We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–157 of 464. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

When speaking last night there was one argument which slipped my mind. In volume 232, No. 13, of 28th February, 1968, the Taoiseach said:

The first question is whether we want a multiplicity of Parties...

He said that one of the flaws in PR was that it brought about a multiplicity of Parties. This of course is not so. One would imagine that having said that, the Taoiseach would be able to point to a time in the past when we had a multiplicity of Parties under the system of PR. There is no country in the world where there is such a small number of Parties in the national parliament. We have only three Parties in this Parliament, the Government Party, the Fine Gael Party, the Labour Party and a few Independents. There is no case to be made, therefore, that PR brings about an undesirable multiplicity of Parties. There is no such thing. A case could, indeed, be made if you were to look at the result and say that PR prevents a multiplicity of Parties and prevents minorities coming together in Parties to express their views. Certainly no case can be made that PR can bring about this undesirable result of a multiplicity of Parties.

The Committee on the Constitution did not recommend the proposed change. On those who want a change rests the obligation to give reasons, and valid reasons, why they want a change. There is no point in saying that they are giving the people an opportunity of deciding whether they want the change or not. In the absence of a clamour from the people, there is no point in saying that you are giving them an opportunity of deciding. You might just as well say that you are giving them an opportunity of deciding that Parliament should be abolished, and that you are giving them an opportunity of deciding on a one man dictatorship in this country. There has been no clamour for a change and, therefore, it is not a valid reason to say that people are being given the opportunity.

The only reason this referendum is being brought about at present is that the Government are aware there is no possibility after the next election of Fianna Fáil forming a Government on their own. Therefore, they say to themselves: "Let us go for the single-seat constituency, rig the constituencies in our favour and look for a complete majority in those circumstances. If we fail, we are no worse off than we were at first. We cannot win the next time in any case." That is the only reason why they are now seeking to change the system. If they were honest and if they had no ulterior motive, they would be able to produce compelling reasons for such a change.

It has been calculated that if the system is changed—and I do not think the people will vote for that—Fianna Fáil will have between 90 and 100 seats. Whether that calculation is correct or not, it would be interesting to visualise what might happen in this country if it were. It would be interesting to visualise what Fianna Fáil would do in those circumstances. We might then really find out what "Blaneyism" means and how far it could go so far as the farmers are concerned.

Comment on this

Four hundred cows.

Comment on this

That is 399 more than the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has. We might see how the farmers would be treated. We have already experience of how they were treated with a small majority. We might have experience of how the workers would be treated. We might have a resurgence of "Bolandism" as we saw it in the Army. We could visualise how the local gauleiters would rule the roost locally.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We might even have grass growing on Shannon.

Comment on this

That is quite possible. Can the Senator not do better than Shannon? It does not affect me at all. We might then see how the farmers and workers would be treated by this benevolent Government with the huge majority they sought, to better the lives of the people. We might then have legislation which would effectively control both farmers and workers in the interests of Fianna Fáil. We might then have a very interesting position when the only legal tender in this country would be the Fianna Fáil cumann card in the smaller denominations and the Taca membership card in the larger ones.

Let us look at a local area where Fianna Fáil have a complete majority and see how they operate there. In this way we might have a better idea of how they might operate nationally if they had this huge majority. Take, for instance, the constituency of Clare where I live. There, Fianna Fáil have a complete majority locally. They have had this complete majority for over 40 years.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

To be exact, 42 years.

Comment on this

Let us have a look at what happens there. I have been a member of Clare County Council for a long time. Even long before I entered it, I cannot remember any time in the last 40 years when any member other than a Fianna Fáil member was put on any of the sub-committees of the county council.

Comment on this

Fine Gael do that in Wexford where they have no majority.

Comment on this

There is no Fine Gael member on the agricultural committee, the vocational committee or the mental hospital visiting committee. Not alone that, but there is no Labour member or no Independent member on those committees—no member of any Party other than Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

You started it. Now you are getting your own medicine back.

Comment on this

Even on those committees where they can co-opt extern members, no man is co-opted unless he is a card-bearing member of Fianna Fáil. On one occasion, for some reason or other, the chairman of the NFA was put on the agricultural committee. It was stated it was because he was chairman of the NFA. But the following term he was removed without any reason whatever, although he was still chairman of the NFA. They also refused to appoint to the agricultural committee the reverend chairman of the local agricultural show committee, who would have had some knowledge of agriculture. Instead they put on bakers, publicans and others— anybody but a farmer. The only qualification was Fianna Fáil membership.

I remember on one occasion when we had the unique position that a Fianna Fáil member of the county council was actively canvassing, and in fact getting support, for membership of the governing body of UCG. The qualification he was boasting of—the only one he had—was that he had a brother a priest in Australia. Fortunately, even Fianna Fáil could not stomach that and they reappointed the Bishop of the Diocese.

Take, for instance, the mental hospital committee under a Fianna Fáil majority such as we might have nationally if PR were abolished. There are members of the Clare County Council who have lived for years within sight of the gates of the mental hospital. Do you think they would be put on that committee? They are not even given the courtesy of being allowed to go inside this hospital.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That is a protection.

Comment on this

Yet Fianna Fáil members are brought 40 to 50 miles from the tip of the Loop Head peninsula to meetings of that committee at public expense. There are many within a half a mile who would have no expense, and who are willing to act, but they are not Fianna Fáil members. They are not Fine Gael either. This is how Fianna Fáil might be expected to act nationally. The Fianna Fáil Party do not act this way in every instance. They appoint other than Fianna Fáil members to some committees. Any member at all on Clare County Council can be a member of the old age pensions committee. Any member can be on the visiting committee of the county hospital. The only reason that is so is that they wish to go on it; but there are no expenses payable to those committees. Therefore, anybody and everybody, no matter what his qualifications are, can act on those committees.

What happens then? Extern members are appointed to those committees. They are not Fianna Fáil councillors, but they hope to be. No member of Clare County Council staff, no member of the official staff, can be seen in public talking to a member of the Opposition. If he is, he is branded immediately. This happens in spite of the fact that those people have a perfect right to talk to whom they wish. This is conveyed to them bluntly, as it was very often conveyed to myself in regard to my position.

This is the threat and this is the weapon which Fianna Fáil use when they want to get their own way. When they want to get something, they make promises and they also use threats when they want to get people to do something they want. I have forgotten the number of times I have been personally threatened in regard to my job because of my activities on the county council but I never bothered my head about them. Being a member of a political Party is an exceedingly tough job.

That is what Fianna Fáil do in County Clare in regard to the Opposition. That is what they may do nationally with a majority. On the basis of what they are doing already with the slim majority which they have, we can have a rough idea of what they might do if they have a greater majority. In the past 13 or 14 years during which I have been a member of Clare County Council—I will only speak of what has happened during my own time—unless a person was first of all vetted by the local cumann, he was not appointed as rate collector.

Comment on this

Fine Gael are very good at that.

Comment on this

Unless the person was the son or daughter, the brother or sister or the first cousin of a county councillor, he was not appointed.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Was this first cousin once removed or twice removed?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He was never removed once he got the job.

Comment on this

Does that happen in Laois County Council? Tell us what happens there.

Comment on this

I will not speak of the time before I became a member of the county council. I know plenty about that time but it is only hearsay. I will speak of my own experience during the past 13 or 14 years.

Comment on this

Does it have to do with the presiding officer at the last election?

Comment on this

I will be coming to that. In most instances, although there were one or two exceptions, where the person appointed was not the son, daughter, nephew, niece, first cousin or second cousin of a Fianna Fáil councillor, he was without exception a Fianna Fáil cumann secretary, a chairman or some other official. Those are the facts. They make no exceptions. If they cannot find a Fianna Fáil official, then they will find a Fianna Fáil man's son or a councillor's son. I see road gangers, road overseers and many foremen, with very few honourable exceptions, who have been appointed by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

(Longford): The reason is so many people are supporters of Fianna Fáil in Clare it has to happen.

Comment on this

Where would you find a Fine Gael man?

Comment on this

We can see on polling day in our county institutions that they are almost empty of staff. Their holidays have been arranged in such a way that the only people who get off to go out working canvassing, acting as presiding officers and personation agents are Fianna Fáil people.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why do not the people of Clare revolt against that if that is what happens? Why do they stand for that?

Comment on this

The people of Clare are not satisfied but they have lived so long in the belief that they had to vote this way, if they wanted to get something, that that is what they do. However, it will change.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

They must be pretty happy when they have been satisfied up to now.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Have the 8,000 any rights?

Comment on this

I will not delay the House too long because I am sure there will be other speakers who will delay longer than I will.

Comment on this

You are doing what you were put there for.

Comment on this

We reported a presiding officer. It was alleged that we reported a Fine Gael presiding officer but he was a Fianna Fáil presiding officer. This will show again how the Fianna Fáil Party works. We reported this presiding officer to the Attorney General in the proper manner.

Comment on this

Which Bill is this on?

Comment on this

We reported that we had evidence——

Comment on this

Which Bill does it refer to?

Comment on this

It is the straight vote.

Comment on this

This is how Fianna Fáil work if they have a majority. If they get it nationally, this is how it would work nationally. I will challenge them on this. We reported to the Attorney General a Fianna Fáil rate collector appointed by Fianna Fáil and a man who, I understand, boasted —I may be wrong because this is just hearsay—he voted 22 times for the Fianna Fáil candidate in the last presidential election as a presiding officer. We reported him through the normal channels to the Attorney General that we had evidence that he was seen voting twice, putting two ballot papers into a ballot box as a returning officer. The Attorney General investigated this matter and his report was that there was no evidence. We then sent the Attorney General, again in the proper manner, two sworn affidavits on this subject. Again the Attorney General reported that there was no evidence. We then instituted a private complaint and because of the evidence which the Attorney General said did not exist or could not be got, that Fianna Fáil rate collector who was acting as a returning officer in the local elections, was found guilty and got a suspended sentence of one month in gaol and was bound to the peace on one charge but was found not guilty on a technicality on the other, merely on a technicality, the evidence was conclusive but he was found not guilty on a technicality, on the presumption that he was innocent unless it was proved conclusively that he was guilty. This is how Fianna Fáil operates locally where they have a majority. The evidence is there and was proved in open court of a Fianna Fáil rate collector, a Fianna Fáil member who was acting as a Fianna Fáil member in the last election and not a Fine Gael supporter.

Comment on this

He was a Fine Gael supporter until you crucified him.

Comment on this

I cannot imagine where the Senator got that but I have my ideas. However, that is the position. That is how Fianna Fáil operate where they have a complete majority. I could go on but I will not.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Ah, do.

Comment on this

If they could get that sort of majority nationally, they would operate in the same way.

Finally, if our system of election is to be changed, then it is reasonable to expect that the people who seek the change should give valid and compelling reasons why the change is necessary. It is also reasonable to expect that in putting this to the people for the second time in nine years they would advance reasons other than those which the people rejected nine years ago. If they had different reasons, if they had valid, compelling reasons, there might be some substance in their arguments but there is none. The same reasons as were rejected are trotted out again in the hope that if they succeed here, they will win a general eletion later on and if they fail here, they will be no worse off than they are now. In my opinion, that is an impertinent type of brainwashing, to try to blind the people with propaganda without clearly showing any evidence that a demand for change exists.

Comment on this

(Longford): I feel somewhat inhibited in proceeding to speak at this hour of the morning, having listened to the many profound arguments from the other side of the House. I suppose I should feel inhibited having listened to the very learned discourse from the Senator who has preceded me and if I have shortcomings and if I am a bit confused, I trust my colleagues will understand why I am a bit confused.

Comment on this

We understand fully, Sir.

Comment on this

(Longford): While there is always a temptation to follow and answer the person who has spoken before one, I shall try to refrain from that though I do feel it will inhibit me a bit. I should like, if I can, to raise the discussion a wee bit at this stage, even though it is early in the morning, because it is deteriorating. All sorts of arguments are unfortunately being used and all sorts of statements are being made apparently without any regard to what the issue is or what the Bills are all about. That is a pity because in the long run no matter on what side of the House one is, that sort of thing does damage to the whole institution of parliament. I am one of those people who believe that parliament at all times, no matter what Government are in power, has a duty to protect itself. Being to some degree an individualist or a crank—another name for an individualist, I suppose— I am always of the opinion that parliament must, as far as possible, preserve its power and its privilege and, if you like, its dignity as far as dignity will guard the power of parliament.

I have always felt that there is an eternal war between the executive authority representing central power and parliament representing the people. By the very nature of things and by the very nature of man, there is a collision between the two since power is a thing that people seem to want to have in parliament and in government. That is why I think that when you have silly discussion, and we have had a certain amount of silly discussion on this measure, in the long run it damages the institution of parliament. I do not want to see 15, 20 or 25 years from now—I may not be around and many of us may not be around— the power of parliament eroded here. That is the reason that parliament and members of parliament should be a little more careful in the sort of argument they are prepared to profess in parliament.

That may be a preamble or a prelude to what I have to say on these Bills, but I feel that there are times when it is necessary, and this applies to both sides of the House, and it will apply in the future as it has applied in the past. We know, any of us who pay any attention at all to contemporary history, the number of parliaments that have disappeared in our life and time all over the continent of Europe, and in other countries, I feel certain. Nine years ago I spoke from this side of the House on this question. I have listened again to the same arguments from the benches on the other side of the House. The principal reason why I would support a Bill to give the people a chance and advise the people to abolish the system of voting that we call proportional representation is that I am quite satisfied that it would have destroyed this country long ago as it destroyed parliamentary institutions in other countries, except for one historic fact.

I say this quite sincerely and deliberately. I know it may be regarded as political heresy by some of my own colleagues, but it is my belief and I am therefore entitled to say it. I believe that one of the great blessings of the Civil War, while it had many curses, and it is true to say that the majority of us forgot the bitterness of it more quickly than probably any other country in the world——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It had no blessings.

Comment on this

(Longford): The greatest blessing it had, in my view—I expected that sort of criticism —was that it divided this country into two fairly evenly matched groups, each with good men and men not so hot. I suppose I might be among those not so hot. Be that as it may, the Civil War did that and that was one of the long-term blessings of the Civil War. The result was that you had two major groups or political Parties comprising a broad cross-section of people, doctors, university professors, tailors, publicans and so on on both sides with a broad national policy. As a result there was no grouping of sectional interests or pressure groups. I am certain that is why this sophisticated system of voting worked reasonably well. If there had not been a civil war or some similar confrontation, the country would long ago have broken up into pressure groups.

That is why I supported the proposal nine years ago. The arguments against it were that you would have a dictatorship if the system were changed. It was also said that Fianna Fáil were beaten and that it was the last effort to keep Fianna Fáil in power. From another point of view, it was said that there was danger to the rights of minorities. The tragedy, I think, is—and it has been said again by at least one Member of this House; I think it was Senator McQuillan—that the people opposite seem to feel that despite the merit of these two measures, they want to use them in an attempt to whip Fianna Fáil. That is, I think, one of the best ways of undermining parliamentary institutions, particularly when an attempt is made to improve and cement the foundations of parliamentary institutions.

Nine years ago it was said that Fianna Fáil could not possibly get back in the next election. I heard the same thing from the Senator who spoke before me and some others who should know better in the Fine Gael front benches. Despite the fact that the people did not change the system of voting they still elected Fianna Fáil who have been continuously in government since. Fianna Fáil would win under any election system that was fairly organised and controlled because they have the majority of the people behind them for better or worse. It is as simple as that and the sooner those who want to think otherwise admit this, the better for themselves. This must be admitted and the reason for it is that Fianna Fáil have merit and are consistent in policy. It is not that they have a monopoly of governing ability but one of the factors that have kept Fianna Fáil in power since the last referendum and will continue to keep them in power is the quality of the Opposition. If the present Opposition had a more conservative and balanced approach, instead of the silly attitudes they have adopted they would present much greater danger to Fianna Fáil. I know there are many in Fine Gael at different levels at the top and down the country—I do not want to mention names as my purpose is not to annoy people—who are honest-thinking people, people of stability.

However, Fianna Fáil have been in government since the last referendum. Prophets of evil then said that Fianna Fáil were beaten and afraid of losing the next election and that it was because they wanted to establish a near dictatorship that PR had to be removed. Even learned academic gentlemen came across with that sort of talk. The sad thing is that I do not think they have learned since.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What about the prophecies of instability from your side and how urgent it was to change the system?

Comment on this

They are still relevant.

Comment on this

(Longford): I am very grateful for the help from the Senator. I do not say that in any vicious way: it is not in my nature.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator is too gentlemanly.

Comment on this

(Longford): No, I am disguised as a gentleman. Why should Fianna Fáil have a particular dislike for the PR system? I assure people on both sides that I have won more elections under that system than I lost. It may be vanity on my part but I think I should make a brave effort at winning them also in the future. Fianna Fáil won more elections than they lost under PR. They have no reason to be afraid of it. Over the past 30 years they have done pretty well by any standards under the PR system and do not fear it now or in future—I mean, the immediate future. While I am not a betting person, I am prepared to lay a fairly heavy bet with any man opposite that Fianna Fáil will win the next general election and emerge as the strongest Party under the present or any other system of voting. We are not afraid, any more than we were afraid nine years ago, of being put out of power.

As I said, I am convinced that the one great blessing of the Civil War is that it did organise our people into large groups, so that we have enjoyed a great measure of stability. However, eventually those historical influences will cease to operate and a situation could develop in which there would be a number of vocal minorities. I have always found that minorities are more dogged and arrogant than any other sections of society. I think it was Gladstone who, in the House of Commons at a time when the Whigs and the Tories were well matched, referred to a dominant minority. I think he was right. Be that as it may, people may have different views. We must agree that we have the makings at the moment of two or three farmers' Parties; I am a farmer myself. I am a member of one trade organisation which may have political leanings and may seek representation in this House. There is another organisation, a fairly arrogant group, who also might seek representation in this House. We have had two Labour Parties in the past, and we could have two or three in the future. There are at least three different teaching organisations. If all such groups were to seek representation in Parliament, I would not like to be the person who would have to form a Government. He would want to be a pretty good wrangler to do it. I cannot imagine how stability could emerge if that pattern developed.

Politics is a practical science. It is not an academic exercise or a university topic for discourse without decisions being made. Nine years ago the then Taoiseach said that politics was the greatest of the practical sciences. I agree with him on many things, but I certainly agree with him on that. It must be treated as a practical science and not as an abstract science. If a government see that in the future, in 15 or even in 50 years time, a situation could develop where there would be a multiplicity of Parties, they have the responsibility and the duty to take steps to avert that situation, where pressure groups or dominant minorities would be so dominant that they would dictate to the majority. That is why there is a duty today as there was nine years ago to take the necessary steps. It is not possible to make such a change when you have an era of chaos or near-chaos. It is only when the Government have a practical working majority that it can be done. Even if the Government did not succeed in this attempt, there would still be a duty on the Government nine years hence to do the same thing, whether it be a Fine Gael, a Fianna Fáil or a Labour Government. I would always hope that in our sober moments the majority on all sides of the Dáil and Seanad would like to see a system of parliamentary government emerge which would provide stability and which would build up a better society for our grandchildren than we ourselves enjoy.

That is why I think it is tragic that despite the fact that there is a large bulk of opinion in Fine Gael in favour of the change, other people in Fine Gael saw fit to ignore that bulk of sober opinion and want to use this measure as a sort of lash with which to whip the Fianna Fáil Government. That is not the way to get into power, and I would say that their behaviour is the reason why Fianna Fáil are in power; I am not vain enough to suggest that Fianna Fáil Ministers have a monopoly of talent or of virtue. However, I do not want to advise them too much. It is their job to get their own philosophers.

The reason is simple enough. Why assume that the people down the country are silly and cannot think, that they are incapable of weighing things up? That is where the academic leaders of Fine Gael seem to make a mistake. The real fact is that to some degree Fianna Fáil have a large body of support in the country. The people feel they know where they stand with Fianna Fáil, but they are not too sure about the other group. That is the reason Fianna Fáil get a fairly substantial measure of support in every constituency. To put it neatly, the people vote for the status quo, whether we like it or not.

Some time ago we had people trying to explain philosophically the uproar in Paris when the students, the factory workers and public servants went on an enormous stampede. It appeared that there was no real leader, no common factor. They did not seem to understand what they wanted. I was speaking to an Englishman, a member of the Conservative Party, and he assured me that the French leader would not last 48 hours. Being a country man, I have not had the experience of being in Paris but I was inclined to take a different view. I had a mental picture of General de Gaule and I took a different view, but I did not contradict him because he seemed to know more about it than I did. As it turned out I happened to be right.

When a general election was held, General de Gaulle, who is regarded by some people as a horrid person who is trying to trample his people under a jackboot, got a vote of confidence greater than he had ever got before. Why? It was not that they liked him any better, but because they did not want chaos, did not want their institutions destroyed, and did not want their country broken into little pieces. He seemed to be their only hope and they decided: "We may not like him, but we will vote for him." That is why de Gaulle got an increased measure of support in France. For the same reason Fianna Fáil get a larger bulk of support in this country than they would get if there were a more effective and responsible Opposition.

Nine years ago the prophets of evil were saying we were on the road out. We have won every election since, and I am prepared to predict, although I do not want to be a prophet in this institution, that we will win again. We will win until such times as there is a really competent and constructive Party to take the place of Fianna Fáil. The people will return Fianna Fáil at the next election, and possibly at the one after that, I would hazard a guess, although I would not be too sure about that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

That will be under the straight vote.

Comment on this

(Longford): It does not matter what system of voting we have. The Party with the most support will win the election whatever the system of election.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

What more do you want?

Comment on this

Ask your computer.

Comment on this

(Longford): If we fail this time and we are in power nine years from now, we will do the same again. We have to have some sense of responsibility. I should not like to see our measure of freedom and democracy, won at a very dear price, ending up in chaos or near-chaos. As I said, politics is a practical science. It is not an academic exercise in the university. That is my answer.

Nine years ago this question of flexibility as between the constituencies was not before us. There appeared to be no necessity for it. When I first heard the word "tolerance" used in this connection, I was not too sure what it meant. I always regarded tolerance as being the measure of space between the bearing surface and the bearing. I have a gauge for measuring tolerance in that field. That is why I was a bit confused when I first heard the Taoiseach and other people who use words in a wider area than I do, using the word in this connection. It is a good word, but I personally would prefer the word "flexibility". However, I will not quarrel on such a narrow issue.

Comment on this

The Senator must not exhaust the tolerance of the Chair.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Or the flexibility of the rules of the House.

Comment on this

(Longford): I do not intend to do so. There was no provision in regard to tolerance nine years ago. There was no necessity for it. The approach of the Legislature towards the number of voters in the constituencies was such that there was no need for it. The opinion of the Legislature in framing legislation was that so far as possible representation should be weighted in favour of the areas which seemed to need more represenation because of their topographical outlines. In areas like Mayo, Leitrim and Sligo, it appeared that it would take fewer voters to elect a Deputy than in other areas.

It seems that what the Legislature and the courts hold can be two different things. A prominent member of Fine Gael challenged the interpretation in the courts. It annoyed me at the time that the courts held that you had to have near equality of population per seat. The new electoral law provided that as far as possible there should be the same number of people in each constituency. I do not think the majority of people, particularly in the west of Ireland and the rural areas, wanted that. That is why there is a necessity for that measure now. I hope it will be passed.

I think it is ridiculous to have a situation whereby, in one constituency, a representative can drive through his constituency in seven minutes. A member of the Fianna Fáil Party, who has been a member for a very long time— he is not in Government—told me some years ago that he could drive through his constituency, from one point to another, in seven minutes. I think it is an unfair situation——

Comment on this

He could walk it.

Comment on this

(Longford):——that that constituency should have the same sort of representation as an area such as North Mayo, South Mayo, Clare, Sligo-Leitrim, Roscommon-Leitrim. In view of the fact that the present Act, which made provision for the constituency boundaries, is of such a nature as to achieve a nearer equality in population per constituency, county boundaries have to be disregarded. Existing boundaries command old loyalties. At the moment, under existing law, it is a function for the Minister for Local Government. Under the new proposal for legislation, it will be a function for a commission. Whether the people on the other side of this House have more faith in the Minister for Local Government or in an independent commission, I shall leave it to themselves to decide. The fact is that, at the moment, he has been described in this House in his absence as the rather horrid Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He made horrid and lurid remarks about me, anyway.

Comment on this

(Longford): It was said apropos a particular aspect of his duty as Minister for Local Government. I know the Minister can be as awkward as myself at times, and maybe more so, but I would never admit that he would be guilty of some of the things that were suggested by some of those people opposite.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Do you think I was guilty of the things he suggested of me?

Comment on this

You were.

Comment on this

(Longford): I did not know you were there, Sir.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

You are right to avoid the question.

Comment on this

(Longford): It is easy to start a smear campaign. It may keep people out of power forever.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He did against me. I do not think the Minister's smear campaign against me will keep us out for very long.

Comment on this

(Longford): I am not aware of it. Even if the Minister did wrong, that does not give you the right to do wrong.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I accept that, but I am not the person envisaged by your remarks.

Comment on this

(Longford): I hear Senator Carton talking over there. It is interesting to note the difference between the tone of his voice and that of Senator Garret FitzGerald. There is no viciousness in Senator Carton's tone of voice as there is in Senator Garret FitzGerald's. I think the question of having a situation whereby it will take fewer votes and fewer people in a western constituency, by comparison with a constituency in Dublin—whether it is north of the Liffey or south of the Liffey or Dublin county, for that matter, where the Minister seeks to get elected—is quite right and fair. It is quite a different matter to be a public representative of any Party for a Dublin constituency as compared with Sligo-Leitrim, Cavan, Donegal or Roscommon and that is particularly so when there is a breach of county boundaries; and people do not like it. We may accept it in quiet desperation, but that is about as far as we go. I know that people do not like to see a county boundary violently breached to provide constituency boundaries.

I fear there is not enough tolerance, enough flexibility, in the present proposal to prevent the violation of county boundaries. I hope there is—time will tell—enough flexibility to ensure that constituencies can be organised without breach of existing county boundaries. We have a situation now in Roscommon-South Leitrim, which runs to beyond Carrigallen. Surely the people opposite should agree that it is quite a different thing to be a public representative there from what it is to be a public representative in Dublin North-Central or Dublin South-Central?

Again, take Sligo and North Leitrim which runs from the borders of Cavan almost into Ballina. Surely it is a different thing to be a public representative there from being a public representative in Dublin South-Central or Dublin South-West? Senator O'Quigley comes from the west of Ireland. He tries to justify himself in voting against that sort of thing and in trying to get people not to develop that situation——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

——because of the principle of one man, one vote.

Comment on this

(Longford): Even at this late hour, I would hope that there would be thinking people in Fine Gael who would re-think this a wee bit. In the long run, the people of the country will assess its value, no matter what Party they may belong to. Do not forget that the people there are still the people of Leitrim. No silly arguments by well-trained speakers and lawyers will prevail. Everything will carefully be assessed by the people there, who are well able to do it.

Comment on this

Is it Sligo-Leitrim?

Comment on this

(Longford): Anywhere in the West. It applies to rural Ireland.

Comment on this

The constituency is called Sligo-Leitrim.

Comment on this

And Roscommon-Leitrim.

Comment on this

(Longford): If you knew the country, you would not ask me that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There are people in the West who also believe in the democratic principle of one man, one vote.

Comment on this

You did not know it nine years ago and you do not know it now.

Comment on this

(Longford): I won more elections under proportional representation than I lost. Many of my colleagues think so.

Comment on this

That, again, is tolerance.

Comment on this

(Longford): It may be charity on their part.

Comment on this

Let us concede that.

Comment on this

(Longford): I do not think the present system of what we call proportional representation is proportional representation at all. Comparisions have been made with outside countries. With an election where there are ten candidates and where there are a few crackpots or jackpots as candidates, I cannot understand why people give No. 1 to a candidate whom the majority would not consider at all. The person who votes for that candidate can then give a vote to the next nearest crackpot and then when he sees that that horse is not going to win, he can put his bet on the third horse and in this way he gets a good few bets.

I spent a long week in Longford trying to sort out this business. I saw an old and esteemed colleague of mine, General MacEoin, eliminated and a younger and newer member of Fine Gael took his seat. How I felt about that is another matter. I saw the way in which some people got a number of chances and there was a fairly strict scrutiny. When the first horse did not win, they had another chance and then when that horse did not win, they had another chance and so on. People who voted for General MacEoin had only one chance. That is the way I look at it. In regard to PR and giving a voice to minorities, there are other systems and I would suggest that if you want to make the system fairer, then you could put a fractional value on the No. 2 vote, a lower fractional value on the No. 3 vote and so on. I would not suggest what those fractions should be for they would have to vary.

Comment on this

You would have to get a computer.

Comment on this

(Longford): No, I would get a human being to help me. I do not believe in machines all that much. The machine is as good or as bad as its master. I think I would get Senator Garret FitzGerald to work out the various mathematics. That would be one improvement on our present system. I think it was Senator Garret FitzGerald who suggested that the French system is not nearly as good as our system and that our system is more sophisticated. As far as I know under the French system when people vote in the first election, they see who has the largest number of votes and the smallest. A candidate who does not get a certain percentage —I think it is ten per cent—is wiped off the slate. Another election is then held in a week's time during which the people have time to think about the situation before they vote again.

Comment on this

Everybody.

Comment on this

(Longford): Not necessarily everybody.

Comment on this

Everybody gets a chance.

Comment on this

(Longford): What happens in practice I suggest is that the crackpots do not vote any more. They become dissatisfied and say “A plague on both your houses.”

Comment on this

(Longford): Even the French system would be an improvement. It can be said that the system in France does not give representation to minorities, but nobody can say that minorities have to be represented at the expense of the majority.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Nobody ever suggested that.

Comment on this

(Longford): In the long run the safest and soundest system to have is that proposed in the Bill, and I believe the people will adopt that system. The people do not want to have a situation at any time in the future where you could have near-chaos and where it would be difficult to form a Government. In the long run, the whole purpose is to form a Government. The majority of people would prefer single-seat constituencies, despite all the talk and misrepresentation. I believe that they will adopt the proposed system.

Comment on this

This is the second debate on this subject inside ten years and this debate is in its second week. At this stage it would be difficult for anybody to say anything new and the speeches we have heard suggest that every Senator has made up his mind and therefore I see no excuse for making a long speech. I should like to say one or two things, however. I have heard many reasons advanced in this House, and I have read the debates in the other House, why the Government wish to depart from the present PR system and replace it by the straight vote system. Some of these reasons are plausible and some of them are unworthy. I represent the graduates of Trinity College and I would say on their behalf and on behalf of Trinity College that we have no complaint about the treatment of the college or the graduates by this Government or their predecessors. If therefore I do not find myself in sympathy with the present proposal it is not from any desire that I have or feel my constituents have for getting rid of the Fianna Fáil Party.

I believe on the evidence that the PR system is the one that has the greatest potential—whether it is always realised or not is another matter—for giving the fairest representation to all sections of the people. An objection that might be valid and which would influence me a lot is that it is complicated and difficult to understand and to operate. That objection would carry a good deal of weight with me if we were setting up the system for the first time but that is not the situation. The system has been in operation for a very long number of years. People understand the machinery the Minister's Department have set up for dealing with it and are able to cope so far as one can see and therefore the objection I have mentioned loses its force, in my opinion anyway.

There is another point, that is, that the adoption of the single-member constituency would, of course, make these constituencies very much smaller than they are. There would be three times, or thereabouts, as many constituencies as we have now and each would be proportionately smaller. But, no matter how small you make a constituency, it will still be a complex unit. It will not be a uniform body of people. Many interests will always be involved and, in those circumstances, it is wiser, I think, to have more than one representative for a unit like that.

I have heard it said that it would be difficult for a person in a constituency with a certain political affiliation to have his interests looked after by a Deputy who was not of the same political affiliation. I am not thinking of that consideration at all; I am thinking of an interest, perhaps professional, perhaps industrial, in a constituency, which has a legitimate proposal to put to the Government, and it can only do so through a member who knows nothing about the particular interest at all. Where you have a number of interests in a constituency, as you must have, I believe it is better to have more than one representative. That situation could not evolve under the proposal here. I myself would prefer the single transferable vote system to the system proposed and I might even be persuaded to propose substituting it for the system now before the House. I am afraid I do not find myself in sympathy with the proposal before the House.

Comment on this

Because of the importance of these measures, it is vitally important that as many Senators as possible should give their views in order that the people may know where we stand. The Third Amendment Bill has become known as the Tolerance Bill. Under this alleged tolerance, it will require something over 16,000 voters to elect a representative in a rural constituency while it will require something over 23,000 voters to elect a representative in an urban constituency. It is regrettable that this Bill should be necessary. The blame for that must lie with the Government; we are told the Bill is necessary to preserve equilibrium of representation as between rural areas and urban areas. If the population in the rural areas has declined, I cannot see how this Bill will help those who are left.

The fact that there is no provision for a Commission in this Bill makes it suspect. The absence of any provision for a Commission does not support the contention that there is a desire or a necessity to preserve equilibrium between urban and rural constituencies. I can speak only of the area which I know. In 1961 Fianna Fáil, for their own advantage, took part of Louth and put it into Monaghan. They did not have regard to electoral area boundaries. They cut across boundaries and, in doing that, they ensured that Fine Gael pockets would be thrown into Monaghan and the redistribution would help Fianna Fáil pockets in Louth in preventing two Fine Gael Deputies being returned in Louth. The extra Fine Gael vote in Monaghan would make no effective difference in the result in Monaghan.

The Fourth Amendment Bill is designed to introduce here the British system of voting. I remember the days when anyone who supported Cumann na nGaedheal was told he was West Briton. It strikes me that, as the years go by, Fianna Fáil are becoming more and more West Briton. Fianna Fáil are becoming more and more what we were supposed to be in those days. I have heard no request for this change except from certain sections of Fianna Fáil. I believe this Bill is introduced as a result of the last local government election because Fianna Fáil now feel that they may not have in the future the majority they have had in the past, and this is an effort on their part to hold on to power at all costs. I did not see any evidence of any discussion by the Committee on the Constitution about this change or any suggestion that this system should be introduced.

It is ridiculous to spend over £100,000 on this referendum. Fianna Fáil, of course, will have tremendous amounts of money from their own resources to spend on this election. We, in Fine Gael, will have to depend on small subscriptions from our supporters: so will the Labour Party. We will be put to the trouble of asking supporters to come to our aid, but I have no doubt the money will be forthcoming when the people realise what is involved.

I listened last night to Senator Nash. I thought his contribution might easily be described as a sermon on the evils of proportional representation. He said proportional representation led to the formation of pressure groups. I would remind the Senator that he is himself a member of a pressure group because he is a member of the Incorporated Law Society. Any member of a society, a professional organisation, a trade union or a business organisation can be regarded as a member of a pressure group. People come together in these groups to use their combined strength to get the best deal they can for their profession or trade.

The Senator says proportional representation leads to the formation of more and more pressure groups. If he examined the proposal before the House, he would realise that the proposed system makes for the formation of more and more pressure groups because any system under which 35 per cent of the electorate can get a seat must be an unfair system. I remember in 1957 when we had two Nationalists in Fermanagh and Tyrone—I think there was another one—going to Westminster. At that time an extreme element sprang up in Northern Ireland. The result was that the Nationalists lost representation in Westminster. The people who wanted to have it lost it.

As far as Stormont is concerned, before the last election the Nationalist Party, the Labour Party and the Independent Labour Party discussed the areas that they would contest. It was decided that if the Nationalist Party did not contest Belfast, the other Party would not contest the rural area. That system is more susceptible to the machinations of pressure groups than is the system of PR because this could not happen under PR. Pressure groups would not be so effective.

PR is the system best known to the people and the only system that people under old age pension age have ever used. Some years ago there was a certain urban election, the count in which brought home very forcibly to me that the people do understand the PR system. I remember totalling the valid poll and totalling the votes cast for each candidate. There was not one vote wasted. It cannot, therefore, be said that the people do not understand the working of PR.

The Fianna Fáil speakers have been inconsistent in their approach to these Bills. In the Dáil a Deputy said that this measure would benefit more Fine Gael and Labour. The other day Senator Yeats said that the aim of the Government Party was to have a strong government and strong opposition—a two-Party system. I may be simple in my beliefs but I do not believe that Fianna Fáil would bring in a measure to benefit either Fine Gael or Labour.

The primary function of a Dáil election is to elect Members to Dáil Éireann. If it is described as a Dáil election, the function must be to elect Members to the Dáil and then, those Members having been duly elected, it is their function to elect a Government.

Some speakers seemed to favour inter-Party Government and, on the other hand, we heard a great deal about the ills of inter-Party Government. I can confidently say that the best Government that there ever was in this country was the Government in office from 1948 to 1951. That Government introduced many useful schemes. In the autumn of 1947 there was a mini-Budget and the people were told by Fianna Fáil that there was nothing but gloom and bad times ahead, that extra taxation had to be imposed on necessary commodities. In 1948, when the inter-Party Government came into office, those taxes were removed and many useful schemes such as the Local Authorities (Works) Act, the Land Project, the new Trade Agreement with Great Britain, were introduced.

From what I can hear from the people around my area, I believe that this measure will be rejected by the people in the referendum. If there should be a low poll—that is what possibly Fianna Fáil are hoping for— it is not impossible that by some chance the measure might be carried. If that were to happen, democracy for all time in this country would be dead because we would never get another chance of having a referendum.

Comment on this
Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. K. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Is oth lion nach raibh mé i láthair nuair do bhí an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin ag caint ach tá súil agam go maithfidh sé dom é mar tuigfidh sé go raibh mé tar éis bheith ag éisteacht ar feadh uair go leith leis an Seanadóir MacGearailt ag caint agus, mar sin, tuigfidh sé go raibh faoiseamh beag tuilte agam. Chun na fírinne a rá, cheapas go mbeadh an Seanadóir Mac Gearailt ag caint fiú nuair a thiocfainn ar ais. Bhí sé ag ath-rá chuile rud a bhí ráite aige faoi dhó nó faoi thrí cheana féin agus a bhí ráite ag mórán Seanadóirí eile chomh maith. Bhí gach comhartha air go raibh sé ar aigne aige leanúint leis sin ar feadh cuid mhaith aimsire. De réir deallraimh, tar éis bailiú líom as an Teach d'éirigh sé as go luath agus do labhair cúpla Seanadóirí eile le linn dom bheith as láthair.

De réir mar a chuala mé, do chuir an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin i n-iúl don Teach go raibh sé i bhfábhar suíocháin aonair ach gur cheap sé gur bhfearr go mbeadh vóta ion-aistrithe ann in áit an vóta dírigh atá á thairiscint againn don phobal. Aontaím go bhfuil agus go raibh le tamall anuas mórán cainte ann faoi'n chóras seo atá in aigne an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin agus go mór mór go bhfuil an-trácht air ins na nuachtaín ag tuairisceoirí poiliticiúla. Aontaím, freisin, go bhfuil daoine á rá gurab é seo an chóras atá ag teastáil ó na daoine. Níl aon fhianaise ann go bhfuil sé sin fíor.

Do thairg an Teachta Ó Neachtain leasú sa Dáil ag moladh an córais seo, an vóta ion-aistrithe ins an dáil-cheantar ag suíocháin aonair, ach ní bhfuair sé tacaíocht ar bith. Ní raibh oiread agus Teachta Dála amháin i bhfábhar na tairiscinte sin agus orthu sin áirím an Teachta Ó Neachtain féin. Chuir seisean in iúl go soiléir gur bhfearr leis féin an vóta díreach mar ba léir dó gurbh é sin an córas ab fhearr don tír, ach gurbh é a thuairim go mbéadh sé níos fuiriste an suíochán aonair a fháil sa tír dá nglacfaí leis an córas toghchánaíochta seo—córas an vóta inaistrithe leis an suíochán aonair—dá nglacfaí leis sin go mbéadh sé níos fuiriste nó níos cinnte, dá bhfaighfí na suíocháin aonair.

Dob é tuairim an Teachta Ó Neachtain sa Dáil go raibh sé níos tábhachtaí an suíochán aonair d'fháil, go mbéadh sé sásta glacadh leis an gcóras toghchánaíochta seo chun an suíochán aonair d'fáil. Aontaím leis gurbh é an rud is tábhachtaí deireadh do chur leis na dáil-cheantair ilshuíocháin agus an suíochán aonair a bhunú. Is é sin an rud is tábhachtaí ach, ar an taobh eile de, tá mé lánchinnte go gcruthófar gurbh é an vóta díreach an córas toghchánaíochta is fearr—an t-aon chóras amháin a thugann cothram na féinne don vótálaí, a thugann an mheá chéana vótála do gach vótálaí sa tír. Mar adubhras, dob é sin tuairim an Teachta Ó Neachtain féin agus tuairim chuile eile Teachta sa Dáil mar ní bhfuair an leasú a chuir sé os comhair na Dála tacaíocht ar bith ó Theachta Dála ar bith ó dhream-an Seanadóir Mac Gearailt.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Ní raibh sé féin ann i ndeireadh na díospóireachta.

Comment on this

Tá sé sin fíor—mí raibh sé ann mar d'imríodh cleas air agus ní raibh sé ann an uair a chríochnaigh an díospóireacht ar an leasú. Do pléadh an cheist seo sa Dáil. Do pléadh í go mion agus cé gur labhair a lán daoine ar an leasú, bhí sé soiléir nach raibh duine ar bith i bhfábhar na tairiscinte a chuir an Teachta Ó Neachtain os comhair na Dála.

Comment on this

An féidir an dara rogha a thabhairt?

Comment on this

Sin ceist eile. Dubhradh liom gur phlé an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin an cheist sin aréir. De réir na comhairle atá agamsa ó lucht an dlí ní féidir é sin a dhéanamh. Nuair is gá leasú ar bith a dhéanamh ar an mBunreacht i gcás na hionadaíochta cionmhaire, caithfear i dtosach báire Bille ar leith a chur faoi bhráid dhá Theach an Oireachtais, ag léiriú cad é an leasú gur mian leis an Oireachtas a dhéanamh agus go bhfuil siad le cur os comhair na ndaoine. Mar sin is í an cheist a caithfear a chur ar an pobal ná "An bhfuil tú ag toilú leis an leasú ar an mBunreacht atá leagtha amach sna Billí um an Tríú agus um an gCeathrú Leasú?"

Sin í an t-aon cheist amháin is féidir a chur ar an bpobal. Mar sin, tá sé soiléir im thuairim-se, nach féidir an dá cheist seo a chur ar an bpobal ag an am chéanna. Ar ndóigh, d'fhéadfaí reifreann amháin a bheith ann anois agus ceann eile igceann cúpla mhí dá n-dúiltítí don chéad cheann, ach do réir mar chímíd é, bhéadh sé amaideach dom teacht isteach annseo an seachtain seo ag moladh Bille chun leasú a dhéanamh ar an mBunreacht chun an vóta direach a thabhairt isteach agus a bheith ag teacht isteach an seachtain seo chugainn ag moladh go ndéanfaí leasú eile i dtaobh an vóta ionaistrithe.

Comment on this

Má theipeann ar an irracht seo——

Comment on this

Má theipeann ar an iarracht seo d'fhéadfaimís breathnú eile do bheith againn ar an gceist. Ach, ar ndóigh, féach mar bhéadh an cheist dá ndéanfainn sin. Dá gcuirfí an dá Bhille os comhair an phobail ag an am chéana agus dá n-iarrfaí i bpaipéar amháin ar na vótóirí an bhfuil siad sásta glacadh leis an vóta díreach agus an suíocháin aonair agus, ar an bpaipéar eile, an bhfuil siad sásta glacadh leis an vóta ion-aistrithe sa suíochain aonair, d'fhéadfadh sé tuitim amach go mbéadh tromlach ag an dá thairiscint, agus tá sé soiléir nach bhféadhfaí, ar an abhar sin, an dá cheann a chur le chéile. Ar chaoi ar bith, d'aontíos sa Dáil agus aontaím fós leis an Teachta Ó Neachtain agus an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin agus le duine eile ar bith a ndeireann é, gurab é an rud is tábhachtaí ná na suíocháin aonair a fháil agus, comh fada agus a bhaineann sé liom féin, is cuma liom cén sórt córas toghacháin a bhéas ann ach tá mé lánchinnte gurab é córas an vóta dírigh an córas—an t-aon córas—is fearr chun cothrom na féinne do thabhairt do chuile vótóir, agus ó tharla gurab é sin an tuairim atá ag an Rialtas agus Partí Fianna Fáil agus ó thárla comh maith nach bhfuair an Rialtas treoir ar bith ón gCoiste a chuireadh ar bun chun iniúchadh a dhéanamh ar an mBunreacht, ó thárla gur mar sin atá, luíonn sé le nádúir gurab é sin an tairioscint a chuirfeadh Rialtas Fianna Fáil os chomhair na Dála—sé sin, an vóta díreach.

Bhí seans ag duine ar bith tariscint a chur nó cuidiú leis an tairiscint a mhol an Teachta Ó Neachtain os comhair na Dála ach níor dhein duine ar bith é sin, agus má deireann daoine anois, már deireann tuairisceoirí politíochta go háirithe gurab é na suíocháin aonraic agus an vóta ion-aistrithe a theastaoínn ó phobal na tíre, bheul is cosúil nach bhfuil mórán tuiscint ag na hionadaithe poiblí ar mheoin muintir na tíre.

Sé mo thuairm féin go bhfuil na hionadaithe poiblí in ann meon na ndaoine a thuiscint gach pioc comh maith le scriobhnóir ar bith sna páipéir.

Mar a duras, níor chualas an méid a bhí le rá ag an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin mar bhí mé as láthair agus gabhann mo leithscéal leis—ar ndóigh is minic a bhí orm mo leithscéal a gabháil leis cheanna as ucht bheith as láthair le linn dó bheith ag caint—ach dúradh liom gur iarr sé orm cad a bhí ar aigne an Rialtais maidir leis an córas toghachaín don Seanad. Bheul, caithfidh mé a adhmháil nár thugas árd ar bith ar sin go fóill. Ach, do réir mar thuigim é, tá an córas sin scríofa isteach san mBunreacht comh maith agus bhéadh gá le reifreann eile, mar is eol do'n Seanadóir chun é aistriú. Tá cosúlacht ann, áfach, go mbeidh orainn cursaí toghacháin an t-Seanaid d'aiostriú taobh amuigh de seo ar fad— beidh gá athrú a dhéanamh mar gheall ar teacht le chéile na hollscoileanna. Is féidir linn féachaint isteach sa cheist eile seo ag an am sin agus má tá moladh ar bith ag Seanadóir ar bith, le chur os ar gcóir faoi sin, féachfar isteach ann.

In the debate on these two Bills here in the Seanad, I think the first question which was raised and to which I should devote some time in replying is a question which it should not be necessary for anybody to ask. That is the question as to how it is that the Government are proposing that the Constitution should be amended as suggested in the Third Amendment Bill and the Fourth Amendment Bill. This has been explained on a number of occasions in the Dáil and I think was explained also in my opening speech here. I do not know whether there is much point in my explaining it again. However, since probably every Senator who spoke on the opposite side of the House expressed himself as being entirely mystified as to why there should be any question of amendment of the Constitution in any regard at this time, I had better go into it again.

Possibly if I go into it in some slightly greater detail something of what I say may penetrate even the closed minds of the professors and their pupils on the opposite side of the House. The allegation has been made that there has been no reason advanced as to why either of these Bills should be brought before the House. I think in order to make one more effort at at least explaining why we are making these propositions I should first of all quote the relevant sub-article of the Constitution. Article 16, Section 2, Subsection 3º of the Constitution reads:

The ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census, shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country.

That is the constitutional provision which is primarily responsible for the Government's decision to suggest to the people that the Constitution in regard to our electoral law shall be amended. That Article of the Constitution, which is substantially the same as the corresponding Article in the 1922 Constitution of the Irish Free State, was interpreted right up to the revision of constituencies enacted by the two Houses of the Oireachtas, unanimously in the Dáil and almost unanimously in the Seanad, in 1959, as giving reasonable scope to the Oireachtas to take account of practical considerations such as the existence of prominent geographical features such as mountain ranges, peninsulas and major rivers and lakes and such practical considerations as the existence of established administrative boundaries, even if these administrative boundaries did suffer from the disadvantage of having been originally devised under King John.

In 1959 a revision of constituencies was due in accordance with another provision of the Constitution which provides that revision shall take place in periods of not more than 12 years. A revision was carried out at that time in accordance with this interpretation of the Article of the Constitution which had been believed to be a correct interpretation by the Oireachtas—by the people who had in their deliberations here framed the draft Constitution which was eventually adopted by the people. That revision was unanimously accepted in the Dáil and almost unanimously accepted in the Seanad. But the Fine Gael Party——

Comment on this

It was defeated in the Seanad.

Comment on this

——who had accepted it in the Oireachtas decided to challenge it in the High Court, obviously acting on the same principle on which they acted here: that it is not what is good for the people that is relevant, but the relevant thing to be considered by Fine Gael at all times is to utilise every possible opportunity to discredit anything that is done or proposed by the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Acting on that fundamental principle that activates Fine Gael's every activity, a Fine Gael Senator in this House—he is not here now; he was here then—Senator O'Donovan employed, at his own expense I have no doubt, a Fine Gael solicitor in the other House, Deputy R. Ryan, and Deputy Ryan employed a Fine Gael junior counsel who was a Member of this House, again I have no doubt at the personal expense of Senator John O'Donovan. He employed Senator O'Quigley as his junior counsel and he employed as his senior counsel, Deputy McGilligan. These four individuals, acting entirely, of course, as individuals, without any reference to the fact that they were all members of the Fine Gael Party, conspired to bring before the High Court this measure, which had been passed unanimously by the Dáil and almost unanimously by the Seanad, and put forward their proposition that the Oireachtas had acted in breach of the Constitution by interpreting this Article of the Constitution in the way in which it had been interpreted right from the foundation of the State both in the previous form in the 1922 Irish Free State Constitution, and since the new Constitution of 1937 was enacted, and the result of that——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Conspiracy.

Comment on this

——reference to the High Court by the Fine Gael Party of this matter which they had agreed to in the House was that the High Court decided that it was not permissible to interpret the phrase "so far as it is practicable" in this way and that the Oireachtas was not entitled to take the practical considerations I have mentioned into account in delineating constituencies.

As a result of that decision, the Fianna Fáil Minister for Local Government at the time was compelled to make a fresh revision of constituencies. He did that with the best interpretation he could give of the judgment delivered by the learned judge of the High Court who made this decision. Whether his interpretation of the decision was the correct one or not is something I will discuss later. At any rate, we think it was. The revision of the constituencies that was made in accordance with the decision of the High Court was referred to the Supreme Court and they ruled that that revision of constituencies, based as it was on the decision of the High Court, was in compliance with the terms of the Constitution. Unlike the revision of constituencies that was made in 1959, and that was based on the Constitution, as interpreted by the people who framed the draft Constitution, the revision of constituencies that was based on the decision of the High Court, on the decision of the learned Justice Budd, which was procured through this manoeuvre of the Fine Gael Party, was not received with open arms by either of the Houses of the Oireachtas.

We have been asked was there any public demand for this measure. We are told there was no public demand for the measure. I do not know what means the public have for demanding things.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They can write letters to the papers.

Comment on this

Senator Sheehy Skeffington may think a few internationalists from Trinity College who go out and throw stones at the Garda constitute a public demand. Other people may think that public demand can be deduced to exist in different ways. Whether there was a public demand for this or not, there is no doubt whatever that at the time when this was a live consideration, at the time when the 1961 revision of constituencies which was imposed on the Oireachtas and on the people by the——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Constitution.

Comment on this

——manoeuvres of Fine Gael—at that time there was no doubt whether there was public demand or not. There was a unanimous demand by the public representatives in the Oireachtas that this situation of a constitutional infirmity as Deputy J. A. Costello described it should be remedied. I quote from Volume 188, column 213 of the Official Dáil Report of 12th April, 1961, when this revision of the constituencies that involved the breaching of numerous county boundaries, that involved the uprooting of people out of constituencies and counties in which they had voted all their lives, and in which they still resided. When this was under discussion, Deputy Corish, who is now Leader of the Labour Party but was not then Leader of that Party—I will quote the then Leader as well—said:

We have a peculiar situation in one county, in Kildare, which under the present proposals embodies three county council areas—and the Minister and Deputies know that as far as Parliamentary members are concerned, not alone do Deputies have to make representations in respect of the work of the Government but to a very large extent the work of local authorities also—and it seems that in these constituencies that have to deal with two or three or four local authorities, the work of the Deputies will be very difficult indeed.

That was a comparatively mild statement by Deputy Corish in 1961. This was also the complaint of a Deputy who could claim, I think, to speak with particular authority for the rural community, the late Deputy Donnellan, who spoke at column 214 of the same volume. He started off by saying:

It is regrettable that this Bill had to be introduced because of a decision of the High Court.

Later on in that column he said:

I do not welcome this Bill; I believe it is the death-knell of rural Ireland.

He went on to say:

If we are to develop along that line—I believe we are; as Deputy Dillon said and I repeat, it is nothing personal to me—representation in the near future will belong to the few cities we have and, quoting the words of a gentleman I heard speaking last Saturday night, "to a dwindling population". If that happens, it will be a bad day for the country and we are actually heading in that direction now.

In the next column Deputy Donnellan continued:

I suppose the Minister cannot help this situation. I want to be fair to him and I must say I believe that the 1959 Act that was challenged in the High Court was fairer. I supported it. I believed it was the right thing. Some people thought otherwise. The solicitors and the lawyers came into it. The courts reached a decision much to the disadvantage of rural Ireland and its people. Of course, with Fianna Fáil, the Constitution is almighty. According to them, it is the Gospel. They have an opportunity now of seeing what their Constitution is costing the people of rural Ireland. The Taoiseach was not man enough to submit the matter to a referendum so that the people might be given an opportunity of changing the relevant Article in the Constitution and getting a fair crack of the whip. There is no credit due to those who brought the action in the High Court. If the day comes that Dáil Éireann will be influenced by a completely city mentality, it will be a bad day for Ireland and for her people.

I suppose this is the best Bill the Government can bring in in the circumstances. It is as near as possible to representation for every 20,000. What will be the position if this wrong is permitted to continue? What will be the fate of the people living in the rural areas? Will the majority here be Deputies from Dublin city and Cork city and the other cities? I regret the Taoiseach did not put this by way of referendum to the people. Of course, not so long ago the Government were defeated on another referendum. I suppose they were afraid to have a referendum on a honest issue, remembering their defeat on a dishonest one. I believe that, had they sought such a referendum in this connection, they would have won.

I believe the Government are starting off in the wrong direction. What will be done now will never be undone because the position will be similar to that which obtains in the Civil Service; a precedent has been established and it cannot be changed. The position, as a result of this Bill, may go from bad to worse. Deputy Dillon talked about gerrymandering. I know something about gerrymandering; there is an electoral area now, West Galway, that never existed before. What is the reason for that?

The Minister can always assert that this is not his fault and that he wanted to leave things as they were. I suppose we will have to accept this Bill unless the lawyers see fit to contest another constitutional issue. My remarks have nothing personal in them. I protest as a public representative. I think this Bill is a step in the wrong direction. It will deprive the people in the rural areas of adequate representation. Remember, it is only a start; day after day and year after year, worse will probably come. The precedent has been established. It will be impossible to undo what is being done here now. Another Government tomorrow would probably do the same thing.

I do not know whether Deputy Donnellan had any contact with the people of his constituency or not but he declared himself to be speaking as a public representative. I do not know in what other way the people of Deputy Donnellan's constituency could have made their views known, unless they were to do it in the manner favoured by some of Senator Sheehy Skeffington's associates. This was at a time when this injustice on the people in many parts of rural Ireland was in the process of being perpetrated.

Now another revision of constituencies is called for, if the terms of the Constitution are to be complied with. What happened in 1961 will be as nothing compared with what must happen now, if the terms of the Constitution are not amended, and if they have to be complied with in the same way as in 1961. The people, I will quite agree, have not made any great demands yet for this because they have not seen what is going to happen and the injustice that resulted from what happened in 1961, has become reasonably well established and the people of County Louth who have to vote in Monaghan, the people of Waterford who have to cross the Comeragh mountains to meet their representatives, the people of Roscommon who have to vote in Mayo, the people of Leitrim, some of whom find themselves voting in Roscommon and some in Sligo, the people of Meath and Westmeath who are attached to County Kildare and the people of Wexford who had to be uprooted and transferred to the two-county constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny.

I do not think all these have become completely satisfied with the disruption that the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the High Court imposed upon them in 1961 but they have become accustomed to it and the new arrangements that will have to be made now have not yet come into operation, and the people who will be affected do not know that they are going to be affected and they have not made a demand; but I have no doubt that if the Government went ahead and revised the constituencies in accordance with the present position and made no effort to comply with the unanimous demand of all the Opposition Parties in 1961 to amend the Constitution in this regard, and if we brought in a revision of constituencies based on this interpretation of the Constitution that was extracted by this Fine Gael team of lawyers from the High Court, if we did that, what was said by these Deputies in the Dáil——

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to cast aspersions on a decision of the High Court?

Comment on this

If Senator Quinlan had his way, the people would not vote at all. We would just hand it over to the professors and let them decide on a computer who should represent them in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Is the Minister casting aspersions on a decision of the High Court?

Comment on this

I am castigating the Fine Gael manoeuvre, the Fine Gael team of lawyers who saw an opportunity of discrediting the Fianna Fáil Government——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Of vindicating the Constitution.

Comment on this

——and of making money for themselves on the side. I am casting no reflection on Judge Budd. I do not think he ever did a day's electioneering in his life except possibly when he was a candidate for the Seanad. I do not quarrel with his decision. I am quite sure he interpreted the Constitution in accordance with the correct legal interpretation of the words there.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

So they did vindicate the Constitution then?

Comment on this

They did secure this interpretation of the Constitution from the High Court but I have no doubt that if we were to revise the constituencies in accordance with this requirement and to bring a Bill before the Houses of the Oireachtas without having made any attempt to comply with the unanimous demand to amend the Constitution, then the criticism and the demands that we received in 1961 would pale into insignificance beside the criticisms and the attacks that would be made on us if we did what it would be necessary to do now. Mind you, I am going to say before I sit down exactly what would be required now.

On that occasion when the revision of constituencies in 1961 was being discussed in the Dáil, the then Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, spoke on the matter. I quote from column 226 of the same volume. Deputy Norton said:

The courts have decided that the last Electoral Bill was ultra vires the Constitution; consequently some other Bill had to be introduced and this is the Bill we got. It is worth the time of the House to dwell for a few moments on the situation in which we have been landed by the Constitution, by the courts and by all the legal people who advised the Government. The courts' decision is that the last Bill which gave a seat in constituencies with fewer than 20,000 of a population per seat was ultra vires the Constitution. That has been the position in many constituencies since the Constitution was passed over 20 years ago.

He went on at the end of the same column:

... our legislation in the past has been based upon the assumption that if we did not get the 20,000 in each constituency, it was good enough to get it in the country as a whole.

At column 230, Deputy Norton said:

I think it is crazy to do what is being done with some constituencies. I represent the constituency of Kildare which is known everywhere as a clearly defined territorial area. In order to box the compass in connection with the results at the next election, Kildare has a chunk of south Meath clamped on to it at one end, and an extreme corner of Westmeath at another end. Now to the constituency which consists of the County of Kildare, a chunk of south Meath and a chunk of Westmeath are being added, and it will be all grouped under the heading of Kildare, although that substantial portion will not in fact be Kildare, but portion of two other counties. The only effect of that is effectively to disfranchise people who live in south Meath, and people who live in Longford and Westmeath, because of the fact that those areas are not big enough, or not numerically strong enough, to ensure representation for the counties of which they are a natural part. They will be, as it were, just small lungs of Kildare. I think that is a most undesirable way of trying to create constituencies.

At the end of the column, Deputy Norton said:

It is obviously desirable that we should endeavour to get parliamentary representation to run side by side with local representation. Deputies know that in the course of their duties they have, inevitably, to make representations to local authorities when the business of their constituents requires them to do so. That is not such a difficult job if you have to make representations to the local authority for the area you represent, but if two or three other local authorities are added to the main local authority, a situation will arise which will become unmanageable, and especially unmanageable with regard to the virtues we were told 12 or 18 months ago the small single member constituency had.

I do not blame the Government for introducing a Bill to deal with this situation. A Bill had to be introduced. That was inevitable after the decision of the High Court, but it is quite clear that the Constitution which imposes upon us the responsibilities now clearly defined by the Court, is a Constitution which should be amended...

At column 231 Deputy Norton said:

I think the decision of the judge compelling us to butcher these constituencies in this way is not a satisfactory solution to the whole question of the delineation of constituencies.

Someone ought to have a new look at the situation created by the legal decision, created by the necessity of making Parliament work, making the constituencies work and making them sufficiently homogeneous to ensure that the system of Parliamentary representation so reached will continue to give satisfactory results locally to the electorate, and satisfactory results from the standpoint of having the constituencies adequately represented in Parliament to ensure that their viewpoint will be put adequately and without impairment on the floor of this House.

He concluded:

If we pass this Bill in this most unsatisfactory position we shall leave large portions of the population virtually disfranchised. Some effort should be made to get out the dead timber in the Constitution in that respect and to give us, at least for the subsequent general election, a method of Parliamentary general election which will conform to modern conditions of Parliamentary representation and independent thinking.

Deputy Norton who was then Leader of the Labour Party considered that this requirement of the Constitution which is interpreted at the behest of the Fine Gael Party in this way resulted in the virtual disfranchisement of large portions of the population. Now Senator FitzGerald, and as far as I know all the Senators on the opposite side of the House, believe that far from disfranchising large portions of the population, what it does is ensures their democratic rights for the people of Meath, who were uprooted from their own county and from the constituency in which they had voted all their lives and tacked on to County Kildare, as Deputy Norton said, that it was in vindication of their democratic rights because of course they would suffer terribly if it took fractionally more votes in County Meath to elect a Deputy than in County Westmeath.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is 40 per cent fractionally more?

Comment on this

There may be people who have more contact with the people of Meath than I have and they may know from their contact with the people of Meath that those people were overjoyed when they were transferred out of Meath and into Kildare. Now, according to the assurances they are given by the Fine Gael lawyers, their vote would have the same effect exactly in electing a Deputy as the votes of the people in Kildare. It may be that the changing about of the populations of County Meath and Kildare that would have to take place now would also be received with open arms by the people concerned, by their public representatives and by the political Party organisations. Certainly, it was not received in that way in 1961. If it is part of the function of the Government to try to interpret public demand, I think a unanimous expression of opinion—and I have not finished quoting them yet——

Comment on this

The Chair understands that the House wishes to adjourn from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m.?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It would be in order to continue if there was any possibility of the Minister concluding in a reasonable time, but I suspect he wants to speak at some length.

Comment on this

I certainly want to deal with a lot of your misstatements, but not all of them, that would be impossible.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Unless the Minister hopes to conclude within an hour or an hour and a half, an adjournment would probably be better.

Business suspended at 1.5 p.m. and resumed at 2.10 p.m.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should just like to raise the question of the luncheon break. If a luncheon break is to be abbreviated to make it shorter than normal, I think it should be done by advance agreement and certainly not decided and announced without even an opportunity to discuss the point. The validity of my complaint is vindicated now by the fact that it is nearer to 2.15 than 2 o'clock. It has not been possible to confine the break to one hour. Those who took the matter seriously and who took the trouble to be back on time are put in an unfavourable position.

Comment on this

In answer to Opposition queries as to why these measures are before the House, I have quoted some Deputies on the subject of the revision of the constituencies in 1961. The reason for these quotations is to show that all sides of the House demanded that the situation established by the interpretation of the Constitution by the High Court was an undesirable one and one that should be altered. I have quoted Deputy Corish, the Leader of the Labour Party, and the then Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, and also Deputy Donnellan who claimed to be in a special position to speak for the rural community. That may not be regarded as a reasonably comprehensive cross-section of the public representatives and I think in order to establish that what I say is right and that there was the closest possible indication of a unanimous demand from public representatives for this amendment at that time, I should quote some other opinions expressed.

Another Labour Party Deputy, Deputy Desmond, spoke at great length regarding the situation that was created and naturally with particular reference to another part of the country at column 250 of volume 188 of the Dáil Reports. He said.

Where do the people in West Waterford stand now? To whom will they send their inquiries? Is it to a person representing them who may live in Tipperary? Will they expect him to contact the local authority office in Waterford in order to get fair play for them?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

"The court, thanks be to God, gave the final decision"—a little bit muddled, I must admit.

Comment on this

In the next column Deputy Desmond said:

It was amazing this evening to listen to some Fianna Fáil members bemoaning the terrible position of rural Ireland because of the decision of the High Court. I had hoped that in view of the decision of the High Court, the Taoiseach would move for an amendment of the Constitution, where necessary, to give protection to rural Ireland. Apparently, neither the Taoiseach nor the Minister was prepared to do that. There is no use in the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil now complaining that the people of rural Ireland are being robbed of their rights when, in actual fact, the only people who could restore those rights to them and improve on them, if they wished, were the Taoiseach, the Minister for Local Government, the Fianna Fáil Government and Party. They refused to do so.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would the Minister quote Deputy Lindsay, Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Sherwin?

Comment on this

It was not only the members of the Labour Party who spoke. There was a Party known as Clann na Talmhan which was one of the Parties swallowed up into the ravenous maw of the Fine Gael Party and which Fine Gael hope will soon be followed by the Labour Party which they are now inviting to go into the same position in order to revive temporarily the Fine Gael Party. Deputy T. Lynch, who was a Fine Gael Deputy, also spoke on this matter and at column 257 of the same report he said:

I am glad I voted against the Constitution. I never thought it was any good and the High Court has proved that it was no good. It was obvious to the Government what they could have done and they would not do it. They could have attempted to amend the Constitution. They attempted to amend it with their referendum in order to keep themselves in office.

Further down he said:

In Waterford, we have three members representing this butchered constituency.

This word "butchered" I take out of the mouths of Fine Gael and Labour and Clann na Talmhan Deputies, and I want to point out that it is not I who invented this description. These terms "butchered" and "dismemberment" were used in 1961 by members of the Coalition Parties. I quote again from what Deputy Lynch said:

In Waterford, we have three members representing this butchered constituency. There is the whole of the Nore valley and that part of the west of Waterford, Ballyduff and down the Blackwater valley to Lismore, Cappoquin and Tallow, traditional Waterford places which have been turned over to County Tipperary. It is a scandalous state of affairs that this enormous slice of a constituency is being taken away.

Later on, at column 269, Deputy Kyne of the Labour Party said:

The people of Lismore, Cappoquin, Tallow, Four-Mile-Water, Ballymacarbury, Villierstown, Aglish and Templemichael are as rural as the people in Donegal and they are to be deprived of their right to a Waterford Deputy. They are to be transferred to South Tipperary. Deputy Loughman or any other Deputy from South Tipperary will never be able to represent them. The natural alignment is with their own county.

Then he said:

What will happen when these people from Tallow to within six miles of my own town, a distance of 30 miles, are transferred into South Tipperary? If a South Tipperary representative, whether he be Labour, Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil, wants to raise some matter in connection with county affairs or the health services, he will have to write to the county manager in Dungarvan. If he wants to raise matters in connection with, say, the free milk scheme or the assisted footwear scheme, the South Tipperary Deputy will have no right to interfere. All he can do is write a letter. He is not likely to come down from Cashel, Clonmel or wherever he may be in Tipperary to attend a meeting of the county council in Dungarvan in order to help them out. I know the fate of isolated areas like that: they get a visit just prior to the election. But when these people were within the confines of their natural constituency of Waterford, they were taken care of.

Deputy Manley, another Fine Gael Deputy, said at column 311:

There is one particularly regrettable feature in the chopping up of some counties. We cannot complain on that score in Cork, but some counties have been ruthlessly chopped in order to get the necessary proportion. The county is the administrative unit, so far as local authority goes. There is invariably a certain rivalry between counties. There is a certain clannishness in counties, to the extent very often that people in one county will not vote for someone from a neighbouring county or another county. That is a grave danger in this Bill. I would much prefer to cut down representation and leave the county as the unit. I would regard that as more practicable in the long run.

At column 313, another Fine Gael Deputy from County Louth, which is another county affected by this exercise in theoretical democracy, had this to say:

Coming from County Louth, I should like to assure the Minister that, whilst I sympathise with his position to a certain extent, the people in County Louth area affected, an area which will be put into County Monaghan, are very resentful of the intentions of this Bill.

"the intentions of this Bill," which, according to the theorists in the Fine Gael Front Bench, were to vindicate the democratic rights of these people of County Louth who, because they were, in accordance with the mathematical formula, entitled to something like 3.3 Deputies instead of three, had to be put into County Monaghan. This was to vindicate their democratic rights, but the Fine Gael Deputy representing the area described the reaction of these people to being taken out of County Louth and put into County Monaghan as being very resentful. Admittedly, that is seven years ago and those people may have become acclimatised to their new situation of being in County Monaghan instead of County Louth. However, now the position is they have to go back and another slice of the population at the other end of County Louth will have to go somewhere else. I would say that Deputy Coburn was probably right, and just as the people of Ardee resented being put into County Monaghan the last time, the people who will now be put into County Meath will be resentful also. They are not resentful yet because it has not happened and therefore they have not had the occasion to express their resentment to their public representatives. But I have no doubt that they will be resentful if this happens. It was in order to avoid all this resentment and to avoid this type of attack in the Dáil and in the Seanad that we decided we should now respond to the unanimous demand of the Opposition, speaking on behalf of the people they represent, and that we should, as requested by so many of them, move to amend the Constitution in this regard.

Deputy Coburn went on to say:

Various opinions were expressed by both Fianna Fáil supporters and Fine Gael supporters. They all resent being put into a separate county, being detached from their existing native county of Louth and put into Monaghan.

Earlier this evening, Deputy Faulkner pointed out——

Deputy Faulkner was a Fianna Fáil Deputy. I have refrained from quoting Fianna Fáil opinion because I know that to mention a Fianna Fáil Deputy's opinion is to ensure the uncompromising opposition of every Member on the Opposition benches. However, Deputy Coburn said:

Earlier this evening Deputy Faulkner pointed out that County Louth was a constituency which had enjoyed all down the years since the foundation of this State its own natural boundaries. Admittedly, there were years ago two constituencies in that small county, North and South Louth, but, as a county, its boundaries were always respected. I think it is a very retrograde step for the Minister at this stage to tamper with our boundaries.

While I am on Deputy Coburn, at that time there was another County Louth representative in the Seanad, Senator Donegan, as he then was. Senator Donegan was not pleased with what would happen to that constituency either. He spoke on this question in the Seanad and, as reported in the Official Report, volume 54, column 519, said:

They have now a principal town in Louth, the town of Ardee, which has its town commissioners and they have to deal with the Louth county manager. This town, as far as local administration is concerned, has to deal with the Louth County Council, but at the same time it is in the constituency of Monaghan. I know that in a county area perhaps it would not be quite so serious, but in a town of that kind things which are required by the county council can crop up.

Senator Donegan, as he then was, is no longer in this House, but Senator O'Quigley is. I have here a copy of Senator O'Quigley's contribution to the debate on the revision of the constituencies. It is quite clear that Senator O'Quigley also considered it wrong, considered it an injustice to the people concerned, and presumably also to their public representatives, that this type of carving up of the counties should have to take place. He laid the blame squarely on the Constitution. He implied, in other words, that this was something that was wrong, something that should not happen, but that the blame was on the Constitution. Therefore, I think he obviously implied that the Constitution should be amended if justice were to be done. He absolved his client in the High Court action, Senator O'Donovan, from all blame and laid it instead on the Constitution. I think he was quite right to say that the legal interpretation of the Constitution required that this should be done. Therefore I think Senator O'Quigley was quite right on that occasion in suggesting that the Constitution was at fault and that we should remedy this injustice by amending the Constitution.

As reported at column 490, volume 54 of the Official Report of Thursday, 25th May, 1961, Senator O'Quigley said:

One of the great arguments which brought forth the condemnation and wrath of many people on this Bill is the fact that the county boundaries have been broken into. Let us be quite clear on this. It is not the action of Senator O'Donovan which has brought about this; it is the requirement of the Constitution which has brought it about.

As reported at column 494 of the same volume Senator O'Quigley, who is now so tenaciously determined to hang on to the present position, said:

Therefore, the breach of the boundaries is due, in fact, to the provisions of the 1937 Constitution and nothing else.

As reported at column 497 of the same volume, he said:

It is useless to try to hoodwink the people into believing that the extraordinary manner in which the Minister, for his own purposes and the purposes of his Party, has carved up the country is due to the result of the action taken in the High Court. Rather is it due to the provisions of the Constitution, the provisions which were taken over in 1937, and which could have been amended by ordinary legislation for three years after the first President had been elected.

Senator O'Quigley foresaw the position as it exists today, because at the end of the column he said:

... there can be no doubt whatever that in the next revision of constituencies, county boundaries will also have to be broken into. It would be impossible in certain counties, which I shall not name, to give representation without adding on parts of adjoining areas.

With regard to the question of whether there was a demand for this measure that at least shows that it was reasonable for the Government to assume the Opposition felt that in order to establish a position in which the community in general would be justly treated with regard to Dáil representation, this amendment was required.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would the Minister quote the divergent views of Deputy Coburn, Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Ryan, Deputy M. O'Higgins, Deputy Lindsay, Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Sherwin in this allegedly unanimous debate?

Comment on this

I know this much. Senator FitzGerald who, apparently, is now in control of the Fine Gael Party has decided that it is in the interests of the Fine Gael Party to effect a division of the Irish people on the lines of the urban community versus the rural community. Before I finish, I will give many examples of this new approach which now activates the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That does not answer the question.

Comment on this

People like Deputy Sherwin were not affected.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Lindsay?

Comment on this

Deputy Lindsay is on his way to Dublin, is he not? He is one of the Senator's competitors for a seat in Dublin. Is it not because there are too many applicants for seats in the Dublin area that the Fine Gael Party have decided to try to steal from the rest of Ireland seats to which they are fully entitled and allocate them to Dublin so as to make room for Deputy Lindsay, two of the three, Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy O'Donnell, who are all migrating from rural Ireland in anticipation of the day when rural Ireland will be occupied only by——

Comment on this

The NFA.

Comment on this

——entrepreneurs with farms supporting a minimum of 400 cows?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister is avoiding my question.

Comment on this

It is in anticipation of that day that these people decided to migrate to the Dublin area to look for seats in the future. Apparently there will be two Fine Gael vacancies, but they are thereby providing competition for seats for Senator FitzGerald and Senator O'Quigley— although I do not think there is much to fear from him—for any seats that may be available in the Dublin area. This is part of the reason this attempt is being made to rob parts of the country of seats to which they are fully entitled. I intend to show— whether it be before tea or after tea —that they are entitled to these seats.

Comment on this

Today?

Comment on this

It might be next week: I do not know. It all depends on how long Senator FitzGerald and his assistants keep me with their interruptions. I intend to show him and his friends—next Monday or Tuesday or some other day——

Comment on this

That is a terrible admission.

Comment on this

When I actually do it depends mainly on whether or not Senator FitzGerald can contain himself and on how much of his by-election disruptive tactics he intends to utilise here. I think I have shown that this is not a measure that was inspired solely by the Fianna Fáil Party. Well, I suppose the Senator can hardly interrupt me from outside.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I shall be back.

Comment on this

I think I have shown that there was a demand from all Parties in the Dáil and from both Houses of the Oireachtas for it. In 1961, we did not comply with this demand. For one thing, there was not time. A general election was due. We believed there was not time to pilot a Bill to make the necessary amendment to the Constitution through the two Houses of the Oireachtas and to have a referendum, and to revise the constituencies again, in accordance with the amended Constitution—to do all this—before the next general election was due. We did not, therefore, comply with this demand at that time and we did not do it after the election either because the situation—undesirable and unjust as it was—had in fact then been established. The people had voted for representatives in the new constituencies that were imposed all over the country and Deputies had been elected for those areas. Presumably, the Party organisations had adjusted themselves to the new situation as well as it was possible for them to do it and a revision of constituencies was not constitutionally due for some considerable time. Taking all these factors into consideration, we let the situation stay as it was. In any case, of course, we were within a year or two years of the previous referendum.

The 1965 general election was carried out on this same scheme—the same grotesque constituencies—because the position had been established. We did not think that chopping and changing at frequent intervals was in itself desirable. Therefore, we let the situation continue as it had been established in accordance with the decision of the High Court. However, since then a new factor has come into it. The results of the 1966 Census of Population have been published. Certain Members of the Dáil were very quick to see that these results disclosed that a number of the constituencies— in particular, the ones for which they themselves were elected—were not in compliance with the provisions of Article 16.3 of the Constitution which says that the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census, shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country. They were quick to see that, at the present time, this is not in fact the position.

A number of Dáil Questions were put down to me as to what I proposed to do about it. As I say, it was obvious that what they contended was true and that these constituencies were not in compliance with the terms of the Constitution as we interpreted the decision of the High Court. We interpreted that decision in as liberal a way as it was possible to do so—as indicating that a divergence of five per cent was acceptable.

Looking through the existing constituencies and basing the consideration of them on the assumption that a five per cent divergence from the national average of population per Deputy was permissible, it was obvious that, on the basis of the results of the 1966 census, of the 38 existing constituencies only 14 were in compliance with the terms of the Constitution and the other 24 were out of line with this interpretation of the Constitution—18 of them having a population per Deputy which was too low and six having a population per Deputy which was too high.

We had this demand, then, for a revision of constituencies. It appeared that this demand was one that would have to be complied with. Therefore, the question of whether to comply with this demand and to revise the constituencies in accordance with the legal interpretation of the Constitution or to comply with the demand of the Opposition Parties in the Dáil and Seanad for a revision or for an amendment of the Constitution so as to make this unnecessary, naturally arose.

The Government decided, now that the question had become a live issue, that we would respond to the demand that had been made, the demand to remove what Deputy J. A. Costello described as a "constitutional infirmity," and that we would do this before carrying out the revision that was now required by the Constitution, although it is only seven years since the last revision of the constituencies in 1961. So, in reply to the Opposition queries as to why this Bill is before the House, the answer is that that is the reason. That is why we are deciding to give the people the opportunity of remedying this requirement to inflict an injustice on a large section of the people—to disfranchise them, as was said here.

The only criticism we could reasonably expect was that the amount of scope we were asking, to avoid doing these things, was too small. As we are on this question of why this measure is before the House, I think it is only natural that we on this side of the House should exercise our minds as to why it is that the Opposition have so changed their opinion within the past seven years, the opinion that what had happened in 1961 was unjust to the people in that it resulted in the disfranchising of large sections of the community and inflicted an injustice on them that amounted to butchery and dismemberment——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was not the opinion of the Opposition or of its Leaders.

Comment on this

——and that it sounded the death-knell of rural Ireland. If it continues to obtain, it could be interpreted as giving the all-clear to Senator FitzGerald to put the Fine Gael plan in relation to rural Ireland into operation.

Comment on this

That is the pious hope.

Comment on this

Obviously, the only possible reason for the change of attitude on the part of the Fine Gael Party is that these further seven years of frustrated opposition have emphasised and consolidated their, by now, traditional attitude of applying only the one test to every proposal that comes forward from the Government——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

——the test of principle.

Comment on this

——the test that, if it is put forward by Fianna Fáil, they, as the Opposition, must oppose it. That is their attitude. This is the only test applied by anybody on the Opposition benches—even by the rugged Independent himself from Cork. The rugged Independent is a simple individual. He just applies the same test as Fine Gael and asks "Do Fianna Fáil propose it? If they do I must oppose it." That is his interpretation of rugged Independence. If Fianna Fáil propose it, it is wrong. That is his interpretation with regard to what we look upon as a necessity, to give the people an opportunity of amending the Constitution in this regard in order to avoid injustice. The question naturally arises: what exactly is the present constitutional requirement? In the Dáil discussion the two main Opposition speakers, Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy Ryan, could not agree on what the present position is. I do not know whether Senators can. I could not detect any agreement here either.

Deputy Ryan who was the solicitor in the High Court case had a completely different point of view in regard to the position to the chief Opposition spokesman, Deputy Fitzpatrick. At columns 41 to 43 in Volume 235 of the Official Report where I was disorderly enough to interject, when the Deputy was speaking, the following sentence:

That was because the court permitted the five per cent divergence.

the Deputy replied:

The court allowed no such thing, and typical of the utterly false propaganda being advanced in support of this despicable proposal is the one that the courts have allowed a five per cent divergence.

Comment on this