We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Business. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Coiste (Atogáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 366–564 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

But I do not approve at any time of his "divide and conquer" policy here. Although he is the symbol of the Irish nation, of unity and everything else, I am sorry to say that at home here he has used it to keep us divided at all times; and I think that will emerge at the bar of history.

Comment on this

It is not far to the bar of the polls, anyway.

Comment on this

As an indication I gave the contribution of Deputy Norton in his six-year period, which is recognised as a sound and valuable contribution by all of us. Deputy Norton in that period earned the respect of all people who value this country. It was a courageous, intelligent and fine effort to take on and carry on an alternative Government. It would have been far better at that period had the suggestion of Mr. MacBride been listened to and had we got a National Government which would have tackled our grave problems of unemployment and emigration and which would have put everybody to work to solve those problems. That I think was the glorious opportunity missed.

I put many questions. I put some to the Minister for External Affairs, but he does not seem to have got them very well, so I had better repeat them. You had a strong majority between 1933 and 1938; you commanded a solid majority in Dáil Éireann; also, having abolished the Seanad, you had no opposition there, either. Therefore, would you tell us what measures you were prevented from carrying out during that period by the fact that you did not have another 50 seats, measures which would have been beneficial to the country from that on? Again, in the 1939-44 period, when you had, in effect, almost a Coalition, where you had the loyal support of all the Opposition Parties during that period, where we recognised that we were all in a fairly perilous situation with the war round our shores, when we began to feel at last that we were Irishmen all, and when political recrimination died down in that period, tell us what provision you made in that period for the years after the war?

Where was your emphasis on education? Where was your emphasis on getting the unemployed to work? Where was your emphasis on planning or building for the future? Where were the commissions sitting down to think and to plan for the future? Even England, in her war-torn condition, saw that there was a future over the horizon and she got on with her planning, despite the fact that the bombs were raining down on London. What were you prevented from doing in that period?

I come now to what I regard as the most critical period of all our existence, between 1945 and 1948, the period when we definitely missed our opportunity. In that period you had one of the largest majorities you ever had. Any more seats in the Dáil would not have been of any use to you. During that period I believe that our whole future was lost.

Comment on this

It is not lost yet.

Comment on this

During that period you released all restraint, so that we just ate and made merry, while the rest of the world had to carry on, on short rations, and put aside for the rebuilding of their countries. Had you kept the squeeze on at that period, no more a squeeze than they had in England at the period, had you got some——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not wish to restrict Senators, but I fear the Senator is going somewhat wider than he should. He should address his remarks to the Chair.

Comment on this

The point I want to make to the Minister is this: During that period, why did they not plan more for the future? Why did they not set the basis for a sound economic development?

Comment on this

The Budget of 1947 was an attempt to do that, but it was sabotaged.

Comment on this

The Supplementary Budget?

Comment on this

The introduction of the word "blackmail" in the House has been very bad. It is something we do not believe any Irish Party should be capable of.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes is responsible for it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

Indeed, he was.

Comment on this

The worst feature of all this proposed change is that by means of the single seat constituency, you force Parties to preelection pacts in every constituency and county. That, surely, is a type of bargaining that we should not introduce or debase our Irish political life with. As there are so few differences in policy, I do not see why we should resort to that. I do not see why we cannot have at least a minimum of three seats in which case any good man is certain of being returned.

The Government should show their sincerity to the electors by making honest arguments to the electors and not simply trotting out, as the Minister is trotting out again and again, silly ideas, such as "why not increase the size of the constituency so as to include all minorities, or why not have one constituency for the whole country"?

It is not we who propose to change the system; it is the Government. We are accepting the present system as it is. At least, we regard it as a workable system and one that has worked well. I personally—and I speak for my fellow-members in the universities —would welcome very sincerely a commission to examine our present system, to examine it dispassionately and carefully and to return its findings to the Houses of the Oireachtas from which they could be passed on to the Irish people in a properly-framed Referendum Bill.

There are many features of our Irish Government that we could, with profit, investigate and see if we could change for the better. For instance, there is the total lack of committee work. I remember four years ago, when we were on the Agricultural Institute business, we created almost a sensation by looking for the agricultural committees of the two main political Parties at the time. We found out afterwards that it was quite a job to scrape them together in both Parties.

Comment on this

That statement is not correct.

Comment on this

Very well. Can Senator Carter now give the names of the present members of the Fianna Fáil agricultural committee? Can we have a straight answer to a straight question?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think it is relevant on this debate.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator may know something about political science, but he knows nothing about Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must be allowed to continue his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

While we are talking about minorities, my friend, Senator Mrs. Dowdall, from Cork, made an excellent discovery two weeks ago. She found out that ½ per cent. minority in England had actually got 7 per cent. of the seats. That is taken from the report published in the paper. I see that under my question yesterday that figure was reduced to 3 per cent.

Comment on this

Whose question?

Comment on this

Furthermore, we got the information that that minority are the Jewish minority. They are members of political Parties but, in any case, they are the Jewish minority. So, under the Balfour vote in England, they have got six times what they would be entitled to on a proportionate basis. Cheers for the Balfour system!

What did we find here? I went to the Library and looked up how many members of the Jewish community there are in this country. According to the 1951 census, the figure is 3,930. There is one in about 800 of our population. Therefore, on the basis of fair play and on the Minister's minority approach, they should be entitled to one in 800. What do we find? Actually, they have got one member out of 147. In other words, they have six times their proportionate representation here, just as they have it under the Balfour system.

Comment on this

Because he is a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

I hope, then, the Government Party will drop such frivolities and trivialities from the case they make to the Irish people. I hope Senator Mrs. Dowdall will not repeat that puerile argument.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You can prove anything by mathematics.

Comment on this

I have given the mathematics. The Minister for External Affairs was trotting it out to us again to-day.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

"Trotting"?

Comment on this

I am not putting any emphasis on it here. I am saying that if you want to play with English figures, I have a figure here that you can play with just as well.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Hayes does not like the expression "kicked out" and I do not like "trotted out" or "trotting out".

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

There is nothing wrong with "trotting out". People are always trotting out.

Comment on this

It means producing things a second time.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Some people trot things out; others gallop away from them. It is quite simple.

Comment on this

In addition to the size of our constituency, we are holding for the present system until we get something better served up to us after an impartial commission. That is what we will ask the people to do—to stay put, to stay where they are until they have a better system to move to and know where they are going. If you are concerned with stability of Government—and Fianna Fáil have trotted out that argument again and again—it can be said without fear or favour that we have had the most stable government in the world, probably, in our 37 years here. That assertion cannot be denied.

If the Government are after stability, have they ever considered the effect of the by-election? We have seen two by-elections in Cork in recent years. I can say quite honestly that they were both equally unfair and unjust to the existing Government at the period. The campaign carried on against the inter-Party Government was matched only by the campaign carried on afterwards against the Fianna Fáil Government. They were both a disgrace to our intelligence and to our approach to national problems.

Comment on this

Pharisee, again.

Comment on this

If the Government are after stable government, if they want to keep their majority, why not consider the effect of by-elections? Why not consider putting into the Constitution the giving of power to the existing Government to fill any vacancy during their term of office?

Comment on this

It is a very democratic suggestion.

Comment on this

It is more so than your suggestion to disfranchise 49 per cent. of the people, or even more, in each constituency. It is a suggestion well worth considering.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think it arises under P.R.

Comment on this

So far as the case for holding the present system is concerned, until we know where we are going, I was challenged by Professor Lenihan earlier on——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Lenihan.

Comment on this

I must concede the title to the Senator seeing that he has been able to lecture all of us university professors on our duties and how we should present a fair and impartial case, according to his legalistic mind, which only sees one side at a time.

To pass from that point, if Senator Lenihan is worried that it might be undemocratic to fill by-elections during the period then he might compensate for that by reducing the life of the Government from five years to four, or to three years, or whatever term he thinks fit.

Comment on this

Every new moon.

Comment on this

In other words, the thing is not just black or white. There are not just the existing system and the system which the Taoiseach has found, on looking into his heart. These are not the only two systems. There are 300 variations of P.R. alone and we have worked out an Irish variation of it, one that has given us the utmost stability and sense of fair play between all Parties in its 37 years' existence. Yet it is proposed to give us a system that we have denounced again and again.

Senator Lenihan was rather worried. He could not take my figures that in the last election Fianna Fáil would have got at least 120 seats in the Dáil. He quoted a number of figures from West Cork and from East Cork. They were rather impressive figures. He said, for instance, that West Cork had only something like 9,300 votes out of a total of 26,000. In other words, the Opposition had 17,000, and he threw up his hands in horror and said: "How could Fianna Fáil possibly get a seat there?" He conveniently ignored what is regarded as being a principle in this Bill, the fact that the votes are to be non-transferable. He conveniently ignored that.

Let us have a look at West Cork and see what happened. Fianna Fáil had 9,300 votes, Fine Gael had 5,800 votes, Labour had 6,400 and the farmers 4,600, so we have got to get back to pre-election pacts. But the Irish people will not stand for pre-election pacts. They have not stood for pre-election pacts in Cork. Neither have the people in England stood for them except for a short period during the Conservative-Liberal coalition. Unless we want to corrupt political life and force these political pacts on the people we have to take the figures as they are and presume these Parties will contest and, on that basis, with less than one-third of the votes in West Cork, Fianna Fáil could very easily get the full three seats there.

Comment on this

Not if there was an anti-Fianna Fáil candidate.

Comment on this

There is no such thing as an anti-Fianna Fáil candidate. Again, in East Cork, in that period, there was more or less the same situation. In other words, this golden, Roman rule—divide and conquer—has now come back to Ireland and the instrument is to be the non-transferable vote. The one-seat is not by any means as democratic as the three seat, but the non-transferable vote is the measure of justice that has been inflicted upon the people in this Bill.

Comment on this

Of course, Fianna Fáil might get no seat. The Senator says that they might get three, but they might get none.

Comment on this

No. Senator Dowdall was rather worried about the future of Deputy Casey whom she and the Minister for Education regard as one of the outstanding young Deputies to come out of Cork in recent years. Where can he get a seat, on the figures of the last election? Fianna Fáil had 21,000, Fine Gael 11,000, Labour 6,000, and Sinn Féin 5,000. Where can you carve out the piece of Cork that will ensure a seat for Deputy Casey unless you insist that we must have all these pre-election pacts? If you insist on pre-election pacts do not act the hypocrite or the Pharisee and say that you are cleaning up political life when you are bringing corruption down to the lowest level. After doing that, and splitting the people, you suggest calmly that the person elected on this split will represent all the people of that constituency. Did anybody hear such a fairy tale in all his life?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How can we do that unless the people vote for the referendum?

Comment on this

The people, the people!

Comment on this

Do not be sneering at them.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They all cannot go to the university.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Quinlan should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

Now we shall look at a slight discrepancy. I was rather amused when I heard every virtue is to be associated with the Belfast system of voting. We will have absolute stability; we will have an Opposition that is ready to take over at any period; we will have absolute loyalty, attention and detail to the working of the constituencies and, above all, we will have a considerable increase in the stature and ability of the candidates. All of these fairy tales are being told to this House. I read in the Seanad Debates, at column 883, where the Taoiseach says:—

"Under the single member constituency system, it is quite obvious that an individual who is anxious to serve his particular community, and serve the nation, who is known to his particular community, and respected by it, will have a far better chance of being elected, as against any machine, than he would have under the present system."

There is no doubt whatsoever about that. That is the Q.E.D. at the end of it. There is a golden rule in lecturing: if you are trying to prove something and you cannot, you just simply flourish your hand and say: "It is obvious that——" That covers everything. That seems to be the Taoiseach's view as to what the single member constituency will do.

We have here a recent publication by Dr. Ross. He is an acknowledged specialist in this subject. His reputation is not for us to question since he is an acknowledged expert in his sphere. He has written many books on parliamentary representation. His latest major work, Elections and Electors, has brought him an international reputation. He is a man of standing. What has he to say about how this system works in England? Remember, we are glorifying it now.

Comment on this

Would the Senator be good enough to say who published it?

Comment on this

It is published by Pall Mall.

Comment on this

It is a partisan book published with financial assistance of Arthur MacDougall.

Comment on this

No scientist of Dr. Ross's standing would demean himself by being partisan, particularly in something that is outside his own country.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

On a point of order.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There is no point of order. The Senator will have an opportunity of replying.

Comment on this

I asked the Senator who published the book.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Ryan can put the question and Senator Quinlan can answer it, if he so desires, but it is a matter for Senator Quinlan, and it is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I submit, on a point of order, we are entitled to know exactly who published this book.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

When there is a quotation from a book the reference must be given.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Certainly —the reference. If there is any question of quoting, the reference must be given. The Senator has given the title and the author of the book.

Comment on this

The title of the book is The Irish Election System by Dr. J.F.S. Ross. It is published by the Pall Mall Press, London, and the price is 10/6.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is the full description.

Comment on this

Would the Senator say with whose financial assistance it has been published?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Why should young fellows sit in the front bench and be impertinent to people who have a perfect right to speak here? Senator Quinlan is a member of this House and he has a perfect right to speak.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

A perfect right. He was questioned and he has given the author of the book and the publishers of the book.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Now they want to cross-question him.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Quinlan is in possession.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think a most unfair insinuation has been made by Senator Hayes. If I caught what he said rightly, he said that people were especially selected to sit in the front bench and prevent Senator Quinlan from speaking.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is not exactly what I said. I will repeat what I said, if the Senator wants me to.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

What is the point of pursuing this?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The point is that I allege that Senator Hayes made a most unfair insinuation, if what I took him as saying is right. He said, in other words, that Senator Ryan and Senator Lenihan were specially selected to prevent Senator Quinlan speaking.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I did not say that, Sir.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What did the Senator say?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It does not matter. I will ensure that Senator Quinlan will make his speech just as I will ensure that every other Senator, irrespective of where he sits, will be permitted to make his speech.

Comment on this

In passing, I might remark that I am here in this House because I was asked—I did not seek nomination—by the Irish Engineers Association to stand as their candidate, to represent the graduates of the National University. Put in that way, I obeyed the call to come here and do whatever I could in this House. I am prepared to put work into my efforts. I am prepared to study. I am prepared to learn. I am prepared to have my opinions recorded and I am prepared to change those opinions when confronted with alternative facts which convince me.

Comment on this

Is the Senator prepared to give the facts about who published this book?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Lenihan must——

Comment on this

I did not say anything. I am a good boy.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Ryan must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The Senator may have the book.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

He already has the book.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has predicted all the virtues of the system in the quotation I have already given. The single seat constituency and the single non-transferable vote will give us absolute paragons in each and every constituency. Considering that the members of the Government hold that there will be such a radical change and such a radical improvement in the quality of future representatives, the only conclusion one can come to is that only very few of the sitting Senators and Deputies will contest the next election. I think that is a fair inference. Anyway the Taoiseach holds decided views about this marvellous improvement. This is what Mr. Ross says——

Comment on this

What he is paid to say.

Comment on this

It is not what he is paid to say. One does not say that about a scientist.

Comment on this

I challenge the Senator to read the front page.

Comment on this

That is a typical schoolboy retort.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Ryan must permit Senator Quinlan to make his speech without interruption. The Senator will have an opportunity of interpreting the story of Mr. Ross for the House in his own way later.

Comment on this

This is a quotation from Mr. Ross:—

"He"—that is, the thoughtful elector—"will certainly take into account the fact that the present Irish system leaves far more power in the hands of the electors, and far less in the hands of the Party machines, than does the British system."

It could not be put any more strongly.

Comment on this

It is a statement of fact.

Comment on this

His conclusion is borne out by The Economist, by Christopher Hollis and by all thinking men.

Comment on this

And by our own experience.

Comment on this

He goes on to say:—

"If he"—that is, the Irish elector—"regards the general run of electors with something like contempt, he may think that that is a point in favour of the British system:"

If he distrusts the voters he will want the Balfour system, but——

"if he distrusts the power of the Party machine, he will take the opposite view."

What brought Europe into two world wars? What brought Hitler to power? What brought Mussolini to power?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

P.R.

Comment on this

It was the Party machine gone mad. Is that the solution of our difficulties here?

Comment on this

If it was P.R., why did the Senator write it into the 1937 Constitution?

Comment on this

Again, I say that no number of pseudo- ex cathedra statements by the Taoiseach will convince anyone of the contrary. There is no doubt whatever about that. There is no use in the Taoiseach saying there is no doubt about his argument. I am prepared to give the argument advanced by Mr. Ross at least equal credence. He has lived under the British system.

There is certainly a case to be made. Let us ask independent, neutral people what they think. Let us ask them what is the power and the basis of the Party machine in England? Let us ask them why it is the Party machine there makes its selections a year or more before the actual elections? Let us ask them why they squeeze out independent-minded men? I have mentioned Hyde and Warnock, and this recent affair in Bournemouth. That is the kind of thing that happens under the single-seat non-transferable vote system of election. People with independent minds are simply not wanted.

Another point that must be considered in this context is the fact that we are surprised at the awful savages who got control of the machine in Germany. They were inhuman. They were beasts. No one could say other than that they were scarcely human. Their rise is very easily explained. The same thing has happened in Russia. The same thing has happened in Hungary. The question is: how do all these bad men come to the top? The answer is a simple one. As the standard of political life deteriorates the good element in the population takes the attitude: "We will have nothing to do with these. They are bad. Politics are bad; they are rotten. We will not be contaminated by them." They move out and a worse element moves in, and as things get worse still, more and more people get fed up with the Party machine. They move out, and finally we are left with the Hitlers, the Mussolinis, the Castros and others. These are the men the powerful Party machine throws to the top.

Comment on this

That is what you get with P.R.

Comment on this

One of the outstanding summings-up—though Senator Ryan does not like it; he thinks it is drivel—of what caused the decline of Germany or the decline of any country down from the Roman Empire, is ageing leadership—Party bosses, running the election machine. That, in a nutshell, is what brings about the downfall of systems.

Comment on this

That is what put President Eisenhower and Mr. Foster Dulles in power.

Comment on this

It is a feature of this ageing leadership and especially in democratic powers——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Dr. Adenauer and the Christian Democrats.

Comment on this

——that they have the feeling they are omnipotent and that the country cannot get on without them. You find a couple of Parties, be they Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil, which keep on squabbling between themselves and think they are the be-all and the end-all of the country, and suddenly a revolutionary Party comes up on the wing and sweeps the electorate before they realise anything is happening.

Comment on this

Why not, if they can do it?

Comment on this

Does the Senator want the Communist system here?

Comment on this

Will any body of people support them?

Comment on this

Including the Communist system?

Comment on this

Will the Irish people support them? They never will.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If Senators would not interrupt, we would get on much better.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He asked a question.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

He should not ask a question. Senators know very well we will get on much better if there are no interruptions.

Comment on this

Political sophistry.

Comment on this

That is a most revealing attitude of mind we have got from a man who may one day be a leading light in the Fianna Fáil Party —if the Irish people want a Communist Party, he is prepared——

Comment on this

This sort of sophistry is very wrong——

Comment on this

It is not sophistry.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

What is Senator Lenihan's point?

Comment on this

My point is that I did not say that. I said if a revolutionary Party got the support of the Irish people, they were welcome it.

Comment on this

The Senator used the word "communist".

Comment on this

Lord Castlereagh.

Comment on this

At no stage, did I use the word——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Quinlan accepts that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Why do people not want to have a debate in this Parliament?

Comment on this

Because you are political sophists.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Young Senators have come up to the Front Benches to be impertinent and to interrupt Senator Quinlan and prevent him from speaking.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is the very statement which Senator Hayes denied he made some moments ago and I object to it. There is no truth whatever in that statement.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

All I have to say from the Chair is that there have been too many interruptions from the Front Bench. There have been many more interruptions from the Front Bench than there were earlier to-day when it had other occupants. Senator Quinlan is in possession. Please let us not have any more interruptions.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I resent Senator Hayes's statement.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

They have come up specially.

Comment on this

We have Senator Lenihan saying in one breath that he thinks there will be a tremendous Fianna Fáil majority the next time, and in the next breath, that we will have a Communist Government.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now, now!

Comment on this

At no stage did I make any reference to a Communist Party getting into power with the support——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

If Senators did not interrupt, they could not be misrepresented.

Comment on this

The explanation is quite simple. The next time, if you have this "divide and conquer" Belfast voting system, you will have Fianna Fáil elected to a Dáil in which they will hold five-sixths of the seats. Then they will be tempted—power will go to their heads——

Comment on this

If the people want them.

Comment on this

——as it always goes to the heads of Governments in such circumstances. Power goes to their heads and the first thing has already been foreshadowed in the debates here. We will have the wonderful Belfast system introduced into our local elections. We will have the single seat constituency with the non-transferable vote brought down to the local elections. I challenge the Minister for External Affairs and ask him to give an undertaking that that is not so. Next, we will have——

Comment on this

They did it before and elected good men under it, and I remember, long before I was a member of a county council——

Comment on this

You want that system again?

Comment on this

What is Senator L'Estrange saying?

Comment on this

Some of them are pensioned, but for what I do not know.

Comment on this

Perhaps I can put a question to Senator Brady through the Chair. Does he want that system re-introduced here?

Comment on this

I saw it before and I saw where it elected the cream of the country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I have insisted in the past that we cannot carry on the debate by the process of question and answer. I will not have it.

Comment on this

To carry on with my explanation——

Comment on this

I do not wish to interrupt anybody here——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Please do not; permit Senator Quinlan to continue.

Comment on this

A certain gentleman interrupted me one night and if I got him outside the House, he would not do it again.

Comment on this

He told the truth.

Comment on this

He would not make that statement outside the House. I am in the House now, but I have good reason to know the source of it—a convicted slanderer. That is his source.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I shall have to name Senator Brady if he persists——

Comment on this

I shall tell the Senator the day and date of the I.R.A. court——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not want to name Senator Brady, but if he persists, I shall have to send for the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this

He got the truth.

Comment on this

To proceed— after this Government are elected, the next thing is that the Labour Party are driven out of political life and an extreme Socialist Party begins to emerge here. This Socialist Party links up quite naturally with the revolutionary side of our people. It may take ten or 15 years, but it is inevitable that we will have such a Government forced on us in the end, forced on us by our disregard for democracy in seeking to instal what is tantamount to a one-Party Government system——

Comment on this

Think of it!

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Q.E.D.!

Comment on this

At least Douglas Hyde, the well-known writer and ex-Communist, the man who is devoting his whole life to exposing Communism —and he is not a man whose opinions are to be taken lightly—is by no means certain that we cannot go Communist here. Ponder that, if you value this country as we and everybody else value it.

Comment on this

I have confidence in the Irish people.

Comment on this

To sum up—we believe replacing the multi-seat constituencies by the single seat constituencies is the wrong approach. It is making our Constitution the football of Party politics. Before any such approach is made, we should have had an impartial investigation by a commission which would have taken evidence from people, including the man most quoted here, Professor Hogan. I see the Government Party have dropped his name in the last few debates since they read his conclusions, and perhaps Senator Mullins would be good enough to place page two of the Sunday Press at the disposal of Professor Hogan to give his views to the general public before this referendum is held.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I have no connection whatever with the Sunday Press.

Comment on this

One must apply to the Taoiseach for that.

Comment on this

Well, then, we can apply to the Taoiseach, but if you have such respect for Professor Hogan, as I and every one of his colleagues have, you must know he is a man of the soundest views, a man of the highest integrity, and he is aghast at the present proposals. Any election has to provide two things. It has to provide a Government and it has to provide representation. A Government is provided once you get some clear majority, whether it is for a single Party or a coalition of Parties, a majority that will enable it to carry on and do the work. That is the first requirement.

The second requirement is that there should be proper representation in Parliament. The single seat constituency will do the first; it certainly will give us strong Government, almost as strong Government as they have in Belfast, and perhaps nearly as strong as the British gave us here during their period of rule, but strong Government does not necessarily provide stability. Under that system we will have this violent swing from one side to another, and violent swing always throws up a dictatorship, whether it is dictatorship of the right or dictatorship of the left. We are being asked to change from a system which is acknowledged to be the most stable political system in the world, a system well suited to our needs. The single Party system will not give us the representation we need. It will mean that Parties will go in and out of office and, when a Government changes, most of the leading members of that Government will go out. Under the three seat constituency, that is not so. Normally a Minister of an outgoing Government, if he has done a reasonably good job, is almost certain of re-election, and it may rightly be held that an ex-Minister in the Dáil is almost as valuable as a Minister in office.

That is the foundation upon which democracy is built, and we are going to sacrifice all that. We will get into these wild swings, this instability, this lack of representation and everything else, all for the sake that the Party Whips need not worry about a couple of their members being in hospital. They will always have 30 extra members to call upon. Surely that is not what a Government is for? In fact, a Government with a majority of five or ten, provided it does not have to face the hazards of by-elections and the unfair hazards introduced by them, should go its full term.

Comment on this

Put it in a glass case.

Comment on this

I was amused by some speakers who spoke about my references to the elections in 1933, 1938 and 1944, when I said they created no more disturbance than if the Ministers concerned had been out ill for a fortnight, or had taken a fortnight's holidays. That is what you have during an election campaign. The Ministers are away from their offices quite a lot, but that is the only change. The civil servants carry on and many believe they could carry on far better without the Ministers. Whether that is correct or not is another question.

Comment on this

Is this one last point?

Comment on this

The civil servants carry on and when the same Minister returns to his office he has not to begin and learn the job from the start, as if he were a member of a new team coming in. Such elections should not be classed as elections. It is puerile to class those with the tremendous political upheavals in England where the Conservatives are followed by Labour, where there is a whole policy of nationalisation practised for four or five years, and then the Conservatives come back in office again, trying to unscramble all that. That is not stability and is that what you want here?

When we come to judge other countries we have to insist that the only standard by which we can judge them is the standard of their performances. The population of Western Europe, since 1945, has increased 13 per cent. while ours has decreased. Who has been successful—the Governments of Western Europe or ourselves? They have recovered from the effects of a major war while we sat here and had little or no war damage to make good. The countries of Western Europe are crushed by the heavy burden of taxation caused by the armaments race. They very often live in fear, with Russia across their frontiers, and they have to devote a large proportion of their incomes to national defence. Here, we have no such commitments.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Has the Central Fund Bill already come to the Seanad from the Dáil?

Comment on this

Yet, we have criticised those Governments. They are only Coalition Governments whereas we have had, over most of that period, single Party, large majority Governments. Compare our results with theirs, and personally I would settle any time for the achievements of the Coalition Governments of Denmark, of Holland and of Sweden, than any Belfast system of election.

In fact I do not see that the North has made such comparable progress, under the Belfast system of election, that we should hold it up as an example. Coalitions are natural in those countries. The very divisions of their peoples order them. Labour, Conservatives, Liberals, Radicals, and all these people, are able to come together and do a workmanlike job. They have kept unemployment at a low level. They have expanded production and they have set standards about which we here are all the time preaching. How many times do we hear about what they do in Denmark and in Holland, but now the Minister thinks we should preach a crusade to those people to tell them they are living in sin—perhaps not living in sin—but are on the verge of a volcano, that they should get back from the edge, use the Belfast system of voting, and endeavour to put straitjackets on their political Parties to make them into two main groups.

The Minister forgets the trouble that Signor Fanfanni has in Italy, with his wings, to the left and to the right, and I presume that when the day of a united Ireland comes, as please God it will, the intention of the present Government would be that it should have its Unionist wing too—it should be everything to all men and we should still get back to a two Party system. But, whatever way we approach the solving of the Partition problem, we will not have just two Parties in Ireland after Partition is ended. We will have at least three or four Parties, and, please God, we will work together and work out the salvation of the country to the best of our ability.

Therefore, all this criticism of Coalition Governments is, I suggest, very ill-founded. It is as if government should be an end in itself, and that the majority a Taoiseach carried would be the only test to be applied to his strength. For two years we have had the strongest Government we ever had in this country, but what has been done? For two years we have been waiting for a farm apprenticeship scheme and where is it? It is not even mentioned in the White Paper.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator should not take us into that.

Comment on this

The Senator is tearing it.

Comment on this

We have listened to his drivel long enough.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister if Fianna Fáil had another 20 of a majority during the past two years would he have brought in a farm apprenticeship scheme that would give at least 40 or 50 farms each year to good, young men who would qualify to work them? Is it a lack of a majority in the Dáil that prevents him doing so? Does he believe he would do this with an increased majority under the Belfast system of election?

Comment on this

The Senator should tell us who will provide the land to do that.

Comment on this

I wish the Senator would interject more clearly so that I could hear what he says.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We do not want any interjections. I understand that Senator Mullins wants to make a statement to the House before it adjourns and I wish Senator Quinlan would keep that in mind.

Comment on this

To-day we were treated to suggestions that we should launch a crusade to the United States. I never heard such nonsense— I am sorry to use that word—brought into this debate by a senior Minister. I can only brand as nonsense the suggestion that the straight vote or the Belfast vote was the only thing we needed to have here to have the same as the American system and that the Belfast vote would work here in exactly the same way for stability as the Belfast vote works in America.

Comment on this

I would like to raise a point of order. I suggest it is out of order——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Oh, now.

Comment on this

I understand that is a point of order. I suggest it is out of order to repeat that this is the Belfast system. I think it is an insult to our intelligence to refer to it as such.

Comment on this

It is a Belfast system. We know that. We are trying to save you from yourselves.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan shifts his position. He called it the illiterate system.

Comment on this

It is suggested that it would act here like it acts in the United States. The United States have taken every precaution to ensure that democracy prevails in the United States.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator has repeated that about eight times.

Comment on this

I have done no such thing. I am repeating a little before summing up.

Comment on this

God help the students at U.C.C.

Comment on this

I think Senator O'Quigley did an excellent job earlier to-night. The point I want to make is this: If you want the American system here, that is all right. Give us the Belfast vote but give us a Senate that has real power and where one-third is elected each two years. Give us a House of Representatives elected every two years. Give us a President elected independently by the people and a President, above all, who can draw his Cabinet from the country as a whole.

Comment on this

That will bring the Senator in, I suppose.

Comment on this

There is much work I have to leave undone to attend here and it is not my own work, my teaching or research work.

Comment on this

The country is greatly indebted to the Senator.

Comment on this

I can stand up at any time and deal with unfounded interruptions. Two most depressing things struck me very forcibly in this debate. One—I am sorry to confess —is the very illogical arguments put forward, especially by the Minister for External Affairs. His speeches, as printed, are the greatest case that can be made for retaining the present system. The other point is that I am deeply worried by the attitude of the rising young men in Fianna Fáil who hope to be Ministers in a few years time. I hope they will realise that politics is not a game.

Comment on this

We know that.

Comment on this

It is a serious occupation. The spirit of divide and conquer will never get us anywhere in this country. As a small nation, with a population of 3,000,000 people, fewer than you have got in the City of New York, our job is to pull together. There may be a hard road ahead. There may be hardships ahead. We may have to tighten our belts. We may have to take less to build for the future, but if we work together and share the sacrifices——

Comment on this

And the triumphs.

Comment on this

——and if we get over the idea that we need a bully and a dictatorship to do the job and if we get back to our Irish heritage, we can make this country the place which those who went before us hoped it would be.

Tugadh tuairisc ar a ndearnadh; an Coiste do shuí arís.

Comment on this