Mines and Quarries Bill, 1964— Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 134–265 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1964 ›
When this measure was being debated in Dáil Éireann, the Minister of the time undertook to consider a certain matter under subsection (2) of section 44. I should be glad to know if the Minister has any statement to make on it.
Comment on this
I am very sorry, but my note just says that the Minister undertook to reconsider the matter. My memory is that it is a matter in regard to the ages of certain persons undertaking certain duties. I think we could let the matter go, if the Minister has nothing on it.
Comment on this
An amendment was inserted by the Dáil. In subsection (3) of section 44, it says that an inspector may, on notice served by the manager of a mine, exempt any apparatus from subsection (2).
Comment on this
This means an inspector could by notice actually remove the restriction on any people undertaking certain of these dangerous duties. Is that the position under the amended section?
Comment on this
The amendment refers to an apparatus and also, of course, to the ages of the persons involved.
Comment on this
I think we could leave it to the good sense of the inspectors.
Comment on this
This section prescribes certain duties for the manager of a mine in regard to support of the mine. Certain measures must be taken if there is any movement of the strata. I should like to ask the Minister whether this imposes an obligation on the person who is manager of an idle mine, or a person who would be manager of a mine, parts of which have been abandoned.
Comment on this
What the Senator means is: if the mine ceases to be a working place, does responsibility devolve on the manager? I think this question arises in the section relating to abandoned mines. Part VII of the Bill says that owners must fence abandoned and disused mines. It is a responsibility of owners of mines not being worked. As the Senator knows, the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Act empowers the sanitary authorities to make dangerous places safe, places such as mine shafts and quarries, whether abandoned or not. I think what the Senator wants done is covered in both.
Comment on this
Part VII imposes the onus on the owner to fence an abandoned mine, but section 49 imposes a duty on a person who has been manager of a mine which became idle. He has a duty to maintain the support within that mine. There is the instance of a mine, part of which has been abandoned, where unless the manager's authority is revoked, he has a duty to maintain the support in this abandoned mine, or the abandoned parts of a mine. I raise this particulary because there is no provision in this section for an inspector to give an exemption order.
Comment on this
I do not think this would give rise to the point the Senator makes. If a mine is abandoned, it is covered by Part VII which I have mentioned. If there is an abandoned part of a working mine he has the responsibility to keep the working part of the mine safe and to ensure that the abandoned part would not endanger the working part in any way.
Comment on this
My trouble is that section 49 does not make any distinction between a working mine and an abandoned mine or parts of a working mine which are abandoned.
Comment on this
Would the Senator like to achieve the situation where this was clearly stated as a working part?
Comment on this
This could be achieved if the Minister's inspectors were given power to grant exemption from the duty of section 49. The Minister's inspectors could give an exempting order for the abandoned part where they were satisfied that it did not endanger the working parts. Unfortunately, there is no escape subsection.
Comment on this
The existence of disused mines would ensure that the responsibility to interfere was taken.
Comment on this
My worry is that we are placing too great an onus on the managers.
Comment on this
Does the Senator want it stated clearly that this applies only to working mines when another part of the Bill deals with disused parts as a separate consideration?
Comment on this
I have this anxiety naturally in examining the section. While I am looking at it in this way I feel this point is not clear. When a point is not clear I feel it should be put beyond doubt.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would feel it could be interpreted as referring to the security of workers. If there are no people in actual fact working there the security of the workers does not arise at all in abandoned mines. I think the word "secure" would meet the Senator's point.
Comment on this
It is a minor point and I have no wish to press it.
Comment on this
This section deals with the provision for lights and safety lighting in mines. At the present moment this is not terribly important in regard to mining in this country because we do not have gassy mines here. I am sure all of us hope that mining will expand as an industry and it may be that in future we will have to deal with the question of gassy mines. Therefore, we should deal with this section as if it were equally as relevant as all others. There is a provision here in regard to safety lamps and similar apparatus but the position is that there is no provision similar to the provision which occurs in the codes of other countries whereby it is an offence to interfere with safety lamps or lighting equipment of any type. This is a matter of such prime importance in other countries that it is actually made an offence to damage, interfere or tamper in any way with safety lamps which are used in gassy mines.
During the Second Stage of the Bill there was some discussion as to whether mine managers should be given power to introduce certain regulations on their own or to be able to fine workmen for breaches of the regulations. The Minister's predecessor felt it would be undesirable to do this. If we do not introduce any ruling here which makes it an offence to interfere with safety lamps or to tamper with them in any way then there is no provision for this. Amendment 13, which I shall move on section 75, seeks to repair this in some way. I thought it well to mention this matter on this section.
Comment on this
Section 140 covers the position of a person wilfully interfering with any man's appliance so this would cover the Senator's point.
Comment on this
It does not revoke any section in regard to the person who does so.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
Before section 75 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) A person employed at a mine who contravenes—
(a) any transport or support rules having effect with respect to the mine; or
(b) any directions given to him by or on behalf of the owner or manager of the mine or any rule made by the manager of the mine for regulating the conduct either of all persons employed thereat or any class of persons so employed to which that person belongs, being directions given, or a rule made, for the purpose of securing compliance with this Act, orders made thereunder or regulations or any transport or support rules having effect with respect to the mine or of securing the safety or health of that person or any other person employed at the mine;
shall be guilty of an offence.
(2) A person who negligently or wilfully does at a mine anything likely to endanger the safety of the mine or the safety or health of persons thereat or negligently or wilfully omits to do at a mine anything necessary for securing the safety of the mine or the safety or health of persons thereat shall be guilty of an offence.
(3) A person (not being an official of the mine) who, without permission granted by such an official, removes, alters or tampers with anything provided at a mine for the purpose of securing the safety or health of persons employed thereat shall be guilty of an offence."
This amendment proposes that a new section be inserted before section 75 in order to make it clear and put beyond any doubt that people who break any regulations which are made, whether they be transport rules, safety regulations or any other regulations which are imposed by the manager, shall be punished in accordance with the offence committed. It may well be that this is covered by section 140 but on my reading of the Bill I felt that this amendment would make this particular matter clear beyond any doubt. I should be interested to have the Minister's comment on it.
Comment on this
I have been advised that it would not be constitutional to allow rules made by managers of mines automatically to become law. It is open to the owner to make rules for his mine and to transmit them to the Minister as a draft for the making of special regulations. I think the matters covered in this suggested new section are covered in section 40, in the event of their becoming special regulations.
Comment on this
I am interested in what the Minister has to say on this particular point. May it be taken, then, in regard to regulations made in respect of a particular mine, that the Minister would make these the subject of special regulation? Would this become a normal thing or would it be an unusual thing?
Comment on this
He would have to publicise his intention of making such regulations and give interested parties an opportunity to object. He could then make the regulations or amend draft regulations. It is open to him to do it, subject to that consideration of allowing interested parties——
Comment on this
The Minister anticipates that this would be the best way in order to maintain these regulations?
Comment on this
It would be unconstitutional to allow a manager's regulations to become law without——
Comment on this
It is very desirable that the hands of managers, who carry very great responsibility under this Bill, should not be weakened in any way in regard to the carrying out of the regulations which they themselves make. I think the suggestion of the Minister that these could become special regulations is a most excellent one and I hope it becomes the practice. Accordingly, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In subsection (1), line 38, before ",that" to insert "or it is reported to him".
Section 75 deals with the duties of the manager and other persons in the case of danger arising in a particular mine. As the section reads at the moment, if the manager or other authorised person finds out that there is any danger of inflammable or noxious gas he can take certain precautions. It seems to me that, as the section reads, the manager is asked to take these precautions only if he knows this thing of his own knowledge. The amendment proposes that the manager may immediately take all the safety precautions that he can, and withdraw all the workmen from the mine and do all the other things necessary to be done as soon as it is reported to him by anybody and that there is no necessity for him to know this thing of his own knowledge. I think that is what would happen in practice. There is, I think, a slight danger that a manager who withdrew workmen needlessly might be subject to action by his owner for having done so when he did not personally know there was a real danger.
Comment on this
I do not think so. There is, generally, under the Bill a placing of responsibility on the shoulders of the managers and they are at liberty to evacuate a mine if they wish to do so. But the law should not, I think, require them to do it on a report, in so far as there could be many rumours and reports which would be better investigated by the manager before making a decision.
Comment on this
I think that is reasonable and I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
What is the position in the event of danger being discovered by some other person who is perfectly competent to determine whether there is danger? For example, what is the position if a Minister's inspector sees danger arising, or sees danger arising very rapidly, during the time he is inspecting a mine? Is it necessary for him then to report to the manager?
Comment on this
I do not think you would have to legislate for that. Somewhere else in the Bill, inspectors have rights to take action at once.
Comment on this
I suppose that, if they took action, nobody would disagree.
Comment on this
It is suggested that we take amendments Nos. 15, 16, 17 and 18 together.
Comment on this
The section provides that regulations may require provision for washing and changing, canteen facilities and an adequate supply of drinking water. It was suggested on the Committee Stage in the Dáil that the provision of some of these amenities should be made a statutory requirement and the Minister undertook to look at the section to see if it would be possible to separate the minimal requirements from the desirable ones. As a result of the examination which was made, it was considered that the supply of drinking water should be a statutory requirement.
Comment on this
In view of the Government amendments in regard to the provision of drinking water, I shall not move amendment No. 18, which seeks to do the same thing. I wish to express thanks to the Minister for meeting this point. Mining is a thirsty business, probably more thirst provoking than discussing a Mining Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
Before section 95 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) Where the person in charge of a part of a quarry is of opinion that a danger exists at any place in that part, he shall comply with the following requirements, namely:—
(a) he shall forthwith cause all persons employed in so much of that part as appears to him to be affected (hereinafter referred to as the "affected area") to leave it;
(b) unless he is a manager of the quarry, he shall, forthwith ofter complying with the foregoing paragraph, inform his immediate superior or, in a case where he is responsible to two or more immediate superiors, each of them within whose jurisdiction any part of the affected area is situated, that the danger exists;
(c) so soon after complying with paragraph (b) of this subsection section (or, in a case where that paragraph does not apply, paragraph (a) of this subsection) as it is possible so to do without undue risk, he shall himself ascertain, or cause some competent person to ascertain, the condition of the affected area and the measures that it is necessary to take for the purpose of rendering it safe.
(2) Where, on any occasion, persons have been caused to leave an affected area in pursuance of the foregoing subsection, no person shall thereafter be permitted to enter it so long as the person in charge of it is not satisfied that it is free from all danger:
Provided that nothing in this subsection shall be taken to prohibit a person from entering an affected area for the purpose of saving life, giving effect to paragraph (c) of the foregoing subsection, rendering that area or any other part of the quarry safe, or ascertaining either the effectiveness of any measures taken for the last-mentioned purpose or whether, apart from this proviso, persons may lawfully be permitted to enter the affected area.
(3) Where persons have, on any occasion, been caused to leave an affected area in pursuance of subsection (1) of this section, the person who caused them to leave it shall record in a book to be provided for that purpose by the owner of the quarry particulars of the reason for his causing them to leave that area and of the matters disclosed as a result of giving effect to paragraph (c) of that subsection and subscribe his signature thereto."
There is adequate and very good provision in the Bill for the withdrawal of workmen in the case of danger in mines. There is no provision in the Bill for the withdrawal of workmen from a quarry in the case of danger suddenly arising. I have sought in this amendment to provide that, in the case of quarries, the manager should have the duty to withdraw the workmen. If we look at what is happening in this country at the moment and at what is happening in our mines and quarries we must agree that there is probably greater danger to life and limb in the operation of quarries than mines in the country. Accordingly, I think this would be a useful provision to have in the Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Senator is equating section 75 in relation to mines. With regard to danger from noxious gases and inflammable gases, it is a danger which does not arise in the case of quarries. Generally, the dangerous working conditions in quarries can be covered by section 90 and by general regulations.
Comment on this
I probably have been attempting to go too far in this particular amendment. I see no reason to press it.
Comment on this
My point here is a very minor one. It seems to me that the provision in paragraph (e) in regard to the people who will have power to appear at an inquest differs from other provisions. There is no definition of a friend of the deceased person on whom the inquest is being held. There is a particularly loose provision by comparison with appearances in respect of the workers. In one instance the provision is very strict whereas elsewhere it is loose. Here you are restricted to a person appointed in writing by the majority of the persons employed at the mine or quarry, whereas any person may turn up claiming to be a friend.
Comment on this
This runs right through the Bill. The protection of the workers is always on the basis of a majority of the workers in the mine or quarry. Presumably at an inquest which sets out to determine the cause of death, any question concerning the workers in the mine or the owners of the mine would be in relation to conditions of working.
Comment on this
This refers to people who may be appointed as inspectors on behalf of workmen and who have certain rights in regard to the inspection of a mine. Under the 1911 Act there was no method of appointment and in Britain in the 1954 Act they limited the provision. How does the Minister anticipate the workmen's inspectors will be appointed under this section?
Comment on this
Conditions are laid down but it is left to the workers in the quarry or mine to appoint their inspectors. They are not directed as to how to do it. Conditions and qualifications are laid down but otherwise the workers are expected to appoint.
Comment on this
If the workers were organised in two separate unions would the position then be that one might appoint one inspector and another union another inspector? It appears to me there may be some difficulty.
Comment on this
They would appoint two. However, this has not been used for a long time. In practice it does not arise. In this particular work I do not think the allegiance of the electorate would have anything to do with it.
Comment on this
I imagine the reason this provision has not been invoked has been because it would be at their own cost.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In line 33, before "as" to insert "and maintained".
We should insist specifically on the responsibility to maintain the abandoned mine in a safe condition. That is the reason for my amendment. It appears to me that there is a possibility the duties under section 105 could be discharged by making the entrance safe once and for all but that there would be no liability to maintain it.
Comment on this
It might be desirable but it would be very hard to enforce it. You can, of course, propose that every abandoned or unused mine be sealed and fenced by the owner but if, after some years, you find that the seal has broken down it might not be possible to put the onus on an individual to maintain it. I would refer the Senator to another Act of the Oireachtas, the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Act, 1964, which empowers the sanitary authorities to undertake the onus to make dangerous places such as mines safe and, if possible, to recoup the cost from the owners.
Comment on this
I do not wish to press this point too hard but it seems to me better if we placed the onus under this Bill. If it became impossible to trace the owner, then the provision could not be enforced. If an owner is abandoning and closing down a mine he can do certain work. He can do it in two ways. He can do a job that might cost more money initially but which would need very little or no maintenance afterwards, or he could do the job at a lesser initial cost but which would need maintenance later. By leaving out the duty to maintain we are encouraging owners to do a skimpy job initially at less cost. It seems to me it would be far better if we put the onus on the owner to maintain.
Comment on this
I should like to support the amendment. It involves a matter of life and death. Some child may enter a mine and lose his life. Even if it is not intended to enforce it on every occasion, it would be better to add here the words suggested in the amendment.
Comment on this
I would refer the Seanad to the fact that owners are required to make an efficient sealing off which will be subject to inspection. If the owner can be found he can be required to contribute to the cost of maintenance under the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Act, 1964, and I do not think this amendment is, therefore, necessary. We have an Act under which maintenance can be ensured and we can here require that the first sealing off is efficient.
Comment on this
But it will not have the advantage of being in this Bill so the owners of mines and quarries would have their minds and attention directed to it here and now.
Comment on this
Nor shall we have the advantage of knowing that the person appointed to carry out the inspection on behalf of the Minister to see that the first sealing off is efficient will be a person qualified from the point of view of intimate knowledge of mines and quarries. The Minister should make things doubly safe. There may be a case of a child's life and it would be far preferable to have provision under two Acts than that the life of one child should be lost.
Comment on this
I can guarantee that the intention of the inspector of mines would be to ensure that the first sealing off would be efficient. I still feel it would not always be possible to implement this. There is another Act under which places can be made safe, and if the owner is able to contribute, or available to contribute, he can be made to contribute under that other Act.
Comment on this
If it is possible to enforce it under another Act, I do not see why it is not possible to enforce it under this Act.
Comment on this
It is a matter of inspection. We can guarantee to the Seanad that the first sealing off will be efficient, but to accept the amendment would mean continued inspection by inspectors of the Department of Industry and Commerce, whereas in the other case the onus would be on the local sanitary authority, which would be much more convenient.
Comment on this
The onus should remain where they are in a better position to know where there are abandoned mines. All abandoned mines will be known and listed in the Minister's office, in the office of the mining inspector. Having made the initial inspection, they would be in a position to look at the sealing off and say: "This is a good job but it should be inspected in 12 months time." They may say of another case: "This sealing off has been done properly, and it need not be inspected for three years." They would be in a better position than the sanitary inspector of a local authority to judge the condition of the sealing off of the mines. I do not like to differ from the Minister on this point, but I feel he is being unwise in not accepting the amendment.
Comment on this
This Bill is intended to protect the actual workers in mines and quarries, and still I feel that this matter, which is a very serious matter, has been quite reasonably dealt with under the other Act. I will undertake to the Seanad to see that the local sanitary authority are always advised where a mine is sealed off within their area by an inspector of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I still feel that disused quarries and mines should come within the sanitary services rather than under a Bill calculated to protect the workers.
Comment on this
The Bill refers to the protection and welfare of workers in mines and quarries rather than to the protection of people from accidents in abandoned mines, which is already covered in another Act. I will undertake to have the local sanitary authority advised of the existence of sealed off mines which may require inspection from time to time, but I still prefer them to be dealt with under the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Act, 1964.
Comment on this
Can we be sure the Minister's successors will do the same thing? Secondly, why should the section be in the Bill at all if it is not to be a good section? As it stands, it does not refer specifically to workers, and the effect of the section is much more likely to be on people wandering around in the district. There will not be any workers if the mine is disused.
Comment on this
Sealing off operations have been the business of the inspector of mines, but accidents which may arise in a disused mine after one, two or three years, can hardly be considered to be the business of the inspector of the conditions of employment in the mines. As I have said, this is already covered in another Act.
Comment on this
In other words, one can put it this way: here the responsibility of the Minister for Industry and Commerce ends, and someone else takes over that responsibility.
Comment on this
What I am offering the Seanad is that I shall arrange for the transfer of responsibility in each case to the local sanitary authority in the district where a mine is closed.
Comment on this
I do not think we should disagree at this stage. Surely the sealing off of the approach to or the exit from a mine should be a permanent operation. I am appealing to the Senator not to divide the House at this hour of the day.
Comment on this
I withdraw my amendment with grave reluctance. I am still of the opinion that this work could be most efficiently done within the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear that we will require a standard of efficiency in the sealing off, and that we will see to the transfer of responsibility.
Comment on this
Section 109 deals with restrictions on the employment of women and young persons. I understand that the hours of employment which are prescribed here arise from an ILO Convention to which this country was a party. I also understand the hours which are prescribed in accordance with that ILO Convention will make things extremely awkward for mine owners due to the fact that the hours of shift work here do not suit these particular hours. As I understand it, the ILO Convention was originally drafted and passed on the basis of shift hours of work in British mines. The position is that our hours of shift work are different from the hours in British mines. Accordingly we find ourselves creating a very awkward situation for our mine managers because of our adherence to the ILO Convention. I would ask the Minister that in future when any ILO Conventions of this type which involve hours of work, are being discussed, to see that extreme care is taken to ensure there are not any circumstances in a particular industry which would make it awkward to apply the Convention here.
Comment on this
What redress, if any, has a miner in the event of his being turned down by a mine owner on the basis that he is affected by coal dust? Coming, as I do, from a mining area, I find that a miner affected by coal dust is black-listed. He goes from one mine to another seeking employment, and fails to get it. I do not think there was any provision in the old Act for a medical inspection. It may be said that he is looked after by the mining company through workmen's compensation, but I know of a case recently where a man did not get workmen's compensation. He applied to the Department of Social Welfare for unemployment benefit but, according to the Department, he was fit and capable of working, although he had been ostracised and turned down by the various mines. Unfortunately, there is a black-list.
There are various degrees of coal dust. I understand some men may be more affected by it than others. I also understand a man may have that complaint for years and yet live a normal life. Some provision should be made in the Bill for people who may be affected by coal dust. It is a terrible hardship on a man, after working in a mine for 40 years from the age of 16, to find he cannot continue in that employment. I am quoting an actual case.
Comment on this
I do not mean compensation, but some redress. If he cannot get a job in another mine because he is affected by coal dust, has he any redress? Can he fight his case on the basis that his complaint is not malignant?
Comment on this
It is for his own protection that a miner who is suffering from the beginnings of a disease should not be permitted to work. I do not think what the Senator mentions arises in the Bill.
Comment on this
On that point, it might interest the Minister to know that in the explanatory memorandum given out originally, under section 111 provision is made for (a) compulsory medical examination of all persons seeking employment, and (b) compulsory medical examination of serving miners at regular intervals, with provision for suitable or alternative employment or compensation for those found to be suffering from respiratory disease. There is nothing in the section dealing with that point.
Comment on this
On the Second Stage of the Bill I made certain remarks about the position here in regard to the treatment of those suffering from pneumoconiosis suggesting that it should be possible in this country to set up a scheme whereby we could avoid the very undesirable position which exists at the moment where workers continue working until an advanced stage of the disease and then take civil actions for damages against the owners of the mine. I think it should be possible to set up a scheme which would have the backing of the owners, the workers and the Department. I would ask the Minister to examine the remarks I made on the Second Stage.
Comment on this
I think we should go further in the direction of the scheme in Britain where a tribunal of the workers, employers and the Minister is set up. This tribunal could re-allocate a person a particular type of work rather than allow him to become completely incapacitated. Steps could be taken early on so that a man could remain in employment in his own locality and in his own industry.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
To add a new subsection as follows:
"( ) In the event of the publication by the Minister of a book containing such portions of the Act, orders and regulations made under the Act as apply to any particular class, the manager shall give a copy of such book (if he has not already done so) to each person of that particular class who is employed in the mine at the time of publication of the book or who is newly employed in the mine after that time."
I adverted earlier to the position we will have when this Bill becomes law. It is a good code in regard to mines and quarries in this country but it will, by the time the Minister has made regulations under the Act, be a complex code. I think there is a duty on the Minister to publish in a convenient form what the particular code will be. It is in anticipation of the Minister seeing the necessity to publish a book containing certain statutory provisions, orders and regulations under the Act that I move this particular amendment. It ensures that in the event of the Minister providing these publications it would then be the duty of the managers to make them available to the people to whom they apply. Accordingly, this amendment not only imposes a duty on the manager to make the publications available but in a sense it also looks in the direction of the Minister strongly urging that such publications should be made.
Comment on this
As the Bill stands the manager is required to keep copies of the Acts, orders, regulations and rules affecting the mines and to permit employees to read these. It would be difficult to justify employees being given copies of all these.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister to exercise all the commonsense we all know he has. To make a copy of an Act convenient at all times to a man who is handling explosives underground is not meeting the particular case in this manner. I think the Minister should not leave completely behind him his zeal for education. What I would envisage being done is that there should be a series of publications so that the man whose job it is to light a fuse underground would be able to have a publication which would tell him the statutory duties appropriate to his particular conditions in the operation of the mine. It is no use handing a ganger a series of roneoed sheets, which are statutory orders so-and-so, or refer him to Iris Oifigiúil.
I think there is a job here not only of laying down a proper code for mines and quarries but also to undertake the task of making it available. This has been done in Britain for many years. Every person at every level in operation in Britain can secure details of his particular work. I should like to state the different volumes which are issued in Britain. There is a volume issued which applies to the duties of all underground workers. Volume two applies to the duties of surface workers. Volume three applies to the duties of winding engine men. Volume four applies to the duties of mechanics and electricians. Volume five refers to the duties of deputies and shotfirers. Of course, there are the larger volumes which will specify the duties of managers, deputy managers and the like. It would be as well if the Minister brought some of his zeal for education into the Department of Industry and Commerce. Here is an excellent opportunity to lay down a code to educate the members of a team in an industry as to what their duties are so that we can get away from the idea that you can go to the Post Office and look it up provided you go at a particular hour of the day.
Comment on this
If the Senator undertakes to withdraw the amendment I shall undertake to exercise the commonsense he prescribes for me in informing the workers. Of course, any such arrangement for giving these publications out would not relieve the manager of making known to the workers what their duties are.
Comment on this
Having the Minister's assurance on this and taking cognisance of the fact, we shall keep an eye out to see how he operates and I withdraw the amendment. I see here a great opportunity for the managers to do a particular job which needs doing in every industry in this country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
Before subsection (2) to insert a new subsection as follows:
"( ) Inspectors appointed for the purposes of this Act to inspect mines and quarries shall have had practical experience as miners or quarriers as the case may be."
I suggest that this should be in the Bill. No doubt the Minister will make regulations but I think the man appointed should have practical experience. It will put an onus on the inspector that such and such may have to be done. It might be an emergency. Very probably the manager of a mine might use bad language and he will have to bow to the will of the inspector who may never have had any practical experience. I feel an inspector should at least have practical experience of mines. I have no idea what type of man the Minister would appoint but it should be set out in the statute that he shall have practical experience. We have set it out in section 104 that the employees must have practical experience. I am sure anybody working in a mine, where perhaps an emergency regulation was about to be made by an inspector, would prefer to work under one who had practical experience of mines or quarries.
Comment on this
It has been the practice to require inspectors to have this type of experience. I consider this amendment would perhaps restrict the Minister somewhat if it were taken as a matter of course that suitable practical experience would be required of a person who was to be an inspector. I might say it has not been the practice to make the differentiation in the case of mines or quarries.
Comment on this
It is all right if the Minister thinks it is not necessary.
Comment on this
What the Senator is seeking is already practice and will continue to be so as far as practicable.
Comment on this
This section deals with the provision of inspectors and I take it that an inspector will have the functions of promoting the prevention of accidents and also the promotion of productivity in mines. I should like to ask the Minister how many inspectors does he envisage will be appointed and what does he accept will be the average number of inspections per year of a working mine?
Comment on this
In the first place, I do not think the inspector, under this Act, would have any function in relation to productivity except in so far as safety and the welfare of the workers are concerned. He would have no direct responsibility for productivity. The position under this Act is that we wish to ensure the safety and welfare of the workers. With regard to the number of inspections, I shall have to inquire.
Comment on this
I understand the position at present is that there are two inspections and the second has only just been authorised. Does the Minister anticipate that further inspections will take place?
Comment on this
The position here is not the same as regards mines and quarries in other countries. Inspections are not on the same scale.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In subsection (1) (d) (i), page 54, to delete all words from and including "so" in line 37 to the end of the subparagraph and substitute "provided that no one shall be required by virtue of this section to answer any question or to give any evidence tending to criminate himself."
The Bill reads:
so, however, that no answer given by a person in pursuance of a requirement imposed under this subparagraph shall be admissible in evidence against him in any proceedings.
The wording of the amendment is, I think, more usual and has been used in other Bills. It is, if anything, slightly broader than the words used in the Bill. This has been used in the Factories Act. The words as they stand in the Bill might possibly be used in an unfair manner against a person being questioned. I can think of a conspiracy charge against two people working in a mine. The evidence of each of them could be used against the other under this subsection. If those people were charged with conspiracy and both were compelled to answer questions, each of them could give evidence against the other. The evidence might be unfair against one of them. I put this amendment down because I do not see why there should be a change in wording from that in previous Bills. I do not know why the draftsman could not keep to the same wording as has been used in previous Bills. It would be much more suitable to do so.
Comment on this
The intention was to put in a phrase additional to that in the Factories Act by saying no answer given would be admissible as evidence. The Factories Act says that a person need not answer a question which may incriminate him. This leaves an anxiety or responsibility on the person being questioned to determine what might incriminate him and might have the effect of completely wrecking the person's answer because of the fear of incrimination. As this section is drafted, no answer given by the person questioned can be used in evidence against him. It would have the effect of protecting him completely and relieving him of the responsibility of determining whether such evidence could incriminate him. This seems to me to be better than the Factories Act, even though it is a change.
Comment on this
I see that. Could it be used in the case of a conspiracy charge?
Comment on this
I imagine if a conspiracy charge arose under the Factories Act, they would have to sign a declaration but a person would avoid answering a question which might incriminate him. Under this Bill he need not answer it at all. His answer is negative or positive. This is more like a coroner's inquest. This type of investigation is to find out something rather than incriminate a person.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
Before subsection (2) to insert a new subsection as follows:
"( ) If the responsible person objects to the remedy required by the inspector under this section he may within seven days appeal to the Minister in writing stating his objections to the said remedy and the Minister's decision thereon shall be final."
This amendment is put down simply to give a person the right to make an appeal to the Minister. I think that otherwise matters could be held up for a considerable time in a mine if an inspector and a manager-owner disagreed over some important point. The inspector could indicate a requirement of any kind whatsoever under the section as it stands. It might take a long time for any change to be made in that requirement if there is no right of immediate appeal to the Minister. It might hold up the whole working of the mine. I would ask the Minister to consider whether some immediate method of dealing with perhaps a disputed requirement by an inspector under that section could be provided.
Comment on this
The Senator appreciates what my objection would have been. The appeal machinery already contained in this Bill would be cumbersome and slow. This section is aimed at a position of imminent danger or disaster which has to be dealt with at once. An appeal with any slow-moving machinery, at a time like that, would be very undesirable. But, having once taken action, the owner could then appeal to the Minister. This is erring on the safe side. The Senator can see why it would be more desirable to close down a working, while awaiting the outcome of an appeal, than to allow people to work in imminent danger of catastrophe.
Comment on this
I agree, but I am seeking appeal to the Minister within seven days and an inspection.
Comment on this
They can appeal, but it is essential for safety to allow the inspector to take whatever action is necessary. Then the owner can appeal to the Minister for a reversal of the inspector's order if he thinks that necessary.
Comment on this
The ordinary administrative appeal to the Minister, which is provided for in the Bill, will be open.
Comment on this
That exists, in practice, not necessarily in the Bill, that a person can appeal to the Minister.
Comment on this
I gather it is an established custom that people can appeal to the Minister and that it is not necessary to legislate for it.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that the person who felt the decision of an inspector was wrong would immediately write to the Minister but if he had no actual legal support for it, he might find the matter could be delayed by an inspector for a very long time.
Comment on this
I imagine that the only circumstances of appeal would be when a man would consider the decision of the inspector unreasonable.
Comment on this
The inspector might want one remedy and the manager might suggest another. It might be very important that the mine should not stop for a long time or that the dispute——
Comment on this
The Senator appreciates that it concerns a matter of imminent danger? It would be in the event of some condition of imminent danger or catastrophe or accident that the inspector would do this. If he acted unreasonably, you could not delay his action: you would have to let him act in your view unreasonably and then you could appeal to the Minister on that basis and assume that a Minister of State would act.
Comment on this
So long as it is agreed that he has that right of appeal to the Minister.
Comment on this
You might have danger and a manager might say: "I will take such and such precautions," while the inspector might say: "You must not take those steps but these other precautions which I am suggesting," precautions with which the manager might not agree at all. Somebody must then make a decision as to which precaution is the one to take in the immediate time because, as the Minister now says, perhaps there is imminent danger in the mine. The whole working must stop or either of two precautions must be taken—and the inspector indicates one and the manager indicates the other. I think an immediate appeal is necessary.
Comment on this
You want more. In a clash of opinions, you want a referee. In cases of imminent danger, I think you have to take the chance of the work slowing down and stopping to prevent a catastrophe.
Comment on this
I agree, but we do not want the works closed for two months.
Comment on this
I do not think that would happen, in practice. How does the Minister make up his mind? Does he send down another inspector?
Comment on this
This would be done. I do not think any Minister would want mines or quarries closed down.
Comment on this
At this stage I should like to thank the Minister, on this his first appearance in the House having charge of this Department, for having dealt with this complex Bill with such good humour. I should like also to thank him for meeting the amendments which were proposed.
Comment on this
Gach rath go raibh ar Sheanadóirí.
The Seanad adjourned at 5.45 p.m. sine die.