Central Fund Bill, 1962 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 1–111 of 221. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1962 ›
Before the debate was adjourned last evening, I had dealt in a general way with the fall in population, with emigration, and with the flight from the land in the light of the demand made in the Book of Estimates. I had also dealt particularly with a very serious aspect of our economy, that is, the flight from the land and the dissatisfaction of the farmers as a result. I should like to make one point on that before moving on, that is, that many people seem to take the view that the farmers are protesting solely against the increase in rates. That is not entirely accurate. They are protesting particularly on the ground that they are not getting their fair share of the national income compared with other sections of the community.
I shall not detain the House very much longer, but throughout the discussion on the Vote on Account in the Dáil and on the Central Fund Bill here, reference has been made to the general policy of the Government on health, and I should like to deal with that policy in so far as its affects the bill we are asked to approve here. The health services are now entirely regulated by the Health Act of 1952, and there can be very little doubt that that Act is a most unsatisfactory piece of legislation. It has not given satisfaction to anybody, to the lower income group, the middle income group, or what are described as the higher income groups.
I do not think the Government have any policy on health. That is one aspect on which they can be seriously criticised. The last general election was fought here not so very long ago and the health services formed one of the principal bones of contention. It was a very short election campaign, fast and furious, with not much time for the Opposition Parties to put their views before the people. The Minister and the Government fought the election and defended the health services as regulated by the Health Act, and the Fine Gael Party put an alternative health scheme to the people. I can be fairly accurate in saying that the result of the election was that the Government got a serious rebuff. They lost 80,000 votes and seven seats. The Fine Gael Party gained 50,000 votes and seven seats.
A very short time after the Dáil reassembled, the Fine Gael Party put down a motion for debate condemning in so many words the Government's policy on health and inviting the Government to bring in a comprehensive health scheme. One would have expected the Minister for Health either to come into the Dáil and do what he did in the country, defend the Bill, say it was a good Bill, that he approved of it and that he would continue to operate it, or accept the Fine Gael proposition and say that the election had proved that the people did not want the Health Act because it was unsatisfactory.
The Minister for Health did neither of those things. It was the clear duty of the Minister and the Government to put a policy on health before the Dáil and the country but that was not done. The Minister simply said in so many words: "I have no policy on health. I admit that the Health Act is unsatisfactory, but I have no alternative and I invite all Parties in the Dáil to give me a health policy."
I say he neglected his duty in that respect and that the Government must be condemned for continuing to impose on the country an Act that it does not want and which, at any rate by implication, the Minister admits is unsatisfactory. I may be pardoned for going into detail because I am replying to figures given by the Minister in the Dáil on the cost of the Health Act. It has been said that it is too expensive and that it is costing much more than was promised when it was introduced.
The Minister gave certain figures in the Dáil for Wexford, and I propose to give the figures for Cavan dealing with the increases which I say the Health Act and the policy of the Government on health have brought about. In 1953/54 the rate in the £ for health services in Cavan was 9/4. In 1962/63, the current year, the rate in respect of health in Cavan is 16/11. That is an increase of 7/7. I want at once to say that there is no sum for public assistance in these figures. Admittedly, in that increase of 7/7 there is a sum of 1/8 in respect of mental health. That means the increase in the demand for health services in Cavan between 1653/54 and 1962/63 was 5/11 or, in round figures, 6/- and that does not include public assistance or public health.
The Minister said that the sum of 2/6 in Wexford was included in the figures which he gave in respect of Wexford to cover the increases in salaries, wages, and that sort of thing. Cavan is a smaller county than Wexford and probably the population is not as big and, therefore, we may take it that the sum in Cavan would be less than 2/6. I do not say that 2/6 is relevant. I say there is an increase amounting to 6/- on the health services in Cavan, as a direct result of ministerial action. The major portion of that 6/- is due to the unsatisfactory Health Act, and all of the 6/- is due to ministerial action, either the action of the Minister for Finance when he was Minister for Health and introduced the Health Bill of 1952, or the action of the Minister for Finance when, as Minister for Finance, he removed the food subsidies in 1957 and started off a round of wage increases which ultimately ended in the last wage increase.
Those are the figures in detail. I have not the figures for Monaghan as accurately, but I am sure there are some people in the House who have. According to my information the increase in Monaghan is 7/-. I have not got the figures for Monaghan broken down as accurately as the figures for Cavan, which are deadly accurate. I say the Government have failed in their duty to the people and to the country in regard to the health services.
There has been talk about inflation. During the earlier stages of the discussion it seemed to be doubtful whether or not there was inflation, but after the speeches of the Taoiseach and the Minister in the Dáil, and after the very learned and powerful speech we heard from Senator O'Brien here, there cannot be any doubt but that we are in the midst of inflation, brought about not by any outside sources, but by positive action on the part of the Government.
Of all the points with which I have dealt, in my humble opinion — and I say this with great deliberation and after giving it a lot of thought — the most serious aspect is the flight from the land of the small farmers, the middle-sized farmers and, in Monaghan, Cavan and Donegal, the fair-sized farmers. I understand the Minister told me last night — I think it was not very orderly at the time— that he had not any policy to deal with this drift of population from the land. If I am wrong in that he will correct me, but if the Government have no policy on that dreadfully serious aspect of our economy it is high time they got down to it and made some honest effort to do something about it.
Comment on this
Ar an mBille Lár-Chiste seo, tá caoi againn ar imeachtaí na tíre do mheas féachaint an ag dul chun cinn atáimid nó a mhalairt. Dar ndó, nuair chuirimid chun an gnó san a dhéanamh, is ceart dúinn é dhéanamh chomh beacht cruinn agus is féidir linn agus gan ligint dár ndearcadh poilitíochta ná dár gclaonadh aigne chur isteach orainn. Admhuím áfach, nach fuiriste é sin a dhéanamh nuair a thuiteann sé amach go mbíonn an duine i bhfus ag iarraidh an lámh uachtair d'fháil ar an bhfear thall agus vice versa. Mar sin féin, tá dualgas fé leith orainne, comhaltaí an tSeanaid a tuigtear atá saor, nó leathshaor, go h-áirithe, ó chungas na poilitíochta aghaidh a thabhairt ar an gnó so go ciallmhar agus breith a thabhairt ar obair an Rialtais maidir le rialú na tíre i gcúrsaí cultúir agus oideachais, i gcúrsaí eacanamaíochta agus sóisialacha agus mar sin de. Mar aon leo san uile agus bhféidir níos tábhachtaí ná iad san uile, tá ceist na síochána sa tír agus is mór againn an cheist í. Is cúis sásaimh dúinn go bhfuil síocháin sa tír againn agus gura fada mar sin é, pé Rialtas dár gcine a bheidh i mbun cúrsaí, mar is maith atá a fhios againn ná bíonn rí ná rath ar aon tír ná bíonn síocháin bunaithe inti de réir toil na ndaoine.
Maidir leis an méid caiteachais atá beartaithe ag an Rialtas i gcóir na bliana airgeadais seo atá fé mheas againn, tá níos mó ná stracfhéachaint tugtha againn ar na breiseanna atá leagtha amach agus dá gcuirtí ar mo choinsias mé ní fhéadfainn méar a leagadh ar aon ceann acu a déarfainn ba cheart laghdú a dhéanamh air— talamhaíocht, na seirbhísí sóisialacha, oideachas, rialtas áitiúil, cuartaíocht. Siad san gan amhras na seirbhísí is tábhachtaí agus na seirbhísí go mbímíd go léir ag iarraidh cur leo, nó ba cheart dom a rá, ag áiteamh ar an Rialtas cur leo ar mhaithe leis an náisiún. Chím, leis, go bhfuil breis bheag airgid le cur ar fáil don Ghaeltacht le haghaidh scoláireachtaí don Ghaeltacht, tithe sa Ghaeltacht agus mar sin de agus dar ndó, is caiteachas é sin go bhfuil a lán againn toilteanach seasamh leis agus é mholadh ar son na teangan agus lucht labharta na teangan sa Ghaeltacht.
I have listened to the speeches from the opposite benches on this Central Fund Bill and, while some of them could be regarded as constructive, I fear that the same cannot be said about others of them. It is extraordinary, when we have a task like this to perform, namely, to examine the amount of expenditure proposed for the coming financial year, that we cannot do so without letting political affiliations run away with us.
Comment on this
I have listened to Senator Fitzpatrick last night and again today. One would imagine from the way he spoke that the country was in a very bad state. He mentioned such things as emigration, the flight from the land, and so on. He painted a very dismal picture about Cavan. He tried to impress upon us that there was emigration from that county and a flight from the land to a degree never known before. If there is such a flow of emigration and such a flight from the land as he says, one would be justified in coming to the conclusion that economic conditions there are not good but it is a strange thing that in the last general election — and it is not too long since the last general election — Cavan was one of the counties that gave Fianna Fáil two seats out of three.
Comment on this
It would appear from that that the ordinary people of Cavan are quite satisfied with the policy of the Government because otherwise they would not have given them two seats out of three.
Comment on this
It was no mean achievement under proportional representation to get two seats out of three. We can take the Senator's description of the frightful conditions in Cavan with a grain of salt. He told us last night about the way in which small farmers as well as other people were closing their doors, abandoning their homes and flying to England. He said that to his knowledge three families had closed their doors, abandoned their homes and gone to England but he did not tell us when that took place. That could have taken place a few years ago because I remember we had a debate in this House on the question of emigration when the Coalition Government were in office and I pointed out to them then that there were families in a certain part of the country with which I am acquainted leaving their homes and going to England at that time and the then Minister for Industry and Commerce had no remedy.
Now, these people stand up and try to impress upon us that it is only now that there is a tide of emigration from this country. The incidence of emigration at present is not as great as it was. I do not want to go into this in any detail because it has been ably dealt with by the Minister and by the Taoiseach in the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, in the Dáil, quite recently, gave statistics to show that emigration at present is not as great as it has been. The situation is improving as regards emigration and we have now reached a position in which the natural growth in the population equates the amount of emigration taking place.
Comment on this
As the Senator is so anxious to get the figures, I shall give them. There are no absolutely reliable statistics for emigration because, as has been pointed out, people go into the Six Counties and come back again; there is a passage of people through the Six Counties and that cannot be accounted for. But, on the basis of the movement of people to and from England by sea and by air, the figure of emigration for 1955/56 was 44,000 and for 1961, 27,000 — 17,000 fewer.
Comment on this
These are the figures I have for emigration. These are the statistics given in the Dáil quite recently, last week or whatever time it was.
Senator Fitzpatrick also referred to the monstrous expenditure for which this Government are responsible. "Monstrous expenditure". That, of course, was a sweeping statement. Other people also, people in Dáil Éireann, colleagues of the Senator's, members of the same Party, launched an attack on the Government on account of this expenditure, but did any single one of them point a finger to any item of expenditure that could be done away with or reduced? Not at all.
Comment on this
I did not criticise the expenditure. I criticised the return received for the money spent.
Comment on this
I admit that it is very important entirely to ascertain to what purposes the money is being put. It is at least as important if not more important to find out how the money is to be utilised than the size of the bill. There is no doubt about that but here again we have the items. The Minister for Finance was good enough to circulate a table which gives the items of expenditure that are to be increased and the items that are to be decreased and among those items to be increased is agriculture. There is an increase of £3.5 million there.
Comment on this
An increase of £3.5 million for agriculture. Is there any Senator here who will have the hardihood to stand up and tell us that is too much for the farmers of the country? On the contrary.
Comment on this
Have we not been told by economists that we are not spending enough on agriculture, enough to improve the quality of the land, enough to make fertilisers, lime and so on cheap for the farmers to purchase so as to improve the fertility of their land? Is it not for that purpose as well as for the purpose of bringing technical instruction within reach of the farmers that this increase is included in the Estimates for the coming financial year? We have heard from other speakers opposite and from members of the Fine Gael Party in the Dáil about the plight of the farmers and, of course, they are showing great sympathy with the farmers now. We were told by Senator Fitzpatrick here last night that the present leader of the Fine Gael Party was a wonderful Minister for Agriculture. He must think, of course, that we have very short recollections because one of the first things he did when he took office was to slash the price of wheat without rhyme or reason and without consulting any section of the farmers. That amounted to 12/6d.
Comment on this
That was the first action of the Minister for Agriculture and his second—there were others but I am talking about the major operations for which he was responsible——
Comment on this
How did he stand by the dairy farmers? He made a serious attempt to cut the price of milk delivered to the creameries. He told them they should be prepared to accept a shilling a gallon for their milk and that for five years. When he made these decisions, did he make any attempt to consult the farmers? He did not want any consultation with the farmers because we remember one time when the farmers tried to send a deputation to him he would not receive them, sent them about their business and said they were racketeers and Fianna Fáil racketeers at that.
Comment on this
The Minister who directed the affairs of the Department of Agriculture for three years during the Coalition period——
Comment on this
I am not going into all the details of these increases, but there is also an increase of £3 million for education and that in my view is right and proper. We in this country regard education as very important. We also regard the building of new schools and the renovation of old schools when new ones cannot be built as very important and the money has to be found for all that. I am very glad to say — and all of us are very glad to be able to say — that the rate of building schools at the present time is much in excess of what it has been for years.
Comment on this
The building programme being carried out at the present time by the Fianna Fáil Government is far ahead of anything that has taken place so far.
There is an increase of £1.4 million for social services. Nobody will find fault with that. I have not heard any Senator finding fault with it nor did any Opposition speaker in the Dáil. There is an increase of £1.2 million for Post and Telegraphs, an increase of £1.6 million for the Army and the Garda Síochána; an increase of £1 million for industrial promotion, that is money to be given to the Industrial Development Authority for the inauguration of industrial projects; there is an increase for tourism of £.3 million. That will be money well spent because we all believe that tourism should be encouraged more and more. When we spend money on tourism we are backing a sure winner. There is no doubt about that, especially when we know that last year we got a return from tourism of something in the region of £42 million and the tourist industry, in my opinion, is capable of better and further expansion.
All these increases I have mentioned — I could mention more but these are the major increases — amount to about £12 million or most of the increase in the Bill we have before us today. On top of that, of course, there is the increased remuneration for all the State servants. Nobody here has blamed the Government for accepting the awards that came as a result of conciliation and arbitration to these public servants: teachers, Gardaí, the Army, Civil Servants and so on. All of these are as much entitled to increases as the people engaged in commercial pursuits. Therefore, if there is to be criticism of the Government for the amount of expenditure, we should expect those who criticise us to show exactly why this item of expenditure should not be there, why that item should not be there, and so on.
Having listened to Senator McGuire last evening, I must say he made what I consider to be a very constructive speech. There is one point on which I should be inclined to disagree. He said that it was the duty of the Government to keep control over expenditure and to resist the claims of people outside. Of course, there is no doubt about that; it goes without saying that it is the duty of the Government; but if there are people in the Opposition who criticise the expenditure, it is also their duty to show how expenditure should be cut down.
Comment on this
You will have the Opposition joining the Government yet.
Comment on this
If there are members of the Opposition who are critical of the Government because of the amount of expenditure they find necessary to keep the services of the State going, then a duty devolves on those who criticise to show exactly where economies could be effected.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied the Government are doing a good job. They put the Programme for Economic Expansion before the people and at that time, they said they expected there would be an increase of two per cent. in national production. It is very gratifying to know that their expectations were not alone fulfilled but very much exceeded. As was pointed out to us, there has been an increase of five per cent. If the Government keep on that course, then in a couple of years, there will be an even brighter picture to show to the people.
The policy of the Government has been praised by people engaged in the commercial life of the country, people who had no political axe to grind. Their statements appeared in the newspapers for everybody to read. I do not intend to read them now. They have said the policy of the Government is proving itself and that the Government's ambition to have productivity increased is being realised. They said that and they are perfectly right.
The standard of living here is as high as in most parts of Europe. We hope that the people will continue to enjoy that standard but we know that to keep up that standard, productivity will also have to be kept up and probably increased still further. If there are certain politicians who find fault with the position as it is, it is up to them to show us exactly how the position can be improved. It is extraordinary how the ideas and outlook of politicians change when they go from one side of the House to the other.
Comment on this
When Fine Gael were the dominant Party in the Coalition Government, they had nothing for anyone. They had nothing for the farmers and very little for the recipients of social welfare, but now that they are out of office, they are prepared to scatter largesse between all sections of the community. In other words, Fine Gael in office are a totally different proposition from Fine Gael out of office. We know that from experience.
Comment on this
They talk about the plight of farmers now and they refer to the farmers' organisation and to the farmers' demands on the Government, which of course the farmers are perfectly entitled to make and one would imagine from what Fine Gael speakers say that they are the champions of the farmers and were always the champions of the farmers. Everybody knows they were nothing of the sort. The farmers themselves know it. They are intelligent enough to know who are their friends and who are their enemies.
Comment on this
It would appear so from the last election and it will appear much more clearly after the next election.
Comment on this
There is no question about the next election. That will be a swan song.
Comment on this
Mar fhocal scoir, is dóigh liom go bhfuil muintir na tíre lán-tsásta le cuspóir an Rialtais. Tá cúrsaí na tíre ag dul ar aghaidh go maith agus má leantar mar sin, beidh toradh obair an Rialtais le feiscint i gceann cúpla bliain eile. Molaim-se an obair atá ar siúl acu agus tá sé le moladh ag muintir na tíre ar fad.
Comment on this
I wonder, Sir, before we continue, would you inform Senator L'Estrange, who seems to have been demoted, and Senator Fitzpatrick that we can conduct the debate in a calm, civilised manner, as we have been doing up to this, but that if this sniping continues, two can play at it.
Comment on this
In reply to Senator Ó Maoláin, might I say that last night, in his absence, I made what was virtually a maiden speech in the midst of a barrage of interruptions from the Minister and everybody else on that side of the House.
Comment on this
Tá sé deachair domh-sa labhairt faoin mBille seo, ós rud é go raibh baint agam le cúrsaí eadrána agus idir-réitigh maidir le tuarastal na múinteoirí náisiúnta.
Is mór an bhreis atá a chur leis an Meastachán le haghaidh oideachais, ach sé mo thuairim go mbeidh gá le níos mó a chaitheamh ar oideachas ins na blianta atá le teacht.
Bíodh is go bhfuair na múinteoirí breis ní dóigh liom go bhfuil siad sásta fós.
I find it rather difficult to speak on this Bill for the reason that I was individually responsible to a certain extent for adding a considerable sum to it in my capacity as a member of the arbitration council for teachers' salaries. The second largest item in the Estimates is an increase of £3,000,000 for education. I intend to approach this question in a very objective way because, like Senator Stanford, I represent a vocational group and I want to try to steer my way as carefully as possible between inter-Party interests.
The Seanad should be a body which should look objectively at the various aspects of national economy and treat our problems objectively because they are problems which affect the entire community. They are matters which affect the whole nation, especially at this very vital juncture in our existence. We should try to get away from the type of debate of which we had some experience and get together as people elected by the people to see what we can do for the betterment of the nation and the people who sent us here.
It is true that this is a record bill but I shall forecast that next year we will have another record bill and the one after that will be another record bill because that is the history of the depreciation in the value of money. If you throw your minds back to the story of the Good Samaritan finding the man on the side of the road between Jerusalem and Jerico, you will remember that he brought him to an inn and it is a source of great amusement to children to hear that taking out two pennies he gave them to the innkeeper to keep the injured man and said that he would on his return pay him any extra expense incurred. Children laugh at the idea that the man found by the wayside could be kept for two pennies. Such is a history of the depreciation of money down along the line.
Side by side with that, of course, you have the increase in public expenditure. There has, over the past hundred years or so, been a very considerable change in the attitude towards public expenditure from the time when the policy was of restricted public expenditure and the neglect of large sections of the community. Over the past hundred years you have had a more egalitarian approach, spreading out money to give more people a better chance. That is the situation you will have to face. If the bill is large this year it will be larger next year because if we go into the Common Market — I do not like mentioning this matter because I believe it is verboten here— you will have to tackle the question of equal pay and a revision of the educational system to bring it into line with other systems. If you envisage the abolition of the Border you will have to agree that it is time there was an inter-Party statement of national policy on what we are going to do to maintain the advantages enjoyed by people in the North of Ireland by way of free places in schools, free secondary education and university education practically free. All books and equipment are given free in primary schools. There will have to be a statement of attitude towards that situation. That should not come from any one Party. It should be at inter-Party level, expressing the attitude generally of the people this side of the Border towards the advantages enjoyed by people in the Six Counties in the field of education.
The bill next year will be even bigger still, but that is, as Senator Professor O'Brien said yesterday, the history of public expenditure. It is not a phenomenon confined to this country. It is the experience in many countries throughout the world. In the estimated increase of £16.6 million we have been told that £1¾ millions need not be taken into account but we will have to meet about £14.9 million extra. Judging from the way the taxation net is drawing in considerable amounts, that will be met so I do not think there is any great cause for alarm in the suggested increase in expenditure over the coming year.
It is a well-known law of economics that governments tend constantly to assume new functions and perform old ones more carefully, and this involves nations in considerable increasing expenditure. A thing which has to be looked after, however — and the point was raised by Senator Professor O'Brien in his very constructive speech yesterday — is that in relation to public expenditure one must keep an eye on the level of taxation and the level of debt. These are the two main things which I hope the Government will watch when bringing in the Budget— the level of taxation so that it will not reach beyond the safe level of 25 per cent. set out by Colin Clarke, and the level of debt. The amount of money we pay for the service of debt at the present time is dangerously high, but I think the Government will have the wisdom to look after that aspect of our economy.
There was a welcome announcement in the Minister's statement that he is going to do something for pensioners. We all have a social obligation to our pensioners, and a civilisation is judged largely by the way it treats old people. If we disregard those people who have suffered immensely because of the depreciation in money over the past few years and neglect them, we would be doing them a great injustice. We are bound morally in conscience to see that, as far as possible within our economy, the purchasing power of their pensions should be equated to what it was when they left the service. I am speaking on behalf of national teachers when I mention that many people who retired when their pensions equalled half of their salaries, now in relation to the present level of salaries and purchasing power, those pensions have been reduced to one-third. That is completely unjust and is a vote of no confidence in the services these people have given to the nation. We should in fairness, justice and duty see, as we are morally bound to, that as far as possible those pensions are brought up to their proper level so that they will regain their purchasing power.
There is one thing which I certainly deplore which has been going on for the past few years throughout the country, not alone during the present régime of the Fianna Fáil Government but also during the inter-party Government. That is the spreading of gloom through the country, the talk about our being sunk, that we just cannot make the grade as a nation, that we are beaten by emigration and are being wiped out. It is about time that we turned round and faced in the opposite direction, because we are at a very important crossroads in the history of our country, and if we face into the situation considering that we are beaten before we begin there will be disastrous effects. There is an old Latin dictum posse quia posse videntur—those things are possible which seem to be possible. Like a young lad doing a problem, if he says before beginning that he cannot do it he will never do it. But if he faces into the problem with courage and determination and sets about it with a feeling of confidence that he can do the job he will do it. He may fail to complete it but he will make a better shot at it than if he faced into it with no confidence. As a nation we should on every side of this and the other House get together and face up to the very large task which lies ahead. Whilst it is very nice to indulge in political sniping as between one Party and another we should realise that we all have a very great obligation placed on us at this juncture. Looking at the political situation of this nation, many people who have no connection with politics feel convinced that there will be a period of great political instability for ten or fifteen years, because looking at the present state of the Parties, suppose you had an election tomorrow morning——
Comment on this
The Senator will keep in mind that it is expenditure policy we are discussing.
Comment on this
We have to face up to certain aspects of our economy and I feel that we can deal with them in a kind of supra-Party way. I am leading to that, and speaking as one not connected with any political Party. If you had an election in the morning you might have a little shift here and there but the overall picture would be much the same, and if you repeated the performance three years after, it would be still much the same. There is rumour that the farmers may come into politics which would lead to further fragmentation of the entire elected groupings in the Dáil and Seanad.
Because of that and because of the serious position facing the nation on the road ahead, certain aspects of our economy should be treated as being above politics — such a matter as unemployment, which is of course almost synonymous with emigration. That can only be tackled with the goodwill of every side. A group representative of all those in this House and the Dáil should get together with an advisory group drawn from industry, farming, advertising, marketing and so on to see in what way they can engage in land reclamation and exploitation and also in the establishing of new industries. It is only through the establishment of new industries you can create greater employment and stem emigration. From that greater employment, you will have the sequence of higher national income and, paradoxically enough, lower taxation.
We should examine certain aspects of our economy on a non-political basis. With the help, maybe, of vocational people here, we might table a motion that certain stated aspects of our economy should be dealt with in that way for the betterment of the nation. We should not adopt an attitude of gloating and criticism as one Party scores a little point here and another Party another little point there, as a result of victory or defeat in relation to a certain policy. We must come together as a nation and do the best we can for our people.
Comment on this
When opening the debate here yesterday, Senator McGuire made a special plea for constructive criticism. He deplored a destructive critic. I considered his sentiments very noble indeed, and was foolish enough to think that his colleagues would pay attention to him. However, the Senator from Cavan, Senator Fitzpatrick, made a speech that was not only destructive but unrealistic. He painted a picture of dismal gloom, of utter despair, of a nation going backwards instead of forwards, of a nation approaching bankruptcy. Senator Fitzpatrick is a lawyer and he sometimes is obliged to make a case when he has nothing to go on.
Comment on this
I am sure Senator L'Estrange will be given ample opportunity to speak before this debate closes. Senator Fitzpatrick is also a keen drama enthusiast. His performance here yesterday was superb.
Comment on this
Listening to him, I could not help thinking that if bold Hanrahan were here, he would surely say "We'll all be ruined before the year is out." But is the picture really so bad as we are led to believe? Senator Fitzpatrick based his arguments on the fact that the estimates for the coming year have been increased by ten per cent. He gives as an example the businessman who spends more than he can earn and faces bankruptcy. That may be quite so; but the businessman who invests more money in his business to increase production and have greater efficiency will not go bankrupt. He will prosper.
That is exactly what the Government are doing in this Book of Estimates. Practically the entire increase is being used to increase production. It is being devoted to agriculture, tourism, industry, the social services and the eighth round wage increase. Senator Fitzpatrick had the audacity to question the policy of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Let me say to Senator Fitzpatrick that we have very long memories. We do not forget so easily the bleak winter of 1956-57. We do not forget the circumstances which led to the departure of the Coalition Government. We do not forget the occasion when they deserted the ship. Listening to Senator Fitzpatrick, one would get the impression that he and Fine Gael could do better than the Minister for Finance. But they had an opportunity in 1957 and, rather than face that Budget, they resigned. No one asked them to resign. Their term of office did not expire for two years. Why then did they leave?
Comment on this
We cannot easily forget the financial state of this country when the Minister went to the Department of Finance in 1957. Like Old Mother Hubbard, he found the financial cupboard bare. Now, in the very short time of five years, he is able to give extra boosts to agriculture, tourism and industry. The tourist industry is of particular importance to this country. Year after year, the earnings are increased. Every section, including the farmers, benefit from tourism. This year, it is proposed to increase the allocation of money for that purpose.
The anxiety of foreign industrialists to build factories here is a vote of confidence in the stability of the Government. In my own town, a factory opened two weeks ago; 12 miles away a factory will open in a month's time; and 40 miles further on there is another factory in course of construction. This is as a result of Fianna Fáil's policy to bring industry to this country. It is now proposed to provide an extra £1,000,000 for this purpose.
Listening to Fine Gael speakers and members of the NFA, one would get the impression that agriculture is the stepchild of Fianna Fáil. Senator Fitzpatrick made a passionate speech about the flight from the land. It is quite true that in rural Ireland many people are leaving the land, but it is wrong to think that this is due entirely to their inability to earn a living from it. The tendency among our young people to-day is to get off the land and work in the towns and cities of this country or, in some cases, abroad.
Many people leave the land today because the social conditions do not compare with those enjoyed by their cousins in the towns and cities of this country. Twenty years ago social amenities were considered luxuries in rural Ireland, but today the provision of proper water and sewerage facilities is no longer looked upon as a luxury but as an absolute vital necessity. The modern young girl, with her secondary or technical school education, refuses to marry and settle down in the primitive conditions that have existed in parts of rural Ireland. This is a very important factor in the flight from the land. What are the Government doing about it?
They are doing everything about it. An ambitious programme has been announced under which, within the next ten years, it is hoped that water and sewerage facilities will be made available to as many homes as possible in the country. There are, of course, people who oppose this programme and to those I would point out that we are living in an era of progress. People living in rural Ireland deserve the same social amenities as urban dwellers and the Fianna Fáil Government will provide them with those facilities. In this Book of Estimates, more money is being provided for the Bovine Tuberculosis Scheme. In the Dáil, Deputy Booth stated that the Coalition Government retarded that scheme in 1954.
Comment on this
Like myself, Deputy Booth is not a farmer but he had his facts right. The scheme began in 1954 and for three years it was muddled by the Coalition Government. Tests were carried out in certain areas. One farmer had his stock tested while his neighbour had not. Reactors were left on the farms and farmers were allowed to sell those reactors in the open market and had no call to state that they were, in fact, reactors. That was the policy of the Coalition Government in respect of the Bovine Tuberculosis Scheme. It was not until a Fianna Fáil Government returned to office that the first five areas were cleared in a very short time. I defy contradiction of what I say in this respect. I speak as a member of a family of veterinary surgeons.
Several Senators have referred to the marches that have been taking place in this country in recent months and curiously enough Senator Fitzpatrick compared them with the marches in the early 1930's. We know what the policy of those marchers was and is he now suggesting that today's marchers have a similar policy? In 1960-61 farmers in this country paid £7,750,000 in rates on agricultural land out of a total of £22,000,000 paid altogether. At the same time, they paid £250,000 in income tax out of a total of £28,000,000 in all. The farmers contributed in 1960-61 £8,000,000, but in this year £36,000,000 is being provided for the farming population. These figures alone suggest that it is an utter fallacy to say that agriculture is the step-child of Fianna Fáil.
By increasing the Estimates this year, the Government are preparing this country for entry into the new Europe. If we are to satisfy the EEC that we are in a position to fulfil the obligations of the Treaty of Rome, greater efficiency and increased production are required. Senator Fitzpatrick asked what the Fianna Fáil policy in this respect was. It is to increase production and improve efficiency. The Book of Estimates indicates quite clearly that Fianna Fáil are tackling this problem quite well.
In this crucial period in our history it is essential that the morale of our people should be at its highest if we are to satisfy the other European countries in the Common Market that we are capable of fulfilling our obligations. We must make them realise that an Irishman is as good as any man and that he is capable of producing goods and commodities as well as anybody in any country.
Since Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932, Fine Gael have opposed every worthwhile programme introduced. It appears from the pattern of Senator Fitzpatrick's speech that they intend to continue doing just that. The Vote on Account can be responsible for discussions of a varying nature, some of them quite irrelevant, and I would in conclusion like to refer to a speech made in the Dáil by Deputy McGilligan during the debate on the Vote on Account. For reasons best known to himself he alluded to a letter written by me in connection with a Fianna Fáil bazaar. I do not know what that had to do with the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
The Senator will understand it is a rule of this House that we do not comment by name on Deputies in the other House.
Comment on this
If that speaker could persuade his colleagues in the same Party in Donegal to run similar bazaars they might be able to pay not only their expenses in the last general election but in the four general elections before that.
Comment on this
In rising to speak in this debate I shall pick out a few facts and try to probe what the Government's policy is in regard to them — the policy as revealed, as far as we can judge, in the Book of Estimates. I must begin with the Vote for the Universities. At the outset, I must say it is heartening that the Government have at last made a start on facing up to the requirements of the Universities because for almost 50 years the universities were left without any significant capital addition while universities in all other countries boomed and expanded and have been recognised as the main forward force in any forward-looking country.
We are thankful a start has been made but we hope that start will not be confined to our capital city. We hope it will be recognised that there are such places as the provinces. We hope our very legitimate requirements in Cork and also in our sister College in Galway will be met because we work in conditions which are not comparable even with those in Ghana.
Having said that, I must criticise very sharply the short-sighted policy of the Government in their approach to the current staffing and running of our universities.
The Estimates are a severe jolt inasmuch as they leave out the very minute expansionist policy which was in being in the past three years and under which there was a recognised additional sum, almost a token sum, for University College, Cork, with similar sums for the other colleges, of something around £10,000 per annum. At least, it recognised the necessity for a staff expansion and modernisation.
What do we find in the Book of Estimates? We find that the National University has been given an increase of 18 per cent. which, when considered in the light of the fact that public funds provide two-thirds of the income of our universities, means that unless we raise students' fees, which we are very reluctant to do and which will be strongly opposed by hard-pressed parents, the net increase is just 12 per cent.
Already, most of our technical staff, technicians, and so on, have received awards far greater than that. Therefore, with what is being provided, I think it is impossible to give even to the statutory staff the increase that has been given to all the State employees here, the increase that is just cushioning those receiving it for the round of inflation that will inevitably follow. It is not that we are being given a 12 per cent. increase because I am certain that, within 12 months, most of it will be eaten up in inflation.
In analysing the picture, we find real reasons to congratulate Trinity College, Dublin, on succeeding in getting a 50 per cent. increase on their grant of the previous year. Some of that was put down for repairs to buildings. I can assure the Minister and the House that our problems in Cork for repairs and buildings are no less pressing than those in other universities. Yet we can read in the Book of Estimates that only Trinity College, Dublin, has been given a 50 per cent. increase.
Even if you rule out that increase for repairs, which we have to meet, in any case, it still leaves an increase of 33? per cent. I do not say that grudgingly. I should like to learn the secret from Trinity College, Dublin, of how they achieved this — or is it that the nearer you are to Dublin, the better chance you have of getting it?
We have to look at our whole university system in contrast with that of the nearest university to us, Queen's University, Belfast. We have to recognise that, as well as having a political Border in this country, we have an educational border, a border that is probably a bigger barrier to unification than the political Border. We find that Queen's University, Belfast, with 3,500 students, is receiving a greater yearly assessment from the Government than our whole National University, with double that number of students. In short, the cost per student here is somewhere around £150, while in Belfast it is £300, and that figure is not excessive. It is actually an average figure for the whole British system.
Can the Minister name any other single body in this country — industrial or institutional — capable of doing a job at half the amount the job costs in either the Six Counties or in England? I should like to know the Government's policy in this connection. We talk about Partition and we picture it ending. If it ended in the morning, what is our policy on education? Are the North to have to come down to the totally inadequate levels which we have in the Twenty-six Counties? I think the academic people in Queen's University, Belfast, would fight very strongly if they were subject to a reduction in their standards which would prevent them from doing the job that a modern university must do.
I should like to hear the Minister outline his policy in this connection. I should be glad if the Minister and the Government would at least set a target and say: "We cannot next year increase you up to levels in Queen's." In fact, we could not absorb an increase next year that means the provision of additional staff which, in itself, is a relatively slow and long-term project.
I want the Government to say they will do it in, say, ten years and match the building programme being put up in ten years, progressively increasing the standards of all the universities here. Then we can say that the universities are prepared for the unification of the country, that parity has been achieved between standards here and in the Six Counties.
We are not asking for special conditions for ourselves in making that request. We are asking only for facilities that other countries deem absolutely necessary so that the university can play its proper rôle in the full development of the country. All the speakers here have painted a picture of our being a forward-looking, dynamic, progressive nation, ready to join the Common Market, and so on. If we are, we must recognise that Western Europe owes its greatness to the way it has developed the mind of its people, the skill conveyed to them, manually and otherwise. If we join, we must ensure that our people will get the same standards.
It is a high tribute to our universities that our graduates can compare so favourably with those from highly-endowed universities. That cannot continue indefinitely. Year after year, the gap is growing wider. The real expansion in university facilities has taken place since the last War and we have scarcely heard about that expansion yet. Consequently, I am putting it to the Minister to see that something is done about this matter. I have figures before me to show——
Comment on this
The Senator will understand that he may not go into details.
Comment on this
The Senator will understand that they are more suitable for the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
It depends on what the Senator says, not on what he looks at.
Comment on this
These figures show that in the past 15 years university income here has increased 400 per cent. That takes account only of inflation and a very moderate increase in expansion. That is for the National University system. However, the figure in respect of Trinity College, Dublin, has increased 750 per cent. I wonder how Trinity College, Dublin, succeeded in doing that? I hope we can learn the secret.
I was somewhat disturbed by Senator Stanford's talk yesterday about discrimination. By and large, I think the Government have met the problem of Trinity College, Dublin, very fairly. If any universities can claim to be discriminated against, I think it is the two provincial university colleges in Cork and Galway whose income has not kept pace with that of the others and who are finding it very difficult to cope with the situation at present.
Of necessity, our classes are smaller than the classes in the very much larger universities in this city. Consequently, the cost per student has to be somewhat higher, unless you say that some subjects such as archaeology should close down in our universities. Even that means that we cannot mass-produce our graduates. Therefore, again, the standard has been laid where, with the present round of wage increases, a professorship in Cork or Galway is remunerated at the level of that of a senior lecturer in a university here. That is a situation that is plain discrimination unless the Government state as definite policy that these colleges should be treated as junior colleges and that it wishes to concentrate everything in this city.
Again, we have a very real case of discrimination practised against Maynooth College which is our greatest jewel today. I can speak from firsthand knowledge of the wonderful research work that is being carried out there under simply appalling conditions without clerical help or any of the facilities which should be provided. Yet, their grant stands at the same level as it did ten years ago.
Comment on this
I hesitate to interrupt the Senator again but he must not go into details of the Estimates.
Comment on this
I take it that "without clerical help" in the Maynooth context means "without the help of clerks"?
Comment on this
The Senator will understand that this is a debate on general policy and if we get into details we shall not be able to finish.
Comment on this
Surely general financial policy, if it means anything, means how the Government are cutting the loaf and sharing it out? This is our opportunity to show that the Government are being unfair to a certain section of the community. I give the example of Maynooth College. Why has its grant not been increased? If £20,000 is fair for them today, it was much too generous ten years ago. Yet we find, in today's context, that £20,000 is just what it costs to——
Comment on this
The Senator will excuse me interrupting him but I must insist that he shall not go into details of the Estimates. That is how this debate is going to be conducted.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to see how I can prove charges of discrimination without giving facts to substantiate them.
Comment on this
The Senator will have an opportunity on the Appropriation Bill, when it will be perfectly in order.
Comment on this
Surely it is in order for the Senator who comes from Cork — I do not, I have a different College to be interested in — to discuss the grants UCC gets in the Estimates as distinct from the grants other Colleges get? If he is not entitled to do that, I do not know what he is entitled to discuss.
Comment on this
The understanding I have is that general policy only will be discussed and detailed questions relating to detailed expenditure should be reserved for the Appropriation Bill. I hope the Senator will co-operate. I think the business of the House would be better done if we observe that.
Comment on this
Yes, but under protest. I do not see how the very general conclusions I have drawn and the facts I have given can in any way be described as detailed. I do not think that this is a detail — the muddle that prevails here in veterinary education, a muddle which I feel will be made worse by the new building programme that may go ahead of the report of the Commission of Higher Education because we have two Faculties sharing in the one building. We find that the fact that they produced 36 veterinary surgeons last year cost £200,000 out of State money or as much as it cost to run our University College. I suggest that that should be looked into very carefully.
I want to make a plea here — and I do not think it is a detail — for the neglected College of Surgeons. Again, it has stayed at pre-glacial level with its grant of £4,500. I think it should be either crossed off the books or treated in a proper and adequate way as a unit of our educational system.
There is a lesson to be learned from all those Estimates and the lesson we in the universities feel very strongly is the lack of consultation. When we put in our estimates for what we require to do a reasonable job for the year ahead, we hear nothing more of these estimates until the results appear in the papers. That would be all very well if our other groups were treated in the same way but, as far as I know, I believe that with State companies or State Departments their estimates can be argued back and forth across the table — as they should be — and finally they are given opportunities to justify their figures and to arrive at a mutually satisfactory decision or agreement with the financial authorities.
I think that is why we find that those who are nearest with pressure get the best results and consequently we find that increases to those are higher than the increases to those further removed. For instance, the private agricultural schools and colleges have a mere 2½ per cent increase, 6d. in the £, while the corresponding agricultural schools run by the State have an increase of 16 per cent., omitting, of course, the capital sum for the purchase of land in last year's Estimate. I am not saying that is an over-estimate but I am very definitely saying that 2½ per cent. for our private agricultural schools is almost an insult to the bodies which are doing such a remarkable job for the development of our country.
I might contrast university grants with the increase that is being given to the governing bodies of the Veterinary College. They get a 40 per cent. increase while the others get increases of the order of 17 per cent. or 18 per cent. They show very worthwhile provision for equipment. In other words they had an opportunity to argue their case——
Comment on this
Will the Senator now come to general policy? He has been going into considerable detail.
Comment on this
Surely it deals with the Government's approach to parcelling out the finances of the year? I am just making a plea that the time has come when there should be a combined committee of the Dáil and Seanad or a committee of the Dáil alone, something that would approximate the Appropriations Committee in the American Senate, where the elected representatives would have to do their duty of going over the Estimates while there were still opportunities to correct anomalies. It would be a very forward step if we got such a committee. We saw how its action in the US recently cut a bill for 100,000,000 dollars to 25,000,000 dollars when it asserted its authority.
Finally, I might say that our staff in the universities, speaking of those that I can see, are fit to hold their own with similar staffs anywhere because all members of this staff have gone abroad to the best graduate schools in England, America and elsewhere and have brought back their degrees with distinction from those places. Universities outside would be eager and willing to snap up those people and appoint them to positions far higher than they hold here.
The older people, those who are settled in for a number of years, are perhaps tied here but we are finding it increasingly difficult to attract back to our country the younger trained scientists. Unless we can bring them back there is little hope of getting the dynamic approach we need for the future. Many of us are seriously worried about the difficulties of bringing back such students. In my own department and the allied department of engineering, we have 12 students in training and we are worried as to how to get them placed so that they can make the maximum contribution to our national effort. I would appeal to the Government to set their standards high and not to adopt a penny wise and pound foolish policy. It is pound foolish to take a trained scientist in whose education a great investment has been made, to bring him back and not give him the tools to do the job he is trained to do because you are paying him for sitting down and not producing what he is capable of producing.
I want to draw attention to the down-grading of these private and semi-private bodies. Another body which has been very seriously downgraded and on which our future depends a great deal is the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society. The grant-in-aid to this organisation which represents the spirit of co-operation in this country stands at exactly the same level as it stood ten years ago. I dare not mention the figure — that might be detail — but Senators can check the figure from the Estimate. Surely when we are trying to market agricultural produce, when we are trying to set in motion a new spirit in relation to our farming, the IAOS has a vital role to play? Even though it was by-passed, and wrongly so, in my view, in the setting up of the recent Bord Bainne, the fact remains that it is the body on which the whole of our agricultural development depends and it is the body that must diffuse the co-operative spirit throughout our agriculture. It is that co-operative spirit that will enable our small farms to meet the challenge of the large investment in mechanisation that is necessary in modern agriculture.
I appeal very strongly to the Minister to reconsider the treatment of those bodies and above all, to reconsider the setting up of some type of appropriation committee to ensure that all those presenting claims on the public purse will have an opportunity of proving their claims before a committee that is concerned only with trying to keep an even balance between State and non-State demands. I am not saying that in any spirit of criticism of the present administration or those in charge of our finances. It only stands to reason that if you are trying to share out something that is scarce, those who have the greatest opportunity for pressure, those who are closest in to you and have the best opportunity of arguing their case are those who succeed best. Our immediate requirements for the coming year were three times the increase we were actually given. I do not mind our being treated in that way if other bodies are treated the same way, but when others have an opportunity of putting through their legitimate demands, all bodies should have that opportunity. I make a special plea in the case of the universities because it is not something for ourselves. We want the tools and the equipment to do the job for this country that a modern university can do for a modern state in the modern world.
Comment on this
The purpose of this debate is to consider Government policy as indicated in the figures before us. The function of the Government is to raise moneys to stimulate production, to give better and more advanced social services and to improve the amenities of the community so far as the public purse can afford it. Those three items can be extended as the people can afford to extend them, and the people can extend them as productivitity increases.
In some respects, the Government have not a completely free hand because there are certain important sections of the community who, by virtue of the right of free bargaining, can make their own arrangements. Employers and trade unionists can fix their own figures to a certain extent and by reason of the figures they fix, we may have a tendency towards inflation or a tendency towards deflation. Over those tendencies the Government have only a limited control. They can control them only within very small limits of taxation. Those figures, however to a great extent bind the Government when they come to prepare their Estimates for the year. They cannot say that our civil servants, our teachers, our Guards, our Army personnel, all other public servants, are not to be rewarded on an even scale. They must reward them on the same basis of a fair day's pay for a fair day's work which already has been arranged between those private bargaining bodies. A very substantial part of the increase in the Estimates is due to this.
It is for us to consider whether or not we think the Government's policy in that respect is correct. I do not think anybody will suggest it was incorrect. That accounts for approximately 45 per cent. of the total increase in the Estimates. We have to consider the remainder of the Estimates in toto. There is no use in saying that it is the biggest increase ever. That is not constructive. What we must consider is whether this bill is one which the people can meet, whether the appropriations in it are such as will stimulate production as production should be stimulated in accordance with the economy of the country, whether the cost of the services provided comes within the limits of our capacity to pay, whether it gives the best social services it can give, and whether it improves the amenities of the people.
I notice that the largest portion of the bill, £39,000,000 goes to the most important section of our community, the farming community. We are primarily and fundamentally, and have been up to the moment, an agricultural country. From 1953 to 1961, I notice that the grants to the farming community have been increased from £13,000,000 to £39,000,000. In that respect, I congratulate the Government. I think that was a very proper increase. There are, however, limits to the extent to which any Government can help the farmers. There are fundamentally only two ways in which one can help them — one, by increasing subsidies and, secondly, by improving their productive capacity. Unfortunately, in this country, and perhaps, unfortunately also, in most of the civilised countries of the world, the trend has been away from the land. Certainly in every country within the European Common Market, that has been and is the trend. The farmer, once he goes outside his own country, is unable to get for his products the cost of production; the nett result is that every country, without exception, in the European Common Market today is granting subsidies to its farmers for export and, when our Government try to find export markets for our farmers, they find themselves faced with that problem. They have to compete with prices which are depressed below the level of production, but they have to compete also with the subsidies given by other Governments. Proportionately to the wealth of our country, our subsidies exceed those of any other country in the European Common Market. There is, too, a limit to the extent to which one can grant subsidies, without doing damage to the farmers themselves.
Senators who take an interest in our agricultural community, as most of us do, even those of us who have been a very short time in public life, are aware that this country got a very sharp rap on the knuckies not so long ago by reason of the size of the subsidies which it gave to the Irish farmers on the export market. The policy of the Government, therefore, in that respect must be to give the Irish farmer the maximum subsidy possible without creating offence, the maximum subsidy which will not prevent our country from being admitted on equal terms to the Common Market, because, as we all know, the Treaty of Rome provides that subsidies cannot be granted ad lib for agricultural exports. That, of course, will mean that the price of farming products will have to be increased to the cost of production. Within those limits, as far as I can see, our Government have gone to the very edge to which they can go, without doing actual harm to the Irish farming community.
The balance of the products which our Irish farmers sell, one way and another, even on the home market are subsidised as to 75 per cent. of them by our Government. On the export markets, one-fifth, or as near as makes no difference, of the price which the Irish farmer gets for his exports is actually paid out of the taxpayer's pocket. We do not begrudge that to the farmers. The Government apparently do not begrudge it to the farmers and, having examined the matter, they presumably are in the best position to judge. But, further, by financial assistance, we cannot assist our farmers, other than by education and by every endeavour possible to get further markets for them.
In this respect, I note the figure provided. A very substantial sum will be expended in the investigating and procuring of further markets. I notice, with pleasure also, that in the boards set up to study the possibility of securing new markets, the Irish farming community is represented. Undoubtedly, the farming community is depressed here. It is depressed everywhere. But, within the limits I have mentioned, that is all any Government can do.
In another way, of course, the Government can help our Irish farmers and our rural community. In the ordinary course of events, a farm of 30, 40 or 50 Irish or statute acres will provide a living for only one child. No farmer can hope to keep his entire family on the land. To absorb the surplus members something further must be done. That is done now by the encouragement of rural industries. In this respect, I am happy to note that the increase in employment in industry in this country is approximately 7,000 per annum. The grant which our Government give towards the fostering and development of these industries is approximately £3,750 per annum. Now, let me say, and I can speak from some experience over the years, as an industrialist, my experience has been that £1,000 to £1,500 capital expenditure on an average is necessary, we have found, for each extra employee. In other words, if you decide in your industry to employ 10 new people in the year, you will find on an average that you have got to expend in capital a sum of from £10,000 to £15,000. For a contribution of some £500 per head, or slightly less, the Government have helped the Irish rural community to absorb into industrial employment an extra 7,000 per annum, thereby providing an outlet for the second, third, and fourth son of the Irish farmer.
May I say that I should like to pay a very sincere tribute to Senator McGuire for his constructive and instructive approach to the examination of these accounts. I should also like —I am referring to them in the order in which they spoke — to pay a very sincere tribute to Senator Murphy. I do not wish to be taken, when I speak about free bargaining, as criticising the trade unions in the eighth round of increases. I have a very considerable experience of trade unions in this country, and of more than one trade union, and I may say for myself— perhaps I was lucky — that my experience of them has been that they are very responsible people.
They do not do things haphazardly. They approach them in an objective way. Sometimes, being a democratic body, they have to take the views of their members who, perhaps, are not as well versed as the officials in the underlying principles and they may have to go beyond the limits of what industry can bear. At least, they have endeavoured in the eighth round increase—and they have made no secret of the fact that that has been their approach — to increase the status of the Irish worker. They said they were increasing that status on the increased productivity of last year, and what they hope will be the increased productivity of next year. It does seem, perhaps, that they have gone a little far, that there has been a certain amount of inflation as a result, and that the country will have to answer for that inflation. On the other hand, there is a possibility, as Senator McGuire pointed out, that with the co-operation which now exists between the employers' federation and the trade unions, we shall get that increased productivity.
For a young country, our increased productivity has been phenomenal, and we are under a debt of obligation, not only to the Government who have sponsored and encouraged that industrial development, and to our employers, private individuals who have sunk their money in it, but also our trade unions and workers. This Bill is far too important and far too serious in the life of the country to be used for political sniping. I should like to pay a sincere tribute to those Senators who have approached it objectively, and I hope that as the years go by, while constructive criticism continues, if our Government, our employers, our workers, our trade unions and our farmers, with one and all in a small community knowing one another, pull together and work together, there is a great future for this young country of ours.
Comment on this
I should like to congratulate Senator Quinlan for sticking to matters in which he is interested. I, coming from a rural area, will try to deal with the effects of the Government's policy on the rural areas. I am afraid I cannot accede to the request made by Senator Brosnahan in his comments on the painting of dark pictures of rural Ireland today. In my opinion, the picture is indeed very black now.
We in the Labour Party were not shocked by the size of the Estimate, and for that reason, there is a fundamental difference between the attitude of the Fine Gael Party and the attitude of the Labour Party on this matter. The Fine Gael Party believe in taking out the axe, that that is the cure for all ills, but we in the Labour Party are under the impression that more money should be forthcoming under certain headings. We believe that would be of benefit to the country, and that unless more money is available under various headings, we shall not get to the root of the evils, and to the root of our troubles, especially in rural areas.
We believe there should be more money for social services, employment, education and lands and various other Departments. There has been some progress in that direction and it is only natural to expect that there should be increased taxation. That progress has not been as great as some of us were led to believe, because, as Senator Murphy said, the Government give with one hand and take away with the other in the form of income tax. We disagree with the Government's policy with regard to the spending of money collected through taxation. We consider it absolutely ridiculous, for example, to give £5 a week unemployment benefit to a man with a family when he could be usefully employed on the roads, in forestry, in drainage, and various other works, at about £6 10s. or £7 a week, which is the average wage for a rural worker. We believe the gap between what is handed out in social welfare benefits and the actual wage that can be earned should be closed by way of money given in some judicious way, to provide employment or increase productivity, instead of by way of unemployment benefit.
There is too much concentration on Dublin and too little on the rural areas where there is decay and dry rot. Any Government whose policy it is to have one-fifth of the population concentrated in one big city are facing disaster. It happened in another country in Europe. Austria were faced with disaster when they concentrated a great portion of their population at one point. An attempt is being made by the Government to keep people in the undeveloped areas by giving huge grants for industries but it is time the Government asked themselves if that policy has paid any dividends.
In spite of those grants, we find the population is falling, year in and year out, in every county west of the Shannon. Now Monaghan, Cavan and Longford have been included in the undeveloped areas. What I find hard to understand is that these grants are given to keep people in the undeveloped areas, but it is the policy of the Irish Land Commission, when they acquire a farm in Westmeath or Meath as a result of agitation by local uneconomic holders and farmers' sons, to bring people across the Shannon from the areas to which these huge grants are given and give them holdings instead of giving them to the uneconomic holders and farmers' sons in the midlands.
Those farmers' sons have been reared on farms and know how to farm them. Under the present system, if there is no industry in the midlands, as a result of the policy of the Government, they are forced to go to work in industrial concerns in places where they could be described as square pegs in round holes. In my opinion, they are the people who should get the farms. Because of that policy, there are many locked doors, and the NFA hold protest marches throughout rural Ireland.
It is logical, when huge grants are given to the undeveloped areas, that people who know the conditions of farming in the midlands — and particularly farmers' sons — should be entitled to a holding of land as well as people who qualify because they have a couple of acres of land and who could be described as the "baby" of the Land Commission. Westmeath, particularly Mullingar, has lost industry after industry as a result of the haywire policy of the Government in refusing to give the same grants as are given in the undeveloped areas.
I should like to refer to the policy of the Government in allowing foreigners to buy up all the land in Meath and Westmeath. When it is a case of the sale of a 500 or a 600 acre farm it is the dollar or the mark that counts. The Minister should increase the amount given for land so that farms which come on the market could be bought and given to Irish people. The sooner that is done the better.
The greatest problem in rural Ireland today is the absence of job security. Bog workers, farm workers, forestry workers and road workers have no job security. They have a very low standard of living owing to wage rates and instability of employment. The employment is seasonal. If the Government, and particularly the Department of Local Government, would not dicate so much to local authorities as to how money should be expended, a great deal could be done in the provision of employment in the off seasons.
Comment on this
Departmental expenditure does not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
I am saying that we should be given a free hand to decide how the money given under this heading should be spent. The inter-Party Government were the only Government that made any attempt to deal with the problem of casual and seasonal employment. They did so under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and gave county councils a free hand to use that money so as to absorb labour during the off season and to provide employment. No man will stay in a job unless he has job security. Job security does not exist for rural workers and the Government have been doing nothing whatsoever about it.
If the Government were to provide schemes to give full employment to rural workers there would be a huge saving in social welfare benefits and people would be employed in productive work such as land drainage, road improvement, forestry and various other useful operations. That could be done for the small difference, in many cases, between the weekly social welfare benefit and a week's wage.
The decrease in the number of farm labourers is a tragedy for rural Ireland. In Westmeath, in 1956, there were 1,595 full-time farm workers. To-day there are 816. That figure is borne out by the fact that there were only 816 claims for rebate of rates in respect of employment last year. Apparently, farmers are unable to pay the miserable wages that a farm worker gets. It is important to remember that within 12 months of the day a farmer dispenses with his labour he is a poor man. He will find that his drains are blocked, his hedges uncut, noxious weeds growing in his fields and his crops not sown or cared for as is done where there is proper husbandry.
It would seem that the small farmer faces annihilation. Unless some system is adopted to save him, I am afraid we will never cure the ills of this country. All politicians that I ever heard, at chapel gates or anywhere else, always said the small farmer was the backbone of the country. No one talks about the small farmer today. He cannot rear his family on his holding and, unless he has some side line, he cannot carry on. In no part of the country was that proved so convincingly as in the midlands where Bord na Móna were operating. Every small farmer in the neighbourhood, by hook or by crook, got a car and travelled 15 to 20 miles to work for Bord na Móna every day and his farm became purely a side line and no longer a means of livelihood for him. Bord na Móna went to the trouble of providing houses. According to last week's paper, they are seeking tenants for these houses because there is no one to go into them. It was thought that they would have to go across the Shannon for extra workers but now they have sufficient labour available in the vicinity. If that state of affairs continues, it cannot be said that there are any prospects for rural Ireland when the small farmer whose father reared a large family on his holding cannot make ends meet.
The small farmers must devise means to reduce overheads. In other words, they must start a co-operative system. There is too much individuality. If Jack Murphy gets a tractor, Paddy Murphy has to get a tractor. That is the cause of the trouble. Farmers should form small groups for the purpose of buying and using machinery. The people who invest money in that machinery should have their work carried out first. There could be a big reduction in overheads under such a scheme, which might make it possible for these people to make ends meet.
People say that the Government are doing nothing about education. Nothing is further from the truth. The colossal total of £20,500,000 for education for the year 1962-63 indicates that the Government are doing quite a lot for education. Again, apparently, if you are in Dublin or in one of the big cities you will get everything you want. The universities are getting what they want.
Comment on this
If one takes a trip to rural Ireland one can see whether the schools there are adequate or not, whether the sanitary accommodation in them is suitable, and whether they are the type of schools we should have in 1962.
The Government this year introduced the Apprenticeship Act. I hold that about three or four years ago every vocational committee in the country should have been warned that the Apprenticeship Act was about to be passed and told what commitments they would have as a result. There are vast rural areas which have no vocational school. The people have no means whatever of getting their children to vocational schools to get their group certificate to qualify as apprentices. The Act was premature, first of all, because if a man buys a bird, surely he buys a cage first and surely we should have provided the schools first.
I agree with Senator Stanford that it is gratifying that the Government have provided a substantial sum for scholarships. He had a reasonable complaint about the position in relation to Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council but the picture is not exactly as black as he wished to paint it. Scholarships to secondary schools and universities are available to the minority and I do not know of any county outside Dublin where conditions are laid down about what school you go to. They may have good reasons in Dublin but the position regarding Dublin University is ridiculous. The Minister should give consideration to both Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council because if a person belonging to the minority wins a scholarship and makes application to Dublin County Council to attend the school of his own choice, assuming that is Trinity College, he should be allowed to attend Trinity College. It might be said that the Minister has no function in this matter. The Minister has a function because he gives the money. He provides a vast amount of the money for these scholarships so he should direct how the money should be spent, just as the Minister for Local Government directs us on how the money should be spent in the county councils.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
I think I was at the point of dealing with remarks made by Senator Stanford on Scholarships given by Dublin County Council.
Comment on this
On a point of fact: Dublin Corporation, not Dublin County Council.
Comment on this
The Senator mentioned the county council yesterday.
Comment on this
No; I did not mention the county council yesterday.
Comment on this
If a person wins a scholarship, he should be in a position to write in and say he wished to go to a certain school and that would obviously be Dublin University. If Dublin Corporation, in their wisdom, operated some restriction, then there should be an exception to that restriction, because we should have no religious discrimination. It is something that should be settled because on the whole we have no complaints in the rest of the country and there should not be any here in relation to Dublin Corporation. This council, if it is not acting in a way that can be described as repugnant to the Constitution, is certainly acting in a way that is contrary to the spirit of the Constitution.
Senator McGlinchey and others raised the point that the Government had increased the grants to Bord Fáilte. We in Westmeath have more reason to complain about the distribution of these grants than any other county. We have the most beautiful lakes in the country.
Comment on this
The question of distribution does not properly arise.
Comment on this
We are asked to provide the money in the Estimates for this work and I hold that there should be more equitable distribution.
Comment on this
The Senator may hold that but he may not discuss it in detail. It would be more properly raised on the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
We contribute to these funds and should get a fair share of them. We have no access to our lakes, no proper roads or anything else, and I would ask the Minister to ask the Minister responsible to consider giving a fair distribution of grants throughout the country, instead of concentrating on Dublin, Wicklow and Donegal.
I wish to criticise the policy of the Government on expenditure under the Health Act. It is absolutely impossible to find anyone in this country today who is satisfied with the Health Act as it stands. The maintenance fee for insured workers is the cause of quite an amount of trouble and it should be abolished completely. There should be an increase in the health grant, if necessary, to meet that maintenance fee of 10/- per day for insured workers. When a man is ill, he is not earning and that is sufficient reason why he should not be asked to pay maintenance. According to my calculation, an increase in the national health contribution of 2d. would cover the full amount being collected from people insured under National Health. It is worth consideration. This extra 2d. should be added to national health contributions and in that way eliminate this 10/- maintenance fee per day for the middle income group. I am not exactly worried about the increase in taxation, especially if the Government will remember that there are 26 counties to be considered. The major portion of the money should not come to the city of Dublin. Everything comes to the city of Dublin. A new aircraft factory is being built and possibly the Government will provide £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 for that purpose. It is a very good thing but it is still Dublin which is getting it. We are drawing the people away from the rural areas.
I am sorry that I cannot paint a brighter picture of the situation in rural Ireland to-day after 40 years of native Government. Every day I get letters from people looking for work. I got one last night which was typical. Here is an extract from it:
I wonder if you could get him a spell on the roads——
This was written on behalf of another man——
He has nothing but 27/6d. dole and I can assure you he is hungry. He owes £4 cottage rent and he has got the final notice before taking him to court. There is no work with the farmers.
That is typical of the type of letter I get every day. I often get five or six of them. We believe that something must be done by the Government, no matter where the money comes from. They must try to cure the ills of the rural areas, if this country is to be as it should be. I would much prefer to come in here and say that Ireland is a land flowing with milk and honey rather than to have to come in and say that everything is not all right. Everybody living in rural Ireland realises that decay is setting in and that it is getting worse every day.
Comment on this
I wonder, a Chathaoirligh, could we get any indication as to how many others intend to speak so that we can ascertain when the Minister will get in?
Comment on this
We have about four speakers. I am not tying myself precisely but I think the Minister will get in around the time suggested, 9.30 p.m. or so.
Comment on this
It is understood that the Minister will get in at 9.30 p.m.?
Comment on this
This debate is one in which I intervene with trepidation. The huge sums of money being referred to and disposed of create an atmosphere something akin to Wall Street, a place in which I would find myself ill fitted to say anything in regard to higher finance. What I would like to say however, is quite simple. It arises from this table which shows the major increases and decreases compared with the 1961-62 Estimates. This looks to me to be very imprudent housekeeping. It looks like using the housekeeping money on luxury articles, while some of the family are in need of essentials. For instance, take tourism. There is to be an increased expenditure of £359,000. I wonder is it a really good bargain to spend money on attracting tourists here? I wonder, indeed, if it is even necessary. So far as I can judge, we still have our eyes on the very distant lands, America, in the main, for the largest volume of our tourists. Yet we know, with few exceptions, American visitors are people who only come once and are not likely to come back again. That being so, does it really matter how greatly they are impressed with our new rich hotels? Many of us know that a very big volume of Americans who come here do so simply because they have been saving for a lifetime to get the money to come, and others come because years ago they took out an insurance policy which at maturity gives them not a pension for life, not a lump sum, but a holiday. I have seen advertisements for these policies and I have discussed them with visitors, one of whom told me that in no circumstances would the companies give a money payment in lieu of the holiday. One might be in delicate health or really ill when the policy matures but to use my informant's own words: "You must take the holiday, even if it kills you."
No matter how elaborate we make our hotels, these visitors can never be what I would call repeat visitors. I feel we can get a very large volume of visitors, and the revenue we require from them, from our neighbours in Great Britain and countries much nearer than America. I feel we can do that at far less expense. I should be the last person in the world to advocate poor, shabby hotels and I should not like to be misunderstood on that point. I think it was Senator McGuire who coined the phrase that what we really wanted was "first-class second-class hotels" and I would be in full agreement with that.
The next item that struck me was defensive equipment for which there is an increase of £300,994. What can be visualised here, when we do not know what we have to defend ourselves against and what type of equipment we can give to our defence forces that would not be out of date in a very short time? There has been criticism from time to time of huge expenditure on equipment that was obselete almost before it was unpacked from the delivery crates but I do not want to go into that. What I would like to know is—would the country be any worse off if instead of increasing this Estimate we had left it as it was or even reduced it?
The increase in grants to vocational education committees is smaller than that for either tourism or defensive equipment. I would like to have seen this on the upward trend, for in this lies our true and only defensive equipment. In the Common Market atmosphere we know we will require, as well as trained scientists, highly trained technicians if we are to survive, and, in the main, these technicians will come from the students of our vocational schools. We have a crying need for trained technicians. Emigration due to unemployment, low wages and lack of opportunities have robbed us of our best technicians. Indeed, many of our skilled technicians whom we trained and paid for their training will be working for our competitors, and these must be replaced by men well equipped and trained to meet the competition we will have to face.
I should like to have seen our national housekeeper making an even bigger increase in the money available for this work even at this stage if it could be done; if not, maybe in the Budget the Minister would hammer off a very big chunk of the proposed expenditure on tourism and on defensive equipment and give it where it is most needed. If he would do that it would be a very good thing. Give it by increased pensions and benefits to our aged, to our infirm, to our widows and orphans and those in receipt of social welfare benefits, and add a good bit of it to the vocational education committee grants where they can be used for the training of our technicians so that by their skills they will be able to contribute to the building of this country as a truly Christian country, a peace-loving nation, where the shadow of insecurity will disappear and where the old, the infirm, the widow and the orphan will be enabled to live in decency and comfort.
Comment on this
The bill before us today in the Estimates for the public services for the year ended March 31, 1963, is for a sum of £148,373,916. There is no doubt about the fact that the Minister for Finance is seeking to extract from the people of this country with a dwindling population the largest sum ever asked by a Minister for Finance. There is no denying that everybody got a profound shock when they heard the sum of £148,000,000 as it will be agreed that the people of Ireland are over-taxed and unable to bear any further burden. The increase that is demanded this year is £17,000,000 more than what was spent last year, and it represents an 8 per cent. increase in taxation with only a 4 per cent. increase in national production. It is £43,000,000 up on the Budget of 1956 even without taking into consideration the £9,000,000 which the Minister saved that year when he abolished subsidies.
We have heard a lot about criticism, but it might be no harm to state that when the Government of that day introduced their Budget for £105,000,000 they were criticised very severely by the Fianna Fáil Party. They were severely criticised by Deputy Lemass, who is now the Taoiseach and one of the people responsible for putting on the people this further burden of £52,000,000. In the Dáil debates for the 8th May, 1956, Volume 157, at column 49 the present Taoiseach stated:
We announced that we had made up our minds on that fact and that, so far as we were concerned, there would be no increase in tax rates above the 1953 level. We made it clear that, if any Budget difficulty arose, that difficulty would be met by a reduction of expenditure and not by increasing the burdens on the taxpayer.
Now we find the same people who in 1956 wanted to reduce expenditure and stated that they would not increase taxation coming before us looking for an extra £52,000,000. Of course, this is nothing new for Fianna Fáil, who say one thing when in opposition and do the very opposite the moment they get into power. This Bill was just an opportunity to discuss Government policy, and the Government policy has been discussed for the past few days. Of course, when we criticise the present Government we will be told that it is only destructive criticism. It is the duty of an Opposition to say what they believe to be right and what they believe should be done in the interests of the people of the whole country. There is no denying that the huge impost imposed upon the people by the present Fianna Fáil Government is grinding down the people of Ireland. Farmers and business people are being crushed between increased costs, increased rates and reduced prices.
Unfortunately, some of the people have got so used to the crushing burdens imposed by successive Fianna Fáil Governments that they have become like punch-drunk boxers. They can absorb punishment without seeming to be affected in any way, but they are affected and very seriously affected. The fact that there are so many closed homes in rural Ireland and that £215,000 people have emigrated during the past five years shows that the people are losing faith and confidence in themselves and the Government and are gravely affected by soaring taxation. Like the punch-drunk boxer, many of them have lost initiative, ambition and the competitive instinct. They have become like animated punchbags for the two-fisted pummelling of increased rates and taxes. The burden of £148,000,000, represents nearly 30 per cent. of the national income; in 1930/31, it was only 18 per cent. The Party now in power told us at that time that if they were elected they would run the country on £2,000,000 less than it cost to run it at the time. Instead of running it at £2,000,000 less, they have increased it by almost £120,000,000.
This sum of £148,000,000 represents an average of £48 a head for every man, woman and child in the country, or nearly £220 for an average-sized family. Under such a crushing burden, with emigration and unemployment chronic, is it any wonder that incentive is lacking and money for investment scarce? One would think the Minister would be guided by what happened already in regard to industrialists. In 1956, the inter-Party Government brought in a Bill to reduce taxation on exports and we all know there was a great breakthrough in that direction. The same would happen in other directions if the people had less taxation to bear.
The fact that the Government have introduced this huge bill shows a complete lack of understanding on their part. There is nothing in it to give our people further employment. The pot seems to be boiling over without the Government paying any attention, but that is merely in keeping with the Fianna Fáil policy of taking money and squandering it. Over the years, the Fianna Fáil Governments have squandered much of the taxpayers' money. As I said, Fianna Fáil in opposition say one thing but as a Government, say something else. Let me quote the then Deputy Lemass speaking in the Dáil on 6th March, 1951, at column 1167 of the Official Report. He said:
We have got to persuade the people that, instead of giving the Government 5/4 out of every £1, they should give 6/- or 6/6d. or 7/-, persuade them that it is better for themselves that they should spend less at their own discretion and let the Government do their spending for them.
I doubt if that is a good policy in a country where we believe, or should believe, in private enterprise. The Government are increasing the burden and taking 5/-, 6/- or 7/- from the people. Therefore, they cannot have the initiative to plan ahead and work as they should. They will say to themselves: "What is the use of our working? We are working only for the Government. As soon as we make the money, they will take it from us." The Government are certainly taking the 6/- or 7/- from the people and they are certainly spending it. ESB charges and bus charges and, in fact, every single thing a person can purchase has increased in price at present.
We are entitled to discuss Government policy here and compare it with the promises they made to the people in the past. Let us contrast the state of affairs existing today with the promises made by Fianna Fáil, especially in the 1957 election. The people were led to believe that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power, the food subsidies would be maintained and there would be no increase in food prices. Both the President of Ireland, the then Taoiseach, and Deputy Lemass, who is now the Taoiseach, stated this—one of them in Dungarvan and the other in Belmullet.
Vigorous measures were to be taken to deal with economic problems and to provide employment. They were to "get cracking". We were to have the £100,000,000 plan to provide 100,000 new jobs. But, in spite of all we heard about that, there are 57,000 fewer people employed today than there were in 1955 or even in 1956, despite all the new factories that have been built and opened since then. We all know that instead of the people having better times they got dearer food, the subsidies were removed to a tune of £9,000,000 and increase in the cost of living took place. Since then, we have had increased hospital charges, fewer people are at work and fewer houses have been built.
The Local Authorities (Works) Act, which gave valuable employment in the different counties, was referred to by Senator McAuliffe today. It helped to give employment in the lean periods from December to March. I have always believed that was money well spent because it helped to do drainage.
I agree with Senator McAuliffe that in an under-developed country like ours, where there is plenty of work to be done on drainage, forestry and land reclamation, we should have no unemployed people. Instead of expecting a single man to live on 30/- a week or a married man to live on 61/- a week, our efforts should be directed at having them employed in constructive work at £7 a week or whatever rates county councils pay. County councils were able to do a considerable amount of such work in the past under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
The present Government scrapped that scheme and that is another reason why rates have increased in nearly every county. That is so because councils had to face up to the major problem of trying to give employment to such people thrown out of work through the abandonment of the Local Authorities (Works) Act. The Government also did away with the double byre grant scheme.
I heard Senators today lamenting the fact that Deputy Dillon reduced the price of wheat. He did reduce the price of wheat by 12/- in 1953 or 1954. However, if we look at the Statistical Abstract for Ireland, 1961, we will see at Page 316 that in 1953 the farmers got 32/- per cwt. for wheat but that in 1959, under Fianna Fáil, the very people now shedding crocodile tears, they got only 29/4d. per cwt. In 1960, still under Fianna Fáil, they got only 27/7d. We should also bear in mind that in answer to a question in the Dáil yesterday the Taoiseach announced that £1 in 1953 would purchase only 14/2d. worth today.
Barley prices have also been reduced by 10/- per barrel since 1953. That was done by the people who tell us they have always done well for the farmers, better than Fine Gael or any other Party. Let us take pig prices. The official statistics show that in 1953 porkers, dead weight, were 256/- per cwt. In 1960 they were 224/- per cwt. The same applies to bacon pigs. In 1953 they were 256/9d. but by 1960 they had dropped to 228/9d. per cwt. We can take turkeys. They also dropped in price as did eggs and chickens.
We all realise that the small farmer, the backbone of this country, has been trying to live on the sale of pigs, of barley, poultry and a little wheat. Each one of those commodities has been reduced in price. If we take another look at the statistics we will see that cattle and sheep have also been reduced in price. The Taoiseach stated in the Dáil that the farmers' income had increased by £16,000,000. I hope the Minister will tell us where the Taoiseach got his figures. I have given the prices for wheat, pigs, poultry and barley. I can also give details of the price of wool which dropped from 4/1½d. in 1953 to 3/10½d. per Ib. in 1960.
Let us then come to cattle. In 1955, referred to as one of the disastrous years under the inter-Party Government, two to three year old cattle realised £60 17s. Compare that price in 1953 with the price in 1960.