We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Finance Bill, 1961 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage.

Contributions 158–356 of 356. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1961
Enacted

No. 17 of 1961 ›

Nobody can deny that the standard of living of the Irish farmer to-day is at the lowest level since the Economic War. Never since the days of the Economic War were things so bad with the farmers of Ireland as they are to-day and there is nobody who can deny that fact. As Senator Burke has stated, the income of the farmers dropped from 29.9 per cent. of the national income to, I think, the 24 per cent. of the national income they received last year.

The farmers are being crushed with soaring taxation. They face increasing taxation every day and reduced prices for their produce. If anybody looks up the official statistics, he will find that under all headings the farmer is getting less today than he received in 1953. For wheat in 1953 he was getting 32/- per 112 lbs.; in 1960, he got 29/4. For oats in 1953 he got 24/6; last year he got 18/8d. For fat cattle per 112 lbs. in 1953 he received £10 10s. and last year the price was down to £10 8s. per cwt. deadweight. In 1953 for hoggets, sheep, per 112 lbs., deadweight, he received £14 16s. 3d. and last year he received £12 13s.

The position is worse today because lamb prices have dropped. It is impossible to sell lambs today. Yet the people getting those reduced prices are paying more and more in taxation. It is no wonder that the small farmer who is being crushed between reduced prices and increasing taxation is locking the door and leaving the land. That is a bad day's work for this country. The day the small farmer is driven out completely—and he is being driven out fast at the present time—will be a very bad day for this country.

The Fianna Fáil Party have always claimed in the past that they represented the small farmer. The world knows they are doing very little for the small farmer of Ireland today. We talk about getting markets abroad. The inter-Party Government negotiated and secured markets in Germany and France for lambs and sheep. I think that in 1957 we exported £7 million worth of lamb to France. What has happened to those markets, despite the fact that we are buying at least five times as much from France and from Germany as they are buying from us? Why can our Minister not go over and say: "We are not prepared to buy £15 million worth from you unless you are prepared to buy the same amount from us"? They have not done that and the time has come to do it. Four years ago, a sum of £250,000 was set aside for marketing and helping to find new markets. I remember Senator Lenihan speaking at length here about that. What has happened to that project? Last year, we were the only country in the world not represented at the British Trade Fair in London where we have one of our best markets. We have mentioned this on numerous occasions but so far we have failed to get any reasonable excuse.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I thought the Senator did not want us to have anything to do with Britain?

Comment on this

No; it was you on that side of the House who said "the British market is gone and gone forever, thanks be to God." We always believed, not for the love of them or because of the colour of their eyes, or because we were more pro-British than you on that side of the House, that it was good business to deal with our nearest neighbour. You said the market was gone and gone forever and the people were urged to keep bees instead of cattle.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That was a most unfortunate interruption.

Comment on this

That day is gone and you seem to be converted now to the idea of a British market.

Comment on this

I just want to speak briefly as my own county has been mentioned by Senator Burke and Senator L'Estrange. I want to refute what they stated. Senator L'Estrange was probably in Kilkee recently. He says the houses are being locked up there, and that the people have gone away.

Comment on this

I am sorry I had not got a camera with me.

Comment on this

That is a gross untruth. In Clare, we are very fortunate. We have very little unemployment and we have to thank the Government and the Minister for Finance for that. We have one of the best sources of employment in the country, that is, Shannon Airport, where at the moment there is employment for about 1,500 people. Most of them are from Clare but a good many of them are from Limerick. We can remember the predictions made about this airport by the false prophets. It was to be a place where rabbits would be jumping around. The rabbits would probably have died from myxomatosis but I take it that the hares would have taken their place. The Fianna Fáil Government purchased the Constellations years ago but the very minute the inter-Party Government got into office, they sold them and they got more for them than the Fianna Fáil Government gave for them. I suppose they wanted the money. They closed down the Lockheed workshop where Clare men were to be trained as skilled technicians. The result is that it has started again only in the past couple of years and we are about 10 or 12 years behind.

Taking the picture all round, in Clare, we have good farmers, men who use their land effectively and men who know how to use their vote. They knew how to use their vote in 1928, right down to Parnell's time and again when a greater man than any of them came along in 1917 and it was our greatest privilege to have him represent us for almost 40 years.

Comment on this

Amen.

Comment on this

The people of Clare were described as incompetent and it was said that they were locking their doors and running to England. The people of Clare are able to produce the finest horses and the horse which got first place in Cork recently was produced in Kilkee and bred in Doonbeg. The picture painted here tonight by Senator L'Estrange and Senator Burke was the greatest possible misrepresentation of the facts. I know of course that they have not any great love for the Clare people.

Comment on this

We love all the Irish people.

Comment on this

We do not export them, like the Government.

Comment on this

Any time they came there, the people pronounced judgment on them. I did not interrupt Senator Burke and Senator L'Estrange and I expect the same courtesy as I gave them.

Comment on this

We are only helping the Senator.

Comment on this

They will be appealing to them again soon and I have no doubt what the result will be, and in their hearts neither have they. Why did Senator L'Estrange not come down to the bye-election a year and a half ago when the present President——

Comment on this

I was helping to win the bye-election for Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this

I was hoping to meet the Senator down there. I want to congratulate the Minister on our present position. We have had a balanced Budget for the past four years. We know what the position was in 1957 and 1958. Those of us who were in local authorities knew there was no money for any schemes. The then Government had not got it and they were not able to raise it. Fianna Fáil did not put them out, either. They had some time to go and they went out themselves. They went to the people to put the position right and the people did put it right and they will do so again in a few months' time.

Comment on this

Furmhór na Seanadóirí a labhair go dtí seo, labhradar, im thuairimse, mar gheall ar neithe nach bhfuil morán baint acu leis an mBille seo. Ba mhaith liomsa an méid atá le rá agam a dhiriú ar neithe a bhaineann leis an mBille atá ós ár gcomhair.

Is Bille é seo a bhfuil baint aige le cúrsaí cáin. Tá fuath againn go léir do chánacha agus do chánacha a dhíol. Caithfear iad a dhíol; caithfear gnótha na tíre a choinneáil ar siúl. Rud ná luaitear in aon chor is ea gur in Éirinn a chaithtear an t-airgead sin ar fad beagnach. Is aindeis an crot a bheadh ar ghnó poiblí na hÉireann mura ndeintí é sin. Tá na feirmeoirí ag coinne le teagasc agus le deontaisí, le feabhsú ar a gcuid eallach, ar a gcuid síl agus ar a gcuid oibre. Bíonn lucht oibre agus daoine bochta ag coinne le seirbhísí leighis, seirbhísí fóirthne, le tithe agus le neithe eile. Ar na neithe sin a caithtear an t-airgead. Ar mhuintir na hÉireann a caithtear an t-airgead agus má baintear de chuid againn é, caithtear ar an bpobal i gcoitinne é agus ar dhaoine a íochann fíor-bheagán den chnósach a bhíonn déanta ag an Aire.

Is ar an mBille ba mhaith liomsa go ndéanfaimid caint agus ní ar an rud a dúirt ár sean-mháthair 60 nó 80 bliain ó shoin. Ná bímis ag caint faoin mbéal bocht. Ní dúthaigh bhocht í seo; ní dúthaigh aindeis í seo. Tá neithe inti gur ceart a fheabhsú. Tá an Rialtas ag gabháil don fheabhsú sin agus tá ag éirigh leo. Bíodh deire againn le cáineadh agus leis an mbéal bocht. Ní dúthaigh aindeis í seo; ní dúthaigh bhriste í seo.

Ag caint ar thalamhaíocht, ar thalamh agus ar thithe dúnta, tá a fhios againn go bhfuil a leithéidí ann. Tá a fhios againn go bhfuil cuid den phobal ag tréigint cuid den talamh ach tá a fhios againn, leis, go bhfuil cuid eile den phobal sásta dhá luach a thúirt ar aon phíosa talúin a bhíonn le fáil. Is cómhartha é sin den mhuinín atá ann maidir le cúrsaí talmhaíochta. Ní fíor a rá go bhfuil na feirmeoirí dhá dtréigint ag an Rialtas. Ní fíor ach oiread go bhfuil na hoibritheoirí agus lucht tionscail dhá thréigint ag an Rialtas. Tá an Rialtas ag déanamh oiread agus is féidir leo agus tá siad dhá dhéanamh slachtmhar go leor, éifeachtúil go leor agus torthúil go leor.

Comment on this

Senator O'Donovan put as an alternative whether it was better to have a deficit in the Budget or to balance it by the creation of money. I do not think that is an alternative because I do not think there was inflation during the past three or four years and, therefore, the alternative does not apply. He also spoke of various parts of the country being much worse off because of the increase in tax revenue. I am prepared to admit that there may be certain parts of the country which are not as well off as we would like to see them, and which we would like to see better off, but I do not think it can be claimed that, generally speaking, anyway, this Government put up taxation. It is true that we got more money but we took a big slice off income tax and the allowances applicable to income tax, such as family allowances and earned income allowances.

We put a tax on many commodities such as fruit, and so on and we increased the tax on tobacco. As I mentioned here before, we increased the tax on tobacco four times since we became the Government. We increased it by 2d. in 1957, by 1d. since then and by 1d. this year, making 4d. altogether. That was not as bad as what my predecessor did. When Deputy Sweetman was Minister for Finance, he put 5d. on the price of tobacco in one go. It took me four years to put it up by 4d. and in only one hour he put it up by 5d. I suppose tobacco is a good mark for taxation and we both thought it a good way of getting money.

Senator O'Donovan said that if Dean Swift were alive, he would have suitable comments to make on some of our policies. I should be surprised if an intelligent man like Dean Swift were Fine Gael, if he were here.

With regard to the case raised by Senator O'Donovan about Table 20 of the Central Bank report on capital transactions, I am afraid I cannot give a proper explanation. Even if I knew it, I probably could not give it. As Senators are aware, I could not give individual figures in relation to how it is made up, even if I knew them. This is a net figure which relates to capital coming in and going out. One figure was mentioned by the Senator, and since everyone knows it, it is no harm for me to mention it. The Whitegate Refinery brought in £12 million and that would go part of the way towards explaining the whole position. A sum of £32 million was spent in 1958 and 1959 on capital transactions coming in. I cannot say any more.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

You are not alone in that.

Comment on this

I might be able to get the figures but they would be confidential.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We have not got any explanation.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Senator O'Donovan that there is any cooking of these figures. He wound up with the usual forecast that our financial system is sure to go wrong and that a crash is coming. We have been told that for the past four years and perhaps it will be postponed for another year.

Comment on this

That doom is around the corner!

Comment on this

Senator O'Brien made one very weighty remark. He said that with a growing economy in Europe, it would be very difficult to prevent the economy here from growing. All I can say is that when there was a growing economy on the Continent, the Coalition Government prevented it from growing here in 1956.

Comment on this

That was the time of the Suez crisis.

Comment on this

The Coalition Government were able to put back the hands of the clock.

Senator O'Brien also asked me if we had any intention of introducing a measure of inter-budgetary fiscal controls, somewhat on the lines of controls introduced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in Britain. We have, of course, one control here which he left out, the Control of Imports Act, but the powers given under that Act have always been used by the Government to protect our industries, never in a revenue sense, or in a fiscal sense. Apart from that, I may assure the Senator that we have no intention of looking for these powers because we do not see any necessity for them in the circumstances here.

I agree with Senator O'Brien that the balance of payments position does not look so good this year as it did last year. In fact, in the first five months, we were £6 million worse off than last year. With regard to this balance of payments, if you can see the explanation and see that there is a good reason for it, there is no need to worry. I have not examined the figures recently but I did after the first two or three months and there were a few items at least that one would expect to be against us this year more than last year. One important item was wheat. On account of the very bad harvest last year, 30 per cent. of our wheat was taken for milling, and we had therefore to import a much bigger quantity of wheat than usual. That is probably shown in the increased imports. There may also be other items of capital imports but I do not know if these are there.

Senator O'Brien gave a very reasoned estimate of the prospects of our economy for the present year, 1961. I think he gave a very honest forecast of what the economy would be like this year. It was not an exaggerated account of what we can expect and I would say that on the whole it was satisfactory. The Seanad, I am sure, will be quite satisfied if things turn out as outlined by Senator O'Brien.

On the Common Market, Senator O'Brien pointed out that we would have to cut our profits, as otherwise we could not compete. We all agree that costs must come down and that that is the only way we can compete against other countries in the Common Market. He was right enough in saying that, apart from labour, which is a big item in costs, there are also other items. There is the payment of executives, dividends and other factors which must be very closely watched by the companies concerned. They must also look to their efficiency and their productivity to bring things into line so that they can compete with all comers. These things are being looked after by the industries themselves to a great extent. However, as outlined in the Dáil by the Taoiseach, there are committees examining that particular aspect of industry, committees composed of representatives of industry and of the Government, economists, technicians and others useful in such an examination.

Senator O'Brien went on to say that the Government could not do very much to help the economy compete in the Common Market but that we could avoid putting on extra taxation which might have the effect of raising the cost of living and that we should resist as far as possible any increase in wages to Government servants. He rightly pointed out these facts, but I do not think we are ever the first to give increases. We are usually approached by Civil Service organisations when increases are given by other organisations outside and, as we have a conciliation and arbitration system, it of course is influenced by increases given outside and so civil servants get an increase. In other words, we do not lead the movement to increase wages; we follow others.

Senator O'Brien agreed that we were going in the right direction by changing our taxation from earnings to spending. Senator Murphy who spoke afterwards did not agree with that point of view. There are naturally views on both sides, but I think we might be creating hardship if we were to move rapidly from one to another. If, for instance, we adopted the report of the Commission and put it into operation just as it was, we would certainly be creating great hardship for some people.

As I am on that point, I want to deal with these reports because Senator Murphy drew attention to them. First of all, he was afraid that Government policy on that particular recommendation to change over to some extent from income tax to purchase tax was not satisfactory because it was not definitely a turn down, as one might say. We could not exactly turn it down because we had been pursuing a policy of changing from direct to indirect taxation. Even in this recent Budget, we took off a certain amount of income tax and put an increased tax on tobacco so it would be rather illogical if we turned the idea down completely and that is the reason it was stated in that way.

Finally, he said we issued the report regarding income tax for farmers and gave our decision the next day. That is correct. We were preparing that White Paper on income tax under every aspect, death duties and so on and wanted to deal with the various reports from the Commission so far as they had arrived. The report on income tax for farmers had not arrived very long. We had sent it for printing. We had taken our decision in the meantime, as is often done, and so we issued the printed report and the White Paper practically on the following day. That was because we had no time at our disposal to do anything else. It has often occurred before that the Government have issued reports of commissions and given the decision on them. We did depart from that recently. We issued reports from various commissions and did not announce our decision until afterwards.

To go back to Senator Stanford, he said he was sorry we had made no provision for a reduction in the tax on petrol. He made the allegation that we were paying a higher tax on an inferior commodity than was sold to the people of Britain or the North of Ireland. It is true that our tax is slightly higher. There is not much in it. I think it is a penny or three halfpence. But this is the first time I heard the allegation that it is an inferior commodity. I do not believe that, but, however, a responsible Senator has made the allegation and I will certainly make an inquiry about it. I am sure Senator L'Estrange would not like it to be true and I would not, either.

Another point which he raised was in regard to the 25 per cent. stamp duty on estates purchased by aliens. He gave the example of a person who might have bought an estate but who had not concluded the deal. He bought the estate knowing what it was going to cost and calculating what the three per cent. stamp duty would be and suggested that he might not be in a position to pay another 22 per cent. stamp duty. That point was argued very strongly in the Dáil by Deputy Sweetman. We ended by not accepting it because there were many reasons against accepting it. There are reasons for accepting it, I admit, but there were many reasons for not accepting it, principally because it would be almost impossible to prevent fraud. I take it that it will come up again on Committee Stage and I do not intend to deal with it further now.

Senator Ó Ciosáin said that, according to Senator Donegan, agriculture is relegated to the background and Senator Burke said that unfortunately that is so. Now, Fine Gael are adepts at generalisations.

Comment on this

Wait for the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why did the Senator not stay out?

Comment on this

Another generalisation by Fine Gael is that they kept the cost of living down, which is not true. Another generalisation is that they kept emigration down, which is not true, either. These are all generalisations. Now I will ask Senator Donegan to answer two simple questions. What did we not do that we should have done in the past four years? That is an easy one. Any member of an Opposition should be able to give an answer to that. I would be able to do so if I were in an Opposition. What did Fine Gael do now that we did not do? They never give any answer to these questions. They always make generalisations. They try to make the farmers believe them, without giving any particulars or any reasons.

Comment on this

You will get detailed answers on the Appropriation Bill for about threequarters of an hour.

Comment on this

I hope the Senator will live up to his promise.

Comment on this

He will.

Comment on this

Do not mention milk.

Comment on this

Do not mention cattle; do not mention grass or the British Market.

Comment on this

Do not mention milk because Deputy Dillon's price for milk was 1/- a gallon.

Comment on this

Never. That is wrong.

Comment on this

They deny that now.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I will not go any further with you tonight.

Comment on this

The Minister may be on a John Duffy effort. We will deal with him on the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this

Do not mention milk.

Comment on this

We will mention milk.

Comment on this

It is on record——

Comment on this

What about the promises you made about milk which you did not fulfil?

Comment on this

We fulfilled all our promises. Do not mention pigs. Senator Burke is paying more for pigs now than in 1956.

Comment on this

Because Deputy Dillon guaranteed the price.

Comment on this

Pig numbers were never so low in this country as when Deputy Dillon left office.

Comment on this

They went down to 460,000 in 1947.

Comment on this

I ask the Chair to keep order.

Comment on this

Ask the Minister to keep order. Let him not invite answers.

Comment on this

Take your medicine.

Comment on this

The Minister is not mentioning wheat.

Comment on this

I will mention wheat next. I can see that the Senators are not going to answer questions. They are going to deny these things.

Comment on this

They will be answered.

Comment on this

They would not be found dead in a field of wheat.

Comment on this

Senator Donegan asked about wheat and the recent prices for wheat. I claim credit for having had a big influence in persuading the Government to agree to these prices. I come from a wheat-growing county. I told every farmer I met in County Wexford what I am telling the House now and every farmer in County Wexford said I was right.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that for the past 12 months wheat was handled as it should be handled?

Comment on this

I never met a farmer in County Wexford when I was going round saying that I got this thing done who did not say I was right. The reason is that they were all good farmers because they were on the side of Fianna Fáil. A good farmer wants to see this price because——

Comment on this

A drop of 10/- a barrel since 1953.

Comment on this

From 1957 up, there is no change.

Comment on this

Wheat was 84/- in 1953.

Comment on this

And Deputy Dillon brought it down by 12/-.

Comment on this

And the Minister brought it down another 12/-.

Comment on this

The good farmer likes to see this new price. The good farmer says it will be so much greater this year or next year. He will have to pay a levy to pay for the wheat exported. He does not want to pay a milling price for wheat that is not fit for milling under 57/-. Every good farmer in the country is delighted with the change. The farmers who talk to Senator Donegan and who do not like the change are not farmers at all.

Comment on this

What did you say in your radio speech in 1957? You reduced it a further 12/-.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Let us have no more interruptions.

Comment on this

It was a cruel blow——

Comment on this

"A cruel blow" is right.

Comment on this

That is the year you put beet and wheat up the spout.

Comment on this

"The British market is gone forever" and you cut the calves' throat.

Comment on this

These boys are sleeping in top hats and swallow-tail coats.

Comment on this

Is the Senator dealing with the top hats now? He must be feeling very sore. The 1/- a gallon is a very hard one on him.

Comment on this

A top hat would hold a gallon.

Comment on this

You would want a top hat to top that all right — 1/- a gallon for milk.

Comment on this

It was a terrible policy — 1/- a gallon.

Comment on this

Do you remember when you had it down to 4d. and when turkeys were selling at 2d. a lb?

Comment on this

We had to fight the Blueshirts as well as the British.

Comment on this

The Blueshirts fought for Parliamentary democracy.

Comment on this

They fought for the British.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There must be no more interruptions. I notice that this discussion always ends up with the Economic War and the Blueshirts. They are extremely remote from the Finance Bill of any year in the 1960's.

Comment on this

They were not remote in the 1930's.

Comment on this

I would not take long if the Senators would allow me to talk. I think it was Senator Murphy who raised the point about P.A.Y.E. He said that the people paying income tax under P.A.Y.E. have an objection to paying income tax but they think it is all right as, in the circumstances, they must pay and that is the best way. But he said they have a suspicion that other people are getting away with it. That may be but I do not know what we are to do about it. We have tightened up the Income Tax Acts to a great extent during the past two or three years. I had to fight very hard to get some of those sections through, both in the Dáil and in the Seanad. If I were to bring measures here that would give the Revenue Commissioners power to make sure that all these sections were paying their proper income tax, I am afraid the liberal element in the Dáil and Seanad would be very much against me. I would not mind doing it at all if I thought I could get some sort of agreement on it.

Comment on this

We shall have another five years and maybe we shall have a try at it.

Comment on this

To go where?

Comment on this

The Senator is in the wilderness.

Comment on this

Do not worry. Fianna Fáil are on the way out. They made three or four good attempts to stay in during the past three years.

Comment on this

I am not a betting man but I know people who would put hundreds of pounds——

Comment on this

We might have a little bet.

Comment on this

The Senator would drop down to sixpences when it came to placing the bet.

Comment on this

£1 a seat up or down. There—you have that bet. Would you take it? I do not think you would.

Comment on this

I see. So you think we should get a majority again? I think we shall, myself.

Comment on this

No. I will have that bet with the Minister.

Comment on this

The Senator is not prepared to bet on the majority?

Comment on this

I will have a bet of £1 a seat up or down with you now, if you like, but you are not prepared to take the bet.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This should be arranged afterwards. This is not the place for it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

This is not a betting place.

Comment on this

You could collect tax, too.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan said he thought there was danger in the negotiations that the Government might sell agriculture, as it were, in order to get better provision for the industrialists. There is no intention whatever of doing that. I can assure the Senator that that is entirely a false impression, if he has got it.

Senator Burke talked about inter-Party Government measures which had the effect of keeping the population figure stationary for one year. When we go back, we find the year was April, 1953, to April, 1954—not that the population remained stationary but it was the only year, up to last year, when employment increased since the State was set up. It is a most extraordinary thing that any Senator on the other side should claim that as a credit for the Coalition because it occurred in the three years when Fianna Fáil were in office. In the first year, there might be some reason for saying it was due to Coalition policy but it was in the third year that Fianna Fáil were in office that that position was achieved. They were then in office for three years again but they did not hold that position. Employment went down each year and only in 1960, that is, between April, 1956, and April, 1960, were we able again to get the position where employment was not decreasing. As a matter of fact, it just held its own in that year. We have not yet had the figures for the year from April, 1960, to April, 1961. These figures are not usually available until the end of the year. I am just pointing out that it was in that particular year that that occurred.

Coming on to emigration, I want Senators to realise that we came into office early in March, 1957. It is hard to influence a policy that has been very wrong. It is very hard to get it right for a few months, anyway. However, I am not claiming that now but I would ask Senators to make this up for themselves. They can do it, I think, if they take the three years from 1st March, 1954, to 1st March, 1957—the three years they were there—and take the emigration during those three years and take the four years 1st March, 1957, to 1st March, 1961, and take the average for these four years and then, as the schoolteacher says, let me know what the result is.

Comment on this

There is an answer to that. So many have emigrated that very few are now left to emigrate.

Comment on this

They would do better than that in first class.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator will say he is right when I tell him this, too. In the past six months, the emigration figures went down very much.

Comment on this

Eighty thousand people applied for work in Great Britain, according to the British Government.

Comment on this

You are talking about another figure now. I am talking about the net movement in and out of this country by sea and air. These are the figures that are taken as an estimate. It can only be an estimate of emigration between census periods. For one thing, we have no figures of people going across the Border and back. The estimate assumes the fact, if you like, that the net movement across the Border cancels out and therefore they take the other figure as being the nearest.

Comment on this

We have not Donegal-Glasgow or Louth-Glasgow at all.

Comment on this

Senator L'Estrange told us that for the ten years Fine Gael were there, they started the E.S.B. and the beet factory.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

One beet factory.

Comment on this

You called them white elephants at that time.

Comment on this

I know, and I have been hearing for the past 30 years that claim of Cumann na nGaedheal that their Party started those two projects. Strange, they never claimed more than that over ten years.

Comment on this

We could sit for an hour on it. Do not forget the Land Project and——

Comment on this

They could not claim more because it was not there. They were in between 1948 and 1951. They claimed nothing for that period. For the period between 1954 and 1957, they claimed Whitegate and the St. Patrick's Copper Mines. In a period of 16 years, they claimed four projects in this country and they cannot claim another.

Comment on this

The Minister is not talking to school children now.

Comment on this

We had exploration in Wicklow in 1948, which Deputy McGilligan stopped for three years. When we came back, we started exploration again. By the time we went out, it was patently clear that something was there. These people came along and started the copper mines and now they have the cheek to call that Fine Gael policy, after trying to stop the project as far as they could.

Take Whitegate. An election was fought in, I think, 1937. The present Taoiseach was endeavouring at that time to get a refinery in this country. He had not succeeded but Fine Gael and Labour made a combined attack on him for thinking of such a thing as starting an oil refinery in this country. In fact, a paper was got out specially for the election—Labour News. It carried advertisements, quite sufficient to pay for the paper, anyway, and these advertisements were about the oil refinery. We had to stand all that onslaught from Fine Gael and Labour and when the Coalition were there, they got Whitegate going. Senator L'Estrange takes 1947 as a basic year. That is not only unfair but it is absolutely ridiculous.

Comment on this

The Minister can take 1946, if he wants to.

Comment on this

Every Senator knows that around that time, from 1945 to 1947, because we had no fertilisers, it took some 1,000,000 acres of wheat to supply the country. We had to grow twice the acreage of potatoes to get the yield we needed and the same applied to everything else because no fertilisers could be got during the war as we had no shipping available for that purpose. That meant that the yields were extremely low in 1947. As Senators know, we renew our seeds practically every year to some extent and these seeds are sold as pedigree seeds, or imported seeds, and under all sorts of labels. We got no seeds in during the war. I am not arguing too strongly, but I often thought we could produce our seeds just as well as the foreign ones. We had no imports of feeding stuffs. We do import a good deal of feeding stuffs and as a result of importing them, we had a certain output of pigs and poultry and so on. In addition, by importing our feeding stuffs, we get the proteins necessary not only for pigs and poultry but also for cattle, milk and other things. It is a most important item and we were not getting it during those years. That being the position, have Fine Gael not got a poor footing when they take that as a basic year? Deputy Dillon mentioned it a few times in the Dáil but he does not use it now because we shamed him out of it. The Senator has not got the same shame as Deputy Dillon.

Senator Burke complained, and I do not know exactly what his point is, that of the total output agriculture formed a bigger percentage ten years ago than now. It does not matter what year he took. He was talking about the percentage. I do not know whether there is very much in that point. One of the big troubles we all recognise in agriculture is to find a market for our produce that is remunerative. If industrialists over the past four or five years have been finding markets for their products, is that not all right? Let them go ahead. I think Senator Burke would expect the Government to say: "Just hold back because your percentage of the national product is going too high." That would be a ridiculous point. His case in regard to agriculture forming a lower proportion now than it did at that time is not valid at all. His case that the total income of farmers is not any better than it was four or five years ago is a point that has to be kept in mind.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is certainly worse.

Comment on this

It is about the same. Take the last three years. It is lower than last year but last year was higher than the previous year.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Nobody knows better than the Minister.

Comment on this

I know all right. That is why I am trying to talk about it now. It is about the same, but, as I said, we have done our best. We have put money into it. We have tried to bring down the cost to the farmer by giving him cheaper fertilisers. We have continued the Land Project and drainage in both a big way and a small way——

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I strongly object to that. As a matter of fact, in the area I come from, it is quite apparent that the amount for land reclamation has been reduced considerably.

Comment on this

No, not considerably.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In West Cork.

Comment on this

We are spending much more money on arterial drainage which must be done before other drainage. We are also taking in intermediate rivers which will get further down to the farmer. As far as land reclamation is concerned, the amount is certainly not 20 per cent. less than it was five or six years ago.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is certainly more than 50 per cent.

Comment on this

No; look at the Estimate and you will see.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I want to draw the Minister's attention to a question asked in Dáil Éireann last week as to why the amount of money spent on land reclamation in West Cork was reduced. If the Minister can answer me and tell me that the amount of money available in West Cork at the moment is the amount that was available last year, I shall be very glad to hear it.

Comment on this

I could not tell the Senator about any particular place. I know that the amount of money I am paying to the Minister for Agriculture is about 15 per cent. less than the highest peak ever reached.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This discussion would be more appropriate on the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Can we ask—

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We will have it on the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

May I ask a question?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

When the Minister has finished.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I hope we will have the opportunity then.

Comment on this

I agree, Sir, I am afraid I am not in order. As I say, we are doing what we can for agriculture. We are cheapening the farmer's costs of production. We are giving him incentives and one example of that is that if we had not brought in the subsidy on fat cattle, he would be getting between £10 and £20 per beast——

Comment on this

I wonder what will happen next month when you reduce it by £1?

Comment on this

It will still be the same position. The Senator is always wondering but he will find it is not going to vary very much.

Comment on this

We shall have to wait and see.

Comment on this

I am just mentioning that as an instance. All these price incentives, the fixed price for certain things, are designed to help the farmer and I invite the Senator to say what more could we do.

Comment on this

On the Appropriation Bill.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What will the Minister do next month?

Comment on this

The point is that industry may move more quickly than agriculture because industry is finding markets for its goods and all credit to it. They have gone into the British market. It must be admitted that they are getting in under a tariff but they are competing against British industries and successfully selling their goods there. That is a very good start and if we come to the Common Market, we should be able to make sufficient improvement to compete against all comers, as in the British market.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister should tell us what he is going to do about agriculture. He has spoken about industry and I want to hear what he is going to do about agriculture.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister, on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party are in full voice.

Comment on this

I have only one or two notes left. Senator Donegan talked about a "Fanny Adams" Budget. I think he meant there was nothing in it.

Comment on this

A "Sweet Fanny Adams" Budget.

Comment on this

We gave the biggest income tax reduction ever given in 40 years.

Comment on this

It was not much.

Comment on this

The Senator talks about a "Fanny Adams" Budget——

Comment on this

"Sweet Fanny Adams."

Comment on this

It shows they will say anything.

Comment on this

If you gave anything with one hand, you took it away with the other.

Comment on this

Where did we take it away?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

On the Finance Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That was a queer stunt in Drogheda last week.

Comment on this

No. I picked the man I thought was better for the job.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It was a somersault.

Comment on this

We picked the man who was better for the mayoralty. He happened to be Fianna Fáil. Was that not fair enough?

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Everyone is aware that the Leader of the House does not give a twopenny Fanny Adams what happens to agriculture.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order! The Leader of the House is not a farmer.

Comment on this

You would admire me for what I did in Drogheda, if you had the spunk.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It did not work.

Comment on this

It worked perfectly.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It has nothing to do with the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Some Senators quoted from the report of the Central Bank. I should like them to look at Table 18 which gives the resources of the various countries and the utilisation of those resources. There is one figure, in particular, I should like Senators to note because it was said by several Senators that taxation was growing very rapidly here. As a matter of fact, if Senators look at the sixth column headed "Public Consumption"—that is where the money is used for public purposes —it shows that the increase in public consumption is lower in Ireland than in any other country in Europe, so we are not so bad after all.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister is now apologising——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is quite clear that the Minister is now apologising for the money that was spent on agriculture.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

I am not apologising for it.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister is trying to apologise.

Comment on this

I am glad we are spending money on agriculture and I am glad we are able to spend money on agriculture. Before I sit down, let me say this about agriculture. Senator L'Estrange said that the farmers were never so badly off. Senators should try to see the full picture. The position in 1956 was that I got letters and letters and letters—I was a T.D. at the time—from farmers asking me to do something to keep the banks off them. The banks were calling in money and saying: "If you do not pay, out you go." They were calling in money all around. Last year, the banks were putting advertisements in the papers saying to the farmers: "We will lend you money." That is a big difference.

Comment on this

Does the Minister claim credit for that?

Comment on this

I am not claiming credit for it but it is a fact.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister is claiming credit for something for which he is not responsible.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There is no doubt that he is responsible for agriculture and the bad position of the farmers.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

No one knows what the Minister——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must resume his seat.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There is no doubt that the Minister——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I must protest. This is making a farce of the House.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister was responsible for the position of the farmers during the Economic War and he can never outlive that.

Comment on this

I would rather outlive that than try to outlive having been a Blueshirt.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I cannot hear the Senator any more.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister and I were together in 1920.

Comment on this

We were.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

We were in the same place. As a Blueshirt, I can tell the Minister that I was just as perturbed——

Comment on this

About the colour of the shirts.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

——about our nation as he was.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must sit down.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

My friend was with me, too.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must sit down. The Minister has allowed him to intervene.

Comment on this

I shall finish now if the Senator will allow me. Senators will agree that the position is that the banks were advertising credit a few months ago, whereas they were calling in money in 1956. Senators will also agree that land was never so dear and the farmers are paying more for it.

Comment on this
John L. O'Sullivan Mr. J.L. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It was never so dear and the Germans are the purchasers.

Comment on this

I am concluding now if the Senator will allow me. I have more faith in the judgment of the banks and the farmers than I have in the judgment of Fine Gael.

Comment on this