We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage.

Contributions 237–482 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Livestock Marts Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 13 of 1967 ›

I am not referring to the Minister in the way he is going to be referred to.

Comment on this

The Senator should not abuse the privileges of the House. The Senator, to continue.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

As clever as the Senator is, he cannot foresee what anyone may say.

Comment on this

I am merely going on what they said when Deputy Haughey was Minister for Agriculture. However, let me say the Honourable Mr. Neil Blaney, as he is always referred to in the Fianna Fáil Party. I do not want them to say: "It was the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Neil Blaney, who was responsible for this Bill. Do not blame us, it was all Deputy Blaney's fault," as they said about Mr. Haughey and his dispute with the NFA.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would confine himself to the terms of the amendment.

Comment on this

I shall do so.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We know what the Senator is at.

Comment on this

The Senator is at amendment No. 3 on the Order Paper. I do not want to leave members of the Fianna Fáil Party in any doubt as to what is in this Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We have no doubt at all. You need not worry—we know what is in it.

Comment on this

I think you do not and that is the reason why there is such a deep division in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Words taken from the Honourable James Dillon.

Comment on this

I shall show that something that the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this

Will the Senator come back to the terms of the amendment?

Comment on this

I beg to be excused from replying to these interruptions.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We excuse you.

Comment on this

What section 6 of the Bill provides in relation to the size, design, maintenance, ventilation, possibly heating, possibly lighting, washing facilities and sanitary convenience are all matters which will be the concern of the owner and the provider of the livestock marts. Is it going to be an answer by the lessee of those premises to say: "Ha, ha, the size may not be right, the design may not be right, the maintenance may not be right, the toilet and other accommodation may not be right; but these are all matters for the provider."? Will that be a good answer to the Minister and the barrister of ten years standing before whom he will go to meet this empty formula and make an appeal which will be considered afterwards by the Minister?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely the Senator is not finding fault with the barrister of ten years standing?

Comment on this

I shall deal with that on the next amendment. There is all night for dealing with that. I have as much respect for the barrister of ten years standing as the next because all I have to do is look into the mirror.

Comment on this

You will see something.

Comment on this

Yes, and not unpleasant, in my view.

Comment on this

Alice in Wonderland.

Comment on this

Let there be no doubt that the lessor and landlord is going to be caught equally with the person who occupies the premises. If he is not, what is the objection to clarifying the definition of "the business of a livestock mart" by including the words, which would put beyond any doubt the secure position of the landlord and lessor, "but does not include the leasing or letting of any such place"? I wonder has the advice given to the Minister by his advisers been that that would injure the Bill or would it mean that the acceptance of that amendment might be some kind of a tribute to those who proposed it and would that too greatly offend the Minister's reputation of being tough, rough and as hard as they come?

Comment on this

If the point made by Senator O'Quigley is that the lessor must have a licence, do I take it that if I decide to build six marts in different parts of this country, have a telephone beside my bed and run the marts from my bed, phone up occasionally and find out how things are going, I will have to apply to the Minister for a licence from my bed? This seems to be the point being made by Senator O'Quigley.

Comment on this

The Senator has divined our fears aright because that is what this police state type of Bill amounts to. That is the point we were on to earlier this evening if the Senator appreciated what we were dealing with. We were talking about the provision of marts for the sale of livestock by auction. The definition means the business of selling livestock by auction. The auctioneer has a premises, and if he is a company has a registered office where he conducts business of selling livestock by auction. He also conducts it in the mart. It means that both places have to be licensed. That is what we were talking about earlier this evening.

Comment on this

I am quite sure that in the licensing Acts there is a paragraph much the same as this which provides that a person may not carry on the business of a publichouse without a licence but it is possible to run five or six publichouses from an office without having a licence. I think, therefore, that the suggestion of Senator O'Quigley is absolutely ridiculous.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If Senator McGlinchey examined the relevant legislation, he would find it is much closer to the amendment I put down in that it relates to the licensed premises just as I have suggested that the legislation should apply to the livestock mart.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 1 has been disposed of.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think the Senator has, in fact, got our point. We are concerned to protect the inviolability of his bedroom from the inspector of the Department.

Comment on this

It is the business, not the premises.

Comment on this

The question is that amendment No. 3 be agreed.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I was hoping we would hear the Parliamentary Secretary on the subject as he has listened to the debate with some attention, judging by his interruptions.

Comment on this

With all due respect to the Senator, I think the Minister has more than adequately covered the points raised and he did say, in fact, that commonsense will ensure that landlords of places used for mart premises will not be held responsible for the operation of those businesses and I would suggest, with all due respect to the Senator, that the Minister made one very significant contribution when he mentioned the word "commonsense" which seems to be completely lacking in the Fine Gael Front Bench.

With all due deference to the Senator, I think that if he weighs what the Minister stated in this regard, he will find that it more than meets all the arguments he adduced and, indeed, the ones which were completely extraneous to the matter in question, and which had no bearing whatever on this amendment. The amendment, as such, is unacceptable and we find that the arguments adduced weigh not at all on the side of altering the situation.

Comment on this

I should like to direct your attention, Sir, to the fact that the division bell is not ringing all over the premises. It is not ringing down at the post office or the restaurant. Something should be done about it.

Comment on this

How does the Senator know the bells are not ringing.

Comment on this

I have my ways of knowing.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 8
·
Níl 30
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments Nos. 4, 7, 8, 11, 12, 15, 17, 18, 19, 22 and 31 will be taken together. There are alternative proposals inherent in these amendments and separate decisions can be had for each group, if necessary.

Comment on this

I presume we can have separate decisions on these amendments.

Comment on this

On each group.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do not know what you mean.

Comment on this

We have a group, amendments Nos. 4 and 8, in the name of Senator O'Quigley; amendment No. 7, in the name of Senator Quinlan; amendments Nos. 15, 17, 18, 19 and 22 in the name of Senator Murphy. These are alternative proposals so we can get separate decisions on them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 12 and 31 are also separate.

Comment on this

I do not think that amendment No. 12 should be in the grouping mentioned.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 4, in the name of Senator O'Quigley.

Comment on this

Do I understand the position to be that we move each of these amendments as we go along and debate them together?

Comment on this

They will be taken as a group but the debate will be on No. 4.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is each group to be moved separately? There is one case where there are two groups of amendments in the name of the same Senator.

Comment on this

At the end of the debate, the groups will be mentioned and a decision will be taken on them.

Comment on this

The position then appears to be that if the vote were taken on No. 4——

Comment on this

The debate is over the whole range of the amendments.

Comment on this

——the others will be put forward and a decision then taken?

Comment on this

No. 4 is the amendment; No. 8 is consequential on No. 4, and so on.

Comment on this

We will be guided by the Chair.

Comment on this

Would you please call out the amendments again?

Comment on this

The group which we are discussing together is: Nos. 4, 7, 8, 11, 12, 15, 17, 18, 19, 22 and 31.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

To delete line 17.

This amendment is at the heart of this Bill. It is to delete the sentence: "licence" means a licence under section 3 of this Act. In conjunction with that, I take it I am in order in talking on amendment No. 8 which means that if we decide to abandon the licensing of livestock marts and the carrying on of the business of livestock marts, we will put into their place another system of regulating—I do not like the word "control"—the conduct of the business of livestock marts.

As indicated on Second Stage, we in the Fine Gael Party are utterly and irrevocably opposed to the licensing of livestock marts as proposed in this Bill. There is a time and a place for everything and a time when certain things ought not to be done. The introduction of this Bill at this time has been judged by the Fine Gael Party, and in the light of the terms of the Bill itself, to be singularly inappropriate. The Minister has certain information, and I suppose the Minister for Justice has certain information, about things which were done during the unhappy dispute between the Government and the National Farmers Association and, perhaps, between the Government and the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association, for all we know. But one transgression—or isolated transgressions of this kind—does not put a whole class in this community or, indeed, in any other community, into the category of habitual criminals, and that is what this Bill, by implication, does.

Livestock marts were operated freely and successfully by the farmers and the co-operative movement, in its various aspects in this country, without let or hindrance, or assistance from, as far as I know, the Minister for Agriculture or his Department. I do not know whether they ever got any grants from the Agricultural Credit Corporation or from any other financial organisation operating under the aegis of the Oireachtas but those marts operated satisfactorily. Because of certain transgressions, in such instances as we have been told, the Minister proposes to take what can only be described as total power in relation to the existence and the coming into existence of livestock marts. If the Minister and the Government were genuinely concerned about the location and conduct of the business of livestock marts, there was another much more effective way in which they could have regulated them as the interests of the common good in their view would require.

There was nothing to prevent the Minister bringing in a Bill to make it obligatory on all livestock marts and persons carrying on the business of livestock by auction from registering with him, with committees of agriculture or with the various sanitary authorities—preferably, I would think, with committees of agriculture. Thereafter, having done that and made it an offence to conduct a business that was not registered, there was nothing to prevent the Minister from laying down standards of hygiene relating to size, design, maintenance, repair, cleansing, ventilation, the inspection of livestock by veterinary officers and the observance of other requirements which were deemed necessary, and, if those requirements were not complied with, to make it an offence, for failure to do so and, in that connection, to impose the kind of penalties in relation to repeated acts of non-compliance, or failure to comply, as we find in the licensing code.

The Factories Act, I am sure, is of as much concern to the people of this country as are the livestock marts. As the House will readily appreciate, we were more concerned, in the factory legislation, with the wellbeing and safety of the people who work in those factories and, to a lesser extent, of people coming into the factories on their lawful occasions. We did not require, the Oireachtas did not require, and the common good has not since demanded, since the introduction of that Act in 1955, that factories be licensed, that before you could have a factory you had to apply to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for a licence. That was not found necessary, but we were able, in the Factories Act of 1955, to prescribe standards of cleanliness in relation to overcrowding, temperature, ventilation, lighting, drainage of floors, slippery floors, sanitary accommodation, the protection of eyes, the use of phosphate, underground rooms, the lifting of excessive weights, operations involving glass or heat, lead process, industrial poisoning, the fencing in of dangerous machinery and other requirements in connection with transmission machinery, in relation to hoists and lifts, the training of persons working at dangerous machines, in relation to chains, ropes and lifting tackle, cranes, construction of floors, precautions against explosion of inflammable dust, gas, vapour or substance, and so on.

Here we were dealing with human beings, and we did not require the factory owners of this country, whether the occupiers or the persons who built them, as a class of criminals, to be licensed before being allowed to open a factory. Bearing that precedent in mind, I cannot see why there is any necessity for this piece of legislation, to require that somebody must go, cap in hand, and perhaps money in his pocket, to a Minister of State in order to obtain a licence or to hold on to a licence——

Comment on this

I thought it was understood that the licence was free. What exactly is the Senator implying?

Comment on this

——which a Minister of State can give him.

Comment on this

What does the Senator mean?

Comment on this

I will expand on that in good time.

Comment on this

Not by the use of further cliches, please.

Comment on this

I do not want to be anticipated in my speech or to get out of the order in which I am determined to make it. I say that what was good enough in 1955 in relation to human beings, and where human beings work, would seem to me to be eminently suitable for cattle in 1967, and it is not that they have got any more valuable, because their price has gone down steadily.

Comment on this

Why does the Senator not refer to some of the other Acts of 1955, such as the Seed Production Act?

Comment on this

We will come to them in good time. I want to point out that that was an Act passed by the inter-Party Government. Lest anybody should think that was an Act which did not commend itself to the Fianna Fáil Party, I remind the House that in 1958 we enacted a Bill, which is now entitled the Office Premises Act, 1958.

Comment on this

I hope the Senator will not repeat what he has said in regard to the Companies Act.

Comment on this

I am not dealing with the Companies Act at all; I am dealing with the Office Premises Act.

Comment on this

That has already been discussed here this evening.

Comment on this

The Companies Act, ach sin scéal eile.

Comment on this

Do not be running away from 1955.

Comment on this

Caithfidh an Seanadóir claoí leis an leasú.

Comment on this

Tá tréan-iarracht á déanamh agam ach níltear dom ligint.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Tá saor-chead ag an Seanadóir: Lean leis.

Comment on this

Más féidir leis.

Comment on this

In the Office Premises Act, 1958, a measure introduced in this House by the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, we find no necessity to license people before they can keep an office. Deputy Lemass then, thorough-going and all as he was in his defiant post-revolutionary attitude, did not think he should provide that anybody who keeps an office should have to apply to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for permission to open and keep an office. That was not the view of Deputy Lemass or the Fianna Fáil Party in 1958. They enacted in 1958, with the consent of everybody—it was all but an agreed measure—the Office Premises Act, a measure which laid down standards in relation to cleanliness, overcrowding, temperature, ventilation, lighting, and had standards in relation to unsuitable rooms, safety, welfare, health and so on. I do not wish to weary the House unduly but the Bill made it an offence on the part of a person keeping an office if he failed to comply with the standards prescribed under the Act.

What would be wrong with enacting parallel legislation, if it were required at all, in relation to cattle marts? Why is it that in 1967 what is good enough and what has been found to be sufficiently effective in relation to factory and office premises is not good enough in relation to places where we sell by auction or otherwise cattle, sheep and pigs.

Comment on this

Cattle, sheep and pigs cannot speak or raise objections but officers working in offices could draw the authorities' attention——

Comment on this

If the Senator was ever at a pig market, she would have heard pigs and bonhams raising most effective objections.

Comment on this

I do not speak their language and I should not understand their grunts.

Comment on this

That is a deficiency in the Senator's upbringing. That is the worst of being city-born. This spurious concern for cattle, sheep and pigs, at a time when we should be dealing with redundancy payments or things of that nature, does not impress me at all. It may be justification in the Senator's mind for voting for this Bill but I am not impressed by that at all. If, indeed, the Senator were concerned about the people who have no voice, why is it that for so long in so many towns we have the medieval system where streets are the market places, where fairs are held in the streets and there is no concern for the women and young children who have to bear the fifth and squalor of their towns because a medieval king in medieval times made a charter, of which the Minister spoke——

Comment on this

Is the Senator asking the Minister to abolish fairs?

Comment on this

He is not doing anything of the kind. He is expressing concern for human beings.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

As always.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil want the marts hygienic but they do not give a damn how the fairs are run.

Comment on this

They will be like funeral parlours where rank corruption lies in state. That is what the cattle marts will be like because we shall have nothing but the decaying carcases of surplus cattle in the cattle marts while we have the Minister and Government in office. Under this Bill we are vesting in the Minister power to grant or withhold or revoke a licence. If a licence is granted by the Minister, all is well. If the Minister decides to withhold a licence from a person applying to establish a new mart, the Minister under this Bill provides no effective redress to the person who may be aggrieved by his decision. If the Minister decides to revoke a licence he is entitled to do so under section 3.

Up to now, up to the amendments in the Dáil, the Minister was not obliged even to fulfil the first requirement of natural justice—to give the reasons why he was revoking or withholding a licence. As a result of the pressure of public opinion and the numerous deputations the Minister has had, we have a spurious form of appeal provided in section 3. I say it is spurious because an appeal to a person nominated by the Minister can inspire no confidence of fair play in any fair-minded or reasonable citizen. The Fine Gael Party are utterly opposed to vesting in the one person the power to grant, to withhold, to revoke——

Comment on this

What about 1955?

Comment on this

I will deal with that in a moment. That is as absolute a power as it is possible to vest in any Minister of State and if that was done in 1955, and it was, it illustrates the difference between time and place and person——

Comment on this

And which side of the House you happen to be at a particular time.

Comment on this

I want to make it perfectly clear that our view in the Fine Gael Party is that matters of this kind are best determined by somebody other than a Minister of State. For that reason, on the Town Planning Bill of 1963 the Fine Gael Party opposed resolutely, in up to 130 amendments, the vesting of the vital power of appeal under the Town Planning Acts in the Minister for Local Government because we became aware, and we now know, the opportunities for graft that exist where powers of that kind are vested in a Minister of State and nobody knows better than the Minister for Agriculture, former Minister for Local Government, of the opportunities for graft and corruption that exist under this Bill and under the Planning and Development Act, 1963. The Minister knows all these opportunities—and they exist.

With all the talk one hears around the country and in this city at the present time, I do not think we ought, any longer, to vest in any Minister of State the power of birth, existence or non-existence of any business which the Minister seeks in this Bill. The Minister says to somebody who tries to establish a mart: "No, you cannot have it in that place." He may give it to the fellow in another field and the reason that may be adduced is that that field is on higher ground and there is better drainage there—and that is sufficient to convince an unsuspecting public but we know and the people know the opportunities that exist for graft and corruption where powers such as these are vested in a Minister of State.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Repetition.

Comment on this

We are not prepared to entrust such powers any longer to any Minister of State. For that reason, in relation to the Planning and Development Act, 1963, we have introduced a Bill to take away from the Minister for Local Government the power of deciding appeals and to vest that power, instead, in a judge of a court with an assessor on either side, one to be nominated by the Minister for Local Government and another from a panel compiled by the Local Appointments Commission.

As I understand the system of democracy we have in this country, we, in giving ourselves the Constitution that we have, have set our face against allowing any organ of State too much power. For that reason, we have made or attempted to make the Government subordinate to the Legislature and to the courts. We have made both Government and the Legislature subordinate to the courts so that individual freedom and liberty might be preserved.

There is no other system that civil-isation has evolved which provides the same kind of freedom and security, in dignity, for the individual as does our Constitution, the English Constitution and the American Constitution, to a lesser extent the English Constitution than ours and that of the Americans. For that reason, we have entrusted the right to decide what one might call matters of life and death, matters of continuing in business or not continuing in business, not to a Minister of State but to an independent judiciary that is above and beyond reproach, that has unquestioned integrity and that cannot be reached by graft or corruption. Because of the position in which they are placed, the same cannot be said of Members of the Oireachtas or of members of the executive arm of the State, of the Government.

I have been invited to say more about money and licences. I accept the ruling of the Chair, given here on the Appropriation Bill last December. I shall not try to circumvent that. What I said on that occasion is on record.

Comment on this

The Senator should not make accusations of corruption.

Comment on this

I said I shall not expose any Minister of State to the temptations provided in legislation of this kind, now that we know what can happen.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What does the Senator mean by that?

Comment on this

Read the Report.

Comment on this

I remember the former Minister for Finance who is now Senator Dr. Ryan.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would the Chair ask the Senator what he means by that last statement, which is a reprehensible statement?

Comment on this

The Chair cannot prevent Senators from making political charges. Senator O'Quigley should continue—on the amendment, please.

Comment on this

I have not provided an interpretation section to my speech. I remember that, in his first Budget speech, the present Senator Dr. Ryan made the very laudable proposition that he would reduce the number of grades in the Civil Service. He said the structure was too complex and that there were too many grades in the Civil Service. For that, he received the encomiums not only of his Party but of the entire press in this country. Everybody thought we ought not to multiply unnecessarily grades in the Civil Service; that we ought to try to cut down on public expenditure; that, in that important field, the streamlining of our business administration, no better lead could be given than by the new Minister for Finance, the then Deputy Dr. James Ryan.

I find it very difficult to understand why it is necessary, when we come to a Bill of this kind, to by-pass the institutions which we have determined in our Constitution to establish to decide disputes between man and man and between the Government and the citizen. What is wrong with the courts? What particular power has the barrister of ten years standing, that is to be established under section 3 (6), that a district court would not have? Every day, the district courts deal with licences of one kind or another. They deal with dance hall licences. They are able to decide whether or not premises are suitable for the young people attending dances; whether the accommodation and the cloakrooms are adequate. They can decide, on evidence adduced before them, what number of people should be allowed to get into a dance hall. They can grant licences for restaurants and eating houses under the Intoxicating Liquor Acts. They can decide to renew licences. The circuit courts can decide to grant new licences under the Intoxicating Liquor Acts to hotels and public places. The district court can grant licences for lorries. They can grant licences, on appeal in relation to the suitability of premises, to betting offices. These are but a few of the variety of matters which the district court is called upon to adjudicate upon every day in the course of the administration of its jurisdiction.

Likewise, under the Health Acts of 1947 and 1953 and the old Health Acts which were in operation here when we took over, the Sale of Drugs Act, the Pharmacy Acts and the various regulations made under them, the courts were able to decide whether or not premises were in a fit and proper condition for the sale of food, for the display of food, for catering, and so on. No difficulty has been experienced in regard to any decisions of the district court in these matters. Why is it, then, that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Fianna Fáil Party say, when it comes to the grant of a licence in respect of a livestock mart, that the courts are inadequate? Did the courts prove inadequate to deal with any of the various licences in the past or did they prove inadequate or hostile to any Government, including the present Government, in the administration of justice? The answer, of course, is that they have not. We have yet to have from the Minister a reason why a district court cannot adjudicate upon the granting or revoking of a licence but a barrister of ten years standing or upwards can. Now, in this amendment we propose that a district court shall be given the jurisdiction to grant a licence—what we call a certificate of qualification— to a person carrying on the business of a livestock mart. We provide that such a certificate of qualification shall be sought in open court so that the world and its mother—to use an unloved cliché of Senator Ryan's—will know who is applying for what and where, the objections being made, the people who are objecting, and they can adjudicate for themselves through the medium of the press whether a person should or should not have a mart at a particular place.

What can be fairer and what could conduce more to justice and respect for the law than that an application be made in open court before a person whose independence, experience and integrity are not open to question. An application made in that kind of forum would inspire a great deal more confidence than the hugger-mugger approach of an application for a licence to a Minister of State, backed up by numerous representations from Deputies, Senators and fellow-travellers of a particular Minister. That is the alternative, an application in open court or the hugger-mugger applications that would be made to a Minister of State if this Bill goes through. I should like to hear the Minister advance his reasons for this. Let him ignore what happened in earlier days, and let him give us his reasons. This is what the public want to know.

Why must he duplicate the existing machinery of the courts with an ad hoc barrister of ten years standing? Why is the Minister afraid of the courts? Why does he not use the existing machinery? Why does he disregard justice in open court? Why was it that the Minister in his first Bill proposed that on his diktat, he would grant or revoke a licence without reason assigned, without notifying the person in advance what the reasons were, and with no right of appeal? When he has been pressurised by the members of his own Party, and by public bodies such as the Incorporated Law Society, he then pretends he is giving a form of appeal in the guise of a barrister of ten years' standing who will be appointed by him and who will have no independence. That is the important thing; he will have no independence whatever. If he tries to equate the decision of a barrister of ten years' standing, appointed by himself and then to be subject to review by the Minister for Agriculture, with the decision of a judge of one of our courts, established by law under our Constitution, he is trying to equate two things which cannot and never will be equated. There is no equation between them.

On previous occasions I have adverted to the obligation that lies upon every Member of the Seanad to see that this House does not enact any law which is in any way repugnant to the Constitution. I have drawn the attention of the Minister and of the House to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of the Solicitors Act, which was reported under the title of O'Farrell v. Gorman, re the Solicitors Act, in the 1964 Irish Reports. I cannot see how, in the face of that decision, the Minister can justify himself in taking the advice he will tell us he has got that this Bill is perfectly constitutional. No doubt, he will say that he has been advised that the Bill is constitutional, but I want to put on record my view that this Bill, in the light of that decision, cannot be regarded as constitutional, because everything the O'Farrell and Gorman case decides as being wrong and as being a usurpation of the judicial power of the State entrusted to and only to be exercised by judges established under the Constitution, is to be found in this Bill.

The fact that the Minister when revoking a licence will cause a statement of his reasons for doing so to be laid before each House of the Oireachtas is of no more value than saying he shall provide a death certificate when the man is dead, because on the date on which he lays before each House of the Oireachtas the statement of his reasons for revoking the licence of the livestock mart, the man who conducts it, or the co-operative society, will be out of business and it does not matter what happens then, because no matter who the Minister of the day is, there will be no redress. If a motion is put down to condemn the Minister or to appeal to the Minister or to request the Minister to cancel the revocation or renew the licence, the Minister will be able to snap his fingers and the motion will be defeated in exactly the same way as amendments to this Bill are being defeated by a majority in Dáil Éireann and in this House.

Let the members of the Fianna Fáil Party and those nominated by the Taoiseach and everybody else, remember that what our Constitution and what 1916 was about was the protection of individual liberty, giving the citizens of the 1920s, the 1960s and the 1980s security from arbitrary power imposed by a Government or exercisable by a Minister of State. That is what this Bill is going to do, to give arbitrary powers to a Minister of State. Let everybody remember that in the landlord days, whenever the battering-ram was brought to knock down country cottages, the first call-out was to open in the name of the law. The Minister will revoke licences, or refuse to grant licences to other people, all in the name of this law which is as invalid and oppressive and disregardful of individual freedom and liberty as the law which entitled the bailiff to call upon the cottier tenant to open in the name of the law. Let us have no doubt whatever, that is what this Bill is about.

When you have to apply to a Minister of State for a licence to go about your ordinary business of selling turf, of selling coal, that you have to be licensed for that, and that he can any day he likes revoke that licence and you have no redress under any court in the land, then you have reached the stage of despotism which I always understood our Constitution was designed to safeguard against and a stage of despotism which I understood we had finally thrown off in 1922 when we established our own Parliament and our own courts. Let the senior members of the Fianna Fáil Party not forget that, long before we had formal freedom here, one of the first things we did in the Sinn Féin days when we had our own Parliament out there in the Mansion House, was to establish our own Sinn Féin courts.

Comment on this

We should never have known it if you did not tell us.

Comment on this

I am recalling it. It is only last week I had the solitary experience of taking into my hands a very rare document—the Rules of the Sinn Féin courts. They were a reality.

Comment on this

And destroyed by your predecessors in 1922.

Comment on this

I knew that Oisín i ndiadh na Féinne would return. Now it is Oisín agus Harvey.

Comment on this

We used to hear a lot about Partition.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

We will not hear it now.

Comment on this

There are no votes for Fianna Fáil in that now.

Comment on this

That is the fundamental objection there is to vesting in the Minister, and, indeed, that objection was always as fundamental in vesting in any Minister this arbitrary and despotic power. But, as I say, there is a time and place for everything. In the past the members of my Party and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party in opposition were prepared to entrust those powers to different Ministers of State, and that is where personalities come into it. That is where the personality and the circumstances change the situation. If a Minister comes in good faith to grapple with a problem and says "Here is an evil I want to eliminate" and everybody agrees, first of all, there is an evil present—it is not in this case, which is the first thing to distinguish this Bill—then he says "This is the way I propose to deal with it. I will operate these powers reasonably. My Departmental officials will ensure that this, that and the other is done. We will hear representations and you can be satisfied that these powers will be used sparingly, with commonsense and with discretion."

That is one thing. But when you have a Minister of State, who is working fulltime to make himself the most detested public figure in modern Ireland, introducing a Bill of this kind for which there is no need and to remedy an evil which does not exist, it is a very different story altogether. Somebody said something to me some time ago. I want to return to it. The members of the Fianna Fáil Party, as I said, individually down in their own constituencies will blame Deputy Neil Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture, for the Livestock Marts Act of 1967.

Comment on this

They will blame Deputy Neil Blaney in Tipperary, in Louth, in Laois-Offaly, in Kildare, in Kilkenny, where the County Committee of Agriculture passed a vote of censure on the Minister for introducing this Bill and a proposer proposing a direct "No" could not get a seconder. In Kilkenny the Fianna Fáil people will say: "We are all against it, but it was Deputy Neil Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, who was insistent on this going through and we all know how tough he is. He is the man with the Donegal Mafia. You know what they are like." I want that to be very clear. Let the people know this. The Fianna Fáil Party as a body, despite the good show they will put on here, do not support this Bill. There are individual members, Deputies and Senators, who do not support this Bill. We have been told that they have opposed it in the Party rooms. I am breaking no confidences because no Senator or Deputy has spoken to me. But we know it.

Comment on this

Wishful thinking.

Comment on this

Senator Nash, I can say, opposes this Bill and opposed it most vehemently within the confines of the Incorporated Law Society.

Comment on this

We listened to him the other evening.

Comment on this

He is not here this evening—the fugitive Senator fleeing from his conscience.

Comment on this

Where was the Senator?

Comment on this

I was entrained for Castlebar, where I had gone to earn my living. I am always here whenever I can be. That is more than can be said for many Senators. When I am here, I think Senators will agree I speak much more——

Comment on this

We certainly all agree with that.

Comment on this

——than the Members on that side.

Comment on this

And get a lot less said.

Comment on this

I do not know what you are complaining about.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator O'Quigley, on amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

Senator Nash is violently opposed to this and he is now at war with his conscience and a fugitive from this House. The newspapers do not approve of this Bill.

Comment on this

Which of them?

Comment on this

I have met rank and file members of the Fianna Fáil Party, the stalwarts down the country, who have said to me: "For God's sake, do your best to defeat this Bill."

Comment on this

It shows how much you are out of touch with opinion in your own Party when you laugh so hollowly as that.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps the Senator would come to the amendment?

Comment on this

This section is extremely objectionable, not only to myself, to my Party and to other Members of the House but to those people. One of those people said to me: "You know it is the lowest possible motive for objecting to it. It is going to do and it is doing our Party untold harm. We know that will not appeal to you. It is my lowest reason for being opposed to this Bill."

Comment on this

Where do you keep them locked up?

Comment on this

If anybody wants an oath on that, they can have it.

Comment on this

Does that account for the extra votes we got?

Comment on this

Does it account for the extra votes we got? I want to return to the amendment——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Thank you, Senator.

Comment on this

——after these diversions. I want to point out that we do not believe in the duplication of official functionaries. I share Senator Dr. Ryan's view that we ought not to build up a structure that is too complex or that contains too numerous strata. I think, therefore, that the district court is well suited for the granting of certificates of qualification to anybody who wants to embark on what would appear nowadays to be the very perilous business of engaging in the business of livestock mart. In amendment No. 8, which is down in my name, we propose not only that the application should be made in open court, but that the district justice ought to take into account the character, the conduct and fitness of the applicant, the fitness and convenience of the place and, as the courts have done successfully over the years in relation to other matters, take the businessman's view of it, consider whether or not there are an undue number of livestock marts in the area where it is proposed to carry on the mart in respect of which the application is being made to the court and, on that application, the Minister, livestock mart owners and any other person interested can come in and make his objections and, in the light of these objections, as the court does at present in relation, for instance, to dance hall licences, the court can impose its conditions.

I want to say that if the Minister is persuaded, as undoubtedly he has been, that it is right and proper that an investigation into the refusal by him to grant a licence to a prospective livestock mart proprietor or into his revocation of a licence should be the subject of an inquiry by a barrister of ten years standing——

Comment on this

The barrister speaking at the moment was often in a mart himself and knows what a mart is.

Comment on this

If the Minister has been persuaded into thinking that a barrister of ten years standing has some contribution to make to his deliberations——

Comment on this

Contribution is very easy. There is no necessity for a barrister.

Comment on this

I entirely agree. That is why I am entirely opposed to the idea of introducing barristers, licences, permissions or regulations into the conduct of livestock marts. The Senator has a point there and has, at least, if not the substance, certainly the spirit of this Bill within him. At any rate, if the Minister, as I say, has been persuaded to bring into his deliberations a barrister of ten years' standing, a much stronger case could be made by the Minister and by anybody else speaking on this Bill for going the whole way and leaving these considerations to the courts which the people have established to adjudicate on differences between themselves individually and between themselves and the Government.

It is for that reason that my Party are utterly opposed to the notion that a licence has to be sought, that a licence can be revoked by a Minister of State and that we think, in common with the many other people outside this House and the proposers and seconders of amendment No. 7, that this entire matter of deciding upon who shall have a licence or who shall conduct marts, who shall adjudicate on whether they are being conducted or not, should be left to the courts and not to the Minister.

Senator Stanford rose.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The House understands that we are taking these various groups and they are being discussed in the one debate? There will be separate decisions, of course. It is rather confusing, possibly, but the basis appears to be roughly the same.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to amendment No. 7, which stands in my name and in the names of Senator Quinlan, Senator Dónal Ó Conalláin and Senator Jessop. We put down this amendment primarily on a matter of principle. As we know, or as we should know, in this House, the welfare of our country depends on an equilibrium. It depends on an equilibrium between the Government and the courts, mainly, or between the Government and the Parliament and the courts. If we upset that equilibrium, if we disturb it, we are going to harm the ultimate welfare of our country. The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that at a delicate point of equilibrium the courts will have the ultimate decision.

I have been talking to honoured members of the Fianna Fáil Party on this matter and I know that this is a fine line to draw. I know that there are many matters in which the Minister grants the licence. I know that there are other matters in which the courts grant the licence. I think particularly of dance halls; I think of public houses. So the question in my mind is at which side of this fine line should this particular piece of licensing fall, and I am convinced personally that it should go to the courts, for several reasons: first, because it seems to me that where the representatives of the legal body have spoken they are firmly of the opinion that this should be a matter for their decision; secondly, I agree with the argument put forward by Fine Gael speakers that it would be unfortunate in the present climate of opinion in the country if it seemed —and I emphasise the word "seemed"—that the Government were taking powers which might be punitive—and I emphasise the word "punitive".

I do not think we can be at all sure about the probability of this. But the fact is that many people in the country fear that this power of licensing might be used in a punitive way. So, we have the lawyers as a body and we have a good many of the farmers and other citizens of the country perturbed about giving the powers of licensing to the Minister here.

There is another body I should like to mention, an honourable and highly respected one, the Irish Association of Civil Liberty.

Comment on this

I am a country man and I should like to ask a few questions so far as your contribution is concerned to the effect that the Dáil and Seanad have no function whatsoever, only the courts.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator must not interrupt.

Comment on this

The Senator is very disorderly.

Comment on this

He should listen and learn.

Comment on this

I was referring to this respected and, as I think, honourable body, the Irish Association of Civil Liberty. They have no political affiliations. They are not, I hasten to add, to be confused with another body of similar name—a very confusing similarity—which is very much more radical than the original Irish Association of Civil Liberty. This Association has gone into this question in considerable detail and has very firmly come out in the public press against the taking of powers of licensing in this case by the Minister.

I think it is clear from the Bill itself that the Minister and the Government have qualms in this matter. That is the reason, obviously, why they suggest that if there is need for arbitration a barrister of ten years standing should be called to arbitrate. This will not do at all. It is halfway between two points of view and I do not think it satisfies either. To be quite frank, there is the gravest risk that such a barrister of ten years standing may have clear Party affiliations. In fact his promotion for the next ten years may depend exactly on how he decides matters of this kind. There is a very grave risk there. It is a risk which would not arise if a judge or a district justice, who is exempt and free from Party affiliations, should have this task. It seems to me crystal clear that it is highly desirable for the courts to have this decision.

I would appeal to the Minister, first, in terms of the general political theory —the kind of political theory on which I think almost all thinkers would agree —of the necessity for this equilibrium in the forces in the State; and, secondly, on the matter of expediency, that at this moment of some public alarm, it would be most regrettable to give the impression that this Bill will be used punitively. There are many things in this Bill that are desirable and good, but in this instance a fundamental issue is raised, and I would appeal to the Minister to consider it in that light.

Comment on this

I wish to support the amendment. The Senator has made a very excellent case for it, showing that if we believe in Government of the people, for the people and by the people—in other words, if we believe in democracy—the views of the overwhelming majority of the citizens of this State should carry weight. The association best in a position to adjudicate on the division of powers between the Legislature and the judiciary, that is, the Incorporated Law Society, have made their position completely clear in this situation, that they believe this is a matter for the courts. If the Minister and the Government can get away with the present effort, then it is the beginning of the end, for all licensing will pass on to the respective Ministers to be there fought and contested on Party political lines. If any local group wish to object to the setting up of a mart in their area, what is the proper thing to do? Get hold of your local TDs and send them after the Minister concerned; get them to put Party pressure on the Minister; get the local cumainn to pass resolutions and have those resolutions sent to the Minister. That is the logical outcome and, apparently, it is the only way to influence the Minister's decision.

Then if the Minister grants a licence or refuses it and an appeal is desired or required, we have what one can only call a farce, this so-called appeal to a barrister of ten years standing, a barrister who is already standing in the queue to be elevated to a judgeship at the next possible opening. Surely the people cannot look on such an arbitration scheme as a substitute for the cold, dispassionate judgment of the court itself. This would not be accepted in a civilised or democratic country. Indeed, I have a headline here from the Irish Times of 27th July, which says: “Lynch for Paris in October: Tackling the last hurdle armed with five EEC assurances”— and fettered by the Marts Bill, because that is what it is. In other words, it is proof positive to the other countries in Europe that we have not got a proper conception of democracy——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would the Senator tell us who said that?

Comment on this

We do not know the position occupied by international organisations.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would the Senator tell us what he is quoting from?

Comment on this

The Irish Times of Thursday, July 27th.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will the Senator quote it in full?

Comment on this

He should. It bears repetition.

Comment on this

The heading says: "Lynch for Paris in October", and the subheading is: "Tackling the last hurdle armed with five EEC assurances", and I suggest that should be coupled with "and fettered——

Comment on this

End of quotation.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Where did the other thing come in?

Comment on this

The cleverality of the Senator.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would the Senator have the grace to withdraw it?

Comment on this

It is indicative of the Minister's attitude—

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will the Senator withdraw that aspersion on the integrity of the Irish Times?

Comment on this

It is significant, on this crucial and most important amendment aimed at the central defect in this Marts Bill, that the Minister has seen fit to depart from the House.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If that is the type of distortion the Senator has to use—

Comment on this

The only question posed by Senator Stanford here has been this question of which licences go to the courts and which are the subject of ministerial decision.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nobody could take the Senator seriously after that.

Comment on this

We have to be very clear on the difference between the Dairy Produce Bill, 1928, the Seed Production Bill, the feeding stuffs Bill and other such legislation. In each of those cases, the legislation is dealing with a quality end product.

Comment on this

Cattle are not, of course.

Comment on this

No, and if Senator Yeats knew a little more about agriculture and spent a little more time out of Dublin, he would see the difference between a pound of butter and a bullock.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If Senator Quinlan spent a little more time in the Seanad, he would get used to telling the truth.

Comment on this

He would see that in the case of the quality end product, the whole reputation of the product depends on keeping a quality control. To that end a section has to be set up charged with the keeping of that control, in this case, in the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries. That section is empowered—and again quite rightly—to take drastic steps to ensure that our product is safeguarded and that its quality and its good name remain. However, in the case of the product of the mart, which is a bullock, he is not an end product; he is merely the product as it stands and later on has to be processed through a meat processing factory.

Comment on this

We should never have known if the Senator did not tell us.

Comment on this

You cannot take fundamentals too carefully, because we see the confusion that is being created in regard to the very simple difference between the two, showing that while one is appropriate for Ministerial action, the other is not. Senator Yeats was shocked in the last debate at the fact that a Minister had power to send inspectors in to burn some crops growing in a field but if the Senator knew a little more about the production of quality seeds he would realise that in producing seeds of this kind—it was probably beet seed or something like that—steps must be taken to ensure that there is not cross pollination of the seeds. To that end, certain other seeds cannot be grown within a specified area surrounding that field and consequently——

Comment on this

Can there not be an appeal?

Comment on this

There cannot be an appeal against established facts, as to whether the seed is growing there or not. Commonsense applies to these things. We must take account of what is happening in other countries. Especially at a time when we are so conscious of the international position and when, apparently, we cannot talk or even think of existence outside of association with EEC, one would imagine that in addition to gearing our industries and our organisations for competition in the EEC we would also be concerned to find out how they operate in the EEC, how their legislation works, and that we should be taking steps gradually to harmonise our laws with common practice in the EEC countries. In fact, the Minister for Justice assured the House some four years ago that that was the main aim of the law reform section in the Department of Justice and to that end they have brought in at least three or four Bills aimed at such law reform. Why then, if that is desirable—as, indeed, it is—depart so radically at the present juncture because nowhere in Western Europe is there anything approaching the type of licensing system that is proposed here?

We need only look across the Border and we see that there is not any licensing system in vogue there where they have only some controls in conjunction with efficiency payments as operated through the marts. The same practice prevails in England and we find that while our Minister is engaged in what I might call a nineteenth century feud with the farming organisations and with his failure to accord to that organisation the status it should have in any modern democratic state, in England there has been a complete review in a Bill which became an Act within the last year and which I have here with me, a Bill to establish a meat and livestock commission. This was the British approach to the same problem, something that had no relation to the advent here of the National Agricultural Council. In the British case the functions of the committee are carefully spelled out and the wide powers given to this commission include power to establish a meat and livestock commission and make other provision for the livestock and livestock products industries; to authorise grants for improvements of agricultural lands and make provision with respect to the shape and size of farms and related matters; agriculture and forestry on hill land, co-operative activities in agriculture; diseases of animals and other matters connected with agriculture. In other words, this is a fully comprehensive approach to the full development of agriculture by what we might call, in effect, a semi-State organisation, a body that has an independent existence. It has its functions spelled out very clearly in the Bill which runs to 94 pages. It is something that anyone concerned with the problem of the scientific and logical development of agriculture should study to see that in the scope of this commission there is integrated all the factors, the production, the processing and marketing. All these are combined in the one commission.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator holding up the English Government as an example for us to follow?

Comment on this

I think we can learn a bit from them. I am never ashamed to learn from any other organisation which can offer us a good example.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator recall his speech on the Free Trade Area two years ago and his opinions then in common with Senator FitzGerald?

Comment on this

Yes, and I stand over them as a scientist.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not be such a hypocrite.

Comment on this

Senator Ó Maoláin is going too far. Senator Quinlan is making a perfectly reasonable and logical statement and it is intolerable that the Leader of the House should set a bad example.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

He did not set the example. These interruptions have been happening all through the debate.

Comment on this

We are considering the position in England where marts are not licensed. In connection with the provisions regarding marts, I should like to go through several pages but I have referred the House to this Act which is available in the Library, but I want to refer particularly to pages 76 and 77 which set out the functions of the commission. I shall quote the relevant part dealing with livestock markets: Article (1) deals with:

Advising on suitable and fair terms (other than financial terms) of contracts for the sale of livestock and meat, and preparing model or standard terms for inclusion in such contracts.

(2) Giving advice and information to assist buyers and sellers of livestock and meat to make bargains and do business.

—again "advising".

Section 9, subsection (1), provides for:

Giving advice and information to those owning, conducting or using livestock auction markets on the efficient lay-out, design and operation of such markets, including in particular efficient methods of handling and penning livestock, and generally on matters conducive to efficiency.

(2) Compiling standard codes of practice for any of the activities connected with livestock auction markets with a view to their efficient and equitable organisation.

Comment on this

Yes, it is excellent. In other words, the commission will work in full harmony with the owners and advise them all the time. That is not the type of dictatorship proposed in this Bill.

Comment on this

That is wrong: you know it is wrong.

Comment on this

In respect of recommendations to the Government for adoption by the Government, section 5, subsection (4), sets out:

If at any time the Commission are satisfied—

(a) that a system compiled under this section is practicable, and

(b) that they have obtained sufficient experience of the operation of the system, and

(c) that they have the resources and facilities required to operate the system,

they shall submit particulars of the system to the Ministers with the view to the making of an order under the next following section.

In other words, they are to proceed gradually and to learn by experiment, and they are to be certain that what they are recommending is operable before they make any recommendation to the Ministers. That is an excellent safeguard.

A great deal of capital has been made out of the fact that orders made by the Minister will be laid before both Houses and may be annulled within 21 days without in any way preventing anything being done under the order in the intermediate period. In the English Act, subsection (11) provides:

No order shall be made under this section unless a draft of the order has been laid before and approved by a resolution of each House of Parliament.

This is a positive and democratic approach rather than a negative approach. Nothing is done until Parliament has endorsed and approved the order. That is a much more satisfactory procedure than the one we have of locking the stable door when the horse has fied.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

What the Senator is saying is very relevant to the Bill but I am wondering what it has to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

My amendment seeks to have the powers sought exercised by the courts rather than by the Minister. I am showing that the powers sought are completely undemocratic in any case, and that they are much more severe and more totalitarian than any corresponding legislation in operation in Northern Ireland, in England or in the EEC countries.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Did the Senator read them all?

Comment on this

I do not see any need for such legislation. The marts are there and have established themselves. There is a need for certain minor types of control to prevent mushroom growth but that period is past. We have a fairly stabilised system. The Minister is now insisting that we are to have licensing, whether we like it or not. In that case I want to ensure that it at least becomes a duty of the courts, rather than a prerogative of the Minister concerned.

I have adduced arguments showing that this legislation is totally out of step with the rest of Europe. In fact, if we were taking the Border seriously —which I do not think the Minister is—there should be an effort to coordinate the legislation here with the legislation in operation in Northern Ireland. There should at least be an effort not to bring in legislation here that the people in Northern Ireland would feel was repugnant to their ideas of freedom and liberty.

Anyone concerned with the freedom of the individual—and that applies to all citizens—would regard this Bill as a totally unnecessary intrusion by the State into the realm of the activities of private enterprise and co-operation. Any democracy or any group of citizens with any concept of freedom would view with horror and alarm the entrusting of these licensing powers in this Bill to the Minister. They would take it that we were substituting political pressure for reasoned argument within the courts, that any group of citizens who wished to object to a proposal to set up a mart in a certain area would be compelled to use political pressure as a means of registering their objection rather than briefing a barrister and having him go to court and present their case there.

In the past few days we have read of the operation of the courts in regard to the supermarkets. Even though they operated under a law which was over 80 years old, adequate scope was provided for the registering of objections—both the Minister's objection to the granting of licences and the reasons for it, and the right of the owner to defend his application in open court. He also has a right to appeal. That is democracy and I cannot see why it cannot apply here as elsewhere.

As mentioned by Senator Stanford, it is doubly necessary at a time when relations are in such a very unhappy condition between the Minister and the farming community that legislation that appears to be punitive should not be brought in and that powers should not be given to the Minister which people might feel could be used against any farming organisation. There is no need to mince words. If this is aimed at any organisation, it is aimed at the National Farmers' Association. No organisation has done more to uplift standards in agriculture, to improve production and make people efficiency-conscious than the NFA.

I cannot see how our application to join the EEC is strengthened when one of the steps the Government are taking in preparation for joining the EEC is an effort to break the main farmers' organisation, an organisation with 126,000 members. Tomorrow when the change from one president to another takes place, the president of the Ulster Farmers' Union will be an honoured guest at the change-over. That is the organisation the President of which, Mr. Deasy, held very urgent and necessary talks three days ago with his counterpart in the British farmers' association on mutual problems in relation to the marketing of cattle. These are all natural functions and this is the sort of thing which has been too long delayed. Ministers have appealed to the farmers to get together and form a single organisation. That single organisation is now there and it is up to the Minister and the Government to give it both the necessary recognition and the necessary status to ensure that it can play its proper role in the future development of agriculture within or without the European Economic Community.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator, I take it this is a passing reference.

Comment on this

A passing reference but, again, this is one of those things which sows the seed for the legislation before the House. We must face facts. I endorse Senator Stanford's appeal. Even at this late stage I would ask the Minister to prove himself a big man by divesting himself of this proposed power and give it instead to the courts where it rightfully belongs. I appeal to him to take that positive step towards the rationalisation of functions as between the Legislature and the Judiciary because, if we get into the European Economic Community, our future will lie on this division of power since the orders will not then be coming from the Minister or the Department of Agriculture; they will be coming from Brussels and if we vest this power in the courts and they use it well it will become even more significant than it might appear to be now. Secondly, I would ask the Minister to show that there is a purpose being served by talking in this House, to show that he is open to reason. I trust he will get up and make a dramatic announcement indicating that he will send this portion of the Bill back to where it rightfully belongs, to the Irish courts set up by the Irish people and backed by the Irish people.

Comment on this

Perhaps the House would give the Minister the opportunity of replying to the general points.

Comment on this

He is entitled to speak, I think, as often as he likes in this debate.

Comment on this

At this juncture perhaps the House would like to hear the Minister on the general points so far.

Comment on this

My intervention may or may not be dramatic but the announcement that Senator Quinlan is anxious to hear is unlikely to be, I am sorry to say, dramatic in the sense that he wishes it to be. I have heard only part of what Senator Quinlan had to say but, from the little I did hear, his role here in this debate would seem to be that of an advocate or a recruiting officer for the NFA. I do not know what that has got to do with this particular Bill and I cannot understand why it was repeated parrot-like by the Senator, as it has been repeated by his Fine Gael colleagues here and in the other House, that this measure is vindictive and this is a Bill of vengeance. I do not know what sort of little minds people who talk like that have got.

Have they any idea what the Bill is about? Why do they not read the Bill and find out for themselves what it is about instead of taking their cue from others, coming along here to assert that this Bill is aimed against the NFA? I said before—I repeat it now—that I have no row with the NFA. I object to the farming community being regarded as one and the same thing as the NFA and, from that point of view, I take the Senator who has just sat down to task. I have already appealed to other Senators and told them that they are either deliberately or intentionally trying to create difficulties by insisting that the NFA is the farming community of this country.

Comment on this

The Minister is clearly suffering from a delusion if he thinks he has not got a row with the NFA.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Relations are excellent.

Comment on this

My relationship with the farming community is, as I have already stated——

Comment on this

At its lowest.

Comment on this

——excellent and, so far as the NFA are concerned, I have not had a row with them. I have no row with them and, if they are making rows, that is their affair. I should not really have started to deal with the points made by Senator Quinlan first because he was the last speaker, but the whole tone of his speech consisted in harping on this idea that this Government have something to do with the NFA and the NFA represent the entire farming community and I am accused of trying to do down the farming community by introducing a Bill of vengeance directed at the NFA. The fact is I have brought in a Bill to license livestock marts, something of which none of us here, contrary to what Senator Quinlan thinks, need be ashamed. There is nothing undemocratic about this particular measure and nothing totalitarian. I am really shocked that Senator Quinlan should suggest I should model my legislation and behaviour on examples set in the Six Counties, a place about which I know a good deal more than the Senator does. I shall say no more than that.

The suggestion is that the giving of this power to the Minister is something unparalleled in the Six Counties, in Britain and in the EEC. They are, however, paralleled in many measures operative in this country today. I instance the dairy Acts, the Pigs and Bacon Acts, the control of AI stations, the Seeds and Fertilisers Act and the Planning Act of 1963, about which we heard so much from Senator O'Quigley.

Comment on this

Was it not opposed tooth and nail in the Dáil?

Comment on this

It is on record. On the Committee Stage, there were some 253 amendments. There were no divisions on any of them throughout the entire Committee Stage.

Comment on this

Tell us about the Report Stage?

Comment on this

The Senator wants to know about the Report Stage. There were 24 amendments agreed, five withdrawn and three not moved. One amendment was negatived. There was no division on the Report Stage and no division on the Final Stage. For the Senator's information, there is on record something which I think he should read and learn off, from somebody who was the Leader of his Party at that particular time. He had the clear situation developed, with which I am sure the Senator could not but agree at the time, since he was the Leader of the Fine Gael Party: at the end of the entire proceedings, we had a speech from the then Leader of the Opposition and the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, and this speech——

Comment on this

He paid tribute to Deputy Jones and generally to the manner in which the debate was conducted in the House.

Comment on this

Will the Senator just wait for this? This is something the Senator should know about because it is the most important statement by the Leader of his Party at that time in regard to the Planning Act. The reason he made this particular statement is that we had the situation of a very difficult Bill going through the Dáil with at least 253 amendments, and while those amendments were discussed, while they were put down by various people, we find that, in fact, there was no division on any of them. Surely to heavens the Senator at this stage must admit that he is in cloud-cuckooland when he talks about the total opposition of Fine Gael to the Planning Act, that they were going to try to amend it at this stage and that he should then go so far in his hallucinations as to challenge me and say: "If not on the Committee Stage, it must have been on the Report Stage". There, again, there were 33 amendments and not a division on the 33.

Comment on this

The Minister accepted some amendments.

Comment on this

Two hundred and forty-two agreed, three not moved and one negatived: no division on Report Stage and no division on the Final Stage, and a speech by Deputy Dillon at that time not just praising Deputy Jones but going on a little further. At column 1662 of volume 204, of the Official Report of 19th July, 1963, here is what Deputy Dillon had to say:

I would like to say a valedictory word on this Bill before it leaves the House. As an experienced parliamentarian, I have participated in a very minor and insignificant way in the discussions on this Bill but I have been a close observer of its progress in this House. As an experienced politician, I accept the principle that it is never expedient to praise a member of the Administration——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He was right in that obviously.

Comment on this

——but, subject to that reservation, we have reason to congratulate the Minister and Deputy Jones for a very fine performance in the enactment of a formidable piece of legislation which, we are all probably agreed, has been improved by its passage through this House.

Comment on this
Mr. Ó Maoláin

That is why they sent him to limbo.

Comment on this

He went on:

It would be only becoming for me here to express fully my admiration for the manner in which Deputy Jones has dealt with this piece of legislation on behalf of our Party and the Opposition. His encyclopaedic knowledge of it and his unfailing diligence and skill in bringing before the House those aspects of the legislation which we thought were susceptible of improvement have resulted in very valuable amendments to this Bill. That, in turn, resulted in an accented demonstration of the perfection of parliamentary legislation. That, I freely admit, could not have happened if Deputy Jones's efforts had not been met by the Minister, and when I speak of the Minister I speak of him in the widest sense of that term, in the spirit in which he has met them.

Comment on this

Ha, ha!

Comment on this

Maybe Senator O'Quigley would feel that that is enough of this at this stage. That surely crucifies his argument here about the Planning Act as a bit of legislation that was pushed through and that Fine Gael fought against——

Comment on this

We put down 253 amendments and the Minister accepted——

Comment on this

——when we find his Leader at that time talking in terms in which no person in the Opposition ever talked of a Minister of State in relation to any piece of legislation, not to speak of a Bill that was opposed, as Senator O'Quigley was asserting here this evening.

Comment on this

I have spoken in those terms in this House about the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

The Planning Act was a bad, bad choice.

Comment on this

I shall go back to it tomorrow.

Comment on this

It was a very bad choice.

Comment on this

The Minister has to get Deputy Dillon to help him; he cannot get the members of his own Party to help.

Comment on this

Two hundred and eighty six opportunities by way of amendment and on not one was there a division.

Comment on this

Because the Minister said he was looking into——

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would allow the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

Two hundred and eighty six amendments on the various stages of that Bill and on not one was there a division, nor was there a division on the Report Stage, nor was there a division on the Final Stage of the passage of that very complicated bit of legislation, and then we had this speech by the then Leader of the Party. Maybe that was why he was dumped since—I do not know—but the fact is that Senator O'Quigley could not have picked a worse runner to support his argument or carry his colours than the Planning Act.

Comment on this

Tomorrow is another day.

Comment on this

Having said that, we have the other Acts I mentioned which are much more appropriate and have much more in common with the measure before us now. We have the Dairying Act running for 39 years where the creameries operate under licences granted at the sole discretion of the Minister for Agriculture, whoever he may have been or whoever he may be at whatever time those licences are sought. Will anybody suggest, including Senator Quinlan, that there are not a great number of those licences under which many creameries operate today? I challenge the Senator, and any other person here or outside this House, to say that there has, at any stage, been any effort made to upset that particular piece of legislation on any basis but particularly do I challenge anybody to suggest that there has been an attempt to upset or repeal or amend it on the basis that it was unfairly used, either politically or otherwise, by any Minister under any Government in the past 39 years.

This sort of legislation has been in operation since 1928, giving the Minister for Agriculture these powers at his sole discretion and without having to report to the Dáil either that he has refused or revoked a licence or give any reason for it which I am obliging the Minister for Agriculture to do under this Bill. These things have been in operation and not a finger has ever been raised and not a word has ever been said, and I challenge those who are challenging this Bill and the powers being sought by the Minister and the Government to say that there ever has been cause for complaint in this regard. Thirty-nine years of operation is surely a far better testimonial to the impartial manner of operation of the Ministers for Agriculture of this sort of power than all the gibbering that may have come from those who oppose a similar sort of power being given to the Minister today. Surely this is commonsense. Surely this is a logical way to look at things? If we do not agree that the 1928 Act makes up our minds, that one swallow never made a summer, let us look at the provisions of the 1935 Pigs and Bacon Act, where we find again——

Comment on this

The Minister is equating a pound of butter to a bullock.

Comment on this

I am afraid I do not understand.

Comment on this

One is a quality end product; the other is not.

Comment on this

That is the answer.

Comment on this

The butter is an end product of cows. What does the Senator call bullocks and heifers? Are they not end products of the same cows?

Comment on this

I do not know where they come from so. Whatever sort of produce it is I do not quite know.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister must eat no meat obviously.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator might be able to help me in this one. We have the AI stations and the licensing of those stations. This again falls within the discretion of the Minister for Agriculture. What are they dealing with? Are they end products? I will not press that one. I will leave you to think over that until tomorrow. We have the fertilisers, feedingstuffs and mineral mixtures. Are they end products?

Comment on this

They are quality products.

Comment on this

The Senator is getting slightly mixed up. It is the next one he will say is a quality product. The Seed Production Act is a quality one. The Fertiliser, Feedingstuffs and Mineral Mixtures Act was passed under another Government, as was the Seed Act around the same time by the same Government. In every one of those Acts going back to 1956, 1947 and 1928, the Minister for Agriculture is given those particular powers. I have those powers today under those Acts in regard to all these things and nobody has, to my knowledge, made a complaint in regard to this Minister or any previous Minister having those powers. No such complaint has been received in regard to those pieces of legislation over the years.

Comment on this

There was no dispute.

Comment on this

You cannot get away from the fact that none of those Acts requests the Minister to bring to the Oireachtas his reason for revoking licences. He is not obliged to give any reason for doing so. Under this Bill, which is so much objected to because of this particular intention, which all sorts of people are talking about as a bad thing and that we should send it to the courts, the Minister is obliged to make his reasons for revoking licences known to the Oireachtas. There has been a lot of talk about the courts here and about how they have no difficulty in administering licences under the different Acts. There has been talk about dancehall and publichouse licences. I have already said—I have no hesitation in putting forward the point again—that there is not a true analogy to be drawn between the granting of dancehall licences, publichouse licences and the granting of licences for livestock marts. The reason I say this is that those who have to deal with this deal with public health and the courts deal with the public morals of our people.

Comment on this

May I just ask the Minister about auctioneers?

Comment on this

I have not made myself up on that one, and unlike some of the other speakers here, I do not, as Senator O'Quigley would say, anticipate what I am going to say. If I do not deal with this at the moments, it is not because I do not intend to. There are other matters I want to deal with now. I will remember the question and will come back to it at a later time.

All this hysteria that is being developed, pseudo-hysteria so far as Fine Gael are concerned, just does not ring true. The fact is that Senator O'Quigley before tea had a clear mind as to whether it is total opposition to the Bill which is the Fine Gael line, or whether it is his own line, to drive a coach and four through it and render it ineffective. He said that any good lawyer, including himself, could show how that could be done. That clear mind has disappeared since tea. I do not know whether he got a message about this or whether there is some other reason, but he is now reverting to the Fine Gael, line of total opposition for opposition's sake. I want to say that this really will not work.

There was all the talk about the provision in relation to barristers of ten years standing, that it is of no use, that it has no meaning. I notice that in fact barristers have not been mentioned at all since tea. This does not sound too good coming from those people. I mentioned the Pigs and Bacon Act of 1935. I am not aware that any particular objection has been made by Fine Gael over the years in regard to it. For the benefit of Senators who are interested, I refer to subsection (3) (c) (1) of section 30 of that Act. There they will find without doubt, without any change whatsoever, the same thing as is contained in this Bill, setting apart a barrister of ten years standing to make certain inquiries.

Comment on this

Is that as an arbitrator, that report to the Minister?

Comment on this

I have given ample references to enable the Senator to follow this up.

Comment on this

The Minister might be a little more helpful.

Comment on this

I am trying to be more helpful but there are other things I have to say before ten o'clock, and I only have a few minutes left. There are other provisions in some of those other pieces of legislation which are exactly the same as in this Bill.

Comment on this

They are other Fianna Fáil pieces of legislation.

Comment on this

I come again to Senator Quinlan. This Bill is designed, according to the Senator, to break the NFA and is not a preparation for the EEC. It is quite obvious the Senator has not been in circulation at all lately because he would realise that this is not what he says it is. He says it is a measure to break the NFA and secondly, it is not part of our preparation for the EEC or not the only thing we may be doing in preparation for the EEC. Again, I would refer him to the various newspapers, and suggest not that he read merely the various headlines, as apparently he did earlier today, but take a selection from over the past four or five weeks and to read the debates in the Dáil on the Adjournment motion. He will find that a great deal is being done in our preparation for our possible entry into the EEC in the years which lie ahead. A great deal more remains to be done and we are finding ways of doing this.

This Bill, I must reiterate, is in essence a measure that will perpetuate the rights of our farmers to sell their cattle without let, hindrance, intimidation or victimisation by any person in any part of this country who sets out to operate what we commonly regard, as a livestock mart. The reason for this asserting of those rights is to make sure that the rights of farmers to buy and sell will be preserved in the future when marts will by and large supplant fairs. Where the marts are successful, the fairs will gradually disappear.

Comment on this

Is there any great urgency?

Comment on this

I am not in a hurry about it. I am quite prepared to talk about it until the cows come home, quite prepared to talk about it again tomorrow.

Comment on this

Let the Minister get back to what he was talking about.

Comment on this

With regard to the urgency of this legislation, it was ordered to be printed on 31st May last. It is a very ordinary piece of legislation with several precepts in it relating to agricultural matters. Surely it is not our fault if Fine Gael cannot understand it, and if in addition the Labour Party, of which I understand Senator McQuillan is a member, cannot understand it. We have to be ever grateful to the Incorporated Law Society who were so succinct in their views in the matter, which they published in the newspapers. They had not the courtesy to send their thoughts to me but no fault to them—they are an eminent body.

Comment on this