Leinster House Building Work. - Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1962— Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 183–384 of 384. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1962 ›
I appreciate that but an extra half-hour in the morning is equivalent to one hour up to the time buses cease to run. We have the buses in Dublin until 11.30 p.m. In Cork, it is 11.15. In Cork and Dublin, workers may have to work until 12 midnight and in most cases they may lose the bus. The section specifies 12.30 a.m. and that means they would not get away. In the big industrial centres like Dublin and Cork, workers have to travel a long distance. This is a real hardship and -I think the Minister should re-examine the matter. Even 12 o'clock midnight would certainly be late. I do not think the catering trade is so pushed in regard to serving the public that we need to give 12.30 a.m. to hotels and restaurants. Not alone do certain sections of the public require 12.30 a.m. but 3 o'clock in the morning. There are sections of the public who would be available for service even at those hours, just as there are people available for service at 12.30 a.m.
The worker can probably look for better conditions but, as I said on earlier amendments, you cannot compensate for hardship. You have your trade union and you can get yourself looked after for this undue hardship you are undergoing but that is not the approach to it. You cannot compensate somebody at that time if he thinks his conditions should be such that he should not have to continue work up to that hour. There are industries in which workers have to work, not only until 12.30 a.m. but, perhaps, 6 a.m. but they do not go to work until 10 or 11 p.m. They are all right because they work through the difficult period and can get a bus in the morning but not so the people who begin work at 4 or 5 o'clock in the evening. I suggest that it would be worth the Minister's while to re-examine the position.
Comment on this
This will not result in any hardship at all to the workers in the catering trade because in a number of hotels and restaurants at the moment, the negotiated agreements between the trade unions and the management are such that they do not even avail of what is there. Some hotels and restaurants will not serve up to 12 o'clock, which is available to them, because of the agreement between the unions and the management. This will not involve any additional hours of work on any member of these unions, unless they voluntarily agree to it.
Comment on this
Is it not possible that the bona fide houses of the past can now add on a restaurant section and by that means come back into business again and continue until 12.30 a.m. ?
Comment on this
There is a provision whereby any licensed premises can have a restaurant portion and for that restaurant portion, they can get a limited restaurant certificate. The portion must be separate from the licensed portion of the premises. It must be a bona fide restaurant and there can be no bar in that portion.
Comment on this
Can the drink not be brought across from the main bar ?
Comment on this
In subsection (b) (ii) of Section 9, a substantial meal is described as a meal which is not normally served in the premises. You make provision there——
Comment on this
This half an hour can be availed of only in a premises which is a bona fide restaurant. The drink can be served only with the meal as part of the meal.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In subsection (1), paragraph (b), line 54, to delete "ten" and substitute "nine".
Comment on this
Perhaps I can help the Senator here. This amendment seems to me to be designed to have the same effect in regard to the serving of a drink with a meal in clubs on Sunday nights. I think it is the same principle as is in the other amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In line 41, to delete "fifteen" and substitute "twelve".
This is designed to cut down some of the rather surreptitious increases that have taken place. This is to ensure that not more than 12 authorisations or approximately one per month will be made. I do not think there is any point in pressing the amendment at this stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In subsection (1), pages 5 and 6, to delete paragraph (b) (ii).
This is mainly for the purpose of getting some information and the Minister has dealt with it in the separate provision in regard to restaurants and public houses.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 8, to delete subsection (9).
This is mainly for the purpose of clarification. Subsection (9) of Section 11 says:
The provisions of the Licensing Acts requiring an offence to be endorsed on a licence shall not apply to an offence committed in respect of an occasional licence.
In regard to the words "shall not", does that still leave discretion to the court to impose an endorsement, if it sees fit ?
Comment on this
In that case, I fail to see why there should be any differentiation between an offence committed under an occasional licence and an offence committed in the ordinary course of business.
Comment on this
The business of a compulsory endorsement is rather Draconian and I think the Dáil and the Seanad would only agree to taking away the discretion of the courts in a matter of this sort because they would want to strengthen the hand of the Executive in enforcing the law. It is not something we would like on its own merits. What is involved here is this: if the publican has an occasional licence which allows him to operate at an unlicensed dance hall or at a race meeting or somewhere other than his own premises and an offence is committed, it would be harsh and unreasonable that that offence should be endorsed on his licence.
Comment on this
My query was : has the justice still got the power to endorse it ?
Comment on this
He has not. He may not endorse it on the licence. I think it only fair that to have an endorsement of the licence the offence should be committed on the premises to which the licence is attached. An occasional licence is very often in operation at such places as race meetings where an infringement is not as serious as if it happened on the premises itself and where the difficulty of supervision is very considerably increased on the publican. It would be unnecessarily harsh to have an endorsement arising out of an offence which took place away from the publican's premises. We are not making any change here. We are simply re-enacting what is in the law at present.
Comment on this
It does seem rather harsh in one case to have a compulsory endorsement for an offence committed between, say, 11.10 and 11.15 p.m. and in another case to have a most flagrant violation in the case of an occasional licence which would not carry an endorsement, no matter how many times it happened.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain what is meant by paragraph (b) which reads:
... it is held elsewhere than in the open air or in a tent, marquee or other such structure...
Comment on this
Is the wording very loose for such an important matter ? "... or other such structure"—who will judge whether the "other such structure" is a marquee or a tent ? What is meant by that ?
Comment on this
To a temporary building of some description, say, for a race meeting. That is the way I read it.
Comment on this
It is to obviate the situation where an occasional licence could be obtained for a dance at a crossroads, in a marquee or a tent.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In subsection (1), page 9, to delete paragraph (c), lines 1 to 4 inclusive.
Comment on this
Provision is made in this section for exemption orders for special occasions such as festivals, private functions, and so on. On those occasions, a bar is allowed for dances under certain circumstances. Paragraph (c) reads:
the occasion of a dance that is held in such a ballroom on a day that, in the opinion of the Court, is a day of special festivity generally or in the locality in which the premises are situate.
In other words, without a meal. I agree in regard to paragraph (b) that where there is provision for a meal, there is greater likelihood of having a well-ordered dance hall than could be envisaged under (c). From my experience of seeing some local dance halls where there is no provision for meals but where a bar is pushed into some corner or other, I am not in favour of that being encouraged. Above all, on such special occasions, provision is made in other sections of the code for the granting of extended licences so that there are ample drinking facilities available in the place in which the special occasion is happening. The very least that might be expected is that those who wish to enjoy a dance should be left to enjoy it without having a bar superimposed on it. Consequently, I think paragraph (c) should be deleted.
Comment on this
That is my view, too, by and large, and I framed the Bill on the basis that as far as we can we should not have drinking at dances. The Senator will appreciate that the Bill tightens things up generally in that respect but I feel that it is reasonable to allow this exemption on six occasions during the year. Senators will readily think of the sort of gala occasions, a holiday occasion, which would be involved. It is reasonable to allow six special licences in the year, particularly when we are tightening things up and are in fact prohibiting bars in any other circumstances. We are providing that a dance hall which is not licensed can on six special festive occasions have an occasional licence. The same applies to a licensed restaurant.
Comment on this
The Minister should keep this very much under review because it is a very undesirable trend since it makes dancing very unenjoyable for many present. Six occasions during a year amount to a lot and I should like the Minister to see as far as possible that the laws relating to drunk and disorderly people at such functions are severely enforced on these occasions.
Comment on this
I understand that if this section is passed, a problem will arise in respect to certain premises in Dublin which run dances which are well organised and controlled and where at present there are facilities for the serving of drink. Now apparently a meal will have to be served costing at least 5/-. There are two such establishments in Dublin which run these dances, usually finishing at 12 midnight and usually frequented by social clubs, and I am told this section—I must confess I do not completely understand it—will mean the employees in these places will lose their jobs— that there will no longer be this sort of work for them which they now have during the winter months. These are well conducted places where everything is done in an orderly way, where there is no serving of drinks after the hour permitted. This section will mean the running of such dances will no longer be feasible since they would be required to provide a meal costing not less than 5/-. The Minister was very sympathetic about this problem in the Dáil and I am wondering if he has in the meantime arrived at any solution.
Comment on this
I am afraid not. I went into it very carefully. I should like to explain now what is involved. There are very few dancehalls which are licensed. Senators will appreciate the normal dancehall does not have a licence attached to it and that drink can be sold only if an occasional licence is procured. Those Senator Murphy has in mind are in a different category. They are dancehalls which are part of premises, the whole of which are licensed, and up to now they have been able to run the ordinary type of dance at which no meal is served, to have a bar there and to sell drink.
I have gone into this matter very carefully and I am afraid there is nothing I can do for them because, whereas I might like to, I could not possibly make an exception, make a provision that would apply to them and not to dancehalls in general. It would run counter to my proposal against selling drink in dancehalls. I have also gone into the employment matter and I am not satisfied there will be any dire consequences from that point of view. In discussions with the trade union representatives I was able to satisfy myself there will not be any unemployment of any real nature resulting from this, unemployment which would not be absorbed in surrounding premises for similar types of functions. Senators will realise that these dancehalls are in a different category from the normal commercial dancehalls because they may open for the serving of drinks up to 11.30 p.m. in the summer and 11 p.m. in the winter—the same time as applies to the ordinary public houses.
Comment on this
The ones Senator Murphy spoke about have, so really all that is involved is that we are preventing them from selling drink after the ordinary public house closing time—11 p.m. in the winter and 11.30 in the summer. As well, they will still be able to sell drink at dances where a meal is served and will have six special occasions during the year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40 :
To delete subsection (3).
There is a serious principle involved in this amendment and I would respectfully ask the Minister and the House to consider it carefully. Since 1927 it has been possible for publicans to get exemption orders enabling them to open their premises early on the mornings of fair days and market days or to serve numbers of people following any lawful trade or calling. That provision was first introduced by Section 4 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act of 1927 and it has been availed of, particularly throughout rural Ireland on mornings of fair days. In the country, it was largely availed of only on fair days, except, perhaps, in fishing villages where people fishing late at night could have a drink.
In the city of Dublin, this section was availed of by public houses serving the needs of people attending the Dublin markets and also by publicans serving dock workers. Indeed the present Bill does not disapprove of that section—it approves of the principle of that section. It does lay down that exemption orders cannot be granted to accommodate people attending public fairs or markets earlier than 5 o'clock in the morning and it provides that it shall not be availed of by publicans who want to cater for people attending a fair or market before seven o'clock in the morning. Therefore, the position is that authority is confirmed in this Act to the district courts to grant exemptions to publicans for fair day mornings from five o'clock, whereas publicans who do not avail of this section may not open until 10.30 a.m.
Provision is also made for the district court to grant exemptions to publicans catering for people who follow a lawful trade or calling from seven o'clock in the morning, whereas publicans who do not avail of it may not open until 10.30 a.m. That is all right, but there is one extraordinary subsection in Section 15 of the Bill which confirms the provisions of Section 4 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act of 1927 which I have just read. This section, which I propose to read, is subsection (3) of Section 15 which states:
A general exemption order shall not be granted in respect of premises situate in the County Borough of Dublin unless a general exemption order was in force in respect of the premises on the 19th day of April, 1962, or at any time during the two years immediately preceding that date.
That means that any publican who has not, within the past two years, obtained a special exemption order, fair day or lawful trade or calling—I use those for want of better terms— cannot now, and will never in the future be able to, obtain such an exemption order in the city of Dublin.
Let us see how that will affect some publicans. I think the Minister's idea —I do not know whether he amended this section in the Dáil or not—was to do away with these exemption orders in the city of Dublin unless a publican could establish that he was serving the needs of people attending the Dublin Market. I think that was his original idea when drafting the Bill but he gave in to pressure to continue the section so far as publicans in the dock area were concerned. Then he put in this extraordinary provision. He froze the section as of 19th April of this year. He said that unless a publican had an exemption then, or within two years, that publican will not in the future be able to get one.
As I understand it, the effect is this: there are a considerable number of public houses in Parnell Street in this city, for example: I am told there are up to 20, and only one of those public houses under this section will be entitled to an early opening licence. I think that is monstrous. It is creating a valuable vested interest. It is making fish of one and flesh of another. I do not know the name of the owner of the public house concerned but I venture to suggest to the House that the value of the public house in Parnell Street will go up by thousands of pounds as a result of this Bill if it becomes law and the value of the other houses will be reduced accordingly.
I am told that the same situation applies in North King Street, that there are a considerable number of public houses there, that three of them were in time and secured exemption orders. They will be able to continue to open at seven in the morning while the others will not. It is no argument to say that the others did not avail of the opportunity. Perhaps a man would want to sell his house and the fact that he may not open in that street beside a man who may open, will certainly be held against his premises. Or perhaps he wants to hand on his house to his son and perhaps the son is more energetic than the father but he may not open at seven. He must remain closed until 10.30 a.m. whereas his next-door neighbour may open at either five or seven, as the case may be.
The Minister, in introducing the Bill, told us that his whole or his great aim was to achieve uniformity. Here we have the case of one public house in 20 that is entitled to open for three-and-a-half hours more than all the other public houses in the street. I say that is not right; it is unjust.
Comment on this
The Senator will realise that the court made it clear that it would not give any others in that street this right.
Comment on this
The Minister is consolidating that situation in the legislation.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to delete the subsection and to allow anybody who, by law, is entitled to it to get a licence. Certain circumstances might prevail at one time : these may change. Another undesirable feature of this is that the provision has been imposed on the publicans in these areas without any notice whatever. If a section were included in the Bill saying that after 31st December, 1963 or 1964, no further exemption orders would be granted, the people in these streets would in the meantime have an opportunity of applying to the courts and if they could make a case that they were entitled to a licence, they would get it but under this section they are not entitled to it.
I urge on the House as strongly as I possibly can that this subsection is undesirable, that it is unjust and a deplorable departure from ordinary legislation. I feel that the Minister acceded to pressure and that he put in this subsection with a view to pleasing a certain few who complained to him. He should reconsider the matter and adjust it in some way that would meet the justice of the case and do justice to these publicans. I have not much hope of convincing the Minister that he should accept the amendment now, in view of the anxiety of the Government and some other people in the country to have this Bill signed by the President— perhaps tomorrow—but I make an urgent appeal to the Minister to give an assurance to the House that he will reconsider the matter and introduce amending legislation in the very near future to meet the case.
Comment on this
I support Senator Fitzpatrick in this. Realising, as I do, the particular hurry associated with the required passage of this Bill and even the abridgement of the time in which the President is to sign the Bill, I do not think there is any prospect of the Minister acceding to our proposal at this time. In support of Senator Fitzpatrick, however, in what he said in relation to uniformity, if there is to be uniformity of distribution and of practice, there should be, by the very equity of the matter, uniformity of opportunity to practise the licensed trade and to distribute or sell alcohol generally. I do not think that creating a vested interest of this kind is right. Senator Fitzpatrick may have more knowledge than I, when he said that the Minister yielded to pressure of some kind. It is quite possible that, because a judge refused to give extra licences, the Minister may feel that he is justified in taking the line that it is better to consolidate it now in the Legislature, as the matter has been consolidated, as it were, in the courts.
The Minister well knows, and we who practise and have knowledge of it well know, that circumstances change from time to time. An application that might not succeed today might well succeed in the not too distant future. Having regard to the fact that the Minister cannot, in the circumstances prevailing here at the moment, accept these proposals, I would ask from him an undertaking at least, or a promise—I will not go so far as to say an undertaking, although a breach of promise in some cases could be as disastrous as a breach of an undertaking—that when the 2.30 p.m. to 3.30 p.m. opening in Waterford is being considered around Easter of next year, this matter will also be considered.
Comment on this
Might I clarify in this regard, that if circumstances so change as to warrant such consideration, it would be given. I think Senator Lindsay agrees with me—I will not ask him to agree with me— that in the present circumstances it is desirable to freeze the situation. If it becomes apparent later on, however, that circumstances have so changed that further early morning openings would be necessary or desirable, I would agree to reconsider it.
Comment on this
I appreciate the distinction the Minister has made, but I would not go so far as to agree that it is desirable to freeze the situation. I forgot to say that another judge might easily do a different thing if another case came to be considered. I do not wish the judiciary any harm or anything like that, but you never can tell.
Comment on this
I certainly do not wish to go on record as agreeing with the Minister when he suggests that it is desirable to freeze the position as it is.
Comment on this
I am convinced that nothing could be less desirable, that it is unsound, bad and should not be proceeded with.
Comment on this
What is the actual position now? Will the Minister wait until circumstances change and can he give us an idea of how circumstances might change?
Comment on this
It seems to me from studying the developments in recent years that there are sufficient of these early morning opening extensions in Dublin to cater for the reasonable needs of the persons desiring these facilities. If a situation were to come about in which it could be demonstrated that the facilities were not adequate or situated in appropriate places and that some extensions were desirable, I would certainly consider them.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister is well aware that in Parnell Street, one pub is not adequate for the markets.
Comment on this
There should be at least two in order that people who did not wish to meet could avoid one another.
Comment on this
The Parnell Street extension was not granted to facilitate the markets but for another purpose.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, it is utilised by the people at the markets.
Comment on this
We may get stranded in Parnell Street. I do not know the geography of the city very well, but perhaps there are other public houses nearer the markets, and nearer the docks, not now enjoying exemptions because they have not applied.
Comment on this
Perhaps their owners are old are not enthusiastic about business. They will be frozen under the section, but perhaps there are now public houses nearer the markets and the docks who would get licences——
Comment on this
Close by is a declaration that no man has a right to set a boundary to the march of a nation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In subsection (1), to delete from and including "the period" in lines 48 and 49 to the end of the subsection and substitute "such period before half-past twelve o'clock in the afternoon on Sundays and Saint Patrick's Day as the Court may determine".
I was quite clear in my Second Reading speech on the kind of places I have in mind in this amendment. This proposal would appear further to increase the number of opening hours on Sunday. At the risk of a belt of Senator Quinlan's crozier, or being mildly admonished by Senator Cole in this near-gathering unanimity of the Ecumenical Year—while undertaking these risks—I do not want to be described as a person who subscribes to the potted morality to which the Minister has referred.
In this amendment, I hope to cover the outlying public houses in villages where the church or the chapel, as the case may be, is one of ease and one in which there is normally an early Mass or an early service, perhaps at 10 o'clock and ending at 11 o'clock. I do not know whether mixed trading is allowed on Sunday——
Comment on this
In many cases which I have in mind, the older people who might be described as, "up the airy mountain and down the rushy glen" people, can get the other necessaries of life, as the Minister puts it. They can tie up the pony and trap and they can do anything they like on those premises, in a business or social line, except get a drink. Under this legislation, there might be abuses which I mentioned earlier such as drinks being prepared and passed out in bottles of various sizes.
In any event, the people in those remote areas should get our best consideration. We had them under discussion in regard to special services from the E.S.B. yesterday and, after all, we must have available a certain amount of current of both kinds to people in areas such as that. I know that nothing can be done about it in this Bill. It is something that could probably be kept under review for a certain length of time. These areas are outlying. They are not easily supervised. They are not the kinds of places to which people would repair on a Sunday morning in any kind of bona fide fashion.
While I am not openly advocating any breach of the law, I think that, by and large, they will probably get on all right without any great notice being taken of them. It would be a pity, once an effort is made to have the law observed, that there should be outlying places where the law is not observed and where the non-observance is not being detected.
Comment on this
I believe that legislation should be for the benefit of every section of the community. The Minister has stressed the desirability of uniformity a great deal today. I believe that if a man in any big town or city can have a drink after last Mass on Sunday, then the man in the small village or town in rural Ireland should be allowed the same facility.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald is right. In large cities and towns, last Mass does, by and large, coincide with this. In the country, they would be gone home.
Comment on this
The Minister wants uniformity. The public will not get uniformity. In fact, they will be gone home one and a half hours before the public houses open. In rural Ireland, the older generation— the men who for very many years past have had a pint, no matter what law they were under—will, in my opinion, continue to have their drink. It would be better if a little consideration were given to them, even at the risk of having the opening hour on Sunday morning reduced to an hour after last Mass, apart from the extension. Therefore, I would ask the Minister to give his most sympathetic consideration to the older section of the community in rural Ireland.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42 :
In subsection (1), line 50, after "Saint Patrick's Day" to add "provided that the afternoon opening hours are altered to twelve noon to 1.20 p.m.".
This section provides that in certain circumstances, provided a considerable number of people in the locality are not likely to be attending Divine Service, the opening on Sunday may be at 12 noon rather than at 12.30 p.m. My reading of it is that it is just another thin end of the wedge by which it will become the custom in the larger towns. We can obviously satisfy the requirement that a considerable number of people in the locality are not likely to be attending Divine Services at that period. In other words, where you have three or four Masses, you can conclude that those attending the last Mass are, according to this, not a considerable number. That means that it will be used in large towns and it will then seep down to the smaller towns and you will get this 12 o'clock opening and the Bill allows the opening to continue until 2 p.m.
If the public houses are to be allowed to open at 12 noon then, in the interests of the Minister's wonderful new-found principle of uniformity, the least that could be done is to make the time of opening uniform and restrict it to one and a half hours, the same as for other places. Therefore, I think we should write in that the opening hours shall be from 12.30 to 1.20 or 1.30 p.m., depending on whatever hours are required.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the Senator. In fact, it would have a lack of uniformity in closing hours. The Senator's proposal would result in some public houses closing at 1.20 and others at 1.50 p.m. I do not think it is really worth the Senator's while fighting me on this point.
This provision of the half hour in rural Ireland—and that is what it amounts to—is for the benefit of people who come a long way to last Mass and who want to have a drink before they go home again, maybe three, four, five or six miles. It is a reasonable facility to give to these people. I do not think you should penalise them by chopping it off at the other end. If 2 p.m. is a suitable time for closing generally, I do not think you should revert to 1.30 p.m. or 1.20 p.m. just because you are providing the facility earlier for these people.
Comment on this
I cannot see how the Minister's principle of uniformity applies here. Surely the uniformity should be the length of the opening?
Comment on this
The length is more important than the time. You have deliberately put in non-uniformity of opening hours—12 noon against 12.30. Therefore, after that, the important thing is the length of the facility provided. You are making the case that the last Mass is before 12 noon and that one of those mythical characters whom we have got cannot carry on without his drink and must have it at 12 noon. One and a half hours should be enough for him, the same as is provided everywhere else.
I feel the section as it stands will very soon lead to a two-hour recognised opening, from 12 to 2 p.m., or with the ten minutes, from 12 to 2.10 p.m. Then, the Minister abhors those breaks from 2.10 to 4 p.m. Therefore, I fear the next Bill that will come before us will mean that the Minister will wipe out this closed period because it is not fair to somebody and we shall arrive back at opening hours for Sunday from 12 noon to 10.10 p.m.
Then, in the interests of uniformity, it will be just as well to make the opening hours on Sunday the same as those on weekdays and complete the desecration of the Sabbath. If the Minister is to be logical and consistent about this wonderful system of uniformity, this is one place where it should be applied.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 43 and 44 might be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43 :
In subsection (7), page 12, line 22, to delete "ten" and substitute "twenty".
This is in relation to notice that must be given in a locality in which an extension is claimed. This is a permanent extension of what the Minister has shown now—from one and-a-half to two hours. In other words, it is an extension of one-third. Consequently, it is quite a serious matter.
Full and adequate notice should be given. It specifies here that notice must be given to the Gárda Síochána of not less than ten days. Why the rush? Is there as much rush about it as there is about this Bill which must have early signature by the President lest the weekend should not pass off properly? Why the rush for this? Why not have, in place of ten days, 20 days? Also, in the case of the notice that has to be inserted in the paper, why is the period "not less than seven days?" Why not keep for that the same amount of days—20 days? What is the hurry in pushing this local application through?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 43 and 44 deal exclusively with the notice to be given to the Garda Síochána. You could make that period of notice anything you liked but the idea of giving notice is that the Garda Síochána should be able to consider the matter and see what action they would take. Ten days for the purpose of the Garda Síochána is quite adequate and that really is all that is involved. If the ten days is adequate for the Garda Síochána, there is no need to alter it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In subsection (7), page 12, to add at the end of the subsection "and a copy of the notice was sent to all ministers of religion in the locality"
This provision of an extra half hour on Sunday mornings is tied in by an Act of the Oireachtas. Subsection (2) says:
The District Court shall not make an order under this section in respect of a period during which or part of which a considerable number of people in the locality to which the order would relate would be likely to be attending Divine Service.
Subsection (3) says:
Any person appearing to the District Court to have a bona fide interest in the matter may appear and give evidence on the hearing of an application under this section.
We may take it that the ministers of religion in the localities concerned would be concerned with this extension. Consequently I feel that in courtesy to them when the notice of intention to seek the extension of hours is put in the local press a copy should be sent to all ministers of religion in the locality.
Comment on this
I suggest that would be a new departure. Normally where the situation requires a person to be put on notice the vehicle stipulated in the various statutes is the newspaper. Notice published in the newspaper should be adequate for everybody concerned including the various ministers of religion who, as Senator Quinlan pointed out, have a direct interest in this matter. I feel sure the insertion in the newspaper would suffice. I can see a lot of difficulty in the actual administration of what is proposed by Senator Quinlan.
Comment on this
It would merely be an act of simple courtesy. Otherwise all Ministers of religion on the passing of this Bill must realise that henceforth they cannot afford to omit reading any local paper any week and that the local papers will have to be scanned to see if there is any application for an extension of the licensing laws. That is a totally wrong obligation to place on such ministers of religion when they should be extended the courtesy of getting a copy of the advertisement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46 :
In subsection (1), to delete all words from "it is shown" in line 32 down to and including "situate" in line 35.
Here we have the same provision in regard to unlicensed business. In other words if a licensed premises carries on a mixed business, perhaps the selling of newspaper, the publican must get special permission to open for three-quarters of an hour to carry on such business. We may take it that there are others in the town doing the same business, selling newspapers or whatever else shops are allowed to open for on Sunday mornings, yet we find here that these openings cannot occur at a time when a considerable number of the people in the locality would be likely to be attending Divine Service. It is the same provision as the provision in regard to opening for the sale of intoxicating liquor. I cannot see any connection between the two. I cannot see if after First Mass it is desirable that certain public houses should open——
Comment on this
The Senator seems to be mixed up. He is now talking on the following amendment, No. 46.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 46 deals with the consent of the majority of publicans in the locality.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Amendment No. 46 is still in connection with exemptions for unlicensed business on Sunday mornings. It is required that before a particular licensed premises may open to carry on unlicenced business, that is, selling newspapers or whatever else they engage in, it must be shown to the satisfaction of the court that the application has the approval of the majority of holders of such licences in respect of premises so situated. In other words all the publicans must indicate whether they are in favour of a particular publican, who has a mixed business, opening to sell newspapers. I cannot see that there is any necessity to get the consent of the other publicans for opening to carry on such legitimate business.
Comment on this
I must confess that this point had not occurred to me before. I agree with Senator Quinlan that where a man is opening his premises for non-licensed business it should not be necessary for him to have the consent of the majority of publicans in the area. You could have a little village with two flourishing publicans not doing much of a mixed business and you could have one struggling publican selling newspapers and groceries and who, in order to make some money, might find it desirable or even essential to open on a Sunday morning for mixed business. That is the type of man who would be at the mercy of the two other big men and he cannot open or get permission to open unless he has their consent.
Comment on this
Well, he does. I am sure the Minister did not intend that situation to arise. I cannot understand why the sale of ordinary commodities should be controlled by the majority of publicans in the locality.
Comment on this
The idea is that a set period would be fixed in each locality when the houses would open for unlicensed business. Somebody must decide in any locality what is the most suitable period for opening and the most logical people to settle upon are in fact the people doing the business, namely, the publicans. The idea is that the majority of publicans in any locality would agree to an opening for three-quarters of an hour after first Mass. That is what is enshrined in the Bill. There must be some group of people to whom that decision is left. The logical people to leave it to are those engaged in the business. Do we not all know that in rural Ireland 90 per cent. of the publicans have mixed businesses? It is theoretically conceivable that the sort of situation outlined by Senator Fitzpatrick could arise, but I think it is so remote that we need not worry about it. As far as I can decide, this is the simplest machinery to which we can have recourse in this matter.
Comment on this
That gives the power of veto to publicans who do not intend to open because they have not a mixed business or have the type of mixed business that does not call for Sunday opening. It gives those people the right of veto on other publicans down the street who wish to open to sell, perhaps, newspapers.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan is either not a realist or he does not know businessmen. If businessmen of any sort are provided in the statute with the opportunity to open, after a few days of doing business, they will avail of it. There will be no veto exercised.
Comment on this
Surely there are many types of business that do not call for Sunday opening? The court is left the discretion of giving the power to open. I take it that power will be given on individual applications? It will relate to the business to be carried on in those premises.
Comment on this
Yes, but it will relate to the type of unlicensed business for which the publican wishes to open?
Comment on this
No. This is purely a provision which will enable licensed premises to open for a period of three-quarters of a hour early on a Sunday morning to do unlicensed business and nothing else. The idea is that the period should be fixed for each locality to correspond with the period immediately after first Mass, so that people can get papers, cigarettes and so on. There will not be any difficulty about it. The publicans will decide among themselves what three-quarters of an hour will be fixed. You must remember that there are also unlicensed houses. The ordinary general news agency and grocer does the same business. There is no monopoly involved.
Comment on this
In the towns I know pretty well myself there are many publicans carrying on a straight public house business. They do not open on Sundays and would not be allowed to under this section.
Comment on this
The discretion is left to the court. The court does not have to allow the application. It is up to the court to investigate it. I take it that if the publican had not been opening in the past and had not any provision for such trade on weekdays or other times, the court would not look with favour on an application to open now and engage in a new line of business? Certainly, I do not think the local residents and the shopkeepers who are carrying on that trade as their sole means of livelihood would favour seeing public houses who have not been in the business previously being brought into it by this.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
To delete subsection (2).
The provision that I adverted to deals with the publican who has never opened during that period, has no intention of opening and has nothing to sell during that opening period and he has the right of vote and, in sufficient numbers, the right of veto on other publicans who have been carrying on a mixed business during the week.
Comment on this
That provision is strange enough, but it beats me to see why there is any question of a connection between a considerable number attending Divine Service and the question of whether the local mixed businesses, with a public house on one side and a counter on the other, should be allowed to open or not. If it means that, then the provision in the previous section to which I adverted is almost not worth the paper on which it is written.
Comment on this
The proposal is that this period of 45 minutes in the early morning for unlicensed business should not clash with the period of Divine Service. The Senator's amendment will have the effect of removing that impediment. In other words, that they could clash. Is that what the Senator means?
Comment on this
Surely that would not be desirable? If we were to accept that principle, there is no reason why a public house should not open for unlicensed business for the whole of Sunday morning. The suggestion here is that they should be open only for a limited period after first Mass, and by reference to Mass I intend, of course, to include all other religious services. There should be a period of three-quarters of an hour, so that people coming from Divine Service would be able to procure their groceries, newspapers, cigarettes, and so on, but I cannot see why the Senator would want to remove the restriction that that should not clash with the period of Divine Service.
Comment on this
I must say that I agree entirely with Senator Quinlan on this amendment. It is obvious that he has gone into this section very thoroughly. Obviously, the provision relates to the opening of licensed premises for licensed business from 12 to 12.30. The provision that that period should not clash with the time when a considerable number of people are attending Divine Service is to avoid the abuse whereby people would go to the public house instead of to Divine Service. There is no likelihood of people going into a sweet shop and eating sweets for three-quarters of an hour instead of going to Divine Service. Furthermore, the unlicensed premises selling sweets, cigarettes and newspapers can keep open during the period of Divine Service. No objection is taken to it. I think Senator Quinlan is quite right that this subsection is not really necessary.
Comment on this
I cannot see any real objection to the length of time in which licensed premises open for unlicensed business. If a corresponding shop is allowed to open for one-and-a-half hours, I cannot see why a licensed business doing the same type of trade cannot be allowed to open also.
Comment on this
Surely the Senator must admit that a licensed premises is not the same as an ordinary news-agency and tobacconist? There is always the possibility of a breach of the licensing laws in respect of a licensed premises.
Comment on this
We are legislating to give facilities to people to have recourse to these premises for unlicensed business. We must not close our eyes to the fact that they are still licensed premises, and the temptation is there. If Senator Quinlan could show some overwhelming reason why they should be able to stay open during the period of a religious service, I would reconsider the matter, but there seems to be no such reason. Surely three-quarters of an hour is sufficient on Sunday morning?
Comment on this
We had a Bill recently granting huge increases in salaries to the judiciary, including district justices——
Comment on this
——and we should leave some discretion now to the district justices. Granted premises are entitled to open for a period of three-quarters of an hour on Sunday morning, it should be for the justice to decide on the most suitable period. I cannot see that having a premises open could be in any way a mark of disrespect to Divine Service. Secondly, the only valid objection is that raised by the Minister; he says the temptation would be there and there might be illicit drinking in the three-quarters of an hour. If that is the case, then he has given a three-quarter hour period, and that is the measure of the chance he will take. I cannot see any connection with the other section, and I think some discretion should be allowed to the district justice when dealing with a particular case.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan has been accused of being a moralist by the Minister. Obviously, in relation to this section, the Minister is much more moral than either Senator Quinlan or Senator Cole.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In lines 10 and 11 to delete "prohibited hours in respect of" and substitute "licensed".
The object of this section is to do away with certain defences which were raised, in desperation, by publicans in order to hold on to their licences, which defences the Minister thought unreasonable. The defence in question sought to throw on the prosecution the onus of proving that the particular premises was a licensed premises. Proving that could involve the State in a good deal of trouble. Indeed, in certain cases, it might not be capable of proof at all. In order to do away with that defence, the Minister has put Section 23 into the Bill and he proceeds to presume, until the contrary is proved, that a licence is attached to certain premises. Now I think the section is defective. It says "in a prosecution for an offence in relation to prohibited hours in respect of premises". I think there could be other offences not involving prohibited hours.
Comment on this
The one that immediately suggests itself is the refusal to admit the Garda. As a matter of fact, although I do not like mentioning this, the publican who was prosecuted in the case which gives rise now to this section was also prosecuted for trading during prohibited hours. I think my amendment would cover any offence with which a publican could be charged in relation to such premises. I am afraid I now find myself in the capacity of poacher gone gamekeeper.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Senator's desire to be helpful. I agree with his interpretation of the situation. What is proposed is related entirely to an offence within the prohibited hours, an offence such as refusing to admit the Garda after the normal closing hours or during the non-prohibited hours——
Comment on this
That offence is not covered, but I do not think it is of any real importance. I put in this provision to make certain prosecutions easier for the State. I do not wish to go further than that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In subsection (9) (b), page 17, line 37, to delete "forty-eight hours" and substitute "two weeks".
This amendment is tabled for the purpose of getting information. Why is a search warrant confined to a period of 48 hours? It would seem that the superintendent concerned should have discretion to pick his time for a raid any time within a couple of weeks of getting the warrant.
Comment on this
Once a warrant is issued, it must be executed within 48 hours. That is a reasonable protection for the private citizen and private premises. There is no reason why the Garda should seek any more than that. In fact, they do not seek any more than that; 48 hours is quite adequate. As the Senator says, they should pick their time, and then proceed to raid within the 48 hours. This is the normal period. In the Gaming and Lotteries Act, 48 hours is the period stipulated.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In subsection (1) (a), page 18, line 2, to delete "one-fiftieth" and substitute "one-two hundredth".
I would much prefer to see this section deleted altogether from the Bill because it makes provision for the general sale of liqueur chocolates. As I hope to show, this could be a very dangerous provision and one that could lend itself to wide abuses. However, having little or no hope of getting the Minister to delete the section, and probably less hope of getting him to make any change, I would be failing in my duty if I did not alert the Seanad and the public to the dangers inherent in this provision. I intend to do so despite any derisive comments or sub-editorials which the Irish Times or other newspapers may produce.
It is provided here that these liqueur chocolates shall contain not more than one-fiftieth of a gallon of liqueur per lb. of confectionery. That is one-fiftieth of a gallon of proof spirit. That works out at a glass and a half of liqueur per lb. of chocolates. Now the chocolates must be under 1½ ozs. The ordinary chocolate weighs at most half an ounce. One can understand how very large these liqueur chocolates could be if the section were availed of fully. At most there would be ten chocolates to the lb. One could consume a glass of liqueur, therefore, by eating seven chocolates. If the chocolates disagreed with one's digestion, one could simply drink the liqueur and throw away the chocolates.
Comment on this
One is not allowed to buy a liqueur in unlicensed premises. It seems to me this provision could be used to get young people used to drinking—taking drink they would not dream of taking in the ordinary way. People might be prevailed on to take these chocolates with no realisation of what was in them. It could be quite a fashion at teenage parties and local dances to pass the chocolates round. In that way, one could create a situation which, if availed of to the full, could be as dangerous as the reefer situation in America and elsewhere. I cannot see any reason why this provision should be brought in. The liqueur chocolates which are available today are much lower in strength and in size than those provided for in this Bill. The Bill opens the way for what could become a real abuse.
Comment on this
I do not think the Senator's fears are realistic. I think he is tilting at windmills. I am not being derisive.
Comment on this
Does the Minister agree with my calculations as to the amount of liqueur which can be got into the chocolates in accordance with the Bill?
Comment on this
If the digestion can stand up to it, it can be just as pleasant to taste it out of the chocolate as out of a glass.
Comment on this
I do not think everybody has the capacity of Senator Ó Maoláin.
Comment on this
In a less jocose mood, I would ask the Senator to withdraw that.
Comment on this
It is not in order and I have asked Senator Quinlan to withdraw it.
Comment on this
I understood that Senator Ó Maoláin set his capacity at one hundred. In my capacity, I could not be a party to withdraw an amendment that would in any way try to go——
Comment on this
Yes. I can see they are something that could appeal to young people and, perhaps, not so young people.
Comment on this
Why would Senator Ó Maoláin not assist in this Bill? I have often wondered why he is against the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
As far as price is concerned, these are selling at something like 15/- a pound. You can get your glass of benedictine or brandy from the liqueur chocolates at a cost of 10/- I do not think 10/- is an insuperable obstacle to any person buying them.
Comment on this
With due respect to Senator Hayes, I hope he will not criticise me for prolonging this. The net issue is this. At the present moment liqueur chocolates can be sold—I do not want to mention names —at any grocery which is an off-licensed premises, but an ordinary grocer cannot sell them. You could walk into a grocery on one side of the street and purchase them but you cannot purchase them in a grocery on the other side of the street. That is an anomaly as it stands at present.
Comment on this
The Minister is referring to the sale of Irish coffee chocolates.
Comment on this
You would want a ton of those. A glass of liqueur to a ton of chocolates is not strong but the Bill opens the way to a type of exploitation that will be seized upon if we allow this section to stand. I suggest that to mitigate this, it should be brought down to reality. If you must allow it in the case of some of those chocolates on sale, which are only liqueur chocolates in name, we can frame the Bill to allow those and no others. In other words, let us reduce the amount of liqueur per pound of confectionery from, say, one-fiftieth of a gallon down to one two-hundredth, that is to say, down to something less than one quarter of a glass per pound of chocolates and so cut down on the size of the chocolates involved. One and a half ounces is three times the size of the existing chocolates. You can cut down the amount by cutting down the size also and thus keep in touch with reality. That would allow of the sale of the liqueur chocolates on the market today but would prevent the abuse that would be made of this section if we allow it to stand.
Comment on this
I rise to oppose this section on principle. It allows for a still further increase in the number of licensed premises. Some of the licences which have not been removed have got a further year in which to change.
Comment on this
The Senator is wrong. All that is concerned here is allowing those who have a six-day licence to transform them into seven day licences but no new licence can be created.
Comment on this
The section provides for an extension of the drinking facilities. Above all, it provides for an extension of Sunday drinking facilities. The six-day licences which have not changed so far are given one year to change. The whole difficulty with regard to the licensing trade is that we have far too many licensed premises. Successive Governments so far have tried at least to hold the number at the level at which it was in 1922 and 1923 and tried to extend some licences where that was feasible. I should like to urge on the Minister in the years ahead to use every provision to eliminate many of the uneconomic licensed premises in our towns today. There may be a small town having anything up to 20 or 30 licensed premises, some of which are not making more than a few pounds a week return. If the Minister could use any means of extinguishing those, even at the cost of compensating them for whatever loss is involved, it would be a step in the right direction.
Comment on this
I have already undertaken, if an opportunity presents itself, to examine as a separate question whether or not some scheme could be devised whereby redundant or unnecessary licences could be purchased by some compensation fund. I do not think it is relevant to this Bill. It is something that will have to be looked at separately, as a separate question. I have given an undertaking, if the time and circumstances permit, to look into the matter and see whether some kind of scheme could be devised.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
Before Section 34 to insert the following new section:
"Section 23 (which amends section 2 of the Act of 1902) of the Act of 1960 is hereby amended by the substitution of ‘three years' for ‘two years' in subsection (2)."
Everybody knows there are six-day and seven-day licensed premises in this country. Up to 1943, a person who had a six-day licensed premises could not get a seven-day licensed premises. Between 1943 and 1960, a person with a six-day licensed premises could purchase a seven-day licensed premises, extinguish it and convert his six-day licence into a seven-day licence, or purchase a seven-day licensed premises, transfer it to the six-day licensed premises, extinguish the six-day licence and make it a seven-day licence. That was the position until 1960. The Act of 1960 gave a person who had a six-day licensed premises the right to pay £200 to the Revenue Commissioners and convert his six-day licence into a seven-day licence but it was provided in the 1960 Bill that that should cease two years after the coming into force of the 1960 Act. This amendment proposes to extend for a further year the time for converting a six-day licence into a seven-day licence by paying £200.
Up to 1960, a person who had a licence on the coming into force of the Act of 1902 and which lapsed any time subsequent to 1902 could revive that licence by applying to the circuit court. The Act of 1960 continued his right to do so only for a period of two years after the coming into force of the 1960 Act. The 1960 Act restricted the right of a person to revive a licence which had lapsed for more than five years.
What I am asking the Minister to do is to extend the right of a person who owns a licence which has lapsed any time since 1902 to revive that licence up to and including a year from the coming into operation of this Act. The reason I am asking the Minister to do that is, first of all, that he is extending Section 27 of the Act of 1960 for a further year. I am asking him to give the same facilities to a person with a lapsed licence because there have been cases of hardship. There are people up and down the country who own licences and who did not know they could revive them until it was too late. I know of one case in County Sligo where a person could have revived a licence but failed because satisfactory proof was not forthcoming in time that the licence existed in 1902, and that proof was not forthcoming because the documentary proof was destroyed during the trouble in 1921 or 1922. There is a case of real hardship and I am sure there are others. I would ask the Minister either to extend the section without reservation for a further year or to bring in a new section extending the Act of 1902 for a further year in cases where it can be shown that hardship exists. In the case I have in mind —and I am sure there are others— hardship does exist.
Comment on this
I cannot accede to this and I would expect Senator Quinlan to leap to his feet to support me in its rejection. If we were to extend this for another year, it would undoubtedly mean that approximately 1,000—maybe more, maybe less—new licences would be created.
Comment on this
Could be and almost certainly would be created. There is no doubt those licences would be created for sale and once they were re-created, they would not be confined to the areas in which they are at present; they could be transferred to different parts of the country. If most people who are interested in this whole problem of licences are agreed on one thing more than anything else, it is that there are too many licences in the country. We would be very unwise to throw this door open and permit the re-creating of about 1,000 new licences. Hard cases, as we all know, make bad law and the fact that a few people have slept on their rights and have not availed of the provision that existed up to now should not lead us into a situation where we would make possible the re-creating of 1,000 new licences. The people concerned have had two clear years to avail of this opportunity and we would be doing a very bad day's work if we were to accede to this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
Before Section 36 to insert the following new section:
"Section 37 of the Act of 1960 is hereby repealed."
This last of a long number of amendments deals with compulsory endorsement. It is of considerable importance and I would ask the Minister to give it serious consideration. Under the Act of 1927, provision was made for endorsing licences and in that Act it was provided that if a certain number of endorsements— three, I think—had been placed on a licence, the licence became defunct. However, that Act contained a number of provisions giving relief against endorsement. One section of the Act stated that the district justice might not endorse a licence if he were satisfied that the offence was trivial or if there were other special circumstances. Section 27 of the Act of 1927 conferred power on the circuit court judge to remove an endorsement although affirming the conviction. Section 30 of that Act contained very important provisions because it stated that endorsement of a licence did not pass to a bona fide purchaser of the premises to which the licence was attached.
The Act of 1943 tightened up the provision relating to endorsements. It simply said that the district justice should endorse if he thought fit. The Act of 1960, for the first time, made it obligatory on the district justice on a second or any subsequent conviction under the licensing Acts following the passing of that Act to endorse, and as I understand it when three endorsements have been placed on a licence the licence becomes defunct. This Bill also provides that an endorsement or endorsements pass on to a purchaser for valuable consideration.
Comment on this
I am glad to accept the Minister as speaking ex cathedra on this matter. While that takes some of the force from my argument, I think it is still very undesirable that district justices should not have discretion as to whether or not they should endorse licences. As I have said there is no difference between an offence committed at 11.31 p.m. during the period of summer time and an offence committed during the early hours of the following morning. The Minister has tried to relieve that situation by introducing this ten-minute drinking-up time. I have the height of contempt for that provision. It will not meet the case it is meant to meet but will bring back into disrepute the licensing code.
I respectfully submit to the Minister that it is fundamentally wrong to impose these minimum penalties in legislation of this nature. It is taking away the dignity of the courts to deprive them of the jurisdiction to measure appropriate penalties. The Minister at some stage should review this compulsory endorsement clause so that we should give to district justices discretion to measure penalties in cases arising during one hour after closing time. I do not suggest that there should be no penalty for offences which occur during the period up to one hour after closing time. In fact I am suggesting that heavy monetary penalties would be imposed. I should like the Minister, for my own information, to clarify the position in relation to endorsements passing on to a purchaser for valuable consideration.
Comment on this
The relevant provision in the 1927 Act, Section 30, is still extant and has not been affected by anything that has been done since. It provides that these endorsements shall not run against a bona fide purchaser for value and that where a person disposes of his interest in a licensed premises the new owner starts off with a clean sheet.
Comment on this
We will not hold that against the Senator. These matters are very complex and it takes a masterly intellect to grasp them. This section has led to a fair amount of comment and I met a deputation of publicans and discussed it fully with them. They suggested we should abandon this provision, that it was penal, Draconian and gave rise to very considerable hardship. I said to them that if it were a question of maintaining the enforcement of law and keeping the compulsory endorsement provision, or doing away with the compulsory endorsement and having the enforcement suffer, which would they prefer. This was a large and representative deputation and they were in unanimous agreement in saying that if it were a choice they would prefer to retain the compulsory endorsement provision rather than have the enforcement of law suffer. One thing everybody was satisfied with in the 1960 Act was that it was impartially enforced so that when one publican closed he knew his brethren in the same locality were closed also.
This provision is necessary for enforcement and is not as bad as people seem to regard it. The first offence is not entered on the licence at all. I give in that respect the analogy of the dog being allowed one bite before anything happens to him. The first is, if you like, a free offence which is not endorsed on the licence. The second remains extant on the licence for two years. If there is a third offence it remains endorsed for a period of four years and if there is a fourth or further offence it remains on the licence for a period of six years. Therefore, a publican needs to be pretty wilful to get to the stage where he is in danger of losing his licence.
It is only when he has committed a fourth offence that he is getting into serious difficulties because that fourth offence remains endorsed on his licence for six years before it becomes obliterated. As I said earlier the bona fide purchaser for value starts out with a clean sheet. Bearing all that in mind I think we should retain this provision and should not revert to the old provision of permitting the licensing code to go into disrepute because the courts would be very reluctant to exercise a discretion to make endorsements on a licence. We want enforcement and the extension of the licensing hours is justified only on the basis that what is proposed here will be strictly enforced. If we want enforcement we must retain this endorsement provision.
I do not think that is unfair or will lead to hardship and I suggest to Senator Fitzpatrick that it would be desirable to retain it particularly as I now have introduced this proposal for a ten-minute drinking up time. I have thus taken away the only really valid complaint publicans would have that they would be in danger of committing offences in the period immediately following closing time.
Comment on this
I want to be recorded as dissenting on grounds which I have repeatedly stated and need not repeat now.
Comment on this
We are entitled to discuss the Bill as it is. It is now precisely as it came to us from the other House. It contains some things with which I do not agree but I do not propose to discuss that now. We have had an excellent Committee discussion on the Bill here but it has not been in the least fruitful, so far as I am concerned. It seems to me that the Bill would not be as it is now if the Minister were free and the circumstances such that he could have accepted amendments. It also seems that if we had received the Bill earlier it would certainly not be as it is now. It would contain certain changes suggested here and accepted by the Minister with good humour and goodwill. I should like to ask the Minister whether, in the light of his experience here, he would endeavour to persuade the Taoiseach and his colleagues in the Government so to order their business that this House would have an opportunity of proving its usefulness and of doing something constructive in regard to legislation.
We had a good-humoured discussion here and it might have persuaded the Minister but in fact it did not accomplish anything. I suggest to the Minister, in the light of his experience and in the light of the influence he must be in a position to exercise, that he should exercise his influence so as to see that we would get legislation in such a way as to enable us to be effective in dealing with it.
Comment on this
I should like to join with Senator Hayes in saying that we had a very useful discussion and while we did not get anything from the Minister, he certainly turned us down with good grace. We did not really expect anything from him because we knew that he was determined to have the Bill for the weekend. Let us hope that when introducing the next licensing Bill he will bear in mind the discussion we had here today. Speaking personally, I think the worst feature of the whole Bill is the 10 minutes "drinking up" time. I detest that provision. I think it will lead to trouble and bring the law into disrepute. I wish to join with Senator Nash and support the plea made by him on the Second Stage when he asked that the licensing laws should be codified. It is a dreadful mistake that this Bill has been introduced not as a comprehensive measure but rather as an amending measure. It deals with licensing Acts back as far as 1833—there are nearly 20 of them. I think it was the Minister's intention to codify——
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt but this is rather a Second Reading point and not strictly relevant on this Stage.
Comment on this
I have practically finished. I am sure the Minister did intend to codify but time did not permit. He should see the pitfalls that may arise with all the various Acts. Even great minds like his can fall into a trap by the gap in Section 23 not being closed and great minds like mine, confronted with the magnitude of the legislation, may not realise that the endorsement does not pass on to the purchaser.
Comment on this
Or that the speech just made is not relevant on this Stage.
Comment on this
I should like to support what Senator Hayes has said about the proper ordering of Government business. This Bill came to us very late. We are asked to co-operate in order to get it through. While not very keen on that we realise there are difficulties, in regard to the staff of the House for example, and we do not wish to hold it up.
However, I must oppose the final passage of the Bill because, as I said earlier, it is a Bill which in some respects, particularly in regard to Sunday trading, provides for longer hours which are not required by the publicans and their employees and, so far as we can judge, not greatly desired either by the customers. It will lead to inconvenience to the people directly involved and possibly also to the public.
A final point—would the Minister take time to give us an assurance that when this Bill is passed the legislation will be strictly enforced? I know his predecessor, when the previous Act was going through, did give very firm assurances. They were complied with but I suspect that of late there is a tendency to relax. People have got the idea that there is a more liberal approach to the enforcement of trading hours and I am told that in some cases the law is not as strictly enforced as formerly. I hope the Minister will avail of this opportunity to assure the House that the new legislation will be very strictly enforced throughout the whole country.
Comment on this
Apropos of what Senator Fitzpatrick and Senator Murphy have said, I should like to say that I think one of the best things in the Bill is this ten minutes "drinking-up" period. As I pointed out on the Second Stage, I hold that thousands of people were deprived of their rights under the law by being refused the privilege of purchasing a drink in some public houses after 20 minutes to 11 at night in the winter and in most public houses after a quarter to eleven. Now they will be able to buy their drink and the publican will be able to sell it with the assurance that they will have ten minutes to finish it and thus their rights as citizens under the law will be restored. I congratulate the Minister particularly on that point.
Comment on this
I wish to reinforce the plea made by Senator Hayes for better ordering of business. Might I express the hope that many Bills like this will be first introduced in the Seanad? We would give the Minister concerned the fullest co-operation in combing the Bill and we might then be effective in helping the passage of the Bill through the Dáil. We might succeed in ironing out many snags and get our views across to the Minister. That would expedite business and in some way justify the existence of the Seanad because today, although we have talked a great deal and tried very hard, we have achieved nothing.
Comment on this
In reply to Senator Hayes and the other Senators, I appreciate that the Seanad is in a position to improve any legislation that comes before it. I think in the past, from time to time, I have given concrete indications of that appreciation by accepting amendments put down by Senators.
I am sorry this Bill came before the Seanad in the way it did and that the mechanics of the situation—although they did not entirely prevent it—made it difficult for me to accept any amendments. I am not certain that the Bill is not perfect as it is. I have a strong suspicion that it is as good as human ingenuity could make it. Nevertheless, if the mechanics of the situation were different, it is possible that some amendments might have been accepted if for no other reason than the fact that the arguments for and against were even, and we like to meet the Seanad where possible.
As I say, it was not my intention that the situation should work out this way. I had hoped that the Bill would get to the Seanad much earlier and that we could have the sort of useful discussion that Senator Hayes mentioned. However, I merely want to say in conclusion to the Chair and to Senators that I am very grateful, indeed, for the courteous way in which they received the Bill, and for their kind co-operation in expediting its passage.
Comment on this
Senator Murphy, Senator Quinlan, Senator McDonald and Senator Fitzgerald will be recorded as dissenting.