We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–169 of 357. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

I do not believe that the Bill will last too long if we are to depend on the speakers from the other side of the House. They have been shy to intervene so far. That does not surprise me since it is very hard to find arguments in favour of abolishing proportional representation.

Comment on this

The Senator will be agreeably surprised.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that the Senators opposite intend to put forward some arguments. In 1958 we had a referendum to see if PR should be abolished. Seeing that the proposition was defeated in the past ten years, I think it should not have come up in the time of the present generation. If PR could be abolished in 1958, the Fianna Fáil Party then had the best opportunity ever. There was also a Presidential election that year, and despite the fact that the Fianna Fáil nominee was elected President, the people showed great intelligence and maturity by rejecting the proposal to abolish PR.

In my opinion, PR as a system of election has served the country well. At present the Fianna Fáil Party have an overall majority and there is nothing to prevent them from doing anything that would be to the advantage of the people; yet on 28th June, 1968, there were 53,341 people unemployed against 48,355 in the corresponding week last year. That in itself shows the Government are wasting too much time introducing legislation such as we are dealing with now and forgetting about the needs of the people. Our housing situation is deplorable and our roads, especially in the vicinity of the city of Dublin, leading to the north, west and south, are substandard. The death rate is going up, and the Minister for Local Government took 25 per cent off our grants last year. Unless we bring our roads up to standard, we shall continue to have a high death rate on the roads.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this related to the discussion? Can we discuss our foreign affairs policy and everything else on this measure?

Comment on this

I am hoping the Senator will come to the matters of the Bill presently.

Comment on this

It will not speed things up if I have to deal with roads and housing as well.

Comment on this

There was no argument put forward so far for the abolition of PR that impressed anyone. Three Cabinet Ministers have stated that the straight vote will improve the standard of the candidates, and the Fianna Fáil backbenchers are asking what is wrong with them as public representatives. They claim they have the confidence of the electorate. What qualities does the Minister expect in candidates under the straight vote system? Must they belong to the small man group that was once described as the backbone of Fianna Fáil? Or must they be lawyers, barristers or university graduates? Or must they come from the aristocracy or the new rich, members of Taca? I should like to hear the Minister explain to the House what type of candidate he expects to get under the straight vote. If he wants a short answer to that question, I can tell him that the best candidate he can get is the vote catcher. Candidates will not come into this House unless they are capable of collecting votes.

There is no chance of getting rid of PR. Fianna Fáil themselves are divided on the matter, and there is no teamwork. The Third Amendment will also be defeated as it is a clear indication that the Government have failed to keep the people on the farms and in the rural areas. A falling population in those areas has created a problem as regards the siting of the constituencies. Perhaps if the Government had brought in the tolerance amendment to the Constitution, it would have had some chance, but with the two amendments together, the answer will be "no" in both cases.

I am certainly against the straight vote. I do not want to see here the system of election that exists in Northern Ireland and in Britain. We all know that a very large percentage of the people who are returned to Parliament in Northern Ireland have not contested an election for years. That is not a healthy sign.

If the Government succeed in getting rid of PR, it will be a very interesting game of draughts, seeing where the different candidates will go forward. The strong ones will avoid other strong ones and try to find weak ones to oppose.

We in the Labour Party have no desire to prolong this discussion. We want the Bill to go through, because it will go through whether we like it or not. There will be no amendments here today, nor on Committee or Report Stages. By weight of numbers the Bill will be passed through this House, and the sooner the better so that the people can decide whether the Government are right or wrong.

Comment on this

One of the arguments we have heard in dealing with this Bill is that there has been no demand for these proposals. This is sometimes blown up to such an extent that it sounds like a real argument. We are given the impression that unless a Bill has been demanded by demonstrations, by protest marches, and so on, we should not introduce a Bill into this House. As everybody in the House knows, 99 Bills out of 100 are introduced without any tangible form of demand, without any kind of protest, demonstration or petition. The suggestion that there is no demand for this legislation is ridiculous and should not be given any regard whatever.

In fact, there was quite a demand for both of the proposals which are before us. Take, first of all, the proposal in the Third Amendment. There was a very definite demand by all Parties in 1959, when the revision of constituencies was introduced, for the kind of variation, the tolerance, that is proposed now. The Parties demanded and approved of the proposals in that Bill. That is certainly an indication that there is a demand for tolerance of the kind proposed. When the constituencies were again revised in accordance with the High Court decision, and when the Dáil saw the kind of constituencies they were going to have, there were many protests made from all Parties at that time against the kind of constituencies that were resulting, and that can certainly be construed as a demand for the tolerance proposed in this Bill. If this Bill is not passed, and if the amendment to the Constitution is not passed, and if the constituencies are then revised according to the present tenets of the Constitution, when the kind of constituencies we will have are seen, there will then be a great demand for the alteration of the system, but by that time it would be too late to do anything about it.

In looking at the proposal made in the Third Amendment Bill, we have to look and see what is the extent of the amendment. To what extent is it departing from what we had in the past? To what extent is it departing from the wording of the previous Constitutions? The Constitution says that the number of population in each of the constituencies "shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same". The 1922 Constitution, it is significant to note, said that so far as possible it should be the same. That, of course, was a much more extreme and strict wording. There is an indication in the present Constitution that this test should not be interpreted as strictly as in the 1922 Constitution.

In the Bill we are considering it is proposed to interpret the phrase, "so far as it is practicable" in the way in which it was intended when the Constitution was introduced, and not in the way in which it was interpreted by a High Court judge. He was, of course, quite entitled to and justified in interpreting it as he thought fit. I think it is generally agreed that this was not the intention of the Legislature or the people when this phrase was originally used. The word "practicable" could be very widely interpreted and that is why it is necessary to spell out exactly what is intended by that word, so that there can be no ambiguity or misunderstanding as to what is intended in the future.

The word "practicable" was interpreted by the Dáil in one way in 1959, and by a judge of the High Court in another way a short time afterwards. The significant fact is that both parties agreed that it meant that there should be some tolerance. Both the Legislature and the High Court agreed it meant that there should be some tolerance. The judge of the High Court said there should be reasonable latitude in interpreting "so far as it is practicable". It is a matter of applying commonsense to see how far you can go to meet the practical problems which will have to be met in trying to draw up the constituencies. It is quite absurd, in my opinion, to have the parrot-like cries we have had about one man, one vote, as though that were to be interpreted in a strict mathematical sense.

It cannot seriously be proposed that you could draw up constituencies which would have exactly the same number of population, or the same number of electors. Even if the impossible were done and you had 144 constituencies or 40 constituencies, according to whether we have the PR system or the single-seat system, with exactly the same number of constituents, by the time it was printed it would be invalidated because of deaths and movements of population. We have to realise that any scheme to arrange the constituencies must be drawn up in a practical way, and that the number in the constituencies must be exactly the same only in so far as it is practicable.

The Bill before us provides for tolerance and for deviation having regard to the extent and the accessibility of the constituencies, having regard to what would be convenient areas of representation, and having regard to the avoidance of overlapping county boroughs. These are aims which everyone would agree are worth considering even though they might have other reasons for opposing the Bill. They are aims which, if fulfilled, will make for more convenient constituencies and which will make the electoral system work better. They are a commonsense approach to a difficult problem, and a commonsense approach to the aspects of our political life which need a commonsense approach. There is no need for an attitude of trying to arrive at mathematical precision which would be quite impractical.

Everyone must admit that there are problems which are being dealt with by this Bill. It would be futile to pretend that these problems do not exist. No one can deny that in the constituencies in the more thinly populated parts of the country, it is more difficult for the constituents to get in touch with their Deputy. No one can deny that in most cases the constituents in the thinly populated parts of the country are more in need of seeing their Deputy more often than the constituents in the city constituencies. I do not think that anyone, whatever his reasons for opposing this Bill might be, would deny that this problem exists, and that it would be met by this Bill. It is certainly true to say that a Deputy who had to deal with a constituency, parts of which were in two or three different counties, would have a problem. He might have to consult three different county councils possibly. He would have an almost impossible task.

If we have a constituency—as inevitably we will have unless this amendment is passed—parts of which are in two or three different counties, and which will have to be administered from the electorate's point of view by two or three different county councils, this will present very real problems and difficulties. These are not difficulties which are being made up for the purpose of having this Bill passed. Any fairminded person who is familiar with the electoral system, familiar with how elections are administered and fought, familiar with the problems of Deputies in constituencies, must admit that these problems exist and could be met by the proposals in this Bill. In my view, the arguments in favour of having a certain amount of tolerance so as to permit a solution, or even a partial solution, of this problem are more than outweighed by the arguments which have been made against introducing this amendment of the Constitution.

It has been suggested that this amendment—suggested, sometimes, in very intemperate language—is undemocratic, that it will lead to gerrymandering, that it will lead to various kinds of abuses. It is very difficult to take this kind of criticism seriously, having regard to the fact that the 1959 Bill was supported by all Parties in the Dáil. The Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party agreed and approved of the 1959 Bill when it was going through the Dáil. That Bill, in fact, provided for far more tolerance than is suggested by the present Bill. Therefore, if this Bill is undemocratic and is liable to lead to abuses, then certainly Fine Gael and Labour and the other Members of the Dáil were very remiss in 1959 in approving of the Bill that was going through at that time and, in fact, have been guilty at that time of everything that Fianna Fáil are being accused of at the present time.

It is suggested that the present system of allowing tolerance of constituencies will permit of gerrymandering. This, in theory, of course, is so: in theory, it could be done. In practice, however, it is different. Anybody who studies the Bill, who looks at it in a reasonable way, must realise that the areas will, in the first case, almost always be circumscribed by county boundaries and by other natural boundaries: the constituencies will normally fall into some natural area. When that is realised, I think it will be conceded that the possibility of gerrymandering is so remote as to be of no practical significance—quite apart from the fact that it would take a very clever person indeed to pick out an area in any part of this country and to say that this area, if made in this way, would suit Fianna Fáil or, if made in that way, would suit Fine Gael, or something like that. The extent to which that could be done, having regard to the fact that county boundaries will have to be respected as far as possible, is very insignificant, I understand.

It is very easy to throw out such a suggestion: it sounds great. You can throw it out, mention Northern Ireland as a footnote and then leave that point and go on to the next subject without substantiating your suggestion in any detail or making any attempt to show how or where it could be done. The suggestion can be left there, leaving a bad smell behind it, without your trying to prove it in any way. If that is the best argument that can be made against this Bill, then there should be no trouble in piloting it through this House.

The deviation tolerance proposed in this Bill is the minimum necessary to provide for widespread breaching of boundaries. It is not sufficient to do that entirely because, to do that entirely, would require a tolerance of something like 30 per cent. What is being done will avoid the breaching of boundaries in the majority of cases. We must always have regard not merely to the position at the moment but to the position that will arise if this amendment is not passed. Unless it is passed, there will probably not be a single county in the country which will be intact when the revision takes place.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald says it is nonsense. I am sure he has figures to suggest why it is nonsense. Whether they can stand up to examination is another matter. There will scarcely be a county in the whole country which will be intact unless this amendment is passed.

Comment on this

One—only one.

Comment on this

Therefore, it is legitimate to pass this Bill, the purpose of which is to introduce a system which will save us and protect the country from having virtually every single county carved up under the present provisions of the Constitution. No consideration of the question of tolerance, of one man, one vote, is complete without emphasising that the Constitution is dealing with population, not with electorate. Consequently, when we talk about the number under the Constitution at the moment—not less than 20,000 or more than 30,000—we talk about population: we are not talking about electorate. When the proportion of the electorate in each constituency is examined, it will be found that this has a very definite and a very important bearing on any argument that may be made about having one man, one vote. It will be found that, if one really wants to attempt to abide by the principle of one man, one vote, some adjustment will have to be provided for because there are significantly different proportions of electors in the various constituencies. The proportion varies very widely in the constituencies.

There are approximately 60 voters for each 100 members of the population in the country but this varies because of different age groups in different constituencies. The bigger cities have a very large floating population—people in hospitals, in hotels, in educational institutions, and so on— and this makes a very significant difference in the number who vote in any particular constituency as compared with the population in that constituency.

Let me give on example: there are many of them. In South-West Donegal, 67 per cent of the population are electors, whereas, in Dublin North-West, only 51 per cent of the population are electors. This means, in practical terms, that it takes 13,567 voters to elect a Teachta Dála in Donegal whereas it takes only 10,204 voters to elect a Teachta Dála in Dublin. Looking at that position and having regard to the proportion of electors, as things stand at the moment, we realise we have not the position of one man, one vote as between, for instance, these two constituencies. In these circumstances, it is quite legitimate and only proper and just to try to have some difference between city constituencies and country constituencies to redress this balance and to provide that it will require something in or about the same number of electors to elect a Teachta Dála in a city constituency as in a remote rural constituency.

Comment on this

What about the——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Éist, a leanbh.

Comment on this

I am sure Senator Quinlan will have hours and hours to make his speech. If you adopt the tolerance provided for in this Bill, the position in the two counties I have mentioned would be—and this is taking the tolerance at its most extreme—that it would take 11,305 electors in Donegal and 11,907 electors in Dublin, so that the tolerance suggested would in fact give you a position where the number of voters required is as near as practicable to being equal in a city constituency and in a country constituency, that is, if you adopt the tolerance suggested in the Bill. If you do not do so, and I must emphasise this, the position you are going to have is that it will take 13,569 in Donegal as against 10,204 in Dublin South-West. That means that it takes more than 30 per cent extra to elect a TD in Donegal. That is not by any stretch of the imagination complying with the principle of one man, one vote. That is the position you will have unless you do something about it.

Again, we are dealing with the tolerance as though it were something quite new, as though we were introducing some quite unusual and new feature into the electoral system. This of course is not true. Even though it may not have been widely known, even though people may not have given much attention to it until recently, in all the revisions of constituencies which have been made since 1922, there were very considerable tolerances as between the various constituencies. Between 1922 and up to the present Constitution, the tolerance that existed existed, in spite of the fact that the wording of the 1922 Constitution was much stricter than the wording in the present Constitution. As I mentioned, this tolerance not only is something which has always existed, but when the 1959 Bill was being examined by the High Court, it was agreed by the judge that some tolerance was inevitable and that a reasonable latitude would have to be allowed. The tolerance allowed in the Bill which he was considering was very much greater than is being provided for now.

I should mention also that one recommendation of the Committee on the Constitution which reported recently, and which was comprised of all Parties, was that there should be a tolerance of some 17,500 to 22,500, which is only very slightly less than the tolerance suggested in this Bill. Therefore, it would be idle to pretend that in suggesting the tolerance proposed in this Bill, anything is being done which is unusual or which is new, or that anything is being done which has not been tacitly, if not openly, agreed and approved by all Parties in the past. The system of tolerances is not, of course, by any means confined to this country. The Constitution of Denmark provides that when electoral areas are being arranged, account should be taken not only of the number of inhabitants but of the number of electors and the density of population. I mentioned the number of electors a short time ago. It is not merely a question of population, for regard must be had to the number of electors.

Under the Constitution of Norway, specific numbers of Parliamentary representatives are alloted to named provinces and cities. In Sweden since 1953, it has been provided that each province must have a minimum parliamentary representation regardless of population. Again, this is something on the lines of what we are proposing to ensure that the western sparsely-populated counties, in spite of the fall in population, should be represented by a minimum number of Deputies. The electoral law of Great Britain specifically allows higher representation for rural areas. The number of persons required to elect a Member of Parliament in a remote single-member constituency in Scotland, for example, may be one-third of that required in the case of an industrial single-member constituency in England. Over the whole of Great Britain, the average rural vote has been estimated to be worth about eight per cent more than the average urban vote.

In Australia, the Boundary Commissioners in each State are required by law to take into account the community of territorial interests, economic, social and regional, means of communication, population trends, density of population, physical features and existing boundaries. The electorate of each constituency must not be greater or less than the quota by more than one-fifth. In the Bill before us, it is not more than one-sixth, which is less than Australia. In Canada and New Zealand, care has been taken in framing the electoral laws to ensure that factors other than population are taken into account and to prevent representation for specified territorial areas from falling below certain levels. Recent legislation in Canada allows even greater scope than the Australian system, the population tolerance being 25 per cent of the quota for each province. In Germany, the tolerance is 33? and in the United States, the tolerance up to quite recently was quite fantastic because no revision of constituencies had been carried out for over 50 years, and with the drift of people into the cities, the difference between the number required to elect a representative in the city and in the country was out of all proportion. It ran into many hundreds per cent and there was no comparison at all. This reached such an extent that the Supreme Court has taken a hand in trying to get it back into balance but I am certain that when they do so, it will not be a question of mathematical accuracy but of what is practical.

Mr. W.J.M. MacKenzie, the author of the book Free Elections, sums up the situation in the following words:

It is obvious that in a diversified country, if all districts have approximately the same number of voters, some members (of the legislature) will find "contact" more difficult than do others, because of relatively bad communications and scattered population. It is, therefore, usual to allow large sparsely-populated districts a rather more generous allocation of seats than that to which they are numerically entitled.... In Western countries the argument generally favours country against town.

This is a general summing up of the attitude of various countries to this question of tolerances. One cannot but agree that what we are proposing to do is merely in line with what has been done in democratic countries throughout the western world. It is quite evident that the kind of mathematical exactitude that is being suggested by some speakers on the Opposition side could not be expected, and one can only come to the conclusion that those who advocated that, those who spoke in favour of it, were merely playing politics and doing so with their tongues in their cheeks and not really believing what they were saying.

Failure to introduce this amendment would, in my view, cause great administrative difficulties. It would result in a grotesque carving-up of county boundaries and that not only within the next year, when revision will be necessary, but again in 12 years time, or whenever the next revision falls to be made. Not alone would we have grotesque constituencies, with bits of counties running into one another, but that would have to be changed again and again in order to comply with the strict interpretation with which we are faced here.

Furthermore, as well as administrative difficulties, we would have manifest injustices inflicted on many rural constituencies in which it would take up to 30 per cent more electors to elect a representative than it would in urban constituencies. Any reasonable person, who considers the pros and cons and the arguments in favour of this Bill, plus the arguments against the Bill, cannot but come to the conclusion that the arguments in favour far outweigh the arguments against. Consequently, the Bill is worthy of support and the amendment is worthy of acceptance when it comes before the country in the referendum.

In regard to the Fourth Amendment, first of all, we would have to consider, I think, what kind of Parliament we want. What do we want from our parliamentary system? We want a system which will ensure that the electorate get as a government the men they want in government. Secondly, just as important, if not more important, we want a system which will provide that, when the people are dissatisfied with a government, they can get rid of that government. Under the single-seat, straight-vote system I do not think it can be denied that, if more people want a Fianna Fáil candidate rather than any other candidate, they will get that candidate. Whoever most of the people want they will get. If that member is a member of the government Party and if, after a certain time, the government goes out of favour there is no doubt but that, when an election takes place, the people, if they want some other man more than they want him, will get that other man and the man who supported the government and who has lost favour will go.

There is no validity in the devious and complicated arguments advanced against this measure. There is no validity in the argument that, even though Fianna Fáil lose the support of the people and the people turn against Fianna Fáil, in some extraordinary way their men will be elected, despite the fact that the people no longer want them. It passes comprehension how anybody can read that into the proposed system. It passes comprehension how anybody can suggest that, if more people in a constituency want one of the Opposition candidates, nevertheless the Fianna Fáil candidate will be elected. It is very difficult to understand this argument. Perhaps some of the speakers on the other side will explain how this could come about. I certainly cannot understand how it could happen.

Leaving aside for the moment the question of what particular party we want, what do we want from our parliamentary system? Do we want a Parliament in which all minorities are represented by a separate party, with all the resultant weaknesses inevitable in that kind of Parliament? This, of course, is actually one of the alleged merits of proportional representation. Do we want an effective Parliament, a Parliament with clear-cut views and with clear-cut support for the government of the day until such time as that government loses the support of the people and inevitably the support of Parliament? In such a Parliament every minority would not be represented separately but would, of course, have representation in the bigger parties.

Modern conditions are very different from the conditions which existed a century ago. Today government has become almost totally involved in every aspect of the life of the community. In such a state the old-style type of Parliament, the debating society type of Parliament, is quite unsuitable. It is certainly no longer adapted to present-day needs. A government today has to take responsibility for many different policies and has to gauge support and public reaction to many different policies. Such a government needs parliamentary support to see through the comprehensive policies called for from a government in modern conditions.

One of the merits of proportional representation, if it has any merit, is the fact that it will produce parties representing various minorities. If one believes that there is some intrinsic merit in proportional representation one believes in it because it will give representation to minorities. The logical development from that is that it will produce different parties representing different minorities. That means a multiplicity of parties. Do we want a multiplicity of parties? Having regard to the ups-and-downs of the smaller parties in this country over the last 40 years it is evident, I think, that the people do not want a multiplicity of parties, whatever their loyalty may be to proportional representation. If proportional representation is to be effective, in so far as it is effective at all, the likelihood is that it will produce a multiplicity of parties. If it produces a multiplicity of parties then it will be too late to do anything to change it and we will have a large number of parties, each representing a minority, inevitably unable to agree. It will be impossible to form a government and it will be impossible for Parliament to function. The present system has been defended on the grounds of the alleged merits of proportional representation. It is defended because it will produce what proportional representation is alleged to produce. In fact, the system we have is not proportional representation in any real sense. As I have said, it has not produced parties representing minorities. We have at the moment three parties and none of the three can be said to represent minorities. Each of them represents very large sections of the community and no Party is there primarily to represent a minority.

So that it can be said that it is futile to defend PR, in so far as it is defended, because it is a system that will produce representation for minorities, because it has not done so, and I think it may be said that in a country this size, the proportional representation system as originally conceived could not possibly be successful unless you went the whole way and had one constituency for the entire country, in which case you then would have a reasonable chance of having Deputies elected to represent almost every shade of minority opinion as well as majority opinions. You certainly would have a system then where the minorities would elect a certain number of Deputies and where every point of view in the country would have a say in Parliament, but you would probably almost certainly have a system which it would be impossible to operate, where it would be almost impossible to elect a government and, if elected, almost impossible to keep that government in office for more than a few months at a time.

But we have not got that system and I do not think anybody in the country would seriously advocate that we should go the whole way and have one big constituency so as to give PR a real chance and, in the meantime, we have something which is called PR but which, in fact, has not any of the real characteristics of PR and which can certainly be described as being neither fish, flesh nor good red herring.

In advocating this amendment, I am not doing so on the basis that PR in this country has been a complete failure in practice. I have said that I believe that it is not, in fact, the kind of system that was originally conceived but, for what it is worth, in the way it did operate, I am not suggesting that it was a complete failure. It worked reasonably well over the past 40 or 50 years but it must be admitted that there were factors in its favour which protected the country from what might have happened if PR had worked in another environment. The fact that we did have a Civil War in this country, the fact that the country was divided into two main loyalties, ensured that there was not a multiplicity of Parties, ensured that there were two or three large Parties and that we did not have constant splinter groups, constant smaller Parties, representing minorities. So that, because of that, the worst features, looking at it from one point of view, depending on one's point of view, the worst features of PR were not allowed to develop and, consequently, although it was, as I say, reasonably successful, I think that was because of factors which existed in this country which prevented the weaknesses and defects of PR from coming to light. That is why it has worked reasonably well in the past but these factors will certainly not operate to the same extent in the future and in the future we might possibly have the multiplicity of Parties under PR which we have luckily avoided in the past.

In advocating the straight vote and the single-seat constituency, I am happy to know that Fianna Fáil are not the only Party, that the members of Fianna Fáil are not the only people, who are in favour. There are many people who have no active connection with Fianna Fáil who are wholeheartedly in favour of the single-seat constituency, wholeheartedly in favour of the straight vote. There are many people who are not only not connected with Fianna Fáil but prominent members of the other Parties who are very much in favour of the single-seat constituency and the straight vote. It is impossible, certainly quite unreasonable, for any of the other Parties to suggest that in advocating the single-seat constituency and in advocating the straight vote, Fianna Fáil are doing it for any sinister motives, having regard to the fact that in all Parties there are reasonable people who agree that it is the best system and the system that would bring the most benefit to this country.

Nor am I going to criticise PR in the extravagant way that some of the members of Fine Gael did in the past, in the extravagant way that Deputy Dillon did in the past—he called it the child of the brains of all the cranks in creation—or the vehement way in which it was criticised by Deputy John Costello many years ago. I merely mention these things to show that the extreme advocacy of PR at the present time by some of the other Parties is a little bit inconsistent with what was argued by some of their members in the past. What is held by some of their members at the present time and their opposition to the straight vote and the single-seat constituency, again, is at variance with the views held by some of their prominent members at the present time, which, I think, merely goes to show that, whatever one's views may be about it—and it is quite obvious that there is room for many different points of view about it—it is a very reasonable thing to do as I am doing and as Fianna Fáil are doing, that is, to suggest that the single-seat constituency and the straight vote is the best possible system for this country.

I would suggest to some of those who oppose this Bill that they should be less intemperate, less outspoken, in their opposition to this proposal. They should remember that they have had to change their mind about many proposals Fianna Fáil have introduced in the past and, just as they now fancy themselves on many occasions as the defenders of the Constitution which they bitterly opposed when it was brought out, they may some day be posing as the defenders of the single-seat constituency and the straight vote and, if they are too intemperate, they may then repent all the speeches which they are making now opposing the single-seat constituency.

In considering the arguments for and against the two proposals contained in the Fourth Amendment, it is not necessary to argue very hard in regard to the proposal for the single-seat constituency because almost everybody sees the merit of this kind of constituency and I think the vast majority of people are in favour of it. It is quite obvious that it has very great merits, that it is more compact, that it would enable a Deputy to look after his constituents on the one hand and, at the same time, give a reasonable amount of time to his legislative duties. It would eliminate the artificial competition between Deputies, particularly between Deputies of the one Party who have to spend so much time trying to obtain benefits for their constituents which are either not obtainable by their constituents or which their constituents will get in any event. I have no doubt that the system of single-seat constituencies would raise parliamentary standards, would encourage better candidates to stand for election in the future.

Having regard to the effects, to the results at elections, I believe that the single-seat constituency would lead to more decisive election results, to a bigger swing when the Government of the day went out and to a more stable and a stronger form of government. This would be a very healthy situation. Sometimes people say Fianna Fáil cannot be serious and cannot be sincere when they say they want a system in which, when they lose favour, they would go completely out of office. I have no hesitation in saying I am in favour of a system which will ensure that when the Party in power, whether Fianna Fáil or any other Party, lose the support of the people, they will go completely out and another Party will go in, and that the alternative Party going in with a strong Government will carry on as best they can until, in turn, they are rejected by the people.

This system of having a strong swing, with the Government Party of the day going out of office and allowing another Government to come in to do the work and having the Party who go out taking a chance, when the time comes, of going back again strongly as a Government, is the better system. I have no doubt that such a system is much better than the kind of system we have under PR where the strength of the Party, whether they lose support or not, is cushioned and where you have situations in which the Government of the day are very often within a few seats of having an overall majority and there is great uncertainty as to whether they will stay in office, great uncertainty as to whether they will have the ability to put their policies into operation, whether they can carry out the policies they put before the people.

I have no hesitation in saying that the present system, which produces that kind of uncertainty and that kind of cushioning against loss of support from the people, is not a good one. I much prefer a system which ensures the swing for a strong Government so that whichever Government come in after an election and stay in will do it with a strong majority.

I was referring earlier to the people who were paying lip support to the principle of one man, one vote when dealing with the Third Amendment. Dealing with the Fourth Amendment and the question of the transferable vote, this principle of every person merely having one vote, and one vote as good as anybody else, seems to be entirely forgotten because under the transferable vote system, some people have several votes and some people have one vote that is quite ineffective. Therefore, those who are in favour of the principle of one man, one vote should endeavour to be consistent. It seems to me they are not being consistent if they are in favour of it for the Third Amendment and at the same time opposing it for the Fourth Amendment. With the straight vote, the man with the biggest number of votes, the best man before the people, is the man who is elected. To suggest that the transferable vote is in some way fairer, more equitable, more reasonable or logical, does not stand up to examination. It is something we have had in this country for a long time and something we are used to, something that to a considerable extent we take for granted—something that is so complicated that rather than try to work it out, most people accept on their face value the arguments made in favour of the transferable vote. The idea that it is a fairer system is something which just does not stand up to examination.

If you have the straight vote and the person who heads the poll gets the majority, then of course nobody can have any objection because he has had an overall majority. No matter what system we have, he would have that. The point on which the advocate of the straight vote and their opponents come to issue is where the person who gets the most votes does not, in fact, get an overall majority. It is alleged that the advantage of the transferable vote is that in order to be elected, a person must get the majority of the votes, which means a certain number of his own first preferences and a certain number of votes which come to him in rather devious ways. I suggest that the system is completely contrived, completely unjust, and that it does not stand up to any serious examination as to its fairness, because the basic difficulty in the system is that some of the transfers are counted and some are not, and the way in which that is arrived at is entirely arbitrary and capricious.

I do not intend to go too deeply into the mathematical corridors or ramifications of the transferable vote but I ask Senators to consider a very simple situation in which A, B, and C get 4,000, 3,000 and 2,000 votes respectively under the transferable vote system. C, who gets 2,000, is eliminated and if most of his votes go to B then B is elected, but no consideration at all is given to the second preferences of A and B. If B were eliminated and his second preferences were distributed, they might easily elect A. Alternatively, if A's preferences were distributed, they might elect C. What is the justification, what is the sense in only C's preferences being counted? What is the justification for the fact that the preferences that went to the candidate who got the lowest number of votes should be counted or, to look at it another way, why is it that the voters who picked the worst horse get another chance to vote, whereas the voters who picked the man who got the most votes get no chance with their second votes?

This is what happens and it leads to the situation where A got 4,000 votes, C is eliminated and perhaps 1,001 votes go to B, who then has 4,001 votes— 3,000 of his own and 1,001 second preference votes. Is there any sense in a man for whom only 3,000 people voted primarily and 1,001 people wanted as a second choice being elected and a man who had 4,000 first preferences being beaten by him? It does not make sense. It may be a very nice exercise in mathematics; it may be a very interesting system; it may be a thousand and one different things; but it does not make sense by any reckoning. That is the system we have. That is the system which is alleged to be a fair, more equitable and more logical system than merely having three or four going up for election and the man who gets the most votes being elected. I challenge any speaker speaking in this debate to justify this position and to show it is more logical, fairer or better in any way than the system of first past the post.

I am not going to go into all the other incongruities of the PR system. It does not make sense and has not made sense in the past. Again and again, you hear people express amazement at the situations which have occurred in the past in various constituencies, where the person who got the most first preferences eventually was not elected. Nor does it make sense— to get into slightly more deeper waters and deal with something which, I am sure, 999 people out of 1,000 do not know about—that when surpluses are being distributed at an election here under PR, the returning officer merely picks bundles at random and decides he will distribute this or that bundle. Picking that bundle may elect A and picking this bundle may elect B. There is no logical explanation why this bundle is picked and that is not.

Comment on this

Except the laws of statistics.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Because we are told that the PR system has such tremendous hidden advantages, we are expected to accept it without really examining it. On this occasion we should really examine it, not all of it but at least some of the more glaring deficiencies that exist and that make it a system which is anything but logical and anything but fair and reasonable.

We are not for the moment dealing with whether we should reform the PR system as it applies to multi-seat constituencies. We are considering at the moment whether we should have in a single-seat constituency the transferable vote or the majority vote. Whatever the arguments are for having the transferable vote in the PR system —and in that case of course we must have some kind of transferable vote— there seems to be no merit at all in retaining one of the characteristics of the PR system when it is proposed to change the system to a single-seat constituency. While we have to have a transferable vote of some kind in multi-seat PR constituencies, there is no argument in favour of it if we are to have single-seat constituencies. It is only a kind of half-baked sentimental idea that we should not get rid of the characteristics of PR altogether and that, even though we might be in favour of single-seat constituencies, we should retain one of the characteristics of the PR system just for old time's sake.

To me that does not make sense. I think the people will agree that if we are to have the single-seat constituency, we should have it and have it in the best possible form. The best possible form is where the man who gets most of the people to support him is the man who is elected and not the man who gets a certain number of the votes and the second and third preferences of various other voters.

I believe the proposals embodied in these Bills will improve the parliamentary system. I believe that a very good prima facie case has been made for them. I hope that the Seanad will support these Bills as the Dáil has done. Finally, I ask the Seanad to remember that we are not changing the system. By passing this Bill we are not making any changes in the electoral system. We are not imposing any changes on the people. We are merely giving the people an opportunity to say whether or not they think the system proposed is better than the system which we had up to now.

For that reason I do not know why some members of the Opposition—not in this House so far—in the other House have got so excited about these Bills and have become so intemperate in their objection. If the people do not like the system proposed, the people will say so. The people can make up their minds very adequately. Although it is legitimate for the political Parties to do their best to help them to make up their minds, the people will say if they do not like this system. They are only being given an opportunity to say whether the proposals being made in these Bills would give a better parliamentary system than what we have at the moment. The people are entitled to be consulted in these matters and the Constitution provides for such consultation. I would ask the Opposition to allow that very important and valuable democratic process to take its course.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill and to support the motion standing in the names of other Senators and of myself. My reasons for opposing the abolition of proportional representation were given at some length in February, 1959, when the Seanad debated the proposal for something like 70 hours, as I reckon, and then eventually rejected it. Now, for the sake of Senator Ó Maoláin's very laudable desire to finish our business by 1st August, I propose to be as brief as I can.

First, may I meet two arguments in Senator Ryan's very reasonable speech? The first suggestion he made was that perhaps some Members of this House would oppose the abolition of proportional representation because they felt that certain small minorities might lose their representation. I think I can speak for one of those small minorities. I would like to say emphatically that those days, to my mind, are past. Nine years ago, when we debated a similar Bill, many, I think, still felt it would be well for the small minorities to have people of their own kind in Parliament to represent them. I believe that these small minorities have a confidence now which they did not have then. I believe they no longer think it necessary to have one of their own people representing them on all occasions. In other words, I believe that this argument is outdated. I do not think any of us in this House is likely to say we protest in the name of the small minorities. Times have changed very much for the better in our country on that count, and I am happy to be able to say that.

On the other hand, I think we should speak for the majority, and in fact what this proposal intends, apparently, is to undermine the right of the majority to elect the Government. The statistical figures are perfectly clear on this point. They have been published by the Labour Party and others. Time and again in England we have seen a minority of voters electing the majority in Parliament. To my mind, that is a clear injustice. It is undeniably wrong mathematically. It seems undeniably wrong in principle.

May I, for a moment, meet another argument that Senator Ryan put forward? At first, he nearly shook me. This was his ingenious tale of A and B and C, A with 4,000 votes, B with 3,000 and C with 2,000. Senator Ryan thinks it is unreasonable that C's second preferences should be distributed but not A's or B's. He would like a clearcut decision, as he calls it, for either A or B or C. I suggest that a mark of civilisation is some subtlety, some flexibility, in choice. I suggest it is crude that one should be told: you must choose A or B or C, with no alternative.

To take one choice which looms before some of us in this House in the immediate present, let us consider, for example, the proposed merger of Trinity College, Dublin, with University College, Dublin, instead of Senator Ryan's A and B and C. Let A be the Government proposals; let B be the Trinity College proposals, and C the UCD proposals. Is the ideal thing that everyone should say: "I choose either A or B or C; I do not want anything else, and I will not take it"? Is it not more civilised, more reasonable, to say: "If possible, I should like A but if I cannot get A, I would prefer B." I suggest this is the best way to seek out the mind of the people in the country. That is the justification for the alternative vote.

Comment on this

Judging from recent pronouncements, the universities are not doing that.

Comment on this

In fact, I claim that one of the colleges is being flexible on the matter; the other less flexible. Which is which I leave to the House to judge.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

On a point of order, I should like to point out that what I said was that we should have either no preferences or all preferences—equal treatment.

Comment on this

This is the Senator's way of looking at it. He wants to rule out the alternative: I want to keep the alternative. I want a subtler choice which I think is the mode of civilisation. However, that is my thinking now, but these matters need a good deal of consideration, and if I change my mind, I shall certainly tell Senator Ryan. But I stand very firmly on this point, that mathematically it is clear that if we abolish PR, we may be faced with the position that people elected by the minority of the voters may be the majority in Parliament. I do not accept that as desirable.

My second objection is this: I do not accept the argument that strong and stable government is necessarily good government. How can we accept such an argument? Do we think that a strong man is necessarily better than a weak man? If we do, our theology and morality have changed drastically within the past few years. Do we think people who stay in office longer are necessarily better governors than those who stay in office a shorter time? That is nonsensical. I cannot understand how people can think in this way. The fact is that "strong" and "stable" are morally neutral qualities. I emphasise "neutral" qualities. They can be used for good or for evil. They are irrelevant to our decision today. What we are interested in is good government. There is nothing at all in common necessarily between lengthy government or strong government and good government.

Hitler's government was strong and long. So was Mussolini's. Nobody would suggest they were good governments. Incidentally, in case people think I am bringing in the wrong analogies, nobody would say that they were anything like any government we have had here in the past 46 years. But they are proofs that length and strength do not necessarily have anything to do with goodness. In other words, the electors' choice is never between good, stable, strong government and bad, weak, unstable government. It is between the best government they can get and worse government.

I know how our colleagues on the other side are thinking and I admire them for it in many ways. They are thinking that there is no risk whatever of bad government as long as they are in office. Be frank, gentlemen, that is what you are thinking. All right; but we do not all think that way. We all, I hope, remember Lord Acton's famous dictum: "All power tends to corrupt; absolute power corrupts absolutely."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is worn out.

Comment on this

It is not worn out. We can see it every year in some country or other, and we do not want to see it in our own. There is something in an excess of power which does corrupt. The country does not want this, I believe. The country wants it always to be that the majority of the people will decide the majority of Parliament. This is what PR, as we have it now, gives, to my mind. That is the second reason why I oppose the change, although I should add, incidentally, that I am not opposed to the change proposed in the first Bill, the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. My mind is open on that. It may well be that in this matter the Fianna Fáil Government are right.

To return to the arguments against the abolition of PR, my third argument is simply an historical one. Nine years ago, after the most careful and laborious deliberations in this House, we rejected the proposal. The country rejected it. Surely it is unreasonable to bring it up again now? I see no answer to this. It will bring a kind of chaos into our politics if matters that have been decided in the past ten years by the will of the people should be brought up again.

I promised to be brief, and I must stop. I believe that what I have put forward is not a matter of opinion. Mathematically, the system we have at the moment prevents minority government. Morally, I am certain that strength and length are not equal to goodness. Historically, we determined the matter—rightly as I see it—nine years ago. Therefore I oppose the Bill for the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

As Senator Stanford has said, there is no demand for this measure; it was decided by the electorate nine years ago. Senator Ryan thought there was nothing improper, and, in fact, that there was something commendable, in the Government going to the people, and that it would be ridiculous if they expected to be consulted on every measure introduced into the Oireachtas by the Government. However, this is an Article enshrined in our Constitution, and nine years ago a submission was made to the electorate, and by a majority of 30,000, the people decided to retain PR.

I know the Minister said in the other House that it was a small majority, but since then we have had a Presidential election where the successful Fianna Fáil candidate secured one-third of the majority that was secured for the retention of PR, and he enjoys in office the complete loyalty of every citizen of our State. Nobody, not even the worst crank in our community, has alleged for a moment that because he was elected by such an extremely narrow majority he was not completely entitled to the loyalty of all citizens or that his stature was in any way diminished in occupying the position of President.

How, therefore, can a Minister of this Government justify the resurrection of an issue that was decided by three times that majority and putting it to the people? This incurs expense. We have cuts in our roads grants. We are awaiting the restoration of moneys to promote rural improvement schemes. There are many avenues of activity in which this £100,000 could well be spent by the Government.

Apart from that, as has been said, this proposal has introduced chaotic conditions into our political life. There was no demand for it. A Fianna Fáil Deputy from the constituency in which I reside, Deputy Crowley, coming on the television programme "Open House" within the past 12 months had a question addressed to him from the audience—and it could not have been an embarrassing question, because the questioner happened to be his closest friend—as to his views on the electoral system and whether it would be advisable to re-present the question of the abolition of PR. That Fianna Fáil Deputy committed himself openly on television, not only before his own electorate but before the country at large, as being quite satisfied with the decision of the people nine years ago.

From where did this demand emanate? I contend that it has its origin in the fact that elections have shown diminishing support for the Government Party. They may claim to have won a certain number of by-elections, but the figures prove that in the local elections, in the Presidential election, and in certain of the by-elections, a reduced vote was recorded for the Government Party. In the constituency of Cork, electing the Taoiseach, there was a reduction of 3,000 votes. It shows that the Labour Party have made significant advances in the urban areas, advances confined, I know, to the urban areas. This was reflected in Cork city and in Limerick, and if the occasion arose in Dublin, no doubt it would also be reflected here.

Comment on this

I take it that in concluding I may discuss the by-election results?

Comment on this

If they are mentioned in the debate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In the other House the Minister discussed them repeatedly.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

May I suggest that we set an example in this and not discuss them too long?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Not for too long. I had come to the point of the reasons for the introduction of this proposal at this time. Senator Ryan and others have spoken of people thinking again and the possibility of their holding different views at different times, but down through the years since this State was founded we have had repeated statements made by people in responsible positions about the advantages of PR. Speaking in 1937 the then Taoiseach said:

The system we have we know; the people know it.

We can claim to have advanced educationally since then. If they knew it then, I claim they know it better now.

On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think we have a good deal to be thankful for in the country: we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of PR here. It gives a certain amount of stability, and on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties.

Senator Ryan roundly condemned the practice of a person having a following preference. How is this Seanad elected? There is not a Member sitting in this House, unless he was nominated by the Taoiseach, who did not avidly try to secure as many lower preferences as he could in order to be elected to the Seanad. There is not as yet a proposal to abolish this system that has been condemned by the Government in all its moods and tenses. It was an outrageous thing that anybody should have any right to exercise a preference electorally beyond the X mark of the illiterate, that this should be the be-all and the end-all when it came to exercising electoral preferences. However, we here are elected to the Seanad under probably one of the most outrageous systems that was ever devised by man. It requires the electorate to exercise a degree of transferability which is far in excess of any measure of transferability that could be exercised in elections to Dáil Éireann. Having regard to the fact that Seanadóirí are themselves elected by the PR system, it is rather strange to be asking us to condemn a system by which we are sitting here and by which we have the right to express views here. I cannot follow the logicality of that.

It is alleged, too, that in the nine years that have gone since the people were last consulted about PR, new people have come on the register. There is not a month that goes by that we do not pass legislation which becomes an Act of the Oireachtas and which may not operate for many years to come, perhaps without amendment for many more years, but people who have come on the register subsequently are not consulted on the matter. The fact that a person might not have been entitled to express an opinion at a particular moment does not weaken the decision taken by those who had the right at that moment. If that were not the case, then this House could be questioned in relation to its authority to express a view on anything because the local elections have been held since this House was elected. It is to be noted that the Fine Gael Party secured an increase of 75 seats in the process of the local elections. Consequently we could say that if we now had a reflection of the opinion of those elected to the local authorities throughout the country, we would have a different complexion in this Chamber. At any rate, that disposes of the argument that some additional people are now entitled to vote who did not have that opportunity nine years ago.

The Taoiseach went on to say—this is a present President and I think the de-Stalinisation of Russia has nothing on the de-Valeranisation by Fianna Fáil in respect of many of the commitments made by this gentleman when he was Taoiseach—on the same occasion:

I think we get probably in this country more than in any other country better balanced results from the system we have. If you take the countries where PR exist, you get better balanced results than you get in other countries. I think we get the benefits of PR in reasonably balanced legislation here better than in any other country that I have read about or know about.

There is also the question as to whether minorities should be deliberately prevented from securing popular election. We know that in Britain the system we are now asked to adopt is favoured by the two major Parties. We all know that there is in Britain a population in excess of the entire population of the Republic of Ireland who vote Liberal, and they elect nine Members. There is controversy from time to time with regard to the size of the Dáil, and whether the number should be this or that. I have repeatedly defended the suggestion that there is a minimum below which you cannot go. I think it would not be advisable to have a Dáil with less than the present number. I have said that on many occasions. It is necessary to have behind the Government sufficient back benchers to express an opinion apart from that of the Government, and there should be sufficient personnel to draw on to provide a Government.

What would anyone think if it were suggested that nine Deputies would be sufficient to represent the entire population of the Republic of Ireland Yet under the system which it is proposed we should adopt that condition obtains in the neighbouring island of Britain. There are many thousands of Liberal sympathisers who, when they take their ballot papers in their hands, while their first preference would be for the Liberal candidate, have the immediate reaction: "We may as well stay at home as cast a vote for the Liberal candidate. We are unhappy about the activities of the Government. We feel there should be a change." Consequently, if there is a Labour Government, they vote Conservative. They do not vote for the candidate of their first choice, and they have not got a transferable vote. If they had PR they could vote for the candidate of the Party of their choice first, and then exercise a preference between the candidates of the other Parties. They are denied that opportunity and they refrain from voting for the first Party of their choice because they want to express a preference between the Government and the only other Party that can challenge the Government to secure office.

I agree with what Senator Stanford said about the position of the minorities in this country, but I still claim that it would be completely improper to legislate against the emergence of a minority Party. The situation in Northern Ireland was very closely examined by a very eminent person, Professor A. J. Allaway. He referred to the claim made for the first past the post system of election as being a simple system. He remarked that, "simplicity can at times, however, be purchased at too high a price, and Northern Ireland is a good example of this fact." He went on to say:

There are many men and women with progressive views on both sides of Northern Ireland's great divide who, because of the electoral arrangements now in operation, are alike condemned to impotence. If they try to found progressive Parties, Unionist, Nationalist or Border-neutral, they find that the votes their candidates poll, however considerable in the aggregate over the constituencies as a whole, are insufficient to return more than perhaps one or two members. This in time disheartens them, and in due course, they descend to oblivion.

This is taken from an article entitled Northern Ireland and Proportional Representation by Professor A. J. Allaway.

Another eminent man who did considerable research into the position under the electoral system that operates in Northern Ireland and which we are now asked to adopt in the Republic, Nicholas Mansergh, said:

The minority, embittered by the partition of the country and resentful of Government by their traditional opponents, were naturally sensitive to the smallest infringement of their rights. In such circumstances the Government displayed a frankly aggressive attitude in abolishing PR for local government elections in 1922 and for parliamentary elections in 1929. Even if there had been no accompanying injustices of any kind, this action revealed a complete lack of sympathy with the minority outlook. At the worst it was Party manoeuvre; at the best a psychological mistake. A comparison between the electoral returns before and after 1929 reveals that the change has affected neither the accuracy of representation nor the number of the small Parties to the extent that was anticipated.

He also said:

It has, however, drawn attention, and added to, the frozen condition of Ulster's political life. This is most clearly indicated by the very large proportion of uncontested seats in local, parliamentary and Imperial elections. When 70 per cent of the members of the House of Commons of Northern Ireland—admittedly the most important legislative body in the province—are returned, as in 1933, without a contest, then indeed there is just occasion for the democrat to fear for the future of representative government.

These are important and well-qualified commentaries on the effect of the Northern Ireland system which we are asked to adopt.

We know that the development of the single-seat non-transferable system brings in its train, or practically automatically, the development of the safe seat, the situation where you have Members elected without being required to contest their seats in subsequent elections. I know it is easy for a Party that has a Deputy elected in every constituency in the Republic to be complacent in relation to the circumstances of a Party that may not have a representative in each constituency. A Party without a representative in a constituency realises only too well the formidable difficulties that face it in maintaining its energy, in maintaining its initiative, when it has not got a public representative elected to the national legislature not alone to represent it there relative to Departmental worries, but also in the more important matters of national affairs.

It is hypocrisy and ludicrous for any member of the Government or any supporter of the Government's proposals in this measure to allege for a moment that they are concerned regarding the future of their successors in office and are presenting this measure—as so many have argued in debate —as something that ultimately would be to the great advantage of an Opposition Party. They know full well—it has been calculated by people who are independent observers and qualified to make research into these matters— that the present Party in Government could, through this system, secure a colossal majority in the next Dáil without an increase in support in the country: in fact, with a continuation of the diminishing support reflected over the past few years.

This situation, I claim, would be unhealthy. I should like to know what legislation the Government were inhibited from introducing, from implementing, because they may feel that, at the moment, they have not sufficient strength in the Dáil. We know that, back in the 1947 period, at a time when they had a very strong overall majority, we had repressive legislation such as the Wages (Standstill) Order—all prepared for presentation to be enacted— proposing the most extraordinary fines for any employer who would dare to give an increase to his employees. That was on the records at a time when we had strong and stable government. However, over the past decade, was there any occasion when the Government failed to enact any measure which they considered was for the betterment of the people? It may have been very closely examined, criticised and amended or opposed but it passed into law. Therefore, what hidden measures have they in mind for which they would require an extraordinary majority in Dáil Éireann?

I suggest it would not be well for any Party—I do not care what Party it would be—to have such power vested in them. The allegation was also made—Senator Eoin Ryan repeated it today—that proportional representation leads to a multiplicity of Parties. Proportional representation permitted the emergence of a number of Parties since the foundation of the State but they did not survive over-long. At least, however, their supporters had the opportunity—which they availed of— of electing some number of them to the national legislature. If they were unsuccessful and if they dwindled, well and good. Can you, however, imagine a situation if all of those people were denied the privilege of electing the people they wanted to elect, by a deliberate system of election that would prevent their election?

We know the problems we encountered in the earlier days of the State, due to minority activity. We realise that it was only when Parliamentary responsibility was given to these people that, eventually, we had the development of the peaceful and democratic type of government that, fortunately, we have enjoyed over the past 35 years. I suggest that there now exist in this country three Parties and that these do not represent a multiplicity of Parties relative to any Parliament. I suggest that we have stability inasmuch as we have not had the over-frequent changes of government that are supposed to follow where proportional representation is the accepted process of election. But, mind you, I think the Government are inclined to regard stability with their own election: they have it synchronised. This is their interpretation of stability. They appear to have arrived at the stage of arrogance where they would regard the election of any other Party as being, in fact, instability. This is a negation of democracy. The people are entitled, if they so desire, to change their government. I suggest the system of proportional representation has not led either to instability or to the multiplicity of Parties that it was alleged would result.

Now, Sir, an extraordinary case is being made on the Government side relative to the quality of the Deputy. Seemingly, there appeared to be considerable misgivings among the Government Party over the years relative to the quality of Deputies. They suggest the introduction of the single-seat non-transferable vote would automatically result in the emergence of a much better type of public representative: I cannot agree. In the first place, you confine the selection of the Deputy to a smaller number of electors, that is, assuming the elected candidate resides in his constituency. Let me put it on record that, in Britain, where the system operates that we are asked to accept, one-third of the membership of the House of Commons reside in the city of London and do not reside in their constituencies. So, there we have the development of the safe seat and the Party pet nominated in an area where he may or may not be opposed but is certain of election. This is done by the Party caucus. In the system we have had since the foundation of the State, the democratic convention methods are employed by political Parties in selecting a team of candidates. Beyond that, we give the electorate an opportunity of selecting from that panel those whom they deem most suitable to be elected. Some of us are in this House, perhaps, as victims of this particular choice being given to the electorate. We may have had membership of the other House and other candidates from our own Party may have come up and, being one of a team of Party candidates, submitted themselves to the electorate on the ballot paper and we may have fallen by the wayside. However, we accept the will of the people in that respect. In retrospect, I can see my successor performing more arduously and bringing better ideas to my Party organisation and to the constituency.

I think the maintenance of proportional representation gives the right and power to the electorate to change their Deputy if they so desire either by the substitution of a Deputy of another Party or a candidate from the Party to which they give their allegiance. By changing the electoral system to the single non-transferable vote, you remove that choice from the electorate which they have exercised down through the years by reason of having a panel of candidates from which to select their first choice. Knowing the candidates, it is only natural that they would continue to exercise their preferences until they have exhausted the list. There have been improvements in this. I want to say quite frankly to the Labour Party that it was most regrettable that in some recent elections some of their Party advised the electorate not to exercise PR to its fullest extent. However, I think that was just a passing phase and that now it is over. There is no doubt that as election followed election, the people showed a greater appreciation of their rights in the exercise of the ballot by way of the continuing preferences for the candidates presented to them.

I cannot understand the allegation that the single-member seat Deputy will be a better Deputy than a Deputy from a multi-member constituency. At different times I represented two constituencies. The first constituency to which I was elected did not have a coastline nor any great tourist attraction, and I found myself confined to agriculture and a few other aspects of legislative work. When I moved to the other constituency, I became involved in activities affecting the urban dweller, where tourism was prominent and so on. If you restrict the area of the constituency, you restrict the field of operations of the Deputy and you restrict the numbers and types of people he will meet as a public representative. It removes the element of competition between Deputies. I know this would be a considerable relief to the elected Deputy and no doubt many of our civil servants could satisfy us that there is duplication of work. If more than one Deputy is approached about a problem, is it not a healthy thing to have competition? It is better to have that than to have the system that operates in the country we propose to copy, where Members of Parliament reside in the city of London.

I regard the multi-member constituency as providing a Deputy with wider interests than in the smaller single-member constituency. There are faults in the operations of Deputies under the existing system but how and why have they arisen? It is not the system that is at fault. The fault lies in the fact that in recent years letters have been coming to some Deputies from Government Departments giving information in regard to grant applications and other matters about which they had never been approached and never made representation, and then they complain about the accumulation of work. In a constituency which is very close to mine and in which a Government Deputy is privileged, even if another Deputy makes representations about a particular matter, the reply will go to the privileged Deputy. I know that this is a subject of an inquiry in the Minister's Department at present. It is not the system that is responsible for this; it is the machinations that go on and which have grown over the years.

Formerly, Members of the Oireachtas used to write to the Secretary of a Department and receive a reply from him or from the civil servant concerned, but now the situation is that almost automatically all such correspondence goes to the Minister in order to give the matter political colour and as if it were due to the beneficence of the political head of the Department rather than the rights of the people if they had never approached a political representative. How then can people who operate in such a manner complain about the volume of work in a multi-seat constituency? If we were to adopt the proposed system, the Party who secured the strong majority which we hear about would have a majority of constituencies, with a Deputy for each one of them, and the people in those constituencies would have no other Deputy to cater for them. No matter how actively they had opposed that Deputy, they would be confined to him if they wished to have any intervention in relation to a Departmental matter. It would not be good for a Deputy to be confined in his activities to solitary operations on his own.

We have had the commendable practice down through the years in multi-member constituencies, particularly where the Deputies were members of the local authorities, of having joint consultation and joint deputations to various Departments. That was a healthy development, but it would disappear under the single-seat system. Apart from the embarrassment that could be caused to a person who had actively opposed the election of a Deputy and who would like to engage in a similar activity in the future, in having to approach that Deputy about some matter, there is also the point that the Deputy is likely to be engaged in some professional or business capacity and how could a competitor approach him about a problem which he would like to discuss in confidence? How could he reveal the confidential and intimate nature of his business to that Deputy? We know that that can be overcome quite readily under the multi-member system.

From the selfish point of view of the elected Deputy, it would be very much easier to be elected without competition in a single-member constituency and be confined to a limited area beyond which he may not travel. There are adjoining single-member constituencies in which people are engaged in different activities, and when measures which would have an impact on their livelihoods come up in the House, there would be Deputies who would ignore them and who would confine their activities solely to whatever would be parochial problems.

We have the situation clearly defined for us in our operations in Cork County Council where we have three housing and sanitary committees and, when matters arise at the general meeting of the county council, we know the rivalry that exists when it comes to the allocation of moneys vis-à-vis the different areas. The same position would arise in the case of the single-member constituency. The Deputy elected would have a much narrower outlook and a very much smaller field of consultation; the wider the field of consultation the better. Secondly, there is no validity whatsoever in the case made by the Government that there will emerge from the single-member constituency a better type of Deputy.

The Minister and those supporting him referred to the rearrangement of constituencies as presenting certain problems. They expressed themselves as aghast at the possibility of being required to cross county boundaries. Every time constituencies have been revised since the foundation of the State the revision was carried out under a Fianna Fáil Government and we are only too well aware of some of the things that have arisen in the process of rearranging constituencies. I cannot accept the bona fides of the Minister and his Party when they talk about the hideous possibility of having to cut up counties and re-align them with adjoining counties. When the late William J. Broderick, who was unanimously elected chairman of Cork County Council for more years than any other chairman of a local authority because of the respect for his ability, was elected a Deputy to Dáil Éireann by his native town of Youghal, that town was lifted right across the estuary of the River Blackwater and put into County Waterford in an effort to displace Deputy Broderick from membership of Dáil Éireann—a deliberate piece of gerrymandering. However, it misfired because the people of Waterford, too, were alert to the qualities of this particular man and they returned him for County Waterford. It was naturally a tremendous upset to an elected representative to find himself divorced from his native county and from the town in which he resided and transferred into another county for the express purpose of unseating him, but, as I said, without success on that occasion.

In the North Cork constituency, there was a very respected Deputy, Deputy Dan Desmond, who was elected to the Dáil for many years. When the constituencies were revised, the village of Ballyvoureen, in which he resided, was divided in two and his sister-in-law who lived across the road from him was in one constituency and he was in another. On the last occasion on which constituencies were revised, there were five Deputies representing the City of Cork, three Fianna Fáil, one Fine Gael and one Labour. Is it a coincidence that that section of the city in which Deputy Stephen Barrett and the late Deputy Seán Casey resided was lifted away out of the city of Cork and transferred into the constituency of mid-Cork and the two non-Fianna Fáil Deputies, who represented the city of Cork, were denied the opportunity of voting for themselves, as were their families, their friends and their neighbours. Yet, they were returned by the people of Cork. How any Minister in the Fianna Fáil Party or any Deputy in that Party could complain about being required to do extraordinary things in the rearrangement of constituencies beats me when we remember what was done down through the years. They surely are talking with their tongues in their cheeks.

There is no doubt that the electorate have expressed their opinions under proportional representation and have had the opportunity under this system of expressing their opinions. If they wanted Independents elected, then they elected them. They gave them a run of the course. If they were dissatisfied with them, they displaced them, and we had the situation in which five Independent Deputies elected a Fianna Fáil Government in defiance of the mandate they received at the general election in which they were returned and, on the next occasion on which the electorate got the opportunity, not one of the five was returned to Dáil Éireann. That shows just how people react if the Deputy elected does not live up to his undertakings when seeking election.

In local elections Independent representation was eliminated to a very great extent under proportional representation. If the people want Party representation at local or national level, then they express that opinion in the ballot boxes. We have neither in Dáil Éireann nor in the county councils a multiplicity of Parties nor a multiplicity of independently elected Members because the people are availing of the present system to elect one or other of the three Parties.

I contend this is a blatant effort to prevent either Fine Gael or Labour advancing. It is an effort to introduce a system, which was wrongly criticised even by Winston Churchill because his party gained considerably from the fact that it operated to the advantage of the Conservatives. He wrongly condemned it as representing an unfair system to minorities in any legislature. If we want any evidence of the injustice or the demerits of the proposed new system, we have only to look at the recent BGA election held under the straight vote system. In the Mallow electoral area, the two Fianna Fáil candidates secured 44 per cent of the votes. They received no seat. I wonder would their political supporters be very happy should that occur in Parliament. Would any elector be happy with a system in which a Party could secure almost 50 per cent of the vote and fail to secure a seat in Parliament? We are being asked to accept a system we have criticised severely because of the manner in which it operates in Northern Ireland and Britain, where you can have uncontested seats and absentee Members. It is a system which operates to prevent the emergence of any challenging Party to the Party in power and the Party that would play yo-yo with the Party in power because the system guarantees them against the emergence of any other competing Party.

Comment on this

I oppose this measure and I support the motion in my name and the names of other Senators condemning this proposal. It is virtually impossible to discuss this proposal without some measure of repetition. I detest repetition. I detest even more having to sit and listen to it and, therefore, I propose to be brief.

Over the greater part of the past 50 years the people of this country have clearly and repeatedly demonstrated their capacity and their ability to understand and to use the system of PR in the exercise of their votes wisely, intelligently and, I think, quite well. Because the people have intelligently used that system, we have elected governments which have, above all else, been representative of every articulate group and of every articulate section or shade of public thought and of social life in this country.

Under the same system we have produced the most stable government of any country in Europe, and probably beyond. Under the same system, by reasoned and by regular consultation with and reference to the opinions of the people, successive general elections have each given us successive governments with an average life of anything from three to four years at a time and have produced for us a method by which the policies of our small but representative number of political Parties have been kept reasonably well attuned to the needs and to the wishes of all sections of our people.

When the Fianna Fáil Party made their last bid to impose their will on the political life of this country, the people, as recently as 1959, resolutely and with due deliberation rejected their proposal to abolish our present electoral system. That was only nine short years ago, nothing more than a fleeting moment in the political life of any country. Yet, we have the Fianna Fáil Party and this Government adamantly introducing this proposal once again, in 1968.

I do not propose to elaborate further on it but it has been said and I want to ask in all earnestness can anyone say with any conviction, either in this House or anywhere outside it, that there is, in fact, any semblance of evidence of any desire among any representative section of our people for a change in the electoral system? I say, and I say it with conviction, that there is not, that even amongst the Fianna Fáil Party itself, there is no such desire and I say that with conviction because I have, in fact, asked members of the Fianna Fáil Party— numbers of them—what their views on this system were and I refuse to believe that the people to whom I have spoken are all hypocrites or liars. I refuse to accept that. I accept the answers I got from them.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Eight months ago the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis unanimously asked for this.

Comment on this

I say with conviction that inside the Fianna Fáil Party itself there is no desire for this change.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Fifteen hundred delegates representing the Fianna Fáil Party asked for it.

Comment on this

The Senator tried to pretend that he was a member at one time but is known not to be now.

Comment on this

The Government may say I am wrong.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Unanimously.

Comment on this

All Russian elections were unanimous.

Comment on this

Why does the Senator not talk about his own Party, if he has one?

Comment on this

You want to make sure that he will not have one.

Comment on this

The truth is that the Fianna Fáil Party have denied the members of their own Party even the right to vote on this question.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Bunkum.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If the Senator kept closer to the Bill it would be advantageous.

Comment on this

Kept closer to the truth.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He is becoming argumentative. We shall have to sit up and take notice of him.

Comment on this

When the shoe pinches, one is bound to hear from them. The fact is that what I have said is the truth.

Comment on this

Saying it will not make it a fact.

Comment on this

Nobody wants this, apparently, apart from some type of clique or some type of minority group within the Fianna Fáil Party itself, and obviously, pretty close to Government level. In all truth, they appear to be the only people who say that there is some necessity or some demand for this change which they are now proposing. Nobody, apart from that type of minority group, has asked for this change and as far as any reasonable man can ascertain at the moment, nobody wants that change.

Therefore, I would ask in all seriousness, is it not deplorable that on this question the whole industrial, social and political life of the country has now to be senselessly plunged into an unwanted campaign leading to a referendum, with all the disturbance, all the dislocation——

Comment on this

What dislocation?

Comment on this

——to say nothing of the expense which that sort of campaign would involve for our country?

Comment on this

What dislocation?

Comment on this

I say that it is wrong, morally wrong as well as everything else, for the Government to inflict that sort of exercise on a number of people, particularly at a time when, I suggest, the energies of every Party in this House would be far better employed in some attempt to improve the living standards and the general welfare of our people.

The Government's proposal, therefore, appears to me to portray a cynical, if not an arrogant, disregard for the views and the opinions of the majority of the people of the country. I hope, indeed I am confident, that the people can be relied on once again to give the only answer possible to that type of obnoxious proposal.

Having said that, I would say, without further comment, that I honestly feel that the sooner these Bills are put through all Stages in this House and the sooner the people are given the opportunity of again rejecting the Government's proposal, the better.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why do you not let them through, then?

Comment on this

We will go on opposing them now and at any time the same proposals are produced in the future, and for the same good reasons. Our views are clearly stated in the motion which was originally tabled by the members of this Party over our names, and I hope that every Member of this House—I include all the Members of the House not committed to the views of the minority clique who have produced these proposals—will support the views of my Party and refuse to be a party to the passage of these Bills through this House.

Comment on this

In these two Bills we are discussing two amendments to the Constitution. It is necessary to have them passed so that there may be an opportunity of submitting them, in a democratic way, to the people of the country by way of referendum. We will ask them whether they favour the single-seat constituency and the straight vote system. With confidence we hope and expect that the people will come down firmly in favour of both proposals so that future elections will be carried out under the straight vote system in single-seat constituencies.

We have heard quite a lot here about PR. It is a system imported into this country, as we all know, by the British Government because in the 1918 election the Irish people overwhelmingly decided they wanted to get rid of the British. In a referendum there was an alarming overall majority and that was distasteful from the British point of view and the British Government, with craft and cuteness, pawned off this obnoxious system on us, introducing it in 1920. That system was carried on after the Treaty had been accepted and it has been in existence here since. Many people have blamed Fianna Fáil because that system was allowed to be retained in our Constitution in 1937, but many of the young people today are not aware of the great difficulties, trials and tribulations this Party had to undergo in the early years of their existence after being established in 1926. However, Fianna Fáil carried through the Constitution which so many people have been so fond of and to which they were so diametrically opposed that they established a hostile, mobile force of Blueshirts, designed——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

To oppose the 1937 Constitution? That is a remarkable historical statement.

Comment on this

These are facts. This army of Blueshirts was founded in 1933——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They disappeared in 1936 and the Constitution was not until 1937.

Comment on this

I am glad I have raised a ripple over there.

Comment on this

Keep your ripples to yourself.

Comment on this

The children do not know as their forefathers did of the Blueshirts parading throughout the country trying to ensure that democratic rule would not be allowed to continue and that the will of the majority of the people would not be accepted.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In 1937?

Comment on this

These are bald, salient facts. It is the truth. The Senator may be learned in his own way as a professor, but I will keep on in my own way.

Comment on this

Provided you keep to the level of the truth. You know nothing about the Blueshirts.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Bury them.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will Senators allow Senator Dolan to continue on the Bill?

Comment on this

If what I am saying is not palatable, I cannot help it. I am only stating facts. That was the position in 1933 when this army was founded to try to upset our democratic institution. There was an economic war at the time and we know that many of these people favoured the British Government in their efforts, by tariffs and by refusal to take our cattle, to put the Irish nation out of existence. It was in a climate such as that that the Constitution was piloted through to remove from this country the right then in existence to avail of appeal to the King of England from decisions of the Supreme Court. Many people in this country at the time did not agree we should have these things removed but we in Fianna Fáil wanted to have our ports clear of the British Army. We wanted to be masters of our own fate, we wanted the Irish people to be supreme in their Government and their Constitution, owing allegiance to no outside power. That was the Fianna Fáil slant but it was not the slant of many others at that time.

In these circumstances, it was rather difficult for Fianna Fáil to pilot through the Constitution but, faithful as of old, the Irish people stood with us. I shall not go into the nice things that have been said and the only reason I mentioned this is that during that time, because this Government had so much on their plate by way of internal trouble and difficulties outside with the old traditional enemy, it was decided not to raise too many difficult issues and this question of PR was left in the Constitution. In doing so, however, we allowed the people, at a later date, the opportunity to decide——

Comment on this

It is enshrined in the Constitution, not left in. It is there, spoken for by the then Taoiseach who congratulated us for it.

Comment on this

As I have been trying to say, it was left in but an escape route, if you like, was left, so that at a later date, if they so wished, the Irish people could change the system. At present because we have an overall majority in Dáil Éireann and because it is only at a time like that you would get a Government to bring in such measures, we have now brought these Bills before the House so as to give the people an opportunity of deciding by referendum which of these they want, or both——

Comment on this

We will let you commit political suicide.

Comment on this

We have been a long time in office——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Would Senator Carton tell his Party to stop the cackle and let the Bills through?

Comment on this

The only thing you have to do is to go to the Park——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will Senators allow Senator Dolan to continue?

Comment on this

They had their Party up for sale not long ago and I do not think they got a bid. They have a good record for auctions. However, this ridiculous system of PR was kept on in the 1937 Constitution. Now, we sincerely hope, the people of Ireland will see through this difficult system which very few people understand. I am told on good authority that it is only a few learned university professors who are able to explain how this intricate, obnoxious system works. In an election under PR, very often when it comes to transferring votes the system works like this. Supposing the quota was 6,000 votes and that 7,000 votes were cast, 1,000 would be transferred. We know that the 1,000 votes are got by plucking at random 1,000 voting papers out of the 7,000. All you need is a pluck here and a pull there and you could have a different result each time.

Comment on this

The Senator is not doing too badly on a subject he knows nothing about.

Comment on this

If you do not understand it, that only bears out my point. We are trying to give the people a system whereby they can elect a Government. We do not want to perpetuate an obnoxious, intricate system the people do not understand. The majority of Irish people like to be straightforward in their dealings and nothing is more obnoxious than the man who is shilly-shallying. There is good in the individual if he is manly enough to be able to take the pencil in his hand and say: "I vote No. 1 for that man and I have no other choice." This business of asking him to vote for five people in order of his choice is ridiculous. People should be able to make up their minds and say: "This is the type of Government we want. We know their policies and we know what they have done in the past." We do not have to send voters in to mark up to 11 or 12 on their papers and have people at election counts going over to the blackboard with chalk, ready-reckoners, calculus and various higher mathematics, endeavouring to find out who won the seat. We had long counts in the last election, some of them going into the tenth or twelfth count. The Fine Gael people should remember that because they had their casualties in those long counts, too. We should get rid of this system. It is a system imported for the reasons I have stated. It is not in use in any country in the world I know of.

Comment on this

It is not suitable for an educated people?

Comment on this

Tá tú ceart go leor. There is not anything wrong with a system which the ordinary people can understand. I would hate to see an electoral system which the ordinary man in the street could not understand. A crooked system which mesmerises them should not be used. Fianna Fáil have come down firmly for the straight vote, and we hope that the people will support us in that if they get a chance. It is true that there was a referendum nine or ten years ago. Those of us who took part in it remember it was rather controversial because at the same time we were electing a President.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Did that make it more difficult for you to win it?

Comment on this

It never made it difficult for us to win it, but people might fall for the Opposition's propaganda that Fianna Fáil were doing this for selfish motives.

Comment on this

We would never do a thing like that.

Comment on this

At last you are falling into line with the thinking of the majority of the people who have given us their support for the past 40 years and for which we thank them. We hope in the future to give an even better account of ourselves and help the people along. Our previous proposal was rejected in the referendum and we are criticised now for bringing it before the people again. We feel we know what is good for the country. We do not put our own interests before those of the country. If we wanted to do that, we could sit tight, do nothing about it and allow all this carving up of constituencies to continue. We could allow coalition after coalition to take office for a month or a year and this would have a detrimental effect on the life of the country. We have not chosen that line. We are thinking of the future and of the people of Ireland.

We emphatically believe that the system we are now proposing is much better and for that reason we are putting it to the people. An election is held to elect a government. Therefore, the system should be simple and effective. We know that in the past, because of the PR system, we had Coalition Governments on a few occasions. They were groups of politicians of various political opinions who came together after the election was over to carve up the various ministerial posts among themselves and to form a government.

I will admit that the majority of these people were probably genuine and were making an honest attempt to give a government over a period, But we all know it is not easy to reconcile the various elements in a Coalition Government, in particular when many of the minorities would be pressing for more than their fair share of the national cake just because they hold certain ministerial posts. Despite the best intentions of whoever is the Taoiseach, I do not think a Government like that could have survived any longer. The people had their eyes on what was happening. Those in business would be reluctant to embark on new ventures because they were not sure of what would happen from day to day. They were afraid the Government would collapse in a week or a month. Foreign investors would not be inclined to embark on projects here when a Coalition Government were in power. For those reasons we have always felt Coalition Governments were disastrous.

Comment on this

Including the one you had yourselves, the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse?

Comment on this

I want to say emphatically that we in Fianna Fáil never took part in a Coalition Government. You can verify that fact quite easily. We have never doled out ministerial posts to various Parties seeking to form a Government behind the backs of the electorate. We have always stood firmly on our own policies. We said that if we did not get the support of the majority of Deputies in the Chamber we were prepared to walk over to the other side. We did that. That is why we have been in office so long and have been returned so often. We have never liked the idea of a Coalition, which would not be for the betterment of the Irish nation. A coalition may, with a certain amount of experience, last for a while, but coalitions are bad and we would never subscribe to such an arrangement. We have never done so and never shall. As a Party, we would gladly and willingly walk into the Opposition benches rather than do this behind the backs of the people. That has never been our way of thinking at all and I think the people understand that fairly well.

Business suspended at 6.05 p.m. and resumed at 7.15 p.m.

Comment on this

Before we adjourned, I was referring to Coalition Governments. I was about to say I thought they were bad for the economy and for the country generally, the reason being, of course, that these Coalition Governments were composed of different elements purporting to put separate policies before the people prior to an election and then coming together after the election, behind the backs of the electorate, and forming a Government and a Cabinet of their own. There is a difference between that and what is called a minority Government, where one single Party has its own Cabinet and gets the support of individual Deputies. Such a Government could make some progress and do some good for the country. There would be a united Cabinet having the one policy, and it would not be a matter of one Minister vying with another, as would happen in a Coalition, in an effort to get some Party advantage.

These two Bills are necessary. A decline has taken place in the rural population and it is necessary to reexamine this whole question of constituencies, their boundaries, their extent, populations and so forth. We believe that the single-seat constituency is the best in the present circumstances. It will mean that very few county boundaries will have to be breached in order to comply with the decision that was taken in the High Court in 1961. At that time many of our county boundaries were breached. Parts of Leitrim found themselves in County Roscommon, and parts of Kildare, Meath and Westmeath were all lumped together to form a constituency. That is not good, irrespective of what Senator Dooge may have said regarding the founding of counties going back to the time of King John. It is true they have been a long time in existence. It is over 300 years since the last county was founded. That is a fairly long tradition. Rural people and, I am sure, city people as well, take a certain pride in their own county, whether it be in relation to football or in relation to anyone belonging to their county representing that county in any contest at home or abroad. It is only right and proper that we should have a certain amount of pride in our own parishes and in our own counties, and certainly in rural Ireland we do not like to see county boundaries being breached because of that tradition.

Along with that, there is the administration unit of the county council which has jurisdiction within the county boundaries. If the counties are broken up, there is the difficult problem of Deputies having to deal with various county councils in relation to matters appertaining to their constituencies. My own constituency is a three-seater, and under the new arrangement, without breaching the county boundaries, we would still have a three-seat constituency. I think this would be a much more pleasing solution to the problem than to have us amalgamated with our neighbours in Monaghan, who are also Ulster people. We like them and they are our neighbours. This would give us a five-seat constituency which would extend from Belcoo Bridge which is 25 miles from Sligo and Bundoran, across Glan Gap and up to Belturbet and Killeshandra in Cavan, down to Virginia, into Clones and as far as Ardee in Louth. That would be a rather unwieldy constituency for any one Deputy to try to represent. A Fine Gael Deputy who is a Monaghan man said such an arrangement would be right into his barrow, but perhaps he was in a jocular mood. The real fact is that Cavan people would appreciate if this three-seat constituency were divided into three different units and let the best horse jump the ditch so far as representation is concerned.

Senator O'Sullvan said that Fianna Fáil would gerrymander these constituencies to suit themselves. Nothing could be further from the truth than that statement. This did not happen in the past and it will not happen in the future. He quoted the case of mid-Cork. He was a Member of Dáil Éireann at the time and he agreed with that division. He did not vote against it. When a by-election took place some years later, it was a Fine Gael candidate who gained the seat, so it was not a matter of gerrymandering to suit the interests of Fianna Fáil.

In the new set-up, there will be a Commission which will deal with these boundaries, and set them up. Fianna Fáil will have no majority on that Commission. That is a fair method of doing it. Apart from that, we do not like to see a decline of population in rural Ireland. These are facts. We do not like to see a decline in our representation in the National Parliament. We do not like to see the cities overloaded, as it were, with Deputies. We appreciate the difficulties of the people representing rural Ireland because those areas are sparsely populated and communications may not be too good. We believe that a certain amount of tolerance in that respect is fully justified. Fine Gael should approach it from the same angle. They should be concerned about the rural population.

It may be that Fine Gael Deputies may have their eye on city constituencies, as I think they have, and they may be more interested in seeing a big increase in the representation in the city areas, and a decline in the rural areas. I would not like to visualise what would happen in Mayo, Leitrim, Roscommon or Galway, if this single-seat proposition is not carried, because we will have multi-seat constituencies. They will be very unwieldy and no account will be taken of the county boundaries as they exist at present.

We in Fianna Fáil were totally against PR from the beginning because we felt it was a lottery system which the average voter did not understand, or few understood, and that it encouraged people to be rather hesitant in making decisions. We prefer a system under which the people could come down firmly and strongly on the side of one Party or another. Indeed, if we follow the pattern of recent by-elections, we can see that up to 80 per cent of the people who voted followed that line of thinking because there were thousands of "plumpers" in these by-elections. Furthermore, preference was exercised in only 20 per cent of the total vote.

It has been argued that it might be better for the Government to spend the money which will be involved in this referendum on other useful work, as it is called. I feel, and I am sure the people of Ireland feel, that the most useful work that could be done in the circumstances is to ensure that the electorate themselves will know what they are doing when they are choosing a Government. It has been proved over the years that the system of proportional representation is not decisive. Very often, a second election has had to be held to ensure that the Government would have an overall majority. It has been estimated that, since 1948, there have been 24 small Parties in existence, many of them grouping to form a Coalition, so to speak. While many individual members of those Parties might have the interests of the country very much at heart—or think they have—certainly they had their own sectional interests at heart.

It has been said that, if this Bill goes through, Fianna Fáil will sweep the country at the next general election. That is a wonderful compliment. We do not want to boast about our achievements but we cannot be blamed for being rather proud of them. However, I feel that some of the Opposition's estimates are based on the results of the last local government elections and do not take into account the votes secured by people because they were local or because they had particular ties or loyalties in those areas so that, in fact, very often such votes are strictly not Party votes at all.

The Opposition say that Fianna Fáil will secure at least 93 seats at the next general election if proportional representation is abolished. I do not think they are justified in saying so. However, Fianna Fáil will put their policy to the people and will not enter into a Coalition. Fianna Fáil will try to implement their policy to the best of their ability. Surely a Government who are prepared to risk their popularity by going to the country so as to give an opportunity to the people themselves—who, in the long run, are the masters—to decide what is right, must obviously have the interests of the nation at heart?

Comment on this

It has been asserted that this legislation is all Fianna Fáil thinking and that the subject of proportional representation never raised its head so far as any of the Opposition Parties are concerned. Senator Yeats quoted from various journals and papers to show that many prominent people in the Opposition are in favour of the straight vote. As a comparatively young man, I had a great admiration for Deputy Cosgrave who is now the Leader of the Opposition. I thought him very fair-minded. His father fought against the British in this country at a time when people were badly needed. The son, Liam, always conveyed the idea to me that he was a good leader, that he could think for himself and make up his own mind. It is on record, and it has not been denied, that, as Leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Cosgrave has declared his implicit faith in the straight vote. If arguments from the Government side of the House would not weigh with the Opposition, one would think arguments from a man such as the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Cosgrave, would weigh heavily with them when they come to make their choice.

It is also true that a former Minister in the Coalition declared proportional representation to be ludicrous, to be a fraud and a cod, and he said it ought to be abolished. He said it is the brainchild of cranks and, so far as this country is concerned, it was tried out on the dog, foisted on us by half-lunatics and would work on paper like a jig-saw puzzle. Words to that effect were said by Deputy Dillon on 26th March, 1947. Other prominent people within the ranks of Fine Gael held similar views. Deputy J.A. Costello was once Taoiseach of this country. He said on one occasion that proportional representation is imperfect, that, on paper, it might work all right but, in practice, it has many difficulties.

I mention those views to show that, within the ranks of the present Opposition, many people who rank high in Fine Gael—people who have had positions of trust and responsibility given to them or thrust upon them—do not hold with proportional representation and have not made their statements lightly or without consideration. At no time, so far as I know, have they spoken against the straight vote but they have said that proportional representation is not the best system for any country or for a country such as ours. We in Fianna Fáil have always believed that to be so. We believe emphatically that, this time, the Irish public will realise that it is in their political interest to vote for the straight vote electoral system. There are something like 400,000 extra people on the register today as compared with 1959.

If the full facts are put to them plainly and honestly, we believe that the people will decide that Fianna Fáil are acting in the interests of the people and not, as is being hinted, in the interests of the Fianna Fáil Party. We are giving them an opportunity to give themselves a system which will make it easier for them to get rid of us, if that is their desire. It will give them the strongest possible weapon to approve or disapprove of the actions and policies of a Government or a Party. Furthermore, under the straight vote system, there will always be an Opposition ready to take over from an outgoing Government.

If anything happened to Fianna Fáil it is deplorable that not one of the Opposition Paries is fit to take over. That is a poor state of affairs. It is perfectly true that our accomplishments, while we had an overall majority or a comfortable majority in Dáil Éireann, are something any Party could be proud of. I say in all sincerity that these two Bills are very important to the life of the nation and that we are looking very far ahead. We feel the people should be given this system; they should give this system to themselves. We feel, too, that this matter of tolerance is very important to rural Ireland. Combining the two measures, I feel the people who will sit down and think the matter out for themselves will decide to adopt an electoral system which they and their neighbours understand, a system without any of the intricacies or any of the difficulties by way of calculation or otherwise that are in the present system. They will get rid of this system and we will forge ahead with a new system which will be used by future generations to decide quickly and effectively whether they believe a Government are doing the best they can for the people or not.

Comment on this

It would be possible for me, remembering the debate in 1959, to get up and simply say: "See the Seanad Debates, Volume 50, columns 443 to 471." I imagine that a number of Senators might prefer me to do this, but I am afraid that this is not in my nature, and I feel constrained to put the case again in favour of proportional representation and the single transferable vote in face of the repeated effort on the part of Fianna Fáil to abolish it. On the last occasion it was said to us that we should leave it to the electorate to decide and my answer to that was: "Yes, by all means; but let us first of all give our advice to the electorate; let us state a reasoned case why the electorate would be well advised to retain PR, and let us also employ the only power we have in the Seanad to delay this legislation for 90 days, in order to give the electorate full time to ponder the strength of our case for retention and of the Fianna Fáil case for abolition."

The Seanad on that occasion defeated the measure by one vote, and it had to go back to the Dáil, and the Dáil had to pass a resolution deeming that the measure had been passed by the Seanad and the delay was of 90 days. We all know the result and I will come to that later on, but I can claim that I foresaw the result for at column 471 at the end of my speech I said:

...if the referendum does go to the people, the result may well surprise Fianna Fáil, because many voters who have lately voted for Fianna Fáil, ...will not vote, as Fianna Fáil asks them, for the abolition of PR, but will preserve in the hands of the electors all the valuable discriminatory powers which PR at present enables them to wield.

This turned out to be the case. Although the Presidential election was held at the same time, and although Mr. de Valera was strongly and publicly committed to the abolition of PR, the people's answer to these two questions—(a) Whom do you want for President and (b) Do you want to abolish PR? —showed a measure of political maturity which I and many like me found encouraging, because while President de Valera was elected by 538,003 votes against General MacEoin's 407,536, a majority of 127,467, the vote for the retention of PR was 486,989 against those who voted for the abolition, 453,322.

I ask the House to note that while Mr. de Valera as a person gained a majority of over 120,000 votes the policy that he advocated in relation to PR on that occasion was defeated by 33,000 votes. In other words, there was a swing from the personal vote for Mr. de Valera against the abolition of PR of some 150,000 votes; or to put it another way, the difference in fact between the vote for Mr. de Valera and the vote against PR was over 84,000 votes. This question, then, that is before us today has been duly referred to the tribunal of the people, and we are entitled to ask the Government: "Why do you refuse to accept the people's verdict? Why do you refuse the verdict of this tribunal to which it was referred?" We were asked: "Why not leave it to the people", and we said: "Yes, with our advice and time to reflect", and the people decided.

It was referred to the tribunal of the people and it is quite obvious that the circumstance of the votes being taken at the time for such a special candidate as Éamon de Valera for the Presidency was very strongly in favour of the Fianna Fáil view; yet the people rejected the abolition of PR. Why, therefore, must we go back again now? I do not feel that that question has been fully answered by either the Minister or those who spoke in favour of abolition. I was rather surprised to hear Senator Dolan say—and I was a little apprehensive, when I saw the papers before him, that perhaps what I ventured to call before "the single transferable speech" was again being handed around in the ranks of Fianna Fáil, but I do not think it was a transferable speech and as far as I could see it was all his own work—but he did say that PR was "obnoxious", "ridiculous" and that it was "intricate". He slid over the fact that this was not merely retained in the Fianna Fáil Constitution of 1937 but was enshrined in it, as Senator O'Sullivan said. It was a fresh Constitution, freshly devised, and there was no earthly reason to put it in if it was, as Senator Dolan said, ridiculous, obnoxious and intricate. Why was it put into the 1937 Constitution which was sponsored by his Party? He does not answer why.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He did.

Comment on this

I did answer it.

Comment on this

That was when the Senator was snoring.

Comment on this

I hear interruptions from Senator Ó Maoláin, from Senator Dolan and from the Minister but I am afraid that they blend so harmoniously that I only get the chord. I did not hear an answer to my question. He only referred to the Blueshirts in 1933, and my view of the Blueshirts would be precisely that of Senator Ó Maoláin; and I imagine many of the younger Members of Fine Gael would feel much as we do, but I did not hear why Fianna Fáil felt obliged to put into the Constitution something which was obnoxious, ridiculous and intricate.

Comment on this

The explanation is there.

Comment on this

Why do Fianna Fáil put before us things that are obnoxious? Why do they sponsor the ridiculous? What element in Fianna Fáil gives such support to the absurd, the ridiculous, the obnoxious, the hateful? I did not hear Senator Dolan explain that, not to my satisfaction. The fresh Constitution was devised and into this Constitution was put something that I regard as wholly admirable, but which we are now asked to believe was ridiculous and obnoxious. It was not less intricate then, was it less ridiculous or less obnoxious? I am still waiting for a coherent answer to that question. It may come from later speeches but I have not heard it yet.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator inviting answers or interruptions or will he wait until later on?

Comment on this

I should be very pleased if you, a Chathaoirleach, would allow a coherent answer, but I am not sure whether the Misleader of the House is able to give that kind of answer.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If the Senator consults the "Thoughts of Mao", perhaps he might get some information in them.

Comment on this

I am afraid I am not one of those who kowtow to Mao. I am afraid Senator Ó Maoláin is under a serious misapprehension, perhaps owing to the fact that his own name starts off with much the same syllable. Shall we call him "Ó Maoláin?"

I listened with great interest to Senator Yeats in a similar state of confusion; he claimed that the Irish people did not really understand this system; Senator Dolan said much the same thing.

Comment on this

Many of them.

Comment on this

How many of them.

Comment on this

I was not suggesting the Senator said all of them. The point he made was that a large number, sufficiently large to be significant, did not understand the system. Senator Dolan said much the same thing.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They do not.

Comment on this

Senator Yeats said that, when there are a whole host of candidates before them, they find it difficult to sort them out and express preferences. I should like to say that one improvement introduced lately is very good; that is that the Party affiliations of the various candidates are now shown on the ballot paper. That should have been done long ago. They are now shown, and this is a step forward, and it is perfectly easy to spot the candidates from the Party one supports, and it is quite easy to express one's preferences.

Comment on this

Not more than one-tenth of the papers are filled up completely.

Comment on this

That may be quite true, but I do not think Senator Yeats can claim, on the one hand, that the very low preferences have no significance and, on the other hand, complain because numbers of the people do not fill in these lower preferences. It is quite true that, in general, the upper preferences are more frequently filled. It is true there is a multiplicity of names on the ballot paper, but I can assure Senator Yeats that it is quite within the compass of the intelligence of the ordinary Irish voter to express preferences over a fairly wide range. I am inclined to ask Senator Yeats, when next he is in a betting shop, to note the kind of combinations of preferences expressed by the average punter. If the average punter goes in with a 1/- accumulator on six horses, he knows exactly what should be carried forward from horse to horse.

Comment on this

I am glad the Senator agrees with me that PR is like backing horses.

Comment on this

If the punter express his preferences for a cross double or cross treble and relates that to four horses, he can actually get six cross doubles or four cross trebles, and the ordinary Irish punter is quite well aware of these facts and you will find him following up an each way double or an each way treble with the greatest of ease.

Comment on this

I do not know what they are.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Much easier than dividing a surplus.

Comment on this

Senator Yeats, when I meet him in a turf accountant's office, always wears a long beard, but I have no doubt at all that Senator Yeats is every bit as intelligent as these punters and will be able to lay his 1/- accumulator with just as much acumen as they do and calculate the odds with just as much ease.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I challenge the Senator to go into any pub or bookie's office and take the first ten people he meets and ask them how a surplus is divided.

Comment on this

If I might continue, I am quite convinced that, when a man puts on an each way double or treble, he is quite capable not merely of calculating what he will get if his first horse is placed at 6 to 5 and he is entitled to a quarter of the odds, plus the odds on the winner, if the horse happens to win, and quite capable of realising that that will be carried forward, plus his initial stake; and, if on the next horse he gets 11 to 8, but is only entitled to a quarter of the odds because the horse is only placed, he realises what will be carried forward to the third horse and, if the third horse is 7 to 4, the punter knows exactly how many pounds, shillings and pence he is entitled to, less tax, of course.

Comment on this

Could we now come to the Third and Fourth Amendments?

Comment on this

That being so, I reject the view of Senator Yeats that the ordinary Irish voter has not got enough intelligence to understand a voting paper and to express quite simple preferences——

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this

——for ten or 20 candidates, marking them one, two, three, four in the order of his preferences.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is Mao tactics. That is not what Senator Yeats said.

Comment on this

I appreciate the tribute paid to me by Senator Ó Maoláin. Mere invective and shouting is a clear demonstration that my case is solid.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Yeats did not say what the Senator says he said.

Comment on this

Senator Yeats quite emphatically said that many of the voters did not understand the system——

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

——and were consequently incapable of registering their preferences over a long list. I am suggesting that they are quite capable of doing so, not only in the turf accountant's office, not only in the polling booth, but also in relation to competitions every Sunday in the Sunday Press. There you find people every Sunday expressing very marked preferences as between, for instance, a high buttoned double-breasted suit in beige-caramel check, or a navy crepe worsted suit, side fastened with gold loops and tiny belt, or a pebblestone tweed suit, in pink-blue mixture, double-breasted jacket and buttoned to the neck, or again a tastefully designed suit with welted seaming in fine wool tweed.

Comment on this

The Senator knows this is not a matter of judgement. This is just gambling.

Comment on this

I am sorry——

Comment on this

There is no element of judgement involved in these competitions. It is pure gambling.

Comment on this

There is judgement involved.

Comment on this

I am sorry Senator Yeats is reluctant to allow me at least to finish a sentence. His claim is cruelly damaging to the newspaper in question. This is certainly our greatest Sunday newspaper, bar none, and the amount of money that is sent into it and the jury that decides on the skill of the competitors is all set forth here for Senator Yeats to examine.

Comment on this

It is still a lottery.

Comment on this

And, if he claims it is a pure lottery, that is a grave disappointment to those of us who have been going in for this competition week after week, hoping to win a Fiat or even an Escort at the end of our expression of preferences.

Comment on this

If the Senator shut his eyes, he would have just as good a chance.

Comment on this

This is very disappointing, but nevertheless I think these examples demonstrate that it is by no means impossible to ask the ordinary Irish person to express a preference. If they can express their preference between the kind of costumes I have read out— the high buttoned double-breasted suit in beige-caramel check as opposed to the pebblestone tweed suit —I see no reason why these same people should not express quite coherently a preference between, say, Senator Michael Yeats and Deputy Brendan Corish or Deputy Liam Cosgrave, or for the more subtle differences between Senator Michael Yeats and Deputy Martin Corry, for instance, standing in the same Party interest. This being so, I feel Senator Yeats has not quite accepted the fact that voters with power to discriminate are there in the polling booth, and exercise there this discriminatory power. Senator Yeats also said there is "a random element" in the PR system. That is perfectly true, but it is in fact statistically insignificant. It is perfectly true that the physical transfer of some surplus votes is, as it were, fortuitous but, nevertheless, the numbers are such that the random element is very small and is not statistically significant.

Comment on this

There could be thousands of votes involved.

Comment on this

Further, I would say that everything in life has a random element about it, even some of the speeches of Senator Yeats seem to me to contain more than the average random element. There is something, however, that is not random to which the attention of the House should be drawn, that is, that under the so-called straight-vote system or the plumper system or the straitjacket system, which enables you just to vote once and that is all, you can have a large number of minority MPs. Senator Ryan and Senator Dolan both asked how, if Fianna Fáil had not got a majority support, could they possibly, with the change in the electoral system, win a big majority of seats? The answer is, they might well win a big majority of seats on a minority of votes, and I should like to quote figures in support of that. I quote, as I intend to quote further, from a very compelling book Voting in Democracies by Enid Lakeman and——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is enough.

Comment on this

——James D. Lambert. I did not expect quite the neigh of laughter from Senator Yeats that we got, but I did expect Fianna Fáil laughter because I remember on every single occasion when Miss Lakeman was either speaking or writing to the papers here, she wiped the floor with Fianna Fáil statistically and factually and, logically enough, they foam at the mouth now when they hear of Miss Enid Lakeman. Not one has answered her effectively and her letters appear now unanswered, even in the Irish Press, and even Senator Yeats is not answering them except by this rather raucous laughter, the explanation of which Oliver Goldsmith has given us some years ago.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They have more sense.

Comment on this

The reference to the minority MP in this volume is to the minority MP in the British Parliament only and I am going to read this table on to the record of the House because I think it is important to have it for reference.

The table gives for elections from 1918 to 1955 the total number of seats won by the minority candidates, that is to say, by candidates who under the so-called straight vote system, got less than half the votes in their constituency but were nevertheless elected, and I read it as follows: In 1918, there were 94 seats won by minority candidates; in 1922, 176; in 1923, 216; in 1924, 120; in 1929, 315; in 1931, 33; in 1935, 58; in 1945, 177; in 1950, 187; in 1951, 39; in 1955, 37.

I draw attention of the House to the fact that, as Miss Lakeman and Mr. Lambert say, the Party with the second largest number of votes actually won the 1929 election when there was the record number of 315 minority seats. This is what the Fianna Fáil speakers may well laughingly call "the straight vote" in which you could have nearly half the Parliament elected in constituencies where their candidate failed to get a majority.

I quote just one constituency, the constituency of Conway, in which, in the general election of 1950, the candidate Jones, for the Labour Party, was elected and he got 15,176 votes. The Conservative candidate, Price-White, got 14,373 votes and the Liberal candidate, Hodson, got 9,937 votes. The man who got elected got 15,000 and the votes cast against him were over 24,000.

Comment on this

That is codology.

Comment on this

They do not like that.

Comment on this

If there is a sort of howl of interruptions, I cannot understand them. I am quite happy to be interrupted by, say, three at a time.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

This is what is going to be merged into the University of Dublin. God help the students.

Comment on this

This is my answer to the question asked both by Deputy Ryan and Deputy Dolan: how could you possibly get a government elected under the straight vote system unless it had majority support in the country? This is the answer: you can get a candidate elected by the split vote, and this is really the system that is called the straight vote. It is the split vote system, and everywhere where you have three or more candidates—and in most Irish constituencies there are at least three—the votes will be split and very frequently, perhaps as frequently as in Britain down the years from 1918 to 1955, minority candidates will get elected and it is perfectly possible, as I have shown, even for the government itself to get elected by minority votes.

Senator Yeats also defends the statement that, as far as he knew, under the straight vote system no Party ever got a two-thirds majority.

Comment on this

Oh, no; that is not what I said.

Comment on this

He is making it up as he goes along.

Comment on this

This was in relation to the suggestion that Fianna Fáil would get 95 seats on less than 40 per cent of the votes. I said it had never happened and could not happen that a Party got a two-thirds majority on less than 40 per cent of the poll.

Comment on this

That is democracy.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I used to think that Senator Quinlan was tops but Senator Sheehy Skeffington beats him.

Comment on this

I accept this correction and the record will show whether this is very well remembered. I am not shedding any doubt upon it but I am referring to occasions: in 1924, when the Conservative Party, with 47 per cent of the votes, got 67 per cent of the seats and, in 1931, with 55 per cent of the votes, got 76 per cent of the seats, and in 1935, with 54 per cent of the votes, got 70 per cent of the seats.

This split vote system or straitjacket vote system is the system whereby the minority may well, if they can also contrive the boundaries of the constituencies to their satisfaction, get a majority, a big majority, in Parliament, and this is what all of us here ought to be afraid of.

Senator Yeats also quoted at length from the Cumann na nGaedheal policy and—I suppose, the ad hominem argument is a legitimate one in debate— he quoted several Cumann na nGaedheal and Fine Gael speakers who in the past were opposed to PR, but, surely, it is legitimate to ask Senator Yeats, through you, Sir, is it not possible to conceive that on these occasions Cumann na nGaedheal were wrong and that now Fianna Fáil are wrong; or must we say that Cumann na nGaedheal, of course, were right and, therefore, Fianna Fáil were right now? I prefer the first conclusion: Cumann na nGaedheal were certainly wrong then, and Fianna Fáil are certainly wrong now.

I noted the phrase of Senator Yeats when he said it is hard to know where Fianna Fáil policy starts and where it stops.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

This is dreadful.

Comment on this

I am sorry but I noted this as it was being said and I am certain that it was in these words it was said.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It was not.

Comment on this

I note the Senator's indignant denial but these are the words he used.

Comment on this

They are not the words I used.

Comment on this

"It is hard to know where Fine Gael policy starts and where it stops."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator said "Fianna Fáil" just now.

Comment on this

You have no policy.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator is doting.

Comment on this

Senator Sheehy Skeffington to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have no policy. He was speaking about our policy.

Mr. P. O'Reilly (Longford) rose.

Comment on this

Senator O'Reilly to resume his seat.

Comment on this

I accept the revised version.

Comment on this

If I made a slip of the tongue, I apologise to the House and to Senator Yeats. The words were : "It is hard to know where Fine Gael policy starts and where it stops." I propose to tell Senator Yeats where it stops. It stops in Fianna Fáil, presumably. Senator Yeats quoted the policy of Fine Gael when they were opposed to PR. Now he is opposed to it and so are his Party. Therefore, the answer to his question is that it starts in Fine Gael and stops in Fianna Fáil. I hope Senator Yeats is satisfied with the answer.

The case made for the abolition of PR is based largely on four points. The first is that we would get better TDs under this plumper voting system; the second is that there would be great stability of Government; the third is that we would be unlikely to get ad hoc coalitions; and the fourth that we would be avoiding multiplicity of Parties. Let us examine these four points.

The first is that we would get better TDs. This point has already been dealt with well by Senator D.J. O'Sullivan. However, I cannot help imagining the scene in which the Taoiseach had a look at the Dáil and decided that they were a pretty scruffy-looking lot and that he could do a lot better. I can imagine him saying: "I see a chap over there whom we could improve on. There are quite a number of TDs here whom we could improve on". It is not clear whether it is the same people who will be improved on by a new process of election or whether lurking in the background there are potential model TDs who do not come forward, who do not get elected or selected or nominated because the electoral system so far has not satisfied their philosophy, their ethos. It may be it will be the same TDs but greatly improved because it will be a different system. I cannot see it. I regard that as complete hokum.

I feel that the Dáil—and the Seanad too for that matter, but the Dáil particularly being more directly elected— mirrors the feeling of the country and expresses the political aspirations of the people. Only too well, one sometimes thinks, but it reflects the feelings of the country. Edmund Burke said: "The virtue, the spirit, the essence of the House of Commons, consists in its being the express image of the feelings of the nation," and this "express image" is safeguarded, this parliamentary express image, under PR. Consequently, the PR system, which gives a full, clear and coherent image of the aspirations of the people, is most desirable for the community's peace of mind.

They tell us we will get better TDs under the single-seat system. Better from whose point of view? In what way will they be better? I have a suspicion it will be mainly from the point of view of the Party bosses, who find it much easier to manage TDs who are sane, safe and docile backbenchers, who will give no trouble to the Party machine. Under this system, only one person will be selected for each Party in each constituency and he had better be a good boy or he will not be nominated. They will not run the risk of letting the voter decide as to whether number one, two, three or four of the Fianna Fáil candidates shall top the poll. Up to now it has been within the power of the voters to decide, even in the case of Ministers, that they prefer younger men, more active men, and Ministers have even been defeated because of this by members of their own Parties, and the Party bosses, and the Ministers, dislike it, but the voters have had the power of making such decisions.

Party bosses, of course, want the decision to be made by the Party, by the inner caucus. Therefore, when they say they will get better TDs, they mean more docile TDs. The present backbenchers in the Dáil have very little real power, because the real power is exercised within the inner caucus of the Party, and it would seem that the only backbencher with real power today is the one who writes in Saturday's Irish Times. However, with the Dáil, if we want to improve the working capacity of TDs, the Government, if they are sincere, will extend the system of all-Party Committees in which a good deal of the drudgery work attached to legislation will be carried out, and from such a process you will get better backbenchers because they will be backbenchers with more responsibility and effective legislative power than at present.

It is realised that a backbencher today has as little effective power beyond that to persuade, as we have now in the Seanad. Does the term "better TD" mean that he will be a better TD in his constituency? I detest the concept of a TD as a kind of a local fixer, a man who fixes thing up, who uses his "influence", but, even if one were to take this rather narrow concept of the duties of a parliamentarian, I suggest that in a constituency where there are at least two other Members of Parliament representing the same constituency in different interests, the voter is more likely to get more alacrity from a TD with colleagues in his own constituency than where the TD is the sole representative in the constituency. Where there is rivalry between TDs in the same constituency, the voter will get more action than where the TD feels himself to be alone representing the constituency. Of course, a great amount of this work could be avoided for the TD by some system for dealing with legitimate complaints such as an ombudsman as they have in other countries.

The second argument used against PR and in favour of this so-called straight vote system is that you get greater stability of government, stronger government. Senator Stanford dealt well with that point. I realise, of course, that Fianna Fáil, who can get a unanimous decision from 1,500 voters at an Ard Fheis—a unanimous decision—appear to be pretty strongly governed. I do not think even the meetings in the Soviet Union get such a measure of unanimity. I remember votes in the Soviet Academy of Science on the Lysenko policy of 698 for and two against, a result Fianna Fáil can better.

I argue that sometimes a Government who are not too stable, too secure, too self-satisfied, are better for the country, because they are more sensitive to public opinion. Such a Government could not snap their fingers at public opinion. If they are not too secure, too safe with a big overall majority, they can be tipped out of office and therefore they have to be amenable to public opinion, have to endeavour to fulfil promises made. Stability does not necessarily mean actual strength, and in this connection I refer to the situation in Britain in 1931. I happened to be in London during the few days when the election results were coming in in November, 1931. I remember the political atmosphere and of course the National Government swept the country in that election. The result was that 14,532,519 votes went to the National Government. All other Parties got 7,123,854, just about half of the Government poll. Incidentally, the National Government on that vote—it was a two to one vote throughout the country—got 544 seats in Parliament, while all others got 61. This is the system that is laughingly known as the straight vote. We had a taste of it the other day in the Beet Growers Association election. In 1935 similar figures were shown, with 433 seats for the National Government and 182 against. The result was that this National Government remained solidly in power with a colossal majority for nine long years. What years were they? They were the years from November, 1931, to April, 1940. The year 1931 was two years before Hitler came to power in Germany and April, 1940, was the date of the collapse of France and the defeat of the British in Narvik. They had this stable Government for these nine long years. They had a colossal majority. Nobody could say their majority was not big enough. They were nine long years in unbroken power with immense stability from two years before Hitler to April, 1940. What was Winston Churchill's verdict on that Government? He said in 1940: "Never has a great nation been so naked before her foes". This being so, it makes nonsense of any claims that stability equals strength. A Government may well have an enormous majority and be so stable that it need not listen to anybody. It can be both arrogant and weak, and that is what the National Government in Britain was in those days—arrogant and weak. I say to the present Fianna Fáil Government: "Beware; there are signs of justification for both these adjectives in relation to the present Government."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Has the Senator forgotten that the National Government had Baldwin?

Comment on this

It had Baldwin and Ramsay MacDonald. I am prepared to speak at greater length if you consider it to be in order for me, and go into the various deficiencies of that Government. I mentioned the fact that it had a colossal majority, stayed in unbroken power for nine years and yet left the country naked to its foes, to quote Churchill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They had Baldwin. The Senators know the history of what happened.

Comment on this