An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 390–598 of 802. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
We got rid of the Oath and of the Governor General. However, the Fianna Fáil Party did not think fit in 1937 to get rid of the clause which said that Members of the Dáil shall be elected on principles of PR. That was all right in 1922; it was all right in 1927; it was all right in 1932; it was all right in 1935; and then the great mathematician himself, Mr. Eamon de Valera——
Comment on this
He is an integral part, unfortunately, of Irish history.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the Senator is not debarred from abusing the President, he is bound to be interrupted. I ask that he be——
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley is looking for trouble. If he wants that sort of debate, we will be happy to give it to him.
Comment on this
I will come to that in my time, and very quickly. The Constitution could have been amended at any time from 1932 by Act of Parliament. But it was not done by the then President of the Executive Council or by the Fianna Fáil Party. The then President of the Executive Council was a mathematician and he wanted a nice, neat formula. He devised that for his own purposes and put it into the 1937 Constitution, with the aid and assistance of the entire Fianna Fáil Party. It was a particular form of proportional representation with the minimum number of seats in a constituency fixed at three. If he had left the 1922 Constitution—of course, he did not like it because he said it was dictated by the British and this was continued to be said by Fianna Fáil—and had forgotten about his prejudices, he could at all times have used the Constitution to introduce a different kind of proportional representation. But, since that was not done, the system of proportional representation we have since then has become part of Irish political life. It is for that reason, it being basic to our political system, that we will not change it and the people will not change it.
The then President said in 1937 concerning proportional representation:
The system we have we know; the people know it. On the whole it has worked pretty well. I think we have a good deal to be thankful for in the country: we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of PR here. It gives a certain amount of stability, and on this system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties.
Are you going to throw out President de Valera with that statement of his?
Comment on this
He also said that if we want to change, we can do it by a referendum.
Comment on this
We can. You tried to do it in 1959 but the people would not have it. Now you are trying to do it again at a time when it is quite irrelevant to the needs of the country. We might as well put a Bill to the people tomorrow asking them to get rid of the Dáil. That would be a silly proposal, and this one is just as silly. President de Valera was not always wrong. The cardio-visual approach he had to the Irish people enabled him sometimes to express a point of view. He expressed it well in 1937 when he put it into the Constitution. I have always said, and Senator Garret FitzGerald said this evening, that this Constitution of 1937 is a splendid document, because it is a reproduction of the 1922 Constitution. In regard to the fundamental system of government, the method of election, the bi-cameral system, it differs nothing.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley should be allowed to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
I want to deal with the kind of things Fianna Fáil could have done at any time by an Act of Parliament when they had a big majority. In 1935 they were called upon, in pursuance of the provisions of the Constitution, to revise the constituencies. They did it by the Electoral Act of 1935. They had got into power on a number of dishonest promises, one of which was that there should not be more than 100 Deputies in the Dáil. We had the pitiful excuses of the late President O'Kelly, then Minister for Local Government, and Deputy Lemass when the Electoral Bill was going through that, when they had gone into Government and learned something about the art of politics, they could not do with 100 seats and that the best they could do to redeem their promise was a Dáil of 136 seats compared with 152 up to that time.
Again, on the basis of expediency and to bring their Dáil representation down to what they considered would be a favourable number of Deputies at that time, they butchered every county, or nearly every county, in order to get their 136 Deputies. In those days they had not the slightest concern about breaching the geographical boundaries of administrative counties. They forgot about lakes, rivers, streams and all the other beauties of nature that mark out our different counties. We have 11 constituencies out of 34 with parts of other constituencies tacked on. In those days they had not the slightest concern about administrative boundaries because it was necessary in the interests of political expediency to redeem the promise to reduce the Dáil to the lowest number they could get it down to.
This is not the findings of one man or the views expressed by one or two people. This was a vote of the entire Fianna Fáil Party. The Schedule to the 1935 Act shows what they did. The constituency of Meath-Westmeath consisted of the administrative county of Meath and the administrative county of Westmeath except the portion comprised in the county constituency of Athlone-Longford. To that constituency they gave five seats. Then they had this new constituency of Athlone-Longford, which consisted of the administrative county of Longford and certain district electoral divisions of Westmeath as well as certain places in Roscommon. That had three seats. Roscommon was the administrative county of Roscommon except the portion comprised in the county constituency of Athlone-Longford. All of Sligo was in except the portion comprised in the county constituency of Leitrim. Leitrim consisted of itself and the portion taken out of Sligo. East Galway was comprised of the administrative county of Galway except the portion comprised in the county constituencies of Clare and West Galway. It shed a bit to Clare and West Galway and it was given four seats. Clare county constituency was made up of the administrative county of Clare and portion of Galway. Where is the honouring of administrative boundaries in that?
Listen to what they did with Carlow-Kildare. It comprised the administrative county of Kildare and the administrative county of Carlow except the portions thereof comprised in the county constituencies of Wicklow and Wexford. The carve-up of Wexford was not a case of the west being broken and bleeding, but a case of the east being broken and bleeding. Carlow county was divided up between Wicklow, Wexford and Carlow-Kildare. Wicklow—and this is something the Parliamentary Secretary at present with us should be interested in—consisted of itself and the portions taken out of Carlow. Wexford consisted of itself and the portions taken out of Carlow, while Waterford consisted of the County Borough of Waterford, the administrative county of Waterford and parts of County Cork.
This was the butchering that had gone on for the purpose, as was explained in the debate, of working out a system that would give them as near to 100 Deputies as possible. The best they could do at the time was 136. In those days there was not anything like the good roads and the number of cars or telephones now available to people if they wished to contact their Deputies. People could travel to any portion of these different constituencies and there was no concern whether they belonged to a particular county or not. That was the arrangement made.
When you look at that and see the way the Fianna Fáil Party in 1937 dealt with the provisions of the 1922 Constitution, it is impossible for the people to have respect for the judgment of Fianna Fáil when it comes to the devising of constituencies and the devising of means whereby the boundaries and limits of constituencies are to be drawn up. I understand there is an agreement to go on until 6.30 p.m.
Comment on this
If the Senator wishes to continue and finish before 6.30 p.m. that is all right. We can adjourn then.
Comment on this
At what time is it proposed to adjourn? Who is making these arrangements? We came in here on Tuesday and were told that the Seanad was sitting on Tuesday from 3 to 10 p.m.; on Wednesday, from 3 p.m. to 10 p.m. and on Thursday from 10.30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Now we are going on until 6.30 p.m. with no apologies. Can people make no arrangements? What kind of procedure is this?
Comment on this
I announced today that we would sit until the Second Stage was finished, or at least until all the speakers had finished and that, if necessary, we would sit tomorrow morning.
Comment on this
Does that mean that we are sitting until 10 o'clock tonight?
Comment on this
It is proposed that we adjourn then at half-past six.
Comment on this
Could we be told at what time the Minister is likely to being his speech?
Comment on this
Are we adjourning then or will the Minister start, say, at 10 o'clock and go on until 11?
Comment on this
If he has not finished at 10 or 11 we would go on until midnight?
Comment on this
I am hopeful that if the Senators who desire to speak have finished by 9 p.m. the Minister will be able to get in at that hour.
Comment on this
The arrangement was that we would finish tonight.
Comment on this
It is proposed to continue until 6.30. Senator O'Quigley on the Bill.
Comment on this
All this talk about county boundaries certainly had no place in the Fianna Fáil philosophy or thinking in 1935. What is more significant is that they continued with that system from 1935 right up to the next revision of constituencies 12 years later in 1947, even after the 1937 Constitution had been enacted.
In practice it does not very much matter where people live or by whom they are represented because what people want and what the country wants is good representation in Dáil Éireann and it does not matter to a person who his Deputy is, whether he lives in Dublin North Central or Dublin North East, if he is getting good government and good services. The same applies equally in respect of people living in rural Ireland. If the economy is prospering it does not matter to people how many or how few Deputies they have or how near they live to a Deputy. Ultimately, their concern is whether they are prospering, whether there is a good social system, good social services, good educational facilities and a reasonable cost of living and whether we have peace and order and tranquility within the bounds of the State. That is what matters.
I listened to Senator O'Kennedy with great respect because his speech was unusual coming from the opposite benches. It had a refreshing honesty and candour which does not characterise many speeches from that side of the House. When I listened to Senator Flanagan and heard him moaning and groaning and going on with the parish pump type of approach he adopted towards national affairs I began to despair of good coming out of the Fianna Fáil Party. The picture he painted of the west of Ireland and of its decrepit state was, perhaps, no exaggeration. The other day when I spoke of the decay and despondency in rural areas, there were shouts of "No" from the Fianna Fáil Party but Senator Flanagan told us the same thing today about the magnitude of the problems with which the people of south Mayo have to wrestle every day. Having extra Deputies is no use to them because even if Deputies visit, four or five times a year, every house in the constituency it will not bring more factories, more water supplies or help to remedy the decline in population or get better prices for cattle or pigs.
None of these things matters—how often people see a Deputy or how near they are to him. What utimately matters is the economic and social policy of the Government, or which the Government are compelled by the Opposition—which has been the case for the past seven years—to provide for the people. We have had to do this in respect of education, health, and social services and we are trying to do it in relation to other things. If anybody looks at our policy, our economic plan, in the publication, "Policy for a Just Society", he will find it spelled out there. There were no articles in the Irish Times saying that the economic policy of the Fine Gael Party was unintelligible as the Irish Times articles said the other day about the Minister for Finance, Mr. Haughey, when they said he was talking about a subject he was unable to explain.
Comment on this
It shows how ignorant the Irish Times leading article can be at times and how malicious.
Comment on this
The political correspondent of the Irish Times, when commenting on our policy for a just society did not have to opine and infer what Fine Gael meant because it was spelled out quite clearly. In the last few years we, as an Opposition, have had to kick the Government into introducing some of the policies we have advocated while the Government were spending their time rowing with the farmers.
When Senator Flanagan asked me if I were going to vote against the tolerance Bill I could answer: "Yes, certainly" because the day that the west of Ireland votes for the tolerance Bill they sign the death warrant of rural Ireland in accepting the position that the population of rural Ireland is going to continue to decline because the tolerance Bill is based on the presumption and premises that that will happen and for that reason they must be given more representation than the population figures would entitle them to have.
That is what is contained in the so-called tolerance Bill for rural Ireland. That is why I say to them: "Tell the Government that in rural Ireland you are not prepared to accept a state of decline in the future." If the people do not do that the Government will be able to say in time, and no doubt their propagandists will be able to manipulate the wording so as to say that even the whole country recognised that there are certain counties where the population would continue to fall and that this was accepted by the people in the referendum of 1968. That is why I say to the people of the west of Ireland and of South Mayo, from which Senator Flanagan comes, that chief of all the things they must do is accept that they will continue in a state of decline. On the other hand, you have the Fianna Fáil Party recognising this and proposing to send down civil servants to Castlebar—against their will—in order to bolster up the local population.
Senator Yeats, of course, has inherited a poetical fancy and an innate sense of curiosity which obliges him to poke around in debates, pamphlets, documents——
Comment on this
What has the Senator been doing, going back to 1935 or even 1922? I did not go that far.
Comment on this
Of course, he will find pronouncements by different members of the Fine Gael Party now and again about PR. Of course he will.
Comment on this
He may find that, too. However, this is the significant thing, that Fine Gael as a Party have always kept in line with public opinion.
Comment on this
I shall come to that in a minute. We have kept in line with public opinion, and we were wrong, let it be said, in the Thirties in suggesting the abolition of PR, because when that was put into the Constitution in 1937, it was accepted by the people. We were right in 1959, and we are right again today.
Comment on this
I am glad to have the acknowledgment from the Fianna Fáil Party that our Leader is sometimes right. As I say, we have always kept in line with public opinion, and if we had a proposal to make and if the people did not accept it, it was dropped. We did not seek to impose our views upon the people when the people indicated in 1937 that they wanted PR as it was used up to that time in this country.
It is interesting to recall the shift that has taken place in the debate on this Bill as compared with 1959. Fianna Fáil, of course, still talk about the evils of coalition government, but the main argument in 1959 was that PR led to a multiplicity of Parties. Time has proved Fianna Fáil wrong, because in 1968 there are only three political Parties in this country, and all their gloomy forecasts as to what would happen if PR was not abolished in 1959 have been belied with the passage of time. Not alone are there fewer political Parties but there are even fewer Independents. The reason is that the people have seen that these small Parties and these Independents do not, in the long run, or indeed in the very short run as in this case, have anything very constructive to offer, and that in our day what is wanted is organisation through Parties, and they have elected in favour of three.
It will always be so. There will always be three political Parties in this country, even without the straight vote or even if you are to abolish PR and replace it with the straight vote. History has so ordained that there was a Cumann na nGaedheal Government which set up the State and another Party which rebelled against that State. That is history and we cannot get away from it. There are not the same references in these days to what happened in 1922.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture went down to Limerick and wrote in red paint or directed his minions to write in red paint "77" under the name of O'Higgins. As I say, that is history. There was and there always will be a trade union movement, and there always will be a need for a trade union movement.
Comment on this
Thanks to Fianna Fáil, there is a big trade union movement here today. There was no trade union movement when Fine Gael were in office: 8,000 or 9,000 members in the whole country.
Comment on this
There always will be a trade union movement and the trade unions will always find among their members persons whom they would wish to see elected to Dáil Éireann. There are new trends developing in public affairs around the world that have not yet come to these shores, and I shall deal with those in a minute. The object of the Fianna Fáil exercise is to get rid of Fine Gael or Labour, one or the other. Deputy Lemass, when he was Taoiseach, said that Fine Gael was a redundant Party. The Minister for Agriculture, who was then Minister for Local Government, in 1959 said— and the press reported it and we saw it in our own typescripts here but he had it erased from the Official Report—that when PR was abolished, Fine Gael would have had it.
Comment on this
The Senator may not criticise in that fashion the proceedings of the Dáil or the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The Senator may not indulge in remarks of that kind, and he knows very well that he should not.
Comment on this
That is what the Minister for Agriculture said in 1959, and that is what the then Taoiseach said, that Fine Gael was a redundant Party. They want to get rid of Fine Gael or Labour, a surplus Party. That is the whole object of this exercise. Then we have Senator O'Kennedy trying to tell us here today that this proposal is introduced for our benefit, that we ought to be able to see that in time we would become the alternative Party to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Is that what your Leader tells you at the Party meetings?
Comment on this
These Parties have evolved through history. The people's preferences are cast in that mould and there is nothing very much Fianna Fáil can do about it. They would love to be able to squelch one or other, or both, because in keeping in with the megalomaniac view of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, they believe there will always be a Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
So there will be so long as there is no alternative.
Comment on this
Consequently, they want to make quite sure it will be that much easier for them by abolishing one or other of those Parties. If the Fianna Fáil Party wanted to present the honest image that Senator O'Kennedy tried to present this morning, and if they really believed it was necessary in the interests of this country and the interests of our institutions and political stability to change the system of election, I would have expected that at some of the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheiseanna, if the cumainn did not put down a resolution to abolish the system of PR from 1959 onwards, at least the National Executive would have done so or they would have prompted some cumann to put down such a resolution.
Comment on this
No such resolution appeared on the Fianna Fáil agenda until the last Ard-Fheis.
Comment on this
Bring them here and put them before the House. It is my information—and I am not making the statement without due inquiry——
Comment on this
Possibly they concealed it in Irish. At any rate, if the Fianna Fáil Government were interested in allowing a healthy discussion to take place on the matter, they would have produced a White Paper in the same way as they produced a report of the committee on the development centres; they would have produced a White Paper as the Minister for Finance produced one in connection with the added value tax or in regard to standard time; or in the same way as they did on a variety of other matters, like the decimal system. That is what a Government do when they believe they have a problem which affects the nation so that they can get the reactions of the press and of various people. They would have done it openly, and not in the dishonest way they attempted to do it by wedging the business of PR into this expansive report of the Committee which dealt with the Constitution. They would have done it openly and honestly if they believed it was a national problem. The views of all Parties would have been taken into consideration. They did not do that because they were not honest in their approach, and it is this dishonest approach which will be the undoing of Fianna Fáil in the referendum.
I want to just suppose that Fianna Fáil got 90 seats at the next election. I want to contemplate that frightening prospect.
Comment on this
I want the Seanad to consider that frightening prospect.
Comment on this
In that hypothetical situation we would have 90 Fianna Fáil Deputies in 90 constituencies, with no Opposition TD in any of the 90 constituencies. The 90 Fianna Fáil Deputies would so cultivate that situation, and so dig themselves in, that it would take something like the foot and mouth disease to get rid of them. I know what I am talking about because I know the present methods used by Fianna Fáil under PR in order to win votes, and in order to intimidate people into continuing to vote for them.
Comment on this
They would carry on their present activities, what I regard as a kind of police State activities. They would tell the people that if they did not vote for So-and-So they would lose their jobs, as if they were not entitled to jobs in their own country. They would tell them they would not get grants for houses, or grants for sewerage, or that they would not get a licence for this or that, or that they would lose their pensions.
Comment on this
It is easy to see from the interruptions that I have hit a sensitive point. This goes on all the time. When I say this to some decent people in Fianna Fáil, they say they do not believe it goes on, but it does.
Comment on this
When I tell them that is so, they say that they would not stand over it. These are the tactics that would be employed if Fianna Fáil had 90 seats. There would be no getting them out in the unlikely event of their getting 90 seats in 90 constituencies. These are the tactics by which they have continued in power and, on a grander scale and more blatantly in modern times, they have set up the Taca organisation which is a form of political blackmail in order to make people subscribe for benefits received and to be received. It is used to compel the support of people. Why is it that the Minister for Local Government would not surrender the power he has in regard to planning appeals under the 1963 Act? The reason, as we all know, and as Dundrum Enterprises found out to their cost——
Comment on this
The public know and every builder, architect, engineer and quantity surveyor in the State knows——
Comment on this
——that there is corruption going on, and it is only once in a while that someone like Mr. Kelly as in the case of Dundrum Enterprises will sue for the money to which he said he was entitled for favours which he got from a planning appeal. We all know this. Every builder, architect, engineer and quantity surveyor in the country knows it. Getting planning permission is now regarded as one of those expenses one must incur if one wants to undertake a particular piece of development. These are the unscrupulous and unfair methods by which Fianna Fáil have continued in power. I regard it as an insult to the memory of the men who sacrificed their lives in 1916 to see unfortunate widows and fathers of large families afraid to express their preferences openly, because they are afraid it would get back to the Fianna Fáil Party. There are people who believe that there is no such thing as the secrecy of the ballot box, and this is cultivated by Fianna Fáil who say: "We will get to know how you voted."
Comment on this
They are told that Fianna Fáil will find out how they voted.
Comment on this
What you regard as contemptible and scurrilous is a measure of the depths to which the people in Fianna Fáil descend in order to get political power.
Comment on this
Under the straight vote system, inevitably we would have one-Party rule. We hear talk about strong government and stable government. We have seen the result of the straight vote system in countries that have stable government. In the Dáil the Taoiseach referred to the stability they have in the ancient democracy of the United Kingdom and in Canada and the United States. Who will say there is fair representation for all the people in the United States or in Britain?
Comment on this
No, they are not dictatorships, but I want to illustrate how democracy can be misused. There is in France, the home of democracy, I suppose, or Republicanism—Senator FitzGerald would say Britain is the home of democracy——
Comment on this
There is in France strong and stable government under a wise and great leader. That strong and stable government have brought about the kind of thing we have witnessed— damage done to the tune of £3,000 million in France. All is quiet at present but wait until the students return to the Latin Quarter in October and it will not be so peaceful. Do not forget that people have strong views and if they cannot find a vehicle for expressing their views in Parliament, there is the extra-parliamentary opposition which is now spoken about. We have seen that in France. They have the same in Japan, called zengakeran. That is a phonetic rendering. This is to be a new pattern for people to express themselves. Now, in this country, we did have a very strong and vocal minority in the form of the IRA. However, a number of remedial measures were taken to dampen down the strong views the IRA had in this country not the least of which was the removal of the king as the head of our country for the purposes of external representation.
Comment on this
It is now 6.30 p.m. I want to know if the Senator will move the adjournment. If not, I propose to move the adjournment until 7.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I will finish now but we shall resume at a later stage.
Business suspended at 6.30 p.m. and resumed at 7.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Before tea I was saying that one of the reasons the tolerance Bill must be opposed is because to agree that the population of the counties for which it is allegedly intended to be designed means that the populations of these counties would continue to decline and that is something which I for one will not ask the people of these counties or in other parts of Ireland to accept. An equally strong reason for opposing the Fourth Amendment Bill is that the abolition of PR would mean that all the people who believe they are entitled to start new Parties, who believe that the public are tired of the old Parties would find themselves completely frustrated by knowing that at the beginning at any rate they could never obtain any seat in the Dáil. It is of great significance that the people in certain constituencies in their wisdom elected four Sinn Féin candidates in the 1957 general election. These four candidates never took their seats but we never had any complaints from the Sinn Féin Party that they were being oppressed because they had the entitlement to seek representation in the Dáil and got it and did not use it. In the next general election the people in their wisdom and with a degree of political maturity wiped them off the map.
In catering for political minorities, for instance, the great numbers of people in the trade union movement who traditionally have had Dáil representation, it is equally important to bear in mind that we have a national problem which people are inclined to forget. One of the great national problems is Partition and it was very disquieting to note at the Orange celebrations this month that Mr. Craig and Mr. Faulkner were able to get up and say, as Senator O'Kennedy in his innocence said today, that the minority in the North have no cause in justice to complain about anything. What Senator O'Kennedy said was that minorities in this country should involve themselves in political Parties and should involve themselves in other activities and that they have no right to be minorities. That is the kind of attitude, the kind of cant and the kind of thinking that will be taken up in the North in the same way as Captain O'Neill speaking in his home town on Orange day said, as a result of what the Minister for Education had to say about 1916, that the people down South were now realising the wisdom of the North's stand in 1922. If we get rid of minorities and if the rights of minorities to have representation under proportional representation are got rid of, we are inviting the North to continue to say that the minorities up there have no right to be represented. That was the theme of Senator O'Kennedy's speech today.
Comment on this
Read the Report when it comes out. It will be a while before it does come out but read it. The theme and the whole idea of abolishing proportional representation is a long way removed from what Mr. de Valera said to the Evening Standard in 1938. He said then that taking into account the prevailing sentiments in the North and of the majority of the whole island he would immediately have a single all-Ireland Party election under proportional representation in order to be fair to minorities. This, he said, might entail a different Executive but what he proposed in the existing situation would be to say to Belfast:
Keep all your present powers, we ask only one thing of you, we think the area you control is not the area in justice you could claim even for Parliament but we will make the concession if you guarantee fair play for the minority and consent to the transfer to an all-Irish Parliament of the powers now reserved to the Parliament of Westminster.
Inherent in that was the idea that the minority in the North was entitled to be treated fairly.
Comment on this
So Senator Yeats, speaking on behalf of Fianna Fáil, says the minority in Derry are being treated fairly.
Comment on this
Is the minority in Northern Ireland being treated fairly?
Comment on this
We have come a long way from the statement made by the Taoiseach of the day, Deputy Éamon de Valera, to the Evening Standard in 1938.
Comment on this
We are telling the Senators on that side also what the Fine Gael Party have done and said about proportional representation all over the years and what they say now.
Comment on this
I want to refer now to another matter raised by Senator O'Kennedy. Mark you, his speech was referred to as a serious contribution to the debate. He was, I think, well worth listening to, but I gathered from him, from the Taoiseach and from all the other Fianna Fáil speakers, that the system of the straight vote and the single seat is designed to achieve a better type of candidate for the Dáil. I have no doubt in my mind but that, under the straight vote system, the Fianna Fáil Party will continue to select the same kind of candidate as they have selected under proportional representation. The theory may be all right but, in practice, this will not make the slightest difference and, if there was any sincerity whatever in Fianna Fáil's alleged anxiety to get good candidates and good representatives into Parliament, their Taoiseach would have exercised his discretion in relation to the selection of 11 members to the Seanad in such a fashion as to command the respect of the community.
Comment on this
I will not go into the 11, but when that point was raised with Deputy Lemass in the Committee on the Constitution, he said: "What can you do?" The newspapers have time and time again condemned the Taoiseach's selection. When the Taoiseach had it in his power to bring into Parliament people of merit and people of quality, people who, if they were presented to the public would not be elected because they had no popular appeal, but who, because of their quality and merit, should be in Parliament, the Taoiseach declined time and time again to appoint such people. When one sees that in relation to a matter in which the Taoiseach has absolute discretion one can only conclude that no better candidates would be selected by Fianna Fáil under the straight vote system. The Taoiseach calls it the relative majority system.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would cease reflecting offensively on Members of the House.
Comment on this
I am merely talking about what has gone wrong.
Comment on this
The whole purpose of any electoral system, the whole purpose of government, the whole purpose of a constitution, the whole purpose of all the money spent on the Army and the Garda Síochána, is to ensure domestic peace and order. What must be avoided is a situation in which discontent among certain sections of the community can erupt into violence. Proportional representation has led to such a situation. We have had in this country, especially since the repeal of the External Relations Act in 1949, order and tranquillity. The dissident, republican minority know that there is available to them a means by which they can get representation for their point of view. They have sought that representation and the fact is that we have had peace. There is fair representation for all points of view and that can only be achieved under proportional representation. The fact that people can get representation even for points of view that are not generally accepted has given us one of the greatest blessings any country can enjoy, internal peace; from that we can move on to peace among nations but we must, first of all, have domestic peace. We have had that. I venture to forecast—I do not mind forecasting because history teaches—that if we ever reach the stage at which we have a strong, arbitrary government here we will cease to have the peace and tranquillity we have enjoyed up to now.
When I see a government that can be so wide of the mark in interpreting public sentiment as the Fianna Fáil Government has been I am appalled at the prospect of a Fianna Fáil Government with an absolute overall majority. I see a Fianna Fáil Government so out of touch with the real needs of the people that a member of a Fianna Fáil Cabinet can produce and present to Parliament legislation prohibiting a man leaving £300 or £900 to his wife; that was the first Succession Bill introduced into the Dáil by Deputy Haughey when he was Minister for Justice. A man who died and left £300 would be compelled, had that legislation been enacted, to leave one-third of that to his children. That shows ignorance of affairs. When I see that sort of thing I wonder what would Fianna Fáil do if they had an absolute majority. Again, it was a strong Opposition and a vocal press, plus the chance of a general election, which resulted in Deputy Haughey being quietly dropped and that particular provision suitably amended.
Again, the Fisheries Bill is still lying in the Dáil. In that Bill Fianna Fáil propose that young lads fishing across the Moy, or over the Shannon, or in some mountain streams, must pay a licence in 1968. It will no longer be lawful for a young lad to take his rod and wet his line; he will have to pay a licence and, if he does not do so, he will commit an offence. That is the way Fianna Fáil govern and that is the way they will get taxation to finance the protection of fisheries. They will require everybody, irrespective of means, to pay a fishery licence.
Again, there is the Livestock Marts Bill which was being steamrolled through the Dáil. The debate was guillotined. It is working very satisfactorily. Nothing has been done for the livestock marts since they got their licences but it was absolutely urgent at that time. All that the Minister for Agriculture wanted was to get a hold over the livestock marts and, having done that, he has done nothing since. He has not introduced any regulation and it has made not the slightest difference to the manner in which these marts are functioning. The first thing he wanted was to get a hold and power and to be in a position to tell these people: "If you do not do what I want you to do, you will be closed down." He is less likely to do anything now after the beetgrowers' election. These are only random samples——
Comment on this
——of the Fianna Fáil approach to legislation when they have a majority. If they ever reach the stage where they have the large majority they hope they would get under the single-seat there would be literally no standing them.
Comment on this
If you have, it is a great pity you do not do something about the economy of the country.
Comment on this
Of course, they have enough to do anything but the Fianna Fáil Party know that they are on the way out——
Comment on this
——and they realise it behoves them to be of good behaviour and to try to curry favour with public opinion until the next general election but I have no doubt whatever that if they got into power with this majority the difference between life under a Fianna Fáil Government with an absolute majority of 90 and life in some of the eastern countries of Europe would be very difficult to detect.
Comment on this
What do you know about eastern countries in Europe? I did not intend to intervene unduly in this debate but I am prompted to do so by the vitriolic speech made by Senator O'Quigley. I was shocked and disgusted, in fact, to listen to his speech before tea. He was beginning to get equally objectionable after tea. I am inclined, for the record, to think that some things must be stated because of the continued misrepresentation of the facts of history which has gone unchallenged from year to year and from week to week. When opportunity like this occurs, I think the facts should be stated and the record put right.
Senator O'Quigley is supposed to be a man of some intelligence and his Party is supposed to have some patriotic outlook. He is supposed to have some interest in the peace and comfort and goodwill of the citizens of this country.
Comment on this
He is supposed to want to see the people of this country living in harmony together. We all do.
Comment on this
If there is one thing that I find deplorable it is this misrepresentation of the history of the period surrounding the Treaty and what followed. It is distasteful to have to remind Senators here in an Irish Parliament of the true facts of the situation that existed at that time but Senator O'Quigley has given the other side of the picture and I feel that it is right and proper that I should give the true facts as history will relate them.
Senator O'Quigley says that, because of expediency, Fianna Fáil changed the Constitution in 1937. He added to that that the 1937 Constitution was a reproduction of the 1922 Constitution and, then, that the 1922 Constitution was enacted by the people of Ireland and, finally, that the Fianna Fáil people rebelled against that State.
Let us take the facts of the situation as they are known to historians and as they will be seen in the light of history in the future and as they can be verified now by Senator FitzGerald or any other equally interested statistician or historian.
The 1922 Constitution, said Senator O'Quigley, was enacted by the people. It was a document, a draft of which was sent over to Great Britain for approval of the British Government. It was radically changed by the British Government. It was sent back to the Provisional Government of the Irish Free State and they were told that this was the document they would have to have as their governing fundamental law. It was concealed from the people until the morning of the poll in June, 1922, at the packed election, and on the morning of the poll, when newspapers were scarce in this country, when their circulation was minimal compared with what it is now, when very few people in rural Ireland even saw a newspaper until a couple of days after it was published, and many people had to rely on weekly newspapers—on that morning the terms of that abject, disgraceful document were published in the Irish Independent, the Cork Examiner, the Cork Constitution, the Freeman's Journal and a couple of the Belfast papers and that was all that the people of these 26 Counties who were free to vote on that Constitution knew about it. It could not, therefore, be said to be a Constitution enacted by the people of Ireland and, particularly, by the people of rural Ireland.
Senator O'Quigley says that the Constitution of 1937 was introduced because of expediency by Fianna Fáil. The Constitution of 1937 was introduced after a long period of tearing up inch by inch the disgraceful document which was forced down the throats of the Irish people in June, 1922 and inch by inch it was torn to bits after Fianna Fáil became the Government, in 1932, until there was nothing left but tatters and shreads and then the Constitution of 1937 was, first of all, presented to the Dáil and then to the people and there were six or seven weeks of debate and discussion throughout the country and, having passed through the Dáil and Seanad, it was then submitted to the people by way of referendum, a thing which the Fine Gael Party very much dislikes.
Comment on this
The referendum resulted in the enactment by the people by a free plebiscite of the Constitution of 1937.
Senator O'Quigley further tries to confuse those who do not know the facts by alleging that the 1937 Constitution under which we live was a reproduction of that disgraceful document of 1922. Senator O'Quigley knows damn well that there were 13 Articles in that 1922 Constitution which could not be changed by even 20 votes of the Irish people. He knows of the subservience of the so-called Irish Parliament to the Parliament of Great Britain. He knows of the allegiance which had to be sworn to the British Crown, its heirs and successors. He knows that, in fact, it was the Constitution of a very diminutive colony, not the Constitution even of a dominion, certainly not the Constitution of a free nation.
Comment on this
This is the Constitution which Senator O'Quigley says was incorporated in the Constitution of 1937.
Comment on this
There will not be one of them left. They are running.
Comment on this
The Constitution of 1937 was a republican Constitution which established a Republic, as proof of which, in 1949 when it was decided to name this State, no trouble was found. There was no impediment, there was nothing extraordinary in the declaration of this Republic. All that was required was a simple Act of Parliament because the 1937 Constitution, not being a reproduction of the Constitution of 1922, was capable of being used in that way as a Constitution of an independent Irish State. Senator O'Quigley, in spite of his knowledge— and he must know something; God knows he talks enough here to have read some books on history—says that on top of all that we have a national problem, Partition, ignoring the historical fact that the Constitution of 1922 was a partitionist Constitution based on a sell-out of the Irish nation by the Treaty of 1921 which assented to the partition of Ireland, and subsequently, in 1925, under the same Constitution, an Act was passed through the Dáil and Seanad of this Free State, as it then was called, through the British House of Commons and the House of Lords and through the House of Commons in Northern Ireland, ratifying the partition of Ireland, so far as it legally could be done, for all time, and the title deeds of partition, enshrined and embodied in the Treaty and in the Constitution of 1922, were solidified and ratified by the elected representatives of the people here and by the British Parliament and the Parliament of Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
That is a confounded misrepresentation of the facts.
Comment on this
——to minimise that objection by our whole policy which would put an end to that and we have got very little co-operation from Fine Gael as that goes, that is for the record and for historical accuracy. Senator O'Quigley says that reports coming in from Fianna Fáil around the country have left the Taoiseach dispirited. Where he gets the idea that these reports are coming in I do not know. He must have the Taoiseach's office bugged or the Fianna Fáil headquarters connected by a bugging machine to his house, or he must have a crystal ball into which he looks every morning, or he must be a soothsayer, but certainly if he is conning himself into believing that reports are coming in to make the Taoiseach dispirited he is barking up the wrong tree indeed.
Far from reports coming in and making the Taoiseach dispirited, the reports which we have got on the reaction of the public to the question of the straight vote and the single-seat constituency are so encouraging that I have no doubt whatsoever that if this Fine Gael-Labour Coalition will allow this question to be put to the people they will reverse the foolish decision they made in 1959 at the behest of both those Parties at that time. He says Fine Gael have always kept in line with public opinion. The most notable example of Fine Gael keeping in line with public opinion occurred in 1933. Many Senators will remember that time. In the previous April, 1932, the British Government, at the behest of Fine Gael, imposed a list of economic sanctions on Irish produce——
Comment on this
——and began to wage an economic war against the produce of the Irish. They began to wage that war with the fullest co-operation and with the collaboration of the quisling members of Fine Gael. They did it for nine months. At that time I read their organ every week and week by week what the British Government forgot to put a tariff on they suggested. That was the assistance Fine Gael gave to an Irish Government in January, 1933.
Comment on this
Despite it we survived, including yourself and your forebears.
Comment on this
In 1933, the Fianna Fáil Government decided the time had come to consult the people, and unlike Fine Gael and Labour they were not afraid to consult the people. They went to them any time and on any question on which they wished to get a mandate, and they got it.
Comment on this
Take your medicine now. I have to sit here listening to Senator O'Quigley and you will listen to me now. In January, 1933, Fianna Fáil went to the people and at a general election in the cold of winter the Fianna Fáil Party were returned with 77 seats, an overall majority in Parliament, and they are the Party which Fine Gael say are out of touch with the people. They say that Fine Gael are in line with the people at all times. They opposed the stand taken at that time by the Government and they were decisively repudiated.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley, of course, could not refrain from the usual personal sneers which he addresses to the Ministers for Local Government and Finance and he roped in the staid and respected Irish Times leader writer to bolster up his smear at the Minister for Finance. The leader writer of the Irish Times, if he had any sense of shame left, when he read the comments of readers in his letter columns must have felt at least that he had put his two feet into it, hook, line and sinker, and if Senator O'Quigley cannot find any other vehicle through which to throw mud at Deputy Haughey he should abandon the attempt because the attempt was killed at birth by the people who read the newspaper in which this smearing editorial appeared. In regard to the Minister for Local Government, I have no doubt his record, against that of Senator O'Quigley, will stand the test of any reliable investigation made. I have no doubt it will be found that the Minister for Local Government will be able to put Mr. O'Quigley in as good a box as I would be able to put him.
Comment on this
Members of the House must be addressed by their proper titles.
Comment on this
One is inclined to forget that he is a Senator. He does not conduct himself like one.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley gave us an exhibition of the usual Fine Gael trua Muire banshee moans and wails about the awful thing which will happen if the people of Ireland vote for the tolerance Bill. He said they would be signing their death warrant, that this would be a police State, that corruption would be rampant. I thought Senator Quinlan had a monopoly but now I find Senator O'Quigley has imbibed the medicine closely on the heels of our scientific friend from Cork. What has happened in France, to which Senator O'Quigley referred, and what is happening in other countries is due to the fact that the mentality of anarchists is being spread as it is being slowly and surely spread here by Senators Quinlan and O'Quigley—the mentality of bringing the public institutions of this country into disrepute, of bringing the public representatives into contempt, of casting doubt on the integrity of the judges and the police, making sure there is a feeling of dissatisfaction around the country in the homes of the people. If this is the kind of stuff the Fine Gael Party are going to present to us as an excuse for depriving the people of the right to decide for themselves whether they want to change the electoral system or not, then God help the policy of Fine Gael for the future.
Senator O'Quigley also had the infernal impudence to refer to the late President Seán T. O'Kelly, whose boots, of course, he was not fit to lick and whose record he could never approach if he lived to 1,000 years. Senator O'Quigley, in his attempt to sneer at the late Seán T. O'Kelly and in his description of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Seán Lemass, as a man with a megalomaniac mind, shows how small-minded, how puerile and how fifthy are his own ideas. To describe people who did so much for their country in this way and whose records are well known and to try to besmirch them——
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley is trying to do his damnedest to destroy not only the truth of history but to destroy the memory of men who have served this country well. The great housing schemes around this town are a monument to Seán T. O'Kelly and every factory is a monument to Seán Lemass.
Comment on this
He referred to the former Taoiseach as having addressed sarcastic remarks to Fine Gael in which he described them as a surplus Party. Has anyone any doubt that Fine Gael are a surplus Party and that they are going to be a surplus Party? Whether it is the straight vote or PR, inch by inch they are going down the drain. They have no future, no faith in themselves, no prospect of success. They reached their high-water mark and now they are sinking. The sooner they make up their minds to get out and let the country decide properly and fairly and without the propaganda they have been using, the better for the country. They should make up their minds that they have no prospects, no policy and that the type of policy they have, which is based on personal abuse, will never for long command the adherence of any section of the voters. I make no apology for saying that Fine Gael are a surplus Party and should get out. They should liquidate themselves before the electors liquidate them.
Senator O'Quigley also talked about the fate of small Parties which have disappeared, leaving now only three Parties. He said there would always be only three Parties in this country. There will certainly be two, whatever about the third. As for the small Parties, he ought to examine his records to find out why many of the small Parties disappeared. We all know about the lady from Bengal who went for a ride on a tiger. Many farmers' Parties went for a ride on the Fine Gael tiger and came back inside the tiger. Fine Gael gobbled them up. Indeed, the Labour Party gobbled up one or two in its time also.
Comment on this
No, the National Labour Party, otherwise camouflaged as the ITGWU. Senator O'Quigley referred to what the President said in 1937, that PR had worked fairly well here. Certainly, it had worked fairly well. There is no reason for anyone to hang his head because the President said that in 1937. But Senator O'Quigley failed to quote what the President said a few years afterwards when he gave a warning about indecisive elections, gave a warning about the dangers of PR and what would happen in the course of time. Senator O'Quigley, if he looks up the records, will find those references which might amaze him. He will not find that everything is as rosy in the garden in regard to that.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley wound up by telling us that we were wasting public time and public money in debating a useless measure rejected in 1959. If this is a useless measure and if we are wasting public time and money, I do not know how the Senator interprets the word "democracy". These two measures are intended to give the people the opportunity (1) to institute the policy of one man, one vote and (2) to institute the policy of the single-seat and the straight vote. If he thinks that consulting the people as to whether that is wise, foolish, good, bad or indifferent is wrong, then I do not understand what he understands by the word "democracy". If he thinks that is a waste of time, I am afraid his idea of a waste of time and mine do not coincide.
Senator O'Quigley said he was telling us what the Fine Gael Party had said and done about PR, but he omitted very carefully to tell what the Fine Gael Party did about PR in certain years. Let us go back, for instance, to 1927 when Fianna Fáil entered the Dáil. I remember a series of full-page advertisements on the front page of the Irish Independent and among them was a wonderful advertisement from the Fine Gael Party, then camouflaged as Cumann na nGaedheal—they change their spots so often that sometimes I do not know what to call them—telling us all the awful things that were going to happen under PR if this Fianna Fáil Party and its allies succeeded in doing such-and-such a thing. Down at the bottom was that they intended to get rid of PR. We did not hear anything about that one. In the years that followed there was an organisation formed by Fine Gael called the Youth Movement. The Youth Movement had an organ called the Blue Flag and week after week in the Blue Flag——
Comment on this
I have a file of the thing. You will have to take your medicine. I find in the Blue Flag a most interesting article on why we should get rid of PR. In United Ireland, which was also an official organ of the Party, I also find an interesting article advocating the abolition of PR. Senator O'Quigley has not told us everything about what Fine Gael did and said about PR. I do not think it is worth wasting any more time dealing with him on that subject.
I would like to register my protest against the whole tone of his speech and his introduction of issues which should not be brought into public debate on a Bill like this, because when they are historically twisted and distorted, as they were twisted and distorted by him, they are bound to have reverberations and to rise answers from anybody present who knows the truth. I advise him in the future to be more careful. He should remember that we are not all simpletons. Some of us who have already been through this period have good memories and have tongues that can speak, thank God.
All that is in these two Bills before the Seanad at present——
Comment on this
——is that the people are being given an opportunity to change the present defective system of election. All we want is to have these two Bills passed by the Oireachtas so that a referendum can be instituted to give the people that opportunity.
The decision to introduce these Bills was not taken overnight. The decision to have a referendum to decide the question of an electoral system was not a matter of fun and games. It was well thought out and was taken in response to many requests from the strongest political organisation in the country over many years advocating the abolition of PR and the introduction of single-seat constituencies. The Government, in their wisdom, decided that the time had come to try the people again as to whether they agreed with the Government's view or not. The fact that nine years have passed since the first decision was made on this issue is not relevant. As Deputy Sheldon pointed out and as I want to emphasise, more than 50 per cent of the present register are people who have not had the opportunity to vote and did not vote in the 1959 referendum.
It should be remembered in regard to the 1937 referendum that the people who enacted the Constitution and voted for or against it are now all over 52 years of age and nobody in this part of Ireland had an opportunity of voting for or against PR in that referendum unless he is now over 52. That means that there is a vast body of young people who have reached maturity and come on the register who are entitled to pronounce as to whether their country should be governed, or Parliament elected, under this system or a better system. If you are not prepared to give them that opportunity you should not talk about encouraging youth.
Comment on this
Then we should have a referendum every nine years.
Comment on this
Because Fine Gael is a dying Party it is anxious to hang on to the present system in the hope of regaining some semblance of the power it once had. One of the reasons many people in Fine Gael, I should say, would be anxious to hang on to this system is that under it we heard some talk from various speakers on the Coalition side about safe seats. There is nothing safer under heaven regarding parliamentary seats than the prominent member of the Party or Leader of the Party who goes up for election under PR. Once he is in, it would take TNT to get him out because the Leader of a Party, in a constituency with three or four seats, is almost certain to be elected.
Comment on this
I do not know whether that has in any way inspired Fine Gael or Labour decisions. The Labour Party is composed of a group of personalities all well known in their own areas and pretty popular and all bound to get a seat under this PR system of having three, four or five seats. Perhaps that is why they are anxious to hang on to the PR system.
It is because Fine Gael are a dying Party and the Labour Party have no faith in itself as a possible future Government, as successors to Fianna Fáil. They do not seem to have any faith and do not believe it can be done. They are not willing to take the big gamble of putting up candidates in a straight vote election in the belief that they could get a big majority of seats. If the people decided to give them that big majority, well and good. I hope Labour will get enough faith in itself some day, that they will see that nothing is gained by a timid approach and that they must have courage and go into battle believing the battle can be won. Their whole attitude up to now has been that if they get a few seats it will be enough to shout about. They do not seem to want more.
We also decided on this campaign in the knowledge that it would be no cakewalk, that it would be a tough, long drawn-out battle. We knew we would face the Fine Gael Party, small and dwindling as it is; that we would face the Labour Party with its powerful backing of the trade union movement now after it rallied them in 1957 at the last minute. We knew we had to face a comparatively hostile newspaper group all over the country because most of the country's newspapers are opposed to everything Fianna Fáil stands for. We had also to surmount the feeling people have that it is dangerous to change, the feeling of lassitude and letting things stand. In deciding to go ahead with this proposal we knew what we were up against and we are not afraid of the result. We believe the people will do what we ask them to do and that we shall secure their approval for these proposed amendments of the Constitution.
We took this decision not on the grounds of expediency, or selfishness or any other motive but because of a real honest-to-goodness belief that this would be good for the country's future, giving it stability of government and a system of election which would ensure that stability of government so that we would not be subject to the rise and fall of minority governments, small governments, dictation by small Parties and all the other crises that occur in many other countries as a consequence of peculiar systems. That is why we decided to go to the country with this proposition. It does not matter what Fine Gael believe or what they allege inspired us. This is the truth of the matter and this is why we are doing it.
I suppose it is not useful to say to Fine Gael and Labour that their arguments about this being a selfish action on our part do not stand up because we did so well under PR. We did very well under PR and are doing very well under PR.
Comment on this
The proof of it is that in 13 out of 14 elections since Fianna Fáil were first elected we have been the largest Party. We became the Government as a result of ten general elections. We secured more votes than all the other Parties put together in five general elections. Nobody can say that PR has treated us badly.
Comment on this
Nobody can say that we would do any better, possibly, under the straight vote. Nobody can say we have any ulterior motive because we can be the government of this part of Ireland for as long as we care to be——
Comment on this
——because there is no possible alternative to us. Fine Gael is dying and Labour has no faith in itself and neither will ever become the Government. Fianna Fáil will be the largest Party under PR.
Comment on this
Under the straight vote there is the possibility of change. Certainly under PR, as admitted even by their own electoral experts, we shall never fall below 63 to 65 seats——
Comment on this
Under this present system Fianna Fáil have been in power for 36 years. Anybody who says we are making this new proposal because PR does not suit us or because we have any motives other than the future good of the country is saying something that is not grounded on facts. It is no harm to remind Senators that in 1965 we got a majority in Dáil Éireann as a result of a general election. That is only three years ago. That majority has been satisfactorily and progressively increased since by a series of wins in by-elections. Further evidence that the support, far from dwindling, is increasing is the fact that at the local government elections, we successfully held the number of seats which we held prior to the elections. There is no evidence whatsoever to show that there is any diminution in the strength of the public support for the Government or for the policy of Fianna Fáil.
Therefore, why should we try to get rid of PR unless we believe it would be detrimental to the future welfare and good government of the country? We are not getting rid of it, and we are not asking Fine Gael or Labour to get rid of it; we are asking the people to decide, and we want the Fine Gael and Labour Parties to give them a say. Labour have shown a degree of enthusiasm for getting this to the people, I am very pleased to record; they are anxious to get it out as fast as possible. They have said so in their speeches here. I did not hear anything like that from Senator O'Quigley. The sooner we get this matter to the people and let the people decide for themselves, the sooner will everybody be satisfied that the highest tribunal in the land has made its decision on the proposition. If the Government are turned down on it, well and good; that is the wish of the people. On the other hand, if the proposals are accepted, then that is satisfactory to us and proves that the Government were in line with public opinion at this time.
Comment on this
Senator Ó Maoláin referred to Senator Dooge's point. Senator Dooge said that, on the basis of the shares of the votes in the local election Fianna Fáil would secure, he thought, 64 seats under PR — column 1250.
Comment on this
The Senator denied that earlier today. I said 98 seats under the straight vote on the basis of less than 40 per cent of the vote, and he denied that.
Comment on this
I explained most clearly that, on the basis of the local election results, in which Fianna Fáil got just less than 40 per cent, it represented in a general election, where there would not be so many Independents, an equivalent of 44 per cent.
Comment on this
The Senators can argue that out between them later. I am not finished yet. Let me come to this motion put down by the Labour Party and its new-found colleague, Senator Sheehy Skeffington.
Comment on this
I do not know which end of it he is in. The Labour Party motion reveals completely muddled thinking and a lack of appreciation of the meaning of the English language. In that connection it would be no harm to devote a little time to it. The motion says that the proposal to consult the people is dictatorial and undemocratic. All the time since I have been a baby and since I began to read papers and books and learned the meaning of words, I have understood that a democrat is one who accepts the verdict of the people at an election or at a plebiscite and accepts majority rule. I always understood that a dictator is one who is invested with absolute power and who disregards the wishes of the people.
Comment on this
No, I am talking about the motion. Let the Senator keep his ears open and listen. I do not want to go back to 1922. A referendum according to my book, means the submission of any question at political issue to the people for a decision by them as to whether they like it or not. Having got these definitions right, let us see what we have here. Senator Murphy comes across with this one. He says the issue was decided already, that it was a clearcut decision when the people accepted the Constitution and again in 1959. They accepted the Constitution and PR, right enough, and they rejected the proposal to amend the Constitution in 1959. Fair enough. Is there any reason why they should not be given another opportunity in view of what I said, that over 50 per cent of the electorate did not vote or had not a vote at the time of the 1959 plebiscite? That argument is as much as saying we should not have a general election every four years because it is only a few years since we consulted the people. That would suit many people's book.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with the general election. It is a separate issue, and must be decided as a separate issue.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with the general election. We hope that between the time these Bills are passed by the Seanad and the holding of the referendum, the people will have had ample opportunity to examine the proposals for themselves and to hear the case which we hope to put to them. Senator Murphy also says that the referendum proposals are due to the power-hungry people in Fianna Fáil. I wonder who they could be. I do not know what more the power-hungry people—if there are such people—could get than the power they have at the moment, and to allege that the referendum proposals are due to power-hungry people seems to me to be absurd. I do not know the reason for using a phrase like "power-hungry".
Comment on this
Anything that it is alleged power-hungry people want to do at the moment they can do; they have a majority in order to enable them to do it.