We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Business. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Coiste (Atogáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–185 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

Last night I was trying to describe in a homely way what would happen in Ireland if this measure were passed. I expressed the view that what happened in England and various other places has no great relation to what would happen here. Such practised politicians as the Taoiseach and others who have had experience over the same period are capable of assessing what the results will be here. But the people on the Taoiseach's side have chosen, as Senator Mullins did last night, to concentrate, not on what they know will happen here, but on what happened elsewhere in different conditions and, indeed, in most cases, in a completely different set-up.

I contend that the issue here has been confused by the creation 12 or 15 years ago of a great number of three seat constituencies. When that happened, the really fair results which P.R. should give did not materialise. I want to pose the question that if a man secures over 100,000 votes—a normal number for a five seat constituency under P.R.—which may be triple the number of votes necessary to elect him, is he not entitled to the seat? But, in fact, if you restrict the voting to a small constituency in which there is, perhaps, a valid poll of 9,000 in one election, that man may be defeated by the hack type of politician who attends all the funerals and does all the messenger boy operations. For instance, if a man of the calibre of Major-General Costello chose to enter politics on any political side or as an Independent, would anybody take the view that he should not be elected? Or, if a man with the experience of Senator McGuire, who is managing director of a fine firm in Dublin, chose to stand for the Dáil, would anyone say that such a man, with his experience, education and ability, should not be a member of the Dáil and could not on any side of the House do good work for the Irish nation and his constituents? Both those men should command a seat in Dáil Éireann if they wished it or had the time to devote to it.

Would it not be true to say that in many constituencies with a valid poll of 9,000—which will be the sort of thing one can expect in a constituency representing 20,000—the local political boss would beat either of those two men hollow? If the election were held in a constituency of over 100,000 persons, in other words, a five seat constituency, is it not a fact that without a shadow of doubt either of these two men would be elected to Dáil Éireann and would serve the country well? Why, then, do we exclude the people who should represent us and who have proved by their actions, life and ability that they are worthy to represent the people? Why do we confine the selection always to the local politician?

It is wise to give practical examples. The first thing is to take somebody who is a good legislator, well worthy of his seat in Dáil Éireann and who cannot, therefore, consider himself insulted when one discusses his normal practice and way of life. All the Deputies from North County Dublin are known to me, with the exception of the Minister for Defence whom I met only once. I think Deputy Rooney and Deputy P.J. Burke are excellent legislators and good members of Dáil Éireann. I would not grudge either of them a place in Dáil Éireann even if the number of seats there was restricted to 50 or 60. However, if this Bill goes through, North County Dublin will be divided into four or five constituencies. A man of the very excellent habits and way of life of Deputy P.J. Burke could not be defeated in a particular area in that constituency. Any man who attends every funeral in the constituency, any man who is reported in the Evening Mail as getting a bus shelter for the residents of Ballyfermot, for example, any man who is constantly in the news doing these small jobs, will be elected.

I chose Deputy Burke because I think he is a good legislator. My point is that a man who does all that work and all these things might not be a good legislator. He might be a rotten legislator. He might be prepared to do all these messenger boy jobs and attend all these funerals and be present at all public occasions, know everybody, meet everybody and see everybody just to be in Dáil Éireann and to draw his Dáil allowance. The reason why I took Deputy P.J. Burke as an example is that he is a good legislator.

Comment on this

On a point of order. It is very insulting for any member of the Seanad to call any member of the other House a messenger boy. I object to Senator Donegan saying that Deputy P.J. Burke went around as a messenger boy.

Comment on this

Did I say that? Certainly, I did not mean it in that sense. I did not intend that. I had in mind his way of life. I went out of my way not to offend him. I wanted to point out how such a man can be elected to Dáil Éireann when, in fact, he might not be a good legislator.

There is the question of the needle vote. If there is a valid poll of 9,000 votes, in many constituencies a Party would know they would get 4,000 or 5,000 of those votes. If the Party were sure of getting 5,000, assessing politics as most of us have to do, they would be elected. Where they get 4,000 votes there is, as one would expect, a certain disappointment that just because they could not swing another 501 votes, the representative of that Party was not elected. Does not that make for skullduggery and all sorts of local efforts to gain that odd 500 votes?

It is very relevant to give examples of public boards where one vote will swing the day and when, three or four days before an important vote, it is known to all that a certain number of people would vote one way and a certain number of people would vote another way—because they had declared their intention of so doing— and that one member was holding the casting vote. I have seen the greatest efforts made in such a situation, at times dishonest efforts, to sway that man to vote a particular way. I have seen the other thing happen. I have seen that member try to exert pressure on Parties on each side of the public board in order to get something for his vote. I do not refer to money or anything like that.

For instance, suppose in a particular case a village had the balance of power. If the number of votes in a village was sufficient to have a member elected or to have two members elected and if the village in question had not a water supply or a sewerage scheme, does not one think that a local development association or a local development committee in that village would exert the greatest pressure and say, in effect: "We will vote for the Party that will give us the amenity we require for our village?"

There might be a village some miles away which was just as entitled to similar amenities as the first village but, because of the pressure that could be exerted by the first village, the Parties would vie with one another in their promises to give that first village or that particular set of persons whatever they require.

Every Senator, without exception, is a member of a public board. They all know what happens when the needle vote comes up. It is either bought or sold—not with money but with allegiance, with things people want in the days to come. I have seen it happen. Thank God, I was never a party to it because it is most unfair that such a situation should obtain in a small constituency.

Here is another example. I will not mention the public board. A position was going for one year. The central figure in this affair would have cut off his right hand before giving anything to anybody for a vote. He is a man of the highest integrity and honesty. He is not of my Party. I will not mention his name. In this particular instance my office was rung up on the day before this vote was to take place. A gentleman said: "If two other gentlemen"—not I—"will change their votes on this measure you can elect anybody you like to-morrow to this position." I said that these gentlemen would not dream of changing their votes simply to gain a position for an individual. The following day the vote took place. The gentleman who rang me up voted in the way he was not expected to vote. A month later two gentlemen changed their votes on a particular thing which cost, in a certain rateable area, £350 in the rates for the next 30 years—£9,000. Can one imagine in a small constituency the pressure that would be exerted on a Party, on a candidate to do certain things and, if he did certain things, he would be voted for? I submit that the analogy is perfect. I have seen that happen. It will happen in the small 9,000 valid poll constituencies. It is unfair to place candidates in an invidious position like that. I want to emphasise that the central figure in the matter I have referred to was a man of the greatest integrity and honesty and had nothing to do with it but, nevertheless, it was done. It was not his fault if he found himself in the position for 12 months.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would now come away from local government and come to the matter of the Bill.

Comment on this

Great play has been made about England. I do not want to labour the matter. In passing, however, I should like to say that the single seat constituency there is entirely different from what is envisaged here. A person needs 30,000 votes to be elected there where here it would be possible to be elected with 5,000 votes. The opportunity for the candidate to make personal contact is obvious here but it would be completely impossible in England.

Last night I dealt with the opportunity of a political Party to see to it that an opponent would not be elected by the simple expedient of putting up a "man of straw". Senator Mullins said that people could co-operate to ensure defeat of somebody they did not like. In fact, what Deputy Mullins imagines could hurt his Party could not be done although it would be possible to see to it that a person was not elected by the simple expedient of putting up the right type of "man of straw" who would split the vote, if it was not a regimented vote such as that of Fianna Fáil, but what I would refer to as a fluid vote.

The provision in the section whereby the constituencies are measured out is specific. It says:—

"Having due regard to geographical features and established administrative and territorial divisions and, subject to those considerations, in such manner that the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census, shall, so far as is practicable, be the same throughout the country."

Comment on this

The Senator is now anticipating another section.

Comment on this

I am sorry. What I am doing is pointing out the town versus the country aspects and it is necessary to give the quotation but I will not labour it. In that context I submit the single member constituency must react so that even a town of 5,000 must exert a very great effect on the result of any election and if we are to depart from the ordinary political arguments and insist on the town versus country aspects we will have done a very bad day's work.

Great play has also been made on the fact that there was no opportunity to gerrymander but I submit that there is every opportunity in the single seat constituency to gerrymander and I do not imply that such an idea exists in the mind of anybody. When the suggestion is made by certain members on the opposite side of the House that there is no opportunity to gerrymander, it is only fair to say that there is every opportunity. The simple way would be to take the three seat constituency of Louth and to see how, if you were low enough to do so, you could gerrymander such a constituency. One could review the experience in that county and see that it is true that Cooley has a preponderance of Fianna Fáil votes, that Clogherhead has more Fianna Fáil votes than Fine Gael, that Togher has more Fine Gael votes than Fianna Fáil, that Reaghstown gave more votes to Fianna Fáil than usual at the last election.

These are the things that ordinary everyday politicians know. It is their business to know them and, if that is the position, is not the opportunity there to gerrymander? I do not say that anybody has the idea of doing so and I would never have raised the point but for the fact that it was raised on the opposite side by various Senators. If a person was in command of the division of a constituency there is not the slightest doubt that he could gerrymander to his heart's content.

Finally, I would say that the section dealing with the single seat constituency is catastrophic. The constituency is too small. It will make for the sort of election which there was in days gone by when the constituency was bigger. Why do we raise the "ante" in this poker game? Would it not be far better that a man would have to be elected in a wider section of the populace and that a man should be elected on his legislative ability rather than on the basis of his personal contacts? Would it not be far better, if it were possible, to get the type of person who could legislate rather than the type of person who knows everybody in a certain area?

Comment on this

Senator Donegan is like the character in Oscar Wilde's play who said: "I can only understand what I am saying when I listen to myself attentively." That quotation would aptly describe Senator Donegan's speech, which was liberally interspersed with the usual priggish notions which we hear expressed by people who are either afraid or ashamed to enter politics. Senator Donegan being already an established politician in his own right, one is surprised to hear such sentiments from him. He stands in the market place like the pharisee, striking his breast at intervals and saying. "Thanks be to God I am not like the other politicians". Senator Donegan asked us when was a vote so valuable. I could tell Senator Donegan when a vote was valuable to them—when they brought in a man on a stretcher into this House to decide a vote. Was that man's vote not valuable? We are all of us, I hope, politicians and we should not be ashamed of that fact.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The man to whom the Senator has referred was myself. I came voluntarily but, on the Senator's side, they had men in wheelchairs.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order. It is not a point of information. The Senator was carried into the Dáil to give his vote in favour of the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

It was not his fault that he was sick.

Comment on this

I am replying to Senator Donegan when he stands in the market place striking his breast——

Comment on this

It was in the Temple.

Comment on this

——saying "I am not like other politicians." The one thing which I detest in politics is priggishness. A similar attitude was adopted by Senator Quinlan. He came in representing vocationalism and, indeed, if his attitude in this House is a measure of the type of candidate we will get from the vocational organisations, then give me the old-fashioned politicians every time because when one sets out to be a politician one must stand over his utterances. You cannot stand back from the common herd and look down upon them and say, "I am not like the rest of them. I am something different. I am a new Messiah and I am going to preach a new clean gospel which I hope will be the means of converting those poor politicians."

Senator Quinlan set out last night to deprecate the politicians who took part in the affairs of the country for the past 37 years.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I said no such thing.

Comment on this

The Senator will sit and listen to my speech just the same as I sat last night and listened to his. The Senator, when he enters politics, will take what is coming to him.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly, but not false statements.

Comment on this

I am not making a false statement. The Senator, in effect, said that he held out no hope for the future if politics as practised in the past continue to be practised in future. He also said that the incidence of emigration and unemployment was due to the incompetence of the politics and the politicians of the past. I want to challenge him on that argument.

Does the Senator think for one moment that we have not progressed in the past 37 years? Will the Senator not agree that the more prosperous we become the more difficult will be our problems in relation to the two matters I mentioned? Does not the Senator agree, for instance, that the more prosperous we become in the farming sector the more difficult will be our problems with regard to employment for agricultural workers? Can he not see that migration and emigration are twin problems which beset Europe and the countries outside Europe at the present time?

Will the Senator not realise that we are a young country starting from a new low with no experience of self-government? Further, will the Senator not agree that the men on both sides of this House who took part even in the civil war and who subsequently formed the Governments and Oppositions up to the present time are entitled to a certain amount of gratitude and, I would say, even charity from the younger politicians and especially from the politicians of our age? It is not fair to get up in this House and say that they have made a mess of it to such an extent that they were, if you like, the direct cause of the twin evils which I mentioned.

Senator Quinlan posed three questions to the Taoiseach. Unfortunately, I have not the logic of the Taoiseach. If I had, I would be jostling him for leadership of the Fianna Fáil Party but, in my own way, I will attempt to answer Senator Quinlan's queries. I think the query he put was this: Was it the fact that the Coalition Government was so constituted that militated against the Government taking a firm and decisive action at any stage? He posed that query and I am open to correction if I am misquoting him.

Comment on this

I am quoting the Senator from memory and, if I misquote him, I say I am open for correction. I can give instances to the Senator where the fact that the former Government was so constituted prevented firm decisions being taken. One of the instances was with regard to the Social Welfare Bill of 1950. We were promised a comprehensive social Bill. Did we get it or did we not? I leave it to the Senator to decide that question.

Minorities are much lauded now on the opposite side. I also remember a certain minority forcing the Government of the day to beat a hasty retreat over a certain decision which was taken with regard to a post office. It beat a retreat with its tail between its legs. Can the Senator refute that?

Here is a third instance, for good measure: Does the Senator remember in 1957, when the Government claimed they were going to deal with the incidents on the Border, that Deputy MacBride came home from America and withdrew his support from the Government owing to that decision? Did those events not militate against good government? If the Senator is so impersonal in his outlook, perhaps he would give his opinion on that later on?

We assert again that the system of election, whether it is the straight vote or P.R., does not matter to a political Party and that all the finicky arguments so assiduously advanced by Senator O'Quigley, Senator Quinlan and the rest of them fall down when you come to the ugly fact. An ugly fact, as has been said, can almost always slay the most beautiful hypothesis and the ugly fact is that if you look at any record of the elections down through the years you will see that any Party who proposed a programme and put it before the people and who stood by that programme and worked to it during their term of office, let it be long or short, always won out in the end. Fianna Fáil did better than any other Party I know of under P.R.

Comment on this

The graveyard vote. The dead vote.

Comment on this

I challenge that statement. I would ask the Senator to withdraw it because he knows the statement is not correct. After all, the Senator's statement will be on the record of the House. I should like, if he makes a statement like that, that he would support it with facts. I know the Senator cannot do that.

Comment on this

It is well known.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The empty canister can only rattle. Do not mind him.

Comment on this

Exactly. When seeking election, we were always concerned, first of all, with our policy and how it was presented to the people. It seems to me that the Fine Gael Party can be described as the Party of no hope. They and their fellow travellers have all got on the band wagon of no hope or no return. They seem to think that if the system of P.R. is changed in favour of the straight vote they have no future. In thinking that, they tie up with this issue all those outside issues which are not at all applicable to us in our present circumstance.

I am not at all clear, listening to the members of the Opposition, that the Fine Gael Party are of one mind in this matter. There is a division running through the Party, from top to bottom, regarding the question we are discussing to-day. There is a number of people, solid supporters, in the Fine Gael Party and in the country who believe that the straight vote system would give us relative stability.

Do the Senators opposite argue that a series of ramshackle Governments, lasting, on the average, for two years and seven months, is calculated to give the country stability? Senator Quinlan seems to think that politics is a huge joke. He seems to be of the opinion that it is advisable that Ministers should be away from their offices now and again to engage in electioneering in the country, and described it as the equivalent of a holiday. I have some experience of politics and I can assure the Senator that politicians do not regard electioneering as a holiday and I can further assure the Senator that, when he takes it so flippantly, he has no idea of our political system, even though when he arrived back from the Cameroons he started to lecture us on what we should do in the political Parties here.

Any record of the elections down the years will show that most of the small Parties disappeared under P.R. It has been argued that this change would mean the disappearance of the smaller Parties. No one can deny the fact, for instance, that in 1923 the Farmers started off with 15 seats and to-day they have three seats in the Dáil. Clann na Poblachta started out with ten seats in 1948 and to-day they have only one. What happened in that case? Was it the system of election we had then which was responsible for eliminating them or was it their policy or lack of policy? Did P.R. not rid the country of small Parties?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is the whole argument.

Comment on this

It is argued by the Opposition that the straight vote will rid the country of minorities. It has been argued from every platform on which they have stood since this question was mooted that we were making this change to fasten Fianna Fáil on the country for the future. It has been argued that Fine Gael would disappear as a political Party. I want the people who are putting forward these arguments to support them with facts. We have had various examples given by politicians who seem to know all the answers and all the shady tactics but who say that they themselves would not become entangled in these tactics. I wonder how they know so much about them if they are not entangled in them already.

When we come to discuss an important matter like this we should bring sober judgment to it. We have been dragged into the byways; we have been brought to the parish pump, to the Cameroons in Africa, around America and the world and back home, after the fashion of a modern sputnik.

Quite a number of voluntary organisations have chimed in on this chant that Fine Gael will disappear. We heard speeches here yesterday evening which were reminiscent of a funeral oration. I could almost feel myself standing at the graveside presiding at the obsequies of the Fine Gael Party, hearing some of the Senators patting down the last sods on the grave and the hollow sound made by the stones before the dispersal. What grounds has Senator Quinlan or any other Senator for these sentiments? I think it is merely sentiment.

The people have the final say in this matter and we have no right in a discussion on this Bill to cloud the issue or to introduce extraneous matters unconnected with the Bill. For want of a better argument, the Opposition have tried to put it across on every conceivable occasion that certain Parties will disappear if this change is brought about. There is no substance in those arguments; they will not hold water. The intentions of political Parties should not be taken into account in regard to this Bill because all political Parties have the same right as we have to put their views before the people. If they put their policy before the people and if the policy is ratified, then there is nothing to prevent their putting it into effect.

Suppose for a moment that the Opposition speakers were again successful and got another period in Government would they revert to P.R.? I pose that question to the leaders of the Fine Gael Party.

If the Fine Gael Party believe they have a future and if they believe that the future lies with our own people and not with the peoples of other lands or with any outsiders, there is nothing to prevent their fighting as hard to get a majority under the straight vote as we shall fight. If Fine Gael and Labour want to coalesce in the morning, declaring a common policy before it happened, not after the election, they have a much better chance of getting a majority under the straight vote than we have. Will the people opposite do that?

There has been a number of speeches here calculated to cause mutiny amongst minorities. These are people who would wish to make scapegoats of certain minorities and send them out into the desert to die. Many of the politicians opposite would like to do that, if one is to judge by the way they bandied about the names of the various political organisations. That is an old knack; it has been happening since the world began. Political Parties in other countries have used the smaller Party as a scapegoat. I should like to say that we have no minorities such as they have in the Cameroons, where they have minorities of class and creed.

Comment on this

You want to do away with them.

Comment on this

I showed the Senator where they were done away with under P.R. We did not do away with them but they did away with themselves. They can either do that or do otherwise under the straight vote and the Senator is intelligent enough to know that. Yet he produces that facile argument in unison with his colleagues to try to tell the voters otherwise.

Senator O'Quigley gave an example here of standards and he reduced this issue to a pint of porter. He said one has to have standards, and instanced the standard pint. But he was careful to note, when speaking of the Constitution, that he wanted some sort of vague instrument which could be used by ambitious politicians to suit their own purposes. The Bill before the House seeks to amend the Constitution. Our Constitution cannot be used by any politician for any purpose, and certainly not without the consent of the people. So, Senators should not make odious comparisons.

Senator O'Quigley instanced the case of the 1922 Constitution. I have nothing to say to the 1922 Constitution except this: When the Government found themselves in certain difficulties in 1927, they were unsure of their position under the Constitution. As far as I remember, they had to have recourse to the opinion of a constitutional lawyer. That would suggest to me that the older Constitution was much more vague than the present Constitution on the matter of elections and electoral systems.

Senator Sheehy Skeffington always seems to be in the minority. No matter what system of election you might have or what type of Constitution you might frame, it would not suit him. Certainly he would have to have something different and, in seeking something different, he would not be on common ground with the rest of us. Since I came into this House I have been trying to discover what Senator Sheehy Skeffington is really driving at. I am sure that the Senator is much better read than I am in history and philosophy but, if he studies the history of the United States, England and other countries which have had the straight vote down through the years, he will find that in the long run it has given much better results than P.R. has at any given time. P.R. is creating difficulties for the Italian Government at present and is also creating difficulties in Israel. Incidentally, the latter are trying to get rid of it. I hope in their efforts they will not have as much trouble as we have had.

All I wish to say in conclusion is that the people will have the final say in this matter. I hope in their approach to it they will not be as clouded on this issue as the speakers opposite seem to be.

Comment on this

I am surprised at the turn the speeches from the Government side have taken. Almost every Government speaker who now comes to his feet thinks it his duty in loyalty to the Party to attack the Independents and to sneer at people because they happen to be university professors. There is no argument behind anything they say other than the fact that these independent people have supported Fine Gael, Labour and other organised Parties in trying to inform the people what they may lose if P.R. is taken from them.

Fianna Fáil were elected with the largest overall majority any Party has enjoyed here in recent times. They were elected on an appeal to an economic issue. They said they would solve unemployment. They told each man's wife that they would put her husband back to work. Now, instead of solving our economic problems, they introduce a Bill to amend the Constitution and remove P.R. from it. It is an affront to the intelligence of the Irish people to treat them in that way. The only glib answer they have is: let the people decide. The ordinary man or woman—particularly the woman whose husband has only one or two days' work in the week or maybe none—has not the time to read up the various systems and go into the pros and cons of P.R. and other forms of representation. The slick catch-cry will be bandied about this House, at the crossroads and at the church gates of this country during the next three months: "Let the people decide. Fine Gael and Labour want to stop the people from having the opportunity to decide." We shall give the people the opportunity. We shall see to it that they will know, to the best of their ability, what they are doing and what is behind this matter.

I particularly resent the sort of speech made by Senator Carter. He made almost a personal attack on Senator Quinlan because he happens to be a University Professor—not because he says things that Senator Carter does not like——

Comment on this

I do not want to be misquoted. I never mentioned the fact that Senator Quinlan is a University Professor. I want Senator Burke to withdraw that, in common decency.

Comment on this

I took a note of what Deputy Carter said. He said: There are people going around saying, "We are not like the rest of men" and "we are like a new Messiah."

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

What sort of talk is that? If anybody has taken on the rôle of a Messiah in this country, and has used every organ of the Press and public opinion, as well as the elusiveness and all the other gimmicks that it takes to do it, the Taoiseach has done it more than any other person.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now where are the personalities? The Senator should deal with the Bill.

Comment on this

He says he holds all the truth—and he has not risen from the dead to prove it. We were attacked as being Messiahs because we wanted to engage in objective and factual arguments here. We will continue, no matter what form of attack is used against us, to put the facts before the people.

I spent a considerable amount of time during the past month or two in reading about these matters when I could have been better employed in the vocation I have in the country in minding my own business rather than in reading up about forms of Government. I recall to mind what Alexander Pope said about forms of Government. He said that they are the things for which fools contest. We are wasting the time of this nation when everybody knows, and when the men at the corner who have not jobs know, that our problems are economic rather than political or academic. Our time is being wasted on this. People who should be doing otherwise, who have the taste, maybe, and the experience and whatever little ability we have in doing our job, are not allowed to do it. We are taken away from it. We are the spearhead.

I have a book here by a man who has had some experience of politics but whose taste is rather literary. His name is Christopher Hollis, M.P., and the name of his book is Can Parliament Survive? He wrote this book some years ago. I bought it in September, 1949, before there was any talk about the question which we are now discussing in this House. I want to quote briefly from that book because this is a problem that confronted him. He spent a considerable amount of time in wondering about what change should be made.

Both the Taoiseach and his Party here can decide these things. They must be decided without discussion. They must be decided without having a commission sitting to consider them. They must be decided within the halls of the Party. What sort of super brains trust, what sort of Messianic mission is bestowed on that Party? They are adopting that doctrinaire approach to this matter. Let us have facts rather than attack people because they happen to have M.Sc. degrees or something like that and sneer at them because they have a——

Comment on this

That is not fair. No one——

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan has been referred to in a sneering way as a scientist. It was done here, any amount of times, and that tone has been introduced here.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He has never stopped talking about himself as a scientist.

Comment on this

The old saying is that if you have no defence you must attack.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs told him to keep to his trade.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What is wrong with his trade? Is Senator Dr. O'Donovan ashamed of the word "trade" or "tradesman"?

Comment on this

I do not like the word used in that fashion.

Comment on this

Senators must address the Chair.

Comment on this

There has been a great deal of sneering about the Cameroons. With the permission of the Chair, I will quote briefly what Christopher Hollis said in his book. In the second paragraph of Chapter II, he says:—

"We live in Britain under a Parliamentary Government, worked on a predominantly two-party system. Since it exists, some Englishmen think of the two-party system as a self-evident truth—think that it somehow stands to reason that on every matter there should be two opinions and neither one nor three and that those who think alike on A, B and C must also, if they are honest men, think alike on D, E and F. This is obviously hardly so. A two-party system, whatever else we may think of it, is certainly an artificial oddity and it is worth while considering how it came to be and why and whether the benefits of it outweigh its evils and absurdities."

He said that when examining the system in 1948 and 1949, the system we are to be given, the system that the intellectual people in the British Parliament, who have the training to examine these things, say that maybe they would need to consider in regard to the running of their own Parliament. We are now being told that a system that the thinking members of the British Parliament are not satisfied with should be imposed on us. Another second best will be handed to us—not something that will be a solution. Mr. Hollis continues:—

"If any of the philosophers have any lesson to teach us about constitutional history, there would appear to be a great deal more truth in the Platonic theory that constitutions move round in a cycle, each form taking its turn and giving place after a time to another, and indeed all forms of Government are so manifestly bad and some form of Government is so manifestly necessary, that it is not surprising that men should always be acutely conscious of the defects of the particular form from which they are suffering at the moment,..."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

May I ask a question? Would Senator Burke inform us what particular credentials this Mr. Christopher Hollis has to be regarded as an expert mind?

Comment on this

As good as Earnán de Blaghd.

Comment on this

Maybe, in 100 years' time, he might have as good credentials as Edmund Burke. In his day in Parliament, everybody went out because they did not want to listen to him. Senators know that. Some of the more studious members said, "We can read about him afterwards", but nobody listened to him.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator seems to think that Mr. Hollis is an authority on everything.

Comment on this

He is a Member of Parliament. He is a well-known scholar and author. I want to continue with the quotation——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And these are his only credentials?

Comment on this

I will continue with the quotation I was reading before I was interrupted:—

"......should willingly change it for another, only to find that the new form has also its deficiencies."

Now we are to change from this system and we have not been told the deficiencies. No one has made a study of it. The people doing it have had no experience of working in the Parliaments in which this proposed system is operating. They say to us, "Let the people decide. You are trying to stop the people from deciding."

Comment on this

Do you think the people are not capable of deciding?

Comment on this

I am not saying whether or not the people are capable of deciding. What I said was—Senator Ryan was probably listening to me when I started—that we will give the people the fullest opportunity of judging the implications of this measure. We shall see to it here, at the crossroads and outside the Church doors that the people will be told all the arguments and will get all the publicity and all the information we can provide. It is our duty. The late Pope, in 1953, speaking on adult education, said:—

"The right to vote, in particular, which gives to everyone an equal possibility of influencing public life, requires in the one who exercises it at least an elementary notion of political principles and their application within the national and international sphere of politics.'

If we are going to change our system we should give the people more than an elementary notion of what will happen or what the changes will be. Apparently there are many people on the opposite side of the House who object to the fact that we are going to give them that opportunity. I think of the centuries we spent looking for the opportunity to run our own affairs and I am saddened when I remember that most of this half century has been wasted in futile discussion. We should be able to find the necessary common agreement. But when we are beginning to get more agreement on economic affairs this diversion, this disturbing influence is thrown into the melting pot of Irish politics, to divide us.

Anyone who studies politics knows that the nearer to equilibrium that you can bring the pendulum, the better, and that if you agitate the pendulum violently you will do harm. If you have a Conservative Government on one occasion and a Communist or Socialist Government on the next, you cannot survive. There has been a lot of talk about Britain and America. The reason why they were so successful with the two-Party Government was that there was no violent change when the Conservatives and the Liberals changed in Britain, and when the Republicans and the Democrats changed in America. It is like changing a board of directors, working according to a memorandum and articles of association. They are changed because they may be too old or ineffective, because they cease to have the drive, or cease to have the necessary qualities. In a democracy they may fail to attract the people, who are the electorate. That is the aim that we should have here but the aim of this Bill is to agitate the pendulum violently, to get extremes in Irish politics so that there will be a swing in the electorate, so that you will have, say, nationalisation at one time and denationalisation at another time.

I was impressed when I heard Senator Quinlan saying that we had a philosophy of life which was held by all the people, that we were all Christians and that we should have a more common approach, rather than something that was going to divide us. I said on a previous occasion that the first decade of our opportunity was lost here. I want to see us given another opportunity and that is why I am opposed to this Bill so vigorously. I believe it will drive a wedge in Irish life, that it will drive a wedge under the foundation stones of this State and shake the whole edifice.

There has been a lot of talk about the fact that perhaps Fine Gael will be driven into the wilderness. It is quite possible that Fine Gael will be driven into the wilderness for a time. As a Party we are not as politically minded as our political opponents. Most of the people in this Party seem to have been brought into politics one way or another through their vocations and they would prefer to be doing something else, as Dr. Johnson said when asked about matters of that kind. We are not quite so good, as Senator Donegan said, for going to all the funerals; we have not got the taste for it. We do not want to do it. If anybody objects to what I am saying, there was a letter written by Commandant Brennan Whitmore——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I submit that this is a Second Stage speech and not a speech on the section. The Senator is talking about the Bill, about the principles, and making a speech exactly the same as on the Second Stage. He has not referred to the section yet.

Comment on this

The Chair agrees that the Senator is going very wide of the section and hopes that the Senator will return to the section.

Comment on this

We would love to hear him on the section.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir. Is it in order for Senators on the opposite benches to be usurping the rights of the Chair and directing the Chair's attention?

Comment on this

The Senator was quite in order in drawing the attention of the Chair to a matter to which he thinks the attention of the Chair should be drawn. That applies to either side of the House.

Comment on this

The section is:—

Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members who represent constituencies, and one member only shall be returned for each constituency."

I have tried to keep as near to that section as I could but I found it necessary to answer a number of points which have been raised by Senators on the other side. One of the things said yesterday, and again to-day, was that it must be left to the people to decide but this man whom I quote, from Monday's Irish Independent, W.R. Brennan Whitmore, attacks both Fine Gael and the Labour Party for their lack of political organisation. He says that the reason why Fianna Fáil are so successful is that they have good political organisation. I shall not burden the House by reading the letter. Will the matter be left to the electorate or will it be put across in a high powered canvass? Will the people be allowed to decide calmly on how they will change this Bill, or how they will elect these members to represent them in the single seat constituencies? I doubt it.

Another thing which ran through my mind when I heard these speeches and this recommendation for changing the Constitution is what old Oliver Cromwell said, namely, that nobody goes as far as the man who does not know where he is going. In this Bill I fear that we are being driven a great deal further than we realise. No single member can tell us what the benefits will be. They tell us that we will get a better member but I wonder will the Party give us the better member. That is the danger which I see.

In conclusion, I want to say that the Government should devote a greater part of its time in going into the economic issues rather than bringing this into Irish political life as a solvent and a disturbance, as a waste of our time and a waste of our efforts. As far as I am concerned, I must indict the Government with wasting our time when we could be better concerned with solving unemployment and the other matters on which we should work together regardless of Party. But we are not allowed, because our co-operation is not sought and is not wanted.

Comment on this

May I comment very briefly on what the Minister and Senator Mullins said about me yesterday? First I should like to say, quite emphatically, that I agree with much of what they say. I agree that the religious minority has no justification to fear political injustice and has no immediate reason to expect any ill-treatment in the future. I entirely agree with that. The plain fact is that they have been generously and sympathetically treated. May I in self-defence say that I have said that continuously for over 20 years in places where it was not at all a popular thing to say, and that can be proved? I have always told my co-religionists that they have been treated generously and are likely to be treated generously. I agree with the Minister and Senator Mullins on that.

But we are legislating here for the future—not for the past and not even for the present. Everyone in this House knows that history is unpredictable. Who, in the spacious days of 1910 or even the early 1930's, could have imagined what was going to happen in the civilised countries of Italy and Germany? But it did happen. No matter how strong our confidence in the community of the majority in the Republic is, we cannot be certain of it to-morrow. That is why I believe I would be failing in my duty to one-fourteenth of our population in the Republic—and, I emphasise this, almost a quarter of the population in the whole country— if I did not point out emphatically that a constitutional safeguard against even a remote possible danger of this kind would be removed by the change proposed in this Bill.

That is the fact upon which I stand. It has not been refuted. The Minister very reasonably wondered why, when I dislike the denominational approach to politics, I introduced it yesterday. The answer, I think, is clear to every thinking man. Sometimes one greatly dislikes doing one's duty. It can be an extremely unpleasant thing to do. I personally found it unpleasant to raise that matter yesterday but it had to be done.

The fact is that several Protestants asked me straight, as they are entitled to ask me, what would be the effects of this change on them as a minority. I answered them in the terms in which I spoke to the Seanad yesterday, that it would have this particular effect, that they would need a much larger percentage of the electorate in any constituency than they need at present if they wanted to return some one as a Protestant for Protestants. Let me say something very definitely here. I said that with the greatest effort not to arouse any feelings of bigotry or fanaticism. I made no attempt, and I will make no attempt, to beat any kind of Protestant drum and say that Protestants must, as Protestants, vote against this proposed change. I believe that the Minister would be entitled to condemn that, as would every right-thinking person.

I would be failing in my duty, when there is a clear mathematical state of affairs before us, if I did not make that clear to them and to this House. What is more, though I do not care to incur the opprobrium of the Minister and Senator Mullins, I would very much prefer their opprobrium than to be told at the bar of history in 50 years' time that this was the consequence of that measure and that I said nothing about it and neither did any other of our representatives.

In our small way in this House we are making history. We are making good laws or bad laws. Every one of us should speak with that in mind. It is not just what people are saying to-day. It is what people will say in 20 or 30 years' time. Sir, I bow my head when Senator Mullins and the Minister speak of things being disgraceful, but I would prefer to bow to it now than that I or my descendants should have to do it 50 years hence. That is what could happen if we have a change such as could happen here. It might be disgraceful for me not to point out the risk.

Obviously, however, the Minister and Senator Mullins dislike what I have done. They are entitled to that dislike but sometimes we simply must hurt. I was surprised, however, when the Minister used the phrase "a scrap of paper being no guarantee". It is a curious phrase to use. As well as I can remember, it was first used when the Germans invaded Belgium. They had a treaty with the Belgians not to invade them. They did invade them. The Kaiser said it was ridiculous; what did a piece of paper matter; he would invade them. He invaded Belgium but the tide turned against him. It aroused the moral indignation of the world, not simply because of the invasion but because of the specific contempt for treaty guarantees. I do not think the Minister meant that.

Comment on this

I did not use the phrase. It was used by Senator Mullins but not in the sense the Senator is talking about.

Comment on this

I beg the Minister's pardon. I withdraw that statement and I will deflect my remarks in the direction of Senator Mullins. I apologise to the Minister. I was unavoidably absent during his speech. I understood he used that phrase. However, the fact remains that the minority at the moment have the goodwill of the majority. I am happy to say we have it. At the same time, why should we scrap this scrap of paper? I welcome the generosity of the people who put it into the Constitution of 1922 and the Constitution of 1937. Why should it be taken out now?

Let me once again safeguard myself from misunderstanding. I do not pretend to suggest that there is any intention on the part of the present Government to infringe upon the rights of the minority in this matter. This is a consequential matter. It is the result of a decision that has been taken on completely different grounds. I have complete confidence in the present Government and previous Governments. They are not aiming legislation against the minority but it is a consequential effect which the religious minority should face up to.

Many of my co-religionists, as the Minister rightly suggests, would say: "We do not want any special treatment. We are not interested in that; we will disregard it". But they should know what the choice is and what its implications are. That is what I have offered. The Minister, from what I read of the report of his speech and from what I heard and from what Senator Mullins has said, did not try to refute my facts or figures. They said it was unjust or wrong to raise the matter but I stand on the facts and figures I gave yesterday. It will be almost impossible for members of the religious minority, if they want to elect their own members by themselves, to voice their opinions in the Dáil, if this change is approved. If the Government supporters can refute my figures I will withdraw, but not otherwise.

There is one other matter. A curiously misleading phrase has been used by both sides of the House—I venture to employ that phrase in the geographical sense. It is "the straight vote". It is a ludicrous phrase. This proposed change is neither more straight nor more crooked than any other kind of voting. Senator Quinlan suggested a rather drastic alternative—"the illiterate vote". That perhaps is a reflection on many people in our country. It is not "the illiterate vote" but I do suggest it is the wasting vote, and I suggest it with very great emphasis for the following reasons.

It is possible under the proposed system that 66 per cent. of the electorate will find their votes absolutely useless. Does that encourage people to go and vote? Does it encourage them to take an interest in the elections? That is what we very much want in this country, more interest in these matters, but I do not think we shall get that. The people will realise that it is possible for a candidate with 34 per cent. of the votes to be elected and nothing whatever will come of the other 66 per cent. We did press for the transferable vote which would ensure that the most that could be lost would be 50 per cent. but we did not get that.

I shall not press this point but I suggest that anyone who uses the phrase "the straight vote" is using a misleading phrase and any person who prefers to use the phrase "the wasting vote" or "the wasteful vote" is using a clearly descriptive phrase.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I am very glad that Senator Stanford has come into the House. I was sorry he was not here yesterday when I was dealing with his speech. As he pointed out, under the system we have if any minority, identifiable as a minority, wants to be sure of getting a candidate returned it must have at least 16? per cent., that is in a five-member constituency, of which there are only a few. In a four-member constituency they must have 20 per cent.—plus one, in all cases—and in a three-member constituency they must have 25 per cent. Of all the constituencies we have, in what constituency has the Protestant minority 16? per cent.?

Comment on this

I suggest they have it in Dún Laoghaire, in some of Dublin constituencies and in Donegal.

Comment on this

No, definitely not, and the reason that there are Protestant representatives in the Dáil is that they do not go up as Protestants and they must get the support of non-Protestants to be elected.

Comment on this

If one looks at the population statistics for these boroughs, one will see they have over 20 per cent. Unless the Minister can produce some evidence for the statements he is making now——

Comment on this
A Senator

The Senator has not produced it either.

Comment on this

I shall go down and get the population statistics.

Comment on this

We shall get somebody else to go down and get them. The Senator can speak after me and it would be as well for him to sit here until we have this out.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister I have not the slightest intention of leaving the House while he is speaking.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear that. There is not a constituency in the Twenty-Six Counties in which Protestants have 16? per cent. or 25 per cent. They could not be elected on their own as Protestants to speak merely for Protestants, and for purely selfish or exclusively Protestant interests. I put this challenge to the Senator in the debate in the Dáil, and to people who are of the same mind as he is, that if they wanted to make certain that tiny minorities were represented, they would have to change the system we have and make the country all one constituency. That is not unusual under P.R. It was operated in two or three places in Europe. Senator Stanford and the others do not demand strict proportionality. They want to mouth a lot about minorities and scare people into voting against this measure not because of their religious convictions but because they have a prejudice against it, and because of their political immaturity. They want to get people to vote against this on the plea that it will affect adversely religious minorities or some other type of minority that would be entitled to be represented as such.

In the Twenty-Six Counties you have a non-Catholic minority of 7 per cent. If that voting strength were distributed over the whole country it could not, under the present system, get a candidate returned without help, and in all cases I know of where candidates of the religious minorities were elected, they got help from their neighbours of a different religious persuasion.

The one thing that this debate has brought out is that, in spite of all the chat that went on about minorities, all the Senators on that side of the House are agreed that they do not want minorities any smaller than are represented at present in the Dáil. I put it up to them that if they wanted to protect a minority that had only one-150th of the votes in the country, they should really do something about it, but they turned their back on that. They do not want any minority smaller than the present minorities.

I can understand the Labour Party, Fine Gael, Clann na Talmhan and Clann na Poblachta that was, having that point of view. As political Parties go they are very lazy. They do not like thinking out new ideas or taking the trouble to convert sufficient people to vote for them. They are lazy politicians. They want to have little Parties that can coalesce and have a leader or two at the top who are inevitably given a seat or two in the Cabinet and a Ministry to run for a while. They do not want to expand any further than they have. They are doing nicely as it is.

Senator Quinlan wanted a continuation of the present system and wanted Fianna Fáil never to coalesce, so that the alternative to Fianna Fáil would be inevitably a Coalition. If Fianna Fáil had been prepared to coalesce with other Parties in the past we might have had, long before now, the situation that was reached in certain countries on the Continent and elsewhere whereby the representatives of the people were divided into a number of small and equal Parties and that there would be always a Coalition because no Party could ever have the opportunity of forming a Government on its own. That is a delightful system for Parties that have really no belief in what they stand for, that have a policy of attack merely to attract sufficient votes to get sufficient seats to be able to demand a seat or two in the Cabinet, with no further responsibility than that. Fianna Fáil have different ideas. We go to the people to get their support for a policy we believe in. If the people do not give us sufficient support for that policy we will not play the Coalition game as the various Coalition groups are prepared to play it.

Senator Dr. Sheehy Skeffington denied yesterday that in this Second Reading speech he stood for minorities smaller than are possible to be elected under the present system. I would call his attention to column 452, Volume 50, of the Official Report in which he said:—

"By the single transferable vote, in my contention, P.R. offers a system which ensures that political Parties and political ideas will be represented in Parliament, in this House and in the other House, in proportion to the voting strength they command among the electorate. Such a system is eminently just..."

Does Senator Sheehy Skeffington deny that the ordinary clear meaning of that is that he is advocating a system of P.R. which ensures that political Parties and political ideas will be represented in the Dáil according to their voting strength among the electorate?

Comment on this

As I am asked the question, I went on in the following two paragraphs of the same speech to make it quite clear that our present system, which I accept, favours only the big Parties but that that slight disproportion was acceptable; I offered to quote percentage figures, though I said that I did not want to weary the House by quoting percentage figures, but offered to quote them, if anybody asked for them, to show that the two big Parties alone regularly and uniformly benefited disproportionately under this system.

Comment on this

What I am trying to find out is precisely and clearly what Senators have in mind about P.R. so that there will be no codding the people down the country that they were in favour of complete proportionality which would give the minorities of one-one hundred and fiftieth of the country the right to be certain that they could get a seat. Senator Professor Stanford cannot go down the country and say that he was all out to get the 7 per cent minority a guarantee that in all circumstances they would be able to get elected as a minority interest. If that was what was in their minds I challenged them to put down a motion which would in all circumstances guarantee that anyone who had one vote out of every 150 could get a Dáil seat; but they did not do it. They oppose the change to this straight vote system on the plea that it will adversely affect minorities, although the present proportional system which they want to hold on to does not guarantee a minority of less than 15? or 16? per cent. this right to be certain of a seat.

Senator Dr. Sheehy Skeffington went on a little further, and I will add to what I have already quoted. Having said that a system which ensures that political Parties and political ideas will be represented in Parliament in proportion to the voting strength they command among the electorate would be eminently just—he did not, however, whether it was just or not, put in any amendment to secure that end —he went on:—

"...to desire any other system, even for Party benefit, seems to me to desire to derive Party benefit from electoral injustice and disproportionate representation."

I want to make it clear that no one in the Seanad or the Dáil was so much in favour of minority representation that they were impelled to put down an amendment which would secure representation for the smallest minorities, and yet they will go around the country, as many of them will, saying that when Fianna Fáil passed this Bill through the Oireachtas, or asked the people to adopt it, they were doing so in order to crush minorities and to deprive them of their just rights.

Senator Professor Quinlan was very anxious to know what various eminent gentlemen, statesmen, in other countries, thought about P.R. I invited him to read the Dáil debates, when he would see quoted there by various members of Fianna Fáil the opinions of very eminent statesmen in Europe who saw their countries collapse because of P.R., but Senator Professor Quinlan did not seem to take that trouble. He wants to get a commission employed to go into this whole business of P.R. and see what the commission would recommend. I believe, as I said here before, that the best type of commission to inquire into this matter are the people of Ireland, who have had experience of politics and government over the last 30 or 40 years.

I think Senator Hayes correctly described P.R. and its weaknesses. He said: "Three seat constituencies are not as good from the point of view of representation and workability as the British single non-transferable vote constituency."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Of course, that was on another subject altogether. The Minister is quoting out of context, without giving the reference and without stating the subject under debate.

Comment on this

The subject under debate was the Constituencies (Revision) Bill, 1947. In the course of that Bill Senator Hayes said: "Three seat constituencies are not as good from the point of view of representation and workability as the British single non-transferable vote constituency."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I was arguing for a five seat constituency at that particuular moment, was I not?

Comment on this

The Senator may have been arguing for 100 seats, but what he said about the three seat constituencies was that "they are not as good from the point of view of representation and workability as the British single non-transferable vote constituency."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It was not a judgment. It was a statement made obiter, on the side.

Comment on this

But it was said. The Senator is trying to persuade the Seanad to vote for the continuation of three seat constituencies.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Of the system we have.

Comment on this

Of three seat constituencies.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Of the system we have.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It would be better to let the Minister continue.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Would he not say something about P.R. now and again?

Comment on this

Senator Hayes wants to continue the system of three seat constituencies and to persuade the Seanad to vote for them, even though we are offering the alternative which he said was better—the single non-transferable vote constituency.

There are others who had similar views to Senator Hayes's on this matter. We cannot call on the foreign statesmen who saw Germany and Italy collapse through the weaknesses of P.R., but we can call to witness people who had experience of Government here and who know the weaknesses of P.R. During one of the elections of 1927 Cumann na nGaedheal published an advertisement about the idea of Coalition Governments.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Thirty-two years ago.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister ought to be permitted to continue.

Comment on this

Thirty-two years ago. Not so very long ago the Leader of the Fine Gael Party said that one of the weaknesses of P.R. was its tendency to create a multiplicity of Parties.

Comment on this

That is 22 years ago.

Comment on this

At column 1345, Volume 67 of the Dáil Debates, Deputy Costello said:—

"Under the system of the single transferable vote we are bound to have a large number of Parties returned."

He went on:—

"We always understood that the real defect under any system of P.R., and particularly the system of the single transferable vote, was that it led in circumstances where there are no big economic issues before the country, to a large number of small Parties being returned, making for instability in Government."

He said that that was inherent in the system of P.R. and the single transferable vote. I do not have to ask M. Robert Schumann what he thinks of P.R. We have it on the authority of Deputy Costello, who has had experience of Government since 1922 on several occasions and who had the experience in recent years of running a Coalition, that P.R. leads to a multiplicity of Parties and that that, in turn, leads to instability in Government.

At that time, in 1947, there were others on the Fine Gael side who had experience of the Dáil and of Government whose ideas coincided with those of Deputy Costello and Senator Hayes. Mr. McGilligan said: "It was always held with regard to P.R., which this country adopted, that we had adopted the worst possible system." But Senator Hayes wants us to keep "the worst possible system"—the system which Deputy Costello indicates leads to a multiplicity of Parties—a large number of small Parties making for instability in Government. I think Deputy Dillon exaggerated slightly when he turned his tongue on P.R., because he said: "I think P.R. is a fraud and a cod and that it ought to be abolished." But Senator Hayes wants it not to be abolished. He wants to keep what Deputy Dillon described as "a fraud and a cod and the brainchild of all the cranks in creation."

Having the authority of these gentlemen on this commission we are in the process of holding in the Seanad at present and having secured the evidence of what they really think about P.R. when they stagger into disclosing their real minds on the matter, let us go back to the men who ran the country up to 1927. In 1927 an advertisement was issued by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, in the course of which they said to the electors: "Your fight in this election is a fight for Government." The word "Government" was underlined. They said there were only three possible types of Government. They went on to point out what they were—a Cumann na nGaedheal Government, a Republican Government or a Coalition Government. They described what would happen under a Coalition Government. They said:—

"Coalition means bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups."

Comment on this

That was the time you asked Senator Baxter to be Minister for Agriculture and——

Comment on this

"Bargaining for place and power between minority groups." But Senator Hayes and those who were with him want us to keep this system of election which creates the multiplicity of irresponsible small Parties which would carry on this bargaining for place and power that is so rightly condemned by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Senator Hayes never said that, of course.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes got somebody else to say it for him.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Senator Hayes never said it. It is not true that Senator Hayes said it. It is just not true. However, go on. It does not make any difference.

Comment on this

Is Senator Hayes running away from the Cumann na nGaedheal advertisement at that period?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Senator Hayes never ran away from anything. I know more about it than the Minister.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes was not a candidate because he was the Ceann Comhairle. The first time he became a candidate he got kicked out by the electors. However, on this occasion, he carried on as Ceann Comhairle, recognised as a member of Cumann na nGaedheal. He is now trying—32 years afterwards—to repudiate the argument which the Cumann na nGaedheal people used in order to get a majority from the people.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister is attributing a statement to me which I never made.

Comment on this

I am attributing this statement to Senator Hayes's Party. That is all.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is a different thing altogether. Let the Minister talk about the Party.

Comment on this

Did I not quote the advertisement? Senator Hayes did not put in the advertisement.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I did not put in the advertisement and I did not say what is in the advertisement. The Minister should confine himself to what I said.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it the Minister will accept Senator Hayes's correction?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I had nothing whatever to do with that advertisement.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Does the Minister accept Senator Hayes's correction?

Comment on this

Wait now.

Comment on this
Senators

The Chair.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I appeal to Senators to let us do our utmost to have order and decorum in this debate. Senator Hayes has corrected the Minister's statement. I take it the Minister will accept Senator Hayes's correction that he did not make that statement?

Comment on this

We will require to get very clear——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it that when a member of this House makes a statement, through the Chair, the opposite number accepts the truth of what the Senator says. That is the practice in this House.

Comment on this

If the practice of the House is to let Senator Hayes run away from something he said, after a lapse of 32 years, I am quite content.

Comment on this
Senators

The Chair.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The rule of order surely is what the Leas-Chathaoirleach has said. The Minister is attributing to me an opinion which I never stated anywhere. He gives no reference except an advertisement which was issued in 1927 and with which, palpably, I had nothing to do. Let the Minister talk about my opinions as I state them and about the Cumann na nGaedheal Party when I was associated with it—not that I object to the advertisement or mind what the Minister says. I do not mind at all. However, the Minister should not put words into people's mouths unless he can show where the words were used.

Comment on this

I put the words into the mouths of the people who used them— and they were the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, to which Senator Hayes belonged.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I did not belong to it. It is untrue that I belonged to the Cumann na nGaedheal Party then.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

This is a sensational revelation.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I was Ceann Comhairle of Dáil Éireann in 1927. I had nothing to do with the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I never attended a meeting of it and I had nothing to do with it. The Minister knows that as well as I do. This is just an old spleen against me which is being vented by the Minister. It is not true and the Minister cannot get away with it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We will now proceed in a peaceful way with the debate, with the Minister setting the example—the high standard of example which we hope to see in this House.

Comment on this

I always set that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Let us have the Minister's acceptance of Senator Hayes's correction and go on from there.

Comment on this

I accept that Senator Hayes was in the political deep-freeze for ten years.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I suggest to the Minister that that is not the right approach. At the moment, I have the responsibility of preserving order in this House. If any member of the Opposition had made a statement similar to the statement made by the Minister and if it were corrected by a member on the other side, the correction would be accepted and we would pass on. The Minister must either accept or reject Senator Hayes's correction.

Comment on this

We dealt with that long ago.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Minister does not accept the correction offered by Senator Hayes then I have another duty cast upon me.

Comment on this

I have accepted Senator Hayes's explanation that he was in the political deep freeze and that he was not a member of Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That statement is untrue. It is a dirty phrase of the Minister——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Hayes will resume his seat.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister is giving vent to an old spleen against me.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I ask the Minister to accept the statement made by Senator Hayes unequivocally and to pass on from that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I was not in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party at that moment at all.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Why does the Minister not tell Senator Stanford something about minorities?

Comment on this

But Senator Hayes says he was not a member of Cumann na nGaedheal—and of course we accept his statement—in 1927. Everybody else in the country thought he was— but we accept his statement that he was not.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Nobody else in the country thought I was.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Of course they did. I thought it, and everyone else thought it, too.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister is biassed against me.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator has made a statement in this House. Whether or not Senator Ó Maoláin or the Minister or any other Senator makes assertions about Senator Hayes, when Senator Hayes makes a statement of correction, then the truth of what Senator Hayes says will be accepted.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He said nobody in the country thought he was a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I did, and thousands of others did, too.

Comment on this

We cannot care about what you think. Senator Ó Maoláin was expelled from the Fianna Fáil Party in those years.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator L'Estrange will please let us have order in the House or the House must adjourn. We cannot go on with the business which was ordered for discussion.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I am used—if I may put it this way—to not being accepted in some statements. I did not say everybody in the country knew I was not a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. The Minister said everybody in the country thought I was. That is a different thing and it is not true.

The Minister, as a matter of fact, is departing from the subject of P.R. in order to work off an old spleen against me. I do not begrudge it to him but he will not get away with it so long as I am here. It is to do——

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear Senator Hayes say, after all these years, what he has just said. In 1932, he was a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I was, yes—after March.

Comment on this

After March. Professor Hayes walked from the Ceann Comhairle's Chair to sit on the Opposition Benches.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

My successor did the same thing, the Lord have mercy on him. He did the identical same thing the day he walked in.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

All that is not material to this discussion. I hope the Minister will appreciate that fact.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It is quite irrelevant.

Comment on this

We are talking at the present time about the Cumann na nGaedheal advertisement in which Cumann na nGaedheal asked the people to vote for them in 1927. They emphasised that a Coalition Government was inevitable if the people did not vote for or give their support to Cumann na nGaedheal. They showed that a multiplicity of small Parties, which tended to be created under P.R., meant bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups.

The next point made by Cumann na nGaedheal, in their appeal to the people in 1927 to support them, was that a Coalition meant a weak Government with no stated policy. The third was frequent changes of Government. The fourth was consequent depression in trade and industry and the fifth was no progress, but stability, security and credit in constant danger.

Comment on this

Did Fianna Fáil agree to that at that time?

Comment on this

I do not know. As a matter of fact, I did not recollect the advertisement until it was discovered, after Senator Hayes again became a member of Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

It is quite possible that Cumann na nGaedheal were wrong then and that Fianna Fáil are wrong now.

Comment on this

Let us examine it. Remember that they were wrong in the light of their own experience. They said it would create bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups. Surely we saw that in 1948. We had a number of minority groups who swore by bell, book and candle that they would not touch Fine Gael with a forty-foot pole. They asked the people to elect them on the basis that they would not touch Fine Gael, would not coalesce with them. When they were elected they immediately started to negotiate for joining up with Fine Gael.

Comment on this

On a point of order, on what section is the Minister speaking?

Comment on this

I am speaking on the same section as everybody else spoke on.

Comment on this

The Minister should come back to the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is a matter for the Chair. The Minister to continue.

Comment on this

Go back to China.

Comment on this

I was challenged as to whether, in fact, P.R. turned out as badly an was anticipated by Cumann na nGaedheal in 1927, when this bargaining for place and power between irresponsible groups, in fact, occurred. I want to judge the irresponsibility of the groups who formed the Coalition by what they said to the electorate, whether they behaved as responsible people who had undertaken to serve the electorate in a certain way. Deputy Blowick, who became a member of this Coalition, said on the 3rd of June, 1948, a few months before he became a Minister:—

"When we went in there——"

that is into the Dáil

"——as a Farmers' Party, the only real farmers' organisation at present in the Dáil, we had to overcome a nasty odour as three other previous Parties had joined with Fine Gael and many people thought it would only be a matter of time until we had lost our identity as Independents. I can tell you that the strict attitude of independence which was adopted at the beginning still stands, that there will be no merging with any Party. We have no right to sell that independence. We never asked your authority to do so and we are not asking you now for that authority."

Although he asked the authority to stand as an Independent, to repudiate any idea of Coalition, within a couple of months——

Comment on this

Did they merge?

Comment on this

They bargained for place and power with Fine Gael.

Comment on this

The Minister has no evidence of that.

Comment on this

And they got a Ministry for the time being. On the 1st October, 1947, the same gentleman said that while he remained the Leader of the Party, "it would veer neither to the right nor to the left, and would continue to refuse to be drawn into coalition with Fine Gael, or any Party in the Dáil." Is that definite enough? They would refuse to be drawn into coalition, but they did bargain for place and power and they got into the coalition. The Labour Party spoke in the same manner about coalitions but they joined the coalition. The national organiser of the Party, at Dún Laoghaire, said that "Fianna Fáil would not get an overall majority and, in the eventuality, the Labour Party would not go into a coalition." But they did. They bargained for place and power. It took place between these irresponsible minority groups and the various promises and policies that they put before the people were thrown into the waste-paper basket in order to get this place and power which was so much condemned by Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

Are we not going on to 1951?

Comment on this

It was "a weak Government and had no stated policy." There were completely contradictory policies placed before the people by the various groups that went to form this coalition. You had the Empire Party that nailed the Union Jack to the mast, in Deputy Costello's election address, and you had the Clann na Poblachta Party that were completely opposite, but that coalition certainly had no stated policy before the election and the Lord only knew, from time to time, what was going to come out of the negotiations, let us call them that, which went on between them. But we know some of the things which did come out.

Another point in that Fine Gael advertisement was "the consequent depression in trade and industry" and there certainly was a consequent depression in trade and industry. During the first coalition the area under tillage went down by 500,000 acres. They were so short of money for other things that in their first Budget they cut out the £94,000 set aside for mineral development and the £250,000 set aside for lime and fertilisers.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir. Earlier this evening the Chair ruled that we were entitled to draw the attention of the Chair to speeches which were not in order. I wonder what the policy of the inter-Party Government of 1948 has to do with the fact that: "Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members who represent constituencies, and one member only shall be returned for each constituency"? I do not see the relevance.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it that the Minister is referring to these matters in passing and that he will not dwell on them unnecessarily. I do not want to restrict the Minister but perhaps he would deal with the section.

Comment on this

I was so keen to carry out Senator Quinlan's request for evidence about P.R.——

Comment on this

I did not ask for that.

Comment on this

——and I thought that I would give him evidence from our own experience which cannot be contested. I pointed out that certainly Cumann na nGaedheal were right when they said it would cause depression in trade and industry. It certainly caused depression in the trades and industries to which I have referred, when Cumann na nGaedheal cut down in the first years on these subsidies and expenditures——

Comment on this

What subsidies? You cut down the subsidies by £15,000,000.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister recognises the difficulty in which he places the Chair when he goes into these figures. I want the debate to be as satisfactory and as orderly as possible. I do not want to restrict any member of the House. If I permit the number of acres of barley and other subjects to be discussed, where will we stop? I put that to the Minister.

Comment on this

It was certainly proved beyond any doubt that a Coalition formed by the multiplicity of small Parties caused depression in trade and industry between the years 1948 and 1951.

Comment on this

They abolished all the Minister's taxes.

Comment on this

When we came back we had to make good the deficit they left behind and tried to build up——

Comment on this

With the Marshall Aid money.

Comment on this

——the things they had destroyed, such as mineral development and the chassis factory and so on.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What about the order Senator O'Quigley is so fond of?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am trying to do my best. The Minister is not helping as much as he could.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Neither is the Opposition.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Leader of the House could give the good example.

Comment on this

We have heard grumblings from inside about what went on in the Coalition. Ex-Deputy Larkin gave strong evidence in favour of the condemnation of Coalitions by Cumann na nGaedheal back in 1927. Deputy Larkin, in 1952, after the collapse of the first Coalition, said: "We know that Fine Gael utilised every opportunity that came not only in the open light of day but in the dark of night. Next time we may know better".

Comment on this

Tell us something new.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister is entitled to give that quotation and he should be permitted to continue.

Comment on this