Industrial Grants (Amendment) Bill, 1961: Second and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 124–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 22 of 1961 ›
Senator Ó Cíosáin cannot understand what we said.
Comment on this
You cannot have it both ways. The objects of this Bill are twofold. It is a Bill to extend the Undeveloped Areas Acts and to extend the Industrial Grants Act. One would imagine from the speeches we have heard from those on the opposite benches that the enactment of the original Undeveloped Areas Act was due to the Coalition Government. It was, of course, the Fianna Fáil Government which enacted the Undeveloped Areas Act in 1952. There is no doubt about that and, if I remember rightly, there was no opposition to it in this House at the time, but it appears there is opposition now——
Comment on this
——judging from the speeches we have heard. Some Senators blow hot and cold on measures like this. We have also heard reference to foreign industrialists coming in here and it seems to me that there is opposition to that from the Opposition benches, that they do not want foreign industrialists to come in.
Comment on this
It is in violent conflict with a statement made by the Leader of the Fine Gael Party in the Dáil, a report of which I read. He said that his Party were out to encourage foreign industrialists to come in and set up industries. Where do we stand?
Comment on this
I was interested to hear Senator L'Estrange talking about the taxpayers' money and how careful we should be of it. One would think that we on this side of the House had no respect for the taxpayers' money. We certainly have and we can tell Senator L'Estrange and some of the people opposite that taxation at the present time is lower than it was when the Coalition Government left office.
Comment on this
We have to be for or against this policy of setting up industries here. It is as simple as that.
Comment on this
It will not be possible to have industries set up here without the expenditure of a certain amount of money. There is no doubt about that. I am in favour of this Bill and I think it is a step in the right direction. Those who talk about the flight from the land and who say we are not investing money in the land are not stating facts because there is more money being invested in the land today than there has been invested for a number of years.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that there is more money being spent on the development of agriculture——
Comment on this
I should like to give an example of that but I do not want to widen the scope of the debate. As I said before, when we hear speeches such as we heard today from the Opposition benches, we want to know whether these Senators are in favour of extending the industrial policy of the country or not.
Comment on this
I do not like to chase all of the hares started during this debate but unfortunately there are some I cannot ignore. However, I shall come first to the more constructive contributions that were made. First of all, I can take Senator McGuire's suggestion that we might begin to contemplate grouping industries in different parts of the country. It would be a good idea but we must realise that the siting of an industry must be, and always will be, a matter for those investing in it, for those carrying the equity. I have always maintained that neither Foras Tionscal nor I should influence any industrialist to site his undertaking in any part of the country. This is something that must remain peculiarly a matter for the industrialist himself. There are many technicalities that operate in relation to the siting of an industry and these must be left to the promoter himself.
In relation to the criticism that the Bill was not necessary—I never know how to address the Chair when the occupant has made a contribution on the floor of the House and then resumes the Chair——
Comment on this
The Minister may act with elasticity in the matter.
Comment on this
You said, Sir, that the Bill was not necessary and was only a piece of election propaganda. We have in the Industrial Development Authority and in Foras Tionscal two bodies which carry the confidence of the community and certainly carry the confidence of members of both Houses of the Oireachtas who have had any contact with them. Many months ago, they represented to me that the moneys available for grants were being committed and that they foresaw, before the end of this year, the possibility that all the money they were authorised by the Oireachtas to commit would have been committed. Therefore they asked me if I would introduce an amending Bill to ensure that no project presented to them would be refused grant assistance, or held up in any way for want of money.
It was on the basis of that request, and having examined the situation as I saw it, that I decided to introduce this Bill. I do not know whether the chairmen or members of these bodies have any interest in the election propaganda of Fianna Fáil. I doubt if they have, but I can assure the House that it is only on the basis of what was suggested to me that this Bill appears before the Seanad and not as a piece of Fianna Fáil propaganda. In any event, the performance of the Government over the past four and a half years has been such as to make it unnecessary to rush in pieces of election propaganda at this stage. There is no Bill before the House that is not essential.
Comment on this
Senator Murphy did pose the question, whether in the event of our being admitted a member of the European Economic Community, we should not think twice about this policy of giving grants to industry. I do not want to accuse him of defeatism but perhaps I misunderstood the Senator. He is shaking his head.
Comment on this
Giving grants to industry in underdeveloped areas which might not stand up and survive.
Comment on this
The implication was clearly that industries are now being set up with the aid of grants given by Foras Tionscal without studying the effect which European Economic Community conditions will have on them. I take it that that is what he meant. Again, I should like to assure the Senator that every industry to which a grant commitment is made is examined very closely by the Industrial Development Authority, in the first place, and, secondly, by Foras Tionscal, and unless it is seen to be a viable industry and unless it is established to Foras Tionscal that it has a reasonable prospect of surviving, a grant will not be given.
I should like to add that in most cases the bulk of the output of these new industries is designed for export, and already many of them are engaged in successful exporting operations in many parts of the world, which indicates that, even as of now, they are prepared to withstand world competition. I am not going to suggest that that is applicable to all cases, but by and large, I do not think the Senator need have any fears about a very careful appraisal being made of the soundness of an industry before any grant is given to it.
The suggestion was made that the Bill was introduced before our decision to make application to become a member of E.E.C. and that therefore we might have second thoughts even about going ahead with the Bill. I can only repeat that our possible accession to E.E.C. was envisaged many months ago and certainly before this Bill was introduced.
Senator Quinlan made the point that while £26 million represented the total capital investment in these industries, £8 million was a quite substantial amount to be paid by way of grants by the Exchequer. That is true. He also suggested that the workers in those factories might be induced by Foras Tionscal to make contributions to the capital of those industries. As the Senator knows, moneys provided for grants are taken out of the capital account, and that account includes such savings by the ordinary workers as the Post Office Savings Bank, small contributions to national loans, and the like, so that in that fashion the workers who are being given good employment are enabled to contribute to our savings and in that fashion, indirectly though it might be, to contribute to the capital structure of our industrial undertakings.
Senator Carter made some mild complaint about the delay in the printing of the report of Foras Tionscal. I think the House ought to be aware that that report was in the hands of the members in June, that is, the report for the year ended 31st March, 1961, and I think it could almost be fairly claimed that it was probably the first report of a State-sponsored body that was in the hands of members of the Oireachtas.
He also complained that the wording of the Act or of the literature of Foras Tionscal might be vague enough to be considered by foreigners as indicating that full 100 per cent. grants would be given for factory buildings and 50 per cent. grants for machinery in the undeveloped areas. I have here a copy of the "handout" of Foras Tionscal in this connection. It clearly says "grants not exceeding the full cost of factory and grants not exceeding half the cost of machinery and equipment." It may be that the Act might not be as specific as that, but as far as foreigners coming into this country are concerned, they will be told at a very early stage that the grants of 100 per cent. for factory and 50 per cent. for machinery are maximum grants and are not available in all cases—in fact, are available only in very few, because it is only reasonable to assume that Foras Tionscal will look to the promoter of the industry for his own contribution to show his confidence in his undertaking.
As Senator Quinlan pointed out, £26 million total investment against £8 million grants committed, is a fair indication that quite a substantial contribution is required from these promoters before a grant of the taxpayers' money is forthcoming. I think that, too, will answer the suggestion of Senator L'Estrange that as soon as Common Market conditions come into operation for us, these people are going to abandon their factories. They are hardly likely to abandon contributions of that order of the balance of £26 million when £8 million grant money is taken from it. Of course, these people are interested in their investment and in the return this investment will give to them. They come here, not, as Senator L'Estrange suggested, to get a back door entrance into the British market. In that respect, I stand over my interjection that statements like that are nothing but sabotage. They come here because in these places they have an intelligent and adaptable labour force, a labour force capable of producing goods of a quality equal, if not superior, to the quality of goods produced in any other countries.
As far as the suggestion is concerned that some of them are using locations in Ireland to enable goods to get into the British market by the back door, I should like to remind the House that the conditions under which Irish goods are given preferential treatment on the British market come under the trade agreements made between this country and Great Britain, and the relationships between the two countries in this respect to ensure that the terms of these agreements are properly carried out and adhered to are very close and cordial. On any occasion when there is the slightest doubt—I do not think there has been any suggestion that these trade agreements are being availed of in that way —there is the closest degree of cooperation possible between the authorities on both sides to ensure that there is no such evasion. That is why I suggest that to make wild, unsustainable and unsustained charges in this House that foreign industrialists have come here and have done so to defeat the terms of these agreements is sabotage. These charges should not be made unless they can be supported.
Senator O'Quigley suggested, and supported Senator L'Estrange in this respect, that this is only an extension of the 1956 Industrial Grants Act. He is right, but only very partially right. To ignore the 1952 Act is completely wrong. The Undeveloped Areas Act, 1952, was passed for the purpose of inducing the establishment of industries in the undeveloped areas which corresponded mainly with what were known as the congested districts. The phrase congested districts was a handy statutory definition imported into the Undeveloped Areas Act, 1952. Under that Act power was vested in the Minister of Industry and Commerce to schedule contiguous areas and say that grants should be given to industries located in those contiguous areas. In 1956, the Coalition Government brought in a Bill bringing the grants available to new industrial undertakings outside the undeveloped areas up to a maximum of £50 million.
In 1959, the Undeveloped Areas Act, and the Industrial Grants Act, 1956, were taken together for amendment purposes primarily for the purpose of the increasing of the ceiling of grants applicable to both areas. In the 1956 Act, the ceiling was brought to £10 million. Therefore, this Bill is not only an extension of the 1956 Act but also of the 1952 Act and the 1959 Act. Its primary purpose, as I have said, is to raise the ceiling from the £10 million fixed in 1959, to £15 million. That appears to be necessary even at present, or will be necessary in the course of some months.
I should like to assure the Senator that grants are not handed out lavishly. The closest possible examination is made of each and every proposition. Grants are not given out willy-nilly, but are given as the undertaking develops, as the factory is built and the machinery installed. The closest possible scrutiny is made of the expenditure of the grants. Not only that, but there is in the agreement the condition that the promoters are not entitled to part with the factory premises, or their shares, unless within a specified time. That has always been part of the agreements made between Foras Tionscal and the people who sought and got grants.
In this Bill, we are removing a doubt which arose that those conditions were enforceable and we are including a provision to make them statutorily enforceable. There can be no suggestion whatever that grants are given lavishly without any regard for their effect or without any regard for the taxpayer who is providing the moneys.
Those, I think, are some of the main points which were raised. I want to say that while negotiations will soon be in hand for our accession to the Common Market, we must, in no circumstances, in the meantime sit down to see what is going to happen. Unless we have confidence in ourselves and in the future, we will get nowhere.
Comment on this
We will have to proceed on the basis that we have a viable economy and that our people are able and prepared to work as hard and as efficiently as people in other parts of Europe. I am not suggesting that we will not have our difficulties. We certainly will, but so far as the Government are concerned, they have taken full account of those difficulties.
The suggestion was made during the course of the debate that we are ill-prepared for our advent into the Common Market. It is well known that all of our industries have been alerted and that the Committee of Industrial Organisation has been set up to examine closely—with the help of economists and with technical help —what the effects of our accession to the Common Market are likely to be. Therefore, when the time comes, we shall be properly prepared.
There should be no illusions about our accession to the Common Market from the point of view of time. In the case of Britain, it will take several months and possibly years before she ultimately becomes a member. It is inevitable, in any event, that there will be long and protracted negotiations in the case of each country's application for admission. We propose to use those months to ensure that industry will be prepared to the fullest possible extent for any changes that will be brought about by our accession to the Common Market. We shall be well able, in most cases, to face up to the obligations of the Rome Treaty in so far as industry is concerned.
Comment on this
In view of the general approval of this Bill, we might get the remaining Stages today.
Comment on this
We are anxious to co-operate.
Agreed to take remaining Stages to-day.
Bill considered in Committee.
Comment on this
Apropos a remark by Senator Quinlan, I should not like it to be thought that I had stated or suggested in my speech on Second Reading that the small units of industry will not survive in the future. In fact, I have no doubt that the small Irish industries can survive, and will survive, provided they produce a commodity, with perhaps an Irish character, that is well and efficiently made.
Comment on this
I want to make a few observations on this, the most important section of the Bill. The Minister has taken us through the various developments of the Undeveloped Areas Act, 1952, and the amending Acts of 1956 and 1959. The Minister did not say anything with which I would substantially disagree. In fact, I do not think he said anything that was not in accord with what I stated myself.
I want to make the point that the 1956 Act was responsible for the extension of the free grants for industry to areas outside the undeveloped areas. When the 1956 Act was introduced it was the expressed view of the Taoiseach that that should have been done by way of order rather than by way of special enactment. This section very properly provides an increase of £5 million in the amount which may be paid by way of grants. That is something which in 1956 was completely anathema to the Taoiseach. He is on record as saying he did not agree with free loans at all. That is a remarkable thing to hear from the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I will quote it in extenso. Then there can be no two ways about it and no doubt that this was the attitude of Deputy Lemass in 1956. At column 1947, Volume 160 of the Dáil Debates, he said:
I have urged already here that, in present circumstances, having regard to the policy being pursued by the commercial banks, the general tightness of money now existing, it is desirable that the resources and, perhaps, the powers of the Industrial Credit Company should be extended, that that undertaking should be enabled to provide money for industrial expansion through investment in the shares of private undertakings, shares which it might not be desirable to market at the present time, or to deal with smaller concerns by way of repayable loans or the purchase of debentures.
It is harmless so far. He went on:
I think that is necessary but I think that is all that is necessary and, indeed, I am quite certain that, if that were done, it could be said that no industrial concern with any prospect of development, any prospect of making a profit, would not be able to proceed because of shortage of money.
That is the background. Of course I cannot speak with the same conviction while reading, as did the Taoiseach when making that statement. He went on:
What is the danger we are facing because of this proposal? The Minister is taking power for the Industrial Development Authority to give grants to any new industrial enterprise anywhere. The danger is that no industrial enterprise will ever start again without getting this free grant from public funds.
Comment on this
He went on:
We have a provision in this Bill which obliges the Industrial Development Authority to take certain things into account and a section which also gives them power to impose conditions. These are provisions which I think are likely to be far more effective——
The House should take note of this.
——in retarding industrial development than helping it.
Comment on this
He goes on:
I believe that over the main part of the industrial field private enterprise is the best force on which to rely.
In another paragraph, he deals with private enterprise and I want to come to that, but afterwards he says:
If it could be shown that any single industrial proposition that would not otherwise proceed was likely to go ahead quickly because of the provisions of this Bill I would say that is an argument in its favour. We have not been told that. Indeed no reason has been advanced for the Bill at all. There is an implied assumption that industrial development has been held up by the absence of free grants. That is not true. Industrial development has been held up to some extent by inability to get capital.
Comment on this
There was a credit squeeze; the Senator forgets that we were in the middle of a credit squeeze.
Comment on this
It was "Tighten your belts. There is no money. Jam yesterday, jam tomorrow but never jam today."
Comment on this
The Senator must be allowed to finish his quotation of Deputy Lemass anyway. He must not be interrupted.
Comment on this
The Minister said he would like to reassert what had been said. I will continue my quotation:
Meet that by making it possible to get capital. You do not have to meet it by going into the pockets of the taxpayer to hand out grants of this kind when by doing so you are creating a situation in which concerns that might otherwise develop will not develop unless that grant is given to them and where the policy of western development is negative at the same time.
I must confess that I have a very considerable dislike of most of these proposals for money for nothing——
Comment on this
——and in the past whenever I had as Minister to bring propositions here involving Government grants of any kind, I felt obliged to defend the proposal in full——
The Bill had to be defended. You had to defend giving grants to an industrial enterprise——
——and the absence of any attempt to defend this Bill by the Minister in introducing it, the unwarranted assumption upon which he based his remarks, indicate to me that no very great thought has been given to this proposition at all.
Now I conclude the Second Reading speech:
The Minister can have this Bill as far as I am concerned but I want to make it clear that in my view—and I may at some time in the future be empowered to influence Government policy—I think it has no importance whatever in relation to our national development and it represents a completely wrong approach to the problems of Irish industry as they exist today.
Comment on this
Is there anybody on that side of the House or the Minister who can say that the Taoiseach was not altogether opposed to the extension of these grants outside the undeveloped areas? If they do, they do not understand him or else I have read his speech very badly.
Comment on this
It was that Act which a previous Minister for Industry and Commerce introduced for industrial development which led to the increase in our industrial exports about which we hear so much—and very properly—at the present time.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley missed the point of my review of the Undeveloped Areas Act and the Industrial Grants Act and their integration for certain purposes. I wanted to make the point during my reply on the Second Reading that the increasing of the ceiling from £10 million to £15 million for the purpose of covering grants was applicable both to the Undeveloped Areas Act, as it originally was, and to the Industrial Development Act and this integration, this Bill, is consequent more on the 1952 Act then on the 1956 Act.
Comment on this
I listened to that speech by the Taoiseach. I know its import and it is this: capital was then the biggest difficulty in the establishment of industries in this country and he advocated at that time that if instead of giving grants limited to £50,000 under the Industrial Grants Act of 1956, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton, could contrive some system of making capital more freely available, it would serve more the industrialisation of the country than that Act with its limited provisions. Limited provisions they were because grants were not given— still are not given—outside the undeveloped areas, if it can be shown that the industries could be established within the undeveloped areas. The thinking behind that speech was quite clear: that the starting of an industry should not fail for want of capital, whether that capital was a grant or ordinary investment carrying interest rates for the lenders or investors, as the case may be.
Comment on this
It ill becomes anybody on that side of the House to criticise the Taoiseach for his approach to industrial problems because he is, and is widely accepted as being, the chief architect of industrial expansion in this country.
Comment on this
I want to make one thing certain: the Minister for Industry and Commerce has tried now to retrieve a situation irretrievable since the days of 1956——
Comment on this
——when Deputy Lemass came out flat-footed against the Industrial Grants Bill of 1956. There are no two ways about it:
I must confess that I have a very considerable dislike of most of these proposals for money for nothing.
That was on the previous Bill.
Comment on this
These are provisions which I think are likely to be far more effective in retarding industrial development than in helping it.
Then he put the coping stone on it when he promised that if he could ever influence a Government, he would in effect repeal this Act. That was on capital. Let there be no two ways about it.
Comment on this
The Senator has summarised the quotation in three sentences.
Comment on this
He summarised in three sentences a long quotation. It was too long perhaps, but nevertheless he did summarise it.
Comment on this
I have made my speech, given my quotation and will stand on the summary I have read.
Comment on this
This is the same approach to industry as the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party towards grasslands. At one time, they said that people were ranchers.
Comment on this
Is industry likely to go ahead if the boardroom spend as much time discussing what was said in 1956 or 1930 or what Daniel O'Connell said in 1830? It is regrettable that in this House so many hours have been spent discussing promises and broken promises.
Comment on this
It is as well that he should know who can be trusted for ideals.
Comment on this
In order to establish that you have accurate versions and political and economic Damascuses, we have to refer to these kinds of records.
Comment on this
Does Senator O'Quigley remember the back-lane factories which Fine Gael were so fond of sneering at? Does he remember the little girls who got employment in them?
Comment on this
It would be better if the Senator were allowed to speak.
Comment on this
Certainly, if he keeps to the point. If he asks for trouble and trails his coat, he is going to get it.
Comment on this
I am speaking to a point which is very sharp and is hurting the Senator very much.
Comment on this
I want to repeat, notwithstanding the feelings of Senator Stanford for whom I have considerable regard, that in 1956 the Taoiseach was opposed to the idea of giving grants outside the undeveloped areas.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley has misinterpreted to a certain extent what the Taoiseach said as Deputy Lemass in 1956. The Deputy, of course, was well aware of the financial position of the country then. He knew that unless it was possible to provide capital, the provisions of the then Bill would be meaningless. We know very well that capital was not available because the only way to get capital is through national loans. An attempt was made to get capital in that way and we know it was not a great success. We could leave it at that.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a question about the review he has promised. When making such a considerable increase in the total capital of £10 million to £15 million, many of us would have wished that we had the results of this review before us. I accept the Minister's case as to why he has to do it now but I asked him a question in my Second Reading speech whether he would ensure that this review would be carried out in the most independent manner for us.
Comment on this
I happen to have been reading the Industrial Grants Acts. If you turn to the enactments repealed at the end of the Industrial Grants Act, 1959, you find that they include the Industrial Grants Act, 1956. If you look at the Industrial Grants Act, 1956, you find it is a facsimile of the Industrial Grants Act, 1959, except that, in 1959, the Fianna Fáil Government were expanding the scope and increasing the amount of money. There is no doubt that this policy is the policy of the previous Government—the policy of Deputy Sweetman. People may say that politicians spend hours arguing about this. What are they sent here for but to decide policy, but when one policy is adopted by one group, having been initiated by another, why should this group suddenly decide that they were the people who first did this? They were not. Their particular line of industry was one which to a certain measure succeeded. It was Sinn Féin industrial policy.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the Sinn Féin political idea. What I mean is the idea of going at it ourselves alone—behind tariff walls, we will produce the goods for our people here and the enticement to do so will be tariff walls. Two things were clearly expounded by Deputy Sweetman at the time. One was the granting of relief from income on new exports and the other, industrial grants, whereby grants would be made available for the propagation of industry. These two things are absolutely clear and it is quite stupid politically for anybody to say that we spend three hours discussing what happened in 1956. It is absolutely important as to which side everybody is on. If one political group is converted to the other, that is very important as far as policy is concerned. It is the sort of thing that will decide who will be the next Government. The idea is clear to anybody who sat in the Dáil at that time. It was the previous Government who initiated these things which have been expanded by the present Government. They were voted against by them at that time.
Comment on this
We do not come here to get a lecture from anybody, even though he is a professor. It is a good idea that we discuss all legislation that comes before us, even if we have to spend three or four hours in doing so. It is equally a good idea for any Government to continue the policy of a previous Government, if that policy has proved right and even if that particular Government were against the introduction of it.
It is only right to offer proof to the House, as I think it has been offered by Senator O'Quigley, when he quoted the extracts from the speech by Deputy Lemass, as he then was, in 1956. I think nobody can go behind the remarks he made at that time because he was definitely against this Bill. He was definitely against giving grants outside the undeveloped areas. Perhaps the House would like me to read the remarks.
Comment on this
There are certain points that should definitely be read. Let me quote:
You do not have to meet it by going into the pockets of the taxpayers to hand out grants of this kind...
He further stated:
I must confess that I have a very considerable dislike of most of these proposals for money for nothing...
If I said that, it would be national sabotage but it is all right for Deputy Lemass to say that.
He further stated:
The implication is that this Finance Bill gives some enormous financial aid to industry. I have calculated that the maximum amount of money that it could possibly cost the Government, even if we assume that we will get a 10 per cent. increase in industrial exports and a 10 per cent. increase in coal production, is less than £10,000.
He was very far out in his estimate at that time. We are all delighted that he was so far out in his estimate and that he was so wrong. He also stated:
These are provisions which I think are likely to be far more effective in retarding industrial development than in helping it.
If I said that today, it would be regarded as national sabotage. I would be told that I was trying to sabotage industry in the country but it is all right for Deputy Lemass to say it. It is only right that we should let the people know where Deputy Lemass stood and where Fianna Fáil stood as regards industrial grants in 1956.
Then he continued:—
I believe that over the main part of the industrial field private enterprise is the best course on which to rely.
He wanted private enterprise then; he did not want any grants, good, bad or indifferent.
in conclusion, and to put the coping stone on it—
Comment on this
I want to put on record where the Taoiseach stood in 1956 as regards the grants that have brought industries to this country and that have been responsible for the huge exports of industrial production over the past few years. It is only right that we should know where the Taoiseach stood at that time. He finished off by saying:
I think it has no importance——
—he was speaking of the Bill——
—whatever in relation to our industrial development and it represents a completely wrong approach to the problems of Irish industry as they exist to-day.
That was Deputy Lemass. How wrong he was in 1956! We are all glad to see he was wrong, but, at the same time, I want to say we are delighted that the Minister realises this is a good Bill and that it has done good work for Irish industry and for the economy of the country.
Comment on this
Sílim gur Alt a 3 de'n Bhille seo atá fé díospóireacht againn anois. Sílim nach í an tárna Céim de'n Bhille a ba chóir a bheith ar siúil anois, fe mar atá. Ba mhaith liom go gcuirfí deire leis an díospoíreacht seo i dtreo is gur feídir linn dul ar ais ar cheist an cóir £10,000,000 nó £15,000,000 a cheadú. Sin í an cheist.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange accused me of giving a lecture. He has spoken for approximately 20 minutes in the most dogmatic tone of voice I have heard in the past few years. I spoke for one minute and I propose to speak for just another minute. This is an exhibition of the futility of Party politics at its worst. We have before us a sensible Bill, doing a good job, as everyone has admitted. We have spent the best part of 2½ hours arguing about who deserves credit for this policy. Whether or not it is a good Bill, it has nothing to do with past ordering of industry in this country. It simply has to do with a few votes at the next election —and it will get no votes. Senator L'Estrange is only deceiving himself. The people of Ireland are intelligent enough to think for the present and the future.
Comment on this
It will not make the slightest difference.
Comment on this
I admire Party politics very often but this is one of the afternoons when it has shown itself at its very worst.
Comment on this
Suppose we leave Fine Gael happy in the delusion that they have been responsible for our industrial advancement, for having more people in industry now in the country than ever before, for having our industrial exports at a record level for the past two years. Suppose we just leave it at that and leave it to the people to decide in a couple of months' time, and pass on——
Comment on this
I want to come to the point specifically raised by Senator Quinlan that, in order to make it as objective as possible, the review should be done by some outside agency. I think that is what he meant. The review will have to be done in a very close way—to the point, perhaps, that the details of some firms will have to be examined. It would be impossible to expect individual firms to disclose details of their business to outsiders in any way. Foras Tionscal are intimate, in so far as they can be, with the details of some industries. I want to assure the Senator that this will be an objective review. While I cannot accept, for the reason I have stated, that one can give outside people access to details of the business of firms, the Senator need be under no illusion that the review will not be as objective as possible and any defects in the scheme, as now administered, will be repaired.
Comment on this
It seems to me that in the Minister's concluding statement he was referring more to the work envisaged by the C.I.O.——
Comment on this
——than to forms existing at the moment and to see how they would stand in the context of the European Economic Community. I think what Senator Quinlan was referring to was the statement in the Minister's Second Reading speech which I gather was the review of the policy— whether it was correct policy to differentiate between areas in regard to grants for industrial establishments.
Comment on this
I do not think that, involved in that, would be the finances of existing industries of firms and seeing how they are doing at the moment but rather the principle as to whether it is good policy to continue what we have been doing in that direction.
Comment on this
The Minister, in his Second Reading speech, which is substantially the same as that made by him in the Dáil, said:
I do feel, however, that the time has come to undertake a comprehensive review of the present scheme. The objects of such review would be to assess the extent to which the existing system has been successful and to see whether any modifications of the system are desirable. In particular, I feel we will have to give careful consideration to the question of whether the present concept of the undeveloped areas has outlived its usefulness.
I feel it would be wrong that this review should be totally entrusted to the body which, over the years, has been charged with carrying out this policy.
Comment on this
I paid the highest tribute possible to this body. I feel that the time has come for some body other than this to have a look at it. If there are reasons such as the Minister has advanced, why could we not have a completely independent review? I appeal to him at least to see to it that independent, outside experts will be included in whatever team will carry out this review— whether that team be a joint team from his Department, Foras Tionscal, or a more widely placed team—so as to try to ensure that it will be as objective and scientific as possible.