An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Coiste. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–148 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
Sula rachaimid i gCoiste ar an mBille, b'fhéidir go bhfónfaidh sé do na Seanadóiri má thugaim cuntas réasúnta mion ar thuairimí an Chathaoirligh faoin nós imeachta ba chóir a leanúint.
Teastaíonn uaim a chur in iúl i gcoitinne go dtairgfear na ceisteanna go léir i nGaeilge agus i mBéarla agus go gcinnfidh siad an t-ábhar i gcás an téacsa Ghaeilge agus an téacsa Bhéarla.
Is é tuairim an Chathaoirligh nár chóir aon díospóireacht a bheith ann faoi alt 1, an t-alt a dhéanann an socrú foirmiúil chun ábhar atá sa Bhunreacht cheana a scriosadh agus ábhar nua a chur isteach sa Bhunreacht. Tá sonrai an ábhair nua sin sa Sceideal agus meastar dá ndéantaí díospóireacht faoi alt 1 gur ró-dhóigh go ndéanfaí an díospóireacht chéanna in athuair i gcás an Sceidil. Ar an ábhar go bhfuil leasuithe curtha síos le haghaidh an Sceidil, measann an Cathaoirleach gurbh oiriúnaí dá mba orthu sin a dhéanfaí an díospóireacht.
Do réir na treorach atá ceadaithe ag an Teach, tairgfear ceist ar leithligh ar gach fo-alt faoi leith d'alt 2 agus ar gach alt faoi leith ina dhiaidh sin den Sceideal i ngach cás tar éis leasuithe a bheidh in ordú ar na fo-ailt nó na hailt a bheith curtha de láimh. Déanfar an cheist faoin Sceideal a chur ansin agus ina dhiaidh sin na ceisteanna faoin Réamhrá agus faoin Tedeal.
Teastaíonn uaim a chur in iúl ag an bpointe seo go bhfuil leasuithe Uimh. 1 agus 2 as ordú toisc go bhfuil siad ar neamhréir le prionsabal an Bhille mar léadh é an Dara Uair. Tá sé sin curtha in iúl do na Seanadóirí lena mbaineann sé.
Tá súil agam go nglacfaidh an Teach leis an nós imeachta seo atá minithe agam.
Before we go into Committee on the Bill, it may be helpful to Senators if I indicate in some detail the Chair's views on the procedure which should be adopted.
In general I should say that all questions will be proposed bilingually and will decide the issue in respect of both the Irish and English texts.
In the opinion of the Chair, there should be no debate on Section 1 which makes the formal arrangement for the deletion of existing matter from, and the insertion of new matter in, the Constitution. The details of such new matter are contained in the Schedule and it is considered that debate on Section 1 would be inevitably repeated on the Schedule. As amendments have been tabled to the Schedule the Chair feels that the debate may more appropriately take place thereon.
In accordance with the instruction approved of by the House, a separate question will be proposed on each of the sub-sections of Section 2 and on each of the subsequent sections of the Schedule in each case after amendments to the sub-sections or sections that are in order have been disposed of. The question on the Schedule will then be put followed by the questions on the Preamble and the Title.
At this stage, I should inform the House that amendments Nos. 1 and 2 are out of order as they are in conflict with the principle of the Bill as read a Second Time. The Senators concerned have been informed.
I trust that the procedure outlined will prove acceptable to the House.
Comment on this
I should have said I agree entirely that the Committee must pass Sections 1 and 2 of the Bill and then take the detailed discussion. I should have mentioned that in my statement on the motion.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Arising out of the first amendment, standing in the names of Professor George O'Brien and myself, about the question of the transferable versus the non-transferable vote, while I bow to the Chair in its ruling, I should have thought that the main principle of the Bill was the breaking-down of the constituencies and the substitution of single member constituencies for the others.
I believe that, in linking two principles together like this, in trying to carry in the principle of the non-transferable vote, as it were, on the coat-tails of the principle of the breaking-down of constituencies, the approach is unfair to the people of the country. I do not wish to elaborate, but I would point out that, in marked contrast to this package Bill that has been offered to the Irish people, is our very democratic approach to settling the problems of the people in the Cameroons, in Africa.
Comment on this
I wish to protest at the linking together of the two principles.
Comment on this
May I make a point of order? The principle of this Bill, I submit, is the deletion of P.R. from the Constitution. The insertion of single member constituencies, with the single transferable vote has no element of P.R. at all in it and, therefore, is not contrary to the principle of the Bill. I submit to you, Sir, that what we have decided on the Second Reading is that we will abolish P.R.—take it out of the Constitution—but that the insertion in the Constitution of a scheme whereby single member constituencies and a single non-transferable vote for these constituencies is not P.R., contains no element at all of it, and therefore is not contrary to the principles of the Bill.
Comment on this
I should inform the House that the Chair understands the principles of the Bill to be (1) provision for single seat constituencies and (2) provision for the non-transferable vote, or the single vote, as it is popularly called. These are the principles enshrined in the Bill—no more and no less.
D'aontaíodh le Altanna a 1 agus 2.
Comment on this
This sub-section abolishes the multiple seat constituency. It is to be remarked from the point of view of the history of this matter that the number of three seat constituencies was, more than once, increased. There were only three in 1923; they became 15 in 1935 and they became 22 in 1947. The three seat constituencies offer a smaller degree of proportionality than the five seat constituencies. The policy of the Taoiseach and his Government has been to increase the number of three seat constituencies. But that increase did not give them precisely what they wanted. In a three seat constituency a big Party might get two seats. The biggest Party would necessarily get two seats and get them on a simple majority. For example, if the quota was 6,000 then 6,001 votes would give them two seats. In any event, they would be likely to get one seat, but that was not sufficient and the three seat and the five seat constituencies are now being abolished and we are going back to the single seat.
The five seat constituency was a better arrangement for the purpose of P.R. It left the Dáil door open to anybody who could get one-sixth of the votes in a constituency. What we need most in this country is new blood in politics. I submit that the five seat constituency gave a better chance to younger people. It gave a better chance to new policies, even novel policies, to get some representation in the Dáil than they could possibly have under the new system. It gave an opportunity to younger people who had no cachet or stamp from a Party to get into the Dáil.
The destruction of P.R. which is contained in this sub-section and the substitution of the single seat gives the Party bosses much greater power and gives the ordinary voter much less choice and much less power of selection. If he belongs to a particular Party, he gets only one candidate. His choice is that he must vote for that candidate or renege his Party—a position in which people in this country do not like to find themselves—a position, in fact, in which they like to find themselves less in this country than in most. The only way in which that can be met is under the five seat constituency. Even under the three seat constituency the voter always had a choice between members of his own Party. For example, if he so chose, he could select a younger member or any member whom he considered a better member than the sitting member.
Under the new system he has to displace the sitting member at the Party convention first, before he gets any choice. The result would be, I think, to give you a House much more fixed and static than it is at present. It would be invidious to give examples but there are examples of cases where a younger man of the Fianna Fáil Party, for example, defeated an older sitting Deputy. The same thing has occurred in other Parties. I submit that the possibility that that can happen is good—and I am speaking by no means, of course, as a younger man myself. It is a good thing that, even within their own Party, voters should have a choice between A and B.
P.R. here has created a good and an admirable Parliament and has overcome a great many difficulties. I think it was the Parliament and the fact that people came into a Parliament and the fact that work had to be done in a Parliament and that there was no other way of doing it and that people came in, in great variety, enabled us to overcome the aftermath of the civil war. The Parliament and the system under which it was elected had a great deal to do with that. Apart from that aspect, it showed former Unionists and former extreme Nationalists that each group was human and composed of good Irishmen and had good qualities. I saw that Parliament working. I think P.R. made a very good Parliament and did extremely good national work.
One of the great differences—I shall not go into history except for this slight comparison — between the Parnell split and the civil war was that when the Parnell split was over everybody was defeated: nothing was to be done. However, after the civil war, there was everything to be done inside this Parliament. One of the most creditable things to this Parliament and the members on different sides is that people who had been physically opposed to each other in the civil war were able to sit down and work in a very orderly manner and carry out the parliamentary work very well. In spite of accusations made from time to time that that was not so, it is so. It is a great credit to the Irish people and the men who came into the Dáil. An effort was made to establish a situation in which there would be no fraternisation. Some front benchers endeavoured to bring that about but, as a matter of fact, the common sense and the ordinary Irish humanity of the back benchers saw that that did not happen, and it did not happen.
I have an entirely different idea of Parliament from the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach, in his final speech on the Second Stage of this Bill, revealed why he had inserted this particular provision into this amendment of the Constitution. He wants a Parliament which will not have discussion. The essence of a Parliament, surely, is that it should be a deliberative assembly, that there should be discussion in it. But the Taoiseach wants a Parliament which will have a very substantial majority of one Party and which, when that majority comes in, will have discussion in camera on the Government's proposals. He thinks the Government is much more important than the Parliament. I do not agree with him and I think that a situation where the Government can overawe the Parliament by a substantial majority, and where discussion is mainly in camera—which, being translated, means in the Government Party room instead of the Dáil chamber—is a bad scheme. I take issue with the Taoiseach on that matter.
I do not favour government which would be strong enough to rush everything through, to save time as the Taoiseach says, with people who have the same common interest. The Taoiseach is able to persuade himself, and some others, that what he wants is right, is in the national interest and that discussion in his Party is always in the national interest and no other matter comes into it. We all know that that is not so and the Taoiseach himself knows that that is not so.
It seems to me that the system we have is a much more democratic system than the system set out in this Bill. We have all had experience of Governments, on both sides, which had majorities and even of Governments with slender majorities, and every Minister I ever knew was always in a hurry. I think the idea of taking the brakes off Government and Ministers is a very bad idea both for the Government and for the people and, ultimately, for democracy. The Taoiseach's desire is to gag the majority and judge democracy, or the way it works, by the size of a parliamentary majority. I think that is quite wrong and foolish. We had no inquiry into this. We were told we should leave it to the politicians and, in fact, during the debate the word "professor"— since a number of professors here were opposed to the measure—became almost a term of reproach and so also did the word "scientist." One Senator was reproached with being a scientist and he and the professors were told that they should mind their own business and leave this to the politicians. What does that mean? It means leaving it to the propagandists and the skilled deceivers of the people, to the Irish Press and to the Sunday Press, to the people who are under the Taoiseach's control and specially employed for the purpose of making black into white. Let nobody inquire into it and when a scientist discusses this he is told: “Tut, tut. Mind your own business. Go home and teach mathematical physics, but do not speak to us”. Everybody knows that is the whole idea. I think that is a wrong idea and that it is going to work out very badly for the whole of us.
Another thing that is bound to happen is that if you abolish the three seat and the five seat constituencies you are bound to create a Parliament which will be much more urban than the present one. Take any example you wish. Take Louth, with Dundalk at one end and Drogheda at the other. Take Kildare, or Waterford, or any place you like, no matter how you divide the constituency, the town vote is bound to be of greater importance and bound to give a much more urban Dáil than you get at present.
Similarly, the system means that you are abolishing majority representation. This means that a Party that tops the poll, the first candidate past the post, will get in without a majority; it means a substitution of minority election for majority election.
The Taoiseach and other people on the far side blandly tell us that the people opposed to the big Parties should get together. Why should they be driven to do that? Why can we not take an example from the Six Counties, from Northern Ireland? Our fundamental case against Partition is that the people across the Border are Irishmen, like we are, and if they are like us we can learn from them what our reactions are likely to be at the result of abolishing P.R. The result of abolishing P.R. there has not been to reduce the number of Parties. The number has increased more than under P.R. and, incidentally, there are more Independents. They have not come together, although they have a greater pressure to come together than anybody has here. But they have not come together. Neither would people here come together.
It seems to me that you are excluding minorities under this particular sub-section and taking the foundations from under the Dáil. There have been all kinds of examples given of how politicians deal with matters. We are told that people with outlandish policies should not be able to get in with one-sixth of the votes. What is an outlandish policy? It is any kind of policy which the Taoiseach, or some other Minister of the Fianna Fáil Party defines as outlandish. The notion that people not in a majority have a policy which is outlandish is entirely false and the same applies to the idea of small Parties making promises which they cannot fulfil. How anybody of any authority in the Fianna Fáil Party can have the effrontery to say that people make promises which they know they cannot fulfil baffles me. I can remember the most outlandish promises being made, promises to bring emigrants back, to get the wheels of industry turning, to do all kinds of things which they knew they could not do. There were promises to solve unemployment, to destroy the British market and other kinds of promises. No small Party could possibly compete with the big Parties here with regard to promises.
I suggest that in this sub-section we have a scheme which is going to work entirely in favour of big Parties, going to work entirely against minorities and take the foundations from under the Dáil. As far as we are concerned, the vast majority of the people know only the system that we have. They have worked it very intelligently. One of the most remarkable things about P.R. which has been commented upon by people coming here is the intelligent way in which votes are transferred. When a casual outsider asks why a vote has been transferred from, say, a Fine Gael candidate to a Fianna Fáil candidate, or vice versa, then, if you know anything about local affairs, you can give him the reason right away. This matter will, of course, arise on the next sub-section but what we are doing here is endeavouring to create a situation in which the people with a substantial minority of votes will get a substantial majority in the Dáil and thus have power to put a policy into operation, without a majority of the people in the country behind the policy.
We have discussed this at some length already but no single argument was put up on this matter. All kinds of research was made into what somebody else said, what people said at various times, but, in all the debate we had on the Second Stage, there was no discussion from the Government Benches about P.R. itself and its genuine effects as contrasted with the British system. The Taoiseach put the matter quite simply. He said: "P.R. creates Parties." Of course, P.R. does not create Parties; Parties were there before P.R. and the Party has an organic life of its own and is entitled to exist.
The situation that somebody should say to Fine Gael or Labour: "You must amalgamate with somebody else to fight us" should not be allowed. The Taoiseach was as plain as a pikestaff about this. He said he once believed in P.R.—although, mark you, both the Minister for External Affairs and the Minister for Defence have said he did not believe in it at all in 1937 and only put it in to deceive somebody. But, leaving that out for the moment, his own line is that he was really shaken in 1948 when he saw himself defeated and he thought P.R. was the cause of it. When it happened again in 1954, he thought that was unforgivable on the part of P.R. and decided to abolish it. That is why it is being abolished now. It is being abolished for purely Party, political, partisan reasons. No arguments of any kind, except that particular kind of argument, have been advanced for the change and I am against it.
Comment on this
On this matter—the sub-section which deals with the provisions that constituencies shall be represented by one member only—I should like to suggest that if this new arrangement goes through and is approved in the referendum, people, voters in particular, will very soon learn to regret it, when they find that they are represented in the Dáil by only one T.D.
Senator Hayes has mentioned that multiple seat constituencies have been reduced. There used to be a great number of seven seat constituencies and then five seat constituencies. Now there is a great number of three seat constituencies. I would see in the three seat constituencies a considerable advantage, nevertheless, over the single seat constituency, for the reason that I think it is a good thing for the voter to regard himself as being represented, not just by one T.D. or just by a T.D. in one Party.
Not so very long ago the Minister for Health made a speech in which he said in effect: "You can judge your T.D. by the work he does for and in his constituency. You will be closer to him if the constituency is smaller," and so on. But you cannot fairly judge his rival in action, unless his rival is also a T.D. You have only one standard of comparison in relation to that constituency, if that constituency has only one representative. You cannot say to yourself: "I can now see in practice and in activity whether the Labour T.D. or the Fianna Fáil T.D. or the Fine Gael T.D. or the Clann na Talmhan T.D. or the Clann na Poblachta T.D. or the Independent is in fact actively representing me in the way I desire to be represented."
If we take seriously the contention of the Minister for Health in that regard, it clearly becomes less possible for us to judge our T.D. in action if we have nobody with whom to compare him, basing the comparison on activity in relation to the same local constituency problems. Of course, you can say: "I think that the present T.D. is probably acting more in accordance with the interests of this constituency than his rival in another Party would have done if elected ", or "the rival, if he had been elected, would probably have acted better" but we would have only a very vague and purely imaginary comparison.
At present, even in the small three seat constituency, it is possible to see for yourself which of these representatives, be they of any Party, is in fact actively and effectively concerned with the interests of the constituency. Therefore, it seems to me that the argument that you will get better, more effective and closer representation by a single member falls to the ground. It is far more valuable, if you find that the representative of your own Party is not anxious for some reason, to raise a particular matter which seems of vital interest and concern to you locally, to be able to get in touch with a representative of another Party who represents your constituency and to say to him: "Here are the facts. Will you take this matter up? Fianna Fáil do not want to touch it. It is dynamite. Fine Gael do not want to touch it; they think it is safer to do nothing. The Labour Party seem to be scared". You could run the gamut. Perhaps in the end you would find nobody to raise it but your chance of finding somebody to raise a particular local matter is greater if you have three, four or five representatives of different and competing Parties, than if you have simply one.
I remember an occasion in the Seanad when a Senator got up and said in relation to a bridge that might or might not be built in his part of the world that he besought the Minister—he was a Fine Gael Minister—to accept a particular amendment in relation to the Youghal Bridge because, if he did not, though he knew exactly what the local people thought about it, he would be forced to vote against his conscience, if the Whips were put on. That Senator has disappeared from amongst us; possibly, I do not know, due to the fact that the local people thought he should have voted rather with his conscience than with the Whips. It seems to me, however, that in local matters of that kind it is a very healthy thing for the Parliament and for the country to have three or four T.D.s representing the same constituency, and knowing the same problems, than to have simply one Party man.
In an election in County Antrim, in the 1920s, before they abolished P.R., there was an eight seat constituency. The result of the first count was that three members were elected. The first was a Cabinet Minister, a Unionist; the second was a Cabinet Member, a Unionist; and the third was a Nationalist. On the first count, the other candidates—there were ten in all—were fourth, a Unionist; fifth, a Unionist; sixth, a Unionist; seventh, a Unionist; eighth, a Unionist, ninth, a Unionist, and tenth, a Farmer. When the surplus votes of the first two Unionists were distributed, no further candidate was elected; some of the other Unionists went up a bit; but, when the surplus votes of the Nationalist were distributed, Number 10, the Farmer, reached the quota and was elected. The final result in that eight seat constituency was that you had six Unionists, one Nationalist and one Farmer, because those who were most anxious to get a Nationalist in had as a second choice a Farmer, and exercised their rights under P.R. P.R. has been abolished there and you now have the entire area represented by one Party.
Nobody could suggest that a system which gives you six members of the Government Party opposed by two others is unstable and it seems to me that, in a certain sense, a crushing overall majority is less stable in practice than the system which gives a chance to minorities in that way.
Furthermore, if there is only one seat per constituency, it is fairly obvious that no Party will put up more than one candidate. Theoretically it is possible for a Party to put up two candidates even if there is only one seat but they would be far more likely to do so under the system of the single transferable vote. In practice, it is quite obvious that the voters will have one Party man put before them. That means that the electors will be given no choice as between different shades of political view, and economic and humanitarian outlook, within the same Party. At present, when there may be as many as five or six candidates from one Party the elector can vote very loyally for the whole Party ticket, but can express a preference, for reasons of shades of difference of opinion within the Party, for one or other candidate.
All that will be abolished, if there is only one Party candidate. There will be no allowance made for shades of difference within the Party. It may well be that there are no shades of difference within the Party. When I endeavoured on the Second Stage to goad Senator Lenihan into telling me whether there was anybody at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis who argued against the abolition of P.R., all he replied was that "there was a discussion". I could not extract from him even the statement that there was a single person who said anything against it! It may well be, therefore, that all shades of difference within the Party have been ironed out completely; that there is no difference of opinion on anything within the Fianna Fáil Party.
That may well be true of the other Parties also, but, if it is, and if it is the case that each Party must ask the elector to take a single person as representing them absolutely on everything, then I think it is a great pity for our Irish democracy, because the life blood of democracy lies in the discussion of differences of opinion, not merely as between Parties, but within Parties. The Party that is most healthy is the one that allows for the widest difference of opinion within the Party. If it simply means that we will have a single person representing the Party, and will not be given the chance to choose even as between Party representatives, it will be a bad day for Irish democracy.
The single seat constituency system places a premium on "safeness". What the Party wants is the "safe" candidate, the candidate who will never argue about anything, the candidate who will vote as he is asked to vote, the candidate who will not give any trouble, the candidate who will never criticise a Minister, a candidate who will be a good boy or a good girl. That means, in fact, putting a premium on mediocrity. I am afraid that one result of the single seat constituency inevitably will be the putting before the electorate of the same "sane and safe" mediocrities, the safe people who will follow the Party line blindly, docilely and obediently. Therefore, it seems to me that the whole principle enshrined in this sub-section is wrong, and intrinsically bad for our democratic system.
Comment on this
In speaking to the Second Reading of this Bill, I mentioned the fact that this change in our electoral system might bear heavily on the minorities. I did not give any details. I tried to speak from the national point of view and not from the point of view of any particular denomination. But some people asked me afterwards whether I could substantiate what I had said when I said it would bear hardly on the religious minority. I think it is only reasonable that, very briefly, I should try to substantiate that point now as a reason for opposing this section of the Bill.
We all know that P.R. was established in the Irish Constitutions of 1922 and 1937 with the express purpose of safeguarding the rights of minorities. Both the constitutional and the military leaders in the struggle for Irish independence before and after 1916 liberally affirmed their determination to preserve those rights, not only for the sake of the minorities themselves, but in the name of justice and for the general good of the Irish nation. In fact, long before the British Government introduced P.R. into Ireland it had been advocated by independent-minded Irishmen for Ireland as a whole.
My claim is that this change will remove that safeguard for the minorities and, in particular, for the Protestant minority to which I belong. Let me briefly explain the mathematics of the situation. Under P.R., the following are the percentages of votes which are certain to win a seat —I emphasise the word "certain": In a five member constituency, 16? per cent. of the voting plus the one is certain to get a seat; in a four member constituency, 20 per cent. plus one; and in a three member constituency, 25 per cent. plus one. But, under the other system, to be certain of winning a seat in a two-sided contest you must get 50 per cent. plus one; and the minimum possible to win is 33? per cent. plus one where there are three candidates for the seat. You can see at once the unfavourable comparison there for the Protestant minority, and this applies to other minorities.
Once again, under P.R., as low as figure as 16? per cent. plus one can win a seat and the highest figure necessary to be certain of a seat is 25 per cent. plus one, whereas under the other system, which is called the straight vote but which should, I think, very much more appropriately be called the simple vote—or even the wasting vote would be a better name still—you will need possibly 50 per cent. plus one.
I do not like the denominational approach. I do not think it is necessary in our country to-day. I hope it will never be necessary. But there is a possibility that in some crisis the Protestant minority would want to be sure of electing one of their own people to speak for them in the Dáil. That, I think, is an undesirable situation. I hope it will never happen. But it might happen. Under the present system, they are sure that they can have three or possibly four people of their own elected by Protestants as Protestants to the Dáil. In a certain situation in this country that might be desirable and just.
Under the proposed change it will be virtually impossible for Protestants, simply all Protestants, to elect a Protestant in the new Dáil because I doubt—I have not absolutely final figures for this—whether Protestants command 40 per cent. plus one of the voting in any particular constituency or are likely to do it.
Those are my arguments against the section. I think they are precise mathematical arguments to show why this change does bear heavily on the Protestant minority.
I want to emphasise, once again, that I hope it will not make any practical difference. I have confidence that the major Parties will continue to give full opportunities to Protestants who have the ability and the desire to serve their country. But I still think, as a matter of justice, that the religious minority should be certain of being able to elect certain members for for themselves, if necessary. That is why I oppose this section.
Comment on this
I am very much in favour of this section because I believe it is fundamental to the success of the measure which is under discussion. Senator Stanford said that he disliked the denominational approach to this matter. Indeed, I think that is an approach which should be avoided by this House if at all possible but I submit that the Senator's own approach was of that kind.
It would be far better to argue this section on its merits than to drag in this question of religious minorities. There is nothing in the section that would preclude religious minorities from having candidates put up in a general election, that is, if those candidates would be selected by one or other of the big Parties on the basis that they are worthy of selection. This question of minorities has been overemphasised. The minority groups in any democratic country like this will always be able to find their own feet. In the Dáil and in the Seanad we have T.D.s and Senators who belong to different religious denominations. They are able to render a good account of themselves. If, by their energy and their general political conduct in our national life, they prove themselves worthy of support, the Irish people will undoubtedly support them again.
That, of course, applies to majorities as well as minorities. Even a majority Party will not select candidates unless those candidates are suitable and will be effective representatives if they are elected. I do not agree with Senator Sheehy Skeffington when he says that in the case of the single seat constituency there is no standard of comparison. Of course there will be a general standard of comparison and the people will be always in a position to know whether their representative in the Dáil is doing his work in an energetic and conscientious way or not. If they find that one of their T.D.s, whatever Party he represents, is not rendering a good account of his stewardship, they have no remedy until the next general election comes along. That applies both to the present system and the system of the single seat constituency. If they find that the person in whom they have reposed their confidences for a period of five years, or whatever the period is, has not measured up to their expectations of him, there is no remedy in either case until the next general election.
Senator Sheehy Skeffington also mentioned the question of some bridge or other and the attitude that a certain Senator took up here in connection with the matter. I submit that dealing with the question of bridges and roads is not the primary purpose for which a T.D. is elected. His primary function is to make his contribution towards the councils of the nation and I am afraid that in the past all of us were inclined to attach too much importance to these local affairs, and not give enough attention to the primary duty that we were elected for, namely, to contribute to debates in An Dáil on general national matters. The duty of a T.D. when he is elected is to take his place in the Dáil and contribute to the main stream of discussion, thus assisting the Government of the day to make their decisions as a result of whatever discussion has taken place in the Dáil.
I was surprised to hear Senator Hayes say that Parliament is more important than Government. I do not agree with him, because if you had the finest Parliament in the world and if that Parliament were composed of the best members that could be imagined, unless there was a Government there capable enough and effective enough to safeguard the interests of the nation, whatever work would be done in Parliament would be of no account. There must be a Government in the first instance. Without a properly elected Government, a Government with stability behind it, there can be no progress and if there cannot be national progress what good is Parliament? What good would be the discussions that would take place in Parliament if there were no group of individuals capable of giving the people a lead from day to day and of making sure that the rights and liberties of the people would be upheld and questions of national importance attended to?
Effective Government is more important to-day than it has ever been. We are living in a critical age when there are tensions all round us. A cold war is raging in the world and nobody can tell from one week to another what will happen. In order to deal with a situation like that, you want a united, solid Government, a Government that will know where it is going. That does not arise so much on this section and I do not want to elaborate on it.
I am entirely in favour of the single seat constituency. Speaking from a certain amount of experience, I am a great believer in fixing responsibility on one person in all these matters. If you fix full responsibility on one person you will be able to judge in the end whether he is worthy of support or not. I do not want to repeat what I said on the Second Reading but my experience is that where there are three or five T.D.s representing a constituency you will find them all engaged in exactly the same work; there is a dissipation of energy between them. One person could do the work as effectively as three or five. The representations they make to the Department will bear the same fruit if their case is a good one. If the case is not a good one, it is not likely to succeed even when three or five make representations. Under the present system civil servants must waste time considering representations from each one of these representatives. It is a waste of time on the part of whatever officials would have to deal with the individual representations of these T.D.s, all making these representations about the one thing. So, as I said at the outset, I am very much in favour of the one seat constituency. Before this Bill came before the Dáil or the Seanad, I was of the same opinion. I have had experience of how many members of the Dáil have had to traverse the same path about something concerning the welfare of the constituency they represented.
Comment on this
The sub-section we are considering here reads:—
"Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members who represent constituencies..."
I presume the word "democratically" represent is implied there from our Constitution, although it is not mentioned. If that is so, and in view of the second part of this sub-section which reads:—
"...and one member only shall be returned for each constituency,"
I suggest that, if the first part means "democratically represent" the second part is contradictory because that one member can be elected by a minority vote. I suppose it is being maintained that, to have single seat constituencies is, in fact, a fully democratic procedure. I suggest that where this particular system works in England it is demonstrably not democratic. The same can be said in relation to Northern Ireland. Indeed, when we had the system ourselves before the Treaty, I do not think that even then it could be claimed to be a democratic form of representation in constituencies.
In England, it is quite clear that there are large Liberal elements all over the country, who are quite strong and yet who never get any representation in their constituencies. They are permanently disfranchised by the one seat system. Similarly, in other areas where there are large Labour elements —in fact, only marginal areas—the Labour Party have never been able to get representation. Similarly, there are areas where Conservatives have never been able to get representation in Labour areas. Therefore, there are large elements in the population who never have any voice in the government of the country or representation in Parliament.
In England, the representation in each area is completely in the hands of the Party bosses or, if you like, in the hands of the Party. In some isolated cases you will find that the local committees are, in fact, able to put up candidates but they have to be sanctioned by headquarters. It boils down to the fact that in England the large majority of the sitting members of Parliament are the picks of the parliamentary Parties and, therefore, the parliamentary bosses and, really, the Party Whips, because if they do not obey the Whips the bosses do not want them and they are not allowed to stand. Therefore, they are just heads in Parliament who will vote the way they are required to vote by the leaders of the Party. I suggest that not by any stretch of imagination could that system be held up as an ideal system of democracy and yet that is what is inherent in this proposed sub-section.
I shall come now to the other headline in this regard and refer to Northern Ireland. We can all see what has been happening there. For nearly 40 years now, there has been practically no change of representatives there. There has been absolutely no change of representation in the form of a Government. Our Nationalist brethren up there have never a hope of getting any proportionate representation in the Parliament or in the Government of the country, under this system which is proposed to be brought in here now.
We have heard here representatives of minority Parties who, quite rightly, have declared that in this proposal they see the end of any chance of having even a reasonable degree of representation in future in Parliament. They will have to be content with the local big Party representative who is put in to represent the constituency and then have to do the best they can and make the best case they can to him in order to get any degree of representation and to have their voices in any way heard in Parliament.
I suggest that a Deputy would have to perform a miracle if he could go into our Parliament and give a fair representation to all the people making approaches to him for this, that and the other. It is impossible for one man to represent all the different elements of all the different Parties within any given constituency. I think it is a very retrograde step to set up a system like that in a country like this where we have a good variety of independent thought, which is very desirable. We Irish pride ourselves that we do not like to be driven like sheep but this measure is designed for a sheep-like population or, if it is not designed for one, then it is designed to make a sheep-like population.
I come now to our experience in our own country. I am old enough to remember the single vote system working in Ireland. I come from Waterford, which was John Redmond's constituency at the time of the old Irish Party. The same thing happened there when Sinn Féin came into existence. They had a sweeping success when the population of the country was able to assert itself but that success came only when the assertion came in a huge enormous over-sweeping way. In the ordinary course of events before Sinn Féin had arisen—in 1912 or 1913—there was an M.P. in County Waterford whose name was Power—a well-known Power, because everybody in Waterford is named Power—who died. The story is told that a certain individual in the vicinity of Tramore wished to be put up for the constituency. I do not think it is any harm to refer to the case now because all concerned are long since dead. This individual wrote to Father O'Donnell who was the Administrator in the Cathedral in Waterford. He was John Redmond's right-hand man, as many P.P.s were in those days. In his letter the individual asked Fr. O'Donnell that he should be put up for the constituency. He was in fact put up and was elected. There was no question about it: it was as easy as that. An interesting sidelight on this case was the following story. Father O'Donnell wrote to the individual and said he would be very glad to recommend him to John Redmond and then he wrote to John Redmond and told him not to touch that man with a forty-foot pole. Father O'Donnell put the letters in the wrong envelopes. However, the individual in question was elected M.P. in the place of Mr. Power. That is the kind of thing we are going back to—the single member constituency in England where four-fifths of the seats become permanent. Once a man is established in a constituency as a member, he has got an immense patronage and it is very hard to move him. Once he has got the patronage of the area and an all-over power, he has a 50-yards start in the 100 yards on everybody else at an election and even within the Party itself because, once he is sitting, even if he is not very good, the Party itself cannot remove him. The system is undemocratic.
As regards Northern Ireland, everybody in this House could make a speech on the conditions in Northern Ireland if he wished to do so. The single vote system is meant to give an exclusive advantage to the Party, to the leader of the Party and to the representative. This I think is most undemocratic. For these reasons I am opposed to this sub-section and to the single member constituency system.
Comment on this
I think it would be a very good idea for the Senator who has just spoken to undertake a personal crusade to the United States and Britain to save them from this undemocratic form of election that they have in these countries. If it will be undemocratic here, surely it is undemocratic there. I think these countries should be saved for democracy and Senator McGuire might be the man to do it.
Senator Stanford said that he did not like taking the denominational approach but he certainly took it and he took it in a most political way, using the religion of a certain minority to try to get them to vote for his political convictions against P.R. If we want to have the denominational approach, and if Senator Stanford or anybody else wants to raise it, we will face it. The Protestants here represent 7 per cent. of the people and they get a 2 per cent. representation in the Dáil. Can anybody deny that? If Senator Stanford wants to get the Protestants to go off into one corner of the country to set up an enclave and have their representation according to their numbers well, then, it does not seem that they will get the true proportion under the system we propose to abolish and which Senator Stanford wants us to retain.
The fact is that it is well known that minorities here are interested only in their own peculiarity whether it is of religion, or some social approach, or anything else. If they are a very tiny minority they do not do well under P.R. Nobody bothers about them. Senator Cole, I thought, made a very reasonable speech on this business the other day. If this issue is raised, it has to be faced. Senator Cole said what we all know to be a fact, that 30 years ago it would have been impossible to get the religious minority here to join the ordinary Parties——
Comment on this
They did not join either of the big Parties in any numbers and we know that, in fact, they tried to put up in Monaghan, Cavan and certain other parts of the country, in two or three other constituencies, Protestant candidates, as Protestants, to represent their interests as Protestants, no matter whether they were farmers or labourers or anything else. That was the narrow denominational approach which Senator Stanford takes. The result was that the Protestant candidates were not returned and that we have——
Comment on this
The thing is, if you want the representation for a 7 per cent. minority, no matter what you call it, you cannot get it under the P.R. system which we are abolishing. It has been proved that their representation was wiped out and it was only those who joined the major Parties who survived.
What is the position in, say, Britain where there is a very much smaller religious minority than 7 per cent.? Our religious minority of 7 per cent., in fact, does not get direct representation, but through the Parties it has a representation of, say, 2 per cent. in the Dáil. In Britain there is a minority of one half of ½ per cent. and it gets representation of more than 3 per cent. It is recognised that in the United States of America, where there is a great number of minorities—minorities of colour, of race, of creed, of nationality, and of economic or religious beliefs—the straight voting system gives these minorities better representation than they could possibly get under any system of P.R.
Senator Stanford pointed out that in order to be sure of electing a representative here a minority would want to have 25 per cent. in a constituency. That means that a minority that has only 7 per cent. all over the country could never get a candidate elected as a minority candidate. In the U.S.A. there are minorities of much less than 7 per cent. but they are represented in Congress because, while they might be only a few per cent. all over the country, their votes and their influence have a marginal importance and that marginal importance might be a vital factor in an election in any constituency in any part of the United States of America. All big Parties tend to have representatives in the panel of candidates for various things, various vacancies, and the result is that all sorts of minorities, very tiny minorities, have representation in the United States Congress. The straight vote system has this integrating effect, this very valuable effect, on the social life of the United States, that it tends to force all these minorities to find their common interest, whereas P.R., as we know, tends to make every small group exaggerate its exclusive personal interest, or minority interest, and to take no heed of the general interest which must be served if the nation as a whole is to make progress.
Senator Hayes in discussing this matter on the Second Reading, in his main speech, said we wanted to give individuals the power to blackmail by having a single member constituency; that with the straight vote we were putting it is the power of individuals to blackmail the political Parties, that if they did not get something for standing down they would go forward and threaten one or other of the larger Parties with defeat. He objected to it because the straight vote gave individuals the power to blackmail before an election. What we are concerned with more than anything else is that, if there is to be blackmail, it should be practiced openly before the election so that the people will know who is blackmailing whom while they have the time to decide whether they will vote for that system or not or for the individuals involved in the bargaining, or blackmail, as Senator Hayes put it. Senator Hayes does not want blackmail before an election; he wants it afterwards.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes is wriggling on the precise meaning of the word "blackmail." Whatever it means, he does not want it before the election——
Comment on this
I do not want it at all. I want the Minister to talk about P.R., but he is not able. He is talking about blackmail. Let us hear him on P.R. for a moment.
Comment on this
We shall hear him on the P.R. blackmail that Senator Hayes wants to continue. Senator Hayes would like the blackmail to be postponed until after the election.
Comment on this
I do not want it at all. I have never been associated with blackmail of any kind, public or private, and the Minister knows it.
Comment on this
If there is to be blackmail, does the Senator want it before the election or postponed until after the election.
Comment on this
What we feel is that if there is to be blackmail, it should not be after the election when the people have no remedy. But if the smaller Parties or groups of Parties are to blackmail each other to secure that they will get a few Ministries to run or something of that kind, they should be forced to do it before the election. It is better to do it before the election than afterwards.
I thought from the speeches made by Senator Sheehy Skeffington, Senator Stanford, Senator Quinlan and others on the Second Reading that we would have an opportunity on this Committee Stage to test exactly what size of minority the various sections of this House want to have represented in the Dáil. But there has been no resolution put down to secure that if we are to have 150 seats in the Dáil any minority with one vote in 150 should have the opportunity of getting elected. We discussed this matter for months in the Dáil and we discussed it here for several weeks. In my speeches I challenged those talking about minority representation that there was one way of getting representation for the smallest minority it is possible to have represented in the Dáil, and that is to have an amendment making the Twenty-Six Counties into one constituency, so that, if we are to have 150 seats in the Dáil, any minority with one out of 150 votes could get representation, or any minority with 10 per cent. could get 10 per cent. of the representation in the Dáil.
Why has that amendment not been put down? If the Senators here are so enthusiastic about getting all minorities represented as they represent themselves to be when talking and as they will represent themselves to be when we will have the campaign on this referendum in the country——
Comment on this
On a point of order, we made no such statements.
Comment on this
I did not mention Senator Quinlan in connection with that matter. It was Senator Stanford, Senator Hayes and other Senators who were weeping about minorities, saying that we wanted to destroy minorities, that we wanted minorities to have no rights and that we wanted the Dáil to be completely Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
When it comes now to the Committee Stage, when they could have put in an amendment to secure that a minority of one in 150 could get representation, they turn their backs on it. Even to-day Senator Sheehy Skeffington spoke about a voter having no choice, as between the candidates of the one Party, to select the candidate whose opinions are the nearest shade to his own, and saying that in three or four member constituencies, when Parties put up three or four candidates, they give the voters a choice even as between the candidates of the single Party. But there has been no amendment. Voters could get a very close approximation to their own shade of opinion if they had the right to choose one candidate out of 150. But Senator Sheehy Skeffington did not put down an amendment to that effect, nor did the other Senators who spoke in much the same strain.
Comment on this
The Minister has not learned much about parliamentary procedure in 30 years in Parliament. How could anyone put down an amendment like that?
Comment on this
I have sized up Senator Hayes. When Senator Hayes does not want to face an issue in this Seanad, whether it is a question of economics or anything else, he tries to get a row going about the civil war or the British market. That is his tactic.
Comment on this
Senators who persist in interrupting other Senators or Ministers are clearly out of order.
Comment on this
Senator O'Donovan is out of order and must resume his seat.
Comment on this
May I make a point of order, Sir? When a Senator rises to make a point of order, can he be answered from the Chair to the effect that he is not in order?
Comment on this
When Senators persist in interrupting other Senators, it is clear they are out of order.
Comment on this
When a Senator rises to make a point of order, he can be told he is quite wrong, but can he be told he is out of order?
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled. The Minister to continue.
Comment on this
I should like to say to Senator McGuire, who made the allegation that the straight vote system is undemocratic and will turn the Irish people into a flock of sheep, that he should really take time off and go to Britain, the United States, Canada and those other countries to prevent them from turning their people into crowds of sheep and to get them to live up to his standard of democracy.
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs, in spite of his many trips to the United States as Irish representative to the United Nations, does not seem to know very much about the Constitution of the United States. I am going to deal with points made by the Minister. If the Minister knew anything about the Constitution of the United States he would know that the Constitution of the United States is so framed that there can never be tyranny under the Constitution and the purpose of democratic Government and of democratic Constitutions is to prevent any of the organs of Government becoming too strong.
That is the system we have in our Constitution and that is the system which they have in the United States Constitution. If the Minister knew anything about the Constitution of the United States, to examine which he urges Senator McGuire to go out to the United States, he would know that there is a distinct separation between the powers of Government and the powers of the Legislature. The Government is represented by the President and the Legislature has its own powers. The Legislature is there for the purpose of exercising control and keeping in check the President, who is the executive arm of Government. That is why democracy in the United States is safe and will continue to be safe.
Further, if the Minister knew anything about recent events in the United States, he would know that, since 1954, the Party of the President of the United States has been in a minority in Congress and in a very decided minority since the elections of 1958. It is for that very reason, it is because of that constitutional set-up, that democracy is so safe in the United States of America. If that was the type of amendment that was being brought in here, that the Executive, that is to say, the Government, would be answerable to the Legislature, that is to say, the Dáil, in the way the President of the United States is answerable to the Houses of Congress, then we might be in agreement with such a change but that is not the change that is being brought in here. The change that is being made here is to deny the people of the country the representation to which they are entitled and to which they have been entitled for the past 40 years.
The Minister talked about Great Britain. He is, apparently, converted to the British market and British ships and now to the British Constitution. In that context might I recall to the House that in 1936 we had a Fianna Fáil Government unnecessarily consenting to an amendment of the British Constitution and they had no mandate from the people to do so?
Comment on this
The External Relations Act was raised by Fianna Fáil speakers on the Second Stage. I am entitled to refer to the External Relations Act and I say that, if that Act was repealed, it was repealed because it was unnecessary in our circumstances because we had a Republic and because a majority of the Dáil, including the Fianna Fáil members of Dáil Éireann, were in favour of repealing it. In 1936, when Edward VIII, King of England, was abdicating——
Comment on this
And King of the Free State, quite so—there was no necessity whatever on this country to introduce any legislation to deal with that matter. When the King of England was gone, when Edward VIII was gone, then we had no King in this country. Instead of that, we had Dáil Éireann summoned by telegram to put through the External Relations Act. The result was that it was so well drafted and we were in such great haste to amend the Constitution that we had two Kings in this Country— George VI until the repeal of the External Relations Act and the former Edward VIII, Duke of Windsor, for certain purposes from December, 1936 until July 1937, when that position was rectified by an Act of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
This is not a subject for the amendment of the sub-section.
Comment on this
If we are going to talk about what was done by the Coalition Government and by pressure groups in the Coalition Government, as alleged by Fianna Fáil, we might as well say these things, within the rules of order. The Minister talks about the United States. The position of the United States has no relationship whatever with us and well the Minister knows it. The United States is a Federal State consisting of 49 different States with a population of 160,000,000. It is the greater of the two greatest powers in the world. You cannot compare that kind of country with a country such as this and you cannot compare its constitutional procedure with the procedure under our Constitution. In any event, they do not bear any comparison because the two systems under which Government is provided in the United States and in this country have no relationship whatever.
The Minister then talks of what was going on in Great Britain. I thought that, when I had said something on the Second Stage about the British Constitution and the manner by which candidates for election to Parliament are elected, the Minister would not raise that one again. I am going to reread for the Minister's benefit a passage from The Economist, dated January 24th, which deals with the position obtaining in Britain. There is not real democracy in Great Britain. It is run by a small junta in the different constituencies in Britain.
Comment on this
And other people. If the Senator reads articles in recent issues of The Observer he will find the same thing.
Comment on this
At page 298 of The Economist where it deals with the position of the election of candidates in a single member constituency, it says:—
"Constituency associations are usually run by a small group of active and often extremist Party workers. Even in theory this small group is elected only by the few hundreds of local zealots who work for a candidate, not by the tens of thousands who vote for him; in practice it is often personally dominated by two or three active enthusiasts who have time to spare. Yet, because of the device of nominating a ‘prospective parliamentary candidates' well before the election, this tiny and unrepresentative group has absolute control over the timing of what is in most cases the de facto choice of a candidate.”
We have seen in Britain in the case of the recent by-election in Southend a candidate wholly unacceptable to even the constituency association foisted upon that constituency. That is the kind of system that the Government wants to introduce here.
It may well be, of course, that we have Mr. Churchill speaking in favour of P.R. and that he sees what way the wind is blowing and we may find ourselves in the ludicrous position of having abolished P.R. and then finding ourselves in the position that Britain will have changed its electoral system and have introduced the single transferable vote.
The Minister then comes along with what can be regarded only as a completely absurd challenge to Senator Professor Stanford and others that we should turn the Twenty-Six Counties into one constituency. That sort of debating point shows the weakness of the arguments of the Minister and his supporters in favour of this particular amendment. We are not idiots and we do not want to have an idiotic system of that kind.
Comment on this
We have had a particular system and it has worked to our satisfaction and has been incorporated in the Constitution by the people. We do not want it changed. That is all we are saying on this Bill. The Minister says, then, that we have turned our backs upon amending this Bill. The Minister knows very well, as Senator Professor Hayes has pointed out, that if such an amendment was put down it would be immediately ruled out of order by the Chair, and people are not going to waste their time putting down an amendment which they know would be completely out of order.
Comment on this
That is not the reason. The reason is that it was an idiotic amendment.
Comment on this
We do. We believe in a workable system of P.R. anyway. The Taoiseach is on record as having stated in Volume 50, column 254:—
"From 1938, that is, for the past 20 years, looking at the working of this system, I have on many occasions pointed out that, if it should lead here to a multiplicity of Parties, it would be well for the people, in the interests of government, in the interests of the State and in the interests of the community, to get rid of it."
There was provision in the Constitution which was enacted on the 1st July, 1937, and came into operation on the 29th December, 1937, for making amendments for a period of approximately three years from the date of entry into office of the first President. The position was that up to May in 1941 the Constitution was capable of amendment. The Taoiseach now says that since 1938 he has been speaking against P.R. but though he had an opportunity between 1938 and 1941 of amending the Constitution he did not do so.
Comment on this
It might, of course, be said that this was a radical change but the Government did a whole lot of other things to it. There was one amendment of the Constitution in 1939 and no less than 30 in 1941.
Comment on this
One of them was regarded by many people as a most far-reaching amendment and a most dangerous one, that would enable a Government to make grave inroads upon the liberty of the people. That is the amendment to Article 28 sub-section (3) of the Constitution. As enacted by the people, sub-section (3) of Article 28 said:—
"Nothing in this Constitution shall be invoked to invalidate any law enacted by the Oireachtas which is expressed to be for the purpose of securing the public safety and the preservation of the State in time of war or armed rebellion, or to nullify any act done or purporting to be done in pursuance of any such law."
That was a fair and reasonable provision. One of the amendments which was incorporated in 1941 provided for the addition to this sub-section of the words "and ‘time of war or armed rebellion' includes such time after the termination of any war, or of any such armed conflict as aforesaid, or of any armed rebellion, as may elapse until each of the Houses of the Oireachtas shall have resolved that the national emergency occasioned by such war, armed conflict, or armed rebellion has ceased to exist."
We can now, therefore, have the position in which either House of the Oireachtas can decide that a national emergency——
Comment on this
The Chair is the judge of order. Senator O'Quigley.
Comment on this
Senators have said that the amendments were only trifling or technical. The amendment made in 1941 which I am speaking about was not at all technical.
Comment on this
I will come back to that if the Senator will only be patient and listen to me a little longer.
Comment on this
The amendment I speak about vests in either the Seanad or the Dáil the power to continue a national emergency for so long as either House thinks proper, and that means that the liberties of the subject as set out in this Constitution can be indefinitely suspended. That was an amendment which could vitally affect the very liberties of the people and sweep away rights guaranteed under the Constitution. It is a very fundamental amendment, and it was thought fit and proper to put it into the Constitution by an amendment in 1941, when we were in the throes of a great war. The Taoiseach has said that he had doubts about P.R. when they were putting it into the Constitution but he did not think it appropriate to amend the Constitution in any way to abolish P.R. in 1941.
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs stated in the Dáil that P.R. was put into the 1922 Constitution because of some kind of compulsion or coercion from the British. That, of course, does not stand the test of history. What was put into the 1922 Constitution was merely a simple statement that the members of Dáil Éireann shall be elected upon the principles of P.R. As Fianna Fáil were talking about what is going on in Australia, the United States, Finland and every other place, I thought it was quite in order that we should know what the position was in other countries. I examined 89 Constitutions of other countries. In only two Constitutions which prescribe P.R. is the precise method of P.R. that is to be used set down. The farmers of the 1937 Constitution were not satisfied with what the British had imposed upon us. If they are right in their own statements, they wanted to go further and tie us up much more than the British had done in the 1922 Constitution, because they introduced an amendment in the 1937 Constitution that "members shall be elected on the principles of P.R. by means of the single transferable vote". The whole difficulty arises from the fact that these words "by means of the single transferable vote" tie us to a particular form of P.R.
I have heard Senator Lenihan and some of his colleagues saying at a debating society meeting that there were 1,000 systems of P.R. In spite of the great varieties you can have to suit conditions in different countries, the 1937 Constitution amended the provisions of the 1922 Constitution so as to tie us to one system, the single transferable vote. If the Taoiseach had thought it suited his own position in 1937 there would have been nothing wrong in leaving the Constitution just as it was in that respect in 1922. There would have been no great opposition to it and the system of P.R. that would be employed in Ireland could have been determined by an electoral law. If we wanted to go further than that we could say: "The electoral law shall not be changed more than once in 20 years." That would give us more stability.
In the course of his reply on the Second Reading of the Bill, the Taoiseach said that if we found the system we are introducing did not work we could change it. I have a fundamental objection to such a suggestion. The Constitution should be like the yard measurement: it should be standard and should be subjected to as little change as possible. If we are going to tinker around with the Constitution, amending it as particular Parties' interests demand, we are getting away from the protection and stability that having a written Constitution was intended, and ought, to give us. What we are doing now is something that should be more or less permanent. If we do not get that permanency, our Constitution is a much less valuable document than I thought it to be.
This amendment to the Constitution arises out of a philosophical concept completely different from that on which democratic institutions should be based. This amendment runs completely counter to the general framework of our Constitution. Our Constitution provides that all powers of Government, legislative, executive and judicial shall be exercisable only by or on the authority of the organs of State established by the Constitution. Contrary to what the Taoiseach says, the Legislature, that is, the Dáil and Seanad, are just as important organs of State as the Government and they are intended to be so in the Constitution. Under the Constitution, the Government is supposed to be answerable to the Dáil and the Government, contrary to what the Taoiseach says, are not our rulers. At column 250, Volume 50, of the Seanad Debates of the 4th February, 1959, the Taoiseach says:——
"One of the main purposes of elections is to provide a Government."
The first purpose of an election is to provide a Dáil and it is from the Dáil that the Government are selected. The purpose of providing the Dáil is that the people shall be represented, in accordance with their choice and their decision, in the making of laws. It is the laws that are passed by the Dáil and Seanad that govern the people and that the people must obey. The Taoiseach continues:—
"Two main purposes are indicated in the Constitution—two matters on which the ultimate power is with the people. The first is deciding who will be their rulers—in other words, their Government—and the second is deciding what is to be the national policy."
I have read the Constitution many times and I do not know where you will find in it any statement, expressed or implied, that the purpose of an election is to determine national policy. The purpose of an election is to elect Deputies who will determine the laws which will govern the people. I agree entirely with Senator Kissane when he states that Deputies should come into Dáil Éireann for the purpose of making their contribution to the councils of the nation. That is their primary purpose and that is the purpose of a representative Parliament. Under this system of single member constituencies we will not have a representative Parliament and indeed of all Parties it ill-becomes Fianna Fáil—with the name they have adopted, wrongly I believe, "Fianna Fáil"—to deny the people what is long established in the Irish mind, cothrom na Féinne.
Comment on this
Cothrom na Féinne, fair play; that is what P.R. gives, what we have always wanted for everybody. I quote the Taoiseach again at column 886, Volume 50, of the Seanad Debates of the 19th February, 1959:—
"When you speak about candidate B with 40 per cent. getting in where you had a division of 35, 40 and 25 per cent., you are not going to say that the 35 per cent. and the 25 per cent. should be added together and that it is a matter of 60 against 40."
The Taoiseach is certainly getting away from what was in the Gospel last Sunday: "He that is not with me is against me."
Comment on this
That is a practical application of Christianity: "He that is not with me is against me."
Comment on this
But the Taoiseach says that 60 per cent., or some proportion of those voters are in favour of the 40 per cent. man. If that is so, why did they not vote for him? It was interesting to hear the Taoiseach, on the Final Stage of this Bill, deal with all the elections—1932, 1933, 1937, 1938, 1943, 1944, 1948, 1951—and then, full stop. There was a full stop at 1951. I was waiting to see what he would have to say when he came to the 1954 election. At that time, the people who are now being asked to change over to the single member constituency and abolish P.R. had had the experience of a Coalition Government formed in 1948 and they knew, in the 1954 election, that there was a possibility that if they did not vote for Fianna Fáil they would have a Coalition Government. They knew that, in spite of the warnings issued to them by the Taoiseach not to vote for coalition Parties, they would get another Coalition Government but they did, in fact, vote for a Coalition Government and a Coalition Government they got.
What had the Taoiseach to say after the general election? He recognised the right of the people to make their choice. As reported in the Irish Press, some days after the election of the Coalition Government, he had this to say: “The coalition Parties have a majority and they can form a Government.” But he did not deal with the 1954 situation because he was in the difficult position that the people knew that P.R. would lead to Coalition Government and they accepted that position in 1954 and they had a Coalition Government and, if it happened again——
Comment on this
—— in the same way as they changed their minds in 1954. Is the Taoiseach afraid that, the people having had the valuable experience of two periods of Coalition Government and having seen the benefits to be derived from two periods of Coalition Government, Coalition Government would become a feature of our political life? As I said on the Second Stage, and I repeat it now, Coalition Governments were very welcome in our political life. They brought together people among whom there was very little difference of opinion on most matters. Some Senators may laugh. I would point out to them that on the Second Reading of the Bill in the Dáil the Taoiseach stated that the small Parties had no fundamental point of difference. If they had no fundamental point of difference I would ask what is to prevent them from coming together? They are in no different position from members of a big Party where you have conservative and Left opinion in a big Party. I do not know what goes on inside Fianna Fáil Party rooms but, looking at the different strata of our economic life from which the members are drawn —they say they represent all sections of the community: farmers, workers, professional people, and so on—there is no fundamental difference between the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, I take it. If that be so and if they can agree, then, why can we not have small Parties amongst whom there is no fundamental point of difference acting in the same way as a large Party? I would ask that question of Fianna Fáil speakers?
Apparently the motto of the Taoiseach is to divide and rule. At column 254 of the Official Report of Seanad Éireann of the 4th February, 1959, the Taoiseach is reported as saying:—
"We all know there were issues here which divided the country into two major Parties. As long as that was so and there was no public support of any kind for the smaller Parties, they found it very difficult to operate and had not operated to any extent. It is different when the aims and objects which divided the major Parties are no longer there."
I always thought, as a young person having grown up in a free country, that the great misfortune in Irish history was the split in 1922, and I still believe it to be so. Here we have the Taoiseach regarding as good the fact that we had a split and now saying that because there are no major differences between the Parties and nothing to keep them apart, they must be kept apart, and the only way to do it is to amend the Constitution. Frankly, I do not understand that outlook and, if it was for no reason other than that, I would be strongly opposed to this amendment.
Comment on this
I had not intended to intervene again on this sub-section, but I do so because I have been named and, I think, seriously misunderstood by two speakers. I refrained from interrupting them when they did so, as I think it is more orderly, perhaps, and more effective to answer them afterwards. The first was Senator Kissane, who seemed completely to misunderstand what I said in rebuttal of what the Minister for Health said. The Minister for Health has been telling the country widely that single seat constituencies, which is the subject matter of the sub-section which we are now discussing, ensured T.D.s who will be very closely in touch, because of the smallness of the area involved, with their electors. He has said that the electors will be able to see how they behave and act and judge them in action in relation to their own local issues because they will be close to the area. Senator Kissane's answer was that he was surprised that I should suggest that local issues should be allowed to predominate in Parliament, and so on.
I did not make any such suggestion. I suggest that if you are concerned with local issues, concerned to have your Deputy living in the area and close to his constituents, the people will have a proper chance of judging him only if there are two or three such people of different political tints, all concerned with such issues, and all in the Parliament at the same time, for purposes of real comparison. Furthermore, I want to make it clear that the concern with local issues and being in the area, and so on, is not merely in the mind of the Minister for Health but is also in the mind of the Taoiseach. As reported at column 882 of the Official Report of Seanad Éireann of 19th February, 1959, the Taoiseach is reported as follows:—
"In a single member constituency the people will know the candidate, assuming, for the moment, that he comes from within the area. If he is brought in from outside, one can rest assured that there will be those within the area who will take very good care to let the people know what he is like. In fact, the chances of someone coming in from outside are slight unless there is some exceptionally good reason."
At column 883, he continued:—
"They will want someone who will be representative of their community,..."
Later on, he says:—
"...who will be interested in their interests and who will, having come into the National Assembly, examine proposed legislation from the point of view of how that legislation will bear upon those whom he represents."
That laying of emphasis on local affairs was not done by me, as Senator Kissane seems to think. It was not done by me but by the Minister for Health and by the Taoiseach. His condemnation rebounds upon them. My point was that if you are really concerned with having a local man as your Deputy, then a Fianna Fáil Deputy, a Labour Deputy, a Fine Gael Deputy, if they are all in the Parliament, and equally in touch with the same local issues, can far more easily be compared for their relative capacity in Parliament than if only one member is elected and the others are all defeated.
Senator Kissane also said that if several T.D.s in different Parties are concerned with the same case there will be "duplication of effort". He said that if the case is good, action will be taken and that, if it is bad, no action will be taken. I am prepared to believe that Senator Kissane is a very innocent man, but I am afraid I do not believe that the mere merit of the case is sufficient to have it dealt with by the Government if it is raised by an Opposition T.D., or if there is no fear of its being raised by an Opposition T.D. by reason of the fact that for the area there is no Opposition T.D. at all. Therefore, I would say that if you want local as well as national interests really to be dealt with by the Opposition—which I regard as an essential part of democratic practice—then you must have at least three, and preferably more, representing the different shades of opinion in the same area.
The Minister for External Affairs also mentioned me by name in regard to my speech just now, and my speech on the Second Stage. He said he was surprised that I, and others, had not put down an amendment to transform the whole country into a single constituency, in order that we might have perfect P.R., so that if the 150th part of the electorate could be got together on one issue they would be entitled to a representative. The reason that I did not put down such an amendment, apart from the fact that it would have been ruled out of order, is that I do not ask for exact or extreme P.R. I would go so far as to say that I think a seven seat constituency is better than a five seat constituency, and a five seat constituency is better than a three seat constituency, but I made it quite clear —I hoped—on the Second Reading that the method of P.R. which we have, even though it gives a preponderance of power to the big Parties, is a good system, a good working system.
We have a good working system of P.R., and I recognised that though it did not give full and absolute P.R. to all the minorities, it did give them a reasonable look in. In other words, I am relatively satisfied with the present system, and it is a very poor argument for the Minister to say: "Since you want P.R. you must want the extreme kind, and since you did not ask for it you cannot be sincere in saying you want it at all." The extreme case would be for every single minority to be represented in Parliament in proportion to their strength. I did not ask for that and I did not hear any other Senator asking for it.
What I did say was that we thought the present system a reasonable compromise, and I mentioned the fact that the only two Parties in the last three elections that have got more seats than their proportion of votes have been the two big Parties. That has happened. Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil received more than their proportion of seats in the elections under this system, but we recognise that while that gives them a working majority it does not give them too great power. To say to us that because we want to retain the measure of P.R. that we now have, we should fly to the extreme and demand absolute P.R., would be as absurd as for us to say to the Government: "We are surprised that you are very much for the single seat constituency system and yet do not ask for single Party Parliament, because it would give the Government even more power and more stability".
It would be grossly unfair to say to Fianna Fáil: "Because you want the single seat constituency, because you want stable Government, why do you not go to the extreme and carry your convictions to the limit and say you want only one Party?" That would be unfair, it would be the extreme case. We do not want the extreme. It would be ridiculous for me to get up and say to the representatives of Fianna Fáil: "Why did you not, instead of asking for single seat constituencies, ask for single Party Government or, in other words, dictatorship, if you are really sincere in wanting full and stable power to implement your policy?" That would be unfair. It would be unfair to challenge Fianna Fáil on the grounds that, because they want some more power, to explain why they do not grab all the power. So, also, it is unfair to the supporters of the present system, which is not fully P.R., and which gives big Parties plenty of power, to say: "Why do you not go the whole hog and ask for complete P.R.?"
We suggest that under the present system the big Parties are clearly given more power than their voting strength but that power is necessary for the continuance of Government. The system gives them extra power, but it does not eliminate the small Parties. We ask them to be satisfied with that surplus of power, and not to go out grabbing for even more.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene so soon again in this debate but Senator Sheehy Skeffington accused me of misquoting him——
Comment on this
——misinterpreting his statement and I feel that I have to return the compliment. He tried to point out to the Seanad that the statement I made was in some way at variance with the statement of the Taoiseach and the statement of the Minister for Health. I said, of course, and I repeat that the primary business of a T.D. is to take his place in the National Assembly and to contribute to the debates that take place therein.
Comment on this
But when I said that I did not mean to convey the impression that the T.D. should be excluded from representing his constituents' point of view, because there is such a thing as social legislation: legislation on agricultural matters, legislation on industrial matters and so on, in which the constituents of the said T.D. may have a very vital interest. It would be, of course, the duty of the T.D. to put his point of view before the National Assembly on behalf of the constituents he represents.
When I advocate that, there is nothing that could be said to be at variance with anything that has been said by the Taoiseach or by the Minister for Health. Of course, it will always be the duty of the T.D. to keep a watchful eye on everything that happens in the Dáil so that nothing will be done that would work out to the detriment of the people he represents. Any good public representative can do that and, at the same time, make his contribution towards whatever national policy will be enunciated by those entrusted with the conduct of the affairs of the nation, for the time being.
As I said before, and I repeat it now, I am a firm believer in fixing responsibility on one individual, so that there can be no evasion of responsibility. If the person who has been elected to represent his constituents in any part of the country is found wanting in his advocacy for or on behalf of the people whom he represents, or found wanting in his general attitude towards what takes place in the National Assembly, well, then, the remedy will be there in the next election and the remedy will not be available any sooner.
Comment on this
But you cannot compare him with another local sitting T.D.
Comment on this
Well, if he cannot be compared with another local sitting T.D. he can be compared with other Deputies who are engaged in exactly the same business. The speeches and happenings in the Dáil are very widely reported. The people will be always in a position to read those reports, judge for themselves and make up their minds as to whether the person they have elected to the Dáil is worthy of their continued support or not.
Comment on this
That is a different point. I would say again that I am in favour of this section. I am in favour of the establishment of the single member constituency; and I believe that if it is enacted with the other provisions in the Bill, it will show good results in the time to come.
Comment on this
The kind of speech Senator Kissane has just made is one which could very well be followed out. It would be very interesting and profitable if we were to discuss the precise function of Deputies, whether these functions have heretofore been the best that could be contrived for the national interest and whether the electoral system we have is good for the particular purposes we want or whether a new system should be adopted. I should like very much to follow Senator Kissane on that particular line and discuss it.
However, I rose for a rather different purpose. I found the Minister's speech on the subject this evening— perhaps I should say off the subject? —rather depressing. He began on a personal note about Senator McGuire who, after all, did say something about P.R. The Minister, in a sneering way and in a rather elephantine effort at humour, said that Senator McGuire should go to the United States on a crusade. I should like to put it to the House that if Senator McGuire did go to the United States, as a member of a crusade or otherwise, he would prove to be more knowledgeable and acceptable to the people of the United States than the present Minister for External Affairs.
Comment on this
I am saying it and a great many important people in America have said it quite clearly.
Comment on this
Senator Lenihan must learn to make his contribution to order in this House.
Comment on this
I want to make certain that the interruptions from that side will be dealt with in the same way.
Comment on this
Is Senator Mullins rising to a point of order?
Comment on this
I accept your suggestion that interruptions should cease, but I want it to be on all sides of the House.
Comment on this
On a point of information. In what way are pronouncements made in the United States related to the section with which we are dealing?
Comment on this
I am sure Senator Kissane heard the Minister make reference to Senator McGuire going to the United States. Senator Hayes is on that point. The Minister was not ruled out and I am not ruling out Senator Hayes on that point. I hope my ruling is clear.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it. I think if Senator McGuire went to the United States, as a representative on a crusade, or otherwise, he would be more knowledgeable and more acceptable to the people of the United States than the present Minister. At any rate, he would be lucid. He would not be personal. Certainly, he would be courteous and would be more like a representative Irishman in every shape and form than the Minister for External Affairs.
If the Minister wants to give advice perhaps he would go over to France and make a trip to Scandinavia and tell all these people that what they want is the British system of election, and if they only had the common sense of the Fianna Fáil Party and adopted the British system of election, all their evils would disappear. There would not be a bit of trouble in Scandinavia and there would be absolute stability in France. All they would have to do is adopt the British system. The Minister has hated the British in his time, just as he hates me at the moment. There is an example for him of something he could do to make retribution to the base, brutal and bloody Saxon.
Having said that, let me come on to P.R. I did not say I wanted minorities of a small character represented in the Dáil. What I said—and what the Minister in his speech on the Second Stage and his speech here to-day did not advert to—is that what we have at present is a system whereby you must get a majority to get into the Dáil and what we are substituting for it is a system whereby you may get the minority of votes in the constituencies and still get a substantial majority of the seats. The Minister suggested a ludicrous amendment. I will confess to him he reminded me of something I did not think of before. I should like to suggest an amendment—and I think it would be in order—to add certain words: "That Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members who represent constituencies and one member only shall be returned for each constituency, even if such member is elected on a minority vote." That would be a suitable amendment and it would express the precise kind of thing we are doing in this Bill and in this sub-section.
That is the position. The voter's choice is strictly limited. What I said was that we have a system which gives a fair representation to the voters on the votes cast and that we are substituting for that system a system which will enable a well-organised Party to get a minority of the votes in the country and a substantial majority of the seats in the Dáil. In other words, we are substituting a minority system for the system we have.
It is alleged that stability and continuity are assured by the British system. The reverse is true. Rapid change takes place under the British system. We get more stability and more continuity here. It is surely healthier for the body politic, and particularly healthier for us in our circumstances and with our history, that there should be a fair system of election and no frustration on the part of anybody.
I should like to hear from Senator Kissane, who has experience of this. I should like to discuss this matter on a calmer basis and see what kind of Dáil we really do want. I have seen a great many different kinds of Dáil. It is doubtful whether there should be insistence on a full Party programme. It is doubtful whether a Government should resign when it is defeated if it is not on a matter of importance. I believe we are a homogeneous community; and I think the Dáil and Seanad, but particularly the Dáil, proved completely that we are a homogeneous community, because in spite of the efforts made, and made very actively—the Minister himself made them—to keep people apart, the back benchers did get together and proved we were a homogeneous community that could not be divided. If that is so, why not let the Dáil act according to that? Why could we not have more special committees and less full dress debates? Why should we have what we have at present: a constant edge as between one side and the other? There is no reason why the Dáil should be a battlefield. We might make improvements there and let the electoral system alone.
There is only one other thing I should like to say. I put it before, but I should like to put it again. It has been said that this move is being made in the cause of progress. Progress towards what? What kind of progress has been impeded by this system of election we have had here since the State was founded? Will someone tell us what the Party in office who want to abolish P.R., have been prevented from doing by the system of election that obtains here? What have they been prevented from doing by not having the overwhelming majority which they say they want now? They have done a certain amount of harm and they might have done more if they had an overwhelming majority. I doubt it. Then we are told to let the people decide. We are not keeping the people from deciding but if the Senators are so anxious to let the people decide why would they not let the people have a system of election which would enable them to decide how many Deputies would get into the Dáil on a particular basis and for a particular purpose instead of having a system under which a distinct minority of votes at an election can give a substantial majority in the Dáil?
I see no reason at all for this particular sub-section except the reason that has been given so clearly by the Taoiseach now that under the present system he has been defeated and he is seeking—and seeking in vain—another system under which he cannot be defeated. There is no national reason whatever for this sub-section—nothing except Party political reasons. No one has told us what the real reasons are except these and I think nobody can.
Comment on this
There has been some discussion about the question of minorities. When the question was put as to why an amendment was not put down to try to deal with the people who are minorities, who have been deprived of their representation, it was Senator Sheehy Skeffington who said that, of course, those who opposed this Bill did not want to go all the way on the question of providing representation for minorities. I think he was probably speaking for many others on the opposite benches who were not prepared to go the whole way and have one constituency for the whole country in which every type of minority would be represented. Senator Sheehy Skeffington is willing to give representation to minorities, to those minorities who would be represented in a five seat constituency or possibly in a seven seat constituency but he is not prepared to go further than that.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation. I said I accepted the present position which includes three seat constituencies. My point was that the big Parties under the present system are given extra power but the present system does not eliminate the small Parties.
Comment on this
My point is that Senator Sheehy Skeffington was apparently satisfied with the system which would provide at most a seven seat constituency. He would not ask for a bigger constituency than that. I think I am correct in interpreting his position in that way but why stop at a seven seat constituency? Why, if a question of minorities is being dealt with, and its consideration is apparently giving trouble to a lot of people, does he decide to stop at a seven seat constituency? How can Senator Sheehy Skeffington decide that once you have a constituency of say, seven seats, you will be able to get a seat in that size constituency, that in that situation you are adequately dealing with the right of minorities because it is quite clear that you will not deal with all minorities under such a system and that you will not give representation to all minorities?
I do not see why you can suddenly pick a certain size of constituency and say, thus far shall we go and no further. Who is to determine what size of constituency you can stop at? Who is to determine what size of a minority you must give representation to and what size of a minority you need not give representation to? Senator Sheehy Skeffington is apparently deciding to his own satisfaction that if you have a five seat or at the most a seven seat constituency you are going far enough but many others would probably decide that that was not going far enough.
I believe that it is when you stop to consider this question of how far you should go you realise the impossibility of dealing adequately with this question of minorities—the impossibility of dealing with it on the basis of trying to give representation on a proportional basis to different sections of the community. I believe it is impossible to do that under P.R. and certainly under P.R. as we have known it here during the past 30 years.
In the Dáil at the moment under the system which is being defended you have a number of Parties but I do not think it can be contended that you have minorities represented in the sense in which it has been argued here that minorities should be represented because neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael in the Dáil represent minorities. I think that both of them purport to represent all sections of the community.
I do not think it can seriously be suggested that Clann na Talmhan represents any particular minority and although the Labour Party does purport to represent a minority, in fact, they do not succeed in doing so to any great extent, so that the present P.R. system, which is being defended and which is being fought for because it is supposed to be giving representation to minorities, in fact, has failed entirely to do so. No matter how far you extend it, even to five seats or seven seats, I do not think you will appreciably improve the position and those who are defending P.R. are not prepared to go the whole way and have one constituency in which, undoubtedly, you would have every type of minority in the country adequately represented.
If you sincerely believe that the primary consideration in the electoral system is to give satisfactory representation to minorities, then you must go the whole way and have one constituency for the whole country in which every minority, no matter how small, will have their chance of having representation. If you are not going the whole way, if you are going to cut it down to a constituency of five seats, seven seats or three seats, then it is quite clear that under that system you will not give representation to minorities. It is only wasting time to attempt to do it in that way.
The proof of that is the fact that in the Dáil at the moment we have not representation for minorities. Deputy Sheldon when he was speaking on this Bill in the Dáil summed it up very well when he gave the reason why he was voting for the amendment of the Constitution. He said that the trouble about the present electoral system was that it appeared to be doing something which it did not, in fact, do. That, I think, is the principal handicap, the principal disadvantage in the present system.
In so far as it may be contended that some minorities are represented in the Dáil at the moment, in so far as Labour is represented there and in so far as Clann na Talmhan may be regarded as a certain type of minority, a certain section of the farming community, then there is no reason why the same number of Deputies should not be elected under the single member constituency and the non-transferable vote. Consequently, I believe the proposed new system can produce exactly the same Dáil and deal with the question of representation just as satisfactorily as it is being dealt with to-day.
Comment on this
It is very unfortunate that the Taoiseach has plunged the country into a bitter political controversy at this particular time in his determination to abolish P.R. There was never more important and pressing work to be done than there is now and never in the history of our country was it more important that all Parties should work in close unity and harmony in the interests of the country and try to end unemployment, to end emigration, and to get cracking, as some people stated a few months ago. This is a most retrograde step.
Comment on this
This is not a Second Reading debate.
Comment on this
I entirely agree. It is a most retrograde step which may have far-reaching consequences. The idea of the Taoiseach seems to be to divide the people when they should be coming together and working in the interests of all sections of the community. No matter what has been stated here to-day or was stated in summing up by the Taoiseach on the last day, P.R. has served this country very well. It has given us stability and strong Government but, unfortunately, it may not have given us good Government all the time. We all know that it gives the different Parties representation more or less proportionate to their strength. The British system, which the Fianna Fáil Party are trying to foist on the country, does not do that. There is no better example than what has taken place in Northern Ireland, where the minority has been kept down and has not got fair representation. We know that this straight voting system will suit the large, well-organised Party, and the Party with most money behind it. We know what that Party is at the present time, the Party that has very big industrialists who will give big subscriptions. That is the Party that can succeed under this scheme. Under the system of straight voting you can have freak results and a minority Government. Only a year or two ago a minority in this country tried to usurp the authority of the Dáil.
Comment on this
We hear Fianna Fáil to-day speaking about democracy and the rule of law. This is coming from people who from 1922 to 1927 did not think much about democracy and in that time usurped——
Comment on this
We need not go back to that period at all.
Comment on this
When we hear these people talking about democracy it is only right that we should know what happened between 1922 and 1927.
Comment on this
We have had enough of that period, and I am not going to permit discussion of that period on this sub-section of the Schedule. I hope that interruptions will cease and we will have a more amicable discussion.
Comment on this
I do not object to discussing that period. I will not sit here and hear any Senator discussing——
Comment on this
I am not going to permit discussion. I am responsible for order.
Comment on this
I said that a year or two ago a certain minority in this country tried to usurp power and interfere with the legitimate Government.