Land Bill, 1963: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 132–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
I would suggest that something should be done about this problem. I thought it arose on section 19, but if it is not in section 19, it should be there or in some similar section. My point is such parcels should be easily purchased by anyone. If you had six or ten half-acres, some person should take active steps to consolidate them.
Comment on this
There is a legal way of dealing with this matter. We have this problem in some rural areas with cutaway bog. In some cases it is let for turbary and in other cases it is for resale. In other words, you have exactly the same position as you have with commonage. You have a number of people who have a moiety. There is the very same consideration as there is in commonage but there is a provision in this Bill that will at least make it easier to deal with that situation. It arises on another section which we shall be dealing with later.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
To delete subsection (3) and substitute:
"( ) The powers of the Land Commission under this section shall not be exercised compulsorily in such a way as would be likely to cause serious interference with the amenities of any occupied dwellinghouse in existence at the date of the service by the Land Commission of the notice of intention to exercise such powers."
There are three points in this amendment. Under the subsection, as it stands, it is provided that the Land Commission powers to define and extend or improve rights of way shall not be exercised compulsorily. The first point is that it restricts only the compulsory exercise of the powers of the Land Commission to defining, extending or improving rights of way. Secondly, this right shall not be exercised compulsorily in relation to any right of way over land adjoining an occupied dwellinghouse. I raised a point on the Second Reading as to the meaning of the word "adjoining". I take it to mean quite plainly actually beside an occupied dwellinghouse and that seems to me too close a place for a right of way to be in relation to a dwellinghouse. Thirdly, it applies to an occupied dwellinghouse which was in existence for a period of one year prior to the date of the notice by the Land Commission. A dwellinghouse which was erected six months before the notice could be affected by this subsection.
In effect, the amendment proposes to deal with certain portions of the subsection and to restrict the powers of the Land Commission so that they will not be exercised compulsorily in relation to any right of way under this section. It also attempts to get a more workable definition of "adjoining" by providing that the powers shall not be exercised compulsorily in such way as would be likely to cause serious interference with the amenities of an occupied dwellinghouse. The amenities of an occupied dwellinghouse are, naturally enough, very much wider than something merely adjoining it. It might be that a right of way adjoining an occupied dwellinghouse might not interfere with its amenities, but it could very well be that a right of way over land adjoining an occupied dwellinghouse would seriously interfere with its amenities, and this amendment is an attempt to deal with the amenities of a house. Clearly it would not be right to so interfere with the rights of an owner that his whole privacy could be disturbed by a right of way almost adjoining or, in other words, just outside the subsection, because adjoining, I think, must be right beside; and, if you are not right beside, then you could be just a little outside right beside, and that is almost the same thing as adjoining. If there is a proviso that the amenities of a dwellinghouse shall not be interfered with, then there is some protection for a person in an occupied dwellinghouse.
The final point of this amendment is to remove from the subsection the proviso that the dwellinghouse must have been in existence one year prior to the date of the notice. It seems to me to be utterly wrong that a notice served can affect an occupied dwellinghouse, a house in which someone has been living for one year prior to the date of the notice. This is the first intimation of the intentions of the Land Commission and, if the house is in existence at that point, and occupied, it will probably have been planned a year before, but if the notice is to affect a house which was in existence at the commencement of the year ending on the date of the notice, then it seems to me to be quite unfair.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. There is one further point I should like to raise. I should like to ask the Minister whether subsection (3) could be used in any way to control action under subsection (2).
It does look as if it could. The practical situation I have in mind is something like this: the owner of a house finds that, under some new regulation made by the Land Commission, motorcars will be parked right up against his windows and his front door. Under subsection (2) here, so far as I can see, there is nothing to prevent that. If our amendment is adopted, since that would be interfering with the amenities of the house, it could be prevented. I am seriously worried to think that under subsection (2) life in a house might be made virtually unliveable with the parking of cars right up against the dwellinghouse. Perhaps the Minister can explain—I am sure he can—the situation satisfactorily to us.
Comment on this
One of the first reasons for the introduction of this section is to bring rights of way up to date. Senators may not be aware that it is generally believed that the Land Commission have unrestricted power to create rights of way. That is not, in fact, so under the existing law. They have power to create certain types of rights of way. If, however, it were necessary to extend a right of way from one portion of a holding purchased under the Land Acts to and across land held in absolute fee simple or under a fee farm grant, or which was outside the scope of the Acts for any other reason, then the Land Commission could not do anything with that right of way.
Outside of these particular cases, there is the urgent question in many instances of enabling the Land Commission to make some of these rights of way usable. In many cases they are just what country people call "bridle paths". They originated long before Mr. Ford thought of his tractor. In these days of modern machinery it is essential that the Land Commission should have power to modernise many of these rights of way to enable farmers to bring in machinery. After the enactment of this Bill the Land Commission will have unrestricted power, irrespective of tenure, to improve rights of way. That is No. 1. Secondly they will have power to create new rights of way where such are necessary irrespective of the tenure under which the lands are held.
We have come up against a number of difficulties in relation to local community effort in developing fishing and other amenities. As far as lakes are concerned the law is very complicated indeed. Some lakes are State lakes. In the case of other lakes, it is an interesting study to visualise what might be the position when water, because of a drainage scheme, disappears and new land appears, land that was formerly under the lake. The question is who should have the rights there.
Then you have the other case where there is the old presumption ad medium fluvium—that the riparian owners around the lake claim and assert that out to the middle of the lake they own the land under water and that it is portion of their holding. We have had cases where people were prevented from mooring or parking boats in the water opposite the holdings of some such people and where there have been attempts to hold them up to ransom and to prevent the very desirable development of local communities and angling clubs developing inland fisheries, which are becoming more and more important to our own people and to the tourist business.
Subsection (3) states:
The powers of the Land Commission under this section to define and extend or improve rights of way to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river shall not be exercised compulsorily in relation to any right of way over land adjoining an occupied dwellinghouse which was in existence at the commencement of the period of one year ending on the date of the notice in respect of that right of way served by the Land Commission.
The reason for that is that we feel in certain instances it would be well known that the Land Commission would be asked to create a right of way in a certain locality. Matters of this kind are generally discussed publicly by some local development associations and it would become known that they were about to apply to the Land Commission to exercise their powers under this section to retain this right of way; and a recalcitrant individual, a difficult man, could anticipate and stop this by shoving up some type of building in the vicinity of that place, thus preventing the development going ahead as well as preventing the Land Commission creating the desirable right of way.
One matter I forgot to mention earlier—Senators may have read about it — is that some owners who had acquired property beside the seashore suddenly put up walls all around them to prevent the people exercising rights they had been able to exercise from time immemorial. The simple answer is that in such cases the public themselves or, through the Attorney General, can ensure the continuance of the exercise of those rights—a right, for instance, to go to the seashore where the local people used to go.
In many instances of which I have knowledge, it is the old story that what is everybody's business is nobody's business: people are slow in asserting their rights, though they are very vocal in talking about them. Where there is any doubt and where the Land Commission are satisfied that these rights had been enjoyed by the public in some of those areas and that those rights are now being interfered with or cut off from the user of the public, then without any expensive litigation, there would be power in this section for the Land Commission to declare a right of way to the seashore, no matter what is said here. That is one of the intentions behind the section. Needless to say, that right of the Land Commission would not be exercised indiscriminately: it would be exercised only where the Land Commission were satisfied it was necessary to do so.
It is hardly practical to lay down a rule to cover all the cases of nuisance feared by the Senators who put down this amendment. Rights of way or car parks could exist near a dwelling or a building, but there could be no question of such rights existing if a belt of trees intervened between a public amenity and a dwelling. Conversely, a car park might be regarded as an eyesore if there were only open ground between it and the dwellinghouse. All these matters have convinced me that the use of the word "adjoining" in the subsection makes it a desirable provision.
The owner of any dwelling, as the movers of this amendment should realise, could easily concoct an objection even though there was a very considerable distance between the building or dwellinghouse and the amenity the section seeks to have retained. That is the difficulty you encounter when you take away the word "adjoining". The only practical thing is to retain "adjoining" and let the Lay Commissioners decide all difficult cases at their discretion. The section as it stands provides the necessary enabling powers for the Land Commission to get over objections in cases where the interests of the local community are mooted by some local development committee or other such body.
I feel it would be unlikely that any bona fide objection would be accidentally defeated by the one year clause. Perhaps the House may consider a year, in this instance, rather a long period. Senators might even consider it unreasonable. I feel, however, that to meet the dangers that have been referred to, some period should be laid down that would prevent somebody thwarting the Land Commission or the Department from implementing local wishes. I envisage that the sticking up of some kind of building or dwellinghouse to stop a right of way going ahead would not be achieved by this amendment.
On the question of notice, I accept, of course, what has been said about car parks. I accept that car parks could become an eyesore if placed near a dwellinghouse. The sole reason the provision has been inserted here is to prevent a situation where a far-seeing man might stick up something that would prevent the Land Commission from utilising this power in a case where it was very desirable to do so. If the House thinks there is something unreasonable in that, or if a Senator can suggest a more effective way to improve it, I shall be very pleased to hear it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree it is unreasonable that the owner of a house should live under the threat of having a car park laid down beside his premises? Could that happen, virtually, to anyone or can it happen only in certain circumstances? As I read the Bill, this subsection (2) gives absolute powers to the Land Commission. If the Minister could show me that this right can be exercised only in certain very specific circumstances, I would be much happier.
Comment on this
I can assure the Senator that what is being asked in this section is this—let me be quite clear—this right of way or car park, or what have you, under this section, could not be put there at all beside a house or on land adjoining a house that had been in existence for over 12 months.
Comment on this
This "house" provision here has been designed solely by me anticipating some bright individual who sticks up something in a rush to stop a right of way being created. If Senators think that a period of 12 months is too long for that purpose, I shall consider fixing, perhaps six months. That, perhaps, may serve the purpose.
Comment on this
Did I understand the Minister aright, that he replied to Senator Stanford that subsection (2) is governed by the one year period of subsection (3) ? I do not think this is so. It would be so if our amendment stood but it is not so as subsection (3) is now drafted because these powers are only the powers to define and extend rights of way and that year only applies to this part of it but does not apply to subsection (2). Is that not so?
Comment on this
That is how I read it myself. I should like to be absolutely certain on this.
Comment on this
This is the point which Senator Stanford originally made and which seems to me to be correct but the Minister's reply, as I understood it, was that the powers given under subsection (2) will not apply to a house which was in existence at the commencement of the period of a year ending on the date of the notice. But, as I read subsection (2), the powers there are in no way affected by subsection (3). Subsection (3) does not refer to these powers. Subsection (3) refers to the powers to extend rights of way to and from the sea. This is a part of the force of our amendment, to bring subsection (2) within the limitations of subsection (3).
Comment on this
Subsection (2) spells out the purposes for which the law under section 43 of the Land Act, 1923, and section 39 of the Land Act of 1931 are extended. These particular powers could not be used for these purposes prior to this Bill or money advanced in respect of conferring rights to park vehicles or to beach boats and rights to moor or anchor boats. These are new powers. But subsection (3) would certainly, I think, override subsection (2) and the powers under subsection (3) to define and extend or improve rights of way to and from the sea, or to and from a lake or river, could not be exercised compulsorily in relation to any right of way over land adjoining an occupied dwellinghouse which was in existence at the commencement of the period of one year on the date of the notice in respect of that right of way served by the Land Commission.
I want to make it clear that right of way to the sea or to a lake or to a river cannot be exercised compulsorily on land adjoining a dwellinghouse that is there more than one year before the Land Commission serves its notice and moves in. I think Senators understand that. The way this is worded was devised, and I am advised the effect of it would be, to stop anybody anticipating the demand for such a right of way by putting up some building and defeating the Land Commission's purpose.
Comment on this
Is it that perhaps subsection (2) is covered under the word "improved" in subsection (3) ? Is that the contention? Otherwise, I do not see anything in subsection (3) which controls subsection (2) unless what is stated in subsection (2) is deemed to be a form of improvement. That is stretching it a bit far. I wonder would the Minister consider it, if we withdrew this amendment, perhaps, with the consent of my colleague?
Comment on this
I should like to be clear on a couple of points raised by the movers of this amendment. If we go back to subsection (1), which provides the power to expend money for the benefit or improvement of any land, it says that the powers of the Land Commission shall, in addition to the matters mentioned in section 43 of the 1923 Act and section 39 of the 1931 Act, include power to confer on the Land Commission and their licensees, and to define and extend or improve, ways and rights of way over any land whatsoever and so on. These powers I referred to earlier tonight. I think I quoted them. These sections of the 1923 and 1931 Acts defined a number of categories for which money can be advanced for resale of lands, and so on. They did not provide, as I pointed out earlier on this Bill, for rights of turbary in certain incorporeal hereditaments which have been dealt with under a previous section. But there were these limited powers, as I say, for the production of rights of way which are now being extended here in a general way to cover all land under subsection (1) of the section.
The power goes with this subsection (1) "to define and extend or improve, ways and rights of way over any land whatsoever (including any accretion, through alluvion or dereliction, whether or not caused by drainage)"—that is the point I referred to where you have new land appearing as a result of major drainage—"for the purpose of facilitating passage to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river which adjoins lands sold or agreed to be sold under the Land Purchase Acts, whether such rights of way are or are not conferred as to be appurtenant to any land, and whether any terminal point of such ways and rights of way is or is not situate on lands sold or agreed to be sold under the Land Purchase Acts.
That is an overall power and, I would suggest to the Senators, to cover any type of right of way over any type of land leading to or from the sea or otherwise. Subsection (2) provides that the powers conferred here and extended by section 20 may be exercised for the purposes of conferring and defining rights to park vehicles or to beach boats and rights to moor or anchor boats. These are completely new powers that were not provided for in any of the previous Land Acts and that is the purpose of writing them in here. The Senators say subsection (3) would allow the creation of a car park quite close to a dwelling and they are asking that the provisions of the subsection should not be applied to a dwellinghouse that is in existence at the date of the service of the notice. If I interpret the amendment of the Senators correctly, the only real issue between us would be under subsection (3) as to whether this provision, whereby you could still create a right of way under this section on land adjoining a house that has gone up within the previous 12 months is unreasonable. If I am misinterpreting Senator Ross's amendment, perhaps he will enlighten me.
Comment on this
I have tried to follow the arguments on this amendment. The Minister has told us that the right to create car parks or moorings for boats is an innovation, that it has not been a part of the previous Acts. If that is so I respectfully submit that there is nothing in subsection (3) to prevent the creation of a car park beside a house. Subsection (1) deals with rights of way, movements to and from. Subsection (3) deals with the same thing, rights of way, the right to pass over a person's land to gain access to the sea or to a lake, whereas subsection (2) of section 20 specifically deals with the right to park vehicles and the right to moor boats.
If the Land Commission sought to do so there is nothing to prevent them under subsection (3) creating a car park right up against a house even if it had been in existence for more than 12 months. If a person's house was immediately overlooking a lake or overlooking the sea there is nothing in subsection (3) to prevent the Land Commission creating moorings for boats there. This is an oversight in subsection (3) which could be cured by inserting in subsection (3) after "right of way", "parking place or mooring for boats". There is a lot of weight in what Senator Ross and Senator Stanford have said. There is more than a doubt. It is quite open to the Minister and the Land Commission to do the sort of thing that the Senators fear may be done.
Comment on this
I should be happy if we could think over this rather complicated situation and take it up again on the Report Stage. As Senator Ross pointed out, this amendment of ours is trying to do three things at once which, perhaps, is a little too much. However, the two things I want to emphasise that need to be done are, first, to shorten the period from one year to, say, six months and, secondly, to make absolutely certain that subsection (2) is controlled by subsection (3). If we could get these two things I should be very happy whatever wording is used.
Comment on this
As we said, there are three points in this amendment but to go back to the first one for a moment, I think the Minister has agreed in effect that subsection (3) governs the other two subsections. While I am not going to press the point now—I think Senator Stanford is quite right to say we should think over this amendment because we believe it is a fundamental amendment—would it not meet what the Minister says if he accepted the first part of our amendment? If the words in line 48 to the middle of line 50: "to define and extend or improve rights of way to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river" were deleted the subsection would read: "The powers of the Land Commission under this section shall not be exercised compulsorily..." That makes it absolutely clear that the entire section is governed by subsection (3). I would ask the Minister to consider that because in effect that does what he tells us subsection (3) does and meets part of our amendment.
In regard to the word "adjoining" again I appreciate the Minister's difficulty here and I do not know how far we may be able to go in trying to meet this. I object to the word "adjoining" because it is too tight. The Minister finds that our amendment is unacceptable because it is too wide. Perhaps we can meet somewhere in the middle.
On the final point of the house which was in existence at the commencement of a period of a year ending on the date of the notice, if someone, as the Minister has suggested, hears or if it is common knowledge that the Land Commission intend to exercise their powers, is it really likely that someone will come along and, in the Minister's words, shove up a house to try to stop the Land Commission proceeding? In the first place, if our amendment is accepted any such dwelling house must be an occupied dwelling house.
It might meet our point if it was a dwelling house of a certain size or a certain valuation but it must be occupied or it must be built at the time of the notice and anyway planning consent will probably have to be obtained before it can be put up. Therefore, by the time the dwelling house is built and the person gets himself into it a year or so will have elapsed. So that we come back to the point that the period is from the service of the notice and that the house has to be occupied before that. In practice, I think the Land Commission will have very nearly a year in which to let their intentions be known if they want that.
But what concerns me here is that the Minister has assured the House that these powers will not be exercised indiscriminately. I am perfectly certain that is the intention of the Minister but it is quite wrong to accept wording in a Bill that any Minister assures us will not be used indiscriminately. This is a matter of principle; it is not a matter for this particular Bill or Minister. We should not be guided or influenced in any way by the assurances of any person. What we should be concerned with is what is in the Bill and what will be eventually in the Act. This is something that seems to us to be fundamental and that is why this amendment is tabled, but we are quite prepared to withdraw it and ask the Minister to reconsider the position because I think there is very little now between us and we hope that either he or we, or both of us, will introduce a new amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
This has been a very interesting discussion on a very complicated section of the Bill and, listening to it, a different point of view strikes me now. Subsection (3) says the powers of the Land Commission under this section to define and extend or improve rights of way—I understand to define a right of way is to establish a new right of way—"to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river shall not be exercised compulsorily in relation to any right of way over land adjoining an occupied dwelling house..." We are all picturing the right of way adjoining an occupied dwelling house but I think it is not definite enough here because it is "over land adjoining an occupied dwelling house".
If I have a ten-acre field adjoining my dwelling house, that is land adjoining it, and I think none of us wants a right of way coming by the front door, the back door and the side door. The path might be there already; it might be 50 yards away from the house, but if we are to define a new path or access or a new motor road to the sea, we cannot do it according to the wording here because it is in land adjoining an occupied dwelling house. If I were a lawyer, I should say on the wording here that is land adjoining a dwelling house.
I think we should be more precise in our definition. We cannot say "in close proximity", but I think the Minister should get some phrase which would allow the approach to be defined, extended or improved without coming up beside a premises. The present wording is not adequate. It says "land adjoining", while the right of way might be 300 or 400 yards away.
Comment on this
Senator Ross has intimated his desire to withdraw the amendment. Would the House agree to leave the matter there?
Comment on this
I undertake to have a look at the points raised to see if we can meet what the Senators have in mind as between subsection (1) and subsection (3) dealing with powers to define, extend or improve rights of way. Subsection (2) sets out the purposes for which these powers may be exercised. I shall consider what it may be possible to do.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In subsection (3), line 51, to delete "adjoining" and substitute "within one hundred yards of".
I think the point of my amendment has been aired by a number of Senators. Senator Ó Donnabháin has raised exactly the same point, that "adjoining" is much too loose a definition. I should like to know the precise legal definition of "adjoining". It would be much more satisfactory to give some measure such as 50 yards, 100 yards or 200 yards so that the right of way will not be brought right up to your front or back door, something that will be capable of being operated. Perhaps 100 yards would be appropriate in this case. I should like to hear the Minister on this point.
Comment on this
It is really the same point made in a different way as that in the previous amendment and the same consideration will apply.
Comment on this
I think we need something like the provision the Minister has brought in. The points made by Senator Ross, Senator Quinlan and Senator Stanford may be worth examining but not to any great extent because we know there is a completely changed position today and it is good to see a section like this now being introduced. I do not know how far it could be improved. The position has changed completely in regard to the question of a right of way to the sea. Perhaps more people now go to the sea and to lakes than originally when such places were served by a very poor right of way, very narrow roads, passages in some cases and when there were very few facilities of any kind. That was in the old days when there were no roads and little transport. This measure sets out rights to park vehicles and beach boats in subsection (2) and also rights to moor or anchor boats.
Not a lot of that kind of facility is needed yet and I suppose if beaches were properly developed, the boats need not enter into it at all except just to anchor; but in many places there are no facilities to tie up boats and they may have to be brought on to the beach. You must, however, put vehicles somewhere. If people like a particular seaside place, they drive there and they find themselves back, perhaps, a half-mile with no place to put their cars. When we talk of the Land Commission here, we are not inclined to think they are very extreme and likely to give quite a lot of facilities. They will not interfere easily, even though they have certain rights. I agree that where there has been a dwelling house for a considerable time —and the time laid down is pretty safe—it is a different matter. If a new house is being erected, it might not be a suitable place for it but that is unlikely to happen. Under the new Planning Act a person must have permission now to erect a dwelling anywhere.
Comment on this
Would the Senator not agree that these matters have been fully debated already?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Chair will bear with me for a moment. I am just making the point that what have referred to in the section is needed. There may be some very slight thing required because you must provide facilities for people and you cannot treat that matter lightly, and at the same time not encroach too much on private property. It is well worth treating it very carefully.
Comment on this
Speaking on the Second Reading, this was one of the sections I welcomed. I consider it a very important and necessary section. I should like the Minister to answer a point of clarification on this section, which deals with the right of the Land Commission to expend money for the benefit or improvement of any lands, including powers to confer on the Land Commission and their licensees and to define and extend or improve ways and rights of way over any land whatsoever, and so on. I should like to know if the power of law is now being given to the custom which is prevalent in local areas of the right to fish, the right of access to fishing and the right to have boats moored on particular waters, and the right which is enjoyed by local anglers, anglers' associations and tourist development associations.
Does the section apply only to land which will be acquired by the Land Commission? This Bill deals with acquisition of land for the relief of congestion. Does the section apply also to land held privately? I should like to know if under this section provision can be made by those associations I have mentioned for development of amenities such as provision of platforms for fishing because there has been difficulty in some areas in that regard, and also the provision of caravan sites or chalets near to or overlooking lakes. These are points on which I should like clarification— whether it applies only to land acquired by the Land Commission or also to land privately-owned.
Comment on this
I should like to welcome this section. It is long overdue. I see that the Minister described it as a novel item which calls for some explanation. Broadly speaking, the existing Land Acts, in so far as they deal with rights of way, are concerned with the question of private access to agricultural land for the purpose of working it. I should like the Minister to go a little further as regards private rights of way to agricultural land for this purpose. I have several problems on my mind trying to bring about some arrangement between neighbours to get access to their land. I think that it has come down from the penal times when if you put your right of way on the high land, you would be charged more taxes and that the old landlord system took you into the boreens and the bottom of the land. In modern times, you have the combine, and the combine requires a road 12 or 15 feet wide, whereas you will find roads of ten feet or nine feet width, and sometimes eight feet, and the modern machinery cannot be brought into the land.
Comment on this
These matters have already been dealt with in this discussion.
Comment on this
I am making my point and if I am not out of order, I should like to continue.
Comment on this
The Chair does not wish to interfere with the rights of Senators, but repeating a statement made by other Senators is repetition, which is not in order.
Comment on this
I am speaking on section 20 and I should like to continue speaking on this section.
Comment on this
The Senator will continue if he is in order.
Comment on this
I should not like to dispute the ruling of the Chair. I should like to know if the Minister would introduce something in the Bill that would remove certain difficulties about this. The Land Commission in the old times marked out rights of way to certain property but they never registered those rights of way. It is most important that the Land Commission would see that those rights of way were registered for this purpose. I know people who cannot get to their land at present because the rights of way are not registered. We had experiences in Westmeath of certain people purchasing property who were aliens and we had a right of way to the lakes before they purchased the property but when they purchased, they put a lock on the gate and left people outside the gate. There was nobody brave enough to break that lock. I must say this much, that Bord Fáilte have come along giving grants to provide rights of way to those places. That is a very good thing. The amendment to the section put down by Senator Quinlan that a right of way should not interfere with a man's private property or his privacy as regards his use of it was a good amendment and I was very glad to hear the Minister saying tonight that he would give it consideration.
Comment on this
I wish to welcome this section as something we need very badly. It does guarantee, I hope, the right to reasonable access to the sea. I have some worries about the wording of some of the phrasing here, for instance, where the section gives power both to define and extend or improve ways and rights of way over any land for the purpose of facilitating passage to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river which adjoins land sold or agreed to be sold under the Land Purchase Acts. I am just worried as to whether the phrase "which adjoins lands sold or agreed to be sold under the Land Purchase Acts" covers all three: in other words, covers passage to and from the river, the sea, and a lake. The intention of the Minister is clear, that this is meant to qualify only river and consequently I think commas would be in order after "sea" and after "lake". This is only a minor point but it is necessary to be quite specific to make sure that the right asserted is a right to all the sea and all the lakes while the right asserted to a river is only that to the river adjoining a particular place that is being sold or about to be taken.
Comment on this
The section is intended to cover and does cover rights of way in all three cases: to the sea, to the rivers and to lakes. I think whatever doubts Senators may have about subsection (3) generally speaking, the objectives we are trying to attain under the section meet with the approval of the House. On the questions which have arisen on subsection (3) of section 20, I shall have a look at them between now and Report Stage. Senator McAuliffe will have another opportunity on section 33, dealing with rights of way over land per se, leaving out this question of sea or river or lake, when we can deal with the matters troubling him, registered rights of way or unsuitable rights of way. The Senator will get an opportunity of discussing it later on.
Comment on this
Does the point raised on the section apply to lands that are being acquired by the Land Commission or to lands privately-owned?
Comment on this
This and the other sections apply to all lands no matter under what tenure the lands are held. Demesne lands were never the subject of the Land Acts but these powers creating rights over them will now apply. That was not the case formerly but this Bill will now close the gap.
Comment on this
Without going quite so far as the question of commas raised by Senator Quinlan, I should like some clarification on phraseology. Subsection (1) refers to the passage to and from the sea or to and from a lake or river. I wonder why they put "to and from" in twice, why it should not be in three times. Why should lake and river be put together if they are to be separated from sea? Would it not be clearer to say "to and from the sea, or a lake or a river"? There would be no doubt at all then about the adjoining land. It seems odd that "to and from" should be in governing the sea and then that lake and river should be lumped together. I cannot see why lake and river should be lumped together rather than the whole three, or any two, and have "to and from the sea", or "to and from a lake" and "to and from a river". What is the point of putting "lake and river" together and distinguishing them from "sea"?
Comment on this
I cannot see why this is so. No doubt the draftsman must have some reason for making the distinction. It is not readily apparent to me. It may be, though I would not like to stick to the view, that this question of providing for rights of way to the sea is new and in the case of rights of way to lakes or rivers there may be some case law and a question of servitudes arising. I am only hazarding that as a guess because I feel the draftsman must have some reason for making the distinction which the perceptive Senator has spotted in this section. So long as there is no restriction expressed or implied, I would be happy enough with it. As a matter of interest, I must find out myself.
Comment on this
I should like to clear up one point on section 33 which the Minister mentioned. I was under the impression that the Land Commission would only step in if they were acquiring the land and they would not settle the question of the right of way. I should like to know from the Minister, if there are disputes about rights of way on any land for the purpose of working that land as it should be worked and because of a failure to get a proper right of way to that land whether it is provided in the Bill that a person will get a right on land when the Land Commission have acquired that land.
Comment on this
I am afraid I shall have to wait for section 33 to deal with rights of way solely concerned with entry into land, which is the type of right of way that interests the Senator.
I have been informed there is undoubtedly a reason as Senator Sheldon feels for this distinction he referred to and the reference "which adjoins lands" qualifies only a lake or river, whereas it does not qualify the sea. If the Senator re-reads the wording, he will see the reason the draftsman put it that way.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister if, henceforth, all holdings to be transferred will be consolidated as one holding. In County Laois, for example, there are some 8,000 odd farms and yet there are over 23,000 rated holdings. If it is the policy now very quickly to consolidate all these holdings, it will mean that the farms that are at present in many instances scattered, having a field here and another perhaps half a mile away, will not be consolidated while they are still physically divided. I should like to see the Land Commission endeavour before compulsorily consolidating a holding to have the holding or the farm as one physical unit. I think this could be done by a process of exchanges. Perhaps the consolidation could be tackled even on a parochial basis, taking parish by parish. I should like to know whether that is the Land Commission intention.
Comment on this
The proposals in section 25 mean that the Land Commission will have power on consent of the party concerned to order consolidation of any two or more holdings, and those holdings should become one for all purposes and should be registered as one holding in the Land Registry. The position before this was that even where it was desirable, for instance, where there was one holding subject to the Land Acts, under the Registration of Title Act, and there was another holding held under a different tenure and not subject to the Land Acts, they could not be consolidated. The position was the same before the passage of this Bill. No doubt some Senators have come across this difficulty in practice.
This is an enabling section to wipe out these difficulties and to enable consolidation to go ahead, irrespective of the tenure under which the different portions of land are held. It is a compulsory matter. It is an enabling section, where this is desirable. No doubt the Senator is aware that it is a statistical death-trap for the unwary if you go working in a number of holdings. There may be several of them or there may be one individual who may have six different valuations held under different rate receipts and different titles. Such figures, if they are not carefully examined, can be very misleading.
Comment on this
Does the Minister intend, under this section, that there should be an active policy by the Land Commission to consolidate, in accordance with the section, so that the initiative would come from the Land Commission in respect of holdings where there is no connection with division or anything else, but simply to facilitate getting a more accurate picture of the number of holdings, their distribution and so on? I consider that would be worth while.
Comment on this
The purpose of the Land Commission is, of course, to consolidate and, where they give additions of land and so on, to consolidate with the parent holding. As I have explained, the power was also there, before this section, to consolidate a portion of land with the parent holding, if that land was under a similar title. It is peculiar that you get perhaps a portion of land, where the title originated as a squatter's title and it is registered outside the Land Act. Under existing law that could not be allocated and consolidated with the parent holding.
Comment on this
They can be discussed together and a separate decision taken on each.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
To add at the end:
"; and provided further that the name of the owner and address of the holding so inspected be published as soon as possible in Iris Oifigiúil.”.
This is a section that has caused considerable public controversy at all political levels. It has caused considerable irritation at all levels of our national life. As far as political controversy is concerned, I have really no great worries and as far as irritation is concerned, that is something no more than irritation and will ultimately pass away.
My concern, in putting down this amendment, is based, not on any political motive, or on any feeling of irritation. It is based on a desire to rid our people of all possible fear and apprehension. Whether fears or apprehensions are justified or not, people have them and they are entitled, in my view, to go through life and live on their holdings without them. With that introduction, I would safely say of every Land Bill, no matter under what Government, there will always be found in every part of this country ruthless and unscrupulous land hungry people, not necessarily associated with one political Party or another, who will seize upon some phrase, some paragraph or some section of the proposed legislation in order to frighten certain of their neighbours into the fear and apprehension to which I have referred.
I have put down this amendment therefore primarily with a view to implementing the maxim well known in our law that, not alone must justice be done but it must be seen to be done. I do not think the Minister would be giving anything away, politically or legally, if he accepted this amendment of mine or, if he were not satisfied with the wording of it, possibly, on the Report Stage, either he or I, by joint effort, might be able to get some formula that would get rid of the political controversy and the irritation and, above all, of the fear and apprehension, which is rampant throughout the country.
I have received a considerable number of letters from people who, in my view, have nothing at all to fear from this Bill or any part of it, but who have been misled by neighbours, not by any political people from one side or the other, into a position where they fear they are inferior. The happiness of our people is extremely important and if something like this were done now or if some formula were brought in on the Report Stage, it would do a great deal of good.
The Minister, if I interpreted his Second Reading reply correctly, is concerned mainly in this section with expedition. If this section is concerned mainly with expedition, then I am not in the slightest way opposed, if it is expedition only, nor do I fear any abuse by the political head of the Department in the operation of the provisions of this or any other section, because even if the political head of a Department were disposed to abuse his power in this regard initially, then in the following up proceedings by the Land Commission inspectors and the Lay Commissioners, in my view, there is a sufficient brake to prevent that abuse causing any trouble.
As I say, I do not fear abuses. I believe that no Minister of any Government would be foolish enough to jeopardise his political integrity by wrongfully interfering at the behest of someone inspired by wrong motives, to bring about an inspection of anyone's land and cast him into a position of insecurity. I do not fear those things at all. I believe we have reached such a stage of political maturity that our objective should be not only to discuss provisions such as this, but to educate our people on every possible occasion to the fact that abuse of political power is not as widespread as some people think.
There will always be abuses. Some may be deliberate, and some unintentional, but they are not as bad as some people would represent them to be. That is the kind of thing that brings us into disrepute that we do not deserve, whether we support the Government or are in Opposition. I am sure the Minister is as concerned as I am, or as any of us are, for the happiness of our people and their being given a full sense of security. It is for that reason that I want written into his Bill that the Minister's actions in directing inspections of his kind can be scrutinised.
I do not think there is anything objectionable in that. If I were the political head of the Department, I would welcome it, because it would provide me with a shield for my integrity. If he refuses to allow this scrutiny, I urge on the Minister that he is doing himself a disservice as the political head of the Department—and he is doing a disservice to future heads of the Department—which we in political life can badly afford. It is for those reasons, and none other, that I urge this amendment upon the Minister.
As I said at the beginning, if the Minister does not find the wording of this amendment suitable, or if the wording is in some way unacceptable, I am prepared to reconsider it and try to get something into the Bill which will show: (a) the main purpose of the section is to expedite the work of the Land Commission; and (b) that the steps towards that expedition will be so available to the public that they will realise that all this talk about political abuse and political corruption is doing nothing but a disservice to our political growth.
Comment on this
I shall be proposing amendment No. 37 which reads:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) The Minister shall lay before each House of the Oireachtas on the 1st day of January and the 1st day of July each year a list giving particulars of the cases in which he has authorised an officer to make a determination pursuant to subsection (1) of this section."
I am sorry I cannot agree with much of what has been said by my colleague, Senator Lindsay. I believe that if this power were vested in the Minister, it could lead to very serious abuses against which we must guard. We are legislating for the future. The Minister and Senator Lindsay are two western men. They are both from the some county, and they may argue that the Minister is a reasonable man. We must remember that we are legislating for the future, and what appears in this Bill will be the law for 15 or 20 years. In the future we may not have a reasonable Minister for Lands. There is no denying that the power we are asked to give the Minister in this section could be abused, and very seriously abused. We are told it is the intention to save time. It is stated that the measure is designed to expedite acquisition proceedings. I want to know how this measure can save time and, in any case, in my view, the amount of time that could be saved would not be worth the candle.
Up to this the decision to inspect land was left entirely to the inspectors of the Land Commission. When this section is being inserted in the Bill, we are entitled to ask: Has the Minister lost confidence in his own Commissioners? Were they not doing their work properly? Were they not doing it as he believed they should be doing it? Was any undue influence being brought to bear on them? If a report went in that a certain man's land should be inspected, were they failing to do their duty? We are entitled to know.
Over the past 40 years, we have had different Governments. We had a Cumann na nGaedheal Government, a Fianna Fáil Government, an inter-Party Government, a Fianna Fáil Government, another inter-Party Government, and now we have a Fianna Fáil Government again. Under vigorous pressure from their own supporters, all those Governments defended the principle that no political head of the Department of Lands should ever accept responsibility for what land should be inspected. Great credit was due to them for that attitude, and they were quite right not to yield to temptation over the past 40 years. In the past Fianna Fáil Deputies spoke very strongly against the political head of the Department having any say in land acquisition, and I want to quote some of them.
Speaking about certain powers which were being taken from the Minister at that time, as reported in volume 118, column 907 of the Dáil Debates, the late Mr. Seán Moylan said:
...It is essential that, in any Act dealing with fundamental matters like land, the interpretation of that Act and the manner in which it is to be administered should not be the playthings of politics. It was wise and necessary that these powers should be taken out of the hands of the Minister, whoever the Minister was...
They are being returned again in this Bill. I agree with every word the late Mr. Moylan said at that time. He was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.
As reported in volume 118, column 1255, Deputy Ó Ciosáin, as he then was, said:
...I for one would not be prepared to give any Minister the power to intervene in the question of the acquisition and division of land...
In the next column, he went on:
The fact that the Minister represents a western constituency makes this provision all the more dangerous.
How true, perhaps, that is today.
Comment on this
It has everything to do with it. The Deputy was objecting to the political head of the Department having anything to do with——
Comment on this
With acquisition. There is nothing about acquisition in this section.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange, on the amendment without interruption.
Comment on this
I shall quote it again. He said:
...I for one would not be prepared to give any Minister the power to intervene in the question of the acquisition and division of land...
Those are his words. What do you inspect land for if not to acquire it? Is that not the whole purpose of the Bill?
Comment on this
The Minister has power to direct an inspection for acquisition or otherwise. Then Senator Ó Ciosáin stated "The fact that the Minister represents a western constituency makes this provision all the more dangerous." I would not go even as far as Senator Ó Ciosáin went at that time, although at times I might go far enough. Senator Killilea had ideas in the past on the power that a Minister should have.
Comment on this
Are we discussing the section or the amendment?
Comment on this
I think it is relevant to the amendment because it seeks to make a case for it.
Comment on this
Yes. I will hear the Senator further and decide whether he is in order or not.
Comment on this
I believe that the political head of the Department should not have this power. If he is to have this power, then he should lay on the Table of the House twice a year the names of people whose holdings he has ordered to be inspected. As regards his political power, I want to quote Senator Killilea, then Deputy Killilea, on 17th November, 1949 at column 1158, volume 118. He stated:
I must say I would like to see power in the hands of the Land Commission but I am not prepared to give too many powers to any particular Minister. I have good reasons for that... I have no doubt in my mind that the people who are politically opposed to him will not be the people coming out best in his division of land. For that reason I am not prepared to give it to him or to give it to a Minister from these benches, either.
That is what he stated about giving power to the political head of the Department and he went on to say that there was a danger of a particular Minister getting too many powers and doing too many things from his particular view. He added that he would not like to give to any Minister very drastic powers.
The present Minister for Lands, then Deputy Moran, on 2nd March, 1950, in volume 119, column 1146 stated:
There was never in the history of the country any Minister for Lands who proposed to take this particular power. There is nobody more familiar with the political work that may be done if these powers are given to the Minister than the Minister himself.
I do not know whether it was suspicion haunting the guilty mind there but that is what the Minister had to say about the political head——
Comment on this
The Minister was dealing with giving political power to the head of the Department. He went further and made an accusation that we have not made and at column 1147 of the same volume he said:
This opens wide the door to all kinds of political corruption and the Minister well knows it.
He goes on to say:
I certainly cannot see any reason why the Minister should take this power except for that one purpose— to ensure that where the Minister is dealing with an estate, he will be in a position to look after his own because this particular section gives him specific power so to do.
We believe it is completely——
Comment on this
To give the political head of the Department power in connection with the acquisition of land and the division of land.
Comment on this
It would appear that what the Senator is saying now might be said more appropriately on a later section.
Comment on this
Giving this power can lead to serious abuses and I do object to giving it to the Minister or if he is to get the power I believe the names should be laid on the Table of the House on 1st January and 1st June of each year.
Comment on this
First of all, I want to give the House the reasons for these powers. Let me make it quite clear— I can deal with the matter more fully on the section—that the quotations given by Senator L'Estrange on the 1950 Act were from a speech of mine attacking the provisions in section 12 of that Bill which for the first time took away specifically from the Lay Commissioners and specifically gave to the Minister for Lands the power to deal with the rearrangement of holdings. However, we will have more on that anon when we come to the section. As far as the amendments are concerned, the first is put down by Senator Lindsay and let me preface what I have to say by pointing out to the House how section 27 starts. It commences: "For the removal of doubt, it is hereby declared that the determination of the land to be inspected under subsection (6), section 40 of the 1923 Act, as amended by this Act, is not an excepted matter ..." This section is for the removal of doubts.
I asked Deputies, when discussing this section over quite a long period, to point out, if they could, where there was any provision in any Land Act which made the matter of inspection an excepted matter reserving this function solely to the Lay Commissioners of the Land Commission. Nobody could point out any such power in any of the Land Acts for the simple reason that no such power is there. I pointed out to the Dáil, and I want to point out to this House, that one can go back to the 1923 Act and go right through every Land Act with a fine comb up to this day and there will not be found any legal provision which says that the power to inspect lands for the purposes of the Land Acts is a reserved function of the Land Commissioners. I concede that in practice the notices under section 40 were signed by the Lay Commissioners but what I am submitting to this House, as I did to the other House, is that there is no legal basis in law requiring that such notices should be signed by the Lay Commissioners and that the function of issuing these inspection notices is a reserved function of the Land Commissioners.
Under the 1950 Land Act, the reserved functions of the Lay Commissioners are specifically set out chapter and verse, which I shall give to the House in due course. That Act specifies the functions reserved by law to the Lay Commissioners and excluded from the Minister. It is under that same section 12 of the 1950 Act that, for the first time, power was given to the political head of the Department to deal with the re-arrangement of land. That was a power specifically reserved to the Lay Commissioners before the passage of the 1950 Act and that was the power that I objected to the Minister taking under that Act. I challenge any Senator, as I challenged any Deputy, to point out any section in any Land Act that lays it down that the inspection of lands in order to ascertain their suitability for the purposes of the Land Acts is a reserved function of the Lay Commissioners.
This section is necessary for the purpose of cutting red tape. I do not want to delay the House by going through the existing procedure. Briefly, people go into the local office and say that X's holding is about to be sold, that it is badly needed for the relief of congestion, and they want the Land Commission to take action. The junior inspector draws up a memorandum and sends it to the inspector in charge. It goes from him to the divisional inspector, from the divisional inspector to the senior inspector in Dublin, and from him to the Lay Commissioners for the signing of this notice which goes down through the same bureaucratic routine to the local office, for the sole purpose of enabling the junior inspector to notify the owner that he is going out on the lands to report on their condition and see whether or not they are suitable for the purposes of the Land Acts.
It is on that inspector's report, forwarded in due course to the Lay Commissioners here in Dublin, that a decision is taken as to whether or not such a farm should be acquired. That is the procedure. That will still be the procedure if and when this Bill becomes law because the function is still reserved to the Lay Commissioners to decide what lands should or should not be taken for the purposes of the Land Acts. The men here in Dublin have no way of ascertaining the suitability of any lands until they receive the report from the officer who inspects the lands. Because of all the delay, due to this top-heavy procedure, in very many instances a farm is sold by the owner before the local official is authorised to go out and make his inspection to enable the people in Dublin to decide on the suitability of the farm for acquisition, or otherwise.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not now justifying the section rather than opposing the amendment?
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling, Sir, if you so think. What I wish to make clear, and this is relevant to the first amendment by Senator Lindsay, is that under existing procedure great delays occur. The inspector goes out and inspects the lands. He checks with the owner, finds out the extent of the lands and how they have been used. He may also inquire into the extent of local congestion. He then writes a report which comes up in the routine I have described and ultimately arrives on the table of the Lay Commissioners. Fifty per cent of the cases go no further than the report stage to the Lay Commissioners; the Lay Commissioners decide in 50 per cent of the cases on the report they get from the inspector that the Land Commission should not proceed further in the acquisition of certain lands for the time being. Fifty per cent of the cases, therefore, finish there and then.
In the other 50 per cent of cases, what the Lay Commissioners decide to do is to have compulsory proceedings commenced under existing law. The usual notices are served and published in Iris Oifigiúil, which means that the cases proceed to a court hearing, unless some arrangement is made with the Land Commission in the meantime. For the sake of argument, take it that 50 per cent of the inspections end in the land court; in only one-third does the court decide in favour of the Land Commission. Therefore two-thirds of them, for one reason or another, are adjourned or the court or the Lay Commissioners decide to accept the story of the applicants and allow their objections.
When it comes before the court and the hearing is published in Iris Oifigiúil, it is public property—everybody knows about it. Over all, of the inspections to which I have referred, 50 per cent never see the light of day and nobody knows anything about them. It is a business between the Land Commission and the land owner. What I am asked to do in the first amendment is to publish the name of the owner and the location of the holding as soon as possible in Iris Oifigiúil. In the second amendment, what the House is being invited to do is to prescribe by law that in half of the total number of cases where inspections take place throughout the country, the names and locations of the people and the holdings should be published for public consumption.
We have had already in this House on earlier sections strong allegations by Senator L'Estrange that immediately the Land Commission appeared to take any interest in a holding, there was a vast immediate reduction in the value of that holding. The Senator was at pains to stress the devaluation that occurred on that holding and the great loss the owner was at, consequently. Yet here the Seanad is being invited to publicise the interest of the Land Commission in an individual's holding, even though the Commission, on a report from the Lay Commissioners, have decided no further action should be taken—that this man's land, as far as the Land Commission are concerned, had lost interest.
I suggest to the House that the publication of what really amount to the private affairs of individuals is undesirable. If there is any weight at all in the suggested fears of some Senators that any interest shown by the Land Commission in a farm automatically devalues that holding, such proceedings as are suggested here should be avoided like the plague because we would, through the implementation of this amendment, be indicating to everybody in the country that the Land Commission had inspected the holding and that even though they did not go ahead at that time, the feeling would be that as the Land Commission had once shown an interest in the place, they were more likely to renew that interest at a later date.
Senator L'Estrange's amendment asks that the Minister shall lay before each House of the Oireachtas on 1st January and 1st July each year a list giving particulars of the cases in which he has authorised an officer to make a determination pursuant to subsection (1) of this section. This would have exactly the same effect as I have described when commenting on the other amendment. It would be publishing the names and other details of individuals concerned in hundreds of cases where inspections had been made and in which the Lay Commissioners had decided, on reports from their inspectors, that they would take no further action.
Under the section, what will happen is that the divisional inspectors, of whom there are four for the entire country, will be empowered, on the authorisation of the Minister, to carry out inspections. Where there is an urgent case, the divisional inspector concerned, who has a number of counties under his personal supervision, can forthwith, without further ado, sign a notice empowering one of his junior officers to make an immediate inspection.
Let me emphasise once more that it is as a result of the report of that inspection that the Lay Commissioners will decide to act or not to act: it is still the function of the Lay Commissioners to decide whether the report should be followed up by any further action or whether it should be discontinued. Until now, these matters, unless they became matters of public property by virtue of the fact that they had come before a court where the hearing was in public, were kept strictly between the Commission and the persons concerned. In a number of those cases, private family conditions exist which may be reported to the Lay Commissioners by the inspectors concerned and perhaps it is because of such conditions obtaining in individual cases that the Lay Commissioners, in their wisdom, decided no further action should be taken.
If either or both these amendments were accepted, every inspection carried out under the various Land Acts would henceforth become public property. I can see no reason for these amendments. It is quite true, as Senator Lindsay has suggested, that if, as has been alleged by some Senators, a Minister for Lands would set out to operate this section for the purpose of harassing his political enemies, he would be simply pulling the roof on his head.
Under this procedure, if an inspector of the Land Commission made some inspection which could be said not to have been warranted, I can well imagine the number of questions that would be down for reply on the Dáil Order Paper on the following Wednesday concerning that particular case. We have heard about pressure on the Minister for Lands—any Minister for Lands—but I can tell the House that every Minister for Lands who has and will administer the existing Land Acts must resist pressure where he feels it should be resisted.
There are many powers a Minister for Lands can exercise under existing law, if he wants to do so, for wrong purposes or ulterior motives. The Minister is the political head of the Land Commission. The Lay Commissioners and all the officers in the Commission, except when acting in the exercise of their own reserved powers under law, are the servants of the political head of the Department and any Minister for Lands, any day of the week, must receive deputations about this, that and the other and he has got to exercise his powers and carry the burdens of his office according to his conscience.
On this alleged danger posed to the House by Senator L'Estrange, I should like Senators to exercise their minds in regard to the functions of every Minister for Lands, every day the Dáil sits. Each day he has probably the greatest number of Questions addressed to him by Deputies asking him, as they put it in Dáil terminology, as to the desirability of acquiring certain lands for the relief of congestion. Those questions are put down for the purpose of putting political pressure—there is no other name for it—on the Minister for Lands to have certain lands acquired. Day in, day out, in the Dáil, every single week, we have Deputies heading deputations, exercising political pressure to get the Land Commission to exercise their powers to take over land for the relief of congestion. I do not think it is suggested by anybody that any particular Minister for Lands or the Land Commission are doing anything wrong when they on occasion listen to these representations and check whether they are right or wrong. We get many allegations, it is true, from land-hungry people, suggesting that the Land Commission's powers should be exercised as far as their neighbour's land is concerned. The Lay Commissioners decide whether the allegations made by these people have any foundation in fact or whether they are false. The Land Commission's official goes out and sends up his report. On that report they make their decision as to whether the land should be acquired or left alone.
What the House is asked to do here is to accept these amendments allegedly for the purpose of preventing the Minister for Lands directing special inspections on the lands of his political enemies. There is nothing more farfetched than that suggestion. As Senator Lindsay himself admits, it would be political lunacy. The Minister for Lands who would direct any particular official — who may be a political enemy of his for all he knows because certainly every official of the Land Commission is not a supporter of any political Party—the Minister for Lands who would be so foolish to put that rope around his neck would not deserve to last in his job for very long. That is putting this matter at its worst. Taking the reasoning that has been advanced for the acceptance of these amendments, it is quite clear that not alone would it be wrong to accept them but the effect would be to pinpoint the hundreds of cases of farmers throughout the country whose lands have been inspected and in respect of which the Commissioners, in their wisdom, have decided not to interfere with them.
The position up to the moment is that in such cases the particulars of these people's affairs between themselves and the Land Commission have been confidential. They have not been disclosed to anybody. I suggest to the House that that position should still obtain. Indeed, it would be extremely foolish to interfere with it. As far as the wider matters are concerned, we can deal with them on the section, as you have ruled I cannot demonstrate to the House the reserved functions under the 1950 Act and the changes made in the law under the 1950 Act.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Minister is either missing my point or ignoring it. I never suggested that my amendment was for the purpose of preventing the political head of the Department from determining that inspection should be made of his political opponent's lands. The purpose of my amendment, let me state quite clearly, is to show to the world at large that no Minister directs inspection for political reasons, that the record would be there and that, if a charge is made against him, he could take it up and say "There are the names of the people inspected. Are they your supporters or mine or are they mixed?"
To a large extent the Minister has been, as we say in the west, romping around the roundabouts. He should not forget that I am fully acquainted with the western method of romping about the roundabouts. He has been showing an almost naive concern for privacy about the inspection of holdings. Does not everybody who comes from the country know that the Land Commission inspector is as well known a character as drives a car around the community? If he arrives at the gate of the holding of A.B. some wet or sunny morning, by that evening in every visiting house and every pub in the locality it will be known that the Land Commission inspector visited the lands of A.B. There is no time trying to suggest that there is privacy in this regard. Everybody knows about it.
Comment on this
That is begging the question. The Minister says its purpose is to try to preserve privacy. I say there is no privacy at all. It is for the purpose of the protection of the political head of the Department that I am urging this. I never once said when moving the amendment that I believed there would be political abuse of the powers of the section. I was not talking about the powers of the section. I was talking about the fears of people, whether justified or not, that they were entitled not to be there. I would not engage in what I would call intellectual dishonesty in disputing the legal basis of the whole problem as enunciated by the Minister. There is no point in people trying to pretend otherwise. I am trying to make this section something that is completely beyond suspicion and that no political malefactor or land hungry person interested in politics will be able to make capital out of it by way of directing suspicion against the present Minister for Lands or any other Minister for Lands.
I do not know whether the Minister has misunderstood my whole attitude or not. I hope not. I want him and the House to believe I am quite sincere in my approach to this section. It is not an approach as against the whole of the section, because I recognise the legal position. I could not fail to do so. I recognise that whether a Minister directs an inspection or not—it has been the Minister's experience in the same Land Commission courts—that the Lay Commissioners have always, to use his own expression, leaned backwards in order to protect the owner of land from its being acquired.
What I am anxious about is the atmosphere surrounding a piece of legislation. I want it to be perfectly understood by the people that legislation is being enacted in these Houses of Parliament for their betterment and not for the betterment of a section and to the detriment of another section, but for the benefit of everybody. I see no reason why these inspections, once determined to be done, should not be published somewhere, where people can have recourse to them. I agree with the Minister that any political head of a Department who would indulge in political determination of such notices would be nothing short of a fool and only hastening his own political destruction. But I want it to be made clear in some record that he never did any such thing and that all notices to inspect were determined on the basis of congestion and the need for inspection and that everything was perfectly above board.
For that reason I would urge the Minister to have another look at this. I do not want to gain any political advantage over him. I do not want him to give anything away. I want some amendment put in here—not necessarily this one—some addition to the section to show that the people who make the allegations of corruption are wrong, and that there will be a record there to prove they are wrong irrespective of whom they are hurling the allegations against.
Comment on this
It seems to me that Senator Lindsay's point is that these cases should be published so that people can see whether or not there is political abuse, whether a particular group of people are suffering all the inspections or whether it seems to be indiscriminate. Iris Oifigiúil would show all the inspections that took place all over the country and the people who are discussing this matter amongst themselves will not be concerned with the inspections that took place in counties other than their own. They will be concerned with inspections that took place within their own area.
Comment on this
It is only on that basis that they will make the assessment as to whether or not there has been political discrimination. But, on Senator Lindsay's admission, they will know very well what inspections have taken place within their own area and, consequently, they will learn nothing of importance or of relevance from reading Iris Oifigiúil. They will know the inspections that have taken place in their own county or in their own immediate neighbourhood and they will be well able to make an assessment then as to whether or not there has been political discrimination, so the case that is made by Senator Lindsay for this amendment does not really carry conviction. The amendment is not necessary, on his own admission.
Comment on this
Senator Ryan is being rather naïve too. I am not thinking of the education of the people in any particular area. I trust the people of this country. If I have been speaking with my tongue in my cheek to some extent so far, I think such a list would be very good for the education of an awful lot of our public men who make these allegations from time to time.
Comment on this
I withdraw the amendment now but I shall give it further consideration to see if I can get some easier way or some less objectionable way between now and Report Stage. I do not want to try to embarrass the Minister or the Land Commission in any way in regard to this matter but I do think that the reasons I have given are valid reasons and the underlying motives are correct and sincere. On that basis, I withdraw the amendment at the moment and I should like if the Minister would say whether he will look into it or not. He may not be able to do very much but if he would do whatever he is able to do he would be going a bit of the way towards stopping all this nonsense because a lot of the stuff is nothing more than nonsense.
Comment on this
The Senator is aware that it has always been the practice of every Minister for Lands in replying to any question to refuse to give either the name or any particulars in such cases.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) The Minister shall lay before each House of the Oireachtas on the 1st day of January and the 1st day of July each year a list giving particulars of the cases in which he has authorised an officer to make a determination pursuant to subsection (1) of this section."
The last words of the Minister were very amusing. When a Question was asked in the Dáil last year in which no names were mentioned, the first thing the Minister said in his reply was "I believe you are referring to lands owned by Senator L'Estrange". The name of the farm was not mentioned in the Question. The Minister made sure to mention my name in his reply.
Comment on this
The Question was about land in a particular townland. The townland was mentioned. The Minister got up and said: "I believe you are referring to the land owned by Senator L'Estrange".
Comment on this
There were replies given where the Minister did not preface his remarks by giving the name.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Senator, but we were discussing the question of inspections and the desirability of publication. This has nothing whatever to do with the question he has raised.
Comment on this
It was not any such thing. It was a question as regards the acquisition of land, whether the Minister would take action to acquire the particular lands.
Comment on this
I consider the amendment a very reasonable amendment. If the Minister claims that everything is above board and that there will be no political intimidation I cannot see why he will not accept this very reasonable amendment and agree to lay on the Table of the House at least twice a year the list of farms he has ordered to be inspected. If there is nothing to hide I should like to know why he cannot give at least one good reason. Is he satisfied that there is to be continued whispering as to whose land was inspected? The Minister has stated that it would pinpoint the cases where the Minister had ordered inspection. Deputies and Senators should be entitled to have that information in order to ensure that there was no political intimidation. Until the Minister agrees to this procedure, in my opinion, the Minister is suspect and it would be our duty as the principal Opposition Party to protect the people from political blackmail, political intimidation and from arrogant and dictatorial legislation because, as Senator Lindsay has stated, justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done.
Comment on this
The reason for all this insinuation about political pressure, political influence and what any organisation can do is the fact that Senator L'Estrange's conscience is based on what happened here between 1922 and 1932 when a Cumann na nGaedheal Government were in power——
Comment on this
——which ensured that on the roads and in the Board of Works nobody could get a job unless he had fought for the Free State against the Republic.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange was allowed to develop that theme. I am entitled to develop the theme that he is all wrong, that he has a guilty conscience and that because the Government which he supported at that time were suspect, every succeeding Government were also suspect. I maintain that when Senator L'Estrange makes these allegations he should give time, date and names. If he alleges political pressure or political influence or that a certain thing was done by a Minister or by the Head of any Department, he should specify the time, the place, the name. Until he does that, I shall continue to interrupt and to question him and to insist that that be not tolerated in this House.
Comment on this
May I say that I think Senator Ó Maoláin is quite wrong in the interpretation and in the argument he has advanced? I do not take the line that he took. I do not accept that he is right in the view he has put forward. My view is that Senator L'Estrange and many other people make the case they do, not because they are members of Fine Gael, not because they are on that side of the House, but because they are conscious of the fact that they are land owners rather than farmers. They are afraid that if any inspector of the Land Commission should inspect the lands that they occupy, it would be obvious in many cases that the Land Commission would have a ready-made case for acquisition under the Land Acts. That is why there is this barrage against section 27. This barrage is really a smoke-screen to protect people who, in their own uneasy conscience, feel that the Land Commission would have a case for acquisition. They are protecting themselves by these attacks so that the inspectors of the Land Commission and the Commissioners will fight shy.
Comment on this
The Minister in his remarks earlier on the section stated that it was a section for the purpose of removing doubt and invited any Senator in the House to point out to him any section in any Land Act passed since the foundation of the State which provided that this power of directing an inspection is a reserved function to the Lay Commissioners.
In reply to that question, I wish to ask the Minister if it is not a fact that every political head of the Department since the foundation of the State regarded this power of ordering an inspection as a reserved function and that no such political head ever exercised the function which the Minister now asks the Oireachtas to confer on him as political head of the Department. Senator Boland, who was a Minister of State for many years, stated on the Second Reading that any political head of the Department who would interfere in the acquisition of land would need to get his head examined.
Comment on this
Then I suggest that forthwith we should appoint a psychiatrist to examine the political head of the Land Commission because this section which will undoubtedly be put through the House confers on the political head of this Department power in regard to the initial step in the acquisition of land and I defy contradiction on that.
Comment on this
I defy contradiction. I am taking the word of Senator Boland in regard to the need for psychiatry.
Comment on this
Would the Senator give way so that I may correct what he has said? If the Senator looks up the record, he will find that what I referred to was anybody who would have anything to do with the distribution of land, not the acquisition.
Comment on this
Even accepting what the Senator says — and since I have not a report of what he said, I accept his correction—surely in a small locality the first step in the distribution of land is the first step in the acquisition of land and it boils down to the same thing.
Comment on this
Just to prove the Senator's case. These innuendoes have been going on too long without challenge.
Comment on this
The Senator is talking a bit up in the air if he is talking about names. I am quoting what Senator Boland said and I am developing it. Not alone must justice be done but it must appear to be done. The Minister resisted amendments Nos. 36 and 37 on the grounds that it would not be possible to implement those amendments and that in implementing those amendments one would be giving more undesirable publicity to the inspection of land. If that is so and if it is impossible to put any curb on the political head of the Department, that is all the more reason why that political head should not ask for the power contained in this section and why this House should not give it to him.
I have not been convinced by the argument that this section is necessary to cut red tape, that it is necessary to expedite the acquisition of land. What can the Minister do that the Lay Commissioners could not do? If the Minister can delegate his authority down the line, why could not the Lay Commissioners delegate that authority? What is the objection to the Lay Commissioners saying to an inspector: "We delegate you to deal with these requests for distribution or inspection of land that have come to us"? That is one of the things puzzling me about this section and one of the things I fail to understand in it.
The Minister told us on a previous occasion that these requests will come right up the line from the most junior inspector to the next inspector, and so on. All these requests for inspection, for distribution or acquisition of land whoever they are addressed to, should be sent to the Secretary of the Land Commission who happens to be in this case a Lay Commissioner or if not to the Secretary of the Land Commission, to one of the Lay Commissioners set aside for that purpose and that he should direct what land is to be inspected and what is not to be inspected.
The future of every civil servant within the Land Commission lies in the hands of the political head of the Department for the time being. If an inspector is sent down to inspect land, knowing that he is being sent to do so on the direction of the Minister who is head of his Department, surely that civil servant is likely to be biased, is likely to go out in the frame of mind that the Minister wants this land to be acquired and may well approach the matter with a prejudice in favour of reporting that the land should be acquired.
That is one of the big dangers that I see here. If the authority was delegated to that man by the Lay Commissioners, that inspector would know that the Lay Commissioners could not possibly have any axe to grind and that his only duty was to make a fair and impartial inspection and to supply a fair and impartial report to the Lay Commissioners. We have got on without this section since the foundation of the State and a most compelling argument in favour of resisting the section is the Minister's argument when he says that he thought he always had this power and that his predecessors had it and yet not one of them used it and no Minister ever asked for it explicitly.
I should like the Minister to explain what is the objection to regarding this power of directing an inspection as still being a reserved function, reserved to the Lay Commissioners, and allowing them to delegate it. As far as I am concerned, and certainly as far as this Party are concerned, the Minister will get all the authority and cooperation he likes between the Commissioners and the person who is to carry out the inspection. I have no objection to that and I cannot see how any time would be wasted by adopting that procedure rather than what is suggested by the Minister.
Acquisition and distribution of land are very serious and sacred matters and are so regarded by the people and I shall conclude by saying that the first step in the acquisition of land is the inspection of the holding. I defy contradiction when I say that the first step in the distribution of land is the first step in inspecting it, as the Minister surely knows that what brings about an inspection with a view to acquisition, is a demand from people in the locality, through one channel or another, for land, with a statement that they badly need land and that there is a farm belonging to so-and-so which is suitable for acquisition and distribution.
Therefore, I think the case is conclusive that not alone is the Minister, under this section, taking on himself the first step in the acquisition of land but is also taking on himself the first step in its distribution. I do not want to hold up the distribution of land but I really believe that there is nothing that the Minister, by taking to himself this authority, can do to expedite land division that the Land Commissioners cannot do, given the proper machinery.
Comment on this
Tar éis bheith ag éisteacht le cainteoirí thall ar feadh tamaill maith ag cur síos ar an alt seo is deachair a thuiscint cad tá in aigne acu. Tá siad ag iarraidh cur in a luí orainn, agus is dócha ar mhuintir na tíre, gurab iad féin cosantóirí na ndaoine agus taca na bhfeirmeoirí agus nach bhfuil aon tsuim againne san obair. Níl bun ná barr leis sin mar tá oiread spéise againne le h-éinne maidir le cad is cheart a dhéanamh mar gheall ar ghabháil agus roinnt talúin.
Táim go mór i gcoinne an leasaithe seo toisc an phoiblíocht a thabharfadh sé don obair a bheadh le déanamh agus an tagairt do dhaoine bheith ag tnú le cuairt an chigire talúin. B'fhéidir go mbeadh siad ag caint; bíonn siad ag caint ar a lán rudaí ach tá deifríocht mhór idir chogar mogar agus rud a chur sa pháipéar nó in Iris Oifigiúil. Is fearr an t-alt a fhágaint mar atá sé. Ní féidir liom a thuiscint cad na thaobh go bhfuil na Seanadóirí thall chomh amhrasach mar gheall air agus mar gheall ar an obair atá dhá déanamh ag cigirí Choimisiún na Talmhan agus ag na Coimisinéirí. Daoine neamhspleácha iad na Coimisinéirí agus na cigirí. Níl dabht ar bith mar gheall air sin.
D'admhaigh na daoine thall an méid sin. Má táimid sásta go bhfuil na hoifigí seo neamhspleách i gcóimhlíonadh a gcuid dualgaisí cén eagla atá orainn cúram talúin a thabhairt dóibh? Táimid go léir le blianta fada ag tathaint ar gach Rialtas agus ar gach Aire Talmhan talamh a thógaint anseo is ansúd agus í a roinnt idir feirmeoirí nach bhfuil acu ach paistí beaga. Sin í an fhadbh is mó atá againn—teacht i gcabhair ar na daoine sin agus iad a thógaint as an drochchuma in a bhfuil siad. Sin é an dualgas atá ar Oireachtas Éireann agus má theipeann orainn sin a dhéanamh tá sé de cheart ag na daoine an milleán a chur orainn.
Nílimid i gcoinne na bhfeirmeoirí; táimid ar thaobh na bhfeirmeoirí agus sin é an fáth go bhfuil an Bille seo á reachtáil againn. Táimid ag teacht i gcabhair ar na feirmeoirí pé áit sa tír ina bhfuil siad. Sé ár ndualgas é sin a dhéanamh. Sé ár ndualgas an talamh d'fháil ar dtúis, í a roinnt go cothrom agus go macánta agus sin é díreach an rud a dhéinann Coimisiún na Talmhan. Ní rógairí iad agus tá a lán muinín againn astu agus sin mar is cóir. Sé is mó is ceart dúinn a dhéanamh féachaint timpeall lena fháil amach an bhfuil talamh na tíre dhá h-oibriú i gceart ag na daoine ag a bhfuil sí. Tá talamh ag cuid acu agus táid dhá h-oibriú chomh maith agus is féidir leo. Tá mórán eile gabháltaisí beaga ann agus d'fhéadfaí iad a oibriú níos fearr dá mbeadh tuille talúin ar fáil.