We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 599–802 of 802. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

After the next election under the straight vote they might be sitting in a different direction. One can never tell; it is not a guarantee of permanent victory. The Senator also said the proposals were unpatriotic. Patriotism to me means love of country, concern for the people, the desire to improve their lot. These proposals show concern for the people, the desire to improve their lot in the future by making certain they have stable government. I do not know how Senator Murphy could describe the proposition as unpatriotic. He said it was a plot by the Government who see the prospect of losing power. I can assure Senator Murphy there is no plot whatsoever by the Government against the Labour Party. We do not see the point of the argument. We had six by-elections and the county council elections, giving no evidence that we are losing strength, and the next general election will prove, whether under the straight vote or PR, that Fianna Fáil will be the Government again.

Then we come to the plot to annihilate the Labour Party at a critical time in its growth, and Senator Murphy congratulated Fine Gael on not joining the plot. What about the plot to annihilate Fianna Fáil that is being hatched by the two buckos, Fine Gael and Labour? What about the plot to organise this lovely Coalition that is going to arrange things in every constituency? What about the secret circulars and agreements being made from one end of the country to the other? They do not think we are all fools or that we are all asleep. Instead of talking about plots, Senator Murphy ought to consult Big Brother down there in Liberty Hall and see what he has got to say about it before coming along here with that sort of talk. I can assure him there is no plot except the plot hatched by Fine Gael and Labour.

Comment on this

Will you walk into my parlour?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They want to take them for a ride on the tiger.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Inside or outside?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Murphy of course has the old banshee wail that there is no prospect of a third Party ever gaining power under the straight vote. I remember when I was a young lad I used to read a lot of socialist papers and a lot of labour papers printed in England. Among them was the New Leader. The New Leader used to tell the history of the early days There were two Labour Parties, as Deputy Murphy will know, the Independent Labour Party and the official Labour Party. I remember reading articles by George Lansbury, Bob Smyllie and Ramsay MacDonald on the prospect of a Labour Government in Britain.

In those days they used to write contradictory articles pointing out that with Liberal and Tory controlled banks and newspapers, and all organs of public opinion plus transport, there was no hope that the Labour Party would ever get anywhere in England. They began, and gradually they got a few Members into Parliament. Keir Hardy kept preaching the gospel and bit by bit they increased. They had faith in themselves, and they preached the gospel. They were the crusaders. I remember Ramsay MacDonald fighting a by-election as a peace candidate in Keighley in Yorkshire. He got about 2,000 votes out of a total of 65,000 votes. He was run off the streets and stoned and everything else, but he did not give up and neither did the Labour Party in Keighley. It became a Labour stronghold.

Bit by bit the Labour Party grew and got bigger. They kept on preaching and crusading. They preached socialism and they believed in it. The three-Party system in Britain was supposed to keep the Labour Party out because the Liberals and Tories had everything, but the Labour Party gradually found themselves in the position of being the new challenger. I think it must have been the hunger marches of the 30s and the stories of desolation and starvation in the Rhonnda Valley when people like Ellen Wilkinson were writing books about "The town that was Murdered" which started the big swing, because from 1931 on things improved.

Comment on this

Have we to go through this again?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now they are the Government in Great Britain and they had a much harder row to furrow than the Labour Party here. They became the Government with an overall majority. Let no one say to me that it cannot be done, and that a third Party can never become the Government. A third Party can, provided they have faith in themselves, work hard, believe in themselves, and stick to their guns. Let us hear no more arguments that a third Party can never be the Government. It could be done in England, and it can be done here— not for a long time though, unless they pin their colours to the mast and get going.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Senator is very nervous about our getting together.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am afraid Fine Gael might eat them up.

Comment on this

He is trying to protect us from the Fine Gael tiger.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

By bringing in this Bill, they are saving Labour from the tiger.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Murphy also said that it was doubtful if a majority in Fianna Fáil were satisfied with the proposal, and that it was pushed through by a certain clique. I do not know what clique, or what was pushed through. All I know is that the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis were enthusiastic about it, the Fianna Fáil National Executive, elected by the Ard-Fheis were enthusiastic about it, and that Fianna Fáil discussed it at length, and completely and decidedly voted in favour of it, and we will go to the country as a united team.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Some Ministers and some Members were not in favour of it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It was also said that Fianna Fáil had fallen into the hands of Taca. I knew that would come at some time. Let us get the record straight about Taca, which seems to have become a dirty word in the minds of Fine Gael and Labour. They are trying to put the story across that there is something sinister in it and something of which we should be ashamed.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was a mistake to give it a four-letter word name.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There is nothing sinister, nothing hidden and nothing to be ashamed about in Taca. Fianna Fáil supporters come together——

Comment on this

It is voluntary, and it is not stolen money.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

If the people in Taca are good enough and generous enough to devote their time and money to a political Party to fight elections and carry on campaigns, in my book they are good citizens. Those critics outside the Party, and outside any Party, who stand on the ditch and throw sneers and mud are the most reprehensible, the most distasteful, and the most nauseating characters I know. There is nothing whatever wrong with Taca. It is an organisation pledged to raise money for Fianna Fáil. In every country in the world where there is political democracy, political Parties have to get money. In every country in the world there is a Taca. Even the Labour Party have a Taca now, in the big building down there with big brother John watching and dictating what they will do and how much he will give them to do it. I can tell you our Taca "aint" anything like what that Taca will be before he is finished with the Labour Party. He will exact his pound of flesh. There is no doubt in the world about that. We are not worried about Taca and others should stop talking about it, because it does not pull any rabbits out of the hole.

We also heard from Senator Murphy that this proposal was an attempt to take from us our democratic rights. God, the idea of going to consult the people is an attempt to take from us our democratic rights! I do not know who "us" means. It certainly does not mean the people, because the people are being consulted. They are being given the final voice. They are being asked what do they think about it. How in the name of goodness can you take away democratic rights by asking the people to decide on the system of election? If the people want to take away their so-called democratic rights, is that not their business? They are the bosses. You accept that, do you not? If you accept the people's verdict, let us get these Bills to hell out of here and get voting on them.

I heard from Senator Murphy a few nice little phrases of which I took particular note. He said these Bills were a retreat from democracy, an attack on democracy, and they would lead to the complete destruction of democracy. Imagine that! If you consult the people at an election or a plebiscite you have a retreat from democracy, an attack on democracy, and you destroy democracy. It is not worth talking about.

Comment on this

Why not give them a choice of three?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What do I hear? Listen, go and play with your rattle, sonny. You had two hours and ten minutes.

Comment on this

Why not consult them properly?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is like Senator Quinlan up there. Senator Murphy is talking about imposing "the British system". I think Senator Quinlan went back to the 1959 slogan of "The Belfast system". Anyhow, we are going to impose the British system, according to Senator Murphy, but the fact is that we are not. We are trying to remove the British-imposed system of proportional representation which was foisted on us here by the British Government. If there is any system——

Comment on this

Try it out on the dog.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was copper-fastened in the 1937 Constitution.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Let Senator Quinlan keep quiet and not tempt me, now. I am in excellent humour at the moment. I might not be that way long.

Comment on this

Hurry up, I am dying for a smoke.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

So am I, Dominick. I shall be with you in a moment. Another little thing strikes me about this democracy business. I should like to see a little more democracy from the self-styled custodians of the said democratic tradition, to wit, the Labour Party. I do not think Fine Gael have any use for democracy any more. The Labour Party make a big noise about it. I should like to see a little more democracy from them.

For instance, there is a thing operated called the "political levy". Trade unions get various and sundry semi-Government agencies to collect for them and it is collected in various factories and shops. That trade union levy—granted it is only small but it is the principle I am after—is collected and it is handed over to the treasurers. Now, I find from my experience that if a person does not want to pay that levy he has the utmost difficulty with the democratic trade union secretary of his branch in getting the form which it is necessary for him to get in order to opt out of paying it. The British Trade Disputes Act was repealed by the British Government.

Comment on this

It is taken, anyhow, even if——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There is the utmost difficulty in getting these forms. I have complaints from all over the country that branch officials have refused to give them in some cases. They said they are not available. They put all sorts of obstacles in the way of applicants for these forms.

If the Labour Party are the custodians of democracy, as they say they are, they should do something about that before more trouble is created as a consequence. The political levy is not an evidence of democracy. It is an evidence of where men who support one Party are obliged to pay into the funds of another Party.

Comment on this

Yes. Blackmail: intimidation.

Comment on this

And it is governed by law.

Comment on this

And rigged branch meetings.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not know about all this talk about Fianna Fáil and all the inside information that Senator Murphy has about us and what we are doing but a few little incidents happened recently at the Labour Party Committees and at the Labour Party Conference that tickled my palate for further information. I am naturally inquisitive. I was inclined to question this democracy business and this respect for democracy that we are charged with running away from and with trying to destroy. If I remember rightly, there have been three or four incidents recently in the Labour Party in which otherwise worthy Members of the Labour Party were sacked, suspended, railroaded or liquidated and no evidence was given, no trial, nothing. It does not come so well then from representatives of the Party to speak about democracy and to charge us with running away from it and with destroying it and to say that we are creating chaos as a consequence.

With regard to the trade union intervention in this proportional representation business, granted they have massive funds, granted they will institute a tremendous campaign by advertisement—they have the money and they will do it—but I hope they will not do what they did in 1959——

Comment on this

The £1 million building.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

——when, at the last moment, they started a campaign of terror and lies around the city of Dublin, in every bus depot and milk depot and in every CIE railway station where men were working. There were whispers and leaflets that if the proposal to abolish proportional representation was carried those men would be out of work and they would never get a job again.

Comment on this

It is news to me.

Comment on this

You organised it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There were 30,000 votes cast that time in Dublin city that defeated the proposal to abolish proportional representation and it was due to that last-minute intervention of the leaflet campaign——

Comment on this

What leaflet?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

——48 hours before the poll. Inquire about that. It is reminiscent of what happened in 1937 when the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party mounted the most scandalous campaign in Irish political history against the enactment of the Irish Republican Constitution—the two combined. There was no——

Comment on this

It was not Republican then.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Are you back, too? Conduct yourself until I come to you.

Comment on this

It was and is—and it was brought in.

Comment on this

Senator Ó Maoláin has forgotten the meaning of the word "republican".

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Let Senator Sheehy Skeffington keep quiet until I come to him.

Comment on this

It was enacted in spite of you.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am not unmindful of Mao and these Chinese Communists you are sponsoring in Trinity. Mark you, they are not Russian Communists: they are Chinese Communists.

Comment on this

Ó Mao-láin: "lán" means "full" and Mao is Mao.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

As I was about to say before I was interrupted, Senator Dooge also had a few nice things to say. One thing that tickled me, however, was that, all through his speech, he refused to describe the proposed system, as other Fine Gael and Labour speakers described it, as the "straight vote". Every time he used the expression "relative majority system". He was determined that under no circumstances would he slip into the expression "straight vote". I was making a bet with myself that, in the course of his speech, which took two hours and 15 minutes, he would at some time slip up and say "straight vote" but he did not. I compliment him on not saying those two words "straight vote".

Comment on this

It is not a straight vote.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely it is nonsense to refuse to describe it in the way in which it will officially be described?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

On the ballot paper stimulated by you people.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Dooge had a little story, like Senator Murphy, about seats safe for the Labour Party no matter how unpopular they became—this was England: in other words, that they could not be defeated. Once they got a hold on a seat, the argument was that they could not be defeated. Surely Senator Dooge and the other Senators who swallowed that bit of gospel must be aware of what happened at recent by-elections in Scotland and Wales? Let us start with the two sensational victories by the Scottish and Welsh Nationalists. In Wales, the British Labour Party majority of 16,000 was turned into a Nationalist win of 18,000 and in Scotland the Labour Party majority was turned into a very fine Scottish Nationalist majority. Then a series of by-elections took place in Labour Party strongholds and, one by one, the Tories won them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Not all.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

To say there is such a thing as a safe seat for all time under the straight vote system is nonsense. There is no such thing as a safe-seat for all time. There may be a safe seat for a little while but there is no such thing as a safe seat. You can be defeated in a safe seat just the same as in the other——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

When was the last time the Opposition in Britain was reduced to below 24 per cent?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator will not enter into an argument with the master satistician. Let Senator FitzGerald mind his statistics and not interrupt me. Senator Dooge also agreed with the Minister that it was not possible to predict the result of any general election. He said that the results of local elections are not an infallible guide. But he proceeded forthwith to predict that Fianna Fáil on the basis of whatever calculations he made were going to get 98 seats. Senator Murphy was going to give us 90 to 100 seats. Well, it was all grist to the mill but somehow or other I do not agree with those predictions.

Comment on this

Senator O'Kennedy gave you 85.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

All grist to the mill. I am quite satisfied. Now we come to the new expert on betting and the totalisator. The way he is using his newly-found ill-gotten gains shocked me—these accumulators and doubles and cross doubles had me mesmerised the other night. Senator Sheehy Skeffington was so bad on this occasion that I am not going to devote very much time to him. I have to have regard to the possibility of my blood pressure increasing. He referred to the tribunal of the people and asked why did we refuse to accept their verdict. We did, of course, accept the verdict but verdicts are always open to change in matters submitted to the electorate. If the electorate like to change their government they get the opportunity every four or five years and they can throw out one government and put in another.

If the electorate feel that they want a different system of electing that government surely they are entitled to get it as they are the highest tribunal in the land? I do not see any reason why we should be ashamed of giving them the opportunity of doing this. Senator Sheehy Skeffington being an outsider like Senator Quinlan, a hurler on the ditch, was talking about the Party bosses. Senator Quinlan said that the Party bosses will dictate who is going to be a TD. If Senator Quinlan had the slightest idea of what goes on in a Party he would know that the Party bosses are very circumspect about trying to dictate anything of that nature to a country or even to a city convention. They would want to have very good insurance policies payable on death if they tried it out. I cannot stand these non-politicals like Senator Quinlan who presided at the meeting addressed by the ex-leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Dillon, at University College, Cork, which is soon to be a separate and independent university, and who has not got the guts to join the Fine Gael Party but pontificates——

Comment on this

It was a nonpolitical meeting and it was addressed the following week by the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Sit down. I have no time for people like Senator Quinlan who can see wrong in everything, who can see the faults in all political Parties and who can correct all the faults at a distance but has not the moral guts to go into a Party and be subjected to discipline, have his views examined and if unpalatable have them rejected and accept that rejection like a man. He is an expert on everything, he knows a little about everything and my summing up of him is that while he is a very estimable gentleman in his profession no doubt, has a high education and plenty of ability and is an eminent scientist, as a politician he is tripe, a dud and knows about it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He gets elected.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He should keep off subjects about which he is abysmally ignorant. Senator Sheehy Skeffington said that Fianna Fáil were a disastrous failure——

Comment on this

I was quoting Mr. de Valera. Those are his words.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

About what?

Comment on this

The failure radically to alter the whole system of credit finance, distribution and production.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

No, your comment was that Fianna Fáil were a disastrous failure. We will see it on the record. Why do you run away from it? The Senator has more intelligence politically than Senator Quinlan but he has the "Thoughts of Mao" in his pocket——

Comment on this

I was quoting the thoughts of Mr. de Valera: "If we shirk any item... we shall have failed in our duty and failed cruelly and disastrously."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Irish Times is not going to print that stuff for you. Senator Sheehy Skeffington said that the first Coalition did a lot of good and that they worked loyally together. Do not believe anybody on this side of the House about how they worked loyally together but go to my most estimable friend, James Larkin, and read what he said about working with that Coalition. Read what he said about how they worked so loyally together and then come back with your sackcloth and ashes and tell me the truth. I am afraid Senator Sheehy Skeffington would do better at betting than dealing with political Parties. He is not so hot on that subject. Senator Stanford also was very upset about the idea that we were going to consult the people in such a short-time. Why are all the university people so worried about consulting the people? Is it because this magnificent merger is going to bring them all together? I should love to hear some of the conversations that are going on in the universities about the merger. Senator O'Sullivan had something to say about how the electorate have shown diminishing support for Fianna Fáil and I have dealt with that matter.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What about me?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not worry, I have a four gallon mug for you.

Comment on this

Nobody knows what the Senator said.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Quinlan said that the people were highly critical of our Parliamentary institutions and suspected that they were not working properly. He wound up on that magnificent anarchic note which was worthy of Comrade Danny the Red in Paris and he said that if Parnell came back he would find nothing changed. Imagine that from Senator Patrick F. Quinlan.

Comment on this

In the Parliament.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely that rules him out from all serious consideration. The Senator had to get in a few jibes about the North of Ireland system of voting and the English system of voting. I was shocked to find last week, or the week before, when the Minister for Agriculture had a Wool Bill here, that Senator Quinlan was loud and long in his admiration of the way they did things in the Six Counties and in Britain. We could not do anything right, but up there and over there everything was perfect and the Wool Bill they had up there and over there was the cat's pyjamas. But we here were so ignorant we could do nothing right. These professors with inferiority complexes make me sick.

Comment on this

The Senator does not understand the independent approach.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I will put Fidel Castro on to the Senator, if he is not careful. The Senator used to have a great admiration for him at one time, but he has changed his tune a bit.

Comment on this

Admiration for Castro? The Senator is really confused now.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I forgot the most relevant part when I was discussing history with Senator O'Quigley. I understand now why Fine Gael do not like referenda and why they are running away from this one. I forgot there was a provision for a referendum in the old Free State Constitution. Some poor chaps, who took the thing seriously, started going around the country collecting signatures to present to the Ceann Comhairle of Dáil Éireann to have a referendum on whether the elected representatives of the Irish people should be obliged to swear an oath of allegiance to George V, his heirs and successors, and the Cumann na nGaedheal Government removed the referendum provision by an Act passed overnight in the Dáil and all our bundle of signatures was of no use. That is a historical fact with regard to that Constitution. When there was a chance of a referendum doing any good, Cumann na nGaedheal took it out of the Constitution rather than let the people pronounce. We do not do that sort of thing.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

You cannot.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We go to the people at every opportunity to ask them whether they want us and, the day they say they do not, we will bow out.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The BGA election, for instance.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What was wrong with that? It was the straight vote. A group of people were linked up in a combination. I suspect some of the Fine Gael people suffered equally but, whoever did, it was a straight vote.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Two left out of 60 as an opposition. Is that what the Senator wants in the Dáil?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I am not worried about the beet growers election.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Faith, Martin Corry is.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Martin is well able to worry. The main thing is that this system of voting which we have here is a tribal system. We want to substitute it with the honest man's system of election, the decent, peaceful citizen's way of electing a Member of Parliament, in a single-seat constituency of reasonable size, where that Member of Parliament will know his constituents and be able to give them proper service. We want to ensure the people in remote parts are not hijacked out of their right of representation in the Dáil by any judgment given on a previous Bill some years ago. We want to make certain that, under this tolerance provision, there will be representation for remote parts of the country and I cannot see any reason why Fine Gael and Labour should waste so much time discussing trivialities. If they have any concrete proposition to put up, well and good.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I put a proposition to the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The sooner they make up their minds to allow us to get the Bill through, get it signed by the President, let the regulations be made, the order circulated, the voters brought to the polls and the verdict given, the sooner we will all be peaceful, happy and content for Christmas.

Comment on this

This Bill transcends both Party and person. Ireland, as a nation, is not just the people of the present day. It derives its traditions from men who are long dead. Part of the Irish nation lies in the traditions derived from such men as Parnell, Daniel O'Connell, the men of '98, Wolfe Tone, the men of 1916, and so on. Just as the nation is not delimited by the present generation and includes the past, so also we of today must look beyond the present and provide for the future.

It seems to me that this Bill can have serious and important repercussions on the future. There may be a difference of opinion as to which course should be adopted, but there can be no doubt about its importance. The fact that a referendum was held nine years ago is no reason why the matter should not again be submitted to the people because, since then, the views of the people may have changed. No sensible person would suggest that a government should not submit its policy to the people, or submit themselves and their Party to the people, and to the people's decision after very much shorter periods.

I think, therefore, that it is most regrettable that the opposition to this Bill is to a great extent based on what seemed to me to be pro-Party arguments: what will it do to this Party and what will it do to that Party? I believe these arguments are completely irrelevant. It is most regrettable that the issue cannot be discussed on its merits instead of suggesting that the Government has introduced it to make a majority safe for themselves. I have no doubt that, when this Bill was introduced some nine years ago, the very same arguments were advanced. No doubt it was urged then that because the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party would be leaving the Party—he was going up for election as President— the Party would dissolve without his leadership. The straight vote was, therefore, being introduced to hold the Party together and keep it in power. The very same arguments are being advanced today.

Since then, in all the interim, the Fianna Fáil Party has remained in power. I have grave doubts whether that would have been possible under a system of straight voting. Possibly it would. It might, therefore, have been a benefit to the country or it might have been a loss to the country that the straight vote system was beaten then. That is a matter of opinion according to which political Party one believes in but I do feel that the matter should be considered fairly, objectively and reasonably because it is a most important matter.

I have heard democracy and democratic principles defined during the last few days with completely conflicting meanings. It is just like the word "love": you can attach almost any meaning you like to it. You can actually prostitute the word. It does seem to me that in some of the meanings given to democracy in the last few days it has been practically prostituted. Democracy, for each speaker, was something he was in favour of and something the other Party were against but democracy, of course, has a very strict scientific meaning.

Aristotle, the Greek philosopher of old, was, I think, the first person who gave colour to the idea. He contended that there was something fundamentally equal in all human beings. Christianity gave, so to speak, flesh and blood to that abstract idea. Democracy, then, began to mean that all men had a fundamental equality, a fundamental common dignity, because all men were created to the image and likeness of their Creator; all men had a common right to happiness; all men had a common right to equal opportunity. Democracy, like every other form of society, is something that grows, that expands. It is also something that could get sickly and could die.

It is, in my view, going to have a very important bearing on whether democracy in this country will grow and will expand or whether it will get sickly and lose its vitality, whether there is the passage or the rejection of the type of vote, whether the straight vote or proportional representation. No one, I am sure, would deny that democracy, to a greater or lesser extent, has existed in England for many generations. England is treated as the oldest of the democracies but its meaning has been changing down through the years because democracy has been expanding and improving. Today it means that every human being, no matter what his colour, no matter what he works at, no matter what his beliefs, has a fundamental human dignity and if he lives in a democratic State, is entitled to equal opportunity and an equal chance of of happiness and an equal chance of advancing himself.

Rousseau said that democracy was fit only for the angels because the ideal was too high; it was man's human attempt to attain the Divine. I do feel that in the free world and in this nation if it is to progress and to advance, it is most important that democracy in its true sense should get every opportunity of growing and being vital. The issue for us, therefore, is whether democracy as truly understood will grow and develop better under a straight vote and single-seat constituency or will grow and develop better under proportional representation.

In the old days in England during the Whigs and Tories, we had democracy, but in those days no one was entitled to sit in Parliament except the landed proprietors. Yet, England was probably one of the most liberal countries in Europe, if not in the world for many centuries, but it was only in 1862, by the Reform Act, that the middle classes got a vote for the first time in England. It was some 20 years later when votes were given to the working classes and almost 20 years later again when votes were given to all male members of the population other than paupers, criminals and lunatics. Down to 1919, both in this country and in England, 50 per cent of the population were disenfranchised; as women had no vote whatsoever. So voting in itself, while it is a sign of democracy, is not an essential of democracy.

I heard people speak here of majorities as if there was a divine right of majorities as the old Stuart kings claimed to have a divine right of kings. Of course, majorities can go wrong as anybody else can. We were informed here of what was done in Germany, of what was done in Italy. I have no doubt whatsoever that for very many years, certainly for some years prior to 1939, Hitler would have got more than 50 per cent of the votes in Italy, but you still would not have had democracy either in Germany or in Italy.

Some of the most important political functionaries in any State are not elected at all. There are no Members of this Parliament other than the Ministers who have a more important bearing on the State and who represent the State more intimately than our ambassadors but they are not elected. Our judges also perform a very important political function but they are not elected. In some countries they are. Even where they are elected, it is found that the system of appointment is far more satisfactory. Our juries, if we come before them in a civil action, can decide whether we get property, whether we do without property. If we come before them in a criminal action, they can decide whether we are to be allowed our liberty or are to be deprived of our liberty. They perform a most important political function but they are not elected.

I, therefore, want to make the point clear once and for all that while voting may be an important thing, it is not a fundamental principle of democracy; even though it is in many cases a sign of democracy. So all this argument about a Government being elected without a 50 per cent majority of the people has absolutely nothing whatsoever to say to democracy. Democracy is an ideal that lives in the hearts and souls of the people and unless the people themselves are educated to discipline themselves, to live with their fellow men, to make sacrifices for their fellow men, to be satisfied with their share, or their fair share, of the public cake you can never have a democracy.

But the Government of a country, as the trustees for the people of the country, can guide and help democracy. They can create the institutions on which it can grow and develop and become vital and robust and strong. The Government of a country must have, therefore, so to speak, their fingers on the pulse of the people on broad issues. Most of the political questions and most of the political principles are rather foreign to many people. They are not concerned with the details of politics except in so far as they can affect them personally. Therefore, if democracy is to work at all, it must work on a representative basis, and parliamentary democracy on a representative basis is the only effective way in which democracy can be successful. But a parliamentary representative must be something more than a mere delegate.

The strange feature about proportional representation is that it was introduced because of the fear of clear majorities, the direct opposite of what has been said here during all these days. Thomas Hare was the architect of PR in Britain. His idea was taken up by the political philosopher, John Stuart Mill. Mill was a complete individualist. He had a grave distrust of political Parties and a still graver distrust of majorities, and when the franchise was extended to the ordinary common people in England, he felt that once a majority got into power, even for a limited period, they would prove to be a tyranny on the minority, and it was for that reason that he advocated PR.

PR is not something which grew naturally in the hearts and the feelings of men. It is something devised in the brains of certain mathematicians like Hare and of political philosophers like Mill. It was not, therefore, a natural growth. I know of no two sciences which merge so badly as the science of mathematics and political science.

Comment on this

What about President de Valera?

Comment on this

Political science is something which deals with the psychology of the people, that considers people as they are, how they should be at their best, how their may be at their worst. It has to take into account their feelings, their reactions, their traditions, their hopes, their ambitions. Mathematics, on the other hand, is an abstract science which deals with ciphers, figures, calculations, and you might as well endeavour to measure colour by weight as to measure political science by mathematics.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There is no such thing as psephology, then?

Comment on this

I bow to the wisdom of my friends.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You had better ask the Irish Times leader writer.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am an amateur psephologist. The Senator did not know that?

Comment on this

This principle was first put into practice for the most part following the 1914-18 war and I must say I was surprised that Senator FitzGerald, who knows so much about —what is the word? —psephology should be the one to tell us it has been accepted and was a success in most European countries.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What had been?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I never said anything of the kind. It does not exist in any other country in Western Europe. What I said was that the spot vote, the first past the post principle in single-seat constituencies, has proved unworkable in any country in Europe except Britain.

Comment on this

Am I to assume the Senator did not say that PR, in some form or another, was the system of election adopted in most of the countries of Western Europe?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In none of them.

Comment on this

He does not know what he is saying.

Comment on this

Let me tell the House that PR was tried and failed in the following countries: Italy, Germany, Austria, Poland, Bulgaria, Greece, Yugoslavia, Lithuania, Estonia, Latvia, Czechoslovakia, Rumania.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would the Senator say what he means by PR? In the other House it became clear——

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

Will Senator FitzGerald restrict himself to one speech on the Second Stage?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I was asking a question, which it has been the practice to allow.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator is not entitled to ask questions in the middle of a debate. I do not know if it comes into psephology but it certainly comes into Standing Orders.

Comment on this

In seven countries the break-down of democracy was caused by the use of PR.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was not.

Comment on this

He cannot take it.

Comment on this

Those seven countries were Italy, Germany, Austria, Poland, Bulgaria, Greece and Yugoslavia and the true cause of the break-down of democracy in those countries was the adoption of PR.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They never had the system.

Comment on this

That is a very simplified view of European history.

Comment on this

It is a factual one. Ireland appears to be one of the first countries where PR did not cause a collapse of democracy, but let me say, without hurting the feelings of any Party in the House, that I believe future historians will allege that democracy in this country came very near to the point of collapse twice in the history of the State, in 1932 and in 1937, and the fundamental cause then, too, in this country was the use of PR. Democracy is not something we can take for granted. It is not something we can leave to thrive on its own. It is a rather delicate growth which, once lost, can never be recovered, particularly in these days of mass media and all the other technologies which tyranny can control.

One of the big defects of PR is that it not only represents minorities but it creates minorities and creates minorities outside the political Parties. It is therefore inimical to democracy because the only basis on which democracy can flourish is through political Parties. I define a political Party as a Party who have as its main aim the common good, rather than the good of a narrow section of the community. If any Party confine their programme to the good of a certain section of the community, that is a pressure group and is not a political Party in the true sense. Proportional representation has caused trouble in so many countries because it gives rise to pressure groups, so that in Italy they came to the conclusion that there was no further point in having political Parties and that what they should have was economic groups. They said they would avoid political Parties altogether. That was the cause of the corporate State in Italy which provided the cloak for totalitarian despotism in Italy.

We must not forget that at the time of the polls the people elect not only representatives but also a Government. You cannot treat the two matters not only as distinct but as conflicting. You cannot, on the one hand, elect a Government to guide and direct the people and, on the other hand, elect representatives to frustrate the Government, to stop them, to break them and to prevent them. It is here I see the first big difference between proportional representation and the direct vote.

In a direct vote, for the most part it is impossible to get elected unless you are a political Party as distinct from a pressure group. Not only must the Party be a political Party in the true sense of the word, but it must in advance let the general public know what are its principles and what is its policy for the common good. Let there be two, three or four Parties—I do not care how many—under a direct vote what happens then is that the general public decide which of the policies submitted to them is the most attractive and adopt that policy.

The Party with that policy are going to be the Government for the next three or four years. They are going to be a true political Party in the best sense, not in the sense that has been spoken of here for the past few days, where we have been denigrating politicians and one another, as if there were something shameful and disgraceful in being a member of a political Party, and implying motives of distrust and dishonesty to everyone else. It was most humiliating to listen to some of the speeches made. I find it hard to know why some people must believe that everybody who is not of their political view is a rogue, is selfish and is dishonest.

Surely that is a bad headline for the general public? I can assure the people who say and think those things that, with complete honesty, most of the people about whom they say them could answer with absolute truth: "I am just a man. I am just like you. I have done some things I never should, perhaps like you, but, thank the Lord, I have sense to see the rest of men with charity. They are good enough, as good as me—just men like you." I feel that one thing besides the direct vote that is going to be essential in the Parliament of this country if democracy is to grow and flourish is that members of opposite political Parties should try to exercise towards each other a little Christian charity and not dishonestly create an atmosphere of distrust of Members of Parliament and of parliamentary institutions.

Another cause of the downfall of democracies where PR is adopted has been the coalitions of various Parties. Coalitions are invariably dishonest. I have no hesitation in saying this. When Parties go to the polls, they stress the differences between their policies and everybody else's policy. Thereby they hope to get votes. Then, when they are elected, there is no Party able to take over Government, no Party able to govern the country. When the general public have no further voice in the matter, these Parties go behind closed doors and decide between themselves what principles each Party will renege and what promises each Party will forget. The general public can no longer do anything whatever about it. Therefore, a Coalition Government, by and large, is a fraud on the general public. It does not represent the common interest. If there is any negation of democracy in its true sense, it is a negation of democracy.

I see nothing wrong whatever if people who get only 40 per cent of the votes of the general public become the Government of the country, unless some other Party have a greater percentage. These people put before the electorate a policy on a broad basis. They must understand the feelings of the people and the temperament of the people. If their policy is not a success, the people can throw them out the next time. That is a far cry from the fraud on the general public created by coalitions.

We have heard suggestions here that it would be a great thing if in the next general election no Party got more than 66 seats. Fifty per cent of the seats is 77 seats. What would then happen? If the largest Party got only 66 seats in the next election, I do not care what Party it is, a Government could not be formed other than a Coalition Government, which, as I said, would be a deliberate fraud. Otherwise, that Party of 66 would move into Government, appoint their Ministers, endeavour to carry out their policy, and at any time at the whim of any four or five Independents—who represent nothing or nobody but themselves, or who perhaps represent a pressure party—that Government could be thrown out of office. The whole common good of the country and the people at large would be forgotten.

Proportional representation is something that breeds greed, discontent and factions in the public. That is fundamental and inherent in it. It breeds greed and discontent above all in those people who have less claim on the public purse and on the national cake. Your cottage tenants because they are poor cannot form a pressure party. Your old age pensioners may be large in number, but they cannot form a pressure group or pressure party. Your pressure party will be formed by well-to-do, well-organised sections of the community who already, perhaps, enjoy more than their fair share of the national cake. They can hold any Government up to ransom.

If we would just once realise that the average politician in this House is a fundamentally decent man, that fundamentally he is at least as good as the average cross-section of the country— and in most cases very much better, because people do not elect a political Party from the worst types in the community. In most cases a Member of our Parliament of any Party is dedicated and hardworking. If the Taoiseach appoints him a Minister, he is usually unselfish and dedicated to his cause and his work. Surely, if such a political Party have put their policy before the people and that has been accepted, nothing can go very far wrong—I do not care what Party is concerned. Such a Government can display imagination. At present most people complain that there is a dead centre of mediocrity in the country, with no progress, no ideas, no imagination. Surely, it is stultifying to imagination and progress if you hamstring a Government at every attempt. Give them a chance, whatever Party it is. Let them try their ideas; experiment, if you will. They cannot go far wrong in three or four years. If their ideas do not prove successful, fling them out. Quite a small swing in votes will be sufficient to do that and put another political Party into power.

You cannot be in Opposition under a direct vote unless you have a definite policy because you must submit it in advance to the people and the people vote on policy rather than personality. They vote for something rather than against something. PR is completely negative: under PR they do not vote for a Government or for a Party; they really vote against it. In 19 cases out of 20, that is how votes are cast.

Another grave danger, if the Government are not strong, is that the Taoiseach has not a completely free hand in the appointement of Ministers. It is all very well to say that Ministers of a Government have joint and several responsibilities but each man must have his own personal pride and responsibility and the country needs leadership. A Government must suggest things. It is completely degrading in this House that we should be told that the Government have gone beyond their duty because they suggest to the people that now, after nine years, the people should have an opportunity of deciding whether, in their view, it is more advantageous to the country, whether it will help to expand the economy, help democracy and help to have new ideas if the people get an opportunity of voting on the electoral system. To suggest that a Government cannot have that amount of initiative is completely degrading because it assumes that the representatives in Parliament are merely delegates, that the Government are composed merely of delegates. The Government are there as leaders to inspire, suggest and direct, and if the people want it otherwise, they can have it.

On the question of whether and Member of Parliament is a delegate or a representative, I read some weeks ago a speech by Deputy Cosgrave at, I think, a dinner or celebration for him. I admired him for his sentiments; he showed himself a true parliamentarian. His speech was a quotation from the speech of Edmund Burke after the Bristol election where he sets out how proud and happy he was to be the representative of the people and points out that being a representative was very different from being a mere delegate. Deputy Cosgrave's speech struck a chord in my memory when I read it and I looked up the speeches of Edmund Burke and this is it, so far as I can recollect:

It ought to be the happiness and glory of a representative to live in the strictest union, the closest correspondence and the most unreserved communication with his constituents. Their wishes ought to have great weight with him, their opinion high respect; their business his unremitting attention. It is his duty to sacrifice his repose, his pleasure, his satisfactions to theirs and above all, ever, and in all cases to prefer their interests to his own. But, his unbiased opinion, his mature judgment, his enlightened conscience he ought not to sacrifice to you, to any man, or to any set of men living. These he does not derive from your pleasure; no, nor from the law and the Constitution. They are a trust from Providence for the abuse of which he is deeply answerable.

That is an expression one can expect, as a rule, only under the direct vote, not the sort of expression of one elected to Parliament as a member of a pressure group. I admire Deputy Cosgrave for it. He showed the courage of his convictions in thus expressing his views. Only under a straight vote system can parliamentarians with the sentiments of Burke hope to exist. Therefore, I feel absolutely and unreservedly committed to supporting any steps that may be taken for the introduction of the straight vote, single-member constituency because I feel that otherwise I would be false to my own conscience. That I believe it to be essential for the progress of true democracy is the only reason prompting me to do so. PR frustrates government, mitigates or removes imagination and stultifies opposition.

I see nothing wrong or strange in the situation that Senator Garret FitzGerald points out, of an Opposition being sometimes considerably reduced or reduced much more substantially than it would be otherwise. May I indicate to Senator FitzGerald that what is more important than the quantity of the Opposition is its quality? Under proportional representation you will not get an Opposition of the proper quality because at no time have they to submit their policy to the test of public opinion in the assurance that if it be accepted they must put it into practice.

Comment on this

I think that every argument possible for and against the two Amendments have been made, and I do not intend to keep the House very long at this late hour. However, there is one argument that deserves repetition, that is, that it is the duty of a Government to do the right thing at the right point in time. Carlyle once said that a word spoken in season may be the matter of ages, and indeed the right thing done by a Government at the right time is certainly the most important thing in its history. I believe this point in time has come to get rid of PR. All the other speakers on this side of the House have adequately proved why this should be done.

The main reason is, as Senator Nash has said, that if we do not get rid of PR, the only alternative facing the people is a Coalition Government, if they ever wish to change horses. We all know the horrors and the disasters of coalitions not only in our own country but in other countries. I certainly do not wish to go into the disasters of this type of government, but that is the one and only reason that has motivated our Taoiseach, our Minister and our Government to put this issue before the people once again. As I said, if there is to be a change of Government we do not mind if it is a Fine Gael Government or a Labour Government, but we do not want to inflict a Coalition Government on the people of Ireland ever again or to be responsible for leaving a system of election in this country which would produce it.

When the Fianna Fáil Government formulated our wonderful Constitution, against which the two Parties opposite fought tooth and nail, they enshrined in it provision for a referendum, and for that we should be very grateful to the Fianna Fáil Party. We know, and it has gone down in history, that even though Fine Gael and Labour knew this was an ideal Constitution, they did everything humanly possible to defeat it, and the only reason they worked so hard to defeat it was that it was introduced by Fianna Fáil.

The very same kind of opposition is taking place this time against these two Amendments. The only reason they have for opposing the two Amendments is that they have been brought in by the Fianna Fáil Government. They are not a bit concerned whether it is good or bad for the country. Their one and only aim is to defeat Fianna Fáil in the referendum. Those are the lowest motives any Opposition Party could have.

Several other points have been raised already, but I think I should refer to the tolerance. Senator Ryan has amply proved with facts and figures that the value of a country vote is by no means equal to that of a city vote. We believe we should have a representative on the number of electors in an area and not on the size of the population. In our cities and urban areas we have not a true representation at all. We want the rural vote to have at least the same value as the city vote, which it has not today. We also want our county boundaries to be kept intact, if possible.

I do not like the many suggestions that under the straight vote there would be a better type of Deputy. It would be more true to say there would be more honesty in our Deputies. They would not be claiming to get for our people grants and other things to which they are entitled and which they would get if the Deputies were never there. I do not know about securing a better type of Deputy, but I do believe there would be more honesty.

There were many references to the value of votes, to A being equal to B plus C, and that has already been ably explained. If the second preference votes of one section are counted, the second preference votes of everybody else deserve to get the same value. Backbencher has said we have too many hind-tit Deputies in every Party, and I thoroughly agree with him. Any man would surely prefer to be elected on his own merits in a small area than to go riding in on the tail of somebody else. There is one thing which has not been quoted here in this House. It is an objective opinion by Father O'Connor, Lecturer on Politics in UCD. This was an article which was in the Irish Press, and it looks as if the Opposition Deputies here have not read that article. He said:

Let us suppose that Fianna Fáil gets 120 seats in the next election. This would simply mean that Fianna Fáil policy appealed to the people in the constituencies and that they wanted it. This is what politics is about. Fianna Fáil is not a homogeneous Party after all, and if they happen to get a majority of Deputies, there will be different opinions emerging within the Party and helping to shape policy. These different views may not emerge under the Party Whip inside the Dáil but they will appear in terms of ironing out policy in the Party rooms. If Fianna Fáil can maintain unity in this sort of monolithic structure, this will be because the leadership is presenting a policy which finds a response among the local representatives. If Fianna Fáil wins more seats and more power, then it speaks very poorly for the other two Parties. Personally I have more faith in their capacity to meet the challenge.

I think that explains, as Senator Ó Maoláin said, the fear and trembling of the two parties in the Opposition, and that is the reason they want to cling on to PR. When history comes to be written, whether we win or lose this referendum, we will go down to future generations as having done the right thing at the right time, and I know history will prove me right.

Comment on this

I was intrigued last week when Senator Yeats was speaking, because I believe Senator Yeats, like myself, is a man of simple political faith.

Comment on this

Not perhaps the same faith.

Comment on this

No. His simple faith is very obvious, and I presume that mine is also obvious. Mine can be simply expressed. I believe that everything Fianna Fáil say is intended to deceive, and everything they do is intended to better themselves. I am fortified and buttressed in that simple belief by profound conviction that I am right. As I said, the other evening I was intrigued to hear a man who has the same simple faith as mine quoting Herbert Morrison away back in 1924 in the House of Commons. I asked myself what was the Senator's preoccupation with a dead man.

Comment on this

The truth lives on.

Comment on this

That is quite true, as I intend to show the Senator, but I wondered to myself why should the Senator quote a man who as he said last Thursday was no friend of Ireland. The Senator is a simple politician like myself and I take that to mean that he was an enemy of Ireland. Yet I found Senator Yeats quoting him. I decided that I myself would do a little digging into the past too to see why Senator Yeats picked that particular gentleman to quote, and why Senator Yeats should pay so much attention to what an enemy of Ireland had to say.

Comment on this

All our enemies do not tell lies all the time.

Comment on this

I am prepared to concede to the Senator that all our enemies do not tell lies—not all of them. I might not include the Senator, but if he would allow me to make my own speech, I would be much obliged. I wondered why he picked this enemy of Ireland and why he went back so far—almost a lifetime. In spite of my best efforts, I could not find any friend of Ireland around that time, in the same company as Herbert Morrison, who had anything good to say about Ireland. Neither could I find anyone else, friend or enemy of that man in the British Parliament, who had anything good to say about Ireland.

I was very puzzled, but while I was delving into the past—and I freely admit I have not the Senator's capacity for delving—I discovered someone the Senator might also accept as an authority, and as telling the truth about PR, and about what he and his friends call the straight vote. I discovered that a former Leader of the Senator's now Deputy Seán Lemass, is on record in the Official Report of the Dáil debates of 21st March, 1934, at column 1288, Volume 51, as saying:

It is not possible to gerrymander in this country. One reason is because proportional representation operates...

He went on to say:

... so long as you have the principle of proportional representation, it does not matter how you divide the country...

When this attempt to abolish PR has finished and failed, the position will be as it is, but if by any chance—and it is hardly conceivable that the people will allow Fianna Fáil to do away with PR, but since it is being put to the people, and since we cannot know in advance exactly what the people will do, we must concede to the Senator that there is a small chance, a slight chance, that PR will be abolished—it is abolished then Deputy Lemass's Party will seek straight away to alter the constituencies.

Comment on this

No. There will be an independent Commission.

Comment on this

An independent Commission. We have seen so many independent Fianna Fáil commissions.

Comment on this

There will be a High Court judge. The Senator should read the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

Comment on this

The Senator should shut up. He has been at it for three days. Do not be like a budgie all the time. If PR does not exist, Fianna Fáil will attempt to gerrymander the constituencies. Then perhaps Deputy Lemass's Party will see their chance. I presume that since they are coupling the abolition of PR with what, in my opinion, will be an attempt to gerrymander, Deputy Lemass will be an authority whom the Senator and his Party will consult, when they come to gerrymander the constituencies.

I also discovered another friend of the Senator's, indeed, a friend of all the Senator's Party, a man whom Senator Ó Maoláin defended here very strongly tonight and, since he was such a good friend of the Senator's, I should like to quote him. The late Mr. Seán T. O'Kelly, then Deputy O'Kelly, is reported at column 1324, Volume 51, of the Official Report as saying:

There are many ideas as to what is the best form of proportional representation and the best area to select as a constituency. I have taken a great interest in proportional representation. I was a member of a proportional representation society in this country long before the idea was definitely adopted as a guiding principle in elections.

This I presume was long before the British stuffed it down our necks. He went on:

I still stand for proportional representation. I believe in this country it is suited to the needs of the people and I would vote against any Bill that proposed to abolish the system.

That was Mr. S. T. O'Kelly, a man for whom the Senator and his Leader have a great admiration, a man for whom I have a great admiration, believe it or not.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He was entitled to his view.

Comment on this

He was also entitled to admiration.

Comment on this

(Longford): In what year was that said? That is important.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was said in the course of the present century.

Comment on this

1934.

Comment on this

(Longford): That is a long time ago.

Comment on this

It is not as far back as 1924.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is not as far back as 1927 and the Fine Gael advertisement which was referred to earlier.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is not as far back as the 1922 Constitution which was also referred to.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

With less relevance.

Comment on this

I thought you wanted the Minister to get in before 11 o'clock. I am prepared to stay here all night.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I said before 10 o'clock. We do not care now how long you stay.

Comment on this

The Minister was quick to point out that he could not hear someone because of a conversation here. If Senators want to interrupt me, they should address me through the Chair and the Chair will deal with them. Those were the views of the late Mr. S.T. O'Kelly. He was entitled to his views, as Senator Ó Maoláin said. No one will take those views from him.

There was another great friend of the Senator's, I discovered, who had a great admiration for the system of PR also. Mind you, if I bore the Senator and his Party, I think he has to take the blame on his own head. He intrigued me so much with what he had to say about Herbert Morrison that I had to go back to what his old friend said. This old friend was Deputy Éamon de Valera, the then Taoiseach. As reported in Volume 171 of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, column 1959, he is reported as saying:

The system we have we know; the people know it. On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think that we have a good deal to be thankful for in this country; we have to be very grateful that we have had a system of PR here. It gives a certain amount of stability, and on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties. I understood when I was in opposition that this whole principle of PR was being threatened and I was rather anxious here that we would ensure in the Constitution a reasonable basis for PR.

Further, in the same speech, the then Taoiseach said:

I think we get, probably, in this country more than any other country, better balanced results from the system we have. If you take the countries where PR exists you get better balanced results than you get in other countries.

That is the opinion of a responsible man when he was Taoiseach of this country and which they would have defended at one time to the death. Because Mr. Éamon de Valera is beyond criticism in his present position, we can only criticise him as he was then. He has now left active politics and all his friends and his cohorts and the famous rearguard which he had can now say his opinions are worth nothing: I will go that far with them, I had not a great deal of regard for his opinions but, when they are put on record and when we find that the people across the way, who had such a high regard for him, are now acting in disregard of the opinions he expressed, I think we are entitled to remind them of what he said. Further, again, in the same speech, Deputy Éamon de Valera, as he then was, is reported as saying:

I think we get the benefits of PR in reasonably balanced legislation here better than in any other country I have read about or know anything about.

I am sure Senators will state that Mr. Éamon de Valera is knowledgeable: at least he claims to be such.

I have quoted the opinions expressed by Deputy Seán Lemass, the late Deputy. Seán T. O'Kelly and Deputy Éamon de Valera, as he was then. I did a bit of further research into another source and I discovered that a great friend of Senator Yeats, one might say, apart from the fact that he was also an enemy of——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Yeats is an Anglophobe.

Comment on this

I have a note here of what Hermann Goering said on 13th March, 1946, at the Nuremburg trial:

If the German election had been held on the British system the Nazi Party would have won every seat in the Reichstage.

Now, there is the position. We have friends of the Fianna Fáil Party and former Leaders of the Party praising proportional representation and then we have some of their soulmates, perhaps, praising proportional representation also.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Did the Nazi Party not get in through proportional representation?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

Forty-three per cent in a free election. That is all they got.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Do not mind the percentage.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

No. The other side of the House do not know what proportional representation is.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Did Hitler not take over the Reichstage in 1932 as a result of the proportional representation election? Look it up again, boy: the oracle who knows everything.

Comment on this

I thoroughly agree with Mr. Éamon de Valera's judgment here. His knowledge of history at that period could not be disputed. He knew about Germany and Italy, first hand.

Comment on this

Your tribute will be conveyed personally.

Comment on this

It is the first time I have paid a tribute to him. I hope it will not be the last time.

Comment on this

By God, it is. Tell the truth, anyway. Do not be a hypocrite.

Comment on this

Might we have Senator McHugh, without interruption, please?

Comment on this

As reported at column 1953 of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, Volume 232, the Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, is reported as saying that all of these eminent authorities in Western Europe and North America who support the straight vote have done so on the basis that it is the system most likely to produce stable Government. All of those people who support the straight vote in Western Europe and in North America are eminent authorities, according to the Taoiseach. I do not see any analogy at all between the system they have in North America and the system they have in Western Europe. We must remember that the enormous population of those countries makes the position completely different from the position we have here.

If we look at Annex 5 of the Report of the Committee on the Constitution, December, 1967, we can see, straight away, the position obtaining in some of those countries the Taoiseach spoke about. He referred to Canada as one of the countries in North America. On average, each Member of the Lower House there represents 64,000 inhabitants. It takes four representatives in my constituency to represent far fewer people. In Britain, it takes one Member of the Lower House to represent 80,000 people. In Italy, it takes one Member to represent 80,000 persons. In France, there is one representative for 93,000 people. I do not know what the Taoiseach meant when he said that eminent authorities in North America and Western Europe support the straight vote and consider it the system most likely to produce stable Government. One must compare like with like. Take an area in this country where four Members represent, roughly, 80,000 to 84,000 people.

Comment on this

Each of them represent 80,000 people.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was talking about each of the constituencies in those places.

Comment on this

Each of the four Clare Members represents 80,000 people.

Comment on this

He has two colleagues or three. The Taoiseach asks us to accept his proposition but I cannot see the sense of it. Perhaps the Taoiseach knows more about these things than I do: I am prepared to concede him that.

Comment on this

You can say that again, anyhow.

Comment on this

Frankly, however, I cannot see it. The Taoiseach further said, as reported in the same debate, that the people have already given their answer and their verdict. I agree. The people gave their verdict whenever they were consulted and their verdict was quite clear. PR was in the 1922 Constitution and the people accepted that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They never saw it until after the election.

Comment on this

They never saw it: we will accept that. They accepted it in every successive general election. They accepted it in 1937 also. We had a referendum in 1957 and the people accepted the system of PR then. Now we find the Fianna Fáil Party coming in during the middle of a Dáil term, with a majority in both Houses, seeking something for which they never sought a mandate from the people, the abolition of PR. When they were seeking election, they never told the people that if they secured a majority, they would abolish PR. Now they steamroll it through. That is exactly what is happening. They want to give their faithful supporters an opportunity of saying "yes" again and once again we will hear the slogan "Vote yes" only on this occasion they will be asked to vote "yes" twice. They believe they can bulldoze this across the people as they bulldozed it through the Dáil and as they are bulldozing it through this House because if we were talking until Doomsday, not one comma in these Bills would be altered. They are enabled to do it because they have a majority granted by providence.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They got it with 47½ per cent of the votes.

Comment on this

Then we hear talk about coalitions and intrigues and decisions being made without consulting the people and talk about coalitions or inter-Party Governments being formed without the people being consulted. The people were asked to vote for candidates and those elected were sent in here as representatives and not as delegates, as Senator Nash said. They decided to form a Coalition Government and they were quite entitled to do so. I am sorry that Senator Nash has left the House. He spoke about people in coalitions masquerading under different guises, as Labour and supporting Fine Gael or masquerading as Independents and supporting Fine Gael. When he said that he stirred my memory. I have a clear recollection of people now in Fianna Fáil who were masquerading as Independents in one area with one card and as Fianna Fáil cumann members in another area with another card. If the Senator were here, that might stir his recollection also.

I thought Senator Nash spoke rather well and he gave the impression to anybody who had not heard him before that he was sincere because he spoke very sincerely. He talked about the dangers of PR and about the results which sprang from it. He spoke about those dishonest coalition governments, those terrible people who come together as representatives of the people and decide for themselves what they should do. Any reasonable person would prefer a Deputy who after being elected says openly that he will support any form of government, let it be inter-Party, coalition or minority government, who says that this is what he is going to do as long as he is the representative of the people. He is entitled to do that. We saw how Senator Nash shuddered when he referred to the terrible coalitionists and he gave the impression that he was glad there were seats between him and us but I wonder did he hear the cock crowing behind him in an empty seat.

Comment on this
A Senator

What?

Comment on this

It will come to you some time. We can look around and see some of the people who coalesced with Fianna Fáil and who did not tell the people who elected them that they were going to do that and who afterwards were paid for their work by being returned to this House as the Taoiseach's nominees. We are entitled to say that we disbelieve the people who talk about coalition intrigue with this sanctimonious outlook. Once the representatives of the people are elected, they are perfectly entitled to decide for themselves what they will opt for and as long as they retain the confidence of the people, they are entitled to act in that fashion but the people who acted as Mr. Leneghan acted and a few more Independents and went for a ride on the Fianna Fáil tiger, we know what——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now, now, that is my story.

Comment on this

I know it is but I thought it was too nice a turn of phrase to miss. Certainly he has wound up on something, whether it is a tiger or not. I would say that he and people like him will think again before they go for a ride on that particular tiger. Proportional representation has been objected to on so many grounds and so many arguments have been advanced against it that it is almost impossible to remember every one of them. Some of them were not even worth writing down. One or two were so fatuous that they are not worth rebutting.

One objection voiced was the long counts. Politically, I have a fairly long memory and I only remember two long counts in one general election in two constituencies. Apparently, because there were two long counts in two constituencies, the whole system must now be thrown overboard. Everything must be scrapped because a couple of people were inconvenienced and because the Taoiseach did not know for a little while whether or not he would have a majority. The whole system must now be scrapped to satisfy the people who think it takes too long to count the votes.

Comment on this

The computer will revolutionise that.

Comment on this

It takes three weeks to fight a general election and one whole day to cast the votes. There is no talk about the long delay in fighting the election. Why not have voting on two successive days? That should speed up the counting. It should satisfy those who advance fatuous arguments for abolishing proportional representation. Of course, the real reason for the proposed abolition is not the long count; the real reason is the anxiety of Fianna Fáil to ensure that Fianna Fáil will remain in office as the Government. Assuming we go over to the straight vote and the single-seat constituency—it is a foolish assumption—we shall then have here the type of thing to which Senator Quinlan referred yesterday, the safe seat, the seat the Party in power nurse for the faithful few, and no contest. It is not often one sees such simple faith. People have a right to vote and the risk involved in having safe seats is, to me, the paramount reason why there should be no such thing as the single-seat constituency. There are too many safe seats in Northern Ireland. There are quite a number of safe seats across the water, though that does not concern us.

I have here an interesting editorial which appeared in Irish News on 2nd February last. This paper could not be described as a friend of the Government in the North of Ireland. It is the Nationalist paper, the paper the members of Fianna Fáil would carry in their pockets. The editorial says:

Fianna Fáil cannot point to any volume of public opinion that the 1959 decision should be reconsidered. The abolition of proportional representation in favour of the British electoral system will certainly benefit Fianna Fáil and make serious inroads in the present strength in Dáil Éireann of Fine Gael and Labour. Leinster House will then be offered the nearest approach to a one-Party system of government, such as we have at Stormont, as it is possible to achieve.

The Fianna Fáil arguments in favour of the straight vote with single-seat constituencies and the non-transferable vote, so far, have been singularly unconvincing. Apart from the absence of public demand for any change, the PR system, so often lauded by Mr. de Valera when he led the Party, can hardly be said to have resulted in unstable government from Leinster House.

When we talk about unstable government and look at the situation here and the type of Government we have had since 1922, then, anyone who says we have had unstable government is talking through his hat. We have had only two Parties producing two Leaders of Governments in Dáil Éireann—Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal and Fine Gael, which is really Cumann na nGaedheal. There have been only two Heads of Government from a Party point of view in the past 40 years and those two Heads represented two Parties, I do not think there is a country in Western Europe with such a long history of stable government, of strong government, and to come along at this stage and say that the straight vote will give us stable government as against unstable government under the PR system is just sheer nonsense.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The leader goes on to say:

If, as Fianna Fáil claims, there are many disabilities in the form of government which PR produces, they must be attached to the party in power, not to the electoral system.

That is the opinion of the Nationalist paper in Northern Ireland. It has no axe to grind.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They are not infallible and the Senator should not quote them as he would the Bible.

Comment on this

The Senator is very funny, but he is not infallible. I do not pretend to be infallible either, but I claim to be pretty accurate in matters political. The editorial concludes:

Mr. Lynch is a forward-looking Taoiseach;

They can say that again——

but if he is offering the people a straight choice between PR and the British electoral formula (which produces governments on a minority vote), he is also seeking to concentrate power, in perpetuity, in the hands of Fianna Fáil. The people will doubtless give him his answer, as they did in 1959.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is a Fine Gael organ.

Comment on this

That is typical Fine Gael; it is what we would expect.

Comment on this

We know what is typical. The Senators on the other side forget that someone who comes from a county like County Clare is quite used to this sort of thing. One gets accustomed to it. Another argument for the single-seat constituency is that there would be less work for civil servants and Ministers. They would not have to write to several Deputies on the one footy matter. They would not have to write to every Deputy in a constituency about an old age pension claim or some land division. The position is that one Deputy in a constituency writes in and, the following week, his colleague in the same Party writes in, and eventually all the Deputies write in, then the Senators, then the county councillors, the town commissioners and, finally, the lowest rank of all, the Fianna Fáil peace commissioners. The argument is that this is a waste of time for civil servants and for Ministers.

Comment on this

There are very few listening tonight.

Comment on this

This is an absolutely crazy argument. Elections are not fought on the basis of going before the people and saying: "If you give us your votes we will make the work of civil servants easy and will ensure that they will not have to write more than one letter to one Deputy on any given subject". It is crazy to come before the House with this kind of silly argument, that it is too difficult for civil servants to keep up with their work. I have no idea what that means. Senator O'Kennedy made an excellent speech, but I heard him talking about writing to five Deputies and five Senators on footling matters and I said to myself that Senator O'Kennedy is slipping; there must be something wrong.

When the Fianna Fáil Party decided that they were going to abolish the system of proportional representation, I am sure they brought all the men of simple faith, all the true blues, together, including Senator Yeats, and had long consultation deep into the night and then evolved this idea that they would appoint a Committee on the Constitution and that then they would attempt to blind the people into believing that this Committee suggested that the Constitution should be amended and that the system of PR should be abolished. This Committee, as everybody knows, made no such report. I am not saying that Fianna Fáil are alleging that they made any such report but I am quite certain that they must have been disappointed, because of the way the Committee was constituted, that they were able to bring out this report.

Comment on this

Did Cumann na nGaedheal try that in 1929?

Comment on this

Have we to compete with the Senator or am I to be allowed to make my speech? I can see the Chair's difficulty but surely the Whip has no such difficulty? As I have said, the Fianna Fáil Party must have been greatly disappointed because the Committee did not produce a recommendation that the system of proportional representation be abolished. They made no such recommendation. They just set out the arguments for. I am sure they were put by Fianna Fáil. It has been put on record in this House that the then Taoiseach who set up this Committee and who afterwards became a member of the Committee stated that there was no intention and that it would be completely foolish to attempt to go to the people again with another proposition to abolish proportional representation. That has been put on the record here and on the record of the other House. If Deputy Seán Lemass thought fit to deny that, I am sure he would have denied it. The mere fact that he does not think fit to deny it would give reason to any normal person to believe that that is what he said.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Of course it is.

Comment on this

I lost my train of thought when I was interrupted. There is one point I wanted to make. There is the suggestion that the PR system was in some way too complicated for our people to use properly. It has been used to good effect since 1922. It has been used in every election. The fact that it takes a long time to count the votes indicates that the electorate must be exercising their votes very carefully and, to use the words of Senator Honan, very decisively. I fail to see how you can use a preference vote any less decisively than a No. 1 vote.

If we refer again to this Report on the Constitution we see, in Annex 13, how the people voted since 1922. The percentage of spoiled votes in 1922 was 3.48. The percentage of the total electorate who voted was 62. In 1923 the percentage of spoiled votes increased slightly to 3.66 and from 1923 t has decreased until, in the election of 65, the percentage of spoiled votes as 0.91—not even one per cent—out a total vote of 75.1 per cent.

Comment on this

Anybody who says, therefore, that the system is too complex for us, that the Irish people cannot use this system, is talking nonsense.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Who is saying "Hear, hear"?

Comment on this

Am I to appeal directly to the Whips? If you have not respect for this House and allow this type of thing, the Leader of the House should show respect and remove this person. I know he is doing his best. He was doing his best today, too.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It will becomes anybody from that side to talk about respect for the House.

Comment on this

This report has shown clearly——

Comment on this

Will Senator Ahern conduct himself or leave the House?

Comment on this

I will leave the House.

Comment on this

As I was saying, this report has shown conclusively that our people can and do use the system of PR intelligently. Then, when we find the Fianna Fáil Party producing the argument that the system is too complex, it is time we sat up and examined that argument carefully. If these are the only reasons, the stupid reasons, Fianna Fáil have for their attempt to change the system of election, there is no doubt as to the verdict the people will give because, to my mind, there is a clear obligation on the people who want to change the system of election, and consequently to change our Constitution, to give not merely valid but compelling reasons.

Comment on this

It is now 11 o'clock. Does the House wish to adjourn or to proceed?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The House will adjourn until 10.30 a.m. tomorrow.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Could I inquire what the arrangements are? The arrangement for tomorrow was that business would conclude between 1 p.m. and 1.30 p.m.

Comment on this

The Senator is trying to be funny.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

All the agreements go by the board—they have been broken by those over there.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald could not keep any agreement. He has no word.

Comment on this

I did not hear what the Leader of the House said because of the Minister's mumbling interruptions.

Comment on this

Tá an Seanad ar athló.

Comment on this

I appeal to you, Sir, to ask the Leader of the House to repeat what he said and which could not be heard through the Minister's mumbles.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There was an arrangement——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I propose that the Seanad meet at 10.30 a.m. tomorrow and continue until it has done what I was foolish enough to believe would be done today—conclude the Second Stage of this Bill.

Comment on this