An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–119 of 232. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
I was speaking yesterday evening about the purpose of this Bill being to remove the rights of minorities to representation in Dáil Éireann. It would be less than fair if I did not acknowledge that the majority had rights in this respect also and that they could, in fact, curtail the rights of the minorities in certain circumstances. They could do so if, in fact, it were found that government was impossible under the existing setup, if government were impossible because of the exercise of the present rights of minorities, which in effect deprived the majority of their rights of government.
Fianna Fáil have failed to show that the exercise of the rights of minorities, the right of representation, has in fact led to a collapse of government in the State. I know that Fianna Fáil do not like inter-Party government or, as they term it, coalition government, and I respect their views in that regard because they believe they themselves are the best political Party. They would hardly be in it otherwise, and I can always respect another person's point of view. However, I think it is wrong for a majority to say that simply because they do not like the prospect of being deprived of power, do not like the fact that by a combination of minority Parties previously, they were deprived of power, they will so alter the rules that it will not be possible, ever afterwards, for such a situation to repeat itself.
As a Labour spokesman, I think I should stress that the trade union movement is opposed to this move to abolish P.R. It is very important at this time that the trade union viewpoint should be made known. It is also particularly unfortunate that this move should be set on foot when there is the very bright prospect of the trade unions as a whole achieving unity, and, by unity, making a far more responsible and powerful trade union force. At the same time, we see a manoeuvre by a major political Party here so to arrange things that the united Labour movement will not have a hope of representation in Dáil Éireann, or a hope of joining in any future Governments. That is wrong and the trade union movement is protesting against that effort to deprive it of its rights.
The views of the Labour movement are perhaps best expressed in a resolution adopted by the National Executive of the Irish Trade Union Congress, which I should like to read for the benefit of Senators. They said:—
"The Irish trade union movement comprising the largest and most representative group of democratic organisations in Ireland has a special concern and a historic responsibility in securing that the democratic system of government shall be maintained. As P.R. is a system of election suitable to advanced democracies and as the system of the single seat constituencies diminishes the democratic authority of the electorate, restricts their freedom to select and change their public representatives in accordance with the requirements of a living and changing community and opens the door to domination by minority Governments, the National Executive of the Irish Trade Union Congress must regard the proposed abolition of P.R. as a retrograde step which the trade union movement must deprecate and oppose."
The Congress of Irish Unions, the other wing of the trade union movement, adopted a resolution which, I think, was circulated to Senators. It said:—
"Having considered the issues relevant to the proposal to amend the Constitution and discontinue the the present method of electing members to Dáil Éireann by the P.R. system of voting, the Central Council of the Congress of Irish Unions (1) is of opinion that justification for such action has not been established; (2) urges Deputies, Senators and citizens not to support or vote for any system of election which may result in a person securing membership of Dáil Éireann in a single-member constituency without having received a majority of the votes recorded in such constituency; (3) submits that such a method of election would not be in the best interests of the citizens of Ireland; would be in conflict with the sound democratic principle which is traditional to the trade union movement in Ireland, that is, that important issues should be decided by the majority vote of persons having the right to decide such an issue."
Those are the views of the two congresses of what I hope will soon be a united trade union movement. We feel it is particularly unfortunate that now, when unity in the trade union movement is in sight and when a more responsible, I hope, and more powerful trade union movement will result, a movement prepared to play its part in developing the economy of this country, the chance of political representation in Dáil Éireann should be snatched from it by an alteration in the system of election.
The Labour Party in this country has a democratic tradition of which I am proud, and, without wishing to hurt anybody's feelings, we have perhaps more reason to be proud of our democratic tradition than other Parties. I think we can rightly say that the Labour Party saved democracy here in the situation immediately resulting from the civil war. The leader of Fine Gael was kind enough yesterday to refer to the work of the Labour Party led by the then Deputy Tom Johnson. Not alone did we, in my view, save democracy at that time but we brought Fianna Fáil into Dáil Éireann. We preserved the Dáil until they, in their own good time, were prepared to come along and form a democratic Opposition. Indeed, the Labour Party—perhaps now there are some misgivings about it—did bring Fianna Fáil into the House as a Government for the first time.
I hope the Labour movement and the Labour Party will always abide by the democratic processes, but I warn Fianna Fáil that in fact what they are doing is pushing the Labour movement underground. I think that would be disastrous for the country. I hope I shall not have a part in that, but I warn Fianna Fáil that what they are doing is depriving an important minority Party of representation in Dáil Éireann and pushing it, with Sinn Féin, inevitably into undemocratic processes and methods. I hope I shall never have a part in that, but I am warning Fianna Fáil that it is inevitable, if they persist in their action of building up their Party as a powerful and permanent force in Government, with a weak Opposition and without a chance of the Labour Party developing as a political force and, as I would hope, eventually developing as a major political Party here.
For those reasons, I and my colleagues will vote against the Second Reading of this measure. We feel that if we voted for it or if we did not oppose the Second Reading we would, in effect, be giving approval to the principles in the Schedule attached to the Bill. We are against the abolition of P.R. We favour the P.R. method of election, as did the Taoiseach himself up to quite recently, and we believe it is in the best interests of the country and of Fianna Fáil and all the other Parties that that method of election should be preserved.
Comment on this
To some extent, I am in the same position as Senator O'Brien when he described himself yesterday as being in some sense an onlooker on the political scene, and more or less independent of the Parties in the House. It is from the onlooker's point of view that I should like to express my opinions on the Bill.
Two main arguments, I think, have been suggested against the Bill in this House and in the Dáil. The first is that it is designed to and that it will perpetuate one Party, the Government Party, in office. The second is that it will abolish, or at least greatly reduce, the chance of a minority—let it be a minority existing now or in the future —obtaining representation in the Dáil. With regard to the first point, I personally feel that the main Opposition Party must be taking a very pessimistic view of their future, their policy and the men in their Party. I cannot understand the Fine Gael Party and the remarks made by the Leader of that Party in this House yesterday. I took down fairly accurately, I think, a statement he made yesterday: "The Taoiseach is the head of a Party which normally heads the poll in most constituencies and may be assumed to continue to do so in the future."
Comment on this
I think the Senator used the words "assumed" and "in the future".
Comment on this
If I were behind Senator Hayes in that Party, I would say he was taking a very pessimistic view of the Party's outlook. Other speakers have taken the same view in the Dáil and in the Seanad. I cannot see that any Party which is the main Opposition has any right to express that view. If a Government becomes unpopular, to whom can the people turn but to the main Opposition Party to form a Government? Surely they must realise that, sooner or later—and later, if not sooner—a Government will become unpopular or stale and the people will turn to someone else?
Comment on this
Since I have been invoked, may I say that nothing I said should be construed as being contrary to the view expressed by the Senator? Of course, I agree with that view.
Comment on this
Nothing I said should be construed as disagreeing with the view that a Government may become unpopular and be replaced by another Government. What I did say was that Fianna Fáil normally tops the poll and if that state of affairs continues this Bill will favour them.
Comment on this
I took it that the Senator was assuming otherwise.
Comment on this
I hope I am wrong, as I believe that the country demands at least two substantial Parties, one to be in Government and one in Opposition. I am not criticising Fine Gael or its policy and I am quite prepared to admit that there are just as good men in the Fine Gael Party as in the Government Party. I think they would, perhaps, have been the Government to-day if they had not formed a Coalition Government, but that is my personal opinion. I think they would, perhaps, have been sponsoring this Bill in the House to-day. If the single substantial Opposition has a policy, the history of Parties here and elsewhere shows that sooner or later the people will turn to them to form a Government.
I have a certain fear that, in the first election or two under this new system of election—new to us, in any case—strange results may be produced in some constituencies. We may have a lot of Independents or a lot of popular men and they may not be the most suitable men. In a constituency with a country town, if there is a popular man in that town and if he decides to stand or is put forward, he may be elected although he may be very unsuitable. However, I believe that situation would end after one or two tries, at the most. It is up to the Parties themselves, particularly the larger Parties, to see that that does not happen.
Under this Bill the Parties will have a better chance of selecting a candidate and asking a constituency to elect him. In that respect, I disagree to a great extent with the criticisms directed towards the English system, where the Party selects a candidate, brings him down to the constituency and asks them to adopt him and elect him. There may be a certain amount to be said against that, but at the same time there is an enormous amount to be said for it. In that way a Party can select a man they know will be useful in a Government and who might not have a very great chance of being elected in his own constituency, perhaps because there is another man there or because this man might not appeal to the public at an election meeting. If a Party could say that he was a very essential man, with experience in business or farming, and if they could ask a constituency to adopt him in preference to some local, but not very suitable, man they may wish to put forward, I have every belief that that would be a better system of election.
In passing, I should like to say— though it may seem wrong, coming from a candidate who has competed twice or three times for the Dáil—that I think the membership of the Dáil, generally speaking, could be vastly improved—not as to a very large extent but perhaps up to 40 per cent. I think that is an opinion held very largely in the country. It is up to Parties, particularly the larger Parties, to select more suitable candidates; and under this Bill they would have a greater chance of selecting them and having them elected than under a system of P.R., where the Party would have to introduce its candidate to the whole of a large constituency in each case.
I feel that by the method of election proposed in the Bill we can get away from the idea—and it is a very strong idea in the country—that a member of the Dáil is a delegate sent up from the constituency to ask questions about electric current or the old age pension. Instead of that idea, the electors would be put in a position to send up to the Dáil a person who, as Senator Stanford said yesterday, would improve Parliament.
The support given in the past to small minorities, especially over the last 20 years, has been indicative of a quest by the people, not so much for a new Party as a quest for new names in the political life of the country. That is borne out by the fact that when the same type of men were returned to the Dáil in some of those Parties, they were dropped in the next election. There is a demand from the country and the electorate to improve Parliament, and I believe there would be a greater possibility of doing it under this Bill.
I have directed some of my remarks to the Fine Gael Party; may I direct some to the Labour Party as well? I think Senator Murphy made a very pessimistic speech for his Party in the House. To a certain extent the Labour Party may, at first, suffer under this Bill, but they will not if they have a national policy. I think they have not had a national policy. They have had a policy which was purely and simply a policy for members of trade unions. If their policy were extended to small farmers, for example, who have no backing of a trade union to put their views to the country, the Labour Party would receive greater support than they are getting at present. If they had a more national policy they would be accepted by a greater number of people. The small farmers are far worse off than trade union members who have the support of a large trade union to fight their case.
Before I go on to the second point, I should like to comment on one or two remarks made by Senator O'Brien. He said, I think, that he distrusts a strong Government. He suggested that this Bill will bring us strong government. There may be a little to be said against strong government, but at the same time I think a strong government is needed if there is unpopular but very necessary legislation to be brought before Parliament. It must be strong to pass unpopular legislation—even legislation the Opposition sometimes regard as necessary; otherwise they can only dabble with the more important legislation, which might be very controversial if it had to be brought forword by a Coalition Government.
I do not agree with Senator O'Brien's suggestion that if this change is made now, it can never be changed again. I do not think there is anything to prevent Fine Gael and Labour here and now saying through their representatives: "If we are returned, let it be as a coalition or as single Parties; we will give the people another chance to vote on this question." I do not think it would be wrong to let the people in another ten years discuss and vote on this question again.
The second main argument used by the Opposition, here and in the Dáil, was that this will greatly reduce the chance of minorities being represented in the Dáil. It may be to a certain extent—and, of course, it is the Government's view—that it might not be a bad thing. To a great extent I must agree with that. I cannot conceive three, four, five or six architects trying to build a house. Sooner or later, one or other of those will say: "I want to build my room in my part bigger than yours. I want to build my corner higher than yours. If I do not get my way I shall take my bricks away. I do not care if the house falls to the ground." That has been the position in Coalition Government and it has been the position in Coalition Governments all over Europe. Sooner or later, one person says: "If I do not get my way on this point I am taking my support away." A Government with that threat behind it has great difficulty and must of necessity curb perhaps very good intentions. It must curb its drive, initiative and originality in legislation. In a way it is a pity to see a large Party, or even a small Party, with originality of outlook, drive and good men, curbed or restrained because they have formed part of a Coalition Government and some other section of that Government is restricting that drive and initiative.
Senator Stanford and others have said that the youth in this country are anxious to play their part in politics generally. I think the suggestion is that there is a vast section of thinking youth in this country at present who are rather restrained by the political Parties here. I am not sure I can altogether agree with that. They should be able to accept in some way one or other of the three main political Parties here—the Government Party, Fine Gael or Labour. It may be that they do not agree with the policies they offer, but surely if sufficient of the youth and sufficient of the people do not agree with the policies of those Parties, they can change the policies?
How is the policy of a Party ever changed? Surely it is by its members pressing the leaders, pressing those who formulate policy to change it slightly this way or that? Surely the youth of this Party can see in one or other of these three Parties an outlook for their point of view? It may be that they disagree to a certain degree. But at the same time I feel they have a fairly good choice of Parties in which they can play their part.
I know it has been said that the main difference between the two main political Parties dates from the civil war and things a long way back. But that feeling is gradually but surely dying out, and I hope in a very few years it will be gone for good. Surely there is democracy within a Party as well as within a Parliament? Whichever of these Parties they choose, surely these people will be able to make their ideas felt within that Party and eventually within the Government of the country? That is considering the matter from the point of view of the minority of which I am a member. You may call them Unionists, or Protestants, or whatever you like.
From the foundation of this State, there have been Independent members of this House of that persuasion and it must be admitted, in all fairness, that they have contributed to the best of their ability to the social and economic well-being of the country as a whole. I know they have been criticised for standing aloof to a certain extent in the beginning and for not joining with the then existing Parties. Personally, looking back on the situation with historical objectivity, I do not think one can blame them and I do not believe any member of this House does blame them now.
Remember, 90 per cent. of these people—ex-Unionists, shall we call them?—found themselves in a political situation to which they were bitterly opposed. For them to have turned around immediately and joined with their erstwhile enemies, so to speak, would have been wrong and, had they done so at that early stage, they would not to-day enjoy the respect they have gained over the years. As time passed, they were invited and encouraged by the political Parties in the State. They did not do so initially. I am sure most people here are aware of what happened down the years from 1922.
What has happened in relation to the sons and daughters of these people —the second generation? Have they not gradually but surely taken their place in the different organisations— political, agricultural, industrial? They have accepted the invitation, and they are surely, but gradually, taking their place in the life of the nation. That is their rightful position, and they should accept it. They have offered and are offering themselves, with all that they can contribute to the good of the country, to the different organisations throughout the country and to the various political Parties. They have been accepted.
To my mind, that is the proper way for a minority to take its place and the proper manner in which to express its views in this, or any other, country. The proper approach is within the framework of the organisations and Parties which exist. If they wish to influence these Parties and organisations, the correct way in which to do it is from within. That is the stable way, the adult way, in which to serve one's country politically, socially, economically. One should not expect legislation to leave the way open for every two or three people to get together and form a so-called Party in order to get into the Dáil and let off political steam. The Dáil is not the place for that and people desirous of doing that sort of thing should at least have a substantial say in a Party before they expect to be elected to the Dáil.
I am very happy that the minority of which I happen to be one have taken their place in the life of the country and I strongly recommend to another minority that they should follow the example we have set and take their place in the political life of the country through the medium of an already established Party, if that is their wish. If they wish to influence policy, then they can start within the framework of the Party, in a small way at first, perhaps, and with greater force and success later and, if their view is acceptable to the people as a whole, then they will eventually get their way and have their policy accepted.
Comment on this
Aside from politics altogether, one can agree in toto with the sentiments expressed by Senator Cole. Of course, Senator Cole adopts the proper approach to this Bill. He views it as it should be viewed, calmly, dispassionately, objectively. He does not take the view, and rightly so, that minorities will be eliminated under this measure. We have heard a number of arguments from those who oppose the measure that this Bill will sweep away minority representation. So far, I have heard only one or two make the case that a minority can be described as a smaller Party than Fianna Fáil. That is, indeed, a very vague description. It does not represent the true position and I am convinced that those who put forward that argument do not themselves believe in it.
When the Commission on Vocational Organisation was sitting away back in the early '40s, a questionnaire was issued to over 333 bodies of whose existence the commission was aware. Replies were received from roughly 150 bodies; 44 bodies could not be traced; no reply was received from the remaining 139. Oral evidence was taken from 174 organisations in all. These included State bodies, Government Departments and outside organisations. The sentiments expressed in the report are not in conformity with those expressed in this House so far in this debate.
We on this side of the House assert that, whether the present system goes or stays, minority representation will have its fair share in the Houses of the Oireachtas. Yet, Fine Gael, apparently, have taken it upon themselves to act as a buffer, as it were, between the people and the Referendum Bill. We, as a Party supporting the Government, are merely asking the people for a decision as to whether they want to retain P.R. as a system or to revert to the straight vote. We believe, and it is held by many other great organisations in the world, that the straight vote system, if given a chance, will give a period of stability.
Comment on this
We also believe that, if the Fine Gael Party have any faith in the future, they ought to be of one mind on this matter but we have heard and, indeed, until this matter is decided, the people will continue to hear various speeches from different members of Fine Gael and the Opposition Parties. What strikes me, listening to them, is that, somehow or other, they all seem to be in conflict. Most of the leading members of the Fine Gael Party who expressed themselves in the past and who are recorded in this House and in the other House as expressing themselves in favour of a straight vote system are now engaged in a wild campaign—it can be described as nothing but a wild campaign—in order to distort and destroy and to rob the people of their chance to vote on this matter.
One has only to look up the records of the Dáil to discover some of the conflicting arguments advanced by the members of the Opposition. I can recall—and I quote from the free Press—Deputy Dillon on 12th November, 1947, when he said in the lower House:—
"I think P.R. is a fraud and a cod and ought to be abolished. I believe in the single member constituency with the single transferable vote so that the man who gets the support of the largest number of people living in the constituency will represent the constituency."
Comment on this
What do the Fine Gael Party want? Do they want P.R.? Do they want the alternative vote? Do they want a limited form of P.R. or do they want P.R. in a small constituency with the single transferable vote? So far, in this argument, they have not even made that clear and I must say that they have succeeded in confusing me on that issue, at any rate.
Comment on this
I am thankful to Senator L'Estrange for his very sage remarks. Senator L'Estrange came down to Longford last Sunday week and spent an hour roaring at his supporters like a bull at a gate.
Comment on this
That is the only manner in which I can describe it. We in Fianna Fáil do not subscribe to those tactics. We believe in letting each and every member have his say and we believe that that is what has kept us together as a Party and that is what will keep us together in the future as a Party.
Senator Cole rightly posed the query to the Fine Gael Party as to whether they wanted to continue as a separate unit or, on the other hand, whether they had lost faith in the future. If they have lost faith in the future, we cannot restore their faith but we can, at least, keep our own faith and, as in the past, we can continue to work for the aims and objects for which our organisation was founded.
In the course of my travels as a politician I hear a number of people deprecating the efforts of politicians. Some of those people have no experience of public life whatsoever but, on the other hand, I can sympathise with them because of the experience in listening to members of large organisations, like Fine Gael, who represent a goodly section of the community, some of whose followers have no more liking for P.R. than we have, some of whose followers in the past have condemned it as a system and some of whose followers to-day would be prepared to vote against it if they were allowed.
We assert that the intentions of Fianna Fáil as a political Party do not arise on this subject and that the matter of this referendum should be allowed to go to the people uncoloured, unadulterated and unbiassed and that is the very thing that is not going to be allowed to happen. The Fine Gael Party, as I said earlier, have taken it upon themselves to oppose the Bill at every stage. They are now saying, in effect, that the people must not be allowed to take an independent line on this matter. They are saying, in effect, that it must be discoloured so as to cause the greatest amount of confusion possible. As I have said, their attempt to act as a buffer in this matter is to be deprecated.
The system of P.R. has been discussed on many occasions. We are asked why we are introducing a proposal to abolish it now. The reasons are simple enough. The first is that the 12-yearly period for the review of the constituencies is due to expire and the second is that any alterations to be made in the Constitution should be put to the people at the same time. We are prepared to argue that there is nothing wrong about that. When Deputy MacEntee was Minister for Local Government in 1947, he had some doubts about what the results of P.R. as a system of election would be if allowed to continue. Speaking in the Seanad on the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1947, as reported in Volume 34, column 1031, of the Official Report, he said:—
"The Constitution does more than merely set up a Legislature. It also sets up an executive organ, the Government, and for these two arms of the State to function properly something more than an Assembly which will be a mathematical replica of all shades of opinion in the country is necessary."
Even at that time, the Fianna Fáil Party had grave doubts as to the advisability of continuing P.R. as the system of election and at that time conditions for changing the system were not as favourable as they are to-day.
Comment on this
We have now, after many tries, a Government with an overall majority, a Government with a very good prospect of continuing in office for their full term. We have also a period of economic expansion, a period in which all the indicators favour the Government, after one of the worst harvests in history; our balance of payments situation looks all right; and our internal affairs are in order. On the political front, there is no unrest, at least on any big scale with which the Government are not able to grapple at any time, so that when Senator O'Brien said this is not an opportune time, my reply is: "When is the opportune time?" When, like the timid politicians in Europe, have the Irish people admitted that they will forgo their rights to be their own masters? What commission could be set up that would have greater authority to make a recommendation to amend our Constitution than the people? What commission could the Dáil or Seanad recommend to do the work that the people could not do better?
I was surprised to hear Senator O'Brien, who is a man of vast experience, expressing himself in so timid a fashion because it seems to me that the timid politicians of Europe were responsible for two-thirds of the dictatorships which we know to have cropped up in the past 20 years—timid politicians who refused to exercise their rights, refused to uphold the principles of their Parties and, in the long run, refused to uphold the principles of their countries. Since when have Party politics become so discoloured? What is wrong with being a Party politician? Is it not true that as the Trade Union Congress say, through unity they get strength, and if you have all shades of opinion represented in a political Party, is it not a much better means and a much better lever for getting work done——
Comment on this
——than a motley group who have no aims or objects in common? I pose that as a fair question to Senator O'Brien and others who are timid about this matter.
Comment on this
That is an echo, a ghost. I said that timid politicians were the curse of the Continent of Europe and I hope that we in the Fianna Fáil Party will never fall into error in that regard. I hope we shall always continue to uphold what is fair and just and not be afraid to express our views either inside or outside this House.
The Leader of the Opposition Party, Senator Hayes, spoke here yesterday and expressed very strong sentiments in condemnation of our efforts to change this system. I shall not bore the House with quotations from the past, but Senator Hayes was not always as opposed to the straight vote system as he is to-day. For some reason or other in 1947, when the previous change was being made, as reported in Volume 34 of the Official Report, he said that the straight vote was preferable to the limited form of P.R. we were working. What has happened in the meantime to change his views so violently on that matter? We, as a Party, have had 36 odd years of seeing the defects of the present system. One of the things that strike me about it is that no matter what programme a political Party may put before the electorate, they must almost always have a second type.
That has obtained down the years from 1932 onwards and it would have obtained again, I believe, in 1948, but for the desire of the Parties opposite to try out an experiment. We all know that the experiment did not succeed and that it resulted or could have resulted in further splintering. They tried that experiment simply because the atmosphere was favourable to it. Suppose for a moment that they had not a strong Party in opposition and suppose that Fianna Fáil splintered into a number of smaller Parties, would that experiment, even in its limited fashion, succeed or would the Government of the day then run even for a course of three and a half years? I wonder. The experiment tried out was a limited one. It had a limited life but, nevertheless, it was bolstered up and helped by the fact that it had a strong single Party in opposition in the shape of Fianna Fáil.
The Leader of the Opposition in the Dáil, Deputy Costello, expressed himself many times regarding this matter. He is on record as making various speeches. He has this to say in June 1937 when speaking during the Dáil debates on the draft Constitution:—
"Earlier in these debates Deputy de Valera had expressed the hope that P.R. would not, in fact, lead to a multiplicity of Parties, but pointed out that, in any event, the Constitution could be changed by a vote of the people in any respect that might be found necessary."
Deputy Costello then gave his views saying:—
"As regards the abuses the President of the Executive Council fears from a grouping of Parties, or from the intrigues that might go on, as a result of a large number of Parties being returned by P.R., I think that, to a certain extent, is inherent in any system of P.R."
He then recognised that P.R.——
Comment on this
I did not say it was a bad thing. I say that the Leader of the Opposition then recognised the inherent danger in P.R. He knew then, and for a long number of years even before that, that there was always the danger of splintering under P.R. He knew that it had a disintegrating influence and that but for certain safeguards it would have led to trouble here long ago. He knew that but for the power of dissolution which bolstered it up, the power of the people to amend the Constitution and the large group which opposed him in Fianna Fáil, certainly in other circumstances and in a different atmosphere it could lead to trouble in a far shorter period and that it could have put stresses and strains on our economy which were, as I say, not revealed by reason of the fact that it had so many helpful agents and elements in order to give it a chance to survive as long as it did.
Senator Murphy said that Labour is going to be wiped out as a minority. How Senator Murphy arrives at that opinion I do not know. Labour will get their chance. If Labour have a policy, if they pursue that policy and are not led into violent swings one way or the other by reason of coalescing with other Parties, and if they have faith in their policy, I believe that there is a place for Labour under the straight vote system—an even greater place than they have at the present time.
If we are to adopt the attitude that we can have it both ways, then we shall go nowhere. If we set out as a political Party with aims and objects, publish those and put a programme before the people, then I think we should be at least men enough, if you like, to stand behind it and let the Party stand or fall on that footing. No, that is not enough. Fine Gael, of course, have to say to Labour: "Look, Labour, you are going to be wiped out under this. We want you to come up here and toe the line with us on this matter and vote with us and strive——"
Comment on this
Yes, I am just after saying that but Fine Gael induced them along that line. Fine Gael said to them: "Look, Labour, you are going to be wiped out anyway over this thing. Stand in with us for a period until at least we are able to discolour this Bill sufficiently in order to get a biassed view on it from the electorate. If we are able to defeat it, we shall all take our chance afterwards."
Comment on this
I do not know if there has even been agreement on that point. It strikes me that in the welter of confusion there is some sort of line —I am trying to discover it—which the various Parties must toe. Labour is being pushed up to that line. We have in our Party as many representatives of Labour, organised or unorganised, or even more, than any other Party in this House. I think that the Fianna Fáil Party supporting their Government can be deemed to be the best Labour Government this Government ever had.
Comment on this
That is an old slogan. It has no political bite at this stage. As far as the standstill is concerned, we have drawn the Senator's teeth long ago on that matter.
It was mentioned in the course of the debate by some representatives of the universities how desirable it would be that universities should have representation and that the various graduates and those who attend universities should take an active interest in public life. I hope they do and I hope some of them will be weaned away from the idea that you can shoot your way into unity, because you cannot. That idea has been abroad in some of our universities. How it was generated there I do not know, but at this stage in our career it does not take a university graduate to discover that you cannot shoot your way into unity. That idea must die if we are to make any progress in the years ahead.
It was said that we wanted to shoot Sinn Féin under the carpet. We do not agree with that point at all. From my experiences in the 1957 election I want to make the point that Fine Gael are responsible for having an unconstitutional candidate elected to the Dáil.
Comment on this
I will prove it on the figures. I want to make the further point that in a broadcast they condemned the actions of a certain illegal organisation and at the same time they went to the electorate in Longford-Westmeath and they discoloured the situation so much that the Fine Gael electors in Longford-Westmeath extended over 1,000 preference votes to a Sinn Féin candidate who would not recognise them. Is that not so? I defy contradiction on it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I was director of elections in Westmeath and that statement is completely wrong. The country knows where we stood as regards Sinn Féin since 1921. We have been consistent in that. It was not 1,000 of our transfers that put Senator Carter out of the Dáil.
Comment on this
Senator Carter should be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
Senator Carter never mentioned the fact that he was driven out of the Dáil. There are no personalities in this matter. It is just a matter of principle. Senator Carter was prepared to take his chance, the same as any other candidate. I am making the point that the electorate were confused in Longford-Westmeath. Fine Gael supporters, ordinary decent men upholding the traditions of constitutional government, were induced to vote for a non-constitutional candidate by the slogan: "Vote for anyone except a Fianna Fáil candidate".
Comment on this
Yes. You cannot have it both ways. Those who say we are sweeping Sinn Féin under the carpet should examine their own consciences. They should look under their own carpet and see what is there. As far as I know, the gates are open for them.
Comment on this
Whatever claims Sinn Féin may advance are not a matter of moment just now. The candidates returned as Teachtaí Dála do not recognise this Oireachtas. They do not give recognition to the Constitution. Certainly, they do not recognise the Fine Gael Party who were responsible for having some of them elected to the Dáil.
Comment on this
That is some of the discoloration that is thrown on this Bill. That is what all this prolonged argument is about.
Comment on this
It is an attempt by certain people to rob the people of their right to change their own Constitution.
Comment on this
I do not want to turn this speech into an electioneering speech. However, when one has a certain amount of experience, one likes to hear common sense. One likes to have, even in politics, straight dealing. No Party can have it both ways.
Comment on this
I am afraid I shall be an anticlimax after so much eloquence but, if a timid Independent might be borne with by the House to express his views on the proposal, I should be grateful. The trend of political development in the past 20 or 30 years in free Europe has been to increase the political power of the people by extending the voting area. At first, it looks as if the proposal before us at present will limit the political power of the individual by decreasing his field of choice. That in itself is a thing that those of us who regard ourselves as individuals and members of the minority must examine closely. We shall proceed to examine it partly by referring to the debates that have taken place in the other House where the subject was discussed exhaustingly, if not exhaustively, and partly to the arguments put forward in our meetings yesterday and to-day.
My first difficulty in approaching this subject in a detached manner is that you are endeavouring to abolish P.R.; well and good, so be it, but what will you do instead? Instead, you are proposing to replace it by the single non-transferable vote. Unfortunately, the trend of the arguments has largely been towards emphasising the merits or defects of P.R. An adequate case has not been put forward for the alternative that we are being asked to consider. It is rather as if some well-meaning person said: "Tea is very bad for you. It tans the stomach and splinters the digestion. You must all drink coffee." There are alternatives to coffee." There is milk and there are other beverages.
Comment on this
So I believe. It is not enough to presume that the only alternative to P.R. is the single non-transferable vote. That is wrong. I should feel much happier if the proposed change were from P.R. to the transferable single vote. I feel we have wasted a lot of other people's time in stressing the merits or demerits of P.R. and in not having a case made out and examining the alternatives including the single non-transferable vote, about which I am not at all happy. However, I have many other objections to the situation with which we find ourselves confronted.
An argument advanced—it can sound a very serious argument—is that, in daring to discuss these proposals, we are interfering with the choice of our country, the choice of our people, to answer the straight question—in other words, that we are interfering with the proposed referendum. We are—because we do not see the need for the referendum. The major argument underlying that can be disposed of in this way. If that argument were to hold good then every year would be a matrimonial leap year. Imagine a man wondering whether he would pop the question or not and being told by a friend that he is interfering with the lady's right to reply. Before Caitlín Ní hUallacháin can reply to the question she must be asked it and in a clear way in which she knows exactly who is proposing what, why, when and where.
As a result of the proposals before us, it seems to me that three separate individual questions are being asked of Caitlín Ní hUallacháin. There is a hypothetical change; it was referred to yesterday by Senator O'Brien. The procedure which seems to me to confront the unfortunate individual elector with a very complicated and logical dilemma is: "If A. goes, B. follows and C. takes its place, will you agree?" Surely it would have been possible to devise a simpler formula? Surely it would have been better to say: "We propose to set up a non-transferable single vote instead of the present system; are you in favour of this?"
By the time you have worked out the full significance of P.R. you get so confused that you just have to look to your leaders for information and opinion. After all, P.R. is an extraordinarily confusing issue. There is a great deal to be said on both sides. Those arguments, by analogy, in relation to what has taken place and is taking place in foreign countries can be very misleading as analogous arguments can be misleading. To attribute the disaster of 1940 in France to P.R. is historically unsound. The disaster of 1940 and the so-near disaster of 1914 both stemmed from the disaster of 1870 when there was anything but P.R. in France, when there was the dictatorship of Napoleon III.
I happened to be in Paris in the 1920's at the time of a very violent French election. I would not have described the way it was carried out as P.R. P.R. misrepresentation might have been a more accurate term. I saw the posters of the various Parties, in colour. The nearest things they remind me of were some of the circus posters I used to see as a small boy.
Each one set forth the merits of the elephants and the acrobats of each Party. There was the most fearful abuse by opposing Parties. At one stage, I feared I should not be able to get out of France alive. I discussed it with my friends but they said: "Our politics are like that. The politicians take it seriously, but we do not." To argue that the operations of P.R. in France, our great and friendly neighbour, are in any way like the system working here is, I think, quite unsound.
Turning to the question of the Constitution itself, I regard the Constitution as something sacred and changes in it should be made only under the very gravest conditions of necessity. The method of introduction of the proposed change in the Constitution seems to me to raise many objections. First of all, it was not on a parliamentary programme. The proposed change came on us very suddenly. Coming on so suddenly it of course engendered a great deal more heat than would normally have been caused and I deplore that. The Constitution is such a precious possession that changes in it should not be made a Party matter. A decision on any changes should be made by the will of the majority in the Oireachtas and left open to a free vote.
As regards the timing of the changes, it would be more appropriate to make such a proposal towards the end of a season of Parliament. Then if the Party in power failed to get the proposal carried they could take it to the country. It is not right to bring it in at this stage and in this manner. As regards the arguments on the Bill I have heard no convincing arguments in favour of the single non-transferable vote. Perhaps we shall hear them later. The principal argument in favour of the abolition of P.R. is this danger of splintering. Surely the difficulty goes a bit deeper than that.
I should like to refer to what was said on this question of Parties by the Leader of this House, by Senator Carter and Senator Cole. I have pondered this question for a long time; I have raised it several times in the House and got no satisfactory answer, namely, what is to be the ultimate cleavage of the Irish Parliament? We believe in the parliamentary system. Parliament exists because men think alike. Governments and Oppositions exist because men tend to differ. I believe in a system which gives a strong Government and a strong Opposition. It is the duty of the Opposition to criticise the Government knowing that sooner or later the Opposition will be faced with the responsibility of assuming power itself. That exercises a check on the Opposition.
We all know of the cleavages in Parliament long ago. In Britain it was the Whig and Tory. There are other cleavages we could mention. In our country we had the isolationists and the associationists, two natural cleavages in connection with the major problem of our country, Partition. The isolationists would say: "We will make this country so desirable that eventually they will come home to us." The associationists would say: "We will make some kind of framework into which all of us can fit." That is one type of cleavage. Another type would be agriculture versus industry, representing two ways in which human effort and ingenuity can be channelled, each requiring the operations of a Party to safeguard its interests.
The two major Parties here, as we know, have arisen from an unhappy far-off event which is receding in time but which still casts its shadows. However, they do not now represent a rational division of political opinion. That we know, because so many of our friends, when we ask what Party they are voting for, will say: "I do not vote for Parties now. I vote for men. I vote for men I can trust and in whom I can have confidence." If we can eventually evolve a balance in the Parties I think the splintering danger will disappear. The principal fault in our present situation is our inability to divide into two acceptable, counterpoising Parties. What may come of it I do not know but I am reminded by Senator Cole of the words of Grattan who said: "You may change the Constitution but the character of the country you cannot change."
Whatever happens I still have every confidence in the sanity of my countrymen, in my own sanity and in the patience of this House. This referendum question is a rather complicated one. It is really not an issue to which you can say "yes" or "no." For that reason I do not feel I can honestly support the proposal.
Comment on this
It seems a truism to say the Seanad is one of the Houses of the Oireachtas but it appears to me to be necessary to say that. Article 15 of the Constitution provides:—
"1º The National Parliament shall be called and known, and is in this Constitution referred to, as the Oireachtas.
2º The Oireachtas shall consist of the President and two Houses, viz.: a House of Representatives to be called Dáil Éireann and a Senate to be called Seanad Éireann."
The reason I refer to these truisms is the editorial which appears in this morning's issue of the Irish Press. That paper in its editorial exemplifies the position in which the Fianna Fáil Party find themselves on this question. Having nothing but bad arguments to put in favour of their proposal they fall back on silly arguments. The article reads:—
"Having opposed the Bill providing for the referendum at every stage in the Dáil, they—"
meaning Fine Gael—
"—are now striving to hold it up in the Seanad. That was the sole purpose of Senator Hayes's proposal to keep the Bill there for 90 days, the utmost delay possible under the Constitution."
Then it goes on to say in the next following paragraph:—
"A more serious aspect of Senator Hayes's proposal is that it asks the Senate to act in conflict with its plain duty."
I think the first duty of the Seanad is to examine and scrutinise all Bills that come to it from the Dáil and, in discussing this Bill, it is doing no more than its plain constitutional duty. Furthermore, I would like to remind the leader writer in the Irish Press that under the British constitutional system, which is so much admired by the present Government that it is now proposing to introduce the British system of election, the House of Lords has delaying power and can delay a Bill, not for 90 days, but for two years and these Bills can never get to the people.
Comment on this
They were so much better in this country in devising our constitutional procedure than the British. The British never thought of devising a written Constitution as we have, and it is for that reason I would be glad the people would continue to use the Constitution they themselves have enacted and which they themselves adopted.
Senator Kissane yesterday brought us through certain sections of the report of the Royal Commission of 1908. I have been unable yet to trace the report of the commission in question but it seems more than strange that again, in order to bolster up the arguments in favour of the Government's proposal, we have to dig up the report of a Royal Commission that is now 50 years out of date. It is a very poor commentary upon the strength of the case made in favour of this Bill but, in any event, what I would like to observe on that report is that that report was talking about a theoretical position. We are not talking about a theoretical position in this country. We are talking about something of which we know, something that has been with us for 40 years or so. We know how P.R. has worked. As far back as 21 years ago the Taoiseach was able to say: "The system we have we know; the people know it", and we do not have to go back to a Royal Commission of 50 years ago to find out whether P.R. does suit, or does not suit, this country.
Professor Stanford, in his very lucid and able speech last night, said that the shift of emphasis should be from Party and Government to people and Parliament, and that is a point of view with which I entirely agree. As the Constitution provides, the Dáil is a House which is representative of the people. That is the fundamental property which the Dáil has, that it is representative of the people and, being representative of the people, it is provided in Article 28 of the Constitution that the Government shall be responsible to Dáil Éireann. In other words, it means that the Government shall be responsible to the representatives of the people, and the representatives of the people know the views of the people as well as any ten, 11 or 12 members of a Government and are, therefore, in a position to comment upon various measures that have been put through by the Government. That is the way by which the democratic system works properly when you have a Dáil, when you have a public House or a House of Representatives making the Government answerable to it.
It is extremely easy to point out what will happen in a general kind of way, to say that this system proposed by the Government will give a large majority to one Party and will give strong Opposition, eliminating small Parties and thereby integrating the opposition from three or four small Parties into one strong Opposition. I should like to put the point of view to the House that we should try to look at the proposed system as it would work out in practice. One of the great safeguards which the democracies have, and which totalitarian systems of government have not, is that under the democratic system the Government is daily answerable to the Dáil. Under the system proposed we may well find ourselves in a position where the Government will not, in fact, be answerable to anybody except to itself. That is the curious, paradoxical position in which we shall find ourselves because the Government will control the Party and the Party will act as the Government wants it to act. Therefore, you get into the curious situation where the Government can do what it likes irrespective of the wishes of the Party and, of course, irrespective of the wishes of the community.
Some people have forecast that under the proposed system it is possible that out of a Dáil of 140 seats the Government—whether it be a Fianna Fáil Government, a Fine Gael Government, a Labour Government or any other kind of Government—would have 120 out of 140 seats. That would leave probably an Opposition of 20 seats. If they want to work it out at 100 seats to 40 I am quite prepared to do so for the purposes of my argument. It seems to me it would be somewhere in the region of 100 seats. If that were not to be the case, there would be no purpose in saying that this system would give you a strong Government and, if we have that position, I want to ask the Taoiseach, who has on different occasions spoken of the necessity for strong opposition, to indicate how we are going to have strong opposition.
Deputy Booth, speaking in the Dáil, as reported at column 1191, Volume 171 of the Official Report, said:—
"Let the Deputy look up his facts and he will see that many times the Taoiseach has reflected on the absolute necessity for having a strong, virile, intelligent Opposition, which will query everyone. Let us forget about that."
I take that to mean: "Let us not forget about that."
"The new system cannot, will not, and must not wipe out the Opposition."
One of the restraints which is exercised upon Governments in a parliamentary democracy is the answerability of the Government to Parliament every day, and the means by which the Government is made answerable to the Dáil every day is the Parliamentary Question. Under the new situation you will have 120 constituencies which will be represented by the Government Party. Will anybody tell me that if there is a person resident in one of these 120 constituencies he is going to get his Deputy to put down a question of a kind that will embarrass the Government? Of course he will not and that means, as far as 120 out of 140 constituencies are concerned, the use of the Parliamentary Question will be completely nullified by this measure. I might say it is not so much at the moment that people can ask these questions that their rights are safeguarded. It is the very system of the Parliamentary Question which prevents abuses, and everybody knows that. It is the fact that something that is done or is not done, by a Government Department or by a Government Minister, may be made the subject of a Parliamentary Question which prevents the abuses which you have in totalitarian countries.
Mind you, in talking about abuses I am not saying that one Government more than another is likely to be guilty of gross abuses of any kind. These abuses just happen through expediency or through the desire on the part of a Government Minister to favour one more than another. They can arise in the granting of licences, in the making of grants, in the issuing of permits and so on, and so many of the rights of the people nowadays are determined by statute, and are in the hands of Government Ministers and Government Departments, it is of vital importance to the people that they should, at every stage, be able to question Ministers and call them to account in the Dáil for their activities. But as far as I can see the Parliamentary Question would be nullified for the vast majority of the people.
Since reference has been made so frequently to the British system I am given to understand, on good authority, that in Britain a member of the Government Party never puts down any kind of question that would embarras a Minister of his own Party. That is natural enough and quite understandable but you could have the Crickel Down affair in England and you can have other things that have happened since.
The Taoiseach spoke about a strong and virile Opposition. It will want to be an extremely strong and virile Opposition if half the number of Deputies will be able to perform the work now performed by the present Opposition. Will anybody tell me how an Opposition comprising as few as 20, or perhaps as many as 40 members, is going to deal with all aspects of Government business that will fall to be dealt with in the new situation? Every year on average we have from 30 to 50 Bills going through the Dáil. If the Dáil is not to become a mere rubber stamp—a kind of machine like a slot machine where you insert a penny and a penny stamp comes out— if it is not to reach that situation, we must have sufficient people to examine Bills as there are at the present time. I cannot see how, under the new situation, that will happen.
Then you have the votes for the different Estimates, in which, apart altogether from legislation, the policy of the different Ministers of the Government as a whole in relation to the different matters dealt with in the various Departments of State, is open to examination and criticism. The allocation of moneys towards different projects also comes under review. How does anybody think that you will draw from as few as 20 Deputies sufficient men who will have the time and the knowledge to examine the up to 100 Estimates which are contained in the Book of Estimates? Are we to have moneys voted without any adequate consideration by the Opposition of how these moneys are to be devoted?
Where are the 20 people to get the time to examine and criticise the Estimates? If they do not examine the Estimates and do not criticise them, then we might as well forget about parliamentary government because we will, in fact, have a Government putting through whatever it alone thinks is in the best interests of the people. We know very well what happened with Governments who thought that what they were putting through was in the best interests of the people. We had it in Germany and Italy; we have it in Russia, Yugoslavia, Roumania, Czechoslovakia and China. All these Governments think they are acting in the best interests of the people. That is what we are going to have in this country, a Government that will be able to put through any legislation that they want to because there will be insufficient people available as an Opposition to act as any kind of brake on the Government.
There has been a great deal of talk about Coalition Governments. I am glad that Senator Stanford, with his authority as a Professor of Classics, has pointed out that "coalition" is a neutral word and that "stability" is a neutral word, because I always thought Coalition Governments were a very good thing and I think that I am not incorrect in saying that coalitions did a great deal of good in this country. At least, they gave confidence to the people that should the Taoiseach pass from the political scene, lo and behold, there could be another Government that could continue the affairs of State for up to three years. That was one great achievement of the first Coalition Government. Deputy Dillon in the Dáil often states, and rightly so, that as a result of two periods of coalition government we have doubled the volume of our exports and trebled their value, and that is a fact.
Comment on this
Last year we had an increase in our cattle entirely due to the policy pursued by Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture. The statistics are there. These statistics are collected by the Statistics Office, which is under the control of the Taoiseach; it was brought under the control of the Taoiseach so that people would be able to rely on the statistics. I trust that if people on the opposite side laugh because these statistics are quoted they are not in any way implying that there is anything wrong with them.
Another reason the Coalition Government of 1948 was to be welcomed was that it was a sign of the people maturing politically; it was part of the process of evolution which has made the British Constitution the Constitution that it is. As Senator O'Brien pointed out last night, a Constitution is an organic thing and, in many ways, a Constitution is as good as the way it is worked and the use made of it. Therefore, when within the framework of the Constitution, you had a Government truly answerable to Dáil Éireann —and you had such a Government in 1948—it was something to be grateful for and something to be welcomed, because it was part of the proper way in which a Constitution should be developed.
Apart altogether from the aspect of the Parliamentary Question, because that is only a safeguard which is there to prevent abuses, I also want to point out that the existence, and the need for, a strong Opposition have been recognised in this country over the Accounts Committee and the purpose of the Public Accounts Committee is to examine the Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General on the expenditure of the moneys voted by the Oireachtas for Government services. The chairmanship of the Public Accounts Committee is traditionally held by a member of the Opposition Party. That is another of the safeguards which have been recognised in this country, to keep the Government in check. Our whole constitutional system and our practice have been designed to keep the Government in check because it has been recognised by political theorists and practical politicians that a Government with too much power is dangerous. Would anybody tell me where, out of 20 Deputies forming an Opposition, having to do the work now performed by three times that number, we are going to get in future a chairman for the Public Accounts Committee?
At this stage I want to refer to the very serious flaw which arises from comparing the system of government which operates in Britain with the system we have here. It is all very well to say that the two-Party system has worked well in Britain and that therefore it should work well here but we must recognise that there are substantial differences between this country and Britain. Otherwise, we could not have separated from them. Apart altogether from philosophies or politics there are physical differences and economic differences. This country has a population of fewer than three million while Britain has a population of about 48 million and that makes a difference of 45 million. That is something of a difference when you come to talk about a political system and a method of electing representatives for the people.
As a result of that disparity in population you have of course a much higher number of seats in the House of Commons than we have here. Consequently when you talk about the two-Party system working well in Britain and of there being, as we know, a strong Opposition, you must have regard to the fact that it is possible to have a strong Opposition in Britain because you have a larger number of seats in the House of Commons than we have here, whereas when it comes to forming a Government the difference between the number of people necessary to form a Government in Britain and here is not very great and for that reason people are inclined to assimilate the two positions.
Since 1910 the lowest number to which the Opposition fell in Britain was 61 in 1931, but it is an entirely different thing to try to form an Opposition from as few as 20, or even from 40 people, as we are asked to do in this country. We are asked to brand that as a strong and virile Opposition.
Senator Ó Maoláin asked yesterday, if you had some instrument that proved defective, what would you do but bring it back to the people who made it. That is one kind of simile, but if I had someone who advised me wrongly in regard to the building of a house, somebody who said the foundations were all right when he had doubts about them, I certainly would not have that man to advise me again and I think Senator Ó Maoláin would adopt the same attitude. He would have nothing whatever to do with him. Now the country is to be asked to adopt the advice of the Taoiseach on this measure.
At column 993 of Volume 171 of the Official Report, the Taoiseach is reported as having said:—
"I have been asked why I did not incorporate it in the Constitution. When we took office, there was already a Constitution here. Subsequently my anxiety was to get the new Constitution through, and it was my desire to keep as close as possible to the system with which the people were familiar. I can also confess—I have no difficulty whatever in confessing—that, like many another thing, it looked all right on paper and I was affected by that. I was one of the first to say, in 1919, that although I knew quite well the fundamental reasons which urged the British to introduce the system, yet I felt that in our circumstances at the time it was not likely to do harm. On paper, it appeared to be a fair system. It was for that reason I retained it, but I said at the time that, though it had worked out all right up to then, if at any time it proved to be unsatisfactory, it could be changed."
The Taoiseach spoke to the same effect on the Final Stage of the Bill. I can only ask: Is the Taoiseach entirely satisfied, in the light of all the argument that he has heard, that the new system he is proposing is the best system? Bagehot, the political theorist, said: "There is no man as wise on any matter as a number of men after a good discussion." He was commenting on the British Constitution. I wonder if the Taoiseach still has doubts as to whether the new system is as good as he thinks it will be. I, for one, would not be inclined to adopt, and certainly do not adopt, the advice that he now gives because it is as clear to me as daylight that the new proposals if put into effect, so far from improving the lot of the people, would take away or endanger many of their rights.
I could also quote the Taoiseach on another occasion—in 1951, I think— after the first Coalition Government. The Taoiseach had been to America and had met some of the Red Indian chiefs. He came back with a homely proverb of which he gave the Irish people the benefit. He told them in 1948 these groups had got together and formed a Coalition Government and, of course, the country had been in a dreadful mess on account of that: "Let that not happen again. As the old Indians used to say: ‘Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me'." The people were ill-advised in 1936 by the Taoiseach apparently, on his own admission; they ought not be ill-advised the second time.
There is no doubt that P.R. gives representation to Parties in accordance with the wishes of the people and it is for the people to decide who their representative will be. If, during the last 21 years, the people wanted a two-Party system they could have had it. They could have voted Fine Gael or Labour, but they did not want that. They could have had the two Parties, Fine Gael and the Labour Party but they did not want that. They could have voted Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael if they wanted to. As Professor Fearon remarked this afternoon—I cannot put it as well as he did—we can only have in political life what the people want to give. You cannot force the people into the straitjacket of the two-Party system. Anybody who reads history will see how difficult it is to effect changes in the minds of people or force them to go along a particular path.
The Peace of Westphalia in 1648, 310 years ago, laid down the principle of cuius regio eius religio, by which it was intended that the people in a particular State should adopt the religion of their prince and, of course, it did not work. That is the teaching of history. Of course, it did not work because people have minds and wills of their own. If the Taoiseach thinks that this constitutional measure will change the views of the people, the people who always thought that Labour was right, the people who always thought that Fine Gael was right, the people who always thought that Sinn Féin was right, he must be ignoring his own experience and he is certainly ignoring the teaching of history.
As I say, the system of P.R. in our country has given Parties seats in proportion to the number of votes cast for them. That is all they are entitled to get. I have here some figures which I quote from the book Voting in Democracies by Enid Lakeman and James D. Lambert. This appears to be the first edition. I understand it is to go into another edition. On page 243, there is an appendix which shows that in the 1933 election Fianna Fáil got 49½ per cent. of the votes and 50½ per cent. of the seats. That is proportionate. Clann na Gaedheal—I take it that should be Cumann na nGaedheal —got 30½ per cent. of the votes and 31½ per cent. of the seats; the Centre Party got 9 per cent. of the votes and 7 per cent. of the seats; Labour got 6 per cent. of the votes and 5 per cent. of the seats; Independents got 5 per cent. of the votes and 6 per cent. of the seats and that is all the seats they were entitled to get.
In the 1951 elections—the figures for 1948 are also available—Fianna Fáil got 46 per cent. of the votes and 47½ per cent. of the seats; Fine Gael got 25½ per cent. of the votes and 26½ per cent. of the seats; Clann na Poblachta got 4 per cent. of the votes and 1½ per cent. of the seats—that is where P.R. does not necessarily favour splinter or small Parties; Labour got 11½ per cent. of the votes and 11 per cent. of the seats; Farmers got 3 per cent. of the votes and 4 per cent. of the seats; Independents got 10 per cent. of the votes and 9½ per cent. of the seats.
That is representing the people according to their wishes and that is the way the people are entitled to be represented, according to their wishes, but this measure proposes to say to the people: "You are not to have your wishes any more. You will vote the way we say is in the best interests of the country."
Before I go any further, I want to point out that, when it did come to amending the Constitution, the Government might at least have produced an amendment that will work from a mechanical point of view and will not require further amendment as it appears to me this amendment will require in a few years' time.
It is proposed to set up a commission. There are a number of people who think that the commission being set up under this Bill is something like the type of commission one ordinarily hears about, before which people will be able to give evidence, to which people who have been aggrieved by a decision of a previous commission will be able to make representation and get the commission to change the demarcation of the boundaries. As I read the Bill, there is no intention of giving the people any such right. The people are to have no rights, apparently, as to the way in which they are to be represented or as to the constituencies in which they are to be put. They will be deprived fairly effectively of any opportunity to express their view in Dáil Éireann because the report of the commission can be set aside or modified only by a two-thirds majority of the Dáil.
At any rate, it is proposed to establish a commission. I take it that it is intended that the commission should be able to function but it seems to me that in certain circumstances, which are not unusual circumstances at all. the commission will be absolutely unable to function and will reach a constitutional impasse where there will be nothing for it but to go back to the people to get them to amend the Constitution to get themselves out of the mess into which this amendment has got them.
It is provided that the commission will consist of seven people, three nominated by the Taoiseach and three by the Ceann Comhairle, with a chairman who will be nominated by the President. An extraordinary provision is that the President, for reasons which to him seem sufficient, may terminate the appointment of any member of the commission and, of course, such a decision cannot be the subject of any query by the courts. That may be strange, but there it is.
The important thing is that the quorum of the constituency commission shall be four and the commission may act notwithstanding vacancies in its membership. Any member of the commission, it is provided, may resign from office by placing his resignation in the hands of the President. Supposing there is a judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court who is chairman of the commission and he finds that the situation is so utterly impossible that he cannot do anything with it and he places his resignation in the hands of the President. There is no provision in this Bill for appointment of another chairman and, therefore, you could have a commission consisting of six people which, under the Constitution, may still act, notwithstanding a vacancy in its membership.
There is nothing in this Bill which says that there must always be a chairman. Supposing, then, that you have the six members of the commission, three from the Government side and three from the Opposition, each side at loggerheads for a period up to six months. Undoubtedly, they would fail to secure unanimous agreement or agreement by a majority. It is then provided in the Bill that the chairman shall, not later than seven months after the date of the President's request, present to the President a report setting out the boundaries and that will be the report of the commission, but, in the situation which I have instanced—and it is quite a possibility because there will be no obligation on a judge to continue sitting; he may place his resignation in the hands of the President; that is his constitutional right, which cannot be denied to him—we would have a commission that cannot agree and there might be no report of any kind, good, bad or indifferent.
That is the kind of Bill the people are being asked to implement, a Bill that will not work in a quite foreseeable contingency. There is always the President. It may be argued that the President might not accept the judge's resignation. I do not think the President can refuse to do so. Supposing, after the rigours of six months' arguing, or apart altogether from that, the judge who is chairman falls ill— and judges are as liable to fall ill as the next—and that six months have elapsed and seven months elapse and the judge is advised by his doctors that he ought to do no work. Again, in that circumstances, we will have the situation where we will have a commission that has not produced a report; there is no chairman to produce a report and we are into a constitutional crisis. If that is the way in which it is intended to establish a constitutional organ, it does not seem to me to be paying much respect to the Constitution to incorporate such a haphazardly devised system upon which it is expected this commission will work.
The Taoiseach and other members of Fianna Fáil in the Dáil and here have stated it is not intended to abolish small Parties. That seems to be a contradiction because one would imagine the whole purpose of the Bill was to abolish small Parties. Whether or not it is the intention, that, in the opinion of very many people, will be the result. As Senator Murphy pointed out today, the whole trade union movement is to be deprived of a political arm. I venture to think that the existence of the political arm of the trade union movement has been a very stabilising force in industry in this country. It is an enormous wrong to members of trade unions to impose a standstill wages Order, while allowing prices and profits to rise, but it is some satisfaction to members of trade unions to know that they have in Parliament people who will vindicate and defend their rights. If a situation of this kind were to occur again, or if any other kind of legislation were to be introduced by the Government and there was no political arm, no member of a trade union to voice the opinions of the trade unionists and protest on their behalf, that small safeguard that existed—the safeguard that people have at least been heard—will have been done away with. You would have what obtains in France, Italy and other countries—general strikes that would paralyse the whole economy. They had a general strike in Argentina the other day, and it required strong action on the part of the Government. We have no doubt that the strong Government would be able to take strong action, irrespective of the rights of the people concerned.
Those who voice their fears about the abolition of small Parties are, in my opinion, very correct. They have got a good view of what the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Government to minorities has been in the past. They have had no time for minorities. They have sought by legislative act to abolish these minorities.
Comment on this
In 1941, the Government put through the Oireachtas an Act entitled the Trade Union Act, 1941. Under that Act it was provided that a tribunal was to be set up. On this occasion, it was a tribunal, not a commission. Always set up somebody else to do the work you do not like to do.
Comment on this
The commission I want set up is a commission that will inform and recommend, not a tribunal that will decide. Under the 1941 Act, the tribunal had the final decision. Under this Bill, the commission will have the final decision and Parliament will have to have a two-thirds majority to alter it.
The Trade Union Act provided that if there were a certain number of trade unions catering for members of a particular class of workman, the larger of these could apply to the tribunal to have the sole right of organising all the workers in that class. If the tribunal so decided, then for a period of five years, the other trade unions, the minority unions, would not be entitled and it would be an offence punishable by law to admit a new member. That is the way in which it was proposed to treat a free association whose freedom is guaranteed under the Constitution. Freedom of association is one of the personal and fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution. In the teeth of that guarantee, that was the way the Government proposed to deal with trade unions. It is much easier to talk to one big body and to make a deal with it. But the small unions can keep the bigger ones on their toes, and minorities can be troublesome. That is the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Government towards minorities. They have no right to exist—they are too troublesome. "We cannot be dealing with these people; get rid of the lot of them."
We have had a good deal of talk about what goes on in other countries.
Comment on this
Excuse me, Senator. You mentioned minorities. Would you give us more examples now? You said a Bill was passed which was to suppress minorities and that there were many cases where Fianna Fáil attempted to suppress minorities. Now give us more.
Comment on this
I shall make my speech in my own way. I will not be cross-examined or cross-questioned by Senator Mullins.
Comment on this
If Senator Mullins has a point of order to raise or a question to put, there is an orderly way of doing it, and the Senator is quite aware of that.
Comment on this
I shall give the Senator another example. In 1953, we had the situation in which the Government had its own employees under its thumb. The Civil Service got an award at arbitration which gave them certain entitlement. We had the Government saying: "No, we will not pay that; we will not give you what is your right." That was a small minority appeal. In relation to the rest of the community, the Civil Service stands as a minority. That was the treatment meted out to them by the Government. The Government may have revised its position since then. That was an example of a minority with no power.
We have had a great deal of reference to what has been happening all over the world in regard to P.R. We have heard it said that it is not in operation in many countries. It might be well if we clarified our minds on what countries it has, in fact, been operating in and in what way it has been operated, with a view to having another look at this Bill. I have examined the Constitutions of 89 nations. Eighty of these have written Constitutions. There are two cases where there are no written Constitutions. These are Egypt and Pakistan. At present they are only formulating Constitutions. There are three of them which have interim Constitutions: Cuba, Indonesia and Nepal. An interesting feature of the Constitutions of the world is that most of them are of recent origin, 45 per cent. being less than ten years old and 56 per cent. less than 25 years old.
All these Constitutions, therefore, have been drafted in the light of modern experience and in the light of what happened in Germany, Italy, France and other countries. Sixteen of these countries have Governments of a federal type. Sixteen States are federal States—Argentine, Australia, Austria, Brazil, Canada, Germany, India, Libya, Mexico, Switzerland, U.S.S.R., Finland, Yugoslavia, U.S.A., Burma and the Union of South Africa. It seems to me to be wholly fallacious and absolutely wrong to draw comparisons between the Constitution of a unitary State, such as those with a heterogeneous population, and a country with different independent States within the State and with a wide diversity of people and population.
Another matter which has a bearing on this question is the form of Legislature which these countries have; 49 of them have a bicameral legislative system and 38 have a unicameral legislative system; eight have no elected representatives. These latter are small like Andorra and Liechtenstein.
Great play has been made with the fact that the former Taoiseach had something to say about the form in which P.R. was put into the 1937 Constitution. Deputy Costello wished to have the position flexible. He wished to have the precise form of P.R. applied here determined by law. There would be no difficulty whatever in doing that here. On the other hand, the present Taoiseach, of course, has always struck out for rigidity. He argued for that in 1936 and 1937, and that is his argument on the present Bill.
The curious position is that of the 18 nations that have P.R. there are only two or three which defined in their Constitutions the precise form they have. If the Taoiseach had taken the advice tendered when the 1937 Constitution was being discussed we would not now be in the situation of having to put the country to the expense of a referendum on this issue. We would, rather, be in a position in which a large measure of agreement could be secured as to the best system of P.R. to be applied in our circumstances and in the light of our experience.
It is not valid, I think, to compare Austria with this country because Austria is a Federal State. However, the Constitution of Austria is the Constitution of 1920, amended in 1925 and 1929 respectively, and declared law in 1945 on the ending of the occupation. That Constitution provides in Article 26 that the National Council, which is the equivalent of our Dáil, shall be elected by the people of the Federation according to the principles of P.R. on the basis of equal, direct, secret and personal suffrage of men and women who have completed their 21st year. It is also provided that the Federal electoral law determines whether and under what conditions persons who are not citizens shall have the right to vote. Details concerning electoral procedure are determined by Federal Law. That is a country which has not got a precise form of P.R. tied up in its Constitution.
In Belgium, P.R. was introduced in 1921. There have been various revisions since then, but it has never occurred to the Belgian people that P.R. has caused economic chaos, political instability, emigration and so forth. It has not occurred to them that P.R. has been responsible for these things and that they should, therefore, abolish it.
Brazil also has P.R. I understand from Press reports that Brazil is founding a new Government. Its Constitution was adopted in 1946—adopted, I take it, in the light of the knowledge of the harrowing experiences we have had here as a result of P.R. One would have thought that Brazil, when drafting its new Constitution, would have regard to the disastrous effects into which P.R. has led us and be warned thereby. But that has not happened.
In Denmark, the Constitution of 1953 replaced that of 1920. Article 31 provides that the members of the Folketing shall be elected by general and direct ballot. Rules for the exercise of the suffrage are laid down by Act of Parliament which, to secure equal representation, shall prescribe the manner of election and decide whether P.R. shall be adopted with or without election to single-member constituencies. There, you have P.R. in single-member constituencies. Apparently, Denmark, when amending its Constitution as late as 1953, did not find in its experience that P.R. had wrought havoc and economic instability.
P.R. is also provided for in the Constitution of Ecuador. Its Constitution was adopted in 1946, P.R. is provided for in Finland, but the precise form of it is not provided for in the Constitution. That is dealt with by the Diet Act of 1928 which provides that representatives shall be elected by direct and personal suffrage. For these elections, the country shall be divided into electoral districts, with a minimum of 12 and a maximum of 18, and the rest of the procedure is laid down in the Act of Parliament.
I come now to West Germany. According to one of the speakers supporting Fianna Fáil, Hitler came to power as a result of P.R. As I understand modern history, Hitler came to power and then proceeded to abolish the Constitution. He got a clear overall majority and was able to form such a strong Government that he could abolish the Constitution and lead Europe into the situation into which he led it subsequently.
Comment on this
Yes, they were all wrong except his Party. That being the position, if P.R. had wrought the destruction of Germany and brought about a world war, one would imagine that Western Germany, determined in its Constitution to adopt peaceful means for the solution of its problems and thereby contribute to world peace and so one, and remembering all the sorrows, destruction, pain and woe it had been through, would have seen that P.R. had brought about the rule of Hitler and had caused all the woes and sufferings they endured, and, in the light of that experience, would say that, whatever other form of government or system of election they adopted, they would not adopt P.R.
Comment on this
That, of course, is not the case, because Federal Germany has adopted P.R. I shall read for the benefit of the Seanad the relevant article from the Constitution of Western Germany:—
"38. The Deputies of the Bundestag shall be elected by the people in universal, free, equal, direct and secret elections. They shall be representatives of the people as a whole, not bound to orders and instructions, and subject only to their conscience.
"The Federal Convention which elects the Federal President consists of members of the Bundestage and an equal number of members elected by the popular representative bodies of the Laender according to the principles of P.R."
If Senator Lenihan wants to produce something which shows that Federal Germany does not employ the system of P.R., I shall immediately withdraw what I have said. I am not trying to pull a fast one; I am trying to give the House the benefit of some tedious research and I trust I am not being tedious in doing so.
Iceland has a Parliament which dates back as far as the year 900, the oldest parliament in history. It has P.R. They amended the Constitution there as lately as 1944 and they have not seen that P.R. has done them any harm.
Comment on this
Italy was another country mentioned by one of the Fianna Fáil speakers—Senator Ó Maoláin, I think. I quote from this book by Messrs. Lakeman and Lambert, to which I have referred already.
Comment on this
I thought the Senator would be very familiar with it.
Comment on this
The Senator is entitled to have the name of the book.
Comment on this
It is Voting in Democracies, by Enid Lakeman and James D. Lambert.
Comment on this
At page 189, they say:—
"The rise of Fascism was assisted by the ineffective policies and dissensions amongst other groups. By 1922, Mussolini was able to form a cabinet, based on a coalition of four Parties. He introduced a new electoral law"
—this is where Mussolini came to power—
"under which the country was divided into 15 constituencies, and each Party submitted national lists of candidates. The Party with the largest poll was entitled to two-thirds of the seats (356), while the remaining seats were divided proportionally among the other Parties."
That is, the P.R. applied, apparently, only as far as the sharing out of the minority of the seats went.
"As it turned out, the ‘premium' for the largest Party was not needed to secure a Fascist victory; they polled not far short of two-thirds of the votes, and the end of the first experiment in Italian democracy was at hand."
In fact, when Mussolini came into power after the election in 1922, he had been voted into power by nearly two-thirds of the voters.
Comment on this
I would like, through the Chair, to ask the Senator was Signor Mussolini not in power when that amending Electoral Act was introduced?
Comment on this
He was only a member. He was a member of the Parliament, with a fairly substantial representation there.
Comment on this
As far as leading Italy into the war was concerned, P.R. was not the cause.
Comment on this
Too strong a Government. The only country I can find to date which sets down with precision the particular variety of P.R. that should be applied in its election is the State of Luxembourg—and anyone listening to the light programme from Radio Luxembourg will be aware that it is not a State of great consequence. It is not a large State; there are only 300,000 in it and therefore the particular system they have adopted is perhaps suitable to them. In any event, a referendum in Luxembourg is not the same thing as a referendum in a country ten times that size, as this is. It provides that Deputies are elected on the basis of universal suffrage, pure and simple, by ballot, according to the rules of P.R., in conformity with the principle of the smallest electoral quotient and under rules to be determined by law. That delimits the particular system to the proportional system.
Comment on this
Let me turn to the Netherlands Constitution. The Taoiseach has referred to the conversation which passed between the former Prime Minister of Holland and, I think, some member of the British Government. They have P.R. and, as far as my information goes, they have amended their Constitution —their Constitution is more easily amended than the Constitution in this country, as it is done by Act of Parliament—and they have not changed the system.
Likewise, in Nicaragua, the Constitution was adopted in 1950. They have a form of P.R. there. They have had experience of what happened in all the other countries for the last 25 or 30 years and they have thought well to adopt it.
In New Zealand, I am not able to say what the position is, as New Zealand has only whatever Constitution the British Parliament gives it. I think it is the British Parliament which determines the Constitution there. I do not know whether it is able to amend its Constitution so as to change its electoral system.
In Norway, the system of election is proportional. They say:—
"The rules to be applied hereunto, as well as the particular regulations concerning the elections, shall be determined by law, subject to the provisions laid down in the Constitution."
They have a system of P.R. also in Peru, where it is provided by Article 88 of the Constitution that the system of election shall give representation to minorities, with a tendency to proportionality. The details of the system are left to be determined by law.
The House is aware of the system which is in operation in Sweden and Switzerland. The Swedish system is operating under an Act of 1866. The Swiss system is operating under a Constitution which, I think, was last amended in 1874. The only other country I can find that has the same system is Uruguay, but again it does not go the length of determining in what precise form the system shall work under its Constitution.
Comment on this
The Senator promised to tell us something about Cuba and I was waiting for him to come to Cuba.
Comment on this
I did not make any promise to anybody to say anything about Cuba, but if the Senator was listening to me, he would have heard me say at the beginning that there were three countries which had only a provisional Constitution and Cuba was one. If the Senator does not listen to me, it is not my fault.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has always expressed his intense dislike of Coalition Governments——
Comment on this
——and he was even known on one occasion to have expressed his hatred for them, purely, of course, as a form of Government. If that is so, I find it extremely difficult to understand the point of view which the Taoiseach adopted in certain passages of his speech in the Dáil on this Bill. At column 337, Volume 172, of the Official Reports, the Taoiseach said:—
"Let us look at where the system we propose is working and see what is happening."
I have looked at the system all over the world and I find it works in 18 countries.
Comment on this
I have indicated at any rate, that all the woes and evils that have been attributed to it in France, Italy and Germany exist only in the minds of the Senators opposite, or the Fianna Fáil Senators opposite. The Taoiseach went on:—
"I do say that it does not tend so much to create these Parties. What generally happens is that you have various sections of the community represented to varying extents in the major Parties, because it does tend to discourage the creation of a number of small Parties, which in most cases are purely artificial."
The small Parties are purely artificial.
"They do not represent any fundamental differences in the community."
Well, if the small Parties do not represent any fundamental differences in the community, and if they do not have any fundamental differences themselves, what then is wrong with forming Coalition Governments? Is there not a homogeneity of thought and of view among those people, so that they can equally well form a Coalition Government as a single Party can, if it is a Party consisting of people with minds and souls and wills of their own and has also these differences which have to be reconciled in some form of compromise?
At a later stage, the Taoiseach went on to say:—
"What happens is that somebody comes along and thinks, if he is able to get in on an election, that when he forms a Party, he will be assured of a seat in the Government. That is the temptation, allurement or urging for the formation of purely artificial Parties that have no fundamental point of difference."
"No fundamental point of difference" and still are not to be entitled to come together and agree on forming a Government.
Comment on this
They lasted three and a half years but two and a quarter is the average for a Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
I have not known of any Coalition Government being defeated upon a measure in the Dáil and then having to go to the country.
Comment on this
They were able to put through their legislation and plan on the support of the Dáil. That is entirely in accordance with the constitutional position. If Fianna Fáil want to change that position, they should do so.
Comment on this
At column 338 of the same volume, the Taoiseach said:—
"Consequently, not having some big issue to divide the people, and to divide them so that they would be in two groups, the tendency will be to split up into these minor, artificial, small Parties."
That seems to be an attempt to force, people into the position where they will have to vote for one Party or another. The attitude he adopts seems to be: "He that is not with me is against me and those who are against me are one lot and should fall into one Party." That is not the way it has worked in this country and it is not the way it will work in the future. We have heard from the Fianna Fáil Front Benches great admiration for the British system of election. Of course, curious to relate, there is some growing body of people in Great Britain who are not at all satisfied with their system of election——
Comment on this
——and it looks as if some improvements may come in time. The British have always been extremely slow to catch themselves on. That is part of their difficulty with regard to this country. If they had given us Home Rule in 1914 or earlier, we might have been satisfied with that for a long time, and they would have been saved a lot of embarrassment and a lot of the Empire might have been saved. They have been very slow to make changes, but they have made changes in good time and perhaps because changes have been slow in the British Constitution, domestically, they have been wise and have done well for themselves.
The Eonomist of 24th January, 1959, speaks about the selection of candidates under the two-Party system and the single member constituency, and is not at all pleased or satisfied with the type of candidate or the type of representation they are getting in the House of Commons. On page 298, it says:—
"Constituency associations are usually run by a small group of active and often extreme Party workers. Even in theory this small group is selected only by the few hundreds of local zealots who work for the candidate, not by the tens of thousands who vote for him; in practice, it is often personally dominated by two or three active enthusiasts who have time to spare. Yet, because of the device of nominating a ‘prospective parliamentary candidate' well before the election, this tiny and unrepresentative group has absolute control over the timing of what is in most cases the de facto choice of a candidate.”
We see where the two-Party system has got to in Great Britain, and where the single member constituency has got to in Great Britain, that the prospective Parliamentary candidate is selected by a small group—not even by a Party— within an association, who have time to spare to devote to these things, and who put up their man and get him put forward as the prospective candidate for the next election, and then when it comes to nomination, he is nominated.
The Economist goes on in a later paragraph to give this extremely interesting piece of information:—
"But, if the coming election comes up to current forecasts, this will be the third time in a row in which the turnover of seats between Parties will have been very small. This means that perhaps five-sixths of the seats in the country are currently regarded as safe. Their only focus of political interest as far as Parliament is concerned lies in the choice of candidate by the dominant Party."
It asks the question:—
"Should this continue to be staged managed, as at present in all Parties, by at most 50 or 60 people and often by two or three?"
That is the kind of system the Taoiseach wants to change over to where our candidates will be selected by a few people in a constituency and they will be safe, as is bound to happen under this system, in these safe seats and the people will be robbed of their choice of candidate, not to speak of representation in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am not saying that Fianna Fáil would do that.
Comment on this
The Senator must have a guilty conscience. I said Parties can do it. Fine Gael can do it, and if they do it, it is wrong, even though Fine Gael do it.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.