An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 197–403 of 403. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
The sequence of events was that the Sligo Corporation got into financial trouble. They wanted to increase the rate, to increase their borrowing, so that they could keep the ordinary services going. They had not got the money. They were told that they could get these increased powers if in the same Bill they asked for P.R. The two things were linked. They could not get one without the other.
Comment on this
I have not paid much attention to this controversy. I understand it has been widespread in the Sligo papers. I did see one letter, in the Sunday Press, I think it was, which said that there was a meeting in the town of Sligo of the citizenry and that it was agreed by the citizenry that they would approach the Government of the day, that is, they would make an approach to Parliament to get a P.R. system in the town. I read that letter and that is what that letter said, that they would approach the British Government and ask them. I can well see why in the town of Sligo they wanted to have the business interest represented on the corporation and agreed to this. If the Minister says that they wanted money, I will accept the Minister's word for it.
This is a quotation, again in relation to the British: "They did it for he purpose of dividing us." First of all, you ask yourself did it divide us? Has P.R. ever, in fact, divided us or had any influence on the people?
One final point in relation to the Constitution. The first Constitution of this country said the following about the matter—I think this is germane——
Comment on this
The Constitution of the Irish Free State, Saorstát Éireann Act, 1922:—
"The members shall be elected upon principles of P.R."
Listen to it carefully:—
"The members shall be elected upon principles of P.R."
That was implemented in the Electoral Act, 1923. What was put into the 1937 Constitution was:—
"The members shall be elected on the system of P.R. by means of the single transferable vote."
Comment on this
They went further, definitely further, and I do not think that there has been any answer to that particular question so far in the discussion either in this House or in the Dáil.
I might say that it was with some reluctance that I was prevailed on to intervene in this debate. It is not because I have not the view that the Bill should be opposed. I have the view that the Bill should be opposed but I do not like speaking about problems that I do not profess are my territory. I attended many courses of lectures on the subject, politics, in a number of universities. Anywhere I went I attended the course on politics but I always felt that it was an extremely nebulous subject—nebulous, very difficult to get hold of. I must say that at 8 o'clock last night Senator L'Estrange had improved my education considerably. He brought the practice of politics in this country to ground level, something that my mind could grasp, in his account of five county councils where the Fianna Fáil people have a majority and they exclude everybody else, all the other councillors, from every association with the operation of the county council and the administration of services. That was something I could understand. That was arithmetical. That was totalitarian arithmetic and that was a piece of political action that I could understand all right.
Comment on this
Senator O'Donovan must be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
I think—and I am now going to speak for myself—that this Bill is the political last will and testament of the present Taoiseach, Éamon de Valera. It is an attempt to bestow this nation on his own Party, if he can do it. We all know by experience what happens in many cases in relation to harsh and unfair wills. In the first case, it may not be upheld in the courts. In this case, the lower courts are the Dáil and the Seanad, so, even if they find their way through these courts, there is a final immediate court of appeal—appeal to the people. It is more than an appeal: it is a court to which the case must go but there is, in fact, no finality about the matter. If it goes through this time it will come up for judgment at each election subsequently; it will come up again and again until, in my opinion, it will inevitably result perhaps in the complete obliteration of the Fianna Fáil Party at a time when it might be desirable that they should remain perhaps as the main Opposition in the Dáil.
I have not the gift of prophecy but let us not forget what happened to the Irish Party: I shall come back to the Irish Party and its methods of selection, and so on, later on. On a number of occasions the Taoiseach spoke in the Dáil about meeting people between 1948 and 1951 who were in accord with his view that P.R. should be abolished. One asks oneself how is it that he did not mention it until 1958? Is it not obvious that the Taoiseach is using his imagination in that or did he expect people to say to him, when he drew down the question of P.R.: "I disagree with you entirely, Chief" or "Mr. de Valera", depending on the person? If it was a Fine Gael person he would say "Mr. de Valera"—he was then the Leader of the Opposition. If it was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party he would say "Chief".
Comment on this
In the Seanad, the Senator will refer to him as "the Taoiseach".
Comment on this
I am stating a fact. I have referred to him as "the Taoiseach, Mr. de Valera." I mentioned his name once. I am talking about the conversation that would have taken place when he was not Taoiseach. I think I am quite within my rights to speak that way.
I think it would occur to anybody, in relation to the statesmanship of this matter, that, in any other democracy in Western Europe, if a serious constitutional change of this sort were about to be made, there would be consultation with the Opposition Parties before bringing it forward. I think there is no doubt whatsoever about that. If there had been such an approach, I think a compromise solution might have been possible. The Senators can think of the compromise solution for themselves.
Comment on this
We have had a number of commissions in this country on various problems. For example, we had a very big commission which reported on the track performances of greyhounds and other performances in relation to greyhounds and a Bill was introduced. Yet, we have an amendment to the Constitution and there is no question of setting up any group of people to study it or advise the Government about it.
In his speech when introducing this Bill here the Taoiseach said, as reported at column 251 of Volume 50 of the Official Report of Seanad Eireann: "We have a system of representative democracy here." That is perfectly true. What has he set out to do? In this Bill, he is setting out to make it less representative. At the foot of column 251 and the top of column 252 we read this statement by the Taoiseach in relation to inter-Party Governments: "It is a game of poker at the Government meetings instead of frank discussion." How does the Taoiseach know that? I sat at Government meetings for three years and I never saw a game of poker played at them.
Comment on this
Since questions of card games have been introduced, there are stories which most of us have heard in our lifetime about the innocent young fellow coming back from abroad with some money and being caught out by a group of card sharpers. If he turned out to be a good card player what did the card sharpers do? They tried to vary the rules. They would say: "You can have only one straight flush in a game", or: "You can get fours only once." I think there is a little bit of a card game in this matter.
I should like to come back to the suggestions about those words that are used. The first words I noticed in relation to this matter were that it was a "national question". Every matter which becomes of importance to the Fianna Fáil Party, by that very fact, becomes a national question in this country. If it becomes of importance to the Fianna Fáil Party—it does not matter whether it is the starting of a new newspaper, an evening or a Sunday paper, or whatever it is—it is a national question. I could add in this sense, using the words "national question", if we accept my definition, what is the Irish nation in this sense? Is it the 600,000 people who voted for Fianna Fáil—one-seventh of the population? After all, if that is what a national question means in this country and in this context I am prepared to accept that.
I think, again, that there is in all this an element of the "bread and circuses" but do not forget that there can be no bread in it, whether free bread or cheap bread, because the price of bread has gone up 60 per cent. since Fianna Fáil came into office. Therefore, we are to have one circus— not circuses but one circus. I will give the Taoiseach credit; he is an excellent ringmaster in the matter. Genuinely, I am not saying that cynically or anything else: I think the Taoiseach does understand how to handle those problems very well.
The other word used, which has been adverted to by Senator Stanford, a word I used to notice a great deal from Mr. Lemass in 1953 and which, strangely enough, he used at a meeting of some association on the very night on which Senator Stanford used it here, is the word "stability". Mr. Lemass kept talking about stability during the whole of the year 1953 although the cost of living had gone up 17 points the previous year through his Government's action. He said: "We now have stability", on the very night that the word was used here by Senator Stanford. In other words, you are on a different plane. If that is the meaning of it, I am quite prepared to accept it.
But when you get down to the pure political side of the thing, we must admit that we have had only three Prime Minister in this country since 1922. If that is instability, I do not know where stability exists. I think there is an extreme form of Party egotism in this matter, the essence of which is: "Who is to replace us?" as if the mould only existed between 1880-1900 and was then broken or lost with the turn of the century. In fact, when we think about stability—I will not dilate on it—I would say that we have had a drop of 150,000 persons in the population of this country in the past few years. We have stability there on a different plane. We knock 5 per cent. off the population and there is not quite so much unemployment.
Another term that I hear in this matter is "the people". Senator Ted O'Sullivan referred to the matter and I can paraphrase his words. He said, extremely well I thought, in different ways, that Fine Gael are trying to keep this Bill from the people. The fact that the Fine Gael Party opposed the First Reading in the Dáil was indicative of their serious objection to the proposals in the Bill. It had nothing to do with keeping it from the people. Nothing that they could do would keep it from the people as they are in a minority in the Dáil. Why were they not entitled to object to the First Reading if in fact they did not like what was in the Bill?
Comment on this
They had a duty, of course. I think that this Bill is a blatant attempt to take away a certain part of the people's liberty. These liberties and powers have been gradually chipped off. Let me give as an example the way in which the powers of the local councils were chipped away down the years until the last Coalition Government came into power. The powers of the representatives in the local bodies were chipped away and reduced to very limited proportions. That had a certain effect on the working of those bodies and the last inter-Party Government did attempt to do something about it.
Another word which has been used is "democracy". Let us not forget that the Soviet people have used this word in their propaganda since the war, all over the world. I notice that a Deputy in the Dáil recently spoke about "their system of democracy" in relation to Soviet Russia. I do not understand that kind of usage in relation to words, and I do not pretend to understand it. I do not understand the word as applied in Italy during the Fascist régime, and in Germany during the Nazi régime, and it was used in both places.
Now, the question is—the Fianna Fáil Party suggest—that you should have effective Government. All modern Governments have plenty of power. Technological developments, communications of all sorts, starting with the railways and going on to the roads, the telephone and wireless, all result in a centralisation of power in the central Government of any country. It is a completely different situation to what it was 100 years ago. Anybody who suggests that the Government in a country have not got ample powers already is fooling himself for one thing. Once you have a Government established, if you have a system, as in France, where they did not have to go back to the people but just kept chopping Ministries around—not under P.R.; it had nothing to do with P.R.; it was because they did not have to go back to the people again, and even did without a Government for a period— I think that is quite an abnormal situation. If the French Deputies had to go back to their constituencies again they would not have had these lacunae Governments which they did have.
I think Senator O'Brien put the matter extremely well when he said, as reported at column 317, that the powers of the Seanad should be strengthened. The problem now in modern States, with which most representatives should concern themselves, is the problem of the filching away by the central Government of the natural rights of the citizens, and that is being constantly done. In relation to Government, I agree with the view that there is greater danger of tyranny than of anarchy. If we like we can take the phrase—"Government of the people, by the people, for the people." Who are the people in this context? What does the essence of the problem mean? Does it mean the 45 per cent. of the people who have been voting for Fianna Fáil, and who really are only 30 per cent. at most of the population—that is to say, about three adults out of every ten? Are they "the people" in this context? I do not understand the phrase "the people" in that way. Every man has the same natural rights and the other seven people have just as many rights as the three who vote for the Fianna Fáil Party.
I should like to advert to a point about statistics. I have noticed in the little book by Mr. Ross about the Irish election system, that, from the point of view of the Fianna Fáil Party, the results have been excellent. In every election since 1923 they got more than their proper proportion of seats. In 1943, they got 9 seats more than they should have got. That was the election in which they were shaken. In the last election, in 1957, the Fianna Fáil Party got seven seats more than they should have got. That means that under the present system the bigger Parties get their seats at a cheaper price than small Parties.
There has been a good deal of talk throughout the debate—and the matter was adverted to by the Taoiseach—about the question of duplication of elections. Somebody asked, I think very appropriately, why was there not a second election in 1952. There are various explanations for that. It is suggested—I am not making the suggestion—that it was because agreement was made with the Independent Deputies that there would be no election for three years. I have a different explanation for it. I believe, and it would take a good deal to shake my belief, that the real reason was that the reaction to Deputy MacEntee's Budget was so severe that the Taoiseach knew he would be in for a heavy defeat if there was another election.
Comment on this
Nothing will shake my belief that the Taoiseach knew he would be heavily defeated and he kept on postponing an election for as long as he could on a very shaky majority until he was in the position when he had no longer any majority.
When we talk about the American election system we must remember it is not the same as the British system. What is proposed here is the British election system and, I am reminded, it is also the system in the Six Counties. In the American election system there are what are called primary elections. You register as a Democrat, or as a Republican, and you are then entitled to vote in the primary elections. That leads to a certain amount of hoofling for this reason, that many Republicans can register as Democrats and put in a less strong candidate as a Democrat than the man who might be elected. They can vote for the candidate they would like to see up, the man they can more easily defeat in the main election. I think it is a defective system in that way.
Senator Lenihan asked me a question earlier this evening and I promised to reply to it. I come to it now. He asked how it was that the first inter-Party Government came to an end in June, 1951. The circumstances are quite plain to anybody who reads the debate. The popular opinion about the matter is, in my view, all wrong. The break-up took place on quite a simple issue, on the Vote for Agriculture when certain Independent Deputies, Deputy Cogan, Deputy O'Reilly of Cavan, and Deputy Lehane of Cork, said they were going to vote against the Estimate. There were discussions on the matter and the inter-Party Government at that time were not prepared to pay the price those Deputies wanted. Therefore, there was no bargaining.
Comment on this
It does not matter. They were not prepared to pay it, but the Fianna Fáil Party are in trouble about it since.
Comment on this
Yes, and they have had to cut it when the cost of living has gone up 20 per cent. Having paid the price in 1951, they had to cut it in 1958, seven years later when the cost of living had risen about 20 per cent. That is the history of the matter. There had been difficulties, certainly, about a Clann na Poblachta Minister earlier but they were over for three months at that time. Senators can go back to that time and they will find that these are the facts. They are quite easy to check. Deputy Dr. Browne had resigned three months earlier. In fact, as anybody might point out the inter-Party Government won that election.
Comment on this
If anybody would like to hear the results I shall read them out. Fianna Fáil got 68 seats, Fine Gael got 40, Labour got 16, Clann na Talmhan 6, Clann na Poblachta 2, and 14 Independents were elected. Four of these Independents elected by inter-Party votes joined the Fianna Fáil Government and subsequently paid the penalty at the following election. Every one of them went, even the man who joined the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil formed a Government of collusion as against Coalition.
Comment on this
Coming to general political points, I think the Fianna Fáil Party is falling behind public opinion and has been behind it for a very long time. That does happen to Parties led by old men and even more important, perhaps, than the men being old is whether they have been a long time in politics.
Comment on this
I depends on what the Senator means by "ahead". If he means that Fianna Fáil want to take away their liberties, then I agree with the Senator——
Comment on this
No. We are thinking far in advance of them but now the Senator says we are far behind them.
Comment on this
It is always the case that conventional wisdom, as it is called, in these matters is leagues behind public opinion. That is especially so in a country where there are three daily papers, the most progressive of which is the Irish Times——
Comment on this
I shall come back on it later. We have three daily papers one of which, according to Senator Ó Maoláin, is the organ of the Fine Gael Party. I must say I have never noticed it. To my mind, the Irish Press represents two things: the Fianna Fáil Party personified by the Taoiseach and the new industrialists. The Irish Independent represents politically the older established order of society here. Let me put a name to it and say it represents the old Nationalist Party, the old Irish Party. It is closer to representing that than it is to representing Fine Gael. I believe in being fair and it is a fact that the Independent has taken a very specific line on this matter.
Senator Ó Maoláin complained that they did not publish letters. The Senator's letters are not the only ones that were not published by the Independent.
Comment on this
Well, I sent them one myself and they did not publish it. At the end of his speech Senator Carter referred to the transfer of votes in Longford-Westmeath in the last general election. I did not check up on it; I take his word that 1,000 Fine Gael votes were transferred to the Sinn Féin candidate who is now Deputy Rory Brady. I do not know Deputy Brady but a colleague of mine who was concerned with his education spoke to me very highly about him. Is it not possible that these Fine Gael supporters preferred to give their second or third preferences, or whatever it was, to Deputy Brady rather than to Senator Carter? I am not saying that if I were there I would do it, knowing Senator Carter——
Comment on this
Are we to take it that the Front Bench in the Seanad, representing Fine Gael, are advocating votes for unconstitutional candidates? Are we to infer that from the Senator's argument?
Comment on this
No, I am simply giving a possible explanation of why the transfers did not all go to Senator Carter. Let me advert to an incident that happened in a constituency which I know well. One of the Fianna Fáil supporters said to me: "We would rather so-and-so was elected than another person." I had been at the election and I was watching the transfer of votes and I said to a Fianna Fáil supporter: "Your votes went one, two; two, one; one, two; and they did not show much evidence of that preference". The man said to me: "That is an entirely different matter. We had to survive ourselves." In other words, he was just indulging in a piece of palaver and there was no serious intention of a real preference to one candidate rather than another.
When people talk about the transfer of votes they should realise that for people who are not Fianna Fáil, the voting goes: One, two, three, four, five, six; but I see the Fianna Fáil papers marked: One, two; two, one; where there are two Fianna Fáil candidates, or if there are four Fianna Fáil candidates: One, two, three, four; three, two, one, four and so on. If there are only two candidates, the voting goes: One, two, two, one, two, one—if the voters are given equal instructions—and never a vote for anybody else. So that anybody in the Fianna Fáil Party who says that the Fine Gael voters should have voted for himself or anybody else in any constituency—well, all I can say is they must expect completely different treatment from what they give to other people.
Comment on this
I did not say any such thing; I did not make that point. I made the point that the Fine Gael Party advocated, and are advocating in this House, that the elector should vote for unconstitutional candidates.
Comment on this
What constitutes an unconstitutional candidates?
Comment on this
I should like to advert to a few points in conclusion. Senator Lenihan adverted to this point —and I would not refer to it now except that he made the same statement on the Finance Bill last year. In speaking about the Government White Paper, he said: "The banks have confidence in the Government of the day." Are we to take it that this is a continuance of Deputy MacEntee's vicious campaign in 1956 to the effect that the country was bust, a campaign which he engineered underground and in relation to which he came out in the open only on the debate on the second lot of levies?
Comment on this
There must be no further crosstalk. All remarks must be addressed to the Chair.
Comment on this
"The banks have confidence in the Government of the day." We all know that the commercial banks' liquid assets in London began to go down and gradually were reduced until they reached a level that the banks thought required attention from them. I did not agree with the opinion of the banks and I do not agree to-day with the opinion of the banks, but they were entitled to have that opinion. They were operating a certain system, but there was no question of the banks having confidence in the Government of the day. That is very close to being an unconstitutional remark also.
I have one or two other points. In this House, there are 11 nominees of the Taoiseach. We all know what the position is. Every independent Senator, except perhaps Senator Cole who was nominated by the Taoiseach, has spoken about this measure.
Comment on this
I am talking about this House. Would anybody tell me why all these independent people are inclined to take that line? Is it not because they feel there is something to fear in this measure? They are not subject to any influence by the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party——
Comment on this
——and I do not believe anybody in either Party has attempted to influence them. I want to speak about another distinguished person in this country who is quoted by Senator Tomás Ó Maoláin, that is, Earnán de Blaghd. Mr. de Blaghd has been out of Irish politics for 25 years. He has come back in various publications on this question of P.R. I do not know what his standing is in relation to this matter. I believe it is nil.
Comment on this
I believe it is nil. He was responsible for putting his Party out of office for 16 years; he did such stupid, ignorant things in relation to finance, taking 1/- off the old age pensions——
Comment on this
It is not usual in this House to refer to outsiders in those terms. Gentlemen outside this House are not in a position to defend themselves. It is not fair to attack them.
Comment on this
It is most unfair that a distinguished Irish gentleman should be attacked here by a Senator.
Comment on this
As far as his standing is concerned, I think it can be said that since 1932, week after week in many publications, he has written on every subject including politics.
Comment on this
Senator O'Donovan must be allowed to continue.
Comment on this
I shall just make this remark. I do not believe he would get 500 votes in any constituency in Ireland to-day, and I shall leave it at that. Senator Colley when speaking last night about the way P.R. works, said that if there are 7,000 first preference votes cast and those voters have a candidate elected, they get no second, third or fourth choice. Why should they? Have they not had their full vote? I do not know whether Senator Colley was making a joke of the matter or was so concerned about the arithmetical mechanism that he did not understand what he was talking about.
Comment on this
The record will show whether I understood or not. They are single transferable votes.
Comment on this
Votes which have received full value are not transferable and are allowed to have no further effect in the election. There may be people who do not understand the system. That does not prevent their using it perfectly well. There are many operations in industry, in every walk of life, in which people engage every day while not understanding the reasons for them. I think that Senator Quinlan, who appealed to the Taoiseach at the end of his speech, to think about this matter again, will get a very dusty answer.
It has become fashionable to read quotations. I have a few quotations from Parnell and his Party by Conor Cruise O'Brien, which show the effect through time of the highly centralised Party. The author speaks about the élite as it came into existence in 1883. It consisted of about half the Party. I am quoting from page 146:—
"This body was too cumbrous for the effective manipulation of power, and there was a tendency for an informal inner managerial clique to grow up consisting of ‘the Lieutenants' as they were called, that is men who were politically close to Parnell and trusted by him (and who were not necessarily officers of the Party). This group consisted initially of Healy, Sexton and J.J. O'Kelly; later elections added Dr. J.E. Kenny, Timothy Harrington and William O'Brien."
It goes on to describe how they operated in relation to the 1885 election, to show how they went around the country attending the conventions. O'Kelly attended the 14; Sexton, 10; Healy, 9; Bigger, 9; Parnell, 6; Harrington, 6; T.D. Sullivan, 6; William O'Brien, 9; Dillon, 4; and John Redmond, 4. It then refers to John Redmond being a young man, and the footnote ends as follows:—
"As for Dillon, who had just returned to public life after an absence of over three years, it is probable that he was still in some degree suspect for his earlier tendency to pursue an independent policy."
Comment on this
I am interested only in finding out whether Senator O'Donovan is quoting this old stuff of 75 years ago as what is happening to-day.
Comment on this
The Chair and the House have been very considerate, in particular towards Senator L'Estrange. May I ask him now to try to repay that compliment to the House?
Comment on this
This is my final point on this Bill. I am quoting now from page 147:—
"The lamentations of men like F.H. O'Donnell about the rising power of the Party machine were futile. A united Party was essential if anything practical was to be achieved, and a united Party was necessarily a disciplined one and therefore machine-controlled. The sacrifices involved—including often the rejection of individuals of high integrity and ability in favour of pliant henchmen—had to be accepted if political effectiveness was to be secured. Similarly, it is not necessary to cite Mitchel's iron law of oligarchy' in order to show that the rise of some sort of Party directorate, intermediate between the leader and the rank and file, is bound to come with any high degree of organisation."
It goes on to say:—
"The type of machine finally adopted in Ireland seems to have been more powerful in its limited sphere than the liberal one."
—that is the Liberal Party in England—
"No Irish ‘county convention'"
—this is how it becomes germane to the present situation—
"could stand up to Parnellite dictation in the way the liberal association of, say, Bradford or Liverpool could, if necessary, resist the liberal executive. Ostrogorski regarded it as a rare occurrence for the liberal central organisation to bring ‘regular pressure to bear' on a local association in favour of a candidate.... On the whole the comment of the Irish Times (2nd October, 1885) on the working of the convention system seems justified: ‘This process of finding a parliamentary representation is unique. There has not been anything like it’.”
—the Party grew very largely after this 1885 election—
"The new members, as we have seen, were hand-picked, pledge-bound, and paid out of Party funds. The ‘policy of the Party' came down to them from above, from the leader and his lieutenants, and they had no choice but to obey. But the party policy was still, in essentials, the Kilmainham policy, i.e., a strictly constitutional anti-revolutionary policy, which could probably only have been framed at a period when the social make-up of the party was relatively upper class, and its political make-up contained large conservative elements. That it was possible to continue this policy smoothly through and after the general election of 1885 with the greatly widened suffrage and consequent choice of more plebeian representatives, was due in a large measure to the development of the Party machine in the years between the Kilmainham treaty and the general election."
—the Kilmainham treaty being the treaty between the Liberal Party and the Parnellite Party—
"Throughout that period the Healys and the Harringtons, the engineers of the party, had been hard at work, so that, when the flood of mass-democracy rose, it did not sweep away the Kilmainham edifice, but was held in new and solid dykes."
One final word from the book:—
"It is notable that not one of the 50-odd new members of the Irish Party returned in the 1885-1886 elections under the National League system of managed conventions, ever rose to any sort of leadership in the Party, although many of them had very long parliamentary careers. By their selection the ‘lieutenants' ensured not merely the provision of a solid block of votes for any Parnellite policy, but their own continued predominance in the councils of the party."
Comment on this
May I ask the Senator one historical question arising from that? Is it not true that that was the only effective period the Irish Party ever had?
Comment on this
As we are dealing with constitutional matters, I should like to draw the attention of the House to the very significant remark made by Senator O'Donovan when making a rather savage attack on Mr. Blythe, because Mr. Blythe was no longer willing to toe the Party line. One of the many criticisms made of the Coalition Government was the fact that they were unable, or unwilling, to abide by the principle of collective responsibility. Most people regarded that as arising from the nature of the Coalition Governments, but apparently as far as Fine Gael are concerned, that failure to abide by the principle of collective responsibility goes back much further, because Senator O'Donovan named Mr. Blythe for the terrible financial blunders he made, which apparently were responsible for Cumann na nGaedheal's misfortune. Apparently, even at that time, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government did not conform to the principle of collective responsibility. The blame is put on Mr. Blythe only; the remaining members of the Cabinet, apparently, are taking no responsibility whatever for what he did.
One of the points made in the course of this debate was that no reference to the proposed amendment of the Constitution was made in the last general election. It was suggested by a number of speakers that we should have told the people in the last general election that we proposed to make this change. But I am sure Senators are all well aware that the only way in which an amendment to the Constitution can take place is by a referendum. So that, even if Fianna Fáil had said at the last election that they proposed to make this change, or even if the people had given them an overwhelming majority on that issue, it would have had no effect whatever. It would still have been necessary to introduce this Bill and to have a referendum to ascertain the wishes of the people on this point.
Therefore, it is of no consequence whatever, and it is not a valid point, to say that Fianna Fáil are in some way to blame because they did not mention this at the last election. As a matter of fact, Fianna Fáil would have been wrong to mention it at the last election, because the Constitution lays down that when a Bill is being introduced to hold a referendum in connection with an amendment of the Constitution, that Bill should contain no other proposal. In other words, the issue should not be mixed up with any other issue.
Comment on this
In the same way it would have been quite wrong for the Fianna Fáil Party to mix up the question of an amendment of the Constitution with the various other issues, the economic position and so on, which were mentioned in the general election. Therefore, I suggest that Fianna Fáil were quite right and were acting very properly in refusing to allow this issue to be confused with the various other issues which were dealt with during the general election.
The Government are approaching this amendment in the way in which the Constitution says it should be approached. In doing that, they are approaching it in a very responsible and very proper manner. It has been suggested also that quite apart from the last general election nobody in the country, none of the Fianna Fáil leaders or anybody else, mentioned P.R. or discussed it during the past ten or 15 years. It has been suggested that the Taoiseach did not become a convert to the straight vote and certainly did not express any views about it until the last two years. A number of quotations have been given in the Dáil—quotations not only from the Taoiseach but from a number of other people on both sides of the House—giving their views on P.R. I shall not give the House these quotations which have been given before, but I shall quote from a very interesting article I have here. It is an article by the late Sir B.N. Rawle who was constitutional adviser to the Indian Constituent Assembly. The article, for those who would like to check up on it, to see if I am quoting it accurately, appeared in a paper called The Hindu published in Madras on 23rd January, 1958.
Comment on this
Sir B.N. Rawle describes his visit to Dublin in November, 1947. He says: "I had the privilege of an interview with Mr. de Valera, who was most cordial and considerate. He remarked that if he had a chance of rewriting the Irish Constitution he would make three changes, and the first of the three changes that he would make— he would do away with P.R. in any shape or form. He preferred the British system as it made for strong Government."
Comment on this
It was published in India. Now, it is clear from that that, in 1947, the Taoiseach had the very strong and very definite view that P.R. was a system of which he no longer approved. I would once again remind those who mention 1948 as a vital date governing the Taoiseach's change of mind that that was in 1947.
The issue of P.R. and the straight vote is now being put to the people. What is before us at the moment? The Bill before us is not any piece of permanent legislation. We are not proposing to do anything; we are not proposing to amend the Constitution. We are merely attempting to give the people an opportunity of giving us their view on it. I find it difficult to understand the attitude of Senators who propose to vote against this Bill. I understand fully the attitude of Senators who have spoken against the Bill, who have objected to the Bill and who have said some very extravagant things about the Bill. They are perfectly entitled to do that. But it is difficult to understand the attitude of a Senator who does not want the people to have an opportunity of expressing their view. I think it can only be concluded that a Senator who does not want to have the view of the people is himself taking the view that the people are not entitled to give their view, that they are not capable of giving their view; or possibly—it is just possible—the Senator concerned is afraid that the people might express their view in a way the Senator would not like.
There have been strong protests from Fine Gael against our trying to put through something now without consulting the people, meaning without consulting the people in the course of the last general election. That comes rather strangely from Fine Gael, or from any member of the Coalition, having regard to the way in which the Republic of Ireland Bill was put through in 1949, not only without consulting the people, but in the teeth of the professed policy of Fine Gael. A referendum at that time would have been a very useful means of ascertaining whether or not the people wanted that Bill; but Fine Gael, at that time, not having consulted the people in the previous general election and not having given the people an opportunity of expressing their wishes by way of referendum, put the Bill through regardless of what the wishes of the people were.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Opposition at that time never asked for that. We are asking for it now.
Comment on this
One other point made is that the demand for this Bill is not there, that nobody wants it. First of all, it is unlikely that the man in the street will take the initiative in introducing a change of this kind. Any reform of the electoral system is, in the natural course of events, likely to come from one or other of the Parties. It is likely to come from those who are interested in politics and interested in the mechanics of politics. It is only natural that some Party should take the lead in introducing a Bill of this kind. Fianna Fáil believe that the demand is there. From my own experience, I believe a great many people want a change to the straight vote, but I am quite willing to admit that I may be wrong. I am quite willing to admit that Fianna Fáil may be wrong. Perhaps we are wrong. The referendum which we propose to hold, and which we are asking this House to allow us to hold, is to find out whether or not we are wrong. We may be wrong. Where is the use in asking whether or not there is a demand or whether or not we may be wrong in thinking there is a demand? There is a very easy way to find out whether or not the demand is there. The referendum is the way to do it. Why not, therefore, see whether there is a demand by way of referendum?
Another point made is that the Bill is a distraction, that there are so many other things that should be done, we should not be worrying about this issue at the moment. The implications in that is that perhaps the Bill is a good one, that perhaps the change to the straight vote would be a good idea, but at the moment it is a distraction: that we have not time to deal with it at the moment; but, if there is any truth in the suggestion that it is a good one, then surely it is a good one now at this moment, just as good as it would be two or three years hence. It may be that the Bill is badly timed. I am not admitting that it is, but it may be that the Government are showing bad timing in attempting to introduce the change now. Be that as it may, the Bill is before the House now, the proposal is on its way to the country now and, if it is ever to be a good idea, if there is any truth in the suggestion or the implication that it may be a good thing, then it may be a good thing now just as well as at any other time.
There is a further point with regard to the argument that the Bill is a distraction. It might be better to have one good distraction now rather than have a series of distractions in the future. In the past, quite apart from the Coalition days, it was necessary to hold second elections. During the Fianna Fáil term of office, there was a second election in 1933, in 1938 and in 1944. These were all serious distractions. They were all distractions at a time when great work was being done to develop the country. Had it not been necessary to hold these second elections in those years, more work would have been done, and it would have been done more quickly. They were serious distractions. The elections held during the time of the Coalition were also serious distractions. I suggest it may be well worth while to have a good distraction now, if you choose to regard it as a distraction, rather than have many distractions in the future.
I think that if P.R. continues and if the Party structure and the developments which have been taking place continue under P.R. it is almost certain there will be many distractions in the future, many attempts to form Governments, many failures to form Governments and frequent elections. Therefore, if it is a distractions, I suggest it is well worth while having the distraction now, getting it over with and looking forward to a future in which we shall not have many distractions of a similar kind.
It has been suggested by Senator Quinlan and, I think, by Senator O'Donovan, that we should be set up a commission. I should be very interested to know who would be on that commission and where we are to look for the experts for the commission. What kind of experts can we hope to find outside the Houses of the Oireachtas who would be so much better qualified to deal with an electoral system than we?
Comment on this
Is it not quite clear that the people best qualified to deal with the electoral system, or the amending of the electoral system, are the members of the Dáil and Seanad?
Comment on this
On a point of order, I answered that question pretty fully in my speech. Perhaps the Senator was not present.
Comment on this
It is quite clear that in the Dáil and Seanad there are people who are best qualified to deal with that problem, both from the theoretical and the practical point of view. We have, from time to time in the past, been severely criticised when Bills were introduced dealing with agriculture, industry, the professions, and so on, because it was suggested we were attempting to deal with subjects we knew nothing about. It was suggested that we were interfering in vocational matters and so on, and attempting to dictate to those spheres of society on something about which we could not be expected to know anything. Surely if there is one thing that we can expected to know something about, one type of subject on which we can claim to be experts, it is anything to do with the electoral system.
The suggestion of setting up a commission is the purest nonsense and although I was not here when Senator Quinlan claims he answered the question which I put, I just cannot imagine who he suggested should be on that commission, who would be better qualified to deal with that subject than the members of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
On a point of information, I suggested M. Schumann of France, Professor Hoftstee of Holland and Lord Pakenham of England, as only three of the many good friends of Ireland who would help us in every way possible.
Comment on this
I am very grateful for Senator Quinlan's help in the matter, but I cannot say I am very impressed by his suggestion.
Comment on this
Would Senator Lenihan please try to act in a manner befitting a member of this House? There will be less difficulty, if he does so. Will Senator Lenihan please respect the views of the Chair?
Comment on this
If a commission of both Houses were set up, bringing in experts, we would almost certainly end up with a commission of theorists and amateur politicians who would almost certainly bring in recommendations which would be quite impracticable and in saying that there is a possibility that this kind of commission of outside experts might bring in impracticable suggestions, I should like to quote the words of a man known to us all, a man who is very quotable. Possibly Senators may have heard this quotation before on a number of occasions but it is very relevant. The quotation is part of what Deputy Dillon said on 12th November, 1947. He said:—
"P.R. is, in fact, as we all know in our hearts, the child of the brains of all the cranks in creation. So far as this country is concerned, it was tried out on the dog. I doubt if any other sane democratic country in the world has put it into operation in regard to its Parliament... it is true to say that the kind of P.R. that we have operating in this country has not been adopted in any other country. It was foisted upon us by a collection of half-lunatics who believed that they had something lovely that would work on paper like a jig-saw puzzle, but like all these crank ideas in operation, it has resulted here in an election in 1931, an election in 1932, an election in 1938, an election in 1939, an election in 1943, and an election in 1944."
That is the kind of thing——
Comment on this
Would the Senator give the source of the quotation for the purpose of the record?
Comment on this
It is to be found in the Dáil Reports of 12th November, 1947.
Comment on this
The Dáil Debates of November, 1947. Deputy Dillon was talking about the kind of electoral system that you get from a bunch of cranks who sit down and think they have some wonderful system which seems to be beautiful on paper but when put into operation does not work out.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange should permit Senator Ryan, who does not interrupt other Senators, to continue his speech.
Comment on this
If Senator L'Estrange behaves himself, I shall tell a little story about him later on.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange, I hope, will behave himself. I shall see to it that every Senator, no matter on which side of the House, will behave himself.
Comment on this
That is the kind of crank recommendation which we are likely to get from the commission and, therefore, I am completely against the suggestion. I think it would not work out in practice to be nearly so good, or so practical, or so fruitful, as the discussions on this proposal have been in the Dáil and the Seanad.
I believe an electoral system should conform to three rules. First, it should provide effective government; secondly, it should provide the machinery whereby the Government can be changed at regular intervals; thirdly—and I put them in that order —it should provide a Dáil which is broadly representative.
The first essential is effective government. Far too much emphasis is being placed in these debates on representation, on mathematical representation, on attempting to give every minority the exact proportion of representation to which it would be entitled according to the proportion of the population it represents. Fundamentally, the electoral system has to provide a Government and there is no use in providing a Dáil, no matter how representative it is, if it cannot carry on the business of the country. The Dáil is not a place where we can be satisfied to have Deputies who glory in the fact that they represent an exact section of the population. It is not merely a place where Deputies can be satisfied to discuss matters and to achieve nothing. Unless the Dáil gives effect to the wishes of the people whom the Deputies represent, then it is useless and will certainly, in due course, deteriorate into some kind of anarchy.
The present system of what is referred to as P.R., is defended on its merits as a representative system. In fact, it is not P.R. because it does not give representation to minorities. At present, the Dáil consists of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Talmhan and a few other Independents and small Parties. Do any of these Parties represent minorities? Neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael purport to represent minorities; they both purport to represent all sections of the community. Clann na Talmhan does, I think, make a claim, though not a very strong one, to represent the farmers of the country. But even if they do make the claim, it is quite clear that they have not succeeded in acting as the spokesmen of the farmers so that they do not represent the minority here.
Labour purports to speak on behalf of the trade unions. Labour to some extent does represent the minority. It comes nearer to representing a minority than any other Party in the Dáil but, even so, it does not get anything like the position which it should have if it represented, in fact, the unions or labour so that if you look at the Dáil at the moment the position is that the present system has not given us a Dáil in which minorities are represented. It has failed to do that and, consequently, it is not deserving of our support or our confidence.
Deputy Sheldon, when speaking on this Bill in the Dáil, said that one of the reasons he was voting for the amendment—and I quote him—was that: "the present system appears to be doing something which it is not doing." That, I believe, is one of the principal arguments against the present system. It purports to be P.R. It purports to give representation to minorities but if you look at the Dáil at the moment the fact of the matter is that it is not doing that.
Of course, as has already been said, the system is not P.R. in its proper form because if it were we would have one big constituency. If we had one big constituency, which the members opposite have hastened to assure us they do not want, the position, assuming for the moment a Dáil of 100 members, would be that anybody with 1 per cent. or fewer of the votes could have a member. That would mean that we would have everybody represented in the Dáil. We would have tinkers, tailors, soldiers, sailors, rich men, poor men, beggarmen and thieves. Everybody would be represented. You would have splendid representation then but it is quite clear that it would be quite impossible to form a Government and, consequently, I do not think anybody would want that system. To that extent nobody really wants P.R. although many people at the moment are saying they are fighting for its retention.
I should like just to quote a few words to the House from page 20 of Professor Hogan's book, Election and Representation:—
"Therefore the nearer the approach to proportionality, that is the larger the size of the constituency, the easier it is for all sorts of minorities to elect their own candidates with their own votes, and so the easier it becomes for them to set up separate political Parties without having to accommodate their points of view and policies to those of other Parties, or without concerning themselves with the interests of the community at large. Hence the tendency of P.R. to act as an instrument of dissociation, to release minorities from the framework of the major political Parties into which they would have had to fit themselves under the majority system. In short, P.R. not merely reflects existing minorities, but tends to manufacture them, producing separate political Parties at the expense of the major political Parties.
One incidental but most important result in view of the revolutionary ferment prevailing in the world to-day is that not merely is a new stimulus thereby given to the legitimate ambition of minorities to assert themselves politically but new possibilities of representation are opened up for the illicit ambitions of those minority groups of an extremist and revolutionary character, which under the majority system would have little hope of finding their way into Parliament in order to use it as a platform for disseminating anti-democratic and anti-parliamentary ideas and policies."
Comment on this
I wonder would Senator Ryan tell us what he says about majorities? The Senator is talking about minorities.
Comment on this
I have several other things to quote from Professor Hogan's book.
Comment on this
And a special part of the conclusion for the benefit of Senator Quinlan.
Comment on this
The Senator must be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
In dealing with the rights of minorities Senator Stanford, in a rather restrained way, and Senator L'Estrange in anything but a restrained way, dealt with the question of those groups which might be denied representation under the new system and who would as a result resort to unconstitutional means. I think it is not a very good practice to suggest to these groups that if they do not get representation under the new system they are more or less justified in resorting to unconstitutional means.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I qualified that statement by saying that our Party never stood for unconstitutional means since 1921.
Comment on this
Is that a point of order? The front benchers stood for it to-night, but they are asleep now.
Comment on this
I suggest that it is a very dangerous doctrine to propose, that any minority—and I am not talking merely about minorities which are likely to resort to violence—unable to get representation is entitled, or may or could resort to other means. Is every minority, no matter how small, to take it that if they cannot get representation they can look for other means of achieving their object? Where do you stop with minorities? What minority, of what size, has a right to representation and what minority has no right to representation and no right to take other means of achieving its objects?
It is very easy to say that at the present time we should keep the status quo. It is very convenient for the members of the smaller Parties who are represented at the moment to say that things are all right as they are now, that minorities are getting due representation as things stand at the moment because the particular Party concerned is getting representation. Senator Murphy, speaking on this subject, said that it was only right and fair that a Party the size of the Labour Party should be represented and it was only right, he said, with some reluctance, that a Party of the size of Clann na Talmhan should get representation. Then be referred to Clann na Poblachta and said that perhaps a few years ago they were entitled to representation. It is clear that Senator Murphy was looking at it from his own point of view. He was judging who should get representation on this basis: “My Party is entitled to it, anyhow, and possibly a Party a little smaller than my Party, just in case my Party goes down a little at any time, but we must have a limit”.
When is a minority not a minority? Who is to decide at what stage a minority no longer has any rights of representation? Who is to decide that a minority in the country with the support of 50,000 people is entitled to representation, but a minority with 49,000 people is not entitled to any representation? I suggest that when one begins to examine that problem it is impossible to find an answer. It has been said about peace that "one cannot divide peace," that it is indivisible. Much the same goes for representation. One cannot say that one minority is entitled and another minority a little smaller is not entitled.
I believe there is no need for Parties in this country representing minorities as such. There is no section of this community, no part of the community, which because of language, because of race, because of some other characteristic of that kind, is set apart from the rest of the country, such as there is in Switzerland, where there are the Italian Swiss, the French Swiss and the German Swiss. Possibly Parties and minorities are necessary there. In this country, however, there is a homogeneous population. There is no need for separate Parties representing Parties as such.
Where one small group wants some particular thing achieved, the best way of achieving it is by working through one of the larger Parties. There may be a group which wants to achieve one particular object. For example, fishermen may decide they want to start a movement to extend the fishing limit to 12 miles, or a group may want some particular form of land division; but is is quite unnecessary to form a Party to achieve that one object. Not only is that unnecessary but it is undersirable, since the members of that Party in the Dáil will contribute little or nothing on other matters, but will concentrate on one particular object. They will have little or no views to offer on other matters. As soon as the object in which they are interested is achieved, or on the other hand as soon as it is clear that their particular object cannot be achieved, that Party will have outlived its usefulness and it will gradually fade away. In the meantime, it may have done serious damage to the structure of the Parties in the Dáil. Two or three votes may have held up a Government for several months; it may have put out a Government or it may have caused several elections.
It is a much better and more efficient and more desirable way of approaching it, where a minority has a particular object to achieve, that it should approach the existing Parties to get the support of one or other of those Parties and, having got the undertaking of that big Party to put their policy into operation, to promise to support that Party in whatever election comes next. The alternative to that—what has been happening to some extent in the past—is that a small Party like that gets elected at a general election and after the election, without indicating to the people what they intend to do, they promise some Party or group of Parties that, in return for putting their policy into operation, they will support that group of Parties and form a Coalition. It is much better that the pressure group should approach the Parties before the general election and pledge its support to a particular Party so that that Party could have stated in the general election what their policy was on this matter.
It has been suggested that it would not be possible to form a new Party under the straight vote system. I think it is quite clear that, if the existing Parties refuse to listen to a group which gradually gets bigger and bigger, that new movement will eventually form a Party and will eventually be able to take over the government of the country. That has been clearly proved by the fact that the Labour Party in Britain, which started from nothing, when there were just Liberal and Conservative Parties, was able to build itself up gradually, because the two existing Parties would not conform to their wishes and would not put their policy into operation. The Labour Party was a completely new Party, but it eventually reached the stage where it was able to take over the government of the country.
I should like to quote to the House an example of the way in which some of the members here present have agreed with me that it is sometimes desirable for smaller pressure groups or Parties to try to get their wishes achieved by working with one of the bigger Parties. When Senator L'Estrange was talking about minorities, he said: "I see no reason why farmers should not be represented in Parliament as a Party." I wonder why Senator L'Estrange did not live up to this belief in the past. He was in Clann na Talmhan in 1947 and he could have stayed with Clann na Talmhan and sought representation for Clann na Talmhan, representing a particular section of the farmers' point of view. He did not do so and I will tell the House in his own words why he did not do so. In the Westmeath Examiner for 13th December, 1947, there is a report of the Fine Gael Convention in Mullingar, which took place on the 8th December, 1947. At that convention, Senator L'Estrange said——
Comment on this
Mr. L'Estrange, so. He said that at a meeting of the county executive of Clann na Talmhan he had obtained authority to attend the convention. He offered himself as a Fine Gael candidate because he believed that there were as good farmers in Fine Gael as there were in Clann na Talmhan.
Comment on this
Mr. L'Estrange said that, having seen what had happened in France and in other countries as a result of small Parties, he had come to the conclusion that Fine Gael was the only Party capable of forming an alternative Government.
Comment on this
I am glad that at that time—perhaps it was when he was Mr. L'Estrange—he had sounder views on this question.
Comment on this
He had a view at that time that it was a good thing for minorities, instead of trying to remain in small Parties, to try to achieve their objectives through one of the larger Parties. General MacEoin said he welcomed Mr. L'Estrange the more because it proved they still had young farmers who could think for themselves.
Comment on this
Mr. Cosgrave said that Mr. L'Estrange's selection was of great significance; it meant that sectional interests were prepared to subordinate themselves to national considerations.
Comment on this
One member leaving the Party need not finish it. The Senator must be complimenting me.
Comment on this
I am glad that, at any time, Mr. L'Estrange, General MacEoin and Mr. Cosgrave agreed with the kind of view which I am expressing here to-night.
Comment on this
I would like to refer to another matter. Senator L'Estrange, speaking here yesterday—this time as a Senator—quoted Frank Gallagher's book The Indivisible Island and he gave the following quotation:—
"One of the greatest wrongs that can be done to a minority in a democratic State is to deprive it of its political rights, particularly of its electoral rights, for these are so often a shield for the rest."
Senator L'Estrange did not go on to say what Frank Gallagher was talking about. Further down, the author says:—
"The denial in the case of the North is achieved by an arrangement of the electoral boundaries."
Comment on this
That is not what the Senator implied by this quotation. It is quite clear that it was nothing to do with the system of election that operated in Northern Ireland, that that was the way in which the minorities were being denied their rights. It was because they were being gerrymandered. That is the way the author referred to the matter. In relation to Northern Ireland, it has been said by, amongst other members of this House, Senator Quinlan, that the minority in the North of Ireland suffered because of the change to the straight vote.
Comment on this
On a point of information, I made no such statement.
Comment on this
In dealing with that question, I should like to quote from Senator Quinlan's favourite chapter, the conclusions in Professor Hogan's book Election and Representation. Professor Hogan says, on page 91, in the chapter showing his conclusions:—
"It can be shown that, in fact, neither the adoption of P.R. in 1920, nor its replacement by the majority system in 1929 materially affected the balance of power as between the Unionist majority and the National minority. It is only when national minorities are spread in small groups over a wide area that they will elect more deputies under P.R. than they would under the majority system. If they are geographically concentrated, which tends to be the case with the Nationalist minorities of the Six Counties, they will in fact, enjoy all the advantages which majorities ordinarily acquire under the majority system. In these circumstances, national minorities are likely to fare better under the majority system. It is well to be clear that, as regards either the minority or majority in the Six Counties, P.R. has told neither in favour of one nor the other."
Comment on this
On a point of correction, I made exactly that statement but I went on to amplify it to show how the direct vote has kept the Parties asunder. In the immediate period, it made no difference, but it has kept the Parties asunder.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan went on to say, having dealt with the position in Northern Ireland, that if P.R. had been retained in Northern Ireland, he had no doubt that by this time the forces, the Parties, the various minorities and Independents who were opposed to the Unionists, would, by this time have managed to form a Government and to put out the Unionist Government.
Comment on this
Having regard to the fact that there is a solid block of Unionist votes in the Six Counties of approximately 60 per cent., it is very difficult to understand how it would have been possible, under any electoral system, straight vote, P.R., or anything else, to return a Government which would manage to put out the Unionist Party. I would say, if that is the fruit of Senator Quinlan's examination of the system in Northern Ireland, if that is the fruit of his examination as a scientist of the position in Northern Ireland, then I am strongly of the opinion that the sooner the scientists get back to their science and allow the politicians to deal with politics and the electoral system, the better it will be for this country.
Comment on this
Will Senator Brady allow me to conduct the business?
Comment on this
This has to be a brief explanation because the Senator's speech can be read.
Comment on this
I wish to say that that is a misquotation of what I said, and what I said will be available in full in the reports.
Comment on this
It is not an exact quotation. I have no doubt it is the gist of what Senator Quinlan said.
Comment on this
The second point to which I referred earlier on, to which an electoral system must conform, is that it must be such as to enable the people to change the Government at regular intervals, if they wish to do so. It is important that the system provides that that can be done in an effective way and, in that respect, the straight vote system with the single seat constituency is much more effective than the present one, because, under that system, when a Government have lost the confidence of the people, the swing against them is almost always stronger than under the system which we have here. The swing towards the alternative Government is stronger and the changing of the Government, which is the wish of the people, is carried out more effectively.
Under the system we have here, there has been, on a number of occasions, a stalemate, where the people apparently did not want the Government which they had before the election, but they produced a Dáil in which it was very difficult to form a new Government. That was the position in this country in 1932, 1937, 1943, 1948, 1951 and 1954. I believe that a system which will give a strong swing, which will put out a Government that do not govern effectively and put in the Parties that the people want is a much better electoral system.
The necessity to have second elections in 1933, 1938 and 1944 shows the shortcomings of the system we have. Professor Hogan says that if we had the straight vote between 1922 and the time that he wrote the book, which was 1945, the only difference it would have made in regard to the Governments which we have had is that the Governments both before 1932 and after 1932 would have been much stronger and more stable ones. According to the figures, between 1922 and 1945, the change would have come just the same in 1932 but the Governments both before and after, many of which were extremely precarious ones, would have been stronger Governments. In that way, the will of the people would have been achieved just the same. We would have had the same Governments but we would have had better Governments, Governments which were more stable and more effective.
There has been talk of dictatorship which it is rather difficult to take seriously, that this is an effort to introduce dictatorship into this country, the dictatorship of Fianna Fáil, the dictatorship of the big Party. First of all, I should like to say that the people of England, the United States of America, Canada, New Zealand and various other countries, all of them very successful democracies of long standing, would be very surprised to hear that they are living under what amounts to dictatorship, that they are living under a system in which the people are not permitted to have their way, not permitted to have the Government they want or the representation they want. That is complete nonsense. It is contributing very little to this debate to exaggerate to that extent the position that would exist under the new system. There is nothing surer under the straight vote than that the people will put in the Government they want and will put out the Government they do not want, and will do that much more effectively than under the present system.
It is suggested that this change is being introduced in order to keep Fianna Fáil in office indefinitely. I am willing to admit that, if the change does take place, Fianna Fáil probably will do well in the next general election, but, no matter how good a Government is, the public eventually swing against it and sooner or later, no matter how good Fianna Fáil Governments you may have in future——
Comment on this
No matter how good a Government we may have in future under Fianna Fáil, and I have no doubt that we will have extremely good ones——
Comment on this
——sooner or later, the people will get tired of a particular Government and when that time comes, the opportunity will arise for the Opposition to form a Government, either one particular Party alone or a combination of Parties. I do not see why Fine Gael and Labour should be so pessimistic about this matter. To suggest that Fianna Fáil will remain in office indefinitely means that the people want Fianna Fáil and will want Fianna Fáil to remain in office indefinitely or, alternatively, it means that the Opposition to Fianna Fáil will be so poor, so weak, that the people could not contemplate putting in the alternative.
Comment on this
Consequently, I would urge Fine Gael and Labour to cheer up.
Comment on this
I would make one point, that there is no future for them under the straight vote, under the present system or under any other system, unless they have a policy and leadership.
The third point I mentioned was that the Dáil and the Government should be broadly representative. In a single seat constituency which would approximate to about one-fourth of the average county, the Deputy would be elected in most cases by a cross-section of the community. A Deputy elected by and representative of a cross-section of the community would be much better qualified to deal with national issues than a representative of a minority group. In considering legislation, policy, and so on, such a person would have to have regard to all sections of the community and not allow himself to be dominated by any particular section. This House in particular should remember that, in so far as the voicing of the view of a particular minority in the sense of a vocational minority is concerned, the Seanad is available and is here specifically to fulfil that need, if it is merely a question of having the view of a particular vocation, a particular section of the community which forms one particular occupation or profession, expressed.
There have been many references in the Dáil and Seanad to the various European countries which suffered under P.R. I shall not go into the details of the various countries which it is usual to mention. The countries mentioned include Italy, Germany, France, Austria and Greece. It is possible to argue, on the one hand, that the fact that they had trouble in forming Government was due to a different type of P.R. from the type that we have here and on the other, that the fact that they had trouble had nothing whatever to do with P.R. but was due to particular circumstances in each particular country; but I think it is true to say that all these countries experienced multiplicity of Parties, that all these countries, sooner or later, found difficulty in forming a Government, and that most of these countries ended up eventually with a dictatorship of one kind or another.
Senator Quinlan, in dealing with Germany and Italy, said that, of course, the position in Germany had nothing to do with P.R. I am not purporting to quote him exactly.
Comment on this
What he did say was that the position in Germany was due, amongst other things, to ageing leadership, to the election of mediocrities and that, as a result of these and one or two other factors, Hitler came into power.
Comment on this
That was an extremely facile, extremely superficial, summing up of what happened in Germany.
Comment on this
On a point of information, it was a quotation.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan said that amongst the reasons which led to Hitler coming into power, were ageing leadership, the election of mediocrities —these were two of the three points he mentioned.
Comment on this
That is a quotation from Dr. O'Leary, I understand.
Comment on this
I forget where the Senator got the quotation, but he was adopting it as his own.
Comment on this
I take it that, in giving that quotation, Senator Quinlan approved of it and, in so doing, was satisfied, as far as we know, that the situation in Germany and the coming into power of Hitler was due not to P.R. but to these few points which I have mentioned. It seems clear—a matter he did not refer to—that these circumstances, these reasons which he mentioned—ageing leadership, election of mediocrities, and so on—had been caused by the system of P.R., that it was the P.R. system which led to the situation in Germany which allowed Hitler to come into power. I have heard some rather superficial references to some of these European countries and to the fact that they did or did not owe their misfortune to P.R. but I must confess that the most facile and the least scientific, I have heard was that given to us by Senator Quinlan.
Senator Quinlan also referred to the fact that the difficulties in the early 1930s, the difficulties in Europe, were matched by the difficulties in America and that, even though there had been difficulties in Europe, economic difficulties and so on, the people of the United States fared no better, that they had the bread lines too and that they had a very difficult time. But what Senator Quinlan did not mention and what is the essential difference is that, in these very different circumstances which existed in these European countries and in America at the same time, the American system stood up to those difficulties and managed eventually to deal with them under the system of Government which they had whereas the most of these European countries, under the particular type of P.R. Government they had, were not able to stand up to their difficulties and collapsed and most of them ended in dictatorship of one kind or another.
Comment on this
Because Europe was just broke and America had the money.
Comment on this
It think it is fair to say that the lesson of these countries, including most of the countries in Europe which I have mentioned— Italy, Germany, France, Austria, Greece, and so on—is that by trying for too much representation they ended up by undermining the democratic system. They tried for too much. They tried for a system that was too perfect in giving representation and, in so doing, they undermined the whole democratic system and the system collapsed.
Comment on this
Plato in his Republic makes one statement which I think is very applicable. He says: “The most aggravated form of tyranny and slavery arises out of the most extreme form of liberty.” That, I think, is what happened in many of these countries which were too ambitious in their electoral systems.
Comment on this
It may be said that the system of P.R. worked here and that consequently we should retain it. I think it fair to say that the fact that P.R. worked here in the past 30 years is no proof that it will work here in the future. There were very special circumstances in the country over the years which made it possible for that system to carry on. The Civil War and the aftermath of the Civil War divided the country into two parts. That produced a type of two-Party system which resulted in a situation in this country of half the country supporting Fianna Fáil and roughly half against it. Consequently, the system which we had worked reasonably well not by any means as well as some people have suggested it worked but it did manage to survive because of these particular circumstances.
These issues are no longer dominating the political system. Consequently, it is almost certain that the structure of Parliament, the structure of the Parties, would change in the future. That being so, there is a very real danger that we would have a multiplicity of Parties, that we would have a situation in due course very similar to the situation which existed in these European countries to which I have referred.
I should like to make one final quotation from Election and Representation by James Hogan, D.Litt., Professor of History, University College, Cork, which is on page 44 and onwards. He says there:—
"On a broad view of the character of representative democracy, there are, at all times and in all conditions, certain factors which it is essential to take into account. There are the shifts and changes in public opinion which introduce into the succession of political power an element of hazard from which the traditional political régimes of the hereditary type were relatively free, and, on the other hand, there is the tendency to faction and oligarchy which would appear to be inseparable from the existence of permanent party organisations. There can be little doubt that these factors tend in their general result to expose parliamentary democracy in a greater measure than any other type of constitutional régime to the particular peril of anarchy. As anarchy, the parent of tyranny, is the malady to which representative democracy is most characteristically susceptible, and as impotence in government is invariably the immediate author or occasion of anarchy, it follows that representative democracy can afford, in less measure than any other type of political régime, to dispense with the conditions of self-reliant, firm, consecutive government. The great complexity of the economic, social, and international conditions to which a modern democracy has to adapt itself, if it is to survive, calls for increased government action in very many directions. Hence, far from having decreased, the need for strengthening the function of government has greatly increased. No one who has fairly studied the evidence can doubt that one of the major factors in the decline of the parliamentary system has been its failure to develop itself as efficiently on the executive as on the legislative side.
If we may accept as universally valid a political proposition which in effect is directly challenged by those who repudiate the principle of government as such, that is to say, if we acknowledge that government to be good must be effective, then it follows that democratic government, like any other form of government, must needs possess within its assigned constitutional and legal limits a real freedom of judgment, initiative, and action in all matters where the ordering of the affairs of the community is concerned. When, furthermore, we have to concede, whether we like it or not, that there is no other practical way of avoiding under modern conditions the extremes of chaos or dictatorship than to accept a considerable extension of the functions and activities of government, it will be evident that there could be no fallacy more disastrous in its consequences than to think of the representative process as primarily designed to neutralise, checkmate, or obstruct the activities of government."
Finally he says:—
"There are the strongest reasons why we should welcome, under almost any conceivable circumstances, the possession of a strong and constant majority in Parliament by whatever properly-constituted Government happens to be in office."
That is the end of the quote.
In case it should be suggested that I am not having regard to the chapter on "Conclusions" or that I was not being fair to Professor Hogan, I should mention that he says on page 93:—
"While we have been convinced by our investigation into the working of P.R. in Éire that it requires a further shift towards the majority system, if we are asked how far this process should go, we feel bound to admit that we could only offer some tentative suggestions."
Professor Hogan is not prepared to come down definitely and say exactly what we should have. He says that he is convinced that there should be a further shift towards the majority system, and, after that, all he is prepared to do is to make tentative suggestions. Finally, I should like to say that if we do arrive at the position that we have multiplicity of Parties these various Parties will have a vested interest in the system of P.R. and if we are in that situation it is quite clear that they will never agree to any change which would eliminate them. We have the opportunity now.
It has been asked why this Bill is being introduced now. One of the reasons is that we have an opportunity now to test public opinion on it. Public opinion will be able to say whether or not they want it but the situation may never arise again when you will have a Dáil which will be willing to allow public opinion to decide, one way or the other, for P.R. or for the straight vote. That is an opportunity which I believe the people are entitled to have. It is an opportunity which the Dáil has voted to give them and it is an opportunity which, whether you agree with the amendment or not, should be given to the people. I believe that whether you are right or wrong about this, whether or not you represent the views of the people on this, you should have sufficient confidence in your own point of view and in the wisdom of the people, to allow the people to express their opinion.
Comment on this
In rising to speak against this Bill one is dumbfounded by the amount of ground that has been covered. I should like first to refer to the contribution of the Minister for External Affairs and his reference to the Seven Wise Men of Greece. My view is that this measure has not been referred to any group of wise men in this country. It has been referred simply to the Oracle. The system in Greece was to refer matters to the Oracle of Delphi and I think the suggestion of the Minister for External Affairs is rather ludicrous.
Senator Ryan in the case made for the abolition of P.R. has given a great deal of post factum information. He has made a great case to bolster a decision already taken and the speeches in the other House would suggest and make that abundantly clear. As a person elected to this House on the Commercial and Industrial Panel it behoves me to look at the matter from a certain angle. I think this Bill is brought in here as a new disturbance, a new source of agitation and irritation in public life.
During the last few months a series of the most learned, informative and valuable contributions and suggestions as to what ought to be done for our economy and as to what form our economy should take, have emanated from official and semi-official organs of government. It behoves us no matter what our political affiliations, to devote our energies to the practical application of these invaluable suggestions. The most important of these was that which has been edited and produced by Mr. T.K. Whitaker, who has had the assistance of all the best brains in the various Government Departments and many of the best authorities outside this country. He has thanked university professors from the North of Ireland and various other people who have studied our economy, for helping him with this work.
As a businessman, having a businessman's approach to this problem, I ask would it not be well to get together to have something done about this matter? I am running a business; it has been in our family for nearly 100 years and, thank God, we never had a strike. To-day we talk about works' councils and working arrangements and lectures in summer schools. Various pamphlets and books have been written on social problems, how to reconcile business problems and to safeguard our economy, so that the units in our economy may progress. The present idea of a large dominant Party is repugnant to that philosophical tenet, that we should all work in co-operation.
I believe that what we require is a new dynamic spirit in Irish affairs. It is not altogether a political solution that is required in Ireland. If we speak to any of our young men who have graduated recently from our universities, will any of them say that a mere change of one of the laws of our State is adequate to produce this dynamic spirit that will light up the minds, and enthusiasm, of the youth to do something about our problems?
Anything we won here we won by firing the imagination and enthusiasm of all the people. That is why I oppose this Bill. It will drive underground a variety of opinions and ideas and variety of ideas is one of the greatest things one can have in any country, the feeling that you might be able to do something different and better and with more imagination than anybody else has ever been able to do it. By this measure you will kill, stifle or destroy imagination and anybody who wants to do anything different will be regimented in one dominant political Party. If that Party changes, it may change because of ill-considered catch-cries bandied round at the time of an election rather than because of any ability to reason or adopt a commonsense approach to proposals. A greater measure of agreement must be reached between us. If this Government, the strongest since the establishment of the State, suggested a closer working arrangement with a view to seeing what is the best system of promoting the development of the country, one would understand it.
It has been said that no one can better see what form of Government we should have than those who have represented us democratically in the Oireachtas. If that is so, why was a commission not set up composed of a selected number from the Dáil and Seanad and asked to get information from our civil servants and university authorities and to consider all the evidence fairly and objectively and conclusively and then each and every one of us asked to abide by the decision reached by the best brains in a most thorough inquiry and accept the report produced by such a commission? We did not get that type of suggestion. We were told this was to be done for the good of the country, by a political Party that has by no means a monopoly of political wisdom. The very thing they enshrined in the Constitution they will not now tolerate.
I do not want to quote very much but I should like to refer to paragraphs 13 and 14 of Economic Development. Paragraph 14, page 5, says:—
"For all these reasons the importance of the next five to ten years for the economic and political future of Ireland cannot be over-stressed."
At paragraph 13, it says:—
"A concerted and comprehensive programme aimed at a steady progress in material welfare, even though supported by the Churches and other leaders of opinion, could only be successful if the individual members of the community were realistic and patriotic enough to accept the standard of living produced by their own exertions here, even if it should continue for some time to be lower than the standard available abroad. Otherwise, the possibility of economic progress scarcely exists."
Is not the only way we can get that accepted and the only way we can declare war on this problem of our economy progress, the way of general agreement? Does anyone think the views of the trade unionists, the farmers, the professional people can be reconciled in any other way? We have evidence of the difficulty of that daily; we have statements from the Information Bureau giving the results of various inquiries and arbitration proceedings; we have people saying they can get better pay in the North or in Britain. Those interests cannot be reconciled by a strong, dominant government; it can be done only by getting these groups to work in harmony with the Government, by making them feel they are part of the Government and that if they all put their shoulders to the wheel, a better standard of living will be secured. To-day, the per capita wealth of everybody in this country is only 55 per cent. of that of the people of the neighbouring island and our people can move freely to Britain. Should it not be the aim of each one of us, no matter what group he represents, to try to reduce this gap and in that way help to solve our greatest economic problem, emigration, and the many other problems we have here?
In Britain, they have all the welfare provisions, facilities for education and research and so on because the individual incomes and output are higher. It is not a matter for the Government or Parliament to try to produce measures that will improve our situation in that regard; that improvement will come only from the people. All the people want is a lead and co-operation. They want to be asked to give their patriotic effort in a wholehearted manner, but they will not do that, in my opinion, through the abolition of P.R. They will give it if we move in the reverse direction.
I was just about to leave school when the Civil War came and I knew many people engaged in the epics that led up to the freedom of this country. One man I knew often said to me that if the first decade of our freedom had not been wasted, who knows to what extent we would have advanced? I believe we want to get the benefit of that decade, that we want agreed objectives. The young men and women who are leaving our universities and who are unfortunately cynical about what we can do, could be given that leadership they look for if there was something akin to complete co-operation, something on the lines of all-Party government here.
We must look back on our history in order to draw the proper conclusions when asked to decide on this measure. I mention the Civil War, in no spirit of attributing blame to anyone for it. Many countries have had episodes in their history from which they are able to derive good results through the application of appropriate remedies to ensure that such episodes will not recur. The Civil War was part of the growing pains of the nation and in many respects we acquitted ourselves better, with more intelligence and more credit, as our institutions which have since developed show, than many other countries.
Cuireadh an díospóireacht ar ath-ló.