Central Fund Bill, 1961 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 1–200 of 399. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 7 of 1961 ›
Before we adjourned last night I was trying to let light into the dark minds of the Coalition supporters and I was referring——
Comment on this
I wish the Senator would not start off on that note.
Comment on this
——to the success stories of the Fianna Fáil administration about which Senator Murphy appears to have some doubts. He referred to the expenditure on Haulbowline and, as far as I could gather from his remarks, suggested there was some laxity either on the part of the Government or on the part of Irish Steel in the rapid development of that concern.
I should like to recall to Senator Murphy's mind that in 1959/60 the total sales of their products exceeded £2 million and they were ten per cent. above the highest figure previously recorded. It is interesting and satisfactory to note that over £500,000 worth of that total was export products. At present there is a big programme of reconstruction and expansion under way and when it is completed this firm will be in a position to make a greatly increased contribution to the national economy. I do not think Senator Murphy need have any worries that Irish Steel will go ahead and will play the same vital part in our economy as all the other great industrial undertakings which have had their beginnings as a consequence of the policy of Fianna Fáil.
Senator Murphy made some reference to unemployment but, no matter how he juggles the figures, the fact remains that there are some 31,000 fewer people out of work now than when the Coalition were thrown out in 1957. Therefore, we have, in fact, "got cracking". I notice he did not take too much time on the cost of living. I do not deny that it has increased but it should be recorded that the increase was smaller proportionately than that which took place in the last three years of the Coalition Government. Furthermore, as Senator Murphy is well aware, wages have gone up steadily since 1957 and over 700,000 workers have been cushioned against price rises by an increase in real wages of some 11.5 per cent.
Senator Murphy waxes eloquent on the fact that Fianna Fáil now welcomes foreign capital. He forgets the position that obtained here in 1932 when the first Fianna Fáil Government took over the administration of this part of Ireland. He forgets the measures that were necessary at that time to get an industrial drive going and to re-create in the minds of our people the belief that Irish brains and Irish skill could do what people in other countries had been able to do in regard to manufactured goods.
It took some time to get that going and it needed measure on the Statute Book to ensure that industrial undertakings started here would not go to the wall as a consequence of unfair competition from outside. That process, as I say, took some years and the point was reached where Irish industry was on its feet and was able under its own steam to go into the export market where we need no longer, because of the development of skill and techniques, fear the incursion of foreign competition. Therefore foreign capital may now come to this country without doing damage to our home industries. It should be remembered, however, that foreign capital would not come to this country were it not for the stability of this Government, were it not for the progressive development of the national economy under the present Government and the satisfactory outcome of the measures adopted by the Government to ensure the stability of the economy.
Senator Murphy got some fun out of the use of the phrase "Let us get cracking." He reminded me of the fact that the Party of which he is such a distinguished member made a certain series of promises to the electorate in 1954. It would be very interesting, in view of the very serious promises they made to the electorate, to see how that Party "got cracking" when they were in a position to do so.
Comment on this
In case anyone doubts it, I have here a copy of the official Labour promise which was made in Dublin a few days before the poll in 1954. It is a very well-produced job, and states what the Labour Party solemnly committed itself to. Under a cross-heading in leaded type, "Labour's Pledge", here is what it says:
Labour has made its position on prices quite clear.
This is in capital letters.
It is pledged to reduce food prices and will insist on increasing the subsidies if this is necessary to bring about a reduction.
Comment on this
I continue the quotation:
Labour is the only Party which has given this pledge to the electorate. No matter what the position is after the election Labour will stand firm by this pledge.
Comment on this
—— they added this:
Labour cannot be in a position after the elections to form a Government on its own but it can control any Government that is formed.
They were three years in office as members of the Coalition Government. The statement is in black and white—it was issued officially by the Labour Party—that they could control any Government that was formed. They were pledged to reduce prices. Let us see how they "got cracking".
It is interesting and educative to the people, in view of all the play that has been made here from time to time with the words "cost of living" and "rise in prices", to see how that particular group in the Coalition "got cracking" on their promise to reduce prices.
On 24th October, 1956, nearing the end of the Coalition's second term of disastrous office, a Question was asked in the Dáil of the then Taoiseach. At column 7 of Volume 160 of the Official Report, the Taoiseach replied to the Question. The Question was if he would state the items which had risen in price under the Coalition. The Taoiseach gave a list of 112 items. It is most interesting to see what those items were: Beef, mutton, ham, pork, sausages, boiling fowl, herring, whiting, cod steak, tinned salmon, eggs, cheese, lard, fresh milk, condensed milk, cake, oatmeal, rice, semolina, potatoes, cabbage, onions, carrots, cooking apples, oranges, tomatoes, sultanas, tinned pears, tea, coffee, cocoa, jam, sauce, sweets, chocolate, biscuits, minerals, coal, gas, turf, electricity, firewood, candles, paraffin oil, rent, rates, repairs, suits, overcoats, raincoats, flannel trousers, overalls, sportscoats, shirts, pyjamas, blouses, skirts, woollen dresses, cotton dresses, hats, knitting wool, boots and shoes, children's sandals, beer and ale, stout, whiskey, cigarettes, tobacco, mattresses, chairs, three-piece suites, bedroom suites, radios, linoleum, blankets, sheets, curtain materials, cutlery, crockery, galvanised buckets, scrubbing brushes, soap, soap powder, scouring powder, education, hotel expenses, boot polish, toothpaste, razor blades and face powder.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Senator is going into too much detail.
Comment on this
There are only a few more and it is important that they should be recorded: Medicines, matches, writing pads, envelopes, bicycles, cycle tyres, admission to cinemas, admission to football matches, admission to dances, shoe repairs, hairdressing, dry cleaning, motor cars, motor cycles, petrol, train fares, bus fares, papers, magazines, postage, telephone.
Comment on this
That was the way in which the Coalition Government in three years "got cracking" on the reduction of the cost of living and the reduction of prices.
Comment on this
That was the way in which the Labour Party kept the solemn pledge which they had made to the people on the occasion of the general election that they would control any Government that was formed. They were in a position to control the Government of which they were members and apparently they either forgot their election promises or deliberately ignored them, or just did not give a damn what happened once they were members of the Government.
In case the Fine Gael Party should feel aggrieved at all the blame being put on Labour for this colossal swindle, I should like to display here the famous little leaflet by which they perpetrated the most colossal fraud ever perpetrated on the people. That leaflet was issued in 1954 by Fine Gael, on the same lines as the Labour Party. A few of the points in it are of interest. They say that all the increases which took place in the price of certain items quoted were deliberately imposed on the people by the present Government, by Fianna Fáil. They say that they have taken unnecessary sums of money and they ask: "So you want relief from high taxation and the high cost of living? If so, change the Government. Fine Gael for better times." That was 1954.
Comment on this
The "better times" operated to the brink of disaster. The Labour Party in some constituencies were not quite satisfied that the facts given in this leaflet were convincing enough. So, in one constituency, one of the Labour candidates proceeded to invent figures not at all in accord with the figures in the leaflet issued by the Fine Gael Party or, indeed, by the Labour Party. The swindle took place and was successful. That is not bad enough.
Senator O'Quigley referred here last night to the well-known maxim quoted by the distinguished and beloved Leader of Fianna Fáil at that time—"Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me." The Coalition succeeded in fooling the people twice, once in 1948 and again in 1954. They got away with it and did nothing. They will never again succeed, and neither will any other Party or combination of Parties, in perpetrating that fraudulent swindle on the people by way of leaflets of this type or in any other way since the people have had such bitter experience of what that type of electioneering meant to them and of what these unfilled promises meant.
Senator Donegan referred to the credit facilities to farmers and to the fact that farmers could now get a bank overdraft. What a change from the days of the Government which Senator Donegan supported. What a change from County Louth in 1954. For the benefit of Senator Donegan and other people over there who seem to think that all these things have been forgotten, I should like to recall the devastating analysis of the position of the agricultural community which was made by a member of this Houses, one of the most highly-respected business men of this country and one of the strongest supporters of Fine Gael. I refer to the late Senator McGee of Ardee.
As reported in the Drogheda Independent of 26th February, 1955, he had this to say with regard to the Coalition Government:
I am afraid there is an anti-agricultural bias being taken up by the Government. Within the last eight days I arranged mortgages for two respectable farmers. The worst of it was that these men told me that had they not voted as they did the present situation would not have arisen.
Obviously they voted for Fine Gael and the Coalition. The quotation continues:
I do not want to be unfair but I want to keep the Government from making fools of themselves. There is not a farmer in Louth who after the difficulties he had to contend with last year, did not wonder if there was any Christian charity left in them at all.
He meant left in the Fine Gael Coalition Government. He wound up with this remark:
In my opinion they are gone mad. When Mr. de Valera said a few years ago that if the other side ever got into power Ireland was finished I did not realise it would come so soon.
It took two years after that before the people got the opportunity of correcting the blunder they made in 1954.
Comment on this
The Senator does not like the truth but he will get it. Senator Donegan is a great man when he comes in here where he thinks the national newspapers may report the gems of wisdom that fall from his mouth. He is a great man for giving praise occasionally to Irish industry and to its development. However, when he goes down the country and gets into a cosy little corner amongst the Fine Gael supporters he plays a different tune.
I was interested to read the report of a Fine Gael dinner in County Louth in the Drogheda Independent of 14th January, 1961, at which Senator Donegan is quoted as having addressed some admonitory remarks to his hearers about the claims for industrial development which were being made by the Fianna Fáil Government. He is reported as saying:
The Government prefer to play the tariff wall and set up sheds where "do-it-yourself" kits could be assembled.
That was Senator Donegan's reference to industrial development and to the magnificent productive units which have been established in this country during the past four years.
Comment on this
I should like every worker in the great Cement Works in Drogheda, which were started in spite of the opposition of Fine Gael, to read Senator Donegan's reference and to ask himself if the Drogheda Cement Works are an example of the "do-it-yourself kits" which Senator Donegan thinks is the only type of industry which Fianna Fáil set up in this country. I should like also the workers in the many splendid boot factories in County Louth and in the industrial area of Dunleer to take heed of Senator Donegan's insulting references and to make up their minds, when they have the opportunity, to deal with Senator Donegan in the right and proper manner.
Comment on this
If the Senator does not keep quiet, I shall have to turn to him. Senator Burke had a few words to say last night that call for comment also. He was worried that the cost of running the country was getting out of hand. As is the usual practice with his colleagues in Fine Gael, he failed to give any indication as to where he would make cuts, what services he would reduce or in what way he would deal with the problem. It is the same old streanncán we have heard for years. It is the same old streanncán the late Dr. T.F.O'Higgins indulged in in a Press controversy with me about 15 years ago. We wrote letters to the newspapers for about a month. I continued to challenge him to indicate how Fine Gael would deal with matters, how they would cut expenditure, on what services they would save and how much they would save. After a month's controversy, I failed to get an answer from him. We cannot get an answer from Fine Gael or from the Labour Party here.
I should like to know from some Fine Gael speaker what services they would like cut to curb rising expenditure and to save money as they are so anxious to do. I should like to draw attention to the Book of Estimates on which this debate is based and which Senators no doubt have studied. If Senator O'Donovan will refer to the audited expenditure for 1953-54—the last year Fianna Fáil were in office before the Coalition took over—he will find it was £104,931,089. In the year in which the Fine Gael Coalition were thrown out by the people, 1956-57, he will find that the audited expenditure had risen to £109,456,420. There was an increase in expenditure every year the Coalition were in office to a total of £4,525,331.
Comment on this
I would recall also for the benefit of the financial wizards on the other side that the Coalition which lasted from 1948 to 1951 left deficits totalling £61 million behind them. By 1954, the Fianna Fáil Government had reduced that deficit to £8 million, but, unfortunately, the second Coalition came into office and again they left a deficit of £14 million. Not alone that, but the debt they left to be paid out of taxation for the payment of principal and interest on loans increased from £4½ million, when the first Coalition took over, to £10 million when they left in 1951. When they were thrown out in 1957, it was up to £17 million.
Comment on this
We have been told that current expenditure on State services rose by 10.9 per cent. in the last year but the gross national product also went up by 16.3 per cent.
Comment on this
We are entitled to the free speech which Senator O'Donovan and his Blueshirts tried to deny the people in 1934.
Comment on this
Senator Ó Maoláin should be allowed to proceed in an orderly fashion.
Comment on this
In an otherwise sensible speech, Senator McGuire claimed that the expansion in industry and exports was due to some action taken by the Coalition Government. Senator McGuire should have regard to what I said in reply to Senator Murphy. There would be no industries, no exports and no possibility of giving employment, were it not for the fact that in 1932 the rot of the first ten years of Cumann na nGaelheal was stopped. A Government with drive, initiative and belief in themselves and in the people took over, and an industrial drive was got going which established industries here which are a credit to the country. Were it not for the fact that these industries were in existence—brought into existence under Fianna Fáil policy—no steps taken by any Government would have resulted in any exports, much less an increase in exports.
The unfortunate thing, however, about it was that, in 1956-57, the old pattern of 1931 was repeating itself in the 26 Counties. Workers were going on short time; industries were beginning to close down; and the same situation as that which existed in 1931 was fast becoming a reality. On that point, it occurs to me that it would repay the economists and the financial wizards on the other side, and would repay Senator Murphy also, to go to the National Library one day and do one simple thing: get the files for the last months of 1931 or February, 1957 and compare them with the files of any newspaper for 1961 and see the difference in regard to employment, and in regard to the opportunities for work now open to the people of this country, and see the number of columns of advertisements for jobs vacant.
Comment on this
The comparison would have a salutary effect on the minds of those who made it. On the subject of the amazing recovery which has taken place since 1957, I quoted tributes from Fine Gael sources in this House last night and I should like to quote a few more for the edification of the gentlemen on the other side. We have heard quite a lot about the doleful position of West Cork and its railways. I should like to quote now from a speech made by a very estimable gentleman, Alderman Stephen D. Barrett, Fine Gael Deputy for Cork and Lord Mayor of the city.
Comment on this
Here is what he said, as reported in the Irish Independent on 3rd November, 1960:
In the hitherto depressed area of West Cork new forces were at work giving promise of absorption of local labour and a call to those in exile to return home for employment.
In the country generally there was a new spirit.
Economically, great efforts were being made to capture the export market and attract tourist trade, and, politically and socially, to wipe out the bitterness and rancour of the past.
The Irish Independent cannot be claimed in any way to have any affiliations with Fianna Fáil or the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
On 5th November, 1960, the Irish Independent said:
In the course of the past year there has been an encouraging upsurge in the hitherto slowly expanding Irish economy. Most of the main economic indicators have moved upwards, some by quite substantial margins, and it is generally agreed that a new dynamic of progress has been released.
In substantiation of our claim, I should like to refer also to another very estimable gentleman who represents the county of Meath in the Fine Gael interest. Captain Giles, who was discouraged by the weeping and wailing and banshee talk of some Fine Gael speakers, said, as reported in the Official Report of the Dáil on March 14th:
I do not want to complain about the country's desperate plight—it is not in a desperate plight at all.
Since I referred to industry and the situation which exists in regard to advertisements for jobs in the employment columns, let me also refer to the advertising business. There is in this country a very valuable journal which I hope every member of the Seanad gets, reads and studies. I refer to Development. The current issue of Development was so packed and cluttered with advertisements that it had to defer publication of quite an amount of editorial material. Here is what Development had to say in explanation of that fact:
This advertising boom, by the way, certainly reflects the change which is coming over the country. Business is looking up in scores of unexpected sectors. And naturally people react more agreeably; they get more cheerful, more optimistic, more confident—and are emboldened to become more enterprising.
Development cannot be accused of being a Fianna Fáil publication, either.
All these matters are worthy of comment, and, when one takes them in conjunction with the doleful prophecies made on the Central Fund Bill in 1957 and subsequent years and in conjunction with the doleful prophecies, reported in the Irish Independent of March 21st, last year, by the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Dillon, one can evaluate in a proper way the statements made in criticism of the Government and the developments which have taken place. Deputy Dillon said that if the Government policy continued on the present lines, there would be a major economic crisis. There is no economic crisis. That theme song was sung by Fine Gael year after year since 1932. When we had our backs to the wall, they sang it and they continued to sing it when things were going well. They are the banshees and the Jeremiahs. They cannot get out of the habit. They have grown so accustomed to it that it has become second nature to them. But the people, the businessmen and the workers are witnesses to what is happening.
This country is going ahead in spite of Fine Gael and every effort made to impede its progress. Thanks to the fact that a Fianna Fáil Government are in control of the administration of these Twenty-Six Counties and to the knowledge the people have of the good work Fianna Fáil have done in the past and will continue to do in the future, there can be no doubt that when this general election has taken place, we shall find Fianna Fáil credited with an even greater number of seats than in the catastrophic defeat of Fine Gael in 1957.
Comment on this
In view of the present high cost of living and of the fact that the boundaries of Dublin have now been extended as far as Upper Ballyfermot, Walkinstown, Bluebell, Crumlin, Churchtown, Rathfarnham and Harmonstown and Finglas on the North side, I feel the Government ought to give careful consideration to the conditions of the working-class people living in those areas. It is obvious that in the very near future we shall have a further increase in bus fares. It is time for the Government, through C.I.E., to initiate some scheme whereby employers in the city will be able to supply their employees living in those outlying areas with tickets, weekly or otherwise, at a reduced rate. Such a scheme would not be abused. It would be workable only between the employers and the employees living in those areas. At present there is great hardship on the unemployed living in those areas. They have to attend employment exchanges twice or three times a week. The Government should consider, again through C.I.E., some means of providing them with travelling tickets.
Comment on this
That matter must be discussed on another occasion. It is not in order on this Bill. It is a matter of detail. We can discuss only general principles on the Bill.
Comment on this
I shall leave it at that, then. I merely wanted the Government to consider some scheme for the benefit of the particular classes to whom I have referred.
Comment on this
I had not intended to speak this morning but, having heard the recent spate of tirade, I feel bound to comment. What good does it do to this House, or to the country in general, that we should have a recital of broken promises and failures? Whom is it persuading? Whom is it impressing? It is not persuading or impressing anyone in this House. It is not persuading or impressing any newspaper reader throughout the country. What is it doing, this kind of dialogue in this House and in the other House? The kind of dialogue I mean is this: "You broke your promises in 1922": "That is all right, because you broke your promises in 1923." And so it goes on. The answer to accusations of broken promises and failure is simply to accuse the other Party of broken promises and failures.
What is the ultimate effect on the country? The demoralisation of the country and the devaluing of our political standards. What the country is hearing is the negative side—a catalogue of broken promises and failures—everywhere in this kind of debate. I say to the leaders of the Parties on both sides that it is impressing no one; it is getting no votes; it is giving fodder to the people in this country who say that politics is in a bad way and that Party politics is a bad system.
I really believe it is beyond the reasonable comprehension of an intelligent person why Senator Mullins, Senator O'Donovan, or any others who have gone in for this broken-promise technique, should believe it is doing any good to anyone. I do not want to produce a tirade of my own in reply to this, although it sounds like it. I am simply considering the effect on the country. I am going to try to do something positive. I should like to put it to the leaders of the Parties, as an Independent myself, that this negative criticism of politics in the past in this country is getting them nowhere and getting no votes.
Obviously, it is the imminence of the general election that is stirring up this kind of recrimination. But surely they should realise that it is not getting any votes and that, at the lowest level, it is futile. I appeal to our leaders, one and all, in this House and elsewhere, in the future to let the dialogue be: "We did this" and the answer be: "We did something better." That is an argument that appeals to reasonable and practicable people, not: "You did something bad" with the answer: "You did something worse." That is pulling politics down, down and down, in the eyes of the people of this country.
Let us have the positive approach. Let us have the statement of what was done and the counter statement of what was done better. Or, if we like statements of policies, let us have a statement such as: "Our intention is to do this" and, instead of the reply being: "You broke your promises before; therefore, you are bound to break them again", let it be positive: "Our intention is to do this better thing." Then politics will be steadily rising in the country, then politics will be constructive. But I greatly deplore the kind of denunciatory and recriminatory speech Senator Mullins has just made; and when anyone else makes it, I greatly deplore it. I am certain I am speaking for 90 per cent. of the voters. That is the point.
Comment on this
Including Senator Sheehy Skeffington, perhaps. But it is not even getting votes.
Comment on this
The future looks bright for this country. As soon as Fianna Fáil have made up their minds about the new constituencies, have quit wrangling and fighting amongst themselves, have presented the new Electoral Bill to the Dáil and held a general election, a new Government will be elected. And we have no doubt in our minds after the Sligo-Leitrim by-election that that Government will be a Fine Gael Government, a Government prepared to work in the interests of all our people, irrespective of class, creed or politics.
At the conclusion of his speech Senator Mullins said this country was going ahead in spite of Fine Gael. I want to say this country is going ahead in spite of Fianna Fáil, in spite of the fact that they plunged the country into a civil war in the past and tried to burn it out. It took the leaders of Fine Gael, many of whom are still with us, to build it up again. The Fianna Fáil Party have now been in office for four years and this Bill gives us an opportunity of reviewing their work and of contrasting the state of affairs that exists today with the promises they made in 1957. When Senator Ó Maoláin speaks about swindles and broken promises, he reminds me of the Russian delegates at the United Nations talking about peace and the rights of minorities. As far as Senator Ó Maoláin is concerned, I look upon him as the father of the bandy-legged boy who, when he was sending the boy to school, said: "Johnnie, you are very bandy and if you happen to get into a row with any other boy call him `bandy legs, bandy legs' before he gets the opportunity of saying it to you." I agree with Senator Stanford that it would be much better to avoid accusations.
Comment on this
I want to say that when others do it I shall do it. When Senator Ó Maoláin makes speeches like that which he has just made it is only right that we should reply to them and we are entitled to do so on this Bill.
Comment on this
Let those who are older than I am give the example. It is up to the leaders of Parties to give the good example and, if they do not give it, do not blame the back benchers in a Party. If we were to consider all the Fianna Fáil promises, all that they hoped to do and were to do but forgot to do, we should be here for months. According to the Taoiseach, since 1932 we have been breasting the hill, we have been rounding the corner, but he has never been able to bring us to the land of promise and the land of sunshine which was held before the people.
In spite of the fact that Fianna Fáil have been in power for 23 out of the last 31 years, the greatest admission of failure appeared on their own posters at the recent Sligo-Leitrim by-election when on every boarding they told us that "Ireland's progress has now begun; keep it going." After 31 years that in itself is an admission of failure.
Comment on this
It is an admission of their own failure that they say, after 31 years, that Ireland's progress has now begun, despite the fact that they were in office for 23 of those 31 years.
Comment on this
Could we talk, Sir, about 1961 and 1962 on, instead of looking back?
Comment on this
If the matter is in relation to general financial policy, it is in order.
Comment on this
I want to make my own speech, and I do not want lectures from anybody. Some people may be accustomed to giving lectures at other times but I shall make my own type of speech. In any case, the people of Sligo-Leitrim did not believe the Government and their propaganda. They did not believe that Ireland's progress has even yet begun, and they served them with notice to quit. No one would welcome a counter-irritant as a substitute for a cure and there is no doubt that that precisely is what is in this Bill. It will be admitted by all that the country today needs a dynamic Government, a Government prepared to work hard and to lead the people to better times by a progressive policy, by example and hard work, and not by making flowery speeches as is happening at present.
Ministers should devote more time to the work of their Departments and less time to running around the country attending dinners and making after-dinner speeches. Everything in the garden may appear rosy when a man gets up to make an after-dinner speech, following a good dinner and whatever else goes along with it, but the majority of the people do not seem to share the optimism of our Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries when they are travelling the length and breadth of the country using flowery language and speaking in half truths. Indeed, if the flowery language of those speeches could do anything to make us wealthy or prosperous, no doubt we would be one of the most prosperous countries in Europe today.
We all agree that the Minister is seeking to extract from a dwindling population the largest sum ever asked for by any Minister, the sum of £132 million. There is no denying that people generally suffered a profound shock when they heard the figure because the people at present are overtaxed and unable to bear any further burdens. Money is not found growing on trees or under gooseberry bushes. Taxation is crippling production, it is crippling the farmers and it is crippling our industrialists. The sum sought by the Minister shows an increase of £8 million over that of last year and, if we take into account the £9 million saved by the abolition of the subsidies, the amount demanded now is £36 million over the 1957 figure. There has been a further increase in the amount taken out of people's pockets in rates of £3½ million. That is an increase of £40 million over the last four years, an increase of over 40 per cent.
There are many people who want to know when there will be an end to increased taxation. It would be no harm to remind the Government, because they often reminded the inter-Party Government when they were in office, that it is often the last straw that breaks the camel's back. We have £132 million being taken from the people's pockets in 1961 despite what appears in the Official Report for May, 1956, almost five years ago. The present Taoiseach, then Deputy Lemass in Opposition, was trying to win the people's votes by making false promises, promises he had no intention of fulfilling. In 1956, he said:
Taxation in this country has reached the danger limit. So far as we are concerned there will be no increase above the 1953 level.
Despite that specific promise, we are now paying £40 million above the 1957 level.
The Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance, and the Fianna Fáil Party want conveniently to forget their promises. That is nothing new. In 1932, when it was costing £22 million to run the country, they secured many votes by making a specific promise—it was made by Éamon de Valera, now An tUachtarán. He said that when Fianna Fáil were in power, they would reduce that figure by £2 million to £20 million. That gained many votes and the Party became the Government and, since then, I think taxation has increased every year. Instead of reducing taxation, as they said, by £2 million, it has since increased by £110 million.
No matter what Senator Ó Maoláin has said, if we contrast the present situation with the promises made in 1957, it can be truthfully said that never was so much promised as was promised by Fianna Fáil in 1957; never was so much expected by the people as a result and never has so little been done by any Government as has been done by Fianna Fáil in the past four years to honour the promises they made. It was a campaign of fraud. They went out determined to cheat the Irish voters and their promises were but stepping stones to office. They got back into power and very quickly forgot their promises. Many politicians blame the people for their apathy at elections, but what can one expect from the people when the Leaders of the Party and Ministers deny their own words after getting into office, deny they ever made such promises?
In 1957, the people were led to expect that subsidies would be maintained. These are Fianna Fáil words, that there would be no increase in prices. This was said both by the present Taoiseach and the former Taoiseach, Mr. de Valera. They said there would be no increase in taxation and that we would have vigorous measures to solve our economic problems and that immediate action would be taken to provide employment. The Government would "get cracking." There was a £100 million plan to problem vide 100,000 new jobs. The farmers were promised better times and better prices. How did the Government keep these promises? By withdrawing food subsidies, increasing the cost of foodstuffs and increasing taxation by £40 million. The farmers are getting less for their produce and emigration is increasing. There are fewer people at work. In 1957, we were told by the former Taoiseach and by Deputy Lemass, in the one night, that the subsidies "will be maintained". Fianna Fáil speakers and the Irish Press especially claim that Fianna Fáil have been consistent.
Comment on this
They have been consistent in two things: they have broken every major promise they made to the Irish people and they have been consistent in their inconsistency. Although the Taoiseach promised that there would be no increase in the costs of essential foodstuffs, they are now skyhigh. Fianna Fáil have achieved one record: the cost of living stands at the all-time high level of 149 points. Subsidies were removed to the tune of £9 million. Instead of keeping down the cost of living, as the poor were led to believe, the essential foodstuffs that the poor and the workers must use three or four times a day were increased in cost through deliberate Government action. Deliberate Government action sent up the cost of living immediately after the change of Government. The loaf for which the worker's wife had to pay 9d. went to ?d., despite the fact that we were told there would be no increase in essential foodstuffs. That was an increase of 6d. per loaf. Butter costing 3/9. was increased to 4/7., an increase of 10d. per lb. by the Party who said there would be no increase in the price of essential foodstuffs, the Party who always keep their word. The Party who claim to have been always consistent and who said that if every ship on the sea was sent to the bottom, we could do without John Bull and the rest of the world, sold our butter to John Bull at 2/6 and 2/8per lb., while charging the Irish housewife 4/7d. per lb. If that is the hallmark of consistency, I do not know the meaning of the word.
Flour was increased in price from 4/- to 8/- per stone. These are the essential foodstuffs of the poor. The wealthy man can go to the hotel and have a mixed grill or beef steak and onions, or whatever he wishes, but the poor must have bread, butter and sugar at least four times a day. To say the least of it, it was very unfair of the Government to break their word as Fianna Fáil did when they increased the price of essential foodstuffs in the past four years. No matter what may be said by Senator Ó Maoláin, it was no easy task for the inter-Party Government to find the money to maintain subsidies. It can truthfully be said of them that, during their seven years in office, they did not increase the price of essential foodstuffs. That increase was brought about subsequently by the deliberate action of Fianna Fáil.
Let us take for a moment the promises made about emigration. We remember the promise of Fianna Fáil that vigorous measures would be taken immediately Fianna Fáil were returned to office to stem the tide of emigration. They cried out at the chapel gates lamenting the canker of emigration and the harm it was doing to the people and to our economy. What have they done about emigration in the past four years? The official figures show that 185,000 Irish men and women applied for work permits in Britain in that period. The Minister for Finance said in the Dáil that Fine Gael had mentioned a figure of 200,000. They certainly did, and the only mistake they made was that their figure of 200,000 was too low.
Comment on this
Their estimate was too conservative. The pattern in the distant past was that a man, his son, or his daughter, emigrated and sent home money to help to keep the homestead going, be it a cottage in Mullingar, a small farm in Leitrim, Sligo, or anywhere else. What is the pattern to-day? Those of us who were down in Sligo recently will carry abiding memories of what we saw there. The little homesteads are closed. When we inquired why they were closed, we were told that the occupants had emigrated to England. One man applied for a permit in England but that man had with him his wife and five, six, seven or eight children. All these were driven from the land by Fianna Fáil policy.
The Government who have driven those people from the land can afford to spend £10,000,000 on jets. If we had the money and could afford it, it would be quite right and proper to spend the money on jets for our national prestige, and the emphasis has been on prestige. We have not, however, work to maintain our own people at home. I believe it would be much better to have the smoke swirling out of the chimneys on the little homesteads in the rural areas than to have it pouring from the jets in the sky. That £10,000,000 could be spent to much better advantage, if it were spent in keeping our own people at home. In our circumstances, it would be better to spend that £10,000,000 on providing work for our people than to compel them to seek a livelihood in another country.
We remember the promises made in regard to employment and unemployment. We remember the posters: "Get cracking. Wives, put your husbands to work". Unfortunately the wives who went into the polling booths and put their 1, 2 and 3 before the Fianna Fáil candidates did not think that the promises made would be broken so quickly. Instead of the Government putting their husbands to work, they compelled them to emigrate to England to earn a livelihood. It is perfectly obvious that people cannot be employed in Birmingham and Coventry and London and, at the same time, appear on the unemployment register here.
We remember the £100,000,000 plan. We remember the special four-page supplement in the Irish Press. We remember the promise made by Deputy Lemass to spend £100,000,000 and to provide 100,000 new jobs. Where is that £100,000,000 plan today? Where are the 100,000 new jobs? Of course, there are now only 99,998 new jobs because the Fianna Fáil Government, on returning to office, created an additional ministerial post. Practically their first act was to appoint a Minister for Transport and Power, despite the fact that, in 1956, Fianna Fáil Deputies stated in the Dáil that we should have fewer Ministers and that Justice and Defence should be amalgamated.
They created, too, a new post for the Taoiseach's son-in-law, the post of Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Justice. There were times when the Minister for Justice had a hard and difficult task. For the past 10 or 12 years, that Ministry has come to be regarded as one of the easiest Ministries. Yet, the Fianna Fáil Government saw fit to create the post of Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Justice. These two new appointments cost the taxpayers £10,000 to £12,000 per year. That is the blister that has been put upon the people.
Statistics prove conclusively that there are practically 50,000 fewer people employed today as against 1956. Fianna Fáil, of course, indulge in half-truths. They pick out the few industries in which there are increases in employment and they paint a rosy and a glowing picture. They never paint the full picture. The full picture would show that today there are 25,000 fewer people employed on the land as compared with 1956.
I mentioned here on an earlier occasion that Fianna Fáil had clamped down on housebuilding, despite all the promises they made in the past. In my own county, in one year, we built 200 labourers' cottages. For the past four years—I defy contradiction on this; I am speaking as chairman of the Westmeath County Council and the Minister can get the facts—we have had a housing scheme on hands. Away back in 1955, that scheme was drafted. For four and a half years, we have been trying to get sanction for that scheme. The plans have been sent back time after time, with the request that we should dot the "i's" and cross the "t's". We were advised at one time not to plaster the walls either inside or out. Remember, the Government were spending £10,000,000 on jets, but they wanted the labourer to live in a cottage without any plaster on the walls. That was the suggestion that emanated from the Department of Local Government. We intended to put wooden floors; we were advised that cement floors would be good enough. The plans were sent back. We refused to implement the instructions we got from the Department. Only in the past four or five months, with a general election in the offing, have they agreed to sanction our plans. Fortunately, we had our way; we will build a decent house, plastered inside and out, and with wooden floors. There will be two fireplaces; the Department recommended that there should be only one. That is the Party who talk about progress.
Comment on this
We are going ahead with that scheme. We are putting money on our rates and borrowing £40,000 to go ahead with that scheme. We hear a lot about State grants provided for houses year after year. I can give the figures in respect of each year from 1948. There was only £341,000 paid out up to 1954-1955. There was a change of Government when £2,022,000 was paid out. In 1955-56, £2,248,000 was paid out. And that is the year in which we are told there was a financial crisis.
We hear the Fianna Fáil Party blaming the inter-Party Government for everything that went wrong at that time. Senator Ó Maoláin spoke about the moaners and groaners. I remember where the moaners and groaners were during those years in spite of the fact that £2,248,000— the largest sum ever—was paid out. Nothing like that sum was paid out in the past four years. In spite of the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party speak of the great upsurge we have in this country, there are over 5,000 fewer people employed today by the county councils than in 1956. I admit that most of that employment was due to the introduction by the inter-Party Government of the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
My own county got from £32,000 to as high as £62,000 in one particular year. No matter what may be said about that, I contend it was money well spent. It helped to give employment. I have often said this— and I do not mind saying it again— that in an undeveloped country like Ireland, where there is drainage work, afforestation work, land work and other work to be done, no able bodied man should be unemployed. Instead of expecting a man to live on 31/- or £3 a week dole, the Government should have schemes like the Local Authorities (Works) Act schemes, to put that man into employment, so that, instead of being a burden on the State and a burden on himself, he will be an asset to himself and an asset to the State. We should pay him a wage of £6 or £7 or whatever the wage paid by the local authority is. It should be a wage upon which he can at least live an ordinary decent life.
We believe in that. We think it is wrong for Fianna Fáil to do away with that scheme. The reason for doing that was that it was introduced by the inter-Party Government. The Fianna Fáil Party at their Ard Fheis last year passed a resolution demanding that the Fianna Fáil Government should reintroduce that scheme. At the General Council of County Councils, upon which members of Fianna Fáil are in the majority, a similar resolution was passed unanimously, but in spite of that, the Government still refuse to implement that scheme. It is no wonder that the Most Reverend Dr. Lucey, Bishop of Cork, said recently that never since the days of the Famine had there been so few people at work in relation to the total population. That is the truth in this country.
In spite of the vigorous measures that were to be taken by Fianna Fáil to end unemployment and emigration, Fianna Fáil claim credit because of a reduction of something like 20,000 or 25,000 in the number of unemployed. It is an empty kind of boast to declare that you have purchased a reduction of 20,000 in the number of unemployed by exporting well over 200,000 men, women and children in the past four years. Let us now come to the promises made by Fianna Fáil to the farmers. There were to be better times for all.
Comment on this
Yes, but better prices and better times were promised to the farmers by Fianna Fáil. We know that is not the case today. We know that in 1953 the farmer got 29.4 per cent. of the national income. In 1958, he got 25 per cent. of the national income and in 1959 he got 24 per cent. of the national income, in spite of the fact that his overhead expenses are increasing. We know that the agricultural sales index figure in 1953 was 100. It went up to 107 in 1955 and it is now back to 96 in spite of the promises made by the Fianna Fáil Party.
While the farmers' rates, wages and overhead expenses have gone up anything from 30 to 40 per cent. in the past seven or eight years, their income has declined by almost 100 per cent. Those are the better times which the farmers have got from the present Government. I remember the promises made to the milk farmers. I remember being at a by-election in County Kerry and coming across a Fianna Fáil T.D. putting up posters for the march which was to take place in Dublin regarding the milk prices. We remember the rosy promises held out to the milk men of this country by Fianna Fáil but when they got back into office, instead of giving the farmers the increase they promised them, the price of milk was cut by 1d. per gallon.
Comment on this
It is not. Even if the Minister whispered to the Senator to say that, both the Senator and the Minister are completely wrong. They were demanding a fair price for milk. When the Senator tries to make little of Deputy Dillon's 1/- a gallon, as the Senator says, that is only a half truth. He promised a minimum to put a floor under the price of milk. He promised that for five years he would give 1/-, and 1/- was much better in 1948 than the Government's price is now because the cost of living and the overheads of the farmers have increased by 100 per cent. Having regard to those facts, the present Government would want to pay the milk producers 2/- a gallon in order that it would be as good as the 1/-promised at that time.
Comment on this
He wanted to bring down the price at that time. He wanted to bring down the price to 1/-.
Comment on this
They could get all they could possibly get at ½., ?d. or ¼d., but the State was prepared to say that they would get a guaranteed price of 1/-.
Comment on this
I beg to differ with the Minister. The Minister can look up the figures and see that it was not.
Let us come to wheat and examine the position now compared with the position when Fianna Fáil took over and the dishonest promises they made to the people. The Minister for Finance took a hand in that because he stated over Radio Eireann that the cut in wheat prices was unnecessary. I was listening to the Minister speaking in County Carlow when the farmers were led to believe that if the Fianna Fáil Party were returned to office, they would give a price of £4 2s. 6d. per barrel for wheat. Despite that promise made by Fianna Fáil in 1957, despite the fact that farmers' rates have increased by 20 per cent., that wages, machinery and machinery parts, oil and all their other overhead expenses have increased by anything from 25 per cent. to 30 per cent., instead of getting what they should be getting now, nearly £5 per barrel, they are getting and will get this year 20 per cent. less than they were getting in 1956. Therefore, instead of Fianna Fáil paying £4 2s. 6d. for wheat under the last wheat order that was issued, farmers will be very lucky if they get anything from £3 5s. to £3 10s. per barrel.
When we are speaking about wheat, is is no harm to say that, in 1956, under an inter-Party Government with Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, enough wheat was grown to supply our full needs. There was even a surplus and it was grown not through filling ten fields with inspectors but by paying a fair and reasonable price to the farmer for his products.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon said no such thing. He said he would not be got dead in a field of Fianna Fáil wheat and who would blame him? You were producing three to three and a half barrels to the acre and if you look up the statistics, you will see they are getting 20 to 25 barrels——
Comment on this
From the official statistics, you will see they were getting three and a half to four barrels an acre.
Comment on this
They had a difficult period trying to build up this country and they did a good job in building it up after the robbery that was done to the economy.
Comment on this
That is remote from the Bill before the House.
Comment on this
Senator Ó Maoláin referred to a statement by the late Senator McGee in 1955 in relation to an anti-agricultural bias on the part of the Fine Gael Government. There is certainly an anti-agricultural bias in this Government. He was referring to wheat prices and he said: "If there is any Christian charity left...". If there is any Christian charity left in Fianna Fáil and if they believe Senator McGee was right in 1955, why do they not restore the price of wheat to £4 2s. 6d., now that the farmers' costs of production are 30 per cent. to 40 per cent. higher than they were then? If they are not hypocrites, why do they not do it? Why do they quote this statement at all? Instead of showing some Christian charity to the farmers and giving them over £5 per barrel for their wheat to which they would be entitled, Fianna Fáil are to give them 10/- to 12/- less than they received when the late Senator McGee made that statement.
There is definitely an anti-agricultural bias and you cannot expect anything else when there is a city man as Taoiseach who has never been interested in the small farmers. Unless there is something done for the small farmers of Ireland, and done shortly, they may all turn the key in the door and leave the land. In 1957, Fianna Fáil promised that if they were restored to office, they would give £4 2s. 6d. per barrel when the price of the loaf was 9d.; now the farmer or his wife must pay ?d. for a loaf and the people who professed to have some Christian charity in them are prepared to give the farmer only £3 5s. or £3 10s. per barrel for his wheat. The stone of flour that was 4/- then now costs 8/- while the farmer gets 10/- less for wheat. There is very little Christian charity in that and the Government who are doing that cannot claim they are favouring the farmers in any way.
Another breach of faith by this Government and this Minister is in regard to the promise made by the Minister for Finance to reduce the number of civil servants. We all recall clearly the popular reaction to the statement by the Minister for Finance when he indicated he would carry out a survey which would result in greater economy in the operation of the Civil Service and that it was the intention of the Government to weed out any surplus personnel and that in consequence of the examination there would be more efficient administration with fewer personnel.
How did he weed them out? He weeded them out by doing as they have done in my own county, taking good Fianna Fáil supporters out of their homes and planking them into the Civil Service without sitting for any examination. Instead of weeding out civil servants and having a reduced number, what do we find?
Comment on this
That is a serious charge and the Senator should be called upon to give details of it. He should be asked to give the names of those concerned.
Comment on this
The charge I have made is quite true. Fianna Fáil people from my constituency have been taken out of their homes, put into a State car and placed in the Civil Service without doing any examination.
Comment on this
I do not think it correct to say they were put into State cars but we all know there is a method of making appointments to the Civil Service without examination.
Comment on this
The Minister will not make that kind of remark to me.
Comment on this
The Chair has said there is a method of making appointments to the Civil Service—it has always been there—without examination.
Comment on this
Under the Schedule to the Civil Service Regulation Act. I do not have to answer the Minister on that.
Comment on this
Is the Senator to be asked to withdraw that allegation? The Minister has denied it and I understand the procedure is——
Comment on this
May I intervene on a point of information? The Minister, apparently, is not aware of the legislation governing appointments under the Civil Service Regulation Act and the Civil Service Commissioners Act. There is, in fact, statutory authority for appointing persons to the Civil Service without requiring them to undergo an examination.
Comment on this
On the making of every such appointment, the Government must bring the names of the appointee before Parliament and state that the appointment has been made.
Comment on this
——people can be recruited as temporary civil servants without examination.
Comment on this
This does not relate to the statement of Senator L'Estrange.
Comment on this
Let me say this: Senator L'Estrange's original remark was perfectly in order. I do not think his remark that they were put into State cars and brought up to the city was in order.
Comment on this
Is it not evident from what the Leas-Chathaoirleach and Senator O'Quigley have said that they must either come in following an examination or in the public interest, in which case the names are put before the Dáil and Seanad? Let the Senator produce the names.
Comment on this
They are only some of thousands who have been put into the Civil Service by the back door in the past few years which is doing untold harm to the Civil Service.
Comment on this
There has been an introduction of back-door methods of appointing people who are not fit to be in the Civil Service.
Comment on this
Quite apart from the instance I gave, it is well known that there are temporary appointments to the Civil Service which are very numerous and made by all Governments even without being scheduled. A whole list of appointments may be scheduled.
Comment on this
The statement was that they were put into the Civil Service by back-door methods and put into State cars——
Comment on this
——and brought up, presumably at the request of some Minister or Parliamentary Secretary, and put into jobs to which they were not entitled.
Comment on this
Apparently, Senator O'Grady did not hear Senator L'Estrange withdrawing the allegation that they were put into State cars.
Comment on this
It is off the record. As I said, his original statement was in order.
Comment on this
It is not of much importance when he does not give us the names of those who he alleges were put into State cars and State jobs.
Comment on this
I have allowed a good deal of interchange about this matter.
Comment on this
It is very seldom that I interrupt and if I did not consider it necessary, I would not do so.
Comment on this
I am not thinking of the Senator particularly. Three other people have interrupted. The matter has been fully ventilated and I think the Senator might conclude his remarks on it.
Comment on this
There was popular Press reaction when the Minister made the statement that the number of civil servants would be reduced. There were articles in all the papers. There was even an article in the Irish Press pointing out the wonderful work that was about to be done, the efficiency we would have in future in the Civil Service, that Dr. Ryan would use the hatchet. We see how it has been used. We see an addition of 400 to the Civil Service.
It seems to be the Government's intention at present to create two types of people, the well-off and the poor. There is do denying that the majority of our people are much worse off now than they were, say, four years ago. I do not agree with Fianna Fáil policy which gives a cost of living increase of £10 per week to a High Court judge who already had £4,900 a year, or about £100 per week, and at the same time, decides that 5/- or 7/6 is enough to give a road worker and 4/- is enough to give an agricultural labourer, and gives 6d. to 9d. to an Army pensioner, 2/4 a week to the soldiers who fought recently in the Congo and who got such praise in our papers and form our politicians. When the Government got an opportunity to do something for them, they gave them the beautiful sum of 2/4 a week, while, as I said, they gave High Court judges £10 per week.
Comment on this
The creation of such a wide division between the fortunes of a small minority and the fortunes of the majority of our people in town and country will bring about very grave and difficult social, economic and political problems in our society and, if it continues, could lead to communism in our country.
It is no harm to point out to the Government that you cannot build a prosperous community on a poverty-stricken agricultural community and that is what the Fianna Fáil Government are trying to do at the present time. We on this side of the House have always agreed with the industrial campaign, with the setting up of industries.
Comment on this
The Cumann na nGaedheal Government started the Shannon Scheme — a Government which had the wisdom to put first things first.
Comment on this
If we had not got the Shannon Scheme and the electricity, we could not have had the industrial revolution which we had afterwards. The only good thing about it was that certain people who tried to destroy our country at that time did not get to destroy the Shannon Scheme, despite the fact that they did destroy a good deal in this country.
Comment on this
When the first beet factories were started, they were referred to by the people on the far side of the House as white elephants. We remember the propaganda and publicity they indulged in at that time.
Comment on this
They referred to the Shannon scheme and the Electricity Supply Board at that time as white elephants.
Comment on this
It would be much better if we could have industries based on raw materials from our own country. Everybody knows that if we export an extra £50 million of agricultural products, let it be cattle, sheep or pigs, over the next three or four months, there will be £48 million or perhaps £49 million net profit coming into this country to be distributed amongst farmers, shopkeepers, merchants and every stratum in our society. It may be necessary to pay £1 million or £2 million for imported cotton seed cake or some other commodity we cannot produce.
Comment on this
If we export £15 million worth of industrial produce, the reverse is often the case. After importing the raw material, we shall be very lucky if we have £1 million or £2 million net profit coming back to this country to distribute among our people.
While our export figures may be high, we will not have real prosperity unless we can export more from the land or export more from factories where the raw material can be produced at home. There is a market at our door worth £200 million for small fruits and vegetables. Instead of having our jet planes travelling throughout the world, it would be better to have a shuttle plane service to London, Coventry, Birmingham and those other places in England where the markets are. If we had only 10 per cent. of that market, it would be worth £20 million to us. It would make a big difference to our economy and we could keep many more people in employment in their own country.
When we speak about industries, one would think all the new industries had been established under Fianna Fáil. If there is an increase in industrial exports at present, credit should be given where credit is due. Much of the credit for that is due to the fact that Deputy Sweetman when Minister for Finance and Deputy Norton when Minister for Industry and Commerce gave concessions to industrialists. Fianna Fáil introduced a Bill in 1932 which forbade any foreign capital to come into this country.
Comment on this
The Senator does not understand the position; it is quite clear. He has not got round to studying that subject.
Comment on this
Laugh as much as you like. Facts are facts and cannot be denied. They brought in the money for the mines in Avoca. The people who were loudest in their denunciations were members of the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
What happened in 1936? The Fianna Fáil Party were in office and if anybody killed it, it must have been the Government at that time. We have always been in favour of bringing in people with "know-how" to start industries.
Comment on this
The landlords were put out of this country in the past. People are coming to-day with fat cheque books from Germany and other countries and are buying up our land. That is wrong. It is all right to bring in money——
Comment on this
It is wrong that our land should be allowed to be sold to foreigners as is happening now under a Fianna Fáil Government. When we speak of the number of industries set up recently, I would direct the attention of the House to the reply given recently to a Parliamentary Question addressed by Deputy Sweetman to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Here are the Minister's figures for the number of factories established in this country with the aid of foreign capital and technicians: For the years ending 31st March, 1955-56, 21; 31st March, 1956-57, 18; 31st March 1957-58, 21; 31st March, 1958-59, 13; 31st March, 1959-60, 7. They are going down each year, remember. So, instead of the great progress we have and the buoyant economy, the figures were seven in 1959-60; 13 in 1958-59; and in the years before that they were 21, 18, 21. So, in the last two years of inter-Party Government, 39 factories were established, 21 plus 18. In the three years of Fianna Fáil, only 41 factories were established. It took Fianna Fáil three years to do what the inter-Party Government did in two years.
Comment on this
If you look up the official statistics, despite all the bragging by Fianna Fáil, at present there are 25,000 fewer people in industrial employment than there were in 1956.
Comment on this
There is no necessity to check on this. Deputy Sweetman asked the Question; your own Minister for Industry and Commerce answered the question. These are the figures given by your own Minister for Industry and Commerce. If you cannot believe the figures of your own Minister, I cannot help you. All I can say is : God help you.
Comment on this
I do not think Senator Laurence Walsh has any Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange is getting large encouragement from the number of his colleagues over there.
Comment on this
For any degree of prosperity we have in Ireland to-day, if we give credit where credit is due, we shall have to give it to the inter-Party Government, and especially to Deputy Dillon who put the farmers of Ireland on their feet.
Comment on this
Under the land reclamation scheme, 1,000,000 acres of land were reclaimed and are in full production to-day. Deputy Dillon encouraged the farmers to improve their land and to improve their grass. He said they should try to make two blades of grass grow where one formerly grew. We remember what Fianna Fáil said at that time. They said we were pro-British; they said we were ranchers and they spoke about the man with the dog. Now they have adopted the same policy themselves.
On 9th May, 1960, speaking at Inchicore, the Taoiseach proclaimed: "The keystone of Fianna Fáil economic policy is the British market." He tells us that in 1960. What a change has come over Fianna Fáil in 30 years! We were once told that the British market was gone and gone for ever and thanks be to God. The man who is now An tUachtarán once told us that the production of cattle in this country was finished and he advised the farmers to keep bees. He said he had been informed on very good authority that the best type of bee to keep was the Egyptian bee. Definitely many farmers have been stung —and they are still being stung—by the drones of the Fianna Fáil Party in the past 30 years.
Comment on this
The people did not take his advice and did not keep bees.
If they had done what he suggested, he would not be where he is to-day with a salary of £52,000 a year.
Comment on this
He has referred to An tUachtarán. He is going too far.
Comment on this
Senators should allow Senator Carter to make a point of order.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange has referred to An tUachtarán in an undignified manner and has misrepresented him.
Comment on this
I feel that one cannot get away from reference to a very active politician. I think the Senator is about to conclude on that. The first part of the reference should not be made in the House normally, and the second part of the reference is not really relevant to this debate.