An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 198–389 of 802. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
It is a prickly kind of amusement. I regard our Constitution in most respects as excellent. In any event, it gives security for democratic representation. It has only slightly amended the provisions of the original Constitution of 1922 that provided us with a guarantee that some of the things which happen in South Africa and in some of the Southern States in the US cannot happen here. The concept in certain countries of favouring one section more than others is one which is alien to any reasonable democratic approach. It is an abuse of democracy and it has been applied most effectively in South Africa to get a particular Party into power and in the Southern States of the US.
The Supreme Court in the US has found unconstitutional the efforts in those States in America to keep the negroes in those parts of the US from securing their rights as citizens—it has found the tolerance there to be unconstitutional.
Comment on this
That system has now been found to be unconstitutional, as Mr. Justice Budd found it unconstitutional here. No one reading his judgment could be in any doubt as to what he meant or intended when he said that all this led to the conclusion that any construction of the sub-clause which would have the effect of destroying the dominant preamble of the Constitution that all citizens had equal political rights, should be rejected.
That was the issue: the question of equal political rights for the citizen wherever he may choose to live. That was indicated in that case, as anybody who understood the purpose of the Constitution of 1937 knew it would be. The present Government are now trying to subvert this by a change in the Constitution with a view to depriving part of the people of their rights. It is something which should at this stage in our constitutional history arouse our suspicions and our hackles and should create strong opposition to a Government who undertake such a proposal.
The arguments put forward are from first to last dishonest. The argument about chopping counties is dishonest in that the number of counties which would be chopped up would remain at the small number of six or seven. There is no question of the whole country having to be subdivided. The tolerance of one-sixth is not necessary and goes far beyond what is necessary to avoid the subdivision of counties— and is almost three times as much as would be needed to ensure an equitable distribution of constituencies on the basis of electorate.
I have been very glad to see that on this issue there is a clear division between the Parties. Obviously, this is an issue which could cut across Party politics. Obviously, people who live in parts of the country which would benefit from an unfair and inequitable re-distribution of seats must be tempted to support this proposal. It would not be surprising if there were in all Parties those who would support this because of their interest in their own area and in view of the strong local loyalties we have in Ireland which may transcend attachment to the democratic principle. Nevertheless, despite the possible attractions of such a proposal and its attraction to people in such areas, despite the danger of a stand on democratic principles being misrepresented, our Party has had no hesitation in standing firm in this.
It would have been easy for Fine Gael to let this proposal pass. The Party would, in fact, have benefited. The Fourth Amendment of the Constitution will, as we know, be defeated when it comes before the people in October. If Fine Gael had not opposed the Third Amendment, it is quite possible it would have been passed. As Fine Gael draws their strength disproportionately from those parts of the country, having in Connacht 11 of the 23 seats there, the effect of the Third Amendment alone being passed would be to benefit Fine Gael by increasing the proportion of seats in the part of the country where they are strongest. If the Fourth Amendment were also passed, Fine Gael would, of course, lose because the effect of the Fourth Amendment would be to change representation in Connacht very much to the advantage of Fianna Fáil. As, however, Fine Gael know and believe—as indeed Fianna Fáil know and believe—that the Fourth Amendment will be defeated, the effect of the Third Amendment would have been to benefit Fine Gael, not enormously but by a seat or two. Despite that fact and despite the fact it is always difficult to oppose something that can be misrepresented against you in certain parts of the country, we stood firm on this principle, because it is a democratic principle, that we are not prepared to trade. I am glad we did so.
Comment on this
It was not a principle nine years ago apparently?
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil oscillate between telling us that we were in favour of this proposal nine years ago and that we sabotaged it by taking a case to the High Court. Which horse are they backing?
I now turn to the Fourth Amendment Bill, having dealt adequately with the Third Amendment. The Fourth Amendment raises some issues of principle also, although less important in this case, I think, where important practical issues are, however, involved. There are widely varying views on it within each Party. I am not sure whether in Fianna Fáil the Party ever allowed a vote to be taken on the matter. I am not sure whether we know what the strength of the feeling is in that Party. However, there are divergent views in both Parties. There are people in Fianna Fáil who worked very hard against this proposal and who have expressed great disappointment at the results of their efforts. There are also among those who are against the proposal, different nuances of attitude. On the side of those who favour retaining the existing system, there are those who do so on very strong grounds of principle, those who have an attachment in principle to PR because of its fairness and equity. There are others who do not attach the same degree of importance to this, but who have other grounds, and they are important practical grounds, for feeling that the system is better than the system it is proposed to subsitute for it.
I have never been a dedicated or fervent supporter of PR as a system. But I think as between the two systems now proposed, it would be very difficult for anybody who studied them sufficiently and who understood the implications of them, to do other than support PR. This is not because PR is all virtue but because with all its defects—they are many, and I am conscious of them—it is in the Irish context at this stage of our history superior in its results for the country to the system proposed in its stead.
I am not putting forward the thesis as some of my colleagues are, particularly in the Labour Party—and they are perfectly entitled to do this—that we must have PR at all costs, for ever, regardless. It has great advantages, which one should be very slow to get rid of. The onus of proof is on anybody who proposes to change a system which is fair and equitable in the representation it gives to the different interests in the country. But there may be practical reasons for departing in some measure from the principle of equitable representation in order to achieve more effective government. I do not deny that. Indeed, I have always asserted it. But the onus is on the people who, like those on the other side—and like myself on other occasions—have suggested that there may be a reason for departing from it. The onus is on those of us who have said that to prove our point.
It is a heavy onus for anybody to bear to seek to change a system which is fair and equitable. I think, however, that it has defects. The multi-seat constituency has certain disadvantages which have been outlined at great length. In certain respects the single-seat constituency has advantages, if you could look at it in isolation and if you did not concern yourself with its impact on the whole electoral and parliamentary system. If it yielded the same results as the multi-seat constituency in terms of the number of seats the various Parties would get, the case in favour of it would be very strong. Nevertheless, the single-seat constituency does involve a departure from the proportionality of representation which is a feature of our present system and which guarantees equity. One should be slow to depart from it. It would be necessary to see that any departure from it would not distort or would not undermine to any excessive degree the principle of proportionality and equitable representation and that the outcome of the change would be a system which would be clearly more beneficial than the existing system.
These are things which have not been shown and cannot be shown as regards the new system now proposed to us. For that reason I oppose it. In 1959, when I had nothing to do with politics, I opposed it most strongly because I had studied it in some depth then, perhaps in more depth than many of the people who are now proposing the change without clearly understanding the implications of it. It is from that standpoint that I approach this debate, not from an ideological standpoint—though I accept the depth of feeling underlying the ideological arguments made by supporters of PR. I respect their feelings and would be slow to press them away from their position unless I could be sure that what I was proposing was something better in a clearcut way than the present system.
Let us consider what is now proposed. It is a system which involves the person who secures most votes in an area being elected. It is a fact that Fianna Fáil are, and have been for some decades, the largest Party in the country as a whole. They are also the Party which secures most votes in most constituencies. Were the country to be divided into 40 constituencies and were there 40 Members in the Dáil—if the existing constituencies were used to elect 40 Members to the Dáil—it is very clear that 36, 37 or 38 of those would be Fianna Fáil and two or three or four would be Opposition Deputies. Some people might, in an oversimplified way, assume that one could derive a picture of what way 144 seats would be distributed by extrapolating from that base and saying that if Fianna Fáil get 37 out of 40, then clearly they would get all but ten out of 144. This does not follow. It would be a gross oversimplification and an unfair comment on the measure because divergences between the patterns of voting in different areas within constituencies can be quite marked. It is not simply a case of splitting up a three- or four-seat constituency into three or four or single-seat areas and of assuming that all of them will elect somebody representing the Party, which if you had taken the constituency as a whole, as a guide, would be at the head of the poll. There will be significant divergences from this pattern in many constituencies.
Therefore, in an attempt to asses what the consequences of the change would be at this point in our history, one cannot adopt that approach. One must look behind the figures for Dáil elections and see how the preferences are distributed and see how the political allegiances vary throughout the constituencies. In looking for such information, we have one valid source, subject to some minor qualifications, the local elections held last year. Senator Dooge has explained how he carried out a calculation on this basis and I want to go over the ground briefly, adopting a slightly different approach. What in fact was done when these calculations were made was to use the local election results as a guide or index to the distribution of Party allegiances within the constituencies so as not to get an oversimplified result and to discover whether in fact Party allegiances within the area are as evenly distributed as would appear superficially to be the case or whether they are unevenly divided, so that although Fianna Fáil headed the poll in certain five-seat constituencies, there were certain areas where Fine Gael had the advantage and would head the poll if the area were a single-seat constituency. The local electoral areas provide a guide for this purpose. They are, on average, not dissimilar in population to that which a single-seat constituency would have, although the average varies a good deal. There are many which are very small and many very large but, on average, the difference is not very great.
There are several approaches that may be made to this matter. One which I regard as somewhat crude, but which I think is adequate for the purpose of the calculation, is the approach of taking all the electoral areas and seeing who headed the poll in each, and as there are 144 of them in the county as a whole approximately, relating them to the single-seat constituencies. This I regard as unduly crude. It was, in fact, the first basis of the Chubb-Thornley calculation. However, having done that and then, taking account of the fact that the average rural electoral area is larger than the urban electoral area, by grossing up the urban results and grossing down the rural results, they got a balanced pattern. The result they got was reasonably valid, but I thought the approach was a bit crude.
I thought it would be better to attempt the operation in somewhat greater depth and to examine in each constituency the electoral areas in some detail, with a view to seeing how they might be divided into single-seat constituencies or their equivalents. These county electoral areas were randomly selected regardless of existing political allegiances. They were devised long ago and bear no relationship to the pattern of support for the Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour Parties. They represent a random selection averaging something approximating to what a single-seat constituency would be. In the calculations which Senator Dooge and I carried out quite separately—although my calculation was confined to the alternative vote and did not extend to the spot or straight vote, as the Minister likes to call it—we looked at these constituencies and devised single-seat constituencies, in some cases breaking up very large electoral areas and in some cases combining smaller ones together to get the best simulation we could of what the pattern of voting would be likely to be in a single-seat constituency.
We did this separately and compared results afterwards. We used a slightly different technique in the city of Dublin where there are special problems and got slightly different results from each other in this area. But the overall result in regard to the alternative vote in my calculation is within three of Senator Dooge's result and is also within two or three of the results achieved by Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornley. There are three independent operations and these calculations were carried out simply in order to get an answer and not for propaganda purposes. They were carried out before this issue arose as a public issue simply to see what the alternative results would be and to obtain a result for our own internal guidance. Certainly, we did not wish to mislead ourselves as to what the results of the system would be. We wished the information to be available to our colleagues to enables them to make a decision in this matter and guide them towards a decision.
Comment on this
We were not looking for any result except one that would enables the Fine Gael Party to take a decision on what the effects of a change of this kind would be. Any question of bias is ruled out.
Comment on this
Similarly, in the case of Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornley, they adopted a purely scientific approach and were similarly unbiased. The effect of the three calculations was to produce very similar results. The Thornley-Chubb approach, because of their rather crude method of handling the Dublin rural area divergence, led to a slight underassessment of the Fianna Fáil seats that would be secured at this stage in the electoral situation envisaged. They got a figure of 93 and Senator Dooge got 98. I would have expected some such divergence because of the particular methods adopted. Substantially, the results derived are similar within a very few seats. We have three independent checks for this purpose.
The result did not surprise me very much because in 1959 I carried out an exercise of a similar kind myself. There was no political angle to it whatever. I was just concerned to know something of the working of the political electoral system. The result was very similar in character although based on completely different material related to the 1950s, whereas we now have information from the 1965 general election and the 1967 local elections. The result I got was similar and it showed this very high figure of seats for a relatively small figure of votes in the range around 40 per cent.
Comment on this
On the basis of a large number of candidates in each area.
Comment on this
No. I do not think the Senator was present when Senator Dooge explained that the Independent votes were discounted for this purpose, an action which he validated——
Comment on this
Were discounted for his purpose. Senator Dooge explained that he validated his caculation in relation to Cork where it was shown that the Independent votes balance out and did not affect the overall results.
Comment on this
I am very sorry if Senator Yeats gives up. It is a pity he was not here when Senator Dooge explained——
Comment on this
He showed that the Independent votes spread pretty evenly over the Parties and do not affect the ultimate result. Therefore, we have a measure of the likely result of this system at certain different levels in the political spectrum. We have figures for Labour, Fine Gael, and Fianna Fáil. In votes Labour are around the 15 per cent mark; Fine Gael are around the 35 per cent mark; and Fianna Fáil are around the 45 per cent mark. The exact figures I shall come to later. Taking the figures one gets from these three independent studies, one gets a curve of relationship between seats and votes.
I have also, in the course of studying this matter, examined the election results in Britain since 1935. I have gone back further, but the earlier ones, because of the different Party structure, are not relevant to our present situation. If one takes the results of elections in Britain since 1935, except two in the 50s where the Liberal vote was so small that it is not a true representation of the three-Party system, one can plot a curve of the relationship between seats and votes in that country. In fact, the various points one gets all fall very closely on the curve line. We also know from our own experience the relationship between seats and votes under PR. It is possible, therefore, to plot all four curves, the British curve with the straight vote, the Irish curve with the straight vote, the Irish curve with the alternative vote, single-seat constituencies, and the Irish curve with PR, and to compare the results. That is something I have done in considerable detail, and I have certain figures to which I shall come and which I am prepared to place in the Library of the House for inspection by anyone who wishes to examine and to validate them or invalidate them by checks and tests.
The results show an extraordinarily high ratio of changeover of seats to votes, particularly in the range from 35 to 45 per cent. This is something which is to be expected on a priori grounds because the British system is known to be extremely unstable, and any spot vote system is liable to be unstable in this way because of the first past the post element. The British system we know to be unstable and we would except that an election under this system in Ireland would yield even more distorted results for the reason that Ireland, unlike Britian, does not have the phenomenon of the safe seat. It is characteristic of certain areas in Britian, where political allegiance is so class-orientated, to have these safe seats, and in fact right through hundreds of years the Party system has been maintained there because of these local strengths.
I have examined these historically, and I think one will find — and I direct the Minister's attention particularly to this; I am sure he will be increased—— if one studies the political situation in England around 1641, the period of the civil war, and compares it with today, one finds there was a Royalist-Roundhead break-up of England similar to the Tory-Labour break-up of England today. In other words, there is a deep-rooted geographical division going back far into history, to the 17th century and even earlier than that, to the Puritan-Anglican division of the 16th century and, possibly, to the Lollards in the 14th century. The fact that this division is there means that at any moment in time the Party against whom the political tide has turned will retain substantial representation in Parliament. The pendulum swings widely, and even wildly under the spot vote system, but it never swings too far because of these safe seats. There will be at least 100,but is usually around 150.
Comment on this
Yes, but that result was complicated by the fact generally speaking, this figure for safe seats would be around 150. In Ireland we do not have this. There are areas, it is true, particularly Clare and, perhaps, Donegal, where Fianna Fáil are strong and are unlikely to be dislodged easily in the future. These areas are relatively few in mumber. There is no compaison between Ireland and Britain in this respect. The division within the Republic is not geographical; although it is in the island as a whole. In these circumstances, it is inevitable that the political pendulum will swing very widely under the straight vote, much more than in Britain. As I have said, one would except, on a priori grounds, that this wopuld be the result, and that is what emerges from my own independent study in 1959, when I had no political axe to grind, from the studies Senator Dooge and I carried out to guide Fine Gael, and from the study carried ou independently by Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornely. These studies have been undertaken on four separate occasions, and one can take the results as representing the true position, and no amount of argument or laughter will easily discredit them.
This, therefore, is the position, that we are asked to adopt an electoral system which is known to be extremely unstable in its home country, Britian. I should like the House to consider why it is that the British electoral system, which is the simplest and most obvious electoral system, the first system devised, does not operate in any part of the world except in Britian, Canada, the United States and, for certain purposes only, in Australia. There is a very good reason for this, because the system is inherently so unstable as to be in most countries totally unworkable. It began to operate in very abnormal circumstances in the country in which democracy originated, Britian, a country in which religious and political divisions were of such a character that this simple system was able to work when the Party system evolved. The idea of a single seat and people putting in an X after the name when the could not write wa something which, as it happened, did work in the country in which denocracy originated. It was then exported to other countries. It has worked in the United States because the United States is a federal community in which there are deep political divisions, Democrats in the South and Republicans in parts of the North, and so on. It has worked also in Canada because it is a federal country with deep political/geographical divisions, with the Conservatives and the Liberals deeply entrenched in different areas. In every other country it had to be abandoned, because in other countries where political allegiances are fairly evenly distributed the system is totally unworkable. In different countries they employ different techniques. In a number of countries they employ a list system rather than a system of voting for individuals. In France, they have the system of the second ballot.
Comment on this
I thought we were not supposed to consider other countries, that we were to make up our own minds.
Comment on this
When we were looking at other countries the Senator said we should not do this.
Comment on this
I am looking behind the scenes at the figures Fianna Fáil were giving. It is of value to consider other countries as long as we demonstrate exactly what happens there. I am concerned to establish that apart from America and Canada, every other country has had to abondon the simple, straightforward straight vote electoral vote system. It would not have been abondoned if there was not something wrong with it. The reason it had to be abandoned was that it was unworkable, that it would create such enormous swings and vast majorities, as to undermine and endanger democracy. So we have the list system in Europe, and we have the list system in Europe, and we have the French with two ballots, so that for any area where one does not get an overall majority on the first ballot, there is a second ballot, and certain people pull out and different alliances are formed, and have the PR system in one or two other countries, in Ireland, for instance, in Malta, Gibraltar, Tasmania, and in certain cases in Australia.
I am not saying that PR is the best solution. I think it has great merits. It is an equitable system. If it is working, I do not see why we should be in a hurry to depart from it, although a case could be made for departing from it. It may be that some other system would be better. I have an open mind on that, and I am quite prepared to hear arguments on it. But the British system is one which happened to originate in a cpountry where it happens to work becuse there are deep religious, political and geographical divisions. They exportes it successfully to a couple of other areas which were colonised in different ways and which developed into federal communities but elsewhere is has been replaced with a system which mitigated its appaling effcts. This has not been stated adequately either in this House or in the 1959 debate——
Comment on this
It is working badly in Britain today.
Comment on this
I do not defend it in Britain, but in Britain it does not wipe out the Opposition. It does not lead to intolerable swings in which half of the House disappears at one blow. At least there is some kind of an Opposition in Parliament to protect democracy. In this country the Opposition—and whether it is Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour does not matter—would be decimated under that system. Fianna Fáil do not talk about the dangers of that system. They talk about the weaknesses of PR, but they are not entitled to foist on this country a system which is unworkable except in abnormal circumstances, a system which would yield total political instability, a system under which a fall or rise of eight, ten or 12 per cent in the votes could lead to a loss of 30, 35, 40 or 50 seats for one Party, and similar gains for another, a situation in which Fianna Fáil at their weakest since 1932 would get 98 seats——
Comment on this
——at their weakest. Let us face facts. At the moment Fianna Fáil have probably 44 per cent of the votes. I think the figure wa down to 43 per cent on only one occasion. There was a swing against them in the recent local elections and in the by-elections since 1965.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to talk about the by-elections. It might be no harm to face the facts and consider why this proposal is put forward at this point in time. This proposal willshift the point above which a majority can be gained by Fianna Fáil. The Fianna Fáil share of the vote has dropped. At the moment it is probably 43 or 44 per cent, and it has moved down into the area where Fianna Fáil cannot get a majority under PR. It is not a coincidence that at this point in time a new electoral system is proposed.
Let us examine the figures which show the decline in Fianna Fáil strength. Let us look at the figures of the election results over the past ten years. They were published in the papers a year or so ago.
Comment on this
Are these the figures that ignores the Independents?
Comment on this
For this purpose, the Independents are not included. I am quite prepared to compare the figures for the local elections together and the general elections together, but I am concerned to show the relationship between the three political Parties at all recent elections. These figures show the relative position of the three Parties vis-á-vis each other. The Fianna Fáil figures are: at the 1957 general election, 57 per cent; at the 1960 local elections, 51 per cent; at the 1961 general election, 50 per cent.
Comment on this
Of the total votes for the three Parties. The total votes including Independents show an identical trend for the general elections together and the local elections together, but I am showing the relative position of the Parties vis-á-vis each other.
Comment on this
There is an identical trend for the general elections and for the local elections. I will start again: the 1957 general election, 57 per cent; the 1960 local elections, 51 per cent; the 1961 general election, 50 per cent.
Comment on this
Surely the Senator is entitled to speak without these interruptions?
Comment on this
How could the senator hear when he was interrupting?
Comment on this
I am sorry if I did not speak loudly enough to be heard over the interruptions: 1957 general election, 57 per cent; 1960 local elections, 51 per cent; 1961 general election, 50 per cent; 1965 general election 49 per cent; and 1967 local elections, 45½ per cent. The Fine Gael figures were: 1957 general election, 32 per cent; 1960 local elections, 35 per cent; 1961 general election, 36½ per cent; 1965 general election, 35 per cent after a slight dip; and 1967 local elections, 38 per cent. The Labour figures were: 1957 general election, 11 per cent; 1960 local elections, 14 per cent; 1961 general election, 13½ per cent; 1965 general election, 16 per cent; and 1967 general election, 16½ per cent.
Those are the figures of the Party votes and I am quite prepared to produce the figures for the general elections together and the local elections together, including the Independents, and they all show the same downward trend. Ww are considering here the Party vote and this downward trend which has perturbed Fianna Fáil. There was a drop of from 49 per cent to 45½ per cent in their share of the Party votes between 1965 and 1967.
I want to give the figure now for the four sets of by-elections we have had since the 1965 gerneral election. In the Waterford-South Kerry batch, the swing in the vote, that is, the fall in the Fianna Fáil share of the total vote, was six per cent. It fell from 47 per cent to 44.2 per cent, a drop of 2.8 points which is six per cent of 47. In the West Limerick and Cork by-elections, the swing against Fianna Fáil in the same terms was 7½ per cen. In the Clare and Wicklow by-elections, the swing was 15 per cent. In the Limerick by-election, the swing was 17 per cent. These are the best com,parisons that can be made. To show the care with which they have been carried out, in the case of the South Kerry result, it is a comparison of the first count of the by-election with the second count of the general election, after the elimination of Mr. Courtney, so you get a fair comparison between the three Party figures rather than a distorted picture. In each case, they are the best comparison that can be made. If you have Independents in one election and not in another, you get a complete distortion of the percentages. That is the trend of the Fianna Fáil votes— a sharp down-turn between the general election and the local elections of 1967; a sharp decline accelerating at each by-election in the four sets of by-elections we have had.
I do not suggest by-elections are necessarily representative. It is not the experience in this or other countries that a general election held shortly after a by-election yields exactly the same swing against the Government. It is normal for the swing to be somewhat exaggerated in by-elections. I do not suggest a general election would necessarily show a swing of 17 per cent against Fianna Fáil just because that is the Limerick by-election result: it could well be less than that. Nevertheless, there has been an accelerating swing against the Government throughout these four by-elections and local elections.
No Impartial observer within the Fianna Fáil Party or outside it, if such there be in Fianna Fáil—I am sure there are such when it affects the interests of their own Party—could but be perturbed by that situation. The logical consequence is a change to a system of election in which the crucial point to secure a majority is not 46 per cent or, indeed, by an unfortunate quirk for Fianna Fáil the last time, 47½ per cent, in order to get 50 per cent of the seats—that was just an abnormality—but about 40 to 41 per cent: for anything above that they will get a majority.
It is a sound calculation that the swing against Fianna Fáil has probably not reached such proprotions as to push their share of the poll below 41 per cent. Allowing for the natural exaggeration in by-elections, the swing against Fianna Fáil at the moment is probably ten per cent, plus or minus a couple of points. As they got 47½ per cent last time, they would probably now get 43 per cent and, with luck, perhaps 44 per cent. That is a figure which could not give them a majority under the present system but it would give them a nice fat majority under the proposed system. If they got 44 per cent of the votes under the proposed system, they would get 98 seats, as is shown by the studies we carried out. I think the figure of 98 seats is probably marginally more accurate than the Chubb-Thornely 93 seats. If they got 43 per cent, they would probably get about 90 seats. This is a very comfortable result in contrast to the uncomfortable position of something in the sixties in a Dáil of 144 seats— which is where Fianna Fáil willstand in the next general election after being defeated in the referendum, except that the defeat in the referendum may accelerate the trend against Fianna Fáil and their share may fall below the 43 per cent or 44 per cent. such, I think, would be the calculation of much political commentators at the present time. This is the position that faces us.
The Government, seeing their position slipping consistently, and at an accelerating rate, propose to change the electoral system to one which will secure for them the largest number of seats they have ever had—far beyond anything they ever had in this state— with the smallest proportion of the vote they have ever had in this State. That is the proposal we are faced with. The voices from the Finna Fáil benches and from the Ministers of the Government call on us to accept this attractive proposal with the bait that Fine Gael might be in office with an enormous majority under the new electoral system and they tell us——
Comment on this
——in soft and attractive terms that this is a device for the benefit of Fine Gael. The honest ones among them—Senator O'Kennedy and some others—admit that the effect at the next general election will be to put Fianna Fáil in power with 85 to 90 seats. I think it would be over 90 seats: he thinks it wouls be under. I will accept his figure for the purpose. It is a reasonable figure. It is enough for the sake of my argument. Senator O'Kennedy says we should accept Fianna Fáil in power the next time because who knows what might happen the next time? Who knows what the future of this country would be if, after 17 years of Fianna Fáil rule—as it then would be—the Government were in office with 85 to 90 seats, with the Fine Gael Party reduced to the 30s and the Labour Party reduced to perhaps ten seats. After five more years of Fianna Fáil rule with a majority far larger than they would ever have under our present electoral system, we are told, in effect that there would be a wonderful swing to Fine Gael; that Fine Gael would be in office on its own; that Labour would disappear, and that people would then vote for either of the two Parties, Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. We are expected to fall for that kind of talk. They think we are suckers.
Comment on this
We are neither suckers nor dishonest nor are we prepared to endanger the future of this country for that kind of calculation. The proposed electoral system involves such an enormous turnover of seats to votes that it would endanger the working of the democratic system. How many people would be as keen to enter public life—regrettably not enough are —if they had to face a typical election swing against the Party which would normally lead to a loss or gain of between 30 and 50 seats —that, in fact, it would be quite normal for the Party to lose half its Dep[uties at a general election? This is what would happen. If we examine the swings in general elections back to 1948, I know of no case where the swing has been less than six per cent. On several occasions, the swing has been 12 per cent and once it was eight per cent. Typically, the swing is about ten per cent.
A ten per cent swing over the critical range of 40 to 45 per cent of the votes will yield a loss of 40 seats. A 12 per cent swing in votes—it happened twice in the past 20 years—would eliminate 50 seats over this range. How many people would be prepared to go into politics when the odds are almost evens that, at every election, they would be out on their ear—which, mathematically, would be the result? I do not think that would be good for Irish politics. What kind of system would it be where the larger Opposition Party would, quite normally, be reduced to 30 seats and the smaller Opposition Party to about ten seats? What sort of alternative Government would it be able to form? How could it hold itself out to the electorate as capable of forming an alternative Government. With 30-odd seats, how many people of Cabinet rank would there be, considering the difficulty the present Government have found, to find a Government out of 74 seats. They have been forced to resort in some cases to the scrapings at the bottom of the barrel. What sort of alternative Government would the larger Opposition Party be able to form, even if they managed to attract a bettr calibre of Deputy than the present Government with about 30-odd seats? We are told that, at the second-next election, people will swing to Fine Gael and throw out Fianna Fáil. That is said by Fianna Fáil as if their one great hope in life is that Fianna Fáil will be wiped out of office in 1975. But for whom would the people then vote? Will they vote for the Fine Gael Party which would be reduced to 30-odd seats and with perhapos one-half or one-third of its present front bench eliminated in that election?
We are frequently told by Fianna Fáil that we do not look like an alternative Government. It is legitimate for any Government to say that to an Opposition. I trust we shall be saying it to Fianna Fáil in a few years time. How much more force would there be in that taunt when the larger Opposition Party would be reduced to such a small scale? With a Government already showing signs of arrogance and authoritarianism with miniscule majorities or no majority at all, what would it be like with a Government which had a majority of th proportions forecast under the proposed electoral system? Is ther anything in the farming community to reasure us? Is there anything in the Government's handling of Radio Telefís Éireann to reassure us? Is there anything in the Government's mishandling of advertising for The Irish Farmers' Journal to reassure us? Is there anything to reassure us in the Government's attempt to use Government advertising to force a newspaper to adopt a particular line? Is there anything in the new Criminal Justice Bill to reassure us, and so on? Is there anything in the Government's handling of public matters at present to encourage people to hand to a Fianna Fáil Government 95 seats in the Dáil so that they would be ruled by strong Fianna Fáil government? We know what “weak” Fianna Fáil government means and the farmers know what it means, and would they thank Fine Gael for handing them over to a strong Government at this stage because we are told that in 1975 we might hope to sweep in with a similar majority and be in a position to do to others what they have done to us?
This is something I am prepared to support. I am not committed to the present electoral system and I am open to conviction that there amy be a better system. I see many defects in the system and i have criticised it publicly in the past and I will do so again. However, I am not prepared to get rid of a reasonably livable-with devil for a devil we do not know but the delineation of which we can at least see, and it is not attractive. I am not prepared to recommend that to my Party or to the country. Whatever defects there are in PR, we must stand firm on it. We must at all costs reject this proposal to introduce a system which is unworkable in other countries, except in a small handful of countries which have a particular geographical basis or structure. We must avoid the introduction of such a system in politically homogenous country. We must reject it because it is a bad system and because it would give this Government with their declining support another five years in office some 12 years in office already.
It must be rejected also because one of the objectives of the proposal is to wipe out the Labour Party and because that Party have something to offer the country, something of a special character which we of the other Parties do not offer in quite the same way. They represent in a particular way in which we cannot, with our broader national basis, the working people. We know that they only get the support of a proportion of the working class vote at the moment, as most of it is shared by the larger Parties, but nevertheless because of their particular dedication to the interests of this group, they have an important function to perform. It is proposed that this Party should be wiped out by rigging the electoral system against them and that we in Fine Gael should co-operate in this. It is suggested to us that we should engage in this dishonourable deal at the expense of the Labour Party. On that count alone, I would be aginst it.
The Labour Party have a vital role to play and their extinction would be disastrous in many ways. They play a positive and useful role, representing as they do in a particular way the interests of a section of the community, and this proposal would force out of Parliament the particular, peculiar, representatives of the working people. I mean "peculiar" in the sense that they represent them in a way peculair to them, and that no one else represents them in quite the same way. I mean nothing objectionable
Comment on this
I am not prepared to support any such proposal. I can think of nothing more calculated to stir up the always latent dissatisfaction of a people with a parliamentary system in any country, and particularly in this country where we have a long tradition of opposition to our parliamentary system, a country which moreover is so strongly middle-class. To rig the electoral system so that the one Party which particularly represents the interests of these people would be pushed out, is not the way to secure restraint and political peace. Would this secure respect for our parliamentary institutions? Would it ensure political stability? I think not. I think that while one can see defects in PR, while there is case for limiting proportionality of the system to give it a little bias which would give us slightly larger majorities, there is no case for the wholesale removal of the system, for wiping out one Party and leaving one important section without representation which they seek and secure through the Labour Party. That is another reason why I will not engage in this dishonourable deal.
Comment on this
While he may not believe that PR is the best system, he is not prepared to engage in a dishonourable deal to do down the Labour Party and foist on the people the proposed systm which would have that effect.
Comment on this
I see defects in the present system and I see that there is a possibility of improving it, but not in this way. Any change which is to be made must be made by agreement amongst all Parties and it must not be directed to doing down one Party. By the aggreement of all Parties, it mast be carefully considered and calculated to see that it will in fact achieve an improvement and that it is not foisted on us without adequate consideration and study. I should like to ask the Minister what study has he carried out into the defects of this system? Will he put before the House his figures and shown us the basis of his calculations in the same detail as I have done and as Senator Dooge, Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornely have done? What is your expectation? Where are your calculations? Have you made any?
Comment on this
Have you or have you not studied it? Do you know or do you not know the results it would be likely to produce.
Comment on this
The Senator is conducting his speech on the basis of cross-examination and directing questions to me.
Comment on this
I resent the imputation that the Chair is being unfair. In due course, the Minister will have the opportunity to reply. Senator FitzGerald, without interruption.
Comment on this
I should like to apologise for posing rhetorical questions. They do arise out of rhetoric, and at times because of rhetoric, one forgets oneself. Let us consider what has happened in Britain with this system, even with their strong geographical basis for their politics. Earlier Senator Yeats challenged: were there any Parties in Britain with a minority vote——
Comment on this
Senator Dooge said that with 40 per cent, Fianna Fáil will get 98 seats. I say that is ridiculous.
Comment on this
I am sorry; let me explain. I think Senator Yeats has got Senator Dooge slightly wrong. Senator Dooge's calculations were on the basis of the local election figures in which Fianna Fáil got just under 40 per cent of the votes and the probability is that, on the basis of those figures, Fianna Fáil would get in a general election about 44 per cent of the votes. I want to get the record straight, in case there was any misunderstanding in connection with the presentation of the figures. There is no claim made here that in a general election, Fianna Fáil, with less than 44 per cent of the votes, would get 70 per cent of the seats. If Senator Dooge did not make himself clear, then I apologise on behalf of Senator Dooge in absentia. Because of the large number of Independents standing, the votes for all three Parties were depressed in the local elections. Using these figures as a basis for calculating the distribution of votes within constituencies, one arrives at the conclusion that Fianna Fáil, with 44 per cent of the votes, would obtain in a general election 68 per cent of the seats. That is the only claim we make and, if there is any misunderstanding, I apologise to Senator Yeats. It is important that we should not let ourselves be confused.
In Britain, where the system works less viciously, in 1918 35 per cent of the votes secured 54 per cent of the seats for the Conservatives. Although the British system is not as extreme, 47 per cent of the votes in 1924 secured 67 per cent of the seats. That instance is somewhat similar to our own situation. I am anxious Senator Yeats should get the full force of my remarks, because he is particularly interested.
Comment on this
In 1924, 47 per cent of the votes gave the Conservatives 67 per cent of the seats. That is quite close to our situation here. It is not quite as extreme because the variation will be somewhat greater here. In 1945, 48 per cent of the votes gave Labour 62 per cent of the seats. Because of the concentration of its votes in the urban areas, Labour cannot mobilise and use its votes adequately and, for that reason, they benefit less from the system than do the Conservatives. In 1951, there was an interesting result; the Labour Party secured 48.8 per cent of the votes and the Conservatives secured 48.0 per cent, but the Conservatives won the election.
Comment on this
These remarks are addressed to me; the Senator, specifically said so.
Comment on this
I was not seeking a running commentary from Senator Yeats and, if he thought I was, I apologise for misleading him. The British system can produce the most extraordinary results. Senator Yeats will, I am sure, recall the election of 1923 in which the Conservatives lost only one per cent—I want to check— I think 39 per cent of the votes gave the Conservatives 56 per cent of the seats in 1922, but in 1923 they lost one per cent of the votes, they got 38 per cent of the votes in 1923, but they got only 42 per cent of the seats.
Let us consider briefly some of the objections made to proportional representation—briefly because I do not think this is the crucial issue. I have, I think, dealt with the real issue in this debate. "The multiple constituency is a disadvantage". It is. There are disadvantages in it. All things being equal, the single seat would be preferable, but it is arguable that the loss of proportionality this would entail outweighs the disadvantages of the single-seat constituency as against the multiple seat constituency. That is arguable and my convictions in this regard are not as strong as those of other people.
There are some contradictions in the Minister's approach because, in speaking about the Fourth Amendment, he talked about the undesirable feature of a TD being too concerned in constituency matters, but the Third Amendment is specifically designed to enable a TD to be concerned in constituency matters. The Minister should reconcile these two contradictions. There is, then, the objection to the large number of names on the ballot paper. I am not at all convinced that this is a disadvantage. All these arguments are falsified by the extraordinarily intelligent way in which our people have consistently used PR. "Intelligent" does not mean voting for either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael; it may mean voting No. 1 Fianna Fáil and No. 2 Fine Gael. People have done that for very good reasons. They are entitled to do it.
In Dublin North-East in 1957, I noticed a great many people voted in what I regarded as a most intelligent manner, in that they knew what they wanted to achieve and they achieved it. They put the Sinn Féin candidate No. 14. A number voted alphabetically for the rest. This showed a suitable disinterest in the finer nuances as between Fianna Fáil, Labour and Fine Gael. They kept Sinn Féin out. They wanted to keep Sinn Féin out and they voted intelligently to do so. Some voters start at the bottom and vote up, putting the man they like least last. I have done that myself in university Senate elections. That is another way of voting intelligently.
The people understand the system and all this talk of the system being too complicated is so much nonsense. The complications involved are a matter for the people doing the counting. The argument that we may have to change the system because we have to wait a long time for the result is just ludicrous. Indeed, so many of the arguments are ludicrous that it is sufficient to mention them in order to dismiss them. The point about some lower preferences not being counted is a nice debating point. We are not looking for mathematical perfection. We are looking for a system which is fair and equitable, which represents the various interests of the country, and which is likely to result in a Government with a reasonable majority. Whether every fourth preference counts, or does not count, is something the Minister may worry about, but not many other people worry about it.
Comment on this
There is just one other point I should like to clarify, in case there should be any doubts about how the single seat spot vote system may yield in this country such extraordinary results. If one takes three of four constituencies, which I shall name, one can demonstrate what will happen. In Donegal at the moment, there are four Fianna Fáil and two Fine Gael Deputies. If one examines the local election areas, one finds that in every electoral area, without exception, there is a Fianna Fáil majority of not less than 1,000 over Fine Gael, who, in each case, were the next Party in line. Unless, therefore, one gets a very large swing indeed, a swing of 25 per cent against Fianna Fáil, the result of any election there under the spot vote single-seat system means that every seat goes to Fianna Fáil, whereas, at the moment, four go to Fianna Fáil and two to Fine Gael.
Again, in Meath, all the seats would go to Fianna Fáil because they have a majority in all the electoral areas. No matter how one chops up the areas and no matter how one distributes County Meath, the representation will be, under the spot vote single-seat system, Fianna Fáil three seats and none for anybody else. In Waterford, a similar situation would arise. In all the rural areas of the county Fianna Fáil have a clear majority. They also have a clear majority in two of the three city wards. Fine Gael and Labour lead in one ward by a couple of hundred, but that is insufficient if that ward is linked, as it will have to be, with some neighbouring area to form a single-seat constituency. No matter how you chop it up, and without bothering to gerrymander at all, Waterford becomes three Fianna Fáil, instead of one, one and one.
The same position will arise in Clare. Other Parties have representation there now but, under the proposed system, Clare will become an entirely Fianna Fáil stronghold. That is because the distribution of the votes is fairly even. They are not strongholds of particular Parties in many cases, and constituencies, at present represented by three Parties, will, under this system, become represented solely by Fianna Fáil. That is the reason why you get this extraordinary change over to something like 98 seats.
These are the points I wanted to make. In conclusion, I should like again to appeal to the House and to anybody in the House who is uncommitted, if there be some, and to the people, that, whatever they may feel about the defects of PR and they may share my doubts as to its perfection, they in no circumstances adopt a system which hardly any other country has been able to work, a system which would lead to a political instability we have never known and hope we never will know. I hope that the Irish people will in October next reject this proposal. After that, we shall see where we stand under PR at the next general election.
Comment on this
So much has been said on this matter over a number of weeks in both this House and the other House that I am seriously tempted to emulate the late President Coolidge who is reported as having said after he came back from church and his wife asked him what the sermon was about, "sin", and when she asked what the preacher had to say about it, replied after some thought: "He was against it." If I were really merciful, I would think at this stage I would just say that I am against the present system and sit down but I do not see why I should do so. Therefore, I propose to say something about the proposal before us and give, more or less, again, the views I gave nine years ago. To many people, I am sure, it is a surprise to know that I did speak nine years ago. This is one of the results of the system of censorship which is in polite circles called editing.
The choice before us and, later on, the people, is between the multi-member constituency with the transferable vote and the single-member constituency with the straight vote, or whatever other name anyone likes to put on it—the relative majority, I believe, is the official title. It may seem a bit oversimplified to mention this at this stage, but there has been such a spate of oratory which appeared to me to bring in almost everything else, that I thought it would be no harm to say that it is on this proposal I am speaking.
So far, listening to the protagonists for the various Parties, it strikes me that each of them is more concerned as to how this will affect the Party than as to how it will affect the country. There is this odd point of view that nothing will really change the electorate, that the electorate are fixed in their opinions one way or the other and all we have to do is to find a system which gives so many percentages in this way and so many percentages that way that one's own Party will profit by it.
I think it was unkind for Senator FitzGerald to relegate the Labour Party to the odd tail at the end of things and limit them just to represent some decent working people, implying that it would be quite impossible for the Labour Party to produce a programme which would have a wider interest. It is reasonably certain that in Great Britain the Labour Party programme appeals to more than the humble workingman. I do not see any reason why the same thing should not happen here, so that it is not very kind, if I may say so. It sometimes strikes me that Fine Gael are in a bit of a cleft stick. They are never quite sure whether in competing for the anti-Fianna Fáil vote they ought to kick Labour in the teeth or, hoping for some measure of support, ought to placate them in some way. I hope in saying this I will be recognised as being reasonably objective. I know it is very difficult for people to believe that a nominated Member of the Seanad is objective. May I say, in order to counterbalance this, when I may be disposed to give my opinion, that I have no political ambitions at all. I will be quite honest. I could not care less whether whatever system of election is chosen by the people helps Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour. All I am interested in is that there should be a system which will be clear, simple and will produce a good Parliament. What happens the various Parties is to me a matter of no importance whatsoever. What is really confusing the country at the present moment is the complete inability to distinguish between the two major Parties. This, of course, will probably disappear in time.
If I may turn now to the question of the single-member seat as against the multi-member seat, by this time a great many people, apparently, who in 1959 disapproved completely of the single-member constituency are now beginning to tend towards it, not altogether, possibly, but there is not nearly as much disagreement with the suggestion that the single-member constituency is a good one as there was then. However, I should just like briefly to say that I think the single-member constituency is good. Senator FitzGerald, I think, said that from the Government point of view it had been stated that this was because it would be convenient for Deputies. I do not know whether it was said or not. I am not interested whether it is or not. I think it is more convenient for the constituents and this is to me what matters.
A relatively small area represented by one person gives a great many benefits to the people in that area. For one thing, they will be saved the awful trouble of running to three or four Deputies, making representations on whatever they want to talk about. Apart from that, one of the benefits I would like to see coming from it and which I believe would—this may shock the Party people—is safe seats for one Party or the other because I believe that one of the very important things that must come—and I agree with Senator Quinlan on this—is that much greater use should be made of committees dealing with the complexities of modern life which more and more demand greater specialisation.
Senator Quinlan and I would probably disagree on the type of committee. I should like to see more committees which would be of the same type as the Public Accounts Committee of the Dáil and the Statutory Instruments Committee of the Seanad which operate with the minimum of day to day publicity. Their findings and all the evidence brought before them are produced in a report, so that no one can say that it is an entirely secret affair and that the public are not informed as to what is going on, but it does have the effect that the members of the Committee can devote their attention to the business in hands without looking over their shoulders to see if the press are reporting what they are doing, which frequently, I think, influences what a man may say.
This type of committee is the sort I should like to see used more. I should not like to see the American committee system here because if anything their committees are more publicised than the meetings of either House of Congress. A great many Americans in the administration would be glad to see these publicised committees getting on with their jobs quicker and not spending so much time cutting public figures.
However, that is by the way. Another point of importance is the question of the type of candidate. It is all very well to say that a change to the single-member constituency will not affect the type of candidate. I think it will. I do not think the present system which allows several candidates from one Party to be put forward—the theory is that it gives the voter a choice of various people from the one Party— in practice, and after 18 years of experience in the Dáil as a candidate on six occasions, it is reasonably clear to me and to anybody involved that a great many of those put up as second, third and fourth strings are put up as stooges, to collect the local vote. We are very neighbourly-minded; the Party are known well; and if they have not a candidate their Party vote would go to the other Party. It is a thoroughly bad system which has led to the trouble which everybody seems to agree we are in from a parliamentary viewpoint.
Comment on this
For sound local reasons, apparently.
Comment on this
I doubt it very much. I am not keen on the "sound local reasons" as being the right way to determine parliamentary matters.
Comment on this
Parish pump is the basis of democracy, not Dublin.
Comment on this
I disagree. I should like to see people becoming more broadminded, to see them looking at their country as a whole and not minding the little local fiddle-de-dees. There are local councils to deal with that kind of thing. I would agree if Senator Sheehy Skeffington made the case that our local government be greatly improved to take care of these parish pump matters. There is far too much emphasis here put on parish pump matters and not nearly enough on national politics—not nearly enough time given by legislators to legislation, too much of their time being taken up with other matters. We can agree to disagree on that.
In relation to what would be a good Parliament, some people think the present Dáil is too big, that there is no necessity for representation on the basis of one member per 20,000 electors, whereas in other countries it is one per 80,000 or 90,000. At the same time as this comment is made, it is quite obvious that in the countries with very large constituencies, there is a good deal of feeling that Parliament and the people are becoming further apart. A contributory factor is the utter impossibility of any single representative being adequately in touch with the constituency of 80,000 or 90,000 which he represents.
From that point of view, I think the size of the Dáil is about right. When you take account of the Members of the Government and Parliamentary Secretaries, you are not left with too many for other uses. Basically, therefore, the objection to change boils down to the system of voting—whether it should be by transferable vote or straight vote. As long as you have multi-member constituencies, the transferable vote is inevitable. Its relationship to PR is reasonably vague from the point of view of regarding PR as a kind of religion. It might apply if the country were one big constituency but when it comes down to the relationship between the system and PR, the appropriateness becomes less and less and I do not propose to talk about PR in that context. I will talk about the present system. I think people have come round more and more to considering the single-member constituency, and the most important matter to consider therefore is how the single-member should be elected. The absurdity of using the transferable vote in this situation is that it gives an undue preponderance to those people who select the least popular candidates because, having had their shot at having a different person elected, the voters now have a second go and are entitled to decide between those ahead of them.
For instance, I cannot see the logic of a Labour voter being put in the odd position of deciding between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil—why the Labour voter should prefer one to the other is beyond me, they are so similar in outlook. It does not arise from a practical viewpoint. To begin with, there could be confusion. Such a voter might for some odd reason prefer one Party to the other, but what happens if the persons he chooses between are in a reverse position? There are so many anomalies that I do not propose to speak about them. Senator Sheehy Skeffington made some reference to horse racing. If a horse race were run under the system he likes, it would mean that the jockey who rode the horse which finished first would have to have a chat with the jockey on the horse which finished third to see if the chap who passed the post first should be declared the winner. This is more or less what the single transferable vote would do.
Comment on this
You would get quarter the odds on an each way bet.
Comment on this
I yield to the Senator's better knowledge of that matter. What I am discussing is that there are three horses and that only one of them can win.
Comment on this
There is nobody placed in a single-seat constituency.
Comment on this
That is the point I was making. Now, a great many people are in favour of single-seat constituencies and the question is how to pick out the constituencies. My reference to its relationship to horse racing was in an effort to suggest that if this is fair in elections, it should also be a fair system in horse racing.
Comment on this
That was not the point I made. The point I made is that the ordinary Irish voter has the capacity to make selection on a preferential basis. What I said has nothing to do with the fairness of horse racing. It just displays the native wit of the ordinary Irish punter. He is not such a fool as Senator Yeats seemed to suggest.
Comment on this
A few weeks ago when I ventured to interrupt him, Senator Sheehy Skeffington got very indignant.
Comment on this
He did. However, I am not greatly interested in the Senator's interest in horse racing, but it brought the stray thought into my mind that the one could be related to the other. It is not a very good argument, but it was not I who started it.
Comment on this
One of the curious things about this whole discussion has been that most people seem to be more worried about the effect on their Parties and themselves than anything else. Another oddity is that the very same people who accuse Fianna Fáil of looking for a system that will benefit them, think it virtuous of the Labour Party to fight for a system that benefits them. I cannot see either of these being very virtuous, but certainly it is a contradiction to put the blame on one Party for seeking its advantage and not to blame the other for seeking its advantage. But this type of inconsistency in political comment is by no means rare.
A good deal of reference has been made to what happens in other countries. In the long run, it is not so much a system that determines a country's Government as the will of the people. If Fianna Fáil believe that by changing the system, they are going to be there forever, they are codding themselves because they are assuming that, no matter how they govern, the people will keep on electing them. I see no validity in the type of argument that it is inevitable that this or that will happen. In the long run, it is the will of the people that will decide. Whatever Government are in power under whatever circumstances, if they go too far against the will of the people, they will be thrown out—and I think they will be thrown out more quickly and effectively under the single-seat straight vote. That would be an advantage.
The straight vote certainly did not preserve the Liberal Party, who swept the country in 1906, from being swept into oblivion in the end. It did not prevent the Labour Party, which started only 60 years ago, from becoming a major Party. At the moment I do not believe the straight vote would necessarily save the Labour Party if there were a sudden election in England, although they are in an overwhelming position at the moment. The question of performanence in parliamentary life is one better avoided.
It has been suggested that there would be sudden swings and great instability with rapid changes of Government. This might or might not happen. I do not think it necessarily would, but it would be a very great advantage in the long run to have different Parties in power. It would be a good idea that the Front Bench of the various Parties be given the job of running the country. It would give them experience of such matters. There would not be quite so much jealousy and quite so much comment as from a Front Bench which had never had to assume office, comment which very often is quite uninformed. Whatever swings might or might not take place, it would be to the country's advantage in the long run that a better opportunity be given the various Parties to be in office.
I referred earlier to inconsistencies of argument. I admit most of the inconsistencies do not come from within either House, although at the moment the most glaring one does, that is, this curious motion which is being taken in conjunction with these Bills. I hope I am not being unfair, but it appears to me that basically what it says is that a referendum is undemocratic. I admit that may not be the intention of those who worded the motion, but it looks curiously like that. The suggestion, I take it, is that nine years is too short a time to elapse?
Comment on this
I produce these figures with a certain amount of hesitancy and, if they are shown to be wrong, I will withdraw the whole argument. On a rough calculation, in the nine years which have elapsed, somewhere around 400,000 young people here have attained the right to vote. One of the prepondering arguments in the world at the moment is that young people could be more involved in national life. It seems odd that anyone should attempt to suggest that the opinion of all these people who have attained the vote should not be taken into account, because the electorate in 1959 settled the matter. If my figure is anywhere near right, these people who have attained the vote since 1959 represent somewhere between one-quarter and one-fifth of the electorate. It is highly desirable that their opinion should be taken into account.
Comment on this
Will their opinion be taken into account in another nine years if they vote for the retention of PR on this occasion?
Comment on this
That, I trust, will be for the Labour Government of the day to decide. I am sure the Senator is as optimistic as I am on this matter. Another oddity is the decent oblivion into which the Press have allowed this odd proposal to remain. The Press are not always as kind to parliamentary absurdities, but on this occasion they have been kind and very little notice has been taken of this odd proposal.
Reference has been made to the intelligence of the electorate in using the present system. I hope it will not be suggested that I have been prejudiced against the present system by something which happened in my first election. There were four seats and 13 candidates. I was asked to meet an old lady who had gone in to vote. She had mentioned to my man that she was a great friend of my family and that she was going to vote for me. When she came out we had a short conversation. She explained her friendship with my uncle and went on to add that she had done the best she could for me by saying she had given me 13 votes and Blaney only one.
Comment on this
I admit she was entitled to her choice. If that is the way it worked, then I had far more voters than the result showed, because the father of the present Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries came out at the head of the poll. All I could hope was that he was getting the No. Is intended for me. A fair amount of mixing up of voters does take place. If I vote for a candidate who reaches the quota, my choice as regards other candidates is barred. Although a great many people look at the constituency and give you three names, of the three, if they are elected, they elect only one. There is this reservation, that if the most successful candidate got a sufficiently large vote and a surplus, my second choice might help someone else and, if by chance my vote got into the right parcel, I might even influence the fate of somebody else. If I really wish to exercise a good deal of voting in an election, I should take the least favoured candidate, and when he is eliminated, my second choice is as good as the first of anybody else, and if I give my second choice to the next least favoured candidate, the same applies until at some stage my vote disappears.
Comment on this
The Senator does not suggest that the captain of a football team would select a man who got three votes out of 12 on the first count?
Comment on this
There are hidden depths in universities. I wonder how many voters understand what is really happening or even how many Senators even realise what happens on the 19th count just because somebody did or did not put down certain figures.
I intended to say more about the effect of the non-transferable vote in single-seat constituencies but I think I have said enough to show that it would put far too much power in the hands of small minorities. The nearer the two major candidates are in a three-corner contest, the more power there would be in the hands of a very tiny minority. There has been a good deal of talk about minorities and their right to representation. Unless a minority is geographically reasonably centred, under the present system they cannot get direct representation. Even a much larger minority scattered over the country has no hope of direct representation so that changing over to single-member constituencies with single non-transferable votes would not have any effect.
Comment on this
Not really. It is only a minority that is concentrated in a particular area that has any chance of direct representation. I trust I have made my position reasonably clear. I do not pretend to be more logical than anybody else. Possibly, I have some advantage over some of the Senators in that I have had experience of the present system and from my point of view, these experiences were successful. I have learned a great deal from my 25 years experience in public life and this is not some sudden decision on my part. I was of the same opinion nine years ago; although it is unlikely that a great many people would know that. One of the things that happen in public life is that very often one is speaking in camera. I should like to assure Senators who may be disturbed that I do not agree with their point of view, that they need not worry, seeing that nine years ago I spoke for an hour and five minutes on this issue and as far as the Press were concerned, it was not recorded that I had spoken at all. I do not want to appear bitter about this, but I do remember the time when I politely pointed out that the Irish Times did not refer to the fact that I had spoken. I was told that I had begun to speak at 10 o'clock in the evening and that nobody could be expected to be reported at that hour in the Irish Times. Strangely, or perhaps things have changed, Senator Quinlan who spoke after 10 o'clock until 11 p.m. the other night was reported in the Irish Times.
Comment on this
When Governments do this, it is known as censorship, but when a newspaper does it, it is merely editing. In this connection I was interested in a TV feature a few weeks ago, "Tomorrow's People", and a number of young journalists were being interviewed. Two of them hit the nail on the head when they said that as far as Irish newspapers were concerned, there was not enough political news and too much political comment. I thought that was fair comment. I do not object to comment by somebody who puts his name down, but there are too many faceless men in editorial sancta who are always complaining about the faceless men in the corridors of power. I may say, if I am not taking this too far away——
Comment on this
——the public should know the opinion of people in public life. How can they know if these people in public life are not reported? Think of the devastating effect on the Irish public if Senator Sheehy Skeffington were not reported.
Comment on this
Tá sé soiléir gur conspóid é seo idir na dreamanna éagsúla politíochta agus sin é an fáth gur cuí agus gur cóir liomsa páirt a ghlachadh sa dhíospóireacht seo mar má thagann tráth vótála amach anseo, ba mhaith liom go mbeadh a fhios ag an saol céard a thug orm dul ar thaobh amháin nó ar thaobh eile sa vótáil sin. Tá mo chuid féin smaointiúcháin déanta agam ar an scéal agus, murab ionann agus furmhór mór an Tí seo, níl aon lasc ná aon cheangal orm mo vóta a chaitheamh ar bhealach amháin ná ar bhealach eile. Tá a fhios againn roimh ré, dá fheabhas na hargóintí a luaifear i bhfábhar PR, go vótálfaidh an mhuintir ar m'aghaidh amach ina coinne agus mar a chéile, dá fheabhas na hargóintí a luaifear i gcoinne PR, tá a fhios againn roimh ré i dtaobh na ndaoine ar an taobh seo den Teach, cés moite díom féin agus b'fhéidir duine nó beirt eile, go vótálfaidh siad ar a son. Agus is eol dúinn roimh ré chomh maith cén toradh a bhéas ar an vótáil sin.
B'fhéidir go dtuigfí as sin gur am amú againne bheith ag cur is ag cúiteamh anseo, á lua seo is á lua siúd nuair atá an rud go léir socair roimh ré. Ach ní mar sin atá mar is iad muintir na tíre amuigh a thabharfaidh an bhreith dheiridh ar an scéal agus má tá ceangal ar fhurmhór na Seanadóirí anseo, níl aon cheangal ar an muintir amuigh.
Comment on this
Táim ag teacht go dtí sin. Ba mhaith liom a rá gur ceart mar sin gach gné den cheist a phlé go mion chun muintir na tíre a chur ar an eolas agus chun go mbeidh siadsan in ann breith chóir fhírinneach a dhéanamh agus, chun na críche sin, ba cheart an phlé anseo a fhoilsiú go fóirleathan í measc na ndaoine. Nuair a bhí mise ag iarraidh teacht ar réiteach le mo choinsias féin faoin tairiscint seo mar chonachtas an scéal dom.
Tá dhá phríomh-phrionsabal ann agus dhá mhór-cheist le freagairt dá réir: (1) an fearr agus an féiliúnaí Ionadaíocht Chionmhar nó a mhalairt; agus (2) an fearr agus an féiliúnaí Dáilcheantar aonTeachta nó Dáilcheantar il-Theachta? D'fhéadfadh duine freagra dearfa a thabhairt ar an dá cheist sin agus sin díreach mar d'fhreagróinn féin iad. Tar éis a bhfuil léite agus cloiste agam faoin scéal is é mo bharúil láidir gur fearr agus gur féiliúnaí mar chóras vótála an ionadaíocht chionmhar ná a mhalairt, an vóta díreach mar atá á thabhairt air, agus gur fearr i bhfad agus gur féiliúnaí mar chóras toghchánaíochta an Dáilcheantar aonair ná an Dáilcheantar il-Theachta. Agus creidim go láidir gur mar sin ab fhearr le tromlach na tíre é, ach, de réir na reachtaíochta atá ós ár gcomhair anois, sin rud nach gceadaítear dóibh a bheith acu.
Le linn don Seanadóir Eoin Ó Riain a bheith ag caint inné dúirt sé go raibh sé de cheart ag muintir na tíre a rá cén córas toghchánaíochta is fearr leo agus tagaim leis go hiomlán. Ach, dar liomsa, tá an ceart sin á shéanadh orthu. Níl ach aon rogha caol amháin á thairiscint dóibh, rogha idir ionadaíocht chionmhar plus Dáilcheantair il-Theachta ar thaobh amháin agus an vóta díreach plus Dáilcheantair aonair ar an taobh eile. An bhfuil sé de cheart ag an Rialtas gach rogha eile a shéanadh orthu nó an bhfuil sé thar acmhainn an duine páipéar reifrinn nó páipéar vótála a cheapadh a chuirfeadh ar chumas an vótálaí an dara rogha a dhéanamh, nó an tríú rogha má tá an tríú ceann ann?
Mar atá an scéal, taimíd taobh le aon rogha amháin agus do dhuine mar mise, ar bhfearr leis ionadaíocht chionmhar a choinneáil agus Dáilcheantair aonair a thabhairt isteach, agus nach féidir an dá cheann a bheith aige, ní mór do an dá cheann a chur sa mheá agus teacht ar réiteach eatarthu. Tar éis mo mhachnamh a dhéanamh ar an scéal, tá titim na meá de bheagán, dar liomsa, i bhfábhar an Dáilcheantair aonair. Creidim gur mó de mhaith a dhéanfadh sé sin do chúrsaí parlaiminte agus do chúrsaí riaracháin na tíre ná an mhaith a thiocfadh as an ionadaíocht chionmhar a choinneáil. Mar sin, dá mbéinn sásta gur idir an dá chúrsa sin amháin a bhí bealach ár leasa, ní bheadh deacracht ar bith agam. Rachainn leis an Rialtas sa vótáil. Ach níl mé sásta gur mar sin atá. Níl mé sásta go bhfuil seans á thabhairt san reachtaíocht seo do mhuintir na tíre a rogha córas toghchánaíochta a roghnú. Is mar a chéile é agus a rá le duine atá ag ceannach gluaisteáin: "Tig leat do rogha dath a bheith agat ach é bheith gorm". Mar sin, caithfidh mé teacht ar an intinn gur fearr gan an tairiscint seo a chur faoi bhreith an phobail sa riocht ina bhfuil sé faoi láthair. Muran féidir ag an bpointe seo an rogha a leathnú do réir mar tá léirithe agam ní féidir liom go coinsiasach vótáil ar a shon.
Sa chás go rithfear an reachtaíocht seo mar atá sé faoi láthair agus go gcuirfear faoi bhráid an phobail é sa riocht ina bhfuil sé, beidh an fhadhb chéanna díreach le réiteach ag an gnáth-vótálaí amuigh agus atá agamsa anseo sa Seanad. Tá na mílte daoine, ar ndóigh, a leanfaidh pé treoir a tugtar dóibh do réir mar tá siad báúil le pairtí amháin nó le pairtí eile, ach tá na céadta míle ann mar mé féin a bhéas ag iarraidh a gcoinsias a shlánú agus a chaithfidh diúltú don tairiscint toisc nach bhfuil an rogha is mian leo á thairiscint dóibh.
Comment on this
Go drugallach, mar a dubhras, táim in bhur naghaidh.
Comment on this
Mar nach cóir é a chur sa riocht so. Nílim ag déanamh rogha anso. Táim ag iarraidh an reachtaíocht is féiliúnaí agus an rogha is leithne a chur ós comhair an phobail.
Comment on this
Sin scéal eile. Tá sé raite agam nach bhfuil rogha á dhéanamh agam anso.
Comment on this
Sílim go bhfuil sé reásúnta rogha sóiléir a chur fé bhreith na tíre. Caithfear rogha a dhéanamh ansin idir an dá rud a cuirfear, agus ní cheart go mbéimís taobh le haon rogha amháin. Ní ceart roghá cúng mar seo a bhrú ar dhaoine.
Má tá i ndán is go n-éireoidh leis an mbeartas seo agus go nglacfaidh an pobal leis an vóta díreach i gcoitinne mar chóras vótála, ba mhaith liom a fháil amach céard tá beartaithe ag an Aire mar chóras toghcháin don Seanad. Tá sé furasta go leor an tír a roinnt ar bhun tíreolach chun Dáilcheantair aonair a sholáthar ach ní fheicim gur indéanta an córas céanna a chur i bhfeidhm ar an Seanad agus go háirithe ar ionadaíocht na nollscoileanna sa Seanad. B'fhéidir nár mhiste leis an Aire i ndeireadh na díospóireachta seo dhá rud a nochtadh dúinn: an bhfuil aon seans fós ann go leathnófar an rogha a chuirfear os comhair an phobail agus céard tá beartaithe aige do thóghchán an tSeanaid faoin gcóras nua má ghlactar leis san fhómhar.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the opportunity to say something on the Third and Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bills and the motion. I am supporting the Amendments and will vote against the motion. The Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill deals with the tolerance issue. We must not lose sight of the fact that a decision on this amendment is really forced on us at the present time as a result of a High Court decision. Therefore, it is imperative that there must be a recasting of the constituencies. Consequently, if the constituencies are to be recast, and if there is to be a referendum, it is the most natural thing that the Government should bring up again, and offer for the consideration of the people of the country, the question of what system we should operate in elections in the future.
I have been a good listener in this House. It is only on rare occasions that I have been exasperated to the extent of interrupting anyone or interjecting a remark when someone was speaking. I should like to follow critically some of the things said by Senator Dooge in a speech lasting two hours and ten minutes. He said that the county boundaries were of no consequence, that they existed since the time of King John and were not created by Cumann Luithchleas Gaedheal and were perpetuated since then. I have operated in a county for many years as a public official and I know the importance of the county boundaries and county divisions. I cannot stress too highly the importance of sticking as far as possible in this and in any administrative legislation to the existing county boundaries. When they are breached, we have pockets and town-lands in which people vote for the county council in one county and Dáil Deputies in another. It is my experience that it is absolutely imperative that for better administration, the county and Dáil boundaries should coincide as far as possible.
Since a recasting of the constituencies must be carried out now, it is important that the rearrangement should be in the interests of the people. I was very glad that Senator Sheldon mentioned that. The interests of the people seem to have been lost to a great extent in the consideration of the interests of the political Parties. In the distribution of the constituencies, I am particularly anxious to see that so far as possible the present representation in the west of Ireland is maintained. Senator FitzGerald said that the purpose of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is to give further representation to the West, two extra seats as far as I remember. I understood he meant that it was possible that as a result of the tolerance issue the west of Ireland would get two extra seats.
Comment on this
I said that on the basis of the electorate, they could get two extra seats, but the Bill would enable them to be given five extra seats.
Comment on this
We do not want any extra seats. We are quite satisfied with the representation we have and we will jealously guard that representation.
Comment on this
Extra seats over and above what they are entitled to on the basis of population, not extra to the number they now have.
Comment on this
Not extra to the number we now have but extra to our entitlement.
Comment on this
In fact, the present number of Deputies is more or less unfair. I hate this catchcry which has been going around the country for some months past, to "save the West". I would love if these people who are meddling in the west would keep away from us. All we want in the west is a fair deal. We want a reasonable way of living. Our area, as everyone knows, is not adapted to large industries. Our land is not able to maintain in modern comfort a high density of population. The very nature of our countryside presents many problems unknown to the eastern and better-off counties. We are not begging; we are not unreasonable, when we highlight our problems. The only way we can seek redress is through our county councils, our committees at local levels, and our public representatives in the Dáil and Seanad at national level.
When Senator Dooge drew a comparison at great length between Dublin County and South Mayo, he was not being exactly fair. Senator Dooge knows a considerable amount about Dublin County because at one time he was Chairman of Dublin County Council, but I submit he knows very little about the problems of the west. If he did, he would not have taken those two counties for comparison. Dublin County has a population of 146,000—74,600 electors—which is 29,181 of the population per Deputy, which is 9,153 or 45.07 per cent above the national average. According to the latest figure, South Mayo has a population of 67,798—41,857 electors—which 16,950 of the population per Deputy, or 15.37 of the population per Deputy below the national average. Comparing those two districts and their populations, Senator Dooge made no allowance for hospitals, boarding schools, tourists, visitors, hotels, holiday camps, large housing estates, Dublin Airport, factories, etc., all of which influence the number of people in a particular area.
If on the other side we take into account the number of electors per Deputy, we get a different picture. In Dublin we have 14,920 electors per Deputy, which is 3,021 above the national average—a big difference—or 25 per cent as against something over 40: 25 per cent of electors as against 45 per cent of population. In South Mayo, we have 10,464 electors per Deputy which is 1,435 electors or 12.06 below the national average. Therefore, you will see that the comparison of electors per Deputy is a more realistic figure than that of population per Deputy. I am not saying that, now, because it is in our favour but it is a fact.
The next consideration would be the difficulties or the problems which arise in the two constituencies which were offered here for consideration. The northern portion of Dublin county could be covered. Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown, I understand, covers a large portion of the rural area of South Dublin. North Dublin could in fact be covered by an active Deputy on a push bicycle. The people are generally well-off. They live in good houses, on the best of land. All services are available in most cases. Roads present no problem. Hospitals and schools are on the doorstep. Every requirement for the household is within easy distance. Employment is good and available to all who wish to seek and use it.
County Mayo stretches from Tallaghbawn, which is 30 miles west of Westport, through Westport, Castlebar, Kiltimagh, Kilkelly, Charlestown and Ballaghaderreen, a length of 80 miles approximately with three-fifths of County Mayo stretching to the south for an average of 25 miles but, in some areas, stretching to the south for a distance of 35 miles. One finds every conceivable type of problem which is met with in a rural area and, in an isolated west of Ireland area, it has to be met with and dealt with by Dáil Deputies and Senators in that area. Roads, housing, hospital services, education, scholarships, piers, harbours, water and sewerage extensions, extensions of ESB to out-of-the-way areas, land acquisition and division, turbary and bog plots, drainage, social services, telephone and ESB extensions—in fact, every conceivable form of demand and request for help is made to Deputies and Senators by people in those areas —and that is the purpose they are elected to serve. Although many people would stress that they are legislators, we must bear in mind, at the same time, the constituency limits and the number of Deputies who were agreed on unanimously in the Dáil by all Parties—but not in the Seanad—in 1959.
The present arrangement of constituencies would have been quite acceptable and would not be under consideration now, were it not for the High Court decision of Mr. Justice Budd and on that decision and on his terms, the review of constituencies must now take place. If we have a review now—and we must—is it not the most natural and economic decision to put the full facts before the electorate, to tell them the changes the Government recommend, to set out those changes as clearly as human intelligence can devise on the ballot paper and to leave the decision with the people? I cannot see anything more reasonable and I ask the Opposition if they would now have raised the tolerance question, were it not for Mr. Justice Budd's decision.
The present position, as I have stated, is that Dublin County has 3,021 or 25.09 above the national average per Deputy, South Mayo has 1,435 persons or 12.06 below the average. All that is asked for in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is that a possible variation of one-sixth above the national average and one-sixth below the national average should be written into an Act amending the Constitution.
With regard to population, the national average per Deputy is 20,028. To add one-sixth to that brings a maximum figure which we want to write in now and pass in this legislation. The maximum figure per Deputy would be 23,366 and the minimum would be 16,690. If we examine the present figures per Deputy in the reply given by the Minister for Local Government in the Dáil we shall find that, at present, there are just four constituencies where the number of population per Deputy exceeds that which is proposed in this Bill. These four constituencies are Dublin North-East, Dublin North-West, Dublin County, Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.
There is at present no constituency, not even in the worst area in the west of Ireland, where the number of population per Deputy is below the figure proposed, but there are four under 17,000. The figure proposed is 16,690. Actually, there are four under 17,000 —North Mayo, South Mayo, Roscommon and Sligo-Leitrim—and there are four more under 18,000—Cork South-West, Donegal South-West, Galway East and Monaghan. All we want, as far as the amendment is concerned, is that our position in the west of Ireland will be at least stabilised at its present membership until the matter has to come up for consideration again in 12 years time. When we take into account the representation we have had, I should like to point out that, in very many cases in the west and south of Ireland, the Senators have to come along and assist and do a lot of work where the Dáil Deputies are unable to do it.
What is the position with regard to representation in the Seanad? If one examines the list of 60 members of the Seanad, one will find that, of the 60, 14 are living in Dublin city; seven are living in Dublin county and 13 in the rest of Leinster, so that the province of Leinster has resident in it 34 Members of Seanad Éireann and the province of Munster has 13 Members of Seanad Éireann. Three counties of Ulster have eight Members of Seanad Éireann and the province of Connacht has five.
If you add 34 Senators to assist Deputies in Leinster, then anybody who wants to have a problem aired or who seeks advice or information would only have to travel ten miles to the nearest Deputy or Senator. However, in Connacht thousands and thousands of people have never seen a Dáil Deputy, except possibly at election times, and Dáil Deputies are not available to them because of the extent of the district. In South Mayo, we have four Deputies and two of them are resident in Dublin because they are Ministers and two live in the county. However, it does not make the slightest difference. The two Fine Gael Deputies in the county are men for whom I have the highest regard and I sincerely hope they will be returned for many years to serve the interests of their people. As far as they are concerned, the problems with which they deal are the problems of people of every political persuasion. In the same way anybody who comes to me gets the greatest possible help, no matter what Party he supports.
I ask the House, and Senator O'Quigley in particular, would they stand for any opposition to the amendment of the Constitution which tends to place that representation for our province and our county in jeopardy? I cannot believe that the Senator will. If we are left with our present representation, then we can tell a number of those busybodies who are going around to leave the west alone. If, on the other hand, we have Labour and Fine Gael joining to defeat that proposal, let them take as their slogan not "Save the West" but "To Hell or to Connacht".
Another thing which is being said quite dishonestly, something which I want to have corrected, is that an effort is being made to have more Dáil Deputies as a result of these measures. Taking the figures which are proposed in the amendments to the Constitution, it is absolutely truthful to say that no provision is made for a single extra Deputy. I hope that that untruthful and unjust propaganda will not be continued. Undoubtedly the Fourth Amendment which deals with the straight vote and single-seat constituency would be of great advantage to the electorate. Many times every day, and most of all on Sundays, Deputies and Senators are approached by constituents in regard to their problems, people seeking help and seeking advice, some of whom may travel 40 miles to see their representative. The Deputies barely know anything about these people, their families, their backgrounds, and so on, but in all cases those people are met with sympathy and dealt with as fairly as possible. What an immense improvement there would be in the service available to local people if they had a Deputy in their own area, if the constituencies were small, single-member constituencies?
The point has been made that we would get better representatives, and I agree, and when I say that, I do not mean that which was stressed here today; I mean representatives who would be better and who would be in a better position to give a better service to the people they represent. As I said, the background and so on of people who travel long distances to see their representatives are not known to the Deputy or Senator and he can only get advice about them through the county council or in some roundabout way. Long ago it used be the national teacher but, of course, no national teachers are living in the country now; they are all living in the towns, and they are no longer available to give the people advice or help. Long ago they were regarded as the people's guides, philosophers and friends. Now they are not available to be consulted by the people or by Deputies or Senators.
In rural areas a change to the single-member constituency is a must. It would be a tremendous advantage to the constituents and also to the public representative, whether he is a Deputy or a Senator. So far as by-elections are concerned, when they take place, it will be within a small limited area where the candidates will be selected for the appeal they make to the local constituents, for the service they have been giving, for the example they have been setting and because of the usefulness of their lives in their particular areas. All these things will be taken into consideration. Only people of the highest integrity, of really worthwhile character, will be offered as candidates. In that way, and I have no hesitation in saying this, the standard of representation in the Dáil will be greatly improved.
Comment on this
Where are all these splendid people now?
Comment on this
There are some of them noticeably absent from this House. There are some in this House in high positions who have not yet learned manners. I have never interrupted the Senator and I object to the Senator interrupting me. Coming from a university professor, I think it shows a very poor standard and poor quality.
Comment on this
The question is awkward, but it is legitimate.
Comment on this
He is the ex-Supreme Knight and he does not like Trinity.
Comment on this
Would Senator O'Quigley please remain within the bounds of decency?
Comment on this
The Senator is not now talking to the members of Mayo County Council, as he did long ago, when he was known as the "Great Dictator".
Comment on this
Consider by-elections in which you will have men of high character, respected in their districts, and, for that reason, they will be put up as candidates. Such men are to be found in the Fianna Fáil ranks, in the Labour ranks and in the Fine Gael ranks in every constituency. Personality and the capacity to serve will be the deciding factor and the Party machine will have very much less influence than it has at present with the electorate.
Comment on this
Service will have its reward. By-elections will not be won by the Party machine, by organisation, by money. They will be won by the wisdom of the people voting for their own man in their own areas and in their own interests. I am very glad Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien is here because in one part of her very excellent speech she mentioned that she had been converted from some of the Opposition by the speech of Senator Yeats.
Comment on this
What I said was that Senator Yeats's speech spiked some of my guns. He did what I hoped other people would do but had not done; he said some of the things I wanted to say.
Comment on this
I would like to suggest for Members of this House consideration for the necessity for change, change, in the first place, to the single-member constituency and, in the second place, change as far as the method of election is concerned. I sincerely hope that change will not result in the wholesale wiping out of some of the very excellent Deputies we have in other Parties. Personally, I do not wish to wipe out any Deputy. I pay tribute to the work of the Deputies in South Mayo, who have been very liberal with help and advice to their constituents. I fervently hope that in any redistribution of seats there will be a fair and equitable distribution. Some people have criticised the boundaries of constituencies because they run in a zig-zag fashion. If one follows townland boundaries or electoral areas, one will find greater irregularities. If one cuts across a townland boundary or an electoral area, one is accused of gerrymandering. It is as simple as that. Change is necessary and I hope all Parties will share in the responsibility of recasting constituencies in the best interests of the people. I believe the Commission will be fair to everybody and I hope the Commission will have the co-operation of all Parties.
The forecasts in regard to results following on the passing of these measures may have been a very useful exercise. They may have been a study in depth. They were made for a very specific purpose and that was to prejudice people, to prejudice the electors and to create a scare by suggesting that an ultra-strong Government would result and that Government would use its powers arbitrarily, not for the benefit of the people but for the persecution and destruction of the people.
Comment on this
Is the Senator casting reflections on Radio Telefís Éireann and on the Political Science Department of TCD?
Comment on this
I said they appeared to me to be put out with an ulterior motive.
Comment on this
These forecasts and calculations were an idle exercise, an exercise carried out before those indulging in the exercise had any knowledge of what the constituencies' shape, size or form would be. I believe the people have seen through that and I believe these calculations and forecasts will have no influence whatsoever on the people from the point of view of their endorsing the single-member constituencies.
Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien said that proportional representation has served us well and she sees no need for change.
Comment on this
We have proposals for a change in our health services. We have proposals for a change in our educational system. Proposals are under consideration for improving our social services. We have proposals under consideration for a change in taxation. All these services have served us well for a number of years. In lighter vein, we have proposals for changes in fashion and, in more serious vein, we have proposals for change in the Catholic Church. It is only reasonable then that we should consider changes in our electoral system, if these changes are in the interests of the people. It is only fair the people should be given an opportunity to decide, because, remember, we did not always have a majority when we were arriving at decisions and taking serious steps. I will bring a very personal occasion to mind for Senator Mrs. Connolly O'Brien—1916. When the people who went out in 1916 decided to sacrifice their lives in the interests of the people, the very papers who are now condemning the efforts of the Government in proposing these Amendments to the Constitution are the papers which condemned the men of 1916 who went out and achieved the freedom which we now enjoy, and I mention them by name—the Irish Independent and the Irish Press——
Comment on this
I mean the Irish Times: The Irish Press was not in existence at that time.
Comment on this
There is every reason why we should change our system if the majority of the people are convinced that it is in their best interests and the best interests of the country. As I said, everything we have in this country, our freedom, resulted from a decision to act in the best interests of the country and in the best interests of the people. The members of Fianna Fáil are no less interested in the best interests of the country now. They fought opposition, disappointment, frustration, in the pursuit of their policies in the interests of the people and in the interests of the country, and they have been proved right and, having been returned to power, as we have heard here, have been in power for 30 years. The people have confirmed their confidence in Fianna Fáil in six out of seven by-elections fought since the Government publicly announced their decision to bring in these Amendments of the Constitution. The results in the by-elections must have been influenced by the Government's decision which had been made known.
It is a fact that there are many variations of PR which could be tried but the one that has been forced on this country and tried in this country is not foolproof. Senator FitzGerald and many other people testified to the many defects in the system. Where you take multi-seat constituencies, the vast majority of votes cast are never examined for second preference or for subsequent preference. It is true that PR seems to influence elections more in multi-seat rather than in single-seat constituencies but in every case it is the tail wagging the dog.
I will give you some figures. In North Mayo in the last general election, 21,899 votes were cast and 16,020 of those votes were never examined for second preference, that is, 73.2 per cent; 5,789 or 26.8 per cent were examined for second preference and of these, seven per cent did not have a second preference—they were plumpers. I will not go through all of them but I have the seven by-election figures here. In the Wicklow by-election, which was the by-election won by Fine Gael, 67.7 per cent of the votes cast were never examined for second preference.
Comment on this
I will tell you why they might have been. Thirty-two per cent were examined for second preference and 19.4 per cent of those were non-transferable but you go down to the other end of the scale and the lowest vote cast was 191, which was 0.7 per cent of the total votes cast and that vote could have been counted, as explained here before by Senator Sheldon, five times. A vote for a person who got 0.7 per cent of the total votes cast could, if lucky, have passed right up until it came into the final reckoning and count as five No. 1 votes.
Comment on this
Counted five times as a No. 1 vote. The first lowest candidate got 191 votes. The second lowest candidate got 509 votes, so that his votes would count there as another No. 1. It could go up to the third last. It would count as a third No. 1 up to the fourth candidate and eventually decide the issue as a No. 5.
Comment on this
In the final result, only one person benefits from that vote. It passes on only if the candidate is eliminated.
Comment on this
That is one of the defects, that one vote could decide between two people which should be eliminated.
Comment on this
In the seven by-elections—I will not go through the figures but I have them if I am asked for them—taking the total figures, 80.3 per cent of the votes cast were never taken into account for a second preference. In those seven by-elections, the final result was influenced unduly, as has been pointed out, by the 19.7 per cent of people—you can call them irresponsible as some did; you can call them what you will—in any case, 19.7 per cent had the final influence where 80.3 per cent were never examined for second preference.
Comment on this
Where does the one man, one vote come in? That was mentioned by only one Senator, Senator McAuliffe. The really responsible electors have only one vote which counts towards a result, that is, the people who vote responsibly for the candidates who belong to a Party who can form a Government, that is, Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour. Could anything be more ridiculous than that the people who vote No. 1 for the candidate who gets 100,200 or 300 votes will have his vote go right along until in the end it can be multiplied five times? If preferences were carried forward as surpluses are divided, in proportion, not in the easy way that Senator Quinlan gave out the £1,000 today——
Comment on this
The Senator made a profit. He had 4,000 votes, the quota was 1,000; the man who got the 1,000 kept the 1,000 for himself and divided the 3,000 amongst the others.
Comment on this
The Senator divided the 3,000 at 10s, so that he made a profit that was not accounted for.
Comment on this
However, if in the tail-end the votes were transferred as the fraction which they constituted of the total poll cast, everything would be reasonable, but that only happens in a non-transferable surplus and does not happen in an elimination count, which is quite wrong. It has been contended that we are taking up the time of the House discussing this. I have not taken more than my share and I do not often intrude myself. This question is primarily one for the people. Fianna Fáil find themselves in a position in which they have to take a decision. They are strong enough at the present time to be able to face the electors on this issue, to put the issue before them. In that, they are not acting entirely in the interests of their own Party. Ultimately it may be in the interests of their own Party——
Comment on this
——but if the decisions go against Fianna Fáil, then every Senator on that side will agree that Fianna Fáil will have put their heads in the noose. At the same time, Fianna Fáil have not ever put the Party before the country and they are not doing it now. They are giving the electors of the country a chance and they are not influenced by the S O S which was sent out by a very prominent Fine Gael Deputy to try to form a coalition with Labour. I do not interpret "S O S" as "Save our Souls" but as "Save Oliver's Surplus". In this matter we are pressing our view with the greatest vehemence—we are putting the case fairly and squarely before the people—and if the people mark X before the word "Yes" in the ballot papers, it is not a sign of ignorance. I assure you it is a sign of great intelligence and I am satisfied the people will show their intelligence and that there will be quite a number of Senators and Members of the Dáil who will be gravely disappointed.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that when the people get an opportunity to pass judgment on these proposals, they will, as in 1959, show their intelligence. These Bills are before us in very strange circumstances, and a remarkable thing about the debate in this House as compared with 1959 is that no senior Minister has been delegated to pilot these Bills through in the same way as happened in 1959. It is remarkable that on this occasion the Taoiseach has not thought it worth his while or has not found time to come to the Seanad——
Comment on this
——or allowed to come in to pilot these Bills in the Seanad in the way his predecessor did in 1959, and God knows—I say it sincerely and with charity—he was under a much greater disability, as we all know now, in bringing his proposals here in 1959 than his much younger successor, but it is significant that the Taoiseach has not come to the House to put these Bills before us. It is probably fair to say that at this stage the reports coming in from the Fianna Fáil Party all over the country have left the Taoiseach and many others in his Party dispirited about these proposals and the only person who has stuck it out the whole time in the Dáil and who has been given the job of dealing with it here is the Minister for Local Government, significantly enough, the godchild of the Taoiseach who introduced the referendum proposals in 1959.
There is no doubt that when one looks at the many problems that confront the country in 1968, and the lack of resources to deal with these problems—the high rate of emigration and all the difficulties we face in the future — we are wasting public time and money and losing most valuable time in debating proposals settled by the people in 1959. If it is logical to say that the electorate has changed since 1959, it would be equally logical to say that the whole Constitution should be changed—that we should ask do we still want a Seanad, do we still want a President, do we still want Irish as the first official language? I do not doubt that the reason why that has not been done is that these things in the Constitution do no affect the fortunes of Fianna Fáil in the same way as the system of election does.
Comment on this
That is the reason why we are held up now as in 1959, wasting public time and money, losing valuable time which could be devoted to trying to meet the competition we have to meet from other countries, debating useless measures which even the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
We have to discharge our duties, and, God knows, we are paid enough for it.
Comment on this
What is important is that Government Ministers, instead of bringing their minds to bear on such matters as the introduction of the new health scheme and the finding of a solution to the depopulation of the west, are spending their time dealing with the useless proposals contained in this Bill.
Comment on this
It is interesting to see how the wheel turns a full circle, how the Fianna Fáil Party, who because of expediency in 1937 changed the Constitution, because of expediency are now trying to change a system they do not like. Under the 1922 Constitution, all that was required was that the "Members of the Dáil shall be elected on principles of PR".
Comment on this
Senator O'Kennedy spoke earlier about cattle and sheep and pigs. I will say no more. The 1922 Constitution was enacted by the people of this country after a committee of experts, who had examined Constitutions throughout the world——
Comment on this
It was published on the morning of the poll and the people had no chance to read it.
Comment on this
The 1922 Constitution was enacted by the people of Ireland——
Comment on this
——and during the following five years it was capable of being amended by Act of Parliament——