We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Central Fund Bill, 1961 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.

Contributions 201–399 of 399. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Central Fund Bill, 1961
Enacted

No. 7 of 1961 ›

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There is no question of its being withdrawn. In fact it is true, but I think it should not have been made. I cannot see that the Senator should be asked to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If references of this type are to be allowed, and if this type of procedure is to be continued, then Parliamentary Government, as we understand it in this Seanad, must go by the board.

Comment on this

The Senator dragged in the mud——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Senator will allow me? Personally, I noticed references to many matters in this debate. There are other authorities in the community to whom it is equally objectionable to refer. I mean other parts of the Government and the Judiciary, equally with the President and the Oireachtas.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I agree.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

But I think that one cannot really avoid reference to a person who was the Leader of a particular Party for a long period, and during a period of time which has, in fact, been drawn into the debate to-day.

Comment on this

I think it is completely wrong.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think the matter is now finished.

Comment on this

It drags down the tone of this debate, and reduces it to the status of a meeting of the Westmeath County Council where Senator L'Estrange is the star performer and gets away with this type of muck.

Comment on this

One thing is certain. I was elected to the Westmeath County Council when Senator Carter could not get elected to the Longford County Council.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There is no question——

Comment on this

The Leader of the House set the tone for the debate.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There is provision in the Book of Estimates for the President's Establishment. It is not an important part of the Estimates Volume, but, at the same time, I cannot stop the Senator from making the reference.

Comment on this

While you, Sir, as Leas-Chathaoirleach, were on your feet a moment ago, I noticed that the Senator who caused all the trouble, Senator L'Estrange, had not the courtesy to resume his seat in accordance with Standing Orders, thereby showing disrespect for the Chair as well as the President.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I agree with Senator O'Grady. When the Chair is ruling on a point of order, a Senator must resume his seat.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I should like to refer to the statement made by Senator L'Estrange that I set the tone for this debate. Perhaps I did, but I made no personal or insulting reference to any person or to the Leader of any Party.

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I agree that the Leader of the House did not make any personal reference in relation to outsiders, but it seemed to me that he did widen the range of the debate very considerably.

Comment on this

Senator L'Estrange would not speak like that in a public street. He spoke under the privilege of the House.

Comment on this

Senators on the opposite side of the House are beginning to learn now that Ireland is an agricultural country. If the people on the land are wealthy, then the whole nation can be wealthy, and if the people on the land are poor, then the whole nation will be poor. It has often been said by the illustrious leader of our Party, Deputy Dillon, that the standard of living of every man, woman and child ultimately depends on what the farmers of Ireland and their workers can profitably export because we have no underground wealth, no coal, steel, ore, or anything like that.

No one can deny that the farmer must have that money coming from exports to pay his bills, to buy artificial manure and seeds and to pay his rates. In my county of Westmeath, 77 per cent. of the rates come from the land. The farmer must pay rates in order that our services—roads, mental hospitals and other services—can be maintained. That money must come in from abroad to help us to buy raw materials and to keep the wheels of industry turning.

We have 12,000,000 acres of fertile arable soil, and we have a population of 2,500,000 people. Therefore, there are five acres of land for every person in the country. In 1948, after six years of uninterrupted strong Fianna Fáil Government, we had the lowest number of cattle, sheep and pigs on record. Our total exports were only £39,000,000, and they had increased by only £3,000,000 from 1932—a period of 16 years—despite the fact that everything we had to export doubled. If they had not doubled, our exports would have gone down by nearly £20,000,000.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator forget what was happening in those days and what his colleagues were doing?

Comment on this

We should give credit where credit is due. In 1957, our total exports were £131,000,000, an increase of 92 per cent, in ten years. The inter-Party Government were in office for seven of those years. Senator Lenihan claimed credit for the increased export figure in 1957. That is ridiculous, and he knows it as well as everybody else. Fianna Fáil came into power in March of that year. Does Senator Lenihan think that the three-year-old cattle, and the two-year-old sheep and pigs which contributed to the export trade in 1957, were born and grew up in a month or two when the Fianna Fáil Government came into power? They may have had a magic wand in the past when they tried to fool the people with their promises, but they certainly could not do that. Credit must be given where credit is due and that was due to the work done by the Government in the years preceding 1957.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They left 94,000 registered unemployed in 1957.

Comment on this

I should like to remind Senator Ó Maoláin that there were 156,000 unemployed when Fianna Fáil were in office in 1935. If he looks up the record, he will see that there were 60,000 more people unemployed at that time. The prosperity we have is due to the fact that when there was a change of Government in 1948, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Morrissey, who were both Ministers, went to England to negotiate the Trade Agreement of 1948, which tied the price of our cattle to the price of British cattle.

If the price of British cattle goes up by 10/- a cwt. on 1st April, our Irish farmers get that increase also, because Deputy Dillon had the wisdom and the foresight in 1948 to tie the price of Irish cattle to the price of British cattle, knowing that if he went out of office, no matter how incompetent a Minister for Agriculture we might then have, he could stay at home in his office in Merrion Street and let the National Farmers Organisation in England look for better prices for their cattle and they would have to be passed on to us. That is what has been happening since the Trade Agreement was negotiated in 1948.

Last year, the Minister for Finance told us they would have negotiated as good a trade agreement. From 1938 to 1948, no Minister went over there. Instead, they sent civil servants——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

When they went in 1938, they brought back something good, and you could not.

Comment on this

That was when the farmers lost £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 and you gave the British an extra £10,000,000 to which they were not entitled.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

As a result of the treachery of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

You had taken £200,000,000 out of the pockets of the people here in taxation and tariffs, more than the annuities ever amounted to.

Comment on this

We beat the British and the Blueshirts combined then.

Comment on this

The Blueshirts were necessary when there were rogues and blackguards in this country trying to put down free speech and when your Taoiseach at the time would not protect free speech here.

Comment on this

Free speech !

Comment on this

The Blueshirts ensured free speech here, despite you and the likes of you.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order !

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You thought you were going to repeat the 1922 stunt.

Comment on this

The people on your side started 1922 against the law-fully-elected Government of the day, and you know that. The Minister for Finance stated that Fianna Fáil would have got us as good a trade agreement——

Comment on this

Or perhaps better.

Comment on this

Is it not true that, from 1939 to 1945 England was in the midst of a World War, her ships were being sent to the bottom of the ocean and her people were rationed to two ounces of meat per week? The arch-patriots of Fianna Fáil have always told us that England's difficulty was Ireland's opportunity. Was this not Ireland's opportunity then? If you had any regard for our farmers and wanted to see them get just prices, why did not the Minister, when he was Minister for Agriculture, go over and get a better trade agreement for them? You failed to do so. All that is wrong now is that you are all jealous because Deputy Dillon did it in 1948.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator is continually referring to "you". It would help considerably if he would refer to the Party or the Minister; in other words, if he would address his remarks to the Chair.

Comment on this

There has been a lot of talk about the buoyancy in the revenue and the increased prosperity we are supposed to have here. Over the past seven years, cattle have been exported here at £70 or £80 per head. These were cattle, or the progeny of cattle, that would have been slaughtered, had Fianna Fáil not been put out of office in 1948. Even in 1947, 114,000 calves were slaughtered and the owners paid 10/- for the hides.

Comment on this

Would the Senator not leave the knife out of his hand?

Comment on this

Nobody can deny that. Had those cattle been kept instead of slaughtered, they could have been reared and exported for £50 or £70 per head, as they were afterwards when there was a change of Government and we had a Government who would not continue the daft policy of Fianna Fáil. It is agreed by everybody that the farmers are not getting a fair crack of the whip at present.

Comment on this

Why does the Senator not reduce the rate in Westmeath where he is in control?

Comment on this

We cannot reduce the rate because the Government which Senator Carter supports told us, when introducing the Health Bill, it would cost 2/- in the £, but now it is costing 11/- in the £. You tried to get on Longford County Council, but the people would not elect you to it.

Comment on this

I did not—I could be elected any time I wished.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Perhaps we might finish with this private dispute between the two Senators.

Comment on this

The Senator is driving up the rates in Westmeath because of lack of moral courage.

Comment on this

I have always had moral courage, whether here or in Westmeath County Council. One thing neither you nor anybody else can accuse me of is lack of the courage to say what I believe is right.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This private county council row should be terminated.

Comment on this

There is no row in Westmeath County Council. We are a happy and united family. When we struck the rate, Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour were a happy, united family and we came to an agreement on the increased rate without a vote. Perhaps if we had members like Senator Carter, we would not be able to do that. But the Fianna Fáil members in our county are respectable citizens and we were able to come to a fair compromise.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think that is enough about the County Westmeath rate.

Comment on this

As I say, the farmers are not getting a fair crack of the whip. In the past four years, they have lost over £30,000,000 on cattle prices, wheat prices went down, and there were lower prices for barley and oats. The farmer's wife got bad prices for for her poultry. She got bad prices for her turkeys at Christmas. Despite the fact there was an outcry against inter-Party Government that they were not strong enough to deal with a union in Dublin in regard to container traffic, the "strong Government" we have now did not deal with it during the past four years, and that is causing untold harm.

The Irish farmers have been in the front line of every war in this country, national, social and economic. All they want is a fair price for their produce, and they are definitely not getting that at present. Since the Government have deliberately increased the cost of living, we, in Fine Gael, believe it is their duty to compensate people for it. While the farmers have to pay 25 per cent. more for foodstuffs and contribute to increased wages, they themselves are receiving 10 per cent. less for their produce than they were getting four years ago. That is altogether wrong. If it continues much longer, we shall have a much more serious flight from the land than at present.

About three years ago, the Minister for Finance allocated £250,000 for agricultural marketing. That was done with a great flourish of trumpets. I remember hearing Senator Lenihan speak at length about it. I should like to know how much of that has been spent and what it is intended to do about marketing. We all know our marketing system is completely antediluvian. On the eve of leaving office, Fianna Fáil have introduced a Bill to set up a Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That would be more appropriate to the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to mention that this sum of £250,000 was set aside and nothing has been done about it. Last year, a Trade Fair was held in London, at which almost every country in the world, even countries from the most backward parts of Africa, were represented; yet Ireland was absent.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This matter is not in order, not because it relates to expenditure but because the Senator is going into too much detail. He should reserve these remarks for the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this

I want to refer to certain figures in regard to the cost of living. I have mentioned figures in regard to the cost of living on numerous occasions in the past and every time I mentioned them the Minister for Finance told me that my figures were completely wrong.

Comment on this

So they are.

Comment on this

I have got the Statistical Abstract and I have taken figures for different periods of Government and the Minister can look up the statistics and see they are quite correct. I know that when he gets up to speak he will start by saying that every figure I gave was completely wrong and a complete misrepresentation of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Phony figures.

Comment on this

There was a change of Government in 1948. In February of that year when the inter-Party Government came into office the cost of living stood at 99 points. They were in office until June, 1951, and when they went out the cost of living was 109 points, that is an increase of 10 points during their three to four years of office. Fianna Fáil came in in June, 1951, with the cost of living at 109 points. They introduced their Budget of 1952, which sent up the cost of living and when they went out of office on 2nd June, 1954, the cost of living stood at 124 points, an increase of 15 points. The inter-Party Government again came into power on the 2nd June, 1954, with the cost of living standing at 124 points and they went out on the 20th March, 1957, with the cost of living at 135 points, an increase of 11 points. Fianna Fáil once more came into power on the 20th March, 1957, with the cost of living at 135 points and today, after four years of Fianna Fáil Government, the cost of living is 149 points, an increase of 15 points. Now, if you add together the two terms during which the inter-Party Government were in office, seven and a half years, the cost of living went up by 21 points, and if you add together the two periods that Fianna Fáil were in power, only seven years, it has gone up——

Comment on this

The Senator's figures are phony.

Comment on this

My figures are correct. The Senator can put on his glasses and read the official statistics if he does not believe them. The cost of living during the two periods of Fianna Fáil Government went up by 29 points and for the two inter-Party Government periods of office by 21 points.

Comment on this

The 21 points are for six years and the 29 points for seven years.

Comment on this

They were in for three and one-quarter years and three and a half years.

Comment on this

Less than three and one-quarter and less than three.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister might answer that in the course of his reply.

Comment on this

I cannot reply to everything.

Comment on this

The Minister will if it is important.

Comment on this

From 1st March, 1948 to May, 1951, according to my calculation, would be three years and three months. Would that not be right? And from May, 1954, to the 20th March, 1957——

Comment on this

Yes, less than three years.

Comment on this

Two years and ten months. If you add two years and ten months and three years and ten months together you get six years and one month. During the period of the first inter-Party Government we had the Korean war.

Comment on this

My goodness!

Comment on this

The Minister can look up the official statistics——

Comment on this

What about the Congo?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order.

Comment on this

The Balubas are out now.

Comment on this

The prices of all our exports increased very substantially. As a matter of fact they increased by 12 or 14 per cent. During the next three years we had the Suez crisis and the prices of our imports increased by 11 per cent. There has been only a four per cent. increase in our import prices in the last four years and, despite that fact, the cost of living went up by 15 points due to deliberate Government action, although import prices remained almost stationary or increased very little. Credit should be given where credit is due. Although import prices increased by 14 or 15 per cent during both terms of the inter-Party Government they were not responsible for that fact. Although import prices increased much more steeply than during the Fianna Fáil Government's term of office, the inter-Party Government were able to keep the cost of living much more stable.

Today we have in Ireland people who are able and willing to work, who are looking for a lead from the Government but unfortunately they are not getting it. The people proved in Sligo-Leitrim and Carlow-Kilkenny, where the Fianna Fáil poll dropped by 8,000——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There were eight by-elections and we won five of them.

Comment on this

We will drive the Senator around Sligo-Leitrim in the near future.

Comment on this

I want to say that no Government in this country can promise the same material wealth as is available in England and America, but there is no denying that if we had a proper Government, a dynamic Government, prepared to work in the interests of all the people, this country could be made a much better country for people to live and work in. That can only come when we have a change of Government and I believe it will come very, very shortly.

Comment on this

If the occasion were different I would very definitely be anxious to speak at greater length. It is a great pity that we have to come in here and listen to a Senator with the ability of Senator L'Estrange wasting his time and the time of the Seanad talking about the slaughter of calves, and referring to the Blueshirts, something which is past history.

Comment on this

I did not start the talk about the Blueshirts.

Comment on this

Senator Tunney was not here last night to hear Senator Ó Maoláin.

Comment on this

There are many things it would pay the country to forget. It is a shame to waste time talking about what one side or the other promised. Many promises were made and were not fulfilled. I give credit where credit is due. The inter-Party Government did good work for the country and the present Government have done good work, and if all that was good in both sides came together, something really worthwhile might result. Talking about the slaughter of calves will not prevent emigration.

Comment on this

If we had the calves, it might.

Comment on this

I am not one to say very much or to take up the time of the House, but it is tragic that people who are elected as responsible people should devote all their time to criticising others, instead of supporting and helping them for the betterment of the country and cutting out the humbug that we have been hearing for the past 30 or 40 years. After listening, for the past two hours, to the statements made, I feel it is a bad day for the country when the domestic affairs of any man are brought up for discussion. Reference has been made to a Parliamentary Secretary recently appointed. Is it not sad that despite the man's ability and qualifications, it should be said that he should be debarred from a position because the partner in life whom he chose happens to be the Taoiseach's daughter? It is time to get rid of that humbug and I appeal to all concerned to do so. If he has the ability and has the qualifications, as I am satisfied he has, and as the majority of people feel he has—he has proved himself a worthy Parliamentary Secretary—why should he not get the position?

I heard that Senator Ó Maoláin was rather rough on the Labour Party and if I had heard him, I would deal with him also.

Comment on this

Are you not doing now precisely what you complained about Senator L'Estrange doing?

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

Criticising other people.

Comment on this

No; what I am saying about Senator L'Estrange is not the same thing. I am talking about the humbug that has been going on for the past 30 years.

Comment on this

It will never stop.

Comment on this

I am speaking as one of those who fought for the freedom of the country. It is time to cut out the humbug and the great harm it is doing and give credit where it is due. I was in the Fianna Fáil Party and I had the courage to leave it on a particular point, a standstill order, but I want Senator L'Estrange to remember that many members of the Government risked their lives for the freedom of this country, something which many other people have not offered to do.

Comment on this

They were well paid for it.

Comment on this

Senator L'Estrange could not imagine anyone doing anything, unless he was paid for it.

Comment on this

I am not going to drag down the level of this House. Speaking as one of those who joined the movement, I can say that not one person went into it at that time for payment. It was done for the freedom and the honour of the country, for God and Ireland.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator has taken this debate back farther than it has yet gone this morning.

Comment on this

What I am saying could have a great effect on the country. If we could get the best in each Party to come together and plan something practical, we might then be able to stop emigration.

Senator L'Estrange made one point, with which I agree, in regard to the small farmers. I should like the Minister to realise that we will not get the small farmers in Connacht to remain on their mountainy holdings, so long as the price of a small bag of flour is £4 because they have not £4 to give for it. Let us be honest and admit that is the cause of the closed doors. I would earnestly appeal to the Minister on their behalf to reconsider the decision to withdraw the subsidies, particularly on flour, because while these people may have butter in some seasons, and may be able to use eggs as substitutes, they cannot buy flour. Where would the money come from? Prices for stock last year were bad.

I want to speak for another class of people whom I have not heard mentioned. These are the people in this city and county and in other towns who are trying to buy their own homes and, at the same time, pay everybody 20/-in the £. I am making a very earnest appeal to the Minister for them, because as a member of a local authority, I know what I am talking about. This authority has lent £11 million under the Small Dwellings Act. When the rates of interest go up, it is sad for me —I have always been opposed to evictions—to find at every meeting of the county council a list of from six to 18 people, of whose houses the council must take possession. These people feel so degraded in the eyes of their friends and relatives when they cannot keep their homes that they clear out of the country. Something should be done to reduce loan charges for these people who are making an honest effort to buy their own homes.

Immediate steps should be taken to abolish ground rents. Speaking as one of those who took part in the land war to drive the British landlord out of the country, I say it is a disgrace that we have a worse type of scoundrel as landlords in and around Dublin getting £100 per acre for land that did not cost them——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is not in order.

Comment on this

It is not too much to say that such things should not happen. Surely it is in order to speak on the reduction of loan charges? With all respect, it is as much in order as the slaughter of calves.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

The Senator was going to get support from Senator Carter there.

Comment on this

Every right-minded man in the country should support the aims and ideals I stand for. I am not afraid to tell the truth. I want to impress on the Minister that these are the new poor but, because of their inherent decency and honesty, they try to hide their poverty. The result is that, in the end, they have to clear out. The majority are young people starting off in life, with a family coming along. The position is not so acute in the first few years, but, as the family grows and the impact of full rates falls on them, they begin to know real hardship. The Minister can get from the Dublin County Council statistics of the numbers who have had to be dispossessed because of their inability to meet a burden of £3 per week for ground rent, rates, and loan repayments.

The only other matter to which I wish to refer is the position of local authorities. There is no doubt that the members of local authorities, once elected, co-operate to the utmost and do their very best, but they have no real power.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator is again advocating legislation, I think.

Comment on this

I am advocating righteousness. If the members of the Dublin County Council want to improve a road for seven people living along it, they cannot do so because the manager holds the improvement of such a road does not come under the heading of a public utility. I would regard a road used by only two families as coming under the heading of a public utility, not to mind seven. All the elected members can do is strike the rate and appoint a rate collector.

Again, we spend thousands annually on road leading to this city, roads used by people from every other county in Ireland; but we have no power to provide footpaths for school children and pedestrians to save them from the perils of traffic. That is one reason the slaughter on the roads is so heavy. I appeal to the Minister to look into these matters to see if something can be done to give more power to local authorities.

Business suspended at 1.15 p.m. and resumed at 2.45 p.m.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Finance (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I was glad that Senator Stanford intervened in this debate and, indeed, I agree with many of the things he said. I do not see much use in going back on the promises on both sides but if ever a public platform could be provided to go over all the promises in the past 40 years it would provide an interesting experiment. There are only two promises by this Government to which I intend to refer.

I agree with Senator Stanford in particular that negative criticism is not much good. It may serve the purpose of either political Party but it does not seem to me to do the slightest good to the country generally. I would, therefore, as I said often here before and as I said in the Dáil on the occasion of the last debate, be glad, indeed, to welcome a positive approach to any of the problems we have at the moment. I stated at the end of the debate in the Dáil that I was disappointed there was no positive suggestion in respect of a solution of many matters at the present time. I am afraid that I cannot say I was any more fortunate in this House in getting a positive suggestion of that kind. I am afraid I have to say also that, although the Dáil is frankly a political assembly, I do not think it is as political at the moment as this House.

Comment on this

It is not all the one way.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I have never seen Fine Gael so political as they are at the moment. They talk about depression in the country but it appears to me that the depression is on the Fine Gael side. It looks to me that the more this country progresses, the more depressed Fine Gael become. They were holding on to the last straw of cattle prices but, since cattle prices went up, they seem to have fallen to the lowest depths of depression. They have tried to get away from the depression by making wild attacks on the Fianna Fáil policy at the present time. Even Senator O'Quigley said that cattle prices would not do any good to the farmers and to the small farmers in particular. If that were to be admitted, it is a great pity that we did not have that opinion expressed last year when cattle prices were going down.

Comment on this

The Minister is misquoting me deliberately.

Comment on this

If they had, we might have been able to settle down to discuss what could be done to improve matters. However, we have to take the debate as it was and try to deal with some of the points raised. Undoubtedly, there is increased expenditure. There is not much point in any Senator saying that it is the highest expenditure ever. I am quite sure that next year, the year after and the year after that again, the same thing will be said.

Expenditure is going up all the time and the value of money is going down somewhat all the time. As some speaker on this side of the House said, there has been no suggestion from any speaker on either side as to where economies could be made. As a matter of fact, I was looking through a comparison between the expenditure for 1957-1958 and the present time. I find that the biggest is, of course, in agriculture, which has gone up by £8 million. What Senator Donegan said is hardly right—that the position with regard to agricultural expenditure was static. It is exactly twice as much as it was in 1957-1958. The general aim of the Government, as far as agricultural expenditure goes, is to help the farmer to produce more and produce a better article at a lower cost. Take the expenditure on the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. That is aimed at enabling the farmer to produce a more marketable article from the point of view of home consumption and public health and also to produce an article that will get a better price on the foreign market.

Let us take another big increase on the subsidies for fertilisers. The object behind that is to help the farmer to get more out of his land. The same would apply to the reclamation and rehabilitation scheme. If the farmer could get more out of his land, even at present costs or even at slightly increased costs, he would be better off. Therefore these various schemes under the Agriculture Vote which are costing so much money in recent years are all directed towards helping the farmer to produce better and at a lower cost.

Another big increase occurs in the case of social welfare. Social welfare costs have gone up by £3,000,000 and the cost of living has gone up—Senator L'Estrange gave the figures—by 17 points in the corresponding period. Therefore the social welfare recipient has got more to compensate him for the increased cost of living. Senator L'Estrange said the cost of living went up by 11 points under the last Government and by 17 points under this Government.

Comment on this

To be correct, it went up by 14 points under the Minister's Government.

Comment on this

Under the Coalition Government the old age pension went up by 2/6. Some of the Senators on the other side are very quick at making calculations. Which is better, to give 2/6 against 11 points or 4/- against 14 points? That is the position in regard to the cost of living. The same would apply to unemployment assistance, unemployment insurance and sickness benefit recipients. They have got these increased benefits to compensate them for the increase in the cost of living.

Wage earners were also mentioned. Since the beginning of 1957 real wages have gone up by 11 per cent. to compensate wage earners for the increase in the cost of living. We have compensated these two big classes, social welfare recipients and wage earners for any increase in the cost of living. There is the other big class left, farmers. I cannot claim that in regard to the cost of living they have been compensated in running their own households, as it were.

The next big increase is £2.6 million for education. No Senator will object to that increase; in fact most Senators here would say we should do more and so we would, if we could afford it. The Posts and Telegraphs Vote went up by £2.5 million but that money is an investment. The more we spend on Posts and Telegraphs the more we get back. It is just about paying its way all the time and the fact that we are now paying £2,500,000 more into it every year means we are getting the same amount back. Therefore we can disregard that.

Another item is £1.5 million for Local Government. Generally speaking, there are in Local Government many activities covered by that, housing, sanitary schemes, and so on, but that £1.5 million is practically all in capital expenditure. Under Public Works, arterial drainage schemes and many other schemes of that kind amount to £1.7 million. When all those items are added together, the total is almost £20,000,000 which is the difference between the £111 million of the 1957-58 Estimates and the £131 million in the current Estimates. A point made by the Opposition, which is a fair point, is that we have not now to pay for food subsidies that were provided for in the Estimates of 1957-58. It is not fair, however, to take the figure of £9,000,000 because we had to give compensation to various sections of the community when these food subsidies were taken off. As far as I remember, the net gain to the Exchequer in taking off the food subsidies was about £6,000,000.

Comment on this

£6,500,000.

Comment on this

All right, £6,500,000. Senator Lenihan took emigration and unemployment together and Senator O'Donovan said that was not right.

Comment on this

It was the Minister himself who took it.

Comment on this

Yes, but Senator Lenihan did, too.

Comment on this

You were both wrong.

Comment on this

We are both right.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The point made by Senator Lenihan is correct. Senator L'Estrange claimed that the very big increase in exports started in 1957 and was therefore due to the wise rule of the Coalition Government, but if emigration was very high in the early months of 1957 we can equally claim it was due to the unwise rule of the Coalition Government.

I want to explain, when Senator O'Donovan says that sometimes we cannot give emigration figures and sometimes we do, the Statistics Department say: "We cannot give you accurate figures of emigration. We can only give the figures at the end of each census period", which, of course, is correct. They do, however, give figures of the movements outwards and inwards by sea and air and the differences are taken as an indication of the emigration during the intervening years. As any Senator can see, there can be an error to the extent of people passing across the Border and back during those years but if we assume, as we generally do in those figures, that the movement across the Border is about equal one way and the other, then the figures of movement outwards and inwards by sea and air can be taken as at least a reliable guide to the emigration during the period.

On that, Senators will find by examining it that there was something over 60,000, in 1957. Leave that for a moment because we do not want to claim that. Take 1958, 1959 and 1960. The figure for those three years was slightly lower than for 1954, 1955 and 1956. So, there is nothing to boast about there. It is not as low as we would like it to be but it is slightly lower. If we just admit that fact, that we have not done much better than the Coalition Government in that respect, then we could talk perhaps more sensibly on the question of a remedy for this situation.

I do not think we should be saddled with the 1957 figures but, at any rate, we cannot be saddled with the January and February figures of 1957 and nearly one-half the emigration in 1957 took place during those two months. We can disregard 1957, if you like. That is a correct figure but if Senator L'Estrange knew much about statistics he could catch me out on another point there. That is the correct figure.

Comment on this

January and February go into the previous year.

Comment on this

They always do, of course. The Senator is quite right, but why should we be saddled with the figure if they went out in those two months?

Comment on this

The same would apply to every year.

Comment on this

If you do not take January and February of 1957, things are all right as far as we are concerned; they are not any worse than they were. In fact, the position is a bit better than it was under the Coalition Government. So, let us accept the fact that emigration is an evil that none of us has been able to solve and let us settle down to solving that great problem that we have without saying, first of all, it adds up to 180,000. Then Fine Gael in the Dáil rounded it off to 200,000 and Senator L'Estrange says the figure should be 250,000. What do we gain by that? Whether it is 180,000, 200,000 or 250,000, it does not matter in the slightest as far as the person who has to emigrate is concerned. It does not matter in the slightest whether Senator L'Estrange is right or Fine Gael in the Dáil is right or I am right, but what does matter is, are we going to make it possible for people who are growing up now to find work in this country? I shall come to that point again.

With regard to employment, anybody who has listened to this debate on both sides would be convinced, if he were a credulous person inclined to believe everything he hears, that there was no reduction in employment during the three years the Coalition Government were there and that there has been a big reduction since. There are two tables published. One is agricultural employment and the other is non-agricultural employment. By adding these together, you get the figures mentioned by some of the Senators here. Adding these two figures together, in April, 1954, when the change of Government took place, it was 1,185,000 and in 1957, when the change came again, 1,136,000. So it was down 49,000. All we can gather from that is that, whatever criticism may be levelled against us, the Coalition. Government certainly had not the remedy when they were there. Whether they have a remedy now or not, I do not know, but certainly they had not got the remedy when they were there because the figure went down by 49,000. There are only two years' figures given since then, the beginning of 1958 and the beginning of 1959— down 24,000. So, in three years under the Coalition Government it went down 49,000 and in the two years that we were there it went down 24,000.

Comment on this

Give us the four years.

Comment on this

I shall hand the Senator the green book and let him make it up for himself. I am not going to accept Senator L'Estrange's statistics.

Comment on this

You cannot compare what happened in two years with what happened in three years.

Comment on this

I am saying that I have not got the figures for the third year here. I guarantee that it is not any worse than either of those two. So, two years and 24,000 compared with three years and 49,000 is not an unfavourable comparison as far as we are concerned. Still, it is going down and the point is what are we going to do about that? We have been doing what we can. We have stopped the big reduction. It is getting smaller and smaller. If any Senator from the other side of the House can say that there is anything that we have done that is not right or can suggest something which might improve things, that will be all to the good.

There was one year in which there was no reduction. That was the year 1954. In April, 1954, as compared with April, 1953, the number employed was 1,185,000 compared with 1,182,000 the year before which meant that during that term of Fianna Fáil, when it came to the end, they had got the thing right. For the first time it was got right. The Coalition Government came in and added 49,000 to it. Now, it has taken us three years to get it right and I am quite sure it will be right this year but if by any chance the people go mad and put them back again it is sure to go wrong again. These are the figures out of the green book which any Senator can get himself.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister must have up-to-date figures and could give us the last four years or the last three years?

Comment on this

I have not got them. They are not published yet. I shall have them when I come to the Budget.

Comment on this

Apply to the Minister for Transport and Power. He has plenty of statistics.

Comment on this

Look at the point they are making now. These Fine Gael men who are looking for depression, searching for depression and searching for the figures, when I say their figures are wrong they say: "Give us three years" but you will not find depression in these figures no matter how much you search for it.

Comment on this

You will not find anything else.

Comment on this

Not if the Senator has his way. I shall pass on to a more levelheaded speaker, Senator George O'Brien. Senator O'Brien seemed to think there was a discrepancy between the balance of payments out-turn for this year and the external assets. I do not want to say that Senator O'Brien was wrong but I think he has not seen the final figure—that is all I can say about that—because in the final figure I think he will see that the balance of payments will close within £1,000,000 either way. I am not sure whether it will be up to £1,000,000 plus or £1,000,000 minus but it is within £1,000,000 either way and as far as the external assets of the Central Bank, commercial banks and Departmental funds are concerned, they are down by only £300,000, so that there is a fair balance there, fair enough, anyway, to say that the figures are fairly correct in this case.

Another point raised by Senator O'Brien and on which he spent a good part of his speech was the national debt and its growth. When speaking in the Dáil on this subject, I said we need not be too worried about the increase in the national debt so long as the charges bear a fair relationship to the gross national product. That applies to this part of current expenditure but it applies to current expenditure in general. If the gross national product is growing, as it is every year, and if we remain around that 18 per cent, for current expenditure, things should work out all right. Since 1956-57, when the service of the net interest and sinking fund took 2.4 per cent. of the gross national product, it has grown slightly until 1960-61. It is estimated at 2.9 for the current year. Apparently it is growing but it has not grown to any very alarming extent. It has grown from 2.4 to 2.9.

Senator O'Donovan took up a question raised by Deputy Dillon and my reply to the question with regard to the influence of borrowing on the gross national product. Both Deputy Dillon and Senator O'Donovan seemed to suggest that the recent growth in the national income has artificially been reduced by an expansion in bank and hire purchase credit. It is not a valid argument to say that that had a direct influence on increasing the national income. The recent increase in the national income has been a genuine increase, measured in real terms, after allowing for changes in money values. The increase in gross national production in 1959 over 1958 was 3 per cent. In 1960, it is expected the increase in real value will be of the order of ¾ per cent. over 1959.

Senator O'Donovan argued that the hire purchase debt entered directly into the computation of national income and said that, on the other hand, bank credit could be regarded as coming indirectly into the national income. I presume he had in mind that personal expenditure can be increased beyond current income by resort to hire purchase or any other credit and that total personal expenditure plus personal savings is by definition equal to personal income which is related to national income.

If personal expenditure is swollen by purchases based on credit, the personal savings figure will to a great extent be reduced, since personal savings are found by subtracting personal expenditure from the separately-estimated personal income figure. Hire purchase does not directly increase the national income but it has an indirect effect. All credit has. We must admit that it plays a useful part in helping to stimulate production and therefore to channel national income. There is nothing wrong about using credit in the proper way. It is the abuses that are to be feared. If there is an abuse, it is almost certain to be shown in the balance of payments. If credit is used for consumer goods, and so on, the balance of payments will reflect that and it would result in an adverse balance in the payments.

We have three years' experience of a balanced economy as far as the balance of payments is concerned. So long as that remains, we can feel fairly happy about our credit position. If due to excessive spending on consumer goods, the balance of payments should show an adverse figure, it would mean we were living beyond our means. That is exactly what was shown by the figures for 1955 and 1956.

Speaking on cattle prices, Deputy Donegan said the first ray of light in the past four years appeared recently. Undoubtedly, cattle prices were down in 1960 compared with 1959 and 1958. Although they were down in 1960 they were better than they were in 1956. The increases in price in 1958 and 1959 were not maintained. They went back in 1960. Fortunately, they are going up again. Whether or not that will be maintained is a difficult question to answer. To some extent, prices went down on the very big increases in 1958 and 1959.

In our agricultural spending, we have aimed at increasing production. We have made it possible for the farmer to get better crops by draining his land and fertilising it properly so as to carry more stock. We have had some successes. There are more cattle, more sheep and more pigs now than for many years. Senator L'Estrange talked about 1948. When some adverse event occurred in 1948 or 1950 he talked about the Korean War. He had no sympathy whatever for us in trying to carry on during a world war. We had come out of a world war and our stocks were naturally very depleted. Our crops were very poor. We had no artificial manures for some years. We found it difficult to produce enough food for the people, apart from anything that was exported.

Comment on this

We had grass.

Comment on this

The stocks were low at that time. If Senator L'Estrange thinks that a Minister for Agriculture, who built up the stocks of this country in three years from 1948, is a superman I would say that any man you might pick off the street could do the same. Artificial manures were beginning to come in. It was possible for farmers to go ahead again. It would have taken a very able Minister to stop them from going on with that production.

Comment on this

We had grass.

Comment on this

We had no artificial manures. Senator L'Estrange hates listening to the truth because it is foreign to him. He cannot bear the truth.

Comment on this

I do not mind.

Comment on this

To take a datum year like 1948 is going beyond the bounds of the ridiculous. It is the sort of thing that would suit Senator L'Estrange to build a case upon. In the last four years I have come into this House three or four times and I have heard the same thing trotted out on each occasion. I used to waste time explaining to Senator L'Estrange why we had to do such things as slaughter calves, but it is not worthwhile. He will not be educated. We had our difficulties with the Blueshirts——

Comment on this

Senator Ó Maoláin is wearing a blue shirt beside the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is not your kind of blue.

Comment on this

Senator Donegan and Senator L'Estrange also referred to the price of wheat. I am not telling any Cabinet secret when I say that I was responsible, against the opinion of the Minister for Agriculture, for the recent reduction in the price of wheat. I was responsible for getting the price down, because I wanted to get it down in the interests of good farming. Senator L'Estrange and Senator Donegan are here to represent farmers who produce 55 per cent. bushelling wheat. I do not want those farmers represented here. I do not want farmers to produce wheat that is no good for anything, not even for feeding, and then want the full price for it. I want to see some inducement given to them to produce good wheat.

Comment on this

The weather was responsible for that.

Comment on this

The price is just as good as ever for the farmers who produce good wheat. In bad weather, good farmers produce good wheat, and bad farmers do not. If farmers grow wheat in a haphazard fashion and do not employ labour, if bad weather comes, the crop will be at the very low bushelling rate of 53, 54 or 55. It is not fair to expect the taxpayers and the consumers to pay for the trash that came in last year. I met several farmers in Wexford since the price for bad wheat was reduced, and every one of them said to me: "You did not go far enough."

Comment on this

The inter-Party Government did the same thing in 1954, for the same reason, and the Minister was not satisfied.

Comment on this

When Deputy Dillon reduced the price, the wheat was good. I reduced the price of bad wheat. Senators must remember that means that if we have a surplus, there will be a levy, but the levy will not be high, because disposing of bad wheat will not cost us much. I want to encourage the good grower. Let Senator L'Estrange and Senator Donegan look after the indifferent person who does not know how to grow wheat at all.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order !

Comment on this

Senator Donegan gave another Fine Gael figure—their statistics are always very interesting—and said that the Land Project was now costing half what it cost in 1956-57. When I came into office, I saw in a publication that a man got £160 an acre under the B. Scheme for reclaiming land. We think that was a scandal. It was a scandal that the taxpayers should provide money of that kind for the reclamation of land. There was wasteful expenditure and wasteful administration under the B. Scheme. The A. Scheme was much better. The inspector went to the farmer and said: "If you do that yourself, and if you do it right, we will inspect it, and if we are satisfied, you will get a grant," and the farmer was told what the grant was.

We turned completely to the A Scheme and what was the result? The total spent on that scheme in 1956-57 was £2.7 million and this year we are providing £2.3 million. I admit that is a bit down, but it is not half what Senator Donegan said. Senator Donegan would have no scruple about repeating that figure to the farmers in County Louth and Senator L'Estrange would have no scruple either, even after I have told him the correct figure now. He will go on saying it.

Senator Donegan also said that the farmers were not getting more for milk. and I think Senator L'Estrange said the same. They are getting more for milk. We gave them ?d. per gallon at the beginning of last year. More milk was produced last year—in fact, it was the second highest year on record— so that altogether the farmers got a big amount of money for milk last year compared with what they got in other years.

Comment on this

They got £12 to £15 as well for the calves.

Comment on this

I would be here until 8 o'clock to-night, if I were to deal with all Senator L'Estrange's interruptions. They are always wrong but it takes some time to deal with them. I wrote down some points while he was speaking, and when I give the correct figures in reply to those points, he has something else to say. I cannot catch up with his lies and figures. Before leaving the subject, I may say that 1/7d. is a better price than 1/-.

Comment on this

What about the cost of living and the overhead expenses?

Comment on this

No matter what you compare, the Fianna Fáil price of 1/7d. is better than the Fine Gael price of 1/-.

Comment on this

It would need to be 2/- now to be as good as 1/- in 1948.

Comment on this

Senator Barry asked me if I could ensure that all the industrial projects are sound. I cannot. That reminds me of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government from 1922 to 1932, which put on about three tariffs in ten years. I remember they put a tariff on rosary beads, which are not a big item, and the Tariff Commission consisting of three men, working full time, took over four months to investigate that tariff and they visited many of the cities of Europe——

Comment on this

They must have been praying most of the time.

Comment on this

Ten years, and only three tariffs altogether. We all know there are a number of tariffs at the present time and I certainly cannot guarantee that every proposal that comes along is sound. I should like to say that any complaints I got against the Industrial Authority or against Foras Talúntais were always to the effect that they were too restrictive and hard to get through. They give a fair amount of consideration to any project that comes before them, and they do not want to let anything through, unless it has a fair chance of success.

Senator Barry also asked about the credentials of people who start industries here. That reminds me of silly attacks about bringing in foreigners with capital. If Senators looked at this in a reasonable and sensible way, they would thank us for building up industry. We built up industries for the home market and those industries produced textiles, leather, boots, shoes and cement. They now export goods and they account for about £20 million of our export business. That is all Irish capital—I am not sure about cement but most of it is Irish capital. They operate under the Control of Manufactures Act. They use Irish capital, Irish raw materials to a great extent, and Irish labour, and there is a good labour content being built up all the time.

Senator Barry said that he would like to have Senator Lenihan talking from the other side of the House supposing a Fine Gael Government had been in office for the past three or four years. He asked would Senator Lenihan be able to answer some questions. First of all, would Senator Lenihan like to draw a graph of the cattle prices for the past four years? As a matter of fact, that graph would show that they were at their lowest when we took over, and they have been higher ever since. They have never been so low since. They were very high in 1957 and 1958; they were practically as high in 1959; then they went down a bit again. In the graph for pigs, you could cut out the two depressions for the two three-year periods when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

It was the other way about.

Comment on this

Every time he was there, pigs went down. Now they are at their highest. Senator Barry talked about those who promised the food subsidies would not be removed and did not keep that promise. Is it not a remarkable record of this Party that when Fine Gael put their big organisation to reading every newspaper, every speech and every leaflet produced by Fianna Fáil, the only thing they could turn up was this matter of the food subsidies?

Why should we have made promises at that time? The people were coming up to us and saying: "For God's sake, put your heart into it and win this election." Take this matter of the food subsidies. If I had been asked the question put to the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste at the time: "Is it true you intend to do away with the food subsidies?" or "Is it true you have decided to do away with them?", I would have said "No." There was no indication to us during the election that it would be necessary. We had no indication that it would be necessary to find something like £14,000,000 to balance the Budget. In fact, we did not balance it because that was not sufficient. We cut out the food subsidies because we had to, but we did not go far enough.

Several times in the Dáil, I have asked ex-members of that Government what would they have done at that time. I have never had a suggestion from one of them as to where we could get another £100,000. We put on £3,000,000 extra taxation. That was as much as we could raise at the time. Every one knows the more you try to get, the more it goes down. Every extra penny on tobacco or on the pint gives you less. We could get only £3,000,000; we cut out the food subsidies; and yet our Budget was unbalanced to the extent of £5,500,000. No member of that Government ever told me where I could get an extra £100,000, and I would be very grateful if Senator L'Estrange could tell me.

Comment on this

They will get it when they are back in power.

Comment on this

So they are keeping it to themselves. The next thing Senator Barry wanted to know was how the Government would be defended on the question of putting up E.S.B. charges and bus fares. In 1956, E.S.B. charges went up by more than they have gone up at present, but at that time Fine Gael did not go around organising meetings about it. The people took it as a necessary evil and had to put up with it. Now, when they are going up under Fianna Fáil, a Fine Gael meeting is held in every village, and innocent people come in to listen to them protesting against the E.S.B. charges.

Comment on this

That is the first time I heard that the N.F.A. is Fine Gael.

Comment on this

The Senator must not have been reading the newspapers. He should pay a little more attention to politics. Both Senator Barry and Senator Murphy referred to Senator Lenihan's "political speech". I have often heard about the kettle calling the pot black, but you really could call the pot black in this case. Was it the only political speech? As I said, I never heard such political speeches in my life as I heard from Fine Gael on this occasion.

Comment on this

From both sides.

Comment on this

All right. We will have it that way, so. Senator McGuire also criticised the type of speech made here.

Comment on this

No answer.

Comment on this

He said they were all either black or white. If Fine Gael were speaking, Fianna Fáil were black; and if Fianna Fáil were speaking, Fine Gael were black. But Senator McGuire managed to make a speech himself where it was all either black or off white. I agree with him that any advance that has been made here —and I shall not say under whom— has been made by the people, sometimes wisely led and sometimes unwisely led, according as the leadership was constructive or not.

Take this question of credit. As Minister for Finance, I met the Boards of the Industrial Credit Company and the Agricultural Credit Corporation and told them they should be as helpful as possible in the matter of credit. I said to them: "You are not going to give out much credit if you have to be absolutely sure in every case you deal with. The reason I am saying that is if you fail to get back your money, I am not going to blame you." That should be the policy to help industry and agriculture, but yet we were criticised for that by a number of Fine Gael speakers, both in the Dáil and Seanad. Whether they are still tied to the restrictive policy they had when they were in office, and which led to the restriction of credit, I do not know. That is where leadership comes in. The people will do the thing, but there must be wise leadership. The people must not be restricted in their efforts to go ahead.

Senator McGuire also said that the reason our national loans were successful was that the interest rates were higher. On the average, perhaps, about a half per cent, but that is not so much. It may be due to the fact that there is more money available now and that there is more confidence now, but, in any event, I do not think it is entirely due to more attractive interest rates. As Senator McGuire pointed out in another connection, it was the general rate of interest earned at the time that decided the rate. Whenever a Minister is going for a national loan, he tries to find out what will attract money, considering the general interest rates all round. Interest rates all round were a bit higher when we were there and that made a great difference.

Another point raised was that Deputy Lemass, as he then was, had declared that Fianna Fáil had decided taxation was high enough and should not be raised. There are two ways of looking at this matter. Do Senators think if we are taking £131,000,000 this year, we should take only £131,000,000 next year and cut our taxation accordingly, to expect from the same tax a higher yield? If Deputy Lemass meant what I would mean by making that statement, it was that if we do not raise taxation but get in more, that is all right. We are not raising taxation but we are getting in more today.

We have changed certain taxes since 1957. We have increased some and reduced others. I am quite sure if they were tabulated we would find that we were getting in the same amount as if there had been no change. We took off as much as we put on, so that even though we have not increased taxation, I admit we are getting in more money. That is because—to use a word I do not like—of greater buoyancy. There is more money there. For instance we are getting in more income tax now than last year because people are earning more and they are bound to pay more——

Comment on this

P.A.Y.E.

Comment on this

They are paying more. It is not all due to P.A.Y.E. and anyway, if they were not earning the money, P.A.Y.E. would not get it off them. I am not giving away any secrets when I say that I expect to get more income tax next year than last year. We shall have a good Budget this year.

Comment on this

And then go to the country immediately afterwards.

Comment on this

And we shall do that as much to "grig" Fine Gael as to please Fianna Fáil. Senator McGuire said that he did not approve of putting industries here and there under political pressure. That is the kind of statement I do not like to hear. I do not know where political pressure can be used. I have done my best to get industries in my own town and I did not succeed and I think I am as good at using political pressure as anyone else. Where can it be used? After all, what happens is that local people say: "We are going to start an industry." They know what they have in mind, they say they are going ahead and they know where they are going to start it. As far as people from outside are concerned, they show us their location and they have never been told: "You must go there." Of course there is an inducement to them now to go to the underdeveloped areas because of the bigger grants, but apart from that no pressure can be used on them.

I was complaining that no suggestions were made but I have to give credit to Senator McGuire for suggesting that the amenities in the country should be made more attractive by having farm villages, industrial centres, more tourism and so on. At any rate, it is a suggestion although I do not know how practical it is. It would be difficult to get the farmers to live in a village like that. They are accustomed to living on their own farms. In fact, on a few occasions I have seen cases of two farmers living side by side and when one of these farms comes to be sold, its purchase is not regarded as an attractive proposition. Nobody likes to go and live practically in the same yard as another man. People have these ideas and it will take a long time to get rid of them. Senator McGuire said he would like to see a Fine Gael Government trying it. Well, if it could be tried in vacuo it would be all right but we would not like to see it tried because we think it would finish the country altogether.

Comment on this

There is every hope now.

Comment on this

They will be growing sideburns before there is a Fine Gael Government.

Comment on this

There is not much chance for the Senator.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley in his speech tried to destroy any hope the farmers might have from the increase in cattle prices. He said that as far as the small farmer was concerned it was not going to do him any good. As a matter of fact, he said that when there was a bad harvest it did not do the small farmer any harm. I think a bad harvest can do the small farmer an awful lot of harm. After all it is not only wheat that can be injured. There may be a bad crop of potatoes, barley, oats or, worse still, you might have a bad crop of hay. Therefore the bad harvest is just as serious for the small farmer as the big farmer, and I am quite sure that that increase in the price of cattle will benefit the small farmer.

The Senator said that a few days' work on Bord na Móna would be more important to the small farmer. He did not say the Coalition Government were responsible for Bord na Móna. The establishment of Bord na Móna was the only thing they did not claim in this debate. In fact, we all remember that when the Coalition came into office in 1948 they closed it down. It was one of the Fianna Fáil schemes. They closed it down but after a few years when they found they could not get coal, they started it again and they organised committees to encourage the cutting of turf. Of course it became a Coalition scheme because they had to encourage the cutting of turf after closing it down. In the same year, 1948, in regard to the Avoca Mines, they took out of the Estimates the amount provided for the mineral exploration, I think it was £80,000. It was kept out until Fianna Fáil come back into office. Fianna Fáil put it back again and carried out exploratory work and they found certain minerals. As a result, the St. Patrick's Copper Mines were started.

Senator Burke said that the Coalition kept down the cost of living. I have noticed that some Fine Gael people believe that. Senator L'Estrange gave certain figures. I did not check on them; I accept they are in or about right. If the cost of living is up and if anything can be done about it, let us try to get down to doing it.

Another point made by a number of speakers was that the farmers are not holding their proportion of the national income. They are not, but that point alone, I would say, is not of any great consequence. One can imagine that if we discovered a huge quantity of oil, which we could just pump out and export, the national income would go up by 50 per cent. but the farmers would not benefit by more than two or three per cent. so that their proportion would be lessened. What happened during the last few years was that industries increased very much more rapidly than before and outstripped agriculture and therefore the farmers had a lesser proportion of the national income than others. It is regrettable that agriculture did not advance as rapidly as industry but that is no reason why we should put a brake on industry and hold it back——

Comment on this

You should change the method of taxation.

Comment on this

——until agriculture advanced. But I do not think there is much in that point, about the proportion that various people get. It is possible, with the great expansion in tourism, that perhaps hotels are getting more than before. That is possible but those things will vary up and down and the figures of proportion are just an indication of a trend.

Comment on this

There is a 20 per cent. reduction.

Comment on this

It was not as much as that. I do not think that figure is correct.

Comment on this

Look up the figures.

Comment on this

That is all I have to say.

Comment on this

If I understand it correctly, this section deals with the Excess Vote for the Department of External Affairs. That Excess Vote has been certified by the Department of External Affairs as being due to the movements of ambassadors. I have not seen the certificate but I have been so informed by a member of the Public Accounts Committee. This kind of Excess Vote, of course, is quite an extraordinary event. The reason it was allowed to occur in 1959-60 was what I might call, for want of a better word, the antics of the Minister for External Affairs in the United Nations.

I have never spoken about this matter, although I felt pretty strongly about it. I might say I know something about it because the previous Government were tempted—I shall not say who the tempters were—before they left office to be first out of the box at the United Nations in relation to this neutralism. That Government resisted the temptation, very properly, I think. There was reason for that. I think it is quite unsuitable for a country of our size to be the first to raise a matter of international importance——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Inferiority com plex again.

Comment on this

It is not an inferiority complex. This is a matter of function and of what, in my opinion, the proper behaviour of people should be. We could play a very important part in international affairs——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We have played such a part.

Comment on this

I must ask Senator Ó Maoláin not to interrupt.

Comment on this

——because we opposed what is known in the modern world as colonialism. We were one of the first countries successfully to oppose it. Therefore, we can play a very important part. But this was a very different matter. The Minister is our representative and I would not criticise him in the United States, but here at home, we are quite entitled to criticise him. One can put it in any language one likes but he took us into the Red lobby in U.N.O.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is the greatest fraud I ever heard.

Comment on this

I am coming to the more important part of this in relation to this Bill. If the Minister, having done that, was prepared to face the consequences, that is to say, to come to Dáil Éireann for a Supplementary Estimate as he should have come at the beginning of 1960, no doubt he would have had a debate lasting a couple of days on his hands, but at least he could say that he had faced up to it and that he did not take the back door way out.

This amount of money is now, in effect, being charged 15 months after it was spent. Of course, there is a certificate that it was due to pushing Ambassadors around but you deal with moneys of this sort within the year. Any excess could be due to any item you like to pick in the case of a Vote with an expenditure of this size. What I want to convey is that in the accounts branch of the Department of External Affairs, there was not the slightest doubt that it was well known well in advance of 31st March, 1960, that this excess would be incurred.

An excess Vote is not a joke. I remember one excess Vote in Dáil Éireann many years ago for an amount of £1 or £2 on a Vote accounted for by the Department of Finance. Deputy Dillon said then: "They are very honest. They did not try to cook the figures. It would be quite easy to leave a bill unpaid over the year, particularly in the case of a small sum." This is a completely different matter. I believe it was done because the Minister for External Affairs was not prepared to face up to the consequences in the Dáil. It was hoped that it would be forgotten, that the circumstances arose a long time back and that nobody would say anything about it.

I believe, first of all, that particular performance at U.N.O. was no credit to this country and, secondly, that very unfortunately, in my opinion, it let down our missionaries abroad. I regard that as a very shameful matter. These are people who do not go out of this country except to give a service of a special kind. I want to register my protest here about this matter being held over in this fashion for a period of 12 or 15 months. It is an extremely bad business and I am sorry that the Government did not have the courage to face up to it at the time and instead took what I call a cowardly backstairs way out of it.

Comment on this

Is the Senator trying to convey that he has not read the Dáil Debates or that he has forgotten about them in order to make this attack which he knows is not warranted about the United Nations? Expenditure in relation to the United Nations does not come out of this Vote at all. The Senator has given the impression that this was due to extra expenditure at the United Nations. That does not come under this Vote. I do not think I need say any more.

Comment on this

Since the Minister has taken that way out now, I must say that the Minister for External Affairs should have come to Dáil Éireann for authority for a Supplementary Estimate and he would have had to account for the policy of his Department, and he did not do it. So much for the Minister's answer.

Comment on this

The Senator wanted to throw some mud as usual at the Minister for External Affairs about the United Nations, about his actions there. It does not arise under this Vote.

Comment on this

I have never spoken on the subject before so why does the Minister say throw mud "as usual"?

Comment on this

The Senator knows the facts very well. He always reads the Dáil Debates because he quotes them here but it seems he decided to put them away and forget about them because they did not suit.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And it was out of order altogether.

Comment on this

It is not out of order.

Comment on this

The United Nations is not in this at all.

Comment on this

This is a shameful attack by the Deputy Leader of this House. We all know that the Opposition had ample opportunity to put down a motion of no confidence last year and to take full advantage of such a motion to criticise the Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this

He was not there.

Comment on this

It is a shame that the Committee Stage of the Central Fund Bill should be used for an attack on the Minister for External Affairs who, it is agreed in general, has made great strides at United Nations meetings. Not merely is that agreed at home but also in Europe and beyond. I can produce evidence here from various papers in support of that statement. I do not think Senator O'Donovan can support his criticism by a single scrap of evidence.

Comment on this

There is no use in calling this a shameful attack or anything of the kind. The Government or the Department of External Affairs could quite easily have prevented this happening. There has been no explanation yet as to how this happened. You do not get rid of £6,900 of departmental funds by dropping it out of the window. How did it happen? There is no use in pretending that you can drop a sum like that out of a £400,000 Vote. If it were £690, I should say, well and good—there might be quite a simple explanation; but there is no simple explanation for this. The purpose of the Supply Services discussion is well known.

The purpose is to ensure that the Government will come to Dáil Éireann if they want to spend money, particularly if they want to spend it in relation to a service, the expenditure on which can be criticised. Suppose it were an error, one would be quite entitled to ask: "How come an error of this magnitude?" If one felt it was a straightforward error, one might say: "Well and good." All the evidence here, however, certainly points to the fact that there was going to be no Supplementary Estimate taken for that Department that year because the Government did not want a discussion on the matter in Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this