Public Business. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Coiste (Atogáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 186–365 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
Senator Hayes and myself had some questioning as to what was meant by blackmail. Deputy Larkin said it could be done in the open light of day. This game was going on not only in the light of day but in the dark of night.
Comment on this
He used the words "dark of night." He said that Fine Gael used every opportunity that came not only in the open light of day but in the dark of night and that next time they might know better. I did not put it into Deputy Larkin's mouth. I put it into the mouth that used it—Senator Hayes's. Since Senator Hayes has objected, he said that abolishing P.R. and adopting the straight vote system meant that we were putting it in the power of individuals to blackmail.
Comment on this
If the Minister chooses to give a quotation to the House, the quotation ought to be given clearly, fully and completely. He is giving a quotation from Deputy Larkin and on the records of the House it should be the exact quotation. Nothing else should be introduced into Deputy Larkin's statement.
Comment on this
In justice to Deputy Larkin, who is not in the House to defend himself, I want the Minister to understand that a quotation is being given from the mouth of Deputy Larkin and it ought to be recorded on the records of this House as Deputy Larkin gave it.
Comment on this
It is so recorded. I gave it exactly as Deputy Larkin said it. It was not Deputy Larkin who spoke about blackmail, but Senator Hayes. I want to explain that so that there will be no mistake about it. It was Senator Hayes. He spoke on the 4th February, a few weeks back, and the column in the Official Report is 264.
Comment on this
He said "that was the idea"—about abolishing P.R. "Make certain the bargain will be struck beforehand. That is the idea," said Senator Hayes. "You must bargain beforehand."
Comment on this
Perhaps, somebody would look at this to see if it is a fact that I am not able to read properly.
Comment on this
But I think I know what the Senator meant people to understand. It was that if we adopted the straight vote system, small Parties, if they wanted to make certain that they were not going to waste their efforts, should then combine against the Party they wanted to defeat and that under P.R. they could make these bargains, and postpone the bargaining, the blackmail, if you want to put it that way, until after the election.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes said that was our idea, that we wanted them to bargain beforehand. He wanted to bargain afterwards.
Comment on this
The Senator cannot wriggle out of the fact that, under the P.R. system, the blackmail is postponed until after the election.
Comment on this
The bargain is postponed until after the election but we want to make certain, if there is going to be blackmail and bargaining, that it should be done while the people have a chance of expressing their will upon the matter and give a choice between those who are not prepared to be subjected to blackmail or to have this sort of bargaining and those who are.
Comment on this
Let us come down to, perhaps, a more fundamental point on the subject of the debate and ask ourselves what exactly do we want from elections? I think it is true that all Senators are now in agreement that we do not want complete proportionality. We do not want what Senator Sheehy Skeffington described as complete proportionality. We do not want a system which ensures that "political Parties and ideas will be represented in Parliament in proportion to the voting strength they command among the electorate". No one has suggested that we should have such a system. They want something else but the one thing they do not want is that "political Parties and political ideas would be represented in Parliament in proportion to the voting strength they command among the electorate".
If we do not want complete proportionality according to the electoral strength among the people, what do we want from an electoral system? I submit that what we want is what has been put forward by Fianna Fáil on many occasions and by very eminent statesmen from a great number of other countries, that is, a Government that can be changed peacefully, that can be held responsible by the people for its acts or inaction.
In our opinion the best way of getting a Government that can be held responsible is the straight vote system. We believe, with Senator Hayes, with Cumann na nGaedheal of the old days, with Deputy Costello, that P.R. leads to a multiplicity of small Parties, that it creates all these difficulties that were so eloquently and accurately described by many people who had responsibility for Government here and in other countries. We want the co-operation of the people in the referendum to get rid of that system and to adopt a system that has proved itself to be effective and worthwhile in countries that adopted it a couple of hundred years ago.
We know from our history that those who wanted the Irish people to be a failure always wanted to divide them. In the old days when the method of operation was the sword they tried to get the Irish people to make war upon one another for the benefit of their suppressors. In more modern days they tried systems of election. P.R. was one of them. We want to get rid of P.R. and to adopt a system which tends to promote unity rather than division among our people.
Comment on this
We do not want, of course, the single Party Government which was advocated by the Blue Shirts.
Comment on this
We do not want the type of Government hailed by Cumann na nGaedheal, that was black shirted in Italy and brown shirted in Germany——
Comment on this
——and that was going to be blue shirted in Ireland. We do not want that sort of Government. What we want is a reasonable system of election that will give the people on the one hand, a stable Government, a Government that will be able to put through the policy that it has asked the people to support and, on the other hand, a stable Opposition that will be able to form an alternative Government.
What objection have the people who are always preaching about unity to unity among small Parties? For three years we were deafened in the Seanad and in the Dáil by talk about the wonderful thing that unity was between Fine Gael, Clann na Poblachta, Labour, Clann na Talmhan and whatever other clanns there were at that time. If unity is such a good thing, why reject it before an election? Why not go to the people and say: "We cannot get Fianna Fáil to join us, but we can get all these other people who are prepared to sit down round a table, have an intellectual discussion and arrive at a common policy for our common needs"? Why is that not said before the election? Why is it left until all the bargaining occurs or until all these groups are satisfied about the Ministries they are to run?
We believe that, in spite of the difficulty that Fine Gael find in facing up to this solution of our political problem, that the people will insist on it, and that the referendum will go through by as big if not an even bigger majority than did the Constitution. The Constitution was opposed even more bitterly than this amendment.
Comment on this
The battle over the Constitution is not under discussion in this.
Comment on this
We shall pass from that to the next battle which we shall win with a bigger majority. There may be certain people who do not think very much of consulting the people. They do not want to have a referendum. Cumann na nGaedheal were never very keen on having the people consulted in a referendum. They took very strong measures to make certain that they would not be consulted, but they are going to be consulted on this occasion——
Comment on this
——and they will give the answer that Fianna Fáil want. The reason Fine Gael slid down from 60 members in the Dáil to 30 was because they had contempt for the people's intelligence, and it was only when they were through their penance that the people let them up again to 40. If they continue the way they are going they will have very much less than 40. We are going to make certain that the people will understand exactly the issues involved, and I have every expectation that just as the people in the last election gave Fianna Fáil the greatest majority they ever gave any Party in order to get rid of the Coalition, they are going to vote "yes" in this referendum by the greatest possible majority so that that type of Coalition is not going to return in Ireland.
Comment on this
I wonder what Senator Stanford thinks of the Minister's speech. I am sure he must have a certain feeling of guilt, because it was apparently in reply to Senator Stanford that the Minister rose. I thought that the Minister was going to give us some kind of thoughtful and reasoned reply to the speech of Senator Stanford, which has importance in view of the nature of his rerepresentation here. I would have expected the Minister to make an effort to meet that speech which was reasonably and lucidly made. There may have been flaws in Senator Stanford's arguments. None of us is perfect and all of us may make mistakes when we speak. At any rate the Minister got up and said that he hoped that Senator Stanford would not go away. The Minister's tall figure almost threatened Senator Stanford, and I thought that Senator Stanford was going to get a desperate dressing-down and that we would hear a great deal about minorities and be shown how absurdly illogical and unfounded all Senator Stanford's arguments were. Alas and alack, it was poor Senator Michael Hayes who came in for all the abuse and there was hardly a word about Senator Stanford.
Whether Senator Stanford rejoices in that or not I do not know, but I was very interested in the Minister's attitude. The Minister is obsessed by Fine Gael. He cannot get away from it. He can make no speech without drawing in Fine Gael and it is apparently Fine Gael and Senator Hayes that are really on his mind. His whole attitude to this very genuine problem is absurd, and he gives me the feeling of being very glad that I am not any small minority in this country subject to the Minister. We in Fine Gael have had to face the Minister in a great many ways and we have defeated him before, more than once.
Comment on this
The Minister need not be so cocky about what is going to happen on the referendum or on anything else. He has shown to-day not only an insulting attitude but also an attitude of intolerance, of truculence, and of menace to the people who have spoken against him. He simply refused to discuss this question of P.R. After all, what is it all about? Here we have a system which has been working for the last 40 years, recommended to us by the present Government in 1937 in the most unmistakable language after having had experience of quite a number of elections. We are proposing to destroy that and to adopt the British system with the single non-transferable vote in small constituencies but, strange as it may seem, whatever the Minister appeared to be talking about he never said a word about that. That is the matter being discussed now.
The Minister's organisation have rooted out all kinds of quotations which the Minister persistently distorts. Every quotation the Minister gives he gives partially and then he slips on to another matter, but he is not going to get away with that here, naturally enough, because none of us was born yesterday. He gave a very interesting example of the technique this evening in a quotation from Deputy Larkin. He did not say which Deputy Larkin and I do not know which. There were two at the particular moment.
Comment on this
He quoted from Deputy Larkin without saying which it was, Deputy James Larkin or Deputy Denis Larkin, and he slipped in the word "blackmail" which Deputy Larkin did not use at all.
Comment on this
The whole implication of what the Minister said was that Deputy Larkin had been alluding to blackmail. Then he stepped back to his favourite topic, Senator Hayes.
Comment on this
Professor Hayes would appear to be the villain of the piece with regard to this question of the Coalition advertisement in 1927 which the Minister is so proud to quote. The Minister's leader and the Minister himself were in favour of a Coalition in 1922, but they were beaten by some small Parties.
Comment on this
Senator Mullins and every other Senator will permit the Senator in occupation to speak.
Comment on this
Senator Mullins can give his interpretation to the House when Senator Hayes is finished, and so can any other Senator, but the Senator in possession is entitled to make his speech, and whatever side he is on I will see that he will make it without interruption.
Comment on this
They thought that they would smash the Treaty in 1922 by a Coalition, but it did not work out that way. They were in favour of a Coalition also in 1927. I do not think that Coalitions are relevant, but the Minister was reading a lot into the advertisement and making a very mean attempt to pin it on to me. I had nothing to do with it, any more than the Minister, and I am sure he had nothing to do with it. There has been no reference to the kind of coalition that the Minister and his leader wanted to make when they came into the Dáil in 1927. The proposal was to have a Government composed—it is interesting to remember this now—of the smaller Parties in the Dáil, a Government in which Fianna Fáil would not take any part, and from which the Cumann na nGaedheal Party would be shut out, so that you would have a Government in the Dáil supported by Fianna Fáil, who would not be in it, and the two main Parties would be excluded. Could any coalition, even at the Minister's worst and lowest form of argument, be more foolish than that? That is the kind of coalition they wanted. It was after the election they made all kinds of bargainings and promises. The story is well known.
I am not sure what the appropriate word is, although I am pretty good at words—whether it was my fortune or my misfortune to thwart that particular plan, and the Minister has not forgotten it. When Fianna Fáil came into Dáil Éireann in 1927 a vote of no confidence was put down. There was a division and because a particular man did not vote as he had promised to vote there was a tie. Because I voted against that vote of no confidence, as, of course, the Ceann Comhairle was entitled to do and was correct in doing, the Minister has never forgiven me. He wants to make out that I am a blackmailer, that I am given to making bargains, and this, that and the other. This is the kind of thing that he was trying to do in 1927. I am the person who was the instrument, perhaps the instrument of Providence, that prevented him from getting in, and kept him out of office for five years.
I am not saying now that the Minister was kicked out. I do not use that kind of language. But he was defeated in a division. Many men in this place were defeated in elections and I do not think that the word "kicked out" is very appropriate, but I could say that the Minister was kicked out of Government in 1948 and that is what is wrong with him. But I am not saying that. I am saying that he was put constitutionally out of Government. Now he is trying in this particular section of the Bill to ensure that so long as he lives it cannot happen again. That is the whole story.
One of the points made is: why cannot the people in the different Parties combine before an election? But why should a Labour man or a Fine Gael man not have a right to go for election if he likes? Why should he have to make a bargain with anybody else? Why is the P.R. system not allowed to operate as it is? The P.R. system does give minorities of any respectable size a good chance. It is useless for the Minister to repeat his old point that, unless you extend something to its fullest limit, you should not be in favour of it. It is like a fellow eating no breakfast at all unless he can get a six-course breakfast. As Senator Sheehy Skeffington and other Senators have said, whatever we think about the present system, it is better than any other system proposed. That is why we are against this Bill and why we are going to vote against this referendum. The present system is not perfect. Various criticisms have been made at various times. Unlike the Minister, I have reflected something on our parliamentary system, and I know something about it. I am one of the people who preserved Parliament against the Minister, both when he was outside it and when he was in it. He did his best from both sides.
Comment on this
The Parliament of this State, of the State of which the Minister was himself a Minister.
Comment on this
The Parliament of the Irish Free State, which followed the one you suppressed in June, 1922.
Comment on this
Senator Mullins must learn to listen to other people.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil are trying to destroy the whole basis of proper parliamentary government. They do not want to hear anybody talk except themselves. The Taoiseach makes up his mind on this and, as a man said to me a long time ago: "Away leis agus más away, away leó go léir ina dhiaidh"—away go all the boys after him, rooting out the files, pulling out all kinds of arguments and quotations to support the Chief.
There is a story in Irish about an old woman on a frosty night. She went into town. There was a great frost and all the dogs were barking. She bent down to pick up a stone, but the stones were frozen together. She said: "Is bocht an scéal é, madraí scaoilte agus clocha ceangailte"—'tis a poor case, stones tied and dogs loose. That is what they want, but Fine Gael will not give it to them. The Minister should cultivate a sense of humour. The whole purpose of this business is to devise a scheme whereby a Party that gets first past the post gets a big majority of seats—a majority of seats entirely out of harmony with, and out of proportion to the votes they get in the country.
The Minister has given no consideration to the problem. He has no knowledge of it. He has displayed colossal ignorance of France. I notice he did not mention France here at all and I think I know the reason. There are two reasons in this House. The Minister does not know anything about Europe and he displayed a like ignorance of the Constitution of the United States. He tried to divert the whole debate into the wrong channel. The Minister has made no inquiries of any kind relating to the facts. The Minister has not got a grasp of anything at all except the coat tails of his leader.
Comment on this
I want to make three points arising out of the Minister's recent intervention. First of all, I should like to suggest in relation to his quotation of the 1927 Cumann na nGaedheal advertisement on P.R. and the wickedness that might ensue from it, that in my opinion the views contained in that advertisement of Cumann na nGaedheal at that time were wrong. But I also suggest that in now taking the same view as Cumann na nGaedheal did then, Fianna Fáil are equally wrong. I am not prepared to accept the view that because Fianna Fáil have now adopted the view that Cumann na nGaedheal then had, it has suddenly become right. I think it is still wrong.
The second point is that I should like to make it quite clear that, personally, in my support of P.R. as a just system, I am no more in favour of absolute P.R. than the Minister, in supporting the single seat constituency system, as giving strong Government, is in favour of an absolutely single Party Parliament.
The third point I want to make is to put this question as briefly as I can to the Minister. The Minister gave us figures of percentages that Protestants and other minorities would need in order to get representation in various sizes of constituencies. He quoted percentages and figures. Would he agree that, on his own figures, on his quotas and percentages, Protestants or any other minorities have less chance of being elected, as such, in five seat constituencies than in seven seat constituencies, and less chance again in three seat constituencies than in five seat constituencies and, consequently, even less chance in one seat constituencies than under the present system? In other words, by changing the present system, I would suggest, and I should like to hear the Minister's answer to that specific question, their chances of being elected as such are perceptibly diminished by transforming all the constituencies into single seat constituencies in accordance with this very sub-section, which we are now supposed to be discussing.
Comment on this
What is less than nothing? They have no chance at the moment in any constituency we have.
Comment on this
On a point of information. On the last occasion, when the Committee Stage was fixed for to-day, in deference to the wishes of Senator Hayes and others, the hope was expressed that there would be a reasonable, workmanlike handling of the Committee Stage and that it would not be unduly delayed. If everybody is to make two speeches on the Committee Stage, I should like to know when does Senator Hayes or the Leader of the Labour Party expect we shall carry out the understanding I got here on the last occasion?
Comment on this
May I say I have not spoken yet but the Minister has made two speeches, largely beside the point, in my view?
Comment on this
Perhaps this matter could be discussed by Senator Hayes and Senator Mullins during the interval?
Comment on this
The only suggestion I can make is that if the debate is to be continued on these lines and not in the orderly fashion Senator Hayes suggested it would be on the last occasion, and as there is a lot of other important business as well as this, we will have to sit later, longer and oftener.
Comment on this
We are prepared to sit as long as the Senator likes but he will have to exercise some control himself.
Comment on this
We are not going into that at this moment.
Comment on this
It might be no harm if we did have a discussion on order in this House because it has become most disorderly.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
I have already spoken on the Committee Stage but like the Minister for External Affairs I would like to speak on the section. The Minister in his latest intervention again raises the question of making the whole country into one constituency. The Minister knows very well that nobody wants such a ridiculous system. I have already pointed out that in the 1922 Constitution all that we were bound to do was to have elections on the principle of P.R. and it was left open to the Oireachtas by electoral law to determine what form of P.R. we should have.
The Minister repeated this evening that P.R. was imposed on us by the British and was therefore inserted into the 1922 Constitution but, not satisfied with that, the present Government when they introduced the Constitution of 1937 went further than the British and tied us to one form of P.R., the form of the single transferable vote. When the Minister quotes from speeches of Deputies Costello, McGilligan and Dillon he does not tell the whole story. What they said in those speeches was that the system of P.R. that operated here was not perhaps the best system and that it should not be written into the Constitution as the particular form of P.R. that we should employ here.
The Minister knows, if he has studied the problem, that there are forms of P.R. that can be adopted to achieve the end which the Government allege they want to achieve by this amendment to the Constitution. The Minister has been challenged upon certain figures by Senator Stanford and I trust that Senator Stanford will produce figures which will place beyond yea or nay the theories advanced by him in relation to the religious minority in this country. But the Minister comes along and speaks of P.R. being employed in two or three countries in Europe on the basis of using the whole country as one constituency. I would like the Minister to name these countries because I do not know of any country in Europe employing the whole country as a single constituency unless the Minister is talking about the pocket States of Andorra or Liechtenstein or San Morena. If he wants to compare these with this country the proper basis for comparison would be urban or parish councils because that is what elections in these countries amount to.
There is only one country in the world, as far as I know, which employs the whole country as a single constituency for the purpose of election on the basis of P.R., and that is Uruguay; but I would point out to the Minister that that is not in relation to the representative assembly. It is in relation to the Government that the whole country is used as a single constituency. It is provided by the Constitution of Uruguay, which was ratified by the people in 1951, that the Chamber of Representatives should consist of 99 members, elected by the people. It goes on to provide that they should be elected to represent departments and that there should be not less than two representatives for each department. For the purpose of electing a Government, there is a different procedure used from that used at the present time in this country or Britain or the United States of America. It is provided by the Constitution of Uruguay that the executive authority of the State shall be exercised by the National Council of Government. The National Council of Government is to consist of nine members—and here we have the whole country employed as a constituency—elected directly by the people, together with a double number of alternates for a period of four years, in accordance with the rules of suffrage set forth in Section 3 of the Constitution. The Republic is to be considered as a single electoral district. When the National Council of Government is elected, it is provided that the Party receiving the most votes shall have six councillors and three council seats shall go to the Party with the next highest votes. That is not the whole picture because it is the National Council of Government in Uruguay which appoints the Ministers of State and it is provided that the Presidency of the Council is to rotate annually. That is an entirely different system from the one we have. If the Minister wants to talk about countries being turned into a single constituency for P.R., he might inform the House of the country he has in mind, instead of dealing with it in the skimpy fashion he has used in this debate.
The Minister has unearthed all that could be said against our particular form of P.R. by certain Deputies of the Fine Gael Party. He also gave us the benefit of an advertisement published by Cumann na nGaedheal in 1927; but the Minister's industry has not gone to the length of giving us quotations from various Ministers in the Fianna Fáil Government, from Fianna Fáil T.D.s and Senators and other leading members of the Fianna Fáil Party which show that all of those Ministers and T.D.s in Fianna Fáil— with the exception of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health 12 years ago—had no doubts about the value of P.R. as a system of election for Ireland.
With the exception of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health on one occasion, there was no word from Fianna Fáil criticising P.R. as a method of election—not a single word. We have had nothing but adulation and admiration for it in the 1937 Constitution, and I agree with that. I have a great admiration for the Constitution, for the manner in which it sets forth and regulates how the Government of the country is to be conducted and for the guarantees of personal rights which it contains. It is intended now to make inroads upon that Constitution.
The Taoiseach, in opening the Second Stage debate here, referred to a conversation he had with the King of Italy some time before the war. The King of Italy, mark you, is quoted in support of the case against P.R. This is what the King of Italy had to say, according to the Taoiseach, as reported in Volume 50, column 256 of the Seanad Debates:—
"The present system," said the King, "is better than the system we had."
That, mark you, was before the war; and "the present system" of which the King of Italy spoke was a system which led to the World War, which was such a scourge to humanity. It is that view which is brought into this House now and quoted in support of the case against P.R. In other words, dictatorship, according to the Taoiseach, the dictatorship which led to the formation of the Axis Powers, was better than the weaknesses of P.R.— and a world war, apparently, is better than the weaknesses of P.R. That certainly is a new line of argument and, indeed, an interesting sidelight upon the views of the Taoiseach in relation to parliamentary democracy —parliamentary democracy in the Italy of Mussolini, of unhappy memory.
The Minister for External Affairs, on the Second Reading of the Bill, was in a mood for asking questions of both Fine Gael and Labour. He posed a question here which he wished to have answered by Fine Gael and Labour, as to whether, in the event of the amendment to the Constitution being adopted, that amendment would, at some future time, be repealed by both of those Parties. I would like now to ask the Minister a simple and straightforward question, but before doing so I want to lay the base on which I think the question ought to be asked. The Constitution is the Constitution of the people and it expresses the will of the people as to the form of Government they have; and one section of the Constitution is just as important as any other section in expressing the will of the people. It is no thanks to the Government, as has been pointed out, that this amendment will be by way of referendum. That is what the people have decided they want. In our particular Constitution, as in parliamentary democracy generally, the Government is responsible to Dáil Éireann. The Constitution provides that "the Government shall meet and act as a collective authority, and shall be collectively responsible for the Departments of State administered by the members of the Government." Those are the provisions of the Constitution and they have as much weight and significance as any other provisions.
I would like to ask the Minister for External Affairs how—in the situation which Fianna Fáil hope this amendment will produce, where the Government of the day will have an overwhelming majority of the seats—the Government can be made answerable to Dáil Éireann with a diminished Opposition. I would like the Minister to explain how the Government can be made answerable to Dáil Éireann when it comes to examining, say, Estimates for the Departments of State. At the present time, on the Vote on Account, on the Estimates and at Budget time, the Government are made answerable for the administration of Government Departments and for their Financial and economic policy. But it requires a lot of time, thought and work, and quite a number of people to pool their energies, in order to make the Government answerable to it.
I want also to ask the Minister, through the Chair, how he expects, under the new dispensation as he would have it, the parliamentary question will work. The parliamentary question has always been regarded in Britain and in this country as one of the great safeguards of democracy. Its very existence prevents abuses arising and, when abuses do arise, it enables these to be investigated in the full light of debate and discussion in Parliament.
We had cases in this country, under our own Constitution, of inquiries into certain practices that were going on. We had a railway tribunal inquiry, a Locke Distillery inquiry, a Monaghan Bacon Curing Company inquiry, and others. I am not concerned with the results of these inquiries. The fact is that, once there was a semblance that things were not right, it was in the public interest that these matters should be probed in Parliament. I am wondering how that will happen if we have not sufficient Deputies in the Opposition to deal with matters of these kinds. If they are to deal with matters of that kind, they will not have any time for legislation, Estimates, and so on.
If the Minister for External Affairs is interested in the preservation of our parliamentary democracy, I should like him to give us his opinion of how it will function under the new system that would be involved if this amendment of the Constitution is enacted. Even at this stage, we have the Taoiseach preparing the way for a further change. He said, in reply to the debate on the Second Stage, that if the new system does not work the Constitution can be changed. I want to know what will happen if P.R. has failed and if the straight vote system, as it is called, fails. What will we have then? What change is in the mind of the Taoiseach? What will be possible then?
Will we have somebody coming back from the Irish equivalent of Colombey Les Deux Églises—another General de Gaulle returning from retirement to take over the dictatorship which the king of Italy so much admired and which the present Taoiseach quotes in support of the case against P.R. Is that the system the Taoiseach has in mind?
Machiavelli, in The Prince, says that one change prepares the way for another change. I wonder what will be the next change from the present change? We are getting away from P.R., from fair play to the people. We are getting now a system of two-Party Government. That is what the amendment seeks to achieve. Having had two-Party Government, will the next step be one-Party Government such as they have in Russia and in the other Communist dominated countries? Is that where we are going? We have one change preparing the way for another. Has the Taoiseach accepted the Fabian philosophy of the inevitability of gradualness by consolidating the particular type of P.R. that we have in the 1937 Constitution which has caused him to introduce this amendment which in time will lead to another?
The Taoiseach comes along and says that the present system is a bad system and that now we should adopt the two-Party system. The Taoiseach seems to be of opinion that that system may not work and that we can always change the Constitution. As reported at column 880, Volume 50, of the Official Report, the Taoiseach said:—
"We are not freezing this, as somebody said, into the Constitution. The Constitution can be amended. If at any time it was considered that there was a bette system than the straight vote, and we have succeeded in getting the straight vote into use, the people would have a far better chance of changing back than they would ever have of changing from the present system to the straight vote system, because in the one case the vested interests would be so numerous and so powerful that we would never have in the Dáil an opportunity of getting an overall majority."
It is clear from that quotation that the Taoiseach has some doubts again in his mind, as he had in 1937 when he put P.R. in the Constitution, about this particular change.
Of course, my view of the purpose of this section is that it is purely an alibi for the Government's failure to make progress by asking the country to give them another chance, that if they have another system of election, all will be well. I do not believe, and I do not believe anybody in the country believes, that the election of the same kind of people with the same kind of outlook will, by a different system of election, produce any better results. There is an old saying in Ireland that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. It does not matter what kind of system of election you have if the quality of the people who will be returned is the same. You will not have any greater progress under a system which gives the Government an overall majority than you will have under the present system.
Senator Quinlan asked the Minister a question and the Minister shied away from it this afternoon. He asked the Minister what schemes of national importance the Government failed to put through by reason of the existence of the system of P.R. The Minister changed that question in some particular way and did not deal with the matter at all.
Senator Ó Maoláin dealt at great length with the British elections from early in the 1900's down to the present time. We all got these particulars and know how they work. I had always thought that what suited Britain did not suit this country and for very good reasons—that the type of economy in Britain is entirely different from our economy. Here, we are predominantly an agricultural community. In Britain the community is predominantly industrial. There, you have large areas of population. Here, we have very few areas with large populations. There you have a lot of workers in the cities. Apart altogether from that, you have a different kind of tradition there with the Crown and hereditary aristocracy and a tradition of great wealth among industrialists and the aristocracy. You have nothing like that in this country.
There is a statement on record by a very prominent person, whose name I shall not mention, that this country is one of the most egalitarian countries in Europe, not excluding Soviet Russia. It cannot be said that Britain is a very egalitarian country. At the same time, it is thought fit to suggest that a system of election that suits Britain suits this country.
I would point out to the Minister and to the House that the system in Britain that gives violent changes from right to left does not at all suit this country. We have made great efforts, through recent legislation and through bodies such as Coras Tráchtála and the visits of different Ministers to the U.S.A., to attract foreign capital here. They do not want any foreign capital in Britain. At some periods, I understand, they were suffering from over-investment. We are suffering from under-investment.
Now it is proposed, because the people have forgotten the bitterness of the civil war, to divide the people along different lines into right and left. Does anybody think that, in that situation, you will have American industrialists or Dutch or Swedish industrialists, or anybody else, coming into the country to invest their money, knowing that at some stage you may have in Government, if the forecasts of the Fianna Fáil members are right, a leftish kind of Government that would be disposed to nationalise industry and thereby ruin the investment which foreign investors had made in this country? Is that the way in which we will attract foreign capital into the country? I do not think it is. It does not, apparently, make any difference to the Government what the consequences of this election will be, provided they get their own way.
In that context it reminds me very much—since so much history has been quoted—of Diarmuid MacMorrough who was the cause of all our trouble. Because he could not get his way with the High King and with O'Rourke of Breffni he went to England and brought over the British, in order to vent his spleen and secure his own position. The Government now want to secure their own position and to vent their spleen on the electorate who, in 1948 and 1951, decided they did not want Fianna Fáil. Because of that we are now to amend the Constitution to entrench the Fianna Fáil Party in office if at all possible.
The Taoiseach is of the opinion that it is the Government that counts most, that it is the mainspring of action. He has stated that at column 871, Volume 50, of the Official Reports. That is not what the people have said in the Constitution. The Constitution was enacted by the people and they have not said that the Government counts most. They said that the Government shall be responsible to Dáil Éireann and the Government has not got the last say in every matter. It is not the Government that is entitled to declare war. It is provided in the Constitution, in Article 28, Section 3, that:—
"War shall not be declared and the State shall not participate in any war save with the consent of Dáil Éireann."
The people did not think that the Government counts most there, that it was the be all and the end all and the mainspring of action. The people in their Constitution said that that was a reserved function for the Dáil. We have a situation in this country where people have certain views about one of our great national problems. This particular amendment to the Constitution, if it were adopted, would facilitate a minority in gaining a majority of seats in Dáil Éireann and that seems to be the mentality of some of those who are in what, at the moment, is a very small minority. But we propose to facilitate that small minority, in certain circumstances, to employ this particular section of the Constitution for the purpose of declaring war.
I wonder if the Taoiseach and the Government have considered that aspect of the matter. It could become a very serious problem at some future date. Remember, it may not be in ten years' time, but it might be in 20 or 30 years' time. That is the kind of situation which we are providing for and which we are facilitating.
We had Senator Mullins quoting Mr. Ernest Blythe in the National Observer on P.R. I am happy to say that the National Observer is not in the same position as the paper with which Senator Mullins would be most familiar. It is not a controlled paper. There is freedom of expression in it and for the expression of a different point of view and it would never happen in the Irish Press, or any of its associated newspapers, that you would have such a strong dissenting view welcomed for the purpose of creating informed public opinion upon such an important subject as this.
Senator Mullins also objects to quotations from Pope Pius XII and from the present Pope. But I recall that on a very solemn occasion when we met here recently Senator Mullins, in spite of the solemnity of the occasion, could not refrain from quoting what the late Holy Father had to say in relation to our Constitution and I could not but think that that was done for a particular purpose. It ill becomes Senator Mullins to object to quotations from the Pope, or any other person, in relation to the Constitution.
Finally, I want to say that having got rid, to a great extent, of the bitterness engendered by the civil war, P.R. has had this effect, that where you had a number of Parties with several candidates going up in a particular constituency, the very fact that the number two, three, four and five votes would be useful to different Parties meant that there was less bitterness in elections than there would be in a straight fight. Under the system of P.R. Parties do not want to offend too much, if they can avoid it, the personal feelings of the other candidates and their supporters. That is because, if they do, they will alienate the support of their opponents and they will lose the preference votes. That has an integrating effect in constituencies and prevents the development of that personal spleen which is something we can all do without. It is a form of election that lends itself to the promotion of charity amongst people who have different or opposing political views.
Apparently, however, that is not what is wanted. What is wanted, apparently, is that people, having got over the bitterness of the civil war, should now be divided into right and left. That seems to me to be a very deplorable, unstatesmanlike and unworthy attitude for a Government to adopt.
Comment on this
If the Senator had been here earlier—I am quite certain he was engaged on the business of the House—he would understand the line of my argument.
Comment on this
That is what it is intended to create. We are told we have too many Parties. We are supposed to have Parties now divided, not on the basis of a political breach—the Taoiseach says that no longer exists— but we are to have them divided on the only other issues which exist, economic and social issues. If that is the case, it seems to me to involve a division of right and left, and the very words right and left have been used by the Taoiseach, but then the Taoiseach in his customary manner says: "Of course, I am only using these in order to indicate that there will be some kind of difference." But apparently that is what was at the back of the Taoiseach's mind. As a result of the system of P.R. in any constituency, there are people who are unwilling to offend their opponents because of the fact that to do so would alienate preference votes which might come to them and which might be useful to them. That is something which promotes a certain order, harmony, goodwill and a feeling of good fellowship among candidates. But that will not be the atmosphere which will prevail in the future under this new system.
We had from members of the Fianna Fáil Party what I can only describe as a hypocritical solicitude for the interests of the Labour Party. In the Dáil the Minister for Industry and Commerce said he regarded the Fine Gael Party as a surplus Party and he was not shedding any crocodile tears for that Party. The reason, of course, was that he felt Fine Gael constituted the greatest threat to Fianna Fáil. We have had, as I said, a great deal of hypocritical solicitude for the Labour Party. That is merely an attempt to comfort the Labour Party, but it will not deceive them.
We had the Minister for External Affairs giving us quotations from the speeches of Deputy Costello, Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Dillon on the question of P.R. The Minister was unable to produce any quotations from himself or any of his colleagues in the Government condemning P.R. since it was written into the Constitution in 1937.
Comment on this
The Senator has made that statement on a number of occasions already. The Senator appreciates repetition is not permissible in a debate like this.
Comment on this
I am aware of that and I have no intention of repeating myself, but I do want to repeat, and with emphasis, what the Taoiseach had to say about P.R. in 1937. At column 1343 of Volume 67 of the Official Report he had this to say:—
"The system we have we know; the people know it."
We are told now that the new system is a simple system. There is no need for simplicity when the people have a system they know, and know very well. He goes on:—
"On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think that we have a good deal to be thankful for in this country; we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of P.R. here."
Having had a system of P.R. for a longer period now one would imagine we should be even more grateful but, instead of that, we want to pitch P.R. out of the Constitution altogether.
"It gives a certain amount of stability."
I entirely agree it can give stability, and there are more kinds of stability in a country than mere stability of government. In Britain one does not find all that stability despite the fact that they have the straight vote system. Under the Labour Government in 1950-51 you had the Minister of Health resigning from the Government on the very small issue of the payment of 1/- for prescriptions under the Health Act. That created certain difficulties for the Labour Government. You had Lord Salisbury resigning over the question of the treatment of Cyprus and Mr. Thorneycroft, Chancellor of the Exchequer, resigned over the Budget of 1950.
Comment on this
In what way is all this relevant to sub-section 1º of Section 2?
Comment on this
It is related in this way: we have been told that the single member constituency and the non-transferable vote gives stability of Government. I am pointing out that where you have people resigning from Government there can be no suggestion of stability. The Prime Minister admitted when Mr. Thorneycroft resigned that there were difficulties. They were able to get over their difficulties. Earlier than that, you had Dr. Dalton resigning as Chancellor of the Exchequer. Therefore, you do not necessarily have stability of Government with the straight vote and the single member constituency. What would happen to-morrow morning if it were known that the Minister for Finance, Dr. Ryan, had resigned because the Government wanted to incorporate something in the Budget with which he did not agree? Would it not give rise to a first-class Government crisis? Everybody would think the Government was at an end. At any rate, at one time the Taoiseach was of the opinion that P.R. gives a certain amount of stability.
Comment on this
That has been repeated very often. Might I draw the attention of the House to the fact that there are certain well-known rules of parliamentary procedure and conduct and I think Senators ought to have some regard for those rules from now on?
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned, I have the utmost respect for law and order in general and, in particular, for the rules of order in relation to debate in this House.
Comment on this
The Senator knows that under Standing Orders repetition is not permitted.
Comment on this
I am aware of that and I have no intention of repeating myself. With every respect, I have not repeated myself in these quotations. The Taoiseach further said:—
". . . on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties."
These are the points we are trying to make in the course of this debate in support of P.R. We want fair representation of Parties and not the ridiculous kind of system the Minister for External Affairs has suggested under which 1/50th of the votes could command representation.
"I understood when I was in opposition that this whole principle of P.R. was being threatened, and I was rather anxious here that we would ensure in the Constitution a reasonable basis for P.R."
There, we must part company with the Taoiseach. He did not provide us with a reasonable basis for P.R. inasmuch as he tied us to a particular system. But I am quite prepared to vote for the system we have—the system we know! We know the amount of protection it gives us. I am prepared to vote for maintaining it as against adopting a system that has never been tried out here under native Government.
At column 1353 of the same volume the Taoiseach had this to say about P.R.:—
"I think we get, probably in this country more than in any other country, better balanced results from the system we have. If you take the countries where P.R. exists you get better balanced results than you get in other countries."
Apparently history has changed and you never did get better balanced results in the countries which had P.R. as against the countries which did not have it.
This reminds me of a book written by the late George Orwell, 1894 in which he forecast that the Communist would rewrite history in the light of subsequent events in order to correct any mistakes that had been made. We had that recently in Soviet Russia. In a publication similar to the Encyclopaedia Britannica published in Russia Stalin was given many pages, all devoted to praising him for his work for the Soviet Republic. After his death, when he was denounced by Khrushchev at the Twentieth Congress, they set about rewriting Stalin's biography. In 1937 P.R. had been abolished in Italy. Mussolini was in power. P.R. had been abolished in Germany. Hitler was in power. We have the Taoiseach agreeing apparently now that Fascist Italy was far better off than Italy under P.R. I do not think any sane person could agree that it was better to have Mussolini and World War II rather than the kind of Government there would have been in Italy had P.R. continued there.
Comment on this
In what I can only describe as a rather astounding performance, the Minister for External Affairs this evening said that the Party to which I belong, Fine Gael, have never been very receptive of new ideas. I hope he did not mean to infer that what is now being done is something new, because I think the general impression given to the House from the Fianna Fáil Benches is that we are taking a step backwards and that what we are doing is really retrograde. It is an old system of election which we are going back to and we are leaving behind us a system of election of which we have been proud for the past 40 years. We shall all be very sorry if this change is made.
The section we are discussing deals with reducing the size of the constituencies to afford representation by one elected candidate, and discharging the transferable vote to use the non-transferable vote. I wonder will that system produce a better Deputy in Dáil Éireann? Senator Lenihan said he thought under the new system we would get better types into Parliament. I do not think we will. You will get better electioneers, men who are able to catch votes more effectively. As everyone in this House knows, the best public representative is not the man who is the best vote-catcher. Vote-catching is a completely separate department but we have known all our lives that many men who are expert at it are completely tongue-tied and useless when they come to discuss legislation in this or the other House.
What is more, the people who are better than average—I have to go outside our own Parliament because it would be invidious to quote names here—men like Mr. Nicholson of Bournemouth and Mr. Montogomery Hyde in the North of Ireland—are men whom it is very unusual to find elected under the straight vote system. They always tend to be in the minority in their thinking and they are not any the less valuable for that.
As was said earlier this evening by one of the Government Senators, Senator Sheehy Skeffington has always been in a minority. In many ways, that was a very considerable tribute to Senator Sheehy Skeffington because, very often, such men are the salt of the society they live in.
One thing you are doing, when you confine the constituencies to one man and essentially to one Party candidate, is taking a choice from the electorate and, in taking that choice, you are taking something valuable, something which was making a contribution to the quality of the Oireachtas. You will provide the docile T.D., the docile man, the man who comes to heel, and these are not the most useful men to have in Parliament; but that, apparently, is what you want. You want a Party of docile men, a big Party with a very small group opposing them. You will not, of course, maintain the balance because eventually the pendulum will swing and when it swings the Party taking over will take over with a big group of docile men behind it. You are closing the door on the thoughtful man, on the slightly intransigent person, who does not belong to any Party but makes every Party produce in the end the best Government.
We have been talking a lot about minorities. The Government must admit that the minorities must do better under the old system, but it is just funny to think that a member of, say, a religious minority could get himself adopted by one of the large Parties in any of the constituencies where there is only one seat. It is cynical to talk about it. Even inside the Party itself, there is a kind of mental minority that you are going to discard and lose. It may not matter next year, or the year after, or even the year after, but it will make a difference in 20 years' time. You are establishing forever the power of the Party. Do Senators think that is a good thing to do? I disagree.
As I said on the Second Reading, I do not know what is wrong with the idea of Government by agreement, why different groups cannot agree to govern and adjust their points of view. You want to stop that. You want to do in public life what you cannot do in your private life. The result, of course, in the long run, will be what you have pretty well got now. As I said before, you can change the results of a game temporarily by changing the rules, but it is only a temporary gain and eventually you will lose. The Irish people will stand for it for a short time, perhaps for one or two elections, but after a short time you will find that you have taken an extremely dangerous step.
I am afraid I must say the whole thing is just a temporary solution for what I can only call imminent Fianna Fáil difficulties. If you make promises and fail to keep them, you do not want to face the electorate on the basis where they can punish you most effectively. It is a cynical diversion and it will not cure anything in this country. It will solve none of our problems and it will be spoken of very contemptuously by the man who walks up the gangway of the emigrant ship.
A humorous periodical is published in Dublin and, in this month's number, I see a cartoon of the Taoiseach imitating Rowan Hamilton writing on the wall: "Fianna Fáil - P.R. = Fianna Fáil +." I agree there is a great deal of truth in that. You are just naked and unashamed about what you are trying to do and I would have much more respect for the Taoiseach and the Government if they did not try to justify it as sound national policy, which it is not. It is a temporary advantage for Fianna Fáil but not for Ireland.
An American Minister some years ago had the same kind of idea. He thought what was good for General Motors was good for America. He was discarded, and Fianna Fáil will be discarded eventually, and discarded much more effectively because they have made the pendulum take too wide a swing. They are reducing the standard deliberately and they will pay for it because they are deliberately trying to suit their Party's imminent position. They should not be pious about it and, above all, they should not say that we are trying to stop people from expressing their views because we must have a referendum and Fianna Fáil should not try to make a virtue out of that.
Comment on this
This section deals with the substitution of the multi-member constituency by the single member constituency. Senator Mullins gave us quite an interesting talk last night as to how the British system of election worked in Britain. He did not bring us a little nearer home and show us how this British system of election worked in a part of Ireland.
Comment on this
I notice the Senators opposite do not like it when I mention what happens under the British system of election in the northern part of Ireland, because there we have seen that instead of the single member constituency and the non-transferable vote building up an Opposition which will eventually replace the Government, we see it puts into power a Party which shows no indication whatever of being moved out of office.
Comment on this
That still does not answer the point that you have shown how this system works in Britain. You do not like having it pointed out that it works in a part of Ireland, namely, in the Six Counties.
Comment on this
I might at this stage once again appeal to Senators, on both sides, to have some regard to the dignity of this House.
Comment on this
The single member constituency in the British system of election has shown us that in Northern Ireland a Government is in power with an overwhelming majority, contemptuous of any minorities, of other Parties, and apparently riveted in power for all time. Senator Mullins also told us what happened the Labour Party in Great Britain, and how they eventually came to power under the system of election in operation there. I think he was trying to convince us that with that system in operation here the Labour Party could expect the same type of progress.
Comment on this
The Labour Party has a policy, but now is not the time to talk about it. I hope we will try to convince Senator Mullins of that on another day.
Comment on this
I want to correct the Senator. He did not give the interpretation which I gave. I said the Labour Party could expect the same here in due time if they had a policy.
Comment on this
If I may answer that interruption, the Labour Party have a policy and I will speak to Senator Mullins about it later. Now is not the time for me to do that as I, at least, want to be in order in spite of other Senators not making very much effort in that direction. The fact of the matter is that this part of Ireland is largely an agricultural country. We have not here the concentration of industrial workers that there is in, Britain so that, therefore, there is not the same scope for an industrial Labour Party as there is in Britain. Senator Mullins, however, suggested that we should be more socialist and he implied that if we were more socialist in our viewpoint we could expect greater support from the ordinary electors.
I do not know whether I can convince Senator Mullins that the Labour Party is a democratic Party, and if he likes to come in to play his part in shaping the policy of the Labour Party to a more socialist angle—if that is what he wishes—he is welcome to come into the Party to do that. I now understand why he likes to wear a red tie, and it suits him as well as it suits the Minister here. The fact of the matter is that the Labour Party believes in justice and it believes in its own right to be dealt with justly. Neither the Taoiseach, the Minister, nor indeed any spokesman from Fianna Fáil, has accepted the point that I made on Second Reading, namely, that no majority have a right to do a wrong to a minority.
We have a Constitution as a whole, adopted by the people, and an integral part of it is the P.R. system of election, but now it is proposed to tear that out and, in doing in so, it is proposed to do an injustice to a minority. Senator Stanford has spoken about religious minorities and I am talking about a political minority because, whether we like it or not, we in the Labour Party are a political minority at the moment. We are the third political Party in this country and, if the majority of the people approved of this change in the Constitution, that would be doing a wrong to a minority. They would be depriving the Labour Party and the industrial arm of the trade union movement of representation in Dáil Éireann.
It is useless brushing that aside. That is the fact of the matter and Senator Quinlan pinpointed it last night when he showed what would happen in Cork City under this new system of election, if it were approved by the people. Indeed, I have intimate knowledge of that. I know that my trade union have never been without representation in Dáil Éireann in the sense that one of our members has always been a Deputy in the Dáil. He has not represented our trade union in that sense, but he has been there to assist our trade union in legislation affecting our members. Since the earliest years of the Dáil Deputy Bill Davin was there, a member of my union, and for a time he was joined by Deputy Martin O'Sullivan. Now those two people, having contributed their share to building up the State, have passed on and Deputy Seán Casey is there but, under the new system, the Labour Party cannot expect to have any representative in Dáil Éireann. I say that is an injustice to a minority and, no matter what majority approves of it, it is still an injustice.
In regard to the type of representative we might expect, let us look at the figures of the last election. I have referred to Cork City, and Senator Quinlan has shown that in Cork City at the moment there are three Fianna Fáil Deputies, one Fine Gael and one Labour Deputy and that, with the introduction of the single member constituency in that particular area, we can expect, if the votes are left as they are, that instead of three Fianna Fáil and two Opposition Deputies we would have five Fianna Fáil Deputies.
I have been looking at the position in Dublin City. In Dublin City at the moment there are 12 Deputies representing Fianna Fáil, seven representing Fine Gael and five others, including Labour and Independents. I have taken out the first preferences that have been cast for Fianna Fáil in the various Dublin City constituencies and I find that out of a total of 173,000-odd first preferences Fianna Fáil had nearly 76,000. In other words, about 44 per cent. of the first preferences went to Fianna Fáil. But if Dublin City were carved up into single member constituencies it is very probable that, instead of 12 Fianna Fáil and 12 others, you would have 24 Fianna Fáil Deputies from Dublin City. That is the position on the assumption that votes are left as they are, that the Fianna Fáil vote will stay largely as it is. Even though it is a minority vote in Dublin City, less than the aggregate vote for Fine Gael, Labour and Independents, it would secure all the seats.
We all have experience of how political loyalties are based in this country. If a family took one side in the civil war, pro-or anti-Treaty, the tendency is to stay with that particular viewpoint and to support the political Party that took a particular side at that time. I know there are exceptions. I know you will find that perhaps one son or daughter in a family will take a different viewpoint apart from the family tradition. I find that usually such people who so depart are even more extreme on the other side than the people who took a decision when there was a split on the Treaty. That is the basis of our political organisation in this country, unfortunately.
We had some hope that we would depart from that sort of loyalty, that political division, as we progressed and as year followed year but, if we will have this new system of election with two Parties, Fianna Fáil and another Party, possibly Fine Gael at the moment, with those two Parties, the basis will largely be the old basis of the civil war—anti-Treaty or pro-Treaty. That is unfortunate.
Senator Barry made the very relevant point that this can be very dangerous. I am sure Fianna Fáil have totted up the figures. They are not doing this blindfold. They know that if they can hold on to the Fianna Fáil vote which, I think, they can, largely because of the family tradition of anti-Treaty, as it is, they can expect to have an overwhelming majority in Dáil Éireann under this new system. But if there was a swing, what would you find? You would have a complete swing and you would have a Dáil elected then with an overwhelming majority of a Party which had a very small number in the previous Dáil. In other words, you would have a body of inexperienced Deputies going into Dáil Éireann and a number of Ministers inexperienced in parliamentary affairs taking over ministerial responsibilities. I do not think that is a good way of conducting Parliament.
I oppose the section because, as I say, it attempts to do an injustice to a minority. It is no answer for Fianna Fáil speakers to say that Labour can get representation with Fine Gael or enter into bargains with Fine Gael. We are entitled to our own viewpoint. Whether you agree with it or not, we still are so entitled, but what will the position be if the people are misguided enough by Fianna Fáil and their propaganda to change the present system of election and to wipe out Labour representation in Dáil Éireann? What will be the reaction of the organised trade union movement which at the moment has a political arm? I should certainly like it to be more effective and I hope it will be more effective but, as it is, there is a political arm of the trade union movement.
What will the trade union movement do if that political arm is cut off? They will have to look elsewhere. How will they react? We have had no experience in this country of what is known as the political strike. The only sort of action we have had by groups of workers on political affairs was in regard to the national struggle where, in my own vocation, it was a question of transporting the armed forces of the Crown and where the people of the railway said they would not drive the engines; where it was a question of importing arms and, again, when the organised workers took action in support of the prisoners on hunger strike in Mountjoy. That is the only experience, away back in the past, of what I would call the political strike but if you take away the political arm, the political representation of the trade union movement in Dáil Éireann, inevitably they will have to look for some other weapon. I would hate to see that happen.
Indeed, some of my colleagues argue—and I think rightly—that such a development would probably give a stronger weapon to the trade unions than seeking representation in Dáil Éireann. In other words, when the trade unions want to advocate some general improvement for their members, some legislation of assistance to their members or for the underprivileged people in the community, instead of having the Labour Party advance that policy or speak about it and advocate it in Dáil Éireann, the trade unions would use industrial action; that there would be nationwide strikes maybe of one day or two days, the sort of strike that has happened in other countries and which I certainly would not like to see happen here. I warn the House, not in any threatening fashion at all, that it is inevitable, if you take away political representation of the trade union movement, the Labour movement in Dáil Éireann, they will have to seek other weapons.
Comment on this
I am sorry Senator Lenihan was not listening. I do not think that would be a good thing. It would be very bad for this country and for democracy but I think, with our present basis of political Parties, that if you intervene and take away P.R., if you have the single seat constituency and if you have Deputies elected on a minority vote, as they will be, then you are, in effect, destroying democracy in this country.
I mentioned Dublin City. I showed the House the figures in the various Dublin constituencies. Fianna Fáil have less than 44 per cent. of the first preferences in the various Dublin City constituencies but if you divide those into single member constituencies then in all those constituencies, even though Fianna Fáil are still a minority, they can expect to get their candidates in because Fine Gael will put up a candidate, Labour will put up a candidate and, perhaps, the Independents and Sinn Féin because the Opposition will be divided into various sectors.
We might be asked why do we not make a bargain. I have answered that. We will not do that. We are an independent political Party and will not merge with Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or with anybody else. Before it is too late, can Fianna Fáil think again about this matter? It may give them a great deal of power in the next Dáil. It may choke them with power but it certainly will be very bad for democracy and the country.
Comment on this
I rise again because some of my remarks have been very much misconstrued. As well as that, several Senators, including Senator Lenihan, have asked for greater amplification of some of the points I have made. The first point I want to get quite clear is that neither I nor any of the university Senators have at any time deprecated political Parties. We approve wholeheartedly of them. I am delighted to see young men of any walk of life going into the political Parties and I only hope they go into all the Parties. However, we feel we have a different rôle to play, in that, due to being in the university, we are placed in a position of independence where we are expected to speak our minds and if we are worthy of the university tradition we shall speak our minds without fear or favour. That is the hallmark of a university. It is the reason why in all totalitarian States the first organ to be brought under the control of the Government is the university. Independent thought and action must be squashed until the thought that is appropriate to the ruling Party can come forth. That is what has happened in Russia, in Hungary and all over the world.
Much of the ill-directed criticism that is made here has the same mentality behind it, the mentality that does not understand the necessity for clear and impartial judgment. I shall present facts and it is up to other Senators to contradict them by facts if they can. We can and do make mistakes, but we shall strive to be worthy of our tradition and of the university we represent.
That is the spirit in which my colleagues and I have considered this Bill. We resent ill-founded criticism to the effect that because we take a different line from that of the Government we have become more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves. We shall criticise Fine Gael in the same way as we criticise this Government, and I hope they will take it in a better spirit than it has been taken by the Government side.
The overall judgment of a Government must be made on the basis of how it caters for its population, whether we have three seat or one seat constituencies, whether we have a single Party Government or a Coalition Government. I am sorry and loath to say that, judged by these standards, we have to hang our heads as a result of our period of self-government. It is true we have done a good deal but it is nothing like what we had hoped to do or what we could have done had we pulled together.
While I do not wish to get into any political controversy, one simple fact that has been overlooked in condemning Coalition Governments and condemning the 1948 Government is that Mr. MacBride did everything possible to get a National Government formed at that period, a Government that would grapple with our unemployment, emigration and other major problems. Does anybody tell me that if a National Government had been formed it could have left a worse record behind it than we have to-day with 200,000 people gone in the five years from 1950 to 1955, and with the number increasing? Surely that in itself is an absolute confession of failure and brings out the necessity for re-thinking by our Party and the necessity for common action. As Irishmen we all have a stake in this country and we should be determined to make something of the country. The inter-Party Government of the period to which I referred gave us some of the most valuable members we ever had. We all acknowledge the excellent work of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass——
Comment on this
We do, as university representatives, but we also acknowledge the excellent work done by the former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, and by Mr. MacBride. During that period I was proud of the brilliance and of the behaviour of Mr. MacBride as our distinguished Minister for External Affairs. I would make bold to say that he has been our best Minister for External Affairs and the proof of it is the many times since he left office he has been asked back to serve on commissions in other countries. I have also been proud to listen to the splendid, Christian approach of Deputy Cosgrave in his period of office as Minister for External Affairs. I heard him speak at the inter-Parliamentary Union at which he made the finest Christian speech that was ever made in that assembly.
In this debate I do not wish to deal with the happenings associated with our present foreign ministry, but I hope to take that up at great length on the Central Fund Bill at the end of this month. Those events are a slur on our national name. I could have hung my head in shame all during my stay in America in September and October. That is something on which a referendum could be held and on which the people would give you an answer.
Comment on this
The Senator is now becoming irrelevant. Will he now come to the sub-section?
Comment on this
It was only a passing reference and I come now to the sub-section, to the merits of the single seat constituency as against the multi-seat constituency and the merits of the straight vote, which has been described in glowing terms by the Taoiseach. He said it is a straightforward method but that above all it has the advantage of simplicity. That is a big commendation. Let us see how this simple system works.
Comment on this
The Senator will remember that it is Section 2. 1º that is under discussion.
Comment on this
Yes, the section in the Bill dealing with multi-seat constituencies as against single seat constituencies and its effect in representing the views of the population as a whole. We have the figures from the British general election in 1945 and I appeal to everybody to analyse these figures. In the 1945 election in England 487 people out of every 1,000 voted Labour, that is, slightly under half, and they got five out of every eight seats. They got a total of 393 seats. There is no objection to that. Five years afterwards Labour got 463 out of every 1,000 votes, losing 24 votes out of every 1,000 or two in every 100; yet their number of seats dropped from 393 to 315. But listen to what is coming. A year afterwards they went to the electorate, gaining 23 votes in every 1,000, which brought them back almost to their 1945 position with 486 votes out of every 1,000. In 1945, they had 487 votes in every 1,000, a difference of one vote per 1,000. Yet, in 1945 they got 393 seats, and in 1951 they got 304 seats and were defeated. Can anybody call that an honest system or a simple system? Can anybody suggest for one moment it is fair that the same vote which put in an overwhelming Labour Government in 1945, should put them in Opposition in 1951? Surely that is not a fair system. You cannot describe it as a simple system. In fact, you might call it a crooked system, if you called it anything, because there is such distortion of the views of the electorate.
In 1931, the coalition Parties in England, the Liberals and Conservatives, for 14,500,000 votes got 554 seats, and the Labour Party Opposition, for half that number of votes, for 7,000,000 votes, got 61 seats. It took almost five times as many votes to elect a Labour member to the House as it took to elect a Government member. Is that the type of distortion we want? If it is, why not pick out the names of Deputies from the sweepstakes drum in Ballsbridge? Yet the Taoiseach said, and I quote again, "It is a simple method." Yes, it is a simple method in that you only have to put down an "X". It does not matter whether you are literate or illiterate, you can make an "X". But he says it is a straightforward system. Straightforward, where there is even a greater lottery than there is in the sweepstake, where for the same vote in one election you get 393 seats and in the next you get 304. Remember, that is the Frankenstein monster brought into Irish political life by this change from the multiple member constituency to the single member constituency. Senators may think it is bad in England, but it is nothing compared to what it can be here if ever the misfortune happens that this Bill is passed. Here we do not have those tied seats that they have in England. It was the tied seats that were given to the few Labour representatives in 1931. Is it any wonder we say here, with your system of divide and conquer, that if the voting were the same as at the last election, there would be at least 120 Fianna Fáil Deputies returned and less than 20 Opposition Deputies?
Where are you going with such a system? Remember, it could work against you the time after just as well as it can work for you the next time. Certainly, that is the very antithesis of stability. Remember, in 1931, in England, the country was tidied up, like the Taoiseach wishes, into neat divisions. On the one hand was the Conservative and Liberal Coalition, and on the other the Labour Party. So, the electors were faced with only two names in each constituency. Yet you see the appalling result: four and a half times or five times as many votes were required to elect a Labour man as to elect a member of the Coalition. Is that what you want here? Do you want to ask the Irish people to introduce a system by which you can get a Fianna Fáil Deputy elected for one-fifth of the votes it takes any other Deputy to get elected?
I think it is about time we were getting some little bit of understanding of the Six-County system. We should call this straight vote what it is: it is the Belfast system we are introducing here.
Comment on this
Let us see how the Belfast system works. According to a Government spokesman, Senator Ryan, 60 per cent. of the people in Northern Ireland are Unionists, and Senator Ryan accuses us of distorting the facts when we give the results of the last election there: 39 members out of 52 for the Unionists—75 per cent. of the total seats—and a handful, 13, for the Opposition.
Comment on this
I shall come to that. In other words, it takes at least twice as many votes to elect a member of the Opposition in Belfast as it does to elect a member of the Unionist Party. I say at least twice because, of that 60 per cent. of Unionists, some of them are supporting Opposition candidates—they are supporting the Unionist Labour candidates. So I ask in all sincerity—this is another straight question for a straight answer from the Minister for External Affairs—do you endorse this system in Northern Ireland, by which twice as many votes are required to elect a Nationalist or a Labour member as are required to elect a Unionist; or do you say it is unfair to our people across the Border?
Now, to come to Senator Lenihan's little L. and H. debating point, where he says you cannot compare, because the change over took place in 1929. I think the Taoiseach should send his congratulations, at least posthumously, to Lord Craigavon as the first man who got away from this frightful P.R. system and learned how to control minorities. Take the figures for the 1925 general election in Northern Ireland, as given in Professor Hogan's book. The Unionist Party, including the Independent Unionists—and they really should not be lumped together with the Unionist Party because under the straight vote they are enemies of the Unionist Party proper, as are Sinn Féin—but, conceding that, in 1925, we get 33 members elected for the Unionists out of 52, that is about 65 per cent. In the following election in 1929, under the Belfast voting system, we get 37 between Unionists and Independent Unionists. So, they went up from 33 to 37. You say that is immaterial. What are four seats in 52, or, referring to our Parliament here, what is a mere ten seats? We have seen Parties glorying in election success here with far less than a gain of ten seats. In fact, Fianna Fáil have not oscillated much more than ten seats during their period. Anyway, the Unionists' share went up by four in 1932, about 12 per cent.
Comment on this
The figures are right here before me and Senator Lenihan will get his chance. Those figures, you might say in a rough generalisation, did not appear to make much difference at that period, a few seats, three or four. But see the record of the Unionist Party ever since! It went from 34 seats to 39 in 1938 and to-day it is 39. Here is a straight question and I want a straight answer to it: Does the Minister for External Affairs think that this continued support for the Unionist Party, this growth from 33 seats up to 39 and staying steadily at 39, is a tribute to the excellence of the Government that the Unionist Party have given to the Six Counties in that 30 years?
Comment on this
I want a straight answer to a straight question. Let us analyse the facts again. Nowhere else in the world has there been a Government remaining in undisputed power since 1922, in other words 37 years of undisputed power, and yet our political Parties and Ministers wax eloquent on the failings, faults, injustices and the gerrymandering and everything else associated with that Government. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot approve of the system and say the results are right and proper and at the same time say that the North has the worst Government in the world and the most unfair Government for the past 30 years.
Comment on this
Would the Senator answer a straight question?
Comment on this
No, it is simply a question I would like to ask.
Comment on this
If Senator Quinlan wishes to give way, the Senator may ask the question.
Comment on this
I do not mind; I have nothing to fear from any question.
Comment on this
Will the Senator answer this question? Is it not impossible from the day the British imposed Partition on the Six Counties to have a change of Government?
Comment on this
No, Sir, not for one moment. If we concede that, we might as well forget about Partition. I was just coming to these facts which would make the Senator's question altogether unnecessary. If we had P.R. in the Six Counties, just as in every other country we would have the rise of a Labour Party which would have as one of its essential ingredients opposition to the existing Government, the Unionists. After a few years they would begin to trade—I shall not use the word "trade"—they would begin to exchange No. 2 and 3 preferences with the various other Nationalist Parties because at least the Nationalists would prefer to give No. 2 votes to the Labour Unionist Opposition than to the Unionist Party in power. I take it nobody disputes that point.
We take also the business of creating a multiplicity of small Parties. Actually, the Belfast vote has done that because once a man deviates from the Party he has either to go into exterior darkness or he has to go up as an Independent. What have we to-day? We have as many as four different Labour candidates contesting seats in some of the Northern constituencies in past elections. These are as much enemies of one another on election platforms as they are of the Unionists proper. If they had P.R. there, while those people would differ from one another just as National Labour and the Labour Party differed here in the 1940's, still they would be Labour first, just as I hope all of us here are Irish first. They would be Labour first, and would pass their No. 2 or No. 3 votes to other members of the Labour Party, and so breaches would be healed and there would be no great loss in the overall effectiveness of the votes. These would combine; they would have increased their strength and eventually the day would be reached—in fact I think it would have been reached by now, but for the war —where the stage would be set for an inter-Party Government to displace the Unionist Government in Belfast. In that inter-Party Government the Nationalists would be offered a part and they would take their place in it.
Comment on this
Of course they would not be able to carry out their complete programme. They would have to work out an agreed programme with Unionist Labour. They would get down to the business of running the Government and after three, or four, or five years of that in the North the ordinary, decent working members, the non-Catholic members who dread this "Catholic monster", would see that after all "these Nationalists", "these Catholics" are not such bad fellows and that they are able to co-operate just as Labour and Fine Gael co-operated here to their undying credit. That would create a new feeling, a feeling that co-operation with Catholics was possible. Remember that is the main barrier to ending Partition, this feeling of distrust that Protestants have of co-operating with Catholics. It can only be broken, first of all, within the Six Counties itself and the straight vote or, as we should call it, the Belfast vote has seen to it that that is not possible either at local or national levels.
I sincerely ask Senators across the House if they do believe in ending Partition to think over this seriously——
Comment on this
——and I will be very interested to hear Senator Lenihan try, in his best court-room manner, to refute my arguments.
Comment on this
I hope he will be able to refute my arguments without throwing too many bouquets to the Unionist Party although I suppose a few bouquets from him after all that has been said in the past year might go some distance towards softening the Unionists.
So much for Northern Ireland. We now come to a matter that was treated as a huge joke, the referendum in the British Cameroons. In fact, one member thought I was talking of the system of Government there. That just shows the attention that is given to the debates and it shows the closed type of mind that hears in what is said only what it wishes to accept. I was simply citing, to the credit of the high standard set by our representative, Mr. Kennedy, his address to a committee of the United Nations where he insisted that you should not confront the people of the British Cameroons with the question: Do you want black or white?, as our people are being confronted—
Comment on this
On a point of order. I would like to know the relevance of the British Cameroons to this debate?
Comment on this
It was raised by one of the Front Bench intellectuals over there, Senator Carter, and consequently I am entitled to show the misrepresentation that he put on my words.
Our representative insisted it was not sufficient to ask these people: Do you want to join with one country or stay as you are? They worked out four possibilities, including eventual independence as one. I have listed those before and I do not need to give them again. He insisted, and quite rightly so, that the people should be asked to select which one of those four was the most suitable to them, by being asked: "Which one do you approve of best?" They would have to use three or four figures —1, 2, 3, 4 to record their approval. Would it not be a grand thing, could you not say you were consulting the people, if you broke up this trick question into four parts, that is to say, if you put down: "Do you approve of the multi-membered constituency or do you not?" And again: "Do you approve that the constituencies be reduced still further, that no constituency should have more than three seats?" And again: "Do you think we should introduce the single seat constituency but with the transferable vote?" And finally: "Do you think we should introduce the single seat constituency with the non-transferable vote—the Belfast system?" If you wish to be fair to the people, you would have given them that choice, but you are not, you are just giving them this trick question: "Do you approve of one system as an alternative to the other?"
Comment on this
It is only fair that the North should be honoured by the name of their system, that it should be called "the Belfast system", because after all they were the first people in the world to break away from this monster P.R. Why did they break away from it? Ask Lord Craigavon. He cannot be here now.
Comment on this
The most valuable case which has been made against the proposed change, the most valuable contributions in that regard, have come from the Government side of the House, including those of the Minister for External Affairs. They are the most quotable, on the question of the commission, showing how they just do not want to give the facts to the people, showing how cynical has been the charge against us here that we are preventing the people from having their choice, that we are standing in the way of the people. We are not; we are demanding that, first of all, the people have full and adequate information which they can respect as being impartial. Secondly, we are asking that the referendum be put to to the people in an intelligent and simple form. We are "simple minded people" here, if we quote the Taoiseach; "the simple method appeals to us" in a direct question. Nothing could be more indicative of the whole project than the direct question which has been formulated for our people.
Above all, there is the cynical talk of "appealing to the people" and "letting it go to the people".
Comment on this
Did you ever hear the other exponents of the straight vote, those who have taken the straight vote to its logical conclusion, where there is only one Party? Did you ever hear the leaders of Russia and Hungary talk about "the people"? They would not go out of this room without "consulting the people"—and they would get a 99.9 per cent. majority on every question they put to the people.
Comment on this
I mentioned some of the excellent work done by the members of the inter-Party Government and in the same breath I mentioned some of the work done by Fianna Fáil. As an outstanding example, I mentioned Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
I certainly repect and regard the Taoiseach for the figure he represents abroad.