We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 461–675 of 675. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Livestock Marts Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 13 of 1967 ›

Very briefly, I want to conclude on amendment No. 7 which stands in the names of Senator Stanford, Senator Ó Conalláin, Senator Jessop and myself. The amendment is put down solely to show the concern expressed in all independent and thinking quarters on the question of the anti-democratic nature of the power sought in this section, denying the right of appeal to the courts in a matter where obviously that appeal and the granting of the licence should rest with our courts.

I do not want to take very long on this, but I want to reiterate that the Incorporated Law Society cannot by any stretch of the imagination be regarded as a political body. Neither can the civil liberties group, or the co-operative marts or the associated marts. Yet, one and all of those groups have come out and above all, condemned it on leaving the granting of licences to the whim of the Minister and the pressures that can be exercised by local cumainn on the Minister, whatever Party he represents. That is wrong. It is a further indication of the political immaturity of the country as a whole, and a failure to develop along democratic lines which would give the groups concerned more and more responsibility for the organisation of their own affairs, and the carrying out of the work following from it.

Members who are not prepared to stand back from the system and look at it can be beguiled by various precedents or pseudo precedents. I do not want to go into them again, but I suggest that anyone concerned should have a chat with an agricultural instructor and he will be put right on those precedents. Surely that is within the reach of Senators on the opposite side who have spoken. Indeed, I think Senator Yeats would learn a lot if he came from Dublin and consulted people down the country. He would get to know the problems and grasp the difference. I would hope that after a week's instruction he might come back realising the difference between a pound of butter and a bullock.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator know the difference between end products?

Comment on this

He would then have made some real progress. I hope that even at this late stage the Minister will show himself big enough for his post by having the courage to acknowledge that he is wrong, and withdrawing this measure, or alternatively if he will not take the proper course of withdrawal, that he will think it over calmly for the next six months. He should take the course which was endorsed by all the independent authorities that the licences should be given by the courts, the same as licences are given for supermarkets, dance halls, solicitors, auctioneers and various other groups. The courts should be allowed to function, and we should be proud that we have a judicial system, even if there is a glaring case of the need for urgent reform in that system to do away with political patronage which unfortunately is at the base of it. Let us accept it is far better that this work should be entrusted to the judiciary who have risen above the political patronage of their appointments and have proved themselves worthy of our confidence. They are capable of administering the licensing requirements in this Bill if the Minister insists on licences. I appeal to him even at this late stage to accept amendment No. 7. I am proud and happy to know that the last occasion we had such a full quota of university Senators endorsing an amendment here was during the debate on PR.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That was the time the Senator could not throw enough dirty water on the systems in Belfast and England.

Comment on this

We have done a service to the country by alerting them to the pitfalls and dangers, and to the anti-democratic nature of this proposal. I am happy that we have again taken our stand, and I hope that we have in some way shown what we think of this anti-democratic measure that has been introduced hastily and with such bad timing.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now let battle begin.

Comment on this

I will speak only on the three amendments on the Order Paper, Nos. 4, 7 and 8. After two days' discussion we are still on section 1 of the Bill, so I do not know how long Senators opposite intend to delay this legislation by their superfluous talk. The first amendment, amendment No. 4, in the name of Senator O'Quigley, is to delete line 17. He did not say a word about this line which deals with the licensing of the marts. The second amendment is in the name of Senator Stanford, I am sorry to say, who usually talks intelligently in this House.

Comment on this

Always.

Comment on this

He is not making an intelligent recommendation in this amendment. He spoke fairly decently on it himself, but it was ruined by the superiority complex of his assistant, Senator Quinlan.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Remember he is a vocational Senator.

Comment on this

The subsections of the amendment are ridiculous. Subsection (2) of the amendment reads:

Such District Justice shall, at the time of the granting of the licence, attach to such licence such condition as he shall think proper and shall specify same in the licence.

How is he to know?

Comment on this

From the evidence to be given by the officers of the Minister.

Comment on this

Will you be quiet? Who is to give the evidence?

Comment on this

The officers of the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not want your interruptions or gesticulations.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Senator should not ask questions if he does not want answers.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Questions are rhetorical.

Comment on this

Does the Senator realise how the courts operate?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Quinlan frequently asks why people are allowed to interrupt. They are not.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the terminology of these amendments. At least amendment No. 8 in the name of Senator O'Quigley gives some reason and explanation for the system adopted but so far as amendment No. 7 is concerned, Senator Quinlan talks about a procedure of the court. On subsection (2) of the amendment I want to know how is the district justice to form his judgment? Who will give him any information? The Minister has a staff who can supply information. Has the district justice any means of getting information? Subsection (3) of the amendment provides:

The District Justice may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence.

When, where, how or why? Who is to tell him? Who is to give him any information? These super intelligent members from the universities put this down in black and white as an amendment to an intelligent section on the Bill.

Comment on this

I will not listen to you. I will not tolerate your interruptions. I want to point out that subsections (2), (3) and (4) of this amendment are nonsensical. They mean nothing and they could never operate before a district justice or anyone else. I will not listen to your interruptions.

Comment on this

The Senator has not got a legal training.

Comment on this

What did you get? Subsection (4) of the amendment provides:

Upon breach of a condition attached to a licence the holder of the licence shall be guilty of an offence.

They do not specify in any way how he is to get this information, how he is to amend or revoke, or why. Senator O'Quigley in his amendment does endeavour to lay down some line of procedure, but there is no line of procedure in this particular case. It is absurd to think that a district justice, hearing an application for a licence, would know all the circumstances and everything about the licence. There is no one to give him any statement. Subsection (4) reads: "Upon breach of a condition attached to a licence the holder of the licence shall be guilty of an offence." Could anything be more absurd than that? The unfortunate district justice will have to know something from somebody. Who is to give him the information of a breach of a licence? This amendment is tabled by these superior vocational university representatives here. It is a lot of nonsense and I am surprised at Senator Stanford but not a bit surprised at Senator Quinlan, remembering the supercilious attitude he adopts usually in these matters—he knows everything and we know nothing. The whole thing is absurd.

Amendment No. 8 is a lengthy one in the name of Senator O'Quigley and he, at least, indicates how the information is to be provided. I was often before justices in the district courts giving evidence on behalf of local authorities and on behalf of the Minister and I know something about this kind of thing. How are district justices to know in this particular case unless they get information from someone? The district justice is a most unsuitable person to try to implement this provision on his own. It is absurd to suggest that district justices should issue licences for marts, marts about which they know nothing, less indeed than Senator Quinlan knows about them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is what Fianna Fáil think of the courts.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator FitzGerald should read what Fine Gael thought of them about two years ago.

Comment on this

These are irrelevancies. Senator Quinlan mentioned end products, again in his usual supercilious fashion and said the same situation does not occur anywhere else. I made one trip to Holland. We were taken out to Friesland and shown the end products produced there. The Senator need not tell me they were not cattle, because they were not cattle, but they were the end products from licensed cattle marts. The one thing that struck me was who supervised the work of the 77 co-operatives providing the central authority and they explained to us that they had their marketing system all over the world, even in the Falkland Islands. I asked what check there was on those and I was told the Government check them all. Yet Senator Quinlan has the cheek to come along here and tell us they are allowed to do everything on their own. They cannot. There must be supervision. With regard to supervision then, who is to supervise but the Minister established democratically? I am speaking here as a public representative and a former official who had to implement legislation enacted by the Houses of the Oireachtas.

There has been a great deal of talk about this being done and that being done. Senators have a right to object but I know one occasion on which the Members of this House agreed that an emergency order in relation to the bombing of the North Strand should be altered, and it was altered. I do not know of any occasion since on which Members of the Oireachtas were so interested in the powers they have to bring up any of those orders and they are still there. Under the Milk and Dairies Act, which does not deal with creameries, there is more legislation through the medium of orders made by the Minister under the Act than there is in the Act itself. The same is true of the Diseases of Animals Act. The Act passed is really a codification of the law and it provides that the Minister may make orders to deal with this, that and the other.

As public representatives we have certain obligations on us and we have certain responsibilities. To come in here and suggest handing over to the district courts a duty which the courts are not able to fulfil shows utter irresponsibility. That is my final statement on that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The front bench Fianna Fáil view of the courts.

Comment on this

District justices would not be capable of doing the work with anything like the efficiency of the Minister and his Department. There is just no comparison. I trust that the Opposition will not continue in that strain any further.

Comment on this

I tried to terminate the debate and the Senator started it all over again.

Comment on this

I have been speaking for five minutes and I have spoken to three amendments. I have explained why they are not suitable under our democratic system.

Comment on this

We did not take part in this debate yesterday or today because our amendments relate to section 3. However, I think the time has arrived when someone has to say something about the trend of the debate. We have to ask ourselves why it is this debate is likely to turn into a marathon unless someone takes drastic action to bring it to a close. We have been reasonable all along in our approach to this Bill. We believe there should be legislation to control marts but we do not believe that legislation is tremendously urgent. We also believe that certain amendments should be made. Senator Murphy moved an amendment and I am quite certain, from the reaction on the Fianna Fáil side of the House, that they are quite prepared to listen to his reasoning, but then, before the Minister had time to reply, Senator O'Quigley came in and announced that he would contest every single word. The challenge was thrown at the Minister and the Minister, being the man he is, fond of a fight, took up the challenge and said: "Word for word I will take you on". That is what has put us in the position we are in today.

We may find ourselves in the position that section 3 of this Bill may never be reached and that the amendments in which we are interested may never be discussed. We do not want to find ourselves in that position. We want to get just a fair crack of the whip and to make the suggestions that we have to make in a reasonable way. We are not playing a game for the NFA or anyone else. The NFA was no great good to the Labour Party. It was no great good to the Fianna Fáil Party. The Fine Gael Party did away with one type of representative in the county council, the Independent councillor. They did not harm any other Party but they got rid of the Independents. The success has apparently gone to their heads and they want to get all the public attention they can at present and they bring in some amendments which I consider absolutely and totally ridiculous. We spent a couple of hours speaking on two words "or otherwise".

I also blame the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party for not accepting a proposal I made on last Thursday night that we should meet today at 3 o'clock and finish up tomorrow night with the Committee Stage. The Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party did not accept that proposition. Indeed, he had a way out in that I had accused the Government Party of using the guillotine in Dáil Éireann and I have said that I did not consider it right or proper for the Government Party to use the guillotine when legislation was being introduced which was not of an emergency type. There is no emergency about this legislation and it should be dealt with like every other Act of Parliament.

The Minister made great play of the fact that there were so many amendments to the Planning Act and it went through the Dáil without divisions et cetera but he approached the Planning Act in a much different way from the way he is approaching the Livestock Marts Bill. He is approaching the Livestock Marts Bill as if it were life or death. There is no life or death about it.

I should like to ask the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party why he did not accept the proposal made by the Labour Party on Thursday night to meet today and conclude the Committee Stage tomorrow night, putting down reasonable amendments and withdrawing unreasonable amendments. I think the Government Party, if they had accepted that motion, could not have been accused of using the guillotine. We could have been accused of using the guillotine then. We were quite prepared to accept that responsibility. We wanted to curtail the debate on this Bill because there are several other people to be considered outside of the people who are in this House. We have the staff here who should be on holidays; we have several people here who have made arrangements to take their families to the Gaeltacht and various other places, and they cannot go, and what is it all for? It is all a little bit of spite between the Fine Gael Party and the Minister as a result of NFA activities.

I do not believe the House should have been held here. The Minister could have made a compromise by accepting the amendment we put down. He could have made a compromise by saying: "Let us deal with the Second Stage of the Bill and we will come back in September and do the Committee Stage. Bring in your amendments and deal with them and let them be sensible amendments." If that had been done, we should all be in a happier position here today. We may go on to Friday. Nothing will happen between now and Friday but people will lose their tempers and they will not be better friends anyway when they end up on Friday.

My suggestion is that there should be some approach to conclude the business. The Minister should give way some little bit, for instance, by saying that he would delay the Report Stage until September.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I should like to say in reference to what Senator McAuliffe has said that the proposition which was made on Thursday night was quite acceptable to me but I said it would be acceptable if the Fine Gael Party accepted it. If the Senator remembers, I recall that Senator Garret FitzGerald said that he felt he could not give any such undertaking. The proposition was quite acceptable to me.

Comment on this

May I say in reply to that, that last night when the Leader of the House put the proposition here, he put it to a vote. Why were we not called on to vote on the proposal made on Thursday night? I think that when a Member of the House makes a proposal and gets a seconder, he is entitled to get the opportunity of having a vote on the proposition. It struck me that the Leader of the House did not want this debate to conclude. He wanted it to drag out and fall down.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

This seems to be a discussion on something that is not before the House.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I have Thursday's Official Report.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am putting amendment No. 4 in the name of Senator John B. O'Quigley "To delete line 17". The fate of amendment No. 8 will depend on the decision in regard to amendment No. 4 but the fate of amendment No. 7 will not. It may have a separate decision if the Senators moving it wish, but there will be no further debate on it. To make this clear also and to avoid any confusion, I am going to put the motion to the House in the form "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the section".

Tá 30
·
Níl 13
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Amendment No. 8 falls.

Comment on this

I understand that the amendment is put.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That section 1 stand part of the Bill".

Tá 30
·
Níl 9
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

In the course of the discussion yesterday, a question was raised, which the Minister has not yet answered, as to whether weekly or fortnightly pig sales in provincial towns, usually held in a yard attached to some business premises, would be regarded as livestock mart sales. There is a grave risk of a severe injustice being inflicted on a certain section of the community, if they are deprived of this service, a service which has been available for many years and which serves a wide area in each provincial town, where the farmers can bring in their pigs to either the weekly or fortnightly market and have them sold there, either by hand or by auction, to buyers, usually representatives from the bacon factories.

If these are to constitute sales at livestock marts, not only will the people be deprived of that service, but should the proprietors decide to comply with the regulations and bring them up to the required standard, the cost involved would mean that the people concerned would decide it was not worth the amount of money involved and would drop the idea altogether, with severe consequential hardship on a great many people. Therefore, I oppose the section.

Comment on this

There are a few matters arising on this section which I should like the Minister to deal with. Under section 3 (8), existing livestock marts are to be automatically granted licences but only if, in relation to the place where the business is carried on, the regulations made under the Act are complied with. It will be an offence under section 2 to carry on the business of a livestock mart unless there is a licence in force in respect of the place. There are in existence livestock marts which will be of a size, design and will have such arrangements as regards ventilation, heating, lighting and accommodation as are prescribed in paragraphs (e) and (f) of section 6 (2), but whose owners may never be able to comply with whatever specifications are laid down in the regulations.

I can see that the Minister will delay the making of an order putting section 2 (1) into operation so as to enable certain marts to go about complying with the regulations. What will happen to the owners of a mart which, because of its size and design, is not capable physically of being made to comply with the regulations? That is the first question. I do not know what will happen to the owners of such a mart. It may be there will be marts of such size and design that economically it would not be feasible, without pulling down the whole thing, to comply with the regulations made under section 6.

Then, in relation to the marts that will qualify as regards maintenance, cleansing, ventilation, minor types of renovation and repairs, for how long is it intended to delay the coming into operation of subsection (1)? The Minister would have a discretion to appoint the order for a certain day. Could he indicate, in terms of months or years, when the section would come into operation?

Comment on this

Senator Malone expressed fears in regard to the sale of pigs in a yard, as might be affected by section 2. I do not quite understand whether or not he means that there are such places that have been adapted for the sale by auction of pigs or other livestock. Is this the kind of place he has in mind or just a yard in which pigs are now traded in, not necessarily by auction? I am rather at a loss to know which he has in mind.

Comment on this

There are yards where the pigs are sold by auction and by hand.

Comment on this

Is it commonly regarded as a pig mart at the moment?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

It is not? Then, until we see the actual case, it would be very difficult to be specific. It would have to stand on the merits of the procedure there, the practice there. It would be very difficult indeed to say, offhand, that this, that or the other operation that might be going on at the moment comes within the terms of the measure.

Comment on this

If the practice heretofore has been that pigs were sold under the hammer, will they not automatically come under the terms of the Bill?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would say whether this is what is provided for under section 4. Section 4 is something I could not understand, but, having heard what Senator Malone has just said, perhaps the Minister has in mind the making of exemptions under section 4.

Comment on this

One of the things in regard to these regulations is that the regulations themselves can indeed be used to define times within which certain things might be done—in other words, within the regulations, it can be stated that a particular time or times would be given in particular affirmations in relation to changes which might be necessary. Without wishing to anticipate the debate on the actual section, I would say that the two marts associations—the co-operative and the private marts associations—have agreed that they will help me with these draft regulations and lend the use of their experience to me and my Department in the drafting of these regulations. Therefore, we should be apprised pretty clearly by those operating the marts as to reasonable times to attain certain things that might be demanded under the Bill, when enacted, and that might not be provided in existing marts. To give times is not possible at this stage but these times and delays, as it were, of the actual impact of the Bill, when enacted, in certain instances will be determined in consultation with the two marts associations who have already agreed to lend us their aid in this particular direction.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say whether he has been in communication with the Livestock Marts Association since the last time a statement went into the newspapers from that Association in relation to this Marts Bill? I gather from the Minister now that he has been consulting with them since then in relation to this Bill.

Comment on this

If the Senator gathered that, he gathered wrongly. However, it is a fact that this was agreed to by both associations separately in their talks with me. Not only were they anxious to be consulted in these draft regulations and the content of them, but I also was very happy that they should agree to lend their knowledge and experience to me and to my Department in the final drafting of the regulations. In spite of what newspapers or others who talk may have caused to be published in the newspapers, I have no reason to believe that either of these marts associations will not act in the manner which they promised at that particular time.

Senator Murphy asked if section 4 might be relevant to the problem raised by Senator Malone. It is possible that, under this exemption section, matters that could not otherwise be dealt with reasonably may well be brought in under the exemptions as being the way to deal with them. It is terribly difficult to be specific or definitive in regard to the Bill, when enacted, on hypothetical cases.

Comment on this

I am reading from the Cork Examiner of 8th July, 1967. It is a statement issued by the Associated Livestock Marts of Ireland on 7th July, 1967. It reads:

The case presented by the marts can be summarised under three main headings:

(1) the Associated Livestock Marts' of Ireland great concern at the excessive power which the proposed legislation was giving the Minister;

(2) that there was no appeal to the courts;

(3) that the marts' freedom to conduct their own business in their own way was being undermined.

Were these very points taken up with the Minister in his recent discussions?

Comment on this

I think the best thing I can do is to nail this bogey where it belongs, once and for all. I have here a document which I mentioned in the Dáil but which I refrained from using at that time because it was not my property but which I shall now read as such use has been made of alleged statements by the Associated Livestock Marts. It is a report of a meeting with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries which was held in the offices of the Department on Friday, 30th June, 1967, at 4 p.m. This is a report by the Associated Livestock Marts of Ireland of that meeting—not my report. It reads as follows:

The executive committee of the Associated Livestock Marts of Ireland met the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Mr. Neil T. Blaney, T.D. and senior officers of his Department on Friday, 30th June, 1967, to discuss the Livestock Marts Bill, 1967. The marts' team was led by Colonel B. F. Blood, Chairman.

The meeting was held in a cordial atmosphere throughout and the Minister expressed his desire to appreciate our point of view and to allay our fears as far as possible. The case presented by the marts can be summarised under three headings:—

(1) our great concern at the excessive power which proposed legislation was giving the Minister;

(2) that there was no appeal to the courts;

(3) that our freedom to do our own business in our own way was being undermined.

In addition, we expressed strong objections to the severity of the penalties, as proposed in the Bill. We also pointed out that the regulations which have yet to be drafted should be reasonable and realistic and that there should be a general statement of conditions rather than that conditions attached to one licence should vary from those of another.

In replying to the marts' case, the Minister said this Bill was drafted in the normal way and that it was not the intention to have anything sinister in it. Many other pieces of legislation already enacted had given similar powers to the Ministers concerned. He would very much appreciate, he said, if the Marts' Association would be available for further consultations with regard to the drafting of the regulations.

With regard to the right of appeal, he himself felt that, as far as possible, there should be this right of appeal to someone other than the Minister. He would be prepared to do this in all matters except in the case where marts refused to stay open for business or where they discriminated against patrons for what were clearly to be seen to be other than ordinary commercial reasons. Continuing, he said, as far as the exemptions in section 4 were concerned, this referred to dispersal sales and sales conducted by the RDS and did not mean that some marts could continue in business with different standards from the general body of marts.

With regard to section 6, the Minister said he appreciated that mart-owners needed freedom to use their discretion with regard to certain individuals; it was his intention to preserve this freedom. As far as the requirements of Section 6 were concerned, it was intended that the regulations should be reasonable and that every mart would be given ample time with regard to any changes they might have to make.

On section 7, the mart team expressed strong resentment on subsection (1) (b), i.e. on the power of an official of the Minister to take a member of the Garda Síochána with him to the mart. The Minister said, on reflection, he was prepared to knock this provision out entirely. On (c) of subsection (1) the Minister said he appreciated the fears of marts with regard to the production of certain documents and he said he would go out of his way to make it clear that it was only those documents relating to the movements of cattle that could be examined and that certainly the marts' accounts would not be looked at. He could absolutely guarantee that there would be no fear that this would be used for taxation purposes.

On subsection (1) (e), the mart representatives expressed concern that the Minister's officer should seek information from any person whom the officer believed to be employed on the premises. The Minister said he recognised that this was undesirable, and he was quite prepared to amend this to read "responsible person", i.e. the owner or manager, and that only in the event of the "responsible person" obviously not co-operating with the officer would he then question a subordinate person.

On section 8, the marts' team stressed that the penalties suggested were highly excessive, and that while it was recognised that the courts would be dealing with this matter, it might, nevertheless, mislead the court into imposing a heavier fine or penalty than the case, in justice, warranted, because of the maximum penalty being £1,000 or 6 months in jail or both. The Minister undertook to review this point.

On section 8, subsection (2), it was clarified that if an organisation such as our own commented publicly on some incident in relation to this legislation, we would not be committing an offence under the Act.

Fidelity Bond

The Minister said it was his intention to see that farmers would be protected in future in any case where a mart ran into financial difficulties. He recognised that there were a number of ways in which this protection could be provided. At the request of mart representatives he said he was quite prepared to afford them an opportunity of coming up with their own scheme for this purpose, and provided that it afforded the protection which he had in mind, he would certainly accept it.

Licensing

All existing marts would be automatically entitled to a licence.

This concluded the meeting.

That is dated 3/7/67.

Comment on this

The last sentence of what the Minister read out means that all existing marts would be automatically entitled to a licence. That is a fairly accurate reproduction of that last sentence. I take it that the Minister does not dissent from the accuracy of that part of the report? That is the impression that is being conveyed, but that is not what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

Maybe the Senator is confusing it with the amendment. The amendment is very confusing anyway; I know that. The amendment proposed by some of his colleagues is most misleading in this regard.

Comment on this

We will come back to that later on. Subsection (8) does say that:

Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, a person who carries on the business of a livestock mart at any place and who, immediately before the passing of this Act, carried on that business at that place, shall, if in relation to the place, the regulations under this Act are complied with, be entitled to be granted a licence in respect of the place.

That is quite a different thing to what is stated in that report, that all existing livestock marts will be automatically entitled to a licence. They certainly will not be automatically entitled; they will have to comply with the regulations. I submit that if the regulations in regard to size and design—which are something about which the livestock marts cannot do anything—do not comply with the regulations, then they will not and cannot legally be given a licence by the Minister. I think that is true and the Minister should clarify that so that people afterwards cannot say he has left them with a wrong impression. Existing livestock marts can only get a licence if they comply with the regulations and the interpretation of whatever the Minister said by the marts association, which drafted that report, is not correct. It is not correct to say that all existing marts will automatically get licences. It may well be that that will turn out to be so, that all of them will comply with the regulations which will be made in relation to design and size, but I am not at all satisfied that it will be so. If they do not comply with the regulations, and they were unable to do so without tremendous cost, then they are automatically excluded by section 2 from carrying on that business.

Comment on this

Lest anybody goes chasing this hare, I want to say that Senator O'Quigley is, as it were, in his own mind drafting the regulations and has them drafted when he speaks as he has spoken. The regulations will take care of this. It is quite true that what is recorded here is a synopsis of what was given to these people to understand, that those marts in operation, which have been carrying on business before the passing of this Act, will be granted licences. In so far as the regulations are concerned, those regulations may have application at a date ahead, all of them or part of them. This is a matter that will be discussed with these marts associations in regard to whatever regulations may be made, as to their impact in regard to marts generally, whether they can be applied now or in one month's time or in six months or a year, from now, in whole or in part. This is what they were told and what in fact is intended and what is capable of being done in that manner and will be done.

Comment on this

Will the Minister be able to attach different conditions to existing marts, such as that in six months time, one will have to have installed lighting and ventilation facilities? Do I understand that in no circumstances will the Minister attach such conditions to the licences to be issued to existing marts as would make it economically impossible for them to continue in business? I am trying to ensure that in relation to the physical aspect of the buildings, there will not be any condition which will involve such alteration as would make it uneconomic for the mart owners and that this will not be applied in one year's time or two years' time.

Comment on this

It would be quite wrong of me to say categorically that no case could arise wherein the economics of bringing a mart premises up to the standards of the general run of marts would cost too much. I cannot say that. I would hope this would not be the case. I cannot categorically say it will not happen in the way the Senator presented it. Getting back to the regulations, too much emphasis is being placed on a particular mart. Perhaps this was unintentional. Certainly it was not my intention to have separate regulations to apply to each mart. General regulations will apply to all marts in a general way. As to the date on which they will apply to existing marts which will be licensed straight away, this is something which will have to be gone into and examined in regard to the time for any part of the regulations to be effective and on what date they should become effective. What would be fair and reasonable in respect of the changes brought about by the regulations, what would be a reasonable time to give—all this will have to be given very thorough consideration.

It is my intention that this will be the sort of approach we will have to this matter, being the reasonable thing to do. We do not want to bring in regulations that will immediately put on the spot half the marts of the country. We have no intention of wiping them out or making the changes so onerous that it would not pay them to carry them out. Clearly, that would be lunacy on my part and I have no intention of going in that direction. I will be consulting with the Marts Association in regard to these things and no doubt will hear from them at first hand what would be regarded as a reasonable time for certain requirements to be applied generally which at present may be operated at only a few marts, how long it would take, what would be the cost and what would be a reasonable time to allow before this would be actually obligatory on them. This could apply to all or part of the regulations. The dates on which they would come into operation, or on which any part of the regulations would come into operation, would not be the same. We can deal with it on the basis of what is reasonable and fair and what could be expected from the mart owners.

Comment on this

Is there not a difficulty in catering for the different sizes there? Obviously, an installation that has cost £200,000 can afford more superior standards and equipment than a small mart in a poor part of the country. It would seem difficult to draft regulations and standards that would apply overall. Would the Minister consider having different standards for different sizes of installations?

Comment on this

I am still not satisfied in regard to the regulations and licences the Minister proposes to introduce. Subsection (1) says:

A person shall not carry on the business of a livestock mart at any place unless there is for the time being a licence in force in respect of that place.

When we read that in conjunction with the definition section, I should like an assurance from the Minister that the one-day events I have referred to, annual shows and sales of pedigree cattle in particular, will be allowed. These shows and sales are held all over the country and still serve a very important purpose. The Minister might allay the fears of the House by giving us some idea of his intentions in regard to these events. There are not so many of them but yet there are a few in each county. It has been the pattern of Irish farming that they have been patronised over the years and have served the country well in improving the quality and standard of Irish stock. Would the Minister give the House an assurance that these one-day events—the annual sales of pedigree cattle held on farms—will be exempted under the regulations?

Comment on this

It is the general intention under this exemption section that we can deal with that very type of operation which is, as the Senator says, the occasional or annual show. These are the things we have in mind for the exemptions.

Comment on this

Where there is a county show and sale organised by a committee or some pedigree owners have an annual sale of heifers, that would be allowed?

Comment on this

Whether it is an individual or a group, the committee of a co-operative movement or a number of individuals, would not enter into the matter at all. It would be the occasion rather than who was organising it that would be relevant. We would hope to have dispersal sales and clearance sales brought within the terms of the exemptions.

Comment on this

They are already covered in the definition section?

Comment on this

That is the whole point. By the definition section embracing certain things we do not want to take in, it means that we have to use this device to bring them out again. You might ask: "Why not leave them out of the definition section?" Our whole problem from a drafting point of view is to bring in all we want to bring in and to ensure that we do not bring in, as has happened in many other Bills, more than we wish to do. There are many fringe elements we do not want to bring in, so the exemption section device is the usual way out. That is why it is here—to rid ourselves of things which might be inadvertently there but which we do not want to catch.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

Before section 3 to insert a new section as follows:

"(1) Applications of or on behalf of a person who proposes to carry on the business of a livestock mart at a specified place, shall be made to a District Justice having jurisdiction in the District Court area wherein it is proposed to carry on such business.

(2) Such District Justice shall, at the time of the granting of the licence, attach to such licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify same in the licence.

(3) The District Justice may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence.

(4) Upon breach of a condition attached to a licence the holder of the licence shall be guilty of an offence.

(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, a person who carries on the business of a livestock mart at any place and who, immediately before the passing of this Act, carried on that business at that place, shall, if in relation to the place, the regulations under this Act are complied with, be entitled to be granted a licence in respect of the place."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In subsection (1), line 27, before "who" to insert "or an unincorporated body of persons."

The reason I move this amendment is that in section 8 of the Bill there is a reference to a "body corporate" and in subsection (2) to "an unincorporated body of persons". It seems to me that one of the fundamental principles of good drafting is to use the same term or phrase throughout a Bill. The position is quite clear as far as the Interpretation Act is concerned, because that provides the meaning of particular words that occur frequently in different Acts. In the Interpretation Act of 1937, in section 11, the word "person" when occurring in any enactment of the Oireachtas:

... shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate (whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole) and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual.

Equally, it is provided in the same section 11, dealing with the singular and plurals:

Every word importing the singular shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as if it also imported the plural...

and vice versa. The reason I am bringing in the unincorporated body of persons here in section 3 is that there is a reference to an unincorporated body of persons in section 8, and if the Interpretation Act were allowed to have its effect upon this particular enactment of the Oireachtas, no difficulty and no ambiguity would arise but when in section 3 you refer to a person and in section 8 refer to a person and a body corporate and an unincorporated body of persons, you certainly are introducing an unnecessary ambiguity. It is in order, therefore, to ensure that unincorporated bodies of persons, which would be friendly societies and co-operative societies, would be entitled to apply for and obtain a licence that I suggest that “a person or unincorporated body of persons who propose to carry on the business” should be the reading of section 3 subsection (1). As I say, no difficulty would arise if the Interpretation Act were allowed to have its effect upon the Bill and “unincorporated body of persons” were not introduced in subsection (2) of section 8. It seems to me that it would make it entirely clear that an unincorporated body would be entitled to apply for and obtain a licence if it is put in here in section 3, subsection (1).

Comment on this

On this matter I have inquired very assiduously and the situation is far from what the Senator has said. If the Interpretation Act were to be imported into subsection (2) of section 8, this would lead, I am assured, to utter confusion.

In section 8, subsection (2) at the moment, the words "person, body corporate and unincorporated body of persons", are being used in their ordinary meaning and not as per the Interpretation Act, and this is allowable, and in fact, is provided for in the Interpretation Act under section 11 (c). Section 11 (c) of the Interpretation Act gives the ways and means where we might depart. Briefly, it says, "unless the contrary intention appears". That is stated in the Interpretation Act of 1937 at section 11 (c) and, as I say if we were to import the Interpretation Act into section 8, subsection (2) of this Bill, we would not make for clarity but rather for confusion. As I say, I have checked this very, very critically and have been advised accordingly that this is, in fact, what the outcome would be.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister has been entirely correctly advised because, whether we like it or not and whether the Minister intends it or not, or the parliamentary draftsman intends it or not, the Interpretation Act does, in fact, have application unless the contrary intention appears. The plain truth of the matter is that the Interpretation Act applies throughout the whole of this Bill and "person" in subsection (1) of section 3 would mean what is stated in the Interpretation Act, that is to say, it is to be construed as importing a body corporate, whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual. There is no contrary intention in section 3, subsection (1) that "person" shall mean other than what is stated in clause (c) of section 11 of the Interpretation Act but the confusion arises because the parliamentary draftsman, perhaps, has taken this particular section from some other precedent and he goes on to spell out who is to be deemed guilty of an offence.

If he had said "where an offence under this Act is committed by a person" that would clearly include a body corporate whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual, by virtue of the Interpretation Act of 1937. There would be no necessity whatever, and there is no necessity, to put it into subsection (2) of section 8 because the Interpretation Act takes effect automatically and it is because of the confusion of putting it in in section 8 and leaving it out in section 3 that afterwards the Minister's advisers may say: "Oh, well, Minister, that may be so, that that is what the parliamentary draftsman said but we do not think, Minister, that you can do this." It is to remove that that I think either you delete all these surplus words in subsection (2) of section 8 because they are already imported into the section by the Interpretation Act or, alternatively, to make sure that co-operative societies are entitled to get the licence, you accept the amendment I suggest.

Comment on this

I think perhaps what the Senator is after is that if we take section 11 (c) of the Interpretation Act, which defines the word "person" as follows:

The word "person" shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate (whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole) and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual;

That is what "person" means under that Interpretation Act but where I feel the Senator is going wrong is that he is trying to say that if "person" means that, all these things together can be reversed and mean "person", and that is not so. I think this is really what is being said here.

Comment on this

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 11, 15, 17, 18, 19 and 22.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In subsection (1) to delete all words from and including "may" where it secondly occurs in line 30 to the end of the subsection and substitute "shall grant a licence authorising the carrying on of the business of a livestock mart at that place provided the applicant complies with regulations made by the Minister".

I am glad the temperature of this debate has gone down before we start on these amendments because I was hoping that we would approach the matter in a more reasonable mind. I am moving amendment No. 11 and discussing with it some other amendments, as you said—15, 17, 18, 19 and 22. These are mainly the amendments put down by the Labour Party Senators, some of which have been supported by some of the Fine Gael Senators. The support is welcome, I suppose.

We are dealing here with a Bill as described in its Title:

An Act to provide for the control and regulation by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries of livestock marts and the sale of livestock at such marts...

The point I want to make is that it is "for the control and regulation by the Minister". This is what the Bill sets out to provide. The Bill has been given a Second Reading by the Seanad. So, taking that situation, that the Seanad has agreed that the Minister should regulate livestock marts, we are accepting that as the case and what we are doing is saying: "Right; if these must be regulated, and the Seanad has agreed that they should be regulated, they should be regulated in such a way that there will be a fair measurement given to all the marts and all people who propose in future to set up the business of cattle marts."

I want to direct the attention of the Seanad to the wording of section 3 and the other sections which it is proposed to amend by the other amendments we are discussing simultaneously. It will be seen that in section 3 we are providing that "the Minister may at his discretion, grant or refuse to grant a licence authorising the carrying on of the business of a livestock mart at that place." Subsection (2) says:

The Minister may, at the time of the granting of a licence, attach to the licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify in the licence.

Subsection (3) says:

The Minister may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence.

Subsection (5) says:

Where the holder of a licence is guilty of any offence under this Act, the Minister may, if he so thinks fit, revoke the licence.

The Minister was making great play with precedents for this Ministerial authority, and he was mentioning, in particular, the Creamery Act, 1928, where this wording seems to have originated. In section 14 of that Act, we find the same sort of situation:

(1) It shall not be lawful for any person after the expiration of one month from the passing of this Act to maintain a creamery to which this section applies unless such person is authorised so to do by licence granted by the Minister under this section.

(2) The Minister may, if he so thinks fit——

There is a familiar ring about those words.

——grant to any person a licence to maintain a specified creamery to which this section applies subject to such (if any) conditions as the Minister shall specify in such licence.

This is the wording which is brought into this Bill that we now have before us, and the Minister, incidentally, is justifying asking for all this power and all this authority by reason of precedents which exist in previous Acts, and the first of those he mentioned was the 1928 Act. I suppose when you come to draft any Bill you look back and see what wording was used previously and this sort of thing carries on from Act to Act. However, in the same section I was reading from, section 14 of the 1928 Act, there is a further subsection, subsection (4):

This section applies to any creamery which, on or after the 1st day of January, 1928, and before the passing of this Act, either was opened for the first time for the carrying on of creamery business therein or was re-opened for the carrying on of creamery business after a period during which such business was not carried on therein and also applies to any creamery the business of which was, on or after the 1st day of January, 1928, and before the passing of this Act, extended by the addition thereto of a class, branch, or department of creamery business not then carried on in such creamery.

These very exceptional powers which were written into an Act in 1928 were in relation to a limited period and in respect of creameries which were set up or acquired in the interval between 1st January of that year and the passing of the Creamery Act, 1928. When we look at the Creamery Act of that year and the purpose of it, we shall understand why it was necessary to take these special powers, because the Title of that Act reads:

An Act to make provision for the more effective regulation and control in certain respects of the dairying industry and persons and co-operative societies engaged therein with a view to the better re-organisation of that industry and for other matters connected with such reorganisation.

It was an Act to provide for the rationalisation of the creamery industry and, judging by the Schedules to that Act, it was something which was asked for by the creamery industry generally. In the First Schedule there is mention of the fact that:

...WHEREAS in the year 1926 the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, Limited, with a view to aiding the Dairying Industry in Ireland, opened negotiations for the acquisition of the business and undertakings of the Condensed Milk Company of Ireland (1924), Limited, and of the Newmarket Dairy Company, Limited, to the end that redundant creameries might be eliminated with resultant benefit to the Dairying Industry...

Redundant creameries were, apparently, being eliminated, and it was quite understandable that, in the interval between the legislation being talked of and its final enactment, get-rich-quick smart chaps who acquired a creamery or proceeded to set up a creamery in order to get compensation or to get bought over, should be prevented from doing so. That is quite clearly the reason why these very special powers were taken in the 1928 Act where in section 14 it was provided, as I said, that the Minister may grant a licence and may attach a condition to such a licence. That only applied in very special circumstances and, quite obviously, to a very limited group, to people who, in the interval between the intention to rationalise the creamery industry and the final enactment of the legislation, might try to step in and get money by way of compensation by being acquired as a redundant creamery.

The Minister made great play of that. I have not had a chance of checking on the other Acts he mentioned but it is important that we should look at the first one where this type of wording originated. It originated in the 1928 Creamery Act and I am making the point that it related to a specific problem and I suggest we would all have agreed, if we were there in 1928, that it was the proper way of dealing with that problem at that time.

However, that is not the problem we are dealing with in regard to livestock marts. There is no question of rationalising them, of abolishing or removing redundant marts, there are no special funds involved. I accept it is desirable we should regulate the conduct of these marts and that there should be proper standards of hygiene. Marts deal with a very important industry and I accept it is quite right that they should deal with all customers equally and should not attempt to boycott certain individuals who might not agree with the majority at any time in any place. That would be wrong and the Minister is right in stepping in if that has occurred and saying: "We shall have to regulate the conduct of the livestock marts and I must take the necessary authority to enable me to do so".

We in the Labour Party accept that and we agree to give the Minister this power. On Second Reading, what we said was: "It is not desirable we should go ahead at this time because of the possibility of further worsening relations with the farming community". We thought that was more important than the necessity or desirability of regulating the conduct of the business of livestock marts. Our amendment on Second Reading was defeated.

We are now dealing with the Committee Stage and what we are saying very generally in our amendments is that the Minister should make regulations, that anybody who complies with them should be thereby empowered to set up the business of a livestock mart. There should be rules and they should apply to everybody equally: it should not be the case, as provided for in the Bill, that the Minister may at his discretion grant a licence and that he may, again at his discretion, attach any conditions to a licence and, in a later subsection, that he may vary the conditions, revoke the conditions.

We suggest he is thereby taking too much power. He would not be seen to deal equally with all the people involved because he could attach one condition to one mart and another condition to a neighbouring mart. We say that is wrong. We say there should be proper standards of hygiene, as is envisaged in later sections of the Bill, but we say these standards should attach to all marts equally and that the Minister should not be in a position to discriminate against certain people because he may not like them, because they may irritate him or because they may not have the proper political pull.

I do not think it is any insult to anybody in the sort of society in which we live, with political Parties, to suggest that political pull is relevant and effective. Of course, it is. We all know that and accept it as a fact of life. Many of us regret it but there it is. If you can use sufficient influence you can get more consideration than the person who has not the same sort of political influence. The Minister, being a good politician himself, will not take umbrage at the suggestion that that is a fact of life in Ireland today. One of his colleagues, I think it was the Minister for Education, made the remark about some being more equal than others.

That is what we in the Labour Party want to avoid in relation to the business of livestock marts. We say it is right and proper that they should be regulated in the interests of the very important industries in which they are engaged, particularly in the interests of the farmers, their customers. We say there should not be any discrimination against one farmer by the operators of a mart, but we emphasise that the conditions should be equal and that the Minister should not appear to discriminate or be put in the temptation of discriminating between one mart operator and another.

That is why, in amendment No. 11, we provide not that the Minister may grant a licence but that the Minister shall grant a licence authorising the carrying on of the business of a livestock mart, provided the applicant complies with regulations made by the Minister. That is the main burden of these amendments: we are trying to take out this freedom, if that is the proper expression, to discriminate between one mart operator and another. We want to provide that the Minister shall make regulations. We are giving him the authority to say what are the minimum requirements in regard to marts and then, providing that anybody, whatever his colour, religion, political affiliations, comes up to the minimum requirements laid down by the Minister and wants to engage in the business of a livestock mart, he must be given a licence to do so.

The Minister may argue that we shall have the situation then in which there may be too many livestock marts. This Bill does not set out to deal with that problem at all. We are not dealing with the problem of redundant cattle marts. Nobody has suggested there are too many. They are a commercial business and if anybody bites off more than he can chew, if he thinks he can put another out of business, that is all right. We accept that position and the Minister does not pretend he wants to deal with that problem. What he is doing here is seeking authority to make regulations and to apply these regulations and conditions at his sole discretion to different operators.

It is useless for the Minister or anybody else to say: "I would not do that. I will not discriminate. I will apply the regulations equally all round." What I am saying is that we should not give him authority to discriminate. We are dealing with an important piece of legislation and I hope I shall get the support of many Senators to ensure that regulations, once made by the Minister, will apply to all equally so that we shall not have a situation in which the Minister may make an exception of one particular man, letting him get a licence even though he does not come up to the regulations, and on the contrary attaching a condition to one licence which might be onerous and which might not attach to a competitor. We suggest that is wrong and that it should not be allowed in legislation.

Let me come to another aspect of this section, if I may deal with it on this amendment. In one of our amendments we propose to delete subsection (6) of section 3. Senators may wonder why. That becomes redundant if we accept the principle I have been advocating of having minimum conditions and applying them to all equally so that anybody who complies with these minimum conditions must get a licence and anybody who does not cannot be given a licence. If that were so, there would be no question of providing for the type of appeal mentioned in subsection (6) of section 3. That point has already been made and I need not labour it now.

In regard to the barrister who is asked to make a report to the Minister, there is no provision that his inquiry will be published, and there is no provision that the report he makes to the Minister will be published, or even given to the person who applies. I may be wrong in that last part. The person who conducts the inquiry reports to the Minister, and the Minister can suppress the report, and take no account of it. He is not bound to act on it, or accept it. The person simply reports to the Minister and that is as far as this legislation goes.

Let us go back to paragraph (b) of section 3:

Whenever the Minister proposes to revoke a licence because of a contravention of regulations under section 6 of this Act prescribing any matter specified in paragraphs (e) to (i) of section 6 (2) of this Act...

It is (e) to (i). What about (a) to (d)? These are exempt. It seems to me that these are the ones which might be subjected to an inquiry or examination because (e) to (i) deal with physical requirements as to the design, maintenance, repair, cleaning and accommodation. Further on there is something about hygienic and veterinary requirements, but these seem to be matters which are factual. Either they are correct or they are not, and the person whose licence is threatened with revocation can readily prove whether he has kept in line with the requirements laid down by the Minister. Paragraphs (a) to (d) are the ones on which there might be some doubt, and on which a legal mind might conduct an inquiry.

For example paragraph (b) provides:

——that entries for such auctions shall not be refused except in circumstances prescribed in the regulations,

In other words, there is the discrimination I was talking about earlier between one farmer and another, between one customer and another. It appears to me that this is a matter about which doubt might exist. There might be a difference of opinion as to whether or not discrimination was exercised, and a particular farmer might feel he was discriminated against. There might be a conflict of evidence and opinion on this and if there were to be an appeal I would have thought it was on this sort of aspect that the appeal would lie, and not upon the physical things in a livestock mart.

The Minister has very deliberately kept paragraphs (a) to (b) from going to appeal and, again, he is keeping the sole discretion and authority to himself in a matter which might involve a dispute between a farmer and an operator of a mart, on whether in fact there was discrimination, whether a bid was properly taken, and different things like that. The Minister clearly is keeping the right to himself to make a judgment and to revoke or not to revoke the licence of a mart operator.

We are saying: "Look; accept our amendment. Lay down that minimum regulations are necessary and give the right to anyone who complies with these minimum regulations to be given a licence or to retain a licence", and this section which I think is redundant anyway—it is not a very good section—would not be necessary. A number of amendments are being discussed in conjunction with this amendment. I am advocating to the Minister and to Fianna Fáil Senators that they should take this matter out of the rather political atmosphere in which it has been up to now. As some of my colleagues said earlier, we feel that Fine Gael are afraid of their lives that the Minister might make some concession in the Bill—afraid of their lives.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

That is my opinion, and I am entitled to it.

Comment on this

They are hoping the Minister will stay on his high horse and keep on this course, and that Fine Gael might make political capital out of the difficulties and bad feelings which will be created by the operation of this Bill. No matter how the Minister may operate it, there will always be the charge that there is discrimination, that he is attaching one condition to one licence and a different condition to another licence because the operator has contributed or has not contributed to the Fianna Fáil Party funds.

I can see the point of view of Fine Gael. This would be very desirable for Fine Gael. This would be great political capital up and down the country. As I said, I am of the opinion that Fine Gael would be very disappointed if, in fact, the Minister amended this legislation in any way. That is one of the reasons for the way in which the Bill was fought in the Dáil. I do not think there was much effort to try to get any consensus of opinion, or to try to get agreement Fine Gael went for the Minister hammer and tongs and knowing the Minister, and knowing the type of personality he has, it was quite certain that he would not budge an inch. At the same time, Fine Gael were saying they would fight the Bill line by line.

We are saying this is a bit too important for that sort of political carry-on. We are saying we accept that it is right and proper that the livestock marts should be regulated, and that conditions should be laid down for the operation of livestock marts. We are saying it is unfortunate that this should be done at this particular time, but that has already been decided by the Seanad.

If the marts are to be regulated, they should be regulated in such a way that there could not be any temptation to discriminate, or any power to discriminate between one and another. The regulations should be clearly stated. There should be minimum regulation requirements and anyone complying with them should be entitled to get a licence either to continue to operate, or to start a new business of operating, a livestock mart, and it should not be on the basis of what pressure or what representations any individual or any group can bring to bear, and the type of condition that might then be attached to the particular licence, a condition which, as I have already pointed out, may be varied at any time by the Minister at his sole discretion. If he does not like the way in which a particular operator is carrying on, if there is some row, or something, he will be under the temptation all the time to vary the conditions attaching to the licence and might, indeed, put a person out of business. We do not want that and I am hoping that some of the Fianna Fáil Senators may persuade the Minister that the approach we suggest here is not an unreasonable approach. It can be seen to be the just way of tackling the problem.

There may be need for some tightening up in the amendment because amendments put down by individual Senators are not word perfect. I am trying to get across the general principle that we should give the Minister the power to make the regulations. He and his Department are the best qualified to know what the minimum requirements should be for the operation of cattle marts. We give him that power to lay down what they should be, but, equally, any person who complies with the regulations should be entitled to get a licence and to retain it. He should not run the risk of being put out of business at any time because of the sole discretion of the Minister. That is what it boils down to because what we are being asked to give here in this Bill is power to the Minister to vary a condition, or conditions, at his sole discretion. We think that is wrong. It is bad legislation and it is not right to depend on the precedent in the 1928 Act dealing with creameries, which, as I pointed out, was an Act dealing with a very limited problem and, in the circumstances of the time what was done could readily be seen to be both desirable and necessary in order to deal with the particular problem. It is not right to carry that sort of legislation into this Marts Bill, which deals with a completely different problem altogether.

I am hoping the Minister will see his way to accepting this amendment. He may have read the newspaper report today of the address of the new President of the NFA. That address might give an opportunity for improving relations generally. I know the Minister says he has no quarrel with anybody, but perhaps he might accept this way of going about the problem. It would improve the position generally and it would, I hope, get agriculture back into a better relationship, which I think more important than any quarrels between political Parties or any credit or prestige they might get out of these quarrels. The good of the agricultural community is more important, and I appeal very strongly to the Minister, and not from a political point of view because we will not get any political capital out of this, to accept the principle enshrined in this amendment. It may need tidying up. What is important is the principle. The Minister should have the power to lay down the minimum requirements and, where these are complied with, the individual, group, co-operative or company should have the right to a licence and the right to retain that licence so long as he or they comply with these minimum requirements.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

Might I just clear up one point? Does Senator O'Quigley wish his amendment No. 12 to be discussed at the same time? There will, of course, be a separate decision.

Comment on this

Yes. I shall speak after the Minister.

Comment on this

This amendment might well be said to be acceptable if the Bill dealt only with certain limited matters, such as design, accommodation, hygiene, and so on. As the House is well aware, the Bill is much wider in scope than that and, in that wider scope, surely the Minister must be given some right to grant, refuse or revoke licences in certain circumstances. Under subsection (8) of section 3, which is proposed to be amended, marts in business immediately before the passing of the Act will, as we have already said, be entitled to a licence provided certain regulations ultimately are complied with. Possibly I can do no better than to quote what I said when introducing this Bill to the Dáil at column 874 of the Official Report of 21st June, 1967:

It is not the object of this Bill to hinder in the slightest way the legitimate operations of livestock marts or to prevent the establishment of new marts in areas not already catered for. Its purposes are to exercise a reasonable degree of control over the establishment of new livestock marts, to ensure for example that there is no uneconomic overlapping where a tendency to undesirable proliferation may occur in particular areas and also to ensure that adequate facilities of various kinds are provided and that the services of the marts are available fairly and reasonably to all clients.

That sets out in a very definite way, I think, the greater and wider scope of this Bill and should indicate to Senator Murphy that the restriction imposed, if his amendment were carried, would negative that wider scope to which I have referred in regard to keeping in check the unnecessary proliferation of marts.

If this expressed intention escaped the Senator, it may be because it was expressed before the great delay occurred, and I should mention here that, on that Second Reading in the Dáil, there was no great interest displayed by Fine Gael, or anybody else for that matter, in finding out what the Bill was about. It went through in a reasonably short time and perhaps this particular passage in my introductory speech was overlooked. But the intention was there stated and I refer the Senator and the House to it now in order to clarify for all concerned that we are not dealing only with design, accommodation, hygienic conditions, et cetera. but with a much wider context altogether. It is the intention that the Bill should be much wider in its scope and that, being the intention, an intention both desirable and necessary in the future, acceptance of the amendment in the light of that wider scope would nullify and indeed restrict the scope of the Bill as against that intention already expressed.

Comment on this

I wonder would I be correct in saying that from what the Minister has just remarked the scope of the Bill leaves it that he can regulate as to design, place and various other aspects in that a person or number of people desiring to set up a mart would be given a provisional licence on application to the Department with their plans, specifications, and so on and having obtained town planning permission to erect the building and lay-out of the mart, they would then be given a provisional licence under which they would know the principle and the extent of the regulations to be attached to the licence so as to save them from involving themselves in a huge expense which, if they were not given a provisional licence, they would not incur. As we say down the country, there are more ways of choking a dog than giving him butter and when they come to apply for their licence, the Minister could then, even at that stage attach to it such regulations as would render it practically impossible for them to carry on.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I am cutting in on Senator Murphy, but I am glad that Senator Malone raised this point. This is indeed the intention. This is what I think is the reasonable, sensible approach to this Bill, that before any real commitment by way of even commissioning any cost or incurring any worthwhile cost, it would be a facility offered that the sponsors could come in to the Department, explain what they wanted, probably give us a sketch plan of what they were proposing to do and generally go into what the regulations were, that we could define as to what or how they fell short or could conform to them and generally have regard to this matter of proliferation or otherwise and say to this group of sponsors: "Everything considered, if you build there, according to those plans or generally amended plans, you will get a licence". This is the way we wish to have it and certainly the only sensible way it could be dealt with.

Comment on this

Do I understand that we are discussing amendments Nos. 11, 15, 17, 18, 19 and 22?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I suggest you might also discuss No. 12.

Comment on this

It is important to know that we are discussing that group of amendments in the name of Senator Murphy. I have an amendment on the Paper, No. 12, which has much the same effect and the same idea behind it as Senator Murphy's, that is, if Senator Murphy's more desirable amendment is not accepted by the House. Senator Murphy has done great service to all of us by drawing a distinction between what is contained in the Dairy Produce Act of 1928, the circumstances in which it was drafted and the purposes it was designed to meet and Bills such as the present Bill.

I must confess that I have very little time for going back to what was done in the 1920s and to whether it was done by way of legislation or otherwise. I think we ought to deal with the circumstances we find in 1967 and as we expect to find them in the next five or ten years. For that reason, I have made a present to the Minister of everything that took place in the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s and 1950s. I do not intend, and I certainly have not got the time nor have we any staff to engage in the kind of research that would enable us to counter some of the falsities that have been propounded by the other side in relation to those Bills. It would be very interesting to hear how Senator Yeats, if he wants to extend the debate the way they have been entending it on the Fianna Fáil side, can get around to answer the remarks made by Senator Murphy in relation to the Dairy Produce Act of 1928.

This group of amendments proposed by Senator Murphy, in the absence of the acceptance of amendment No. 8, would be a vast improvement on this Bill. It is incorrect to say that Fine Gael do not want to see some improvement in this Bill. The truth of the matter is that our view of this Bill is that it is constructed so badly that it is very difficult to shape it into the kind of measure that would be acceptable to us. It is the old case of whether it is better to pull down a dwelling and start to build from scratch or whether you should try to patch, renovate and try to shore up an existing tottering building. We think this is the kind of Bill that corresponds with that kind of building and it is a question of whether it is better to scrap it and start afresh. That is the reason we oppose and will continue to oppose the Bill, while, at the same time, if we can persuade the Minister to accept some amendments that will improve it, we will seek to do so. I am satisfied in my own mind that the Minister has not the slightest intention of accepting any amendment to this Bill. I am quite satisfied that that is the intention in the Minister's mind. I would regard it as extraordinary if the Minister accepted some amendment that is proposed from this side of the House, no matter from whom it came. For that reason I do not expect that the Minister will accept any amendment but——

Comment on this

You are making sure that he will not.

Comment on this

——I should be very happy if the Minister did accept it. When you find that a Minister goes back to what happened in previous times and says that all those Bills went through without any opposition and so on, it is very important at this stage to show one's opposition the whole way, and at the same time, to do one's best to have amendments accepted.

The Minister has not given any indication so far of the principles on which he will exercise his discretion in the granting or the withholding of a licence for a new livestock mart. I shall come to subsection (8) later on. I am not at all happy that it will be possible under section 3(1) for people to continue in business, pending compliance with the regulations. Compliance with the regulations may take a matter of months and years in the case of existing marts, but existing marts cannot get a licence under subsection (8) until they have complied with the regulations. There does not seem to be any interim position except to say that the Minister will allow them unlawfully to carry on the business of a livestock mart without a licence and that will not have any ill-consequence on the person unlawfully carrying on the business because he will delay the bringing into operation of an order implementing section 2 of the Bill. That seems to be the only way in which it can be done. People will unlawfully under this Act continue the business of a livestock mart but they will be immune from punishment because the Minister will not bring in section 2 of the Bill.

Amendment No. 12 proposes to delete the words "at his discretion" in subsection (1) of section 3. Senator Murphy's amendments propose to make it obligatory and automatic that the Minister will, if a person complies with regulations, give a licence to carry on a livestock mart. It is proposed then to delete subsection (2) so as to prevent the Minister from favouring one as against the other in the conditions which he will impose on the various licences. One can see some reason for having conditions in relation to existing marts because one can say that the licence will issue or the licence will be continued, provided a person complies with certain conditions. There is no argument at all for imposing conditions which may vary from applicant to applicant in the case of a new mart.

If one of those conditions were to be a fidelity bond, that a certain amount should be entered into, that should be stated boldly in this measure. If that had been stated boldly, the Minister might have gained some kudos, politically and from the public, for appearing to protect the interests of those who deal with livestock marts already. It amazes me that that is one of the conditions that is being put in at this stage. I rather think that was an after-thought on the part of the Minister when he met the Livestock Marts Association according to the report he read out for us this evening and that that was not one of the primary purposes for which this Bill was introduced.

It is proposed to delete subsections (3), (4) and (5). Again, it comes back to what we were saying earlier—and I do not intend to repeat—that it is not the Minister who should have the power to amend or revoke licences and it is not the Minister who should have power to declare that a person has committed an offence. What seems to me to be much more serious—this comes back again to the impartiality of this measure and its unconstitutionality —is to find that a person will be found guilty of an offence by a Minister of State for a breach of the regulations made pursuant to paragraphs (a) to (e) of subsection (2) of section 6, that is, all those regulations relating to the actual conduct of marts, the conduct of auctions and so on. If the Minister decides that an offence has been committed, then he is entitled without further ado, and without waiting for court proceedings or anything else, to revoke the licence. If that is not the assumption of judicial power of a somewhat different character to the power we were talking about earlier, I do not know what it is. I should like to know what the legal Members of this House, the Senators who have some legal training, think about that and its unconstitutionality. I should like to know what Senator Nash would have to say about this. I am glad he is in the House because if he has anything to say, he can say it, and if he has any-think to say about me, he can say it.

Comment on this

Not behind your back.

Comment on this

I cannot be blamed if the Senator chooses to absent himself from the Chamber when I am speaking. Let every member of the Fianna Fáil Party be clear about this, that what we are providing in subsection (5) and what will be provided is that the Minister will decide that somebody has committed an offence. How will the Minister decide that?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Do I take it the Senator wishes to include amendments Nos. 20 and 21 in this debate?

Comment on this

They appear to be somewhat different.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That appeared to be what the Senator was dealing with.

Comment on this

I would not quite agree. The proposal is to delete this altogether. It seems to me that we ought to delete it. I believe that in other circumstances we would do so but I do not think we will do so tonight. It is proposed in subsection (5) that the Minister will find the person guilty of an offence. In other words, the Minister, on the basis of reports made to him, a letter written to him by somebody down the country or by a Deputy, Senator or somebody else and the matter is investigated, to use the official terminology, by an officer of the Minister, it will be said that that person had done something against a, b, c, x, or y. On that basis the Minister will then decide that the livestock mart proprietor has been guilty of putting up at the wrong time the complainant's cattle for sale or refusing to sell them. It is on the basis of a report made to the Minister that that person will be found guilty of committing that offence. The Minister will not hear any of those people. It will be said that the matter has been fully investigated by the Minister's Departmental officers and they have now come to the conclusion that there has been an offence under section (2) of section 6 in relation to paragraph (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e) or in relation to all of them.

That is the new system of administration of justice proposed in this Bill. The Minister cannot deny that that is the way in which people will be found guilty. He has no power of subpoena. He cannot bring people in and say: "Tell me your own story. What happened on the 18th of March when you were in the livestock mart?" He will not have the auctioneer's clerk associated with the livestock mart to find out personally what went on. Not at all. It is the Minister's officers who will make inquiries and having satisfied the Departmental officers, a report having been made, the Minister will then come to the conclusion that an offence has been committed. Then that person's licence can be revoked.

We see at the moment an inquiry going on in another place. It is very easy to make charges. It is not always as easy to prove them. People take offence very easily and feel aggrieved very easily and one can well see persons dealing with livestock marts taking offence because they have not fared as well as they might have particularly if they see there is discrimination against them as compared with other users of the marts.

That is the kind of offence the Minister will not make the subject of any appeal to a barrister of ten years standing. The Minister has been talking about the right of appeal to a barrister of ten years standing. That is not one of the things, as I read the section, which will be the subject of any consideration by a barrister of ten years standing because paragraph (b) of subsection (6) of section 3 provides that it is only a contravention of the regulations in relation to the physical aspect of livestock marts which will be the subject of inquiry by a barrister of ten years standing, so all the talk we have had about an appeal to a barrister of ten years standing turns out to be only half an appeal. May I put it another way? It is an appeal in respect of half of the items referred to in subsection (2) of section 6.

Comment on this

On a point of order, are we discussing only two amendments here or are we discussing more than two?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are discussing amendments Nos. 11, 15, 17, 18, 19, 22, and also No. 12.

Comment on this

Thanks very much.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

On a point of correction, Senator O'Quigley, there is no proposal to delete subsection (5). It is mainly to change the words in it; that is amendment No. 19. I think there is some misapprehension here.

Comment on this

May I say that that amendment does not go anything like far enough?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am just pointing this out in case there is any misapprehension.

Comment on this

Are we debating amendment No. 31?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is in the group.

Comment on this

It was read out this morning.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is in the group debated with amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

We are not debating that at the moment.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It seems to be cognate but, of course, there will be a separate decision.

Comment on this

It was agreed this morning that we would discuss amendments Nos. 11, 15, 17, 18, 19 and 22 together.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have ascertained that Senator O'Quigley is satisfied that amendment No. 12 can be discussed with a separate decision. The Senator will appreciate the difficulty in that if amendment No. 11 were carried, Senator O'Quigley would be deprived of his rights under amendment No. 12.

Comment on this

He said he would be happy if it were carried.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I understand that since he has decided that he would be satisfied if they were discussed together.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Chair is anxious to make the Senator happy.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair is interested in making all Senators happy.

Comment on this

At any rate, it now boils down to the fact that all this talk about an appeal to a barrister of ten years standing is an appeal in respect of only a selected number of matters, that is to say, in respect of the physical aspect of livestock marts and not in relation to these much more controversial matters of the conduct of the whole of the business of livestock marts. It now turns out that the Minister may satisfy himself that there has been an offence in relation to the actual conduct of the business. This is a vague type of thing. Having satisfied himself that an offence has been committed, he may then, if he thinks fit, revoke the licence. That to me is a clear reading of the situation. If that is not a clear attempt at usurpation by the Minister of the powers of the courts, I do not know what it is. For that reason, I think we must oppose the sections which are the subject of these amendments. If the House—and I make no more appeals to the Minister—had the good sense to accept Senator Murphy's amendment No. 11, it would certainly be passing legislation which would be considerably less unacceptable than the Bill as it now stands.

Comment on this

I should like to try to get back to the amendment before we again start exchanging pleasantries. I thank the Minister for what he said, I think, on Second Stage in the Dáil. He did not say it here but it is important to remind the Minister what he did say here. He made a number of main points:

That the Bill is necessary in the national interest and not least in the interest of the farming community: it has been introduced for no other reason...

I shall come back to that. The Minister has now stated that there are other things which can be imposed under regulations and on which he should have a discretion in the granting or revocation of a licence. He said that there might be uneconomic overlapping of marts; there might be proliferation of marts. That was the point he was making on Second Reading in the Dáil. You will excuse me for overlooking that because there is no hint of that at all in section 6 which says:

The Minister may, for the purpose of ensuring the proper conduct of places where the business of a livestock mart is carried on and the proper conduct of such businesses, adequate and suitable hygienic and veterinary standards...

It goes on then to deal with what we have been talking about, the acceptance of bids, discrimination between one farmer and another and then the physical requirements of marts. There is no mention of the location of marts or even a general hint in section 6 that the Minister wants power to regulate so as to avoid the overlapping of marts.

I suggest that this is the more dangerous position which I suggested earlier. Are we to have a situation in which the Minister can decide which mart will have competition and which mart will not?

That is in effect of what he is saying. He wants this power. I think that is quite wrong. At least it seems so to me. The people whom the Minister must protect are the farming community. They are to be protected so that marts which will deprive the farmer of his money will not go into operation. We have put down an amendment so as to avoid that. We say that the regulations should provide cover in respect of that, so that the marts in order to go into business at all should be able to make arrangements in this respect. The intention is that they should have fidelity bonds and that they should not be allowed to trade unless they can provide that the farmers who sell their products through the marts get payment for what they have sold. They are the people whom the Minister says on Second Stage he wants to protect, that the Bill has been introduced for no other reason. I suggest the Minister has no function in the matter of protecting present mart operators from competition or of deciding that those private companies, or whatever they may be, can have a preserve so long as the Minister so decides. But, if there is a mart operating in, say, Kilkenny, that mart can be happy for, so long as the Minister so wishes, they will not suffer any competition from a neighbouring mart setting up and getting the business. They are all right; they are happy and they can operate straight away.

I am suggesting that that is not the function of the Minister in this matter. His function is to protect the farming community. The marts are businesses in competition with one another, I should hope, and the competition should provide the best services to the customers, the farmers and the buyers. I am opposed to the situation that the Minister would now indicate to us, as he has already indicated to the Dáil, that, in fact, he wants to have discretion so as to avoid the proliferation of marts and their uneconomic overlapping.

I am suggesting that that is not the Minister's function and that that can best be taken care of by the ordinary competition among those people who are engaged in private enterprise, who go into this business of their own choice. I suggest that the Minister has no function to protect people and to prevent neighbouring competition being set up to provide other and equal services for the farmers.

Let us go back to another undesirable aspect of this. The Minister may decide at his sole discretion that a licence may be given to a new operator because he does not want to protect a particular operator. A mart in Kilkenny, say, might be doing nicely under this arrangement but the Minister may decide that five miles away he will give a licence to another mart which would be, I am sure, ground for complaint by the original mart. I do not see why there should be any reasonable ground for complaint if the other operator can provide this service. It is very dangerous that the Minister should envisage exercising his discretion in this way. I am suggesting it is not his function; his function is to protect the farmers, as he told us in his Second Reading speech. I would not accept this argument as justifying the giving of sole discretion to the Minister to grant licences, to attach conditions to licences and to change or revoke those conditions as he so wishes.

I am still appealing to him to accept this amendment and I am suggesting that this other sort of function he wants to take on is clearly not provided for in the Bill and is not, I suggest, his function, as Minister for Agriculture, but can best be taken care of by the operators themselves.

Comment on this

The last point Senator Murphy spoke about is one of the most important and, to my mind, will be one of the most difficult things the Minister will have to deal with under this Bill, that is, he will have to limit the number of marts, despite what Senator Murphy has said, because as surely as there are two marts within a certain mileage proximity, one will go.

Comment on this

The Minister has to decide.

Comment on this

For the farmers' sake, I think somebody should decide. Then the people who send their cattle to one some week will not be caught.

Comment on this

No—the fidelity bond.

Comment on this

The people who come into my mart know I have a bond subscribed to possibly by all the other marts in Ireland. This will support me. That is the sort of thing you will find happening.

I know of a case, not in this part of the country, of marts in two towns— actually they were practically 11 miles apart. What happened was both of them started off and I can assure you that any town in Ireland will give people who wish to start a mart the greatest encouragement because it is important for the town to have that influx of people once or twice a week, important for the business people of those towns. They will give anybody who starts talking about opening a mart great encouragement, and even subscriptions, if necessary.

With regard to these two marts, it happened that the one in the larger town gradually grew and grew and the buyers, who are the people who make the mart, went to the second one. The smaller one was the mart nearer me and to which I should like to have sent the cattle. You went in there on a Wednesday with your cattle and there were probably only three main buyers there. They knew each other; they stood together and when the cattle came into the ring, one bid the other and very often there was no other bid. Sometimes two of them would bid for a short time, with no other bid. It ended up that all the bigger farmers who could afford a lorry took the cattle to the other town. Those were nearly all graded fat cattle. You were left with your three buyers and the other mart was merely left to small farmers with one or two geese who could not afford either to transport them themselves or arrange to get a place in a lorry. The second mart dropped and dropped until it was impossible to sell cattle at any price in it at all: cattle went every week very considerably below the price obtaining in the other mart. The Minister may need to take this decision and I think he must take it.

Since this debate started, I have heard comments from both sides of the House that this decision could have been taken long ago when these marts started in the country at first.

Comment on this

But is the Minister not providing that every existing mart will get a licence?

Comment on this

I am not trying to anticipate what the Minister will do, but for the sake of the farmers, if you like to put it that way, marts should not be allowed to start up like mushrooms, two in one town or two within five miles of each other, because it would depress the prices for the farmers. The bigger the mart, the better market the farmers will get for their cattle.

We considered starting a co-operative mart in Cavan in the past 12 months. A very prominent man connected with Cork Co-operative Mart came up to give us his advice and I think he said: "I would not like to see the marts less than 15, 20, or even 25 miles apart and then the farmers will get their value; it will be a big sale; there will be a lot of buyers and the farmers will get the true value of their cattle". It will be a very difficult decision the Minister and the Department will make in this instance, but I think it should be made for the benefit of the farmers. If the time comes when one of those marts is not giving satisfactory service, then the question of transport comes into it, transport to another mart, but, if you think, as Senator Murphy has said, that everybody should get a mart, everybody who applies gets a mart, you will not be assisting the farmer in the slightest and it will be to the detriment of the price he will get for his cattle.

Comment on this

We hold, as Senator Murphy has already pointed out, that too much freedom is given to the Minister in the Bill in its present form, particularly in the matter of granting and revoking licences. We take it the regulations made by the Minister will cover all essentials, to ensure the marts are suitable in every respect, that business is carried on in a proper manner and that they are situated a reasonable distance apart. Therefore, our amendments provide that where an applicant complies with the stringent regulations, the Minister will have no choice but to grant a licence and, once he has so granted a licence, cannot withdraw it. The Bill as it stands at the moment says "at his entire discretion" for offences, real or imaginary, outside the regulations already prescribed. Such a provision, if left in the Bill, would constitute a hardship on mart owners because of the uncertainties which the Bill holds even though the licence has already been granted.

We want the best possible marts but I cannot see mart owners putting their capital into the marts because of the lack of security which the Minister's wide powers involves. Where, for any reason, the Minister may think fit, he can add some new condition to those already stated in the regulations and on the added condition, can withdraw the licence.

Likewise, the Labour Party are firmly of the opinion that a mart owner who breaks the regulations prescribed by the Minister should have his licence revoked. We would be in full agreement with the withdrawal of his licence in such circumstances. The regulations should be wide and strict but they should be standard and known to all licensed holders. Such firm and wide regulations would eliminate such things as the overlapping and unnecessary proliferation of marts mentioned by the Minister. Our amendments would obviate that undesirable happening and the other things which have been referred to in the debate.

Comment on this

We seem to be going on a much more even keel since teatime and I hope the Minister will try to meet some of the amendments now. I should say that the amendment now before the House is probably the most reasonable one that has come before it so far. Really we do not ask the Minister to do very much. In fact, we are taking a load off his shoulders by asking him to accept the amendment instead of its being left to his discretion.

Fears have been expressed here as to the number of marts and one would think, to hear some people speak, that marts grew up like mushrooms. I can assure Senator Cole that there is no great danger of marts springing up within a few miles of one another because when a group of people come together to provide a mart, there is a matter of £30,000 or £40,000 involved and you will certainly not get any group of people to put up such an amount for a proposition that is likely to lose money. The most likely way one could lose money is by erecting a second mart beside an existing mart.

I have a fair idea of marts in the midlands, the area where most finished cattle are sold and where marts are very well utilised, and it works out that the marts that are there and are doing very well are from 19 to 20 miles, and up to 25 miles from one another. Take a circle from Edenderry to Tullamore, Moate and Mullingar. That takes in a huge countryside and there is not the slightest likelihood that any other mart will start up in that area. That covers a huge part of the midlands because the type of money it takes to erect a mart is not to be picked up on the roadside and usually people who erect these marts must go to the bank managers to get the money, and bank managers are very difficult people to deal with, if a good, solid proposition is not put before them.

I am not in the least worried about marts going up all over the country. There are well established marts and the people who run them have made a tremendous job of it because they have arranged transport and have done it very well. People know when to have their cattle ready. Lorries are sent to collect them in time. The cattle are delivered back in time and the whole thing is well organised. For that reason where any mart is well established, it is not likely that someone else will try to start up in competition. Therefore, the Minister should reconsider the whole question of withdrawing licences or giving licences at his discretion. What we really want to provide is that the applicant shall comply with the regulations made by the Minister. There should be only one set of regulations and one law for everybody, and if the Minister lays down the regulations and says: "These are the regulations under which you may provide a mart," everybody will know where he stands and the Minister will be in a much happier position than if he were to deal with each case individually.

Some people might say that because of political influence he did something for some group or, because of another type of political influence, he refused to do it for another group. He would leave himself open to criticism because he had not a fixed set of regulations.

We must also remember that before any application for a mart comes to the Minister, it must be dealt with by the planning authority. The planning authority is a slow-moving body and would be very slow to give permission, I think, to a new mart to start up in competition with an existing mart where everything was satisfactory. For that reason, quite a number of the applications would never come before the Minister. I can assure the Minister that if there is ever an appeal against the decision of the planning authority, he will not be worried for quite a long time. Last January I made an appeal for a gentleman who was refused permission to erect petrol pumps in a rural area. Just to check up, I telephoned several times since. I rang up this morning and there is not the slightest sign of that appeal being dealt with yet.

The Planning Act has been quoted in that the Minister had such wide powers under it but I certainly would not like to see the Minister with the same powers under the Marts Bill. If there were a decision by which the Minister revoked a licence, I think it would be very serious if there were a long delay before the decision as to whether the person should get his licence back or should be put out of the business entirely. I ask the Minister to consider the amendment by the Labour Party. I believe it is a reasonable amendment and I think he will avoid headaches if he accepts it and lays down general regulations for all those who wish to operate marts.

Comment on this

There will be regulations. This is so clearly mentioned so many times in the Bill that there can be no doubt in anybody's mind about it. I have already indicated that it is not my intention to have regulations for every mart in the country whether existing or yet to come. This would not be possible, even if one were mad enough to attempt to do it. Coming to the matter or overlapping, this is very relevant, and I was glad to hear Senator Cole deal with it in much the same terms as I think about it myself. It is in the interests of farmers. If somebody says "Let them go; let them eat each other out; let the strongest survive", who is to survive, who is paying for it all? If one fellow loses, do you think he will not get it back from the farming community which will be left to his sole tender mercies in the future? This is very much in the interests of the farming community. If a mart is operating properly and normally and is giving a good service to its farming community around it, surely there is nothing wrong if, as a sort of side benefit, that mart is given the further security of continuing and possibly expending more money to attract more buyers, and so on? This is the essence of mart business.

If there are not the buyers, if there are insufficient buyers or if there is no business, then, no matter how many marts you have or where they are located, the farmer will be the loser. The establishment of a mart in competition with an existing established mart can have only one intention, namely, to put the existing mart out of business. If the existing mart is doing its job properly and well, maybe doing it pretty well even from its own commercial viewpoint, the only reason for the establishment of the other one to do business that the existing mart is doing is to put the existing mart out of business. If the end product is that somebody will go to the wall, then a lot of money will be lost. Even though, because of fidelity bonds, insurance, and so forth, the farmers as individuals will not have lost money the cost of these bonds will go up—and who will pay for that but the farmers? They will provide the money to be paid for the extra cost of the bonds as a result of the greater number of casualties that can and will take place if we do nothing about overlapping in the future. Some overlapping and some crashes have already taken place, to the direct loss of the farmers. We hope to cure that in the future.

The whole idea of fidelity bonds, insurance, or cover for the farmers was described by Senator O'Quigley as merely an afterthought after pressure had been built up by Fine Gael or somebody else, and it was alleged that we did this in face of rising public opinion. It shows how lacking in interest were Senator O'Quigley and his colleagues when in my introductory speech in the Dáil I mentioned the matter as follows:

Another matter which it would be desirable to cover is the safeguarding of the financial interests of farmers selling livestock at marts.

During the course of that debate—I recall it quite well—I was chided on this matter and I came back to it in my closing speech on Second Reading and referred to the persons who had complained about my not mentioning it and I pointed out that I had mentioned it in my introductory speech.

Comment on this

Merely in that vague way.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley is so innocent that we need to wrap this up and hand it to him. I refer the Senator to my introductory and closing speeches on the Second Reading of this Bill in the Dáil. Despite all the time he has taken up in this House telling us of the care and interest he had in this Bill, he had not sufficient interest even to read those two speeches which I made in the Dáil and therefore what he has said in this connection sounds hollow to me. Surely these are the first available documents that would be read by anybody as concerned as he professes to be. But, not at all; the Senator never heard of it before.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister not mention it in this House?

Comment on this

I do accept that the Members of this House are intelligent, literate, capable of reading and under-standing——

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I dispute that.

Comment on this

To be very intelligent does not necessarily mean that we read the Dáil Debates.

Comment on this

In the case of one so concerned as the display given here on this measure by Senator O'Quigley would lead one to believe, surely nobody will chide me if I chide him for his lack of reading and research even on the Second Reading of this measure in the Dáil? Surely this would be accepted from me. Not at all. He would not think about that. He would prefer to find a way to get it across that such a thing as this was merely an afterthought—and sort of no apology to anybody.

It was categorically said by him that this whole business was merely an afterthought, after pressure by Fine Gael. He suggested that public opinion made us say this merely as an afterthought, whereas such is not the case. As I have said, the matter is there. Then, as well, you see, if one attended this House as assiduously as would appear a Senator should, being so interested in this measure as he displayed himself to be, Senator O'Quigley would have been here—presumably he was not here—to hear the debate so far, during which this matter was mentioned. I refer Senator O'Quigley to columns 1034-35 of Volume 63, No. 12, of the Official Report of Seanad Éireann, in relation to Thursday last, 27th July, 1967. Having said that, that is practically enough about it.

Comment on this

He cleared out last Wednesday.

Comment on this

It has not been circulated yet.

Comment on this

If the Senator had been here he would have heard but now he can read what he missed by not being here on that particular day. He will never appreciate how much he missed by being absent on that day unless he reads the debate.

Some points were raised, other than that, which had some relevance to the Bill and to which I should like to reply. One of these concerns section 6—section 6 and the making of regulations do not give the Minister the opportunity to deal with this matter of proliferation or overlapping of marts. As I read and understand section 6, it gives the Minister authority: it is permissive, if you like. He may make regulations under this and certain of these regulations can in fact regulate the manner in which he may grant the licence. This is quite possible and conceivable so there is not any manner or means of things that appertain to the wellbeing of the mart business in the future that cannot in fact conceivably be brought within the terms of the regulations I am empowered to make under section 6 right through this Bill. If it is slightly confusing, I do not really take the blame for that inasmuch as this is the manner in which it has been drafted, but there is no doubt whatever that it does give the authority and the power which I have mentioned.

Senator O'Quigley—correct me if I am wrong in this—dealt at length, as I understand it, with amendment No. 20 which I understood it to be clarified is not before us at the moment. That being so, I have the right to speak on what he said on that amendment but I intend to reserve what I have to say until it is appropriate to discuss it. My understanding was that amendment No. 20 was not in the group.

Comment on this

The Minister is correct.

Comment on this

The Senator spoke on this amendment but it was purely a mistake.

Comment on this

It was not; it was directed towards subsection (5).

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely we do not have to listen to it all again.

Comment on this

This is what he was hoping for. The likelihood is that he thought so well of what he said that he wishes to have it said again. On the other hand, he might not be here when it is discussed again. It could happen that he might be gone. In any event, I will not deal with that at all. What we are supposed to be discussing is amendment No. 11 and the other amendments with it—No. 15 and Nos. 17 and 19, which I understand are also under discussion. This amendment again follows from No. 11. The amendment would curtail and indeed wipe out any discretion the Minister might have in regard to granting or revoking a licence. No. 19 merely confirms that to a greater degree. This is a point of which great play has been made, probably in good faith, that it would be far better according to the amendment, that we would make regulations and stick to them flat-footedly. This might avoid the fears expressed about political intrigue about which we hear so much but of which we see so little.

Comment on this

There are none so blind as those who will not see.

Comment on this

I have a slight feeling of pity for the gentleman over there. However, is it a good thing to have the matter dealt with in this way, that we should have regulations which we would regard as all embracing? But even with the help of Senator O'Quigley and his colleagues, I am sure if we did this we would barely have them made for a month when we would have to begin remaking them. In all this matter of laying down regulations in changing times, and in a changing world, where there will be big changes, and no more so than in the marts, it would not be wise to plump for this idea of making all-round flatfooted regulations, that if people complied with them, they would just have to get licences. I am thinking in terms of proliferation and additions and new marts. We want to think in terms of a private mart owner trying to muscle in where a co-operative has made a success—or, it might be the reverse, that a private fellow might have made a good start and was building up a fair business and it could be the co-operative group who decided they wanted to get in and take over his business, and then he would be gone.

That might be all right and it might be possible to swallow, although I do not like it, but think in terms of outside concerns coming into the country.

Comment on this

Like the supermarkets at the moment.

Comment on this

It might not be a bad example or a bad analogy. Do we want to have the Minister of the day, even if he should be a Fine Gael Minister——

Comment on this

When it does happen.

Comment on this

Even in those dire circumstances, I would wish to see any Minister for Agriculture being in the position of being able to exercise his discretion to prevent an outside group or monopoly trying to muscle in and get hold of the mart outlets.

Comment on this

What is going to happen when we have free trade?

Comment on this

The Senator cannot have it both ways. When the Constitution suits him, he uses it, and similarly with the EEC. Deal with the Ireland of today.

Comment on this

And 1970.

Comment on this

Quite truly, is this not a possibility to which we must have some regard and to which it is worth having regard? It could be a very serious matter for us. I think this is valid and not just purely an argument for argument's sake.

Comment on this

If that is desirable, the regulations should provide——

Comment on this

Wait now. We provide that companies other than companies owned by Irish nationals, or an Irish national, will do this, that and the other. Surely the Senator, and some of the other Senators who are professional men, are fully aware of how useful that particular phraseology would be in preventing those who wish to come in from coming in? This has been going on since Adam's time. We know how the Control of Manufactures Act worked. We know that it did not work and we decided that it was better to remove it. As Senators know, there was evasion under it and there would be evasion under any regulations which tried to define who was a national, what company was nationally-owned——

Comment on this

You want to do it on your own guess.

Comment on this

Would the Senator prefer the Minister's guess in the interests of the farming and agricultural community to the manipulations of those who find ways around the law, to our detriment? A good lawyer, of whom there are not too many, with or without ten years operations, would be available—more power to the lawyers; that is their business—would have no bother at all in finding a way around these things. I prefer the assessment of the Minister for Agriculture of the day of the situation, if there was that danger, than leaving it to the tender mercies and advice of the well up lawyers of this or any other country.

Comment on this

I thought it was Government policy to encourage foreign enterprise to come in.

Comment on this

I have talked about that in another context. It is not very relevant to say that the situation was not very foolproof under the Manufactures Act. There is no conflict between my utterances and my Party policy. Do not group me with Fine Gael who say one thing here and another elsewhere. This is a habit of theirs but not of mine.

Comment on this

Introduce the Control of Manufactures Act and then repeal it; oppose the Industrial Development Authority and then use it; impose the Industrial Grants Act and then repeal it. That is Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Ní thuigimid.

Comment on this

It will be on the record.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 22 is an amendment which would arise if Nos. 11 and 19 were carried. Assuming they were carried, this again would give the Minister no discretion whatever. I would not go along with the idea that the Minister should have no discretion with regard to these matters. It is a necessary part of the control, in the best interests of the farming community and of the country generally, that the Minister should have discretion, that he should be enabled to meet the changing circumstances of the times, that he should have this discretion in order to do what is best in the interests of the farmers as far as the marts are concerned under this Bill. That is why I feel we should have it in this way.

If we were to accept amendment No. 11, which is the primary amendment here, it could only work if we forgot about the wider context, the more important things, the unnecessary proliferation, the overlapping, the wiping out of one mart by another merely because of its financial strength, doing so not in the interests of the farmer but possibly as a way of building up a monopoly for its own financial benefit. These things cannot be rolled into regulations that would hold water. Discretion has been objected to here—I do not blame those who objected—but, weighing the thing in the balance, discretion to the Minister in this particular matter is a necessary part of the exercise of the controls we feel are useful and necessary for this important business of livestock marketing in the future.

Comment on this

Arising out of the Minister's reply and in forming a judgment on the present amendment, the question arises as to how the Minister will frame those regulations. I do not altogether agree with Senator Murphy that you can frame those watertight regulations. For one thing, I should like to ask the Minister how he proposes to approach framing the regulations required, for instance, in section 6 (2) (e) which prescribes requirements as to the size, design, maintenance, repair, cleansing, cleanliness, ventilation, heating and lighting of any building in which auctions are held. I am not aware at present that there is any section in the Minister's Department that could in any sense be regarded as competent to provide this advice and this judgment, and I feel that the Board of Works could not have specialist competence in this. I think the only advice available is from the IAOS headquarters, but they, in turn, would be the first to acknowledge their inadequacy in this and the difficulty of keeping up to date with it. It is something that, even as attempted by the Minister, is far too sweeping.

The approach used in the Agriculture Act just recently in England, with the Meat and Livestock Commission, where they restrict themselves merely to advising and giving information on those aspects, would be a far better approach and one that the Minister's facilities might be able to manage. But I certainly cannot see the Minister, either with his present resources or with some specialist units he is going to set up, turning out a supermart design outfit that would be complying with this. It is a section in which we have to accept flexibility and we have to accept different standards in the different mart sizes. It is a subject you cannot regulate on. I should like to have the Minister's view as to how he proposes, taking this one example, to set up this really exceptional specialist design unit.

Comment on this

It is quite true there are no specialist advisers or consultant groups in this matter of the design, lay-out, amenities and so on in regard to marts; but there are a large number of people who have been associated with these marts, whether through private operation or groups, or through the IAOS, and there are vets and other such people who have had recourse to these places. Therefore, there is a great fund of information available in regard to what works and what does not work in connection with such matters as the penning of the cattle, bringing them to the ring, their transport to the premises and so on. There must be a great fund of information available, if we get it and identify it. The IAOS, as the Senator said, has quite a fund of this information garnered from their various associations, those actively engaged in the marts. I have no doubt also that a great deal of information could be got from the various private operators. many of whom probably started in a small way and came up the hard way— and there is no better way than that of finding out how to make things go. These two groups have promised their support and the benefit of their experience to me and my Department in drawing up regulations, and we are very glad to have it.

In addition, there will undoubtedly be certain technical people who have been associated with certain of the marts already, people who have constructed them and have discovered faults in those already designed and who may have found some better way because of later designs. There will be an amount of knowledge available there. In addition, there will be undoubtedly available to us—and there is no reason why we should not seek it, if the occasion should arise—a fund of knowledge from other parts, and if we should find it useful in our circumstances, we should have no hesitation in calling upon it. But, as I said earlier, the fact that they do things in a certain way in certain countries does not mean that we should follow blindly. But, if they have something to add and we need the assistance of somebody from outside who may have more experience of the solution of particular problems, we will bring in these people to add to those in the IAOS and the Associated Marts, who can contribute worthwhile knowledge and get it down in regulations.

These regulations will not be as detailed as Senator Quinlan fears. He expressed fear of the danger of going out for a uniform size. There is no question of that at all in our minds. In fact, it just could not be tolerated, because there will be marts with a big throughput, those with a middle throughput and the smaller ones. Undoubtedly, we could not say to all of those: "You must all be of one size". What I think we will be saying is that there will be a relationship between the amenities provided in the small one, the middle-sized one and the big one. This is the sort of uniformity I am thinking of rather than just a uniform plan for all marts, regardless of the throughput. This is the way that I feel at this juncture we will be approaching this matter of trying to get knowledge from anybody who has it and is prepared to give it. The two associations have already promised this and when we get that far, we may find that we are not so short of information but if we are, and if it is to be got somewhere else, we will look for it.

Comment on this

This will not mean that a large section will have to be set up within the Minister's Department; in other words, practical, commonsense standards will be adopted?

Comment on this

This is the idea.

Comment on this

Marts have already done that within the limits of their financial resources.

Comment on this

Reason will have to prevail in the relationship of all these things.

Comment on this

Senator McAuliffe in supporting Senator Murphy's amendment claimed that there would be no likelihood of a proliferation or mushroom growth of marts, or something like that, arsing in any part of the country. From Ballyjamesduff to Kells, a distance of 17 miles, some months ago there were, those two towns inclusive, four cattle marts. There were four; now there are three, much to somebody's loss.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister can be serious when he talks about its not being possible to draw up regulations to cover the dangers he outlined. Nobody suggests that the regulations cannot be amended or improved as time goes on but our point is that they should be standard changes and not individual ones. For instance, subsection (2) of section 3 refers to the granting of "a" licence, presumably an individual licence to which the Minister can attach special conditions. Then the next subsection says that the Minister may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to an individual licence. All the time it is an individual licence. It is in that individual licence change that the danger lies. I think the Minister can cover the main and important things such as the proliferation of marts and about outsiders coming in, by changes in the regulations—standard changes in standard regulations —and avoid this individual thing which is the real danger.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister is it fair to assume that initially the application for the mart will be made to the local town planning authority. I am not suggesting now that the finished project should be but before applying to him for a licence, will it have to pass the local town planning authority, which is something I do not think the Minister covered?

Comment on this

I am glad the Senator has reminded me because there was something said already about the planning Acts which is completely wrong. It has been asserted by Senator McAuliffe that there would be screening done by the local planning authority and where there is a mart already existing it was unlikely that the authority would allow another one. That is completely and absolutely out of this world, has no relevance to the planning Acts in that sense in that the criteria on which planning permission will be granted or refused cannot have regard to whether or not there is already a mart in the district or town, or not. I wanted to bring that out clearly.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say——

Comment on this

I am answering the other one first and will come back to this again. I want to make quite clear to Senator McAuliffe that the planning authority will not be a screen in any way stopping the proliferation of marts. This is not something that would stand up for a moment if the local authority granted or, should I say, refused a mart merely on the basis that there was already one there.

Comment on this

They are refusing petrol stations.

Comment on this

They are having regard to what is there already?

Comment on this

Regard may be had but they may not just throw it out and, mainly speaking, these are not upheld on appeal. But, certainly, if they threw out a mart application on the basis that there is already one in the town, if this was the only reason, it would get through on appeal as surely as it went on appeal to the Minister for Local Government. There is not a doubt in the world.

Comment on this

It would take a long time to come out of the appeals office.

Comment on this

It might be delayed. I do not doubt. One has to take cognisance of that. Do not employ a contractor next week unless planning permission was applied for last month. It would be foolish to do that.

To get back to the question raised by Senator Carton, he wants to know whether or not it will be a condition of our granting a licence that there would have had to be town planning approval for the particular proposal.

Comment on this

Having regard to the town plan that is in existence.

Comment on this

I cannot answer the Senator straight out but will put it this way—for a premises to be newly licensed, I have already suggested tonight that the ideal way would be that the proposed plans, which would be merely sketch plans, in such location, and so forth, would be brought along or sent to the office of the Minister for Agriculture. This would be on the basis that we could consider it and say to the proposers that as far as we were concerned if they did it in such a way in this particular location they could expect that they would be licensed. That is No. 1, but we can add, and will add, indeed, that town planning permission will be an absolutely essential part in order to complete the final application and build the job; unless passed by town planning, it will not get a licence.

Comment on this

I thought it was vital in view of the fact that most towns have a plan and would like a mart to be in a certain place and would like them to notify the Department.

Comment on this

We will be putting it into the regulations but it is a bit round-about because of the approval of plans on the basis of plans.

Comment on this

It is better for you to give your licence before it goes up for town planning.

Comment on this

No. What we would be saying to them would be that if they got planning permission on these general plans they had shown to us and everything else considered—no location overlapping or what have you—subject to all those things, if they went ahead on this basis they could assume that they would get their licence from us. It is merely to facilitate a citizen rather than put him to unnecessary expense and then to find that he could not get a licence that I said in reply to Senator Carton that there must be planning permission in any event—this would be required.

Comment on this

I must indeed, congratulate the Minister. I have often heard him described as a good political operator and he has demonstrated his ability here tonight. First of all, in reply to my speech on the amendment, he agrued that he should be given discretion because it was desirable that there should be no uneconomic overlapping of marts, that there should be no proliferation of marts and he rightly drew my attention to the fact that he may have pointed this out in his Second Reading speech in the Dáil. Then, when I had argued that that was not really his function as a Minister for Agriculture, he came up with another argument, that it was desirable to keep out non-nationals from the operating of cattle marts. Then, for good measure, he threw in the argument that, of course, it was also desirable that he should, by exercise of the regulations, prevent the creation of a monopoly in cattle marts. It seemed to me to be quite the opposite of the first argument about proliferation of marts. We are now up against the argument that the regulations will prevent the creation of a monopoly. These will be marvellous regulations.

Comment on this

There is no doubt in the world about that.

Comment on this

Everything will be in these regulations for the benefit of the farmers: we are glad to have that assurance. This thing about the prevention of monopolies reminds me of the non-nationals who are coming in here and acquiring supermarkets. We are told the Government do not intend to take any action in that regard, because it is all for the benefit of the customers that there should be this competition. However, in relation to the cattle marts, apparently it is not for the benefit of the customers, namely the farmers. We have had every sort of argument put forward against the amendment, but it all boils down to this, that the Minister wants the sole discretion to do as he wishes: to grant a licence or not to grant a licence; to attach a condition to a licence, or not to attach a condition to it; to vary that condition at any time, if he so wishes. He wants that power and I am saying that, both for his own protection and the protection of the country and of the farming community, this power should not be given to the Minister.

He has not told us at all about these conditions that he will be able to attach to a licence. Who will know of these conditions? Where he attaches conditions to a licence, will the Houses of the Oireachtas be informed of such conditions? Will it be the owner of the cattle mart and the Minister only who will know? Again, if he varies a condition at his sole discretion, will the Houses of the Oireachtas be told about it? Will it be laid before the House? All this seems to be secret. All this is giving the Minister sole discretion to do as he wishes.

I suggest it is relevant to look at section 6 and see what sort of regulations are envisaged here. The section says:

The Minister may, for the purpose of ensuring the proper conduct of places where the business of a livestock mart is carried on and the proper conduct of such businesses...

"Ensuring the proper conduct of places where the business of a livestock mart is carried on"—the section does not talk about the location of the cattle mart. It does not go on to say that the Minister may make regulations providing where cattle marts shall be established, or their distance apart. My colleague, Senator Miss Davidson, made the very good point that if it is necessary for the Minister to have this surveillance and to say: "You shall not found a cattle mart here because there is a cattle mart in another town ten miles away", this can be provided for in the regulations. Again we are saying that these regulations should be open and seen and common to all; the law should be applied equally.

Comment on this

They will be laid before both Houses.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the regulations about location.

Comment on this

What about the conditions which the Minister may attach to a licence? Under which provisions will they be laid before the Houses?

Comment on this

Section 10.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

May I interrupt the Senator to say—in case there is any gobbledygook such as took place last night—that we desire the Seanad to meet at 10.30 a.m. tomorrow and that we propose to sit until 10.30 tomorrow night?

Comment on this

If there is a debate here upon when the House should sit, I do not think that should be characterised by the Leader of the House as gobbledygook. That is the first thing.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I did not say when the House should sit was gobbledygook. What went on last night was gobbledygook, or mumbo-jumbo, if Congolese is more understandable.

Comment on this

If that is the standard the Leader of the House wants to set and if that is the extent to which his vocabulary goes——

Comment on this

I suggest tha. Senator Murphy continue until 10.30 and that then the Leader of the House move the motion.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I just wanted to be sure there would not be any of these asinine objections they raised last night.

Comment on this

Is it in order——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I repeat the word "asinine".

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Leader of the House to refer to objections made on any subject as being asinine?

Comment on this

It is, if they are.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Last night's objections were asinine.

Comment on this

I want a ruling from the Chair. Is it in order for the Leader of the House to refer to the deliberations here as being asinine? Is it parliamentary?

Comment on this

On an agriculture Bill, it does not seem to be very much out of order. Senator Murphy, to continue.

Comment on this

I thought I was in possession and that the amendment before the House——

Comment on this

One can be abusive on an agriculture Bill? That is the Cathaoirleach's standard?

Comment on this

Does the Senator want a division on the amendment?

Comment on this

As it is now within a few minutes of 10.30, this is the time at which we decide to adjourn. We may go on with the division, and then we shall take the motion for the Adjournment after the division.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Tá 29
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendment No. 12.

Comment on this

But that has not been moved before 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

It has been dealt with already.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Yes, a whole lot of them were dealt with together. In the name of Providence let us get rid of them now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In subsection (1), line 30, to delete "at his discretion".

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 29
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?