We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Housing Bill, 1965—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 113–232 of 232. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing Bill, 1965
Enacted

No. 20 of 1965 ›

No, but the local authority through the secretary are in a position to know what lands are being acquired by the Land Commission. The investigations I have made since this matter was raised in the other House indicate that the Land Commission co-operate with the local authorities in matters such as this and to such a degree that I do not think the amendment suggested is really necessary at all. I would go further and say that if it came to the point where the Land Commission behaved other than in the manner in which they have behaved up to the moment, and if the land could not be taken over by agreement, it could be taken over by compulsion. This would be something which the Land Commission would like to avoid if at all possible. This is something which is not likely to occur. If it did happen the local authority would know, if they did not get co-operation from the Land Commission, they could acquire the land if it was necessary to provide much needed housing.

I do not think this is ever likely to happen but if it did the local authority could get the land by compulsion. They would then get the land which they could have got with the co-operation of the Land Commission. That is the blackest picture of the matter and I do not envisage it happening. The county councils know of this land because they are informed by the rates authorities when there is a change. They are notified because of the redistribution of the various amounts of valuation and rates. All in all, we get the information and, having got the information, we make our requests to the Land Commission. History up to the moment is that they co-operate and, in the last analysis, if that happy state of affairs should for any reason cease to be the case, then we can direct the local authorities to take the step I indicated. In the last analysis the local authority will still get the land even though they have not got co-operation from the Land Commission.

As I have already said, I do not think that is likely to happen and I do not feel because of those things that we require this amendment. I want to say, with regard to land held by other associated bodies like the health authority and so forth, that we are in the course of preparing a circular to issue to our local authorities to bring to their attention the desirability of contact with those other bodies whom they know hold land which could be used for housing purposes. We are sending a general circular on the line which would bring about possible acquisition by agreement of certain land, which those bodies own, and which they do not want, but which the housing authorities might need. We are sending this circular out so that we will have an appraisal of the land held by semi-State bodies and other similar bodies so that this will be investigated and where it is desired by one body but not necessarily by the other that steps can be taken to clear up this situation. We know there are lands idle by one public body which would be needed by another.

Comment on this

The Minister has been very specific in his explanation but he indicated that local authorities will always know when land is going and they can acquire the land. The Minister indicated that the rates office would inform them of the change of ownership. Amendment No. 39, subsection (1), states:

Before allocating any land for the purposes of the Land Act the Land Commission shall inform a housing authority of the area and location of such land and the manager of the authority shall place any such communication before the next meeting of the authority.

The point I am trying to get at here is that the manager of the authority would, on receiving information in the rates office that the Land Commission had acquired certain lands in any particular area, inform the local authority that the Land Commission had acquired land in that particular area. In that connection in my county we have never been informed by the manager that land was acquired. The land that has been acquired by the Meath County Council from the Land Commission has been acquired because of the activities of the members of the local authority who brought it to the notice of the officials and asked them to start investigating to acquire this land. As the Minister is aware, some of that land has been acquired but it has all been acquired in a way which reflects great credit on the co-operation that was received from the Land Commission and the officials of the local authority. I hope the Minister does not feel that I am insinuating that we should go after the Land Commission and take land off them. We should inform the Land Commission that we have a problem in that particular area where they have land and they will co-operate with us in the provision of sites.

Comment on this

I am not quite clear what the Senator is getting after but it seems to me that he is suggesting that there is a danger of the communication from the Land Commission never coming to the notice of the elected body. When the Land Commission notify the manager of the change in ownership of land is the Senator saying that unless this is further publicised by being brought to the notice of the elected members that they will, in certain circumstances, not be notified of the communication by the Land Commission?

Comment on this

That would be correct. It would not be known by all the local authority representatives. It would be known by those in the area who might not be as actively conversant with the matter as the local authority representative from outside the area.

Comment on this

Is this the kernel of the Senator's complaint?

Comment on this

I have in mind in the same circular, which I have already mentioned, that we will direct that such information as that which will come to the knowledge of your secretary or manager, from the Land Commission, will be put before your full council. We will direct that that be done in the circular which has not yet gone out. It is still in the course of preparation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:

"( ) A housing authority may be authorised to acquire land by agreement or otherwise for the purpose of facilitating the acquisition, by agreement or otherwise, of land under tillage, within or adjacent to an urban area, non-municipal town or an area serviced by water and sewerage."

This amendment is really something on the lines of the other amendments which we had. This is designed to enable local authorities to acquire land, by agreement or otherwise, which they might not require but it would enable them to swop it for land which would be inside a serviced area, for example, where there was water and sewerage and where it is possible to provide a housing scheme. This would enable a local authority to acquire a site which is serviced in many of our villages because you could say to the owner: "If you give us that site and the two or three acres there we will give you four or five acres one mile or a half mile outside the town which is outside the serviced area and which because it is not serviced it would prevent the local authority from developing it and providing houses on it."

Comment on this

The very quick answer to this amendment is that it is not terribly clear what the amendment intends to do. Housing authorities have full power to acquire by agreement or compulsorily land required for the purpose of any of their powers, functions or duties. Whether the land is under tillage or not is immaterial as far as the powers of the local authority are concerned. They have ample power. We have already been discussing what power they have. What probably is in mind is that it might bring about a situation wherein instead of acquiring land from a man they could give him land of equivalent value, and particularly that they could give him more acres even at a different location which would be of little value for building or any other council purpose but might get the farmer to part more readily with his land than he would for money. If we tried to put any such thing into legislation goodness knows what organisations, we would have down on our heads, because we would become landbrokers rather than local authorities. If we do not have something in the law it is more likely that many things similar to that which we might wish to write in could be done if we did not specifically write in what we might do. As sure as we write in what we could do we will have all the legal advice saying "you cannot do anything fringing upon it".

I have no doubt of what is in the mind of the Senator, and I also have no doubt, as a member of a council as I once was, that this particular type of operation, without being written in the law, is capable of being done, but far be it from me as a Minister to put it into the law that it can and should be legal to do it and that we should make it a point in the law that we should do it. The danger of writing such a thing in here would be that some councils would become real landbrokers, not, possibly, always for the benefit of the powers, functions and duties of the local authority, and there would be a lot of trouble created by transactions that could then be put on foot. The difficulties we now have and criticisms made about the Land Commission making allotments would be nothing to what might arise if the council began in their own way to make allotments and to have exchange deals as between one lot of land and another. You would be in for very great trouble and possibly we could have abuse of it. Where there is a genuine case and where this is the only way to get over the problem an exchange of one parcel of land for another is not beyond the ingenuity of the Senator and many others in our local authorities throughout the country. It is not impossible of being done if the case is a good one in which the council as a whole are fully agreed that it would be a proper thing to do.

I would not put this in the law at all. I would be against putting it in. We have ample powers and ample ingenuity when the occasion demands, but to write it in would have its dangers. To leave things as they are leaves it possible to lessen the danger of abuse.

Comment on this

The Minister has made a very good case for the amendment but I can see his reason now for not writing it in. There is a very good case for it but the Minister is afraid to write it in. He also says that he knows that this is capable of being implemented. It is because I also know that it is capable of being implemented that I wanted to have it written into the Bill. Being capable of being implemented and being implemented are two different things, because, as the Minister explained, he was a member of a local authority and he knows the difficulty you can have if you go to an official and ask him to give so and so down in the town, who has two acres of excellent building site serviced with everything right, four acres half a mile outside the town. He would say that that would be inequitable, that he could not do it because there was nothing in the Act that would enable him to do it. The same official would be prepared to give this man two acres half a mile away, conveniently ignoring the fact that he would be getting two acres of land beside water and sewerage. It is for that very reason that I wanted it in to strengthen the hand of a man like the Minister.

Comment on this

This is getting back to another matter on which in another context I am having special intructions prepared to go out to councils. It has to do with the absolute inflexible uniformity with which officials dealing with land acquisition are inclined to relate values, which is entirely wrong. This inflexible uniformity of price per acre has brought about more compulsory acquisition proceedings than need have arisen if there was a real effort made to evaluate lands being acquired for whatever purpose the council needs them at their real value, rather than saying, "it is £100 an acre" whether it is rock and heather or really top grassland, or an acre out in the middle of a field which leaves two halves on either side of a new road useless, or some taken as a strip along half a dozen fields. There appears to be an inflexible uniformity, over the years, applied particularly in another sphere of activity of local authorities, and I am having a circular instruction prepared dealing with this matter, that there will have to be a more realistic approach and a better attempt at proper evaluation of land being acquired. This is not only to give the landowner a fair deal but also to cut down on the unnecessary compulsory order proceedings that arise directly in many cases from inflexible application of uniform prices of lands being acquired regardless of location or quality. While it arises in another set of circumstances, it equally applies to the substance of what Senator Fitzgerald has said. We might widen the instructions by also making reference to land for other local authority purposes, asking that proper values be made of all lands related to use value, whether it is good land or bad and so forth. If we did this it would have the effect that four acres could be the equivalent of two acres for the purpose of exchange in the future.

Comment on this

Part of this section relating to the fact that the authority may acquire land by compulsion leads me to comment on the very cumbersome procedure which compulsory acquisition as we know it is. A local authority requiring a certain portion of land for immediate building requirements seek to acquire it but find that the owner will not sell. A CPO is entered into and there is the slow, tedious, long drawn-out method of procedure. I cannot, therefore, understand why, in a case like that, an arbitrator cannot be immediately appointed to get over this slow procedure and bring the matter to a conclusion quickly in order that the local authority may get on with the work. It has happened that acquisition has taken as long as two years. It could be done much more quickly and to everybody's satisfaction if an arbitrator could be appointed immediately.

Comment on this

This section enables the housing authority to acquire land which is not necessarily immediately required for building, and I should like to welcome the section. I think it is a good one. I suppose the time has not come yet when we can go as far as Fintan Lawlor a hundred years ago, when he wanted to nationalise or municipalise all land, which is what I should like to see. If a county council or a local housing authority were to use the powers granted under this section, they might well have a very positive effect on the planning of the country.

If Kerry had done this in relation to the land around the Lakes of Killarney, the local authority would have found themselves in a position of greater power when certain building took place about which they found they had no real powers at all. The same would apply to Cork County Council in relation to Whiddy Island when the whole landscape can be destroyed and a major target in an atomic war can be put up without any local power over the land when it was sold by private interests. This section is a good one because in a small, restricted field it places public interest above private greed and even private property and private ownership. It gives a slightly increased enabling power to local authorities to acquire land ahead of need. I welcome this and look forward to an extension of the principle in the community interest.

Comment on this

I agree with the Senator who has taken issue with the time lag and the cumbersome method of CPO, but this sympathy stems entirely from looking at the thing from the local authority viewpoint which must be balanced by the viewpoint of the person from whom the land is to be acquired. Unfortunately, we must have procedure that gives a fair opportunity to the landowner, no matter how little sympathy we might have with him or with his stand against the local authority. We have got to deal with all the people from whom land may from time to time be acquired compulsorily and adopt a procedure to ensure that their rights are not violated.

This, in turn, at times creates a situation wherein the time it takes can be wearisome to the local authority. The system, in practice, is probably more long drawn out than in theory it could be. The causes of this rather lengthy operation are something I do not think we can deal with here today. I should like, however, to point out that the time lag could be speeded up quite a bit and this does not need any change in the system, the regulations or the law. The procedure we must retain even if we may at times feel somewhat annoyed and irritated by its delays. The delays need not be what they were in the past if we all do our own end of the job a little more expeditiously. We must leave it there and whatever else we may do we must safeguard the rights of the individual from whom we are taking property. Though we may irritate a local authority, we must remember the land belongs to the people and we must be very careful not to violate their right of ownership. However, if we can expedite the procedure we should try to do so.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I feel Senator Sheehy Skeffington produced a very unfortunate instance in support of his case when he referred to the necessity for control in relation to the development in Whiddy Island. In this instance, the local authority had all the powers necessary if they decided to use them, if, in fact, they were foolish enough to decide so to use them that they would hamper this development. The land is of little value to the companies concerned if the harbour authority, in this instance Cork County Council, were not known to encourage the development which is about to take place there.

Every care was exercised and I should not like it put on record that there was dangerous exploitation in relation to Whiddy Island and its environment. There was close co-operation between Ibernia—the local tourist association—the Cork Economic Council of which I happen to be a member and the local authority, and full cognisance was taken of every possibility. Every care was taken to ensure that far from creating any difficulties or reducing the amenities that exist, this development will enhance the position in that area. The powers were already in the hands of the local authority who were extremely gratified at the indications of the establishment of this industry——

Comment on this

More shame to them.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Time will tell. If the Senator had been as closely involved in the frequent and lengthy consultations between Cork County Council, the manager of the Cork Economic Council, the manager of Ibernia and the others involved, I think he would be completely satisfied that this is one of the greatest developments that has taken place in the south of Ireland. The effect will be that the Cork Housing Authority will be involved in further development in that region in consequence of the Whiddy Island development because there will be a degree of employment where at the moment all eyes are on foreign shores because our nationals have to leave to get employment abroad.

I can assure the Senator that nobody will be more surprised than I if in the years to come anything should result from the establishment of this concern to detract in the slightest degree from the guarantee we have that the utmost care will be exercised in the carrying out of the buildings so that nothing will be done, even temporarily, to damage the amenities of Bantry Bay.

Comment on this

Will the buildings include a temple to Mammon?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is better to have Mammon at home than Mammon abroad.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The point raised by Senator Sheehy Skeffington has been adequately dealt with.

Comment on this

This amendment does not involve any change of substance from what was originally intended. It was put down to clarify the intention. By virtue of section 121 (5) "under this Act" will recover the disposal under the Bill of land acquired under any enactment repealed by the Bill. If section 88 were left as it stands some doubt might arise as to the power of housing authorities to dispose under the Bill of the land acquired prior to its enactment.

Comment on this

The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that county councils will require payment to them of such sums as may be approved by the Minister where they consent to the alienations or subdivision of a vested cottage by the purchaser. Under the section as it stood it was discretionary on the authority to require payment. The amendment will enable sales or transfers of cottages to members of the family or to the householder and the purchase will be effected without any requirement of payment to the local authority, as at present.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is there a prescribed proportion of moneys admitted? I think it is one-third, is it not?

Comment on this

If the annuity is to continue, it is one-third.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It "may" be one-third or "shall" be one-third?

Comment on this

Not less than one-third.

I might also mention the intention of considering on Report Stage a further amendment to this section declaring that sales effected without consent shall be null and void.

Comment on this

The Chair suggests we take amendments Nos. 44, 45 and 46 together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:

In subsection (1), lines 43 and 46 to delete "good structural condition" and substitute "good structural repair and sanitary condition".

This, to my mind, is a very important amendment because the section brings about a very big change in the law as it stands with regard to local authority vesting of cottages and putting those cottages into good repair. I am not satisfied that sound structural repair is a proper way in which to hand over a cottage. It is too vague and is a very big change from what was contained in the 1936 Labourers Act, when we consider that for a long number of years an organisation known as the Cottage Tenants Association campaigned for the right of tenants to purchase or vest their own cottages. Eventually, as a result of their efforts, the 1936 Labourers Act was introduced and while this was a much maligned Act in many ways, it did serve a very useful purpose.

One of its most useful purposes was section 18 which states:

Whenever a board of health proposes to make a vesting order in respect of any cottage which is not in good repair and sanitary condition, such board of health, before making such vesting order, shall carry out on or in such cottage all works which shall be necessary to put such cottage in good repair and sanitary condition.

When we examine that against the section which will replace it in the 1965 Housing Act, we find there is a great difference. I am not happy that merely to hand over a cottage in good structural condition to a tenant is conferring any benefit on that tenant, if we do not ensure that he gets his cottage vested in the same way as those of us who had cottages vested under the 1936 Labourers Act because a house may be structurally sound if the walls and roof are sound, but there are many other aspects of a house which would cost a lot of money if that phrase is to be interpreted as meaning a sound cottage merely because the walls and roof are in good structural condition. You have to take into consideration window frames, door frames and things like that which will be interpreted under section 106 of this Bill as meaning that the house is structurally sound and the tenant will have to accept what the engineer may regard as being structurally sound.

It is also stated here, as in the 1936 Act, that you can appeal to the Minister. Under the 1936 Act, when appeals were made to the Minister, in almost all cases on the visit of an inspector from the Department, as a result of such an appeal, repairs had to be carried out. The inspector from the Department was not satisfied that the house was handed over in a proper state of repair. He listed certain repairs that had to be carried out and they were then carried out. Not only were the local authorities served with a list of repairs to be carried out, but the tenant of the vested cottage was also served with a list of repairs to be carried out. To my mind any change or deviation from the system appertaining to the 1936 Act would be detrimental to the tenants trying to vest their own houses.

Comment on this

I should like to know how many appeals from cottiers were successful?

Comment on this

In reply to Senator Ahern, I think 75 per cent were upheld. That does not mean that all the points raised in the appeals were acceded to.

The change here is brought about by reason of the fact that it is costing the local authorities between £300,000 and £400,000 per annum to put these cottages into repair for the purpose of vesting. Senator Fitzgerald seemed to think that so long as the walls and roof are sound we think that is sufficient. That is not so. Windows and window frames, doors and door frames, would be part of the structure, and would be included. For instance, if the entrance door to a cottage were eaten away by woodworm or dry rot, there would be an obligation on the local authority to provide a new door prior to vesting. That would be part of the structure.

One of the main complaints was that the local authorities were being asked to do small little repairs that should normally be carried out by the tenants themselves—replacing a pane of glass or something like that—rather than expecting the local authority to do it. Quite a number of the appeals are finicky little appeals, but because the tenants had the right to appeal they lodged an appeal, and in many cases the engineer did not see eye to eye with them and refused the applications. At the same time, it seems that 75 per cent of the applications were successful because the local authorities did not tackle the job in the first instance and did not carry out essential repairs.

Senator Fitzgerald referred to window frames, door frames and floors. They will come under the heading of "structure" and will have to be attended to by the local authorities.

Comment on this

In Cork it costs us roughly £450 per cottage to carry out these repairs for vesting. The average is £450 per cottage. There is a lot of cribbing about doors and windows, but I think that with £450 being paid a good job is being done. I am glad that the Minister has brought in the provision that the local authorities have the right to purchase these cottages before they go on the open market.

Comment on this

I am not satisfied with the Parliamentary Secretary's explanation and I do not think it is correct in many ways. If the position is to remain as it was under the 1936 Act, why then have we such a change in the 1965 Act?

Comment on this

It means nothing.

Comment on this

It must mean something or the change would not be made. I feel very strongly about this because I know a great deal more, perhaps, about labourers' cottages than anyone here, for the simple reason that I was born and reared in one.

Comment on this

They had no sanitary services.

Comment on this

That is quite correct, and if this Bill is left as it is, they still will not have any sanitary services. I cannot see any cogent reason why we should have such a sensational change, and why we should hand over a cottage under the 1965 Bill in a state of repair which would not be tolerated under an Act passed 30 years ago.

Comment on this

This is a vested cottage?

Comment on this

When the tenant wants to vest his cottage.

Comment on this

Who is the owner?

Comment on this

The tenant, when it is vested.

Comment on this

What about the local authority?

Comment on this

I am not talking about the local authority.

Comment on this

Are we to allow cottages to be bought by every Tom, Dick and Harry?

Comment on this

I think the Senator is confusing this with another section.

Comment on this

I am not confusing it at all. I know well what I am after.

Comment on this

I am talking about cottages vested by the tenants. According to the 1936 Act they must be put in a proper state of repair by the local authority before vesting. If after they are repaired by the local authority, the tenant is not satisfied that they are in a proper state of repair, he has the right of appeal to the Minister. The Minister sends down an inspector and in a very high percentage of cases that inspector has invariably lists of repairs that should have been carried out by the local authority and that now must be carried out by them.

Comment on this

Do they do it?

Comment on this

I think they do not.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with Senator Fitzgerald in his anxiety about this particular section because primarily you are dealing with the local authority engineer. I have had considerable experience in connection with repairs to cottages preparatory to vesting them. The House can accept it that the engineers of local authorities are in all cases prepared to do what is just and reasonable. We find cases, of course, where tenants who are able to have their cottages vested in them whom we think are unreasonable because they expect repairs to be carried out which they would not do themselves and which ordinary householders would not do.

When appeals have been made I feel the county engineers and inspectors of the Local Government Department have leaned over backwards, I might say, towards helping out the tenants. Invariably, the local authority engineers have dealt with this matter very fairly. Although the change may not appear to be necessary, I do not see any danger whatever in it.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Senator Flanagan on that because I never found anybody leaning over backwards so far as the local authority are concerned. I have found that doors and windows are left out. The only person who suffers because of this is the person inside the cottage. Sometimes when they have done some work to the cottage they do not even put back the half door or window.

Comment on this

I should like to support my colleague very strongly in regard to this amendment. I think it is absolutely essential. As I said on Second Stage, this is a most regrettable step backwards. Why does the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary want the change? I know it would be less costly to proceed on the lines on which he is proceeding when vesting. It would be much more costly, when payments have to be made under the health code, to endeavour to cure the results stemming from the effects that will shortly be necessary to ensure that sanitary conditions prevail although the dwelling is structurally sound. Such a dwelling could withstand the elements for hundreds of years thereby causing ill health and disease to succeeding occupants. Surely we want healthy families; not merely families housed in sturdy premises under insanitary health-destroying conditions.

I should like to give a little illustration of a case which might help the Minister to understand what I am getting at, It is perhaps this case which gives me so much anxiety about the step which the Minister proposes to take. I want to ask him to take a good long look at this amendment before he thinks of rejecting it. A young man of my acquaintance developed tuberculosis. His family was very comfortably circumstanced. They lived in a fine, perfectly structured house belonging to the company in which his father was in a senior executive position. In spite of good food and attention this young man's health declined. A long holiday away from home saw a great improvement in his health but when he returned his health declined again.

Three other members of that family developed tuberculosis. I discussed this matter with my late father who was an acknowledged expert in all branches of building and architecture. He examined the house and he said: "It is a fine house but it is a death trap. No one could be healthy and live in that house." He explained at great length what the shortcomings were— among them the fact that the wrong materials in relation to location had been used. These are things which go much deeper than window frames, coats of paint, woodworm or such matters. My father said that the house was in fine structural condition and repair but was completely insanitary and a menace to health.

That young man, aged 21 years, died of tuberculosis. Shortly afterwards the family moved to a house in the suburbs. A daughter already suffering from tuberculosis recovered. Other younger members of the family are today alive and in good health. I hope I can convince the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister of the value of existing legislation and ask him very sincerely not to spoil what good is in the Bill by changing the existing law in this very important matter.

Comment on this

If we do not accept the amendment we will not spoil the Bill at all because I am quite convinced that if a cottage is put into good structural condition it will meet the case. We will try to avoid doing the finicky little jobs that can cost a lot of money. I will give an example of what it can cost to carry out some repairs by the local authorities. In Cork there were some cottages built 27 years ago. The annuity to be paid was £2 12s. 0d. and the cost of repairs carried out to those cottages was £363. The annuity on some houses which were built 50 years ago was £1 1s. 0d. and the cost of repairs carried out by the local authorities was £112. As I say, it is the small jobs which can be very costly.

The Minister feels very strongly about this matter. He feels the tenant should accept some responsibility for the small repairs which need to be carried out. If there is bad flooring in the house it has to be carried out by the local authority. A new roof has to be provided by the local authority. Interior and exterior plastering, new windows and frames have to be provided if the engineer is satisfied that they should be provided. It is the smaller type of job that we feel should be the responsibility of the tenant rather than of the local authority. We still think that the points will be met and that we can get satisfaction with the Bill as it stands rather than by accepting the amendment of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

I cannot for the life of me see why, if there is such gross inefficiency, it should be felt that the Parliamentary Secretary or anybody else should be responsible except the local authority for dealing with this matter. There must be something wrong locally, and instead of coming up here to try to get things changed they should be looked after there. In my county we do not have any of these troubles. Senator Flanagan is much better acquainted with this type of thing, and he has made a somewhat similar statement here already. We require a bit of commonsense in dealing with these things. It must be considered that a great many people to whom we have given cottages are people who had a very bad type of house before, and it is possible that they fail, when they go in there before the houses are vested, to keep them up to normal standards to which they should be kept. We have not this thing in our county, but of course we are a very advanced people down there. A lot of things have been talked about here which make very little sense. If you put a beggar on horseback he will ride to the devil. It is quite possible that it happens because of the way in which we select candidates for housing schemes, that we put people into houses who may require a little more training for that type of house before they are put into them. Afterwards they are not kept to the standard, but who is to blame? Not the local authority but the tenant. The trouble is that the local authority are blamed, and that is unfair.

What are we going to do? Are we going to continue in a circle in which we will paint every door and window, sweep every floor, for everybody going into a local authority house? I do not think we can do it. I do not see any reason why we should draw a line as between the ordinary small farmer in the country who builds and maintains his own house and this type of person put in by us into a local authority house. It is a very unfair division. I do not mind what anybody in the Labour Party says about it. Many of these people who go into our houses are much better off than the people who have to build their own houses with an ordinary grant and have to maintain them. I do not think that there has been a fair return. As far as we in the west are concerned— Senator Flanagan will bear me out on this—our county council are perfectly fair to these people and will go a long way out of its way to try to ensure that their houses are right. We do not ask them to vest them until the cottages are right, but after that we feel that they should put in their own doors and windows, tiles and slates and whatever else they have to put up. After that they should keep them in a reasonable condition. I want to say quite clearly that we do not use any compulsion but they do get it right.

Comment on this

I find it difficult to believe that the people in the west or in any part of Ireland are as backward as the previous speaker would have us believe they are. However, in Laois at any rate, they do not fit the description he painted. I wish to support this amendment because I believe that the tenants have a right to expect repairs, especially vesting repairs, but in many councils in the midlands with which I am acquainted the backlog of repairs is indeed regrettable. I find that it is necessary to have this particular section as strongly worded as possible in the interests of the tenants. For that reason I strongly support the amendment.

Vesting repairs certainly cause a problem. It is quite true that many of the tenants enjoy houses with very small rents. Nevertheless, the cottages in many instances are both old and small, and after vesting it gives the tenant an opportunity of availing of the grants and building on. It is imperative that the cottage should be handed over in a reasonable state of repair to the tenant. I am in favour of the vesting system because it gives people an opportunity of being proud of their own houses and gives them the value of the ownership of property, and the great improvement in the standard of cottages all over the country is admirable. Yet my sympathies are with the people who seek repairs. It is extraordinary to find that in many cases the weaker members of the community, the elderly people, who seek vesting repairs very often are complaining about a door being draughty or decayed and you will find contractors replacing them with a worse one, perhaps from another cottage. That happens over and over again. It is important for members of the county councils to keep on the track of all these things, especially since the money allocated for vesting has in most cases been restricted over the past few years. The people who are tenants, whether they are council houses or not, are entitled to have them put in a proper state of repair before they vest.

Comment on this

I am fully behind the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary in this matter of finicky repairs. Finicky repairs, or the need for them, should not arise. I am behind Senator Lenehan in that. I would like to see our people educated so that they would be proud of their houses, and painting the doors and windows, seeing that the doors do not fall into disrepair and that hinges are oiled, but for the life of me I cannot see how good sanitary conditions could be called finicky. Finicky repairs by no stretch of the imagination could come under the definition of sanitary conditions. It has nothing to do with sanitary conditions. I have a great deal of experience of the building industry and I do not see that painting doors, mending windows, correcting draughty doors and that kind of thing could be described as having anything to do with sanitary conditions of the premises by any stretch of the imagination. As I have said, I am fully behind the Minister. No Government Department, no local authority should have to do the little things one would do if one had built a house and owned it and was proud of it.

I should like to know why the Minister dropped the words "and sanitary condition"—what he calls finicky repairs. I should like to hear the Parliamentary Secretary relate finicky repairs to sanitary conditions. I see no connection. Sanitary science is taught in the building industry. It is looked upon as an important part of the training of architects and of people in charge of building construction. Sanitary science has always been looked upon as a very important and serious thing and I can assure the Seanad that sanitary science never dealt with finicky repairs.

Comment on this

It is a pity we have wasted so much time in discussing this matter. There is no difference between what is in the Bill and what was in the Act.

Comment on this

Why the change then?

Comment on this

Time and again we have changed terminology and commented on it. To my mind, the present wording is far more satisfactory than the previous wording. You can have good structural conditions without structural repair. Repair means defects. The present wording is more satisfactory.

Comment on this

Good repair and sanitary conditions.

Comment on this

I know as much about cottages as anybody and as far as I know there is no such thing as sanitary services in cottages. Some of them may have been built close together and they may now have sanitary services, sewerage and water supplies. They are not in the cottages I know. Do we mean by sanitary conditions that there must be wallpaper on the walls?

Comment on this

We are wasting the time of the Seanad in discussing it. I repeat that the wording in the Bill is much more satisfactory. We are wasting time discussing a finicky thing.

Comment on this

We accept the Parliamentary Secretary's word that in the near future there will be no such thing as a house without water and sewerage.

Comment on this

No new houses, certainly.

Comment on this

When all the new houses have been put up, the old houses can then be dealt with. When we have got all houses with sewerage and water supplies we shall still have a Bill that omits sanitary conditions. A house with all the amenities could still be a very insanitary house. It could have damp walls even if they were structurally perfect. They could be houses without damp courses. Wrong materials could have been used. While we give the Minister full credit for providing that no new house will be without toilet accommodation and water, we ask why he wants to leave out sanitary conditions.

Comment on this

I should like to support the amendment. One of the big problems of the local authorities is to get tenants to vest. Local authorities want to get the houses off their hands. Speaking from experience of my own county only, we hope in the course of the next few years to arrive at the maximum number of vestings with only isolated cases where vesting would not be practicable. The main reason why so many tenants in my county are vesting is because we are doing a first-class job of repair to houses before vesting. When a house is vested, if the occupier is not thoroughly satisfied he can appeal to the Minister, an inspector will come and see whether further repairs are necessary.

There are very old houses in the county which cost more to repair than they cost to build but they have to be brought up to the standard Senator Miss Davidson spoke about. It is unfair and unreasonable to ask people to accept less when they are vesting. It is costing the ratepayers a sizeable amount of money but it is money well spent. Having taken over a well-repaired house, structurally sound, sanitary serviced, people are proud of their houses and make every effort to keep them that way. We have had example after example of this. Any attempt to change that system will not be for the benefit of the local authorities or the people concerned.

Comment on this

The house a tenant seeks to vest is the house in which he has been living, the house for which he has been paying rent. He knows the condition of the house. No amount of work that can be done will repair damp courses in houses which did not have damp courses from the beginning and no amount of work will make a house up to the point where it satisfies a tenant who wants to be unreasonable. I have had experience of this.

Ninety per cent of the cottages in Mayo have been vested and the remaining ten per cent are not vested because the tenants have chosen to be unreasonable. It may be over a crack in the ceiling. The ordinary occupier will agree it is something that cannot be repaired but an unreasonable tenant will say he wants a new ceiling. If sanitary services are put into old cottages there must be a change of rent. The expenditure is taken into account and a new rent must be fixed for the cottage. I repeat that a cottage vested is a cottage in which the person has lived for a number of years. Everything reasonable will be done. Any defects—timbers, flooring, windows, doors and door frames—are invariably put in. I do not think Senators on the other side need be so uneasy. We are dealing with professional people who are anxious to do the right thing as between the tenant and the ratepayer.

Comment on this

This amendment is not put down to help the people who want to get finicky repairs done. We all realise that there are many unreasonable people in the country, some of them living in labourers' cottages. The Parliamentary Secretary mentioned a cottage which cost £363 to repair which was set at an annuity of £2 12s., approximately 1/- a week. If that cost £363 to repair there are two reasons why it could have fallen into that state. Firstly, the occupier could have been a very bad tenant, but, secondly, you could have a reasonably good tenant in that house, and because the local authority in question did not make any attempt to keep the house in repair for a long number of years the result was, when the tenant went to vest his house, the local authority found it was in a very bad state of repair. Therefore, after many years they went to repair that house knowing they would be vesting it at 1/- per week.

The Parliamentary Secretary mentioned that I need not worry about door or window frames or floor boards. We all know, and I say this with all due respect to Senator Flanagan, who is an engineer and has experience of this, that there are engineers going to labourers' cottages and making out a list of repairs to be carried out and if there are one or two broken boards on the floor they are prepared to take out these two boards and put in new ones, but they are not prepared to put in a new floor.

Comment on this

What would an ordinary ratepayer do in his own case?

Comment on this

I am not concerned with what an ordinary ratepayer would do in his own case. I am specifically concerned with the labourer's cottage the occupier of which is also a ratepayer.

Comment on this

You have two responsibilities — responsibility to the local authority and——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order; Senator Fitzgerald, to continue.

Comment on this

We have also examples of a very bad door in a labourer's cottage and the engineer goes out and says the bottom of the door is bad all right and he sends a carpenter out who cuts two and a half feet off the door and it is repaired. We come to the bigger issues and I agree with Senator Flanagan when he mentions that nothing we put in the Bill will enable anybody to put a damp course in a house already erected. But, there is something we can put in this Bill and which we are now taking out of the law which would enable a tenant to get a damp course put on the roof of his house which was not put there when the house was erected. That has been done to my knowledge. That would be a hefty bill for somebody who would have to vest his house knowing that that house has no damp course under the roof. That was done not long ago. I can mention a specific case and the roof had to be taken off as a result of an appeal to the Department of Local Government and new felt was put under the roof. That was a very important thing for the tenant. That was his right under the 1936 Act but I wonder will he have that right under the 1965 Act if this amendment is not accepted.

Comment on this

I think Senator Miss Davidson and Senator Fitzgerald are looking for a hypothetical law for hypothetical people.

Comment on this

I am looking for a continuation of the old law.

Comment on this

I doubt that anybody has more experience of these things than Senator Flanagan. The same position exists down in Mayo, believe it or not, and we are no different from others.

Comment on this

I thought the Mayo people were different.

Comment on this

I do not know whether we are a more advanced people in Mayo or not but we have not these problems at all. Unfortunately, it is not a question of this Bill alone; it is the same with most Bills going through. I always hear people arguing on a hypothetical basis. Senators here do not argue about how people live in this country. They argue as if people did not exist. We in Mayo bring our houses up to a good standard. The people see the houses before they vest them. They have to sign a document before they vest and nobody is so completely daft as to sign the document unless he is satisfied beforehand.

Deputy Flanagan said there were ten per cent not vested. I do not think that is right. I would say that it is two per cent. Senators opposite should examine their conscience in the light of this fact. It is all right to say that the Minister is introducing some type of law that will make things difficult for tenants. We have bent forward several times to help our tenants. The unfortunate thing coming out here is that you are trying to brand local authorities and landlords with making a profit. We should have commonsense. We are giving these people houses at a price that is unknown in any part of the world. We should be reasonable and fair and I do not think Senators opposite are.

Comment on this

I agree thoroughly with Senator Lenehan that local authorities have been operating fairly, that in Mayo they are advanced and that cottages are repaired to the satisfaction of reasonable people taking possession of them. All we are asking is that the same position will continue, that the same authority and direction to the local authority will continue under this legislation as heretofore. I am saying that good repairs and sanitary conditions should continue, and not be altered. Senator Flanagan has wide experience in this matter. He told us that the local authority engineers and the local authorities themselves operate this reasonably and there are no complaints. We agree. We are only asking that that position should continue, that it should not be changed and that we should not proceed to give different directions to the local engineers and local authorities. I think we have general acceptance all round and that is a proper and good thing.

This is an amendment to a section but it is a section in a whole Housing Bill. I presume it is the wish of the House to try to improve the housing conditions of all our people. If I am purchasing a house, the local authority and Government Departments inspect that house and make sure that I, as an ordinary purchaser, will get a house that is in a proper condition. I do not know what the definitions are but I make quite sure that I will get a good house.

We are talking about the tenants of local authorities. They are entitled to this protection when they are purchasing a house which forever after they will maintain in good order and condition because it will be their own property. They should continue to be treated as they have been treated. That is, the cottage should be in good repair and there should be good sanitary conditions. An argument has not been made, I suggest, for altering that position by changing those directions.

We were told that there is some argument about cost. In other words, we will save on these people. I do not agree with that. We should continue to treat them as we have been treating them and the words and the direction in this respect should remain as they have been, and we are sure they have operated fairly in Mayo and other counties.

Comment on this

The position has been clarified somewhat as far as this question of good repair and sanitary conditions go. We find now in the case made for it that it does not necessarily follow that we have to have flush toilets. Under the 1936 Act we had no such things. Senator Miss Davidson made a point about such things as ground damp. This comes up through the walls because no damp course was provided. This is something which is happening in houses erected 50, 60, 70 or 80 years ago. What can we do about it? Can you put a damp course in now? We would not have been able to put in a damp course under the 1936 Labourers Act either so where does one go from there in regard to that part of the section which deals with sanitary conditions? Damp is what we are getting at here.

Comment on this

Modern techniques can control damp, even without a damp course, to a very great extent.

Comment on this

Not very effectively, I am afraid. I have tried it myself on a number of occasions and it is not that easy. At the same time, under the 1936 Labourers Act we had some old council cottages which did not have this facility. Yet the tenants were prepared to vest them if they were replastered inside.

Comment on this

But they can still be replastered under this Bill. If a tenant wishes to vest his cottage he calls for an engineer who comes along and finds, maybe, that the plaster work three feet from the floor is damp; he recommends that the plaster be removed and the wall replastered. It can be done by patchwork. That was the position under the 1936 Labourers Act. It would still be the same position under this Bill.

Senator J. Fitzgerald talked about felt on a roof. Fifty years ago they did not put any felt on roofs.

Comment on this

I was talking about a house built less than 50 years ago.

Comment on this

What happens where the house was erected when felt was not in use for that purpose and instead of felt you had rendering underneath the slates which has since fallen away? Do you think we should now put on felt?

Comment on this

If section 106 means what the Parliamentary Secretary is telling us it means, we will have to do that.

Comment on this

It would still be structurally sound. Would it not happen in any house built over the last 40 or 50 years? In the case of houses built in the 1930s felt had to be placed on the roof underneath the tiles and some contractors, I take it, got away with it, took the chance that the engineer was not around and subsequently somebody found out. It was the responsibility of the local authority to see that the job was done in the first instance. Bad supervision caused the local authority this added expense and they would be obliged to incur it.

As far as putting a house in good sanitary condition is concerned, the wording of the present Bill will be as effective as the 1936 Labourers Act. The only addition is that we find, on appeal, that while there might be one major item the rest of them are all cracked panes of glass, one knob missing on the door and tenants expect the local authority to provide these things. Our engineers try to lean over backwards to meet the wishes of the tenants. While I said earlier that 70 per cent of the people who appeal get the important work done, the other items are excluded. Senator J. Fitzgerald made this point and rightly so. I knew cases where a council engineer would decide to put in three or four floorboards. The tenant might feel there should be three or four more but there is nothing to stop the tenant appealing against that decision and getting the work done if he has a case to make and if there is justice in his case. Again, we have the right of appeal to the Minister under this Bill, so we are quite satisfied that the wording of the Bill, as it is, meets the case and that it will as far as the tenant is concerned. His interests will be looked after just as well as they were under the 1936 Labourers Act.

Many appeals are lodged with the Department for cracked panes of glass or a lock on an internal door which should, in the normal course of events, be the responsibility of the tenant. Most of these cases, of course, are turned down but, all in all, we feel that the wording of the Bill will meet these cases and we are quite happy about it.

Comment on this

I want to emphasise that we are not putting down this amendment so that those unreasonable people can have those little repairs the Parliamentary Secretary has mentioned carried out. We know that is unreasonable. We know these unreasonable requests have been made to the Department, to local authority engineers and local authority representatives but this is something we have got to live with and about which we have got to be as broadminded as we can. This amendment is put down to ensure that we will continue to treat tenants vesting their cottages in the same way as they would have been treated under the 1936 Labourers Act. As I pointed out, this Act, passed over 30 years ago was advocated for a very long time by a Cottage Tenants' Association. Senator Dr. Ryan will be able to name the Minister for Local Government in the Fianna Fáil Government who introduced it. The section I quoted from that Act was a very useful one. The changes, to my mind, are drastic. It is very obvious that this is an attempt to discourage people from making appeals to the Department of Local Government because there is another change in this, which has not been mentioned by anybody and which I intend to mention now. It is that not alone has there been a change in the Act whereby you must within 21 days write in to the Minister making an appeal against repairs carried out by your local authority but now it must be accompanied by a fee which will be specified by the Minister for Local Government. When the fee is specified it may mean that that will again help to discourage a person from appealing to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Tá 24
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is proposed to take amendments Nos. 48, 54 and 55 together.

Comment on this

The purpose of this amendment is to enable a body performing a function on behalf of the Minister where a housing authority have failed to carry out such function to prosecute an offence where necessary. It follows that if a body is to be empowered to carry out such functions in certain circumstances it must also be enabled to prosecute offences committed in connection with the performance of the functions. For example, if the National Building Agency were required to discharge a local authority's functions in regard to overcrowded and unfit property it would need the power to prosecute.

Comment on this

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:

In subsection (2), line 47, to delete "shall" and substitute "shall not" and in line 48 to delete "also".

I hope that the Parliamentary Secretary will consider accepting this amendment which is somewhat different from the proposal I made on Second Stage. It is designed to permit a tenant member of a housing authority to exercise his vote in so far as it relates to rates and dwellings even where his own house is part of a collective scheme but the withdrawal of his right to vote where a proposal concerns his personal dwelling and rent only. It seems rather unfair that such a tenant should be prevented from voting when a resolution on a question arises concerning the whole scheme in which he might be one of several hundred tenants.

Comment on this

I am afraid we are not prepared to accept the amendment because we feel that a local representative should not be in a position to vote for something in relation to which he may himself be a beneficiary. I am not quite sure if I got the point made by the Senator but I think I know what she is trying to get at. A councillor could vote, for instance, to allow rents to be increased in a housing scheme which would be outside his own electoral area.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. If his cottage was one of a fairly large scheme of cottages and there was a proposal to raise or lower the rents of the whole scheme, it would be unfair if he was not permitted to take part in that collective voting. We would be prepared to concede, if the rent under discussion was his own personal rent, the withdrawal of his vote in those circumstances. I pointed out, on Second Reading, that if a number of tenants lived in a scheme of this nature they would be prevented, as the law stands at the moment, from voting on a proposal to raise the rents whereas another councillor who might be the local publican or the local millowner could vote for the raising of the rents. He would have a beneficial interest in the rents, going up for the simple reason that if they went up his rates could go down substantially. This is unfair discrimination. As I say, we would concede that he should be stopped from voting on his own personal rent but we still think he should be able to vote on the collective scheme perhaps even of raising the rent in the whole scheme but not of his own personal house.

Comment on this

Would not the decision of a collective scheme affect him if he was a tenant?

Comment on this

Yes, to a small degree.

Comment on this

Therefore, he would be a beneficiary.

Comment on this

Would not the millowner also be a beneficiary?

Comment on this

Do you mean the millowner who is a councillor?

Comment on this

His vote would be of benefit to the whole rent-paying community if the result of his vote was to bring about a saving in the rents.

Comment on this

Yes, but he might be a big ratepayer and save up to £200 a year.

Comment on this

I suppose that could be so but I doubt very much that that would happen. He would want to be a substantial ratepayer.

Comment on this

If he was a millowner he would be a substantial ratepayer.

Comment on this

The worst feature of this section, as I see it, is that it denies a public representative, because of his station in life, he may be of the working class, to play his full part on a local authority to which he was elected. That is the first and most serious objection I have to the section. The fixing of the rents of cottages is primarily a managerial function. The manager in most cases will determine what that rent may be and a local authority who may feel that the manager is laying it on and charging what they feel is an excessive rent may pressurise the manager into reducing the rent somewhat. The local authority as such will find it very difficult to get the manager to agree to accept a rent if he feels that it is not an economic one. There is nothing wrong in anyone who is about to become a tenant of an isolated cottage—the Parliamentary Secretary and those in the rural areas will know what I mean—being precluded from fixing the rent because he is going in as a beneficiary, but if we come to the terrace or scheme of houses that may be allocated by the county council and the council member is getting one of those houses it is wrong to deprive that public representative of the right to play his part in the fixing of a rent for the entire terrace, because even if he were not getting one of those houses himself his brother or his sister might be getting one, and in that way he would be playing an equally important part as if he were fixing the rent of the terrace and had been appointed tenant of one himself. There does not seem to be much sense in the section, but what I take strong exception to the section for is that it deprives an elected public representative of his right to play his full part on the local authority because he happens to be a member of that section of the community who would be entitled to be housed by a local authority.

Comment on this

It does not necessarily have to be confined to members who are tenants. No man can vote himself a contract for the county council. The councillor who is a contractor for the supply of meat or vegetables or is a building contractor cannot vote himself a contract for the council. An employee of the council cannot vote himself an increase in wages.

Comment on this

Under our amendment he would not be able to vote.

Comment on this

This is the principle there for some time. However, if it is acceptable to the Senators, I would ask the Minister to have a look at it between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Thank you very much.

Comment on this

This is a drafting amendment. It inserts the word "or" which was inadvertently omitted in line 18. Without this word the subsection would lose its meaning.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Chair would suggest that amendments Nos. 52 and 53 be debated together, if that is agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

To add to the section a new subsections as follows:

( ) A person voting as a member of a housing authority (or any committee mentioned in section 110) upon any resolution or question which is proposed or arises under sections 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 39, 40, 53, 55, 56, 57, 58, 60, 70, 90 and 97 shall not be deemed to be beneficially interested therein.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:

( ) A person voting as a member of a local authority upon any resolution under section 4 of the City and County Management (Amendment) Act, 1955, relating to sections 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 39, 40, 53, 55, 56, 57, 58, 60, 70, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 90, 97, 98, 106 and 112 shall not be deemed to be beneficially interested therein.

In view of the Parliamentary Secretary's undertaking with regard to amendment No. 50, I will withdraw this amendment, as well, for further debate on Report Stage.

Comment on this

On section 115 generally, particularly after what Senator Fitzgerald has said, I feel that this is one of those cases that people in local authorities and other committees have met before. It is very difficult sometimes to make a decision as to whether a person has a beneficial interest or not. You find those cases mentioned by Senator Fitzgerald where you have a relation, perhaps a distant relation, and how far out are you going to go with relations to know where the representative has a beneficial interest in the vote or not? I am not quite sure that we could not come to some arrangement where the authority or whatever it may be could by unanimous decision decide that the person was entitled to vote. It is practically impossible to put down in rules what we want to do because you will always get a difficult case to decide. If it is going to be left to the individual to make the decision it might be very embarrassing to him and to his constituents. If it is left to the Chairman it will be equally embarrassing to him. It should be left, perhaps, to the local authority itself, that it could decide by either a two-thirds majority or by a unanimous decision in any case like this where it was doubtful whether the person had a beneficial interest or not. Even in cases where perhaps the person himself was gaining some benefit but the whole feeling of the council or other authority was that he should be allowed by a majority or a unanimous decision of those at the meeting to vote or otherwise as they thought fit, then this would be a solution. It is an impossible question for the Chairman or the person himself or anybody to draw the line.

Comment on this

I am not at all happy either, about this section. There are very few instances in which a member of any county council will have an opportunity of voting for anything that will benefit itself with the possible exception of fixing a rent. Somebody mentioned contracts, but the placing of contracts, as most members know, is a managerial function and, therefore, does not come before the county council as such. For that reason I feel that it is wrong to debar members of a local authority in any way. After all, the number of public-spirited men and women prepared to give a considerable amount of their time in this voluntary public service is limited enough without putting in these restrictions, because of the fact that the only case I can see when members of a local authority would have an opportunity of being involved is in the case where a member is a tenant of the council and the council is fixing rent for his particular house or housing scheme. Members of a local authority are not eligible to tender for supplies to our institutions, therefore it would not arise in cases of that kind.

Perhaps the Bill would be better without this entire section. On the other hand, even when the council are getting down to fixing a rent for a member who is a tenant and his neighbour knows that he is a member of the council, and the council decide to fix the rent and his name does not appear in the local paper as being for or against it, it is very harmful to that individual member, because people will not understand that he was statute barred from taking part and will think that he was shirking his duties and responsibilities. In all, section 115 is one that will not help individual members of our county councils throughout the country, and for that reason it is a pity that it should be left in the Bill, because the amount of abuse this section will get in the years ahead or similar instances in past years are, indeed, very few, if any, at all. Since the Parliamentary Secretary was good enough to say that they would have another look at it, perhaps he would go further and consider dropping the entire section altogether.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot go that far, tonight anyway. I have indicated that I shall ask the Minister to have another look at it. I am quite sure he will note the points made by Senators.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 54 and 55 to this section have already been debated.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The amendments to section 121 have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this