We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 158–299 of 464. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The court never laid down what the divergence was.

Comment on this

I am quoting Deputy Ryan, who went on to say:

The courts have allowed no divergence from equality in so far as equality is practicable. The courts have said, because our Constitution says and because the people of Ireland said, equality should operate in the ratio between population and Deputy as far as it was practicable. In relation to the 1961 revision equality as far as it was practicable was operated. The courts have not said that a five per cent divergence is permissible. That is not what the courts said. That is not what the Constitution says. That is not what the law at the moment says and that is why I queried last week the ruling out of order of an amendment when the reason for ruling it out of order was supposed to be that the law at the moment allowed a five per cent divergence. The law allows no divergence whatsoever. It says it shall be equal as far as practicable.

It is open to this House and to the Seanad now under our existing law to make a re-arrangement of constituencies but there is an obligation on this House and on the other House to make the ratio between the population and Deputies equal as far as practicable. This House and the Seanad have no right to assume, and nobody has any right to assume, that the courts would allow a five per cent differential in the year 1968, because if it were possible to arrange the constituencies with equality without any differential, that is the obligation which would lie on us to achieve and it is that equality which the Minister and the Government are now seeking to depart from. They are now saying that no longer will there be an obligation to achieve that equality. We are to allow a divergence which is going to disfranchise almost one-third of the people living in the urban areas compared with their politically more powerful cousins down the country.

And note "down the country". The emphasis is on "down". I have drawn a line under it and Deputy Ryan underlined it when he was talking. In 1961, of course, the Fine Gael view was that the people who in order to comply with this requirement had to be removed from one county to another would be disfranchised. Now it is the urban people whose numbers will be assessed by including the numbers of visitors in hotels, students in colleges, babies in maternity homes and patients in the regional hospitals who will be disfranchised. Deputy Ryan said that there was no divergence at all permitted. Deputy Ryan has the same view as Senator FitzGerald that this is merely an exercise in figures, merely a question of figures.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What is practicable.

Comment on this

There is no appreciation of the fact that the figures represent human beings. That does not enter into it; it is purely an exercise in figures. I suppose it is part of Senator FitzGerald's training to deal in figures only and ignore the fact that these figures represent human beings. However, the chief Opposition spokesman in the Dáil, Deputy T. J. Fitzpatrick, has a completely different idea about what the legal position is and on the same day in the same volume at column 106, he said:

The Minister is misquoting the judgment. The judgment said that 17 per cent was too high. It said absolutely nothing between 17 and four per cent.

Deputy Fitzpatrick's case apparently is on the one hand that the position at present is substantially what we are trying to achieve——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Where is the contradiction? I am waiting to hear it.

Comment on this

If the Senator cannot see the contradiction——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The High Court ruled that 17 per cent was too much.

Comment on this

I would not be so foolish as to try to elucidate anything for the Senator.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There is no contradiction. We have established that.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick maintains that the position is substantially the position that we are trying to make clear in the Bill, whereas Deputy Ryan says we must have absolute mathematical accuracy with regard to equality and that the court allows no divergence whatever. You can take your choice of what the Opposition attitude is. While Deputy Fitzpatrick maintains that the position is as we want it to be he is at the same time equally determined with the other urban orientated Deputies and Senators to ensure that the Constitution is not amended so as to make it clear that what he says is the position is in fact the position. I do not know what interpretation the Opposition place on the present legal position. I have long ago given up any attempt to try to interpret the mind of Fine Gael. They change from day to day and from year to year and they change in accordance with what they believe to be the Fianna Fáil attitude and also in accordance with the oscillations in the control of the Fine Gael Party between the Law Library and the UCD campus.

In government, with regard to this question of the delineation of constituencies, you have a practical job to do and in order to do that, you have to try to have some reasonable idea of what is permissible and what is not. In order to do that in 1961, the Minister for Local Government tried to assess from the mass of verbiage which constituted the decision of the High Court just exactly what the position is. I admit that nowhere in the judgment does it state clearly and definitively that a divergence of five per cent is permissible. That, apparently, would not be the legal way to do things. That would not provide scope for people like Deputy Ryan, Senator O'Quigley and ex-Deputy McGilligan to enrich themselves by deriving part of their incomes from constitutional wrangling.

I agree that it is not all that clear, but on page 143 of Irish Reports, Budd, J. 1961, O'Donovan v. The Attorney General, it is stated:

Another suggestion was to divide Galway into two constituencies, West Galway with three seats, and East Galway with five seats. It was submitted that this could be done fairly simply by transferring the nine electoral divisions of Carmore, Clare-galway, Annaghdown, Ballinduff, Donaghpatrick, Headford, Kilcoona, Killeany and Kilursa, with a joint population of 5,166 to West Galway and consolidating the remainder of the other two existing constituencies. For clarity I set out the result:— Suggested constituency, West Galway, 3 seats, population 60,269, ratio of members to population 1 to 20,089; East Galway 5 seats, population 95,284, ratio of members to population 1 to 19,057.

That represents 1,070 below the national average at that time. Budd, J. went on to say:

Both suggestions would constitute constituencies with a ratio of members to population reasonably close to the national average. These illustrations show what is practicable in these instances and may be compared with what in fact has been done.

Now, in trying to arrive at an idea as to what scope was available to the Oireachtas in revising constituencies, I think it was only natural to assume that a divergence of 1,000 from the national average, or five per cent, was, in the view of the court, reasonably close to the national average and the revision of constituencies in 1961 was, in fact, based on that interpretation of the decision of Budd, J. It was submitted to the Supreme Court; the Supreme Court ruled on it and found it to be constitutional. At another stage in the report, at page 154, Budd, J. gave the same indication as to the divergence which he considered was permissible when he said:

Moreover, in so far as the City and County of Dublin is concerned we know for a positive fact that the figures can be worked out so that the difference in ratio does not exceed 1,000.

Any normal person endeavouring to interpret the legal position as established in the High Court as a result of the Fine Gael manoeuvres in that court, would, I think, assume that the court regarded a divergence of 1,000 from the national average as a reasonable divergence. That was permissible and the 1961 revision was based on that. It was found to be constitutional by the Supreme Court, so that, in looking at the present position and trying to see what would have to happen if the revision required were to be carried out in accordance with the present constitutional requirements, any normal person would assume that a divergence of five per cent would be permissible.

That is what I assumed. Deputy Ryan says I am wrong: that there is no divergence permitted. Of course, if he is right, the situation would be even worse than the situation that disclosed itself to me as a result of my examination. On the other hand, Deputy Fitzpatrick also says I am wrong. He says there is no specified limit to the divergence permissible and he relies on the Supreme Court decision on the 1961 scheme of constituencies. This is, of course, the point: the Supreme Court were merely giving a decision on the 1961 scheme of constituencies. They gave no indication whatever of reversing Mr. Justice Budd's decision and, therefore, so far as there is any law on the matter, it is clearly Mr. Justice Budd's decision.

It is true that the Supreme Court did say that it was, in the first instance, a matter for the Oireachtas. But it went on to say that a scheme could quite rightly be referred to the court and ruled on and it could only be assumed that they agreed with Mr. Justice Budd's ruling because they gave no indication whatsoever of disagreeing with its general tenor. What does this amount to? The Oireachtas could do what they liked and then refer the matter to the courts and the courts would tell the Oireachtas whether or not they may do this. That means, of course, that the Oireachtas can do what they like and I suggest that the only reasonable assumption one can make is that a maximum divergence of five per cent can be made on the national average in revising constituencies.

Members of the judiciary and members of the legal profession, particularly people like Deputy Ryan and Senator O'Quigley, and other prominent members of Fine Gael in the Dáil and Seanad, who get part of their income from constitutional wrangling, may see nothing objectionable in this process, that is, that the Minister for Local Government should, first of all, make a revision of constituencies, that he should then bring it laboriously through the two Houses of the Oireachtas, and then refer it to the Supreme Court. If the Supreme Court happen to find it to their liking, well and good. If they do not find it to their liking, then the Minister will have to go through the whole process all over again, until eventually, as a result of trial and error an acceptable scheme is arrived at. But the Oireachtas have a practical job of work to do and surely it is reasonable to expect that it should be known in advance just what can be done and what cannot be done?

We have tried to operate on the basis of Mr. Justice Budd's decision and we believe that decision indicates as clearly as it is possible to indicate that a divergence of five per cent would be constitutionally acceptable. Deputy Ryan and Senator O'Quigley say that that is wrong, that no divergence is permissible. Deputy Fitzpatrick says there is no definite limit laid down to the permissible divergence below 17 per cent. We believe there is a permitted divergence but that it is so small as to be of no use from the point of view of avoiding breaching county boundaries, and so on. If Deputy Ryan's viewpoint is right—it is, apparently, also the viewpoint of Senator FitzGerald—then the proposal in the Third Amendment Bill is designed to introduced a minimal degree of flexibility where there is at present an unreasonable rigidity. If Deputy Fitzpatrick is right, we are merely clearifying the position and making it intelligible to the layman by putting an upper limit where, according to Deputy Fitzpatrick, there is none at present. If Deputy John A. Costello is right, we are rectifying a constitutional infirmity in the only way in which it is possible to rectify it. All these different viewpoints in the Opposition are, of course, crystallised into an attitude of opposition to the Bill because it has been put forward by Fianna Fáil, even though it can be clearly shown to have been in response to the unanimous demand by the Opposition Parties.

One thing that is clear is that anyone setting out to revise constituencies has to make some assumption about the degree of exactness in relation to parity of population per seat, which can be regarded as being as near as practicable, and the only assumption I can make is that that is a maximum of five per cent. On the basis of 144 Deputies and the population figure arrived at in the 1966 census, the national average of population per Deputy is 20,028. In examining what would have to be done to comply with the demand to revise constituencies, I have assumed that, in present circumstances, a maximum population of 21,028 per Deputy would be permitted and that a minimum population of 19,028 would be permitted. In other words, the maximum population in a three-seat constituency would be 63,084, in a four-seat constituency, 84,112 and, in a five-seat constituency, 105,140.

I have assumed that if a constituency has more than these numbers but less than would be sufficient to justify an extra representative, it must either unload some of the surplus population and retain its present representation or it must receive an addition of population from an adjoining area and gain an extra representative or representatives. I have also assumed that the minimum population allowable in a three-seat constituency is 57,084, in a four-seat constituency, 76,112 and in a five-seat constituency, 95,140. So that a constituency with less than the minimum population appropriate to its present number of seats must receive an addition to retain its representation or unload some of its population so as to reduce the numbers at least to the maximum for the next lower number of seats provided, of course, that that would not be lower than three.

The 1959 revision of constituencies was based on what Deputy Fitzpatrick says is the law according to the Supreme Court. That revision of constituencies was declared to be unconstitutional by the High Court and the Supreme Court did not contradict it.

The 1961 revision of constituencies was based on the assumption I have mentioned and that assumption was based on Mr. Justice Budd's decision. It is clear, as I said, that the only possible assumption is that a maximum divergence of five per cent from the national average is allowed and a revision is now required because 24 out of the 38 constituencies are no longer in compliance with the Constitution and it must be clear to most people that even if there are only 24 out of the 38 constituencies out of line, the solution of the problem in these 24 places will inevitably involve other constituencies, that when you have to deal with a situation in one constituency by transferring population to it or from it, it is inevitable or almost inevitable, at any rate, that a chain reaction will be set up. I will show, for instances, that what has to happen in the Cavan-Monaghan area does affect other constituencies and other countries right down to the County Kildare, if not, indeed, right down to Wexford.

In the same way what has to happen —and happen completely unjustifiably and unnecessarily—in Donegal and Clare, will affect each county in the Province of Connacht and will, in fact, affect one county to the extent of removing it completely as a separate recognisable entity from the whole scheme of constituencies.

In Dublin, you would only have to start from scratch. It would not be feasible to deal with the Dublin situation on the basis of chopping and changing, adding and subtracting, in existing constituencies.

Even apart from the breaching of county boundaries and the injustice and disfranchisement this inflicts on the people concerned, frequent changing of the constituencies as is now required after each census is unfair to the people, to their public representatives and to Party organisations which, being composed of voluntary workers, are deserving also of some consideration.

It is interesting to see what the approach of Opposition Deputies to what is now required was. I just think it appropriate to give some indication of the irresponsible way in which Opposition Deputies approach this. At Volume 233, column 1722 of the Official Report for April 3rd, 1968, Deputy Harte said, referring to his own county of Donegal:

We have at the present time two constituencies, each sending three Deputies to the House, and if commonsense is to be observed and if the Constitution is to be honoured, it should be one constituency sending back five Deputies. This will be conceded by anybody with limited intelligence, who devotes any time to the political scene in Donegal.

Of course, Deputy Harte made a very incomplete examination of the situation in Donegal or he would not have said that because the situation is a lot more involved than that, as I will show, but I think that Deputy Harte did see that to apply the solution with regard to Donegal that he recommended would involve, let me say, the expatriation of a considerable number of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents into the Province of Connacht and Deputy Harte, probably realising that Deputy O'Donnell was one of the Fine Gael rural Deputies who were embarking on the trek to Dublin city saw then that that would be likely to leave the whole of Donegal available to him for the accumulation of one quota of votes. That was obviously his approach.

Comment on this

Why do you not deal with the points raised here?

Comment on this

He did not care that this solution to the Donegal problem which he recommended would involve what Fine Gael Deputies described in 1961 as disfranchising a considerable portion of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents.

Deputy Tully had not got a much more responsible approach to the problem either. I was speaking on the matter at Volume 235, column 85. I was referring to the Louth and Meath situation. I quote from the Official Report:

Mr. Boland: The boundaries of County Louth must be breached if this amendment is not carried both by the Dáil and by the people. The constitutional requirement at present is that the population of County Louth is too many for three seats and too few for four seats.

Admittedly there is at least one other way—possibly there are a number of other ways—in which this could be dealt with, but there is no way in which Louth can be kept as a complete county. It could be dealt with by transferring part of County Meath——

Mr. James Tully: Do that please. It would be a nice cushy one for me.

Deputy Tully's only reaction to the possibility of a large section of the people of Meath being required to become members of the constituency of Louth instead of the constituency of Meath in which they have always been was the immediate vision of a nice cushy seat for him. No consideration for the feelings of the people but the vision of a cushy seat, with part of County Meath and the whole of County Louth, inspired Deputy Tully to abandon with alacrity the rest of the people of County Meath who had elected him to his position as their representative.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

That is what he said:

Do that please. It would be a nice cushy one for me.

Comment on this

That was in the Dáil. Why not deal with the points made in the Seanad

Comment on this

At column 40, on the same day, I was dealing with the position in the Cavan-Monaghan area and said this:

Again, as Deputy Fitzpatrick knows, the likelihood is that if what we are proposing is not accepted, if we are not given some scope in avoiding anomalies, one of the things that are likely to happen is that the counties of Cavan and Monaghan will be combined to form one constituency.

Deputy T. J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) said:

That would suit me down to the ground.

The only approach was the personal approach that, in the case of Meath, it would give a nice cushy seat to Deputy Tully and, in the case of Cavan-Monaghan, would suit Deputy Fitzpatrick down to the ground.

Comment on this

The Minister has not much to go on.

Comment on this

Nothing about the people of Cavan and Monaghan. That is typical of the whole Opposition.

Comment on this

How is the Minister going to fit 144 constituencies inside the county boundaries?

Comment on this

Regarding this inconsistency of approach by the Opposition to this matter, I should like to refer to the attitude of the rugged Independent again.

Comment on this

The Minister is not telling us what the Fianna Fáil people said.

Comment on this

No, because they are against it.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan is the rugged Independent—his own description. I have heard of Independents but apparently he has a new party, a party of rugged Independents. The attitude of the rugged Independent is to oppose this Bill which gives a certain clearly defined limited scope for the avoidance of these injustices, for the avoidance of the removal of these well defined, established areas and constituencies in our representation. He opposes any divergence that may be permitted from the national average and at the same time says he will be prepared to allocate, and to write it into the Constitution for all time, that the present quota of seats in each county should remain unchanged. He says it is unjust and undemocratic to allow a divergence of a maximum of one-sixth in clearly defined circumstances, but the rugged Independent would be prepared instead to write into the Constitution a provision that each county, irrespective of population, would retain its present representation. Of course, it is clear that the rugged Independent's approach to this question, as to every other question, is the same as the approach of Fine Gael and Labour—that if it is proposed by Fianna Fáil they must oppose it with every argument——

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

What it is does not matter. If in order to do this you have to contradict yourself in every second sentence, it does not matter, it is all in a good cause—oppose Fianna Fáil. There is just the one test: to oppose all the time if it is proposed by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It could not be right.

Comment on this

Exactly. If it is proposed by Fianna Fáil, it could not be right and the duty of the Opposition, whether Fine Gael, Labour or rugged Independents, is to oppose with every conceivable argument, no matter how contradictory they may be. When I was introducing these two Bills here a few days ago, I said that what would have to happen in regard to what the Opposition spoke about as the butchery and dismembering of constituencies would be worse than what was done in 1961 and Senator Eoin Ryan emphasised that point later.

I do not remember what the reaction was when I mentioned it myself, but I was sitting here while Senator Ryan was speaking and his emphasising of this fact was greeted with scornful sniggers from the Opposition Front Bench. Senator Garret FitzGerald got to work furiously. He went through the performance of tearing his hair, plotting graphs and drawing curves with a straight edge and so on. When I saw that furious burst of activity, I expected that Senator FitzGerald, when he rose to speak, in a very scientific way would try to refute this statement of fact. In fact Senator FitzGerald did no more than to get up and say: "That is all wrong. There are only six counties affected in this way if a revision of constituencies is made."

He just made the bald statement, despite all the curves, graphs and plottings and despite his reference to Senator Quinlan's computer. All he produced was the bald, unsupported statement, which I will show is completely wrong, the statement that only six counties would be affected in this way. I must say I expected something more, particularly in view of the fact that I saw him going into the operation of plotting his graphs. I remember seeing him leaving and coming back with more information and putting down another point on his graph, but he merely came out with this bald and completely wrong statement.

It will be necessary for me to show just what would have to happen exactly. I cannot give it definitely because of course in some cases there will be alternative possible solutions and the adoption of either one would probably give rise to different problems in different constituencies. Therefore, if you start with Donegal, you will have a large number of possible alternatives before you arrive in Wexford. However, Senator FitzGerald indicated that this conclusion that only six counties would be affected was arrived at as a result of a joint effort by himself and his professorial colleague, Senator Dooge. He speaks fairly rapidly and I did not get all his examples jotted down, but he said one of the adjustments that would have to be made would be between Donegal and Sligo.

These two learned professorial Senators on the Fine Gael Front Bench, who in discussing the forecasts of other equally learned gentlemen on what would happen under the straight vote, so scornfully rejected what Senator FitzGerald described as the crudities of the other eminent professors, have not apparently in their own approach to this simple and realistic matter deemed it necessary to equip themselves with even an elementary acquaintance with the geography of Ireland.

Before embarking on such a complex operation as making even a tentative rearrangement of constituencies under the Bill, I would not ask these two distinguished alumni of the National University of Ireland to study geography at university level—to join first year Arts students doing a grind in order to repeat their examinations in September. I would not ask them to go to that trouble, but if they have any children of schoolgoing age themselves, or any neighbours who have children going to the national school, or if they would stop the first child of nine or ten whom they see toddling to school and ask him to be so kind as to produce a school atlas and to give them a brief run over the map of Ireland, they will discover that at no point do the counties of Sligo and Donegal touch. It seems to me that despite all Senator FitzGerald's protestations of a scientific approach and despite the display he put on of tearing his hair, plotting his graphs, drawing his curves, he made an even bigger ass of himself than usual. Even the rawest and least well academically qualified Fine Gael election worker will tell him that in adjusting one county with another, which is undesirable in itself, if it has to be done, they should at least be contiguous counties.

Comment on this

Sit down.

Comment on this

I know in Donegal for the learned professors' information——

Comment on this

On a point of order, an expression was used——

Comment on this

I did not mean to refer to the Senator as an ass. I used the colloquial expression that he made an ass of himself. I do not mean that he grew a tail or long ears or anything like that.

Comment on this

The expression used——

Comment on this

The Senator should have a sense of humour.

Comment on this

The Minister, to continue.

Comment on this

For the information of the learned professors on the Fine Gael Front Bench and their colleagues, such as the rugged Independent from Cork, the counties of Sligo and Donegal are not contiguous at any point.

This is what comes of attempting to perform a practical job such as delineating parliamentary constituencies in accordance with a theoretical and ad hoc mathematical law specially invented for the purpose by no less a person that Senator FitzGerald himself. I suppose this will be known henceforth as “FitzGerald's Law”. This is what comes from doing this and excluding from the operation and application of the law any element of commonsense. “FitzGerald's Law” or “FitzGerald's Theorem” or “Teoragáin Mhic Gearailt” or whatever it is to be known as in future, for the delineation of constituencies is about as appropriate as FitzGerald's Law for the solution of our agricultural problems by the division of the land of Ireland into farms of a minimum of 400 cows each.

Comment on this

I suppose it is unreasonable to expect Senator Dooge and Senator FitzGerald to exercise commonsense which they have not got. On the other hand, it may well be that even the application of "FitzGerald's Law" proved too laborious and that instead they utilised the services of their distinguished and rugged colleague's — Senator Quinlan's — computer and that possibly the absentminded professor from Cork forgot to whisper in the ear of his beloved machine that it would be desirable, if it did not mind, that the counties to be fused, or partly fused, should be contiguous.

In any case, it is certainly not too harsh to describe it, as I did, as a pseudo-scientific approach that does not take account of the juxtaposition of counties in the delineation of constituencies.

Comment on this

It may be that this was not due either to ignorance of the geography of Ireland or to carelessness. It may well be that to the eminent professorial intellectuals who have taken over control of the Fine Gael Party—it may well be that to them there is nothing incongruous in constituencies consisting of a bit here and a bit there and parts of other countries and other constituencies coming in between, and perhaps in deciding that only a small number of constituencies need be breached in present circumstances, they visualised the topping up of these constituencies deficient in population from the population, surplus to requirements in other places. however far distant they may be.

To someone like Senator FitzGerald who can regard the question of revising constituencies every five years —after each census—as merely a minor exercise with figures, a minor question of adjusting figures, who can ignore the fact that figures represent people. this matter of part of another constituency, or constituencies intervening between the two parts of one constituency in two different provinces, is possibly something of no consequence, just as it is of no consequence that people should be changed in and out of constituencies like shuttlecocks with the result that people, or representatives, or Party organisations do not know where they are or whether they are coming or going.

Comment on this

They did not know it before; they know it now.

Comment on this

I suppose Senator FitzGerald or Senator Dooge might not see anything incongruous in remedying a discrepancy in population in Donegal by requiring people in Errigal Road, Drimnagh, to vote in Donegal—and, in fact, there might be more people in Errigal Road, Drimnagh, interested in Donegal than there would be in Manorhamilton — or possibly topping up Waterford with Comeragh Road, or Tipperary with Galtymore Road, or Kerry with Brandon Road, or West Galway with Spiddal or Clifden Road in Ballyfermot. I can well imagine that Senators FitzGerald, Dooge and Quinlan would not see anything particularly wrong with that.

Senator FitzGerald said that six counties would be affected by this if a revision had to be carried out. As far as I can gather, he is one in the Fine Gael Party who has the view that no divergence whatever is permitted. In my examination, I assume that a maximum divergence of five per cent is, in fact, permitted. There is a considerable number in excess of six counties which would be affected in this way. It is doubtful if there is any county that would not be affected. I do not ask Senators to take my word for it as Senators FitzGerald asked the House to take his word. I propose to go into the constituencies and the counties and show that this is in fact so. This is on the basis of the assumption that I have already put before the House, that a five per cent divergence is permissible; in other words, that a maximum population per Deputy of 21,028 and a minimum of 19,028 per Deputy is permissible.

I start with Donegal where the population in accordance with the 1966 census is 108,549. In accordance with the assumption that a 5 per cent divergence is permissible, the minimum population requirement in present circumstances for six seats is 114,168. Of course, according to some of the Opposition, the minimum population required would be 6,000 more, 120,168, but I assume that the minimum population is 114,168 and the population is, in accordance with the 1966 census, 108,549. That means that if Donegal is to retain its present representation of six Deputies, it must get at least 5,619 people from somewhere else.

Senator FitzGerald apparently would bring them from County Sligo and jump them over the intervening county of Leitrim. It would be more natural and more justifiable to go to the adjoining County Leitrim which is the only county in this part of the country which does adjoin County Donegal. We cannot very well go to Derry or Tyrone. However, if Donegal is to retain the six seats, this at least would have to be done. They would have to get an additional 5,619 people from somewhere else. Deputy Harte, who is the only Donegal Deputy who spoke on the matter, recommends that it be dealt with in a different way. He says that the whole county of Donegal should be a five-seat constituency. It cannot be a five-seat constituency, either in accordance with my interpretation of the Constitution or in accordance with Senator FitzGerald's interpretation of the Constitution.

In accordance with my interpretation, which is based, I think reasonably, on Judge Budd's decision, the maximum population allowable for five seats would be 105,140. According to Senator FitzGerald's interpretation, Deputy Ryan's interpretation and the interpretation of I do not know how many other members of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party and the rugged Independent, the figure would be 100,140. I think it would be allowable to have 105,140 people for five Deputies in Donegal which has a population of 108,549. So, if Deputy Harte's solution to the Donegal problem is to be applied, then it is necessary to transfer from the county of Donegal 3,409 people at the very least. That is if there is any way in which to select 3,409 people, because of course information is not available in that detail in the Report of the Census of Population. It is possible, and probable —certainly with the present Government—that in carrying out this operation the desire would certainly be to minimise the reduction of representatives for those areas in general. That would involve making the maximum possible utilisation of the population in accordance with the Census Report.

Therefore it is more likely, as I say, that in carrying out Deputy Harte's recommendation for Donegal, the most reasonable thing to do would be to transfer in excess of 3,409 people from Donegal. If it were to be based on the exact minimum allowed, the number would be 3,409 but if you try to make the maximum possible utilisation of the population for seats in the western area or rural area as a whole, the number would more likely approach the maximum of 13,409. County Donegal is therefore obviously a county which cannot be dealt with in accordance with the present interpretation of the Constitution, except by, as the Opposition Members put it, butchering county boundaries in some way.

Comment on this

One parish.

Comment on this

That means expatriating to another county a minimum of 3,409 or a maximum of 13,409 and this would, as I say, be more likely to be nearer to the maximum of 13,409 than to 3,409.

So for obvious reasons Donegal must be interfered with. Deputy Harte wants it to be done by getting rid of part of the constituents of his colleague, Deputy O'Donnell. Obviously apart from the situation arising in County Leitrim and County Sligo and the other counties in Connacht, to rectify the situation in Donegal would involve at least the neighbouring county of Leitrim, probably both County Sligo and County Leitrim and through those counties, other counties in Connacht also. They then are affected by the situation in Donegal, apart altogether from the actual situation within the counties themselves.

Before I deal with the counties of the province of Connacht, I think it would be appropriate to deal with the county at the other end of the province, the southern end of it, County Clare, because I cannot see how that whole area could be dealt with, except by treating the area which is bounded by the Atlantic, the Northern Ireland border and the Shannon as an entity in itself. In County Clare the population is, in accordance with the 1966 Census, 73,597 and the representation of the county at present is four seats. In accordance with my assessment, which is too liberal according to the Opposition, the minimum population required for four seats is 76,112 so there is a deficiency, if Clare is to retain its representation, of at least 2,515. On the other hand, if the representation in Clare is to be based on the exact average of population, the deficiency would be 4,000 more than that.

If Clare is to be dealt with by retaining its present representation, at least 2,515 people must be transferred to it from some other county. I would look on that as indicating that those must come from County Galway, which borders it. Of course, to the professors and their pupils on the Opposition benches this may not appear to be necessary. They may see nothing incongruous in transferring this population from across the Shannon, from Tipperary or Limerick or Kerry but I think any normal person would take this population from Galway rather than from across the Shannon.

The situation in Clare could be dealt with in another way by reducing the representation from four to three. In accordance with my interpretation of the learned judge's decision, the maximum population that would be allowable for three seats is 63,084. This solution would involve the transfer from County Clare of, at the very least, 10,513 people probably to County Galway. If it is to be done in accordance with the exact average rather than on the basis of a five per cent permissible divergence, then the number to be transferred would be 13,513, but if it is to be on the basis of the maximum utilisation of the total population, then the number to be transferred would be 16,513.

Obviously then those two counties at the northern and southern extremities of the Province of Connacht must, in order to be in accordance with the present interpretation of the Constitution, have their county boundaries breached in some way, either by receiving population transferred from Galway to Clare and from Leitrim or from Leitrim and Sligo to Donegal or they must have it taken away by a transferring of population from Donegal to Leitrim or to Sligo and Leitrim and from Clare to Galway. Those are two counties that would have to be breached. This is, as we are told by the Opposition, in order to establish the sacred, democratic, inviolable principle of one man, one vote. In fact it is nothing of the kind. If the representation of those two counties were to be based on voters rather than population, we would find both Donegal and Clare are fully entitled to their present representation, that the voters are there to justify it and that they have as equal an entitlement to their present representation as any constituency in any urban area. In fact, in Clare the number of voters per Deputy is substantially greater than the national average of voters per Deputy. We have the Opposition putting forward the pretence, putting forward the fraudulent argument, that they are opposing this Bill in order to establish the fundamental, sacred, democratic principle of every vote being exactly equal in its effect on the election of a candidate in every part of the country irrespective of every other consideration. But in both of these counties the present representation is fully justified and even on the most rigid interpretation of any democratic principle there is no reason whatever why either of these two county boundaries should be breached. However, Senators opposite want to insist that they will be breached and as I shall show later this is in accordance with a definite policy of theirs. Those two counties as I have shown must have this dismemberment carried out on them and this affects the position in the five Connacht counties irrespective of the situation within the counties themselves. Obviously, then we have some complicating factors in discussing the situation in individual counties.

Let us deal with County Leitrim which borders Donegal. It is quite clear that Leitrim cannot under either the present conditions or under the proposed conditions constitute a constituency itself because the total population in accordance with the 1966 Census is 30,572 and the Constitution at present provides that there must be a minimum of three seats per constituency. The minimum population in accordance with my interpretation of the Constitution for three seats is 57,084 so I think that Senator FitzGerald or even Senator Quinlan's computer would admit that the county of Leitrim cannot form a constituency completely enclosed in its own boundaries. The same thing applies to the county of Sligo where the population according to the 1966 Census is 51,263. Obviously, apart from the fact that at least County Leitrim and probably the two counties of Sligo and Leitrim must be involved in the solution of the completely unnecessary problem in Donegal it is quite apparent that these two countries must be involved in some adjustment between themselves. Now we have four counties without going out of the West at all which must be breached in the way that was found to be so objectionable in 1961. These are the only four I have spoken of so far. We will discover a lot more of them.

Comment on this

It was done.

Comment on this

Let us consider for a moment the present constituency of Sligo-Leitrim which of course does not by any means represent the present two counties of Sligo and Leitrim. The population of the present constituency of Sligo-Leitrim is 67,892 and in accordance with my interpretation of the constitutional requirement the minimum population required for four seats is 76,112 so that there is there already a deficiency of at least 8,220. Now if Deputy Harte's solution for the situation in Donegal is adopted of course this deficiency could be met by a transfer of the requisite number of people from Donegal and then we would have a constituency of Sligo-Leitrim-Donegal which, of course, in the view of Senator FitzGerald, who considers this merely an exercise in figures, is unimportant. For him, that is just a detail and the interests of the people of Sligo, the people of Leitrim and the people of Donegal do not arise. It is purely a question of juggling the figures and I suppose the interests of the Deputies are not important either.

Take, for instance, the Deputy who represents South-West Donegal, in the Fine Gael interest, Deputy P. O'Donnell. I understand that he is one of those who is seeking a constituency in the Dublin area at present but it may be that he might change his mind, particularly in view of the competition from two of the three Deputies O'Higgins, from Deputy Lindsay, from Senator FitzGerald, from Senator O'Quigley and so on. He might decide it would be better to change his mind and try to get elected there. Obviously he would be likely to decide to move out of Donegal in view of the fact that all Deputy Harte's constituency is remaining and a large part of his would be going out and he might decide to try his luck in the Sligo-Leitrim-Donegal constituency. We would have an interesting situation from the Fine Gael point of view there where we would have Deputies McLaughlin, Gilhawley and P. O'Donnell going for this four-seat constituency and, as I shall show later, Deputy Reynolds also so we would have four of them competing. That would be very interesting and no doubt it would show up the many advantages of the multi-member constituencies before the election would be over. However, it is now clear that Donegal, Clare, Sligo and Leitrim must be breached. The constituency of Sligo-Leitrim must be altered.

We come now to the county of Roscommon and the constituency of Roscommon which of course are two different things and have to be two different things because of the decision of the High Court. The population of the constituency of Roscommon is, in accordance with the 1966 Census, 67,605. There are four seats in that area and in accordance with my interpretation of the Constitution, which is the most liberal one and apparently not agreed with by the Opposition, the minimum population required for four seats would be 76,112. There are 67,605 people in the constituency of Roscommon so there is a deficiency to be rectified there. There are at present 2,566 Roscommon people attached to County Mayo but the return of those people would not be sufficient to remedy the deficiency of population in the constituency of Roscommon. Therefore, even assuming that the integrity of the county as a whole is restored and that the part of Leitrim attached to it could remain attached to it there would still have to be an addition of population from somewhere else to Roscommon in order to maintain its present representation. I think any practical person deciding on this would say they would have to come from the only two other counties that would be available in Connacht, that is Mayo or Galway, although that assumes that Sligo-Leitrim is dealt with in a definite way and of course they could conceivably come from Sligo. Obviously then if the constituency of Roscommon was to retain its present four seats you would have a constituency of Sligo-Roscommon-Leitrim or Mayo-Roscommon-Leitrim or Galway-Roscommon-Leitrim.

If we look at the county Roscommon as a whole we find that the population is 56,228. The minimum population that would be required for three seats in accordance with my interpretation is 57,084 so that the county of Roscommon as a whole has not got sufficient population for three seats but it almost has. It might be that it would be decided that the most reasonable solution to the Roscommon problem would be instead of adding almost half County Leitrim and part of some other county, merely to re-annex the portion of Roscommon ceded to County Mayo and add some slight proportion from some other county, whether it be Leitrim, Mayo, Sligo or Galway. If that were to happen, the major part of the county of Leitrim at present attached to Roscommon would have to go elsewhere; and, of course, it would either go to the revised constituency of Sligo-Leitrim or it might be utilised to remedy the totally unnecessary situation that arises in the county of Cavan. It is quite clear that one of the possible solutions and possibly the most reasonable solution of the Roscommon problem would require the major portion of the part of County Leitrim attached to Roscommon to be no longer so attached.

Comment on this

If you could get some of the people back from Birmingham, it might straighten it out a bit.

Comment on this

That means this is the fifth county that could not be dealt with inside the confines of its own boundaries. We have only looked at five yet. Senator FitzGerald and Senator Quinlan's computer feel there are only six in the whole country. We have only looked at five and these five must be dealt with in this anomalous way.

Now let us come to Mayo, where the population in accordance with the 1966 Census is 115,547. At present there are seven seats in Mayo plus the part of Roscommon attached to one of the two constituencies there. The minimum population required for seven seats is, according to my assumption, 133,196. According to the Opposition it is even more than that. Obviously, County Mayo, even with the addition of part of Roscommon, cannot retain its present seven seats. But since the maximum population for six seats is 126,168, the situation in Mayo could conceivably be dealt with within the confines of the boundaries of the county.

At last we have arrived at one county which, if it could be divorced from the situation in the country as a whole, could be dealt with within its own boundaries, but, of course, it cannot be divorced from the country as a whole. The present Government, and I think any Government, approaching this matter would approach it from the point of view of making the maximum utilisation reasonably possible of the population of the rural area as a whole. If that were to be the approach, the Government would be unlikely to decide to waste, as it were, about 10,500 of population in Mayo. Therefore, looking at it from the practical point of view, it is likely that Mayo's boundaries would also be breached, apart from the fact that the situation in Galway, Roscommon, Sligo and Leitrim would probably require it anyway.

The remaining county in the Province of Connacht and the west of Ireland generally is the county of Galway, which has a population of 148,340. At present it has eight seats. This requires a minimum population of 152,224. The county of Galway is obviously deficient then in the number required to justify its present representation. It would, as I have shown already, be inevitably involved in an adjustment with County Clare. It seems quite clear also that it would have to be adjusted with County Mayo and/or with County Roscommon, probably with both. Therefore, County Galway is another county that would have to be breached. We now have reached six that would have to be breached and seven that would almost certainly have to be breached without going out of the west of Ireland at all.

This is necessary, we are told, in the interests of democracy. This is necessary to establish this new-found sacred principle that every vote must constitute the exact same fraction of the number electing a Deputy in every single constituency. But an examination of the figures in the register of electors for 1967/68 discloses that even that principle, if there is such a principle, does not require this to be done at all. The total population of the Province of Connacht is 401,950. The population of Donegal is 108,549 and of Clare 73,597. Therefore, the total population of this area, which I shall call for want of a better description, the western area, is 584,096. If the Constitution is not amended as we propose, the maximum representation that this area, which at present has 33 seats, can get is 30. That means there must be a reduction of three seats here unless the amendment we suggest is made.

In this total area the number of voters in 1967-68 was 365,740. If we assume that the same maximum divergence would be permitted in regard to voters as is permitted in regard to electors on the basis of the national average of voters this area would be entitled to 32 seats. Therefore, even on the most rigid application of this principle of one man, one vote, the most that would be required in this western area would be a reduction of one seat. The Opposition campaign against the proposed amendment means then that they are insisting on a reduction of three seats in this western area, although even the strictest application of this so-called principle requires a reduction of one only.

On this basis both Donegal and Clare could be left as they are and there would be a reduction of one seat in Connacht. This is exactly what would probably happen if the proposed amendment is accepted. Remember, it is provided in the Bill that this maximum divergence of one-sixth above or below the national average can only be employed in certain circumstances. It can only be employed to avoid the breaching of county boundaries and to take account of the area and accessibility of constituencies. It would, in fact, not be constitutionally permissible to exercise the maximum divergence over the whole of this western area. The result is very likely to be that there will in fact be a reduction of one seat in that area. By a very strict delineation of constituencies, it might be possible to avoid an immediate reduction in the number of seats, but this is unlikely. In any case, it is quite clear that, even if it were possible and even if the present representation in the western area were maintained, the result will be considerably nearer to this principle of one man, one vote than what must happen if the change we propose is not made.

Obviously the Opposition Parties' campaign against the proposal for the purpose of ensuring a reduction in the representation of the west of Ireland is not justified by any democratic principle and certainly not justified by considerations of area and accessibility which are considered relevant in every other democracy in the world. It would be impossible to apply the maximum divergence of one-sixth uniformly to this whole area; it cannot be done: even if it were the most that could be allocated would be 34, not 35 as Senator FitzGerald said, because even if the actual figure did work out at 34.3 or 34.9, neither I know, nor anyone else in the Government knows, of any area in which it could allocate 9 of a Deputy to a constituency. It is quite clear, however, that since the divergence must be only for the purposes specified in the Bill the maximum divergence cannot be applied all round and the most likely situation is that the number of Deputies in the western area would be exactly what is justified by the number of voters.

I think many people, whether living in urban or rural areas, think that 32 or 33 Deputies from this whole area, stretching from Malin Head in Donegal to Loop Head in Clare and from Athlone to Belmullet would not be excessive representation. I think people in general will look upon it as a rather mean operation to try to insist that this number should be reduced undemocratically to 30 when the most that would be required would be a reduction to 32. Many people, even in Dublin city, would, I think, say that Dublin as a whole is reasonably adequately represented by 34 as compared with at most 33 for the area I have described and that there is no great need to insist that the increase in the Dublin area should be from 34 to 38 as against a maximum of 36 that would be required on the basis of voters, particularly when this can only be done by inflicting an injustice on people in other parts of the country and on the representatives of other parts of the country.

Many people would, in fact, think that even though there is some reasonably substantial divergence from the national average involved that the present representation of 34 Deputies for Dublin and 33 for the area from Malin Head to Loop Head and from Athlone to Belmullet substantially represents justice to the people of the two areas concerned.

Without crossing the Shannon at all, I have established that more counties than Senator FitzGerald said would have to have their county boundaries breached if the proposed change is not made. There are two counties remaining in the part of the Province of Ulster under the control of the Oireachtas. There is the constituency of Cavan, which at present coincides with the county of Cavan but if the Opposition have their way that will not do so for very long. The population of County Cavan, according to the 1966 census, is 54,022, and the minimum population required for three seats is 57,084. Obviously, unless this change is made, the boundaries of County Cavan must be breached. This could be done in different ways. It could be topped up with part of County Leitrim which is obviously booked for extinction as a county unless this change is made and since it must already be utilised to adjust the situation in Donegal, Sligo and Roscommon, why not use another part of it to deal with the situation in Cavan?

Comment on this

Why did you not butcher Louth?

Comment on this

That is one of the possibilities. Another possibility is, as I explained in the Dáil, to take the two counties of Cavan and Monaghan and combine them to form a five-seat constituency. The numbers would make that a feasible solution. I cannot forecast, not being in that business like the Opposition Senators, exactly what would happen but I can say this: on the figures as available, County Cavan need not be breached at all if we were to act in accordance with the principle of one man, one vote because the number of voters on the 1967-68 register is 34,301 and the national average of voters per Deputy is 11,899, and if you allow the same divergence in regard to voters, as is in my assumption allowed with regard to population, then the minimum number of voters required to justify a three-seat constituency is 33,912. There are 34,301 voters in County Cavan which is also at present the constituency of Cavan and there is no democratic reason why County Cavan would have to be interfered with at all as a constituency. But Deputy Fitzpatrick and the Opposition in general insist that this must be done and refuse to agree that the Constitution should be amended so as to prevent this injustice being done to the people of that area and as I pointed out, all Parties here agreed in 1961 it was an injustice to uproot people from their own counties and put them into other counties for election purposes.

Comment on this

What about County Louth?

Comment on this

If Senator Rooney had been following me, he would have realised that I was gradually working my way over to County Louth. In fact, at this stage there is only one county separating me from County Louth. I shall come to County Louth in due course. First, I want to point out that County Cavan should retain its integrity as a county but it cannot retain its integrity—and Senator FitzGerald is insisting that it will not. County Monaghan is different from the constituency of Monaghan because the population of the constituency of Monaghan is 53,325 but the population of County Monaghan is 45,732 which means that 7,593 people who live in Louth are included in the constituency of Monaghan. The minimum population for three seats, the present representation of Monaghan, is 57,084. Obviously, then, the constituency of Monaghan must be adjusted in some way. It cannot be dealt with within the confines of the county, except possibly by joining Counties Cavan and Monaghan into a single five-member constituency which Deputy Fitzpatrick would welcome with open arms, because, as he said, it would suit him down to the ground. But it is not necessary and I do not think it desirable.

Other people who take a more responsible view and who would not look at everything from the viewpoint of their own personal convenience would agree that a constituency comprised of the counties of Monaghan and Cavan would not be a desirable one. But that is one way in which the Monaghan situation could be dealt with, by linking the counties of Cavan and Monaghan, but that would require the return of the 7,593 people to Louth. Of course, if the Cavan situation was dealt with by adjustment with the remnants of County Leitrim, then this solution for Monaghan would not be available and the constituency of Monaghan would then have to be dealt with in some other way. It would require an addition of at least 3,759 people to retain its present representation of three seats. It so happens County Louth, which was utilised to top up County Monaghan the last time, could spare anything up to 4,842, so one other possible solution of the Monaghan situation would be a further transfusion of people from County Louth. As I pointed out, neither Deputy Faulkner nor Deputy Coburn nor Senator Donegan on the last occasion thought this was a desirable way of dealing with the Monaghan situation. They were unanimous in thinking that these 7,000-odd people who had to be uprooted from Louth and constrained to vote in County Monaghan for Monaghan Deputies were resentful of this and would have preferred to remain in their county voting for County Louth candidates even if this involved taking a slightly greater number of people to elect a Deputy in County Louth than in County Monaghan.

In 1961 when this was actually done none of these representatives of County Louth felt that what happened on that occasion was a vindication of the democratic rights of the people of County Louth. They felt they were interpreting the views of their constituents reasonably accurately when they said they would have preferred to remain in County Louth to elect their three Deputies and let the people of County Monaghan also elect three Deputies, even though it would mean that each voter in Monaghan contributed fractionally more to the election of a Deputy than each voter in County Louth. The total number of Deputies was neither increased nor decreased by this unnecessary butchering of Counties Louth and Monaghan. The total number of Deputies was still the same, six, three who were returned for the constituency of County Louth, not the whole county, and three who were returned for the constituency of Monaghan comprising the whole of County Monaghan and a small part of County Louth. Senator FitzGerald and people like him look upon all this merely as an exercise in statistics, suggesting this as a desirable thing to do, but the Deputies who represented these areas did not think so; and I am inclined to think they were probably more accurately reflecting the views of the people in general with regard to the application of democratic principles. As Senator Rooney has some particular interest in County Louth, and since, apparently, he is not sufficiently interested himself to look up the figures which are available to him —they were given by me in a reply to a Parliamentary Question on 26th March, 1968—I will give him the figures in regard to County Louth and the constituency of County Louth. In County Louth the population, according to the 1966 Census, was 69,519. In the constituency of Louth the population is 61,926. The population in the constituency of Louth is within the permitted range for three seats; the population in County Louth is not. We do not know which we will be dealing with, but as I pointed out there is one solution to the Cavan-Monaghan problem which appeals to at least one of the Fine Gael representatives for the area, Deputy Fitzpatrick; I do not know if it appeals in the same way to Deputy Dillon, nor do I know whether Deputy Dillon is too much above these things even to consider the matter. However, the solution that appeals to the only Fine Gael representative who has expressed an opinion on it is that Counties Cavan and Monaghan should be joined together to comprise a five-seat constituency. As I said, this would involve the return to County Louth of the population which is at present attached to County Monaghan. The population of County Louth is 69,519, but the maximum population allowed for three seats is 63,084, so that something must happen with County Louth; either the population must be transferred from Louth to some other county, and it cannot be to Monaghan if Deputy Fitzpatrick's solution is adopted. Therefore the only other county to which to transfer it is County Meath. The situation in Louth arising from the rectification of the Cavan-Monaghan situation could be dealt with in the way which appeals to Deputy James Tully, by transferring a portion of County Meath to Louth and making Louth a four-seat constituency, thus achieving the nice result of a cushy seat for Deputy James Tully.

Comment on this

How would Meath be dealt with then?

Comment on this

Senator Fitzgerald will have noted that Meath would appear to be the next county for me to deal with, having started at Donegal and gone down to Clare to the boundary of the Shannon and come around by Cavan and Louth, which seems to be required in order to refute the ridiculous statement of Senator Fitzgerald, which may, for all I know, have emanated from the wrong information being fed into the computer by the rugged Independent from Cork. I do not know where it came from but in any case it was wrong.

Comment on this

I have shown, without going beyond the Shannon, that it was completely wrong.

Comment on this

Surely we can deal with this after the referendum.

Comment on this

I know Senator Rooney would like it to be dealt with after the referendum, but it happens to be relevant to the question people are being asked in the referendum, and whether Senator Rooney or either of the Senator Fitzgeralds or the rugged Independent from Cork or anybody else likes it, the people will hear this before the referendum takes place. The people will have this information available to them when they are making their decision. It would suit Senator Rooney and others grand if this information was withheld from the people until after the referendum. Then there would be the situation they desire, that only one side of the case, and that is an unjustifiable side of the case, would be put before the people. We intend, in spite of the efforts of the Opposition, and in spite of the paper wall that we know will be erected by the newspapers, to place these facts before the people. We intend that the people of Cavan will know their representatives are determined that their county will be breached and butchered, as they described it themselves in 1961, and that this is unnecessary. We intend that the people of Donegal will know exactly what Deputy Harte has suggested should be done in Donegal, that he has suggested a solution that would involve a substantial portion of Donegal being expatriated to the Province of Connacht to which a gentleman famed in song and story was once exiled. The same fate, apparently, is to be inflicted on some of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents by Deputy Harte. We will make the people in that part of the country aware of what is proposed for them and aware of exactly what is involved in the Opposition's determination to hang on to this present situation which results and must result in weighting the urban vote at the expense of the rural vote.

In response to repeated requests from Senator Rooney, I was proceeding to deal with County Louth. All the time I was dealing with other counties, Senator Rooney was asking me to deal with County Louth but, as soon as I started to deal with Louth, he objected to that. He does not want me to deal with it, but I will deal with it.

Comment on this

It weakens the Minister's case.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil organisation, in spite of all efforts, will make the people of County Louth aware of what exactly the opposition to this amendment means. I pointed out, and I regret having to do so again, but in order that Senator Rooney who is so interested in the position in Louth will not lose the trend, I have to point it out again, that if the situation in Cavan and Monaghan is dealt with in the way the Fine Gael representative for Cavan, if not for Monaghan—possibly both— wants it dealt with, that would involve the Minister for Local Government and eventually the Oireachtas, and possibly the Constituency Commission, to deal with the situation in County Louth which has a population of 69,519 and now returns three Deputies to the Dáil, whereas the present law requires for that number of Deputies a maximum of 63,084 people, men, women and children——

Comment on this

The single-seat areas will cross the boundaries.

Comment on this

If Senator Rooney likes, when we come to discuss the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, we will deal with all this again from the point of view of the single seats. I will start at Malin Head again and finish up in West Cork or wherever Senator Rooney likes.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Acting Chairman (Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

We will deal with it quicker if Senator Rooney removes himself or contains himself. I do not care which.

Comment on this

With apologies to the Minister, are we sitting past 5 o'clock. I understood that Standing Orders provide that if we sat at 10.30 a.m., we finished at 5 o'clock.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The order of the House is that we sit until we conclude the Second Stage of the Bills.

Comment on this

Irrespective of time?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

I am still outside the boundaries of Louth. I still have to go through the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Despite Senator Rooney's interruptions—he is still valiantly defending the borders of Louth—and the interruptions of the rugged Independent from Cork, when they have finished interrupting, I will eventually deal with Louth. I will deal with it either before tea, or after tea today, or tomorrow or Sunday, or Monday or Tuesday or Wednesday of next week.

Comment on this

We will have adequate opportunity to reopen it next week.

Comment on this

Who broke the Louth border?

Comment on this

I am still outside it.

Comment on this

Who broke it?

Comment on this

Who?

Comment on this

Your Government.

Comment on this

Yes, of course. We will go back to the situation in 1961. The situation in Louth in 1961 was this: the population in accordance with the interpretation of the Constitution which was extracted from the High Court by the Fine Gael Party was too high for three seats. The situation in the adjoining county of Monaghan— in another province, I agree, but an adjoining county—was that the population was too low for three seats, but the joint population of Monaghan and Louth was sufficient for six seats. In order to vindicate the rights of the people of Louth, and in order to ensure that the people in neighbouring Monaghan did not have this terribly unfair advantage over the people of Louth, to comply with the interpretation of the Constitution extracted from the High Court by the Fine Gael Party, it was necessary to make an adjustment between Louth and Monaghan. It could have been done in other ways. Monaghan also borders Meath but because there was a problem in Louth and Monaghan and because Meath borders Kildare in which there was a similar problem this was the solution that was adopted.

The Fianna Fáil Government under compulsion, under the requirement of the High Court, brought a Bill before the two Houses in 1961, making the adjustment which was required to comply with the Constitution. As I said before, but I will repeat it because Senator Rooney insists, that Bill was received very unfavourably on all sides of the House. In fact, the representatives for Louth from the two sides demanded that this situation be remedied. Senator Rooney who now is the only spokesman for Louth on the opposite side does not want it to be remedied. He wants to insist that if Louth gets part of the population from Monaghan at one end, that should be compensated for by transferring part of the population to Meath. This would facilitate Deputy James Tully and create a nice cushy seat for him.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

There is no requirement in Standing Orders for repetition.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, but neither is there any provision in Standing Orders that the debate on Second Reading should proceed by means of question and answer across the floor.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am endeavouring to ensure that interruptions cease.

Comment on this

With Senator Rooney's gracious permission, I will now deal with the situation in Louth in 1968 instead of 1961. Would that be in order, Sir? Over the past 15, 20 or 30 minutes—I do not know for how long—Senator Rooney has prevented me from doing this, although prior to that he was inviting me to deal with it, but as soon as I proceeded to do so, Senator Rooney objected and did his best to prevent me from dealing with it.

It would not be in order for me to tell Deputy Rooney again the population of County Louth, but if Deputy Rooney likes to refer back to the Official Report when it comes out, he will find that the population in Louth would be too much for a three-seat constituency, that it would be in breach of the Constitution, and that it would be a monstrous injustice to the people of Louth to require them to continue to elect only three Deputies for this huge county. Consequently the situation must be dealt with either by transferring 6,435 people to Meath and Louth remaining a three-seat constituency, or by transferring at least 6,597 people from Meath and Louth becoming a four-seat constituency. It is anyone's guess which might happen. As Senators know, I would be only too anxious to facilitate Deputy James Tully and it is quite likely that we might adopt the solution which appeals so much to Deputy Tully. Those are some of the alternatives for County Louth if the Opposition's attempt to hang on to the present situation is successful.

Some other impatient Senator foresaw the situation in the constituency and/or county of Meath, because they do not coincide. The population of the county of Meath is 67,323 and the population of the constituency of Meath is 60,830. This means that there are 6,493 County Meath people attached to the constituency of Kildare-Westmeath. The maximum population allowed for a three-seat constituency is 63,084. The minimum population is 57,084. So the present constituency of Meath is one of the 14 constituencies that at present comply with the requirements of the Constitution. But that, as I think some Senators may already suspect, does not mean that the present constituency of Meath can remain untouched.

Senators may remember that a situation arises in Louth which requires adjustment. I do not think it would be desirable to adjust it, say, by transferring the population of Cooley Road, Drimnagh, to County Louth. The more likely way is by adjustment with County Meath. If it is to be dealt with in Deputy James Tully's suggested way, there must be at least 6,597 people from Meath transferred to Louth—and that, of course, would mean that the constituency of Meath would have to be topped up from somewhere else and the most reasonable way to do that would appear to me to be to return the population of County Meath, at present attached to County Kildare, or some portion of it and, in fact, the County Meath situation could be dealt with in that way. But that would raise complications in Kildare and complications in Longford-Westmeath.

It could be that the County Meath situation, unnecessarily arising because of the situation in Cavan and Monaghan and percolating down through County Louth, might more appropriately be dealt with by adjustment with part of the North County Dublin which should be an area that might concern my colleague, Senator Rooney. One of the possible solutions would then involve adjustment for the North County Dublin and the vacancy created in County Meath by the departure of Deputy James Tully to the constituency of Louth might well be competed for by Senator Rooney or, as Senator FitzGerald says, possibly by my gracious senior colleague, Deputy P.J. Burke but somehow or other I do not think so. I think my association with Deputy Burke will continue for a longer period. Except, of course, that the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution will probably make us neighbours rather than cohabitants of a constituency.

That, then, is briefly the County Meath situation—unless anybody wants it to be dealt with in greater detail, we shall not go into it any further but, as I pointed out, possibly the most likely solution of the Meath problem would involve a return of the population of Meath that is at present attached to the constituency of Kildare. It is not definite because, as I said, the further you get away from the source of all this trouble, the more alternative solutions there are available. However, it must be quite clear that it is quite on the cards that the constituency of Kildare may have to be reduced by the return of the 6,493 Meath people attached to it.

By the way, with each succeeding county, I hope Senators will notice that we are adding to the number of counties whose borders will have to be breached. I think if Senators would count back over them, they will see that we must have already approximately double the total that the eminent professors, Senators FitzGerald and Dooge——

Comment on this

You really need a computer.

Comment on this

These are all based on actual figures and on a more liberal interpretation of the Constitution than Senators opposite are prepared to agree to. I think we have already fairly well dealt with Senator FitzGerald's——

Comment on this

The Minister is carving them up, anyhow.

Comment on this

——unsubstantiated statement that only six counties need to be dealt with in this way. We are going on to the constituency of Kildare or the County of Kildare: it is a matter of choice as to which end we start at. Let us deal with the county because simple souls like Senators FitzGerald and Dooge think you can deal with all of these things in isolation.

There are 66,404 people in County Kildare according to the 1966 Census. The constituency of County Kildare returns four Deputies to the Dáil but obviously the County of Kildare could not do this at 66,000. It would be nearer to the position of a three-seat constituency which has a maximum allowable population of 63,084—and there are 66,404 people in the County of Kildare. Therefore, if you were to deal with Kildare on its own, you must either deal with it by adding people to it from somewhere else or by moving people from it to somewhere else.

In the constituency of Kildare, the population is 79,998. According to my estimation, the minimum required for four seats is 76,112. So we have arrived at another constituency that is already within the requirements of the Constitution—one of the 14 out of 38. But I think, as already has become apparent, that does not mean that there is no need to chop and change the constituency of Kildare because it appears fairly likely that the people from the County of Meath—who are, in the words of the late Leader of the Labour Party, the "chunk" of County Meath that is attached on to Kildare—will have to return to County Meath: that seems one of the likelihoods. If this happens, then of course the remaining part of the constituency of Kildare would not be sufficient for four seats but it would be too many of three seats so that the constituency of Kildare would have to be adjusted in some way.

Because another complication arises from the fact that Longford-Westmeath no longer has the population to justify the retention of its present four Deputies, it seems likely that the population of Westmeath—the chunk of Westmeath—attached to Kildare would also have to be returned or at least a substantial part of it. So, either the county of Kildare or the county of Kildare plus a small part of County Westmeath would have to be dealt with in some way by adjustment with some other county and it appears to be likely, once again, that possibly the most likely constituency with which it would be adjusted would be my own constituency of County Dublin again and that one of the results of dealing with the situation in Meath and Kildare— which, of course, are interdependent— might be that a substantial part of North County Dublin would be in County Meath or else a substantial part of County Meath in North County Dublin and a substantial part of South County Dublin in County Kildare. It could easily happen that both my present Fine Gael colleagues in the representation of County Dublin and my former Fine Gael colleague in the representation of County Dublin might both find themselves residing in other constituencies if this butchering is insisted on. So, Kildare is another county and it seems another constituency that would have to be butchered.

Comment on this

There are many other ways in which Kildare could be dealt with. It seems likely that the situation in either Kildare or Meath, or both, will also involve breaching of the sacred boundary of County Dublin.

Another way in which the Kildare problem could be dealt with if the portions of Meath and Westmeath at present attached to it were returned would be that Kildare and Carlow could be joined as before to form a five-seat constituency. The numbers in fact would facilitate that because the population of County Carlow is 33,593 and this added to the population of County Kildare would make the joint constituency just right to form a five-seat constituency. What arises unnecessarily in County Cavan and County Monaghan may involve the detachment of Carlow from its present alignment to County Kilkenny and a rejoining with County Kildare. The chain reaction therefore may proceed down as far as Carlow and Kilkenny. The constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny is a misnomer because the constituency is Carlow, Kilkenny and Wexford. It was necessary on the last occasion to transfer an area which now comprises 4,398 people from County Wexford to the constituency which is formed by Carlow and Kilkenny and which may be required to be disrupted. The requirement to detach these people from County Wexford arose not so much from the position in Carlow-Kilkenny but in County Wexford where these people were held to be deprived of their democratic rights by being allowed to vote for Wexford Deputies. In order to vindicate their democratic rights they had to be required to vote for Carlow and Kilkenny Deputies although they lived in County Wexford.

This solution of the Kildare problem by joining Carlow with Kildare might appear to be quite desirable as Kilkenny has a population that would justify a three-seat constituency of its own. It would no longer require the detachment of some of its people from Wexford. Unfortunately this solution may be too simple, but the County Wexford could absorb all this population and still comply with the requirements of the Constitution for four seats. Therefore, County Wexford need not continue, in the words of the Opposition on the last occasion, to be butchered in this way. The present constituency of Laois-Offaly is barely within the requirements of the Constitution and these two counties, this very workable and manageable constituency, could be left as it is at least until the next census. It does not appear in any way certain that they could continue to remain undisturbed for very much longer than the next census because their combined population is 96,312 and the minimum required for five seats is 95,140. Now we come to the one county which as far as I can see would apparently be likely to escape either an adjustment with an adjoining county or a combination with an adjoining county, and this is County Wicklow. How long it will be before there will have to be a change is another matter.

That leaves only two counties in Leinster still to be dealt with. Portions of them are joined together to form the constituency of Longford-Westmeath. The present population of the constituency is 74,788 and it has a representation of four Deputies. The minimum required for four Deputies is 76,112 so that that constituency will require an adjustment which will probably be done by returning either all or part of the Westmeath people who are attached to County Kildare.

I am leaving out Dublin, where obviously the situation will have to be dealt with from scratch. It would not be practicable to deal with the situation in Dublin by additions and subtractions from existing constituencies since it will be affected by the solution of the Meath and Kildare problems. That brings us to the Province of Munster. In Munster the most obvious place to start with would be with the Limerick-Kerry area. The present population of County Kerry is 112,785 and as Senators know there are six Deputies for County Kerry and the minimum population required for six seats is 114,168. Therefore Kerry, unless the Constitution is amended as we propose, cannot be dealt with by adjustment within the county boundaries. It seems to me obvious therefore that this must be dealt with either by an adjustment with County Limerick or County Cork. The existence of a mountain range between Cork and Kerry is of no importance because this is purely a question of figures and I suppose to people like Senator FitzGerald it might even be dealt with by an adjustment with County Clare. The fact that the Shannon intervenes, and the mouth of the Shannon at that, would not be relevant either. County Kerry requires either to be reduced to a five-seat constituency with a substantial transfer of population to some other county or else to be adjusted by the transfer of population from either Limerick or Cork to Kerry.

Another county that must be breached in accordance with the present position and another county that adds to the refutation of what Senator FitzGerald alleged was the position, is Limerick. The population of the county including the county borough is 137,357 and in that county there are seven seats, a three-seat constituency and a four-seat constituency. The minimum population required for seven seats is 133,196. Obviously, then, the county of Limerick could afford to have transferred from it sufficient population to justify the retention of six seats in Kerry, but this is a matter that will require some considerable consideration in order to discover whether the situation in Kerry would be more properly dealt with in that way or by way of adjustment with the county of Cork. Obviously, if the Kerry situation has to be dealt with in that way, then Limerick is another county which will have to be breached. At what gain for democracy? The total number of Deputies in the total area of Limerick and Kerry will still be 13. It is true that, if we do not require some people in Limerick to vote for Deputies in Kerry, then we will have a marginally greater number of people represented by each Limerick Deputy than we would have represented by each Kerry Deputy and this, apparently, would be inflicting a monstrous injustice on the people of Limerick and an undemocratic advantage on the people of Kerry. We would have to rectify that by requiring some of them to be, at least until the next census, in the constituency of Kerry.

This all arises out of the fact that the population of County Kerry is marginally below the minimum that would be required for six seats on the basis of the present interpretation of the requirements in the Constitution. If Senators would look at the number of voters in County Kerry, they will find there were in 1967-68 70,087 and, if the county of Kerry were to retain its present representation of six Deputies, this would, in fact, give almost exactly the national average of voters per Deputy. The minimum voters in accordance with the same maximum divergence of five per cent required for six seats is 67,824. There are 70,087 voters in the county of Kerry so that no democratic principle, however theoretical, requires this butchery to be done and the only thing that requires it to be done is the insistence of the Opposition Parties—Fine Gael, Labour and the rugged Independents — that this situation requiring such injustice should continue. As I have pointed out, the total number there would still be 13 Deputies, seven representing Limerick and six representing Kerry, but some Limerick people would have their democratic rights vindicated by being required to vote for Kerry instead of Limerick Deputies. That, no doubt, is an exercise well worth all the effort and expense the Opposition Parties will put into trying to maintain this position.

As I said, that is only one of the possible solutions to the Kerry problem. It could also be dealt with by adjustment with the county of Cork and we can well imagine the election cars travelling up and down the Healy Pass transporting the voters from Cork into Kerry to vote. In dealing then with the situation in the county and borough of Cork, which is a fairly complicated one, obviously we must, first of all, make some assumptions with regard to how the Kerry situation will be dealt with. We have also to make some assumptions with regard to Waterford and that involves assumptions also in regard to Tipperary. If it is possible, and if this is considered the most desirable way of dealing with it, to leave the county of Cork completely within its own boundaries, then the total representation of Cork could remain as it is; but the constituencies, of course, could not remain as they are. Constituencies would have to be adjusted, one with the other, and there are many ways in which this could be done. As I have said, the figures are published in the Official Report and I will leave Senators to work out the many different permutations and combinations that could be made in the county of Cork, either dealing with it on its own or making some assumptions with regard to adjustments with the bordering counties. No doubt, in doing that, they will avail themselves of the generous offer by Senator "Rugged Independent" Quinlan of the assistance of the toy computer.

Comment on this

We come now to the county of Tipperary, or the two counties of Tipperary. What we outsiders generally look upon as the county of Tipperary is, of course, divided into two separate counties. Not being a Tipperaryman myself, I do not consider the border between the North Riding and the South Riding as of any great significance. Possibly the people who reside in the county do. In any event that boundary has already been breached. It is equally obvious from the figures that a further adjustment will have to take place. I would not consider that of any great significance myself. Looking at it from the point of view of someone outside the county of Tipperary, there the total population is 122,812. It would be possible, if the county could be considered in isolation, to deal with the representation of the county within the confines of its own boundaries by allocating six seats. This would result in there being a marginally greater number of people than the national average per Deputy in the two three-seat constituencies or the six single-seat constituencies, whichever it would be. But it would be possible to do it within my interpretation of present constitutional requirements.

This would involve the return to the county of Waterford of the present substantial number of Waterford people who vote in County Tipperary, who were transferred there in 1961, much to the dissatisfaction of every public representative in County Waterford and in, I think, County Tipperary also. If Tipperary is dealt with in this way, we will then be left, if the constituencies are revised by the return of the population of Waterford, with a problem in Waterford similar to the problem that had to be solved on the last occasion there.

The population of County Waterford including the county borough, is 73,080 and at present the constituency of Waterford returns three Deputies to the Dáil. The maximum population allowable for a three-seat constituency, in accordance with my interpretation of the Constitution, is 63,084. If the population at present attached to Tipperary, although it is separated from Tipperary by the Comeragh Mountains, is returned to Waterford, then Waterford must be adjusted in some way with some other county, either by transferring at least approximately 10,000 people out of Waterford or by transferring at least something over 3,000 people to Waterford. It could be dealt with in conjunction with Wexford or Kilkenny, or, again, with County Cork, but I understand there were a number of objections when Waterford was adjusted with Cork before. It was considered a monstrous injustice to require the people in the adjoining part of Cork to vote in County Waterford instead of in County Cork, whereas now the Opposition contend this would be a vindication of their democratic rights, but if the Opposition's attempt to hang on to the present position which they so roundly condemned in 1961 is successful, the likelihood is that the only way in which the situation in Waterford can be dealt with—the least unsatisfactory way in which it can be dealt with—would be either by requiring part of the population of Waterford to vote in some County Cork constituency or by transferring part of the people of East Cork to a County Waterford constituency, which would then return four Deputies.

Unlike Senator FitzGerald, giving the Seanad some sketchy information with regard to what is likely to happen, I have given the figures and the figures that are relevant, according to Senator FitzGerald. I have based it on a more liberal interpretation of the decision of the High Court than the Opposition are prepared to concede. I have shown that, even on this liberal interpretation of the Constitution, practically every county in Ireland must have its boundaries breached, practically every constituency in Ireland must be disrupted. I think every single one, except the constituency of Wicklow, must be disrupted in some way and the question that arises is whether or not the proposal we are putting before the people to avoid that is a desirable one or not, whether it is democratically necessary and otherwise desirable that this continual chopping and changing and shuffling around of people from county to county, province to province, constituency to constituency is something that is desirable or whether it is not.

That is the question that we intend to ask the people and we intend that the people will know exactly what is involved and, unfortunately, much as I would like to facilitate my colleague, Senator Rooney, I cannot agree to wait until after the referendum for the people to find out what would happen.

Comment on this

We know the answer.

Comment on this

I appreciate very much indeed that this would suit Senator Rooney and the Fine Gael Party and the rugged Independents but——

Comment on this

You are only waiting for a chance to gerrymander.

Comment on this

The answer is "No".

Comment on this

——I am not prepared to co-operate. We will make every effort, and we think we will be successful, to let the people know exactly what is involved in this whole proposal of the Opposition's to retain the present completely unjustifiable position.

We are asking that there should be granted a maximum scope of one-sixth divergence from the national average, in certain specified circumstances only, to avoid this type of butchery, this type of injustice, and the Opposition seem to think that this is something terrible, this is a substantial departure from democratic principles. In fact, compared with the situation in other countries, what we are asking for is a very small permitted divergence indeed. I think I should, first of all, indicate exactly what the position is in the neighbouring country of Great Britain or the United Kingdom or whatever you like to call it and in order to show that a much greater divergence from the national average is allowable there, it is not necessary to compare, say, extremely rural and depopulated constituencies with highly urbanised and built-up constituencies because, if we compare only London boroughs with London boroughs, we find that the lowest electorate is 33,811 in Bermondsey and the highest is 69,870 in Putney (Wandsworth), which gives an excess of 207 per cent of the most populous constituency there over the least populous, the divergence from the national average being in one case 40 per cent below the national average and in the other case 23 per cent above it. If we compare other English boroughs outside of London we find that in Portsmouth-Langstone—the electorate is 96,166 and in Birmingham-Ladywood—the electorate is 25,294, which gives an excess of 380 per cent as between one and the other; and in English counties—Billericay-Essex— the electorate is 102,198 as against Leominster in Hereford, where the electorate is 38,880, which is an excess of one over the other of 363 per cent. With regard to Welsh boroughs, the Newport electorate exceeds that of the Rhondda West by 218 per cent. In regard to Welsh counties, Monmouth exceeds Merionethshire by 253 per cent. In regard to Scottish boroughs, Glasgow-Cathcart — exceeds Kelkingrove by 271 per cent and in Scottish counties, Dumbartonshire exceeds Western Isles by 340 per cent.

Comment on this

Does the Minister approve of that?

Comment on this

The question of whether I approve of that or not does not arise. I have sufficient to do to deal with the 38 constituencies in the 26 Counties here. I am only saying that what we are asking shall be done, for the purpose, and the only purpose, of avoiding injustice, is very modest compared with the position in this adjoining country. So that, the most populous constituency is 80 per cent above the national average and the least populous is 60 per cent below the national average, meaning that the range is that the most populous constituency is 450 per cent more than the least populous one.

For a time in Great Britain a maximum tolerance of plus or minus 25 per cent was fixed and this applied for some years but it was abandoned as being too restrictive and I have given the present position.

In Austria, a divergence exists of 20 per cent above or below the national average; in West Germany 33? above or below; in Canada, 25 per cent above or below the national average and in France there are cases where it is 60 per cent below and 46 per cent above the national average. If this proposal of ours is undemocratic, it is certainly similar to but much more modest than the position in many other countries.

We are proposing certain reasons— that this divergence can only be exercised for certain clearly specified reasons—namely, to avoid if possible the breaching of county boundaries, and to take account of the extent and the accessibility of constituencies; and it is interesting to note what is the position in England and Wales in this respect. There constituencies must be decided in accordance with certain rules, and part of the rules contain the following: One, No county or any part thereof shall be included in a constituency which includes the whole or any part of any other county or the whole or part of a county borough or a metropolitan borough; two, No county borough or any part thereof shall include in a constituency the whole or any part of any other county borough or metropolitan borough; three, No metropolitan borough or any part thereof shall be included in a constituency which includes the whole or any part of any other metropolitan borough; and four, No county district shall be included partly in one constituency and partly in another constituency.

I shall now get down to one of the two diametrically opposed positions which the rugged Independent from Cork University advises. All we want to do is that, subject to a maximum divergence of one-sixth above or below the national average, every attempt should be made to avoid the breach of county boundaries, as against what happens in another country which is looked on as a democracy and which expressly prohibits any county or any part thereof being included in any constituency which includes the whole or part of any other county or the whole or part of a county borough or a metropolitan borough——

Comment on this

Return Blackrock to Cork, then.

Comment on this

That is one of the likely eventualities.

Comment on this

You would lose another seat.

Comment on this

No, no. Do not forget we have four seats there. I will be dealing with that. Senator FitzGerald dealt at length with it and I will prove to Senator FitzGerald that we will retain the four seats we have in Cork. I have not dealt with Cork in any great detail because I had a kind of an inkling—a kind of feeling was penetrating through me—that Senators were getting slightly tired.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Now I find that the rugged Independent from Cork is greatly offended because I did not go in detail into the many possibilities of what might happen in Cork, and one of those undoubtedly is that on this occasion the butchery of the Cork borough that was imposed on it by the decision of the High Court, which was extracted by the manoeuvring of Fine Gael, might be avoided on this occasion and that in the necessary adjustment of the constituencies in Cork, having first of all necessarily dealt with the surrounding counties, that part of the solution may be that the integrity of the Cork borough boundary might be respected on this occasion.

The rugged Independent from Cork apparently sees that as the most desirable exercise. The breaching of the Donegal county boundary, the disappearance from the map of Leitrim and the breaching of the county boundaries of Louth, Kildare, Meath and of every county west of the Shannon are of no importance to him so long as the Cork borough boundary is respected. It strikes me that Senator Quinlan wants to salve his conscience for his decision to oppose this proposal to amend the Constitution, based on his uniform approach to everything proposed by Fianna Fáil. Apparently, if he is assured that the county borough boundary of Cork would not be breached, that would salve his conscience.

Comment on this

The city boundary.

Comment on this

I should like to think of Senator Quinlan sleeping easily when he gets home some time tonight, or possibly some time in the early hours of the morning or possibly some time during the weekend, I suppose. I cannot say for certain, but it is quite likely that even if Senator Quinlan has his way and the people refuse to make this amendment of the Constitution, which was demanded by all shades of opinion in 1961, that the integrity of the Cork county borough boundary will not be breached. It is a boundary which has not been very long in existence. I seem to remember a rugged Independent of our own Party putting up a considerable fight in regard to the establishment of the same boundary and I do not think it enjoys such complete acceptance in its own area as do the boundaries of long established counties like Leitrim, Donegal, Cavan, Monaghan and so on, though they were established by the infamous King John, Senator Dooge told us, and the boundary of Cork borough was established by the much more infamous Fianna Fáil Government.

I have shown that it is extremely doubtful if any county except Wicklow can retain its integrity unless this amendment is made. One of the things of which I was accused was that I pointed out in my opening remarks that the overall effect of the operation of this proposal for a maximum permitted divergence of one-sixth above or below the national average—I emphasise that this is the maximum permissible divergence—would be roughly to equate the value of a rural vote in general with an urban vote in general.

I do not, of course, suggest for a moment that every rural vote would form the exact same fraction of the number of votes per Deputy as each urban vote, nor indeed would it be possible to equate the value of each rural vote with each urban vote in this way. It would not be possible to do it even if we wanted to. Neither would it be possible to ensure that each urban vote is equated with each other urban vote and it is not correct to say that I implied that the percentage of the people of voting age in the total population was uniformly low in all urban areas and uniformly high in all rural areas. It is a fact, however, that in general the pattern is one of a higher proportion of adults in rural areas, though there are some rural areas with a high average percentage of people of less than 21 years of age and some urban areas with a high percentage average of people of more than 21 years of age.

I said that in general in built-up areas the pattern is one of a higher proportion of people of less than voting age than in rural areas in general, and that statement will stand up to examination. I did not say, either, that the objective of this proposal was to ensure that each vote would be of exactly the same effect in electing a Deputy in every part of the country, but the overall position, if you take the two most obviously highly populated and built-up areas, the Dublin area and the Cork city area—Dublin, including the county, the county borough and the borough of Dún Laoghaire—and if you look at that area as a whole and the rest of Ireland as a whole, the position is that in the Dublin and Cork area the proportion of electors to population is 56 per cent and in the rest of the country the percentage of population comprised by the electorate is 61 per cent. If a revision of constituencies on the proposed basis of strict parity of population per Deputy is to be made then the result will be that as compared with a vote in these more densely populated areas a vote in the rest of the country in general will be 9 per cent less effective. It is a fact which cannot be controverted that in the present constituency of Dublin North West the percentage of voters in the total population is 50.96 per cent and in the present constituency of Donegal South West the corresponding percentage is 67.74 per cent.

If the constituencies are revised, as Senators opposite want them to be revised, then it will take 10,206 voters to elect a Deputy in the Dublin area and 13,567 voters in the Donegal area. This is the situation that Senators opposite are so desperately trying to cling to. They want to ensure that the present situation, which requires 13,567 voters in Donegal to elect a Deputy and requires in the Dublin North West area only 10,206, will continue. The only justification I heard put forward for this was that it was quite right that voting power should be decided in accordance with the size of the family. Much more than the size of the family comes into this. As I pointed out to Senators already, the total population is the population resident in the area on a particular night, and it does not matter whether they are babies in maternity hospitals whose parents may reside anywhere, patients in regional hospitals, students at colleges, aliens in hotels, or residents, such as Senators having to stay overnight because of the fact that they took longer than they expected to do their business.

All these factors contribute to increasing the effect of each vote in the particular area in which they happen to be on the particular night. Even if we accept this theory—we have already discovered the FitzGerald theory and I do not know who put forward this one —but even if we accept this proposition that votes should be weighted in accordance with the family responsibility of the voter then surely this should be done on a personal basis, and why should people who have no family in the built-up areas have this differential attached to their votes as well as the fathers and mothers of families. If it were possible to carry out an investigation of family responsibility for voters in the country there might be something to be said for this, but I cannot see why single people—and there are such in Dublin as well as in rural parts of Ireland—should have their votes increased as well as the fathers and mothers of families, or why people in religious institutions, who have not got families—and a lot of them do not vote at all—and there are a number of them in built-up areas— should have their votes increased for this purpose. This proposition is an unjustifiable one and, in any case, I do not see that it is really democratically necessary to try to ensure it.

As I pointed out, what the Senators opposite want to insist on is that this type of disparity in representation should continue: that it is right and just that it should take 13,567 people in Donegal South West to elect a Deputy and only 10,206 in Dublin North West; that it is right that it should take 33 per cent more in the widely scattered rural area of Donegal than in the comparatively compact and reasonably manageable area of Dublin North West. I was born and reared in Dublin city and I think it is easier to get around a Dublin constituency than it is, for instance, to get around the constituency which Deputy Harte wants for himself—the whole of Donegal, or a constituency of the whole of County Kerry with all the peninsulas and mountain ranges that that would involve.

I know Deputy Ryan's contention, for instance, about Dublin city. I was not impressed with his description of the trials and tribulations of a city Deputy in having to cover the vast expanse between Rathmines and Kimmage in a constituency in Dublin South West. Deputy Ryan is so obsessed with his difficulties in that area that he is on record as maintaining that it was a much more arduous operation to cover the whole of that constituency than the whole of such a simple constituency as Donegal or Kerry or the joint counties of Laois/ Offaly.

This proposed divergence is a maximum divergence and can only operate for certain clearly specified reasons. It seems obvious, therefore, that even if any Minister or any Commission wanted to operate the maximum divergence for the benefit of rural areas in general it would not be permissible and it would be possible to have such a revision of constituencies declared unconstitutional by the High Court. If such a revision of constituencies were ever made, I am sure that these people of Fine Gael in the Seanad and the Dáil Deputies who specialise in constitutional wrangling would not be too slow in ensuring that this matter was one to be decided on by the competent legal authorities.

Any Senator who wants to approach this in an objective way will see that it could only be in a few cases that this maximum divergence of one-sixth above or below the national average could operate. It is quite likely that there will be some rural areas as well as some urban areas in which the population per Deputy will be somewhat over the national average rather than somewhat under it. This would obviously require to be done in order to avoid a breach of county boundaries. It is a fact that despite the drift from the land, the total urban population is still considerably below the total rural population. I am talking of the total urban population in terms of urban areas that would be of sufficient size to constitute constituencies on their own. The total rural population is still greater than the total urban population. That being so, if the maximum divergence of one-sixth below the national average were to be operated in relation to the total rural population, then in order that the overall result would be the national average to be complied with, the divergence in urban areas would have to be more than one-sixth greater than the national average per Deputy. Of course this would not be permissible. Even assuming that all the evil intentions that are ascribed to myself and the Fianna Fáil Government were true, and even if it were not a matter that could be referred to the High Court, it would not be possible to operate the maximum divergence of one-sixth in all areas in a uniform way.

The position in fact is obvious. There will be a few cases in rural areas in which the population per Deputy will be something approaching one-sixth below the national average, there will be some in which it will approximate to the national average, there will be some in which the proportion per Deputy will vary between five-sixths of the national average and the national average, and there will be probably some in which it will be marginally above the national average. Clearly it is doubtful if the overall result will be even to nullify the nine per cent by which the electorate per Deputy in rural areas would exceed the corresponding number in built-up areas in Dublin and Cork, in accordance with the present constitutional requirements.

Certainly there is no likelihood of the overall rural vote being more effective than the overall urban vote. It is not claimed that the number of voters per Deputy will be exactly the same in each constituency. Of course, this could not be achieved, if it is, at the same time, desired to avoid breaching county boundaries, which is one of the requirements we are proposing to carry into the Constitution. Apparently there is an idea here that the most important thing is to ensure that it takes exactly the same number of votes to elect every Deputy. If so this position will be more nearly attained under the proposed amendment than under the present requirements. This is absolutely clear and incontrovertible. If constituencies were to be delineated on the basis of an accurate analysis of the register of voters and on a strict equality of voters per Deputy, then this could be achieved for that one year but it is questionable whether this is democratically necessary. Certainly neither I nor anyone else on this side of the House has suggested that this was necessary or that this was the purpose of the Bill.

I do not think, for example, that it is necessary that the people of Louth and the people of Monaghan should be interchanged, as they have been, in order to vindicate their democratic rights or that the people of Waterford should have to be shifted in and out of County Tipperary in this way. The fact is the change we propose will clearly in general do no more than make the average rural vote equally as effective as the average urban vote to elect a Deputy. I quite freely admit that this was not the actual objective, that the reason for the proposal was to accede to the demand from all sections of the House that there should be reasonable scope to avoid the anomaly and injustice of breaching county boundaries, which had to occur on the last occasion in 1961, and would have to occur on such a much wider scale now, if this change is not made.

In order to oppose this, the Opposition allege that this would favour rural votes as against urban votes. In fact, an investigation shows this to be wrong. As I pointed out, I have been asked why I did not propose merely to base representation on the Register of Electors instead of on census. I have already dealt with this, though I admit not at great detail, in my opening statement. I pointed out that while this would ensure that the present weighting of the urban vote in general as against the rural vote in general would be eliminated, it would still not get over the real injustice of this frequent chopping and changing and breaching of administrative boundaries. A certain amount of permitted deviation would still be required if this were to be done. In fact, the percentage deviation required in a constituency revision based on the electorate rather than the population would be roughly the same in some individual constituencies.

Of course, if constituencies were to be based on the number of votes and a divergent percentage to be specified, then it could much more truly be argued that the result would be to give added weight to the votes in certain areas. There are a number of practical reasons why it is preferable to use the census figures of population as a basis, provided always that there is reasonable scope permitted. For one thing, representation has been based on the census figures since the foundation of the State and it worked reasonably well, while the phrase "as far as it is practical" was interpreted as intended by the people who inserted it into the Constitution. The dissatisfaction which has arisen as a result of the High Court decision will be substantially cured by the present proposal. Apart from that, it is so easy to confuse the Opposition that to propose a change from population to voters in addition to the other changes would probably make their confusion absolute. As Senators know, that is the last thing we desire.

We have done everything possible to unconfuse the minds of the Opposition, not very successfully I must admit, but we did everything we could. We separated the proposal into two different proposals. We put them back again for Second Reading. We separated them again for Committee and other Stages of the Bill. The more we did, the more confused the Opposition got. Apart from that, the fact is that the compilation of the census figures is undertaken on a national scale, organised on a national basis and carried out by experts and they are generally accepted as having a high degree of accuracy and a uniform degree of accuracy over the country as a whole.

On the other hand, anybody who has any practical experience of political activity—I know that that does not apply to a lot of the more academic Members of the Opposition here in this House—will know that the accuracy of the register is constantly being criticised and that in fact the figures of electorate based on registers compiled as at present would not have the same degree of confidence as figures derived from a census. The register of course has to be prepared annually. The electorate figures derived from the register of voters then would not have the same degree of finality and if a register, even a year or two years after the register on which constituencies were based disclosed a significant change, then we would inevitably have pressures for even more frequent revision of constituencies than under the present system. The fact that the register has to be compiled every year does not, I think, justify the same expense as is inevitably incurred in the compilation of the census, which is only once every five years. Therefore, I think the proposition we are making of continuing the basis of revision or the delineation of constituencies fundamentally on census figures, but allowing a very small amount of scope in order to avoid injustices, seems to be a reasonable one.

One of the most amusing things I heard so far was Senator Garret FitzGerald purporting to commit, as he described it, "his" Party to supporting an amendment. I take that with a grain of salt because not even the Leader of the Fine Gael Party can speak about the mind of the Fine Gael Party, and although there is, I suppose, a fairly widespread opinion that the real leadership and control of the Fine Gael Party rests in this House rather than in the Dáil still the titular Leader of the Party is in the Dáil, and I do not think it would be reasonable to expect me to accept an undertaking from a Member of this House, even one of the eminence of Senator FitzGerald, to the effect that his Party would support such an amendment. No such amendment was suggested by his Party in the Dáil and it strikes me that his suggestion that this amendment should be made here now is merely made in pursuance of the campaign that the Opposition Parties have been carrying out for some time to delay this question going before the people.

Comment on this

The sooner the better.

Comment on this

The allegation has been made that the whole purpose of this Bill is to facilitate the vicious desire of the Fianna Fáil Party to gerrymander constituencies. At the beginning of my reply to this debate, I gave some quotations to show how strenuously the Opposition spokesmen objected to what had to happen in 1961. I admit that their objections to the constitutional position that requires that type of thing were interspersed with abuse and allegations of gerrymandering; in other words, that their acceptance of the position that it was necessary to detach portions of counties and attach them to other counties was interspersed with allegations that the portions of counties that were selected for this were selected on the basis of gerrymandering.

In this context also perhaps it would be relevant to point out that the revision of constituencies that was made two years prior to that, in 1959, was unanimously accepted and that that revision of constituencies was done in accordance with the principle that we are asking the people to establish now, but there were no allegations of gerrymandering then. It was only when the present position was established by the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the High Court that these allegations of gerrymandering were made.

Personally I do not think it is possible to gerrymander here. I would be of the same opinion in this respect as Senator Dooge, that is, that there are not these strong traditional and unshakable allegiance of certain parts of the country to certain political Parties and that information as to the voting strength not only at past elections but at future elections is not available to any political Party. However, even let us assume that Senator Dooge and I are wrong, that this information is available and that it is available in sufficient detail for an unscrupulous Minister such as myself to select the portions of constituencies favourable to his own Party and thereby leave, of course, the portions that are unfavourable in another constituency; let us suppose this is possible —I do not think it is but let us suppose for the sake of argument that it is—in which set of circumstances is the possession of this information more likely to be usable for the purpose of benefiting the Party to which the Minister of the time happens to belong, the present circumstances which are similar to those that existed in 1961 and which produced allegations of gerrymandering or the circumstances that we propose should exist from now on which are the same as the circumstances that it was assumed existed in 1959 when the revision of constituencies was found to be unobjectionable to all Parties?

Comment on this

Not to everyone in this House.

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

To all the people who were engaged in the practical contesting of elections.

Comment on this

Two Members of the Labour Party voted against the Second Stage in this House and one Member of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

I agree, and I assure Senator Sheehy Skeffington that I only said "accepted by the two Houses of the Oireachtas" for the purpose of brevity. In fact, I accept that there were four Members of the Seanad who did not agree with the 1959 revision of constituencies, but having read through what they had to say about it, I interpreted their opposition as being opposition on the ground that the Constitution did not permit scope in regard to the number of population per Deputy for the purpose of avoiding breaches of county boundaries rather than on the ground that the avoidance of doing these things constituted gerrymandering.

The allegations of gerrymandering were on the basis of the present position and we are proposing to revert to the position that existed from 1922 to 1959. I think anybody who would approach this objectively would agree that if it is possible to gerrymander in this country, if the information is available and if the people in different parts of the country are, as the Opposition want us to believe, ignorant people who vote according to tradition and who make no assessment of the merits and demerits of the different proposals put before them for the conduct of the country's affairs—if all these things are right—I do not agree that any of them are right but if they are—then I think it is obvious that the present situation is the situation which gives scope for gerrymandering because the present situation requires that where there is not the national average of population per Deputy available within the confines of one county that situation must be "redressed"—I endeavoured to put the word "redressed" in inverted commas as I said it—that situation must be "redressed" by the attaching of part of another county to that county, or by detaching part of that county and adding it to another county.

It is there that the scope for gerrymandering arises. It is there that the selection can be made. It is there, if the Party of the Minister making the revision—which will for all foreseeable time be the Fianna Fáil Party and the Minister for the next revision myself —has information of the manner in which the people in the different townlands voted at the last election and the manner in which they will vote at the next election available, that is the situation in which the Minister can select the townlands to be detached or attached and that gives an unscrupulous Minister, myself in this case, scope for gerrymandering.

Comment on this

Is it proper for the Minister to describe himself as an unscrupulous Minister?

Comment on this

I think I have been described in that way already when I was not here. I do not say I would not have been described in the same way if I had been here. I was told I was described in that way by a distinguished and eminent Member of this House. All this time I am assuming that the information with regard to the past voting patterns of the people— again this is based on Opposition contentions—indicates the way they will vote the next time. I am assuming that the Minister is unscrupulous. All this is based on Opposition contentions. I am also assuming that I will be the Minister, but that is something I know from the results of by-elections. If all this is true, it is clear that it is the present situation, which the Opposition want to hang on to, that makes it possible to gerrymander, because the townlands in rural areas for attachment or detachment can be selected in accordance with the accuracy of the information available or in accordance with the degree of unscrupulousness of the Minister concerned—and I gather from the Opposition that they do not see much to choose from in regard to unscrupulousness as between myself and my predecessor, now the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. But from what I was told, I believe they would think that I am even more unscrupulous.

Comment on this

That is what I gathered. It is in a situation in which I can pick the townlands that I can gerrymander, rather than the situation we are asking the people to establish, where the requirement in the Constitution will be to adhere to county boundaries as far as possible.

I did not draw up the county boundaries. Senator Dooge told us it was King John who did it. We have had many distinguished Members of our Party, but we never had royalty in it. King John was not a member of the Fianna Fáil Party and in drawing up the county boundaries, I do not think he had any reference to the interest of the Fianna Fáil Party. It is clear that the situation we propose is a situation that will certainly make it considerably more difficult to gerrymander the constituencies.

This is another indication that the Opposition's attitude to this Bill is purely and simply based on the one consistent principle that they always adhere to, that is, that this Bill has been proposed by Fianna Fáil and, therefore, although they demanded it only seven years ago, there must be some ulterior or sinister motive behind it and they must oppose it. The arguments they use to oppose it do not matter, so long as they carry out their function as an Opposition and oppose it.

We had complaints here again that we had not got provision for a Constituency Commission in this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. There was no reference, of course, to the fact that there is provision for a Commission in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I do not think it was even adverted to that our original intention was to put our proposals for electoral reform in one question to the people and that they were only subdivided in this way in order to attempt the impossible, that is, to dispel the confusion in the minds of the Opposition.

But we proposed that there should be a Constituency Commission set up in what appears to be the fairest way possible. When, in order to comply with the Opposition's request, it was decided to separate this proposal for electoral reform into two separate proposals, we had to make a decision as to which of these Bills we would insert the provision for a Constituency Commission into. We have not got a computer. We did not feed the relevant facts into a computer, but we exercised our judgment, and we thought, in view of the fact that it could only be in one Bill, the more appropriate Bill would be the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. After all, what is the purpose of the Third Amendment Bill? It is merely to revert to the situation that existed prior to 1959, a situation which will require only minor adjustments, at 12 yearly intervals, of the existing constituencies.

That being so, and in view of the fact that we are also proposing that it should be a requirement to adhere to county boundaries, if possible, it appeared to us that since the Constituency Commission was only to be in one Bill, it was not so terribly necessary in the Third Amendment Bill. But the Fourth Amendment proposes a completely new system of constituencies. It proposes in the present state of the population 144 new, single-seat constituencies. In other words, it requires a fundamental recasting of the basis of parliamentary representation.

That is obviously a set of circumstances in which it would be desirable that this fundamental review of constituencies should be dealt with by a neutral, or at least an evenly balanced commission. I think the Opposition know that is the position, but again they feel they must object on all possible grounds, whether they are logical or not. We are advising the people to vote "yes" to both of these proposals. Therefore, we on this side of the House are asking the people to provide a Commission to review the constituencies, to ensure it will be written into the Constitution that the constituencies will only be revised by a Constituency Commission evenly balanced. The Opposition are advising the people to vote "no" to both of these proposals. They are advising the people not to accept a commission. What do they want? Is it not obvious that if the people take our advice, they will have a Constituency Commission and, if they take the Opposition's advice, they will not?

I suggested in introducing the Second Stage of the Bill that Senators might ask themselves two questions and, as I might have expected, they refused to do so because they had got their instructions before they came in here. The first question was whether there is, as Deputy J.A. Costello says, a constitutional infirmity that requires to be remedied. I think this debate has clearly established that there is.

Comment on this

It is now 6 o'clock. Does the House wish to adjourn?

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us some idea as to how long he is likely to take so that we could adjourn for tea, if necessary?

Comment on this

There are two Bills.

Comment on this

The agreement was that we should continue until we finished the Second Stage.

Comment on this

We have had so many agreements that have been broken that we do not want to have this one broken.

Comment on this

I do not want to interfere with the time honoured custom of the House.

Comment on this

The decision was to finish.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think we should adjourn for an hour for tea.

Comment on this

No. The decision was to finish.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maolán Fianna Fáil

The decision was to sit until we finish the Second Stage. That does not prevent us from adjourning for lunch or tea. The Senators opposite may have had their rest and have come back now. The Minister requires a break also.

Comment on this

I do not see any reason for filibustering.

Comment on this

The agreement or the understanding was that we could expect to conclude about 1.30 today.

Comment on this

Who broke that? The professors and their pupils.

Comment on this

If the Minister would cease interrupting me, I want to say that I quite appreciate that the arrangements went a bit wrong this morning——

Comment on this

Last night.

Comment on this

That is not a matter for the Chair. The question is: Does the House wish to adjourn?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

We will adjourn.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the sitting be suspended until 7 p.m."

Tá 29
·
Níl 18
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Before we adjourned I was dealing with the Opposition's complaints to the effect that the provision for the Constituency Commission was in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill rather than the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I explained just why it was we thought it more appropriate that it should be in the Bill which proposes to make the more fundamental change in the scheme of the constituencies and the electoral system generally.

I suppose it is a good idea for the Government to try so far as it is possible to meet the wishes of the Opposition so far as they can ascertain them. I have already indicated that we find considerable difficulty in ascertaining the views of the Opposition on any subject because they change so frequently. They may have a view on one occasion but they only hold that view in the belief that it is opposite to the view of the Fianna Fáil Party. If at any time they discover that their view happens to coincide with the view of the Fianna Fáil Party, they drop it like a hot cake and adopt a diametrically opposite view. I do not think there was any reason for the Fianna Fáil Government to believe that the Opposition would have any interest in a Constituency Commission either on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill or on the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill because the proposition we put to the people in 1959 was a single proposition. It was no more involved, in my opinion, than the two propositions we are now putting. Although the need for the clarification of the constitutional provision with regard to the phrase "as near as it is practicable" had not actually arisen at that time, still the proposal in the 1959 Bill did provide for making it clear in the Constitution that regard should be had to the exact same things as we are proposing that regard should be had to now. The only difference is that, in 1959, there was no specific limit put on maximum divergence. On that occasion, the Opposition apparently found no great difficulty in understanding this involved proposal.

This time, when the proposals are substantially the same, the Opposition demanded that they be separated. We separated them. Then we had to put this provision for the Constituency Commission into one Bill or the other. We performed that separation of the proposal into two separate proposals to convenience the Opposition in an effort to interpret their mind. What I want to point out is that we had no reason to believe the Opposition would have any interest whatever in the Constituency Commission because the 1959 proposal contained provision for a Constituency Commission and, so far from welcoming that, the Opposition put down an amendment to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. Of course, it was not voted on until 1959 but it was described as the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. The Opposition put down an amendment proposing the deletion from that Bill of all provision for a Commission to delineate constituencies.

Now, when we are only providing one commission, instead of two separate commissions, they object. They wanted no commission in 1959. They want two commissions in 1968. How could any Government interpret the wishes of people whose approach is obviously based only on the one principle that, whatever the Government do, whether it is to meet them or not, is wrong? Deputy T. F. O'Higgins proposed this amendment on 21st January, 1959. As reported in volume 172, No. 7, column 946 of the Official Report of Dáil Éireann, this was the opinion he expressed about this whole idea of a Constituency Commission:

We think that this Constituency Commission should not be inserted into the Constitution.

Further on, in the course of the same speech, he said:

... we say in this amendment: "Forget about your Constituency Commission. Let any law revising constituencies be passed here through the Dáil. Let it be supported and defended in the Dáil. Let the Minister who seeks to introduce it take full responsibility for it in this House where he can be challenged in the broad light of day, with the press looking on, and the public entitled to admission." We say that is the responsible course for any Minister or any Government genuinely intending to do the right thing to adopt.

Have no Commission. We are proposing in the Bill to revert to the position that existed before 1961—we are proposing to insert the Commission into the other Bill. However, in view of the attitude expressed by both sections of the Opposition in 1959, I think the only suggestion we could reasonably have expected on this occasion—it is only nine years later and, according to the Opposition, it is unreasonable to expect anybody to change his mind in the short space of nine years—from the Opposition would be a suggestion to take the provision for the Constituency Commission out of the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill and to do what they suggested in 1959, namely, to let the Minister take responsibility for the delineation of constituencies. If we cannot expect the people, having seen the disadvantage of the proportional representation system, to change their mind, well, how much less should we expect a responsible Opposition, elected public representatives, to change their mind within such a short period.

I can give further quotation from Deputy O'Higgins and from other Deputies on both sides of the Coalition objecting to the idea of a Commission at all and, in particular, of course, objecting to a "lickspittle of a judge", as he was described, being appointed as chairman. I rather gather, however, that some Members of the Opposition are anxious to go home early and I shall therefore confine myself to saying that it was not only——

Comment on this

It is not only the Members of the Opposition who are anxious to go home tonight.

Comment on this

——the Fine Gael section of the Coalition that objected to anybody except the Minister for Local Government in this context. Their partners in Coalition, the Labour Party, also objected. Deputy Corish, who is now the Leader of the Labour Party in Dáil Éireann, had this to say on the amendment:

The reason I favour the amendment is not so much because it retains what is embodied in the Constitution at present, but because I believe it will work and there is a certain amount of elasticity about it ...

Elasticity, mark you.

At least, it gives the power to the Oireachtas to determine what the constituencies will be, what form they will take and what population will be represented in each. I do not think the system it is proposed now to enshrine in the Constitution will work. It is crude. As Deputy Declan Costello described it, it is putting the veneer of respectability on these other two proposals. For that reason, I think the House should reject this part of the Schedule and adopt the amendment proposed by the two Fine Gael Deputies, or something reasonably near it.

If we were to try to adopt the wishes of the Opposition, we would have no Constituency Commission. It was our intention to put the proposal to the people in the same way as in 1959. It was not our intention to confuse the people by asking them to vote on two ballot papers. We proposed to put a Commission into the Bill to amend the Constitution because we thought that was desirable and in view of the fact that we were proposing a complete recasting of the whole scheme of parliamentary representation. As I say, the only objection we could have anticipated was that a Constituency Commission was not desirable at all. Here we find that far from it not being possible for the people to change their minds in the short space of nine years, whereas neither section of the Opposition wanted any Commission in 1959, now they want two separate Commissions to do the same job.

It would not be unreasonable if the Government despaired of ever interpreting the minds of either of the Opposition Parties. The main thread running through the critism of the Third Amendment is that it will give the Government too much discretion. I pointed out already that that was a complete misrepresentation and that it is the present system that gives the Government too much discretion. If the Fourth Amendment is passed, we will have the Commission presided over by a judge. If, on the other hand, the people accept, let us assume, the Third Amendment and not the Fourth, then we will have the position which existed prior to 1959, multi-seat constituencies and the requirements enshrined in the Constitution that so far as possible constituencies will consist of whole counties or a union of whole counties.

Outside of Dublin, of course, some of the larger counties will have to be divided into two constituencies but this does not give very great scope for what the Opposition call gerrymandering. Even they would have to admit that. Within the Dublin area, the constituencies must be very evenly divided in terms of population per Deputy. This is for two reasons. First of all, there will be no factor relating to the extent and accessibility of constituencies that would justify different treatment in regard to the population per Deputy in one area rather than another and any substantial disparity in the Dublin area could certainly be challenged in the courts.

Secondly, assuming that the requirements of the country as a whole would limit Dublin representation to about 36 as against 34 (at which level a Dublin vote would substantially have the same value as a vote in the rest of the country generally), the population per Deputy in the Dublin area will be quite near the maximum permitted, and since the maximum cannot be exceeded in the case of any single constituency this would mean you would have nearly exact numerical parity of population per Deputy in the Dublin area.

I am convinced that irrespective of the views expressed on the opposite side of the House, practically every Deputy and every Senator believes that the proposed Third Amendment is both reasonable and necessary. They have this inherent idea, however, that if it is proposed by Fianna Fáil, there must be some sinister ulterior motive behind it. The Opposition attitude to the Third Amendment is particularly contemptible and is indicative of their inability to judge any issue objectively. This arises from their long history of continued Opposition. In 1961 all sides of the House appeared to believe that what was required by the High Court decision was undesirable and unjust. That appeared to be an almost unanimous opinion. Of course in any suggestion of unanimity it should be assumed that we leave out people like Senator Sheehy Skeffington whom I have never heard agree with anything which was supported by any substantial body of opinion in the country.

I have shown that it was natural for us to assume that the only possible criticism of this proposal would have been that what was proposed was insufficient to deal with this problem either in present or in future circumstances. Instead, we have had this bogus opposition based on the belief that inevitably there is some sinister motive behind anything put forward by Fianna Fáil. We have had a cynical and completely unnecessary and dishonest attempt to divide the people on the basis of the urban population versus the rural population. There is a clear indication in the attitude to this Bill of the decision by both of the Opposition Parties to abandon the people of rural Ireland. Obviously Fine Gael assume that those people in rural Ireland who support them will continue to support them, despite this deliberate attempt to downgrade the value of the rural vote in comparison with the urban vote. It is significant that Deputy J.A. Costello when talking about this rural vote in the Dáil in his most effective sarcastic and contemptuous courtroom manner referred to it as the "cow" vote. It is indicative of the attitude of the Fine Gael Party——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is a misquotation.

Comment on this

——to rural Ireland and an indication of their contempt for the intelligence of their own supporters in rural Ireland. Apparently they assume that these supporters of theirs, to whom Deputy J.A. Costello refers so contemptuously as the "cow" vote, will be so bovine as to continue voting for Fine Gael even though Fine Gael are obviously, through the medium of Senator FitzGerald, planning the elimination of the rural community, at the same time as they are kicking their own leader, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, in the teeth. Of course, they demonstrated a similar contempt for the intelligence of the urban voters because they apparently believe they can turn the people in the urban areas against the rural backbone of the community. They believe they can induce the people in built-up areas to covet the differential voting power they offer them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Equality of voting power.

Comment on this

They think they can induce the people of Dublin to covet the increase from the present 34 seats to 38 seats although only 36 seats are justified according to the number of voters. They believe they can succeed in inducing the people to covet this extra representation at the expense of the area from Malin Head in Donegal to Loop Head in Clare, and from Athlone to Belmullet which, at the moment, has 33 seats and which is, even on the basis of the most rigid application of one man, one vote, entitled to 32 seats. But Fine Gael and Labour want to reduce that entire area to 30 seats and they think the people in the urban areas are so biased against the rural areas they will cooperate with the Opposition Parties in this deliberate and scandalous deprivation of the rural community of representation to which they are fully entitled even in accordance with the most rigid interpretation of any democratic principle.

I think I have just as much knowledge of the mentality of the Dublin people as anybody else. I was born and reared among them. I am elected for a Dublin constituency. I do not think that is the approach they will adopt. I think that, even if it did mean a slight excess voting power for the people in that expansive area, they might even consider that the present representation of 34 Deputies in Dublin and 33 in that whole western area would not be unreasonable and they would not, in fact, want anything more than the strict justice which this proposal will give. I do not think they will fall for this attempt by Fine Gael and Labour to turn them against the rural community and covet these two extra seats, seats which Fine Gael want only to try to accommodate the two of the three Deputies O'Higgins, who want to come to Dublin, Deputy O'Donnell, who wants to come to Dublin, Deputy Lindsay, who wants to come to Dublin and people like Senator Garret FitzGerald and Senator O'Quigley, who also want to get Dublin seats, and the whole purpose of the exercise is to try to accommodate all these different ambitions in the Dublin area.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

We do not need new seats. We can pick up enough from you people.

Comment on this

The Dublin people are quite satisfied to get their entitlement, and no more, and they will feel that this is a proposition to divide the country into urban population versus rural population, thereby loading the dice against the people in the rural areas by this stratagem of deliberately, through the Constitution, downgrading the value of the rural vote in general. That is the fundamental difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. We have always respected the people's intelligence and we can confidently recommend this proposal to them in both urban and rural areas. We fully expect this legislation to be enacted and accepted both by the people in Dublin and the people in the rest of the country because we believe in the innate sense of fairplay of the Irish people, whether they live in the cities or whether they live in the rural areas. Fine Gael has contempt for their intelligence. That is why they have spent so long in Opposition. That is why they will continue in that position because the people are not the fools they think they are.

Perhaps, now, we might for the time being, at any rate, leave the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and deal with the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister has spoken for only six hours on it.

Comment on this

I know, but I should not like to keep Senator FitzGerald here because he finds it so hard to contain himself.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am very happy.

Comment on this

The trouble is that, in speaking on the Third Amendment to the Constitution Bill, I so affront Senator FitzGerald's conscience that he resorts to the type of conduct for which he utilised the group of Fine Gael supporters in by-elections all round the country. Here, without this specialist group of meeting disrupters, Senator FitzGerald's conscience is troubled by what he is doing. I am showing him what he is doing and he takes on himself the task of——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have already denied this allegation in explicit and specific terms and is it in order for the Minister now to continue to repeat it? The allegations were made in the most explicit terms. Is the Minister in order now in repeating them?

Comment on this

The Senator——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Allow the Chair to rule, please.

Comment on this