Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 145–287 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1967 ›
In the absence of any powers in the Act to charge fees, I fail to see the relevance of the Senators' speeches. During Second Reading, in his introductory statement the Minister assured the House that there is no requirement in the Bill for the payment by livestock marts of either licence or registration fees. This meets Senator McDonald's point. It has been stated by the Minister that the Bill has no requirement for the payment by livestock marts of any fee for licence or registration.
Comment on this
They are not provided for in the Bill. It is not the function of the Bill to charge farmers who are going into any mart.
Comment on this
When we have Senator Nash and the Parliamentary Secretary telling us that the Minister is entitled to prescribe a fidelity bond, though there is nothing about it in the Bill, we are not prepared to accept that kind of assurance. Senator Nash told us that Senator Murphy's amendment, providing for the proper carrying on of the business of the marts, is contained in section 6 (1), which gives general power. That is all related to the proper carrying on of the business of marts. Of course, there is power if the Minister wants to use it by regulation to say that vendors of cattle in those marts shall pay a toll or a poundage or some kind of cattle tax. That power is there. Will the Minister give the categorical assurance that it is not intended to use any power contained in the Bill to impose on farmers selling cattle any fee, toll, poundage or other charge?
Comment on this
The Senator may have that assurance. That is in order. This is more of the propaganda, trying in every way to bring about mass hysteria.
Comment on this
We know all about the Fianna Fáil cattle tax. What the Minister stated on Second Reading is entirely related to the registration fee and the obtaining of a licence. He said there would be no formal charge for obtaining a licence. That is all he said.
Comment on this
It might be appropriate to ask the Parliamentary Secretary if he would be prepared to say that mart committees or owners cannot levy a charge against any people whose cattle are sold in the marts, for retransmission to any organisation, farmers' organisation or otherwise.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I will be very brief on the section because nearly all that can be said about it has been said already. However, I want to refer to what I consider to be a deficiency in paragraph (d), that is to say, there is no time limit imposed on the Minister within which he shall approve of the conditions of sale, and the conditions of sale for a livestock mart owner may in some circumstances be matters of urgency. Therefore, it is desirable that that matter should be dealt with, and should have been dealt with, in the section. I am glad the Minister is present again because it seems there are powers in the Bill which nobody reading it would have thought existed. According to the Minister's Parliamentary Secretary, one of the powers is to set up a compensation fund. That is feasible and possible under the regulations and I understood that to be Senator Nash's reading of subsection (1) of section 6. If there are to be regulations in regard to tolls and charges that may be and can be made by the Minister under section 6, these should be set out clearly in the Bill.
Senator Honan referred to a matter before lunch which is of very considerable importance. It may well be that Senator Honan was seeking an assurance on a matter about which he feels deeply. He certainly showed considerable candour and brought to light what a number of people had been saying this Bill is directed against. He asked the Parliamentary Secretary a question which was not answered. The question was: would the regulations provide that in a case where a livestock mart was run by a committee of persons, the committee would not be entitled to raise any levy in the course of the conduct of their business to provide contributions to a particular organisation. That, translated into ordinary everyday speech, means that Senator Honan wants to know if the Minister can prevent a livestock mart from making a contribution to, let us say, the Fine Gael Party, or to the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I want to know can they do that or be prevented from doing that—or, more pertinently, to the Creamery Milk Suppliers Association or the NFA. That is what Senator Honan is worried about. He may have said the wrong thing at the wrong time. That may be disturbing the Minister. But "the facility which the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries possesses for saying the wrong thing at the wrong time is quite frightening," says an editorial in the Cork Examiner this morning. I hope the Minister will not be too cross with Senator Honan for saying the right thing at the wrong time.
Comment on this
The Seanad divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 58:
Before subsection (2) to insert a new subsection as follows:
"( ) The Minister or an officer of the Minister shall not disclose to the Revenue Commissioners or to any other person any information relating to the business of a livestock mart obtained in the exercise of any of the powers under this Act or the regulations made thereunder."
The purpose of this amendment is to safeguard the owners of livestock marts who are obliged to disclose information to the Minister's officers and servants from having that information noised abroad either to competitors of the marts or to other persons. Some of the persons the livestock mart owners might be concerned about their getting information would be the Revenue Commissioners. The Revenue Commissioners, in my view, have ample powers of their own to ascertain such information as is necessary for them for the discharge of their functions and it would allay suspicions and fears considerably if it were made clear in the Bill that the information obtained as a result of the inquiries of the Minister's officers and servants was not going to be transmitted to any other Department of State and that it would be used only in connection with the business with which the Minister's officers were immediately and directly concerned. I know that when the position is the other way, the Revenue Commissioners normally will not disclose any information obtained by them to other Departments. Under the existing code of taxation legislation, they hold all the powers they require, without having that information obtained under penalty as provided in section 7 and having that transmitted to them from the Minister's officers or servants.
It is equally important that the private affairs of one mart should not be disclosed to, perhaps, a competitor in another mart. It is for that reason that the amendment provides also that the Minister's officers—and the Minister, although it is very unlikely that he would—shall not disclose to any other person information relating to the business of a livestock mart obtained by him. This is a desirable safeguard in order to preserve the business secrets of a mart. Even with the rigorous income tax code we have, legislation does provide, where there are disputes between the Revenue Commissioners and the taxpayer as to his liability, for the hearing of appeals either to the Special Commissioners or to the judge of the Circuit Court privately, and where matters have to be argued out in court, it is always done anonymously. It is very desirable that the safeguards in the taxation code should not be set at nought by this section.
Comment on this
I am rather surprised to see this amendment put forward, because every business in the country at the present time must submit to the Department of Industry and Commerce—I am talking about businesses other than a cattle mart business— full detailed statistical information about every aspect of their activities: the number of employees they have and what they are paid; what they were paid last year; the type of goods produced; the type of raw materials used; what they cost and what their selling price was; what the added value was—absolutely every detail. They do so with the full assurance that these details will not be disclosed by the Department either to competitors or to any other Department of State.
To incorporate something of this nature in this Bill when there is no such safeguard applying in the case of ordinary business would seem to assume that there is this difference, that people engaged in the cattle mart business can, without committing any breach of ethics, defraud the Revenue Commissioners, whereas in any other business, it would be a breach of ethics. There seems to be a discrimination. Of course it is unethical, but some people, unfortunately, do not consider it unethical. In any event, in manufacturing business of every type, there must be disclosed to the Department of Industry and Commerce considerably more details than have to be disclosed to the inspectors of taxes. Therefore, to introduce such an amendment into this Bill would be most invidious.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading of the Bill, I referred to this matter being dealt with under section 7, and I said in respect of taxation of land, that the trend is to derate land completely. It is quite obvious to everyone that if we derate land completely, there must be another form of taxation created to fill the gap caused by the fact that people have not to pay rates any further. I hold that the Marts Bill is not just a Bill to make regulations or to stop abuses in regard to people not being allowed to sell their cattle or in regard to a certain organisation going in and preventing sales. That only happened when certain people were not present. It has not happened since, and the owners of the marts were the only people who were really hurt by the fact that cattle were not sold in the marts. The mart owners do not want any obstruction. They are not at fault at all. The mart owners never tried to stop a beast being sold at a mart.
Comment on this
Would the Senator come to amendment No. 58, which is the only matter before the House?
Comment on this
I am speaking on amendment No. 58 which relates to section 7.
Comment on this
The Senator may discuss section 7 later on.
Comment on this
Not as well. The Senator must come to the amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment refers to not disclosing information to the Revenue Commissioners. The section says they must disclose information to the Revenue Commissioners, and we do not want them to disclose to the Revenue Commissioners——
Comment on this
The amendment says they should not be asked to disclose information to the Revenue Commissioners as to the sales a particular farmer made or as to the sales that took place in a mart. I say that with the derating of land, a new system of taxation will be introduced and the Revenue Commissioners will get their information from the sales that take place in the marts. It is for that reason I am opposing the section.
Comment on this
We have just heard two of the most bizarre reasons from Senator McAuliffe and Senator O'Quigley for supporting this proposal. Senator McAuliffe feels, strangely, that were it not for this amendment, the Bill specifically gives power to the Revenue Commissioners to use information which the Minister may require solely to inform him as to whether or not a mart is being properly managed and is properly functioning. There is no such suggestion in the Bill. There are no grounds for the suggestion that this amendment is needed to allay the suspicions—not a very happy word— and fears of Senator O'Quigley that the Minister intends to start on an entirely new track of facilitating the disclosure to the Revenue Commissioners of information which he and his Department need entirely and exclusively for the purpose of ensuring that the marts come within the regulations proposed under the Bill. Here we have an instance of the suggestion implied in many of the amendments put down on Committee Stage that the Bill gives powers of intrusion which, in fact, it does not give.
Senator O'Quigley knows well that there is no reason, as Senator Nash has pointed out, for either fear or suspicion in his mind. Regarding what Senator Nash has said, were we to write in such a specific provision as this amendment, we would have to go back over all our legislation and write in what is long established as a convention, a tradition and, indeed, a principle, that the Minister involved in any such legislation will not disclose information to the Revenue Commissioners. I do not think legislation need specifically state that, since the principle has always been there and will always be there.
My final point is in regard to Senator McAuliffe's fear that because the Government have embarked on a programme of derating in the interests of the agricultural community, they will be seeking ways and means of making up the money through giving information to the Revenue Commissioners. The Senator and others like him who may believe that will find, as the Government's further programme for the relief of rates expands, that there is no need for fear that any such programme will be maintained on the basis of spying activities such as he suggests but purely on increased productivity which has always been the basis of Fianna Fáil reliefs from taxation.
Comment on this
I should like to be as satisfied as Senator O'Kennedy seems to be that this section is as innocent as he appears to think. The amendment we are discussing proposes a very simple precaution, merely to insert one additional clause. Nobody could question the necessity for some such, if not safeguard, at least assurance, being written into this section.
To see the effect of the amendment we must also look again at the section of the Bill. The amendment simply proposes that the Minister or his officers "shall not disclose to the Revenue Commissioners...". Looking down at section 7 (2), the first provision is that an "officer of the Minister shall, for the purposes of the execution of this Act, have power, first, to enter, inspect and examine at all reasonable times...". I do not think anybody could have any serious objection to that. The next provision is where we begin to ask why and what is the necessity for it—"...An officer of the Minister shall have power to require the production of any documents required to be kept in pursuance of regulations under this Act and to inspect, examine and copy any of them". That is an unusual provision, to my mind. Nobody could possibly say it was all right without at least asking why.
If you go down through the other subsections, your suspicions will, if anything, be confirmed. I happen to represent a section of people who have suffered for far too long under the imposition by which their earnings of one kind or another are completely open for inspection at all times by the Revenue Commissioners. Their most intimate and confidential sources of income are not only available to the Commisssioners but the workers are compelled to make them available, either themselves or their employers. Consequently, I have ample reason to complain of the discrimination, so to speak, that can be carried on under that sort of system in which one section of the community is treated in one way and another section in another. If for no other reason than that I question the desirability of opening yet another avenue for that sort of inquisition to the Revenue Commissioners.
I agree there should be an honest and fair return of turnovers handled by any of these marts. The Commissioners are entitled to ask for information and evidence to support it from time to time, but I am not prepared to say that an officer of the Minister should have all these powers, not alone to inspect, to enter and demand production of documents, but even, if necessary, to copy them. For what purpose? I am entitled to ask that question. I can only answer that there must be some ulterior motive in it. If it is not the motive Senator McAuliffe ascribes to it, what is the motive? Why must the Minister have all these powers?
For these reasons, if for no others, I think the amendment before the House is reasonable. It does not alter the effect of the legislation or cut it down or take away anything from the Minister. It simply obliges him to see that an assurance is given, as we require, that whatever information he collects in this way is not disclosed to the Revenue Commissioners. In dealing with this section of the community, I think this is a perfectly reasonable request.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. There is every justification for Senator McAuliffe's and other Senators' suspicions and fears which I think are well founded, despite what Senator O'Kennedy has said. Derating of agricultural land is a direct result of the Government's late awakening to the fact that the farmers are no longer able to pay rates at the level at which they have been called on to pay them.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald may not indulge in that discussion. The Senator will come to the amendment.
Comment on this
Not so long ago we had An Foras Tionscal warning all interested parties that there would be a severe reduction and set-back in the cattle industry towards the end of the year. For that piece of information, given with all good intention, we had Dr. J.G. Litton axed out of his job. Surely that is just one example of how far the Minister and the Government are prepared to go.
Comment on this
If the Minister and the Government do not want to impose additional taxation on the marts——
Comment on this
There is no question of taxation in this amendment. The Senator is going too far outside it.
Comment on this
If there is no ulterior motive behind this section, acceptance of the amendment should come easy to the Minister and he could give a clear indication of the Government's intention not to impose additional taxation on the farmers.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the section which says that the Minister shall not give appropriate information to the Revenue Commissioners. That is our complaint. There is no undertaking in this Bill that the information obtained by the Minister for Agriculture will not be made available to the Revenue Commissioners. The purpose of the amendment is to ensure that if the Minister wants this Bill for the reasons he has set out, he will give an undertaking that he is not trying to put through the Bill in order to obtain information useful to the Revenue Commissioners.
As Deputy Crowley has mentioned, the Bill says that the Minister may send down an officer to inspect documents and to take copies. I am sure several copies would be available. This section gives the Minister power to go to the marts and get the names and addresses of the customers. It gives him power to see the business transactions of the customers. It gives him power to see what the turnover of the marts has been. It gives him power to see how many cattle were sold by the marts on any day, month or year. We know that the banks, when dealing with the financial affairs of people, do not furnish information to the Revenue Commissioners, but here we have a Bill which permits a Minister to provide that information to the Revenue Commissioners, not only in respect of the business transactions of the marts but also the business transactions of the farmers and the customers who are doing business through the marts.
This Marts Bill will have very widespread effects so far as the farmers are concerned because it will enable their affairs to be found out through the marts where they sell their cattle. There is nothing in the Bill to stop the Minister from making that information available to the Revenue Commissioners. The Minister will also be asked many questions in the Dáil about the business transactions of the marts, and so far as I am concerned, he will be answerable to the Dáil. He will be required to give that information in the Dáil and this will go further towards prying into the affairs of the marts and their customers.
Comment on this
This amendment belongs to the class of amendments put down for one specific reason—to raise invented stories about what the Bill intends to do. The only purpose of putting down this amendment is to try to suggest to unintelligent ears that the Minister will use the Bill to tax the farmers and the marts.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley knows as well as I do that there is not a word of truth in that.
Comment on this
Senator Rooney would say anything that suited him for the moment. Senator O'Quigley sneered at what he called my habit of going back to 1920 for previous legislation. I will quote precedents every time Senators like Senator Rooney, Senator McDonald and Senator O'Quigley say that such and such a section has no precedent and that its intention is to do down the farmers. This section deals with inspections. There has never been an Act dealing with agricultural matters since 1924 that has not included a provision of this kind, even when the late Deputy Hogan was Minister——
Comment on this
There is a whole chain of Acts which are still in force with a provision exactly analogous to this. This applies not only to agriculture but to manufacturing industry. There is a vast mass of records that have to be made available to the inspectors of the various Departments, and there has never been any suggestion that they are used for any purpose other than the purpose immediately related to the legislation in question. This is fantastic and ludicrous, and if Senator Rooney does not know it, he should. There has never been any suggestion that any Department of State have betrayed their trust by giving information of this kind. The amendment was put down to suggest that the Bill would be used for some kind of skullduggery. There is not a word of truth in that suggestion and no one knows that better than Senator Rooney and Senator O'Quigley.
Comment on this
Senator Nash, Senator Yeats and Senator O'Kennedy have all indicated that in this amendment I am trying to do something new and something which implies that the officers of the Minister would be guilty of a breach of trust. We seem to have editorials as a matter of course now decrying the Minister for Agriculture. "Each new morn, new widows howl", like those in Macbeth. It was the Irish Times yesterday and the Cork Examiner today. They cannot all be wrong.
Comment on this
Senator Nash occupies a very special position in this Chamber because he is nominated by the Incorporated Law Society and elected to the Seanad on a cultural and educational panel by virtue of that nomination. When he speaks with such apparent authority on what the law is, one is inclined to regard him as being fairly accurate. One might take a different view of Senator yeats' researches into the law. Senator Nash said there never was such a provision as this in any other legislation. He now shakes his head in affirmation of that assertion. I took the first Book of Statutes I came across, the 1955 volume. I took the first volume and I will not look at any more. I have not got any civil servants or Taoiseach's nominees to do research for me. The Prices Act, 1958, was introduced by Deputy Seán Lemass. Section 24 reads:
An authorised officer may, for the purpose of obtaining any information which the Minister may require for enabling him to exercise his functions under this Act, do any one or more of the following things——
If Senators follow me they will find that subsection (1) of section 7 of this Bill is almost an exact parallel. Paragraph (a) of section 24 of the Prices Act reads:
... at all reasonable times enter premises at which any activity in connection with the business of manufacturing or processing or packaging or supplying or distributing commodities or in connection with the organisation or assistance of persons engaged in any such business is carried on, and inspect the premises——
Paragraph (b) reads:
require the person who carries on such activity and any person employed in connection therewith to produce to him any books, documents or records relating to such activity...
Paragraph (c) reads:
inspect and copy or take extracts from such books, documents or records—
Paragraph (d) reads:
require such person to give to him any information...
Let us turn to section 25 and see if Senator Nash is drawing the long bow.
Comment on this
Yesterday the Senator was looking for a quotation from the Minister for Education: "ceteris paribus we will look after our own.”
Comment on this
Section 25 of the Prices Act provides:
No person shall disclose information...
Comment on this
It is 23rd February, 1967, Official Report of Dáil Éireann. Look it up.
No person shall disclose information available to him by virtue of the powers of obtaining information conferred on him by this Act or through being present at a meeting of an Advisory Committee held in private.
Comment on this
I shall read it very slowly because the Senator is dull of perception today.
No person shall disclose information available to him by virtue of the powers of obtaining information conferred on him by this Act or through being present at a meeting of an Advisory Committee held in private.
Comment on this
That is the Prices Advisory Committee, a completely different thing altogether.
Comment on this
What I am talking about is subsection (1). Let Senator Nash not be so obtuse. He has been caught out redhanded and he is extremely obtuse if he is not prepared to admit he has been caught out.
Comment on this
Senator Yeats and Senator Nash have both been caught out. That is the first Act. I have no fleet of officials to do research for me, but there it is. That was very important because it was highly political. The issue involved was highly controversial. One can imagine Deputy Lemass, when he was putting this Bill through, expressing the Government's firm intention to control prices. Deputy Lemass felt he had done a very good job, I recollect, on the Report Stage of that Bill. It is interesting to note that was one of the Bills on which the Government were defeated in 1958. But that was Deputy Lemass's view. He was a businessman and he knew something about business secrets. That is my view.
Comment on this
Since I have civil servants who do research, and do it a great deal more successfully than the Senator, I shall quote. I will take the Fertilisers, Feeding Stuffs and Mineral Mixtures Act, 1955; by a strange coincidence the section is section 7.
Comment on this
I expect the provision is contained in all those Acts.
Comment on this
This is subsection (1):
Every person who carries on or is employed in connection with the business of manufacture, import or sale by wholesale or retail of any fertiliser, feeding stuff, compound feeding stuff or mineral mixture shall at all reasonable times—
(a) produce, at the request of an authorised officer, any books, documents or records relating to such business which are in the power, possession or procurement of such person, permit the authorised officer to inspect and take extracts from such books, documents or records and give to him any information which he may reasonably require with regard to any entries therein,
(b) afford to an authorised officer all reasonable facilities for the inspection, sampling and taking stock of any fertilisers, feeding stuffs, compound feeding stuffs or mineral mixtures....
I shall not go on with this. It runs into two pages. The first part is the really relevant part with regard to documents, records, inspection, the taking of copies, and so forth. That Act did not call for any research on the part of the Senator because we had already given the reference several times in the course of these discussions.
We have then the Seed Production Act, 1955. Subsection (1) of section 17 of that Act provides:
An inspector may at all reasonable times enter and inspect any premises in which he has reasonable grounds for believing that seeds to which this Part applies are kept and may examine and take samples of any such seeds which he finds in the premises.
Subsection (b) provides:
The inspector may request the person in charge of the premises to give him the name and address of the person from whom the seeds found in the premises were obtained.
Section 18, subsection (1) provides:
The licensee shall keep such records as may be prescribed and shall from time to time make the appropriate entries in the records.
And subsection (2) provides:
Every record kept in pursuance of this section may be inspected at all reasonable times by an inspector.
Subsection (3) provides:
The licensee shall produce for the inspection of the inspector on request the record and also the invoices, consignment notes, receipts and other documents (including copies where originals are not available) reasonably requested by the inspector for the purpose of verifying any entry in or explaining any omission from the record.
We come then to the Factories Act of 1955. It was a funny year anyhow. We had a Coalition Government.
Comment on this
Section 94, subsection (1) provides:
An inspector shall, for the purposes of the execution of this Act, have power to do all or any of the following things, that is to say—
(a) to enter, inspect and examine at all reasonable times, by day and night, a factory, and every part thereof, when he has reasonable cause to believe that any person is employed therein, and to enter by day any place which he has reasonable cause to believe to be a factory and any part of any building of which a factory forms part and in which he has reasonable cause to believe that explosive or highly inflammable materials are stored or used;
(b) to take with him a member of the Garda Síochána if he has reasonable cause to apprehend any serious obstruction in the execution of his duty.
That is worth recording because there was a similar subsection in this Bill and I took it out by amendment, believing it was no longer necessary, unlike the people who produced that Act in 1955. These may not be strictly related, though the Seed Production Act and the Fertilisers, Feeding Stuffs and Mineral Mixtures Act are directly related to agriculture. The Creamery Act, 1928, surely parallels what we are doing now. In section 15 (1) there is the provision:
Every person in charge of a creamery within the meaning of this Act shall, upon being so required for the purposes of this Act by an officer of the Department, produce to such officer all records, books and other documents in his custody relating to such creamery and permit such inspector to examine and take copies of or extracts from the same.
That power has been there since 1928. There were no amendments. No amendment on the lines of the amendment proposed here was ever thought to be required. On no occasion since 1928 has there been any request to that effect by any Member of either House of the Oireachtas. To my knowledge, no attempt was ever made to have inserted in that Act an amendment similar to the amendment before the House now. That Act has been in operation since 1928 and its operation has been quite successful in relation to the inspection of records, the taking of copies, and so on and so forth. There has never been a single complaint by anybody. There has never been objection raised, such as Senators who have spoken against the section as it stands suggest will occur if the amendment they now propose is not accepted. Surely the commonsense of the Senators who have made the case for this amendment, and against the section as it stands, will now dictate to them the wisdom of their seeing the light and not insisting on this unnecessary amendment going into this Bill.
May I take the opportunity on the amendment to say that not only is it not necessary but it has been clearly demonstrated over the years that it is unnecessary. I wish to go on record as saying without any equivocation, to allay any suspicions that may have been raised by the sort of talk we have listened to, that there is no danger whatsoever and there is not the slightest possibility that any of the records, documents or information ascertained by or on behalf of the Minister now or in the future would be used other than for the purpose of this particular Act. In saying that, I am not making any big offering to anybody. I am merely indicating my belief in conforming to that which has been established over years of practice and experience and, as has been very wisely stated by Senator Yeats, if we were to undermine in any way the good faith of the people with whom we deal in regard to these matters, then all the laws and all the rest we may lay down would be of scant use in so far as keeping of records would be concerned because if, for any reason, these people should be led to the belief by false propaganda or otherwise that we were going to misuse our information; then they would know from the kickoff that the Bill was not in the interests of their industry and they would also know that it would pay them not to give us the true records and to try to deceive us.
This is surely what the Senators of the Opposition are trying to induce people to do. They are trying to induce people who are running a straight, honest business, by fear of what they promise tomorrow which will never arise, to bring them around to being dishonest people and keep dishonest books. This is really what is being sponsored here by Fine Gael and it is not the only place they have sponsored it. They started this down in Galway about four weeks ago. A rumour went around, got some publicity—as naturally other things can get publicity, not necessarily in editorials. When news is scarce they have to fill up with something. We have the knowledge that this was fostered by those who are not necessarily interested in the marts or their well-being but who are anti-Fianna Fáil and are trying to make trouble. Five or six weeks ago it was started. It was published. There is always some hack around who will pick up a thing and publish it provided it is anti-Fianna Fáil.
It was published and it arose from a statement made in Galway. I have promised—and I kept that promise in the Dáil—the Marts Association that I would, in speaking to the two Houses, take the opportunity to make special mention of this particular matter so as to dispel the rumours that have been put about and which have been propagated here today and to say that there is no question of the information to be got under this section being used for any purpose other than the operation of this Bill. I want to say that again to re-emphasise it to keep faith with those whom I told that I would do this who, let us be fair to them, did not themselves on their own admission believe the rumours because the people whom I was talking to are members of the IAOS, of the co-operative movement throughout the country who have had experience as nobody else had of the operation of the Creameries Act since 1924 and 1928 which I have just now quoted and they know that these rumours are completely unfounded; that there is no case that can be shown where complaint ever was made or any well-founded suggestion ever could be made as to abuse of the power under the 1928 Creameries Act. They merely wished for what I am now doing, giving public utterance by way of assurance that the rumours are just rumours without any basis in fact whatsoever so that people might not be misled by false pictures painted here or elsewhere.
Comment on this
The very simplest way of dispelling the rumours is to incorporate this amendment in the Bill. Then there will be no doubt at all about it. When the Minister was talking about the 1928 and the 1958 Acts, I thought he was going to say that there was no provision in those Acts such as has been in the Prices Act of 1958 but he did not do that and I have not the time nor the inclination to do the research to see whether they are there or not. As regards his assurances, I remember a very solemn assurance given by a former Taoiseach, Éamon de Valera, in Belmullet in 1961 that they would not remove the food subsidies and they were not in office six months when they did.
Comment on this
By reason of the quotation of the Prices Act of 1958 I must intervene to reiterate what I said already, that there is no single piece of legislation in this country and I challenge anybody to produce it, where information has to be furnished to a Government Department for the purpose of carrying out the terms of an Act where it is provided that that Department will not disclose it to anybody else.
Comment on this
The 1958 Act is not at all relevant. It is a Prices Act in which provision is made to have a tribunal of people other than civil servants hearing evidence.
Comment on this
Those people are getting secret information about everybody's business who appears before them and gives evidence. I reiterate again that there is no single instance where information has to be given to a Government Department for the purposes of effectively carrying an Act into effect where there is a proviso that that Government Department will keep it secret. The reason is that it is an accepted tradition in the Civil Service with a very, very binding force that no Government Department will, in any circumstances disclose to any other Government Department information which they get for the purpose of discharging their duties. To introduce into this measure an amendment such as suggested would mean that now that tradition is to be departed from; that it is to be observed where you have an Act of Parliament but not to be observed where you have not an Act of Parliament. Such suggestion would undermine the whole confidence in the Civil Service.
Comment on this
Question put: "That leave be given to withdraw amendment No. 42".
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 60:
In subsection (4), line 46, to delete "if so required".
The amendment is designed to ensure that any officer or inspector of the Department of Agriculture or the particular officers the Minister proposes to appoint will be able to walk into any established cattle mart and openly to go about their business. Seeing that they will be there now, there is no reason why they should not cultivate good relations between the mart-owners and the farming community, and walk in and produce their cards so that everybody will know who they are, their duties and what they are there for. There is no reason why the Minister should inflict an additional body of spies on the farmers. He can require them to produce their identity documents when they go into these places and so give these people a better chance of doing their work in harmony and perhaps it will lead to co-operattion.
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I want to draw attention to the powers that have been given in this section to an officer of the Minister. Among the powers are those set out in subsection (1): (a) to enter, and inspect the place, and (b) to require the production of any documents and to inspect, examine and copy any of them. We had a fairly lengthy and somewhat acrimonious debate on the simple amendment I put down to provide that there should be no disclosure of information. In the course of that debate, both Senators Yeats and Nash threw out a challenge —and there is nothing I like better than answering a challenge and doing that single-handed without the aid of civil servants or anything else——
Comment on this
I have the Library in Leinster House the same as any other Senator.
Comment on this
Senator Nash threw out a challenge. I am sorry he is not in the House now to hear what I have to say. He said that all the statistics collected and all the returns to any Department of State are generally, without any obligation on them, not to be disclosed. He said there was no analogous provision in the statutes relating to these officers. One minute's research provides a complete answer to the challenge and shows how reckless Senator Nash is, and he has put himself in the position where nobody will trust his opinion as to what the law is ever again.
The Statistics Act, 1926, provides that the Minister may collect, compile, abstract and publish statistics relating to any matter affecting the general economic and other activities and conditions in Saorstát Éireann and in particular all or any of the following matters: (b) vital, social and educational matters; (d) employment and unemployment; (e) emigration and immigration; (f) agriculture; (h) industry; (i) commerce; (j) banking, insurance and finance. That is subsection (2). Section 14 provides:
Save for the purpose of a prosecution for an offence under this Act, no officer of statistics shall publish or disclose to any person, other than another officer of statistics concerned with the matter in the course of his duties as such officer the contents or any part of the contents or any individual schedule, form, or other document filled in or otherwise completed by any person in pursuance of a requisition made under this Act or the contents or any part of the contents of any record or document (not being a record or document open to public inspection) which was inspected or of which a copy was taken or obtained by an officer of statistics in exercise of any power in that behalf conferred on him by this Act or any valuable information or answer given relating to any individual person, business or concern.
Subsection (2) of that section says:
Every officer of statistics who shall publish or disclose the contents or any part of the contents of any such individual schedule, form, or other document as aforesaid or any such record or document as aforesaid or any verbal information or answer given relating to any individual person, business or concern in contravention of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds or,... to imprisonment...
Now, will Senator Nash have the grace to admit that he was recklessly wrong in what he said—recklessly wrong? He has put himself outside the pale of being heard by anybody at all in this matter. All the statistics and all the information that are collected for any Department of State are collected under this Act and there is an absolute prohibition on disclosure. I do not want to make it an offence for a civil servant concerned or a particular health authority. I merely want to provide that what applies to industry, and prohibition on what applies to industrial procedure, as provided in Lemass's Prices Act, 1958 should also apply to the Livestock Marts Bill, 1967, and so on.
Comment on this
I have not intervened in this debate up to now but I find I am compelled to speak. I am sick and tired of listening to Senator O'Quigley using one phrase all through these six days whenever he got the opportunity. He strikes me as being a distinct example of what Myles na gCopaleen described as "The Béal Bocht." We hear him whining that he did not have civil servants or people to engage in the necessary research. I want to know whether it is not a fact that the Fine Gael Party enjoy some thousands of pounds of the taxpayers' money voted by the Dáil each year for the purpose of secretarial assistance and research. If they get that money which the finance accounts and the Accountant-General verifie they get, what are they doing with it? If Senator O'Quigley cannot get secretarial assistance, cannot get assistance to dig out the research, what is happening to the money? I think it is time we had an inquiry into that.
Comment on this
We do not get nearly enough money for the purposes for which the money is supposed to be devoted. A great deal is devoted to the kind of research necessary for the formulation of policy documents which have to be produced.
Comment on this
I am distressed about this obviously quite appalling waste of taxpayers' money.
Comment on this
Will Senator McDonald please let Senator Yeats continue?
Comment on this
All I want to say about these two alleged analogies that Senator O'Quigley has produced is that really one would despair of seeing any rhyme or reason in anything Senator O'Quigley says in regard to legislation of this kind. First of all, the Prices Act is no analogy. That Act relates, amongst other things, to people who are not civil servants, who would not in the absence of such a provision in the Act be under any restriction with regard to the publication of confidential material. It is essential to have a clause of that kind in that Act in order to deal with persons who are not civil servants.
The Statistics Act now produced by Senator O'Quigley has no relation at all to the matter in hand. That is an Act relating to the publication to the country at large of information that is collected. Since it gives a blanket power to publish everything that is collected, obviously there has to be such a section dealing with that. It has no relation to the type of legislation with which we are dealing.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the proposed paragraph be there added."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 61:
To delete subsection (2).
Subsection (2) deals with the position of companies and unincorporated bodies of persons. It seems to me it is throwing too great a risk of being found guilty of an offence on persons who may be merely clerks or servants with no discretion or say in the running of the company or committee. It is going that bit too far to bring them within the penal section of the Bill and, for that reason, the subsection should be deleted. In regard to corporations or unincorporated bodies, section 11 of the 1937 Interpretation Act, paragraph (i) and paragraph (c), already has brought them within the provisions of the Act and we propose that the subsection be deleted.
Comment on this
Oh, yes.
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In subsection (3) (a), lines 19 and 20 to delete "one hundred" and substitute "ten".
This is one of a group of amendments the purpose of which is to bring down the maximum fines and penalties in all cases to more realistic figures. We have seen in the past few months farmers getting maximum jail sentences and maximum fines for technical offences. For that reason we feel the penalties set out in the subsection are excessive. Members will recall that not so long ago there were almost 100 farmers serving three months in penitentiaries for little more than a parking offence.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister not to discriminate further against the farming community. I ask him to reduce these rather heavy fines down to something in keeping with every day court practice.
Comment on this
I will give the Senator cases of personal hardship as the result of the trivial offences he has spoken of. Would he like me to do so?
Comment on this
There were injuries to health and life as a result of these technical offences. I will give the Senator some examples if he wants them.
Comment on this
At the same time as these farmers were serving long terms in prison, we find people in this city not being brought to justice for attacks on the person.
Comment on this
The entire forces of the State were set on this much maligned section of the community. There is no comparison between the fines and punishment the Minister proposes to impose under this section and those usually imposed. For instance, in subsection (3) (a), the Minister proposes a fine of £100. Any reasonable-minded person will agree this is excessive, taken in conjunction with the continuing fine of £10 a day. I ask the Minister to have second thoughts. The section of people we are dealing with always have been law-abiding.
Comment on this
It is most unfair either to jail them for long periods or to impose these heavy fines.
Comment on this
I should like to tell the Senator that his idea of a technical offence is most extraordinary. Before asking him a question, I should like to express my astonishment that on top of attacking the courts, on top of attacking the manner in which the Garda Síochána carry out their work for the protection of life and property in this city——
Comment on this
He spoke about the unsatisfactory manner in which the enforcement of law and order was being carried out in this city. More than anything, what I want to get from him is his explanation of these comparatively minor technical offences he spoke about. The technical offences I know about, which many of these criminals he is pleading on behalf of committed, occurred when bunches of hoodlums did not alone damage to life and property but also prevented clergymen—I emphasise "clergymen"—from rendering the Last Rites. There is a particular case I have in mind. If we are so polite that we are afraid to mention hoodlums or call a spade a spade, Senator McDonald can proceed to tell us more about these technical offences, or he can go on assuming that the people will believe his description of these offences. Many of the people shown leniency by the Government refused to accept it and the only thing asked for in return was that these people would recognise the laws enacted by the people through constitutional means.
Comment on this
I take it, then, the farmers cannot expect leniency from the Minister or from Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
That is another example of what somebody described as the planted lie. Say it often enough, shout it loud enough——
Comment on this
Will Senator Rooney keep quiet and allow Senator McDonald to proceed on the amendment?
Comment on this
I should like to put the position that will obtain under these subsections clearly and distinctly so that Senator McDonald can understand it. We in Fianna Fáil have always believed in the courts of this country. The Minister is not, as Senator McDonald suggests, meting out terms of imprisonment or fines in this Bill. He is doing nothing of the kind. That is a matter for the courts. Unlike the situation that arose recently in this country with certain elements, including Fine Gael, we in Fianna Fáil believe that matters of this kind are for the courts. The penalty inflicted by the court is a matter for the court: it is not a matter for the Government. If, under this Bill, a fine of £100, or any other sum, is meted out by a court, it is not because the Minister thinks it should be so but because the court has decided, in its wisdom, that the offence warrants that fine. That is the point. It has nothing to do with the Minister. Everything the Senator has said is designed, apparently, to upset the whole idea of the courts fixing penalties. No court will fix a penalty for a particular offence, be it a trivial or an important offence, except on the basis that the penalty they are inflicting is in accordance with the gravity of the offence committed.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the new subsection be there added".
Do you agree with this result?
Might I intervene on a point of order? I understand that in my absence, Senator O'Quigley again saw fit to make an attack upon me.
Comment on this
I referred to the Statistics Acts, of which there are two, one in 1926 and one in 1946, and I take it that it was to the Statistics Act, 1926 he referred.
Comment on this
I take it that it is a point of explanation. I want to know what it is.
Comment on this
I want to justify what I said. I understand that Senator O'Quigley made an attack, not only on the accuracy of what I said but on my integrity in stating——
Comment on this
The Senator may raise this on another occasion. It may not be raised now.
Comment on this
I suggest the Senator consider raising it at the next sitting.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In subsection (3) (a), line 21, to delete "ten" and substitute "three".
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 64, and with it we can take No. 67. Separate decisions may be had, if necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In subsection (3) (a), to delete lines 23 to 25 inclusive.
The purpose of these two amendments is quite simple. At matters stand now, the fine that will be imposed will be one of £100 and there is provision for a further fine not exceeding £10 per day for every day during which the offence continues. In paragraph (b) there is provision for a fine of £500 and a fine of £50 per day in respect of continuing offences. It seems to me that these large fines are all designed to create the impression that terrible offences are going to be committed by livestock mart owners and also by people buying or selling in livestock marts. They come within the penal clause of subsection (1) of this section. It is going to be suggested that they are all engaged in terrible crimes that merit heavy penalties of £100 and £10 a day. I do not think for a moment that there ought be any question of a term of imprisonment together with these penalties. If fines of that kind are imposed, or are to be imposed, for every day the offence is continued, no business or individual could continue as they would be paying what would amount to a daily rental of £10, or in the case of a company or unincorporated body, a daily rental of £50. I know of no business that could stand up to that and therefore if these fines are to be imposed, they would seem to be sufficient without providing also for stretches of imprisonment.
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In subsection (3) (b), line 27, to delete "five" and substitute "one".
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In subsection (3) (b), line 29, to delete "fifty" and substitute "five".
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:
In subsection (3) (b) to delete all words from and including "or" in line 30 to the end of the paragraph.
Amendment put and declared negatived.
Comment on this
There is just one matter which intrigues me. I want to ask the Minister in what particular set of circumstances a person will be tried on indictment, as provided in paragraph (b). It is a matter of information—what will determine whether there will be a summary trial or a trial on indictment?
Comment on this
The accepted procedure in criminal law will decide it.
Comment on this
Not being very learned, but trying to appear to be commonsense; to be punctilious, as you were not when you misquoted an Act of Parliament, the introduction to which set out the actual position regarding that Act.
Comment on this
I can understand density, but not duplicity; prejudice, but not prevarication.
Comment on this
The Senator will have an opportunity of dealing with that. I am entirely correct.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the new subsection be there inserted".
Do you agree with this result?
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".
Do you agree with this result?
In view of the minute examination which this measure has got on Second Stage and in Committee and in order to save Members from the possibility of having to spend time here next week, I thought it might commend itself to the House if we were to take the remaining Stages now.
Comment on this
I think the Leader of the House has misinterpreted the feeling of the House. We shall not give the Report and Final Stages now.
Comment on this
It would be most unjust to ask us to deal with Report Stage now. It is possible that some amendments will be put down, and people need some time to think over the amendments and put them down, if they so desire.
Comment on this
I have not the slightest desire to curb the discussion. Since Senators have given such a detailed examination to the Bill, it looked to me as if everyone had gone far enough with it. I thought it might commend itself to the Seanad and that Senators would like to do the job now.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might make a counter-proposition. As there does not appear to be any great urgency about the Bill, and in view of the fact that the Minister has indicated that he may not make regulations at all, if upon examination it becomes apparent that it might be too difficult or too unwieldy, Report Stage of the Bill could be taken next October. That would facilitate the staff of the House and it would facilitate Members of the House, too, whose interests do not concern me as much as those of people who have no say in having their holidays disrupted.
Comment on this
I was sincere in suggesting that we take Report Stage now, but in view of the fact that Senator O'Quigley has become facetious and made a suggestion about October, to accommodate Members from the country, and in view of the fact that next Monday is a Bank Holiday, I suggest we take Report and Final Stages next Wednesday at 3 p.m.
Comment on this
That is not agreed and I want to give a reason. We should be afforded the normal facility of having the Report of this debate before us so that we can get a consensus of opinion from various sides of the House in relation to certain amendments. Some amendments commended themselves to people on the other side af the House, and we cannot frame amendments for Report Stage without having the Report of the debates before us. That will not be available by next Wednesday. Also in view of the fact that next Monday is a bank holiday, to suggest that we meet next Wednesday is tantamount to exercising a guillotine.
Comment on this
It is time to call a spade a spade. Senator O'Quigley knows very well that on the Second Stage of this Bill we had a very long and representative debate and also on Committee Stage, so there is no question of a guillotine.
Comment on this
The only motion before the House is that the Seanad adjourn until next Wednesday at 3 p.m. to take Report Stage.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?