We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Central Fund Bill, 1962 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.

Contributions 112–221 of 221. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Central Fund Bill, 1962
Enacted

No. 6 of 1962 ›

I am making my own speech and the Senator can make his. I shall give the Senator the Statistical Abstract if he wants it. In 1955 the price of two to three year old cattle was £60 17s. In 1960 the same animals were selling at £56 6s. Yet the farmers are supposed to be well off now. Fat cattle, three years old and upward, were £66 12s. in 1955 and in 1960 they had fallen to £62 14s. The same trend was noticeable in sheep prices. Let us take 1953.

Comment on this

No, 1956.

Comment on this

Yes. In that year, for store sheep the price was £6 16s. 6d. and in 1960 it was £5 14s. 9d. The Senator asked me to give him the figure for 1956 and I have given it.

Comment on this

I asked the Senator to take cattle.

Comment on this

I am at sheep now. Take 1956 for fat sheep, two year olds and over. That price was £6 2s. 9d. but in 1960 it was £5 8s. 3d. Take the worst year—the one bad year in the reign of that Government —the prices for sheep were from £1 to 50/- higher than they were in 1960. If we take pigs, on which the majority of the small farmers make a living, young pigs were 118/3d. in 1953 and in 1956 they were 111/6d. Then in 1960 they were exactly 110/-. Yet we are told the farmers are well off and that Fianna Fáil did better for them than any other Party. That should prove to Senator Yeats or any other Senator that after taking the worst year overall, 1956, the prices were much better than they were in 1960 under Fianna Fáil.

Fianna Fáil speakers will always tell you they have been consistent. I think they have been consistent in breaking every major promise they made over the past 30 or 40 years. They would promise the sun, moon and stars at a general election in order to get into power. Then, when they get back into power, they very quickly forget about the promises they made. They have also been consistent in increasing the cost of living. Today, they have another record: the cost of living stands at an all-time high record of 145 points.

Despite the promises Fianna Fáil made away back in the past that they would maintain the subsidies and reduce the cost of living, through deliberate Government action they increased the price of the loaf by 7d., the pound of butter from 3/9d. to 4/7d. and the stone of flour from 4/- to 8/-.

The Minister for Finance has always claimed, in argument with me that he gave figures in the Dáil to prove that the cost of living went up nothing more under Fianna Fáil than it did under the inter-Party Government. I went to the trouble today of getting the figures. They are to be found in the Statistical Abstract. If the Minister looks at them he will find that during the six and a half years of inter-Party Government the cost of living went up roughly 21 points and that during seven and a half years of Fianna Fáil Government it went up 34 points.

When the inter-Party Government came into office in 1948, the cost of living stood at 99 points. They were three years in office. I have the days and dates. In the past, the Minister got up and said that Senator L'Estrange quoted figures here which were wrong and that that is the usual Fine Gael stunt of getting up and giving wrong figures in the hope that the people of Ireland will believe them.

When the inter-Party Government went out of office on 30th May, 1951, the cost of living stood at 109 points, an increase of ten points. Fianna Fáil came in with the cost of living at 109 points and introduced the Budget of 1952. When they were leaving office in May, 1954 the cost of living stood at 124 points, an increase of 15 points.

When the inter-Party Government came back to office in May, 1954, the cost of living stood at 124 points. When they were leaving office in March, 1957, the figure was 135 points, an increase of 11 points.

Fianna Fáil took over in March, 1957, when the figure stood at 135 points. Today, it stands at 154 points, an increase of 19 points. If you add the ten plus 11 points increase under the inter-Party Government you get an increase of 21 points in six and a half years. If you add 15 plus 19 points under the two terms of Fianna Fáil Government—the third, if you like, counting their last six months—you get an increase of 34 points in seven and a half years.

Comment on this
A Senator

The £ has remained static.

Comment on this

Due to the action of Fianna Fáil, it has remained anything but static. In today's Irish Press,“The Truth in the News”, we read that the Minister announced yesterday that compared with 1953 the £ will now purchase goods to the value of 14/2d. Anybody who asserts that the £ has remained static would need to send up to the Park for an Oxford Dictionary.

Comment on this

Why send there for it?

Comment on this

At one time somebody needed it in relation to the definition of the word "Republic".

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If Senator L'Estrange wishes to continue along those lines, he will get a bellyful. He is seeking to insult the President.

Comment on this

I do not think that was meant.

Comment on this

Of course, it was meant.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There was a deliberate sneer. It is not the first time Senator L'Estrange has done so. It is about time a stop was put to it.

Comment on this

We on this side of the House have always believed in this predominantly agricultural country that if the people on the land are prosperous the whole nation will be prosperous but if the people on the land are poor, as they are today, then the whole nation is poor.

We have very little underground wealth in this country. We have no coal, steel or ore. However, we have 12,000,000 of fertile arable soil for a dwindling population which is now roughly 2,500,000. In the final analysis the standard of living of every man, woman and child in this country depends on what the farmers of Ireland and their labourers can get from our land and export profitably. The farmers are entitled to a fair crack of the whip and they are not getting it.

Their costs, as I have proved, have been reduced since 1953 while their rates, taxes and costs of production are soaring.

The farmer must live on his profits which represent the difference between cost of production and selling price. From 1948, perhaps, to 1953 or 1954, his costs of production increased slightly but due to the trade agreement which Deputy Dillon made with the British Government in 1948 the cost of everything he had to sell also increased so that he had a margin of profit and could earn a decent living for his family and himself on the land.

Today, the farmers' costs are increasing and the prices at which they sell are decreasing with the result that their profits are becoming smaller and smaller. As Senator McAuliffe pointed out, many small farmers have to work on the roads or on the bogs or wherever they can get work. Even Mr. Lemass speaking in Brussels recently—

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Yes. The Taoiseach speaking in Brussels recently admitted that the farmers in Ireland represent nearly 40 per cent of the people and were responsible for 75 per cent of our exports, but if we look up the national income figures, we find that in 1953 they were getting 29.9 per cent of the national income, while at the present time the percentage they receive is down to 20. I cannot understand how anyone has the audacity to say that the Government are the friends of the farmers and that Fine Gael in the Government who preceded them were not the friends of the farmers.

In the past, the farmers were attacked as they were attacked by the Taoiseach recently in the Dáil. In the past, he said they had feather-bedded conditions——

Comment on this

And who said that?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach spoke about the feather-bedded conditions the farmers had——

Comment on this
A Senator

Quote!

Comment on this

On 24th November, 1953, Mr. Lemass told members of the Dublin Society of Chartered Accountants that the farmers in recent years enjoyed—and I quote—"feather-bedded conditions of regulated sales and guaranteed prices."

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would give the reference?

Comment on this

The Irish Press of 25th November and he made the speech on the 24th. Irish farmers are not surprised at being taxed out of existence by the Taoiseach because while he was always anxious to bolster up industry as much as possible—all credit to him—he never had any regard for the people and farmers of rural Ireland.

On 1st February, 1954, Mr. Lemass told UCD Literary and Historical Society that the farmers did not want to be better off. He said—and I quote:—"It appeared to him that the difficulty up to the present was that the farmers did not want to be better off. He believed that farmers up to recently had a standard to which they aspired and were not prepared to make the effort necessary for a higher one." That statement is reported in the Irish Press of 2nd February, 1954. Earlier, in the course of the same speech, he said they had grants and guaranteed prices for certain crops and so long as the farmer continued to be successful in his political agitation, he was not likely to be attracted by the idea of having to do these things for himself. We also know, and were not surprised when, the Minister announced that the subsidy on fat cattle is to be withdrawn from 1st April. That is a retrograde step that will have very dangerous consequences.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It took the Senator eight months to wake up to that. It was announced eight months ago and a month ago in the Dáil. The Senator only woke up to it yesterday.

Comment on this

We once had a Fianna Fáil Senator who wanted to put a tax and levy on every beast leaving this country. I can give the relevant quotation, if necessary. The

Tánaiste in introducing his Budget on 6th May, 1953, said—and I quote from the Dáil debates, Volume 138, column 1185: "Taxation presses lightly on the land." The farmers of Ireland know now why they are being attacked by the Government. The Taoiseach has said they have too many grants, that they have feather-bedded conditions and he was going to see to it in the future that they will not be as well off as they were in the past.

The farmers are on the march at the present time and people will not, and I think, cannot blame them. Senator McGlinchy said here today—I do not know what he was getting at— that he wanted to know if they were the same as the marchers in the 'thirties. They are marching today because they believe they are not getting a fair crack of the whip, not getting a fair share of the national cake. Nobody can deny that they are the hardest-worked section of the community and their labourers with them. For long periods of the year, they work, not five days but six days a week and often seven days a week.

Somebody mentioned yesterday that they are the worst-paid section of the community, not able to pay the agricultural worker a decent wage. There are many small farmers. It should be remembered that 65 per cent. of the farms in Ireland are less than 30 acres and that any man with less than 30 acres has not £5 a week from it. He has not as much as a road-worker and is not able to pay agricultural workers £6 a week. It is a deplorable state of affairs in an agricultural country because I believe the agricultural labourer is a highly technical man. He has to work hard from eight in the morning until six in the evening for five and a half days of the week and should get as much as a bus driver, £10 or £11, or anybody working in a non-productive capacity. He is doing his part. The majority of these men have stood loyally by the farmers and, with the farmers, are responsible for 75 per cent. of our exports.

I do not blame the farmers for marching. They have been in the front line in every war in this country, national, social and economic. They are seeking justice, demanding a fair return for their labour and they are not getting it. Seeing the huge sums that are being spend at present and seeing that people are getting an eight round of increases—I do not begrudge them to anybody—is it not wrong that some people get increase and others get no increase but instead reduced prices since 1953? I do not care how anybody argues; the figures and statistics are there and nobody can suggest that the farmer is not getting less today for everything he has to sell than he got in 1953. Instead of getting pounds he is getting only so many fourteen-shillings-and-twopences.

The Government should remember that, at present, out of the chaos of conflicting ideas and theories of which the farmers have for long been the victims, there at last arises a unified voice demanding attention. There is a limit to the endurance of any section of the community and that limit has been reached by the farmers of Ireland.

We were given certain figures today by Senator McGlinchey. As far as my county is concerned they are completely wrong, He said the farmers of Ireland paid £7,500,000 rates out of £21,000,000. In my county of Westmeath 76 per cent. of the rates comes from the land. I do not know what the percentages are in other counties but I do know that. The farmers' incomes —the Taoiseach admitted it — did increase from 1947 to 1955 but the increase in rates and their overhead expenditure have been out of proportion to their incomes. If you look up the statistics you will find that from 1947—I am taking the years the Taoiseach mentioned in the Dáil—rates in the county health districts have increased 200 per cent. from £3.9 million to £12,000,000 but the farm incomes have increased from £78.9 million to £124,000,000, a 57 per cent. increase. I wonder is that justice. In my own county the rates increased from 12/8 in 1947 to 36/9 in 1962, another 200 per cent. increase.

It will also be admitted that farmers are paying for a large number of services from which they receive little or no benefit. They are paying for sanitary services and water schemes for other people from which they themselves derive no benefit. Senator Fitzpatrick mentioned last night, and it was decried here today, that any degree of prosperity we have in Ireland was due to the work of Deputy James Dillon and the work of the inter-Party Government from 1948 to 1951 and especially to the cattle trade agreement that was negotiated in 1948. If you read the Taoiseach's speech you will find it is stated at column 1199, Volume 193, of the Official Report of 8th March, 1962, that he said:

The general pattern revealed by our record is, however, that in the period from 1948 to 1961 farm incomes per head improved more rapidly during the first half of that period and non-farm incomes caught up in the second half.

Statistics go to prove that farm incomes improved from 1948 to 1953 and that since that they have not improved in any way. Senator McGlinchey criticised what had been done by the inter-Party Government on the bovine TB eradication scheme which began in 1954. If Fianna Fáil are as progressive as he claims they were, why did they not support the scheme in 1951, 1952, or 1953? They had to wait until they got back into power to try to operate the scheme prepared in 1951. Senator McGlinchey ruined his own argument because he said it was not until Fianna Fáil came into office that five clearance areas were cleared in a very short time. They were certainly cleared because the spade work had been done before the change of Government.

Comment on this
A Senator

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

It is not nonsense. If Fianna Fáil are as progressive as they claim to be, why did they not start the scheme in 1951, 1952, or 1953? England started it away back in 1945. The United States started in 1943 or 1944 and other countries started 25 and 30 years ago. Why did Fianna Fáil wait until Deputy James Dillon came into power in 1954 and started the TB eradication scheme? Is it not because Fianna Fáil had no belief in the cattle industry? Did they not tell us from their own mouths the British market had gone and gone forever?

On the 9th May, 1960, when the Taoiseach was speaking at Inchicore he said that Fianna Fáil realised that agriculture is now the cornerstone of their economic policy. It is a pity they did not realise that 20 years earlier. If they had the people would be much better off than they are today and there would not have been the emigration of 215,000 people during the past five years.

One of the greatest dangers facing us today on the ever of our decision to enter the Common Market is the high-priced economy forced upon us by the Fianna Fáil Government. It was forced upon us by their reducing the food subsidies, extravagantly increasing the cost of living, the cost of Government administration and taxation which is now, according to the Book of Estimates before us £2,000,000 higher than it was five years ago.

Senator Nash said that when the Government got markets abroad it was found very often it was not economic to export to those markets. What is the real reason? It is that the Government have forced upon us a high-priced economy and we are now pricing ourselves out of many of the markets of Europe and even of the world. That has been forced upon the farmers and people of Ireland by deliberate Government policy. As regards butter, for example, it costs us £3,000,000 or £3,500,000 to export it to Britain and sell it there at 2/7d. when we were charging our own people 4/7d. per Ib. Some of our industrial products are much higher-priced here in Ireland than in Common Market countries due, I claim, to the Government policy of putting prices in Ireland at a relatively higher level than world prices. A flabby cost structure over the years has been inflated like a balloon. There is a serious danger of a collapse of the balloon. It cannot be denied that Government policy both in its timing and general direction has caused this rise in costs and in prices.

As far as we on this side of the House are concerned we welcome new industries. Away back in 1924 Cumann na nGaedheal started the first of our industries. They started the Shannon Scheme and the first of our beet factories. We hear people talking about destructive criticism but people who are now Ministers and in high and important positions in the Government referred to those industries as white elephants. We welcome industries. We do not mind who sets them up. We welcome people with money from abroad, with technical know-how. In 1956 it was the inter-Party Government who made the decision that those people could come here, who gave tax concessions, and who gave grants of up to two-thirds of the cost of erecting the factories.

We hear talk about constructive criticism but it might be no harm to quote what the Taoiseach had to say about those grants at that time. At column 1948 of Volume 160 of the Official Report he said:

These are provisions which I think are likely to be far more effective in retarding industrial development than helping it. I believe that over the main part of the industrial field, private enterprise is the best force on which to rely.

At column 1949 he went on to say:

I must confess that I have a very considerable dislike of most of these proposals for money or nothing...

He was not in favour of these grants at that time. Further down in the same column he said:

I have calculated that the maximum amount of money that it could possibly cost the Government, even if we assume that we will get a 10 per cent. increase in industrial exports and a 10 per cent. increase in coal production, is less than £10,000.

I have not the exact figure but I would say that, perhaps, from £25,000,000 to £30,000,000 was spent on grants since the Taoiseach made those famous statements away back in 1956 when the Bill to give grants to industrialists coming in here was introduced in Dáil Éireann. At column 1950 of the same volume he said:

The Minister can have his Bill, as far as I am concerned, but I want to make it clear that, in my view— and I may at some time in the future be empowered to influence Government policy—I think it has no importance whatever in relation to our industrial development and it represents a completely wrong approach to the problems of Irish industry as they exist to-day.

How wrong can a man be? The Taoiseach bitterly opposed the Bill at that time and now, in the Seanad, Fianna Fáil are claiming full credit for the industries which were established under it. Yet here it is in black and white that the Taoiseach opposed the Bill that gave the concessions which made it possible for those industrialists to come here from abroad with their money.

We all know that at the time of the 1932 Control of Manufactures Act Fianna Fáil wanted no one. They wanted us to be a little isle in the middle of the Atlantic. They told us that if every ship were to go to the bottom of the sea we would be all right, that we could do without England and the rest of the world. They made it impossible for anyone to come here from abroad with foreign capital. We believe it is better to have such people coming here and setting up industries giving employment to Irish boys and girls at home than that they should have to go to London, Birmingham, Liverpool or any other part of the world. We are completely in favour of that now, and we were then. It was the inter-Party Government that introduced the Bill for which Fianna Fáil are claiming credit today. Unfortunately they are getting much of the credit because they have three newspapers, the radio and television, to put across their side of the story at all times.

The Fianna Fáil Party went around the country putting up posters at every graveyard and on every hoarding saying that borrowing money would make the country bankrupt, that it was a wrong approach and we were even told, to use the Taoiseach's words, that the provisions of the Bill were "likely to be far more effective in retarding industrial development than in helping it." They have changed completely over the past few years and they now know and value the work that was done under those schemes.

The Industrial Development Authority Bill was introduced in 1949. The Taoiseach voiced his aggressive opposition to it in these terms:

I want it understood that my opposition and the opposition of Fianna Fáil to the whole idea in this Bill is fundamental and that at the earliest possible occasion we will terminate it.

They have not terminated it yet. They adopted it, as they adopted other schemes introduced by us.

It has been pointed out that despite the promise of 100,000 new jobs there are almost 51,000 fewer people employed to-day than there were six or seven years ago. I shall give the figure for 1956. Some one always asks what about 1956, because 1956 is always looked upon as a very bad year? There were 1,163,000 people gainfully occupied in 1956. In 1960, that figure had dropped to 1,112,000, that is, a decline of 51,000. That is the year that Fianna Fáil like us to take. We were told during the election that 1960 was the country's best year. The Minister has the figures. I should like him to refute them if he can. Instead of more people being put to work, there are fewer in industry, fewer in agriculture, fewer employed on the roads, fewer employed by the county councils. That is especially true, and it is caused principally by the discontinuance of the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

Before the elections, away back in 1957, Fianna Fáil said they were to be judged on what they would do in relation to emigration, if they were returned to power. They published a pamphlet headed "Facts for Voters". In that pamphlet, they said:

The present state of emigration is the most serious problem now facing the nation. The recent census return has shown that the situation must be righted quickly if disaster is to be avoided. The full employment proposals recently announced by Fianna Fáil show how the Party intends to deal with the problem of emigration by providing work for our own people. The Fianna Fáil plan proposes an increase over the years for five years in the number of new jobs by 1000,000.

Instead of ending emigration, 215,000 people were driven out of the country in those same five years, due to Fianna Fáil policy and, as I have already said, there are 51,000 fewer people employed in 1960 as compared with 1955.

When the Germans were running out of East Berlin to West Berlin at the rate of 1,000 per week, that exodus rated bannerlines throughout the length and breadth of the world. If we take an average over the five years, we find that 43,000 people left the country annually at the rate of 800 per week. In face of that, we have Fianna Fáil speakers telling us that everything in the garden is lovely. We have Fianna Fáil Ministers making after-dinner speeches at public engagements, and some of them are just Party political meetings. The Ministers are like film stars. At these dinners they tell us all about the great little country we have. Every Irishman and woman would like to see our own people working at home for decent wages. Any responsible Government would face up to the situation and tell the people the truth. They would admit that their policy has not been a success; they would promise to change it and to do their best to give employment. But they do not tell the people that, even thought they have their papers, and the wireless, and television. No—they say the people were never better off.

Recently a Fianna Fáil councillor in Westmeath mentioned a townland where there were 46 people on the register ten years ago. The last voter died a month ago. There is not one voter in that townland now. In Westmeath in 1926, we had a population of 57,818 people; in 1936, the population was 54,706. It remained at that figure up to 1956; it was 54,122 in that year. Then we had the golden reign of Fianna Fáil. In 1961, the population was 52,778. That is no proud achievement for any Government. It was Goldsmith who said:

"Ill fares the land, to hastening ills a prey,"

where Governments impose more burdens, increased taxation "and men decay". Governments may flourish or may fade, but people can unmake them just as people made them, and——

"A bold peasantry, their country's pride,

When once destroyed can never be supplied."

As Senator Fitzpatrick has stated, going through the country today, one sees doors closed and houses locked up. The people have emigrated. Some of them have written home to auctioneers instructing them to sell out the little homes. Nobody likes to leave his own little home or his own parish and go abroad to a strange land; but there is no living for these people on the land of Ireland today. It would be much better if the Government faced up to their responsibilities and told the people the truth. One of the grave failures of the Government is their inability to realise that a declining population means a reduced home market for the products of both agriculture and industry. What is the use in talking about increased production when the most important market we have is shrinking daily? The Government's complacency in face of a rapidly declining population is alarming. It shows how completely out of touch they are with the facts of the situation.

Fianna Fáil claim credit for a reduction in the number of unemployed. That reduction was purchased at a dear price. It is an empty boast to claim they purchased a reduction in the number of unemployed by exporting 215,000 of our people in the past five years. These were the cream of the country. What is left are those under 15 or 16 and the older people. If we want to hold our own in the future, we must keep the cream of our people at home. It seems to be the Government's intention to create two social strata in the country—the well-off and the poor. Admittedly, there is prosperity in the cities and towns because there are industries in these places. In rural Ireland, the majority of the people are worse off than they were four or five years ago.

The policy of the Government of giving increases of £10 to £20 per week to High Court and Supreme Court judges is completely wrong. Their policy is to give the man at the top of the ladder £10, £12, £20 a week and to give the man on the bottom rung of the ladder 5/-, 7/6d. or 10/- per week. The man at the bottom of the ladder requires the increase more than the man at the top. The Government's policy in that respect is wrong.

Another breach of faith by the Government with the people is in regard to the Civil Service. We clearly recall the popular reaction to the statement by the Minister for Finance a few years ago that he would carry out a survey which would result in greater economy in the Civil Service; that it was the intention of the Government to weed out any surplus personnel and that the examination would result in more efficient administration with fewer personnel. How has the Minister weeded them out? What is the position in regard to the promise made in 1957? The Minister will have to admit that he has failed miserably in reducing the number of civil servants. He has not weeded them out. According to the Book of Estimates, there are 483 additional permanent civil servants and an increased cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 as compared with last year. What is the explanation for the fact that the number of permanent civil servants has increased by 483 and the number of temporary civil servants by 247—a total of 730?

I should like to know what the Minister has to say now about the proud boast he made in 1957 that he was determined to see that the numbers and the cost of the Civil Service were reduced. How has he kept that promise? He has kept it as Fianna Fáil have kept the majority of their promises, by doing exactly the opposite. Instead of weeding out surplus personnel and reducing the cost to the taxpayer, he has increased the number of civil servants by 730 and the cost to the taxpayer by £2,750,000. So much for that promise. It is not to be wondered at. It is just one to be added to the long list of promises broken by the Government.

I have already referred to the fact that the subsidy payable on the export of beef is to be abolished on 1st April. That is a retrograde step which may have far-reaching consequences. This country lives by its export trade. Eighty per cent. of the increase in our exports in the first nine months of 1961 was attributable to agriculture.

I want to refer briefly to our marketing system, which, unfortunately, is antediluvian, hundreds of years out of date. For that reason, everybody on this side of the House gave the Minister credit and was delighted when, in 1957, he announced that he was setting aside the sum of £230,000 towards the establishment of proper marketing boards. What has been done in the past four years? Where are the boards that were to be set up? A question was asked in the Dáil about a month ago as to why out of that £230,000 only £23,000 had been spent. Nobody can claim that that is progressive policy or that the Government are doing their part to find markets.

According to the Book of Estimates, we are spending nearly £750,000 on embassies. Even though we are a small nation, it is right and necessary that we should hold our head high and hold our own in every country but I should like to know if we are getting value for the money that is spent. I believe we are not. In each Irish embassy or consulate, there should be a graduate of agriculture or a salesman having a knowledge of agriculture. In the modern world, aggressive salesmanship is required to secure the markets needed for the progress we should like to see. Farmers could increase production in the morning, if they had a market for that increased production. Unfortunately, it has been the experience of farmers that the moment they increased production of cattle, sheep, pigs, wheat or any other commodity, the bottom fell out of the market and the only time that it was profitable to increase production was a time of scarcity. It is completely wrong that that should be the case but it arises from the fact that our marketing system is completely outdated and outmoded.

Irish people are scattered throughout the world. If we had good salesmen in our embassies abroad, they could bring to the attention of Irish people in the different countries the fact that we had agricultural produce for sale and that the extra money was needed at home and could organise these people to buy more from us than they are buying, in the knowledge that they would be helping their own brothers and sisters at home. Our ambassadors would be better employed in that way than by apeing some of the bigger countries by having big functions and wining and dining. That might be all right for other countries but does not get us anywhere.

We should have our own ships to take our produce to the British or any other market and not be dependent on British Railways or any other company. We should have an air ferry service to London, which has a population of 6,000,000 and is one of the best markets in the world.

I want to mention health schemes. The Minister stated in the Dáil that he was prepared to quote figures to show that the health rate did not increase by more than 2/6d. or 3/- since 1953. Senator Fitzpatrick has spoken for Cavan and Monaghan and I should like to say that in Westmeath, the health rate is one of the most crushing burdens on the ratepayers. In 1953, it cost 2/11¼d. and at present it is costing 9/6d. in the rates. Rather than an increase of 2/-, there is an increase of 6/6d. The same applies in the majority of counties.

The year 1962 is a year heavy with destiny for the Irish people. Political decisions may be taken this year that will alter the fate and the character of our nation for years to come. I refer to the question of our entering the European Economic Community. The Government should have published a White Paper giving full information to the farmers in regard to the economic implications of our entry into the EEC and the effects on farmers, if we are accepted, as I hope we will be. Senator McGlinchey spoke to-day about destructive speeches being made by certain people. It would be no harm if he were to mention that matter at some of the meetings of the Fianna Fáil Party. It is a well known fact that some of the most destructive speeches were made by our own Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this

Deputy Sheridan has destroyed you anyway.

Comment on this

I am quite happy and content where I am.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We are not.

Comment on this

Speeches were made by the Minister for External Affairs where he insulted some of our friends and tried to give succour to some of our enemies at the United Nations. It is a well known fact that the Belgians and French are anything but favourable to our admittance to the Common Market.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not be silly.

Comment on this

Another article of creed.

Comment on this

We never claimed that if every ship were sent to the bottom of the sea we could do without the rest of the world. We were prepared to co-operate with the rest of Europe in the interests of our people. It is an important question because if we are accepted the Sinn Féin protection policy and tariffs must be eliminated. Free Trade must be the order of the day and we shall definitely cease to be as independent as we are at present. Undoubtedly, we shall have a voice in the deliberations but ours will be a small voice. There are many people throughout the length and breadth of Ireland who are asking the question asked on Telefís Éireann by a man who interviewed the Taoiseach when he was going abroad: "Where is the Minister for Agriculture?" Everybody is asking that question. If we are an agricultural country, if the Government had agriculture at heart, why was the Minister for Agriculture not brought over to Brussels?

Comment on this

The Senator may not debate this question of the Common Market.

Comment on this

He is not debating it.

Comment on this

I was talking about Government policy and Ministers are paid out of this particular Vote. We all agree with increased production. We would all like to see it, but we should remember that all the throaty exhortations in the world will not prepare us to play our full part in the future if an inefficient Government and an inefficient Minister for Agriculture inefficiently administer wrongly conceived policy. That is what is happening in this country. Valuable years have been lost. The people should have been prepared by the Government for the task that lies ahead. Grave matters will require negotiation on behalf of the Irish people in the years ahead and I think it is a pity that we shall not have men of the calibre and ability of Deputy James Dillon who negotiated the cattle trade agreement of 1948 which, as the Taoiseach himself admitted when speaking on 7th March this year, brought prosperity to the farmers of Ireland in the period from 1948 to 1953. There is no doubt in the world that enterprise, initiative and leadership will be needed in the years ahead. We want people to deal with agriculture and I think it is unfortunate that it has been handled in the way it has been handled over the past few years.

I think it was Patrick Pearse who said—and it is undoubtedly true in our own day—that Ireland has excommunicated some of those who have served her best and canonised some of those who have served her worst. That is very true if you look back over the past 20 or 30 years. It would be much better if the people of Ireland today would take a lesson from what happened in Germany after the last war, pulled their weight and instead of saying "What do I get out of the country?" said "What can I do?" To succeed in the future and meet the challenge that faces us, I accept Pearse's definition: "a true Irishman or Irish woman is one who specifically or virtually recognises this Irish nation as an identity and being part of it owes and gives it service."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Deo gratias.

Comment on this

Before I come to the general policy of the Government as referred to in the Bill, I should like to say a couple of words on a matter which, strictly speaking, does not relate to the Bill but which was raised by Senators Stanford and McAuliffe. I hope I will not be out of order but I certainly do not wish to say much on it: the question of university scholarships. I would heartily agree with what they said. I feel that when a local authority is considering the question of university scholarships and arranges its schemes for them, there should be no provision whatever regarding the university at which the scholarships are held. The matter should be left quite simply. If someone succeeds in winning a scholarship it should be left to him or to her to decide where he or she wants to go. Even in Northern Ireland, which is not always renowned for its broad views on matters of this kind, several local authorities do, in fact, include provision in their schemes whereby scholarships can be held in any university in Ireland and I would be sorry to think that any of our local authorities would not be as broadminded as they are.

I would not agree with one or two Senators who have poured scorn on the idea of dealing with the Bill in a political manner. The Bill deals with Government policy generally is an entirely political matter.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I cannot see any objection to dealing with a matter of this kind which is an intensely political one and on a basis of Party politics, but that is different from dealing with it in an entirely destructive manner. I was interested listening earlier on to Senator McGuire's speech in which he appealed to Senators in general to deal with the Bill in a constructive way. I do not know whether he felt it would have any results. I was a little bit dubious myself, I am sorry to say. Later we had a speech from Senator Fitzpatrick and rarely if ever have I heard a more destructive speech. Then we had a speech from Senator L'Estrange and, of course, it became instantly clear that Senator Fitzpatrick's record had gone by the board. Listening to Senator L'Estrange I felt one might borrow a phrase from Winston Churchill and say: never in all human history has any one man taken so long to say so little.

Comment on this

I will not ask the Senator to quote his actual words. That was about the air force—something to the effect that never had so much been owed by so many to so few.

Comment on this

I am not attempting, like Senator L'Estrange, to misquote. I was quite honestly borrowing a phrase and applying it to the matter in hand.

Comment on this

Where was I misquoting?

Comment on this

It is a matter to which I intend to come.

We had all the paraphrases and the round phrases which sound so well and mean so little that this Book of Estimates is the largest there ever has been in the history of the State, as if that had not been true of almost every Book of Estimates over the past 30 years. We have had a string of utterly meaningless phrases of that kind. I could not attempt even if I wished to, to follow Senator L'Estrange into the highways and byways of modern and not so modern Irish history and the statements or alleged statements made by people in 1921 and 1927. No one is interested in what people said in 1921 or 1927. I am convinced that the public has no interest in what happened 30 years ago.

A couple of matters were dealt with by Senator L'Estrange which, in the interests of accuracy, ought to be cleared up in the record. There were, for example, a couple of alleged quotations attributed to the Taoiseach. The first one has appeared many times in propaganda issued by Fine Gael. I have heard it in speeches and seen it in leaflets. The first time I saw it in a leaflet, I thought to myself that I should check it. It was about the people having to spare 6/8d. instead of 5/4d., or whatever it was, to give to the Government. The only trouble with it was that six words were left out of the sentence—not another sentence but the same sentence. I cannot remember the exact words—I have not got the quotation with me—but what it amounted to was that it started off by saying that if the people wanted more Government services, then they must be taught to give 6/8d. instead of 5/4d. and so forth. Then, of course, it becomes a completely different statement and is almost a truism, that if the people want the Government to spend more, they must expect higher taxes. That is a perfectly reasonable statement with which Senator L'Estrange would have to agree. I recommend Senator L'Estrange the next time to look up the original report and find the six words.

Comment on this

Give me the six words now.

Comment on this

I was giving them when the Senator left the House.

Comment on this

The Senator said he could not remember them when I was going out.

Comment on this

The quotation, in effect, is that if the people want more Government services, they must expect to pay higher taxes which is an eminently reasonable statement and I recommend that Senator L'Estrange check it before he uses it again.

Comment on this

He will not.

Comment on this

It is not in it to check it.

Comment on this

Did the Senator not read it out for Senator L'Estrange?

Comment on this

He is only giving it from memory.

Comment on this

I checked it carefully when I first saw it. The second statement attributed to the Taoiseach was that Fianna Fáil said they would not increase the Estimates. Fianna Fáil never said anything of the kind. What the Taoiseach has always stated, and which there again can be quoted as a truism, was that if the national income increases, it then becomes possible either to give a remission in taxes or increased Government services. That is a point that we in Fianna Fáil have always made, that one must attempt to increase the national income and alongside that, give either a remission of taxation or increased services, or both.

The only other thing I wish to refer to from Senator L'Estrange's speech is this question which he has so carefully evaded about the price of cattle in 1956 and now. I asked him to quote the price of cattle when he was quoting from the Statistical Abstract and of course he did not. I am not blaming Deputy Dillon for the price of cattle in 1956; I am not suggesting he had any control over it. This is a matter of the export market. We cannot control it and Deputy Dillon could not. If we are to have comparisons of prices, then it may be said that the price of cattle in 1956 was far below what it is now. There is a very big difference and the price in 1962 is more favourable than it was in 1956. That is not really a matter about which one wants to boast, although it is fair to say that the guaranteed payments made last year amounting to over £5,000,000 had a lot to do with it. If Senator L'Estrange wants to quote figures, it is well to quote ones which do not suit him as well as those that do.

Comment on this

Let us have the 1956 statistics.

Comment on this

I think Senator L'Estrange is as well aware as anyone in this House that the price of cattle in March, 1962, is far and away higher than it was when Deputy Dillon went out of office in 1957.

Comment on this

You must take an average.

Comment on this

I think we can be clear on it and I do not think it requires quotations from the Statistical Abstract. One thing that is clear about the present economic position is that it is better now than it has been for many years. We are not suggesting that everything is perfect— certainly not. We are not suggesting that many things could not still be done. We are not suggesting that with regard to farmers great improvements could not be effected. There is no point in producing distorted and exaggerated figures to spread about an atmosphere of gloom and despondency. There is no point in that at all, because these gloomy pictures are totally unjustified. As regards the present position, as people might not be prepared to accept figures I might give and might suggest that I might have taken the wrong ones, or that I distorted them, I just jotted down one or two points made by Senator O'Brien yesterday.

He mentioned that last year the national income went up by five per cent; that industrial output went up by nine per cent.; that emigration last year for the first time in a long time just about balanced the natural increase in population and that therefore we can say for the moment that the population is stable. He stated that, in the balance of payments, there was a deficit of perhaps £5,000,000 but that that was certainly more than offset by the imports of capital. This is a picture which on the whole one must regard as favourable. It may be that in a year or two, other factors may intervene to change that picture somewhat, but we have to look at the picture as it is at the moment and it does not in any way justify the gloomy forebodings and statements we heard in this debate.

As regards the position of farmers, we have heard an enormous amount about them. We have heard about the flight from the land. Senator Fitzpatrick seemed to think one of the greatest insults he could fling at the Minister was that he had stated that the flight from the land existed in many other lands. That is perfectly true. We are not saying that to suggest it absolves the Government from dealing with the position. The fact remains that in every country in Europe and in the United States and Canada, there is the same problem, that there is a constant flight from the land to the cities, and in our case abroad as well.

What are the reasons for the flight from the land? I suppose it is fair to say, speaking very generally, they are the same in every country. They result from the general conditions, the standard of living and the standard of amenities on the land which are not as good as in the cities. That is the basic reason. People want the same standard of life that they see enjoyed by others in the larger cities. The only way in the long run that one can deal with that position is to try to level up the standard of living to that in the towns. That is what the Government are trying to do.

It may be said that the Government are not doing enough, but we should be clear on this—in March, 1957, the last inter-Party Government left office and Deputy Dillon ceased to be Minister for Agriculture. One assumes that at that time members of Fine Gael particularly were happy that everything that should be done for the farmers was being done for them, and that what could be planned was being planned. The fact remains that in this present financial year double the amount is being spent on various aids to farmers as in the last year of Deputy Dillon. If Deputy Dillon was doing well we are doing twice as well. It may be suggested that we should spend even more than the £35,000,000 being spent this year. That is an arguable point, but it is not a point that comes well from people who were quite happy when only £17,000,000 was being spent. This money is going basically for two purposes—to increase the prices paid to farmers for their produce and to reduce the cost of producing farm produce.

There is only one other point I wish to make and I hope I will not seem to be destructive in my turn in doing so, that it is only fair to make a short comparison between the present position and the beginning of 1957. At that time there were about 95,000 or 96,000 people out of work. The number is something like 30,000 fewer now. At that time the country was emerging from a very serious balance of payments deficit of £35,000,000, whereas, as we heard from Senator Professor O'Brien yesterday, we have the position today where the balance of payments is pretty well in balance.

Comment on this

I think he said that we were heading for another balance of payments problem.

Comment on this

I am prepared to agree that he said that because of other factors the position in the coming year may not be so favourable, but he said that in the present year we are in balance. Both industrial and agricultural production were falling in 1956-57. They are now, of course, increasing. National income itself fell between 1956 and 1957, whereas in each of the past three years there has been an increase of something like five per cent. in the national income. It was four and a half per cent. in the first year and round five per cent. in the next two. This is a rate of increase which we have never had before in this country and which compares very favourable with European countries generally. Only two or three have done better than we have.

These facts are enough to show that, although we do not suggest for a moment that matters could not be better or that things could not be improved, there is no justification whatever for the moaning and groaninge we have heard for hours in this debate. Anyone who looks at the position in that factual way must consider that things are better than they have been for a long number of years, and that there is every prospect that if present Government policy is continued they will get still better in the years to come.

Comment on this

I do not intend to make a very long speech or to be over-critical, because I realize there are problems facing the Government and I believe any criticism offered should be constructive. I hope that what I have to say will be taken as being constructive.

It has been mentioned that the bill we are confronted with of £148,000,000 is a record, but, as Senator Brosnahan pointed out, it is a record that will not stand the test of time because, like all other records, I believe it will be broken this time 12 months. At least it has beaten the record of the Budget presented 12 months ago. Maybe in many ways that is a good thing.

I was surprised to hear speakers referring to the eighth round of wage increases as being responsible for this budget of £148,000,000. I do not think that that is the case, because it must be conceded that the eighth round wage increases, which in most cases were fixed by the Labour Court, were granted to catch up with the increase in the cost of living. We have heard that as a result of shorter working hours and bigger wages we should have increased productivity. I for one feel that this phrase "increased productivity" is a hackneyed one, at least to the farming community, because not so very many years ago we had full page and half page advertisements in all our papers calling on them to grow more wheat, more oats and more barley. It will be conceded that the farmers did just that, and as a result, we found that the market is very limited for most of those commodities, especially oats, bacon, poultry, milk and butter. There are many commodities that come into that category. I do not know what is responsible for it. Is it our haphazard and inadequate marketing system, so that you can have over-production in so many items and so many ways? This is a problem that should merit the attention of any Government, because where you have over-production you have depressed prices, and it is like the story of the family "first up, best dressed". In this case it is a question of the people being first in the market who can get the best prices and those who through no fault of their own—either because of the weather or late sowing or something—come in with the bulk of the commodity find they have a commodity for sale that is not wanted.

I would impress on the Minister and the Government that if something were done to alleviate that position it would be a step in the right direction. I know that it is easy to make that suggestion and somebody can ask me what I would suggest. It is very difficult to offer a solution but I believe there must be some system whereby we can have organised marketing and not this rather haphazard system that we have at the moment.

It will be noticed that Britain has again played a rather slick trick inasmuch as she has limited our butter quota to 12,000 tons. That leaves us with a large surplus of butter on our hands. At present it does not seem there is any alternative market available and quite an amount of that butter will have to go into cold storage. When it is in cold storage it will not bring in any money. It is rather unfortunate, although I believe we have no alternative, that the 12,000 tons of butter we are exporting to Britain at the moment is being exported at a price of approximately 256/- a cwt. That butter cost 466/- a cwt., so it means it is being sold at a loss of 210/- a cwt. These are circumstances over which we have no control. If the price of butter were reduced on the home market from 4/7d., which is a luxury price, there would not be so much of it in cold storage and we would not find ourselves in the position of having to ask the British to take our butter with a ten guinea cheque put into each box. I offer that suggestion and hope the Government will do something about it. It would be appreciated if butter were to be made available at a more economic price than 4/7d. per lb.

I was glad to notice in today's paper that the Minister in the Dáil last night made a very definite promise that old age pensioners were to get sympathetic consideration in the Budget. I realise the Minister is confronted with a problem of finding the money, but I can assure him that the people would not resent a small increase in taxation if the money were devoted to alleviating the position of old age pensioners, blind pensioners and those in receipt of unemployment assistance. I am sure everybody will agree it is asking the impossible to expect old age pensioners to live on 30/- a week. A lb. of butter and a loaf costs almost 6/-, and that is one-fifth of what they get in pension. Pensioners living on their own with a non-contributory pension of 30/- a week have to pay for light and heating and so on. Such people would be on semi-starvation level were it not for the goodness of neighbours. I would appeal to the Minister to be generous in dealing with them and not deal with them in terms of 1/- or half-a-crown. He should give them a decent increase to enable their standard of living to be improved.

Comment on this

I must draw the attention of Senators to the fact that there is an understanding the Minister would get in at approximately 9.30.

Comment on this

It is not a hard understanding, but I think we on this side of the House are just about finished now.

Comment on this

Members of the Labour Party have offered. I deliberately interrupted, when this arrangement was announced without consultation with me, to say there were people offering from this side. I asked had account been taken of that and I was told yes. If Senators are offering to speak, they must be heard. After all, we have not taken up all the time this evening.

Comment on this

There was an understanding that the Minister would get in at approximately 9.30, and I did make the remark that it would not matter very much if it went a few minutes on the other side. I mention that in the hope that speakers would be as brief as possible in order to give a chance to those who have already offered.

Comment on this

I agree with Senators that the creation of this air of gloom is not for the good of the country. We all may have cause to complain under various headings. I come from a county where there is a high rate of emigration. Nevertheless, we appreciate that at least something is being done to alleviate the difficulties facing our people. In County Leitrim 75 per cent. of the money available comes from Government sources and 25 per cent. directly from the pockets of the ratepayers. Under the Health Act 99.1 per cent. of our people qualify as middle-income group patients. Of over 1,000 patients treated last year in our county hospital, over 60 per cent. received free medical attention. The Health Act must be given a chance. I do not know what the old Health Act was like, but I am sure it had its growing pains, too. Some people are advocating that health should be a national charge, but that could cut both ways.

I believe emigration is not entirely due to economic conditions, and I come from a county that has suffered severely from it. There is a good deal of psychology involved. People are prone to go for various reasons. We do not hear anything about the people coming back, and some are coming back. I must criticise the outlook of some of our public representatives who actually encourage people to get out as soon as possible before the ship sinks. Public representatives, particularly Deputies and Senators, should encourage people to avail of Government and local authority services. If they avail of them and make use of them, they will be able to make out.

I can quote the case of a farmer in the so-called poor county of Leitrim to show that people can make out. In a farm management competition a man with a 35-acre farm came second out of 25 farmers. He raised his income to £6000-odd for the year. He was second, not because he was less efficient, but because the income level had risen. That might not have sounded good to the farmers. This man told me he had a terrible time trying to convince his neighbours that that was the position. That means also that he has to feed nine in family and the only thing that he has coming is the family allowance. He is operating his farm as well as he can and availing himself of all Government services. That is happening in a county which has not got the potential of other areas. Our people must be given a lead and we should not be arguing that they should get out of the country as quickly as they can.

Comment on this

Over 20,000 have left Leitrim.

Comment on this

This is the Senator who sheds crocodile tears over the farmers, but what contribution does he make towards the economy of this country? My information is that he has a big farm in Meath or Westmeath. What is he doing to help the economy of the country?

Comment on this

I was up until 6 o'clock this morning doing something about productivity.

Comment on this

There is a quotation which occurs to me when I hear all this talk about expenditure. It is the people who make Governments and it is the people who create the services, and if a demand is made, it must be met by the Government. The quotation I have in mind is: "The Government can only give you what you give them." It is all right from the point of view of political expediency, and to make political capital, to get up here and criticise the Government, but when Senator L'Estrange made his marathon speech here today, he never once indicated what he would do for the future. We must all look to the future and work for the future. We had five glorious years here when we had a patriotic spirit abroad and why not join together behind the Government and develop our country on the eve of it joining the Common Market? Having heard the speakers here this evening referring to the Common Market I am beginning to wonder whether Fine Gael are genuine in their desire that we should join it.

Comment on this

Senator Stanford said that there were several roads to be travelled. I want to take only a few short strides along the vocational road. My concern is mainly in regard to the salaried workers. I commend the Minister on the increases in Civil Service pay, but I would ask him if he is absolutely sure he has done enough in order to give to the Civil Service the morale necessary in the tasks that lie ahead in the critical years we are now facing.

The Civil Service will have as difficult a job of adaptation as any of our manufacturers or industrialists and I would ask the Minister to ensure that all sectors of the Civil Service are kept in line with comparable outside employment. If the Minister is to maintain a proper morale among civil servants, it will be necessary for him to institute a fact-finding body which would have the confidence of the Minister and his advisers and of the responsible associations of the Civil Service and which would be able to report to both bodies on this question of comparability of employment within and without the Civil Service.

Unless this is done, there will be very grave danger—in fact, the danger exists—that we will lose staff from the Civil Service, staff we can ill afford, to private industry. There will also be a failure to recruit sufficient people to the Service of the calibre required. I would urge this point especially on the Minister.

The second and final point is in respect of the question of expenditure on education. I should like it to be remembered that expenditure on education is not only social expenditure but also sound investment. Not only is expenditure on education necessary because everybody with talent has a right to be educated to the limit of that talent, but also because this expenditure is one of the best ways in which we can invest our capital. Here is investment in the great natural resources of the brain which can be educated to make up for our lack of other resources. Senator Quinlan said the grants in Britain to universities are more than twice what we give here. If maintenance grants are included, the total grants from central funds for universities in Britain are four times what they are here in proportion to the student population. Yet what does Britain think of this level of university grants? Here is what the London Times on Thursday last said:

Are the economy and public finances really in such a bad way that this is the best the Government can do for a truly vital sector of the economy.

Can we not ask with much greater force if our economy is in such a bad way that we must leave this vital sector of our economy in such a poor way when we need to develop it much more because of our undeveloped state by comparison with Britain.

Comment on this

I shall restrict myself to two points. The first is the extra grant of £1,000,000 for future development projects. I am not a gloomy Member of the House and I do not want to be associated with those who are. It seems to me that the economy is in a healthy position. It may be perfectly true there are signs of inflation, but the economy is healthy and even shows signs of buoyancy. At the same time, I look at these grants made for industrial promotion and it does seem to me that there is a good deal of foreign investment attracted to this country from Europe, America and elsewhere by our grants and by loans through the Industrial Credit Corporation. But the amount of money which comes in in this way compared with that put up by the foreign investors very often seems to be in too high a proportion. It seems to me there is a certain danger in our policy on these lines.

Certainly we have attracted a number of important and thriving industries, but I do not know quite how far we shall be able to support those industries. From my experience, the foreign investors come here and are attracted by two things: first, the comparative cheapness of our labour and secondly, by the export tax reliefs we give some of them. They are also attracted, of course, by the skill of our labour which is quite high by comparison with other countries. I do not know for how long we shall be able to keep down the cheapness of our labour, or for how long those export reliefs will be valuable to us.

It seems to me that with the eighth round increase in salaries and wages, if there are further rounds, and there may very well be, if productivity is not kept up, the cheapness of our labour will no longer attract new industrialists. We must therefore pay greater attention to labour-employer relationships and increased productivity. We must be very careful, too, about our export reliefs because they tend to be too much towards industrialists who are exporting to the United Kingdom.

At the moment, most industrialists who export are getting a certain bonus because they can get into the United Kingdom market with Imperial preference. If we enter the Common Market, Imperial preference will be of no use to us. We shall be on very competitive terms with other countries in the Common Market and possibly other countries as well. Therefore, we have to try to divert our exports, if we can, from the United Kingdom to other countries where we can export without the benefit of Imperial preference so that when the time does come when we must compete on the open market, we shall be able to do so successfully.

My second point is completely different. I hope I shall be forgiven for bringing it up again. I think it is important. It is the point mentioned by Senator Stanford yesterday about university scholarships. I mention it again because I think there has been some misunderstanding about the true position. I think the House should know the true position.

This afternoon, Senator McAuliffe spoke about university scholarships not being available to the minority from Dublin Corporation and from Dublin County Council. I think the House should know that he was not fair to Dublin County Council. Dublin County Council make grants equally available to the minority to go to Trinity College, Dublin, or for anybody to go to University College, Dublin. The terms of the scholarship scheme for Dublin Corporation should be made quite clear to this House because I think the House will agree they are most unfair.

Dublin Corporation propose to allocate a sum of £7,680 in 1962 for the provision of 48 university scholarships of £160 each. They are tenable only in University College. The candidates are placed in order of merit by the President of University College and they may take the university course only in accordance with the report of the President of University College. That seems completely unfair to the minority. I do not believe it is the wish of the House that that situation should exist. Certainly, Trinity College, Dublin, has been most fairly treated by the Government—and I speak as an ordinary graduate, not as a member of the staff. The ordinary graduates are very appreciative of that.

The House should know that there are only 13 counties and cities which encourage, by ordinary scholarship arrangements, students to go to Trinity College, Dublin. They are: Dublin County Council; Cavan; Donegal; Kerry; Kildare; Laois; Limerick City; Meath; Monaghan; Offaly; Roscommon; Westmeath, Wicklow and, under certain condition, Carlow, Leitrim, Louth, Sligo, Waterford, and Wexford. Nine or ten counties or cities in this country do not give scholarships to Trinity College, Dublin. That seems unfair and I think it should be publicised.

The graduates of Trinity College, Dublin, are active and more than willing to play their part in this country. It is only fair that the graduates of the future, who are the school-children of to-day, should equally be given their chance in all the counties and cities of Ireland which give scholarships to universities.

Comment on this

Can the Senator tell us if there was any provision about Matriculation in Irish? Does he mean to say there is a bar on a religious basis or on the basis of the Irish language?

Comment on this

Leave the matter as it is. The matter has been dealt with. I think we have gone far enough.

Comment on this

It is not a question of the Irish language at all.

Comment on this

The matter can be debated later.

Mr. Desmond rose.

Comment on this

Might I draw attention to the time and to the agreement with the Minister?

Comment on this

I intend to give every possible facility to the Minister to reply. There are just a few matters which I wish to mention. I shall omit practically all of what I intended to say. I did not think that statements as long as some we have heard would be made in this debate. We must recognise that so long as a Senator has something to say he is entitled to do so. I shall try to be brief.

In so far as some essential services are concerned, the Bill could not be considered even sufficient let alone be thought, as some people think it is, rather large. I am referring to social services such as social assistance and social welfare. Reference has already been made to that by Senator Fitzgerald. I think it was practically the only reference to it in this very lengthy debate. In my opinion, it is one of the most important points. Each of the various services referred to is important in its own way.

What could be more important than the poorer sections of the community? I have in mind disabled persons unable to work and not qualified for certain top level social benefits. A disabled person might receive 22/6d. a week social welfare assistance. Is it not about time the Government examined the position to see what is the purchasing power today of 22/6d., or of 30/- which widows and old age pensioners receive? What about all the other people in receipt of social welfare benefits? Just think of their plight.

To judge by some of the debates, one would imagine that, even as things are, we should not be doing so much because the money has to be taken off in some other direction. It is money well spent to assist the most helpless sections of the community. Give them purchasing power. We are not exporting something. In that way we are distributing the national income to a greater extent.

It is generally admitted that the national income has improved. We hear talk about buoyancy in our economy. Some people criticised our production but it is keeping in line with any increase. Not alone that, the figures will show anybody who examines them that production is keeping well in advance of the eighth round. I have the figures and could quote them but I have said I will be brief.

It is about time we thought of distributing the national income as much as possible to the more helpless sections of our community. It is not to our credit that we have not apportioned a greater part of the national income to those in need of assistance. I have not time to develop that point now but all Senators know the categories I have in mind.

The Minister should tell us the intentions of the Government. I understand they have continually under examination the Programme for Economic Expansion. Have any of the various responsible organisations been consulted in that connection— organisations such as the Congress of Irish Unions, which represents the organised workers, the farming organisations including, of course, the agricultural workers?

Agriculture is undoubtedly a vitally important industry in this country. We have talked a lot about it, and rightly so. We are all sorry to note that, gradually, employment on the land is lessening. There is much I could say on it but at this stage I cannot refer to what I intended to say. I should like to know if these bodies have been consulted. We have the Federated Union of Employers, a responsible organisation concerned with negotiations between workers and employers. All those organisations are important in the study and improvement of production so that everybody will have the better standard of living to which they are entitled. Have they been consulted, or is this something that has been drafted outside those organisations? Consultation with such bodies is very important. Their advice and experience could be most useful.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Finance (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I shall deal first with the last question put to me. The first Programme for Economic Expansion dealt with the five years ending in November 1963 and the Government some time ago did start to assemble data for a new programme but at present it seems almost a waste of time to publish anything until we find out how we stand in regard to the Common Market. I am afraid we must wait for that before we publish a new programme. That does not prevent us getting the material ready in the meantime. Also, there is a committee on industrial organisation, as Senators know, on which we have representatives of manufacturers, employers, trade unions and Government Departments. They are dealing with what they believe it will be necessary for industry to do in order to fit itself for entry into the Common Market. That, I feel, will be of some importance when we come to publish the Programme for Economic Expansion.

Senator Ross spoke about our industries going into the Common Market. We have considered this for some time back in this way. Our industries have been going into the British market and competing very successfully there against British industries. Now, going back to Euclid, things equal to the same thing are equal to each other. If British industries think they can compete in the Common Market, then so should we. We should be just as good. Looked at in that way, we should have no fear of the Common Market. We may have some failures. That cannot be helped, but on the other hand, those who succeed in competing in the Common Market will be all the more competent for that and will, I hope, be able to give us better and cheaper articles at home as a result.

I do not agree exactly with the Senator that industries are coming in here because of cheap labour. Any of those I met who started industries here always stressed the intelligence of labour and the interest that labour here took in its work. They did not claim that they were getting cheaper labour here than elsewhere: perhaps they are.

Senator Fitzgerald made a very constructive suggestion. Dealing with the disposal of butter, he suggested we were charging the consumer what is regarded as the economic price to the producer. I think everybody would agree with that if we had no export, the consumers here should pay a fair price to the farmer for his butter. That is what the home price of butter is. Some producers feel they are not getting enough and would like more. Perhaps they are entitled to it, but that is the understanding of the home price.

The Senator suggests that we could lower that price and get more butter consumed and have less for export and therefore less export subsidy. I can assure the Senator that idea has been very carefully considered more than once but it would be extremely costly. To do anything worthwhile in regard to the home price of butter, to bring it down substantially so as to have a much bigger consumption, would cost more, I fear, than we could afford. Of course, it would have to be raised by taxation and perhaps the taxation would not be any more welcome than the present price of butter.

Both Senator Fitzgerald and Senator Desmond expressed the wish that we should not forget the social welfare group in the Budget. I think I can claim that out of the five Budgets I brought in, I remembered them in four, which is fairly good. The amounts, to the Senator's mind, were small each time but I think it is better to do that, to give what we can afford each time rather than wait until next year or two years' time when we might be able to give more. As far as I am concerned, that would be my policy.

I can assure Senator Dooge that I am quite satisfied that the morale of the Civil Service is quite good. As Senators know, in most cases in this last round of wages, we made agreements with the various organisations in the Civil Service. We agreed to give them a certain amount and it was accepted. A few cases went to arbitration and I am sure they were pleased also. I think I can say that we are getting a better standard of recruits than has been the case for a few years back. Of course, we improved conditions considerably for recruits and as a result we are getting better recruits and I believe the future of the Civil Service is not in any danger.

As regards university grants referred to by the same Senator and also by Senator Quinlan and, I think, by Senator Stanford, I certainly have no time to go into the matter in detail but one cannot judge this matter very well by percentages. First, the basic amounts may not be, in all cases, a fixed amount. It may happen that we would have to raise the basic amount in one place as compared with another. I do not think you could say that for all time there will be a fixed percentage all round and there will be no difference in that percentage. It is rather intricate and I could not possibly go into it now.

There was some criticism that we did not give sufficient to enable the Colleges to give increased remuneration to their staffs. It was discussed with me and I agreed to give what would enable the Colleges to pay the same rate of increase as would be applicable to equal salaries outside in other occupations. I think that was fair enough. The Colleges may argue that the basic wage is too low, but I fear we shall have to discuss that again. For the moment, we thought we were doing what was right by enabling them to give the ordinary percentage increase.

Senator Quinlan talked about the Appropriations Committee but I think he was rather mistaken about the powers of that Committee. While it has power to cut expenditure, it has not power to increase it. I do not think that was the type of committee Senator Quinlan had in mind.

Senator L'Estrange made the same speech as I have heard for many years, with the same misleading figures and the same misquotations. I do not want to go into them fully; I shall just mention one thing. The Senator picked out certain figures for 1953. He spoke about sheep and a few other things, but he did not mention cattle and milk products which are two big items.

Comment on this

I did mention cattle.

Comment on this

If the total is taken, we find the income of the farmers in 1953 was £149.3 million and their income in 1956, just by way of contrast, was £143.5 million. Their income in 1961, calculated within £1 million of being correct, was £168 million.

Comment on this

The £ is worth only 14/2d.

Comment on this

If the Senator would listen to me as patiently as I listened to him for an hour-and-a-half tonight, he might learn something but I do not know whether he is capable of learning anything. According to statistics— we are all arguing on statistics and therefore we must accept them—the farmers have £25 million more than they had in 1956. That does not correspond with what Senator L'Estrange told us.

Senator L'Estrange wound up almost every point he made by telling us what the inter-Party Government did. If we were to believe Senator L'Estrange— I think he almost believes it himself— we could say we would hardly be alive now only for the inter-Party Government. Is it not strange that the Senator does not go down to any crossroads and say: "Give us back an inter-Party Government"? He knows he would be mobbed if he did. Not a single person in this country wants an inter-Party government. The Fine Gael Party do not want it; they would not mention it outside for the world. The Labour Party do not want it and they are quite right because they got a sickener there, I am sure. Fianna Fail do not want it. Nobody wants it and the Senator is only wasting his time telling us what the inter-Party did because he will not look for an inter-Party Government again.

Towards the end of his speech here today, Senator Fitzpatrick, when giving the health figures, said there was no public assistance included. He did not look them up properly if there is no public assistance in them because practically all expenditure in 1953 was classed as public assistance.

Comment on this

According to my information, it was under a separate heading and I had it excluded deliberately from the figures I got.

Comment on this

If the Senator left out public assistance, the figures could not be right because dispensary doctors were paid out of public assistance in 1953; hospitals, fever hospitals and practically everything else came out of public assistance. The figures are no use if the Senator excluded public assistance. However, I was attacked in the Dáil by some Fine Gael speaker—we have some unreasonable men there, too—on the ground that I did not live up to my promise when I said the 1953 Act would never cost more than 2/- in the £. I said I lived up to it and I produced the figures from Wexford to show the 1953 Act would cost not more but considerably less than 2/- because the mental hospital, which was nothing whatever to do with the 1953 Act, cost a certain amount. The increases given to dispensary doctors, nurses and all the staffs of district and county hospitals, fever hospitals, and so on, have to be paid, if there was never a 1953 Act. It was on that basis the calculation was made and I produced those figures to the Dáil.

Comment on this

Why are you going to scrap the Act?

Comment on this

Right enough. Some Senator said when the Minister was faced with this motion in the Dáil he should have said: "I will accept" or: "No; I am defending the Act as it is." However, he acted admirably because when this motion was put down in the Dáil, he said: "Let us set up a Committee to examine this." He knew that when the Fine Gael members of that Committee sat down around that table, they could not go on with this wild talk about the expenses of the Health Act. They would have to get down to real figures. When the report of this Committee appears, it will show what were the good points of the 1953 Act and the bad points. There may be bad points in it; I do not claim to be infallible as Senator L'Estrange claims for Deputy Dillon. Mistakes may have been made but they will be pointed out in a factual way but not by means of the type of criticism we have heard from some of the Fine Gael Senators in this debate.

Senator McGuire said that the State first spends and then collects, which is a very bad way of doing business. It strikes me the system is very like that of the bean a' tighe, the women of the house, who spends her money and says to the wage earner: “You will have to give me a little more this week because I spent all you gave me last week.” The following week she may say: “You can go to the picture because I got on fairly well.” She changes from week to week as the Government change from year to year. Sometimes they give back money and sometimes they take money.

Another point made by Senator McGuire was that the Estimates are published before the Budget is introduced; in other words we publish the Estimates before we know where we are with the finances. We do not exactly do that but we shall let that point go. These Estimates come in in December. It is difficult to know what the revenue will be from 1st April following that and for the ensuing 12 months. We have some idea. Some years, the Minister for Finance will say to the other Ministers: "We have a very bad year in store and you must cut your Estimates down to the bone".

Another year, he may say: "I think we are going to have a good year and we can be a bit liberal in our expenditure." When it comes to the Budget, cuts have to be made sometimes. I had to cut the food subsidies on one occasion when I was up against a situation that was handed over to me, and the boys cut a shilling off the old age pensions in the same way. That can be done to a good extent.

Comment on this

A lot of things happened since 1929.

Comment on this

So many things happened that they will never do it again. Sometimes we can bring in a Budget in which we can afford some expansion. We can do something for the social welfare people, for the farmers, and so on, but the change is made at Budget time. That is the point I want to make.

I have been attacked again on this question of the increase in the number of civil servants. I said in my first Budget I had to make a saving on the Civil Service. I had to make substantial savings because of the position that was left to me by the inter-Party Government. They gave me the favour —they gave me so many favours—of a deficit of £17 million and I had to do something about it.

Comment on this

The Minister said £7 million.

Comment on this

It was £17 million to start with. We took off the food subsidies and reduced the amount for the Civil Service by £250,000. From that on, the Civil Service went up again. The State, as I am sure all Senators are aware, is expanding in its activities all the time, and everybody wants it to expand. Everybody wants that service to expand. Everybody is looking for a telephone. The number of subscribers has increased enormously in the past few years. One of the biggest items in increase in personnel is in the Post Office in the grades responsible for installing telephones and servicing them. That is one of the biggest increases that have taken place. Indeed, we cannot keep up with the demand for telephones.

There is then PAYE. Increased personnel are required to look after that. Practically every Act that is passed—not all, but a good many— means extra staff. Take the Road Traffic Act passed last year. I mention that in particular because only a few days ago I had a request for the staff necessary to administer that Act. I have to look after all these things. Numbers are therefore going up. There is, too, an increase in staff because of shorter working hours. That is what has happened with regard to existing personnel. We had to increase the existing staff in order to give shorter hours.

Against all that there are, of course, economies. O and M has been introduced. Reports are given as to where staff can be cut or where an office can continue to function successfully without quite so many staff. I quite agree with the point made by Senator McGuire with regard to the forms issued by Government Departments. They are far too long and involved. I have come across some myself which I have noted for consideration. That is a matter that is being attended to all the time. These things are being examined to see if some change can be made.

Senator O'Brien posed certain questions. He said the net income had risen rapidly in 1961-62 and he wanted to know if net income will rise as rapidly in 1962-63. He asked about the balance of payments. I am afraid I shall have to give the Senator the answer I give to so many questions at this time of the year; we shall have to wait for the Budget.

I do not want to deal with the cost of living here. I dealt with it in some detail in the Dáil. There, I said that over the five years since 1957, the percentage was just a shade lower than it had been in the three years before 1957. That, of course, is nothing to brag about. I need not remind the House that the cost of living did go up rather rapidly under the inter-Party Government. We were able to do only a little better in our five years.

There was a good deal of assumption in relation to the flight from the land and, listening to some Senators here, one would imagine that nobody ever left the land until 1957, and that everybody has been leaving since. There is, of course, no truth whatsoever in that. Senator L'Estrange seems to have all the statistics under his control and anybody who wants them can get them from Senator L'Estrange, if he has not altered them to suit himself.

Comment on this

I guarantee none is altered. The Minister may check them all.

Comment on this

The Senator will show them to anyone who is interested. Senator Fitzpatrick might look them up. It would ease his mind to discover that things are not as bad as he thinks.

Comment on this

It was a drive through the country that convinced me.

Comment on this

Take the three years 1954, 1955 and 1956; 27,000 left the land. Since we came in, the number over the five years is 22,000. That is 22,000 in five years as against 27,000 in three years. The number that left employment other than employment on the land during the three years 1954, 1955 and 1956 was 22,000. During our five years, it was 1,000.

Comment on this

I challenge that.

Comment on this

If one adds the two together—those who went out of employment on the land, and otherwise, during the Coalition three years and those who acted similarly during our five years—one gets a total of 49,000 respectively in the three years and 24,000 in our five years. That is the flight from the land. It would be too much to hope, I suppose, that Senators will in future correct their figures.

Comment on this

It will be easy to correct those because they are wrong.

Comment on this

Reference was made to employment outside of agriculture. I think some Senators were under the impression that things were very good in 1955. So they were. There was an increase from 1953 to 1955 and the increase reached a fairly good figure at that time. Then, of course, we had the catastrophe of 1956. That did away with the improvement. However, the figure has now gone up from 153,000 around that time to 168,000. In the past few years, it has been going up very satisfactorily.

The Taoiseach's speech was referred to by a number of Senators sitting on my right. They tried to give the impression that the Taoiseach was rather insulting to the farmers. I asked Senator Fitzpatrick could he quote anything the Taoiseach said for which blame could be imputed to him. It is just no use baldly saying he was insulting. Mark you, practically every executive thought the same way; it was sort of passed round that the Taoiseach had made an insulting speech. They had not read the speech, but they accepted the rumour. It would appear now that, even though the Senators here may not accept the rumour themselves, they want everybody else to accept it. They continue to make the allegation. There is not one sentence in the Taoiseach's speech in the Dáil to which objection could be taken by any farmer, unless he was prejudiced against the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach said the NFA was a very responsible body.

Comment on this

Irresponsible.

Comment on this

But when they made this claim for £84,000,000, he thought they had departed from their responsibility. That is about the worst thing he said against them. I am quite sure that if I came into this Chamber and the only thing I said about Senator L'Estrange was that he was irresponsible, he would think I was letting him down very lightly. He might even think I was being complimentary to him. That was the worst thing the Taoiseach said against the farmers; they had become irresponsible in their demand for £84,000,000. So they had. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Half the NFA are Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael half are leading them now.

Comment on this

That is a good, healthy sign.

Comment on this

It is a good thing to have leaders.

Comment on this

So it is. There is no doubt about that. Any of them I know in my own county, I met them with a different shirt on them on another occasion.

Comment on this

Some of them have no shirts now.

Comment on this

Some of them are over there on the Minister's side of the Chamber.

Comment on this

Another figure that was played about with a good deal was the Agricultural Price Index. Taking 1953 as base 100, it is now 101.1. That is not much of an improvement, but it is a vast improvement on 1956 when it was 93.5. At the same time, output had gone up by about six per cent. so, if you multiply the three per cent. increase in prices under the Coalition Government by the increase in output, the farmers are about ten per cent. better off. I mentioned in the Dáil that those working on the land were in receipt of about £20 less per head. After all expenses had been deducted, such as rates, the cost of foodstuffs, fertilisers, and so on, the money divided amongst them would be £20 per head per year less as compared with what those employed in industry were getting and, if that £20 were covered, the farmers would be as well off, or should be as well off, as those engaged in industry. That would cost some £8,000,000 or £10,000,000: it would not cost £84,000,000. We can only hope that things will continue to improve.

The average profit from an acre of land is about £10. If you take the total number of acres and multiply it by £10, it might be all right for the man with 60, 70 or 100 acres. If, after paying all his expenses, he has £10 an acre for himself he might think that was all right and be satisfied, but it is not so easy for the small farmer with, say, ten acres. He must be helped in some way or another, but I got no suggestions from the other side of the House as to how he could be helped. I heard a lot of wild and spurious figures, misapplied figures which were given to try to create the impression that the Government were not doing anything to help the man with ten acres.

Let us see what we can do for him. First of all, he cannot live on ten acres. There is no doubt about that. We must help him, and the first thing that strikes us is to give him a bit of land. The Land Commission are doing their best for the uneconomic holders and the only thing stopping them is the availability of land. About 40 years ago, there was plenty of land to be got. Big estates were available to be taken over. When they were taken over small farmers got a holding, and their small farms were added to another man's small farm. Now those big estates are not available. There are very few of them left. The Land Commission can get some smaller estates but 100 acres do not go very far. However, the Land Commission are doing their best to help the small farmers.

The next way in which we can help them is by encouraging them to get a better income from their ten acres by more intensive farming, such as fruit growing. We do that so far as we can but it is a slow job. We are doing what we can to push fruit growing and we are helping the Sugar Company to start a potato factory and fruit factories to help the small farmer as best we can. If he had a few acres of fruit, he might get £120 or £140 an acre for it, and he has the other seven or eight acres for other purposes and he is all right. But again we cannot cover all the small farmers in a scheme like that.

The next way to help him is to get him a bit of employment. It must be admitted that we have pushed forestry as far as we can. I was Minister in charge of forestry about 30 years ago. When I took over, we were taking 2,000 acres a year and our target was 4,000. We reached that target in a few years. Forestry was taken from me and given to someone else. Now the target is 25,000 acres and there is a lot of private planting, too. The result will be that in future years we shall be exporting timber because we shall not want it all. So we are doing our best in that regard.

We are attacked by some Senators on the other side of the House for our attempt to encourage manufacurers to go into what are called the undeveloped districts. The reason we are encouraging them to go to those districts is to help the congested farmers by providing jobs for them. Again, that can help only a limited number of small farmers.

So a certain number are helped by the Land Commission, a certain number by more intensive culture, a certain number by forestry, turf cutting and other Bord na Móna activities, and a certain number by industry, but even after that, a big number of small farmers are left. I heard no suggestion from the other side of the House as to how we should help them. We are doing the best we can to push the schemes we have in mind; we are doing all we can. A few other schemes were brought in in our time such as the glasshouses scheme which helped a few dozen or a few score of farmers. The Minister for the Gaeltacht brought in Sceim na Muc. A sow can bring in perhaps £100 a year in progeny, slips, if she is well managed and the farmer is lucky. All these things help but there will be many who may not be reached for some time.

Senator Fitzpatrick said that I said in the Dáil when I was winding up that it was markets we wanted. I believe the farmers are hardworking, intelligent, and that they know their job. When I was Minister for Agriculture, I spent holidays in at least five or six European countries. I always went to the rural areas. I came across farmers in Denmark, France, Germany, Sweden, Italy and, of course, England and I found them the same as farmers everywhere. I usually had someone with me who could talk their language, and I found they were prepared to put their elbows on the gate and talk for the whole afternoon, if you would talk with them. They were competent men rather like our own, but I think farmers have a leisurely way of getting things done. Even though they have a leisurely way, they are hardworking and they know their job. I have no fear about the farmers being able to face the Common Market. Senator Fitzpatrick expressed some doubts about that but I believe they will make the grade.

I have told the House what we are doing to try to help small farmers. We are doing what we can in that direction and we are prepared to increase that help, but can any Senator help us with any further suggestion? If he can, he should do so rather than go round the country trying to make the farming community jealous of their industrial neighbours by saying: "You are badly treated and the Government should do something for you." There is no use in trying to make the farmers discontented, disheartened and jealous of their neighbours by telling them they are not well treated.

Comment on this

I had hoped that the Minister would deal with marketing.

Comment on this

In regard to marketing, suppose we could fix a price for bacon and tell the farmers that no matter how many pigs they produced, we would dispose of them at that price, there would be a big increase in pig production. The same would apply to practically anything you could name. Even at present prices you would have that increase. Maybe not in eggs but, at present prices, generally you would have that increase.

I have been criticised again both in the Dáil and here—at least, the Government have been criticised; I suppose that, perhaps, I am away from the criticism here—that I provided the money in 1957 for marketing and only £27,000 was used. It was a slow process, indeed, the whole job, but marketing boards have been set up in both milk products and bacon and the producers have their say there now and there is money provided for that. In fact, money can be got from that famous £250,000 to investigate foreign markets. I hope they will be successful in their quest for foreign markets but it is not an easy matter. There are very few countries in Europe now that are not practically self-sufficient in agriculture themselves. They might want an odd thing but not very much. It would be a different matter if we were all thrown in together in one unit, as we would be in the Common Market. Then I think there would be a market for a fair number of commodities and, I hope, an increasing market too. The Minister for Agriculture, naturally, would be able to deal with this question of markets better than I am. I am not sure how far they have got in the Milk Marketing Board, Board Bainne, or in the Bacon Marketing Board but I hope they will make some headway and dispose of those commodities.

A good many Senators thought that if we had more commercial attachés we might do better. We have been considering that but we feel — the Department of Finance I am talking about; not the Government — that many of our Ministers abroad could do that job as well as their own. After all, it is not a very onerous job. Any intelligent man could learn what there is to be learned about it. Partly in that way and partly by appointing commercial attachés—a few have been appointed—we are trying to find out what markets there are to be got in these foreign countries generally. I do not know if we can do any more at the moment.

The Common Market looks a good proposition for agriculture. The policy on agriculture is not yet agreed. They did agree on a certain policy but now, I think, they have not altogether agreed on the interpretation of that policy. So that we have not exactly got a full outline of what the policy is. I am sure we will get it soon. The principles laid down behind that agricultural policy appear to be sound and I am sure we would succeed there.

Let us go on to industry. There was a good deal of discussion here on the question of the eighth round increase of wages. Let us deal with that and the question of productivity. A Senator said he thought the word "productivity" was rather overdone, if you like. Of course, it is a way of expressing a certain idea. If wages keep pace, as it were, with productivity, then no harm can be done at all to anybody. That is the whole idea in talking about productivity, increased output, and so on. It is wrong for any Labour Senator to say that either the Taoiseach or myself or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party has ever objected to an increase in wages. That is silly talk. Is it not our object, and the object not alone of ourselves but of every Party, to give a better standard of living to everybody? If we are to achieve that object, naturally, we will welcome better wages being paid where they can be paid without doing any harm to anybody.

There is no doubt, as the Taoiseach pointed out, that the rounds of wage increases which came before this last round were all properly timed and, therefore, did no harm to anybody because the profit was there to absorb the wages. The eighth round appears to have been rather premature and the evidence of that is that there is a tendency towards an increase in prices, which would be the symptom always if an increase in wages were given prematurely. I should not say wages alone —any loosening up of money, an increase of wages, salaries, dividends—it does not matter; it is all the same—the loosening up of money of any kind, if it is not matched by increased productivity, does lead to a certain amount of danger in the economic sphere.

As I say, it is very difficult to know but suppose it has happened that this round came too soon, that it was premature, then there is more money there than can be absorbed. That is the point. Part of it can go to savings—not much of our money goes to savings as a rule. If not, it will go to higher prices and there is a tendency to higher prices. It may not develop any more. If there is no increase in output, then the money will be spent on imports and if more money is being spent on increased imports and if that is combined with increasing costs, exports may go down, and that is the terrible danger. You will reach a position then when you will have lower exports and higher imports. The balance of trade goes wrong and the banks find difficulty in their transactions. There is restriction of credit followed by unemployment and the whole thing is worse than if the increase had never been given.

That is the full story of the worst picture you could draw of the matter. I do not think it will happen in this case because I think it is quite possible for productivity to come up to the increased wages. It is probably not far behind it. It is quite possible for it to come up and I think there is a desire on both the employers' side and the employees' side to see that is done and I am sure it will work out all right in that case.

I do not think I need say any more about it at the moment as it is getting late but I am just giving my version of what might happen if the round of wages came before the productivity was there to meet it.

The unemployment that would come after the restriction of credit will, I think, be avoided. I do not think we are going to reach that stage. I think that will be avoided. Senator Murphy said that the employers and the employees are inclined to discuss this matter. It is certain that neither side can lose by discussing the matter and if there is an attempt made to keep the advancing increase in national income in line with advancing wages—or put it vice versa if you like—then no harm can be done.

Above all, an increase in prices should be avoided because we have the experience that once prices increase they never go down again; you never get them down again. Higher prices, as Senators know, mean a higher cost of living, which makes workers discontented again and makes it awkward for a Minister for Finance because everybody he is dealing with must get an increase in pay and he, therefore, puts on taxation. That, again, adds to the spiral. So, the whole thing is a vicious circle, as it were.

I have only a word or two to say about the Dublin Corporation scholarships. I find that Senator Stanford raised that matter on a previous occasion and the Minister for Education pointed out, which is true, that he has no control over local authorities in the conditions they attach to their scholarships. However, I will bring this matter again to the attention of the Minister to see if he can do anything by persuasion, as he said. Perhaps, he can do something by persuasion. I will bring it to his attention again to see if he can. It is open to the Senator also, if he has a friend in the Dublin Corporation, to ask him to see if he can do anything about it, which may be the best way to approach it.

One other point that I want to mention is that Senator George O'Brien said that he thought our taxation was now going out of line with national income. No; not up to the present time. I cannot speak for the coming year. But, up to the present time, it has remained remarkably in line, indeed. From 1956-57 down to the Estimates for this year—that is the non-capital services, of course—they have only risen from £26.6 million to £26.8 million. That is only .2 per cent. of the national income so our taxation, therefore, may be taken as kept in line.

The last point I want to make about taxation is that there is always, I am afraid, a certain amount of confusion about what we mean by taxation. I may have said—I do not know; I do not think so because I do not think I was interested in the subject when I was in Opposition—that taxation was going too high. But do we mean the level of the tax or do we mean the amount that comes in by way of revenue? It is the level of tax, naturally, that we have in mind because every Senator must see that in a changing world with increasing costs, if a bit more is to be got each year that is a good thing. Let us say I can get 2s. on a glass of whiskey and people drink a little more, that is a net increase in revenue and so long as I have not put another penny on the glass of whiskey we have not got increased taxation.

On that basis, we have lowered taxation in the past five years. In other words, if I had made no change whatever in taxation from the 1957 Budget up the whole way to last year, if income tax was what it was and the tobacco tax the same, I would be getting £5 million more now than I am actually getting. I have actually lowered taxation but the amount coming in is much more than it was. That is the point I want to make. When we talk of increased taxation, what we mean is putting a higher tax on the article, whatever it may be, but we do not mean getting more yield from a particular tax which is already there.

I hope I have dealt with any questions which have been raised. If not, I will be glad to answer any questions if I can.

Comment on this