Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–144 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1967 ›
The House is taking, with amendment No. 38, amendments Nos. 39, 45 and 46.
Comment on this
Before we adjourned last night, the Minister was reassuring the House in his own style that this section is quite a harmless piece of legislation. He stressed that subsection (1) of section 6 provides that the Minister may make regulations. Surely he is not serious in trying to put across to us that, just as an afterthought, perhaps, he may make a regulation when everybody knows that the sole reason for this Bill is to make regulations to ensure that should it happen that cattle are seized, there will be no danger to those who go along to the marts to buy them. In other words, the Minister is taking new protection so that the John Browns of the future will be adequately safeguarded under the terms of section 6 of this Bill.
Last night I mentioned that paragraph (e) prescribes requirements as to size, design, maintenance, repair, cleansing, cleanliness, ventilation, heating and lighting of any building. I am not at all against providing even luxurious fittings in marts for the comfort of our Irish farmers. What I am against is the Minister prescribing fittings or luxurious buildings for which the Irish farmers must pay and will have to pay out of the price for their cattle. I object to any regulations which will require a further drain on the resources of our Irish farmers at a time when they can ill afford any excess expenditure at all on those lines. Nobody and no Minister should have powers such as are sought in paragraph (e) because any such regulation which the Minister will insist be complied with will definitely cost money and the only people who are there to pay for it are the Irish farmers. With the present trend in cattle prices, surely the Seanad should not add still further to the ever-increasing burden our farmers are being called upon to bear.
In paragraph (f), the Minister is again taking unto himself powers to prescribe requirements as to accommodation including washing facilities and sanitary conveniences at such places. There are already on the Statute Book powers for these purposes in any of the Health Acts from 1878 to 1962 and in the Sanitary Services Acts from 1878 to 1964. Surely there already exists sufficient power to ensure that public health will adequately be safeguarded? This paragraph is completely unnecessary. It is put into this section so that the Minister, if he so desires, may bring in crippling legislation which can pile on extra unnecessary cost for the mart committees or mart owners.
Last night, the Minister seemed to take exception to the suggestion that the officers of his Department and his draftsman would better be employed in endeavouring to sell surplus Irish cattle abroad. He said it was rather silly to expect draftsmen to sell our cattle. I cannot understand how the self-same draftsman is sufficiently well-equipped to know all about the requirements for marts throughout the country at a time, especially, when there have been no complaints against the conditions of operation or structural defects in those establishments. I do not trust the Minister with the power to bring in regulations on such a wide scale as he is taking in this Bill. We remember the Planning Act of 1963. When the Minister makes regulations he has a rather lively and imaginative mind. For instance, who would have thought that under the Planning Act he would have slapped in regulations which collected £8 on each petrol pump——
Comment on this
The planning legislation is not before the House. I would ask the Senator to keep to the amendments.
Comment on this
The Chair has been very lenient over the past five days and that leniency should not be abused.
Comment on this
I quite agree, but I was just saying that in the past the Minister has thought up quite extraordinary regulations and I feel that if he is given the opportunity, he will do so again. I reject completely his assurance of last night that he only "may" make regulations. We all know that not only will he make regulations to control these marts but that it is more than likely he already has a good idea of the type of regulations and what he intends to do in the not too distant future. I cannot see how he can put forward that argument, in view of the fact that he has insisted that this Bill should go through the House at this time, that there is so much urgency about it that it has to be rushed through——
Comment on this
Certain amendments are before the House and the Bill as a whole is not under discussion We are dealing with the amendments and would the Senator keep to the amendments?
Comment on this
Last night the Minister said he "may" make regulations and I am making the case that he already has regulations made. The whole purpose of the Bill is to make regulations. Under subsection (1) of section 6, there is sufficient power for the Minister to make regulations without interfering with the running of these marts as he certainly will if he is given the power he is seeking. As far as paragraph (b) is concerned, I should like to ask the Minister if he would consider the fact that it has happened on a few occasions that cattle traders have purchased sizable numbers of cattle and then sought protection of the courts. Those cases are well known and were well publicised. It is true that in some cases the marts suffered heavy losses and in other cases individual farmers suffered heavy losses. I should like the Minister to indicate what safeguards he is going to introduce to indemnify the individual farmer and the marts against operators of this kind. I was distressed to read in the newspapers not long ago where such a rustler, when brought to court for buying cattle without having the money to pay for them, had his case dismissed because he argued that he had not intended to defraud, but at the same time he bought the cattle and sold them over again. That was poor consolation to the farmer who was caught for £1,000. That did not go to the marts at all. The farmers have no guarantees against such individuals. As the industry operates, there is a certain amount of good faith involved, but on occasion this type of rustler gets in and——
Comment on this
There is nothing in this Bill to deal with that type of individual. If the Minister insists that every bid must be accepted——
Comment on this
The Senator is not now dealing with the amendment before the House.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald to continue on the amendments.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
I was merely asking the Minister if the farmers can expect any safeguards from these individual operators because under section 6 auctioneers and marts will not be free to refuse a bid even from a person whom to all intents and purposes they know is a man of straw.
Comment on this
The question is that amendment No. 38 be agreed.
Comment on this
The Chair has no power to ask anybody to speak.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 39:
In subsection (2) to delete paragraph (c).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In subsection (2) (d), line 37, before "and" where it secondly occurs to insert "such approval not to be unnecessarily withheld".
This is an amendment to provide that where the conditions of sale at a livestock mart are submitted to the Minister the approval of the Minister will not be, as set down, "unnecessarily" withheld. I think that is a typographical error. I think what was intended was "will not be unreasonably withheld". That is common form in a lot of legislation one finds on the Statute Book.
I am not entirely happy with the position that will arise where livestock mart owners are going to have to submit their conditions of sale to the Minister. It may well be that standard conditions of sale would develop and a blanket approval for these would be given but there may be circumstances where deviations from the standard regulations are necessary to suit a particular situation and I can see that difficulty will arise, people will be subjected to, possibly, a charge in the courts, for having departed from the standard regulations as approved by the Minister.
In addition, when one appreciates the kind of delays that occur in Departments, I think it is proper to provide that if a livestock mart owner submits regulations today he will get a decision from the Department tomorrow. That is the kind of competence you will not get from a Department of State. We have had to provide in the Town Planning Acts that where application is made for planning permission, if it is not given within two months it will be deemed to have been granted. I want to ensure that if somebody is having a livestock sale, say, in a month's time, and submits the conditions of sale to the Minister for Agriculture there will be no delay whatever in getting approval for the altered conditions.
One can immediately envisage the civil servant turning these over and examining them and making remarks and then writing out to find out what is meant by this and what is meant by that and sending out a whole list of inquiries and then when they come back there will be another set of inquiries arising out of the replies, and letters saying that the Minister's attention has been directed to so and so and asking what is meant by this and what is meant by that. That kind of rigmarole does not accord with my sense of business and it is not the kind of situation that I want to see livestock mart owners put in. I want to ensure that if a livestock mart owner applies to have his conditions of sale approved by the Minister these will be approved with speed, that the approval will not be unnecessarily or unreasonably withheld, but I do not think the amendment as drafted quite meets the situation. I think the approval should be deemed given if it is not forthcoming within whatever period we specify—a week or a fortnight. The Minister should make up his mind. He is the man who is supposed to know. If he is not satisfied with one thing, let him state what he does want.
Comment on this
At the risk of repetition, may I say that it must be assumed that the Minister for Agriculture and, indeed, every Minister of this State, will be fair and impartial in the discharge of his duties? If we accept the first line of argument, that every Minister is impartial in the discharge of his duties, the insertion of the words "such approval not to be unnecessarily withheld" does not improve the situation one bit. Rather would it indicate a lack of faith in the Minister. We can be sure that the Minister will not withhold approval without very good and cogent reason. Therefore, the insertion of the words "such approval not to be unnecessarily withheld" is superfluous, and if these words were inserted, it would make relatively no difference as regards the normal operation of the Act.
Comment on this
We all assume that Ministers are fair and impartial and reasonable and there is such a a thing known to the law as the reasonable man. That is a concept we are up against every day in administering justice. But, having accepted that there is such a concept as the reasonable man we find deviations from the norm every day. Let nobody be fooled by anything the Parliamentary Secretary says. I envisage considerable delay on the part of the Minister, not necessarily the Minister himself, but through his Civil Service machine there is going to be considerable delay. I think we must get the Civil Service to sit up and realise that in 1967 civil servants have a part to play in the business life of the country and must attune themselves to the tempo of business in 1967. That is the kind of efficiency and speed I want to get.
I do not intend to press this amendment because it does not quite adequately meet what I want to put in but what I will do is put down an amendment to ensure that we will have speed and efficiency and a minimum of delay in handling agricultural problems as well as other problems. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.
Mr. Dolan rose.
Comment on this
That does not prevent the Senator from speaking.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation or of order, or whatever it is, this technique—"I will withdraw the amendment and put down one", et cetera—I can visualise what that is intended to achieve and I object to the withdrawal of the amendment.
Comment on this
The question is whether the Senator be allowed to withdraw the amendment. Does Senator Dolan wish to speak?
Comment on this
Yes. I wish to say that as far as the amendment is concerned it was another of these efforts by the Opposition to obstruct and delay this Bill. It would achieve nothing. It is typical of the mentality of the Fine Gael effort in this respect. They have been trying here for the past four or five days and they tried for a couple of weeks in the Lower House, to ascribe all types of reasons to the Minister in introducing this Bill. At one point they are on the side of the mart owners. Then they are crying for the farmers. The whole thing is just a matter of raising a hare and bringing in irrelevant discussion for the sake of prolonging the debate. References have been made during the debate on this Bill to the Minister and to the Fianna Fáil organisation, to John Browns and so forth.
Comment on this
Regardless of the wishes of Senator Rooney, the Chair does not wish to hear it.
Comment on this
He was a very useful individual as far as I am concerned. This amendment should be treated with the contempt it deserves.
Comment on this
The question is whether Senator O'Quigley be given leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I ask Senator Rooney to withdraw that remark that the Chair has acted improperly.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to withdraw that remark that the Chair has acted improperly.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Senator has not said anything that was improper in relation to the Chair. What he said was——
Comment on this
The Senator has imputed impropriety to the Chair. The matter is now closed.
Comment on this
Is there any parliamentary precedent for not allowing a Senator to withdraw his amendment?
Comment on this
The Senator must be aware that amendments may be withdrawn only by leave of the House. There are precedents.
Comment on this
Might I seek the guidance of the Chair on this matter? The Government do not wish me to withdraw this amendment, and a vote has been taken by the Chair. Are we now entitled to challenge a division as to whether I am entitled to withdraw the amendment or not?
Comment on this
Yes. The motion is before the House. Does the Senator want a division?
Comment on this
Question put: "That section 9 stand part of the Bill".
Do you agree with this result?
Vótáil—no, I shall not pursue this absurdity except to say that, of course, I can put down an amendment to meet my needs on Report Stage. I intend to raise this matter on the section. For the information of Senator Ó Maoláin such an amendment would be in order.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 45 and 46 have already been discussed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In subsection (2) to delete paragraph (e).
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In subsection (2) to delete paragraph (f).
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In subsection (2), page 5, to add a new paragraph as follows:
"( ) provide that the person carrying on the business of a livestock mart shall make adequate arrangements to safeguard the payments to persons whose property has been auctioned."
This seeks to ensure that something else will be provided in the regulations to be made by the Minister in connection with the proper conduct of livestock marts. This is something that can be accepted by the Minister because he made the point, when he reminded the House on Second Reading that this measure was being introduced principally in the interests of the farming community.
The purpose of the amendment is to safeguard the farming community in doing business with a livestock mart. We are now proposing to license these marts and in the situation when they will operate on the licence issued by the Minister, the farmers who bring their livestock for auction to these marts are entitled, now that they are under the Minister's surveillance, to be guaranteed by the Minister or to have the Minister ensure that when they bring cattle to the mart, they will, in fact, be paid for what has been sold. We have had reports of situations where, because of the failure of the cattle mart and the bad conduct of business by them, the cheques the farmers got for the sale of cattle bounced. Senator Dolan referred to some instances of this. That is regrettable. Up to now the marts have been operating without supervision or control but now the Minister is bringing them under control and it is sensible to provide in the regulations which will cover the conduct of the marts that they will be required to make adequate arrangements to safeguard payments to persons whose property has been auctioned.
I think the House will understand the sense of the amendment and that the wording will be found reasonable. It is the best I could think of and therefore I hope the House will accept it and add this condition to the list we have already included under section 6 (2).
Comment on this
This provision is unnecessary because it is being dealt with first, by regulation and secondly, it can also be dealt with by section 3 (2), which says that the Minister may, at the time of the granting of a licence, attach to the licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify in the licence. I may add that the Marts Association will be consulted as regards the provisions and regulations being implemented and therefore the necessity for this amendment does not exist.
Comment on this
I cannot agree with the Parliamentary Secretary. Surely what is envisaged and provided for under section 3 (2) is the sort of exception where you attach a special condition to a licence which might go on to one licence and not another and which may vary from individual to individual and from business to business. What we have in section 6 is the sort of general regulation which would presumably apply to all marts. That is my reading of the section. What I want here is not something that may or may not be attached as a condition to one licence and not to another but that there should be something like the provisions in respect of maintenance of proper veterinary standards, that there should be something that will apply to all marts that get a licence after this legislation is passed. It is not sufficient answer for the Parliamentary Secretary to say that the Minister under section 3 (2) may attach such a condition as I envisage to a licence and shall so specify in the licence.
I suspect that the position is that the Minister finds himself in this situation: "Perhaps it would be desirable to have this included in the general regulations, perhaps it was not properly considered, or perhaps sufficient attention was not paid to it— that is not a criticism, and is not intended to be a criticism—and it could usefully be added to the section, but we do not want to accept any amendments in the Seanad and we do not want to concede anything". That is really the attitude, and the Parliamentary Secretary comes in with the excuse that it can be done under the exceptional arrangements which we can make under subsection (2) of section 3.
I want this to be one of the regulations which would govern all the marts, and not one which would govern one and not another, because one mart may fail at one time and another which is apparently healthy economically may fail in years to come, and if such marts have to operate under a licence given by the Minister, they should be required to make proper arrangements to safeguard payments to the farmers whose property is auctioned at the marts. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to look at this again. Surely it would be sensible to add the amendment to the section. Perhaps the wording is not the best, although I think it is, but the principle is important and should be accepted.
Comment on this
A great deal has been said, but we have been given very few facts, about the number of people who lost money as a result of the operation of livestock marts. I should like to hear from Senator Dolan or the Parliamentary Secretary whether it is of the order of 5,000, 10,000 or 20,000 and in how many marts did this occur. This campaign is unfair to all the competent mart owners and auctioneers who are engaged in that business. Accusations have been made and, so far, no facts have been produced. Let it be stated quite plainly where this occurred. Was it in Ballybofey or where? I do not know. We should have the same clarity about these charges as one sees in the Aberfan Report which stated in no uncertain terms who was responsible for what. There is no use in mouthing charges and throwing mud which sticks to everyone.
Of course we are all in favour of people being paid for the cattle they sell at the marts but, with respect to the Senators who put down this amendment, I do not think the amendment would achieve the desirable object we all wish to achieve. Nor indeed is the Bill in any sense calculated to afford to the farmers the protection they may require. No amount of legislation will make people competent and honest, and ultimately it is competence and honesty which ensure that people get their money when they sell their cattle at a livestock mart. We can make all the regulations in the world about fidelity bonds being entered into, but if the livestock mart owner allows his fidelity bond to lapse unknown to the Minister, carries out a sale, and makes off with the proceeds, there is no security for the owners of the cattle.
Quite clearly you cannot legislate for honesty and competence to ensure that there will not be any loss, but there is a system by which one could ensure that if that kind of thing did happen and a fidelity bond were reneged upon or allowed to lapse, the sellers of the cattle would be protected. There is an admirable system in the legal profession. A fund is contributed to by all the solicitors, and if a solicitor peculates, as solicitors have done through incompetence or otherwise, and if he makes off with the client's money, a fund which has been built up by the solicitors with their own money is available to compensate the client whose money was taken by an incompetent or fraudulent solicitor.
That is a real remedy. There is nothing in this Bill to enable the Minister to do that. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will not say he can do it under the regulations because he cannot, and he cannot do it by conditions. It just cannot be done under the Bill. That is a real system and a real safeguard and if the Minister were really concerned about safeguarding the farmers selling their cattle, that is the kind of system he would have brought in, by statute, as was done in the case of solicitors. No regulations however admirable or however well designed can provide the proper safeguards because they will be of no use if the fidelity bond is not paid up. Therefore, I do not think this amendment meets the situation.
Comment on this
I should like to say with regard to this matter which was referred to by the Leader of the Opposition that I did not make any wild charges about cattle marts as a whole. I know of many cattle mart owners who are excellent and reputable people but at the same time this Bill is designed, in the main, to protect the ordinary farmer.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley is well aware, I am sure, from his own supporters—if they are not all away on holidays—that such a case as I have referred to has occurred——
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would refrain from mentioning the names of people who are not here to defend themselves.
Comment on this
I did not mention any names. I was saying that cattle marts which were in existence have gone out of existence, and that people who brought their cattle there and sold them were not paid.
Comment on this
I rise to direct attention to the fact that we are discussing an amendment moved by Senator Murphy on behalf of the Labour Party. I do not think any reasonable-minded person can deny that Senator Murphy made an unanswerable case for the amendment. I am prompted to speak because of the experience we have all had during this entire debate. I am sure the debate on this Bill, and particularly the debate on Committee Stage, will go down in the history of the House as the most futile and senseless we have ever had on any Bill. For the life of me, I cannot see what purpose it is serving or what good it is doing to anyone.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would confine his remarks to the amendment before the House.
Comment on this
I am trying to direct my remarks to the amendment and, with your indulgence, it will not, perhaps, take me too long to do so.
Comment on this
The Chair has been very indulgent over the past five days.
Comment on this
I agree, Sir; I do not think anyone will deny that. The Government ought at this juncture to take time to have a look at least at this particular amendment. It is not my intention to repeat anything Senator Murphy has said—we have had far too much of that in the course of this debate—but I put it to the Parliamentary Secretary that the Government surely owe it to themselves to demonstrate even by one small gesture that they are, in fact, prepared to listen to reasonable argument. We expect that much consideration from the Government. A great deal of the debate is to be deplored. I do not apportion any blame for that. I am simply reminding the House that we reached a position of utter absurdity this morning when we divided the House on the question whether or not a member of the House had, in fact, the right to withdraw an amendment. I do not think we should repeat that exercise. Something is needed to lift the debate out of the depth of absurdity to which it has sunk in order to demonstrate to everybody in the House, and outside it, that the Government have not completely lost their senses yet.
Comment on this
I agree wholeheartedly with the aim of this amendment. There are, I think, very few people on this side of the House who do not agree with it. The method, however, of achieving that aim is not the method suggested in the amendment. Subsection (1) of section 6 provides:
The Minister may, for the purpose of ensuring the proper conduct of places where the business of a livestock mart is carried on and the proper conduct of such businesses ... make such regulations as he thinks appropriate in relation to such businesses.
Subsection (2), which is the subsection Senator Murphy wishes to have amended, provides:
Without prejudice to the generality of subsection (1) of this section, regulations under this section may—
The governing word there is "may". And here is where we add the amendment:
( ) provide that the person carrying on the business of a livestock mart shall make adequate arrangements to safeguard the payments to persons whose property has been auctioned.
The whole purpose of this Bill, as I understand it, is to protect the ordinary farmers. That protection must be given to them in various directions and from different points of view. It must be given from the point of view of providing hygiene; it must be given from the point of view that every farmer has the right to sell his cattle on the mart; it must be given from the point of view that every farmer will be paid for his stock when it is sold on the mart. Despite what Senator O'Quigley has said, this Bill provides that regulations may be made to cover all these things or any additional things that may be found either necessary or reasonable for protecting the ordinary farmer.
The proper way to do these things is by regulation. Ordinarily, as a lawyer, I am opposed to delegated legislation, that is, legislation by regulation, but there are certain circumstances and certain types of business in which it is acknowledged that the only way in which one can do the greatest good is by making regulations instead of incorporating safeguards in a Bill. The reason for that is that it is only by consultation with the interested parties —the farmers, on the one hand, selling their cattle and, on the other hand, the cattle marts themselves—that one can ascertain the best and most effective way of doing things.
Senator O'Quigley referred to one method, the method adopted by the Incorporated Law Society: the members of the Society jointly and severally guarantee the honesty of every member and, if any person embezzles a client's money or is guilty of fraud, all his colleagues, without exception and without limit, must make good the amount lost or the fraud perpetrated. That is one way of doing it. It is only one of many. Senator O'Quigley has suggested that such a method is not possible by regulation. Of course it is, once it is provided for in legislation.
Incorporating this amendment of Senator Murphy will not put the matter any further. The Minister has given an undertaking—I am sure it will be found on the records; I do not know whether it arose in the Dáil, but it certainly did here, and I am quite sure my ears did not deceive me—that this is one of the regulations which will have to be made. Even if the amendment were to be accepted, we would still be governed by the word "may", subject to the fact that, when the regulations are made, they will be statutory regulations and will be laid before both Houses. I should imagine that, if such a regulation were not among the general regulations, there would then be very grave cause for concern and for criticism.
There are, of course, other ways in which Senator Murphy's aim can be achieved. This is not the only way. With regard to the fidelity bond, the bond is paid for in advance and the receipt from the insurance company must be produced before a man can carry on. There are various other ways. I agree with Senator O'Quigley that you cannot make a man either competent or honest by Act of Parliament, but you can by Act of Parliament and by regulations under the Act protect other people from defalcation. While it is agreed by everybody that this is one of the primary protections the farmer would require, I think Senator Murphy and Senator Crowley will find, if they refer again to the wording of the section, that this is not the way to do it. Ultimately we are dependent on the regulations. I have no doubt whatsoever that it could be done better under regulations rather than by incorporating it in the framework of the Bill. For one thing, there is more flexibility when it is done by regulation. The first method you hit upon need not necessarily be the best method. Therefore, while agreeing with the aim of the amendment, I find myself, for the very same reasons as Senator Crowley and Senator Murphy gave, namely, adequate protection, against the incorporation of the amendment in the Bill.
Comment on this
It appears that this Bill is to be made law and is to be enforced on the marts and the farmers whether they like it or not. The amendment by Senator Murphy and his colleagues is a very reasonable amendment. I was glad to hear that even Senator Nash approves of it and that he approves of the spirit and the aim of it.
Comment on this
When we have approved of it, let us face the position as we find it. This Marts Bill was introduced by the Government. They were not requested by the marts committees to introduce it or by the farmers or even by the people who Senator Dolan says lost their money—I shall come to that later. Neither were they asked by the IAOS or by the Livestock Marts Association or by any of those people who would be interested in it. No, there is nobody interested in this Bill——
Comment on this
Will the Senator confine his attention to the amendment.
Comment on this
The Senator may not wander over the whole Bill at this stage.
Comment on this
No, Sir. I am referring to the financial standing of the marts and that is what I am going to discuss. First of all, this Marts Bill is being imposed on the people who are concerned with the contents of it. In trying to justify this Bill Fianna Fáil have tried by insinuation to make the public believe that every mart in the country is in danger of collapse——
Comment on this
——and that they are rushing to the assistance of the farmers by forcing this Bill through the Dáil and Seanad, an unwanted Bill and one that has been resisted in the Dáil and Seanad for those very reasons. Normally, legislation comes about as a result of representation from the parties and organisations concerned. No attempt is being made by the Government on this occasion to put on the Statute Book a Bill that has been requested because it has not been. An effort is being made by some of the Fianna Fáil speakers to make the public at large think that this Marts Bill is designed to protect the farmers against loss resulting from marts going out of business. The farmers have full confidence in the marts as they stand and the proof of it is the increasing and expanding volume of business which is being transacted through those marts. The trend is all towards the marts. If the farmers were afraid of losing their money by transacting business through those marts and if they had not confidence in them we should not have a situation where the volume of business being transacted through the marts is increasing. The effort of the Government in order to justify this Bill is to give the marts a bad name by creating some kind of suspicion in relation to the marts. They use this kind of chat as an excuse for imposing this Bill. I feel it is only right at this stage to challenge the Government on this issue and let them say once and for all that half the marts in this country are not in danger of collapsing as it would seem from the excuses put up by the Government in favour of bringing in this Bill.
There was some reference to taking out a bond. We all know that the bond will have to be related to the turnover because there are some marts transacting a greater volume of business than others and the smaller marts would be required to pay a very heavy premium if the premium was a uniform payment due from the marts. It would, of course, have to be related to their turnover.
Senator Dolan frequently in this debate has mentioned the fact that some farmers lost their money as a result of a mart going out of business. I am not forcing him to mention the name of the mart concerned but I am not convinced that the amount of money lost was in any way substantial. We have had publicity in relation to one or two isolated cases but of course the isolated case does not justify a Bill of this nature that is going to affect every mart in the country, every farmer in the country and the livestock trade in general. This talk is deliberately designed to create a suspicion regarding the financial standing of those mart owners. This suspicion is being created in order to justify the imposition of this Bill which has been resisted by all the interests concerned, the farmers, the marts and all those associated with it.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary might be able to give the figure a little more accurately but my recollection is that the mart turnover is approximately £250 million.
Comment on this
Senator Dolan is either too stupid or too perverse——
Comment on this
The case I made was that a bond of £5,000 might be sufficient to cover a turnover of £100,000 in any one day because you would not expect a deficiency of £100,000 in turnover in one day.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear the Senator say that because that is exactly what Fianna Fáil are saying all the time; that the marts are in danger of collapse——
Comment on this
I wish the Senator would discuss the amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment is:
In subsection (2), page 5, to add a new paragraph as follows:
"( ) provide that the person carrying on the business of a livestock mart shall make adequate arrangements to safeguard the payments to persons whose property has been auctioned."
I have read this for the Senators.
Comment on this
The amendment is exactly what I am dealing with now. I am dealing with the turnover of the sales mart and I have come to the point where I am going to mention that the total turnover of the marts in this country would be approximately £250 million. Is there anybody over there prepared to contradict that figure?
Comment on this
We hear the Senators over there talking about losses of a couple of thousand pounds. A couple of thousand pounds out of £250 million.
Comment on this
The regulations are not going to help unless you adopt the system I suggested.
Comment on this
All this suspicion that is being created regarding the financial standing of marts is being justified by the Fianna Fáil Party repeating that somebody lost a couple of thousand pounds in connection with some mart that went out of business. Where there is a figure of £250 million concerned surely you can expect that some business or other may go out of business.
Comment on this
All these places have lost far more money than all the marts in the country could be expected to lose in a year in connection with their business. This turnover of £250 million is the kind of figure that the Government are interested in because eventually I am sure they will be putting on a cattle tax and the mart owners will be the tax collectors.
Comment on this
The Senator is wandering from the amendment.
Comment on this
I am for the amendment. The point I am making is that the Fianna Fáil Party, for the past couple of months, have been talking about marts going broke.
Comment on this
I would certainly wish, first of all, to compliment Senator Crowley on his anticipation and to reassure Senator Murphy about the Minister's statement which he made here and which I quote from Volume 63, column 1035 of the 27th July:
Let me say, and go on the record here and now, without any question, as saying that one of the uses to which I first intend to put this measure, if it is enacted, is to ensure that there is either an insurance bond, a fidelity bond or whatever you like, that there will be cover for our farmers who may suffer losses in the future in regard to those marts as some of them have sustained up to the present.
The basic aim of the entire Bill is to ensure the orderly marketing of cattle, No. 1, and to safeguard the interest of farmers, No. 2. We in the Fianna Fáil Party do not cast aspersions on the cattle marts' integrity and the running of them but we are concerned with safeguarding the ordinary farmers, and even though the sums of money which would be lost might be insignificant to the wealthy elements of this nation, it is always well to remember that whereas a pound is not an awful lot of money when you have a lot, it can be a whale of a lot of money when you have not got it and to some of the small farmers the loss of even a few pounds would be of tremendous significance.
The regulations which will be provided after consultations with the marts will provide for suitable provisions designed to safeguard the interests of the owners of stock. Senator Murphy can be quite assured that his amendment is more than covered in the existing portion of this Bill and that its addition would be somewhat superfluous.
Comment on this
Special conditions will undoubtedly arise and it would be foolhardy of me to anticipate what those might be in certain circumstances. All marts cannot be of equal merit and the same case cannot be adduced for each one. If a certain case is adduced for one mart or several marts in one part of the country, there may be particular reasons for that not being suitable in other parts. I am not stating there will be such cases but there could well be, and it would be unwise to tie oneself to legislation under which there could be no guarantee that in very exceptional circumstances you were not committed to one particular situation.
Senator McDonald mentioned the size of marts, and the regulation of a particular size of mart. If the existing ones were lesser than the size prescribed, it could mean that they might not get a licence. I want to assure the Senator that such is not likely to happen. Now, to get back to this amendment, section 6 (1) gives general power to make regulations in regard to various aspects of the business of marts, including the taking out of a fidelity bond.
Comment on this
One would imagine that a matter like this would be highlighted in the regulation section but this is an afterthought.
Comment on this
The other subsections provide for the making of regulations. The Minister has assured the House, and I now want to assure the House again, that one of the uses to which he first intends putting this measure is "to ensure that there is an insurance bond, a fidelity bond or whatever you like, that there will be a cover for our farmers who may suffer losses in the future in regard to those marts". Possibly this might meet Senator O'Quigley's suggestion. If the marts associations themselves devised such a system of guarantee as he mentioned, it might help.
Comment on this
I guarantee that the Minister will provide such an assurance. If he makes regulations, he will provide for this.
Comment on this
I thank the Parliamentary Secretary for his reply. I think the second reply was rather different from the first one, but it was an improvement. I quite agree with Senator Nash that what we are dealing with here is an amendment which is not in any way obligatory. The section provides that the Minister may make regulations, but do not blame us for that. The Labour Party approach to this was quite different. It seems to me that the Fine Gael Senators are worried by the possible cost of this sort of cover to the livestock marts. It was suggested that the fidelity bond or the indemnity bond might not be completely satisfactory, that insurance might be allowed to lapse and farmers might be stuck as a result.
We are not in this amendment making any reference to a fidelity bond or an indemnity bond. We are not saying how the business should be done. We are saying it should be provided in the regulations that adequate arrangements are made to safeguard the interests of the farmers who trade through cattle marts. We are not attempting to define how it should be done but we are saying that if regulations are to be made in regard to washing facilities and veterinary requirements, the farmers' pockets are more important. This should be in the regulations and it should be in the Bill. We should not be fobbed off with an assurance by the Minister that he will, of course, if he makes regulations, provide for this.
We have existing things covered. They are not inexhaustible and it says they are not. We can suppose there will be important things which will be covered in regulations. For example, in paragraph (a), we prescribe the manner in which entries for auctions of livestock at such places shall be received and in paragraph (b), that entries for such auctions shall not be refused except in circumstances prescribed in the regulations. Those are all very important and I think the others are important too. We should have veterinary requirements and certain standards for such places and at such auctions. They may be relatively unimportant things. Surely the most important thing is that once a livestock mart operates under a licence issued by the Minister, it should be required to make reasonable arrangements to guarantee payment to the farmers whose livestock goes through that mart. This is not unreasonable and it is an important provision. It deserves to be written into the regulations. It deserves equal importance with the ventilation facilities, washing facilities and all that type of thing.
These are important in themselves— I do not want anybody to misinterpret me in that respect—for the health of the cattle and for the health of the people in those cattle marts, but surely what is of fundamental importance, particularly for the poor man, is that he should know, when he goes into a mart operating under a licence given by the Minister, he is going to a reputable person and if his cattle are sold at that auction, no cheque will bounce and he will be guaranteed against loss because of failure by anybody.
Again, I am not casting any aspersions on cattle marts or their operation. I do not know any of them. All I am saying is that in the interests of the farmer who will use those cattle marts, operating under licence from the Minister, there should be a condition that under the licence provided for in the regulations, adequate arrangements will be made to safeguard payments to persons whose property has been auctioned. Therefore, I press this amendment as I think it is of importance, and even more important than the cleanliness of premises or the inspection of cattle.
Comment on this
I am sorry for intervening a second time. I think the section meets exactly the point to which Senator Murphy has referred. First of all, let us take subsection (1). That deals with generalities: it gives the fundamentals. Subsection (2) deals only with details.
Comment on this
Under subsection (1) you have the fundamentals to the regulations ensuring the proper conduct of places—that is the first thing. Secondly, there is the proper conduct of business. The business of a cattle mart is to take cattle which belong to other people, to sell those cattle for the owners to cattle dealers and to ensure that the owners are paid. That is the absolute fundamental business of the cattle marts.
Comment on this
I am coming to them. This is the fundamental business. The regulations must, first of all, apply to the fundamentals. One of the fundamentals before you get to any of the details at all is the actual conduct of the business, the taking of the cattle from the owners, the selling of them to third parties and ensuring that the owners are paid and receive their money. Having dealt with the fundamentals of the business, under subsection (2) it might be considered that it is not a fundamental part of the business to ensure that the marts are kept properly washed, or to deal with the time at which the entries are received, whether a week beforehand, a day beforehand or on the day of the mart. Those are all minor points. If subsection (2) did not exist, it could possibly be argued that these kinds of details did not come within the ambit of subsection (1). Therefore, by writing them into subsection (2), you are making a detail of what is a fundamental.
Comment on this
If because he does not want to listen to logic my friend cannot and will not understand me, I cannot help that. The actual wording of the section speaks for itself. Subsection (1) is fundamental and you cannot necessarily introduce regulations regarding details. The auction mart might quite reasonably decide: "All right; when we accept entries, the entries we receive and whom we receive them from are details which we can decide." You may under subsection (1), supposing subsection (2) did not exist, decide on the fundamentals and payment for the cattle is one of the fundamentals which goes under subsection (1).
The only point of difference between Senator Murphy and me is that he feels this fundamental should be part of the Bill; in other words, this should be incorporated in the Bill. If you incorporate it in the Bill, it will be inflexible. From my point of view, this should be incorporated in an order, a statutory regulation, and not in the Bill. Thereby you can as effectively get the type of control of payment that would be most satisfactory to everybody.
I quite agree that there are general regulations governing payment. There may be certain fundamentals again there, leaving room, if you like, for certain discrepancies in detail. The bonds provided by one mart might not necessarily be decided for another mart. I do not say that bonds are the best method. There could be inspection of books, ensuring that they keep separate bank accounts so that there will not be an overdraft and that money cannot be lodged to their own account. The only way you can arrive at the best method is, first of all, by discussion with interested parties and finding out what would be most satisfactory and then by incorporating what you have decided in the regulations.
Comment on this
I really think Senator O'Quigley has a point when he says that subsections (1) and (2) of the section go into a lot of details. Senator Nash says they certainly are not of the very greatest importance. Of course they are. Perhaps subsections (b), (c) and (d) are fundamentals. They are, I think, one of the chief reasons for the measure at all. Surely it is a fundamental thing at an auction that you safeguard and make regulations about the way entries to marts will be received, providing that entries for such auctions shall not be refused except as prescribed in the regulations. There is all this talk about avoiding discrimination and about fundamentals. I say that it is equally fundamental to provide that the farmer who puts his cattle through the mart licensed by the Minister should have arrangements made for payment, that he should be guaranteed, if his property has been sold and the cheque is not satisfactory, that he will receive payment for putting his cattle through a licensed auction mart.
Senator Nash made the point: "Look, we are not going into details; there might be need to have consultation with the livestock marts and the associations about the details of this." The Minister has already made it clear that there will be consultations before he sets out to draw up regulations such as are envisaged under subsection (2). It does not take in any way from our argument that this should also be written into subsection (2) and should be the subject of consultation with the livestock marts before the Minister makes regulations. It should not be left out of the Bill altogether, as a sort of afterthought which might be included.
Comment on this
Question put: "That section 10 stand part of the Bill".
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 52:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"( ) The power of the Minister to make regulations under this section does not include the power to make regulations requiring the payment by any person, or unincorporated body of persons carrying on the business of a livestock mart, or by any other person of any licence fee, toll, poundage or other charge in relation to the selling or buying of livestock, or to the discharge by a health authority or by an officer of the Minister or the Minister of their respective functions under this Act, or under regulations or in relation to any veterinary examination, inspection or supervision under this Act or regulations."
I should like to draw your attention, a Chathaoirleach, to a small error in the printing of this. The amendment should read:
"( ) The power of the Minister to make regulations under this section does not include the power to make regulations requiring the payment by any person, or unincorporated body of persons carrying on the business of a livestock mart, or by any other person of any licence fee, toll, poundage or other charge in relation to the selling or buying of livestock, for the discharge,
rather than
or to the discharge by a health authority....
It only came to my notice this morning and I should like to say I am not attaching any blame to the officials or anybody else involved. The purpose of the amendment is to make it quite clear that charges for the administration of this Act will not be passed on to mart proprietors or to farmers but rather that they will be a charge on the Department. In the discussion during the past hour or so, the Parliamentary Secretary reminded us that the Minister stated that if a mart went bust, the cost would be met by an insurance bond and he added "or what you like". Does the phrase "what you like" include a charge on the farmers who sell cattle in the marts?
Veterinary examinations and inspection supervisions will probably increase at marts as time goes on because of the introduction in them of brucellosis tests and bovine TB tests. There will be more inspections of marts and of animals in them and this will involve a greater number of inspectors from the Department. I can imagine that the Minister for Finance, when he has a look at the costs coming up to Budget time, will direct the attention of the Minister to the continually rising costs of administering this Act and may suggest as a means of getting those costs down that a charge be put on sellers of cattle. It is to ensure that no such charge will be made that we have put down the amendment.
Comment on this
Briefly, I should like to support the amendment. Earlier in the debate the Minister told us of the ancient charter which imposed tolls or headage payments on cattle being shown at fairs. It is to be hoped he will not re-introduce a toll system under this Bill. That is why we put down the amendment. We should like an assurance from the Minister that he will not avail of the powers under the Bill to introduce any such toll or headage charge.