We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Gaming and Lotteries Bill, 1955—Committee Stage.

Contributions 169–340 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Gaming and Lotteries Bill, 1955
Enacted

No. 6 of 1955 ›

I do not think you would get any such prize.

Comment on this

Slot-machines are allowed, provided they do not return more than the stake.

Comment on this

The amendment is more or less on the lines of that proposed by Senator Bergin, and I suggest that the use of slot-machines could be allowed to a limited extent to supplement other amusements in funfairs and arcades. I do not think, from reading the section, that it gives the Minister the powers he suggests; that is, the power to allow the use of slot-machines for the return of prizes in kind. So far as I can see, these machines are to be allowed for amusement only and the successful operator can get no more than the amount of his stake. I do not think, in those circumstances, it could be regarded as an attraction in any way. At least everybody who places a stake likes to get a small benefit, if successful. I think if the Minister would accept this amendment, with safeguards, he would be doing a useful service.

I can see objections to the use of slot-machines to any great extent by children and regulations might be made to prevent that. I would not be in favour of children being permitted to take part to any extent in gaming on slot-machines. There should be some safeguards, but, at the same time, I do not think it right to rule these machines out altogether. I think some amendment should be made to this section to provide that the prizes in kind would be something more than the amount of the stake. It could be a limited figure but it should provide some inducement.

Comment on this

I think that experience has shown that these machines ought to be restricted, for the person operating them has got only a 100 to 1 chance of getting any return. I remember on one occasion working one of these machines and putting in 48 pennies without any result. The only benefit these machines might have would be to develop the biceps in the pulling of the lever. I agree they are only there for the purpose of racketeering on an innocent public and I agree they should be abolished.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. I cannot see that slot-machines are such a terrible danger that they should be abolished altogether. Under sub-section (3) of Section 10, we allow people to play these machines for prizes in kind. Every penny goes back to the person who owns the machines. He has all the profit but the person who plays the machine has no chance whatever.

These slot-machines are popular. There is no doubt about that. Senator O'Gorman was tempted one time and actually spent 4/-. If he spent 4/-, he must have played the machine for an hour. The people who visit our amusement centres like our slot-machines and we should try to meet them as far as we can without hurting our own people. The people who go on holidays go to spend the money they have saved up. It is only in respect of the tourist resorts that we want this permission. At the present time, if anybody goes to Tramore, Bundoran, or Bray, he will see that there is not a single slot-machine in operation. The tourist likes to play the slot-machines. I think we should allow people to spend their money in the way they enjoy best.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

I refuse to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

In view of the Minister's attitude, I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

At column 698, Volume 45, No. 8, of the Official Debates of the 23rd November, 1955, the Minister stated:—

"I have no doubt, however, that if the local authority of a particular place indicates, by way of resolution, its view that licences should be issued only for the holiday season or a specified period of a year the District Court concerned, when hearing applications, would take cognisance of such a view."

The District Court is the licensing authority, and as the local authority will be a noticing party in all applications to the District Court for certificates for licences, as in the case of dance-hall licences, it could decide when and when not a certificate should be issued by the court. The court will take into consideration their objections. Once this part of the Bill is adopted by the local authority, it appears to be completely unnecessary to go through the expensive and cumbersome procedure set out in Sections 12 and 13, which necessitates at least two advertisements in each of two papers and the calling, possibly, of a special meeting of the local authority.

The District Court will be the body which will decide ultimately whether or not the certificate to enable a licence to be issued will be granted. The District Court, therefore, will hear the representations which have to be made to the local authority. I feel it is unnecessary to include Sections 12 and 13 of the Bill. While I, as a solicitor, may earn a certain amount of money by the procedure which is set out in the Bill, I feel the procedure is unnecessary and that it is the District Court which is the proper body to deal with this matter.

Comment on this

At a time when we have appeals from all over the country to give greater powers to public representatives, surely now is the time when these public representatives should have a right to say that they object. As I explained on the Second Reading, music is being played until 1 o'clock in the morning at seaside places to the annoyance of a number of visitors. I explained before that I received letters of complaints in this connection. Deputies put questions down in the House in connection with the objections raised by traders in Talbot Street where loud music interferes with the traders from early morning until very late at night. All the public bodies need do is to agree to allow amusements into an area and certify they have a right to go before the district-justice. I think no citizen will object to giving a right to a public body and then appeal to the district justice. Once the public body decides by resolution, it cannot rescind it, and the amusement caterer can get his rights from the district justice.

There is opposition from traders in Talbot Street. I have received letters. I have personal knowledge of the situation in some seaside places where people going for a rest after illness complain about juke boxes and loudspeakers going on until midnight and 1 o'clock in the morning. The public bodies have no remedy and we have no remedy. Now the public bodies can say they object to any noise or music after 12 o'clock. We are giving that right to the public bodies. I am sure that the Senator, on reflection, will agree it is right that public representatives should have a say in deciding where amusements should be held. One would not like to have amusements in Glendalough, for instance, and the public body would have the right to say that they will not allow amusement caterers to go into Glendalough. The district justice will take notice of the fact that the public authority has made that objection and will stipulate that amusements will not be allowed there. I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

The whole point is that the local authorities either adopt or do not adopt the sections. If they do adopt the sections, then at least they have control. It is a matter then for the District Court to grant or not to grant the certificate. The representation which the local authority will make to the court will be taken into consideration. If the local authority suggest that they should stop at 12 o'clock, and so forth, the Minister has already indicated that the court will take cognisance of that representation. Even if Sections 12 and 13 were deleted, notice must be given to the local authority 28 days before the application is made. The local authority can then decide whether they should object to the application, or whether they should suggest to the court that the court should impose certain restrictions on the granting of the certificate.

The sections which I suggest should be deleted simply give the local authority the power either to adopt or not to adopt the Act. If the sections are not adopted by the local authority, then the matter cannot come before the District Court at all. In the case of a large county such as Donegal, while a county councillor in Ballyshannon may feel that the licence should be granted, a county councillor in Moville — which is 80 or 90 miles away — may feel that it should not be granted. However, you must take the decision at a meeting of the local authority.

Comment on this

I should like to support a point made by Senator Walsh in regard to a large county. The Minister makes the case that the local representatives should have a say in this matter as to whether or not an amusement hall should be opened. In the operation of this section, however, it may be that the representatives of a district affected by this particular amusement may desire to have it in their district, but the majority of the council, who are not perhaps interested in it at all, may decide against it, and thus the wishes of the local representatives would be frustrated.

It would be different, of course, in the case of an urban area or a county borough, but, in regard to a county council of a large county, this could operate very unfairly as far as the district concerned would be affected.

I should also like to ask the Minister, in connection with this section, whether the section, if passed, and assuming that the county council of a county decides not to bring it into operation, means that no travelling amusement caterers can enter that county. If it does, it seems a very serious restriction. Very often, there are amusement caterers — even apart from carnivals or anything else that is locally organised — who operate and travel from one county to another. Would they be prohibited from entering a county which had declined or refused to bring this part of the Act into operation?

Comment on this

Take, as Senator Walsh suggested, a large county such as Donegal, or any county you care to mention. A licence may be granted and there may be restriction in relation to certain areas. Some persons may feel aggrieved and, in fact, it is quite possible that a county council might have a grievance against a certain area. They might not just like the county councillor from that area and say: "We will not include that area." That is possible. In my view, when granting the permission, they ought to give the reasons why they are granting the permission. If people feel aggrieved, I think they ought to be entitled to bring the matter before the district justice, but only in a case where an Order is granted. If the local authority decide they will not grant any licence, I think the aggrieved person should not be entitled to bring the matter before the district justice. Where, however, they grant a licence with a restriction, I feel that anyone who feels aggrieved ought to be entitled to bring the matter before the district justice.

I quite agree that, in a place such as Glendalough, it would destroy the whole tradition of the district to set up amusements and, in my opinion, that would be a reasonable ground for the granting of a limited licence to a county such as Wicklow. That is the only difficulty I can see. There is a very great safeguard. The following season the local authority can always withdraw the licence for the whole area, if they feel that any abuse has taken place of the privilege which they are entitled to grant.

Comment on this

I find it difficult to understand why the principle of local option is introduced merely for this particular part of this Bill, or for this Bill alone. It seems to me that the idea is rather objectionable. Quite apart from that, however, assuming that the local authority does vote in favour of such licences, I think it will be a very difficult matter for the district justice to refuse applications because he will be faced, straight off, with the general approval by the local authority. The result might easily be that in a particular area far more licences would be granted by the court than would be desirable. In my view, this joint business of approval by the local authority and then application to the court will raise quite a series of difficulties and strange reactions.

Comment on this

I just want to make a suggestion about the difficulties mentioned by Senators in relation to large counties. I suggest the difficulty could easily be surmounted by leaving the matter, instead of to the county, to the electoral area concerned. In County Roscommon, matters that concern the various electoral areas are very often left to the members of the respective electoral areas to decide. In my view, the objections expressed by Senators in regard to a large county could be simplified if electoral areas were substituted, instead of the whole county.

Comment on this

The local authority, say, for Donegal can adopt it for Ballyshannon and decide that if the people of Bundoran make a petition to the local authority not to allow the funfairs in Bundoran——

Comment on this

Bundoran would be an urban area.

Comment on this

Senator Cogan mentioned travelling shows. This does not affect travelling shows at all — only amusement halls and funfairs. Our original intention was to have it only for tourist resorts. The question then arose of a definition of "tourist resorts": we had to go back to the original position. Take, for instance, Dublin Corporation. They know the wishes of the people of the city and — representing, as they do, the people of the city — naturally they are entitled to decide, and they do decide, whether or not they will allow an amusement hall in a particular place. The least we may do is to give the local authority —we have been appealing a lot on behalf of local authorities — the right to interpret the wishes of the people in the area and to say what the people desire. I know that many of the public bodies put in advertisements to try to get amusements into their area during the summer time. If they are interested in tourism, they do everything they possibly can to attract visitors, and I do not think it is right that we should deny the right to, say, the City of Dublin to decide what they think their people desire. That is all I ask, that we should give the right to public representatives to decide whether a particular amusement should be allowed or not.

Comment on this

Not a particular amusement, but a particular area.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the suggestion put forward by Senator Meighan that, instead of each county council deciding for the entire county, the decision be taken by each electoral area separately?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are dealing now with Section 12. I hope the House appreciates that. We are not dealing with Section 13.

Comment on this

I would ask you to take the two sections together.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We have been discussing them.

Comment on this

I am prepared to withdraw.

Comment on this

This is only a drafting amendment. Since the Local Government Act, 1955, became law a short time ago, all town commissioners are bodies corporate and the words which the amendment seeks to have struck out are no longer necessary.

This amendment gives me an opportunity of clarifying a point raised on the Second Reading. It was suggested that there was no provision for the adoption of this part of the Bill in a town which had not an urban council. That is not so. The definition of "local authority" in Section 2 includes town commissioners. There are, of course, small towns which have no commissioners, but they are not towns as defined in the Local Government Acts and, under this Bill, it would be for the county council to adopt or not to adopt the provisions in relation to them.

Comment on this

I raised that on the Second Reading, as to what was meant by this definition of a town. The Bill implies a definition under the Local Government Act under which a town is any town with town commissioners. I think under this section the decision taken by the county council should not cover the whole county. I know that there is provision for the exclusion of areas, but I think each electoral area should have the right to decide its own destiny.

Comment on this

I have noticed this only now. A local authority may move such a resolution and it may rescind it. It is provided that evidence of the passing of the resolution may be given in court by the production of a copy of the newspaper containing the notice. I think it should be certified under seal of the council which passes the resolution, and that the court should not be bound to accept a copy of the newspaper, without knowing whether there has been a rescinding of the resolution or not. The procedure provided by the Bill seems to me to be a very slack way of dealing with the matter. After all, this is an important matter and surely the proper procedure would be to say that a certificate under the seal of the local authority would be required. It is, of course, the business of the person making the application to the district justice to give proof of the passing of the resolution, but it seems strange that he should be able to do that by picking up a copy of an old newspaper and producing it to the district justice.

Comment on this

Its purpose is merely to produce evidence for the court against a person who suggests that the public body has not passed the resolution. It is to rebut evidence.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should consider that on the Report Stage, because it does seem a very loose way of doing it. I suggest that evidence should be given in the proper way, that is, under the seal of the local authority.

Comment on this

The matter dealt with in my amendment No. 23 has already been raised, and I am prepared to accept the Minister's undertaking that he will reconsider this matter on the Report Stage. The same would apply, Sir, to amendment No. 24.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:—

In paragraph (d), line 12, to delete "ten shillings" and substitute "thirty shillings".

I think that the maximum prize of 10/- is too small because, in the operation of some of these games, you have, in certain cases, as many as 100 people playing a game and each giving 6d. as a contribution. In less than ten minutes, that game can be over and, 10/- being the maximum prize, it means that the promoter receives £2 out of that pool of 50/-. I think that is too much and I think I am entitled to suggest to the Minister, with respect, that the prize should be 30/-, in which case the promoter would only take 20/-. If these games are operated with a maximum prize of 10/-, it means that, at the end of 12 or 14 hours' operation, the takings of the operator would be fantastic. Any person who participates in a game of that nature should be protected by us and should be entitled, as one of the participants, to a fair share of what we call "the pool". I think, Sir, that my proposal is reasonable and I ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this

I have discussed this with showmen and amusement caterers and they agree that 10/- is sufficient for amusement only.

There are only a few halls in Dublin whose owners are anxious to have a higher prize to induce people to remain longer and spend their money in the hope of getting the larger prize. There is no demand, outside a few owners of halls in Dublin, to increase the prize beyond 10/-. The Senator will agree that to do so would defeat the purpose of the Bill. If we are to try not to make gambling popular and not to give an inducement to people who can ill-afford it to spend their money, in the hope of getting large prizes, we should confine it to 10/-, and you will not then have such an inducement there. It is with the wishes of the genuine amusement caterers that we have included 10/- as the maximum prize.

Comment on this

I respectfully ask why would not the amusement proprietors say: "Keep the prize to 10/-"? They also are participants in the gambling as are the speculators, and they would very naturally expect the prize to be limited to 10/-, because their profits will be greater. I again ask the Minister to reconsider that point, and, at the risk of repeating myself, I must say that I merely want to try to make the game reasonable, make the profits reasonable and make the chances reasonable. The Minister must have had at one time or another a flutter and he must know that, in present circumstances, these people would come and ask him to keep the prize down to 10/-. If it goes to 30/-, you reduce their profit to £1. I will simply go over the thing again: if 100 people play this game, all contributing 6d. each, that produces 50/-. The Minister tells you that you must not receive any prize money more than 10/-, and that gives the promoter a profit of £2. That £2 can be earned by the promoter in a matter of five or ten minutes. A game may last an hour, but you could average it out over a quarter of an hour. That is £8 an hour, 12 hours a day— not bad. I suggest that it should be made 30/-.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

The answer to that, I suppose, is that I will withdraw it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:—

In sub-section (1), line 20, after "funfair" to add "where a certificate of suitability of the premises has been issued by the local authority".

I am moving this amendment on behalf of Senator Hawkins. A local authority are a notice party, and one of the reasons they should be is the fact that they will be responsible for the safety of the building in which the funfair may be held. Likewise, a local authority are a notice party in connection with applications for dance-hall licences. It would be desirable that an engineer on behalf of that authority should attend the court and give a certificate as to whether or not the premises are suitable for the function. There may be a danger to public life. There may be certain fire safety precautions that should be taken into consideration. For that reason, if the amendment is not accepted, it means that a funfair may be held on premises which are a danger to life and limb, and not suitable for the public.

Comment on this

Again, we had to consider the wishes of the people in the rural areas. The Senator may be quite right, but a local authority may not wish to exercise their powers as, maybe, some small amusement caterer may want to use for the time being a wooden structure and would be there only for a short time. They may not desire to send an engineer and have an inspection, and for that reason we left in the Bill a right to the local authority to use their discretion at a particular time as to whether it would be necessary to prohibit that particular place from having a funfair or not.

Comment on this

The local authority would be notified at least 28 days before an application is made to the District Court, and therefore would have ample time to ascertain if the building in which it was proposed to carry on the funfair is suitable or not. It is not unreasonable, therefore, to ask the local authority to produce that certificate to the court, so that the court will be in the position of knowing that there is no danger to the public who are to participate.

Comment on this

The Senator must know that a local authority may not wish to have a meeting at the particular time; therefore, I do not want to compel the local authority, where they so decide, to go into court. I want to give them self-determination, to decide for themselves in the circumstances of a particular case, whether they should go into court or not. The Senator may find that in his own area there may be a structure, and, while it would not comply with all the sections of the local authority, the local authority might find that it would not meet the wishes of the people to deprive the locality of amusement for the time being. Therefore, we have decided not to put anything in the Act to compel the local authority to do something which they may decide themselves not to do.

Comment on this

Might this difficulty not be met by adding in sub-section (4) of Section 15 a power to the court to attach conditions as to the condition of the premises? That would seem to me to be a very natural thing and would bring such premises into line with other public premises.

Comment on this

The local authority will surely give evidence, if, in their opinion, the premises are not suitable.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

(7) A caterer who has been operating as such in the same premises for a period of ten years or more shall be granted a certificate by the court on proving that he has complied with the other requirements of the Act.

I want to provide by this amendment that a caterer or operator who has been operating in a premises for a period of ten years or greater shall not be subjected to applying to a court or elsewhere for continuity in the premises. The Minister should consider that old-established premises ought to be covered automatically in this Bill. I am sure the Minister knows that there are a number of these institutions here in Dublin, giving reasonable employment, and it would be unfair, just with a stroke of the pen, just because we are introducing the new measure here, not to afford protection to those people. I do not think that the Minister for one moment entertains the idea of hurting those people, or injuring them in their business, but I should like to see that incorporated in the Bill. Perhaps the Minister would give the Seanad an assurance that there is no possibility of men in old-established entertainment rooms, arcades, etc., in the country being injured by the introduction of this Bill.

Comment on this

This amendment is in conflict with other provisions of the Bill, but, in any event, it would be unacceptable to me. What we are being asked to do is to give special rights to those persons who have been operating gaming houses for the past ten years or more, contrary to the law of the land and despite police prosecutions. The prosecutions have been brought regularly before the courts. Is it seriously suggested that such persons should be given preferential treatment, because they have been carrying on illegally for ten years, over citizens who have been complying with the law?

Apart from this objection in principle, there is also the fact that there is no guarantee that a local authority, say, the Dublin Corporation, would approve of the hall where a man has been operating ten and 12 years. They may have good reason for disapproving, or they may have objections from a large number of people. Therefore, I am not going to agree to an amendment that would give one individual the rights which a majority of other individuals do not possess, simply and solely because he has been carrying on illegally for the past ten years.

Comment on this

We are all anxious to uphold the rights of local authorities, but individuals also have rights. If a person has been operating an amusement hall of this kind for a number of years, is it possible that, under this Bill, if a county council fails to bring the Act into operation, that man's business may be closed down without a penny compensation? There appears to be grave injustice there and some provision should be made for it.

Even those who were operating illegally for that period were doing so under Acts which were themselves illegal in the moral sense, inasmuch as they had no moral support in this country and were recognised generally as being obsolete, in the sense that the authorities did not enforce them.

Comment on this

The Minister states that my new sub-section may be conflicting with the Bill and he gives as one of his reasons that there may be one of these caterers who has committed various offences over the years, and, therefore, there may be good reason why he should not get authority to carry on now because he is ten years in business. But it is clearly stated in this proposed sub-section that he "shall be granted a certificate by the court on proving that he has complied with the other requirements of the Act".

Surely to be a decent man and run a proper establishment is one of the requirements. So, when the Minister brushes me aside with the remark that this sub-section may be in conflict with the Bill, I begin to doubt the Bill. This makes it clear that any man who is operating this business for the past ten years should get some consideration, some priority and some guarantee of continuity in the business that he has run decently and cleanly for the past ten years. There is no conflict there. I have not studied the Bill so minutely and perhaps it conflicts with my sub-section. It is practically an insult for the Minister to slip my sub-section aside, with the remark that it conflicts with the Bill.

I do not know these people personally, but I have seen them operating over the years and have seen nothing wrong. I am not one of those who want to see slot-machines in seaside resorts or "honky-tonks", as the Americans call them. When the Minister is introducing a Bill to legalise these people, we should see that they will not be regarded in the terms I have just used. This particular sub-section will give those men who are the pioneers of this business in the city and elsewhere a chance to continue. We should not be so hasty at all in deciding that they are doing a wrong thing in entertaining people in this country. A little entertainment does not do any harm and my sub-section itself possibly does less harm than the Bill.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with Senator Carton. These people knew they were operating illegally and were subject to many prosecutions during the last ten or 20 years. Are we now to give them something as compensation for having broken the law? They should be in jail, instead of getting a preference.

Comment on this

I have not asked for compensation.

Comment on this

No. You want to give them a preference.

Comment on this

Give them priority.

Comment on this

You are going to give them something.

Comment on this

They are entitled to the continuation of their business.

Comment on this

You are going to compel the local authority to give them a licence. The local authority has power to refuse or allow people to operate in the area.

Comment on this

It is a case of "live and let live."

Comment on this

They could apply the same as anyone else and I presume they would be allowed to operate, provided they behave themselves.

Comment on this

The Minister said certain people had been prosecuted. I take it, as Senator Carton did, that that might injure their chances in securing a licence.

Comment on this

Having expiated the offence.

Comment on this

If that outlook were to prevail, it would be a very serious thing. It is one thing to be prosecuted on a technical breach of a law that is outmoded and obsolete and quite another thing to be charged with an indictable offence. Surely we must have some sympathy for those compelled to break the law technically because it was outmoded. I do not know any of these people, but if they were put in a disadvantageous position, it would be a serious case. You could have a district justice who was such a puritan that he would say that, because people were prosecuted before and fined under a statute — even though it was outmoded — they were to be refused a licence. That would be quite a serious matter.

Comment on this

I do not think any hardship is being imposed on these people, or intended to be imposed on them. The laws we are passing here do not impose any more restrictions than the existing laws. If we were to give these people the consideration sought, we would be condoning the offences.

Comment on this

I think that, in view of the speeches made by some of the Senators now, they should have opposed the Second Reading of this Bill, because what is being attempted is a watering-down of this measure to such an extent that it will be of little use at all. I think we have to come back to the essential point and realise that this Bill is being introduced to overcome abuses which were definitely rampant throughout the city and other parts of the country. To suggest that the status quo should remain and that these people should be allowed to continue defeats the whole intention of the Bill.

I do not think it is right to say that establishments which have been in operation here for ten years should, because of that particular fact, be allowed to continue, irrespective of the character of the people conducting them, irrespective of the type of machines and irrespective of the people who frequent these establishments. I think that would be wrong. I do suggest that Senator Carton should allow the section to stand; that is, that the local authorities should have sole discretion in the matter and that licences should be granted by the courts after taking into account all the relevant factors.

Comment on this

What is meant, in effect, is that previous prosecutions will not place them in any privileged position, nor will it place them at any disadvantage before the court. The fact that they had been prosecuted before does not put them in any privileged position, nor does it place them at any disadvantage. The amendment wants to give them a privilege. I say now, and I give the assurance, that a previous prosecution will not be used against these people, when they make an application before the courts, nor will it give them any privilege. I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I am merely asking that these people be assured continuity in the business they have been engaged in over the years.

Comment on this

I am certain that district justices will take into consideration all the factors. I think few Senators here have not been prosecuted in other days, but that fact was not taken into consideration when they became Senators. In this particular case, the district justices will regard the applications in their proper light, taking into consideration all the factors, provided the applications have been passed by the local authority.

Comment on this

I do not wish anybody to construe my remarks as an effort to defend criminals. These are all decent people who have been carrying on their business and they want no privilege, unless one can say it is a privilege to be permitted to carry on one's ordinary occupation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:—

To delete sub-section (3).

Under this sub-section, it is provided that, if any ticket, counterfoil or coupon for use in a lottery is found at any place or premises searched in pursuance of a search warrant under the Act, it shall be evidence, until the contrary is proved, in a prosecution for a contravention that the person having control over the place or premises had it in his possession for sale or distribution. The first suggestion I have to make on that matter is that this is the sort of sub-section one might find in emergency legislation dealing with public order. I think it is quite unreasonable that, in a normal statute, the ordinary principles of justice should not apply, that is, that the onus should be on the prosecution to prove the case.

It seems to me that there might be difficulty about the phrase "person in control of the premises". It does seem strange that a lottery should be regarded as such a terrible thing that legislation of this kind should be necessary to deal with it. I would ask the Minister whether or not he has considered that the ordinary law should apply and that, if a person is found in possession of such coupons or counterfoils, it is for the State to prove the case.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) provides that, where a premises is searched, and lottery tickets or other documents are found, there will be a presumption that they were kept for sale. It must be remembered that, before a search warrant is issued, the district justice must issue a search warrant and must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for granting it. It is necessary that the person concerned should show, in fact, where he got the coupons or counterfoils. It would be absurd that the police should have to undertake the difficult and impossible task of showing that they were for sale.

Comment on this
Mr. Douglas

I support the case made by Senator Cox, because I feel that this sub-section, if it is allowed to remain part of the Bill, is taking away the rights of the citizen. It is quite clear that, if tickets are found on the premises, they might easily have arrived there by chance. I receive quite a number of tickets for lotteries from Northern Ireland and other parts of the world and they may be lying on my desk for two or three days before I tear them up. The fact is the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is aiding and abetting these lotteries when he delivers these letters to my office. Under this section, then, we could persuade the district justice that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was, in fact, aiding and abetting, and we should be entitled to a search warrant to search the post office to see what tickets were there. That is what the sub-section provides, so far as I can see. I think the onus should be on the prosecution to prove that the tickets were there for sale.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

I do not know whether depending on a district justice to grant a search warrant is giving great protection to the citizen. Everyone will remember a year or so ago when a district justice issued search warrants, with the result that the stock-in-trade of a certain company was taken out of their possession. I do seriously say that it is not right, in dealing with a comparatively small matter like lottery tickets, to insert provisions of this kind, merely to simplify the task of prosecution. I think it is a possible precedent of a very dangerous nature and I should certainly ask the Minister to consider it. I will withdraw the amendment now, but I ask the right to raise it again.

Comment on this

The district justice must be satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt before he issues a warrant under this section. It is not new, because sub-section (3) is on the lines of Section 2 of the Gaming Act, 1845. If there is any point in getting the legal representatives in the Attorney-General's office to further consider the matter, I have no objection.

Comment on this

I think one should be very careful in statutes of this kind in regard to inserting these extraordinary powers which may be necessary in a matter of national emergency. I think it is much more important to preserve the ordinary liberty and the ordinary rights of the citizen in a court of justice.

Comment on this

I heartily agree with the sentiments expressed by Senator Cox. It was always understood that a man was innocent until proved guilty. The less legislation we have putting the onus on the defendant to prove himself innocent, the better. It should be avoided by the Legislature as far as possible.

While an ex-parte application may be made to a district justice to grant a search warrant, that, in itself, is no justification why the owner of a premises should be presumed guilty, until he can prove that he is innocent of the offence alleged.

Comment on this

I will raise the matter again.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

In lines 6 to 8 to delete "other than an announcement of the results of a lottery declared by any provision of this Part not to be unlawful" and substitute "not being a lottery declared by any provision of this Act not to be unlawful".

The sense of the section is that no person shall print, publish in any newspaper or periodical publication, exhibit on any cinema screen or broadcast any announcement concerning a lottery, other than the result of the lottery. When a lottery is lawful and has been licensed, there is no reason whatever why it should not be referred to in a newspaper or broadcast. It seems to me that this section envisages a lottery as something almost as bad as a plague. It seems to me to be carrying legislation to a ridiculous extent. If, under this Bill, lotteries are very carefully supervised, are licensed and declared to be legal, I do not see why on earth they could not be referred to in newspapers or advertised. Why should they be restricted to an announcement of the result? If a charity runs a lottery which is perfectly normal, why, in the name of goodness, should there not be references to it in a newspaper? It is a question of importance, for again it touches on public rights.

Comment on this

I support this amendment very strongly. I spoke on the matter on Second Reading and drew attention to it. The more I think of it, the more it seems to me to be very unfair to the liberty of the Press, the public and the promoters of lotteries. If a lottery is not legal under this part of the Act, then, of course, no reference to anything in that connection could be made in the Press. If a lottery is legal under this part of the Act, like Senator Cox, I cannot see why the newspapers should not be allowed to give it publicity. Either the lottery is against the public interest or not. If it is against the public interest, it is not allowed to take place under this Bill; but if people are allowed to promote lotteries under this part of the Bill, they should be allowed to promote them successfully and there is no way to promote them successfully other than by advertising them in the Press. It would be very unfair to newspaper proprietors to deprive them of any source of revenue. If the lottery is in accordance with the law under this Bill and if there are no objections from any other point of view, I cannot see why the promoters should not be allowed to get full publicity and the Press enabled to secure whatever advertising revenue they can derive from it.

Comment on this

I agree with the sentiments expressed, but I should like Senator Cox to explain how the substitution of his wording would, in fact, enforce the principles he has put before us.

Comment on this

I should like to inquire as to what is meant by this section, because it is so all-embracing.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator will deal with the amendment first and we can discuss the section later.

Comment on this

I accept the Chair's ruling, since a question has been asked of Senator Cox in regard to the amendment.

Comment on this

The wording of the section, according to my amendment, would be:—

"No person shall print, publish in any newspaper or periodical publication, exhibit on any cinema screen or broadcast by radio any notice or announcement concerning a lottery, not being a lottery declared by any provision of this Act not to be unlawful, or cause or procure any such notice or announcement to be so printed, published, exhibited or broadcast or knowingly circulate or cause or procure to be circulated any newspaper or periodical publication containing any such notice or announcement."

Comment on this

Some of these lotteries for charitable purposes are promoted by commercial organisations with an eye on the 40 per cent. expenses allowed. I am afraid that it would interfere with parochial lotteries got up in a local area. When it is only 40 per cent. they may not be in a position to advertise very widely, but they can communicate through the post with voluntary helpers to try to secure the sale of tickets for the particular lottery. If you are going to allow the Press, radio and other forms of advertising to be used, then the small lotteries will be unable to carry on and the commercial organisations will take over. No one is interfering with the liberty of the individual or the Press in the country. We agreed to a lottery up to £500 — against my own views. I understand, from the deputation that met me, that the expenses of some of the lotteries were unduly high and that there was too small a prize for the object for which the lottery was organised. I have one lottery in mind. They told me it was for a very worthy cause and that the people subscribed very liberally throughout the country at 1/- per ticket. They told me that £1,100 was collected weekly. Of that £1,100 over £700 went in expenses and only £200 went towards the worthy object in respect of which the people had purchased the tickets. In other words, they were paying 1/- for a very worthy cause, believing that it was going to the object, and then found that the larger amount was going in expenses. In this case, we have confined it to 40 per cent. expenses. Then they can use the voluntary helpers. I believe that will achieve the purpose.

Comment on this

I believe that, unwittingly, the Minister is rather unfair. I have some other amendments later on trying to deal with this very question of the proportion of the amount collected which will be available for the charity. The Minister has offered his rejection of the right to publish particulars in the newspapers on the ground that the distribution might not be a fair distribution or might not leave much in the hands of the charity. I think a very big principle is involved. I will not press the amendment now. Once again, I will reserve the right to bring it up on the next stage and I trust I may press it then.

Comment on this

While I understand that the amendment has been withdrawn, my opinion of it is that it would have the effect of putting the section in the position that it would be just as well it were not in the Bill at all. I think Senator Cox would agree with me. He might be right, because it is just another section that will create another group of lawbreakers. It is ominous in its definition as to printing, publishing, and so forth. What is meant by these words? If I read it correctly, it means that anybody printing or publishing or circulating a newspaper containing the result of a lottery is committing an offence.

I take it the Minister refers only to the newspapers operating within the limits of this State. He forgets, however, that quite a lot of journals, newspapers and periodicals of one kind or another are imported. Surely it is elementary to imagine that since a daily or Sunday newspaper is not allowed to print these results, they can insert a notice saying: "We are not allowed to print the results of the lottery, but they will appear in such and such a cross-Channel paper which is circulated in this country." What can the Minister do about that? Furthermore, if I read the section correctly, it means this. Once that begins to happen — and this is elementary, my dear Watson — it will boost the sales of certain journals which are not printed in this country, but which are circulating here.

If the Minister intends to enforce the law — and I know that, as far as this Bill has gone up to now, it is not enforceable because it brings the law into contempt — he will then be forced to prosecute newsagents up and down the country. I should like to know what is going to happen? I should like to hear from Senator Cox or Senator Walsh if they would be prepared to regard the section in that light. Without any legal knowledge, I suggest that what I have said is the position. If the Minister tries to put this section into force, he will have to prosecute all our newsagents selling the results of these illegal lotteries which appear in journals that are not printed in this country.

Comment on this

It seems to me that if such publication is considered undesirable, there should be some provision in the Bill, and I am not aware that there is, for prosecuting people who insert these advertisements — the newspapers and the other periodicals that accept these advertisements, and not merely the people who insert them. There is a great deal in what Senator O'Reilly says. Cross-Channel newspapers can come in and they would be completely free from any prosecutions under the Bill, as far as I know. There ought to be some penal provision in the Bill for punishing the newspapers as well as the promoters of the lotteries who insert the advertisements. There may be another relevant section in another part of the Bill, but I am not aware of it at the moment.

Comment on this

I do not share Senator O'Reilly's fears in connection with the matter. For the information of Senators, the British Football Pools Act has a similar clause, and there is no objection to it, and it is working very satisfactorily. The Press will not insert advertisements, in respect of any particular lottery or sweep, unless they are paid for doing so.

Comment on this

It does not answer my point. Really, it is annoying to feel that one is right and yet that one is not getting an opinion one way or another. Will this section create a position such as I have outlined, assuming that the results are printed in cross-Channel journals circulating here? I argue that if our newsagents sell those papers or periodicals, they will be breaking the law so far as this section is concerned and should be prosecuted, if this section becomes law. They may not be prosecuted because we have such a bundle of statute law in this country which is not enforced, but, in my opinion, that is the sort of thing that makes laws ridiculous. Why add to that sort of law? I have been arguing on that principle all day. The Minister's reply has not satisfied me. If cross-Channel journals start printing the results and if those journals are sold by our newsagents here, then I submit they are breaking the law and should be prosecuted.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that a person who sold such a newspaper could be prosecuted and would have directly infringed the Act. Furthermore, I believe that anyone who procured such a newspaper to be circulated might be prosecuted. Therefore, there is quite a wide range of possible prosecutions.

Comment on this

Is it not time we stopped passing laws such as that?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:—

In paragraph (b), line 22, after "concerned" to add "or to members of the society".

It would appear that a lottery confined to the members of a society is not excluded, but the notice must be exhibited only on the premises of the society. I can visualise occasions where, say, a golf club, or some other society, may run a sweepstake confined to the members, and, if it is required that the notice may only be exhibited in the premises, the society cannot notify members who are not in the habit of frequenting the premises. The amendment would permit members of the society to be notified.

Comment on this

The type of lottery envisaged under Section 23 is a small office or factory lottery, promoted on the day of a big race, where the contribution is 1/- or 6d. Lotteries in which a written notice is sent to members are generally of a more ambitious nature and are seldom confined to the members of the societies. These can operate under Section 27.

Comment on this

If the lottery is confined entirely to the members of the society, is there any reason why the members should not be permitted to be notified?

Comment on this

I am not wedded to it. I am prepared to accept it, because I understand the Senator's point of view. You will have in many places like a factory, fellows who are not workers in the factory and they will take a chance for a 1/- stake. I will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to comment on the wording of the section. It reads: "A lottery shall not be unlawful if... (b) there is no written notice of announcement relating to the lottery except a notice on the premises of the society or other persons concerned."

Does that mean that the notice has to be printed on the person?

Comment on this

They can have their wives and daughters and sons in it, although they would not be members of the staff of the factory. I am accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

I should like to ask, for the sake of clarification, in relation to sub-section (b), just precisely what is meant by the words "no person may win more than the value of the £25 in the lottery." In that case, if these two conditions are fulfilled, the lottery shall not be unlawful. Does that mean that the first prize shall not be more than £25, or that the total value of all the prizes shall not be more than £25, because, in theory, a person might win one, two, three or more prizes? I do not think the sub-section is sufficiently clearly drafted to indicate whether it means the first prize or the total value of all the prizes, which, in theory, at any rate, might be won by the one person.

Comment on this

The value of any prize at a whist drive.

Comment on this

A single prize?

Comment on this

Any single prize.

Comment on this

The value of all the prizes taken together, or each individual prize? One person might win £25 and the others might win £25. It seems to be very vague.

Comment on this

One person may win a £25 prize. There may be a second prize.

Comment on this

For £24?

Comment on this

In some lotteries, a person might win the first and second prizes. Does that mean that the first prize should not be more than £15?

Comment on this

There was a big debate in the Dáil on this.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It does seem to me that, if the first prize is £25, the same person could not win the second.

Comment on this

He could not.

Comment on this

Without making the lottery illegal.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Douglas

It would appear to me, reading this section, that you could have in an extreme case prize money to the value of £25 and all a promoter has to do is to see that no one wins more than £25.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider including the word "total"?

Comment on this

I tried to meet the wishes of the Dáil, and, against my own personal views, I accepted the Dáil's amendment. As I have already pointed out, our desire is to make a Bill that will not encourage gambling. I believe that is the desire of Senators and Deputies, but I realise that this will not be the last Bill and that some other Government will have to try to remove the defects.

Comment on this

This House may not be very important, but I do not see why we should be asked to pass a section which to any intelligent person is clearly meaningless, simply because it was adopted at the suggestion of some Deputy in the Dáil. It is perfectly clear that the wording of this section is completely unclear, and I think it is only reasonable that the Minister should tell us what he does mean by it. That is not asking very much. I do object to an answer being given that asks us to adopt a meaningless section because the Dáil has approved of it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Does the section not really mean that no single prize offered should be of a higher value than £25, and, if it means that, is there any objection to saying that?

Comment on this

Why not say that?

Comment on this

I will see if there is any point in what the Senator raises.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It could be amended now and the Minister could change it again, if he wants to, on the next stage.

Comment on this

If the House agrees.

Comment on this

I think we ought not to pass the sub-section as it stands.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Perhaps Senator Cox would apply his mind to my wording and see if he could improve on it —that no money prize in a lottery shall be of greater value than £25.

Comment on this

Yes, but that implies that there might be a lot of prizes of that value.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Yes, if that is what is meant.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept it, if it meets with the approval of the Seanad.

Comment on this

Very well; that is clear, but it means that there could be a number of prizes of that size.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes's suggestion would mean that no prize will be of greater money value than £25 and would suggest that you could have £24, £23, £22 and so on right down the line.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

I suggest that there should be only one prize in any one lottery. I am not going to frame it. It is not my job. Apparently the whole thing does not make sense as it is.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Carton, not that there should be only one prize, but that it would be possible to have one prize of £25 and another of £24 19s. 11d. and so on and to have a lottery to the value of thousands of pounds. That could happen, but it is unlikely. The Minister said a lot of things to-night and I agree with him on one, that this will not be the last measure dealing with this question. I am totally with him in that, because there are so many anomalies in this whole Bill and each section of it that we may have 98 people out of every 100 technically breaking the law, if it is to be enforced. I know it will not be. It would be a joke if this measure were to be enforced, and there would be such an uproar that the Minister or some other Minister would be in here very quickly to amend it, if it became an Act.

Comment on this

Did Senator O'Reilly ever attend a dance in the country?

Comment on this

Yes, of course.

Comment on this

Then he knows that there is never a lottery for £1,000 or anything like that.

Comment on this

Of course not.

Comment on this

He knows that 95 per cent. of the people will go there for the object for which the dance is held and not for the purpose of gaining a large amount of money. They may have a lottery at a dance where you would have a couple of hundred people and you would give an inducement of perhaps £15 and two prizes of £7, but nothing more than that. I am prepared to look into the matter on the Report Stage to ensure that no prize will be greater than £25.

Comment on this

The total prize money in any one lottery should not exceed £25.

Comment on this
Mr. Douglas

I was going to say just what Senator Carton has said. I entirely agree with the Minister that this Bill should be an effort to restrict gambling, but under the section as we have it at the moment, and even with Senator Hayes's suggested amendment, we are not attempting to restrict gambling, but trying to encourage it. This section should be worded to state that the total prize fund in any lottery at a dance shall not exceed £25 and it should be left to the promoters to decide how that £25 will be divided up. That would meet the point the Minister is anxious about.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the principle of Senator Hayes's suggestion, and bring in an amendment on the Report Stage that will meet the wishes of the Seanad.

Comment on this

Senators will remember the lottery in "Alice in Wonderland", in which everyone was given a prize.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:—

In paragraph (c), line 46, before "as" to insert "or night".

Quite frequently, in rural areas particularly, carnivals and bazaars go on well after midnight. This may be only a technical point, but it seems to me that, if the announcement of the result of the draw takes place after midnight, it would be illegal as the section stands, and accordingly it would be very desirable and necessary to permit the announcement to be made not only on the same day as stated, but to add the words "or night".

Comment on this

I agree with the suggestion.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:—

In paragraph (e), line 49, to delete "10/-" and substitute "30/-".

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This matter has been dealt with on an earlier section.

Comment on this

May I, with your permission, Sir, refer to an observation made by the Minister in relation to the £25 prize at a dance, when he said that he thought it would have to be something like that to make it attractive. I have performed callisthenics jumping up and down here on this amendment and trying to make the other suggestion of mine, regarding the 30/-, attractive also. I wish the Minister would think in terms of that section, as he does in connection with the dance-hall prizes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:—

In sub-section (1), line 56, before "in" to insert "or the Six Counties known as Northern Ireland".

Section 26 provides that a lottery shall not be unlawful, if its promoters and directors are wholly within the State, which, of course, implies that it is unlawful, if it is not conducted wholly within the State. I have put down an amendment to that to say "in the State or in the Six Counties known as Northern Ireland". The sub-section as it stands would clearly make illegal a lottery promoted here for a charity in Northern Ireland. That, I think, is utterly unthinkable. I imagine that the last thing anybody wants in this House is to do anything which in any way savours of or helps Partition, and if we pass legislation, the effect of which is that a charity in Northern Ireland could not promote for its own purposes a lottery down here, we are legislating something that we should not legislate.

As will appear in other amendments, I have in mind the case of the Mater Hospital in Belfast, which, for reasons I cannot go into, has been denied by the Government of Northern Ireland the reliefs and grants and so on which are accorded to other hospitals in that area. The Mater Hospital in Belfast is a hospital of the religion of the great majority of the people in the 32 Counties and of a section which is very nearly one-half in the Six Counties. I think it is a hospital which should lie very close to our hearts. Unless we accept the principle of Partition, I can see no reason why we should not help such a hospital of our own people in Northern Ireland as a hospital of our own down here. This section excludes absolutely the possibility of a lottery here which is promoted outside. I would very strongly urge that it is very wrong that we should do that. I know that the lottery run on behalf of that particular hospital in Belfast is essential to its continuance and existence there. Senator Walsh's amendment is similar to mine and we might combine forces, as his points are probably the same.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Cox has amendment No. 54 dealing with some of the matters he has mentioned. He may care to discuss them now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

If this amendment is not accepted, I take it that amendment No. 54 will fall?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We can take a decision on amendment No. 54 later on.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to take it on amendment No. 54, if I am defeated on this one.

Comment on this

I should like to support the amendment proposed by Senator Cox, in view of the fact that the Hospitals Sweepstakes have saved the central and local authorities many millions of pounds, by assisting in the erection of hospitals. The Sweepstakes have also assisted the voluntary hospitals. It is only reasonable that the Mater Hospital in Belfast should be assisted, the same as voluntary hospitals elsewhere. It provides excellent facilities and services for the people in Northern Ireland, particularly our nationalist people. This voluntary hospital has been treated unfairly and, unlike hospitals in this State, it has to carry on without any State assistance. Considering the substantial amount contributed by the nationalists there towards the Hospitals' Trust Fund here, it is only fair that we should reciprocate by permitting the Y.P. Pools, which circulate here at the moment, to continue. It is only a small concession for the Minister to make and it would show our sympathy and consideration for our northern nationalists. Lip-service is given from time to time here, but this amendment would be a practical way of showing our goodwill towards the fight they are waging against great odds in maintaining this extremely well-run institution. If this Bill is passed in its present form it will be a serious blow to that institution and it is hard to see how it can continue. I myself had the privilege each week of subscribing to this hospital through these pools and I would feel very sore if I were deprived of that privilege, in view of the regard we must have for our people there and the fact that other hospitals are getting 100 per cent. grants, while this hospital does not benefit from the health services that apply to Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

I am in general sympathy with what has been said by Senator Cox and Senator Walsh. If we accept Senator Cox's amendment, sub-section (1) of Section 26 would read strangely:—

"A lottery shall not be unlawful if it is promoted and conducted wholly within the State or the Six Counties known as Northern Ireland in accordance with a permit or licence."

Section 27, sub-section (3) says:—

"A permit shall not be granted more than once in six months for the benefit of any one beneficiary."

That would mean that the permit could be given only once in six months. If it is a lottery licensed under Section 28 (2) (c), the total value of the prizes is £500. That might exclude the lottery which Senators have in mind. Are they satisfied that, by these amendments, asking for the inclusion of lotteries promoted in Northern Ireland, they are bringing about the circumstances for which they have devised the amendments?

Comment on this

I have set down other amendments for later sections, which will arise in due course. I understand that it is likely that the Matter Hospital could continue, perhaps not as well as in the past, if there is a limitation on the prize money, but it will not continue in a satisfactory way. Naturally, one has to deal with each of the sections as it comes along. I repeat that I have been told on the very highest authority that this lottery is vital to the hospital and I feel that, if we let that hospital in Belfast down, we will be making a very poor show.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The two Senators have made it clear that they are endeavouring to help the Y.P. Pools. Everybody here will have the greatest sympathy with the object of the two amendments, but the question is whether these methods are the best. There are two separate methods. Senator Cox's remedy is a general inclusion of the Six Counties. It is quite clear that, if we were to accept it or Senator Walsh's amendment, the consequential amendments would afterwards be inserted. Senator Walsh is pressing to allow such lotteries outside the State as may be permitted by the Minister. That would put the Minister for Justice here in rather a difficulty.

The Bill as it stands does not prevent the Mater Hospital, or the Foreign Missions, or any such body in Northern Ireland from benefiting from a lottery which is promoted within our territory.

It seems to me that the remedy would be that the Mater Hospital, or any other such charity outside the State, should be able to benefit from the promotion of a lottery held, promoted and conducted within the State. In other words, if it is desired to have the sale of tickets for that purpose, which is entirely a praiseworthy purpose, then these tickets should be sold under the aegis of an organisation within the State. It is essential, I think, that we should be able to supervise anything of that kind and that is a suggestion that is made —that these tickets should be sold under the aegis of a separate body formed here. There is no objection to that, I think, and there should be no difficulty in obtaining the necessary permission. That would be a more practical and a more desirable way of accomplishing the objects which Senator Cox and Senator Walsh have in mind than the methods set out in the two amendments.

Comment on this

I support what Senator Hayes has said. Most of us in this House agree that we should support the Matter Hospital, but I do not think that supporting the Y.P. in the form suggested in this amendment is the best way to do it, because in that way we would not only help the Mater Hospital, but also the Northern Ireland Government who are able to collect almost as much from the Y.P. Pools as the Mater Hospital does. If we allow the Y.P. Pools to be run here in the South, we would be able to control it and the whole of the money deriving from it would go to the Mater Hospital without any deductions.

Comment on this

This is a matter I have discussed in very great detail with the authorities responsible for the Mater Hospital in Belfast. They take the view that there could be so much cheating and dishonesty about a lottery that unless they could continue to operate as they have in the past, they could not stand over it. There is the further point that a separate organisation here would, of course, involve a great deal of additional expense.

On the tax position, it is very difficult to answer that or to say what really the position would be, but I would press extremely strongly that if a charity in Northern Ireland wishes to run a lottery here, it should be permitted to do so. It has to obtain the permission provided under the Act before it can run it.

Comment on this

Senator Cox's last speech surprises me, because the implication was that they could not get honest people in the Twenty-Six Counties to run the lottery for the benefit of the Mater Hospital. That is an absurd argument. I agree with Senator Hayes and Senator Bergin in what they have said and there is the fact that we should not do anything which would favour the partition of the country. The fact is we would be subsidising the Six-County Government to a very large extent. The Mater Hospital got something like £130,000 a year from the Twenty-Six Counties out of the pools and I am not so sure that that would not be an item in favour of the policy of Partition.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The first point which Senator McHugh made struck me when Senator Cox was speaking. Surely he is doing a disservice to the promoters of this lottery on behalf of the Mater Hospital, Belfast, when he states that they feel they could not get in the Twenty-Six Counties a group of people who would honestly conduct the lottery? That is an absurd suggestion to make and I doubt very much that it could be correct. I know there is cheating in connection with lotteries and that is what the Minister is endeavouring to deal with in the Bill.

Senator Cox also suggested the expense that would be incurred, but surely, if there is so much goodwill, the goodwill of which Senator Cox and Senator Walsh have spoken, it would be possible to get a voluntary group of reputable and honest people who would do this work and continue to provide for the Mater Hospital an income from this part of the State. If that is impossible, then human nature is worse than the most pessimistic of us ever thought it to be.

Comment on this

I did not wish to make any suggestion of dishonesty about this matter. What I suggested was that those who are responsible have always looked after this particular lottery. They have gone fully into it and they feel terribly reluctant to conduct the lottery, unless they are able to supervise it. These people are in a position to guarantee what they are doing and it would be extremely difficult to operate the lottery simultaneously in Dublin and Belfast.

Comment on this

I cannot see that it would be so difficult as Senator Cox says for the Y.P. people to maintain a separate organisation here. We all know that, when this Bill passes, the amount of prize money for the Y.P. will be limited to £500. We should not make the position such that other charities will be placed at a disadvantage—charities such as the Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda. Any additional expense which would be entailed by the Y.P. setting up a separate organisation here would be offset by leaving out the deductions for taxes which would be deducted, if the pools were run in Northern Ireland. I assume that the amount made here would be free of tax and would run into a considerable amount in a year.

Comment on this

Senator Bergin referred to the fact that the Lourdes Hospital run a pool. I should like to refer the Senator to the fact that the Hospitals' Trust Fund have provided substantial amounts towards that hospital over a short period of years. Tickets for the Hospitals' Sweepstakes cost £1 and membership of the Y.P. Pools is only 1/-.

Senator McHugh and Senator Bergin have referred to the fact that the Northern Government would benefit to some extent by subscriptions to these pools in Northern Ireland. We must not forget the fact that our Government benefits to a considerable extent from the sweepstakes subscriptions pouring into us from America and other countries, including Northern Ireland. A considerable sum goes to the Government by way of stamp duties. In view of the fact that we are permitting the Hospitals' Trust Fund which runs into a tremendous amount of money and where the people are committed to buy tickets for £1 each, I do not think it is unreasonable to show some reciprocation towards the people who are affected so adversely as the people who are trying to maintain the Mater Hospital.

If the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment suggested by Senator Cox, then we should at least include the Mater Hospital as one of the hospitals which should benefit from the funds of the Hospitals' Trust.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

There does not appear to be any relevancy in Senator Walsh's argument because the Hospitals' Trust Fund is a different matter. What we are endeavouring to do is to see whether the Mater Hospital in Belfast can be helped. I do not see any other way in which it can be helped by legislation. I do not think that an amendment of the kind Senator Cox proposes should be accepted or any amendment which places the onus on the Minister of permitting certain lotteries outside the State. That is an onus that should not be placed upon any Minister. The suggestion I made, and which Senator Bergin supports, is that it should be possible to have a reputable and competent committee which could run within the State a lottery within the terms of our law for that particular hospital. If that is impossible, I think it is impossible to do anything else

Comment on this

I agree. If it is not possible to set up a separate organisation in our State, it is impossible to do anything. Not more than 40 per cent. will be allowed in regard to the expenses of running a draw. I do not see how the Y.P. Pool could be run; the fact that the prize is confined to £500 would make it impossible. We run pools in the South—there is one for the rehabilitation of people suffering from T.B.—and such draws are run extremely well. It would be better if a group of people could be got together who would handle a pool for the North of Ireland.

Comment on this

We seem to be getting nowhere in the discussion on this section. If we were to remove the section completely from the Bill, would that have any bad effect? The whole thing turns on that point.

"A lottery shall not be unlawful if it is promoted and conducted wholly within the State in accordance with a permit or a licence."

I should like to hear from the Minister whether he regards that sub-section as absolutely imperative.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Yes, certainly.

Comment on this

Would the Minister fear that, by its removal, graver evils would arise?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Would not all kinds of lotteries promoted anywhere then become law?

Comment on this

Take out the word "wholly" and bring in the word "partly".

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

You would leave yourself wide open.

Comment on this

I suppose so. I am prepared to agree with the Senator on that, but we do not seem to be making any progress towards the solution of the problem raised.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment and raise it again. I think this is a matter of national importance in the true sense.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

As we have gone a certain distance on this Bill and as we are going to take a further stage after Christmas, I wonder whether the House would agree to sit a little later to-night in order to enable us to see what further progress could be made with the Committee Stage?

Comment on this

There is a rather large number of amendments to be dealt with yet.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

All right. I do not think it is worth while to go on.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) This section shall not render a lottery which is promoted within the State and in respect of which no person outside the State is entitled to purchase any ticket, counterfoil, coupon or chance unlawful by reason only of the fact that documents, books, records, or other papers are transmitted outside the State to the trustees of or to the object of the charitable or philanthropic purpose or purposes for which the lottery is promoted: Provided always that such lottery is duly permitted or licensed under this Act.

This is very much the same point. I hope the Minister will agree with the amendment, if, in fact, there is any desire at all to help the Mater Hospital.

Comment on this

I have provided deliberately that the Mater Hospital may benefit from the charity, but, in order that we may be able to distinguish between bona fide promotions and others, it is essential that records should be available at all times for police supervision, as provided for in Section 51. I think that clause should meet the Senator's point of view.

Comment on this

It does not. If there is a charity outside the State which is the beneficiary of a lottery conducted within the State, it is clear that the records will have to go to the beneficiary outside the State.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Why? I do not understand Senator Cox's point. Must the documents be transmitted outside the State?

The Seanad adjourned at 10 p.m. until 3 p.m. on Thursday, 15th December, 1955.

Comment on this