We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–226 of 675. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Livestock Marts Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 13 of 1967 ›

The Minister had some things to say about this amendment last night which it is necessary to clear up. The Minister was at great pains to show the position in relation to previous legislation about which I shall not go into detail now. I have not got a clatter of civil servants to do research for me and to get me all the details in regard to what went on since 1924. I do not propose to follow the Minister down along that path. What happened in 1928, 1936, 1955 and 1956 was, as I have said before—and I hate repeating myself—dealt with in a time of calm. There was no questioning the bona fides of the Minister who introduced the legislation to deal with an existing difficulty or to anticipate or apprehend even a particular difficulty. That is not this case.

What is done at present, notwithstanding the euphoric atmosphere in which the Minister chooses or pretends to live, is that the machinery of Parliament is being used as an instrument for wreaking revenge on a section of the community. When that kind of situation develops, everybody is called to an abrupt halt. Everybody asks himself or herself if it is right that the machinery of Parliament should be used in this way. Once the Minister's motives are suspect, then the House, the Dáil, the Press, various organisations around the country, and the public, are apt to take a look at what has been going on in the past and what is being done in the present.

When one sees the manner in which the Local Government (Planning and Development) Act has, in fact, been operated—and I am going to say no more than that—one begins to see how absolutely dangerous it is to vest absolute power in a final way in a Minister of State. Because of that, the Fine Gael Party have put down a Bill in the Dáil to remove the power of deciding planning permission appeals and related matters from the Minister for Local Government and proposing that it should be vested in a planning board which will consist of a judge of one of our courts and assessors to assist him.

Comment on this

May I draw the attention of the Senator to the fact that he has already made that statement?

Comment on this

Several times.

Comment on this

But the Minister chooses to say that Fine Gael were quite happy with the Local Government (Planning and Development) Act, 1963, and that there were no divisions on it. I want to counter that by saying yes, that they might have been prepared to repose trust in the Minister in 1963 but having had the experience of the way in which that Act has been operated, they have given evidence, by the way in which they put down a Bill in Parliament, to show that they are no longer prepared to do that. Certainly in this Bill we are not prepared to vest the power of deciding whether a mart should come into existence, or remain in existence, in a Minister of State.

Let us look at the provisions of section 3 of this Bill. First of all, the Minister, in subsection (2), may "at the time of the granting of a licence, attach to the licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify in the licence." We find that the Minister "may if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence" and he may also, if the holder is guilty of an offence, if he thinks fit, revoke the licence, so that the Minister is going to become prosecutor and judge and jury in relation to any licence. If that accords with the notions of justice held by the Fianna Fáil Party, it certainly does not accord with the simple notions of natural justice held by the vast majority of the people and the fact that the Minister proposes to issue the death certificate in the form of laying a statement before each House of the Oireachtas does not bring back to life the mart which has been closed down by the say-so of the Minister.

When the Minister talked about what went on in the Dail, a certain softness came over him which has not been noticeable previously in this House, especially during this debate. One thought it rather nice of the Minister and one began to think that there was no such a thing as a really hard Minister for Agriculture in the person of the present Minister. We heard him saying that Deputy Dillon in 1963 said that he was a very nice person and that "he had words of praise to say of me," and he quoted with approval what Deputy Dillon said about him. That was a very nice interlude, showing how susceptible even a Minister in charge of the Mafia from Donegal is to a little flattery.

Comment on this

Showing how wrong you were.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Could we have, Sir, an explanation from Senator O'Quigley in regard to his reference to this Italian organisation, the Mafia? I am sick and tired listening to this and I should like to know what he means.

Comment on this

The Senator should ask the Minister——

Comment on this

Italian affairs would not be in order on this amendment.

Comment on this

I rather thought that would be the ruling. I am prohibited from explaining because Italian affairs are out of order on this amendment.

Comment on this

The Senator will now become relevant.

Comment on this

I want to say that in the Dáil on the Local Government (Planning and Development) Act, Deputy Jones, in numerous amendments——

Comment on this

This has already been mentioned by the Senator.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

By the Minister.

Comment on this

If the Minister makes a statement which requires to be corrected, I think I am in order in correcting it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Minister was answering the Senator.

Comment on this

Standing Orders state clearly that irrelevancy and repetition in debate are out of order.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

But the Planning Act would hardly be out of order or the Minister would have been out of order over a long period.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley to continue on the amendment.

Comment on this

I am trying to be relevant but I suppose if one tries to follow the Minister for Agriculture and tries to correct him, one is inevitably inclined to go wrong and to find oneself in trouble with the Chair for being irrelevant. I think it is not irrelevant to point out that what the Minister and the Fianna Fáil Party are seeking in this Bill is the kind of power which properly cannot and ought not, under our Constitution, be exercised by a Minister of State.

Comment on this

Like the Blueshirt powers.

Comment on this

Oisín speaks again.

Comment on this

Blueshirt dictatorship.

Comment on this

I have already, in passing, referred to the decision of the Supreme Court. Either the Fianna Fáil Party accept decisions of the Supreme Court or they do not. If they do not, they should say so. I understand that the Constitution provides that the Supreme Court will have the final say in whether the enactments of the Oireachtas are constitutional or not, and it is relevant on this Bill to draw attention to the close analogy that exists between the granting of a licence by a Minister of State and its revocation by him, even after an inquiry by a barrister of ten years standing, and the situation which obtained under the Solicitors Act, 1954, under which a Disciplinary Committee, consisting of solicitors, was established to investigate charges of unprofessional conduct or misconduct on the part of solicitors. That was a body consisting of solicitors' peers skilled in law and, one would have thought, not unsuited to adjudicate whether a particular solicitor had done right or wrong. Even after the solicitor had been adjudicated guilty of misconduct by the Disciplinary Committee, he had a right of appeal to the Chief Justice. That safeguard was provided in the Solicitors Act, 1954, and the Supreme Court held, and it is on record for everybody to read in the 1960 Irish Reports, beginning on page 239, that:

The question of whether or not a solicitor is to be allowed continue to practise his profession is a justifiable controversy.

By its adjudication the Disciplinary Committee purports to decide the controversy in a final manner and, if necessary, its decision will be enforced by the authority of the State.

The Disciplinary Committee, in ordering the applicants' names should be struck off the roll of solicitors were purporting to exercise judicial power.

It went on to say:

That as the powers were limited to solicitors and were subject to a right of appeal to the Courts, the said powers were of a limited nature within the meaning of Article 37 of the Constitution.

The Report also said that the powers and functions conferred by the Act on the Committee could not be described as merely limited powers and functions of a judicial nature within Article 37 of the Constitution and accordingly the exercise of such power was unconstitutional and accordingly the appellants were invalidly struck off the roll of solicitors.

Now the short point in all of this and the relevance and the acute relevance of this particular decision to the present Bill is this. A solicitor is entitled to practise by virtue of a statute, an Act of Parliament. The proprietor of a livestock mart is to be entitled to set up business and to continue in business by virtue of a licence to be given to him by a Minister of State. The decision whether he will continue as the proprietor of a livestock mart or not is going to be determined by a Minister of State. If it is wrong or unconstitutional for the disciplinary Committee of the Law Society to strike off the rolls a solicitor and prevent him from practising, it seems to me that, if a Minister of State decides to revoke the licence of an owner of a livestock mart and prevent him from continuing the business of a livestock mart, it is equally unconstitutional and that the power proposed to be given in this Bill to a Minister of State is a power of a judicial nature exercisable under our Constitution only by the judges appointed to our courts and, therefore, this Bill would appear to me to be unconstitutional.

How the Minister can tell us that this Bill is constitutional I do not for a moment pretend to understand. I should like to see the distinction or to hear the Minister distinguish between this case and the Solicitors Act case. I should like to hear him point out the differences. I am quite open to conviction. I should be glad to know what the views of the legal adviser of the Minister and the Government are in this particular matter. I am sure that the owners of livestock marts would also be interested in them. I think I will leave it at that for the moment, because I cannot for the life of me see how in the light of the Supreme Court decision, it can be said that this Bill is not unconstitutional. I do not for a moment say that that is the only reason for rejecting this Bill.

Comment on this

It is the amendment that is under consideration.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why not leave the Bill to the Supreme Court you have been talking about, where you are going to test it?

Comment on this

I did not say I was going to. That is like saying it is all right if a fellow steals my car because the courts will deal with him. The car should not be stolen in the first place. The House should not enact legislation which is unconstitutional.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is what you think.

Comment on this

That is what the Constitution says. The Oireachtas shall not enact——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You think it is unconstitutional: we do not.

Comment on this

I want to find out how the Minister's legal adviser distinguishes between the power proposed to be vested in him to grant or revoke licences under this Bill and the Solicitors Act case.

Comment on this

How do you distinguish it from previous Acts?

Comment on this

Which ones?

Comment on this

The ones cited more than once.

Comment on this

They may be unconstitutional, too.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Fine Gael Party have been very remiss in not doing something about it.

Comment on this

The 1955 Act was passed before the decision of the Supreme Court in the Solicitors Act. That is one of the reasons. What I should like to know is how he distinguishes his right to grant or revoke a licence from the Solicitors Act case.

Comment on this

When Senator O'Quigley has been speaking here on a few occasions, it reminded me of the man who found he had been speaking prose all his life and did not realise it. Apparently, if we are to believe what Senator O'Quigley said, we have been living in an age of despotism and of suppression because he has told us that, if the powers which the Minister seeks in this Bill are given to him, we shall then be in an age of despotism, regardless of the fact that these same powers exist in numerous other Acts for the past 30 or 35 years. Apparently, we did not realise we were living in this age of despotism, to use one of the clichés he mentioned.

Senator Quinlan regards the powers in this Bill as the beginning of the end. In view of the fact that that beginning, if it is really a beginning, took place over 30 years ago, it is hardly appropriate to wake up at this stage and find we are at the beginning of the end.

If the only objection to this Bill were the objection that the Minister is being given powers to grant licences and withhold licences, which powers should be given to a court, then one might take it seriously; one might debate it seriously and wonder whether there was something in this suggestion. But it is quite clear, abundantly clear, from the process of this Bill in the other House and in this House, that this is just one more attempt to attack the Bill, that this is a search for any possible objection that Fine Gael can lay hands on to oppose this Bill. Having regard to the fact that there are not only 68 amendments to the Bill but that there have been votes and objections on every conceivable issue, including the Order of Business, what time we should start, what time we should finish, we think it is quite clear this cannot be taken seriously. In regard to the weight and the validity of some of the amendments that have been put down to this Bill, some of the many amendments, from a study of those it is quite clear that in the vast majority of cases they are not serious amendments and certainly undermine any confidence one can have in the sincerity of those opposing this Bill.

The new-found concern of Fine Gael in this connection is really very touching. It is something which they might have brought into play many years ago. But, apparently, there is something quite different about this particular Bill. There is something quite different about this particular Government. There is something quite different about this particular Minister. Apparently, it is all right to give these powers to other Ministers in other Governments in other years, but not in this particular case.

Senator O'Quigley, in discussing this question of powers which have been given to Ministers in the past and powers that have, on the other hand, been given to the courts, mentions the Factories Acts, the Office Premises Act, the Dance Halls Act and a number of other Acts, but, curiously enough, he steers as far away as possible from the agricultural Acts because the agricultural Acts are relevant and do have the powers which he now suggests should not be given to the Minister. He said that if this Bill is passed, it will probably be unconstitutional. If it is unconstitutional, then the whole edifice of agricultural Acts will collapse on the following day.

Comment on this

That may be so.

Comment on this

But, of course, Senator O'Quigley knows that that is not true. He knows in any event—at least he says he knows—ways around this Act.

Comment on this

No I did not.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, that is what he said.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

The Supreme Court is a very practical court and if the Supreme Court comes to the conclusion that Senator O'Quigley is right, that it is very easy, that any good lawyer can find a way around this Act, then the Supreme Court will not take the Act seriously and it will be quite unnecessary to declare it unconstitutional.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I never heard of the Supreme Court taking that view.

Comment on this

Yes, if the law is not binding, if you can get around it, nobody will be in jeopardy.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Could the Senator give an example of where the Supreme Court deemed an Act to be constitutional because it is ineffective? I do not recall such a case.

Comment on this

If the Act does not do something which is contrary to the liberty of the subject or unconstitutional, if it is an Act which, in fact, has no teeth in it and will not be effective, then the Supreme Court will not bother to find it unconstitutional.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There are enough loopholes in the various Finance Acts but they are not unconstitutional.

Comment on this

The Minister and Senator Yeats have outlined a number of Acts and I am not going to outline them again because I know that everybody in the Seanad, including the Leaders of the Opposition, are well aware of the details of those Acts and well aware that the powers in those Acts are almost identical and in some cases identical with the powers given in the Bill now before us. In every case the ones which have been mentioned are relevant in the sense that they are dealing with agriculture, in the sense that they are dealing with the giving and withholding of licences, in the sense that those licences are given or withheld by the Minister and in many cases there are far fewer protections given in these Acts, because it is not necessary in many of those cases to bring the Order or to bring the decision before the Houses of the Oireachtas.

All of those Acts were passed either by Coalition Ministers or before the Coalition Governments were in power and if they were as repugnant to Fine Gael as they now allege the giving of such powers is, then they could have done something about it. Why this sudden change? Why on this occasion are such powers not powers that should be given to the Minister?

Senator O'Quigley has talked about motives in relation to this Bill, has suggested that the Minister has introduced it, not for the good of the community, not for the good of the farming community, but because of some vendetta he has, some alleged row he has, with some particular section of the farmers.

It seems to me that if we go into motives on this Bill, if we concern ourselves with the motives of those who support or oppose this Bill, the motives of Fine Gael do not stand up to very careful examination because if anything is clear from the way in which this Bill has been opposed it is clear that the motives of Fine Gael were not above board, that the motives of Fine Gael were merely ones of political expediency, to try to oppose this Bill, to try to find some issue upon which they could regain the confidence of the people, the confidence which they lost many years ago and are never likely to regain. Therefore I do not think that Fine Gael in particular should attempt to deal too carefully with the question of motives when they are dealing with this Bill. It is impossible to regard their new-found concern for the constitutional rights of the farming community and the constitutional rights of the owners of marts as being serious.

It should be remembered that the Constitution is there to protect not merely one small section of the community but every member of the community and in so far as the Constitution has to pick between a small section and the majority of the community, the agricultural community as a whole would certainly be regarded as being far more important and whose rights should be sustained rather than a limited number of owners of livestock marts.

Senator Stanford in dealing with this Bill said it was one which would have to be considered carefully to see whether it is on one side or the other of the line where the powers should not be given to a Minister or where it was permissible to give them to the Minister. Senator Stanford, on this Bill, has been very sincere. He has shown by his discussion and by his voting on the Bill that he is not resolutely opposed to it, that he is not going to fight it to the finish, as Fine Gael said, that he is prepared to consider it in a detached and reasonable way. I accept that his objection to this Bill is sincere but I would ask him and I would ask anybody who may be impressed by his sincerity, why was this Bill picked on, why this particular Bill?

It has been suggested that there was some public disquiet about this Bill. I am not aware of any public disquiet. I am aware that Fine Gael and the NFA attempted to work up an agitation about this Bill. I am aware that they spoke on many occasions about it and got their speeches put into the papers and in that way we see a certain amount in the newspapers about it. We are not aware of any public disquiet.

Comment on this

You are out of touch.

Comment on this

I am aware of a very deliberate and very vicious campaign about this Bill.

Comment on this

Does that include the Incorporated Law Society?

Comment on this

The motives behind that campaign are motives which, as I said, do not bear very careful examination.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Does that include the Incorporated Law Society?

Comment on this

And the Junior Chamber of Commerce?

Comment on this

Including the Incorporated Law Society who are not, I am afraid, free from a certain amount of political influence at certain times.

Comment on this

Senator Nash is one of your political nominees.

Comment on this

It is very nice to see the Incorporated Law Society waking up to an apparent flaw, an apparent objection to this Bill but I wonder why they did not make the same objection to the various other Bills which have exactly the same points.

Comment on this

They have, indeed.

Comment on this

Again, I wonder, why this particular Bill? The reason is that this particular Bill is the subject of a vicious campaign on the part of the NFA and Fine Gael to attempt to continue a practice in the livestock marts which was clearly discriminating against individual farmers, individual subjects, people who are entitled to the protection of the Constitution.

Comment on this

In how many instances?

Comment on this

This Bill was introduced to enable the individual farmer to have the right to sell his livestock in a livestock mart and not to be prevented from doing so by proprietors of livestock marts who were not prepared to give him his constitutional rights.

Comment on this

Even the John Browns?

Comment on this

He has rights, too.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He put you fellows in your box.

Comment on this

Tell us more about the John Browns.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I will tell you.

Comment on this

Perhaps Senator Rooney will allow the Senator to make his speech?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

And Senator Ó Maoláin.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And Senator O'Quigley and Senator FitzGerald.

Comment on this

Senator Ryan.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Sorry: this kind of thing gets me on the raw.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Stanford when he says that every Bill of this kind that is introduced in which powers are given to the Minister should be examined to ensure that they are powers which it is legitimate for the Minister to have. I agree that this examination should take place. I agree that the Executive, the Administration, have a tendency to take more power than they should have, a very natural tendency. Their concern is to get the job done with the minimum of fuss and without getting entangled in cases in court and so on. I understand the reason they do this but, although it is a natural tendency, it is a tendency which must always be watched, because vigilance is the price of liberty.

Comment on this

Another of the clichés of which Senator Ryan approves.

Comment on this

But, of course, we must not reach the stage where every Act seems to hold some danger to liberty. We must not reach the stage where every power given to a Minister appears to him to infringe the principles of liberty. Certainly we must not allow ourselves, when we are considering a Bill, to be influenced by agitation which is spurious or a campaign which is vicious, by factors which have nothing whatever to do with the liberty of the subject.

I have, on a number of occasions when Bills came before this House, spoken on this subject. I have taken action in so far as I could to prevent things going into Bills which I felt infringed this liberty. I shall continue to do so in the future, but this Bill does not appear to me to be on the wrong side of the line, to employ the phrase used by Senator Stanford. It seems to me that, having regard to the history of the agriculture Acts, having regard to the almost exactly similar powers that have been given to Ministers for Agriculture, and having regard to the way in which those powers have been used, we are quite safe in giving the powers the Minister seeks in this Bill. Those powers, apparently, have not been abused in the past.

Senator O'Quigley says that the powers sought in this case are unconstitutional. If the powers given in previous Acts were abused by a Minister and if some individual were prejudiced or oppressed as a result of the powers given in the past, then, if Senator O'Quigley is right, what the Minister was doing was unconstitutional and the individual who was oppressed would have his right to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

What does that cost?

Comment on this

As there has been no outcry or no complaint about the way in which those powers have been used in the past, we can only come to the conclusion either that those powers were never used in a way that oppressed anybody or that, if they were used in a way that had oppressed somebody, then Senator O'Quigley and his friends did not leap to his rescue, did not tell him his rights under the Constitution and did not advise him in the way that we are now being advised he could get relief from the Supreme Court.

It is quite clear from the history of the way in which those Acts have been used that there has been no source of complaint, that they have not been abused, that the various Ministers for Agriculture have not used these powers to the detriment of individual members of the community. In the circumstances, I see no reason why this Bill should be picked out for special attention. I see no reason why we should come to the conclusion in this case that the powers given to the Minister are on the wrong side of the line.

When we look at the amendments which have been put down to this Bill, most of which are still before us, it is quite clear that the objection to this Bill on the ground that it gives powers to the Minister which he should not have is not a valid objection. It is highly suspect in view of the fact that it is in the company of so many other amendments which have no validity whatever and which, undoubtedly, as soon as this Bill is passed, will be forgotten and treated with the contempt they deserve.

Comment on this

The opening part of Senator Ryan's speech was directed towards motives. May I make an appeal to drop this discussion of motives? It is utterly futile. Our motives, even those of the simplest of us, are obscure, hidden and complex. We can only guess what each other's motives are. Rather than make guesses, let us get down to principles and stay on principles; then we may get somewhere on this Bill. We have raised principles on this matter, and they have not been satisfactorily met.

The Minister has made a promise and I look forward to his fulfilling it to show us that the powers given to the court of licensing auctioneers does not give a good parallel to what we are asking in this case. I see that public-houses and dancehalls may be different matters, but the case of auctioneers comes very close to this Bill. I should also be interested if he or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party could give an example of similar powers being taken by small countries like our own, either in the EEC or elsewhere. My information is that they do not exist. Why should we, then, do it particularly?

Senator Ryan said there was no public disquiet. Then he went on to admit there was public disquiet which had been whipped up in the press and in other ways. I can only say to him that in independent circles—by which I mean professors of law and ordinary citizens of the country who are not committed to any Party whatever— there is a degree of public disquiet. It is a matter of opinion, one against the other. In these circumstances, to enact legislation that may be punitive is regrettable. The present Minister assures us, and I am quite convinced of it, that he will not abuse his powers. I remember some years ago Senator McGuire, sitting in the front seat here on the left, saying that the Government of this country now had collected enough power to establish, pretty well, a totalitarian state as soon as they wanted. He made some reference to legislation in Poland and said that in many cases the powers of a Minister of State in Poland were not greater than in this country. We are adding to them all the time. At the moment we are democratic. At the moment we can trust Governments on either side not to be totalitarian. But suppose the sudden step is made, no legislation would be necessary; it has all been enacted by this House and the other House, simply to turn us into another Poland.

Comment on this

That is absolutely correct.

Comment on this

I am not interested in the slightest degree in the honour and glory of Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. This is a game that has to be played. I recognise the value of the Party for arousing loyalties and so on, but a great deal of what we are saying today is purely personal and purely partisan. I want answers on principles. Would the Minister or someone else answer the argument put forward by Senator Quinlan which I think needs the greatest emphasis? He pointed out that if these licences have to go to court, then the applicants can brief barristers and the people who oppose the application can brief barristers and have it out in open court on grounds of principle. Accept what is in the Bill at the moment, and as Senator Quinlan quite correctly said it will be fought on political loyalties, and even the arbitrator himself, a barrister of ten years standing, may well make his decision on grounds of political loyalties. I say that is striking at the welfare. of this State. I stand on that and I have heard no argument to make me change my mind. I hope I shall hear a satisfactory argument and if I do, I shall openly withdraw but if not, I shall stand very firmly on Senator Quinlan's amendment in which I have the honour to share.

Comment on this

I was a little surprised to hear Senator Quinlan—this is just one point only—emphasise so strongly his objection to a barrister of ten years standing in this case. We have had barristers and members of the legal profession holding inquiries in various ways through the years and I doubt very much if there has ever been any question of their sincerity or the complete impartiality of their decisions. I would say the same about any other profession and I think it extraordinary that these two Senators, without giving any examples, can suggest, as a reason for the deletion of section 3 of this Bill, that they could not trust a member of any profession—I presume the same applies to the professors and to the teachers—of ten years standing who might be appointed by the Government, not to do something for purely personal or political reasons, because in the future such persons would hope to get some advancement out of it. I do not believe such persons are very frequently met in this country. In the case of all of these inquiries, the arbitrator, if anything, leans against authority, against the Minister and in favour of the ordinary man. I am a little sad that people like Senator Stanford and Senator Quinlan should have that opinion of their own profession, which, I presume, is included.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, what we are speaking of is the risk of this happening, not the certainty.

Comment on this

And precedents also.

Comment on this

Senator Cole, to continue.

Comment on this

I hope not, if he misrepresents us.

Comment on this

This is the impression I got from what the Senators said. That was their chief and only objection to the section so far as I could gather. I should think that, shall we say, if times were normal anybody such as the proprietor of a mart and particularly the farming community would prefer to have an inquiry like this where things would be much less expensive and I should think much quicker and much more informal. When we have subsection 7 of section 3 following I see no objection to having an inquiry before a barrister of ten years standing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I listened with attention to what Senator Ryan had to say, as, indeed, I always do. As I recognise Senator Stanford's sincerity, I recognise Senator Ryan's also, although in one respect I think he allowed his irritation with what he regards as the objectionable tactics of the other side to overcome his judgment and that was when he ascribed the whole of this controversy on this Bill to the Fine Gael Party and the NFA and the agitation it has aroused. I think it is a mistake on his part to do that. There is more to it than that. While it is not easy to do so, I have tried to stand back from this issue. I know that in the heat of the moment exaggerated statements have been made by both sides and it is not easy to stand back and see the true issues lying at the heart of the matter. I thought Senator Stanford, who is in a better position to do so than those of us in the front of the House, has been able to do this and to detect what are the real issues in the midst of the controversy and, at times, the irrelevancies.

Trying to take a detached view of it, it seems to me that this is an objectionable power and I am saying this not because I happen to be on this side of the House but because it is something that I would feel whatever side of the House I was on. I feel that also in relation to some, at least, of the other Acts to which reference has been made. I have not had an opportunity of reading them all since reference was made to them as we have not the same resources in research as the other side of the House. Unfortunately, I missed Senator Yeats' speech on Second Stage and could only check up on some of the points that were made in the time available as I had been away. It seems to me that in relation to some of the other Acts to which reference by was made and which were enacted by the other side previously I would have the same objections to them as I have to this Bill. It may be argued—indeed, it is argued—that if this is so, why has this not been raised? That is a question which raises two points. Whatever were the circumstances of the times when those two Acts were passed—I cannot accept any responsibility for them as I was not here at the time—I think if I were here I should have objected to them but, in any case, several things have happened since then which would have made me more determined to object to them.

One thing is the fact that our courts have decided an issue that is relevant to this. We have had occasion before to refer to the case of Farrell v O'Gorman. It may be that the interpretation we put on the decision is one that the courts would not sustain. It is very hard to know how to interpret these decisions and we are naturally inclined to look at them from our own point of view. However, on reading this case again, I think it is directly relevant.

I would make a distinction here between ministerial power—this is a distinction similar to, but not identical with Senator Quinlan's—to regulate certain activities in order to protect the public and subject to certain safeguards and a different ministerial power which I think should not be given to any Minister or Government by any House of the Oireachtas and that is the power to determine whether or not people shall carry on their business. These are two different things. It seems quite proper that the Minister should have power to regulate the way in which people carry on business, to regulate the quality of the products produced and the honesty of the presentation of these products to the public. It may be necessary to provide safeguards to prevent abuse by the Minister of such a power but that he should have such power seems to me to be proper.

On the other hand, it does not seem proper that the Minister should have power to decide whether or not a person may carry on his profession or occupation. This is an objection similar to that made by Senator Quinlan who makes a distinction between this Bill and previous Acts. In this respect I do not entirely follow him in that distinction. I think it is difficult to make a distinction and sustain it fully. It seems to me that if I object to the Minister having power to regulate the right of a person to carry on his means of livelihood then some of the previous Acts—I have not examined them fully in the short time available to me—are equally objectionable. In particular the one at which I did look, the 1955 Act, dealing with seeds and animal I feedingstuffs, gives the Minister power to decide whether people shall have the right to manufacture these goods. It seems to me that power is analogous and equally objectionable. It may be that some of the other Acts contain this power to regulate the way in which people carry on their functions and carry on their professional activities.

I cannot see on what ground Senator Quinlan makes a distinction between the present Bill and the power contained in the Act which I have examined. I think I should have had to object to that Act in regard to the right to a licence to manufacture fertilisers and feedingstuffs if I had been here even before being alerted to it by the case of Farrell v O'Gorman in 1958. That case highlights the position and forces us to consider in relation to the legislation coming into the House whether or not it is unconstitutional. I will quote two sentences—I do not want to quote at length—from the final paragraph of that judgment which seems to me to be directly relevant. It reads:

The power to strike a solicitor off the rolls is a "disciplinary" and "punitive" power, to adopt the language of the judges In Re Grey——

Then there are various references. It goes on, shortly afterwards:

It seems to the court that the power to strike a solicitor off the rolls is, when exercised, and administration of justice, both because the infiction of such a severe penalty on a citizen is a matter which calls for the exercise of the judicial power of the State and because to entrust such a power to persons other than judges is to interfere with the necessities of the proper administration of justice.

The point being made there, and the point being made throughout this judgement is that where the matter at stake is the right of a person to carry on his means of livelihood, as distinct from how he carries it on, then this is a justiciable matter; this is a matter for the courts, a matter that cannot be decided by any domestic tribunal or any Minister.

We are bound to have regard to that decision. It has had an effect on previous legislation. In the light of that decision, some of the previous legislation referred to in this House would, if brought to the courts, also be found to be unconstitutional on the same grounds—some of it, at any rate. We have to have regard to that. I think that contrary to the contention Senator Ó Maoláin seems to be putting forward, we in this House must have regard to this. We are required by the Constitution not to pass legislation contrary to the Constitution. I admit this is an issue of doubt and argument in some respects but it is certainly a matter of conscience. An obligation is imposed on us. We are here acting under the Constitution and owing loyalty to it. We are required to apply our minds to the question of whether something is unconstitutional or not.

If I were on the other side of the House, on this issue, holding the views I do, I would have no alternative as a matter of conscience, to voting against this Bill. I am not suggesting this would necessarily apply to any person on the other side of the House. They make their own judgements on a different basis. They have been persuaded by arguments other than by mine. I am sure that in voting for the Bill—as most of them, perhaps all, will do—they will do so in good conscience. Nevertheless I hold that we are bound, because this is a matter of conscience. I am not taking the line I am taking because this is a Party issue. If it were simply a Party issue, I would put up the best showing I could, I suppose, and if no issue of conscience were involved, I would support the Party on it, but I am speaking from conviction. I would hold the same conviction if I were on the other side of the House. We are bound to act in conscience in this way. We must apply our minds to the question of whether the Bill is unconstitutional, and vote accordingly.

I want to deal with this carefully and calmly, and I hope, fairly. There is another reason for the feelings I would have about such a Bill in any circumstances — and even before the case of Farrell v. O'Gorman. We need to be very careful about this Bill and this section of the Bill which we are now proposing to amend, because there is an issue of controversy here. I think this does change the situation somewhat. I do not defend the act of any Government in introducing legislation which I would regard as unconstitutional or objectionable. I am not defending the action of any past Government in introducing legislation, if it can be shown to be similar to this legislation, and which is objectionable.

I believe that if that were done— and it seems to me to have been done in one case at least in 1955—that was a wrong action by the Government. Nevertheless this much can be said in relation to it, and I think it is fair to say it. Those Bills were introduced so far as I am aware — and certainly nothing to the contrary has ever been said from the other side—in circumstances where there was not an issue of controversy, where no question was raised by anyone—I am open to correction on this; I may be wrong but nothing to the contrary has been said so far and therefore I am assuming this until I hear to the contrary—and no issue was raised that those Bills were introduced in any way in circumstances where they could be represented as being designed as punitive measures of any kind.

I recognise that there is a difference of opinion as to whether this legislation is motivated by past and present controversy. I can quite see that people on the other side of the House might feel the Bill has merits of its own, and that, whatever one may argue about the timing of it, it cannot be seen solely in the context of controversy but stands on its own feet. Nevertheless it is a fact that it is being introduced at a time when the Minister, despite, if I may say so, his somewhat naive assurances, is in conflict with an important section of the farming community.

The Bill is certainly seen by many people as being one intended as being punitive. This may be unfair to the Minister; it may be unfair to the Government; but seen in that light it seems to me that we have to regard a Bill somewhat differently from a Bill introduced in a non-controversial situation. It is most undesirable that any Minister should take and receive powers which appear, in any event, to be unconstitutional, which at any time appear to be objectionable, but that he should take and receive these powers at this time, in these circumstances is worse because, indeed, it threatens to bring into discredit the legitimate exercise of the Minister's powers. It would have been better for the Government and for the country if the Bill had been postponed and not pressed at this time, so that it could be represented and could be seen sincerely by many people as being a punitive measures. It may be that people outside the House may not accept that this is the case but the Bill has not benefited from this and certainly the debates in the other House, and indeed to some extent in this House—and we must all take some blame for this— have not been as detached and unemotional as they could have been because of the circumstances in which the Bill was introduced. We have to have some regard for those circumstances.

The whole question of ministerial powers is one which one looks at somewhat differently from the way one might look at it in other circumstances when those powers are sought in conditions of controversy. Having said that, I do not propose to press it very far, because I do not want it to be suggested that I am defending other legislation of a similar character merely because it was introduced at a time when there was no issue of controversy. I would not wish to defend it in those circumstances.

We have to take this amendment very seriously, because what is proposed in the section of the Bill we are seeking to amend is something which would at any time be objectionable, and which when it was done in the past was objectionable at that time, and should not have been done, and which is not only objectionable now but is, I think, on any reasonable reading of Farrell v. O'Gorman, unconstitutional. It is also objectionable because of the circumstances in which the Bill is being introduced and the doubts that have been raised as a result of the timing and method of its introduction and the nature of the powers being taken, the doubts raised as to the intention of the Minister in bringing in this Bill.

Senator Stanford asked if auctioneers and other people are licensed by the courts why, in fact, in this instance auction marts cannot be so licensed. I should like to take that a little further. What is puzzling me is this. We have an Auctioneers Bill recently passed, which governs these auction marts. I want to be clear on this: it is my understanding that a recent decision of, I think, the High Court decided this issue and, in fact, the Auctioneers Act applies to auction marts. They are already under control. It may well be, and I should like to hear the Minister on this, that the powers taken in the Auctioneers Bill, while sufficient for the business of normal auctioneering, are for some reason inadequate in this particular instance. If that is the case, then it would be quite proper for the Minister to come into the House and seek an amendment of the earlier Act to perfect it in its application to auction marts. That would be a reasonable procedure; it may well be a desirable procedure in the light of some events which have perturbed the Minister in recent months. Had the Minister done that, although there might have been people who would have disagreed in some measure with the Minister taking such action, he could, I think, have defended it very readily and no kind of major attack could have been mounted against him.

It is a matter of some puzzlement that instead of adopting that straightforward procedure to extend the application of the earlier Act to auction marts to whatever extent the Minister might think necessary, the Minister introduces a completely new Bill in which he takes to himself this power previously given to the courts in relation to auctions. Nothing that has been said justifies that procedure. The Minister has said a good deal to justify some additional action in relation to auction marts, though he has not made it clear precisely what the defects are in the Auctioneers Act which make the present legislation necessary. I should like him to tell us now something of the Auctioneers Act in its application to auction marts and explain why, though it gave the responsible Minister and the Government all the powers necessary to deal with auctions, it is inadequate in dealing with auction marts, either because of some oversight, on the one hand, or because of events that happened subsequently, and it is, therefore, necessary to strengthen it in some way.

The Minister has ignored the Auctioneers Act entirely, and, I think, wrongly. He has not told us precisely what the defects are that make this Bill necessary. However that may be, the correct procedure would have been to amend the Act and give whatever extra powers are necessary to the courts to deal with any particular problem. The onus is on the Minister to explain why he has adopted the extraordinary procedure of not amending that recently passed Act and of introducing completely fresh legislation giving him a different kind of power.

I admit there are precedents for the Minister talking this power, precedents even in relation to the earning of a livelihood by people, because the case has been made by Senator Yeats and others that such powers already exist in previous legislation. To my way of thinking, the normal step would have been to amend the Auctioneers Act to give additional powers rather than harking back to earlier dictates which, by implication, have been impugned by the decision in Farrell and O'Gorman. I should like the Minister to tell us why he has not adopted the normal procedure.

Senator Cole raised the question of barristers-at-law of ten years standing and some objection made to their employment in this connection. I think he may have misunderstood slightly the objection made. As I read the Bill —I am open to correction if I have not read it properly—this power is to investigate and make a reports to the Minister. The barrister is not an arbitrator. He does not seem to have any power to decide anything and there is no provision that his report must be published. The fact that the Minister must appoint someone, to produce a report which he must receive —I do not think he is even liable to read it—does not seem to me to offer any safeguard to anybody. The Minister will not be bound by the report. In my opinion, that is not a from of appeal.

On the question of ten years standing, it is a mistake in a matter which can be a matter of political controversy and in which the Minister may be called upon to justify his position, to leave such a matter to a barrister of ten years standing. The Minister will be under pressure. He will make his decision. It will be disputed and he will then appoint someone to investigate and report privately to him. If this is confined to a practising barrister of ten years standing, in all circumstances the temptation will be there to appoint someone likely to produce a favourable report. Now I am not prepared to say there are such people, but it is wrong to put the Minister in a position in which he might feel such a person could be found. Promotion in the law is a matter of patronage. It is a matter of decision by the Government and it is wrong to put any Minister in a position in which he might find a person looking for some judicial appointment who, in turn, with that appointment in view, might be tempted to give a decision favourable to the Minister in order to take the Minister out of his difficulty. It is not proper to put a Minister in that position.

Comment on this

The Senator is not talking about the amendment.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am talking about the amendment. I am certainly talking about that which Senator Cole talked about.

Comment on this

The Senator is talking on a different section altogether.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am talking about a proposal with regard to a certain procedure proposed in the Bill and pointing out that one of the reasons why the judicial process is to be desired is that the procedure in the Bill is objectionable since it does not permit of any proper method of appeal other than to the Minister. If I am out of order, I am sure the Cathaoirleach would have told me so before this, and would have told Senator Cole likewise.

These are the main points I want to make, but I should like to deal with one matter raised by Senator Ryan. He said this was simply Fine Gael-NFA agitation. It is a pity he said that. Much of what he said I accept as sincere and some I accept without qualification but I think that, influenced by his political affiliation, he overstated the position. Any objective person examining this could see immediately that it is in no way limited to Fine Gael and the NFA. One has only to list the organisations involved. First of all, the Labour Party are seeking to amend this because they too find it objectionable. The Labour Party are not under the control of either Fine Gael or the NFA. There is also an amendment tabled by four Independents and we have heard them tell us that the reason they put down this amendment is that they find this entirely objectionable. They are not under the control of either Fine Gael or the NFA. However, the really objectionable feature of Senator Ryan's speech—on reflection, he may wish to withdraw it—was the fact that he impugned the honesty and integrity of the Incorporated Law Society. He said their decision was due to political influence. That was an unfortunate reference. He was provoked to it by interruption and he may now wish to withdraw it. It is obvious nonsense because the Incorporated Law Society does not give decisions under political influence. It is representative of all political allegiances. The members of it act as lawyers and, as lawyers, this is objectionable to them. It is not a question of a successful attempt by a particular group to get control of the Society. We have then the Association of Civil Liberty. It is not under the influence of Fine Gael. Many of the people in it are hostile to Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator would not accuse them of being supporters of Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Or of Fine Gael either.

Comment on this

These things have been mentioned very often in the debate.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am merely replying to points made in order to refute them.

Comment on this

No speaker is entitled to disobey Standing Orders.

Comment on this

Each speaker is entitled to make his own speech.

Comment on this

Senator Rooney will understand that no Senator can disobey the Standing Orders. Senator FitzGerald, to continue, and avoid this continuous repetition.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In regard to repetition, I am not aware that the things I have been saying about the Incorporated Law Society and the Association of Civil Liberty have been said previously. They may have been said in my absence from the House. We have also had the views of the Press and agricultural bodies and I do not think it can be reasonably suggested that this is all Fine Gael and NFA agitation. It is a pity that that should be said from the other side of the House. It is a pity there is not recognition on the other side of the House that there is a genuine issue here, an issue of principle, to which there are two sides. It is not simply a political issue. There is a political element in it which keeps intruding into the debate and which we all try to keep out of it, none of us entirely successfully, but there is a genuine issue of principle here, one which should concern us all as Members of this House. I think we should endeavour to approach it as far as possible in a reasonable, detached way, as I have endeavoured to do in this contribution at any rate. I hope that in the light of what has been said the Minister will reconsider the position.

Where matters have been brought to the courts as to their constitutionality, I think it is correct to say that in the majority of cases the courts have found that they were unconstitutional. In many cases one can say this about a Bill, that the chances of its being tested are not very great. I would think that in this instance the Bill may well be tested in the courts because there are interests involved in this who have the resources to attempt such a testing. The Minister may well find that to press ahead with a Bill, despite the warnings given to him sincerely and in good faith, in some instances at least, which is very likely to be found unconstitutional is not going to help him politically or in any other way, and I think his political stature would be increased considerably if at this stage, having listened to a debate in the Seanad which I think so far has been a more helpful debate than was possible in the more charged atmosphere of the Dáil he reconsidered his position.

I appeal to him to reconsider the matter and I think his political stature would be enhanced. Quite why I should want it to be enhanced is another question and I am not sure I should be pressing him on the issue. From a political point of view, I think the best thing is that the Bill goes through and the Minister takes any medicine that comes subsequently. However, one cannot always simply take the narrow, political point of view and from the country's point of view, and the Minister's and his Party's point of view, it would be better if they had second thoughts at this stage. I suppose they will not. I suppose any appeal of that kind will fall on deaf ears but I hope the Minister will have the commonsense —a word used on several occasions on this Bill—to reconsider his position on this part of the Bill.

I have said, and I am clear that it is the view not only of myself but of others on this side of the House, that a case can be made for some kind of Bill to regulate livestock marts. The timing of it, the content of it, the way it is presented one could argue about, but some kind of Bill certainly can be said to be needed. It is not this Bill in its present form. I think the Bill could be amended. If some of the amendments, including this amendment and others that have been put forward, are taken seriously, it could be amended into a form which would be reasonable, but in its present form and in the form in which it is likely to leave this House, it is unsatisfactory and the Minister is not going to benefit from pushing it through. I appeal to him at this stage to reconsider his position on this particular part of the Bill.

Comment on this

(Longford): Since I have not spoken on this measure before, I, at any rate, can hardly fall foul of the Chair on the question of repetition——

Comment on this

No, but you have been interrupting.

Comment on this

(Longford):——except that I may have been gently interjecting in the debate previously.

May I say, Sir, that it seems to me, if I might quote somebody opposite, that what is under discussion now is an internal question of power versus responsibility. That seems to be the kernel of this matter. It is not a new matter; it has been discussed long and often in this House. Since I have views on this question, I feel I should express them. It appears that what we now seem to want to emerge in this debate is to have an area of responsibility without power. Senator Stanford quite rightly and quite ably dealt with the situation where you have a dissemination of power of a diffusion of power, where it is scattered between, say, three main Parties, the Legislature, the courts and the executive, the three sources of power. To me it has always seemed that in a democracy power is scattered much more widely. You may have, say, in the county council foreman, power to do certain things, power vested in him which cannot be taken from him. That is the sort of scatteration and dissemination of power that really makes democracy work but in the long run power must be held by a Government sufficient to discharge their responsibility. Despite the fact that I believe basically in democracy, I should not like to see a situation whereby a Minister or an executive had responsibility without the power to discharge it. It is the opposite side of the coin in this particular case. It is easy enough to suggest the abuse of power but the greatest abuse of power is a situation where Caesar has not the power at all. Then you have chaos.

Comment on this

Caesar had it.

Comment on this

Hitler had the power. What did he do with it?

Comment on this

(Longford): It has always appeared to me that extreme liberty is one concept and extreme authority another. Extreme liberty is chaos and extreme authority is tyranny, and somewhere in between those two opposing forces you have a point of balance.

Comment on this

I thought we were on the amendment.

Comment on this

(Longford): Somewhere in between you have a thing called order or reasonably ordered conditions.

Comment on this

You will embarrass that side of the House.

Comment on this

(Longford): It is not a very steady point of balance; it is something that shifts this way and that, depending on the point in time but it is by a balance between those two forces that you have any reasonable order in society.

Having said that in reply to Senator Stanford, because he did raise this very important matter, I think it is necessary that a Government, elected to power by a Parliament in a democracy, should have enough power, and no more power than is necessary, to do a particular job of work at a particular time. That is why, when a Minister wants money, he comes to Parliament and asks for and gets only as much money, particularly an the case of capital expenditure, as is necessary at the time. If with the passage of time, more money is required for development, he asks for it again.

Comment on this

Money is much different from power.

Comment on this

(Longford): That is the sort of curbing of power that Parliament exercises on an executive. I still believe that this thing that we call liberty in its real sense is just a point of balance, an uneasy point of balance between extreme liberty on the one side and extreme authority on the other. Now relating that to this Bill, this question of power, I know a lot of people have spoken, and have probably repeated themselves, on many aspects of this Bill. To me there is a valid and good criticism which could be made objectively by the Opposition but which tragically has not been done. One of the questions in regard to this matter of licensing, which we are talking about now, is that the timing was wrong. I wholeheartedly agree with the people who say that the time was wrong——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

(Longford):—— but I do so from quite a different point of view.

Comment on this

It is good to get some agreement from you.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Wait for it.

Comment on this

(Longford): The timing is wrong to the extent of five to ten years. I do not mind criticising the Minister and I think he ought to try to reply to me when I ask him why have certain sections of the Department to take ten years to make up their mind that something should be done about licensing and the control of this new and vested interest——

Comment on this

The present Minister was not there ten years ago.

Comment on this

(Longford):——particularly in view of the fact that similar power was sought immediately the artificial insemination centres began to emerge in this country. I do not think three stations were fully established before the Minister was asked to do something. It was promoted by the Veterinary Section of the Department of Agriculture. I am long enough in this House to know that you can have many mansions in my father's house, that you can have many sections in a Department, and I know further that you can have varied conditions within certain sections.

Comment on this

Now you have it within the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

(Longford): Never mind the Fianna Fáil Party. They are well able to look after themselves.

Comment on this

We know it and Taca know it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You will get enough of Taca before it is finished with you.

Comment on this

(Longford): As I said, something should be said about this and it should preferably be said by a constructive Opposition. The artificial insemination scheme had barely got under way, even though many officers in certain sections of the Department of Agriculture were opposed to it, when a Minister was asked to take more power in regard to the scheme. I know very well about this because I was an advocate of that particular system when I was rather younger than I am now. I did not get the Seanad election because I was for this.

Comment on this

For livestock. Would that be relevant to the records?

Comment on this

(Longford): I am sorry Senator Garret FitzGerald cannot have a little more manners.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think there is a misunderstanding because I have not interrupted at all. I have been listening intently and with interest to the Senator, which is more that can be said of other Members of the House.

Comment on this

(Longford): It is a pity I am getting under the skin of certain people. They are wriggling about so much that it is hard to know who is talking. I remember when the Bill to control artificial insemination was brought in here, the same sort of power was sought and given by this House and Dáil Éireann as is now sought under this measure. If I remember aright the only complaint, and possibly a legitimate complaint, from the Opposition was that the Minister was not taking more power to do something about this and was not taking power to provide a service. The Minister replied: “I am taking only enough power to keep a control in the event of this medium of cattle breeding developing. I am taking only the power which is necessary in the public interest to keep control of it.” That basically was the Minister's attitude. At this stage he was pressed by the Opposition to aid and foster the development of artificial insemination. He resisted that but the power taken under that Bill, which is now an Act, is similar to the power sought under this Bill. There was no appeal at that time to barristers of any number of years standing. I dislike this because it farms out from the Minister power which should be vested in him. I do not think, despite anything the Minister may say, that he would improve the Bill by accepting that amendment. That is his business, it is not mine.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is all our business.

Comment on this

(Longford): I still feel the timing is wrong in that it is five to ten years late. If the Department of Agriculture had been more alive to the situation, this vested interest would not have grown up without any control in the public interest. However, even now I am glad that something is being done to give enough control to ensure that this matter is made right and that a service will be given to the people.

We are conscious of the fact that cattle marts will replace fairs and that people are entitled to the same rights, privileges and safeguards, if and when fairs completely die out. They are entitled to that. All the people are entitled to it. I should like the Minister to give the House an indication of what sort of conditions he will attach granting licences to existing marts or any new marts that may develop.

Comment on this

We are all interested in that.

Comment on this

(Longford): I know very stringent conditions are attached to licences issued to co-operative creameries. As far as I know, there has not been any objection by the co-operative societies, the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society or any other society in regard to the very exact conditions that are laid down. Even in the Dairy Produce Act very stringent conditions are laid down in regard to the control of creameries. Some of us know that every creamery has to get a separate licence and in the granting of that licence, conditions are laid down by regulations which compel the creameries to do certain things. Those conditions are very exacting, regarding the taking of samples of milk, the testing of milk for butter fat valuation, drip tests and many other tests in relation to the amount of butter-fat in the milk and the number of pounds of butter produced. All those records must be very accurate. I know there are cases where creameries have been fined heavily by the Department for a breach of those regulations. Even the creameries themselves did not seek to kick up a row or create agitation in regard to those conditions. The farming community believe in these things.

Quite often there is criticism and even in this House yesterday, I noticed that desire to criticise. There are still people who for one reason or another think that the regulations are not strictly enough enforced. They will tell you that the Department's inspectors do not visit creameries often enough. There may be criticism on that line but I, living in a rural area, know the attitude of the people and I do not want to be told by certain people that they know all the answers to the opinions of the farming community.

In the area of the country from which I come I know quite well that the majority of the farmers feel that there is necessity for this Bill and a necessity for regulation and for licensing. That is true and I can give the reason. Senators should not be too glib.

I want to inquire from the Minister whether in the granting of a licence, he will ensure that the people who will operate cattle marts will be compelled to enter into some sort of fidelity bond, or guarantee bond, or to lodge a large sum in a bank or with a credit group, to ensure that the people who trust them with their business will, in fact, be paid. That is the fundamental question with regard to a licence. I want to know from the Minister that there will be such cover.

Comment on this

There is a deposit by auctioneers in the High Court.

Comment on this

(Longford): I will try to make my own speech without help from the Senator. I come from an area where there are a large number of farmers. Some of them are small farmers who are not as well in touch with matters as Senator O'Quigley. I also know of small farmers having got a cheque, or little document, from a particular mart. I have been interviewed by one of those people and have been informed that the farmers are hoping that this Bill will get them out of difficulty. Perhaps £100 or £120 may not be a lot to some people but it is a lot of money to a small farmer in the parish of Mullaghoran.

Comment on this

It is a fortune to me at any rate.

Comment on this

(Longford): I happen to have in my possession such a little document, a cheque, drawn at a particular cattle mart by a small farmer called Dolan—no relation to Senator Dolan here—in the parish of Mullaghoran. He was paid with this cheque for a few cattle he sent to a cattle mart in the north midlands and I would be prepared to sell this cheque at a discount to any Member of this House. I offer it to Senator O'Quigley or to any of the economists or calculators over there if they are prepared to take it. If my friends do not give me the full amount, I will put up the rest myself. Still, they tell us there is no need for control but they know in their hearts there is such a need. The majority of the people know there is need for control because there have been abuses which could have been prevented if a Bill of this nature had been brought in in the past five or six years.

Comment on this

There is nothing about deposits in this Bill.

Comment on this

(Longford): I should like to hear from the Minister what the attitude is with regard to a guarantee. I am putting the Minister a straightforward question and I hope to get an answer without any beating around the bush. If the Minister does not reply to my query, I shall remind him of it.

There is another important aspect here with regard to farming out the Minister's power to a barrister of four or five years standing. I do not think the Bill would be improved by such a provision. If you want to give responsibility to a Minister, you must give him power as well. Parliament has a way of dealing with this, or any, Minister who misuses or abuses power. That is the way it should be and I do not think that this thing of farming out to a barrister——

Comment on this

Of ten years standing.

Comment on this

(Longford):——of ten years standing will improve the Bill. It is very easy to criticise a barrister and say that he is not nice. How is it that so many of them become gentlemen when they become judges? They become fine people when they are promoted to the Bench.

Comment on this

They are always gentlemen.

Comment on this

(Longford): There is another aspect of this which rather annoys me, the question of equity for the people who sell cattle. I wonder is there a danger of misuse of power. Power is something that can be misused at many levels of society and not just at ministerial level. People and organisations, in my view, are more likely to misuse power than an executive authority, whether they be the GAA or any other group. Mind you, there can be a lack of freedom in the area of amateur games. Supposing the hypothetical situation were to develop that as soon as this terrible Minister gets power to grant new licences, he were to grant a licence to a friendly society, to FF people, say, in Donegal, to support a cattle mart in Lifford or Letterkenny, or somewhere else, and supposing a certain body were to resolve the difficulties in the friendly society and the Minister gave a licence to this group and they were a group of people who were politically-minded and mind you, I think the people in Donegal take their politics seriously— and let us suppose that unless that group to whom the Minister gave this licence had a green card from a certain place in Mount Street, say, their cattle would not be sold until a particular time, I would agree that would be an abuse of power on the part of the Minister. Most people on this side of the House would agree that if the Minister did this sort of thing in Lifford, or Carndonagh or Ballybofey, there would not be support forthcoming from this side of the House.

I want to ask the Minister what power is he taking, or what regulation does he propose to make, to ensure that the sort of thing I have instanced might happen in Donegal will not happen. This is a very important matter. Intimidation is intimidation, no matter in what garment you dress it. You cannot have full freedom if that sort of thing be allowed to happen. The Minister has a function and a duty in this matter and it is a function and a duty he cannot farm out to a barrister of five or ten years standing, because it is a function he owes to the people.

There are other similar matters on which I should like to hear the Minister giving his views to this House because all the talk so far has not really been material to this Bill or to the people. The Minister has a duty to indicate flatly his intentions to this House and to me, particularly on the two points I have raised and on the other matters in regard to which he proposes to make regulations, to give a general indication of the conditions he proposes to impose in the granting of a licence, so that the genuine fears people have will be allayed. For the reasons I have indicated, many people now have the feeling: "Maybe it is a pity we ever left the fairs; maybe it is a pity our fairs have gone down."

Comment on this

It was the buyers who were worried about the fairs, not the unfortunate people who were selling.

Comment on this

(Longford): I am afraid I raised a very wide issue, that of power, control and responsibility involved in this amendment. I felt, particularly as I did not speak on the Second Stage, that I was entitled to say many of the things I had intended to say then, without, I hope, violating the rules of order in making a Second Reading speech.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

The Senator is no more diffuse than many others.

Comment on this

(Longford): I hope I have been as near the mark in relation to what is involved in this Bill as possible. I hope the Minister will see fit to answer my queries as to the sort of regulations he proposes to make.

Finishing on the note on which I began, I do not think there is any danger of an abuse of power, any more than I think there has been any abuse of power under the Act which controls artificial insemination, or the Act which controls the operation of our co-operative creameries. I know there has never been a suggestion from the creameries, from either individual co-operative societies or the IAOS—that there has been an abuse of power. I do not envisage, I do not at all fear an abuse of power on the part of this terrible Minister, or any other Minister, because any Minister coming into Parliament asks for power to guard against every contingency, as is only reasonable. That was proved even by the advocates of human liberty such as Senator Stanford, who on the one occasion on which he had the responsibility and the right, piloted through this House the Protection of Animals Bill and, once the responsibility fell on his shoulders, immediately developed the same mentality in regard to having that Bill as strong as possible. That is inevitably what happens. I am not criticising Senator Stanford, because that is the way things happen; I would do the same myself in similar circumstances.

It is true the Minister wants to have the power to guard against every contingency but when people criticise, it is usually not because of any abuse of power but because of the failure of the Executive to put the power properly into force. That is a fairly accurate picture of the situation. Most of the criticism we come up against is criticism of the failure, for instance, of the Department to inspect creameries often. That is the criticism I am quite certain is most common, but I do not fear an abuse of power, even if this hypothetical situation I envisaged in Donegal were to arise. Once that sort of thing happens, that abuse of power is very easily challenged and falls to the ground very quickly.

My real criticism of the Bill is that it comes far too late, because hardship could have been prevented in certain areas had it been introduced some years earlier. The Bill is not improved, as far as I can see, by the appointment of some person to a quasi-judicial position, a barrister of so many years standing. Where responsibility is vested in a Minister, power should be given to the Minister, and once a Government begin to farm out power, it is the beginning of the end of democracy.

Comment on this

Following on Senator Stanford's very able contribution this morning, I think we have to get back to fundamentals in assessing these amendments. The most disturbing fact of all is, I think, the chorus we get: "Ah, sure, a Minister has never abused power here; we can see what he could have done under all the Acts passed, but our Ministers are good Christians and would never do such a thing," and so on. That is a most naive approach to legislation unworthy of any developed country because, after all, a good dictatorship is surely the most efficient form of government, provided the dictator is an angel, and is like the Minister who is acquitted—all the various Ministers who have been acquitted—of abusing power. We have got to draft legislation in a democratic country in such a way that it is independent of the personality of the Minister, in such a way that a Minister cannot abuse power, in such a way that power is diffused as much as possible throughout the various elements of the community and that the responsibility is placed as nearly as possible to the source of the action.

In the present case, we have had the question of whether the ultimate responsibility should lie with the Minister or with the courts. The examples given, such as the Dairy Produce Act, the Pigs and Bacon Act and all the various other Acts all relate to a quality product and a continued check has to be kept by the makers of that product on the various steps and tests necessary to ensure quality. Those tests have to be reported to a central authority and that authority has to be empowered to act quickly for the common good, to protect the name of the product. That is done here by various Acts through the Minister, through having within the Department of Agriculture a section specifically charged with that task.

That is not the only way or the best way of doing it. In Denmark, we find that such quality control is not the responsibility of the Government but of the co-operative movement itself, and it is sad to reflect that we, who gave such a wonderful lead to the world in pioneering the co-operative movement, through such people as Plunkett and Father Finlay, are lagging away behind Denmark and others in the full realisation of the principles of co-operation. All that in Denmark is done by the co-operative movement.

Comment on this

Not correct.

Comment on this

Of course it is, at every stage.

Comment on this

I have seen it in Holland and the Government control it.

Comment on this

Here, in our rather unprincipled approach to legislation, we are always looking for precedents and distorting them to get more and more power to the Executive and away from the courts and the various other bodies concerned. The amendment seeks to keep this power with the courts. The licensing of marts and so on is an operation that does not require any continuous check-up. A mart is licensed, and in the absence of complaints, everything proceeds all right, much the same as in the case of dance-halls or the conduct of auctioneers. There the quality of the end product is not specifically influenced by the actual operation of the system. I agree with Senator O'Reilly that, if legislation were necessary, some measure of licensing would have been useful five or ten years ago when there was a great deal of mushroom growth and a great many marts being established in areas where they were too close to existing marts. At that stage no step was taken to heed the pleas of the co-operative movement who wanted to have a rationalisation of the marts system and to have certain rules drawn up for the establishment of marts.

It was not done then, but now, when everything is going right, we have this Bill and it is rather amusing to anyone who has had experience of fairs—I can claim quite a bit of experience of them as a young man in Limerick—to see the crocodile tears being shed for the rights, the privileges and the safeguards that operated at fairs. Did anyone ever hear of the tanglers and the system by which cattle were taken from the widow at away below market value? On one occasion when I was 16 years of age, I was entrusted with the care of an animal and I was beset by a tangler and the animal was taken away forcibly from me by the tangler at away below its value. That was common practice, but with the marts system as operated the animals go for fair sale and the widow and the inexperienced person have just as good a chance of selling their animals as the most experienced marketing assessor. It is really laughable to hear the sudden concern for those wonderful institutions called fairs and no doubt, the wonderfully hygienic residue left after those fairs. Is it the intention to set them up as a tourist attraction in our parks and to supply wellingon boots——

Comment on this

Who said they were wonderful?

Comment on this

Senator O'Reilly extolled the rights, privileges and the safeguards——

Comment on this

How is this relevant to the amendment?

Comment on this

It is a little more relevant than the last speaker was.

Comment on this

We will have to keep interrupting.

Comment on this

The Bill leaves almost everything to regulations to be made by the Minister, including the conditions attached to licences and so on. Therefore, we are within our rights in insisting that the adjudication on these matters should be made in open court.

I was surprised to hear Senator Cole's contribution. He said he thought we were casting aspersions on barristers of ten years standing. We were not. We were only pointing out the absurdity of a system whereby the Minister will make a decision which very often will have been the subject of intense political representation. If he decides a mart is to be established in a certain area, he will have intense representation from the area in which the mart is to be established. There will be an appeal by a mart in a neighbouring area that the new mart will be too close to its territory and there will be some local residents who will say that the site selected for the new mart will affect their property adversely.

In such a situation the Minister will call in a barrister to hear the appeal. The barrister will make no report except to the Minister and the Minister will make his final decision, having got the report of the barrister, but is not bound to accept that report. Surely that is eyewash on a grand scale, something that should not be tolerated as legislation, especially when we have the courts able and capable of doing this work?

This idea of an appeal is something we should watch carefully because we have had some of the most grotesque examples. During the past one and a half years, we had the grotesque situation in which the Limerick City Vocational Education Committee were investigated by an inquiry presided over by the Assistant Secretary of the Department of Education, a Department involved in the matter just as much as the local committee being investigated. Not alone must justice be done but it must be seen to be done and that in all cases should be our standpoint here.

Is there any use at this stage in asking the Minister or some of the Senators opposite to pause and see the clear-cut distinction between the various products in the dairy business, the pigs and bacon industry and so on and this Bill which is introduced for the licensing of marts? Surely the Members cannot be serious when they say they fail to see a distinction between the work of the mart as compared with the work of ensuring a quality product coming from a creamery?

Comment on this

We see the distinction very clearly.

Comment on this

Tell us what the amendment means.

Comment on this

The amendment is perfectly obvious.

Comment on this

Will the Senator tell the House how they will implement subsections (2), (3) and (4)?

Comment on this

I shall make my case without any help from Senator Ó Donnabháin. It is doubly necessary that the final decision should rest with the courts, due to the loose way in which the Bill is drafted and the enormous powers given to the Minister to make regulations. We are given little or no idea of what is behind these regulations. Take just one regulation under section 6 (e)—"prescribe requirements as to the size, design, maintenance, repair, cleansing, cleanliness, ventilation, heating and lighting of any building in which such auctions are held".

Comment on this

Will the Senator now discuss his amendment— amendment No. 7—and tell the House how it could be implemented?

Comment on this

The amendment is concerned with the application of these regulations, among a myriad of others.

Comment on this

Speak on that, then.

Comment on this

"Prescribe": in other words, the totalitarian attitude is adopted. The Minister does not like to follow the example of the parliament in Northern Ireland in this instance, though why I do not know. He does not like to look at their legislation. However, we can look at their legislation which, in this matter, is precisely the legislation that prevails in Great Britain. For the edification of our Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, we can compare what has been done by the British Minister of Agriculture, Mr. Peart, with whom he has been having so many conversations recently and we can note his approach to this job.

Our Minister uses the word "prescribe"—a totalitarian attitude. The British Minister of Agriculture, Mr. Peart, in the Schedule to the Agriculture Act, 1966, dealing with marts, and so on, speaks in section 9 as follows: "The function of this Commission"—the Meat and Livestock Commission—"is to give advice and information to those owning or conducting or using livestock marts on the efficient lay-out, design and operation of such marts including in particular efficient methods of handling and penning livestock and generally on matters conducive to efficiency.""To give advice": in other words, the democratic approach, the co-operative approach, the approach that takes it that those people are in business; the approach that those operating the marts, whether they are co-operative or private, must, within the limits of their resources, study all available systems and try to get the best design possible for their situation. The Meat and Livestock Commission, which consists of members—independent members— nominated by the Government, who constitute an independent commission, just advise.

Why, then, are we so different from the British farmers, not to mention the farmers in the Six Counties, or Northern Ireland, for whom I have the greatest respect? Why are we so different that we must be browbeaten and subject to totalitarian action? Everything must be prescribed. In fact, the impossible must be prescribed because, once a mart is up—and most of our marts are up—how, then, can these conditions be attached? In any case, where is the section within the Department of Agriculture or elsewhere that knows anything about the requirements that are governed by the regulations here?

Comment on this

They will make them up as they go along.

Comment on this

The district justice will.

Comment on this

About ten years ago, I had the honour of helping the Golden Vale Co-operative Marts in Kilmallock with the design, as honorary engineer to the project. We got excellent help from the engineering group of the IAOS. They found out as much as they could. However, there was no section in the Office of Public Works or in the Department of Agriculture or elsewhere that knew anything about the conditions in those marts.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They did not need it when you were around.

Comment on this

Will an organisation be set up even to carry out the provisions of that one subsection of section 6? If you take the responsibility of prescribing all of those things, surely you must prescribe for a background of expert knowledge on the subject of what is latest and best in this connection. Surely you should do so. Surely the co-operative movement and the independent mart-owners of this country, whether present or future, should be credited at least with the desire to look after their own capital and that—and it is their responsibility alone—they would go to see what is done elsewhere, both here and abroad, and endeavour to get the best value possible for money in the design of their marts. Indeed, it seems rather amazing that all such little details should be the subject of ministerial prescription by regulation.

Comment on this

Or the district justices, according to your amendment.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

The deletion of many of these sections and the question whether a mart will or will not get a licence is surely the responsibility of the open court.

Comment on this

The Senator should speak on his own amendment.

Comment on this

We have amendments down to exclude——

Comment on this

It is fortunate that Senator Ó Donnabháin is not Cathaoirleach and that we have a Cathaoirleach——

Comment on this

There are only two minutes to go.

Comment on this

The British Commission gives advice and information to assist buyers and sellers of livestock and meat to make bargains in the new business——

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan told us that last night.

Comment on this

I did, but it does not seem to have been grasped.

Comment on this

On a point of order, there seems to be some sort of plot to prevent discussion of the Labour Party amendments. Are we to continue like this for the next few days, or is Senator Quinlan making his own filibuster?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am not sure that it is a point of order; it may be a point of fact.

Business suspended at 1 p.m. and resumed at 2.15 p.m.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister for specific examples of small countries of western Europe of control legislation on livestock marts and of the powers taken by any Minister for Agriculture in those places that remotely resemble what he is looking for here. To the best of my knowledge, and despite my efforts to get such information, there is none. I find that the organised farmers in those areas would not stand for such Government interference in their business. The co-operative movement which is so highly developed in those countries would not stand for it and, indeed, the Governments in those areas are wise enough to realise that they have certain things to do and that the more they can get the people to do for themselves the better they are governing them. Therefore they give as much responsibility to the co-operatives as possible. Here we go in the reverse direction and the Minister must do everything, even to the extent in section 6 of prescribing all sorts of facilities, prescribing requirements for washing facilities, sanitary conveniences, et cetera.

It is unbelievable that the people are to be allowed to do nothing under this Bill. It is the very antithesis of co-operation at a time when we have had studies carried out in regard to the co-operative movement and when we realise it is necessary to look at the co-operative movement and gear it for the time ahead. Is the Minister seriously considering our entry into the EEC? If he is preparing for it, has he sections in his Department actively studying what is considered good agricultural practice by the ministries of the various European members of the Six? Does he believe in the liaison with all the subsidiary organisations, co-operative movements, farming organisations and so on? Is he giving serious study to what is considered right and proper in the Six and at what we should aim if we are to meet the challenge of the Common Market? I should like very definite and positive assurances on that.

I can detect no evidence whatsoever that we are prepared to learn from any other region. I note the Minister's reluctance to learn from Northern Ireland. As I pointed out, you have exactly the same agricultural legislation and agricultural pattern in Northern Ireland as you have in Great Britain. Therefore, let us look at Great Britain. Let us look at the success they have had in expanding their agricultural production while we drift along at something the statisticians can scarcely measure. Now that our application for entry into the EEC has been re-activated, give us some confidence, some feeling that our major industry and its political head, the present Minister, is even at this late stage prepared to benefit from the example of other countries and prepared to try to lead a united team on the agricultural front in the Common Market negotiations.

Indeed, my respect for the Commission in Brussels, and for Dr. Mansholt in particular, would go down considerably if I felt they would not be seriously perturbed at the lack of preparation on the agricultural front here for the Common Market and the lack of leadership being shown by the Minister, and, indeed, by the whole organisation structure in these internal feuds which are no credit to the Minister or to any section of our community. Indeed, I think the Minister must carry the major share of blame for that. I would ask him, please, so that we may see this measure in some broader context than we have it at present——

Comment on this

I take it the Senator is discussing amendment No. 7. It has to do with the jurisdiction of district justices.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would come to the amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment seeks to take the power of ultimate decision in this matter from the Minister, as political head, and to place it in the courts.

Comment on this

That is in order.

Comment on this

I want to know is this direction of taking away of power and the consolidation of all power in the Minister's hands, is this part of our preparation for entry into the Common Market? Can the Minister give specific instances of where this is taking place in Holland, Belgium, Denmark, Luxembourg or any other place on the Continent of Europe? I challenge the Minister to produce examples. I know he cannot. It is the very antithesis of what is regarded as good agricultural practice there. That is why I support this measure strongly and urge the Seanad to do so also as at least one step in trying to make some little bit of preparation for the Common Market, at least to undo the damage done by our failure to develop——

Comment on this

The Common Market is not the main issue here.

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

Listening to Senator Quinlan would not convince anybody that this amendment is either useful or necessary. Bringing in the Common Market and other matters may have some relevance in his mind, but they do not add up to a great deal. Neither does it make a very good argument. But an appeal is made here about leading a united team to Europe and it just reminds me of the disunity being created by, for instance, Fine Gael who have gone across themselves to Europe to discuss our entry into it——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

And supported it.

Comment on this

——without any knowledge being given to the Government of the country whose job it is to negotiate our way in on behalf of the whole Irish people.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

A knowledge of what?

Comment on this

Any knowledge of what you, Senator, and your colleagues had in the document you presented when you were in Brussels as a political Party.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Why should the Government have any such knowledge?

Comment on this

Because of the fact that your colleague in Fine Gael, Senator Quinlan, appeals for unity, for a united team.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Which we showed.

Comment on this

Here we have elements of what might be regarded as the united team going battering off on their own without telling anybody where they are going and what they are doing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

And supporting the Government.

Comment on this

How do we know?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Why should you know?

Comment on this

Why should we know?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

Because it is the nation's business you are meddling in and meddling is what you have been doing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

We are perfectly entitled to communicate with the EEC Commission without telling the Government what we said.

Comment on this

Is that so? At the same time, the Government are fully entitled to communicate and to tell you what they said. Then we have complaints from your colleagues about a united team going to Europe. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There was unity; there was no dissenting voice in the Dáil.

Comment on this

The united team is all right so long as it is Fine Gael who are doing it. Let us have less of this claptrap about united teams from Fine Gael when they themselves do not wish to have unity, do not wish to let anybody know what they are doing abroad or what they are talking about, even though it is alleged it is on the nation's business——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Will you publish all the documents submitted?

Comment on this

——without the authority of the people behind them. Fine Gael have no authority to talk on behalf of the Irish people and, for that matter, neither have certain other people who have gone either in their individual capacity or in the capacity of representing other organisations. These things are going on. It is about time, now that they have been taken out, that they should be taken out and shaken around to see what they are about. Let us hear less of these appeals about unity and a team going to the EEC.

Comment on this

We will have to get a licence from the people to talk to people in foreign countries. That is the new concept of freedom.

Comment on this

If I were to say— presumably, being high in the order of rank in your Party, between yourself and your co-leader in the Front Bench, you would be able to say whether this is so or not—that one of the aspects presented by Fine Gael and trotted around in Brussels by them was that they were the great Europeans in the Fine Gael Party and, of course, Fianna Fáil were really a Sinn Féin group——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

No such statement was made.

Comment on this

This may be only tittle-tattle. I am delighted to hear that something was not said since we cannot deduce from anything what was said. I am glad to know that that was not said because it has been talked about as if it had been said.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The only problem we had was in cross-examination by the Commission as to the position of the Minister for External Affairs, to explain how his position lined up with that of the Government.

Comment on this

If you looked after the position of your own Party, that is the most you have competence to do, and judging by the manner in which you have been dragging over the years, you have very little competence in that direction.

Comment on this

The Labour Party were out for 14 years in England and got in again. The outer wilderness does not mean anything.

Comment on this

We are told here by Senator Stanford that there was a public opinion against this Bill. I do not for a moment disagree. An opinion was engendered by certain people and it was got through to organs of calculation and propaganda in this country, our newspapers, radio and television and all the rest of it, and they were all given to understand a whole lot of things about this Bill which, when the Bill came to be discussed by those really interested, they discovered were not in the Bill at all.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

And they have all said nothing in the press, have they?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

It is, as I say, conceded that there was a public opinion generated on false propaganda disseminated, wilfully or otherwise, by certain elements in our community who had the ear of the press and of our other media of communication. When the Bill emerged and came to be discussed, it was not what had been published as to what it contained that actually was in it. Indeed, this is part of the confusion Fine Gael are suffering from, that, having either sponsored or been delighted to believe that sponsored by others, as to the things that were objectionable that were said to be in the Bill and not in it, when it came to discussing it in the Dáil they were not able to pass the first section, were not able to get away from that, because of the confusion self-created or wished upon themselves. The fact that we get wrong interpretations circulated amongst the public in regard to any matter cannot be regarded as a fault of the Bill itself. It can be attributed to those who, whatever their purpose, spread this sort of propaganda. It could also be said that, as charged against the Government, our public relations should have been sufficiently good to have combatted that sort of false propaganda as to what the Bill contained, but it did not contain anything like the number of objectionable things that were first alleged to be contained in it. They were not in it and are not in it.

What does this Bill, in general, attempt to do? I wish to reiterate that it will secure and perpetuate the rights of the farming community freely to sell and/or buy livestock in marts which are superseding fairs, rights which they have enjoyed for a long time back. Nobody denies that this is the entitlement of our farmers. Fine Gael do not deny it; neither do any of the mart organisations deny it. Nobody denies anywhere I have heard people talking that this right for the future is of importance to our farmers.

We must look at this Bill not only as something that can give this right and ensure the continuance of this right but as something which will also in its operation, facilitate the growth of marts that are doing their business properly, and prevent marts being established and developing into badly run marts, which would not be in the interests of the farming community or the agricultural industry. This Bill, if passed, will facilitate growth in the right direction by helping to curb growth in the wrong direction in this business that is so important to all of us.

The financial standing of the mart operators is being provided for under this legislation. Surely this is another matter about which nobody can complain, a matter which most people, even those who oppose the Bill generally, will concede is one that requires attention. We cannot look forward to a situation developing where further marts may go into bankruptcy and where the farmers, big or small, will be the people who pay the piper because they have sold their cattle in one or two sales in that mart before its closure. We know this is not a dream of ours but a reality. This is something that has already happened and we do not want it repeated. We can prevent it and will prevent it under this measure. Nobody surely would welcome a situation in which marts which are insecurely based financially can go bankrupt without anybody having control over the situation or knowledge of it until it has happened? The regulatory sections of this Bill will ensure that such a situation will not arise.

The marts associations are aware that this is one of the matters that will be dealt with when this Bill is enacted. I do not think they object, and that is talking very conservatively as to what I believe they think in regard to this matter. Indeed, I would say that some of them to whom I have talked in their individual capacity have indicated that it is something that should be done, that it is necessary, that it is a good thing from all points of view that marts operating should be securely based by bond, insurance or otherwise, to ensure against loss by farmers who participate in sales or purchases, as the case may be.

We were asked then about the Auctioneers Act and the granting of licences to auctioneers. I was particularly asked about this by Senator Stanford. As far as I am aware, the Auctioneers Act licenses an individual to perform and carry on the business of an auctioneer. This Bill deals with the licensing of places, not individuals, and there is a very distinct difference between the two. There is a very telling difference, in that in one case it is a matter of giving a licence to or withholding a licence from a person, as has been trotted out here by Senator FitzGerald and Senator O'Quigley when they spoke about the control of solicitors and the power of the Supreme Court in regard to the striking off the roll of any member of the profession. Again this is a matter of taking away the means of earning a livelihood from a professional man. If a place is not regarded as suitable for a mart, no licence will issue, but it does not follow from that that there was any prescriptive right denied to the man or men or committee who may own the site that is proposed as a mart. That is a different matter altogether.

It is true to say that the wellbeing of the farming community and the agricultural industry is the responsibility of the Minister for Agriculture. Since this matter of marts, the organisation and the regulation of operations within the marts, are matters of growing importance, surely they must by their very nature be regarded as within the competence of the Minister for Agriculture who is charged with this responsibility of controlling and regulating matters in the best interest of the community whom the Minister is there to serve in a particular way. This again is the reason why we should consider this matter away from those other cases that have been quoted. Neither the case of striking of a solicitor off the rolls nor the granting of a licence to an auctioneer as a means whereby he can earn a livelihood is parallel with what is in this Bill, which relates to places that may be licensed for the purpose of carrying on the business of a mart.

Other countries have been mentioned. Surely we in this country should be regarded as the best judges, in our own circumstances, of what is best for us. This is what has been regarded as the proper approach to those things in the past, and I am not aware that anything has taken place to change that very sensible approach to this or any other kind of legislation affecting the wellbeing of our people. Therefore, we do not agree that if this is not paralleled in another country it must be wrong. Neither do we assert that because we do it and it is not done in another country, they are wrong.

Comment on this

Why must we be more totalitarian than the others?

Comment on this

If Senator Quinlan wants to be totalitarian, that is his business.

Comment on this

I am talking about the Minister.

Comment on this

Do not start mixing the two things up. If it is the Senator's wish that we go totalitarian, it is not mine.

Comment on this