We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Coiste. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Committee Stage.

Contributions 149–293 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

I did not. I never mentioned 1922, but if there are things on the Fianna Fáil people's consciences, I cannot be responsible for that. I said that a year or two ago when we had a majority Government it had to take action to put down a minority.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We had to put down the Blue Shirts.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Mullins, really, as Leader of the House, must give a good example.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If Senator L'Estrange discusses the Bill I am prepared to give good example.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Mullins must accept the Chair's ruling.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do accept it unreservedly and hope that Senator L'Estrange will accept it too.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I say that Senator L'Estrange will accept it too.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to accept the ruling of the House even though Senator Mullins called me a liar. I am quite prepared to accept your ruling, Sir. The last day I spoke Senator Mullins referred to me as a liar twice.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not going back. Senator L'Estrange will resume his seat, please. We are not going back on what took place the last day. We are not taking up any questions with regard to order on the last day. Senator L'Estrange has referred to something of which I have no knowledge. If something like that took place on the last day and it was brought to the attention of the Chair then it is not going to be raised now. Senators must try to keep to the discussion on the sub-section.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I withdrew the expression in deference to the good order of the House.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Mullins withdrew the expression.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Then it is over.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is finished, and that was accepted by the House. It must be accepted by Senator L'Estrange and everybody else, and it is not open to discussion again.

Comment on this

I claim that a minority Government cannot act or speak in the interests of the whole people of the country as a majority Government can. We know that under the straight voting system, in a constituency where 12,000 people can vote, Fianna Fáil can get 4,000 votes, Fine Gael 3,000, Labour 2,000, Clann na Poblachta 2,000 and an Independent 1,000 votes. That will mean that the man with 4,000 votes would be elected to represent the whole 12,000 voters and the other 8,000 voters would have no legitimate representative in Parliament to speak for them. Nobody can deny that that can happen under this system. We gave examples on the last day which I am not going to go over again of what has happened in South Africa, and what happened in France where the Communists got 5,000,000 votes and only ten seats; it took 500,000 votes to elect one Communist Deputy whereas one Government supporter, a de Gaullist, was elected with 19,000 votes. We have heard a lot about minorities. We know that under our present political system it cannot be said that the Parties we have here now will not give fair play to the religious minorities—though at one time I believe that was not so.

The Parties we have now are all giving fair play to minorities, but we do not know what can happen under the straight vote system or what sort of Government we might have in 20, 30 or 40 years' time. We could have a set-up in which a Government might not give proper representation to minorities.

The farmers are the most important section of the community. The success or failure of our economy depends on them. Under P.R. they get a fair crack of the whip but if this referendum were carried—although I believe it will not be—you could have a socialist Government here. That could easily happen if there were an economic depression in Britain and if a couple of hundred thousand of our people had to come back here because under this system of single member constituencies 35 per cent. of the voters in a constituency could elect a Deputy. The farmers are entitled, as a national Farmers' Party, to put up their candidates and get fair representation. Under P.R. they can do that in the majority of the constituencies.

The same remarks apply to Labour. Under the straight vote system you could have a Government representing industrialists or perhaps ratepayers, and the Labour organisation might not get fair representation. Farmers and workers are the two most important sections of our people. They are entitled to have a system of election which will give them fair play. Although they can get that under the present system they will not get it if Fianna Fáil carry through this referendum and if the British and the Six County system of election is put into operation here.

We have heard a great deal about the selection of parliamentary representatives. Under P.R. the people have a choice but, if P.R. goes, the Party bosses will be in complete control. They will come to the different conventions and will be more inclined to select the "yes" man, the Party man, who will not kick over the traces, who will have very little to say and who will follow the leader at all times. That applies especially to the Party which forms the present Government. For 40 years the whole Party was in favour of P.R. The Taoiseach spoke in favour of P.R.—I quoted his words on the last day and I shall not repeat them now—in 1911, 1919, 1927, and he put it into the Constitution of 1937.

We had Senators telling us what happened in Germany and Italy when Hitler and Mussolini came to power. Senator Lenihan should remember that Hitler was five years in power and Mussolini six years in power in 1937 and if the Taoiseach had his eyes open then as he claims to have now he should have seen the wrongs of P.R. and should not have enshrined it in his Constitution of 1937.

The Taoiseach stated the last day that from 1938 onwards he knew that P.R. was wrong. Whom does he think he is fooling? For three years afterwards he had power to bring in a Bill to Dáil Éireann and by a simple majority there change that system if he so desired. In 1953 the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, stated he was in favour of P.R.

It might be no harm to quote from the Irish Catholic of the 23rd December, 1958, what Pope John XXIII said when he called on the people to participate actively in the political life of their country and carefully to select their parliamentary representatives. If this Bill goes through the people cannot select their parliamentary representatives. They will be selected by the Party bosses. The Pope stated:—

"Voters must choose their representatives with the greatest wisdom and knowledge because their choice is of particular importance in a democratic regime in which the representatives of the people have legislative power.

The moral rectitude, the practical capacity and the intellectual powers of parliamentary deputies are for the people of a democratic regime a matter of life and death, of prosperity or of decadence, of recovery or of perpetual ill condition."

If this Bill goes through, the people will have no choice whatever. They will have no way of judging the moral rectitude of the candidate, or as to whether he is a proper type of man or not. The Party bosses will select the candidate and the Fianna Fáil supporters will vote for that candidate. That system is altogether wrong. We want to get the best type of people into our Parliament.

Let us take, for example, the constituency of Longford-Westmeath where under P.R. you could have 14 or 15 candidates, where Fianna Fáil might have five candidates, Fine Gael four and other Parties three each. The people there have a choice and can vote one, two, three, all the way down to 15 if they wish. Fianna Fáil supporters can return the two best people out of their five candidates and Fine Gael supporters can do the same. However, under the new system, the British system that is being proposed, when the people go out to vote, all the Fianna Fáil supporters must vote for the man the Party bosses and the Party hacks have chosen whether he is good, bad or indifferent. We know the Parties do that because of elections in Roscommon and Wicklow candidates were selected by the people at a democratic convention and in Carlow-Kilkenny, the daughter of a Fianna Fáil ex-Minister was selected in a democratic way at a Party convention, but the autocrats and the dictators at Party headquarters turned these candidates down because they wanted to get better Party candidates and people who would toe the Party line.

It was interesting to listen to-day to the Minister for External Affairs. He asked Senator McGuire to make a crusade to England—I shall leave out what he said about America—to see how democracy has been saved there.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

When the House adjourned I was mentioning that the Minister for External Affairs said it was a pity that Senator McGuire did not make a crusade to Britain to see how democracy was saved in that country. It is a pity he did not add Red China and Cuba to that list. It might have been more relevant if he had mentioned Cuba.

If this measure goes through and if we have a system under which one member is returned for each constituency, then, as could very well happen in a view of the fact that Fianna Fáil had a majority in 39 constituencies out of 41 the last time, you could have the Fianna Fáil Party with perhaps 100 to 110 members and a very small Opposition. If graft, corruption and patronage continue as at present the people would become disillusioned and what you might have here in a few years is a Fidel Castro. That is what we all want to avoid but, unfortunately, we seem to be heading in that direction.

When the Minister was quoting Britain and British democracy and implying that we should make a crusade to Britain, he said he had learned a little in the last 30 years. I remember the time we were told to burn everything British except their coal; that we had whipped John Bull left, right and centre; that the British market was gone and gone forever, thanks be to God. I remember when the Minister who is present to-day said that if every ship in the world were sent to the bottom of the sea we could do without Britain and the rest of the world. Now the Minister comes in here and, in this year of 1959, is of the opinion that we should go over to Britain to see how the proposed system for this country has saved democracy there. There is no doubt that the Minister has come a long way and learned a little in the past 30 years.

There was much talk about small Parties making promises before elections which they knew they had no intention of fulfilling. When I hear certain people speak along those lines, I am reminded of the Russian delegates speaking at the United Nations about peace and democracies. There is no small Party in this country which can equal the largest Party that we have here at present for making and breaking promises. We can go back to the promises made in 1932 that they alone had a plan to restore the Irish language and to end emigration and unemployment and to levy equitable rates on the farmers—they were between 6/- and 9/- in the £ then and we know what they are now. We had their promises of 1952 to maintain the subsidies and to reduce the cost of living and we know that those promises were not kept. Several promises were made before the 1954 General Election. We were promised definitely that subsidies would not be interfered with. Immediately Fianna Fáil got into power they sent the prices of bread, flour, and sugar up by almost 100 per cent.

The Minister for External Affairs spoke about blackmail being practised openly. If people in other Parties practise blackmail, either openly or behind closed doors, we on this side of the House, and the people who came before me since 1922—those in Cumann na nGaedheal—have a clean record in that regard. Let anybody on the far side give quotations now. The Minister said it was better to blackmail openly before elections than afterwards. It is a wonder that Fianna Fáil do not do what they preach—and if I am asked to give a quotation I will certainly give it.

In 1951 Fianna Fáil were in a minority after the general election of that year and were depending on the votes of five Independent Deputies. They met in the Party's headquarters and published a 17-point programme. Point No. 15 of that programme was to maintain the subsidies and to reduce the cost of living. We know the blackmail that went on at that time to get the votes of five Independents and we know that they were promised that there would be no general election for three years, or, if there was, that they would be compensated in other ways.

The Taoiseach stated here that any time he was not strong enough to govern, and had to depend on any small Party, he went to the country the next year and got a majority. He told us that he went to the country in 1933 because he did not have an overall majority; he went in 1938 because he did not get an overall majority in 1937; he went in 1944 because he did not get an overall majority in 1943 and he said —you can look up his own words:—

"Had we got back into power again in 1948 we would have gone to the country in 1949 and we would have got the overall majority that we wanted."

The question I want to ask the Taoiseach is this: if there was no blackmail practised openly—I am using the words of the Minister for External Affairs—and if there was no blackmail practised behind closed doors, why did he not go to the country in 1952 and have the general election that he said he would have had in 1949 if he had been elected in 1948?

The reason is quite obvious: two of the people who supported him left him and they were afterwards put into the Seanad. Indeed, despite the scurrilous attack which was definitely made in the other House on the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health, the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, has appointed one of the men to the Hospitals' Commission at a salary almost similar to what he would receive here.

Comment on this

The Senator will now come to the sub-section.

Comment on this

I am referring to the fact that the Minister for External Affairs spoke here to-day about blackmail being practised. This sub-section says: "Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members who represent constituencies, and one member only shall be returned for each constituency." I should like to know, if this goes through, can any guarantee be got from the Taoiseach, or the Minister for External Affairs, that those who differ from them politically will get a fair crack of the whip? Can there be any guarantee got from them? When I spoke on the last day I mentioned what has happened in Clare and what has happened, and is happening, in Galway, and the members for those constituencies were to reply, but so far I have not heard any reply.

Comment on this

The Senator will remember that this Bill has to do with parliamentary elections.

Comment on this

But remember, Sir, that this Bill says that one member shall be returned for each constituency. Let us take the County of Clare. There are four seats at present there and if this Bill goes through they will be held by four Fianna Fáil Deputies. Nobody can deny, unless it is gerrymandered to suit Fine Gael, and that is not very likely—that with the vote Fianna Fáil have there will be four Fianna Fáil Deputies. The same applies to Galway. If Galway is a single member constituency, instead of having the representation that you have at present—Fianna Fáil have the majority even though in some constituencies they have a majority of only several thousand votes—there can very easily be nine Fianna Fáil Deputies in Galway. Nine plus four makes 13 Fianna Fáil Deputies in this huge area of the country.

We are told that Deputies have to attend to the work of their constituents. Who is to attend to the work of those who stand for the Fine Gael policy in either Clare or Galway? Senator Lenihan may laugh. I know in my own county where people approached Fianna Fáil county councillors and they were asked if they were members of the local club and had they paid their subscription this year. I know that and I can prove it. I stated on the last day what was going on in Clare and Galway and certain people tried to contradict me but, as I said, if this system is passed, Fianna Fáil can get all the seats in Clare and the Opposition will get none. Fianna Fáil have 17 seats at present on the county council and the Opposition have 14. Despite that fact, on the subsidiary bodies where travelling expenses are paid——

Comment on this

I want to remind the Senator that local authorities are not involved in this Bill, which has to do with parliamentary elections.

Comment on this

But many of these people on the county councils in those areas will be the future T.D.s and surely if Fianna Fáil county councillors where the Party has a majority, do not give fair play and fair representation, then, when these people stand for the single seat constituencies and get into Leinster House, we cannot expect to get fair play from them. If they deny representation on every subsidiary body, except on two or three little hospital committees where there are no travelling expenses, then, surely, when they are promoted and come to Leinster House, they will dictate to the people of the whole country the same as they are doing in Clare and Galway.

Comment on this

I want to suggest to the Senator finally that he has adverted sufficiently to that matter and that he must now come to the question of parliamentary elections and the revision of constituencies.

Comment on this

I think that the present system has suited us admirably up to the present. It has given minorities fair representation in Parliament and I would recommend that the people vote against this measure.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I want to register my protest against the speech made here to-night by Senator Stanford. I think it was the most disgraceful speech I have heard from a public representative since I came into the Seanad. I think the Senator has done a disservice, not alone to the orderly conduct of affairs in this country, but a disservice to the unity which exists and which shall continue to exist amongst all sections of our people here. The idea that the protection of any religious minority in this island depends on a few lines on a piece of paper in a Constitution, or in an Act, or in a law, is so monstrous that I am surprised Senator Stanford could give it credence for one moment. It is not because their rights are guaranteed on paper or by law and it is not because a law is passed changing the system of election that any religious minority in this country will suffer in any way. The history of this country, even in times of stress, was such that religious minorities had no cause to fear the actions of the majority. I think that, particularly at this time, to introduce denominationalism into a debate on a system of election is something which should not be condoned or allowed to pass without comment.

Another unfortunate reference which Senator Stanford made was to the fact that a religious minority under P.R. can be sure of getting three Deputies elected as Protestants, and that under the proposed alteration in the system Protestants could not be elected as Protestants.

Comment on this

In point of fact, I said Protestants could not be certain of election as Protestants—quite a different thing.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maóláin Fianna Fáil

Very well. The mentality behind it is the same. It might be added for the information of Professor Stanford that the only representative of the Protestant minority in Dáil Éireann, who was elected as such, made a very strong case for this Bill and voted in favour of it.

Comment on this

He was elected by Catholics and Protestants.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I feel that to make a statement such as Senator Stanford made, that the change in the electoral system, will remove the safeguard for the Protestant minority, is so nonsensical that if the newspapers see fit to publish it, people will only laugh at the ridiculousness of the statement.

I do not intend to pursue the statements made here by certain Senators which were far from the subject under consideration. However, I should like to make reference to Senator McGuire's belief in regard to the straight vote system in England that it is not an ideal democratic system and that about four-fifths of the seats are permanently considered safe seats. Senator O'Quigley followed somewhat the same line and introduced the United States Constitution as a red herring. Another Senator stated that if the straight vote system were in operation here, Labour, for instance, might not get fair play.

In view of the statements which have been made in this House on the Second Stage, in the Dáil and throughout the country from public platforms with regard to what is likely to happen under the straight vote, it would be well to examine what has happened in the country nearest us which is operating the straight vote, and consider then whether the prospects put forward by the doleful prophets of Fine Gael and Labour here have any relation to the facts. For instance, we had the leader of the Fine Gael Party, a former Taoiseach, stating, at column 616, Volume 171, of the Dáil Debates, that the proposals

"are intended to put the political power of the people into the hands of the major political Party sponsoring them."

He was followed by the leader of the Labour Party, at column 618 of the same Volume, who said:—

"The architects of this Bill, if they wanted to confess openly what their intentions were, might have added in brackets, ‘to provide for the continued control of the Oireachtas by the Fianna Fáil Party'."

One would imagine that when the people approve of the proposals in the referendum and we have elections under the straight vote, by some means unknown to any living person, the results of the general election under that system are already known to Fianna Fáil and that we can forecast, as some of the Labour and Fine Gael speakers have forecast, the exact number of seats we will get and the number the Opposition will get. Listening to them, one would imagine that such an overwhelming majority would be achieved by Parties under the straight vote system that they could go on forever and that there would be hardly any hope of the people getting an opportunity in a reasonable time to pronounce judgment on what the Government elected at the previous election had done.

We are told that under the straight vote an Opposition would be wiped out, that the small Parties would be wiped out and that, in particular, the Bill was aimed at the Labour Party. I do not know what mentality pervades the Labour people who have spoken here and in the country but of one thing I am sure: if they approach the task of building a strong Party with a view to forming a Government with the hopeless outlook given expression to in their speeches here, then there is not much hope of their unseating either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael either under P.R. or the straight vote.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

"Alas!" said he. There is a famous musical called Show Boat. There was a famous song in it called “Old Man River.” Listening to the Fine Gael and Labour speakers reminds me of one of the lines in it sung by Paul Robeson. It is: “they are tired of living and scared of dying.”

Comment on this

And they want to do away with any opposition.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

But "they still keep rolling along".

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They want to get rid of opposition, said Senator Burke.

Comment on this

Somebody else saw that show too.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If "they still keep rolling along," why are they so pessimistic? Why are they so afraid of the straight vote and why do they turn the whole business which will arise under the straight vote into a sort of bogeyman?

Because of the peculiar statements which have been made here, I should like to refer to the history of recent political government in England, which is the country nearest to us that has the straight vote, and the state what happened to Parties and how it was that a certain Party became the Government of England with a great majority because they had confidence in themselves, undoubtedly, and put forward a programme which appealed to the people.

Before doing that, it might be of interest to recall, also, in reply to the statements that we are riveting a Fianna Fáil dictatorship on the backs of the people, what actually happened under the straight vote system in Great Britain. It is interesting to note that since 1900 there were 15 general elections in Great Britain. Let us examine them to see how the dictatorship of the straight vote operated.

The outcome of those 15 general elections was that on six occasions there was a Conservative Government, on four occasions there was a Labour Government, on three occasions there was a Liberal Government and on two occasions there was a Coalition Government. It was interesting, also, to note that only the Liberal Party ever formed a Government three times in a row. Labour and the Conservatives did get a second successive term of office but only on one occasion each. There were 15 general elections in Great Britain under the straight vote since 1900. Under P.R. here, a period or only 37 years—we had 14 general elections, one less than the British had in 59 years of the straight vote.

Comment on this

How many since 1932?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

These elections proved that no Party is invulnerable. Under the straight vote no Party can establish an impregnable hold on the people or on the votes. No Party can go up for election and say with certainty that they will be re-elected. The history of the last 16 years under the straight vote in Great Britain is eloquent testimony to that. It is the most informative and educative piece of history that could be recalled to Senators. I propose to recall it. It might enthuse the representatives of Labour here also.

The Conservatives and Liberals or Radicals, as some of them were known at that time, farmed out the Government of Great Britain between them in the early part of the century and the end of the 19th century. The modern Labour Party in Britain as such came into existence less than 60 years ago and in the first general election in 1900 the Labour Party put forward 15 candidates. They got two of them elected. They did not howl for P.R. either. In 1906 the Labour Party put 50 candidates into the field. Twenty-nine were elected. At that time, as a result of that election, there were 379 Liberals and 157 Conservatives and 83 Nationalists. The Opposition Party were not wiped out.

In January, 1910, the Labour Party won 40 seats. They added two more to their total in the second election which followed at the end of that year. In 1918, a month after the great allied victory in World War I, when they had what was known as the Khaki election, and we had what was known as the Republican Victory election here, the Labour Party won 57 seats in spite of the war hysteria and in spite of the anti-Kaiser mentality put forward by the war-time Coalition Government. Incidentally, at that time they polled over 2,500,000 votes in spite of all the handicaps I have mentioned. A significant development at that time was that from being a sort of wishy-washy representation of the working people they began to adopt a definitely socialist outlook and thus marked themselves out as apart from the Liberal and Conservative Parties.

In this 1918 election, too, for the first time the people of Britain were offered a choice of two alternative Governments because Labour had 316 candidates in the field. They did not, however, succeed. It took them 27 years after that before they became a Government but they did not whine and cry about riveting a dictatorship and the unfairness of the vote or anything like that. They just plodded on, worked and produced a policy and gained the confidence of the people.

We continue the story. In 1922, Labour got 142 seats and they added 49 more to this total when a snap election was held in 1923. Those Senators who take any interest in what happens in other countries will remember that Ramsey MacDonald, with a Party of 191 Labour men behind him, but relying on the support of the Liberals—159 of them—formed the first Labour Government in Britain in 1923. The minority Government fell when the Liberals withdrew their support because of the foreign policy adopted by Ramsey MacDonald.

There was a general election then and the consequence of the scare propaganda which was perpertrated by the experts whom we have so often learned to distrust in this country was the defeat of the Labour Party. Although they lost 40 seats, their candidates polled a record total at that time of 5,500,000 votes. It did not dishearten them. They did not whine for the P.R. system to give them a fair deal. They did not say that the Tories and the Liberals had put a dictatorship on their backs. They just kept on and accepted the verdict of the people.

Labour came out of the General Election of 1929 with a greater representation in the House of Commons than any other Party. They got 288 seats and the second Labour Government was formed but it was again relying on Liberal support. It was not a Coalition Government, but was a minority Government carrying on with the support of another Party so long as its policy appealed to the other Party. It lasted only two years.

That Government was heavily defeated in the election of 1931 by a coalition of Tories, Liberals, and, unfortunately, a bunch of renegade labourites who befuddled the electorate with a scare story about the savings banks, that their deposits would be worthless and the pound would drop. The consequence was that the Labour Party lost 200 seats, and went back with 52 returned, but they did not give up. All this is a propos of the position which obtains in this country, where it is alleged that, because there are two big Parties now, there must be always two big Parties and never a third or a fourth or a fifth Party under straight voting.

Labour staged a comeback in 1935 and won three times as many seats as they had won in 1931. They had 156 seats. I know that some Senators do not like this medicine, but they must take it. I am going to continue speaking until I am satisfied that I have done my best to educate them. After all these years, we come to 1945 and victory, and what a victory. It was a total victory. As I said here in the Second Stage debate, in reply to an ignorant interruption, the Labour Party swept Britain and achieved an independent majority of almost 150 seats over all other Parties and groups combined. They got 394 seats, and an interesting thing about it is that only one of their 603 candidates lost his deposit.

Comment on this

Why are you quoting England all the time? I thought you did not like England.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

This great sweep did not wipe out every other Party.

Comment on this

It led to two big Parties. You are proving just what we want to say.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There were 188 Conservatives returned, as well as Liberals, Unionists, Communists, National Government supporters and Independents to the number of 60. This was at a time when Labour swept Britain with the greatest majority ever. Would you not imagine that at that time, when Labour secured such a grip on the Government of the country and people showed such tremendous support, that they were there for ever, that it would be impossible to shift them, if what we have been told is true—that under the straight voting system with single seat constituencies you could never shift Fianna Fáil out of Government? Maybe these people, if they had been living in Britain in 1945, would have said that there was no hope of ever shifting the Labour Party but it did not work out that way. In five short years—in fact, less—public opinion began to swing around, and, when the election of 1950 came, the Conservatives were again on the road back; Labour lost 79 seats and the Conservatives gained 100. The Labour Government majority in the House of Commons was reduced to seven but this time not one of its 617 candidates lost his deposit.

After the sweeping victory of 1945, in five years that tremendous force was reduced to a majority of seven under the straight vote. We are told here that once the straight vote system is brought in here there will be one Government for all time, and it will be Fianna Fáil. I am trying to show Senators that they need not be so pessimistic. In the ordinary way of life, people will change their opinions and Senators may hope that if they behave themselves and are good boys and stop being so ignorant here now, and try to listen to my voice, they themselves may some day——

Comment on this

Is it in order to refer to us as ignorant? I did not interrupt and I refuse to be referred to as ignorant.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

During four and a half years of the Labour Government —it is interesting in regard to what we are told about the stranglehold Fianna Fáil or any other Party will get—there were 52 by-elections and the Labour Party put up a remarkable record of not losing one seat they held at the general election. Would that not make anybody believe that there was no possibility of any alternative Government ever arising in Britain for many moons? But, as I have said, when the election came in 1950, in spite of the tremendous record of achievement they had put up in five years and of the fact that they were the most energetic and active Government Britain had had for a century and in spite of the tremendous support they had got from the people in the previous general election, they were left without an effective working majority in Parliament under the straight vote.

It is interesting also to note, in view of what has been said in the debate on the Second Stage of the Bill and also in the Dáil, that in that election of 1950 every one of the 613 seats in Britain was contested. There was a stern fight for every one of them and even the seat of the Speaker of the House of Commons was contested and he had to win it at the polls. The Labour Government at that time could not carry on with a majority of seven and there was another general election. This time Labour lost 19 seats and the Conservatives gained 22, and with a strength of 320 to 296 the Conservatives formed a Government which ran its full term.

What I want to try to drive into the heads of Senators—and none are so blind as they who will not see—is the fact that even at times of greatest Party victory under the straight voting system the Opposition Parties were not reduced to nullity and impotence. They were not wiped out. They were a very effective force in Parliament and formed a very constructive and active opposition and when the Government policy lost public approval even the biggest majority at the previous election was no guarantee that they would be returned at the next. Take, for instance, what happened in the last general election in Britain, when the Conservatives got a second term of office with 344 seats to Labour's 277. The popular vote was 13,311,938 to 12,405,246 for Labour. Does anyone tell me there can be any aspersions cast on the democratic system of which that Government was elected such as the aspersions that were cast here to-night? Does anybody tell me that is not a fair and just system by which the people of a nation can choose its Government and Parliament?

I have shown, in the history of the rise in 50 short years of a tremendous Party in Britain, that under the straight vote system there is no such thing as an insurance policy for all time for any Party, that so long as a Party commands the support of the people, so long as a Party's policy merits the co-operation of the people, it will attract public support. When it does not do that, when its representatives fall down on their job, the Party loses support and no safe seats or anything else will be of any use. I should like to quote an article, which appears in the Fine Gael monthly paper, the National Observer, by one of those who helped to get the abolition of P.R. included in the first draft statement of policy issued by Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Quote his name.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely the Senator reads the National Observer. This is what he says:—

"Personally, I am so certain that a return to straight voting would not only be for the good of the country by ensuring continuance of stable Government but also for the good of Fine Gael as a Party, by giving it a chance of taking the lead, and that I think an effort should be made to dissuade Deputies and their immediate friends from settling down into an attitude of blank pessimistic opposition to the proposed change. Nearly all the arguments which have heretofore been most frequently used against the restoration of straight voting are so ill-founded and divorced from reason that long-continued use of them cannot but do harm."

That article is by Earnán de Blaghad and it saves me time in answering and answers Senators in a more effective way than anything I could say. There is no need for Fine Gael to be so pessimistic and so downhearted. There is no need for them to visualise the end of the world—it will not come that fast —and there is no need to bring into the fight against the straight vote everything that can be thought of at home and abroad from the Bible to pronouncements of His Holiness the Pope. There is no need for the introduction of propaganda of that nature.

The straight vote is a common-sense method of election. The single seat constituency is the type of area which will enable the people to secure good representation, to know their representatives and to keep tabs on them, and which will enable the representative to keep tabs on his constituency and know the people in it. It will give more effective and more satisfactory representation than the P.R. system has given us in that regard during the past 40 years. I would advise the Labour and Fine Gael Parties not to think the end of the world is coming. We believe in the co-existence of the Parties. We are not afraid to have the Labour Party, the Fine Gael Party or any other Parties provided the people want them, but it is a matter for the people to decide, not for us. We do not intend to wipe out anybody. As I said on the Second Stage of the Bill, any wiping out that will be done will be done by the people.

Comment on this

We want the chance to wipe you out.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am very sorry to see that Senator O'Leary, who has been jumping up and down like a jack-in-the-box, seems to suggest a serious split in the Labour Party. He and his fellow Senators here do not seem to be able to see any hope for the future, whereas one of his leaders addressing the Institute of Public Relations in Dublin the other night forecast that the united trade union movement, one of whose treasurers represents Labour in the Seanad, would move forward to a political future, not on the lines of the American Labour Party but on the lines of the British Labour Party; in other words, he visualised what I have been talking about for the last 15 minutes in regard to the history of the British Labour Party, that far from there being dark skies and no prospects, a united trade union movement can succeed in having a future in the political life of the nation. I have no doubt he speaks the mind of sensible representatives of the workers and that is the approach which supporters of the Labour Party should have in regard to these matters.

As for Fine Gael, if they feel that the people have lost confidence in them, that they will not be able to command sufficient support in any of the constituencies under the straight vote, it would be better for them to merge with some of the other Parties or some of the successors of the other Parties which in the past they tried to gobble up and did gobble up on a few occasions.

So many things have been said by Senator Professor Hayes here that it would take a whole speech to answer them and I do not intend to do it. One thing he said was that what we need most is new blood in politics. Under the straight vote system which the people will enact through a referendum, there will be new blood in politics. The P.R. system is not conducive to the emergence of new blood in the political life of the country. It ensures the continuity of representation by people who get in on personal grounds or at the tail end of a Party or by climbing up a ladder or getting transfers down to the 30th count, and so on, but it does not encourage or give a chance to new blood, young blood, to get into political life in the way in which the single seat constituency and the straight vote would. Therefore, if the Senator Professor Hayes really wants to see new blood in our political life he should withdraw his opposition to this Bill.

Senator Professor Hayes also said that nobody should say to Fine Gael or Labour: "You must amalgamate with someone else to fight us." Nobody is saying that. All anybody has said is that under the straight vote system there is nothing to prevent Parties or candidates in any constituency deciding that they will co-operate to ensure the defeat of somebody they do not like. They can do so under this system in exactly the same way as they can do it under P.R. But there is no question of their being able to do it under this system in exactly the same way as it was done under P.R.: in other words under this single seat constituency system, if there is any concerted plan of opposition to anyone, the cards will have to be put on the table before polling day and not after, so that the people will see clearly that they are either voting for a one-Party representative or for a representative of a conglomeration or combination of several Parties with a design approved by the several Parties concerned.

All I should like to add is a reference to that statement made by Senator Professor Hayes. The bargaining which goes on and which went on and which was described as a political blackmail is something which is peculiar to P.R. and peculiar to the coalition conditions which existed here on two occasions in the past ten or 12 years. It would be very unwise for Senator Professor Hayes or any of the other members of the Opposition to deny that any such thing existed. There is no doubt whatsoever about it. On another occasion, when it would be more relevant to the subject under discussion, I hope to return to it. For the moment, I am content to say I hope the members of Seanad Éireann will see that this sub-section is approved and that the Committee Stage of the Bill is passed within a reasonable time so that we may get down to other and serious work which awaits us.

Comment on this

I rise on this Committee Stage because, as a young man and a scientist, I am utterly disgusted with the attempt made to form what should be reasonable debate. I find the professor is held up as something that should be scoffed at and laughed at. My colleague, Senator O'Quigley, has done perhaps the finest job that has been done in this House and is giving value to the Irish people who sent him here. He has investigated 89 Constitutions. He was discharging his duty in the highest and noblest sense of the word. It ill befits any group to scoff at him. On the contrary, those people should be delighted with his painstaking work.

I myself, in my own way, have tried also to take what I hope is the scientific approach. I was trained as a scientist. I am used to dealing with scientists—people who know the facts; people who can discuss facts; people who will refute facts by other facts. I am not used to dealing with people who indulge in wild generalisations such as one made by Senator O'Reilly, for example. Speaking in this House on 18th February, 1959, as reported in the Official Report, column 830, Senator O'Reilly said:—

"I think if I suggest the Independent Senators on the Opposite side have become more Fine Gael than the Fine Gael members themselves it would be correct."

That is an outrageous statement. We were Independent, I presume, when we voted, and readily so, for the Government representative as Chairman of the Seanad—and we would do so again. We were right when we supported the Government on a number of their Bills but we are wrong when we try to do——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Has this anything to do with the question before the House?

Comment on this

It certainly has. When we try to make a scientific investigation in order to make a contribution to this Bill we are scoffed at and sneered at. What disturbs me more than anything else is the fact that the scoffing and the sneering have come from the younger elements across the House—a fact which makes me despair almost for the future of this country.

Comment on this

Has the Senator not got a sense of humour?

Comment on this

I have another quotation here from the speech made by Senator Lahiffe in this House on 18th February 1959, as reported at column 749 of the Official Report.

"I was speaking to some of the people in the West of Ireland since last week. They read some of those learned speeches"

—"learned" there, is a word of opprobium, too—

"and their attitude appears to be that the whole trouble in the world to-day is created by scientists and they say:—‘God help us if the scientists have anything to do with it any more.' We have only to mention the fact that the scientists have recommended that we retain P.R. and we have no further trouble about getting them to do what is right."

I assume that these two statements are actually the most valuable contributions made in this House towards showing the Irish people precisely what all this is about and getting them to take a stand and say that a proper investigation has not been made into where we are going.

There is no independent document, no report of a commission, to tell us where we are going except accounts of what is happening in other countries— conditions that do not fit here—and a tendency to ignore the close example we have got across the Border. Of course, that must be dismissed.

Comment on this

There is no parallel.

Comment on this

"There is no parallel." That is a typical argument. The Taoiseach set the headline when he said in this House on 19th February, 1959, as reported in the Official Report, column 881:—

"I do not know whether I should continue on this. The arguments that have been put forward here are simply arguments on a basis that do not stand careful examination."

It is a rule of debate that, when you have not a good case, you abuse your opponents. I suggest we have had far too much of that in the present debate.

Speaking, I hope, for the young men of this country, speaking for the graduates of the National University of Ireland who sent me here, I say we ask more from the country than what we are getting here. These men have lost confidence in our political parties. Like Nero, the political parties are fiddling while Rome is burning. They are destroying the very foundation on which our political system is built— the confidence of the people of this country.

Comment on this

Let the Senator make his contribution and stop——

Comment on this

A Minister's son.

Comment on this

I shall turn to some of Senator Ryan's wild generalisations. Let us examine the steps taken to bring three seat, four seat or five seat constituencies down to single seat constituencies, which is a most revolutionary and dangerous move. I wonder that we did not secure reliable prediction from men acknowledged as impartial, to show us where we are heading, before taking the step. I appeal for that commission. Lord Pakenham is, perhaps, the greatest friend this country has ever had in England. He knows the inside and the outside of the straight vote. He can tell us whether the Taoiseach's idea that all is fair and lovely in English politics, that they are all saints over there and that we are simply blackmailers here, is correct. I should like to hear Lord Pakenham's views on that matter.

I suggest that Monsieur Schumann, the greatest man in Western Europe to-day, not excepting Doctor Adenauer, could tell us the ins and outs of the straight vote system. He knows the purpose of Government. It is not the aggrandisement of a Party or the handing of dictatorial powers to any leader. It is the development of a country along Christian lines as befits Western Europe and as befits us more than anybody else. There is a man we can rely upon. We can get representatives from Denmark or anywhere else. If you do not want them to sit on a commission, you can get their advice as witnesses. But what do we find? How is this suggestion received? We find that the Minister for External Affairs says— he is actually the most open about it —at column 637, Volume 50:—

"We have had a commission of 147 men sitting on the proposed change for almost three months in the Dáil and I do not know how long it is going to take here. I think that is the best type of commission."

So he does subscribe to the idea of a commission. Did anybody ever see such a result as we have had from this commission, with the same charges being repeated and counter-repeated, with no effort being made to arrive at any conclusions? Did this, or did it not, happen in England? Was P.R. in operation in France? There were no efforts to arrive at conclusions. Surely if we treat the Dáil or the Seanad as a commission, the product of their months of discussion should be taken, analysed and conclusions drawn from it, if that is possible.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Has not the question of the commission suggested by Senator Quinlan already been decided? Is it in order to continue on this subject?

Comment on this

Surely it is in order to know what will happen when we move from the three seat constituency to the one seat constituency, to know what is proposed in this paragraph?

Comment on this

The Chair feels that the Senator is going unduly outside the scope of the section. The Seanad has already decided in principle for the single member constituencies.

Comment on this

Yes, but we are discussing the reasons and the arguments advanced by Senator Mullins——

Comment on this

The vote on the Second Reading decided that question.

Comment on this

Yes. Perhaps the Senator does not like the quotations but other members have given quotations and I am giving a few to bear out the necessity for being careful, for knowing where we are going. I would have expected Senator O'Donovan, as a man with scientific training, to appreciate the scientific approach. For Senator O'Donovan's benefit, I find that the Minister for External Affairs thinks a commission is a good idea and thinks there should be some effort to sum up what has happened in those debates. I presume that will be done. I hope it will be done for the guidance of the electors.

We come now to column 691 of the Official Reports and we find there that Senator Ryan is much more dogmatic on this than the Minister for External Affairs. He says:—

"The suggestion of setting up a commission is the purest nonsense and although I was not here when Senator Quinlan claims he answered the question which I put, I just cannot imagine who he suggests would be on that commission, who would be better qualified to deal with that subject than the members of the Oireachtas.

I suggest that such extravagant language as "the purest nonsense" merely reflects the weakness of the arguments that are being advanced.

We turn now to column 878, where the Taoiseach refers to the same thing. He says:—

"We had some Senators suggesting we should have had a commission. I think Senators travelled a good deal in seeing what other people had done. But our people have got first-hand knowledge, if they care to use it, first-hand knowledge of how this system works, why up to the present time it has worked not too unsuccessfully and the danger that lies inherent in it—the danger that comes from the fact that it induces a multiplicity of Parties and that with a multiplicity of Parties you will have endemic coalitions."

Well, the Taoiseach apparently does not make any real commitment on the question of a commission. To pass from the commission. It just shows that when you ask something that is scientific it is not refuted by direct argument; we are told we have the information already: it is really unnecessary. It is refuted by extravagant arguments, such as by describing it as the "purest nonsense", or some other type of L. and H. debating tactics.

Now I come to the points mentioned by the Minister for External Affairs. I, too, happened to be in the United States of America and I have taken a close interest in the economic life of the United States. I took a deep interest in it when I was there and there is no parallel whatsoever between the system there and the system we are proposing to introduce here. The straight vote in that country is ringed around with all forms of safeguards. The gravest fear that I have about the introduction of the straight vote and the reduction of the constituencies from three seat to one seat, is that it will lead to completely violent swings from one extreme to the other, unless the Party that gets the first big swing begins to feel that with their majority—probably five to one in the next election—they have a divine right to rule and henceforth the people have no right to do wrong. Consequently, steps must be taken to ensure that they cannot have instability of government, which would be interpreted as putting out the government that is in power——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How can they do that?

Comment on this

If Senator Mullins is really keen to know, I shall again give him those few points. First of all, in the United States you simply cannot have such a swing. That whole set up of the American Constitution was gone into by Senator O'Quigley and I do not want to go into it in detail. You have the division of powers; you have the President and his executive and you have a real Senate, not a shadow debating society like we have got. It has got real powers and, moreover, it is elected on a straight vote, in other words, single constituencies, but it is elected in three stages, ruling out any drive to a complete swing.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

But it is a straight vote?

Comment on this

That is the least feature of it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

But it is a straight vote election, is it not?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is what I wanted.

Comment on this

The really important feature is that the election is staggered. You have one-third elected this year, one-third is elected two years afterwards and one-third is elected two years after that. Whatever system you use, that will ensure that the pendulum cannot swing too far. The real danger is where the swing of the pendulum is too great. Then, the House of Representatives in America is elected every two years. So that, even if it does swing, as it very often does, the swing will be corrected quite quickly in a couple of years. There are all the other safeguards up above. There are highly developed democratic organisations that are always on their toes to challenge the Government on any breach of democratic rights there. We have not got to anything like the same stage or maturity of political development here.

Again, we take the other extreme, which is the English system, worked up so effectively by Senator Mullins. He gave a very interesting survey of the whole system and for that we are indebted to him. But there is a number of points that show that the English system is completely inapplicable here. That is due to the sharp division between the two groups there, the complete difference in philosophy between the Conservatives, on the one side, and Labour on the other, where anything between 400 and 500 of the 600 seats are completely tied. In other words, there is no possibility of a change.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are not tied.

Comment on this

The whole swing takes place in the 100 or 150, or at most 200 seats, where there is a chance for a change. So that, one of the worst effects of the straight vote is prevented in England by the tied seat system. Personally, I do not think I or anybody else here would be willing to sacrifice our independence and freedom of action to institute two-third tied seats here so that we would avoid a danger like that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There is no such thing as two-third tied seats in Britain.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Leader of the House should have more patience, like the Leader of the Opposition.

Comment on this

I should like to have these points answered. I should like to be well and truly assured on them by some really important person. For instance, I should like if Lord Pakenham could assure us that those conditions would not develop here. It is not unreasonable to ask that the electors should have that information before they are called on to give any decision or to vote.

We also see in England that candidates are picked two years in advance. In fact, there is the spectacle of a successor already picked to an Independent Conservative in Bournemouth, Mr. Nicolson, because Mr. Nicolson did not absolutely toe the Party line. It is very interesting to note how it works. Under the guise of democracy, the Party did not want to throw him out and say "You cannot stand any longer." But, as he has pointed out in his book, which should be required reading for all who speak on this, it was the loyal Party adherents down in the constituency that got the whisper from the big noises in Whitehall "Take care of him; he is a renegade." The Party machine went into action in the constituency, and Senators know the result. It is summed up here:—

"Every Party organisation aims at building up a solid core of adherents in the constituency, men and women who can be relied on to raise money and organise election campaigns. To these people the service of a Party is an end in itself and Party activities have a semi-religious character. For their benefit Party myths are invented and illusions fostered so that there is a permanent and artificial division between men of true and men of false political beliefs."

That would seem to sum up a lot of the debate we have had here: that the country must be divided into the sheep and the goats, and that the sheep will get everything.

Comment on this

The Senator will give the reference of the quotation.

Comment on this

The Times Literary Supplement of Friday, 10th October, 1958. The book is The Life and Soul of the Party, by Nicholson. It is published for the sum of 18/-.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

And it will be in the Library to-morrow.

Comment on this

I have been really intrigued by the statement of the Minister for External Affairs, and earlier, by the statement of Senator Mrs. Dowdall, about this half per cent. minority who have got seven per cent. of the votes under the English system. The Minister promised to give a straight answer to a straight question. May I ask who are the half per cent. minority referred to?

Comment on this

A half per cent. of the population in Britain are Jewish, and they get three per cent. of the representation. I did not say seven per cent.; I said three per cent.

Comment on this

It is not the first country in the world where the Jews have got very high representation. I think that is a tribute to the tenacity of the Jewish people, but it is rather remarkable that the Jewish people, with their outstanding success in England, did not see fit to impose the same system in the new State of Israel.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator has not read the papers.

Comment on this

Yes, I have read the papers, and I have seen where Mr. Ben Gurion, the same as any other man who has had uninterrupted power for a long time, is trying to think how he can perpetuate himself. He is looking longingly at the British system and saying, "If I could have that, I could possibly keep my Party in power for the next 20 years." I am sure that the Jews as a nation do not regard division as a foundation upon which they can build their young nation. They regard the co-operation and understanding of all groups in politics as absolutely essential to the national well-being; they consider that all are capable of making a contribution to the common good.

Again, I was appalled by the efforts to try to make the whole debate rediculous by resorting to the secondary school tactics of putting the case to the extreme and trying to suggest that if we are sincere in P.R., we should advocate one constituency for the whole country. Senator Sheehy Skeffington answered that exceedingly well when he said that the present system combined the two essentials of giving fair representation to all sections in Parliament and, at the same time, offering a chance of having stable Government for the period. You have got to combine the two. The present system does that reasonably well and, if we are to change from that, well, there are many alternatives besides what is being proposed.

Professor Hogan has been quoted so often and with such gusto that it would be well to know what his considered opinion on this is. His considered opinion is that if we do need a further shift in the direction of majority government, to give a bigger bonus to the larger Parties, we might consider breaking down the five and four seat constituencies to three seats; or even go a little bit further and, if we are not satisfied with that, we might institute in sparsely populated regions, like Kerry and parts of Connemara, a few trial single seat constituencies but, of course, with the transferable vote. That is his opinion. I have his authority to quote it here and I hope that Senators in future will not try to mis-represent what Professor Hogan says.

Senators' quotations show one thing. They show Professor Hogan the scientist and the man who can pick the faults in both systems. When they quote they quote just the faults. Anybody can find the faults. Why not quote the faults he finds in majority government? Why not quote the fact that he is convinced that it was the straight vote or the illiterate vote, where you place your "X", that brought the Reds into Spain? That is in his book and that should be quoted. Do we want anything like that to happen?

In the single seat non-transferable vote system there is a grave danger of getting these tremendous swings. That is the view of most people who have studied the problem carefully and with whom I have discussed the matter. I am asked how one can make predictions of election results. Surely any scientist must be prepared to make predictions. He must be prepared to get his figures together to show the basis of his predictions. Anybody who wishes to differ and who has the figures is entitled to show how the matter should be interpreted otherwise.

In my own constituency of Cork we have the situation where out of 43,000 votes cast in the last election three Fianna Fáil candidates were returned. I am in agreement with that. It gives a nice bonus to the majority Party. It gives them 60 per cent. of the representation for about 47 per cent. of the votes. That is a one-third bonus— quite a substantial bonus. The others elected there were—one Fine Gael member and one Labour man. The people of Cork are quite satisfied with that representation—at least they are satisfied in so far as each group feel they have somebody to go to. Fianna Fáil have their three members. Fine Gael can approach their man, Deputy Stephen Barrett, and Labour have a first-class representative in Deputy Casey so that the people feel they are represented. They feel they have access to Parliament.

What is proposed to be done? Cork City will now be divided into five regions and the poll in each region will then be about 9,000 votes the next time. No doubt we will have a Fianna Fáil candidate in each place. Also, I take it that we shall have a Fine Gael and a Labour candidate. What will the result be? Fianna Fáil, provided they can get about 37 or 38 per cent. of the votes in any one of the places, will be sure of the seat because the rest will be distributed between the two others, Fine Gael and Labour—not to mention any Independent who may stand for election.

The situation is that in Cork, on the average, 48 out of every 100 people voted for Fianna Fáil. Could anybody tell me how you can cut— or shall I use the word "gerrymander?"—a pocket out of Cork in which Fianna Fáil on the showing in the last election would have less than 37 per cent. of the votes? I certainly am not aware of any such regions in the city. The result of this manoeuvre, then, will be that in place of the present representation for Cork City there will be five Fianna Fáil Deputies for Cork City.

I do not think that the people of Cork City, when that is explained to them, will have any doubt whatever about the justification for the retention of P.R. I do not think they will listen to any fantastic tales by anyone, whether Minister or Senator, about the injustice of P.R. Surely the concrete example of the injustice of the straight vote or the illiterate vote for Cork City will be the fact that next time there must be five Fianna Fáil representatives?

Then, of course, we have the wonderful case made that the representative will suddenly become conscious of the whole community. He will represent everybody in his constituency. He will become what you might call a coalition or inter-Party man—the same to everybody. If he is to carry out all these duties properly, on Monday night he must attend at Fianna Fáil headquarters, on Tuesday night, Fine Gael headquarters and on Wednesday night he must go back to the Labour headquarters. I do not know whether the Independent will be able to get hold of him on any night of the week.

Surely nobody is serious in suggesting that that type of representation will be better than what we have at present? I should like to go on record as stating that if they lose Deputy Casey in Cork City they will lose one of the best Deputies they have. He is a first class man. He is also a man who took long and serious steps to train himself before he ever entered public life. He is a man who has got all the social teaching. That also might be said about Senator Murphy and Senator Crowley. In other words, the Labour Party are to be congratulated on the type of men it is turning out at present. It ill behaves any Government to contemplate driving these men out of Parliament. They are a credit anywhere, whether they are in Government or in Opposition. I say that while I am identified with no Party whatsoever.

I come to my own home county in West Limerick where, in recent years, Fianna Fáil have got a fairly substantial majority and which previously was a seven seat constituency. That was cut up rather nicely. Now there is a three seat and a four seat constituency. The three seat constituency is such that it has returned, since it was formed, two Fianna Fáil Deputies and one Fine Gael Deputy. I do not object. It gives an edge to the majority Party.

What will happen from now on? At present, there are three Deputies in West Limerick. The last time there were elected there Deputy Collins, Deputy Ó Briain and Deputy Jones. Fianna Fáil got 53 per cent. of the votes and they got two seats. The others got 47 per cent. This will be divided up and there will be three Fianna Fáil Deputies returned there the next time. If the last election had been conducted on the system now proposed, it is almost certain that we would have three Government representatives and no Fine Gael representative. I do not think the people of West Limerick would appreciate that.

I could go on but I do not wish to weary the House with the election results from all the other regions. Of course, we are reminded by the Taoiseach and others that it is not fair to add together the Labour and Fine Gael vote. He would like to split it equally between the two. That is not what is happening. The split is that at least 95 per cent. of the vote from one group has transferred over to the other in the election.

Next, we have the claim, again rather extravagantly made, that the proposed change will do at least one thing: It will make every Party stand on its own two feet. That is a grand thing, that seems on the surface to be very well worth while, but is it a fact? We have only to look across the Border to see that it is not so, because after 30 years we are to-day no nearer the replacement of the Unionist Government than we were in 1929.

Senator Ryan thought that far too much was made of this because he conceives that 60 per cent. of the North are Unionists. In fact that is the highest figure I have heard conceded by anybody here who was advocating the ending of Partition. The last election results gave 39 seats out of 52 to the Unionist Party. That is 75 per cent. representation for 60 per cent. of the people, and the others, who got 40 per cent. of the vote on Senator Ryan's calculation, had to be content with 25 per cent. of the seats. He is content with the system under which a Unionist in the North requires only half as many votes to elect him as a Nationalist or a Labour man.

Where can we make progress when we have such wrong thinking on these important issues? If that is the case why do we not recognise that the Unionists are fixed in the North always and for all time, and give over satire-rattling about Partition? I was one of those at the inter-Parliamentary Union in London last year and we were, to tell the truth, a bit nauseated about two much sabre-rattling on the Partition question. The speeches made then will all have to be rewritten, because we cannot charge them with gerrymandering, as has been charged down the years. We should be honest about it, withdraw our charges and instruct our representatives in the U.N.O. and elsewhere to withdraw those charges, and to do it gracefully.

We come to the business that those advocating the abolition of P.R. want to push the whole thing to the absurdity of suggesting that we are looking for a single constituency for the whole country. But they rebel when we point out where the other system, of straight voting, can be pushed to. They rebel when we tell them where it has taken the people of Russia, Hungary, China, and everywhere else. In fact, every one of those dictatorships has its straight voting. They get the citizens to put down their X before the name of the candidate the government tells them. They are progressing recently, and feel that they ought to have the trappings of democracy, so they are, in a few elections behind the Iron Curtain, putting up a selected opposition as well. There is where the straight vote leads you.

Remember that here, while we may pride ourselves on our Christian heritage and traditions and the way we observe our religious festivals and our religion, those who are studying us, the philosophers, whose business it is to study trends, have for years called out against the dictatorial leanings and developments evident in Irish politics over the last 20 or 30 years. We have the whole period of the ‘30's when there was ruthless centralisation of government, with the county councils and corporations and all the rest being almost squeezed out of existence. You might say that they are there to-day simply to draw their travelling expenses and do what the manager tells them. It is no wonder that we have our rates and everything else at the level we have, when the local authorities will not be given the necessary function in that matter.

The totalitarian outlook is most dangerous when it is in people who are not aware that they have that outlook. That is our real difficulty here. People say "how can Ireland go Communist? How could such a thing happen?" But Douglas Hyde, who knows a lot more about the methods of Communism than anybody in this or the other House, is not so dogmatic about it. In fact, he is almost dreading the fact that it could happen.

Again, take Professor James Hogan, who has been quoted here. If you read his pamphlet, published in 1939, "Can Ireland become Communist?" you cannot be so complacent. Power corrupts and absolute power absolutely corrupts. That is what we have to keep in mind, and democracy has to be hedged around with all forms of safeguards. That is why we on this side feel that we are doing our duty to the Irish nation by debating this measure fully and properly and by spending hours carrying out scientific investigations. I am proud to say that I am doing that while still putting 40 or 50 hours into my own job. I can say to anybody that I have not for one moment neglected that job. I have spent extra hours in endeavouring to make a scientific approach to and analysis of this problem. The more I analyse it the more frightened I become of the dreadful consequences that can happen.

Up and down the country there are young men, and men not so young, who are trying to find out what this is all about. No better advice could be given to those people than that they should obtain the Seanad reports over the past four weeks, go through them carefully and critically examine the arguments put up, see the answers by those opposing this motion and, above all, note the extravagant statements and the use of the principle: "If you have a bad case, abuse your opponents." These Seanad reports, in my view, present the most damning case that can be made against the present proposal. I believe that they are not by any means finished yet.

We come to the Labour Party in England. I want to make just one passing reference to it. Perhaps Senator Mullins, who is not here, and who takes such a poor view of professors in this country, might be surprised if he saw the number of professors who are in the British Labour Party and I suppose he would be amazed, too, at the fact that these are the men who hold most of the safe seats. The Party simply imposes them on the people down the country. I wonder will the present or any future Government endeavour to make more use of our universities when they do get all these safe seats.

I want to go on record as having approved very much of Senator Stanford's statement, which was reasoned and perfectly legitimate and sound, and one that should not be dismissed in the way in which it has been. His statement merely covered a possibility which he and I and everybody else hope will never arise here. However, if we have Senator Mullins referring to safeguards in the Constitution as just scraps of paper, what guarantee or protection does the Constitution give us?

I do not think young Ireland can afford to sit down and wait while some new Party grows up, like the British Labour Party, in the hope that it might obtain power here after 27 years. If that is the hope that is held out to us, that we will have Party bosses of the worst type until then, that we are going to repeat the history and follow the absolute reign for 27 years of the Unionist Party in the Six Counties then there is little future in this country for any young people.

One of the most frightening features of the single seat constituency and the non-transferable vote is the way men of ability have been squelched out in the North and in Britain. We have the recent case of Mr. Montgomery Hyde and only a few years back we had that of Dr. Warnock who, because he was a brilliant man was pushed out by the Party bosses. If they had P.R. in the North you would have far better representation for the opposition. Take the 1955 Westminster Election, where 127,000 in the four constituencies in Belfast voted Unionist, 52,000 voted Labour and 18,000 Nationalist. By the magic of the straight vote the Unionists got the four seats and there was no representation for anybody else. Does anybody here say it is a fair system that deprives 70,000 non-Unionist voters in Belfast of representation? If that is the case, everything we have been saying about Partition up to this has been all wrong.

The National Parliament has been mentioned. It is a healthy sign that there are some few in the Fine Gael ranks who are in favour of the straight vote, who have the courage of their convictions and are not tied up by Party considerations. I would be far happier about this measure if it could be shown that there are three or four supporters of the Government who are not in favour of it. This 100 per cent. support gives me the same sickening feeling I experience on seeing that Hitler or Stalin got 99.9 per cent. of the votes in an election. Such people never get less than 99.9 per cent. of the votes cast.

A great deal has been said about consulting the people. When this is being done, why not consult the people properly, first of all, by letting them have an authoritative report by impartial people setting out precisely what we might expect from any one of the half dozen changes to be made in the present system? When the people have had that report, why not consult them properly instead of giving them a package deal in which you say: Do you approve of the single seat constituency and the non-transferable vote? Surely these are two distinct and separate questions.

If we respect the people and if we regard them as the final arbiters in this, surely they have the right to answer each of these questions separately: No. 1. Do you approve of the single seat constituency? If a majority are in favour of No. 1, No. 2 could be put: Do you approve of having the vote transferable or should it be non-transferable?

From what I have read in the Cork Examiner of 25th February, the fact that what I am saying is simple logic is clear to our representatives in the United Nations. Apparently, when we go away, we can be objective. Before that assembly there is the question of the future of the British Cameroons in Africa and the question of holding a plebiscite. There are disputes in the Trusteeship Committee of the General Assembly as to what the future should be there and as to what questions they should ask those people. We do not think they are being fair to those people. They are not asking them sufficient questions. They are not putting all the alternatives before the people and so our representative, Mr. Kennedy, suggests that four choices should be offered in the plebiscite. It is accepted by us that a plebiscite is not a matter of black and white, yes or no. He wants four choices, and rightly so. These are the four questions suggested: No. 1. Should the British Cameroons integrate with Nigeria; No. 2. Should they integrate with the French Cameroons; No. 3. Should there be a continued trusteeship; and No. 4. Should there be eventual independence?

You cannot solve that problem by an X vote. You must get down to your 1, 2, 3 and 4. The people will have to be asked to vote No. 1 for the proposition they favour most, No. 2 for their second choice, No. 3 for their third, and No. 4 for their fourth. They are being asked to vote in an intelligent way, not in the way in which you treat illiterates by asking them to make their mark, to put down their X. Some have suggested that the use of the figures 1, 2, 3 and 4 is wrong. All it means in the case of the British Cameroons is that it saves going back next week and the week after and the week after that again. If you were to operate this plebiscite with an X you should say: "Put an X against your choice". The Xs would be totalled up and the proposition that gets the least number of Xs out of the four is ruled out and we are back the week after with three questions. Then we ask them to put their X to the proposition they favour most of the three. The Xs are counted up again and the question with the least number of Xs is eliminated. Finally we are down to two questions and they vote accordingly. But the simple process of 1, 2, 3 and 4, which is capable of being understood by any national schoolboy is being used to avoid the expense and delay of repetition.

All the person is asked simply is: "If we cannot comply with your first choice, what will we do after it?"

Senators are all familiar with this question of voting, whether it be for a lord mayor, a rate collector, or anything else. Four, five or six names are proposed. You put your "X" before the name you think best. Then the "Xs" are totalled up and the candidate with the lowest number is declared out. You vote again until you eventually bring it down to two candidates and then you vote between those two. All that could be done at any corporation or county council meeting in a single vote by simply asking the members to vote 1, 2, 3 and 4— it being understood that, if they cannot give them the man they give the No. 1 vote to, they will give them the man to whom they give No. 2. There is a lot of misunderstanding of that throughout the country and a feeling that a simple vote is the right thing for a simple people. Surely our people, in this day and age, are able to put down 1, 2, 3, 4 rather than be reduced simply to making "Xs".

I want to comment on the question of stability of Government. It is claimed that the reduction from multi seat down to single seat constituencies will contribute to stability of Government. I have made the point that my fear is that it will give over-stability, which is, if you wish, far worse than under-stability. You get these complete swings. It raises the question then: Have we had instability of Government or are we likely to have instability of Government in this country in the future?

We have got to look at those frightful tragedies that the proposers of this Bill have cited, where the Government, in 1933, had an election after a year; in 1938, they had an election after another year and again in 1944. Well, these actually were only examples of good political craft on the part of the Taoiseach himself. They caused no more instability here than a good bout of 'flu would have caused. All they meant was that, for three or four weeks between the declaration of an election and the election itself, the Ministers were absent part of the time from their offices. They were still there as Ministers but they were absent just part of the time. In fact, you might say it was equal to taking two weeks' holidays. They returned after the election to the same offices they had before the election. I submit that to regard such a thing as instability of Government or as preventing any action is very much against the facts.

The Minister for External Affairs has been demanding a straight answer to a straight question. Perhaps he will give a straight answer to a very straight question I want to put to him. I do not expect the answer to-day. We will give him a few days. The question is this: Will the Minister list, in each of the periods in which his Party were in Government, just three items that they were prevented from carrying through due to the fact that they had not a greater majority in the House than they had? I am asking the Minister to list just three in each period to show how these were the vital happenings that would have made all the difference to our present position. Personally, I, as a scientist, or any other person—Senator Mrs. Dowdall may laugh——

Comment on this

I am bored with the repetition.

Comment on this

Repetition is sometimes very good. Teachers use it to try to get a fact across, sometimes.

Comment on this

The Senator has used that phrase on quite a number of occasions.

Comment on this

I hope it will improve Senator O'Reilly's knowledge of science and scientists. Speaking for the younger people of this country—

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan need not be so offensive.

Comment on this

Speaking for the younger people, I must point out that our emigration is running from 40,000 to 50,000 a year while our birthrate is only 60,000. Our unemployment is running at 80,000 a year. These figures condemn the Government we have had in our own time. Did anybody, starting off in 1918 or 1920, contemplate such a trend of events? What would they have said if they were told that that would be the effect of our attempts at self-government in 30 years? How would they have reacted if they were told that we would have more Irish in England by 1959 than we had in the Six Counties in 1922? Surely that condemns our Government offhand? I am not criticising their efforts but it shows we have not been as successful as we should. It shows that, to us here, emigration is a far greater catastrophe than the world war was for Britain. It shows that far more of our population was being lost than the number of the British population killed during the world war years.

Comment on this

Is this relevant to the question before the House?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator blaming P.R. for that?

Comment on this

Perhaps you do not like to mention emigration and to mention those facts as showing the failure of our Government. Perhaps the Minister for External Affairs will be able to show that they were prevented from taking measures over the past years that would have righted our emigration position. I do not see where that can be but we can wait and see what he will have to say on it.

In England, the great catastrophe of the world war was faced by a uniting of all the Parties together for the common good. For five solid years, England was ruled by coalition. Mr. Atlee, as the Deputy Premier, was consulted on everything by Mr. Churchill and it was that unity that pulled the nation through. I feel we shall not get anywhere with emigration or Partition until we face those problems, as a united nation.

I think I am voicing the opinion of most of the young people of this country when I say that, at least for four or five years, there should be an end to Party squabbling and an effort should be made to get down to it and to pull this country out of the position in which we find ourselves—a position that is far more serious, nationally, for us than even the dark days of Dunkirk were for the British nation.

Again on the question of stability, even if we take the position when Fianna Fáil were replaced by the inter-Party Government, I say that most other countries would have regarded that as a ripple on the ocean. They would have regarded it as just a slight change of emphasis. A new team had come together but they had basically the same philosophy. They were basically trying to do their best to pull the country together. Bear in mind that the two have the same team of advisors. That is what is lost sight of in all our discussions on stability.

Our Civil Service provides the whole machinery behind our Government— one Minister and 100 or more civil servants in his Department. He has to rely on their judgment and on their integrity and we can all pay respect to, and compliment our Civil Service for the integrity and the brains that are in it. At all times they are striving to find out what is best for the country and they propound their schemes to our Ministers. No man is such a colossal genius that he could dispense with his Civil Service Department and do everything himself. Therefore, when you replace one Minister by another that is not instability unless, perhaps, it is like England in 1945 where you had a real difference in policy in the change-over —on the question of nationalisation or non-nationalisation—and that creates instability, creates a major change in your system. But we have had no changes here comparable to that.

Again, take the fact that we have worship of the Party, and loyalty to the Party, and it is said that all small groups must be forced into the Party strait jacket. We heard Italy being mentioned. What is really the trouble with the Christian Democrats? The trouble is that they are left and right wing and the trouble is within their own Party itself. I venture to say that we have much more fundamental agreement between all our Parties— between the Labour Party and Fianna Fáil or between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, or Fianna Fáil and Labour—and that there is much more basic agreement than there is even among the members of even one of the British Parties.

First of all, we all subscribe to the Christian principles and the position of the family. We subscribe to the question of aid for Church schools. We subscribe to all those very important principles, but in the British Conservative Party there is no such fundamental philosophy to keep the members together and it is a poor substitute for fundamental philosophy to think that the Party strait jacket can do it. So that we are just merely contributing then, to the wave of cynicism that has hit the country by trying to make a mountain out of a molehill and the example is the independent Senators. As long as we supported the Government, if we voted for the Government Cathaoirleach for the Seanad, we were independent, but once we show signs of thinking for ourselves, once we are prepared to have an honest viewpoint that differs from the viewpoint of the Government, then we are to be insulted by Senator Lahiffe and others who jeered that we had become more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves.

Comment on this

Give the quotation.

Comment on this

If the Senator wants it I will give it, but I have already given it.

Comment on this

It has been quoted already.

Comment on this

I did not hear it.

Comment on this

It is only delaying the House.

Comment on this

I never used that expression.

Comment on this

Tell the Seanad that I used the expression.

Comment on this

I must apologise to Senator Lahiffe because it was Senator O'Reilly who made the statement. He said, at column 829, Volume 50:—

"I think if I suggest the Independent Senators on the opposite side have become more Fine Gael than the Fine Gael members themselves, it would be correct."

Senator Lahiffe's quotation was the one in which learned speeches and scientists were sneered at.

Comment on this

Quote.

Comment on this

The quotation is as follows, at column 749, of the same volume——

"I was speaking to some of the people in the West of Ireland since last week. They read some of those learned speeches and their attitude appears to be that the whole trouble in the world to-day is created by scientists and they say: "God help us if the scientists have anything to do with it any more."

I do not think the scientists——

Comment on this

I do not think any scientific approach to our problems could have given us a position in which 40,000 to 50,000 people are compelled to emigrate every year, that is, if you have a family of six, at present trends, four or five, at least, have to emigrate to earn their living. Surely that is not what our forefathers fought and died for.

Finally, on the question of strong government. We seem to worship strong government and I wonder is it a reaction to our past because, after all, we had the strongest Government in the world here for 700 years. Do we want to return to that position? I think that if we are lauding everything British and want to get back to the strong arm and strong methods of the British is it not really proof that, after all, we have lost confidence?

Comment on this

The scientific approach, about which we have heard so much, has a rather Marxist tone about it. I do not propose to go into any particular analysis of that. I prefer to get down to a more reasonable analysis of this very straightforward measure. The speakers opposite should have a real knowledge of the issues at stake and should rid themselves of the sort of hysterical and humorous outburst we have just listened to.

Comment on this

On a point of correction. There was nothing humorous about it.

Comment on this

There is a very net issue here and there is nothing wrong or unfair about putting a fair and simple question to the people. Senator Quinlan talked about some referendum in the British Cameroons dealing with various trusteeship arrangements with their neighbours and which has no relevance to a simple question of "Yes" or "No" on the straight vote system. We are asking the people to reject the system that is now in operation and, instead, to improve the position of the country by having this well-tried system in order to give more effective government. That is all the proposal means and I do not think there is anything dishonest or unfair about it.

The only issue the people have to decide, and there is no point in clouding it, is whether the system proposed to them would give more effective government. The Government have been active in the economic sphere. They have issued a White Paper on the matter which deals with expansion over the next few years. In addition, in the constitutional sphere, the Government have decided that an improvement could be effected by the introduction of the straight voting system, that it would give more effective government than the present system. That is the only question on which the people are being asked to say "Yes" or "No". I fail to see how it could be put more simply. Unfortunately, a lot of irrelevancies were introduced and I feel it incumbent on myself, as a Government spokesman, to refute some of them.

I mentioned figures on the Second Stage and it is rather difficult to have to repeat them again. They are figures which operated in the Six Counties area when they had P.R. there in the 1920s and figures in the election after 1929 when they reverted to the straight vote system and the single-member constituency. In 1921 and 1925, in the Six County area, under P.R. the National Republican and Sinn Féin groups got 12 seats. In the two elections under the straight vote in 1929 and 1923 they lost one seat—they dropped from 12 to 11 seats. Right through that period, in the two elections under P.R., followed by two elections under the straight vote system, the Unionist Party representation in the Stormont Parliament did not change one whit. That is unanswerable. In 1921, the Unionist representation in the Stormont Parliament was 34. In 1933, under the majority system, it was still 34.

Comment on this

It is 39 to-day; it is growing.

Comment on this

Surely the apposite scientific figures to that are the figures of the elections immediately before and after the change in the electoral system? Senator Quinlan knows that the situation in the Six Counties is one that has been dealt with by a monolithic Party following sectarian ideals. With that end in view the constituencies are gerrymandered. If Senator Quinlan wants to become more partisan than he has been, he may charge that we are going to gerrymander the constituencies. But he has not gone that far.

It is impossible to gerrymander constituencies in the Twenty-Six Counties where, as Senator Quinlan says, we are a homogeneous people, believing in the same Christian principles. Gerrymandering has succeeded principally in areas like South Africa and the Six Counties, where sectarian groups can juggle about in non-sectarian areas. As an example of the sort of scientific reckoning we have been given in this debate, we had a quotation from the election figures in 1957 in Cork City—Senator Quinlan's area. He stated that, on those figures and assuming Fianna Fáil held their support, they would get all five seats under the single seat system. That is what the lawyers call special pleading. It is not very academic and no great tribute to scholarship. You can lift out a particular figure in a particular constituency to make a case on that basis.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I referred to the other constituencies, but time prevented me from going through them.

Comment on this

Looking at the figures for the election of 1957, it is probably true that we might do well in Cork City but, on those figures, we would probably do very badly in West Cork. In 1957, the total Fianna Fáil vote in West Cork was 9,380 and the total anti Fianna Fáil vote was 16,939.

Comment on this

It is split in two.

Comment on this

It was twice the Fianna Fáil vote in West Cork. We would be lucky to get a seat there under the single seat system. In North Kerry our total vote in 1957 was 13,207 and the total anti-Fianna Fáil vote was 21,260. We would have a struggle in North Kerry. As a particular example of Professor Quinlan's special pleading, he went into County Limerick and quoted West Limerick where, undoubtedly, we would do well. In 1957, we got 17,000 votes and the anti-Fianna Fáil vote was 8,000. We would do well there, but surely all honesty and good scholarship should have made Professor Quinlan move to East Limerick were we got 16,000 votes and the anti Fianna Fáil vote was 20,000.

The point is quite apparent. Just as in Britain, support varies throughout the country. In two-Party development, strong Fianna Fáil areas and strong Fine Gael areas would emerge. That happens in Britain, Canada and the United States, and there is no reason for it not to happen here. Going back to the election of 1954, and taking the figures for the constituencies of Cork West, Cork East, Cork North and Cork South, we find Fianna Fáil would be doing well to get an odd seat here and there. In Cork West, in 1954, our vote was 9,500 against 19,000; in Cork East it was 12,500 against 17,000; in Cork North it was 11,500 against 17,500; in Cork South, it was 10,500 against nearly 20,000.

Comment on this

The Senator is ignoring the transferable vote.

Comment on this

I am quoting the figures.

Comment on this

That is not scientific.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator should be permitted to continue.

Comment on this

On a point of Order. I should like to draw the attention of the Chair to the fact that it seems to be the practice for Members to repeat themselves.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Leave that to the Chair.

Comment on this

I do not think the people who oppose this measure can ride two hobby horses at the same time. It has become the practice to throw in the great, big, evil spectre of Communism. It is a great gambit. Deputy General MacEoin was the first man to use it some weeks ago. It is blatant political chancing.

Comment on this

What about MacEntee of a few years ago?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is it in order for Senator L'Estrange to refer to the Minister for Health as "MacEntee"?

Comment on this

The Minister for Health.

Comment on this

On the one hand, we are told that this measure is to ensure the perpetuation of Fianna Fáil as a totalitarian Government and on the other hand, we are told it will pave the way for an alternative Government to form a Marxist Government. You cannot argue that this measure is designed to perpetuate us, and say, at the same time, it will mean Communists sweeping all at the next election. It is a blatant partisan argument. Surely the answer to any of these wrong ideas, that we do not want to develop this country, is the organisation of sound national Parties? A lot of play has been made by Senator Quinlan about young men. I happen to be a fairly young fellow. I faced the people in two elections as a member of a political Party with older members of my Party fighting the campaign with me. I see nothing wrong with the joining of the older and younger people in the major political Parties. Surely it is in that direction we can progress in the future.

Comment on this

You will not be able to in the single seat constituency.

Comment on this

I can assure the Senator I have the utmost confidence in my ability to deal with that situation.

Comment on this

You cannot go forward with other members of your Party any more.

Comment on this

I have the greatest confidence in my ability to deal with that. The national Parties in this country have a very good record. We have had this notion by vocationally-minded people of something being wrong with our political Parties and political leaders. We have made considerable progress since 1921. I am not ashamed of what the older generation did during that period. This proposal is designed to provide the people with a system of election whereby progress can be made more effectively in the future. Surely the strongest bulwark against cynicism or any wrong political philosophy is the organisation of national Parties on a sound political basis. We have attempted to do that in the Fianna Fáil Party. At Fianna Fáil conventions, where candidates have been selected, I have seen as fine a body of men as are in the community. I have seen 200 or 300 people electing their candidates in a democratic fashion. The Fine Gael Party do the same thing. I do not see where the Party caucus is at headquarters.

Comment on this

They were not all ratified.

Comment on this

The ratification clause is one heading. This measure represents a challenge to the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party to come in with us and provide an alternative Government within a sound parliamentary framework. Instead of —to use an American expression— bellyaching about other "isms" coming in, why cannot they take the time to organise their Parties nationally and be in a position to be an alternative Government if the people so decide? If our national Party get in young people and organise themselves they can reject or repel any challenge from any wrong philosophy.

It might be no harm to mention that the present system has not benefited at all the larger minority Party. They have one seat out of 30 in the City of Dublin—an industrial city with approximately 500,000 of a population. In Belfast they have six seats—four Labour, one National Labour and one Republican Labour. In this city at the moment, under the present system, there is only one city Labour Deputy. That is sufficient indictment of or comment on the present system.

If you have a minority Party and if that Party enlarges its appeal, if it makes a broad national appeal outside the section it represents and makes a countrywide drive, that minority Party, under the straight vote system, can get into Government. The classical example of that is the example of the Labour Party in England mentioned by Senator Ó Maoláin.

If there is one thing upon which there is unanimity at the moment it is that the single seat idea is good. There is unanimity in regard to the single seat idea being a good one. I am convinced that the straight vote system will lead to a much better candidate going forward for election than you had heretofore. I am convinced that political Parties will be induced by reason of this compact area to select much better candidates than have been selected.

It was mentioned that this proposal will do away with personalities and that it will make the election a mere cipher arrangement and that if the Party bosses—that was the denigrating term used—selected a man that man would get in. I do not think the facts prove that. Personalities will certainly count in this smaller and more compact area. There is an analogy in a recent election in the United States which proves the point. Only a few months ago there was a landslide in the election in the States. Practically every seat for the House of Representatives and the Senate went to the Republican Party. In New York State, in particular, despite the fact that New York is traditionally Democratic, they beat the outgoing Democrat, Mr. Harriman, and elected Mr. Rockefeller, a Republican. Mr. Rockefeller had a personality and an ability which appealed to the people in New York State. That is a clear example of a personality being successful. It is an example of ability of a certain kind appealing to the people and breaking through the Party barriers.

I can see that happening in this county in many constituencies where you have smaller areas. I can see that happening on the strength of a person's ability alone. I genuinely think that. You have the parallel case in New York.

The inherent idea in this proposal is that of an alternative Government. It is as net and as simple as that. We think that this change will permit the people more effectively to provide themselves with a Government. In opposition you will have an alternative Government to which the public can swing in the event of the people rejecting the Government in office. We think that can be done better under this system.

On Second Reading, I dealt with the failures of the system in the past. It does not require much imagination to look ahead. Assuming that in 1961, under the present system, the people decide to reject the Fianna Fáil Party, to whom can they hand over the reins of Government, since the Labour Party said they will never again coalesce with the Fine Gael Party? That was a public utterance made since the formation of the Government. If the people decide to reject Fianna Fáil at the next general election, who is to govern the country?

Surely it would be much better if, in the next general election, the people decide to reject Fianna Fáil that as well as doing that negative function, they can do something positive, by electing another Government from a major Party, which will produce a policy that will enable the people to swing to them. That is the challenge inherent in this idea. Where, for instance, is the shadow Cabinet at the moment? If the Labour Party will not coalesce with the Fine Gael Party, where is the alternative Government in the Dáil to-day? Where do we see it being built up?

As a university graduate, I was genuinely disappointed at the contributions made here by the university representatives. I mean that in all sincerity.

Comment on this

Because they did not favour Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

I take the view that all six of them were entitled to vote as they did. I see nothing whatever wrong with that, but I would have expected university representatives to come to the Seanad and put the pros and cons, in respect of this prosposal. Any thinking academic man could, in coming in here, inform the House by postulating arguments in favour of the proposal and then postulating arguments in favour of the retention of the present system and could have given us a balanced statement and could have come to the conclusion that on balance the retention of the present system would be better than a change. I see nothing wrong with that, but not one of them made an attempt to give us a balanced analysis.

Comment on this

In your opinion.

Comment on this

Analysis of the speeches would lead one to that conclusion. I did not hear one word of approbation for the Government proposal coming from Senator Professor Quinlan, Senator Professor O'Brien, or Senator Professor Stanford. Senator Sheehy Skeffington, of course, always has his own line. There was nothing at all of independent balanced argument from the professors. The only balanced argument of an academic kind relates to this question of representation, and you would expect university professors to give us a balanced argument about it and possibly come down on one side if they wished; but there is a definite philosophical issue and they made no attempt to analyse it.

We feel that the emphasis should be on government, that what is needed in this country above all else is effective government. A lot of people in Ireland think that way too. Senator Professor Quinlan says that we are all more or less of the same way of thinking and all follow the Christian way of life. I suppose that is true in the Twenty-Six County area of our island, that 95 per cent. of our people are integrated in that we have, broadly speaking, a system where there are few excesses of power, wealth or status. If that is the case, why dissipate our energy in creating minority Parties?

Comment on this

Why prevent it?

Comment on this

Surely if we have an integrated community we can reflect all shades of view in two or three Parties. I personally have no doubt that the three major Parties—Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour—can easily fit within their Party organisations every shade of political opinion in the country. I see no reason why political thought and opinion should not work through those Party organisations and push themselves to the forefront if they wish. I cannot see why those so-called minority interests cannot fit themselves into those Party structures.

Comment on this

Are you not legislating for the future?

Comment on this

Is there anything wrong with that? That is what every Government worth its salt does. It legislates for the future. It does not sit back and wait for any opportunistic breath of wind this way or that way. The Government is looking ahead to the future and thinks that there is no reason in the world why we should have a system which artificially creates minority Parties. The effect of those minority Parties, Clann na Talún and Clann na Poblachta, is, undoubtedly, that, far from representing shades of opinion in society, they merely become pressure groups whose leaders use their key position to put the gun to the heads of responsible Parties and say that they want Ministry A or B or C. It comes down to that, to power politics and groups holding the gun to the heads of Party leaders.

I do not see why we should have that situation or why our energies should be dissipated in organising minority Parties of that description. I feel that 99 per cent. of the shades of opinion can be fitted into Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael or the Labour Party and surely Fine Gael and Labour can face up to the challenge in this measure, which is saying to them: "Come in with Fianna Fáil and we can have a balanced society in this country and always provide a Government. You can be the alternative Government if you organise nationally and put your policy to the people and persuade them to reject Fianna Fáil." I hope that there will always be room for independent men in Irish political life.

Comment on this
John O'Donovan Professor O'Donovan Fine Gael

I did not think that the Senator was giving them much of a show in his analysis.

Comment on this

Anyway, the thing is to get down to this analysis of the alternative Government idea. That is the challenge of this proposal and we ask the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party to face up to that. If they get down to hard work we can be rejected and put out of existence but it must be admitted that that will not happen, because the Fianna Fáil Party got where it is by getting down to work.

If we can avoid recrimination and the hysterical speech making of which we have had too much, particularly from Senator Professor Quinlan, we will get down to practical work. Men of vocational impulses like Senator Professor Quinlan would be better if they got into one of those Parties and worked through them in every debate instead of sitting on the fence here and making sneering remarks about youth having lost faith in politics. If they tend to lose faith the challenge is to youth also to get into political Parties. We have far too much of this denigrating of political parties, sneering at political bosses and the political machine. Political Parties make democracy possible and make it work. We are proud in Fianna Fáil to say that we have a political organisation that is grounded democratically in every parish in the country. We ask Senators on the other side to organise themselves efficiently on that basis and to come in to be an alternative Government.

Comment on this

Initially I want to protest against the behaviour of Senator Mullins. When I entered this House to-day he was speaking, and he referred to "ignorant interruptions". Perhaps he was in order. While the Leas-Chathaoirleach could not hear him, I heard him refer to Senators opposite as "ignorant". I refuse to come here to be called ignorant in that fashion by the Leader of the House.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

O.K., stay at home.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Senator Mullins, and I did not behave in a fashion that gave him the right to call me ignorant. I want to protest against that.

I am quite fed up of listening to all these arguments about countries overseas and particularly the constant litany of results of the English Parliament produced by Senator Mullins. Everybody in the House will accept the fact that the present Taoiseach is well able to assess the impact of this new system if it is imposed on Irish political life. The Front Bench on the opposite side as well as on this side would be highly experienced and quite able, without referring to any country in the world, to assess what would happen and where votes would go. Perhaps even people like me who are only in political life since 1954 would be quite able to assess what would be the results of this measure in their own particular constituencies at least. I feel that I am perfectly able, without referring to England or to the Cameroons as Senator Quinlan referred to, or any of those places, to assess the results that would come if this system should come to be approved by the people in the referendum, though I believe it will not come.

The first thing I generalised about on the Second Stage of this Bill was the point on which I will now particularise, that is, the question of one member representing an area. I am a local politician as well as in the Seanad, and I know full well the way that these things work. I know how certain people will ring up, say, the Drogheda Corporation office in the evening when the manager has left and ask what were the orders made by the manager that day. Having got the information that Mrs. A got a house, the politician writes: "I am glad to inform you that I have been told to-day by the county manager that you have got a house." The professional politician with time on his hands and the opportunity to do that can become well nigh invincible although his legislative ability may be nil and although he may be a complete menace.

Let me give the House another instance. Supposing the local politician is friendly with the local labour organiser and that there are men doing some work for a contractor, say, digging a drain. If the politician succeeds in getting all of those men into the union he is hailed as the saviour of all, as the man who got everybody into the union. Does that man not gain votes? Of course he does. Has he any legislative ability? Very probably he has not, because a man who will try to gain votes in that fashion is not likely to be the type of man who would have such ability. If he were, he would seek votes in the proper manner by advocating the policy of his Party in so far as he believed in it and not put to the people proposals of his Party in which he did not believe.

There is a myriad of ways in which a man could get votes if he had nothing else to do. I have plenty to do, but in any event I would not stoop to seek votes in the manner in which it can be done. All over Ireland there are people who, for a Dáil or a Seanad allowance, and for the kudos to be gained, would do that. I submit that the single member constituency of 20,000 people gives them the opportunity to do it.

I should like to draw attention to a statement made by Senator Mullins. He says Parties can co-operate in the single member constituency to secure the defeat of somebody they do not like. In a peculiar way the Fianna Fáil Party—although they cannot co-operate; it is not a thing they know very well—can act in such a way as to ensure the defeat of somebody they do not like. In saying that I want to make it clear that I do not think that politicians on every side or any side are plaster saints. It is like horse-racing, dog-racing or any other activity like that. The little kick in the ankle or the dig in the ribs is used just as often as the straight attempt in order to gain one's end. All Parties use these methods, but it is open more to the large Party who have a vote which is largely regimented, which consists of certain families who have supported them right down from 1922. Some of them are foremen in factories who, perhaps, have got their jobs in the period from 1932 when in the natural way, not because of Fianna Fáil legislation, factories were built in Ireland. They support the Fianna Fáil Party because of their jobs. Apart from that type of vote, there is the independent and more flexible vote, the one that is better for the Irish nation. I would not be here if that were not the case. However, when there is an inflexible 4,000 Fianna Fáil vote in an electorate of 9,000, which is the average of a constituency of 20,000 people, is it not up to the Fianna Fáil Party, if they assess the situation as one in which they have only 4,000 votes and there is a possibility that an independent vote will reach 5,000, to throw £100 to a man of straw who might normally only get 2,000 votes? In this way the man who should be elected, if the election were honestly run, is defeated by the man of straw.

There is a story in County Louth about a certain man—let us call him Donegan so that nobody can say I am naming anybody—who some years ago held the key vote on a certain issue at a county council meeting. Another man went on Sunday morning to try to persuade him not to turn up at the council meeting. The key-man went into the public house and had a drink and he was still drinking that night. He went home and the following morning he returned and had another couple of drinks. This man who should have gone to the meeting that day was to be seen riding around on a green Raleigh bicycle, and it is still referred to as the "Donegan bicycle". Politics is not a game for plaster saints. If a Party do not want to see a certain man getting in they can give £100 to a man of straw and see to it that that man is elected although the other man should get the majority and win.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Could that man on the green bicycle have won it in a bet for having been able to take so much whiskey?

Comment on this

He could, indeed, but he did not.

Again on this question of messenger boys, I act as messenger boy, too. I have to write 70 letters a week on political matters and I know my opposite number does the same thing. However, when the constituency is brought down from an area of 67,000 votes to an area of 9,000 votes, is it not true that the best messenger boy is the man who will rush up to a Department at Government expense and ask: "What about Jimmy Donegan's reconstruction grant?", and who, when he is told: "We are going to give that," will write to Jimmy Donegan saying: "You are going to get your reconstruction grant"? That, of course, means extra votes for that politician.

Is that not the kind of thing we want to stop? Is there any legislative ability needed for that? I do not want to go too far on this point, but I do suggest, with respect, intending no personal insult, that that sort of thing is responsible for the mediocrity of the Front Bench of the Fianna Fáil Party in the Seanad, with one exception.

Tugadh tuairisc ar a ndearnadh; an Coiste do shuí arís.

Comment on this