We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Local Government Bill, 1954—Committee Stage.

Contributions 218–440 of 440. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill, 1954
Enacted

No. 14 of 1954 ›

I oppose this section, not that I am in any way against the principle which I think the Minister has in mind, namely, to obviate the necessity for calling people over and over again to an interview in connection with these local posts. While it is desirable to bring about an amendment of the law in that regard, we must make sure at the same time that, in doing so, we do not open the gate to abuses, and to hardships as well. One thing which struck me was that, in spite of the fact that the section can be regarded as a revolutionary one, we have got very little explanation of it so far, and I should like the Minister, when dealing with the points I am making, to give us a full statement as to how, in his view, this section will operate, because so far as I see there can be many pitfalls.

For instance, there is a reference in the following section to panels, with which we will deal later on, but anybody looking at the marginal note to Section 29 will rub his eyes, because that marginal note reads: "Dispensing with competitive examination". Before we dispense with these competitive examinations, we must make sure that we will not find ourselves in a more dangerous position than we were in before. For instance, what kind of panels are we going to have? How long will these panels be in existence? If somebody whose name is on the panel is called to fill a post and does not find it convenient to do so, because the post may not suit him, what will his position be afterwards? We have so many things to consider that I should like to get a statement from the Minister as to how he thinks the section will operate.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There is very little revolutionary in the section. First of all, I might explain that the competitive examination means a written examination. As the law stands at the moment in all appointments made by the Local Appointments Commissioners the first thing they do is to request the Minister to dispense with written examinations, and all appointments are made on an oral interview but the commissioners must seek the concurrence of the Minister in each and every case. It has never yet been known to have been refused. We want to wipe out this procedure whereby the commissioners must go to the Minister every time they wish to make an appointment, and seek concurrence in wiping out the competitive examination, in other words, the written examination. It is merely to do something, to legalise something in general which has been done in individual cases in the past. I am only dealing with Section 29 and the amendment opposing the section. That is all this does: it expedites appointments, it saves all this correspondence between the Minister and the commission which has been gone into in each individual case. I would like the House to determine the meaning of written competition or rather competitive examination when they are considering the section. Competitive examination means written examination when you accept the fact that down through the years each successive Minister has concurred in the wiping out of the written competition. This is merely to make a general rule of it. There will be no necessity for it in the future. In other words, in future, appointments will be made on the qualifications, plus the oral interview. There is nothing revolutionary in it.

Comment on this

I would refer the Minister to the explanatory memorandum. It refers to Section 9 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926. When the Local Appointments Commissioners obtain the Minister's consent to the selection of a person for appointment to office, otherwise than by competitive examination which is taken to mean a written examination, in practice all selections are made by interview board, so that in reality there is no use at all in talking about written examinations. We are discussing interviews and nothing else, because in practice, even according to the explanatory memorandum it is a qualification which is taken to mean, and must be taken to mean, just an interview. The difficulty then is that if these interviews are dispensed with——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There is no intention to dispense with interviews, absolutely none.

Comment on this

That puts a different complexion on it.

Comment on this

This, I take it, is to cover mainly cases of appointments where, say, academic qualifications would be stipulated, as for instance, a veterinary surgeon. He would have to be qualified. A medical officer would have to have his diploma from the proper authority, and it is obvious there would be no need to hold an examination in the ordinary sense of the word for such persons as these. I expect that is the type of person covered by this.

Comment on this

It has been the procedure that such people were not expected to undergo the ordinary written examinations.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

And the Minister concurred in the dispensing with the written examination.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister whether it is the intention on the whole to dispense with this competitive examination in the case of university graduates? There is quite a number of appointments in the Civil Service where for university graduates a degree is stipulated as a qualification. So far I think such candidates must undergo a written examination. Is it the intention to dispense with that examination in regard to appointments? I quite understand that the Minister is in a difficulty because this has to do with local appointments.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Would the Senator look at the first of the lines of the section which is explanatory?

Comment on this

I use the case of people going for the Civil Service. There are certain positions in local authorities where there might be a position for a——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

A medical officer.

Comment on this

Not medical officers. Their diplomas are of a different kind. There may be town clerkships, and so on, where certain qualifications are said to be essential; for instance a leaving certificate or university degree from a professional examining body, where it is the intention of the local authority to dispense with written examinations in the case of these people, taking the thing by and large.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It will be left to the commissioners who will have the option. They will know.

Comment on this

I want to find out whether it is the intention to dispense with that.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

In practice I understand that will be the intention.

Comment on this

I understood that the intention behind the section was to put an end to that system by which candidates were called over and over again for interview, even candidates living across the Channel.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is Section 29 with which we are dealing, not Section 30. Section 30 is the section to which you are referring.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

In sub-section (2) to delete all words after "arrange" in line 19 down to and including "persons" in line 22 and substitute the following words "for the setting up of panels of persons whose qualifications are known to the commissioners by reason of their having been already up for interview."

In view of the statement which we have got from the Minister I find myself in a difficult position as regards this amendment which I have put down because the Minister has now told us that he has no intention whatever to interfere with the interview system.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I have no intention.

Comment on this

If that is so, what has the Minister in mind at all, because I understood that the intention was to establish a position by which people would be called for interview, and their record taken down for future reference, so that they need not be called again; in other words, that their names would be classified on the proper panel.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is correct.

Comment on this

If my interpretation of it is correct, I want to make sure, by putting forward this amendment, that nobody will ever be put on a panel unless he has been before the Appointments Commission.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They will not be put on a panel unless they have been before the Appointments Commission.

Comment on this

I did not quite understand from the section itself that that point was safeguarded.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is only by means of the interview that they will get on the panel at all.

Comment on this

I am not very happy about this section. In regard to this panel, take the case of the secretary of a county council who happens to die suddenly in any particular county. The accountant in that particular county would, naturally, be competent to deal with the duties of the secretary. He will be familiar with the county and with the circumstances obtaining in it on account of his association with the secretary throughout the years. It could happen that a secretary would be appointed from the panel, whereas the accountant, even if he applied for the position, would have no chance of getting it. The same thing could happen in regard to a dispensary doctor.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It could happen to-day as the law stands.

Comment on this

If a dispensary doctor died in a very good dispensary area you would have several other doctors in the county who would naturally like to be promoted.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We are not doing away with the powers of transfer.

Comment on this

On the very point raised by Senator Ruane, it is quite possible that a person whose name would be first on the panel would be called upon later on to fill a certain post which would not suit him at all.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

He need not take it.

Comment on this

He need not take it. I am afraid his position would be more or less prejudiced. What would be his position at all?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

His position would not be prejudiced in the least.

Comment on this

Would his name be still left on the panel?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

And at the head of the list?

Comment on this

Will there be a new interview?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

No, not necessarily.

Comment on this

We would want to be very careful in regard to this matter. We are enacting a section that was never before in any Local Government Act. Before enacting it, we would want to see fairly clearly for ourselves how the section is going to operate. If I am an applicant for a certain post through the Local Appointments Commissioners and I fail to get it, somebody else gets it. My name is put on the panel first because of the marks I secured. If at a later date another post of the same kind becomes vacant in a different part of the country and I do not want to go for it and I am called upon by the Appointments Commissioners to take that post and I do not take it, will my name be still on the panel in the same position as it was before?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Yes. As far as I know there is no reason why the commissioners should change.

Comment on this

Might I put it to the Minister that the position is rather different in this country for various reasons? Some of the best brains in this country have to leave it. Many of them often want to get back to Ireland. Tragically enough, they never get back. In regard to this panel let us suppose the commissioners decide to hold a commission to select men in regard to the appointment of a district medical officer of health. A panel of a dozen names, say, is drawn up. I understand that as subsequent vacancies arise in dispensary districts the commissioners would then take the name from the panel and appoint the person so named forthwith. Does not that mean that the service is not necessarily getting the best man available for each appointment at the time? Does it not mean from the point of view of the professional and technical man concerned that a man may be available for appointment who may be vastly superior to the man promoted from the panel, but because an interview is not being held he is not able to get the post?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Might I explain the position? There has been a considerable amount of criticism about the delay in regard to vacancies. We all know the amount of time and money that is spent by people appearing before the Local Appointments Commissioners. Some of them appear nine or ten times before the commissioners and they pay a fee each time. They travel at considerable expense and a considerable amount of time is wasted on the filling of the appointment. The theory at the back of the section is that when a vacancy occurs applications are invited for it. There may be a dozen applicants for one position. They are placed in order of merit on a panel. The commissioners, first of all, may make regulations with the consent of the appropriate Minister governing the period which the panel may last. It may last six months, 12 months, or two years. Personally, I think that six months would be a reasonable period. If a vacancy occurs within the six months period, then those in the order of priority on the panel will be offered positions if they apply for them. Once the period in which the panel will be in existence expires, then a new panel will be set up. That will save time and money and in my opinion it will save a considerable amount of criticism.

With regard to the question of a vacancy for dispensary doctors, you may have 20 or 30 applicants. Not only do they apply for that dispensary but for five or six others, at the same time paying substantial fees on each occasion. If those men knew that the one interview would do, say, for the next 12 vacancies they would be much more satisfied and content.

Comment on this

What about all the young men who would come along in the next six months?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

When a vacancy occurs in Arklow, say, for a dispensary doctor, not only will people apply for the Arklow vacancy but also for the other vacancies which may occur in the six months. That will bring into the field for the position advertised originally people who would not dream of applying.

With regard to the point raised by Senator Ruane, there will be nothing in this section to prevent an accountant applying for a county secretaryship. As a matter of fact he will be in the glorious position that if he wants the secretaryship of his own county he need not wait for a vacancy to occur at all. He can apply for the next vacancy, get his name on the panel, and wait for the period when he can fill a vacancy in his turn.

Somebody raised the question of a doctor in a dispensary district being debarred from transferring to another dispensary district. He is not debarred. Provided he is in a dispensary for a period of not less than one year the local authority has power to transfer a doctor to another district. The section will not interfere with that in any way.

In this section we have merely endeavoured to satisfy a certain amount of criticism we have got both in this House, in the Dáil and all over the country about the delay in filling appointments through the Local Appointments Commission. We are trying to expedite these appointments. That is the only reason we have had for this section.

Comment on this

Will the Minister be able to indicate how long the panel is to be effective?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The commissioners will make regulations all of which will be subject to the sanction of the Minister. You will often have at least three Ministers concerned, that is Health, Social Welfare and Local Government. It will be, I presume, a matter for each Minister to decide in conjunction with the Local Appointments Commission how long a particular panel would last. I think myself that in certain cases like medical officers the period should be six months. Where you have the appointment of a county manager it might be a very good idea to let the panel run for two years. We appoint county managers in this country only once every couple of years. But we might have a number of appointments where six months ought to be long enough. That would be a matter for regulations made by the commissioners with the sanction of the Minister.

Comment on this

We ought to be clear. If a panel is to last only for six months or even for 12 months it will tend to become a perfect nuisance, whereas if it is to exist for two years obviously you are going to run into the danger of depriving a good man of a chance of getting the position.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Am I not correct in saying that the Local Appointments Commissioners, like the Civil Service Commissioners, have power to make regulations governing their procedure for filling these posts? If they get this extra power under this section there is nothing to prevent them from advertising every post and having a panel as well. They need not necessarily appoint people from the panel.

Regarding the people about whom Senator ffrench-O'Carroll spoke, a new man may apply and the commissioners may look at their panel and say: "There is a better man on the panel." They may put him on the panel in some other position, not necessarily giving him a job. If an outstanding person applies better than anybody on the panel I understand that there is nothing in this section to prevent the Local Appointments Commission from appointing him.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is correct.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Might I advert to another point? The Senator says that people with brains leave this country and never get back. I think that is not so. During the first ten years of this State I was chairman of the Civil Service Commission and my experience was that a great many people came back. I have seen on the paper over and over again where Dr. Patrick O'Connor in Middlesex was appointed to a dispensary somewhere or other. You often see where doctors with Irish names and Irish degrees with English addresses have come back. So far as this system is concerned I have heard the criticism over and over again that people are deprived of the opportunity of applying and coming up for interview. This would enable the commissioners to add to their present scheme, whatever it may be, the method of having a panel for a period limited as they might in their own experience think fit. I think that would be an improvement from the point of view of the applicants.

Comment on this

Do I understand Professor Hayes to say that the commissioners will advertise the post?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

They could.

Comment on this

That is the point. The position is that they do not have to advertise the posts. That is the whole point in the section.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I wanted the opinion of the House and I do not appear to have got an amendment on it other than the amendment in the name of Senator Kissane.

Comment on this

Does Professor Hayes not agree with me, and he has a lot more experience than I have, that, in fact, a lot of the best brains are lost to this country in professional and technical life? However, that is something we need not go into now. Whatever we may say about getting jobs or not getting them in this country, the Appointments Commission, with all its defects, is the best thing we have. There is no doubt about it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is true.

Comment on this

Particularly when so many of our really good people are outside this country we should have one thing definite—that there should be a public advertisement for every post.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

So there will.

Comment on this

With new applicants entitled to be registered?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I may tell you I have been approached by a number of Senator ffrench-O'Carroll's profession who have requested this section. This panel system is not a new one. We have had it in the Civil Service. It has worked admirably. We have it in the E.S.B. and in C.I.E. We have never yet heard any complaint about it. I have been approached many times by engineers and by doctors who tell me that in trying to get back to this country they have applied to the Local Appointments Commissioners six, seven, eight or nine times. They have had to pay their travelling expenses, say, from Middlesex or Aberdeen, in order to appear before the Local Appointments Commissioners. Finally they say that they will never get an appointment and they stop away and we lose them. A particular job might not induce them to come back, but if you put a man's name on the panel once in six months or two years you are helping. We have been requested by a lot of absentee medical men. Sometimes they tell me that they do not hear of vacancies.

Comment on this

They do not.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

If their name are on the panel a vacancy will be brought to their notice. They may be offered a position if they have priority on the panel. A number of our young engineers go abroad and are most anxious to come back here. The same thing applies to them. They would be very glad to have their names on a panel as a safeguard.

Comment on this

Vacancies occur frequently not only for medical people but for, say, storekeepers and so on. If you create a panel and appoint from that panel, as I understand it from the Minister, for the next six months or two years, when vacancies happen in the meantime, a point arises which I think nobody has made yet. If the vacancy is in Galway, a number of people will deservedly apply for that vacancy and the panel is created. Supposing that in six months' time you have a vacancy in Cork, what I am anxious to know is will that vacancy be filled from the panel of people who applied for Galway?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Yes, or it may not.

Comment on this

That is exactly the trouble, to my mind.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

If there is a new applicant better than those on the panel——

Comment on this

How are you going to know that he is better?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The commissioners will decide.

Comment on this

I say that in justice the vacancy in Cork must be advertised again. Unless there is something put into this section to compel the commissioners to advertise every vacancy they will retain the panel. If you do that you are doing an injustice to the applicants and enabling a favoured few to get on the panel.

Comment on this

Were there not injustices before the panel was created? I remember some time ago in the South when doctors were appointed to various positions very serious complaints were made. The public have to be considered as well as the applicants for the posts.

Comment on this

I take it that when the Appointments Commissioners make an appointment they have to take into consideration the question of suitability—suitability for rural administration in the case of a person with no rural experience, who has been brought up with a city or urban bias. In the case that Senator Ruane has mentioned, of an accountant who acts temporarily as a county secretary, he may not be interested in any other county but that where the secretary has died; and as he is acting in a temporary capacity, he may prove suitable. If the section is passed as it is, the next person on the panel would be appointed, to the exclusion of the person interested in that particular county.

Comment on this

Could I make a final appeal to the Minister to reconsider this? I suggest that a lot of dissatisfaction occurs in this country over appointments because they are made without being advertised. In all professions there are appointments made, so to speak, behind closed doors, where there is no public advertisement, and there is a great deal of resentment about it. The Minister says, very rightly, that a lot of professional and technical men protest that they have gone before the Appointments Commissioners and have gone to a lot of expense and so on, and have not got an appointment. That is perfectly natural, but let the Minister contrast that with what the position would be under the panel, if the panel lasts for two years. Men outside this country who are well qualified and have suitable experience may be waiting an opportunity to get back and every time an appointment is made they may be told: "That is one from the panel". After a couple of years, is that something which is right—"that is one from the panel"? He would hear that again and again.

There is one point that has been overlooked. The Minister seems to think the panel would be of great advantage to us. I do not think so, because professional men have to work all the time to earn their living like everyone else and if a doctor, an engineer or an architect applies for a post and does not get it and goes on the panel I am quite sure that in at least 50 per cent. of the cases of the names of the men who remain on the panel, when they are offered posts that subsequently become available they will be otherwise employed and, as they are otherwise employed, they will in a number of cases not be prepared to change the appointment. It may be an offer of appointment in a town that does not suit them or they may have got a better appointment abroad. I cannot see how a panel is going to be a tremendous advantage. It is quite wrong to assume that if you interview a dozen people and take one and put the other 11 on the panel you are going to have even seven or eight available for other appointments as they arise in the next six or 12 months. I ask the Minister again to stick to the best form of appointment that we have in this country, that is, a public advertisement and open competition for every post that is available.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

With regard to the point raised by Senator O'Sullivan, in setting up the panel it is not the intention to set up a panel for occasional vacancies such as he mentions. In thinking over this section and drafting it, what we thought of was dispensary doctors and assistant engineers. Those were the two we really thought of. As it stands at the moment, one could practically say that what is occurring is a panel system. Every time there is a vacancy for an engineer, there are generally six or seven vacancies on the same day and all the applicants apply for all the vacancies at the same time in the hope of getting one or other of them.

Comment on this

But they know what they are applying for.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They do, definitely. I am anxious to meet Senators on this. I have an open mind on most of these things, but I have been pressed so much by professional people to bring in this section that unfortunately I cannot accept the amendment. However, I would be prepared to consult with the Appointments Commissioners and put before them the various suggestions which have been made here by the House—I must say most constructive suggestions indeed—and see if I can bring in any amendment on Report. Bear in mind, however, that I am not thinking of county surgeons. I am merely thinking of the dispensary doctor who wants to get into a dispensary and does not care where it is as long as he can do his year there and wait for a transfer. I am thinking of unfortunate men who are spending a considerable amount of money in travelling expenses and fees and I am also thinking of the assistant engineer. Those are the only two classes. I have not thought of county managers, to be honest, but of two classes particularly.

Comment on this

Why not mention those two?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is what it might be possible to arrange between now and Report, if the Senators would be satisfied with that.

Comment on this

Or otherwise advertise every position.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is the position at the moment—advertising every position.

Comment on this

Yes, but you would have the panel at the same time.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Would the Senator be in favour of retaining the panel for other positions than those two, dispensary doctors and assistant engineers?

Comment on this

And advertise those positions also and get more new people on the panel.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

If the House would be agreeable that I should take the matter up between now and Report with the commissioners, I should be pleased to do so.

Comment on this

I appreciate what the Minister has said. I would like to bring to notice another class I am particularly interested in as a member of a county committee of agriculture. We appoint poultry instructresses and instructors in agriculture. While awaiting appointment it is necessary to make a temporary appointment and that means that the person seeking the position has in many cases to make a canvass of the entire county. I am making the case perhaps in favour of the panel for these particular cases.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The panel would help very much there.

Comment on this

It would help, as they would be involved in a considerable amount of expense in securing that temporary appointment; whereas if they could get on the panel after qualifying, they would avoid that.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is the reason why I introduced the section.

Comment on this

People who have not been able to make a successful canvass would be out of employment for some years.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being withdrawn?

Comment on this

Yes, in view of the Minister's statement that he is going to look into the question again.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

To add at the end of sub-section (3) "together with an additional fine, not exceeding £5 for each day on which the offence is continued."

As the road may be closed for more than one day, for two or three days, and as it would be an offence to obstruct or interfere with anything on it, I would ask the Minister to consider making it a continuing offence—as in the next section, Section 36, where it is a continuing offence and there is a fine not exceeding £5 with an additional £1 for each day on which the offence is continued. As the section stands, when the offence has been committed no further fines can be imposed, even if it extends over a period of days.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

In the law as it stands at the moment there is no question of a continuing offence at all. Secondary roads are closed now by Section 29 of the Local Government Act of 1925. It contains no provision whatsoever in regard to an offence or penalties. The sub-section has been introduced primarily to deal with people who interfere with the holding of a road race. The events such as we envisage do not last more than a day. I think the House is aware of cases where we had an intervention. The obstruction, in the case of events such as these, does not last longer than a day. In view of that, I do not think we should go to the trouble of making the offence a continuing offence.

Comment on this

This only applies to the holding of road races?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Or to bowling down in the County Cork.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister could not stop that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think he could take power to stop what is causing a great deal of anxiety in rural Ireland—that is the conduct of people who camp on our public highways?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Not under the section.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the local authority may, according to the section, grant permission for such period and subject to such condition as they think fit. Therefore, the local authority could close a road for several days.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Under Section 29 of the Local Government Act.

Comment on this

Under the 1925 Act they are permitted to do that.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

You may have motor races lasting for two or three days. I think that would be the maximum period.

Comment on this

You may have trials being held before the races. These may go on for some days, as I think that they used to, in preparation for the Grand Prix in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

On the section, I would suggest that traffic signs should be included for pedestrian crossings. I am just wondering whether extra legislation would be required. Traffic signs might also be included for railway crossings.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

These may be covered.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

To delete sub-section (1).

Section 40 of this Bill proposes to amend Section 52 of the Act of 1946 which gave power to a local authority to execute works in relation to the erection of bridges. It is now proposed to extend that power, notwithstanding the fact that that will constitute interference with certain rights, including the right of navigation. Despite the fact that it does that, the local authority will be entitled to proceed with the erection of bridges.

I am of opinion that, in this matter, the local authorities and the Department have sufficient powers under Section 52 of the 1946 Act, and that it would be a retrograde step to give the power asked for in this section. I think it would be wrong for Parliament to pass a section in a Bill which would give authority or power to any local authority or to any Department of State which would enable either to disregard the rights of navigation which have been there for our people for generations.

Comment on this

The other amendments to this section in the names of Senator McHugh and Senator Stanford may be discussed with the amendment which has just been moved.

Comment on this

If Senator Hawkins' amendment is accepted, I think that our subsequent amendments would fall. I think it would be better if Senator Hawkins' amendment were taken first. Amendment No. 17 provides for the acceptance of the general principle of keeping open our navigable highways. If amendment No. 17 is accepted, there will be no need to move amendment No. 18.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

What the Cathaoirleach has suggested is that the three amendments be discussed together. I think Senator McHugh's point refers to decisions that may be made. Naturally, if Senator Hawkins' amendment is carried, amendments Nos. 17 and 18 will not arise. If his amendment were defeated, amendment No. 17 would be put, and if amendment No. 17 were carried it would cover amendment No. 18 and if defeated, amendment No. 18 would survive and could still be put.

Comment on this

I have suggested that the three amendments might be discussed together.

Comment on this

I said on an earlier stage of the Bill what I have in mind in regard to this section. The amendments standing in my name and in the name of Senator Stanford rest on the principle of keeping open our public navigable highways. As I made the case for that before, I do not propose to do so again, except to indicate that the principle for which it contends is already acknowledged to some extent by the Bill in exempting the River Shannon. Barge traffic of various kinds already operates and is a feature of continental waterways.

If, in the future we wish to develop our own navigable highways for the transport of various commodities, it would be well to have the power to carry on that transport by barges on our public water ways. Suppose, for example, the new oil refinery were to be located at Foynes. I do not know, of course, where it will be located, but Foynes in many respects might be an admirable location for it. In that event, the refined product could be sent up the Shannon and its various tributaries to different parts of Ireland without the necessity of having it transported by road. I think the case made by the Inland Waterways Association, which has circularised Senators on this particular Section of the Bill, reveals the importance of the case for keeping our inland waterways open.

Comment on this

I would like to support the two amendments which have been spoken to. I would prefer to see Senator Hawkins' amendment passed. There may be legislative difficulties in connection with it, in view of the fact that it is a rather sweeping amendment and may have repercussions of which we are not aware at the moment. The Minister will inform us on that.

The reason I support the two amendments referred to is that I cannot see why, when the case is given away for the Shannon, it should not be given also for the great rivers, for example, of the South East—the Blackwater, the Suir, the Barrow and the Slaney. If we seal up the entrances to these rivers we may damage transport, we may damage fishing and we may damage tourist traffic. It is quite possible that people in the future may want to use our inland waterways for travel as a pleasant way of seeing the country. I think that, if we were to spend a great deal of money on sealing up a natural asset, it would be most regrettable. I can see that it will be more expensive to put in opening bridges—they will need machinery and they will need a man or men to look after them—but I am perfectly certain that it would be a retrograde step to seal up the mouths of these great rivers as can be done under the Bill as it stands.

I should like to quote one fact from the strong case made by the Inland Waterways Association: As recently as January 1st, 1953, the Board of Roads and Waterways in Sweden obtained State grants for the building of about 150 opening bridges over the various waterways there. The Swedes are a very sensible, a very practical and a very shrewd people, and we would be greatly mistaken if we ignored that policy and took this retrograde step. I hope that at least one of these amendments will be adopted and I would regret personally if it is simply the Blackwater which is saved. I have a great affection for the Suir and the Barrow and it would be a very sad thing if navigation, fishing and tourist traffic were interfered, with on those rivers.

Comment on this

I should like to ask how arterial drainage will affect the rivers of which Senators McHugh and Stanford have spoken. Maybe some of the difficulties they envisage could be got over by prescribing suitable heights for the bridges spanning these rivers. I think that high level bridges are in many cases much more convenient than opening bridges. I understand that it is a difficult technical problem to construct opening bridges. They always require maintenance and certainly require personnel to operate them. When they are open, they impede the flow of traffic and are inclined to cause congestion, not alone on the bridges but on the waterways themselves.

One of the matters which has been the subject of much discussion is the bridge at Youghal. I hope that bridge will be sufficiently high over the Blackwater to allow traffic up as far as Cappoquin and to enable tourist motor boats or pleasure vessels of that sort to ply on that river again, as they did in the past. The same applies to the other rivers he mentioned, the Slaney, the Suir and the Barrow and, in fact, to all the navigable waters in this country. Some safeguard should be inserted in the Bill to ensure that if in the future it becomes desirable or profitable to exploit these rivers in one way or another, we will not be precluded from doing so by the bridges erected over them.

Comment on this

There are very few members in the House or, I may say, of the general public, who will not have heard of what has become known as the famous Youghal bridge, and as one more intimately associated with Youghal than anybody in this House and as one who realises the serious position which has arisen in the commercial life of Youghal for the past 15 or 16 years, I would make an appeal to the Minister to give us a swivel bridge. The old bridge which has been in existence since 1877 has an opening to permit ships—schooners, as we call them down there—to ply up the river as far as Coolbagh, Cooneen and Killahala. In reading the debate in the Dáil, I noticed that, if the proposed bridge is erected at Ardsallagh—I sincerely hope it will not be, because I always advocated in the Dáil, and want to advocate here now, that it be erected as near as possible to the original site—the Minister indicated that it was to be a fixed bridge, with a clearance of 21 feet over high water mark.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Maximum high water mark.

Comment on this

I have made inquiries and I find that, in the past year or so, from 12 to 15 vessels went up to Killahala Quay, 12 or 14 miles from Youghal. No later than last Sundayweek, I made it my business to go there for the reason that I heard that a vesssel, the De Wadden, a two-masted schooner, which comes to Youghal with coal every few months, had arrived there. I saw her loading a very big cargo of pit props. I judged the height of her masts—any man born in a seaport town will have a very good idea of the height of masts— to be in the region of 30 to 35 feet, and my worry is that if the Minister proceeds with his decision to have a fixed bridge, all navigable traffic on the Blackwater will be finished forever.

We have been waiting long enough. People may say that we can blame ourselves for that, for the reason that we could not come to a unanimous verdict, but nobody wants to make political capital out of this. It has been tried, I know, but as one whose interests are centred in Youghal, and I hope they will be centred in Youghal for the rest of my life, I want to make a special appeal to the Minister to give us what is known as a swivel bridge. The De Wadden, the Happy Harry and various other schooners of similar size going up there represent a big trade which means something in harbour dues to us in Youghal. My fear is that we will kill a trade that has developed considerably over the past 30 or 40 years in pit props to destinations across-Channel.

I have been requested by my own people, and particularly by the fishermen of my town, to make this appeal. The upper reaches of the Blackwater, extending from Youghal bridge to Ardsallagh House, are a very prolific salmon fishing ground and the fishermen, any more than ourselves, do not want to see that taken away, and if the proposed bridge is put there—I hope, as I say, it will not be erected there—it will ruin a very fine fishing ground which has a reputation for salmon fishing for the past 50 or 60 years.

I would ask the Minister to give the amendment proposed by Senators McHugh and Stanford in relation to the Blackwater every consideration, because it is a serious matter for a town which has suffered considerably because of this infamous bridge, if I may put it that way. If the Minister forces it, as a loyal Party member, I must support him, but against my better judgment and against my conscience. However, being a Party man I must support him if it goes to a division, but it is with very great regret that I will have to do so.

Comment on this

I should like to support what has been said in favour of the amendments. I think that the section, while well-intentioned, is a dangerous one, and I feel that we should look very carefully at any section which suggests a wiping out of rights. It is quite obvious that individuals in certain circumstances have to sacrifice their rights in the public interest, but we should proceed very carefully before passing a section which says that such and such a bridge can be erected "notwithstanding that it constitutes or will constitute an interference with any rights".

In sub-section (5) there is the question of compensation. I should like the Minister to explain what compensation might be claimed under the head of loss of a right of navigation. The sub-section says that compensation will be paid for, and so on, but it does not say how it will be calculated. There is a reference in sub-section (6) to compensation payable by a road authority, presumably for loss of land. How do you calculate what compensation is necessary and will be paid for the loss of a right of navigation? That is just one of the few points I would like to make.

There is another point: whether legislation of this kind is really good law. I notice in the Schedule that of the 1946 Act four sections are repealed, 33, 36, 39 and 42. I also notice that in Section 54 of the Local Government Act, 1946, which is not repealed, there is a sub-section which gives the right to an owner of land to apply to a District Court to stop a local authority from having entry to his land. Sub-section (4) of Section 54 of the original Act says that the Justice may, if he shall think it is proper, either wholly prohibit entry or specify conditions, and so on. Furthermore, sub-section (5) of that same section lays down that where a Justice prohibits under this section the proposed entry on land it shall not be lawful for any person to enter under this section on the land. If this section is to remain in operation, and we are not asked to repeal it, and if under the new section the building of bridges could be carried out notwithstanding, it seems to me that in law we have a contradiction, an unrepealed section which gives the District Justice the right to prevent entry into a man's land. I am not quite clear how you can build a bridge without having got the right of entry. If the Justice prohibited such an entry, I fail to see, even with the passing of this section, with all its words, "not withstanding that it constitutes... an interference with any right," how this section can in fact repeal by these words, Section 54, which in the Schedule we are not asked to repeal. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister that this section is not even good law.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

One would think that in this section I am introducing for the first time legislation to enable local authorities build bridges over navigable waters. I am doing no such thing. I am merely clarifying the position of my predecessor. Under Section 60 of the Local Government Act of 1946 a local authority cannot build a bridge over navigable waters unless it does so with the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce or under the authority of a bridge Order. Under that section the local authority if they wish to build a bridge over a navigable waterway have two methods whereby they may do it:—

"(1) With the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce who is the Minister responsible for looking after navigable waters;

(2) by means of a bridge Order."

We are only dealing with a bridge Order under this section. Supposing we want a bridge Order. Under Section 48, the Minister for Local Government cannot give a bridge Order unless he holds a local inquiry, or else gets the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. If the local authority want a bridge, there must be a local inquiry or the consent of the Minister responsible, namely, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, must be obtained. Therefore, rights of navigation are fully protected and provided for under the procedure laid down in the 1948 Act. But there has been a difference in the legal opinion tendered by some eminent lawyers as to the right even under Section 48 of the Local Government Bill to make a bridge Order for a navigable waterway, for a permanent structure. It is to clarify that doubt that I have brought in this section. I am merely endeavouring to clarify what my predecessor endeavoured to do in 1946. A full inquiry will be held before a bridge Order may be made, and that was the intention of the 1946 Act. As I say, there is a difference of opinion about the legal interpretation of it. We would imagine that I propose building barriers across the mouth of navigable waterways to prevent ships going up and hindering navigation. That is the last thing I would do. I know too much about navigation to prevent or rather to endeavour to legislate for this hindrance or obstruction. I do not wish here to enter into a controversy over the famous Youghal bridge. Just to show you what our intentions are, if the bridge is to be built as a fixed bridge at Ardshallagh, we propose leaving a clearance of 21 feet when the tide is at its maximum and a clearance of 40 feet when the tide is at its minimum. Now with steppable masts —and after all most boats for inland navigation such as the boats mentioned by Senator O'Gorman have got steppable masts—there is no difficulty whatever in boats going up the river. They will not be obstructed in any way. As a matter of fact a member of Dáil Eireann told me that he once waited in a comparatively small boat at Youghal for three weeks for sufficient water to get to Cappoquin. If he had to wait for three weeks a clearance of 21 feet at maximum tide will bring up any boat with up-to-date steppable masts. I do not think we need trouble much about that. With regard to the question of the fishery I cannot see how it enters into it at all.

Senator Skeffington raised the question of compensation, and how it will be determined. Sub-section (1) of Section 40 sets out the machinery by which it will be determined. It is the same as the machinery as set up for determining compensation to be paid when land is acquired. Section 54 of the 1946 Act deals with the entry of lands for the purpose of taking a survey. The Senator might refer to that. If the local authority want land for a bridge such as this, they can acquire it compulsorily under the Local Government Act of 1898. The section to which the Senator referred deals only with entry on land for survey purposes. When it comes to the acquisition of land, he can go back to the Act of 1898. I want to assure the House that I would be the very last person to obstruct the navigable rivers of this country. It is true that we could not give a sufficient clearance at Athlone. We made an exception just to show that we were bona fide in this. We are satisfied that in regard to the other navigable rivers in the country, we can give sufficient clearance for boats equipped with steppable masts which are the most up-to-date boats of the present day.

Comment on this

Is it not the usual practice to adapt the boats to the traffic coming through the ports, rather than try to adapt the ships to the ports through which they pass?

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that one of the ships which is trading at the moment on the Blackwater and carrying over 200 tons of cargo per month has a bridge superstructure of 21 feet? It will be a hard scrape for it to get through. That ship will want to go up the river at high tide.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It can only go up once a fortnight.

Comment on this

In some cases larger cargoes than 200 tons are carried. The matter is one worth considering. Is the Minister aware that some of the ships on the Blackwater which go up to Cappoquin have masts up to 60 feet above water level? I do not think it fair to tell those people that they must take down their masts and put in a different kind. They have been on this river for over 100 years. I agree with Senator Skeffington when he stressed the fact that we should be on our guard when a section uses a phrase like "notwithstanding that it constitutes or will constitute an interference with any right". I think this is one of those sections in regard to which we must be particularly on our guard. I do not wish to imply that the Minister himself has any evil intention.

Let me say that I am not interested in the Minister's intentions at the moment. I want to make sure that this section is just and safe. The Minister in the process of time may not be Minister. The 70 years' span of life applies to all of us but this Act may last for 50 years or 100 years. The Minister's intentions are irrelevant. We are interested in the law and in legislation and we must have legislation as good as we can, otherwise we are not doing our duty. I insist that to ask these fishermen and traders on the river to lower their masts or superstructure is unjust. I hope the Minister will yield on this section. I think it would be greatly appreciated throughout the country.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Senator McHugh raised the point that we should build our ships to suit our harbours and not our harbours to suit our ships. I understand that, prior to the building of Butt Bridge and O'Connell Bridge, ships came up as far as Guinness's wharf. They still come up. They have adapted themselves to those bridges. There is no doubt that they are able to come up. Admittedly, the ships that came up there, outmoded vessels with 60-foot masts, could no longer go up. I doubt if they could go under some of the bridges in some of the larger ports of this country.

Senator Stanford referred to the navigable rights we are taking away from certain fishermen but it is a most peculiar thing that, when a public inquiry was held in Youghal, the only evidence tendered in opposition to a fixed bridge was that of the people of Youghal who said their town would be ruined. The fishermen had an opportunity of appearing. The owners of these ships had an opportunity of appearing. Not one of them appeared, despite the fact that the inquiry was held in public and a considerable amount of publicity given to it in the Press. Not one of these gentlemen was represented at the inquiry. The only evidence offered there and the only objection to the building of a fixed bridge at Ardsallagh was that the town of Youghal would be ruined.

As a result, Youghal stirred up a bit of a hornet's nest so far as the local authority there was concerned. We must remember that Cork County Council were unanimous in deciding that this bridge should be built at Ardsallagh. The Cork County Council are the people who are mainly concerned and they were backed up by the other local authority principally concerned, namely, Waterford County Council. They were in agreement on the appointment of a consultant to advise them as to which type of bridge was the better. The consultant advised them and they accepted his advice. When all that was done and when certain Deputies and Senators saw that Youghal might suffer, according to them, they suddenly thought of this brilliant idea of bringing in the unfortunate fishermen.

Too often, the unfortunate fishermen of this country have become a cat's-paw in matters such as this. I interviewed the fishermen. There is no class of people for whom I have greater regard. I should not like to see their livelihood go. I am satisfied that there are no more watchful people or people more careful of their rights than fishermen. They were there. Most of the fishermen concerned were at the inquiry listening. They raised no objection and they saw nothing being done to interfere with their rights until some person came along and said: "This is your opportunity to kick up a row. You will be helping the town of Youghal if you do".

The same thing applies to the merchants of Cappoquin who chartered these vessels. Some of them reside in Youghal. They never complained that navigation would be obstructed by the building of a bridge. We never heard of that until there was a change of Government and until a decision was about to be arrived at. My predecessor had definitely decided as to the decision he would take. They were inveigled into this on the side of Youghal. I am satisfied from the conversations I had that the only objection to the building of a bridge was that the people of Youghal thought they would suffer financially by having the bridge built further away from the town than the existing bridge. That is all that there is to the whole matter. I would ask the proposers of these amendments to withdraw them in the interests of the people of Waterford and Cork and let us get on with the job of building the bridge.

Comment on this

I would like to assure the Minister and the House in putting down my amendment I did not intend to take a ramble to Youghal by road or river.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We have cruised down that river too often.

Comment on this

The purpose of my amendment was to preserve for the people a right they have. We have a number of navigable rivers in the country and under this sub-section we are giving power to the bridge authorities, notwithstanding any interference with any right, including right of navigation, to proceed with a bridge. The Minister refers us to Section 48 of the 1946 Act, and he has already put before us the procedure that was adopted in the case of Youghal. That has no relation at all to my mind to the general principle of the application of this sub-section, because we are doing something more than has been provided under Section 48. There is provision made under Section 48 for an inquiry to be held. You must get a certificate from the Minister for Industry and Commerce and so on. What this House is now asked to pass is a section of a Bill, and I would like to say that it does not matter very much, when this matter comes to be considered by the Department or the bridge authority or a court of law, what the Minister's views here were. It is not the views expressed or recorded in the records of this or the other House which will be taken into consideration. It is the facts that are in the Bill which will then be an Act if passed, and the facts are that we are taking away a right and giving power to the bridge authority to erect a bridge whether it interferes with the right of navigation or not.

We have quite recently passed a Tourist Bill to develop our tourist industry. Apart from the commercial aspects of interference by the erection of permanent bridges over our rivers I would like to preserve for our people the amenities these rivers may provide in the future. I do not agree with the Minister that we should just erect bridges and say to the ship owners or people who would be prepared to put boats of one type or another on these rivers that they must have such a ship or boat as the bridge will take. We have here to-night given our approval to the right of the bridge authority to do these things. It is too serious a step to ask this House to take. While the Minister has expressed sympathy with the amendment I would ask him for an assurance that between this and the Report Stage he will try to bring in some amendments to this section that will remove the fears we have expressed. If he does this he will serve a good purpose.

Comment on this

There is just one point that I would like to take up. The Minister gave me the impression, and gave it perhaps also to others, that this amendment had something to do with the change of Government.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I did not intend to give that impression.

Comment on this

As the Minister knows we speak for the ordinary citizens on the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I accept that.

Comment on this

The ordinary people and the Inland Waterways Association of Ireland are not primarily interested in Party politics. It is a matter of national politics. It is certainly on that level that I am supporting the amendment. Personally I would disagree with Senator Hawkins when he suggested that if we get a very firm assurance from the Minister we should withdraw the amendment now. I think it should be pressed now, and I hope that the Minister will be in an accommodating spirit about it. I feel that it is a matter of national importance and that he will do good for the country by accepting this amendment.

Comment on this

I was, of course, very interested in this discussion, being a member of Cork County Council for more than 30 years. Having listened to the talk about Youghal bridge, I beg to ask the Minister to have some consideration for the people who travel between the Counties of Cork and Waterford. What is happening to them all these years?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I am in full agreement with the Senator.

Comment on this

We have heard all about these navigable rivers and about tourists. The road between Cork and Waterford has been held up for many years and it is about time that a bridge was built. I cannot understand how the people of Youghal could suffer because this bridge is going to be five-eighths of a mile up the river.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I would not be a party to having the navigation of our rivers interfered with in any way from the national point of view, but I cannot see anything happening in this case. I am anxious, and we are all anxious in Cork, that this question should be dealt with once and for all and that the work should begin.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I cannot deal with it until I get the section.

Comment on this

A lot has been said about navigation and navigation rights. I wonder are other rights being considered? Reference was made to the value of navigation rights. There are authorities and rights that are really obsolete. It could easily happen that a lot of these rights now being fought over with a great deal of ardour could become obsolete in a very short time. What puts that into my mind is a thing that I am sure some members of the House are quite conversant with. The Cathaoirleach, if he was in a position to speak, could say a lot about it.

I know of a case where a navigation work was executed less than 100 years ago. It cost Her Majesty Queen Victoria's Exchequer several hundred thousand pounds, and a special Act was passed through the British House of Commons making provision for it. What happened? I do not know whether I am a good historian, but at least one boat got as high as summit level of that navigation work, and since then it is in complete disrepair. Still you have an authority which is transborder, appointed by Leitrim County Council and Fermanagh County Council and others. They elect a body which does not in fact exist. It may be a bit out of order, and it may not, but I quoted it to show what may happen because these things have happened. You have authorities existing in the country which are nobody's baby. Having regard to the fact that transportation methods are changing so rapidly I wonder is it proper that a particular mode of transport right should be allowed to impede development. I do not want to go into the controversy, but if local authorities in the South of Ireland decide what is best in their opinion they should be the best judges of their own business.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I would be very slow to give advice to the people in Cork or Waterford as to what they should do, as I would object to them advising the people in Cavan, Leitrim or Donegal as to what they should do. They should be the best judges of their own business and I know that they are. Having heard this argument with regard to the navigation of the Blackwater I feel that we should not forget that we have obsolete navigation rights. I think that the Minister knows the Ballinamore-Ballyconnell Canal. I believe it was the pipe dream of Sir Eric Drummond, a very decent man as an administrator as far as the Irish people are concerned. He got the notion—just parallel with the introduction of steam power—of building canals. There was one from the Corrib, a similar one from the Corrib to Lough Mask; in the North of Ireland there was the Bann and the Coleraine Canal. Provision was made in a special Act for the maintenance of those works, but what has happened about them? They are just not in operation. I believe there was a marvellous effort made in Galway recently to get one particular boat out from that canal; and it was made successfully, and good luck to them. In the case of the works executed in Roscommon, Leitrim, Cavan and Fermanagh, no one would get any boat, big or small, across the navigation. Still you have the navigation authority proposing to take responsibilities and proposing to levy a tax on the local authorities of Roscommon, Leitrim and Cavan for the maintenance of a navigation which does not exist in practice. Since this has happened with navigation work which has been constructed within 100 years, it could easily happen with the navigation on the Blackwater or any other river.

I greatly fear it is for sentimental purposes that a lot of this is being argued. Those are my views. I do not think it should be argued too far. The bridge or road authorities in Waterford or Cork are the best judges of their own business and it should not be argued here at all.

Comment on this

We must realise that we are legislating for the future. I think it would be the desire of everyone that we should develop waterways rather than close them up as is being suggested. I am anxious to know the difference in the cost. Supposing some factory has developed in Tallow or Lismore, why should we put a fixed bridge across for the sake of £50,000? If the bridge was wanted all along, when the place was not so developed as it is now—and Youghal is developing in a nice way with industries—we should be slow to put a fixed bridge in such waterways, especially in the Youghal rivers.

I fail to see that it is being dealt with from a sentimental point of view. We have to bear in mind that what we are doing to-night will be a means of closing the river for the next 100 years and for the sake of £50,000 we should leave it open.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister one question for the purpose of clarification. We are all in sympathy with the Senators who say they would like to see the Youghal bridge built quickly. The Minister seems to reply: "Give me the section and we can go ahead." I would like to ask him in what way the dropping of the section would prevent him from going ahead with the Youghal bridge?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is doubtful.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 19 has been ruled out of order on the ground that it tends to increase the charge on State funds.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We cannot take that just now.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister would the Road Fund be regarded as a State fund and, if not, would he be prepared to consider amending it——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Road Fund is a State Fund, if that assists.

Comment on this

That is all I wanted to know.

Comment on this

I began by trying to deal with the general principle, but the Minister and others have brought it down to specific instances. That is just as well, when some Senators are under the impression that the discussion has been taking a sentimental turn. There is nothing sentimental about the situation on the River Blackwater. As far as I can determine from newspaper reports, from a record in the Youghal Tribune of December 18th, 1954, the board of fishery conservators unanimously passed a resolution against the proposed bridge at Ardsallagh. There were also letters from the chairman of Youghal Urban District Council—which, after all, is the relevant local authority.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

No, the Cork County Council is the relevant authority.

Comment on this

At least they are closer to Youghal bridge.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They do not contribute anything to it.

Comment on this

That is no reason why they should be penalised. I had the idea that perhaps Cork County Council is thinking in terms of streamlined roads over Ardsallagh bridge and not thinking of the people of Youghal. As far as I can determine, the local people of Youghal—which is the important point—the board of conservators, the urban council and quite a number of fishermen—although they may be hoping for pretty generous compensation—are against it. I believe it would cause considerable detriment to Youghal to have it by-passed and also detriment to fishermen and to the public purse—and that is particularly important.

In this particular case the skilled Irish bridge construction consultants' engineers advised against building that bridge at Ardsallagh. Their opinion was endorsed by the best British and Australian bridge building firms. They held—that is, the Irish firm and the outside consultants—that Youghal bridge could be kept open and reconstructed at a cost under £250,000. On the other hand, the consultant called in as adviser to Cork County Council, which had an overriding decision, advised that the reconstruction of Youghal bridge would cost about £500,000. He also gave— he was not asked for it—an estimate that the construction of a fixed bridge at Ardsallagh would cost £190,000 to £200,000. He did not mention the major roads that would have to be built, or the safeguards to be taken against landslides to which that part of the terrain is subject, and he did not allow for compensation. The county council, having heard his evidence, decided for Ardsallagh bridge and they appointed, guess who? —the consultant who had turned in that report condemning the reconstruction of an open bridge at Youghal Harbour. In other words, they were making him judge and jury of his own case. I think that decidedly smacks of corruption.

This question has been brought down to specific instances, although we tried to avoid doing that; so if we vote on a specific question let us realise we are also voting on a principle, namely, the principle of keeping open the navigable public highways. I shall support Senator Hawkins' amendment and if that is beaten I shall vote for the second, my own amendment and that of Senator Stanford. If that should fail, I shall if necessary fight the third line of action on the Blackwater. I urge Senators to think deeply before they vote against these amendments.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the motion being pressed?

Comment on this

Could we get an undertaking from the Minister that he will give this matter consideration?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I am very sorry I cannot give any such undertaking. I may say the section is required also in connection with a bridge in County Donegal—Lifford bridge.

Comment on this

I am not clear why the section is required. I put the question just now to the Minister and he says it is doubtful. I am still left in doubt by that reply.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

In my opinion and in the opinion of some lawyers, the Minister may make a bridge Order under the old section. Other lawyers disagree and say it is doubtful whether a bridge Order could be made for a fixed bridge over a navigable river under Section 60 of the 1946 Act. Lawyers have disagreed as to what may be done under that section and it is to clarify the position and put it beyond yea or nay that I have introduced this section here.

Comment on this

Surely our object is to prevent the Minister having any such power under any circumstances? That is why we are putting forward this amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

He is not looking for power at all. The power he thinks is there, but this is put in to clarify the position beyond the yea or nay.

Comment on this

It seems that the Minister is not prepared to go to the courts.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I am more concerned with giving the people abridge than in fighting law cases.

Comment on this

Our concern is to keep the river open.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 17
·
Níl 14
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 17:—

In line 25, page 16, before the word "the" to insert the words "or the navigable part of any Irish river".

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 15
·
Níl 19
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 18:—

In line 25, page 16, before the word "the" to insert the words "or the River Blackwater".

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Might I ask how many Senators desire a division on amendment No. 18?

Comment on this

Would the Senators who desire a division on amendment No. 18 please rise?

Senators Dowdall, McHugh, Stanford, Sheehy Skeffington, Cogan and Teehan rose.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 15
·
Níl 19
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Can we have an undertaking from the Minister on this section which states:—

"(1) A rate made by a local authority shall not be invalidated by reason only of the fact that notice relating to the revised valuation list or appeal list prepared under the Valuation Acts has not been affixed at any place in accordance with those Acts."

This is a statutory regulation compelling the person responsible for the publication of this list to have it posted up at certain places. By this section we are relieving the officer of that duty. I think the least that we should insist on is that such a notice of revision of valuation should be published in two local papers circulating in the particular area.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I will look into the matter between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The public should be made aware in some definite manner that we have relieved the officer of the responsibility of having the notices posted in formally prescribed places. It should be made known to them that such a revision has taken place.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Section 18 of the Valuation of Ireland Act of 1852 sets out:—

"The authority shall, within three days after the receipt of such lists, cause to be affixed a notice on the principal outer door or gate pier of the church, and of any one Roman Catholic chapel and of any one Presbyterian meeting house within every parish or part of a parish including a county or urban district in which any hereditaments or tenements contained in such list are situate, stating the time at which said lists were so transmitted, and the time and place at which said lists may be inspected, and shall, at all reasonable hours on every day, from and after the receipt of said lists, for 21 days..."

I think that should be sufficient publication. It is very old and has satisfied the people down through the years. I think that sufficient notice. In December, 1949, a circular was issued to all local authorities requiring them to consider the practice of adopting some common method of notifying ratepayers by post of any alteration in the valuation of the holding immediately after the receipt of the revised valuation list.

I understand that most, not all, of the local authorities now carry out that request so that with the publication given under Section 18, the practice which exists with the local authorities and in view of the fact that individual rated occupiers are notified of increases or decreases, I think that sufficient notice is given to all parties concerned.

Comment on this

Up to the present there was an obligation on the local authority to do the things the Minister has pointed out in order that the rate might be valid. We are removing that impediment and if through neglect or oversight of the appointed officer to carry out his functions they are not carried out, still the collection of the rates is valid. That being so, there could be an inclination on the part of a local authority not to go to the expense or trouble of carrying out these publications. Very few local authorities have adopted the system of notifying the tenant of any increase in his valuation. It is important that the tenant should be notified and that we should insist, if we are dispensing with the former conditions, on publication in at least two local papers circulating in the district.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Senator will appreciate the volume of these lists. It is a huge volume. All we aim to do is to stop publication on church or chapel gates but we will carry out all the other methods. It is only waste of time suggesting that they could possibly be published on church gates. We will go through all the other methods mentioned for publication and ask that the local authorities bring to the notice of each occupier the changes in valuation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:—

In sub-section (1), line 7, to insert the word "cultural" before "and".

On the occasion of the Second Reading of the Bill I put a few questions as to whether certain organisations would be eligible for financial assistance under this section. There appeared to be some doubt. I mentioned, for instance, Muintir na Tíre, Macra na Feirme and the Irish Countrywomen's Association. From my reading of the appropriate section in the 1941 Act it appeared to me that they could form themselves into a local council within the meaning of the section. But then from my reading of the wording it would appear that such a body as the Gaelic League would not qualify under this section because the words "economic" and "social" are mentioned but not "cultural." It appears to me that by reason of the fact that the words "social" and "economic" are specifically mentioned in the former Act and repeated in this section a virile branch of the Gaelic League, anxious to have a hall erected in a parish for cultural purposes, would not qualify for financial assistance.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Would it not be a social body as well?

Comment on this

That is the point. Social is mentioned specifically.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

And that includes cultural.

Comment on this

I do not think it includes cultural.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It should if it does not.

Comment on this

Lest there might be any doubt about it, I thought it advisable to put down the word "cultural." If there was a branch of the Gaelic League in any part of the country which would see their way to collect funds for the purpose of spreading the language and native culture they would be entitled to the assistance that this section can give if we adopted the amendment I now propose. I ask for the insertion of the word "cultural." It would then be economic, social and cultural activities.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I sympathise with what the Senator wants and I agree with him entirely. It seems to me that the word "social" would include cultural in that particular context. Surely a dramatic society, for example, would be both social and cultural? So would a music society. Branches of the Gaelic League, as I knew them, were certainly social bodies unless they have changed since I got older. Parnell Square is associated in my mind with social events as well as with the learning of Irish.

Comment on this

It does seem to be well worth while putting the matter beyond doubt. Professor Hayes is no doubt right in his interpretation but I can hear others saying: "No, we are restricted to social and economic" and ruling that cultural did not come under this. In regard to legislation we should try to be as clear and full as possible. I think it is desirable to add the word "cultural".

Comment on this

I am in full agreement with what Senator Hayes said. The word "social" does include "cultural" but if we added the word "cultural" then in my opinion the amendment would actually restrict the scope of the section. For instance, in order to qualify a council would then require not only to be social and economic but also cultural. A group which had no pretensions to being cultural but formed to further the social and economic interests of the inhabitants would be excluded. I am advised that the word "social" includes cultural and that the scope of the Bill would definitely be restricted if we accepted the amendment. We must have social, cultural and economic to qualify. As it stands at the moment if you accept that social includes cultural then you only require social and economic to qualify you under the section. In view of that, I think you would restrict the scope of the Bill if the House accepted the amendment.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the one way of meeting the matter would be to substitute the word "or" for "and" and thus widen the scope of the section.

Comment on this

I would think that the word "or" should be put in because I find it very difficult to imagine what kind of body is both "social" and "economic".

Comment on this

I was going to mention that point too, that if as the Minister says the addition of the word "cultural" draws across the other words that precede it, then it could be said that the use of the words "social and economic" together would come under the same rule. Would it not be better to make use of the little word "or" so as to leave no doubt whatever in people's minds?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

As I have pointed out I would like to accept the amendment. I will certainly look into it. I see the Senator's point of view and am very anxious to meet it. I will look into it between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:—

In line 41, sub-section (4), after the word "building" to insert "and the appointment of corporation representatives to the body or committee entrusted with the management of the said building."

This amendment is self-explanatory. It is based on the view that it would be a good thing that where local authorities are making grants to other bodies they should have the right to representation on those bodies in supervising the way the money is spent. At present Section 52 allows a corporation to provide a building to be used by an approved local council, and they may entrust the care and management of that building to the council either permanently or temporarily. For this purpose they may by agreement acquire land. They may even supply furniture, office equipment and stationery. They may contribute to or pay the full wages of a person acting as caretaker, and so on. They may even make a grant to an approved local council for providing a building for public meetings, lectures and exhibitions. All of that is excellent, but I feel that at the end of paragraph (b) of sub-section (4) under which they are entitled to make an agreement with the corporation, "including agreements governing the use and disposal of the building," it would be wise that such agreements should include the possibility of the appointment of corporation representatives to the body or committee entrusted with the management of the building, to recognise the principle of representation of the local elected persons on any committee or council which was going to spend money in this way provided by the local authorities.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think the amendment is not really essential. The section as it stands empowers a local authority, before giving a grant, to require a local council to enter into such an agreement as the local authority considers proper. They may make any regulations they wish before giving sanction to the grant. The local authority could say that it would not give a grant to an approved local council unless the local council agreed to give the local authority representation. As the section stands you are leaving it to the local authority to make regulations, and if they want representation on the local council they may make that a condition precedent to giving a grant. There would then be no necessity for the amendment. I think the section as it stands covers the intention the Senator has in mind. I suggest to him that a local authority would have ample power and discretion and, after all, discretion is one of the things we like to leave with them.

Comment on this

I would agree with the Minister except for the fact that I notice some specific points are already made as to the kind of agreement that can be made. You have a bracket which says "including agreements governing the use and disposal of the building," and it seems to me that that is the point where we might mention the possibility of drawing public attention to the desirability of having public representatives on such a council.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The reference in brackets is merely inter alia. They have a right anyway under this section if they wish to avail of it.

Comment on this

I should prefer that where public money is being spent they would be reminded that they have a right to representation.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think it would not be very long until they found it out for themselves. Rest assured of that. I would like the Senator to appreciate that one of the reasons why I do not accept this amendment is not that I do not agree with it but that I think it is fully covered. I am most anxious to get this Bill through. It is now the month of April and the Second Reading was taken in the month of October. I want to avoid if at all possible going back to the Dáil with it, but if I have to go back I want to go back with as few amendments as possible, or only with amendments which are essential. I think this is not really necessary in view of the wording of the section.

Comment on this

I sympathise with the Minister and I do not want to obstruct in any way, but I think there is at least one amendment—the last one —which must go back.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There will be certain amendments.

Comment on this

If some go back, the Bill will all have to go back.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It will have to go back, but the fewer amendments the better. Some people may tell you that you are laying down regulations as to what a local authority must do.

Comment on this

You are giving them power.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They have got it already and I am certain they will discover it very quickly too. If they do not discover it when the Bill becomes an Act they will discover it when they read the discussion which has taken place on the amendment, which I hope will be brought to their notice. I am nearly certain it will.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

In sub-section (1) to add a new paragraph as follows:—

(c) A list of ratepayers prepared under this section shall be published in the prescribed manner both before and after adoption.

I think this is a very reasonable amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would the Senator be agreeable to discussing amendments Nos. 23, 24 and 25 together?

Comment on this

They are all of the same nature and I would ask the House to deal with them together. All I suggest is that the list of ratepayers should receive publication in the prescribed manner both before and after adoption. If people are going to become ratepayers it is only fair that they should have notice.

Comment on this

Arising out of the amendments of Senator O'Brien, it has been the practice of courtesy of certain public bodies to send a letter to a ratepayer if his hereditament has been reduced. I wonder would the Minister by Order make a regulation requiring the town clerk, the county manager, county secretary or other appropriate official to do so? Most public bodies have passed such regulations requiring their officials to do so. It is always appreciated by the ratepayer when he is given notice, and it is in line with the amendments of Senator O'Brien that the person who has to pay the tax or bear the burden should be informed. By statute he has a right to appeal to the Minister, and he should be made aware of the fact that he has this right so that he can give notice within the 21 days.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The purpose of Section 53 is to aneble the occupiers of small dwellings to be treated as ratepayers and thus enable them to vote in the plebiscite to change a place name. For this purpose local authorities are being empowered under the section to prepare and adopt a list of ratepayers. In the case of a local authority which is urban, one can realise the volume of that particular list. It will be a very big list. The purpose of the amendment is to require the list of ratepayers to be published both before and after the local authority have adopted it. That would be difficult and very expensive for a local authority, particularly a local authority in an urban district or town.

I can assure Senators that in the new regulations which will be made under Section 53 provision will be included requiring a local authority to give notice when the list of ratepayers has been prepared and before it has been adopted by the local authority, so as to permit persons interested to inspect the list. I will provide in the regulations under Section 53 to enable them to notify rated occupiers of the preparation of the list and give them an opportunity to inspect it. I think that will meet the requirements in the proposed amendment.

Comment on this

Is it not correct that this list referred to in Section 53 will be compiled only where an application is made or suggestion is made to have the name of a street changed? It is not very clear that it is only where such an application is made that the authority will take the first steps in that direction. It is only for such a purpose that this list is being prepared and it is only where proposals have been adopted to take a plebiscite for the changing of a place-name.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is correct.

Comment on this

It has no relation to the revision of valuations.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Absolutely none.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:—

In line 49, page 23, before the word "or" to insert the words "approved local council".

This amendment is to make it clear that an approved local council would have priority over a society, club or committee. I would ask the Minister to insert the words "approved local council" as in Section 54 where the council is responsible and entitled to obtain a grant for the erection of a building. After all, an approved council comprises the most responsible members of the community and in my opinion they would be most suited to receive a grant for construction of a swimming pool. The words in the section may be sufficient to cover that, but I would like the Minister to specify that particular council in this section.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

If the Senator refers to the section he will see:—

"A local authority to whom this section applies, may, with the consent of the Minister and subject to such terms and conditions as they think fit, contribute to the funds of a society, club, committee or other body..."

I think that would cover the suggestion the Senator has made. I can visualise a local committee, an approved council, who may not be in the least interested in swimming; they may think a swimming pool is a danger in the town, a danger to the children; but the local swimming club may be very interested in procuring a grant and it would be a tragedy if they were deprived of it where the local approved council were not interested.

Comment on this

I did not intend for a moment that anyone else would be excluded. I simply wanted the Minister to include this in the section.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is included under "or other body".

Comment on this

But not specifically. They may not feel they are entitled to the grant if they are not specifically set out, as a swimming club is, and just as the approved council is specifically set out in Section 54. One of the reasons why approved local authorities do not function very much is that there is not much incentive for their activities. If the approved local council are the first people naturally entitled to receive a grant, I do not see why they should not be specifically set out in that particular section.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

In Section 55 the approved local council has no definition whatever for the purpose of this section. I think that the broad term "or other body" should cover all approved local councils or other bodies. I assure the Senator that there is no approved local council which wishes to avail of the section which will not take very good care to inquire whether they come under the term "or other body".

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 27:—

In line 18, page 24, before the word "for" to insert the words "or gallery".

Amendments Nos. 27, 28 and 29 stand together. Section 57 is a permissive section which allows a council of a county or a corporation of a borough, with the consent of the Minister, to make contributions, but it mentions specifically for, the purpose of providing a museum for the reception of objects of local antiquarian interest. That is highly desirable and a very admirable purpose, but I think you might add to that "or gallery" for the reception of objects of local antiquarian "or artistic" interest. In that way if a local body wanted to make a contribution for a gallery to exhibit pictures either particularly referring to its own history or of general artistic appeal, it would have the power. Seeing that the intentions are to allow local bodies where they think fit—strictly leaving it to them, of course—to encourage museums, it is desirable they should also be allowed —again in any case where they think fit—to contribute towards the expenses of a gallery for artistic purposes. Therefore, the amendment would fit into the intentions of the Bill. The section as drafted mentions the word "museum" and that would seem to exclude everything else.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I understand that county borough corporations appear to be empowered under the Public Libraries Act to establish and maintain art galleries, and the Corporations of Dublin, Limerick and Waterford have actually done so. County councils and county borough authorities are empowered under Section 10 (2) of the Irish Universities Act of 1908 to place any sum at the disposal of an Irish university to be applied for any educational purpose which the local authority consider will benefit the county or the borough.

The university authorities in Cork, I understand, maintain a museum under this section on behalf of the corporation. Apart from people having a commercial interest in art, such as art dealers, it is difficult to see what type of body, other than a university, a local authority or a State-endowed body would want to set up an art gallery. I really cannot see it, and I suggest it would be unthinkable to have a local authority providing a subsidy for commercial art galleries. I respectfully suggest to the House that there is already sufficient provision for a local contribution to art galleries maintained by universities or established by local authorities. I have had no local demand for additional powers of the type which the Senator's amendment would suggest. I am satisfied that, apart from these commercial dealers, no other body would benefit by the amendment suggested by the Senator. I think, in view of what I have said about the Irish University Act of 1908, and the other Act which I quoted, that ample provision is being made for contributions towards the maintenance and upkeep of art galleries.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I agree entirely with what the Minister has said from the point of view of corporations and county boroughs. This amendment was suggested by the Arts Council. I have no interest, and I suppose neither has the Arts Council any interest, in commercial exhibitions, that is, exhibitions by art dealers although these may have a cultural as well as a commercial value. I think, for example, that if you wanted to have a contribution towards an exhibition of pictures in Tralee, the county council might be prepared to make a contribution. However, the matter is clear from the point of view of county boroughs. I know that the museum which the Minister has mentioned is run by University College, Cork, with the assistance, I think, of the Cork Borough Council. With regard to art galleries generally, and the county councils, I would like to make some further inquiries and so I propose that I should be allowed to withdraw the amendment. I may be able to put it down again in another form.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

To delete sub-section (1) and substitute the following:—

(1) (a) The Minister may by regulations make provision in relation to all or any local authorities with respect to all or any of the following matters:—

(i) Making of contracts;

(ii) accounts,

(iii) audit of accounts.

(b) The Minister may by regulations make provision in relation to all or any local authorities except a county or other borough with respect to any of the following matters:—

(i) summoning of meetings;

(ii) procedure.

I should like, first of all, to observe that I have notified the Minister that under paragraph (c) of Section 61, sub-section (1) and under the Public Assistance Act of 1939, there is a similar provision, and that he has never made regulations with regard to contracts. I would ask him, when this Bill becomes an Act, that he should make regulations with regard to contracts because I think that is desirable in the public interest. That, however, is not the real point covered by my amendment.

The point of my amendment is that we should continue certain of the old powers and traditions which our nine county boroughs and borough councils in this country have. A corporation is the oldest form of local government that we have in the country. It goes back to medieval times. A great deal of the procedure and ceremonial associated with these corporations is of medieval origin. The people of Ireland have taken over these rights and privileges and have used them for the purposes of local government.

The present-day constitution and procedure of borough councils are time honoured. For instance, in Clonmel for each meeting the Mayor signs a "precept". This is worded in old English and is read at each meeting and runs thus:—

"Borough of Clonmel—To Wit I hereby convene a monthly meeting of the Council of the Borough of Clonmel to be held in the council chamber within the town hall...etc."

Likewise, all resolutions of the Clonmel Corporation are worded thus:—

"At a meeting of the Council of the Borough of Clonmel holden in the council chamber...etc."

Under Section 60, sub-section (1) of this Bill, it is provided:—

"The Minister may by regulations make provision in relation to all or any local authorities with respect to all or any of the following matters:— (a) summoning and holding of meetings, (b) procedure, (c) making of contracts, (d) accounts, (e) audit of accounts, (f) matters which are subsidiary or ancillary to any of the foregoing matters."

When regulations under paragraphs (a) and (b) above are made, the old traditional practices of the Clonmel Corporation will disappear. There are only nine boroughs, and I suggest that these should be allowed to continue with their existing procedure. It is all set out in the Municipal Corporation Act of 1840. The corporations have carried on very well heretofore and the proposed regulations are solely to facilitate county managers and officials. They have no other useful purpose.

Paragraph (f) of Section 60, sub-section (1) now provides that regulations may be made in respect of "matters which are subsidiary or ancillary to any of the foregoing matters." It is evident that this paragraph has been introduced so that the proposed regulations will provide that county managers in counties where there are boroughs will be empowered by law to wear robes of office and take part in civic functions. An Act passed in 1950, the Repeal of Enactments Act, repealed the section of the Municipal Corporations Act which binds that the Mayor in a borough shall have precedence over all other persons inside the borough. Regulations under paragraphs (b) and (f) of sub-section (1) of Section 60 can now provide that county managers shall wear robes of office when taking part in civic functions. It will sound rather ironical that a Minister who is taking power to give back to the urban councils, corporations and county councils some of the powers which they had formerly should at the same time be removing some of the traditional powers which the nine county boroughs had. For that reason, I am suggesting that the section be divided for the purpose of excluding the four County Boroughs of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford and the Borough Councils of Dún Laoghaire, Drogheda, Kilkenny and; Galway so that they will be allowed to carry on under the old time hallowed procedure which they have had in the past.

As there is no time now to finish on my amendment, may I ask to be allowed the privilege of having my amendment recommitted on a later stage of the Bill?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

As there is only this amendment and one or two others for discussion on this stage, I would suggest, subject to the agreement of the House and of the Chair, that we should now finish the Committee Stage of the discussion, and on the Report Stage recommit the Bill from Section 61 to the end. That would enable Senators who have amendments down for this stage to have the privilege of Committee procedure from Section 61 onwards. We could then take the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is the House agreed on that suggestion?

Agreed.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The remaining sections of the Bill can now be taken.

Comment on this