and not as we would like to have it.
Comment on this
On this question of putting a motion on the general principle before we make any change, there is the obvious objection that we would never get the motion accepted. As soon as it is proposed as a general principle, someone will say he agrees with it in nine cases out of ten, but that as he is being asked to accept the principle for ten out of ten he cannot vote for it although he has an immense amount of sympathy for the motion. In this particular case, we can accept the principle.
Comment on this
The average span of life is three score and ten. Let us put them into retirement for some years before they pass on.
Comment on this
My interpretation of the wording of paragraph (a) is that it will be mandatory on a local authority after a period of three months to ask the commissioners to recommend a person for appointment to office. I can visualise cases where the appointee may be ill or have met with a serious accident or be otherwise incapacitated. Also, there may be an agreement between two local authorities where the person to be appointed was at the time a member of one local authority and was being appointed by the commissioners to another local authority and where the first one desired he should remain to the end of the financial year. That may occur in the case of a vocational teacher or some such person. It would be much more desirable not to have it mandatory, to leave it discretionary on the part of the local authority to request the commissioners to make that appointment. If the Minister is prepared to accept that amendment, I would ask him to consider changing the three months to two months, that the local authority could ask the person to take up the appointment within two months, but in that case he need not take it up within that time if the local authority is agreeable.
Comment on this
In the Senator's Second Reading speech on the Bill I understood him to say that he held that the section should be permissive. Is that right? The section is permissive, it is optional; but I sincerely hope that local authorities will not construe it in that way. I hope they will make it mandatory in many cases. May I give the example of Arranmore Island, which has not had a permanent dispensary doctor for the past ten years? Every doctor refrains from going in for a period of 12 months until he gets an appointment elsewhere, with the result that they have no permanently resident doctor there for a good many years. I hope this section will amend that position. To satisfy Senator Walsh, I may say that the section is permissive.
Comment on this
Is the Minister suggesting that the word "shall" is permissive rather than the word "may".
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the question of dispensary doctors on Arranmore Island. The Minister is aware that a doctor has been acting there for the past 18 months in a temporary capacity. Possible, there was no application made to the Appointments Commissioners for the appointment of a full-time man.
Comment on this
If the Minister is satisfied that it is permissive, then I am satisfied.
Comment on this
I would draw the Senator's attention to sub-section (1) of Section 27, which provides:—
"Section 6 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the addition of the following sub-sections:—
‘(5) Sub-section (4) of this section shall have effect subject to the proviso that where the local authority specify a period (not less than three months) within which the person who is recommended by the commissioners or who is thought proper by the local authority to be appointed (as the case may be) is to take up duty and notify him of the period so specified, the local authority shall not appoint him unless he takes up duty within that period.' "
That is permissive so far as the local authority is concerned.
Comment on this
I take it that the direction is given before the appointment is made. The Appointments Commissioners request the appointee to take up the position within three months of appointment because of the fact that the local authority has requested them to do so, and the local authority decides the question prior to the appointment being made.
Comment on this
Once a person is notified that he has been appointed to a position it is mandatory on that person to take up the position within three months. Otherwise the local authority may request the Appointments Commissioners to make a further appointment.
Comment on this
Yes. The Senator wants me to compel the local authority. I am leaving it optional with the local authority and in that way I am giving them a bit of power. The Senator will not have that.
Comment on this
I say that the word "may" would give the local authority permission, but not the word "shall". Take, for example, the case of a county engineer. He is asked to take up an appointment within three months. The local authority of the county in which he is serving may wish him to remain until the end of the year. The other local authority may be willing to agree to that, but once he has been appointed to the other county the local authority there would have no option but to see that he took up the appointment with them.
Comment on this
I would refer the Senator to sub-section (4) of Section 6 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, which provides:—
"On receiving from the commissioners their recommendation under this section, the local authority shall appoint to the said office the person recommended by the commissioners or, where more than one person is so recommended such one of the persons so recommended as they shall think proper."
The operative word there is "shall". There is no option and they shall make the appointment. What we are doing here is we are giving the local authority some little discretion in the matter.
Comment on this
I would direct the attention of the House to paragraph (b) of Section 27 of this Bill which provides:—
"if the local authority does not, within three months after the expiration of the said period, request the commissioners to recommend to them a person for appointment to the office, the Minister may on behalf of the local authority request the commissioners to recommend to the local authority a person for appointment to the office,".
Therefore, I submit that if a person does not take up an appointment within three months, the Minister is being empowered to make a request to the Appointments Commissioners on behalf of the local authority where it failed to make the request itself. The question arises, who is to give the necessary information to the Minister that some dispensary doctor or engineer has not taken up the position to which he was appointed? Where a local authority does not exercise this power, then the Minister can step in.
Comment on this
May I point out that paragraph (b) of Section 27 of this Bill is taken word for word from sub-section (2) of Section 6 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926? Sub-section (3) of Section 6 of that Act provides:—
"On receiving such request as aforesaid from the local authority or the Minister (as the case may be) the commissioners shall select in accordance with this Act and recommend to the local authority one person for appointment to the said office or shall, if they so think proper, select in accordance with this Act and recommend to the local authority two or more persons for such appointment."
The Senator has asked, who will notify the Minister? We shall follow precedent. I do not know who has been notifying him during all the years but we shall follow precedent.
Comment on this
We are dealing here with a position that, in many cases, has been created by the fact that a person appointed to a position was not, for one reason or another, prepared to take it up. I have known a dispensary district in my own county where the complaint has been that a doctor was prepared to take an appointment for a short period, as a stepping-off ground for some better appointment. That is one of the things that is going to flow from the activities of the Appointments Commissioners. If the local authority had the responsibility of appointing doctors to Arranmore and Inishbofin Islands, it is probable that they would remain there for the remainder of their lives. Under this Bill, if a doctor is appointed to Ballydehob dispensary and is expected to take up duty not later than, say, 26th November, and if he does not arrive on that date, who is going to notify the Minister? Is the Minister then going to make application to the Appointments Commissioners?
Comment on this
If the local authority is not anxious to do it, is it then only that the Minister steps in?
Comment on this
But now we are trying to rectify a position that has arisen because of people not having taken up positions to which they were appointed.