Land Bill, 1963: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–131 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
I move amendment No. 29:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) This section shall not apply to the transfer by an owner of land to the child of that owner."
As the Seanad is aware, section 13 of this Bill suspends dealings with lands where a provisional list under subsection (2) of section 40 of the Land Act, 1923, had been published until the termination of the proceedings under the Land Acts for the acquisition of the lands and it also suspends dealings with lands for a period of three months where a notice has been served following an inspection. The object of my amendment is to provide that that suspension shall not apply to the transfer of the land in question from father to child. I do not think this should be very contentious and I am hopeful that the Minister will see fit to accept it. I presume that the object of section 13 is to ensure that the position of the Land Commission will not be adversely affected following the publication of the list or the service of the notice by a transfer by the owner of the land to some third person. Presumably, the position of the Land Commission could be adversely affected if a person, who was not working the land properly himself or was not residing within three miles of the land itself, sold and transferred the land to another person who was prepared to work it properly or to live on it. I do not think there should be any objection to that if the transfer is from the owner of the land to his own child.
As a matter of fact, it might be a good thing in certain circumstances if the hand of the owner who was not making use of the lands and was not residing on them were forced a little to make him transfer to a member of his own family. I think, by and large, it is a good thing that farmers' sons should be encouraged to succeed their fathers in the ownership and working of family farms. I could see the force of the Minister's point in preventing the Land Commission being prejudiced, as I have said, by a sale to a complete outsider, but I strongly urge on the Minister and on the House that a sale on a transfer by a father to a son is in a totally different category and should be treated as such.
The Land Commission will not be prejudiced if the son who succeeds does not work the farm or does not reside on it. They can only be prejudiced if the son who succeeds the father under the transfer operates on a different basis to his father, operates on lines which would make it unreasonable for the Land Commission to take over the land. If the son who acquired from the father under the transfer did that I think it is highly desirable and should be encouraged.
Comment on this
I should like very much to support this amendment. For years back agricultural organisations and people interested in stemming the flight from the land have been advocating that the farmers' sons should be encouraged to marry at an early age, and time and time again I have heard lecturers advocating that farmers should build a separate house on the farm and transfer portion of the farm to a son and make him take on responsibilities of his own.
People who have an interest in the preservation of the population in rural Ireland are certainly of the opinion that unless the marrying age of the Irish farmer is reduced and unless they marry at a younger age the position will continue to deteriorate. I can see where a young man wants to marry and if this section is passed as it is a farmer will be prevented from transferring, shall we say, portion of the holding to his son and thereby the arrangements will have to be left in abeyance for a matter of months. Anyone who knows the temperament of the older Irish farmers must surely realise that it is difficult to get round some of these older people to even consider making a transfer of this kind.
If this transfer is made more difficult by introducing a freezing period of three months plus, I think the entire job would be altogether more difficult. I feel if the Minister accepts this amendment it will certainly not cut across the policy we have been advocating over the past few years and the efforts that have been made. Muintir na Tíre made a very exacting survey in County Limerick a few years ago on this particular marriage settlement question. The farming community have constantly been told the way these problems are tackled in other countries. If this Bill is now to more or less put a stop to that practice, which has only recently started in this country, I think it would be a retrograde step. I would, therefore, ask the Minister to accept this amendment which will in my opinion in no way interfere with the section.
Comment on this
I have a great deal of sympathy with this amendment. I imagine the Minister would like to modify considerably the qualifications of the child and the prospects of whether he or she will make a good farmer and make proper use of the land. All of us know places—I know them myself—where sons, who would normally succeed, have gone away from the farm because they could not get any support for making greater use of the more modern methods of farming. They left their fathers, not because they could not agree on other matters, but that they could not get any support for any progressive use of the farm.
If this amendment were accepted I believe it would help considerably a great many of those cases. I do not believe, as Senator Fitzpatrick has mentioned, that it will hold up the work of the Land Commission very much. They can limit it to a term and if there is no change made in the use of the land they can then apply to take over the land. I should like to support the amendment but I should like something done in regard to the qualifications of the child.
Comment on this
I consider the amendment, as set out by Senator Fitzpatrick, a reasonable one. In fact, it could be said that it is more than reasonable. As I, and I am sure others, understand the position, a farmer or the owner of land coming to what he regards as the end of his days decides to make a will. He is naturally anxious that the property, whether it is large or small, should go to the right person. In some cases it does not happen that the man makes a will but in 99 per cent of the cases it happens that way. The man usually gives his property to some member of his family. Very often he gives it to the eldest, who is usually a son, if he is on the land with him. Even if he is not on the land, it is natural that he will give it to one of the family.
The amendment says a child of the owner but we all know—and I am sure the Minister himself knows—of cases where there may be no family but there might be a nephew or, perhaps, a brother's child, whether it is a boy or a girl, helping that man, who had no family of his own. That relation lived happily with the man. That owner, knowing that individual very well, knowing the services rendered to him, would like to leave the place to him. I do not know where the Lay Commissioners would come in there at all. That has not been the practice. I do not believe the Minister has ever received any complaint that there have been abuses in matters of that kind. It may not have gone completely right in some cases because family relations did not agree with the will. Somebody would, perhaps, think it was a different member of the family who should have been considered as the owner but I have never heard of any case in the country outside of that where there might be a dispute. There might be something to be said if there was a question of a stranger coming in from some place.
Comment on this
The Senator must come to the amendment before the House.
Comment on this
I am just trying to build up a case around the amendment, to show that there might be some case of abuse. I consider the amendment is reasonable and I should be very glad to hear what case the Minister can make with regard to it.
Comment on this
I personally do not consider there is any need for the amendment in view of the fact that when notice is served on the owner, he will have to show reason why he can transfer or sell his farm. I have no doubt the Commissioners are sympathetic enough with every case that is put to them. One of the things which struck me about the Bill is that we are spending so much time on small things, trying to create a problem where there is no problem, that we are not concentrating on the solution which the Bill was intended to provide — the relief of congestion. There are people waiting for the passage of this Bill to get some benefit from it. At the rate we are going we will still have some of the speakers on the Opposition side having something to talk about and delaying the passage of the Bill.
Comment on this
The owner of the land, when the notice is served on him, can explain why he is selling and to whom.
Comment on this
Before the Minister replies I should like to say something arising out of Senator Cole's contribution. The amendment, as drafted, is narrow enough and it does not need any further restrictions. If the son, to whom the farm is transferred, does not own the farm, does not reside on the farm on which the father did not reside then he will be in no better position than the father and the Land Commission will be in no worse position.
Comment on this
There are obviously some very naïve Senators in this House and I do not believe Senator Fitzpatrick, who moved this amendment, is one of them. The section is designed to deal with one of the greatest abuses we have in this country, that is frustrating the Land Commission, jumping the legal gun because of the red tape which is involved in this process at the present time. It has been conceded by anybody who is concerned with this particular Bill that a section like this is essential. The only argument we have had about this section was on the length of the freezing period. I had a deputation from the National Farmers Association to discuss this matter with me and they afterwards wrote to me:
We appreciate the necessity of empowering the Land Commission to take prompt and effective action in certain circumstances but we consider that the Land Commission prohibition under this section on transfer, letting and subletting should be limited to one month.
I indicated in the Dáil that the freezing period would be six months but as a result of the discussion with the NFA that was reduced to three months on Report Stage with certain provision set out in the section for a further period in certain circumstances. The mover of the amendment tries to convey the impression that the case he is contemplating here is that of the normal working farmer in the occupation of a normal farm, which, of course, is completely at variance with the type of people we propose to deal with under this section.
After the passage of the Bill, there will be no more intention on the part of the Land Commission to move in on any ordinary working farmer who is working his land according to the usual methods of husbandry, and has his residence on the land. There is no intention whatsoever to attack that kind of man, and such a man has adequate defences open to him under the law. The law now is, and has been for quite a long time, that irrespective of whether a man was working his land, or resident upon it, if there was congestion in the immediate vicinity, the Land Commission would be entitled to move in and take over the land. Although that power is there, the mover of the amendment started off discussing this section as if the powers were to be used in the case of an ordinary farmer who was, perhaps, holding on too long and not transferring to his son. The same strain was taken up by Senator McDonald.
This section will apply in the case where land has been let for years. Possibly the owner is living abroad and under the present procedure gets a section 40 notice; he then gets busy and sells the land to get rid of it before the Land Commission under their present cumbersome procedure have time to publish a notice in Iris Oifigiúil. If the land is advertised for sale by the owner within the previous 12 months the ordinary defence would not be open to him and this section would apply. As I have said elsewhere, I think that where land is for sale, and there is good reason for acquiring that land for the relief of congestion, such land should be vulnerable to the Land Commission for acquisition. It is suggested here that there should be this way out by transferring to the son, even though the land is required for the relief of congestion. It would not be a case in which the owner was living abroad or had land let for a number of years, and a bad history of user. It is suggested that if we put in an amendment of this kind enabling him to defeat the Land Commission procedure in such a case by transferring to the son we would be doing a good job. Of course, it is obvious that this could be used as a device to defeat the whole purpose of the section.
If a man were living in England for the past 30 years with his land let, and he heard the Land Commission were after it for the relief of congestion and transferred it to a son in New York, who sold it to someone else the following day, the Land Commission procedure would be frustrated. Another Senator wanted the land to go to a daughter or a nephew, and so on. The idea of allowing the owner to transfer is quite all right if we are dealing with the ordinary family man. That does not come under this section at all, as Senators who have read the debate in the Dáil are well aware.
Week after week for years past, the main complaint by people in the congested areas, and Deputies in Dáil Éireann, has been that the Land Commission do not move in, in time, and that people got rid of lands which were badly needed for the relief of congestion. This is a way of ensuring that a bad user who has been living abroad for years cannot get rid of his lands immediately he hears the Land Commission are starting proceedings, and of ensuring that he cannot defeat the objectives of the Land Commission for his own purposes. If there were a case in which the owner, no matter where he was living, had a son who was prepared to come back and work the land, the son has the same right to put in an objection. Probably if the owner were living abroad, the son would be living abroad too, but this section would not be operated where a son or any member of the family was normally working on the family farm.
As I pointed out again and again, the land courts have invariably adjourned such cases for a year, or two years, to see if the owner or his son would come back and work the land. The same procedure would be open in the event of there being such a case and, incidentally, I doubt that there would be such a case in practice. If there was a son who was prepared to come back and take responsibility for the land and work it, I have no doubt the Land Commission would follow the same procedure. In fact, they have leaned over backwards to enable such people to come back and take up responsibility for the land.
There is a crying need for this section. That has been accepted by all parties who have considered this problem. If an amendment such as this were accepted, people could defeat the purposes of the Land Commission, and Land Commission policy, by this device. I suggest to the Senator that in view of the fact that the necessity for this section has been recognised by everyone concerned with the congestion problem, he should withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
May I ask one question? Am I correct in thinking that the sale would not interrupt the proceedings mentioned in section 13 (1)? Am I correct in thinking that notwithstanding the sale those proceedings would go on?
Comment on this
Am I correct in thinking that notwithstanding the sale or transfer to the son the proceedings mentioned in section 13 (1) would still continue to their termination and the Land Commission might be prejudiced by the sale or transfer?
Comment on this
Once the notice had been served it would take effect under the section. If the son were concerned it would be the same as it would now after publication of the Iris Oifigiúil notice. The sale or transfer to him would take effect if the Land Commission consented. If they did not consent it could not take effect.
Comment on this
I do not take it that way. He would not be in his father's boots because the transaction would be void unless the Land Commission consented to it.
Comment on this
No, if the amendment were accepted it would mean that the Land Commission would have to start anew with the son.
Comment on this
They would have to wait, just as the procedure is now, because now where the Land Commission have served a section 40 notice, with the procedure where the file goes up to different officials until it ultimately gets processed through the Lay Commissioners, and a notice is printed in Iris Oifigiúil, a transfer or sale takes place and the Land Commission is defeated and must sit back to see how the new owner conducts himself. It takes a couple of years to see what methods he will use. In the very same way if the amendment is accepted the Land Commission's proceedings would be wiped out. The son would be there, whether he is there or in New York, and they would have to start off with him.
Comment on this
I would have expected the Minister to treat this amendment seriously and he has not done so. I am perfectly well aware it is unlikely that the Land Commission will move in on a farmer who is operating his farm according to the best standards of husbandry. The case I have in mind is a farmer who has become old or is not using his farm as well as he should and whose son has, perhaps for that reason, moved off from him temporarily, or who may be living at home but is frustrated because he has not got the authority to run the farm as it should be. If the Land Commission move in on such a farmer he may say he wants to keep the farm in the family and in order to do that is prepared to hand over the reins and let the young man come back from whereever he is to work the farm, or hand over the reins to a son who is already at home but has not got the reins. That is a perfectly clear case and with all respects to the Minister it is absurd to say that a farmer in England might improve the position of his son or worsen the position of the Land Commission by transferring his farm to his son in America. That is not treating the amendment or the House seriously.
The Minister quoted a very far fetched type of case that the farmer in England could transfer to the son in New York who in turn could transfer to a complete outsider and in that way defeat the Land Commission. That is a very extreme case and one which it would not be beyond the ingenuity of the Minister or his advisers to provide against in a redrafted amendment. Nobody here is against the relief of congestion. Everybody here believes that where there is a tradition of farming in a family it should be kept there. Everybody will agree, I hope, that it is a good thing that sons should be encouraged to succeed their parents on the family holding. If they have temporarily emigrated or gone to work elsewhere in the country they should be encouraged to come home. My case is simple. It boils down to this. Where a farmer is not working his farm to the satisfaction of the Land Commission and where he is prepared to transfer that farm to his son who is prepared to work it to the satisfaction of the Land Commission, he should be allowed to do so. If the Minister introduced that sort of amendment in any form of language that will guarantee the right of that farmer to do just that I will be satisfied and I will not insist on the wording of my amendment if the Minister thinks it goes too far.
I am not prepared to accept a pious assurance from the Minister that the Land Commission of today or of the future, or the Minister of today or his successors, will act in this very reasonable manner and can be relied upon to do so. I want to guarantee that a farmer is to be entitled to transfer his farm to his son who is prepared to work it and I say that to deny a father that right is going much too far and is quite unnecessary in the interests of the distribution of land. The Minister can even put into his amendment if he likes that where it is necessary for the relief of immediate congestion he can go ahead and take the farm. That provision is there already but I do not want, by agreeing to this section as it stands, further to prejudice the right of a father to do what I say he is entitled to do, or make it more difficult for the father to do that and to hand over to the Land Commission the right to deprive him from doing that.
Comment on this
I agree with nine-tenths of what the Minister said. I have great concern, however, for the congests for whom this Bill is primarily being brought into the House and I also have a great regard and sympathy for sons of farmers who are perfectly willing and anxious to carry on and make a success of life and who by reason of their youth, upbringing and surroundings would dearly love to live in the country where they were brought up, but who because they did not get any encouragement from the father, who is perhaps getting old, or has backward ideas, felt they had to leave. I do not think the case the Minister made, that the father would be absent and the son might be away somewhere else, will ever arise. The Minister could easily amend the amendment to prohibit anybody like that succeeding.
There are many cases where very often a widow stayed on a farm which was left to her, or, perhaps, it was her own, and attempted to farm it in her own way. A son or sons could not just stay there and went away but they would dearly have loved to stay and perhaps had the qualifications to farm it successfully and properly, and yet, they not being there, the Land Commission might be quite right in moving to take over that land. Perhaps if the Minister would reconsider it along the lines that the proceedings would be adjourned for a certain time on the transfer of the land, it might be a solution which would meet Senator Fitzpatrick's case.
Comment on this
I certainly cannot follow the Minister's line of argument, and his description of the Irish farmer does not fit any of the men in the midlands who are my colleagues. If, as some Senators say, this Bill is primarily to ease congestion, some regard should be given to the hard-working tillage farmers in the midlands who have no desire to pull a fast one on the Department or the Land Commission. I cannot believe that the position is as the Minister has painted. If it were, then surely we could get around the situation by legislating for both types, including the ordinary decent farmers I know who are my neighbours and who must be in the majority. I refuse to accept that they are not. For that reason I think it is a poor thing to say that we are just easing congestion. We should not at the same time be increasing the amount of red tape involved for an orderly succession by a farmer's son to a farm in the midlands and the tillage areas.
The coming generation of Irish farmers will undoubtedly be the best this or any country has ever known. They are the first generation who have a wide secondary education and for that reason they will have the best results. If this Bill in order to ease congestion in the west and other parts of the country should hamstring those lads and deprive them of their rights to succeed their fathers, it would be deplorable. There are a hundred and one reasons why this particular section is bad——
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister should insist on his legislation for what I think must be the minority in the west. Certainly his description bears no resemblance to farmers I know in the midlands.
Comment on this
I have listened very carefully to the debate on this amendment and I would appeal to the Minister very strongly to reconsider his attitude to it. His whole attitude is based on the suggestion that the amendment is not necessary, that the Land Commission do not do this now, as we know, and that they have no intention of doing so in the future. That is a very bad approach to legislation and one that we as a responsible legislative assembly should not adopt. We have been told again and again that when the Bill leaves this House all that matters is what is written in the Bill, not the pious hopes of the Minister or the clarifications or views expressed by any Senator—only what is written in the Bill and what the lawyers can make out of it.
There is here in this amendment a very legitimate and reasonable aspiration that a man should be able to pass on his property to his son. The father might have had differences with the son or might even have been farming it badly or so on and the Land Commission might quite properly come after him but at that stage he still should have the right to pass the farm on to the son, provided that the son is taking over in a bona fide manner, which the Minister can guarantee to achieve by rewording the amendment. Provided that is the case the son should have the right in law to receive the farm from his father and not have to depend on the practice of the Land Commission at that period.
The Land Commission, if ruthless enough, could say: "We have got this farm into our power and we are not going to give it up and that is the end of it," and nobody could dispute that with them. It would not be done now. The Minister would never approve of that but this Bill, like the Acts of 1923 and 1933, will probably remain the Land Act for many years and we do not know what pressure the Land Commission will be under or what change of policy will take place, and consequently we should ensure that the son has a right in law to receive the property from his father even if the father had been remiss in the past and farmed badly. The son deserves his chance but he must be a bona fide recipient of it. His chance should not be left to the discretion of anybody which is capable of changing its policy in that regard from year to year.
I appeal to the Minister to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage that will satisfy both the legitimate wish expressed here in the Seanad, to enable the son to achieve his succession, and the other object the Minister has in view. The Minister is concerned that there will not be any jiggery-pokery by long distance from London, New York, perhaps Biarritz which has been mentioned in dispatches in the past or other places around the globe to keep the Land Commission from achieving their legitimate purposes. The Minister can do that and I appeal to him to do it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I can assure the House, to quote Senator Quinlan about jiggery-pokery that a tremendous amount of it has gone on from London and New York since this Bill was first introduced in anticipation of jumping the gun. From my experience, I am very suspicious of providing an obvious means of another way out. I really think Senators have got off to a wrong start on this section which, as I have emphasised already, is recognised by all concerned with this problem as being necessary. Let me emphasise again what I cannot emphasise too often, that this section is here for the particular purpose of getting after the individual in the category set out in the Bill who has a long history of bad land user, who has possibly had the land up for sale, and in very many cases, of beating the individual who has been habitually up to now, even though he is in England or New York, beating the Land Commission by effecting a quick sale before they can put what I have described as a legal plaster on that bad holding.
There is no case that comes to my mind at the moment that I have ever come across where, if there is a question of a transfer to a son, the Land Commission did not accept the situation. They always do. It may occur that a son in England is a waster and a habitual drunkard and I do not know if it is suggested that this individual with a long history of bad land user or letting his land, if the Land Commission got after him, should defeat their purpose by transferring to such a son. Again, I ask Senators to consider, in case there was a son who was willing to come back and work these lands, how it is that it would be left to the last moment to the Land Commission to move in with their notice and then this son would be resurrected for the purpose of frustrating the Land Commission proceedings.
Section 13 does not prohibit transfers. It merely gives the Land Commission power to control so that they can stop undesirable transactions. It gives control for a period of three months. If a proposition comes up with which the Land Commission are satisfied they withdraw their notice. That is the end of it. Quite obviously, they would not pursue a case with a history of the father letting the lands, even though he had gone away to Jericho for the past twenty years, if he had a son who was prepared to come home and take over. The Land Commission would obviously regard that as a desirable solution. Indeed, where we are compiling a register under this Bill of holdings that have been vacant for a long time my information is that people are being written to wherever they are and told that if they are prepared to come back, take up residence and work the land it is all right but, otherwise, the Land Commission propose to take over and compensate them for the lands.
That is the position and I think the way Senators have gone wrong in this matter is getting the idea that this procedure will be used against the ordinary resident farmer who is working his lands in the ordinary way. There is nothing further from the truth and the realities of the situation. This procedure is designed to cover the individual who knows he has no case against compulsory Land Commission proceedings. I want Senators to realise that in such a situation it means that this is a man who has been letting his lands for a long time and is not entitled to avail of the provisions in law, what we call the "adequates". He knows he has not a hope, and I assume is so advised by his advisers, of succeding under the ordinary law. Therefore, in order to frustrate the Land Commission he jumps the gun and sells before the Land Commission procedure can go through.
This deals with a situation which has been a regular occurrence over the years. Any Senators who represent congested areas are well aware of this fact and, even though the sons may be in New York, Australia or England, in many cases, to spite the neighbours, people will effect transfer or a conveyence to a forty first cousin who is living 20 miles away.
Comment on this
The Land Commission wait and see how they get on. I have said that the suggested or theoretical facts put forward here would obviously be acceptable to the Land Commission and, in any case, I could visualise they would accept a son and withdraw the proceedings. There has never been a case in my experience, and I am sure in the experience of anybody else concerned with this matter for the past 30 years, in which I have seen the Land Commission refuse the petition where either the owner, a son or any near relation was prepared to take up residence on the land and work it. The same would be the position here.
Irrespective of what has been said here, it has been suggested that what I have said is far-fetched. It is no such thing. To my own knowledge it is the type of evasion that has been going on. In the county from which I come time and again I have had letters from people in America saying what a desperate thing it is to interfere with the family homestead and they have as much intention of returning to the family homestead as I have of flying to the moon. In many cases people know land will be reported and that some of the neighbours have been agitating about vacant land or lands let, and to spite these they would transfer to any distant relation for the purpose of frustrating the Land Commission proceedings.
If the House thinks I am taking a snap judgment on this, I shall have another look at it between now and Report Stage. What I have said has not been said lightly. It is my experience and the suggestion I have thrown out as a method of evasion, the transfer to a son for the purpose of frustrating the Land Commission proceedings and the son, the following day, making a deal with some of his relations, would defeat the whole purpose for which this very section is here to deal.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear the Minister say that he proposes to have another look at this before Report Stage. I should like, finally, to put on record a few points that have occurred to me since the Minister started to speak and which I feel may be of help to him. On the Second Reading of the Bill I said I feared that in order to carry out some very desirable sections of this Bill the Minister was prepared to invade the reasonable rights of farmers and landowners. If the Minister does not yield something on this reasonably framed amendment, I can only consider his refusal to do so a classical example of the invasion of the reasonable rights of the people I have spoken about.
The Minister asked if a farmer wants to transfer his farm to his son why does he leave it over until the last moment and until the Land Commission move in. The Minister, from his vast professional and political experience and his experience of country people, knows as well as I do that there are many farmers in this country who are unreasonably prepared to hold on to their holdings, even against their own sons, to the very last moment. As a result, land is not made the best use of. The Minister is, therefore, perfectly well aware, and I am satisfied he is, that the only thing that will bring some of these old, and not so old, men to their senses and to their sense of responsibility to their family is the threat of the Land Commission moving in to take over. Then, the family will unite and blood becomes much thicker than water and then the father and the son who did not see eye to eye in the past and who disagreed on fundamental matters in the past will come together in order to keep the farm in the family name and the father will end by handing it over. That is the experience everybody has.
I want to make it perfectly clear the amendment which I have put forward here will not hinder the relief of congestion. If the Minister and the Land Commission want the farm for the relief of congestion and if it is vitally necessary to them, they are welcome to it, as far as I am concerned. They are entitled to it and have plenty of powers to take it.
The second thing I want to say is the amendment which I put forward does not seek to perpetuate the derelict farm or to perpetuate the wrongful or inadequate user of a farm. If the son is not prepared to take over and work the farm properly, the Minister can put a modification into the amendment and the Land Commission can take whatever action they wish to take under the law.
The Minister says all he wants to do is to get after the individual who has a long history as a bad user of land. He has the machinery to do that and he can put the son on trial for a number of years if he wants to do so. There is no use in the Minister saying to me in reply that the Land Commission have power now to put him on trial. I say the son of a farmer should not be left at the mercy of the Land Commission or at the mercy of the Minister. Land owners should still have some rights left, especially when they seek only to exercise those rights in respect of their own children.
The Minister, in answering the case I made, went very far outside the amendment. I leave it to the House to judge whether it is a wide, far flung amendment or whether it is too narrow, as drafted. It reads:
This section shall not apply to the transfer by an owner of land to the child of that owner.
The Minister, when he spoke about transfer of land to outsiders, spoke about jumping the legal gun of the Land Commission but this amendment certainly does not extend to strangers. It is no more than an appeal to the Minister to recognise the right of a father, even if he has been guilty of failure to use his land to the best advantage, to transfer that land to a son, provided (a) the land is not required for congestion and (b) the son is prepared to use it. I do not care what language the Minister uses to amend or modify my amendment, so long as it guarantees to the owner of land the right to do as he wishes.
Comment on this
All I want to say is that the Land Commission would not be there at all but for the fact that land is required for the relief of congestion. A man could have a farm for years in a congested area which is vitally necessary for the relief of people on £2, £3 or £4 valuation. The Land Commission duly get after this person and serve notice under this section. The owner can defeat that notice by making a transfer overnight. He can transfer it to a married daughter living in Dublin. Generally speaking, those concerned with this problem know there is wild land hunger and fantastic prices paid for land in the congested areas. There are people who accumulate land in those areas, possibly shopkeepers or cattle dealers. If this device is there, this person can defeat the Land Commission notice by transferring the land to a married daughter in Dublin. He can sell, inside 24 hours, to the local shopkeeper. Anybody who is familiar with rural Ireland knows that that is the position and that it is used as a means of evasion. However, as I said, I shall have another look at this. I still say, in genuine cases, as suggested by the Senator, if a case is put up, there will be no question of the Land Commission not withdrawing their proceedings.
Comment on this
The Chair would wish, at this stage, to ask Senators to consider seriously the necessity of avoiding repetition.
Comment on this
The Land Commission were not the most popular institution in this country some years ago when they were acquiring land for four per cent Land Bonds. However, the Land Commission have adopted the policy of paying the market value for farms and if that policy is continued——
Comment on this
Surely that is not in order on this amendment. Can the Senator relate it to the amendment?
Comment on this
It relates to the difficulty they have been experiencing in acquiring the land but if they continue paying the market value, then the Minister will not have to say that farmers are jumping the gun. If the farmer gets the same price from the Land Commission as he would get from someone else, I cannot see his objection to selling to the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I shall withdraw my amendment as the Minister has promised to have another look at it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) On being notified by a person (hereafter called the prospective purchaser) that he has entered into a contract to purchase land the Land Commission shall on request from the prospective purchaser state whether any notice has been served pursuant to subsection (2) of this section in relation to such land and any such notice served within the following six months following the date of such notification shall be served on the prospective purchaser in addition to the owner."
I readily admit that this is largely a conveyancing amendment which I trust the Minister and I will understand, whether we agree on it or not. If this section is passed as it at present is, it means that once the notice is published in Iris Oifigiúil, or once the notice referred to in subsection (2) of the section is served, all dealings in the land are frozen until proceedings in the Land Commission are terminated or for a period of three months. Another subsection says:
Any attempted or purported sale, transfer, letting, sub-letting or subdivision in contravention of this section shall be null and void against all persons.
As the Minister will appreciate, that is going to place a solicitor, acting for a purchaser or, indeed, a purchaser, acting for himself, in a very difficult position in relation to investigation of title. He will have to find out whether, at any time up to the date that he registers his transfer of conveyance, such a notice has been served. Subject to correction, I think, if before he perfects his title by registering his conveyance in the Registry of Deeds or by registering his transfer or the transfer of the land in the Land Registry, the notice is published in Iris Oifigiúil or the notice served, he will have lost title. I quite readily concede that publication in Iris Oifigiúil is not so important because a person can check up on that, but I should like to know if the Minister has considered the difficulty that may confront the person who buys land in respect of which the notice has been served, the notice mentioned in subsection (2).
My amendment seeks to ask the Land Commission to keep a register of such notices and to inform the prospective purchaser whether or not the notice has been served. It goes on to suggest that once a prospective purchaser puts the Land Commission on notice that he is interested in purchasing these lands or has signed a contract to purchase them, the Land Commission shall serve a notice within six months on the prospective purchaser. I do not think that is unreasonable.
My amendment has been put down for the purpose of putting forward this argument, and for the purpose of asking the Minister to provide protective machinery for the prospective purchaser. Quite possibly the machinery outlined by me is not the best possible.
It may not even be practical, but I urge on the Minister that some such machinery is necessary for the prospective purchasers, and to make the work of their advisers tolerable.
Comment on this
This amendment is unnecessary and would be impractical. The first part of the Senator's amendment would mean that the Land Commission would be constantly answering standard queries from purchasers all over the country. This is a matter which is done at present, and I suggest should continue to be done by requisition on title between the solicitors concerned, that is, the solicitor for the purchaser and the solicitor for the vendor. The second part of the amendment could be used to frustrate acquisition proceedings by compelling the Land Commission to serve copy notices on prospective purchasers who may be men of straw.
Whatever views the Senator may have, I would like to refer him to subsection (5) which provides:
Whenever a provisional list or a notice referred to in this section affecting registered land is published or served, the Land Commission shall furnish a copy of the list or notice to the Registrar of Titles who shall, upon receipt by him of such copy, make such entries in the appropriate register as appear to him to be necessary.
The Senator has evidently overlooked the fact that when we serve a notice it will be in the Land Registry in the particular folio concerned in the sale.
Comment on this
The Minister has said this can be dealt with by way of requisition on title between the solicitors for the purchaser and the vendor. As the Minister knows, requisitions on title merely ask for information and get answers.
Comment on this
Which constitutes a binding contract and entitles the prospective purchaser to follow the vendor for damages, but what use is this if the vendor has cleared out of the country or if the vendor is a man of straw?
As we all know, there are delays in the Land Commission. One of the Minister's arguments in favour of the Bill is that there are delays in the Land Commission. Subsection (5) provides: "Whenever a provisional list or a notice referred to in this section affecting registered land is published or served..." Is that the provisional list mentioned in subsection (1) or would that cover the notice served under subsection (2)? At any rate, subsection (5) provides:
Whenever a provisional list or a notice referred to in this section affecting registered land is published or served, the Land Commission shall furnish a copy of the list or notice to the Registrar of Titles who shall, upon receipt by him of such copy, make such entries in the appropriate register as appear to him to be necessary.
Some time could elapse between the serving of the notice and its forwarding to the Land Registry. I know from inquiries made in the Land Registry that delays can take place there. We have the Central Land Registry here, and presumably those will be sent to the Central Land Registry, but practitioners are entitled to search in one of the many district registries throughout the country, and it will be days later when the information comes down. All I am asking is that the Minister should set up a register of these notices so that they can be inspected in the Land Commission immediately they are served. There is something controversial about this section but there is nothing controversial about the amendment. It merely seeks to protect the purchasers and to make the work of their legal advisers easier.
Presumably when this Bill was being drafted, it was drafted from the angle of the Land Commission, or with a Civil Service slant. It is not unreasonable that I should come in here and put up these arguments from the point of view of the legal practitioners who will have to get over this type of difficulty. In all seriousness, I say to the Minister he should not take a firm stand on this amendment now, but should afford himself an opportunity of considering it and perhaps discussing it with representatives of the Incorporated Law Society, or the Rules Committee under the Registration of Titles Act and, if necessary, bring in an amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
There is no necessity for me to consider this for two minutes.
For donkey's years, notices have been published in Iris Oifigiúil, with no registration, no notification to the Land Registry, and no notification anywhere. There was the ordinary requisition on title as the Senator well knows in proceedings pending or threatened. That was for the protection of the purchaser. There is not a bit of difference in this except that for the first time we are notifying the Land Registry and they would be prohibited under the law from accepting a transfer in any case unless the consent of the Land Commission had been obtained. So the solicitor concerned can do what he has done for the past 50 years. He can either furnish an ordinary requisition on the title or write to the Land Commission and ask them have they any proceedings pending or threatening. The solicitor acting for the purchaser can, and should, and must, unless he is negligent, bespeak a copy of the folio concerned and make search in the Land Registry.
There is no necessity for this amendment. As a matter of fact, it is being made far easier here than it was before to ascertain in a simple way whether the Land Commission have moved or have not moved and whether proceedings are pending or not pending.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) Any land owner who wishes to dispose, by way of sale of his property, as a unit, shall be free to do so, and shall not have to seek the consent or approval of the Land Commission under this section."
The Minister in reply to the Second Reading debate at column 361, volume 58 No. 5 said:
The law against subdivision and fragmentation which applies now to 85 or 90 per cent of the land will apply to all land in future. Because of the misrepresentation that has taken place, one would imagine we were seeking some fantastic power. Nothing could be further from the truth. Could there be anything more illogical than the State providing millions—mark you, this is an expensive business—to build up economic units and, at the same time, allowing anybody at his own will and pleasure to fragment his holding in any way he wishes? It certainly does not make sense to me and I am sure it does not make sense to sensible men inside and outside this House.
The building up of these units should be the concern of all of us.
If the Minister means what he then said I do not imagine he will object to this amendment because if a farmer sells his holding in one lot to a landless man the result will still be the same number of holdings or farms; if he sells it to a smallholder it will mean that another farmer will have a more economic and viable unit, and the latter will be the more likely to happen. For that reason the Minister should consider the amendment. The vast number of sales in the midlands, at least in the arable parts, are of small holdings of under 30 or 40 acres and if the Government in their efforts to tackle and settle this problem of congestion want to do away with red tape are going, in the process, to entangle the genuine farming community in never-ending rolls of red tape, it would be a pity. This is a reasonable amendment because in no way will it affect the position of the congests. Furthermore, the Commission will have the opportunity of going to the auction and buying the holding or the farm and if they are the highest bidders this is the way it should be.
It has only been in comparatively recent years that the Land Commission started paying the market value for a farm and since then the farmers' antagonism towards the Commission has almost vanished. Nowadays people do not mind the Commission inquiring after holdings—I am speaking for the midlands—and it was only when the Commission were acquiring farms and paying in practically useless four per cent land bonds that people took exception to the Commission. If the Minister accepts this amendment it will certainly not mean more red tape for the ordinary hard-working farmers in the midlands, the men who earn their bread by the sweat of their brow and who are working seven days a week every week of the year. It will allow them a right they have enjoyed for over 100 years, that is, the right of free sale. If the Minister should say that it defeats the purpose at least he could qualify the amendment by allowing it to apply in areas which are not congested areas.
Comment on this
This section has nothing whatever to do with the ordinary hard-working farmer of the midlands or any other hard-working farmer who is working his lands or is in possession of them. The only point of the section is to prevent landowners from carrying out quick sales while they are subject to inspection or while proceedings are going on. The cases involved are the kind of cases where there has been a long history of bad user and so on. If the amendment were accepted the section might as well not be there. Normally, the owner who wishes to defeat the proceedings sells his holding as one unit. He would not attempt to sell it piecemeal because invariably such partial sale would entail the consent of the Land Commission which, of course, would not be forthcoming when there were proceedings pending for the acquisition of the lands.
The necessity for this section has been recognised by all parties to meet the abuse that it was designed to defeat and if the amendment was accepted you could scrap the whole section and indeed, you could largely forget about the Bill being an instrument of any use whatever for the purpose for which it is designed, that is for the relief of congestion.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that this is to stop farmers from selling land during the process of acquisition but the explanatory memorandum states:
Section 13 introduces a system of control on dealings in land in respect of which the Land Commission propose to institute or actually have instituted acquisition or resumption proceedings.
Now, if we take this in conjunction with section 27, where the political head of the Commission has power, and can issue instructions, which can be done under short notice under this section, it also interferes with the right of free sale. This section is a prohibition on the sale, transfer, letting or subletting of land and definitely purports to restrict what is known as the three F's. Let there be no doubt about that. This arbitrary section is more in keeping with the USSR or Hitler's Germany about which the Tánaiste was speaking recently.
Comment on this
We are interested in natural justice. The farmer is entitled to his rights and we want to see that the owner of property gets his full price and the market value for his property. This is something about which the Minister was so concerned in the 1950 Act when he tabled a motion to that effect and spoke to that effect. Let there be no denying that the price of land will be depreciated under this section. You will have local agitation and intimidation and you will not have free sale. When the notice is served, the farmer, who has land for sale, may have neighhours who are interested; the agitation will start and those people will not give the market value for the land. The man who has the land and who is entitled to the market value will definitely lose heavily because of the section.
There were other people away back in 1950 who also wanted to see the farmer and the landowner get justice and fair play and a fair price. Senator Ó Ciosáin was one of those people who spoke at that time and I quote from volume 118 at column 1263:
If I were a land owner and if I were trying to make use of the land as best I could, in accordance with good methods of husbandry, as the term goes, I would like to know that every safeguard will be given to me before I would be compelled to part with that land—every safeguard as to the price that would be paid and everything else. It appears to me that some of those safeguards are being weakened.
He also said at column 1264:
Reference has been made to the proposal under which the Minister's agents will be able to go into the open market to purchase land, I do not intend to go into that very much, because it has been dealt with elaborately already. It appears to me to be somewhat of an interference with one of the three F's—free sale.
The Senator was interested at that time in free sale just as we are interested in free sale now.
Comment on this
You should read that again because I made use of the words "working the land in accordance with proper methods of husbandry". The farmer who does that need have no fear at all of the provisions of this Bill.
Comment on this
We know that if a farmer is not working his land, it can be taken from him at present. This is going to get at other farmers. If the need were not there, there would be no necessity for this Bill. The late Mr. Moylan said, as reported in volume 118, column 905 on l6th November 1949:
I have in great measure come around to the idea that a man's property shall not be taken from him without giving him adequate compensation, and I suppose that adequate compensation must be interpreted as market value, though arriving at market value will not be a very easy matter.
I claim that once this notice is served, the farmer or property owner, the man who is entitled to justice and fair play from this or any Government, is not going to get market value for his land. He is entitled to get that and it is our duty the best we can to bring home to the Minister the necessity for seeing that the farmer gets market value for his land. This section, if it goes through as it is, will stop any farmer from getting market value for his land.
Comment on this
The section cannot possibly affect the market value, any more than the service of a section 40 notice, followed by compulsory proceedings, today affects market values. The same procedure will apply. Under the law as it stands, the Land Commission must offer not a price for the purpose of bargaining but what in their view is the market value of the land. The owner in such a case who is dissatisfied with that offer has the right, as he will have under this Bill, to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, to produce his valuers there who will give evidence, no doubt as they do at the moment, of prices per acre or per farm of comparable farms that were realised anywhere in the district by them or others, and the judge of the High Court who presides over that Tribunal will decide as between that evidence and the evidence of the Land Commission as to what the market value of the particular land may be.
Under the existing law, except that the procedure is far too slow, we have exactly the same position as will obtain under this Bill, that once the Land Commission get as far as serving their notice in Iris Oifigiúil, they can then in effect prevent the sale without their consent. In such a case today, I think nobody can say that the owner has not got market value for his land. The very same law will apply if this Bill is passed. He will have the same right to go before the Appeal Tribunal if he is not satisfied with the price offered to him by the Land Commission.
It has happened, is happening and will happen in the future, that in certain instances the Land Commission, because of the price fixed by the Appeal Tribunal, may pull out and leave the Land there. Whereas the owner has an appeal to the Appeal Tribunal against the price which the Land Commission are advised and consider to be the market value, the Land Commission have no appeal on the question of price. Therefore the law provides that if the Appeal Tribunal in any case fixes a price which the Land Commission consider to be outrageous, they have power to withdraw completely out of the proceedings and not to acquire the land. Of course, you can have a decision of that kind depending upon the kind of evidence that is produced before the Appeal Tribunal where in certain instances the long bow may be drawn by witnesses giving evidence as to value, just as you can have remarkable decisions on the question of damages in the ordinary civil law case.
The very same law will apply. The owner will have the same right to have the judge of the High Court fix a market value if he is not satisfied with the offer made to him. I cannot in view of that see how it can be argued that this notice is going to devalue the land any more than publication of the notice under section 40 in Iris Oifigiúil does under the law as it exists today.
Comment on this
This is the section which prohibits the sale, transfer, letting or sub-letting, except with the consent of the Land Commission, of land concerning which the Land Commission have instituted or Propose to institute proceedings for acquisition. When proceedings have been instituted, the control period runs until the termination of those proceedings. Where notice of inspection with a view to possible acquisition has been served, the control period runs for three months and if necessary, it can be extended for another three months. I regard this as drastic interference with the rights of ownership.
The proposal is that by simply serving a notice of inspection, a Land Commission officer, a senior inspector or person of higher rank, can freeze all dealings in the land for a period of three months and then for a further period of three months. I appreciate the necessity of empowering the Land Commission to take prompt and effective action in certain circumstances, but I consider that the period of control should be reduced to one month, with power to give the Minister another month and if necessary, perhaps an extension to a third month.
Any owner of land can be at very serious loss if his land is frozen for three months and he is prohibited from letting, sub-letting or selling it during that period. As I said before, the long delay will lead to agitation and intimidation. Even the Minister in 1950 was very concerned about farmers getting the market value. He stated at that time, on the 29th March, 1950, and I quote from the Dáil Debates of that date at column 261:
"The Land Commission are interested in this farm, they are going to take it under the powers vested in them; if they do not take it one way, they will take it in another." That means that the vendor's market in his holding is destroyed.
We did not go so far as to say it was destroyed but the Minister did, whether it was shedding crocodile tears or not. He went on to say:
He will have to accept whatever the offer is that is made by the gentlemen from the Land Commission.
That rebuts what the Minister stated a few moments ago that the Land Commissioners will give him the market value. The Minister continued:
He will have to accept whatever the offer is that is made by the gentlemen from the Land Commission or else he can sit back and wait for a notice to be published in Iris Oifigiúil declaring that his farm is needed for the relief of congestion.
Further down the Minister stated:
he is going to frighten off intending purchasers.
Then, he continued, at column 262:
I have no doubt that it will destroy the sale of a particular farm in the public market.
The Minister stated a few moments ago that the Land Commission will give the market value but, at this particular time, he stated that they must "sit back and wait until the gentleman from the Land Commission makes an offer". At the same time, we contend there will be a definite loss. We are not going so far as the Minister by saying the sale of the land will be destroyed.
I should like to refer to Senator Mrs. Ahern's speech. She condemned some of us and lectured some of us as well. I have a cutting from the Irish Independent of the 8th August, 1964, about a meeting of the Irish Countrywomen's Association and they were speaking on section 13 of this Bill which we are discussing here today.
Comment on this
The Senator may have only just come in, but we are discussing the section, as amended, now. I want to quote what the Irish Countrywomen's Association had to say because they were very concerned with section 13 of this Bill. There were 250 people present and the wording of the resolution is:
We, the members of the ICA, protest in the strongest possible terms against those provisions of the Land Bill, 1963, which seek to deprive the Irish farmer of the ownership of his land, won, after long years of hardship, eviction, deportation, imprisonment and death and to reduce him to the status of a mere tenant-at-will of the State.
We say that these provisions are not only repugnant to the Constitution, which guarantees the right to private property, but render nugatory the natural right bestowed on man by God to possess property, that he may use and dispose of as he chooses—without interference, so long as he does no injury to his neighbour.
I should like to know whether Senator Mrs. Ahern's assessment of the people who made the insinuations and innuendos at that meeting is that "suspicion haunts the guilty mind". It must haunt the minds of the majority of the members of the Irish. Countrywomen's Association. Or does Senator Mrs. Ahern speak as a member of the Irish Countrywomen's Association or as a member of the Fianna Fáil Party? As such, I do not blame her but she certainly did not speak on behalf of the Irish Countrywomen's Association because this resolution was passed unanimously at a meeting at which 250 members were present.
It has been suggested by Senator Mooney that our opposition to certain sections of the Bill have been considered and that we were obstructive. We have a duty here. It was mentioned 12 or 14 times last year, but we have a duty and we come here to sift and make constructive suggestions if necessary. In 1950 the Minister came in and said he wanted the Bill. It was held up in the Dáil. Nobody blamed any of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time for making the self same arguments we are making today.
Comment on this
The Minister from the time the Bill was introduced until it passed the Dáil inserted 46 or 47 new amendments in the Bill. That shows the constructive suggestions made in the Dáil had some effect with the Minister. Our opposition to this section is motivated by a grave sense of responsibility, by the merits of the proposal it contains. The real issue is: do the farmers who are supposed to own the land really own and control it, or is the land of Ireland to be controlled by the State or by the Land Commission? It boils down to that. We should all remember that Irish traditions are founded on Irish land from which we all sprang and to which we must all one day inevitably return. Unless we have the fundamental guarantee of the natural law to own land, to invest in, dispose of or work the land to the best of our ability, there can be no future for the Irish farmer or for Irish agriculture.
I have stated and it cannot be denied that the effect of this section is that land will be divided and the Government will use it in conjunction with section 27 for the purpose of exerting political pressure on those who do not actively support them.
Comment on this
Nonsense; do not be entering that caveat again. I asked you for names and places the last day; it is time to stop and grow up.
Comment on this
I think the Leader of the House ought to address the Chair.
Comment on this
It is a form of dictatorship and it could have the effect of turning back the pages of history and throwing away what was gained by the Irish farmers after years of bloodshed and struggle. We know the people in the congested area of Ireland have their rights, but the landowners in the rest of Ireland have their rights, too, and we are not prepared to abolish the rights of free sale and fixity of tenure which took generations of struggle and loss of life to obtain. I oppose this section.
Comment on this
First of all, I did not expect to be brought into the discussion at all. I was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party before I even heard of the Irish Countrywomen's Association. I think it must have been in Carlow that the Bill was discussed but it was not the verdict of the Irish Countrywomen's Association.
Comment on this
During my Presidency, this never came before the Association as a resolution. Therefore, whatever views were discussed were not the views of the Irish Countrywomen's Association as a whole. They were individual views and the same thing happened in Carlow. Two people spoke on the Land Bill there. There was a discussion but there was no resolution put to the body of the Irish Countrywomen's Association. It was very surprising the report said nothing about the woman who said it was the first thing that was done to save the west. Miss Browne from Cleggan said she welcomed the Bill but that did not get any publicity. The views expressed there were individual views and had nothing whatever to do with the body of the association.
Comment on this
Let me say this: I am accused of putting in something that would be typical of Stalin in the USSR or Hitler an Germany. Senator L'Estrange, at that time, was much more familiar with those people than I ever was.
Comment on this
I object to such accusations which degrade Irish politics.
Comment on this
The more I listen to people like Senator L'Estrange talking about me being a Hitler under this Bill, and consider what he and his beshirted pals were doing at that time, the more I think it is time we got down to what we are really asking here. The reference to what I said on the 1950 Act in the Dáil is really only relevant in so far as it has proved my political stability over 15 years.
I argued then that the farmers should get the market value where the State took over land. The law prior to then was that the price paid for land acquired by the Land Commission should be the price that was reasonable to the Land Commission for their purposes and reasonable to the farmer, which of course is an entirely different matter from giving the market value. As a result of my argument at that time and others, it was decided, and was so enacted, that in future the market value would be paid. Actually the procedure suggested by me as to how the market value should be arrived at is now the stock procedure before the Appeal Tribunal. The position before that was as I have said.
The position now is that, where land is required, no matter for what purpose, the owner is entitled to market value. When the Land Commission go to take over lands, the offer they make is not an offer in the hope of coming up like the man buying a cow in a field. They must make an offer to the individual concerned, which they consider to be the market value. In many instances that has worked out well and can prove to be fair to the Land Commission and to the taxpayer. Naturally, when a matter of this kind comes before the court and an offer is made that is unacceptable to the owner, the people aze inclined to think the Land Commission when making their offer did not offer what the owner would ultimately get.
I can assure the Seanad that the Land Commission receive the advice of their own experts about the market value. If the owner is not satisfied, he can go to the appeal tribunal. They are an independent body. The Appeal Board is presided over by a High Court judge. He listens to evidence of the value of sales of land in the area and he decides in that way what the market value is. That very same procedure will be there when this Bill passes as it has been there and in practice, over the last number of years.
Let me point out that the adequate protection of the Land Commission about providing adequate employment and adequate production was decided in a legal decision in a case known as the Jenkinson case. The owner was letting his lands to others in conacre. The people to whom he was letting the land were working the land. That turned out to be a defence against the Land Commission acquisition of lands which were let. Of course, it made new case law. It made another prohibition on acquiring lands that have been habitually let over a period of years.
There was another legal decision in what is known as the Quinlan case. If it were shown before the court that the new owner, irrespective of whether he used the land for 20 years before, was now working the lands, then the Land Commission proceedings were frustrated and finished with. The owner succeeded. It is to deal with those cases, first, the Jenkinson case decision; about 1953, and the Quinlan decision in the Supreme Court about 1962 that we have this provision. Those decisions enable people, who have a bad land user history, and possibly a record of absenteeism, or people who have let their lands for quite a long time, to defeat the Land Commission acquiring such lands for the relief of congestion. It is to get over these forms of abuse that this section is here.
As I have said, all parties concerned with the relief of congestion realise the necessity for this particular section. The National Farmers Association, who are interested naturally in the relief of congestion for their own members in the congested counties in the west have said:
We appreciate the necessity of empowering the Land Commission to take prompt and effective action in certain circumstances but we consider that the Land Commission prohibition under this section on transfer, letting and subletting should be limited to one month.
We had arguments as to whether the period should be one, three or six months but there was no argument from any responsible body of opinion that the section should not be there or that this power was not necessary for the Land Commission to deal with the situations I have described here, of the frustrating of the Land Commission and debarring them from acquiring these lands which are so badly needed for the relief of congestion.
It is quite obvious from the opposition launched by Fine Gael against this section, both here and in the other House, that they are not concerned with the relief of congestion, but are concerned——
Comment on this
——with giving lip service to the relief of congestion when they are speaking in the west of Ireland, but when we come to this section that will be of immense help to the Land Commission in getting this land which is vital for the relief of congestion, the three "F's" are trotted out, and we are told it is an invasion of the farmers' rights, and cannot pass. Everyone here and outside knows that unless we can get powers to deal with this job, we are wasting our time trying to solve the congestion problem. The necessity for this section has been recognised by every responsible body inside and outside this Chamber who have discussed it. While there has been disagreement about the period of time, there has been no disagreement about the necessity for the section. This Bill would be useless without it, and I am asking the House to pass the section as it stands.
Comment on this
Section 13 has been described as a drastic section and it is one of the controversial sections the Land Bill contains. To my mind without section 13 this Bill would be nothing more than pious platitudes. It has been stated that the powers contained in this section are drastic. As a matter of fact they are considered by many to be too drastic an interference with the rights of farmers. I cannot agree that that is so. I believe that if we had a similar section to section 13 in many of the previous Land Bills that were passed, we might not be discussing a 1963 Land Bill at the moment, because I believe that it was for the lack of a section similar to section 13 that so much land slipped through the net of the Land Commission, and is not now worked and used by the people of this country for whom the first Land Act was intended, and for the relief of congestion.
Every genuine effort made by the Land Commission to acquire estates in many parts of the country was defeated by all types of subterfuges and, indeed, I believe many forms of subterfuge may be used by the slick people with whom the Land Commission will have to deal, to defeat section 13. At least we can say section 13 goes much further to bring more land into the net of the Land Commission than any section we have had in any other Land Bill.
I do not visualise the Land Commission or the Minister using any unconstitutional methods to acquire land, nor do I visualise the Land Commission introducing or adopting USSR methods to acquire land. We all know there are many large tracts of land in this State that are not being utilised in the best interest of the State, which are owned by Mayfair or Grafton Street farmers as a hobby or as a place in which to put away money. The genuine farmer who utilises his land in his own best interest, and the interests of the nation, has nothing to fear from this Bill or this section. I certainly welcome the section and I believe that without this section the Bill would not be worth discussing.
Comment on this
I oppose this section for a number of reasons. I find it hard to believe the Minister when he says one thing, and there is something different in black and green in the Bill itself. This section prohibits, the sale, transfer letting or subletting of certain lands without the consent of the Land Commission. The Minister said:
Could there be anything more illogical than the State providing millions... to build up economic units and, at the same time, allowing anybody at his own will and pleasure to fragment his holding in any way he wishes.
At the same time he insists on introducing additional red tape which will affect a great majority of Irish farmers who wish to dispose of their property or who wish to transfer their property. There is a widespread practice in rural Ireland whereby farmers sign over their holdings to their sons or daughters and then become eligible for old age pensions. I can see this section introducing additional red tape that will cause unnecessary delays.
I also believe the section cuts across section 6 which encourages farmers to retire. We now have a situation in which farmers voluntarily sign over their holdings to their sons or daughters who wish to marry, and when this Bill passes that will be delayed for at least three months. At the same time, the farmers will be brought to the notice of the Land Commission and people will be in doubt as to whether their lands will be confiscated or acquired for division purposes.
I believe too much stress is being placed on the congested areas when only small sections of the country are scheduled as congested districts. I would have thought the Minister would have introduced some qualification into the section to enable farmers in non-congested areas to dispose of their property a little more easily. With the excellent Civil Service the Minister has at his disposal, it should be possible to write those sentiments into the Bill. The Bill emphatically states one thing, and the Minister says something which is almost different. He says there is no fear about the provisions of the Bill, and that they will not apply. I know the Civil Service to be excellently qualified personnel and surely it is not beyond their capabilities to write that in once and for all, and leave no ground for fears.
The question of valuation for sale has been raised. I cannot see where difficulties arise for the Land Commission if they pursue a policy of buying the lands they acquire at public auctions. If they go to a public auction and are the highest bidders, no one will object to them purchasing a holding. That is the most satisfactory way that land has been acquired in the past. It is wrong to impose additional handicaps on farmers. After all, they are the only section of the community who live behind the times. They have to work late and early; they have no union hours and still have a seven-day week. For additional hardships to be placed on the community in this way is certainly not conducive to encouraging younger generations to devote their lives to the land. In a world in which a huge proportion of the population is almost starving the Government should strive to do everything possible to encourage more people to devote their lives to farming.
The fact that this section would make it more difficult for young farmers to succeed to their fathers' holdings is deplorable. As most people know, older farmers are sometimes difficult to convert to modern ideas and sometimes it is only after great persuasion that they allow the introduction even of modern machinery and modern methods of farming and husbandry into the farms. Here we have a section in a 1963 Bill, being passed in 1965, which is going to add to the difficulty of young farmers bringing their places into line and making them viable holdings. I regret very much that the Minister could not amend this very drastic section. It may have benefits for the congested districts but certainly it will be a grave cause of hardship for the majority of the farming community.
Comment on this
Anyone who is really sincere in helping the Land Commission to provide land for the small holders must support this Bill. This section in my opinion is one of the most important and by it people who want to sell land to anyone other than the Land Commission will be stopped in their efforts. I was rather surprised to hear Senator L'Estrange compare the Minister's action to that of a Hitlerite action. If it takes a Hitlerite to do this, then I must say I am very surprised indeed. It was not the Minister for Lands who once said that the Blackshirts were victorious in Italy and the Brownshirts in Germany and that the Blueshirts would be successful here. It was not the Minister who said on the 28th February, 1934——
Comment on this
The blackguards were stopping free speech when they were put down by the Blueshirts.
Comment on this
How does the Senator relate this to the Land Bill?
Comment on this
I shall just conclude by saying that the Land Commission will be in a position to prevent any sales to people other than to those who deserve land from the Land Commission and the result will be that smallholders in the west and northwest will benefit considerably.
Comment on this
I have certain misgivings about this. Too many extreme cases have been quoted on both sides. The fact is if land is wanted, and it is wanted, it can be taken under several sections. The main question is the question of market value and surely it would appear that the sale is, by and large, the only means of determining market value. We all know about rules of thumb and so on, and that land cannot go over a certain price. That must be the approach of a body like the Land Commission buying outside the public market but I cannot see why the Land Commission would not compete more actively on the public market and buy all the land they want. The amount of land that comes up for sale every year is at least four or five times the amount acquired by the Land Commission in any one year. It is nonsense, therefore, to say that the Land Commission cannot get what land they want. Land is for sale and we see farms being sold that could be divided. Half of County Limerick has been bought up by a big landowner. In the year 1957 the purchase price of land per holding was £1,625 out of a total cost of £4,116.
Comment on this
Would the Senator say where he got his figures for half the land of Limerick being bought.
Comment on this
It was just 40 per cent of the total cost and we are quibbling about the market value of it being determined by some formula.
That formula is going to determine market value for £160 and one might have to go another 10 per cent or 15 per cent in some places in the open market. We calmly accepted an administration cost of £420 per farm back in 1957. If you want to solve the land congestion problem the open market solves it any time and if the Land Commission go into the open market they can buy next year or in any year twice the amount they would settle this year and get it without any negotiations whatever simply by lifting a finger.
If perhaps they believe it has been puffed they have their remedy—just let the puffer keep it. If the person who outbids them in the open market is not making proper use of that land the Land Bill is there and they can take it from him in a year or two if necessary, so that you have your remedies and there is no need whatsoever to trespass on the right of the private citizen. We are just talking in terms of what may mean a plus or minus £50,000 on the land bill in the year. It is something that will level itself out in due course. Market value cannot be determined in any other way except with reference to the market. That holds whether it is in land or any other property. Consequently, I feel that many of the misgivings expressed on section 13 are highly justified. I also feel that if the section were not in the Bill and the Minister simply employed a good buying agent he could get twice the amount of land to subdivide as has been subdivided this year. The only brake on the Minister is the amount that the Department of Finance are prepared to put at his disposal in any one year.
I would appeal, whether we have section 13 in or out of the Bill, that the Minister would make far more use of the public market. I know of a farm of 240 acres of real good land which was for sale recently in County Limerick. It was making a reasonable figure of around £30,000 on the market. Where was the representative of the Land Commission at that sale? The price was not in any way exorbitant but there was no bid by the Land Commission. I do not see why not. A lot of this section 13 is an unnecessary complication of a problem that could be solved properly and much more speedily by adopting the ordinary commercial methods. I hold strongly that there is far more land to be bought in public auctions than the Minister will ever be capable of handing out for the relief of congestion in any one year.
Comment on this
Out of the volume of froth and bubbles we have heard from Senator Quinlan just now might I try to bring him back to earth and ask him would he give us his authority for his statement that half the land of County Limerick was bought by big landlords. When, where and how did he get that authority?
Comment on this
I shall deal with that on another section of this Bill.
Comment on this
If the Senator knew Limerick as well as I do he would know the very genuine concern——
Comment on this
We do not want another speech. I just want an answer to the question. This is typical of the Senator's attitude to things in general. He uses this language and then when he is challenged to produce his authority he starts another speech.
Comment on this
It is typical of this debate that when we think we are coming to a decision someone starts a red herring again.
Comment on this
I do not think that Senator Stanford is correct in suggesting that I am introducing a red herring. I am looking for information, to know what is the authority for Senator Quinlan's fantastic statement.
Comment on this
The Senator may be quoted as saying the exact opposite of what he said today because as a representative of a Party he can be excused for changing his mind when it becomes necessary for Party policy. I stand here as an Independent and I have to stand over every word I utter.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan did not purport to quote from anything and accordingly he cannot be asked to give his authority. I cannot force him to give his authority. He has, however, indicated that he is prepared to deal with the matter at some more length on a further section, and I do not think that I can go any further or that Senator Ó Maoláin can do anything but accept that at this stage.
Comment on this
Is the House agreed to accept section 13 as amended?
Comment on this
Before the discussion is brought to a close on the section I should like to say that being a member of a Party here I have not changed my mind about this question of land tenure. Senator L'Estrange quoted me as saying on the occasion of the debate on the 1950 Land Act that every safeguard should be given to the farmer who works his land in accordance with proper methods of husbandry. They were my sentiments then and they are my views now.
There is no departure from that principle in this section.
Comment on this
I am standing behind the section. Any amount of fire and fury has been brought into this debate, especially on section 13, so much so that it would be as well that we would have a decision of the House on it to find out who are in favour of the system of land tenure, the three Fs and so on and who are not.
Comment on this
Unless Senator Ó Donnabháin is voting against this section——
Comment on this
I think we know what the Senator has in mind. We have been listening to Senator L'Estrange and other Fine Gael representatives plus their exterior ally Professor Quinlan all day today and all day yesterday, and the least we could know now is that they are prepared to go on record as being against this section. That, I think, is what is in Senator Ó Donnabháin's mind. Surely they are prepared to stand up and be counted against this section. As far as I know there are only two or three.
Comment on this
I want to object in the strongest possible terms to the statement by the Leader of the House that I have any connection with any political Party. I do not say that I am in any way better for that, but simply that in my position here I am an Independent and, therefore, I have to take the full brunt of the accuracy of any statement I make. I have to stand behind those statements and I shall stand behind them next year or any year just as firmly as I do now in this House.
Comment on this
I want to protest in the strongest possible way at the way in which the business of this House has been held up for hours especially discussing this section 13 which is a vital section of the Bill.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Senator to continue on this line. A protest against the length of time that this is taking appears to be a reflection on the Chair that order has not been preserved—I mean the Chair in globo, not being personal about it. I think that people are entitled to discuss matters. The only thing I would say, if I might give an obiter dictum on the matter, is that there is a certain inclination to repetition which for the rest of the debate might be avoided on both sides.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In subsection (2) to add at the end:
", and to all other persons (if any) appearing to be in receipt of the rents and profits or to have control and management of the land in question".
With the permission of the House I will speak for Senator Ross on this amendment and I hope that the Minister will accept it as a reasonable one. The intention is that those who are legally involved in section 14 should be given due notice of the fact. The intention of the amendment is to see that the persons named in subsection (1) of section 14 should be given the courtesy and the common justice of being informed under subsection (2). If there are great difficulties, of course, it cannot be done.
The Minister will tell us; but if there are no great difficulties I wonder would he not yield on this point. It does seem to be unjust that persons who are legally involved should not receive due notice. I would ask the Minister to consider the amendment sympathetically.
Comment on this
I think that possibly Senator Ross did not appreciate the purpose of this section. I presume the Senator fears the Land Commission might deal with one member of a family and leave others at a disadvantage or deal with an agent and leave the principal in the dark. There are two flaws in the proposal. It does not take into consideration subsection (6). The nomination does not override the essential rights of other interested parties. The whole point of section 14 is that it will enable the Land Commission to proceed with their work without the necessity of tracing persons who are not readily available.
The amendment would in many cases oblige them to trace such persons. In other words, it would recreate the type of impasse we are trying to abolish under this particular section.
Perhaps, I could give the House an example. The Land Commission want to commence proceedings against an absent owner but are unable to serve notice because he keeps his address secret. We have a number of these cases. Under section 14 they could appoint a cousin as nominee who is managing the land for the owner or they could appoint somebody to whom he has the lands let, or his agent. If they believe the cousin is transmitting the profits to the owner they must serve a copy of the nomination on the owner of the lands. We must rely on subsection (6) to safeguard the rights of other interested parties. It is important that the fact of nomination does not make the nominee owner of the property, or indeed, of any part or share of it which was not lawfully his in any event. It is a legal device, as I am sure Senator Ross appreciates, to get over the difficulty of trying to trace absentees or a multiplicity of owners. They are people who may have an interest under intestacy or otherwise in land being acquired by the Land Commission. This device of nominee will be there only for the purpose of getting the Land Commission proceedings through.
As far as the purchase money or compensation is concerned, they are the owners of the lands. Whoever they may be, they will have to prove their title to the purchase money in the ordinary way. Senators will appreciate that we have a number of cases in which it is impossible to trace some of these owners, or some people who may be interested in the land in cases where representation has not been received over, perhaps, two or three generations. It it in these cases it is impossible for the Land Commission to proceed, where such proceedings are necessary. The vast majority of these cases arise in congested areas. They may be small cases and it may be vital for Land Commission purposes in rearranging schemes, as it often happens the owners are all over the face of the earth and, in many cases, it is often virtually impossible to trace them. Where there is an agent there or somebody in possession and, generally speaking there is, that person must be appointed. I direct Senators' attention to the wording of the section:
Where, in any proceedings under the Land Purchase Acts, the Land Commission deem it necessary or expedient for the exercise of their powers under those Acts so to do, they may, after compliance with subsection (2) of this section, by order appoint any person or persons appearing to them to be in receipt of the rents and profits or to have the control and management of any land (in this section referred to as the land) or, if there be no such person or persons or if such person or any one of such persons is under a disability, some other person, to be the nominee, for the purposes of those proceedings but for no other purpose.
Before the Land Commission would appoint what I might term a legal stooge, that is one of their officials, for the purpose of operating this particular section the House will see they must first, if these parties are available, appoint as their nominee the person or persons appearing to them to be in receipt of the rents or profits or who have the control or management of the land.
Senators will appreciate that in 99 per cent of cases these people who are in occupation or in receipt of rents or profits, or in control are in touch with the owners wherever they may be and one of these people will be appointed under this section merely for the purpose of enabling these proceedings to go through.
The fears of Senator Ross that some people might be overlooked or people who were not entitled might get the whole of the purchase money do not arise because all the ordinary proofs will have to be adduced before the purchase money or compensation is parted with.
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Minister for a clear and thorough exposition of the case. Right through this Bill he has been good at this; we have all been very much educated. It seems to me what he has said needs careful consideration and, if Senator Ross agrees, I would ask for leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I agree with that. I do not think there is any suggestion behind this amendment that the Land Commission should be appointing a legal stooge, as the Minister called it. The principle behind it is, of course, that they should be in a position to appoint a nominee and merely serve him. If the right nominee is appointed, he will inform all people interested. I certainly agree to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:—
In subsection (3), line 25, to add "; if the appeal is upheld the costs shall be borne by the Land Commission".
This amendment is similar to one I moved yesterday, except I think it applies more forcibly here. In this case if a person appeals against the decision of the Examiner then an appeal goes to the Judicial Commissioner and if the person concerned is not satisfied with the verdict of the Judicial Commissioner, he considers a right of appeal to the Supreme Court on a specific question of law. Appeal to the Supreme Court can be an expensive business and if the appeal is withheld it is only right and proper that the costs should be borne by the Land Commission. I should like to hear whether this is satisfactory to the Minister.
Comment on this
This amendment would involve, I believe, an unwarranted intrusion on the discretion of the Supreme Court. The normal rule is that the successful appellant is invariably awarded costs by the Supreme Court, unless there is some good and sufficient reason for the judge in the Supreme Court refusing costs. The normal rule in those cases is that costs will be awarded where the appellant is successful. Now it would be unique—it was never written into the statute as far as I know—if we were to provide that the Supreme Court must award costs to the successful appellant. The Senator can be assured that is the case.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his explanation and I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not too clear about the changes being made by section 19 and what the Minister really seeks to achieve by this section. We all appreciate the fact that to read this Bill fully, and to know what it contains, we would have to read all the Land Acts from 1923 up, including the 1950 Act we heard so much about today. We fully realise that is not practical. The meaning I was inclined to take from this section was that where there were parcels of land, say, areas of bog separate from the parent holding, and where such parcels were adjacent to one another, it would be possible for the owner of one acre or half an acre to purchase the adjacent parcels and the Land Commission would readily consent to such an operation so as not to create waste. That is quite often the case, where there are such parcels of land some distance from the parent holding. I hope that is what the section means and I should like to hear the Minister confirm that that is so.
Comment on this
This is designed to remove certain doubts about the Land Commission's powers to allocate money under the Land Acts for the purchase and allocation of what we call resell turbary rights, shooting rights, seaweed rights, by way of advance, in the same way as they resell parcels of land and to vest such rights by the same procedures as are used for parcels of land. The basic authority for resale transactions, that is, the resale of tenants' holdings, is section 31 of the Land Act, 1923, which states that "advances may be made to the following persons or bodies for the purchase by them from the Land Commission of parcels of land", and then goes on to name six categories of allottees.
The section is silent as to incorporeal hereditaments; in other words, it is silent about the right of the Land Commission to deal with turbary rights, shooting or fishing rights. Therefore, it is to remove these doubts that we have this section. The Land Commission have made advances of money for this purpose. They have been allocating in the same way as they have been allocating for reselling lands to tenants. That is the purpose of this section and although these practices have not been challenged, the fact remains that the Land Commission cannot point to any clear-cut authority to enable them to deal with those different types of rights in the same way and to advance money for their purchase as they deal with the purchase and allocation of land.
Comment on this
I must confess that I did not take the wrong meaning from the section. I am then inclined to inquire what is the position, under this Bill, in regard to that matter which I think should be raised under this section? There are in many cases parcels of bog——
Comment on this
I do not think it arises under this section. This section deals with incorporeal rights. Parcels of bog land certainly do not come under that heading.
Comment on this
I understood from the Minister it dealt with other rights. The Land Commission seem to be in doubt whether they had clear-cut law.
Comment on this
The Minister is making pretty sure now. My point is that there are cases of parcels of land on which there is bog which is set. If the owner of the land on which the bog is set lives some miles away, it might be easier if that were in the hands of one owner or if the parcel were near where he lived. It seems to me in that sort of area we have developed waste.