We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–197 of 802. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Last evening I looked briefly at some other countries and at their systems. There are two others worthy of mention here, first of all, the State of Israel which was set up in 1947 and in the foundation of which Jews from many parts of the world played a great part. They had firsthand experience of living under various electoral systems. They had experienced the tyranny of Hitlerism; they had lived in the United States of America; many had come from England. Consequently, it is highly significant that when they chose an electoral system for their country, they chose proportional representation and took the whole country as a single electoral unit. They were concerned with the idea of fair play and the idea of giving all reasonable shades of opinion within the country an opportunity to express themselves in the National Parliament. They were confident that with this coming together and expressing themselves in a modern parliamentary system, with an adequate system of committees, they would be able, operating as intelligent human beings with a common purpose of developing the new State of Israel, to work together despite whatever Party labels they had, and provide efficient and stable government for the new State.

Their expectations have been realised in the fullest possible measure and, indeed, these expectations would not have been realised if there had been any opportunist politicians amongst them who would put Party aggrandisement and Party advancement before the co-operative development of Israel. We can learn from that success story and I commend Members of the House to study it.

At the other pole there is the performance in South Africa. Many people in this country and elsewhere are rightly concerned with the racialist policies being pursued there. The main factor in ensuring the continuance of the racialist policy there is the straight vote system wherein the country is divided into single-seat constituencies and where the present ruling Party is thereby able to exploit racialism to the fullest and to keep its hold on Parliament. The other more moderate Party, the United Party, has been prevented from developing and bringing in a middle-of-the-road policy due to the straitjacket imposed by the straight vote system on them.

There you get a classical study, much the same as that which I gave last night on Northern Ireland, of the safe seats where almost 20 per cent of the seats are safe and where the governing Party do not contest areas where they are not likely to get a good vote—they do not wish to expose their hand in these areas. Calculations made by distinguished political commentators show that the United Party there actually have a majority of the overall votes, allowing for those areas where they have a strong predominant vote. In the other areas where the straight vote hands over representation to the governing Party, the United Party have got considerable support, varying from one-third to 40 per cent; yet because of the straight vote system they have not got a single representative in these areas. We should stop and think when we see a system exploited in that way.

These are sufficient international comparisons, but, of course, in all cases we should take them with caution because our circumstances differ from those in every other country in major ways and consequently we must allow for that when we propose to make changes. It therefore becomes important to consider the system we have and which we know and which has given us the most stable government in Europe—so stable, indeed, that it encourages stagnation—and we should insist that that system should not be changed unnecessarily for another system—unknown here and which could produce the same glaring defects it has produced in South Africa and Northern Ireland.

We now turn to our present system, that of PR. Frankly I am shocked at the lack of knowledge of the system displayed by some Members on the opposite side of the House. It proves that the course in civics now being introduced into the schools is really needed because what is a very simple concept seems to be completely misunderstood. I have used successfully an illustration with some groups of young people to explain PR and I propose to give it here. We shall take a situation in which people are accustomed to dealing with money and therefore they are able to add, to subtract and to divide. Take the case of a constituency in which the quota has been calculated at 1,000 votes—a candidate, to be elected, must get 1,000 votes. For the sake of simplicity, we shall equate a vote to £1 so that the voters can see how to divide votes.

Take four candidates in this constituency and assume a candidate is elected when he gets 1,000 votes. In this constituency the voter looks on his vote as being £1—indeed, in a democracy, a vote is far more sacred but we will take it for illustration as being represented by £1. The voter registers his preference by giving £1 to his favourite candidate. One candidate receives 2,000 votes, or, £2,000 and he needs only 1,000 votes or £1,000 to be elected. Looking at that situation, what would any child do? The candidate has £2,000 and he needs only £1,000; therefore he hands back 10s to each of his supporters, which leaves him with the required £1,000 made up in 10s notes. The voters having got back 10s each, are then free to give their 10s notes to other candidates to help to bring their totals up to £1,000. The idea of proportion there, of portion of a vote being transferred, is a quite natural, ordinary process of the sharing money which even children of ten years of age are able to understand.

Comment on this

Pure codology.

Comment on this

The idea of the transferable vote cannot be the great evil that Fianna Fáil have suddenly discovered it to be. Is not the transferable vote enshrined in the Constitution for election to the highest post in the State, that is, of President? I quote from Article 12 (2):

The voting shall be by secret ballot and on the system of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote.

In other words, the Presidency is on the single transferable vote and nobody has suggested that the Government have any intention of changing that system.

Again, we can turn to the election of Seanad Éireann, of which all Members are no doubt intimately aware. That is covered by Article 18 (5):

Every election of the elected Members of Seanad Éireann shall be held on the system of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote.

Again, there is no clamour to get rid of that. Apparently Seanad Éireann is quite happy to continue to live in sin and enjoy its greatly increased emoluments. Surely, if the Senators opposite are serious about the evils of the transferable vote, they should be clamouring equally strongly in this referendum to change the system for Seanad Éireann and for the President?

Comment on this

Can the Senator not appreciate that there might be an advantage in having different systems of elections for the two Houses?

Comment on this

Senator Yeats cannot have his cake and eat it.

Comment on this

Many countries have a different system of election for the two Houses.

Comment on this

So apparently all the evils of PR and the single transferable vote do not apply to Seanad Éireann as long as Seanad Éireann continues to elect Senator Yeats and others to the House?

Comment on this

That is a childish remark, unworthy of the Senator.

Comment on this

There was reference to a lottery in the system of transferring surpluses. I suggest that Senators read in the Library the documents on Ireland which are put out from time to time by the Information Division of the Department of External Affairs. I take it Senators will accept that as an unbiased and authoritative source? In No. 1 of this series, they have given how the Dáil is elected and so on. On page 5 of this, they deal with the question of the transfer of surpluses, which caused Senator Dolan to make such criticisms yesterday. His criticisms do not find any support from this official document. It speaks of the transfer of surpluses and says:

There is an element of chance— more apparent than real—in the transfer of a surplus. Where the surplus arises out of original votes there is no element of chance as regards the number of papers to be distributed, but the papers are taken from the top of the parcel of second preferences. It may be that the number of third preferences for a candidate in the papers so taken may not be in the same proportion as in the whole parcel of papers from which the papers were taken. It is a virtual certainty, however, that where the number of papers is substantial, and the papers are thoroughly mixed before being sorted according to first preferences, any sub-parcel taken at random will be characteristic of the whole parcel.

That is the basic theory of random sampling. The Department of External Affairs have gone on record that they are quite happy this is so and that any parcel taken will reflect the characteristic——

Comment on this

Has the Senator ever been at a Dáil count?

Comment on this

I certainly have.

Comment on this

(Longford): You were not at the long count in Longford that had a different result each time.

Comment on this

When the number of vacancies is large in relation to the number of electors, that is, where the quota is less than 100 as in Seanad Éireann, an exact method of counting is essential. That is the method used in the elections to Seanad Éireann. The only reason that a slight short cut is taken at present in the distribution of surpluses at the third or fourth stage is purely the economic one; to save all the additional counting with the reasonable certainty, as given by statisticians and others, that when thoroughly mixed, the samples will be representative.

Comment on this

When are they thoroughly mixed?

Comment on this

There is an element of chance there, but shall we go one stage beyond that? Perhaps Senators have heard of the electronic computer? Perhaps they have heard of elections as they are carried out in the States at present—and as, I have no doubt, they will be carried out here in ten years—by means of computers. In ten years' time it will be regarded as pre-historic to see people counting as they do today.

Comment on this

The voting machine cannot be used with PR.

Comment on this

I will write a programme for the Senator that will do it.

Comment on this

I am not talking about computers. The American voting machine cannot be used here.

Comment on this

The voter simply either registers his vote directly on a type of teleprinter machine or, alternatively, he makes the appropriate marks on a card that are recognised by the computer as it "reads" the card. When such a system is introduced, as undoubtedly it will be in a very short time, the results will be available before Senator Yeats has his first cup of tea after the close of the count.

Comment on this

The American voting machine has two lists of candidates.

Comment on this

Any moderate speed computer would take at most ten minutes to complete the count in any constituency and can go to as many decimal places as desired. There will be no longer any need for what has been objected to by the Senators, that is, having to take for convenience a certain representative bundle. All the votes will be scanned and everything done in accordance with exact proportionality, just as is used in Seanad Éireann elections. That will probably be of great comfort to Senator Dolan, who distrusts the informed opinion of the Department of External Affairs and the judgment that the PR system, even though it takes a certain short cut when dealing with some of the higher surpluses, is perfectly fair, just and representative.

Comment on this

And, of course, they are afraid of the machine.

Comment on this

Also, this will relieve the Minister for Local Government who does not like those long counts. He will simply wait until the computers ticker-tape out the result——

Comment on this

Quite obviously the Senator does not know the American system.

Comment on this

It would probably take all the fun out of the counts and perhaps there are people who will regret that. However, that is progress and therefore we should quit asking childish questions that are only based on ignorance of modern technology and ignorance of what will, almost certainly, be the vote counting system here within ten years.

Comment on this

Not under the American system.

Comment on this

Perhaps I should deal now with the tolerance Bill, the Third Amendment Bill. I have a certain sympathy with the underlying reasons here but I cannot see that the Government's approach is the proper one. There is no point in giving arbitrary percentages of the number of those under 21 in various constituencies in an effort to suggest that the tolerance will simply be used to ensure that the number of adult voters——

Comment on this

Nobody said that.

Comment on this

——will be roughly the same in each constituency. If we want the election to be based on the electorate, why not say so and why not amend the Constitution and base tolerance and everything else on so many thousand electors? I do not altogether agree with that because that includes only those over 21 and I think all our young people, especially those in the secondary schools and upwards, would feel that they should count as much as any of the older generation in reckoning individuals in the constituency. Be that as it may, it is a question of deciding on the whole population or the population over the age of 14, leaving school—which might be a reasonable compromise—or the electorate. But that could be written in. There is no point in going through the maze of figures the Minister uses to suggest that this Bill might equate voters in Donegal and Dublin.

Tears are being shed over the breaching of county boundaries, or does the country really consist of 26 republics? Perhaps I should say 27, if North Tipperary and South Tipperary count as two. This was propounded by the Liberal candidate in the recent Limerick by-election who wanted a republic for Limerick! Now, apparently, we want 26 republics. However, if there is a genuine reason—I do not feel it is that important—for keeping counties in units, the proper approach is to bring in a Bill to amend the Constitution to provide specific Dáil representation for each county. It could be based roughly on the present population figure and let there be three, five or seven elected in whatever suitable divisions are made in a county. In Limerick you have two threes——

Comment on this

You have not.

Comment on this

No reasonable person in town or country would object to such an arrangement which would get away from this revision of the constituencies which must take place every 12 years under the Constitution. It would also get away from such grotesque gerrymandering as we have been subjected to in Cork city where one of the most populous and respected parts of the city, the Blackrock suburbs, were arbitrarily cut off and put into Mid-Cork while on the other side of the city the horns of the city constituency run out to grab voters in Carey's Pike and places like that.

Comment on this

Did the Cork Deputies not vote for that?

Comment on this

They did not vote against it.

Comment on this

Two of the sitting Cork Deputies at that time were actually in the area being cut off. Likewise, I know how the lines wriggle and weave in County Limerick. This is something we should not tolerate. It should not be left to arbitrary decisions of this kind. We should fix the lines once and for all. Consequently, I oppose the Bill as it is at present and I think we can only solve this problem on a broad basis by simply going ahead and fixing numbers for the county if we want to keep county boundaries. We could bring in a population tolerance so that if the population changed drastically in a region, there could be an adjustment of seats up or down, and as part of that adjustment, it is only right that the facility should be available for two-seater constituencies if these were required to make up the complement within a county.

Comment on this

(Longford): The Constitution says that the lowest number shall be three.

Comment on this

But we are changing the Constitution now and that is just a consequential change. If there were an agreed pattern of representation worked out——

Comment on this

(Longford): It would require a referendum.

Comment on this

I know that, but are we not putting a referendum to the country now and why not have another question on it? Obviously consequential adjustments must be made in the Constitution if a major principle is agreed on and if that principle were representation by counties, the necessary constitutional changes should be made. It would be far more acceptable and there would be far less questioning of it than there is of the present attempt which provides too many opportunities for gerrymandering, too many arbitrary adjustments, and, I believe, will not commend itself to any thinking voter. For that reason, I propose to vote against the Third Amendment Bill and to advise all I can to do likewise.

Comment on this

We knew that all along.

Comment on this

(Longford): The Senator will even vote against the tolerance, despite all his protestations?

Comment on this

There is only one consideration—Fianna Fáil brought it in.

Comment on this

(Longford): We would have some respect for the Senator if he said he would vote for the tolerance.

Comment on this

I will vote for a Bill amended on the lines I have suggested and I will support permanent representation on a county basis or on the basis of some two counties that have already been put together.

Comment on this

On the present figures of representation?

Comment on this

Irrespective of population.

Comment on this

Forecasts of what might happen under the straight vote system were given on Telefís Éireann by two very eminent authorities, Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornley and I am appalled to read what I can only describe as ignorant comment by the Minister when he classed them as the pseudo-scientific forecasts. I should have thought any responsible member of the Government would have had sufficient experience of dealing with specialists and would have accepted the bona fides——

Comment on this

They are not specialists.

Comment on this

——of the estimates given by specialists. Apparently he does not like the estimates, he proceeds like the Russians in a former era, to attack the specialists rather than accept the figures given. The epithet "pseudo-scientific" is unworthy of the Minister, and I have no doubt whatever that in Irish academic circles it will only increase the academic stature of the people who have been so unjustly attacked.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Any time anyone says anything to the Senator his stature is increased.

Comment on this

They know nothing whatever about the subject.

Comment on this

These experts in political science adopt the modern approach to their subject. They must of course make certain assumptions——

Comment on this

Their assumptions were wrong.

Comment on this

——and the forecast is made on the basis of these assumptions. I am quite certain the forecast would be accepted by any reasonably educated person as being the best that could be made at this stage.

Comment on this

I do not think their conclusions agreed with those of Fine Gael?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Within a couple of seats.

Comment on this

On the single-seat transferable vote?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes. They used a slightly different method, a slightly more sophisticated one.

Comment on this

Do without voters altogether. Let the specialists return the Dáil, the fellows with the long hair.

Comment on this

They said that for something less than 45 per cent of the electorate, Fianna Fáil would get about 70 per cent of the seats.

Comment on this

Less than 40 per cent is what they said.

Comment on this

That is better still.

Comment on this

That is more nonsensical. It has never happened in any country.

Comment on this

It is not nonsensical.

Comment on this

That a Party with less than 40 per cent of the votes could get 70 per cent of the seats? It has never happened.

Comment on this

The electorate need not vote at all. Let the specialists decide the issue.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It has happened. In England in 1918, the Conservatives got 35 per cent of the votes and 54 per cent of the seats; in England in 1922, the Conservatives got 39 per cent of the votes and 66 per cent of the seats.

Comment on this

It has never happened that a Party got 70 per cent of the seats with 40 per cent of the votes.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Nor has anybody said that it would.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan, to continue.

Comment on this

They just took a number out of the air.

Comment on this

To take Senator Yeats's figures, getting 70 per cent of the seats with 40 per cent of the votes is manifestly unjust——

Comment on this

Manifestly impossible.

Comment on this

——and no amount of denial or protestation will convince the ordinary voter with a sense of fair play that this straight vote it is a system on which to base the development of Ireland in the 70s and the 80s. The argument has been trotted out again and again that the straight vote system will produce better candidates. That suggests that the candidates as selected by the conventions at present are not the best available, and, secondly, it suggests that the parties, in their wisdom, would be better able to select candidates than the voters have been, because in future only one candidate will be presented by any Party in any constituency. Therefore the elector who wishes to support the Party can vote only for that candidate and none other. In this modern age where a great deal of lip service has been paid to youth, a Party in selecting three candidates proceeds to select, more or less, as follows: No. 1 has been there almost all his life; No. 2 is in more or less a similar position; and No. 3 is put up as a new candidate. He is not expected to get in, but he gives a fresh look to the panel. The electors very often have voted for that No. 3 candidate, and rightly so. The result is that a young man may have an opportunity of displacing one of the two elders. Of course, that would not happen under the straight vote because such a young man's name would probably never get on the ballot paper. A little more explanation is obviously needed by the electors to convince them that better candidates will be produced under the straight vote! Better candidates will be produced if the Parties take steps to ensure some professional evaluation of the candidates, but I do not hear any plans for that. In any case, I went into the necessity for that on the recent Allowances to Members Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator has not the moral courage to join any Party. How can he speak about Parties?

Comment on this

What Party would take him?

Comment on this

I am here as an Independent and I can give my views without fear or favour. Whether I disagree with Senator Ó Maoláin or Senator FitzGerald or Senator Murphy, I give my views.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He knows nothing about Parties, so he should not pontificate upon the subject.

Comment on this

I have a distinguished electorate, and I am proud to represent an electorate which is larger than in most of the constituencies in the country.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The most gullible electorate in Ireland.

Comment on this

They are part and parcel of the Coalition.

Comment on this

On past occasions the university electorate have given their views on the efforts by the Government Party to get candidates elected on the official ticket. The universities have always been proud to send rugged Independents into this House.

Comment on this

Name one. You are Fine Gael but you have not got the guts to call yourself Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They have not got the guts to elect anyone but Fine Gael.

Comment on this

And the Senator is one of them.

Comment on this

He has not the honesty to call himself what he is.

Comment on this

The people outside the House have their own view on what weight to attach to statements made by Senator Ó Maoláin and the Minister. I am happy to allow my performance here to stand or fall on their judgment.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is a good circus act all right.

Comment on this

The Minister says that in future Deputies will be able to give more time to their duties here, because they will not be driven by competition from other Deputies. Again that calls for a review of their role, for ensuring that when Members are elected, they recognise that their primary duty is to play their part as legislators, and that they are relieved of most of their messenger boy chores. This is an evil with which we have to cope. All Parties realise that the "messenger boy" evil could be coped with by a united approach; by all Parties bringing home to the electorate that they have their rights which they can get by applying in the usual way, and that it is wrong to feel that they can get those rights only if a TD intervenes. Our present system of paternalism by TDs is undignified, and is unworthy in view of the increased emphasis we are putting on education. We should make an effort to root out paternalism and try to develop a more educated electorate.

To sum up, in our approach to this, as in our approach to the modernisation of the salaries of Members of both Houses, and especially of this House, we have got our priorities all wrong. The whole parliamentary system should be modernised to provide us with a 20th century parliamentary system. We can learn from the successful small countries in Europe and elsewhere, where we see the development of a 20th century committee system. Our system should be in that mould. The Committee which inquired into the Constitution might have been a beginning, but unfortunately it was aborted. Its recommendations have been pigeonholed, and a Constitution change they did not make or consider is being rushed through. We cannot take pride in such a misuse of an inter-Party Committee.

No case has been made for this change. The electorate gave their views nine years ago and nothing has happened since then to justify changing from the system of PR. It has been suggested that it leads to a multiplicity of Parties and instability of government, but the reverse has been the case. We can take pride in the fact that the system we have has worked quite well and served us well. No case has been made to suggest that a new system would give us better candidates At the moment four candidates go forward and two are elected, and the electorate play a great part in selecting those two. If there is a change, the Party bosses will decide what two names will go before the electorate. Surely no thinking person believes that this will lead to the selection of better candidates? An educated electorate in Ireland today value the right to discriminate between candidates and value the weight they attach to their No. 1 preference, and the ability to give youth a chance under the PR system.

No case has been made to show that Deputies would be better in the sense of being better legislators because the present system does not give an efficient approach to legislation and does not provide the means for a Deputy to function as a real legislator. In other countries Deputies have regular contacts with civil servants and expert groups. Here civil servants are just the people we see behind the present Minister or any other Minister frantically trying to keep him on the rails. We have no real contacts with them. If television ever comes into the House, it will kill this farcical means of communicating with civil servants. The papers have voiced public opinion very strongly and they are to be complimented on the lead they have given on this question. They have been calling for a wider choice than is being presented. The single-seat with the transferable vote would not be as good at our present stage of development, and I do not think it could ever be as good, as the three-seat constituency and PR.

However, the electorate should be given the choice. There is no real legal difficulty about that. The Government do not wish to give the people the third choice of the single-seat with the transferable vote which I believe the electorate would probably favour. The electorate feel that our political institutions are not functioning properly, and that Deputies are not functioning as might be expected in a modern democracy. Some may be wrongly inclined to attribute part of that to our mode of election. I feel that the electorate today would probably opt for the third course. The Government are afraid they would, and therefore they do not want to put that alternative before them.

In our nation today we have made great strides in education. It is sad to think we are now trying to suggest that our people are so ignorant that they are unable to understand a simple system like proportionality, like fair play——

Comment on this

The Senator has said that several times already. Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

Our people will not be led away by any suggestions that you cannot get a grouping of Parties to provide a Government; in other words, that a coalition is not a proper and viable alternative to any other form of government. Coalitions are in operation in practically all countries in Europe today. Who are we to judge these——

Comment on this

We can judge by our own experience.

Comment on this

We can judge their performances, how they have developed their countries over the years. In that regard, I feel that we lag very considerably behind. Forty years of coalition rule in Denmark has certainly done something for that country. It is only in keeping with the general development of the co-operative movement as it has been developed in that country. Where there is a natural inclination to committee work, and to co-operation, then, co-operation at the highest level—co-operation in government between individuals dedicated to the welfare of the country and between Parties dedicated to the welfare of the country—is not only feasible but desirable.

For all those reasons, then, I have every confidence that the electorate will, in a much more resounding manner than on the last occasion, reject these Bills. I suggest, however, that their rejection and the whole process of putting them before the electorate damage our political image. I suggest the urgent task between us is to modernise. If Parnell came back today, he would not find any significant change here.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator said that in the first hour of his speech last night.

Comment on this

He would find some change outside the House. But, within the House, he would find the procedures exactly the same as they were in his day. If that is progress, then those who claim it as progress are just simply saying they are not living in this century: they are away back in the 19th century.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Two hours and ten minutes.

Comment on this

It is seldom that one can invoke, in favour of one's arguments, the lares et penates of the Fine Gael Party, the great household gods from whom the tradition of the Party has developed. Indeed, I think Senator Yeats, earlier in this debate clearly indicated that, if we on this side of the House wished to invoke these, we should fairly be entitled to do so. My only reason for making this point is that if those great father-figures, those domestic gods of the Fine Gael Party, could make these absolute statements in an absolute fashion against the system of proportional representation in their time and speaking with tongues of truth and justice, according to themselves and their Party, it comes rather badly that, when the Fianna Fáil Party make the very same suggestions they themselves made in their time, the Fianna Fáil Party speak with tongues of wickedness and sometimes, it is even suggested, of corruption.

My reason for introducing that note at this stage is that I would hope that, far from the hysteria and the cries that have come from both Fine Gael and Labour, we could all consult and, indeed, on the subsequent campaign consider in a fair and objective fashion the balance of advantages to be got between these two systems. I must say that I think the Opposition's campaign so far has been based entirely on hysteria—entirely on it—and on unfair and unreasoned criticism.

Might I direct myself, in the first place, to the Labour Party who act like the Fine Gael Party, on occasion. It is the first time, I think, in this House that I have stood to criticise as strongly as I hope to do today the attitude of these Parties to any measure. In politics, it is a little tiresome to hear people claim for themselves the halo of virtue while adorning the other Party at all times with the horns of wickedness. I certainly will not accept the badge of wickedness pinned on us by the virtuous Members of Fine Gael or Labour.

The Labour Party have a motion before this House today to the effect that, in view of the opposition of the electorate in 1959, the latest attempt by the Government to change that decision is dictatorial and undemocratic—two very reasoned words; two words that arouse in no way anybody's emotions. To anybody who is in any way committed to the idea of representative government, the words "dictatorship" and "democracy" mean nothing at all—not by a long shot. The Labour Party are fully aware of the effect such cries could have on the electorate if the electorate failed to reason rather than to be affected by such evocative terms as these.

Let us have a look at the democracy element, first of all. If this system which we now have is the criterion of democracy, and the only criterion of democracy, then let us hear the democracies of the world—and, mind you, we may be surprised to hear where they are. One, we have had a long association with over a long number of years, because many of our great Fenians spent much of their lives in prison there, was known as Van Diemen's Land, now Tasmania. It has the system of proportional representation we have. The other two are not two that would immediately spring to mind and they are two, of course, that have had long association with the British Empire and Commonwealth, as indeed, Tasmania, and they are Malta and Gibraltar. This, then, is supposed to be the criterion of democracy, that, of all the democratic nations in the world, the only ones they can invoke in favour of this essential criterion are those three small and, one might say, almost unknown nations. We are being blamed as undemocratic for suggesting that we change a system which is hardly known to the democratic world.

Comment on this

You already had the democratic answer in 1959 and you are rejecting it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Tell us how many countries have the proposed system.

Comment on this

I shall—and the countries that have it are far more significant than the ones that have our present system.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If not more numerous.

Comment on this

We come to the question of dictatorship. We are endeavouring here, to impose, á la Labour Party, dictatorship. If we are, we are following in strange company because the greatest democracies— some of them, at least—of the world are involved here. We all have various views about various democracies: there is a compromise involved in it. However, the recognised established democracies—the United States, Britain, New Zealand, Canada to a certain extent—have the same system. All of these nations, according to the Labour Party, are dictatorships. Now, they will have to “come clean” at some stage and clearly say to the people—if they want to use these terms—that these nations are dictatorships and that the only democracies are the small and almost unknown countries I have already indicated.

Comment on this

That is a misinterpretation of the resolution.

Comment on this

Indeed it is not.

Comment on this

It is; be honest.

Comment on this

It has been suggested both in this House and outside it that Fianna Fáil are launching themselves on a programme of dictatorship, that they are trying to get rid of democracy. I can refer to many of the references. There was such a suggestion from the Chairman of the Labour Party, from the Leader of the Labour Party and many such people. If they are not expected to stand over the statements of their own leaders, there can hardly be any reason in Party democracy at all. What do the Labour Party want?

Comment on this

We want PR and we will keep it.

Comment on this

The Party who want PR want it against the interests of democracy because their own Chairman, and I presume he has authority to speak, said that under this system they hoped to achieve the balance of power in Parliament. This Party who are so concerned about democracy sees the essence of democracy as being a balance of power government, a minority group who may hopefully increase their representation by four or five seats. That minority would dictate to a Party which is three times their size as to how they should implement policy. It is a very false cry to invoke democracy by a Party who as their Chairman and Leader have said, reject coalition and who said that their intention was to reach a stage in Dáil Éireann where for their Party interests they could maintain a balance of power and could say to either Party "Yes, go ahead and form your Government; we will not join you——

Comment on this

Any reasonable person who considers the democratic process will immediately say that the Government should be representative in so far as possible of the majority views of the people and their policy should as far as possible be effected in the interests of the majority view. How can a minority group with a balance of power who can say: "Form your Government; we are with you as long as you support and implement policies that we are prepared to accept but on the first occasion on which you introduce a policy or legislation which we, the great minority, the people with the great balance of power, refuse to accept, then you are shipwrecked", be acceptable to the people? I do not think the Irish people want this. The Labour Party may want it but the people do not, and no democratic people would want it.

Comment on this

Could the Senator give us the reference? I think we are entitled to it.

Comment on this

Since the debate has turned to a serious level, perhaps the Senators will allow it to continue.

Comment on this

That is a very partial statement.

Comment on this

I do not think that the people can be asked to accept that their Government and their democratic institutions should be sacrificed to the power ambition of the Labour Party, which is legitimate—they may have more here in this House than another Party. Our institutions should not be used for this purpose if it is only to be a stepping stone along the way. Senator Fitzgerald said that it was the balance of power on the way to power and that is a fair enough indication of why the Labour Party want to retain PR, not for the nation but for the Labour Party.

Comment on this

What is wrong with an agreement——

Comment on this

I would appeal to Senators to allow the debate to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

The Labour Party may have fears enough from experience of the results of PR to justify their support for its retention. On a quick look through many of the constituencies, you will find that Labour Party candidates generally have been either the last or the second last to be elected, depending on whether you are dealing with a three- or a five-seat constituency. If I might give an example, take the constituency in which I live, North Tipperary, where on the last occasion the Labour Party's first preference vote was not half the Fianna Fáil first preferences. It was 1,000 less than half the Fianna Fáil first preference vote. Nonetheless that constituency is represented by one Labour Member and one Fianna Fáil Member. For more than twice the vote, 1,000 votes more than twice the vote, this divine system gives that type of representation.

We turn now for a moment to Fine Gael and I will endeavour to give my reasons for their attitude, which they can criticise later, in regard to the systems. I would like to give them some notion of our opinions about their selfish reasoning, if it is permitted to suggest that Fine Gael ever have selfish reasons. If they would invoke the same spirits to whom I referred in opening, they might be somewhat more realistic and more determined in the business of politics than they have shown themselves to be for a long time. Their offer of coalition has now been rejected and yet after every election, whether it is a local government election or a presidential election—and I for one cannot see that the last presidential election was related directly to Party politics and that it was fought on that basis but if Fine Gael can produce proof, I will accept it—we hear the pious hopes and the empty talk that "We will form a single Party Government". We have heard it so often, that under the system of PR they can form a single Party Government, and it has got to the stage that their supporters throughout the country feel frustrated and they are utterly unbelieving in this Party who can make such impossible and utterly unrealistic claims. No doubt before the next election, if it is under PR, they will still say: "We offer ourselves as an alternative Government", knowing in all honesty that this is an utter impossibility.

This is what PR holds for them, the opportunity to parade impossible and false promises before the electorate, the opportunity to boost themselves beyond the status and position which they really have at present. If they were really serious about the business of politics and about the possibility of taking up the responsibilities of government, then they would take this opportunity and face this challenge as so many of their full-time, hard-work-ing politicians have taken it and would be prepared to take it. I mention, if I may, the Leader of their Party and another man who is widely regarded as a full-time politician, Deputy Flanagan. They and numerous others are prepared to devote their full time and their full energies to the business of politics. Whether we can always agree with the manner in which they do it is another matter but they do devote their time to it and they are the ones who are in favour of the straight vote.

Where are the ones who are against the straight vote system, the part-timers, the ones who hardly know their constituencies, the ones who are on cliff-hanging majorities—they hardly need to be named—the ones who are concerned with entrenching themselves and not concerned with devoting time and energy to the business of opposing? If I may say again—I am sure that, for all the examples I can quote, others can be quoted against me—I have met many frustrated Fine Gael supporters, frustrated by the fact that their Party have not proved worthy of their support for so long, frustrated by the fact that their Party will not take the first realistic opportunity that is being given to them really to offer themselves as an alternative Government. Mark you, despite much of the prognostications and the prophecies of the experts, I think many of these frustrated Fine Gael supporters will express their view on the referendum in a fashion that will come as a major surprise to the Fine Gael Party.

Fine Gael have offered—strangely, not their leader; maybe not even a spokesman or appointed spokesman— an imploring hand for alms, a hand "to relieve me from my present misery", to the Labour Party, a hand of coalition so that one or other of us can gain some advantage; but I think, be it said to the credit of the Labour Party, the Labour Party have rejected the imploring hand, at least up to this point, and they are prepared to say: "If you want to effect your policy, if you want to achieve your aims, you had better learn to do it with your own energy and your own achievement", and not be in any way relying on the support of a Party who, in fact, must have, I expect, different fundamental policies. One could say to that same imploring hand: "withdraw your hand and put your hand under your posterior and push yourself up, stand on your own two feet and, at least, for once make a real effort, a determined effort, to offer an opposition and an alternative to a Fianna Fáil Government." I do not pretend nor suggest, for one moment here, that a Fianna Fáil Government is the only possible Government for this country, but that is something which, I think, the combined Opposition have for so long contrived to effect.

To come to the suggestion that Senator Sheehy Skeffington put to me a few moments ago that the electorate have already given their view on this nine years ago: as one of those who did not have an opportunity of giving a view on it nine years ago, I welcome the opportunity now and may I say that, in fact, I share this opportunity with more than 50 per cent of the present electorate? More than 50 per cent of the present electorate did not express a view on this on the last occasion.

Comment on this

Is the Senator sure they will express a view on this occasion?

Comment on this

I happen to be one of the 50 per cent and I welcome the opportunity on this occasion. If, then, nine years ago this decision was reached by less than 50 per cent of the present electorate, may I remind both Parties that the only possible alternative under the present system is coalition or inter-Party. But Senator Quinlan tells us that coalition has some type of wicked connotation that I was not previously aware of. The only alternative then has twice since been rejected by the same electorate and in more recent times. The only possible alternative to Fianna Fáil government at present is a coalition or inter-Party Government and that union since 1959 has been twice since rejected and surely it is only reasonable to assume that the electorate, if given another chance, would prove equally consistent and reject it for the third and fourth time. That is why this suggestion of its being dictatorial and undemocratic to ask the people to consider again, in view of the fact that the electorate has changed so much, does not, I think, stand up to any kind of reasoned examination.

If I might for a moment consider the position of coalition and the nature of coalition which, as I say, and I affirm in so far as one can from recent experience and from normal observation, this is the only alternative to Fianna Fáil at present, I have scarcely heard its problems better expressed than in this quotation from a learned and distinguished Member of this House, Senator Garret FitzGerald, when he said that former coalition governments gave rise to "papering over of wide political differences between Fine Gael and its left-wing partners and it led to weak governments susceptible to pressure from too many different angles". There are the ipsissima verba of Senator Garret FitzGerald at a time when, I think, he was not a fully active member of the Fine Gael Party or, if he was, he was not promoting the fact that he was. If that was true then, it is still true now: “weak governments susceptible to pressure from too many different angles”, and I must say I wholeheartedly agree with his observation then. Whether or not he has had any reason to change that in the meantime I will be pleased to hear.

Surely if even now a coalition is to be offered as a reasonable alternative to the electorate, presumably under the PR system, the electors are entitled to know how that coalition will effect its policy, how they intend to compromise on each of their different policies. This, of course, is again on the assumption, for the purpose of this argument, that the Labour Party will change their mind. If that should be so, I should like to hear the Labour Party's views on, for instance, Deputy Cosgrave's farm policy. Equally, I should like to hear the Fine Gael supporters being asked to accept Dr. Browne's nationalisation programme.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

When the Labour Party accept, we might, if that day ever arises.

Comment on this

Are we now being told these policy statements are just straws in the wind? Anybody can say anything on either of these policies and we are not expected to commit them to them. If the vice-chairman——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He was not the vice-chairman at the time he made the statement. That is not true.

Comment on this

He was the official spokesman of Labour.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That was misstated on Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

He was the official spokesman.

Comment on this

Do not be too sure of that.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept that he was not vice-chairman, for some reason or other.

Comment on this

Was Fianna Fáil bound by the statement by the Minister for Education that 1916 was a mistake? People will make wild statements. Are you bound by that?

Comment on this

The Minister for Education did not say that 1916 was a mistake. If he had, I would certainly disagree strongly.

Comment on this

We all know he is impetuous and irresponsible.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He was chided by the Daily Telegraph for saying that 1916 was a mistake. That is a great humiliation.

Comment on this

We could continue this exercise for quite a while in every field from social welfare to foreign affairs but I should like to keep to the electoral system and what may result from it, if I may. I am just simply saying that if this only alternative to PR is to be worked, then, in fairness, both Parties who would operate it must come to the electorate and say: "We will compromise on this aspect of our policy. We will accept that part of their policy to effect this what we might call electoral policy, that is, electoral coalition policy, we ask you to support as against the policy of the other Party, Fianna Fáil who ask you to support a different policy."

Comment on this

That is fair comment.

Comment on this

I am prepared, whatever its merits or otherwise, to say that if we are going to talk in terms of coalition, we must at least inform the electorate, who will make the choice, of this decision rather than combining subsequently, having to a certain extent duped the electorate into thinking that they were voting for different Parties with different aims, after the electorate had been duped to effect an end of which that electorate had never been informed.

Taking a brief look at coalition situations throughout European countries, taking, first of all, West Germany, you find you have what most people will agree is a most unnatural alliance, if one can say there can be an unnatural alliance in politics, that is, between the Christian Democrats and the Socialists. The only two major Parties in the Bundestag are, in fact, combined together, two opposing Parties with entirely opposite policies, combined together to keep out the minority groups such as the NPD—the neo-Nazi Party.

On a recent visit to Germany I was perfectly convinced by members of both of these Parties that they thought this was a most unnatural coalition, a most unhappy one, and the only thing that was keeping them together was the common fear of the neo-Nazi Party and, in fact, they went further—again these are individual views and I do not take them as absolute truths—and said that this was due to the system of election which was a list system of election, a form of PR, which was imposed on them, possibly for justifiable and enlightened reasons, after the last war, by the major Powers, but I can assure you now that the German people themselves, and particularly the two major Parties, are very anxious to change their system of election so that they will have a system akin to the one which we are now proposing to the people in this country so that from herein they will not have to combine together in this unnatural political alliance to offset the danger of the minorities having any effective say in the government, particularly what they might regard as being undesirable minorities, because none of us, I suppose, can presume to say that such minorities are entitled to spokesmen in the House or that these minorities are not entitled to spokesmen in the House. I would suppose that the neo-Nazis in Germany feel that they represent in many ways the views of the essential Germany just as much as other minorities, Socialist and others, feel that they represent the essential views of their nation.

I had two days ago the experience of giving a lift to a German student who is over here on holidays. Many a German student coming to Ireland would introduce himself, as this one did to me, as being a personal friend of Rudi Dschuke, setting himself up, first of all, as being a man with whom you could discuss and get very intimate details of the recent German student demonstrations. He, a member of the Socialist Student Movement, as you call it, said—in heavier and more deliberate tones, of course—there is now no difference between the Socialist Party and the Christian Democrat Party; it is just a farce; they are not any longer different Parties and we students feel no part of either one of them because they have been obliged to join in this unnatural coalition.

Comment on this

The students here say the same about Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Then they have the Labour Party to turn to but they have nobody to turn to in Germany by virtue of the coalition system over there.

I do not think I need dwell very long on coalitions nor do I intend to go into the history of inter-Party Governments in this country, but if one just looks at the problems that have arisen for a long number of years in Europe, in Italy, Belgium, in France up to de Gaulle's time and now in Germany, we will see immediately that certainly the coalition is the least desirable from of Government, second only to the balance of power Government of which the Labour Party are so enamoured.

So much then for the hopes and aspirations of the Opposition Parties who have criticised Fianna Fáil so strongly for what they intend to effect under this proposal. If we just look at the Fianna Fáil situation for the moment and see what advantages accrue to them from the present system, the immediate advantage that occurs to anybody is that every electorate over the last number of years has known that there is no single alternative to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Alas, maybe, as Senator Sheehy Skeffington says, and I am prepared to accept that many share his view. For that reason I would suggest that there may have been people who, if there had been a single alternative to Fianna Fáil, would have voted for that alternative who, in the absence of such single alternative, have voted and will continue to vote for Fianna Fáil. It is because of this absence of alternative, amongst many other factors, that the dual Opposition Parties have remained weak and Fianna Fáil have remained strong. Therefore, surely, it would be in the Fianna Fáil interest to maintain a system whereby you will encourage and foster to a certain stage of growth at least—because apparently they are not going to grow beyond a certain stage—two different Parties both of whom will prevent each other from gaining an overall majority, thereby leaving the only alternative of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Would we not be in a worse position then than the German student? He has no Party to vote for. Now you want to confine it here to two Parties.

Comment on this

No. His two Parties are combined together to effect a common policy in coalition but if he had two different Parties, one in Government and the other in Opposition, then I think he would not have been worried.

Comment on this

He wants to join Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Not at all, but anybody who wishes is welcome.

Comment on this

Is the Senator opposed to the principle of mergers?

Comment on this

To unnatural mergers.

Comment on this

Universities and their problems I do not wish to discuss at this stage. Whatever be the complications and the complexities of ordinary Government and legislative business, I do not presume to know anything about the problems and complications, as of now, of the university system.

Comment on this

Clearly the Minister for Education does not either.

Comment on this

I am speaking of the personal problems involving both sides.

Comment on this

Of the value of having a choice, an alternative?

Comment on this

We had a little of that yesterday. I was referring to the advantages to Fianna Fáil of maintaining PR and the facts have shown that, during 32 out of the past 36 years, the electors have maintained Fianna Fáil in office. They have voted for the Party almost all of the time—the Party to which there has been no alternative. I cannot see how anybody who belongs to the other Parties can really be politically serious if he expresses the belief that some day, if they want to sit on these benches rather than on those benches, they can be against these proposals instead of accepting that chance now.

Another loss Fianna Fáil would suffer by the abolition of PR is that, being in Government, many of the Fianna Fáil political figures are probably better known to the community at large than those of the Opposition. The only reason I say this is that Fianna Fáil have the advantage of being in Government and also the advantage of being judged on their merits, on their work. Accordingly, one quick look at election results shows that almost all Fianna Fáil Ministers have succeeded in bringing in at least one other Fianna Fáil candidate under the PR system—ministerial surpluses throughout the country have been very effective for Fianna Fáil—and in changing from this system Fianna Fáil are taking the risk of losing that beneficial effect because under the straight vote system each candidate must stand on his own feet.

Take the case of a Minister, any Minister, who will have a large surplus under the straight vote system. No matter what happens he will have elected himself only, and the surplus will not be transferred or effect the election of any other candidate. Fianna Fáil or otherwise. This is something Fianna Fáil considered seriously in assessing whether it was to their disadvantage to get rid of PR. There may be some Fianna Fáil people who think we might have 85 or 90 seats under the straight vote system and there may be some Fianna Fáil people who think we have introduced this because it is good for Fianna Fáil. I must confess I believe that if the straight vote system was introduced as of now, in the next election we probably would get as many as 85 or 90 seats.

Comment on this

You agree with Professor Chubb, then?

Comment on this

Reasonably so, but I was not commenting on Professor Chubb, though the Minister commented on his argument as being pseudo-scientific, which was not a comment on his personality. However, that would probably be the outcome of the next election.

Comment on this

Definitely to be hoped for by the Party.

Comment on this

It is my personal view. However, it is not at all so secure in the election after the next one and nobody can offer any suggestion or any prophecy, not even the specialists to whom Senator Quinlan has referred, as to what will happen in the following election. In the light of the experience of 32 years during which Fianna Fáil have been in power almost unchallenged, surely it does not seem to be unduly selfish or impossible to suppose they will be there the next time, but to go on and say that they will not be there unless they still have the support of the people is to offer an opportunity that all Opposition Parties should grasp. But they do not. As a member of Fianna Fáil, I will fight determinedly to see that they will be there the time after the next election, but it is the business of the Opposition to fight equally strongly to see we shall not be there, but this opportunity they are not grasping.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass said there will always be a Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

He may well think so, and in the present situation, what he said is probably true.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

You want to make sure of that.

Comment on this

Fine Gael are not prepared to accept the position that that situation will change. Are their shoulders strong enough to bear the burdens of office or have they time from their personal activities to devote to the assumption of government?

Comment on this

A distasteful challenge.

Comment on this

All Minister have to accept the interference which ministerial responsibility involves—interference with their own domestic affairs, their private lives. That is something that each man, when he takes up the challenge of politics, has to evaluate. He cannot compromise or say: "Better leave it to somebody else". He cannot depend on the two sides of a river to steer him straight in the middle channel: he must steer in the channel and devote all his energies to the determination of what he considers worth while in that channel.

The British situation has shown that with any swing, any change of favour, even as small a percentage as five, there can be a change of Government. I notice Senator FitzGerald preparing and amassing loads of figures—I have not the same aptitude for figures—and I trust he will be able to tell us what percentage swing we would need to change from 85 Fianna Fáil seats to 75 Fine Gael seats. He might make some comment. I do not think it would be a big percentage.

Comment on this

Five or six.

Comment on this

You have an economist over there, too.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan last night made the strongest possible argument in favour of the British voting system and he longed for the day when he could hear Fianna Fáil backbenchers get up, with courage and positive criticism, to criticise their own Government. I share the longing with him but may I tell him at the same time that he has a poor view of the Irish character if he thinks it is only because they are too puny or cowardly that they do not do so? It is no such thing. One of the significant factors here is the size of the Government majority and naturally there is room for rebels in a majority which is reasonably strong. There is room for positive criticism, which sometimes does not come from the Opposition Party, of Government policies and programmes in a majority which is strong. There is hardly any such room, and Senator Quinlan knows this well, in a Party which must rely on a majority of two or three seats.

Comment on this

Parnell said——

Comment on this

This is where I disagree with Senator Quinlan. I have never yet met an Irishman not prepared to differ and disagree. The fact of entry into politics, far from limiting that virtue, increases enthusiasm for it. If Senator Quinlan is so anxious to have the day when we will have objective criticism from the Government back benches, such as they have in England and the United States, he should get up on his bicycle and campaign as hard as possible for the straight vote.

Before going on to consider the balance of advantages, might I consider a query put to me by Senator Sheehy Skeffington when I interrupted another speaker. He asked me for my view of the single-seat alternative vote. I am entirely opposed to it, even more so than I am to PR. In this country you will have a situation, with three Parties, where the two Opposition Parties for the time being will combine to campaign and support each other in their preferences against the Government Party for the time being. The result would be that you would have almost a change of Government after each election, something I am not prepared to consider because I feel it would not be in the best interests of the community. There must be some continuity and the straight vote system will give that, provided the Party in Government deserve and continue to have the full support of the electorate.

Let us consider now the straight vote as against PR. It is important to relate the voting system to the normal experience of people either in their business or home life. Our expression of choice here should merely be an extension of our expression of choice in other aspects of life. On one occasion I sought the views of a person who had long experience counting votes as to how a particular surplus would be transferred because I was very much concerned in my personal interest. He replied: "How could you expect me to know? I only count the votes." How right he was. There was a man with long experience who did not know how the surplus could be transferred in this particular instance.

The straight vote is a determination of choice between one, two, or three possibilities. It is the type of situation one meets every day in life, whether in the home or business or otherwise. You choose one and adhere to it. If it is wrong, you change from it and adopt the other.

Comment on this

Did you never back a horse?

Comment on this

I am talking about the ordinary experience of virtuous men. I am afraid I do not have the fund of experience Senator McHugh attributed to me yesterday. Most housewives do not engage in the frivolity of backing horses, whatever else they may do. We apply this principle of one choice in life and why can we not apply it in politics? We do not say in life: "I shall buy that bullock, but if I cannot buy the old bullock, I will buy a pig and if I cannot get a pig, I will buy a sheep."

Comment on this

That is the Fianna Fáil list of candidates you are discussing.

Comment on this

I am talking about the PR system. In ordinary life you make your choice and stick by it. If you are wrong in buying the bullock, you sell him and come back six months later and buy the pig. Surely, to extend the ordinary experience of life to politics is something entirely logical and something which the people themselves would more readily understand?

Another aspect of the straight vote and the single seat is that you can have representation for every single area in every constituency. Senators must be aware that there are many areas throughout the country that have not had representation for a long number of years and possibly never had it in the Dáil. Certainly, there is one such area in North Tipperary and there is another area which has always been represented by two. Surely it is not unreasonable for people in any area to expect that they should have representation the same as any other? This cannot be guaranteed under PR—there is no gainsaying that—but it can under the single-seat system being proposed. The people will support it for that reason.

I hope I have cleared the air of the hysteria and emotion at the start and the appropriate thing now is to consider the systems. Under the straight vote system the electorate know fully beforehand what policy each Party has —or at least they should if the Parties can express themselves. They know that if they vote for that Party they are voting for that policy. It is very desirable that they should be given the opportunity of expressing their choice for a Government and a policy. This is clearly effected under the straight vote system where they have an opportunity of knowing and evaluating policies. This they do not have as clearly, if at all, under the PR system.

Comment on this

But no choice of individual?

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept no choice of individual. I do not think on this earth we will get a system which will meet all our hopes. The electorate are entitled to express their choice in respect of the Government and the policy they wish to support. Clearly, they can do this under the straight vote system but cannot under PR.

Let us look at the effects of PR on the business of Deputies themselves. I do not wish to be critical of any individual Deputy. That would be wrong of me. I do not want any of these comments to be taken as subjective criticism from somebody who thinks he knows better. I think PR lends itself to producing the type of Deputy more concerned with maintaining himself in the House than with effecting policy. It certainly lends itself to that rather than to doing the real job of policy. Many Deputies are very expert in maintaining themselves. I am just querying whether or not their contribution—I am expressing no view; the public can express their own views— is more or less valuable because their energies are devoted to maintaining themselves. This is one of the creatures and infants of the PR system because of the competition aroused while a single candidate, representing a single constituency, will not be forced to become involved in this kind of competition and certainly will not justify himself by maintaining himself. He can only justify himself by the positive work he does because there are no other standards by which to judge him than the work he does in the House. When you have a single representative you cannot say: "He is not as good at getting a job done as Deputy So-and-so." That will not be the test the electorate will apply. Their test will be: "Is he doing his job or not?" There may be some who will say that he is not as good at getting a job done as somebody else but that he is a good man at his work in the House. I hope this will be one of the effective results of the introduction of the new system.

I do not wish to repeat arguments ad nauseam but this competition which arises between Deputies even in the same Party will be abolished. It will mean—this is very significant—a great saving of time and energy in the Civil Service where frequently four or five different letters, if there happen to be that number of seats in the constituency, must be written to all the different Deputies. Civil servants suffer this obligation and fulfil it. Surely we should be very much concerned about that? No one Deputy can be blamed for taking up the cudgels when asked to do so. He is not aware possibly that the other four have been asked and the only people who are aware of it are the civil servants who could be using their time more gainfully than in writing five different letters to five individual Deputies. This often happens. The removal of practices that are wasteful such as writing multiple letters should be welcomed by all. I suggest the retention of PR will only maintain and increase that tendency while its removal will speed the day when people will be judged on their performance.

It has been said that PR is much fairer than the straight vote, that it is the only fair system. Senator Ryan indicated in a very significant way that if it is as fair as people say it is, the preferences of every candidate should be counted. There is a system of election called the Borda list system of election which evaluates the preferences of candidates as expressed so that a No. 1 vote counts as one, a No. 2 as a half and No. 3 as a third or thereabouts and so on. I suggested this particular system with its clear evaluation in counting No. 2 votes as a half is preferable to PR which makes a No. 2 equal to a No. 1 or a No. 3 equal to a No. 1. I certainly would not accept that. But evaluation votes according to the Borda system, when I suggested it, aroused no enthusiasm among any Fine Gael people to whom I mentioned it. If they are so concerned with a fair system, they might have considered this system. It was a personal notion of mine and not one that I have any authority to suggest but it is an electoral system. There was no enthusiasm for it among the Fine Gael people to whom I spoke. I did mention it to one or two in my own Party and they were prepared to accept——

Comment on this

Then perhaps we should have a committee to look into it.

Comment on this

One of the committees of which the Senator is so enamoured. I am merely concerned with people who say that PR is the only fair system. How fair is it? As Senator Yeats clearly indicated, a system which haphazardly takes a bunch of surplus votes from the top of the votes of an elected candidate can hardly be described as fair. Mark you, I was surprised that it satisfied Senator Sheehy Skeffington who said that, by and large, it works out all right considering that he is a man who likes precision in determining universal justice. I was surprised that he was prepared to accept that one candidate might be unjustly sacrificed, no matter to which Party he belongs, so long as another candidate somewhere else would be elected and balance up the position so far as the Party is concerned. That is what happens under PR.

Are we to be satisfied with such a system when you have, as happened on the last occasion, a difference of four or five or six votes between candidates and when you can be sure that if these votes were counted in a different order, your result could be entirely different? How can we say this is a realistic system of election? It is anything but that. It is certainly not a fair system all the time nor accurate any of the time, and is not exclusive in its selection of candidates. It is a haphazard and capricious system.

Here I want to contradict what Deputy Fitzpatrick said on television. I wish people, if they are going to use figures, would use figures based on experience or accuracy. Deputy Fitzpatrick said on television that Fianna Fáil wanted to get 65 per cent of the seats with 35 per cent of the votes. He repeated this ad nauseam to such an extent that I suppose some viewers who did not know better would believe this had happened. I wish I had an opportunity of sharing the platform with him on that occasion. I would have asked him where he got the 65 per cent of the seats for 35 per cent of the votes because Fianna Fáil, for a long number of years, certainly not since they became the Government, did not get anything like as little as 35 per cent of the votes. There is no prospect, however dearly Deputy Fitzpatrick and his colleagues might wish it, that Fianna Fáil will have as little as 35 per cent of the votes. That is a position which is possibly more familiar to his own Party. There is no sign of its being familiar to us and I have no doubt that will continue to be the case so long as the Opposition Parties behave as they do.

I wish people would try to be accurate and I wish Deputy Treacy on the same occasion could have given one concrete fact as an evaluation of the system instead of saying that our people would man the barricades and that our people would fight for democracy. Which barricades? And which people? Churchill on the shores of Europe could not have spoken with more ponderous solemnity. Certainly he would have expressed more ideas than we had from Deputy Treacy who had not a single idea but spoke about people and barricades. One would think we were out in France again in the Great War.

If we are to discuss these things let us be factual and realistic and forget the hysteria and the "our people" references. If anybody can talk about "our people", certainly Fianna Fáil, with their representation, can claim that much more than the Labour Party. In fact, our experience has been that in ten out of 15 elections held since 1930 the most successful Party got less than 50 per cent of the votes. We are then told that the proposed straight vote system will mean that the most successful Party will not represent the majority view and this is said in the clear light of the fact that even under the existing system the most successful Party on two-thirds of the occasions got less than 50 per cent of the votes.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It has only once got over 50 per cent.

Comment on this

I believe one would get better candidates, more determined candidates who will stand on their own two feet, under the straight vote system than under the existing system. We must take cognisance of human nature and the considerations that affect established political figures. This is an experience that the Labour Party have never had because they put up only one candidate anyway, and Fine Gael have experienced it to a lesser extent, but it is something Fianna Fáil, being the major Party, have been faced with on many occasions. If an established political figure sees emerging a promising young figure, or a not-so-young figure—age does not matter— with potentially strong support in the Party, I would not criticise him too strongly if he tried to place a few barriers in his rival's way and if he supported the selection of a weaker running mate rather than that of a strong running mate. I am not saying it is desirable this should be so but we must take human nature into account. I would say: "Get that bright young man as a running mate rather than the other person who may not be so strong", but nobody knows what he would do in such circumstances unless he was perfectly sure of his position. There have been many young men and many parties that have been frustrated in their efforts to place a programme before the electorate, and I am convinced that the present system is responsible for that frustration. We will not get the best candidates under PR, unless we are able to work the miracle of changing human nature, a miracle which I do not think can be worked in this life. Under the straight vote—and this is not a criticism of the Members of this House—you will get people, by and large, who are selected because of their ability and achievement, and surely this is what we want to get.

Another problem that arises very often is that of minorities. In this small country each individual Irishman is a minority. Therefore there is nothing sacred about minorities. I often feel myself I belong to the minority. What we must do is learn to blend our minority views with those of the majority in a particular group. It is not the business of Government to pander to or to accommodate minority views or the views of small sectional groups who have special causes to plead. It is the business of these groups to integrate themselves into the structure of the parties as they stand, to express their minority views and try to effect a change in the policies of those parties by expressing such views. My view is that minorities do not exist in Ireland, but if they do, there must be one million minorities or three and a half million minorities, the total population of the country. The fundamental object in a democracy must surely be to promote common aims and benefits and not to underline differences, as PR does. We must realise that there may be other ideas which are at least as well informed as our own, to compromise and, let us be honest, to learn from those other ideas.

It has been said on this issue of the electoral system that there is no demand for a change, and that the Government have decided to do something before the people actually want it. Let it be clearly said that the Government are not doing anything finally in this matter. It is the people who will do it. Possibly there is no demand to man Deputy Treacy's barricades, but there is a necessity for what we are proposing. There is a clear indication, particularly in the line of the Labour Party to which I have referred earlier, that they are working strongly towards the achievement of a system where they will have their little balance of power. Three or four more seats will do it, possibly at the expense of the Government Party—not that I am pessimistic enough to think they can do it, but it is not an impossible situation. We should not wait until that chaotic situation arises, when the Labour Party would have that balance of power, to seek to remedy it. I am not prepared to wait for the illness to suggest the remedy. Before the onset of the illness one should suggest a remedy, and that is what the Government are doing.

I hope that from now on in this discussion we shall hear expressed the issues and not the reasons why all of us devils on this side of the House are suggesting for corrupt power reasons abolition of PR, while all the angels and saints and blessed ones on the other side are proposing its retention for entirely divine reasons. From now on I should like to hear factual issues being discussed. Let us talk about what we are trying to do. Perhaps it is not in the interests of the Opposition to do this, but if it is done, they may be very surprised at the decision of the people.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is why they are not prepared to do it.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay on the other aspects of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, because Senator Ryan has covered every aspect of that that I could hope to refer to. May I just say on this question of tolerance, as the Minister indicated in opening, that the rural vote will become approximately equal to the urban vote. I do not think anybody can challenge that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I shall.

Comment on this

Senator Garret FitzGerald is going to mesmerise us with figures, but I say that generally the rural vote will have the same effect as the urban vote, because, as has been said here so often, the Constitution does not relate the constituencies to the electorate but to the population, and, of course. the population is far removed from the electorate. That is where the discrepancy arises. If Fine Gael and Labour are not prepared to give the rural vote the same value as the urban vote, let them say so clearly. Many people forget that there is a constituency in Dublin which is the most highly represented constituency in the country. It has more TDs per electors, so far as I know, than any other constituency, with the exception of one, but that is forgotten. It is Dublin South-Central or Dublin North-Central, I think. If the Government were proposing, which they are not, to make the rural vote of more value than the urban vote, they would be in fairly good company. Many of the people so beloved by Senator Quinlan with established democratic institutions, and particularly nations that have a society structure similar to our own, based on an urban society with a large rural hinterland, such as Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Great Britain, Australia, Canada, New Zealand——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

South Africa and the southern States.

Comment on this

—— all have enshrined in their Constitutions and their electoral systems a balance of tolerance in favour of the rural areas. In some cases the tolerance is based not on population but on the electorate. They make the rural vote much more valuable than the urban vote. If they have done so, it is in our interest to do so also.

I am sure we will get detailed criticism of these proposals from the Senators who follow, but I hope they will not confine those criticisms to the Government Party. Let them not search their hearts' for the reasons they think Fianna Fáil have introduced this proposal, but let them say what they think they are about when they refuse to look into their own hearts for the reasons they are opposing these suggestions.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like, first of all, to congratulate Senator O'Kennedy on an excellent speech in defence of these proposals. It was an honest speech. Even though he was partial in his selection of arguments, the only place where he was not speaking fairly and honestly was in the last few minutes of his speech dealing with the question of tolerance.

Comment on this

I am subject to correction.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If he had prepared that part of his speech in the same way as he prepared the earlier parts, he might not have commented quite in the terms he did.

I welcome the opportunity of speaking on this Bill. The last time the referendum was held I was not involved in politics and I felt a certain amount of frustration at the time, although I did get the opportunity of speaking on certain platforms of a non-political nature. I am glad to have the opportunity now to speak on both these Bills, and try to put across some of the facts and figures which have tended to be overlooked because of the over-generalised approach not only by the Government but also by the Opposition. We are dealing with matters of facts and figures, although there are also certain general principles at stake. The first is the principle of one man, one vote, although the other side will vary in their interpretation of whether one man is an elector or a person. There are certain principles of fair representation. But what is involved is mainly a practical exercise in figures. A good deal of what has been said would be true if the figures were different, but they are not. We cannot get away from the arithmetic.

I am speaking now from personal conviction. I am glad that the policy adopted by my Party corresponds with my conviction. Had it not done so, I might have been in a dilemma. I want to put forward what I have felt for the past ten years as a result of a fair amount of study of some of the problems, a study which for a long time was carried out in an impartial atmosphere outside of politics. My first contact with this question of tolerance was when I was at a meeting in 1959 and Deputy Declan Costello came in with a piece of green paper in his hand. It was the Bill proposing the distribution of the constituencies which was subsequently invalidated by Mr. Justice Budd in the High Court. I asked Deputy Costello was this the Bill whose publication had been announced and he said it was. I asked to see it, and within a matter of three or four minutes after taking it in my hand, I said: "This Bill is certainly unconstitutional." I felt that there was no doubt that if someone took it to the High Court as Mr. John O'Donovan did on his own personal responsibility and at his own financial risk—it was a remarkable thing for any man to have done; it showed a sense of public spirit; I was not prepared to take that risk myself—that it would be invalidated, as it was, in the High Court.

Let us examine this business of tolerance more closely. The whole purpose of this Bill is to enable some areas of the country to have 40 per cent more Dáil representation than others. Lest someone should say the figure is 16? per cent, let me point out that that figure of 16? per cent is upwards and downwards. A five-seat constituency can range between 87,000 and 117,000 population. This means that 117,000 people in one part of the country can be represented by five Deputies, and in another by seven. Seven is 40 per cent more than five. The purpose of the Bill is to enable some parts of the country to have 40 per cent more representation in the Dáil than others. The question is whether that is an excessive or a proper tolerance. Obviously some tolerance is required.

When this proposition was before Mr. Justice Budd in the High Court, a tolerance of 17.2 per cent in the maximum case was involved, 17.2 per cent on either side. That is a tolerance of over 40 per cent. That was a proposal that some parts of the country would have over 40 per cent more representation than others. He ruled that to be unconstitutional. A subsequent court decision ruled that five per cent tolerance was constitutional. We do not know with certainly between those two figures what tolerance might be acceptable under the present Constitution. We know that the proposal to give some areas 40 per cent more representation is unconstitutional. We do not know what the constitutional limit is. That is something which can be tested only when a particular proposition comes before the courts. It would not be proper for the courts to lay down a particular percentage. Each proposition has to be considered on its merits.

The Minister put forward a number of arguments in favour of the proposition to give some parts of the country 40 per cent more representation than others. He said that the constituencies should be based on local communities. We would all be agreed that, so far as it is practicable, that should be done, but I doubt whether the preservation of the county boundaries at all costs is of such importance as to warrant a gross departure from equitable representation in parliament.

Secondly, the Minister said that much of the Deputy's work relates to matters within the competence of the county council and that, therefore, the county council boundary should be respected for the convenience of the Deputy. Many arguments running through this whole question both of tolerance and of proportional representation versus the single seat have been related to the convenience of the Deputy. I mean no disrespect to Deputies when I say that this country should not be run for their convenience. The idea that an electoral system should be designed to convenience Deputies may commend itself to the 144 Deputies in Dáil Éireann but it does not commend itself to the 2,900,000 people outside. It is an argument to which we should pay little attention. It is an argument that may have received undue attention in the Dáil but it is an argument that should receive little attention here, particularly as our electorate is even wider. All of us have had to travel 20 odd counties in order to get here in the first instance.

Business suspended at 1.5 p.m. and resumed at 2.15 p.m.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

When business was suspended I was dealing with some of the arguments put forward by the Minister in defence of the so-called tolerance system. The second of these arguments related to the fact that, in his opinion, much of a Deputy's work relates to matters within the competence of the county council and therefore for him to have an area involving more than one county council and under the present system in one case, even three county councils, is to impose on him an unfair burden. I have already said, in the context of another objection of the Minister's that I do not believe that the electoral system should be geared to the private and personal needs and the convenience of Deputies. I particularly do not believe that it should be geared to their work in connection with county councils. I would remind the House of the judgment of Mr. Justice Budd on this particular issue, in which he laid it down that: "Most important functions are positively assigned to Deputies by the Constitution, the paramount duty being that of making laws for the country. The Constitution did not anywhere in the Articles relating to the functions of Deputies recognise or sanction their intervention in administrative affairs." That, laid down at the national level, is a fortiori all the more true at the local level.

The third objection made by the Minister—it is even more ludicrous— was that the work of registration of electors and the holding of elections is geared to counties and it is inconvenient for county registrars. It is bad enough that we should be told that the electoral system should be geared to the convenience of Deputies but, when it reaches the stage of being told that we must abandon the principle of one man, one vote to suit the convenience of county registrars, then at that stage we must call a halt. That argument is as inept and as bad as the argument that proportional representation is bad because it takes a long time to count the votes.

The Minister's fourth argument was that in the light of this five per cent tolerance that emerged from the Supreme Court decision—we do not know that this is the maximum tolerance allowable and I suspect it could be exceeded in certain circumstances— it was doubtful if any constituency could remain intact in future elections. The Taoiseach made a somewhat similar statement in the Dáil when he talked about the country being divided up into small fractions, or words to that effect. These allegations are simply not true. The fact is that, with a country such as ours, with 26 counties, 144 seats and three- to five-seat constituencies, I suspect there is quite possibly a mathematical law which determines that, in order to achieve the division of these constituencies with a five per cent tolerance, the number of cases in which parts of a county have to be transferred into other adjoining counties is around six or seven.

That emerged in the 1961 division and an examination of the 1966 population figures shows that, once again, the allocation of six or seven pieces of counties to other counties would achieve the result required within the terms of the five per cent tolerance. if that is, in fact, the maximum tolerance. The suggestion that the position will get worse at each election and that, before long, every county will be chopped up, is one for which there is no justification. There is nothing in the situation to make it get worse. There is a changing pattern of population as a result of which it will be necessary to vary the cases of counties which have to be chopped up from time to time so that, in each revision scheme, different counties may be affected in this way and counties which were previously divided may be restored to their territorial integrity.

In the light of the 1966 population statistics the fact is that the amount of subdivision required in this way is almost identical with that in the previous revision based on the 1956 election. Only six counties in fact will need to be affected this time as against seven the last time, although in one case two separate pieces of a county would need to be associated with other counties, but it is effectively the same amount of subdivision.

The Minister must know this because the Minister has able advisers who must have gone into all the possibilities. Again, they cannot have overlooked the fact that division can be managed in this way within the terms of the five per cent tolerance. Let us look first at the last election. The counties affected were Wexford, Louth, Meath, Westmeath, Waterford, Leitrim and Roscommon. Pieces of these were attached to other counties. The counties to which pieces were added were Monaghan, Carlow, Kildare, Tipperary, Sligo, Mayo and again Roscommon. Roscommon lost a piece to Mayo but gained a piece also; it was affected in both directions. Two counties were indirectly affected, Kilkenny and Longford through being attached to counties that were directly affected. In all 15 counties were affected. The Minister said 16. I am always doubtful about alleging inaccuracy in cases like this because Ministers are well advised, and perhaps I have overlooked something —perhaps there is a sixteenth county which I have overlooked, but I can find only 15. But of these 15 counties involved there are only actually seven counties, parts of which have to be allocated to other counties. The effect upon the remaining counties is that something is added to them, not that a part of that county is chopped up and allocated elsewhere. That is what was done on the last occasion. Parts of seven counties were allocated to other counties.

On this occasion on the basis of the 1966 census and this five per cent tolerance, the job can be done affecting one less county although one county would be affected in two directions. There is no increase in the amount of chopping up required and the allegations to that effect are simply incorrect and less than honest.

The counties affected in this way would be, as before, Waterford and Tipperary. Whether you add a bit of Waterford to Tipperary or vice versa is something that is open; the job could be managed in either way, but the same problem exists in that area as existed on the last occasion. It would be necessary to add part of Kildare to Carlow-Kilkenny, a piece of Louth to Meath or vice versa, a small piece of Cork to Kerry, parts of Galway to Clare, and to Roscommon-Leitrim and a piece of Donegal to Sligo.

There are other possible divisions. I do not advocate this particular division any more than I would advocate the division the Minister implemented the last time. It is a matter for the Minister to decide on the one that causes the least inconvenience. I am merely saying that the one I am suggesting would achieve the required result, causing no more disturbance than on the last occasion. The Minister may say that he has a better way of doing it and I am quite willing to consider any other solution, but he cannot say that he cannot do this job without causing more disturbance of the operation of county boundaries than was required on the last occasion. Statements to that effect by himself and the Taoiseach are, in fact, untrue. If the Minister wishes to challenge that, he can do so in the course of his reply.

The Minister has said also that the one-sixth tolerance proposed is the smallest deviation which would, in general, enable the breaching of county boundaries to be avoided. This is also untrue. Again, looking at the actual position of the 1966 population statistics, the tolerance of 16? per cent is not needed in order "in general, to enable the breaching of county boundaries to be avoided" for, in fact, an 11 per cent tolerance would achieve this result in every case except one— Louth-Meath—and the Minister in using the words "in general" clearly meant to imply that there could be individual exceptions. This has always been the case. I recall as a child the constituency of Athlone-Longford. Part of Westmeath-Athlone was added to Longford. There was another case which eludes me. Throughout the history of the State there have been such cases, even when much more than a five per cent tolerance was employed. It would be possible, with an 11 per cent tolerance, to make only one exception—Louth-Meath. To say that 16? per cent tolerance is the minimum required in order, in general, to enable breaching of county boundaries to be avoided is as untrue as the Minister's other statement that the whole country would have to be chopped up if we stuck to the five per cent tolerance.

As I have said, I suspect—and if Senator Quinlan were here, I should like to hear his views on it as he is a mathematician of some competence— that in all probability, there is a mathematical law involved here. If one takes the actual figures of 144 seats and three- to five-seat constituencies and five per cent tolerance, I suspect statistically you would arrive on any given occasion at a subdivision involving the order of seven counties, pieces of which would have to be attached to other counties. That is probably a stable figure and there is no reason why it should increase with the years.

The Minister went on to say that a deviation of this order would be necessary for the purpose, irrespective of whether representation was based on population or on electorate. This, as I shall also show in a moment, is an untrue statement. He said, moreover:

...the overall results of the operation of a divergence within these limits, confined to taking account of the factors mentioned in the Bill, will do no more than in general equate the value of a rural vote to that of an urban vote—if it even does that.

I will show that this is untrue and that, in fact, it has three times as much effect. He went on to say that the percentage of electorate to population was not the same in rural and urban areas, that the electorate as a percentage of the population was appreciably higher in rural areas than in city areas. There is, indeed, some general truth in this although it is not uniformly the case. Donegal and Dublin North-West are the two extreme examples of divergence between the electorate and population. They are, in fact, quite exceptional. In almost every other case the divergence is substantially less than in these two cases.

The Minister went on to say that under the present Constitution there is definite discrimination against areas outside the larger cities and boroughs and expressed the hope that Senators would endorse the principle of one-man-one-vote of equal value, which is inherent in the proposals in the Bill.

These statements are untrue or misleading in various ways. It is good to challenge them because they have not been adequately challenged so far. In this House we should get at the facts of the case.

First of all, on this question of remedying the population-electorate variation, and the suggestion that this is the purpose of the Bill—this is patently dishonest, for two reasons. First of all, if this were, in fact, the purpose or even a purpose of the Bill, then it would be written into the Bill that one of the grounds on which the tolerance would be used would be to enable this to be achieved. In fact, no such reference occurs in the Bill and, if I read the Bill correctly, it would be illegal to take into account this difference between population and electorate in employing the tolerance for the purpose of fixing constituency boundaries. To claim that the purpose of the Bill is to do something which the Bill omits to do, and which this omission renders illegal, is to go beyond the bounds of permissible parliamentary hyperbole.

Comment on this

And nobody said it but the Senator.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am quoting what the Minister said.

Comment on this

You are inventing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

May I quote?—

...the overall results of the operation of a divergence within these limits, confined to taking account of the factors mentioned in the Bill, will do no more than in general equate the value of a rural vote to that of an urban vote—if it even does that.

Comment on this

That is not what you said one minute ago. What you said was a lie.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister should allow me to finish. The Bill does not permit one, in fact, to achieve this result. It is, of course, possible, in doing some of the things the Bill permits one to do that one may achieve this result, or the opposite result, and in certain constituencies the application of the criteria in the Bill would, in fact, achieve the opposite result. But the Bill does not permit the Minister to set out to achieve this result of basing the distribution of Deputies on electorate rather than population. It is something he might achieve by applying the criteria in the Bill, but only accidentally. To set out to do it would be illegal and not by any means a necessary consequence of the application of the criteria in the Bill.

The one-sixth tolerance that he provides for is three times as great as the tolerance required to achieve the result he claims he wants to achieve. The fact is that if one examines the constituencies to see where there is a divergence between electorate and population, one finds that in a number of western constituencies there is such divergence to their disadvantage. The Minister is correct in stating that a problem exists. I shall name the cases, in fact, county by county and the number of seats—they are of course decimal points of seats—affected.

In the case of Donegal, the operation of the population principle gives Donegal 0.5 less of a seat than it would get if seats were allocated on an electorate basis. It is 0.5 in Donegal; in Sligo-Leitrim-Roscommon together it is 0.55; in Mayo it is .2, in Clare it is 0.35, in Kerry it is 0.2, and in Cavan it is .2. There are no other cases of significance, where the divergence is in any way substantial. The sum total represents 2.05 seats. The fact is that under our Constitution, which: the Minister does not propose to amend in this respect, the application of the population principle as against the electorate principle gives to the western counties two fewer seats—leads to under-representation of the West by two seats. It is undesirable this should be the case and, as I have said, I will be perfectly happy, and my Party will be perfectly happy, to substitute the electoral basis for the population basis——

Comment on this

The Senator knows no such thing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

We will be more than happy to do it.

Comment on this

The Senator knows no such thing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is arguable which basis one could make the better case for, but we are prepared to put into the Bill the application of one principle rather than the other if this is to the advantage of the West. I have no reservations on that and my Party have not any, and if the Minister is prepared to put into the Bill that the electorate basis shall be chosen rather than the population basis, he will have the support of my Party. He has not done so because he does not want to, and I do not think he will do it. He has not inserted the electorate basis rather than the population basis as a basis for the distribution of constituencies. Nothing could have been further from his mind than to do anything about this divergence which is to the disadvantage of the West——

Comment on this

Nobody but the Senator has said it is.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If the Minister wants to do it, he will have the support of this side of the House. What he has done is to give himself the right to use a tolerance up to one-sixth for the purpose of enabling him to give to the West, if that is the area he chooses to favour, one-sixth more seats. In the counties I have named, there are now 30 seats and the application of this principle would enable that part of the country to be given 35 seats—one-sixth more than 30—and the Minister's statement in this respect, which I have already quoted, to the effect that this tolerance will do no more than in general equate the value of a rural vote to that of an urban vote is not only untrue but it is grossly untrue. The effect of the tolerance is to make possible a divergence 2½ times greater than that required to overcome the point about the electorate. In making that statement, not only has the Minister misled Members on this side of the House but also those on the other side, because I think I am right in saying that Senator E. Ryan, who is about to sit down, was misled in his remarks, because apparently he made the mistake of believing what the Minister said without checking it. I acquit Senator Ryan of being dishonest but not of carelessness in taking the words of the Minister without checking them, something I would never do myself.

I have nailed three or four untruths in this matter which go to the root of the whole issue. I accept, of course, that there is a valid point in favour of the electorate system, though accepting that the case in favour of the population basis is quite strong. Some people favour a slight weighting of the system in favour of areas involving people with families and this does not seem to be objectionable, but the electorate basis does weigh slightly marginally in favour of the West, and my Party are prepared to accept that. However, the Minister has no intention of accepting the argument in favour of the electorate basis. He has no intention of substituting that term in the Bill for the determination of the constituencies.

If he repents even at this late stage and shows his intention to amend the Bill in this respect, he will have our support, although he might have a slightly irritated Dáil, being recalled for this purpose, if he agrees to substitute as the basis of the division of the country the electorate basis instead of the population basis. The effect would be to reduce the tolerance required, in order to achieve substantially the maintenance of county boundaries, to eight per cent, half the tolerance which he proposes in the Bill. If he permitted this tolerance to be substituted it is something we would be quite happy about because it would be a reasonable tolerance so long as it was used only for the purpose of maintaining county boundaries and not for the purpose of creating a bias in favour of one area against another—it would maintain county boundaries except those of Louth-Meath and Waterford-Tipperary.

I suspect that if the Minister, instead of introducing the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and giving us all the trouble of debating it here and giving the country all the bother of voting on it, had drawn up his constituencies and allowed himself such a tolerance as I have been suggesting, it would have been found to be constitutional. To get the tolerance down to eight per cent from 16? per cent is of great importance. This would meet all the points the Minister has made about county boundaries and about the electorate and it would not leave room for suggestions about gerrymandering of the country which the Minister's proposal in the Bill leaves open.

The Minister referred to tolerance arrangements in other countries and I am unconvinced by these references. They have many practices in other countries which I regard as objectionable and undemocratic and there is no reason on earth why we should copy them. We are fortunate in having a Constitution which I regard as being very good. Every time I say anything in favour of it people on the other side get prickly.

Comment on this