We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–224 of 467. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959
Enacted

No. 41 of 1959 ›

Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 1:

To add at the end of the section the following subsection:

( ) This Act shall come into operation on such day as the Minister shall by order appoint.

I put down this amendment because the Bill is a very compendious one. It fixes the hours of opening and closing for weekdays and Sundays for town and country and there has been considerable discussion about it. Both employers and employees, particularly in Dublin, have indicated difficulties in working the provisions of the Bill. As at present drafted, once we pass it here, it will be signed within seven days by the President and will then become law, but what I am suggesting in this amendment is that the Minister should take power—it is a usual thing; it occurs in a great many Acts—to add at the end of the section that: "This Act shall come into operation on such day as the Minister shall by order appoint."

That gives power to the Minister to delay the Act by, say, a week, a fortnight or a month, as he may think fit or as he may be advised, and at the same time, it allows him to make an order bringing the Act into operation the day after it is signed. It does not in any way hamper the Minister but it does give him power, when the Bill has been passed, to give a fortnight for consultations between the licensed vintners and the trade unions of their assistants and employees with regard to its working, if these are needed in, for example, Dublin city. He may say: "I shall postpone the operation of the Bill for a fortnight and in that time. will you have your problems settled?" It seems to me that would be very much to the advantage of the Bill and the Minister, and at the same time, it would not impose any obligation on him. It is quite a common power and I think the Bill would be better if this subsection were inserted.

Comment on this

I should like to support the amendment but I should go a little further than Senator Hayes. The reason the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association is concerned about this matter is that its members are aware of considerable difficulties with regard to arranging the new hours of work that will be necessary, and with regard to the payments that will have to be made to staffs for them. There was considerable delay in having the Bill passed through the other House and I understand these people may have put the matter of discussions on the long finger. At any rate, I understand negotiations have not yet started and I think the Bill may become law by the end of this month, and certainly by the middle of next month.

It may be that the Minister would like to see some part of this year's tourist trade covered by the Bill. I am aware that the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association are anxious that the Bill should not become operative until the end of the present tourist season, that is, until October next. This amendment would enable the Minister to fix 1st October as the date when it will become operative.

I do not think they are exaggerating the problem. Unlike the Minister, who said he had no experience of the matter at all, I have heard it discussed at length and I find both the workers and the owners of the public houses are well aware of the difficulties of the problem. As Senator Hayes said, there is no reason why the Minister should not do it in this way. The only reason might be that the Minister might feel there has already been too much delay about bringing in the Bill. Originally, the suggestion was that it would be law by St. Patrick's Day, 1960, but it has gone on for so long now that I do not think the fixing of some date such as 1st October would make much difference.

Comment on this
Oscar Traynor Minister for Justice (Mr. Traynor) Fianna Fáil

It might be desirable that I should intervene at this stage, first of all, to point out that the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association about which Senator O'Donovan has spoken represents, I think, less than 700 publicans, whereas there are something like 12,000 publicans throughout the State. Therefore, as far as endeavouring to meet the wishes of the publicans in general are concerned, it is really a question of the greater good for the greater number.

On the concluding Stages of the Bill in the Dáil, Deputy Mulcahy asked me when the Bill was likely to become law. I could not give him a date but I pessimistically stated that I thought it would be the end of the autumn. As a result of that statement, both the Department and I have received a plethora of letters from all over the country asking us to have the Bill expedited and to give it the full effect of law with the least possible delay.

That is the point of view of the type of publican who has been in the past respecting the law and acting legally. The people who have not been doing so are the people anxious to see the present state of chaos continue for as long as possible. Therefore, from that point of view alone, I feel very strongly that the House should agree to allow the Bill to become law when it is signed by the President. It will take anything from five to seven days after its having been passed in both Houses. That is the period it must be with the President. There would, therefore, be something in the nature of a week or so after the passing of the Act by both Houses before it could be brought into operation.

If I were to accede to the suggestion made by Senator Hayes that I should accept this amendment and bring it in in my own good time, we would not be getting any further. If it were left to me to bring the Act into operation after it had been signed by the President, knowing the situation intimately as I know it now, I would bring it into operation within the shortest possible time, and I think that would be in the interest of the general public. There is one thing that the new law will do, that is, it will bring to an end the so-called bona fide trade, which is, in my opinion, the cause of the situation existing at present—the nonrecognition of the law and the failure of the police to take the necessary action in respect of that non-recognition.

As I said here on the Second Stage, I propose to broadcast to the people interested, the licensees and the drinking public, the necessity and the desirability of obeying the law. I propose to do that, not in the form of a threat but rather in the form of a warning and an appeal to these people to respect the law and not to endanger licensees by putting them in a position in which they might find themselves with an endorsement on their licences. From that point of view, I feel I could not accept this amendment. I think it would not be in the general interest of the public, nor would it be in the interest of the vast majority of publicans, especially those who have been trading in a legal manner.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

This amendment has nothing to do with the merits of the Bill. By and large, as I indicated on the Second Stage, I am with the Minister with regard to what is in the Bill. But the Bill, as the Minister himself has indicated, will come into operation rather earlier than he expected. There are a very big number of amendments on the Order Paper to-day, but they concern hours and many of them will be taken together. The amendment does not prevent the Bill from becoming law when the Minister orders it to become law, but it does give the Minister power to deal with the situation which exists, particularly in Dublin. The Minister's mathematics, I take it, are correct— that there are 700 people in the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association but that there are 12,000 publicans in the country. On the other hand, I think the 700 are mainly in Dublin and it is mainly a Dublin problem.

Everybody knows that in this country, and I suppose in other countries as well, people do not face something until they have to; and the people will not really believe in this Bill until it becomes an Act. When it becomes an Act it will become something quite different from what it is now and they will have to stir themselves and see what they will do about it. It seems to me that if the Minister had power to say, particularly in Dublin: "Look, I will give you a fortnight or a month to work this thing out," that would be desirable.

The Minister does not lose anything by accepting this amendment. He does not relinquish any power. On the contrary, he gains power, and if he wants the Bill at once, as I say, he can get it at once; but it is very undesirable, it seems to me, that the Bill should become law on a particular date. It is not only permissive; certain things would be obligatory, such as the change in the hours on Sundays. It is very undesirable, for example, in Dublin, that, owing to trade union difficulties or financial difficulties, some publicans should be open under the new hours and that some should retain the old hours, which I think they could do in many instances, particularly with regard to closing on weekdays.

I do not see what harm it could possibly do the Minister to have this power. He may not actually use it at all. He may use it only to postpone the Bill for two or three days or he may use it to postpone the Bill for a fortnight.

The situation in Dublin is really very difficult because there is considerable expense involved and there is the question of trade union activities and working hours. It would be very desirable to have a breathing space in which those matters could be settled. For that reason, I think the Minister should accept this amendment and take this power. He could put the Bill into operation a week or a fortnight after it has been signed. There is nothing in this amendment which in any way limits or hampers the Minister in his judgment of the situation as he finds it. It would give him power which, at the moment, he has not got and which I think he should take.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. I must say it surprised me that there was not a section like this in the Bill when it came to this House, in view of the statement made by the Minister in the Dáil. I must confess that anyone who reads this Bill, which is an amendment of the 1943, the 1927 and the 1902 Acts, would find it extremely difficult to understand what the law will be, or what the law is, with regard to hours of opening.

It may well happen, as we often-times find, that this extremely valuable explanatory memorandum will not be available in the Government Publications Sales Office. It is quite a practice with the Stationery Office not to publish sufficient copies of documents of this kind, for which there is great demand by the public. I would not be a bit surprised if, when the Bill is finally passed, people who go to look for the memorandum will not be able to find it. For that reason, it would appear to me that some time should be allowed to elapse during which the Minister and the Department could publish frequently, in various places and in various ways, what the new hours will be.

The Minister spoke about respect for the law, but I do not know how the ordinary members of the public will know what the hours are, once this Bill becomes an Act, unless they have had an opportunity, for a matter of some days or weeks, to become informed by advertisements or otherwise, as to what the new situation will be. I know the Minister intends to speak on Radio Éireann about the Bill, and probably about the hours, but not all the members of the public will hear that broadcast, and it will not be available to them in any other form. It will be very quickly forgotten and the public probably will be very confused. The Minister would do well to get this Bill off to a good start, and to take some few weeks within which to enable himself, the Department and the Garda authorities, to publish the new licensing laws and to give the public an opportunity of becoming familiar with the new and complicated situation which will arise, as a result of the passing of this legislation.

The Minister has said there are only 700 publicans represented by the Licensed Vintners' Association. I have always thought that organisation represented a good many more, but so far from that adding any point to the Minister's argument as to why the Bill should come into operation immediately, I think it strengthens the case in favour of the amendment, because where people are organised, they have their own trade journals, and circulars are sent out to members from the headquarters secretariat which keeps them up-to-date on new developments. I should have thought that, at any rate, that information would be available to all publicans through their trade organisations, but now it appears that it will be available to only 700 at most out of 12,000. In the interests of getting this legislation off to a good start, and in the interests of the publicans and their staff who will have to make new arrangements, the Minister should take the time which it has been suggested in this amendment will be necessary.

Comment on this

I have not the same high opinion of this Bill as have many other people in this House. I notice the amount of unction or vaseline that was rubbed on it on Second Reading in this House. I do not think the Minister meant what he said when he put a statement like "in the interests of the general public" in conjunction with statements like "I have had letters from a great many people in the country who were keeping the law" and "people who have been breaking the law are anxious to see chaos continue". I do not think the Minister meant that for a moment but the inference was there.

I say to the Minister without fear of contradiction, because it cannot be contradicted truthfully, that the only part of Ireland generally—I, cannot speak for the other cities—where the law is observed is Dublin city. Senator Murphy said here last week that the trade union houses kept the law better than the other houses. I agree with that view.

Comment on this

The Senator is like myself. He does not understand the publicans.

Comment on this

I am not as innocent as that. I say that if there are 1,000 public houses in Dublin, the law is kept absolutely in 95 per cent. of them. Do not forget there is a slight concession at the end of the day. People have time to finish their drinks, and the public house may not close until 10.40 p.m. without breaking the law. There is a little leeway of a few minutes. That is well known.

For the Minister to come into the House, as he undoubtedly did on Second Reading, and say that the law was not being observed at present, and that the new law will be observed, is innocence, in my opinion. As I say, on the whole, the law is best observed in Dublin. Therefore, when serious representations are made by the Licensed Vintners' Association to the effect that they have a serious problem on their hands, we should listen to them.

Again, I think the Minister is in a cleft stick because he did mention the autumn in the other House. No one wants to trap the Minister if, in fact, he answered a question he did not expect, or he might have expected the Bill to take longer to go through this House. We usually sit to the end of July and I forecast that the Bill will be through the House by the end of the month. Certainly there will not be undue delay unless we deliberately adopt the tactic of postponing each Stage. I do not think we shall do that.

I cannot see why the Minister should be so reluctant to put this amendment in the Bill. He could do what he likes about it when he reconsiders the matter and he could put the Bill into operation immediately it was signed, or he could fix a day. Let me say again that I believe, so far as Dublin is concerned, that it is the place where the law is observed. So far as this amendment is concerned, there is no connection between non-observance of the law and the bona fide traffic. I know that to be true from personal observation.

I feel we are creating more difficulty for the trade unions and for the owners, and we must remember that in the past decade we had two strikes by the workers in public houses. One of them lasted a very long time. I can understand the enticement the Minister has not mentioned but which I think is at the back of this: "Let us get part of the tourist season into this. Let us get in the months of July and August —the most important parts of the tourist season." I could imagine pressure from people in tourist resorts who observe the law there. They see a chance to be open until 11.30 p.m. I could well imagine that they would want to be open until that time and to be in a competitive position. If the Minister accepted this amendment, he could operate it whatever way he liked. I feel there is a certain commitment by the Minister who said, perhaps accidentally, he thought the Bill would be in operation in the autumn. July is not the autumn by any stretch of the imagination.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator O'Donovan said he has not the same high opinion of the Bill as some other Senators.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I have a very high opinion of the Bill. I also have some acquaintance with politics and the working of politics in this country. I am against any postponement or any power to postpone the operation of the Bill. The Minister has stated that even if he had that power by Order, his inclination would be to bring the Bill into operation as soon as possible after its signature by the President. That being so, I can see no sense in attempting to camouflage the position. That is what acceptance of this amendment would amount to.

From experience, we know what happens in this country when well-organised groups get together and decide to use the influence they can command to bring pressure to bear on Deputies, Senators and Governments. Should such a power by Order be available to the Minister, a campaign would undoubtedly start to give effect to what Senator O'Donovan has said, namely, that the Bill according to the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association should not become operative until October.

I do not see sense or reason in the suggestion that it is taking anyone at an unfair advantage or that it will create insuperable difficulties for publicans or trade unions if the Bill comes into operation next week or the week after. This Bill is based on the Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the position of the intoxicating liquor laws of 1957. It has been under discussion, one way or another, for the past three years. It has been under discussion in the Dáil since last October. The discussions have received a very good press. They have been widely reported.

Publicans and trade unions were aware that the Bill was on the stocks, that it had been introduced, that it had passed the Dáil, that it was coming to the Seanad, that it would undoubtedly pass the Seanad because of the high level of intelligence of the members of this House and that, therefore, something would happen involving changes in their modus operandi. I have no patience with the suggestion that the enactment of this legislation and the bringing into operation of the Bill as quickly as possible will take anybody at a disadvantage. There has been plenty of time.

Any suggestion to the contrary by the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association is merely an effort to stall the operation of this very long-delayed and long-awaited reform of the licensing laws. I am very strongly against any proposal which would delay the coming into operation of this Bill for even an hour after the time when it could come into operation after signature by the President.

I believe in the principle, referred to by the Minister, that the greatest good of the greatest number should be the guiding factor in this Bill.

Comment on this

Jean Jacques Rousseau.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am absolutely satisfied that the greatest good of the greatest number will be achieved by the early enactment and immediate operation of this Bill. During the debate on the Second Reading, I referred to the absurdity of our existing licensing code and the urgent need for a Bill such as the Bill before us. I said that, while it falls short of the distance I would be prepared to go in regard to change, it brought about some very necessary and beneficial changes.

Senators who seem to have a sympathy with the suggestion that operation of that Bill should be deferred until October have apparently forgotten what is in the Bill. They may have forgotten, what the Bill will achieve. In view of Senator O'Quigley's statement that people may not know the official hours—that, possibly, they may find it difficult to get them— perhaps it would be well to recapitulate the principal aims of this Bill. If people are interested enough to get copies of the Seanad debates and if the newspapers can find space enough, there will be no reason why every newspaper reader will not be acquainted with its provisions and what it seeks to achieve. This Bill which it is sought by the licensed trade to defer until October, according to one of the speakers here——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The amendment does not seek to defer the Bill until October.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator O'Donovan suggested that the licensed trade were anxious to have the Bill operative about October. The Bill which it is sought to defer by that suggestion, at least, will end the flagrant disregard of the licensing laws, of which we have heard so much——

Comment on this

In Dublin.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

——by thousands of people not only in rural Ireland but in Dublin, too, as Senator O'Donovan would know if he kept his fingers on the pulse of the various constituencies.

Comment on this

I live here and I do not go to bed before 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Our present licensing laws are flagrantly disregarded by thousands of people— people whom Garda Commissioner D. J. Costigan described as "decent upright citizens who would not do a wrong knowingly to a fellow-man." This Bill will end the bona fide traffic on weekdays and Sundays. The Gardai told the Liquor Commission that the bona fide traffic caused the greatest difficulty in the enforcement of the law and was probably the chief cause of most of the public abuses arising out of drink.

Comment on this

This is a Second Reading speech. What has this to do with the amendment?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am giving the reasons why this Bill should come into operation immediately. Although Senator Hayes's amendment seeks only to give the Minister power to bring the Bill into operation by Order, I can visualise the type of campaign which would begin immediately the Minister had that power to defer the operation of the Bill not alone until October but to a much later date.

Comment on this

Not later, I would say, than 31st August.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Those are reasons why the Bill should be brought into operation and those are reasons why the amendment suggested by Senator Hayes should not be accepted. This Bill, as I said, will establish uniform hours of trading.

Comment on this

I think we are going outside the scope of the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not think so, Sir.

Comment on this

The Senator is going into a discussion of the Bill in general. He must confine himself to this amendment.

Comment on this

We heard it before, Joe.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator will hear it again because Senator O'Quigley is afraid that the people will not know what the provisions of the Bill are and, when the Bill is enacted, they will not be able to get copies.

Comment on this

We cannot go into all the provisions of this Bill on this amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We shall continue on the next one, so.

Comment on this

The Senator understands that on the various sections, he will have scope for explanations of the kind he wants to make now.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I should like to say that, unlike some of the Senators, I have found a very widespread desire that the Bill should come into operation immediately and I hope the Seanad will not accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I was surprised at what Senator Ó Maoláin said about everybody knowing all about what is in this Bill the very day it passes the Seanad. I remember well some regulation being made in regard to the closing of confectionery shops at a certain hour of the evening. I do not think five per cent of the people running these businesses knew about it To suggest for a moment that every publican in the country is buying a copy of the Seanad Debates, is reading them and studying everything said on Second Reading and on Committee Stage is fantastic.

Comment on this

Publichouse talk.

Comment on this

Perhaps, that is happening in Dublin but it is not happening in the country. The reason I should like to support the amendment is that there has been widespread disrespect for the law. If anything has made people cynical with regard to respect for the law, it is the way in which the archaic licensing laws have been administered. I am not blaming anyone because I think they were an impossible travesty on common sense. I should like to see a Bill, when it has been enacted brought in to operation with full vigour and in as formal a manner as possible.

I think we are too secularised with regard to this thing. Every publican in the country will have to comb the papers, if there is not something more important happening that day, to see when the Bill passes the Seanad. Then he will have to search his mind to find out what the period is and then he will probably have to look at the papers again.

I should like the Minister to broad cast an explanation over Radio Éireann to everyone that this is a law freely passed by the elected representatives of this country and that it is a law which will be enforced as it should be. I should like to see the Minister doing as I suggest and if he likes, he need not tie himself to a month as a maximum. I should hate that it should just happen automatically and that people should know nothing about it beyond hearing it said that "the new law come into force to-day." Those charged with the responsibility of government have an obligation on them to bring back into this country true respect for law and justice. In Ireland, we had not the benefit of the Romans coming here to give us a respect for law and our own Government should endeavour to inculcate in our people that true respect for the law.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The sooner we get the Bill, the better.

Comment on this

The Senator can have it at any time he likes.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

I must say that when I saw this amendment on the Order Paper, I wondered what arguments would be adduced in favour of it. I did not expect to be treated to the arguments put up here by some members opposite. One would think, from the way they spoke, that the people of the country are a very dull people and that it takes a long time for them to understand things that appear in print.

Comment on this

The fight for existence is hard in the country.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

I should like to know what ambiguity there is about the provisions of this Bill. If there are any ambiguities, then there would be something to be said for the amendment, but the hours at which the public houses will open and close under the Bill are set forth very clearly and unambiguously. If that is so, what useful purpose could be served by any postponement of the measure?

Could anybody opposite tell me that? Even if it were conceded that the people of the country were not in a position to understand what appears in the Bill, what special way would there be afterwards of getting them to understand it, beyond what they have at their disposal now? The members opposite—even Senator Hayes who moved the amendment—seemed to be very concerned about the publicans in Dublin but I have read all the speeches on this measure and all the comments, and I do not see any great volume of opinion against the enforcement of the provisions of the Bill either in Dublin or elsewhere.

As I say, I was wondering what argument would be put forward in favour of this amendment. No argument was put forward here to convince me——

Comment on this

That would be hard.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

——that it would be wise for the Minister to postpone it. I must say that the attitude of the members opposite here to-day is very much in contrast with their usual attitude when they tell us from time to time that there is too much Ministerial control in this country. They tell us that the Minister rises above the law sometimes and does things the Oireachtas never intended him to do. We have to-day a position in which several members opposite would like to give the Minister more power than he wants to have. Accordingly, I think the Minister is wise in deciding to reject this amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment which Senator Hayes asks us to insert is no more or less than a provision which has been contained in other Bills which have come before us. In fact I was surprised there was not such a provision in the Bill when it was introduced, and even more so that the Minister allowed the Bill to go so far, so quickly, without inserting such a provision. It also surprises me very much that the Minister sees fit not to accept the amendment.

After all, he has not been asked to postpone the coming into operation of the Act. He has been asked only to take power to fix the date from which the new Act will operate. The date on which the Bill, and eventually the Act, becomes law is decided by the date on which the President signs it. Are we to have newspapers surmising as to when the President will sign the Act? Are we to have a news flash from Arus an Uachtaráin that at 3 p.m. that day the President signed the Act and that from that day the public houses can stay open until 11.30 p.m.?

Surely it would be more dignified if the Minister took power to order the date on which the Act comes into operation. I should like the Minister to look at the amendment from that aspect. I should imagine that for the current holiday season, various area exemption orders have been granted by the courts. What will happen in respect of these on the day the Act is signed by the President? Do they automatically lapse, or are we to have an overlapping of those exemption orders hours with the new hours provided in this Bill? Perhaps I have not read the Bill sufficiently to clarify those matters.

I think, however, this is another aspect which should persuade the Minister to accept the amendment. If he does not want to postpone implementing the legislation, he is not obliged to do so. He can, in accepting the amendment, make it clear that it is not with the intention of postponing the legislation that this provision has been inserted but of making for an even operation of the new law.

Comment on this

As a country man, I welcome the facilities afforded under this Bill for Sunday drinking in rural areas. I may say that the people in rural Ireland are not any less sober than those in the cities and I have no doubt there will be no abuse of the new facilities for reasonable imbibing on Sundays.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Senator's remarks are not relevant.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I think the Senator is coming to his point.

Comment on this

I regret to see that the hours for Sunday drinking in certain cases will not operate to suit the farmers or their labourers.

Comment on this

The Senator's remarks may well arise on a later section. If the Senator continues in that strain, he will be out of order.

Comment on this

I was only about to suggest that the hours from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. are completely wrong because they cut across the time when farmers and their men are foddering their cows or coming from devotions and so on.

Comment on this

The first thing I want to do is to try to allay several of the fears expressed here. I do not know whether I shall be able to do that or whether some Senators want to have their fears allayed. The main point I want to make at the outset is that advertisements will be published in all the newspapers when this Bill is passed to notify all and sundry that the hours are as printed in the notice, and I do not know whether the public will be made any more aware, by reason of those advertisements, than they would have been if they had been taking an intelligent interest in the matter throughout the long discussions here and in the Dáil.

This Bill has now been nearly seven months under discussion and surely our people are intelligent enough to take an interest in affairs that affect themselves. In addition to these advertisements, there will be police notices and, in addition to that again, the police will inform, and have been informing, the licensed trade throughout the country of the fact that when this Bill does become the law of the land, it will be strictly enforced.

There can be no truth in the suggestion that anybody will be taken unawares. Such a suggestion is too ridiculous to be worthy of consideration. As far as Dublin is concerned, a deputation of the licensed grocers and vintners were received in the Department of Justice and it was made very clear to them that, when the Bill became law, the hours set out in it would be strictly enforced.

Another point is that public houses do not have to remain open, if the owners do not want to. Any publican who does not want to remain open until 11.30 p.m. need not do so. Furthermore, I should like to explain to Senator Murphy, who is making gestures at me, that there will be dozens of workers working much later than those in public houses after the Bill becomes law. We must not forget the fact that bus drivers, bus conductors and the various others who work in conjunction with those services, will have to work much later. They will probably have to cater for all the people likely to come out of the public houses at 11.30 p.m.

My opinion is that the premises in the city centre will deal mainly with people living in their own vicinity and that public houses in the suburbs, at that hour of the night, will facilitate only the people who live in their localities. I cannot see that there is any danger of overlapping, as far as this legislation is concerned.

It is quite possible that the public will deal with this Bill in the same way as they dealt with any other Bills of a similar kind. There is something unreal about the amendment which says that the Act shall come into operation on such day as the Minister shall order. I am telling the House that the Bill will come into operation after the President signs it. I do not think there is any necessity to go any further than that. Certainly I cannot see that there is any realism in the suggestion at all.

Comment on this

What happens area exemptions orders?

Comment on this

One would imagine from all that has been said on the Government side that this amendment was something that had appeared on the papers of the Oireachtas for the first time in 38 years. This is a regular thing. It is a regular subsection in various kind of enactments, and it is always inserted where there are particular difficulties associated with a transition from one state of affairs to another. That is all that is behind the amendment. I listened attentively to Senator Ó Maoláin, who seemed to suggest that the amendment was in some way designed to defeat or delay the Bill. As far as I am concerned, and, I am sure, as far as Senator Hayes and the other speakers who spoke in favour of it, are concerned, the purpose simply is, the Bill being so complicated, the hours having been changed and there having been so much discussion about them in the Dáil, to give the public some time in which to become familiar with them, after the legislation has become law.

The Minister has said that this has been going on for seven months in the Dáil. So it has. Consequently, when the Bill passed through the Committee Stage in the Dáil, everybody considered that it was kind of the Minister to provide members of the Oireachtas with a memorandum saying what way the legislation stood at that stage because the legislation was so complicated and there had been such a long debate that it was by no means clear after the Committee Stage what the position was, and similarly on the Report Stage.

I am quite satisfied that as far as the vast majority of the people are concerned, despite what we may think of ourselves here, they do not read the papers nearly as attentively as we would probably wish them to. Be that as it may, I am certain that if you were to meet members of the public and ask them the hours for Sunday afternoons after the Bill becomes law, nine out of ten would not be able to tell you. I regret that the Minister is not sufficiently trusted by his own members on the other side of the House to take this power which we suggest he should be given for one purpose only, in the interests of the licensing laws.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Beware the Greeks when they come bearing gifts.

Comment on this

In this kind of legislation, certainty is of the essence of the game. The Minister intends to put advertisements in the newspapers and to make a broadcast, but in neither case can he specify a date, because under the Constitution the President has three days in which to sign a Bill, the 5th, the 6th, or the 7th day after the Bill has been passed. Is the Minister going to make a special arrangement with the President to sign this Bill on the 5th day, on the 6th or on the 7th? He will not, because the President would not make any such arrangement with him. We are told that there are 10,000 establishments operating. Are they to be in the position that they do not know, or that some evening it will be announced by Radio Éireann: "The President signed the Bill to-day and you may remain open to-night till 11.30"?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is cod.

Comment on this

It is not cod. Supposing a person has no radio, or that the necessary arrangements have not been made with the trade unions and negotiations are still going on. It is all right to talk, as the Minister talked, about the interests of the general public—something coming from Jean Jacques Rousseau—or to talk about the greatest good of the greatest number—that statement from the utilitarian school in Britain. That is very interesting higher political theory, but this is a very simple practical difficulty. As I see it, you must have this Bill becoming law on a specific date; otherwise you will have differences between different parts of the country. They will not give rise to any great trouble—the Guards are reasonable men—but it is a bad start for a law that is to bring about all the reform the Minister hopes it will bring about.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

This amendment, unlike the bona fide traffic, is offered in complete good faith. It is not offered for the purpose of keeping the Bill from being enforced or with a view to doing any harm to the tourist trade. It is not offered, as somebody said, because of any ambiguity in the Bill. I do not see any ambiguity in the Bill. It is offered simply to enable the Minister to do what he says he wants to do, namely, to make a broadcast and publicise in the Press the hours in this Bill when it becomes an Act.

Surely it is desirable that when making the broadcast, he should be able to say: "This Bill, which got great discussion in the two Houses of the Oireachtas and about which I received a great number of deputations, is now law. It has been signed by the President, and I propose under the provisions of subsection (2) of Section 1 of the Act to fix Sunday, 10th July for the coming into operation of the Act, and I want to warn all and sundry that these are the opening hours...." Would that not be reasonable? The Minister does not accept that.

Senator Ó Ciosáin says, of course, that the Minister is wise. When you are on that side of the House, the Minister is always wise. That is a feature of Ministers: they are always wise to their own people. Another feature of Ministers is that they never give way even on simple things. I was hoping that the Minister with his experience might perhaps yield a particular thing even for his own advantage, but he does not.

All this Parliamentary business means that after years and years of turning a thing over in the Department, they devise a Bill, and when anybody points out a flaw, they give a thousand and one arguments, like the Thousand and One Nights long ago, to prove that they do not need to amend it. The Minister does need to have in this Bill a provision which will enable him to fix a day for putting it into operation. The idea that the amendment has been moved so that the Bill will be postponed either until October or until 1st September or until August is nonsense. The Minister could have the power and exercise it at his own discretion.

It seems to me as a matter of common sense that to give the Bill a good start and to accomplish what the Minister says he wants to accomplish and what we all agree we want to accomplish, namely, uniform hours throughout the country for the public houses to open and shut and a uniform enforcement of the law, with the goodwill of the owners and employees, surely there should be plenty of publicity and the Minister should be able, by broadcast and police notice, to draw attention to it. To do that, he will want to be able to fix the date.

However, if the Minister does not want that, I do not know what he proposes to do except to say that when the Bill becomes law, it will be enforced without being able to give a precise date. I see no reason why he would not have this power. It is offered in good faith and for the better working of this measure. If he does not want it, nobody can force it on him.

Amendment put and declared negatived.

Comment on this

I should like to make a suggestion to the House as to how we might best deal with the question of the repeals. In the ordinary course the House would, no doubt, take the repeals at the end, when we come to the Schedule. In general, I see no difficulty in adhering to this procedure in this case, but there are two items in the repeals which are so closely bound up with the positive provisions of the Bill that I submit to the House that it would be almost impossible to have a proper discussion, if we deferred those two repeal items to the end. I refer, of course, to the bona fide provision—Section 15 of the Act of 1927—and area exemption orders—Section 16 of the 1927 Act.

I intend, with the permission of the Cathaoirleach, to propose to the House at a later stage that we should discuss area exemption orders at the same time as we discuss general opening on Sunday evening, and I do not propose to refer to them further now.

I submit to the House, however, that the time for any debate on the proposed abolition of the bona fide trade is now. If we do not decide now on the question of the bona fide trade, it will be extremely difficult to discuss the proposed general opening hours in the next section, since it is obvious that one is linked with the other. I made a similar suggestion in the Dáil and it was accepted, and in repeating it here, I have taken note of the fact that in this House, as in the Dáil, there seems to be unanimity or near-unanimity that, whatever differences of opinion there may be about the general opening hours, the bona fide trade, as such, must go.

May I make it quite clear—this question was asked in the Dáil—that in asking the House to decide now on the abolition of the bona fide provision, I am in no way seeking to limit the debate that may take place on the general opening hours? In particular, a decision to abolish the trade does not, of course, preclude any Senator from advocating on Section 4 that there should be a differential between closing hours in city and country.

Could we, therefore, have agreement that, in accepting Section 3, the House will be accepting the proposal to abolish bona fide trading so that the debate on Section 4 can proceed in the context of such a decision?

Comment on this

I do not see any objection to this, provided it will not be argued, in any circumstances, if we propose 10.30 p.m. for Dublin and 11.30 p.m. for the rest of the country, that we are endeavouring to restore the bona fide houses. I accept the Minister's assurance, though I am quite certain that some Senators on the other side of the House will immediately say that we are seeking to do that if we propose those hours. However, the Minister has given an assurance that it will not limit us in that matter in any way.

Comment on this

Restoring it under a new Act.

Comment on this

I wish to support what Senator O'Donovan has said. I have no objection to the Minister doing what he wishes and I agree with Senator O'Donovan's very well intentioned and well-thought out contention that it should not cut across the validity of our amendments and should not in any way give an argument, a conceded argument, to the Minister on the question of deviation from uniformity.

Comment on this

The acceptance of the abolition does not interfere with the general debate at all.

Comment on this

And, as such, no argument will be made on that score?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Various amendments have been tabled to this Section. Would the House be agreeable to take amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 4 together?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I think so.

Comment on this

These three amendments have to do with the closing hour on weekdays. Perhaps if Senators would keep that in mind, it would help them very much in the course of the debate.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 4, to delete lines 15 to 19, inclusive, and substitute "after the hour of half-past ten o'clock in the evening".

I do not want to be long-winded on this amendment, though I must make the point that the question of the closing hours on weekdays is probably the most important aspect of the Bill. What is proposed in the Bill is that for June, July, August and September, public houses should stay open until 11.30 at night, and until 11 o'clock for the remainder of the year. In this amendment, I am suggesting that a better arrangement would be a closing all the year around at 10.30 p.m. The reasons I tabled it are: first, that I think the hours of 11.30 p.m. and 11 p.m. are too late; secondly, that there is no real demand for such late hours; and, thirdly, that the best interests of both the people frequenting public houses and the owners and workers in them will be better served by a closing hour of 10.30 p.m.

It has been said from the opposite side of the House that there is a public demand for these later closing hours, but, listening to the debate on the first amendment, it struck me that we were being given an example of the publicans in the major centre of population, Dublin, not being in any way anxious for these longer hours and indeed, according to Senator O'Donovan, asking for a stay of execution. Apparently this great public demand for longer hours is not coming from the publicans in Dublin and it is certainly not coming from the people who work in the public houses.

It is quite true that the law is better observed—I shall put it as far as that—by the publicans and the workers in Dublin city than in other parts of the country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They are the people who are observing the law as it stands at the moment. However, one of the arguments in favour of longer hours is that the law as it stands is not being generally observed in other areas, so the publicans and the workers in Dublin are to have these longer hours stuffed down their throats because people down the country are not observing the law. That is a very unwelcome liberty for them to receive from the Government.

They do not want longer hours. They do not think they will sell any more liquor, or that there will be any better custom for them than what they have at the moment, but I am prepared, as I said on Second Reading, to concede that 10 p.m. closing during winter is possibly too early and I suggest that 10.30 p.m. all the year round would amply meet the needs of the people who want to take drink, and would be to the convenience of the people who run public houses and the workers who have to earn their livelihood in them.

The suggestion has been thrown out that other workers work longer hours. Bus drivers and bus conductors work longer hours than those proposed for assistants in public houses under this Bill, but they do so on a particular shift. Transport workers, post office workers and people in the hotel industry have to work longer hours because it is necessary. I want to submit to the House that there is no real necessity to ask the assistants in public houses. to work beyond 10.30 p.m. all the year round. The public's requirements in regard to intoxicating liquor can adequately be met up to 10.30 p.m. without asking the assistants to work until 11.30 p.m. for four months of the year and until 11 p.m. for the remaining months.

On Second Reading, I suggested to the House that we should dismiss completely this argument that the 11.30 p.m. opening would be to the benefit of the tourist industry. I do not think there is any evidence to that effect, or that it can be shown that we shall get more tourists if the public houses remain open for an hour longer. Indeed, it is the experience of everybody who has knowledge of public houses and of tourists that the tourists are the people who best observe the law as it stands at present, that they are quite prepared to leave the public houses at the prescribed hour. We must remember that tourists invariably stay in hotels which are licensed and if they want to drink later than the prescribed hour, until one or two in the morning, being residents of these hotels, they are entitled to do so. Therefore, there is no need for later opening hours to meet the suggested demands of the tourist industry.

In Dublin, most public houses are operated by trade union labour. The majority of the people working in these public houses have to get back to their homes and lodgings when they finish work at night. I have some experience of this. I know some of the people concerned and I know that they already have some little difficulty in getting "digs" because of the awkward hours they have to work. They are under a disadvantage m that respect. Landladies tend to welcome them a little less than they do the people who finish work at 5 or 6 o'clock in the evening and who have regular hours of coming and going.

Now it is suggested that these people for four months of the year shall work in the public houses until after 11.30 at night. None of us can imagine that at 11.30 p.m. they automatically will take off their aprons, put on their coats and go out. Do any of us imagine that because the closing hour will now be 11.30 p.m., the doors can be closed, the house cleared immediately at that hour and the assistants can walk away? Any of us who know the circumstances will understand that the people concerned will be still at work up to 12 midnight when transport has ceased and they will then have to make their way home to their "digs" or houses. That will be most awkward for those in "digs" and what about the people who are married: what sort of family circumstances will they have if they finish work at 12 midnight for four months of the year and possibly up to that hour for the remaining 12 months?

I am hoping——perhaps it is a vain hope—that the Minister will again look into this question and recognise that there is no real demand for these later closing hours, that they are certainly not welcome to the trade in Dublin, to the employers and to the workers. Further, there is no demand, I think, from the people who frequent these public houses for an opening hour as late as 11.30 p.m. These are the views of the people concerned. They are certainly the views of the workers concerned and I think an injustice is being done to them by imposing these longer hours on them.

The Minister said on the last day— and he said it again today—that there is no obligation on the public houses concerned to stay open until 11.30 p.m. or 11 p.m. That would be all right if Dublin could be tied up so tightly that the employers' organisation and the trade union concerned could agree that every public house would close at exactly 10.30 p.m. or 11 p.m.—some agreed time earlier than 11.30 p.m.— and that they could, irrespective of the law, impose their own closing hour, but of course, that is not practicable. All the houses are not trade union houses. In some of them, the proprietor and his family are able to run the business. If one public house is to remain open until 11.30 p.m., can anyone envisage that another public house could possibly close down at 10.30 p.m.? They would very quickly find themselves out of business and there would be a bonus for the people prepared to stay open a little longer. In any case, there will then be that drift to premises outside the city, if there is a big margin between the closing hour in the city and that operating in the rural areas.

I want to suggest to the Minister again that he is going too far in the Bill in providing for a closing hour on weekdays of 11.30 p.m. for four months of the year and of 11 p.m. for the remaining months. What I am suggesting is a 10.30 p.m. closing all round. If that does not meet with the wishes of the Seanad, I should be quite prepared to go back a little further if we could reach a compromise—go back to what is suggested by Senator O'Quigley, half-an-hour later—if that will meet with the wishes of the Seanad, so that we could have some improvement on what is suggested in the Bill, 11.30 p.m. for four months of the year and 11 p.m. for the remaining eight months.

Comment on this

I am concerned about various aspects of this matter. I have no great interest myself in the hours which the public houses open. I found an extraordinary interest in the topic here in Dublin, and I can say I found unanimity of opinion on the part of the owners, the workers and the people who frequent the public houses, that the present hours are about right. Senator Murphy spoke only for the owners and the workers, and I can add from discussions I have heard that there was unanimity——

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

In Dublin?

Comment on this

Unanimity in Dublin. There is no question about that, in so far as you will ever get unanimity in an assembly of Irishmen. I understand from the grapevine that there were serious discussions in the Fianna Fáil Party, and I heard that the Minister was going to give way on the question of the hours, and that the hour would be 11 p.m. all the year round. There were many rumours to that effect in the trade in Dublin, and particularly among the workers. I do not know where they got that idea. I understand there was the mother and father of a row in the Fianna Fáil Party about the whole matter and this Bill was carried by only a small majority. If such is the case, the obvious thing to do is to give way on the issue, but again, apparently, the managers have had their way, as Senator Hayes said earlier on his amendment—the managers make up their minds and the Minister obeys.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Did the Senator not mention a majority?

Comment on this

I said the managers make up their minds and the Ministers obey.

Comment on this

That is the first I have heard of it.

Comment on this

That is a bigger question and it is an issue which I do not think we should discuss here. It is fairly well known all over the world—it is nearly as well known to-day as the opinion of Jean Jacques Rousseau or the utilitarian theory mentioned by Senator Ó Maoláin— that there are managerial revolutions. One can get Penguin books by the half-dozen dealing with the subject. For the past 20 years, the power of the managers has been well known and the Minister, I think, knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would come back to the amendment.

Comment on this

There were two things the Minister said which perturbed me. One was on Second Reading when he said:

The hours ... are, in fact, a compromise. They are later than one section of the licensed trade and organised labour would wish and they are earlier than other sections of the licensed trade and some sections of the general public want.

Who are this section of the public who want to drink after 11.30 p.m.?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The thousands the Senator did not meet.

Comment on this

We all know what happens in cold blood. We know that when they have half a dozen drinks or one over the eight——

Comment on this

The greater good of the greater number.

Comment on this

The bigger the number, the more they want. Senator Ó Maoláin knows that problem as well as I do.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do.

Comment on this

The only solution I can suggest is to have the hour of 11.30 p.m. in the country. Could we prescribe some area like the city and county of Dublin and Bray and say the hour there is 10.30 p.m.? If I suggest that, I shall immediately be accused of restoring the bona fide trade, but that problem is not insurmountable.

The second point which perturbed me was made by the Minister today and was not, so far as I can recollect, made previously by him. It is that the hours of work of certain people are later than those now proposed in the Bill. It was inherent in the Minister's statement that the transport workers will have to work longer hours to take home the people who will drink until 11.30, and the workers in the public houses.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

No; he did not say that.

Comment on this

I said it was inherent—I did not say the Minister said it.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

The Senator read it into it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The last buses leave at 11.30p.m.

Comment on this

Do not forget that there are, at present, arrangements to take the transport workers home. Might I say it is a regular thing if you are passing Donnybrook bridge to pick up many of these people who live in the Terenure area and take them home. They say it takes too long on the bus which has to go around the city. They prefer to be picked up by a motorist who lives near Terenure or Crumlin, and I am sure it is the same in other parts of the city. In fact, there are arrangements to take them home. I ask the Minister in all seriousness: is this a stunt to create extra employment by going back to having buses running up to the hours of 12.30 or 1 a.m.? Of course that will create employment since more people will be working on the transport system, if the existing trade union rules are to continue. As I say, it would create employment but it is a most extraordinary way to do it.

I did not misread what the Minister said. It was implicit and inherent in what he said that the city transport workers will have to work longer hours. That will be the next step after this Bill becomes law. A case will be made: "How are we to get home? We went to a picture house until 10.30 p.m., and then went for a few drinks and lo and behold, with the pleasant company, we forgot our bus left at 11.30. We cannot afford to take a taxi to take us home."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How do waitresses and newspaper men and women get home?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

But they get home.

Comment on this

Do not forget these people are not very big people. Some of those big institutions provide transport to take their staffs home and Senator Ó Maoláin probably knows that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Public house assistants are not very big people.

Comment on this

Public houses are not big organisations. Newspapers are.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They do not provide transport.

Comment on this

Public houses are run by comparatively small people.

Comment on this

Surely the Irish Press takes its workers home at night?

Comment on this

I was wondering whether or not they did. There is the problem inherent in this Bill that the law was not being observed and that, therefore, a solution must be found. It was stated by—perhaps I might mention his name; he is now attached to the Government—Deputy J. Brennan that the law would be observed in future. I am not that much of a cynic, but I do not believe it will be better observed in rural Ireland in the future than it is at present.

I am sure the Minister will do his best, but I am afraid I must say that the Bill, far from containing the seeds of improvement, contains the seeds of decay, I regret to say. That is why I was perturbed by the nature of the discussions here last week, when so many people said how good the Bill was. We are living in a democracy, and if the people want 11.30 p.m. in the Bill, they are entitled to it, but I see no reason why 11.30 p.m. should be forced on the owners of public houses in Dublin, on the workers in the public houses in Dublin and on the people who take their refreshment in the public houses in Dublin. Why should they be compelled to have these hours?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are not compelled.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

They are not compelled to stay open until 11.30 p.m.

Comment on this

They are, in practice.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are not, in effect, and the Senator knows that.

Comment on this

They are, in practice, and Senator Ó Maoláin knows it.

Comment on this

I do not know if the problem is or is not capable of solution but I say there is no effort in this Bill to solve it. I leave it to the Minister to have regard to the views which will be expressed by others on it.

Comment on this

I have tabled amendments to the section which are now being discussed with this amendment. I must say it was with no great confidence that I put them down, in view of the concluding remarks of the Minister on Second Stage. While he would welcome improvements to the Bill, he said the Bill cannot be made better in respect of the hours. That does not encourage anybody to put down amendments. Apparently the Minister has closed his mind in advance to all these amendments.

Comment on this

No, that is not true. What I have in mind is something that is an improvement, which is a different thing. But the hours cannot be improved.

Comment on this

Yes—that the hours cannot be improved. Therefore, when we get up here to talk in support of these amendments, we do so in the certain knowledge that we shall not move the Minister one whit. None-the-less, since we have the right to put down amendments to the Bill, we have a duty to put them down as we conceive them to be necessary. For that reason, I put down the amendments I conceived to be necessary.

I must confess I have never been able to understand where the demand has come from for some of the hours included in the Bill in its earlier stages and included in it now. I do not want to deal with the early opening hours on Sunday. The Government, it appears, were fully convinced that the hours originally in the Bill for the early opening on Sunday were absolutely the best. To the Government's credit, be it said, they changed these hours. Likewise, I have no doubt that the hours for ordinary weekday opening at night are not the best.

I do not understand what influences have been at work to persuade the Government that 11.30 p.m. in summer and 11 p.m. in winter are hours for which there is a public demand. I have discussed this right from the time the Commission's Report came out. I have never heard people in and around the city of Dublin say they want longer opening hours than 11 p.m. in. summer and 10.30 p.m. in winter. There seems to be fair agreement that these are the suitable hours for summer and winter.

A line of argument some people take is that there should be no restrictions whatever. The function of the State is to remove obstacles to the good life. Acting through the Legislature, the State is entitled to recognise that drinking represents an overwhelming temptation for a substantial number of people. Therefore, it is right and proper to remove the strong, overwhelming temptation that late drinking represents for a number of people in the same way as it is right and proper to legislate in regard to the poisons a chemist may sell, and things of that kind. These are necessary steps in the interests of the community.

Once one accepts that the State has this right to legislate, it then becomes a matter of establishing that there is a demand for these late drinking hours. I do not know where that demand comes from. Senator Murphy says the workers do not want them. Senator O'Donovan says the publicans do not want them. Temperance Associations say they do not want them. The drinking classes say they do not want them because they will upset the whole routine of their family and personal life which they have been observing for years. It is a routine which suits them. In either winter or summer, the regular drinkers, who constitute the steady trade of the public houses, leave home approximately an hour or an hour and a half before closing time, or perhaps a shorter period, depending on whether they drink pints or "small ones". They leave home at a certain fixed period before the public houses close and go down to the local and have these few drinks. In summer, they want to be back around 11 p.m., and in winter they want to be home around 10.30 p.m.

Bearing in mind the need for uniformity, the conditions which prevail in rural areas, the particular position of farm workers, one must recognise that these hours should be extended somewhat. That is the justification for extending the 10 p.m. hour to 10.30 p.m. in winter and the 11 p.m. hour to 11.30 p.m. in summer. It is clear that there is not a demand for the longer drinking hours proposed in the Bill.

I would refer the House to an illustration of the lack of public demand for late drinking hours in summer. I have been told by a number of people in different towns that, during the Tostal period when area exemption orders were procured for the purposes of the Tostal, there was no demand after the usual hours. When permission was obtained to enable people to drink until midnight, or perhaps it was 11.30 p.m.—when the hours were extended in the summer months from 10.30 p.m. to either 11.30 p.m. or to midnight—I have been told by pub licans that after the ordinary hou there was no demand whatever in towns where the extension was granted. I believe the same position applied in Dublin. In fact, in some towns, after their experience in the first couple of years of that extension, the publicans did not think it worth their while to pay fees to solicitors to go into court to get the extension.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How does the Senator make out that these extended hours will encourage too much drinking?

Comment on this

I am not talking about that. I am talking about a particular pattern that has existed up to the present. Once this Bill becomes law and receives the sanction and approval of the Legislature, drinking habits will gradually change. People will find themselves drinking until 11 p.m. in winter and until 11.30 p.m. in summer, although at present their disposition is that they do not want to be put in that position. They recognise that that will happen and they do not want it to happen.

It would be very interesting if the Minister could give the House some information as to the number of towns or areas which availed of the extension providing longer opening hours during the Tostal period. That might indicate the demand. I do not know that any questions were asked on that subject in the Dáil. Perhaps the Minister has not that information but it would be most illuminating. It would be a fairly clear indication of die lack of public demand for the drinking hours proposed in the Bill.

Another point that strikes me about the extension until 11.30 p.m. during the summer is that I had always supposed that one of the evils of the bona fide trade was that people were drinking to a late hour and that it was considered that midnight was altogether too late. All that was in addition to the fact that people were travelling distances to bona fide houses, perhaps drinking too much and then getting involved in road accidents. I always thought midnight was regarded as too late for the vast majority for whom we must cater. The vast majority of the people in this country do not want to be out of their homes after 11.30 p.m.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Who told you?

Comment on this

That is my experience and I have been so reminded by respectable, decent, ordinary Irish people. Senator Ó Maoláin may know a different kind.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I know all classes.

Comment on this

The vast majority of the people I know and of other people they know are at home most nights of the week around 11 p.m. or 11.30 p.m. Here we are starting a new social custom, a new type of arrangement among families, whereby people will be out until all hours of the night, as it is said, in summer time and until 11 o'clock and after it in winter time. I do not know whether Senator Ó Maoláin would adopt this legalistic approach thrown out by Senator Ó Ciosáin last day, that there is no compulsion on public houses to open and no obligation on anyone——

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

And neither is there.

Comment on this

——to stay there. The Bible says that the spirit is, indeed, willing but the flesh is weak. As far as the public houses are concerned, the spirit is willing arid is also too strong.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It has gone down 30 per cent.

Comment on this

That is only Power's.

Comment on this

That is the situation that practical people must face up to. I do not think it is any kind of an argument to say that printers, transport people and others have to work late. It is too bad for that group of people who have to do it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is too bad for the publicans.

Comment on this

I do not see why we should add to the number of people in the hardship class. "The proper direction for people socially minded;" and "people interested in the betterment of the conditions of the workers" are phrases which I think I heard coming from that side of the House on occasions. So far from adding to the number of the hardship classes, we should do everything possible to reduce the number or keep it stable. It is no argument to say that there are other people who suffer and who might as well suffer, too.

The Minister touched upon the possibility of extending the transport services. The way he put it and as I picked him up—Senator O'Donovan is not always right in his interpretation of things—is that, perhaps, it might be necessary to have increased transport services because of these extensions of the hours of drinking and that he would not favour an extension of the transport facilities, I take it, for the reason that that would only be encouraging people to drink for a longer period. That is the reason the Minister would not favour an extension of the transport services. This House can be assured that so far as C.I.E. are concerned, the least C.I.E. would want to do is to facilitate people who want to use transport services. We have had an example of that in the Bray railway line—incidentally, I raised the matter last Wednesday—which is now being kept open for the next two months. Presumably, what they did was not legal.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator may not discuss that matter on this Bill.

Comment on this

If the Minister has any hope that the unfortunate barmen who will have to work longer hours will be facilitated by C.I.E., that is, indeed, a very remote hope and one which will not be realised. Consequently, I would urge on the House, notwithstanding what the Minister said that these hours cannot be improved, to support the amendments which have been tabled.

Comment on this

I want to confirm Senator O'Quigley's worst fears by saying that I do not propose to accept the amendment. When Senator Murphy was speaking, he said there were no demands from the publicans and no demands from the assistants. Demands do not come from these individuals. Demands for services usually come from the general public. In every possible respect it is public feeling that creates the demand and the people on whom the demand is made are the people who have to supply the amenities the public seek, so that from the point of view of the publicans or the assistants not making any demands, that does not, in fact, arise.

The hours which Senator Murphy is now seeking are the very hours which brought about the situation which the Commission recommended should be ended by the adoption of the hours set out in the Bill. That seems to me to be a rather extraordinary attitude. Senator Murphy was a member of the Commission and must have been well aware of the evidence given to the Commission by the vast number of witnesses who appeared before them and he must have been aware of the fact that there were demands for this type of service.

Senator O'Donovan asked where did this demand come from and who made it. Senator O'Quigley asked the same question. It only goes to show that neither Senator O'Donovan nor Senator O'Quigley had recourse to the Report of the Commission which was issued by the State following its presentation. In the course of their discussions on week-day general drinking, they had this to say:

We had convincing evidence from all over the country that the present hours fail to meet actual needs in rural areas.

Demand comes from the fact that the drinking public were drinking up to the latest possible hour in the city of Dublin public houses. After that, they appear to have gone out to the bona fide houses and carried on there. I am not convinced that the Dublin publicans were closing their houses at the required hours any more than I am convinced that the publicans in rural Ireland were doing so.

I have myself seen up to, say, 10.45 or 10.50 p.m. premises lighted up, with numerous cars outside the doors. I am pretty certain that if I were to investigate, I would find that there were quite a number of drinkers inside being served with drinks and served illegally. Surely that is a demand. What is Senator O'Quigley shaking his head about? They are drinking illegally if they are on the premises.

Comment on this

They may be on the premises——

Comment on this

They are not being served after 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

If they are on the premises after the hours specified in the licensing Acts, they are on the premises illegally. There can be no doubt about that.

When Senator Murphy talked about people having to work what he seemed to regard as abnormal hours, I should like to remind him of the fact that they do not have to work outside the hours their trade union accepts as being fair, and it will be up to the publican to make his own arrangements as to whether his men work as the transport men work—on the basis of a split day, some of them coming in the morning and working till the afternoon and others coming in the afternoon and working throughout the evening. As I have said, it is a matter for arrangement between the workers and their employers and I cannot honestly see how these things could not be overcome They are simple matters and I do not think any worker would be expected to work any longer than the hours set out in the Shops Acts.

Again, I want to point out that when we talk about workers having to work abnormal hours, we are forgetting that on the fringe of the city, we have these bona fide houses where the men do not stop working until 12 midnight or after. Nobody seems to take notice of that fact. Nobody says that these are abnormal hours; it has not been suggested that these men are doing any more than carrying out the terms of their employment or doing anything which is not to their own satisfaction.

The hours are not my hours. They are the hours the Commission recommended. Someone referred also to the fact that we changed the hour on Sunday afternoon from one o'clock to 12.30. The original hour recommended by the Commission was 12.30 but the Government, because of the views expressed to them in regard to the question of late Mass and so on, decided it would be much better not to allow the hours to interfere with religious services. Accordingly, in their wisdom or otherwise, the Government decided that 12.30 p.m. would be too near to the last Mass and that 1 p.m. would be more suitable. Having heard the almost unanimous expression of opinion in the other House, I recommended to the Government that we should revert to the hours recommended by the Commission. That was the reason the time was changed back from 1 p.m. to 12.30 p.m.—to meet what could be regarded as public demand.

I want to repeat that whatever action the Commission took in regard to their recommendations, I must assume, and we all must assume, because they were all men of education, of wisdom, of intelligence, that the hours are in fact based on the evidence produced to them in the course of their hearings. Practically everything in the Commission's Report, with very few exceptions of a minor character, were accepted by the Government. These are the things that now comprise the Bill.

Some Senators, Senator O'Donovan particularly and, I think, Senator O'Quigley, quoted me as using some words in respect of public transport. What I tried to convey to the House was that public transport would leave the city at 11.30 p.m., but I added to that by saying that I believe the general public will drink in their own local areas. I do not see how a suggestion that public transport should work later than the present hours can be imputed to me. I believe that what will happen is that the various licensed premises in the city and in the suburbs will cater for their own local customers.

I should like to finish by reminding the House that the Commission said they had convincing evidence that the hours operating in the licensed trade at the moment were not sufficient and that on that evidence they decided to recommend extended hours. These are the hours in the Bill; these are the hours I recommend to the House; and I cannot accept any amendment aimed at altering these hours.

Comment on this

It seems there is not the same demand for a lengthening of the hours in the cities as there is in the country. One of the practical difficulties is that there is an hour's difference between the city and the country and that people are inclined to go out to the country after the city houses close. Perhaps a very sensible compromise would be if we could agree that there would be a half hour in the difference as between city and country. If country public houses were allowed to remain open for only a half an hour later than those in the city, it would not then be worth people's while to go out to the country to drink.

The Minister mentioned my name in connection with a passage in the Commission's Report referring to rural Ireland. I should like to say that we all want to make of this a very good Bill. Public houses to which I have gone in the city close punctually at 10 p.m. or 10.30 p.m. as the case may be and for about ten minutes before the time, people are talking about the time. Perhaps sometimes it does take five minutes or so to get people out of the houses but it is my general impression of public houses in Dublin that they close punctually. I cannot say I am an authority but one cannot be a politician in rural Ireland without knowing what happens in public houses there.

I am looking forward to a new law which will be fair to the people and respected by the Minister's officials who will have to carry it out. I want to see a measure which the general body of publicans will also respect and observe. That is what we have all been hoping for. Half of the cynical approach of the people to the law is brought about by the disrespect which has arisen in rural Ireland for the licensing laws.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I never heard such unctuous hypocrisy as all this talk and pretence about the observance of the licensing laws in Dublin by the public and those who operate the laws. Surely the Senators who made those statements are aware of what is happening here. Surely they are aware of the evidence given to the Licensing Commission. Surely, if they have any contact with the world around them, they must know what goes on between 10.30 p.m. and midnight in respect of drinking in this city and its suburbs.

There is no doubt whatsoever that the law is being flagrantly defied and broken night after night and Sunday after Sunday, because of the fact that in spite of what Senators have said, there is a demand for more suitable hours during which people can get a drink and get it in comfort. There is no doubt whatever that the consumers have no organisation, but there is every evidence as evidenced by Press reports of meetings of various small trading bodies and of licensed associations outside Dublin which have appeared in the Press during the past two or three years, to show that the hours suggested by the Commission commend themselves to those people. There is every evidence also from contacts which people have with the country to substantiate the claim that, in rural Ireland particularly, there has been discrimination against the country dweller in our existing legislation, and this uniformity of hours which is being given in this Bill will to a great extent rectify and put an end to that discrimination and end the urban bias which has existed in our legislation.

Comment on this

No one spoke against the country hours.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Certainly Senator Murphy wants the hour to be put back to 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

That is not discrimination.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Of course it is discrimination. Senator O'Quigley provided us with as fine a sample of the survival of the slave mind from the days of the conquerer as I have heard in this House.

Comment on this

I thought the slave mind existed only in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator O'Quigley has suggested that the Irish people could not be trusted to drink, that the Irish people, unlike those of any country in Europe or any country in North or South America, could not be given reasonable hours to drink because they might drink too much. He has the same mentality as the gentleman who imposed a ban on drinking on St. Patrick's Day on everybody but the wealthy sections of our community. I think he ought to be ashamed of himself for suggesting that the Government should control the hours of drinking in the same way as one would control the sale of poison. In civilised countries, countries just as civilised as this, where men are just as civilised as Senator O'Quigley, all through Europe, one can drink around the clock, as I pointed out on the last occasion. There is no question whatever that our people are in any sense inferior in any way to the people of those countries. They can be as well trusted to have a rational approach to facilities provided for them in regard to drink as the people of any other country, and I resent that insinuation by Senator O'Quigley.

Senator O'Donovan and Senator Murphy both seem to suggest that everybody in Dublin was agreed that 10.30 p.m. should be the hour. I do not know what type of people they mix with, but Senator O'Quigley mixes with what are described as the best people, because ordinary people, with whom he does not mix, are absolutely dead against this idea which he expressed, that 10.30 p.m. is a reasonable hour. I should like Senator O'Quigley, Senator Murphy and Senator O'Donovan to make a spot check at any street comer in Dublin at any time between 10 p.m. and 10.30 p.m. and ask the people who are wending their way towards a hostelry for a drink whether they think that 10.30 p.m. is a reasonable hour or whether they should be permitted to have a drink up to 11 p.m. or 11.30 p.m. I am quite certain that they would be astonished at the answer.

I would ask them to stand outside the Gate or the Olympia Theatre any night at 10.30 or 10.35 p.m. when the shows end and make a spot check on the theatregoers when they come out and find themselves in the position on any of those warm nights of having a thirst on them, as most human beings have, and who would like to remedy that thirst by getting a bottle of beer, but who cannot do it because of the unreasonable laws which close the public houses at 10.30 p.m. I ask Senator O'Quigley to make such a spot check outside any theatre at any time during these summer months. He will be astonished at the answers he will get.

There is no reason in the world why a minority of employers and workers here in the city of Dublin should dictate the policy of the majority and deny the majority the right to drink in comfort and in suitable hours just because it does not suit them to have working hours which do not appeal to them. Many other classes of the community have working hours which do not appeal to them. We cannot all be at leisure at the same time.

There is no doubt that so far as trade unions are concerned, not more than 10 per cent. of the workers in the licensed trade are members of the trade unions, and I do not think the trade unions can speak in their name and declare that they are vehemently against these proposed hours. So far as traders are concerned, there is a six per cent. minority of the total trade population in Ireland who are against the extended hours, but the wishes of the majority must supersede the ideas and the convenience of the small minority. Therefore, I do not think any case has been made for the amendments suggested here by Senators Murphy, O'Quigley and Burke.

Comment on this

In support of these amendments, I should like to make a few general observations which I hope to do in the sense of a comment on the Bill generally. I should like to begin by going back to the point dealt with by the Minister and by Senator Ó Maoláin that we have in fact some demand for an extension of these hours. In that context, I think the Minister quite frankly was being unfair to the House in quoting the sentence he quoted from the Commission's Report, because unless I read that sentence incorrectly and heard the Minister incorrectly, I am satisfied that the sentence refers specifically to the rural areas.

Again, I want to make the point that in fact there is no broad public demand of any kind whatever for the extended hours suggested in this Bill. Like some others who have spoken, I want to say that I do not accept the fallacious proposition that there is some type of benefit to be created to the tourist trade by the passage of this Bill. Surely we do not have to argue that the tourists coming into this country are not, normally, at any rate, dependent on the ordinary hours in which the public houses are permitted to remain open. Ninety-five per cent. or ninety-nine per cent. of them will be staying in establishments where they can drink any time they want to right round the clock, without any regard whatever to the ordinary hours during which the citizens are permitted to drink in public houses. I hope that will be the end of that argument because I do not think it is helpful to the debate on the Bill.

As a trade union official, I naturally must direct my attention to the effect which the passage of Bill will have on the very large number of people employed in the licensed trade. I have taken the trouble to consult the trade unions which cater for these people and, as Senator Ó Maoláin has invited us to consult various categories of the public, I invite him to come along with me and consult the trade unions. Not alone will they supply him with arguments but they will also give him evidence that the members of the licensing trade have no particular liking for this measure.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They represent only 10 per cent. of the employees.

Comment on this

I challenge that. I think that figure is entirely unrealistic and I should like to refute it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is not.

Comment on this

Apart from that consideration, I should like to make the point that an extension of the hours is bound to have a deleterious effect on the social welfare of the community as a whole, and in particular, of those people directly engaged in the licensed trade. It has already been pointed out that very large numbers of people are engaged in the industry, either as employers or employees, and if this Bill is passed unamended, not alone will they be faced with problems of working longer hours but also, at the end of a long and a very tiring day, of having to find their own ways or means of getting home. In many cases, they will have to travel very long distances at a very late hour and that will also apply to a very large number of female workers in the trade. Surely nobody can stand up in this House and say that is a good thing? I submit it is a very bad thing and something we ought to try to avoid, if we can.

I should also like to criticise the Bill on the ground that it makes no provision whatever for the protection of the health and welfare of workers engaged in the licensed trade. In that respect, it is very lacking and while, perhaps, it might be necessary if there were some type of public demand for longer hours, we cannot ignore the fact that in the absence of such a demand, it is an entirely unnecessary imposition on quite a large and important section of the community.

In a general sense, I should like to make the point that there is obviously an unanswerable case for granting similar facilities to the rural areas on weekdays and Sundays as already exist in the urban areas, but even in that instance, we ought to make quite sure that, in passing this Bill, we are not creating greater anomalies and possibly encouraging greater abuses than those we are trying to cure. Very serious problems will arise when the Bill is passed if we are to have what is known as combined public houses and grocery shops, which represent a very large percentage of licensed premises in rural areas, opening on Sundays.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think that will arise on another amendment. That refers to Sunday opening and is not relevant here.

Comment on this

Then I shall come back to it when that section is reached, but I think it is a very important aspect of what ought to be debated by the House. Play has been made that the adoption of Senator Murphy's amendment could, in fact, be something like a reversion to the bona fide trade. That is utterly absurd. What is wrong at the moment is that there is a lack of uniformity in the hours of opening in the urban areas as distinct from rural areas, and we have the absurd position that houses on the fringe of cities are able to stay open longer at night than those in the cities. Surely that is a problem capable of a much easier solution than that suggested here? I do not think its solution would involve any protracted debate because the remedy is obvious—the introduction of uniformity in the hours of closing. It is not so important whether the closing hour be 10.30 p.m. or 11 p.m. Whatever is uniform will solve the problem and it should be possible to find agreement upon more reasonable hours than those suggested in the Bill.

As has been said, the law is being flouted at the moment and I believe it is most important to make sure that when this Bill is passed, the law will be observed strictly. In that connection I suggest that it is essential that, in future, the Government must eliminate the widespread evasion of the law by clubs. We have heard little mention of this during the debate but I suggest it is a very serious and important aspect of the problem and I hope the Minister will not overlook it. I want to suggest that instead of allowing the type of latitude that is still allowed in this Bill to clubs——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That also will be more relevant on another section.

Comment on this

Very good, Sir. I thought I might get away with it this time.

Comment on this

The Senator may be making an omnibus speech.

Comment on this

I thought I might facilitate the Chair by avoiding having to speak again. However, I shall enlarge on that point when the relevant section is under debate. Nothing I have heard so far from the Minister has convinced me that he has a case for the passing of this section of the Bill, without at least having a further look at the amendments. Like Senator Murphy, I believe it should be a very easy matter for us to find agreement upon a uniform hour, whether that hour be 10.30 p.m. or 11 p.m. as suggested by Senator O'Quigley. The important thing is that we should look for uniformity and if we make an honest approach to the matter, we can solve the problem.

Comment on this

I have some sympathy with the amendments but, on balance, I think the Bill as it stands represents about as good a compromise as one can reach. It ought, in theory, to be sufficient to say: "Well, you can drink in winter until 10.30 p.m. and in summer to 11 p.m.," but I am afraid if these amendments are accepted, in practice, they will be open to further abuses and that the problems we are trying to solve will not be solved. It would be nice to think that our people are, in the main, a people of adults, that they can respect the law, and that if we decide they shall not drink after 10.30 p.m., they will all go home as good citizens and give up drinking. I am not by any means averse to a drink myself, but I do think in general that far too much drink is absorbed in this country, but I do not believe you can make people virtuous by legislation. I do not believe you can compel a certain attitude if it is not widely acceptable.

I think It has been implied in many speeches today that if we keep the public houses open until 11.30 p.m. the drinking classes—as Senator O'Quigley referred to them in the plural, and I know it has been said that work is the curse of the drinking classes—will regard themselves as being obliged to remain in the public houses to drink until 11.30 p.m. I do not think that is the case, and I do not think it is the case that the public houses themselves need necessarily feel compelled to remain open until the last possible moment allowed by law.

It seems to me that in Senator O'Quigley's speech and in the speeches of one or two who supported him, there was an implied contradiction because he said that among the drinkers, the consumers, there was no great demand and yet Senator Murphy, I think, suggested that if one public house were to keep open until a later hour, they would all have to do so because of the competition. Competition is produced only by the demand of the consumer, and if it is true the consumers do not demand this late opening, then an occasional pub which remains open until a later hour would not take a very considerable amount of trade from others who decided to close earlier. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot say, on the one hand: "Every public house must remain open until the very last moment" and, on the other: "There is no demand among consumers for the late kind of drinking."

It was suggested by many people that the law at present is far less observed in the country than in the city. There was a suggestion, from Senator Burke, I think, that we might allow an extra half hour in the country. Of course, the result of that would be not that people would rush out for this extra half hour but that they would go out to the public houses where they could drink for an extra half hour and they would then rush back drunk in charge of their cars. You would have the same situation as at present.

Comment on this

They might not come in, either.

Comment on this

They might not come in and they might not arrive. The tendency would be to seek the extra half hour, if it is granted in the country. Therefore, it seems to me that perhaps, on balance, the Bill represents a good compromise. There is the extension of the hours. It would be nice if we could say we do not need to regulate this because we are a grown-up nation and we can take a drink or leave it. Some legislation, however, is necessary, and I think the present legislation, though there may be criticism of it, represents a happy compromise.

With regard to the point of the trade unions and late hours of working, I think that is irrelevant. It is up to the trade unions to negotiate the conditions of pay related to the work involved. If it is decided that this kind of late work requires a considerable increase in pay, that is the job of the trade union. It is not the job of Parliament to say: "Let us fix it so that a particular section of workers will not have to get their trade unions to do what they should do."

The same applies to the question of transport as related to these late hours. It might, no doubt, be quite a good thing in general, apart entirely from the drinking classes, to have some kind of late bus throughout the night in various parts of Dublin as they have in Glasgow and other big cities where drivers and conductors volunteer because they get double pay for that kind of work. I do not think that is really relevant to the question of late hours in public houses. The new hours proposed are not unreasonable for reasonable people. I do not believe that the unreasonable people will or can be cured by legislation. Therefore, I am opposed to these amendments.

Comment on this

I think that uniformity is necessary in the hour at which public houses close. It is true that most public houses are open to both bona fides and locals until 12 midnight. Whether or not that is flouting the law is not very important, because the fact is that most superintendents and sergeants of the Garda Síochána do not raid pubs in rural areas between 10.30 p.m. and 12 o'clock midnight. It is an unwritten law in some areas that locals can remain on the premises until 12 midnight. I have gone to political branch meetings in public houses off the main road and I have often seen the front door open until that hour. It is almost necessary that that should be the situation. In the country, men have to milk their cows around 5 p.m., but during the busy period, when they would most like a drink, they stay out in the fields cutting hay, if the weather is right, until 6 p.m. They come in, milk their cows, get the milk into the can and have their tea about 9.30 or 10 p.m. They then clean themselves up and go down to the pub for three or four bottles of stout and remain with their friends until shortly after 12 o'clock. Whether or not the fact that new time is not observed in quite a few country houses is a contributory factor, I do not know, but that is what happens in most of rural Ireland.

I remember when I was a Deputy hearing the former Deputy Dunne making a most impassioned plea on the Estimate for Justice on behalf of the fruit and vegetable growers of Rush and Lusk who had to work during the summer months for as long as daylight lasted and who could not have a drink until 12 o'clock. The reason he made that plea was that an area exemption order to give them the right to drink up to 12 o'clock had not been granted. The superintendent in that district was rather strict and insisted that only bona fides could be present from 10.30 to 12. Senator Murphy and Senator Crowley made an impassioned case for a minority, but here was a member of their own Party making an impassioned case from the opposite point of view but also on behalf of a minority.

While I agree there must be uniformity, there must be a later hour in the country, especially during the summer period, than 10.30 p.m. as is suggested in most of these amendments. I can see the difficulty in which Senator Miss Davidson, Senator Murphy and Senator Crowley find themselves. The ideal thing for the industrial worker who stops work at 5 or 6 o'clock would be that he should come home, have his tea, spend some time with his wife and then, if he is a member of the drinking classes, go down to his public house for an hour, be back in his bed after 11.30 and be fit to go to work at 8 o'clock the following morning. That would be the ideal for the industrial worker, but I feel the industrial worker should not impress his ideal on the whole of the country.

As Senator Sheehy Skeffington says, it is the job of the trade unions to negotiate for the workers in the public houses. Various classes of people all over the city, gas workers, firemen, street cleaners, have to work during the night, early in the morning or at various odd hours. Shift work of any kind is not pleasant, is not conducive to good health or to allowing a man spend the time he should with his family. However, modern living prescribes that such must occur. It is nobody's fault that these hours have to be worked. When the majority demands, the majority must rule. There is no more case for a barman who has to work until 11.30 at night than there is for a fireman who on certain weeks has to stay on duty all night or for a nurse in the Mater Hospital who for as long as six weeks at a time, is on the most arduous duty all night.

If the union or the trade association to which any worker belongs have a complaint, or if they feel that the home life or the family life of the worker is being interfered with, then it is their job to see to it that a change is made, that the employer gives more hours off or that there is shift work. If that means an extra penny on the pint, that, again, is no part of the difficulty with which this House is confronted. My view is that the compromise of 11.30 p.m. in the summer and 11 p.m. in the winter for town and country is as fair a compromise as could be devised, having regard to the country with its problems in the background and the town with its problems. The representatives of the organised workers make their case to create an ideal situation for the industrial worker but I think a fair compromise has been achieved and nothing better could be done.

I shall finish as I started by saying I believe that on Sundays or week days, with regard to closing at night, there must be uniformity. At that end of the period, there is a danger, and, as Senator Sheehy Skeffington said, even if the difference is only half an hour, people may be sitting in their motor car at 6 o'clock waiting to go for a drink and may decide: "We will go out three miles and settle down there, because we will have that extra half hour at the end." I feel quite certain that no better hours could be proposed than those contained in the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not see much merit in the amendment. What system of equity would the movers of the amendment substitute for the bona fide system. If we are all agreed that the object of the Bill is to create uniformity, it would create a differential. Are we to re-enact the bona fide clause? If not, I cannot see how we are to have this differential.

A Commission was set up in 1957, and the members were agreed to a large extent at any rate, that we must have uniformity. Therefore, if we seek to insert amendments of this description, we are throwing the trading hours back into chaos again and having recourse to some trade like the bona fide trade, which was so strongly condemned by all members of the Oireachtas, by the public and by everyone, so far as I can see, except the Dublin publicans. The Dublin publicans, apparently, constitute themselves as a sort of pressure group to ensure hours that suit themselves. As the Minister pointed out, there is no reason why we should let the tail wag the dog in this instance. The other parts of the country are entitled, by virtue of overwhelming numbers, if you like, to have uniformity. The main objective of the Bill is good, and it should be preserved.

Comment on this

In supporting the amendment to shorten the hours of trading in public houses under this Bill, I say once more that I believe it would be for the good of the general public, if the public house hours were shortened. I endeavoured to point out that view on Second Stage, and I am still of the same opinion. I was completely unimpressed by what I might describe as Senator Ó Maoláin's bibulous pilgrimage through the unholy lands——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maolán Fianna Fáil

Oh, no.

Comment on this

A European pubcrawl.

Comment on this

——and his claim that unrestricted drinking hours would be for the good of our people and would illustrate to the world the pride and freedom of our people. We are not unmindful of the fact that there are classes of workers who must work late hours and, at column 1522, Volume 52, of the Official Report of 8th June, I said:

We know there are certain essential undertakings where the employees cannot have the normal holidays and all reasonably-minded workers accept this situation.

I think that will be generally agreed.

I should also like to refer to something the Minister said in regard to the categories of workers who have to work unusual hours. At column 1540 of the same volume, the Minister said:

I attended a trade union function in the late months of last year in Clery's Restaurant and I did not leave the premises until 12 midnight. There must have been 60 to 100 girls employed there serving meals, drinks and so on to the guests of the trade union concerned. I was wondering at the meal how those girls were to get home. There is that type of trade that must be carried on. and the difficulties will no doubt be got over.

I interviewed the union which caters for these employees. I learned that that is not a normal staff. They wait at what are regarded as special functions. They are a special staff which begin work, perhaps, at 8 o'clock or 9 o'clock at night, and they are paid special rates, bearing in mind the fact that they have to pay for taxis to get home.

The Minister then went on to say:

Then there is the ordinary hotel trade where workers may work to three o'clock in the morning and people can be served with meals and drink, and they, too, have to get home.

The union assured me that there is no ordinary hotel trade where the workers work to three a.m. and then have to go home. They assured me that no staff works late in hotels except the special staffs who work for what they call special functions.

Comment on this

A number of arguments have been advanced as to why the hours should be changed by half an hour or an hour, and some of these arguments have something to recommend them. At this stage of the Bill, we should completely reject the suggestion, which is still being made by some Senators, that there is no demand for later hours than those existing at present. It seems to me to be completely at variance with the facts to say there is no demand for later hours. It is quite clear, if we take, for instance, the bona fide system in Dublin when there are tens of thousands of people leaving the pubs in Dublin every night and getting into cars and going to the bona fide houses——

Comment on this

That is a bit of exaggeration.

Comment on this

I shall not go into the figures. Say, 9,000 or 8,000 are leaving the city——

Comment on this

How many bona fide houses are there in Dublin?

Comment on this

Name a figure.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

We do not know.

Comment on this

They represent thousands of people who are obviously demanding later hours than the existing hours of 10 p.m. or 10.30 p.m. in the public houses in Dublin. It is quite clear that by going to the bona fide premises, they are demanding later hours. It is quite clear that the tens of thousands—this time I shall say tens of thousands without qualification—of people all over the country about whom we have heard again and again, who drink in the local public house well after the permitted hours are demanding later hours than are permitted under the present law. If the fact that they are drinking after the permitted hours is not a proof that they demand later hours, I do not know what one could bring forward by way of proof.

Recent statistics of the thousands of offences against the licensing laws are an indication that people are not satisfied with the existing hours. They persist in drinking after the permitted hours. That is absolutely clear proof that there is a demand for later hours than those permitted under existing laws. Whatever arguments are adduced for adjusting hours—arguments, for instance, that we are a weak people who must be protected against ourselves which in itself is arguable—let us face the fact that there is a demand for later hours and let us approach the amendments and the Bill on the basis that there is undoubtedly such a demand.

When we talk about hours, it is a question of getting hours for which the people will settle. It is a question of getting a compromise which will have the support of the public generally. If the hours are fixed too early, people will not be satisfied and will not settle for them and there will be widespread evasion as there is at present. It is necessary to have hours which will appear to the public to be reasonable in all the circumstances and will be somewhat later than those allowed at the moment.

The hours in the Bill are as good a compromise as can be got, bearing in mind that many people would like much later hours while many other people might think it proper that there should be much earlier hours. Although some good arguments have been adduced for the amendment, we must agree that the hours in the Bill are better.

Comment on this

In his intervention, the Minister referred to the Commission of which I was a member. I signed the Minority Report but that minority was a very substantial minority. Indeed, for a time, the Commission were in grave doubt as to which was the Majority Report. However, some persons signed one way and, as a result, what we thought was the Minority Report became the Majority Report. I happened to be with that very substantial minority.

The minority had something to say about the closing hours. There is nothing illogical in what I have advocated here and the fact that I signed the Minority Report. The views I have been expressing here are similar to the views expressed by this very substantial minority. In its report, that minority said:

After hearing the evidence of employers, workers, temperance organisations and consumers, we reached the conclusion that there was no general demand for longer hours in the County Boroughs, although we are prepared to recommend the removal of the present distinction between Summer and Winter and to suggest 10.30 p.m. closing all the year round.

We fully agree that in the country areas the later working habits of the population and other reasons justify a week-day closing hour there of 11.30 p.m. and we realise that this, coupled with our proposal for the cities, creates a difference of one hour between the country and the County Borough closing times. We also recommend that there should be general opening throughout the whole country on Sundays.

In making this recommendation it will be noted that its effect would be to reduce the differential in trading hours between County Boroughs and other areas, at present two hours in Winter and one and half in Summer, to a flat one hour all the year round. We are satisfied that this recommendation will create no problem or give grounds for abuse.

At this point I want to say something about the very holy word that has been introduced in regard to the licensing laws, the word "uniformity." We are told it is essential that there should be uniformity in the trading hours throughout the country. There is the view that the bona fide trade was the background to this “uniformity.” There was a substantial difference between the closing hour in the county boroughs and outside the county boroughs, which encouraged people, if they had a few drinks taken and when they were less logical and less reasonable than they might otherwise be, to travel further to have more drinks and thereafter to be a danger to themselves and other road users.

The argument of the Minority Report is that a distinction of one hour would cut out that sort of traffic. On leaving the public house at 10.45 p.m., when the closing hour was 10.30 p.m., people would not be disposed to jump into their cars and run helter-skelter out the country to a public house that would close at 11.30 p.m. It was reasoned that that difference was not sufficiently wide enough to permit the continuance of the bona fide trade.

That Minority Report had regard to what I have regard to, namely, the need of the publicans, of the employers and of the drinking public in the county borough areas. It did not disregard what Senators have been speaking about now, namely, the different social habits in the rural areas. That was a reasonable approach. Senators might dismiss from their minds the very holy word "uniformity" which has been introduced. We are generally reasonable at this hour of the afternoon. Being reasonable people, we must recognise that a closing hour of 10.30 p.m. in the city and 11.30 in the country areas, if we want it, would not encourage the continuance of the bona fide traffic and would meet the needs of the county borough people and the rural community.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Pioneer Total Abstinence Association not keen on that word "uniformity"?

Comment on this

They were, but I do not imagine it can be argued that the Total Abstinence people are, as is implied, in favour of or very anxious for a closing hour of 11.30 p.m. for four months of the year.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They ought to have as much interest in protecting the people as the Senators over there, seeing that they signed the report for the 11.30 p.m. closing.

Comment on this

Is Senator Ó Maoláin speaking on behalf of the Total Abstinence people?

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7.15 p.m.

Comment on this

It has been asserted by Senator Ó Maoláin that the trade unions represented only ten per cent. of the workers involved. I wonder to what workers he is referring. If he is referring to the workers involved in Dublin, definitely the assertion is not correct. The workers employed in the public houses in Dublin are practically completely organised in trade unions.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How many of them are in the Dublin pubs?

Comment on this

Does the Senator mean the workers employed in public houses throughout the country? I should imagine that if he is referring to the people who work in public houses, many of whom are the proprietors and their families, ten per cent. might be correct but when I refer to workers, I refer to the people employed, who are paid a wage and who are not simply the proprietors or the families of the proprietors.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is what I was referring to.

Comment on this

Is the Senator referring to the actual people?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Assistants, porters and so on.

Comment on this

I think the Senator's information is quite incorrect. They are practically fully organised in Dublin, Cork and other big centres. They are organised by different unions but they are trade union members, generally speaking.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What is the percentage of the total number employed in the trade?

Comment on this

I have not that information readily available. I could not accept the assertion that only ten per cent. of the people employed are organised.

Comment on this

The employees— people who are employed and paid wages.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

Senator Sheehy Skeffington usually—I am sorry he is not here—makes a knowledgeable contribution to the debate on any Bill before the house, but in regard to this Bill, I think he is not particularly knowledgeable. Anybody who knows the trade we are talking about will, I think, acknowledge that there is no real contradiction in my asserting there is no public demand for a later closing hour than 10.30 p.m. and my suggesting, at the same time, that public houses in the city of Dublin could not possibly close before 11.30 p.m., if the law puts the closing time back to 11.30 p.m. We all know, when people have a few drinks at that time of the night, as I said earlier and as I said on Second Reading, they are not quite the same people as they are at 8 o'clock or 9 o'clock the following morning.

Senators were kind enough to acknowledge that there were arguments for a 10.30 p.m. closing hour in Dublin city and, I think, in the other county boroughs, but I must also accept the arguments put up by Senators, who know more about the rural problem, that a 10.30 p.m. closing hour would not suit the rural community. I want to suggest that it is not impossible for us to meet both points of view. There is, I think, a good point of view against an 11.30 p.m. closing time in the county borough areas and there is equally as good a point of view in favour of an 11.30 p.m. closing in the rural areas. I think it is possible to meet both points of view.

It was asserted that the Dublin publicans and the employees were trying to stuff their point of view down the throats of the majority in the country and that they wanted the hours changed to suit their particular point of view. I am suggesting it is possible to meet their point of view and that it is equally possible, at the same time, to meet the point of view of the rural areas.

I should be prepared to withdraw this amendment, if there were any indication that between now and Report Stage favourable consideration would be given to trying to meet those two points of view; in other words, a different closing time in the county boroughs and the rural areas. The answer which I know the Minister has in mind is the desirability of uniformity, but, as I said earlier on, let us think of the arguments in favour of uniformity. It is no magic word. The idea behind uniformity was to cut out the bona fide traffic, any abuses which crept into the bona fide trade.

I want to suggest to the House— this is my view and I think it is reasonable—that if there is a difference of one hour between the closing time in the county borough and rural area, there will not be that movement to the rural area from the city public houses when they close. That is where the abuses have arisen. That is what the Minister and all sides of the House should want to stop—that movement out, when the city pubs close, to the bona fide public house for another hour and a half of drinking during the summer period, with its consequent risk to life and limb.

I want to suggest that if public houses in the city close at 10.30 p.m. possibly people will not leave them until 10.45 p.m. If the closing time in the rural area is 11.30 p.m. they will not think it worth while then to get into their cars and charge out to the country for the small time that is left, between the closing time in the city and in the rural area. In that way, you would not have the abuse of the bona fide trade; you would not have that inducement to leave the city public houses when they close and proceed to the bona fide houses.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator suggest that the public houses which by law are supposed to close at 10.30 p.m. may not actually close until 10.35 p.m.? Therefore the law will not be enforced.

Comment on this

It would be, in the sense that there would be no serving of drink after 10.30 p.m. Surely nobody envisages that under the new law everybody will be out of the public houses at 11.30 p.m.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why not?

Comment on this

That is unreasonable and impracticable and could not be done.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It can be done, but you want until 10.30 p.m. to ensure that it is done.

Comment on this

I know what happens in the North where the law is very rigidly enforced and where there is provision for very heavy fines for breaking the law. Even there, the public houses are not cleared at the time laid down in the legislation. There is always that ten minutes or quarter of an hour between the closing time and the time the people leave the premises. I do not think there is anything unreasonable in suggesting that with a difference of simply one hour, there would not be that inducement for people to leave the city public houses and proceed to the rural area. In that way the point of view of the people in the county borough and in the rural area would be met.

There is no political point of view involved in this. If we can—and it is the responsibility of the House to endeavour to do it—we must try to meet the wishes of as many people as possible in this new legislation. I should like the Minister to give us some indication that between now and the Report Stage, he will give favourable consideration to the suggestion that both points of view could be met, without running the risk of continuing the bona fide trade and the abuses which have crept in in regard to that trade. I hope other Senators who know the circumstances of the rural community will agree with me that this is a fair compromise which would be generally satisfactory and that they will ask the Minister to adopt it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We would then have to vote against the Minister.

Comment on this

In commenting upon the amendments before the House, the Minister quoted an extract from the Commission's Report as indicating that there was in fact a demand for the hours set out in the Bill. I have referred before, and I intend to continue to refer, within the rules of order——

Comment on this

Not with undue repetition, I hope.

Comment on this

——within the rules of order, to refer to the position when the reports of commissions suit the Government. The reports then become the Bible and are quoted in the Seanad and the Dáil as being the last word. The Minister in this case reads an extract and that is an end of the matter. "The Commission had convincing evidence..." If, as frequently happens, the Government do not accept the recommendations of a commission, the report is then of no value whatever. Accordingly, as far as reading extracts from commissions' reports affects me, I must say I do not place any reliance whatsoever on them and when the Minister must quote from the Report of the Commission here, it weakens his position.

The fact is there is no disputing the need for meeting the reasonable requirements of the people in rural Ireland. Therefore, there was no necessity for the Minister to read any extract from the Report. Everybody agrees that as far as Sunday opening hours were concerned, the law was quite inequitable, unreasonable and unjust, as far as the people of rural Ireland were affected. Therefore, I do not see what was the necessity for reading from the Report.

It will be accepted that it is desirable to have uniformity of hours throughout the State. In fact this Bill will become known as the great Act of Uniformity. I wish that Senator O'Reilly were here. He is wont to illustrate current problems by reference to Irish and Continental history, and he could tell us how much suffering and tribulation the Act of Uniformity of Henry VIII brought to this country. I am concerned very much as to whether certain sections of this Act of Uniformity will cause strong tribulations to families by too late drinking hours in the cities and in rural Ireland.

I quite concede that there will be occasions when people in rural Ireland working on the farms, cutting hay at this time of the year and later on cutting corn, will be working as long as there is daylight, and at the end of a hard day, in order to get the hayseed out of their throats and noses, will find it desirable to have a drink in a public house. You cannot store pints in an ordinary dwelling house; therefore, the man on the farm is entitled to have his pint freshly drawn from the barrel.

That is the justification for saying that his reasonable requirements must be met; but we must also bear in mind that the number of occasions on which that type of necessity will arise is extremely limited. The number of days in any year on which people will work as long as there is daylight to cut hay, even on the biggest farm, will be very few, and the same applies to corn. You do not have people working to all hours, once they have been cut, except, perhaps, cutting turf and coming home late. That will happen only on a very few nights during the summer.

Therefore, when you come to talk about rural needs, it should be borne in mind that as a matter of practice and fact, 11 p.m. is not at all unreasonable and would probably be quite satisfactory, certainly during the whole summer period, and for the few days that would be involved, people would be prepared to put up with any inconvenience that might arise. We should also bear in mind that this is in fact an improvement on the existing position.

Senator Ó Maoláin was somewhat unkind to me when he spoke of my knowing only the views of the best people.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You asked for it.

Comment on this

My views are got from people drinking at the bars of public houses, and good people drink at the bars of public houses, though they are not the best people in the sense in which Senator Ó Maoláin used that phrase. The best people are to be found in clubs, as the Senator knows.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not belong to any clubs.

Comment on this

I do not either, and my views, as gathered from people drinking in bars in Dublin and in the country, are that there is no demand whatever for the hours in this Bill, but great reluctance and fear that, if they come in, people will be compelled to change their way of life. That arises from the fact that they will not leave at 10.30 p.m. What will be keeping them there is natural fondness for having an extra drink in social company. They do not want to have that temptation to keep them. I remember recently hearing at a mission or some such religious gathering a preacher outline the different ways of dealing with temptation, and saying that one very good way was to run away from it. People will not run out of public houses, and they do not want to be put in this situation because they know that they will not run away from it.

Senator Ó Maoláin refers to the fact that on the Continent people can drink round the clock. That is so, but we know what alcoholism has cost France. Eighteen months ago, it was said that it was costing more than the Algerian War, which was costing £1,000,000 a day.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We know what restrictions are doing in the case of Sweden, which has the highest suicide rate in Europe.

Comment on this

Talking about the highest suicide rate in Europe in Sweden is hardly relevant.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is as relevant as the Algerian War.

Comment on this

I am talking merely about what it costs in France. As far as suicide is concerned, I should like to have statistics as to how many per thousand of the Swedish population go to church every Sunday of the year.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What has that to do with it?

Comment on this

That probably accounts for a great deal of the suicide, where people have no hope and nothing to live for.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense. They are very religious people in Sweden.

Comment on this

We shall not accept that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not accept my word. Make inquiries yourself.

Comment on this

Senators must not cast aspersions on other people.

Comment on this

I respectfully agree with your ruling, Sir.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Bring the Senator back from Algeria and I shall return from Sweden.

Comment on this

If I were not rocketed about the place by Senator Ó Maoláin, I would not find myself in the position that I have to draw attention to these known and established statistical facts. I want also to refer to another factor—the effect of drink on people here and in Continental countries.

Comment on this

The remarks, I hope, will be relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

Entirely relevant, because they all bear on whether or not the hours suggested in the Bill or those in the amendment are the more desirable. In that context, Senator Ó Maoláin referred to the hours, or lack of hours, on the Continent. I am trying to distinguish the two positions. On the Continent, the alcoholic content of whatever people are drinking as compared with what people drink here is much lower. That of course has its own effect on the amount of intoxication to be found there. You cannot merely talk about what causes it on the Continent without taking into consideration all these other relevant factors. We can be certain that Senator Ó Maoláin and those who support longer hours will say the trade unions are entitled to fight for higher wages, which will be passed on to the consumer, so that as a result of this measure the price of drink ought to be increased.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense.

Comment on this

That is the clear result of what has been said. The price of drink will undoubtedly be increased as a result of longer working hours which the staffs of public houses will have to work.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They will not have longer working hours. The Conditions of Employment Act will look after that.

Comment on this

The price is going up. Everybody knows that.

Comment on this

They will be working at later hours at night. It may be some consolation at this stage for the drinking public to know that they are getting a cheaper pint and a cheaper bottle of stout now before the passing of this Bill than they will get six months after its passage, and they ought to drink and be merry, for tomorrow they will be paying for it through their noses.

Senator Murphy has robbed me of a comment I was about to make on Senator Sheehy Skeffington's contribution. Senator Sheehy Skeffington is always able to fit every Bill before this House into the socialist pattern which he advocates on every possible occasion. On this occasion, there is nothing on which dialectical materialism or anything of that kind can be brought to bear on this measure, and so, whether it is good or bad, Senator Sheehy Skeffington on this occasion has forborne to advocate that the State should nationalise all public houses and that then all would be well for the drinking classes. He has forborne to do that, but endeavoured to make some kind of comment upon the contributions made by Senator Murphy and myself. It is perfectly clear that he was completely at sea and in as much fog when talking about this matter as he would find himself at about twenty minutes to eleven in any public house at night-time.

The plain fact of the matter is, as Senator Murphy said, that if one public house in an area decides to remain open it does not matter whether all the other public houses are content to close or that the majority of the drinking people are also content to stop drinking at the hour the majority of the public houses will close. All houses will have to remain open and the inevitable tendency will be that everybody will drink for the full stretch of the time allowed in this Bill. There is no inconsistency between that statement and the statement that people do not want the new hours proposed in the Bill.

It was amusing to listen to Senator Ryan talk about the tens of thousands of people—mark you, the tens of thousands of people—leaving Dublin every evening after 10.30 in summertime to go out to the bona fide houses. There must be a great many more public houses around Dublin than we thought and they must be ten times or twenty times larger than we thought if they can accommodate the tens of thousands of people who go out to them from Dublin.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There are seven hundred or eight hundred of them——

Comment on this

There are not.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

——within reach of Dublin.

Comment on this

Seven or eight would be more like it. The point, however, to be deduced from Senator Ryan's view of the demand that these people represent is that because we have an intemperate and immoderate set of drinking people who say that they must get into their cars after drinking in Dublin and go out to the bona fide houses, because they exist the whole law should be revised to meet their particular requirements. I thought the Minister and Senator Ó Maoláin were talking about the greatest good for the greatest number. According to Senator Ryan, because there is a set of people who constitute a minority, and a minority of intemperate habits—that applies to a great number of the people who went to the bona fide houses—the whole pattern of social behaviour and of drinking should be changed. That to my mind is a most pernicious argument and if for no other reason than to scotch that outlook I think these amendments should be accepted.

Comment on this

As one who has some knowledge of the trade from both ends, both as a supplier and as one being supplied, I as a rural trader would like to say that as far as I am aware the Bill is welcomed in country districts. While I listened to the debate for the last few hours I found it hard to reconcile the different points of view expressed by Senator Murphy and Senator O'Quigley. I wonder if the people in the trade in Dublin would be so enthusiastic as Senator Murphy would like us to think if there were different trading hours in the city of Dublin and outside the borough? Would it not occur to him that, in the first instance, the customer would not bother going to his local public house? Would he not naturally go where he could remain for the longest time? I think he would. There was a certain amount of discussion about the number of people who leave Dublin after regular closing hours and while the Dublin people do not seem to agree on the matter, if my memory serves me right, the traffic on any road by which I have ever left Dublin resembled the traffic coming from a race meeting so great were the numbers going to popular and even unpopular public houses. I can assure the House that they are not all local people.

I hope that whatever time the Minister decides on will be enforced rigidly because it is a well-known fact that what I would describe as undesirable drinking takes place. I agree with Senator O'Quigley when he speaks about the different types of people who frequent different types of bars, ordinary bars and lounge bars. To my mind the lounge bar was introduced to cater for both males and females. I agree that where they drink is not so important as the conditions under which they drink. It is well known that certain places can remain open until any time at night they wish, while others are not allowed to do so. Because of that I hope that whenever the Bill is enacted it will be rigidly enforced. I hope the position will be put on a sound basis for the next twenty to thirty years.

The trade all over the country is quite happy about the Minister's attitude towards the reduction of licences. It is a step in the right direction and I should like to compliment the Minister and his predecessors on that aspect of the Bill. The aim of previous Ministers has been to cut down the licences——

Comment on this

That matter does not arise on the second amendment.

Comment on this

I respectfully submit that it is relevant in the sense that the object the Minister has in mind is to reduce the number of licences as far as possible.

Comment on this

It may be a fact hut it is not relevant on this amendment.

Comment on this

Very well. That is my contribution.

Comment on this

I realise of course, that we are simply attempting to sail against the wind in this discussion but nevertheless we have a duty to perform. I notice that Senator Ó Maoláin and Senator O'Quigley have one thing in common—that neither is a member of a club of any sort. I am afraid I cannot even find that much in common with Senator Ó Maoláin on this Bill because I belong to a modest club. I was really rather shocked when the Minister, in answer to the case I made about the position in the city of Dublin, quoted from the Report a sentence which specifically referred to the rural areas:

We had convincing evidence from all over the country that the present hours fail to meet actual needs in rural areas.

Comment on this