Housing Bill, 1965—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–112 of 232. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1965 ›
I move amendment No. 23:
Before section 56 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) A housing authority may, by resolution, decide to provide such and so many houses (or building sites) as may be specified in the resolution, in any area or within a specified time and the manager of a housing authority shall give effect to any resolution passed under this section."
This is a simple amendment and its purpose is to aim at speeding up housing by advanced site planning and keeping various schemes in line with changing requirements such as the movement of population and other things that may require much more advanced planning than we have.
Comment on this
I am afraid we cannot accept the amendment. We had similar amendments on Committee and Report Stages in the Dáil and we are satisfied that the elected representatives are the people to decide on housing policy, and that extends as far as the acquisition of sites and the planning of local authority programmes over a period of years are concerned and the manager implements council policy. I take it what the Senator is saying in this amendment is that the elected representatives are the people who should go out and acquire sites and decide on policy.
Comment on this
What, in effect, we mean is that power should be given to housing authorities to acquire sites in advance of what at the moment would appear to be their housing requirements. Very often we come across the problem in local authorities where the members feel there is a necessity for a number of sites for the erection of a number of houses. The officials will not see eye to eye. There are certain specific conditions laid down and the medical officer of health must be able to ensure that there are a number of people in that area who require houses. If, for example, there are 20 badly housed people in an area who would appear to the medical officer of health or to the local authority to be badly housed, that is the number of houses that can be built in that year—that number and no more. No provision is made for anything that might happen in the next five to ten years. No provision is made for the advanced acquisition of sites for people who may require houses if that number of houses have been completed.
Comment on this
Surely we have already discussed in the Bill the question of the assessment of the housing needs for areas. Local authorities will have power to acquire land for future housing and building programmes. The difficulty here is, I think, that, as a result of a resolution passed by the council they will erect a number of houses in an area or some member of the council does it or the manager does it on their behalf. Is that not so? Up to now the council might decide to build ten houses. The officials would investigate the applicants and needs of the people in the area. They may decide to the satisfaction of the council that six houses are sufficient to cater for the needs at that particular time, and the council might decide to go ahead with the six.
Comment on this
It often happens. You have instanced the case where the local authority are in agreement with the manager that there are sufficient houses. I want to state the case that where the elected representatives are not satisfied that a sufficient number of houses are being erected and I do know of a specific case where in 1959, after four years of up and down to the Department of Local Government, it was decided—in spite of the wishes of the elected representatives of that area —to build 20 houses on a site where we felt 28 to 30 houses should be built. But in the long run—as one member of the local authority mentioned, half a loaf is better than no bread—we agreed to the 20 houses. The 20 houses were erected and tenants were appointed to these houses early in 1960. In 1964 it was agreed to build the other eight houses, and the eight houses built in 1964 cost as much as 12 of the first 20. I want to emphasise this—which I think is a very important point—that those 20 houses were erected in this particular village as a result of the number of applications received for them in that village. Over 60 people applied for these houses and it was as a result of the number of applicants that it was decided to acquire land and go ahead with the second scheme but we were precluded from erecting any more than 20 houses in that scheme until four years had elapsed. It is to prevent that kind of thing happening that I would respectfully request the Parliamentary Secretary to accept this amendment of ours.
Comment on this
It would appear from what Senator Fitzgerald has said that the manager is separate from the council. In the first instance, the council adopt a programme, passes a resolution and give certain instructions to the county manager. If he falls down on his job, they have the remedy in their own hands.
Comment on this
Some day if the Parliamentary Secretary ever has a moment he might look at the Dunboyne file on the 1956 scheme. He will find that what I am saying is correct —that the 20 houses were all the Department would sanction on that particular site and yet four or five years afterwards they sanctioned the building of a further eight and those eight cost as much as 12 of the original 20. If the 28 altogether had been built and if the people had been housed altogether it would have been a much more economic scheme and eight people would have been housed much earlier than they were.
Comment on this
This was fairly fully discussed in the Dáil and we still have not changed our minds about it. We still think the elected representatives have all the power in their own hands. They can direct the managers to lay emphasis on a particular area, to ensure the housing needs are met, in their policy in relation to the acquisition of sites and have all these things taken into consideration. If the county manager falls down on his job then they have the remedy in their own hands.
Comment on this
I do not think the county manager failed in his job in this particular instance but if the Parliamentary Secretary can say to me he is prepared to influence the officials in the Custom House that the elected representatives and the officials in a local authority or housing area are the best judges of their business, I shall be quite satisfied that this amendment has served a useful purpose. It is the officials of the Department of Local Government I am getting at, not the county managers.
Comment on this
We are dealing with this as it affects the local authorities so it is the local authority officials with whom we are dealing as against the Department's officials. There is no sense in dragging in the people of the Custom House. In the first instance the Senator referred to the engineers and the chief medical officer but we think that in their own examination of the applicants they chose a site so the Department of Local Government had nothing to do with it except that now they have set down certain headings under which the programme can be properly drawn up.
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Parliamentary Secretary that the housing authority, with the manager, are the final arbiter in determining the number of houses to be built on a particular occasion?
Comment on this
But the Parliamentary Secretary, by his intervention, conveys to me that it is for determination completely by the local authority with the manager. Apart from the availability of finance we had difficulties—before the present financial crisis —regarding the curtailment by the Department of the number of houses necessary. I shall cite the Blarney incident in particular. Deputy Corry is the expert in this regard and his comments would be worth hearing regarding the whittling down by the Department, not by the housing committee or by the manager. It would be unfair to the local authorities now for anybody to allege that they were the final arbiters. It was a matter for decision between the housing authority and the manager. We have had so many sad experiences in all good faith of having arrived at what we thought was a genuine assessment of the housing needs but when it came to the Custom House we found that only a fraction were declared as being desirable.
Comment on this
Section 55—that is the section with which we dealt last week—gives the local authority power to draw up their programme and they can decide, as we hope they will, on the future programming of their housing needs in their own area. If there is an area likely to be developed as a result of a number of industries then it is up to the local authority— if they are aware of such industries— to programme for it. As far as the Department of Local Government are concerned they would come into it only on the question of availability of capital to carry out the programme.
Comment on this
I think subsections (1) and (2) of this amendment cover it very well because subsection (1) ensure that:
A housing authority may, by resolution decide to provide such and so many houses (or building sites) as may be specified in the Resolution, in any area or within a specified time and the manager of a housing authority shall give effect to any resolution passed under this section.
and subsection (2) ensures that:
If it appears to the manager of a housing authority that the number of houses (or building sites) proposed to be provided pursuant to a resolution passed under this section, in any area, is insufficient, he shall make due provision for such additional houses and shall inform the members of the housing authority accordingly.
This is combining the two—the manager and the local authority—and if they, in their wisdom, feel that provision should be made for so many houses or so many sites that that should be implemented. I have instanced the case of the housing scheme in Dunboyne to illustrate that where the manager and the housing authority, the elected representatives, were at one, they were still frustrated by the officials in the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
The Senator is going outside the scope of the amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment has to do with the manager of a housing authority and the local authority. Is the amendment withdrawn?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In subsection (2), line 46, to delete "may" and substitute "shall".
My object in putting down this amendment is to change the section so as to make it mandatory upon the local authority to do certain things, with an escape clause, if they so resolve, instead of making it merely permissive. At present subsection (2) of section 56 reads:
A housing authority may, in connection with dwellings provided, to be provided or which in the opinion of the authority will in the future require to be provided under this Act, provide and, if they think fit, maintain in good order and repair roads, shops, playgrounds, places of recreation, parks, allotments...
I think this is too weak. It is saying that a housing authority may provide these things and, if they think fit, they may even maintain them in good repair, and so on. It seems to be a rather flabby way of ensuring that these things will be provided where they are necessary. With your permission, Sir, I am taking my three amendments, Nos. 24, 25 and 26, together. I am simply transposing the word "may" into "shall" and omitting "if they think fit". Obviously, there might be cases where a particular item would not be necessary, and in amendment No. 26 I am inserting the clause "unless by specific resolution one or more of these amenities be deemed by the authority to be unnecessary".
In other words, I am asking that the Act shall say that it shall be clearly considered the thing to do, to provide not merely houses but also recreation grounds, parks, playgrounds and so on, that this shall be the rule rather than the exception, and that we shall not be content to say that the local authority may do these things if they think fit. I suggest that we should say the local authority shall do these things unless by specific resolution they deem one or more of these amenities to be unnecessary.
The past record of local authorities was not always good in this regard. I remember that for many years the playground in the Kimmage housing scheme appeared only on the maps of the city architect and not in Kimmage. About 15 years after the scheme was completed these recreational facilities were finally provided. This contains a kind of implication, an implied pattern of life in the community that is being provided with such a housing scheme. Unless, as well as houses, it be deemed normal and natural to provide for such things as shops, playgrounds, swimming pools, parks, and so on, and unless this is considered normal and virtually mandatory upon the local authority, they tend to put these things on the long finger.
I suggest to the Seanad that they should look at Dublin and consider it in comparison with other towns of this size. In relation to swimming pool recreational facilities, Dublin is an absolute disgrace in Western Europe. Therefore I feel we must word this section more strongly, and not be content to say that the local authorities may do these things if they think fit. We should specifically demand that the local authorities shall do these things unless by specific resolution they deem one or other of these amenities to be unnecessary in a particular instance.
Comment on this
I have a good deal of sympathy with the idea behind these amendments, but I doubt if, as they are drafted, they do more than provide a peg on which to hang an argument.
Comment on this
A good argument and, therefore, a good peg.
Comment on this
It may be a good argument but it is shockingly bad drafting if I may say so, because if these amendments were accepted you would have the odd situation that it would be mandatory on the local authority to provide and maintain shops in good order and repair, unless by a resolution they decided that shops were not an amenity which was necessary in the district. That would be going rather far. It could hardly be said that shops were not a necessary amenity, or that sites for churches were not necessary. I do not think anyone could envisage that a local authority should have to provide shops, playgrounds, sites for places of worship, factories, offices, and so on, and not only provide them but keep them in good order and repair.
I can see what the Senator is getting at, and I have a great deal of sympathy with it. Some method should be found to speed up the provision of proper facilities in new housing areas, but I suggest this is not the way to do it, because the local authorities would be faced with one of two absurdities. They would either have to provide these things, or pass a resolution saying that a site for a place of worship was not a suitable amenity in a district, which might be going rather far, or that shops or factories and offices were not necessary. I can see what the Senator wants to do and I think the provision of these facilities should be speeded up, but I suggest not by way of these amendments.
Comment on this
I should like to support the amendments with the same reservations Senator Sheldon has expressed. If there is a real need for shops they will almost certainly emerge, and roads will be provided and kept in some sort of repair, but playgrounds, places of recreation, parks and so on, are in a different category. They are more likely to be neglected unless something is specifically laid down. Perhaps some reference might be made in the amendments to their being provided within some period of time after the housing estate has reached a certain stage of completion. Under the amendments the housing authority might be put in a position of having to put up playgrounds, and so on, even before the estate had reached the stage where they were necessary. I wonder if the Parliamentary Secretary would have another look at the section. As Senator Sheldon says, the amendments might make the whole position rather difficult. I am certain that Senator Sheehy Skeffington is right in urging that it should not be left entirely to the discretion of the local authorities to provide such things as recreation grounds, playgrounds, etc.
Comment on this
Like Senator Sheldon, we have sympathy with the view behind the amendment. Unfortunately, no distinction is made between an urban and a rural area, and if we accepted the amendment as it is, every local authority in the country would have to pass a resolution that all these amenities were not necessary even when they were building one single county council cottage. Again, if the amendment were accepted the county councils would be obliged to provide all these amenities and to maintain them unless they passed a resolution. In view of that we feel we could not place this obligation on local authorities. This is something you cannot legislate for. Local authorities have a certain amount of discretion as it is. If you put this on them as a statutory obligation they either do the work or they have to decide, by resolution, not to provide those amenities. As Senator Sheldon says this could be misrepresented in many ways in relation to other facilities. Therefore, we cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I accept the Parliamentary Secretary's objection. In relation to rural areas it is true that if you build just one or two houses it might not be necessary to put up shops or anything else. Nevertheless, future rural housing development might well lie in community centres. This has been done very successfully in Holland. Most rural housing areas there are grouped around recreation halls and playgrounds. The effect of this is that social amenities are available in rural communities. I feel perhaps that something which would help local authorities to recognise that the building and provision of houses is something more than just putting up houses is very desirable. The whole social structure of community living should be taken into account by local authorities.
Senator Sheldon's objection is sound at least in one respect. This to some extent would be met by dropping my amendment No. 25 which asks that the words "if they think fit" be omitted. Some form of motion should be put in which would make it necessary to provide at least certain social amenities. A shopping centre is surely a necessary social amenity in nine cases out of ten. I do not feel that people in outlying housing areas are well served by shops. It might well be a good idea if the local authorities were to own or at least be landlords of shops, and keep them in proper condition. In any event I would rather see the onus put on the local authorities to decide that particular amenities were not necessary. I do not want to delay the Seanad further and with leave I should like to withdraw my amendments, leaving myself open, perhaps, on Report Stage, to introduce a changed or improved version of them.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) Sites provided or to be provided under this section and section 57 (in areas where sewers are not available) shall be large enough to accommodate a septic tank, having regard to local soil conditions."
This is to ensure that sites of sufficient area will be provided because I have a feeling in some instances that the quarter acre suggested by the Minister in the circular might not be enough to enable a person building a house to comply with the regulations with regard to the distance of a septic tank from an existing house or road or that kind of thing. It is with a view to getting an assurance with regard to that that we put down this amendment.
Comment on this
In dealing with the amendment as it is the sites should be large enough to accommodate a septic tank having regard to local soil conditions. In this connection you might have to give them a two-acre site.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is stretching his imagination.
Comment on this
It is quite possible that the lay-out of a site might be such that it is not possible without such a large site. Those of us who are members of local authorities have come across this kind of case. The required distance was laid down by the chief medical officer of health. If you were to allow this amendment you would have to take into consideration other things besides septic tanks. The question of a septic tank is something that will have to be sorted out. As it is at the moment there are a number of cottages throughout the country that cannot provide septic tanks on their own sites and be the required distance from the main road or their own house. There is a question of change necessary. It is necessary that there should be the 60 feet distance from the house or public roadway. In some local authority areas the medical officer will allow a lesser distance. We are not prepared to accept this amendment. In relation to septic tanks this can be done administratively rather than by statute. There is no guarantee that what would prevail on one site would prevail on another. The same conditions cannot prevail throughout the whole country. With regard to future sites we would hope there would be no question of septic tanks having to be provided subsequently as it would be Government policy and indeed local authority policy in any future housing scheme that they would be fully serviced so the question of a new septic tank would not arise.
Comment on this
I am opposed to this section because it seems to me that it is no part of the function of local authorities to provide sites for private builders or building speculators. The local authority and the corporation do all the hard work, lay drains, put in roads and lay on all the other services. After having done all this hard and unprofitable work they are then prepared to hand over to private enterprise so that the cream can go into private hands. I do not think it is part of the function of local authorities to do the preliminary drudgery work for private enterprise. If private enterprise wants to go in for building work it is better that they should develop the sites themselves. This work should not be done at public expense and then handed over so that private enterprise can make a profit.
Senator FitzGerald in his speech on the Second Reading made a valuable point and gave figures to prove that in Northern Ireland there is far greater emphasis on building by public authorities than by private enterprise. This section is going in the wrong direction. It is trying, at public expense, to take a good deal of the hard work out of building by private enterprise leaving the profit in private hands. There is still a field for private enterprise to engage in building but I feel that when local authorities have developed sites they should do the building. They should not have the right to hand over the job to private enterprise after they have done the hard work themselves and thus allow somebody else to take the profits from it.
Comment on this
I disagree with Senator Sheehy Skeffington's amendment because some two years ago one county council in this country provided serviced sites in order to encourage individuals to build houses for themselves. They provided serviced sites at £100 each, and it can be truthfully said that the scheme was very successful and people who would otherwise have waited for the county council to build houses were able to engage a contractor of their own and build quite nice houses for themselves. This is what it should be. Many people find difficulty in acquiring suitable housing sites. They have not got the same powers of acquiring land as the county council. From my own experience we have had eight or ten houses built in Portlaoise which possibly would not have been built by private individuals were it not for this scheme. I should like to see the Minister going a step further and perhaps encouraging the councils to develop this line of thought by giving them some kind of grant as an incentive to encourage people to build their own houses. In addition, from the county council point of view roads, sewerage and water facilities will be provided to the council's satisfaction. It has been the experience in the past, when a council took over some of these schemes, that many of the roads were not completed with as much care as would be taken by the council's own staff. What is provided for in section 57 is nearly ideal, and I would like to see much more of it throughout the country.
Comment on this
I should like to endorse Senator McDonald's remarks. Sometimes we reach the stage where some of these applicants that come before local authorities, having obtained the approval of the members of the authority and of the manager, find that due to the rigid adherence to strict examination in the Department they have not been approved for the provision of local authority housing, and that class of person find in recent years, particularly if they are close to industrial development, that the initial costs of the provision of a serviced site are a very great obstacle in embarking on what we should at all costs encourage—the ownership of houses by this category of people. This section gives an opportunity to the housing authority to organise in an orderly fashion a site with the amenities necessary so that such people will get a reasonable opportunity of acquiring a site with the least expense involved not alone to the person concerned but to the various housing sections dealing with grants of various kinds.
I support the retention of the scheme for that reason. We could depend on the good sense of the local authorities that they would in exercising their responsibilities obviate the development of what Senator Sheehy Skeffington fears, namely the abuse of this section by developers to the extent that it would be inimical to others and to the public finances. The provision should be retained so that local authorities may in the exercise of commonsense avail of it for the purposes outlined.
Relative to the provision of roadways we have frequently come up against difficulties where schemes have been developed and tenants of the houses concerned who are at the stage where they are faced with heavy financial responsibility in furnishing their homes and meeting the commitments involved in getting a house are faced with the roadways problem. It would be very helpful if the councils were prepared to take over those roadways once they were brought into proper condition. In many instances they have not recourse to the rural improvements scheme grants. Could the Minister make an approach to the Minister for Finance to permit the payment of rural improvements scheme grants in those areas where they are not yet applicable for bringing those roadways into the condition where they will meet the requirements of the council engineers for take over and maintenance for the local authorities? We all know instances where people are making an effort to make their homes presentable and face appalling difficulties relative to the service of these roadways because the developers have failed. It takes the utmost pressure on the part of the local authorities, where they can exercise this influence, to get them to bring the roads into some reasonable condition. It is a very heavy charge on the residents in those areas if they have to embark on the considerable expense involved in bringing the roadway to the condition where it could be taken over by the local authority.
I would ask the Minister again to look into this consultation with the Minister for Finance to see whether the scheme of rural improvement grants could not be extended to cover these categories. There are not very many of these cases, but they entail a considerable hardship on those people, who are ratepayers and taxpayers.
Comment on this
Would it be permissible under this section for the local authority themselves to provide sites as a part of or even the whole of the local authority contribution towards the grant? I would think that would be the way it could work in certain cases, that the local authority might provide housing sites.
Comment on this
(Longford): We cannot lose sight of the fact that the housing authority are the county council, which are also the road authority and the sanitary authority. No matter who builds the houses the responsibility for providing roads is on the road authority, which are the county council, and the responsibility for sewerage facilities and water services is on the sanitary authority. Where contractors are building houses for private people on sites provided by the local authority sometimes the contractors competent to build houses are not competent to build roads, and an attempt by people not equipped to build roads properly can be very poor.
This creates a headache for the road authority afterwards, and also for the people who are compelled to live along these roads. It is a good thing that the county councils should create a situation whereby sites can be developed and roads made so that private people can, with the aid of grants and other facilities, provide their own houses. I belive that the house, a home, is a thing that is private and personal, and the intention and purpose of all legislation should be to create a climate or a situation whereby as many people as it is practicably possible will erect their own houses. They have a sense of achievement, of responsibility, of pride and of self-help. If we had more and more people getting out of the idea of relying on the local authorities to house them, we would have more and more people with a sense of responsibility. On the other hand, I do not think it would be good to go further than is absolutely necessary in this matter, pointing out again, of course, that there is no help like self-help.
Comment on this
The retention of this section is most important if housing is to get its full impetus. The section means that people will be able to get sites and have those sites developed cheaper because a housing authority can acquire four or five acres and the development of such an area will be much cheaper——
Comment on this
To whom? To the building contractor or to the tenants?
Comment on this
Cheaper to the person who has to pay the contractor. Three out of four people who build their own houses do so with the aid of borrowed money. The purpose of the Bill is that everybody will be housed, no matter how poor, and giving an impetus to people to build their own houses means that the local authority will have more money left, larger funds on which they can call in order to house the poorest, the people who have most claim on the State for housing. It also means there will be more orderly development. If a council acquire an area and there is development for 30 sites, the council would charge each person one thirtieth of the entire cost. The section will also provide that the houses must be built to a certain standard, that they must fit in with the general surroundings and that they must be in accord with the plans for adjoining houses. There will be no loss to the State. Take the ordinary person in a town. Say two people wish to build houses. They cannot acquire sites or they cannot acquire sites to which there is a road. On the other hand, if there is a site for 20 houses, it will be found that 15 or 20 people will wish to build houses there. If the building of houses is to get maximum impetus, if it is to be done in an orderly manner and if the maximum amount of money is to be left to house the most needy, then this section is essential.
Comment on this
Senator Nash in a general way has covered the real purpose of this section and the associated sections, 44 and 88. I have no doubt these sections will to a large degree do what those in favour of them have suggested. They will encourage local authorities to acquire larger tracts of land than may be required for their own housing needs. In so doing, they will purchase it at cheaper rates per site than the rates at which individuals could purchase the land in single sites. For the development of a group of houses, the cost will be much less than if each individual site were developed at different times by different individuals. As well, the additions thus provided to a town or an area will be better planned than could be ever hoped for if building occurred haphazardly, bit by bit.
The demand for some provision of this nature has been fairly evident on the part of local authorities and in recent years I have been advocating that they should acquire land for eventual use by private individuals. Any reluctance they showed was caused by the feeling that they would be expected to carry too much cost if they were to make a useful contribution in this direction. At any rate, the sections concerned have been sought by the local authorities and are very much welcomed by them. I submit they will do a great deal of good in the manner I have mentioned, together with the undoubted advantage and attraction these provisions will have for people to build who might not otherwise be able to attempt building because of the extraordinarily high cost of single sites, plus the extraordinarily high additional cost of developing such individual sites.
This should mean that in many towns people who might not otherwise attempt to build houses—they were scared off by the exorbitantly high cost of acquiring and developing individual sites — will now be inclined to build their own houses. This is a power being given that will be of great value to all concerned. Furthermore, under section 88 which provides the power to dispose of these building sites, conditions will be laid down by way of regulation and direction as to how the sites are to be disposed of, including the terms of disposal. I envisage that these regulations will take in not only the manner in which such sites will be disposed of but the terms and the cost. They will, therefore, carry no bonuses to anybody who might hope to make money from building on those sites.
The regulations will enable local authorities to sell the sites at much less than their original value to people whom they wish to encourage to build. This will ensure that those who do not need this assistance will not get it at the cost of the taxpayer and the ratepayer. The incentive is to people who need sites fully developed by the council at bargain prices and with a subsidy from the Central Fund. In this fashion we will help those who most need our help and withhold it from those who do not require it or, indeed, who might even abuse such encouragement by making money for their personal benefit at the expense of the taxpayer and ratepayer. The three sections I have mentioned will give this power we did not have in the past.
Comment on this
It seems to me from what the Minister has said and indeed from the point of view expressed by the Senators who have spoken, that there is a general assumption that the section refers to the provision of sites to private people who will then buy them. The section does not say that. It states:
A housing authority may provide sites for building purposes on land acquired or appropriated by them...
The Minister encourages me by saying that regulations will provide and see to it that there is no abuse. But, as the section stands, it will permit a local authority under the terms of this section to provide a whole acreage of sites to a local gombeen man with local influence and allow him to acquire land that had been compulsorily acquired from his neighbours and which had been appropriated by them at a cut price, perhaps even at a price below that which the local authority paid for it, and then develop it and rent the houses to a large number of people and, perhaps, slap on ground-rents as well. Possibly this is not envisaged, and may not be possible under the regulations the Minister mentions. But the section as it stands permits the provision of sites not merely for the worthy private owner—the case for him is obvious and has been well made —but also for the speculative builder. "A housing authority may provide sites for building purposes on land acquired or appropriated by them", and so on.
I am entirely sympathetic with what Senator McDonald says about the private individual but I feel that very often a private individual will get a fairer "do", as it were, from the local authority as a landlord, and such letting could well be extended, than from the private landlord living on his rent.
Senator McDonald also mentioned that if the council are to do the initial site work it will be done better and more satisfactory. I think he will agree, however, that, as Senator O'Reilly pointed out, this has to be done to the council's satisfaction anyway, so that the mere decision either to do this, or not to do it, is not really relevant at all. It is not relevant to the satisfactory manner in which the site is originally developed. There is nothing, as I see it, in this section to prevent a speculative builder acquiring these sites and putting a ground rent on them or even selling the houses and then slapping on a ground rent of £15 or £20 a year. This may be prevented by regulations, but it is not prevented by the section to which I am opposed. I feel also that these ground rents would give an inflated land value out of all proportion to the service done by the private builder particularly when this land has been compulsorily acquired by the local authority in the first place. The value is largely added to the land by the local authority, and under this section, unless there are strong safeguards provided in the regulations, the profit arising from this added value will go into private pockets. This seems to me to be bad.
Senator O'Reilly has stressed the value of the private ownership of houses. I think perhaps he went too far when he said that the tenant, the non-owner, has not the same sense of responsibility towards the property as the owner of the house. I feel in making a generalisation like that Senator O'Reilly has not been fair.
Comment on this
The Senator may not intentionally be unfair to tenants of local authority houses and corporation and county council tenants, where admittedly you will get some people who are abusing the houses, but the big majority of these houses are admirably kept. I do not feel that merely to be a tenant of a local authority house instead of owning a house would necessarily mean that the houses would not be kept at such a high standard.
I do not follow what Senator Nash said about being more orderly if the local authority step aside and allow private——
Comment on this
I agree but this section says the local authority do not do it. They can hand over. They just ensure drainage, sewerage and roads and then stand aside.
Comment on this
If it is intended to do all the layout and design of the houses, gardens and parks this will then provide a more orderly development than if the authority stops half way and hands it over to the private individual, as the section allows.
Finally, the Minister says it will cost less perhaps to the local authority if they can, as it were, pass on the sites, once they have done the initial work, to somebody else. It will cost less perhaps to the local authority, but it may well cost more to the person living in the house. He may have to pay not only an economic rent to the local authority or something like it, but he may also have to pay an excessive profit plus a ground rent, so it may cost less to the local authority, but more to the people for whom in theory, at any rate, such houses are being built.
I would contend, therefore, that where the site is actually acquired or appropriated, in the words of the section, by a local authority it should be fully developed by the local authority to the point of providing the house on it, and in that case ultimately, from the point of view of the individual, the cost will be less, and the planning and harmony greater. If there are regulations which will modify the bad effects of the section as it still stands, I shall welcome them. I should just like to ask the Minister before I consider whether I shall withdraw my opposition to this or not, by whom does he envisage these regulations will be made—by the Minister under this Act or by the different local authorities? He has mentioned very wise regulations which might be made. I should just like to know by whom?
Comment on this
By the Minister governing the payment of the subsidy and relating to the payment of the subsidy in respect of these sites. That is, the subsidy under section 24 would be regulated by the Minister on the general terms I have already indicated here.
Comment on this
This is a satisfactory answer, provided the regulations made under this power are of the kind the Minister has in mind. I feel that we as a legislative Chamber are being asked to pass a section which we are told will be all right because under another section the Minister has power to make regulations that will prevent it being abused.
Comment on this
The Senator would seem to have a very poor view of county councils.
Comment on this
I feel, perhaps, we could put down an amendment on Report Stage that would satisfy the Minister. There are some 20 regulations the builder must undertake to fulfil. Generally the houses are sold on a lease of 99 years and the authority must be satisfied with the type of house and everything else.
On the question of playgrounds, have the local authorities power to use such land acquired for houses for playgrounds, especially playgrounds adjacent to the larger schools in built-up areas? I have such a case in mind and I feel it is most desirable that when schools provide 600 pupils they should have adequate facilities for recreational purposes. I would ask the Minister if it is in order for a housing authority to allocate what they acquire as a housing site for a school playground?
Comment on this
Yes. In so far as this section is concerned in the last few lines of it the local authority may do development works on lands for playgrounds and such matters. The last few lines of this section sets out what they may do.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
A housing authority may, by resolution, direct a county manager to acquire, on behalf of the authority, from time to time, a minimum number of building sites in such urban and non-municipal town areas as may be specified in the resolution and the manager shall comply with such direction.
With your permission, a Chathaoirleach, I shall take amendments Nos. 28 and 29 together. This is an amendment to ensure that the building of houses and the acquisition and development of sites can go ahead, pending the implementation of the Planning Act. It may not be the experience of any other councillor here but I have a feeling that in many areas the Planning Act is being used as a reason for sites not being acquired and developed because people in the planning office have not made up their minds as to what the particular area will be used for; whether it is to be a residential area, an industrial area, a green belt, a park or something like that. While this is happening land which could properly have been acquired for housing is passed out of the hands of local authorities and is not now available. Local authorities should be encouraged to go ahead and acquire land and further develop sites for the provision of houses.
Comment on this
The matter raised by Senator Fitzgerald relates to a large degree, to the actions which may or are being taken under the Planning Act. The development plan itself would dictate for some considerable time to come the pattern of the growth of any area, particularly the built-up areas and while it is not by law required to be produced finally until October, 1967, it is in existence now. In practically every planning authority in the country there is what we call a provisional plan and the provisional plan is an outline of what we expect the general development plan to contain. The reason for this interim plan is that naturally, in the period while the overall plan is being prepared and finalised it was seen that it would not be possible to just stop everything. Neither would it be possible to allow everything to go ahead so this provisional plan is in fact —as its name indicates—a provisional interim plan which is the general guide by which local planning authorities determine where certain developments may or may not take place. It should, without any doubt, make it possible for the same planning authorities to acquire sites. Certainly it should leave them in the position that they are not debarred from acquiring sites for their own development plan, which will not necessarily emerge for another year or year and a half. In that sense the fears expressed by Senator Fitzgerald, while six months ago might have carried a great deal of weight, are much less well founded now than they were then. The provisional plan now in operation in these areas does enable local authorities to acquire, with a fair knowledge of what they are doing, sites for any purpose in the future, including housing sites.
Comment on this
I have the feeling the Minister is depending on the planning schemes for the implementation of this Bill. Yet it seems that the planning schemes will not be ready for years upon years as far as I can see. Take Dublin County Council—they have provided in Balbriggan 30 sites for persons who wanted to build their own houses and have another 38 sites in preparation. As soon as the money is again available these sites will be made available for applicants. In the adjoining town of Skerries we have a situation in which there is no land at all. This is also the case in Santry, Malahide and Swords while, as I mentioned on Second Stage, in Rush they were given some land by the Land Commission but only a few acres of that land was available. This was on the Kenure Estate which I mentioned where land went abegging at less than £300 an acre, the only complaint apparently being that there was too much land available in that location. I think every town should have considerable advance land arrangements for sites. This is surely a very good social object. The requirements are changing so frequently that paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) of subsection (2) of amendment No. 29, we suggest, are absolutely necessary, if we are to keep in line with increasing and shifting populations.
Comment on this
Perhaps I should have said a little more on this. Section 77, with which we shall be dealing later, deals with advance acquisition and under that particular section it is revised for this very purpose of acquiring land for houses in the future. This section would take care of the fears expressed by Senator Miss Davidson. Also, to add to the precautions—if you like to call them that— which will be there when this Bill becomes an Act is the provision that, when programming, this is something which would be required from all councils in the future under this Housing Bill. Building programmes will have to be devised and under section 77 the acquisition of land in advance of projected needs is dealt with there and it gives power to do that prior to acquisition. This, together with the programme which will be drawn up and the power contained in the section, should in my estimation, remove any fears in the mind of any member of the House as to the adequacy of the power which will be there empowering local authorities to do these jobs, to do them properly, to plan them properly and to take the action required by way of land acquisition to ensure that their programmes ultimately are carried out. This not only means that we can deal with the programming of actual building of houses by the council but we will also have power to acquire land for sites which may be used by others than the council. It will not be the want of power in the Bill which will cause any of our local authorities to fall down on this matter. The power will be adequate. It is a question of the performance and, of course, the money.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
In subsection (1), line 50, before "in" to insert "and publish".
This is a very short amendment to provide that it shall be the duty of a housing authority not only to make a scheme determining the priorities for the allocation of houses, but also to publish that scheme. It is of vital importance that if there is a scheme of priorities, the public shall know it, that the people involved, prospective tenants and so on, shall know it. I am not suggesting that the local authorities might forget the order of priorities they have decided upon, but I am suggesting that it is healthier in a democratic community for everyone to know just precisely upon what principle the allocation of houses and the establishment of priorities are being decided. Therefore I propose that the words "and publish" should be inserted in the section.
Comment on this
I can see the point of the amendment in that I think the fear of the Senator is that while the authorities may make priorities they may not be seen to be made or understood to be made. None of us connected with this matter, least of all the local authorities who will make the priorities, would have any objection to publication in the slightest degree. The difficulty I see is that a scheme of priorities so drawn up can be quite a lengthy matter. If they are well and truly drawn up they will probably stand for years. If we required them to be published in a newspaper they would appear only once. The newspaper might be seen, or it might not be seen, and even if it were seen it would probably disappear over the years and a copy would not be kept for future guidance.
If there is to be some method of publication I think it would be better if it were done by way of printed pamphlet or booklet. This could be made public on request at any time by anyone. It could be kept up to date and reprinted if necessary. I am thinking in terms of Dublin city where there are 10,000 applicants for houses. This figure will be diminished by the provision of houses, but there will be a continuing body of people concerned year by year, and, therefore, something that will be available to them from year to year would be better than a single publication by way of public announcement. If the Seanad wishes, on Report Stage I can bring in a suitably worded amendment to provide for this type of publication. I do not know whether there would need to be some small charge—this is something we might like to think about—to cover the cost of this publication, and to obviate a possibility of people continuously looking for copies even though they were not really interested, and not caring for their copy in the knowledge that if they dirtied one copy they could get a clean one for nothing. I suggest that something on these lines might be better than a single publication in a newspaper by the local authorities.
Comment on this
I should like to thank the Minister for the way in which he has received this amendment. My notion was not just publication in a newspaper. I felt that a notice in the office or on the office wall would be quite enough, where people could see the priorities upon which the local authorities worked. The word "publish" is capable of wide interpretation. I do not think it would be necessary to have a handbook. There could be a notice posted on the wall like the bye-laws of a company, or the licensing regulations in a licensed premises. If the Minister were prepared to accept the words "and publish" that would not commit him to a newspaper advertisement. It simply means to make public.
Comment on this
I do not think we could deal with it without some form of amendment. It might, indeed, be a better idea to put an obligation on the local authority to have it pasted up and available at all times.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In subsection (3), page 40, to delete paragraph (d).
This seems to me to be a vitally necessary amendment. I am asking for the deletion of paragraph (d) of subsection (3). Subsection (3) provides:
In making or amending a scheme under this section the housing authority shall have regard to the following primary objectives:—
Among the primary objectives there is one which seems to me to be highly objectionable and, in fact, questionable upon social and medical grounds in the light of modern medical practice and knowledge. The subsection states as one of the "primary objectives" the "segregation of persons suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis".
If a person is suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis and is positive and can spread infection, he should not be at home. He should be receiving hospital treatment. That is the practice, and that is what would be encouraged and, indeed, so far as possible, insisted upon. If a person has had pulmonary tuberculosis—as I have had some 30 years ago—and has recovered from it, and is no longer a menace to the population, in that regard at any rate, it is obviously wrong to suggest that he must be placed in a "segregated" portion of a housing estate. I hesitate to use the word "ghetto" but it looks rather like that. It is out of date to suggest that a person suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis should be segregated as a "primary objective" in the allocation of houses. Perhaps that would have been legitimate 20 years ago but not today. I do not think this is by any means necessary. On the contrary, I think it could be quite harmful. I do not think that this provision would really be used, but if it were used it could have most unhappy consequences for such people and their families.
Comment on this
There are two interpretations of this subsection to which Senator Sheehy Skeffington takes exception. One is that there shall be certain houses in an estate which shall be available for families where someone is known to be suffering from tuberculosis—segregation, in fact, of the people in the community. That is probably the objectionable aspect which he sees. It would be thoroughly objectionable, of course. The other possible interpretation is that one reason for giving a family a house in an estate like that would be to allow them to have a separate room for one member of the family who happens to have tuberculosis. It need not necessarily be generally known amongst the community that that is the situation in that family.
If a number of people had applied for houses and the list was being reviewed, and in that list there was a family one member of which was suffering from tuberculosis, and if for one reason or another he could not go into hospital the situation would certainly be made better if he could be given a separate room and would thus be segregated from the rest of the family. I do not know which of those two interpretations the Minister intends in the section. If it is the first interpretation I would certainly support it but there are circumstances in which people still remain with their families even though they are suffering from tuberculosis which might be open and infectious at that stage.
The Public Health Acts give authority to the Health Authorities to almost compel people with open tuberculosis to go into hospital but there are very few health authorities who are willing to take advantage of that power because putting people into hospital against their will for any reason is very bad for the disease from which they are suffering. If you could provide, for the purpose of allowing people suffering from such a disease, for separate accommodation and if that was the intention of the section I would certainly support it. I think it would be very bad if there were certain houses in an estate that were known to be special houses for people suffering from tuberculosis.
Comment on this
I want to say straight away that there seems to be some misinterpretation on what is intended here. In order to put it in a somewhat better way I should mention that the present law carries with it regulations known as the Management and Letting Regulations and they give priority to people suffering from tuberculosis in certain circumstances. These regulations have been laid down for quite a long time and constitute the law at the moment. In such cases, all things being equal, an applicant or a member of his family suffering from tuberculosis can get priority over other people in similar housing conditions. We are not going quite so far in this particular measure as we have been going in the past. We are saying that there are four primary priorities to which the local authorities must have regard in drawing up their letting priorities for any housing scheme. The one which it is suggested should be removed is one of four. Regard must be had to all four priorities. We do not want, at least in the sense that has been suggested here, to separate them from all other people and make it a sort of ghetto into which we would put them. It is rather in conformity with practice in the past that there should be recognition given to the fact that this disease is still a prevalent disease. In fact, it is the most prevalent infectious disease at the moment. We want to provide, where we can, that when we are housing such families that it should be possible for the person suffering from this disease to have a separate room. I should say, in that regard, for the last year for which I have figures that 2,178 cases of this type of tuberculosis were notified to the health authorities and that there are at present 15,193 cases on the register of local authorities. The bulk of that figure are in their own homes.
Comment on this
Most of those would no longer be open, positive cases.
Comment on this
We are far from the point where this disease would no longer be a problem disease. It is still a problem disease and in the history of housing legislation it is being dealt with in a sympathetic way. This is being done in order to help those people, particularly their families. They are given priority lettings and bigger houses so that the person suffering from the disease can have a separate room. We are giving a somewhat watered down version of the law here by saying that this is one of four categories to which priority should be given. We are saying that regard must be had to those priorities with regard to lettings. It is on that preference and in that context that this whole thing is intended. As I have said in the past there was even more direct legislation with regard to this. I think this regulation should be left there. It has served its purpose in the past and probably has helped us to reduce the incidence of the disease. I think this should be left there so that it will continue to reduce the wiping out of this disease.
Comment on this
The Minister has disillusioned me to some extent. I thought we had got to the stage that anybody suffering from active tuberculosis, with the facilities we have provided by medical authorities and local authorities, would go into hospital. I know the disease is still infectious and something needs to be done but I must say I understood we had reached the situation where anybody affected with tuberculosis would be given the strongest possible advice to go into hospital and be treated there. We have special hospitals suitable for the treatment of such disease. Some of them are practically vacant now. It is a pity that we in the Seanad would not indicate that the ideal treatment for any case of open tuberculosis was to have it treated in hospital. I must admit that the Minister has convinced me that this would possibly still be necessary. I should like to voice my opinion that the sooner the disease is obliterated the better.
Comment on this
I should not like it to be taken from what I have said that we are in any way condoning that the institutions provided for the treatment of this disease are unsuitable or that they should not be used. I know from my own personal knowledge that quite a number of those people have already had hospital treatment. In fact, it seems to be the pattern of the treatment of this disease, particularly when the infection is not so severe, that people suffering from it spend a short period in a sanitorium and after that they go home again and remain on the local authority register. They attend clinics and are usually on tablets and other treatment. In other words, the great majority of those people have had hospital treatment and are receiving further treatment while they are at home. Those are the people we should have regard to particularly with regard to priorities in the matter of housing.
Comment on this
I think the word "segregate" should be changed and some other word provided.
Comment on this
I should like to thank the Minister for his explanation, which satisfied me entirely as to his intention. It is quite a good intention, but I think we all agree that the wording is unfortunate and that a better wording might be found. I, therefore, wish to withdraw my amendment, and perhaps on Report Stage I might refer to the matter further.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In subsection (1) (c), page 41, to delete all words from and including "or" in line 5 to the end of the paragraph.
This amendment advocates the deletion of certain words dealing with the disclosure of circumstances of poverty so great that assistance from public funds under the Health Acts or the Public Assistance Act has had to be sought. In the more reasonable atmosphere of today's approach to the problem of poverty and destitution such a disclosure is uncalled for, particularly in fixing rents chargeable. I should like to see references of that kind removed from legislation.
Comment on this
While one could subscribe to the sentiments expressed by Senator Miss Davidson the effect would be to debar the local authority from finding out information on this form of income. We would be positively taking this opportunity away from them. While in the general sense it is possible that they may not have to have recourse to this provision, nevertheless it would be wrong to bring about a situation wherein the local authority could not obtain this information.
Comment on this
Surely the authority would already have that information on their books. It is a punishment to a person to have to put it on a form.
Comment on this
I should like to support the amendment. It seems to me that any funds such people are getting from public assistance will only have come after a full investigation of means and will have been regarded as the absolute minimum necessary or allowable, and thus ineligible to be counted as contributing towards the rent that would be fixed.
Comment on this
Possibly it has been oversimplified, but the health authority and the housing authority are not the same body even though in many cases their membership could be exactly similar. Dealing with the matter as suggested by the amendment would prevent the housing authority from obtaining this information. They would have no right to obtain it even though membership of both bodies might be common.
Comment on this
Any funds under the public assistance scheme would be irrelevant to the calculation of rents, because whatever is given under such a scheme would be given only after a stringent means test had already been applied, so that therefore it would be unjust to regard them as capable of helping an old person to contribute to the rent.
Comment on this
I support the amendment because I have the feeling that this is going to be used as a means of calculating the rent in the same way as income from employment. An old man might be receiving disablement benefit of £1.5.0 a week and his son might be working at £10 a week, and then the income coming into the house would be calculated as £11.5.0. That would mean that he would be paying a rent based on £11.5.0 rather than on the £10 that the son was earning.
Comment on this
The point about it is that the information is required for the adjustment of the rent. It is immediately assumed that the adjustment will always be upwards. If you want to have a clear assessment of the rent-paying situation in any particular case, the first thing you have to have is the entire background in regard to income from whatever source so as to see what exactly the situation is of this particular family or individual. Then you can base your figure depending on the overall picture.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister would agree that if a married son were appointed tenant of a local authority house his income only should be taken into consideration when the rent is being calculated. Would it be fair, if that son were maintaining his mother, who was in receipt of old age pension, that her old age pension should also be taken into account by the local authority in determining that the rent should be increased because he was maintaining his mother who had the old age pension? I can agree with the Minister 95 per cent of the way, inasmuch as you must have the income coming into the house, but it is not right that he pays the rent because his son may be maintaining an aged mother or father in receipt of old age pension, disability pension, home assistance or anything of that kind.
Comment on this
The point has been overshadowed here that this matter of the mother being maintained by the son when she is in receipt of the old age pension has already come to be dealt with in the differential rent schemes, and it, together with other such similar benefits, have in many schemes that I have seen been ignored and disregarded, so that nothing we are doing here is proposing to change that. Rather the practice has been in the direction advocated by the Senators. What we seek here, nothing more and nothing less, is that in the determination of what should be paid the local authority can get all the information it requires. What it does after it gets it is not what we are dealing with now. That is another day's work. I want to keep this so that they can know the full picture and act with justice to the tenants.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that it is the easiest thing in the world, if a local authority or a housing authority have appointed tenants to houses, for the authority to know that they are paying home assistance to any residents in houses, and if they feel that there is an old age pensioner in the house or somebody receiving social welfare benefits or any other kind of benefit they can get that information from the Department of Social Welfare? I do not think it is right that the people should be worried in this way so that the local authority may use it in assessing the rent.
Comment on this
This is not what we are dealing with. We are dealing with the amendment proposed to delete part of subsection (c) of subsection (1). The section lays down that the housing authority in determining the rent may require the person to whom they are letting the house to furnish particulars on a number of matters, and subsection (c) refers to particulars of any assistance, benefit or allowance received by or on behalf of the person or a member of his family residing with him from State funds or under the Public Assistance Act, 1939, the Health Acts, 1947 to 1960, or from any other source whatsoever. It is the requirement on the person to furnish this information that is being deleted, not what may be done after the information would have been received.
They will do two different things altogether. This is a manner of getting the full facts of a case and, having got them, we do not say or lay down in this section in the slightest degree what will be done with them. What we are providing is that the entire circumstances will be known in the best and most accurate way possible. The amendment seeks to lessen the garnering of the informations. I wish to point out that informations may be got but they need not always be accurate. There may be inaccurate informations and I suggest it would be far better to go for accurate informations under the law. Then, it would be established beyond yea or nay that those were the facts. What we do afterwards is a matter that will be dealt with in another provision.
Comment on this
The last phrase is most comprehensive—"from any other source whatsoever". We are concentrating on two items of a comprehensive investigation.
Comment on this
What I think is objectionable is getting people to write down on a form what the authority themselves must already know because the home assistance officer knows whom he is calling on.
Comment on this
I appreciate the point but I should like to remind the Senator that things have changed somewhat in recent times. For instance, the Dublin Health Authority now are a completely different body from what they were some years ago and from what similar bodies are in some other areas. In Dublin and Cork, the personnel of the health authorities are completely different, the executive are completely different, being drawn from a much wider area than heretofore. If they are all from local councils, they are not all from the one council. Therefore, these informations are not available to the general comprehensive health authority. Therefore, it is not true to say we are seeking information they already have. In some instances that may be so but the tendency is, where there is a number of big areas, towards completely separate health and housing bodies and this will spread instead of diminishing. In future years, it may be that health authorities will be completely separate bodies from housing authorities and that they will not have the knowledge county councils now have available to them through their health officers.
Comment on this
The purpose of these amendments is to ensure that the procedure adopted by local authorities and the National Building Agency for the recovery of possession of houses or property occupied by trespassers will be reasonably simple and also fair to the trespasser. Under this proposed provision the authority or Agency will serve a demand for possession on the trespasser indicating that if he does not give possession they intend to apply to the district court. If they do not get possession, they will apply to the district court which will issue its summons. On hearing a case, the court will then issue its finding for possession if it is satisfied the procedure has been followed. Under the section as it stood, the trespasser would have to be served with a demand for possession and if he failed to give up possession with a notice of the authority's or the Agency's intention to apply to the court. This notice is now being dispensed with. Recovery from a trespasser was a more difficult and lengthy procedure than recovery from a legitimate occupier. The trespasser was put in a more favourable position than the legitimate occupier in cases where recovery for possession was sought.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In line 51, to delete "rooms" and substitute "bedrooms".
It seems to me that in reading this section, in line 51 the words "the number of rooms" are not sufficient. This is in connection with the definition of overcrowding. The section reads:
A house shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be overcrowded at any time when the number of persons ordinarily sleeping in the house and the number of rooms therein either—
(a) are such that any two of those persons, being persons of ten years of age or more of opposite sexes and not being persons living together as husband and wife, must sleep in the same room, or
(b) are such that the free air space in any rooms used as a sleeping apartment, for any person is less than four hundred cubic feet (the height of the room, if it exceeds eight feet, being taken to be eight feet, for the purpose of calculating free air space),
and "overcrowding" shall be construed accordingly.
The point I wish to make is that instead of having line 51 referring to the number of persons ordinarily sleeping in the house and to the number of rooms, bedrooms should be specified because we do not want to define the house as not being overcrowded because there are two boys sleeping in the bathroom, a girl sleeping in the kitchen, somebody sleeping in the hall and somebody sleeping in the parlour. As the section is phrased, as long as you have enough "rooms" to go round it does not matter whether there are people sleeping all over the house. I feel that a house would be overcrowded without necessarily breaking the terms of this section, even if there were people sleeping in the bathroom, in the kitchen, in the scullery and in all downstairs rooms. I feel "bedrooms" should be used here to avoid misinterpretation of what is clearly in the Minister's mind.
Comment on this
Taking Senator Sheehy Skeffington's reading of the section as it stands, one could establish a case on the grounds he has made, but what we have to remember is that this overcrowding definition is required for and relates to payment of subsidy. Therefore, it is, if you like, the yardstick which will be used by the public authority and the central authority to decide whether overcrowding exists and whether a subsidy is payable at a higher or lower rate or at all.
In this way it would stretch things a little too far to expect or anticipate in any way, or even think, that the local authority or the central authority officers would condone a situation where on a visit to a house it was alleged that overcrowding existed and it was said that there were people sleeping in the bathroom and the hall and that the bedrooms as such could not be said to be overcrowded according to the section. I think also the acceptance of the amendment and the substitution of "bedrooms" for "rooms" would bring about a certain confusion in another direction where there is likely to be greater danger and that would be in the administration of the matter by the local or central authority. That is, if we had the amendment accepted here we could, for instance, in relation to a bedsittingroom, containing an alcove or a kitchenette, regard that room as not being a bedroom. That being so, no matter how many people you put into it it can never be overcrowded. So, the acceptance of the amendment by clearing up, if you like in a theoretical sort of way, the objection the Senator has made would, without doubt, create in regard to bedsittingrooms a situation which none of us would wish to obtain. In other words, if you put in "bedrooms" for "rooms" and think in terms of bedsittingrooms they could be regarded as non-bedrooms and not concerned with sleeping space, or otherwise these rooms could not be regarded as overcrowded even though half a dozen people are sleeping in them.
If we look at the situation and the reason for this overcrowding definition and keep in mind what it was intended for, I think the dangers that are seen there will not arise at all for the reason that it is not a person or persons living in the house who would be interested into getting us to believe they were not overcrowded. It would depend on whether the particular house was overcrowded or not. This is a case where subsidy is or is not payable, depending on whether the house is overcrowded or not. Overcrowding under the section is something there can be no doubts about and there is no danger of overcrowding being condoned by the public or the central authority on the basis that they would regard sleeping in the corridors or in the hall or bathroom satisfactory as sleeping space in the true sense.
Comment on this
I am satisfied the Minister's intentions are of the best. Nevertheless, this definition of overcrowding in Part IV which deals with "overcrowding or unfit houses", might relate to a family seeking accommodation on grounds of overcrowding. They might find themselves being told: "You are not overcrowded as to sex, because the number of people of different sexes having to sleep in the same room is not excessive, in view of the number of rooms you have."
The section says:
A house shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be overcrowded at any time when the number of persons ordinarily sleeping in the house and the number of rooms therein either—
(a) are such that...
and the local authority not wanting to reconsider a particular family, or being unable to do so, might argue: "You have enough rooms to prevent this type of overcrowding; why can you not put the boys in the parlour?" I feel this is a lowering of living standards. I recognise that the definition of a bedroom may be difficult because the bedsittingroom mentioned might be a perfectly legitimate use of a parlour that is not otherwise used. I am a bit unhappy, nevertheless, that it is simply a question of the "number of rooms". One should not regard it as normal that the parlour would also be a bedroom for some of the family and that this would prevent the house from being deemed overcrowded. I am afraid some families in this country are overcrowded in reality which would not be regarded as overcrowded according to the present definition of this section.
Comment on this
There is another feature also. The misuse of this particular section would be by the persons who hoped to gain from it. They would be the people who would hope to get rehousing as a result of a definition or examination which according to the definition indicated that they were overcrowded according to law. If we are to change this and make it "bedroom", I can see then that those who would have the best of a particular vested interest, who would then be the occupier of any house, could in effect, decide that one or two bedrooms used as such now should be converted into a sittingroom or another diningroom and then make out that they are overcrowded according to law though they have an ample amount of living accommodation. Then they could point out and say under the law—we are in number and in sex and in age so and so and we have only two bedrooms— despite the fact that they have three or four livingrooms. This would be legitimate and probably could be upheld and they could claim this to their advantage if they wanted a different house in a different area. This could be done by a person who was going to gain from it, whereas the dangers pointed out by Senator Sheehy Skeffington are dangers that in my estimation cannot and will not arise for the reason that those who would be determining what the law implies or intends would be people who have no personal vested interest. They would be on an objective investigation as to whether overcrowding exists or not according to the spirit and intention of the law. Therefore, the danger of their doing these queer things—they could possibly squeeze in and still be within the law—does not exist but it could exist in the reverse in that the occupiers could, for their own personal gain and their own motives, bring about a queer situation if we change the law and agree to the amendment. They would have motives in that they would have something to gain. The public or civil servant has nothing to gain in misinterpreting the law.
Comment on this
That is so; the public official has nothing to gain except perhaps the pleasure of dragging his feet. The public official, however, sometimes seems to derive immeasurable joy from dragging his feet. I can see technical difficulties in this connection. There is a case with which I was familiar, among hundreds of cases which came before a local Council of Action branch of the Pearse Street Labour Party and Trade Union movement. It was a case of a family of seven living in one room in Corporation Buildings in Railway Street. The children ranged from a girl of 23 to a boy of 16. They were all sleeping in one room. Their aim or ambition was to get a second room which the corporation finally conceded to them. Subsequently the men slept in one room and the girls in another. It took six months to get this second room. That was many years ago, and I have no doubt that public officials have since advanced greatly in general saintliness and behaviour, but I think many tenants applying for rehousing on grounds of overcrowding would even today find that public authorities and public officials do not act with quite that alacrity with which the Minister seems to credit them. I feel a bit unhappy, therefore, about the use of the word "rooms" but I think the Minister has a point that if we did change it to "bedrooms" it would present certain technical difficulties. I beg leave to withdraw the amendment, but I hope that, in the interpretation of this, the public authority will be anxious to rehouse people where there is genuine overcrowding and will not use this section simply to say—"Oh, you have got enough rooms, you could put the boys in the parlour".
Comment on this
In practice I am not too happy about this section because we find when it comes to rehousing that what the ordinary person would deem to be an overcrowded house would be one where you have two and three families living in a small three-roomed house—a house originally designed with two bedrooms, a kitchenette or kitchen and livingroom or parlour. The most usual of these cases is where married members of the family return from England and, successfully finding work at home, have nowhere to go and are taken in by their parents. Very often one finds up to 20 people living in what was originally a three-roomed house. The fact that the local authorities turn down these families for rehousing because they do not earn the higher rate of subsidy creates an extraordinary situation. I feel the system whereby town commissioned houses and subtenants of town commissioned houses do not rank for the two-thirds subsidy is something which certainly needs to be corrected. For that reason this definition of overcrowding can be left vague. I should like to see the distinction between town commissioned houses and local authority houses dropped.
Comment on this
I should like to repeat a question I asked on the Second Reading on subsection (2) of this section. This again deals with overcrowded houses. Subsection (2) says:
(2) Where the owner of a house is causing or permitting the house to be overcrowded, the housing authority may, if they think fit, serve on such owner a notice in writing requiring him to desist from causing or permitting such overcrowding and specifying the period, being not less than twenty-one days beginning on the date of the notice, within which, or the event after the occurrence of which, the requirements of the notice are to be complied with.
We have been told on several sections here of practical difficulties. I should like to ask how does the owner of a house suddenly "desist" within 21 days from permitting his house to be overcrowded? What does he do; what is he expected to do?
Comment on this
This will be entirely related to the tenementing of houses and the continuance of that practice. It is particularly related to the situation where people will have been taken out of tenement conditions, where overcrowding was remedied, where they had been rehoused and the owner continues to refill the house, as it were, to the same capacity as that which had already been relieved. It is to prevent overcrowding and to prevent the recreation of conditions which may already have been relieved by the housing authority which is intended here.
Comment on this
I have every sympathy with the intentions, but the practical problem remains. If a scoundrel of this type is told he must stop permitting overcrowding this means he has to get rid of some of his tenants, and, in the process of law, this could take three months— six months if he has a good lawyer— and he is required by this section to do it within 21 days. I do not see how he can do it, but I grant that he should be forced to try.
Comment on this
The following subsections (3) and (4) deal with the making effective of the law in this regard.
Comment on this
These deal with penalties which fall upon him if he does not. But supposing, with the best will in the world, he decides to get rid of a due proportion of his tenants, he could do it only by a process of law, and I doubt if he could get an individual tenant out within 21 days. The lawyers here might perhaps tell us if I am right in that.
Comment on this
The Bill says "not less than 21 days". It is not "within 21 days" but "not less than 21 days".
Comment on this
Could it not be stated that by serving a notice to quit and taking legal action in the matter he is ceasing to permit overcrowding? He caused the overcrowding when he allowed these people in; he permits it by allowing them to remain.
Comment on this
That is always assuming his notice to quit is valid and that he has the right under the law to evict these tenants, which he may not have.
Comment on this
I would contend that this is all right once Senator Yeats is on the bench.
Comment on this
I am sure there would be other people with equal commonsense on the bench.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
Before section 76 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) A housing authority may acquire by agreement any land situate within or without their functional area although the area or tract of land offered for sale by auction or by private treaty is in excess of the reasonable requirements of the authority for immediate and further need, and, having reserved sufficient land for immediate and further needs, the housing authority may dispose of any surplus land.
(2) A housing authority may acquire land which is not suitable or convenient for the purposes of this Act provided that the land is acquired with a view to an exchange of that land for suitable land.
(3) The power conferred on a housing authority under this section shall be in addition to their powers to acquire land under section 82 of the Local Government Act, 1946.
(4) This section shall come into operation on the passing of this Act."
The purpose of this amendment is to enable local authorities to acquire land in an area where land is difficult to acquire. One often hears of land going on the market adjacent to a town or village. It may be in excess of the amount of land required by that local authority but the owner of the land is not prepared to sell a portion of it. He is prepared to sell all or nothing. In these circumstances, local authorities are precluded from acquiring or purchasing that land because it is much in excess of their requirements. The purpose of this amendment is to enable a local authority to acquire all the land in that particular area for sale and, having established what they require for their own houses—for the provision of houses and for the provision of sites in that area—could then dispose of the excess land which they did not require.
Comment on this
The amendment would appear to enable a housing authority to acquire land, by agreement, in excess of reasonable requirements for the immediate and future needs; to enable a housing authority to dispose of surplus land; to enable a local authority to acquire land for the purpose of exchanging it for other land; and the powers in the amendment would be in addition to those already in section 82 of the Local Government Act, 1946.
Section 82 of the 1946 Act is the section we rely on primarily to do the things that are sought to be done in these amendments. In that section there is power for the local authority, with the consent of the Minister, to acquire by agreement lands, "which in their opinion they will require in the future for the purposes of their powers and duties notwithstanding that they have not determined the manner in which or the purpose for which they will use the land."
This is a pretty wide section, and that is the law as it now stands. I should add that subsection (4) of the same section provides, "...a power conferred on a local authority by any Act to acquire land for a particular purpose shall be deemed to include a power to acquire land which the local authority do not require immediately for that purpose but which in their opinion they will require for that purpose in the future."
The subsection which we are talking about it regarded as conferring powers of compulsory acquisition of land not immediately required so long as there are reasonable grounds for believing that the lands will be used in the future. The powers we have in the 1946 Act, and the powers we derive from many other Acts, put beyond any question the need for any further elaboration of the law to enable local authorities to acquire any land that the members of a local authority would ever hope to need, that is, assuming they had not all gone over the top at the same time, or that they had not all gone out the window on the same morning. That is the way I see it. I do not think there is any doubt in the world but that the power is there.
We have ample power. It is the performance and the money which are the real kernel of our problem rather than a lack of power. The fact is that the amendments are catered for already, and the motive underlying them is catered for in a number of Acts which give us more than adequate power for land acquisition without specifying what we want it for, how it may be finally used, or what year we may need it in. Taking it all round there is power, and power to spare, without adding more in this way. If it should ever come to pass that it is found that what I am saying is short of what really is the situation, and that there is a lack of this power, in whatever capacity I am in at the time I will support the elaboration of the law making the power as wide as I have now said I believe it to be. I believe it is wide enough at the moment, and if any fault is found with it in the future, that will be another day's work.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
Before section 76 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) Before allocating any land for the purposes of the Land Acts the Land Commission shall inform a housing authority of the area and location of such land and the manager of the authority shall place any such communication before the next meeting of the authority.
(2) Whenever a housing authority informs the Land Commission that the authority needs land in any specified area for their powers and duties and certifies that all or part of the land in the hands of the Land Commission is suitable, the Land Commission shall first make an allocation of suitable land to the housing authority before allotting the lands for the purposes of the Land Acts.
(3) Whenever any local authority has land surplus to their needs that local authority shall, before disposing of the surplus land, offer the land to the housing authority."
The purpose of the amendment is to ensure that where the Land Commission acquire land they will inform the local authority in that area, and that if there is a need for sites for housing in that area, some of the land will be made available to the local authority to enable them to provide houses. I may say in passing that my local authority have had experience of the co-operation of the Land Commission. When we requested the Land Commission to provide a site in one village they did so. When the Land Commission acquire land close to a town or village the local authority should be able to exchange or barter another piece of land for land adjacent to the town or village. In that way the Land Commission could help the local authority to provide more sites.
Comment on this
This matter was discussed on Committee Stage in the Dáil. I said I agreed with the sentiment and the intention of the amendment, and I undertook to have a look at the matter with a view to amending the section, but the trouble in regard to subsection (3) of the amendment—to start with the last one first — is that it is not appropriate to this Housing Bill at all. We would not be in a position in this House to dictate to the Land Commission any more than we would be able to dictate to the health people or any other body, in local government or housing legislation. Senator Fitzgerald has indicated that the Land Commission were not unreasonable in their dealings with his local authority. The situation at present is that the Land Commission notify the secretary of the county council—and, in fact, they must —when they are acquiring and taking over land. That is in relation to valuation.