We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 120–232 of 232. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

Before the adjournment, I was talking about the objections to the method of selection of candidates that exists in Britain at the present time and I had quoted from the 24th January issue of The Economist. Having posed the problems that exist in relation to this matter in Britain, The Economist then says and I quote:—

"The solution for a British constituency cannot be dogmatically laid down. The first requirement is that there should be much more public discussion locally and nationally about the processes of selecting candidates".

In that regard, I want to make this observation. In this country, we have had very little discussion locally and nationally on this subject. There has been a great deal of discussion in the past six months or so, but the people do not lend themselves to forcible feeding. It is only over a period of time that they can absorb the issues involved in an important matter like this.

I am also reminded about what I said in another place by what I have read just now. It is that P.R. has not become a matter of serious concern to this State for the 40 years it has been in existence. Despite the doubts and misgivings the Taoiseach had about it in 1936, I do not know of any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party, with, we now understand from the Minister for Health, the exception of the Minister for Health, who had anything to say against P.R. as a system of election.

Senator Carter this evening quoted from the Dáil Debates on the Electoral (Amendment) Act of 1947 in which the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy MacEntee, expressed certain doubts about P.R. as a method of election. It led to the formation of a multiplicity of Parties and the necessity, therefore, for Coalition Governments but Senator Carter did not, of course, read the whole quotation. If he reads a little earlier in the same volume of the Dáil Debates, he will find that the Minister for Local Government in those days had no difficulty whatever in accepting P.R. as a system of election for the Legislature. He said it was in the Constitution and was accepted as a principle for election, but he saw these difficulties. With that lone exception, I do not know of any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party, with the exception of the Taoiseach, who had any objection whatever to the system of P.R.

Is it not more than strange that all of a sudden all the members of Fianna Fáil should see the light and that this grave and serious disease which was gnawing at the vitals of the body politic should now become apparent to them? It existed all those years and they were quite unable to diagnose it. The reason is quite plain. They never thought there was anything wrong with it. The only person who ever saw anything wrong with it is the Taoiseach.

He never spoke about the deficiencies of P.R. except at times of general elections and, of course, what is said at the time of general elections is said for a particular purpose, that is of securing election. That is the immediate purpose of talking at an election. When the Taoiseach spoke about the deficiencies of P.R. in the elections of 1943, 1948, 1951 and 1954—I assume he spoke against P.R. in all those days —his purpose—it was clear to me when I read his speeches—was not to decry P.R. as a system, but to maintain one thing, that Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach were always right. It was not that the people would have rejected them, if they failed to make a Government. That would not be the cause of Fianna Fáil failing to be a Government. It was the system of P.R. that was wrong and that is what would be the cause of their defeat.

We have also had the Taoiseach talking about the multiplicity of Parties which arises because small Parties can make extravagant and fanciful promises, knowing they will never be called upon to implement them and thereby attract a number of votes, and so you have a multiplication of Parties. The making of fanciful promises does not apply only if it does apply at all, to small Parties. At the last election, we had what did not then appear to the electorate to be a fanciful promise made by the Taoiseach. He undertook that the food subsidies would not be abolished. Likewise, the Tánaiste undertook that the Fianna Fáil Government would not abolish food subsidies—but they were abolished.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

The Tánaiste in Waterford and the Taoiseach in Belmullet—both of them on the same night.

Comment on this

Do not ask me to produce the quotations. Senator Lenihan knows of them very well. I am sure he made some statements himself, too. Then the Taoiseach abolishes food subsidies and what, indeed, was the excuse given? It ran something along these lines: "Well, of course, we did not know the state of the national accounts until we got in."

Comment on this

When we got there, the cupboard was bare.

Comment on this

There was a deficiency of £60,000,000——

Comment on this

Assuming that that was so, how then could small political Parties that never had representation know how the national accounts were? Is it not therefore natural that they should make promises that are perhaps out of proportion to the performance?

The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance and leading members of his Party were in office for a period of 16 years up to 1948 and then for another period of three years from 1951 to 1954. They were well acquainted with the way the business of government was conducted. Furthermore, they had access to all the documents issued in connection with the national accounts. More than that, they had it in their power at any time to put down a Parliamentary Question asking the Minister for Finance for this set of statistics, the Minister for Agriculture for another set, the Minister for Industry and Commerce for another set and the Taoiseach for another set. In that way, they could assemble all the information that would enable them to propound a policy they could fulfil. Either they wilfully abstained from doing that or they made a false promise. In either event, they were guilty of grave deception of the people. Therefore, it will be seen that it is not at all only small Parties, as has been alleged, that promise the sun, moon and the stars to the people.

While I mention the sun, the moon and the stars, I am reminded that the President of America promises the people they will soon reach the moon and will soon be circling the sun. I do not know what he is doing about the stars: I suppose they have those in Hollywood already. At any rate, a comparison has been made between the stability of government that has allegedly resulted from the straight vote in the United States and the straight vote in other countries and the conditions that can emerge from P.R. But that comparison does not hold water for a single moment because there is stability of government in the United States for a reason peculiar to the Constitution of the United States and similar Constitutions. The Constitution of the United States provides that the Government shall be there for four years. The President is elected for a period of four years and there is no question of his going to the country in the interim.

If strong government is wanted in this country, then it is not an amendment of the legislative provisions of the Constitution that we should be dealing with here, but an amendment of Article 28, which deals with the Government. Apparently the Government do not understand the provisions of the Constitution because if it is strong government they are after, then it is Article 28 and not Article 16 that they should be amending.

Another important factor about the situation in the United States—if we want to make comparisons with the United States, we might as well have all the facts—is that in the United States, as every Senator knows, there are elections for half of the Congress every two years. When you talk about having elections in this country every two and a half years, which has been the average, I would point out that in the stable democratic country of the United States, they have elections every two years. The result of these elections has been, in the case of the present holder of the Presidency in America, that, since 1954, President Eisenhower has had a hostile Congress. His Party has not had a majority in the United States Congress. As a result of the elections in November, 1958, he is in an absolute minority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.

The United States Government and country are concerned with issues of peace and war. They are concerned with a vast population of 160,000,000 people. The fate of the free world depends on the United States. In spite of the fact that the Government have not a majority in the Legislature, they are able to carry on and will carry on. Therefore, all this talk about the necessity for a Government Party to have an overwhelming majority in the Legislature does not, by comparison with the United States, bear any examination whatever.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will the Senator now come to the other three that were mentioned?

Comment on this

Senator Lenihan has shown his ignorance of the American Constitution and he does not even read the Irish Press, because, if he did, he would know that what the President of the United States requires to operate his country has to be put through the Congress and the Senate, and he has on occasions had slices of the Budget cut out.

Comment on this

Is a single member of the American Executive, a member of the American Parliament, of either of the Houses of Congress?

Comment on this

If the Senator requires that information, he ought to read the Constitution of the United States. I do not intend to educate him. I understand that, before we rose, he felt extremely tired.

Comment on this

It is time the Senator came away from the Constitution of the United States.

Comment on this

With respect the Government of the United States has been quoted as an example of stability.

Comment on this

It is quite in order to refer to it but it is hardly in order to examine it in detail.

Comment on this

With respect, if we are to make comparisons with the United States, important details are necessary.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley has been talking now for only the past three hours.

Comment on this

The President of the United States has to secure the agreement of Congress in order to get his Budget through. He is in an absolute minority in Congress at the moment, but we do not expect that he will retire and go to the country. That does not happen and never has happened in the United States.

We have had talk about coalitions and bargaining. At column 1285, Volume 172, of the Dáil Debates of the 28th January, 1959, the Taoiseach said:—

"It is very much better that they——"

the Coalition Parties

"——should bargain before rather than after the election. We want their bargaining to be put to the test before the people."

He goes on in the same context. Later on, at column 1289, he refers to one thing the new system definitely does:—

"One thing it definitely does is to compel Parties, if they intend to bargain, to do the bargaining beforehand."

Bargaining between Parties is all right if it is done according to the rules laid down by the Taoiseach and it is all wrong if it is done according to rules laid down by other people. I cannot see any difference between bargains—taking the Taoiseach on his own ground—if they ever existed, which were made after an election and bargains made before an election. The Taoiseach apparently knows a great deal about what went on at these meetings of Parties that formed inter-Party Governments in this country, about the bargains that were made and the Ministries that were offered. He does not, of course, give to the people who are going to be the judges in this matter anything like the kind of evidence they would require in being asked to judge this matter.

The Taoiseach himself may have some experience of bargaining. I am not old enough to remember what went on in 1927 but I understand that the Taoiseach in those days was not above the formation of a Coalition Government and making a bargain with a person who is a member of this House and who could give his own point of view.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I remember those days and there is no truth whatever in that statement.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It is absolutely true.

Comment on this
A Senator

Ask Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach made a bargain in 1927.

Comment on this

With whom?

Comment on this

With Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

That is not true. Senator Baxter made the offer that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Ahern should resume his seat.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach could not get Coalition Governments to work in those days. He could not form one and therefore they are bad. There has been talk about the representation of minorities and I have no doubt at all in my mind that it is much easier now for a religious minority to be nominated than it will be under the proposed system. We have had a long experience in this country of being in the position of a minority. The whole nation was a minority when it formed part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. It is for that very reason, because deep down in our character and in our minds we were always a minority, that P.R. is the system which suits us. There was a time when we had no representation in the only Parliament in which we might be represented, and it is now proposed under this Bill to deny the people that representation to which they are justly entitled under the Constitution, and to change over to a system which has no application whatever to our traditions or to our way of thinking.

One would imagine that there was something wrong about people uniting as an Opposition or as a Government. The Taoiseach would have everything carried out by individuals. It is an extraordinary thing that in the ordinary affairs of life, in the business community, for instance, people come together and, instead of running a business as a family business, run it as a company. People have different views on how business should be carried out —the work of Government is very much a matter of business—but they are always able to agree within the rules of their company how they will carry on their business and improve their position.

The Taoiseach does not believe in that kind of thing. He does not believe that you can have such a thing as a Coalition Government, a number of people with different points of view having common objectives and being able to pursue those common objectives. I am reminded in that context of the fact that when it comes to one company with which the Taoiseach is associated he has to have the controlling voice in it. That is the kind of mentality and outlook that has led to the introduction of this Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is that dirt or argument?

Comment on this

It is fact.

Comment on this

There is no dirt in it.

Comment on this

What dirt is there in it unless you know more than we know?

Comment on this

I do not believe this Bill is for the benefit of the people. No political leader who has ever wrested power from the people has done it except on the pretence that it is in the interests of the people. We know too much about what strong Governments can do. We know the constitutional system for strong government that you have in countries like the Argentine at present. There they can have a strong Government, a President, but a Government will only be as good as the people who constitute it and if we have not had a good Government and the stable Government that the present Government thinks we should have, the fault lies not with the system but with the people in the Government who are charged with the duty of governing the people.

Comment on this

I am opposed to the abolition of P.R. because I believe it to be a most democratic method of electing a representative Government. I do not intend to speak for long. When I first learned this matter was to come before us I gathered a lot of statistics which I intended to use but, from reading the Dáil Debates, I have learned that most of them have already been used, though some of them were not presented as I would prefer them to have been and some of the points were not as well made as I think I could have made them. Still they have been made and reiteration, I fear, has a tendency to become boring rather than convincing. Therefore, I have decided to leave statistics alone. By doing so I leave myself open to the charge that I base my opposition on sentiment. I willingly accept that charge if the old meaning of the word is taken, a judgment based on feeling. Feeling comes from the heart and so does my opposition to the abolition of P.R.

Many years ago, when I was a young girl in my teens, and while the fundamental principles of Labour and Irish Republicanism were being inculcated in me, I attended many meetings where the principles of P.R. were explained and extolled. That was a long time ago, long before there was any hope or prospect of its coming to Ireland. I found those principles so entwined with the fundamental principles of Labour and Irish Republicanism that I find it difficult to disentangle them and I can no more readily forgo one than the other.

It seemed to my young mind that P.R. was so just, so truly democratic a method of electing a Government, that I added it to the list of just things which I wished to win for Ireland and the Irish people. All the years of its usage in our nation have done nothing to change that opinion. I have been told that I so hailed P.R. in my youth because all the movements to which I then belonged, and in which I then worked, were minority movements. Perhaps so; that could be true, but, even so, there is nothing in that fact that reflects discredit on those minority movements or on my opinion.

All great movements in this world, all down the years of history, have begun as a group around a germ of truth or ideal, and who are we in this generation to deny any germ of truth or an ideal its chance or its right to the fullness of its growth? We are a young nation in so far as being a self-governing nation and I do not think that sufficient time has elapsed, or that the time has yet come, to attempt to set it in a firm mould. After all, 40 years is no more than a breath in the life of a nation, and I fear there is a great likelihood of its being more prematurely set in that mould if we revert to the single member constituencies than if we retain the method we still have.

I do not believe that the best ideas for that firm mould will come from my own generation whose minds are sometimes swayed by old antagonisms, as I often find my own, and whose minds, no matter how much we might exalt and rejoice in the advances which have been achieved in our time, still are conditioned by the remembrance of old standards. Therefore, I do not think that from those minds the best ideas for the firm mould will come. The best ideas, I believe, will come from the minds of the present generation and onwards, from those who have been reared in a time free from foreign rule, who take and enjoy freedom as a natural right as they do the present standards in social amenities, and who also consider the hopes, the fears and the activities of my generation as things comparable in time with movements such as those of the Fenians, the Land War, the Young Irelanders, or even things more ancient. The best ideas, I believe, will come from that generation and that which follows it. It is from those generations that the shaping of free Ireland is to come. I believe that the abolition of P.R. will make their task more difficult.

I know it is generally deplored that the youth of the country is apathetic towards taking part in its political activities, but is that to be wondered at since they consider our ideas so ancient that they find none of the political movements that we have shaped completely satisfying, and are reluctant to accord any of them their full support? Still, under P.R., we have had evidence that there is a stirring in their minds towards taking part in the shaping of their country by the numbers of them—not splinters of any Party—who have offered themselves and their ideas to the electorate. That they fail to secure election is not important. What is important is that they give evidence that they are dissatisfied with what is on offer from us, and that the germ of the idea of taking part in the shaping of their country's future is in them.

The hope is that new, young ideas can more readily be achieved through P.R. If we abolish P.R. how can we know what movement of great beauty or utility we have prevented from coming into being, and which may be lost to us and to the country? I do not think there should be any attempt to be little that possibility because that possibility must have its beginnings in a minority group. Have not all the national movements in which we take such great pride, and to which we pay such homage, had their beginnings in minority groups?

It is because I remember the history of my country's struggle that I fail to understand—I simply cannot understand—this objection, this disdain, this fear of minority groups that is expressed by those who approve of the abolition of P.R. I was not reared in the belief that God and Truth are solely on the side of big battalions, nor can I more easily believe that God and Truth are solely on the side of big parliamentary Parties.

There has been much play about the word "stability" and the need for it in our Government. The abolition of P.R. has more or less been practically the only view we have of achieving and maintaining it. I consider that nonsense. I cannot readily think of any country, any democratic country in Western Europe, which has had a Government more stable than ours. Stability is essential to good and efficient Government, but may I ask does, or can, stability of itself ensure good and efficient Government? That question answers itself. Stability is but one prop of good and efficient Government; the greatest prop to good and efficient Government is an electorate satisfied that no unnecessary obstacle has been reared against electing a truly representative Government and that assurance to an electorate can only, I maintain, be achieved through P.R.

There is one more point to which I must refer. When I receive my ballot paper in the referendum I will vote "No", but this Bill has placed me in a most difficult position. Although I am apposed to the abolition of P.R. I would not care that any action of mine should have even the appearance of wishing to deny my fellow citizens their right to have their say on so important a matter since it has been raised, and therefore I must vote for the referendum. I only hope and pray that a majority of the citizens will, like me, vote "No" and thus retain for the country a truly democratic method of electing its Government.

Comment on this

Like the last speaker, I hope to be brief because over the past three months we have read so many long speeches on this matter. For the past two days we have heard almost a repetition of those speeches. There is no doubt that long speeches, which ramble away from the point and bring in many extraneous matters, are tedious to listen to. I can quite understand the impatience of many Senators and their not being able to listen to all this repetition and these long tedious speeches. For that reason, I hope to be very brief and to make just a few points as they occur to me.

This Bill, as every Senator knows, will not really do anything; nothing will actually become law as a result of the passing of the Bill here. Neither can a refusal to pass this Bill prevent an Act of the Dáil from becoming law, so that whatever we do here, with regard to this Bill, we shall have the referendum. It has been charged by the Opposition that the people have not had a sufficient opportunity of examining the pros and cons of this matter. After three months' debating in Dáil Éireann, after all those debates have been published in much detail by the daily papers, the bi-weekly and the weekly newspapers, after all the references to them on Radio Éireann every day and every night, and all the references made to the matter at meetings of the different political Parties, surely there is no foundation for the complaint that it has not received sufficient publicity or that the people have not received sufficient notice of it?

Of course, if the Opposition get their way in requesting that this Bill be not passed by this House the people will have an opportunity of examining the matter for a further three months. Perhaps the longer the people get to consider it the better. I think it is anyhow. I am quite satisfied that the people will have had sufficient time to decide the matter, but what troubles me most is that it is suggested that the people should not be permitted to decide it. Of course, while I shall vote in the opposite way to the last speaker, I think that is certainly wrong. We have had, over the years while Fianna Fáil were in Government, members of the Opposition calling on the Government to consult the people on this, that and the other matter—matters of ordinary administration. Yet, here is a matter which all agree is a very important matter, a matter which nobody else can decide except the people, and it is sought to deprive the people of an opportunity of deciding the matter for themselves. That is wrong.

One of the reasons given for not permitting the people to decide this matter is that there has been no demand for it. Quotations ad lib. have been given both here and in the other House from Dáil debates, and from newspapers, showing that Leaders of both sides of the House have demanded this measure periodically over the past 20 years. I have no intention of producing any of those quotations. I merely give my own ideas on this matter and I have been associated with elections for just over 40 years. I was associated with only one election before the introduction of P.R. but ever since the introduction of P.R., up to the last election, I have met people during my electioneering work in every election, saying: “My goodness, when are you going to abolish P.R. and give us a chance of knowing how we are voting and what we are voting for?” I have met people protesting against this method of election everywhere.

It is remarkable that at every election you have many votes marked with an "X" for the candidate of the voter's choice, instead of No. 1. Of course, we have had spoiled votes with two and three "X's" on them. It is the rule that where a voter marks an "X" opposite the name of the candidate of his choice, if there is no other mark on the paper, that vote is allowed as a No. 1 vote for that candidate. I hold that that is another indication that people would like to go back to the straight vote. I think that applies to local elections as well as to national elections. Another reason given to me by people I meet is that they did not understand, or were unable to follow, or at any rate did not follow the distribution of a surplus during an election. They found it hard to understand how the votes are counted again, and a proportion established and how so many are added to this name or to that. They found it somewhat easier to understand the distribution of votes where the candidate is eliminated. By and large, the system is not generally understood by most of the plain people whose votes decide elections.

It is suggested that this is not an opportune time to decide this issue but I have not yet heard any suggestion as to what would be an opportune time. I believe this is an opportune time because we must revise the constituencies this year, as we are bound to do under the Constitution. It is opportune to decide before the constituencies are revised according to population and other considerations whether or not they should also be reformed into single member constituencies.

On thing that gives me great satisfaction is that neither in the debate here nor in the other House does there seem to be any real objection to single member constituencies. So far, the debate has centred around the question of the single transferable vote and the straight vote and it appears there is very little contention regarding single member constituencies.

I am very much in favour of single member constituencies. I have been a candidate in national and local elections for the past 38 years. I have been a candidate in local elections under P.R. in an eight-member electoral area and in a five-member area. I have been a candidate in Dáil elections in five-seat and three-seat constituencies and my experience over the years in the different areas has been that, whether there were five or eight seats and six or ten or 12 candidates, I always found that each candidate had some area or stronghold of his own, so to speak, on which he depended to get his quota or almost his quota.

In practice where there are eight candidates elected for eight seats, if you examine the situation you find that each candidate had a part of the constituency to himself on which to depend for votes. A candidate who succeeded and became a member catered more or less specially for the needs of the people in that particular area. We have seen in county councils how a candidate from part of an electoral area which he claims as his own bailiwick always tries to get roads improved and all possible amenities for that part of his area as against other parts of the area. Therefore it was more or less looked on as his "single member constituency."

The same applies to Dáil constituencies where each Deputy has a stronghold on which he depends for a certain number of first preference votes. He gets second and third preferences from other candidates in other parts of the area. Similarly, when he goes into the Dáil—taking the case of a Deputy in a five-member constituency—he is particularly concerned with the people in a particular part of the constituency. I think the return to the single member constituency is a great idea. It is good for the people and it is bound to be good for Parliament.

My experience over the years has satisfied me that where a Deputy in any constituency has worked for his people, giving them good honest satisfactory service he need have no fear of going back to the people in his special stronghold to seek re-election. There are many examples of this in every Party and I do not know how it can be said that if this Bill is passed there is no hope of a strong and virile Opposition in the next Dáil. I cannot see that. Knowing the country, the people and the Deputies of all Parties, I am satisfied there are Deputies in every Party in the House who will be re-elected by their own strongholds.

Some Senators seem to fear that many sections of the people will be denied representation if P.R. is abolished. As against that, many sections have been denied representation because of P.R. One cannot have it both ways. A few examples come to my mind. We have the example of West Galway, where a Fine Gael candidate, the sitting member, headed the poll in the three-member constituency and failed to be elected.

Comment on this

They were not denied representation, as the other candidate went in.

Comment on this

I hold that that is a clear case where 4,206 Fine Gael people were denied representation, because of P.R. We had another example where a Fianna Fáil candidate finished with 6,000 votes and failed to get elected and a man who got only 2,000 first preferences was elected over him. These are freak results of P.R. They are on record and they are true. In my own area, a Fine Gael candidate, who was second highest in the poll, failed to be elected over three people under him. That deprived 6,000 Fine Gael people of representation there. That candidate stated publicly that he was not beaten by the people. He was unfairly defeated by a monster called P.R.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Did he say that?

Comment on this

Yes. Against Fianna Fáil, there was another freak result. In North Kerry, Fianna Fáil polled 500 votes in excess of two quotas and got one seat. I hold that there again 7,000 Fianna Fáil people were deprived of representation by P.R. These are just a few examples which occur to me, without any research or worry about them. They are in my mind over the years.

Whether the Seanad passes this Bill or holds it up, it is the people who will decide. Is it not terrible that, in this democratic country, where the referendum is enshrined in our Constitution, we are making an attempt to prevent the people deciding? The people have seen for themselves and they are in a position to decide. They know what has happened in all those countries of Europe where P.R. has led to disaster. They know that, even in our own country, the Government here was brought down by just one man.

Many quibbles have been made by learned professors here on the word "stability," but the people understand what stability means. It means economic security and national security for our people.

Comment on this

They are not getting that.

Comment on this

This must be decided by the people. It is their privilege. Why should we deny the people their privilege?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

We cannot deny them the privilege.

Comment on this

Obstructing them.

Comment on this

We are seeking to do so.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

No, we are not.

Comment on this

Pardon me. I will correct myself, with your permission, a Chathaoirligh, and with that of the Leader of the Opposition. We cannot deny them their rights.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Hear, hear! We cannot.

Comment on this

But it is sought to deny them their rights.

Comment on this

Obstruction.

Comment on this

Let the Taoiseach go to the Park to-night, dissolve the Dáil and have an election.

Comment on this

It is bad business for those opposite if they have to fall back on quibbling about words, trying to obstruct me, instead of making their case.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

We cannot deny the people the right to decide.

Comment on this

I am amazed at the Leader of the Opposition. I listened to him, patiently or impatiently, as the case may be. I must submit to you, a Chathaoirligh, that he is giving a very bad example. We should expect better from him. At any rate, we cannot make the decision. Whether we like it or not, the people will make it. I appeal to this House not to obstruct this Bill or put anything in the way of the people making a decision on this matter.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose this measure, the purpose of which we know by now is to abolish the P.R. system of election. It was quite apparent from its introduction that the Government were determined to avail themselves of their numerical strength in the Oireachtas to abolish the democratic system of the single transferable vote. If they succeed in their design, this action will silence the voice of a very considerable section of the community who feel that neither of the two big Parties represents their particular point of view.

The Government quite frankly admit that it is their desire to avail themselves of their present position of near-dictatorship to endeavour to impose their wishes on the people. They are anxious to push on with this proposition now, because they feel that a general election under P.R., and perhaps without their present leader, would find them very much a minority Party. Their statements concerning their anxiety to allow the people to decide this matter—a subject which we all know never occurred to the people's minds—are rather ridiculous, to put it as plainly as possible.

The attitude which the Government Party are adopting would, no doubt, be admirable were this legislation, which they are forcing through, in furtherance of a project designed to improve the deplorable position of the country, by making employment available to our workless citizens or to raise the standard of our indigent and handicapped people. But when all the energies of the Government are centred on putting through a piece of legislation that will not produce one extra job or bring back one single emigrant, but on the contrary is designed to disfranchise a large section of the people, it is nothing short of tragic.

Government spokesmen say that the abolition of P.R. is necessary to produce a stable Government; but the present Government, elected by P.R., with its comfortable majority, is a stable Government. There is practically nothing standing in their way should they wish to put into operation schemes of full employment or anything else calculated to improve the lot of the people. What, then, does the Government want to do that they fear the votes of the citizens under P.R. might prevent their doing? Their whole attitude confirms the belief that they feel the disappearance of the present Taoiseach from the political scene would, under P.R. and with the present constituencies, mean also the disappearance of the dictatorship of their Party. For that reason, they feel it imperative that the representation of our considerable minorities be eliminated by a recasting of the constituencies and the reintroduction of the British system of the single non-transferable vote.

Throughout the debates in the other House, we have heard reiterated the need for a strong Government. Are the present Government not a strong enough Government? Have they not shown that they can ignore the wishes of the people in such matters as food subsidies, which have been already mentioned? Any Government stronger than that which we have now could be a dangerous dictatorship. There is a lot of truth in the statement made in the Dáil that if the present strong Government could have devised a way to abolish P.R. without bothering to consult the people by way of a referendum, it would have been abolished already.

All this talk on strong Government should sound a warning to our citizens. Why do the Government seek to abolish P.R. and entrench themselves even more firmly? What schemes do they propose to apply to the country that it is necessary to stifle the voices of large sections? It cannot be merely to give us what we already have, that is, stability, for our Government is quoted as an example of stable Government. In the current issue of the Daily Mail Year Book we read at page 24:—

"Both Houses in the Republic of Ireland (‘a country,' pronounces Professor Nicholas Mansergh, ‘remarkable... for her exceptional stability of Government') have enjoyed the single transferable vote system since 1922. The Tasmanian Lower House has employed it since 1907. The House of Laity of the Church Assembly, the Congregational Union, the Liberal Party, the Board of Deputies of British Jews, the National Union of Teachers, the Clerical and Administrative Workers' Union, and the John Lewis Partnership all practise the single transferable vote. In 1949, the Australian Senate substituted the single transferable vote for the alternative vote. The Legislative Assembly of Gibraltar introduced it in 1950."

The publication continues:—

"Of the electoral systems outlined, only one, the single transferable vote, conforms to the demands of natural academic justice. To the now well-established usage of ‘one man, one vote,' it adds the rider, ‘one vote, one value.' It would end such gross injustices as have persisted in three successive South African Elections, where the Malan-Strijdom Nationalists piled up crushing majorities because three quarters of their M.P.s slipped in with small majorities (3,000 down to 47 in 1953), while three-quarters of the Opposition M.P.s suffered vote-wastage by amassing large majorities (8,500-3,000)."

The system which has resulted in the strong Malan Government in South Africa is hardly one that Ireland should adopt. It has produced in South Africa a strong Government, to which Senator Stanford has already made reference. That strong Government has been able to implement and keep in operation an inhuman system of racial segregation that has reduced the native population to the status of slaves; and to put into operation a policy which has closed the Christian mission schools set up by missionaries of various denominations for the education of native children.

Under P.R., such a state of affairs could not remain for long and our people should think carefully and spurn the overtures of a Party that would delude them into voting against P.R., the just and democratic system of voting which enables all sections to have a voice in the government of their country and which will ensure that no minority Government will attain a position where the votes of the majority cannot remove them from office.

Comment on this

I have listened to almost all this debate, which has been fairly lengthy so far, and I have read most of the debate in the Dáil. I heard the Taoiseach putting his case both in the Dáil and Seanad. I should like to say at the outset that P.R. with the single transferable vote seems to me to constitute a vitally important element in our whole democratic society. It represents a vital safeguard of liberal and democratic thought and government.

In his opening remarks here, the Taoiseach said that small Parties might be irresponsible and might "promise and pretend" to the electorate. I think Senator O'Quigley dealt with that well, because it is quite obvious that small Parties are not the only ones to promise and pretend. In fact, they are less likely to get away with it because they do not get the power the bigger Parties get.

The Taoiseach said something else which seemed to me to be revealing. He said that in such Coalition Governments as we have had, the Ministers were forced to report back to, and were under pressure from, their Parties. I personally see no objection whatever to the concept of Ministers reporting to their Parties and being responsible to their Parties. I regard it as revealing that the Taoiseach thinks that would be, in itself, a bad thing; that he regards a Cabinet Minister as being in some way separated from his Party, and having no responsibility to it, as soon as he is elected to a Cabinet seat.

I hope to deal presently with the question of stability. The Taoiseach made the point that in countries where you have single-seat constituencies, you had greater stability. I would simply deny that. I do not think you can make any such generalisation. Most of the countries in South America have such a system of election, and South American countries are far from being regarded as being essentially more stable in their government than others.

I am sorry the Taoiseach is not here. I do not say that in complaint, because I recognise that he has given us a great deal already of his time in this House, which I think we appreciate, because he has obviously heard most of these arguments before. I am sorry he is not here just to put the question —possibly the Minister for External Affairs will answer or put it to him— as to whether he would have liked in this country greater "stability" in the period 1927-1932, greater "stability" because the Government then would have had a bigger majority. At that time, of course, as was pointed out by Senator Hayes, P.R. was giving a pretty fair show to the Republican Party, the Party that subsequently became the Fianna Fáil Party, and I think that should be recognised.

One point in Senator Hayes's speech that I found disappointing—this applies to all Fine Gael speeches so far, and also, indeed, to the Labour speeches—is that we have had no indication from them as to whether if they get back into power, either singly or together, it is their intention, if P.R. is now abolished, to take steps to have it restored. It seems to me that it would be a good thing now if, on that particular point, Fine Gael and Labour were to make their attitude clear.

Senator Ó Maoláin, in making what I hope he will forgive me describing as the single transferable speech, which we subsequently heard two or three times here, and which was made two or three times in the Dáil, made the point that the 1925 Agreement would have been rejected by the people had they been given a chance to have a referendum on it. I have talked a good deal about that on previous occasions, and here I would simply point out that the people, having seen that agreement, signed, agreed, approved and ratified by the Dáil and Seanad, kept the Government, which had brought about that agreement, in power for seven more years after 1925, and that seems to me to make nonsense of the contention that, had the people been consulted, they would have rejected the agreement. They were consulted in successive elections and they kept in power for seven more years the people who had entered into that agreement and had it ratified.

Senator Ó Maoláin was not the only speaker but he was, I think, the first here to refer to conditions in France. I could say a good deal about France, and I might well be tempted to do so, but it seems to me that the situation there is quite irrelevant. P.R. was introduced for the total of the general elections for the first time in France in 1945. I do not know whether this House remembers who became the first Prime Minister after that. I do. It was General de Gaulle, and I do not now know whether he must consequently be regarded at that time as a symbol of instability and as a symbol of stability to-day. However that may be, the system was applied in France only for the six years up to 1951. It did not in fact apply before the war, or since then, and even in 1945-51 they had P.R. by lists. You voted for a Party by list, and if your Party list contained ten names and you got enough votes to elect four of them, it was the Party and not the voter who decided which four of that list would be elected. One of the factors in that was that only the same and safe Party man towards the top of the list was elected. That situation would obtain even more so with a Party with only one candidate in a constituency. Inevitably, there will be a good Party man who will do what he is told—the sane and safe back-bencher who will give no trouble. That, in fact, is one of the major arguments against the abolition of P.R. here.

I should like to refer now to one more point made by some of those who support the abolition of P.R. Senator Carter contends that Fine Gael will benefit by this change, and that the Labour Party will benefit by this change. He rather left me wondering whether Fianna Fáil was going to get any extra seats at all as a result of the change, because, if Fine Gael increases its representation under the new system and the Labour Party also, it seems to me one might as well leave things as they are, as far as getting stronger Fianna Fáil Government goes.

One thing that dismayed me was the way in which this matter came up in the first place. I may say I was shocked by what I can only term the casual manner in which the case was stated in the Dáil for the abolition of this electoral procedure by the Taoiseach, a process which we have had for so many years in this country. I was shocked by the almost casual way that the implication, as it were, was made that the onus was not on the Government to show why it should be abolished but rather on the Opposition to show why it should not be abolished. I felt that that casual approach was not a helpful one. I noted—it has been mentioned—that there was a decision at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. I should like to ask subsequent Fianna Fáil speakers what kind of debate there was at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis on this subject. I did not see any report of such a debate.

Comment on this

It was reported.

Comment on this

I did not see any report of a discussion or any report of a single critical voice raised. I am open to correction. Senator Lenihan says there were people apparently in opposition.

Comment on this

I said there was a discussion, and that discussion was reported in the papers on the following day.

Comment on this

When I say "discussion", I mean discussion from both points of view. I do not mean discussion which consists merely in saying "yes" in a loud voice. Discussion to me means argument. I hope there was argument in the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. Senator Lenihan assures me that there was discussion, but I wonder does he mean, by "discussion," argument for and against, or merely approval of the Executive decision? I am aware, of course, that the Executive of Fianna Fáil is a very stable Government. It governs the Party in an extremely stable way. One result of that stability was a unanimous vote for the abolition of P.R. I accept the assurance that there was vigorous debate. I have no doubt Senator Lenihan was one of the most vocal in criticism of the official view, before actually voting in favour of it subsequently. But in the reports I saw, I saw no evidence of criticism, of heart-searching, of scrutiny of conscience—just total acquiescence!

Now, Senator Carter said that in Fianna Fáil every member can have his say. But what does he say? He says, "yes", "yes", "yes". Now, on such an issue as this——

Comment on this

No. It is only the pink brand of politicians who say "yes, yes, yes".

Comment on this

No. Let him talk. This is very amusing.

Comment on this

I welcome this difference of opinion between Senator Carter and Senator Lenihan, and I hope it is the germ of future individual thinking within the Party, thinking I certainly would welcome, because I find it disturbing that a big Party like Fianna Fáil, a big and democratic Party, with its record, should be so controlled that not a single voice was raised, as far as public report goes, or individual vote cast of dissent, or apparently not even a query raised on such a vital issue as this. One is reminded of a sort of Communist Party meeting in Russia, or a meeting of Russian scientists such as took place in the Lysenko case. When the Lysenko case came before 700 scientists in Russia, they voted by 698 votes to two in favour of the Lysenko theory; of those two, one of them miserably withdrew his opposition that very night and the other, Professor Zdanov, published an object apology in Pravda the next morning, and said his vote was due to “vestiges of the deplorable university habit of thinking for oneself”. My hope is that that habit, which I do not regard as deplorable, has not been completely and ruthlessly eradicated in Fianna Fáil. I hope there are some who are prepared to think for themselves and, if they are not, I still hope that there is independent thinking in this Seanad, and that it is not quite dead from that point of view.

I hope, then, that this question will be considered in the light of what is good for the nation and not merely on grounds of Party advantage. The trouble is that many in Fianna Fáil, and to a notable degree the Taoiseach himself, are deeply and, I think, sincerely convinced that what is good for their Party is necessarily good for the country. They allow themselves to be guided by what I would call politician's intuition, which I would define as "that strange instinct which tells a politician he is right—whether he is or My own feeling in this matter, which is one I regard as being of great gravity, is that the Taoiseach, in sponsoring this rejection now of P.R., is letting down himself, his name, his reputation, his country, and, in the long term, even his own Party. I am no adulator of the Taoiseach, but I recognise in him certain very fine qualities. I think I speak for everybody here when I say that we have all had our moments of pride in having such a man at the head of Government for his personal dignity, his resolution and his courage. But, to me, the high repute deriving from these high qualities will be besmirched in history's record by this penultimate political act of a departing leader.

I shall feel sorry, but, I am afraid, not surprised, if history records this leader, as Goldsmith painted Burke as a man:—

"Who, born for the universe, narrowed his mind

And to Party gave up what was meant for mankind."

The present proposal I regard as a major betrayal, consequently, of one of the best elements in our democratic system, an element which gave fair play to minority views, religious, political and sectional in any sense. It was a thing of which we could be proud, of which we can still be proud if we retain it. It was, in fact, and has been a show piece for the world. It is just and fair; it is a finely balanced, sensitive and faithful recorder of the people's will.

I should like to quote from a letter written in June, 1938, by Rev. Canon Luce of Trinity College, in which he wrote:—

"It would be a thousand pities if a Party in a fit of impatience were to scrap this well-tested instrument of enlightened democracy, an instrument to which we all, irrespective of creed, class and Party, owe far more than we sometimes realise, and which can do for our children what it has done for us.

P.R. has been a healing force in our midst. Old political feuds are dying; public spirit is replacing faction. Our elections are well-conducted. The voice of reason is heard, and the gun is silent. P.R. deserves much of the credit; for P.R. produces contented and loyal minorities, whereas the other system breeds muzzled, silent, discontented minorities, predisposed to doctrines of violence.

P.R. has been a unifying force, and unity is strength. The other system antagonises majority and minority, accentuates the differences between them, and, therefore, weakens both. How, then, can some say that P.R. fails to give strong governance? A contented minority is a strength to the majority, while a discontented minority and a bullying majority are a weakness to the whole body politic.

Since the establishment of the Free State we have lived under several administrations, every one of them elected by P.R. Every one of them has been a strong Government, judged by the true strength of test. Their legislative output has been large, yet most of the grave measures have been carried by the slenderest majority. The scale only just turned, but there was consent behind it, and, whether we approved or disapproved, we all accepted the decisions loyally and cheerfully and made them our own; for we have been able to say to ourselves: ‘It is the will of the people, ascertained under the fairest electoral system ever devised by the wit of man.' We shall not be able to say that if P.R. goes. If P.R. goes, the feeling of enforced submission will banish the freeman's feeling of glad consent to the law which he, through his representative, has helped to make. A Government with a majority of six under P.R. is infinitely stronger than a Government with a majority of sixty elected otherwise."

Part of that was quoted in the Dáil, and it was unfairly suggested by interjection that perhaps since 1938 Canon Luce had changed his mind about that. I am permitted by him to say that he most emphatically has not changed his mind, and that if the referendum is taken he proposes to cast his vote in favour of the retention of the system which he praised in those terms.

My contention, therefore, is that P.R. is an excellent instrument. Why then—the question is legitimate—has it not produced a better Parliament so far, and better. Irish Governments down the years? My answer to that would be: Because the people, whether through ignorance, credulity or under-education, so far have not willed such a Government; they have got, in fact, the Governments that they have chosen. There has been a large measure, I am afraid, of credulity. The feeling was at first: "Let us try ten years of strong, stable Government, 1922 to 1932" and finding it did not satisfy them, the people then said: "All right. Let us try a real Republican Government" and they tried that for 16 long years until 1948.

Then they thought: "All right. That has not satisfied us. We still have not got what we were promised in 1916. Let us try a coalition of the best brains of all the other Parties". That was tried for three years and that did not satisfy. Then they said: "Let us give Fianna Fáil another chance", and they did for three years until 1954. Then they tried a coalition again for another three years, and now Fianna Fáil again. At this juncture some people are saying, and Fianna Fáil are in the van: "Now let us try altering the electoral system". None of these people, apparently, considers that it might be a good idea to alter their policy, and would prefer to change anything rather than the policies they have been applying or misapplying.

There is a wild hope suggested by this Bill that if we abolish P.R. and smash this sturdy, yet finely balanced, electoral apparatus we shall in some extraordinary way save the country. I have been asked, arising out of this Bill, do I think that the abolition of P.R. would really make such a big difference. My answer to that is that in the immediate future, perhaps, it would not because most of the Parties, in fact, put much the same kind of highly-conservative and anti-progressive policy before the people, and most of the people are still being fooled most of the time. And many of those who have ceased to be fooled have left the country. But let us not blame the electoral machine for bad political policies or bad results from such policies.

In my opinion, to feed such a shoddy collection of Party policies into this finely-designed electoral machine and expect it to produce dynamic and progressive Governments, is like feeding sows' ears into a high-powered loom and expecting it to produce a steady supply of silk purses. To harbour such an expectation is folly enough, but to think that the end-product of such a machine can be made intensely beautiful simply by smashing the machine, is a mark, in my submission, of the higher lunacy.

I want that machine to be preserved. I want it to be saved from the wreckers who want to smash it. I want it to be preserved for the day when our electorate will be sufficiently educated to use it and to use it as it can be used.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Senator permitted to read his speech as he has been for the last ten minutes?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator is entitled to refer to notes. He is not entitled to read his speech but is entitled to refer to notes.

Comment on this

I did read at some length an extract from Canon Luce's statement. I am not reading, I am afraid. I am sorry that it seems to disturb Senator Lenihan. At the same time, I have no doubt that such stimulus is intellectually valuable and may be fruitful, but I can assure him that I am not reading now.

I want this machine to be saved, then, for the time when the electorate will be sufficiently educated, as I said, to use it as it can be used and to good purpose. By the single transferable vote, in my contention, P.R. offers a system which ensures that political Parties and political ideas will be represented in Parliament, in this House and in the other House, in proportion to the voting strength they command among the electorate. Such a system is eminently just, and to desire any other system, even for Party benefit, seems to me to desire to derive Party benefit from electoral injustice and disproportionate representation.

Senator O'Quigley has already given the House figures about the proportion between the percentage votes got in recent elections and the percentage of seats secured and it is quite apparent in the 1933 elections, in the 1948, 1951 and 1957 elections, that on each occasion the big Parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, were the only ones that got more than their proportionate share. In other words, our present system, with many three member constituencies, does, in fact, in practice, encourage and favour the bigger Parties.

I shall not weary the House by giving the percentages, unless somebody is prepared to deny that contention, because it can be shown for each of these elections that the only two Parties that on each of those occasions got more than the percentage of seats to which their percentage of votes entitled them were Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, the two big Parties. To deny that, I suggest, is impossible, and I do not believe anybody will challenge me to produce those figures which I am quite happy to produce if anybody does.

The present case against P.R. seems to fall under three main heads: first, the multiplicity of Parties which it is said to produce; second, Coalitions which I may call ad hoc Coalitions, made after the election and, third, that it produces weak unstable Government.

To deal with the first objection first, that it leads to multiplicity of Parties, if we, in Ireland, look at other countries, that seems to be manifestly untrue. There are just as many Parties in Northern Ireland, in the Six-County area, as there are down here. They have the Unionists, the Independent Unionists, the Nationalists, the Labour Party, the Irish Labour Party, Sinn Féin and a number of Independents. They have precisely the same kind of pattern as we have here, although they have not got P.R. —which personally I regret—but the real fear here is not that there will be a multiplicity of Parties, but that there will be competing groups offering much the same policy, but commanding perhaps greater or less public confidence, arising out of their promises, from the electorate.

There are, in fact, very few Parties in this country and most of them derive not from P.R., but from the fact that the people have observed the failure of the bigger Parties, when in power, to keep faith with the electorate. In my opinion, Clann na Poblachta which was the only new Party in recent times which reached anything like fairly large representation, got into power, got into prominence, by taking the 1927 Fianna Fáil policy and promising to implement it. I would defy anybody to find a difference between the Clann na Poblachta policy which they put before the people in 1947-48 and Fianna Fáil policy in 1927. The difference which the people thought they saw was that Clann na Poblachta at least was going to implement it.

What produces the multiplicity of Parties and the subdivisions, is not P.R. but dissatisfaction with the failure of the big Parties to implement their policies. P.R. does not create divisions; it reflects them. It reflects the existing ones, and the single member constituency system merely allows one to pretend that such divisions do not exist. It seems to me that to smash the machine which reveals divisions that are still there, on the pretence that you are getting rid of the divisions by smashing the machine that reveals them, is like thinking that the cure for an unpleasant face is to smash the mirror in which you have just observed it.

The second objection is that it produces ad hoc Coalitions—Coalitions after the event—Parties of widely differing policies coming together after the election. I recognise that there is a modicum of truth in this objection. I think it is fair to say—so far as I understood him—that the Taoiseach's main objection was made under this head. I say that there is a modicum of truth in it. There is a tendency to have post-election inter-Party bargaining. I believe, for instance, if we had a really effective Labour Party in this country, it could never imagine itself taking part in a Coalition with the highly Conservative Fine Gael Party. They might in certain circumstances have said: “So far as your legislation is progressive, we will support you,” but to take office with them seemed to me to be a negation of Labour Party policy. That is my personal opinion but it is obvious that certain bargains were struck, perhaps because the Labour Party is not a very real Labour Party at all. Nevertheless, if the public wanted it, and if the differences are so small in fact between the Parties, why should they not come together, and who is the Taoiseach to tell them that they must not?

We have, in fact, in this country five Tory Parties—Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, the Labour Party, Clann na Talmhan and what remains of Clann na Poblachta—five Tory Parties with five Tory policies—sometimes looking a bit more progressive at election times, but when solidly entrenched in power, looking very Tory indeed. Why should we not have a five-Party Tory Coalition? I do not see why not. I think it would be a pretty clear reflection of the will of the people.

The main Fianna Fáil objection to that, and to joining with any other Party, lies in the fact that they would have to share the power, would have to share the kudos, and perhaps would have to share the spoils of office, but it would also—and that is one value I would see in such a coming together of all the big Parties who really have the same policy—expose, once and for all, to the people the failure of that policy, whether it is called Fine Gael policy, Fianna Fáil policy or whatever Party policy you like. It would expose to the people that the policy itself was wrong, and not the electoral system, nor indeed the T.D.s or the Ministers.

James Connolly saw that long ago. In 1897, he said: "If you could remove the English Army to-morrow and hoist the green flag over Dublin Castle, unless you set about the organisation of a Socialist Republic, your efforts would be in vain." That was Connolly's view of what it would mean and I believe the failure of the successive policies of Irish Governments so far would be shown up, if these five Tory Parties would come together.

It is objected also under this same heading that the electorate—and the Taoiseach said it here in this House— are not told in advance that there is going to be a coalition, and so do not realise that there would be a coalition, and that therefore it is not fair. We must recognise, in so far as it concerns 1948, there is some validity in that point. I did not see any suggestion before the election in 1948 that there would be a "get together", a "rallying together", a coalition against Fianna Fáil. I think there is something in that suggestion, but it has no validity at all in relation to 1954. The people knew perfectly well what would happen if they voted inter-Party in 1954. Therefore, that objection is quite unsound in relation to 1954. The electorate knew exactly what voting for the inter-Party would mean and they knew also—and I think this is significant—how they could increase or diminish the weight of each Party element in the potential Coalition Government. They also knew exactly what the alternative was, and they threw out that alternative—and that alternative was a Fianna Fáil Government.

Furthermore, even in 1948 before the election, Fianna Fáil had an over-all majority in the House, and their Government had 18 months to go, but they were irritated by losing two by-elections, so that instead of going ahead with their policy which they had power to implement—it was not upset in any way in the House—they went to the country and asked the country for a bigger majority, for what was called "a clear majority". That was the main issue in the 1948 election, and the people requested to pass judgment on that main issue in that general election gave the answer: "No", and threw Fianna Fáil out of office.

I should like to ask: did Fianna Fáil learn any lesson from either of those defeats? Did they say: "We must recognise that for some reason the electorate has rejected us. Why did they reject us? Is it because of our policy, because of the way we have been implementing our policy, or is it because we have not yet implemented our policy after 16 years of unbroken power?" I think it legitimate to expect a Party in such conditions to put that type of question to itself.

I have suggested already that the coming into being, into prominence, of Clann na Poblachta was due to the fact that they took the 1927 policy of Fianna Fáil out of cold storage and promised to apply it. Yet after these defeats, what Fianna Fáil, in fact, said was: "No; there could be nothing wrong with us." I am afraid that is the attitude of Fianna Fáil—maybe it is the attitude of any politician who has been in power for a long time. It is not to be found solely in Fianna Fáil, but it is very obvious in Fianna Fáil. "There could not be anything wrong with us, so what is wrong? It must be the voting system, the electoral system. We shall have to change that." The Bourbon family in France were thrown out, and when they came back, it was said of them that they had learned nothing and forgotten nothing. That was due in their case to inordinate pride, and it came before a very big fall.

Now, I should like to say something briefly about the two Coalition Governments for which, I have made it sufficiently clear, I had no immense or passionate admiration. But let us look fairly at what they were, what they did and compare them and their results with one-Party Government results, forgetting for a moment which Party was more arrogant or which Party talked most about what it had done.

In fact, the first Coalition Government was very interesting to observe, because it was composed of the Ministers of different Parties. It is true to say that each one of these Ministers was on his toes to show that he, his Party and his Party's policy could achieve results and bring things about. For a considerable period they did well. That cannot really be objectively or impartially denied. For the first time great strides forward were made in many Departments; though, admittedly, they were strides that could have been made long ago during the 16 years that Fianna Fáil were in power.

That is one of the things that most irritate the present Government. It irritated them when they were in opposition that the Coalition Government did things relatively easily which could have been done long ago.

There was then his healthy rivalry between ministerial colleagues. It remained for quite a time a friendly rivalry. We all know that that friendliness broke down in the end. But within the terms of Tory Government—and that is the only kind of Government we ever had since we got self-Government in this country—they did a reasonably good job. Fianna Fáil may not like that; I view it objectively and I am not a supporter of Coalition Government—they did a good job, both at home and abroad.

In one field in particular more was done in three years than had been done in 25 years before. Ask any T.B. patient, sick person, ask old people, people in the workhouse, the rich or the poor, what was achieved by the then Minister for Health, who was, in my contention and in the belief of many people in this country, the most dynamic and consistently effective Minister we have yet had in any Department. He is not the Minister of whom the Coalition is most apt to boast. Yet he was a Minister with a brilliant record of action. The record of several others of that time in Government stands up to critical examination. Viewed fairly, it will be found that the first Coalition brought the country at least a little further on the road of progress until it smashed itself up when it ran into an ecclesiastical road-block.

Yet, how wrong the present Taoiseach was in his judgment of that first Coalition Government when it came into power, because on the 9th February, 1948—I am quoting from the Irish Times—the present Taoiseach is quoted as saying:—

"The Coalition would fly apart and we would be forced into another general election within a few months."

He was wrong. It ran for three and a quarter years which is just a bit over the average life of British Parliaments since 1918.

The second Coalition Government— I do not want to dwell too long on it— was, I think, less courageous and a less effective Government. It was elected, though, by the people who knew exactly what they were doing. Those people had been consulted by Fianna Fáil when Fianna Fáil had an overall majority. Fianna Fáil went to the people, and the people had said: "Give us back the Coalition again." Though it failed to solve the problems of poverty, unemployment and emigration, its successor to-day, with an equally overall majority, has not been conspicuously more successful in any of these fields.

The third objection to P.R. was stated to be that it does not give strong Government—stability. I should like to ask this question. Does the single seat constituency really give stronger majorities? I should like to give two quotations. The first of these is from an article in The Contemporary Review in 1948 by John Fitzgerald. This article is about the Irish general election in 1948. Mr. Fitzgerald says this about it. One is a remark of his own and the other is a quotation from the Irish Times. The facts he mentions are significant:—

"...In bidding to become the Government at its first general election the Clann——"

—He is referring to Clann na Poblachta—

"ran 93 candidates. It secured 14 per cent. of the total poll, but only 7 per cent. of the seats (173, 166 votes; ten seats). In many constituencies its candidates between them polled well below a quota, and failed to secure representation. Thirty-one of them forfeited their deposits. Some candidates of other parties, including Fianna Fáil, also lost theirs. Fianna Fáil (de Valera) secured 42 per cent. of the votes, and 46 per cent. of the seats."

The second quotation from this article is one from the Irish Times:—

"The election results have proved that the system of the single transferable vote makes for stability rather than chaos.... The threat to political and economic orthodoxy, constituted by Clann na Poblachta, has been largely removed by the electorate."

I suggest that that is proved, supported and confirmed by the figures that Mr. Fitzgerald quotes before that.

The second quotation is also from Mr. Fitzgerald. This is about the British election in 1951 and is from The Contemporary Review of December, 1951. This is in relation to a British election under the single seat constituency system. This is what he said:—

"After more than 18 months' experience of continuing his Government in office with the minute majority of six in the Parliament elected in February, 1950, Mr. Attlee secured a dissolution and asked the country for a renewal of confidence with ‘adequate' parliamentary support."

In other words, he went to the country. He had a majority of only six, and he asked for "a clear majority" under a system which the Taoiseach tells us will give good, strong, clear majorities. Mr. Fitzgerald goes on:—

"The votes cast on October 25th, however, show the country still very evenly divided and the new House of Commons is only slightly less closely balanced than its predecessor ...Although there were only four unopposed returns and nearly 83 per cent. of the citizens voted, in the 621 constituencies fought by 1,376 candidates only 27 changes in party representation arose. Though small, the changes were vital, Labour suffering a net loss of 20 seats to the Conservatives. Mr. Attlee therefore resigned, and Mr. Churchill, with a majority of 17, now leads a Conservative Government."

With this wonderful system which ensures stability and strong majorities, you switch from a Labour majority of six to a Conservative majority of 17 out of a House of 625. That, I submit, makes nonsense of the contention that you are necessarily going to get big majorities out of the single seat non-transferable vote.

On the question of stability, I should like to remind the House that we had this stability, that is to say, if you judge stability by what the Taoiseach seems to mean, and what the Fianna Fáil speakers seem to mean, the big power of the Government. We had it very strongly here between 1922 and 1927 because the minority in the Dáil was minute, 20 or 30 members. Mr. Cosgrave had a very big majority. Is the Taoiseach or Fianna Fáil happy that the country was in a better state or better governed because of that big strong majority with the tiny Opposition? Do they think that the country became less stable in 1927 when Fianna Fáil were in the Dáil between 1927 and 1932, in other words, when the Opposition was made bigger and more effective? Will Fianna Fáil contend that that made for less stability and less good government? Was it better when they stayed out, and when strong Government could tend to do what it liked, and snap its fingers at the Opposition? Was it improved by the increase in the size of the Opposition by the coming into the Dáil in 1927 of Fianna Fáil? The answer is obvious.

One of the dangers about strong Government is that it becomes arrogant in power, and fails after a time even readily to discuss parliamentary amendments, much less accept them. It grows in arrogance as it grows in power. Govment strength. Strength to do what? What is it precisely that the Government has to be strong to do?

Do the supporters of this Bill want the Government to be strong enough to be able to implement its policy, or to be strong enough not to have to bother? I am afraid it is the latter. If your Government is really strong and in office for a long time you do not have to bother so much. There is not so much urgency about applying your policy. That is what happened in the 16 years of Fianna Fáil power.

What was said in relation to the Fianna Fáil paper could be said about the Party. It was said in The Bell, in an article by Dr. Vivian Mercer, that “the Irish Press started with high ideals and a big overdraft. The two diminished side by side down the years until now it has no overdraft”. I am afraid that that is what happened to the Fianna Fáil Party. It started with high ideals, to which many of us who were young at the time looked with hope. It grew in arrogance with increasing power—and arrogance which it has not unlearnt, even after being defeated twice.

I believe, on the contrary, that there is great public benefit to be derived from a situation where the Government is not strong enough to be able to snap its fingers at public opinion, and where if it fails to keep its promises it can be thrown out.

How many remember what in fact the Fianna Fáil aims were? I will refer to them. I will refer to their policy when they had just been elected to these 16 years of power. I should like to quote some words of the Taoiseach on that point. He said:—

"That the whole basis of production, distribution, finance, and credit requires complete overhauling is amply evident from the reports of the various committees which are summarised so admirably in the Secretary-General's report."

I am quoting, by the way, from collected speeches of Mr. de Valera, Peace and War, page 13:—

"If we shirk any item in this task, if we fail to make the radical changes obviously necessary, if we fail to organise our economic life deliberately, and purposely to provide as its first object for the fundamental needs of all our citizens so that everyone may at least be reasonably housed, clothed and fed, we shall be failing in our duty, and failing cruelly and disastrously."

He added:—

"But it must be a will that will seek effective action no matter what interest is crossed——"

Comment on this

We have the best housing conditions in the world.

Comment on this

Senator Lenihan has just interjected to say that we have the best housing conditions in the world.

Comment on this

The Commissioner for Housing for New York City.

Comment on this

I would be very tempted to go down that by-path and perhaps lead Senator Lenihan into Fenian Street, Townsend Street, Francis Street and the rest of them. Remarkable advances have been made in housing by Fianna Fáil, I recognise that, but the stumbling block has been the so-called "economic rent". Consequently, those who most need rehousing are still in the slums.

I have quoted what the present Taoiseach said on the 26th September 1932 when he was President of the Council of the League of Nations, and he said that in Geneva. I think it is fair to put the question: if that was what is put forward as the view of the head of the Government, coming to power for the first time in 1932— the very year he came to power— perhaps Senator Lenihan would tell us if the whole basis of distribution, production, finance and credit has been completely overhauled.

Comment on this

We have more nationalised industry than any country outside the Iron Curtain.

Comment on this

Have we radically changed our entire system in order to provide first for the needs of our people and not first for the greeds of the new Ascendancy? If we have in fact radically altered our whole system of production, distribution and finance, which I deny—we have not radically altered them——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Are we to have a debate on that issue to-night?

Comment on this

I am making the point that the Fianna Fáil Party, in supporting this Bill, are asking for more power. I am asking— power to do what? Why did they not do it when they had the power? I think it fair to mention to the House what it was they said they would do. I made the accusation already that they have failed to implement their policy. I should like to indicate that it is on these points they have not done so. I shall not dwell on it, but I should like to put the question: if in fact that has not been done, this radical overhaul and radical change, and so on, who was it that branded such future failure as cruel and disastrous? I would ask what is the penalty which political Parties and politicians must pay for such cruel and disastrous failure? I suggest it is loss of power. But that penalty is not mentioned in the present Bill. What is asked for is a reward— more power. I do not regard that as equitable. The reward asked for now, after 21 years of power—not 16—is more power, bigger majorities, disproportionate representation.

One other point on this question of strong government is that, when you have a strong Government and a fat majority, when you know you can do exactly what you like with Parliament, not only is effective opposition in Parliament gravely diminished in its effectiveness, as Senator O'Quigley has demonstrated, but any critics who may exist within the Party—people critical of the official line, such as Senator Lenihan, within the Party—are rendered powerless because, whereas with a small majority anybody critical within the Party has a certain measure of influence. I may be wrong, of course, in crediting Senator Lenihan with critical powers within the Party; I may be unfair to him. However, if there be any critics of the official line within any Party with a colossal majority, I submit that those critics are rendered practically powerless if that majority is colossal, whereas if the majority is small then it is one of the points that may be made in favour of Coalitions——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

On a point of information, please. I am trying to follow the Senator's reasoning. Did he make the case that the straight vote system would bring very small majorities—17 in the case of one British Government? Is he now trying to make the case that there will be vast majorities?

Comment on this

That is a legitimate question. If I may be allowed to answer it for the enlightenment of Senator Ó Maoláin I shall be happy to go back over that point. I gave an example of the 1951 situation in Britain that it is untrue to say that you are necessarily, from the single seat constituency system, going to get a big majority. I think I have proved that that is simply not true. Therefore, one of the major reasons for asking for the abolition of P.R. falls to the ground, if you admit that. I said it is not necessarily true. My second point is that, even if you achieve a colossal majority, which does not necessarily follow from the other system, but it can follow, and it did follow in Britain in 1935, and even more so in 1931—if you achieve such a situation with a colossal, complacent government majority then you render nugatory all criticism within the Party which may arise. I should like to quote the figures in 1935 for the British situation. They are not very complicated. The British National Government polled in 1935 12,000,000 votes and for that they got 405 seats. The Labour Party polled 8,500,000 and they got 121 seats. The others polled 1,250,000 and got only 21 seats, the others being mostly Liberals. The Government seats represented, each of them, 30,000 voters; the Labour seats represented 60,000 voters each, and the others each represented 70,000. That is the kind of pattern you may easily get in the single seat constituency system.

I see a danger, too, that strong Government may become immovable Government, and that immovable Government—the Government you cannot shift—may become a motionless Government, a Government that does not create any legislative product or any implementation of policy. I suggest that the talk about "stability" really comes from a desire to rule whether you have the people's authority behind you or not; in other words stability by majorities disproportionate to their voting strength in the country. Parties and politicians under such circumstances are encouraged to mistake power, which they have got by disproportionate representation, for authority given to them by the people, whereas in fact it has been given to them by a bad electoral system.

I should like now to turn to the question as to what was the correct interpretation of the electorate's failure on several occasions to grant any Government in this country a clear majority. What was the correct interpretation of the will of the people in those circumstances? I know that Fianna Fáil in the '30's, at times when they were depending upon the Labour Party for continuance in office, became very irritated, but supposing they had interpreted the people's will as desiring a Fianna Fáil policy with Labour support, a Fianna Fáil policy with Labour leanings, what in fact would have happened? We would have had Irish shipping at a much earlier stage. We would have had far better social welfare before the war. We would have had electricity from turf long before the war instead of having to wait until 1946 for the idea to germinate. We would have had the fairly progressive Government the people were asking for by slanting the grant of power in that way.

If, however, Fianna Fáil were to have considered that, on the whole, Fine Gael was nearer to them than Labour, then you could have had a good, strong, anti-progressive coalition on behalf of the new forces in power in the industrial and commercial fields of wealth and privilege, but Fianna Fáil did not want either type of support. It seems to me that it would have been legitimate to interpret the people's will thus: "We want a Fianna Fáil Government, but as they have made very slow progress we want them to be in the position where the Labour Party can goad them into progressive activity."

That would have been a legitimate interpretation of the people's will, but pride refused that interpretation and two or three times in the '30's and in the '40's though complaint is frequently made by Fianna Fáil itself that there was a multiplicity of elections, many of them were forced by Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil went back to the people and implored them to give them an over-all majority, which the people did. Then the war situation came along with many pressing problems, which could have been solved far earlier during seven years of Fianna Fáil power, as yet untackled.

It has even been suggested that the security of the county might have been in danger during the war because Fianna Fáil had not got a uniformly stable majority during that period.

That suggestion is balderdash. The British Government, from 1931 to 1940 was about as stable as you could get. They had the most colossal majority they ever got in November, 1931, which was two years before Hitler came to power. That Government remained stable from two years before Hitler's coming to power until the battle of Narvik in April, 1940. The real danger to internal security in Britain at that time arose from having an all-powerful Government complacent in its unshakable power. Its colossal stability, in fact, led to colossal conceit and to the very brink of total disaster.

How was that disaster averted? By a Coalition Government. I think that is not without significance. In Ireland during that period all the Parties supported Fianna Fáil very loyally during the war in their main attitude on all major constitutional or security issues. I can think of only one constitutional or security issue on which Fianna Fáil was not so supported; that was when the Government deemed it necessary to alter the rules of evidence in order to execute George Plant, who had been acquitted by the courts. They were not supported in that by Fine Gael and Labour, though it is true that they had the support of Deputy Dillon in the Dáil. That is the only instance I can think of during the war when they failed to win the over-all support of the Parties.

It is nonsense to say, therefore, that our security might have been jeopardised because we had not got a stable war-time Government. In fact, under P.R. in both peace and war, and even in civil war, we have had one of the most stable Governments in Europe. I should like to quote the Economist of the 6th September, 1958, which says:—

"The reasons that Mr. de Valera advances to support a change are that P.R. has caused instability of government and promoted the rise of small Parties. They are hardly reasons which seems to accord with the facts. Since 1922 only three men have formed Governments; Mr. Cosgrave, Mr. de Valera, and Mr. Costello. But this austere standard, the administration of the United States is dangerously unstable and British politics as positively Balkan. The first Irish Government lasted ten years; the second 16; the third, fourth and fifth, three years each. The sixth, Mr. de Valera's own, is now in office with a clear majority. Certainly minor Parties have come and gone: but only three have shown staying power—Mr. de Valera's, Mr. Costello's and Labour."

That seems to me to be fair comment on this question as to whether in peace and war, we would not have stable government. To support that further, I should like briefly to quote from the Manchester Guardian of the 2nd September, 1958, which said:—

"Under P.R. the Irish Republic (formerly Free State) has enjoyed about the stablest Government in Europe. First Mr. Cosgrave's Party had a run of ten years. Then Mr. de Valera's Party had a run of 16 years. Since then the pendulum has swung more evenly but not with uncomfortable rapidity; each side has had about 3 years at a time in office."

Therefore, it seems to me to be true that not only have we not had instability but we have had one of the stablest Governments in Europe, due to the first-class system we have had, a system which is now being besmirched and attacked, and which it is sought now to throw out.

I have endeavoured to examine the case that has been made against P.R. My conviction remains strongly in favour of it for the simple reason that P.R., as opposed to the single-seat constituency with the non-transferable vote, puts effective power on political decisions into the hands of the voter. That is where I want political power to remain, and that is where power should be in a democracy in the hands of the electors, power, real power to express effective preference between Parties, preference between individuals inside Parties, preference between individuals and Parties. That is the power that Party bosses and Party leaders do not like to leave in what they regard as the "irresponsible" hands of the electors. That is the power given into the very hands of the voters by this system of P.R., the power which has given us all the Governments in this country since 1922. Under the one-member system, on the contrary all the voter has to do, all he has a right to do, is to plump for one candidate and, under that system, we shall be coming back to the split vote, and the three-cornered contest, all of which are very bad.

I am afraid it is obvious that Fianna Fáil looks forward to many of those three-cornered contests, but I suggest they are unfair to the electors. They are bad in principle; they are bad in Britain. Furthermore, they have the effect that this misnamed "straight vote" system is often productive of a compromise vote. Many Liberals in Britain to-day vote either Tory or Socialist as a "second best", so as not to waste their votes but, if given the chance to express their preference, they would vote Liberal first and only secondly either Labour or Conservative. The system in Britain does not show a clear picture, since there are many, perhaps thousands, of these "compromise" votes, so, therefore, it is not a straight vote system.

There is one point I wish to make in detail. I take it that we shall come to a Committee Stage, but this is one detail I want to make in case not. That is, in relation to paragraph 3, sub-section (6) on page 12 of this Bill. The section reads as follows:—

"No court shall entertain any question as to whether the commission has been properly constituted or any question as to whether the determination or revision of the boundaries of constituencies as set out in their report has been properly carried out."

I suggest that that proviso is repugnant to the Constitution and I suggest, if the Bill is passed in this form, it will be possible to have that point tested in the courts. It will not be possible, in fact, to hold this referendum at once because the Constitution says, Article 46, Section 4:—

"A Bill containing a proposal or proposals for the amendment of the Constitution shall not contain any other proposal."

This, I would submit, is another proposal. It is a proposal to prevent the courts from having a power which, apparently they would have normally; from exercising a power, from continuing in possession of a power. That is quite a separate issue. It has nothing to do with P.R. It has nothing to do with the whole spirit of this Bill. It is a totally new principle—the taking away by this sub-section of power from the courts to entertain a question as to whether the commission has been properly constituted or as to whether their work has been properly done. I say "take away power" because if the courts have not that power vested in them at present, the sub-section has no meaning at all. But, if that power is so vested in them now, this article is introducing a quite separate and new principle into the whole constitutional situation, which Section 4, Article 46, of the Constitution precludes, and so I suggest, on that one point of detail, it is a very dangerous sub-section. I shall speak further upon it if and when we come to the Committee Stage.

I shall conclude, then, just on this point. The question may be legitimately put and has been put: "Why, if you feel so strongly, not leave it to the electors to decide?"

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

We in the Seanad can do no more than hold it up for 90 days. The worst that can happen to the elecorate is that they will have to think it over for another 90 days, and I do not think that that will do them serious harm. After all, the system has been in operation since 1922. But, if this has to be submitted to the electors, it is going to go to them, to the electorate, without my approval and my sponsorship. It is not going to them as a Bill that has been passed with the help of my vote. Why do I do that? Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien rightly put it on the list of "just things we have won for Ireland," and I am not going to cast a vote in favour of its abolition. I am going to vote against the Bill. So I shall resist by my vote this retrograde measure. I think it does little credit to its sponsors, and if the people were to be cajoled into accepting it, it would deprive the electorate of a valuable degree of discriminatory control over its representatives.

If this Bill goes through, that power of discriminatory control will pass into the smooth hands of the Party bosses, but, however, if the referendum does go to the people, the result may well surprise Fianna Fáil, because many voters who have lately voted for Fianna Fáil, because they have seen Fianna Fáil being just a shade less supine in face of certain pressures than Labour or Fine Gael have proved to be—those Fianna Fáil voters will not vote, as Fianna Fáil asks them, for the abolition of P.R., but will preserve in the hands of the electors all the valuable discriminatory powers which P.R. at present enables them to wield.

Comment on this

I think, before discussing this Bill, it might be no harm to mention that it is a very fundamental and important measure—that is, it is the first opportunity since the foundation of the State that the most democratic of all processes has been invoked, namely, the process of the referendum. A good deal of talk has been bandied about here by some of our university professors and by our opponents in regard to this measure. The allegation has been made that it is an undemocratic Bill and that it will be hurtful to democracy in Ireland. Yet, the very Bill itself envisages that a practical Article in our Constitution is being invoked for the first time, and that the people will get an opportunity of making their decision known in free and open franchise under that Article in the Constitution. It is perhaps no harm to mention that that has been done 21 years after the Constitution was enacted, when the Constitution has come of age.

We are very proud of the fact that the Constitution enshrined the fundamental liberties of our people here. Free of the trimmings in the Constitution, the people can now exercise that free franchise. We are very certain the Bill will go to them despite the obstacles it has met in the Dáil and the further obstacles here in the Seanad. I think the very people who created those obstacles have shown themselves to be anti-democratic. We have taken over the referendum from the cradle of democracy, from Switzerland, where the idea originated, and we are very proud to have it incorporated in our Constitution. Now, when the Constitution has come of age, we are very glad to ask the people to make a simple decision in regard to whether they are in favour of a very simple matter.

Senator O'Brien took the Government to task on the basis that this issue was not being put in a simple fashion to the people. I could hardly see, and I fail to imagine, what he thinks could be simpler. The people are being asked to decide a very net point—whether they want the single seat constituency and the straight vote in that type of constituency. They are being asked to say "yes" or "no" to that. I agree there is the question of the commission wrapped up in that but that really, as far as the people are concerned, is not important. The important point is basically whether they are in favour or are against the system of election that operated up to now, or whether they are for or against the straight vote system in single seat constituencies.

In regard to the question of the attitude of the Seanad to this matter, I think the most correct exposé of a proper attitude in regard to it was made this evening by Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien. She expressed herself very well, in a more dignified manner than other Senators opposed to the Bill expressed themselves, and she made her case quite plain. She was opposed to the measure, but that, however, did not deter her from expressing quite clearly her democratic belief that, in spite of opposing the Bill she was going to vote for it in order not to prevent the people from expressing their views in a referendum as speedily and as expeditiously as possible. Now, in the particular context of the Seanad's function in regard to a measure of this nature, it might be no harm to refer to an attitude adopted by the Fine Gael Leader in this House on a previous occasion in regard to another similar measure. I refer to Senator Hayes——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

On a measure similar to this? There never was one.

Comment on this

It is a reference made by the Senator to the Electoral (Amendment) Act, 1947, on which he spoke and on which he adopted a certain attitude in regard to what the Seanad should do. If I may quote from Volume 34, column 1035, of the Seanad debates, his reaction on that occasion was that he felt:—

"...we ought discuss the general principle, but that the particular matter of the constituencies was something which was peculiarly a matter for the Dáil. We have a constitutional right to deal with it, but it is rather a matter for the Dáil to settle its own business than for us to endeavour to settle it for them."

In other words, as the Senator pointed out in that contribution, he recognised that, although he had, technically, a fundamental right to deal with the Bill, it was peculiarly something for the Dáil to deal with, in that it appertained to the readjustment of the constituencies. Putting that principle further, is it not more apposite in regard to this measure in that it is a matter for the people to decide on the method of election to the Dáil and although technically, under the Constitution, we may have a right to delay it, I think it is an excessive user of that right to frustrate the people from deciding, as expeditiously as possible, the method of election to the Dáil.

The reality of the matter is that this is not a fully representative assembly compared with the popular House. The popular House has passed this measure and I feel that it is an excessive user of our right to frustrate the people from making their decision. For that reason, I applaud the very democratic attitude adopted by Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien. Although she definitely stated she would vote against this measure when she came to cast her vote, she decided, in a proper democratic manner, that she would vote for this Bill in the House, in order not to prevent people from making their own decision on the method of election to Dáil Éireann.

As regards the proposal generally, I should like to say that the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party have disappointed me in that they have been unable, seemingly, to face up to the challenge incorporated in this Bill. In my view, there is no doubt that, the straight vote system will always enable the pendulum to swing decisively one way or the other. It will, in other words, enable the people to express a particular wish decisively. When the people do express their wish and decide against a particular Party, that wish, as well as having a negative effect of putting out one Party, will put in another.

Fine Gael and Labour have not faced up to the challenge in that idea. They have failed to face up to the very definite challenge: "You can be the alternative to this Government, for the full statutory period, if you put your policy and views before the people so that they give you their support and reject the Fianna Fáil Party". That alternative Government idea is inherent in this proposal, of enabling the people not merely to express their view in a negative fashion by merely rejecting one Party, but to put in another to govern for the full statutory period.

Another allegation made, in particular by Senator Sheehy Skeffington, was that this decision was not arrived at democratically by the Fianna Fáil Party. There was an Árd-Fheis of that Party held some months ago in Dublin. There were various resolutions from various Cumainn of that organisation, from all parts of the country, on the agenda for the Árd-Fheis, all proposing that P.R. as a system, as a mechanism of election, should be abolished. There was a full debate on that matter for half a day, occupying nearly one-third of the time of that Árd-Fheis and the resolutions suggesting that this method of election be abolished were passed after full debate and a full report appeared in all the daily newspapers——

Comment on this

Inspired ones.

Comment on this

——of that freely-made decision by the democratic people in our Party. It is now being incorporated into this legislation by the Executive of that Party, in the form of the Government and is being put to the people——

Comment on this

Were there any speeches against the abolition of P.R.?

Comment on this

There was a full discussion on it. If the Senator picks up his Irish Times, or Irish Independent, or Irish Press for, roughly, the middle of October last year, he will see that. It was fully reported.

Comment on this

Were there any speeches against its abolition?

Comment on this

Every delegate rose and applauded it, the Irish Press said.

Comment on this

In addition to that point raised by Senator Sheehy Skeffington, there is another matter to which I should like to refer before going on to the main argument. I must say that certain supposedly independent-minded Senators have disappointed me over the past few days, in particular——

Comment on this

We know that.

Comment on this

——Senators traditionally regarded as vocational Senators. Most people who intelligently read the reports of Oireachtas proceedings, and most people who know what transpires in both Houses, can be satisfied that over the years, two of the most independent and valued Independent members of the Oireachtas are Deputy Russell of Limerick and Deputy Sheldon of East Donegal. They have no particular axe to grind in regard to this matter; they are not under any whip, any alleged whip, of the Fianna Fáil Party; they are not members of our National Executive; and they do not attend our Árd-Fheiseanna. Yet both of these men, in my view, made some of the most valued contributions during the various stages of this Bill in the Dáil. Both of them are independent men who adopt an independent attitude in the Dáil which contrasts favourably, in my view, with the attitude that could, and should have been, adopted by some members of this House.

However, I will go on to the main question which is the Bill before us and which we are seeking to induce Seanad Éireann to pass and to let the people make a decision on it. First of all, I should like to discuss this question of P.R. We have had a particular form of it for a number of years, a particular species, and the system that we have operated for the past number of years is working in only three other areas of the world at the moment—I could hardly refer to them as countries —Tasmania, Malta and Gibraltar. The particular system which we have operated operates only in those three provincial areas. In no national Legislature in the world does our particular brand of P.R. operate. There are various other types known as list systems; but they all have one common factor in that they place emphasis on the mathematical representation of all shades and colours of opinions in Parliament. That is the principle behind the P.R. idea. Call it what you will, that is the basic principle, that there should be as near mathematical representation as possible in Parliament.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was a professor of mathematics and apparently he put it into the Constitution.

Comment on this

That is a rather unnecessary remark. The Senator spoke for over two hours and we listened to it.

Comment on this

Not without interruption.

Comment on this

The Senators opposite did not have to listen to stuff like this.

Comment on this

The alternative to the various types of P.R. we have had all over the world is what is known as the straight vote system, the system which operates in the two oldest democracies in the world, the United States and Britain. It also operates in Canada and New Zealand in particular. The point has been made—and I think it was a very dishonest point coming from a man of the calibre of Professor Stanford who has in many cases made excellent contributions to Seanad debates—that there was a parallel between the Union of South Africa, the Six Counties and here in regard to the system of election. I personally throught that very dishonest because everybody in the House knows that in both areas the whole system of political organisation and the whole way of living in those areas are bedevilled by secretarianism. That is an unfortunate thing and we regret it very much, particularly in regard to the north-eastern portion of our country.

To say that because those two areas where sectarianism may have held monolithic parties together and to say that these monolithic parties are maintained because they use straight voting and that that condemns straight voting is a highly dishonest argument without reference to other countries such as Canada, the United States, Britain, and New Zealand where straight voting operates and where it enables the people properly to express their views. It is highly dishonest to quote the Six Counties. The whole foundation of the Union of South Africa is bedevilled by the apartheid question. There is a sharp division of opinion on that. We all know the situation in the Six Counties where Orange antipathy bedevils the situation. That would operate no matter what system of election was there. The plain fact of the matter is that P.R. did operate in the Six Counties for a few years after 1922 and when they introduced the straight vote system some time in the middle '20's it did not make one whit of difference to the representation of the various groups in the Stormont Parliament. I have not the figures before me but I have read up on the matter and my recollection is that changing from P.R. to the straight vote did not make a whit of difference to Nationalist representation in Stormont. Constituencies are gerrymandered outside the electoral system and the same sort of political gerrymandering is operated in South Africa in order to give a large majority to a particular sectarian group whose primary purpose is the suppression of the people of one colour. It is highly dishonest to try to draw any parallel between the situations in those two parts of the world and compare them with what might happen here under a similar electoral system. It would be far more honest to use for comparison purposes Great Britain, the United States, Canada or New Zealand.

The idea behind P.R. is the question of exact statistical representation and I do not think that should be confused with democracy. The idea we want to get across here for the people to study is that representation cannot be equated to democracy. They are entirely different factors. The idea of P.R. originated with a certain Liberal thinker in Britain in the last century. It was the invention of a man called Thomas Hare. It was followed up by John Stuart Mill and the British P.R. Society was instituted to propagate it.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

In Britain certain people were dissatisfied for years with the straight voting system as it was operated on the basis that it did not give statistical representation, as if that was the object of society. The P.R. Society, sought with no success whatever, to force their own Government to adopt the system——

Comment on this

Do you admit that straight voting does not give statistical representation?

Comment on this

I fully agree that exact statistical representation is not given by the straight voting system but I would say that is not the object of social organisation.

Comment on this

I am glad to have that admission.

Comment on this

My proposition would be that the object of organised society is to provide a system which can guarantee an effective Government and in a democratic system that Government should be a Government that takes cognisance of the important liberties and freedoms which we cherish so much and which are protected by the fundamental law in the Constitution and given effect to by the courts that are given independence under the Constitution. The question of exact statistical representation is irrelevant to the main purposes of society. It is a fact that there should be as good representation as possible in Parliament consistent with those ends, the provision of government for the people and the preservation of the ordinary liberties of the subject.

This idea of mathematical representation was developed in Britain by the P.R. Society and although there has been a lot of argument and debate about it it may be no harm to put on record that it was incorporated in the Government of Ireland Act, 1920 which was vehemently opposed by the Irish people at that time.

Comment on this

And supported by the Taoiseach in 1919.

Comment on this

The first time the views of the Proportional Representation Society were given effect to was in that Act which was abhorred by 90 per cent. of the people, the Government of Ireland Act, 1920. The British, of course, are very sensible in one way. Right through the last century, they proceeded to encourage nationalism in every country in the world. They encouraged revolutions in all the countries of Europe, but they made very sure not to encourage nationalism in this country. But while the British imposed the P.R. system in the Government of Ireland Act, and while the Proportional Representation Society may have exported its views to half the Continent of Europe after the first World War, they made very sure not to adopt it in their own country.

Comment on this

Who incorporated it in the 1937 Constitution?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must be permitted to make his speech.

Comment on this

The point is that the British in their own country are careful not to have any system which would artificially create minorities. They let minorities create themselves artificially outside Hyde Park cornor, if they want to do so, or inside Hyde Park, but they make very certain not to let them into Parliament.

The idea was exported to various continental countries and despite the arguments that have been made, there is no doubt that it is historically true that after the first World War, democracy broke down in both Italy and Germany, two major countries that contributed so much to the Christian tradition and to the European way of life. Democracy broke down in those cases primarily because of this system of P.R. in their Parliaments which made way for a multiplicity of parties and prevented government. Democracy was brought into disrepute, political Parties were discredited and the way was prepared for two of the modern world's greatest dictators, Hitler and Mussolini.

When democracy gets into disrepute, the way is made clear for that type of dictator. The old Greeks, who formulated the ideas of political philosophy, said that the great danger in democracy was that it would always be followed by totalitarianism. They had a school of thought which held that when democracy was discredited there was a tendency towards dictatorship and this tendency in fact caused the downfall of quite a lot of the democratic Greek City States which succumbed to dictatorship.

Democracy, if it places its house in order, can strengthen itself. If democracy disintegrates what follows is totalitarianism. Surely our objective here should be that democracy does not disintegrate. The major purpose of this Bill is to ensure as far as it can be done that democracy does not disintegrate.

Comment on this

Does P.R. do that?

Comment on this

The purpose of the Bill is to see that a system will develop, which can easily develop over the years, whereby the people can be assured of democratic government, whereby democracy can be preserved and whereby democratic Parties will not fall into disrepute or be discredited. One thing is certain, democracy is brought into discredit by the chaos of too many individual Parties and ineffective government.

If democracy is to withstand the challenge of the world to-day, the important thing is to work democracy and in particular to see that democracy can give itself a strong executive.

In regard to that particular aspect, I have already stated, and it is undeniable, that this chaos engendered by P.R. systems gave rise, in two major European countries, to two dictatorships in the 1930s. I do not intend to deal with the disastrous effects of those two great dictatorial régimes. However, after the war the Western German Government thought fit to strengthen its democratic structure. I agree that they did not go the whole way, in having a universal straight voting system. The position at the moment in the Western German Parliament is that half the members of the Parliament are elected on the basis of straight voting and on the basis of the single seat constituency. The position in Germany is rather confused by the fact that the country is divided into Leander or federal areas and that for the purpose of these areas there is P.R. voting. But, as regards the universal voting, apart from the federated areas, the voting is on the single seat basis and with the straight nontransferable vote.

Western Germany, with its knowledge of its experiences under the Weimar Republic in the 1920s, saw fit in its Constitution after the recent world war, to strengthen its position. As a result of what they did at that time, Western Germany is to-day a bulwark or bastion of the free world which every country in the world can see. Furthermore, Western Germany is easily the most prosperous country in Western Europe. The position there is that there are two Parties which have developed in the country, the Christian Democrat Party and the Social-Democratic opposition. The Socialist opposition is not concerned with having socialist clashes but is a moderate Socialist Party. In other words, there are two main Parties, one in government and one in opposition, in Western Germany. Western Europe would not suffer one whit if the Christian Democrats were beaten in the next election and if in their stead the Socialists were put into power in Western Germany.

In the other country, Italy, Signor de Gaspari—before be died some years ago—introduced in 1953 and electoral law at the time to mitigate the P.R. system in Italy. That enabled Italy to get out of the chaos which existed in the country in 1953 and stagger along for a few more years with parliamentary government. Unfortunately, Signor de Gaspari in 1953 did not go far enough. In that particular electoral amendment law of his, although he frustrated a lot of the worst features of P.R., he did not go far enough. As a result, Italy to-day is again in a chaotic situation, without a government. The manoeuvrings and bargainings and intrigues which are going on in Rome to-day will probably continue for weeks on end, before Italy has a Government capable of governing.

Surely these arguments should lead one to think that the sort of development, two or three Party development, giving people a clear choice at an election, enabling them to make a clear choice and give decisive government, is a very desirable one. I think the argument is coercive in favour of that sort of system. I think that our Government —and I am proud to be able to say it —are giving a lead in this matter. They have taken their courage into their hands and are giving a lead. Everywhere in the world to-day we find that this crazy notion of P.R., this crazy notion of giving exact statistical representation in parliament, is on the run.

Comment on this

Our Johnny is the only one in step.

Comment on this

That notion is on the run in Sweden and I venture to suggest that the same will occur in Holland. It has caused constitutional crises in Holland in recent years, which must be very annoying to that very stable people. Everywhere it is on the run and I venture to forecast that within our own time we will see it disappear as a method of election throughout the world.

Only recently, again coincidental with this Government measure, we have seen the situation in France resolve itself. No matter what anyone says, what the French had over the past number of years was a system of P.R. It is called the French List system. One may call it whatever one chooses, but it is a fancy system of P.R. In other words, it embodies the principle of exact statistical representation in parliament. It was a system of P.R. That system has been abolished recently in France and France has got stable government now, effective government for the first time in generations in that country.

Comment on this

That is an oversimplification.

Comment on this

What has been done by the Government in this country is part of a general pattern which is emerging. I submit it is part of a general idea abroad among democratic peoples, that now is the time to strengthen democracy. There is a challenge in the form of the Communist type of State where they are able to give effective government and long term planning; and this challenge must be taken up by the freedom-loving peoples of the world. The democratic answer to that challenge is to strengthen its own institutions and see that the democratic institutions can give effective government and effective leadership while preserving the Christian idea and the essential liberties denied by Communism.

What our Government is doing is merely following out that general pattern which has emerged in Western Germany, and recently in France, and which will emerge in Italy, Sweden and in Holland, I am certain, because of their present constitutional difficulties. What we have seen in this country is our Government taking a lead in the matter, not referring it to any commission or anyone else, but taking a lead and asking the people to make a decision.

I believe there is unanimity on the fact that our present system is unsatisfactory. Anyone who read closely the recent Dáil debates would find that the one patent fact which emerges is that nobody is satisfied with the present system. I quote Deputy J.A. Costello's own words, as given in Volume 171, No. 8 of the Second Reading debates on this measure in the Dáil. He said there were many defects in the present system. I think everyone would agree with that. I think that Deputy Costello's only real disagreement with the Government is that he wanted this matter submitted to a commission. If that were done, a commission would probably come out after weeks and weeks of discussion, having arrived at the same decision as has been arrived at by the Government. The Government did not give it to a commission in France or Western Germany. I venture to say that, when Italy gets out of its present crisis and if any dominant Party emerges in Italy, it will get rid of it also and will not submit the matter to a commission.

The people in the Fine Gael Party, and in particular the leader-writers in the newspaper which supports that Party, the Irish Independent, have been very fond of denouncing commissions and the delaying tactics of commissions and inquiring into wasteful Government expenditure on commissions.

As far as I can see, the only disagreement which Deputy Costello and the Fine Gael leaders have is that of not submitting the question to a Government Commission. As Deputy Costello said, there are many defects in the present system.

Comment on this

He never mentioned a commission in his speech.

Comment on this

I would say that, when Deputy Costello said that, he made a vast understatement. Apart from Deputy Costello's own attitude in the matter, we had the Leader of Clann na Talmhan, Deputy Blowick, who came very near our ideas in the matter. Clann na Talmhan, which is based at least in rural Ireland although it is a splinter offshoot had the common sense to see that the single seat idea was a good one and an amendment was put down by them, which was debated on the Second Reading, to the effect that the Government should adopt the single seat system.

Comment on this

By P.R.

Comment on this

I move the adjournment of the debate.

Cuireadh an díospóireacht ar ath-ló.

Comment on this