We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Private Business. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 123–237 of 237. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

This is a Budget speech.

Comment on this

We will talk on the Budget when it comes.

Comment on this

The Senator will probably be making his Constitution speech on the Budget.

Comment on this

I will make my Constitution speech down the country at every chapel gate, and it will be the same as what I am saying now, advising the people to hold on to what they have. I hope that Fianna Fáil will do the same and take the advice of their own members. It is a scandalous state of affairs that this Bill should be brought in because the Government have no policy. They have no programme; they have nothing to offer the people, nothing in the world.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator should understand that we are on the Constitution Amendment Bill.

Comment on this

Other members spoke of what they did and they condemned all the things the Coalition did. Therefore, I am entitled to say the same. They condemned the Coalition——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There are limits.

Comment on this

And one Senator said we left a big bill behind us. Surely I am entitled to reply to that?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There are limits, in the judgment of the Chair, to what Senators may say in that regard.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should be advised by the Minister for External Affairs that his Government are putting something to the country which the country does not want. The people do not want it. It is something which will upset them. I remember an occasion when there were three elections held on the one day. There was a Presidential election and a local election, and in the cities and the towns there were three ballot boxes. There was general confusion. There were three boxes—a box for the votes for the President, a box for the county council votes and a box for the urban council votes. A great many of the people were confused. Some votes meant for the county council box went into the other two boxes and votes intended for one or other of the remaining two boxes went into the county council box. We shall have confusion again this time. Why is it that this is brought in now? Is it not brought in now because the Taoiseach is thrown into the circle again?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There is nothing about that in the Bill.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that it is introduced now because we are to have a Presidential election? Of course, that would not be put in the Bill — no — but that is the real position. We shall have confusion.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must discuss the Bill.

Comment on this

Do the present Government think that, because they have an overall majority, they can do what they like? We are told that every man is to be free to work out his own salvation. I want to quote from the election card of a candidate for the House of Representatives in Australia in 1958. Here is one of the ideals set forth:—

"In the conflict of ideas and the welter of proposals which contend for the support of free people there emerges one central fact. It is that man was born not only to be free but to enjoy that freedom in the sight of God and his fellow men."

That is the stuff that is given out in Australia where they have P.R.

I shall end my speech with this final quotation. It is from a speech made by Pope John XXIII in 1955 when he was Patriarch of Venice. He is a strong advocate of social justice for the workers and in his Christmas message of 1955 he said:—

"There are three things that call for our brotherly aid: poverty, unemployment and the dismissal of workers.

It is tragic to read in the newspapers that factories have been shut, that short time has been introduced, or, even worse, that workers have been dismissed...

I appeal to industrial leaders, to their technicians and to economists, and I beseech them in the name of the Almighty, to remember that intelligence and wealth were placed at their disposal, not to balance the books, but help them be ministers of Providence to the advantage of the human family."

Those words should be borne in mind by the Government. They should remember that if they have a majority it does not entitle them to ride roughshod over the people with legislation such as the Bill we are discussing here to-day.

Comment on this

I should like to say a very few words — I mean a very few words — on this subject. Since the foundation of this State, perhaps there has not been so much discussion on any measure that has come before the Houses of the Oireachtas as on this proposal to change the electoral system. It would be difficult, and for me impossible, to think of any original new ideas for or against this measure so I shall confine myself to dealing with three arguments put up by opposing speakers to the proposal. The three arguments come under three heads — (1) that the change will deprive minorities of fair representation; (2) that its real purpose is to perpetuate Fianna Fáil in Government for all time in this country and, (3) that the time is inopportune. Briefly, I would like to deal with those points.

I have some figures here. The first argument is, theoretically, very attractive—that P.R. is beneficial to minorities. In fact, it has been proved that it is not so attractive or so beneficial. It is undoubtedly true that if you had a minority of 15 to 20 per cent. evenly distributed throughout the country it is likely that that minority would not get 2 per cent. elected to the Dáil. As well as being a fairly large minority, they must also be geographically well situated to get elected. That, I understand, can be done when there is gerrymandering but in this country we have a minority— what is called in general terms a minority — of 7 or 8 per cent. and they get, in fact, only 3 per cent. representation in the Dáil under the present electoral system. I think that under that system they are being badly treated. In Britain now, under the straight vote system — I make no apology for quoting Britain—there is a minority of 1/2 per cent. of the population which gets 7 or 8 per cent. representation in Parliament. I think these few figures will prove, therefore, that the claim that under P.R. the minorities are well treated is not so.

The second argument is, I think, very unflattering to the electorate as a whole. In what way do Opposition Parties hope or think that Fianna Fáil can cushion itself against a change in public opinion? Do they think that, for all time, Fianna Fáil will have all the answers? In this regard, I find it most disappointing that the speakers of the Opposition Parties — especially the younger ones, the lawyers and learned young men — are so terribly depressed or lacking in hope for their future.

I do not like mentioning names but, in one case, a learned young man spoke at very great length last week. He referred us to the Constitutions of practically all the nations of the civilised world and their electoral forms, but he was so depressed and depressing that if I felt as he feels at his age, I certainly would have nothing to do with politics. I would probably take up bee-keeping or something. How do people think that any Party can say cushion itself against the swing of public opinion that, for all time, they will remain in power and no other Party can get into power? Public opinion will settle that. What is lamentable, I think, is the lack of hope for the future that these other Parties seem to have.

The third argument is that the time is inopportune. The answer has been given very well to that argument. It is that, with the rearrangement this year of constituencies, we can combine that rearrangement with this change in the electoral system. We are not changing it. We are asking the electorate to do it which, to my mind, is the most democratic way to do anything.

It is said that good government brings prosperity. I claim that the electoral system that elects Governments can have a very big say in the prosperity of the country. I hope the Seanad in its wisdom will see fit to pass this Bill. We are criticised very much already — sometimes rightly so — but I think we would be quite wrong, with our limited powers, to try even to hold up this Bill from going to the people and from giving the people the right to decide on this matter.

A point was made last week by Senator Stanford and, as a member of the other sex, I resent his giving as a good example what happens in Switzerland under P.R. where learned and less-learned gentlemen went to the polls last week and decided that women should not have votes. Even though that is a roundabout way of making my point, I think I can claim it is another argument against P.R. When these nations are quoted as if they had a perfect system, in my own way I find great fault with them. In that particular case, I had very great fault to find with the Swiss for not allowing women to vote. I hope that the Seanad in its wisdom will pass this Bill and allow the public to make the decision in this matter.

Comment on this

This proposal to abolish P.R. is the most important to come before the Oireachtas since the foundation of the State. It is a most retrograde step. I hope that when it comes before the people, in a democratic way, they will reject it. I am delighted that the Fianna Fáil Party are now converted to democracy and that, at this stage, they are willing to allow things to go to the people for decision in a democratic way. They did not believe in it at one time but it is their belief now and it is good to see that they have been converted to that way of thinking. When it comes before the people in a democratic way, I know they will reject this measure. In my opinion it is a direct and a blatant attempt to prevent Parliament being representative of the views of the people because it will interfere with the legitimate rights of minorities.

I believe also that it is contrary to our democratic tradition and that it will lead to unrepresentative Parliament, to arrogant government, and that it may pave the way to dictatorship. In addition, it will render more difficult the ending of Partition, for which we are all sincerely hoping in our day. I believe also that it has not been demanded by the people; therefore I claim that in present world conditions, and in our economic circumstances as they are to-day, it will impair rather than assist the solution of national problems. Everybody knows the circumstances to which I refer. They are the figure of 85,000 people unemployed, and the figure of over 70,000 who had to emigrate last year; high taxation, high cost of living and the poverty to which Senator O'Leary referred a few moments ago.

Senator Carter contradicted Senator O'Leary in regard to a statement which he made but he cannot contradict me in this statement. Is it not true that at a Fianna Fáil meeting held three weeks ago, Mr. Austin Sheehy, local secretary of the Longford Fianna Fáil Cumann, said that he never saw such poverty and that in 60 houses which he had visited, doing Legion work, in County Longford, an average of three people had emigrated from each of those houses? That was said by Mr. Sheehy when he was referring to circumstances in the country at the present time. In my opinion this proposal emanates——

Comment on this

On a point of order. As the Senator mentioned my name in connection with this quotation, I should like him to give the source to the House.

Comment on this

The Longford Leader for the 20th January.

Comment on this

I say that we reject the story as printed in the Longford Leader.

Comment on this

Of course you reject it.

Comment on this

It is purely a Party rag.

Comment on this

I hope the Longford Leader hears that the Senator has referred to it as a Party rag. In my opinion, this proposal emanates from a decision arrived at by the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste. One way or the other, the Taoiseach, whether or not he is elected to the Park — and I do not think he will be — has made up his mind to leave active politics. We know that in the past we had a cultured personality in this country. It was “Vote for Dev,”“Let Dev lead the way,”“Let Dev lead you to prosperity.” There was nothing about the rest of the Fianna Fáil Party. If the Tánaiste should be the new Taoiseach——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Now, Senator.

Comment on this

I am entitled to say how this proposal came about and give the reasons for it. I believe the Tánaiste is not wanted, even in the Fianna Fáil Party, by Deputies who have been elected by farmers, because he stated that the farmers had grants for this, that and the other thing and that they were on feather-beds. You have also got the revolutionary section who claim that the Party has gone too much to the Right, that they are Conservatives and that now they are more British than the British themselves. They know they are going to split and the only way to keep together is to say: "We will do away with P.R."

In my opinion this proposal comes from the Taoiseach and from the Tánaiste and from nobody else. I thought that this should have been a national issue above politics and above political Parties but, unfortunately for the country, the Taoiseach does not think so because he first introduced this at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. Neither does Senator Seán Ó Donnabháin think so because he got up and attacked us on this side of the House and spoke about the Blueshirts trying to march on Dublin and about a strong Government putting them down. I want to say that the Blueshirts——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is not in order on this Bill to go into that period of our history.

Comment on this

I am entitled, in passing, to say that we in Fine Gael agree with free speech, that we stand for free speech and the rights of all Parties, not like the blackguards and ruffians in Fianna Fáil who were fed with free beef and with free porter and who were sent out to interrupt meetings——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Senator pursues that line, the debate will become rather disagreeable and unpleasant for the Chair.

Comment on this

He thinks he is on a soap box down in Longford.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Carter can help.

Comment on this

I can.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

And I expect his help.

Comment on this

Those things were raised and at the same time we were supposed to have strong Government. The question was raised in Leinster House about interruptions and assaults at meetings — and this can happen in the future if you have strong one-Party Governments with nobody in Leinster House to stand up for the downtrodden or the minorities. When the Taoiseach was asked about the lack of protection for ratepayers and for people paying for the upkeep of the country he said it was not the business of the Government to make people and causes popular.

As I stated, this measure was first mooted at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. In my opinion this House is the place where the Taoiseach should have first introduced it. On the last day of the debate we had a controversy on this matter and Senator Lenihan directed our attention to the Irish Press for the middle of October and said that we would see there where the matter was discussed at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. I read the report and not one single person spoke against it. As a matter of fact it said that all rose to their feet to applaud the Taoiseach when he introduced this measure. In other words, they all rose to applaud the man who had found out that he was wrong in 1919 and in 1927 when he spoke in favour of it, and that he was wrong in 1937 when he put it into the Constitution. In 1957, however, when he somersaults, we all somersault with him and we all find out, 40 years later, that we have been all wrong. Could it not be that the Taoiseach is wrong now, as he was in times gone by? He has admitted that he was wrong in the past; perhaps he is wrong again. He was wrong four times out of five, because that is his own admission, and in all probability he is wrong the fifth time also.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

The measure we are discussing is described as the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. In my opinion, the proper title for it would be: the "Fianna Fáil Ascendancy Bill". That word "ascendancy" has a bad smell or taste in this country, but there is not the slightest doubt in the minds of the majority of the people at present that the aim of the Bill is to rivet Fianna Fáil in power for as long as possible. Senator Mrs. Dowdall smiles, as well she may. A few moments ago, she said that the young people in Fine Gael who had spoken up to this seemed to be depressed and lacking in hope. I suppose I would count myself as one of the younger members of the Fine Gael Party and we would not be depressed or lacking in hope if we had in power at present a Party who believed in justice, in charity, and in equality. Instead, we have a Party who know all the rules of the game, a wily Party, steeped in deceit and corruption, and I have no doubt that they will try to gerrymander as they did in 1947 when they tried to defeat the aim of P.R. by making 21 three-seat constituencies. But things did not go as they thought at that time and they do not want to make the same mistake again; so, as has been said previously, they changed the rules of the game.

It may be no harm to refer to the history of P.R. in this country. We are now asked to impose on the people of the Twenty-Six Counties the British and the Six-County system. We know that Arthur Griffith was one of the founder members of the P.R. Association here and that he started it in 1911. At, that time, he said in Sinn Féin— these references may be verified in the National Library:—

"We believe the strength of the Irish legislature will reside in including from the beginning representatives of every section of the nation. We desire to see the evil growth of political bossism checked under Home Rule and every section of our community given free speech in an Irish legislature."

We know that the aim of this Bill is to take representation from minorities and from different sections of the community. In a further issue of Sinn Féin on 25th February, 1911, Arthur Griffith also wrote:—

"P.R. secures that the majority of the electors shall rule and that minorities shall be represented in proportion to their strength. It is the one just system of election in democratic Government."

Nobody can say that Arthur Griffith was coerced by the British into making those statements in the organ of Sinn Féin which at that time was seeking to secure our freedom from the British Government. We in Fine Gael regard Arthur Griffith as one of the founders of our Party and we are proud of him. That is not merely one of our Party traditions; it is a national tradition.

It was not Lloyd George or anybody else who inspired that view of Arthur Griffith, and we know that the activities of the P.R. Society in their advocacy of the system from an Irish point of view resulted in the system being embodied in the Home Rule Scheme of 1912. The war intervened and we find that the first election here under P.R. was fought in Sligo. That was done, not at the dictates of the British Government or any other Government, but at the request of the people of Sligo because they found that the system we had up to that had led to chaos.

Many of the Fianna Fáil speakers claim that P.R. will not disfranchise minorities. It might be no harm to quote what the Taoiseach said as reported at column 2341, Volume 171, of the Dáil Debates of the 16th December, 1958:—

"My attitude towards P.R. has been called into question. I remember back in 1919 when it was introduced here. It was an English measure. There is no use in talking about where it arose — it was an English measure and it was in that respect that we had to deal with it."

I am surprised at the Taoiseach trying to fool the people of Ireland by saying it was an English measure. The Taoiseach, the man who states that now, spoke in favour of P.R. in 1919. He spoke again in favour of P.R. in 1927 and he embodied it in the Constitution of 1937. Does the Taoiseach now want to say that it was an English measure and that it was inspired by the British Government and by the English people, although he put it into the Constitution of 1937?

The Taoiseach was in favour of P.R. in 1919. We gained our freedom in 1922 and in an Irish Parliament, composed of men like Arthur Griffith, Mulcahy, MacEoin, Cosgrave and others we had this declaration:—

"Dáil Éireann sitting as a Constituent Assembly in this Provisional Parliament, acknowledging that all lawful authority comes from God to the people and in the confidence that the national life and unity of Ireland shall thus be restored hereby proclaims the establishment of the Irish Free State and in the exercise of undoubted right decrees and enacts..."

—the Constitution of 1922. Article 26 of that Constitution provided that Dáil Éireann should be composed of members elected to represent constituencies determined by law and that the system of election would be in accordance with the principles of P.R.

That was one of the first acts of this House away back in 1922, to proclaim its existence, to declare the manner in which it would control its own affairs and the manner in which people would be elected to Parliament. I hope nobody will tell me that people like Griffith, Mulcahy, MacEoin and Cosgrave, who took over this country from the British in 1921 and who fought to put the British out of this country, were then willing to adopt a British system at the dictates of the British Government and enshrine it in our Constitution of 1922. There was no fear of their doing that. They were Irishmen, inspired men who were there to do their best for all sections of the community, irrespective of class, creed or politics, and they wanted to give fair play to all sections, including the minority.

The founders of this State adopted P.R. and it was continued by them until 1932. In 1932 we had an election again under P.R. and the Fianna Fáil Party came in as the largest Party and took over the Government. If the Government between 1922 and 1932 had done away with P.R. they might have kept the Fianna Fáil Party out of power but they believed in and recognised the rights of Fianna Fáil or of any other legitimate Party which was prepared to work within the rules of the Constitution, and did not try to prevent them entering this Parliament.

In 1937 the Taoiseach embodied P.R. in our Constitution. At that time the Taoiseach was around 55 years of age. He was surely a mature man and if the system was as wrong as Senator Ó Maoláin tried to make us believe —the defects in it were discovered only in the last few years — and if the Taoiseach was the brilliant, far-seeing man we were told he was in the past, why did he not, with all the able lieutenants he had at his side, see these defects in 1937? It had been in operation then for almost 18 years. If it had any of those defects we hear about now, surely the Taoiseach and his able lieutenants should have been able to see them before that?

As reported at column 1343, Volume 67, of the Dáil Debates of the 1st June, 1937, the Taoiseach, speaking on the Constitution, said:—

"The system we have we know; the people know it. On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think that we have a good deal to be thankful for in this country."

That is the Taoiseach, not Gerry L'Estrange or anybody else, speaking. It is the leader of the Irish people. I do not think that I or anybody else in our Party could put it as well.

The Taoiseach was not satisfied with that but continued:—

"We have to be very grateful that we have had the system of P.R. here. It gives a certain amount of stability and on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties."

It gave stability in 1937. It gives instability in 1959. You got fair representation of the Parties in 1937 and he does not want fair representation of Parties now. It leads to a multiplicity of Parties and because the Parties are not supporting the Fianna Fáil Government and are not prepared to toe the Party line, the whole system is wrong.

It might be no harm to quote what the Taoiseach said in the Seanad on 4th February, 1959, as reported at Volume 50, column 254:—

"From 1938, that is, for the past 20 years, looking at the working of this system, I have on many occasions pointed out that, if it should lead here to a multiplicity of Parties..."

From 1938 on! Whom does the Taoiseach think he is fooling in this House? In 1938, 1939 and 1940 he had a majority in the Dáil and he could have changed the terms of the Constitution without a referendum. If in 1938, 1939 and 1940 he thought it was wrong, all he had to do was to bring in a simple Bill and have it passed here. He would not even have to refer it to the people. I believe he did not think that in those years but now he is trying to believe that he did.

On the 1st June, 1937, the Taoiseach said:—

"I think we get, probably, in this country more than in any other country, better balanced results from the system we have. If you take the countries where P.R. exists, you get better balanced results than you get in the other countries. I think we get the benefit of P.R. in reasonable legislation here better than in any other country that I have read about or know anything about."

Again, those are the Taoiseach's own words. They are not my words.

I listened to Fianna Fáil Senators here to-day lamenting the fact that Hitler and Mussolini came to power because of P.R. and weak government. Mussolini and Hitler were in power at that time. Had the Taoiseach not his eyes open? Could he not see then what Fianna Fáil see now? Or does it take the Fianna Fáil Party 20 years to open their eyes and see things as they should see them?

We have heard statements made to-day about P.R. It might be no harm to point out that the General Elections of 1938, 1943, 1944, 1948, 1951, 1954 and 1957 were all held under P.R. and there seemed to have been no objection during all those years. There was not a word from any of our Ministers or any of the Deputies. I defy any Senator here to quote where anyone of them objected to P.R. in the past 20 years. It was all right; it got them into the county councils or elected them to the Dáil or Seanad. Then, lo and behold, in 1958 they wake up suddenly. The Taoiseach says that P.R. is all wrong and must be changed. They chime in to a man behind him and say: "Yes, P.R. is all wrong and we must change it." It now becomes "the British system of election" and they must get rid of it.

In my opinion, the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party now want this country to adopt the British system. In an effort to secure the votes of the unthinking, they appeal to the anti-British feeling inherent in our people by suggesting that the present system of P.R. was imposed on us by the British in 1919. I do not want to repeat myself but, if it was, why did de Valera enshrine it in the Constitution of 1937?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator will refer to the Taoiseach under his proper title? It is very wrong on the part of the Senator to refer to the Taoiseach as "de Valera".

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir. I shall refer to him under his proper title in the future.

We had the argument that P.R. was imposed by the British. That kind of argument is used by Senators who are reasonably intelligent people. It is something similar to the arguments they used before about Britain. They told us: "The British market is gone for ever, thanks be to God." They told us that if every British ship was at the bottom of the sea, we could do without the rest of the world. They told us that we would whip John Bull, right, left and centre. They know there are people who may fall for that and who may rush in for Fianna Fáil if Fianna Fáil can get them to believe that this is a British system — something imposed on us by the British.

The British system of election — the straight vote — may suit Britain, a highly industrialised country where you have two large Parties with some people supporting Labour and employers and others supporting the Conservatives. I do not think it is a system that will suit this country. I claim that the abolition of P.R. will interfere with the legitimate rights of minorities. We have freedom in the Twenty-Six Counties under our present Constitution and under our present system of voting. The minorities are protected and they have certain rights. They can put forward their candidates, and they have a reasonable chance of having them elected. But under the new system they will have very little chance of having their candidates elected.

Now the Fianna Fáil Party want to eliminate Labour, Clann na Talmhan, the National Progressive Democrats, the Independents and also the Fine Gael Party, because we know that on the 7th January, Deputy Blaney, who is a young impetuous Minister, perhaps not as wily as some of the older people, stated in the House that if this referendum goes through, Fine Gael will have had it. We know now that as well as trying to get rid of the other Parties, they are trying to get rid of the Fine Gael Party.

We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy S. Lemass, sneering in the Dáil at the ideas Arthur Griffith had on P.R. In June, 1912, Arthur Griffith wrote in relation to what was coming in the Home Rule Bill of 1914:—

"If democracy is to survive as the working principle of government, it can only survive in the admission of the minority to a share of representation with its strength of the Government of the State."

I should find it hard to accept that Fianna Fáil should have any liking for minorities. When Fianna Fáil were in a minority away back in the 1920s, they had very little respect for the majority view at that time. Now that they are themselves a majority, it would, I suppose, be hard to expect them to have any respect for minorities. It may be of interest to quote what Mr. Gallagher, a great friend of the Taoiseach, stated in his book entitled The Indivisible Island. In chapter 15, he said:—

"One of the greatest wrongs that can be done to a minority in a democratic State is to deprive it of its political right, particularly of its electoral rights, for these are so often a shield for the rest."

That quotation was referred to in the Irish Press of 2nd June, 1957. The Irish Press now wants to get rid of P.R. and wants the straight vote system here, but at that time the Irish Press advised its readers that this book was a fully documented account of how the Six-County minority is deprived of its rights, of how, for the benefit of the Stormont junta, democracy has been extinguished and they said that this book must be read by every Irishman and, having been read, it must be broadcast to the rest of the world. Yet, that is the system they now want us to adopt. Those were their views on 2nd June, 1957; they have somersaulted in the meantime and their views to-day are diametrically opposed to the views they held at that time.

Let me quote the Taoiseach now. Away back in 1927 he stated that minorities should never be denied representation and if it was the object of those who advised the abolition of P.R. to wipe out minorities, then they would never get any support from him. They would get no support from him in 1927. He is prepared to-day to abolish P.R. on his own. He does not want the support of anybody in his proposal to wipe out P.R. and to suppress minorities.

We believe in the legitimate rights of all minorities. This is an agricultural country and, as a farmer, I claim that farmers should be represented in Parliament, if they wish to be represented there.

Comment on this

As farmers.

Comment on this

As farmers, as a minority group. We could have a Socialist Government here interfering with the rights of farmers in different ways. I see nothing wrong in the principle of producers coming together, putting forward candidates in an election, having them elected to Parliament to fight for their rights, for justice and for fair play. I claim the farmer minority is entitled to representation.

We all know that the trade union movement is the biggest in the country. If this measure is passed and if we adopt the straight vote system, will we have a situation in which the doors of Leinster House will be closed in future to a Jim Larkin, to a James Connolly or to any other legitimate representative of the 800,000 workers in this country? I claim Labour are entitled to be represented in Parliament. Nobody can deny that both those sections make the largest contribution to our national economy. If they are denied representation, they will still be subject to all the penalties of citizenship, whilst denied their fundamental right as citizens; it will be a case of taxation, rates, rent, and everything else, without representation.

If this Bill is passed, the Labour Party will get it very hard. They may get a possible two or three seats out of a total Dáil of 144 or 145 seats. They will have a very slender chance of getting any more than that. Fianna Fáil are the largest Party in all but two of the constituencies at the moment. Under this proposed new system, Fianna Fáil, the largest Party, stand to gain because it is the largest Party whose candidate tops the poll on the first count who will get the seat. At the moment, small Parties— Independents, Labour and others— command something in the region of 500,000 votes. If this proposal is carried, all their rights will be eliminated. I do not approve of that.

If Sinn Féin are prepared to come into Parliament, to put forward candidates for election, to recognise the duly elected Government of the country and accept the authority of Parliament, then they should be in a position to command representation. We had people at another stage of our history who were not prepared to accept the authority of Parliament, but they had a safety valve. They had P.R. and that gave them a chance of securing seats in Parliament. They ultimately availed of that chance and they entered the Dáil in 1927. That safety valve should be left and if Sinn Féin wish to put forward candidates, who have a reasonable chance of being elected, they should be in a position to do so; but that can be done only under the system of P.R.

A man should have the right to stand for any Party because, when we consider the matter properly, it is the individual candidate who counts and not so much the Party. If good men are nominated on behalf of a small Party, they should at least — I say "at least"—have a reasonable chance of election. They have that chance under P.R. They will not have it under this proposed new system. We know what happened in Northern Ireland when P.R. was abolished in 1929.

I claim that the straight vote system will lead to unrepresentative Parliament and to arrogant government. Instead of proportional representation according to Party strength, we shall have disproportionate representation. No other system of election is as fair as P.R. This straight vote system is the greatest gamble on earth, and we should not take gambles in this country at the present time. If the country were properly managed, there would be full and plenty for everybody. There is work to be done by everybody; there are problems to be solved by everybody. It is the duty of the Government to solve these problems instead of discussing this measure at length here and elsewhere.

As I said, this proposed system is the greatest gamble on earth. In 1945, the Labour Party in England polled 48 per cent. of the votes and they got a two to one majority of the seats in the House of Commons. In 1951, Labour polled 48½ per cent. of the votes, one half per cent. more than they got in 1945, and they lost the election to the Conservatives, who polled around 44 per cent. or 45 per cent. of the votes. In 1953, in South Africa, the Nationalist Party, with 590,000 votes, secured 92 seats, and the United Party with 608,000 votes— 10,000 or 12,000 more — got only 43 seats. They did not get even half the number of seats—and that is the system we are asked now to adopt here.

It may be no harm to quote the Tánaiste. Even on 10th November, 1933, he was aware of the dangers that might arise under this system as they have arisen in South Africa. In 1933, at a Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis, it was proposed that the system of P.R. should be changed and the British system introduced and the Tánaiste said at that time that P.R. was certainly a better system than that which had prevailed heretofore and that which was then in operation in Great Britain. The system which operated in that country might well give a minority a very substantial majority in Parliament. It had done so in Britain and could do so here under the system of the single member constituency and the non-transferable vote.

Those are not the words of Gerald L'Estrange but the words of the Tánaiste, who may be the next Taoiseach. Nobody can put the matter better — at least, I cannot. Those are the words of the Tánaiste about the proposal he is now asking the people to support, a proposal which would lead, to quote his own words, to a minority Government, a proposal which would be undemocratic and which might result in a policy being put into operation which had not the support of the majority of the people.

We have heard a good deal about the chaos in France and we know that P.R., as we know it here, operated in France for only one year, 1945-46. The real trouble in the past was not P.R. but the fact that Parliament was elected for five years and Deputies could elect a Premier to-day and put him out to-morrow, and their own seats were still safe as Parliament ran for five years. That is not our system, but it is the reason why they had so much trouble and so many changes of Government in France.

We have heard so much recently of the French system that it might be no harm to quote figures from the recent French elections. I have taken the figures from Figaro and Paris Soir and I now quote:—

"The Communist Party got 20.76 per cent. of the votes and 2.2 per cent. of the seats; U.N.R. got 26.47 per cent. of the votes and 40.4 per cent. of the seats; S.F.I.O. got 13.79 per cent. of the votes and 8.6 per cent. of the seats; the Radical Socialists got 2.01 per cent. of the votes and 2.8 per cent. of the seats; other Parties and Independents got 36.97 per cent. of the votes and 46 per cent. of the seats."

I hold no briefs for the Communists but they got over 5,000,000 votes in the election in France and got only ten seats. It took 500,000 votes to secure the election of one single Communist to the French Parliament, while the Government Party secured a seat with approximately 19,000 votes. We have no Party in this country like the Communist Party. We may have some Communist cells, an underground movement, but we have no Communist Party. Our Labour Party is a Party which believes in full social justice and is a good Christian Catholic Party.

Does the Government want to get into power with one-tenth of the votes it would take to elect another Party? It may have been all right to do that in France, but I claim there is no reason, good, bad or indifferent, for adopting similar tactics in this country. I entirely agree with the Taoiseach and with the Minister for External Affairs and if we had a Communist Party, I would stand behind them in any efforts they might make to put down that Party, but I shall not stand behind them in their efforts to crush minorities which are as well entitled to be represented in this House, and this Parliament, as Fianna Fáil or any other Party.

The British system which the Fianna Fáil Party want to foist on us here has led to minority government, as I have told the House, in Great Britain. In Britain over a period of 19 out of 24 years, the Conservative Party have dominated the Government, even though they had a minority in the country. In 31 British elections, the Labour Party lost 224 seats, when on the basis of its electoral voting strength, it should have lost only 39 seats. Accordingly, I believe it is certain that if P.R. is done away with, we will repeatedly have minority Governments in power, and Parliaments in which a majority of the people of the country will be denied representation.

Fianna Fáil will have to admit that they came out all right under P.R. If we look at some figures of elections, we will see that, in 1951, Fianna Fáil polled 46 per cent. of the votes and got 47 per cent. of the seats. Fine Gael polled 25.5 per cent. of the votes and got 26½ per cent. of the seats. That is not a system with which anybody can quarrel. It gives fair representation to the people. There are dangers inherent in the straight vote system, especially in this country, where we have two big Parties at the present time. It is said that there is not much difference between these Parties, but I claim there is a lot of difference, but still it must be admitted that we have two Parties who are to the right of the centre of the road. We all know that in any country where there is the straight vote system, there will never be two Parties to the right of the centre of the road. If there is in power in these countries such a party, there will be in opposition to them in all probability, a Socialist Party. Remember that could easily happen here.

We have many thousands of our kith and kin in Great Britain and if anything went wrong with Great Britain's economy, if they had to come back home and if we had this system, it could happen there would be an area with 10,000 people voting and a candidate getting 3,500 votes might get the seat. If many people had to come back to this country and if there was unrest in that area, we could easily have what is known on the Continent as a Popular Front, with all these people coming together with Sinn Féin perhaps or some other Party, forming a Popular Front here and getting such a Government in power. I do not think that any of us want to see a Government of that description in this country.

We also agree that if this Bill is passed — and I do not believe it will— Fianna Fáil, through manipulation of the constituencies and gerrymandering —there is no use saying they would not do it; it has been done in the past —could get anything from 100 to 126 seats. We know that they could then rivet themselves in power. If we take the 1957 votes, Fianna Fáil is the largest Party in 39 out of the present 40 constituencies. If the distribution of votes was in any way evenly divided in the different constituencies and if Fianna Fáil got the same vote as in the last general election — I will be truthful and say that I believe they will not— they could get 141 of the present 147 seats. That is on the figures in respect of the 1957 election.

Senator O'Sullivan the other day quoted something about what happened in Galway where Fine Gael headed the poll and was not elected. He claimed it was not fair representation because he headed the poll and was not elected. Galway was one of those three-seat constituencies which Fianna Fáil made in 1947 so that if they had only 1 per cent. of the votes more than the other Party they would get two seats out of three. Fine Gael got representation there because their other candidate was elected.

Let us take the votes in regard to the County Galway in the last election. Fianna Fáil polled 11,783; Fine Gael, 8,135. The result of that under P.R. in a constituency where they tried to defeat P.R. by making it a three-seat constituency, was that Fianna Fáil got two seats and Fine Gael got one. To-day on the straight vote system and if this Bill should go through, Fianna Fáil would get three seats for 11,783 votes and Fine Gael would get no seat for 8,135 votes. Therefore, Fianna Fáil would get a seat for every 3,924 votes and Fine Gael would not get a seat at all despite the fact that they had 8,135 votes in that constituency. Certainly, under this system Fine Gael would get no representation in that constituency.

Comment on this

They must not have deserved it.

Comment on this

People do not get all they deserve at times.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

They do not.

Comment on this

I also claim that the abolition of P.R. will deprive all Parties, with the exception of Fianna Fáil, of their just representation in Parliament. I claim, too, that under this new system you could even have an urban Dáil despite the fact that the people in rural Ireland are the most important section. The standard of living of each and every one of us in this country depends upon what the people of rural Ireland produce and export profitably abroad. It could well happen that the townspeople would be able in small constituencies to outvote the country people.

Comment on this

Cod!

Comment on this

There is no cod, good, bad or indifferent about it.

Comment on this

The Senator should restrain himself.

Comment on this

Let me take my own constituency, Westmeath. If you divide up Westmeath in all probability you would have north and south. You would have the town of Mullingar and the town of Athlone. Nobody but people from Mullingar or the town of Athlone will have an opportunity of being elected in Westmeath. The same would apply all round the country because the constituencies will definitely be built up round some big town. Any man who is worth his salt in an election gets 1,000 personal votes. You will have an urban Dáil. There is no denying that. The people who produce all will not have fair representation.

We know that the seats will be divided up on the basis of from 20,000 to 30,000 persons. There are about 9,000 votes cast in any constituency. Therefore, a seat could be won on 3,500 votes, more or less representing 1,000 families. As there are roughly from three to three and a half persons in each family, a Deputy could be elected to Parliament representing 1,000 families. What sort of a Dáil would that be? I claim that, under the present system, you would get a much better type of representative and a much better Dáil.

I also claim that the abolition of P.R. can lead to arrogant government and dictatorship. It could be a plan for permanent dictatorship here for years to come by keeping the one Party in office. We know that power leads to corruption. We want a Government where everybody can get a fair crack of the whip, irrespective of class, creed or politics.

When I speak of arrogant government, I want to say this: On the votes at the last election, Fianna Fáil could get 141 out of 146. Let us say that their popularity is on the decline and let us further assumes that they get 100 to 120 seats which they can easily get under this system if it goes through; you will have no Opposition to stand up for the rights of the people. You will have no Opposition to fight for fair prices for the farmers and a fair wage for the workers or anybody else.

I want to know what happens where Fianna Fáil have a clear majority on the county councils. The very same thing will happen when they have a clear majority in this House. Fianna Fáil have a clear majority on five county councils in Ireland and the inter-Party have a majority on 21. On the 21 county councils the Fianna Fáil Party, although they are in the minority, get fair representation on the general county councils and on all the subsidiary bodies. In the five councils where Fianna Fáil have a majority there is pure dictatorship.

With regard to the five county councils, Fianna Fáil can nominate three men to the General Council of County Councils from each county. The five nominate 15 Fianna Fáil county councillors. Five times three make 15 Fianna Fáil councillors and no other man ever gets a look in. On the other hand, on every one of the councils where Fianna Fáil are in the minority every Party has a fair and just representation. They are not denied representation on any one of the 21 county councils.

I want to go further. In the County Clare, Fianna Fáil have 17 and all others have 14 members. Fianna Fáil have a very slender majority. Every subsidiary body is filled by Fianna Fáil and no inter-Party member can get a chance.

Comment on this

That is not right. Let the Senator tell the truth.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about. I am telling the truth.

Comment on this

The Senator is not telling the truth.

Comment on this

The Claremen are not talking.

Comment on this

I will even go further.

Comment on this

Senator Ahern will resume his seat.

Comment on this

The Senator is not right though.

Comment on this

Senator Ahern will resume his seat.

Comment on this

Not alone that. For some of the subsidiary bodies they have not enough members in the Party to fill the seats, so they go outside the county council and bring in Fianna Fáil men and put them on the different subsidiary bodies; and they will not give a non-Party man a chance. We have Deputy Bill Murphy——

Comment on this

The Senator will remember that local administration is not in question on this Bill.

Comment on this

I agree that local administration is not in question, but I am pointing out what a strong Government can do. Here is what a strong Party can do. Many of those young county councillors in County Clare may be expecting to be, or may be, in the Government in a few years' time and if they are doing this at the present time it is only natural to expect they will do it here if they get this overall majority. I am pointing out what a strong Government with no Opposition can do. There is opposition in County Clare, they are only in a majority of three, but they do this in County Clare——

Comment on this

In 1950 the inter-Party councillors tried to get control of the county council.

Comment on this

In a democratic country any Party is entitled to try to get control of any county council, as long as they do it openly. It might be no harm to tell Senator Brady that at one time he was fined £10 by the I.R.A. Court because he would not take the inmates out of the workhouse when the Black and Tans came to burn it.

Comment on this

It never happened; and I will prove it.

Comment on this

He is the man who is talking about the Irish Constitution.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think this rigmarole by Senator L'Estrange has gone far enough and when he indulges in personalities I think something ought to be done about it. I listened very attentively for the last hour and a half and if he cannot conduct himself, a Chathaoirligh, I suggest you should make him conduct himself.

Comment on this

The same thing happened in Tipperary. We have Senator Burke, a member of Tipperary County Council, a big employer in Clonmel, a man who would do justice to anybody, and he is kept off every single committee in Tipperary. That is what strong government can do and that is what can happen if the Taoiseach gets an overall majority. We have Deputy William Murphy in Clare with 9,000 votes and Vincent McHugh with two and a half quotas. They are able men; I would say they would be better than the backbenchers of any Party, better than the backbenchers of Fine Gael. They are denied representation on any single body in County Clare. The Chairman of Clare County Council is here and he cannot deny that.

The very same thing happened in County Galway. Only Fianna Fáil get a look in there. We have Fintan Coogan, T.D. who got 5,000 or 6,000 in the general election and he is denied representation on any of those bodies. That is very unfair.

Comment on this

Give the names of the others.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach knows this is going on as well as anyone else. That work was well done and was so much to the liking of the Taoiseach that he nominated the Chairman of the Clare County Council to this Seanad on every occasion. He has said: "Well done, thou good and faithful servant; because thou hast been faithful over few things, I will place thee over many." He brings him in here into the Seanad. There is no denying that the Taoiseach knows it is going on. He has been putting his ear to the ground and he is not as sanctimonious as he may look or as he lets on to be.

All this is altogether wrong. It shows what Fianna Fáil can do and will do. That is the reason we in this House have such fear. If they went before the Irish people and if everything were done in a straight fashion and above board, we would have no fear; but the people who are past masters of this kind of thing can make sure, when they get a majority, that they will kill — or try to kill — Fine Gael, Labour or any other Party which tries to raise its head.

The abolition of P.R. and the adoption of the British system will also make more difficult the ending of Partition. Again and again, here and outside, the Taoiseach has said that Partition is our outstanding problem. He told us on numerous occasions that it is the one problem nearest and dearest to his heart. He had a plan to end Partition in 1932 and I think he had a plan to end it at every election since then. If he were serious about it, the last move in the world that he would make would be to give even the appearance of seeking one-Party domination in a united Ireland. The representatives of the Northern Government themselves know how it has worked there. They know what they have been able to do with majorities. The Unionists in Northern Ireland, who know so much about the straight vote, who know exactly how the straight vote works, who know how to keep down minorities, are not going to come in here as a minority themselves under this system, because they know that there can be one-Party domination and that they would never get a chance.

We were all very glad to hear the views of Senator Stanford, Senator Sheehy Skeffington, Senator Fearon and other Senators who can be looked upon definitely as independent Senators. We admire them for the stand they have taken on this Bill. I can do no better than quote the words of Deputy Dockrell, a member of the minority in this country, as spoken in the Dáil on the 13th January, 1959, and reported in Volume 172, column 412, of the Official Debates:—

"The Taoiseach touched lightly on the question of the North. The abolition of P.R. can by no stretch of the imagination be deemed to be a help towards the solution of Partition. The fact that the North did away with P.R. in 1929, or whatever year it was, is no excuse for the South trying to do away with it in 1959. Some day when Partition will have gone — it may not be in my lifetime, but some day it will have gone — the bringing together of our people will be made all the easier, I believe, if we have a system here which readily accepts minorities, a system which will have become so accustomed to the handling of minorities that, out of that handling, there will have developed a very fine instrument of parliamentary democracy. Such a system will make the united Ireland to which we all look forward that much easier."

I could not put this point better than he has put it. The really important words are those in which he points out that, if we have a system here which readily accepts minorities, a united Ireland will be made easier than under a system where minorities may be trampled upon.

I said in my opening remarks that this Bill has not been demanded by public opinion. There was a general election last year; there were other general elections in 1954, 1951, 1948, 1944, 1943 and in other years. We heard no reference to P.R., to the abolition of P.R., in any of those elections. It was never put before the people of this country. The Government were elected "to get cracking", to end emigration and unemployment and not to put up the cost of living or reduce the food subsidies. They never mentioned P.R. in any of their election speeches and they were not elected to abolish P.R.

All the time, the Taoiseach has been telling us that people should come together and let their policies be known before elections so that the electorate will know what they are going to do. He has told us that Parties should not come together afterwards, but should place their policy before the people so that they can vote on it. Surely he cannot come in here and tell us that the people of Ireland, in the last election, voted for the abolition of P.R., or gave the Government any mandate to abolish it?

They never said they were going to do it; yet the Taoiseach, at column 996 of the Official Report for 26th November, 1958, when he seemingly referred to the demand for this measure which was evident to him, stated:—

"It has been suggested that there has been no public opinion, no voice asking for this. All I can say to the Leader of the Opposition is that, if he thinks that, he must have had cotton wool in his ears from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to 1957, because everywhere I went through the country, everyone I met wanted to know when were we going to get rid of that system which was going to ruin the country."

We know he was abroad most of the time from 1948 to 1951, and I do not believe he heard that clamouring at any time from Fine Gael supporters. He might have heard it from Fianna Fáil supporters who were dissatisfied because they were not in office. P.R. seems to be all right for this country when it elects Fianna Fáil to office, but it is completely wrong for this country when it elects any other Government to office. He heard those stories during the years the inter-Party Government were in office.

I have been in public life for 17 years. I am a member of a county council, of the General Council of County Councils and other bodies, and I have not heard in all these bodies during the past 17 years— even during the years 1948 to 1951, or the years 1951 to 1954 — one solitary whisper of a demand for the abolition of P.R. There is no doubt that if a young Fianna Fáil enthusiast in Westmeath County Council, or anywhere else, thinks the Taoiseach is thinking in a particular way, he loves to put down a motion at a council meeting and have his name in the paper. Fine Gael councillors do it and Fianna Fáil councillors love to do it also, but, as I said, during those 17 years, there was not even a single whisper to that effect. I do not know if even the most insignificant organisation in the country, at any time during the past 20 years, has called for the abolition of P.R. There was a resolution at the Fine Gael Árd-Fheis in 1933. That is a long number of years ago and there has not been a resolution, even at a Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis, calling for the abolition of P.R. since then.

The Church in this country advises the different Governments, advises the people, if it sees things are wrong or going wrong in particular times, and never once, in my memory, has any churchman called for the abolition of P.R., or asked that it be changed and that we have the straight vote in order to lead to better Government and better Parliament. We have the brains of the country in our universities and I do not think any such call has ever come from any of them. As a matter of fact, I cannot find any evidence, even amongst Fianna Fáil supporters, to show that this Bill is wanted. I found nothing but praise for the old system of election but then suddenly this year the Taoiseach discovered that it is a freak. Senator Ó Maoláin tells us the foundation is wrong from the very beginning and that there are serious defects in it. Why were these serious defects not found in it in the past 20 years?

We are told by the Fianna Fáil Party that we will get a better type of Deputy and will have less "deadwood" in the Parties under the straight vote system. We were told to-day by Senator Lenihan that we will get a better type of Deputy, but I want to say that we will get the Deputy the Party bosses want us to get, and no other. That is the greatest disadvantage of the proposed change. It will lead to the growth of power of the Party. You will have the Party machine choice of candidate. The choice of the candidate will rest with the machine and not with the people.

I should like to quote the present Pope, as reported in the Irish Catholic of 23rd December, 1958. Pope John XXIII was calling on the faithful to participate actively in the political life of their country and carefully to select their parliamentary representatives. If this Bill goes through, the people cannot participate actively or select the best men. They will have only to vote for the men thrust upon them by the Party machine. The Pope stated:—

"Voters must choose their representatives with the greatest wisdom and knowledge because their choice is of particular importance in a democratic régime in which the representatives of the people have legislative power.

The moral rectitude, the practical capacity and the intellectual powers of parliamentary deputies are for the people of a democratic régime a matter of life and death, of prosperity or of decadence, of recovery or of perpetual ill condition."

If this Bill goes through, the people will have no choice, good, bad or indifferent. The Party conventions will be held and the Party bosses will rule.

It might be no harm to quote An tAthair Ó Heideain, O.P., M.A., who wrote in the Standard of the 15th December, 1958, as follows:—

"Under P.R., a Party supporter is given a choice between several candidates; in West Galway, for example, three were put forward by Fianna Fáil and two by Fine Gael. In a single member constituency, however, a Party would put forward only one candidate and electors who wanted to support the Party's general policy would have no choice but to vote for him."

Even taking Westmeath, where I have always seen 12 to 14 candidates at an election, the people can go out, select and vote for the candidate they think best, even irrespective of a Party. In a position like that, as Pope John XXIII said, the moral rectitude, the practical capacity and the intellectual powers of the candidate can be taken into consideration. A voter can weigh up the intellectual powers and the intellectual capacity of the 14 candidates. He can say: "These particular five candidates are the five best men. I judge them as such: I will vote for them 1, 2, 3, 4, 5." However, under the new system, he will become only a cog in the Party machine. The Party bosses will do the work. If he is a Fianna Fáil man they will select the candidate and he will toe the line. The other Parties will do the same. The people themselves will have very little power. The Party bosses will have all the power.

I want to read this quotation from the Irish Press of 29th January last. It is a report of the Taoiseach's speech when winding up the debate in the Dáil on the 28th January. He is reported as follows:—

"As he understood it, the whole purpose of representative democracy was to try to get into Parliament members who would represent the constituency that elected them. That was done far better, in his opinion, by the system of single-member constituency and the nontransferable vote than by the system they called proportional representation. Surely the best form of representation was that the people in a single constituency would vote for the person they thought best represented their views with regard to their own interests and the national interest. You got that by the single-member constituency."

Who, in the name of goodness, does the present Taoiseach think he is codding? The people have no choice. The Party select the man and the electors have only to go out and put their "X" before his name, if this measure is carried. They have no other say, good, bad or indifferent.

But, under P.R., the electors had the chance, as the Taoiseach said, of voting for people who represented their views. They have not that chance under the Taoiseach's proposed system, good, bad or indifferent. It is not right that certain Ministers should try to mislead the people. In Longford, on 18th January last, the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, made a speech which was reported the following day in the Irish Independent. He was speaking about P.R. and he is reported as follows:—

"From the point of view of public interest it produces many undesirable, in fact, positively harmful situations. Chief among them was that it gave the Party bosses so much power that between them they had almost absolute control of Parliament."

Nobody ever heard anything farther from the truth than that. In a constituency such as Westmeath, the Party bosses would nominate five candidates in Fianna Fáil's case and perhaps five candidates in Fine Gael's case. The Party bosses could nominate five. The people went out and voted for their choice and elected two or three and the Party bosses had no power.

I am wondering now if the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, is annoyed here with the power the present Taoiseach had and the Fianna Fáil bosses had over their candidates for a long number of years. I claim that Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach have continually, over the years, dictated to the Party conventions as to those whom he wanted selected as candidates. As reported at column 2338 of Volume 171 of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, the Taoiseach said:—

"There are the rivalries of various kinds that occur in multiple-member constituencies. They will not be there any longer. The rivalries that occur are very disedifying and tend to bring democratic representation into disrepute."

If they have had those things at Fianna Fáil conventions, it would be much better if the Taoiseach did not put them on record in Leinster House. I know that these things have happened and that the Taoiseach has had the last say.

We know that the Roscommon Fianna Fáil Convention in 1957 got instructions to select a certain candidate. He is in this House. I believe he would make a much better Deputy than some of the other candidates. The convention met. They did not select him. They sent three names. Headquarters refused to sanction the three selected and called another convention for the following week. They met again and the convention refused to select the particular candidate that headquarters wanted. They sent up the other names. Lo and behold, they were sanctioned with the addition of the other candidate, nominated by the Fianna Fáil National Council. That appeared in the local papers and there is no denying it.

In 1952, at the Wicklow by-election, a Fianna Fáil candidate was selected by the people. As the Taoiseach said a few months ago in his remarks which I quoted to the House, the people should have the say. The Fianna Fáil National Executive turned nominees down. They would not allow them to go forward, as their Party nominees, to the people.

The same happened in Carlow-Kilkenny when the daughter of a former Minister for Agriculture was selected. The Fianna Fáil Party bosses and the Party bosses of the organisation refused to ratify the selection of that candidate. The same happened in Sligo-Leitrim with a Fianna Fáil candidate and it also happened in Kerry. Therefore, instead of, as the Taoiseach stated, the people having the power under the new system, the reverse in fact is the case. The Party bosses will have more power now than they had in the past.

Comment on this

On a point of order. A Senator of the Fianna Fáil Party has put out his tongue at Senator L'Estrange. I know that the Cathaoirleach has not seen him. This is the second time it has happened in this House in the past few months.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will Senator Donegan be his age?

Comment on this

Senator L'Estrange.

Comment on this

I do not mind who puts out his tongue at me so long as I am not interrupted.

Comment on this

I assume the Senator has withdrawn it?

Comment on this

That is an understatement.

Comment on this

I think the greatest result of the new system will be that the people will not have a choice of selecting from a panel of candidates the man they want to represent them. Senator Lenihan stated in this debate that the proposed system will give us a much better type of Deputy. He went on to say that good Independents can be elected and will be elected. I think he is contradicting the Taoiseach there because the Taoiseach himself admitted that what he wants are two large Parties — no Independents. The Taoiseach and Senator Lenihan cannot be right at the same time.

Senator Lenihan said that the new system will give us a better type of Deputy. Deputy Seán Flanagan said something similar in the Dáil. It might be no harm to quote what Deputy Seán Flanagan said in Dáil Eireann on 10th December, 1958, at column 1787, Volume 171. He said:—

"There is far too much deawood in this House, people coming in on the third or fourth count in a five-member constituency and doing nothing. That is one of the reasons why I hope that P.R. will be abolished and one of the reasons why I am sure the new system will lead to a better Parliament, a Parliament with less deadwood."

As I said, Senator Lenihan referred to something similar to-day. I do not agree with him and I think the people are better judges, any time, of the candidates who go before them than the political bosses. The political bosses— and I say this as one who knows a little about politics — are more inclined to select the good Party man. One thing is certain, that is, that Fianna Fáil have always done that and if they are in a strong Government, they will continue to do it.

When speaking about deadwood and about men being elected on the fifth and sixth counts, at the bottom of the poll, I might mention that the Minister for Lands was elected on the tenth count with 5,902 votes, 1,000 short of the quota, in 1951 and that, in 1954, in Dublin South-East, the Minister for Health was elected with 6,391 votes, on the last count, 1,000 short of the quota. When speaking of deadwood, are we to regard as deadwood the Minister who is in Health and the Minister who is in Lands at the present time? Apparently Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach have no objection to putting deadwood into two of the most important Ministries in this State. That is what that means, if Senator Lenihan and Deputy Seán Flanagan and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party are correct in what they say about P.R.

Let us come to the question of stability and strong government. This is the argument that is commonly used for the abolition of P.R. — that the British system, that is, the system of the straight vote, would give a strong Government. I want to say that strong government is no substitute for good government. What we want at present is good government, not strong government. This little country of ours unfortunately, I might say, has had ample experience of strong government. We have had experience of strong government from Oliver Cromwell and Lord Salisbury, the British Tory leader, who in the Parnellite days proclaimed that 20 years of resolute government would be a cure for all Irish ills. Does the Taoiseach want to follow in the footsteps of Lord Salisbury and say that 20 years of strong Fianna Fáil government is a cure for all Irish ills? Fianna Fáil are now using the language of the oppressors as well as the system of the oppressors.

It should be the concern of each and every one of us in this House to get and to retain good government. You have strong government in many countries throughout the world and many of them have not been good Governments. We know power is not necessarily beneficial and that power corrupts. We know that there was strong government in Germany and in various other countries. You can say that there is strong government in Russia to-day; that there is strong government in Poland — and we know what they did in 1956 with the Catholics when there was an uprising. There is a strong Government in Yugoslavia and in Red China, but surely that is not the kind of government we want? They are the people who talk more than anyone else about the rights of the people, about the people's democracy and about peace. They never stop talking about peace at the U.N.O.

Nobody can deny that we have had stability here, no matter what the Taoiseach or any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party may state. Since the foundation of this State, we have had only five changes of Government, in 36 years, and three Taoisigh. There is no other country in the world which can claim that record. From 1922 to 1932, we had a Government of young men, a Government which had a hard task and which took over from the British. They helped to build up this State; they founded the Civic Guards and our Irish Army, of which we are all so proud; they started the first of our industries; they started the Shannon scheme, which was said to be a white elephant at that time; they started the first of our beet factories and there is no denying that they were what could be described as a strong and efficient Government. They had to be a strong Government because of the opposition which they met at that time from people who did not believe in the rights of the majority of the people, people who were then in a minority but who were not prepared to obey the laws of the country.

We know they continued in office, and we had stability, from 1922 to 1932. There was a change of Government then and Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932 on a series of promises which they made to the people and which they never fulfilled. The Governments from 1932 to 1948 were, in many ways, strong Governments and stable Governments, because, as Senator Hayes stated, they were able to carry out executions; they had the economic war and they were even able to reduce our cattle population——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator may not debate that now.

Comment on this

In any case, they were referred to as a strong Government and they did those things. From 1948 to 1951, we had a change of Government and that Government was attacked by Senators on the far side of the House. As an attack has been made on Coalition Governments and as they are supposed to be the reason for and the cause of all our woes and troubles, we should be at least allowed to make certain references to their work. We were told to-day by Senator Ó Donnabháin of the huge debt the Coalition Government left in 1951. Despite the fact that I listened to the Minister for External Affairs in County Louth talking about those debts, and despite the fact that other Ministers made the same accusations, the Taoiseach, to give him his due, admitted in Cork that they were left £24,000,000 of Marshall Aid in the "kitty" when the change of Government came in 1951. There was even £6,000,000 of that money available when the Agricultural Institute was being set up last year. The inter-Party Government spent only £16,000,000 in three and a quarter years; Fianna Fáil spent the other £8,000,000 in six months. Senator Seán O'Donovan is wrong when he says that debts were left because the Taoiseach himself admitted in Cork what I have said.

The Government elected in 1948 trebled our exports, doubled our output, built hospitals, houses and schools and, as Senator Sheehy Skeffington said, the T.B. sufferers know the good work that was done by that Government.

Do we in the Twenty-Six Counties want the stability and strong government they have in Northern Ireland, where elections are a mere farce, where half the constituencies are not even contested and the results are known beforehand? Is strength the only quality required in a Government? Unfortunately, the bitter message of history is that Governments can be stronger than they are wise. We have had many strong Governments here, but I doubt if they were sufficiently wise. What we want is good government and in order to have that, we must have a Government supported by the majority of the people. You are sure of getting that kind of Government under P.R.; you cannot be certain of getting that under the system now advocated by the Taoiseach. You had minority government in Britain for 18 out of 24 years; we could have minority government here for the next 20 years.

This is what the Taoiseach had to say on 20th January, 1948, as reported in the Irish Press:—

"A Government is strong only if it has a majority in Parliament because with our system the Government depends on the majority it has in Parliament. It is a weak Government if it has not a strong majority."

Now, the Taoiseach goes on:—

"It is not strong merely because it has a parliamentary majority. If it can be suggested that a Government is not supported by the people then the Government by that very fact is a weak Government."

We are asked by the Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil to adopt a system which may give us minority government for years to come and we are asked to do that in the face of views already expressed by the Taoiseach, notwithstanding the fact that he is on record as saying that no matter what majority a Government may have in this House, it is a weak Government unless it has a majority of the people behind it. A Government elected under P.R. has because of that fact, a majority of the people behind it, while a Government elected under the straight vote may very well be a minority Government.

Fianna Fáil claim they want strong government. They have that at present; they have a majority of 12 or 14 and I wonder if they consider that is not strong enough to carry out their policy. Do they want a Government such as exist in countries abroad? Why cannot this Government with a large, sound and solid majority behind them feel completely stable and able to carry out the promises they made before the last election? I am afraid the whole theme of the debate as we have heard it here is that stability and security and Fianna Fáil are one and the same thing.

We have been told that P.R. leads to Coalition Governments but Coalition Governments were formed here only in 1948 because of the failure of Fianna Fáil to live up to their promises up to them. The Taoiseach has spoken at length about Parties making false promises, but if Fianna Fáil had lived up to their promises and fulfilled the wonderful things they promised the Irish people, there would have been no change of Government in 1948. No matter what has been said on the other side, it was a proud day for the country when Labour, Fine Gael, Farmers and Clann na Poblachta came together with one aim alone — to do their best for all sections of the community, irrespective of class, creed or politics. There is no denying they did that during their term of office.

Going through the Dáil and Seanad debates, I find that on no fewer than 16 occasions did the Taoiseach speak about and condemn Coalition Governments. I should like to know what was wrong with the Coalition Governments of 1948 and 1951 when they were all right in 1927 when Fianna Fáil were trying to form a coalition with Labour and with the Farmers, if they could get them. The Taoiseach tried it at that time but because he failed then, he has hated Coalition Governments ever since.

Speaking about bargaining as reported at column 2346, Volume 171 of the Official Reports the Taoiseach had this to say:—

"Everyone who was living in this country in 1948 knows perfectly well it does mean that——"

He was speaking of bargaining

"——and if there is any doubt in anyone's mind as to whether it would mean that or not, they have only to turn their minds back to 1948 and ask themselves what happened in 1948."

He goes on:—

"...but bargaining between the other Parties took place; they got some Independents to help them, and they came back and pretended they were elected as a Government by the Irish people."

The Taoiseach was speaking there about the Parties that came together at that time to form a Government and do their best for all sections, but his words tell us exactly what Fianna Fáil did in 1951. They got some Independents to help them, and they came back and pretended they were elected as a Government by the Irish people. We know that Fianna Fáil were a minority in 1951. The Taoiseach told us in the Seanad and he stated in the Dáil that he had no objection if Parties came together before an election and made the promises they intended to meet, but he did not do that.

The Fianna Fáil Party met and published a 17-point programme. The promises made in that programme were not made from a platform in the heat of a general election. They were made in the Fianna Fáil Party rooms and signed by no less a person than the Taoiseach. This programme was formed after the 1951 election despite the fact that the Taoiseach says now that all the bargaining should be done before an election. It is wrong if Fine Gael or anybody else does it but it is quite in order when Fianna Fáil does it. Point 15 of that programme was: "To maintain the subsidies and to reduce the cost of living." That point in the programme was deliberately ignored in less than nine months when Fianna Fáil reduced the subsidies and increased the cost of living.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Chair going to allow a discussion on those lines?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

No.

Comment on this

As I say, the bargaining was done. As a result of this 17-point programme the five Independents came in and voted for Fianna Fáil and the people at the next election threw the five of them out. I am sorry the Taoiseach is not here now because I would ask him a question in relation to the following quotation from a speech he made as reported at column 995, Volume 171 of the Dáil Debates of the 26th November, 1958:—

"I have no doubt whatever that, had we been in and had there been a second election in 1948, we would again have got the power, but we required in each case two elections to secure it."

They would have gone to the country in 1949 as they did in 1933 after the 1932 election, as they did in 1937 after the 1936 election and in 1943 after the 1942 election. I am delighted Senator Lenihan is bowing his head in agreement. I should like to ask him this question.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Through the Chair.

Comment on this

Yes. If there was no bargain with the Independents that they would not lose their seats for three years, why did the Taoiseach not go to the country in 1952? It was simply because he had an agreement with those Independents that he would not go to the country. Those people were rejected by the electorate in the 1954 election. I defy contradiction on this because it was told to me by a man who was a Fianna Fáil Senator and who had lost his seat in the 1954 election. This is what he told me: "The Taoiseach came into the Fianna Fáil Party rooms when they were putting the names of their candidates on the Seanad ballot paper and he said: ‘The names of Dr. ffrench O'Carroll and Mr. Cogan must go on that paper.'" The names of Dr. ffrench O'Carroll and Mr. Cogan went on that ballot paper.

Shortly before that at column 30, Volume 110, of the Dáil Debates of the 18th February, 1948, the then Deputy Cogan said of the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera:—

"Just as King Herod sought to destroy an Infant rival, so Eamon de Valera sought to destroy a new Party in the field."

He goes on to criticise the Taoiseach but despite that Deputy Cogan and Deputy Dr. ffrench O'Carroll were made Senators. They were rejected at the last Seanad election and one of them has since been appointed on a commission at roughly the same salary he would get if he were a member of the Seanad. What I want to ask is: will somebody stand up here and contradict that statement?

We are also told that P.R. leads to a multiplicity of Parties. That is not in accordance with the facts. I should like to produce the evidence I have to the contrary. We shall take it that four members constitute a Party, and in 1923 we had four Parties in this State. You had Sinn Féin, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the Labour Party and the Farmers' Party. Three of those Parties were represented in the Dáil and the other Party was sulking outside the gates like little children. They had not dumped their arms at that time or made up their minds to come into Leinster House and accept the Constitution of the State. Applying the same yardstick, in 1959 we have only three Parties as against four Parties in 1923. In fact more Parties were born and died under P.R. than came to maturity. In the intervening years you had the People's Party, the National League, the Farmers' Party and the Centre Party, but we have had only three large Parties here for the past 36 years. The two major Parties at the present time have over 120 of the 147 seats.

When we have heard so much about France and about the new system of election, it might be a good argument to say that 18 Parties went forward at the last French election and 12 or 14 of those Parties have representation in the French Parliament. Therefore, it is not in accordance with the facts to say that P.R. leads to a multiplicity of Parties. As I state, we had four in 1923 and we have only three Parties now. If P.R. goes, another danger is that it will drive Parties underground.

We all understand the Irish people and know what they are capable of doing. They will have their freedom. They fought for it for 700 years. They fought against the British and they will not be denied their freedom now by any political Party. If Parties are denied representation, they will not disappear overnight. There is an old saying that you can lead the Irish, but you cannot drive them. The more you try to trample on the Irish people, the more they will defy you. If they can get representation under P.R., they will seek it through the normal channels in keeping with the Constitution; but if they are denied that representation, they may seek other means of making their presence felt.

The danger of such developments is quite obvious. It has happened before and it can happen again. Suppose the right of representation in the Dáil and Seanad were taken from the Labour Party in the morning? They are strongly organised at present. If they wanted to in the future, they could cripple this country. No one can deny that, when the strength of the trade unions totals 800,000. I am not saying they should do so or that it would be right for them, but they could not be blamed for doing it, if their rights were taken away.

As far as Sinn Féin are concerned, so long as we have P.R., the safety valve is there. They can utilise their energies in trying to get representation in Leinster House and in using Parliament to gain their ends; but if you take that representation away and keep them out, as this Bill will do, you will definitely drive them underground. The safety valve is there and it would be a bad day's work if it were taken away. I want this to be clearly understood. I make no defence of anyone who goes out with a gun against any established Government here. It has never been the history of our Party. As far as we are concerned, we are consistent in that since 1921. But, at the same time, if we deny those people in Sinn Féin their legitimate rights, we are driving them underground and driving them, perhaps, into violent ways.

In 1927, after the murder of Kevin O'Higgins by people who did not subscribe to legitimate government, by people who were driven underground because they claimed at that time they were not getting their rights — or at least what they thought were their rights — the present Taoiseach made a better case in support of my argument than I would be able to make. In Volume 40, column 53, of the Dáil Debates, the Taoiseach referred to the fact that many people had taken up arms here and said this about strong government:—

"The Ministers opposite know only one way in which to solve them! Anyone who gets in your path, ‘squelch him, by God, squelch him', as Carlyle said of Ireland. That is the only policy apparently that the Executive Council knows how to put into operation."

The Taoiseach was talking about strong government at that time. It was too strong for him then. He said they were too strong and that all they wanted to do was to squelch the people and walk on them. Now he wants to get into power again a Party that will be sufficiently strong to squelch the people in the future. He goes on:—

"If you deny people who are animated with honest motives, peaceful ways of doing it, you are throwing them back upon violent ways of doing it. Once they are denied the peaceful way they will get support for the violent way that they would never get otherwise. There is no use in my preaching that doctrine to the Executive Council."

The Taoiseach stated at that time that they would turn towards violent ways. If we deny our young people their rights and take from them what they are entitled to, the danger is you may have here in years to come a Castro such as we have seen in Cuba recently. They will fight for their freedom and let nobody take it from them.

As I said, the abolition of P.R. could easily result in a minority getting the majority of seats. That gravely weakens the authority of Parliament to speak for the people. Nobody can deny that. In the last few years, I notice that the minority group in this country — I refer to the I.R.A. — have claimed the right to use arms without the authority of Parliament. The challenge from those people was met by reasserting the authority of the majority. But if the Government were a minority Government, how could they effectively answer another minority? It would be very hard for a minority Government to try to put down another minority; but when they are in a majority, as they would be if elected under P.R., they would be entitled, in the name of the majority they represent, to crush any conspiracy, whether against the lawfully elected Government of the Twenty-Six Counties, the Government of the Six Counties or any other country.

The danger is that these people, when they go underground, can go back on history and quote the Taoiseach's words to any of us here or they can throw them in the Taoiseach's face, as I shall do now. Remember this is the Taoiseach, who is now asking us to accept his views in regard to P.R. and asking the people to put him into the highest position in the country. In Volume 28, column 1400, of the Dáil Debates, he stated:—

"When we were involved in civil war... I for one, when the flag of the Republic was run up against an Executive... stood by the flag of the Republic and I will do it again."

I was glad to hear Senator Lenihan to-day say that it is important to protect democracy. Democracy was getting very little protection in those days from the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, the man who is Taoiseach and the Head of the Government to-day. He said then:—

"When we were involved in civil war... I for one, when the flag of the Republic was run up against an Executive,... stood by the flag of the Republic and I will do it again."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator is a liar, a Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this

On a point of order. This is a deliberately provocative attitude the Senator is adopting.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator is a liar.

Comment on this

Senator Lenihan was not alive either at the time, so he might as well sit down.

Comment on this

I happen to be a lawyer——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must relate his remarks to the Bill and speak through the Chair.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must relate his speech to the Bill and speak through the Chair. To other Senators, I want to say that I cannot help Senators making provocative speeches and it is not my function to control the style of a Senator's remarks.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Two and a half hours!

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

So long as the Senator is in order, my responsibility is to see that he has the protection of the Chair in making his speech. If I consider Senator L'Estrange out of order I shall so inform the Senator and the House.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Senator to call another Senator a liar?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I did not hear it.

Comment on this

I heard it twice.

Comment on this

Who called him a liar?

Comment on this

If P.R. is abolished Sinn Féin, the I.R.A. and others may be driven underground and they may be inclined to adopt the attitude the Taoiseach adopted in 1929. Remember, it was 1929. It was not away back in the days when he was a wild revolutionary boy. In 1929 he was the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. The young people in Sinn Féin to-day are imbued with the same ideals and if we take away the safety valve of P.R. and deprive them of their right of coming into Dáil Éireann they may go underground; they may take up the gun and stand by the flag of the Republic, as the Taoiseach stated he had done and was prepared, in 1929, to do again. If he was prepared to do so again in 1929, one cannot blame the young people to-day doing in 1959 what the Taoiseach was prepared to do in 1929. He was a mature man then.

He was questioned about the authority of Dáil Éireann to speak for the people and he made this astounding statement — at least it is astounding to me — at column 1398 of Volume 28 of the Official Report:—

"We are asked to state clearly what our attitude to this House is. I have on more than one occasion said exactly what our attitude was. I still hold that our right to be regarded as the legitimate Government of the country is faulty, that this House itself is faulty."

Does he still think it is faulty?

Unless the Taoiseach is prepared to come in here now and withdraw those words, these young people are entitled to say to the Taoiseach: "This House is faulty and, if the National Assembly is faulty, have we not a perfect right to take up arms against a faulty Government and a Government that is not in order?" Surely, those arguments can be used to-day by the young people if we take from them the right which they have at the present time under P.R. and which a wise and good Government gave them in the Constitution of 1922 and for which we, the successors of that good Government, are prepared to fight at the present time.

Fianna Fáil have a very healthy majority in the Dáil. I think they have a majority of ten or 12. Why cannot they get on with their plan for the country? They told us they had a plan. We have 85,000 unemployed at the moment.

Comment on this

That is wrong.

Comment on this

84,000 and some odd hundreds. I notice Senator Mullins is keeping those behind him from heckling me.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not want a debate now on a point of order.

Comment on this

100,000 people emigrated in the last two years.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Read this month's National Observer.

Comment on this

I do not need this month's National Observer, or anything else. That is a well-known fact in relation to both unemployment and emigration. I told the House earlier —Senator Mullins was not here—about the Secretary of the Fianna Fáil Party who stated at a meeting in Longford three weeks ago that he never knew such poverty to exist; in six houses that he visited, an average of two out of three had emigrated in the last two or three years. That was not my experience. That was the experience of the Secretary of the Fianna Fáil Party. It would be much better if the Government tried to do something about these problems rather than introduce a Bill dealing with our electoral system.

Senator Lenihan dealt at length to-day with a statement that appeared in the Irish Times. We all know we were told we would have a £100,000,000 plan three years ago. It has been put into cold storage. Of course, we shall hear a great deal about these plans in the next six or eight months. It would be much better for the country if the Government would get down to doing the work they were elected to do — reducing the cost of living, providing employment, ending emigration and making credit available.

In 1919 and in 1927 the Taoiseach was in favour of P.R. In 1937 he enshrined it in the Constitution. He comes along now and tells us it is wrong. We are asked now to accept the recommendations of a man who says that the system he favoured in 1919, 1927 and 1937 is wrong. There is no denying the wheel has come full circle as far as the Taoiseach is concerned.

This is a revolutionary proposal which may well have very serious repercussions on the political system and on the people as a whole, repercussions which none of us can foresee now. We are taking a leap in the dark. I believe we should retain the system we have, the system which, as the Taoiseach himself said, has worked well, which the Tánaiste told us has worked well and which even the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, told us in 1953 had worked well; the Minister for Health said that the Irish people have P.R. and they should not let anybody take it from them. I appeal to the people now not to let anybody take it from them and not to let anybody impose on them the British or the Six-County system of election. The only solace the Taoiseach and his Government can offer to our suffering people to-day is to tell them to forget their troubles: "You are all right. We will give you this referendum instead of the reforms we promised you." That is how Fianna Fáil are "getting cracking".

I am entitled to discuss this Bill because people fought for the rights of freedom and free speech in Dáil Éireann and in this House. There has been some criticism, and Senator Lenihan referred to obstructionist tactics and one thing and another, but we are entitled to debate the Bill here and let the people know what exactly they are voting on. Fianna Fáil would like to keep them in the dark, rush them into the polling booths and get them to vote "Yes". We appeal to them on this question to vote "No". No better example can be quoted than Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien who was nominated by the Taoiseach, and who stated that when she goes into the polling booth, she will vote "No" and that she advises and has advised the people to vote "No". I know she was in an awkward position and she has said that she will vote for the Bill in the Seanad but will advise the people to vote against it.

We are being asked to pass this Bill on the advice of the Taoiseach. I ask the people not to take his advice or his judgment because he has been consistently wrong over the past 40 years. His own words in this House and in the Dáil have proved that he has been consistently wrong. He was wrong in the past when he refused to enter Parliament and said he would never enter it, but entered afterwards. Was he right when he said he would not take the oath and then took it? Was he wrong when he made the promises of 1932, about derating and so on, and did not keep them? Was he wrong when he said he would abolish the Seanad and was he right when he set it up again? Was he right when he said that the office of President of this little country was costing too much, that we were not like the British Empire and could not afford it and that we should abolish it? If he was right then, is he right now when he seeks the office of President for himself?

Was he right in 1951 and 1954 when he promised to maintain the food subsidies and reduce the cost of living? If he was right when he promised to maintain the subsidies and reduce the cost of living, surely he could not be right when he did away with the subsidies and raised the cost of living by over 30 points, as he did in two Budgets? Was he right — I claim that no man in a Christian country could be right—to advise his Minister for External Affairs to vote for a discussion on the admission of Red China into the United Nations?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is not in order; it is outside this Bill.

Comment on this

I want to claim, Sir——

Comment on this

Considering he has all the muck, let him throw the remainder.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Let him keep the brains trust going.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator L'Estrange.

Comment on this

I claim that a man who has been consistently wrong for 40 years, who has made all these statements in the past, and who got into power because he made these statements, a man who told us, as I said before, that P.R. was right on four occasions and then, on the fifth occasion, tells us he was wrong four times out of five, is as wrong now as he was in the past, and I appeal to the Irish people, when they come to vote on this question, to vote "No".

Comment on this

When I did not get in to speak about two hours ago, I thought I would not get in to-night.

Comment on this

The Senator is in now and he is welcome.

Comment on this

During this debate, there seems to have been an idea that P.R. gives every man one vote and an equal vote. In the course of her remarks, Senator Miss Davidson the other night quoted an extract from the Daily Mail Yearbook in support of her statement in which is stated “To the now well established usage of ‘one man, one vote’ is added the rider ‘one vote, one value’.”

I should like to examine for a moment what actually happens under P.R. and to see whether or not that works out. I wonder do all Senators realise that under P.R. as we have it here, no elector who votes for a man who is elected on the second or subsequent counts, ever gets his second or subsequent preferences counted. The same applies to the runner up, if it happens to work out that there is a runner-up. If a man is elected on the first count with a surplus the voter will have his second vote counted. His vote will count only for a fraction in any event, but his paper may not be used beyond his second vote.

On the other hand, some people vote for a freakish candidate and their papers may be used each time counting for a full vote even as far as the tenth or twelfth vote. I myself have been at the counting of the votes in the old North Dublin days where we counted as far as 17. Then again on the transfer of a surplus, the vote is only valued for a fraction. As I have said, on an elimination, it is valued as a full vote. Again at the transfer the papers that are counted are taken at random and a man voting for a candidate who is elected on the first count is not sure that his paper will travel on. His may be one of those left in the bundle after it is counted for the second time to make up the quota for the man who has been elected.

In other words, the more freakish the candidate a man picks to give his No. 1 vote to, the more votes that elector gets, whereas a man who may vote for a popular or a fairly popular candidate gets only his first vote and does not get his second or subsequent vote into circulation. In view of that, I wonder how anyone can say: "One vote, one value; one man, one vote". The whole system is loaded so heavily against majorities that it is actually, to my mind, desperately unfair.

I happen to have held that view for 40 years. I happen to be one who was trained under some P.R. representatives in 1919 to act as an official counter in the first P.R. election here. Since I understood this system — and I learned it then — I have held those views. It is not a question with me of this thing coming up now because the Taoiseach says it. I am very glad to have the opportunity of recording my vote for this because these have been my personal views on it.

I wonder do the people who talk about injustices to minorities understand what has been happening. Do they understand that at least the straight system gives every elector an equal vote? Whatever faults it may have, it has not got the fault whereby one man gets one vote and another may get ten or even more, if you have bigger constituencies. I, for this reason, welcome the Bill. There are other reasons which I shall deal with later, but I think that, in itself, is enough to condemn it as grossly unfair.

I do not see why any minority should be allowed ten or 12 votes, while the man who may vote for the popular candidate has only one. It is through those means that minorities get small representation. If they are only very small minorities and by being able to get that sort of help as against the man who supports the majority Party, they are able to get a few people elected for a particular point of view. Even in relation to our own Parliament and as it appears in relation to other Parliaments, in a number of cases some of these people seem to forget their duty to the country altogether and simply set out to force the point of view of the section of the people they claim to represent. Nothing else seems to matter because P.R. in every country, in the course of time, leads to a multiplicity of Parties.

We have been asked by some of the people here where is the multiplicity of Parties. Actually, as the Minister for Defence said in the Dáil, we had 21 since 1948. All were not able to get representation and the multiplicity of Parties beyond what we have has not developed. That is due to Fianna Fáil, the largest Party, refusing to coalesce. We gave the people an opportunity of having an alternative. If Fianna Fáil, despite all the urging to join even a national Government, had succumbed to that demand, I would say that by now we would have a multiplicity of Parties and we would definitely have arrived at a difficulty in forming a Government.

In my view the primary function of an election is the formation of a Government. I hold that is far more important than giving equal representation to every small number of people who get together in the country and think they have a right to be in the Government. It works out, when you get those coalitions of a number of Parties, that the smallest Party can hold up the Government.

We have seen other States being left without a Government for as long as four months. We have seen where they have actually arrived at dictatorships. Hitler came to office and power purely and simply through the failure of the Parties elected under P.R. in Germany to form a Government. Do we want that sort of thing to develop here? We have been lucky up to the present, because, as I have stated, Fianna Fáil have refused to coalesce and have been the largest Party.

That position may not continue. Nobody knows what the future will bring, but judging by the history of every other State that we know of in Europe, working through some system of P.R., we will definitely reach the stage of a multiplicity of Parties in a Coalition Government which will be subject to all the ills that have developed in those various States. Can we afford it? Can we afford to have a Government the members of which are pulling against one another internally and not able to give the leadership that is necessary to a developing State? Particularly at the present time, when the Free Trade Area is threatening, are we going to be able to compete and develop in such circumstances?

We have heard talk about this Bill not helping the widows and orphans and the unemployed. What way have we of doing better for them unless we develop? There is nobody in the Dáil or the Seanad who would not like to do better for those people, as far as our resources permit. If we do develop, I say — I do not care what Government are in power — that one of the first things they would do would be to help, if they could do it.

We have it thrown at us by Labour that they do not see how this will happen. It certainly will happen because it will avoid the sort of friction and the ills which follow from coalition government. It will at least give the country a chance of having stable government — not necessarily one with a huge majority. I do not think that Fianna Fáil will get under this system anything like the figures that have been mentioned, when the next election comes along. I doubt if it would do any better than it has done in the last election or even in some of the earlier elections. It does not necessarily follow that it will be a huge overall majority at all. One would not have to go very far in arithmetic at school to realise how wrong are some of the calculations made here.

It has been stated that we are anti-democratic in trying to put this Bill through. It is beyond my comprehension to see how one could be anti-democratic, when one is putting the matter to the people to decide by free vote. My knowledge of democracy and my understanding of the meaning of the word makes nonsense of that argument. When the people are to have the last say in the matter, when it is being put to them to decide it finally by a free vote, I cannot see how it can be said that this is anti-democratic.

I wonder why none of the Opposition, in any of the speeches I have heard, have faced up to the results which have happened in practically every country in Europe that has had P.R. Even those which have been successful under it are considering changing it now. Apparently, they have their own reasons. Fianna Fáil as a Party has no reason whatever to quarrel with P.R., as far as results go. If we were thinking just on those lines, I do not see why we should alter it at all. We have been the largest Party for a very long number of years.

Comment on this

We put you out twice.

Comment on this

Even when things went blackest against us in 1948, we were still the largest Party. We have had the reins of Government for much the biggest part of the period. From that point of view, as a Party there is no reason at all why we should quarrel with P.R. The reason I am opposed to it, and I believe it is the reason of everybody in the Party, is the results which have followed it in other countries. I cannot see what would prevent that happening here, as Parties develop as they will certainly develop under P.R.

I think it was Senator Stanford who expressed concern about what we were going to give to the young people coming along after us. I, for one, should not like to leave a legacy to the young people coming after me as a result of which they would have to face some of the things people have had to face in Europe, that they have even now in Italy, and that they have had in four countries in the last few months. I should not like to leave that sort of legacy to the young people, when we can take steps which will reasonably prevent it, judging by the experience in other countries.

Nobody is attempting to stop anybody from going up for election. After all, it is not Fianna Fáil which prevents anybody from getting a vote; it is the people. If a man can get the vote he will be elected, no matter what he stands for. Every man has got an equal chance of getting a vote. No matter what his label is, he is going to get through if the people want him to do so. I wonder why the Opposition do not face up to that? So far, nobody on the other side has attempted to refute that argument.

Judging by the results in other countries, democracy has failed under P.R. For that reason, the best system we can see is that of the old straight vote, because the countries which use it have been able to change their Governments when the people thought it was necessary to do so. They have been able to carry on a stable economy and they have avoided all those risks and losses which have occurred in other countries through lack of a proper Government. Unfortunately, instead of hearing about a vital question like that, we have heard the same type of propaganda, and false propaganda at that, used against the Constitution, the Constitution which is now approved, accepted and joyfully hailed by everybody.

Comment on this

And now being disembowelled. That is a fact.

Comment on this

I hope we will not have a repetition of that. I hope we have grown up in that respect. We remember all the things said then. Some of the things said about this have been just as bad. For instance, Senator Sheehy Skeffington said there is no guarantee of a very large majority under the straight vote system and that on a few occasions in England there were not large majorities; but then he went on, as reported in Volume 50, column 465 of the Seanad Debates:—

"One of the major reasons for asking for the abolition of P.R. falls to the ground if you admit that."

Now, I do not for a minute admit it. I do not know of anybody in the Fianna Fáil Party who was present at the meetings to discuss it and who wants to put this through because of the big majority which will come to Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil is quite confident in itself that it can hold its own under any system. It has been almost too sickening to listen to the pessimism of some of those on the other side about their chances under this. It is nothing like that that has put Fianna Fáil in its present position. That is due to its confidence in itself, because it has its programme and because it gets down to work on it.

Fianna Fáil can always take its chance and take its beatings if necessary, and will be able to do it in the future, with the new people coming on, owing to the way they are being trained. Fianna Fáil are not doing this in order to get a large majority. It is done because we do not want to leave the legacy I spoke of to the people who will come after us. There certainly will be changes of Government and we want to see, for the sake of the country, no matter what Government is in power, that there always will be an Opposition to take over if necessary so that the interests of the country will not suffer, so that if the people think one Government is going wrong they will have an alternative Government to which they can hand over control.

We have been asked why the present time has been chosen to bring in a measure such as this. The reason is that we have now an overall majority, that the time is normal, that it is the first time which could be called normal when we had an overall majority. This measure would never be brought in by a Coalition Government. It is clear from the way the Parties which support a Coalition Government have spoken about this Bill, that it would not have a chance of a snowball in hell of getting a reading under a Coalition Government. This is the first opportunity there has been. We heard a lot about 1937 and we have been asked why it was not done then. This is the first opportunity since 1937 that there has been to bring in a measure like this. For my part, I am very glad that the Government have seized that opportunity. I hope that the people will be wise enough to adopt this change in the Constitution. I think they have grown up in wisdom, particularly after their experience of the Coalitions which were bad enough for this country but which, I will admit, were not as bad as what happened in other countries. I hope that the people will realise what we are trying to save them from.

The real reason for the Bill is the results that have developed under P.R. in other countries. We are trying to avoid having that happen here. There is also the urgent necessity for development in view of the emergence of the European Free Trade Area, and other competition. We want to build up this country in the way in which the patriots who gave their lives for it sought to see it built up. Those are the reasons for this Bill and if anybody could show us how to avoid all the difficulties that occurred with P.R. in other countries I am sure we would be open to reason.

Comment on this

In speaking as one of the Independent representatives in the Seanad, I am very conscious of the heavy burden that falls on us Independents, and of the many unfair charges to which we leave ourselves open in trying to perform our task. My first opposition to this measure comes from the fact that the people are not told what they are voting on because the Bill seeks to institute something as sacred as a change in our Constitution, without having the necessary commission to give a factual report on what is happening, to give us the proper setting of the history of Europe and not the pocket-book edition that ascribes every failing in Europe to P.R.

What we want are facts and, up and down the country, I have met intelligent people who are crying out for facts. They have not got them in this debate and I do not think that the Dáil or Seanad are the proper bodies to give the necessary, non-Party, impartial, scientific investigation of the issues at stake. That has not been done. It should be done here and, until it is done, we are asking the plain ordinary people of this country to vote on something of which, as is evident from the speeches which members of this House and the other House have made, they have but a very hazy recollection.

Why did these various ills arise in Europe? That is something that is above politics and that bears impartial investigation. Let us know of the various Governments that have functioned in various European countries. Let us have the opinions of the scholars concerned on the reasons for the downfall of those countries. All that is lacking at present and I hold it is grossly unfair to the people of this country to face them with a task, without giving them the necessary information. I can claim myself to be in a very happy position in that fortunately I am a young man, thank God. I was not party to all the bitterness that has come into this country. Our generation, thank God, has been spared that, but we are looking for something more in the future. We regard this as our country, just as the elder statesmen, the elder members of the Dáil and Seanad, regarded this country in 1918 and 1921. You elder members wanted a thing for yourselves. You wanted to get facts and figures. You did not want to be tied up with the Parnellite split and all the other animosities that had crept into our effort to get self government in the 30, 40, 50 years preceding 1916. That is what we, the younger generation, are asking to-day.

I have been privileged to know many of the branches, many of the officers of our splendid rural organisations. I have been privileged to make some little contribution to their advancements, I hope, by travelling, very often at night, 40, 50, 60 miles — I did it twice in the past week — to give those people factual accounts, at least facts as they appeared to me as a scientist, and material put down in such a manner that any scientist can investigate and find any flaws in the arguments, if there are any. That, after all, is the only approach to progress. It is the scientific approach. It is the scientific method about which we hear so much to-day, and our future depends on that. What have we got? We have got our excellent rural organisations completely disgusted with Party politics in this country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think that is in issue.

Comment on this

The issue, as I see it, is the question of the ills of this country being cured by altering our system of election, and the referendum based on that. I am just developing the case that the people need information and that information can be supplied to them only by a proper commission. When we have that done, then we can look forward with pleasure and with confidence to the judgment of the people as a whole. But remember, changing the Constitution, as stated by Senator O'Brien, is one of the most delicate and one of the most sacred tasks any country can undertake, because, if we can change the Constitution without a commission, without impartial report, if we can change it merely by a simple majority of the population at any one time, it can be turned into an issue in Party politics.

We now have the Government advocating this. Will it then give rise to other combinations in future advocating something different? Therefore, I am afraid we are not giving the Constitution the protection we should give it and not treating it as the sacred instrument that it is. When the Constitution was enacted in 1922, it was necessary to have a two-thirds majority to change it. Now I see that provision, that very safe provision, has been altered to a simple majority. I think that is very dangerous, especially at the present time, when an effort is made to treat this issue as a case simply against coalition government. It is brought in close to our two recent Coalition Governments, and is close up to the very difficult international situations they encountered.

I for one hold and I applaud the sentiments expressed by Senator Murphy, as Leader of the Labour Party, when he paid tribute to the work done by all Parties, in all Governments, in their efforts to establish the independence of this country. That is the spirit we need at present, and it is the only spirit that will ensure that our people can have confidence in the protection afforded them by our Constitution, and can develop the country in the way that our generation wishes.

Cuireadh an diospóireacht ar ath-ló.

Comment on this