We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–236 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Livestock Marts Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 13 of 1967 ›

The Chair suggests that amendments Nos. 1, 5, 6, 10, 13, 36, 37, 41, 43, 44, 47, 48, 49, 53 54, 55, 56 and 57 be taken together.

Comment on this

I am afraid I must ask you, Sir, to speak those numbers a little more slowly.

Comment on this

The Chair has spoken.

Comment on this

Would you oblige the House by repeating the numbers, Sir?

Comment on this

The Chair wishes to inform the House that the Senators involved in these amendments have been informed of the suggestion.

Comment on this

Five minutes ago.

Comment on this

Once again, the amendments are: Nos. 1, 5, 6——

Comment on this

I can deal with them slightly faster than that.

Comment on this

Nos. 1, 5, 6, 10, 13, 36, 37, 41, 43, 44, 47, 48, 49, 53, 54, 56 and 57.

Comment on this

Thank you, Sir.

Comment on this

The suggestion is agreed?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

It is understood that the decision on No. 1 will govern the decision on the rest?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes.

SECTION 1.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 1:

To delete lines 13 to 16 and substitute "‘livestock mart' means a place constructed or reconstructed for the sale of livestock by auction".

The point raised here is one which I, indeed, mentioned on the Second Stage as an example of the way in which the drafting of the Bill could be improved in Committee and you will recall that I asked the Minister for an assurance that he would be willing to consider on their merits amendments put forward to improve the Bill and would be prepared to accept them if it could be shown that they would, in fact, have that effect.

In this instance, the wording of the definition "business of a livestock mart" is extremely cumbersome and as a result of its cumbersomeness, an effect is produced which seems to be unintended. At least, I would be surprised if it were intended and I would be surprised if the Minister claimed that it was intended. The definition, as you will see, a Chathaoirleach, is "business of a livestock mart" means two things — the business of selling livestock by auction—that is the first thing — or the business of — words understood—providing a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction, "providing" being modified by the clause "for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise".

The crucial words to which I direct your attention are, "business of a livestock mart" means the business of providing a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. That is one of the two things which "business of a livestock mart" can mean.

It seems to me that this is unnecessary, first of all, because what the Minister wants to do is to regulate the carrying on of the business of livestock marts. I do not understand, although I am quite prepared to hear him on this, why he would want to regulate the business of providing livestock marts as distinct from the business of running them. It may very well be that various organisations exist or could exist for the purpose of providing livestock marts to be leased out and run by other people. The Minister's concern, and it is, as I said on Second Reading, a proper concern, is for the proper running of those marts by the people concerned with their running I am, therefore, puzzled as to the need for this particular reference but perhaps the Minister might be able to indicate that he has some reason for this and on this I should like to hear him.

What bothers me, however, is that as a result of the insertion of this phrase here, the rest of the Bill becomes very cumbersome indeed in drafting and in one respect at least it makes nonsense because if you relate this definition in section 1 to section 2 (1), you find that the effect of the extension of the definition to this second alternative is to introduce the regulation of livestock marts to the place at which a business is carried on of providing livestock marts. That is to say, that if you have a group, perhaps, with headquarters in Dublin or somewhere else, whose interests involve the establishment of livestock marts throughout the country, financing the building of them and then leasing them out to another group to run, then the effect of section 2 (1) is to extend the regulations of this Bill, not to these livestock marts which will, of course, be covered by the first alternative of the definition, but to the offices in Dublin of the company providing the marts.

I doubt very much if this was intended. Indeed, when one reads later on in the Bill the kind of thing the Minister wishes to regulate, including matters of hygiene, it is pretty obvious the he is not seeking to regulate the headquarters in Dublin, Cork or anywhere else, of groups providing livestock marts and yet this is the effect of the combination of the second alternative part of the definition and section 2 (1), which says:

A person shall not carry on the business of a livestock mart at any place unless there is for the time being a licence in force in respect of that place.

Applying to the words "business of a livestock mart" in that clause the second part of the definition, the wording you then get is:

A person shall not carry on the business of providing a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction at any place——

shall not carry on that business at any place

——unless there is for the time being a licence in force in respect of that place.

The effect of the Bill, therefore, is to require that the offices of any group providing livestock marts shall themselves be licensed as livestock marts even though they may be a backroom or a group of front rooms in a building in Dublin all, evidently, not used as livestock marts.

It is quite clear that the Minister did not intend this. I take it he does not propose to issue licences or does not wish to be involved in issuing licences for such offices, to license them as marts and to inspect the hygiene of them. This is not his intention; yet, this is the effect of the loose drafting here and is the effect, in particular, of introducing this second and, I think, unnecessary alternative in the definition section, unnecessary for what the Minister seeks to achieve. Indeed, as I said on Second Reading, one has sympathy with some of the objects of the Bill. Even if one may object to the timing of its introduction, the way it is being pressed or some of the contents of the Bill, the need for some Bill of this kind exists. Nevertheless, one does not accept readily that this is what the Minister wants to achieve or that it is appropriate that he should achieve it.

Therefore, I went through the Bill with some care and have proposed the series of amendments, the first of which is the critical one, others being consequential. The purport of the amendment is to define "business of a livestock mart" much more narrowly and specifically by deleting lines 13 to 16 and by virtue of the amendment proposed here, "livestock mart" is defined rather than "business of a livestock mart" because what the Minister seeks to do, if I understand correctly what he said on Second Reading, is to regulate livestock marts to ensure that they are run properly, both as regards the business side and as regards matters like hygiene, and to ensure the efficient running of livestock marts in the public interest. It is not so much the business of the livestock mart as the livestock mart as a place, the Minister is trying to get at. In fact, the word "place" keeps recurring in the Bill and it is in the Bill because of the cumbersomeness of this initial definition, because the Minister has sought to define, not a livestock mart, which would make the whole Bill much simpler, but the business of a livestock mart.

My amendment proposes to define "livestock mart" rather than "business of a livestock mart" and to define it as a place, thereby getting at what the Minister is trying to get at, the regulation of these places. My amendment and the consequential amendments throughout the Bill will simplify the Bill and get over this anomaly, an unintended anomaly, I am sure, by virtue of which, as the Bill is now drafted, the Minister would be obliged to license offices of groups who are in the business of providing livestock marts.

I do not see that the Minister has any alternative, under the Bill as drafted, but to issue licences in respect of these headquarters premises of groups involved in providing livestock marts. Any such group would be in contravention of the law as drafted here if the premises from which its operations of providing livestock marts were not licensed by the Minister. Therefore I should like to ask the Minister if it is proposed to license such headquarters premises. If it is, then well and good, but it seems a very odd procedure, and I think he ought to tell us why he thinks it necessary to license offices of this kind for the purpose of hygiene and so on.

If the Minister does not propose to issue licences in respect of these headquarters premises, then it is essential to amend the Bill; otherwise, any group who wish to carry on the business of providing livestock marts will find it impossible to do so, as no matter where they have their place of business for this purpose, they will not be operating within the law without a licence.

Perhaps the Minister would tell us why he has included the second phrase. Is there some reason which has not occurred to me for extending this regulatory system to the place of the business of providing livestock marts and, if so, does he intend to issue a livestock mart licence in respect of this place of business? If not, how does he propose that such a firm should carry on business legally?

In the various amendments I have put down, I have tried to carry through the logic of the point I am making, and to point out all the changes that would be required as a consequence of the change I am proposing. I think these changes are needed, and I hope the Minister will meet me on this point and that he will explain how this particularly odd terminology has got into the Bill.

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

The whole purpose of the Bill is to control livestock marts as we understand them and as they are normally operated. However, we must keep in mind the possibility of attempts to circumvent such control. Bearing that in mind, I would say that the Bill and the definition as it is drafted in the Bill is as fair and reasonable as can be devised.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It would help us if the Minister would indicate the kind of evasion he has in mind. I am not familiar with the business of livestock marts and I am not clear how one could evade the control and the running of the mart, which is what the Minister wants to supervise by a procedure of the kind which appears to be envisaged by the wording here. The Minister could enlighten as to what activity he has in mind and what he is trying to cover. There is no point in trying to cover a loophole which the Minister cannot imagine.

I would also ask him to reply to my question as to whether he intends to license as a livestock mart the premises of the headquarters of a group engaging in this kind of business. If it is not so intended, then such a group, as I have said, could have no place within the country in which they could carry on their business legally. If it is a question of a loophole he wishes to cover—and I am thinking on my feet because I was not prepared for the point made by the Minister—then the right way to proceed would be to provide that no one shall carry on with the business of a livestock mart without a licence and, consequently, that the Minister may make regulations of some kind requiring that a licence be issued in respect of these headquarters premises about which we are talking, but to create a situation in which nobody can run this kind of business unless it is licensed as a livestock mart seems nonsensical. Perhaps the Minister would tell us, first, the kind of evasion he has in mind, and, secondly, whether it is his intention that headquarters premises should be licensed.

Comment on this

I do not think what is being discussed at the moment has any relevance to the amendment proposed. In order that I may understand what Senator FitzGerald is getting at, I should like to ask him what he intends in his proposed amendment No. 1, which I do not think has the effect he imagines. I should like to hear from the Senator how he thinks it changes the situation under the existing Bill.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I thought I had explained that. The purpose of the amendment is to apply the system of licensing not to the business of a livestock mart as defined in the present definition section but to the place of a livestock mart. As I said, the word "place" recurs throughout the Bill but "place" in each case has a double meaning. Because of the two-pronged wording of the definition section, "place" in each instance can mean either the livestock mart, the physical place where the sale of livestock is carried on, or it can mean the place of business that may be organising the provision of livestock marts. What I want to do is to eliminate the second meaning because it does not seem to be necessary. It seems to be quite inappropriate that a livestock mart licence should be issued in respect of these premises. I want to get rid of that provision. I hope that clarifies the point and that the Minister will answer the questions I put to him.

Comment on this

No; it does not clarify it very much. The amendment does not give the control or the cover that would be desirable in a case such as this. So far as control is concerned, it would do the job but it could, under this definition as proposed, which is substituting something for that which was already there—at least partly—be open to evasion by a person who had been either refused a licence or had a licence revoked and who would determine that he would carry on business in any case by having temporary pens and a temporary rostrum and all his paraphernalia of a merely temporary kind.

I do not see how "constructed or reconstructed" would cover that sort of situation. Indeed, it would throw one back to the term already used, that is the one which the Senator proposed to abandon, "adapted". That is a word which covers it much better and more securely than the words "constructed or reconstructed". That is one way in which I can visualise this situation developing and I am sure that is something that the Senator does not wish to allow to come to pass and that is the person who has been refused a licence or whose licence has been revoked setting himself up by temporary measures and cocking a snook at the law, while others had to conform to the law and have proper pens and proper equipment in every way.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I can see the Minister's difficulty now. I am sorry I did not understand the point at first. The point he is making arises from the fact that there is a double change in this amendment and what the Minister is concerned about at the moment is not the point I was making in respect of the elimination of the provision in relation to the licensing of the business of providing premises adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. He is concerned about the fact that I have proposed to modify the word "adapted" to "constructed or reconstructed". This was something that was put own in the Dáil. I have not read what was said in the Dáil but my understanding of the purposes of the amendment was that the word "adapt" might not cover—and perhaps on this the Minister could enlighten me—what the Bill proposes to cover as livestock marts.

The word "adapted" in its ordinary use—there may be a lawyer's meaning and a lawyer's view of it—concerns something which existed previously for the purpose but which has been changed and it seems to me to cover "constructed and reconstructed". My fear was that the use of the word "adapted" would not cover a building which was used as a livestock mart in the first instance if it was taken in its ordinary meaning. It may be that legally "adapted" can have a meaning quite the contrary, the meaning of something constructed especially for the purpose. When we talk about adaptation of Irish industry to free trade conditions we do not talk about the widening out of industry and establishing completely new industries but about improving and modifying existing industries so that they can survive in free trade conditions. That is the ordinary meaning of "adapted", adapting something that already exists. I should feel that the wording of the Bill as it is, unless the Minister has very good advice to the contrary on that point and can give legal precedents, would not have the effect that he wishes but would exclude premises built specially for the purpose of a livestock mart many of which exist and which the Minister seems very keen to bring within the framework of this Bill.

This is intended to be taken separately from the main point I was making and I should like to hear the Minister on the main point first. Then we could revert to the point I was making in the first instance from which the Minister has moved away to this other aspect of the amendment.

Comment on this

The term in the Bill is "a place adapted". That could be an open field that a man could adapt. Whether it was by a complete building or part of a building or in some other way made suitable or fit is the meaning of adapted as I understand it. This, applied to a place, could have any of the meanings including "construction or reconstruction" of a building and pens of a temporary nature that could be taken away or anything of that nature which for the time being could be said to have adapted the place or made it suitable or fit for this sort of business. This is the manner in which we see it and the manner in which I have been advised that it covers in a suitable way what we wish to cover in this definition section.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If the Minister is satisfied with that, very well. I must say I have some lingering qualms about it. I think I could see a court ruling that the fact that a building had been constructed ab initio where nothing previously existed did not constitute adaptation, the word “adaptation” meaning a change of some kind in something that had already existed but not something constructed de novo. I am not entirely happy that the Minister is well advised but if the Minister is satisfied that his Bill and his purpose will not be frustrated by the use of the word “adapted” I would not press that point. In the light of what he has said, I am quite prepared on the Fourth Stage to revert to the word “adapted” which he has used and which he says is satisfactory and safe from his point of view.

Having said that, I should like to go back to the first point I was making. Let us, for a moment, assume that the words "constructed or reconstructed" to which he has objected are changed to "adapted". Now, could we deal with the first point I was making? If, in fact, the amendment read: "Livestock mart means a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction," this would rule out the provision of livestock mart licences for the headquarters premises of groups providing livestock marts.

I think the Minister was about to explain what sort of evasion was bothering him. He has mentioned one evasion already, the evasion of temporary arrangements being made which he felt would be encouraged rather than discouraged by using the words "constructed or reconstructed". If we switch, on the Fourth Stage, to "adapted" in this amendment would he explain what kind of evasion that would then in his view in his own text require the addition of the second alternative aspect of the definition which involves the provision of livestock marts licences for these headquarters premises? Does he intend that any groups of this kind which have headquarters premises shall receive livestock mart licences?

Comment on this

The definition in the Bill as we have presented it to the House proposes to control (1) the business of selling livestock by auction irrespective of where it takes place.

Comment on this

Does that include a farm?

Comment on this

Never mind that for a moment. It proposes to control (2) the business of providing a place for such sale or sales designed to circumvent auctioning. That is the essence of this matter.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do not understand that point.

Comment on this

I rather thought that but I am doing the best I can.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

"The provision of a place to circumvent auctioning", what do those words mean? I cannot follow what lies behind that. How could a place circumvent an auction?

Comment on this

The business of providing a place to facilitate the circumvention of auctioning.

Comment on this

A point occurs to me arising out of what both the Minister and Senator FitzGerald have said. It is this: Take a company which is the owner of a livestock mart or, if not the owner, is engaged in the business of selling livestock by auction, that company will have its place of business and that place of business will be its registered office and if it carries on business at its registered office, it seems to me you will have the peculiar situation that the registered office of a company will require to be licensed, as I understand the Bill, because it is carrying on, at its registered office, the business of selling livestock by auction. A peculiar situation will arise with regard to this and it is one which I imagine, has not occurred to the Minister. You have many solicitors' offices and you frequently have accountants' and auditors' offices which are the registered offices of companies. It seems to me that we may find ourselves in the ludicrous position of having to issue a licence to a company in respect of a place where it carries on the business of a livestock mart, the business of selling livestock by auction, that is, at its registered office in an auditor's or solicitor's office.

Comment on this

How can they do that?

Comment on this

If a company is registered, as it has to be, and it frequently happens that it is registered in a solicitor's office, or an auditor's office, or an accountant's office, and carries on the business of selling livestock by auction at its registered office, it seems to me that we are going to have someone applying for a licence in respect of the firm of X, Y and Z, Chartered Accountants, which it does not own, but which is its registered office. The owner of the office may not allow that. He may say: "I do not want to have anything to do with the Minister for Agriculture. I do not want to end up in Mountjoy, or bound to the peace for 12 months, or anything of that kind. Get out." We are then going to have a queer situation.

It seems to me that a registered company that is carrying on at its registered office the business of selling livestock by auction—even if it is only a firm of auctioneers who auction cattle and nothing else, or who auction cattle in addition to other things—may be said to be carrying on the business of a livestock mart because its business is the selling of livestock by auction, and it is inter alia carrying out this business in the company's registered office. It seems to me that we may end up with a situation in which a solicitor's office or an accountant's or an auditor's office, will have to be registered also for carrying out the business of a livestock mart. It will not be a case of a pig in a parlour, but a pig in a solicitor's or accountant's office.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I support what Senator O'Quigley has said. The point about a solicitor's office or an accountant's office was one I was going to make. I want to go back to what the Minister said before to see if I understood it correctly. It seems to me that the point he is making is that the selling of livestock by auction at licensed places is covered in the Bill. I should like to put it to him that my amendment has the same effect. There is no question, as I understand my own amendment, of in any way enabling this business of selling livestock by auction to be carried on anywhere else, because if my amendments to section 2 (1) were accepted the section would read:

A person shall not carry on the business of a livestock mart unless there is for the time being a licence in force in respect of that livestock mart.

The whole business of a livestock mart could only be carried on at a place where there is a licence in force in respect of it. It seems to me that I have covered the point there. If the Minister feels that my amendments would open up the possibility of selling livestock other than at licensed places, that is something we could consider on Report Stage. I think it is covered by the wording there.

I want the Minister to reply to Senator O'Quigley's point about the wording of the Bill requiring that the office of any company which provides livestock marts must be licensed as a livestock mart. I want to direct the Minister's attention to that point, and I want him to deal with it and answer it, and say what his intentions are with regard to solicitors' and accountants' offices, and whether he intends to license them as places where the business of a livestock mart is carried on under this Bill.

So far, the Minister has made several points which seemed reasonable in themselves, but they are peripheral and relate to the wording of the amendment which could be modified on Report Stage. He has not directed his mind, or at any rate has not directed his words, towards the point we are making. Assuming that any of the points he has made can be put through a tightening-up operation on Report Stage, I would ask him to give us his interpretation of the Bill in this respect, and to tell us his intention with regard to the licensing of these offices.

Comment on this

I cannot subscribe at all to the last suggestion made. Reduced to simple terms, it means that some cattle mart company in Thurles or Clonmel, which has its registered office in an accountant's office in Dublin, is carrying on the business of selling cattle by auction in that accountant's office in Dublin.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

No. It is carrying on this business by providing a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction.

Comment on this

Surely an accountant's office in Dublin is not a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

"Business of a livestock mart" is defined in the Bill as "the business of selling livestock by auction or providing... a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction". An accountant's office could be the registered headquarters of a company whose business is providing a place.

Comment on this

I find it very difficult to understand this. Do I understand that the point is in regard to a hypothetical company in Dublin which is building livestock marts?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Providing them.

Comment on this

Is it running livestock marts or building livestock marts?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

With respect to the Senator, it is what the Minister means by "providing".

Comment on this

I listened to Senator FitzGerald and Senator O'Quigley but, with the best will in the world, I was unable to make out what the point is. Are they talking about a company building livestock marts or about a company running livestock marts.

Comment on this

I may help Senator Yeats on this. "Business of a livestock mart" means the business of selling livestock by auction. If the company has a registered office, which it must have, it carries on this business at that registered office. That may not necessarily be the physical location of the office.

Comment on this

We do not intend to license solicitors' offices, accountants' offices, or any other such offices for the purpose of carrying on the business of a livestock mart. We do not envisage the holding of auctions in them. Neither do we envisage stock physically confined in such business premises, premises in which solicitors, accountants, and so on, carry on business. I am sure the Senator will accept that that is not the intention and that such a provision would not be contained in this Bill by this or any other Minister. That is the first question Senator Garret FitzGerald wants answered.

I am not quite sure what the second was, but I presume the intentions defined here in this Bill are as clear to the Senator as they are to everybody else. As I said, the Bill is designed to bring about a certain amount of control in relation to the normal processes of the livestock mart business. In having such control, it is necessary to take particular care that those who would circumvent that control will not be enabled to do so. That is, I think, a reasonable approach. I doubt if there is any Senator here, including those who have spoken in support of their own amendment, who would wish us to put through an amendment here which would bring into licensing control all those marts that are being run properly and that will continue to be run properly. If they improve their premises from the point of view of layout, structure, amenities and facilities, I am sure no one would suggest that, as a result of a decision here, all that should be brought under licensing, while, at the same time, enabling others who would not wish to conform to find a way out and run unlicensed establishments at no loss to themselves but to the loss of those who are actually conforming, who are doing a good job and who wish to continue doing it.

These are the two ways in which we have got to look at a measure such as this. If we are having licensing, we must ensure that we bring all those who are participating in the business within the confines of our jurisdiction and not only that but must make sure that others who wish to remain outside the jurisdiction are not facilitated in doing so by us. It is from that double standpoint one arrives at definitions such as this, definitions designed to make sure that both ends are covered. The legal advice I have is that this section does that in the best way and I cannot really add anything to the knowledge and experience of my legal advisers and of those engaged in drafting over the years.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

First of all, it would appear to me that the Minister holds that the Cork Co-operative Mart is not carrying on its business, which is the business of selling livestock by auction, at the place where they hold their board meetings. This is a very dubious legal point.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, that is not what I said. I said I had no intention of licensing under the Livestock Marts Act, when it becomes law, any such places as solicitors' or accountants' offices.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I was drawing a logical conclusion from the statement made by the Minister. It seems to me that, if he does not license them, that can only be because he believes that at such places the business of a livestock mart is not being carried on. I put it to the Minister that, first of all, the business of the Cork Co-operative Mart is the business of selling livestock by auction, as I understand the operations of that firm, and, secondly, that firm is carrying on its business at whatever place the board meets. I would ask the Minister to state which, if either, of these two propositions he favours?

Comment on this

I have no argument for either. They have no relevance to what is in the Bill.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If the business of Cork Co-operative Mart is the business of selling livestock by auction and if they are carrying on their business vis-á-vis the business of selling livestock by auction where the board meets, then the place where the board meets must be licensed. I think that is a syllogism.

Comment on this

If the Senator wants that, then he should say so, but I have no intention of doing it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What about another Minister?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am not suggesting the Minister ever wanted or intended anything of the kind. I can appreciate he does not want this and he does not intend to do this, but this is an unintended effect of the Bill, as drafted, and I am quite clear as to what is intended and I am quite clear that this is the effect of the Bill, as drafted, and I have put to the Minister a syllogism, the logic of which I defy him to disprove. That is an appropriate method of debate. The Minister having said he accepts both propositions, there is no other conclusion than that the place where the board meeting is held is the place where the company is carrying on its business and the business of the company is selling livestock by auction and a fortiori, then that place must be licensed or else the board cannot meet. The Minister says he agrees with that. He should explain how one does not follow from the other.

The second point is a separate point raised by Senator O'Quigley. I should like the Minister to tell me which place he would envisage as being relevant? You could have a firm whose business is livestock marts, their building, construction and leasing. Such a company might have no other place of business at all other than its registered office. Having built the marts and leased them out, the place of business would be the registered office. What has the Minister in mind? The only places he can license would be the place of business or the registered office. The marts themselves would be licensed to the person carrying on the business there, so that would not arise, and, in those circumstances, the Bill requires that the Minister licenses a place where a firm carries on the business of selling livestock by auction and it seems to me he would be obliged to license them then. Again, I think we deserve an answer.

I am quite prepared to put forward amendments to my amendment on Report Stage. It would, I think, probably require two amendments to meet the Minister's points and to meet his requirements fully. One is that the word "adapted" be put in instead of "constructed or reconstructed" but, if the Minister is happy with "adapted", then I do not want to interfere with it. Secondly, in the light of my amendment, it may be necessary somewhere in the Bill to say, if this is the Minister's intention, that the business of selling livestock by auction shall be carried on only at legal marts. It is possible that in the form in which I have tentatively suggested amending it that would not emerge as a clear statement. I have been thinking about this and I would be prepared to meet the Minister on that point, if he is worried that my amendment would not meet the position. If I do that, I think the confusion he seems to fear is one which could not arise under the amendment I now propose.

The Minister said that the Bill is designed to prevent livestock being sold by auction anywhere except at a licensed place. I understand—perhaps I did not follow out the debate fully or properly in this respect—that, in fact, sales of livestock at a farm, for example, after the death of someone, were not covered by the Bill. Is it in fact the case that nobody may sell livestock by auction except at a livestock mart in future? Is that what the Minister intends? He seems to imply that in what he said to me. If that is the case, it will be necessary for me to meet that point in order to ensure that my amendments will not leave room for confusion. Is that, in fact, what the Minister intends? This is an important point. This had not been my understanding of it, but perhaps I did not read the debate with adequate care.

Perhaps the Minister would say if it is his intention that no auction of any kind of livestock will be held except at a livestock mart in future. There may be a working office as well as a registered office but there is no doubt at all that the registered office forms part of the place where the company, the firm of auctioneers, is carrying on its business. There is no doubt at all about that. If somebody wants to address a communication to the company in relation to its business, the proper and certain place to which the letter shall be addressed as provided in the Companies Act, 1963, is the registered office. May I refresh my learned friend's memory on the other side by referring to section 113 of the Companies Act, 1963? At subsection (1) it says:

A company shall, as from the day on which it begins to carry on business or as from the fourteenth day after the date of its incorporation, whichever is the earlier, have a registered office in the State to which all communications and notices may be addressed.

Would it not be the height of folly on the part of the Legislature in 1963 to direct, ordain or enact that communications were to be sent to a company not to a place where it carries on its business or rather to a place where it does not carry on its business? Would that not be the height of absurdity? What it does is it makes certain that a company being a ubiquitous creature, having no fixed abode shall have a fixed abode, that is, its registered office. That is the first starting place from which a company carries on its business. There is no doubt at all that it may also carry on at other offices but the principal place of business and its principal address is the registered office. That being so, we come back to the section. A company, a firm of auctioneers, would be carrying on the business of a livestock mart, if it is engaged in the business of selling livestock by auction and it will do that at the livestock mart itself, at an office in the town near the bank or at its registered office—at all three places; wherever it has an office, it carries on business—and therefore at the accountant's or solicitor's office if they are the registered offices of the company.

Comment on this

When cheques are being lodged at the local bank it is carrying on business there too.

Comment on this

No; that is an absurd and unwarranted intrusion by Senator Nash. That does not arise at all. There is no doubt at all about it wherever it has an office it is carrying on business. Therefore, if it sells livestock by auction it is in the business of a livestock mart and, therefore, under section 2, subsection (1) it will be necessary to license the offices of auctioneers, auditors, solicitors and every other place where the business is carried on.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to clarify for Senator Yeats that I was raising a different point. I had no discussion with Senator O'Quigley on this amendment. He has strengthened my case by pointing out that not alone in respect of the second part of this definition but in respect of the first part a difficulty exists because of the wording of the Bill. My point related to the question of the case of a company providing livestock marts in the sense of constructing them and leasing them out. I realise now, as Senator O'Quigley pointed out, that the same is true as regards the business of selling livestock by auction. You can hardly say the directors of the Cork Cooperative Marts are not carrying on the business of a livestock mart when they meet—as I believe they do—in the solicitor's office which is the registered office of that company for their board meetings. To say that the board of a company when it meets as a board is not carrying on the business of the company would be ludicrous and the Bill requires that when they are carrying on the business of this company that this must be done in places licensed for this purpose under the Bill. Therefore, I would support Senator O'Quigley on his extension of the point I was making but I do want to distinguish the two points. They are separate and I think they have to be considered separately. I feel they are both valid and I would ask the Minister to answer the reasonable questions that I put to him in the first instance on which we still have not heard from him.

Comment on this

The longer we speak on this the more confused we are getting. Surely to goodness the business of selling livestock by auction is not transacted in any place or anywhere except at the auction where the cattle are sold. There it is the business of selling livestock by auction. Can anyone on the other side tell us where in any office in Dublin or Cork is the business of selling cattle by auction transacted? It can only be transacted in the places which the Minister is endeavouring to have suitable. I should like to ask the Minister the position, for instance, of the RDS which carries on sales at present. I presume they would have to be licensed under this Bill.

Comment on this

No, they would be exempted.

Comment on this

Do not answer me, please. I was asking the Minister.

Comment on this

I was trying to be helpful to the Minister.

Comment on this

Sales of cattle in the Dublin Market are carried on in the premises outside the Dublin Market which traditionally have been used down through the years. They are not classified as marts. They are not called marts at any rate but three or four firms have carried on sales down through the years. I presume that under this Bill they would also have to comply with the regulations of an auction mart, though I am satisfied they are never called an auction mart. Those are things that occur to me but it never occured to me that we could raise the question of whether cattle were sold in a solicitor's office.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to answer a question put to me by Senator Ó Donnabháin by putting two questions to him. Is it not the case that the business of the Cork Cooperative Marts is the business of selling livestock? Does Senator Ó Donnabháin negate that proposition? If he accepts that, does he deny that they carry on the business of the company when the board of directors meet and where they meet?

Comment on this

If they meet in a hotel, they would not be carrying on the business.

Comment on this

Indeed, they would.

Comment on this

I will not carry on a conversation such as has been carried on unfortunately.

Comment on this

Senator Ó Donnabháin raised a very interesting point. He referred to the sales in Dublin and he said they were never described as marts. I presume he is referring to Ganleys, Gavin Lowes and Craigies. They were always referred to as sales and I presume that they are not exempt from the Livestock Marts Bill because, in effect, they are livestock marts.

Comment on this

That is the question I was asking.

Comment on this

I want to raise a point on that. They have their offices across the street from these sales yards and where livestock might not be sold in the yard, it is possible the sale might take place along the street——

Comment on this

Let us be quite clear that if you have in the Dublin Cattle Market certain auctioneers carrying on the business of selling livestock by auction they are also carrying on the exact same business of selling livestock by auction when they write out cheques in their office to complete the sales or fill up documents. There is no doubt about it and these are their registered offices.

Comment on this

I did not refer to the sale of cattle in the Dublin Cattle Market and the Senator is irregular in that. It is a different thing entirely.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Oh, yes. I am hoping the Minister will deal with it. I think he was waiting for the general discussion to develop before he spoke on it but I hope he will give his answer before I conclude. I should be glad if the Minister could help us on that point.

Comment on this

I have not said that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Then I do not understand the point the Minister was making.

Comment on this

I do not know what point the Senator is attributing to having been made by me. I am at a loss to know what it is.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I understood the Minister to say that my amendments as drafted would mean that people could sell livestock at some place other than a mart by putting up a stall or some such structure and that it would not be a licensed mart. If it was not a mart you could sell. The Minister is nodding his head, which I take to be agreement that the business of livestock may take place only in a livestock mart.

Comment on this

That is a very logical conclusion.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I would be glad to have that point explained.

Comment on this

Could I possibly relieve the Senator of a great deal of difficulty? He has got around to the point where his amendment could be suitably amended to meet my wishes. This is a hypothesis, that I am in some problem in regard to what I have already there. In fact, I have no such problem. What is already there is quite in keeping with what I want and is quite satisfactory, so far as my legal advisers have been able to advise me. The problem here is that the Senator is trying to find some way around his amendment to what I want. It is clearly defined in the definition section what I want. I have already there what I want.

Comment on this

The Minister is making one mistake on that. This is symptomatic of the Minister's outlook and that of his Party, because if he is happy with what he wants, then he is not concerned about the views of Seanad Éireann. That seems to me to be highly undemocratic. Because he is happy with the Bill, it does not matter what the views of anybody else are, whether that person be on this side of the House or on his own side. I think Senator FitzGerald is right in trying to ascertain what the position is. Since this Bill as drafted, in the main, will be operated by the present Minister for Agriculture, as long as he is Minister for Agriculture, we want to know the extent to which he proposes to go on one side and on the other. I say this quite sincerely as everything else I say quite sincerely. I am not happy with what is contained in this definition. I may anticipate what the Minister has to say. When he has the section exactly as it is drafted, if anybody wishes to consult me, in five minutes I will indicate to them how they can set the whole thing at nought and still use their livestock premises, and not a sin in the world will they commit against this Bill or any other statute.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

OK, so why worry?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

We are here as legislators.

Comment on this

We are here as legislators and it is in that capacity I am speaking. I can assure the House that this measure which has been so hastily conceived can be as hastily set aside. All one wants to know is a little about the Sale of Goods Act and the general law of contract. In no time at all the Minister can revoke old licences or may refuse licences and the owners of those properties can still use their property to exactly the same effect and in exactly the same way without any contravention of the law. There is no court in the world will find anybody guilty of any offence under this Bill.

I am not very much concerned from that point of view. The Minister may be happy with his definition. This is a case where ignorance is bliss and it would be folly from the point of view of those who oppose the Bill if the Minister were wise to what I have in mind. I am concerned that we are getting things a bit confused, as Senator Ó Donnabháin, the great clarifier, has pointed out. I will ask this question and it will be a ‘yes' or ‘no' answer. I think the answer is ‘no'. There is no doubt that the existing fairs will continue and that the existing fairs do not have to be licensed under this Bill. I would be glad if the Minister would say that existing fairs and markets will continue and that there will be no need to license them.

Comment on this

I want an assurance from the Minister on much the same lines. There is in the midlands an old-standing tradition, especially in regard to bacon pigs, by which buyers attend mostly in the yards of publichouses or business premises one day a week or one day a fortnight. They buy pigs either by weight or by hand or submit them to the factory and let them be graded. Those are the three ways in which this business is transacted. I wonder if the owners of publichouses or merchants who only facilitate their customers by allowing the buyers to stand in their premises for the convenience of the farmers in the surrounding area, will be prevented from doing this now. I should like the Minister to give the House an assurance that this business will be allowed to continue and that there will be no need to have licences for the continuance of this long-standing and recognised practice.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I take it that the Minister, by nodding his head earlier, agreed with me. Before we go any further, we must get this straight. It seems it is the Minister's intention that livestock shall not be sold by auction except in premises licensed for the purposes.

Comment on this

Or exempted.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes; that is the Minister's intention in this regard. Does this mean that the sale of livestock which takes place on a farm after somebody dies would require a licence, if there is no exemption?

Comment on this

How many ways have I to say something for the Senator to understand?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am sorry. On several occasions I have not completely understood the Minister and that is why I am being careful in regard to the particular wording. The Minister's intention is to ensure that the sale of livestock by auction shall be carried on in a livestock mart. This is the purpose of the Bill. I can see that my amendments as I have put them down might not quite ensure that. It was not my intention to weaken the Bill in any respect. I wanted to clarify matters and to strengthen the Bill.

I still put it to the Minister that the Bill as worded means that the place or business of an auction mart, which includes the registered offices of such premises, must be licensed and that also when those premises are leased out to people, they also have to be licensed as livestock marts. No other reading is possible under section 2(1) in conjunction with the definition section. I do not think the Minister can take any other meaning out of this when he reads both sections together. The Minister has said it is not his intention to license the registered offices of livestock marts or other places of business provided for livestock marts. The Bill as worded could create chaos in this business because people would not be able to carry on their business by holding their board meetings or by setting up and organising a group to provide livestock marts. They could not get a licence because the Minister has stated he does not intend to issue it, and, under the law as provided, it would be illegal for them to carry on business in those circumstances.

I have, therefore, made the case completely for the amendment of the section. I accept that the amendments as I have worded them are imperfect and would not meet the Minister's legitimate requirements. Nevertheless, I would press on the Minister that he should accept that there is a need for an amendment here and that between now and Report Stage, he should consider how this should be amended. It would be better that the Minister should amend the Bill than that I should set my hand to it further.

I would ask the Minister, in view of the fact that his case has not in any way refuted it, to reconsider this and by an amendment similar, though not necessarily identical, to mine to amend the Bill in this respect between now and Report Stage, so that it will not create this ridiculous situation which in its present form it will create.

Comment on this

The trouble here is that I appreciate Senator FitzGerald's anxiety about getting this Bill proper while at the same time giving my attention to Senator O'Quigley's admonition that the Bill, in fact, as it stands does not matter, that he could advise anybody for a few half-dollars or a few dollars how to obviate the entire impact of the Bill. This brings me to something I do not understand. While appreciating the anxiety of Senator FitzGerald and having given ear to the wise legal advice being threatened rather than offered by Senator O'Quigley, I just cannot, at the same time, reconcile these views with their Party view, which was that Fine Gael are against this Bill in every way they can possibly oppose it. This was the idea. What are they against if Senator O'Quigley says it means nothing? He can show how to get around it. If that is so, what were we doing when the Bill was opposed by Fine Gael line by line and word by word? What are all the 68 amendments about, some of which have come as late as this morning?

Senator FitzGerald is on his own in this matter. He does not belong to the Party. Or is Senator O'Quigley not in communication with the Party? Is it that they do not listen to the advice of the Party as I have been listening?

All this becomes terribly involved and gets away from the content or merit of the Bill. I wonder is the only sane sort of solution one can come to, what all these divergent contradictions from Fine Gael really boil down to, that we are not supposed to deal with the Bill, that we are to have our attention distracted in so many ways that the Bill fades into obscurity? Is this what we are to get from the various fronts presented by Fine Gael, the various faces of Fine Gael, might I say?

This does not help me to accept even on trust some of the things Senator FitzGerald says, or some of the things Senator O'Quigley says, or some of the things some of the other members of Fine Gael say, when I find and detect that these are a Party not only of several faces but of contradictory and opposing ideas as to what this, that and the other word means.

Comment on this

It is the ambiguity of the provision that gives rise to different points of view.

Comment on this

It is difficult to give any weight to the view of any of those who are so obviously anxious to contribute to the improvement of this Bill when they do not seem to agree among themselves. They are opposing each other in their views. They do not tally up in their views, individually or collectively, and I am at a loss to know what to do about the advice of Fine Gael in this matter. It is not possible for anybody to draw a conclusion from this. Obviously, neither the views of the two Senators who have spoken, nor those of the Party as a whole who have been at me for weeks about this Bill, add up. One would think that we are dealing with a completely different document here today from that which we have discussed on a broad basis and at great length with the Fine Gael Party as a whole. Trying to see through all the mists created by these various approaches, possibly explained by what Senator FitzGerald says, that he had not been talking to Senator O'Quigley before he came in here——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

On this amendment.

Comment on this

——on this amendment—this may explain the divergence of views. What Fine Gael are trying to say is still not clarified. But, probably what I am trying to do is so clear and has been said so often that even Senator O'Quigley must at this stage appreciate what is intended. His anxiety and the anxiety of his colleague to try to attribute what has already been said, meaning that it was never intended, or inferred, to the exercise of great imaginations and hallucinations as we described them the other day, is the only way one can begin to understand the contributions of Senators on the Fine Gael Front Bench on this Bill.

I am driven back to where I started, that is, what we intend to do under this Bill. We have it clear enough, provided you give cognisance to the fact that there are commas here and there in this definition section which I am told are there to facilitate the understanding of what is in it. I know I do not have to say this to Senator Garret FitzGerald or to Senator O'Quigley because both of them and particularly Senator O'Quigley, are quite adept at reading not only the commas in certain passages but those that might be left out. They are there for the benefit of those who may glance across the lines in great haste but they do mean something. They are intended to convey something, and having regard to the commas and the words as well, any commonsense sort of person having read it, will get the message. This is so evident that to try to follow the various advices I have been getting would only confuse those who already understand what is in the Bill. I should not like to do this.

I did, I hope, educate many of the Senators' colleagues as to what is in this section. I believe they know and accept what is in it, that they have a full understanding of what is in it, and that any of those little asides that are being thrown in will confuse them. Quite certainly I should not like the Fine Gael Party getting confused as to what is in the Bill because they fought so hard against it that it would be a letdown if it could be shown that they did not know what they were fighting against. Indeed, perhaps, I gave too much credence to the divergent views expressed by Fine Gael and the views of the two Fine Gael front benchers in this House.

We will not be licensing fairs, as Senator O'Quigley asked. It is not true to say that fairs are something which though they are not coming under licensing in this particular text, will be as free as they were in the past. In fact I would recommend to Senator O'Quigley and to others that they go back and find the charters under which some of those fairs are held, see under an alien power and alien kings what were the terms under which permission for those fairs was granted, see the manner in which they were designated, not only as to place but as to the days of the week they might be held—or the month—the produce that might be offered for sale on any of those particular days, the tolls that might be required to be paid by some lackey in the community who had done a service to the king or queen in the past and was now being paid off through his neighbours by allowing them to sell their produce in their town on specified days and on specified conditions. Those charters still exist. Read those charters and, mind you, some of them are most illuminating, and particularly illuminating in regard to some of the towns where fairs are held under those very charters. But apparently they have never thought about it or gone to the fairs in their home towns which are there and are being held up as having free access to the farmers. They are not at all as free as they would appear to be; they were controlled not so many years ago, there are rights of collecting tolls from people——

Comment on this

They do not collect them now; that is dead.

Comment on this

That shows what Senator McDonald knows about fairs; he does not know that there are tolls being paid.

Comment on this

Not in the midlands, apparently.

Comment on this

People should not start talking unless they know what they are talking about. All I have been saying is that fairs do exist, that tolls are still being paid, that they are there by charters of foreign powers.

Comment on this

We have advanced from 1492.

Comment on this

They are still there.

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is difficult to understand the amendment before the House but I cannot understand the Minister's contribution at all.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

I am afraid the Senator's lack of understanding is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in order?

Comment on this

Is the Minister in order in giving a lecture on medieval history?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Second Reading nature of the debate was puzzling me somewhat.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I understood earlier that Senator Garret FitzGerald said something to the effect that he was not satisfied with the wording of the amendment so I was merely asking him was he withdrawing it; that was all.

Comment on this

May I just finish, because I do not want to fall into the trap Fine Gael have already fallen into—taking to the point of obscurity what has already been said. Therefore, I should just like to leave the charters of the fairs to those who would wish to assert them. They are most interesting: tolls are still being paid and we do not propose even to charge for a licence here. Even where we issue a licence, there will be no charge. This was a point raised by Senator Rooney the other day when he said in an aggrieved sort of tone—"there is no charge". There will not be any charge for a licence.

Comment on this

There is a catch in it when it is free.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think the validity of the points I was making in regard to this amendment has been amply demonstrated by the nature of the Minister's reply. To have replied in such a manner to an amendment in Committee Stage, bringing in such political red herrings, and paying no attention whatever to the technical points— other than pointing out that there were two commas in the sentence which I thought the Minister would have seen I observed from my reading of it—would seem to me to indicate that there is great substance in the point I was making. The Minister has no reply to it; he is obscuring the issue and I am emboldened therefore to feel I have a good point here. I do not understand— I do not want to pursue this matter, other than simply to revert to the point made by the Minister—what are these references to divergencies of views between Senator O'Quigley and myself, because we have discussed this now for 1¾ hours. He extended my argument somewhat further and with that I totally agree.

As regards the nature of the opposition to this Bill, it is my understanding that the function of an Opposition is that in reference to legislation which they consider to be untimely, or to be so substantially unacceptable that it is objectionable, they should oppose it on Second Reading. If that opposition, on Second Reading, should fail, then it is the Opposition's function to improve the measure, to eliminate those aspects of it which are undesirable, and to improve its quality so that it is better drafted. That I understand to be my duty as a legislator. That is what I have always understood and no communications I have had with anybody since I entered politics have altered that view. I considered it entirely appropriate, for the reasons I explained, to improve it, because I recognised that some legislation on auction marts might well be appropriate, even though the timing of it, the manner in which it was being pushed through, and the provisions of the Bill are of such a character as to be substantially inappropriate and, therefore, appropriate for opposition on Second Reading. We are discussing the Committee Stage. I was endeavouring, as I shall endeavour throughout this discussion, to improve it, and the red herrings the Minister has tried to draw across the Bill are simply an indication of the complete weakness of his argument. Therefore I feel I should stand firm on the point I am making.

Comment on this

Lest in replying to the red herrings, I might have created a few more and lest therefore there might be a shoal around—indeed, they might be breeding—let me say for the Senator's benefit that my difficulty in understanding the Fine Gael role—and I take it that when the Senator talks, he talks for Fine Gael in this Chamber—if I am wrong in that, please correct me, because this is where is begins and ends——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I thought I had made that clear during the past two years.

Comment on this

I take it that when Senator Garret FitzGerald speaks on a matter such as this, he is really speaking for his whole Party. As I under stood the Fine Gael Party viewpoint on this Bill, it was one of total opposition to it, and Front Bench spokesmen in that other place went out of their way on many occasions to indicate they were totally opposed to it, that there was no good in the Bill and that as soon as they became a Government, they would repeal it——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes; do not confuse me.

Comment on this

Then, we have Senator O'Quigley, who, I take it, also talks, when he does talk on matters such as this, for Fine Gael.

Comment on this

I am right so far; he says that the Bill, as it has come from the Dáil and is presented to this House, means nothing and that even at a moderate charge, he could show anybody who wishes to consult him the way to deal with it so as to make it practically non-existent, that he could show them a way around it and through it, and that anybody who wants to carry on livestock marts will be quite free to do it if they consult him. I presume, if they consult any of his legal colleagues, they will be able so to advise their clients. Therefore, this Bill, according to that spokesman of Fine Gael, is completely without worth: it does not do anything; it will not stop anybody from carrying on a livestock mart business in the future who wishes to do so.

How can we reconcile the two? One was total opposition by the Fine Gael Party and their Leader, who was followed by his speakers in the other House; and then at this late stage there is a new version and probably, being the latest edition, it is the main one, the common interest of Fine Gael that they do not totally oppose the Bill any more. This has come out only this evening. We have now found from this fount of knowledge that this Bill does not matter. If it does not matter, why the opposition to it? Where do we go from here? If it does not matter, Fine Gael must admit that their interpretation and their reading of the Bill was wrong because it meant something earlier: they said then it was doing all sorts of things they did not wish it to do. That is now to be thrown out the window and we must take the new testament from Senator O'Quigley that it does not matter, that there are so many ways to go through and around it that it might never have been put on the books as far as its effects are concerned.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What about the Succession Bill? Were they not right there?

Comment on this

If that is so, we should be told so. If they are to be considered a responsible Opposition it is only fair to themselves that they should give us clarification of their outlook on this measure.

Comment on this

If the Minister would give way to me——

Comment on this

They should do that for our guidance. Which stand is it to be? Does the Bill mean something, does it do all the terrible things they said it proposed to do during the debate in the Dáil, or does it not mean anything?

Comment on this

Quite clearly the Minister is at his best just now.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

You may think so.

Comment on this

He is out to misrepresent what has been said so clearly. He is out to seek some sort of chink in the armour of Fine Gael. He confesses to be surprised by Senator FitzGerald and he says he is confused. Quite obviously the Minister needs a holiday and very badly. In case the Minister enjoys the cold comfort he was about to enjoy, we on this side, as Senators of Fine Gael, will oppose this Bill line by line and comma by comma and we will do that for the reason that this Bill has been born in hate. It has been brought forth and was designed against a particular section of the community. It is unwarranted interference by the Minister in the ordinary affairs of business people in this country. It takes from people the perfect freedom they have at present to conduct auction marts in the ordinary way and the Minister is taking to himself in this Bill powers which no Minister of State should have entrusted to him, with no right of appeal against an arbitrary and unlawful exercise of these powers by the Minister.

It is for those reasons that we intend to oppose the Bill line by line and section by section. Let there be no mistake at all about that. As I have said—the Minister has chosen to misconstrue and misrepresent it; the Minister is welcome to his happiness when he is like that—even when the Minister gets to the stage of implementing the Bill, if he does prevent people from holding auctions in marts or if he revokes their licences and if they consult with me——

Comment on this

Advertising.

Comment on this

——or with any lawyer, with any good lawyer——

Comment on this

That is better.

Comment on this

——they will be able to continue to use their premises and to frustrate the intentions of the Bill but they will not be able to do what they want to do at present. It will render more awkward what they want to do and it is for that reason that we ought to be careful with these definitions. As Senator FitzGerald has so clearly stated, being democratic and accepting the decision of the majority of Seanad Éireann, we are not without hope, having regard to the 11 Independent Senators who have been nominated by the Taoiseach, though not tied necessarily to the Fianna Fáil Party, such as Senator Nash who, one might say, is committed to opposing sections 2 and 3——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why did Senator O'Quigley not stay to hear the reply to his attack?

Comment on this

I had to go to earn my living to western parts. Senator Nash can deal with what I said and I will be glad to learn from the Official Report what Senator Nash had to say. However, while we are here, and accepting the majority, I am not without hope that Senator Nash and some of the independent Senators nominated by the Taoiseach, who are not necessarily members of the Fianna Fáil Party, may come in with us on some of these amendments. That is what we are about in this Bill: we hope to be able to persuade some of the Senators on the other side to vote with us.

Comment on this

The Senator will have to do better than he has done so far.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding all that was said about this section in Dáil Éireann, as not infrequently happens it falls to Seanad Éireann to make such amendments as make Bills work. We had the Extradition Bill which would never have got off the ground but for an amendment proposed by me and accepted by the Minister for Justice. The Bill simply would not have worked otherwise. It passed Dáil Éireann, it passed the great officials and the Parliamentary draftsman. It may be it is because we have different skills, less to worry us, that we confine ourselves to legislation. We will continue to do this, not perhaps improve the Bill but eradicate its evil effects.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I will put down something slightly different on Report Stage to meet the points the Minister has made.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I object to the withdrawing of amendments with a view to putting them down on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator did not say that. Amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The consequential amendments will not be moved. I suggest that amendments Nos. 2 and 3 be discussed together.

Comment on this

Not this particular one. There is another amendment which might be taken with it. Nos. 1 and 2 might have been taken together. I move amendment No. 2:

In line 15 to delete "or otherwise".

There are two or three things I wish to clarify. This is an amendment which got quite a nailing in Dáil Éireann and, as the Report of the Dáil shows, the amendment was carried. In other words, if we were to operate upon what is contained in the Official Report of Dáil Éireann of 18th July, 1967, I should not be discussing this amendment because these words have already been expunged from the section by the Dáil. I understand that the Journal of the House likewise shows——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair has already ruled on that point.

Comment on this

I am in effect moving an amendment which, upon all the official evidence available to us, has been accepted by Dáil Éireann. However, the Chair has made its ruling and the Chair says we ought to discuss this amendment.

Comment on this

I think this would be a point of order. It has been asserted here, as it was asserted here earlier, that the Record of Dáil Éireann shows that this amendment would have been accepted on another stage in the Dáil. I have here the actual Division Paper used for that division. The question was "Livestock Marts Bill, 1967, Amendment No. 1: ‘That the words stand'". It was carried by 62 votes to 43. My recollection of it, while this assertion was being made earlier by Senator O'Quigley was that the form of this particular amendment, decided by the House, was "That the words proposed to be deleted stand": this was a normal form in the Dáil. Here is the document, signed by the four Whips. I suggest the Chair look at this document just to confirm that the matter is in order as far as the Dáil is concerned.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely that document is the property of the Dáil, not of the Minister?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is the property of the Oireachtas and this is part of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

It is not the property of the Minister. I am surprised that the Minister can get hold of a document which is the property of the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

There is nothing improper about it. The matter was raised here and an improper construction was put on what took place in the Dáil. If the Dáil records, as now available to any Member of the Oireachtas, show otherwise, I am entitled to get the document.

Comment on this

The Minister is not entitled to send one of his servants for a document which is the property of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Of course I am. Who is the Senator to tell me that I am not so entitled?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator want a distortion to remain?

Comment on this

In this instance, I am not concerned about distortion but about whether a document which is——

Comment on this

——public property.

Comment on this

It was sent for by the Minister and given into the possession of a servant of the Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like to express my gratitude to the Minister for removing our doubts in this matter.

Comment on this

That was the purpose for which I sought it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I shall now give the document into the charge of the Clerk Assistant of Seanad Éireann to be returned.

Comment on this

It is an extraordinary situation.

Comment on this

The truth of the matter is that the only document to which I have lawful possession is the Official Report of Dáil Éireann for 18th July, 1967, and it says that the amendment was carried. It does not matter what the form used in Dáil Éireann in relation to the taking of the vote and the announcement of a decision. I took the precaution of doing a little further research to see if this was a peculiar form of wording used in Dáil Éireann in relation to amendments. I find, in relation to the next amendment, contained in the same volume, Volume 230, col. 11 of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, that the amendment was put, the Committee divided, Tá, 40; Níl, 63—and then we have the amendment declared lost and all the other amendments that were debated and were declared lost——

Comment on this

Is the Senator getting away from the amendment he was wrong about?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator admit he made a mistake?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The way the Dáil does its business, and what happens in it according to an unrevised version of what purported to happen there, is not a subject for debate in this House.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister having intervened to make certain observations and having produced a certain document, I feel bound to point out the way in which I got my information. That is all.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is a good job somebody intervened to correct it.

Comment on this

May I say——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I think the whole matter——

Comment on this

I just want to say that I understand the Senator's dilemma in this matter. I merely bring the document to the notice of the House to prove that, whatever the Official Report says, this in fact is what took place and this is the document that counts.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And that should end it.

Comment on this

It is not the first time the Senator has been wrong.

Comment on this

That is all right. I said that on the face of it—prima facie—there appeared to be a conflict between the two documents. When the Senator reads the Official Report, he will see I was quite guarded because I rather suspected that the officials who deal with these matters made, what is quite unusual for them, an error. Therefore I said “prima facie”. I did not think it was an error which was repeated the whole way through the debate. I now want to come back to the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is a pity the Senator did not add that to his contribution at the start.

Comment on this

We generally regret the words we said rather than the words we did not say. It is better to regret that we did not say it rather than to say something else. Now, to the amendment.

This amendment was, I think, debated and considered at length in the Dáil and, as I say, it might more appropriately have been taken with Senator FitzGerald's amendment No. 1. I confess I am not at all clear as to what is meant by including the words "or otherwise" after the word "auction" in line 15. I am quite sure the Minister wants to bring within the ambit of the Bill the business of selling livestock by auction. I am also clear, as a corollary to that, that he wants to bring within the ambit of the Bill the provision "a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction". I do not understand the qualification in the provision "for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise".

I can well understand that the Minister wants to require people to have licences if they are engaged in the holding of sales of livestock by auction at a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. I am quite clear on that. However, in the light of the Minister's explanation that fairs deriving from medieval times are to be permitted to continue without let or hindrance, save in so far as the charter otherwise provides, not all he has said in the Dáil or all he has said here today enables me to understand why it is that, within the purview of this definition, he has a place which is provided for the holding of a sale otherwise than by auction. That is the kind of sale which I do not understand.

I thought the Minister was concerned purely with auctions, sales at auctions, even of sales by auctions. Now he says in this definition that he will prevent people from providing for the holding of sales which will take place not by auction but in some other way. I do not know what these kinds of sales are.

It has been suggested that the phrase "or otherwise", being so comprehensive, will capture a variety of situations which it would appear the Minister did not intend to capture. If the Minister wants to prevent the provision of any particular place for the holding of sales "by auction or otherwise", he should merely put into the Bill a provision for "the holding of sales of livestock" and then it does not make any difference whether or not it is a sale by auction: it is a sale and therefore it is out. If it is a sale otherwise than by auction, it is also out because people would then be obliged to have a licence for all classes of sales, if they provide for the sale of livestock.

For the life of me, I cannot see what the Minister is about or what he has in mind when he says he is going to prevent people from providing a place for the sale of livestock otherwise than by auction when, as I understand it, he is not going to prevent the provision of a place for the holding of a fair and if there is not an auction carried out there, they can sell without let or hindrance. The mere provision of a place for sale of livestock means, under this definition, that they will have to obtain a licence.

What I am saying is not a legalistic interpretation or anything of that kind. We all know that in every town in rural Ireland where one of those medieval fairs is still conducted, there are certain publicans, hardware merchants and grocers who have premises wherein they have large yards into which people put cattle, either after they have sold them or pending bringing them to the fair green, and so on. It seems to me that if a person continues to afford that facility to the farmers near a town, to the customers of his public-house, say, if he continues to hold that place available for sales otherwise than by auction, then, in fact, he is carrying on the business of a livestock mart. That is not so far-fetched as one might think because when we come to the interpretation of statute law, it is not what the Minister thinks or intends that ultimately matters but what the words mean. The Minister knows that as well as I do.

One finds that in the case of the Intoxicating Liquor Act an amendment had to be introduced to the intoxicating liquor code as late as 1962 to permit the parking of animal-drawn vehicles in licensed premises for the hours during which the sale of intoxicating liquor was prohibited. It is provided in section 2 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1962 that:

Notwithstanding anything contained in section 17 (which relates to the offence of being on licensed premises during prohibited hours) of the Act of 1927, it shall not be unlawful——

because up to that time it was unlawful——

for a person to be in any yard, stable, outhouse, shed or other like place forming part of premises in respect of which a licence is in force and which are not situate in a county or other borough... for the sole purpose of leaving therein, attending to, or removing therefrom, an animal-drawn vehicle.

In other words, when the prohibition of being on a licensed premises during prohibited hours was being enforced, it was found that people had horses and carts, or ponies and carts, parked on licensed premises at Mass time principally, and technically they were on licensed premises during prohibited hours and, therefore, guilty of an offence, and the publican with them. In order to mitigate this unforeseen hardship, section 22 of the 1962 Act was enacted.

It seems equally clear that if the person, the same publican as provides the facilities for the animal-drawn vehicle, provides facilities on fair days for people putting cattle, sheep or pigs on his premises, and if it happens that anybody conducts a sale at any time there—it may be the custom in some places that if you go down to Johnny Mac's place, you may be able to buy from X, Y or Z—and if thereafter people go down there and buy cattle, then he is carrying on the business of providing for the holding of sales otherwise than by auction. It may be that two or three people may come in and bid and accordingly the phrase "or otherwise" is going a great deal further than the Minister wants it to go. The definition can capture a great number of people against whom the Minister may not wish to direct his misdirected energies.

Comment on this

Plainly and simply, the inclusion of the words "or otherwise" is necessary to prevent evasion through non-auction sales. That is the sum and substance of it and not much more can be said about it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Evasion through non-auction sales. How could there be evasion when the——

Comment on this

Do not be childish.

Comment on this

People, such as the proprietors of livestock marts, will be reading these debates in order to find out how far they are affected by the Bill. The Licensed Vintners Association, perhaps, and other people who have something to do with the storing of livestock on their premises, will also be concerned with the Bill. The Minister may say that it is designed to prevent evasion but the whole Bill is for one purpose, and it is not clear what kind of——

Comment on this

Non-auction sales.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

But it does not have the effect of preventing evasion at all. I am quite taken aback by this because the wording does not have that effect at all. It is the "business of a livestock mart" and selling by auction. As far as that is concerned, if the livestock are sold by non-auction, the Bill does not provide for it. It does not say anything about whether the cattle are sold by non-auction. It simply provides for the selling by auction or otherwise. The person who provides the place must have the intent that it shall not be used for non-auction sales but it is not the intent in that person's mind which is relevant. The purpose of providing the place must be the holding of non-auction sales. If it is provided quite legitimately as an auction mart and somebody subsequently carries on the sale by non-auction, that would be covered by the definition section. If the Minister is trying to prevent evasion, he is not going about it the right way.

Comment on this

No at all. The trouble about it is that the Senator either does not understand it or does not want to understand it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He is trying very hard.

Comment on this

I do not know which is worse: it is a matter of degree.

Comment on this

Not being able to is the worse.

Comment on this

That is not quite what said.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I certainly want to understand; I admit I do not.

Comment on this

Sale otherwise than by auction at a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. Is that too much to comprehend?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

"Providing for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise, a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction." There are two separate points here. One is that the place must be adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. Believe it or not, I have been in those places. Certain provisions had to be made so that the auction can be carried on. Places have to be provided for the cattle, for the auctioneers and so on. The place must be adapted for this purpose.

Secondly, the purpose for which it is being provided by the person providing it must be for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise. If he contemplates at that point that they should be sold by either method, it comes within this section. If no place is provided for the sale of livestock by auction and subsequently somebody used it for a non-auction method, it would not come within the section.

Comment on this

This is quite capable of evasion unless you put in "or otherwise" because a person could provide a place which he would allege to be not for the holding of auctions but which could be used for it. Unless you have a place for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise, a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction, you are going to clearly have the opportunity of evasion. No matter what the person alleges the place is, if it is used for the sale of livestock by auction it is coming within the Bill.

Comment on this

If that is what is intended, it is a pity it was not said with the somewhat lugubrious clarity of Senator Ryan. At least, there is a great deal of clarity in some of what he says, but it cannot be expressed by throwing in the phrase "or otherwise". That is what it appears to mean. To somebody trying to read this Bill, to construe it, to find the intention, what Senator Ryan said is something you could conceive a Minister providing against. But, if that is what is intended to be put in the Bill, the phrase "or otherwise" just does not meet the Bill, if I might say so.

Comment on this

If it were not there, evasion could take place.

Comment on this

Oh, no. The Senator is talking about a type of evasion that can take place. That is what this definition should set out, spell out, in the detail and length he has given.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

Having been paid the compliment of bringing some clarity to the situation, the Senator should not overplay his hand. That is the kind of evasion one can see the Minister trying to provide against. That is Senator Ryan's interpretation of providing for the holding of sales otherwise than by auction a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. One can see that. May I confess that I have been reading for many years the definitions of different matters contained in Bills?

I have never come across, and I do not suppose we shall ever come across again because it will be seldom you will have Bills drafted with such indecent haste as this one—anything that equals this for lack of clarity, and for confusion. It may well be, of course, that the Minister likes it that way. It may well be that his purpose is not to have it too clear and that he can say afterwards: "It covers this as well as covering that". That may well be his purpose. That is all right in political speeches. We had a person in active political life in this country once upon a time who said one thing you could interpret anyway you liked. This may be carrying on from that style of oratory. That is not the way legislation should be drafted. I think that should be excised from the Bill until such time as what is clear is set out somewhat along the lines of Senator E. Ryan's interpretation of it. It covers what the Minister has in mind.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If I understand Senator Ryan correctly, he would say the amendment as proposed could create a problem. What I do not understand, if what he says is the problem of the definition section, is what purpose or value the clause with the commas has. I can see that if you delete "or otherwise" and leave it there, this might create a problem, now that I begin to understand what the purpose of this section is. But suppose you delete what is between the commas, would you be any worse off? You would be in the position that the business of a livestock mart means the business of selling livestock by auction or providing a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction, which is a matter of fact. If it has the necessary arrangements for that purpose, is there anything to be gained by saying it must be for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise? If it is adapted for the sale of livestock by auction, it could be used either way. Does it matter what the purpose so long as the place is adapted for the sale of livestock by auction? I cannot see there is any value in what lies between the commas. If the intention of putting in "or otherwise" is to have the effect Senator E. Ryan said, it would be best achieved by not putting in the parenthesis at all.

Comment on this

I think the Senator has, up to a point, gone along with great clarity and then suddenly diverted into the unknown. The "or otherwise" is necessary to prevent evasion in regard to places that have been adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. It is specifically there. Without the commas and without the words between the commas, this would not be clear. This is necessary in order to prevent evasion by the sale in forms other than by auction at such places so provided and adapted. The whole intention of this is to stop that gap. This does it and does it effectively. No other form of words we could find would have done it so effectively and with the same number of words. We might have been able to do it with a greater number of words, but that would have only added to the confusion. Without a doubt this is the purpose of it. Without it, it would not be the same definition. It would not have the same context or meaning, and evasion would be quite capable of being perpetrated in places adapted for sale by auction if they sold livestock other than by auction.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am afraid the Minister has left me in the state of confusion I was in before Senator Ryan's intervention. Is the Minister trying to prevent livestock being sold by non-auction methods in auction marts?

Comment on this

If we have somebody who has provided the place and all the paraphernalia, the pens and all the rest of the things necessary for setting up a mart, and either through malpractice or otherwise he is refused a licence or has carried on business in it and has his licence revoked, what we want to ensure is that he does not get around that by being able to carry on sales other than by auction in this place. We want to ensure that he cannot get behind the law by devising certain ways of selling those cattle and obviating the need for a licence. "I have lost my licence," he may say "but I can still carry on." This is what he could do without these two words being there.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is what I thought the Minister intended originally. Senator Ryan was of a somewhat different mind. If that is what the Minister means, first of all, I do not think we should, in fact, agree that in a Bill designed to regulate the business of selling livestock by auction we should set out to allow them to be sold in any other way. This is the first time the intention of the Bill was expressed to be as wide as this, that under this Bill the sale of livestock by non-auction methods can be prevented if it is in a building adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. It is quite inappropriate, beyond the needs of the situation, beyond what appears to be the intention of the Bill. But, having said that, on top of that, the putting in of "or otherwise' does not, in fact, achieve this result because "or otherwise" is in a clause which relates to the purpose of the provision of the premises and does not relate to what is carried on in the premises after being provided.

If the Minister wishes, rightly or wrongly—I would think wrongly—to prevent in such a building livestock being sold by non-auction methods, he would need to say so in some other point in the Bill but in putting the words "or otherwise" in here he is merely governing or affecting in some way the question of the purpose for which the mart is provided. "Providing for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise" that is the purpose for which it was provided. What that purpose may be is one question. What is done subsequently is another. This is the point I was trying to make earlier on and I was diverted from it by Senator Ryan. It is quite clear to me that if the Minister is trying to prevent non-auction sales taking place in an auction mart, this does not achieve that effect and could not possibly be read as doing so. The wording of the section taken as a whole makes that clear. It starts off, "business of a livestock mart" means the business of selling livestock by auction. That is point number one. When it comes to the selling it must be only by auction. When it comes to the question of providing the place, if that purpose is for the sale of cattle by any method then the place can be brought within the Bill whether or not, in fact, it is used for that purpose. But, they are two quite separate things. At no point in that definition section or anywhere in the Bill is there anything said to the effect that people cannot sell by non-auction methods in livestock marts. The wording "or otherwise" only affects the purpose and intention of the person who provides the livestock mart in the first instance, what was in his mind when he provided it. It has no effect whatever on what is done subsequently. If the Minister's intention is as he says it is, it is completely ineffective.

I am in two minds as to whether to abet him in the aims of tightening up on this matter, which I think would be inappropriate, and thereby making it technically a better Bill or leave the Bill in its present state of ambiguity and ineffectiveness. At any rate, the Minister must be clear that this clause does not do what he purports to do at all and will in no way tighten up in the way in which he wants done.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Do you wish the amendment to be put?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Before you put the question, do I understand that amendments Nos. 2 and 3 were being taken together?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

No, they were not.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 30
·
Níl 14
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 3:

In line 16 to add at the end "but does not include the leasing or letting of any such place".

The purpose of the amendment is to add to the definition of the business of a livestock mart the words "but does not include the leasing or letting of any such place". The reason for this is that in the section the business of a livestock mart and carrying on the business of a livestock mart include providing for the holding of sales by auction or otherwise at a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. The term "providing" is a term of very general connotation and can mean two things. It can mean actively providing in the sense that one is the owner and occupier of the mart and that one conducts or sees to the conduct therein of auctions of livestock. It can also mean that a person is the owner of the building, or the site wherein the auction of livestock is carried out. Therefore it seems to me that if I own a livestock mart and let it for a term of years or if I own the ground on which it has already been built and have let it for a term of years and the lessee of the property has built on it a livestock mart and if this Bill were to come into operation and the lessee were to get a licence under section 3 (8) not only would the lessee be bound to be licensed but I who merely fulfil the passive role of being the landlord or lessor of the ground on which the mart has been erected, would also be obliged to get a licence.

I feel that the Minister, comprehensive as he wishes to make the legislation, does not intend to go that far because what it would mean then is that a lessor or landlord or owner of land who would let or who in future might let land upon which would be constructed a livestock mart, if the actual occupier, the person concerned with the operation of the livestock business there were guilty of an offence and that thereafter auctioning of livestock in contravention of the provisions of the Bill were to be carried out, the lessor or landlord would be equally liable to a penalty under section 2 with the person who actually conducted the business in the mart.

I do not know if the Minister wants to go so far. I certainly think that a person who is already letting land on which a livestock business is being carried on should not, because of the action of somebody else, be liable to a penalty under section 2. The distinction which I am drawing between the owner and the occupier has already been drawn in existing legislation in relation to premises. Notwithstanding that the Minister would have this measure removed from the ambit of the court so far as possible, even the Minister may be subject to certiorari— I am not too sure of that—but, certainly, in relation to the penalty provisions which will be the subject of consideration by the district courts, if a court were to construe the Act they would be bound to take note of existing provisions in relation to premises in a somewhat similar position to livestock marts.

I can well see the Attorney General prosecuting these offences calling in aid the Factories Act, 1955 and the Office Premises Act, 1958. In the Factories Act, 1955, a distinction is drawn between the owner and the occupier. In Mr. Shillman's book, The Factory Legislation of Ireland, published in 1956, he refers to the occupier in his introduction on page 10 and says: “The person primarily liable for any contravention of the Act is the occupier of the factory premises.” That is the position under section 100, subsection (1), which provides:

In the event of a contravention in or in connection with or in relation to a factory of any provision of this Act or any regulation or order made thereunder, the occupier or (if the contravention is one in respect of which the owner is by or under this Act made responsible) the owner of the factory shall, subject as hereinafter in this Act provided, be guilty of an offence under this section.

The term "occupier" has been construed in the courts as follows: "The occupier plainly means the person who runs the factory or warehouse, who regulates and controls the work that is done there and who is responsible for the fulfilment of the provisions of the Factories Act within it." I would have thought that the Minister's net only went the distance of capturing the person who runs a livestock mart, who regulates and controls the work done there, and who is responsible for the fulfilment of the provisions of this Bill within that factory or mart.

If one looks at section 6, under which it is proposed to make regulations in relation to livestock marts, one sees clearly that they may prescribe the manner in which such auctions shall be conducted. That is the job of the occupier. They may provide that the receipt of entries for and the conduct of such auctions shall be carried out in accordance with conditions of sale drawn up by the owner of each such place and approved by the Minister. Again that is the job of the occupier and something with which the landlord would have no connection. He may prescribe requirements as to the size, design, maintenance, repair, cleansing, cleanliness, ventilation, heating and lighting: the keeping of the premises in a proper state of repair. Again this would undoubtedly be the job of the occupier.

One can see that the size, design and maintenance would relate to the person who built the premises and let it. The regulations may prescribe requirements as to the accommodation, including washing facilities. That would relate to both the owner and the occupier conducting the auction. They may prescribe requirements as to and provide for the veterinary examination of livestock. That is a matter which would affect only the occupier. They may provide for the inspection of such places. That would be a matter which would affect the occupier rather than the owner.

One finds in the Factories Act, 1955, that the owner is defined as "the person for the time being receiving the rackrent of the premises in connection with which the word is used, whether on his own account or as agent or trustee for any other person, or who would receive the rackrent if the premises were let at a rackrent".

As the definition stands at the moment it seems to me that the owner of the ground upon which the factory is built, or the owner of a building which is let for the auctioning of livestock, or which is a building adapted for the sale of livestock by auction, or otherwise, is equally engaged in the business of a livestock mart with the man who is actually carrying on the business week in, week out, or month in, month out, as the case may be. It seems to me, therefore, that the word "providing" applies equally to the landlord who lets and to the occupier who occupies and actually conducts the business. It may be the Minister's intention to catch both. If it is, this seems to be an extraordinarily ill-conceived piece of legislation.

I do not think the Minister, wittingly, at any rate, would want to go that far. If he does, this suppose is what he would seek to have included in the Bill. I do not think there is any reason why the Minister should want to go against the landlord upon whose ground the mart has been built. I have been trying to get, but I was unable to find, the memorandum and articles of association of the Shannon Free Airport Development Company. They provide buildings in which manufacturing processes can be conducted. They have nothing to do with the manufacture of pianos or mirrors. I see that three factories are to be built in a particular county where a by-election may be expected.

Comment on this

Senator Dolan always reminds me of Oisín and Pádraig, and living in the past. Here we have Oisín i ndiaidh na Féinne agus é ag clampar.

Comment on this

The Senator mentioned Shannon and the rabbits.

Comment on this

I am Pádraig and he is Oisín—and we have the new testament to which the Minister referred earlier this evening.

Comment on this

The Senator has discussed that matter sufficiently and should now come to the amendment.

Comment on this

As I understand it, the Shannon Free Airport Development Company actually provide the buildings. If they provided a livestock mart, if one of their buildings were used for the conduct of a livestock mart in connection with the sale of dead rabbits, I do not think the Minister would want to capture the people who provided the facilities, but having leased it, and having dispossessed themselves of the right of access to it, the right to enter and the right to interfere in the conduct of affairs, should they be subjected to the penal provisions of this Bill? If the Minister wants to make landlords or lessors of premises equally liable with the people who occupy, control and conduct the auctions, then the definition contained in subsection (1) is entirely adequate for his purpose. I do not think he ought to do that and therefore I would urge upon him and upon the Seanad the need for accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

My advice is that landlords could not be held responsible for the business of providing places adapted for mart premises. I should like to say as well, though, having listened to everything that has been said, it is very unlikely that there is such a thing as commonsense used in the application of the law and that commonsense does have quite a high priority in the administration of the law in many ways. The element of commonsense plus the advice I have got is, I feel, ample to ensure landlords are not being brought in under the terms of the Bill, nor is it my wish or intention that they should be in the circumstances as outlined by Senator O'Quigley.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Are we clear as to what is meant by "landlord" here? If, in fact, the mart is provided in the same way as Shannon Free Airport and An Foras Tionscal provide factories, and are the landlords thereof, surely it comes within the scope of this Bill? Could it be held that Shannon Free Airport Company are not providing factories? They are landlords. They lease them out. I have never heard it suggested they are not providing the factories and I find it hard to believe that the Minister can sustain that.

Comment on this

I am not talking about Shannon Free Airport at all and I am sorry Senator McHugh is not here because I had a few remarks to make on that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If they are relevant I am sure the Cathaoirleach will allow the Minister to say them in the absence of Senator McHugh. I am trying to be relevant by giving a direct analogy. If the Minister is prepared to talk about Foras Tionscal and the industrial estate in Waterford, I am quite willing to use that as an example. The word "provides" is quite clear and in this instance I do not think there can be any doubt about it. One might argue that, if it is a question of a ground landlord, the degree of inactivity involved in his particular part might conceivably exclude him from the application of the term "provides". I have no doubt whatever that where a building is built by a company and then leased to some concern for business purposes, that is providing.

Comment on this

The Minister suggested, I think optimistically, that in a matter of this kind it is always possible to use commonsense. Commonsense seems to be lacking at the moment in this discussion but, leaving out of account altogether the remote possibility of looking at this from a commonsense point of view, I should have thought that, reading the Bill, it is made quite clear that in respect of any particular mart, there is only one licence. The suggestion appears to be that it is open to the Minister to hand out licences, right, left and centre, and, under this Bill, it might be held, perhaps, that a ground landlord should also be given a licence to get at the man who is running the mart. It is perfectly obvious that under the Bill there can only be one licence given in respect of any one mart.

Comment on this

Where is that clear?

Comment on this

"A person shall not carry on the business of a livestock mart"—it is subsection (1) section 2.

Comment on this

In other words, you cannot be a landlord.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In respect of which place? Where the business is carried on: we are talking about the headquarters of the company.

Comment on this

In respect of the business: one licence for one place.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

Incidentally, I am amused to hear Senator O'Quigley pontificating about Senator Dolan's habits of interrupting. Senator O'Quigley is one of the most prolific interrupters himself and he has now started to interrupt inside of five minutes.

Comment on this

But I am not back in the past. That is the difference.

Comment on this

There he is again. It seems clear to me that only one licence can be enforced in favour of a particular case and it is ludicrous to suggest that several licences would have to be given, some for the people who own the ground and some for those who own the buildings.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Yeats does not give signs of having listened to the debate with attention. Having discussed the matter at some length and to some purpose before the tea interval, there are clearly two things contemplated in this—one is selling livestock by auction and the other is providing livestock marts, which is property business, State investment business, building livestock marts, providing them, but not running them—that is covered under the first part of the section—and then presumably leasing them out because, if they were operated by the same company, they would fall within the first part of the section but where you have a company providing such a mart, there have to be two licences. We made this point in the early part of the debate and the Minister accepted it in practice by changing the whole concept and making a Second Reading attack on Fine Gael in order to confound the issue because he found himself without any particular argument to refute the point made. There are two places involved. If a livestock mart is leased from a property company, then the place of business, wherever that may be—we need not get involved in the registered place of business—also has to be licensed as a livestock mart under this ludicrous provision. There are two places to be licensed and not just one place.

Comment on this

First of all, I should like to say to the Minister that Ministers are, of course, always advised and sometimes the advice is right and sometimes it is wrong. I have seen Bills here in relation to which Ministers were advised, and undoubtedly thoroughly advised, but, when other people had a look at them, it turned out that the advice was not all that it should have been. I am never impressed with this sort of answer from Ministers: "I am advised this is necessary". That is a cover-up when Ministers do not understand the legal technicalities involved. It is then they resort to: "I am advised by the parliamentary draftsman".

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

"I do not understand it, but...

Comment on this

I do not at all object to interventions by Senator Dolan. I told him the other evening I welcomed them.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would leave that now and come to the subject of the amendment.

Comment on this

He has nothing else to talk about.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt, but I will if the Senator wants me to.

Comment on this

I want to come back to Senator Yeats' point. What section 2 is concerned with is a person who is not to carry on the business of a livestock mart at any place.

Comment on this

Unless——

Comment on this

Yes, unless there is a licence in respect of that place.

Comment on this

Exactly, a licence in respect of that place.

Comment on this

There can be no doubt at all that if you have a big combine which put up a number of livestock marts, and that is all they have, they are providing, for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise, a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction. No amount of commonsense can get over that interpretation. If they own those premises, they are providing, for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise, a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction and being engaged in the business of a livestock mart, they must under section 2 in respect of every place owned by the combine have a licence themselves for providing the premises and the occupier being in the business of selling livestock by auction. That is clear beyond any doubt and the vacant and hollow laughs born of a deep abyssmal ignorance do not impress me and will not do anything to get rid of the precisely analagous situation contained in the Factories Act of 1955 where a clear distinction is drawn between the person who provides the building, being the owner or landlord or lessor, and the person who conducts the factory in the building.

When this Bill gives rise to the difficulties that it undoubtedly will give rise to, I do not want any members of the Fianna Fáil Party to go around and say: "Oh, that was all Blaney's fault; it was Blaney did it."

Comment on this
Donal Davern Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Davern) Fianna Fáil

Surely, Sir, it is not in order to refer to the Minister as "Blaney".

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary did not see the nuances.

Comment on this

Dillon has made his name.

Comment on this

The Senator might refer to the Minister in proper terms.

Comment on this