Industrial Grants (Amendment) Bill, 1961: Second and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 1–123 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 22 of 1961 ›
The main object of the Bill is to increase the funds available to An Foras Tionscal from which grants may be made up to 31st December, 1963, for the promotion of industries both in the undeveloped areas and in the rest of the country. The Bill also provides for the increasing of the number of members of the Board of An Foras Tionscal from 3 to 5. Its remaining provisions effect comparatively minor changes in the Undeveloped Areas Acts 1952 and 1957 and in the Industrial Grants Act, 1959, arising out of the experience of An Foras Tionscal in the operation of these Acts.
The aggregate amount of the grants which may be made by An Foras Tionscal is being increased from £10 million to £15 million. This increase is necessitated by the fact that the provision of £10 million is likely to be exhausted sooner than was anticipated: as at 31st March, 1961, commitments of the order of £8 million had been entered into against the "ceiling" of £10 million. On the basis of these commitments and taking into account projects at present under examination but which have not yet reached the approval stage it is expected that the limit of £10 million may be reached before the end of the present year. Projects for which grants had been approved by An Foras Tionscal as at 31st March, 1961, involve an estimated total capital investment of over £26 million and are expected to give employment to close on 15,000 workers. For details of particular grant payments by An Foras Tionscal, I would refer Senators to the report and accounts of that body for the year ended 31st March, 1961, which were recently presented to the House.
The present legislation relating to industrial grants is due for renewal on 31st December, 1963. I believe that the time has now come to undertake a comprehensive review of the present scheme, designed to assess the extent to which it has been successful and to see whether any modifications of the system are desirable. Among the matters which will have to be brought under review are the question of whether the present concept of the undeveloped areas has outlived its usefulness and whether the time has come to adopt some alternative such as "development areas" to replace the existing "undeveloped areas" with the object of enabling other parts of the country to qualify for the more favourable grants at present applicable to projects sited in the undeveloped areas. The reaching of decisions on these matters must await the outcome of the review to which I have referred. As a preliminary to the undertaking of the review, An Foras Tionscal has in hands a detailed study of grant aided projects, designed to assess the measure of success achieved by the existing grants scheme. Pending the outcome of the review and the enactment of any consequential amending legislation I intend to continue to implement the policy laid down when the Undeveloped Areas Act 1952 was before the House of confining the scheduling of areas outside the undeveloped areas proper to "fringe areas" which are contiguous to the undeveloped areas.
Senators will be aware that the Industrial Grants Act 1959 specified that the maximum grant which may be given by An Foras Tionscal in respect of an industrial project proposed for establishment outside the undeveloped areas may not exceed £250,000 unless the Government, having regard to the amount of employment likely to be afforded by an undertaking, approve of the making of a grant in excess of that figure. When the Industrial Grants Act 1959 was in course of enactment, it was stated that the Government would not be disposed to avail of this special provision unless in the case of a project offering prospects for the employment of 2,000 workers or more. I intend that this requirement should stand pending the outcome of the review to which I have referred and the implementation of any ensuing amending legislation. Nevertheless, I foresee that an exceptional case might arise which would warrant An Foras Tionscal in recommending to the Government the making of a grant in excess of £250,000 for a project which might not have a minimum employment content of 2,000 workers. The type of project which I have in mind as possibly warranting such an exceptional recommendation by An Foras Tionscal would be one of major importance to the general wellbeing and economy of the State and involving an exceptionally large capital investment. A possible example of such a project might be a timber pulp mill or a chemical industry.
The reason for augmenting the board of An Foras Tionscal is that since the passing of the Undeveloped Areas Act 1952 which limited the Board to 3 members, the responsibilities of the Board have been very considerably widened due to the extension of their activities to the whole of the country instead of to the undeveloped areas, as previously and due to the very substantial increase in the number and size of projects which has come forward as a result of the programme undertaken by the Industrial Development Authority for the attraction of external investment.
The object in providing that An Foras Tionscal may make grants towards the provision of plant (e.g. items such as cranes, roof tanks, electric transformers for general use as distinct from one for use in a particular process) is that legal advice recently received by An Foras Tionscal raised doubt as to whether they were entitled to make grants for plant, as distinct from machinery and equipment, as they had been doing.
The provision relating to restrictions on the sale of assets or shares in a grant-aided concern does not introduce any new concept: it is intended to remove any doubts which may exist as to the legality of the present practice of An Foras Tionscal of writing into the agreements entered into with the promoters, a clause that they will not sell the assets or their shares in the concern, without the previous consent of An Foras Tionscal, for a stipulated period.
Finally, I wish to avail of the opportunity of again stating categorically that the facilities under the industrial grants scheme are available to Irish promoters on exactly the same basis as to foreigners.
I confidently recommend this Bill to the House and I should be glad if it could be given an early passage.
Comment on this
This is a very interesting Bill, which involves quite a large sum of money, as well as a very important aspect of our national life, namely, industrial expansion. Up to now, the consideration in this legislation was to put industries into undeveloped areas and I think it is true to say that in going into undeveloped areas, there was, first of all, a social rather than an industrial ideal. First of all, the aim was more to employ people than to create industrial expansion. I suppose the two went together but primarily the aim was to bring employment to the undeveloped areas.
It seems to me that the thinking behind this legislation will have to be changed. It is in fact being changed in one way but for a different reason from that which I have in mind. The reason I have in mind is the advent of the Common Market. Our Taoiseach told us yesterday that we were about to seek admission, when certain conditions are fulfilled. It would seem, therefore, that in future any industries that will be set up, whether in the undeveloped areas or in the new areas envisaged under this Bill to which the grants may be extended, will have to be approached from this point of view. There is, first, the matter of placing isolated industries in out of the way places. That should not be done unless the industries have some special local value where price content and the price of the articles produced are not a major factor.
I welcome the extension of the grants to areas outside the undeveloped areas. It has often been said that the whole of our country is undeveloped or underdeveloped—call it what you will—including Dublin itself. Although there is here the biggest concentration of industry, it is by no means overdeveloped. That being so, I feel that in future the important thing to ensure is that if industries are to be established in underdeveloped areas, the idea of putting in single industries should be got away from and a concentrated effort should be made to put groups of industries in pockets in different parts of the country.
That is important for two reasons. It is important from an economic point of view because a labour market can be created. Instead of having isolated individuals coming to work in one factory or industry, a pool of workers can be created in the area. Secondly, the workers will be inclined to stay in the places in which they are working, where they can have a social life built round a reasonable number of industries. At present one of the difficulties is that very often when an industry is started and when the promoters have spent a lot of time and money on giving people technical training, they lost the workers. The workers went to England or Dublin. Having gained the skills, they were able to sell their skill at a high price in an area where they had a social life. These considerations should be taken into account in the new set-up of our having to establish industries which will have to compete in the open market and with industries in other countries.
I was rather interested when the Minister told us that Foras Tionscal were at present engaged in a review of the present scheme. That would be in accord with what I have been saying. I see that the Minister was asked in the Dáil what effect the funds already advanced had had in the underdeveloped areas. I was very surprised and pleased to hear the Minister say that there were only two failures out of 61 now in production. That is very good. When they are carrying out the review of the present scheme, I am sure Foras Tionscal will also inquire into how many of those 61 now in production will exist in the new arrangement towards which we are moving. Will these industries be able to survive without protection? How long will it be necessary to protect them in order to enable them to survive? Can they be brought into such a state of efficiency as to enable them to compete in the new situation? Generally speaking, the Bill is to be welcomed.
Comment on this
The Minister expressed the wish that this Bill would be given a quick passage. Certainly, I would not wish to delay it. This Bill, however, was initiated prior to the decision in regard to the E.E.C. and largely provides for commitments entered into before that decision was taken at all. In that situation, it is somewhat unreal to be considering the question of developed areas and undeveloped areas because we must face up to the situation that it is not simply a part of the country but the whole country which must be regarded as undeveloped.
I am glad the Minister has given some indication that this question is to be reconsidered but before that reconsideration is entered into, I think we should look carefully at what we are doing at the present time. In other words, I do not think it is very wise, in view of the decision to apply for membership of the European Economic Community, to go ahead with the setting up of industries without attempting to assess whether or not they will have a future. If we become a member of the E.E.C., it does not make sense to set up industries and a year afterwards face the possible dismemberment of them. That is no solution to our economic difficulties.
I referred to developed and undeveloped areas. I should like the Minister to consider his and my native city. I suppose it is regarded as a developed area. It is certainly not in the undeveloped areas but in the context of E.E.C., I wonder what the situation of industry will be there? What, for example, will happen Fords? Does it make sense that Fords could possibly continue to manufacture cars for this small market in the context of the European Community when they could do it at bigger centres nearer the markets and nearer the raw materials? The same situation exists in regard to the neighbouring firm of Dunlops. It is ridiculous to regard such a place as a developed area that would not need special assistance in the development of industry and in the provision of employment.
I grant that this Bill was initiated prior to the decision being taken and I grant that it largely provides for commitments entered into before the decision was taken. Before we go any further, I think the Minister and the authority concerned should take a careful look and see if we could not use our resources better in the situation we are facing and whether we would not be doing a better job for our citizens if we concentrated on the larger units, on industries that would have some possibility of a future in the European Economic Community.
I hope the Minister will not regard what I have said as a criticism of the measure or of what has been done. We should now move away from the idea of developing industry locally so as to provide employment in the undeveloped areas. In the new context, this whole country is undeveloped, not one part developed and another part undeveloped.
Comment on this
No; it is not even that. If it were, it would have something specific. It would be more positive. If Fianna Fáil adopted that attitude in 1932, we would not be in a position now to promote industry. That is my answer to Senator Murphy; that is the answer to Senator Murphy's defeatist speech. The point Senator Murphy was trying to make, that merely because the Common Market is a topical subject——
Comment on this
No. There is nothing new under the sun. For the Senator's information—I do not want to be dragged off the point I am trying to make—the Common Market is not new. If the Senator will study his history, he will see that there is nothing new in the Common Market.
Comment on this
That may be news to Senator L'Estrange. I am quite prepared to accept that that intelligence is quite new to the Senator. I am trying to make the point that the fact that there may be a grouping of countries in Europe does not warrant our ceasing our industrial activity. Far from it. We are now only at the commencement of it. Regardless of what advantages other countries may have, I think we have as good an advantage in the European market as any of them. This Bill has no relation whatsoever to the Common Market but, as the Senator sought to make the point, I should like to say that that is not our attitude.
Senator McGuire made a good point, and it was made before, when he suggested that promotional activities should tend to group industrial efforts. I dare say there is something to be said for that. This Bill deals merely with the financial angle—the Industrial Grants Act. I might say a word about Foras Tionscal: it is more or less responsible, together with the Industrial Credit Company and the Industrial Development Authority. Most reasonable people will agree that Foras Tionscal have done a good job of work in this regard. So have the Industrial Development Authority and the Industrial Credit Company.
I was looking through the last report. One might offer some little criticism on the grounds that the report is scanty in information and a bit late in issuing. But, apart from that, the activities of Foras Tionscal since the Industrial Grants Act—from the period 1956-1959 onwards—are a fairly creditable performance. We are glad, I think, that the Minister has accepted the principle of including marginal areas as ranking for grants under the Act.
I disagree with Senator Murphy that this whole country is an undeveloped country. The Senator has a bad dose of an inferiority complex when he says that. On the contrary, this is a well-developed country. There is nothing undeveloped about it.
Comment on this
I am trying to make a serious point. The Senator will have his soapbox in Mullingar very soon and he can get away with that on the market square when there will be nobody to take him up.
Comment on this
I assume all Parties subscribed to the industrial effort. I said I was glad the Minister had included marginal areas and that he is prepared to sanction comparable grants for areas near the undeveloped areas. We all know that our efforts in this regard will be governed by the size of our purse and the amount of money which can be devoted to promoting industrial activity of this description.
I think most people—chambers of commerce and those interested in promoting industry—can obtain all the information they require from the various bodies set up to deal with this matter. Speaking on my own behalf, I found the Industrial Development Authority, the Industrial Credit Company and Foras Tionscal which, incidentally, is not a State body, very helpful any time I sought information regarding the location of an industry, the financing of an industry or any smaller details regarding preliminaries.
There is nothing good but can be better. While I do not agree with lengthy reports, it might be useful if it were possible to have this report with a little more padding and to have it issued a little earlier. One notes from the report that, of the 100 or so manufacturing projects proposed over the past five years, roughly one-third have British interests involved. It is understandable enough that this type of industrial activity should appeal to the British businessman for reasons which are obvious and into which I need not go now.
There are also some Continental firms interested here and many firms have made contacts with this country over the past few years. I think many of them are anxious—and perhaps in the light of recent events will be more anxious to set up industries here. The reasons are obvious enough—low rates, low taxes, political stability, a good supply of labour and a good potential for industrial technicians. We have upwards of 255 technical schools in this country quite capable of turning out smart young students who are anxious to become, later on, willing workers.
There are many other facilities available to outside industrialists in this legislation. Income tax and corporation profits tax, over a period of ten to 15 years, will be remitted. Any industrialist will realise that this will enable a company to build up a reserve and further to expand from there.
One point I should like to mention is in regard to the wording of the Act where it says that 100 per cent. of the cost of the building and 50 per cent. of the cost of the plant respectively can be paid. I think the wording could be a little more specific. Continental promoters when they see that wording are inclined to look for the full 100 per cent. and 50 per cent., as the case may be. I am quite sure there is available to them sufficient information to let them know that they may not get a grant of that description. I assume that when it comes to legislating on this point, it is hard to be positive. Since the Programme for Industrial Expansion was formulated, there has been more or less steady progress. If we continue that into the next five or ten year period, I am quite sure we shall be in a stronger position than ever to group our industries, if necessary, and to make an assault on whatever market may be available.
Comment on this
I had intended to say a few words on the Minister's brief but the debate has been widened very considerably. I believe in reasonable planning arrangements. Certainly in recent weeks in this House we have had some examples—and we have two more today—of very inadequate planning arrangements, if we are to take the Bills at their face value. Of course we could take the Bills as just pieces of election literature. I am going to develop that point about this Bill.
Comment on this
I want to demonstrate clearly that there is no necessity for this Bill. I will come back to this business of commitments. We know about the Land Commission's commitments. They have £8 million worth of commitments for land each year and what is the amount that is spent?
Comment on this
I am not echoing Deputy McGilligan. It is my own view and I am not echoing anybody. I had not intended saying this but since the Minister takes that line, I may say that when I read this brief, I said to myself: "His master's voice".
Comment on this
Let the cap fit. Two years ago, we had a Bill in this House to provide for grants under these pieces of legislation with a limit of £10 million. Two years later, it has to be increased by another £5 million. Does that suggest reasonable planning? We had the same thing last week when we had the Air Navigation and Transport Bill. The amount in relation to that legislation was increased from £8 million to £10 million two years ago and now it is being made £13 million.
Comment on this
It does not suggest that people can see very far ahead. My main point is that there is no necessity whatever for this piece of legislation at this time. It will probably be two or three years before the sum of £10 million is exceeded in grants under this legislation, that is, moneys paid out.
Comment on this
This is like the Fianna Fáil Deputies in the Dublin Corporation who would not make any grants until the money was in the till; the game worked by two Fianna Fáil Deputies on the Housing Committee. This is the obverse of the coin. It takes years sometimes for commitments to go through a system and I am not talking about the word "debts" which became "commitments" in certain political events in the past.
There is one other matter in the Minister's brief. He states that a possible example of a large project is a timber pulp mill. Am I to take it from this statement that the Government have decided to develop the timber products industry through private industry? If they have, it is a very serious decision to announce in this way.
Comment on this
The Senator should not be talking through his hat. I gave a possible example and the Senator should not be reading things into it.
Comment on this
I shall accept the Minister's word on that score. I shall not develop the point. Either the chemical industry or the pulp industry would be a big thing. They are not really relevant to this Bill, I take it.
The third point I should like to make about this Bill is that apparently over the next couple of years we shall be paying seven per cent. for money. I remember when the Bills dealing with international financial associations, to which we were subscribing, were going through this House, on all sides of the House, we said that it was very unlikely that we would ever want to borrow money from them because they were charging seven per cent. I can see we might easily be going for money to these international bodies for these purposes because apparently we would get it cheaper there than in the particular climate that is building up here at the moment.
In regard to the last few paragraphs of the Minister's brief, it may be again that the same approach of mind applies to this as the Minister pleaded a moment ago. He says that he wishes to avail of the opportunity to state categorically that the facillities under the industrial grant scheme are available to Irish promoters on exactly the same basis as to foreign promoters. This is a remarkable piece of literature. I take it that it was written in the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
I understand that, but I think that sometimes the exact emphasis of the wording may come from somewhere else. Could I ask this: Why has the Minister to come into this House and assure us that the facilities under the industrial grants scheme are available to Irish promoters on exactly the same basis as to foreigners?
Comment on this
I will tell you why. Deputy Dillon specifically appealed to me on the final stage of this Bill last week to make that point on every occasion I could.
Comment on this
All I can say is that Deputy Dillon, the leader of the Party to which I have the honour to belong, must have the Minister's interests at heart, because it suggests to me that there must be throughout the country a strong feeling that a German can get money which an Irishman cannot from an Irish Government.
Comment on this
—that the Minister in his brief concluded: "I confidently recommend the Bill to the House and should be glad if it could be given an early passage." It will be given an early passage all right, but, so far as I am concerned, it could wait two years without the slightest fear of harm being done to any project, to any institution or to any person's livelihood in this country.
Now I want to come to a matter that was introduced in a major way in the discussion, that is, that we find a climate growing up here in relation to the Common Market, that the idea of our joining it has been sold in this country over the past two years by people who have little connection with industry and by a few people who have some connection with agriculture, with the result that the policy of Fianna Fail in relation to industry, which the Fine Gael Party sometimes felt was pressed too hard, but which has on the whole proved successful in relation to the main articles needed by our people—clothing and shelter and many small articles—is to be reversed. Take electric light bulbs. When they were first made in this country, they were terrible. They were not even straight. But now I believe that, in general, we have as good electric bulbs as anywhere in the world. Are we to jettison all these and, at the same time, as Senator Murphy suggested, give away our political freedom as a side wind on it? I am not interested in the people who put their money into those factories, because they have already made at least as much out of them as they put into them, but I am interested in the ordinary people who accepted bad boots and poor quality clothing and badly made delph for many years.
Comment on this
The Senator is now going very far outside the field.
Comment on this
With respect, Senator Carter spoke about what they did in 1932 and I did not hear you call him to order.
Comment on this
The nature of the grants to be made and of the industries to which they are to be made clearly come under this Bill. I believe that on the whole the development of our small industries is now completed. Are we to jettison them and throw overboard something that has been paid for in toil and sweat for the past 40 years—industries the best of which are the ones set up by the first Government here, which was enfiladed on the grounds that it had not given enough protection?
Comment on this
The discussion of individual industries is not appropriate on this Bill.
Comment on this
The spokesmen for some of these small industries are now talking to the people who are concerned about employment in them and it is being said: "You will be compensated if you are wiped out." That is all right. The people who run the industries will be compensated in cash, but what about the workers who will be unemployed as a result?
Comment on this
I am not trying to create a scare. I am just speaking what is in my mind and I am not concerned about what other people say. It was not I who raised this matter on this Bill. If we are to have political economy discussed on this Bill, let us have it. It is quite fair. I am glad to say again that I have on occasions held rather strong views but I find them stated in public by few people. They may state them behind their hands in private all right. On this question of our joining the Common Market in a particular way, I am not alone in my view that we are jettisoning at one stroke of the pen a policy into which so much effort has been put. If there is to be an election on this issue, let us have the election.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's statement on this Bill. The most significant figure he gave was that £26 million is the capital investment in industries providing employment for about 15,000 workers. That is a very comforting fact because it means capital investment of about £2,000 per worker, and as long as we can keep our average capital investment anywhere in that region, we should have no real difficulties with capital supply.
When we are looking at that, it would be well if the Minister and the Government used these same figures to evaluate what the present flight from the land is costing us. There are 7,000 or 8,000 people leaving the land each year. Capital to absorb these into industry would run from £13 million to £15 million a year. I make this suggestion to the Minister in passing from this point, that it would be well to consider that perhaps £13 million or £15 million, if properly invested in the land, might achieve that same objective; in other words, it might accomplish the turning of the tide and keep those 7,000 or 8,000 people on the land. If they are held there, you will have a much sturdier and healthier national community than one where you have this flight from the land.
Comment on this
The Minister has promised a review, and it is quite timely. We all look forward to its findings, especially in the complex situation we find ourselves in at present, as stressed so much by Senator Murphy, that is, the impact of this unknown development on our industries. The next two or three years will be critical and I hope that we shall have full scale and independent reviews of many of our activities, especially a review of what we have achieved up to date in our liberal scheme of grants for industrial development and how these might be regulated to give maximum effect in future.
The Minister said that Foras Tionscal have in hands a detailed study of grant-aided projects, designed to assess the measure of success achieved by the existing grants scheme. That, to my mind, seems to encompass the whole field of the promised review of the present scheme. I must pay the highest possible tribute to Foras Tionscal and their fine staff for what they have done. In this instance, I regard them as the body who have put the policy into operation. They made many of the decisions, and they had a hand in shaping and orientating that policy.
I do not think it is wise that the same body should undertake the major share of the review. A commission or a committee should be set up on which Foras Tionscal would have some representatives, but on which there would also be outside representation. In that way only can we look forward to an impartial and scientific examination of our progress. It is only on such a sound basis that we can chart our course for the future.
The second point which emerged clearly in this debate, and in the Dáil, is the question of the undeveloped areas. The coming of the European Common Market has been seized on by many to belabour the help that has been given to undeveloped areas. That help was of vital importance to the development of the country, and to the creation of small industries in our towns and villages. That, to my mind, was far more important than the creation of the same amount of total employment in Cork or Dublin. It is through the country and its small towns that a nation breathes, and lives, and has its being.
That will be of even greater importance in the future if we join the Common Market, because we will be exposed to all the ramifications of the Treaty of Rome, and we will find that if we are to preserve our nationality, it will be preserved only in so far as we are successful in building up and strengthening our towns, villages and farms. That nationality will not be preserved by having mammoth factories in Cork, Dublin or Galway. I appeal to the Minister, as one who has come from an undeveloped part of the country himself, knows the conditions there, and knows what industries mean to towns and villages, not to fall for the line of reasoning that the workings of the Common Market would aggravate further the flight from the towns and villages in rural Ireland into the cities. I hope that will be resisted by every possible means.
It has been stated that the country as a whole is undeveloped. Of course, that is just one of those extravagant statements. Undeveloped compared with what? Undeveloped compared with London, yes. Undeveloped compared with England, yes. But we have to count our blessings here, and realise that our stage of development is on a par with the stage of development of 20 per cent. of the population of the world, at least. We have nothing to be ashamed of in the use we have made of the few years we have had to develop. I feel confident that if we play our part in the European Economic Community in the spirit of that Community, and if we see, above all, that everything we prize in our national heritage is preserved and strengthened, we can look forward to the coming decades with confidence. Far too much has been made of the effect of joint industries on our industries.
Comment on this
The question of the Common Market does not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
The Senator will remember the matter was debated on a motion last week. In any case, it is not in order on this Bill. Passing reference may be made to it.
Comment on this
I am making a passing reference to the points raised by Senator Murphy and Senator O'Donovan on that question. I have no intention of developing it at length, but so far as it impacts on the grants for which we are voting money, I want to raise these few caveats. I want to caution people against the idea that it is only the chain store or the enormous industrial unit that can survive, and that, by inference, our small industries should be got rid of as quickly as possible.
Such a policy of monopoly is in many ways totally foreign to the spirit that motivates the Common Market. That spirit is shown in the insistence on family farms, and on their part in developing the morale and nationality of the people concerned. Is not the small industry in a town or village the counterpart of a small family farm? When ranches and 1,000 acre units are taboo on the agricultural side, I do not see why we should not be able to resist strongly a great flight to mammoth industries. I have every confidence that our small industries will go from strength to strength, and will play their part in the future, just as they did in the past.
Of this £26 million which the Minister mentioned has been contributed by way of capital, we as a nation have contributed £8 million by way of grant. That is a substantial contribution by the taxpayers, but the contribution I am looking for and cannot find is a contribution by the workers themselves, that is, a contribution by way of worker participation and worker share capital. The savings of the workers, even though small individually, globally can be quite large and play quite a large part in the contribution to the financing of our industries. I wonder whether in designing the grant scheme, Foras Tionscal have made any effort to encourage that type of capitalisation on a par with the more orthodox type of share capital.
Comment on this
This Bill is concerned with the making of grants.
Comment on this
I know. Surely in making grants, and in making an additional £5 million available, we are at liberty to express views as to how those grants may be used for the best fulfilment of our industrial development. That is all I am endeavouring to do.
The Minister has stressed the fact that the terms and inducements are as readily available to Irish promoters as to foreign promoters. I think he was quite right to stress that very strongly. We have heard it stated in the country that if you speak with a German accent, you get far more than a mere ordinary Irishman. I am glad that has been contradicted by the Minister. I feel that if these Irish promoters included worker participation and the local savings of the credit unions, it would be much more securely tied in to the nation as a whole.
Again, in giving grants to small units, the idea is held that when the small units begin to enlarge, you may have to go to the expense of putting up dwellings, and so on, for the workers involved, as in the case of the Shannon Industrial Estate which we have been discussing. I hold in this context that there is no need whatever for that. We are getting too soft in our thinking. In large industrial countries, like England or America, what is half an hour's travel to or from work? Anyone in the city of New York who has only half an hour or an hour's travel considers he is living on the doorstep of the job. Certainly if any worker or any community of workers is within 12 or 15 miles of the plant in an adjacent town or village, there is no reason why our industrial development should have to face the burden of rehousing them within half a mile of the plant.
With regard to the survival of units in our undeveloped areas, if those areas are classed as undeveloped, I do not see why there cannot be a wage differential between them and large cities. This would be just a realistic appraisal of facts, of what it means to be able to live convenient to work and, at the same time, have all the facilities of the Irish countryside. That is worth a considerable amount. I note that the rate paid in Italy to labour is 2/5d. per hour, while here I think it is 4/2d. There will be inequalities in pay between units in the Common Market and I do not see any reason why such inequalities should not prevail in a free market if it is the only means of ensuring that our small industries will remain in our towns and villages.
I look forward to this review to be carried out by the Minister and appeal to him to ensure that it will be conducted neither by his Department nor by Foras Tionscal but will be as independent as any review can be made as it is the most important undertaking at present.
Comment on this
Senator Murphy should be congratulated on the statement he has made today. He asked us to face realities, not to bury our heads in the sand. I think he is quite correct in the facts he stated and I do not agree at all with Senator Carter who regarded Senator Murphy's speech as defeatist. That is all wrong. It would be better if more politicians in the Government and outside told the people the truth. We are concerned here with £8,000,000 of the taxpayers' money and even if we are on the eve of a general election we should be very careful about the spending of that money. The Minister in this Bill is getting permission to increase expenditure from £10 to £15 millions. Seven million pounds roughly have already been spent so we are dealing with expenditure of roughly £8 millions of the taxpayers' money.
Listening to Senator Carter and some Fianna Fáil Senators one would think that talk about increased production was in some way a substitute for a policy of increased production. I should like to tell them that all the exhortations in the world will not prevent production from declining or even factories from closing with an inefficient administration and a wrongly conceived policy. That is the danger facing us today. That is all Senator Murphy has pointed out to the Minister. He asked the Minister to face realities because the situation today is definitely changing and has changed from what it was a year or two ago. Many Continental firms have come here in the last few years and used Ireland as a back door to the British market. If Ireland joins the Common Market along with Britain—and we have stated we will—a danger faces us that those German or French factories with subsidiary factories here can as easily export to the British market from their own countries as from Ireland and may close their factories here.
Comment on this
It was not sabotage for Fianna Fáil to say the Shannon scheme was a white elephant and that the first of our beet factories was a white elephant. We had a man coming along telling us that he had an interest in those from the very beginning, though the same man told us they were white elephants.
Comment on this
I want to agree with Senator Murphy that we must be very particular about the taxpayers' hard-earned money and make sure that those industries will be able to stand on their own feet, export when the tariffs are taken down in a few years as they very well may be and face the difficulties that will undoubtedly confront them from abroad. The circumstances will be very different in the future from what they were in the past 15, 20 or 30 years. These industries may not even have their own home market.
It is, I think, an awful pity that the Government when appeals were made to them four years ago did not set up a committee to go into the pros and cons of the Common Market and how it would affect our industries. If the Government had done that in 1958 and 1959—instead of trying to abolish proportional representation—instead of a fortnight or three weeks ago, they would have the information now and be in a better position to allocate this money having the full facts before them. We all admit that certain Irish industries can compete, are competing and will in the future compete, with industries from abroad. Others who have got the taxpayers' money and protection for long years have made no effort, good, bad or indifferent, to put themselves in a position to compete, if and when we enter the Common Market.
Comment on this
The Minister knows more about them than I do. He might not like to mention them perhaps at the present time, when the country is facing a general election, but he is in a better position to give those examples as he knows all about them.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Senator that on one occasion he was very insistent that the reference for every statement be given. If he is to be allowed to proceed with these innuendoes, he should be compelled to give the references.
Comment on this
I am telling the truth; I am saying what is known by all industrialists in the country. We all like to believe in our heart and soul that every industry set up in Ireland during the past 30 years could weather the storm but we know that many cannot. The Government have stated they will give compensation and that workers will have to be compensated or other employment found for them. There must have been some necessity for stating that. In spending this £8 million, the Government should be very careful. They should see to it that none of these factories will close down within the next two, three, four or five years when we enter the Common Market. It is admitted that this Bill is a continuation of the Industrial Grants Act introduced by Deputy Sweetman in 1956, an Act which was much condemned at the time.
Comment on this
The 1959 Act enlarged the provisions and now we have this 1961 Bill which again enlarges the provisions. It is only another example of Fianna Fáil swallowing Fine Gael policy, a policy which they condemned in the past.
Comment on this
That was for the undeveloped areas. Who passed the Control of Manufactures Act? Fianna Fáil would not allow any money to come in. They said it would be better if every British ship were sent to the bottom of the sea and that we could do without Britain. They wanted to live in an isolated camp of their own. Now we want to export to Britain and the world. At one time, Fianna Fáil said that the British market was gone forever and thanks be to God—it was a damn good business.
Comment on this
You cut their throats, too, but you will not cut ours.
Comment on this
We allowed the money in for the mines at Avoca and we brought in the three oil companies.
Comment on this
You did not. It is still on the Statute Book.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange, to continue on the Bill.
Comment on this
In another section the number of directors is increased from three to two—I mean from three to five. That is an increase of two.
Comment on this
I can add. If you subtract the position created for Deputy Haughey, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Justice, from the 100,000 new jobs which were promised a few years ago, you will find that there are only 99,999 new jobs to be provided.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the turn some of this debate has taken. It appears that on the Government benches any criticism is considered to be sabotage of the nation.
Comment on this
That type of exclusive arrogance has been adopted by that political Party for too long. Personally, I am not going to allow anyone to get away with it here. It is obvious to anyone reading history that the development in industry which took place here in the 1930s was largely a matter of pure expedience rendered necessary by the destruction of the agricultural industry—the industry which has not yet recovered from the ravages of that period. The figures produced in the Budget show that that reduction is still taking place to the continuing disadvantage of the economy.
We will never build up a sound industry of any sort in this country until agriculture is first put on a proper basis and until industry becomes something that will consider agriculture in its proper context. To my mind, the criteria by which industry can best be judged in this country are: Is it an export success? Do the products it produces give good value for money and has it a good employment content?
Many of the reasons why those criteria cannot be applied to many industries here is the siting of industries in disadvantageous positions. Great Britain is a very successful country industrially but there are not many industries sited in the Highlands of Scotland. They would not long survive there. If heavy and suitable industry is to be sited in Ireland when the Common Market comes in and when we will be forced to be competitive, they will probably have to be sited in the portal areas—in places like Waterford, Cork, and possibly Limerick. I doubt if western Donegal, Sligo or such areas will be nearly as suitable. The freight and other charges would be far too great a burden.
Undoubtedly, there will be great opportunities for this country, if only we use them to the best advantage. One thing I have noticed very much in recent years in the enormous development of the economies of northwestern Europe, particularly Britain, northern France, the Low Countries and Western Germany, is the difficulty of finding portal facilities. The portal facilities and the large water areas available in Waterford and Cork are capable of enormous development and expansion. The large ships that trade in the Seven Seas will find it convenient to break down the cargoes and, perhaps, manufacture the raw materials which they will bring in at these portal areas where they can be cleared quickly rather than having to wait days and perhaps weeks, as they do outside Rotterdam, Liverpool and such ports which are fog-bound and bar-bound and so are unsuitable places. These are the sorts of things that ought to be exploited rather than have items manufactured here that have no change of an export potential and that will never give self-sustaining or increasing employment in this little country.
We have too many disadvantages here to think we shall have the money or the wealth to bolster up industries which cannot have a chance of standing on their own two feet. If we do, what happens in the final analysis is that we shall make our agricultural industry uneconomic by the fact that the costs will rise too high on that industry.
I am surprised these points are not borne in mind when the Government are framing their policy. Many of the industries which have been sited in the west could, with advantage to themselves, be sited elsewhere. With a prospective competitive advantage from entering the Common Market, which most people foresaw, they would have been better sited in the south and the south-east than in the west, where they are less likely to be a success because they will carry the increased costs of freight inwards and outwards.
I do not cavil at the Government for making this extra money available for these purposes. It shows that they are interested in promoting this aspect of our economy. We shall not have enough money in this country to promote anything unless we do so in the best and most efficient way. We shall not be allowed to trade in the Common Market because there are shamrocks on our goods but because the goods that bear the shamrock are the best and most competitive goods entering that Market.
Comment on this
Like other Senators, I wish to support this Bill. I do not intend to say a great deal about it because the necessity for having a sufficient sum available for grants for the establishment of industry is clear to all of us. The point raised by Senator Murphy as to whether at this stage we ought to hand out grants lavishly in view of impending developments is well worthy of consideration. It surprises me that a point of that kind, made in a thoughtful and constructive way, should have engendered such heat on the part of Senator Carter and indeed on the part of the Minister himself.
Comment on this
I did, with Senator L'Estrange. If Senator O'Quigley would say what I said in respect of Senator Murphy's speech, I should be interested to hear it.
Comment on this
I shall talk about the Minister's general attitude towards what Senator O'Donovan had to say. I merely want to point out that there are some grounds for feeling that money of this kind, which might more wisely be invested in other ways, may be ill spent. That is a justifiable fear. It is a danger against which the Minister, the Industrial Development Authority and Foras Tionscal will take every possible precaution.
The Minister has challenged Senator L'Estrange as to who introduced, and for what purpose, the 1956 Industrial Grants Act. He talked about the 1952 Act. We all know the 1952 Act was introduced at a time when the Parliamentary Secretary, if my recollection is right, was Secretary of Bord na gCeanntair gCúng.
Comment on this
That is my recollection: perhaps it is at fault. However, the Parliamentary Secretary held some such post.
Comment on this
The present Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
The Minister is trying to pin this Bill to the 1952 Undeveloped Areas Act. This Bill is an amendment and extension of the 1956 Act. The 1956 Act was designed to enable grants to be made for the establishment of industries outside the areas scheduled in the Undeveloped Areas Act, 1952.
Comment on this
There was provision in the 1952 Act for extending the areas of operation of Foras Tionscal by Ministerial Order. At the time the 1956 Act was introduced, the Taoiseach, then Deputy Lemass, opened the debate for the Opposition. He is reported as follows at column 1944 of Volume 160 of the Official Debates:
The first question that arises on this Bill is why it is considered necessary at all.
Then, at column 1946, he is reported as saying:
Why is it considered necessary at this stage that State aid to new industries should be given in the form of free grants. One would have thought that the Minister himself would have felt obliged to give some explanation of his own change of attitude in that regard.
The Taoiseach, in 1956, had no great regard for the Bill which was being introduced and of which this Bill is an amendment. He had no great regard for the policy of providing free grants for the establishment of industry outside the undeveloped areas. That is the only point I wish to make—that this Act helped to lay the foundations for the successful industrial development that we have witnessed over the past few years.
I want to point out that industries are not like mushrooms. They do not grow up overnight. One does not get in the short space of one or two years an increase in industrial output simply because there happens to be a change of Government. The increase in industrial output and export stems from the Industrial Grants Act, 1956, and an Act passed towards the end of that year, the Finance (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, which provided for tax concessions on all profits on goods exported from the country.
These are points which, unfortunately are not sufficiently well known to the public for one reason—that the Opposition Parties lack an Irish Press, an Evening Press and a Sunday Press.
Comment on this
I regret I was not here for the commencement of the debate on this Bill, which is designed to extend the financial provisions for the industrialisation of this country. However, when I did come in and when I listened to the speeches of Senators opposite, I came to the conclusion that they were opposed to the Bill. The conclusion which anybody with a detached mind would reach is that Senators on the opposite side are hostile to the objects this Bill is designed to promote. It would be as well at this or some stage that we should get a clear statement from the members opposite on whether they are for or against this Bill.
Comment on this
That is the impression Senator Ó Cíosáin tries to convey.