We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Mines and Quarries Bill, 1964— Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–133 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Mines and Quarries Bill, 1964
Enacted

No. 33 of 1964 ›

Before I come to the substance of the amendment, one of the definitions in the Bill is that "the Minister" means the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The particular meaning of "Minister for Industry and Commerce" has changed since the Second Reading. I should like to welcome Dr. Hillery on his first occasion here as Minister for Industry and Commerce and to wish him well in his relations with this House in the discharge of his duties.

I move amendment No. 1:

In subsection (3), line 33, after "on" to add: "otherwise than for the purpose of the working of the mine or quarry".

The purpose of this amendment is to clarify the position in regard to operations which are carried on at a mine or a quarry and in regard to which there might be some doubt as to whether they should properly be covered by the Mines and Quarries Bill or by the Factories Act. The position is that, as the section stands, works on manufacturing are excluded through this particular Bill, they being covered by the Factories Act. The form of amendment which I have put down would amend subsection (3) of section 3 in order to bring certain operations within the scope of this Bill, namely, operations which might otherwise be thought as purely manufacturing operations. However, where the manufacturing of certain articles for the purpose of mining is concerned, it might be much better to lead to a unified code in regard to mines and quarries if these particular things were clearly under the Mines and Quarries Bill rather than under the factory code. I should be obliged if the Minister would give us his views on the position as it would be under the section as it stands and under the section as amended.

Comment on this
Patrick John Hillery Minister for Industry and Commerce (Dr. Hillery) Fianna Fáil

I think the amendment might not be necessary because of the words "subject thereto" in line 32 which bring in any procedures ancillary to the processing of mines. It does what the Senator wants.

Comment on this

I see. The Minister, then, is quite satisfied that the inclusion of the words "subject thereto" gives the clarification which the amendment looks for?

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendment in that case.

Comment on this

This is only a matter of deleting an interpretation contained in the subsection. It was used at an early stage in drafting but was subsequently removed. It is just a matter of deleting something which perhaps should have been deleted earlier.

Comment on this

The section deals with certain definitions and it is largely parallel with the corresponding section of the British Act of 1954, section 182. However, there are certain differences on which I should like clarification. There is a definition of "parent" on page 10, line 16. The first question I should like to ask is quite a minor one. In the drafting of the section, "parent" is defined as the person with whom the child is living. My question is whether it is clear that this defines a specific individual in a case where the child is living with both parents. Are both parents covered by the definition? If they are, is there any doubt as to which parent should act?

Comment on this

It means primarily the person having legal custody and in the absence of that person, an individual with whom the child is living.

Comment on this

Which of the parents would have the legal custody?

Comment on this

This is a matter of law and I do not know the law on it.

Comment on this

Presumably it is the father.

Comment on this

I assume it is the father. Up to now either parent had inalienable rights in dealing with children. I assume the father would be regarded as the legal guardian.

Comment on this

In a case where a child was living with a couple but where he is not legally adopted — it does not arise if he is — could the Minister say that no difficulty would arise as to the specific one person involved?

Comment on this

I do not think so. The words "having actual custody" are used and refer to the person with whom the child is living.

Comment on this

The wording is different from the corresponding provision in the British Act and I take it there was good reason for the variation. The definition in the British Act proposes the idea of the person who is receiving a direct benefit from the wages of the young person employed in the mine or quarry. I am perfectly satisfied with the Minister's assurance on the point. One other point involves the use of the word "prescribed". What is its meaning in this context? Does it mean prescribed under this Act or prescribed under any other Act?

Comment on this

By regulation made under this Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 11, line 51, to delete "(other than a special regulation)".

The position under section 8 is that the regulations made under the Bill shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas. However, it is provided in section 8 that special regulations need not be laid before each House of the Oireachtas. The special regulations to be made under this section are regulations which do not apply to all the mines or all the quarries of a particular class. There is a reasonable case that these regulations should not be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas, that a regulation which might apply only to some minor matter involving some small mine is not a matter which should properly become the concern of both Houses.

Nevertheless, is there not some small danger here in completely excluding all special regulations? It may well be that if the Minister made a special regulation under the Act which did not cover all mines or all quarries of a particular type, nevertheless it might cover a very large majority of mines and quarries. He might make special regulations in respect of three-quarters of the mines or quarries of a particular type and would thereby be laying down regulations covering the greater part of the industry. The reason I put down the amendment is to point out that we may be drawing the line a little hard and a little too far away from parliamentary review of the regulations by excluding all special regulations.

Comment on this

A special regulation is a regulation applicable to one mine or quarry only, so there would have to be a series of special regulations to bring about the effect the Senator mentioned. As the Senator says, it would be a bit much to ask that both Houses of the Oireachtas should have a copy of every special regulation. There is a wide arrangement for consultation and, as the Senator knows, every application must be accompanied by a draft, and the Minister must give notice to the person affected of his intention to make the regulation. He must also make arrangements for the provision of copies of the draft and for facilities for lodging objections. He must consider objections which are made, and if an objection is made by the owner of a mine or a quarry, there must be an inquiry, so clearly there is a wide arrangement for full inquiry and consultation. It is hardly necessary to put in the amendment which the Senator suggests. Again we go back to the fact that the special regulation applies to one mine.

Comment on this

The Minister appreciates that the necessity for coming to the Dáil and the Seanad could be circumvented by making a series of special regulations. If a Member of either House thought a special regulation should properly come before the House, I wonder could the Minister give an undertaking that he would be prepared to deal with it expeditiously.

Comment on this

If the Senator feels strongly that there is any danger that the Minister would use the device of having a series of special regulations made to cover an area of policy rather than an individual mine, I think the amendment could be accepted, but I do not think there is any such danger.

Comment on this

I must say I would feel happier if the amendment could be accepted.

Comment on this

Section 11 provides for the carrying into operation, on the coming into force of the new Act, of certain provisions in previous Acts, which will be repealed on the commencement of the new Act. I should like to ask the Minister how does he intend to implement the new Act. Apparently the position is that on the commencement of the new Act all the regulations now in force in regard to mines and quarries, will become regulations prescribed under the new Act. We would then have all the regulations coming into force, and they would not have had the benefit of the procedure outlined in the Second Schedule. There is a very excellent procedure outlined in the Second Schedule for proper review, and for submissions by all interested parties. In regard to the new procedures, is it intended to have any review, any consultation, and to take advice from interested bodies before the commencement of the new Act, or does the Minister intend to bring in all the existing regulations holus-bolus in their present form?

Comment on this

It is essential that all the existing regulations should come into force at once or there would be a gap. I should imagine that after that certain repeals would be considered.

Comment on this

There will be a period during which the Act will be in force and the old regulations will be in force.

Comment on this

To prevent a gap.

Comment on this

The only other point I should like to raise is the question of the great necessity for an informative publication of what precisely the position is when the new Act comes into operation. This is a complex and rather technical measure. It is difficult to study it and to find out what exactly it means. I had great difficulty when I was attempting to study it in finding out the position in regard to mines and quarries legislation. As soon as this Bill comes into force all the regulations will be regulations under the Act. I think it is highly desirable that there should be a digest of information and a summary of the position under the Act. In Britain the position in regard to the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, is very clear. Actually there are four volumes which give an explanation of the mines and quarries code. I think we might well follow suit, perhaps not in such detail, but I think a volume should be issued of the new code for mines and quarries which would cover the statutory position and also the regulations.

Comment on this

I shall note the suggestion made by the Senator.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In subsection (1), line 38, to delete "planned, laid out".

I put down this amendment because as the section now reads it mentions the duty of the owner to secure that the mine or quarry "is planned, laid out, managed and worked..." I was a little worried that there might be a danger of ambiguity as the section is drafted. It is drafted as if the words "planned" and "managed" were mutually exclusive terms. I do not think that this is so, and I think it might be well if we could distinguish between planning which is done before the mine is in operation and planning done after the mine comes into operation. It seems to me that planning and laying out done after a mine comes into operation is part of the managing function, and as the part of the managing function should be reserved to the qualified manager appointed under section 13. As the section stands, there might be some doubt as to the powers of management which are delegated to the qualified manager. The manager must be qualified; the owner need not be. If we leave the power of planning to the owner, who need not be a qualified person, there is a danger that a dispute could arise. It might have to be determined in court whether or not a certain operation after the mine has started to produce was a function of planning or a function of management. The purpose of the amendment is to clear that point.

Comment on this

I do not see the ambiguity. I imagine the owner has an overall responsibility for everything to do with the mine. The manager has prescribed responsibilities under the owner. I do not see that there can be ambiguity in respect of responsibility.

Comment on this

My worry is that there is no doubt that any planning done in advance of the working of the mine before operations start is properly the preserve of the owner. There is no doubt about that. What I am worried about is, after a mine has started to operate there might be certain functions and there could be doubt as to whether these were planning for the continued operation of the mine or management. A question arises as to whether the owner can intervene over the head of the qualified manager on matters which could be held as planning, since they were long term rather than managing, which might be held to be the day to day operation of the mine.

Comment on this

This section covers the original lay-out of the mine.

Comment on this

That is my reading of it too.

Comment on this

Another section would place the responsibility of planning changes in the mine. There is provision in the Bill for the Minister's inspectors to see after faulty planning. I do not think in actual operation there can be ambiguity.

Comment on this

In the hope that planning will be interpreted as advance planning, in which case no ambiguity would arise, I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 5 and 8 will be taken together. They are cognate. There can be separate decisions if necessary but the two can be taken together for discussion.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In subsection (1), line 4, to delete "(if any)".

I shall make a case first in regard to the amendment to section 13. Subsection (1) of section 13 reads: "...no mine shall be worked unless there is a sole manager of the mine, being an individual duly appointed and having such qualifications (if any) as are required under this Part". There is no doubt that the whole spirit of the Bill is that there should be more close control over the particular qualifications which the manager of a mine should have. I do not know if there will be any difficulties on the commencement of the Act in regard to this — that regulations have not been made. If there were any difficulty of that sort, I think it is very undesirable that it should be left open as it is now open under this subsection, that there would be no regulations in regard to the qualifications of managers.

The whole spirit of this particular Bill is that managers must be highly qualified persons. I know the parliamentary draftsman likes to leave a number of loopholes of this sort by putting in "if any"? but I think it would be a most reprehensible position if at any period this Bill were in force as an Act and there were no regulations in regard to the qualifications of mine managers.

Comment on this

In section 15 it is specified that qualifications are required only in places where fourteen persons work underground. You can have managers who have no academic qualifications or specified qualifications, but in all cases the Minister would require that they would be suitable persons from experience or otherwise. I think the amendment would go against the spirit of section 15 which provides that a mine manager must have qualifications only if more than fourteen persons are employed underground.

Comment on this

I appreciate that there will be, and there has been in the past, different degrees of qualifications for different types and sizes of mines. It is absolutely reasonable that there should be different qualifications where more than fourteen people are employed than where there are fewer than fourteen people. I think that is no reason why we should have a position that there is no one single regulation for the qualifications of a person who is going to manage a mine in which twelve people are employed. I feel, even if there are only half a dozen people employed in a mine, there should be some regulation in this regard. There is no need for us to say that in a small mine a person should have a mining diploma or so many years of experience of mining underground.

I think it is entirely reasonable to say that no mine should be worked in this country unless there is some definition of what the qualification of the manager is. We should not lose sight of the fact that we will probably find under the operation of this Bill that there may be more accidents and more danger in the smaller mines than in the larger ones. For the protection of the workmen there should be some qualifications. The Minister has ample power under this Bill to differentiate between the qualifications for the different types and sizes of mines. I feel it is setting an extremely bad headline if we leave this open. There should be no class of mine for which there is no qualification. In other words, an owner can employ anybody. He can put in his unqualified and perhaps not too competent son as manager of a mine just because not more than fourteen people are employed.

Comment on this

I should like to support Senator Dooge on this point. I think it is most important that the manager of a mine should be a fully qualified man. The question of the number of men has never been specifact is it is a mine, a serious business, and as everybody knows all over the world where mines are operated the number of men have never been specified. I am surprised at the point made by the Minister regarding the small number of men involved. The fact is it is a mine and men are underground and need to be protected. We know the greater the number of men the greater the responsibility. The principle is the same; there should be a qualified man performing a job of that kind. In most jobs not so serious as this, management generally see that they get a qualified man to run the industry. The first thing they do is see whether a man is qualified to do a particular job so that everything will go right. For that reason, I think Senator Dooge has made a very important point. It is a serious matter to allow a provision such as section 13 go through in the Bill in that way. An owner might decide that he had not many men employed and it did not matter who his manager was. The principle is the same, the dangers are the same and the reasons are the same why we should see that no risks are taken whether it involves one life or a thousand lives.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Surely the words "if any" are not required in the subsection. If no qualifications are prescribed, then there are no qualifications prescribed for the post. Why should "if any" be prescribed? Surely the word "qualifications" does not mean academic qualifications. One might be qualified for a post by experience, by apprenticeship or other means. I think if the Minister took out the words "if any" there would be no difference in the meaning. If no qualifications are prescribed, then no qualifications are prescribed. I cannot see any point in having the words "(if any)".

Comment on this

I do not know if this amendment would achieve what Senator Dooge wants. Section 15 brings in this question of 14 persons. A mine employing more than 14 persons below ground requires the manager to have qualifications which may be prescribed. A mine smaller than that does not require these qualifications. I do not consider the changing of the words "(if any)" would have any effect. The point being raised might be raised on section 15.

Comment on this

I accept what the Minister says. My reaction to the words "(if any)" is that they set an extremely bad headline.

Comment on this

It is a logical follow-on to the conception that there will be mines where no qualifications are required because of their size. I would point out that there are other parts of the Bill which give protection to the workers. We could discuss this matter on section 15 and leave it as it is.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

What good are the words to the Minister?

Comment on this

If you accept the section, "(if any)" comes in as a fact.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

I do not think so.

Comment on this

If we let section 15 stand, then the two words "(if any)" must in fact go into this section because then there will be some mines for which qualifications are not required. When discussing section 15, if we decide to go away from the figure of 14 persons, which is something inherited from existing legislation, and decide to change it, then we could take away those two words.

Comment on this

The difficulty is that the House has to make up its mind whether or not to accept section 13 before section 15 is raised. It would help us on this matter if the Minister would give some indication as to whether he is willing to consider the amendment on Report Stage on section 15 before we make up our minds on section 13.

Comment on this

I shall accept the Senator's amendment. It means a change later on.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

Again, I am a little anxious about the position on the commencement of the Act, particularly in regard to the question of qualification. It may be that this is more appropriate to a later section but it is as well to raise the matter at the first available opportunity. As I read the Bill before us, on the commencement of the operation of the Bill, the Act of 1911 will be withdrawn and the protection in regard to qualifications given under section 2 of that Act will no longer be available. The Minister has already indicated that as he sees it the Bill will come into force and no new regulations will be made. Therefore, it looks as if there would be an interregnum during which the protection of section 2 of the 1911 Act would have been repealed and the special qualifications made by the procedure under this Act would not yet be in force. There would therefore be between the period of commencement of the Act and the period of making regulations, in regard to qualifications, no statutory provisions in regard to qualifications of mine managers.

Comment on this

The Act will be brought into operation by Ministerial Order and the regulations will be brought into operation at the same time.

Comment on this

This will meet the difficulty.

Comment on this

I should like to express welcome for the amendment which was introduced by the Minister during the proceedings in Dáil Éireann. Every one of us will agree that the safety and health of workers should not be jeopardised in any way. This requires the necessity of employing qualified managers. This was a most excellent amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

In line 22, before "as" to insert "as were prescribed before the passing of this Act subject to such amendments, alterations or additions".

This amendment is again to cover the transition period between the mines and quarries code which we have at the moment and the new code which we will have on the coming into operation of the regulations under the Bill. If this amendment were accepted, it would mean that the position would be that we would start off with the assurance that we had all the safeguards and all the necessary qualifications laid down which we had under the 1911 Act. If there happened to be any interregnum between the passing of the Bill and the making of regulations, this amendment would provide that during the interregnum the qualifications which must be held by mining managers would be the qualifications of the repealed section of the 1911 Act. It would also provide that these would remain in force until such time as they were either modified by extension or reduction in any respect. This amendment would be an added safeguard in case the Minister finds himself unable to bring in the Act and the regulations on the same day. It would also provide that during the interregnum we have the regulations under the 1911 Act carried out.

Comment on this

I do not think this will arise. We will not have an interregnum. I do not think, in general, the amendment would change the law very much. It is not intended to change the law. It is only intended to meet the interregnum and I do not think that question will arise because the Act is brought into force by order and control of the regulations is also brought into operation by order.

Comment on this

It is some months since I studied this Bill in detail. What would happen if the Minister makes an order? He could annul regulations by order by either House of the Oireachtas. Surely there would be an interregnum.

Comment on this

An order will be operative immediately I make it but it could be annulled.

Comment on this

Surely the position would be that there would be no regulations until the new regulations were made?

Comment on this

I still do not think this is necessary. If any of the regulations are annulled, they are annulled immediately. You cannot have two sets of regulations running side by side.

Comment on this

My amendment states that until the new regulations are made, the regulations under the code prior to the commencement of the Act still hold.

Comment on this

Senator Dooge is defeating his own argument. If the regulations were made under this Act, then immediately previous regulations go out. In other words, the regulations you are trying to bring in now will cancel the regulations already there on the commencement of this Act. Although the new regulations may be annulled by either House of the Oireachtas, you cannot do anything about it because they have already cancelled the regulations under the previous Act.

Comment on this

Surely if the regulations were brought before both Houses of the Oireachtas, it would have the added effect of amending the regulations which come in. Then, if these are annulled by the Houses, surely their amending effect is annulled? Surely their negative as well as their positive aspects are annulled?

Comment on this

Until regulations are made under this Bill, the regulations under former Acts continue to operate.

Comment on this

But the statutory provisions in section 2 of the 1911 Act will be repealed. The actual section of the statute will be repealed. That is my worry.

Comment on this

Powers are taken in this Bill to continue the regulations.

Comment on this

If the Minister is confident that the regulations can be made on the same day as the commencement of the new Act, these difficulties do not arise. If the Minister is completely confident on that point, I shall withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I am sorry, I misled the House. This Bill will not be brought into operation until regulations are made so that until the Bill comes into operation the regulations under older Acts continue to operate.

Comment on this

If this is a completely positive intention——

Comment on this

I shall not bring this Bill into operation until regulations are made. It might be that such regulations would be annulled by both Houses of the Oireachtas: it is unlikely. However, I do not know if it will protect——

Comment on this

If the Minister is confident that they will come in on the same day, I shall withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Certain very definite qualifications are laid down under the 1911 Act. The Minister is confident that he will make his regulations on the same day as the new Act comes into force and these would then be the regulations when the Act commences. I should like if the Minister could give some indication as to what his policy will be, in the new regulations, in regard to qualification. It is tremendously important that any new regulations made under section 15, and any qualifications to which section 15 gives effect, should be not less stringent in any way than the regulations set up over 50 years ago under the 1911 Act. I realise that the Minister has not had time to make up his mind about many matters of this sort. I must ask him if he is prepared to state now that the qualifications will be not less than those in force on the passing of the Act.

Comment on this

There will be no reduction in the standard of the qualifications required.

Comment on this

I am very happy to have that assurance from the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

In subsection (1), line 47, to delete "(if any)".

In view of what happened to the previous amendment, I take it that "(if any)" will go the way of all flesh here also?

Comment on this

Yes, that would be logical.

Comment on this

There is one omission here—I thought it might be just as well to mention it—and that is the question in regard to deputies. There is provision I think somewhere in this code for the appointment of deputies. Nowhere else do we find in the Bill any provision for the qualification of deputies. What is the position in regard to that?

Comment on this

It seems to me that the same procedure would stand for a deputy—that a qualification would be prescribed for a deputy by the Minister.

Comment on this

I take it that these would be the same as the qualifications for managers?

Comment on this

Yes, the same as for the manager in that particular mine.

Comment on this

Yes, the same class of mine, the man he is replacing.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In subsection (1), to add a new paragraph as follows:

"( ) the preparation of such plans, sections and other documents as may be required."

In this Bill, as it stands here at the moment, it seems to me that there is a presumption that no owner and no manager of a mine will employ a specialised surveyor. In the Bill, the provision is that, in the event of the Minister's inspector not being satisfied with certain surveys and drawings, the Minister will appoint a surveyor. No option, it seems, is given to the owner or manager of the mine to employ a surveyor on his own behalf.

Comment on this

He is quite free to have the work done either by an expert or by a member of his staff. The position is that the Minister can deal with faulty planning.

Comment on this

I am glad to have the Minister's assurance on this particular point. Under section 18, the duties of different people are laid down. There is no duty on the managers of mines to appoint surveyors because their operations are not covered by the various paragraphs here in section 18 which provides that the managers shall appoint people to secure this, that and the other. It seems to me that there might well be some special provision whereby there is a duty to appoint surveyors.

Comment on this

It would restrict the manager of the mine too much, I think, to specify it. The other appointments mentioned here are for safety reasons. Faulty planning is dealt with under another section. The managers of mines may appoint somebody on their own staff capable of dealing with this particular type of planning or some outside agency or expert.

Comment on this

It is probably covered by subsection (2), anyway.

Comment on this

I do not think the manager should be restricted.

Comment on this

My amendment, as drafted, puts a rather severe obligation on all managers and it might not be proper to do so. With the permission of the House, therefore, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

There is provision here for under managers. In the British Act under managers must be appointed in mines unless the inspector recommends this is not so. It will be appreciated that there is not the same necessity for under managers in mines in Ireland because of the lesser scale of operations but it does seem that if we leave out altogether any mention of under managers some difficulties might arise. I raise the point in order to ascertain if the Minister is completely satisfied that no difficulties will arise in this connection.

Comment on this

I mentioned that this would be covered by the heading "such officials". I do not foresee any difficulties arising.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In line 32, to delete "his duties" and substitute "the duties of that person".

The section says:

It shall be the duty of the manager of every mine to ensure to the best of his ability that every person appointed by him in pursuance of this Act or of regulations understands the nature and scope of his duties.

I put down the amendment because I think there is a very real ambiguity. There are two people involved, the manager and the person appointed by the manager. The final words of the section are "his duties". According to the rules of grammar as I learned them quite some time ago, "his" here refers to the person last named. Section 19 in that sense would read that it shall be the duty of the manager of every mine to ensure to the best of his ability that every person appointed by him understands the nature and scope of the duties of the manager. That is clear from an absolutely grammatical reading of the section. My amendment has been tabled to remove that ambiguity.

Comment on this

The word "person" has been used previously.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister but there is this ambiguity——

Comment on this

I am informed the parliamentary draftsmen are satisfied there is no ambiguity.

Comment on this

I hope they will not find themselves wrong.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Sometimes they do.

Comment on this

There is no ambiguity as regards legal phraseology.

Comment on this

There could be sea lawyers in underground mines. However, if the Minister is happy with the parliamentary draftsmen's grammar——

Comment on this

I am happy with their meaning.

Comment on this

I should like to refer here to the appointment of a surveyor. I am not quite sure how this would work out in practice. The point at issue is that where plans were unsatisfactory the Minister's inspector could investigate. The section gives the Minister power to appoint a surveyor to make a new plan or section. Can I take it that in practice the Minister's inspector might make a recommendation to the manager?

Comment on this

It empowers the Minister to employ and it does not say to employ through a surveyor.

Comment on this

It says the Minister may appoint. It does not give the mine manager freedom.

Comment on this

He would be able to do it himself.

Comment on this

Therefore, the provisions of this section are provisions of the last resort.

Comment on this

Section 32 deals with the means of ingress to and egress from mines. On comparing this with the provisions of section 22 of the 1954 British Act, the provisions proposed by the Minister here appear to be somewhat more severe than those of a relatively recent Act in Britain. It seems to me that the provisions here in this respect are a little too severe. There is a statutory restriction which calls for the fact that there shall be at least two shafts of egress from every seam being worked. On the Second Stage I dwelt at some length on the particular position of mining in this country, on the fact that mining in Ireland very often consists of small seams. There are many cases in this country where we have several small pits being worked in the same mine. Under the British code as I read it, these very small pits are part of the same mine and could use a common exit. However, it appears from this section that small pits, no matter how adjacent, must have separate exits. Maybe I am reading this as being a little more severe than it actually is.

Comment on this

Subsection (7) provides for exemptions which would take the apparent severity out of the section.

Comment on this

I agree that that will meet it. It is better to be severe and to give exemptions than to be lax at the beginning. One other point on the section is the provision that will apply following the accidental closure of an exit. The position under the section is that the manager is bound to maintain at least two outlets from every seam being worked. What is the position of the manager in the event of the accidental closure of one? There is no doubt that work must immediately cease but they have had a great deal of experience in Britain in this field and they are not particularly careless, yet they provide that the manager has discretion, if he posts special notices and sends notice to the Minister's inspector, to allow the shift to be worked out and safety workers to go underground for 24 hours. This is a case in which special exemption might be made under subsection (7). It would be desirable in this case.

Comment on this

I referred to a similar difficulty earlier in cases where ten or more persons are employed at the same time. If we have nine we are not compelled to provide two exits. My suggestion is that when there are fewer than ten men working they should not be permitted to work apart or at any great distance from the one exit. Some distance should be laid down. It could easily happen that a small number might be scattered and work apart. It might only be one but there could be 20 or 30 working together and they need not be near an exit. I am concerned with the principle. There is a great danger and a great risk where the management are free to have only one exit. The principle appears to be wrong. The manager is free to extend the area where they work. Something may happen away from the exit and nine people, or the ten who are allowed under this Bill, may not be near the exit and can easily get lost. I do not like to have that principle in the section, once it involves more than one, two or three people.

Comment on this

I rise on this section as a matter of pure curiosity. My question is: what on earth is the need for two subsections in section 34?

Comment on this

It is a consolidating Bill.

Comment on this

It was duly consolidated in the United Kingdom in 1954 in precisely the same words, written in one subsection. I admit this is curiosity concerning the ways of the parliamentary draftsman.

Comment on this

It is the draftsman's way of doing it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

Before subsection (4), page 21, to insert a new subsection as follows:

"( ) Every road which is used at the beginning or end of a shift by not less than six persons shall be kept free from obstructions and the floor thereof shall be kept in good repair."

This is an important section. It deals with the construction and maintenance of underground roads, and we all appreciate that is a matter of extreme importance. Many things are prescribed which must be done by the manager in regard to underground roads, but there is no provision in this section under which such roads must be kept clear and free from obstruction. There should be a definite obligation, not only that the roads should be properly constructed, but that they should be kept clear and not obstructed by equipment, by dumped materials, or by anything else. I think it necessary that this obligation should be inserted in the section.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

Section 37 deals with height and width of travelling roads. I mentioned on Second Stage that in all probability the position will be that whereas in this instance we are being absolutely specific in regard to what is required, in that a certain height is mentioned, almost inevitably every coalmine in the country will seek exemption from this section. In subsection (2) the height of five feet six inches is prescribed but that will be almost impossible of fulfilment in the various coalmines.

Comment on this

I do not think the Senator spoke on the amendment.

Comment on this

I was talking on the section. I move amendment No. 12:

In subsection (3), line 24, before "this" to insert "subsection (1) of".

Section 145 lays down the procedure in regard to certain notices which inspectors may serve. This point was discussed on Second Stage. Section 145 refers to occasions on which an inspector requires an owner or a manager of a mine to do something more than is specifically laid down by statute. Where an inspector lets off an owner or a manager by giving an exemption, or by requiring something less, there is no need for this appeal procedure. Under section 37, it seems to me that this is the only section where we can have an increase of standard, and any exemption given under subsection (2) is not an appropriate exemption for the procedure of section 145. The point of the amendment is that unnecessarily elaborate procedure has been invoked in regard to exemptions under subsection (2).

Comment on this

It is unlikely that it will be used.

Comment on this

Elaborate procedure has been invoked which was a protection for the manager when an inspector asked him to do something particularly difficult. This is the only place in the Bill where it applies to an exemption and not a requirement.

Comment on this

What the Senator requires is that we apply it not where an appeal would be required, but where the situation represents an easement.

Comment on this

Throughout the Bill it has never been invoked where there is an easement.

Comment on this

I will accept that.

Comment on this

I apologise for having dealt with the section before the amendment. The point I made was that this is the one place in the Bill where we are imposing a regulation which I think will be virtually impossible of application to coalmines.

Comment on this

Provision has been made at an earlier stage for having another look at the requirements. I think it was on Committee Stage in the other House.

Comment on this

I just wished to comment on it, in passing.

Comment on this

I should like to raise a point on which I might well have put down an amendment, but I forbore to do so because the list was becoming rather long. As it stands, section 38 is identical with the similar provision in the United Kingdom code, but it omits subsection (2) of the corresponding section which allows a statutory defence to a manager or an owner, on the ground that the vehicles have been used on the roads for the sole purpose of repair, or in the case of sudden subsidence. The position is that the statutory defences which are allowed in the United Kingdom are not allowed here, and I should like to ask the Minister is there any significance in their omission. Does he agree it is reasonable that certain roads which would not be used during the time of normal mining should be used for the purpose of repair, or might need to be used in the case of sudden subsidence?

Comment on this

I have information on roofs and sides but not on subsidence of floors.

Comment on this

Subsidence of roofs would be involved.

Comment on this

I am not clear as to the point made by the Senator.

Comment on this

I raise this because on comparison I found a distinct difference between the section here and the corresponding section of the British code, in that a statutory defence which is allowed on a prosecution under this section in the British code has been omitted from this code. It seems severe that we do not allow our mine manager in this country to use these particular roads for the purposes of repair.

Comment on this

Section 136 sets out the different defences. That is probably the reason for not having it in this subsection. Section 136 is a blanket defence section.

Comment on this

It is a blanket all right but not thick enough to keep the manager warm. The defence is that it was impracticable to define, or to avoid contravention. Let us take the case for the purposes of repair, where a manager wishes to allow a particular vehicle to be run on a particular road which is relatively narrow. You have allowed him a defence. He will contravene section 38 by doing this and the defence you allow him is that it would be impracticable to avoid it. In Britain, he would be allowed the defence that if he used it not for the purposes of mining but for the purposes of sending in a man to repair, he is then allowed a proper defence. It is a deliberate act on his part to do it for the purposes of repair. I feel that the blanket defence in section 136 is not quite sufficient and I think the code is rather severe on managers. I would hope that this provision would not be invoked in practice by the Minister's inspectors, where certain things were done purely for the purposes of repairs. As I have no amendment, I do not want to press it further.

Comment on this