Private Business. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–122 of 237. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
On the last occasion, I made the point that the Seanad should take a view of this legislation which it should not take of ordinary legislation. This is not in the category of ordinary legislation to which the Seanad can put down amendments to be accepted or rejected in the Dáil. The only purpose of the Seanad in voting against this measure is to delay its coming to the people and enabling them to exercise the franchise. That point cannot be emphasised sufficiently.
The system of P.R. it is proposed to abolish by this measure operates in only three provincial areas: Malta, Tasmania and Gibraltar. The various list systems have been discredited on the Continent in recent years. Recently, France has seen fit to bring in the straight vote and the single seat constituency in order to provide itself with effective government. Italy is in chaos at present due to lack of government caused by the multiplicity of Parties in that country. There is no doubt that if same people could get control of the government there, the Italian Government would also introduce a measure such as that being brought before the Irish people by our Government to abolish this system, which places emphasis on statistical representation and ignores the important factor of providing the community with a Government.
On the last occasion, I pointed out that this system, which it is proposed to introduce here if passed by the people, exists in the old democracies of Britain and the United States of America, and it operates very well in Canada and New Zealand also. Only recently, it enabled the Canadian people to reject decisively a Liberal Government that had ruled Canada for a number of years and give power decisively to the alternative Conservative Government. I was also concerned to rebut the dishonest parallel drawn by Senator Stanford in drawing an analogy between this country and South Africa.
Comment on this
In that context, I pointed out that in South Africa and the Six Counties, the whole way of life is bedevilled by sectarianism. The real split is caused by sectarianism. The constituencies are gerrymandered in order to keep single, monolithic Parties in power and further their own interests. There is no parallel between the situation there and the situation in this country.
As statistical material in support of that contention, I might quote some figures in connection with election results in the Six Counties during the early 20s when they had a system of P.R. and the results which followed when they abolished P.R. and brought in the straight vote. In the election of 1921, there were 32 Unionists elected in the Six Counties area, and there were 12 Nationalists elected under an extreme system of P.R., that is, if you include as Nationalists, National Republicans and Sinn Féin. It is very significant that in 1925 the Nationalist figure remained the same, 12 still, under this extreme system of P.R.
In 1929, the Six County Government abolished P.R. and introduced the straight vote system. The result was that, in 1929, there were again 34 Unionists, as there were in 1921 under the P.R. system that existed at that time, and 11 Nationalists, if you include in the Nationalist group Nationalists, Republicans and Sinn Féin. There was one Nationalist loss to Labour. There was no Unionist gain. In 1933, 34 seats went to Unionists and 11 to Nationalists, under the straight vote system. Any analysis of these figures in 1921 and 1925, before P.R. was abolished, and the figures in 1929 and 1933, after P.R. was abolished, shows quite clearly that the system of election did not make one whit of difference to Nationalist representation in Parliament and that where sectarianism exists and constituencies are gerrymandered to suit the majority sectarian Party, the system of election is an entirely irrelevant factor. It is quite significant that the minority in this country, the only minority that exists, namely the Protestant Unionist minority, have no fears in the matter either.
Comment on this
May I protest against the phrase "Protestant Unionists"? It is grossly unfair to many Nationalist-minded Protestants at the present day—grossly unfair.
Comment on this
——in the sense that the only legitimate minority in this country is the Unionist minority in the 32 Counties.
Comment on this
Every minority is illegitimate according to that.
Comment on this
The only minority that can properly be regarded as a minority in a legitimate sense.
Comment on this
It is quite clear that the idea behind the P.R. system is on the run in Europe as a whole as an exact statistical representation system, and I think in our time we will see it go. However, the argument does not alone rest on that. The argument further rests on how this system has operated here over a number of years. I think we should get down to an analysis of that. Has it operated here well? I do not think it has. I think the straight vote system will make for a real improvement to giving us effective Government. One has only to look, first of all, at the elections prior to the one when the first Coalition Government came into power to see what I mean by that. In 1932 and 1933 there were two elections in order to provide the people with a Government, two elections in successive years. In 1937 and 1938 there were again two elections which the people had to face in order to provide themselves with effective Government. In 1943 and 1944 there were two elections in successive years before the people could decisively exercise their choice and give themselves a Government.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's only concern on these occasions was to provide the people with a Government which had the consistent support of a majority in Dáil Éireann. If any Government is to function it must have a disciplined group of people in Parliament supporting that Government.
Comment on this
Otherwise you have chaos and anarchy. In 1932 and 1933, there was grave danger of the country degenerating into anarchy because of the extra-judicial actions of certain people who had supported the Government prior to 1932. There was ample evidence that this system of P.R. was wasteful in leading to this duplication of elections every four or five years. In 1948, we had a Coalition Government for the first time. It lasted for three years.
Comment on this
It might be no harm to analyse why that first Coalition Government fell, because the manner of its falling was typical of the weakness inherent in the Coalition Government idea. It fell because a classical minority splinter group, the Clann na Poblachta Party, had a row among its own members. It was a classical splinter group and, within its own members, rows and dissension broke out and two Ministers in that Party, represented in the Coalition Government, broke very decisively; the result was the Government itself was forced to break up. Now, that will not happen if you have a single disciplined Party——
Comment on this
——which consistently supports the Government in Dáil Éireann. If a particular Minister happens to disagree with the view of his other Cabinet Ministers, in such a Government supported by such a Party, there will not be any split in the Cabinet, or any withdrawal of support by a small segment of the Party supporting the Government. The inherent weakness in the Coalition idea is that you have members in Government, representative of various Parties, who are responsible primarily not to the Government in which they are participating or to one major Party supporting the Government but, as in this particular case, to a small group of nine or ten in a Party; and, in that particular case, two of the Ministers in the Cabinet were supported by nine or ten members of a splinter group and, when that group broke up and withdrew its support, the Government itself was forced to break up.
However, I do not think the situation then, bad as it was, was anything like as bad as the position which existed when the second Coalition Government went into its death throes— and that is only two short years ago. In February and March of 1957 we had the ludicrous position, which was a laughing matter to the people of the country at the time and put us in a ludicrous light, where three members, the members of a three-Party splinter group—this time, again, the shrunken Clann na Poblachta Party—were able to upset a popular Parliament, Dáil Éireann, composed of 147 members. We had a Government at the time staggering along with various troubles and dissensions. What toppled them? Three members out of a Parliament of 147. The three members of Clann na Poblachta withdrew their support in February 1957 and then the Taoiseach was forced to abandon Government and go to the country.
That sort of situation cannot be allowed to happen here again and a lot of thinking people who never voted for Fianna Fáil in their lives before also thought in March 1957 that that situation should not be allowed to happen again. I think anybody who analyses the situation then will agree that the reason we got the majority we did in March 1957 was that a lot of thinking people saw that that sort of ludicrous situation could not be allowed to happen again if the country was to progress in any degree whatsoever. We are now merely reiterating the decision that was made then rejecting the coalition form of Government. This measure of ours is a reiteration of the people's wish, as expressed in March 1957, and their utter rejection of the coalition principle. This measure on which we are asking the people to decide, will merely ask them to reiterate their votes of March, 1957, rejecting Coalition Government not merely for one statutory term but for ever. That is the main purpose of the measure.
Comment on this
The only reason the P.R. system staggered along for the number of years it did—it did not work well—was that, until recently, people were very sharply divided on the Treaty issue and on the various constitutional issues of the 1930s, issues which divided the people sharply into black and white, for and against. That sharp division which went down through all strata in society, and all professions and people, no longer operates, so that the disintegrating effects of P.R. have become evident in recent years and in all likelihood will probably continue to get worse if the system is not got rid of, and I am confident the people will get rid of it.
To put it in a nutshell, the proposal is one to give the people more effective government and the net issue involved is whether you believe in government or statistical representation. Which do we want—decisive effective government or Parliament as a talking shop, a debating society representative of minute interests and groups in the community?
That is the real issue and, mind you, some years ago, in 1924, the Leader of a then minority Labour Party in the House of Commons was not concerned with perpetuating himself or his Party by some fancy method of P.R. As reported in column 2022, Volume 172 of Hansard, Mr. Herbert Morrison, speaking on behalf of a number of minority Labour Party members on a measure which was put to a free vote of the House of Commons and decisively rejected, that the straight vote system in Britain should be abandoned and P.R. introduced, said:—
"P.R. is a philosophy which is not unnatural to small new parties struggling to get a footing on the electoral field, and not having much staying power or pluck to fight. It is also perfectly natural to decaying political parties, who are doomed to extinction in the course of time, and who can only retain their position by elevating the power of the minority and subjecting the power of the majority. It is perfectly natural to them, but it is not natural to strong men and women who want their country to be governed wisely and firmly, and I hope, therefore, that the House will not accept that type of government."
In other words, the P.R. system is not natural to strong men and women who want their country to be governed wisely and firmly. Surely those words should inspire us in this matter and enable all Parties to face up to the challenge of giving the people that firm, effective and organised government that is so necessary.
Only recently, it was the view of many responsible people who, I venture to say, are still in the Fine Gael Party. In 1947, the Electoral (Amendment) Bill was being debated in the Seanad. It was introduced by Deputy MacEntee, the then Minister for Local Government, and it proposed an alteration in the constituencies and the present Leader of the Fine Gael Party in the Seanad, Senator Hayes, as reported in Volume 34, column 1035 of the Seanad Debates made a very categorical statement which showed that, at that time anyway, he was thinking responsibly. He is still in the Fine Gael Party and he is still the Leader of that Party here, thanks be to God, and I hope that even at this late stage he may begin to think as responsibly as he thought ten years ago. The statement is a very categorical one:—
"These seat constituencies are not as good, from the point of view of representation and workability, as the British single non-transferable vote constituency."
Comment on this
I do not think it is relevant but I shall.
"We are doing what had been done so frequently, producing one principle and adopting a different practice."
I do not think that adds anything or takes anything from it.
Comment on this
"Producing one principle and adopting a different practice". Would the Senator say what we were discussing?
Comment on this
The Electoral (Amendment) Bill of that year which proposed to increase the number of three seat constituencies.
Comment on this
We were discussing an increase in the number of three seat constituencies to which I was opposed as not being sufficiently in accordance with the principles of P.R.
Comment on this
I agree with the Senator that that is the main principle or thread of argument running through his speech, but in the course of his speech he made this laudatory remark about the system of election that operates in Great Britain. It might be no harm to mention——
Comment on this
The choice before us is not as between the three seat constituencies and the single seat. It is a false dilemma which the Senator is putting forward.
Comment on this
Senator Lenihan should be allowed to continue his speech without interruption. Senators will have the right to speak later and they may then answer Senator Lenihan.
Comment on this
Might I say something complimentary about Senator Lenihan? He was good enough to tell me he was going to make this quotation and that is why I am so good on it.
Comment on this
It might be no harm to mention again the very categorical utterance of the Senator on that occasion:—
"Three seat constituencies are not as good, from the point of view of representation and workability, as the British single non-transferable vote constituency."
I agree throughly. The important thing is not representation; the important thing is to protect democracy. There is a very admirable definition of democracy in the book Election and Representation by Professor Hogan, a professor in U.C.C., and in none of the three essential ingredients of democracy which he sets out does the question of representation or exact representation arise. The first of these ingredients is that the governed must have the power to change their governors without recourse to violence. I suggest that that is fairly well known as that provision is already embodied in the Constitution. It must be done every five years.
The second ingredient is that there should be a known and equal system of law, safeguarded by an independent judiciary, as distinct from an arbitrary law which does not have regard to the protection of the rights of the ordinary citizen and the third essential ingredient which he gives is that every law-abiding citizen should have the freedom to speak as he likes, to think as he likes and to vote as he likes, without the fear of being victimised, as a consequence, by his employer, whether his employer happens to be a private individual, a public or a private body, or even the State.
The question of exact minute representation does not arise at all in discussing the question of democracy. There should be such representation or such participation of the people as is consistent with the provision of government for the people and the safeguarding of fundamental rights. These rights are fundamentally guaranteed in our Constitution and we have an independent judiciary to protect them.
There is another point that comes back to this question of minorities or created minorities again. My point is that there is only one minority in the real sense of the word, but there are plenty of created minorities. Any man in the street can create a minority himself. We have a very highly integrated community here in this country of ours. Thanks be to God, there are no extremes of wealth or power or status or position.
Comment on this
We have no extremes. We have the two major national Parties which are properly organised vertically and not horizontally. They cut up through all strata in society. The two national Parties include people from various categories of society— professional men, trade unionists, farmers, businessmen. They are not organised on any class basis. I fail to see why we should bring into the Constitution or into our system here any of the class conscious Parties which so bedevil politics elsewhere. It is a very good thing, and it is a source of strength in our community, that the two major national Parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, are organised on a vertical rather than a horizontal basis. Anybody who knows this country can see that.
I come from a country area as do many other Senators. I know businessmen, farmers and trade unionists living around me, who all have the same ambition in life and roughly the same economic status in their own particular category, and yet who may vote for Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Clann na Talmhan.
This is an integrated community. Therefore, why create minorities? What is the point? Minorities in an integrated community only start dissension, breed trouble and strife. In fact, the net conclusion—and the record is there—is that these created minorities are merely created by particular political leaders who are anxious for power and the only function of the political Parties which result from created minorities is to give power and office to a few grasping men who make up that minority.
Comment on this
They hold the gun to a responsible Party's head at certain times and say: "We want Ministry A or Ministry B." Clann na Poblachta is a classical example of how such a splinter group can function and hold the gun to a responsible Party's head. I see no reason at all for a number of artificially created small Parties in this community—in an integrated community. Two or three major Parties which develop over the years can absorb all shades of thinking and views which exist in a community.
Senator Stanford in his criticism of this measure spoke about the stability of stagnation. He disagreed fundamentally—he can correct me if I am wrong—with the development of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil over the years.
Comment on this
That is entirely misrepresenting the issue.
Comment on this
And may I say, Sir, not the first misrepresentation?
Comment on this
Senator Stanford did use in relation to the present system that developed here the words "stability of stagnation". It is——
Comment on this
May I point out, since the Senator continues to misrepresent, that I referred to the possibility of a stability of stagnation but with no particular reference to any Party? I hope that is clear.
Comment on this
I gathered the Senator meant that the stability of stagnation which he alleged we talked about was the type of stagnation that was in this measure.
Comment on this
That is all right. I should like in future if the Senator would clarify his remarks.
Comment on this
I think he meant the ice age. I think Senator Stanford was referring to the return of the ice age.
Comment on this
I agree with Senators Stanford and Sheehy Skeffington on this question of stability being open to a dangerous interpretation. You may have stability at a lower level; to that extent I am with the Senator. My proposition would be that the stability which would result from a measure like this would be a dynamic stability, a progressive stability and a stability which would at every election enable the people to have an alternative system put before them. To that extent, the straight vote system would provide a dynamic which would always enable Parties to be responsible to the community and to produce their policy before an election so that the people could decisively accept or reject whatever political Party they wanted.
The straight vote system will give that dynamic which will enable us to have stability and at the same time enable a change to be made decisively and definitely so that there will always be an upward progression in politics and in the views expressed by political Parties. The straight vote system will provide that dynamic which is so necessary. I think that the tendency of the P.R. system is towards giving this stagnant effect in political life. Under the present system of P.R. people are never given the opportunity of deciding decisively to accept or reject. You only have shifts round the middle. You have one Party shifted out of office by a few votes and another Party coming in by a few votes. That has been the pattern here in recent years and it will be the pattern ad infinitum, if we do not wish to change it. Under the present system you will never have the pendulum going one way or the other decisively. You may have people of no ability being elected, time in, time out.
Comment on this
In my view P.R. inherently develops towards stability of stagnation, whereas under the straight vote system people can make a change decisively and provide the dynamic. The exact quotation of Senator Stanford will be found at column 330, Volume 50, No. 5 of the Official Report. It is as follows:—
"The other system will stabilise..."
—that is, the straight vote system—
"...but I am afraid it will be the stability of stagnation."
Comment on this
By perpetuating Parties and people in Parliament the P.R. system leads inevitably to stagnation and that tendency has been fought against in this country to a certain extent by one Party which has refused to take part in bargaining. The straight vote system will lead to progression upwards instead of stagnation, whilst it will enable the people to make a change decisively. That is why I am concerned that this measure should get the approval of the Seanad. It is a measure designed to strengthen democracy, the institutions of the State and ensure that our people will be able to use the democratic institutions and provide themselves with a Government at the same time.
The other leg of this proposal is the question of the single seat constituency. I think that whatever the merits or demerits of the straight vote system may be, every reasonable person—I have spoken to all of them— is in agreement that the single seat system is the very best one. Apart from the issue of the transferable vote, the idea of the single seat system, which is one leg of this measure, is a very good one.
Comment on this
Perhaps Senators might learn to address their remarks to the Chair in future.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that the single seat system will give you a better public representative. In the Dáil it will produce Independent representatives of the type of Deputy Sheldon and others who supported this measure although they were under no Whip from the Fianna Fáil Party. That type of Independent mind will always get in. I have no doubt that the good Independent, when standing in his constituency, will always get in under the single seat system. I further say that the political Parties will be forced now to select better candidates. A candidate must be good in order to get in, in a small area of 20,000 to 30,000 people who know him and know his position in the community.
A candidate must be a good candidate if he is to succeed in that type of constituency. Political Parties will have to select better and better candidates in order to secure the election of their particular man in such a constituency. I think that a closer relationship between such a candidate and his constituents will result. This will place greater emphasis on the T.D., apart from being a delegate from the constituency, being a legislator in Parliament. It will place greater emphasis on his importance as a public representative besides being a delegate from his constituency and he will be participating more closely in the Government of the country. Deputy Sheldon brought out that point very well in the Dáil, that there will be more emphasis on the T.D.'s primary function, which is that of a legislator rather than that of a delegate.
The single seat idea is unanswerable, in my view. Those with any association with politics know the demoralising competition going on in constituencies between T.D.s in the multiple seat constituencies. There are four or five Deputies writing about the same thing, making representations about the same thing and competing against one another.
Comment on this
Perhaps Senator O'Leary will address the Chair in future.
Comment on this
The idea of the single seat constituency will prevent a lot of that and it will enable the man to be in closer relationship with his constituents. It will enable him to act better as a legislator and, all in all, it will lead to the development of a better type of person as a representative in our national Parliament.
Before I finish, there are one or two more things I should like to say. Senator Stanford, who spoke eloquently against the measure, expressed a certain wish—I think I am quoting him exactly this time—to shift the emphasis from Government to Parliament. I think that was the tendency of his remarks. That is impracticable in this day and age. In the classical days of 200 years ago, when Britain was the classical example, Parliament was representative not of the mass of the people but merely of a particular oligarchy. That was a time when Parliament was composed of men who wrote long speeches and spoke eloquently for hours on end. That day has gone. The primary function of Parliament, in this day and age, is to act as the people's representative and to give the people a Government.
Comment on this
As the Senator is commenting on my remarks, may I just say that what he means is that the 18th century is 200 years ago? Is that what it comes to?
Comment on this
I do not get that point. The point I am trying to make is that I disagree with him on that fundamental desire of his to shift the emphasis from Government to Parliament. In this modern age, the State has rightly made a great intrusion and rightly it has taken over a lot of things that were unheard of in the laissez faire days. That is a good thing and I agree with the Labour Party in that respect. We in this country have taken the lead decisively in that respect. The State here has entered many fields, with great success. I do not need to elaborate on the success of Bord na Móna or Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann to provide a basis for that argument. The State has a responsibility, in this day and age, to provide an economy which is worth while for the people in the community. To that extent, I think emphasis on Parliament rather than on Government is something which is impracticable at present.
The point made by Senator O'Brien earlier on was that the Government, in introducing this measure, was distracting the community, that this was a distraction and therefore unnecessary. I fail to see that. Surely, if a Government are working well and decisively, they can attack on many fronts at the one time? Even though we place much attention on this measure—and rightly so—and regard it as of particular importance, the Government are going ahead on all the other fronts on which Senator O'Brien would like them to go. The White Paper issued last year provided for a realistic, long-term planning and organisation of all our resources, to raise the standard of living over the next five to seven years. Senator O'Brien will agree with that, and that is sufficient evidence in itself that the Government are thinking decisively in the economic sphere as well as in the constitutional sphere.
In the 1930s, the Fianna Fáil Government of that period were able to do the same thing—they went along on the constitutional sphere and that did not deter them from progressing in the economic sphere as well. In that context, I can do no better than quote from the Irish Review and Annual, a supplement to the Irish Times published on the 1st of January of this year. In its economic section, it refers to the Government White Paper and the developments arising out of it in the industrial and agricultural spheres. It emphasises the expansion of funds, for instance, for the Industrial Credit Company, from £2,500,000 to £20,000,000; it deals with the subsidy for phosphatic fertilisers and with the new cattle credit scheme arranged by the N.F.A.; and with the availability of capital from the banks because the banks are cooperating on account of the confidence they have in the Government of the day.
Comment on this
The Senator should not go further into that matter.
Comment on this
I am not dealing further with that, but there is one matter there which is rather pertinent and I should like to finish on that point. It is an answer to Senator O'Brien's argument that this measure is one of distraction and that there is no progress on other matters. The Review and Annual I have mentioned says:—
"A bewildering succession of new developments marked the year 1958 in the Irish economy. New events and new ideas crowded the scene, and a new spirit, very different from the dejection of 1956 and most of 1957, motivated the actors. No sector of the economy was left untouched by these developments— agriculture, industry, external trade, finance, and the Government sector were all affected in varying degrees by the quickening tempo of economic activity and the recovery of confidence in future prospects."
If that is regarded as distraction, I feel the people will welcome that form of distraction. I see no reason why, while pressing ahead on the economic side, the Government should not introduce this measure to ensure that future Governments will be able to act decisively and effectively in the economic sphere in the future, as this Government are doing at present.
Comment on this
I find myself in trouble because I am in opposition to the last speaker. He thinks I shall support a mere talking shop and says that what he wants is an efficient Government. I shall try to demonstrate where we disagree. I must be brief, as many speakers have been too long about this.
I shall start off by asking the Taoiseach, who is present, who has asked for this change? The Taoiseach himself stated in public that it will be a considerable struggle to do this job. He has said: "You must take off your coats to get it put through". There is no public demand for this. The people who have used this system for almost 40 years have not grumbled at it. Therefore, we must examine that system itself, because of the criticism of it which there has been in the last four months.
On paper, P.R. seems to be a good system. It was admitted by people like Arthur Griffith, who is dead, the Taoiseach who is alive, thank God, Winston Churchill who is also alive, and John Costello who was the Leader of the previous Government, that it was a good system and a fair system. I think it is the duty of this House to examine in what way did that system so fall down in the past two years, and only in the past two years, as to compel the Leader of the Government to attempt to bring this change into operation. Have we had that kind of examination of this system by Government speakers during the past four or five weeks? I do not think we have. Every speech we have heard from the Government side, including the last speech by a very promising young man, Senator Lenihan, have all been die-stamped out of the Party office.
If one goes back over the systems of electing Governments, it will be found that there were four or five systems. The first one was force— you got government by force. The second one was that which gave you a Government by caste, by class. In the last century, you got government by limited franchise; later on, at the beginning of this century, you got government by full franchise for males, and in our time we got government by complete franchise for all people, whether male or female, over 21 years of age. Then, in some countries, you obtained P.R. I think that development was progressive and I want to ask can we undo any one of these steps without uneasiness?
At the moment, the Prime Minister of Ghana, one of the new countries which are growing up in the African continent, has, I think, rather primitive, and if I might say so, aggressive, ideas about government. He was interviewed about a month ago and a report of that interview can be found in the columns of the world's Press. It concerns a proposal of his that perhaps in that country they might dispose of elections. He said they could do that only by having an election about it. They would have to give the people a referendum, but, if the people by referendum agreed to have no more elections, then it would be a completely democratic process. I do not want to use words, or put words into the mouth of anybody on this side of the House, that might offend the Taoiseach, but that is the position that we should be careful about, that there should be no more elections.
We have not been proud of many things in this country, but, since 1922, we have been proud in talking to Englishmen, Canadians and Australians and all the people being quoted here in this House and in the other House, that we have a system of election that is of the fairest possible kind. I think we did feel a bit superior about having that system whereby we could elect our parliamentarians, and I want to ask: are we throwing something away by discarding it? The Taoiseach himself said many years ago that we were very lucky in having P.R. and I often felt, when speeches were made about the British, that P.R. is a bit too intelligent for them. We are a much more intelligent people and I do not think we should discard P.R. and go back to the British system.
In our private lives, do we get our own way about anything? I certainly do not get my own way about anything in my private life. By the time I have finished dealing with my bank manager, my business associates, and my family, I find I must adjust myself to every one of their points of view, and I am surrounded by frustration. I am surrounded by unkindness, the kind of thing the Taoiseach quarrels about. I am neither a lawyer nor a mathematician, but I do think that I have to put up with that kind of thing in my private life, my business life, my community life and my public life. There is not one of us in this House who is not uneasy, in the most efficient way of being uneasy, when we start to reduce standards as we are reducing them by this Bill, when we try to play smartly as we are playing smartly now. I was going to say "when we play politics" because we have all guilty consciences occasionally about the way we do play politics, but I want to say in this House now, so that it will be recorded in the debates, that there is a short-lived cleverness in politics. I think the Taoiseach is one of the men in this House who should realise that.
Why should we not have trouble in Government? Why should Government not be troublesome? Why should we not have to take account of the minds of the people who disagree with us? I have to live with my fellow people in a very troublesome way; I have to give way to them in many directions. I have to forgo many of the things I want. Whether I am in a family, in a private business, in a private community, in a large community, in a Government, even in a Cabinet, as the Taoiseach is, I will find I have to adjust my point of view.
But what kind of a quick solution policy is this we are proposing now? It is pitched for the simples—and there are many simples in our land. Therefore, it is a great wrong for a man to do who knows what a wrong it is. Every one of us here knows that life is not like that. In families, in communities, in Parliament or even in Cabinets, do those of us who are not simples not know that this provides no solution of any kind for any of the difficulties that confront this country at the moment? When those simple people have been induced by the tar barrel—and they will be induced by the tar barrel—to agree to this, will they have done anything that will solve these problems that are before us now? We will get an improvement of some kind from a Government point of view for, maybe, five or ten years. A temporary realignment of men might happen but it will be only temporary because the Irish people will not be pigeon-holed indefinitely.
When it is all done, we shall have to ask ourselves: "What did we do it for?" Our last stage will be far worse than our first because you will only temporarily change the results of the game by changing the rules of a game. But, if you begin all over again, you must begin with a very disillusioned people and it is we in this Parliament who will have made that disillusionment possible. I want the Taoiseach to stop this before it goes any further, before he unleashes something he might not be able to contain. I appeal to the Taoiseach to stop it, above all, because it is unfair and because he said before that it is unfair.
Bear in mind that the difficulties of Government and the difficulties of men in their private lives are not perhaps laid on us by God for anything except our completion.
Comment on this
I should like, at the start, to pay tribute to the speech made by Senator Cole which, in my opinion, was the most useful contribution yet made to this debate. If our friends on the opposite benches are sensible men, they will keep a copy of that speech for future reference because, unlike them, he holds out hope, which they seem to have abandoned. I, for one, cannot understand why they take such a pessimistic view of the future.
Senator Cole also made a very useful contribution with reference to what has been described as the minority. He pointed out that these men, naturally enough, after the change of Government here and having regard to their previous outlook, were slow to come in and to take a full part under the new position which had arisen, but that the younger generation are now happily playing their part. As Senator Cole has said, they realise that, under the new system of the straight vote, they will have an opportunity of getting the fair representation which they failed to get under the P.R. system. It is a fact that, under the P.R. system, they have secured only half the representation to which their numerical strength would entitle them. I hope, and I think every man and woman in the House hopes that, under the new system, they will come in and play their part.
We must all remember that, in days gone by, that minority supplied many of our greater leaders. I need only mention the names of Wolfe Tone, Lord Edward Fitzgerald, Robert Emmet and, later, John Mitchel, Thomas Davis, and all the others. Please God, in the future we will obtain new recruits from that minority who will play their full part in the political life of this country and who will provide us, as they did before, with men of the standard of Charles Stewart Parnell. If they do, I think we can look forward to a happier and a better future in this country.
I think that, if it were necessary to point out how that could be done, I would refer any of those who might be interested to what has happened in another national organisation in which the minority have played a full and a major part. I refer to the National Farmers' Association where they have come in and given of their ability. That ability and that capacity has speedily been acknowledged by their colleagues in that organisation in which they have been elected to the highest positions of honour and responsibility. I make bold to say that the same remarks hold for the trade unions. I am sure that, in the trade union movement, the fact that as man at one time belonged to the minority but is now playing his full part in that movement will not debar him from being promoted to the highest position.
We are told there is perfect unanimity on the other side of the House and that they are all solidly of opinion that this change is the most ruinous ever contemplated for the people. I doubt if they have that much solidarity behind them. I have read most of the speeches made in the Dáil and I observed that there was a notable exception. A very prominent member of the Fine Gael Party and a former Minister of the Coalition Government, if I remember rightly, took no part at all in the debate and, as far as I can recall, voted only once in the Divisions. That is very far from the unanimity we have heard about.
Was that the view of the Fine Gael Party in the days gone by? I just happened to see a report of a speech made by the Vice-President of the Cosgrave Administration, Earnán de Blaghd, who was also a Minister for Finance. Speaking recently at a meeting of a debating society in Bray, at which he presided, he is reported as follows in the Irish Press of 10th instant:—
"If we have a multiplicity of Parties the coalition is formed after the election and not before it and the voters are given no opportunity on it or on the programme adopted for the purposes of the coalition until too late—that is until after the next election.
"The system which enabled a Government to be formed by a single Party or by a more or less permanent coalition of Parties was more democratic than that under which opposing groups sink their differences after the election and adopt programmes which were never put before the electors at all.
"I do not believe that under a straight vote the next election would give Fianna Fáil such an overwhelming majority that the Opposition would be reduced to impotence."
Now, I am sure that neither Senator Cole nor Earnán de Blaghd would be accused of being strong supporters of Fianna Fáil but they gave their views independently. I wish that those who are at present opposing this motion would take these views into account——
Comment on this
Senator O'Leary will please address the Chair.
Comment on this
I have deliberately refrained from interrupting any speaker during the debate and I would hope that the same consideration will be accorded to me. This kind of bickering across the House is not likely to commend itself to the support of the people at large, nor of those who will read the reports. If we could get away from these petty bickerings perhaps we would do better work for the country.
I think it is freely admitted, on all sides, that where you have P.R. on it causes a fungus growth of small Parties with unstable Government and consequent damage to the economy, by scaring away would-be investors, both national and external, as capital is very sensitive to political unrest. For examples of the disastrous consequences which may arise, and which have arisen in recent times, we have only to turn to Iceland during the recent fisheries dispute when the Coalition Government fell because of the defection of one small section of that Government. In Finland a similar state of affairs obtained during the recent Russian threat and a similar state has obtained in France over the years. It is the position of France that has convinced me that the sooner we change the system the better it will be for the future of our people.
In Italy at the present time you have a stalemate and I should like everybody seriously to consider what might happen here in the future. All the Leaders of the principal Parties in this House are now getting on in years. They cannot last for ever and if we look into the future, say, in ten, 15 or 20 years' time, when new generations will have grown up, you may have a new alignment of Parties altogether. If the P.R. system is to be continued you may have 15 or 20 different Parties, with none strong enough to form a Government. Then the bargaining will have to take place; you will have Governments collapsing as happened before and the country will be left in the position in which Italy finds itself, with a stalemate and no Government. That has frequently happened during various crises in France over the past 15 to 20 years.
These are the reasons I feel very strongly on this issue and why I appeal to the Seanad to allow this measure to pass and to leave it to the ultimate authority on all such subjects —the people. If they wish to make a change let them. If they want to retain the present system they will vote for its retention but it is our duty to point out the defects in the present system, and its dangers to the State and the rising generation.
As we are all aware, Fianna Fáil has at present an overall majority and will continue in office for the full term. Undoubtedly Fianna Fáil has done well under P.R. and Fine Gael and the Labour Party, and other Parties, should not be so terribly fond of it. They have not made so very much progress under the system. Fine Gael has not gained so much under it and the Labour Party was stronger numerically in 1923 than they are to-day. Why have they not progressed? What is there to debar either of these Parties, or any other Party that might arise, from proclaiming a policy that will have wide national appeal under capable leadership?
These are the two points which make it essential, and possible, for any Party to get the support of the people. Neither Fianna Fáil nor any other Party can form a Government and continue in office without the support of the people.
The mere fact that Fianna Fáil have been in government for such a lengthy period is due to the fact that they had a policy and that they had a Leader. Mark you, all the remarks of the Opposition have, with a few notable exceptions, been directed to abusing that Leader. Why? Because they have failed to produce a Leader themselves and they are jealous of the Fianna Fáil Party and its Leader. That is why they are cutting their own political throats, because I do not believe personal abuse of any political representative is going to gain the support of the Irish people. They will find that out in the near future when the referendum comes up for a decision by the people. They will be taught and other lesson of the type frequently taught them in the past.
I do not see why if either of these Parties, or any other Party, should come along and provide the people with an alternative policy, and with capable leadership, they could not go to the country and get a clear majority, as Fianna Fáil hopes to do in the next election.
Comment on this
Well, the people will decide that. I do not support to be a prophet at all. I say that in all sincerity. Senator Cole stole my thunder. I had a few points in mind before this debate started but he has come along and has made them with more authority than I could command.
There is nothing to prevent any of these Parties, even under the new system, from putting their policy before the people. They failed to do that in the past. Because of their failure, I think they should be the strongest supporters of this change. It is not the system of voting that makes the difference; it is the policy and the leadership which can enable any Party to get a sufficient majority. I should like to emphasise that for the benefit of those whom it may concern.
It is argued, of course, that under the new system Fianna Fáil will gerrymander the country. I think that is a physical impossibility for any Party even to attempt, and the Fianna Fáil Party is not composed of fools. Fianna Fáil realises that in order to have a good Government you must have a good Opposition. Senators in opposition may sneer at it if they will, but for that reason, I advise them to examine their past with a view to improving their policy and leadership if they hope to form a Government ever again. There was a time when Fine Gael could hope for sufficient support from the people to enable them to form a single Government. I hope they will reach that position again and if they fail I hope Labour will fill the gap. We must have a strong Opposition because only thus can you have good Government under our democratic system.
It is said that the constituencies can be gerrymandered and the Opposition have objected to the appointment of a judge of the High or the Supreme Court——
Comment on this
I think that matter might be left to another occasion.
Comment on this
I do not want to develop the point but I would say in passing that the remarks made in reference to those in high positions, to the president and judges of the High and Supreme Court, reflect no credit on those who made them. It is said also that the youth of the country are not taking part in our political life. Such remarks are not calculated to get the young people to take a serious interest in promoting the welfare of the nation.
If the Opposition would take to heart the very sensible advice tendered to them by an Independent member of the House, Senator Cole, they could benefit by it, and the nation, as a result, would profit accordingly. I sincerely hope the House will pass the Bill and leave it to the people of the country to decide by free vote whether they want the present system of P.R. to continue or whether they want to change over to the direct vote.
Comment on this
As a relatively young man who came into politics in 1954, I have nothing but reverence for the men of the past. I regard this Bill as the most important one to come before the Oireachtas since I was privileged to enter it. I have given it quite a lot of study and the first thing that struck me was the very clear analogy between the main argument used by the Taoiseach for the abolition of P.R. and his behaviour in regard to the measure itself.
The main plank of his argument is that it leads to Coalition Governments. I do not concede that, but he says Coalition Governments are bad because they can bargain after the election and do not need to put their policy of bargaining before the people prior to the election. I do not agree that that is a sound argument but it was used by the Taoiseach. Why then did the Taoiseach not state before the last election that he intended to introduce this Bill? I am sure this matter has not come up in the last two years. If the Taoiseach has been considering this matter I am certain he has been considering it for more than two years.
Why did he not say at the last election: "If I am elected and if I have a majority in the Dáil and the Seanad"—as, of course, he would have—"I shall seek a referendum from the people for the abolition of P.R."? If he submits that it is politically dishonest for two or three groups elected by the people to come together and form a majority Government after the election, is it not dishonest for him to do what he is now doing—submitting this matter to a referendum by the people because of his majority in the House—when he did not say he was going to do so before the election? I should like him to answer that. I think it is a serious charge that he did not include it at the last election in his election programme of statement of policy and I think it is incumbent on him to answer that charge when he replies to the debate.
I do not want to quote Malta, Gibraltar or anywhere else. I leave that to statisticians or people who, perhaps, have a better opportunity to study them than somebody who does not have as much time as perhaps he should have to devote to politics. The first thing that strikes me about this Bill is something that I do not think has been mentioned yet—the danger of the individual member becoming what I call a proprietary politician, the man with the safe seat, or the type of man who is not fair-minded and who tries to seek all the favours for his own side and tries to use his position as a member of the Oireachtas to get favours and positions for his supporters. He may find himself at the end of five years of government in an impregnable position in that constituency. That is a most dangerous possibility.
I do not say the present Government have a large number of that type of person among their members nor that we on this side have them, but I believe it is a dangerous possibility that any individual could be in a position in which he could get quasi-permanent positions for his supporters as temporary postmen, or other appointments in post offices by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. There is the danger that he could get all those minor posts which do not come under the Civil Service Commission given to his own supporters and thus make his position impregnable after, say, five years.
I have found all over Ireland individual conditions the type of which persists in areas where certain individuals have succeeded in that aim. I shall not mention names or places but there is a place in Ireland where a housing society has been formed and the people of that area believe that, if they do not go to a particular, individual in the Party, they will not get a loan or a grant to build a house or get a grant for the reconstruction of a dwelling. There is a great danger that if such persons became numerous on any side of the House, and behaved in that way in single member constituencies, they would become impregnable, and arguments on policy, on legislation carried out by the Government in office, would not matter twopence. Such men would occupy those seats until they died, not because of their ability as legislators nor the ability of the Government they supported to carry out a policy or to behave in accordance with the people's interests, but on the basis of the favours they could curry, the jobs they could get and the posts they could ensure would be given to their supporters in such areas.
There is a further grave danger in this measure if it goes through. At present there is freedom for the individual politician to hold independent views even though he is a member of a Party. I shall not go very much outside this country—P.R. suits us here and that is all that matters— but we all know there are safe seats in English constituencies. If the holder of such a seat rebels against the Party line he is not selected the next time. If such a person for the time being at election time is at variance with his Party he cannot be re-elected. Similiarly here, if there are single member constituencies and the sitting member rebels on a certain point he cannot be re-elected to the Dáil because the official Party candidate would stand against him and would have all the Party machinery behind him to ensure that his opponent would not be elected.
I submit that under P.R. it is possible for a member to be re-elected even if he rebels against his Party, if he has a majority who will support him and who will vote for him as they have a right to do. They may vote No. 1 for the man who rebels and No. 2 for the official Party nominee and in that way the general policy of the Party will be taken into account. The votes could support the Party they wanted to support with the second or third preference votes.
Similarly the safe seat should not exist. No politician is entitled to a safe seat in the Oireachtas. There are people who have made safe seats for themselves under P.R. not by any attempt to curry favour but by their legislative ability and hard work here. They are entitled to those safe seats, but no one is entitled to a safe seat who has not worked for it, who has not general ability for the position. I submit that if this measure is carried there will be in the Oireachtas certain safe seats which can be filled by Party nominees because their names might gain favour for the Party but who at the same time might never stand in the constituency, who might be "absentee landlords" and might never do as much as address a meeting in that constituency. They would be quite safe because they Party majority in the constituency would be rolled out for them like a steamroller.
The people in that constituency would not be getting proper representation. I do not think Party politics are the ideal thing; I do think that the people of the constituency are entitled to a varied representation. They are entitled to have a member who will listen to them, a member who will put forward their claims and a member who will represent in Parliament the interests of that constituency, be it industrial, agricultural, cattle rearing, wheat farming, or whatever activity happens to be the big thing in the constituency. These people are entitled to select a man who will represent their way of life and their way of gaining a livelihood. Under the proposed system the candidate might be a person with a great big name from Dublin and nobody else could run against him.
I believe it is an injustice to hold the referendum on P.R., as has been suggested by the Taoiseach, on the same day as the Presidential election. Is it in order for me to discuss that?
Comment on this
I assume I can discuss it later. The former Minister for Finance raised what appears to me to be a very important issue on the passage of this Bill through the other House. Because of the particular nature of our country the division of it into constituencies of 20,000 people will mean that there will be a town versus a country complex produced and the scales will weigh in favour of the town. The unit of 20,000 people, which will mean about 10,000 or 12,000 votes, will give in many country constituencies a town majority. At the first election I do not think the interests of town versus country would come up but in succeeding elections and in succeeding years there is not the slightest doubt that the people will wake up to the fact that there is such a division, so that the townspeople in a constituency will prefer a townsman whereas country people will prefer to elect a country man.
Is it not a fact that, in such circumstances, instead of taking the whole of the people into consideration the rural T.D. will be looking after the interests of the country people whereas the urban T.D. will be agitating for greater social amenities and lower prices for food? Senator Lenihan referred to the division of the country vertically rather than horizontally. There are many more ways of dividing it than on the basis of income or position, and this is one of the ways of dividing it.
If you take my own constituency, the town of Dundalk, according to the 1956 census, has a population of 20,154. The town of Drogheda has a population of 17,008. The total population of the constituency of Louth is 69,000 people. The Constituency Commission is instructed as follows; and I quote from the Bill:—
"...having due regard to geographical features and established administrative and territorial divisions..."
No matter what way that county is divided there must be a preponderance of urban votes in those two constituencies. You would have to take the town of Dundalk as a unit and, therefore, you would have an urban constituency there. In the town of Drogheda you would have to add 3,000 people to it to make it again an urban constituency with a very small agricultural minority. In the rest of Louth, if it is to be divided in that way, you would have an agricultural constituency, so that if this measure goes through you would have two urban Deputies and one rural Deputy. In election after election the townspeople will say: "We will not elect a countryman because we are townspeople"; and the country people will say: "We will not elect a townsman because we are country people."
The constituency of Louth also gives us very good opportunities for study on this question of the abolition of P.R. Take the case of the last five elections. In the last election the people of Louth elected two Fianna Fáil members and one Fine Gael; at the previous election, two Fine Gael members and one Fianna Fáil; at the previous election, one Labour member, one Fine Gael member and one Fianna Fáil member; and at the previous election two Fianna Fáil members and one Fine Gael.
Under the proposal in this Bill these people will not be given a choice. If they are in one of these small constituencies where a Labour member is not standing, then they have no chance of voting for Labour. If you have, as in the present situation, an area which is an economic, geographical and historical unit, you may have at a time a consensus of opinion that would support a Labour member. Is that economic, geographical and historical unit to be deprived of the opportunity of electing a Labour member? I believe the present units are of the right size. The other units will produce the urban versus rural divisions and will also disfranchise certain members of the population.
With regard to minorities, I want to speak as a man who has no axe to grind in relation to 1922 and has nothing to give the men of 1916 to 1922, including the present Taoiseach, except reverence and goodwill for the part they played during that period. They have done a very good job in relation to minorities. It was not easy at the foundation of this State to satisfy minorities. I am certain that minorities had some idea about what was going to happen to them and that in many cases they were square pegs in round holes. It is a credit to the men who founded the State and those who followed them that the minorities have blended with the majority, that there is no such thing as a religious minority versus majority but that the State is a unit in which we all can live, as our fathers and mothers brought us up to live, as people who have no axe to grind and who respect the laws. One of the big arguments for P.R. is that it has achieved that situation and in doing so it has shown us that it would be an absolute mistake to remove it. If we do, we upset the applecart.
Is the Taoiseach certain of what will happen in relation to the views of religious minorities and other minorities when he passes this measure? I am not sure. I do not know in what way these minorities will behave. I do not know what views the religious minorities have and I do not think they should have ever been asked to express them or decide upon them. The status quo was excellent. It gave them their place in the community and, having taken their place, it is unfair, unwise and undemocratic to uproot them. As Senator Barry said, P.R. in this State represents progression from government by force and class to government by limited franchise, and from there to full franchise. Now with P.R., we are one step ahead of the rest of the world, and we should stay there. As I said, the religious minority should never be asked to express their opinions, once having taken their place proudly in the State. They should be left enjoy their place and live with us as brothers, as they are doing, thank God.
Some of the criticisms of P.R. arise from the fact that we have not perfect P.R. here. Such is the case because of the interference during a revision of the constituencies made in the 1930s. I submit that the "three-seater" is not the perfect example of P.R. The idea of P.R. is that, in a given area with a given population, a member can be elected who has the support of a quota of votes from his particular minority. I submit that the perfect P.R. for Ireland would be 100 members in five-seat constituencies. That would mean that in the five-seat constituency, representing perhaps 120,000 people or 130,000 people, there would be a seat for the person who could represent 20,000 to 30,000 people, or one-fifth of the total. When we created "three-seaters" we created the situation that it was too hard for that minority to become elected. In fact, as will be the case if this measure goes through, the scales swung in favour of the large Party.
I shall take a practical example. In the constituency of Louth the Fianna Fáil Party got a total of 14,600 votes. For that number of votes they received two seats in the Dáil, or one seat per 7,000 of the votes. The Fine Gael Party got 12,600 votes, and for that number of votes they received one seat. In fact, unintentionally— because that constituency has been a "three-seater" since the inception of the State—we have gerrymandering. The situation is that you have too great a difference between the number of votes that the minority has to expend to gain a seat in Parliament and the number of votes which the majority has to expend. If there were a five-seat constituency you would find that, while there would be a discrepancy—mathematically there must be—it would not be 5,000 votes per seat gained.
I understand that in the mid-1930s 17 "three-seater" constituencies were created. In the following election the Government won 16 of them. Unintentionally, I submit—because I do not want in any way to cast reflection on the Taoiseach and the members opposite—it is the gravest gerrymandering. Most of the criticism of P.R. arises from the fact that we have had "three-seaters," which were created by the present Taoiseach in the mid-1930s, and the system was intended for five-seat constituencies.
I submit that this measure is indicative of the intolerance of Fianna Fáil to government by anybody else. The argument put forward by the Taoiseach, that the reason P.R. was bad was because it produced two Coalition Governments, is not an argument that government by coalition is bad but that government is bad if it is not Fianna Fáil government. I sincerely believe that this measure is intended—whether it will or not I do not know—to perpetuate Fianna Fáil in office. As things stand, it could almost bring about such a situation at the next election.
I notice that the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, expressed the same view at the Fine Gael Árd-Fheis. But he said that in the long run it will not serve the Fianna Fáil Party at all. I think it is a measure of the intolerance to government by anybody else which is a facet of the philosophy of the Fianna Fáil Party. We, on our side, are not intolerant of government by anybody else. We are not intolerant of representation by minorities. We are not intolerant of the members of any minority coming into any House of the Oireachtas and making their statement. We are not intolerant of people who do not say: "Yes, yes, yes" all the time.
Senator O'Grady made the case that in our Party we are not at one. I think that, on the whole, we are at one. There has been a great degree of unanimity in our Party. If there has not been complete unanimity, as there has been on the far side, it is because of the nature of the Party over there. It is a dangerous thing to have this monolithic group which never says may. It is much better that there should be some discussion on measures such as this and that different views should be expressed.
As Senator George O'Brien said, this is a portmanteau question. The electorate will be asked: (1) Do you want to do away with P.R.? (2) Do you want to substitute a single, nontransferable vote? (3) Do you agree with two foolscap pages of provisions for the proposed commission? Do Senators not agree that it is unique —almost like the man who won £300,000 in the pools—for all of you people forming a group in the Fianna Fáil Party to have the view that every provision in those two foolscap pages is correct? Is there anyone among you who believes that somewhere in those sections and sub-sections covering these two foolscap pages, there is not some provision with which you do not agree? Of course, there must be many such among you, but you will not admit it. You are monolithic and you believe that everything the Taoiseach does is right. I believe he will do a grave injury to the Irish people if he proceeds with this measure and I, for one, will oppose it here and in the country.
Comment on this
The fact that Senator Sheehy Skeffington has arrived tempts me to address the House as "Fellow Tories." Senator Sheehy Skeffington certainly introduced an element of amusement and levity into the debate, an element which has not characterised this debate as a whole. However, when both sides of the House are Tories—Fianna Fáil were Tories, according to the Senator; Fine Gael were Tories, and Labour—I wonder what would the Senator designate himself as?
Comment on this
A follower of James Connolly, a Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Comment on this
I shall not answer that. I do not want to pursue the matter further, but I hope he proves a decent follower of James Connolly. I should like, at the outset, to express my disappointment at the fact that the debate here has followed the same lines as the debate in the Dáil, namely, quotations, irrelevancies, contradictions and more quotations. The debate could have been much more effective and the speeches considerably shorter, had these irrelevancies been left out. We are in a different category here as compared with the members of the Dáil. The system of election is their main concern; it is not ours. We are here as responsible citizens and it is not necessary for us to follow all these contradictions, irrelevancies and quotations resorted to in the other House. I shall not indulge in any quotations, or irrelevancies, I hope, but later I shall refer to a few remarks made by the Leader of the Opposition in the opening of the debate in the Dáil.
As far as I am concerned, the issue is quite clear. The question has been asked: "Why now?" The answer is that this year there will be a revision of constituencies and it would be absurd not to deal with this matter simultaneously with the required revision of constituencies. We are satisfied that it is desirable the system of election should be changed. Remembering that if at one stage in the Dáil the Leader of the Opposition, the Taoiseach, and everybody else agreed that P.R. was the correct system then, they ought all equally now agree that it is no longer correct. It was weak government in Germany that led to Hitler's being able to seize power. In Italy, Mussolini got into power for the same reason. Both these men achieved office because of weak Coalition Governments—Governments consisting of several Parties. Had there been strong efficient Governments in these countries, neither of these men would have come to power. It was their seizure of power that led the people of Europe into the wholesale slaughter and carnage and all the tragedy of the second World War.
Here, in 1933, a somewhat similar step was tried. We had the Blueshirt movement. The Blueshirt organisation was to march on Dublin. But we were fortunate in having a strong Government in office and that Government said: "You shall not march on Dublin." The Blueshirt movement was frustrated. Military organisations seize power when Governments are weak. There are, of course, different systems of P.R. and I do not propose to delay the House by describing those systems. Suffice it to say that, in the main, they make for multiplicity of Parties, splinter groups, and weak government.
It is mean argument to say that Fianna Fáil are doing this for their own political aggrandisement. The Taoiseach has been accused of doing this for the benefit of his own Party. It should be remembered that legislation is for the future, and retrospective legislation when introduced is looked at askance by everybody. Legislation, in the main, is for the future. The purpose of this Bill is to safeguard the future and to ensure that what happened on the Continent of Europe in the not so distant past will not happen here in the near or distant future. This measure is safeguarding posterity. It is to ensure that what happened in Germany and Italy will not happen here.
Comment on this
And what happened in the past in Italy is recurring there to-day. Hitler seized power in Germany; Mussolini seized power in Italy. There was an attempt here by the Blueshirts to seize power in this country.
Comment on this
This measure is for the purpose of safeguarding the future and to ensure that we shall not have the splinter groups we have had in the past. There was no multiplicity of Parties at the time of the Blueshirts. We have had two Coalition Governments under P.R. here.
Comment on this
They were elected as separate Parties and then they formed a Government jointly.
Comment on this
They did it constitutionally—we do not argue that—but each of them broke down and each of them left a debt. It is no joke for the Fianna Fáil Government to have to try to rectify the mistakes of their predecessors. The Coalition Governments disintegrated and left a debt. In the first instance, Fianna Fáil had to introduce the drastic Budget of 1952 to deal with that situation. But the next Coalition Government did exactly the same thing; they left a string of debts after them.
Comment on this
I have permitted the Senator quite an amount of latitude, but he may not discuss all the policies of all the Governments that have been in office here.
Comment on this
Facilities were given to other speakers and I want the same facilities as were given to those other speakers. I am referring to the fact that we had two Coalitions in this country. They were failures and they left after them an accumulation of debts, and a situation which required rectification by their successors and which subsequently necessitated the introduction of a drastic Budget and the withdrawal of the food subsidies. I shall leave the matter at that.
Comment on this
If I must, I must. I have just stated the facts. The effect of the abolition of P.R. and the introduction of the straight vote will not debar anybody, any party or any individual, from going up for election. It is extraordinary that that has to be repeated but it has been said so often on the other side of the House that this innovation, this alteration in our Constitution, will deprive small Parties of their rights. It will not deprive any Party of their rights; it will not deprive any individual of his or her rights. I have no doubt that several Independents will be elected to the next Dáil, if and when, as I hope it will be, the straight vote system is introduced and the Constitution amended to that effect. Independents and representatives of other Parties will be elected.
It is a defeatist attitude to assume that we will have only one Party and that Party will be Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil may be, and I expect it will be, a big Party, but I do not think the Opposition should assume that they will be composed of diminutive Parties. Supposing they were, they would be as large an Opposition as there was when the Cumann na nGaedheal Government were in office from 1922 to 1927. We have heard the Leader of the Opposition complimenting the Labour Party on the good work they did when acting as a small Opposition because the majority of the Republican representatives were outside the House at the time.
I emphasise that there is no bar against any Party or any individual going up for election and the people who are criticising us for bringing forward this proposal must remember that they tried to set up barriers when they sought to introduce a provision that nobody would be allowed to stand as a candidate for either House of the Oireachtas without declaring that he would take an oath of allegiance to a foreign King. That was a barrier against individuals or Parties standing for election. There is no barrier now against any individual or any Party standing for election.
There is no necessity to go into what other persons said and the contradictions of somebody else and all the quotations on this matter. I emphasise that it will be for the benefit of our nation, if this change is made in the Constitution. There is no necessity to go into the debate on the Constitution of 1937 or to deal with the criticism that individuals elected to the Dáil and the Seanad who were unanimous that it was a good thing at the time are now convinced that it is a bad thing and should be abolished.
I must, however, without going into quotations, refer to the tone adopted in the Dáil by the Leader of the Opposition in opening the debate on this Bill. He indicated at the start that our constituencies were quite different from the constituencies in Great Britain. He said we were a uniform people and that our constituencies could not be divided into Labour, Tory or Liberal constituencies. He pointed out that we were a uniform electorate whether in city or country areas, so far as our politics are concerned. The proposal is that a commission be set up under this Bill in an endeavour to be supremely fair and to avoid criticism and in providing for this commission for the fixing of the constituencies, the matter was taken out of the hands of the Department of Local Government which ordinarily deals with the revision of constituencies. To be fair and to avoid criticism, the Government decided not to leave that task to the Department of Local Government and tried to put it above any reproach by proposing this commission.
At the start of his speech Deputy Costello pointed out that the constituencies could not very well be gerrymandered. He later said — and these are the only words I shall quote because they give an indication of the mentality of the man and the tone which he gave to the debate — speaking of the judge who would be appointed as chairman of this commission, at column 1030, Volume 171, of the Official Report:—
"I will appoint CD. who is a tool of the Government in power, who is what the late Kevin O'Higgins would have called a legal careerist, who got his job on the bench because he was the lick-spittle of a political Party. That is the system supposed to give us impartiality and supposed to create public confidence in this white sepulchre, the commission set up under this Bill."
The Chair may object to unparliamentary language. I have never heard any in the Seanad, though we have had interruptions, but, to my mind, that statement——
Comment on this
The Senator should not pursue that line. The Dáil conducts its own business and it is for the Ceann Comhairle to decide, as he so desires, on the orderliness of any statement made. It is not for us to do so. The Senator will appreciate that point.
Comment on this
I accept your direction, Sir, but am I not entitled to comment on a statement made in the other House by the Leader of the Opposition? Perhaps I shall be allowed just to make a remark. It was a terribly bad lead to give to the other House and to this House, but if the Chair says I may not pursue it further, I am quite satisfied.
Comment on this
I thought the Senator was about to comment on the propriety of the Ceann Comhairle permitting such a statement to be made.
Comment on this
No, Sir; I had no intention of doing that. So far as I can see, greater latitude is allowed in the other House than is allowed, rightly, in this House. If the Chair does not debar me from referring to the bad example given by the Leader of the Opposition in the other House, I shall say that it was a terribly bad lead to give to pass such remarks about a member of his own profession who may be in the High Court or the Supreme Court and to call such a man a lick-spittle. There is no more disgusting term that could be used when one thinks of the literal meaning of the word. I think it was an awful remark to make.
I cannot sit down without referring to a remark made by the Leader of the Opposition in this House when he said that the Constitution of 1937 was only an amendment of the Constitution of 1922. Where he got that fantastic idea, I do not know. I am sorry he is not here to hear me say it. The Constitution of 1937 contains no word whatever of an amendment of the Constitution of 1922—nothing whatsoever. It is an entirely new Constitution. Whom does he think he could deceive by saying that this is only an amendment of the Constitution of 1922? Those are the words in his speech, and, if the House wishes, I can quote the reference, but I do not think it is necessary. He said this Bill was brought in for political reasons by the Taoiseach and for no other reason. That is all wrong. We are safeguarding the future of the country.
Fianna Fáil, having a majority, are doing the correct thing in ensuring that posterity, for which all legislation must be framed, will be safeguarded by the passing of this Bill through the Oireachtas and placing it before the people in a referendum.
Comment on this
It is amusing to hear the Government speakers trying to defend this Bill. Every time there is a new slogan. The Taoiseach always has a new slogan. At one time, the thing to save the country was the language. On another occasion, he used to tell the people not to change horses crossing the stream. On still another occasion, it was the straight road. Now it is the straight vote.
I have been in the House since 1943. I have fought elections since 1934, when I first went into public life. I fought six general elections. On a few occasions, they were elections which were not needed, but because of vanity and a desire for power, the Dáil was dissolved in the middle of the night and the Taoiseach ran up to the Park. He had a majority then, but because of two by-elections, when Seán MacBride and Paddy Kinnane won the seats, the Taoiseach ran up to the Park and dissolved the Dáil. Why? Because he was afraid that the Clann na Poblachta Party at the time were getting too strong. A general election was held. What was the result? Clann na Poblachta won ten seats — some of them in the City of Dublin. I was one who went a long way towards putting the Fianna Fáil Party out of power. I was in the National Labour Party then. Five of us held the balance of power. The night before the Government was changed in 1948, pressure was brought to bear by some people that we should vote Fianna Fáil back.
Comment on this
What happened? I was elected by the people of Wexford in opposition to Fianna Fáil. I am not sorry that I changed the Government at the time. I am proud of the action I took on behalf of the people I represent. Why? Because we released the prisoners in 1948 from the Curragh. We took the gun out of politics and we brought peace and harmony to the people. That cannot be denied.
No case has been made by the Taoiseach or any of the members of his Party in this or the other House. I listened to the finest speeches here last week delivered by such learned men as Senators Hayes, O'Brien, Stanford and others. They gave their views against P.R. from this side of the House. What has been said on the I other side of the House? All the Fianna Fáil speakers had to say is that it would be all right and that the Bill would save the country.
Every country in the world was mentioned. I have literature in my possession at the moment which was sent me by Irish people in Australia where an election took place only last year — in November, 1958. What is said in this literature? You must vote for every candidate. That was the type of literature distributed throughout Australia. It shows the list of candidates and it also shows how to vote. That voters must vote for every candidate is clearly stated. That is all wrong, of course, in a little country like ours.
When I was fighting an election throughout County Wexford, there were big posters on the gable ends of the houses. What was on the posters? "If you do not vote Fianna Fáil, vote for the Constitution." The Taoiseach told the people to vote for the Constitution in 1937 but in 1959 he says it is wrong. He wants the straight vote. Here is an extract from the Evening Herald:“New French law abolishes P.R. in local elections.” But the French statesmen tell us why, whereas the Taoiseach has not told the people why. He refers only to coalitions. Here is what this item says:—
"The French Cabinet has adopted a law abolishing P.R. in local elections in all towns of up to 120,000 people. The decision is expected drastically to reduce Communism and Communist Parties."
Why does the Taoiseach not say he wants this Bill to keep out Sinn Féin, the Labour Party and the Farmers' Party? Why is he not honest about it, like the French people?
He also said that a Coalition Government was like a game of pocker. I think he has the best poker players in his own Party because, when he formed a Coalition Government in 1951, I came to this House on a stretcher to put back the inter-Party Government. I failed. Why? Because of the bargaining with four jokers. He had four jokers in the pack. Where are the four jokers to-day? Who made the bargain to bring the then Deputy Cogan who had been in every Party, an ex-Civic Guard, into the Hospitals Commission? Was that not a bargain? Let the Taoiseach deny that if he wishes. We made no bargains. We had our mandate from the people who elected us. To-day I should like to talk about unemployment and emigration, because I am a worker. I listened to the policy and the programme put before the people in the last general election and I thought the Taoiseach would be doing what Deputy Costello did when he went to the radio in 1948 and brought home the tradesmen to Ireland. That progress went on until 1951, when the sabotage occurred. The housing drive was stopped then.
Senator Carter spoke here the other night and I am glad he is here now. I cut this out of the paper and it is a pity the Taoiseach is not here to hear it. I wonder if Senator Carter believed this. Another Senator spoke here to-day and said there are no poor in the country. This cutting says:—
"Families are starving in Granard; work schemes call to Government. There were families in Granard living in a state of semi-starvation, said Mr. T. Gilbride, at Longford County Council."
There is a county council calling on the Government to do something and some of them are Fianna Fáil people. Another councillor said it was never so bad; he was 26 years on the council and had never seen the position in regard to unemployment so bad.
Comment on this
I am quoting it because I am sure Senator Carter should be able to go down there and then bring pressure on the Government which he supports to do something for those starving people. It is a sad thing that when we have two or three big organisations uniting—there is a united trade union movement now — we are discussing a Bill to take away the rights of the plain people. There are big obstacles before those who seek election to the Dáil. One must have £100 and one must get a certain number of votes or the £100 will be lost. Now we have this obstacle, a straight vote. Can anyone here tell me what is the use of a candidate going down to Clare, if the Taoiseach is not President and has to stand again in Clare? What hope would he have of beating him? None; it could not be done. Moreover, the country seems to have been cut up to suit that Party.
Comment on this
Where was it tried? I will tell the House. It was tried in Wexford in 1943, when South Carlow was brought into Wexford constituency; and when it was of no benefit to Fianna Fáil it was taken out of Wexford again and it went back to Carlow. Is that not gerrymandering? Then Fianna Fáil say they have a policy. Where is their policy, where is the programme they preached to the people? They are in now on false promises. That is how they got elected. Some say they got a majority.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir. Down in Meath the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare used another bogyman. He said the Taoiseach was the greatest living man in the world, that "he kept you out of the war." I looked up the Official Debates of six years ago. There was a debate on defence in the Dáil on the 29th May, 1953. Deputy Cowan was speaking at the time and Deputy Dillon asked him if he would let him say a few words. As we all know, it was during the emergency. Here is the quotation, as given at column 369 of the report:—
"Mr. Dillon: I wonder whether the Deputy would allow me to provide a quotation? I understand that Deputy Rooney was challenged to-day about a quotation upon which he was not able to put his hand."
Comment on this
The Senator must relate this to the Bill we are discussing.
Comment on this
I relate it to the Bill, because this has been used in the debate. In that quotation, produced by Deputy Dillon, the Taoiseach said that our neutrality had depended on two men. The quotation continued:—
"General Mulcahy: And these two were not in this country?
The Taoiseach: No, they were not in this country.
Mr. Dillon: Does that answer mean the late President Roosevelt and Mr. Churchill?
The Taoiseach: Yes."
I ask those over there to get the Official Debates and read that. Then they will know who kept them out of the war.
Comment on this
This Bill has been brought in solely to do away with small Parties, but Fianna Fáil did not say that at the last election. They did not tell the people: "Give us an overall majority and we will deprive you of the right to vote 1, 2, 3 in the next election; you will mark the ballot with an X and that will be all." Fianna Fáil are in here on preference votes, too, because they vote 1, 2, 3 for themselves. It is rather a strange thing that, after all the years of Government, there is nothing to be talked about in the Dáil or Seanad to-day but how the people will vote in the next election. If the present Government run full time, the people will not be asked to vote until 1961 and God knows how many will be called away before then. The people to-day are not worrying how they will vote in the next election. If one goes to the boats and trains, one sees them fleeing out of the country because the country has failed them badly by not making progress.
This Bill is brought in solely because the new generation is coming up. Four of them were elected in the last general election in spite of great opposition. The writing was on the wall then. The Government then came along and said: "We will try to counteract these fellows so that they will not get a majority; and how will we do it? We will bring in a new Bill which will change the Constitution and we will have a straight vote."
I wonder where Fianna Fáil would be in years gone by if that had taken place under the other Governments? Would they have the overall majority to-day? No, they would not. It is about time the Government did something practical instead of bringing in red herrings of this kind. Anyone who has been in public life and has had to fight elections against a big Party — as we in the Labour Party have had to do, just like the Farmers' Party and now the Sinn Féin Party — knows very well that we cannot get the funds and the motor cars to fight our election. We have to fight with small means and now this obstacle is to be thrown up against us. It will take away the rights of the people. There is not a ha'porth else in it. There is no use in saying it is for the good of the country.
I admire Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien, who made a fine speech last week. Certainly, she could not say anything but what was straight and honest. She said she would have to vote for the referendum but that when she got her ballot paper she would vote "No" and she hoped the people outside would do the same. That is something other people will not say. She was honest when she said she was compelled to vote for the referendum but when she would get her ballot paper on voting day she would vote "No" and she asked others to do likewise. It is our job here to tell the people outside what is going on about this P.R. They are asking down the country what is all this talk on P.R. about, and what does it mean? They do not understand it. It was all right up until now.
I remember voting once in County Wexford in an election contested by two candidates, Sir Grattan Esmonde and Sir Roger Sweetman, for the British House of Commons, and the voter placed an X opposite the name of the candidate he preferred. That was a long while ago and, under our Constitution, the people were given the right to vote 1, 2, 3 and 4, or right down the whole list of candidates, but now that system is being abolished.
There are many people listening to me who would not get No. 1 votes but who would get second, third, fourth and fifth preferences under P.R. I got 5,000 first preferences in the last election in Wexford and if anyone should say anything against P.R., it is I, because P.R. beat me, but yet I am not afraid of it. I have won the local elections every time under it, but I am thinking of the other people who contest elections with me and who would have no chance under the straight vote.
If the Government were wise and if the Taoiseach were honest and wise, he could contest the Presidential election, but let him withdraw this Bill because it is only going to put the country to expense. The people do not want that expense; taxation is too high at the present time. I should like to see this money being spent on providing work for the labouring people. Spending it on this referendum is a waste of public money. We get a list of statistics every month from the Office of Works, and from those statistics we can see that there is an army of people waiting for something to be done for them. They are not worrying about how they will vote in the next election.
It is a regrettable state of affairs that people who made supreme sacrifices for this country, the working class people, are to be denied proper representation in Parliament. One or two of their representatives might be elected, but what good is that? The small farmer will be shoved out. The Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs would like to see Fine Gael in, and probably they could join hands then and have no Opposition. Maybe that is what they want, but I think it is wrong to deny to any section of the people their proper representation. The people know how to vote under P.R. They have been learning how to do so all down the years, but now they can make only one choice and can do nothing for the candidates they like next. The Taoiseach said that P.R. was all right, that it was fair, but now he is telling the people that it is all wrong. Who is going to trust a statesman who, in 1937, said it was all right and in 1959, says it is all wrong?
Comment on this
You opposed the Constitution then, too — the Constitution that is so sacred now.
Comment on this
There are people starving with the Constitution. There is no good talking about the Constitution, if you have not got full employment for the people. Remember the promises you made? You criticise the Coalition for not doing everything, but what help did you give the Coalition, when they were in office? Fianna Fáil published all the slander they could put into print. They showed the loaves of bread—they showed everything in that publication but the reduction in the butter price, but all those things have gone up again in price since Fianna Fáil returned to power with a majority.
Young men in other organisations in politics are getting up and talking about this Bill, but I see other honest men listening to me who will not say anything themselves but who will think the more. I should like to hear every member of the Government Party stating the case on this Bill, but only a very few of them have done so. Men of learning have spoken in this House in favour of our stand on this Bill. We have had the university professors——
Comment on this
——and they made a good case why this Bill should not be put through this House. I certainly am going to vote against it. I have instructions to do that from my trade union and from the people. What happened the workers previously when Fianna Fáil had a majority? We had standstill Orders, but what will we have with a one-man power and with a lot of yes-men? Where will the people come in? They will not be thought of at all. It is the Opposition who keep the Government active, and this Government have done nothing since coming into office two years ago. I suppose, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, I might not be allowed to mention that they have had the money from the food subsidies and from the prize bond scheme. They have all the money that the Coalition brought in.
Comment on this
I am giving the Senator great liberty, but there are limits.