Gaming and Lotteries Bill, 1955—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–168 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1955 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
To add a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) The Minister may bring into operation any Part or section of the Act separately or together with other Parts or sections and may fix different days for the coming into operation of the various Parts and sections: Provided always that Part IV of the Act shall not come into operation before June 1st, 1956.
I propose that the Minister should have power to bring the various parts of the Bill into operation on different dates. I understand that, in certain lotteries or competitions, things like football games and so on are involved and the dates may vary. It might be beneficial if the Minister at least had power to say that a particular part of the Bill would operate in respect of a particular kind of competition at different times.
Comment on this
The sooner this Act is brought into operation the better so as to end the present "toleration" of unlawful practices. A short interim period will be necessary so as to permit of arrangements being made for District Court hearings of applications for certificates for gaming licences and lottery licences and for bringing to the notice of local authorities and others their functions under the Act. I intend to fix the date of commencement within one month of the passing of the Act.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
In line 30 to delete "forecasts" and substitute "guesses or estimates".
This is merely a matter of grammar and style. In the Bill, the word "forecast" is used in respect to an estimate as to some past event. I have looked up a number of dictionaries and can find no authority whatever to use the expression "forecast" in respect of a past event. It relates solely to future events. Therefore, I suggest the use of other words which are not open to that criticism; I suggest either a "guess" or an "estimate". It is a pity that we should use in a statute a word which has never been used in that way before.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendment. I have brought the suggested words "guesses or estimates" to the notice of the draftsman who is satisfied that the word "forecasts" is used in the same sense in Section 26 of the British Betting and Lotteries Act of 1934 which relates to restrictions on certain types of prize competitions. As between choices of different words meaning the same thing, I feel that in legislation sponsored by the Government the words of the draftsman attached to the office of the Attorney-General should prevail.
Comment on this
I hope that Senator Cox will press this amendment. I feel as strongly as he does, that it makes us look ridiculous—even if we appeared ridiculous in a previous Act. I think the amendment is admirable, that it makes the position quite clear and that we lose nothing. I would like to see it accepted by the Government or inserted in the Bill by the Seanad.
Comment on this
I should like to support the amendment. The Minister has said that the word "forecast" appears in a British Act, but surely even the British draftsman may go wrong.
Comment on this
The difficulty might be met by changing the order of the words. If we said "forecasts of future events or the results of past events which are not yet ascertained or not yet generally known," would it not meet the case?
Comment on this
Would the Senator withdraw the amendment and let the matter be considered between now and the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I will let it stand over to the Report Stage. I am not keen on withdrawing it, because I think it is just silly to use words that do not mean what they say. I will raise it again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I am not keen one way or the other. I have to accept the advice of the Attorney-General. If the Seanad wishes, I will put in the words.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:—
In line 31, to delete "yet" where it occurs and substitute "then" in each case.
I suggest that the word "yet" could be interpreted as the date of coming into force of the Act and that the word "then" would be more appropriate for that reason.
Comment on this
As between the word "yet" used by the parliamentary draftsman in line 31 and the word "then" suggested by Senator Walsh, I am advised that there is no real difference in meaning and in the circumstances I propose to retain the word "yet" chosen by the draftsman, who is the technical expert in such matters.
Comment on this
If the word "yet" is not the most appropriate word, would the Minister consider other words that would be more suitable? I could have suggested other words.
Comment on this
The Senator must know that I am in the hands of the technical draftsman and must accept his words.
Comment on this
Do I take it that the technical draftsman has considered this?
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment and can put it down again for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In line 36, after "charge" to add "but does not include a building or portion of a building used for a private residence".
This definition appears to have been taken from the Road Traffic Act of 1933. In that Act, a public place is defined as meaning "any street, road or other place to which the public have access with vehicles whether as of right or by permission and whether subject to or free of charge". While that definition might be quite suitable for a public place because of the fact that it must be with vehicles, it might not be just the most appropriate definition in the case under this Bill because of the fact that it might refer to a person's private residence. The public may have access by permission to a person's private residence. Just as the Englishman's home is his castle, I am anxious that an Irishman's home shall be protected under this amendment.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment. I am advised that it is unnecessary and that, being unnecessary, it is undesirable in that it would only throw doubt on the meaning of the other words, not only in this Bill but perhaps in the Road Traffic Act from which it was taken. The Bill provides that the Gardaí may arrest without warrant anybody whom they find conducting gaming, contrary to the Act, in a public place. The definition of "public place" obviously does not, in the ordinary way, cover a private residence, for the general public have not access to it either as of right or by permission. The only case I can think of where the contrary might hold would be some large building such as a castle where the public are admitted for sightseeing. I do not know if we have any such case in Ireland, but if we have all I can say is that they should not start promoting unlawful gaming there. This definition is, as I have said, in the Road Traffic Act and all the provisions about insurance, driving licences and so on hinge on it. It has, at least as far as we are concerned in this Bill, stood the test of time and of court proceedings.
Comment on this
The Minister will agree that it is access with vehicles, which makes the very big difference.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
To delete sub-section (3).
I propose that this sub-section be deleted, on the grounds that it seems to be just nonsense. It commences:—
"Gaming shall not be unlawful if no stake is hazarded by the players..."
The definition of a lottery involves a stake. Why, then, is it necessary to have a solemn section to say that gaming shall not be unlawful, if no stake is hazarded; in other words, shall not be unlawful, if there is no gaming? On the other hand, if the sub-section reads that gaming shall be lawful, no matter what stakes are set between the players, provided they do not set the stake with the promoter, then it seems to me to be leaving the door wide open. Whichever interpretation one comes to on sub-section (3), it does not seem either to make sense or to attain any useful object, and I think it may produce considerable confusion.
Comment on this
I should have thought the section would be welcomed by the House. Its purpose is to give permission to people in hotels to have an innocent game of whist, or some other minor game, so that they will not be prosecuted when they have these games when they are not for their own benefit, but are a matter of amusement. I explained that in the other House.
Comment on this
Do I understand from that that, if I promote some kind of competition or lottery, and I myself derive no benefit from it, all the players can bet as much as they like with one another, or can have any stakes they like as between themselves and that that will not be unlawful?
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept amendment No. 5. As I explained in the other House, the purpose of sub-section (3) of Section 4 is to permit without fear of police prosecution the promotion of or the provision of facilities for gaming such as whist drives or bridge drives or billiard tournaments where the gaming is of an incidental nature and it is primarily carried on for sociable purposes. I would have thought that such a relaxation would be welcomed by everybody. Our object in this Bill is to stop people from being induced to take part to excess in gambling games which may be organised for the personal enrichment of the promoter. At the same time, we do not want to interfere with harmless gaming of a minor nature.
Comment on this
I am not one to enter into a legal battle on this issue, but I should like to put my point of view. Sub-section (1) of this section would really make it illegal—unless it is otherwise provided for—to have any form of gaming, say, bookmakers. I understand that bookmakers work in such a way that there is not an equal chance. I understand that the margin of odds is so arranged that there is a margin of profit for the bookmaker. I suggest that, according to sub-section (1) of this section, bookmakers, as such, would be illegal, as I understand there is not an equal chance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In sub-section (1), to delete paragraph (b).
The amendment is to exclude paragraph (b) which permits a fun-fair or circus or travelling show to carry on for only 10 days. In many parts of the country there are instances where a travelling show may come for a longer period. Sometimes the first few days are devoted to a local charity. It would curtail, possibly, the benefits that might be derived by such charities, if the period were limited to 10 days, as set out in this paragraph.
Comment on this
Although a travelling show may come into a place on a certain day, it can happen that three or four days may elapse before they inform the local sergeant. Then they have ten days from the time they notify the sergeant that they will start gambling on a particular night.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
In sub-section (1), to delete paragraph (c).
With the permission of the Chair, I should like to refer also to amendment No. 9, which seeks to delete paragraph (e), because it is complementary. Amendment No. 7 refers to paragraph (c) of Section 6 (1) of the Bill, which refers to the stake. Amendment No. 9 refers to paragraph (e) of the same section and sub-section of the Bill and refers to the prize of 10/-. The reason I put these amendments down is that, although the amount of the stake and the prize is limited, the number of players in the game is not limited. There is no relationship, therefore, between the amount of the prize and the amount of the pool provided by the players in the game. It is fairly safe to assume that in all games organised at circuses or carnivals, the maximum stake of 6d. will, in fact, be the minimum charge for a chance. Thus, if 100 people participate in a game and pay 6d. each, after providing for a prize of 10/- there would be a profit of £2. A profit of 400 per cent. seems to me to be rather exorbitant. It seems unfair that the Act does not provide that a percentage of the stakes should be the prize. I am prepared to withdraw both of these amendments if the Minister will guarantee that provision will be made to establish a fair ratio between the amount of the stake and the amount of the prize.
Comment on this
I am informed by the showmen that 6d. is usually the maximum price. I am informed that the usual amount in the country is 1d. or 2d. and that 3d. is the maximum. I have personal experience of the matter in rural areas. It is not for the purpose of a big prize that we are going to encourage people to take part. I am sure my predecessor had many distressing letters on this matter from wives and people here in Dublin City, letters imploring the Government to introduce some Bill which would have the effect of not inducing a higher prize. If we keep the prize at 10/-, there will not be many people to continue at the game and there will not be many people even to give 6d. when they find that, if they win, they will only get a prize of 10/-. As far as I know, in the rural areas a price of 6d. will not often be asked, except, perhaps, in the case of a very large excursion day for the circus and amusement people. Only after consultation with showmen did I agree to put this in the Bill.
Comment on this
Whether the stake is one penny or 6d. seems irrelevant. Surely the essence of fair gaming is that there should be some just ratio between the amount of the prize and the amount subscribed by the players? Whether the stake is 6d. or 1d., if the person running the game gets 400 per cent. or 300 per cent. profit it does not seem fair but, rather, an invitation to fleece the general public.
Comment on this
I think Senator McHugh is overlooking the fact that the purpose of this Bill is to curb gaming as far as possible. It seems to me that his argument would, to some extent, encourage it. He is arguing on the relationship between the stake and the prize money.
If you had a position whereby the stake would be more and you compelled the promoter to give as much as possible by way of prize, surely that would simply encourage the people? You can quite well imagine what the position would be at one of these shows at a circus if the stake were 3d. and the prize £100. I do not think Senator McHugh would really desire that. I can quite see his point. He is not too keen about leaving the promoters with a great profit. However, the limiting of the stake and the prize is, I think, the best way possible to curb gaming and also—to some extent, I should imagine—to reduce the profits on these lotteries.
Comment on this
With respect to the last speaker, his argument is that the best way of discouraging gaming is to ensure that the promoter makes an exorbitant profit and that the public are consequently fleeced.
Comment on this
I do not altogether agree with the amendments put down by Senator McHugh, but he has got a point. I think that Senator Walsh's amendment, amendment No. 8, would meet Senator McHugh's objection.
Comment on this
I think it would, but the trouble is that I have no guarantee that Senator Walsh's amendment will be passed if my amendment is withdrawn. I will withdraw the amendment and put it down for Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
In sub-section (1) (c), line 37, to add "the promoter shall not collect more than double the amount of the prize money in each game and"
It is wrong to curb the stake the player will place and not to curb the profits which the promoters may derive out of it. If the promoter can use the excuse set out in this Bill, that he is limited to a prize of 10/- and that the sky is the limit in relation to the number of cards he may sell to the players, 100 per cent. profit is certainly a fair profit. It is the practice in any part of the country that I know of that the winner gets half the pool. If the promoter in a case like this gets half the pool, I think he is doing very well indeed. I would ask the Minister to consider the amendment.
Comment on this
On reconsidering this matter, I thought that the maximum of 10/- would not induce a large number to come to play. I have practical experience for the past 15 or 20 years in connection with fetes and unless you offer a very substantial prize a very large number will not remain.
Comment on this
Does the Minister see any reason why the amendment should not be accepted?
Comment on this
Nobody will remain when the prize is small. What induces them to remain is the prospect of winning £5.
Comment on this
I have no practical experience in regard to these matters, but I noticed that at dances where raffles are held occasionally a very large number of people buy tickets, even though they know that the prize is merely a bottle of whiskey or a box of chocolates. I hope the Minister will consider the amendment suggested by Senator Walsh. I think it is a very fair and reasonable one.
Comment on this
I would be very much in favour of accepting this amendment also. I do not think that the case made by the Minister is a convincing one, because, even though the prize of 10/- would not be regarded as an alluring one, still there would be many games on the same occasion.
Comment on this
The Minister based most of his arguments in refusing to accept these amendments on the opinion of the Attorney-General, but he is basing his refusal to accept this amendment on his own personal experience. The Minister says he has practical experience. Suppose a circus comes to a town and 2,000 people attend. Suppose they have a lottery and sell tickets for 6d. or 3d. each, if the Minister prefers that, at least 50 per cent. of the people may buy tickets, possibly more. Some of those people may buy two, three or four tickets and there may be a profit of 1,000 per cent. on that game. Yet the Minister argues that, by confining it to 10/- there is a safeguard. No matter what experience the Minister has, and since he is not basing his opinion on that of the Attorney-General, which is probably a good thing, the Minister should have some regard for the arguments put forward by Senators Douglas, McHugh and Walsh.
Comment on this
The difference is so thin that it is easy to change from a lottery to a game. One can even sell song sheets.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to consider the views expressed on this section. I notice we have provided that no player may win more than the value of 10/- in each game. I think it could be arranged that you could have prizes that would win 10/- each, and in that way the limit of the prize money which the Minister is using to discourage this gaming could be overcome to some degree. I think there is some merit in Senator Walsh's amendment.
I can quite see the Minister's point of view also in regard to discouraging gaming by keeping down the prize money. I would suggest that the matter be reconsidered, because it could be that some compromise might be reached to meet all our viewpoints. We are all agreed on the aim we are out to achieve. We might disagree as to how exactly it could be possible to accomplish it.
Comment on this
I agree with what I might call the philosophy of Senator Walsh's amendment. There are some points that have to be considered. One is that the Bill, I think, quite properly, speaks of a person not winning more than the value of a certain amount. In a great many of these things, the prizes might be something not money, but some kind of an article. Applying Senator Walsh's amendment to that, I think one should in some way bring the element of value into it. A second point has just occurred to me that the promoters would not make more than 50 per cent. I have gone into the question with some of the people who run these travelling shows. A great many of them eke out a pretty miserable existence. The pay the people working get is extraordinarily low and the people performing are generally grossly underpaid. They have shown an extraordinary loyalty and goodness to one another. It is very often by side-shows that the promoter keeps the show going. While I agree in principle with Senator Walsh, that there ought to be some connection between the amount received and the value of the prize, I doubt if the proportion which he has suggested is allowing enough to the person who runs the fair. After all, these fairs bring a good deal of fun and enjoyment to local people. I would agree that the whole of this section deserves a good deal of thinking over on several aspects.
Comment on this
I can safely say that, between now and the Report Stage, I will have all the points considered to see whether we can meet the wishes of Senators. I am entirely in favour of Senator Walsh's point of view.
Comment on this
Where there is a limit of 10/-, there is a great deal of cost involved in running the game. Even if the profit rate is high, the expenses are high in proportion to the amount involved, and the net profit is low. I think it will have the total effect the Minister envisages in the Bill, if he makes the maximum 10/-. If there were a minimum of £5, I would be inclined to agree with Senator Walsh and Senator McHugh that you should then institute some profit margin, but when the amount is so small, a great deal of the profits will be eaten into by the overheads. I think we will find that these games that were great money spinners, as the promoters called them themselves, will not be as effective when they are restricted under the Bill to 10/-.
Comment on this
Senator Burke must be aware that there may be 40 or 50 games played one after another on the same night—as the Minister apparently knows. Even last week, I had some experience of this, when there was a local bazaar. I am aware that the winner gets half the pool, but the promoter derives considerable benefit from it. If there is a section in a Bill limiting the amount of the prize money, I think it is only right there should be a corresponding section limiting the profits which the promoter should earn from it. There is no doubt the section confers a benefit on a promoter by limiting the money which he will have to pay out, without putting any limit whatsoever on the amount he can take in.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:—
In subsection (1), to delete paragraph (d).
With your permission I would like to speak about amendments Nos. 11 and 14 together. This is really the same argument as that which I made in relation to Section 7, which states:
"(1) Gaming carried on as part of a carnival, bazaar, sports meeting, local festival, exhibition or other like event shall not be unlawful gaming if...
(d) the stake in each game is not more than 6d. for each player, and...
(f) no player may win more than the value of 10/- in each game, and..."
I think exactly the same argument applies. You have to establish some sort of just proportion between the pool divided by the players and the amount to be received by the promoters.
I am prepared to withdraw this and put it in for the Report Stage, but I would like to have some assurance that it will be seriously reconsidered.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:—
In sub-section (1) (d), line 10, to add "the promoter shall not collect more than double the amount of the prize money in each game and".
The same would apply here. I am prepared to withdraw this also, if the Minister seriously considers the matter before the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:—
In sub-section (1), paragraph (e), line 12, before "and" to insert "except accompanied by a parent or someone in loco parentis to that person”
I move this amendment relating to children under the age of 16. I consider it necessary to discourage young people from spending money on these functions, but paragraph (e) is a bit too drastic. One can envisage an occasion when children under 16 would be accompanied by their parents at carnivals or local bazaars. There would be nothing wrong in allowing children of 14 or 15 to take part to a certain extent in these games under the vigilance of their parents or of persons in loco parentis. This could also be the case at seaside resorts where families come for a holiday and like to go to bazaars and carnivals. I would ask the Minister to consider the advisability of relaxing the law he has in mind.
It will be noticed that there is also an age limit in a preceding sub-section to which we have not referred at all. It is in Section 6. It may be asked why we did not propose a similar amendment to Section 6, sub-section (1) paragraph (d). The reason, as far as I am concerned, is that I regret there is a fundamental difference between gaming carried on at circuses and travelling shows and gaming carried on at carnivals, bazaars, sports meetings or local festivals.
Comment on this
I support Senator Kissane. I have memories of being brought as a child to many bazaars at which there were many competitions for children for various stakes. I think it would be quite undesirable, and rather a foolish thing, to forbid children to attend bazaars and charitable organisations of that kind, or participate in things of that kind. As Senator Kissane suggests, if children are accompanied by somebody who is looking after them, very little harm can come to them.
Comment on this
It seems to me to be wrong that the State should take upon itself something which is a responsibility of parents. Parents have a primary responsibility to look after their children. It is bad in principle to incorporate a provision in a Bill that will not, possibly, be enforced to the letter of the law, in the case of a bazaar or a parochial festival of some description. It seems desirable that children should go to these fixtures from time to time: they have a certain educational value. Unlike adults, children have no responsibilities. The amount of money which they are allowed to have from the parents is very limited, and if the parents feel they should be permitted to spend one shilling or two shillings on a game, and if they are accompanied by such persons, I feel it is too harsh of the Minister to insist that any child under 16 years should not be permitted to take part in such a game.
Comment on this
I find it difficult to follow the line of reasoning in this amendment. I agree that children should be allowed to attend a carnival. The amendment means that any child of any age can take part in the gaming——
Comment on this
How will that work? Have the words "in loco parentis” any particular meaning? Is the onus thrown upon the promoter of the carnival, or bazaar, or sports, to find out if the particular adult with the child stands to the child in loco parentis? I do not know how you would work that.
I think the police will have some difficulty in working the Bill as it stands. It seems to me that, in the case of children under 16 years, it would be better if they did not indulge in gaming. The amendment means that there will be no age limit at all, provided the child is accompanied, presumably, by some adult. If I bring my neighbour's children to a bazaar, I do not know whether or not I am in loco parentis: possibly I am. However, it seems to me to put a very difficult obligation on the promoters— that, when a particular child takes part in the gaming, the defence should be made that the child is accompanied by a particular person who is to the child in the position of a parent. I do not know how you are going to prove that. If you insert this amendment in its present form, it would merely mean that any child could take part in any game which is contemplated by Section 7. First and foremost, it seems bad that children should indulge in gaming and, secondly, it would be entirely unworkable, in the particular circumstances in the amendment, unless the child is accompanied by an adult. Even that is difficult to prove. I have gone into carnivals with my own children and have been successfully evaded and avoided by them for the rest of the evening—after they had got money from me.
Comment on this
If Senator Hayes's only objection to this amendment are the words "in loco parentis”, then it would be possible now or at a later stage to arrange for the substitution of the words “an adult appointed by the parents.” Let us examine this amendment not for the purpose of finding fault with it, but for the purpose of finding fault with the section, if the amendment is not accepted. If the amendment is not accepted, is this not the position? Suppose any of us should find ourselves in Lisdoonvarna, Bundoran or Kilkee on a wet day and suppose we go some place there where a game of “pongo” is being played. Suppose we have young children under 16 years with us and suppose we indulge in the simple game of “pongo” or give pennies to the children to play that game. Technically, we are then breaking the law, as this section stands. Senator Hayes knows that. It is to avoid that difficulty that Senator Kissane has picked on this amendment. If this amendment is not accepted we shall be bringing this Bill into contempt. There has been a great deal of evasion, and the previous legislation was so bad that it was being broken every day of the week. Now that we are trying to amend the position, it would appear that, in little ways like that, the law will be brought into contempt again. Any law that is not reasonable or cannot be enforced should not be passed.
Consider the position of people on holidays in places where there are games and gaming shows. The children will go in and then they will break the law. That is bad. It is infringing the rights of parents and the liberty of people. It is the moral responsibility of parents to have some regard as to what is good for their children. That is their responsibility and it is one on which the State cannot encroach. In my view, it is wrong to interfere to that degree with the rights of parents in an issue like this. The playing of simple games is not criminal. The amendment should be accepted. If it is only the legal quibble existing between Senator Hayes and Senator Kissane, I submit they should be able to arrange the matter between themselves.
Comment on this
I oppose the amendment. I do not think it is the intention of the Seanad to encourage children to attend at gambling. There is nothing to prevent children from going to a carnival or a place of amusement, but not to take part in gambling. I am sure it is not the wish of any Senator that they should take part in gambling. It is not the parent who would be prosecuted; it is the promoter. I ask the Seanad to accept the Bill and so prevent the encouragement of children under 16 years to take part in gambling. We have heard of things which have happened. We have heard of juvenile delinquents. There is nothing to prevent adults from buying tickets. Surely we want to prevent children of that age from taking part in some of the gambling at machines in Dublin, apart altogether from anything else? I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes raises the problem of how a promoter is to know if the children are under or over 16 years. It is a difficult thing to enforce. It would be unreasonable to expect that the child would have to bring a birth certificate to show his age. Local charity bazaars are a very common thing in country districts and are run by a voluntary committee. That voluntary committee would be perfectly familiar with the parents of the children and it would not be at all difficult to enforce the position, as far as the country areas are concerned. It seems to me that young children should be permitted to attend a function for charity. Very often, these people are required to assist in promoting the entertainment. The amount they will have to spend will be so limited that it will not make much of a difference.
Comment on this
The same law applies to bookies' shops and licensed premises. The sergeant will use his common sense. There are not many cases of prosecutions of children for being in bookies' shops or on licensed premises.
Comment on this
I have given a great deal of consideration to this amendment. In fact, at the beginning, I thought I was rather opposed to it. My only experience of what I presume are carnivals and bazaars are church carnivals and bazaars. I can remember very well going as a child to these bazaars and paying 3d. or 6d., or even 1d., for the right to take part in a tub-dip. I also remember buying balls to throw at coconuts and buying large rings and trying to throw them over toy motorcars or dolls on stands. It seems to me that, under this section, no child under 16 years will be allowed to take part in any gaming at a carnival: I am sure that that, in fact, constitutes gaming because you are taking a chance when you pay 3d to throw a ring over an article which, under this section, is worth no more than 10/-. Surely it is not intended to prevent children from taking part in Church carnivals?
Comment on this
I have been thinking that a lot of Senators are speaking out of their depth, or are speaking in their innocence. I think they would need to have regard to the situation which has been in existence here in Dublin and which this Bill is trying to curb. We are all in agreement with the general principle that that sort of "dive" in Dublin where some people spend so much of their time should cease to exist. It is all very well to say that a child accompanied by parents, or somebody who is standing to that child in loco parentis, should be allowed to participate. Here again we are being a bit too innocent. That could be overcome as easily as taking kids into a match. We have all seen children outside the gates where a match is being held. They come along and say: “Take me in, Mister”. Similarly, now it will be: “Stand by me, Mister.” Just because some adult is standing beside them, they can take part in these games.
Church bazaars are all right. I suppose children are usually accompanied by adults. In my opinion, the Church bazaar is a very small part of the problem we are dealing with here in this Gaming and Lotteries Bill. I strongly support the Minister in his opposition to this amendment. I suggest to the House that it would defeat and seriously weaken the purpose of this Bill if we allowed children accompanied by parents, or any adult, to take part in these games. I think it would be wholly undesirable. I ask Senators to have regard to the situation existing in Dublin and neighbouring seaside resorts for the past few years.
Comment on this
This amendment applies only to carnivals and bazaars, where the person arranging for holding them derives no personal profit. Consequently, Senator Murphy's remarks do not apply.
Comment on this
Actually, Senator Murphy has tried to make a case against this amendment which the Minister did not make himself. That is not common sense at all to me. If the amendment had some regard to Section 6, it might have some impact on me, but, since it applies to Section 7, it does not impress me at all. I think the amendment should be accepted.
I am not at all convinced by Senator Murphy's argument. He tried to say that we were innocent people to put down this amendment and suggested that we had no experience. There may be evils which Senator Murphy knows of and about which I do not know, because I do not live in Dublin—evils which this section is designed to remedy. Certainly, to infringe on the liberty of parents to the degree intended by this section is not good. I still think the Minister should accept the amendment.
Comment on this
We cannot accept the amendment. My predecessor and myself have received heaps of complaints about children being allowed to attend these places. I am sure that if Senators on the other side had an opportunity of reading a few of these pitiful letters which we have received, they would understand why we cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the House in connection with this amendment, but the Minister referred to a point which made me come to the conclusion that, even if this section is enacted as it stands at present, there will be wholesale evasion of it, because it will be possible for parents of adults to come along with the children and buy tickets for them, and they will actually be taking part then in the gaming in an indirect way. Would it not be as well, then, to have a position where the children themselves, under the vigilance of their parents, would be able to indulge in the pleasure— because a pleasure it would be to their young minds—of participating directly in these games at carnivals and bazaars? We had not in mind any place in Dublin or any "dives" that Senator Murphy referred to. We have in mind what is mentioned in the section of the Bill—carnivals and bazaars, where those conducting those functions make no profit for themselves.
Comment on this
Would the Minister have the matter considered again between now and the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I do not want to mislead the Senator in any way. From the information I have and from the correspondence which I and my predecessor have received, I would be prepared to withdraw the Bill sooner than encourage children to gamble, or give them any facilities for gambling. As I have already said, if the Senator had seen some of the letters which I have seen, I know he would be the first to agree with me on this matter.
Comment on this
Senator Kissane said that adults can buy the stakes or tickets for these games for the children. I think that is the case. The parent is there. You say that the children should be allowed to take part, if the parent or somebody in loco parentis is there. Then you come along with the section as it stands and you say: “The parent can buy the ticket for the child.” Surely that meets the purpose of the amendment? The amendment would open the door completely.
Comment on this
Senator Carton has been unsuccessful in reaching the House owing to an accident. I think his amendment, No. 15, will have to be left over until the next day.
Comment on this
Sub-section (1), paragraph (f), says that no player shall win more than the value of 10/- in each game. May I suggest, Sir, that that paragraph, instead of legalising games, will have the effect of making certain games, such as bagatelle, completely illegal? The Minister has experience of the game and I have played it myself. It is a game where the pool is cumulative and people play until they are all satisfied. Then, whoever has the highest score gets half the pool, which may be as much as £5. Therefore, paragraph (f) will make that game illegal. It may be argued that bagatelle, like snooker, is a game of skill, but a game, according to Section 2, means the playing of a game of skill or chance, or partly of skill or chance, for stakes deposited by the players.
I should like to know from the Minister what effect paragraph (f) will have on the game of bagatelle and what effect it will have on shooting galleries, which are such a popular feature of bazaars, and in which, as in bagatelle, the highest scorer takes half the pool, which, again, may be as high as £5. These are popular games at local bazaars and the fact of making them illegal will bring the law into contempt. Do Senators think that the local sergeant will go into a parochial hall where these games are being played and prosecute the parish priest?
Comment on this
If the Senator will read Section 6, he will see that bagatelle is not an unlawful game. It is only what is prohibited under Section 4 that is not allowed.
Comment on this
I know that, but the effect of paragraph (f) of Section 7 will make it illegal, because it is a cumulative game.
Comment on this
If the Senator will read Section 4, he will find that unlawful games are defined there.
Comment on this
Whether it is regarded as a legal game or not, the fact is that it cannot be played, and neither can there be a shooting gallery. The fact that they are regarded as legal in Section 4 is one matter, but paragraph (f) of Section 7 makes it illegal to play them.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister would the participation of a child in a "bran tub" at a parochial bazaar be a contravention of this section of the Bill. I will not call them harmless games, because they are gambling, but they do take place at Church festivals and would the clergyman or the parish priest be prosecuted if he allowed a child to take part in a "bran tub"?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In sub-section (1), line 26, before "an" to insert "an Irish citizen or".
As the Bill stands, it states that a qualified individual, and only a qualified individual, can promote or provide facilities for gaming under Section 4. Now, I visualise people who have been out of the country for over a year. For instance, in the West of the country, as the House is well aware, a great percentage of our people have to emigrate. When they come home, they may buy a hall, an hotel or a business premises. Apparently, those people who have been out of the State for some months would be excluded, under the section, from promoting, assisting to promote, or providing facilities for gaming. Apart from other considerations, I wonder is it constitutional that an Irish citizen should be deprived of those rights? For that reason, I ask the Minister to include what I regard as elementary justice. An Irish citizen should have the same rights, irrespective of whether or not he has been out of the country for 12 months.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Senator realises what he is opening up? It is the show people who are paying their rents and taxes here who should be facilitated. If the amendment were accepted, we would have people coming in from some other part of the country for the summer months.
Comment on this
They would reap all the benefits in opposition to the showmen who pay their taxes in the country. I do not think I could accept the amendment and allow people to come in here from England and other places for a short period and then go around the country to the detriment of the interests of the recognised showmen who are an asset to the country. I regret I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I cannot accept the Minister's reasons. The Minister states that if a person comes back intending to live here, he must be back for 12 months before he can promote, assist in promoting or provide facilities. A great number of our people have to emigrate, owing to force of circumstances. They do so for the purpose of coming back when they have accumulated sufficient funds to be able to purchase a property in this country. The Minister seems to be concerned that people may come from other portions of the country here. Those persons could not qualify, as the Minister knows, under this section, unless they were Irish citizens. As far as I am aware, an Irish citizen is a person who has been born in the country before 1923.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the situation obtaining at present. If a person was born after 1923 in the occupied portion of our country, he would not be regarded as an Irish citizen. I think it is unjust that an Irish citizen should be deprived of his rights whilst a person who has been here for only 13 months would qualify under the section.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senator Walsh. It seems to me that under the Constitution, if a person is an Irish citizen, he must have a right to do anything that is not actually unlawful. I think there have been far too many Acts stipulating not being in the country for a certain period. Senator Walsh is probably quite correct when he says it is contrary to the Constitution to say that an Irish citizen has not some rights as a citizen just because he has been out of the State for a certain period.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senators Cox and Walsh on this amendment. I put down other amendments with the same end in view, that the rights of Irish citizens should be protected.
Comment on this
The Betting Act of 1931 contains similar provisions. Six-County showmen are taxed in respect of lorries and motor-cars and they pay the taxes in the Six Counties. Surely the Senator does not suggest that we should facilitate them to come in in competition with our recognised showmen whose lorries and motor-cars are taxed in the Republic? To encourage those people to come in would be detrimental to the interests of Irish showmen. I am advised not to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to exclude people who were born and bred in the country?
Comment on this
The showmen themselves discussed the matter with me and they have every sympathy with the Senator's point of view. As a matter of fact, a certain Englishman offered one of our showmen £50,000 merely to use his name. I do not think the Senator would be in favour of a man who is not paying any taxes in this country coming in and getting all the benefit out of the tourist season. The man from the Twenty-Six Counties is not allowed to go up and operate in the Six Counties, but some of the Six County men who are Irish citizens come down here at the present time.
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that we should do everything they do in the Six Counties?
Comment on this
Could anything be done in regard to reciprocal arrangements in regard to the showmen? Such an arrangement would deserve to be encouraged. I think showmen are a class who are inclined to die out. Ireland is too small to have Six County men restricted from coming here. Perhaps the Minister might examine the matter.
Comment on this
Will the Minister consider the people I mentioned, on Report Stage?
Comment on this
The man who is trying to establish after 12 months—the Irish citizen? I certainly will have sympathy with that. That is what the Senator has in mind?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (1), line 28, after "State" to add "provided that a clergyman or minister of religion in charge of a parish or area situated partly in the State and partly outside the State, should for the purpose of this Act, be deemed to have his usual or principal place of residence in the State".
Section 30 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act is being repealed under this Bill and is being re-enacted. Under the ordinary licensing laws, the people who are set out in this section are permitted to be on licensed premises after hours, but, as the law stands at the moment, there are cases such as that of the parish priest of Strabane, which is in the Six Counties, who happens also to be parish priest of Lifford, in the Twenty-Six Counties. As the Bill stands, he, or any of his parishioners in Strabane, would not be permitted to promote a parochial function in which gaming takes place in the portion of the parish inside this State. For that reason, I have put down this amendment that the people mentioned, namely, a clergyman or minister of religion in charge of a parish where the parish is situated on both sides of the Border, should not be debarred from running such a function in the Twenty-Six Counties.
Comment on this
I am in full sympathy with the purpose of the amendment, but I am satisfied that it is not necessary. The Bill as it stands will not interfere with the promotion of gaming at carnivals for the benefit of, say, a charity that clergymen or ministers of religion usually arrange. It is nearly always done by the clergyman's helpers. There may be some doubt as to how particular provisions of the Bill will be uniformly interpreted. It will be necessary to send a comprehensive instruction out to the police, and I shall see that the point made by Senator Walsh will be adverted to in the instructions which I will send to the whole force.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (2), line 46, before "or" to insert "his employees who are in the premises in the ordinary course of their employment, or persons who are resident permanently or temporarily on the premises".
Under Section 9, sub-section (2), the licensee may permit a game of cards to be held in portion of the premises in which intoxicating liquor is not normally sold. The only people who are permitted to play that game under this section would be the licensee or his private friends. I feel that that would exclude other people who are entitled to be on licensed premises after hours, namely those in the employment of the licensee who are there in the ordinary course of their employment, the family of the licensee, and lodgers or guests in an hotel. A guest in an hotel may not be a private friend of the licensee, but still he is entitled to be on those premises at any time of day or night, and, as this section is reenacting Section 30 of the Licensing Act of 1943, I feel that those people should be allowed to be included as able to play cards.
Comment on this
I may be somewhat out of order in saying this, but this sub-section has suggested to my mind a query as to whether provision is made in the Bill to make it lawful, let us say, to play cards for stakes in premises other than licensed premises. I am not quite relevant in raising the point on the section, but, as I read the section and the definition of gaming and look at the exceptions which are made, it seems to me that it is quite possible that there may have been something rather serious overlooked. I am not quite in order in raising that, but I am sure that the Minister will look into it, possibly on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
It would be very unwise to alter the existing law contained in Section 30 of the 1943 Act which we are repeating here and about which we have no complaints whatsoever. There might be very undesirable consequences in altering the position as envisaged in the amendment, and I think we should leave matters as they are at the present time.
Comment on this
The mere fact that there is no complaint simply means that the law is not being enforced. It would be extremely rare to hear of a case where a guest in an hotel was to be prosecuted for playing a game of cards, and I think the House is pretty familiar with the position and with what is common in the country. To take no cognisance of what happens in the country is, in my opinion, a very bad thing. I cannot see why the Minister will not accept the amendment and include those people who can be on the premises at any time and who must from time to time take part in this game of cards.
Comment on this
Under sub-section (3), we are giving permission but the Senator has raised another important point, and I will have it looked into, to see if we can do anything about it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister will see that under sub-section (3) you can have only one stake in the night.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
In sub-section (2), lines 49 and 50, to delete "if the friends are being entertained by him at his own expense".
On the Second Reading of this measure, some of us mentioned that many of its provisions would be found to be unenforceable. The foremost amongst these is the section we are now discussing. Not alone will this section, if enacted in its present form, be unenforceable, but, in my opinion, it will make the whole measure ridiculous. It is necessary to read the sub-section to understand it and see it in its proper perspective. It reads:—
"This section shall not prohibit the licensee or his private friends from playing cards for stakes in a part of the premises other than that in which the sale of intoxicating liquor generally takes place if the friends are being entertained by him at his own expense."
In other words, it appears to me that the only way in which people in rural parts of Ireland can indulge in the favourite pastime of having a game of cards in a room off licensed premises is for the proprietor to put up the stakes himself and those who participate in the game—those who are called "friends" in the section—would not be permitted to put down any stakes. I am totally opposed to this section, as it would cut at the root of social life in rural Ireland, as we know it. It is because I understand what takes place in rural Ireland that I ask the Minister to reconsider this section, and especially the sub-section to which I am referring now.
The Minister may say that already playing a game of cards on licensed premises is unlawful. He must admit that that part of the law is honoured more in the breach than in the observance. Why continue that pretence? Would it not be better to make sure, when we are passing this measure here, that we are doing something that can be enforced? I ask the Minister to consider this very carefully.
Comment on this
It seems to me that, under the Bill as it stands, I am now committing an offence if I play a game of chess with a friend for a shilling in an hotel. I do not know whether that is intended, but apparently we are gaming—because gaming includes a game of skill—and we are playing for money on licensed premises.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister not to press this. If my sizing up of this section is correct, the licensee of premises licensed for the sale of intoxicating liquor shall not permit gaming on the premises. That is sub-section (1), as stated by Senator Kissane. Sub-section (2) says that the "friends" must be entertained at the publican's expense. From my experience, I think you would get very few publicans in Ireland to entertain you at their own expense at this time of the year.
I do not mind admitting that at this time of the year, down in the part of the country to which I belong, there are very few licensed premises where turkey drives do not take place. Many who cannot afford to pay for a turkey would like to have a go for 2/6 in a licensed premises. I would hate to think that if this section is enforced, if I am playing in a licensed premises for a turkey, I am going to incur the displeasure of the law. I do not see any sense in that. As Senator Kissane says, the present law is honoured more in the breach than in the observance. If this is enacted, I cannot see it being enforced in many parts of the country I know of. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider it.
Comment on this
It is a good thing for Senator O'Gorman that this Bill will not come into force before Christmas. My opinion is that it would be a good thing if this particular section did not come into force at all. This sub-section allows the licensed holder to permit his private friends to play games on his premises. As a sub-section, that would be very difficult to enforce. It would be very hard for him to convince the court that certain people were his private friends.
The definition is very peculiar. Apparently the private friends are the people who go in on licensed premises, play cards there, utilise the publican's accommodation, his lighting and heating provisions and "guzzle" his liquor, all at the publican's expense. The public enemies of the publican, apparently, are the poor fellows who remain down in the bar and pay for each drink as they get it. It would be foolish to put such an absurd section as this into the Bill. No one will recognise it and I do not think they should be expected to do so.
The people who enjoy the publican's hospitality, in so far as he provides them with a warm and comfortable room in which to play a game of cards and provides them with lighting and heating, should at least pay for their drinks. There is a saying in the country that if you go into a public-house and accept a drink from the publican, without buying a drink afterwards or in the course of your stay there, you are "taking a slate off the publican's house". This sub-section appears to encourage the complete unroofing of the publican's house, because the only way you can comply with the law, while playing the game of cards, is by making the publican pay for all the drinks. I think that is foolish.
There is nothing radically wrong with people who buy a drink or two in a public-house and enjoy a game of cards. As a matter of fact, it would be a good thing, as people would probably drink less if their minds were occupied by a game of cards during the short period they were there. The section itself is unnecessary and this sub-section is completely unworkable.
Comment on this
I think we will have to leave the law as it stands. It would be undesirable to allow people to play cards in public-houses, because everybody would be the publican's "friend". In the country, everyone who goes in is a friend of the publican—otherwise, he would go into the public-house next door. There would be such a wide interpretation of it that anyone could play cards there. Not alone would the "friends" take the roof off the publican's house, as Senator Cogan said, but they would take the shirt off every innocent fellow in the country—and that is the point we must try to safeguard. The people who administer the law in this country have sufficient sense not to try to stop people playing a half-crown game of cards for a turkey, and I do not think it is necessary to have an Act to give them sanction for doing so.
Comment on this
The only possible case that could be made for this section is, if the Minister could indicate to the House that there is wholesale and serious gambling in public-houses generally. The fact that there may be a few isolated cases does not justify a section like this and only makes lawbreakers out of all the people who go into public-houses. The majority of our public-houses are owned by decent men, men who make a decent living and, besides that, it would be a very bad thing for the Revenue authorities if we had no public-houses in this country.
There is another aspect of this. Suppose a few commercial travellers meet in Cork, or Sligo, or Lifford, or Glenties and, staying in an hotel, decide to have a game of cards, with or without the authority of the proprietor, is it intended to make that sort of thing illegal? The fact that there may be abuses does not justify putting in a section like this. Surely there is enough power under the licensing laws to enable the police to deal with any isolated cases of abuse that may exist. I do not think this section should be passed at all.
Comment on this
We talk a lot in this country about the tourist trade. Unfortunately our climate is not always suitable. As I read the section, it seems to me that if tourists sit down to play a game of bridge for sixpence a hundred in a public-house, they will be breaking the law. That seems to me a ridiculous position to contemplate.
Comment on this
I find myself in agreement with Senator Cogan. I think this section is quite ridiculous. I could never, for instance, understand why it was that we insisted on enshrining in our licensing laws provisions that originated in Great Britain. In most other countries in Europe, it is permissible to play cards on premises, cafés, bars, and so on, in which intoxicating liquor is served. It has often been said, and quite rightly, that the ordinary public-house, or licensed premises, is the club of the average man in this country. I agree with Senator Cogan that there is no reason at all why people should not be permitted to indulge in the social amenity of playing cards on licensed premises. So far as Senator Burke is concerned, may I tell him that I have many a time played cards on licensed premises and never lost my shirt, or anything else.
Comment on this
I merely restate what is in the 1943 Licensing Act. This is a Bill designed, as far as possible, to prevent gaming. It is not designed to encourage gaming. Senator O'Gorman spoke about the half-crown game of cards for a turkey in a rural public-house. The Act which prevents that has been in operation since 1872. I am not going to enshrine in the Act permission for card playing in public-houses which would attract professional and expert sharks from the city who would join in games with men from rural areas who might have taken too much liquor. The game would then become, not the innocent game of cards that Senator Crosbie talked about, but gaming of the very worst type.
If Senators would look at it from that angle they would see that it would be better to remain as we are at present and not encourage gaming in public-houses. If we want to do that, it would be better to change the licensing laws. The licensing laws have been in operation for a long time and we have not heard of dreadful things happening, like men being prosecuted for playing cards for a turkey. There have been exaggerations on one side and I could exaggerate the picture about what I think would happen if profesional sharks were to engage in such games. We all know the difficulties stewards have at rural whist drives where prizes are in the vicinity of £50. The experts come along from outside and the stewards have to watch the various tables to see that these boys will not be able to secure the prizes they came down for.
Comment on this
We are not here concerned with professional sharks who may go down the country from time to time for the purpose of fleecing the innocent people there, but I should remind the Minister that these professional sharks could travel in any case to halls and places where these games are being conducted and where there is no question of gaming taking place on a licensed premises. I want to emphasise that the enactment of this section in its present form will seriously interfere with the social life of the community. In the winter time, the people living in rural Ireland have no other enjoyment than to meet at licensed premises for a game of cards —a "rubber", as they call it—sometimes for 6d. or 1/- a rubber, and have a few drinks at the same time. That is how they pass their winter nights. I hold that the people living in rural Ireland are as much entitled to their enjoyment as the people living in the cities who can go to the theatres, opera and such entertainments.
I wonder do the people of the country realise what we are doing here this evening? I do not think they do. If the people living in rural Ireland were to realise what we are doing here this evening, in putting a section into an Act depriving them of long-established rights they had, in spite of the licensing laws, to have a game of cards at night in a room off a licensed premises, they would be up in arms against us. I ask the Minister to reconsider this section.
Comment on this
May I also appeal to the Minister to reconsider this section? It seems to me that the issues involved are really rather far-reaching. They go a good deal further than the mere section itself. We have had previous occasions over the past 30 years when the public were lightly tampered with by the Legislature, without full consideration of the consequences. Acts have been passed in the Oireachtas rather lightly and without very full consideration, and in the end they have very far-reaching consequences and have exposed the individual in the country to a good deal of interference with his freedom. In some cases, they have almost held us up to ridicule abroad as being ultra-puritanical. I suggest this is a very far-reaching section.
Comment on this
We are not dealing with the section at the moment. We are dealing with amendment No. 19.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I thought I was dealing with the same subject as the previous speaker. I said nothing so far that was not said by a previous speaker. It seems to me that this section might hold us up to ridicule abroad in the eyes of tourists as being an ultra-puritanical country whose citizens could not be trusted to relax in the way that people normally do in other countries. I can quite see the reason for prohibiting such games as roulette and games of chance in licensed premises, but to say that two people in a room at 10 o'clock playing a game of chess are breaking the law, with the danger of the publican's licence being endorsed, seems to me to be going rather far. It is the sort of thing we should not do without full consideration of all the consequences.
With regard to sharks, one would think that the sharks only existed in licensed premises and that a person who is perfectly right elsewhere becomes a shark when he enters a licensed premises. If the community is to be protected against sharks, a great deal more will have to be done than preventing games of chess on licensed premises. A person who is a shark in a licensed premises does not become a harmless minnow elsewhere. If we allow this to pass without full consideration, we will do something which may expose the country to ridicule abroad. It is a far-reaching interference with the right of the public and the holders of publicans' licences. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider the matter.
Comment on this
I want to add my voice also to the objections raised to this section. I listened very carefully to the case made by the Minister for the insertion of the section. As far as I could gather, the only reason he could advance was the fact that similar provisions obtain in regard to licensed premises. I can see no justification for the retention of provisions of this kind in new legislation. The Minister ought to consider the matter very carefully.
Comment on this
If the Minister was in a position to give proof of there being a glaring abuse, well and good, but he did not do that. Instead, he referred to a species of fish—a shark. There is no use in the Minister frightening people down the country with talk about sharks.
Comment on this
They could swim down the Shannon or the canal. There is no use trying to frighten us in regard to sharks coming to local public-houses and skinning us.
Comment on this
I do not play cards myself. I have enough of other vices.
Comment on this
The only other point was that there is already provision in the licensing Acts. That makes the matter much worse—passing legislation that cannot be enforced at all. That is the most ridiculous thing that could be suggested. If it is ever to be enforced, it could be enforced now and again and oftentimes decent people would be open to persecution and prosecution. There is a duty on this House to protect the people from that sort of thing. I certainly cannot agree with the section.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
I do not know whether or not the Senator intends to press this amendment. As I see it, this amendment touches a small portion of the section, but it would, I think, if carried, ensure that at least one source of abuse would be removed. I think it would be entirely wrong to have a situation in which a sort of class distinction, if you like, would be introduced. A few ordinary workingmen or farmers playing cards in the public bar—a place where drink is sold— would be prohibited; but a select few would, apparently, be permitted, under this sub-section, to play cards in the residential portion of the licensed premises, or, as others have pointed out, in the portions of an hotel which are not ordinarily used for the sale of drink.
There is also the danger that, as has been pointed out, people found playing cards other than on the portion of the licensed premises where drink is sold could be charged with violating the law on the ground that, legally, they were consuming drink being supplied to them by the publican. It would be difficult to produce conclusive evidence in order, in the first place, to sustain a prosecution and, secondly, to prove innocence. There is no documentary evidence of sales in a public-house and a publican could sell drink to people playing cards, perhaps in places on his licensed premises not ordinarily used for the consumption of drink, and it would be very hard to prove. Therefore, we would have a lot of evasion of the law and perhaps violation of the whole spirit of the law.
The playing of a game of cards is an innocent form of amusement that is indulged in possibly in every country and private house throughout the State. The case made by the Minister is that certain professional sharks would avail of the freedom given to play cards in licensed premises to "rook" people who, perhaps, might be under the influence of drink. I do not think there is any substance in that. If people want to cheat in those games, they can do it anywhere there is a public game. Most adult people are well able to take care of themselves. The idea of sharks coming to Baltinglass, Tullow or Hacketstown, or places I know, and "rooking" the local people is a little absurd. It is the shark who would go back without his hide. I think there is no purpose in the section. If the Minister would consider on the Report Stage legalising an innocent game of cards in a public-house, I do not see what harm could be done. So far as this amendment is concerned, it seeks to ensure that something should be deleted from the section which could not reasonably be enforced.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Minister has changed his mind in connection with this amendment. I would like to inform the Seanad that I would not have put it down, were I not aware of the fact that we are now, by positive action, doing something that could gravely interfere with the social life of the people, especially in rural Ireland. All of us who come from the country realise that meeting in a country village, or in a house in a provincial town, is a very usual practice, for the purpose of having a harmless game of cards, and, were it not for that pastime the people of the country have, I do not know what they would turn their minds to.
The Minister has mentioned the Licensing Act of 1872. In other words, he is going back almost a century to provide some justification, and a hazy justification it is, for this section that I seek to amend. The people of the country have only a hazy knowledge of the 1872 Act, and, as I have said, it has been honoured all down through the years more in the breach than in the observance. We have now come to the point that the people hardly realise that such an Act is there at all.
The conditions that obtained almost a century ago in the country are not the conditions that obtain to-day. We are living in a different age. We live in an age when people want to have some sort of social life, and the only way the people of the country can have social life is by meeting now and then legitimately, within the legitimate hours, in a licensed premises to have a game of cards for which they put down stakes. I want Senators to bear in mind, and I want the country to bear in mind, that if this Bill is passed in its present form, and if this amendment of mine is not accepted, we are taking positive steps to deprive the people of the country of the right to forgather in a private room in a licensed premises for a game of cards. If that is not totalitarian legislation, I do not know what it is.
Comment on this
There are just two points I would like to make in reference to this amendment. One of them has already been made by the Minister, that this section of the Bill introduces nothing new. The second point I want to make is that the reason for the former position under the licensing code was to prevent publicans, as such, running entertainments, such as games of cards, to entice people into public-houses. I am surprised to hear Senator Kissane say that that was the only social life in the country towns and that, because of that, we should give every encouragement to our young people and our old people to forgather in public-houses, to entice them in by allowing games of cards to be played, entice them into what some people would imagine would be an occasion for people to take strong liquor.
I have no objection to people taking strong liquor, but I think it is against social conscience that we should entice them by these amusements. If a person wants to drink, the public-houses are open during the licensed hours, and sometimes after it. I think Senator Kissane is overstating the case when he implies that the Minister is putting a very rigorous and a very penal clause in the Bill. I want to emphasise that the former position is really being carried on and that to delete the section in the Bill does not meet the issue at all.
I do not think the Senator is really in earnest in suggesting that we should allow gambling in public-houses. It is all very well to say it is a quite harmless social amusement. It can be, I suppose, quite harmless, but the Senator will accept that it could provide a dangerous occasion in many country towns. I suggest that he should not pursue this matter further.
Comment on this
I am singularly unqualified in the matter of public-houses and in the matter of gaming. My acquaintance with public-houses is outside Dublin and is almost entirely confined to the Irish language.
Perhaps I am not well able to read this Bill. I agree that all this section is already in existing legislation, but, if amendment No. 19 were accepted, would it make any difference to the working of the Bill? Sub-section (2) says that this section shall not prohibit the licensee or his private friends from playing cards for stakes in part of the premises other than that in which the sale of intoxicating liquor takes place. I wonder would it be any different if it stopped there, or went on to include the words "if the friends are being entertained by him at his own expense". I doubt very much that it would, in practice, make any difference. I suggest that the Minister might reconsider that point of view.
Perhaps people, in arguing for an amendment of this kind, sometimes go a little too far, but, if the Minister were to reconsider it, we will have a Report Stage on this Bill after Christmas, and Senators will be aware in time whether the Minister is putting down an amendment of his own, and, on the next stage, we can reconsider this matter in the light of the discussion that has taken place this evening from all sides of the House.
Comment on this
As this debate has gone on, one becomes more and more confused as to what really the effect of Section 9 is to be. Apparently it applies to all licensed premises, and that means it applies to hotels, to a club which has a licence, and to any place which has a licence. Having reached that point, it forbids any gaming on those premises, and gaming is defined as anything, whether it is pure skill or chance, or partly skill and partly chance, which is played for a stake; so that solemnly this section as it stands, as I have said previously, forbids one playing chess for a stake, forbids one playing any ordinary card game of skill in a club, forbids one playing a card game of skill in an hotel, forbids the tourists who come here to play a game of bridge in their hotel. And the answer given, when that is pointed out, is that this has always been the law. I am not at all sure that it has been the law always, though I agree that there is a similar provision in the licensing law, but I think that that has been applied as regards licensed premises that would be called public-houses.
It seems to me that there is another side of this. Like Senator Hayes, I do not know much about public-houses, but I have observed in the course of my few travels abroad that, in England, the public-house does seem to be a much more pleasant sort of place than the public-house here, and that very largely seems to be because it is used as a sort of club and people play games — darts and such games. I have never taken a drink, but I have been in public-houses in London and elsewhere in the evening, and I must say that they present a picture which is quite different from anything one associates with an Irish public-house, and that is entirely due to the fact that games are allowed there. It seems to me that there is a great deal in this section which requires further thought. I cannot suggest a few words that will make everything right, and I think the Minister should consider this much more closely than has been done.
Comment on this
First of all, I should like to refer to Senator Murphy's interpretation of what I said. I think he interpreted my words to mean that the people of the country had no other pastime but going into public-houses. I did not want to convey any such thing. What I wanted to convey is that it is a common practice among people in the country to meet socially, and if they want to meet socially, where there is not a parish hall, the only place they can meet is in a public-house, if they want to have a game of cards. It is usual also for those people to have a few drinks in the course of their game, but, if this amendment is not accepted, they will not be able to pay for their few drinks and it would be the proprietor who would have to pay for the whole lot. He cannot be expected to do it. If these people will not be able to indulge in a game of cards, they will be tempted, in that case, to bend their steps towards the bar and drink more than they would have, if they went for the game, so that the alleged evil we seek to remove will be intensified and made worse.
There are also, of course, as Senator Cox has mentioned, other games that can be played, and are played, in licensed premises — games of darts and rings — and it appears to me that they would also be outlawed under this section.
Comment on this
Of course, they do play for stakes, and some will not play at all if they do not have little stakes because they can have an added interest in the game.
Comment on this
Yes, and do you not know that the winner then has to stand a round of drinks?
Comment on this
That may or may not be the practice, but in any case the money passes, and when money passes, when there is a charge, then it comes under this section. However, I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter and, as Senator Hayes has said, perhaps he may find between this and the Report Stage that there is a lot of common sense in what we have been saying here this evening.
Comment on this
The position is that at the present time it is illegal, as some of the legal gentlemen know, to play cards in licensed premises. We are giving permission under this section to play. Senator Kissane speaks about the harmless game. If he reads sub-section (3), harmless games such as a game of bridge are permitted. However, to meet the Senator's wishes, and as I think it is the desire of everybody to have a good gaming Bill which would have the approval of the public, not of any individual, I undertake to consider the matter carefully for the Report Stage and to submit my decision to the Senators who have spoken to enable them to put in any amendment they may require on the Report Stage. But I am giving no guarantee that I am accepting the amendment in any way.
Comment on this
We have given notice of our intention to oppose this section, but, in view of what the Minister has now said, we will withdraw our opposition.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
In sub-section (1), line 12, to add "except for a period beginning on May 1st and extending to September 30th, at seaside resorts, and where the stake does not exceed 1d. and where the number of machines does not exceed 15".
The amendment proposes that the playing of slot-machines at a seaside resort will be legal, within limits. This section of the Bill makes all slot machines illegal. I agree that some amount of control of these machines and the playing of them was necessary, but I think that the section goes too far. The amendment would enable amusement caterers to have slot-machines of a gaming type available during the tourist season at seaside resorts for a very limited stake. We in this country pay a great deal of attention to our tourist trade. We are constantly trying to find ways and means of making tourists interested in coming to our seaside resorts. Nobody in the House can deny that slot-machines are a popular form of entertainment. If they were not a popular form of entertainment, there would be no need to mention them in the Bill as being banned.
The major complaint I have always heard was that they were unfair and that the person who played had not a fair chance of winning. The Minister made that one of his reasons for limiting the stake at "pongo" and other games and he said that that type of gaming did not give a person a fair chance and he wished to discourage it. Slot-machines must be a very fair form of gambling, because so many play them, but I believe it is necessary to control them. The amusement people maintain that the slot-machines are the shop window of the arcade and, without them, they would not get customers to come in and use the other games.
There was a lot of talk about "pongo" and the 10/- limit, and the Minister seemed to think that, if the stake were limited to 6d., one would have a considerable length of interest in the play. I am assured you can lose 6d. in two and a half minutes at "pongo", but if you play 6d. in a penny slot-machine, you will have 30 to 50 minutes playing, depending on the luck you have.
If we ban the slot-machines from the ordinary people, I would ask the Minister to consider making them available to tourists at seaside resorts. The main argument against the use of these machines in towns was that people played with their husbands' wages, or men played with their own wages; but, at seaside resorts, people are spending not their normal housekeeping money but money saved up for a holiday and they should be entitled to spend it in what way they think best. If they think the slot-machine is the best way in which to spend the holiday money which they have saved up, I do not think we have any right to stop them. People who run amusements in Tramore and Bray tell me that the slot-machine is very popular, that many people come to Ireland to have a flutter and that their idea of a flutter is to play the slots. It seems to me that having lost 6d. in two and a half minutes on a legal game of "pongo", one should not be told one cannot lose a penny on a slot-machine. I do not see any sense in banning them completely and I would ask the Minister to consider favourably the amendment I have suggested.
Comment on this
I take it the Senator is also discussing amendment No. 39 on this.
Comment on this
I support Senator Bergin's case for this exemption. When the stake was 6d., it constituted a danger that an excessive amount might be lost, particularly as the slot-machines were in practically every town and were used regardless of the season of the year. They were then a strong temptation to indulgence in gambling. Where they are in seaside resorts and when the stake is only 1d., there is not much danger of abuse and they would be an attraction in those places. Our peculiar climate does not always favour holiday-makers and some seaside places can be very dull. Those who have saved money for a holiday may find the time hanging heavily on their hands and may like to spend a few hours at this pastime, which would augment the other attractions.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. The slot-machines are a form of gambling, but a mild and popular form, and it would be strange if visitors to places like Tramore could not indulge in that amusement, in a country which has betting shops at every corner.
Comment on this
If a case is made for slot-machines, surely the percentage limitation suggested for "pongo" would be even more necessary in this case? Tourists would be attracted then by the feeling that they would get good value for the penny put in. As a young lad, I used to play the slot-machines and always felt I got very bad value. I am sure the percentage profit is enormous. There should be a limit on the profit which could be made by the owner. I understand the machines can be set for that purpose and, if they are allowed here, they should be inspected by the weights and measures inspectors, to see that people get a fair run for their money. I myself would abhor that form of amusement.
Comment on this
Sub-section (3) says:—
"This section does not apply to a machine which is designed for amusement only and, when successfully operated, delivers no more than the amount of the stake and bears a notice explaining that it is of that kind."
It seems from that that the slot machines are not being eliminated altogether.
I wonder what a "seaside resort" is under this amendment. As the tide comes in to Dublin, could Dublin not be one? In the poorer sections of the city, you have, in every huckster's shop, one of those "one-armed gangsters", as they have been called. I never noticed any tourists coming in there to amuse themselves, but I did notice the kids of the neighbourhood putting in a few pennies and pulling the handle each time they came on a message for their parents — and I never saw any of them win anything.
If we are in earnest about overcoming these evils, the provision in sub-section (3) is quite sufficient. They are of no encouragement to tourists and I am strongly in favour of their elimination. There is ample provision in the sub-section and the Seanad should not go any further.
Comment on this
Senator Murphy is quite right when he points out that slot-machines are not prohibited under the Bill. They are prohibited, only if they give a cash return. If they give prizes such as cigarettes or a small box of chocolates, they are allowed under the Bill. It is where they give the cash return which is more than the stake, or where there is the promise of such cash return, that they are prohibited.
I want to point out that opinion of all sections of the community was against cash slot-machines and this Government were united in the view that so long as they are responsible for the affairs of the State in any part of the country coming under their jurisdiction, they will not allow cash slot-machines.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
To add a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) This section does not apply to a licensed arcade, amusement hall or funfair where the ratio of slot-machines to gaming instruments is not greater than one to four and where the stake used to operate machines is not more than one penny.
The amendment proposes to allow the use of such slot-machines at funfairs and arcades. The use of machines in those circumstances would not be harmful to anybody. Some speakers were inclined to think that these machines should be rubbed out. I think, as Senator Bergin has stated, that there should be some means evolved to allow the slot-machines to continue in some form or other. I think that some provision could be made for a limited number of these slot-machines at places such as funfairs and arcades, and it would not be harmful to anybody, but would be a source of attraction to the people who ordinarily go to these places, particularly at seaside resorts. I should like the Minister to consider allowing them in some form of ratio, say a ratio of four to one. In other words, if there were five gaming tables one of them could be a slot-machine.
The Minister has, of course, stated that the Government is not prepared to tolerate these machines, if they are to be used for cash purposes, but would be prepared to tolerate them for prizes in kind. Might I ask the Minister to permit these slot-machines to be used at funfairs and arcades and seaside resorts for the purposes of prizes in kind or if it is possible that that point could be got round by permitting prizes in the form of discs or chits? This is the point I want to get at. The Minister says you cannot have cash prizes, but does that mean that you can have any other sort of prize? I think we should have some arrangement by which the player would get a disc for which he would receive a prize on presentation of the disc at the counter and I put forward the suggestion because I believe it would be a desirable addition to the Bill.
Comment on this
I have already explained on Senator Bergin's amendment that the Government will not tolerate these slot-machines used for cash prizes. If there was a provision for discs or chits, they could be changed for cash. There is nothing in the Bill to prevent the use of slot-machines which give prizes in kind. It is the unanimous decision of the Government to prohibit other uses of these machines, as they have been prohibited in other countries. These machines have given considerable trouble in the past and various decisions have been given from time to time by district justices in connection with them. The chit or disc would be just an easy way of getting round the Act and giving a cash return. We will not allow their use for that purpose.
Comment on this
How is it proposed to make sure that the operator of the slot-machines will get the prizes indicated? Is there any means by which that can be done? If I get a disc from a machine, when I go to the counter, I am supposed to get, for instance, a set of china, but I could get a £5 note instead.