Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 227–460 of 675. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 13 of 1967 ›
It is not my wish, but we are going totalitarian.
Comment on this
Anyhow, getting back to this matter that the far-off hills look green, apparently Senator Quinlan has got to the stage of believing that anything that is outside this country is better than anything within it. Likewise, any legislation not operated in other countries cannot be good if it should operate here. If it operates here and does not operate elsewhere, it must be bad. I do not accept that reasoning at all and I do not think many would. If we look at this matter a little further we find what is done in other countries, for instance, in regard to agricultural matters is not so attractive. I wonder if Senator Quinlan is fully versed in what does take place regarding agriculture and the sale of agricultural products, their import and export in some of the countries whose example he would have us follow. Is he fully aware of the practices there, which we do not have here, and which I hope we never shall have here, in the very countries that he points out as shining examples for us to follow? Either the Senator was out long enough to know what I am talking about or he should not be out at all.
Comment on this
This is not a lecture either from the Senator or to me. I say there are practices regarding the sale and purchase, the import and export of agricultural produce in some of the countries the Senator would like us to have as examples that I should not like to see here as part of our everyday activities. I shall not give examples because if the Senator does not know what I am talking about, he has not been out long enough.
Comment on this
It is not mysterious; it is a statement of fact that the Senator must or should be aware of. I accept that he is aware of it.
Comment on this
If you give bad examples to innocent people, you may spoil them. Senator FitzGerald thinks he would object to the Fertilisers Act, if I am correct.
Comment on this
I shall not revert to what Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, said when he introduced this Bill in 1955. That would probably be going too far back but I take it that since the Senator and Deputy Dillon still belong to the same Party, a quotation from Deputy Dillon only three weeks ago would be far more telling as, for instance, when in the Dáil I was quoting this as an example of what we might be putting into this Bill, he glorified in the fact that——
Comment on this
——that he gloried in the fact that he had the opportunity of putting through this particular Act. I shall get the reference for the Senator, although I am not quoting the Deputy verbatim or attempting to do so. I am merely giving a synopsis of what he said. He threw up his hands and said that he gloried in the fact that he put it through. I take it the Senator and the Deputy are still in the same Party, and, if so, I suppose it shows the democratic methods of the Fine Gael Party in that they can differ on fundamental matters such as this and show a united front at the same time in order to give good example to others.
It has been alleged that the previous Acts, including the Fertilisers Act—I think, by Senator O'Quigley—had been introduced in times different from these. I have no difficulty in conceding that this is true but if by different times it was implied that we are in very critical and strained times now and that this changes our approach to this Bill as against the circumstances that obtained back in 1928, 1935, 1947, 1955 or 1956, I do not agree. I was not around for very long in 1928 and for only slightly longer in 1935 but would any sane person try to make me believe, since I did not live through those times as an adult, that the situation at present when we are sponsoring this Bill is to be regarded as a difficult and dangerous one wherein the Minister of the day cannot be trusted with the powers proposed in this Bill and that he might have been so trusted back in 1928 and 1935 when things were so different and people were so happy at that time that everybody was falling over everybody else to entrust them with those powers?
I was young then but even with the slight and dim memories I have of those days, nobody could convince me that the situation was as stated by Senator O'Quigley or that there is any basis for his argument relating to differing circumstances. Rather, I should say, his argument could be reversed and it could be said that 1928 and 1935 were years in which the circumstances were such that the trusting by the Opposition of a Minister was far less likely in this form of a Bill than it would be today. The reverse of his argument is the fact. Therefore, not only does his argument fall but it is an argument in the opposite direction. If in those days when Government and Opposition had their present roles reversed we could have the then Opposition and the then Oireachtas giving this sort of discretion to the then Minister for Agriculture in the Pigs and Bacon Act and the Dairy Produce Act, surely we have come far enough since then to have far greater faith in each other to the point of giving far more discretion to a Minister for Agriculture today or tomorrow or next year than would possibly have been sought or expected in those years.
We had the usual suggestion thrown out that the Minister is in conflict with a section or an important section of the farming community. I do not know what this is intended to convey but, repeated sufficiently often, it may convey in some way that the Minister has caused this situation and is to blame for it, that only he can rectify it and that the other cherubs are blameless. This seems to be the whole emphasis by Fine Gael.
Comment on this
I have not forgotten about the dual purpose hen, not for a moment. That memory is always with me when Senator Rooney is before me.
Comment on this
Senator Rooney should allow the Minister to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
Is the Senator implying that this thing about a conflict with the farming community has not been said?
Comment on this
On the contrary, I said it myself. I was wondering who suggested that the blame lay on one side. I did not hear that suggestion.
Comment on this
The remark was: "The Minister is in conflict." Why not say: "The NFA is in conflict with the Minister"?
Comment on this
Do that; it will give you exercise and keep your minds balanced. Having got the assurance from the Senator that they will try to balance their utterances, if not their minds, on this matter in future, I will leave it. There is a suggestion that because of the conflict, wheresoever originating, all matters of legislation and all matters of regulations and all matters pertaining to the Department of Agriculture in this State should stop flatfooted until that conflict has been brought to an end by some means or other.
It is being put across in regard to this Bill, as to why it should be delayed, that we should stop and just freeze everything until this conflict has been overcome. I do not subscribe to that idea. I do not see that any section of the community, no matter whom they represent, or how many they represent, if they are a sectional interest, and only part of a sectional interest, as the case in point turns out to be, have a right to have the business of the Oireachtas or the Government held up until they come up again. That is what Fine Gael are asking. These people who are allegedly in conflict are not even asking for this themselves, but Fine Gael are always there to sponsor great causes. One of their causes is to stop this Bill at any cost.
There is an uncharitable story going around. I do not subscribe to it. In fact, it would be a stupid deal if it were made. The suggestion is that a deal was made before the local elections, and that this Bill would be held up, or beaten if possible, by Fine Gael and that in return a certain element of the NFA would back Fine Gael in the local elections. I do not believe that. It would have been a stupid deal.
Comment on this
The NFA could to some degree produce the goods in regard to their alleged part of the bargain, but Fine Gael could not unless they resorted to undemocratic means which I am sure they would never dream of doing. It is, as I say, an uncharitable story.
Comment on this
I do not believe it for a moment because even if Fine Gael were capable of making such a deal, I have enough regard for the other people to realise that they are clever enough and cute enough to know that they would be selling themselves for a mere nothing. Fine Gael could not produce what it is alleged they promised to produce, that is, to stop this Bill. That could not have happened. I am happy to have the opportunity of indicating that it could not and did not happen.
Comment on this
It was not directed to the Minister; I address my remarks to the Chair.
Comment on this
In regard to the information which I promised to Senator FitzGerald and others who are interested as to Deputy Dillon's lauding of his own handiwork in 1958, the reference is volume 229, columns 1490 to 1499 of the Official Report of 6th July.
Comment on this
There was another helpful suggestion that the Auctioneers Act could have been suitably amended to cover marts. While it might be possible to cover auctions by straining the Act and amending it to quite a degree, I do not see how it could be strained and amended to include non-auction sales which are one of the things that were discussed to quite a degree, and which it is necessary to cover if we are to control——
Comment on this
If you do not have places provided capable of being used for auctions, how can you have auction sales or non-auction sales in places suitable for auctions?
Comment on this
It regulates them in regard to the boyos who might try to get around the controls to their own peculiar and personal advantage to the degree that they are not getting away with evasion of the licensing code to which reputable and properly operated marts will adhere.
Comment on this
The Senator should read the section, and read it again, and again, and again. After all that reading, I assert that he will find certain things in it that he has not yet seen. It is a very good definition section. I appreciate the solicitude expressed by Senator FitzGerald for my political future which he feels is in the balance and liable to be cut off at a rather tender age.
Comment on this
I was not really interested in the propriety. I was thanking the Senator for his expression of solicitude.
Senator O'Reilly took me to task with regard to this measure. He made a very excellent case, particularly his assertion that I and the Government and the Department were to be blamed in regard to this measure on the basis that it is five or ten years late. I fully subscribe to that view. These licensing provisions and controls should have been provided many years ago but that is not to say that because they were not provided many years ago it is wrong to provide them now. In fact, the passage of time made it more definite and urgent that it should be done, and the sooner the better. That surely must follow and it must follow particularly in view of the fact that those who are now opposing the provisions in this Bill are the self-same people who advocated the introduction of licensing controls, or otherwise, away back in 1958. How they can change their tune, or how they can dance a different dance to the same tune, is something I just do not understand. The fact of the matter is that those who are opposing this measure expressed themselves as in favour of control in 1958. As I say, I fully agree with Senator O'Reilly that this measure has one fault, that is, that it is many years after the time at which it should have been introduced. But it is not too late. It is comparatively early, but the earlier we can get it the better.
Auctioneers and their bonds were mentioned. That just shows how little the people who make these interjections understand what is at issue. There was mention of fidelity bonds; some said there was no provision for them. I agree we should have them and we are going to have them. By way of interjection, it was, I think, Senator Rooney who asked did not the auctioneer's bond cover this? The auctioneer's bond, as far as I know, is about £5,000. It was raised in the recent Act to that amount. Do the Senators who have this sort of woolly idea in their heads realise that two sales at any sort of well-going cattle mart could involve £50,000 to £100,000?
Comment on this
Quite, and that is why I suggested the Minister might like to amend the Auctioneers Act.
Comment on this
The Senator is way out again. I cannot see how, by any stretch of the imagination, the Auctioneers Act could be amended to cover non-auction sales. Anyway, £5,000 by way of auctioneer's bond would be the answer of Fine Gael to securing the financial interests of the customers of a mart that might be going on the rocks or actually on the rocks to their detriment.
Comment on this
I did not say the Senator said it. I merely have it down here as an interjection—what about auctioneers' bonds?—and it is in the context of discussing fidelity bonds or insurance to cover the liabilities of a mart that might go wallop, for one reason or another, and this is the worth that Fine Gael place on the operations of a mart, as demonstrated by this interjection: £5,000 where £100,000 might be involved in one day.
Comment on this
Tell us all about the Egyptian bees and the platypus and perhaps breaking stones. Tell us more about breaking stones.
Comment on this
I am not assuming anything of the sort. What I am assuming is that the interjection was ill-founded and made in complete ignorance of the facts in relation to the operation of a mart on any given day the mart is open. A bond for £5,000 on the part of the auctioneer would cover only 75 to 100 cattle. Who runs a mart with 75 or 100 cattle? Will someone tell me that? Where is there a mart operating on the basis of a throughput of 100 cattle a day?
Again, it does not follow that there may not be two marts held before the payment for the first one takes place. That is part of the system and, if the marts are running fairly close together, as they may do for different types of animals, one could have marts on successive days, two in the one week, and the two days' sales would be due to be paid after the second mart had been held.
Comment on this
We will take 75 or 100 and one day's operation and we will divide it into two; we will make it even figures to make it easy for Deputy Rooney. We get 37 or 38 cattle—38 on one day and 37 on the other. That would be some going. That would be a real operation. That would be a mart giving the best service possible to those who need it in order to sell their cattle.
Comment on this
Has the Minister conveyed his criticisms of the Auctioneers Act to the Minister for Justice?
Comment on this
The Senator has got some peculiar idea in his head that, when I draw the analogy that can be drawn in regard to the interjection made by Senator Rooney, in order to show how silly it would be to apply this £5,000 bond to cover and secure the interests of farmers selling cattle at the cattle mart, I am criticising; this does not imply criticism of the Auctioneers Act, of the Minister for Justice or of the two Houses of the Oireachtas which passed that Act.
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out the folly of the ways of some of the Senator's colleagues who regard 5/- or 2/6d in the £ as fair compensation if a farmer is silly enough to sell his cattle through a mart that is going bang.
Comment on this
There must have been something else said in all the time it took to say it. No: I think I have replied to all the salient points raised and to some that were not so salient.
Comment on this
Could we have examples of the legislation in Denmark, Holland, Luxembourg and anywhere else?
Comment on this
Now, 39 years is not bad experience in our circumstances. We have had 39 years of operating the Dairy Produce Act and the Senator is a knowledgeable man from the south. He has associations with co-operatives, the IAOS and the NFA. He knows them and knows their conditions. I am saying to him now that surely 39 years experience of a measure similar to this in relation to every creamery in the country is a far better example from which to draw our deductions than anything that might be done in Denmark, Holland, Timbuctoo, or anywhere else. Surely the operation of the Dairy Produce Act here is for us a better guide on which to rely without any fear of taking a wrong step?
Comment on this
No. Occasionally, for our race, it is no harm at all that we should now and again think in terms of what we do as being the best rather than the worst. We have had too many people for far too long who regard what we do as inferior merely because it is done here by somebody in this country. I am not one of those who subscribe to that view.
Comment on this
Marts have been regulated in other countries before this.
Comment on this
We have had 39 years experience of the Dairy Produce Act, with all its implications for the creamery and milk industry, an industry so closely allied to our cattle industry. Surely that is the best proof, the most exacting proof, one could possibly get as to the desirability of following in present and future legislation the guiding lines laid down 39 years ago. Thirty-nine years and not a complaint —not a single complaint by any of those organisations or by any of the individual co-operative societies running creameries today or any day since 1928. In that legislation we have the licence at the sole discretion of the Minister, without any obligation on him to tell the Dáil and the Seanad, until they find out in their own capacity that he has taken a licence away, and even then there is no obligation on him to say that he took it away or that he refused it. Yet despite that overall very wide discretion with no obligation to give any reasons or answers about it, it has never been abused. It has never been abused in 39 years even to the point of eliciting a complaint from one creamery society. That is surely the answer to those who would make a case that whatever about this Marts Bill applying to private mart operators, it was really doing down the co-operatives. All creameries are co-operatives. That, I take it, the Senator is fully aware of.
Comment on this
Co-operatives all of them were, every one of them. Tell me where there is a private creamery?
Comment on this
What is there? Are you sure it is not the Shannon Free Airport Development Company they were talking about here yesterday in your absence who have set up one out at the end of the jet runway or something because it would be outside my jurisdiction if it were in the duty-free, customs-free zone?
Comment on this
The Minister is caught out in saying that all creameries are co-operatives.
Comment on this
No, it is not irrelevant at all. They came into being in buying out some of those people who were no longer able to run them themselves.
Comment on this
No, the only disposal we know of is where they sell aeroplanes that somebody else has paid for.
Comment on this
You tell me the difference between producing butter and cattle.
Comment on this
That is for Senator Quinlan. The Senator missed this last night. What is the end product? Senator Quinlan will tell you all about it because it mystifies me as presented by Senator Quinlan, but I can see that he knows and that I do not, and that he should tell you because I really could not do justice to his idea of the end product. The fact is that we are delighted to see the Senator here after missing half the morning and yesterday. I suppose it is better late than never.
The co-operatives have not expressed any dissatisfaction with their treatment by the present or any other Minister since 1928 in regard to the use of his discretion and the granting, withholding or revocation of licences. This is an important example that we can draw from in a very special way that should confirm in our minds that there it nothing whatever wrong with, nor is there any danger inherent in, the proposals in this measure, that if anything, they are safeguarded to a degree that those others were not in that the Minister is obliged and will be obliged to lay before the two Houses of the Oireachtas his decisions in regard to refusals, his decisions in regard to revocation of licences and the reasons therefor.
People may ask what is the point in that. The point is that as distinct from the courts, the arbitrators or anybody else, the Minister and the Members of the Government of the day are elected by the people. They are open to all sorts of interrogation in both Houses on any of these matters that come within their jurisdiction. I am undertaking by the terms of the Bill to come in and put before the two Houses, where I have refused a licence, and revoked a licence—in both cases—why. Surely Members of this House will be the last to say that they are then helpless.
Comment on this
If in fact there has been a revocation or a refusal and the decision has been wrongly made, for bad reasons, for political reasons and all the rest that have been trotted out here, surely to heavens there is no place where this can be exposed and will be exposed more quickly than in the two Houses of the Oireachtas, if of course they have a case and want to do something about it?
Comment on this
Do not start this poor mouth business again about your being in the minority. This is something you will have to get used to and you will be far happier. You are really not giving yourselves a chance.
I do not agree that an arbitrator appointed in whatever way you like, whether by the Civil Service Commission or the Local Appointments Commission, as somebody suggested, the barrister of ten years standing—I smile when I hear those words: a barrister of ten years standing; it conjures up the picture of a barrister just standing around for ten years——
Comment on this
I knew it was bound to come to something. I shall come back to it again. I do not think that any arbitrator, no matter by whom chosen——
Comment on this
I do not believe a district justice, or indeed any judge, is under the same pressures as an elected public representative in Government to steer an absolutely straight and fair course. I say this with all due respect to those who occupy those other high positions. I really believe this and I believe it because of the fact that we have an Opposition who, if they perform no other function—
Comment on this
——will never miss an opportunity to try to find mud and dirt where there is not any and try to throw it and make it stick where it should not. That being the case, the dangers of anything being done under the counter, unjust or unfair, politically-biased, under this measure are completely and absolutely remote, far more so than if they went before an arbitrator or indeed before the courts.
Comment on this
What I am getting around to are the reflections I have heard expressed in regard to the courts here today. We have been told very seriously by very eminent people, some of whom are at the Bar—I do not mean the sort of bar we have in this House—that we would be in danger in having a barrister of ten years standing—ten years experience might be a better phrase—because of the fact that we would be looking for a compliant —I think that was the word used by Senator FitzGerald—who, he hastened to add, might be hard to find, but, in view of the prospects of promotion which could be made by the Government that we would have these sort of compliant barristers standing around ten years who would do our bidding to get the Minister out of a hole he may have got himself into, by making an unjust decision or proposing to make an unjust one in regard to the refusal or revocation of a licence.
Comment on this
I shall grant the Senator any sort of correction. I should hate to wrong him in this respect.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that if we were to change from this dangerous situation of getting this compliant sort of person I would be seeking out, who now apparently might not be there but maybe would be because of the promotion prospects, we should in fact take it either to the courts or to some body or other presided over by a member of the courts. Yet, those same court members will have been appointed by the Government. Presumably some of the barristers of ten years standing who comply with the wishes of the Minister are the people who, if we are to believe the Senator, now are in those high places and it would be an improvement to refer such matters to them rather than to the Minister. You cannot have it both ways. That is what we are trying to do there. Either the courts are above reproach and their appointees are above reproach. I believe they are. I do not subscribe in the slightest degree to the reflection that was cast on them here today in the sort of analogy employed by Senator FitzGerald when he talked about the compliance of barristers who do the bidding of the Minister in order to get promotion——
Comment on this
Do not worry about that. I cannot fall if the pit is not there. I probably realise better than does the Senator that those people do not exist. If they do not exist, I am quite sure I will learn it as fast as the Senator has, which is just in the last half-hour or so. However, allowing him every latitude in his analogy in relation to the case he made, he cannot have it both ways. I would be interested to know which way.
Barristers of ten years standing are upright people. They are capable of making just appraisals but when they wish to get promotion they will not seek to do the bidding of the Government but will get it by their own effort. That is one way. The other is they will do those things and they will finish up on the bench. We are asked to refer those matters to that bench rather than leave them with the Minister who at least is answerable to the Dáil and Seanad. You cannot have it both ways. I do not subscribe to this view at all. I believe the Senator does not believe what he said.
Comment on this
The people who are put there are of various shades of political opinion. They are very busy people. In fact, from my own experience in regard to various pieces of legislation I have had a hand in going through this House, they are overburdened at various levels of the courts. We should not try to hive off anything to them at all but rather give the Minister something to do. We should not try to throw those things on to the courts who are already very busy on far more important matters. It is not fair to the courts, it is not fair to ourselves here and it denigrates the power and control of Parliament, the Houses of the Oireachtas and the Government, who are the elected representatives of the people who have to be answerable not only to both Houses of the Oireachtas but also to the people. Even there if they can be judged or nailed in this or the other House on matters that can be shown to be corrupt then they have to face the people. It is by the votes of the people they get here and without those votes they will cease to be Members of this Oireachtas.
Those are things which the people should keep in mind in order to have a proper perspective of what the responsibility of the Minister and the Government is and the manner in which they have to approach those things for all those various reasons. It is scandalous that we should have this denigration perpetrated in this august Assembly, the chief institution of our own State, which we as Members of the Oireachtas in a general and in a particular way have a duty to uphold. Yet, we have been doing this for very narrow political advantage. I am really ashamed of Fine Gael in this particular regard.
Comment on this
The Minister finished by mentioning political advantage and it is a very good point on which to start. First of all, we know that the marts have been functioning for the past ten years. We also know, having regard to the arrangements for alterations to be carried out in this House, it was intended that the Dáil and Seanad should have their business completed before the end of June but on the eve of June, on the 31st May, the Minister threw down this Marts Bill on the Table of the House.
He knew very well it was on the eve of the holidays for the Members of the Dáil and Seanad that he was presenting this Bill. He introduced it at that time, of course, assuming that they would be confronted with the closing down before the 1st July and that he would have to get his Bill in spite of quite a lot of other legislation, certainly more urgent, that needed to be dealt with and which has been left over until after the recess. All the time has been taken up by this Bill. It is a strange fact, indeed, that immediately after the activities of the NFA week after week and month after month since January this Bill was presented. It appears to be a rather punitive Bill brought in not during the last ten years but on the eve of closing for the holidays in order that the Minister could get at the farmers.
Let us face it. That is the purpose of this Bill. It is to get after them. It will be a method which will put an extra big stick in the hands of the Minister, to interfere with the activities of the farmers. We can imagine many sets of circumstances in which the Minister, if he gets this Bill in its presents form, can punish members of the National Farmers Association, the ICMSA or any other organised farming group who may find themselves in any dispute with him. Every reputable newspaper has declared against this Bill in principle. Extracts from editorials have been quoted in this House and in the Dáil on several occasions. Those were views expressed by the editors and writers in the newspapers. They were expressing public opinion and they were reflecting public opinion. They were, if you like, interpreting public opinion. All those reputable newspapers have declared against this Bill in principle.
Comment on this
The principle of the Bill is not just immediately before the House. There is an amendment before the House.
Comment on this
Under this Bill the Minister is taking power to put the marts out of business. He will be able to frame regulations in a manner which will enable him to put them out of business. It is a very great power that the Minister is seeking from this House, that is the power to put business people out of their normal commercial activities. Generally speaking, people are allowed to run their own business in their own way but the proposal now is to tell the marts how they should run their business.
It was mentioned—I think by the Minister—that this Bill has been brought in because of some incidents that occurred in the past few months where it appeared the proprietors of the marts, in the interests of their own business, and carrying on their own business in their own way, took action of which the Minister does not approve. The Minister has not at this stage stated the conditions which will attach to the issue of a licence. He is asking us to pass a Bill to give him power to grant a licence, to refuse a licence, to revoke a licence, and, I presume, restore a licence. He has not told us the conditions in which a licence will be issued. I have no doubt that the regulations under which a licence will be issued will be framed in such a manner as to give the Minister great power in relation to the people who will be trying to do business in that mart. This Bill will give the Minister power to deal with the people who do business in the mart, in addition to dealing with the marts themselves. The licence will be subject to a set of conditions and regulations which will affect those using those marts to transact their business. It really amounts to the fact that every, beast going through those marts will be licensed somehow.
The Minister said, of course, that he is ensuring fairness in relation to those licensed marts by promising to have laid before the House the reasons for his refusal to grant a licence, but he knows very well that if there is to be a vote in the Dáil or the Seanad where the majority party exists, he can stand over his decision, regardless of what report has been put on the Table.
Under the factories Acts which deal with human beings, there are penalties if various regulations are not complied with, but there is no question of putting factories out of business. There will be no business withdrawn; they will not be told to fold up, to cease to transact further business in those premises. This Marts Bill refers of course to a place. Under the Factories Act, if regulations are broken, the premises will not be closed down or people will not be put out of business. The marts will be closed down and put out of business if they do not comply with regulations which will be decided, determined and implemented by the Minister.
I notice—I am open to correction here—that there is no distance limit in the Bill. In other words, there could be two marts in one town. Under the fairs regulations, there is a provision by which a fair must be held six or seven miles from another fair. Under the arrangements of the time, fairs were not sanctioned unless they were a minimum distance apart.
Comment on this
I am glad to know that the Senator knows something about it. I am informed, and I think my information is correct, that under the charter, before permission could be given for the establishment of a fair, the distance from the nearest fair was taken into consideration. In fact, I think the nearest distance was six and two-thirds miles. If I am wrong in that, I shall wait to be contradicted.
I did not mentioned the figure until now in relation to places where fairs can be held but I did talk about factories where human beings are concerned. One learned Senator from the Fianna Fáil Party justified this Bill by telling us that pigs cannot speak for themselves and this Bill refers to cattle, sheep and pigs. The Senator telling us that this Bill was necessary because pigs cannot speak for themselves followed by saying, when somebody intervened that we might have complaints, that she did not understand the language of pigs. That was a very good reason for having this Bill implemented.
I mentioned the distance between one mart and another. The Minister will have power under this Bill to withdraw a licence from a mart that may be operating in a certain town and issue a licence to a political pal or supporter——
Comment on this
——in order to put the mart out of business. He will have power to enable another mart to start in the same village or town in order to put an established mart out of business.
Comment on this
Are you against that? It could happen without the Bill. That is one of the things the Bill will prevent.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Bill to prevent a mart which does not exist already being licensed in the same town. It gives power to the Minister to issue a licence for the setting up of another mart.
Comment on this
If the Minister decides to punish a particular mart, or mart committee, or gets on the wrong side of them in the matter of relationship, he can issue a licence for the setting up of another mart for the purpose of embarrassing and putting out of business the mart already established there.
Comment on this
This Bill will give the Minister power to put another there. The Minister could now put those two marts out of business and put his own mart in this town. That is what I object to. A licence can be used to put one mart out of business and to establish another more favourable to the Minister. This is a very serious power which the Minister is taking. It is a serious threat to the marts which are already established and functioning in a satisfactory manner. The shadow of that threat is there all the time. If those marts do not keep on the right side of the Minister, his Government, his Party and the local cumainn, they are then in danger of having their licences withdrawn and a licence given to some other group to set up a mart in the same area. At this stage, when the Minister is asking us to give him a Bill which gives him power to issue a licence and withdraw a licence, he should now set out in detail the conditions which apply to the issue of a licence so that we shall know exactly what the power to issue a licence implies. The powers which will attach to the issue of a licence, the conditions and regulations with which it will be associated are not set out in black and white in this Bill.
Even at this stage—it is now 2nd August—the Minister should not persist in pushing this Bill through in the circumstances in which we find ourselves. He has said that relations between himself, the NFA and the farming community are very happy but I think he will agree that the relationship is not so happy. That is why there is the feeling throughout the country amongst the farmers—and if anybody is interested, he can stop any farmer in the streets or at a fair; he need not go to the marts to see a farmer—and ask him what he thinks of this Bill, he certainly will not say he is in favour of it. The farmers are opposed to the Bill because they realise it is just a noose round their necks which can be tightened if they do not take the line the Minister requires them to take. We have seen ourselves the difficulties which the farmers have been having with the Government at present; they are unable to get any kind of co-operation and are certainly unable to get any kind of guidance in the matter of agricultural policy from the Government at present.
In that situation, it is undemocratic and not right for us to be here now putting through a Bill to which the farmers are opposed. They are the people who will be affected in the long run, because it is the farmers who use those marts, and the livestock from all those marts are channelled through those marts to a great extent now. Those marts have been functioning for the best part of ten years and if they should be subject to certain regulations, it is very strange that the Minister should wait until the eve of the adjournment of the Dáil and Seanad to bring in a Bill of this nature, having regard to the relationship which existed between his Department and the farmers for nearly the past 12 months now. If he wanted to bring it in, he should not have waited until we were just about to close down. It means that apparently the Minister wants to stifle discussion. He has said he is prepared to talk until the cows come home in relation to this Bill, but he knows he is having this Bill debated and argued now at a time which is normally the holiday period.
The Minister's attitude is completely unfair in relation to this matter. If there are amendments which will be acceptable to him, he knows it will be necessary to recall the Dáil in order to have them accepted, if he wishes to have the Bill become law before the Dáil reassembles. On the other hand, if the Minister proposes to oppose every amendment put down here, he should tell us now and not tell us in a fortnight's time. If he is going to accept none of them, why not tell us now? On the other hand, if he has an open mind on the matter, he should let us know at this stage whether any of these amendments are acceptable to him, because it would certainly be a great help to us in this debate if we knew which amendments are acceptable.
Comment on this
Not from the point of view of order; the Minister, like the Senator, is restricted in discussing the amendments before the House.
Comment on this
But the point I am making, Sir, is this; we were brought back here this morning at 10.30 a.m.; we were brought back this week instead of being able to take our holidays, in order to discuss these amendments. If the Minister has no intention of accepting any of the amendments, it is unfair and not right to have us here discussing these points only to be told in the long run he is not accepting any of them. For that reason, even at this stage, he should leave the discussion of the remainder of this Committee Stage over until after the recess.
Comment on this
I do not quite understand the remarks of Senator Rooney about the reasons why we are discussing this Bill more or less in the middle of August. The point I think he should realise is that when this Bill was first introduced as long ago as May last, it was then, as it is now, a short Bill, relatively simple, dealing with a very limited aspect of the country's economic administration.
Comment on this
It introduced no new principle of legislation; it introduced no principle of legislation which had not been in force in numerous Acts in this Country for the past 43 years. The fact that we are here on 2nd August, and may be here for some time to come, is certainly not the responsibility of the Minister, nor is it the responsibility of the Fianna Fáil Party.
This Bill was debated at very great length in another place, which we are not supposed to discuss, and my memory is that the debates was conducted by the Fine Gael Party in such a way that it never got past section 1. We began the Committee Stage discussion of this Bill yesterday afternoon at 3 o'clock; it is now 4 o'clock on the following day and we have not yet dealt with section 1. It is clearly fallacious for Senator Rooney to be attacking the Minister, the Government, or the Fianna Fáil Party for the fact that we are sitting here today discussing this Bill.
There are two contending schools of thought on this amendment. Senator O'Quigley and Senator Quinlan represent one school of thought, a school of thought that says, as does Senator Quinlan, that this is undemocratic, dictatorship and that, as he puts it, any group or auctioneer would look on these licensing powers with horror and alarm. Senator O'Quigley, as far as I remember, is even more picturesque: he says the Bill is unconstitutional, that it gives arbitrary powers to the Minister and, in his usual slightly flamboyant style, spoke about the battering rams of the Land War and said the Minister is suppressive. That school of thought needs to be reminded yet again, as the Minister has done already, of the long succession of Acts that have been passed during the past 40 years. I gave details of those on Second Stage and I do not propose to do so again except to list them, not that it will be of any assistance because those people will go on talking about this Bill as if it were new, dictatorial, arbitrary, oppressive.
There is the Dairy Produce Act of 1924 which includes powers to register creameries, separating stations, manufacturing exporters, butter factories and non-manufacturing exporters. The Creameries Act of 1928 gives the Minister power to license creameries. The Pigs and Bacon Act of 1935 gives the Minister power to license pork butchers and bacon factories.
Comment on this
Are you like the Minister? Do you know the difference?
Comment on this
The Senator has not yet spoken today. He is welcome to do so but I should prefer him to allow me to speak at the moment. I cannot understand what he is saying, anyway. The Minister has absolute discretion to refuse a licence under the Pigs and Bacon Act. The Poultry Hatcheries Act gives powers to refuse or to revoke a licence and the Live Stock (Artificial Insemination) Act, 1947, gives the Minister power to refuse licences and to impose such conditions as he thinks fit. Then there is Deputy Dillon's Act, the Fertilisers Act, which the Minister pointed out he still considers to be a magnificent Act. In that, the Minister can restrict the offering for sale of articles by persons holding licences issued by him and he has absolute discretion to grant or refuse to grant a licence, or attach such conditions as he may think fit, or revoke a licence. In the Seed Production Act, which I strongly advise Senator FitzGerald to read from start to finish as a most interesting Act—it would reduce him to blind fury if the present Minister for Agriculture even considered introducing any of the provisions of that Act—the Minister is given power to authorise people to engage in the business of producing, processing or selling seeds and he may revoke a licence at his discretion.
Comment on this
There are extensive powers with regard to the Control of Exports Acts of 1947 and 1957. The Minister can prohibit exports——
Notice taken that 12 Members were not present; House counted, and 12 Members being present,
Comment on this
I have mentioned those Acts merely to try to point out to Senator O'Quigley, who is now here, and to Senator Quinlan who is not, that it is a ludicrous distortion of the true position to allege that this Bill is dictatorial or oppressive. It introduces no new principles in regard to the licensing of economic activities which have not been contained in any other Acts. As the Minister pointed out today, for the 12th or 13th time, at no time during the past 40 years has anybody, inside a political Party or outside, suggested that those licensing provisions have been misused.
Those amendments seek to hand over to the courts the job of handing out licences and this brings us on to the other school of thought represented by some of the supporters of those amendments, particularly Senators FitzGerald and Stanford. They say there are precedents for this legislation, that this Bill merely reiterates the type of licence provisions which have been contained in many Bills throughout the year; but they say now is the time for a start. That is a more reasonable approach than that of Senators O'Quigley and Quinlan. Their approach is simply ludicrous to anyone who has studied legislation. There is no conceivable argument in favour of it. The other argument is one on which one could have an intelligent discussion.
The type of detailed economic administration which is dealt with in the Bill and which has been dealt with in numerous other Acts, relating particularly to agricultural produce, is not a matter for the courts. This Bill is not an instrument for denigrating the courts or in any way attempting to reduce the importance given to the courts in our constitutional system, but I do not think the courts are adapted or intended for this type of detailed economic administration. If it were consistent to hand over the licensing provisions of this Bill to the courts, then it would be consistent also to hand over all licencing provisions of all types relating to creameries, pigs and bacon, artificial insemination, imports and exports, to the courts. The courts would simply be unable to deal with that business. These are matters for expert administration, not matters for court procedure, and it would be a great mistake to consider taking such a step.
There seems to be a general assumption among certain Members from the other side that Ministers of State live in a sort of ivory tower, that a Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or any other Minister administering licensing provisions can dissociate himself from the general public, that he can quietly take his revenge on any enemies he is alleged to have by eliminating cattle marts and so on. That is a complete misunderstanding of the position the Minister holds as an active politician in public life.
In this connection it might be well if I quoted Deputy Dillon. It may seem strange that two people on this side today should read quotations from the same source. The Minister read one earlier and I should like to read another which puts this point succinctly. While the Seed Production Bill, 1955, was going through the House, a a number of amendments to try to soften some of its dictatorial provisions were moved by various Fianna Fáil Senators. They were all rejected by the Minister, Deputy Dillon. In any event, arising out of the discussion, Deputy Dillon made a point which I think is a good one with regard to the position of a Minister, particularly a Minister who is administering legislation such as this. I quote now from columns 1704-5 of the Official Report of Seanad Éireann of 8th June, 1955, when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture. He said:
What no Minister of State faces with equanimity is a parliamentary question designed to expose him for having used powers conferred on him in an arbitrary manner. Every Minister is open to query as to why he issued a particular Order, and if he does not give a satisfactory answer he can be required to wait from 10.30 to 11 p.m. to answer on a motion on the Adjournment. If he has not satisfied the House, he will then have to face a barrage on his Estimate and of course there is always available to a Deputy the opportunity of raising the matter by specific motion in Dáil Éireann. He can move that the Order under which the Minister acted in an arbitrary way be rescinded.
I mention these things because they all relate to a series of amendments which seem to be founded in the apprehension that there would be arbitrary use of the powers envisaged.
The Minister, in fact, is very much in the hands of the Dáil and the Seanad with regard to the way he uses powers and also—for some reason this greatly upsets Senator Quinlan—in the hands of the public.
Let us think about this in a practical way instead of indulging in the wild theorising that we have had so much of in this debate. Let us think in a practical way of the position of a Minister who decides, apparently through sheer vindictiveness, that he will close down an existing cattle mart. Can you imagine the furore? Picture an Irish country town with a livestock mart which is used by the farmers for some miles around. Picture what would happen if the Minister decided to close the mart and to withdraw the licence. Can you imagine the public meetings, the deputations, both from Opposition people and his own supporters? Think of the questions that would be asked in the Dáil and the general excitement. Is it possible that any Minister would withdraw a licence in these circumstances?
If there is a fault in this procedure of licensing cattle marts and withdrawing licences I should say it is the opposite to what has been alleged. It is not that a Minister would be too active in withdrawing or refusing licences or that he would be oppressive in this matter. There is the consideration of his commitment, as a politician, to public opinion and his desire not to get into trouble in the Dáil for being too weak or for waiting too long before revoking the licence of a cattle mart that obviously was making no effort to comply with the regulations.
By this amendment, Senator O'Quigley and others wish to give the power of issuing licences to the courts. I have already said I think that that is not in the best interests of the public or of the cattle marts themselves because the courts are not adapted to deal with this type of activity. One of the reasons I prefer the procedure of ministerial licensing and general administration in these matters rather than court procedure is that the system of licensing by the Minister is much more flexible. The courts are essentially rigid places.
I would refer Senator O'Quigley to subsection (2) of his proposed section 3, in particular. The Minister has said the Bill provides that all existing cattle marts will get licences provided they avail of the regulations. The Minister has said in the Seanad, and several times in the Dáil, that he will, as an exercise of ministerial authority, give them time to work up their standards. The weaker marts, which perhaps would not be able to comply immediately with the regulations, would be given time to come up to the standards of the better ones.
Under Senator O'Quigley's amendment, the district justice can give a licence to an existing cattle mart only if it complies, as of now, with the regulations. That immediately puts every cattle mart in the country in the position that they cannot get a licence from the district court unless they comply with all the regulations. These regulations can easily be complied with by the more prosperous and better-run marts but it would cause great difficulties for the weaker marts to comply with them, even if the court adjourned the application so as to give them some time to do so. Therefore, the existing marts would be very unwilling to be forced into a situation where they would be governed by Senator O'Quigley's amendment. It would be disastrous in that way.
Comment on this
Surely Senator Yeats is not really serious when he asks the House to contemplate the furore and the protests and the public meetings that would be held should the Minister decide to withdraw a licence from a cattle mart under the terms of this proposed legislation. I am sure all the Senators in the House have, over the past nine or ten months, seen sufficient meetings, marches, sit-down strikes, protest meetings outside prisons and elsewhere, and have read resolutions passed by various public bodies. During the past nine or ten months, open warfare has been witnessed in this country between the farming community, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Government.
Comment on this
What has all that agitation, unrest and dissatisfaction achieved and brought forth? This Bill is the result of all the marching. This Bill is all the Minister has to offer. This is the only piece of legislation that he feels will cure the ills of the agricultural industry at present.
Comment on this
Instead of seeking to improve agricultural prices, the Minister has devoted all his energies for the past four, five or six weeks to the introduction of this measure— which rightly has aroused suspicions and fears among a large section of the public in rural Ireland—and to putting it through the Oireachtas.
I have not as yet heard the Minister or any Government speaker indicate the exact reason why this proposed system of licensing is necessary. To my knowledge, there has been no great outcry or grave dissatisfaction about the marts as at present operated. I certainly have not heard any evidence that any of these marts, whether cooperatively run, or run by private ownership, are being operated in such a way as to infringe the rights of the general public in any respect.
It is quite true that following the seizures of cattle in Offaly, there was some difficulty at Edendery mart but the Minister will agree that that was an isolated case, and in a republican county such as Offaly, where there were always men of high ideals, it is reasonable to see why those people are not going to be walked on as easily as some might imagine it is possible to do. This is completely unnecessary legislation. We are licensing a section of Irish life at this stage and I can see nothing in any section of the Bill that is going to confer any particular benefits on the farming community. I would ask the Minister to indicate what benefits the farmers can expect to enjoy if this Bill is enacted which they do not enjoy at present. On the contrary.
Comment on this
Will the Senator direct his attention to the amendment and not to the Bill?
Comment on this
With respect, I am discussing amendment No. 4. There is no need to license cattle marts at present. They have been erected as the result of private enterprise in a few cases, and in the majority of cases as a direct result of co-operative effort, as a direct result of the co-operation of individual farmers who came together and subscribed to the capital cost of providing the necessary structure. They devoted their time to canvassing their neighbours to ensure a sufficient supply of cattle on sale at each mart. They went out to ensure that reputable buyers from overseas as well as at home would attend those marts so that there would be a brisk demand for cattle. In all, the system has worked admirably and it has really been quite a boon to farmers. It is true that in some places farmers prefer to patronise the old traditional fairs. People who go to fairs are at a decided disadvantage because quite an amount of practice and expertise is required to make a good bargain, whether you are buying or selling, and that is something every man does not enjoy doing to the same extent and something which not every man is capable of doing. People who expose their cattle for sale in a mart all get the very same crack of the whip and for that reason this Bill is to be discouraged.
On the other hand, I regret I have not as yet, having listened to the Minister for many hours, both here and in the Dáil, heard him encouraging the system of selling through cattle marts. In present conditions and with the scarcity of manpower in agriculture, and more especially in the tillage areas, it is imperative that the farmers should have good marts in which to sell their cattle. Under the old system going to a fair meant, for practically every farmer, rising at any time between 2 o'clock and 5 o'clock in the morning and it was impossible to go without looking for somebody to take the cattle to the fair so that the farmer could stay back and do the ordinary farm work himself, such as milking and feeding livestock. Marts, however, start at a more reasonable hour and it is possible for a farmer, by starting his day's work an hour or an hour and a half earlier, to finish his routine jobs before he starts off for the mart at 9 a.m. or 10 a.m. As I said, I regret I have not heard the Minister praise the system and encouraging the farmers to continue on this path.
I am somewhat at a loss to understand his reasoning in regard to the bonds which auctioneers are required to have. Did I understand him to say that a bond of £5,000 was not sufficient for an auctioneer to have if he were selling cattle at a mart because the Minister felt that the value of the cattle that would go under the auctioneer's hammer in one day would exceed, £5,000? Surely that is not a valid argument when practically every week we read about properties worth £250,000 or £500,000 changing hands and yet the auctioneers who handle those sales have a common bond of £5,000.
Comment on this
If you do not get paid, you still have the house.
Comment on this
Did the Senator ever hear of an action of specific performance? That will very quickly dispossess you of your house if you have sold it.
Comment on this
I cannot understand the reasoning behind the Minister's argument. It is a pity that the only remedy the Department and the Minister could bring up for all this unrest which we have experienced is a Bill of this kind which proposes to license and to apply regulations to a section of the agricultural industry which has progressed quite nicely, which is developing on reasonable lines, gaining in popularity and giving an excellent service and which during the course of its evolution, neither applied for nor received any State aid. That is commendable. We hear a lot of talk about factories and industries being established and practically all of them receive grants of one kind or another. Here we have an industry employing quite a few people which has not applied for or received any grants or State aid and yet the Minister feels that to save the agricultural industry, it is necessary to license marts and bring them very much under his hand.
There is one other point. Although yesterday the Minister did give a guarantee that fairs need not be licensed and he had no intention of interfering with them, there is one thing I am not clear on. We have a considerable number of annual sales on farms, especially sales of pedigree cattle, where breeders, whether of dairy breeds or beef breeds, exhibit and sell their own stock by auction. This system is very popular. I attend many such shows each years because you can see there the lineage of the particular animal you may like. People interested in getting into milk breeds, and buying a heifer to start their own herd for instance, can see the parents of the animal in question and satisfy themselves they are getting into a good breed. I should like to ask the Minister specifically if those disposal sales will be allowed freely, as they have been over the years. Many of those sales—I know a couple in my own county—attract buyers not only from the Republic but from each of the 32 counties. They have been held annually for many years. It is important that they be allowed to continue.
What is worrying quite a number of people also are the annual shows and sales—the bull shows held in March throughout the country and the smaller ones later on. Will these be free to operate as they have operated for many years, or will there be any restriction on them? I should like to remind the Minister that all the societies holding these shows and sales co-operated with the Department over the years in the eradication of bovine TB. The Department got every assistance from them. Surely the Department would not wish to bring in regulations which will, to a great extent, knock many of these shows, especially the single-day events. If the Minister is to prescribe buildings, accommodation and so on for those single-day events, I do not think it will be possible for any voluntary show society to construct buildings and sales rings or accommodation in a permanent fashion to comply with the Minister's regulations. This is an important point. There was never greater need than at present for progeny testing in this country and the up-grading of our cattle stocks.
Comment on this
With due respect, I think it might be a bit more appropriate if the Senator would come back to the amendments.
Comment on this
Some Senators seem incapable of understanding the amendments on which they are speaking.
Comment on this
The Senator is going very wide of the mark very often.
Comment on this
Practically every speaker on the far side dealt with a variety of Acts, not one of them in any way connected with cattle marts or the sale of cattle.
Comment on this
I am dealing with shows and sales. With all due respect, Sir, I cannot see why you must exclude shows and sales.
Comment on this
The Chair is now being invited rigidly to apply Standing Order No. 39. The Senator, to continue.
Comment on this
I will endeavour to keep to the subject matter of this amendment. We have, as the Parliamentary Secretary and the Senators on the Government side are aware, many excellent show societies. They have done a tremendous amount of voluntary, unselfish work towards up-grading and improving the quality and value of our livestock. Many of these societies hold an annual show and a sale in conjunction with it. Some of them are one day events and more of them are two or three day events.
Comment on this
The Senator is repeating himself. The matter was dealt with yesterday.
Comment on this
I endeavoured to speak both yesterday and today and this is the only time I was called.
Comment on this
Surely the Senator is entitled to see the effect of the licensing provision upon sales and shows?
Comment on this
I have not heard that mentioned previously either in this House or in the other House.
Comment on this
Shows were dealt with yesterday evening. The Senator has referred to shows several times since he began to speak.
Comment on this
The Senator, to get on with his speech on the amendments. There are three before the House. The scope of them is wide enough without widening it still more.
Comment on this
With due respect, Sir, so far I have been speaking on the first amendment, No. 4 "To delete line 17" in the name of Senator John B. O'Quigley. Line 17 reads:
"Licence" means, a licence under section 3 of this Act.
Comment on this
The Senator is perfectly entitled to make the point but he is not entitled to continue repeating the matter. The Senator, to continue.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister, through the Parliamentary Secretary, to clarify why, in his opinion, this piece of legislation is necessary. I should like him to pinpoint for me the overall reason why it is thought desirable to introduce legislation at this time when other sections of the agricultural industry would, perhaps, benefit more from a more vigorous tightening up.
I should like to mention briefly something that Senator Yeats spoke about regarding the fertilisers legislation of 1955. Surely the House will agree that prior to that legislation being enacted, many tons of Irish beaches were distributed to Irish farmers at fantastic prices, up to £20 a ton, and since the enactment of that legislation the farmers have been getting a fairer deal. People who do not have to pay that sort of money for fertilisers in order to make their living will not as readily see the necessity for legislation of that kind to protect the agricultural community.
The Minister quoted legislation of 1928, 1935 and 1947 and 1955. I invite him to tell the House which Minister for Agriculture was in office in any of those years. Was there ever a Minister who called upon a battalion of troops, who mobilised members of the Garda from at least two divisions, to collect rates from a handful of Irish farmers? Never before——
Comment on this
I am calling on Senator McDonald to deal with the amendments before the House.
Comment on this
I am replying to the Minister who mentioned the legislation in those years. With due respect, he dealt at length with his predecessors who were in office in the years 1928, 1935, 1947 and 1955, and I just wish to point out that the same situation did not arise and the Ministers did not use the same tactics as the present holder of the office has used over the past nine or ten months.
Comment on this
If the Senator looks back to 1935, he will find that things were not so nice, due to certain people.
Comment on this
The Chair does not intend to ask the Senator again to come back to the amendments.
Comment on this
Senator McHugh will allow the business of the Seanad to continue. Senator McDonald must be allowed to continue on the amendments.
Comment on this
One would imagine from listening to the Minister making the case and justifying his actions in introducing this far-reaching legislation that it came as a result of loud and long protestation from some sections of the community who were being penalised but he has not indicated any such difficulties in the industry. Perhaps the Minister might tell the House in reply to which section of the community he is introducing this legislation.
Comment on this
It is hardly necessary for any Minister to have requests from certain sections of the community any time legislation is introduced for the benefit of the nation as a whole. Since this Bill has been introduced, there has been a barrage of opposition from Fine Gael, a great deal of fog and smoke screen around the whole issue and allegations that it has been introduced to penalise certain people, et cetera. I firmly believe that one of the most important parts of the Bill is the one to which this amendment relates, that is, the matter of granting licences. The farmers will certainly be very pleased to see legislation of this type being enacted because it will help to protect their interests.
It is true that cattle marts have sprung up to replace fairs in certain areas but there are many areas in which there are no cattle marts. I am very well aware that, as has been stated in this House, certain cattle marts have closed down and the unfortunate farmers who sold their cattle therein have no redress. The granting of a licence will ensure that people who engage in the business of providing cattle marts must comply with certain standards and there will be regulations made for the protection of persons who sell their cattle in those marts.
I am wondering if some of the people opposite who have criticised the Government for introducing this Bill at this time are aware of what has happened in certain parts of the country already. I freely admit that there are excellent cattle marts in existence that are run on a very high standard but that does not get away from the fact that a few cattle marts have closed down and it is in order to protect the people who sell their cattle in cattle marts that this Bill has been introduced.
To allege that it is introduced for any other reason, as Fine Gael have been doing for quite a long time, is quite wrong. I would respectfully suggest that they are merely trying to take advantage of any difficulties that may exist at present. In particular, they have made reference on many occasions to the NFA. I shall not dwell on that. I would be the first to admit that the farmers are entitled to have an organisation as well as anybody else but if Fine Gael think they are benefiting the farmers in any way by their contributions in this House, I would hasten to warn farmers' associations of all kinds, if at all possible, to steer clear of any advice being tendered from Fianna Fáil high priests.
Comment on this
Fine Gael—because down the years they have swallowed up all the farmers' organisations that ever entered this House. Now they shed crocodile tears regarding them in connection with this Bill. It is high time it was introduced; indeed it is years late, but it is better late than never. It is a great thing to see we are at last having this very necessary and useful piece of legislation. To try to cut out the section which deals with the necessity for holding a licence would completely ruin the effect of the Bill. Some reference has been made to having this decided in court, but it would be presumptuous on my part to tread on that ground, because on this side of the House, the Minister, Senator Yeats and Senator E. Ryan have dealt fully and ably with it.
Comment on this
Could the Chair get any indication as to when the discussion on these three amendments may finish? The House is aware that other Senators are waiting to move their amendments in these four groups.
Comment on this
I suppose that what I have to say will conclude the debate on these amendments, and I was about to open with that hope on this amendment. It has been a much longer and a much more diffusive debate than I would have wished for, and the contributory factor to that state of affairs is not only the speakers from the Government side of the House but, in particular, the Minister who has raised so many hares that many people with a sporting instinct have been endeavouring to hunt them down.
Comment on this
No; I have not said that. I am saying the Minister has raised these hares.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
The Minister has been engaging in a game of political skittles. He concocts arguments; he misinterprets arguments; he twists arguments and statements. Then he demolishes every one of them with logic from his point of view. The political skittles may be an entertaining thing but not very entertaining at this time of the year, and not very useful for the purpose of getting this Bill through the House. If the Bill is progressing so slowly, let the Minister blame himself more than other people.
To go back to the amendment, it says that there ought to be no need for licences and, if licences are to be issued, that it is not a Minister of State should issue them, and certainly not a Minister of State who should decide to cancel or revoke them. I do not intend to repeat anything I have said along that line already, because it is quite evident that what we have to say will not persuade by one vote, except perhaps Senator O'Reilly, that what we are saying is right.
If the Minister and his Department and his predecessors as Ministers for Agriculture were as concerned as they ought to have been about the condition of livestock marts and about the possibility of farmers who sold their cattle in those marts losing money through the mismanagement of the owners and auctioneers, one would have expected in all the many speeches that Ministers make from time to time some indication that legislation was necessary and that something should be done about livestock marts. I know of no speech made by any Minister of State at any time in relation to the condition of livestock marts, or deploring the fact that farmers had lost money. The device that was adopted by one of the Ministers in the Dáil recently of getting a Deputy to put down a question in order to give a matter a public hearing was never adopted in relation to livestock marts.
As it goes on, this debate has produced at least some good and all our time may not be wasted, for it now appears that the Minister has got one reasonable ground for introducing legislation of some kind in relation to livestock marts. He proposes that one of the conditions to be appended to the licence to be issued is that the owner will enter into some kind of fidelity bond to guard against the deprivation of small farmers, or farmers of any kind, of the price of their cattle.
In the speech the Minister made here on the Second Stage of this Bill, he did not make a single reference to what I would consider the best reason he has, or should have, for introducing this Bill. In the whole of the Second Reading speech, the Minister made not a single reference to the desirability or the necessity for safeguarding the financial interests of those who do business with the livestock marts, but as time goes on we find this will be one of the new things attached to the licence. It must be a profoundly disturbing thing for a person engaged in the livestock mart to know that one of the conditions to be attached to the licence will be that he will have to enter into a bond. It may well be the Minister will say they will have to deposit money in a particular bank. However, nobody reading this Bill, no matter how many times he reads it, will find a single word in it which says that will be a condition or that the Minister will have power to regulate that.
That is one of the things I should certainly have thought would be put in the Bill, that the Minister should have power to impose, as one of the conditions of the granting of a licence, a condition that the applicant should enter into a fidelity bond for whatever sum the Minister thinks fit, not exceeding a certain sum. That is a new power the Minister will have, to compel people to enter into that kind of bond, and not a word about it in the Bill or in the Second Reading speech.
Comment on this
He said it in the Second Reading speech in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am talking about what the Minister said here in urging this House to accept the Bill. The second point I want to make is that it is idle for the Minister to say the relations between himself and the agricultural community are excellent. Of course, the relations between the top dog and the underdog are always excellent, when you are on top. If that is what the Minister means, of course relations are excellent, but are they excellent between the farming community and the Minister? There is no one in the country who thinks they are, least of all the Minister.
A strong reason for being opposed to the giving of the absolute power to the Minister of granting or withholding a licence is that it is a power which should be exercised openly and before all the world and everyone should know the reasons why a licence is granted, why it is withheld or why it is revoked. The Minister did say—it may have been a slip of the tongue—that he would lay his reasons before each House of the Oireachtas for the withholding or the revoking of a licence. He only proposes to do that in relation to the revocation of a licence. The concept of the Minister when he introduced this Bill was to give a licence, withhold a licence—no reason given; revoke a licence—no reason given. It was only when public opinion began to exert its pressure—or is it the Fine Gael Party that caused public opinion to exert pressure—that the Minister introduced the amendments, as they now are, Nos. 6a to 7 in the Bill. We have greater power in the Fine Gael Party than I ever thought, because we are able to get the Irish Times to write two editorials, the Irish Independent to write two editorials, the Cork Examiner to write two editorials, the Incorporated Law Society to issue statements, junior chambers of commerce to issue statements——
Comment on this
Surely these matters have been referred to before.
Comment on this
I want to alert the House to the philosophy and the political outlook of the Minister and the danger of investing him with the power of granting or withholding or revoking licences. That was the Minister's original intention: to give a licence and no questions asked or explanation given; to revoke it and no explanation given either. That was his considered opinion until such time as we in the Fine Gael Party got these various forces to operate and compel the Minister to change his mind. What went on in 1928, in 1935, in 1955 and in 1956 was somewhat different because of the lack of the same disturbance between the rural community and the Minister but, more important, let us not forget this—certainly in my mind and in the minds of a great many others—we did not have an organisation known as Taca in 1955 and 1956.
Comment on this
Taca is corruption through the medium of Irish.
Comment on this
We will deal with that. We did not have champagne——
Comment on this
Champagne parties are hardly relevant to this debate. I would ask the Senator to confine himself to the amendment before the House.
Comment on this
I say that the granting of licences at a time when a new organisation such as Taca has been established is fraught with the danger of corruption at every stage. That is one of the reasons why we must strongly oppose giving the power of granting licences to the Minister.
The Minister has gone on with a lot of insincere and hypocritical talk, if I may be permitted to say so, or what sounds insincere or hypocritical talking about the Minister having to steer a straight course and be correct in all the decisions he makes when granting licences or revoking licences. Senator Yeats has gone on the same line and, with that imagination which well becomes him, he conjures up the Minister revoking a livestock mart licence and a livestock mart being shut down as a result of the Minister's activities and he sees all the great panoply of meetings and protests and parliamentary questions and so on and he says, in the face of that, how could any Minister revoke a livestock mart licence.
Comment on this
Let us become a little parochial in this matter and let us look at the number of protests that have been made by parents, county councillors, Deputies and Senators at the closing down of national schools in different parts of rural Ireland. I have seen Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Secretaries going on deputations to the Minister for Education protesting against the closing down of national schools and there has been all the local furore, meetings and so on, but has that changed the mind of the Minister in closing down schools?
Comment on this
Not at all. National schools are still being closed down because the Minister for Education has the power of saying: "Close down". There is no right of appeal and all the processes of democracy to which Senator Yeats has referred can be put to work but, because it is not a national issue, and because it is only a small area that is concerned, it is of no consequence——
Comment on this
The Senator and everybody else know it is done in the interests of the children.
Comment on this
The Senator was requested by the Chair not to interrupt.
Comment on this
I want this debate to finish as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Equally, we had very thorough-going assurances given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, in that confident way he had of giving assurances to the House, that branch railway lines would not be closed down except in extreme circumstances. But the branch lines were closed down one after the other. There were deputations to CIE but they had the power and they closed them down. There were deputations to the Minister for Transport and Power and they were just a waste of time.
The same thing will happen under this Bill. The Minister can snap his fingers at deputations because he has the power and will exercise it. The Minister has given no satisfactory explanation, nor has any member of his Party, as to why they consistently denigrate and downgrade the courts. Why is it that on every possible occasion, instead of allowing the courts which are there to arbitrate between man and man and between the Government and the individual citizen, they have to be bypassed? Does it not show that the Minister and members of his Party do not have trust or confidence in the courts? Mark you, every day the courts deal with business matters such as landlord and tenant applications or licensing of hotels and a variety of things like that. Senator Yeats should know sufficiently well the complex matters with which courts are able to deal and if he says the courts could not deal with this matter, that they would be overcrowded, how can the Minister deal with it, the Minister who has so much work to do, so many aspects of work to attend to in his Department, who has to attend meetings of the Government, who has to confer with his officials day in day out, who has to act as a Deputy for his constituency and who has to write 300 letters a week for his constituents on his own sworn testimony in the courts and who not only has to do all that but has to be an active Party man on top of that? How can he give, to this or any other matter, the calm and detached consideration that the courts which are concerned with no other things but these disputes can give? The idea is absurd and completely unconvincing. If the Seanad thinks that the Minister who gets a report from some officials and asks a few pertinent questions——
Comment on this
I do not think that Deputy Dillon or any other Minister can do all these things in anything like the same way or with the same efficiency as can our courts which are equipped for that purpose. If the Senator wants the Minister to engage in that kind of work and believes that is correct he is certainly living in a land that does not exist. I, therefore, urge the House to accept this amendment to delete line 17 from the Bill. If the House does that, we can then sit down and make some further progress in bringing in a really valuable and worthwhile Bill in the interests of the livestock owners, the marts and those who use them.