We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–221 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

I take it the Minister will set us a good example today with short, pithy speeches and we will get through quickly.

Comment on this

That is not a good start.

Comment on this
Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. K. Boland) Fianna Fáil

I am well aware of the fact that in this House as well as in the other House the Opposition think the way in which debates should be conducted is that they should put their case and that there should be no reply but unfortunately I cannot undertake to comply with that manner of discussion. I can assure the Opposition that as often as they make ridiculous and dishonest charges against the intentions of the Government in proposing this electoral reform those charges will be refuted.

I was dealing with this ridiculous proposition of the Opposition that there should be provision in the Constitution for two separate Commissions and last night I contrasted their present attitude with the attitude adopted in 1959 when the proposition was being put forward in the form of one Bill and the Constituency Commission was included in it, the only fundamental difference being that on that occasion it was to take a two-thirds majority to overrule the decision of the Commission, whereas on this occasion it is to take a simple majority only. In inserting that, it can be shown that we are also complying with the expressed opinion of the Opposition on the last occasion but in 1959 when the complaint could not be made that the Commission would only deal with half of what was being proposed the Opposition attitude was to propose that there should not be a Commission at all. Deputy T. F. O'Higgins and Deputy Costello moved an amendment to that effect. Speaking on the amendment Deputy O'Higgins said at column 946 of Volume 172, of 21st January, 1959:

We think that this Constituency Commission should not be inserted into the Constitution.

He went on to say in the same column:

... we say in this amendment: "Forget about your Constituency Commission. Let any law reviving constituencies be passed here through the Dáil. Let it be supported and defended in the Dáil. Let the Minister who seeks to introduce it take full responsibility for it in this House where he can be challenged in the broad light of day, with the Press looking on and with the public entitled to admission." We say that is the responsible course for any Minister or any Government genuinely intending to do the right thing to adopt.

The present Leader of the Labour Party spoke on the same day at column 980 in support of this proposal to have no Commission to delineate constituencies. Deputy Corish said:

The reason I favour the amendment is not so much because it retains what is embodied in the Constitution at present, but because I believe it will work and there is a certain amount of elasticity about it. At least, it gives the power to the Oireachtas to determine what the constituencies will be, what form they will take and what populations will be represented in each. I do not think the system it is proposed now to enshrine in the Constitution will work. It is crude. As Deputy Declan Costello described it, it is putting the veneer of respectability on these other two proposals. For that reason, I think the House should reject this part of the Schedule and adopt the amendment proposed by the two Fine Gael Deputies, or something reasonably near it.

Now that the Commission is being provided, and provided in the more appropriate of the two Bills into which the proposal has been divided in order to facilitate the Opposition, they want not one Commission but two. I think it must be obvious that when the division into two separate propositions was made, either the Commission would have to be dropped altogether or put into one Bill. The fact is the call for the separation of the proposal into two separate proposals was not a genuine one at all. It was merely meant as part of the Opposition's campaign against the proposal. They were hoping to be able to pretend that if the proposition had been separated, they would have supported the proposals which are now in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

But to their surprise, what was requested was conceded, and these two things were separated. Once this was done, a decision had to be made as to which Bill should have the provision as to the Constituency Commission. Our choice to put it into the Fourth Amendment is because it is there the fundamental change is to be made. As far as we are concerned, we want both Bills passed. Therefore, we want a Commission. As far as the Opposition are concerned, they want no Bill passed and they want no Commission.

Comment on this

We do; we want the Commission, if neither is passed.

Comment on this

All the Opposition want is to oppose what Fianna Fáil are proposing. Senator FitzGerald said that we on this side of the House are prepared to have a Commission in the Fourth Amendment Bill but not prepared to have it in the Third. The contrary is the fact. We want both. We did not want to separate them. We wanted if possible to dispel the confusion in their minds. It has been argued by Senator FitzGerald that if the Third Amendment Bill is passed, there will be a high degree of elasticity in drawing up constituencies. He knows that is not so. He knows that the degree of elasticity will be much less if the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is passed than it will be if it is not passed. This applies whether or not the Fourth Amendment is also passed. In the more likely event of the two Amendments being enacted by the people, that is, the Fourth Amendment being passed also, the requirement will be there to keep within county boundaries as far as possible and that obviously will be more restrictive on the Government, or on the Commission, than if there is no such requirement with regard to county boundaries. In the most likely event of both being passed, there will be less elasticity. In the event of the Fourth Amendment being passed, we will of course have the Commission.

In the more unlikely event of the Third Amendment only being passed, and this is the assumption on which the Opposition base their case, and indeed it is characteristic that they like to base their case on the most farfetched assumptions they can, nothing more will happen than a return to the position that was assumed to obtain here from 1932 to 1959 and the requirement will be there to adhere to county boundaries in so far as it is possible and this will reduce the scope that is available for the revision of constituencies. In fact, that has been conceded when Senator FitzGerald admitted that it was only in the case of Dublin and Cork that there will be really any effective choice available.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I did not admit that and shall refute it in a minute or two.

Comment on this

I hope you will make yourself clear this time. As far as I can remember, that is what the Senator said. It is only within the constituencies of the counties of Dublin and Cork——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Clare, Donegal, Mayo, Galway, Kerry.

Comment on this

—— that there will be much scope for this. However, I dealt with that last night. Senator FitzGerald went on to make the most ridiculous suggestion of all, and I must say I do not know how he relates it to this Bill but he insists on relating it to every section of each Bill and apparently also to every amendment. In view of the fact that this is one of the things I refrained from dealing with in my reply on the Second Stage, I think I will deal with it now when Senator FitzGerald seems to demand that it should be dealt with. Senators know in response to their urgent appeal last Friday night I kept my reply as short as possible——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Terribly short.

Comment on this

I did not encourage Senator FitzGerald to refer to it once again. He made the ridiculous suggestion that under the present system Fianna Fáil are likely to be in a minority after the next election. At least in his attempts to forecast what might happen in the event of the Fourth Amendment Bill being passed— at least there he was dealing with completely new circumstances—there is some excuse for the ridiculous forecast he made. But to suggest that there is any indication that in present circumstances the Fianna Fáil Party will not secure a majority at the next general election is to display his complete and absolute ignorance of practical politics.

We have of course had the clearest possible indication of the virtual certainty of there being a Fianna Fáil Government after the next election. We have had, for one thing, six out of seven by-elections in the lifetime of this Dáil and of course nothing approaching that ever happened before. If Senator FitzGerald would like to contrast that performance with the performance of the Government in either of the two Coalition Governments we had, he will see that out of the three by-elections during the first Coalition Fianna Fáil won one, Fine Gael won one, and Labour won one. In seven by-elections——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this lengthy treatment of by-elections in order?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If it is in order, I take it I will be entitled to reply by-election by by-election.

Comment on this

The Chair thinks that Senator FitzGerald asked a question to which he requires an answer.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am perfectly happy to deal with it either way.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald asked a question to which he did not require an answer.

Comment on this

If the Senator wishes to raise it on the section, it might be as well to dispose of it now.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Then I think it is not in order to go into detail on the amendment. If the Minister wishes to do so now, that is all right but it would appear to me more appropriate to do so on the section. I am happy to do it either way, whichever you think is most appropriate.

Comment on this

I realise this must be a painful subject for the Opposition.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald will be allowed to reply to the matters raised now.

Comment on this

I do not want to delay it, but Senator FitzGerald insists on raising this matter at every possible occasion and the attitude apparently is that there as in everything else the procedure should be that the Opposition should put forward their case and that the Government should not. However, if Senator FitzGerald would like to deal with it later and get some——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Cathaoirleach has stated that we can deal with it now and let us go right ahead.

Comment on this

That is fair enough, so.

Comment on this

That is right. You are repeating it the whole time.

Comment on this

In the first Coalition period, there were three by-elections and the two main sections of the Coalition at the time won one each. That would be two out of three as against one out of three for the Opposition. In the second Coalition period, there were seven by-elections and Fianna Fáil won no less than four of them. So, for the Government to win six out of seven by-elections is obviously a clear indication of continuing support for the Government.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is an indication of a higher parliamentary death rate in Munster.

Comment on this

Now we have it that according to the Opposition the West is our strong area and Munster is our strong area, but the facts are that in the West we happen only to have a majority of one whereas in the Dublin area we have a majority of two.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Under the present system.

Comment on this

So if the West is a strong area for us then the Dublin area is a strong area also, because we have double the majority we have in the West for approximately the same number of seats. Now Munster is our strong area also so apparently it is in part of the province of Ulster that the Opposition did not cede to Great Britain at the time of the Treaty, in those three counties apparently, that the Opposition are strong and possibly strong also in the rest of the province of Leinster.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am sorry to distract the Minister in regard to the by-elections. Let us get on with them in detail.

Comment on this

In whatever degree of detail the Opposition wish. All I want to point out at this stage is—we can go into them in as much detail as required—that despite the maximum possible Coalition effort, despite the fact that there is always a tendency in by-elections, particularly when the Government are not in danger, of every element with any kind of grievance to come out and vote against the Government, we have won six out of seven by-elections and there is a clear indication, if anything, of increasing support for the Government.

Not alone have we had the maximum Coalition effort but we have also had bodies that pretend and represent themselves to be non-political bodies taking an active part against the Government in those six by-elections. In the last three by-elections, in addition to that, we have had this British society, which is described by the Fine Gael Party as being a heavily subsidised one, also campaigning against the Government. Despite that, as I said, we have won six out of seven by-elections, retaining the three seats in the areas where the vacancy was caused by Fianna Fáil Deputies and winning three seats from the Opposition. As I said, we can go into those individually, if necessary, but I think I will wait and see just exactly in what detail the Opposition would like to go into them before doing that. As far as we are concerned, there is nothing we are more happy to consider than those six out of seven wins we have had in the by-elections. If the Opposition also can take some pleasure out of contemplating those six defeats, which they like to look on as moral victories, it is nice to see everybody happy.

As far as we are concerned, we can see the clearest possible proof that Fianna Fáil will definitely be the Government if the present system were by any chance to continue. As to what may happen in the new and clearer circumstances we propose, that is something which is not known yet. However, as I pointed out, it is only legally possible to provide for one Constituency Commission at a time. We have decided to do that in the Bill which will make the more comprehensive change in the matter of constituencies and I am quite satisfied that that was the more appropriate Bill into which to insert the Commission. We are asking the people to pass both those amendments and if the people do that the Constituency Commission will in fact be provided for in the Constitution. This is obviously not a genuine amendment at all.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There are several points I want to deal with, arising out of what has been said by the Minister and Senator Ryan. First of all, there seems to be some confusion in regard to the question of gerrymandering. The position is that where the boundaries of constituencies can be modified by a political decision, a decision by the Minister, there is an opportunity for gerrymandering. Senator Ryan said if I were honest I would admit that this is not possible because nobody knows how people are going to vote. Senator Ryan is being at best rather naïve in this matter. Of course nobody knows how any individual is going to vote; of course there are swings between elections; and of course those swings may at times vary somewhat between one area and another because of local issues or other causes, although the degree of variation from the national swing is relatively small by the standard of other countries, a reflection of the relative homogeneity of our political structure, which extends also, as I pointed out in an earlier speech, to the political geography of the country. The fact is, as anybody who has watched votes being counted knows, there are very wide variations within any constituency, within small areas within it, according to the social composition of the area or its local political tradition or the local popularity of the candidate.

There are very strong variations locally within small areas between different Parties. The percentage of votes a Party may get within a matter of a few hundred yards of an area in a city can vary from below ten per cent to over 70 per cent, depending, particularly in the city and urban areas, on the social character of the areas. In rural areas, the differences are less sudden geographically but can also be very marked and the opportunities for gerrymandering are therefore considerable. It is true of course that at elections there are swings from areas which voted 70 per cent Fine Gael at one election and which might only vote 60 per cent in the next election, or alternatively, might vote 80 per cent for Fine Gael in the next election. Nevertheless, there is a remarkable degree of consistency in the relative Party strengths in the different sub-areas of constituencies.

Anybody who has watched votes being counted knows this. I stood beside the Minister at the Limerick count. I commented to him humorously at the time that whatever about the pre-election organisation, at least we were better organised at counting the votes because we had printed slips on which to record the results from each box as they were checked. The Minister was jotting them down on the back of an envelope in what I thought to be a slightly curious fashion for a Minister with such a reputation for electoral organisation. However, the fact is that both of us were jotting down the results from each box.

Comment on this

I was not responsible for the organisation.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

From each box from each polling station we were noting them. The Minister and myself have records therefore, as anybody has who has watched election counts, of substantial accuracy. One can miss the occasional vote and if you have not enough people doing this, watching the votes being checked, you may miss a few boxes, but assuming you have enough people there, you can get with almost complete accuracy the result of the votes cast in each box at each polling station, units which in rural areas consist very often of a couple of hundred votes and in urban areas of four or five hundred, possibly something of that order of magnitude. So, for those very small areas each Party has almost an exact record of the voting of those areas. The voting composition can vary very widely. As I have said, looking at the Limerick votes being cast, there were areas there where one Party might have less than ten per cent of the votes and other areas where the same Party could have 70 per cent of the votes and the two boxes might have been counted after each other and the two areas might have been within a few hundred yards of each other.

First of all, the Parties know how the votes are cast; secondly the variation in votes as between contiguous areas can be very marked; thirdly, there is remarkable stability in the patterns in that despite the fact that there are general swings backward and forward, the same consistency of voting is there for one Party or another. Those are the facts. The Minister knows them as well as I do. Senator Ryan, who has also been present at counts, knows them as well as I do.

Comment on this

I was talking about Dublin.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In fact the counts Senator Ryan has been present at have very often been in Dublin. In Dublin the same situation applies in regard to checking the votes, so much so, that I recall at the Presidential election, visiting the various rooms where the votes were being counted while the votes were being checked. On the basis of what the speakers of all Parties told me—because one listens to the views of the different Parties on this in case there might be a bias of optimism in one's own Party—I was able to ring the Leader of my Party at 12 o'clock, two and a half hours before the count ended, and tell him the approximate results in Dublin—a 30 per cent majority in Dublin for O'Higgins and 40 per cent in the city and county— 28,000 and 42,000.

Comment on this
A Senator

You seemed to know in Limerick that you were going to be eliminated before the Labour candidate.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In Limerick, the result was very close. When I was talking to the Minister in the morning before half past ten I detected a certain air of gloom. He was by no means certain that they were going to win. That was at 10.30.

Comment on this

Come to the problem of constituencies.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am just establishing the feasibility of gerrymandering, given that the Minister has power to determine the boundaries of constituencies.

Comment on this

In Dublin, most of the votes——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is not the case. I am sorry I have not here a complete record in Dublin but I can bring in a stencilled record for Dublin South-East.

Comment on this

The Senator must never have seen a count in Dublin.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have a stencilled record for Dublin South-East table by table.

Comment on this

These details will not be in order.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am sorry. I am trying to establish the veracity of my statement that the information is available upon which to gerrymander. Let there be no doubt about that. I can produce stencilled records for Dublin, Waterford, Dublin South-East, table by table. Given that that is the situation, the question arises, in how many constituencies under the Minister's scheme will it be possible for the Minister to very boundaries in the event of the Third Amendment being passed and the Fourth Amendment not being passed, which is the situation we contemplate on this issue?

The number of constituencies in which the Minister can determine boundaries represents almost two-thirds of the total. There are, in fact, 90 seats in these constituencies— Dublin, Cork and the six constituencies that are divided in two and where the boundaries within Limerick, Tipperary, Mayo and so on can be varied in order to take in or exclude particular pockets of voters who may be known through the process of watching the checking of votes to favour one side or the other. There are 90 constituencies, therefore, under the Minister's scheme, in which gerrymandering will be feasible. In adition, some room for manoeuvre remains in other cases. The Minister, no doubt, will examine carefully the pattern of voting in Carlow, Kilkenny and Kildare in order to decide whether Carlow is best attached to Kilkenny or Kildare in order to produce the optimum result for his Party. While maintaining the integrity of county boundaries but by linking them together in one or other way, the Minister will be able to take a political decision under this scheme in respect of these counties and there may be others. Even if there are no others, constituencies involving 98 seats will have room for political manoeuvre by a political Minister in determining the pattern of constituencies under the scheme. All this talk about gerrymandering not being possible is nonsense. It is possible in at least 98 out of 144 cases. I hope I have now dealt adequately with that point.

Comment on this

Have you convinced even yourself?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The next point I want to deal with is the by-election results which the Minister has again challenged. By-elections occurred in seven constituencies in which at the last election Fianna Fáil secured about 52½ per cent of the Party votes. In the last election they secured in the country as a whole 49 per cent of the Party votes. These constituencies are, therefore, constituencies biased in Fianna Fáil's favour above the national average of 7 per cent, 52½ per cent being 7 per cent more than 49 per cent. I give all these figures in case the Minister would wish to intervene with a correction.

Comment on this

I take it I can deal with them now in all this detail?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is what you want to do. In these constituencies, inevitably, the results of the by-elections will tend to favour the Party which in the last general election secured more votes there than it did in the country as a whole.

In speaking on the Second Stage, I detailed the results and will just confirm them now in case there may be any doubt as to the position. A swing against Fianna Fáil occurred in all these constituencies. The first batch is Waterford and South Kerry. In the Waterford by-election, the percentage of votes secured by Fianna Fáil was 42.6 as against 48.1 in 1965. In South Kerry, the percentage of votes secured was 44.6 and this must be compared with the second count in South Kerry in 1965, the count after the elimination of the Independent candidate—just to make a fair comparison; it would not be fair to Fianna Fáil to reduce its share as would happen if you included the Independent votes. This gives a drop from 45.9 to 44.6. Taking the two constituencies in these by-elections, Fianna Fáil's share of the Party vote fell from 47.0 to 44.2. If the Minister wishes to challenge this, I have the actual figures. That is a swing of 6 per cent because 44.2 is 6 per cent less than 47.0. The next result was in West Limerick and Cork where Fianna Fáil in the general election in both constituences got 54½ per cent. So much above the national average were they of the Party votes——

Comment on this

Of which Parties?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Of the three main Parties. Let me take constituency by constituency. I do not wish in any way to mislead the House as to the basis of the figures. There were, in fact, no other candidates in either election, if I can read my notes correctly. Therefore, the comparison is between the Parties. In West-Limerick, of the total and Party vote, Fianna Fáil secured 54.5 per cent in 1965; 53.9 in the by-election. In Cork there is a problem in making any comparison because in the general election there were a multiplicity of Independents but unfortunately they were not eliminated until some Party candidates were eliminated and it is not possible, therefore, in the case of Cork to make a valid comparison for any count after the elimination of the last Independent candidate because at that stage some of the Party candidates had disappeared down the drain. The only fair comparison is one between the total Party votes in both elections, excluding Independents. That comparison shows a drop from 54.3 per cent of the Party vote to 47.7 per cent—a drop of 12 per cent and a drop of 7½ per cent taking the two constituencies together. The fall, therefore, in that instance, was a drop of 7½ per cent in Fianna Fáil's share of the Party vote.

Next I come to Clare and Wicklow. In Clare, Fianna Fáil secured in the general election 58.7 per cent and in the by-election 51.0 per cent—a drop of 13 per cent in the Party vote. In Wicklow, in the general election they secured 48.0 per cent of the Party vote. In the by-election, at the stage when Independents and other smaller Parties were eliminated and the three big Parties remained, which is the valid comparison with 1965, they secured 40.0 per cent, a drop of 16½ per cent and a drop of 15 per cent in Clare and Wicklow together. In Clare and Wicklow the decline in Fianna Fáil's share is 15 per cent—note the pattern —six per cent in the first batch; 7½ per cent in the second and 15 per cent in the third.

In East-Limerick in the general election, Fianna Fáil secured 53.5 per cent of the total and Party vote—sorry, of the Party vote. In the by-election, after the elimination of the Independent, they secured 44.4 per cent of the Party vote, a drop of 17 per cent in their share of the Party vote in that instance.

These are the most valid comparisons one can make, in each case selecting the comparison fair to Fianna Fáil. I could easily take first preference votes and show a different picture because in the by-elections where there were more Independents and where Fianna Fáil's share of first preferences was artificially depressed by the presence of Independents. Not until they were eliminated can one see the strength of Fianna Fáil relative to the other Parties. Not wishing to make any unfair comparisons, I take in each of these the comparison of the Party votes, having eliminated the Independents in the most appropriate manner. The position is clear. There has been a cumulative decline in the Fianna Fáil share of the vote—six per cent in the first batch, seven and a half per cent in the second, 15 per cent in the third and 17 per cent in the fourth. As a result of that disastrous trend for Fianna Fáil, combined with the swing in the local elections, which reduced their share of the Party vote from 49 per cent to 45½ per cent in comparison with the general election of 1965, Fianna Fáil decided to introduce these two Bills. These are the only figures available in the absence of public opinion polls.

There is one further point I want to make. The Chair will be glad to hear that it relates directly to the Commission. As we know, a Committee sat and considered these issues. I would like to read what it said.

Comment on this

Whatever about the Minister being capable of gerrymandering constituencies, the Senator is certainly capable of gerrymandering figures.

Comment on this

Will Senator O'Reilly please allow Senator FitzGerald to make his speech without interruption? Senator O'Reilly will be afforded facilities later to speak.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It was a good-humoured interruption and I have no objection to it.

Comment on this

The Chair has objection to it. The debate must proceed in an orderly manner.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

This is what the Committee has to say on the subject of the Commission. I address my remarks particularly to Senator Ryan and to Senator O'Kennedy, whose comments on this I would be glad to hear. I note that on occasions the Committee recorded the views of one side or another, and this has sometimes been abused by misrepresenting such views as the views of the Committee. On certain occasions views were expressed one-sidedly, but there were other times when the Committee reached unanimity and expressed a unanimous view. A unanimous view means that all the Committee support, adopt and press that view. I am concerned about a certain difference between the unanimous views of the Committee, of which both Senator Ryan and Senator O'Kennedy were members, and the views they appear to be pressing on us in this House at the moment and which Senator Ryan has, in fact, raised in the House already. First of all, there was a view expressed which was not the view of the entire Committee but the view of only part of the Committee.

Comment on this

What page?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Page 21, paragraph 57. I quote:

Certain members felt that, even under the existing system, it was desirable to establish a Commission to determine the delimitation of the Constituencies.

We are not told which members felt this and whether they had any Party allegiance. One can, of course, make one's guess, but we have no information. The only occasions on which we knew what people voted and how they voted was when the Committee was unanimous, and that is what the next sentence says:

Though this view was not acceptable to all members, the Committee were unanimous that, in the event of any constitutional change, a Commission should be established to determine the delimitation of the constituencies.

Comment on this

And so it is.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yet this House has before it two amendments to the Constitution, either of which can be passed or rejected. We all recall 1959 when two proposals were put to the electorate, one of which they accepted—the election to the Presidency of Mr. de Valera—and one of which, this proposal, they rejected. Again, two amendments to the Constitution are being put, either of which can be passed or rejected. If one of them—the Third Amendment—is accepted and the other—the Fourth Amendment— is rejected, which is certainly a possibility and which most people would feel is the more likely of the two things to happen, if that happens, we shall have a constitutional change which does not incorporate a Commission, despite the fact that Senator Ryan and Senator O'Kennedy are on record as saying that no such thing should be allowed to happen. I would invite them to join us in the Division Lobbies on this vote.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald claims that he and his Party know how people vote in all areas in the country. I suppose it is probably because they think they have this information—and not only the information as to how they have voted but how they will vote— that they continue to do so badly. As far as we are concerned, we can only make a rough and very tentative assessment as to how the people are likely to vote after a thorough canvass, not before it. We believe that before attempting any forecast as to how people will vote, it is necessary to assess, in so far as it is possible to assess it, how the people are feeling. We would not attempt to insult the people's intelligence by assessing how they are going to vote without first asking them. It is because we have so much more respect for the intelligence of the people that they continue to give us their support.

Senator FitzGerald insisted on giving us his fanciful opinion as to the by-elections in general and individually. I suppose it would be a charitable thing to allow Senator FitzGerald to continue to live in his fool's paradise. But I must say I do not think anybody, even somebody as naïve as Senator FitzGerald, could really believe what he pretends to believe. Of course, there is not any one of the seven constituencies in which there have been by-elections in which it has not been clearly indicated that at worst, as far as we are concerned, there is no change but, generally speaking, that there is an increase in the support for the Government. Since Senator FitzGerald purported to go through them in detail, I will do the same. Let us, first of all, take Waterford and South Kerry, where Senator FitzGerald claims there was an indication of a swing against Fianna Fáil.

One thing I notice about Senator FitzGerald is that he is able to change from considerations based on the operation of the present ridiculous and discriminatory vote to assumptions based on the straight vote system. The fact is that all these by-elections were contested on the discriminatory system of the transferable vote and that in all of them we had a coalition line-up. Despite that, there is no indication in any single one of these constituencies of any change for the worse in the support for Fianna Fáil.

If we take the first two by-elections we had in Waterford and South Kerry, where Fine Gael had the first of their long series of glorious moral victories, in the South Kerry constituency in the general election of 1965 Fianna Fáil barely succeeded in getting two seats out of three. The by-election clearly indicated no change. It clearly indicated that two seats out of the three will be secured by Fianna Fáil again in the next election. The by-election was contested on the system of the transferable vote. Under that system it is quite clear that to gain two seats out of three demonstrates equivalent support as the gaining of a seat in a by-election. Exactly the same amount of support in the constituency is required for each of these things on the basis of the transferable vote. It is quite clear we have every reason to be thoroughly satisfied with the result in South Kerry.

In regard to the Waterford by-election, which was conducted on the same day, Fianna Fáil improved their position substantially because in the general election of 1965 they had succeeded in gaining only one seat out of three. Any Party able to gain only one seat out of three in a general election cannot have any significant hopes of winning the seat in a by-election, particularly when the vacancy is caused by the death of one of the Opposition Deputies. In Waterford, however, Fianna Fáil significantly improved their position because in the circumstances of a Coalition line-up and the transferable vote, we won the seat against all indications because we had only got one seat out of three at the general election and winning a by-election indicates that at the next general election, if the people continue to vote as they did in the by-election, Fianna Fáil will win a seat.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The new psephology.

Comment on this

Apart from that, these two by-elections could not have taken place at a more suitable time for the Opposition, a time when the country was still affected by adverse economic circumstances existing in many countries and naturally affecting us. They took place at a time when it was necessary to cut down on the State's capital programme, when we had credit restrictions and so on and a time when it was possible for the Opposition to endeavour to cash in on the situation that arose because of rivalry between the two major farm organisations in the country. In fact, in those two by-elections the Opposition had actively campaigning for them, picketing polling stations and so on, a major farm organisation, the NFA, putting their own posters there in addition to the Opposition posters outside polling booths advising people to vote against the Government and also putting personnel outside the polling stations. Also, as Senator FitzGerald knows, in addition to the assistance of other sections of the Coalition, the Labour Party and the NFA, they also had the active participation on their side of the anti-language organisation.

Comment on this

The NFA never campaigned——

Comment on this

Despite the adverse economic circumstances, despite the fact of the two allegedly non-political organisations, the NFA and the anti-language movement, campaigning on their side, the result of those two by-elections was increased support for Fianna Fáil in Waterford, a clear indication that if this had been a general election, we would have increased our representation there by gaining two seats out of the three——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

An 11½ per cent drop in the vote.

Comment on this

——and there was an indication in South Kerry that at the next general election we would again retain our two seats out of three. These were the most satisfactory results conceivable for a Fianna Fáil Government. At that time we could have got no more favourable indication and no greater boost to our morale. We had Fine Gael consoling themselves with what they described as moral victories. If they can derive any consolation from this type of situation, they are welcome to it. These two by-elections were followed by by-elections in Cork and West Limerick, where again we had two outstanding victories for the Government. In both constituencies, the Coalition tactics were the same, a man from each section of the Coalition, an effort to ensure that the maximum possible vote would be pulled out in this way and transferred from one to another. I suppose the farming organisation had not so much effect in Cork city but the anti-language organisation which, of course, is a wing of the Fine Gael Party—although I see the Labour Party are now making a bid for their support——

Comment on this

That is an outrageous statement by the Minister and he knows it to be false.

Comment on this

Let the Labour Party defend themselves.

Comment on this

I am talking about your statement which you know to be false.

Comment on this

This organisation made an even more virulent campaign in these two by-elections on behalf of Fine Gael——

Comment on this

Another Fianna Fáil lie.

Comment on this

——but again without any success. What Fianna Fáil achieved in the Cork by-election was to get four seats out of five. It was a Coalition vacancy. Fianna Fáil already had three seats out of the five, the Taoiseach, the then Lord Mayor of Cork and Deputy Healy. The task of the Fianna Fáil workers in Cork was to convince the electorate that in a situation where Fianna Fáil already had three Deputies out of the five, there was some reason why the people should go out and support a fourth Fianna Fáil Deputy. We succeeded outstandingly in getting the people to do that. The result, I suppose, was looked upon as a foregone conclusion but the people came out and decided to give Fianna Fáil four out of the five seats in Cork, despite an all-out effort by the Coalition.

The most amazing thing is that the Fine Gael Party actually have the effrontery to pretend that they can gain some consolation from a result such as the West Limerick by-election. If they can do that, there is no hope for them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is where we gained at the expense of Labour as well as Fianna Fáil. It does not always happen.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Senator is talking about but if he can boost his own morale in this way, well and good. West Limerick, of course, was looked upon as a foregone conclusion and proved in fact to be a foregone conclusion. The Fianna Fáil candidate was returned with a substantial majority, indicating that there is certainly no change in that constituency.

Comment on this

West Limerick was obviously a case where we had a Fine Gael victory at the expense of both other Parties.

Comment on this

It is time that we came back to the Bill.

Comment on this

I think that Senator FitzGerald——

Comment on this

The House will agree that the Chair is being rather generous in allowing such wide scope to the debate.

Comment on this

I certainly agree with that, and you will notice I refrained from dealing individually with the by-elections until Senator FitzGerald insisted on doing so.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I suggested it should be dealt with on the Schedule.

Comment on this

I must agree with your ruling that it is not relevant, but I should certainly like to be allowed at least to deal with the constituency of County Wicklow. I admit Senator FitzGerald not unnaturally slid over Clare.

Comment on this

The Chair is not ruling the Minister as being irrelevant on the matter, but the Chair would like the debate to come a little closer to the matter of the amendment and particularly subsection (5) of the amendment. It is in the light of that subsection that the Chair has allowed the debate to become as wide as it has become.

Comment on this

I admit I would not be able to relate this to the amendment, and I do not think Senator FitzGerald did either. However, I have succeeded, through your indulgence, in dealing with four by-elections, and perhaps I may manage to deal with the other three later when I find the Chair in a particularly indulgent mood again.

Comment on this

The Chair understands that this debate is taking place on the Schedule as well as the amendment, which would preclude its taking place again on the Schedule.

Comment on this

In regard to the Commission I can understand why Senator FitzGerald should be trying to find some inconsistency on the part of some Fianna Fáil Senators having regard to the glaring inconsistencies we have heard from the members of Fine Gael, who were dead against a Commission when this was last discussed and who now want a Commission. I am not inconsistent in this regard. I was in favour of a Commission when this was discussed at the Committee on the Constitution, and I am in favour of a Commission now. A Commission has been provided under the terms of the Fourth Amendment and that Commission would have been included in both amendments if both amendments had been taken in the same Bill. However, one of the tactics that was introduced into this campaign by the Opposition Parties in an attempt to prevent these proposals going before the people was to say that both of these proposals should not be taken in the same Bill. As the Commission could not be put in both Bills—the Minister has legal advice that it cannot be put in both Bills—there was no alternative but to put it in one or other, and I fully support the view that it was more consistent and more logical to put the Commission in the second Bill than in this one.

Consequently, I do not regard myself as being in any way inconsistent in relation to the Commission. I am for a Commission, and when both of these amendments have been passed by the people, there will be a Commission to deal with the setting up of the new constituencies.

Comment on this

I should like to try to bring this debate back upon some kind of orderly lines and to bring it to a quick conclusion. It is quite clear that the Minister has not the slightest intention of having a debate here on this measure which would be in any way relevant. He has got an obsessional preoccupation with Fianna Fáil. That is his whole life, and all that he has said here this morning and all that he said last night was about how well Fianna Fáil had done, were doing and would do.

In any kind of legislation one must have regard for contingencies and possibilities, and if the Minister has, as he pretends to have, all the respect he says he has for the wisdom of the people, then he will not presuppose that the people are going to do one thing rather than another. If he respects the wishes of the people, then the proper thing for him to do is so to frame each Bill that, if only one Bill is accepted, it will stand on its own feet and have in it all that is necessary to meet his wishes, as alleged, the views of the committee of both Houses that sat on the Constitution, and also the needs of the situation. That is not what the Minister wants to do, and Senator Ryan says it cannot be done. That is exactly the attitude that one always gets either from civil servants or from Ministers of State when they do not want to do something. They say it cannot be done; it would not be legal. Anything that the people of Ireland decide to do in a constitution amendment becomes the law and becomes legal. That is a simple fact that the Party across there cannot get into their heads. This is a sovereign people and if they decide in their Constitution to put ten Commissions in ten articles, that is the law because the people of Ireland wish it so.

Comment on this

It is dictatorship, according to some people.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

The Labour Party, particularly.

Comment on this

There was an amendment down to that effect which your Party supported.

Comment on this

That is going to another matter.

Comment on this

What the people decide is democracy.

Comment on this

Yes, and if the people decide to accept both of these Bills that becomes the law and that will be part of the Constitution. What we do object to is the attempt by the Government in power to hoodwink the people into thinking that what they propose is a good measure and suitable to the needs of this country. That is the way dictators work, secretly.

Comment on this

You would not expect us to propose something we did not think was a good measure.

Comment on this

I oftentimes wonder whether you are as stupid as you pretend to be in the measures you propose.

Comment on this

Your courtesy is very warming.

Comment on this

I would ask the Senator to address the Chair.

Comment on this

If we are all nice and polite, stand up and make our speeches, sit down and then have divisions, and we go on like that year after year, then what do Fianna Fáil say? They say the Opposition are not anxious for power, and if you are trenchant and you expose the Fianna Fáil people, then you are impolite.

Comment on this

You can be trenchant without being insulting.

Comment on this

I find it very difficult not to put a label on something that I see requires a label. I want to call attention to the fact that Article 6 of the Constitution of 1937 says in relation to the people of Ireland:

1. All powers of government, legislative, executive and judicial, derive, under God, from the people, whose right it is to designate the rulers of the State and, in final appeal, to decide all questions of national policy, according to the requirements of the common good.

We are told in Article 1:

The Irish nation hereby affirms its inalienable, indefeasible, and sovereign right to choose its own form of Government, to determine its relations with other nations, and to develop its life, political, economic and cultural, in accordance with its own genius and traditions.

Comment on this

There are only about 46 more Articles. The Senator might as well go through them all.

Comment on this

What I want to point out is that we are a sovereign people and that if we want to put two Commissions into Articles, we can do so if we think it is necessary and that it suits the situation. In the 1937 Constitution we adopted the device of putting in 13 Articles, Article 51 to 63, as transitory provisions. Then we provide in Article 52:

This Article and the subsequent Articles shall be omitted from the Constitution after the date on which the first President shall have entered upon his Office.

In 1968 we find the Constitution is down to Article 50. The Minister says that is the reason for not putting a Commission in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Of course it is a spurious and false assertion that it cannot be done. It can be done, and it has been done already. Therefore the amendment which we suggest is entirely feasible. We put the amendment down in this way to get the view of the Government upon it and to avoid controversy so far as possible. We used the words contained in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. We concede that there are certain defects in it. We have not incorporated the transition provision and further matters that have been attended to. In these circumstances it is well worthwhile considering putting the provision in both Bills rather than in one Bill. The Government have conceded that it was right to have two Bills rather than one, and they might now concede that it is right to have a Commission in both Bills. Accordingly, with the leave of the House, I will withdraw the amendment, redraft it and put it down again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I claim the right to reply to Senator O'Quigley's further allegations.

Comment on this

The Minister is in order.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley alleges that I do not want to be relevant in this debate. I admit that I have had to deal with matters which were not relevant to the debate but I am quite satisfied that the record will show that all the irrelevant matters to which I have had to refer were introduced in the first place by members of the Opposition. I agree that there were quite a number of these and, in fact, I would say there were considerably more than there were in the Dáil.

Senator O'Quigley says provision for a Commission should be put in each Bill. The fact of the matter is, as Senator O'Quigley knows as well as I do, that this cannot be done. It would be ridiculous to have a provision for two separate Commissions in the Constitution. As Senator Yeats pointed out, the people could reject a Commission in one Bill and accept it in another. The difficulty would be to interpret whether they had decided for or against a Commission. The only way in which what Senator O'Quigley pretends to want could in fact be done, would be to have two completely separate referenda; in other words, to adopt the procedure of coming to the House, first of all, with the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, bringing it through the Dáil and through the Seanad and holding a referendum on it, and that having been done, to bring the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill through the Dáil and the Seanad with or without provision for a Commission, depending on the result of the first referendum on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, to conduct the separate operation of bringing the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill through the two Houses and the separate operation of having a referendum on it.

As Senator O'Quigley says, we complied with the Opposition's demand for two separate questions. It is only now becoming apparent that what the Opposition wanted was that we should have two separate referenda at two different times. I appreciate the fact that their main desire and hope is to try to delay this matter for so long that it will be too near the next general election to actually implement it before then. I agree that if the procedure I have outlined were adopted, this would be quite likely to be one of the results. Apart from that, if the Opposition are really advocating this procedure, the question of the added cost which has been represented as being vital would be another thing that would arise.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

How?

Comment on this

As Senator O'Quigley and every member of the Opposition knows, this proposal for the Commission had to be put into one Bill or the other when the proposal was subdivided into two separate proposals. This was done at the request of the Opposition. Senator O'Quigley describes this as conceding that it was right to have two Bills rather than one. There is no such concession at all. We merely did it because, on this occasion, unlike 1959, the Opposition were so confused they could not understand it. They said they would be confused and that their voters would be confused. In order to try to do the impossible, in order to try to dispel the confusion in the mind of the Opposition, we agreed to separate a simple proposal for electoral reform into two separate proposals.

Comment on this

What about the press?

Comment on this

The present proposal does not differ significantly from the proposal that was put to the people as one question in 1959. The only difference was that, in 1959, there was no actual limit specified to the amount of consideration that could be given to such practical considerations as the desirability of respecting county boundaries and taking account of the area, extent and accessibility of constituencies. That was the only difference.

In 1959, the Opposition were able to understand these two proposals. They assumed that the people would be able to understand them all together. However, the calibre of the Opposition had apparently so deteriorated between 1959 and 1968 that, on this occasion, they were utterly confused. In order to try to dispel the confusion, if possible, in the Opposition's mind, we acceded to their request and introduced two separate Bills and put the people to the unnecessary complication of having to deal with two separate ballot papers. That was purely and simply to try to make the Opposition happy.

Comment on this

Stop acting the hypocrite.

Comment on this

That, inevitably, involved making a decision as to which of these Bills should contain the——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

There was no tolerance provision in it.

Comment on this

The 1959 referendum proposal contained a specific provision authorising the commission to take account of such relevant factors as county boundaries and the extent and accessibility of constituencies even though, at that time, the actual need for this had not arisen because the High Court action had not yet been taken by Fine Gael. At the same time, the 1959 proposal clarified the position by making it clear that the commission was entitled to take these things into consideration. Subsequent to that, the Fine Gael action in the High Court established that, under the present Constitution, these things could not be taken into consideration. Obviously, then, what I say is right.

Comment on this

The High Court did not decide that: wrong again.

Comment on this

Acceding to the Opposition's request or demand, or whatever you like to call it, to try to clarify this terribly complicated proposal for them inevitably involved a decision to put the commission into one Bill or the other. We decided to put it into the one which will involve the more fundamental change in the scheme of constituencies: that must be conceded. The Opposition did not ask for three separate proposals. If they had done so, we might have conceded that, too. We should like to give them every opportunity to be happy.

Comment on this

We are getting tired of that. Do not be a hypocrite.

Comment on this

If we agreed to three separate Bills, and to three differently-coloured ballot papers for the people, then the Opposition might ask for a fourth Bill. They object only for the sake of objecting. They would probably want four, then. Short of having a third ballot, this was the best possible arrangement that could be made and the Opposition know it.

Comment on this

The Minister claims that, in providing these Bills, he was acceding to the request or the demands of the Opposition. He was doing no such thing. He was acceding to the unanimous demand made by the newspapers—by the Irish Independent, by the Irish Times and by the Cork Examiner. They sprang to action when the grotesque package proposal was proposed on Telefís Éireann by Deputy Lenihan, the Minister for Education. I never saw such a spontaneous and proper outburst of indignation as greeted that package proposal. The Government immediately drew in their horns and, within three weeks, there was an announcement from the Taoiseach that this was not being implemented.

Comment on this

How did you measure the demand?

Comment on this

The solution to the question of a Commission, which is essential and which is recommended, is that there should be a third Bill to provide this, a Bill that would have the backing of all Parties: indeed it could be put in a white voting paper to signify that it was non-controversial. If the Minister was serious in trying to facilitate the public and in trying to put the issues as clearly as possible to the people, in a way they could understand, obviously the constituency Commission should be in a separate Bill altogether.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister forgot the main factor of the success in the Kerry and Waterford by-elections, of which we all in Cork are proud—the fact that Fianna Fáil have got a new Leader. It was a spontaneous outburst of approval in those neighbouring counties that a Corkman had at last taken the helm and they were happy to give him a good send off. However, the public are now strongly critical of his subsequent performance. Unless the Taoiseach can show that he is able to restrain some of his vociferous Ministers then Cork, Kerry and Waterford may take a different view in the next election. That was the main factor. It was surprising to find the Minister giving all sorts of trivia, including the activities of the anti-language organisation.

Comment on this

Anti-language wing of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

Another Fianna Fáil lie.

Comment on this

——which was just a headache for all Parties concerned and has just a nuisance value and no more. He concealed the main factor——

Comment on this

Wait until the Taoiseach is a candidate.

Comment on this

The National Farmers' Association behaved very properly as a vocational group. They advised their members that they had their own allegiances. The organisation did not tell them what to do or how to vote, despite the controversy going on at the time. It is wrong and a grave falsehood for the Minister to suggest that the NFA took part in these campaigns. The one time they were forced into political action was in the recent elections of the Beet Growers' Association—and that was not of their own choosing. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries intervened in the most blatant manner in those elections. The NFA then stood firm and stood behind those proposals. The results were reflected in the fact that they won 58 out of 60 seats. The Minister might be thankful they continued to behave as a vocational group rather than to show the same determination behind a political Party: I do not think it would be right for them to do that. They should at all times judge political Parties by the way they behave towards vocational groups and farming organisations in particular. If they maintain that standard, unless there is that change of attitude in the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, then obviously, in the next election, acting as a vocational group, they will not be helpful to the Government Party.

Comment on this

I might have realised Senator O'Quigley did not mean what he said when he said he wanted to get this dealt with quickly.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He wanted to withdraw. The Minister has insisted on intervening twice now.

Comment on this

However, Senator Quinlan, the rugged Independent, has demonstrated on Senator O'Quigley's behalf that he is ready to continue delaying——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is wrong.

Comment on this

I am entitled to reply to it, too. The Opposition would like to have the debate continued in a different way.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Quicker: get to the country quicker.

Comment on this

Senator Quinlan maintains that we were not acceding to the request of the Opposition but to the request of the Opposition papers. That is the same thing. The Opposition pull the strings and the papers do what they are told.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that about the Irish Press, also?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to be sure the press have that on record. Would the Minister repeat what he said?

Comment on this

The Opposition have to have their way of making a request. This request was made by the Opposition and, in order to keep the Opposition reasonably happy, and particularly in view of the fact that they indicated they intended to support the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, we gave them that opportunity. But, having been given the opportunity, of course they changed their mind because to support it would be agreeing with Fianna Fáil and this is a capital sin in the eyes of the Opposition.

On this question of a package proposal which the rugged Independent from Cork has now resurrected, I have pointed out that, in substance, the proposal was the same as the proposal in 1959, the only difference being that, on this occasion, we proposed a definite limit to the divergence that could be operated in order to take account of the same considerations that were included in the 1959 Bill. It is becoming clearer that the only purpose in all this operation is to delay. Now, on the Committee Stage in the Seanad, the suggestion is made that we should have three Bills instead of two. That suggestion has not been made before now. As I pointed out, we might have considered that when we did decide to give two Bills instead of one, which was all that was necessary. If the Opposition had said: "We want three Bills"——

Comment on this

If you are defeated this time, you can have it the next time.

Comment on this

The Opposition want to start the whole process over again by having three Bills. They appreciate that public opinion in general and, in particular, opinion within the Fine Gael Party is now, day by day, coming round to the view of the Leader of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

The Minister is an innocent man.

Comment on this

Therefore, the only thing they can hope for is that they will succeed in delaying this proposition from going before the people until it is too near the general election. The Chair allowed me to deal partially with by-elections. In reply to Senator FitzGerald's comprehensive dealing with elections, I was allowed to deal with four out of the seven. Although I was stopped at that stage, Senator Quinlan has again come back about the by-elections. Everybody knows that the NFA did picket the polling stations at Waterford and South Kerry; I saw them myself at Waterford. I saw the posters outside the station and I saw the personnel——

Comment on this

In addition to that, the Fine Gael Party know that at every by-election they bring along this other allegedly non-political organisation, the anti-language organisation, and they also have the assistance of the British Proportional Representation Society, that highly-subsidised association——

Comment on this

Another Fianna Fáil lie.

Comment on this

Admittedly, this factor has only come into operation in the last three by-elections with which I have not yet been given the opportunity to deal, but I hope at a later stage to deal with these three as Senator FitzGerald has done. I do not think I should co-operate with Senator Quinlan in further delaying the putting of this amendment by once again going into the by-elections.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I understand that Senator O'Quigley wishes to withdraw the amendment?

Comment on this

I wanted to do that half an hour ago.

Tairgeadh siar an leasú, le cead.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The question is that the Schedule be the Schedule to the Bill.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

May I be clear about what we are doing? It was agreed that we would not have a general debate on the sections but on the Schedule. Have we reached that point now?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The amendments on the Schedule have been disposed of and the question put from the Chair was that the Schedule be agreed to. The House previously agreed that when the Schedule and the amendments had been decided on, there would be no debate on sections 1 and 2.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

But there will be on the Schedule?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There can be now.

Tairgeadh an cheist: "Gurb é an Sceideal is Sceidal don Bhille."

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before we proceed to the discussion on the general question of the Schedule, I should like to point out that there has been a fairly full debate on many of the amendments to the Schedule and many matters have been admitted to discussion which perhaps on a strict interpretation of the rules of order would not have been admitted on the amendments. I would ask those taking part in the debate to refrain from repeating in this general discussion matters that have been adequately discussed on the amendments.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I hope we will all do that. We are all anxious to get this legislation through to the people as quickly as possible. If we can get some co-operation from the Minister, we will make some headway.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Opposition. I will deal with everything they deal with.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister in the course of his discussions here has contradicted himself to quite a degree. He said at one point that the change which they propose would clearly in general do no more than make the average rural vote equally as effective as the average urban vote to elect a Deputy. He went on to say:

I quite freely admit that this was not the actual objective—that the reason for the proposal was to accede to the demand from all sections of the House that there should be reasonable scope to avoid the anomaly and injustice of breaching county boundaries which had to occur on the last occasion in 1961 and would have to occur on such a much wider scale now, if this change is not made.

The Minister also said that Senators opposite wanted to insist that the county boundaries would be breached and that this was in accordance with a definite policy of theirs. The Minister, however, turned down our proposal in regard to the county boundaries, which, if he had accepted it, would have avoided cutting up Cork and Donegal and would have avoided touching Clare and Kerry, to give some examples. He also rejected our amendment that the system be based on the numbers of the electorate, with some additional tolerance for minimising the cutting of county boundaries. At one part the Minister claims that his objective is solely to avoid the anomalies and injustices of breaching county boundaries and said that the Bill is not designed to equate the rural with the urban vote, and in another passage he spoke in relation to Mayo and said that the present Government, and any Government approaching this matter, would approach it from the point of view of making the maximum utilisation reasonably possible of the population and the rural areas as a whole. If that were to be the approach, the Government would be unlikely to decide to waste, as it were, almost 9,500 of the population in Mayo and therefore looking at it from the practical point of view, it was likely, he said, that Mayo's boundaries would also be breached.

So vital is it to give it its fair share of votes he would breach the boundaries unnecessarily for this purpose, although the purpose of the Bill was to avoid breaching county boundaries and not related to this question of parity. There is a flagrant contradiction in this, in the two themes the Minister has put before us. Despite all he said in regard to Mayo, he had the nerve to ask us, as I quoted before, to endorse the principle of one man, one vote of equal value. He told us how he intended to use the Bill, breaching the county boundaries to give Mayo more than its share, even on an electorate basis.

Contradicting himself again, he told us that the only purpose was to equate the rural vote with the urban vote. He told us also that certainly there was no likelihood of an overall rural vote being more effective than an overall urban vote and that in general, it would do no more than make the average rural vote equally as effective as the average urban vote to elect a Deputy. The whole thing was designed to keep the county boundaries and not to equate the vote, and then he said that it was to equate the vote but to do no more than that, than to give the rural vote greater value at the expense of cutting up the county boundaries. As I said, there is a flagrant contradiction in the Minister's three themes running through the debate.

The Minister accused me of having given sketchy information. I was not here at the time but he spoke at some length very personally about me, about my scribbling away on scraps of paper, running my hands through my hair and dashing in and out of the House, and he expressed himself as disappointed that, after all this physical activity, there was no corresponding mental product emerging in what I said, "because", he said, "all he produced after all this was a bald and unsupported statement, which I will show is completely wrong, that these counties will be affected in this way." Later on he claimed:

Unlike Senator FitzGerald...

I have given the figures and figures are all that is relevant, according to Senator FitzGerald... I have shown that on this liberal interpretation of the Constitution, that practically every county in Ireland must have its boundaries breached. I think every single one, except... Wicklow, must be disrupted in some way.

When speaking on the Second Stage, I confined myself as far as possible to reasonable generalities. I thought that discussion on the detail of constituencies would come best on the Schedule and, therefore, I confined myself to making a general statement which I propose now to support in the necessary detail. What I propose is an exercise similar to the one in relation to my election proposal, but in somewhat greater detail, because I will, on this occasion, put to the Minister the precise areas, the transfer of which would achieve the result I claim can be achieved.

The Minister has claimed that, if this change is not made, there will be a much worse breaching of county boundaries now than there was in 1961. He said:

What happened in 1961 will be as nothing to what must happen now.

Again, he said:

...the anomaly and injustice of breaching county boundaries which had to occur on the last occasion in 1961 would have to occur on a much wider scale now, if this change is not made.

I apologise for the English; it is not mine. He claimed that, if this Bill were not passed, the counties would be chopped up in a much more extensive way than in 1961.

On the Second Stage, I examined the situation and I pointed out that there are seven counties, pieces of which would have to be detached and added to other counties, and, on my reckoning, a total of 15 counties would be affected directly by this process—in the case of seven, by having pieces detached, and in the eight others, by having pieces of counties added to them, or to another county with which they are associated in another constituency. The Minister said there were 16: I could not find 16, but I accept his word. We are in the position now that seven counties have pieces detached and 16 are directly or indirectly affected; there is a total of 56,000 people in the areas that are detached, representing something like 1¾ per cent of the population.

I am now going to put to the House a proposed redistribution which will be well within the limits of maximum and minimum population which the Minister has laid down, which will detach pieces from six, not seven, counties, which will affect no more counties than are affected in the present situation, that is, 16, and which will reduce to seven per cent the number of people in the total population who would have to be disturbed, so that only 1.15 per cent will find themselves detached and added to another county and only 25 square miles, or 1.6 per cent of the total area of the country, will be affected.

That represents then, not as the Minister said, a situation about which it could be said that what happened in 1961 will be as nothing to what must happen now, but a situation about which one could not say that it would have to occur on a much wider scale now than in 1961. It will represent, in fact, a situation better than the present situation. It will involve less disturbance, with one less county having a piece detached and 37 per cent fewer people having to be pushed around to vote in counties other than the counties in which they reside. That can be achieved within the present system of tolerance laid down and the Minister's statement and the Taoiseach's statement—the Taoiseach made the statement in the Dáil—that a much greater fractionalising of the country would be necessary are false and misleading. I am not surprised the Minister chanced his arm, because he must know these statements are untrue; I refuse to believe his civil servants are incapable of devising the simple solution that I worked out in a couple of hours——

Comment on this

It was done in the Fianna Fáil rooms.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am, however, surprised that the Taoiseach should have accepted this statement and reproduced it, because the Taoiseach has a reputation for honesty, which he has, on the whole, jealously guarded and for which he is respected in this country. While one expects from his Ministers statements that fall below a certain standard, one does not expect the Taoiseach to make similar statements, though there were two occasions on which he departed from that code, one on the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement and this statement in the Dáil that the country would be fractionalised to a far greater extent in future if this Bill were not passed.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think this is relevant.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I shall now go over the figures and I challenge the Minister to tell me if I am wrong. We are not here dealing with estimates. I do not have to make guesses, guesses which he, shamefacedly, had to admit were accurate for the purposes of the calculation. I am dealing here now with hard population figures—superintendent registrars districts and rural districts—and I shall show specifically which districts, if transferred, would achieve the result within the present system without any amendment, a situation in which only one per cent of the people inhabiting little more than 1½ per cent of this territory would find themselves voting in areas other than the counties in which they live.

We have, first of all, Dublin with a population of 95,047. Its entitlement is to 39.7 seats. I propose, as in my other proposal on the electorate, to reduce this, within the tolerance permitted, to 38 seats, depriving Dublin of approximately two seats because, in the tolerance available, in so far as you have to make any choice, any bias forced by arithmetical calculation should be at the expense of Dublin and in favour of the rest of the country, particularly the West, a thesis we in Fine Gael have put forward constantly. Dublin will then have 4.2 per cent less seats than the five per cent tolerance limit would permit. Wicklow, with a population of 60,428, would have an entitlement of four seats: proposed, three seats, no tolerance required. Wexford, with a population of 83,437, would have an entitlement of 4.17 seats: proposed four seats, tolerance 4 per cent.

Here, I must refer to a mysterious passage in the Minister's speech about which he would, perhaps, enlighten us when he is replying. He said:

County Wexford does not absorb all this population——

Again, the phraseology is a bit obscure.

——and still comply with the requirements of the Constitution either for four seats or three seats. Therefore County Wexford must continue to be butchered in this way.

This I cannot follow:

Population 83,437, 4.17 seats, and tolerance four per cent. It is entitled to four seats and there is no need for any butchering in this case.

The Minister must have nodded at that point because the figures simply do not correspond.

Carlow-Kildare, with 99,997, tolerance of three people, which is about as close as one can hope to get——

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister says that is not right. I must check in case I have made a mistake. One does these things in one's head and without all the resources of the Civil Service and without any totting machine beside one; I could have got them wrong.

Comment on this

It will help to delay anyway.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Population 99,997. That is the figure I read out.

Comment on this

It is not a tolerance of three people.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I see: I am sorry. The Minister is referring to the point that the correct figure is 20,028. It is a tolerance of 31 people. The Minister is perfectly correct in correcting me. There is a tolerance of 31 people which represents .003 per cent.

Comment on this

One hundred and forty three.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I cannot count the number of noughts involved.

Comment on this

It is not 31 people either.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Well, we are talking about .003 per cent—or are there three noughts? I cannot remember which.

Comment on this

It is 143.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Kilkenny has a population of 60,463 people with an entitlement of 3.02: proposed seats 3, tolerance less than .1 per cent. Longford-Westmeath has a population of 81,889, an entitlement of 4.09, four seats and a tolerance of -2.2 per cent. Meath-Louth is one of the cases where it is necessary to cross county boundaries. The population of Meath is 67,323 and the population of Louth is 69,519. If one subtracts the Meath rural district from the county of Meath and adds it to Louth it has a population of 8,568 and we get a figure of 58,755 for Meath with an entitlement of 2.94, seats three, a tolerance of 2.2 per cent. Louth with the addition of the Meath rural district of the county of Meath becomes 78,087, an entitlement of 3.9, give it four seats, tolerance 2.6 per cent.

Comment on this

And a cushy seat for Deputy Tully.

Comment on this

Do not worry about Deputy Tully. He will look after you if you like to take him on in any constituency.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister will perhaps believe me if I say that the main purpose of my exercise is not to provide a cushy seat for Deputy Tully or for anybody else in the Labour Party. What the implications of all this are for the Parties is something for further study. I have simply done this as an exercise to show that this job can be done. I shall look into the other question later.

Waterford has a population of 73,080. If we add to it for example— and these are merely examples; my job is simply to show that it can be done by a system which is reasonable and simple——

Comment on this

It cannot.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

——and produces less disturbance of people than at present. The Minister may choose some other arrangement. He may find that the areas I am proposing to shift are not the ones that suit Fianna Fáil and as he has no commission he can fiddle them around as he likes. Knowing nothing about how the people of Carrick-on-Suir vote, I have worked out that the Carrick-on-Suir superintendent registrar's district with a population of 6,498 could be added to Waterford and you would get 79,578, entitlement 3.98 seats, given four seats, tolerance .2 per cent.

Comment on this

This will all be utilised, I can assure you.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I know it will be utilised. I am quite well aware of the Minister's intention to utilise it, that he will go and tell the people of Carrick-on-Suir that Fine Gael propose they should be detached. I am prepared to risk that because it is our duty in this House to debate this thing intelligently and to disprove the Minister's allegations and not to concern ourselves unduly about the distorted misrepresentations the Minister and his Party will apply as a result.

Comment on this

The Senator realises the people of Carrick-on-Suir will be infuriated by his proposal.

Comment on this

This is an exercise with figures; people do not count.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator FitzGerald, without interruption.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

When they have all finished, I will continue. I know it is infuriating for the Minister to be shown to be guilty of untruths and misrepresentations but it is my job to do so.

Tipperary after the subtraction of the Carrick-on-Suir district has a population of 116,314, with an entitlement of 5.82 seats, with a tolerance of 3.1 per cent you get two three-seat constituencies.

Comment on this

The Senator has not consulted the Opposition Deputies of South Tipperary.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have not consulted anybody and I am not proposing this. I am just showing that this is a way it can be done. It may not be the best way: it probably is not the best way. I am sure the people concerned would not think it is the best way but the onus is on me to show that it can be done and that the Minister has lied to us on this matter and that onus I propose to discharge without regard to what the consequences may be.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator should not use the word "lie" in regard to a statement made in the House.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister has misled us in the matter: I apologise. Interruptions sometimes provoke one to use unparliamentary expressions.

Monaghan-Cavan has a population of 99,754, entitlement 4.99, five seats, a tolerance of .02 per cent. May I refer here to the interesting reference in the Minister's speech on this subject? He said other people who take a more responsible view—it is not entirely clear who he is talking about but I think on this occasion it was not Senator FitzGerald he was talking about—and who would not look at everything from the point of view of their own personal convenience——

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

——would agree that a constituency comprised of the counties of Monaghan and Cavan would not be a desirable one. Who are these other people and on what grounds would it not be desirable?

Comment on this

Monaghan and Cavan people.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister accepts elsewhere in his speech that combinations of two counties are acceptable. There are many cases where this has been done. His measure is not designed to eliminate that. The Minister has said that to eliminate that he would require a tolerance of 30 per cent. There is no objection in principle to this. What is there about Monaghan and Cavan that makes it undesirable there? Could it be the fact that in that area there are about 12,750 nonCatholics who have difficulty in electing a Deputy in two three-seat constituencies but could more readily elect one in a five-seat constituency? If that is not the reason would the Minister tell us what it is and why he is against a five-seat constituency in that area particularly?

Laois-Offaly has a population of 96,312, an entitlement of 4.82, five seats, tolerance 3.8 per cent. Kerry as the Minister has told us at great length in his speech has a population of 112,785 and under the present tolerance arrangements it requires some addition in order to strengthen it to the point where it would be entitled to six seats and to remain two three-seat constituencies. The Minister also made much of the fact that Kerry is surrounded by ranges of mountains. This reminds me of that remarkable speech in the Dáil which caused such hilarity back in 1959 when Mr. Lemass informed the disbelieving Deputies on all sides of the House that Donegal was divided by ranges of mountains with only two passes through these mountains, like the Alps. One wondered why tunnels were not constructed through these massive ranges.

On that occasion I took out my atlas because I had a certain interest in political geography and I discovered that there were five or six routes from one side of Donegal to the other. Now we have Kerry surrounded by mountains. Now I travel in and out of Kerry by train and sometimes by car from Mallow and I would like to tell the Minister that there is a valley through which one can enter Kerry without having to clamber over rugged mountain-tops. It is actually possible to get into Kerry by railway going in through a valley.

Comment on this

I never said it was not possible.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

My suggestion would be that certain areas in that valley which are contiguous to County Kerry and from which I suspect the people bring their milk to Rathmore Processing Plant and would therefore know the roads into Rathmore without climbing into the mountains could be added to Kerry so as to ensure that Kerry has six seats. The Minister may have better proposals. He seems to think in terms of adding something from the other side of the Healy Pass for some reason. I would suggest adding the districts of Knocknagree, Cullen, Doonasheen, Derragh, Caherbarnagh and Coomlogan.

Comment on this

Bould Thady Quill and all.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That would be an extra 4,116 which would give Kerry 116,901, entitlement 5.845, two three-seat constituencies, tolerance 2.6 per cent. This would mean subtracting 4,116 from Cork which would give you 335,587, entitlement 16.78, seats seven, tolerance 1.3 per cent to be divided and gerrymandered at the Minister's will.

Limerick has a population of 137,357, entitlement 6.87 seats, two per cent tolerance required to give it seven seats, three and four as at present. Clare the Minister has told us is short. May I point out that both Clare and Kerry are counties which if our proposal had been accepted, would not have required the addition of other counties? In fact under our proposal which the Minister has rejected, these counties would have sufficient electorate to justify having this number of seats without having any bits added and the Minister has rejected our proposal on the electorate, and so these additions become necessary. Here I suggest—it is only a suggestion; there are various other things one could do —if one added the old Gort registrar's district, before it was reorganised in more recent times as in the 1935 map, that you added 3,100 population to Clare, a population giving 76,697, entitlement to 3.83 seats and 4.2 per cent tolerance required to bring it up to four seats. Roscommon-Leitrim involves the usual adjustments in this area, which Leitrim has suffered so often. It is necessary, first of all, to add from Galway. There are many solutions to this area, as the Minister has indicated. This is a solution. I must put some solution on record to show my good faith in suggesting the Minister has been misleading us in this matter. If one adds from Galway the areas of Ballinasloe, for example, adding the Ballinasloe-Laurencetown registrar's district and the Killure, Ahascragh and Taghboy district electoral division, this would bring the population of Roscommon-Leitrim up to the point where it would satisfy five seats, and where the loss of the strip of land about which the Minister made such a song and dance the other day linking Sligo and Donegal, involving a population of as many as 975 people, can be accepted without affecting the tolerance. Therefore Roscommon-Leitrim losing the little strip of land at the top of the balance of 975 people and gaining 10,189 in the Galway-Ballinasloe region, the province——

Comment on this

Sligo-Leitrim, not Roscommon.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister underrates my knowledge of geography. I would have thought that I showed a certain knowledge of Irish geography in this debate. This is precisely why one has to take a strip off the top of Leitrim with 975 people and to link the two. I am telling the Minister if he would listen. That gives Roscommon-Leitrim 96,014 population, entitlement to 4.8 and 4.1 per cent tolerance required to make it a five-seat constituency. In the case of Galway which had a population of 148,340, insufficient to justify it in having eight seats, the deductions from it have been so devised as not to reduce its entitlement below the seven seat figure. It is not entitled to eight anyway. These are deductions in the direction of Clare and Roscommon, and perhaps even when they have been carried out, Galway is still entitled to the seven seats, which is all its population as a whole is entitled to in any event. These deductions reduced it to 135,051, entitlement to 6.75 seats and a 3.7 per cent tolerance, brings that up to seven giving a three- and four-seat constituency. Mayo has 115,547, an entitlement to 5.78 and 3.8 per cent tolerance, gives six seats in a two-three seat constituency. I have already quoted the Minister's remarkable statement about Mayo, that although Mayo is entitled in its present population to a two-three seat constituency, he proposes to breach the county boundary in order to get some extra seats into the area in some way, so little does he care for county boundaries which in the other part of his speech he told us was the only purpose of this Bill being brought before the House.

Sligo now has a population of 51,263, but add to that 75 from the Tullaghan and Gubbacreeny district electoral divisions of Leitrim and the Ballyshannon and Bundoran area, that is to say, the Ballyshannon registrar's district in Donegal with a population of 6,319 and it gives Sligo with passages forming Donegal, 58,557, entitlement to 2.53 seats and a 2.4 per cent tolerance gives three seats.

Finally, Donegal is entitled, unfortunately, with its 108,549 population at the counting only to five seats anyway and this deduction does not alter that. It brings it to 102,240, entitlement to 5.11 and 2.2 per cent tolerance giving five seats.

I know it is a waste of time trying to avoid misrepresentation from the other side of the House. I will repeat once again what I have done. I have produced a notional exercise to invalidate the Minister's and the Taoiseach's statements, that in this and future divisions, it would be necessary to divide up the country much more drastically than in 1961. This division may not be the best but it is a possible division which may achieve the results I have mentioned. I am not advocating it in particular. There may be better ways of doing it. The Minister's ingenuity no doubt will devise ways better for Fianna Fáil and, indeed, his Department's ingenuity will probably devise ways which will involve less inconvenience for the people concerned and involve perhaps less disturbance for the population than even I propose, but my proposal would involve disturbing only 1.15 per cent of the people of Ireland, detaching them from the counties in which they live and adding them to other counties, that is, 1.15 per cent of the people living in 1.16 per cent of the area of this country, that is, 425 square miles.

That is the terrible crime that is brought upon us, the terrible injustice, the uprooting of people forced on us as if this were the question of Poland taking up East Germany after the war. This is the terrible injustice of uprooting forced on us by this evil constitutional decision which was invented a Fine Gael plot—one per cent of the people of the country voting in a county different from the county in which they live, a disturbance far less than credited. It involves 56,000 people who are disturbed at the moment by the present arrangement, whereas in my amendment only 33,000 would be disturbed. In fact, this is a very minor problem. It is a problem which with an intelligent approach, not bedevilled by the desire to gerrymander, would cause less disturbance than at present.

I suspect that the degree of disturbance in 1961 involved almost two per cent of the people of the country being disturbed—it involved only 1.7 or 1.8 —and this was due to the fact that the Minister was not prepared to take the solutions involving least disturbance but in fact adopted other solutions at the margins in order to get a better political result. I have shown that regardless of the political results— whether it is Deputy Tully or Deputy anybody else from Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour; I have not examined that aspect of the thing, but have simply looked for the solution which involves least disturbance for the least number of people in the least area of the country—this can be achieved in fact with less disturbance than in 1961.

If there is any more disturbance than this involved, it is because the Minister would be trying to gerrymander the country and to disturb more people than is necessary to get a political result. I shall examine with great interest the results of the redistribution that will follow the defeat in this referendum. If in fact the number of people disturbed exceeds 1.15 per cent, I should have no hesitation in pinning this on the Minister, this unnecessary disturbance, as a result of his desire to achieve a political result. I think I have made the point adequately and conclusively. If there is anything wrong with my figures, the Minister can say so, but I do not think there is, I have put all my cards on the table. I have accepted that this may be used in misrepresentation against me. I accept that the Minister will be trotting down to Carrick-on-Suir and Knocknagree and Cullen and Roundstone and Ahascragh and all these places, telling the people that I and Fine Gael wanted them particularly shifted to another constituency. I said nothing of the kind.

I have said that under the present system this is a solution, one that involves a minimum disturbance. It may not be the best solution. I do not particularly advocate it but I put it before the House to show that this House and the other House have been deliberately misled by the Minister, and more so by the Taoiseach, in attempting to pretend that if the present system persists, it would be necessary to chop up this country in a manner much more extensive than anything done in 1961 or in the past. On that I can rest and I look forward very much indeed to hearing the Minister's reply.

Comment on this

The case Senator Garret FitzGerald has made shows that it would be quite easy for the Minister to reorganise the constituencies without much disturbance. He has mentioned that the plan, or scheme, he has submitted for the Minister's consideration will disturb only 1.1 per cent. Some Senators seem to think they would gain great political advantage out of these proposals, particularly the suggestion that Carrick-on-Suir should be moved into another area in order to bring up the representation to a fair figure but it only involves 1.1 per cent of the people, and of course there is nothing in that for Fianna Fáil because even if all the people who would be disturbed by Senator Garret FitzGerald's proposal voted for Fianna Fáil it would only represent an increase of 1.1 of the percentage of the electorate. That would not help Fianna Fáil much. Considering they have lost 9 per cent of the electorate since 1965, 1.1 per cent will not give any help to them at all. It is obvious the Minister would not accept this arrangement because 1.1 per cent would be no help to the Fianna Fáil Party at this stage. He must look rather to doing some constituency butchering, which he has mentioned, in order to get some benefit for the Fianna Fáil Party. I think it was Senator Ryan who mentioned, in fact, that gerrymandering is possible only in Cork and Dublin and that it is not really possible in the rural constituencies where people are less objective when considering policies and candidates for which they might vote. Apparently there is nothing in it for Fianna Fáil as far as the rural areas are concerned.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They claim that. I have already refuted that claim.

Comment on this

All they want to do is to create the maximum amount of disturbance in rural areas in order to make people believe they have a grievance and seek support for the referendum proposals by doing so. The position in Dublin and Cork is quite different: you can have gerrymandering. The Minister knows what happened in Dublin county on the last occasion when Ballyfermot was taken out of the city constituency and brought into the county constituency instead. Ballyfermot now is lost to the Minister as far as support for Fianna Fáil is concerned. He would be very glad on this occasion to get rid of Ballyfermot as far as any constituency he may be representing is concerned. We know even from the last election when Fianna Fáil got the last of three seats that Fianna Fáil are out as far as Ballyfermot is concerned.

Comment on this

Who got the last seat in County Dublin?

Comment on this

I have forgotten, actually.

Comment on this

For the Senator's information, he contested the last seat out of five with Deputy Clinton.

Comment on this

I know. The Minister is showing how successfully gerrymandering of that constituency worked out. I am glad the Minister mentioned this because he did a very good job on it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Senator stands a victim of gerrymandering.

Comment on this

I am not worried about that because I had a long innings. I was longer in the Dáil than the Minister may be as far as that goes.

Comment on this

He was an ordinary TD. The Minister was not that yet.

Comment on this

The Minister has a long way to go.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

He might even end up in the Seanad.

Comment on this

The point is the gerrymandering of Dublin county constituency was so successful that one Fine Gael candidate who had been 17 years in the Dáil competed with another Fine Gael candidate, who was a number of years in the Dáil, for the last of five seats. Surely that was a good job of gerrymandering? That was Fine Gael competing between each other and against each other for the last five seats. This is a clear example of gerrymandering.

Comment on this

Support for Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

During the Presidential election——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Perhaps the Senator would relate his remarks to the difference which would occur whether the Schedule was enacted or not. This is now the point at issue.

Comment on this

Thank you. If I could put it in clear and simple figures, the proposal in the Tolerance Bill is that 10,000 men, women and children in one area will have representation equal to 6,500 men, women and children in another area, if we take the 16 per cent one way or another in addition to the normal movement of population. Obviously that is a ridiculous tolerance and it is designed only to give a good, comprehensive margin for Fianna Fáil gerrymandering and the organisation of areas for the benefit of the Fianna Fáil Party. Senator Garret FitzGerald has given his example of the manner in which this country and this State at the moment could be divided up into constituencies giving an equal representation to the people as required by the Constitution which requires representation on a population basis rather than based on the electorate.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The question of the electorate compared with population was disposed of.

Comment on this

When the Minister is replying, I hope he will be able to point out to Senator FitzGerald that he has a better scheme than the one put to him. I think Senator FitzGerald has made this job very easy for the Minister.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do my best.

Comment on this

There will be no difficulty in mapping out the constituencies if he follows the suggestions from Senator FitzGerald. If he wants to butcher the constituencies in the interests of the Fianna Fáil Party he knows he will have difficulty. I am glad Senator FitzGerald impressed on the Minister that he did not take political representation into consideration when proposing this scheme for revising the constituencies. At this stage the Minister should abandon the idea of gerrymandering. He has been talking about the possibility of Fianna Fáil being replaced by Fine Gael and if he is sincere in believing that Fianna Fáil will be replaced by Fine Gael——

Comment on this

Some time in the 1980s.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear the Senator saying it is nearer than some of them are saying. Some of them said the year 2000.

Comment on this