An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 300–464 of 464. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
I am merely making references to my own personal experience, to something both Senator FitzGerald and I know about.
Comment on this
I am merely referring to the group he had with him, for instance, in Ferrybank in Waterford and in Nicker in Limerick more recently.
Comment on this
I never even heard of the place in Limerick. The allegation is made about me and not about other individuals. The allegation is that I directed their activities in tearing down posters. I have denied that allegation.
Comment on this
I saw the Senator doing it. I experienced it myself. I saw the Senator get these people to come up to try to prevent me speaking in Ferrybank. I was there and it did happen, but it did not succeed.
Comment on this
If the Senator denies the allegation the normal thing is for the denial to be accepted.
Comment on this
If the Rules of Order require me to accept this denial of the evidence of my own experience, then I will have to accept that.
Comment on this
There are more people than I who know of the attempt to disrupt the Fianna Fáil meeting in Ferrybank and in County Limerick and another meeting even in the hallowed precincts of University College, Dublin, itself.
Comment on this
If Senator FitzGerald can restrain himself from attempting to do the same thing here, to disrupt my reply to the debate, these matters need not arise. Of course, if he is unable to restrain himself, it might be more orderly and more consistent with the character that he tries to assume if he would remove himself but, of course, he cannot have one attitude here and another——
Comment on this
I do not think it is in order for a Minister to instruct Senators to remove themselves from the Seanad.
Comment on this
It is, I suppose, only natural that one is inclined to act in the same way in different places. Before Senator FitzGerald's attempt to prevent me from doing so I was proposing to say a few words about the other proposal we are putting before the people, the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, the proposal to replace the present system of multiple member constituencies and the transferable vote, as it is called, by the system of single-seat constituencies and the straight vote. Here, again, the first thing that comes to my mind is the repeated inquiries from the Opposition benches as to why we were asking the people to do this—tá sé ag imeacht—and this time the question was amplified by the remark, in view of the fact that the people pronounced on this issue nine years ago. So, although this also has been explained to the Opposition on a number of occasions, by the Taoiseach and myself and by other speakers on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, both here and in the other House, still, I suppose, since I am replying to this debate, I had better try once again to explain to the Opposition that we see nothing undemocratic in asking the people to decide the matter and explain also the reasons why we are asking them to make this decision.
First of all, there is the fact that the necessity to try to avoid the injustice to which I have referred on the Third Amendment Bill decided us to have a referendum, to ask the people to amend the Constitution, so that before considering this question of the electoral system, a referendum had, in fact, been decided upon. The question then arose as to what was the question to be put to the people and this inevitably raised the question of the electoral system itself and a decision had to be taken as to whether or not we should ask the people to deal with the electoral system, to give themselves a more rational system of representation and of election.
There were a number of factors that came into consideration. First of all, we have what the Opposition have been referring to as the long counts— I do not think I referred to them as long counts; I referred to them as long recounts—and what these long recounts disclosed. I think they were generally believed by the people to be disedifying. They disclosed the fact that there was this considerable element of chance which, of course, as some Senators have said, is insignificant in certain circumstances but in the circumstances of a close result can be quite a significant factor. In fact, in a close result, it would be just as democratic and just as likely to produce the correct result to toss a coin as to who should be elected as to pick bundles of papers at random for redistribution, as it is called. Even though there was no mixing or re-mixing—of the counterfoils, I was going to say, because it is something like a sweepstake—but of the ballot papers on these recounts, still, it was quite obvious that, even allowing for the factor of fatigue which, the longer the count goes, becomes more important in relation to the ultimate result —even apart from the question of fatigue, it becomes quite obvious that as often as you counted the papers, you got a different result. Of course, that arises from the fact that these papers are taken at random.
The people in general, I think, saw that. They saw that the electoral system, to say the least, was not entirely reliable. Anybody who has been present at an election count realises that the conditions under which the returning officer's staff work are certainly far from ideal. They work under scrutiny the closeness of which varies in accordance with the attitude of the returning officer to the agents of the various candidates, but they work under very difficult conditions. Even in a normal count not involving a recount at all, they work for long hours, longer than normal working hours, and the task they have to perform, they not being computers, is a fatiguing one and one which in itself is conducive to the making of mistakes.
Arising out of that experience, the natural thing would be, instead of imposing these longer-than-normal working hours on the returning officer's staff, that there is a clear indication that in order to be even reasonably convinced of the reliability of the results, their working hours should be shorter than normal and that even a normal count without a recount at all should take days rather than hours to complete.
Comment on this
Anybody experienced in election counts who has seen the staff putting ballot papers into pigeonholes in the later stages of a count when one will not know for certain whether it is No. 3, No. 4 or No. 5 is the relevant preference—all depending on the way the vote is cast—will know that there is nothing definite about which figure is the relevant one. When they see these being put into pigeonholes at the same rate as No. 1s, a lot of people are suspicious about the results. That is not taking into account the ridiculous assumption on which the whole process is based, but merely the mechanical operation of distributing these votes according to the ridiculous and unjustifiable rules of the system. Obviously, then, if the count were to be carried out in this more reasonable way, and if we were still to have these long recounts—and it is obvious that we should have had more last time and that we will have more in future, as Senator Quinlan says—in fact, the ballot papers should be thoroughly mixed, not alone the first time, but thoroughly re-mixed the second time, and then we would see the different results.
It would be necessary to instal a replica of the Hospitals Sweepstake drum in every place where a count was taking place in order that the papers should be mixed, first of all, to try to ensure that the random bundle taken for distribution would have a reasonable chance of representing a cross-section of the community's votes rather than that it should, by pure chance, favour one continuing candidate rather than another because it happened to come, in the main, from voters located in one particular part of the constituency. All these things led to a certain feeling among the community in general that the present system of election was not a reliable one, that the results could not be depended on, and though I cannot say that that constituted a demand by the public for a change because I do not know how the public can demand a change, I am saying that it led to something almost approaching an assumption that an effort would be made to provide the people with a more rational and reliable system of electing their public representatives.
In fact, a perusal of the newspapers of the time will indicate that those accurate interpreters of public opinion, the political correspondents of the Opposition newspapers—I would not for the world quote any opinion expressed in the newspaper that is supposed to support the Fianna Fáil Party——
Comment on this
You will be expelled for saying that. That is heresy. Senator FitzGerald is undermining his own position as the power behind the scenes, the grey eminence of the Fine Gael Party. I should not like to encourage the Senator to go along those lines, because I am satisfied that so long as Senator FitzGerald continues to draft the political statements of the Fine Gael Party, we are certain to continue in Government, and I would not like him to do anything to undermine his position in the Fine Gael Party.
As I said, there was considerable speculation about the possibility and the likelihood of the people being given an opportunity to provide themselves with a more rational and reliable system of election before the next general election. The Irish Independent of 13th April, 1965, stated this:
One outcome of the confusion and uncertainty could well be a reappraisal of our whole election machinery, and, particularly, of the system of proportional representation.
The Irish Times of 10th April, 1965, stated:
The Proportional Representation system of voting was mentioned critically more than once; it will no doubt come under scrutiny and indeed under fire in the near future.
The Irish Times of 12th April, 1965, stated:
The marathon of Bolton St. and Longford-Westmeath has done more than Mr. de Valera's campaign to focus attention on the system of PR and after the victory of Mr. Lemass, has become the main talking point of the 1965 election. One must expect the anti-PR lobby to become violently active again in the weeks ahead.
The Irish Times of 13th April, 1965, said:
In the new Dáil Mr. Lemass may be pressed by members of his own party to hold another referendum on the PR system. It is known that many Fianna Fáil deputies feel that no Party can expect to have a comfortable working majority in the Dáil under the present system.
I am not saying that even these or the many letters written to the newspapers on this subject constituted a public demand, a demand by the public for a revision of their electoral system, but they were in the Opposition papers and they did have this effect at least, that they induced an SOS from somebody in this country, whether Fine Gael or Labour, to that redoubtable defender of the faithful, Miss Enid Lakeman, and in the issues of the newspapers around that period, there were plentiful letters from Miss Lakeman, faithfully defending the system that her society exist to maintain in this country but, of course, not in her own country.
I do not know who sent out the SOS that the system was in danger again, that the Government were putting forward a new system. I do not know whether it was Fine Gael, Labour, that is, in other words, the Lakeman Party, or whether it was her particular devotee here, Senator Sheehy Skeffington, or whether she saw the danger; presumably the society which the Fine Gael organ described as a British society and a heavily subsidised society saw the danger that the one place in which this system existed —devised, as Deputy Dillon said, by cranks and half lunatics—even here might cease to operate.
We had this defence being put up against a proposition that had not been made. As I say, I do not know whether there was a public demand for the opportunity to establish a more rational electoral system here. I would say there was something amounting to an assumption that the people would be given an opportunity.
Then we had the informal Committee studying the Constitution, of which some of the Members of this House were members. This Committee were set up to study the Constitution, but I do not think their terms of reference directed their attention in any particular way to the electoral system. I know that the proceedings were supposed to be confidential. I know that the people acting on the Committee undertook that the proceedings would be confidential.
In know that throughout all the period of the sittings that neither the Fianna Fáil Party nor the Government received any indication from their members on the Committee as to what was engaging the Committee's attention. I also know that throughout the whole period that this Committee were in session, the accurate interpreters of public opinion, the people who claim to know what is going on, even among a small group of people who have undertaken to keep confidential what they are doing, regularly assumed that a large part of the time of that Committee was concerned with an attempt to agree on an amendment of the Constitution which would get rid of the system of election and representation that had been shown to be so unsuitable in the previous general election.
Comment on this
In fact, when this Committee did report, it was quite obvious to anybody glancing through the report that the Committee had devoted a considerable amount of time to discussion of the problem. It was obvious that every attempt was made by the Fianna Fáil representatives on that Committee to reach agreement——
Comment on this
Yes, to try to reach agreement. The Fianna Fáil members of the Committee, dedicated as they were known to be since 1959 to the principle of the single-seat constituency and the straight vote, in their attempts to reach agreement with the Opposition, apparently put forward the proposition and certainly, according to the report, they were described as discussing only the proposition of the single-seat constituency with the transferable vote.
It was obvious from the report that this Committee did spend a considerable part of their time discussing the electoral system and that there must have been a certain amount of agreement in the Committee, at least, that the public did desire some improved system. In the event, apparently, it was not possible to get agreement. I do not know what measure of agreement was achieved. I do not know whether the Committee, meeting confidentially, were divided on the lines on which every proposition is divided here—that everybody who is not Fianna Fáil is in Opposition—but I did not ask any Fianna Fáil person who was on that Committee to tell me because I know each and every one of them would honour his undertaking to keep what happened there confidential, and I would not ask them to disclose what attitude any individual members of the Opposition took.
I would contrast that with the attitude of the Members of the Opposition who were on the Committee and who purported to convey opinions which they alleged were expressed by individual members representing Fianna Fáil on that Committee. The mere fact that they claim they are telling this brands them immediately as being people whose word cannot be trusted. Therefore, the statements cannot be taken at their face value because the mere fact that they were made at all indicates that these were people whose word is of no concern to them and that, in fact, they are admittedly committing an open breach of faith in putting forward these allegations as to individual attitudes. One thing is clear. Of the Fianna Fáil members who were on that Committee, each and every one of them has publicly supported the proposition which the Government are now putting forward.
Comment on this
Four of them are on record in the Dáil, and the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, who was on the Committee for a short time, has publicly supported the proposals outside the Dáil. As far as I know, he has not spoken in the Dáil since he resigned as Taoiseach. I hope he will contribute to the discussions there in the future. He did make a point of expressing his support of this proposition and making it clear to his constituents and the people of Ireland that on this matter he stood where he stood in 1959. The same applies to Fianna Fáil Senators who were on that Committee. They have made it clear that they favour this proposition. That does not necessarily mean that any of these people were not prepared to reach a compromise at that Committee if it were possible to have agreement. It was not possible because the Opposition are afraid of anything Fianna Fáil agree to.
In regard to the Constitution Committee, there is the fact that this Committee which was set up to consider the constitution in general did spend a lot of their time considering the desirability of changing the electoral system, although a proposal to amend the electoral system had been defeated by the people, not nine years ago at that time, but five or six years previously. The Committee was set up in 1965 or 1966 so it was a maximum of seven years. Arising out of what happened at the 1965 election, this Committee naturally started to consider the possibility of agreeing on a more rational system of election. I do not think that this breach of faith that has been committed in this House and in the other House, started from the word go and that these people started immediately to retail to the political correspondents what happened at meetings of this Committee, but I would believe that the insistence of political correspondents that the Committee were discussing the electoral system arose out of their assessment of what was likely to be discussed and because they knew that the electoral system was crying out for reform and that these people sitting down would pick out that aspect for their first consideration, something approaching an assumption that the people should be given an opportunity of considering a more rational system.
There was the fact also that the people had more experience of PR in general. They have by now seen, in addition to previous examples that were available to them, the virtual impossibility of both Belgium and Italy forming a government at all because of the multiplicity of Parties there, and they appreciate that the system of election we have here was invented in order to ensure representation for minorities, whoever they are, in the Dáil. In view of the fact that it was designed to ensure minority representation, it was obviously also designed to encourage the formation of small sectional Parties and we believe, at any rate, that this extra experience the people have had of PR systems in general, the examples they have had of the danger of indecisive election results and the knowledge they have that the system is designed to produce exactly that type of result will influence the people on this occasion to rid themselves of this system and thereby avoid the dangers the system must inevitably give rise to.
It is true a decision was made on this proposition nine years ago, but in the period since then, a number of new people have come on to the register and some of these who voted for the old system, or were against a replacement of the old system the last time, have gone off the register. As well as that, there was a comparatively low poll and anybody would agree with the estimate that more than 50 per cent of the present electorate have not, in fact, expressed any opinion on this, either because they did not vote the last time or were not of age to vote.
Those were the reasons why we felt the people should be given an opportunity of ridding themselves of the present system. As well as that, there is the fact that at our annual Ard-Fheis a number of units of the organisation had resolutions on the Clár proposing that this be done, proposing that the system of the single-seat constituency should be established here, not mentioning the system of voting. It is natural that the system of voting would not be mentioned because it was widely believed at that time that an effort was being made to get agreement on a system of voting on a single-seat constituency and obviously our Party were prepared to trust the Government to decide on that particular aspect of it.
There was a clear indication given. Senator Ó Maoláin, who was in charge of the actual counting of the votes, and so on, believes it was unanimous. I believe it was, if not unanimous, virtually unanimous and a decision, therefore, by our Party Ard-Fheis recommended to the Government that the people be given this opportunity of providing themselves with the single-seat constituencies. The Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis, I suppose, does not constitute a unanimous public demand, but it constitutes a substantial public demand. I do not know any body in this country that is more representative of a cross section of the people as a whole than the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis. It is comprised of delegates from every parish and half parish in the country. All different types of people representing different interests in the community came to that Ard-Fheis and they either unanimously, or virtually unanimously, recommended that this be done. That was a substantial section of the community making this demand. It was not a unanimous demand or it could not be interpreted as a unanimous demand of the people as a whole, but in so far as the public demand anyway is concerned, I want to say as a member of the Government that I do not know of any more accurate way of interpreting public opinion than taking the opinions of the people of the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis.
Comment on this
I do not know of any other way, and it is because we have this system of obtaining the views of the people as a whole that we have interpreted the aspirations of the public in general so well as to retain the confidence of the majority of the people as a whole for so long.
In addition to all those things indicating that an opportunity to change the electoral system was expected, there was our own knowledge of the defects of the system.
Comment on this
In case you did not hear me, a consensus of the opinion of everybody, even the Fine Gael Ard Fheis——
Comment on this
I did not hear you because there were so many other people talking. It is not as representative as the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis. You have an Ard Fheis but how anybody could take a consensus of opinion from a Fine Gael Ard Fheis is a matter which is beyond me. You have an Ard Fheis, and if Senator Carton or anybody else is able to interpret anything from the results of that, that is their business. However, one of the factors indicating to us that an opinion was expected was the decision of the Ard Fheis.
Comment on this
I do not want to stop you. I want you to get on with this and get it finished as soon as possible.
Comment on this
As well as that, there was the fact of our own knowledge of the defects and evils of the present system and our knowledge of dangers inherent in it, and also the many advantages which the proposed system presented. Let me say quite definitely, that as far as I am concerned, the main advantage I see is the establishment of the single-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to quote Standing Order 44 of the Standing Orders of the Seanad which says:
After a question (except a question already debarred from debate, under the Standing Orders) has been proposed from the Chair either in the Seanad or in a Committee of the whole Seanad, a Senator may claim to move: "That the question be now put".
You are now in the Chair and I ask you to put the question: "That the question be now put". The Standing Order further says:
Unless it shall appear to the Cathaoirleach that such a motion is an infringement of the rights of a minority, or that the question has not been adequately discussed, or that the motion is otherwise an abuse of these Standing Orders, the question: "That the question be now put" shall be put.
We have been discussing this Bill now for five days.
Comment on this
The Standing Orders provide that I am entitled to be heard on this point of order. I suggest that the question be now put forthwith and decided without amendment or debate. Under Standing Order 44, I am asking that the question be now put. The Minister has debated this for seven hours and by doing so, he is abusing the rights of ordinary people here who are not entitled to do this.
Comment on this
Standing Orders preclude me from giving a decision on the point raised, but it is my intention that the Cathaoirleach be asked to decide on the point of order which has been put.
Comment on this
How do the Standing Orders preclude you? You are in the Chair and how do the Standing Orders preclude you from making a decision on the Standing Orders of this House? You are now the Chairman of this House.
Comment on this
I want to read Standing Order No. 10, which is on page 9.
Comment on this
We have listened to those arguments for long enough and the Minister wants to be stupid.
Comment on this
We want to hear the arguments and the Minister is entitled to speak.
Comment on this
Standing Order No. 10, which you have quoted, says:
During the absence of the Cathaoirleach through illness or other cause, the Leas-Chathaoirleach shall perform the duties devolving upon and exercise the authority conferred upon the Cathaoirleach by these Standing Orders.
There is nothing in that Standing Order which prevents you exercising your authority here.
Comment on this
Surely the Senator who occupies the Chair is either the Cathaoirleach or the Leas-Chathaoirleach?
Comment on this
Unless we are going to be ruled by civil servants, unless we have to listen here to their kind of Civil Service brief, and if we are not to be ruled by Civil Service orders, surely Standing Order No. 10 covers my point?
Comment on this
The Senator is not being ruled by Civil Service orders but by the Standing Orders of the House. The Standing Orders confine the decision to the Cathaoirleach or the Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Comment on this
Are you acting as Cathaoirleach or are you acting as Leas-Chathaoirleach? The Leas-Chathaoirleach is away in England and therefore you must be either acting Cathaoirleach or acting Leas-Chathaoirleach. As the Leas-Chathaoirleach is in England, surely you are acting as Leas-Chathaoirleach?
Comment on this
As the Leas-Chathaoirleach is in England, I am Deputy Chairman acting as Leas-Chathaoirleach, but I am not entitled so to rule.
Comment on this
Wait a minute until I quote this again. It says:
The Leas-Chathaoirleach shall perform the duties devolving upon and exercise the authority conferred upon the Cathaoirleach by these Standing Orders.
Comment on this
As the Leas-Chathaoirleach is in England and the Cathaoirleach is not here, surely you can rule on this?
Comment on this
The Senator is relating what he says to Standing Order No. 44 which applies to closure.
Comment on this
I am not. I am quoting the one you mentioned. You referred me to Standing Order No. 10.
Comment on this
Standing Order No. 10 indicates that the powers conferred on the Cathaoirleach by the Standing Orders shall be all the powers conferred on him by these Standing Orders, excepting the powers conferred by Standing Orders 42 and 44.
Comment on this
On my point of Order, Sir, you referred me to Standing Order No. 10.
Comment on this
I now quote Standing Order No. 11:
If both the Cathaoirleach and the Leas-Chathaoirleach be absent from a meeting of the Seanad, so soon as a quorum is present the Clerk shall so notify the Seanad, and, subject to the provisions of Standing Order 4, the Seanad shall at once proceed to elect one of its members to perform the duties devolving upon and exercise the authority conferred upon the Cathaoirleach by these Standing Orders for that day only. If there be not a quorum present, the Seanad shall stand adjourned until the next sitting day.
You now have the authority of the Cathaoirleach and the Leas-Chathaoirleach under the Standing Orders, and I move that the question be now put and end this stupid debate.
Comment on this
The Chair rules that it has not those powers and it is my intention to send for the Cathaoirleach as is laid down in the event of any point arising which is outside the competence of the Acting Chairman. I am now sending for the Cathaoirleach to determine the point of order raised by the Senator.
Comment on this
——you are not exercising your powers and I say to you further——
Comment on this
I am completely convinced by the reading of Standing Orders that I am correct in my interpretation.
Comment on this
Business is suspended until the Cathaoirleach takes the Chair to deal with the point raised by the Senator.
Business suspended at 8.34 p.m. and resumed at 8.36 p.m.
Comment on this
The Chair understands that Senator McHugh wishes to raise a point of order.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirleach, I raised a point of order in your absence and I quoted Standing Order No. 44 which reads:
After a question (except a question already debarred from debate, under the Standing Orders) has been proposed from the Chair either in the Seanad or in a Committee of the whole Seanad, a Senator may claim to move: "That the question be now put" and unless it shall appear to the Cathaoirleach that such a motion is an infringement of the rights of a minority,
I think we are a minority on this side—
or that the question has not been adequately discussed,
We have been discussing it here for five days, Sir.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what the Minister discussed.
Comment on this
Senator McHugh, to quote the Standing Order without comment.
Comment on this
Do not speak to me when you say "without comment". Speak to the Minister.
Comment on this
If Senator McHugh does not conduct himself, I must ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I shall continue the quotation:
or that the motion is otherwise an abuse of these Standing Orders, the question: "That the question be now put" shall be put forthwith, and decided without amendment or debate.
I am now moving: "That the question be now put", on the ground that it has been adequately discussed.
Comment on this
Do not talk to me about Chair. The Chair has not considered this.
Comment on this
Senator McHugh to resume his seat or leave the House.
Comment on this
——people on the other side of the House were speaking, you did not point a finger at them. You are biased. I will resume my seat because there is no other course open to me, and we will have to listen to this stupid performance, but you are a biased Chairman.
Comment on this
I warn Senator McHugh again that if he does not conduct himself, I will ask him to leave the House. The Minister, to continue.
Comment on this
Before Senator McHugh tried to prevent me from dealing with the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, I was dealing with the requests of the Opposition Senators to explain to them why we decided to put this proposition to the people in view of the fact that a similar proposition had been decided upon nine years ago. In order to make up for the loss of time which has been deliberately occasioned by Senator McHugh, I will assume that I have explained——
Comment on this
I will withdraw. I cannot listen to this stupid Minister.
Comment on this
——reasonably well why we decided to make this proposition. I admit that the establishment of single-seat constituencies is the main objective in this proposal, that the main evil and the main danger to be got rid of is the system of multi-member constituencies—I shall come to that later, I shall explain why this is so—and the corresponding advantage to be obtained if the people have the advantage of having the more normal system of representation by means of single-seat constituencies. There is the fact that you are likely to get better representation, better members eventually, that there will be closer contact between Deputies and the people, that there will be more time available for dealing with their real functions as Members of the Dáil, that the system of single-seat constituencies will be better for public morale, that it will be possible for Parties to make a better effort to obtain a majority because the existing, built-in disincentive in the system of multi-member constituencies against the putting forward of the best possible candidates will be automatically removed, and that the system will be less conducive to splintering, more likely to produce a definite result and enable the people to fulfil their function at election time and that is to choose their own Government.
Briefly, that is why the establishment of single-seat constituencies as opposed to multi-member constituencies is the most important thing. The establishment of the system of the straight vote is also important because this is a proposal to establish for the first time in this country the democratic principle of one man, one vote, to establish the principle of treating every voter in the same way, to get away from the present system which discriminates arbitrarily and unjustifiably as between one voter and another. That is an important consideration also, but as far as I am concerned, it is secondary to the main objective of establishing single-seat constituencies instead of multi-member constituencies.
People have been saying that the public in general would favour single-seat constituencies but with a transferable vote, as in the by-election system at present.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, what is this marathon in aid of? What is the Minister trying to do? We have sat here for four days——
Comment on this
I should inform the Senator that that is not a point of order. The Senator to resume his seat.
Comment on this
If the Senator had asked me what it was in aid of, I would have told him, but I suppose he asked the Chair only and it might not be appropriate for me to reply. There has been this proposition put forward that the people would like to have the single-seat constituency but would like to retain the transferable vote. There is no reason to believe that is so. We had this discussion in the Committee established to investigate the Constitution position and they did not come forward with this suggestion. Because of the fact that the papers were saying that the people wanted this, and that they are described sometimes as organs of public opinion, this idea has gained ground.
Is there any evidence that this is so? An Independent Deputy in the Dáil put down an amendment to this Bill suggesting the system of the transferable vote with single-seat constituencies. That amendment secured no support whatever in the Dáil. I do not know what way the public have of indicating their desires, but public representatives are supposed to be in a position to interpret what the people want. Not one Member of the Dáil on any side of the House indicated that he believed this was what the people wanted. Deputy Norton, who proposed it, made it quite clear that he believed that the straight vote was the more meritorious system, but that he believed that by accepting the less desirable system of voting of the transferable vote, there would be a better prospect of getting the single-seat constituency, which was the more highly-desirable thing. He did not produce any evidence of that because he could not. The fact that he got no support in the Dáil is surely an indication that that evidence was not in fact available.
Therefore, while I agree with Senator McQuillan that the single-seat constituency is the more important thing, the establishment of the principle of one man, one vote inherent in democracy and frustrated by the transferable vote is also important. Since it has not been shown to be even expedient, apart from the fact that it was shown to be undesirable to adopt this system, there seemed to be no reason why the Government should have adopted it. As far as I am concerned, the system of voting is unimportant. But when the responsibility falls on the Government to propose a system of voting, we naturally propose what we believe to be the correct one and the only justifiable system. We would have been failing in our duty if we proposed in the first instance a system which was blatantly discriminatory.
There has been no indication to me that to adopt that system would be in any way more acceptable to the Opposition. All the Opposition take into account is whether a thing is acceptable to Fianna Fáil or not. If it is acceptable to Fianna Fáil, they interpret their duty as being to oppose it. We believe that the fundamental purpose of general elections is to enable the people to choose their own Government. It is our view that that is the fundamental thing in the democratic system. It is quite clear that if the people are organised on the basis of small, sectional Parties, it will obviously become impossible for the people to choose a Government whether they want to or not. The individuals asking for support will be asking for it on the basis of sectional interests rather than on the basis of a broad approach to national affairs as a whole.
Therefore, no matter what the people want to do, a system of election designed to bring this about, and which must inevitably bring it about, eventually will prevent the people from carrying out their fundamental democratic function of choosing their own Government. We believe—apparently the Opposition do not—it is desirable to encourage the people to form themselves into broadly-based national Parties rather than to organise themselves on the basis of minority sectional interests.
We also believe it is desirable to encourage a responsible approach to the exercise of the franchise and that a system of election which guarantees to anybody who wants to exercise his vote in an irresponsible way that, no matter what he does, no matter how irrational or unappealing to the electorate the candidate he chooses is, or the policy put forward by a candidate is, no matter how many individuals such as this he transfers his vote to, the system of election is so arranged as to ensure that his vote will be taken account of at every stage—all that encourages irresponsibility in the exercise of the franchise, which is a serious operation and which should be considered in a responsible way.
Apparently, the Opposition believe it is quite all right that individuals or groups should be elected on the basis of narrow sectional approaches and that the formation of the Government can safely be left to whatever arrangement it is possible for these individuals and groups to make after the election. We believe that is not desirable. We believe it prevents the people from exercising their democratic right of choosing their own Government and from being able to hold the Government responsible for their actions at the next election.
If Governments are formed in this way, first, the policy, if any, which it is possible to agree on after the election will never have been voted on by the people. Secondly, it will not be possible to hold any of these sections forming such a Government responsible for their actions after the election, because they will all be able to say that things would have been different were it not for their partners in such a Coalition Government. We have had an indication from a former Member of a Government such as this that policy was decided on the basis of day-to-day expediency and that members of the Government were waiting day by day for the opportunity to spring the trap on their colleagues. We have that on the authority of the vice-chairman of the Labour Party, a former coalition Minister. We believe also that a situation of political instability in which it is not possible for anybody to interpret or deduce any coherent policy being operated by the Government, is bound to induce economic recession and the two experiences we have had of Governments formed on this basis indicate that belief is the correct one.
We believe that if it becomes impossible for the people to choose a Government, democracy has failed. The Opposition see, and I think have admitted, that at best this system will produce a situation in which there will be no Party available to the people as a Government but the Fianna Fáil Party and that the only alternative will be a coalition which, at present, would consist, apparently, of only two Parties but we do not know how many it might consist of after the next or subsequent general elections.
The whole approach of the Opposition Parties to this particular Bill has been a pathetic appeal for a continuation of conditions which make the formation of coalition governments after the election a feasible proposition. I agree that the people are fully entitled to choose a coalition government if they like but they should have an opportunity of voting on a coalition government. The people are being cheated if the coalition government is formed after the election. Certainly, if it is formed before the election and the people get an opportunity of voting on it there is no objection. The system we propose will, I think, make it more desirable from the point of view of those who want to form coalitions to do so before the election rather than after the election and so not deprive the people of their democratic right of voting for or against the alternative governments available to them.
In addition, I think it must be clear that political Parties would make a better effort to secure a majority in the circumstances of single-seat constituencies rather than as at present because we all know that where a Party finds itself in the position of having one seat out of three in a three-seat constituency or two out of five in a five-seat constituency, the incentive to search out and put forward the best possible candidate to represent the constituency is not always there or certainly is not always felt to the same degree by every member of the Party in such a constituency. That being so, it must be a matter of some difficulty, and it would certainly be easier, to get a genuine overall effort to obtain a majority in circumstances of single-seat constituencies than under the present system. We would not have the situation in which an obvious potential aspirant for the position of candidate and a person who seems reasonably well-qualified to succeed at a general election would have to be eliminated because the existing Deputies in the constituency would find it necessary to eliminate him from the Party, as we have seen happen in the constituency of Dublin North-East where a person who appeared to be likely to be a very live candidate of Fine Gael and who obviously constituted a threat to the two existing Fine Gael Deputies had to be eliminated from the organisation. I refer to Alderman Finegan who posed a very definite threat to the two Fine Gael Deputies and therefore had to be eliminated.
It had been suggested from these benches that the system of single-seat constituencies would eventually produce a good standard of representative in the Dáil as a whole. That was not intended by anybody who said it as a reflection on the present representatives but it is clear that is circumstances where a Deputy would be isolated in the constituency, he would have to stand on his own feet and would not be able to hide behind the activities of any of his colleagues. In those circumstances, the people of the constituency as a whole, whether they supported his Party or another Party, would be able to see the actual merit of the individual representing them in the Dáil. If such a representative proved to be inadequate, the people, and indeed the Party organisation in the constituency, would inevitably decide to replace him so that the ultimate result—it would not be produced immediately—would be to ensure a comparatively high standard of representative generally.
Also, the people would be more adequately represented. Problems that really require the attention of a Deputy could be more adequately dealt with because the area would be smaller and less complex. The Deputy who got some local problem to deal with would be really able to pursue it, unlike the present position where the constituencies are so large and complex and the demands so overwhelming because of the competition between the Deputies representing the constituency that the result is that no Deputy can really adequately pursue such matters genuinely needing attention.
It is also clear that the single-seat constituency system would be better for public morale in general because the present system encourages the belief, which seems more prevalent here than in a number of other countries, that benefits and services available as a right to the people are obtainable by virtue of the efficacy of the representations made by public representatives. Every Member of the House knows that this is not so, but because of the competition between Deputies in the same constituency, because they are competing for the same votes—sometimes even Deputies of the same Party compete for the same votes—there is this built-in tendency to play up to this belief amongst the people and pretend to, and attempt to take credit for things which are available to the people by provision made in the legislation here.
This produces, to some extent, a belief in the existence of petty corruption in the administration of these schemes which is not founded on fact but it is obviously not practicable for a Deputy in present circumstances who would wish to disabuse his constituents of this belief to do so because it is almost certain that if one Deputy attempted to do this, at least one of his colleagues would decide to do the opposite and such a Deputy would soon find himself an ex-Deputy and, possibly, eventually a Member of the Seanad instead of the Dáil.
There would be more scope for new blood in public life generally. Each Party would have the incentive to put up what they believed to be the best possible candidate in each one of the 144 constituencies. No Party puts up 144 candidates at present, and I do not think the incentive is there to put up the best candidate at all times. However, if such a candidate selected by the constituency proved to be reasonably acceptable to the electorate, no doubt he would be persisted with, but if the candidate did not make much impact with the electorate he would be likely to be replaced by a different candidate the next time. Therefore, there would be more scope for new entrants to public life.
I think the system is completely and absolutely fair, because in each of these 144 constituencies the people would be faced with a choice between individuals, one standing on behalf of each Party, and they would see clearly what they were required to vote on, the merits of the individual candidates and the policies they propounded to them. As well as that, the system we propose has the merit of ensuring that every voter's opinion will be treated in the same way, thus establishing the principle of one man, one vote.
The cost and expense of the proposed referendum has been put forward as a reason against this proposal being put before the people. As I pointed out, a referendum had to be held anyway, and putting this second proposition does not in any way add to the cost; but even if it does, and even if we considered it purely and simply in relation to the cost, the cost involved in conducting the referendum would be very quickly recovered in the reduced cost of by-elections. In the period of this Dáil, for instance, we have already had seven by-elections, and I see some of the papers were assuring us we would have several more before the next general election.
The cost of by-elections at present is very considerable. In fact, when a Royal Commission was set up in the neighbouring island to consider the desirability of introducing into their own elections the system that was invented in Britain for us here, the major argument against that was considered to be the disproportionate effort, expense and turmoil that would be involved in by-elections. These people who sat down to consider the matter objectively apparently considered it completely disproportionate that all the people in a large constituency should be required to vote and that all the necessary arrangements for a large constituency should be made in order to replace a fraction of the representation of the constituency.
It must be obvious that the cost of that to the State and the cost also to political Parties is disproportionate to what is involved. For instance, in the by-elections we have had here we have had to try to induce the people of large constituencies such as County Clare and County Wicklow to go to the polls to replace a fraction of their representation; whereas in the circumstances that we propose the task of the political Parties would be to induce the people in constituencies a fraction of the size of the present constituencies to go to the polls to replace their total representation.
It would be more obvious to the people themselves why it was that they should vote, and certainly the effort involved in convincing the people that they should vote would be less, and be less in a greater proportion than the proportion of the reduced size of the constituency, as compared with the present constituencies. I think both Deputies and Senators would find under the new conditions of single-seat constituencies that there would be less serious demand on their time and energies, on their stamina and possibly on their health in the conduct of by-election campaigns than at present, and possibly less disruption of the proceedings of the Oireachtas itself, because of the fact that the smaller areas to be covered and the more obvious reason for voting would call for less intensive effort and for a smaller number of personnel to conduct the election campaign.
That is in so far as the political parties themselves are concerned, but also from the point of view of expense to the State, the number of polling booths to be operated, the staff to be employed, the demands made on the members of the Garda, and so on for election day, would be considerably less and more closely related to the task to be performed, that is the election of one Deputy. I think it would be true to say that within the lifetime of one Dáil alone the cost of the proposed referendum would be recovered in the reduced cost to the State of by-elections.
Another argument that has been used against this proposal is that it must result in the perpetuation of Fianna Fáil in office. That surely constitutes an admission by the Opposition Parties that it is not conceivable at any time in the future, in the clear confrontation that will exist in these 144 separate constituencies, that either of the Opposition Parties or the two Opposition Parties combined could hope to convince more people in a majority of these constituencies than Fianna Fáil can that their proposals for the conduct of the country's affairs are more meritorious than ours.
That surely means either of two things: either it is a reflection on the ability and the capacity of the people to assess the issues at election time; or else it is a clear admission that their policies are inferior to the Fianna Fáil policy and that despite the existence of the full-time policy-drafting committee of the Fine Gael Party, and despite what appears now to be the almost similar full-time committee of the Labour Party drafting new policies, despite all these efforts, despite the continuous process of trial and error, they see no prospect of success in the foreseeable future.
Comment on this
If that is so, then it appears to me to be an admission that the Fianna Fáil policy is better. If so, why should Fianna Fáil not continue to be the Government? Fine Gael should in this instance take their Leader's advice, take the advice of a man who, despite the Party he leads, still retains some confidence in the possibility that at some time in the future he may succeed in putting sufficient backbone into his Party and instilling into them sufficient devotion to the task of ousting the Fianna Fáil Party from office to gain majority support from the people.
It has been said that we are pretending that the purpose of introducing this proposal is to perform a rescue operation on the Fine Gael Party. I want to go on record as saying that so far as I am concerned I have no desire to perform a rescue operation on the Fine Gael Party at all. If I had, I would not be so foolish as to attempt it because Deputy Cosgrave has failed, and that being so, I would not fancy my chances of succeeding. If the Fine Gael Party want to cut their throats, I would be more inclined to provide them with a whet-stone than anything else. I do not want to revive the Fine Gael Party at all. I think they are beyond redemption.
Comment on this
It is a fact, and even Senator Dooge admitted it is a fact, that if at any time the unlikely event should happen that the people should swing over to the Fine Gael Party—even Senator Dooge, in a moment of aberration possibly, admitted this—the system we are proposing will enable the people more effectively to do that. I do not think they will do it. I am quite confident about this. We have retained the support of the people almost from the moment of the foundation of our Party, and certainly from 1932. We will continue to retain it. I could foretell the future and I do not purport to do so. I am confident that we will retain it, but if we do not, the people will have an effective means of getting rid of us. If our expectations are realised and we retain the support of the people, we will continue to be the Government. My belief that we will continue as the Government is based more on my confidence in the merits of the Fianna Fáil policy, and the perspicacity and intelligence of the people than on what we will call the pseudo-scientific messing around with figures described here by members of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I have dealt in a reasonably comprehensive manner with the system of the single-seat constituencies as opposed to the multi-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
If there is any aspect I have not dealt with and if Senators are kind enough to remind me of it, I will endeavour to remedy that situation. It is quite true that just as we have not always got an overall majority under PR since 1932, we have still almost continuously been the Government. It is also true that we might not always get an overall majority under the straight vote system, and just as we have been able to form a Government without having an overall majority under the present system, it is likely that we will find ourselves in the same position under the straight vote.
Comment on this
No one can give any Party, whether it be the Fianna Fáil Party or the Fine Gael Party, a majority except the people. No one can establish that there is an overall majority in favour of any Party except the people in the ballot boxes.
Comment on this
May I intervene? I should like an opportunity to hear the Minister and I object to irrelevant and stupid interruptions.
Comment on this
If the people say in the ballot boxes that there is not an overall majority in favour of any one Party, then no one can say there is, because the people have said there is not. They have said that on a number of occasions under PR, and no doubt will continue to say it under the system of the straight vote. The fact that there is not an overall majority in favour of any of the number of Parties contesting an election does not mean that the people should be deprived of the opportunity of having a Government. It is possible that there could be future Fianna Fáil Governments, and there may be some people who might even visualise the possibility of a future Fine Gael Government. I cannot. None of the Senators here can, but apparently Deputy Cosgrave can. If the people do not want any Party to have an overall majority it is their privilege not to give an overall majority if they so desire. I do not think the system of election should be rigged so as to prevent the people in those circumstances from having a Government whose policies have been put before them.
Comment on this
I admit that after the people have cast their votes, it is possible to devise any number of systems for taking votes cast for some individuals or Party, and giving them to someone else. That is what the present system does. It is a system of unjustifiable rules, based on blatant discrimination as between some voters and others, for the allocation of votes cast for some candidates to others for whom they were not cast. So I admit that as at present there is the possibility of future Governments under this system not having an overall majority, but no one can remedy that except the people at a general election.
I showed by example in the Dáil that the assumption on which votes are transferred under the present system is an absurd assumption. It is based on the foolish and ridiculous suggestion that a figure put opposite a candidate's name, no matter how high that figure might be, indicates in certain fortuitous circumstances equal support for another candidate with a first preference vote. That is the basic fallacy of the whole system. The transfer of votes is granted only to certain arbitrarily selected sections of the electorate.
Let us consider a constituency in which we have this system of transferring votes—of giving votes which were cast for some candidates to others. In this constituency there are three candidates, our old friends, A, B and C. Candidate A gets 4,000 votes, B gets 3,500 votes and C gets 3,000 votes. This system assumes in a facile fashion that it would be unjust and undemocratic to allocate the seat to the candidate with the biggest number of votes and say he has been elected for the constituency, apparently on the basis that only 4,000 votes were cast in his favour and 6,500 votes were cast not in his favour.
Comment on this
Against him, but 3,500 votes were cast in favour of B and 7,000 against him, and 3,000 in favour of C and 7,500 against him.
Comment on this
If this were done on a non-discriminatory basis, well and good. I propose to show the Senator that if this were done on the basis of one man, one vote, and if the voters for each of the three were treated the same, you could arrive at the absurd conclusion that there was an overall majority in favour of everyone. That would be very nice for every candidate, but it would produce a chaotic result, particularly when there is a limit on the number of people who can sit in the Dáil. You have to find some way of deciding between the three, and we are suggesting that this should be a non-discriminatory way, a way that treats everyone the same, which this system does not.
In the situation which I have put forward with these three candidates, the people whom the Fine Gael Party down through the years have described as theorists and faddists, and in other uncomplimentary terms, say that since candidate C is obviously not favoured by the electorate, and has obviously not been voted as being the candidate chosen by the electorate to represent that constituency, the voters who voted for him should be given another vote, and should be allowed to vote as between candidates A and B. This is done on the ridiculous principle of allocating votes in accordance with wherever the voters put No. 2. It is obvious that the allocation of these 3,000 votes as between candidates A and B could result in the transfer of 1,000 to A and 2,000 to B.
Comment on this
Or vice versa. This would give a so-called result. It would result in giving A 5,000 votes consisting of 4,000 actual votes and 1,000 votes taken from someone else, and in B having 5,500 votes. The proponents of this system say this proves that the majority of the people in this constituency want candidate B to be elected. As a result of this fiddling around with votes after they are cast, the 4,000 who voted for candidate A are obviously in identically the same position as were the 3,000 who voted for candidate C. Their candidate has not been deemed to be elected.
These 4,000 are not identifiable members of the community. They are 4,000 people who have not been submitted to any intelligence test, who have not been psychoanalysed or required to answer questions posed by a computer. There is no knowledge as to who these individuals are. This system decides that while the 3,000 who find themselves in the smallest minority in the constituency should be given a second opportunity as between A and B, the 4,000 should not be given the same consideration, apparently on the principle that by being the majority— in the major group of opinion in the constituency—that indicated that in some way their views were not as important from the point of view of democracy as the smallest minority. Surely the fundamental principle in democracy is that the majority view should prevail.
If we are to discriminate between groups on the basis of the number of their fellow constituents they could get to agree with them, it seems to me that the differential in voting power should be given to the major group rather than the minority. This system decides it should be given to the smallest group. In other words, it decides for no reason that can be advanced, no justifiable reason, that the majority group will be treated as second class citizens. They will be given one vote, and in this case where there are three candidates only the minority will be given two votes. On that basis these people go ahead and say it has been established that 5,500 want B, and 5,000 want A. If every voter were dealt with in the same way, if the principle of one man one vote operated, or one man two votes, whichever you like, those 4,000 people who voted for A are surely entitled to a second opportunity as well as those who voted for C. It is possible that if their second preferences were treated in the same way as those of the favoured minority are treated, their second preferences could go 1,500 to B and 2,500 to C, giving another result of 5,000 votes for B and 5,500 for C. Now we find that this can give us the result of an overall majority in favour of B, and an overall majority in favour of C.
On the other hand, it might be argued that this result is now the correct one because, now, we have established that more people want B than A and we have also established that more people want C than B and, that being so, more people want C than A. But, of course, that has not been established at all because there are three possible combinations of two candidates. If the people are entitled to choose between A and B and between B and C, they are entitled to choose also between A and C. There is nothing to declare that only two candidates can stand for election. All three candidates were entitled to stand and the people chose between the three of them, so far as they were allowed. However, after they were chosen, this system comes along to rig the result of what the people said.
As a result of the more general application of this principle, it has been established now that a majority want B and a majority want C. It may be argued, as I said, that more people want C than B and, if so, then the people who voted for B are in exactly the same position as those who voted for C were in their turn. These are also unidentified members of the community who have not given any reason why their votes should be given less consideration than those of others. They are entitled, in accordance with the principles of democracy, to the same consideration as anybody else. It is possible that if the 3,500 voters who voted for B were treated in the same way—if their views were given the same consideration—1,500 of their votes could go to A and the remainder of their votes to C, giving a result of 5,500 votes in favour of A and 5,000 votes in favour of C.
Therefore if you apply this principle of the transferable vote in a non-discriminatory way, if you apply it in accordance with the concept of democracy that every voter should be treated in the same way, you are liable to get the result that the majority in the constituency want everybody. They might want everybody but the Constitution allows them to have only one. Therefore, there must be some system of choosing between them. We suggest it should be a fair system. We suggest it should be a system that treats every voter in the same way. The Opposition suggest it should be this system which accords special treatment to some people who are selected in a completely arbitrary way. As I said, you get this absurd result because of the fact that the whole thing is based on the absurd assumption that an expression of preference of any degree, however small or however large, indicates the same degree of support for a candidate as a first-preference vote which, of course, it does not.
It is possible that the first result I described might have resulted, if the only two candidates were A and C. It is possible that the second result I described might have resulted if the only two candidates were B and C and it is possible that the third result I described might have resulted if the only two candidates were A and B. However, that did not happen because there were three candidates—A, B and C. They were entitled to stand and the people were entitled to choose between them. This is the only practicable way of doing this and at the same time giving every voter equal treatment.
I understand that Senator O'Kennedy mentioned another system and said that a system could be introduced whereby a notional value would be allocated to preference votes and everybody could be treated in the same way by taking account of all the preference votes and applying the notional value to them, totalling them up and allocating a seat to the person who came out on top.
Comment on this
Nobody is suggesting that: the top person at that time. This was after the system had operated when he would have been taken from the top and put on the bottom not by the people but by the returning officers' staffs. It was the system that eliminated him, not the people. In the immortal words of Deputy Seán Collins "it was not the people but the monster PR which defeated" him. It was the monster of PR that defeated candidate A and for candidate A Senator Rooney can substitute Deputy Seán Collins if he likes because he has had experience of the system operating unfairly against him. As I say, you are likely to get this absurd result. The three candidates are entitled to stand and the people are entitled to choose between them. This system is designed to prevent them doing that. It is based on discrimination and on giving an indefinite number of votes to some people, the total number of votes being decided only on the basis of the number of people who decide to present themselves as candidates and on the degree to which the voter is out of tune with majority opinion and it results in encouraging people to vote for one candidate after another whom the electorate in general look upon as having no merit whatever. It is a bad system, it is discriminatory and completely undemocratic and unjustifiable.
As far as I am concerned it is a secondary consideration compared with the desirability of getting rid of the evils of the multi-member constituency and providing the benefits of single-seat constituencies. This was a theoretical example which I gave, but, of course, it actually arises, and in every election you can show that towards the end of the count in multi-member constituencies, not in all, the candidates eventually deemed to be elected have not been established as the candidates the people wanted to see elected. If the votes were dealt with in an non-discriminatory way, it could easily be shown that the electorate wanted other candidates to be elected as well.
In by-elections also this has been demonstrated time and time again when this ridiculous farce of transferring votes that were cast for one particular candidate to other candidates for whom they were not cast is gone through. We can see the unjustifiability of the results and the discrimination inherent in the system of the transferable vote very well from the results of the recent Wicklow by-election where the Coalition tactics at that time produced a field of six candidates and the operation of the transferable vote. The candidate whom the major portion of the electorate favoured got 9,788 votes, the next highest candidate in the estimation of the electorate got 8,035, the next one got 5,761, the next 2,009, the next 509 and the last 191. As a result of the operation of the system, it was found possible to allocate the votes cast for the four lowest candidates between the two highest candidates and to encompass the defeat of the candidate of whom the majority of the people had declared themselves to be in favour.
Comment on this
The operation of this system in the discriminatory way I have described, of taking into consideration the preference votes of some candidates deemed not to have been elected resulted eventually in the allocation of 51.1 per cent of the final vote to the Fine Gael candidate who got 30 per cent of the poll and an allocation of 48.9 to the Fianna Fáil candidate who got some 37 per cent. This succeeded in changing a majority of 1,700 into a minority of less than 546 and the proponents of this ridiculous system say it was established that the majority of the people were in favour of the Fine Gael candidate.
Comment on this
That was only established on the basis of the discrimination inherent in the system. I would suggest to the Opposition that no reason was given why the 9,788 who found themselves in the largest group of opinion in the constituency should be allocated one vote only while some of the other people who also voted for candidates not deemed to have been elected got 5, 4, 3, or 2 votes. This group because they committed the unpardonable crime of agreeing with more of their fellow constituents than people who voted for other candidates were discriminated against and the system decided that they would get one vote and one only.
If there was any desire to treat all voters equally or even reasonably equally or even an attempt to do so, the very least that would have been done is that after this alleged result had been arrived at, after this transference of votes had been effected and a majority had been converted into a deficit, they would have at least gone back to the situation after the fourth count when the situation was that the Labour candidate had now got 6,797 votes, the Fianna Fáil candidate 10,343, and the Fine Gael candidate 8,728 and the Labour candidate having 1,931 less than the Fine Gael candidate was eliminated and his votes were transferred in accordance with the unjustifiable rules of the system, in accordance with the system of taking an expression of opinion that a candidate was second worst of the six as equivalent to an expression of support to the opinion that that candidate was the best of the six.
We do not know how many number fives were transferred from the Labour candidate to either the Fianna Fáil candidate or the Fine Gael candidate, but probably a substantial number of them. At any rate, some of them would be number fives on papers that were actually votes for the Independent candidate who got 191 people in the constituency to support him. Some of them would be number fives on papers which were actually votes for the Liberal candidate, who got 509 people to support him, and some of them could be number fives on the 2,009 voting papers cast in favour of the Sinn Féin candidate, and some of them could be number fives on the 5,761 that were cast for the Labour candidate. But there was an unknown number of fifth preferences, an unknown number of fourth preferences, an unknown number of third preferences and second preferences all taken into account as actual votes and it was as a result of that, this result was obtained.
Comment on this
Of course. We do not know how many. We do not know how many Fine Gael got, but we know how many votes that were not cast for them were allocated.
Comment on this
How is the executive of Fianna Fáil elected?
Comment on this
It is not. It is not a very intelligent system either actually. Now, as a result of this, the candidate that was selected as the best by the biggest group in the constituency was deemed to be defeated, and I say that there is no reason why the 9,788 people who voted for that candidate and, indeed, the 555 whose votes were given this preferential treatment until such time as they committed the unpardonable crime of actually choosing somebody who was chosen by the majority group in the constituency, when the consideration given their votes stopped dead because of this particular crime against democracy, but there is no reason why they should not also have been given the same consideration, or almost the same consideration, as was given to these other people who supported one unpopular policy after another.
Had that been done, had the 10,343 whose votes were at that time allocated to the Fianna Fáil candidate been given the same consideration as was given to other people who voted for candidates not deemed to be elected, it is quite clear that the deficiency of 1,931 between the Labour vote at that stage and the Fine Gael vote would have been transformed into a substantial majority. Had there been any effort made to treat all voters equally in the Wicklow by-election it would, in fact, have been established that there was an overall majority in the constituency in favour of at least two of the candidates. Of course, that just cannot be but, as I pointed out, you will get this result if you behave in a ridiculous way and base your operations on a ridiculous and unjustifiable assumption.
There is then the other possibility that Senator O'Kennedy suggested of allocating notional values to the votes.
First of all, the notional values to be allocated to the preferences would, of course, have to be arbitrary and there would be no way of deciding exactly what fractional value should be given to different preferences, but it would, at least, ensure equal consideration to every voter. Of course, that would have been against the principles of democracy, according to the Opposition, but in any case such a system would eventually tend to become the straight vote system because the people who really wanted to support a candidate would soon see that, by supporting any other candidate, they would in effect reduce their support for the candidate they really wanted to support.
Comment on this
I will take it on Committee Stage when I have the figures. I happen to have the figures for Limerick. The same thing could apply there. I wonder should I deal with the excursions into the realms of the occult by the eminent professors on television and by the equally eminent professors here on the Front Bench of the Opposition. I think I should not deal with them at any great length. I appreciate that television is a medium of entertainment. I had not the experience of actually seeing this performance on television but I did have the opportunity of witnessing Senator Dooge's performance here and, if those who perform on television are as entertaining as Senator Dooge, it must have been quite an enjoyable experience. Senator Dooge merely gave us results. He did not describe the method by which he worked out those results. I have no doubt his mathematics were unimpeachable, but his assumptions were not. His assumptions were nonsense. They were so naïve as to be just funny. While I have no doubt he carried out the actual operation in accordance with the best mathematical principles unfortunately, like the transferable vote itself, his assumptions were rather silly and so his result is in no way reliable.
Comment on this
I think the Minister should be allowed to sit down. He has been standing now for very nearly eight hours.
Comment on this
I was longer sitting. I had the experience of having to listen as patiently as I could to Senator Sheehy Skeffington, Senator Quinlan and others. Unfortunately I had not the pleasure of listening to Senator Rooney but I have heard him on other occasions. On the last occasion on which I heard Senator Rooney speak, he gave us a very learned dissertation on the relative merits of timber draining boards as opposed to stainless steel draining boards. It was very instructive indeed. Although I did not have the pleasant experience of listening, sitting down, to Senator Rooney on this Bill, I did hear quite a lot and I had to sit through quite a lot. I find it a not unpleasant change to be standing now instead of sitting and to see the Senators, who provided me with so much entertainment in their contributions, now being entertained by me.
Comment on this
The Minister is not entertaining his Front Bench.
Comment on this
Maybe not, but then the Front Bench here also spoke. It seems to me there is an indefinable something in the air now which indicates to me that I have outstayed my welcome and that Senators have possibly imbibed as much they they can. Although there are a number of points raised by Senators opposite which I have not dealt with, the fact that I have dealt with a number of them seems to make them more and more disinclined to have all their other points dealt with and, in view of the fact that an air of good humour has now penetrated the Opposition benches, in contradistinction to the air of acrimony that was present some time ago, maybe I will postpone dealing with the remaining points until they are repeated, as I know they will be, on the subsequent Stages of the Bill.
I will just skip through some other aspects. I will content myself with an incomplete exposition of the case in favour of the proposal we are making and present it instead in a more piecemeal fashion on the subsequent Stages of the Bill. I will skip over the other things. I will just conclude by saying that, in supporting this proposal of ours, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party is clearly in the consistent tradition of his Party, whether under the name of Fine Gael or Cumann na nGaedheal. I think Senator Yeats, if nobody else, has already placed on the records of the Seanad incontrovertible evidence that this is no recent conversion of Deputy Cosgrave or that minority of one in the Fine Gael Party that supports his viewpoint.
Comment on this
This was their consistent attitude right from the time that this State was set up in 1922, up to, as far as anybody knows, 1959. There was never any indication given prior to 1959 that they had changed their view. That was probably because the reason for changing their view had not arisen and did not arise until Fianna Fáil proposed to comply with the demands that Cumann na nGaedheal and Fine Gael had been making over the years and then, of course, this unreasoning suspicion, this dread of anything proposed by Fianna Fáil, came into operation and a small majority of the Fine Gael Party reversed the opinion that had up to then been part and parcel of their policy and decided, in 1959, to oppose this proposition for electoral reform. As I say, this was the first indication of change.
During the time after the long recounts in the last general election, when there were pages of newspaper speculation about the possibility of the people being given another opportunity of getting rid of the present irrational system, during that time, the Fine Gael Party changed their Leader and the new Leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, was interviewed and, for some reason or other, the interviewers thought it was a relevant thing, apparently in view of the state of public opinion at the time, to ask the newly-elected Leader of the Fine Gael Party had his attitude to this proposition changed.
Comment on this
Would it be relevant to discuss Fine Gael on Committee Stage?
Comment on this
He indicated that it had not and that he hoped to bring his Party round to his viewpoint. Everybody knew, of course, that Deputy Cosgrave held this view also in 1959, that he remained faithful to the tradition of his Party and knew that he had not succeeded in carrying that viewpoint at that time, but there was always the possibility, now that the Fine Gael Party had changed their Leader, that he might on this occasion be able to get his Party to do what he said he wanted them to do, that was, to accept the possibility that at some time in the future they might be able to devise a policy or might be able to attract candidates of sufficient merit to their Party to at some time command more support in the country than Fianna Fáil but, as we know, in an all-night session, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party failed by a majority of one to lead his Party.
Comment on this
It is becoming clearer and clearer as day follows day that opinion in the Fine Gael Party is gradually coming around to the opinion of the Leader and it is becoming clearer and clearer that the members of the Fine Gael Party in this House and in the Dáil are beginning to appreciate that the Leader of Fine Gael is going to have his way in spite of the Party he has the misfortune to lead.
Comment on this
That is the mistake Fianna Fáil make. That is the first time I was pleased to see the Minister taking a rest.
Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhforfaidh na focail a tairgeadh a scriosadh."
Rinne an Seanad vótáil: Tá, 28; Níl, 20.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".
Do you agree with this result?
I wish to remind the Leader of the House that we will have another Bill on Tuesday.