We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 170–357 of 357. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Your explanation is one person?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Correct.

Comment on this

If they had Tomás Ó Maoláin as Prime Minister, I have no doubt he would have made a better show——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They would have been disarmed.

Comment on this

——but it is possible he might have made a show of himself.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I would have liquidated the Senator, anyway.

Comment on this

I am reasonably confident of the kind heart of the Senator lurking behind this rather sturdy exterior. I do not think he would have liquidated me, but merely locked me up for the duration.

In June, 1938, in arguing this case— I do not want to quote Canon Luce at length again; I did so the last time and those interested can see what was said—Canon Luce said: "A Government with a majority of six under PR is infinitely stronger than a Government with a majority of 60 elected otherwise." I am sure he is right because "elected otherwise" covers a multitude of sins, including minority MPs and even minority Governments.

The so-called straight vote is said to give a Government with big majority. We were told that endlessly here in 1959. In those days we had before us, nevertheless, the example of the Attlee Government of 1950, whose majority was only six in a House of Commons of 625—a tiny majority. That Government lasted for 18 months and in October, 1951, with a big poll in a general election, 83 per cent, the Conservatives came back with a majority of how many seats—a majority of 17. Two successive elections in Britain under the "straight vote" gave tiny majorities in a House of 625. Since then, in 1964 of course, they had a general election in Britain in which the Labour Government under Harold Wilson was returned with a majority of four. So the straight vote system which is being boasted about so much in the Fianna Fáil benches in the Dáil and Seanad, does not produce one of the things promised, that is to say, a big majority.

I have been talking about the United Kingdom where the so-called straight vote is in operation, but let me turn now to Ireland and have a look at our own Parliament since its beginning. I would remind the House that the time when there was the biggest Government majority in the Dáil and the smallest parliamentary Opposition was from 1922 to 1927. The Government majority in the Parliament, then expressed in several votes, amounted to something like 71 votes to 20. On, for instance, the 1925 Agreement the major vote was a vote "for" of 71 and "against"—largely Labour votes —of 20. This was the time when Fianna Fáil were abstaining from the Dáil. Do they now maintain that because of this big parliamentary majority that Government was our best Government yet? Can it be maintained by Fianna Fáil that the best Government yet in this country was from 1922 to 1927 because of the immense parliamentary strength of the Government? Would they regard it as necessarily the stablest and strongest Government? Or would they argue, as indeed I would, that some of the worst actions of that Government—I have not forgotten them—sprang rather from its weakness than from its strength? There is no point in going into detail there, because this can obviously be substantiated.

In 1927 Fianna Fáil came in. I know it gives offence if I mention the circumstances, so I shall not. From 1927 to 1932, they were there as a big and active Opposition. Since the parliamentary Opposition was much increased between 1927 and 1932, would Fianna Fáil today contend that, because the Government's majority was seriously reduced, the country was governed in a far less stable way? Was this one of the main results of Fianna Fáil coming into Parliament? Surely not? We must all recognise today that with Fianna Fáil as a big and effective Opposition the country was better governed, and that its stability has in fact continued to this day, to such an extent, in fact, that on 2nd September, 1958, the Manchester Guardian said:

Under PR the Irish Republic, formerly the Free State, has enjoyed about the stablest Government in Europe.

I am making the point in relation to stability that there is a danger of the Government being too "strong", being all-powerful, in fact, and being complacent in its unshakable power. The influence of critics within the Party, if there are such—and one hopes that there are some in every big Party—is seriously diminished by their Government's large majority. Look at Britain today, and you can see that critics inside and outside the Party with a big majority and in Government can be ignored. You can get the arrogance of the over-powerful Party in government. It is a very bad thing to have a Government so strong that they can afford to ignore public opinion. There is a dangerous, so-called stability which derives from parliamentary majorities being grossly disproportionate to the vote recorded in the country.

The example of France is sometimes mentioned. In fact, they have not got PR. They had it for a short time between 1945 and 1951, though even at that time it was the list system. This enabled the party bosses to decide which candidates on the list should benefit from the proportion of votes going to each Party. That was under the party list system of PR. Now they have this first round and second round which is a kind of modified system allowing voters to make a second choice. If on the first round no candidate gets more than 50 per cent, there is a second vote or poll in that constituency the following week. If, on the first poll, any candidate gets more than 50 per cent of the votes he or she is elected, and that is the end of the voting in that constituency. But if there is a second round, all candidates except those who got less than 10 per cent of the votes may remain in the field; but in effect those who have very little chance usually stand down in favour of others, and you get a second vote on fewer candidates in the same constituency. This is a sort of limited form of transferable or second preference vote. They try to do by a cruder method what we do by a very well devised and well working machine. Let us notice that when they did have the PR list system in 1945 the person elected to be Prime Minister arising out of that election was President Charles De Gaulle. Not even his worst critics would accuse him of being unstable in power. I do not think the effect of list PR then was to produce instability. I recognise that he resigned and went off into the wilderness for a time, but he was not put out by the system.

I have already referred—to turn to more immediate and topical things— to the Beet Growers Association elections. Is Fianna Fáil convinced, particularly the Minister for Agriculture, that the National Council of the BGA is now strong and stable? Is this what is desired? I think these elections were most unfair; and that the unfairness sprang from the so-called straight vote. The adversaries of Fianna Fáil got about 70 per cent of the vote and 58 out of 60 seats. Is Fianna Fáil satisfied that this is a good system? Is this what they want, 58 seats out of 60 for 70 per cent of the vote and poor Fianna Fáil with a full 30 per cent of the votes getting only two seats, one of the two elected, I think, being here with us now?

They had, in fact, a voting strength which would have entitled them to 19 or 20 seats and I would argue that had they got 19 or 20 seats the whole setup would have been much more healthy. It is high time that a good system of PR was introduced into such elections. This, in my submission, cannot be called straight in any valid sense of the word. Minorities, whether Fianna Fáil minorities or others, are entitled to more representation than that, and I do not think that this type of stability which is what is sought by Fianna Fáil throughout the country makes for useful stability.

Fianna Fáil sometimes seem to suggest that somehow or other they have been inhibited from doing a lot of things they would like to do for the country by not having overall majorities in the Dáil. Of course, they frequently had——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nobody ever said that.

Comment on this

I said it was implied. It is possible that Fianna Fáil are quite content with the measure of power they have now, but I have seen it implied that they have not had the desired measure of support in power, and, in fact, not infrequently in the past they have gone to the country because they were asking for an overall majority and were not satisfied to depend on a few Independents.

However that may be, let us recognise that Fianna Fáil have had 30 years of power, the first 16 of which were unbroken, to implement their policy. I have referred before to what was aimed at originally by Fianna Fáil which I saluted long ago, and which seemed to me excellent and for which I am still waiting.

Comment on this

A patient man.

Comment on this

It was defined thus:

... That the whole basis of production, distribution, finance and credit requires complete overhauling and this is amply evident from the reports of the various committees which are summarised so admirably in the Secretary General's report... If we shirk any item of this task, if we fail to make the radical changes which are obviously necessary, if we fail to organise our economic life deliberately and purposely to provide as its first object for the fundamental needs of all our citizens so that everyone may at least be reasonably housed, clothed, and fed we shall be failing in our duty and failing cruelly and disastrously.

That is what was hoped for in 1932. I am of course quoting Mr. de Valera at Geneva. What was hoped for was a radical change in the entire system of production, distribution, finance and credit which was to be so completely overhauled that the first call on it would be to provide for the fundamental needs of the people.

If we have not radically altered our whole system of distribution, credit and finance and production, so as to provide first for these people we have failed cruelly and disastrously as well as failing in our duty. That was what Mr. de Valera hoped for in 1932, the first year of 16 years of unbroken power and the first year in a total of 30 years in power for Fianna Fáil so far.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator forgets that the Economic War started then.

Comment on this

I have not forgotten that.

Comment on this

It is well that everybody else would remember it, also.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He does not forget; he knows it. It just does not suit his book to recall it.

Comment on this

Who fought it? The Blueshirts.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

Perhaps we could have Dr. Sheehy Skeffington continuing without interruptions.

Comment on this

I can well remember the Economic War, and in this House when Deputy L'Estrange was here he seldom allowed us to forget the slaughter of calves. That then seemed to be relevant to almost everything. I notice that it is the Fianna Fáil side now that is referring to the Economic War. It is the Economic War, then, that has so far prevented Fianna Fáil from doing what they proposed and which is responsible for their cruelly and disastrously failing in their duty. I hope that this Economic War will come to an end fairly soon and that they will be able at last, after these 30 years, to implement their policy or perhaps to stand aside for a bit and meditate on just how much they have succeeded in doing and how much they have left undone.

The danger of the so-called straight vote which may give a very powerful Government which may merely talk about doing all kinds of things is that it may well become authoritarian in practice and, as Senator James Douglas said in July, 1950, Parliament may become "simply a machine for registering decision made by the Party that has succeeded in obtaining dictatorial powers." This kind of stability, in my opinion, is motionless stability, and I sometimes feel that the tramping of feet that one has heard from Fianna Fáil down the years is not the sound of marching feet but the sound of the feet of the warriors of destiny loudly marking time. Therefore, I do not think that this sort of time-marking stability, with authoritarian, arrogant views and too much power, is good either for the Party or the country.

I come now to the third argument against the PR system and that is that under the straight vote there would be no ad hoc coalitions. I do not propose to deal at length with that, the House will be relieved to hear, but I recall that we have had two Coalition Governments in this country. The first might bear the label ad hoc, because the Parties came together after the election and formed the Coalition which put Fianna Fáil out. I said on a previous occasion, and I have no reason to alter my view, that the first Coalition Government did a lot of good. The Ministers in the Parties forming that Government worked with one another quite loyally on the whole, and they all succeeded, each in his own way and in his own Party, in making an immense amount of progress in a relatively short time. Then came things like Baltinglass and the Mother and Child Scheme, and the Government collapsed. If they had stood by Dr. Noel Browne they might well be in power today, but they came to grief over this scheme.

It is quite unfair to call the second Coalition Government an ad hoc Coalition, because the electorate knew perfectly well, if they voted for a Coalition in 1954, what it would consist of. They also knew what the alternative was. The alternative was Fianna Fáil, and the electorate, knowing all this, threw out the alternative, Fianna Fáil. This second Coalition, therefore, was not an ad hoc Coalition. About the first Coalition, the then Deputy de Valera had said in 1948, and I quote:

A coalition Government formed from five or six Parties with their divergent views and conflicting programmes, and with a combined strength only equal to that of Fianna Fáil, obviously could not last. Such a Government, if it should ever get down to serious work, would fly apart and we should be forced into another general election within a few months.

That first Coalition Government lasted for three and a quarter years, which is over the average life of all British Parliaments since 1918, so it was not quite as ephemeral as was anticipated by the Fianna Fáil Leader at that time.

Comment on this

It did fly apart.

Comment on this

It did fly apart, just as Fianna Fáil has been defeated in the past and may well be defeated in the future. Sinn Féin flew apart also; I do not know whether the Senator would like to go into that matter.

The fourth argument is that we may have a multiplicity of Parties. Everybody here knows that is nonsense. In the present Dáil we have, effectively, three Parties. In the British House of Commons they have the Labour Party, the Conservative Party, the Liberal Party, a Scottish Nationalist, a Welsh Nationalist; and in the past they have had the I.L.P., the Communist Party, Independents, National Liberals and National Labour, all under the system that is supposed to prevent multiplicity. In Northern Ireland they have the Unionist Party, the Nationalist Party, the Labour Party, the Liberal Party, the Republican Labour Party, the Independent Unionists, and on the fringe, and as yet not elected, candidates of other Parties such as Sinn Féin.

I would suggest, with those who have already dealt well with this point, that they are right when they say PR does not create divisions but reflects them where they already exist. Some people, it is true, do not like what they see when they look in the glass. They do not like their reflection, but, in my view, it is the height of folly to think that by breaking the looking-glass one improves one's image. Fianna Fáil do not like the reflection PR gives them. It does not seem to reflect the kind of face they would like to have, so they say: "Let us smash the machine" like the Luddites of old. If political Parties do not like the image reflected, let them alter their political faces rather than fly into a tantrum and smash this faithful mirror.

PR in this country has a great deal to be said for it. It is said it was introduced by the British, and this is true. It may well have been introduced for ignoble motives or merely in order to give the Unionist minorities representation proportionate to their numbers. I believe the first occasion upon which it was used in Ireland was in a municipal election in Sligo, and the Sligo Champion hailed the results in January, 1919, as follows:

The system has justified its adoption. We saw it work. We saw its simplicity. We saw its unerring honesty to the voter all through; we saw the result in the final count, and we join in the general expression of those who followed it with an intelligent interest—it is as easy as the old way; it is a big improvement and it is absolutely fair.

The Parties and candidates represented then were the Ratepayers Association, Sinn Féin, Labour and Independents. The details are on page 219 of Enid Lakeman's book. This system, which we have used since and got to know even better, is a delicate and accurate recording machine. In Dr. Luce's phrase, it is "a well-tested instrument of enlightened democracy". The wreckers tend to blame the machinery of the election system for all their own failures, for things like emigration, unemployment, tasks untackled, problems unsolved, as if by having another system we would have a marvellous Parliament, wonderful representatives, and an amazing Government. Looking at the two big Parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, I find them very similar. I recognise that Fine Gael has perceptibly improved in Opposition; I recognise that Fianna Fáil has perceptibly disimproved in power. I am very tempted to pronounce here and now a ukase and to say: "There shall be a merger between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. I am not interested in the details. I leave that to the Parties, but I say they must come together and merge. This would save a lot of unnecessary duplication and expense, and save the taxpayer a lot of money." If you challenge any Member of either of these two big Parties to mention one outstanding feature of the programme of the other Party which they could not accept, they will pause for a long time before they answer. Why? Because they are so similar. It is possible that the improvement in Fine Gael which has been so marked—and I say that in all sincerity—has been due to their being in Opposition, and it might well be that a similar treatment could, with advantage, be applied to Fianna Fáil.

The major test of PR as I see it, overriding all else, is that it leaves effective electoral power largely in the hands of the voter. The voter decides, and not the Party bosses. The voter is thoroughly capable of selecting. If you confront people with a choice between A, B, C, D, E, F and G, and if you say to each one of a number of people: "Which do you prefer?" and he says: "I prefer A"; and you say: "There is not enough support for A. Who would your second choice be?" and he says: "I would like E", and you say: "I am sorry, but E does not command enough support either." The choice would be focused and coordinated. If you could do this with every voter and go right around each of them you would get the result you required. This would be a rather clumsy way of doing what is actually achieved under the present voting system.

On page 101 of Enid Lakeman's book she refers to a school experiment carried out by Rowland Hill, and this is how she tells it:—

Rowland Hill ... records that, when he was teaching in his father's school, his pupils were asked to elect a committee by standing beside the boy they liked best. This first produced a number of unequal groups, but soon the boys in the largest groups came to the conclusion that not all of them were actually necessary for the election of their favourite and some moved on to help another candidate, while on the other hand the few supporters of an unpopular boy gave him up as hopeless and transferred themselves to the candidate they considered the next best. The final result was that a number of candidates equal to the number required for the committee were each surrounded by the same number of supporters, with only two or three boys left over who were dissatisfied with all those elected. This is an admirable example of the use of the Single Transferable Vote.

This is in fact what happens in every constituency under PR. The voter is allowed to express coherently and effectively his preference as between Parties, as between Parties and Independents, as between candidates within Parties; he may have a preference for an older candidate or a younger candidate, or a more local candidate, or a woman candidate. The final result is a co-ordination of the preferences which results in the kind of Dáil we have got, which seems to give such profound dissatisfaction to the Government, I am not quite sure why.

It is true that under PR, particularly under the system of the three-seat constituencies, the bigger Parties are always marginally favoured, but ideas, on the whole, are represented in fair proportion. In any country, minorities are entitled to hope for at least some representation. They must not be driven underground. The sort of situation that has very frequently obtained in Britain is at the same time an intolerable situation in relation to voting strength and seats. I should like to quote from a table at page 26 of Enid Lakeman's book. In the election in 1895, for instance, the Conservatives got 49 per cent of the vote and 61 per cent of the seats. In 1906, they got 44 per cent of the votes and 23.5 per cent of the seats. The Liberals got 55 per cent of the votes and 64 per cent of the seats. In 1918, the Conservatives got 35 per cent of the votes and 54 per cent of the seats. In 1924, the Conservatives got 47 per cent of the votes and 67 per cent of the seats. In 1931, they got 55 per cent of the votes and 76 per cent of the seats. In 1935, they got 54 per cent of the votes and 70 per cent of the seats. In 1945, Labour got 48 per cent of the votes and 62 per cent of the seats. In 1951, the last figure I shall quote, the Conservatives got 48 per cent of the votes and 51.5 per cent of the seats.

That kind of minority or near minority Government is the sort of thing which may arouse discontent in the minds of many minorities who might well under such a system be altogether disheartened by the parliamentary system. Already in this country, legislative changes have tipped the scales more in favour of the big Parties. In 1934, an Act was introduced which reduced the number of TDs per constituency to a maximum of five. The comment which Miss Lakeman and Mr. Lambert made about that was that that in itself reduced the chances of the smaller Parties and increased the margin by which the largest Party's seats might exceed strictly proportional numbers. The contrast is worth quoting.

In 1933, Fianna Fáil got 49½ per cent of the votes and 77 seats, representing 50½ per cent. Cumann na nGaedheal got 30½ per cent of the votes and 48 seats, representing 31½ per cent. The Centre Party got nine per cent of the votes and 11 seats, representing seven per cent. The Labour Party got six per cent of the votes and eight seats, representing five per cent. The Independents got five per cent of the votes and nine seats, representing six per cent. In 1948, on the other hand, Fianna Fáil got 42 per cent of the votes and 68 seats, representing 46 per cent. Fine Gael got 20 per cent of the votes and 31 seats, representing 21 per cent. Clann na Poblachta got 13 per cent of the votes and ten seats, representing seven per cent. Labour got nine per cent of the votes and 14 seats, equalling 9½ per cent. National Labour got 2½ per cent of the votes and nine seats, representing 3½ per cent. The Farmers' Party got five per cent of the votes and five seats, equalling 3½ per cent. The Independents got 8½ per cent of the votes and 14 seats, equalling 9½ per cent.

I could quote other figures but I do not intend to do so, as the House will be relieved to hear. It is quite possible to quote many more figures to show that in fact our system of PR marginally favours the bigger Parties. I do not object to that, because the present system of PR gives reasonably fair representation—not absolute representation but reasonably fair representation—to minorities, and that is the important thing. Therefore, the aim of the proposals before us, I would say, is to ensure that one big Party, not necessarily Fianna Fáil, will get quite disproportionately large representation in Parliament.

Senator Ryan talked a good deal about tolerance and the necessity for a certain tolerance. He mentioned the Supreme Court suggestion that a certain "latitude" should be used in interpreting the phrase "so far as it is practicable".

Comment on this

The High Court.

Comment on this

The High Court; I accept the correction. The phrase goes on, "so far as it is practicable, be the same". The aim should be so far as it is practicable to get the same representation. Senator Ryan suggested that all Parties had approved and voted for the Electoral Amendment Act, 1959, that is the Act the constitutionality of which was finally tested and found wanting. I want to quote from Volume 51 of the Official Report of the Seanad Debates, column 1037. I said:

We are asked in this Bill to believe that it is the same when one TD represents 16,000 people, another represents 17,000 or 17,500 and another 24,000. So, under the terms of this Bill, 24,000 is equal to 16,000. I do not know what our primary schoolteachers would think of that piece of mathematics, or what the children in our schools would think of the mathematical capacity of those who ask us to believe that, for practical purposes, 24,000 is equal to 16,000.

I said in the next column:

...the Government say: "We are not going to obey the Constitution, because we do not think it would be good for the country to obey the Constitution."

I will not weary the House with further quotations. I was not the only one. Senator O'Donovan and I made it clear that we were opposed to the Bill. I said it should be re-designed ab initio rather than amended in Committee, because it was fundamentally wrong. When we came to the end of the Second Stage debate and a vote was called for, four Senators voted against it, Senator Miss Davidson, Senator Murphy, Senator L'Estrange and myself. It might have saved a good deal of trouble and money if the Government had paid attention to those of us in this House who warned them that the Bill was unconstitutional. I make that point merely because Senator Ryan seemed to think that everybody on that occasion accepted the 1959 Bill: this is not so in relation to the Seanad.

The argument was made by the Minister and by Senator Ryan that unless we have this tolerance as it is called, country boundaries will have to be "breached"—that is the word that is used. County boundaries are already breached in the Carlow-Kilkenny constituency, in Longford-Westmeath, in Sligo-Leitrim and in Laois-Offaly, and have been for years. These are breaches of country boundaries. I would suggest, as I did in 1959 on the Electoral Amendment Act, that the way to deal with a change in the total of the population is to increase or decrease the number of seats per constituency. I think the ordinary constituency should be seven—not five or three. Then, if this were the case, simply by reducing or increasing the number of seats, one could cope quite easily with significant changes in population.

Senator Ryan asked the question: "How could people want some other Party and yet Fianna Fáil get elected?" I have already answered that—by the split vote system whereby minority candidates get in to such an extent that a minority Government could be elected—not necessarily would be elected but it is conceivable that it could—as the British examples I quoted have shown.

Comment on this

It is conceivable under proportional representation, too.

Comment on this

It is far less likely under proportional representation because a split vote is not possible under proportional represenation.

Comment on this

It is conceivable under both.

Comment on this

Under proportional representation the split vote is not possible because, if you express your preferences, your single vote— you do not have more than one vote— is transferred.

Comment on this

You can have as many as you like.

Comment on this

It gives you one vote, which you can transfer in much the same way as, on the last occasion, Fianna Fáil had one speech which they transferred from Senator to Senator. This time, they have several. The first is called the "straight speech" system.

Comment on this

(Longford): Is it not better to have one speech of our own than to be making Miss Lakeman's speech.

Comment on this

I do not know if the acting Chairman would like me to reply to Senator O'Reilly.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

I should be glad if the Senator would keep to the matter before the House for consideration.

Comment on this

Senator O'Reilly would prefer the single transferable speech by Fianna Fáil to Miss Lakeman. This is the expression of an emotional state by a very romantic and sentimental Senator. I respect him for his emotion. We require a bit of emotion in this House. I feel that, in this matter, the emotions of Senator O'Reilly are not as potent as the arguments against his Government's case.

Comment on this

(Longford): It is a pity my emotions have not a better cause than yourself.

Comment on this

It is a pity they are not better channelled. With them, I might be allowed to bring my remarks to a close, if the interruptions will subside in the hope that eventually I shall shut up.

In conclusion, my view is that, under proportional representation with the single transferable vote, we have in this country the best electoral system in the world. It is completely vital to our democracy. I would regard it as a major betrayal if we were to abolish it.

Proportional representation gives to the voters of Ireland a most valuable measure of discriminating control— control over Parties, control over policies and control over politicians. The move to abolish proportional representation I regard as disgraceful and shameful. It is aimed, in my view, at gaining Party advantage from electoral injustice and disproportional representation. Therefore, in asking the Irish voters of 1968 to reply even more emphatically to those who want to reduce their power, I say—and I say it in a double sense—to all those who say "No" in this referendum: "More power to you".

Comment on this

As somebody said this evening, there has been such a spate of talk on this subject that it is almost impossible to say something at this stage that might be original. I want to refer to the tolerance question. I come from one of the western constituencies. When it became known that it was the census figure for the population that was to decide the number of representatives that would eventually be in each one of the western constituencies, it became readily apparent that a considerable injustice was going to be perpetrated on those constituencies. Everybody knows, I think, that conditions are such in the west that, as soon as it is practicable after leaving school, most of the children there have to leave to seek employment wherever they can get it. Consequently, one finds the homes in the western part of the country denuded of young people at a very early age. Most of them have to go where the employment is available and that, inevitably, is in Dublin and the precincts of Dublin.

If we were to take the census of population figures, then it is quite obvious that these people who come here—notwithstanding the fact that they are not electors—are counted in the population figure here and this fact weighs unduly against the western areas. When you calculate the number of electors that are there in proportion to the population, I think that if justice is to be done to the western counties then some kind of adjustment would have to be made to meet this case. I consider that what is proposed in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is the most suitable way in which it can be done—at least at the moment. If losses in population in the west continue, a new situation would occur. I am one of the people who have confidence that this situation will not always pertain. I hope that vigorous Government policies will be directed to ensure that it does not continue and that the bleeding of the western population will be staunched. For the purpose of this amendment, I think that this is possibly the best that can be done to meet the case and consequently I intend to support it.

With regard to the question of the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill and the single-seat and the single vote, nobody who belongs to a big constituency can be unaware of the real position. I can understand people here in Dublin who live in areas of high density of population and whose constituencies are small and manageable. Indeed, I should say that, in a great number of places, constituencies could be run by telephone. Take a constituency such as Clare where, from the south-western tip to the north-eastern tip, it is nearly 120 miles and think of how the elected representatives are dispersed throughout the area. Everybody knows the tendency is that the elected people will be in the areas of greatest density of population which means that the people in the fringe areas and in the least populated ones can say, with a certain amount of justification, when we canvass them: "We never saw you since the last election." Unfortunately, there is a certain amount of truth in it because it is not possible to get a Teachta Dála to visit all the constituents in this vast area. There is great merit in having a sizeable constituency which you can allocate to one man who without over-stress can feel it is within his power to help in the administration of the affairs of that smaller constituency. It is because of the difficulty of administering big areas that many Government agencies and other contrivances have to be substituted for the kind of work that should be done by the Deputy.

The question of an ombudsman was mentioned today but if 20 ombudsmen were appointed, they would eventually be assimilated into the bureaucratic system that appointed them and become part of the Civil Service. The best ombudsman that can be appointed is the man appointed by the people themselves. They will control him and direct his energies, and if he fails to measure up to their requirements, they will have the right to sack him at the prescribed time. However, if an ombudsman is appointed by the Civil Service Commissioners or in some other way, then the people have him forever and they can never get rid of him, no matter how dissatisfied they might be with him. If we can achieve in the single-seat constituency the appointment of a man who is satisfactory, who has the ability, and if we give to the people the right to appoint him and sack him, the work of the Government would reach into those places where we intend it should reach and those elected will be the representatives of the people and of the Oireachtas.

In regard to the question of the single vote, I have had as much experience at elections as most people and I could never understand from the first time I came into contact with PR why it was invented because the anomalies that grow out of PR are so blatantly evident that I could see neither justice in PR nor anything in its favour. I have seen and everybody else has seen the man who heads the poll having his surplus taken over and divided. A vote in the surplus goes to the people for whom it is intended as a fraction of a vote and sometimes it goes down as a very small fraction, according to the size of the surplus. His quota is taken and put on a shelf and that is the end of that. There might be 8,000 or 10,000 votes in it. We start off at the other end where you have 16 or 17 candidates and a person who had no interest in the election and who gave a vote to a worthless person can have that vote transferred as a full vote. The surplus goes down as a fraction and the votes of the man who is eliminated will go up as full votes. I have followed the progress of some of those votes for ten counts and a person who had not enough civic spirit to find out what was at stake in the election could have his vote used ten times and eventually make it decisive in the election of the last candidate.

Comment on this

With the single vote and the single seat, the person will be faced with making a final decision because he has only one vote.

There has been a lot of talk about how this system is going to affect Fianna Fáil but this in fact is not the point at issue. What is at issue is: is this going to be a better system for the country? I am sure that the Fine Gael Party when they brought out their policy, the "Just Society", for the last election felt, as they were quite right in feeling, that the people would read it and would come to a judgment on it and that it would be the decisive thing in influencing the people to vote for them, just as Fianna Fáil issued their manifesto and the Labour Party theirs, and if there were some Independent groups no doubt they issued some kind of document, too. However, if we feel that people need not take this policy into account or take into account the kind of person the candidate is then the whole question of elections is futile. This is the exercise, that the Parties present their policy to the people and ask them to support it and they offer a candidate who, in their opinion, would serve the people. If these two things are absent from an election, then all this election exercise is pure cod.

If in a smaller constituency you offer a number of people backed up by the policy you give them, then the people have to put on their thinking caps and decide who they are going to vote for. They must say to themselves: "This is a decision that is going to affect me and if such-and-such a Party have a policy that appeals to me, I will support it." In the long run, this is a better system and will give better results. Somebody said that we would get 90 seats but I pay very little attention to all these prognostications because this is going to be a new type of confrontation. If everything that has been said about the people tonight is correct, I am satisfied that this will bring into the country a new type of thinking, it will direct the people into a new stream of thinking and the necessities of the country will come first because they will only have one vote and they will have to be decisive in the way they cast it. For that reason I support this measure.

Comment on this

I do not propose to delay the House because every possible angle has already been covered by speakers in both Houses. However, I feel I have a duty to give my views on these measures. I would say that I blame the Opposition Parties for what has taken place to date in both Houses. I believe that both Fine Gael and Labour are regrettably more concerned at the moment with defeating Fianna Fáil on this measure than they are with securing for the community the best possible voting system. That does not mean that, when I make that statement, I believe the straight vote is the correct system. When Fianna Fáil introduced this measure in the other House, I believe it was possible at that stage to find a measure of agreement between all Parties as to what would be the best possible system. It should have been possible at that stage for Parties to shed selfish Party interests in the interests of the community as a whole. I know—nobody knows better —what happened: the Opposition, with their ear to the ground, knew that the rank and file in the country are anything but enthusiastic for this change. They knew that the rank and file of the Fianna Fáil Party are not a bit enamoured of the proposition. The Opposition Parties, smelling defeat for Fianna Fáil, said: "To hell with the best system; let us get this crowd out."

What we really have at the moment is a political contest to get Fianna Fáil out and replace it with God-knowswhat. I do not think that is a proper atmosphere in which to find the best system of election for our people. I see faults in the present system. I believe Senators on both sides see faults in it. I know there are few members in the other House dedicated to the changes proposed in this Bill. But the Party bosses in one particular Party got the bit in their teeth and were allowed to run away; I believe that in the course of their mad gallop those who drive will drive their Party over the top. That may be a good thing for the country, but it will not be a good thing for Fianna Fáil.

I want to make my position clear. I am not one of those who like to be told that this is the only choice, either accept what is offered—the straight vote and the single seat—or retain proportional representation with multiple seat constituencies. I do not think that is a fair choice. I believe the majority of the electorate would opt for a more sophisticated approach at this stage, but they are not being given that choice by either the Government of the Opposition. That is regrettable. It is a sad state of affairs.

First of all, I shall deal with what has been described as tolerance, the attempt to give, in the view of the Government, equal representation in the west and, in the opposition's view, preferential treatment. Within the past month, a publication was issued on health services. In that there is a forecast made with regard to health services and what they should be within the next 15 to 20 years. It is significant that Galway figures very prominently as the only major centre in the west. In the words of Deputy S. Flanagan, Minister for Health, the Government have accepted in principle these proposals for changes in the health services and those changes envisaged almost the complete annihilation of the population of the west. That means the Government believe that the population in the west will go down, down, down. While that is, apparently, the Government's belief, we have them here in this House and in the Dáil making special provision to ensure that representation for the west in the lower House does not disimprove. In fact, it will improve if this legislation is passed.

Arguments with regard to facilitating travelling, accessibility, and so on, to justify giving extra seats in certain areas are no justification at all for these changes. All the representations in the world will not improve the economic situation or save the people from annihilation. It is not more Deputies that are wanted. Fewer Deputies will do, and more work. The idea seems to have grown up that the main function of a Deputy is to act as a pleader, or a bleeder—a bleeding heart——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Or a bleater.

Comment on this

——for the people in the areas which are not within easy access of big towns. Listening to Senators and Deputies, one would think a Deputy was an administrator in his area with executive powers. There is no Member of this House with more experience than myself of what a Deputy's functions are, of what he can do and what he cannot do. He has certainly no executive powers. The most he can do is listen to confessions.

We have the deplorable position at the moment in many sections of the Civil Service in which a citizen, who writes to a Department about that to which he is justly entitled, does not even get a reply. His letter may be left in the incoming tray until it begins to heat; it may be turned occasionally by a junior official. The attitude has grown up: "Do not bother about it until a Deputy or Senator writes in." It is now accepted in the Civil Service that a Deputy, or Deputies, will write in on at least 90 per cent of matters which should not come to a Deputy at all but should be handled directly by the citizens themselves. No member of this House can say I am exaggerating. I meet it every day as a Senator. The system is such at the present time that a Deputy's time is fully taken up acting as a pleader on behalf of constituents. Members of the Government Party may ask is that not an argument in favour of the single seat. It may be but it is not an argument in favour of the straight vote and what the Government are trying to do is to mix up the two.

I read with care the speech of the Taoiseach in the other House on the two issues in these measures. The arguments put forward by the Taoiseach on the multi-seat constituency were arguments with which I agree to a great extent. The Taoiseach, in my opinion—I know there are Members here who do not agree with this—gave very weighty arguments in favour of the single-seat but the extraordinary thing was that 80 per cent of his speech was devoted to the evils of the multi-seat constituency and many people would be inclined to agree with them and to say: "All right. We will give you the one-seat constituency but we will retain PR."

Comment on this

It cannot be done.

Comment on this

Let us be clear on it. I want to say, a form of PR which is already in operation and Senator O'Kennedy knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

It is not PR.

Comment on this

It is a lot better than what you are trying to bring in.

Comment on this

You cannot have proportional representation unless you have a number of seats to apportion.

Comment on this

Senator O'Kennedy is trying to say that the transferable vote and the single-seat are not giving a fair crack of the whip.

Comment on this

I am saying it is not PR.

Comment on this

Would the Senator settle for it?

Comment on this

That is another matter. The Senator will express his view later. It is not PR.

Comment on this

Will you settle for it?

Comment on this

I will express my view when the time comes.

Comment on this

The weighty arguments put forward by the Taoiseach were on the competition which takes place within a constituency between, say, two Fianna Fáil Deputies, not to mind the competition that takes place between the Government and the Opposition. That was all dealt with far better than I could hope to deal with it. I do not want to keep harping but the simple fact is that I agree, as one who has been a practising politician, that what does go on lowers the functions of a Deputy. There is more of the handshaking, funeral attending, kissing babies' bottoms type of approach in Irish politics than ever there was in America and, let us be blunt about it, who taught the Americans the type of politics they go in for? We know the people who spend most of their time at that caper, watching the funeral columns, watching the birth columns, attending all sorts of functions which, in fact, is only drawing work on themselves of a nature that prevents them from doing the work they were elected to do. I would say that in the other House, without in any way being disrespectful to any Deputy, not more than 25 per cent of them ever read a Bill. That is not their fault. That is the fault of the system. I would suggest to Members of this House and to the public to have a good look at the wastepaper baskets when Deputies get their morning post. I would suggest that in 50 per cent of cases the Bills are in the wastepaper basket without being read.

What happens? We have, then, the situation that the Minister for Finance, Deputy Charles Haughey, states that Deputies' main function is to act as a buffer between bureaucracy and the people. We all know the Minister for Finance, Deputy Charles Haughey, as a very able intelligent Deputy but it is not necessary for us to swallow completely his line of approach in this matter. Nothing would suit Deputy Charles Haughey, Minister for Finance, better than to have a bunch of Deputies full-tilt shaking hands at funerals, writing letters that need never be written, as long as Deputy Charles Haughey is left free of criticism in Dáil Éireann and let get on with the job.

I remember a former Taoiseach not so long ago who had no time whatever for Committees of the House. In fact, when I was a member for a short time of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, no less a person than Deputy Seán Lemass sought to limit the powers of the Deputies and Senators. He sought to run Dáil Éireann like a board of directors and to have Deputies and Senators there occasionally so that they would pass whatever Deputy Seán Lemass and his Cabinet in their wisdom, thought should be put before them. The idea of having awkward customers on the back bench of Fianna Fáil was anathema to these people. They do not want it. I suppose if you get in as a Minister and fancy that you can carry on without advice from your Party, a natural weakness in human nature is to think that criticism would not do you good.

I am still dealing with the duties that are carried out by Deputies, the diversion from the work which they should be doing and I say that I agree with the present Taoiseach when he says the weaknesses are there. If he wanted to remedy that—and mind you, as I said, the greater portion of his speech was taken up with the weaknesses of the multi-seat constituency—if that was the major trouble—and it would appear to be the major trouble, according to the Taoiseach—why did not he settle for the single-seat with the by-election system of election?

Comment on this

It never arose.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Never arose?

Comment on this

Because it was never even contemplated. What has come to light, unfortunately, is that Fianna Fáil was using this argument—and successfully using it, because Senators over there seem to believe this—that this multi-seat system is bad; get rid of it and bring in the single-seat. That is not the logical conclusion that anyone should come to. If you think the multi-seat system is bad, why not have the single-seat with the by-election system of election? The Minister says now it never arose. I should like to know why it did not arise. There is no need to answer now—that is a rhetorical question—unless the Minister would like to answer it, in which case I will give him the opportunity.

Comment on this

I will answer it at the appropriate time. If I forget, you might remind me.

Comment on this

I think the single-seat with what I described as the transferable vote has worked satisfactorily in quite a large number of by-elections. I have never heard Senator O'Kennedy or the other members of Fianna Fáil saying they were not going to contest the by-election in Clare, Limerick, Cork or wherever the regrettable news was that a Deputy had died, because the system was a bad one.

Senator Sheehy Skeffington spoke about the French system. This by-election system that we have here is a more sophisticated version of what the French have at the present time and nobody can accuse the French of lacking in intelligence when it comes to their institutions. They are a very sophisticated nation but in this we are ahead, and the Government now want to go backwards. However, that will be decided outside this House. I hope I am not misquoting him, but Senator Yeats said that only one out of ten ballot papers is filled.

Comment on this

It was a guess.

Comment on this

I accept that, but I should like to remind the Senator that his Party, in many of the constituencies with which I am familiar, instruct their canvassers to instruct the voters: "Vote Nos. 1 and 2 and, if there is a third Fianna Fáil candidate, vote No. 3 and stop there". Therefore, his own Party are the guilty one as far as PR is concerned. Let us be clear about it. Fianna Fáil, whether deliberately or otherwise, have sought through the years to destroy the value of PR, to utilise it in its most limited fashion by saying: "Vote for nobody but Fianna Fáil. Stop there." I am not saying some members of the Opposition Parties are not just as guilty, but Fianna Fáil with the best organised machine in the country—they are welcome to that praise if they need it; Tammany Hall was also well organised —wanted to ensure that their voters would stop dead at the last name on the Fianna Fáil list.

What has happened in the past few years? Fianna Fáil voters, against the advice of canvassers and directors of the Party, have begun to cross the line. So also have voters as far as other Parties are concerned and the lines have become blurred and consequently we now have a truer picture of what the public want, and it spells danger for Fianna Fáil in the long run. Senator Honan, at the conclusion of his speech, stated the Government were mainly concerned with what is good for the country—they wanted to ensure that the system in operation was the best system. The trouble is that during the years Fianna Fáil have always mixed up what is good for the country with what is good for Fianna Fáil and at times there is great diversity between the two.

Comment on this

You are a fair mixture yourself.

Comment on this

I do not know exactly what the Senator has in mind but Fianna Fáil have seemed to believe seriously that if Fianna Fáil are strong and in Government all the time, that is good for the country.

Comment on this

Of course it is.

Comment on this

There we have it.

Comment on this

We must have faith in ourselves.

Comment on this

The Senators should remember that there are unfortunate people with mental illness inside our various institutions and they think they are Napoleon, Wellington and so forth. Fianna Fáil think they are God Almighty, that nobody else can run the country. It is a dangerous delusion. If it were just a matter of playing politics——

Comment on this

(Longford): The majority of the people believe that. That is why we are in power.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

A large minority.

Comment on this

The trouble is that a large section of the very best, the most virile, the healthiest and most needed of our people are not here to vote and the reason is they have been driven out by the policies of Fianna Fáil during the years. I am not suggesting Fianna Fáil alone have done this but they must accept the greatest percentage of the blame because they have been in office during 30 years. Whatever can be said about the two Governments in office for two short periods, between 1948 and 1951 and 1954 and 1957, they were alert——

Comment on this

A fair number of the people who left during those periods came back because of Fianna Fáil policy. The Senator should meet them some time. They came back from England and elsewhere.

Comment on this

Speaking for the constituency which I represented during a number of years, I can say that I know the west and the Senator will admit that the population there is dropping rapidly and that there is no sign of change as far as the provision of work is concerned. Dublin at the present time seems to be flourishing——

Comment on this

The people who came back may not have crossed the Shannon on their way back.

Comment on this

——but it happens to be a huge head on a body that is diseased. In Dublin, though there appears to be wealth and there is wealth and there is money apparently because of the people who pay 35/-for a meal in our so-called hotels——

Comment on this

I will be glad to introduce the Senator to the people who came back.

Comment on this

I should be delighted to meet them. However, Dublin Senators may deal with this matter in a much more expert fashion than I can. If there were any drastic change, any promise of it, on the part of Fianna Fáil, there might be some excuse for accepting this proposal at the present time. Senator Sheehy Skeffington spoke about what the former Leader of Fianna Fáil said about the drastic changes that might be necessary in 1932—the radical changes in financial policy, in land policy—so that our people would be kept at home and settled on the land. Was PR harmful to the implementation of those policies which Fianna Fáil promised in 1932? They have since failed to implement those policies. I will not embarrass them by repeating the promises about the march across the Border to take over the Six Counties and about bringing back the Irish language. All these things they said they would do and I should like them to tell me if PR has thwarted them in their efforts. Was it PR stopped them from doing all those things?

Comment on this

It was the Economic War.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The voice has come back.

Comment on this

Other Members spoke about the necessity for strong government. There is a Bill before the other House at the moment which certainly means strong government. It is legislation that will prevent citizens of this country from coming together, even to discuss political matters, unless they have gone to a sergeant or an inspector of the Garda Síochána. Let me be clear. I am not laying all the blame on Fianna Fáil in this matter. The rights of Deputies in the Dáil have been filched during the past 20 years. No fewer than three times while I was a Member of the other House, Standing Orders were altered to prevent Deputies like me from utilising the House to expose matters which should have been brought before the public gaze—to prevent Deputies from putting down motions on various matters. For the Government's action in thus restricting Standing Orders, the support of other Parties was forthcoming. Therefore, Fianna Fáil in the Committee on Procedure and Privileges were not alone. As a result, I have very little confidence in those in this House and in the Dáil who talk about the rights of minorities.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are all out of step but our Johnny?

Comment on this

Maybe; I do not know. I am talking about the people who talk about the rights of minorities and who in this House and in the other House trample on them. I see no reason why Question Time or the number of motions in Private Members' Time should be restricted. Yet that has been done with the unanimous approval of the three major Parties.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps the Senator would come to the Third Amendment?

Comment on this

I think I am as near to it as any of the others. The Seanad is elected, I gather, because it is supposed to be in a position to restrain the other House from taking the bit in its teeth. It is composed, I gather, of very sensible people whose wisdom can slow down the energetic men in the other House and cause them to think twice. That is what we are told the Seanad is there for. I would like to see the Seanad living up to that reputation. In particular, I would like to see the "cricket team" doing what they were supposed to be elected for—to bring an independent mind to bear on a major issue. I would like to see the Seanad reject these measures so that the Dáil would have another look. I would appeal to those Senators allegedly here as free and independent, although nominated by the Taoiseach, to say at this stage: "We are not going to try at this stage to impose this system on the community."

As a half-way measure which should meet the Taoiseach's objections, those Senators should support the idea of the single-seat and the retention of PR. I do not think it is too late yet. What I am saying now should come from the Opposition Parties. If it did come, the public would not have to suffer the terrible annoyance and bewildering propaganda which will be directed at them in August, September and October and this matter could be settled in a proper fashion. It would be a reasonable compromise at this stage. My knowledge, from talking to people in many parts of the country, is that they would regard it as acceptable. I would urge Senators to give a lead in that respect in this House and send the Bill back to the Lower House for further consideration.

Comment on this

It looks as though we are right back again to where we were on that historic occasion in February, 1959. The tune appears rather familiar. All the virtues ascribed to the straight vote system are being paraded again. First of all, let us have a look at what is proposed —a major change in the Constitution. The Constitution is a most sacred document in any civilised community. Therefore, it should not be changed unless there is grave reason for the change. The change should be preceded by a period of adequate investigation carried out by the most competent committee that can be got together and its findings incorporated in a White Paper that all can study. This was not done on the last occasion and neither has it been done on this occasion.

In fact, it is much more sinister on this occasion because three years ago an all-Party Committee was set up, the Constitution Committee, to look into whatever changes might be necessary in the Constitution, so that we could face the 70s and our expected entry into EEC with confidence. Their report has been presented and it is a reasonable document. It gives the pros and cons of the various problems studied by them. One thing they did not consider, and were not asked to consider by the Government, was the question of the system of election. We have evidence from Senator Dooge, who served on that Committee, and others, that in point of fact, the former Taoiseach, Deputy Seán Lemass, dismissed any idea that they might be foolish enough to reopen the PR issue again. Yet, without the blessing of the Committee and without its advice, this was suddenly foisted on the people at the end of last year.

If it could be dismissed as just a piece of madness that the electorate would deal with in due course—and the electorate can only give one answer to this, that is, the rejection of the proposals—perhaps we could turn a blind eye to the waste of time and the waste of funds, the £200,000 this referendum will cost. But we have got to consider the very serious damage this Act does to the whole concept of parliamentary government in this country. Make no mistake about it, the people outside are highly critical of our parliamentary institutions. They recognise that they are going along in a 19th century, inefficient fashion, that they are totally incapable of dealing with the major problems that confront the nation today. If Charles Stewart Parnell returned tomorrow, within one half hour he would feel he was right back in Parliament again. Nothing has changed since his day. It is the same type of debate, the same lack of committee system that was there in his day, indeed the same blissful ignorance of what constitutes efficient government in other progressive countries.

We have not learned. We rush in to change the electoral system at a time when we should be seriously studying the whole basis of our parliamentary system. Yet, if we are to judge by recent amendments, the only things Parliament is concerned about are money and power—money when it rushes in with unseemly haste to give increases in allowances, increases that could well be justified had the functions of the House been changed, made more efficient and brought up to date. But in contrast to all ideas of negotiation outside this House, the salaries were given a 50 per cent increase without any effort to modernise the functions of the Houses. The same now happens with the electoral system which is only part of the parliamentary process, election to Parliament, and yet the whole structure of Parliament is left untouched and, apparently, is intended to continue like that. The people outside are highly critical. Thank God, they are becoming more educated and beginning to think for themselves, as are people in all civilised countries. Indeed, the process has unfortunately gone a little too far in that it has seen the emergence of rather cynical political commentators, especially Backbencher in the Irish Times, who has done a great deal to give a distorted image of what Parliament is to the people at large. We know of all our failings here but the cynicism of this has unfortunately gone beyond what is necessary and desirable to effect change. I am afraid it can do and has done damage.

Again, the searching eyes of television have been focused on our proceedings and very often in debates portrayed on television, those of us who have experience of the House can see a great deal of what I might call ignorance of parliamentary procedure, in comments by so-called experts on panels where a proper balance in regard to parliamentary representation and knowledge is often not maintained. This all means that thinking people outside are not in a mood to receive the circus that the Government now intends to launch. They are not in a mood for the crocodile tears of the Minister for Local Government on television when his whole purpose seemed to be to help the Opposition Parties into power. The country is too sophisticated today to put up with such blatant cynicism and we shall pay for it if we do not watch out. We shall have all the distortions that will be indulged in when suddenly a Party who have been in power for 30 or 36 years comes to life and proclaims that all along we have been living in sin, that we have had the frightful PR system around our necks. I challenge the Leader of the House, or any other speaker on that side——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not push your luck too far.

Comment on this

——to list out the things that Fianna Fáil have been prevented from doing by the fact that we had PR.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I thought the Senator was serious in looking for a fight.

Comment on this

That effectively calls the bluff of this concern, the feeling that all our ills are due to PR.

Comment on this

We were twice led to financial disaster by Coalitions brought about by PR.

Comment on this

It is wonderful to hear the views and the scares about Coalitions as if the whole of life is not one grand coalition at every stage, in which Senator Yeats and his family play a part. I am sure he is not there with an absolute majority, that he is just part of a coalition in his family and that he has to temper his views to the views of the others in his family and to abide by majority decisions. Likewise, many a highly successful country in the democratic world is governed by coalitions. I wish all governments down the years had been as successful as the coalition governments of Denmark and Holland. I shall return to those in greater detail later.

Government is not merely government for its own sake and its own aggrandisement. It is not merely the creation of Louis XIV and his vassals. The whole test of government is to develop the resources of the country for the people of the country, providing government of the people, for the people and by the people. The more educated and sophisticated our community becomes, the more they must take account of the views of their fellow men and the more they must be able to function in harmony with their fellows in committees and in debates, putting their points of view properly and correctly and arguing to a decision and, when the decision has been taken, to abide by the result.

I am shocked that the Government feel that now that the country is making some strides in education and our people getting more opportunities that this is the very time the right of decision should be taken from them——

Comment on this

The right of decision will be given to them.

Comment on this

—— that they must be put into the straitjacket of the straight vote from fear of coalitions. I hope the Fianna Fáil Party are in some sense a coalition, a coalition between the extremes of Deputy Corry at one end and, perhaps, shall I say, Senator Ó Maoláin at the other.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Two Corkmen.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate that we should be plunged into this controversy now when I think all Parties would be ready to get down in an inter-Party Committee to a real examination in depth of our whole parliamentary system and with the aid of experts from any place from which we wish to bring them, plan and fashion our future parliamentary structure.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What about the Bills?

Comment on this

Nobody can hold that the structure that was adequate in 1900 is adequate in 1968, that the parliamentary structure that served Parnell is adequate today. Many of the Fianna Fáil Party, of whom I think very highly, some excellent Cabinet Ministers whom I have heard with pride in other countries and of whose achievements I have read with pride, are aware of the necessity for this. I might point to the recent speech in Limerick by the Minister for Industry and Commerce where he called for a winter of discussion, an excellent idea and an excellent preparation for the years ahead.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

May I suggest to the Chair that the Deputy be asked to come to the Bills?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What has the Leader of the House against Deputy Colley?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am anxious to hear the Senator on the Bills.

Comment on this

Is the Leader of the House against Deputy Colley who showed his statesmanship, to my mind, by saying at the outset that he wanted contributions from within and without the Party? I look forward as an individual to being able to contribute to some of the discussions.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We did not want that sort of contribution.

Comment on this

Is not agreement between the Government and the vocational groups, for instance, of more immediate concern than securing and riveting Fianna Fáil into power for the next ten years and the devil take the hindmost after that?

The whole educational world is now in a ferment. The efforts of the Minister and his advisers to set themselves up as the lay high commissioners of Irish education are being resisted, and those who have worn their back-teeth in education are demanding that they be heard.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I really must ask——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Acting Chairman (Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

What the Senator is discussing is not relevant.

Comment on this

It is relevant, in so far as the time and energy of these groups is being wasted at a time when we need to modernise our whole parliamentary structure, and in so far as the present effort is just a red herring. We are not facing up to the main task confronting us, the task the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley, called us to, the task that all thinking people in the country realise must be faced, the task to which life was given by the recent BGA elections where a vocational group who had long been trodden on by the Government——

Comment on this

What has this got to do with the Bill before us?

Comment on this

——and taunted with the suggestion that they represented nobody had a sweeping victory that recalled the 1918 victory of Sinn Féin—that it had the same freshness about it, the same originality, and the same hope for the future. That is what we should give attention to, not what is being foisted on us and on which we have wasted so much parliamentary time.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator is wasting time at the moment.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator, without interruption.

Comment on this

The Constitution should be treated as something sacred, not as something that can be changed by a snap parliamentary decision at what Fianna Fáil consider an opportune time——

Comment on this

How can it be changed by a parliamentary decision?

Comment on this

——where it is now proposed to try even by a majority of one to ask the electorate to change a decision given nine years ago.

Comment on this

That is different: that is not what the Senator said.

Comment on this

This would not be tolerated in any country with a written Constitution. The United States has had only 20 amendments to its Constitution in its whole history. This shows the reverence in which a written Constitution should be held. In the United States each amendment has been made only after very serious public discontent which ultimately found its expression in parliamentary action to produce an amendment of the Constitution. The very reverse is the case here. In our first Constitution in 1922, it was necessary to have a two-thirds majority before any change could be made; indeed many, and rightly so, deplored the weakness that was introduced in the 1937 Constitution when all that was required was a simple majority.

Comment on this

The first Constitution could be amended by legislation.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Quinlan, without interruption.

Comment on this

He is only making it up.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator is entitled to contribute as long as he is relevant.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I agree thoroughly with that.

Comment on this

He might try to be accurate.

Comment on this

We know that the present system has served us well, and we know how it works. We know also how the Belfast system works, but, as pointed out by Senator McQuillan, the electorate are not being given a proper chance to express their preference; and to judge by the mood of the electorate, I would think they want far more say than is provided by these two extremes. The excuse given by the Government that this could not be done is simply nonsense. The Constitution, under Article 47.2, makes provision for the referring of any proposal other than a proposal to amend the Constitution to a decision of the people. All that is necessary to refer a question to the people is that it should not seek to amend the Constitution by that decision. A question put to the people in a referendum asking the people to declare their preference, say, between PR and the single-seat transferable vote system would be simply a question put to the electorate for decision. If the referendum on that were carried in accordance with that Article, that would still not amend the Constitution. Therefore the Government would have to go back, pass an Amending Bill and submit that to the people.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Another referendum.

Comment on this

By a properly designed referendum, it would be quite possible to give the people the freedom of choice and expression for which they are asking, that is, by asking whether they favour: (1) the proportional representation system; (2) the single-seat transferable vote system, which would be the by-election system; or (3) the straight vote, or the Belfast system, which is the single-seat nontransferable vote. It would be quite a simple matter to get a consensus of opinion on that, and armed with that consensus of opinion, it would be a simple matter for the Government to proceed with the necessary legislation, confident that they were carrying out an already expressed wish of the people. They could then submit it to the people for formal endorsement.

Comment on this

Very simple but quite illegal.

Comment on this

It is wrong that people should be treated as unthinking human beings and should be given——

Comment on this

The Senator's proposal would be illegal.

Comment on this

Any Party that has been too long in power cannot see that the people have any rights; the only right they concede to the people is the right to continue that Party in power and make it easy for them to go from one election to the next, no matter what discontent there may be in the country at the actions of the Government. We can witness that in relation to the present Government in Britain. They can lose by-election after by-election and have it demonstrated beyond all reasonable doubt that they no longer command the confidence of the voters, and yet armed with the fruits of the wonderful straight vote system—a majority of over 100 seats —they can blithely ignore all such indications of the people's wishes. I do not think that is what we want here.

What is the function of an election in any case? An election has two functions. First, to provide a Government, and secondly, to secure representation for the country at large. In judging this system and comparing it with the system in other countries, we must at all times realise that we must relate everything to our own situation. In many ways here we are unique. What works in other countries does not work here. What proves disastrous in other countries may not have a similar effect here. What has achieved much in other countries has to be accepted with caution here.

When we come to the election of a Government, we are up against an unfortunate tradition which we have in our Parliament, that is, the system of absolute obedience to the Whip. The spectacle of a Member voting against his Government is unknown here.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is not unknown.

Comment on this

Quote an example.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien.

Comment on this

Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien is not, so far as I am aware, a Member of the Fianna Fáil Party. She is one of the Taoiseach's 11 nominees. Not even Deputy Corry has gone to the extent of voting against his Government on any occasion.

Comment on this

He did.

Comment on this

We can see the historical reasons for that. It goes back to Parnell and the Irish Party. When they went to Westminster they constituted themselves as a disruptive group. They wanted to make as much of a nuisance of themselves as they could in the British Parliament. In furtherance of that aim, one requirement was absolute obedience to the Party line. Unfortunately that has continued in Irish politics right down to the present day, no matter what Party are in power. The 100 per cent unanimous agreement in Fianna Fáil on the question of PR is an example of that. In other words, no one in the Party has the courage to come out and voice different views, because that is not done in Irish politics. It is to the credit of the Fine Gael Party that their views seem to be known a little more widely. The views of the few of them who disagree within the Party are known. I look with great approval at the action of some of the Labour Party backbenchers in England and the backbenchers or frontbenchers of the Opposition there. Time and again they have the courage to differ from their Party, speak against their Party and vote against their Party. At the time of the Suez crisis, we had the spectacle of Mr. Macmillan's son leading the rebels against his father's Government.

Comment on this

The fruits of the straight vote.

Comment on this

That was democracy in action. In Europe too a feature of parliament there is an independence of thought and a willingness to vote against one's Party. The point I am making is that where such an attitude prevails, the government must have a larger majority than a majority of three or four, because they can count on some of their own members abstaining or actually voting against them. In Irish politics a Government whose Taoiseach is elected by a majority of one is as safe as a Government with a majority of 50. They are just not voted out.

I was amazed when the political commentators commented on the small majority of our present Government and speculated on how long the Government would survive. I think they were depending on the votes of a few Independents at that time. Anyone who had any political sagacity or political knowledge would have known that there is one thing that is absolutely certain about Independents who support a Government. They will not vote themselves into an election. That is a fact of political life here. It is the same with small Parties. If a Party with three, four or five members commit themselves to supporting a Taoiseach, whether by active support or by abstaining from voting, it can be taken for granted that that small Party will not in the first three years, at any rate, vote themselves into an election during which they would have to contend with double hostility: hostility from the Government Party they had put out, and hostility from the Opposition Parties who would regard them as having let the Opposition down at the time of the election of the Taoiseach. Parties or individuals just do not do that.

Consequently we have an inbuilt stability in our political system which guarantees that any Government will run the major part of their allotted time. When they enter their last year in office, during what might be called the lame duck session, the Government themselves will be looking for an opportune time to move to the electorate. At that stage, if there were grave discontent in the country, a small Party might take their courage in their hands and be technically responsible for forcing a general election. The plain fact is that at least three out of the allotted years are guaranteed, once the Taoiseach has been elected.

This means that the election of a Government here is different from the election of Governments in other countries. In practically every election we will get a conclusive result. If by any chance we did not get a conclusive result, the Government could, as Mr. de Valera very opportunely did in 1933, and again in the mid-Forties, plead that they have not a sufficient majority and rush to the country. The electorate being mature would look at the situation. Many of them who had voted against the Government would weigh up the situation afresh and, in the light of the previous election, some of them would change their minds and vote to strengthen the hand of the Party that had been elected previously.

In the three-seat constituencies, to be elected a candidate must receive 25 per cent of the vote. Anyone getting that percentage does not represent some freak set, or some freak minority. He represents 25 per cent at least of the citizens in that constituency. I was amazed when I heard Senator Honan making such dramatic play about the irresponsible people who give votes to worthless candidates who were eliminated and whose votes were then transferred to some other candidate. Surely, then, Senator Honan must be saying that the lowest candidate of each of the Parties is a worthless individual? He must be saying in, say, Clare—where Fianna Fáil put up four candiates— that the fourth candidate is a worthless individual and that the people who vote for him are irresponsible. Likewise, the same for the second Fine Gael candidate for that area—that anyone voting for him is acting in an irresponsible manner. Surely that does not hold?

The Parties, under our present system, are giving a choice to the electorate. When Fianna Fáil put up four candidates in Clare——

Comment on this

I did not mention Clare.

Comment on this

You did: you mentioned a distance of 120 miles.

Comment on this

The merit of proportional representation is that the electorate can look at the candidates and need not take the candidates in the order in which the Party wishes.

Comment on this

What about the confusion by Independents, and so on? I was not talking about the Party.

Comment on this

They have been fewer and fewer in recent elections, due to the heavy cost involved and the difficulties of competing against well-organised Party machines. The Independents that I know of, who had the courage to go forward, were all worthwhile reputable citizens.

Comment on this

Most of them did not get 1 per cent.

Comment on this

They were entitled to go forward for election and the people who supported them were exercising their democratic rights in doing so. The multiplicity of small Parties was the bogeyman we were threatened with nine years ago. The electorate can judge the validity of the bogeyman scare that was raised in 1959—this multiplicity of small Parties. Indeed, in that time, it might legitimately be felt that we have come to a watershed in Irish political life. Mr. Éamon de Valera, who had been the centre of the scene at that stage for over 40 years, was moving out of active politics. The feeling might have been something like this. What had the future in store? Could a leader come forward to take his place? Could the Party system survive? The electors at that time might justifiably have been a bit apprehensive on that point. The answer has been given. We examine the period since then and we find that, far from new Parties appearing, new splinter groups arising, Irish political life has crystalised down to three Parties—Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour.

Comment on this

Fine Gael swallowed up most of them.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Fine Gael swallowed the farmers.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Might we hear Senator Quinlan without interruption, please?

Comment on this

We find that our claims in 1959 have been justified. The Government's fears have not been realised. Therefore, I doubt if the same old bogeyman will have any terrifying effect on the community this time. The mature electorate will simply judge the whole business by coming back and asking: "Well, if disaster was prophesied in 1959, how did that work out?" Since then, we have had a period of stable government, by any standard. We have also had a period during which the conditions were settled and yet progress has not been what it might have been.

I challenge anyone to suggest that, had the Government had a majority of another 30 over the past nine years, there would be a single one taken off the unemployment register today or that there would be a single additional new factory or that we would have solved, or gone any further towards solving, any one of our national problems that still remain unsolved.

As pointed out both by Senator Sheehy Skeffington and Senator Stanford, we are inclined to confuse strong government with good government. Strong government is where the Government are so strong that they can act in a dictatorial fashion. Indeed, there are many signs of that at the moment. Eight years ago, no Government here would have dreamed of trying to treat vocational groups as this Government are treating them today: no Government would have dared to do that. I would say that a Government of that period would not have thought of doing that because they were more democratic and more conscious of the role of the organisations than the present Government appear to be.

Comment on this

Doing what?

Comment on this

Resolute Government is something that newly-emergent nations may crave for, that is, somebody to tell them what to do at every stage of the day, somebody to regulate their lives, but, with us here, in an educated community, the citizens wish to be part of the government process. That is democratisation. This is really what sparked-off the troubles in France over the past five or six months —a revolt against authoritarianism. Make no mistake about it, that revolt will not be cured by the recent distorted elections and by the——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You are anti-de Gaulle now?

Comment on this

It is interesting to read about de Gaulle's Party in today's papers.

Comment on this

Anti-everything.

Comment on this

I shall leave de Gaulle as your patron saint. While he has saved a crisis, I think Europe will still rue the present harsh approach the de Gaulle Party are taking.

Comment on this

The people voted President de Gaulle into power.

Comment on this

They may be wrong but they are entitled to do it, are they not?

Comment on this

Certainly they are entitled to do it but any student of political science, looking at what is happening, will see that it is only putting off the evil day and reforms must be made. There is no need, under proportional representation, to paint all the picture in extremes because that is not what we have got. We have got our own special variety which is based on the three-seat constituency. When we look at Europe, we see that apart from France, the other countries have some form of PR. In Denmark, they have had PR since 1915 and does anybody seriously suggest that Denmark has not been well governed in that period? The Parliament there revolves around four main Parties and the Government has been largely Coalition all the time, although I would prefer instead of the word "Coalition", which has been given a rather sinister meaning, the term "co-operative Government".

The difference between our system and the European system is that they have developed an adequate and very effective committee system in their parliamentary organisation. Parliamentary committees would mean that in place of talking across the floor and addressing questions to a Minister, when the real people we want to question are hidden at a little desk behind the Minister furiously passing notes to the Minister when a point is raised or whispering into his ears, such officials, who are very worthy people, would be met across the table as human beings and as equals. The parliamentary representatives on these committees in other countries are drawn from all Parties and generally in proportion to their strength in Parliament. They meet officials and they meet experts and they get down to the basic rules of living together, working out problems and discussing them as educated citizens and arriving at conclusions. The committee system is the only basis on which a national Parliament can be adequately organised in the 20th century. In committee we achieve far more than we can achieve at present with our absurd indirect means of communication with the men behind the Minister.

Comment on this

How would this ambition be affected by the proposed system?

Comment on this

It is only to delay time.

Comment on this

The Minister, of course, probably cannot learn but once a committee system is developed, Party lines become blurred and Party clichés no longer count. The members meet as rational, intelligent human beings to discuss the problems at issue and generally they issue agreed recommendations in regard to what is to be done. Consequently once people have worked together in that atmosphere, there is not the slightest difficulty about two Parties co-operating in Government, or three, if the need arises. These are just the simple facts of political life in some of the European democracies.

Comment on this

Despite my belief in the great advantages of PR, if we had a model of the American system offered to us, I would be very keen to accept it because I believe the system of checks and balances and the various lines of demarcation of discussion in the American system represent a real evolution of the democratic system.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator has now dealt exhaustively with that aspect and I would ask him to address his remarks to the matter before the House.

Comment on this

The United States system of election was held up as an example of the straight vote but in point of fact it is nothing of the sort. By no stretch of the imagination can it be used as an example of what the Government propose. For one thing the Chambers involved, the Lower House and the Upper House, when contrasted with the Dáil and the Seanad, show that the role of the Senate there is vastly different. They have much more power than we have. That of course would not be hard because anything with less power than Seanad Éireann could not really be kept alive.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why bother coming up then?

Comment on this

Always in the hope that we can achieve something better. The present Seanad Éireann should be abolished or else reformed. If you abolish it unfortunately——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I want to direct the Senator's attention to the fact that it is the Dáil system of election that is under discussion.

Comment on this

The role of Seanad Éireann bears no relation to the role of the second Chamber which can exercise a restraining and moderating influence on the first Chamber. The two systems cannot be compared. Over and above all this, there is a line of authority from the President down and one cannot compare the President of the United States and his relationship with the Lower House, the one elected by public suffrage, with the relationship of the President here and the Houses of the Oireachtas. Our President has none of the legislative functions which the American President has or the right to initiate legislation. The most glaring example we can find of the straight vote system is in the Government nearest to us. Does anybody seriously wish to tell the electorate in the Republic that all is well with the electoral system in Northern Ireland, to tell them that the straight vote there gives justice to the Nationalist population?

Comment on this

It does not make any difference——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator will please desist from interrupting.

Comment on this

The Senator asked me a question and I am answering him.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It was a rhetorical question.

Comment on this

It is the first time that the Senator has been on the Bill. For goodness' sake, leave him there; he might not come back to it.

Comment on this

In the 1966 election, the results were Unionists, 36, Nationalists, 9, Labour, 2, Republican Labour, 2, Liberals, 1, Independent Unionists, 1 and National Democratic Party, 1. Out of a total of 52, the Unionists Party got almost 75 per cent of the seats. Is it seriously suggested that the Nationalists' supporters in the North represent only 25 per cent in that area? Such a suggestion is the height of absurdity. When the change was made in 1929 from proportional representation to the straight vote, the Premier—I think it was Lord Brookeborough—did not have the neck to suggest that he was making the change so that an alternative Government could come into being in Northern Ireland and so that one day the Nationalists would replace him and his Party. He adopted the straight vote as a simple method of cementing his own Party in power and preventing the emergence of a co-ordinated opposition. That manoeuvre was done, and done successfully, and nobody could suggest on the figures that there is any likelihood of a change of Government there in the next 50 years.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the system of election.

Comment on this

It has, of course, nothing to do with the system of election either that, out of the 52 seats there, 22 are safe seats, uncontested seats! Of these 22, 14 are Unionist, five Nationalist, one Liberal, one Independent and one National Democratic Party. Perhaps we should tell the electorate here that, if this system is brought into operation here, certain areas will be designated safe seats. Possibly County Clare will be able to boast of four safe Fianna Fáil seats. These will be treated, as they are in Britain, as Party perks to be given to favourites of the Party bosses.

Comment on this

I am sure Fine Gael would not agree with the statement that the four seats in Clare would be safe seats for Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Certainly they do, under this rigged system. Other safe seats will be Donegal, Meath, Waterford. These will all be safe seats.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Quinlan.

Comment on this

We have the returns of the general election in the North under the straight vote system. In 1958, in the central constituency, candidate A polled 3,902 votes; candidate B, 3,326; candidate C, 2,437 and candidate D, 1,406. The man with 3,900 votes out of a total of 11,100 votes was declared elected; he was the first past the post. In other words, with less than 35 per cent of the total vote, he was declared elected. The role of candidate C is that of a blocker, as it is called in American football. He prevents candidate B from being elected. Again, in North Antrim, we have Major O'Neill unopposed; mid-Antrim, Dr. Robert Simpson, Unionist, unopposed; South Antrim, R. W. B. McConnell, Unionist, unopposed; Bannside, Captain Terence O'Neill, Unionist, unopposed; Carrick, Alexander Hunter, Unionist, unopposed; Larne, W. W. Topping, Unionist, unopposed. Is that the kind of return we want in County Clare, County Donegal, County Waterford, County Galway? Is that going to be our idea of consulting the electorate. In a county the size of Antrim, surely, out of seven seats, other Parties should have been able to get two or three seats?

Comment on this

The anti-Unionist vote there is trivial.

Comment on this

Then, what about all our claims with regard to Partition, if Senator Yeats thinks that the anti-Unionist vote is so trivial?

Comment on this

It is in Antrim. They would not get seats under any system of election there. Let us be realistic.

Comment on this

Apart from two contests in South Down, the other five seats were again unopposed. The results are the same right through. Under the straight vote system, if a Party feels it has not got a chance of winning, the Party does not contest the election because it has no desire to expose its lack of support. In the 32 constituencies in which there was a contest, some of the polls were as low as 54 per cent; in other words, the electorate who disagreed violently with the candidates offered to them simply stayed away. In only a few cases were there close contests and only in those few cases were there polls running from 75 to 80 per cent.

Comment on this

The Senator knows that that there is no floating vote.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Yeats must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

Perhaps Belgium will be trotted out. Perhaps it will be argued that the modified form of proportional representation in Belgium is responsible for their present difficulties there.

Comment on this

"Chaos" is the word.

Comment on this

Chaos, yes. But it is nothing to the chaos the straight vote would have occasioned in that country. There are strong sectarian differences there and there are strong regional differences between the Flemings and the Walloons. In such a case it is always a matter of compromise. It is not a case in which any one group would feel happy about another group getting an absolute majority to enable that group to ride roughshod over all others.

Comment on this

At least they might be able to form a government.

Comment on this

Experience of working together on committees and in coalitions helps to iron out differences and heal old sores. That experience is actually playing a considerable part in improving conditions in Belgium. As far as the straight vote is concerned, no one in his sane senses in that country would accept it. In Denmark a modified form of proportional representation is in operation. There are 44 seats which are distributed as a residual in order to ensure further proportionality. The system recognises that all groups can make a contribution.

Comment on this

Who picks the 44?

Comment on this

At no time have they sought to give any one Party dictatorial control over the country. The same situation arises in Sweden. Ever since the rise of socialism there, the socialists have worked in coalition with the Agrarian Party. Even when the socialists got an overall majority, they still continued to work in harmony and co-operation with the Agrarian Party.

Comment on this