An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–196 of 403. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
Last evening I opened with just a few brief remarks on the fact that no factual information has been placed before the voters to enable them to make a decision on this very fundamental issue that confronts us. Personally, I have no axe to grind in this matter. Neither has any of my fellow Senators from the universities. Surely it gives rise to thought that the five of us who have spoken, endeavouring to live up to the academic traditions of universities, endeavouring to live up to the tradition of scientific inquiry and impartial presentation of results, are unanimous in this issue? It is not I think that we are unanimous on the virtues of P.R. or on the case against the straight vote but that we are unanimous in the view that enough information is not available to enable the electors to make a decision on this question.
We ourselves feel we are only scratching the surface. I have spoken about this matter with quite a few of my fellow-members. We have spent time endeavouring to go through the systems in other countries, endeavouring to see the pros and cons. We are only beginning. We feel it is absolutely vital that this important issue of changing the Constitution should be approached on a non-Party and impartial basis. Nothing can establish that more than to have before us a White Paper of 40 to 50 or maybe 100 pages giving a whole factual analysis of systems in other countries and making reasonable predictions as to how changes here might react on our system.
We have made some excellent beginnings. We have got the Capital Investment Advisory Committee which has done excellent work. We have all accepted their recommendations in the non-Party and impartial spirit in which they have been given. I might refer to the recent White Paper by the Government. My first reaction on reading it through was that it was more political window-dressing and that we had heard all that before—until I got Mr. Whitaker's excellent Survey on Economic Development. Then the whole thing took on a completely new outlook. Here were the facts and figures that led up to the recommendation in that excellent book. Besides, I and everybody else reading it had confidence in the objectivity of the man who produced that work and the machinery behind the production of the work.
That, I submit, is what we need here and until it comes I feel that, far from being criticised for trying to deny voters their rights, we, the independent Senators here, should be praised for standing for the rights of voters, that is, the rights of voters to know intelligently and to be told impartially where they are going and where they are being led and to ensure that they are not simply being led by catch cries about a Coalition Centre Party or a Coalition inter-Party or being told that Hitler did this and Mussolini did something else. In this scientific day and age, our people demand something better. The young men of Ireland demand it—the young men on whom the future rests and, please God, if they do not get what they demand they will at least observe the well-known principle in liturgy. As a priest said to me recently: "In liturgy, if you do not know where you are going then stay where you are."
I want to proceed briefly to illustrate some of the many ideas and the many things which it is necessary to ascertain. I have some tentative facts here; I am not satisfied completely with them but they show that this question is a far bigger one than its treatment by many speakers would suggest. You just cannot reduce it down to the position that one is right and the other is wrong. As seen by all thinkers on the subject there are two functions in an election. One is to ensure a Government that can carry on; the other is to ensure representation. There is quite a conflict as to which deserves the most emphasis. It is claimed that the straight vote will ensure a stronger form of Government, exaggerating majorities. To that extent, if that claim is correct, where a country needs absolutely resolute Government, because of a disturbed condition, perhaps the straight vote has quite a bit on its side. On the other hand, P.R. gives all reasonable shades of opinion a chance of expression in Parliament so that Parliament can bring the very best ideas to bear on its problems and as far as possible strive for what is the wish of the majority.
That is the problem of representation and I think here we have a vital factor that seems to have been missed —at least I have not seen it referred to up to now, namely, that we are calling for two Parties, a Government and an Opposition who can take over when we get tired of the Government. I think there is nearly agreement on that on all sides — to have at least a Government and an alternative Government. In other countries the lines of division are sharper than here. In France, Italy and so on, very often the issue is clerical or anti-clerical, a question of, "shall we banish religion from the schools or not; shall we drive out the religious schools?" Thank God we have not got those issues here. We are all united on that. We all have the Christian tradition and the Christian outlook on such matters.
Other countries are divided on the question as to whether they shall have Socialism or not. Again, thank God, we have been spared a great deal of that. In addition, you would find other points of diversion such as the pros and cons of monarchy, and all the rest but here we found the point of division in the civil war—the question of which side you were on. That has acted for a number of years to give us two groups and in the language of students of politics it polarises the electorate, draws them to two poles. The young Ireland of to-day is not, however, going to have such out-dated polarisation. Young Ireland recognises that the civil war was an unfortunate and unhappy period of our existence and that the best we can do is draw a veil over it and proceed on to the future.
We cannot use the civil war as a means of polarisation of Parties but this issue has blown up — Coalition or single-Party Government. You have had the Taoiseach's violent denunciation of the idea of Coalition Government; yet the electorate has seen fit to replace one by the other. You had a single-Party Government up to 1948; inter-Party, or Coalition Govment, from 1948 to 1951; back again to the single-Party Government, on to the Coalition and back again to single-Party Government. Would it not be a happy day for this country if you could polarise the political thinking of this country for the next 20 years in that way? By all means let Fianna Fáil hold on to their conception of single-Party Government — and they do a great deal of good for the country by that—but equally let them recognise that Coalition, or inter-Party Government, is quite an alternative type of Government and forms the other pole of our electoral systems. If we do that we may get what we are seeking, something that will polarise our electorate and give us stability and a reasonable amount of continuity in our electoral systems.
I want to establish now the case that there are many things that we do not know about systems in other countries. Many false analogies that have come into the debate call for an impartial study. To begin with I shall take this question of P.R. Listening to many of the speeches here, and reading many of the speeches in the other House, one could be pardoned for concluding that the idea of proportion, and P.R., had escaped many of the members. In fact, there are no fewer than 300 variations of P.R. We in our present system are nearer to the majority form of government than we are to the true ideal of P.R.
P.R. springs from the mathematical idea of giving all groups a say in the government, or at least getting their voices heard in Parliament. The earlier advocates of this measure were idealists. They wanted to ensure that no group whatsoever was excluded. That meant that, in very many cases, the country as a whole was treated as one single constituency so that any candidate in this country, if elections were held on that basis, who could command around 1 per cent. of the vote could be elected to Parliament. That system is at present in operation in Holland and in Israel, to which I shall come back later. We are far from that here with our preponderance of three-seat constituencies. After all, in a three-seat constituency the quota is one quarter, or 25 per cent. of the vote. To get elected you must get 25 per cent. of the vote in a fair-sized region. Certainly you are no longer representing a weak minority when you get that. In fact, you have quite a sizable following in your locality.
I want now to take the various countries and make just a few remarks on each. I might mention that that excellent study was completed less than two years ago in the University of London by a distinguished student of University College, Cork, Dr. Cornelius O'Leary. He did an excellent study of electoral systems and on it he was rewarded with the highest honour the university could confer. It followed from the previous work of Professor James Hogan on election and representation. I think it is almost essential for anybody to discuss this intelligently to have at least read and digested Professor Hogan's book and, if possible, to have read Dr. O'Leary's excellent work. It is the only way that one can see the issues that are at stake.
The country to introduce P.R. first was Belgium, in 1899. It was followed by Sweden in 1907, by Denmark in 1915 and Holland in 1917. Germany and Italy followed in 1919, and so on. It is of comparatively recent growth. It came at the same time as two other distinct happenings, universal suffrage and the rise of Socialism, the days of Labour banding together to advance its rights. We come then to study the history of Europe at that period without making full allowance for those two factors. The opening of the franchise, in fact, is one of the most unpredictable of all things in a country, because you may have a large number who had been deprived of the vote in many cases, or who were illiterate, suddenly having this weapon of recording their votes thrust into their hands. How would they use it? It takes years to develop political sense and it is no wonder that there have been erratic happenings in the working of the system.
Let us take the first-mentioned country, Belguim. Prior to 1899, Belgium operated the usual type of majority system. It was a list system and they had a second ballot which gave a chance for those at the bottom of the poll to drop out, thereby releasing the voters to transfer their votes to some other candidate more likely to be elected. That, after all, is the forerunner of the transferable vote in P.R. In fact, I had a rather interesting session with a strong exponent of the majority system recently. I discussed with him this election of candidates at a Party convention where the object is to select three candidates from, say, six in the field. He was quite adamant that it was done by straight voting. "What do you do?" I asked? "We vote, and then we eliminate the sixth man and vote-again.""Yes," I said, "and then you eliminate the fifth man?""Yes," he replied, "and we vote again." What is that but the transferable vote you have in P.R., except that you do not go back to the voter? You simply ask-him the question: "If your first choice is to be eliminated, what will we do with your vote?" And he tells you there and then what to do with his vote. What is the difference between that and the system of election used at Party conventions? I take it that you have such a system in the national Party executives and in the county councils, as the system by which you select rate collectors and make any other appointments that still remain with the county councils.
To go on — Belgium had two Parties, Catholics and Liberals. These continued after P.R., except for the rise of a Socialist Party which would have come in any case. These three Parties continued right through to 1918 when the Catholics and Liberals combined. After the First World War, the Catholic Party lost its majority and never regained it, but it has continued ever since in coalitions. There have been coalitions of the three major Parties, the Catholics, Liberals and Socialists, or else coalitions of two of the major Parties, usually Catholics and Liberals. By all accounts, Belgium has prospered and has got on quite well.
The test of government is not the power of the Taoiseach or the Prime Minister; it is the development in the country itself. It is the increase in its population, the development of its resources, the place it holds in the world; and who are we to criticise countries like Belgium, Holland, Denmark or Norway? They have done what we could not do. They have increased their population; they have been able to provide bread and work for anyone who wished to stay in his native country, something which we, after 30 years, have not been able to do. Of course, anyone experienced in government—in fact, anybody in any committee — would like to get his own way all the time and would like to be able to count on an absolute majority but "by their fruits you shall know them." That is the only way we can judge how a Government will carry on in the future. Let us take the yardsticks of unemployment, emigration and education. Let us compare the advance in education in Belgium and Holland with what we have done in 30 years. We subscribe to the fact that education is the key to development of a modern nation; yet we can get £1,000,000 at the drop of a hat for the extension of the runways at Shannon Airport, while we cannot get an extra £1,000 a year to provide adult education for the young farmers of Munster. That is our progress and that is what we have got with majority government.
I am just making the point that we must be careful; we can judge Governments only by their fruits and by their impact on the country as a whole and, taken by those standards, Belgium has achieved considerable success. Since pre-war — and pre-war the issue was the same — there are three Parties in Belgium and the Communist Party has not made any significant advance there.
We go on to Scandinavia, Norway, Sweden and Denmark and the main outstanding feature there has been the gradual rise of Socialism. It has largely been tempered by coalitions. Perhaps, that has been very distasteful to the Socialists as a group. They would like to be able to push ahead with all their nationalisation and other Socialist acts. They have been held back by P.R. and Western Europe may thank God for having done that for us, because the Socialism of to-day is much more conservative and staid than the Socialism of 20 or 30 years ago. They see now that nationalisation by itself is not a panacea and they have been tempered by the other Parties in Europe. If we ever have a Socialist Government here, although I, for one, have no desire whatever to see it, I pray it will have to spend many years in apprenticeship in coalitions before it ever emerges as an overall majority Government, and I think everybody here who is interested in the welfare of the country will pray with me in that.
In Sweden the rise of the Socialist Party was through coalition with the Agrarian Party in the 1930's, but even then, when the Socialist Party attained an overall majority, it continued in coalition with the Agrarian Party, proving that it was in no way dissatisfied with the results of the previous years. It was mentioned here quite a lot that they are thinking about changing their system in Sweden. In fact they did change it in 1952. They took the first essential step to change; they established an impartial, unbiassed commission to review the whole question, and it was only on the results of that report that they acted. They were worried. What were they worried about? They were worried about the fact that they thought P.R., as they had it with relatively small constituencies, was rather unfair to the smaller Parties, that the quotas were being set too high and that the smaller Parties were not getting sufficient representation. The report suggested going more proportional, so that smaller Parties could get better representation. When the report was furnished Parliament did not go the whole way with it but went part of the way. They reduced the quotas and arranged for the utilisation of surpluses. They also arranged for preferential voting within the Party list.
That is really an outstanding thing. We have that type of preferential voting here in our multiple-member constituencies. The Party puts up three members and the electorate proceed to elect maybe one, maybe two from the Party list. That was their reform in 1952. We understand they have another commission sitting at present — a proper, logical, scientific, rational approach — and we shall see the outcome of that, too. However, one thing you can certainly bet is that it is not a question of jumping from a fair measure of P.R. to the straight majority in single-member constituencies.
We go on to Norway. P.R. was first introduced around 1917 and from then until 1927 some of the Parties were split and you got several Parties in that period. The split healed in 1927 and since then Socialism has increased in Norway so that it has had a hand in most Norwegian Governments and it actually attained a majority representation of 85 seats out of 152 in 1949, and that with 48 per cent. of the electorate.
We have heard a great deal about Denmark as a wonderful example to us in agriculture, and rightly so. For years we have heard about the Danish production figures. We have heard about the Danish advisory service but, above all, we have heard about the Danish co-operative movement and the fact that the Danish Government knows exactly where to draw the line, that it knows what to leave to the people to do for themselves. Its function is, you might say, to encourage the people to do the job for themselves. Their co-operatives have done that and I need not give fact or figure to prove their tremendous success in that. Yet Denmark has four nation-wide Parties; it has since 1918 had P.R. and has been ruled by various types of Coalition Governments since then and, judged by their performance, highly successful Governments. I only wish our Governments since 1918 could match the record of the Danish Governments since then.
To make things more extreme, in Denmark so anxious are they for representation, that they allot 44 additional seats to those that failed to get representation in the elections. In other words they have a far more extreme form of P.R. than we have here to-day and yet they are perfectly happy with it. The secret of their success is that every parliamentarian in Denmark is a Dane first. He is for the welfare of his country and he assumes that the other members, whatever Party they are in, are actuated by the best motives for the welfare of the country. They agree on ends, ends for the prosperity and welfare of Denmark and its people. They differ in means and that should be our approach, too.
Speaking of coalitions themselves, the greatest coalition in the whole country is the Civil Service and it is doing a very good job. You have the various Departments all trying to get their own schemes through, trying to get money for their own projects, and the Department of Finance is like the Taoiseach sitting in the centre coordinating them and getting them to compromise. The word "compromise" is used as if it were an intrinsically evil word whereas the whole business of life and living here is one of compromise.
Comment on this
Within the family, the local parish council, anywhere you go, and rightly so. We do not want the bully at any level, whether it is in the family, the town council or in the university council. We are coalitions there and we compromise, and I think it is the best possible form of working at any level in the life of the community.
Now we come to Holland which has the most extreme form of P.R. The country is one single constituency so that, if anything, that is asking for trouble. Added to that is the fact that the country is organised quite a bit on sectarian lines. You have the Catholic Party, the Protestant Party, the Catholic Trade Union, the Protestant Trade Union, and so on. If any country was set to go to pieces, you might say it was Holland. Yet, judged by their production and rise in population, they have been the most successful country in Europe over the past 25 years.
No doubt, the leader of the Catholic Party there would love to have an overall majority. But would the rest of the citizens in the country like that? And if the pendulum swung the other way and if the leader of the Protestant Party had an overall majority, would the Catholics like that? In such a situation, the healthiest possible thing is compromise and coalition government. The Dutch have worked out an excellent form of coalition based on what looks like the unpromising foundation of sectarian Parties. They have drawn these groups closer together by emphasising all they have in common, and starting from that as a point of departure. I only wish we could have a little more of that realisation between our various groups here. Take the Catholic and non-Catholic groups in our community. Why not let us concentrate in the future on all we have in common? In any other country, we would be the closest allies, due to what we have in common. Let us not exaggerate differences, but let us rather agree to respect those differences and to emphasise the great amount we have in common.
These are countries that began with their P.R. after the First World War. But most revealing of all is the State of Israel, founded in 1947. If any State was founded to a blueprint, it is Israel. More thought and effort were put into the founding of that State than any other, because the people were coming together from various parts of the world to have what they had looked for for centuries — a homeland. They had lived in many countries, suffering in some and prospering in others, under various forms of government. We can take it that they knew exactly from first hand experience what the different forms of government meant and what they could accomplish.
What form of government did Israel take in 1947? They took the form that any enthusiastic young people with confidence and hope in the future would take. They took the most extreme form of P.R. The whole country is one single constituency, so that you get all shades and types of opinion in that Parliament. I have seen recently a film showing the enormous strides forward that Israel has made in the past ten years. I doubt if we can compare with what they have done in that period. I do say that their form is the most extreme form. Perhaps, with the passage of years, they will modify it and find they will have to exclude minorities of, say, 1, 2 or 3 per cent. They may even get as far as we have got at present and exclude minorities up to 20 per cent., as we do with our four seat constituencies, or minorities up to 25 per cent., as we do with our three seat constituencies. But the fact is that, in the absence of a commission report for this country, I or any other scientist looking at the facts cannot dismiss what has happened in the latest and most carefully thought out investigation into a system of government.
In regard to P.R., we have had Germany and Italy trotted out very much. First of all, let us be fair and face the facts. Any scientist cannot possibly accept a comparison of a nation of 3,000,000 with a nation of 40,000,000 or 50,000,000, a straggling nation with all different types of peoples, a buffer between various "isms". You just cannot regiment or put straitjackets on groups like that, except the straitjacket of dictatorship. And they did that.
Go back after the First World War to the Weimar Republic in 1918. First of all, you had universal suffrage for the first time. That, in itself, was a tremendous gamble at the period. How would it go? As well as that, you had the discontent of the defeated nation in the war. All that was added together. Is it any wonder that you just could not mould such a nation into one or two Parties? Things were all right up to 1928. Then the economic crisis hit them. The Government were unable to cope with the situation which deteriorated and became worse and worse, but a few years afterwards, in the United States, you had a single Party Government trying to cope with the same situation; and did they do any better? You had bread lines and bread queues. The depths of collapse in America were even worse than in Germany.
Is it any wonder that the people in Germany turned to somebody promising? The reason Hitler came to power is relatively simple. It was not P.R. The reason given by Dr. O'Leary was "Party bossism, ageing leadership and the election of mediocrities". That is why Hitler came to power. The youth of Germany had become tired of the older generation prescribing remedies for them. On the one hand, they were behind Hitler; and on the other hand, were the military groups, the ex-soldiers.
Comment on this
Yes. That was the explosive combination. It is ridiculous to suggest that P.R. brought Hitler to power. Certainly no scientist will ever accept such a simple generalisation.
Then in Italy in 1919 you had two Parties — the Socialists who were rabid anti-clericals and the Popular Party led by Don Sturgo. To these were added, as one would expect normally in the aftermath of war, the Democrats and the Fascists. In 1921 and 1922 you had Mussolini emerging as the only strong man in the country. Now, he would have emerged whatever system they had in Italy at that period. He just could not be stopped in the chaos and aftermath of war. Remembering that we place so much reliance here on the majority vote of the people and so forth, we ought to realise that Mussolini commanded a large majority of the Italian voters right through the '20s and the '30s. There is no denying that fact and, had Mussolini played a different hand in the war, we might be taking a different view of him to-day.
With regard to Hitler, there is no denying the fact that he had the German nation behind him all through the '30s. He won support by propaganda and every other means, but the fact is he had the people behind him. For a large part of the period he was producing enough food for the people and helping to alleviate the economic crisis of the time.
Comment on this
Quite so. Senator Ó Maoláin quoted from Professor Hogan's book — quotations which, divorced from their context, might lead one to believe that Professor Hogan was anti-P.R. The quotations are convincing because Professor Hogan, approaching the problem as a scientist, analysed each system and fearlessly exposed the faults and shortcomings of each system. Naturally he was very conscious of the shortcomings in P.R. As I said before, there are 300 varieties of P.R. and I, for one, would vote to the bitter end against any attempt to extend our P.R. here; that is, to extend it and make the whole country into six, seven or eight seat constituencies. That would be a retrograde step.
Professor Hogan also analysed the straight vote system. Now, what seems to have escaped the notice of those reading his book is the fact that he actually wrote a whole chapter in it —"Conclusions". Perhaps I shall be forgiven for reading just a few of the conclusions:—
"It will be apparent from the general trend of our argument that there are strong reasons, reasons especially relevant in the case of Ireland, for seeking a solution for the problem of election and representation in a fresh compromise between P.R., and the majority system rather than reverting violently to the former."
That is what Professor Hogan wrote in 1945.
Last week I had the privilege of having a session with him and he told me that nothing that has happened since has altered his view; he would at the moment go more in the direction of the majority system; in other words, he would take the four and five seat constituencies and break them down into three seat constituencies, giving more power, if you wish, to the Party getting a majority. In the light of the last election that would increase the present Government's representation by at least five or six additional seats. Does anybody contend that, if we put another six on to the impressive tally gained by the present Government in the last election, they would not have ample power? I would go so far as to say they would have too much power and too many representatives.
Comment on this
But Professor Hogan goes further and he suggests that, having broken down the five and six seat constituencies, we might make a start and experiment with a few single seat transferable vote constituencies; but the idea of a non-transferable vote is something that is absolutely anathema to him. With gradual progress and gradual development one knows where one is going and one can make one's changes gradually. Professor Hogan says:—
"The majority system is good where a community is least homogeneous, where, like in America, you have different racial groups that need to be brought together and integrated into the community."
It has a certain effect there, but in a country like ours, a country as homogeneous as ours, we have no such problem. In many ways, in fact, we have too much uniformity.
I would recommend all Senators, before drawing conclusions from what Professor Hogan has written, to read Professor Hogan's conclusions. They are the most important part of what he has written. He says:—
"It is probable that, for example, in Ireland an outright return to the majority system would enable the present Government Party not merely to survive to a ripe old age but to go on governing even after a decline into a state of dotage. In these unhappy circumstances, there is much to be said for having in Parliament at least a few Independents who, because they have minds of their own and are free to speak them, can become the mediums for expressing unpalatable but salutary truths and opinions. However bitter in the mouths for Party leaders and however unpopular with large sections of the electorate, such plain speaking is essential to the elasticity of thought which is an indispensable condition of an alert, fearless and freely developing public opinion."
I want to analyse now some of the countries in which the straight vote system operates and to show that their conditions do not apply to us. But, remember, all the time I am trying to show that this problem is much bigger than we think it is. The Minister does not know the answer. We do not know the answer. Nobody knows the answer. We must study the systems and find out in the light of cold, scientific investigation where we are going. What do we want to do in the future? Do we want to create Parties or do we want to create majorities in the House? No. We want to develop the country; that is our problem.
I shall go on now to the English system which has been so praised here. Under the English system, I find that, in 1951, the Conservative Party polled 250,000 votes less than the Labour Party and got 25 seats more than the Labour Party, so that is an example of the straight vote system of election.
Comment on this
I may mention that these figures have been repeated very often during the debate.
Comment on this
I just want to draw a deduction which has not been drawn. So far from representing the will of the majority, the result of the 1951 election distorted it in England. In 1955, the Labour Party polled 12,400,000 votes and got 277 seats and the Conservatives polled 13,300,000 and got 345 seats. Perhaps that looks all right to us, but in applying the British system here, the real fallacy is in the number of safe seats that are to be found in England. In fact, it is estimated at present in as reliable a journal as The Economist, that 500 of the 600 seats are safe. It is that that keeps the balance in the English electoral system and not any merit of their majority vote.
The 100 seats that are not safe swing violently from one election to another and what would happen if the whole 600 seats in England could swing in the same way? Apply that to our situation here. We have no safe seats in this country. A few seats may appear to be safe, but, by and large, taking our election results over the past 15 years, we find we cannot point to any essentially safe seats. Why? Because we are not divided on any fundamental issue and that is the only type of division that will create safe seats. If we take the British system here, we face violent oscillations.
Going through the electoral results for the previous election, it is very hard to see how any Opposition candidates could be elected. I take it that it is not the wish of the Taoiseach or the wish of the Minister for External Affairs that we should have a lopsided Dáil. In fact, I think both of them would settle for the present majority as being workable, not excessive and giving plenty of Opposition views in the House. At least any democrat would settle for that. If we swing the other way, it is quite certain, on the last results, that if the Opposition got 20 seats, that is the very maximum they could hope for, because in those areas where Fianna Fáil polled less than 50 per cent., as in the Galway region and so on, the Opposition was very neatly divided between Labour, Fine Gael and the Farmers, so that even though Fianna Fáil got 48 per cent. and none of the others got anywhere near that vote, it is certain that under the non-transferable vote, such a seat would go to the majority Party, the 48 per cent. Party.
That is all very well, as the Government know. It may be all very well for their returns, but the pendulum will swing and the pendulum can swing just as easily the other way, and you could have another Government elected and 20 Fianna Fáil seats in the House. If that happens, we will find that the casualties will mainly be the outstanding men of the previous Government Party because in a single seat constituency, if there is a big man standing for one Party, usually what is done is you either concede the election or you mark him with an equally big man. Even if the Opposition fails, its turn is coming in the next election, and in the next election they will naturally see to it that they oppose the big man of the outgoing Government with a big man from their group, and unfortunately these are the people who will be missing from the Opposition in the following Dáil.
Take it another way. The incoming Government with its 100 or 120 members will be composed of people who are new to the Dáil and completely inexperienced in the government. That is a very bad thing. In fact, it was one of the major causes of the excesses that occurred in the French Revolution—the 1789 law which made outgoing members ineligible for reelection. We know what happened then when a completely new and inexperienced group tried to handle what must be regarded as one of the most delicate and ticklish of operations, that of running a Government.
While the English system, the straight vote, might help the Government Party in one election it might just as clearly and definitely obliterate them at the following election. We do not want that to happen nor does the Taoiseach or anybody else. I am convinced from my reading and from what study I can do on it that the conditions here are so dissimilar from conditions in England that it will happen here. I do not want to be dogmatic but I do feel that this is one very vital point on which a proper, impartial commission can give a very valuable opinion.
For my part I would regard even that one objection as far too grave and serious to justify a change unless I could be assured that this would not happen here. In fact, you might sum up the present position in England as being that 46 per cent. of the people are irrevocably committed to Labour; another 46 per cent. to Conservative and 2½ per cent. or 2 per cent. to Liberal, leaving a balance of 6 per cent. It is the votes of this 6 per cent. that make or unmake Governments and here we are devoting all our time to attacking the lunatic fringe and trying to exclude them from control, and the very division in England depends on the votes of that lunatic fringe, or in-between fringe, which wants to know whether the Conservatives will give them more or the Labour Party can afford to buy them better or give them more so that they will swing the vote.
As I say, that very closeness of the English system would not repeat itself here. The danger here is not in that type of oscillation but in the violent swing. In Professor Hogan's book, very convincing facts and figures are given to show that the Spanish Civil War was caused by the direct vote which brought the four Parties in and swung eventually to the Popular Front Government, but I do not wish to weary the House by quoting it.
Coming nearer home we come to the Six Counties.
Comment on this
We are discussing electoral systems and I hope I am discussing the matter in a completely impartial and scientific manner. At least I am endeavouring to do that. What I am saying will be printed in the Official Report and if anybody can produce facts to contradict what I am saying, I shall be only too pleased to get them. That, after all, should be the outlook of any scientist.
Let us take the elections to Westminster in 1955. You find that in the four Belfast constituencies you had the straight vote and the non-transferable and it worked so well that the Unionist poll totalled 127,000 votes. The Labour Party got 52,000 and the Sinn Féin or Nationalist Opposition got 18,000. The Unionist Party, of course, walked off with the four seats. Can Labour or Nationalists in Belfast tell us they consider it an equitable scheme that denies them any one of those four places in Westminster? Can we ask their advice as to whether they think what we are doing here is just or fair? The total Opposition represented 70,000 electors or 36 per cent. of the votes, yet they did not get a single seat of the four to Westminster.
Then we come to the October, 1953 elections in which in Central Belfast you had a result something like this: Independent Labour, 3,900; Unionists, 3,300; Unofficial Irish Labour, 2,400; Irish Labour, 1,400. Independent Labour was elected with 34 per cent. of the vote. Again, I could quote many other examples but I do not wish to take too much time on the matter except to quote the present distribution of Parties there, which is: Unionist, 38: Nationalists, seven; National North of Ireland Labour, four; Representative Labour, one; Independent Labour, one; and Independent Nationalist, one. Surely no one holds that that reflects the views of the people in Northern Ireland or that it represents a suitable Government for the people of Northern Ireland?
When I was a student in America after the war, I was confronted with the problem of Partition. I was asked about it. I wrote home for information and pamphlets and everything else. With great gusto I described the gerrymandering and gave figures such as I am giving now. What am I to say in future? What can any of us say? We have to withdraw all our charges.
Again, let us take the fact that at the last election there were only 21 contests and 27 seats were not contested. That is a travesty of democracy. Is that what we want here—a development where three-quarters of the country are held by safe seats?
Comment on this
Eighteen seats were contested. The total poll by the Unionist Party there was 102,000 votes out of a total of 235,000 votes. They got 45 per cent. of the vote where the contest took place and with that they walked off with 75 per cent. of the seats. You might as well have a lottery and draw a Government as to have it done by a system such as that. These are grave charges and we have got to investigate them. Are we satisfied that there is not something wrong in it?
Believe it or not but 13 Parties contested the last election there—all splintered in various directions with Labour represented by at least four groups. The Nationalists were split in all sections because the majority system there has that splintering effect and because everybody who goes up for election with you is against you. Consequently, there is no co-ordination or coming together or saying: "Vote No. 1 for Labour and vote No. 2 for the Nationalists". We have no cementing influence.
It has been said that the introduction of the straight vote did not cause much of a change in the North and that the representation in the 1929 election was not very widely different from the one that went before. That may be conceded but does anybody concede that if they had P.R. in the North since 1929 those various groups would not have been acting together and getting their representation and eventually have formed a Government? They would have split the existing Government. I think that is an absolute certainty but the longer you have the straight vote there at every election you have more and more splintering with more and more uncontested seats.
I come now to the American system which has been held up in such great detail to us. Fortunately, I had three years' experience of that system and I tried to learn a share about it. If the Government proposal were to introduce the American system here I would be wholeheartedly in favour of the straight vote, but there is no comparison between the American system and our system here because, first of all, the House of Representatives is elected every two years, so that even if you have a swing that swing cannot do any untold damage before the next election. Besides, you have safe regions in America, regions whose history goes back to the American Civil War. Their number to-day is declining but all the South is held traditionally safe for the democrats.
As well as that, the real power in America lies in the American Senate which is elected for six years, one third of the members retiring every two years. They are elected by the straight vote, but you can see quite obviously that in such a system you cannot get any violent swings. The swing you get is a composite of three swings in 1952, 1954 and 1956. Over and above all, you have the President who is elected independently by the people and he, as we have seen, can very often hold an opposite viewpoint to both the majorities in his House.
There you have your pattern of corrective and stable democracy. Again, the President draws his Cabinet not from the two existing Houses but from the country at large. In fact, Mr. Benson—he is Secretary for Agriculture—was an outstanding county agricultural officer. That is the type of men you get there. Above all, they have a highly developed committee system which is, of course, the greatest lack we have in this country.
I, for one, have been totally disillusioned by the little we contribute to-day in this Seanad. In fact, what we can do here is merely talk. The committees should function in any democratic country. I have not seen our Committee for Education, our Committee for Agriculture or our Committee for Industry. Surely those of us who are elected here are able and willing to play our part on these committees. It must be for the betterment of the nation that we have such committees and that we should play our part on them.
So much then for the American system. There is absolutely no comparison. The straight vote system there is purely incidental, but the whole process of progressive democracy can be seen in every corrective step of the way. Also, all their committees are very highly representative. They are representative both of the majority Party and the minority Party. I, for one, was appalled yesterday to hear some of the accusations made by Senator L'Estrange. I hope they are not true. I am waiting for the Senator from Clare to refute what he said about the Clare County Council.
Comment on this
I hope it is not true. If it be true, it is one further condemnation of majority rule, in any country. I hope it can be refuted.
Comment on this
And the Westmeath County Council in 1950. In 1950 Fianna Fáil were excluded from everything on the Westmeath County Council, dominated by Senator L'Estrange. That shook the Senator.
Comment on this
A commission should settle those questions. A thing cannot be true and untrue at the same time; and that is what we are being told here. Now we come to the classic example of the straight vote. That is South Africa. As shown in the May, 1958, returns in South Africa, the Nationalist Party got 103 seats; the United Party, 53; Labour, nothing; Independents, nothing; Native Representatives, three, and Cape Colony representatives, four. In a contest for 132 seats, the Nationalists got 647,000 votes and the United Party 520,000. In other words, there was only a matter of 140,000 votes between them. Actually, it is more significant because 31 of the seats were not contested. Again, it is another feature of majority government that, in the North of Ireland and in South Africa, the Government will not expose their hands; where they know they will be defeated, they will give a walk over to the Opposition.
They did that in South Africa in 31 of the seats, so that actually the contested seats there were 132 and of those the Nationalist got 103, the Opposition got 22 and others seven. It took 6,000 votes to elect a representative for the Government and it took 26,000 votes to elect one for the Opposition.
Comment on this
Yes, I shall give the reason. As stated by the Leader of the United Party, Mr. Graaf, the majority was due to ruthless exploitation of the racial situation in South Africa and to an enormous appeal to sectional sentiment.
Comment on this
It was due to the ruthless exploitation of the racial situation.
Comment on this
Again, I am making the point simply and solely as an experiment related to something that is happening and to something which we want to see analysed coolly, factually and scientifically, before the people are asked to make their choice. It seems to me that the people should be told there are grounds why that cannot happen here, that what happens in the North cannot happen here, that what happens in England cannot happen here because this does not give the majority that the proposers of this Bill say is needed. I make the point that we have a lot to remember; we have a lot to investigate.
To make things more ridiculous in South Africa, in the 31 seats that were not contested, they were not contested because the Opposition Party had an 80 per cent. or 90 per cent. majority in each of those cases. Two of the leading papers in South Africa have dealt with that. The Cape Times estimates that if all the seats were contested the Government Party would have got 654,000 votes and the Opposition 687,000 votes. In other words, the Opposition would have won on a majority poll. Another paper, the Der Burgher does not say that. It says that the Government would have got 703,000 votes and the Opposition 671,000 votes—in other words, a very narrow Government majority, but they get 103 seats in Parliament as against 53 for the Opposition.
We come now to France. Again, this is a very large country with various deep-seated differences— radicialism, anti-clericalism and everything else—and with all those differences we cannot compare ourselves to France. I should like to see what advice we could get from some Frenchmen whom we could look up to. For instance, if we had a commission I would love to see ex-Premier Schumann on it. You might say he has been the outstanding parliamentary figure in Europe during that period.
Comment on this
I am sure he could give us much advice and I, for one, would place tremendous weight on everything he would have to say. We have other friends in all countries, men we look up to. If we want to know something about the English system, why not have Lord Pakenham's advice, which could be supplied to a commission? Surely, he is ever so partial to Ireland and to everything Irish and he would be as keen as we are to see that our country is preserved and that everything we value in Ireland, its traditions and its customs, is preserved. We could rely on his viewpoint. He has, beyond all others, first-hand experience of the working of the two-Party system in England. He knows precisely what weight the Party bosses carry in England. He knows whether the accusations made by the economists are factual or not, though it does seem remarkably strange that the candidates for the next election have been picked long ago and, of course, it is accepted that the safe seats are simply to carry the candidates imposed by the Party bosses. Surely we do not wish that situation to arise here?
We come now to the various things we have heard about the injustice of P.R. I might quote Senator Colley who said that the more freakish the candidate, the more votes he gets. I might also take the various speeches made by the Minister for External Affairs on irresponsible candidates and those who vote for them. Perhaps I could also take the mathematical gymnastics carried out by the Minister for Defence. We could go through all of those but they just simply go to prove that we have not got the facts. Anybody who understands the system—I say this without fear of contradiction as a scientist—could not possibly make those charges against it. It reminds me of the Irish proverb: "Cionn sé an chuileog i súile a dhearbrathar ach ni fheiceann sé í ina shúile féin." We are conscious of the defects in others and we cannot see the glaring defects in ourselves.
Comment on this
And they admit it. Senator Mullins does not admit anything.
Comment on this
I am claiming there is a point of view put forward after a cold, scientific analysis of the facts. All I am asking is that we have an authoritative White Paper drawn up by an impartial commission to give us the facts in this, to tell us where we are going. If we had that commission I for one would be only too happy to accept its recommendations, just as I am only too happy to support in every way possible the White Paper presented by the Government when I have seen the facts behind it, and when I am confident in the facts as given in that excellent publication on economic development by Mr. Whitaker. That, after all, is the only way we can make progress. At least, I do not know of any other.
As I say, you can find injustices in P.R. Let us take a three seat constituency or a five seat constituency.
Comment on this
Where the quota is 16 per cent. you may have a candidate just missing the last seat, and 15 per cent. of the voters then find that their votes go for nothing. I admit that is bad and it is something which complete P.R. strives to avoid, but it is necessary to give an edge to the majority Party. It accounts for giving you your parliamentary majority but what is that compared to the glaring examples of what happens under the straight vote, when 49 per cent. of the people in a constituency can be deprived of having any candidate? You have got to judge these injustices in comparison with the injustices in the system which you are now introducing. What we want to know from the point of view of choosing is: will the injustices be greater under the system we are going to introduce than under the present system? Obviously, they will be greater under the system that is proposed.
The whole question of the transfer of votes and everything else shows again a complete lack of understanding of what are really the basic facts. As I pointed out, in a Party convention you eliminate the last man and you vote again between the remaining four, if there are five candidates. You do that four times before you get a result but, obviously, you cannot do that for the country as a whole, or for a constituency as a whole. Say there are six candidates for three seats then you would hold one election to-day and, after the count, eliminate the last man. Then you would hold a second election and carry on in that way until you had eliminated five candidates, but that is precisely what, in this enlightened and intelligent age, P.R. does.
You ask the voter if his first choice is eliminated what is to be done with his vote. You ask him also: "If your second choice is also eliminated, what do we do with your vote?" The plain fact is that the election is simply a rearrangement by which a quota of voters gets one representative. That is the simple fact behind it and every vote is actualised only once. After all, there is no great pleasure in playing as a child, voting for candidates, if you get no further satisfaction. What you want when you vote is that someone will be elected whom you can regard as being the one nearest to your choice. That is the simple fact and the various transfers of votes, and so on, are just mathematical expedients.
Any good engineer, when designing a house, has to know when a further calculation is insignificant or not. He cannot spend years and years doing all forms of advanced calculations on his house. He has got to start building and he has got to know what approximations, what short cuts, he can take and in an election some of the processes especially in the transfer of distributions, the transfer of surpluses, are short cuts—short cuts that may make no difference whatsoever.
I would suggest to those putting this measure to us that they should at least let us have the facts and place them before the community. Let us face the fact that the case you are making for this is simply that it will ensure a greater majority, but do not ever try to suggest that you are removing injustices created by P.R. by imposing greater injustices. That is only insulting the intelligence of the electorate.
One hears about harebrained candidates, and all the rest, who are eliminated. If one takes the election results in previous times one finds that most of them were the third and fourth choices, that they were members of a Party but happened to fall at the end of the Party's preferences. One does not call those freakish.
One other very serious aspect of this is the fact that, unfortunately, in the past, Party politics have been brought into our local elections, into our county councils. That has been a very retrograde step, one which there seems to be some move at present to get over. At least, we find corporations and county councils acting more as a team for the welfare of the county or the city and we see the rise of ratepayers' representatives and various other groups. That is all to the good because many of us agree that the introduction of Party politics has been very much to the detriment of local government.
What will happen if this measure gets through? A large majority will be returned to the Dáil and that majority, by the simple expedient of passing a Bill, can alter the whole basis of local elections, get back to what was foreshadowed in some of the speeches in the last day or two—the single-seat type of county council representative—and we will be back then to counties being divided into wards with a ward boss in charge and, certainly, any of us does not want that. If the present measure gets under way there is a grave temptation that the Party in power will feel the urge to bring about that position. At least, I should like a very candid declaration from the Taoiseach and his Government that they have no such intention, which might help to allay some of the uneasiness that we feel about this.
We come to the question of whether there should be three seats or one, in other words, reduce the size of our constituencies, but should we get down to the single-seat constituency? There is a certain case to be made for it in the idea of the representative being in his area and having a smaller area to work, and so on but, if we analyse that, it carries its own dangers because in that case it will be the man who is really the best messenger-boy who will get elected. If we value representative government, we do not want too many in that category. There are too many other things to be done besides doing too much needless work of that kind. In fact, in future there will have to be some type of trade union to save the representatives from all the unnecessary work, whether it is filling in income-tax forms or anything else, that is thrust on them. For that reason, I feel that to have single-member constituencies would be retrograde.
Also, of course, there is the fact that those who are closely identified with one political Party or another do not feel happy or at ease going to the member of the other Party who has been elected and asking him to do something for the region. Will Senators take their own case? As Fianna Fáil supporters, how would they like to have to go to the Fine Gael T.D. for everything for their region, except that it would be a means of piling up credit for the next election?
Comment on this
If you do a favour for a man he is expected to remember it at the next election. Now take the case of young representatives. We are all adamant that the future of the country lies with the young men, Sinn Féin, 1918-21, was a young men's organisation. In fact, it must have been glorious and wonderful to be alive at that time to see all the young men in the country marching together and able to do things. Think of the generations that have come since then and how they have been held down and what men of mine or a younger generation can do. Even I am getting old at this stage.
In a three-seat constituency, take the approach in selecting candidates to represent the Party. First of all, there is No. 1. He must be selected; he is old and wise. No. 2 is wise and less old and he must be selected. There is a twinge of conscience and it is felt that they must put up a young man, so that there is at least one young man amongst the three candidates and then it is up to the electorate. They have a choice; they can vote for him if they wish and he can be elected if he gets sufficient votes. In that way the door is open to youth in the multi-member constituency but that door will be closed for many years if we revert to the single-seat constituency.
Again there is the question of ex-Ministers or Ministers of the outgoing Government. I have made the point already that they are the first people who will be displaced in this new system. Do you, who are devoting your lives to political work, want to have a see-saw? Do you want to be out and in, out and in? You may get stability of government in that way. You will not get stability of representation, which is of far more vital concern to the country as a whole.
Also, of course, the single-seat constituency encourages the return of the inexperienced T.D. when a new Government takes over. In a three-seat constituency any ex-Minister, a Minister of the outgoing Government, is almost certain of being returned but in a single-seat constituency, once the swing goes over against him, it is not sufficient to get 49 per cent. of the vote. In a three-seat constituency, as long as he can hold his third of the vote he can be sure of being returned.
The non-transferable vote puts a premium on nuisance factions because a constituency now is much smaller and it costs much less to conduct an election campaign in it. Therefore, any Independent is at liberty to contest the election.
Comment on this
He will not get elected but he will have a nuisance value. We can take the four splinter groups formed from Labour in the North, all competing for the one seat. If his leanings are towards Labour, he will take off sufficient votes to make it impossible for the official Labour man to be elected. The next time the Labour Party or any other Party have to think twice. They must consider that this man got 1,000 votes and that if they could put a Party label on him that 1,000 votes give material for electing a candidate. I am afraid that type of election campaign blackmail is a thing that could happen.
Finally, let us take the question of coalition government. As I have shown, the Governments in Europe could not be anything else but coalitions for the good of their countries. The way the divisions run there they should thank God they have coalitions and that no one Party is left to hold unbridled sway. We should recognise here that the term coalition is an honourable term for work that we do. In every walk of life we compromise, we meet together, we work together, and the suggestion that I made earlier might be considered, namely, to polarise our electors between the single Party and the coalition. Let one be the alternative of the other. If we keep our national life on that level we will retain a sound middle of the road policy that will give stability. What stability? The stability of policy, relative continuity from one Government to another. Surely that is more important than what is held up as stability, the power of a Government simply to ride roughshod through opposition.
Finally, I should like to end on a note of appeal to the Taoiseach as a scientist——
Comment on this
——to let us have this independent commission and not to let the Constitution become a football of Party politics—especially a football of Party politics when provision has already been made to ensure that the Constitution can be changed by a simple majority. In fact, if anything should be changed in the Constitution right now I think it is that provision. You can look through various Constitutions but I doubt if any of them can be changed that simply—certainly not the Constitution of the United States or of any of the others I have examined. I am sure there would be a great measure of co-operation and unanimity all round in removing the defect—the 50 per cent. clause—from our Constitution.
I have no doubt that we will get a watering-down of the present system as a recommendation from such a commission—probably a reversion to all three-seat constituencies. If it comes from the commission, I do not see that any Party could go to the country and oppose it, especially if that commission is made up of men we respect. I was challenged only last evening to say what commission could possibly be better than the Government of the day. We must discount that because we have two sets of people experienced in Government. We have two sets of people who have served in Government—the present Government and the previous Government. They both recommend two different things to us. Therefore, we cannot possibly give to any one of these two groups the right of having their viewpoint accepted as if infallible. That is what we are asked to do.
Let us have this commission. I have been challenged to say what men should be put on it. I am only making suggestions as to various people who would seem to commend themselves for their absolute integrity and knowledge and sympathetic understanding of our country. Take Lord Pakenham of England with his wonderful insight into, and experience of, British politics and, above all, his sincere sympathy with and wish for this country. Take Monsieur Schumann of France who has been the architect of most of the democratic revival in Western Europe. De Gaspari of Italy, Adenauer of Germany and Schumann stand as the three greatest statesmen that have emerged in Western Europe since the war.
Schumann should be able to see any obvious defects in our existing system and make recommendations for its amendment. The real work of Government is to get the voluntary and outside organisations to play their part. The function of Government is rather to help the people to help themselves rather than to baby the people along. From that point of view, we should not have such a commission completely overloaded with active politicians. I should like to see some outstanding representative connected with extra-Government organisations. I can think at present of no better person than Dr. Hoflstee of Holland who was here last summer as a guest of Muintir na Tíre and who lectured at their annual rural week in Roscrea. He is now chairman of the European Sociology Union where the concern is not merely with the government of man but with the whole life of man. No doubt he would be a tremendous asset to us.
I think I have sketched and shown that we need not be insular in this matter or so smug as to think that we ourselves are the only ones with the answers. Let us learn from the others. I appeal to the Government to let us have such an impartial commission. We cannot ask the people of Ireland to vote without information. If the Government do not concede this simple and democratic request then we shall have to table a motion here in the Seanad to ask the Seanad to do the job.
I think it is a job the Seanad could very well do but, if they do not, some other group will have to do it. The information will have to be obtained by hook or by crook, if the voters are to judge the issue democratically.
I have been out two nights a week to rural organisations since Christmas. At every one of the meetings I have been asked: "What is it all about?" They have not the faintest idea. It is degenerating at present into a series of clichés. Surely that is not the way to treat our sacred Constitution? Therefore, I heartily and anxiously appeal to the Taoiseach to take steps to have the commission set up. We do not need the results of this for another two or three years. There is accordingly plenty of time to do the work leisurely and calmly.
In the name of goodness, let us get straightaway back to discussing economic development on which there will be unanimity between us all, since the whole subject has been shorn of Party politics as a result of the excellent document produced by Mr. Whitaker. In this case, we are acting on what the doctor has ordered. I know we can make contributions here. We can suggest even more rapid progress than was indicated in that document. Far more can be done than is outlined in "Economic Development". However, it is a foundation and a tremendous step forward by the Government to produce that document. We all highly appreciate the work of the Government in letting that document come before us. It shows quite clearly that the White Paper is an effort to develop our economy exactly as the doctor has ordered. It has not and should not in any way be tied to any political Party, be it Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour or inter-Party. We are at last moving, we hope, steadily ahead on the firm foundation of fact. Again, we can take our experience with the Capital Investment Advisory Committee and the excellent work they have done. We are largely accepting their recommendations.
The Agricultural Institute Commission did the same. In that case, I was associated with rural organisations which were not satisfied that the proper steps had been taken to find the best scheme. I was associated with universities who felt they had been ridden roughshod over by two Governments—both by the present Opposition when they were in office and by the present Government. Facts were not produced and all the universities and the farmers wanted was facts. I had the high privilege of being associated with the efforts of Macra na Feirme and the National Farmers' Association in carrying out an independent investigation—the greatest work those organisations ever did. It had a profound influence on the Agricultural Institute. As it emerged, it is an excellent institute and one on which the present Government has to be heartily congratulated in their handling and on their appointments both of director and chairman. However, it was the work of the independent organisations that produced the factual basis that could not be ignored.
There is nothing in the Bill before the House about the commission which is contrary to what has happened in the case of the institute. We are proceeding steadily ahead. We pledged ourselves at that time that we were doing a scientific job. We also had the unpleasant job for scientists at that period of holding the Government of the day at bay and carrying on with the investigation. However, we carried it out. Something like that is necessary in this case.
I would ask the Government to take the necessary steps to let us have the facts. I feel I could speak for the independent Senators of both universities in saying that we will heartily cooperate with and welcome any effort to make possible such an approach.
Comment on this
Does the Minister for External Affairs propose to intervene in the debate or to conclude?
Comment on this
I have no objection to that but it is an innovation. May I be allowed to make a brief remark on that? The Minister has a constitutional right to attend and be heard here. I have no desire to cavil at that or to delay his intervention but, heretofore, ministerial rights have been exercised in accordance with the precedents established and prevailing here in my experience for over 20 years under different Governments. The House has had good relations with Ministers and we all want that situation to continue. What is proposed now is an innovation. If it were extended merely in accordance with a constitutional right, we might have the position in which 12 Ministers could attend and speak, as distinct from the Minister who opens the debate and concludes. I presume that is not the intention, but it is possible, and I feel attention should be drawn to it. At the same time in the case of the Minister who has attended very faithfully since the start of this debate, I have no objection to his being heard, apart altogether from his constitutional right.
Comment on this
Might I recall the precedent when there was a motion on the question of the Irish language? As I recall it, the Minister for Education addressed the House as well as the Taoiseach. I think I speak for many Senators when I say that we appreciate the fact when more than one Minister is prepared to come along and listen to the debates. I should welcome his intervention.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the Minister speaking. The precedent which the Senator mentioned was not on a Government Bill. This is the Second Stage of a Government Bill and it is quite a different thing from a motion. As I say, I have no objection, but I think this is an innovation in the handling of a Government Bill.
Comment on this
Having heard the statement of Senator Hayes, I presume I may call on the Minister for External Affairs to intervene?
Comment on this
This debate has not differed very greatly from the debate which we had in the Dáil for a couple of months. We have had a commission of 147 men sitting on the proposed change for almost three months in the Dáil and I do not know how long it is going to take here. I think that is the best type of commission. The scientists, the atomic scientists and technical people are very good in their own trade, but when it comes to a question of what type of electoral system is likely to give the best system of government, I think the people to ask are the men who have been practising that particular art for a great number of years. Not only can we consult the men in this country who have been responsible for government for many years, but we have the opinion of people in other countries, statesmen who have seen the effects of various electoral systems. If the Senators are prepared to go through the Dáil debates, they will see quoted, by many speakers, what a number of German statesmen said about P.R., what a number of Italian statesmen said about it, men who had the experience of seeing the dictatorial groups creeping in, expanding their influence in Parliament and finally taking it over.
I heard—I do not know how true it is—that in the Duma at the time of the Kerensky Government, they were busily engaged in instituting P.R. when Lenin took the matter somewhat out of their hands. The whole basis, the whole object of any electoral system in a democratic country should be to get an effective system of government, in the first instance; secondly, a Government that can be held responsible by the people for their action or inaction during their term of office. In my belief, and in the belief of practically every one of the Fine Gael people who were in power during the period from 1922 to 1932, the system of P.R. tends to lead to a multiplicity of small Parties, making coalitions inevitable and making instability and all that goes with it also inevitable.
The quotations from these Cumann na nGaedheal people are to be found in the Dáil debates. I need not go through them all. I would not go so far as some of the leaders of Fine Gael go in denouncing P.R., as being the creature of the brains of all the cranks of the world, as Deputy Dillon said, but it was an effort by the people who were really hoping to get the fairest system of election, fair representation, so that there would be fair and reasonable Government for all sections of the community. The whole question is what is the best way to get effective Government and fair and just Government for all sections of the community?
In our belief, the best way is the straight vote system. I have listened to a number of Senators speaking and there is no one here, and there was no one in the Dáil, who would propose that we should carry the system of representation, the principle of having representation, to the extent that would turn the country into a single constituency and where anyone who could get one vote in 147 could come into the Dáil. No one has done that so there is a limit to the representation. It is all very well for Senator Quinlan to nod his head, but there have been others who have been talking as if what they wanted was that every identifiable minority in the country should have the possibility of having its own candidate returned to the Dáil. If you go through the list of members of the Dáil at the present time—there is a book on the subject by Mr. McCracken—you see that the Deputies represent about 50 occupations and trades. If you are to take the number of groups that gave evidence to the vocational commission, there were 200 or 300, and we could get a system of election which would make it possible for any one of those 200 or 300 groups if they had three-quarter per cent. of the voters in their favour to return a candidate.
Comment on this
You could have three-quarters of one per cent. of the voters getting one candidate returned. We went a little bit further than that when a small Party with, say, ten votes out of every 147, about 7 per cent. of the voters, could get ten seats. Who wants that as a system?
Comment on this
We want to get that clear. We do not want to give a minority with one vote out of every 147 the possibility of coming into the Dáil, if they so desire?
Comment on this
It would be much better if this debate were conducted through the Chair and not by means of question and answer. It would be more agreeable for everybody.
Comment on this
Sometimes questions and answers can be very revealing. Out of this question and answer comes the fact that these gentlemen who are to go around the country weeping about minorities and how they would love to see them in the Dáil do not want to see the poor, helpless minority that has only one vote out of 147 with the right to come into the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Minister must be permitted to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
That is one system that has obtained in other countries. We heard Senator Quinlan describing it and he said that country was "streets ahead" of us in economic development, but I do not think Senator Quinlan will try to argue that this is because it has that system. But it has that system as he described it, and nobody else wants it even though, associated with P.R. in that system, there is the great economic development described by Senator Quinlan.
We must discuss these matters in relation to our own needs. Somebody asked one of the seven wise men of Greece—I forget which of them it was: "What is the best constitution?" The reply was: "For whom? At what time?" The question for us is: What is the best electoral system for Ireland in the last half of the 20th century. One of the characteristics of our people for a long time is that we are individualists; we like to hold to our own point of view through thick and thin and against the world.
It is a very valuable characteristic and one we should hate to see being hampered in any way, but it is a characteristic that has disadvantages when you want unity for a common purpose. We can get such unity. We have got it under outside pressure from time to time. We had it during the Black and Tan war because we had to have unity "or else". The Power that occupied this country, as in the case of Powers occupying other countries, fostered divisions among the occupied people so as to make them easier to control.
As far back as Elizabeth's day, her representative, Sir George Carew, reported to her:—
"It was thought no ill policy to make the Irish draw blood one upon the other whereby their private quarrels might advance the public service."
That was nothing peculiar at that day and age, and it was the approach of all occupying Powers. It was the method by which they weakened opposition. They promoted civil strife, quarrels, divisions and disunity, and if we want to make pro-progress in our time, we must have an electoral system that reverses that trend completely.
No one will deny any minority, even a minority of one, its right to promote its point of view, but a minority of one can promote its point of view in a manner that will not obstruct national progress. We have the Press, the radio, the public meeting, the small broadsheet, the pamphlet, the leaflet, the small book—all these methods by which the individual, the minority of one, can promote his ideas, if he has good ideas to promote. But at some time or other we must cease merely listening to ideas if we want to make progress; we must take decisions and the question is: how are we to get decisions taken that will result in the best possible progress for the 3,000,000 people for whom we are responsible?
We believe that the straight vote system is better than P.R. for that purpose. Let us first of all get rid of an idea that may be brought forward or promulgated when nobody is listening down the country as to what Fine Gael is standing for. If we have this single constituency for the whole of the State and if we have a majority of 7 per cent. we can get ten seats. All sorts of small Parties could get 7 per cent.; indeed even the embryonic anti-Tory Party, if it tried hard enough, might get 7 per cent. and if they got 7 per cent., they would obtain ten seats in the Dáil.
If we had the Dáil divided into 20 Parties or 80 Parties, as they had in Germany before the advent of Hitler, how would we do the work of the country? After the election we would have to compose our differences. We would have to make the compromises that everybody agrees are necessary if people are to live in the one world. Our opinion is that, in order that we should have effective action and decisions taken in the Dáil, as many of these compromises as possible should be made between the Parties before the election and the nature of the compromises announced so that the people can vote on them. We object strongly to coalitions— and I think we have given proof of our sincerity—because we believe they are disastrous. We believe that if the coalition system came in here, with our divisive background, with our strong tendency to individualism as a nation, it would produce as many Parties as it ever produced in any other country with each of these small Parties defending its little point of view as violently as any small Party in any other country.
It may be that coalition is inevitable. Under any system of election there is no guarantee that there always will be one Party with a majority and a couple of smaller Parties. But is it not better, if democracy is to work, that the compromises, the deals, as Deputy Norton put it, should be made before the election and that the people should know what the Parties intend to do? Is it anything but the height of hypocrisy that half a dozen Parties that have agreed before the election that they will coalesce if the result gives them a combined majority should each go forward to the people for their votes, denounce the other five violently, saying they will never coalesce with them and then immediately after the election get together and form a coalition?
It would have been much easier for Fianna Fáil, on the occasions on which we walked across the floor, to form a coalition than it was for Fine Gael. The reason that Fianna Fáil has gone up in strength while Fine Gael has gone down is that we were prepared to take the knock and say: "If we are going to carry the responsibility of Government, you must give us the power to carry out our duties. We are not going to take responsibility without having power of decision." Fine Gael was prepared to form a coalition. It had not the power of decision and it had to take responsibility for queer things.
I need only refer to Deputy Costello's election address in his constituency in 1948 when he spoke about the External Relations Act, and we know what happened afterwards. He also had to forgo his constitutional right, indeed his constitutional duty, to appoint Ministers. He had to take whatever Ministers were given to him. These Ministers did not measure up to the beautiful conception of the intellectual discussion at the Cabinet Table. Each of the members of the Cabinet had to take instructions from the small Party behind him.
Senator Murphy spoke at length and denounced the straight vote system but he did not answer a question that I notice was put to him by Senator Sheehy Skeffington and, I think, by Senator Fearon.
Comment on this
After I had spoken. I had no opportunity of answering.
Comment on this
I should be very glad to give the Senator the opportunity now. I shall put the question which Senator Sheehy Skeffington asked last night. Will the Labour Party and Fine Gael herewith undertake that, if they get a combined majority after the election, they will introduce legislation to abolish the straight vote?
Comment on this
The Minister is in possession and he is entitled to make his speech; I intend to do my utmost to see that he will be able to do that without interruption.
Comment on this
I have given way to Senator Murphy to answer that question and I should be glad if he would do so.
Comment on this
I would prefer the Minister to make his speech without interruption. If at the end of the Minister's speech somebody wants to give an explanation, that is a matter for the Chair.
Comment on this
The Labour Party believe in P.R. It is their system of election for their administrative council and if Labour gets the opportunity—
Comment on this
——if the Labour Party and Fine Gael get a majority after the straight vote comes in, will they introduce legislation to abolish it?
Comment on this
I am speaking only for the Labour Party and the answer is definitely "yes."
Comment on this
Sir, I have often been asked before whether I have left off beating my wife and my practice is not to answer.
Comment on this
I think Senator Sheehy Skeffington should be satisfied that he knows where they stand.
Comment on this
The Chair wishes to express the view that this debate should not be carried on on the basis of question and answer.
Comment on this
Up to now it has been carried forward on the basis of question and no answer or only half an answer. Perhaps I might, without asking a question, repeat a question that I put to Deputy Norton in the Dáil. I could not get an answer although I asked him 100 times.
Comment on this
The Minister should go back to the Dáil and ask him again.
Comment on this
This question was very simple. It was: would the Labour Party, if Fianna Fáil failed to get a majority in the next election, join with Fine Gael to form another Coalition? I could not get an answer to that question. Was that not queer?
Comment on this
I am suggesting to the Minister and the House that this debate must not be carried on on the basis of question and answer, and the Minister is not to be interrupted by anybody during the course of his speech.
Comment on this
This question occurred to me when I read a report of the Labour Party conference on 20th June, 1957, in which they solemnly decided:—
"The Labour Party will not again take part in an inter-Party Government but will remain in opposition until it achieves a parliamentary majority. This is to be the basis of a statement..."
But it was not the basis of the statement Deputy Norton made because he made no statement. I could not get from Deputy Norton an answer as to whether after the next general election, if Fianna Fáil failed to secure a majority and Labour and Fine Gael were in a position to elect a Taoiseach, they would, in fact, coalesce.
It boils down to this: should the people not know? Should they not have a right to decide whether they want to vote for a coalition or not? Why should the Labour Party come out and denounce Fine Gael and all its works and pomps, saying it was outdated, outworn and a Tory Party, and then, having got those votes, sell out to the Tory Party? What I like about the straight vote is that it will force the Labour Party and Fine Gael to give straight answers to straight questions. While they can bamboozle me and fool me, they cannot fool the straight voter who gets his ballot paper, reads all the election addresses and says: "Which of these do I want?" He will have to get the answer under the straight vote. He need not under the other system because he can fool around with his pencil all over the paper.
There is one further advantage in it. If the people do not want Party "A" and it is the larger party, Parties "B" and "C" will have to announce their decision about a coalition before an election and give the people an effective opportunity of selecting a new policy. After the burst up of the last Coalition we had Deputy Larkin letting the cat out of the bag about what went on. We know he said that: "Fine Gael utilised every opportunity that came, not only in the open light of day but in the dark of night. Next time we may know better."
Comment on this
It is 20th April, 1952. It did not prevent the Labour Party joining again in 1954. I would say the people will make them join ahead of time if the straight vote comes along.
To get back to what is the best electoral system for us in this day and age, let me say this. We cannot go back to the old Greek system and consult every voter on every issue. We cannot have a referendum or a plebiscite or a mass meeting in the Park to decide each question. We have to select representatives of some kind and trust them. We propose that the people in the country should so organise themselves that they will produce a few Parties, so that they will be able to elect one Party or a traditional group of two associated Parties. I am not a prophet and I cannot tell you exactly how it will work out. But in the countries in which it operates it has worked this way. You have two groups, one in Government and the other the alternative group. Either of the groups may be a traditional Coalition, one that has been at work for years. They are two associated groups. They have no great differences of opinion. They are quite different from the Coalition formed here in 1948 in which the extreme Empire Party, at one side, and the extreme Republican Party, at the other side, came together. No one could tell ahead of time what would happen as a result of the union. In these other countries you have two fairly well allied groups of Parties with policies very closely associated indeed. They merely divide themselves into two Parties for the sake of having a more attractive label going to certain parts of the country. Take the Country Party and the Liberal Party in Australia, for example. We believe this system of election has had the effect in other countries, and will have the effect here, of having these two groups, maybe composed of a single Party or of two Parties which are traditionally associated. You have the Government on one side and the alternative Government on the other.
For those who want complete representation of all groups, direct representation, each with his label in his coat, for all the groups in the country, I want to point out that the function of a Parliament is not to be a debating society. Something more must happen at the end of a debate than that the chairman gets up and gives an interesting résumé of the very interesting contributions made and disagreements registered. Decisions have to be made and put into effect. The more clear cut the alternative before the House when coming to a decision, the quicker it can take its decision, and the more effective and penetrating can be the debate. But when there are 101 people arguing each for something completely different from the other 100, then it is hard to get a conclusion and the nearer you come to the two, the proposition and the amendment, the better it is for effective work. Now, we want effective work. We want to be able to take effective decisions. I would say to Senator Quinlan that one of the reasons why we have not made more progress is that we have never really had a Government that knew far enough ahead that it would remain in power sufficiently long to be able to take really effective decisions.
Comment on this
Just a moment now. I am not giving that as an excuse. This country has done marvellous work in its time. When we took over from the British, we were the worst housed white race in the world. We are now one of the best. We have done many other things. When we were in a position to organise ourselves—a great deal was done, admittedly, with State capital because private enterprise would not do the job—our people went to the top in efficiency and in certain cases they can hold their own with anybody to-day. There was one small sugar beet factory in 1932; there was a very small acreage of beet grown in 1932. The factory was run by a foreign combine and was on its last legs. We took over. We built four more factories and, of these four, three of them are now in the first five for sugar conversion. We developed our bogs.
Comment on this
The Shannon scheme was started by an American company. For the Senator's information, an American company was exploring this project as far back as 1912. They got permission from the British to go ahead and do the job, but they did not do it. It took the Irish people themselves to do it. Even if they were led by Cumann na nGaedheal, what does it matter? The Irish people did it. We took over the bogs.
Comment on this
If the Minister were permitted peace, he would make his speech in his own way.
Comment on this
In my belief, the best way to get unity—we are always preaching unity; Fine Gael when——
Comment on this
——when they want to form a coalition, they preach unity: we should have unity, and Fianna Fáil are for disunity simply because they will not come in and form an all-Party Government.
Comment on this
That would be a nice kettle of fish. Have no opposition! Muzzle everybody! And the Government will have their own way. Fine Gael are all for unity except when it comes to declaring that unity before an election. They do not like to say then that they will unite with Labour; but after the election they are all for unity. We want them to come right out and be straight with the people and tell them, before the election, with whom they will unite.
With regard to minority representation, minorities have developed into huge majorities in countries under the straight vote system where the minorities believed in themselves, were prepared to make sacrifices and had the leadership to attact support. The Labour Party in England in 1918 commanded a mere handful of votes. Within five years it was the Government. It increased from 60 representatives to 300 plus. It was not afraid of the straight vote. It still wants it. In the same period here, the Labour Party representation went down. I remember when the Labour Party here had 23 seats. Now they have 11. P.R. has not served them very well. Does the Labour Party merely want to go on meandering along with ten or 11 seats, content if they get two or three seats in the Cabinet from Fine Gael? Is that the height of their ambition? Have they a policy? Do they believe in it? The Labour Party in England had a policy. They believed in it. I do not subscribe to all their policy, but they had a policy and they put it through.
Fine Gael went down, too. I remember when they had 63 seats. Now they have 40 and, if they do not behave themselves, I am sure they will lose the nought, because they do not deserve to win.
Comment on this
——a Party that has no policy, that is afraid to face the people and afraid to have an electoral system which is giving Parties majorities in other countries, does not deserve to win, and they will not win, if they do not pull up their socks. All these calculations as to how many seats Fianna Fáil will command after an election and how many the other poor helpless minorities will command are a little bit foolish really. If a minority can get a seat in a constituency, why should it not be a Labour minority? Why should it be a Fianna Fáil minority?
Comment on this
Why should it not be a Fine Gael minority? By and large, what happens under the straight vote system is that the will of the majority is made effective. It gives Government a chance and, if Government does not take the chance and make good, it gives Government a kick where it deserves it at the first opportunity.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes was very violent about asking people to make a deal before the election.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, he said that the idea that people should be asked to make a deal before election was blackmail.
Comment on this
The Senator is reported as having said it at column 260 of Volume 50:—
"That is the idea; you must bargain beforehand, give individuals power to blackmail."
Now, the point is we want to give them power to blackmail beforehand, and not after, not during the course of government, not when they are supposed to be doing the work they were elected to do and when we cannot discover whether or not the work is being done. That is the difference. It is when the bargaining begins afterwards that the blackmail starts, and the people have then no power to curb it. A Party says: "Do this, or you will not have our support.""Give us these Ministries or you will not get your majority.""Do what we want you to do, or we go out and burst the Government." And they did burst the Government twice. We all know that. We do not have to go to these other countries and analyse the position there, interesting and informative as Senator Quinlan's speech was. But there was really nothing new in it. He did, however, put on record the systems in other countries, but I would advise him to do a little further study.
Comment on this
He will get it if he reads the Dáil Debates. He will find in them references to a number of books and quotations from various people who have written on this subject, people who suffered from coalition and who wanted to get rid of it, just as the Irish people indicated that they wanted to get rid of it in 1957 when they gave Fianna Fáil a great majority to get rid of the Coalition.
Comment on this
There was one argument advanced here which I should like to deal with. It is an idea to which some Senators have given expression, but perhaps after a little argument they will agree with me. It is that as Parties grow, they grow in arrogance. That is the reverse of the truth.
Comment on this
That as Parties grow in strength, they grow in arrogance. That is not true—it is peculiar but people have seen it here—because even though a Party may have the strength to carry on in the Dáil, they cannot do so because they are not arrogant enough.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil want to give them the power to do it.
Comment on this
Please! They cannot do it because public opinion has its healthy effect, even on a Government with a big majority. The bigger the majority, the more likely the Government are to be open to the accusation that they are treating a minority or an individual unfairly.
Comment on this
There is no validity in that argument. Indeed, the reverse is nearer to the truth, that as Parties diminish in strength, they grow in arrogance, not as they grow stronger.
In conclusion, I should like to say that there is no system of election which can make an immature or foolish people successful and the people have given the greatest proof of their political maturity in the past 20 years. They rendered harmless the worst effects of P.R.; they made their slips for a couple of years, but finally they pulled themselves together and exacted a sound vengeance on the people who were trying to play the P.R. Game for the destruction of the country. They gave those people a very salutary lesson and the reason we are in a position to put this proposition to the people and ask them to consider it, is that the people decided at the previous election that they would have no more coalitions if they could help it.
Comment on this
They have given us the power—and we will use it because it is our duty to do so—to pass this legislation and to insist that the people should be consulted——
Comment on this
And we are doing it, and we will do more. If the Senator wants me to deal with the economic situation——
Comment on this
It is a point of order made in an effort to retain order in the House.
Comment on this
The Chair is capable of keeping order in the House and will make its decisions. If I think the Minister is not being given a fair opportunity, I shall not be slow to say so. I am not making any direction.
Comment on this
I have already drawn attention to Senator L'Estrange to whom we listened last night for three hours.
Comment on this
As a people, we have proved ourselves, as I say, to be politically mature. We took this instrument that was imposed upon us for our destruction and division——
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I have the information here for him. It was not because of Arthur Griffith's blue eyes that the British imposed P.R. or gave P.R. to Ireland. Arthur Griffith, like a number of liberal-minded people back in 1910, was led away by the idea of P.R. He had not the experience of Government and he did not know what it was in fact that a successful Government required. He supported P.R. back in 1910 and it was not until 1919 that the British gave it to us—if you want to call it giving.
Comment on this
1919. In February, 1919, they introduced it in the British Parliament and that was just two months after Sinn Féin had achieved a smashing victory under the straight vote system. At that time, the British Attorney General, winding up the debate—Senators can get it by taking this reference; they can see the whole of the debate, but I shall only read a short extract—said:—
"In the general election, 75 per cent. of the representation has gone over to the Sinn Féin Party..."
He looked across at Carson, who was against his Bill and said:—
"Are you going to throw the administration of the local authorities, elected on the present franchise, bodies which have been absolutely captured by people who call the rest of the United Kingdom the ‘enemy'..."
He thought that would settle Carson and that was the only reason they imposed it. There has been foolish talk about Sligo having asked for P.R. The people of the town of Sligo would not be allowed to get a loan to do some work they wanted to do unless they passed a resolution approving the Bill for this loan into which P.R. was shoved. They would not get one without the other.
The fact that the British imposed P.R. upon us does not say it might not be the best system in the world, but they did it for the purpose of dividing us. They did not adopt it for themselves because they knew it would divide them. In this day and age, and we must make up our minds about it, in order to be successful and in order that we should reach that standard or that rate of increase in our production which will enable us to do all the things, or some of the things we want to do in the line of education and so on and so forth, we shall have to be reasonably efficient. At the moment, democratic countries are in competition with systems of government which, no matter what else you may say about them—they are disastrous in every way for the happiness of the people—can turn out goods.
We unfortunately are in that position and we are proposing a system of election that will make our people more efficient, that will help them to get rid of a number of divisions within their Parties and that will give them two effective Parties or groups of Parties in the Dáil, one of which, when it is in Government, can carry through its policy, a policy that it has told to the people, and the other that can propose amendments to the Government's policy—policies which they will be expected by the people to put into operation if they are selected in their turn.
In answer to the question as to what is the best constitution, I say that for the Irish people in the second half of the 20th century the straight vote system is the best electoral system.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
What I propose to say on this matter I propose to divide into two parts. First of all, I want to answer, as best I may, the arguments made by the Minister just before the adjournment. The Minister, I feel, was brought in because there was no member among the nominated members of the Seanad prepared to deal with this matter in the way the Taoiseach would like it dealt with. I think that the nature of the Minister's speech might suggest, as some people will say, that we might also bring down Lord Brookeborough to add to the team.
The Minister's suggestion in the other House that France had been brought to her knees by P.R.—that matter was dealt with by Senator Hayes—was both false and inappropriate. I do not think it is appropriate for people in a small country like our own to make remarks of that kind about a country which, even if it is not in the first four or five Powers in the world, is still a very much more powerful and prosperous country than ours.
Anybody who cares to look up statistics—and I do not feel that they tell the whole story—will see that, before the war, our income per head of the population was rather better than the French income. Despite this business of France being brought to her knees and so forth, French income per head of the population—the real income and that is the only thing that counts—is now about 30 per cent. to 40 per cent. better than ours. It is a peculiar way of going on your knees when you are continuously becoming people are better off, have more food to eat and more facilities and services of all sorts. I do not think it was a very appropriate remark to make.
The Minister based one part of his case on the effect which P.R. had in bringing dictatorship into existence on the Continent. When the Constitution of 1937 was being prepared, all that information was available. It was much more readily available at the time and nearer to hand than it is now, 25 years later. I do not think that anybody believes for a moment what the Minister for Defence said in Kerry, that it was because the Constitution might be defeated if P.R. were taken out of it. I think that is an argumentum ad hominem long after the day.
The Minister for External Affairs also said: "The debate has not differed greatly from the debate which took place in the Dáil." I do not agree at all. Many of the speeches here were on an entirely different basis. There was the speech made by Senator Professor George O'Brien; there was the speech to-day by Senator Professor Quinlan and there was the speech yesterday of Senator L'Estrange.
Comment on this
I will come back to that. If Senators would read Senator L'Estrange's speech when printed, they might be surprised at the effectiveness of the material in it. Then there was the speech of Senator Professor Stanford, an analytical speech of a different kind. These were all different from the speeches made in the Dáil.
I was also a bit perturbed on another point. This is a matter to which I have referred here before; it is not particular to this Minister and it is not in any way personal. I was a bit perturbed when the Minister talked about scientists being "good at their trade". I have protested in this House about that idea, which seems to be deeply ingrained in the Fianna Fáil Party, that tradesmen are the same as technologists, that a technician is the same as a technologist. They are not. The use of a word like "trade"—and that was the word the Minister used, "they are good at their trade"—is not right. It is not a trade. They do not ply a trade, they do not think like tradesmen and they are not engaged to think like tradesmen; they are engaged to try to do original thought on serious problems. It has nothing whatever to do with trading or the practice of craftsmanship.
He said that, in the belief of practically everyone in the Fine Gael Party from 1921 to 1932, "P.R. leads to the growth of small Parties and to coalitions with all that goes with it". Let us take the evidence. We have it in the elections. If anyone examines the history of this country since 1923, when the first election took place—we will come back to the figures later— he will find that there is approximately the same number of Parties now as there was then. Is it possible that the Taoiseach feels that when his great presence leaves the scene of action things will be different? Is it possible that he believes that his own Party may have a fission measure in operation subsequent to his leaving the scene? Is it possible that there is something like that at the back of his thoughts? I do not know. The evidence is that there are as few Parties to-day in Dáil Eireann as there were in the very first election held in this country since this part of Ireland obtained a Government of its own from 1922 onwards.
The Minister said: "We are concerned with the best way to get effective Government; that is where the difference comes in." The problem was phrased well and posed well by Senator Stanford. I think the purpose of elections is to get representation and that the purpose of Dáil Éireann is, when these people are elected, to elect a Taoiseach, who forms a Government. That is the system. The purpose of elections is to get people into Dáil Éireann who will represent the population of the country. As I said at the time, the Minister put up an Aunt Sally: "Would you go and have one constituency in the country?" There was, of course, one election for the Seanad on one occasion, where the whole country was one constituency. That was never tried again. There is this difference. Under P.R., if there is a minority of 1 per cent. of the population in one county, they would get a seat—that is to say one out of 147. If they were in one county, under P.R. they would get the seat. They would need to be in one small area to get a seat under the system which is proposed now. There is a very big difference there.
The Minister says: "We have to discuss these matters in relation to our own needs." I quite agree with him, of course. He asks: "What is the best electoral system for Ireland, in the second half of the 20th century?" With other members here, I think that the best electoral system is to secure representation for different points of view in the community. The Minister suggests: "P.R. will promote civil strife and we do not want that here; we want an electoral system which reverses that trend." This has become an open question in the course of the debate. When this matter was first mooted, I did not profess to know a great deal about it; but I was surprised when a rather conservative member of my own Party mentioned this possibility; and then, when I thought about it I realised that he was speaking the truth.
There is a serious possibility that people who will not get representation in the House will adopt other methods of furthering their ends. In that connection, we all think of one particular Party; but one can think of other Parties. Suppose the Labour Party were obliterated altogether, one could consider them adopting other means to present their views.
Comment on this
Senator Lenihan should grow up. If we had no problems to deal with in this country, one might say it was incitement, but the problems are there and there is no incitement in the fact that I advert to the possibility that certain results may follow. The Minister said: "We must take decisions, we must cease listening to ideas." If one listens to ideas, one must at some stage, of course, decide what one is going to do. The Minister is the man who, on one occasion, asked about something rather serious, said: "You cannot make omelettes without breaking eggs." That seems to me to be the same idea; one must cease listening to ideas. You cannot make omelettes without breaking eggs. It all depends on whether the omelettes are good or bad, and it all depends on whether it might not be better to keep the eggs.
The Minister put up another Aunt Sally: "If we had a Dáil divided into 20 Parties, how would we do the work of the country?" This is an unreal question, which has no relation to the present position in the country. We all know there are three big Parties and a couple of relatively small Parties who have maintained their position because they represent a certain point of view in their own areas.
The Minister said: "We object to Coalitions because we believe they are disastrous." As evidence of this, the Minister did not produce any item whatever. Let us take another matter to which he referred in relation to that, that the Taoiseach in an inter-Party Government had to take responsibility for queer things; and the instance which was given was the declaration of the Republic. I believe that the real reason why the Fianna Fáil Party boycotted the declaration of the Republic when it happened, and subsequently pretended that it had been there all the time, was that if Deputy John A. Costello had not declared the Republic it would have been the ace of trumps for Deputy de Valera in the 1951 general election. He would have played it, that he was going to declare it. He would have phrased it very carefully, but it would have been his ace of trumps. The fact is that it was taken out of politics, just the same as the gun was taken out of politics in this country. These were two worthwhile political efforts.
Comment on this
I shall come back to the 1951 break up. That is the second part of my own speech. I am answering the Minister now. The Minister made an oblique reference— perhaps he did not mean it—when he talked about "deals, as Deputy Norton put it." I read the report of the debates in the Dáil and I do not think that Deputy Norton meant it in that way. It was an oblique reference. I do not know if Deputy Norton used the word "deals" and it seemed rather as if the Minister is suggesting that he had said in the Dáil that there were some kind of deals made. The Minister's phrase was just a phrase and it may have had no particular significance.
The Minister said that it would have been easier for Fianna Fáil to form a coalition but that they went across the House instead. When the 1948 election occurred, I had no great interest in politics; I was working at my job. But I did see one thing. I had been often in the Dáil, as an official, and the question intrigued me: would the Fianna Fáil Party be able to make a junction with the five National Labour Deputies? I had my own opinion about that. I had often seen Deputy James Hickey, Deputy Everett and Deputy O'Leary——
Comment on this
——and I knew the negotiations that went on. I know one of the Ministers was the negotiating instrument and it fell down on Fianna Fáil. I said to myself that Deputy James Hickey would be nothing if he went in with Fianna Fáil, after the line he had taken with them over the years he was a member of the Dáil, and my point of view was vindicated.
Comment on this
Deputy James Hickey did not get a Ministry; that is the answer to that. I had particularly thought of his line of approach to economic matters. During the period the inter-Party Government were in office, the cost of living rose 14 points in Britain, but it did not rise at all here until the outbreak of the Korean War. Deputy Hickey's point of view, therefore, was also vindicated because it had been forecast, before the inter-Party Government took office, that we were facing four of the most difficult years we would ever have to face.
Comment on this
I remember the activities of the Fianna Fáil Party. At that time, I had left the Civil Service and Fianna Fáil were doing nothing at all but, within a couple of months of the outbreak of the war in Korea, they were hot on the question of the cost of living.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party knew just enough economics to be able to back the certainty that the Korean War would raise the cost of living. The Minister to-day asked what would Parties do in certain circumstances in the future. Suppose they do not say anything? I think in politics that is more honest and straighter than saying you will do one thing and then go on to do something else.
Comment on this
The Parties can say nothing about the subject. He who reads may run. Anyone can draw his own conclusions about it. Let me put the practical side of the problem, if this country is divided into single member constituencies. In the last election only 288 candidates, representing all points of view in the country, went forward. Of that number 112 were Fianna Fáil and there were 146 seats contested. That meant that only 176 candidates contested those seats on behalf of all the rest of the Parties, including Independents. The fact of the matter is that none of the other Parties has the resources to throw in two or three candidates to contest each constituency. The Fine Gael Party, which was the biggest Party, had 82 candidates in that election in which there were 146 seats under contest.
I do not think you will need to make many bargains to ensure that there will be only a couple of candidates contesting each seat if you have the kind of situation built up that the Government are envisaging. There is no question about it. This particular kind of approach has led to a situation where there is not the same respect for parliamentary democracy in this country as there was in the past.
The Minister said that he had not the gift of prophecy but he went on to talk about two groups. Suppose this ends up with three groups? Even in that direction the Minister's gift of prophecy is gone. He has talked about 101 people arguing for a different conclusion and that again is really an exaggeration, just the same as when the Minister was talking about Governments being able to see far enough ahead. All I can say is that the Fianna Fáil Party came in as a Radical Party and what has worried most people is that, though they did certain things in the 1930s, more things were not done.
The things they did were quite common to the whole world at that time. There was a major world problem of unemployment but it did not hit this country as much as it did other countries. It did, however, hit us, and we had certain social welfare services brought in, the same as elsewhere. It is true that the Fianna Fáil Party did a certain amount of land division but, if we look back now, the impression one gets is that all the capital expenditure which has been so high in real terms since the war, the forestry programme, the housing and rural electrification programme, all could have been done for a fraction of the cost in the 1930s. At that time Fianna Fáil were in office with an overall majority and they made no effort whatever. Even if they had planted a few trees this country would be infinitely better off than it is to-day.
Towards the end of his speech the Minister talked about the period when Comhlucht Siúicre Teo. was set up. He said we had a foreign combine here which was on its last legs. It was paying a 15 per cent. dividend to the shareholders and they were paid, by the Minister's Government, £2 for every £1 they had invested. From that it does not seem as if it was on its last legs.
Comment on this
We have had quotations about the suggestion that bargains are made after elections but I wish to give only one quotation tonight. I went down to the Library to get it out yesterday. It is a quotation taken from underneath the picture of the Taoiseach which was printed in the Irish Press of May 21st, 1954. This is what he said in one important paragraph:—
"The battle is over. The people have given their decision. The Coalition Parties have a majority and they can form a Government."
That was what he said the day after the election but, five days later, when he had time to think it over he said: "All the bargaining is on." The day after the election, when the count had just finished, he had nothing to say about bargaining. "The Coalition Parties have a majority and they can form a Government"—does that sound as if there was any question of bargaining or that there was any doubt in anybody's mind about the nature of the election? I do not think it does.
Comment on this
The Minister also made a point that certain Parties might do reasonably well, some of them better than others, and so on. If anybody has any doubt about it he has only to look at the election in Dublin South-Central last year, but there is no doubt in anybody's mind that, if this goes through, the Opposition Parties will be reduced substantially, reduced to very small proportions, for two reasons. The Labour Party has really got no newspaper support—that is literally true—and the Fine Gael Party has no money. The Fine Gael Party is not backed by the millers or other people. That is a fact.
Comment on this
Is Senator O'Donovan entitled to make his speech or does Senator Lenihan profess to prevent people making speeches?
Comment on this
Address the remarks of Senator Hayes to Senator L'Estrange and they will be in order.
Comment on this
There was a suggestion by the Minister that some phrase like this was used at the end of the last inter-Party Government: "If you do not do this, we will go out and burst the Government". What happened is quite a simple matter. Mr. Seán MacBride came from the United States where he had been on business.
Comment on this
He met the executive of Clann na Poblachta and they decided that a motion of no confidence in the Government was to be put down by the Clann na Poblachta Party and the Government's majority was gone. "If you do not do this, we will go out and burst the Government". There was no question of the "this". The motion of no confidence was put down. I was in a position to know whether there were any discussions or not about it. There were no discussions. The Clann na Poblachta executive were quite entitled to do it that way.
Comment on this
It does not matter. I am making the case that they did not say: "If you do not do this, we will go out and burst the Government". There was no "this" about it.
Comment on this
The Minister said subsequently that he was concerned at a suggestion that, as Parties grow in strength, they grow in arrogance. He went on to justify that. His argument was that often the bigger the majority the more attention they have to pay to the public, that they feel they are representative of the whole public. Is that borne out by the facts anywhere in the world? If you take the ultimate in the size of Parties you have the Fascist State or the Communist State. They have a form of election there and there you have the complete Party. Is there any suggestion or are we suggesting that these Parties are not more arrogant than Parties can be in a democratic State? We all believe they are more arrogant. We know they are more arrogant.
Finally, the Minister made a suggestion that P.R. was an instrument imposed on us for our destruction and division. The Minister suggested that in the case of Sligo that was brought forward in relation to that town although the British at the time would not build a road for them. Let me say this: Does the Minister know whether, in fact, the people in Sligo asked for it or not? I believe from the surrounding evidence the people of Sligo did ask for it. The Minister by-passed that and slid by that point. He kind of hinted that they did not ask for it. At the same time, I think it was fairly obvious that there was some approach by the people of Sligo about it.