We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959—Committee Stage.

Contributions 225–467 of 467. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959
Enacted

No. 41 of 1959 ›

What is the reference?

Comment on this

The reference is the Report of the Commission of Inquiry, the Majority Report, at page 11. I think Senator Murphy, being a member of the Commission, may have felt constrained to be more modest than I am going to be in dealing with this matter. This Report was signed by 12 people and there was a Minority Report signed by nine. The Minority Report was made the Majority Report by the fact that the two members representing the Pioneer Total Abstinence Association switched sides. That is common knowledge and that is how the Minority Report became the Majority Report. And this is the body that deluged us with literature about this Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

After all, the Pioneers should know something about it.

Comment on this

Apparently they know a lot about switching sides. I do not know about saying they were going to sign one thing and then coming along and signing exactly the opposite. I was not a member of the Commission and therefore I feel quite entitled to say what a member of it might not like to say about his brethren on the commission. This Majority Report, as such, is not worth the paper it is written on. I am not suggesting that there are not interesting things in it such as this provision about Sunday opening, which I think is a great improvement, and making conditions uniform throughout the country, but when we look at the problem one is up against if one tried to get the views—and on this I insist —of the owners of public houses in Dublin, the workers and the people who drink in the public houses in Dublin, it is tremendous.

There was a great belief, as I said, that there would be an hour of 11 o'clock fixed and that the workers would then be able to get home with the available transport facilities at present. There is no use in Senator Ó Maoláin talking about discussions or absence of discussions. Let us be clear about it. I heard some little discussion on this problem. After all, the Bill has been in existence for six or nine months. It was thrashed right out; then it went underground; and then the rumpus broke out in the Fianna Fáil Party; and when it bobbed up again, there was a general belief that the Bill was to be altered to that extent and that the uniform hour would be 11 o'clock all over the country, summer and winter. There is no use in Senator Ó Maoláin talking about a minority of employers and workers who will dictate to the majority and deny the majority comfort and convenience. I do not know whether I heard correctly or not——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator did.

Comment on this

I am talking about opinions now, the opinions that were unanimously conveyed from inside the counter, on top of the counter and outside the counter. They were all the same here in the city of Dublin, that the existing hours were fairly reasonable. They admitted that there was a case relating to the country and they were trying, like sensible people, to see how they could reach some via media, a middle of the road course——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

In how many public houses could that spot check be said to have been made? The Senator says it was inside, outside, up on the counter and down off the counter—was it in one public house, or in 10, I want to know?

Comment on this

In 700 or 800, if the Senator wants me to say it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator does not believe that?

Comment on this

I believe that this view was commonly held all over the city of Dublin and nobody could shake me in that belief, certainly no statement by anybody supporting the Minister on the Bill in this House. We know the Senator said that the trade unions represent only 10 per cent. of the employees and that he certainly was not correct. There are 3,000 employees, if my recollection is correct —I recall it from the time of the strike, 3,000 to 3,500—in public houses in the city of Dublin.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And in the whole country?

Comment on this

The Senator suggested that only 10 per cent. of the workers——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

How many are there in the whole country employed in the licensed trade?

Comment on this

There are certainly not ten times 3,000.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator should get that figure before he starts talking about Dublin.

Comment on this

The word "employee" has a specific meaning—a person who is paid wages—and I take it the Senator was talking of the people. Why did he not bring in all the people, the drinkers and——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I was talking about barmen and porters.

Comment on this

And any farm labourer who helps to roll in a barrel of porter for the local woman down the country—why does he not include that person?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator should find out how many workers are employed.

Comment on this

That can be found out. My recollection is 3,000 or 3,500 in the city of Dublin.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Get the figure for the country and then let us have the proportion for Dublin.

Comment on this

All right, I shall make a statistical guess.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We do not guess about statistics.

Comment on this

I should say that half the people employed in the liquor business are in the city of Dublin. That is my statistical guess as to the number of employees.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You are a long way out.

Comment on this

Senator Sheehy Skeffington made one reflection. He said if we were a nation of adults, we might be trusted perhaps with unlimited drinking hours. When the question of France was discussed here some time ago. Senator Ó Maoláin asked: "What about the Swedes?" He said: "Look what happened in Sweden about whiskey restrictions". But it was the other way round. He said the problem was so terrible that they had to ration whiskey. That was not what caused the trouble. It was the other way. The trouble was because——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense. There were no public houses open. They had to do the drinking secretly. That is correct.

Comment on this

Would the Senator get back to the amendment?

Comment on this

Having made that remark, that if we were a nation of adults, we might be trusted with unlimited drinking hours, Senator Sheehy Skeffington said that far too much drink is absorbed in this country. If there is far too much drink absorbed here today, I wonder what it was like in 1900 when the consumption was about three or four times what it is today per head. Quite frankly, I think the consumption of drink is extremely moderate here. I knew a good lady who came to live in this city and she was here for 10 years, she told me, before she saw a man drunk. She had come from a big town in the midlands where, before the first World War, it was a common thing to see them every Saturday night. I saw them myself in the small town of Clonmel nearly 50 years ago and it was a common sight then, but conditions have changed completely and there is no use in pretending that there is any grave social problem associated with the licensed trade today. I may be wrong but that is my opinion.

Comment on this

Why fight about it? After all, there is only half an hour involved?

Comment on this

I shall answer the Senator. It is only a half-hour but it is a very important half-hour. It is upsetting an agreement between the employers and 3,500 workers. Not only that but, beyond question, it will increase the prices of drink.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Who said it?

Comment on this

I do not mind who said it or who did not say it. I am saying it will.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We do not believe everything the Senator says.

Comment on this

Senator O'Donovan.

Comment on this

Senator Ryan said that suggestions are still being made by some Senators that there is no demand for later hours. I insist that that is correct, that there is no demand in the city of Dublin for later hours. The licensees in Dublin were prepared to compromise to meet the position in relation to rural Ireland and to try to get some agreed middle of the way. There is no use in getting proof. What is the proof that there is a demand for later hours?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What proof is there that there is not?

Comment on this

I shall give the proof provided by a number of Senators just to show the kind of proof it is. The proof of the demand for longer hours is that, the bona fide trade being in existence, on certain occasions—it only happens on certain occasions and only once in a while—people will leave the city of Dublin at 10.30 p.m. because they are in that humour and will go out to one of the houses on the periphery of the city. The total number of these houses is not at all large. I think of an area that I know reasonably well. There is one in Templeogue, one above Whitechurch, one at Goatstown, which is well known to large numbers of people, one at Stepaside, which is also well known. There is a tremendous area and you have only four or five that I can think of.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator's travelling was very limited, if that is the best he can do.

Comment on this

It is a fair segment of the circle around the city.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator should stop talking if that is the best he can think of.

Comment on this

The Senator can add to it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I certainly can. I have told the Senator the figure.

Comment on this

The Senator mentioned a figure of 700 or 800.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Go ahead. Let the Senator give me a list of the ones he knows.

Comment on this

It is an absurd figure as a serious figure in this discussion. I might have a view that the bona fide trade is not at all the serious thing it has been set up to be but I am prepared to go with the Minister that it is desirable to have uniformity, that is, only assuming that there is no other solution. I think there is a possible other solution. If there were a special law in relation to this area, where so many people are employed, that is, the area of the city and county of Dublin, and perhaps the town of Bray, anybody who wanted to go ten to 15 miles would be welcome to it. One way of amending the law would have been to extend the distance from three miles to ten miles. If it were the case that you would not be a bona fide traveller until you had gone ten or 12 miles, that would kill a whole lot of it.

It seems to me that it is no proof that there is a demand for later hours to say that there are at present later hours in existence by the fact of intoxicating liquor being available up to 12 midnight almost within three or four miles of the centre of the city of Dublin, not alone three or four miles from the suburbs. It is available within a couple of miles of the suburbs. That is no proof at all of a demand for later hours.

The final point I would make is this. I take it the Government do not want the cost of living to go up. I take it it is accepted, the cost of intoxicating liquor being included in the index of the cost of living now, that the cost of intoxicating liquor is part of the cost of living. It may not be part of the cost of existence, as someone has commented. Certainly if these hours are imposed on the trade in Dublin, as is apparently the intention, there is not the slightest doubt that the price of drink in the city of Dublin will go up. People may say that that is no concern of ours. I think it is a serious concern. The proof of that is quite simple. The men working in public houses get double time for Sundays, and if these hours are imposed there will have to be complete readjustment of the hours, whether by increasing staff or giving time and a half for overtime for the extra hours now being imposed on the trade. Therefore, so far as the city of Dublin is concerned this Bill is all wrong.

I am not saying that the Bill, if it could be implemented, has not great merits so far as the rest of Ireland is concerned. I know the Minister feels that it is harsh when we say—he has protested that we ought not to say it and I appreciate that the Minister is certainly in earnest about it—we are imposing an evil on the city of Dublin for which there is going to be no countervailing benefit to the rest of the country. If I were satisfied that this Bill could be implemented absolutely in the rest of the country I would think about it again but the evils that will arise in the city are considerable and could be abated by a reasonable approach to the present hours.

Comment on this

May we take it that the Minister will conclude the debate on these amendments now?

Comment on this

I want to make a correction.

Comment on this

Will I be allowed to move my amendments?

Comment on this

I am prepared to give way.

Comment on this

We are still on amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 4.

Comment on this

I misunderstood the Chair.

Comment on this

Senator O'Donovan appears to impute some dishonest motive to the representatives of the Pioneer Total Abstinence Association. They were in a very difficult position, as we must all know. They were representing a very strict type of temperance organisation and they were faced with coming to a decision which must have been a very difficult one for them. They came to their decision on grounds which they made very clear in a separate report of their own in the course of which they said:

In accepting the recommendations concerning closing hours on weekdays we are aware that a closing hour as late as 11.30 p.m. carries many serious disadvantages not the least being an undue interference with family life with regard to owners, assistants and patrons of licensed premises. However, as the alternative to a general closing hour of 11.30 p.m. was to allow different closing hours in the city and the country and so to open the door to abuses attached to bona fide trading we have agreed to this recommendation so as to secure a uniform closing hour in all areas. We would prefer a general closing hour in all areas of 11 p.m.

That was a reasonable statement of their case and indicated the difficult position in which they found themselves. There was nothing dishonest in their taking that decision. In regard to Sunday opening, having said something similar, making reference to the hours of Divine Service and so on, they said:

We are not happy in agreeing to the hours 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. recommended in the Report. The alternative, however, was to allow different hours, of opening in different areas which would, in our opinion, lead to greater disadvantages than are contained in a uniform opening period of 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. For this reason we subscribed to the recommendation.

That was the only reason they had for voting as they did vote. Looking at the Commission's Report I happened to notice that Senator Murphy voted for 11.30 in that minority report.

Comment on this

For the rural areas.

Comment on this

Yes, for the establishment of the bona fide trade. It would be more honest if Senator Murphy put down an amendment saying that the bona fide trade should not be interfered with because what he is doing is trying to establish the bona fide trade through a back door. I will resist that as strongly as I can. The Senator perhaps does not realise it, but that is the effect it will have.

We have been talking about figures and Senator Ryan referred to the numbers of people leaving the city to participate in the bona fide trade. He was not too far out because I have now found after making inquiries that there are 186 houses around Dublin dealing in the bona fide trade. If those 186 houses were to deal with, say, only 50 customers, there would be a total of 9,300 customers. However, it is possible that during the hours of bona fide trading 100 customers could be catered for. If so, there would be nearly 19,000 people catered for.

Comment on this

Totally impossible. Did the Minister ever see a pub that accommodated 100 people?

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

They would be coming and going.

Comment on this

Senators were also arguing theoretically on a large number of points. I cannot deal with theoretical assumptions. I must deal with facts and the fact is that there are 492 licensed premises in Dublin and Dún Laoghaire and they employ 1,721 members of unions; in addition, 500 union members are employed in licensed premises in places like Cork and Galway. Therefore, about 700 licensed premises employ roughly 2,200 assistants and there are almost 12,000 licensed premises throughout the country.

Where did I get these figures? That is a fair question to ask. They are not my figures. These figures were supplied by the trade union representatives who were giving evidence before the Commission. I find it very difficult to believe that Senator Murphy is really serious when he suggests there should be a difference of an hour between the closing time in the city of Dublin and in County Dublin. Surely that is the re-establishment of the bona fide trade.

Comment on this

Then I shall give up trying to reason with the Senator. I find it impossible to reason with a Senator who will not admit that to suggest a difference of an hour between the city of Dublin and the county is an attempt to re-establish the bona fide trade. If uniformity is not attained, there will be the city of Dublin, with its boundary and on one side of that boundary line within, say, 100 yards of it, there will be premises that must close at a certain time, and on the other side of that line premises that can remain open for another hour. What kind of abuse would that lead to? There will be no need to drive from one place to the other to get drink.

If we were to accept such a suggestion, which as I have already said is a most unreal one, what Senator Sheehy Skeffington said would be perfectly correct. People would not rush out of the public house at 11.30 to get drink in the other premises for the extra half-hour. They would be out there two or three hours before that, knowing full well they would have the extra hour sitting in the public house in the country. That is what we want to prevent. We want to ensure that all over the State the police will know that there is a certain fixed hour, 11.30, and that 11.30 is the hour they must see enforced.

I cannot hope to convince any of the Senators who have spoken on the other side. I am satisfied that they are wedded to the amendments they have put down. I can only assume from the figures I have given here that they are not fully acquainted with the facts, and I would only be wasting the time of the House if I tried to argue any further against these amendments. We could go on talking until we adjourn and we would not get any further.

Comment on this

The Minister charged me with being dishonest in my argument in this matter. I shall excuse him because, as he said the last day, he has no experience in regard to public houses, being a teetotaller; similarly the members of the Pioneer Association have no great knowledge of the actual situation. What I am arguing here is that this Minority Report, which was once the Majority Report except for the switching of the views of the representatives of the Total Abstinence Association—and this should be noted by Senator Brennan—which advocated a closing hour of 10.30 in the county borough areas and 11.30 in the rest of the country, was signed not alone by the trade union representatives but by the representatives of the publicans of Dublin.

Comment on this

The interested parties.

Comment on this

The organised group of publicans in Dublin, the employers, were satisfied that this differentiation would not be harmful to them. The differentiation advocated in this Minority Report, which I suggest might now be carefully considered again, was a differentiation of one hour as against a difference which gives rise now to the bona fide trade of two hours in winter and an hour-and-a-half in summer. It is because of that fact that it is worth while for some people, having taken some drink in a city public house, to travel to a bona fide premises. The Minister should consult his own Party and ask their view as to whether they think a difference of one hour would present a great problem and whether they think there would be that rush from city public houses to rural public houses. In fact, by the time people would get to these areas from the centre of the city, the hour would be well passed.

I am not trying to introduce bona fide traffic again by the back door. I wish the Minister would accept my honesty in the matter. I am advocating the view which was subscribed to by the organised workers; and the organised workers are entitled to their point of view. I am also advocating the view of the publicans in Dublin. I think it represents the view also of the publicans in the other county borough areas. I do not think it is unreasonable to suggest that this would meet the views of the two conflicting parties. The rural dwellers want 11.30; city dwellers want 10.30. That would not create any problem. But the Minister says we should insist on 11.30 for everybody for the sake of uniformity.

Perhaps between this and the Report Stage the Minister will, as I have suggested, consult with his own Party members and ask them whether a difference of one hour would create any great problem and whether it would not, in fact, meet the point of view of both city dwellers and rural dwellers. If the Minister will give me that indication now, we can leave this over until the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

Senators should look at the section and at the amendment. I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill".

Comment on this

Votáil.

Comment on this

How many Senators desire to vote?

Senators Murphy, Dr. O'Donovan, Miss Davidson and P. Crowley rose.

Comment on this

The Senators will be recorded as dissenting. The decision on amendment No. 2 governs amendments Nos. 3 and 4. We shall now take up amendment No. 5.

Comment on this

What happens to amendment No. 3?

Comment on this

The decision on amendment No. 2 governs amendments Nos. 3 and 4.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I must say I would be rather inclined to vote for amendments Nos. 3 and 4, but I am obviously being given no opportunity to do so. Do they fall because of our decision on amendment No. 2? There is a different principle involved.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

We decided to to take them all together.

Comment on this

I understood we were debating them together.

Comment on this

I drew the attention of the House to the position twice. The form in which the motion was put to the House was: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill".

Comment on this

Surely, that meant the words referred to in amendment No. 2, taking the first amendment first.

Comment on this

The House has taken a decision on the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill." That governs amendments Nos. 3 and 4.

Comment on this

If that is the case, there will be a different attitude on subsequent amendments. This is the end of co-operation.

Comment on this

I could not make the matter any clearer.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think the matter might have been made clearer, if I may say so. One would be prepared, as I would, to support a motion that the words should not be deleted in relation to Senator Murphy's amendment. But I would also be inclined to support a motion that the words should be deleted on the basis of Senator O'Quigley's amendment. I think we went a little too fast there. Sir, certainly for some of the intellects in the House.

Comment on this

It has been the procedure on many former occasions to put the question in the form in which I put it. Fearing there might be some difficulty, I drew the attention of the House a second time to the form in which the motion was being put. The decision has been taken, and it must stand.

Comment on this

With great respect, may I suggest that in future such a compendious approach may be a little bit misleading? Two principles are involved and we could hardly decide on two principles in one decision. I hope you will look into the procedure for future occasions.

Comment on this

I understood the position to be that we were discussing amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 4 together in order to avoid duplication, triplication and quadruplication of discussion.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

We did not avoid it. We had it.

Comment on this

That was clearly understood. I have never known it to happen before that three different amendments are voted on together.

Comment on this

May I draw the Senator's attention once more to the procedure adopted? I put the question, according to the standard procedure: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill." The House has agreed that the words shall remain in the Bill and that disposes of the matter.

Comment on this

With respect, I took that to apply to amendment No. 2. I did not take it to apply to amendments Nos. 3 and 4. It may be possible, if the House wants to be accommodated, to get over that particular decision by suspending Standing Orders.

Comment on this

We could talk into next week.

Comment on this

Is the accommodation to be all on one side? If that is the approach, you can take the consequences.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

The consequences of what?

Comment on this

I am now calling on Senator Murphy—amendment No.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

In page 4, line 25, to delete "half-past twelve" and substitute "one".

In this amendment we are dealing with the hours proposed for Sunday trading. The Bill provides for opening hours from 12.30 to 2 p.m. and from 5 to 8 p.m. for eight months of the year and 5 to 9 p.m. for the remaining four months. I am advocating the trade union point of view, without any apology to the Senators on the other side of the House, that those hours are unsuitable, represent a hardship on the workers employed in the trade and, furthermore, are not really required by the drinking public. I suggest in this amendment that the opening hour should be put back to 1 p.m. I take it we are dealing with each amendment separately now.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 5 stands on its own.

Comment on this

At the moment the public houses in the county boroughs open at 1 p.m. We have heard a good deal about the fact that there should be no discrimination between urban and rural areas. I accept that that is a good argument. I do not accept, however, that because official drinking hours are extended to the rural areas city public houses should be compelled to open an hour earlier than at present. As Senators are aware, opening at 12.30 p.m. means opening while last Mass is still being celebrated. I think it is quite inappropriate that public houses should open at that hour.

To come back to the worker's point of view, because Saturday night is the busiest night of the week full staffs will be on duty until 11 p.m. or 11.30 p.m. and, as we know, they then have the difficulty of getting home. It would not be unreasonable that they would like to sleep next morning and go to last Mass but that, of course, will not be possible for them now if the provision in this Bill is not changed, if the opening hour is not put back to what it is at present, namely, 1 p.m. I do not think there is any real demand for a 12.30 p.m. opening and I believe the position is adequately and fairly dealt with by the present opening hour of 1 p.m.

Comment on this

In order to help Senators, may I direct attention to the fact that this amendment covers all areas and deals with St. Patrick's Day and Sundays, in connection with the early opening period? I think that should help the House to understand the discussion.

Comment on this

I do not want to hold up the House on this matter except to lay some little emphasis on what Senator Murphy has said. I may say that I have been specifically asked by the representatives of the staffs who will be affected by this section of the Bill to make the strongest possible appeal to the Minister for acceptance of the amendment. Apart from any other consideration, to my personal knowledge there are certain areas in which last Mass on Sundays will still be in progress at 12.30 p.m., when the public house across the street from the church in a country village or town will open its doors for business. We could deduce many other arguments in favour of the amendment but I think that one should be sufficient to appeal to the Minister.

Comment on this

I thought the most welcome attitude of the Minister in the course of this Bill's progress through the Dáil was his meeting the very strong view in rural Ireland that the hours should be 12.30 to 2 o'clock on Sunday morning and afternoon, rather than 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. I find it rather difficult to reconcile Senator Murphy's attitude on this with some of his moral pronouncements on the necessity for restriction of trading hours on the previous amendment. The Minister, in incorporating the hours 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m., is actually restricting the hours of trading by half an hour on Sundays.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that they should stay open until 3 p.m. Read the amendment.

Comment on this

The original proposal was that the opening hours should be 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. The Minister, in fact, has restricted the trading hours by half an hour on Sundays, and Senator Murphy's trade unionists will now be able to get home to lunch at the reasonable hour of 2 p.m. or 2.30 p.m. Under the original proposal the customers and the trade unionists would have to wait until 3 p.m. or 3.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that. Read the amendment.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that the hours of 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. are ideal. There was a certain allegation that there was not a demand for longer opening hours.

Comment on this

That was in a completely different case.

Comment on this

Senator Murphy went to the dishonest extent of bringing in the question of Mass.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for a Senator to describe other Senators as dishonest?

Comment on this

Dishonest argument.

Comment on this

The word "argument" was not used.

Comment on this

The very reason for the introduction of the proposal——

Comment on this

Could we have a ruling from the Chair?

Comment on this

——to have this opening hour of 12.30 p.m. was the very fact that last Mass is finished at 12.30 p.m. in 90 per cent. of the country areas.

Comment on this

The Senator cannot forget the cities.

Comment on this

I see Senator Burke nodding his head.

Comment on this

It is a fact. Nobody is going to come out during the middle of 12 o'clock Mass to go into a pub.

Comment on this

But the original proposal, the one suggested by Senator Murphy as being ideal, is the 1 p.m. opening. If that were the case, people would be hanging around town for a half-an-hour or an hour after last Mass until official opening time, and to rectify that situation the Government did the sensible thing in the Dáil by providing for 12.30 p.m. opening. It was to meet that very situation in which 90 per cent. of the people in rural Ireland will be out of Mass by 12.30 p.m. In addition to facilitating people in rural Ireland, it restricts the hours of work for trade unionists in Dublin city by half an hour and enables people, whether in rural Ireland or in Dublin, to get home for lunch by 2 p.m., and also enables the trade unionists to reach their homes by 2.30 p.m. It is far more practicable and sensible than the original proposal in the Bill.

Comment on this

I feel that 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m is about the best opening period that one could get because there is a habit in rural Ireland for people to avail of the facility of having a bottle of stout before lunch on Sundays.

Comment on this

Or two.

Comment on this

The problem was how to allow such persons to enjoy this drink before lunch and to reconcile it with the late Masses and late Divine Services. It was not worth-while waiting until 1 p.m., from the point of view of both the publicans and the workers behind them, and so it was decided that the earliest possible opening would be 12.30 p.m., which would not hurt anybody. People who go to last Mass have to be in church before the First Gospel and they are usually out again by 12.30 so, in my view, 12.30 p.m. is about right as an opening hour. No shorter period than an hour and a half would justify opening public house doors and setting up the paraphernalia for doing business.

Comment on this

For one bottle of stout?

Comment on this

From the point of view of the publicans and the workers one and half hours is very reasonable. With regard to Senator Murphy's suggestion that staffs will be working late on Saturday night and would like to have a sleep until last Mass on Sunday, I would say that life is not so easy. It is just not that simple and I am quite certain that on Wednesdays and Thursdays—though I think railway pay day is Thursday—with reasonable co-operation between employer and employee there would be an opportunity for all the sleep required. The fact that somebody would have to work until 11.30 on Saturday night and be on duty again next day at 12.15, or 12.30, would not worry me in the least, whether I were employer or employee. I know I have to do a lot tougher things and shall have to continue doing them over a number of years, and I feel that 12.30 as an opening hour is round about right.

I try to be as honest as I can in my approach to this Bill because it is non-political and is not a Bill on which strong representations from vested interests should be taken into account. I would almost, but not quite—perhaps through lack of courage—include the people who have the Pin in the same category. You have all these pressures and I feel none of them should be allowed to impinge too much. The ordinary fellow who takes a drink and the ordinary publican who sells it provide the common denominator. It would be unwise if Dublin made the laws for Ireland or if Ireland made the laws for Dublin. I think that from 12.30 to two o'clock is about the right time. It means that the wife can expect her husband home about 2.15 p.m. and that is not too bad. If you delay it any longer, it would be too bad. At the same time, it means there is a reasonable opening period to allow the publican earn something to pay his staff and it obviates the silly situation of having the staff coming in for an hour.

Comment on this

I agree with what Senator Donegan has said. I think it is necessary to have a one-and-half hour opening period. Not everyone wants to wait until one o'clock for their drink. Outside of the larger towns, the last Mass in rural Ireland on Sunday is at 11.30 a.m. Even where the last Mass is at 12 o'clock, it is usually over about quarter to one. If one wants to go away in the early afternoon, one can have a drink with one's friend from 12.30 to one o'clock and then have an early lunch. If the public houses are closed at 2 o'clock, every woman in Ireland—and we appear to give very little thought to them in this Bill, as in other Bills— will be facilitated by having their husbands home at 2.15 p.m. at the latest.

Comment on this

In fairness to Senator Murphy, the fact should be borne in mind that the effect of the amendment would be not to open public houses after two o'clock, but not to open them until one o'clock.

Comment on this

Would it not be hard on the public house to try to serve everybody in one hour? I do not think it could be done. Do not restrict us to one bottle of stout.

Comment on this

The case Senator Burke has just made is the case I was confronted with in the other House. As I mentioned before the tea adjournment, the Government had decided on the hour of one o'clock. That was a result of representations made in respect of religious services. Believing that they were taking action that would meet with the approval of the clergy, they decided on one o'clock. But when I went into the Dáil, with the Bill, I was almost overwhelmed by the weight of argument against this hour of one o'clock. Twelve-thirty was the hour recommended by the Commission. When I reported back to the Government and mentioned the arguments put forward, the Government gave me permission to put down an amendment providing for an opening hour of 12.30 rather than continuing on with the hour of one o'clock.

The arguments put forward were generally along the same lines as those put forward by Senator Burke. I think they were good arguments and, as Senator Lenihan mentioned, the drinking hours have been reduced by half an hour. The amendment I introduced was intended to ensure that the men folk would have to get out of the premises at a reasonable hour and would go home to their families and, perhaps, do what they should do: attend to their families, take them out to the seaside and matters of that kind. All these factors certainly carried weight with me and it was because of them that I put down the amendment fixing the hour at 12.30 p.m.

As I said, the Dáil were almost unanimous. From all sides of the House, I was met with this attack on the one o'clock hour. I was told, just as Senator Burke mentioned, that the last Mass in rural Ireland is usually at 11.30 a.m. Up to then I was under the impression that there was a 12 o'clock Mass. I was going on the basis that that Mass would be over at a quarter to one and that the people would have to wait only the short period of a quarter of an hour. When I realised that the last Mass was, generally, at 11.30 and would probably be over at about 12.15, I realised the truth of what most of the Deputies were saying, that if the people coming from last Mass had to wait for something like three-quarters of an hour it would tend to induce licensees to admit some of these people illegally and thus we would be getting back to the dangerous situation which the police referred to in their evidence before the Commission. In order to avoid that, I had no difficulty whatever in making up my mind to put down 12.30 so as to ensure that there would be no possibility of people standing around for three-quarters of an hour. What will happen now is that they will have, perhaps, less than a quarter of an hour to wait.

Personally, I do not believe that there will be such a terrific rush on the part of congregations to get to the various licensed premises as we have been led to believe; but there will be people who will have business to do in some of these licensed premises other than getting a drink. I think I have been reasonable in meeting the views expressed by Deputies and I propose to adhere to the hours contained in the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

Yes. Again we have the insistence on the requirements of rural Ireland in regard to this amendment. I wonder would there be any objection to taking into account the requirements of those unimportant people, in the view of the other side of the House, the people in the cities? Here it is definitely the case that 12 o'clock is the last Mass. At present the public houses open at 1 o'clock and there is no demand for an earlier opening. I referred earlier to the plight of the assistant working late on a Saturday night who might feel disposed to have a sleep in and to go to last Mass on Sunday morning. That would not be practicable with the Bill as it stands.

That is the immediate argument that sprang to my mind but in fact the unions' argument was that it is their experience that most of the workers in Dublin come from rural areas and are fond of playing football and hurling. Sunday is the usual time for them to play their matches. It was pointed out to me previously, with the one o'clock opening, they at least had the opportunity of getting to the Park and playing their matches on Sunday morning but that would not be possible now because they would be required to be on duty at an earlier hour.

Let us look for a moment at the over-all position on Sundays. Previously, the public houses opened for a total of four hours in the county boroughs and there was criticism of the fact that there were no legal opening hours in the rural areas. We are now not simply extending the four hours to the rural areas, but imposing 5½ hours in the 26 Counties for four months of the year and 4½ hours for the other eight months. We are increasing the total hours of trading on Sundays when there is no demand for that increase. There has been criticism of discrimination between the cities and the rural areas. It is now proposed to remove that discrimination, but, in doing so, it is proposed to increase the total trading hours on Sundays. I think our inclination should be to try to keep the trading hours on Sundays at as low a minimum as possible.

To go back to the plight of the assistants, we are providing here that the public houses will be open from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. The position is that if they are open at 12.30 p.m., it will be too early for the people concerned to have lunch before going on duty They will have lunch after they finish at 2 o'clock and they have to be back on duty again at 5 o'clock. When then do they have their evening meal? We are providing that the pubs will not be closed until 9 o'clock for four months of the year. These people are human beings. Why is the Minister insisting on providing an opening hour of 12.30 p.m. in the cities when most Masses are at 12 o'clock and there is no need for that opening hour in the city?

I know about this great principle of uniformity. We have all heard about that. That was the cry of the people who were in favour of total abstinence, and I notice that those same people, in giving evidence before the Commission, pointed to the experience that where facilities for drinking are increased, intemperance also increased. The Minister has declined to give different treatment with regard to the closing hour on weekdays as between the cities and the rural areas, but surely there is no great need for uniformity in the opening hour on Sunday mornings. I accept the argument that in the rural areas Mass is generally at 11.30 a.m., as was said in this House and in the Dáil, and I think it is reasonable for the Minister to meet the point of view of the people concerned and to provide for an opening hour of 12.30 p.m., but surely in the cities we could equally provide for a difference. There is no great problem. No one in the city will go charging to the country because the public house is open half an hour earlier on Sunday mornings.

I suggest to the Minister that he should forget, for just half a minute, about this great principle of uniformity and agree, in respect of the cities at any rate, that the opening hour on Sunday mornings should be left as it stands at the moment—1 p.m. rather than 12.30 p.m.—and let the pubs in the rural areas open at 12.30 p.m., if that is what is required by the people concerned, as we are told it is.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The opening hour at the moment is 1.30 p.m.

Comment on this

1.30 p.m. to 3 p.m. in Dublin. That is right.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator said 1 p.m.

Comment on this

In the county boroughs generally, it is 1.30 p.m. to 3 p.m.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

But the Senator is talking about Dublin and he said 1 p.m.

Comment on this

We could make it 1 p.m. in the county boroughs generally, and leave the difference in the rural areas, and let them have an opening hour of 12.30 p.m. I ask the Minister to consider that. There is no great principle involved, and it would help at least to some extent to meet the situation of the people employed in the public houses in the city.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would the Senator enlighten us further? What has the fact that last Mass begins at 12 noon in Dublin to do with it?

Comment on this

The public houses will be open while Mass is still on.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are open every day when Mass is on. They are open at 10.30 a.m. every day.

Comment on this

There is a difference between Mass on a Sunday and Mass on a weekday.

Comment on this

I was hoping that Senator Murphy would accept the reasonable statement made by the Minister in connection with this matter. I want to say that I certainly have never listened to a more tiresome and unrealistic debate in the Seanad.

Comment on this

It would drive one to drink.

Comment on this

Many speakers have talked with their tongues in their cheeks. Senator Donegan said what he thought but other Senators did not.

Comment on this

Because he agreed with the Senator.

Comment on this

Do not provoke the remark that some people cannot think.

Comment on this

Anyone would be provoked by the balderdash talked by the Senator.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator talks gobble-de-gook.

Comment on this

We have the G.A.A. and other organisations in many of our cities and towns, and people travel to different venues of sport all over the country. In that regard, this hour is better than a later hour. Again, it is better to have uniformity. I shall emphasise uniformity and Senator Murphy need not throw up his hands in anguish. An admirable feature of this Bill is that throughout the entire area of the State, we shall have uniform hours in restaurants and hotels——

Comment on this

The Senator should read the Bill.

Comment on this

We are forgetting that the law applies to restaurants, hotels and clubs as well as to public houses. As between the Dublin publican and the Dublin assistant and the country, we shall have uniform hours throughout the entire State——

Comment on this

To suit the rural areas.

Comment on this

——for public houses, for hotels and clubs, and the Garda who will have to enforce the law will know that the same law applies everywhere.

I have often travelled to Thurles, and I found that when a match is starting at 2.30 p.m. or 3 o'clock, the closing hours apply to people I meet in Thurles, but if I want to go into a public house yard, where there are sandwiches and drinks, I am a traveller and the person from Thurles is not. I think it is very suitable for the G.A.A. to have these facilities without any restriction as to whether a person has travelled three miles, 50 miles or 100 miles. When the match is over, the trains usually leave at 6 o'clock and people can have some refreshment in a restaurant, a hotel or a simple pub. I believe these Sunday trading hours are suitable for everyone who wishes to get refreshment. I use the word "refreshment" in relation to licensed premises, hotels, restaurants or public houses anywhere in the country. The fact that the hours will be the same all over the country is the whole appeal of this Bill and that is why uniformity is stressed.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It seems to me that amendments Nos. 6 and 7 could be taken together.

Comment on this

And No. 8, Sir.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

So far as the discussion goes, if the Seanad wishes, we can take amendments Nos. 6 to 11 and also, indeed, amendment No. 12 in the one discussion.

Comment on this

Not No. 12.

Comment on this

So far as I am concerned, I shall not agree to any such discussion, in view of the ruling we had from the Chair on amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 4. We got no assistance or co-operation from the other side of the House.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

At this stage, might I intervene to find out whether the Seanad would agree to sit late to deal with the Committee Stage of this Bill?

Comment on this

No. To-morrow is a holyday of obligation.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I want to point out that that was the understanding I had with Senator Hayes before he left.

Comment on this

But this is another matter now.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am doubtful, judging by the pace of the discussion, if it would be possible to deal with the Committee Stage unless we sat into the early hours of the morning. There are a number of amendments in relation to clubs. I doubt if we could cover the amendments in any reasonable time, even up to 11.30 p.m. Would Senators perhaps consider the matter?

Comment on this

No. To-morrow is a holyday of obligation.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Because Senator O'Quigley did not get his way, he is obstructing. I am quite prepared to accept next week.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is doubtful if we would finish to-night.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for Senator Lenihan to refer to a Senator as a "zoological specimen"?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I did not hear the remark.

Comment on this

He may have been looking at a mirror.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is not a parliamentary remark, but the Chair did not hear it.

Comment on this

Did Senator Lenihan say to which side of the House he was referring?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator O'Quigley has a vivid imagination.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it the position is that we shall discuss Amendments Nos. 6 to 11 together, that there will be one decision on Amendments Nos. 6 and 7——

Comment on this

How can we discuss these amendments if they are not moved? I do not propose to move any of the amendments standing in my name with any other amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The custom, I understand, is that the widest amendment takes precedence, that is, that the widest amendment is taken first. If Senators will look at Amendments Nos. 6 and 7 they will see that number 6 is the wider amendment. If we look at amendments Nos. 8 to 11, we shall see that No. 8 is the widest of these four amendments.

Comment on this

We can discuss them separately, whatever the custom of the House may be. I shall not give any further co-operation.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I understand that this is the rule of the House. If a Senator has an amendment standing in his name and if there is not a separate decision on it, there is no doubt that he can put it down again on Report Stage. I think amendments Nos. 6 to 11 all relate to the one subject, that is, to St. Patrick's Day and Sundays. They relate to the second period on Sundays and St. Patrick's Day.

Comment on this

I think I am the victim of circumstances and of a misunderstanding on the part of some Senators.

Comment on this

Nobody is blaming the Minister. I am not blaming the Minister.

Comment on this

Allow me to continue. I am appealing now for a continuance of the agreement that apparently was reached. The Chair has stated correctly that it was agreed to take amendments Nos. 6 to 11 and also to bring in amendment No. 12 in relation to Section 5 in the name of Senator Donegan. I feel Senator O'Quigley misunderstood the situation. The Chair, as I remember it, put the question twice. He referred in the plural about deleting the words and he repeated it. When it came to a question of asking Senators to stand up, Senator O'Quigley did not stand up.

Comment on this

He could have stood up and recorded his vote——

Comment on this

——without necessarily supporting Senator Murphy's amendment. Then he could promptly have gone on to his own two amendments and pressed them. That is why I say I am the victim of a misunderstanding in the circumstances which obtained at that moment. I am now appealing to the Seanad to agree to carry out the programme as agreed to at the beginning of the debate.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I understand the procedure in this House— and, indeed, on this Bill in the Dáil —is that these two amendments are taken together. Once a decision is taken that the words stand in relation to the broader of the amendments, the other amendment falls.

Comment on this

That was never explained to us.

Comment on this

That was never explained to any of us.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That, I understand, has been the procedure in this House for a very long time.

Comment on this

Senator Stanford did not understand it, either.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think in the circumstances, we should have a discussion on amendments Nos. 6 to 11 together and take two decisions, a decision on Nos. 6 and 7 and a decision on the other four.

Comment on this

I was here. I feel the Minister has explained the situation. I did not understand at the time what was happening but I did afterwards, before the Minister spoke and immediately after the situation had developed. Senator O'Quigley or any one of us could have risen and made the objection when the words were spoken by the Cathaoirleach. Unfortunately, it was a ceremonial matter. The words used by the Cathaoirleach were "that the words proposed to be deleted stand." It was omnibus; it brought in the lot. Even Senator Stanford did not realise the situation. So long as Senator O'Quigley knew that, at the end, we could make our individual objection, it should cover the matter, should it not?

Comment on this

My position is perfectly clear. As far as the other amendments are concerned, I did not understand nor was in any way given by the Chair to understand that we were voting upon three amendments at the one time. I did not intend to vote on the first amendment; I was interested in the other two. I have no grouse with the Minister but rather an abundance of goodwill for him in the very difficult job he has to do in this House. However, I take issue with other people on the other side of the House who are gloating over the fact that these amendments were got rid of. I do not consider that good for this House. I refuse to move any amendment in my name for the purpose of having it discussed with another or others.

Comment on this

An angry young man.

Comment on this

Could they not be discussed together and then moved separately? Would that get over the problem? They all deal with time.

Comment on this

I refuse.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I understand that amendments Nos. 6 and 7 are alternatives and that the decision will be on whether the word "five" shall stand.

Comment on this

Let us presuppose that the words "seven" or "eight" have a large majority here. How is it decided then? How does the House vote for "seven" or for "eight"?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Once a decision was taken that "five" did not stand, you would have to take a decision as to whether you would insert "eight" or "seven". There is no doubt that, once there is a decision that "five" stands, there is a decision on the principle involved. This matter has been thrashed out thoroughly. I think amendments Nos. 6 to 11 certainly go together and I think that Senator Donegan ought to have an option as to whether amendment No. 12 will be taken separately or with the others. There is a slight difference in subject matter. It deals with area exemption orders.

Comment on this

I feel that amendment No. 12 should be taken separately.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Very good.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 4, line 26, to delete "five" and substitute "eight".

One page 12 of the Report of the Commission of Inquiry, I notice it is stated at lines 9 to 13 that:

The general pattern of drinking involves three distinct periods of the day: morning trade after Church Services, afternoon trade following football matches or other similar events and late evening trade when the chores on the farm are finished.

These are the three periods in respect of which it was suggested it was reasonable to allow drinking on a Sunday. The interesting thing is that the first of these periods was allowed and was largely generally accepted with the exception that an amendment appeared in this House to shorten the period from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m. With that possible exception, the first period was universally accepted. I certainly cannot see why the second period was put into the Bill and the third period in the statement quoted was not considered.

It appears that the small number of people in Ireland who attend sports fixtures on a Sunday afternoon are to be accorded facilities while hundreds of thousands of people who have to do agricultural, domestic and other chores will receive no consideration whatsoever. I remember some years ago having a very unofficial conversation, indeed, with a Bishop about Sunday cinemas. He said that the only thing he had any objection to was opening the cinemas on Sunday afternoon. He said that in his Diocese he called the representatives of the cinemas to see him. He told them he would raise no objection to the opening of the cinemas, provided they opened after 8 o'clock on Sunday evening and did not show pictures that were not in keeping with the traditions of the Sabbath. He also gave as one of his particular reasons that he wanted all the people of Ireland, whether they were young, or old or middle aged, to be out in the afternoons and not locked up in a cinema.

We are permitting facilities here for many people to lock themselves up in public houses on a Sunday afternoon. I think it would be much better for the people in rural Ireland and in the big cities of Ireland to be out enjoying themselves. Good facilities are available in Dublin. Indeed, the facilities provided in Dublin are almost better than the facilities available in any other country in Europe.

I should hate to think that the hours from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. should become the drinking hours in Ireland and that after football matches, no matter what the code, there should be an immediate rush for the public house by everybody in order to drink from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. and thus create new horrors on the roads.

Have any Senators driven against people returning from some sporting fixture on a Sunday, Monday or any other day? In connection with these sporting fixtures, I should like to see drinking almost entirely prohibited before the fixture is over. I remember driving against a crowd returning from a match. A man drove straight at me with his lorry. I went into the next Garda Station and reported the matter but the man with the lorry was never picked up. He apparently had facilities for getting drink after the match he attended.

The people who attend these sports fixtures constitute only a small section of the community. Would it not be much better if these people were to go home and perhaps ask their wives, who are looking after their families, to come out for a walk and get a drink if they wanted it? Even if she were a teetotaller, she could meet other people. The idea that all men should drink and come home half-sozzled is no contribution to good social conditions.

The period from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. enshrined the idea of consideration in relation to proper facilities for attending to religious duties and also for the wives at home. If that is so with regard to the period from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m., it is being destroyed by the period from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. which is being inserted here.

In most of Ireland there are religious services. Perhaps these services are not services which the vast majority of the people feel they are obliged to attend. Yet they are there and the public houses are open as a temptation to prevent these people going to these services. In many parts of Ireland, evening Mass is now being celebrated between the hours of 6 p.m. and 8 p.m. and the public houses will be open during those hours. Evening Mass is. for those people who have to work hard in Ireland. It is one of the great changes made by the Papacy in recent years. If we believe in what we say about the period from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m., we should believe it equally in regard to the period from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m.

In conclusion, I want to reiterate what I said before. I believe that 8.30 p.m. to 10 p.m. would be a far more suitable period. The people in most of the towns come in in the evening when they have done their chores— milking cows, feeding calves or whatever else they have to do. There must be ten times the number who will be denied any facilities for drinking on Sundays, while the people who are off all evening and who did nothing to help in the farm are out filling themselves up. The people who have been holding the fort all day will be denied these facilities. I would ask the Minister in all seriousness to consider this amendment. It would be better for the people who attend sports fixtures to go home first of all instead of filling up 40 miles away from their home and then becoming dangers to themselves and to anybody they may meet on the road.

Any day on which there are facilities for drinking after sports fixtures, I always say one should give cyclists a wide berth on the road. When I have to pass a cyclist, it is better to allow him the distance he will fall, so that he will not hit the car if he does so. I say in all seriousness the Minister should amend the hours to those suggested in the amendment—8 p.m. to 10 p.m. and that he might have that amendment inserted on Report Stage. I cannot see any cogent reason why that amendment should not be accepted.

Comment on this

I have not very much to say on this amendment. I feel certain that Senators could adduce evidence for almost any set hours they might deem to be better than those contained in the Bill. I am prepared to concede that. This particular set of hours has been discussed at tremendous length in the Dáil and the same variety of suggestions was made. The differences in the suggestions were astonishing: some people wanted 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., others wanted 8 p.m. to 10 p.m. and others still 8 p.m. to 10.30 p.m. Despite all the suggestions made, in the long run, it was decided that the hours now before the House were most suitable.

It may be that in some circumstances those hours may conflict with the work of some people on farms and elsewhere, but greater benefit will accrue to the vast mass of the people concerned by reason of these hours. We must remember that people will not go into public houses and stay in them the whole time between 5 p.m. and 9 p.m. Suggestions have been made in course of the debate, not necessarily in this House, which suggested that the hours from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. would be utilised fully by the drinkers of this country. I do not believe that.

Fathers of families will bring their households to the seaside resorts. They will entertain their families and in the course of the evening will probably go in, have a drink and come out and join their families, but I do not think there will be anything in the nature of standing in public houses for hours. That is not likely to happen. I am satisfied in general that the hours contained in the Bill are those we should stand by and I feel we should at least give them an experimental period. If we find they are not suitable, that they conflict with the chores of farmers or other people who have to work on Sundays, then we can always bring in an amending Bill aiming at better hours. At the present time, and after a long debate in the other House, these are the hours we believe are most suitable.

What I am saying now in respect of Senator Burke's amendment applies to the other amendments put down to this section. They all show the varied views that exist in respect to hours. It is true to say that Section 4 was discussed for a longer period of time in the other House than any other portion of the Bill, and the same thing is happening here. I think a tremendous lot of hypothesis has been aired. We have a lot of theory which is not realistic. When this Bill operates, you will find, I think, that the people who will be utilising the licensed premises will be ordinary, normal citizens who will go into a bar to have a drink or two. Therefore, I strongly recommend that the hours contained in the Bill are those which should be given a test and which should be experimented with. As I have said, they can be amended later, if necessary.

Comment on this

The Minister is, of course, right in saying that no matter what hours are suggested, nobody can say with certainty that they will be regarded as being correct in, say, five years' time—that the particular hours chosen will be the hours which will be most suitable to most people. However, there are some ways in which one can assess whether particular hours are suitable or not.

I approach the question of the Sunday opening hours very much from the point of view from which Senator Miss Davidson approached the whole Bill on the Second Stage. Hers was a very well-constructed, well thought-out and courageous approach. Much of what she had to say is extremely relevant to the Sunday opening hours. Sunday is, for many people, the only day on which the family have any opportunity of getting together; it is the only day on which fathers can be associated with their young children. In this connection, whatever one may have to say about trade unions being able to get proper compensation for the longer hours their members have to work, there is nothing trade unions can do with the hours as they now stand to enable fathers of families who are engaged in public houses, either as employees or as proprietors, to associate with them during the ordinary day-light hours on Sunday.

The position as I see it will be that you will have opening hours from 12.30 p.m. to 2 p.m. and it will be at the earliest 2.15 p.m. before the man gets out and gets home. If you take a Sunday afternoon, the earliest hour at which he will have finished his mid-day meal will be 3 o'clock and as the Bill stands he will be back on duty again at 5 o'clock. I cannot see how the publican or the barman can ever look forward in the future to being able to go out on Sunday afternoon anywhere with his family. When we come to consider these people, we must have some regard not alone to their rights but also to the rights their children have to the society and company of their parents, and that is something trade unions cannot win for the publicans and the barmen.

I recollect that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, addressing the Television Authority the other day on the inauguration of the Authority, very properly referred to the provisions of the Constitution—which I regret to say are far too infrequently referred to— in regard to the family, and said that the Television Authority should bear in mind that the people of Ireland had enacted in their Constitution that the State was guaranteeing to protect the family in its constitution and authority as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the nation and of the State. That was the Minister's directive to the Television Authority in regard to what kind of programmes they should have on the new television service.

That statement of the Minister was clearly relevant to this Bill, for not alone are we dealing with the families of the publicans and the barmen but we are also dealing with the family of the man who has a particular weakness for having a drink on Sunday. He, like the barman, would be home to have his meal about 3 o'clock and he will be in no mood to go out until sometime around 5 o'clock. If he does, he will probably start drinking again when he goes out and his wife probably will not be able to get him home until 9 o'clock. This problem exists, despite what Senator Ó Maoláin says about my not knowing anything of what goes on in these public houses. This is the kind of thing this Bill is promoting, because once a man has from 2 p.m. until 8 p.m., as Senator Burke suggested in his amendment, it is a fairly good stretch in which he knows he cannot get a drink, and he can do something better for himself and his family for the whole afternoon.

There is a further objection to the word "five" as it appears in the subsection. I do not understand how anybody can say that drinking hours which straddle the normal mealtime hours meet the public demand. What the section says is that there is a large public demand that people should be taken away or lured away from the ordinary mealtime into a public house, that they should be able to drink from 5 p.m. until 8 p.m. in winter time, which straddles the normal tea hours. I know of no such such demand, and this is certainly a case where time will prove that this Bill has not properly gauged the public requirements or the public reaction.

There is in this country something which is again recognised in the Constitution, a practice as important as going to attend G.A.A. matches. That is the family Rosary, which is said in many houses after the evening meal, particularly where there are young children. The tea meal takes place between 6 p.m. and 7.30 p.m., and then the Rosary is said. If it is not said then, it is not said so far as the young children are concerned, until probably after 10.30 p.m., at the end of the news on Radio Éireann on Sunday night. That is an institution as important as any other, and the point of view of people who crusade on behalf of the family Rosary is as important as any other.

No regard whatever is paid in these hours of 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., or 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. in wintertime, to that longstanding institution that is associated with all that is best in our history. No regard whatever is being paid to the family Rosary, and instead of that, at a time when there are so many attacks being made upon our way of life and our philosophy, it is being made much easier for people to get away from those good customs which have made us the people we are today, whatever we be.

I see no reason whatever why the Minister or the Government, if they had that consideration in mind, could have decided that still there is a large public demand for having drinking hours all over the country in the interests of uniformity, and that the hours should be from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. in the wintertime and 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. in the summertime.

Again, apparently with some kind of an eye to the people who go to football matches, whether G.A.A. or soccer, or to any kind of athletic gathering, who on any particular Sunday constitute a minority of the citizens, this hour of 5 p.m. is pitched at that level to accommodate the needs of those people. I do not think we ought to change the whole pattern of social and family life in the interests of what still remains a minority, however big it may be.

Senator Burke has rightly referred to the fact that this business of going into public houses after football matches is conducive to too much drinking and more road accidents on Sunday afternoons. The Minister takes obviously an optimistic view of human nature and of the people he knows, and nobody can blame him for that. He thinks that people will have a few drinks and then be about their business. But that would not happen, particularly coming from a match. If there is one time more than another when people begin to talk at great length, it is after football matches, as to whether the man was in the parallelogram before the ball went in or not, and there will be a most heated long-winded discussion on topics of that kind.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

Nothing in the world. I am merely stating as a fact that that is what happens. The Minister is not right in his assessment of the position that people will go in, have a few drinks and then make for home and everything in the garden will look lovely and green. That will not happen. People will drink for the full stretch from five until nine o'clock.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense.

Comment on this

And nobody knows that better than Senator Ó Maoláin. A while ago, Senator Ó Maoláin was trying to persuade us that people could not be got out of public houses at 10.30 and 11 o'clock at night time. Now he is trying to persuade us that people are most moderate, that they have a few drinks and off they go. That does not happen and will not happen on Sunday afternoons.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator has a very poor opinion of the Irish people.

Comment on this

I have not a poor opinion of the Irish people; on the contrary, and I strongly resent any suggestion that I have a very poor opinion of the Irish people. I have a correct assessment I believe, speaking for myself, of my own faults and failings and I do not regard myself as any worse or any better than the average man.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Then the Senator should withdraw his suggestion that they have no self-discipline and that they will go crazy——

Comment on this

I did not make such a suggestion. I do not see the average Irishman as a man with sprouting wings.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

A man need not have wings to be an ordinary sensible citizen who can take a drink in a rational manner. According to Senator O'Quigley's statement, he will go crazy and cannot even be trusted with the right to have a drink from 5 o'clock to 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

If Senator Ó Maoláin is correct, that we can trust the ordinary, average, decent, temperate and sober man, then the Government would not be introducing this Bill at all. We would have no licensing hours. But from experience they decided that people do tend to take more drink than is good for them. What we must recognise is that we are dealing with fallen human nature. Do not forget that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense.

Comment on this

You do not believe in fallen human nature?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You may have such things in Fine Gael.

Comment on this

I do not know if Senator Ó Maoláin has been in any of these premises this evening but I think he must be taking leave of his senses when he says it is nonsense that we are dealing with fallen human nature. We must take appropriate safeguards in the light of that outstanding fact. However, I do not propose to say anything more on that except to express my firm conviction——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator has said enough.

Comment on this

I want to assure Senator Ó Maoláin that as long as I am a member of a House of Parliament, I shall speak within the rules of order for as long as I want and no gibes or jeers or anything of that kind will prevent me in the slightest degree from expressing my views as best I can. If he thinks that this kind of gibe is going to shorten the discussion, then experience will teach him that that will not be so, as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I have had experience of Senator O'Quigley's tactics for the past three years and I do not need any education on them.

Comment on this

Yes. Well, I can only say this——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think this discussion should now cease.

Comment on this

I agree entirely.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Both parties have stated their view.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I have not stated mine yet.

Comment on this

If anybody reads the Reports of Seanad Éireann for the past three years, since the time Senator Ó Maoláin became Leader of the House, or any three years previous to that, he will find nothing in them to equal Senator Ó Maoláin's record for disorderly interruptions.

Comment on this

I want to put Senator O'Quigley right on one thing, that is, the family Rosary will not be interfered with in the slightest degree as a result of the passing of this Bill. If the Senator had examined the tables at the end of the explanatory memorandum, he would have seen the position in regard to what the hours were and will be in the future. The present opening hours on Sundays in county boroughs are from 1.30 to 3 p.m. and from 5 to 7 p.m. Outside the county boroughs there are the bona fide provisions from 1 to 8 p.m. and there are, in addition, in seaside resorts the area exemption orders which permit four hours of drinking for local people. Therefore, I cannot see how the hours proposed in this Bill will either increase the working hours of the employees or interfere with any of the practices which the Senator referred to.

The extended hours in the Bill, as I said on Second Reading, called for the abolition of the bona fide law and the abolition of the periods permitted under area exemption orders and that is the main reason the hours are extended from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. I do not share the Senator's view that, generally speaking, people are going to remain in public bars from the time they open until they close. It is admitted that some individuals would do that. You have that type of person but in general our people are not what someone described as lounge lizards. They do not do that kind of thing. They are normal people who go in, have a drink or a couple of drinks, have a chat with a friend and go out. In general, they are not lounge lizards and they do not go in and sit in the bar and remain there for four or five hours. They are normal people but there are, as I am quite prepared to admit, abnormal people who like to go into a bar and stay there until it closes.

The reason the closing hour, which operates in the county boroughs, was brought in was definitely for the purpose of stopping that sort of thing, but, in fact, it operated only against a very small minority of the drinking public. I think the hours from 5 to 9 o'clock are reasonable hours and I am pretty certain they will be used by the general public in a reasonable way.

Comment on this

I must ask the Minister to consider my amendments, because he did say to us that perhaps after experience he would change the present hours if the 5 o'clock to 9 o'clock period did not work. It is the one thing I can point to which would improve this Bill: if the hours were shortened and if the hours were made after the supper hour. There are four things which would require to be considered. There is recreation; it provides greater facilities for recreation and having the family together from the time the public houses close at 2 o'clock until they open again at 8 p.m. in the evening.

It allows ample facilities for playing games during that period, for walking or hiking or any other recreation. Even at the seaside, would it not be better for the people to be down on the beaches in the long summer evenings rather than be saying at about twenty minutes to five: "The pubs will be open in a few minutes. We will go up and get in first." I do not think that is necessary. There is also the question of rural opening. All over rural Ireland at present there are missions and retreats and hardly one of them is over before 9 o'clock, official time, and the very minute the people come out everything closes down. Yet, they could spend two hours drinking before going into the retreat. That is something few people want to do. They would be better off playing hurling or rugby or association football or engaged in any other form of sport.

I think the burden is on somebody to prove that the people will not go on drinking more than they want and more than they ought when they drive motor cars. I should like to ask the Minister if he has ever found himself driving among motorists coming from any form of sport, race meeting or anything else. It is generally found that if these drivers have drink on board, they drive to the danger of everybody. I should like to impress on the Minister that we should be much better if we had the hours of 8 p.m. to 10.30 p.m. or 8 p.m. to 10 p.m. or some hours much later than those we have at present. That would do away with these abuses.

My experience of rural life is that there are too many people going into public houses in the normal hours; they will be allowed in on Sundays and they stay in for the whole day. I do not think that would amount to 50 per cent. or 25 per cent. of the drinking public, but it might be 10 or 15 per cent., and if that number of motorists are coming back from various sports fixtures after having too much drink, they are a menace to everything on the road and for that reason I ask the Minister to consider what is suggested. The Report Stage of the Bill will be taken in a week's or a fortnight's time and, in the meantime, he could consult the Garda authorities. They are very responsible people, and he could ask them what they think of the hours and whether it would be better for a man to devote these hours to his own family and recreation. I heard of a case of a Bishop who stated that he would— so to speak—give his blessing to the cinemas opening after 8 o'clock at night, rather than have them open in the afternoon when the people should be out enjoying good air and healthy exercise.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Could we have a decision as to whether we shall attempt to finish this Stage of the Bill tonight?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is evident from what the gentlemen on the other side said a few minutes ago that it is not intended to make the effort to finish tonight. Senator Hayes is not here. Therefore, I suppose the mice can play when he is away and it would be a waste of time discussing the prospects of finishing.

Comment on this

I wonder if it is in order for the Senator to refer to us as mice.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think it is a fairly well-known phrase and is not intended to be derogatory.

Comment on this

We might be inclined to talk about rats if he talks about mice.

Comment on this

Senator Ó Maoláin asked for all he got and more.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I always give back as good as I get, and I shall continue to do so.

Comment on this

In that case the Senator will not get any business through here.

Comment on this

It is my view that Senator Burke holds his opinions strongly and sincerely and he is quite entitled to put his point of view on this amendment but while he speaks sincerely, he can be honestly wrong.

Comment on this

Surely. What I said is not in the deposit of faith.

Comment on this

What I would fear is that if Senator Burke's amendment were accepted and if there were breaches of the law, it would nullify the intentions of the Bill because there is really no use in trying to brand all rural Ireland as a land of drunkards. That has not been done, I think, by Senator Burke but it has been done by other speakers on the amendment.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

If people who drink from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. cannot be reasonably regarded as topers, I do not know of any other term by which you could describe them but I do not think people will use all these hours. People will be free to enter and leave within those hours and these hours will have the great merit of preventing drinking during hours when the law does not permit it.

It is my view, and I have some experience of the matter, that too much restraint really adds to or creates intemperance. I might point out to Senator Burke—and he can check this tomorrow—that it is the experience in rural Ireland, particularly where you have one isolated public house, that groups of people coming out from Mass on Sunday want to get into a public house and to break the law by drinking, to blow the froth off a glass of porter and spit in the sawdust. They enjoy breaking the law——

Comment on this

These same public houses are open on certain Church holidays, like tomorrow. I have this from certain publicans in Leitrim: on those days when the doors are wide open, the people who want to get in illegally on Sundays do not go in at all.

Comment on this

They go to Carrick-on-Shannon.

Comment on this

I think Senator Burke will agree that happens also in Tipperary.

Comment on this

They go into the big towns.

Comment on this

I think when you try to restrain people you create greater abuses. Prohibition in America, as Senator Lenihan would say, was the classic example of that. In my view, when people have reasonable facilities they will use them reasonably and there will be less intemperance and that is all to the good. It can be said that it is wrong to have such long hours. No group of men in any Party can agree absolutely on hours. All we can ever achieve is to agree by a majority and we can mend our hand if we find the decision does not work well in practice but I suggest that the Senator should not press his amendment because I think it would defeat the purpose he intends to achieve.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I should like to suggest to the House that we might finish Section 4 to-night, if the House has no objection.

Comment on this

I thought we had agreed to adjourn at 10 o'clock?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Then the time has come to arrange for the next sitting.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Tuesday, June 21st.

Comment on this